Serial Murderers and their Victims, 5th ed. - Brainshare Public ...

166 CHAPTER 5
P R O F I L E 5.17 Cary Stayner, the Yosemite Park Signature
Killer, 1999
Cary Stayner could have easily been a model gracing the pages of GQ magazine. Tall,
dark, and striking, he rated high on “attractiveness” by many women. Due to his
artistic giftedness, Cary was voted “most creative” by his graduating class and was
expected to become a famous cartoonist. I had the opportunity to examine several
drawings done by Mr. Stayner around 1995. These drawings depicted scenes of death
and destruction, with heads of victims on the ground. The backdrop was Yosemite
National Park. Those who know him describe him as amiable, easy going, and quiet.
He is described as a naturalist, with a penchant for nudity, frequenting secluded lake
areas to sunbathe unencumbered. His acquaintances were shocked at his confessions
of multiple murder and even more so by the macabre means by which he killed.
First born of five children, Cary was eldest brother to Steven Stayner, who in
1972 was kidnapped and held prisoner by a child molester for almost 8 years. He
escaped, bringing with him a 5-year-old child who had also been abducted. Making
national headlines, Steven became the hero, his notoriety pushing his sibling into
obscurity. Disgusted by the book written about his brother and the made-for-TV
movie, Cary’s resentment grew.
At Merced High School, Cary was considered a good student and was thought of
positively. But his home life was deteriorating with the separation of his parents. He
moved in with his uncle, Jesse Stayner, until 1990 when tragedy struck and an
intruder shot Jesse to death. Cary was never considered a suspect and was believed
to have been at work. His employers considered him a diligent worker and a proven
employee, always showing up on time and never the object of customer complaints.
Between 1996 and 1997, Cary moved to El Portal in Yosemite National Park
where he worked as a handyman at several hotels. Those who knew him described
him as likeable, a loner who never dated and was not inclined to close friendships.
Though he occasionally smoked marijuana, he was not disposed to drinking, even
when generous tourists at the hotel offered to indulge everyone with a “round.” But
such benign behavior only masked the brooding predator within. Rarely does evil not
masquerade. For many years, Cary Stayner had fantasized about killing women.
In the spring of 1999, Eureka, California, resident Carol Sund, 42, her daughter
Julie Sund, 16, and an Argentine friend, Silvina Pelosso, 16, were visitors to Yosemite
National Park in California. On February 14, they checked in at Cedar Lodge where
Signatures are helpful in profiling criminal behaviors and can link offenders
to crimes. Signatures also can help determine the level of progression and sophistication
of the predator. This usually means that a first-time offender will not