08.12.2017 Views

Best for Britain Brexit-Reports-6.12.17-FINAL

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Brexit</strong> is not a done deal: Article 50 is revocable<br />

The UK’s triggering of Article 50 of the EU Lisbon Treaty in March 2017 started a two-year<br />

process after which <strong>Britain</strong> should leave the EU. However, prior to 29 March 2019 Article<br />

50 is revocable and <strong>Brexit</strong> is not inevitable. No <strong>Brexit</strong> is an option <strong>for</strong> the<br />

country.<br />

●<br />

●<br />

●<br />

●<br />

●<br />

●<br />

●<br />

The current government has stated that there is no way back from<br />

triggering Article 50.<br />

That reflects Conservative government policy, not legal fact or political<br />

reality.<br />

Article 50 does not prevent <strong>Britain</strong> from withdrawing its request to leave the<br />

EU.<br />

Legally, the letter from the UK government has only triggered the process,<br />

and Parliament will need to vote on the final deal.<br />

Politically, signals from EU leaders have made it clear that they would not<br />

stand in the way if the UK revoked Article 50 be<strong>for</strong>e March 2019.<br />

Lord Kerr 104 , author of Article 50, says that we can change our mind at any<br />

time be<strong>for</strong>e March 2019. The UK still has a choice on <strong>Brexit</strong>.<br />

The Government has a policy of not intending to revoke Article 50, but<br />

legally and politically, nothing should stop the withdrawal of Article 50 if<br />

that is what’s best <strong>for</strong> <strong>Britain</strong>.<br />

What is the government saying?<br />

The Government’s policy has been that Article 50 is a one-way ticket.<br />

● Prime Minister Theresa May said “there can be no turning back” from triggering Article<br />

50. 105<br />

● As a spokesperson <strong>for</strong> the Department <strong>for</strong> Exiting the European Union said "Government<br />

lawyers also made clear in legal proceedings be<strong>for</strong>e the High Court that, as a matter of firm<br />

policy, notification of withdrawal will not be withdrawn." 106<br />

● Former Justice Secretary Liz Truss said, "my understanding is that it is irrevocable." 107<br />

However the government distanced themselves from that claim in February 2017. 108<br />

● Secretary of State <strong>for</strong> Exiting the European Union, David Davis said "is it irrevocable? I<br />

don't know." 109<br />

What does the law say?<br />

Legally, nothing prevents the UK from withdrawing their Article 50 notice be<strong>for</strong>e the end of the<br />

two-year period.<br />

● As long as the UK hasn’t <strong>for</strong>mally left (currently in March 2019), there is nothing in Article 50<br />

indicating that the UK cannot change its mind. The text says that a state has left after the<br />

two-year negotiating period only. If it wants to re-join, it will need to apply like any third<br />

country and go through the whole membership process. 110<br />

● Article 50 provides <strong>for</strong> notification by a member state only of its “intention” to leave, not its<br />

decision. Legally, the word “intention” cannot be interpreted as a final and irreversible<br />

decision. You may withdraw an intention, change it, or trans<strong>for</strong>m it into a decision. 111<br />

21

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!