Hon'ble Mr. Justice Surinder Singh, Judge. - High Court of Himachal ...

More documents

Recommendations

Info

- 4 -alleged that relying upon his experience,qualification and performance was sure to beselected and took steps to seek informationunder the RTI whereby he was supplied withAnnexure P-4, the marks awarded by theselection Committee to each of thecandidates with a note appended to it withrelated information as required. Out of 12candidates, 6 appeared in the interview. Eachof them were awarded marks as follows andthe note to it is shown below:-S/NameofMarks AwardedNCandidateAcademic Qualification1. Sh. MangatRam S/oSh. ChauRamB.A.%AgrtX.25%DiplomainComp/PGDCAAgrtX.25%ExtraQualificationExperienceInterviewTotalRemar50 % 12.5 60.86% 15.2 Absenkst2. Sh. PadamSingh S/oSh. AttarSingh44.9%11.2 80% 20 Absent3. Sh.Surinder Singh S/oSh.MiknuRam4. Sh.AnilKumar S/oSh.MautuRam50% 12.5 59.2%PGDCA14.8 15 5 47.344% 11 49% 12.2 15 6 44.25. Km.CharuSehgal D/OSh.PawanKumar6. Sh.Surender SinghS/o Sh.Amer Singh77.9%45.5%19.4 - - Absent11.3 - - Absent
- 5 -7. Sh.BhopalSingh S/OSh. SaujuRam8. Km.NishaDevi D/OSh. MastRam9. Sh.PramodKumar S/OSh. KartarSingh51.1%47.9%50.4%12.2 55% 13.7 15 3 43.911.9 75% 18.7 15 6 51.612.6 75% 18.7 Absent10.11.Sh. BharatSingh S/OSh.BalwantSinghKm.SanjuBala D/OLt. DaulatRamB.SC(IT)45.3%16.2 - - 15 9 40.211.3 50.83% 12.7 Absent12.Sh. VinayKumar S/oSh. VedPrakash55.65%13.9 75% 20 20 11 64.9Note:-The interview for the post of IT volunteer of Jubbal Tehsil was conducted on09.09.2009 and as per the merit drawn for the purpose candidate at Sr. No.(12) ShriVinay Kumar graded at top of merit, but there was another candidate Sh. Bharat Singh,B.Sc (IT) at Sr.No.(10) who in the selection criteria graded much lower to the candidate atSr. No.(12). As per the guidelines framed in this behalf laid down in the selection criteriathat if candidate with qualification such as BCA/ MCA/ MSc IT/ BSc IT are available, theywould be given preference over candidate with PGDCA. So under these circumstances theselection committee recommends candidate at Sr.No.(10) to be appointed as IT volunteerfor Jubbal Tehsil.Sd/- Sd/- Sd/-Additional District Magistrate (P),Shimla District Informatics Officer, Shimla DistrictRevenue Officer, Shimla.[Emphasis mine]6. The another information supplied underRTI to the petitioner reveals that the followingcriteria was adopted for the interview on9.9.2009:
Page 1 and 2: IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADE
Page 3: - 3 -‘(i) Applicants applying for
Page 7 and 8: - 7 -as compared to respondent Bhar
Page 9 and 10: - 9 -professional degree in the tra
Page 11: - 11 -computer course and shall mak

Hon'ble Mr. Justice Surinder Singh, Judge. - High Court of Himachal ...

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?