23.12.2012 Views

Part 1 - AToL Decapoda

Part 1 - AToL Decapoda

Part 1 - AToL Decapoda

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

202 De Grave & Fransen. Carideorum catalogus (Crustacea: <strong>Decapoda</strong>). Zool. Med. Leiden 85 (2011)<br />

The present case mirrors the consistent usage of H. Milne Edwards in publications<br />

by that author, whose surname was Edwards, but who added Milne to distinguish himself<br />

from his brother William Edwards (see Forest, 1996). As we can see no reason why<br />

the name Charles Spence Bate should be treated different to Henri Milne Edwards, we<br />

here accept the arguments put forward by Dubois (2008) in that authors are signatures<br />

and not persons, and thus have elected to use the name C. Spence Bate.<br />

For the father and son team of Henri Milne Edwards and Alphonse Milne-Edwards,<br />

we herein follow Forest (1996) in the spelling of their surnames, and have added, as is<br />

customary in carcinology, their initial to all citations. Issues surrounding the use of<br />

Guérin and Guérin-Méneville were discussed in Ng et al. (2008) and we follow here<br />

their lead in attributing names after 1836 onwards to Guérin-Méneville and before 1836<br />

to Guérin.<br />

Ng et al. (2008) also provide a more in depth discussion on the spelling of author<br />

names and how these should be cited in the references. As we herein adhere to the same<br />

rules, we refer the reader to that treatise.<br />

In those instances where different taxa have been described by different authors<br />

who share the same surname, we generally have adopted the same rules as outlined in<br />

Ng et al. (2008). In brief, we do not add the authors initials to the person having described<br />

significantly more taxa, but add those to the author having described fewer.<br />

For instance, for taxa described by Peter K.L. Ng we do not add P.K.L. in front of the<br />

surname, whilst we do so for Ngan Kee Ng (thus N.K. Ng). As in Ng et al. (2008) we<br />

do not include initials if the authors were not contemporaries, the intervening time lag<br />

making this sufficiently obvious. For instance, J.Y. Johnson (1863, 1868) and D.S. Johnson<br />

(1961, 1962, 1967, 1973). A special case is the citation of first names for workers of<br />

Chinese descent or nationality, where fashion has dictated how names are used rather<br />

than bibliographical accuracy. For instance, the Chinese freshwater carcinologist Guo<br />

Zhao Liang has published under the names Guo Zhaoliang (abbreviated to Guo, Z.),<br />

Guo Zhao-Liang (Guo, Z.-L.) and Guo Zhao Liang (Guo, Z.L.). As it is evident that in<br />

all three cases this is the same worker, we have elected not to include his initials in the<br />

citations, others, more purists perhaps, may disagree. In the case of the team of A.H.<br />

”Hank” and D.M. ”Dora” Banner, who described numerous alpheid taxa, often jointly,<br />

they stated several times in their larger publications (e.g. Banner & Banner, 1978; Banner<br />

& Banner, 1981a) that they list their own papers in strict chronological order, without<br />

reference to seniority of authorship. We have herein interpreted this as a desire to<br />

reflect a joint effort with order of authorship, perhaps somewhat arbitrarily decided<br />

upon and a reflection of equal share in the description. As such we have elected to not<br />

add initials to citations in the checklist, although order of authorship in the references<br />

is as given in the actual papers to facilitate bibliographical searches. All this makes for<br />

less cumbersome citations, however in other cases, we had no option but to include<br />

initials.<br />

Notes on authorship of taxa<br />

As extensively discussed by Ng et al. (2008) attributing the correct author to a certain<br />

taxon can be confusing, particularly (but not exclusively) in the earlier literature.<br />

Often in the earlier literature another carcinologists’ name is cited behind the species

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!