You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
An example of this is seen in <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong>’s view of the authority of a sane adult woman regarding her<br />
marriage. He did not accord her guardian any authority over her <strong>and</strong> he is the only one of the four imams to<br />
take that position. We also find that he forbade declaration of legal incompetence in the case fools, heedless<br />
people <strong>and</strong> debtors <strong>and</strong> he also forbade any restriction whatsoever on the way a person disposed of his<br />
property except where the deen was concerned.<br />
Concluding Note<br />
The Hanafi school, discussed by scholars, on whose principles questions are extrapolated, is not simply the<br />
position held by <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong> alone. It consists of his positions <strong>and</strong> those of his companions. If you wish, you<br />
could say that it is the position of the school of <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong> in Kufa, <strong>and</strong> then after his death it was taken by<br />
his students, <strong>Abu</strong> Yusuf <strong>and</strong> ash-Shaybani, to Baghdad.<br />
That is why the Hanafi school was an amalgamation <strong>and</strong> did not purely reflect the positions of <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong><br />
in the way that the positions of Malik are reflected in the Maliki school <strong>and</strong> those of ash-Shafi‘i in his school.<br />
There are several reasons which resulted in the Hanafi school comprising this fusion of the opinions of <strong>Abu</strong><br />
<strong>Hanifa</strong>, his companions <strong>and</strong> the fuqaha’ in Iraq contemporary with him, like ‘Uthman al-Batti, Ibn Shibrama<br />
<strong>and</strong> Ibn Abi Layla.<br />
One reason for this was that <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong>’s statements are not transmitted in detail as distinct from the<br />
positions of others. The Iraqi position is transmitted as a corpus in which it is not easily possible to<br />
disentangle the various str<strong>and</strong>s into the statements of each individual.<br />
Another reason is that, in his study of various problems, <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong> relied on the debate <strong>and</strong> discussion of<br />
those issues that took place among his students. Due to his immense scrupulousness, belief in the truth <strong>and</strong><br />
respect for freedom of thought, he asked his students to follow the direction to which the evidence led. <strong>Abu</strong><br />
Yusuf recorded the positions of <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong> along with his own views. Thus the positions presented are a<br />
composite.<br />
<strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong>’s students were in fact independent mujtahids in their own right. Each of them had his own<br />
opinion which might be similar or far from that of his shaykh, even if the methods they used were similar. If<br />
you read the books of the school of <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong>, you will often see a great difference in opinions because of<br />
this characteristic of his school.<br />
It was not only the companions of <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong> whose positions were mixed together. After them the views<br />
of other fuqaha’ were added to what had been transmitted from him <strong>and</strong> his companions. Some were Hanafis<br />
<strong>and</strong> some were not. All of this resulted in a lot of divergent views <strong>and</strong> choices, all of which was based on<br />
exact rules <strong>and</strong> clear principles. Thus what came to be Hanafi fiqh represents the fiqh of Iraq rather than<br />
simply the views of <strong>Abu</strong> <strong>Hanifa</strong>.