الشر ووجود الله للدكتور سامي غامري

)1v ,v
q
v&$v
Stephen(
"v+z Y.vX.v#
O.>v h
Michael(
:jO9J_DG
@ )1( s .G
s
- E
vdF9lcDG
E
%+JE>h O.>h ,%+O.E
d_9GT_G
dp
b_aFG
IO9l_G
2v 7,v G v LSv 2+v IO.#v /G bv VGL9v /vh$G 2kv G v Pv J/.?v 1v )1v G v
Rv
@%v,v1vlv )v#h P vv C f q G a.vPv!v1vlv G 2v&.v\v0Lv2v G JvEv!v$v )vlv1v9vO( )h/
.vHv#h
2vk
2v 7,v &v) Q.uv Sv
)William Lane Craig(
Ov 9v VGLcv gK+v G v .1v
lv 1v !v a.Pv $G 0vL#v 2uv ( 0v.#v "uv )2v.8v
vG
L q .vD k C f q Gz vEv 7v? q G MvtLv$v 7v0 q *v O.vEv 2v+
vVv#
" q G v $v .(v JGL^v G v $v Sv IQ.,v 1v )1v G v Ov 2kv
>v
7lv
vvP
)1v Ev
0lv
h
)#v
.(v kv $v
Fazale(
,2$v
vG e.!v
.1v v f#Sv G v cv !v J/O.?v
Rv L,v 0kv Ov 7lv vG cv C
G v $v )#v
-v8Lv^.v(v# v e.v1v!v0h( )v1v )gv0Lvt
2vk v
s
y?-v )e2011( G tv 9v v/lv 8v 0vLrv 2 k v.v
E J>v
k .v Y
)e2010(
)Law
h .+v .#v kv cv -!v 0vC ,sv.Hv
-v8Lv^.v(v# gv0Lvuv 2vk
.0v
vG
)Tooley
? q 7v G v @ )2( yLSv h .+v .#v 8v uv QL q 2kv
Dv
v ,HLfv "1v h Dv /9v .#v f.tv 8vL#v 2v \ k .v
G
v)Michael Ruse(
.(v -8vL^v v GJ!v bv 71v G v (v 2&vGLVv ( /GMkv ).&vQ
#v
:fG.(v Cz "Uv vG Ev 1v :I. vG 9v \v Q. q eC vG 9v Vv $v y?%1v
bv
Sv uv 7!v #v
.1v Gv )L(v LQ.>v
2kv
:Ev
( 0v.#v "uv )ShQ F0vLVv
7Ov )bv G 0vhQGJv (v v71v GLSv
8v
1v
,)Rana
29v :&v.tv 8v vGh
C & q -v / ZkvL0v 0v)G f.$v .1v O.>v uG E / q v Pv 32v Gh ,JDv h .+v
v)e2013(
(
JEv
&vE .,v G v Sv 2v 7,v vG 29v h Uv lv .,v vG .Sv Lbv $G v 2&v.$v vG $v !v
@LSv
.,& q ILHUz
@ )3( yO.E )G #1
:dpT_p_G
vG
)Georg BuÈ chner(
^GQAf:G
HGaFf
cv L2v #v Sv uv 7!v G v Sv L q G v Ev ? q 7v $G ;v IL1v 2kv G v uv .9v J.1v G Jv .bv Fvv 71v G v lv !v Pv lv 71v v uv Q.2v
8v 9v
lv Ov 7 lv vG 0 $v IJ Dv ) #v ev L 1v 8v 1 q q
v Q. v)Gz Ev O. vG ,yJ 0vJ ?v h ) #v OC v 7 v vP C f q
0 vG
y2lv vPv!kv
L2v L0v 8v
q
-vlv )Gz :O.vEv &#v
2vk
)Michael Martin(
v1vlv a.vP!v ( .#v 0v "uv ))v8Q.v# G
Antony Flew, There is a God: How the world's most notorious atheist changed his mind (New York:
HarperOne, 2007), p.13.
Chad Meister and James K. Dew, eds. God and Evil: The Case for God in a World Filled with Pain
(Downers Grove, Illinois: IVP Books, 2013), p.298.
Randy Alcorn, If God Is Good: Faith in the Midst of Su€ering and Evil (Colorado Springs, Colo.:
Multnomah Books, 2009), p.11.
18
)1(
)2(
)3(