Ebook AKOTrace
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
INDEX<br />
INTRODUCTION: Optimization is the key ............................................................. 3<br />
A small but key investment for any CSP plant ..................................................... 4<br />
Avoiding Poorly Performing CSP plants ................................................................ 5<br />
CSP plants: When temperature regulation fails ................................................... 6<br />
CSP Plants: Poor planning, poor performance ..................................................... 7<br />
4+1 key factors to consider in an electrical heat tracing system ......................... 8<br />
The structure of an optimal heat tracing solution (I) ........................................... 9<br />
The structure of an optimal heat tracing solution (II) ........................................ 10<br />
Optimal installation of the Electrical Heat Tracing System (I) ........................... 12<br />
Optimal installation of the Electrical Heat Tracing System (II) .......................... 14<br />
AKOTRACE® Solution for HTF areas .................................................................... 15<br />
AKOTRACE® Solution for Molten Salt areas ....................................................... 16<br />
PROTrace®: Control and power cabinets for electrical trace circuits (I) ............ 17<br />
PROTrace®: Control and power cabinets for electrical trace circuits (II) ........... 18<br />
PROTrace®: Control and power cabinets for electrical trace circuits (III) .......... 19<br />
PROTrace®: Control and power cabinets for electrical trace circuits (IV) ......... 20<br />
DUOControl Trace: The brain inside AKO´s ProTrace® cabinets (I) ................... 21<br />
DUOControl Trace: The brain inside ProTrace® cabinets (II) ............................. 22<br />
AKONet Trace, AKO´s control software for EHT systems ................................... 23<br />
DUOVision Touch Trace: Designed for small EHT systems ................................ 24<br />
AKO´s MI heating cable ...................................................................................... 25<br />
Temperature Sensors I ....................................................................................... 26<br />
Temperature Sensors II ...................................................................................... 27<br />
AKONet Trace: Alarm Management (I) .............................................................. 28<br />
AKONet Trace: Alarm Management (II) ............................................................. 29<br />
2
Optimization is the key<br />
Optimizing the performance of a concentration solar power (CSP) plant is<br />
essential.<br />
Weather a plant uses parabolic cylinder<br />
technology or a concentrating solar<br />
power tower, managing the process of<br />
transforming sun energy into electricity is<br />
a tricky task. That´s when an optimum<br />
electrical heat-tracing system comes<br />
into place, especially in thermal storage<br />
plants. We know that there are other<br />
components that play an important role<br />
in any plant, but this particular one is<br />
crucial because its malfunction can lead to major problems with costly solutions.<br />
The transformation of energy is possible thanks to the thermal transfer between<br />
heat carrier fluids such as steam, thermal oils or molten salts.<br />
At the end, is the thermal oil, in the case of parabolic cylinder´s plants, and<br />
molten salts, in solar power tower plants, that by ex-changing heat generate<br />
the necessary steam to drive the turbine that makes electricity.<br />
The main function of an electrical heat tracing system is to maintain the right<br />
temperature throughout the process, avoiding solidification of the fluids,<br />
whether they are oils or salts.<br />
If this crucial component fails, the plant could incur into unexpected expenses<br />
or, even worst, it can result in having the plant out of commission for a period of<br />
time.<br />
Even with optimum planning, there are always some unforeseen problems that<br />
can arise during installation, execution and maintenance of any heat tracing<br />
system, and each one of them could have a different impact on the plant.<br />
In following posts we´ll try to analyze some of the most common risks assessed<br />
in economic terms.<br />
3
A small but key investment for any CSP<br />
plant<br />
An electrical heat tracing system represents<br />
just 0,5% of the total investment in a CSP<br />
project, but its failure could lead to major<br />
losses that could affect the overall<br />
profitability ratio of the plant. Therefore,<br />
optimizing the performance of the electrical<br />
heat tracing system is critical to be considered<br />
as market leaders. There are, though,<br />
some factors that could compromise this<br />
goal. How?<br />
Let´s first make a short list of economic indicators that can determine in any<br />
way the outcome of the expected net production of a solar plant:<br />
� Capital expenditure (CAPEX).<br />
� Days of production.<br />
� Production efficiency (a combination between performance and operational<br />
/production costs).<br />
And now let´s make a second list, this time of what happens when the electrical<br />
heat tracing system is not managed properly or fails unexpectedly:<br />
� It raises the plant´s expenses.<br />
� It can reduce the performance of the main electrical production systems.<br />
� The amount of self consumed electricity of the plant could raise unexpectedly.<br />
� If the breakdown causes a plant stoppage, it would inevitable translate<br />
into less production days and major reparation costs.<br />
All these factors are directly related to the first list: They all alter the initial plan<br />
in terms of money and time, and all of the sudden, this 0,5% becomes more<br />
crucial.<br />
We have been talking economics, but in our next post we´ll take a look at the<br />
technical challenges that a plant can face when the electrical heat tracing<br />
system does not perform as expected.<br />
4
Avoiding Poorly Performing CSP plants<br />
The scenarios that could lead a CSP plant to perform poorly are diverse.<br />
All the components of the plant can be in<br />
trouble at some point. There are mistakes<br />
of a more technical nature, but failures<br />
could also emerge from planning to execution;<br />
from maintenance to supervision.<br />
Undoubtedly, the electrical heat tracing<br />
system plays a key role in the overall performance<br />
of the plant. It goes across the<br />
power block (the Thermal Energy Storage, The Heat TransferFluid and the<br />
Balance of Plant systems) therefore, from a technical stand of point we are<br />
talking about a wide range of possible breakdowns.<br />
Let´s enumerate some of them: (1) Unplanned stoppage when heat carrier<br />
fluids get frozen; (2) Loss of performance due to poor temperature regulation of<br />
the processes (HTF, TES, and BOP); (3) Unsuitable requirements (when the plant<br />
is already operational).<br />
There is a saying that goes…”Your lack of planning is not my emergency¨. Well,<br />
unfortunately in CSP plants, lack of planning is everybody´s emergency. It<br />
represents another costly mistake that could prevent a CSP plant to perform<br />
optimally. Some other failures of that nature:<br />
� Unexpected investments and/or interventions when the plant is fully<br />
operational.<br />
� Being behind schedule without enough time to react (taking into account<br />
that the tracing system is one of the last components to be installed).<br />
� Lack of background knowledge to ensure the performance of the plant.<br />
� More investment costs (when the engineering part of the process hasn´t<br />
been planned properly).<br />
Some of these failures could be managed, unexpected problems show up in any<br />
project, but some of them could be avoided. What we´ll try to analyze in<br />
following posts is why CSP plants and their electrical heat tracing systems face<br />
these issues in the first place, and then come up with efficient solutions and<br />
alternatives.<br />
5
CSP plants:<br />
When temperature regulation fails<br />
We continue analyzing ways of avoiding<br />
poor performance in CSP plants and their<br />
electrical heat tracing systems, focusing<br />
today on breakdowns caused when<br />
temperature is not regulated properly.<br />
One of the worst fears for anyone involved<br />
in a CSP project is having the plant out of<br />
commission, even for a short period of<br />
time. But unwanted plant stoppages do<br />
happen and bad temperature regulation can be one of the causes leading to this<br />
undesirable outcome. Let´s take a look at what happens when either water or<br />
heat transfer fluids freeze. This scenario could present itself when:<br />
� The engineering team lacks thermodynamic expertise, that is, do not have<br />
enough experience in Thermal Cycles inside CSP plants, undersizing the<br />
whole project thus causing system failing.<br />
� When the system control solution is weak preventing the staff from receiving<br />
valuable, real time information to help them detect and manage on a<br />
timely manner a wide range of possible system´s breakdowns<br />
� Faulty installation due to lacking of know-how to notice details that are<br />
key to the system and a deficient quality control supervision<br />
Such shortcomings could cause the plant to be out of commission for one day<br />
which translates into $267,000 in losses. There is more: The additional costs of<br />
repairing the tracing system and/or damaged equipment could add up to $8.2<br />
million.<br />
Another issue that could arise regarding temperature supervision is when the<br />
established system for process temperature regulation (HTC, TES, BOP) is not<br />
efficient, resulting in a significant loss of performance. This happens, among<br />
other factors already mentioned in the list above, when the implemented<br />
regulation solution is weak. This particular mistake could cause a 5% increase in<br />
energy self consumption of the electrical heat tracing (for each degree increase<br />
in temperature in the system´s performance).<br />
On our next post, we will analyze what happens when the team in charge of a<br />
CSP plant does a poor job planning the project.<br />
*Data referring to CSP plants using parabolic cylinder technology with a molten salt storage for<br />
up to 7, 5 hours.<br />
6
CSP Plants:<br />
Poor planning, poor performance<br />
It´s only logical: if you don´t plan correctly, you<br />
don´t get the expected results. Breakdowns of a<br />
technical nature are, sometimes, unavoidable. Bad<br />
planning is a human error, and such kind of<br />
mistakes seem easier to solve, don´t they? Yes,<br />
but let´s be honest, in a CSP project with budget<br />
and time concerns and limitations some of the<br />
simplest principles that we all know “in theory”<br />
are rapidly overlooked. All of the sudden solving<br />
this issue gets complicated.<br />
A management team with no experience or that<br />
doesn´t handle properly a CSP project contributes<br />
to:<br />
� Applying an ineffective supervision and quality control solution for the<br />
plant<br />
� A poor execution of an already poor plan<br />
If these problems originated because of time related pressures we have some<br />
bad news: It turns out that to solve them would take even more precious time.<br />
We are talking about delays in the starting of the plant, and since the electrical<br />
tracing system is one of the latest components of the plant to be installed, the<br />
team finds itself in a position with not enough leeway to react.<br />
As in any other business, loss of time means loss of money. In this case we are<br />
talking about:<br />
� The plant could be out of commission for one day which translates into<br />
$267,000 in losses.<br />
� A 20% capital budget deviation, that is $410,000<br />
As we stated at the beginning, poor planning is probably one of the most<br />
complicated issues to handle when analyzing critical risks in an inadequate<br />
electrical heat tracing solution, but it is not impossible to solve. If you want to<br />
learn about how to deal directly with these and other challenges related to the<br />
development of a CSP project, we invite you to get familiar with our Akotrace®<br />
solution.<br />
7
4+1 key factors to consider in an<br />
electrical heat tracing system<br />
In this blog we have already stated how critical<br />
an electrical heat tracing system is in the<br />
temperature control process of any CSP plant.<br />
We would like to go deeper into the issue and<br />
share with you the 4+1 key factors we think<br />
should be taken into account when choosing or<br />
designing a heat tracing solution.<br />
Energy Efficiency<br />
This is particularly relevant since the less energy the plant self-consumes, the<br />
more energy it has to sell, in other words: Managing energy efficiency<br />
improves plant´s productivity.<br />
Connectivity: Control and Monitoring<br />
To be able to detect a problem in a timely manner gives the plant´s staff the<br />
opportunity to react and fix any malfunction in the shortest period of time. On<br />
the other hand, it is nice to know that everything is working fine, have<br />
periodical reports to confirm it, and use this information to make further<br />
improvements.<br />
Usability<br />
The staff should be properly trained and the software intuitive enough to<br />
provide a fast response whenever a crisis arises, as well as to manage the day to<br />
day tasks without a glitch.<br />
Safety and Reliability<br />
Yes, the tracing system is no more than 0,5% of the total investment of any<br />
plant, but if it does not work properly the loss of productivity, and of money,<br />
can be substantial. A safe and reliable solution makes everybody involved in the<br />
plant sleep better at night.<br />
An optional one: Flexibility<br />
This one is up to you, it depends more of your business model. In AKO we<br />
believe that the success of our AKOTRACE® solution relies, in addition to the<br />
above mentioned, on its flexibility to adapt to any project, and to any plant.<br />
Whether it uses parabolic cylinder technology or concentrating solar tower,<br />
AKOTRACE® is designed to be flexible enough to suit every client´s needs. The<br />
projects may be different, but the outcome is always satisfactory.<br />
8
The structure of an optimal heat tracing<br />
solution (I)<br />
After considering all factors involved in the decision making process when<br />
choosing an electrical heat tracing solution, it is time to describe how the<br />
system works. In our case, we want to share with you the structure of our DCS<br />
AKOTRACE® solution, a framework that holds three levels of performance<br />
areas designed to fulfill the needs of any CSP plant.<br />
Field and installation<br />
From the base up, Level 3 is made up of all the heat cables and heaters, probes,<br />
accessories, lagging, and, in general, of any element necessary for the installlation<br />
of the tracing system.<br />
Control and Power<br />
Level 2 distributes the necessary power to the tracing system, regulating and<br />
controlling its delivery according to the information received (thermal probes<br />
and electrical supply; safety indicators, etc)<br />
Supervision and Connectivity<br />
Finally, Level 1 monitors and supervises the tracing system connecting it to both<br />
the plant´s DCS system and to possible telemanagement points.<br />
All three levels of our AKOTRACE® structure are supported by a layer of services<br />
that include maintenance (reactive, proactive and preventive), engineering,<br />
project management, installation and implementation.<br />
In our next post we´ll do a more detailed analysis of the role each one of the<br />
levels play in the structure of our AKOTRACE® electrical heat tracing system.<br />
9
The structure of an optimal heat tracing<br />
solution (II)<br />
The goal of any electrical heat tracing system is to maintain the temperature,<br />
avoiding the freezing of either water or heat transfer fluids.<br />
How AKO does it? Let us explain in detail the three-level structure of our<br />
AKOTRACE® electrical heat tracing system.<br />
Field and Installation (level 3)<br />
It´s made up of all the elements in the<br />
system´s control and is where the electrical<br />
heat tracing circuit is placed. It<br />
includes all the necessary field components,<br />
and depending on the process<br />
needs each control can have:<br />
� Either standardized or custom made heating elements, depending on the<br />
tracing needs, including MI Cable, Self Regulating Cable, heaters and all<br />
accessories required for a full installation<br />
� Up until 4 thermal probes with different redundancy options, this guarantees<br />
data reliability.<br />
� Current probes that constantly monitor the system´s control energy selfconsumption,<br />
warning of any drop below certain values, allowing us to<br />
identify possible failures in those cases when several tracing sections are<br />
integrated into the same system´s control<br />
Control and Power (level 2)<br />
In this level our PROTrace® cabinets<br />
are in charge of monitoring<br />
and distributing the power from<br />
the connection point to system´s<br />
control. They can have different<br />
mechanism of redundancy to avoid<br />
malfunction in case of failure or<br />
during maintenance. They are fully<br />
adaptable. Based on the application,<br />
our PROTrace® cabinets can<br />
be concentrated in different locations or distributed throughout the field. Their<br />
final placement depends on the technical and economical needs of the project.<br />
10
Our system´s control is based on our DUOControl Trace, founded on a PLC<br />
Platform, and integrated into PROTrace® cabinets. It receives data from the<br />
thermal probes and power supply, protection conditions, configuration<br />
variables, etc, and it acts accordingly, regulating the output power to reach and<br />
maintain the desirable temperature, thanks to our advanced control algorithms.<br />
Inside our PROTrace® cabinets there is the possibility to include the kind of<br />
control, via contactor or SSR; the air conditioning or distribution elements and<br />
the automatic transfer switch.<br />
It also accommodates safety and protection elements such as magneto-thermal<br />
circuit breaker, differential circuit breakers protection and a contactor´s security<br />
system in each control, adding an extra safety component in case of switcher´s<br />
failure.<br />
Supervision and Connectivity (level 1)<br />
Our ProTrace® cabinets are stick to<br />
each other with optical fiber connectors.<br />
Their ring configuration allows<br />
for non-stop communication in case<br />
of malfunction in one of the links.<br />
In this ring configuration we have<br />
our DUOWarm Trace, supervising<br />
key variables such as power distribution<br />
and the environment conditions in the cabinet. It also functions as a gateway<br />
with the plant´s DCS system and with the firewall that allows the internet<br />
connection to manage the installation remotely. It has a redundancy system to<br />
avoid communication breakdowns and to facilitate maintenance work.<br />
The local operator panel, made up of a PC Panel with our control software<br />
AKONet Trace, only needs an Ethernet link to the network control DUOControl<br />
Trace, allowing for the total control and supervision of the tracing installation.<br />
We have just share with you the electrical heat tracing system that makes us<br />
worldwide leaders in the sector. We have installed this architecture solution in<br />
more than 25 plants, but we are constantly looking to innovate and find new<br />
ways to optimize our system and at the same time, the productivity of any CSP<br />
plant.<br />
11
Optimal installation of the Electrical<br />
Heat Tracing System (I)<br />
We start a series of posts talking about<br />
the electrical heat tracing elements<br />
installed in the field since the way the<br />
tracing system is installed in any given<br />
surface affects the uniformity of the<br />
reached temperature.<br />
AKO´s experience in this matter, installing<br />
our AKOTRACE® solution, the<br />
most trusted and used electrical heat<br />
tracing system worldwide, gives us a unique vision on how to handle this<br />
critical element in any CSP plant. First of all, before starting any installation it is<br />
important to double check all materials and plan in advance their distribution<br />
following design requirements.<br />
Heating cable<br />
The kind of heating cable to be installed should, besides bringing in the<br />
necessary power to compensate thermal loss, endure the maximum process<br />
temperature of the plant.<br />
It has to be distributed uniformly, reinforcing its presence in areas with higher<br />
probabilities of thermal loss.<br />
If the cable applies more power than it should, the temperature readings will be<br />
higher, on the other hand, if it applies less power it can create cold spots,<br />
causing problems to the plant´s overall.<br />
Special care should be taken when installing the heating cable in critical points<br />
like pipe junctions, to avoid circuit interference operation.<br />
There are some specific criteria to be taken into account when installing<br />
redundant heaters, like the distance between themselves or between the cables<br />
and the probes, but in any case, both should behave the same way.<br />
The heating cables with mineral insulation should be handled with extra caution<br />
due to its stiffness, making its handling more difficult.<br />
Another important characteristic of the heating cable is that changes<br />
temperatures, expanding and contracting constantly, thus obliging the<br />
installation of an anchoring system capable of enduring such fluctuations.<br />
Finally, the tracing system should not represent an obstacle when replacing,<br />
when necessary, elements like valves, probes, etc.<br />
12
Temperature probes<br />
The heating elements and the thermal bridges influence the temperature<br />
readings measured by the probes.<br />
A probe that is too close to the heating element causes a lower temperature<br />
reading. On the other hand, if the probe is installed close to a thermal bridge,<br />
the temperature reading will be above the required one.<br />
If the installation requires probe redundancy, they should be installed depending<br />
on the configuration defined by control.<br />
In following posts we´ll talk about wiring junction boxes, brackets and how to<br />
audit the installation to ensure optimum plant´s performance.<br />
13
Optimal installation of the Electrical<br />
Heat Tracing System (II)<br />
We continue with the series of post we<br />
started a few days ago about the electrical<br />
heat tracing elements installed in the field.<br />
This time we are going to focus on wiring<br />
junction boxes, brackets and how to audit<br />
the installation to ensure optimum plant´s<br />
performance.<br />
Junction boxes and brackets<br />
The junction boxes, used to connect the heating cables or the temperature<br />
probes, must be installed in a way that facilitates its access, but, at the same<br />
time, they should be protected from rain and must avoid excessive mechanical<br />
exposure. Extra protection should be added when the boxes are installed in an<br />
area classified as explosive atmosphere.<br />
About the brackets used for the boxes set up, (and installed over the surface<br />
where it is necessary to control the temperature) we should take into account<br />
that they could cause additional thermal loss, meaning that this point could get<br />
cooler. Depending on the situation it would be convenient the use of an<br />
additional heating cable extension to compensate for possible thermal losses.<br />
Compliance checks and installation logs<br />
Installation inspection is carried out in two phases: The first one takes place<br />
after the installation of the heat tracing system and before lagging.<br />
At this time we have to make sure that all the materials used are undamaged<br />
and that the installation complies with the established requirements.<br />
We should take into consideration that any intervention in the electrical heat<br />
tracing system after lagging requires its removal, that´s why all the necessary<br />
checks have to be made before. This is a critical reminder since any mistake<br />
detected can be easily corrected at this point, but after lagging, the costs of any<br />
repair just skyrockets.<br />
Among the most important checks we should pay special attention to the<br />
installation of the heater and its probes, making sure that all elements are fixed<br />
correctly, properly labeled, and, most especially, they should comply with the<br />
project requirements.<br />
That´s what AKO has learnt over years of research and multiple installations,<br />
the kind of experience that have made our AKOTRACE® solution the most<br />
trusted and used electrical heat tracing system worldwide.<br />
14
AKOTRACE ® Solution for HTF areas<br />
We continue in this post dissecting our AKOTRACE® Electrical Heat Tracing<br />
system, focusing now in our solution for HTF areas.<br />
First of all, let´s establish three critical issues that our solution takes care of:<br />
� Maintenance of temperature between 50 and 60 ºC<br />
� Focus on temperature maintenance, no heating<br />
� Reduction of heat loss<br />
Since in the HTF area we just have to<br />
maintain the temperature, between 50-60<br />
ºC, we only need so much power (compared<br />
to the Molten Salts area) meaning<br />
that the tracing system´s energy consumption<br />
is also low. This reduces thermal loss<br />
in areas with higher levels of exposure,<br />
that´s the case of valve bonnets, that doesn´t need any extra tracing.<br />
Oscillation levels of temperature in these zones make the ON/OFF regulation<br />
the most suitable solution, with a lower number of commutations (start/stop)<br />
from the system, allowing the use of contactors to control it, hence reducing<br />
unnecessary costs in components. This kind of regulation is available in our<br />
DUOControl Trace.<br />
Occasionally, it may be necessary to integrate several sections of trace<br />
connected to the same system control. In these cases the use of current probes<br />
along with our AKONet Trace system allows us to identify breaks in any of the<br />
legs by detecting a decline in energy consumption.<br />
Taking the above mentioned into account, and thanks to the flexibility of our<br />
AKOTRACE® solution, we can reduce costs without losing efficiency, always<br />
prioritizing the safety and security of the plant´s process.<br />
In our next post we´ll specify how our AKOTRACE® Electrical Heat Tracing<br />
solution works in Molten Salt areas.<br />
15
AKOTRACE ® Solution for Molten Salt<br />
areas<br />
As we promised, this post will now talk<br />
about our AKOTRACE® Electrical Heat Tracing<br />
system, for molten salt areas. First we<br />
are going to highlight four critical issues that<br />
our solution takes into consideration:<br />
� Temperature should be maintained at<br />
265 ºC<br />
� There are two kind of tracing circuits:<br />
for temperature maintenance and for heating.<br />
� Higher levels of thermal loss due to higher temperature readings<br />
� Tracing is especially critical in this area and requires a higher level of<br />
readiness.<br />
Thermal loss is higher in molten salt areas due to the higher levels of temperature<br />
readings that should be maintained. Precision is key when regulating the<br />
temperature in this area to be energy efficient and avoid unnecessary<br />
overheating.<br />
The proper regulation algorithm for this application is the Proportional-<br />
Integrated (PI), available in our DUOControl Trace, because it allows each<br />
circuit to be more specific regarding the response speed, and at the same time it<br />
achieves a very precise and reliable regulation, which translates into<br />
temperature fluctuations, with regards to the SP, under a 1 ºC. Since the PI<br />
regulation means variable connection/disconnection cycles, the commutation<br />
element more suitable is the solid state switch-off relay that allows for an<br />
unlimited number of commutations.<br />
There are some circuits that require extra power to guarantee two kind of<br />
working modes: temperature maintenance and heating. Furthermore, this<br />
heating should be done in a limited period of time and making sure not to<br />
surpass the materials design temperature. Our DUOControl Trace application<br />
has some functionalities to control the heating process during both the ramp-up<br />
and the steady state periods.<br />
Due to the extra power, the malfunction of any of the control elements could<br />
cause an excessive temperature increase. To correct this problem, our<br />
AKOTRACE® Electrical Heat Tracing solution offers the option to get a safety<br />
contactor that disconnects temporarily that particular tracing section in case it<br />
reaches the “Safety Temperature Reading”, generating an alarm in both the<br />
operator´s local panel and in the DCS.<br />
There are some critical points that should be treated in a special manner. For<br />
these points AKO has specific solutions that have already been used successfully<br />
in various plants. AKO´s vision allows for a more adaptable installation, specially<br />
designed to cover any plant´s needs, providing each area the necessary<br />
resources according to its importance or criticality in the production process.<br />
16
PROTrace ® : Control and power cabinets<br />
for electrical trace circuits (I)<br />
A very important component in any trace installation is the power and control<br />
cabinet. Its main function consists on monitoring and managing power from the<br />
power supply to the trace circuits, although it can also incorporate subsystems<br />
depending on the installation needs.<br />
AKO has a wide range of cabinets with multiple configurations adaptable to any<br />
installation needs. According to its structure they can be categorized by:<br />
� PROTrace®: They adapt to each plant´s requirements (tower o parabolic through<br />
concentrator) and to the application (molten salts or HTF). They provide a high<br />
safety standard because they allow, among other things, power supply<br />
redundancy in power connections, power sources and probes, as well as<br />
monitoring of the cabinet´s performance.<br />
� ProTrace Distributed: Designed for projects where there is a large distance<br />
between the trace circuits in the electrical rooms (we´ll talk about these ones in<br />
following posts)<br />
PROTrace® cabinets<br />
A standard configuration of the cabinets for solar plants (with molten salts<br />
storage) contains the following components:<br />
Connection and supply<br />
Include all the generic services: Generic<br />
protection, transformers, power supply<br />
for system´s control and supply network<br />
analyzers. The power supplies and connections<br />
can be redundant (we recommend<br />
it in critical processes). In these<br />
cases it monitors the quality of the network<br />
to switch from one connection to<br />
another when needed.<br />
Trace control<br />
Gets the information from different elements of the installation (temperature<br />
probes and electric current, protections status, framework variables, etc) and<br />
acts consequently, modulating the start power in each trace circuit.<br />
Switching<br />
The circuits get connect or disconnected depending on the information gotten<br />
from trace control. Depending on the projected switching frequency, that is the<br />
preset regulation algorithm, they can be contractors or SSR (switch-off relays).<br />
In our next post we´ll continue outlining more components of our PROTrace®<br />
cabinets, including our AKODUO safety system.<br />
17
PROTrace ® : Control and power cabinets<br />
for electrical trace circuits (II)<br />
We continue where we left it in our last post, talking about AKO´s PROTrace®<br />
cabinets. As we have already stated a standard configuration of the cabinets for<br />
solar plants (with molten salts storage) contains the components already<br />
mentioned in our last post plus the following:<br />
AKODUO Safety<br />
In case of reaching safety temperature readings, the system disconnects the<br />
power supply in the damaged circuit using a second safety contactor. This<br />
functionality protects both the heating element and where it is installed in case<br />
of malfunction in the switching elements.<br />
Protection<br />
The cabinets have magneto thermal protection and differentials for both the<br />
fuse boxes and the trace circuits.<br />
Operator panel<br />
They also have an operator panel to monitor and set up the installation<br />
system´s control. Its local installation simplifies any maintenance job both in the<br />
fuse boxes and the field.<br />
Fuse boxes monitoring<br />
To ensure the proper functioning of the cabinet, some points are monitored<br />
(detection of stress, generic protection status, internal temperature, etc.)<br />
generating alarms both in the DCS and in the operator panel. This allows us to<br />
do preventive maintenance, avoiding major problems in the fuse boxes and the<br />
trace installation.<br />
Communications<br />
The cabinets include the communication<br />
network switchers from all the elements of<br />
the system´s control: PLC´s, monitoring,<br />
operator panel, getaway link with plant´s<br />
DCS, and firewall remote management<br />
(when applicable). Communications redundancy<br />
is available to avoid possible link<br />
breakages.<br />
Cooling and Welding<br />
They maintain the temperature inside the cabinet within the established ranges<br />
in the design phase. It is very common to install the power and control cabinets<br />
unsheltered, making the cooling and welding functions very important to ensure<br />
the right functioning of all its elements. We still have more to say about AKO´s<br />
cabinets. In some other post we´ll describe our PROTrace® Distributed, part of<br />
our wide range of cabinets with multiple configurations, adaptable to any<br />
installation.<br />
18
PROTrace ® : Control and power cabinets<br />
for electrical trace circuits (III)<br />
We´ve already mentioned that AKO has a<br />
wide range of cabinets with multiple<br />
configurations adaptable to any installation<br />
needs. Now we are going to describe<br />
our PROTrace® Distributed, a cabinet<br />
designed for projects where there is<br />
a large distance between the trace circuits<br />
in the electrical rooms.<br />
These cabinets differentiate themselves<br />
from the rest because they distribute<br />
power and control throughout the entire<br />
installation by means of three different kinds of cabinets:<br />
� Main Cabinet: Distributes power to secondary cabinets and it acts as a<br />
liaison between the plant´s DCS and the tracing system. It includes a local<br />
panel control<br />
� Secondary Cabinet: Distributes power and communications generated from<br />
the main cabinet to the PROTrace D3 and/or D6 cabinets.<br />
� PROTrace D3 and D6 cabinets: They receive power generated from the<br />
secondary cabinets and then they apply this power to the tracing system,<br />
regulating it according to its configuration and each circuits probe readings<br />
This structure aims to shorten the distances between the control elements and<br />
the tracing circuits, thus dramatically reducing tracing and installation costs.<br />
They are designed for CSP plants with HTF or BOP systems. They are not<br />
suitable in sales or in the process industry.<br />
Any change in the main cabinet´s configuration (where we found the panel<br />
control) or in the plant´s DCS, will be sent to the PROTrace D3 and D6 cabinets<br />
throughout a communications network, but, nevertheless, each cabinet is<br />
autonomous, meaning that they will be working fine even if the network fails.<br />
In our next post we´ll give you more details about our PROTrace D3 and D6<br />
cabinets.<br />
19
PROTrace ® : Control and power cabinets<br />
for electrical trace circuits (IV)<br />
As we promised in our previous post, we are going now to give you more details<br />
about how our PROTrace D3 and D6 cabinets work.<br />
They are available with 3 or 6 control outlets (D3: up to 3 circuits and D6: up to<br />
6 circuits). Each cabinet has two protection elements, independent from each<br />
other, one aimed to control and a second one to power. It includes a contactor<br />
per circuit to regulate outlet power, a CPU, our DUOControl Trace (based in an<br />
industrial PLC, with high levels of availability and reliability) a remote input<br />
module Pt100 and a resistance welding with thermostat.<br />
Their main functions are:<br />
� Circuit alarm management<br />
� Start timer circuit to avoid consumption<br />
peaks<br />
� Temperature supervision per circuit<br />
� Independent set point per circuit<br />
� 2 kinds of control per circuit: ON/OFF<br />
and CETA<br />
� Independent input per circuit<br />
� 3 alarm temperature thresholds: minimum,<br />
maximum and critical (it stops<br />
regulation)<br />
� Output power set per circuit in case of<br />
probe malfunction<br />
20
DUOControl Trace: The brain inside<br />
AKO´s ProTrace ® cabinets (I)<br />
When talking about the structure of an<br />
optimal heat tracing solution we have already<br />
highlighted in previous posts the<br />
importance of what we call level 2 of the<br />
installation, referring to control and power<br />
and where our ProTrace® cabinets are<br />
placed. Within these cabinets is where<br />
you´ll find its “brain”: Our DUOControl<br />
Trace, a device in charge of integrating the<br />
logic of the electrical tracing control, monitoring<br />
the input signals (valves, protection status, alarms) and acting accordingly<br />
on the heating elements.<br />
The DUOControl Trace devices have been specifically designed to facilitate the<br />
configuration and monitoring of the electrical tracing installation. They use PLC<br />
technology, like control hardware, and they provide a high level of reliability to<br />
our DCS-AKOTRACE® system.<br />
Among other functionalities they include the following:<br />
� 4 temperature probes per tracing control, with several redundancy options<br />
� Temporary synchronized disconnection for shedding maneuvers<br />
� Sequential control connection to avoid consumption peaks<br />
� Up to 10 alarm outputs (depending on the configuration)<br />
� 24 process alarms per tracing control<br />
� Independent protection outputs that will disconnect the main output in case of<br />
overheating<br />
� Theoretical totalizing of consumed energy<br />
� Transistor output (TRT) that allows for an unlimited number of maneuvers<br />
� It has 1 or 2 current probes per tracing control, allowing for the supervision of<br />
consumption in single or three phase circuits.<br />
� SD card slot, which allows to upload or to save the controller configuration to<br />
simplify start off and substitution operations<br />
Its modular construction makes it adaptable to any installation. It can<br />
communicate to the DCS plant by means of several protocols: MODBUST/TCP,<br />
Profibus, Devicenet, etc.<br />
Each controller can manage up to 32 tracing controls, performing activation<br />
work in the heating cables, as well as supervising the protection state and status<br />
variables in addition to managing the alarm system.<br />
In our following post we´ll talk about the 3 regulation algorithms (PI, ON/OFF<br />
and CETA) included in our DUOControl Trace devices.<br />
21
DUOControl Trace: The brain inside<br />
ProTrace ® cabinets (II)<br />
We continue talking about the structure of an optimal heat tracing solution, but<br />
this time focusing on our DUOControl Trace device, the brain inside our<br />
ProTrace® cabinets.<br />
We have already stated that depending on the needs of each circuit it has 3<br />
regulation algorithms (PI, ON/OFF and CETA)<br />
PI Control<br />
It is the most appropriate control<br />
for areas that require less temperature<br />
variation maintenance from Set<br />
Point.<br />
The controller is constantly calculating, according to several variables, the<br />
necessary power to reach and maintain the Set Point temperature, and it also<br />
modulates the output with short term connection/disconnection cycles.<br />
In addition to that, it checks the velocity in which the material gets heated,<br />
making sure that it does not exceed its limits.<br />
Each DUOControl Trace has 4 customized PI parameter sets that permit to<br />
adjust the speed response independently in each control.<br />
ON/OFF Control<br />
Fit for areas allowing for greater temperature variations from Set Point.<br />
The output remains active until reaching Set Point temperature plus the<br />
differential programmed, once it has reached this point, it remains disconnected<br />
until reaching Set Point temperature.<br />
CETA Control<br />
This kind of control is suited to compensate thermal losses based on room<br />
temperature, avoiding the cooling of fluids inside the pipes.<br />
The controller estimates the necessary power to reach and maintain Set Point<br />
temperature depending on room temperature and modulates the output with<br />
long-term connection/disconnection cycles.<br />
22
AKONet Trace, AKO´s control software<br />
for EHT systems<br />
We have previously stated in several posts that our AKOTRACE® Electrical Heat<br />
Tracing system is designed in a three-level structure.<br />
� Level 3- Field and Installation<br />
� Level 2- Control and Power<br />
� Level 1- Supervision and Connectivity<br />
It is in the last level, Supervision and Connectivity, where we find AKO´s<br />
newest software to monitor, supervise and control electrical heat tracing<br />
systems.<br />
AKONet Trace it´s been designed to be accessible and easy to use, with great<br />
efficiency and enough versatility for optimal performance even in the most<br />
ambitious projects.<br />
It´s a web application accessible from a PC and remotely from any navigator<br />
connected to the net, even from your phone. One of its setting options includes<br />
the possibility to receive alerts via e-mail and/or SMS.<br />
But there is nothing like a live demo on how the application works to give you a<br />
better sense of its functionality and advantages in any CSP plant´s EHT<br />
installation.<br />
Watch it on YouTube!<br />
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=9CDepX5HcBU<br />
23
DUOVision Touch Trace: Designed for<br />
small EHT systems<br />
We had previously talked about our DUOControl<br />
Trace, which we consider to be the brain inside<br />
our ProTrace® cabinets. Now we are going to<br />
describe you one device that works along with it:<br />
DUOVision Touch Trace.<br />
DUOVision Touch Trace is a 7” high contrast<br />
touch screen that together with DUOControl<br />
Trace controllers allows to framework and<br />
monitor small electrical heat tracing installations<br />
with up to 128 tracing controls, or, in other words, each screen can manage up<br />
to 4 DUOControl Trace with 32 tracing controls each one.<br />
Each tracing control regulates the tracing element´s temperature activating and<br />
deactivating the heating cables, supervising its protections, as well as the<br />
different status variables and the alarm management.<br />
The screen carries out monitoring and frameworking functions, leaving the<br />
tracing management to DUOControl Trace, allowing for the installation to keep<br />
on working even when there is a malfunction. Its main responsibilities are:<br />
� Creation of tracing control groups when needed: Allows for the organization of<br />
different tracing sections in groups, to facilitate its identification during<br />
monitoring or frameworking.<br />
� Up to 3 user levels, according to its permissions: Visualization, operation and<br />
maintenance, which ensures that only qualified people would be able to access<br />
and modify tracing installation frameworks.<br />
� Easy to use frameworking: Allows to change any installation framework even if<br />
you are not familiar with programming.<br />
� Graphical identification of control status. Just with a quick look to the screen<br />
you can see the installation´s tracing status. When an incident arises (disabled<br />
controls, alarms, etc.) the screen will display alarm icons or it will change the<br />
regular colors of the control or control group affected by the problem.<br />
� SD card slot: Which allows for making system´s configuration backups and<br />
restore them when needed, facilitating maintenance work.<br />
� Protection level IP 65: Allows for its installation in industrial environments<br />
� Easy to connect: It only requires power feed and to be connected to the<br />
DUOControl Trace network (Ethernet with RJ45)<br />
� Theoretical totalizing of consumed energy: It allows to know the theoretical<br />
value of the consumed power.<br />
To recap, the DUOVision touch Trace is the ideal alternative to AKOnet Trace,<br />
when working in small EHT installations.<br />
24
AKO´s MI heating cable<br />
One of the key elements in any electrical heat tracing installation is the use of<br />
the right heating cable. In this post we are going to share with you the<br />
specifications of AKO´s Mineral Insulated (MI) heating cable.<br />
In any EHT installation, the maintenance<br />
temperature and the process temperature<br />
determine the kind of heating cable more<br />
suitable to use.<br />
The maintenance temperature is usually<br />
lower than the process temperature, this<br />
fact is determinant to decide the maximum<br />
power that the heating cable can endure<br />
when connected, while the process temperature<br />
is needed to avoid the damage of the<br />
insulated cable when it is disconnected.<br />
In instances when process temperature reaches 450 ºF readings, or when the<br />
maintenance temperature is around 350 ºF, which requires high power from the<br />
heating cable, it gets really difficult to pick the right heating cable.<br />
But AKO´s heating cable with mineral insulation can be used in process temperature<br />
readings of up to 1100 ºF and in maintenance temperature around 900 ºF.<br />
Some other specifications of this cable, besides the power and temperature<br />
requirements, are, among others:<br />
� Corrosion resistance<br />
� Mechanical resistance<br />
� Usable in explosive atmospheres<br />
� Easy to use<br />
When the corrosion is high, the cable is made with a cover with a high nickel<br />
content (Alloy 825). AKO´s MI cable also has a high mechanical resistance, and<br />
at the same time, it is adaptable to the surface in which it has to be applied.<br />
The heating element varies regarding the material or diameter depending on<br />
the lineal resistance we want to achieve. The material used is a mixture of nickel<br />
with other metals.<br />
The heating cable has a heating zone and one or two cold ends to be connected<br />
to the power supply. When the cable is 1 core, it has two cold ends for power<br />
supply, while the 2 cores cable just has one cold end. When assembled in the<br />
power supply, each cable´s cold end includes a cable gland.<br />
The insulation between the cable´s active part and its cover is made out of<br />
Magnesium Oxide (MgO).<br />
AKO´s heating cables with mineral insulation are certified to be used in<br />
explosive atmospheres classified as Class 1 Division 2, Groups A, B, C & D.<br />
25
Temperature Sensors I<br />
In this post we will now talk about the different kind of probes used in tracing<br />
installations and which one works better depending on the circumstances.<br />
Which probe to use and when<br />
In order to install an electrical tracing<br />
to maintain a given temperature,<br />
it is required the installation of a<br />
control loop with a signal provided<br />
by a temperature sensor.<br />
When selecting the temperature sensors we have to take into account the temperature<br />
ranges they will have to endure since the process temperature tends<br />
to be higher to the temperature to be maintained by the electrical tracing.<br />
When the temperature ranges are about -60 ºF and 1100 ºF, the temperature<br />
sensor more suitable is a Pt100 probe. For readings higher or closer to the<br />
provided temperature, such is the case of solar thermal power tower plants, it´s<br />
better to use a type K thermocouple sensor.<br />
The placement of the sensors on the field close to the traced surfaces entails<br />
that they have to be extended to the installation´s electrical cabinets. When<br />
using Pt100 probes we recommend a converter to 4-20mA, making it even<br />
more necessary when installing type K thermocouples. The 4-20 mA signal<br />
avoids temperature measurement mistakes caused by possible electromagnetic<br />
interferences, which makes its application very common in industrial<br />
environments.<br />
AKO has convertors for both Pt100 probes and type K thermocouples to<br />
4-20 mA placed in connection boxes to facilitate its installation.<br />
In our next post we´ll talk about redundancy and the required temperature in<br />
different points.<br />
26
Temperature Sensors II<br />
We continue analyzing the kind of probes used in tracing installations and which<br />
ones are more suitable depending on the circumstances.<br />
Where to install a temperature sensor<br />
Now we are going to focus in temperature measurement in different points of<br />
the tracing system and its redundancy. Usually there is a temperature sensor in<br />
each control area of an electrical tracing installation. But, depending on the<br />
criticality of the set up it could be necessary the installation of several sensors in<br />
the same area. The distribution of these sensors is made in three different ways<br />
depending of the installation´s design requirements:<br />
� In a redundancy point<br />
� In several points without redundancy<br />
� In several points with redundancy<br />
Our controller DUOControl Trace allows for the configuration of the mentioned<br />
sensors, and it controls the system based in its temperature readings. Any<br />
temperature deviation above a determined value or the damage of a sensor will<br />
trigger distinct alarms allowing for a faster and more precise identification of<br />
the problem.<br />
In our next post we will talk about AKONet Trace, our software that monitors,<br />
supervises and controls electrical heat tracing systems. We will explain in detail<br />
how the alarm system works and we will highlight its mobility.<br />
27
AKONet Trace: Alarm Management (I)<br />
We have already described some of<br />
the advantages of our AKONet Trace,<br />
the software that allows for the<br />
configuration and monitoring of<br />
AKO´s electrical tracing installations.<br />
In this case we will focus in the<br />
alarm management´s functionality.<br />
In any electrical tracing installation<br />
the prompt detection of any system´s<br />
anomaly is vital, to both<br />
ensure a proper plant´s performance and to avoid future greater and costlier<br />
breakdowns. For that reason AKO has been working relentlessly to provide<br />
AKONet Trace software with the right tools to manage this kind of incidents in a<br />
rapid and efficient manner.<br />
In case of detecting any anomaly (such as higher or lower temperature readings,<br />
mistakes in probes readings, communications breakdowns, etc.), the system<br />
activates an alarm that gets displayed on the screen in different ways:<br />
� Alarm notification bar: Located in the upper side of the screen, it shows<br />
the active alarms in sequence. Pressing over any of the alarms it is possible<br />
to gain direct access to the alarm´s listing screen that provides detailed<br />
information about the active alarms, offering the possibility to confirm it<br />
or get access to the strained control.<br />
� Alarm´s listing: It shows the entire installation´s alarm listing, being even<br />
able to filter the results throughout different parameters (by dates, by<br />
active alarms, by pending confirmation, etc.) The results can be exported<br />
to PDF or Excel, facilitating its analysis in operating reports.<br />
In our next post we will continue describing more functionalities of the software<br />
including how it works with the system´s control and the categorization of the<br />
alarms depending on its source.<br />
28
AKONet Trace: Alarm Management (II)<br />
We continue with the analysis of our<br />
AKONet Trace, the software that allows<br />
for the configuration and monitoring of<br />
AKO´s electrical tracing installations.<br />
We had previously described two different<br />
ways the software has to display<br />
the alarms on the screen: by means of<br />
an alarm notification bar and with an<br />
alarm´s listing.<br />
Now let´s see how the software works with the system´s control, plus we will<br />
show you how it categorizes the alarms depending on its source.<br />
� Control´s active alarms: When reviewing the details of any system´s control,<br />
you can detect all the active alarms and even confirm them in case it is<br />
necessary.<br />
� Alarm´s icons: There are 3 alarm´s icons depending on where they were<br />
originated:<br />
� I/O Service: Alarms that detect malfunctions in the elements inside the<br />
electrical cabinet: internal temperature and electrical protection status of<br />
the different electrical elements.<br />
� Generics: This kind of alarm gets activated by a cluster, meaning that it can<br />
affect all the tracing circuits controlled by the cluster.<br />
� Control: An alarm generated by any of the installation´s tracing controls. It<br />
also displays an alarm icon in the strained control. When monitoring<br />
groups or cabinets, this same icon gets displayed in the strained group or<br />
cabinets.<br />
In addition to the above mentioned, to facilitate the problem´s resolution,<br />
besides indicating the cause of the alarm, the software also displays the name<br />
of the PLC affected, the name of the control and to which group it belongs, plus<br />
the time and date it was generated. These data allows the maintenance<br />
personnel to locate and repair the breakdown in a very short period of time.<br />
What´s more, apart from being able to view the alarms in the PC panel where<br />
AKONet is executed, all the alarms are communicated to the Distributed<br />
Control System (DCS), in exceptional cases when the client demands having the<br />
tracing system´s control connected to the DCS.<br />
29
AKO ENGINEERING INC.<br />
1490 South Price Road | Chandler | AZ 85286 Suite 311 | USA<br />
Tel. (1) 480 428 5083| e-mail: akoengineering@ako.com|www.akotrace.com<br />
We reserve the right to supply materials that might vary slightly to those described in our Technical Sheets.<br />
Updated information is available on our website: www.ako.com.