<strong>Guild</strong> Notes ▪ Summer/Fall 2009Hugh Manes loses battle with emphysema at 84Hugh Manes, 1924-2009. Photo by NikolManes and courtesy of the Los AngelesTimes.The following obituary is excerptedfrom the one written by Elaine Woo andpublished in the Los Angeles Times onJune 18, 2009.Hugh R. Manes, veteran civil rightslawyer and long-time <strong>Guild</strong> member,died in June after a long battle withemphysema.Manes was born in Chicago on July7, 1924. After graduating high school,he joined the Army as a second lieutenantand served in Europe during WorldWar II. Injured in combat, he was fondof telling people that he was awarded aSilver Star and a Purple Heart while sittingon a bed pan in a military hospital.After the war, he earned a BA atUCLA and a law degree at NorthwesternUniversity in 1952. He began hiscareer at the LA law firm of Wirin,Rissman & Okrand, which was headedby A.L. Wirin, the longtime chief counselof the ACLU in Los Angeles.Manes worked on a number of caseswith the ACLU, representing JapaneseAmericans who had lost property as aresult of federal actions after the PearlHarbor attack and individuals who hadbeen targeted as communists by theHouse Un-American Activities Committee.During the 1960s, he workedwith lawyers from the NLG to gatherevidence of the disenfranchisement ofblack voters in Mississippi. He also representedmen seeking draft defermentsand conscientious objector status.Manes began representing victimsof police misconduct in the 1960s.He tried more than 400 cases duringhis career, and was “probably one ofthe finest” advocates for police-abusevictims in Southern California, saidRobert R. Devich, who presided over a1995 police brutality trial that resultedin a record-setting $23-million award toa group of Samoan-Americans representedby Manes and two colleagues.Manes, who looked like WinstonChurchill and could fill a courtroomwith his baritone voice, encouragedand trained dozens of lawyers to handlecases involving excessive force orother allegations against law enforcementofficers. He offered free monthlyseminars for years at his office in themid-Wilshire area and helped establishthe Police Misconduct <strong>Lawyers</strong> ReferralService, which matched attorneys withpotential clients.According to colleagues, Manesroutinely took on cases with littleexpectation of success or remuneration,particularly in the early years whenfew people believed that police officerscould be guilty of misconduct.Manes is survived by two daughters,Mehgan and Nikol; three sons, Macabee,Ellery and Ari; a sister, AudreyBenesch; and eight grandchildren. □William Moffitt dies—“Empowering the voiceless”by Heidi BoghosianWilliam B. Moffitt died on April24, 2009, at the age of 60, after beinghospitalized for breathing difficulties.He fell into a coma and never regainedconsciousness. In 2000, Bill was thekeynote speaker at the <strong>Guild</strong>’s annualconvention in Boston, Massachusetts.Bill, along with NLG member LindaMoreno, served as defense attorneyfor Dr. Sami Al-Arian, negotiating aplea agreement with the governmentin 2006. Writing about Bill’s death,Dr. Al-Arian recalled how Bill visitedhim in his daughter’s apartment in aWashington suburb, where he was underhouse arrest. “He was still his old self,a maverick, who deeply cared aboutjustice and civil rights, the constitutionand empowering the voiceless.” Forover three years, from 2003-2006, Dr.Al-Arian was placed in solitary confinement,having no contact with anyoneexcept Bill Moffitt and Linda Moreno.Bill was a highly regarded criminaldefense attorney and a named partnerat the firm Asbill Moffitt & Boss inWashington, DC. He served as presidentof the <strong>National</strong> Association of CriminalDefense <strong>Lawyers</strong> from 1999-2000. Hehad been a member of the Board of▪ 26 ▪Directors of the ACLU and had alsoserved as president of the Virginia Collegeof Criminal Defense <strong>Lawyers</strong>, nowthe Virginia Association of CriminalDefense <strong>Lawyers</strong>, an NACDL affiliateorganization. He was a member ofthe bars of Virginia and the District ofColumbia, the Alexandria (Va.) BarAssociation, the American Board ofCriminal <strong>Lawyers</strong>, and the InternationalAssociation of Criminal <strong>Lawyers</strong>. Heserved as a criminal justice expert onnumerous media programs, including:Today Show, CNN’s Crossfire, ABCand CBS News. He is survived by hiswife, Edna, and daughter Pilar. □
Notes-worthy NewsLegendary <strong>Guild</strong> lawyer, Susan Jordan, diesby Paul HarrisWhen someone writes a history of great progressivelawyers, Susan Jordan will be included. Tragically, in May,this long-time <strong>Guild</strong> member died in a small plane crash atthe age of 67.In the 1960s, Susan volunteered to register black votersin Mississippi. This experience sparked her interest in law.She said, “I really admired the lawyers who were engagedin the civil rights movement . . . I knew then that’s what Iwanted to do.”Susan began law practice in 1970 with the People’s LawOffice in Chicago. At the time there were almost no womencriminal defense lawyers in private practice. She experiencedsexism and overt harassment from judges, bailiffs andother attorneys. But she persevered and overcame, eventuallymoving to San Francisco where her skills in federal andstate courts earned her inclusion in the book Best <strong>Lawyers</strong> inAmerica.While teaching part-time at New College Law School,Susan described herself as “a radical feminist who bringsthat political analysis to all aspects of my legal work.” In1974, she represented Inez Garcia in what would become theseminal case in educating and changing how the legal systemtreats violence against women. Ms. Garcia had been convictedof second degree murder for killing a man who helpedrape her. Hired for the retrial, Susan used a self-defensestrategy informed by the women’s movement and won a juryacquittal. For those who want to read about Susan’s work onthe Inez Garcia case, see Black Rage Confronts the Law.Against legal obstacles, a few years later, Susan began toraise the battered woman syndrome defense in jury trials. Sheis considered one of the pioneers of this now successful andconsciousness-raising strategy.Susan split her time between living and practicing in theSan Francisco Bay Area and in the Redwoods of MendocinoCounty. She represented Earth First!, political prisoner MarilynBuck, members of the Symbionese Liberation Army, andeveryday people in trouble with the law. She also co-foundedWomen Defenders, an organization of women criminaldefense lawyers. To deal with the negative aspects of the adversarialsystem, she practiced and taught yoga and organizedmeditation sessions grounded in the Theravada tradition ofBuddhism.Susan and her husband, R.C. Wong, adopted a daughter,Jennifer, when she was 7 years old. Jennifer, with the collaborationof photographer Roslyn Banish, wrote a beautifuland enlightening book titled A Forever Family. The movingphoto of Susan, R.C. and Jennifer on the cover is, by itself,Susan B. Jordan. Photo © Roslyn Banish.worth the purchase.Heartfelt messages of solidarity and courtroom storiesfrom friends and colleagues are traveling throughout theInternet. Susan’s long-time friend Jennie Rhine wrote, “I firstmet Susan Jordan early in the 1970s, soon after she relocatedto the Bay Area from Chicago, at the <strong>National</strong> <strong>Lawyers</strong><strong>Guild</strong>’s annual convention outside of Boulder, Colorado. Theburgeoning women’s movement made sexism a hot issue atthe time, and Susan caught my attention at the meeting whenshe publicly told a male colleague to ‘put it away and zip itup!’ Susan was always ready to tell you what she thought!”Another fierce advocate of the dispossessed, LynneStewart, wrote, “I miss Susan presently and forever, as mymentor, my sister lawyer, but mostly as a kindred spirit lovinglife and fighting for justice.”Paul Harris had the privilege of working with Susanon numerous cases. He teaches “Guerrilla Lawyering” atGolden Gate Law School. □▪ 27 ▪