Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
1<br />
<strong>November</strong> <strong>2015</strong>
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
ON THE COVER:<br />
One of Austrian artist<br />
Stephanie Rauchwarter’s<br />
6-meter Pyjamen kites.<br />
More on page 21.<br />
NOVEMBER <strong>2015</strong><br />
From the Editors 3<br />
Correspondence 5<br />
Contributors 6<br />
AKA Convention 7<br />
SCOTT SKINNER<br />
Off to the Birthplace of Kites 12<br />
ALI FUJINO<br />
Why Kites? 21<br />
STEPHANIE RAUCHWARTER<br />
Kites, the Art of Using Natural Materials 30<br />
SCOTT SKINNER<br />
The Experiments of 1899: Wilbur and 35<br />
Orville Wright Fly a Kite<br />
TOM D. CROUCH<br />
Drachen Foundation does<br />
not own rights to any of the<br />
articles or photographs<br />
within, unless stated. Authors<br />
and photographers retain all<br />
rights to their work. We<br />
thank them for granting us<br />
permission to share it here. If<br />
you would like to request<br />
permission to reprint an<br />
article, please contact us at<br />
discourse@drachen.org, and<br />
we will get you in touch<br />
with the author.<br />
Mikio Toki 46<br />
SCOTT SKINNER<br />
2
FROM THE EDITORS<br />
EDITORS<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
Ali Fujino<br />
Katie Davis<br />
BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
Martin Lester<br />
Joe Hadzicki<br />
Stuart Allen<br />
Dave Lang<br />
Jose Sainz<br />
Ali Fujino<br />
BOARD OF DIRECTORS EMERITUS<br />
Bonnie Wright<br />
Wayne Wilson<br />
Keith Yoshida<br />
ADVISORY BOARD<br />
Paul Reynolds<br />
Drachen Foundation<br />
is a non-profit 501(c)(3)<br />
corporation devoted to the<br />
increase and diffusion of<br />
knowledge about kites<br />
worldwide.<br />
WWW.DRACHEN.ORG<br />
Discourse is published on the<br />
Drachen Foundation website several<br />
times a year and can be downloaded<br />
free at www.drachen.org<br />
(under Browse > Articles).<br />
Playful! I just can’t get past that description<br />
when I think of and see Steffi Rauchwarter’s<br />
kites. Her freedom of expression jumps into<br />
the air on the wings of her imaginative kites<br />
and I smile when I think of “Stupid Fritz” –<br />
what a kite name! Steffi brings her textile and<br />
fine arts background to her cotton-sailed kites<br />
and has worked under the tutelage of fellow<br />
Austrians Anna Rubin and Jan Houterman to<br />
bring these functional and wonderful creations<br />
to festivals throughout Europe. Enjoy her<br />
unique approach and be inspired.<br />
Another inspirational work is the book, Kites,<br />
The Art of Using Natural Materials, by John<br />
Browning. Not a “how-to,” this is a book that<br />
inspires with photographs of John’s wonderful<br />
kites constructed of all-natural materials.<br />
Readers of Discourse and kitemakers of any<br />
background need this book on their library<br />
shelf.<br />
On a much more serious note, we are happy<br />
to have a contribution from Tom Crouch,<br />
Senior Curator of Aeronautics at the<br />
Smithsonian Air and Space Museum. Crouch<br />
examines the early years of the Wright<br />
Brothers’ flight experiments and their first<br />
thoughts on flight stability. Their chosen<br />
analytical tool: a four-line, controllable,<br />
“peculiar sort of box kite!” Thanks to Tom for<br />
revisiting this essay and allowing us to publish<br />
it.<br />
Ali Fujino jumps back in time to 1988 and<br />
reminisces about travel to the birthplace of<br />
kites with one of the United States’ great kite<br />
ambassadors, Dave Checkley. Personally, this<br />
3
was a wonderful trip for me – not only in<br />
meeting Ali, but also in meeting kite friends<br />
Karen Gurezka, Jenny and Clyde Cook, actress<br />
Gloria Stuart, and Simon Frieden, among<br />
others. Peter Lynn tells me that the kite scene is<br />
exploding in China – take a look at these early<br />
days for some perspective.<br />
I took the opportunity to write about two<br />
events: the AKA Convention in Enid,<br />
Oklahoma, and the Japan America Society of<br />
Colorado’s “Kite Days.” The Convention<br />
continues to be a showcase of American<br />
kitemaking and flying, while the JASC event<br />
was an opportunity for Coloradans to meet<br />
and work with Mikio Toki of Tokyo, Japan. One<br />
event inspires by its volume, while the other<br />
inspires with small moments, but both prove<br />
the power of kites to move us.<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
Board President<br />
Drachen Foundation<br />
4
CORRESPONDENCE<br />
I think that kite [in Christopher Skinner’s article<br />
“Kites in a Middle School Science Classroom”]<br />
has a lot of character and just looking at it tells<br />
me that kites don’t have to be perfect as long<br />
as they fly. The joy, the wonderment, the<br />
knowledge they bring when they lift out of<br />
your hands skywards is like putting all three of<br />
those concepts into a fulfillment only flying a<br />
kite you’ve made can bring.<br />
It is scientific and artistic but the beauty is all<br />
in our hands lifting us up. It’s almost spiritual.<br />
Thank you for always sharing.<br />
FRANK KENISKY<br />
USA<br />
Thank you, Drachen Foundation, for being<br />
awesome!<br />
WHATEVER LAB<br />
USA<br />
Great issue!<br />
RICHARD S. ROBERTSON<br />
USA<br />
Another great issue from the end of the line:<br />
Drachen Foundation’s Discourse. With an<br />
interesting story on KAPer Oscar Frey.<br />
KAPSHOP.COM<br />
USA<br />
5
CONTRIBUTORS<br />
TOM D. CROUCH<br />
Washington, DC<br />
Crouch is Senior Curator of Aeronautics at<br />
the Smithsonian’s National Air and Space<br />
Museum. He holds a PhD from Ohio<br />
State University and is author or editor of<br />
15 books and many articles for scholarly<br />
journals and popular magazines.<br />
Eric Long<br />
ALI FUJINO<br />
Seattle, Washington<br />
From work at the Smithsonian to her<br />
present status as Director of Advancement<br />
for the Alaska Wilderness League, Fujino<br />
continues her 24 years with the<br />
Drachen Foundation by serving on<br />
Drachen’s Board of Directors.<br />
Fujino Family<br />
STEPHANIE RAUCHWARTER<br />
Vienna, Austria<br />
Rauchwarter studied painting<br />
and textile art at the Academy of<br />
Fine Art Vienna, changed to the<br />
Academy of Applied Art, and finished<br />
in graphic design. She lives and<br />
works in Vienna.<br />
Collaction<br />
SCOTT SKINNER<br />
Monument, Colorado<br />
A former Air Force instructor<br />
pilot, Drachen’s board president<br />
has flown and designed kites for<br />
three decades. Today, Skinner is<br />
known as a world class,<br />
visionary kite artist.<br />
Courtesy Scott Skinner<br />
6
AKA CONVENTION<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
I have to admit, over 30 years after my first<br />
American Kitefliers Association (AKA)<br />
Convention in 1983, I still get excited to attend<br />
this annual event. My schedule conspired to<br />
give me only three days at this year’s edition,<br />
held in Enid, Oklahoma. In fact, one of those<br />
three days was Monday, when the convention<br />
hadn’t actually officially started. At any rate,<br />
even with a relatively lightly attended<br />
convention (I was #119 and I registered in<br />
Enid), I still found this to be an opportunity to<br />
see people I haven’t seen in years, to see kites<br />
unveiled for the very first time, and to share<br />
kite lore old and new.<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
Kites fly at the <strong>2015</strong> American Kitefliers Association<br />
(AKA) Convention in Enid, Oklahoma.<br />
I was fortunate to watch much of the<br />
comprehensive kitemaking field competition,<br />
and it was a day that did no favors for the<br />
competitors. Very light and sporadic winds<br />
made every flight a test of skill and light-wind/<br />
light-weight construction. Competition<br />
categories had minimal numbers of<br />
competitors and some categories were<br />
cancelled because of a lack of entries, but, as<br />
usual, the great kites maintained the high<br />
standards of past winners. The comprehensive<br />
kitemaking competition is always a snapshot of<br />
kites at a given time and place – wind<br />
conditions and numbers of competitors are<br />
simply two variables along the road to Grand<br />
National Champion.<br />
Also on the field that day was the beginning of<br />
the fighter kite competition. This has become<br />
one of my favorite pieces of the convention.<br />
Great camaraderie, old and new fighter kite<br />
continued on page 11<br />
7
Scott Skinner<br />
A kite from the Buffalo Kite Project, where organizer<br />
TZ Lee and Drake Smith collaborate with<br />
native artists to produce unique kites.<br />
8
Scott Skinner<br />
The city of Enid is rumored to have been so enamored by the<br />
AKA Convention presence that it may promote an annual<br />
event in years that the convention goes elsewhere.<br />
9
Scott Skinner<br />
In Scott Skinner’s three-stick kite workshop, kitemakers were<br />
limited to using three straight sticks of equal length.<br />
10
designs, and skill to fly in any wind<br />
condition are just a few of the reasons that<br />
this group can do its thing any time, any<br />
place. I brought a little piece of fighter kite<br />
history to the convention auction in the<br />
form of a Vic’s Fighter Kite, still in the<br />
original tube and with original instructions.<br />
I had no idea until I opened it up that it was<br />
an early model with steel cross-spars. The<br />
tube included three cross-spars: one for<br />
light winds, one thicker for heavier winds,<br />
and a third to add for fine adjustments in<br />
intermediate winds. I remember being told<br />
that Vic’s changed their fighter sails from<br />
aluminized mylar to clear mylar because of<br />
incidents with power lines. I wondered if I<br />
had the story wrong and it was these steel<br />
spars that were the problem? Shoot an email<br />
to the Drachen Foundation if you remember<br />
details of the Vic’s Fighter Kite.<br />
an annual event in years that the AKA<br />
Convention goes elsewhere. The Buffalo<br />
Kite Project, where organizer TZ Lee and<br />
Drake Smith collaborate with native artists<br />
to produce unique kites, was in Enid this<br />
year. It seems that these would be a perfect<br />
centerpiece for future kite gatherings in Enid<br />
and collaborations with the variety of<br />
Native American tribes in the area. ◆<br />
During the convention, I presented a hands<br />
on workshop on the three-stick method. I<br />
missed my friend Jose Sainz, who has done<br />
the three-stick workshop with me and<br />
brings a completely different approach to<br />
the problem. But in asking these<br />
experienced kitemakers to be limited by<br />
three straight sticks of equal length, I was<br />
pleased to see a variety of creative endproducts<br />
produced. I was fortunate to have<br />
a cancelled workshop and poor outdoor<br />
weather conspire to give my workshop<br />
many more attendees and as much working<br />
space as was needed for everyone to work<br />
comfortably.<br />
I packed up and left immediately after the<br />
workshop and followed Facebook and the<br />
AKA website for results of the week.<br />
Certainly there were wonderful kites and<br />
great people on the vast flying fields of Enid.<br />
The city of Enid honored Oklahoman and<br />
AKA fixture Richard Dermer by naming the<br />
flying fields in his honor, and there are<br />
rumors that Enid is so enamored by the AKA<br />
Convention presence that it may promote<br />
11
OFF TO THE BIRTHPLACE<br />
OF KITES<br />
Ali Fujino<br />
Ali Fujino<br />
Street scenes in early western tourist China, 1988. Taken<br />
by Ali Fujino on one of the last China kite tours to Weifang<br />
developed and run by David and Dorothea Checkley.<br />
It was the year 1988. There were many firsts<br />
this year. It was the first time I experienced<br />
China. It was the first time I met Scott<br />
Skinner and the world famous actress Gloria<br />
Stuart. It was also the first time I met<br />
kitemaking enthusiasts from around the<br />
world, including the infamous David and<br />
Dorothea Checkley of Seattle, Washington.<br />
Let’s start with China.<br />
1988 was the opening of a “new” China to<br />
the western world. The leadership of Mao<br />
had passed, and China was wiggling its way<br />
into a more modern and more capitalistic<br />
way of life. After centuries of being an<br />
insular country, she opened her doors and<br />
asked people to look in. My photos<br />
illustrate the way it was in 1988, which is<br />
nothing like China today. It was a youthful<br />
country interested in being a part of the<br />
modern international world, lusting after a<br />
lifestyle of personal wealth and a culture of<br />
personal independence. I was NOT the first<br />
westerner to visit China, but I was a part of<br />
that door opening. I found there was little<br />
infrastructure for the western visitor. There<br />
were few hotels and very few restaurants.<br />
China greeted us with as much hospitality<br />
as a restrictive government would allow, but<br />
we were not allowed to explore China on<br />
continued on page 16<br />
12
Ali Fujino<br />
1988 new generation China.<br />
13
Ali Fujino<br />
Scott Skinner with children in Weifang, China.<br />
14
Ali Fujino<br />
TOP: Kitemakers with small swallow kite.<br />
BOTTOM: Colorful monkey kites.<br />
15
our own. We always had a Chinese<br />
government tourist guide. The faces of the<br />
people in my photos show it all. It was still<br />
a country with rules and regimentation.<br />
DAVID AND DOROTHEA CHECKLEY<br />
These two individuals were the reason I was<br />
visiting China. Credited with opening the<br />
western door to the traditional kitemakers of<br />
Japan, it was natural for David and<br />
Dorothea to investigate and open the doors<br />
to the traditional kitemakers of China. David<br />
loved kites, and when he wasn’t working as<br />
a professional architect, he was passionately<br />
involved in kiting. He did it all, making his<br />
own kites and starting a cottage industry of<br />
kite designs and products which he<br />
marketed to small kite companies<br />
throughout the United States. The Checkleys<br />
quickly became the royalty of American<br />
kiting, hosting the first Japanese kitefliers in<br />
the United States, as well as visiting these<br />
kite friends in Japan. It was natural for them<br />
to do the same in China. They developed<br />
the tour for those who were interested in<br />
learning more about Chinese kites and<br />
visiting the “birthplace of kites,” Weifang,<br />
China.<br />
SCOTT SKINNER AND ALI FUJINO<br />
Scott was lured from Colorado Springs,<br />
Colorado to learn more about the kites of<br />
China. This was his first trip, and he signed<br />
up to go with the Checkleys. Others from<br />
around the world did the same thing. There<br />
were representatives from Germany,<br />
Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and Italy,<br />
just to name a few countries. We all wanted<br />
to experience Chinese kites. It all seemed<br />
very simple: you paid the Checkleys the<br />
designated amount for the tour and showed<br />
up at the Beijing Airport on the designated<br />
day. The Checkleys would take it from there.<br />
Welcome to China!<br />
The tour was a gloriously long train trip to<br />
the interior of China. Over the days of living<br />
on a slow-moving steam train, this group of<br />
international kitemakers bonded together<br />
and attempted to make sense of the<br />
nonsensical. As the photos show, we<br />
experienced working China. No matter if it<br />
was a job in government or at the Weifang<br />
Kite Factory, this was a country that knew<br />
how to work hard with a goal of supporting<br />
the greater good. We saw a working and<br />
transitioning China. The magic of<br />
experiencing a new approach to kiting<br />
began to take hold. Lively and late-into-thenight<br />
conversations about Chinese kites<br />
ensued throughout the trip.<br />
I was entertained by the expertise and<br />
personal kites of each international<br />
kitemaker on the tour. Traveling afforded the<br />
opportunity to learn more about each<br />
kitemaker and what they were passionate<br />
about. Scott was working on his American<br />
patchwork quilting of ripstop. Tom<br />
Casselman of Boston, Massachusetts gave us<br />
lessons on besting the Chinese in haggling<br />
for their kites. He wanted to collect Chinese<br />
kites to study them. Simon Winchester from<br />
Australia kept a very detailed journal and<br />
took many photos. Ken Conrad of Seattle,<br />
Washington sourced kites for his popular<br />
kite store in downtown Seattle.<br />
The Chinese wowed us with their<br />
spectacular presentations of kites and<br />
festivals. They were large and wellorchestrated<br />
extravaganzas featuring<br />
thousands of local artists, residents, and<br />
school children, celebrating the excitement<br />
of kites and the westerners there to share in<br />
it!<br />
AND WHAT WAS THE RESULT OF THIS 14 DAY<br />
TOUR?<br />
Scott Skinner and I returned and started<br />
continued on page 20<br />
16
Ali Fujino<br />
The 1988 Weifang Kite Festival.<br />
17
Ali Fujino<br />
The Weifang Kite Factory.<br />
18
Ali Fujino<br />
TOP: Scott Skinner with bamboo kite frame.<br />
BOTTOM: USA stunt kite team: Fujino, Conrad, Casselman.<br />
19
Drachen Design, which designed and<br />
marketed kite products, and later turned<br />
into the Drachen Foundation.<br />
David Checkley passed away that following<br />
year from cancer, but left the door open to<br />
the traditional kiting cultures of Japan and<br />
China.<br />
Tom Casselman became one of the foremost<br />
collectors of Japanese and Chinese kites.<br />
and as a kite artist incorporated many of the<br />
Chinese designs into his own ripstop kites.<br />
Ken Conrad marketed Chinese factory kites<br />
throughout the United States, making it<br />
affordable for anyone to own one, and<br />
started a personal collection featuring some<br />
of the most interesting commerciallyproduced<br />
Chinese kites.<br />
Gloria Stuart, the Los Angeles actress, went<br />
on to play the role of Old Rose in the award<br />
winning movie Titanic and was an Academy<br />
Award nominee for best supporting actress<br />
for her role at 100 years old. She<br />
incorporated what she saw in China into her<br />
final silkscreened, letterpressed, and<br />
collaged limited edition art book, Kites.<br />
Isn’t it interesting what can develop from a<br />
simple tour? ◆<br />
20
WHY KITES?<br />
Stephanie Rauchwarter<br />
Collaction<br />
Austrian artist Stephanie Rauchwarter’s creations:<br />
flags, Adventure Beast, and Pyjamaleausenne.<br />
21
Making kites took me to a big free space.<br />
To work in the field of discrepancy between<br />
physical and nature forces and fantasy is for<br />
me a wonderful challenge. The tension to<br />
realize the design I have in my mind and to<br />
make it fly is very stimulating. When you<br />
keep the mind open, you will be able to<br />
find solutions and alternatives.<br />
To place art pieces in the sky, with alwayschanging<br />
light combined with the<br />
movement caused by the wind, this is a very<br />
special performance. Even the “color white”<br />
gets another quality compared to the<br />
situation on the ground.<br />
To focus on cooperation with the wind<br />
means to practice respect for nature for an<br />
instant, an exercise mankind withdraws<br />
from more and more.<br />
◆◆◆<br />
After my studies at the Academy of Fine Art<br />
Vienna, my work covers fine art and applied<br />
art. Changing between these two fields, I<br />
can move my mind not to get in a routine.<br />
I’m very interested in material and<br />
technique, so I can respond.<br />
I have been practicing textile print with<br />
serigraphy for a long time. We know this<br />
technique from the early 20th century when<br />
pop art worked with photo exposure, but<br />
this technique had its beginning in the Far<br />
East, working with silk paper. Using paper<br />
stencils allows me to work quickly and<br />
spontaneously (see page 23). Doing so, I<br />
can avoid a lot of chemicals, which is good<br />
for the environment and my health. An even<br />
color and sharp contours are typical for this<br />
technique. Apart from painting, collage, and<br />
sheet metal sculptures, silkscreen printing is<br />
a recurrent point in my life.<br />
I have organized an open house in my<br />
studio two times a year for a long time. In<br />
2001 at an event in my studio, I asked Jan<br />
Houtermans to join my exhibition with his<br />
very special paper and bamboo kites. He<br />
suggested he help me build my own kite<br />
using printed cotton. So I printed a sail and<br />
he told me where to put the sticks, the<br />
reinforcements, and the bridle. So I did, the<br />
kite flew well, and I made another one (see<br />
page 24). After that, I was still curious about<br />
which material and form can fly.<br />
I started to concentrate on the idea of<br />
cooperating with wind. Wind? Wind force?<br />
Changing movement?<br />
Curious, I went on to research by trial and<br />
error what forms can fly. Interestingly, not so<br />
much error showed up – it flies more that<br />
we think.<br />
The material was clear: cotton or similar<br />
fabric. It is not very often used in the kite<br />
world, so I had to experience it on my own.<br />
Many people told me that this material is<br />
too heavy and it will get loose, but the<br />
practice showed it is not so.<br />
The weight is not so important for the flying<br />
qualities. There is also the aspect of how<br />
densely the fabric is woven and how<br />
smooth the fibers are. Time after time, wash<br />
by machine and the wind does the ironing.<br />
Cotton kites are more tolerant with gusty<br />
winds. I learned that even four-liners can be<br />
made of this material.<br />
The best feeling you can have is to fly a new<br />
kite the first time. It is exciting, and more<br />
other ideas turn up.<br />
To start the construction of a new kite, I<br />
draw a simple sketch and then I start<br />
printing (see page 25). I never use graph<br />
paper. I just cut the sail freehand, taking<br />
care of the symmetry. Doing the sewing, I<br />
continued on page 26<br />
22
Collaction<br />
From a paper stencil cut with a knife, the form attaches to<br />
the silkscreen when it gets contact with the color.<br />
23
Collaction<br />
My first kites, Numero Uno and Blödfritz(”Stupid Fritz”),<br />
both about 1.5m x 3m. The color I use has very good<br />
UV- resistance and they didn’t lose luminosity.<br />
24
Collaction<br />
Monsterheads and sewing machine, with sketch inset.<br />
25
think, “Oh, it will be up in the sky all<br />
alone,” and make some reinforcements.<br />
Maybe I have the understanding of the<br />
relationship between material and<br />
dimension or just luck. To show the<br />
workflow, let’s have an eye on the Pyjamen<br />
kites (see page 27). The span is nearly six<br />
meters. Every kite has its own pattern, due<br />
to my work as a fabric designer. Because<br />
every kite has different cloth, and therefore<br />
a different amount of printed surface and a<br />
slight deviation in the proportions, it has a<br />
different flying behavior that makes his<br />
character. Steady winds allow them to fly<br />
together, although they are constructed for<br />
different winds. The performances with the<br />
Pyjas is special.<br />
In Austria we seldom have good constant<br />
wind. So I thought, “I want to make some<br />
kites especially for this sort of wind.” I<br />
decided to modify the Thai snake. The long<br />
tail would give more support in a changing<br />
wind, but the movement would be still very<br />
fidgety. I thought about which design could<br />
support such a scene: a group of young<br />
impatient boys standing in line (see page<br />
28). They come into play by gusty strong<br />
winds flying them in a chain. They are<br />
jostling and peeking. Great fun. This is for<br />
me proof that the right design can help<br />
when the wind circumstances are not<br />
perfect!<br />
In 2012, Ramlal Tien and Anna Rubin<br />
organized an artist in residence program<br />
with several artists in the park of a Norman<br />
castle. I started to think about an<br />
installation. Concerned that huge, old trees<br />
and shrubs would cause completely<br />
irregular wind, I remembered the German<br />
word windsbraut. It means on the one hand<br />
a figure of Nordic myth. On the other hand<br />
it means turbulence.<br />
My eolic (”of the wind”) installations, “Die<br />
Windsbräute,” were fixed on the vertical<br />
branches of an old oak so they could<br />
change the direction of the movement easily<br />
(see page 29). The movement was smooth<br />
with the right timing. A wonderful side<br />
effect appeared: when there was no wind<br />
they started to pick their noses and to<br />
scratch their ears. They followed us to<br />
different places and landscapes, and once<br />
they ended up disco dancing in Croatia.<br />
Taking part in kite festivals, I met many<br />
artists beginning my kite career in Cervia at<br />
the Arte Vento Festival in Italy. Claudio<br />
Capelli and his daughter Catarina are<br />
constantly supporting the small niche for<br />
artists that want to take issue with eolic art. I<br />
remember that also at other festivals artists<br />
moved closer to get a view of special<br />
combinations and to give the audience the<br />
chance to get a sense for art in the sky.<br />
The multitude of creations is amazing. I<br />
recognized that these people were very<br />
open-minded. They accepted other styles<br />
with curiosity and sympathy, just happy that<br />
there was another facet of creativity in the<br />
sky. Of course there are some divas, trying<br />
to set up concurrence atmosphere, like it<br />
always is on the ground. But the number of<br />
them is obviously small. So many nations<br />
and generations meet and share wind<br />
condition and environs.<br />
Also the discrepancy between small and<br />
fragile kites and bigger constructions is<br />
easily solved: the small in the foreground<br />
and the bigger higher up make a wonderful<br />
view in the sky, and the tendency to think in<br />
hierarchies never showed up. This process is<br />
developing more and more, for example to<br />
help each other to do a flying show.<br />
Does the sky make us more open-minded or<br />
does this happens just by chance?<br />
Nevertheless, it is worth it to interact in this<br />
interesting climate. ◆<br />
26
Collaction<br />
Pyjamargot jumping over the crane, with sketch inset.<br />
27
Collaction<br />
The Boys, five meters long fresh from my printing table.<br />
INSET: Gusty strong winds fly them in a chain.<br />
28
Collaction<br />
Schetch kites: A bride needs veil, train and lace. Fixed on<br />
fishing rods, the form should be simple to preserve<br />
the vague appearance. Sketch inset.<br />
29
KITES, THE ART OF USING<br />
NATURAL MATERIALS<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
A REVIEW OF:<br />
Kites, The Art of Using Natural Materials<br />
by John Browning<br />
Culicidae Press, <strong>2015</strong><br />
Having come full circle in my own kitemaking,<br />
finding the beauty and utility of paper and<br />
bamboo after years of “festival kites” in ripstop<br />
and fiberglass, John Browning’s new book<br />
strikes a chord within my kitemaking soul. The<br />
use of natural materials is hardly new. The kites<br />
of Muna Island, Indonesia, perhaps the first<br />
kites in the world, were made with only plant<br />
material for both kite and line. But John brings<br />
us into the contemporary kite world with his<br />
creative use of leaves, seeds, natural papers,<br />
and bamboo.<br />
The book is really a picture book of many of<br />
John’s kites, but don’t think there is no hard<br />
information to be had. John gives a complete<br />
list of materials used in every kite, and<br />
although his description of material<br />
preparation is limited, he tells us the most<br />
important thing: it takes time, patience, and<br />
experimentation with every material to<br />
discover the best way to end with a viable sail<br />
material. John’s kite shapes are a mix of<br />
creative and traditional and give the reader a<br />
glimpse into John’s active imagination. I<br />
particularly like his more traditional shapes<br />
and those that are evocative of Polynesian and<br />
Maori designs.<br />
Perhaps the most powerful aspect of the book<br />
is that it clearly shows the kite artist’s most<br />
continued on page 34<br />
30
John Browning<br />
Diptera: Open spaces within the confines of a<br />
minimal frame. I love it because it is another<br />
of the endless three-stick kite variations.<br />
31
John Browning<br />
LEFT: Manu Pakau: Flying human form much like the Maori<br />
Te Manu Tukutuku. RIGHT: Photinia Tiers: Another regular kite<br />
shape highlighted by open spaces and irregular edges.<br />
32
John Browning<br />
LEFT: Indo 1: A straightforward design, layering of leaves,<br />
irregular edges, and play of light all contribute to this kite’s<br />
beauty. RIGHT: Sorbus Wings: Layering, different materials,<br />
and an elegant winged shape make this a lovely soaring bird.<br />
33
powerful tool: light. The clearlyphotographed<br />
kites are often shown back-lit<br />
so that kite structure, layering, and sailmaterial<br />
differences are immediately<br />
noticed. It is the nature of these materials<br />
that every leaf is different, every shape is<br />
variable, but to then layer and pattern the<br />
plant material in creative ways, the magic is<br />
revealed. Subtle shades of color, patternsupon-patterns,<br />
and unexpected edges all<br />
emerge to make each kite a specific and<br />
powerful statement.<br />
I’m drawn to several kites that are clearly<br />
inspired by the Japanese; John’s Autumn in<br />
Suruga, Bo Tree 8, Eucalyptus, and<br />
Phormium Sode. But John’s more creative<br />
forms that feature open space within the<br />
kite form, asymmetry, and dramatic<br />
differences in sail densities are inspiring and<br />
thought-provoking (see Cordyline Aspect,<br />
Disci, Falling Keys, Periwinkle Drop, and<br />
Phormium Figures, to name a few). Through<br />
it all though, I find myself coming back to<br />
John’s winged, bird-like, or flying-human<br />
kites. They are at once delicate, powerful,<br />
evocative and graceful: Andes, Beech Indo,<br />
Manu Pakau, Sorbus Wings, Sprinter, and<br />
Winged Orb.<br />
This is not a how-to book. John does not go<br />
into detail on either material preparation or<br />
kite construction, but there is certainly a<br />
wealth of information that can be gleaned<br />
from the pages of Kites, and the value of<br />
John’s beautifully documented work is its<br />
power of inspiration. The forms, the<br />
materials, the ethic of recycling and reusing,<br />
all give the kitemaker within us ideas,<br />
techniques, and motivation to follow John<br />
or to travel new kitemaking roads.<br />
www.culicidaepress.com ◆<br />
34
THE EXPERIMENTS OF 1899:<br />
WILBUR AND ORVILLE<br />
WRIGHT FLY A KITE<br />
Tom D. Crouch<br />
The names of the places where Wilbur and<br />
Orville Wright made history are familiar to<br />
people everywhere who know and cherish the<br />
story of the invention of the airplane. The<br />
brothers tested their first kite/glider at Kitty<br />
Hawk, North Carolina in 1900, then shifted<br />
their seasonal camp four miles south to the Kill<br />
Devils Hills, where they flew from 1901 to<br />
1903. They perfected their invention at<br />
Huffman Prairie, eight miles east of Dayton, in<br />
1904 and 1905, and opened their flying field<br />
there in 1910.<br />
Wilbur astonished the world with his first<br />
public flights from the race course at<br />
Hunaudieres, France, in the high summer of<br />
1908, while Orville demonstrated the airplane<br />
to the Army trials at Ft. Myer, Virginia in 1908<br />
and 1909. Wilbur taught the first three U.S.<br />
Army airmen to fly in 1909 at College Park,<br />
Maryland. And there are other familiar places,<br />
from Gardiner’s Island in New York Harbor,<br />
where Wilbur took off for his flight around the<br />
Statue of Liberty in 1909, to a field near<br />
Montgomery, Alabama, where Orville made<br />
the first night flights and began to instruct the<br />
young men who would fly as members of the<br />
Wright exhibition team.<br />
Library of Congress<br />
Ironically, the precise spot where Wilbur tested<br />
their first experimental aircraft is unknown to<br />
all but the most knowledgeable students of<br />
Wright lore. Many of the circumstances<br />
surrounding that first Wright flight test remain<br />
hazy. Over a century after the Wright brothers<br />
began their period of active experimentation<br />
with the flights of their wing-warping kite of<br />
35
1899, the time has come to clarify the<br />
record of those initial experiments.<br />
In February 1912, when Wilbur Wright was<br />
asked how he became involved in the flying<br />
machine problem, he responded that a local<br />
news article announcing “…the death of<br />
Lilienthal… [August 10, 1896] brought the<br />
subject to our attention and led us to make<br />
some inquiry for books relating to flight.”<br />
“But the only serious books we found<br />
were by Prof. [Etienne Jules] Marey and<br />
these related to the mechanism of birdflight<br />
rather than human flight. As our<br />
interest at that time was mere curiosity as<br />
to what had been done, we did not<br />
pursue the subject further when we failed<br />
to find books relating to human flight.” 1<br />
Orville Wright recalled that their early<br />
interest was a bit more serious than that.<br />
“From the date of the death of Lilienthal,”<br />
he remarked, “we were so interested [in<br />
aeronautics] that we discussed matters in<br />
this line almost daily.” 2 As Wilbur<br />
explained, their smoldering interest in flight<br />
finally burst into flame in June 1899. It was<br />
“…while reading a book on Ornithology<br />
that we became interested in studying the<br />
appearance and habits of birds, but it soon<br />
occurred to us that the really interesting<br />
thing about birds was their power of flight.” 3<br />
“Our own growing belief that men might<br />
nevertheless learn to fly was based on the<br />
idea that while thousands of creatures of<br />
the most dissimilar bodily structures,<br />
such as insects, fishes, reptiles, birds and<br />
mammals, were every day flying through<br />
the air at pleasure, it was reasonable to<br />
suppose that men might also fly. Of<br />
course, there might be, and doubtless<br />
would be, many serious difficulties to be<br />
overcome, but we thought that by<br />
learning what these difficulties were and<br />
finding methods of overcoming them, the<br />
problems of human flight might be<br />
solved, and we thought that probably the<br />
cheapest and best way to take up the<br />
subject would be to acquaint ourselves<br />
with the troubles which others had met in<br />
attempting to solve the problem.”<br />
On May 30, 1899, Wilbur Wright wrote a<br />
letter to the Smithsonian Institution. “I am<br />
an enthusiast,” he explained, “but not a<br />
crank in the sense that I have some pet<br />
theories as to the proper construction of a<br />
flying machine.” Noting that he was “…<br />
about to begin a systematic study of the<br />
subject in preparation for practical work to<br />
which I expect to devote what time I can<br />
spare from my regular business,” he<br />
requested “such papers as the Smithsonian<br />
Institution has published on this subject,<br />
and if possible a list of other works in print<br />
in the English language.” 4<br />
Assistant Secretary of the Smithsonian<br />
Richard Rathbun replied just three days<br />
later. It was a testament both to the speed of<br />
the U.S. Postal Service in the closing years<br />
of the old century, and to the Smithsonian’s<br />
emphasis on rapid response to public<br />
inquiries, even by officials at the highest<br />
levels of the Institution. Moreover, the<br />
response was full and satisfying. Rathbun<br />
provided the Wrights with free copies of<br />
four Smithsonian reprints: translated extracts<br />
from Louis Mouillard’s Empire of the Air;<br />
Otto Lilienthal, The Problem of Flying and<br />
Practical Experiments in Soaring; Samuel P;.<br />
Langley, The Story of Experiments in<br />
Mechanical Flight; and E.C. Huffaker, On<br />
Soaring Flight. He also included a list of<br />
recommended publications on the subject,<br />
including S.P. Langley, Experiments in<br />
Aerodynamics; Octave Chanute’s Progress<br />
in Flying Machines, and the 1895, 1896,<br />
and 1897 issues of The Aeronautical<br />
Annual.<br />
Wilbur immediately replied, thanking<br />
36
Rathbun for the pamphlets and enclosing a<br />
dollar for the Langley volume. An entry for<br />
the second week in June, 1899 in the ledger<br />
in which the Wrights kept a meticulous<br />
account of the receipts and expenditures of<br />
the bicycle shop includes an expenditure of<br />
$5.50 “for books on flying.” In addition to<br />
ordering the Langley book, the brothers<br />
must have taken Rathbun’s advice and<br />
purchased the Chanute volume and the<br />
available issues of the Aeronautical Annual,<br />
as well. 5<br />
The spring of 1899 had been a busy time for<br />
the residents of No. 7 Hawthorne Street,<br />
Dayton, Ohio. The pater familias, seventyone<br />
year old Bishop Milton Wright, as<br />
usual, spent a great deal of time on the<br />
road, visiting far flung congregations,<br />
calling on relatives in Ohio and Indiana,<br />
and attending church conferences. When at<br />
home, he made periodic visits to the dentist<br />
who was fitting him with a “vulcanized”<br />
upper plate; supervised the workmen who<br />
were refurbishing the kitchen and the “east<br />
room” of the house; and handled family<br />
business, including the sale of timber on an<br />
Indiana farm.<br />
But there was always time for his<br />
grandchildren, especially his son Lorin’s<br />
eldest boy and girl, Milton and Ivonette,<br />
who lived just around the corner on Horace<br />
Street. At young Milton’s request, he took<br />
them on walks to their grandmother’s grave<br />
in lovely Woodland Cemetery. On May 10,<br />
1899, the three of them cheered from the<br />
upper story windows of a church office as<br />
Col. William F. “Buffalo Bill” Cody paraded<br />
his Wild West Show through the streets of<br />
Dayton. Grandfather and grandchildren<br />
alike were looking forward to fireworks on<br />
the Fourth of July.<br />
It was a busy spring for twenty-four year old<br />
Katharine Wright, as well. Katie, as her<br />
father and friends knew her, was the only<br />
college graduate in the family, Oberlin,<br />
class of ’98. Recently “elected” a teacher of<br />
English and Latin on the regular faculty of<br />
Central High School, she spent the spring<br />
and summer preparing for and enjoying her<br />
high school reunion and entertaining<br />
visiting college friends. She and a group of<br />
friends hosted a supper for a visiting<br />
Oberlin professor on May 20. A college<br />
chum, Margaret “Mag” Goodwin, arrived<br />
for a visit after June 8. The two of them took<br />
a train for Oberlin, and their first college<br />
reunion, on June 15.<br />
Orville would later recall that serious<br />
discussions of aeronautical issues were well<br />
underway “while Miss Goodwin … was<br />
visiting in our home.” 6 The first step was to<br />
assess the state of the aeronautical arts. “As<br />
to the state of the experimental knowledge<br />
at the time we began our experiments,”<br />
Wilbur explained:<br />
“…we reached the conclusion that the<br />
p r o b l e m o f c o n s t r u c t i n g w i n g s<br />
sufficiently strong to carry the weight of<br />
the machine itself, along with that of the<br />
motor and of the aviator and also of<br />
constructing sufficiently light motors<br />
were sufficiently worked out to present<br />
no serious difficulty; but that the problem<br />
of equilibrium had been the real<br />
stumbling block in all serious attempts to<br />
solve the problem of human flight, and<br />
that this problem of equilibrium in reality<br />
constituted the problem of flight itself.” 7<br />
From the outset, as Wilbur explained, “we<br />
were actively studying the means of<br />
controlling [an] aerial apparatus in the<br />
air….” 8 Lilienthal, the great German gliding<br />
master had been killed when his craft went<br />
out of control, as had Percy Pilcher, an<br />
English experimenter. Determined to avoid<br />
that fate, the Wrights set out to devise an<br />
effective control system before they built<br />
their first flying machine. They immediately<br />
37
ecognized that the real problem related to<br />
control in the roll axis, raising or lowering<br />
either wingtip at will to maintain balance in<br />
the air. “[We] …conceived the idea of<br />
adjusting right and left wings to respective<br />
difference angles of incidence,” Wilbur<br />
explained, “for the purpose of controlling<br />
lateral balance.” 9<br />
How was that to be achieved? Orville<br />
suggested “…mounting the wings … upon<br />
axles extending laterally from the center of<br />
the machine with gears attached to the two<br />
wings meshing so that when the lever<br />
attached to either wing was pushed forward<br />
or backward the wings would face forward<br />
at different angles to each other.” 10 Wilbur,<br />
however, argued that the scheme was<br />
impractical because of the weight of such a<br />
m e c h a n i s m a n d t h e d i f fi c u l t y o f<br />
incorporating it into an adequate structure.<br />
Harriet Silliman, another one of Katharine’s<br />
college friends, arrived for a visit on<br />
Thursday, July 20. 11 Wilbur was working<br />
late in the bicycle shop a day or so later,<br />
while Orville and Katie were off somewhere<br />
entertaining Miss Silliman.<br />
“One evening while studying the<br />
movements of a little square paper tube<br />
which I was using for the purpose of<br />
noting the movements of one side which<br />
I conceived to represent the upper plane<br />
of a double deck structure and the<br />
opposite side which I conceived to<br />
represent the lower plane, I noticed that<br />
the upper plane could be moved bodily<br />
forward or backward with reference to<br />
the lower plane which would be useful in<br />
controlling the fore and aft equilibrium of<br />
the apparatus, or if the top plane were<br />
moved forward at one end and backward<br />
at the other the whole structure would be<br />
twisted so that the right ends of the plane<br />
would be pulled down at the rear while<br />
the left ends would be elevated. Thus<br />
each plane would assume a screw form<br />
or helicoid and the right wing would<br />
have a greater angle than the left wing.” 12<br />
By twisting or “warping” the wing in that<br />
fashion, the operator would increase or<br />
decrease the angle of attack, and the<br />
amount of lift, on one side or the other,<br />
banking into a turn, or simply restoring<br />
lateral balance.<br />
When Orville returned home with the ladies<br />
later that evening, Wilbur was waiting with<br />
the box. “By marking vertical and diagonal<br />
lines on the … two vertical walls… [Wilbur]<br />
represented the upright posts and the<br />
diagonal truss wires of a superposed<br />
aeroplane.” 13 Wilbur carefully positioned<br />
his index fingers and thumbs on either end<br />
of the box and twisted. Orville recalled that<br />
they became “…very enthusiastic….” 14<br />
Wilbur then proceeded to build “…a little<br />
model made out of bamboo having lateral<br />
spars and upright standards connecting<br />
them, the whole being braced by truss<br />
threads.” 15 It was an even clearer<br />
demonstration of the warping principle, and<br />
indicated a means of incorporating the<br />
technique into an actual structure.<br />
His next step was to design, build, and test<br />
their first real aircraft, a kite that would<br />
enable them to test their control system in<br />
the air. “The kite had two slightly curved<br />
planes,” Wilbur explained, “about thirteen<br />
inches from front to rear, and about five feet<br />
from tip to tip, one being placed above the<br />
other and connected to it by two rows of<br />
upright standards, one near the front edge<br />
and the other row near the back edge.”<br />
Wilbur attached the upright struts to the<br />
wings with flexible connections, “…so that<br />
the top plane could be thrown forward or<br />
backward with reference to the lower<br />
plane.” 16 continued on page 40<br />
38
Library of Congress<br />
Side view of glider flying as a kite near the ground, Wilbur at<br />
left and Orville at right, glider turned forward to right and<br />
tipped downward.<br />
39
A single rod attached to the mod-point of<br />
the middle rear strut supported a<br />
rectangular, horizontal elevator. When the<br />
top surface of the kite moved forward or<br />
backward, the trailing edge of the elevator<br />
rose or fell to assist the kite in climbing or<br />
diving.<br />
Orville knew that the classic box kite,<br />
introduced by the Australian Lawrence<br />
Hargrave in 1892, offered a light, strong<br />
aeronautical structure. Such kites were<br />
braced across the front and back with light<br />
wires forming a Pratt Truss, a classic<br />
American bridge truss, and across both<br />
ends. In 1896, the Chicago engineer Octave<br />
Chanute had sponsored successful flight<br />
tests of a hang glider based on that pattern.<br />
If the wire bracing on the ends was<br />
removed, it would enable the top surface to<br />
move to the front or rear of the lower wing,<br />
causing the kite to climb or dive. The wings<br />
could also be twisted for lateral control, like<br />
the box and the bamboo model, but could<br />
not move to the right or left.<br />
Control lines leading to wooden sticks in<br />
the operator’s hands could be connected to<br />
the top and bottom of the outside front<br />
struts on both the right and left sides. The<br />
lines on the right and left were crossed, so<br />
that the operator could tip the top of the<br />
two sticks in his hand forward to allow the<br />
top wing to move back, causing the kite to<br />
climb. Pointing the top of both sticks to the<br />
rear would cause a dive, and pointing the<br />
top of one stick forward and the other to the<br />
rear would cause the kite to bank in one<br />
direction or the other. It would be the first<br />
flying machine of any kind capable of<br />
maneuvering under the control of the pilot.<br />
The structure of the 1899 Wright kite was<br />
built entirely of pine. The wings were<br />
covered with fabric and sealed with<br />
shellac. 17 An examination of the ledger<br />
book in which the Wrights recorded all of<br />
their income and expenditures reveals a<br />
number of interesting purchases that might<br />
have been related to the kite, including<br />
several entries for ten cents worth of muslin,<br />
and Wilbur’s purchase of a ten cent ball of<br />
string in the last week in July or the first in<br />
August. In any case, the book records that<br />
Wilbur reported a great many unspecified<br />
expenditures during late July, any of which<br />
might have been related to the kite. 18<br />
Wilbur later recalled that he was at work on<br />
the kite “within a few days” of having<br />
experimented with the cardboard box and<br />
the bamboo structure. “The actual work on<br />
the kite was done mostly by myself,”<br />
although “…it embodied the results of<br />
numerous conversations between us.” 19<br />
While Orville was helping Katharine<br />
entertain their guest, Wilbur spent long<br />
hours at the bicycle shop, waiting on<br />
customers, performing repairs, and<br />
constructing his kite. “I was not able to be<br />
present when the structure was flown as a<br />
kite, but I operated the machine in … our<br />
store before it was taken out to be flown,”<br />
Orville recalled. “My brother held the kite<br />
in his hands while I warped the wings by<br />
means of the four cords.”<br />
Katharine, Harriet, Orville, and a group of<br />
other friends left for a camping trip at a spot<br />
near Dayton’s Fairview Park during the first<br />
week in August, 1899. The party returned<br />
home on August 7, the first Monday of the<br />
month. 20 The tests of the kite, Wilbur<br />
recalled, were prior to the trip. Orville<br />
agreed with his brother, recalling that he<br />
had returned from the camping trip on<br />
Tuesday, August 8, and that Wilbur had<br />
visited him in camp on Sunday, August 6, at<br />
which point they discussed the kite tests<br />
that had been conducted prior to his<br />
departure. In the late summer of 1899 the<br />
Wrights did not have an assistant who could<br />
man the bicycle shop in their absence.<br />
Presumably, Orville did not witness the kite<br />
40
tests because he had to mind the store. 21<br />
Wilbur reported that he flew the kite “a<br />
number of times about the end of July.” 22<br />
He had given the question of where to fly it<br />
considerable thought, and selected an open<br />
area on the grounds of the Union<br />
Theological Seminary, at the corner of West<br />
First Street and Euclid Avenue in Dayton,<br />
Ohio. “This field is now part of the city,”<br />
Wilbur explained in a deposition offered<br />
just a month before his death. “But at that<br />
time [it was] a retired place where I thought<br />
no one would intrude.” 23<br />
Officials of the Church of the United<br />
Brethren in Christ opened the doors of the<br />
impressive three-story structure in 1878.<br />
Since that time, it had become a landmark<br />
on the western edge of Dayton. Eight years<br />
before, Katharine, then a high school<br />
student, had mentioned the place in an<br />
essay describing the sites encountered by<br />
passengers on a horse car traveling east<br />
along West Third Street. Having begun the<br />
journey at the Third Street car barns, and<br />
passed the already historic Miami City<br />
school, the tour guide directed the attention<br />
of her readers to the next noteworthy site<br />
along the route.<br />
“To the left, about two squares distant, is<br />
another school, sometimes irreverently<br />
called “the preacher factory.” Its official<br />
name is Union Biblical Seminary. It<br />
stands in the center of a beautiful campus<br />
on high ground overlooking the valley of<br />
Wolf Creek, and is the first building to<br />
attract the eye of travelers entering the<br />
city by railroad from the west.” 24<br />
Wilbur remarked that he had flown the kite<br />
more than once. The fact that the drawings<br />
of the kite which he prepared for use during<br />
a deposition on the morning of March 30,<br />
1912, show a short section of pipe tied to<br />
the center forward strut certainly indicates<br />
that he had flown it enough to realize that it<br />
was tail heavy.<br />
In spite of Wilbur’s desire for privacy, there<br />
were witnesses to the tests. Fred Fansher<br />
recalled that he had been flying kites with<br />
ten or twelve other boys in an empty lot<br />
adjacent to the Seminary at the corner of<br />
Summit and West First, when Wilbur Wright<br />
walked by carrying “…what looked to us<br />
like a peculiar sort of box kite.” Curious, the<br />
boys pulled their own kites down and<br />
followed Wilbur onto the Seminary<br />
grounds. 25<br />
John Myers remembered that Wilbur had<br />
asked him to hold the kite as far above his<br />
head as he could and to let it go when<br />
instructed. “There was quite a big wind that<br />
day,” he noted. “I recall that when he tilted<br />
the planes the kite came down very rapidly,<br />
darted in other words…. He made several<br />
attempts and then boxed it up and put it<br />
away.” 26<br />
John Reiniger had been there, as well. “At<br />
times it would have a tendency to come<br />
down.” He recalled, “which would be<br />
overcome by the manipulation of the sticks<br />
in Mr. Wright’s hands.” Once, he<br />
remembered, the kite had gotten completely<br />
out of control and swooped down to the<br />
ground. 27<br />
Of course, Wilbur gave Orville a detailed<br />
account of the tests. Several days later, John<br />
Reiniger and his brother Walter stopped by<br />
the bike shop and provided what we can<br />
safely assume to have been a spirited<br />
description of the proceedings. “According<br />
to Wilbur’s account of the tests,” Orville<br />
remarked, “the model worked very<br />
successfully.”<br />
“It responded promptly to the warping of<br />
the surfaces, always lifting the wing that<br />
had the larger angle [of incidence].<br />
41
Several times, according to Wilbur’s<br />
account to me, when he shifted the upper<br />
surface backward by the manipulation of<br />
the sticks attached to flying cords, the<br />
nose of the machine turned downward as<br />
was intended; but in diving downward it<br />
created a slack in the flying cords, so that<br />
he was not able to control it further. The<br />
model made such a rapid dive to the<br />
ground that the small boys present fell on<br />
their faces to avoid being hit, not having<br />
time to run.” 28<br />
During the course of a series of patent suits<br />
that began in 1909 and ran for over a<br />
decade, the origins and operation of the<br />
1899 kite would repeatedly become a<br />
matter of some legal importance. It was,<br />
after all, the starting point of the Wright<br />
experiments. As a result, the brothers were<br />
forced to reconstruct events that had<br />
occurred more than a decade before, and<br />
which seemed much more important in<br />
hindsight than they had at the time. In<br />
general, their method of dating the small<br />
steps leading to the kite tests involved<br />
remembering the comings and goings of<br />
guests, the camping trip and other<br />
household events occurring at the same<br />
time.<br />
There is one puzzling anomaly, however.<br />
The brothers relied on their father’s<br />
meticulous diary to establish a basic<br />
timeline of events in the Wright household<br />
during the spring and summer of 1899. In<br />
his entry for July 7, Bishop Wright reports<br />
that his grandson Milton visited that<br />
evening, “to see the flying machine.” 29<br />
According to the chronology reconstructed<br />
by the brothers, however, there was no<br />
“flying machine” in early July. The incident<br />
with the paper box, which set everything in<br />
motion, did not occur until on or about July<br />
20. Perhaps young Milton came to look at<br />
pictures of flying machines in the books and<br />
pamphlets that his uncles had recently<br />
acquired.<br />
In addition to reconstructing the weeks<br />
when they had taken their first steps toward<br />
the invention of the airplane, the Wrights<br />
had to locate witnesses who could testify to<br />
having seen the kite maneuvering in the air.<br />
Some of the boys were easy enough to find.<br />
John Reiniger was still living in Dayton, as<br />
were Fred Fansher, who was serving as<br />
Secretary of the Chamber of Commerce in<br />
1912, and John Myers, who had become an<br />
electrician. The Wrights wrote letters to<br />
other men, now living as close as Cincinnati<br />
and as far away as Georgetown, Texas,<br />
whom they thought might have been among<br />
the ten or a dozen youngsters who had seen<br />
the kite fly thirteen years before. 30<br />
Apparently, there were no responses.<br />
Opposing counsel in the various patent suits<br />
would also express curiosity with regard to<br />
the ultimate fate of the objects that had<br />
played such an important role in the initial<br />
involvement of the Wright brothers in<br />
aviation. “I do not think that we have parts<br />
of any of our kites or gliders before the<br />
motor aeroplanes [sic] of 1903,” Wilbur<br />
explained. 31 While he did not actually<br />
remember, he presumed that the little<br />
bamboo model had been “thrown in the<br />
waste basket or wood box.” 32<br />
“The kite remained about the store for three<br />
or four years,” Wilbur recalled, “and was<br />
used at various times in making experiments<br />
with an automatic stabilizer.” During one of<br />
those tests, probably in 1905, “…it was so<br />
badly broken that no attempt was made to<br />
rebuild it.” 33 The 1899 kite had outlived its<br />
historic progeny, the l900, 1901, and 1902<br />
Wright gliders. Like them, however, it<br />
ultimately found its way into “the waste<br />
basket or wood box.”<br />
“Following these flights [of the 1899 kite],”<br />
continued on page 44<br />
42
Library of Congress<br />
Wilbur Wright’s drawing of the 1899 kite with the surfaces<br />
warped. It is in the public domain, drawn from his testimony<br />
in the patent suit, as reproduced in McFarland, The Papers of<br />
Wilbur and Orville Wright (McGraw-Hill, 1953).<br />
43
Wilbur recalled, “we decided to build a<br />
much larger kite sufficient to support a man,<br />
and we made a search for grounds in the<br />
vicinity of Dayton but found nothing that<br />
suited us.” 34 This time they would have to<br />
look a bit farther afield than the Union<br />
Theological Seminary. Just a year later, on<br />
Thursday, September 6, 1900, Wilbur<br />
Wright boarded a Big Four train at Dayton’s<br />
Union Station. He was bound for Elizabeth<br />
City, North Carolina, where he would hire a<br />
boat to carry him across Albermarle Sound<br />
to the little village of Kitty Hawk, on the<br />
Outer Banks of North Carolina. Safely<br />
packed away in the baggage car were the<br />
prefabricated makings of the 1900 kite/<br />
glider, the first full-scale Wright airplane.<br />
The freight charge was $2.53, several times<br />
the cost of the small kite that had started it<br />
all. 35<br />
SIXTEEN YEARS LATER<br />
I wrote this essay 16 years ago, in the spring<br />
of 1999, as a first step toward the<br />
Centennial of Powered Flight, which I<br />
assumed would be celebrated with great<br />
fanfare in 2003. The kite experiments of<br />
1899, so often overlooked by historians,<br />
marked the serious entry of these two<br />
Dayton men into aeronautics, a field in<br />
which they would write their names large<br />
across the sky. The essay was an experiment<br />
in microhistory, an attempt to see just how<br />
much detail I could uncover about those<br />
few weeks in the summer of 1899. Rereading<br />
it now, I found the need to do some<br />
re-writing, not to correct errors, but to<br />
clarify what occurred and to put those<br />
events in a bit more context.<br />
I am more than pleased that my friends from<br />
the Drachen Foundation have chosen to<br />
offer the revised version to a new<br />
generation of readers in their online journal.<br />
I enjoyed re-visiting my own account of the<br />
story, and am grateful to have been able to<br />
make some improvements. My thanks to Ali<br />
Fujino and Scott Skinner for the invitation,<br />
and to editor Katie Davis who helped make<br />
it more presentable.<br />
Tom Crouch<br />
Chantilly, Virginia<br />
October 6, <strong>2015</strong> ◆<br />
44
ENDNOTES<br />
1. Wilbur Wright testimony, U.S. District Court, Western<br />
Division of New York. The Wright Company vs. Herring-<br />
Curtiss Co. and Glenn H. Curtiss. In Equity No. 400.<br />
Complainant’s Record. Vol. 1, pg. 474.<br />
2. Orville Wright deposition, The United States District<br />
Court, Southern District of Ohio, Western Division,<br />
Charles H. Lamson vs. The Wright Company, In Equity No.<br />
6,611, pg. 78, Defendant’s Copy, The Papers of Wilbur and<br />
Orville Wright, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress,<br />
box 63.<br />
3. Wilbur Wright testimony, Wright Company vs. Herring-<br />
Curtiss Co. and Glenn H. Curtiss, Vol. 1, pg. 474.<br />
4. W. Wright to the Smithsonian Institution, May 30, 1899,<br />
in McFarland, PWOW., vol. 1, pg. 4-5.<br />
5. Entry for June 15 (?), 1899, 1899 ledger book, Box 77,<br />
pg. 13, Papers of Wilbur and Orville Wright, Manuscript<br />
Division, Library of Congress.<br />
6. Lamson vs. the Wright Company, pg. 78.<br />
7. Wilbur Wright testimony, Wright Company vs. Herring-<br />
Curtiss Co. and Glenn H. Curtiss, Vol. 1, pg. 478.<br />
8. Lamson vs. the Wright Company, pg. 14.<br />
9. Lamson vs. the Wright Company, pg. 14.<br />
10. Ibid., 78.<br />
11. Bishop Milton Wright, Diary, Paul Lawrence Dunbar<br />
Library, Wright State University.<br />
12. Wilbur Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pgs. 14-15.<br />
13. Orville Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pg. 79.<br />
14. Ibid.<br />
15. Wilbur Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pg. 15.<br />
16. Wilbur Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pg. 16.<br />
17. Wilbur Wright to Octave Chanute, August 10, 1900, in<br />
McFarland, Papers, vol. 1, pg. 22.<br />
18. For the string see: 1899 ledger book, pg. 59, Wright<br />
Papers, Box 77.<br />
19. Wilbur Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pg. 17.<br />
21. For Orville’s recollections see, “Orville Wright on the<br />
Wright experiments of 1899,” in Marvin W. McFarland,<br />
ed., The Papers of Wilbur and Orville Wright (New York:<br />
McGraw-Hill and Company, 1953), vol. 1, pg. 11.<br />
22. Wilbur Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pg. 16.<br />
23. Wilbur Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pg. 17.<br />
24. Katharine Wright, “Rambles in Miami City,” [Central]<br />
High School Times, December 1891, pg. 7.<br />
25. Deposition of Frederick W. Fansher, Dayton, Ohio,<br />
February 2, 1921, Regina Cleary Montgomery et al. vs. the<br />
United States, Court of Claims of the United States, No.<br />
33852. Typed copy of the deposition in the John J.<br />
Montgomery biographical file, National Air and Space<br />
Museum. See also Fansher’s earlier deposition, in Lamson<br />
vs. Wright, pg. 90.<br />
26. Deposition of John K. Myers, Dayton, Ohio, February<br />
2, 1921, Regina Cleary Montgomery et al. vs. the United<br />
States, Court of Claims of the United States, No. 33852.<br />
Typed copy of the deposition in the John J. Montgomery<br />
biographical file, National Air and Space Museum.<br />
27. Deposition of John D. Reiniger, Lamson vs. Wright, pg.<br />
95.<br />
28. “Orville Wright on the Wright experiments of 1899,” in<br />
McFarland, ed., Papers, vol. 1, pg. 11.<br />
29. Bishop Milton Wright, Diary, July 7, 1899, Paul<br />
Lawrence Dunbar Library, Wright State University.<br />
30. Wright brothers to Horace Hiscy, April 13, 1912;<br />
Wright brothers to Joseph Scholl, April 13, 1912; Wright<br />
brothers to Horace Drury, April 13, 1912, all in The Papers<br />
of Wilbur and Orville Wright, Manuscript Division, Library<br />
of Congress, box 63, materials relating to Lamson vs.<br />
Wright.<br />
31. Wilbur Wright, Lamson vs. Wright, pg. 49.<br />
32. Ibid.<br />
33. Ibid., pg. 17.<br />
34. Ibid.<br />
35. For freight charge see: 1900 ledger book, pg. 153,<br />
Wright Papers, Box 77.<br />
20. Orville Wright, testimony, U.S. District Court, Western<br />
Division of New York. The Wright Company vs. Herring-<br />
Curtiss Co. and Glenn H. Curtiss. In Equity No. 400.<br />
Complainant’s Record. Vol. 1, pg. 807. “While Miss S. Was<br />
visiting us we spent a few days camping north of the city,<br />
that is, my sister, Miss S- and I camped with some<br />
friends…. We were camping about one week and we<br />
returned to Dayton, as I remember it, the first Monday of<br />
August 1899.”<br />
45
MIKIO TOKI<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
Kitefliers in Colorado have been lucky for the<br />
last two years because of the Japan America<br />
Society of Colorado and their commitment to<br />
h o s t i n g a k i t e fl y i n t h e S t a p l e t o n<br />
neighborhood of Denver during the annual<br />
Denver Days celebration throughout the city.<br />
With the help of Denver’s Japanese Consulate,<br />
the Society brought kitemaker Mikio Toki to<br />
the event both years. Undaunted by Toki-san’s<br />
late arrival in 2014 (where I was thrown in to<br />
do kitemaking workshops and Toki-san was<br />
only able to spend one day flying kites), this<br />
year Toki was able to lecture and demonstrate<br />
during an opening reception, lead morning<br />
and afternoon workshop sessions, and spend a<br />
full day flying kites on the old Stapleton<br />
Airport grounds. Beautiful, calm August<br />
weather conspired to keep us all grounded for<br />
a good portion of the day, but using mile-high<br />
breezes that came and went, we were all able<br />
to have some magical flying moments. Toki’s<br />
presence has ensured that George Peters,<br />
Melanie Walker, and I have been on a<br />
Colorado kite-field for two consecutive years –<br />
a new record!<br />
Scott Skinner<br />
Japanese kitemaker Mikio Toki has been important<br />
to the preservation of Japanese kite culture both<br />
in Japan and internationally.<br />
Toki’s visits to Colorado have reminded me of<br />
how important he has been to the preservation<br />
of Japanese kite culture both in Japan and<br />
internationally. Like a kitemaker of 100 years<br />
ago, Toki-san is still commissioned during<br />
traditional kite seasons (Children’s Day, New<br />
Year) to make special kites for children and<br />
adults. Unlike his predecessors, kitemaking in<br />
today’s Japan cannot truly be a full-time job.<br />
Luckily for the international kite community,<br />
continued on page 51<br />
46
Scott Skinner<br />
Like a kitemaker of 100 years ago, Toki-san is commissioned<br />
during traditional kite seasons to make special kites.<br />
47
Scott Skinner<br />
Always willing to share his extensive knowledge of the Tokyo<br />
kite tradition, Toki-san has been a mentor to many.<br />
48
Mikio Toki<br />
Examples of Toki-san’s paper and silk kite paintings.<br />
49
Mikio Toki<br />
Examples of Toki-san’s larger kite works.<br />
50
Toki-san travels extensively to festivals,<br />
workshops, and cultural events to share his<br />
knowledge and to supplement his income.<br />
Always willing to share his extensive<br />
knowledge of the Tokyo kite tradition, Tokisan<br />
has been a mentor to many of us who<br />
are interested in the Edo kite forms. He has<br />
the hands-on experience and the shared<br />
knowledge of his Tokyo predecessors to<br />
explain the subtleties of the Edo kite and to<br />
demonstrate their wonderful flying<br />
characteristics. Toki-san playfully described<br />
spending months on one of his first large<br />
Edo-dakos. After skillful painting,<br />
painstaking bamboo-work, and careful<br />
bridling, on the first flight the kite overflew<br />
and crashed dramatically!<br />
Toki-san is no stranger to new ideas and<br />
techniques. He has shown us new Japanese<br />
paper that is as strong as Tyvek. The new<br />
“magic paper” has an internal grid or<br />
lattice, and painting techniques have to be<br />
experimented with, but the paper transmits<br />
light beautifully and can be sewed, glued,<br />
or stapled onto a kite frame of any material.<br />
Toki-san can also create his own stronger<br />
paper using traditional methods, laminating<br />
paper to cotton scrim or to silk. This<br />
technique provides a different painting<br />
surface that results in a more matte-looking<br />
finish.<br />
Toki-san’s craftsmanship has become<br />
spectacular after his many years of<br />
experience. In his small kites that you might<br />
expect some “corners to be cut,” you’ll find<br />
no such thing. Every bridle is perfect,<br />
bamboo is finished and consistent, and the<br />
paintings show maturity and power in the<br />
simplest of images.<br />
www.mikiotoki.com/english1.htm<br />
www.asahi-net.or.jp/~ea8a-tkkw/toki.html<br />
www.facebook.com/mikio.toki ◆<br />
51
iscourse<br />
from the end of the line<br />
Submit your article or photographs to<br />
Discourse! We thank our authors with official<br />
Drachen Foundation gifts. These gifts are not<br />
available for purchase and are reserved for the<br />
authors and special friends of Discourse.<br />
Send your submission or comments to:<br />
discourse@drachen.org<br />
Donations can be made to support Discourse<br />
and other Drachen projects at:<br />
www.drachen.org/donations<br />
52