30.08.2023 Views

Practice-Transcript-6_Redacted_F116

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

26<br />

1 that everybody is talking about, I think that -- at the<br />

2 very least, it should be some persuasive case for the<br />

3 Court because that shooting occurs basically on the side<br />

4 on the -- on the side of this property where it's<br />

5 basically right next to that entrance. That's where the<br />

6 bus bays are.<br />

7 THE COURT: Right.<br />

8 MR. JAVIER: And there that court -- I understand<br />

9 it was a PCA, but they said that the county they were<br />

10 entitled to the discretionary function and the public duty<br />

11 function, so the application of these various concepts is<br />

12 applicable here and the county should be entitled to<br />

13 summary judgment based upon those two -- those two<br />

14 functions.<br />

15 THE COURT: Okay. Anything else you want to tell<br />

16 me?<br />

17 MR. JAVIER: No, judge.<br />

18 THE COURT: You want to respond?<br />

19 MR. CIAMPA: Only if you want me to.<br />

20 THE COURT: Absolutely. I believe in giving<br />

21 everybody an opportunity.<br />

22 MR. CIAMPA: I think Your Honor understands well<br />

23 that Miller -- it says the attack upon Miller allegedly<br />

24 occurred after he had exited the Metrorail station and<br />

25 while he was on a public sidewalk waiting to board a bus.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!