8. On 9 February, the <strong>Audit</strong>or General briefed the Public <strong>Audit</strong> Committee on the jointAccounts Commission/<strong>Audit</strong>or General Edinburgh trams – interim report. At meetings on23 February and 2 <strong>March</strong>, the Committee heard evidence from:Edinburgh City Council - Sue Bruce, Chief Executive; Donald McGougan, Director ofFinance; Dave Anderson, Director of City Development; and Alastair Maclean, Headof Legal and Administrative ServicesTIE - Richard Jeffrey, Chief ExecutiveTransport <strong>Scotland</strong> - David Middleton, Chief Executive; and Ainslie McLaughlin, Director of Major Transport Infrastructure Projects.The Committee may issue a statement on the Edinburgh trams project.9. At its meeting on 23 February, the <strong>Audit</strong>or General briefed the Public <strong>Audit</strong> Committeeon the joint Accounts Commission/<strong>Audit</strong>or General report on The cost of public sectorpensions in <strong>Scotland</strong>. The Committee agreed to include comments on the report withinits legacy paper and to refer the report to the Finance Committee for information.10. The <strong>Audit</strong>or General also briefed the Committee on the joint AccountsCommission/<strong>Audit</strong>or General report Maintaining <strong>Scotland</strong>’s roads: A follow-up report.The Committee also decided to include comments on this report in its legacy paper. TheCommittee also agreed to note correspondence from the Accountable Officer and theUK Government on Improving energy efficiency: A follow-up report.11. The Public <strong>Audit</strong> Committee has published its reports on Getting it right for children inresidential care and The Gathering 2009. Both are available for download from theScottish Parliament’s website.12. On 3 <strong>March</strong>, the Public <strong>Audit</strong> Committee led a debate in the Chamber on the keythemes that the Committee has considered throughout the current Parliamentarysession. The discussion covered transparency, data collection and qualitymeasurement, and governance. Hugh Henry MSP, PAC Convenor, commented on theCommittee’s inability to scrutinise local government expenditure or investigate reportsfrom <strong>Audit</strong> <strong>Scotland</strong> or the Accounts Commission that relate to local government issues.John Swinney MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth,acknowledged the Committee’s frustration and noted the role of the AccountsCommission in scrutinising local government. The Official Report of the debate isavailable for download from the Scottish Parliament’s website.13. The current session of the Parliament ends on 22 <strong>March</strong>, and the Parliament will bedissolved with effect from 00:01 on 23 <strong>March</strong> in advance of the Scottish election on 5May.Other issues14. The Scottish Government has confirmed that all 32 councils had formally accepted thedetailed terms of the proposed funding settlement for <strong>2011</strong>/12 by the deadline of 28February. As a result, the average cash reduction in resource budgets for <strong>2011</strong>/12 willbe 2.6% rather than 6.4%. Amendments to the Local Government Finance Order <strong>2011</strong>giving effect to this funding distribution and funding to compensate for councils freezingcouncil tax will be considered by the Parliament prior to dissolution.2
15. As part of the debate on the <strong>2011</strong>/12 Scottish Budget, The Cabinet Secretary forFinance and Sustainable Growth, John Swinney MSP, announced that he intended toallocate an additional £5 million to help smooth the impact of the redistribution of thisfunding within the <strong>2011</strong>-12 local government finance settlement.16. On 3 <strong>March</strong>, Susan Deacon, Honorary Professor, School of Social and PoliticalScience, University of Edinburgh, has published her independent report for the ScottishGovernment on early years policy, Joining the dots: A better start for <strong>Scotland</strong>’schildren.Conclusion<strong>17</strong>. The Commission is invited to consider and note this report.Fraser McKinlayController of <strong>Audit</strong>, 9 <strong>March</strong> <strong>2011</strong>3