Jewish Report
2016-11-18
2016-11-18
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
18 – 25 November 2016 Opinion and Analysis<br />
SA JEWISH REPORT 17<br />
SA Jewry: Ring the bells that still can ring<br />
TAKING ISSUE<br />
Geoff Sifrin<br />
The death of musician-poet Leonard<br />
(Hebrew name Eliezer) Cohen and<br />
the concurrent ascent to power in<br />
the United States of billionairepolitician<br />
Donald Trump fits in with<br />
the confusion of our era. The former is<br />
mourned by millions, with his legacy of<br />
songs touching the core of what it is to<br />
be human. It is hard to imagine iconic<br />
songs such as “Hallelujah” ever being<br />
bettered.<br />
We don’t know what President<br />
Trump’s legacy will be when he leaves<br />
office. Amidst dismay at his election,<br />
people who find him dangerous look for<br />
an elusive “silver lining”. His attitudes<br />
resonate with the rise of right-wing,<br />
fascist figures in other countries.<br />
Ultra-nationalism, xenophobia,<br />
racism and other social ills that had<br />
become unacceptable in the last few<br />
decades, are respectable again with the<br />
rise of the new right.<br />
Perhaps one positive aspect is that<br />
change is sometimes inherently a good<br />
thing as it moves people out of stale<br />
comfort zones and creates new energy.<br />
In the lyrics of his song “Anthem”,<br />
Cohen wrote: “Ring the bells that still<br />
can ring / Forget your perfect offering<br />
/ There is a crack in everything / That’s<br />
how the light gets in.”<br />
It is hard imagining Trump as a<br />
bringer of light, but perhaps the<br />
crack in the political order he has<br />
shattered was the left’s complacency.<br />
In its enthusiasm for globalisation and<br />
multiculturalism, it neglected masses<br />
of ordinary local people in countries<br />
worldwide who were left behind<br />
and became poorer, while wealthy<br />
international elites were creaming it.<br />
With his contempt for everything<br />
the “enlightened” establishment<br />
regarded as proper political behaviour,<br />
Trump became the voice of those angry<br />
masses.<br />
In times of upheaval, Jews<br />
instinctively ask: “Is it good or bad for<br />
the Jews?” There is cause for concern:<br />
The rise of the new right coincides<br />
with ominous stirrings of racism,<br />
which always goes hand-in-hand with<br />
anti-Semitism and hatred of other<br />
minorities. In countries where it was<br />
taboo not long ago to speak publicly<br />
against the Jews - even if some<br />
people disliked them privately - open<br />
expressions of Jew-hatred have become<br />
common. In France, for example,<br />
masses of Jews are emigrating after<br />
attacks on them.<br />
Even in South Africa, which still<br />
clings to the memory of tolerance and<br />
multiculturalism of Mandela’s “rainbow<br />
nation”, signs are worrying. Earlier this<br />
month, for example, graffiti appeared<br />
at Wits university campus, saying “Kill<br />
a Jew” and “F*** the Jews”; last month,<br />
a kippah-wearing student was called a<br />
“Motherf***ing Jew” by fellow students.<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> organisations say anti-<br />
Semitism remains low in South Africa<br />
compared to other countries. But the<br />
rise of populists such as Economic<br />
Freedom Fighters leader Julius<br />
Malema, who claims to speak for<br />
millions of angry, poor and jobless<br />
black masses, brings dangers. His<br />
populist tactics are similar to Trump’s,<br />
but from a leftwing, albeit nationalistic,<br />
perspective.<br />
In their drive to power, demagogues<br />
willingly use any tools, often couched in<br />
simplistic terminology which promises<br />
to solve everything. While he has not<br />
publicly expressed anti-Semitism,<br />
Malema’s vitriol against whites and his<br />
refrain that “white monopoly capital”<br />
is the root of the country’s problems<br />
could easily be tweaked to “white and<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> monopoly capital”.<br />
Sinister bedfellows would jump from<br />
the sidelines to support him in this<br />
line. <strong>Jewish</strong> South Africans must be<br />
prepared for this.<br />
Trump may turn out to be less<br />
catastrophic than doomsayers predict.<br />
In politics, yelling viciously from the<br />
sidelines is easy, but once a person gets<br />
his hands on the steering wheel, things<br />
look different. And US politics has so<br />
many checks and balances, it is hard for<br />
any leader to go completely off track.<br />
For Malema, however, South Africa’s<br />
political restraints are less robust.<br />
Either way, we’re in for an interesting<br />
few years.<br />
• Read Geoff Sifrin’s regular columns on<br />
his blog sifrintakingissue.wordpress.com<br />
World News in Brief<br />
Leonard Cohen buried in<br />
Montreal before announcement<br />
of his death<br />
MONTREAL - Singer-songwriter Leonard Cohen was buried in his<br />
hometown of Montreal hours before his death was made public.<br />
Cohen died Nov. 7 in Los Angeles and was buried on November<br />
10 at his family’s plot in the Shaar Hashomayim Cemetery,<br />
according to reports citing a statement from Congregation<br />
Shaar Hashomayim, an Orthodox synagogue in the Westmount<br />
neighbourhood.<br />
“Leonard’s wish was to be laid to rest in a traditional <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
rite beside his parents, grandparents and great-grandparents,” the<br />
statement said. He maintained “a lifelong spiritual, musical, and<br />
familial connection to the synagogue of his youth”,<br />
The Cohen family plot is located just through the front gates of<br />
the <strong>Jewish</strong> Cemetery near the base of Mount Royal, The Toronto<br />
Star reported. The only evidence of Cohen’s burial is unsettled earth<br />
covered by fallen brown leaves in front of an unmarked gravestone,<br />
according to the newspaper.<br />
“Hineni, hineni, My Lord” and other lyrics to the song “You Want<br />
It Darker” from his latest album released in September were read<br />
during the traditional <strong>Jewish</strong> graveside funeral attended by family<br />
and close friends only, the French news agency AFP reported.<br />
The announcement of his death was made on November 10<br />
after the funeral.<br />
“My father passed away peacefully at his home in Los Angeles<br />
with the knowledge that he had completed what he felt was one<br />
of his greatest records,” Cohen’s son, Adam, wrote in a Facebook<br />
post. “He was writing up until his last moments with his unique<br />
brand of humour.”<br />
An official statement November 10 on Leonard Cohen’s<br />
Facebook page said there would be a funeral in Los Angeles in<br />
coming days.<br />
Mourners have laid flowers and lit candles at the doorstep of<br />
Cohen’s Montreal home, The Globe and Mail newspaper reported.<br />
Montreal Mayor Denis Coderre reportedly has pledged to find an<br />
appropriate way to honour “one of our greatest Montrealers”. (JTA)<br />
4 Room Apartments<br />
from 1,100,000 NIS<br />
Preslae in south Tel-Aviv<br />
200m from Nave Tzedek<br />
and the sea<br />
Reserve Cliffs - Netanya<br />
300m from the sea<br />
For a private meeting in S.A. from November 21 st -26 th please contact<br />
Selwyn Hare on 087-5503194 / +972-52-7771715<br />
or selwyn@homeinisrael.net www.homeinisrael.com<br />
YOUR ONE STOP SHOP!<br />
Marketing Israel's most exclusive projects &<br />
Resale Properties for all budgets,<br />
including Legal and financing advice.