You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
�<br />
Let C be the midpoint of the segment AB . By hypothesis, we have<br />
tan α + tan β<br />
|OC| =<br />
2<br />
= tan γ , hence OP C = γ and |P C| = 1<br />
cos γ .<br />
Let Q be the point symmetric to P with respect to C . The quadrilateral<br />
P AQB is a parallelogram, and therefore |AQ| = |P B| = 1<br />
ally,<br />
. Eventu-<br />
cos β<br />
2 1 1<br />
= +<br />
cos δ cos α cos β<br />
and hence δ > γ .<br />
Another solution. Set x =<br />
and<br />
= |P A| + |AQ| > |P Q| = 2 · |P C| = 2<br />
cos γ ,<br />
α + β<br />
2<br />
and y =<br />
α − β<br />
2<br />
, then α = x+y , β = x−y<br />
cos α cos β = 1<br />
(cos 2x + cos 2y) =<br />
2<br />
= 1<br />
2 (1 − 2 sin2 x) + 1<br />
2 (2 cos2 y − 1) = cos 2 y − sin 2 x .<br />
By the conditions of the problem,<br />
and<br />
tan γ = 1<br />
�<br />
sin α sin β<br />
�<br />
+ =<br />
2 cos α cos β<br />
1 sin(α + β)<br />
·<br />
2 cos α cos β<br />
1<br />
cos δ<br />
1<br />
�<br />
1 1<br />
�<br />
= + =<br />
2 cos α cos β<br />
1 cos α + cos β<br />
·<br />
2 cos α cos β<br />
Using (3) we hence obtain<br />
tan 2 δ − tan 2 γ =<br />
showing that δ > γ .<br />
= sin x cos x<br />
cos α cos β<br />
= cos x cos y<br />
cos α cos β .<br />
1<br />
cos2 δ − 1 − tan2γ = cos2x cos2y − sin 2 x cos2x cos2α cos2 − 1 =<br />
β<br />
= cos2 x(cos 2 y − sin 2 x)<br />
(cos 2 y − sin 2 x) 2<br />
= cos2 x − cos 2 y + sin 2 x<br />
cos 2 y − sin 2 x<br />
9<br />
− 1 =<br />
=<br />
cos2x cos2y − sin 2 − 1 =<br />
x<br />
sin 2 y<br />
cos α cos β<br />
> 0 ,<br />
(3)