18 <strong>Indigenous</strong> Rights Quarterly ARTICLEVol. II : No. 4 • Oct-Dec 2007Bangladesh: The Army attacks Buddhism to facilitateillegal settlement in the Chittagong Hill TractsOn 25 January 2008, <strong>indigenous</strong>Jumma <strong>peoples</strong> are scheduled tohold a large religious gathering atSarnath Arannyo Kuthir, a Buddhisttemple at Karallyachari inKhagrachari Hill district <strong>of</strong> theChittagong Hill Tracts (CHTs). TheBangladeshi authorities havebanned the meeting. It is unclear ifthe meeting will go ahead. As weupload this Weekly Review, theDeputy Commissioner <strong>of</strong>Khagrachari district is holding ameeting with the local Jumma elders<strong>of</strong> Karallyachari to decide the fate <strong>of</strong>the religious gathering while theBangladesh army personnel havebeen seizing the bikes <strong>and</strong> othervehicles. But if the meeting takesplace it is likely that the governmentwill use violence to suppress it.The government’s actions at the templeare a microcosm <strong>of</strong> an ongoing<strong>and</strong> long established State policy toestablish a homogenous BengaliMuslim society; a policy that impliesthe destruction <strong>of</strong> the identity <strong>of</strong> the<strong>indigenous</strong> Jumma <strong>peoples</strong> througha process <strong>of</strong> illegal <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong>ten violentsettlement <strong>of</strong> the Bengali Muslimsettlers.With international community’sattention focused on Bangladesh’sparliamentary elections the caretakergovernment is free to executethe ethnic cleansing policy in theCHTs without external interference.Background to the SarnathArannyo Kuthir:The banning <strong>of</strong> the religious gatheringcomes as part <strong>of</strong> a pattern <strong>of</strong>wider attacks on the religion <strong>of</strong> the<strong>indigenous</strong> communities. On 14January 2008, the Bangladesh Policearrested Reverend Arya JyotiBhikkhu, Head Priest <strong>of</strong> SarnathArannyo Kuthir, after a settler,Abdul Majid, son <strong>of</strong> late AkadZaman from Karallyachari clustervillage, filed a First InformationReport (No. 1 <strong>of</strong> dated 11/1/2008)under sections 143, 447, 379, 427, 506<strong>and</strong> 109 <strong>of</strong> the Bangladesh PenalCode. The complainant accusedThe government <strong>of</strong>Bangladesh recently sought toban a large religious gatheringat Sarnath Arannyo Kuthir, aBuddhist temple at Karallyachariin Khagrachari Hilldistrict <strong>of</strong> the CHTs. Thegovernment’s actions at thetemple are a microcosm <strong>of</strong> anongoing <strong>and</strong> long establishedState policy to establish ahomogenous Bengali Muslimsociety; a policy that impliesthe destruction <strong>of</strong> the identity<strong>of</strong> the <strong>indigenous</strong> Jumma<strong>peoples</strong> through a process <strong>of</strong>illegal <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong>ten violent settlement<strong>of</strong> the Bengali Muslimsettlers.about 500 <strong>indigenous</strong> <strong>peoples</strong>including Rev Aryo Joti Bhikkhu<strong>and</strong> Late(!) Tumbo Chakma <strong>of</strong> committing<strong>of</strong>fences <strong>of</strong> illegal gathering,theft <strong>and</strong> destruction to privateproperties. In reality, it appears thatthese <strong>indigenous</strong> Jummas were makingtemporary houses to accommodatethe Buddhist monks <strong>and</strong> thedevotees within the temple premise.On 21 January 2008, the AdditionalDistrict Magistrate <strong>of</strong> KhagrachariMr Manindra Kishor Majumder in acommunication (je.pra.kha/je.em/tin-75/2008-63) ordered theOfficer-in-Charge <strong>of</strong> MahalachariPolice Station area to issue showcause on the headmen <strong>and</strong> Karbaris(traditional village chiefs) <strong>of</strong>Karallyachari area as to why theyhad failed to notify the administrationabout the religious programme.He also ordered that the court examinethe l<strong>and</strong> documents <strong>of</strong> the temple<strong>and</strong> threatened legal actionagainst the headmen <strong>and</strong> Karbaris ifthey failed to provide satisfactorydocumentation.On 21 January 2008, Bangladesharmy personnel prevented local peoplefrom constructing a makeshiftbridge over the river Chengi atKarallyachari - Paujjyachari areaunder Mahalchari Police Station.The bridge was being prepared forthe religious programme.Targeting <strong>of</strong> the Buddhist temples:The events at Sarnath ArannyoKuthir are not isolated. Across theCHTs, Buddhist temples have beentargeted for destruction <strong>by</strong> theauthorities. <strong>Indigenous</strong> BuddhistChakmas <strong>and</strong> Marmas usually livein <strong>and</strong> around their temples. Oncetemples are destroyed the area canbe more easily cleared for illegalplain settlers.In August 2007, illegal settlers <strong>and</strong>the Bangladesh army personnel triedto take over the l<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> the SadhanaTila Buddhist temple <strong>of</strong> Babucharaarea under Dighinala upazila inKhagrachari district. As national <strong>and</strong>international protest grew, the defactoruler <strong>of</strong> the country GeneralMoeen U Ahmed visited Dighinalaon 28 August 2007 <strong>and</strong> assuredlocals that the temple will not be
<strong>Indigenous</strong> Rights Quarterly ARTICLEVol. II : No. 4 • Oct-Dec 2007 19destroyed.On 12 September 2007, Khagracharidistrict authorities banned the “construction<strong>of</strong> new Mosque, Hindutemple <strong>and</strong> Buddhist temple” inMahalchari sub-division withoutprior permission <strong>of</strong> the authorities.While the order does not specificallytarget any religious group, given thelong history <strong>of</strong> well documented evidence<strong>of</strong> violations against theJumma <strong>peoples</strong> the political reality isthat the order is targeted at the<strong>indigenous</strong> <strong>peoples</strong> <strong>and</strong> their religioni.e. Buddhism.On 5 November 2007, MajorQamruzzaman, Comm<strong>and</strong>er <strong>of</strong>Babuchara zone, summoned SnehaMoy Chakma <strong>and</strong> Santosh JibonChakma to his camp <strong>and</strong> orderedthem not to use loudspeakers toannounce the Katin ChivorDanotsav, the Buddhist festival thatfollows the end <strong>of</strong> the rain retreat <strong>of</strong>Buddhist monks.On 31 December 2007, a group <strong>of</strong>army personnel led <strong>by</strong> CaptainSohel, Comm<strong>and</strong>er <strong>of</strong> ShuknachariIndra Singh Karbari Para camp <strong>of</strong>the Bangladesh Army, demolishedBhujulichuk Kuthir, a Buddhistmeditation centre in LakshmichariUpazila in Khagrachari district.Captain Shohel threatened witnesseson a prior attack that : “We will nottolerate any Buddha house here; wewant only Allah’s house”.On 17 January 2008, theComm<strong>and</strong>ing Officer <strong>of</strong> Baghaihatzone in Rangamati district threatenedReverend Dwip BongshawBhikkhu, the Head Priest <strong>of</strong> BishwaMoitri Bouddha Vihar at Hazacharavillage in Baghaihat. TheComm<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>of</strong>ficer threatened todemolish the temple if the priest didnot leave.The motivation for taking l<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> theSadhana Tila Buddhist temple <strong>and</strong>its surrounding areas is simple: furtherillegal settlement. <strong>Asian</strong> Centrefor Human Rights (ACHR) is in possession<strong>of</strong> a letter dated 19November 2007 issued <strong>by</strong> Md. SulutZaman, Deputy Secretary <strong>of</strong> theMinistry <strong>of</strong> Chittagong Hill TractsAffairs (MoCHTA). It orders theDeputy Commissioner <strong>of</strong>Khagrachari district to illegally settle812 families into the l<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> the<strong>indigenous</strong> Jummas at Babucharaarea, Baghaichari mouza underDighinala upazila (sub- district) inKhagrachari district.Despite the increasing rate <strong>of</strong>illegal settlement <strong>and</strong> blatanthuman rights violations in theCHTs, international concernis hard to discern. EvenHuman Rights Watch <strong>and</strong>Amnesty International omittedreference to the CHTs intheir Annual reports 2007.L<strong>and</strong> grabbing:There are many other recent incidents<strong>of</strong> forcible l<strong>and</strong> grabbing. InDecember 2007, illegal plain settlersled <strong>by</strong> Md. Wahab from Burighatunder Rangamati district forciblygrabbed 25 acres <strong>of</strong> l<strong>and</strong> belongingto the <strong>indigenous</strong> Jumma people atHatimara village under BurighatMouza in Rangamati district.During March 2007-November2007, a total <strong>of</strong> 399.22 acres <strong>of</strong> l<strong>and</strong>belonging to 133 Jumma individuals<strong>and</strong> a primary school in 14 villagesunder four Unions <strong>of</strong>Mahalchari police station <strong>and</strong>Khagrachari Sadar police stationunder Kagrachari district have beenillegally <strong>and</strong> forcibly grabbed <strong>by</strong>the illegal plain settlers with directhelp from the army.At a press conference in Dhaka on 19January 2008, representatives <strong>of</strong> theCommittee for Protection <strong>of</strong> L<strong>and</strong> inB<strong>and</strong>arban called upon the governmentto cancel the ongoing process<strong>of</strong> acquiring 9,560 acres <strong>of</strong> l<strong>and</strong> forthe purpose <strong>of</strong> expansion <strong>of</strong> RumaGarrison. The government ispresently at the final stage <strong>of</strong> acquiring9,560 acres <strong>of</strong> l<strong>and</strong> for the purpose<strong>of</strong> expansion <strong>of</strong> Ruma Garrisonin three Mouzas <strong>of</strong> Galenga, Pantola<strong>and</strong> Sengum under Ruma Upazillain B<strong>and</strong>arban. Out <strong>of</strong> the total l<strong>and</strong>to be acquired, 1,569.06 acres belongto the <strong>indigenous</strong> <strong>peoples</strong> <strong>and</strong> 4,000acres belong to the ForestDepartment. The project will lead todisplacement <strong>of</strong> 4,315 <strong>indigenous</strong>persons from 644 families. Way backin 1988, a joint study team <strong>of</strong>B<strong>and</strong>arban District Administration<strong>and</strong> the Bangladesh Military statedthat the project would be disastrousfor the local <strong>indigenous</strong> <strong>peoples</strong>.Background to the CHTs crisis:The root <strong>of</strong> the CHTs crisis lies in thepolicies <strong>of</strong> the government <strong>of</strong>Bangladesh which seek to establishhomogenous Bengali muslimsociety. This implies the destruction<strong>of</strong> the identity <strong>of</strong> the <strong>indigenous</strong>Jumma <strong>peoples</strong>. ‘Jumma’ is thecollective name for the eleven tribes<strong>of</strong> the CHTs.Over the last 50 years, hundreds <strong>of</strong>thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> Bengali settlers havebeen moved onto Jumma l<strong>and</strong>.Successive regimes in East Pakistan,<strong>and</strong> later Bangladesh have supportedthe influx <strong>of</strong> Bengali-speakingMuslim migrants into the 5,000 sqkm Hill Tracts, which is sparselypopulated in comparison to the rest<strong>of</strong> the country. The settlement hasbeen carried out with varyingdegrees <strong>of</strong> violence, including in earlierperiods massacre.Today, as a result <strong>of</strong> the aggressivesettlement policy, the ChittagongHill Tracts has a population <strong>of</strong>900,000 which is evenly divided