‘Fuck <strong>All</strong> Editors’: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Ern</strong> <strong>Malley</strong> <strong>Affair</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood’s Bulletin Sc<strong>and</strong>alCass<strong>and</strong>ra Atherton1 Desmond O’Grady was the acting poetry editor of the Bulletin at this time. Douglas Stewart haddeparted <strong>and</strong> Vincent Buckley had yet to be appointed. O’Grady rang Harwood after the sc<strong>and</strong>al,provoking Harwood to characterise him in her letter to the Hoddinotts as gibbering to her ‘Didyou write them? Why? Why?’ As editor of the Bulletin, the ‘paranoiac Donald Horne’ (asHarwood dubbed him) took responsibility for the sonnets. He in turn dubbed the sc<strong>and</strong>al a ‘sadjest’. See A Steady Storm of Correspondence: Selected Letters of <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood 1943-1995,Gregory Kratzmann (ed.), UQP, Australia, 2001; <strong>and</strong> Jennifer Strauss, Boundary Conditions:<strong>The</strong> Poetry of <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood, UQP, Australia, 1992, p 23.2 John Rowan, Subpersonalities: <strong>The</strong> People Inside Us, Routledge, London, 1990, p 8.3 Michael Heyward, <strong>The</strong> <strong>Ern</strong> <strong>Malley</strong> <strong>Affair</strong>, Faber <strong>and</strong> Faber, London, 1993, p 81.4 Chris Wallace-Crabbe, ‘Imaginary Identities’, unpublished paper, University of Melbourne,1989.5 <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood, ‘Gentleness’, Quadrant, vol 21, no 3, 1977, p 15.6 Cass<strong>and</strong>ra Pybus, <strong>The</strong> Devil <strong>and</strong> James McAuley, UQP, Australia, 1999, p 254.7 Heyward, op. cit., p 81.8 ibid., p 61.9 Max Harris <strong>and</strong> Joanna Murray-Smith, <strong>Ern</strong> <strong>Malley</strong>, <strong>All</strong>en <strong>and</strong> Unwin, Sydney, 1987, p 3.10 Heyward, op. cit, p 57.11 ibid., p 137.12 ibid., p 138.13 Harris, op. cit., p 13.14 ibid., p 13.15 ibid.16 Heyward, op. cit., p 153.17 Harris, op. cit., viii.18 ibid., p 8.19 ibid., p 9.20 Quotes from <strong>Ern</strong> <strong>Malley</strong> poems are all taken from Harris’ <strong>and</strong> Murray-Smith’s <strong>Ern</strong> <strong>Malley</strong>, op.cit. However the special collections in the Baillieu library at the University of Melbourne hold‘<strong>The</strong> Darkening Ecliptic’.21 Strauss, op. cit., pp 23-4.22 Tasmanian Truth, 23 August 1961.23 Harwood <strong>and</strong> Buckely were originally going to collaborate on a hoax for Leonie Kramer, theeditor of Australian Poetry. Buckley initially put the idea to Harold Stewart <strong>and</strong> Harwood.Stewart declined <strong>and</strong> Harwood wrote a sonnet using Buckley’s name <strong>and</strong> gave him a copy.Buckley never sent it to Kramer <strong>and</strong> after a time Harwood decided to redraft it <strong>and</strong> send this <strong>and</strong>another to the Bulletin. It should be made clear that it was not intended to hoax Buckley as poetryeditor as he already had a copy <strong>and</strong> had initially collaborated with Harwood. See A Steady Storm,op. cit., Chapter 2.24 Hoddinott, op. cit.
25 C<strong>and</strong>ida Baker, Yacker 3: Australian Writers Talk About <strong>The</strong>ir Work, Pan, Chippendale, 1989, p138.26 ibid.27 Bulletin, 19 August 1961.28 Baker, op. cit., p 138.29 Stephanie Trigg, <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood: Australian Writers’ Series, Oxford University Press,Melbourne, 1994.30 Alison Hoddinott, <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood, <strong>The</strong> Real <strong>and</strong> Imagined World, Angus <strong>and</strong> Robertson, NorthRyde, 1991, p 88.31 Trigg, op. cit., p 12.32 ibid.33 Bulletin, 5 August 1961, p 3.34 ibid.35 Robert Sellick, <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood, CRNLE <strong>and</strong> Monograph Series no 3, Adelaide, 1997 p 25.36 Baker, op. cit., p 137.37 ibid., p 149.38 Jenny Digby, A Woman’s Voice: Conversations with Australian Poets, UQP, 1996, p 610.39 James Vargiu, Psychosynthesis Workbook: Subpersonalities, Synthesis 1, 1974, p 53.40 ibid., p 55.41 John Rowan <strong>and</strong> Mick Cooper (eds), <strong>The</strong> Plural Self: Multiplicity in Everyday Life, Sage,London, 1999, p 2.42 Rowan <strong>and</strong> Cooper, op. cit., p 3.43 Thomas R Whitaker, Social Research, n 63, n3, 1996, p 701.44 John Beston, ‘An Interview with <strong>Gwen</strong> Harwood’, Quadrant, vol 19, no 7, 1975, p 88.