На правах рукописи ЛУЧИНИН ИГОРЬ ВЛАДИМИРОВИЧ ...

GZijZ\Zojmdhibkb
EMQBGBGB=HJVBBJHH<
Ki_pbZevghklv–ZrbguZ]j_]Zlubijhp_kku
Zrbghkljh_gb_\g_nl_i_j_jZ[Zlu\Zxs_cijhfure_gghklb
:

JZ[hlZ\uiheg_gZgZdZn_^j_L_ogheh]byg_nlygh]hZiiZjZlhkljh_gby
Mnbfkdh]h]hkm^Zjkl\_ggh]hg_nlygh]hl_ogbq_kdh]hmgb\_jkbl_lZM=GLM
GZmqgucjmdh\h^bl_ev
^hdlhjl_ogbq_kdbogZmdijhn_kkhjaZ
kem`_gguc^_yl_evgZmdbJhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbb;Zdb_\:<
HnbpbZevgu_hiihg_glu
^hdlhjl_ogbq_kdbogZmdijhn_kkhj
OZnbah\NR
dZg^b^Zll_ogbq_kdbogZmd
:okZgh\JJ
ijb Mnbfkdhf ]hkm^Zjkl\_gghf g_nlyghf l_ogbq_
kdhfmgb\_jkbl_l_ihZ^j_km]MnZmeDhkfhgZ\lh\
K^bkk_jlZpb_cfh`ghhagZdhfblvky\[b[ebhl_d_M=GLM
:\lhj_n_jZljZahkeZg30 fZy]
Mq_guck_dj_lZjv
^bkk_jlZpbhggh]hkh\_lZ
^hdlhjl_ogbq_kdbogZmdijhn_kkhj
B=B[jZ]bfh\

H;S:YO:J:DL?JBKLBD:J:;HLU
:dlmZevghklvijh[e_fu

P_evjZ[hlu
JZajZ[hldZdhgkljmdpbb\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlhjZjZ[hlZxs_]hgZijbgpb
iZo dZ\blZpbhggh–\boj_\uo wnn_dlh\ iha\heyxsbo hkms_kl\blv hqbkldm
klhqguo\h^hlm]e_\h^hjh^h\
Hkgh\gu_aZ^Zqbbkke_^h\Zgby
JZajZ[hlZlvdhgkljmdpbxeZ[hjZlhjgh]hh[jZapZ\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlh
jZiha\heyxs_]hbkihevah\Zlvwnn_dludZ\blZpbbp_gljh[_`gu_bp_gljhkl
j_fbl_evgu_kbeubbkke_^h\ZlvaZdhghf_jghklb^\b`_gbyihlhdh\\g_f
JZajZ[hlZlv f_lh^bdm jZkq_lZ ]_hf_ljbq_kdbo iZjZf_ljh\ \boj_\h]h
k_iZjZlhjZ^ey\u^_e_gbym]e_\h^hjh^guoijbf_k_cbaklhqguo\h^\aZ\bkb
fhklbhlijhba\h^bl_evghklb
3Bkke_^h\Zlv\ebygb_dhgkljmdlb\guojZaf_jh\k_iZjZlhjZboZjZdl_
jbklbd \oh^ys_]h ihlhdZ gZ kl_i_gv \u^_e_gby m]e_\h^hjh^guo ijbf_k_c ba
klhqguo\h^
GZhkgh\_wdki_jbf_glZevguobkke_^h\Zgbcbij_^eh`_gghcf_lh^bdb
jZkq_lZba]hlh\blvhiulgh-ijhfure_gguch[jZa_p\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlhjZ^ey
\g_^j_gby_]hgZij_^ijbylbyog_nl_i_j_jZ[Zlu\Zxs_]hdhfie_dkZ
GZmqgZygh\bagZ
Ij_^eh`_gZf_lh^bdZjZkq_lZ]_hf_ljbq_kdbooZjZdl_jbklbd\boj_\h
]hk_iZjZlhjZknjZdpbhgbjmxsbfmkljhckl\hfgZhkgh\_ihemq_gguol_hj_
lbq_kdbobwdki_jbf_glZevguoj_amevlZlh\
Ihemq_gZ ZgZeblbq_kdZy aZ\bkbfhklv baf_g_gby klZlbq_kdh]h ^Z\e_
gbyihjZ^bmkm\oh^ghcdZf_ju^eyjZaguo^Z\e_gbc`b^dhklbgZ\oh^_\Zi
iZjZl
Ihemq_gh mjZ\g_gb_ mklZgZ\eb\Zxs__ aZ\bkbfhklv baf_g_gby iehl
ghklb]ZaZihjZ^bmkm]Zah\h]hijhkljZgkl\Z\p_glj_\oh^ghcdZf_ju\boj_\h
]hk_iZjZlhjZ

IjZdlbq_kdZyp_gghklv
JZajZ[hlZgZ b j_Zebah\ZgZ l_ogheh]by jZa^_e_gby \h^u hl m]e_\h^h
jh^guoijbf_k_cijbl_fi_jZlmjZoihke_^gbogb`_l_fi_jZlmjugZqZeZdbi_
gby\h^u
2.JZajZ[hlZgZdhgkljmdpby\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlhjZiha\heyxsZyhl^_eylv
hlklhqguo\h^m]e_\h^hjh^gu_ijbf_kbihnjZdpbyf
Ba]hlh\e_g b bkiulZg hiulgh-ijhfure_gguc h[jZa_p \boj_\h]h k_
iZjZlhjZ\p_oZoBI–10 Z BI-b>–H:HDZmqmd]Kl_jeblZfZd<
j_amevlZl_ijh\_^_gguobkiulZgbcdhebq_kl\hm]e_\h^hjh^h\\klhqghc\h^_
mf_gvr_ghgZ
Ijh\_^_gubkiulZgby\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlhjZih^hhqbkld_ijhfukeh
\uo klhqguo \h^ i_j_^ aZdZqdhc bo \ ieZkl gZ dmklh\hc gZkhkghc klZgpbb
G=>M:jeZgg_nlvijbwlhfkh^_j`Zgb_g_nlb\\h^_mf_gvr_ghgZZ
hklZlhqgh_dhebq_kl\hg_nl_ijh^mdlh\ihiZ^Z_l\ieZkl\kbevgh^bki_j]bjh
\Zgghf khklhygbb qlh mkljZgy_l aZfZamqb\Zgb_ ijh^mdlb\guo ieZklh\ b kh
ojZgy_lbodhee_dlhjkdb_k\hckl\Z
:ijh[ZpbyjZ[hlu
Hkgh\gu_iheh`_gbybj_amevlZlujZ[hlu^hdeZ^u\Zebkvbh[km`^Zebkv
gZ « -c gZmqgh-l_ogbq_kdbo dhgn_j_gpbyo klm^_glh\ ZkibjZglh\ b
fheh^uo mqzguo M=GLM] MnZ – ]] J_kim[ebdZgkdhc gZmqghl_ogbq_kdhcdhgn_j_gpbbL_ogbdZgZihjh]_OOI\_dZ]MnZ]_
`^mgZjh^ghfNhjmf_ihijh[e_fZfgZmdbl_ogbdbbh[jZah\ZgbyIIIlukyq_
e_lb_–gh\ucfbj]hkd\Z]II_`^mgZjh^ghcgZmqghcdhgn_j_g
pbbL_hjby b ijZdlbdZ fZkkhh[f_gguo ijhp_kkh\ obfbq_kdhc l_ogheh]bb
Zjmrdbgkdb_ ql_gby ] MnZ ] gZmqgh-l_ogbq_kdbo k_fbgZjZo dZ
n_^ju©L_ogheh]byg_nlygh]hZiiZjZlhkljh_gbyªM=GLM-]]
Im[ebdZpbb
Hkgh\gh_kh^_j`Zgb_^bkk_jlZpbhgghcjZ[hluhim[ebdh\Zgh\gZmq
gh-l_ogbq_kdboklZlvyobl_abkZo^hdeZ^h\gZmqgh-l_ogbq_kdbodhgn_j_gpbc

H[t_fjZ[hlu
>bkk_jlZpbykhklhblba\\_^_gbyq_lujzo]eZ\b\u\h^h\kibkdZebl_
jZlmjubijbeh`_gbc\dexqZ_ljbkmgdZkh^_j`bllZ[ebpkljZgbp
i_qZlgh]hfZl_jbZeZ
:\lhj \ujZ`Z_l ]em[hdmx [eZ]h^Zjghklv dlg KbfZdh\m ?J@:GB?J:;HLU
ZgZ deZkkbnbdZpby f_lh^h\ hqbkldb klhqguo \h^ ih
nZah\h-^bki_jkghcoZjZdl_jbklbd_bobfbq_kdhfmkhklZ\mijbf_k_c
JZkkfhlj_gu hkgh\gu_ f_lh^u jZa^_e_gby hkZ`^_gb_ nbevljh\Zgb_
nehlZpbybwe_dljhnehlZpbyjZa^_e_gb_keh`ghckbkl_fu\ihe_p_gljh[_`
guokbep_gljbnm]bjh\Zgb_bjZa^_e_gb_\]b^jhpbdehgZo

JZkkfhlj_gu kihkh[u b dhgkljmdpbb ]b^jhpbdehgh\ b k_iZjZlhjh\ pb
dehggh]h lbiZ ^ey hqbkldb `b^dhkl_c hl ijbf_k_cl\zj^uo qZklbp fZk_e b
^j
GZb[he__i_jki_dlb\gufbklhqdbaj_gbyih\ur_gbygZ^z`ghklbbwn
n_dlb\ghklb ijhp_kkh\ jZa^_e_gby y\eyxlky kihkh[u hqbkldb `b^dhkl_c k
bkihevah\Zgb_f]b^jhpbdehgh\

obf_^h\hc kibjZeb b h^gh\j_f_ggh i_j_f_sZ_lky \ hk_\hf gZijZ\e_gbb d
keb\ghfmdZgZemk_iZjZlhjZIjbi_j_f_s_gbbhli_jbn_jbbdp_gljmhk_\Zy
kdhjhklvqZklbqdbkj_^um\_ebqb\Z_lky\-jZaijbwlhfp_gljh[_`gZykb
eZ^_ckl\mxsZygZqZklbqdmfh`_l\hajZklb\-jZa;eZ]h^Zjywlhfm
dZdihdZaZebgZrbbkke_^h\Zgbye_]db_dhfihg_glufZkehkj_^u–iZjh\h]h
dhg^_gkZlZ-dhgp_gljbjmxlkydhevp_\ufkeh_f\ijbhk_\hcahg_pbdehgZgZ
]jZgbp_`b^dhklv – ]Zah\uc\ha^mrguc klhe[ ?keb\kj_^_ijbkmlkl\m_l
jZkl\hjbl_evlhbkoh^gmx`b^dhklvij_^\Zjbl_evghgZ]j_\Zxl\l_iehh[f_g
guo ZiiZjZlZo ^h l_fi_jZlmju ijb dhlhjhc hg i_j_c^_l \ iZjhh[jZagh_ kh
klhygb_bfh`_l[ulv\u\_^_g\\b^_kljmbiZjZbaahguhk_\h]hiZjh\h]h\bo
jy
Dhgkljmdpby eZ[hjZlhjgh]h h[jZapZ \boj_\h]h k_iZjZlhjZ ihemq_ggZy
gZ hkgh\_ fh^_jgbaZpbb ]b^jhpbdehgZ ijb\_^_gZ gZ jbk Bkoh^gZy `b^
dhklvgZijbf_jklhqgZy\h^Zkh^_j`ZsZym]e_\h^hjh^u\\h^blky\ZiiZjZl
q_j_aiZljm[hd\h\oh^gmxdZf_jmIh^^_ckl\b_fp_gljh[_`guobZjob
f_^h\uokbeijbi_j_oh^_`b^dhklbbadZf_juq_j_ahl\_jklb_\^bZnjZ]f_
\\uoh^gmxdZf_jmhkms_kl\ey_lkynbabq_kdh_jZa^_e_gb_`b^dhkl_cLy
`_eZy `b^dhklv – \h^Z - \uc^_l q_j_a lZg]_gpbZevguc iZljm[hd:p_lhg
[_gabg kibjlu b ^jm]b_ e_]dhbkiZjyxsb_ky dhfihg_glu hl[bjZxlky q_j_a
iZljm[dbIjbq_fbaiZljm[dZkZfu_e_]db_dhfihg_glu[m^ml\uoh
^blv\\b^_iZjh\Q_j_akfhljh\h_kl_dehfh`gh[uehgZ[ex^ZlvaZih\_^_
gb_f`b^dhklb\gmljb\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlhjZ
>eymemqr_gbyjZa^_eyxs_ckihkh[ghklbZiiZjZlZbm\_ebq_gbyfZkkh
\hc ^heb hl[bjZ_fhc e_]dhbkiZjyxs_cky njZdpbb bkoh^gmx `b^dhklv i_j_^
\\h^hf\k_iZjZlhjij_^\Zjbl_evghih^h]j_\Zxl\l_iehh[f_ggbd_
;uebijhZgZebabjh\Zgukbeu^_ckl\mxsb_\\boj_\hfk_iZjZlhj_JZk
qzlZfbihdZaZghqlhlZg]_gpbZevgZykdhjhklv\k_iZjZlhj_fh`_lm\_ebqblvky
^hfknZdlhjjZa^_e_gbyihp_gljh[_`ghckbe_-\jZaZhg`_ihkbe_
ly`_klb–[he__q_f\jZa

7
8
1
9
d â
d ï
3
d Ä
2
6
5
D
4
JbkKo_fZeZ[hjZlhjgh]hh[jZapZ\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlhjZ
D –\gmlj_ggbc^bZf_ljk_iZjZlhjZd \ –^bZf_lj]Zah\h]h\bojy
d i –^bZf_ljiblZxs_]hiZljm[dZd^ –^bZf_lj^bZnjZ]fu
JZkkfhlj_gu kms_kl\mxsb_ f_lh^bdb jZkqzlZ ijhba\h^bl_evghklb pb
dehgguoZiiZjZlh\
:gZebanhjfme^eyjZkq_lZijhba\h^bl_evghklbijb\_^_gguojy^hfZ\
lhjh\ihdZau\Z_lqlhgbh^gZbaij_^eh`_gguobfbg_^Z_l^hklZlhqgh]hkh\
iZ^_gbyjZkq_lghcijhba\h^bl_evghklbknZdlbq_kdhc
Ijb ba\_klghc ijhba\h^bl_evghklb G ]b^jhpbdehgZ gZb[he__ keh`ghc
aZ^Zq_c y\ey_lky gZoh`^_gb_ lZdbo iZjZf_ljh\ dZd ^bZf_lj pbdehgZ D ieh
sZ^vk_q_gbyf n beb^bZf_ljZiblZxs_]hdZgZeZd n hdjm`ghckdhjhklbihlhdZ
υ t i_j_iZ^Z^Z\e_gby\k_iZjZlhj_∆jkdhjhklbhkZ`^_gby\kieulbyqZklbpb
^j >ey gZoh`^_gby wlbo \_ebqbg \ ijZdlbd_ bkihevamxl nhjfmeu lZ[ebpu
ghfh]jZffufh^_ebjh\Zgb_

jZkqzlguoihnhjfme_JQ_klhgZbgZrbohiulguo^Zgguo\hajZklZ_lkm\_
ebq_gb_f^bZf_ljZpbdehgZk^h
GZijbf_j_fh^_ebjh\Zgbyk_iZjZlhjZihjZkoh^m`b^dhklbbi_j_iZ^m
^Z\e_gby jZkqzlZfb lZd`_ ihdZaZgZ [hevrZy ih]j_rghklv kms_kl\mxs_c f_
lh^bdb
< jZ[hl_ ij_^eh`_gZ f_lh^bdZ jZkqzlZ \boj_\h]h k_iZjZlhjZ hlebqZx
sZykyhlba\_klghcf_lh^bdbjZkqzlZ]b^jhpbdehgZdhlhjZyk\h^blkyd\u[hjm
beb jZkqzlm ]b^jZ\ebq_kdbo b ]_hf_ljbq_kdbo oZjZdl_jbklbd k_iZjZlhjZ_]h
ijhba\h^bl_evghklb ^bZf_ljZ ZiiZjZlZ iblZxs_]h iZljm[dZ jZaf_jh\ ^bZ
njZ]fubiZjhhl[hjhqghc]heh\db
>ey \u[hjZ ^bZf_ljZ k_iZjZlhjZ [ueb kh[jZgu b h[jZ[hlZgu wdki_jb
f_glZevgu_^Zggu_hl_q_kl\_gguobaZjm[_`guoZ\lhjh\ihoZjZdl_jbklbdZf
]b^jhpbdehgh\ ^bZf_ljhf hl ^hf Bo ZgZeba ihdZaZe qlh gZb[he__
ih^oh^ysbf^eyh[_ki_q_gbyaZ^Zgghcijhba\h^bl_evghklbG ν f 3 qy\
ey_lkypbdehgkD m ff
Ih ij_^eh`_gghc f_lh^bd_ b \u[jZgghfm ^bZf_ljm [ueb ih^h[jZgu b
jZkkqblZgu ke_^mxsb_ oZjZdl_jbklbdb k_iZjZlhjZ ^bZf_lj iblZxs_]h iZl
jm[dZd i ff^bZf_lj^bZnjZ]fud^ ff^bZf_lj\ha^mrgh]h\bojy
d \ ff JZkqzl ]_hf_ljbq_kdbo jZaf_jh\ hl^_evguo we_f_glh\ iZjhhl[h
jhqghc ]heh\db k_iZjZlhjZ ijh\_^zg ih jZajZ[hlZgghc gZfb f_lh^bd_ ^ey
klhqghc\h^ukfZdkbfZevgufbfZkkh\ufbdhgp_gljZpbyfb\g_cm]e_\h^hjh
^h\ihj_]eZf_glmij_^ijbylby
:gZeba ebl_jZlmjguo^ZgguoihdZaZeqlh\u[hj\gmlj_gg_]h^bZf_ljZ
D pbdehgguo ZiiZjZlh\ jZaebqgufb Z\lhjZfb \ hkgh\ghf ijh\h^blky ijhba
\hevgh k mq_lhf nmgdpbhgZevghc aZ\bkbfhklb G = ϕ(D ]^_ G – ijhba\h^b
l_evghklvZiiZjZlZihjZ[hq_ckj_^_Ijbwlhf_]h^bZf_ljqZklh\u[bjZ_lky
dhgkljmdlhjZfb ^h\hevgh mkeh\gh qlh mkeh`gy_l khihklZ\e_gb_ j_amevlZlh\
jZaebqguobkke_^h\Zgbc

ke_^h\Zl_eyfbhl^hf\i_j_\h^_gZmkeh\guc^bZf_ljD y klZevguo
ljm[
H^gh\j_f_ggh ij_^eh`_g ^bZiZahg jZkq_lguo ^Z\e_gbc hl ^h
IZijbdhlhjuogZb[he__wnn_dlb\ghfh]mljZ[hlZlv[hevrbgkl\hpbdehg
guoZiiZjZlh\g_nlyghcijhfure_gghklb
Lj_lvy ]eZ\Z ihk\ys_gZ eZ[hjZlhjguf bkke_^h\Zgbyf ij_^eh`_gghc
dhgkljmdpbb\boj_\h]hk_iZjZlhjZ

2
1
3
4
8
5
6
7
14
12 13
11
10

Gv,
ë/ ìèí
60
1
3
2
60
G v
,
ë/ ìèí
40
40
30
20
20
10
0
0,05 0,1 0,15 0,2 pï,Ì Ïà
0 10 20 30 40 50 d 70
Ä ,ìì
JbkAZ\bkbfhklvjZkoh^Z`b^dhklb Jbk

H[jZ[hldZwdki_jbf_glZevguo^ZgguoaZ\bkbfhklbjZkoh^Z`b^dhklbG v
efbghl^bZf_ljZ^bZnjZ]fud^ ffcbkihevah\Zgb_ff_lh^ZgZbf_gvrbo
d\Z^jZlh\iha\hebeZihemqblvg_ebg_cgmxaZ\bkbfhklvke_^mxs_]h\b^Z
G v = 0,5+1,566d^ – 0,017d^2.
(2)
WlZnhjfmeZfh`_l[ulvbkihevah\ZgZ^eyjZkq_lZijhba\h^bl_evghklb
k_iZjZlhjZkD ffihba\_klghfm\u[jZgghfm^bZf_ljm^bZnjZ]fud^.
;hevrh_\gbfZgb_bkke_^h\Zl_ebijb^Zxlbamq_gbxjZkij_^_e_gby^Z\
e_gbyihjZ^bmkmpbdehggh]hZiiZjZlZ
Ihemq_gu wdki_jbf_glZevgu_ aZ\bkbfhklb baf_g_gby ^Z\e_gby ih jZ
^bmkm\oh^ghcdZf_juk_iZjZlhjZ^bZf_ljhfD ff^ey^\mo^bZnjZ]fk
jZaebqguf^bZf_ljhfhl\_jklbcd^jZ\gufbffBkke_^h\Zgbyijh\_
^_guijbq_luj_o^Z\e_gbyoiblZgbyj i bIZ
Ba jbk \b^gh qlh oZjZdl_j baf_g_gby ^Z\e_gby ih jZ^bmkm dZf_ju
h^bgZdh\^eyjZaebqguod^bj i bbf__lljbhlebqZxsb_ky^jm]hl^jm]ZmqZkl
dZGZi_j\hfmqZkld_\bgl_j\Ze_jZ^bmkh\hl^hffgZ[ex^Z_lkyj_a
dh_iZ^_gb_^Z\e_gbyH[tykgblvwlhfh`gh\uoh^hfkljmbba\oh^gh]hiZl
jm[dZ\[hevrhch[t_f\oh^ghcdZf_ju

jIZ
4
3
2
1
Rff
JbkJZkij_^_e_gb_^Z\e_gbyihjZ^bmkm\boj_\hcdZf_ju
k_iZjZlhjZD=ffijbd^ ffb^Z\e_gbbiblZgby
1 –IZ–IZ–IZ–IZ
:\lhjhfl_hj_lbq_kdbbamq_ghjZkij_^_e_gb_^Z\e_gbyihjZ^bmkmdZf_
ju\ahg_`b^dhcnZauijbwlhfihemq_gZke_^mxsZyaZ\bkbfhklv
2
ρ ⎛ R
j =
`
\o
ji
+
2
υ\o⎜
1−
2
2 ⎝ R
]^_j i !`bυ \o –khhl\_lkl\_ggh^Z\e_gb_iehlghklvbkdhjhklv`b^dhklbgZ
\oh^_\k_iZjZlhj
BamjZ\g_gby\b^ghqlhijbR = R \o klZlbq_kdh_^Z\e_gb_jZ\ghJ \o .
Ijbmf_gvr_gbbRhlR \o ^hR`-] ]jZgbpu`b^dhklbk]Zah\hcnZahc]Zah\uf
rgmjhf klZlbq_kdh_ ^Z\e_gb_ mf_gvrZ_lky qlh b ih^l\_j`^Z_lky wdki_jb
f_glZevgufb ^Zggufb Ijbijb[eb`_gbbqZklbp`b^dhklbdhl\_jklbx^bZ
njZ]fu wlZ aZ\bkbfhklv gZjmrZ_lky lZd dZd ^\b`_gb_ `b^dhklb ih kdjmqb
\Zxs_ckykibjZebaZf_gy_lkygZ^\b`_gb_`b^dhklb\hk_\hfgZijZ\e_gbbk
\jZs_gb_f qZklbp gZ R=const gZ kj_a_ ^bZnjZ]fuijb i_j_oh^_ qZklbp ba
\oh^ghcdZf_ju\\uoh^gmx
⎞
⎟,
⎠
(3)

Ihemq_ghlZd`_mjZ\g_gb_jZkij_^_e_gbyklZlbq_kdh]h^Z\e_gbyihjZ
^bmkmdZf_ju\]Zah\hcnZa_
1
K
2
⎛ 1
⎜
k2
⎝ j
\uo
2
1 ⎞
2 R`-]
R\uo
− K
` ]
ln ,
k2
1 −
j
⎟ = υ (4)
⎠ R R
]^_j \uo –^Z\e_gb_gZ\uoh^_]Zah\hcnZaubap_gljZevgh]hdZgZeZhl[hjZkjZ
^bmkhfR \uo .
Ihklhyggu_K 1 bK 2 gZoh^ylkyba\ujZ`_gbc
K 1 < -1/k K 2 =(1/k)-1,
]^_\_ebqbgZ< constbmklZgZ\eb\Z_laZ\bkbfhklvf_`^miehlghklvxb^Z\
e_gb_f\]Zah\hf\boj_hljZ^bmkZ\jZs_gbyqZklbpu\ij_^_eZohl R`-] ^hgm
eygZhkb\jZs_gbyk –ihdZaZl_evZ^bZ[Zlu
?keb `b^dhklv g_ kh^_j`bl jZkl\hj_ggh]h ]ZaZ lh mjZ\g_gb_kijZ
\_^eb\h^eyhibkZgbyijhp_kkZi_j_f_s_gbyqZklbpu`b^dhklbkjZ^bmkZdhj
imkZ\boj_\hcdZf_ju^hjZ^bmkZ]Zah\h]h\bojyR B .
?keb`_`b^dhklvkh^_j`bljZkl\hj_gguc]ZaiZjZ^Z\e_gb_gZkus_
gbyj gZk `b^dhklb]ZahfiZjhfgZl_dms_fjZ^bmk_jZ[hq_]hh[t_fZ\boj_\hc
dZf_ju f_gvr_ ^Z\e_gby gZ \oh^_ \ dZf_jm lh ijb __ \jZs_gbb ih kdjmqb
\Zxs_ckykibjZebgZklmiblfhf_gldh]^Zl_dms__^Z\e_gb_jkgbablky^hj gZk
qlhkhhl\_lkl\m_l^hklb`_gbxqZklbp_c`b^dhklbiheh`_gbygZjZ^bmk_\ha
gbdgh\_gby imaujvdh\ ]ZaZ R I >Zevg_cr__ ijb[eb`_gb_ `b^dhklb d hkb
\jZs_gby[m^_lkhijh\h`^Zlvky\u^_e_gb_fba`b^dhklbimaujvdh\]ZaZDh
ebq_kl\himaujvdh\bbojZaf_j[m^_lm\_ebqb\Zlvkyijbi_j_f_s_gbbdhkb
\jZs_gbyGZ]jZgbp_jZa^_eZ`b^dhklv-]Zah\uciZjh\hcrgmjh[jZam_lky
dbiysbckehcg_[hevrhclhesbguWlhp_gljh[_`gu_kbeug_^ZxldZi_ev
dZf`b^dhklbagZqbl_evghm^Zeblvkyhl]jZgbpujZa^_eZIehlghklv`b^dhklb
\ wlhc ahg_ [m^_l mf_gvrZlvky ba-aZ \u^_e_gby ]Zah\ ijb i_j_f_s_gbb kjZ
^bmkZR I ^hR B l_iehlghklv`b^dhklb\\ujZ`_gbbklZg_li_j_f_gghc\_
ebqbghc
GZmqZkld_jZ^bmkh\kR C ^hR B jZ^bZevgZykhklZ\eyxsZykdhjhklb`b^
dh]hihlhdZgZqg_lmf_gvrZlvkygZjZ^bmk_R B hgZklZg_ljZ\ghcgmexhk_

\ZykhklZ\eyxsZyihlhdZw`m\_ebqb\Z_lkyhlgZjZ^bmk_R C ^hfZdkbfmfZ
gZjZ^bmk_R B ).
Ih^^_ckl\b_f]jZ^b_glZ^Z\e_gbybl_fi_jZlmju`b^dhklvkh^_j`ZsZy
dhfihg_glukjZaebqghcl_fi_jZlmjhcdbi_gbygZqbgZ_lbkiZjylvkyklmi_g
qZlh\u^_eyy\ijbhk_\mxahgm]Zah\mxnZamnjZdpbbkjZagufbl_fi_jZlm
jZfbgZqZeZdbi_gby

G v ,
efbg
1
G* v , Y
efbg
f qZk
2
j i , IZ
G >
ff
JbkAZ\bkbfhklvjZkoh^Z`b^dhklb Jbkey hij_^_e_gby wnn_dlb\ghklb jZajZ[hlZggh]h \boj_\h]h k_iZjZlhjZ
ijh\_^_gu ijhfure_ggu_ bkiulZgby \ p_oZo H:HDZmqmd b gZ DGK–12
G=>M:jeZgg_nlv >ey dhgljhey iZjZf_ljh\ jZ[hlu \boj_\hc k_iZjZpbhg
ghcmklZgh\dbgZjZaebqguoj_`bfZo[ueZjZajZ[hlZgZko_fZh[\yadb\boj_\h
]hk_iZjZlhjZdhlhjZybkihevah\ZeZkvgZf_kl_ijh\_^_gbybkiulZgbc
Ihj_amevlZlZfwdki_jbf_glZevguobkke_^h\Zgbcihkljh_gZaZ\bkbfhklv
\ebygby^bZf_ljZ^bZnjZ]fugZjZkoh^klhqghc\h^ujbk

iZjZlhjkfhglbjh\ZggZ\oh^ghcebgbbklhqghc\h^u\DGKkp_evx^hhqbkl
dbhlg_nlbklhqghc\h^ui_j_^aZdZqdhcihke_^g_c\ieZkl
8
12
10
9
11
3
2
5
6
1
7
4
Jbk

Dhfihg_gl
kf_kb
:p_lhg
:p_lhgbljbe

Ghf_j
hiulZ
LZ[ebpZ
J_amevlZluwdki_jbf_glh\gZDGK–G=>M:jeZgg_nlv
>bZf_lj
^bZnjZ]
fuff
>Z\e_
gb_
IZ
J_amevlZluZgZebah\
f]e
f 3 q \oh^ \uoh^ p_glj
Ijhba\h^b
l_evghklv
Kl_i_gv
hqbkldb
%
1 0,08 11,1 342 91 140 73
2 0,1 12 381 144 965 62
3 50 0,12 13,5 353 108 580 69
4 0,15 15 458 221 1408 52
5
0,2 16,8 362 125 416 65
6 0,08 11,1 318 89 164 72
7 60 0,1 12 406 172 212 58
8
0,15 15 347 105 203 70
J_adhm\_ebqb\Z_lkykh^_j`Zgb_Zp_lhgZ\ijh[Zohlh[jZgguobap_g
ljZevgh]h hk_\h]h dZgZeZ Lh _klv kZfuc e_]dbc gbadhdbiysbc dhfihg_gl
kf_kbdhgp_gljbjm_lkygZhkb\jZs_gby]Zah\h]hiZjh\h]hrgmjZJZg__[ueZ
l_hj_lbq_kdb h[hkgh\ZgZ \hafh`ghklv jZkij_^_e_gby ]Zah\ jZaghc iehlghklb
ihjZ^bmkmdZf_ju
Ih j_amevlZlZf bkke_^h\Zgbc gZ DGK – G=>M:jeZgg_nlv fh`gh
k^_eZlvke_^mxsb_\u\h^ubj_dhf_g^Zpbb

Bamq_gu aZ\bkbfhklv ijhba\h^bl_evghklbk_iZjZlhjZhl\oh^guoiZ
jZf_ljh\ihlhdZ^bZf_ljZ^bZnjZ]fubhkh[_gghklbjZkij_^_e_gby^Z\e_gby
ihjZ^bmkm\oh^ghcdZf_juIh\ur_gb_l_fi_jZlmju`b^dhklbgZ\oh^_\k_
iZjZlhjgZ°Kijb\h^bldkgb`_gbxijhba\h^bl_evghklbk_iZjZlhjZgZ\
^bZiZahg_l_fi_jZlmj«°K
Ij_^eh`_gZ l_hj_lbq_kdZy aZ\bkbfhklv jZkij_^_e_gby klZlbq_kdh]h
^Z\e_gby ih jZ^bmkm \oh^ghc dZf_ju k mq_lhf kdZqdZbaf_g_gby iehlghklb
kj_^ugZ]jZgbp_`b^dhcb]Zah\hcnZadhlhjZydZq_kl\_gghih^l\_j`^Z_lky
j_amevlZlZfbeZ[hjZlhjguobkke_^h\Zgbc
hklb]gmlh -gh_ kh^_j`Zgb_ ijbf_k_c \
ijh[_kh^_j`Zgb_\h^u–ke_^uhlh[jZgghcbap_gljZevgh]hdZgZeZnjZd
pbhgbjmxs_c]heh\dbZiiZjZlZ
BkiulZgbyjZajZ[hlZggh]hk_iZjZlhjZijh\_^_ggu_gZH:HDZmqmd",
ihdZaZebqlh^ey^bZnjZ]fu^bZf_ljhfd^ ffijbijhba\h^bl_evghklb
f 3 qkh^_j`Zgb_m]e_\h^hjh^h\\klhqghc\h^_mf_gvrbehkvgZIjb
bkiulZgbyoijh\_^_gguogZDGK–G=>M:jeZgg_nlvih^hhqbkld_klhq
guo \h^ i_j_^ aZdZqdhc bo \ ijh^mdlb\gu_ ieZklu ^hklb]gmlh kgb`_gb_ kh
^_j`Zgbyg_nlb\klhqghc\h^_gZ
KIBKHDIM;EBD:PBCIHL??>BKK?JL:PBB
DZjZ\Zgh\ZB:EmqbgbgB

fheh^_`b;Zrdbjbb\j_r_gb_dhfie_dkguoijh[e_fg_nlbb]ZaZL_a^hde
44-cgZmq-l_ogdhgnklm^_glh\ZkibjZglh\bfheh^uomq_guo;Zrdbjbb–
MnZMGB-K
BkfZ]beh\

mq-l_og dhgn klm^_glh\ ZkibjZglh\ b fheh^uo mq_guo-MnZM=GLM-
K
EmqbgbgB