More specifically, this review will consider EU competence in:- Trade in goods within the Internal Market, as well as the way in which thistrade is regulated, including through product regulation; product safety; qualitylabelling; market surveillance; and standardisation;- The EU Customs Union, collection <strong>of</strong> taxes and duties at the EU frontier andcustoms’ role in trade facilitation; and- Intellectual property, for which EU legislation provides some uniformsystems <strong>of</strong> protection for unitary rights, and also affects internal and externaltrade.3. CompetenceFor the purposes <strong>of</strong> this review, we are using a broad definition <strong>of</strong> competence.Put simply, competence in this context is about everything deriving from EU lawthat affects what happens in the UK. That means examining all the areas wherethe Treaties give the EU competence to act, including the provisions in theTreaties giving the EU institutions the power to legislate, to adopt non-legislativeacts, or to take any other sort <strong>of</strong> action. But it also means examining areaswhere the Treaties apply directly to the Member States without needing anyfurther action by the EU institutions.The EU’s competences are set out in the EU Treaties. These provide the basisfor any actions the EU institutions take. The EU can only act within the limits <strong>of</strong>the competences conferred on it by the Treaties. Where the Treaties do notconfer competences on the EU, they remain with the Member States. The freemovement <strong>of</strong> goods, including the Customs Union and intellectual property, isspecifically covered in Articles 28 to 37, and 118 <strong>of</strong> the Treaty on the Functioning<strong>of</strong> the EU (TFEU).There are different types <strong>of</strong> competence: exclusive, shared and supporting. Onlythe EU can act in areas where it has exclusive competence, such as the customsunion and common commercial policy. In areas <strong>of</strong> shared competence, such asthe Internal Market or environment and energy, either the EU or the MemberStates may act, but the Member States may be prevented from acting once theEU has done so. In areas <strong>of</strong> supporting competence, such as culture, tourismand education, both the EU and the Member States may act, but action by theEU does not prevent the Member States from taking action <strong>of</strong> their own.The EU must act in accordance with fundamental rights as set out in the Charter<strong>of</strong> Fundamental Rights (such as freedom <strong>of</strong> expression and non-discrimination)and the principles <strong>of</strong> subsidiarity and proportionality. Under the principle <strong>of</strong>subsidiarity, where the EU does not have exclusive competence, it can only act ifit is better placed than the Member States to do so because <strong>of</strong> the scale oreffects <strong>of</strong> the proposed action. Under the principle <strong>of</strong> proportionality, the content4
and form <strong>of</strong> EU action must not exceed what is necessary to achieve theobjectives <strong>of</strong> the EU treaties.4. Objectives <strong>of</strong> this reviewThe aim <strong>of</strong> the review is to consider:(1) how and why EU competence has developed on trade in goods within theInternal Market; the Customs Union; and the protection <strong>of</strong> intellectual property;(2) what the current balance <strong>of</strong> competence is between the UK and the EU inthese areas;(3) how this competence is exercised in practice, including whether it is workingin the UK’s national interest; and(4) the EU’s current direction <strong>of</strong> travel in these areas, including the potentialfuture development <strong>of</strong> the Internal Market, Customs Union and intellectualproperty rights policy, and future challenges and opportunities for the UK.This review will seek to address the issues in a comprehensive, evidence-based,and analytical way. Whilst it is being led by the <strong>Gov</strong>ernment, it will also involvenon-governmental experts, organisations and other individuals who wish to feedin their views. Foreign governments, including our EU partners, and the EUinstitutions, are also invited to contribute. The progress <strong>of</strong> the review will betransparent, including in respect <strong>of</strong> the contributions submitted to it.This part <strong>of</strong> the Balance <strong>of</strong> Competences review will explore the current state <strong>of</strong>EU competence on the free movement <strong>of</strong> goods within the Internal Market,setting out areas <strong>of</strong> exclusive EU competence; areas outside EU competence(and therefore reserved to Member States) and where the boundary currently sitsin areas <strong>of</strong> shared competence.Links to other reviewsThe free movement <strong>of</strong> goods is just one <strong>of</strong> the ‘Four <strong>Free</strong>doms’ that make up theEU’s Internal Market (see diagram below). The other three ‘freedoms’ will becovered in separate reports, and there will be an overall Synoptic Review toexamine the Internal Market as a whole.5