Appraisal of City Development Plan: Raipur - JnNURM

these multiple agencies and functioning of line departments has also not been produced in theCDP. Tables on pages 42 and 47 should be extended for 18 functions of the 12 th schedule.CMC:The operational area of the different agencies of UT such as Municipal Corporation,Engineering Department UT Chandigarh Housing Board etc. has been defined and thefunctions mentioned in the 12 th schedule transferred to Corporation have been depicted in theCDP.NIUA:The status of 18 functions of the 12 th Schedule is well explained and functioning of multipleagencies is provided with adequate details.6. The CDP is more focused on water sector e.g. pages 134 to 196 has been devoted to watersector alone and less attention has been paid to other important sectors that has been coveredfrom page 198 to page 219.CMC:Almost all the sectors have been covered in the CDP such as water supply, sewerage, stormwater drainage, roads, elevated highway, transport etc. The details of the finances of theyears 2001-02 to 2004-05 have been explained in the modified CDPNIUA:Repetitions are removed and details of other sectors are also included.7. The chapter 4 on “Municipal Infrastructure” is mixed up with municipal finance issues. Thecity finances and municipal finance related issues should have been dealt separately.Moreover merely providing a few tables on municipal finances etc. does not solve the purposeof understanding the constraints related city finances.CMC:The necessary amendment has been incorporated in the modified CDP. The finances issueshave been depicted separately.NIUA:Detailed analysis on this issue has been provided in the revised CDP.8. Details of income-expenditure statement for Chandigarh Municipal Corporation andChandigarh Administration have not been provided. Table on page 72 could not beunderstood and has created confusions.CMC:The details of the income and expenditure statements of Chandigarh administration andMunicipal Corporation have now been clearly depicted in the modified CDP.7