A Cautionary Tale of Two JosephsMargaret Page writesfrom Kidderminster.Some time ago now I discovered thatthe Society of Friends had disownedmy great great grandfather, Thomas<strong>Binns</strong>, for “unnecessary frequentingpublic houses and houses of ill fame.”He died of “galloping consumption”(TB) at the early age of fortytwoin 1858, when the youngest of hischildren, my great grandmother wasjust two years old. He was a draper inAshton under Lyne when his other 3daughters and only son were born.His only son, Joseph, (born 1852 inAshton under Lyne) was educated inaccordance with family tradition, atRawden Quaker School. His nephew,David, youngest son of Thomas’sbrother David attended the sameschool. (A fact that seems strange asRawdon School was established, Ithought, for children whose parentswere not members of the Society ofFriends. This was true for Joseph butnot for his cousin David). Could Ihope to find more about the family?Well thanks to Donald Benson <strong>Binns</strong>legacy to us all, in the shape of theBindex database, yes I could.<strong>The</strong> Bindex database collection of<strong>Binns</strong> details often fills in those otherwiseelusive <strong>Binns</strong> facts. One suchexample is the details of the Will ofJoseph’s uncle, David. I wonderwhere Donald found the Will? ThisUncle David (1799-1883) was adraper, a Quaker, and a pillar of Halifaxsociety. I knew from his autobiographythat his children who survivedinfancy were three sons, Joseph,Charles, and David and two daughters,Hannah and Maria.Charles took over the stuff merchantbusiness of George <strong>Binns</strong> and Co. ofBradford when his Uncle George diedhaving no surviving sons from twomarriages.According to David’s autobiography,it was Joseph (born 1836 in Halifax),his second son, who took on the Halifaxdrapery business, firstly in CornMarket, where his father had previouslyhad his business, and then inLord Street, although by the time ofDavid’s death in 1883 the businesswas at 1 Princess Street, Halifax.3DJHDavid himself had moved on retirementto Akeds Road, Halifax.I was armed with this half forgottendetail when, on eBay, I came acrossand was able to purchase a billheaddated 29 th April 1887, for Jos. <strong>Binns</strong>& Co., Wholesale Drapers, Hosiers,and Pinafore Manufacturers of 1 PrincessStreet, Halifax. <strong>The</strong>y were agentsfor Brook’s Reels, Cambell’s LinenReels, and Clark’s Crochet Cocoons.<strong>The</strong> details of items sold in the shopwould have been a reward in itself butthe real beauty, the gem of my purchase,is the etched image of the shopthat I would like to share with you all.In an artistically licensed compositionyou can almost see the goods for salein the shop and the ladies outside intheir bustles and the fine carriages areclearly visible. Also featured proudlyand prominently is the newly erectedTown Hall built in 1869. In case therecould be any doubt about the identityof the building it is clearly labelled.As a bonus another bill, this time for1898, was purchased but either fashionor costs robbed us of an updatedimage. However the text tells us theywere still drapers but had expandedmanufacturing to include “Aprons,Underclothing, Shirts, Hosiery, Etc.”in addition to pinafores. <strong>The</strong>y werestill “Agents for Brook’s Reels,Chadwick’s and Clark’s Crochet BallsPopular Fingerings and Worsteds.”<strong>The</strong> loyalty of the same particular customerover the years enabled the twobills to come to me together and theirpossession sparked a fuller investigationof the cousins Joseph and theirfamilies. For clarity the elder Joseph,son of David will be referred to asJoseph I and the younger, son of Thomaswill be Joseph II.In 1881 Joseph I was aged 44 and livingat 6, Lord Street, Halifax, with hiswife Hannah aged 50 and their threedaughters Mary Ellen, age 19, Lucyage13, and Louisa age 8. He was alinen draper employing three assistants.At the same time, Joseph II wasaged 28 and living at 42, GrosvenorSquare, Halifax with his wife Mary Aand three year old daughter EthelMary.In 1901 there is no trace of Joseph I inHalifax but Joseph II is there in theindex and he is a draper. My mindlogically determined that he mighthave taken over his cousin’s business.Bindex gave Joseph I as dying in1909, an essential date needing verification.I took advantage of the wider searchesavailable for the 1901 census, lookingnot only nationwide but also doing afuzzy search for the missing Joseph Iwho would be aged 64. I was rewardedwith a Joseph Bines (sic) aged64, who was a retired draper living inAudley Villa, Frodsham, Cheshire.<strong>The</strong> other family members indexed as<strong>Binns</strong> were a wife, Jane aged 59, adaughter Lucy, age 33, and a femaleservant Susan, at first an elusive Cinderella.When the census image itselfwas viewed it was clear however, thatSusan did not in fact share the <strong>Binns</strong>name. Joseph I was now married to aJane who was born in Audley, Staffordshirewhereas in 1881 his wifewas called Hannah and was born inUnder Winder Sedbergh. In fact othersources had already established thatJoseph I had married Hannah Robinsonat Lancaster Church [Sep Q 1860]so was that the end of his Quakermembership? Presumably Hannah haddied and I did find the marriage of aJoseph <strong>Binns</strong> to a Jane Bibby registeredin September Quarter 1899 inChester.%,116&211(&7,216
<strong>The</strong> Two Josephs cont’d……………………..So Joseph I had retired from Halifaxand his cousin Joseph II had takenover the business,.. or had he? I havethe certificate for the marriage of JosephII at St Jude’s Church, Bradford,dated 25 th September 1876. He giveshis age as 24, his occupation as a travellerof Halifax, and his father is Thomasa draper. His wife is Mary AnnHinchliff of Blenheim Road, thedaughter of Benjamin Hinchliff, awarehouseman. Further the 1901 censusimages reveal that Joseph II wasin Halifax just as a visitor to anotherdraper and his only daughter, EthelMary, is in Bradford at the home ofher grandfather Benjamin Hinchliff.<strong>The</strong>re is no sign of her mother. Can Iassume she was dead? <strong>The</strong> 1901 censusrecords point to Joseph II having adrapery business in Bradford ratherthan Halifax. Sadly it looks as if the<strong>Binns</strong> name is nearly extinguished inthe family of Joseph II, with just oneillegitimate flicker remaining to thisday descended from Joseph II’s sister,Sarah Frances.Well, what of the fine shop in Halifax?<strong>The</strong>re appears to be three daughtersborn to Joseph I and Hannah, soperhaps no one to carry on the business.Only one daughter, Lucy, aged33, appears on the 1901 census at thesame address as Joseph I and she wasa Deputy Matron in a hospital. I mightnever have known more were it notfor the discovery that a Joseph <strong>Binns</strong>died in Frodsham in 1909 and his Willis available through the Cheshire<strong>Family</strong> History Society website. Acopy of the full Will revealed that itwas made in Saltburn where, I think,he and his new wife Jane must havegone on ‘Honeymoon’. <strong>The</strong> Will confirmsthat Jane is his wife, his daughterLucy was a hospital nurse inDerby, and Louisa was living in Halifax.<strong>The</strong>re is mention made of a sonin-law,William Sutcliffe Ingham butnot of his elder daughter Mary Ellen.Sure enough, I found a marriage registeredin September Quarter 1885, inHalifax, between Mary Ellen <strong>Binns</strong>and William Sutcliffe Ingham, so itseems probable that Mary Ellen haddied before the Will was made in1899.My tale reinforces the fundamentallesson to check original records whereverpossible. You will have seen howmisleading transcription and abbreviatedsearch indexes can be.I am indebted to Bindex for the elusivefacts that enabled my tale to betold. With grateful thanks to Donaldand to those who continued his work,Leslie, Alan, and David and his sonIan <strong>Binns</strong>.Addendum: Four relevant snippets1902 March 22 <strong>The</strong> Nursing Recordand Hospital World; LADY SUPER-INTENDENT Miss Lucy <strong>Binns</strong> hasbeen appointed Matron of the RoyalInfirmary, Hull. She was trained forthree years at the General Infirmary,Leeds, where she subsequently wasappointed <strong>The</strong>atre Sister. She has alsobeen Night Superintendent at theRoyal Infirmary, Derby, in which institutionshe has for the last two yearsand a half held the position of AssistantMatron.1908 July 20 <strong>The</strong> Times; Lucy <strong>Binns</strong>signatory to letter on nurses registrationas Matron at Royal InfirmaryHull.1918 June 18 London Gazette; MissLucy <strong>Binns</strong>, Lady Superintendant Matronat Hull Royal Infirmary awardedRoyal Red Cross Second Class.1918 July 20 <strong>The</strong> British Journal ofNursing; <strong>The</strong> King conferred <strong>The</strong>Royal Red Cross, Second Class, onLady Superintendent Lucy <strong>Binns</strong>, ofthe Civil Nursing Service.AND FINALLYI wonder if Lucy was advocated of theuse of the <strong>Binns</strong> ‘nit comb’ as mentionedin <strong>The</strong> British Journal of Nursingof 24 November 1917.3DJH%,116&211(&7,216