Reflections on 12 years as DeanBY PAUL BRESTSIP REP ARE DTOW RIT E some remInISCenCesfor this issue of<strong>Stanford</strong> <strong>Lawyer</strong>, I glanced at the Fall1987 issue, in which I first appeared as Dean. Thecover photo elicited my first angry letter from an alumnus, whodisapproved ofmy somewhat casual dress. While my wardrobehas improved since then, I fear that he still would be disappointedby my lack ofgravitas a dozen years later. Nonetheless,I've learned a lot during these years. I'm always amazed whenI hear that the average tenure ofa law school dean today is onlyabout three years. It took me that long just to understand whatthe job was and to begin figuring out how to do it.Among the things I learned-tomy surprise and to the astonishment ofthose who knew me before-was to be apretty good fundraiser. (Necessity is themother ofself-invention.) I vividly recallthe first time I asked an alumnus for a gift:I was so nervous that I could not stoptalking, and I negotiated down my initialrequest for $1,000 to halfthat amountwithout ever letting him say a word. Tenyears later, I sat across the desk ofanotherprospect and allowed silence to envelopus as he contemplated an eight-figure request,which ultimately led to a seven-figuregift. One of my most memorablefundraising moments occurred last yearwhen I invited myself to join an alumnicouple at their wedding anniversary dinner,and asked for a major contributionto the Campaign. (It was a bonding ex-perience; they remain good friends andmade a generous gift.) 1() paraphraseBarry Goldwater, shamelessness in thecause of<strong>Stanford</strong> Law Schoo] is no vice,and modenltion no \lrme.One of the greatest joys of thedeanship has been getting to know alumni,learning from them, and bringingwhat I learned back to the Law School.In the process, I've made some lifelongfriends-and I also have a few really goodstories that I'll tell over a beer. I'm basicallya shy person and, at first, I found itdifficult to make small talk. Spectatorsports can be a great ice-breaker, but myignorance was awesome. After trying tocoach me early on, a colleague gave upand suggested that if! found myselfcorneredin a conversation about any sport,I should just say, "How about themNiners!" Our Provost, Condoleezza Rice,was more helpful. When she heard thatCarmen Policy was about to host a parents'night at 3Com Park, she took Irisand me to a <strong>Stanford</strong> football game,placed one ofus on each side, and mentoredus. (Like war, Condi explained,football is a game of territory.) Some ofit stuck, but to this day Carmen wonderswhat planet we came from.People attribute the short tenureof deans to the difficulties of dealing~ SlIMMFR <strong>1999</strong>
with the faculty-"herding cats" is acommon metaphor. If so, that explainsmy relatively long tenure. Of course, Ihave a little black book ofsecrets aboutcolleagues that could nicely supplementmy future income. But the <strong>Stanford</strong> lawfaculty's spirit, commitment, and forgivenesshave made this dean's life a joy.With respect to forgiveness, I think particularlyofa day-long retreat that I unintentionallyscheduled on Big Gameday. (See spectator sports, supra.) It willbe another half-century before the Deanof <strong>Stanford</strong> Law School can mentionthe word "retreat" or "facilitator." Ifthere's one take-home point from myyears as an administrator, it's how muchone can accomplish when the faculty areinformed and consulted, and how badlythings go if they are blindsided.The students also have been a joy.The practice of leaving my office dooropen has led to conversations on everyministrative staff working behind thescenes. My first instinct as Dean was tomicromanage everything. It took a whileto learn that micromanaging a well-functioningadministrative unit was counterproductive,and that micromanaginga poorly functioning unit just postponedaddressing its problems. Perhaps themost important thing I've learned aboutorganizations is how much they dependon people regularly going beyond theirformal job descriptions, how much theirwillingness to do this depends on thespirit of the place-and the importanceof the CEO in maintaining that spirit.Like most law professors, I had littlecurrent knowledge ofthe careers intowhich we send our students. Twelve yearslater, I have a pretty good sense of theprofession. I could also write the definitivecoffee-table book on comparativelaw firm decor.A few years ago, <strong>Stanford</strong> took theour graduates are finding rewarding careers(in all senses) in business. The twinchallenges for the School and the professionare how to increase the professionaland personal satisfactions of privatepractice, and how to expand theLoan Repayment Assistance Programand find other means to enable <strong>Stanford</strong>graduates to pursue careers in public servicedespite the mounting costs of privateeducation.Turning to the School's core educationalmission, the past 12 years havebeen a period of considerable experimentationand innovation. We have developedleading programs in business,technology, environmental law, and conflictresolution. My greatest disappointmentinvolves public interest. Despitestrong course offerings, we lack a coregroup offaculty whom the students canlook to as mentors and, at least until recently,we have not had strong clinicalONE OF THE GREATEST JOYS OF THE DEANSHIP HAS BEEN GETTING TO KNOW ALUMNI, LEARNING FROMTHEM, AND BRINGING WHAT I LEARNED BACK TO THE LAW SCHOOL. IN THE PROCESS,I'VE MADE SOMELIFELONG FRIENDS-AND I ALSO HAVE A FEW REALLY GOOD STORIES THAT I'LL TELL OVER A BEER.conceivable topic-and some inconceivableones-and to an appreciationof students' varied backgrounds, interests,and concerns. Sure, there have beenmoments of tension as well. In contrastto most other graduate students, oursare a pretty political bunch, with themost "progressive" voices usually beingthe loudest. All things being equal, I prefernot to be depicted as Genghis Khan.But a law school would be an impoverishedplace if students were indifferentto the pressing social issues ofour times.As a faculty member, I did not appreciatejust how much the School's functioningdepended on an excellent adleadin establishing an annual "conversation"among a dozen law school deansand partners from the nation's majorfirms. We discuss an array of commonissues, including the academy's role inpreparing students for practice, the ethosand diversity of the profession, and itsglobalization. The problem that mostconcerns me-and many managing partners-isthe reported decline of satisfactionwith large law firm practice. Incontrast, many alumni working in governmentand the not-for-profit sectorfind their work fulfilling even while earningfar less than they could in privatepractice. And an increasing number ofplacements. On the bright side, the numberand quality ofclinical placements atthe East Palo Alto Law Project were atan all-time high this year. The challengenow is to create a vibrant public interestcommunity within the School.At the same time as the faculty hasbuilt pillars ofsubstantive excellence, wehave been rethinking trans-substantiveaspects ofthe curriculum. These includeskills useful across a wide range ofcareers(e.g., communication, quantitative methods,policy analysis, problem solving,and negotiation), ethics and professionalresponsibility, and new approaches toContinued 011 page 68~TANF()RD LAWVlR ED