CFS-WB-CH01
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
UNIT 1 CHAPTER 1
Medical
Evidence of Our
Transphysical
Soul
2
Chapter 1 Overview
Near-death experiences are episodes where people undergo clinical death and then return to physical life,
some reporting afterwards that they maintained consciousness. The very topic of near-death experiences
(NDEs) must be approached with caution. There is a lot of unscientific writing about near-death experiences,
often based on nothing but anecdotes, which is sometimes focused on the writers’ own agendas rather than
evidence.
However, there is also a growing body of legitimate research — actual medical studies published in peer-reviewed
scientific journals — on the subject of NDEs. Before we look at some of these studies, we must consider
what is meant by “near-death experiences.”
In this chapter you will learn that …
■ Science and religion have the same goal.
■ We can learn about our eternal destiny from revelation as well as natural science.
■ Our consciousness cannot be reduced to the brain, and has a transphysical component.
■ Scientific studies on near-death experiences (NDEs) and terminal lucidity provide evidence of survival of
human consciousness after clinical death.
Bible Basics
Beloved, let us love one another; for love is
of God, and he who loves is born of God and
knows God.
— 1 John 4:7
Connections to the Catechism
■ CCC 1016-1017
■ CCC 1052
Lo! I tell you a mystery. We shall not all sleep,
but we shall all be changed.
— 1 Corinthians 15:51
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
3
Chapter 1
Aa
VOCABULARY
Soul: That which animates or
gives life to a body.
Christians have always believed in a soul that lives on after death. But is
this just wishful thinking? As people living in the 21st century and all our
scientific advances, is this really something reasonable to believe?
Before we start to answer this question, consider a different one:
when you think, where in your body does that take place? Or when you
are in that dreamy twilight between being awake and asleep, where
does your awareness come from in your body? Most people today
think of it as being in the brain. But is it? Is it ever anywhere else?
Medical science gives us reason to believe our consciousness may
not be limited to the brain, or even anything physical.
Near-Death Experiences
Where does awareness
come from in your body? Is
your consciousness strictly a
physical process?
You may have read or heard in the media about a sick person whom
doctors thought had no hope of living, but then made a complete recovery.
Or maybe someone who was in a coma, but when they woke
up reported they could hear everything going on around them. These
are fascinating and mysterious events, but they are not near-death
The Flight of the Soul, Poem of the Soul, by Louis Janmot
4 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center
experiences. Near-death experiences, or NDEs, are cases where
people verifiably undergo clinical death for a time, and then return to
physical life. Some of those people afterwards reported that they maintained
consciousness during the clinical death, despite the absence of
brain function. Since this clinical death often happens in a hospital setting
with professional medical oversight, thousands of these NDEs have
been well-documented for scientific study. The patients’ reports reveal
a pattern of several recurring elements.
In many cases of clinical death, people retain their consciousness:
they can see and hear what is going on around them, they can remember
what is happening, and know who they are. Some of these people
report the experience of moving outside their body, passing through
walls in the hospital, and sometimes being transported to another
domain (this is where the popularly-known details of moving through
a tunnel and encountering a bright light come in). But in these cases,
their brains showed no electrical activity. How can this be?
Many physical traumas, like heart attacks and drowning, can deprive
the brain of oxygen. Within 30 seconds, electrical activity in the
brain drops off and most brain functions shut down. Signs of this state
of “clinical death” include a flat EEG (which measures electrical activity
in the brain), fixed and dilated pupils, and the absence of a gag reflex—
indicating that even lower brain functions have stopped. In this state,
higher brain functions such as language, memory, and thinking as well as
sensation (seeing and hearing, etc.) do not work. They are impossible.
Near-Death Experiences
(NDEs): Episodes where
people undergo clinical death
and then return to physical
life, some reporting afterward
that they maintained
consciousness despite the
absence of brain function.
Consciousness: The state
of being awake and aware of
one’s surroundings.
Transphysical: Beyond the
laws of physics.
The Relationship between the Transphysical
Component and the Brain
Now we come to the significance of understanding NDEs. Most people
assume that our consciousness comes from our brain, and that it is
strictly a physical process. When our brains stop working, that’s it. But
when we look at what is happening to the brain during clinical death, and
we compare that to the mental and sensory activity that people report
experiencing in near-death experiences (much of which can be verified
independently as we will see below), it suggests a more complex
relationship. We learn that our consciousness cannot be reduced to the
brain, and has a transphysical component (“transphysical” means beyond
the laws of physics) that lives on even when the connection with
the brain is severed. Our minds are not just matter. They appear to have
a transphysical component (that we might term “a soul”) that interacts
with our physical brain.
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
Unit 1, Chapter 1: Medical Evidence of Our Transphysical Soul
5
Here are some of the scientific studies on NDEs that provide evidence
of survival of human consciousness after clinical death. Many
other studies have reported similar findings.
Important Studies
Parnia-Southampton University Study (2014)
In 2014, scientists under the direction of Dr. Sam Parnia at Southampton
University completed the (then) largest study of NDEs — a 4-year study
of 2,060 patients who had suffered cardiac arrest in hospitals. Almost
one in ten of those patients (185) reported an NDE. Some of them
could still see for several minutes, even though the brain shuts down
beginning 30 seconds after cardiac arrest; the researchers verified patient
accounts of what was going on in the operating room.
The experience of moving
through a tunnel was reported
by nearly 1 in 4 patients in
Ring’s Study, and 1 in 3 in van
Lommel’s study.
The van Lommel et al Study (2001)
Another study published in The Lancet, surveyed 344 cardiac patients
in Dutch hospitals. They found that 18% of patients (62) experienced an
NDE, and that their experiences had an amazing amount in common.
6 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center
Half of these patients were aware of being dead, and over half felt positive
emotions. One in three met with a deceased person, experienced
moving through a tunnel and/or a celestial landscape. And a quarter reported
having an experience where they were moving separately from
their physical body.
The study ruled out several potential physiological causes for the
NDEs, identified some recurring characteristics, and reported verifiable
out-of-body experiences. In other words, patients reported seeing and
hearing things during an out-of-body experience that researchers were
able to corroborate afterwards as accurate. There is no physical way to
account for these sensory experiences in the absence of brain function,
thus indicating some form of transphysical conscious existence.
Dr. Kenneth Ring’s Studies of the Blind (2006)
These studies focused on an interesting subgroup—patients who are
blind. Among the 31 blind patients studied who had an NDE or out-ofbody
experience, 80% reported being able to see during their experience.
Those who had previous experience of seeing and those who had
been blind from birth were both consistent with the reports of sighted
patients in other NDE studies. The ability to see during these experiences,
with enough clarity to report it back afterwards, by people who
do not physically have the ability to see, shows once again, the existence
of a transphysical consciousness (a soul) capable of perception
and intelligence despite the body’s incapacity to do these functions
through physical processes.
There is no
physical way
to account for
these sensory
experiences in
the absence of
brain function,
indicating
some form of
transphysical
conscious
existence.
Consistency of Data
In a 10-year-long study, interviewing over 1,000 patients who had had
a near-death experience, Dr. Moody identified several characteristics
that consistently recurred in their reports of the experience, in similar
proportions to the studies mentioned above by Ring and van Lommel.
For example, one of the characteristics Moody included — the experience
of moving through a tunnel — was also reported in 23% of the cases
in Ring’s study and 31% of those in van Lommel’s.
Dr. Janice Holden’s Assessment of 39 NDE Studies (2007)
If someone awakens from a state of clinical death and reports that they
passed through a tunnel and encountered a being of light that was
overwhelmingly loving and peaceful, there is no way for a scientist to
directly verify such a report. But since it should be physically impossible
for someone in clinical death to see, hear, or remember anything
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
Unit 1, Chapter 1: Medical Evidence of Our Transphysical Soul
7
Veridical: Truthful;
corresponding with reality.
(especially things happening out of view or earshot), what a scientist
can do is look at things reported in NDEs that are verifiable to see if this
physically-unaccountable transphysical perception is accurate in those
cases.
Dr. Holden researched 107 cases from the reports of 39 NDE studies
in which this kind of “veridical” (verifiable) experiences was included.
Defining “accurate” in the most rigorous sense, where a single incorrect
reported detail would make an NDE report inaccurate, Holden’s
report found inaccuracy in only 8% of cases. It is hard to see how this
degree of verifiably accurate reporting from a time when there was no
electrical activity in the brain’s cortex could have a physical explanation.
What would you
think if a patient
who had been
dead woke up,
and told medical
staff things no
one else could
have known, but
turn out to be
true?
Verifiable Evidence
What would you think if a patient who had been dead woke up, and was
able to tell the medical staff what they had said or done while he was
dead? Or even tell them things no one else could have known, but turn
out to be true? There is no shortage of amazing events like this in studies
of NDEs. Virtually every peer-reviewed study reports multiple instances
of such verifiable data. Often, unusual events that occur during
a medical procedure (such as resuscitation) are seen and reported by
the patient; for example, in one case in van Lommel’s study, a patient
accurately told a nurse where she had placed his dentures during resuscitation
efforts, even giving a description of the cart where she had put
them. Patients who describe moving beyond their body to other parts
of the hospital also give verifiable details, often correctly reporting the
clothing or conversation of relatives and friends in the waiting room.
Some patients report going into other rooms in the hospital, giving accurate
descriptions of conversations, clothing, and strangers. Some actually
go through the hospital walls to the outside three or four stories
up. One patient reported seeing a tennis shoe on the ledge with a worn
left toe and a shoelace underneath the heel which had probably been
there from the time of the hospital’s construction. It was found exactly
as described. These veridical experiences are found in every major
study (and confirmed in overviews like Holden’s study) and help to corroborate
the patients’ reports of a conscious yet transphysical (i.e. outof-body)
experience.
NDEs give us good evidence of a transphysical soul, but they are by
no means the only evidence.
8 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center
Blind People who Regain their Sight
Ring’s study found that a large majority (80%) of patients who do not
have the physical capacity to see nonetheless reported being able to
see during clinical death. To date, no adequate physical explanation has
been offered for the visual perception of the blind during clinical death.
Ring’s study found that 80%
of people without the physical
ability to see reported being
able to see during clinical
death.
Absence of Death Anxiety
It is typical for patients to be afraid of death. We have a survival instinct
that is strong, and it is very hard to control anxiety about impending
death using typical de-stressing techniques. Yet several studies show
that patients who were scared before lose their feelings of anxiety
about death after having an NDE. Why would this be? Even children who
underwent clinical death with an NDE had a much lower level of death
anxiety than other children. (Interestingly, young patients who were
clinically dead but did not have an NDE felt more scared about death
afterwards.) In other words, NDEs seem to have a special healing power
transcending the power of survival instincts and subconscious fears
that fall outside of known physiological and psychological explanations.
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
Unit 1, Chapter 1: Medical Evidence of Our Transphysical Soul
9
Physicalism: Belief that
the physical world is all that
exists. This term is sometimes
used interchangeably with
materialism.
Meeting Deceased Persons
Of course, when a person reports that they died and met an old friend
or family member, we cannot directly verify that. But what about when
these reports include information that the patient could not otherwise
have known but can be confirmed by others? This happens with surprising
frequency: a third of these reports involve meeting relatives that the
patient would not know personally, sometimes even meeting strangers
or distant acquaintances. This last point also means it is not simply, as
some hypothesize, that people are simply seeing the loved ones they
are naturally thinking of and would want to see in their dying hours. A
catalog of the kinds of meetings experienced and the data reported
that was not otherwise known by the patient prior to clinical death
has been gathered by Greyson and Kelly at the University of Virginia
Medical School.
Physicalist Explanations
It may not surprise you to learn that some in the current scientific community
do not accept this view of the transphysical origin of human
consciousness. Some have attempted to explain NDEs from a purely
physiological point of view, to restore credibility to the view that our
consciousness has a purely physical origin. That is, some have tried to
find physicalist explanations that can account for NDEs without appealing
to a transphysical consciousness (soul).
Could NDEs be caused by something physical in the brain?
Researchers led by Olaf Blanke in 2003 placed electrodes in the brain
(specifically, the angular gyrus of the parietal lobe) and triggered an
“out-of-body like” experience in several patients. These were not at
all like NDEs, though. Patients reported unusual distortions like seeing
their legs growing shorter, or seeing a body double of themselves.
These experiences are nothing like the highly detailed and accurate reports
of the patient’s real (and often out-of-view) hospital surroundings
found in NDE studies.
Another possible explanation is oxygen deprivation. Lack of oxygen
in the dying brain could cause neurons related to visual sensing to fire,
causing an experience of a white light at the end of a tunnel. However,
all dying people experience loss of oxygen to the brain. So if oxygen
deprivation causes NDEs, everyone would have NDEs. In fact, only 18%
of adults do, and some NDEs happen to people while feeling well.
10 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center
Experimenters ruled out the
possibility that NDEs were
just dreamlets — dream-like
experiences that happen to
fighter pilots when their brains
are under extreme stress.
Eternal: Without beginning or
end; not constrained by time.
One last possibility is that NDEs could in fact be dreamlets: dreamlike
experiences that happen to people like fighter pilots when their
brains are under extreme stress. But research shows that people wake
up from dreamlets confused and anxious — instead of having lucid recollections
and positive, life-transforming experiences as people do with
NDEs.
Even if there were somehow a way to explain NDEs as physical illusions,
it still wouldn’t account for the accurate sense perceptions of
both sighted and blind people during clinical death, when their physical
senses are not functioning. A physical explanation might be able to account
for a hallucination, but it does not explain how people can accurately
report empirical data, including previously unknown information
about deceased individuals during the time of clinical death. All the verifiable
evidence above calls for a transphysical perception that physical
explanations, by definition, cannot offer.
A physical
explanation
cannot explain
how people
can accurately
report empirical
data during the
time of clinical
death.
Near-Death Experiences, Love, and Resurrection
There are interesting clues in the reports of NDEs that indicate our
consciousness is eternal. There are also three similarities between the
reports of NDEs and the revelation and Resurrection of Jesus, who
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
Unit 1, Chapter 1: Medical Evidence of Our Transphysical Soul
11
Transcendent: Going beyond
ordinary limitations.
Resurrection of the Dead:
The raising of all the dead at
the end of time to face the
Last Judgment when the
wicked will be sent to eternal
punishment and the righteous
to eternal life.
preached that God intended us for eternal life as recipients of His unconditional
love. The three points of similarity are freedom from physical
limitations, the experience of love, and transcendence. The following
case from Moody’s study is similar to many:
The patient explains:
I became very weak, and I fell down. I began to feel a
sort of drifting, a movement of my real being in and
out of my body, and to hear beautiful music. I floated
on down the hall and out the door onto the screened-in
porch. There, it almost seemed that clouds, a pink mist
really, began to gather around me, and then I floated
right straight on through the screen, just as though it
weren’t there, and up into this pure crystal clear light,
an illuminating white light. It was beautiful and so bright,
so radiant, but it didn’t hurt my eyes. It’s not any kind
of light you can describe on earth. I didn’t actually see
a person in this light, and yet it has a special identity,
it definitely does. It is a light of perfect understanding
and perfect love…. And all during this time, I felt as
though I was surrounded by an overwhelming love and
compassion.
Patients in NDEs keep bodily powers like seeing and hearing, but
are free of physical constraint: they can to move through walls, ascend
upward, and move beyond the physical domain. The Resurrected Jesus
has these freedoms in His glorified body, and Christian revelation further
teaches that our own bodies will be similarly transformed at the
Resurrection of the Dead.
The second similarity is that the essence of eternal life is love — Jesus
told us love was central in the Kingdom of God, and NDE patients describe
overwhelming love as their dominant experience in the realm of
light.
Finally, there is the experience of transcendence. There is a dimension
of beauty, joy, and paradise — ultimate fulfillment — in many accounts
of NDEs as well as in Christian revelation about the Kingdom of
Heaven. (We will explore this more deeply in future chapters.)
We might conclude from this correlation between medical studies
of near-death experiences and Christian revelation that NDEs provide
empirical veridical and circumstantial corroboration of Jesus’ message
in the New Testament, and also that His message in the New Testament
confirms that our transphysical soul is destined for eternal life.
12 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center
Resurrection of Lazarus, by Lippo Memmi
Evidence of a Soul from Terminal Lucidity
Imagine someone you knew has had advanced Alzheimer’s disease for
ten years. They have not been able to recognize loved ones or even
have a conversation during that time. Then one day, as they approach
death, they suddenly notice you in the room and start talking to you,
almost like normal. This is known as terminal lucidity, and it is another
kind of evidence for our souls and the afterlife. Several studies show us
that the minds of many persons with dementia, Alzheimer’s, or other severe
disorders of the brain suddenly become clear (or lucid) shortly before
death. One week to one day prior to death, some of these patients
phoned family members and friends, and had rational, meaningful, emotional,
and religious conversations with them, even though they had no
use of their cerebral cortex, which is needed for these higher intellectual
functions. The brain, when it is severely atrophied (e.g. from Alzheimer’s
disease), is not capable of such higher functions, so it appears that consciousness
separates from the body shortly before death.
Persons with terminal lucidity show an awareness of relatives,
friends, practical details to which they must attend before dying, God’s
Jesus’ raising of Lazarus is a
sign that all the dead will be
raised at the end of time.
Terminal Lucidity:
Phenomenon where the minds
of patients with dementia or
Alzheimer’s disease suddenly
become clear shortly before
death. Persons with terminal
lucidity are aware of relatives
and friends, God’s presence,
prayers, good and evil,
and right or wrong, even
though their brains had been
incapable of rational thought,
sometimes for many years.
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
Unit 1, Chapter 1: Medical Evidence of Our Transphysical Soul
13
All persons,
even those
with physical,
emotional, or
intellectual
limitations, have
inherent dignity
and are worthy
of respect.
presence, prayers, good and evil, and right or wrong, even though their
brains may have been completely incapable of rational thought for
many years.
For instance, in 1922, there was a woman named Anna Ehmer who
had been born severely mentally impaired. She had never learned
to speak a single word, and had suffered severe infections that had
damaged her brain. Yet, a half an hour before dying, she sang, “Where
does the soul find its home, its peace? Peace, peace, heavenly peace!”
During her terminal lucidity, Anna’s face was transfigured and spiritualized.
Then, she quietly passed away. These final events were witnessed
and verified by two physicians working at the mental institution where
Ehmer resided. This is not an isolated case: researchers found a total
of 81 references to similar cases, reported by 51 different authors,
in which people with severely damaged brain tissue needed for cognitive
processes suddenly came to a heightened sense of consciousness
and focus between one week to one hour before death. Terminal
lucidity shows the presence of a soul even in cases of severe mental
impairment.
As Christians, we know that all persons, even those with physical,
emotional, or intellectual limitations, have souls allowing them to understand
and communicate with God. There is yet another important
consequence of the data coming from the study of terminal lucidity
— namely the existence of a rich inner world within even the most
mentally challenged individuals. All persons, from the unborn to the terminally
ill, and regardless of their circumstances, have an inherent dignity
and are worthy of respect. To treat them any other way, based simply
on their outward appearance or expression, would be a violation of their
dignity and their right to respect.
Conclusion
The medical studies of terminal lucidity, together with those of NDEs,
show that it is reasonable to believe that we have a transcendent soul
that can exist independently of the physical body — and which therefore
can go on after a person dies. In the next chapter, we will be discussing
additional evidence of the soul — and even God’s presence to it — from
philosophy.
14 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center
LIVES
OF
FAITH
Among the Catholic faithful
throughout the centuries,
few have embraced and proclaimed
the inherent harmony
of science and faith, of reason
and revelation, like St. Albert
the Great.
Born sometime between
1193 and 1206, Albert of
Lauingen lived through most
of what has been called “the
greatest of centuries” and bore the title of Magnus
(the Great) while he was still alive. This accolade
was due to his incredible breadth of knowledge and
mastery of virtually every scientific discipline at the
time — literally from A to Z — with contributions to
fields as diverse as anatomy, anthropology, astronomy,
biology, botany, chemistry, dentistry, geography,
geology, medicine, physiology, physics, psychology,
and zoology.
So how did Great Albert get to be so great? To
examine Saint Albert the thinker, we should start
with young Albert the student. Albert’s parents
were of the lower nobility and died when he and
his siblings were relatively young. Albert was raised
by his uncle and likely received the lasting benefits
of a medieval system of education based on
the seven classical liberal arts. By learning the nature
of inflected Latin, Albert grew to understand
the fundamental nature of all languages. By learning
logic, he discovered how to differentiate valid
from invalid arguments and truths from falsehoods.
St. Albert the Great
By learning rhetoric, he saw the
importance of carefully defining
terms, the importance of a powerful
memory, and the necessity
of and methods for tailoring one’s
preaching or teaching to one’s audience.
As a young man he chose
to hone these tools of learning further
at the University of Padua, the
world’s foremost center of learning
of the liberal arts. While he was
there, he entered the newly-formed Dominican
Order at the age of 16.
In 1248 Albert was appointed regent at a new
Studium Gen erale back in Cologne. He introduced
the brilliant works of Aristotle to the West in his
meticulous, line-by-line commentaries on many of
Aristotle’s works, works that some feared threatened
the Faith, since Aristotle reasoned, for example, that
the universe was eternal and that God did not take
interest in human affairs.
Albert faithfully reported what Aristotle truly
taught, the bulk of it being magnificent and in harmony
with the truths of the Church. In his own later
works, Albert was anything but a parrot of Aristotle’s
opinions in science and philosophy, however, contradicting
him at times in specific matters through
his own experience or experimentation. Albert even
wrote a treatise on Aristotle’s errors.
Albert was one of history’s greatest thinkers. A
Doctor of the Church, he is the patron saint of scientists
and philosophers.
Adapted from Hounds of the Lord: Great Dominican Saints Every Catholic Should Know by Dr. Kevin Vost.
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
Unit 1, Chapter 1: Medical Evidence of Our Transphysical Soul
15
Focus and Reflection Questions
1 What is a near-death experience?
2 What does it mean for something to be transphysical?
3 What is the term for a medical state where a person has no electrical activity in the brain, fixed and
dilated pupils, and the absence of a gag reflex?
4 What organ is commonly understood to be where consciousness originates? What does scientific
evidence suggest about this presumption?
5 How many patients were in the study conducted by Parnia-Southampton University Study (2014),
and how many of those reported an NDE?
6 What did scientists find in the van Lommel et al Study (2001)?
7 What were 80% of the blind persons able to do during their NDEs? What does this suggest about
sensation?
8 Which of the studies described in the chapter text do you find most interesting and why?
9 Give an example of veridical data reported by patients with an NDE.
10 Some theorize that people who experience meeting deceased persons during an NDE are simply
seeing the loved ones they would naturally think of. What is a piece of evidence that casts doubt on
this theory?
11 What is terminal lucidity and how does it provide evidence for transphysical consciousness?
12 How did St. Albert the Great’s treatment of Aristotle evidence his commitment to both Faith and
reason?
16 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center
Straight to the Source
ADDITIONAL READINGS FROM PRIMARY SOURCES
Fifth Lateran Council, Session 8, 1512-1517
The soul not only truly exists of itself and essentially as the form of the human body… but it is also
immortal.
1 What does this document say about the human soul?
2 The soul is made in the image of God. What do you think the Council Fathers mean by saying the soul
is the form of the human body?
Fides et Ratio (blessing), An Encyclical Letter of Pope St. John Paul II, September 14, 1998
Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and
God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth — in a word, to know himself — so that, by
knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves (cf.
Ex 33:18; Ps 27:8-9; 63:2-3; Jn 14:8; 1 Jn 3:2).
1 What desire does Pope St. John Paul II say God has placed in the human heart?
2 Why do you think Pope St. John Paul II compares Faith and reason to wings (rather than another set
of two such as hands, eyes, or rollerskates)? Is it an apt metaphor? Why or why not?
Fides et Ratio 1-2, An Encyclical Letter of Pope St. John Paul II, September 14, 1998
1. In both East and West, we may trace a journey which has led humanity down the centuries to meet and
engage truth more and more deeply. It is a journey which has unfolded — as it must — within the horizon
of personal self-consciousness: the more human beings know reality and the world, the more they know
themselves in their uniqueness, with the question of the meaning of things and of their very existence
becoming ever more pressing. This is why all that is the object of our knowledge becomes a part of our
life. The admonition Know yourself was carved on the temple portal at Delphi, as testimony to a basic
truth to be adopted as a minimal norm by those who seek to set themselves apart from the rest of creation
as “human beings”, that is as those who “know themselves”.
Moreover, a cursory glance at ancient history shows clearly how in different parts of the world, with their
different cultures, there arise at the same time the fundamental questions which pervade human life:
Who am I? Where have I come from and where am I going? Why is there evil? What is there after this life?
These are the questions which we find in the sacred writings of Israel, as also in the Veda and the Avesta;
we find them in the writings of Confucius and Lao-Tze, and in the preaching of Tirthankara and Buddha;
© Sophia Institute for Teachers
Unit 1, Chapter 1: Medical Evidence of Our Transphysical Soul
17
they appear in the poetry of Homer and in the tragedies of Euripides and Sophocles, as they do in the
philosophical writings of Plato and Aristotle. They are questions which have their common source in
the quest for meaning which has always compelled the human heart. In fact, the answer given to these
questions decides the direction which people seek to give to their lives.
2. The Church is no stranger to this journey of discovery, nor could she ever be. From the moment when,
through the Paschal Mystery, she received the gift of the ultimate truth about human life, the Church
has made her pilgrim way along the paths of the world to proclaim that Jesus Christ is “the way, and
the truth, and the life” (Jn 14:6). It is her duty to serve humanity in different ways, but one way in particular
imposes a responsibility of a quite special kind: the diakonia of the truth. This mission on the one
hand makes the believing community a partner in humanity’s shared struggle to arrive at truth; and on
the other hand it obliges the believing community to proclaim the certitudes arrived at, albeit with a
sense that every truth attained is but a step towards that fullness of truth which will appear with the final
Revelation of God: “For now we see in a mirror dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part; then I
shall understand fully” (1 Cor 13:12).
1 Why do you think Pope St. John Paul II takes note of fundamental questions observed in the writings
of pre-Christian societies and non-Christian traditions?
2 How does the Church uniquely serve humanity in our pursuit of truth?
3 In this chapter we have examined medical evidence for a soul. How is this study part of the pursuit of
truth?
18 Apologetics I: The Catholic Faith and Science
© Magis Center