26.03.2013 Views

Issue 1 - Dalhousie University

Issue 1 - Dalhousie University

Issue 1 - Dalhousie University

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

SOCIETY FOR THE STUDY OF ARCHITECTURE IN CANADA/SOCIETE POUR L'ETUDE DE L'ARCHITECTURE AU CANADA


Society for the Study of<br />

Architecture in Canada<br />

President<br />

MarkFram<br />

221 Russell Hill Road, No. 302<br />

Toronto, Ontario, M4V 2T3<br />

Past President<br />

Douglas Franklin<br />

30 Renfrew Avenue<br />

Ottawa, Ontario, KlS lZS<br />

Vice-President<br />

Stuart Lazear<br />

National Capital Commission<br />

161 Laurier Avenue West<br />

Ottawa, Ontario, KlP 6J6<br />

Treasurer<br />

Julie Harris<br />

213 Cobourg Avenue<br />

Ottawa, Ontario, KlN 8H9<br />

Secretary<br />

Neil Einarson<br />

754 Mulvey Avenue<br />

Winnipeg, Manitoba, R3M 1H7<br />

Bulletin Editor<br />

Gordon Fulton<br />

Heritage Canada<br />

P.O. Box 1358, Stn. B<br />

Ottawa, Ontario, KlP 5R4<br />

Members-at-large (east to west)<br />

Charles Henley<br />

8 Battery Road<br />

St. John's, Newfoundland, AlA 1A4<br />

Richard Mackinnon<br />

89 Cottage Road<br />

Sydney, Nova Scotia, BlP 2C9<br />

Dr. C. W. Eliot<br />

<strong>University</strong> of Prince Edward Island<br />

550 <strong>University</strong> Avenue<br />

Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, CIA 4P3<br />

Allen Doiron<br />

Provincial Archives<br />

P.O. Box 6000<br />

Fredericton, New Brunswick, E3B 5Hl<br />

Howard Shubert<br />

Canadian Centre for Architecture<br />

1440 St. Catherine Street W., 2nd floor<br />

Montreal, Quebec, H3G 1R8<br />

Anne M. de Fort-Menares<br />

100 Quebec Avenue, Ste 608<br />

Toronto, Ontario, M6P 4B8<br />

Jim Johnson<br />

185 Waverley Street<br />

Winnipeg, Manitoba, R3M 3K4<br />

Frank Korvemaker<br />

Saskatchewan Parks, Recreation and Culture<br />

1942 Hamilton Street<br />

Regina, Saskatchewan, S4P 3V7<br />

Diana Kordan<br />

Historic Sites Service, Alberta Culture<br />

Old St. Stephen's College<br />

8820 112 Street<br />

Edmonton, Alberta, T6G 2P8<br />

Edward Mills<br />

701 - 1133 Melville Street<br />

Vancouver, British Columbia, V6E 4E5<br />

Don Lovell<br />

Public Works and Highways<br />

Government of Northwest Territories<br />

Yellowknife, Northwest Territories, XlA 2L9<br />

res. (416) 961-9956<br />

office (613) 237-1867<br />

res. 236-5395<br />

office (613) 239-5553<br />

res. 741-4233<br />

office (819) 997-6648<br />

res. (613) 233-0932<br />

office (204) 945-4390<br />

res. 284-8783<br />

office (613) 237-1066<br />

(709) 765-5683<br />

office (902) 566-0400<br />

office (514) 871-1418<br />

res. 485-1542<br />

res. ( 416) 769-6862<br />

office (204) 983-3088<br />

res. 452-0377<br />

office (306) 787-5875<br />

res. 586-1405<br />

office ( 403) 427-2022<br />

res. 431-2344<br />

office (604) 666-6317<br />

office ( 403) 873-7818<br />

ISSN No. 0228-0744<br />

Produced with the assistance of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council<br />

COVER· A sleeping porch at the Ninette Sanatorium, Ninette, Manitoba, 1910<br />

(Manitoba Archives). See page 10.<br />

BULLETIN<br />

Volume/Tome 14, Number/Numero 1<br />

A Note from the Editor/Note du redacteur<br />

by Gordon Fulton ......................................................................... 3<br />

The Design of Tuberculosis Sanatoria in Late<br />

Nineteenth Century Canada*<br />

by Leslie Maitland ........................................................................ 5<br />

Modernism and Regionalism: Influences<br />

on the Work of Leslie Fairn*<br />

by Wayde Brown ......................................................................... 14<br />

Research Notes for an Essay on Public Buildings<br />

in Canada<br />

by Mark Fram and Jean Simonton ........................................... 19<br />

C/ ................................................................................................ 21<br />

* Proceedings<br />

Membership fees are payable at the following rates: Student, $10.00;<br />

1ndividuai/Family, $25.00; Organization/Corporation/Institution,<br />

$40.00; Patron, $20.00 (plus a donation of not less than $100.00). There<br />

is a surcharge of $5.00 for all foreign memberships. Contributions over<br />

and above membership fees are welcome, and are tax-deductible. Please<br />

make your cheque or money order payable to the SSAC and send to Box<br />

2302, Sa lion D, Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5W5.<br />

L'abonnement annuel est payable aux prix suivantes: etudiant, 10,00 $;<br />

individuel/famille, 25,00 $; organisation/societe{!nstitut, 40,00 $;<br />

bienfacteur, 20,00 $(plus un don d'au moins 100,00 $).II y a des frais<br />

additionnels de 5,00 $pour les abonnements etrangers. Les contributions<br />

au dessus de l'abonnement annuel sont acceptees et deductible<br />

d'imp6t. Veuillez s.v.p. faire le cheque ou mandai de poste payable a<br />

l'ordre de SEAC et envoyer a C.P. 2302, Succursale D, Ottawa (Ontario)<br />

K1P 5W5.<br />

The Society for the Study of Architecture in Canada is a learned society devoted to<br />

the examination of the role of the built environment in Canadian society. Its membership<br />

includes structural and landscape architects, architectural historians, urban historians<br />

and planners, sociologists, folklorists, and specialists in such fields as heritage<br />

conservation and landscape history. Founded in 1974, the Society is currently the sole<br />

national society whose focus of interest is Canada's built environment in all of its<br />

manifestations.<br />

2 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 14:1


and general research undertaken in Canada on this topic. There is no<br />

lack of material on the topic, though there is no comprehensive study<br />

of public architecture. This is perhaps not surprising, considering the<br />

wide variety of types that "public buildings" may include.<br />

Historic Sites and Monuments Board (HSMB) research papers<br />

prove to contain excellent background information on various specific<br />

building types. So, too, do Canadian Inventory of Historic Building<br />

research papers, though seldom with the broader contextual information<br />

of the HSMB papers. And, appropriately enough, considering my<br />

opening remarks on ground-breaking studies, the SSAC Bulletin<br />

figures well in research on specific buildings.<br />

As has been the case during the past fifteen years, the Bulletin<br />

editor owes a great deal to those who work behind the scenes putting<br />

each issue together. My thanks for this issue go to Christine Derouin<br />

and Sandra Stephens for word processing, and Dominique Michel for<br />

translation.<br />

Gordon Fulton<br />

Editor<br />

publics au Canada (voir aussi p. 23) resument les travaux de recherche<br />

specialisee et generale entrepris au Canada sur le sujet. II existe<br />

beaucoup de documentation sur !'architecture publique, bien qu'aucune<br />

etude exhaustive n'ait ete realisee. Ce n'est pas vraiment surprenant,<br />

si on considere Ia grande variete de genres qui sont compris<br />

dans l'expression "edifices publics".<br />

Les travaux de recherches de Ia Commission des lieux et monuments<br />

historiques {CLMH) contiennent beaucoup d'information de<br />

base sur differents types specifiques de biltiments. II en est de meme<br />

pour l'lnventaire des biltiments historiques du Canada, bien que tres<br />

peu d'articles scient aussi elabores que ceux de Ia CLMH. Quant au<br />

Bulletin de Ia SEAC, il rapporte lui-aussi des travaux de recherche sur<br />

des batiments specifiques. Cela va de pair avec les etudes innovatrices<br />

dont je parlais au debut.<br />

Depuis quinze ans, le redacteur du Bulletin doit beaucoup A ceux<br />

qui travaillent dans l'ombre pour preparer chaque numero. J'aimerais<br />

remercier ce mois-ci Christine Derouin et Sandra Stephens pour le<br />

traitement de texte et Dominique Michel pour Ia traduction.<br />

Gordon Fulton<br />

Redacteur<br />

Leslie Maitland is an architectural historian for the Canadian Parks Service, Environment Canada. She is the author of several articles, and of Neoclassical Architecture in<br />

Canada (Ottawa: Parks Canada, 1980), and of Queen Anne Revival Style in Canadian Architecture (forthcoming).<br />

Wayde Brown received a degree in architecture from the Technical <strong>University</strong> of Nova Scotia and recently completed an M.A. in conservation studies at the <strong>University</strong> of<br />

York, England. He is currently working in Ottawa for the Heritage Recording Services of Environment Canada.<br />

Mark Fram is an architectural consultant, designer, and planner. He holds professional and graduate degrees in architecture and geography from the <strong>University</strong> of Toronto,<br />

and is a director of the Association of Heritage Consultants and president of the SSAC.<br />

Jean Simonton is a conservationist for the Ontario Ministry of Culture and Communications, where she is in charge of inventory, conservation, and management of the<br />

province's historically-significant public documents.<br />

4 SSAC BULETIN SEAC 14:1


Figure 5. Ward in Sick Children's Hospital, Toronto, Ontario. (NAG, C 91313)<br />

Military and cottage hospitals provided architects with models for<br />

small isolated buildings, well ventilated, relatively inexpensive to build<br />

and to operate, and visually satisfying in design. But Koch's discovery<br />

told them they needed a third element: they needed an interior architecture<br />

that could be easily and thoroughly cleaned to eliminate the<br />

tubercle bacillus in the dust, thereby reducing the dangers of reinfection.<br />

Hospitals had already made some advances in the introduction<br />

of dust-free environments in the 1880s, largely as a result of Sir Joseph<br />

Lister's work twenty years earlier on sepsis and antisepsis. 20 To minimize<br />

places where dust and therefore disease might lodge, architects<br />

designed interiors with as few mouldings as possible. Baseboards,<br />

cornices, chair rails, door and window mouldings, window sills, and<br />

other projections were eliminated as much as possible. The junctures<br />

of walls, ceilings, and floors were rounded to facilitate cleaning. Articles<br />

in architectural magazines and books on hospital design gave<br />

clear instructions on how this was to be done.Z 1<br />

New materials and improvements to existing materials entered the<br />

war against bacterial infection. What was needed were non- absorbent,<br />

scrubbable surfaces. Fine-graded portland cement, rather than<br />

plaster, was recommended for walls, because of its non-absorbent<br />

nature and resistance to knocks. New enamel paints applied to these<br />

walls were non-absorbent and scrubbable, unlike the wallpaper and<br />

tints of previous years. Linoleum and terrazzo were relatively new in<br />

the market, and their sanitary nature was quickly appreciated. Because<br />

of their expense they were at this time limited to operating rooms.<br />

Ordinary wood floors were still used elsewhere, but it was recommended<br />

that only hardwoods such as maple and oak be used, and that<br />

Figure 6. Main building, Muskoka Cottage Sanatorium, 1897. G.M. Miller,<br />

architect. (Archives of Ontario)<br />

they be saturated with paraffin to seal the grain and the seams between<br />

the boards. Glazed tiles came into more common use in hospitals for<br />

operating rooms, kitchens, bathrooms, and corridors. The results of<br />

these changes in building technology were hospital wards such as those<br />

in Sick Children's Hospital, Toronto (figure 5). Here, one can see the<br />

recessed door and window mouldings, cove ceilings and corners, and<br />

the high gloss of the paint on the walls. The minimalist effect of this<br />

kind of interior design strikes our eyes as startlingly modern. These<br />

changes in new materials and in the use of existing materials were being<br />

made in hospitals in general. At the same time, improvements in the<br />

8 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 14:1


Figure 7. Plan of Cottage ·o, • Muskoka Cottage Sanatorium, 1898. D. B. Dick, architect. (Archives of Ontario)<br />

Figure 8. Kentville Sanatorium, Kentville, Nova Scotia. J.M. MacGregor, architect.<br />

(Public Archives of Nova Scotia)<br />

design of operating rooms, kitchens, sewage, water supply, and heating<br />

systems began to change hospital construction for the better as well.<br />

The Muskoka Cottage Sanatorium (figure 6), the first institution<br />

built under the aegis of the National Sanatorium Association, opened<br />

in 1897, fifteen years after Koch's discovery. It may have been a long<br />

time coming, but its design had been well considered, and it quickly<br />

proved its worth. The central building, which contained administration,<br />

dining, operating, nurses' accommodation, and wards, was<br />

designed by Toronto architect G.M. Miller. 22 The cottages (figure 7)<br />

to either side were by D.B. Dick, and Burke and Horwood, also of<br />

Toronto. Located on the shores of a lake near Gravenhurst, it was well<br />

isolated from any populated area. Its northern exposure was protected<br />

from cold winds by a dense forest, and the southern exposure was<br />

faced with verandahs on two levels so that patients might spend days<br />

and nights outside. The wooden construction and the subdivision of<br />

patients by degree of infection were borrowed from the Brunei<br />

pavilion. More serious cases were confined to the centre building while<br />

those on the way to recovery stayed in the cottages, safe from reinfection.23<br />

The cottage hospital boasted the latest in linoleum and tile<br />

floors, and cement-lined walls. The architectural style of the building,<br />

like that of the cottage hospitals, was intentionally pretty, cottage-like,<br />

and cheerful, stylistically akin to the design of cottages and resort<br />

hotels of the period. Its wooden construction made it relatively less<br />

expensive to build than a masonry hospital, and it was felt that in case<br />

of fire, patients could be safely evacuated from a building limited to<br />

two storeys in height.<br />

The institution contained all that was needed to repair the body<br />

and maintain the spirits during a stay that could last for years. Diversions<br />

for those on the way to recovery included canoeing and sailing,<br />

tobogganing and snowshoeing, as well as billiards, cards, handicrafts,<br />

and amateur theatricals put on by patients and staff.<br />

In a short time, this institution could report remissions in many of<br />

the cases admitted. 24 These good results, achieved with a relatively<br />

small investment, encouraged other groups, besides the National<br />

Sanatorium Association, to erect cottage sanatoria along very similar<br />

14:1 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 9


Figure 9. Ninette Sanatorium, Ninette, Manitoba, 1910. (Manitoba Archives)<br />

Figure 10. Sanatorium, Tranquille, British Columbia, 1907. W. I Dalton, architect. (NAG, PA 30768)<br />

lines. Some of these others were the Kentville Sanatorium, Kentville,<br />

Nova Scotia (figure 8); 25 Jordan Memorial in River Glade, New<br />

Brunswick; Ninette Sanatorium, Ninette, Manitoba (figure 9 and<br />

cover); the Lake Edward Sanatorium, Lake Edward, Quebec; the<br />

Laurentian Sanatorium, Ste-Agathe-des-Monts, Quebec; 26<br />

Niagara Sanatorium, St. Catharines, Ontario; and the Muskoka Free<br />

Sanatorium, also in Gravenhurst, Ontario. Most were laid out much<br />

like the Muskoka Cottage Sanatorium: central administration building<br />

for the bed-ridden, outlying cottages for the ambulatory, isolation<br />

from settlements, isolation within the institution, buildings oriented<br />

towards the sun and air with lots of verandahs and large windows,<br />

wooden construction, a home-like atmosphere, created in part by an<br />

architecture of studied picturesqueness.<br />

While the cottage hospital sanatorium undoubtedly had good<br />

results, not everyone was convinced that it was the only route to<br />

success against TB. In planning the TB Sanitarium in Tranquille,<br />

the<br />

British Columbia in 1907, Dr. C.A. Fagan pointed out some of the<br />

problems of both the single building institution and the cottage hospital:<br />

As regards the kind of building to be erected, there are many considerations<br />

to be taken into account. Should one adopt the ideas of Brehmer and Deit­<br />

weiler, and have a closed institution in a single building, or adopt the ... cottage<br />

system, with its central administration building? The ... [closed institution in<br />

a single building] was supposed, at one time, to fulfill the requirements of both<br />

of the above, but it is undoubtedly open to many objections, chief among which<br />

may be mentioned, the institutional aspect it gives to life.<br />

The cottage system, as carried on in this country, imparts to the atmosphere<br />

a home-like influence which is much to be appreciated, but the supervision<br />

10 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 14:1


Figure 11. King Edward Memorial, Winnipeg, Manitoba. (Manitoba Archives)<br />

PLAN OF THE KING EDWARD M EMORIAL HOSPITAL<br />

Figure 12. Plan of King Edward Memorial, Winnipeg, Manitoba, 1909. (Manitoba<br />

Archives)<br />

cannot be nearly as thorough. The cost of maintaining the cottage system is<br />

considerably higher than in the closed institution with its single building. 27<br />

Given these objections, doctors went on to demand the creation<br />

of yet another type of institution, a marriage of the cottage hospital<br />

tuberculosis "san" and the urban general hospital. These structures<br />

could be erected in suburban locations, accessible to cities, thereby<br />

making transportation of patients, family visits, and the daily life of<br />

medical staff easier. 28 The buildings themselves were still oriented<br />

towards the sun, still faced with as many verandahs as the design could<br />

accommodate, and still incorporated nonabsorbent, scrubbable<br />

materials with as few dust-catching mouldings as possible. Instead of<br />

many, small buildings there were fewer buildings, larger and more<br />

compact. Figure 10 shows the sanatorium that was erected at Tranquille,<br />

British Columbia, as a result of Dr. Fagan's work on the<br />

problem. This tighter plan facilitated heating, patient care, and supervision.<br />

Separation of types of TB patients was effected within these<br />

large buildings by the use of private or semiprivate rooms (figure<br />

12). 29 In sanatoria, private and semiprivate rooms were introduced<br />

principally for this purpose, and not as a distinction of ability to pay.<br />

Newly-introduced electric bells made it possible for nurses to supervise<br />

patients in private and semiprivate rooms.<br />

Many of these newer buildings were built of masonry, since they<br />

were more than two storeys in height and had to be more fire resistant.<br />

Some of these new suburban TB sans were the Mountain Sanatorium,<br />

Hamilton, by Stewart and Witton, 1913; 30 the expanded Niaraga<br />

Sanatorium, St. catharines; the Lady Grey and the Perley Institute,<br />

Ottawa; 31 the King Edward Memorial San, Winnipeg (figure 11 ); and<br />

the Toronto Free, Queen Mary, and King Edward Sans, Weston. As<br />

the Weston Sanatorium illustrates, the doctors and architects sacrificed<br />

the psychologically positive effects of picturesque design for<br />

more efficient patient care.<br />

Is it possible to evaluate how successful these institutions were?<br />

Exercise, good diet, rest, mild diversion, fresh air, and sunshine might<br />

have been beneficial to the desperately ill in almost any structure. But<br />

the records kept by these institutions show that many who otherwise<br />

did not expect to live walked away from them, sufficiently recovered<br />

to resume their normallives. 32 In isolating those known to be infectious,<br />

and in teaching the ill how to care for themselves without<br />

infecting others, these sans performed a great service to the health of<br />

the general public. In 1901, deaths due to tuberculosis were 180 per<br />

100,000 of the por.ulation; by 1921, deaths due to TB were reduced<br />

to 87 per 100,000. 33 The sanatoria, along with the accomplishments<br />

of the public health movement, can take much of the credit.<br />

14:1 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 11


upon the design of other types of public institutions where sanitary<br />

environments were now perceived as necessary. Schools, prisons,<br />

asylums, factories, even barns were now designed with a mind to the<br />

reduction ofTB and other communicable diseases. The concern for a<br />

healthy living environment, clean, dust free, open to light and air,<br />

radically altered attitudes towards public sanitation, personal hygiene,<br />

parks, and virtually all types of building. House design changed as well.<br />

Houses of the early twentieth century 42 featured sleeping porches,<br />

Endnotes<br />

1 George Jasper Wherrett, The Miracle of the Empty Beds: A History of Tuberculosis in<br />

Canada (foronto: <strong>University</strong> of Toronto Press, 1977). Wherrett covers the history<br />

of the battle against the disease in this book, while making only passing reference to<br />

the sanatoria buildings themselves.<br />

2 This is a generally quoted figure. Statistics on deaths from tuberculosis in Canada<br />

were only available in Ontario and Quebec. Charles P. Lusk, "Statistics in Tuber·<br />

culosis in Ontario," Canada Lancet, Vol. 35, No.5 (January 1902), p. 350.<br />

3 "Sir Alexander Chrichton, Practical Observations on the Treatment and Cure of<br />

Several Varieties of pulmonary consumption; and the effects of the Vapour of Boil·<br />

ing Tar in that Disease," [London: Loyd and Son, 1823) book review in The Quebec<br />

Medica/Journal, Vol. 1 (April1826), pp. 72-80.<br />

4 J.E. Graham, "The Bacillus Tuberculosis in its Practical Bearing on the Diagnosis,<br />

Prognosis, and Treatment of the Disease," Canada Lancet, Vol. 15, No. 12 (August<br />

1883), pp. 356-62.<br />

5 John Furgusen, "Consumption- A Hopeful Outlook," The Canadian Magazine,<br />

Vol. 1, No.8 (October 1893), pp. 628-33.<br />

6 Description by W.G. Cosbie, The Toronto General Hospital, 1819-1965: A Chronicle<br />

(foronto: Macmillan, 1975), p. 66.<br />

7 John D. Thompson and Grace Goldin, The Hospital: A Social and Architectural History<br />

(New Haven and London: Yale <strong>University</strong> Press, 1975), p. 127.<br />

8 Toronto hospitals did not admit TB patients until1901. "Editorial notes," Canadian<br />

Lancet, Vol. 35, No. 4 (December 1901), pp. 272-73.<br />

9 John J. Heagerty, Four Centuries of Medicine in Canada (foronto: Macmillan,<br />

1928), Vol. 2, p. 227; also, G.C. Brink,Acro.


14<br />

Modernism and Regionalism:<br />

Influences on the Work of Leslie Fairn<br />

Figure 1.<br />

By Wayde Brown<br />

I<br />

IN 1923, LE CORBUSIER published what was to become a major document of<br />

the modern movement: J--ers une Architecture (later translated as Towards a New Architecture).<br />

In it, Le Corbusier suggested that "a great epoch has begun. There exists a new spirit<br />

... ; our own epoch is determining, day by day, its own style." 1 Le Corbusier argued the<br />

inevitability of this new spirit, and the inevitability of the new architecture associated with it.<br />

He proclaimed "Architecture or revolution. Revolution can be avoided." 2<br />

The new architecture, the roots of which can be traced back far earlier than 1923, 3 was<br />

indeed inevitable. Labeled the International Style in 1932, this new architecture would<br />

eventually ensure that a hotel in Toronto would be little different from one in Abidjan.<br />

Although Le Corbusier suggested (albeit more literally) that revolution could be avoided,<br />

this new architecture could certainly be viewed as revolutionary; its acceptance, if inevitable,<br />

came about with much struggle. It is this struggle which I explore through the career of Leslie<br />

Fairn.<br />

SSAC BULLETIN SEAC<br />

14:1


- JC R. (.l lol "f !.Lt.V,._ 'T I Co "'<br />

Figure 4. Front elevation of scheme 'll, ·proposed new town hall, New Glasgow,<br />

Nova Scotia, March 1954. (Public Archives of Nova Scotia, Map/Plans Collection)<br />

Figure 5. Front elevation of scheme ·o," proposed new town hall, New Glasgow,<br />

Nova Scotia, 26 March 1954. (Public Archives of Nova Scotia, Map/Plans<br />

Collection)<br />

Figure 6. Front elevation of proposed new town hall, New Glasgow, Nova Scotia,<br />

14 March 1953. (Public Archives of Nova Scotia, Map/Plans Collection)<br />

with a strongly-emphasized central entrance, and the west and south<br />

elevations, each symmetrical, belied a connection with the Beaux-Arts.<br />

The final result was nondescript. An interesting, if esoteric, element<br />

was the medallion design, found at either end of the west elevation. By<br />

the 1970s, this triangular design had become a symbol of Fairn's firm ,<br />

and appeared on the title blocks of his drawings.<br />

In 1952 Fairn submitted a proposal for a community library for the<br />

Town of Liverpool, a small seaport on Nova Scotia's southern shore<br />

which contains a rich store of domestic architecture dating from both<br />

the 18th and 19th centuries. For this project Fairn suggested two vastly<br />

different schemes, neither of which was ever built.<br />

One scheme called for a 1 l/2-storey fieldstone building with a<br />

steeply pitched gable roof and dormers. The residential image of the<br />

structure was strengthened by use of details commonly found in the<br />

local area, including a portico, fan light, and particular mullion patterns.<br />

The interior was divided into several tightly-enclosed spaces, and<br />

along one end wall was a large fireplace.<br />

The other scheme, with one sketch drawn by Fairn and marked<br />

"low cost," showed a one-storey brick building with a flat roof. The<br />

facade was asymmetrical, though the entrance was centrally placed<br />

and prominent. No floor plan for this scheme has been found, but one<br />

might surmise that the interior space would have been less enclosed,<br />

and likely more related to function -that is, with no fireplace.<br />

During 1953-54, Fairn worked on the design of a town hall for New<br />

Glasgow, a town in northern Nova Scotia. Over a period of twelve<br />

months at least eight schemes were developed in a variety of styles,<br />

with, in some cases, similar elevations being applied to different plans.<br />

Three of these schemes were neoclassical, with very similar facade<br />

designs (figure 4). Each was a two-storey structure with round-headed<br />

window openings and centrally-placed entrance way. Above the doorway<br />

was a large Palladian window, a detail already seen in Fairn's<br />

National Research Council proposal (and in Cobb's Macdonald<br />

Library). The facades of these schemes were all symmetrical - one<br />

had a hipped roof while the other two had simple gables. Some ofthese<br />

schemes had cupolas, a detail also found in the NRC proposal and<br />

Cobb's Science Building at <strong>Dalhousie</strong>.<br />

The neoclassical schemes differed in plan. One had a simple<br />

rectangular plan, while the other two had a central rectangle with wings<br />

projecting diagonally from either end. The simple rectangular building<br />

would have been placed on the site with its back to the street, facing<br />

the axes running between a second street and the adjacent court<br />

house. The other two proposals would have faced the building to the<br />

intersection of the two streets, its back to the court house. These two<br />

approaches to the site seemed directly opposed to each other in<br />

attitude. At least two, possibly all three, of these schemes were drawn<br />

by Maiga Vetra, originally from Latvia, who was likely one of the first<br />

women to practice architecture in Nova Scotia.<br />

A fourth scheme, quite unrelated to the others except in plan, is<br />

probably the most interesting; it is certainly the most unexpected. It is<br />

a two-storey building (likely stone) with a flat roof, wide pilasters in<br />

low relief, and a central dome, very shallow, surmounted by a small<br />

cupola (figure 5). An Art Deco imagery is reinforced by details like<br />

the winged clock located in the cornice, over the entrance. This scheme<br />

appears most imaginative if one forgets it was proposed in the 1950s,<br />

not the 1930s, and if one is unaware of a civic building Fairn had<br />

previously proposed for the Town of Dartmouth which employed<br />

many of the same elements.<br />

The other four schemes were more modern in form, though all<br />

featured a prominent central entrance and symmetrical facades (figure<br />

6). Some incorporated Art Deco details. All schemes were two<br />

storeys in height with flat roofs, and horizontal lines were reinforced<br />

by the window detailing. It is interesting that these four "modern"<br />

schemes were the first two designs drawn by Fairn (in March 1953)<br />

and probably the last two designs (dated March 26 and 30, 1954).<br />

None of the eight proposals was ever chosen; in 1962 a former post<br />

office building was bought for use as a town hall. The court house was<br />

demolished in 1963.<br />

14:1 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 17


illuminate the production process and the respective contributions of<br />

the growing professional specializations in architecture and engineering.<br />

Regrettably, similar accounts of provincial or municipal activities<br />

are not so easily accessible, but annual reports and legislative papers<br />

provide some valuable primary data for persistent researchers.<br />

There are now growing numbers of regional and topical studies.<br />

Each province has the history of its legislature recorded in some<br />

generally available form. MacRae and Adamson have surveyed both<br />

court houses and town halls for Ontario. But most research work, even<br />

outside government, tends to focus on the individual building rather<br />

Anick, Norman. "Grosse lie and Partridge Island, Quarantine Stations."<br />

Unpublished report prepared for the Historic Sites and<br />

Monuments Board of Canada (Agenda paper 7), June 1984, pp. 79-<br />

106.<br />

Archibald, Margaret. By Federal Design: The Chief Architect's<br />

Branch of the Department of Public Works, 1881-1914. Ottawa: Environment<br />

Canada-Parks, 1983.<br />

Bodnar, Diana. "The Prairie Legislative Buildings." Prairie Fornm<br />

Voi.5,No.2(Fall1980),pp.143-156.<br />

Buckley, Kenneth. Capita/Formation in Canada, 1896-1930. Toronto:<br />

McClelland and Stewart, 1974.<br />

Carr, Angela K. "Hopkins, Lawford & Nelson at Osgoode Hall: The<br />

Debacle of 1855." SSACBulletin Vol. 13, No.4 (December 1988),<br />

pp. 17-25.<br />

Carter, Margaret, ed. Early Canadian Court Houses. Ottawa: Environment<br />

Canada- Parks, 1983.<br />

Chattopadhyay, B.C. "Government Buildings in Canada and the<br />

U.S.A" M.Arch. thesis, <strong>University</strong> of Toronto, 1964.<br />

Currie, AW. "Public Finance." Canadian Economic Development<br />

(fourth edition). Toronto: Nelson, 1963, pp. 342-361 (Chapter 18).<br />

de Caraffe, Marc, Nathalie Clerk. "Ancien bureau d'enregistrement,<br />

L'Assomption, Quebec." Unpublished report prepared for the Historic<br />

Sites and Monuments Board of Canada (Agenda paper 11 ),<br />

June 1983, pp. 145-160.<br />

de Caraffe, Marc, C.A Hale, Dana Johnson, G.E. Mills, Margaret<br />

Carter. Town Halls of Canada. Ottawa: Environment Canada­<br />

Parks, 1987.<br />

Firestone, O.J. "Government Expenditures." Canada's Economic<br />

Development (draft). Ottawa: Department of Trade and Commerce,<br />

1953, pp. 70-87 (Section 6).<br />

Fort-Menares, Ann(; M. de. "<strong>Issue</strong>s of Hierarchy and Social Ritual:<br />

Mississauga City Hall." SSACBulletin Vol. 10, No.4 (December<br />

1985), pp. 26-31.<br />

Hate, C.A, Jacqueline Adell. "City Market ... Saint John, New<br />

Brunswick." Unpublished report prepared for the Historic Sites<br />

and Monuments Board of Canada (Agenda paper 12), June 1986,<br />

pp. 233-255.<br />

Bibliography<br />

than the type. Such treatments appear in academic journals of architecture,<br />

geography, history, or regional studies (for example, Bodnar,<br />

Holdsworth, Johnson and Maitland [1985], and Fort-Menares).<br />

Chattopadhyay provides a rare linkage between historical and<br />

relatively modern public buildings, and offers the only systematic<br />

review of the city hall construction activity in Canada in the 1950s and<br />

1960s; in at least two cases, Edmonton and Ottawa, the "new" city halls<br />

of that era documented in his work have been threatened in recent<br />

years with replacement by "new new" halls.<br />

Hale, C.A, Mary Cullen. "Old Sunbury County Gaol ... Burton, New<br />

Brunswick." Unpublished report prepared for the Historic Sites<br />

and Monuments Board of Canada (Agenda paper 5), June 1985,<br />

pp. 71 -85.<br />

Holdsworth, Deryck. "Architectural expressions ofthe Canadian National<br />

State." The Canadian Geographer Vol. 30, No.2 (1986), pp.<br />

167-171.<br />

Johnson, Dana. "Former Cobourg Market ... Cobourg, Ontario."<br />

Unpublished report prepared for the Historic Sites and Monuments<br />

Board of Canada (Agenda paper 31), November 1985, pp.<br />

105-123.<br />

Johnson, Dana. "Middlesex County Jail ... London, Ontario." Unpublished<br />

report prepared for the Historic Sites and Monuments<br />

Board of Canada (Agenda paper 18), June 1987, pp. 431-4 78.<br />

Johnson, Dana, Leslie Maitland. "The Former Customs House ...<br />

Hamilton, Ontario [and] the Former Carleton County Jail ... Ottawa,<br />

Ontario." Unpublished report prepared for the Historic Sites<br />

and Monuments Board of Canada (Agenda paper), June 1982, pp.<br />

297-330.<br />

Johnson, Dana, Leslie Maitland. "Osgoode Hall and the Development<br />

ofPublicArchitecture in Canada." SSACBulletin Vol. 10,<br />

No.4 (December 1985), pp. 14-18.<br />

Johnson, Dana, Janet Wright. "Aberdeen Pavilion, Lansdowne Park,<br />

Ottawa, Ontario." Unpublished report prepared for the Historic<br />

Sites and Monuments Board of Canada (Agenda paper 16), June<br />

1983, pp. 233-254.<br />

MacRae, Marion, Anthony Adamson. Cornerstones of Order: CourthousesandTownHallsofOntario,<br />

1784-1914. Toronto: Clarke<br />

Irwin, 1983.<br />

Mills, Edward. "Gonzales Observatory ... Victoria, B.C." Unpublished<br />

report prepared for the Historic Sites and Monuments<br />

Board of Canada (Agenda paper4),June 1984, pp. 31-54.<br />

Owram, Douglas. Building for Canadians. Ottawa: Public Works<br />

Canada, 1979.<br />

Rostecki, Randy, Leslie Maitland. "Post Offices by Thomas Fuller,<br />

1881-1896." Unpublished report prepared for the Historic Sites<br />

and Monuments Board of Canada (Agenda paper), June 1983.<br />

Service de Ia planification du territoire. Les edifices publics<br />

(Repertoire d'architecture traditionelle sur le territoire de la<br />

Communaute urbaine de Montreal; Architecture civile 1). Montreal:<br />

Communaute urbaine de Montreal, 1981.<br />

20 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 14:1


glass window for l'eglise Saint-Pierre as a gift to the people of France.<br />

The Ontario Heritage Foundation was subsequently asked to undertake<br />

the project.<br />

A competition was held to select the most appropriate stained glass<br />

artist living in Ontario. Stephen Thylor, living near Picton, was chosen.<br />

Thylor's design incorporated images of native life, St. Peter (to whom<br />

the church was consecrated), Ontario, and Champlain himself.<br />

The window was on display in Toronto in November 1988, and was<br />

presented to the French Consul General on November 24. It has been<br />

disassembled into nine pieces and packed to be sent by air to Bordeaux<br />

and by land to Brouage. There, early this year, it will be permanently<br />

installed in l'eglise Saint-Pierre.<br />

For more information, contact:<br />

1989 Heritage Directory<br />

Barbara Gough<br />

The Ontario Heritage Foundation<br />

2nd Floor, 77 Bloor Street West<br />

Toronto, Ontario<br />

M7A2R9<br />

The first edition of Heritage Canada's Heritage Directory was<br />

published in March 1989. In it are approximately 100 national associations,<br />

provincial and municipal heritage organizations, federal and<br />

provincial government departments, and crown corporations with<br />

information on their mandates, programmes, publications, and membership.<br />

Copies may be ordered for $25 by VISA or MasterCard by calling<br />

toll-free 1-800-267-6670, or by mailing a cheque or credit card number<br />

and expiry date to:<br />

In Print<br />

The 1989 Heritage Directory<br />

Heritage Canada<br />

P.O. Box 1358, Station B<br />

Ottawa, Ontario<br />

K1P 5R4<br />

A number of SSAC members have recently published books of<br />

interest to architecture aficionados. In addition to Mark Fram and<br />

Jean Simonton's contribution to Building Canada/Batir un pays (see<br />

pages 19-20) and Julie Harris's chapter on airports in the same<br />

publication, members' books include:<br />

•Architecture in Transition: From Art to Practice, 1885-1906, by Kelly<br />

Crossman (Kingston and Montreal: MeGill-Queen's <strong>University</strong> Press,<br />

1987). xi, 193 pp., illus, notes, biblio, index. ISBN 0-7735-0604-7.<br />

Cloth. $35.00.<br />

In the two decades after 1885, Canadian architects grappled with<br />

problems whose long-term implications they could not have seen: the<br />

role of the architect in an industrialized society, the need to accommodate<br />

and integrate applied science, and the need to express their<br />

own and their country's personality in architectural form.<br />

Kelly Crossman places the architecture of these years in a historical<br />

and ideological context by sketching the origins and effects of the shift<br />

in professional structure and perspective which occurred at the turn<br />

of this century. He traces the rise of professionalism as an idea and<br />

architectural nationalism as a goal. Other important themes include<br />

the difficulties posed by steel and glass, the reform of architectural<br />

education, and the early influence of the Arts and Crafts movement.<br />

Architecture in 1ransition<br />

FROl\1 ART TO PR;\CTICF. 1HH5 - El06<br />

K F I. I. l' I . H () \ .\ .\1 ,\ N<br />

•Well-Preserved: The Ontario Heritage Foundation's Manual of Principles<br />

and Practice for Architectural Conservation, by Mark Fram<br />

(Erin Mills, Ont.: The Boston Mills Press, 1988). xi, 240 pp., illus,<br />

appends, biblio, index. ISBN 0-919783-42-2. Paper. $24.95.<br />

Well-Preserved, the Ontario Heritage Foundation's manual of<br />

principles and practice for architectural conservation, provides both a<br />

philosophical framework and a practical guide for restoration and<br />

rehabilitation. The goal of the manual is to provide everyone involved<br />

in conserving built heritage with ready access to a common base of<br />

knowledge and principles about heritage conservation.<br />

Mark Fram has not written a "how-to" book but rather a book<br />

about "what to do, and why to do it." It is divided into four main parts:<br />

Ontario's material heritage from the past two centuries; the terms and<br />

22 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 14:1


principles which govern the conservation of buildings and their environments;<br />

practical applications for these conservation principles,<br />

with case studies; and the human and material resources available to<br />

promote and guide heritage conservation, plus a list of sources for<br />

further information.<br />

Well-Preserved est un guide sur Ies principes et Ia pratique de Ia<br />

conservation en architecture publie par Ia Fondation du patrimoine<br />

ontarien. II fournit a Ia fois Ie cadre theorique et un guide pratique<br />

pour Ies mesures a prendre a pres Ie sauvetage. Le but de ce guide est<br />

d'offrir a taus ceux qui participent a Ia conservation du patrimoine b§ti<br />

un acces facile a une base commune de connaissances et de pratiques<br />

concernant Ia conservation du patrimoine.<br />

Mark Fram souligne que Well-Preserved n'est pas un livre qui dit<br />

"comment faire", mais qui dit "quai faire et pourquoi". Le livre est<br />

divise en quatre parties principales: le patrimoine materiel en Ontario<br />

depuis deux siecles; les termes et les principes regissant Ia conservation<br />

des batiments; les applications pratiques de ces principes de conservation<br />

sur Ie chantier; et Ies ressources humaines et materielles disponibles<br />

pour promouvoir et guider Ia conservation du patrimoine, avec<br />

une liste complete de sources et d'autres renseignements.<br />

WELL·<br />

PRESERVED<br />

THE ONTARIO HERITAGE FOUNDATION'S<br />

MANUAL<br />

OF PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE<br />

FOR ARCHITECTURAL<br />

CONSERVATION<br />

MARK FRAM<br />

•Charles Baillairge, Architect and Engineer, by Christina Cameron<br />

(Kingston and Montreal: MeGill-Queen's <strong>University</strong> Press, 1989).<br />

xxvi, 201 pp., ill us, notes, appends, index. ISBN 0-7735-0638-1. Cloth.<br />

$37.95.<br />

Christina Cameron's definitive professional biography of Charles<br />

Baillairge (1826-1906) includes an analysis of innovations in architec-<br />

tural design and construction technology in Quebec City during the<br />

middle of the nineteenth century, and discusses the radical change in<br />

the role of the architect from the architect/artisan of the previous<br />

century to the professional man who no longer took any part in the<br />

actual construction.<br />

At the heart of the book, though, are the diverse talents of<br />

Baillairge himself. A fourth-generation member of a Quebec City<br />

family of artists and architects, Charles Baillairge was proficient not<br />

only as an architect but also as a surveyor, engineer, mathematician,<br />

and inventor, publishing over 250 books and pamphlets on his many<br />

interests. He designed major public buildings such as the Quebec<br />

Music Hall, Laval <strong>University</strong>, and Dufferin Thrrace, and was supervising<br />

architect for the first Parliament Buildings in Ottawa.<br />

Charles Baillairge<br />

ARCHITECT & ENGINEER<br />

Christina Cameron<br />

•The Queen Anne Revival Style in Canadian Architecture, by Leslie<br />

Maitland (Ottawa: Canadian Parks Service, currently at press).<br />

Other recent publications of note:<br />

•Batir un pays: Histoire des travau.x publics au Canada, preparee sous<br />

Ia direction de Paul-Andre Linteau (Montreal : Editions du Boreal,<br />

1988). 352 pp., illus, notes, index. ISBN 2-89052-250-4. 35,00 $.<br />

En 1976, !'American Public Works Association (APWA) a publie<br />

History of Public Works in the United States: 1776-1976. Cet ouvrage<br />

a suscite beau coup d'interet tant aux Etats-Unis qu'au Canada. Par Ia<br />

suite, le directeur general de l'APWA a incite les membres des sections<br />

14:1 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 23


canadiennes de son association l) publier un ouvrage similaire sur les<br />

travaux publics au Canada. Blitir un pays: Histoire des travaux publics<br />

au Canada est le resultat de leurs efforts.<br />

Ce livre est le premier l) presenter une vision d'ensemble de<br />

l'histoire des grands travaux publics: les pants (par Phyllis Rose); les<br />

routes, rues et autoroutes (Larry McNally); le transport en commun<br />

dans les villes (Paul-Andre Linteau); les chemins de fer (Christopher<br />

Andreae); les voies d'eau (Robert Passfield); !'irrigation et Ia lutte<br />

contre les inondations (A.A. Den Otter); l'electricite (Arnold Roos);<br />

l'approvisionnement en eau (Letty Anderson); les reseaux d'egouts<br />

(Douglas Baldwin); le traitement des dechets solides (Phyllis Rose);<br />

les edifices publics (Mark Fram et Jean Simonton); les aeroports (Julie<br />

Harris); et Ia construction des villes (Alan FJ. Artibise).<br />

[In English: Building Canada: A History of Public Works, edited by<br />

Norman Ball (Toronto: <strong>University</strong> of Toronto Press, 1988). See pages<br />

19-20 in this Bulletin.]<br />

•Changing Landscapes of Southern Ontario, by Virgil Martin (Erin,<br />

Ont.: The Boston Mills Press, 1988). 243 pp., illus, append, biblio,<br />

index. ISBN 0-919783-77-5. Cloth. $24.95.<br />

Paired photographs, before and after, explore the many facets of<br />

southern Ontario's changing landscapes. The photos depict a dramatic<br />

reworking of the urban environment, particularly on the urban frontier<br />

where the countryside is disappearing under a wave of development.<br />

But there are also unexpected evolutions, particularly in the rural<br />

areas: the photos clearly show that trees are generally more abundant<br />

now than at any time during the past century.<br />

Virgil Martin is a photographer from the village of St. Jacobs, near<br />

Waterloo, Ontario. The Early History of Jakobstettel, his local history<br />

published in 1978, is now in its second printing.<br />

•Survivals: Aspects of Industrial Archaeology in Ontario, by Ralph<br />

Greenhill and Dianne Newell (Erin, Ont.: The Boston Mills Press,<br />

1989). 234 pp., illus, biblio, index. ISBN 1-55046-000-5. Cloth. $39.50.<br />

This well-illustrated book documents some of the survivors of<br />

Ontario's industrial heritage through historic illustrations, a series of<br />

in-depth essays by Dianne Newell and Ralph Greenhill, and modern<br />

photographs by Greenhill. Contrary to conventional wisdom, Canada<br />

has not been an engineering or industrial backwater. From the construction<br />

of the Rideau Canal in the 1830s to the St. Clair Tunnel (the<br />

first major subaqueous tunnel in North America) in 1889-91, the<br />

record is one of remarkable achievements. As Newell writes in her<br />

introduction, the purpose of the book is "not to romanticize the past<br />

but to promote a new way of looking at the human landscape around<br />

us, and to increase awareness of its historical significance."<br />

•A Vision of Britain: A Personal View of Architecture, by H.R.H.<br />

Prince Charles (New York: Doubleday, to be published fall1989).<br />

Prince Charles expands on his personal view (televised last fall in<br />

Britain) that "sometime during this century something went wrong"<br />

with the way buildings were designed in Britain. His comments on<br />

modernist design in general- often set out in bold relief by his sense<br />

of outrage, in the words of the Knight-Ridder wire service- have had<br />

an increasingly daunt effect on the architectural profession. It was the<br />

Prince of Wales, for instance, who declared that contemporary ar-<br />

chitects had done more damage to London's skyline than Hitler's<br />

Luftwaffe.<br />

Maxwell Hutchinson, a London architect, president of the Royal<br />

Institute of British Architects, and outspoken critic of H.R.H., will<br />

soon counter Vzsion with a book of his own.<br />

•Bruce Goff: Toward Absolute Architecture, by David G. De Long<br />

(Cambridge: MIT Press, 1988). 337 pp., illus. ISBN 04097-2. Cloth.<br />

$50.00US.<br />

This is the first comprehensive study of America's most idiosyncratic<br />

architect, Bruce Goff (1904-1982). In the seven decades he<br />

practiced architecture Goff designed nearly 500 projects, 140 of which<br />

were built. De Long discusses the architect's development and early<br />

work in Tulsa, his first independent work in Chicago, the periods<br />

working on speculation in Bartlesville and Kansas City, his withdrawal<br />

from active practice following charges of homosexuality, and a triumphant<br />

resurgence with a design for the Japanese Wing of the Los<br />

Angeles County Museum.<br />

• The History of Postmodern Architecture, by Heinrich Klotz, translated<br />

by Radka Donnell (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1988). 480 pp., illus.<br />

ISBN 11123-3. Cloth. $60.00 US.<br />

This first standard work on postmodern architecture of the past 25<br />

years documents a rich and controversial period. More than 500<br />

black-and-white and colour illustrations present a substantial record<br />

of the aesthetic preoccupations of postmodernist architects, their<br />

patrons, and their detractors.<br />

Combining structural analysis with an assessment of programmatic<br />

and philosophical content, Klotz examines both individual projects and<br />

the life work of modern and postmodern architects, including Mies,<br />

Kahn, Moore, Ungers, Rossi, Stirling, Hollein, Gehry, Graves, Meier,<br />

Kedjuk, Eisenman, Botta, Krier, Stern, Koolhas, T. Gordon Smith, and<br />

Culot.<br />

•Modernity and the Classical Tradition: Architectural Essays 1980-<br />

1987, by Alan Colquhoun (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1989). 250 pp.,<br />

illus. ISBN 03138-8. $25.00 US.<br />

Architectural theorist and critic Alan Colquhoun, in a series of<br />

essays, attempts to develop a coherent discourse for the rampant<br />

pluralism that dominates contemporary architecture. He carefully<br />

examines some of the concepts-classicism, romanticism, historicism,<br />

and rationalism - that have prevailed in architectural discourse<br />

during the past two centuries. Colquhoun then looks at the role of<br />

history in relation to the classical avant-garde, focusing on Le Corbusier,<br />

whose work best exemplifies the tensions and contradictions of<br />

the modern movement. Essays in the book's final section address<br />

current controversies, particularly the problem of "post modernism."<br />

•On the Art of Building in Ten Books, by Leon Battista Alberti,<br />

translated by Joseph Rykwert, Neil Leach, and Robert 'Thvernor<br />

(Cambridge: MIT Press, 1988). 500 pp., illus. ISBN 01099-2. Cloth.<br />

$45.00 us.<br />

"Here, at last, we have a reliable, readable, annotated version in<br />

modern English of this Renaissance classic of architectural theory.<br />

Scholars and students of the humanities, no less than architectural<br />

24 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 14:1


historians and practitioners of architecture, will have good reason to<br />

be deeply grateful to Joseph Rykwert and his colleagues for their<br />

commendable initiative and labor in making this important book<br />

available to a wide public." Cecil Grayson, Serena Professor Emeritus<br />

of Italian Studies, Oxford <strong>University</strong>.<br />

• History of Architecture, From the Earliest Times; Its Present Condition<br />

in Europe and the United States, by Mrs. L.C. Tuthill (New York:<br />

Garland Publishing, 1988 [a facsimileofthe Philadelphia 1848edition,<br />

with a new introduction by Lamia Doumato]. 456 pp., illus, biblio.<br />

ISBN 0-8240-3717-0 Cloth. $75.00 US.<br />

With the publication of her History of Architecture in 1848 Louisa<br />

Tuthill established a new tradition of including American architecture<br />

in general histories and became the first of many distinguished women<br />

architectural historians and critics. In addition to showing how nineteenth-century<br />

Americans viewed their built environment, the volume<br />

is of interest because Tuthill stressed the need for conservation, preservation,<br />

and environmental protection; oriented the American aesthetic<br />

toward the arts and craft movement; and argued the merits of<br />

adopting a truly American architecture.<br />

•American Public Architecture: European Roots and Native Expressions,<br />

edited by Craig Zabel and Susan Scott Munshower (Papers in<br />

Art History from the Pennsylvania State <strong>University</strong>, 1988). 300 pp.,<br />

illus. ISBN 0-915773-04-X. Paper. $20.00 US.<br />

Editors Craig and Munshower have assembled a collection of ten<br />

essays on such disparate topics as "Richardson's 1tinity Church and<br />

the New England Meetinghouse," by William H. Pierson, Jr.; "Thnks<br />

and Towers: Waterworks in America," by JohnS. Garner; and "Modernized<br />

Classicism and Washington, D.C.," by Richard Guy Wilson.<br />

•Bearers of Meaning: The Classical Orders in Antiquity, the Middle<br />

Ages, and the Renaissance, by John Onians (Lawrenceville, NJ: Princeton<br />

<strong>University</strong> Press, 1989). 400 pp., illus. ISBN 04043-5. Cloth.<br />

$75.00 us.<br />

We often take it for granted that the classical orders, created by<br />

the ancient Greeks and embellished by the Romans,simply disappeared<br />

during the "Dark Ages," to be rediscovered only during the<br />

Renaissance. The author, however, demonstrates that the orders did<br />

not go underground in the Middle Ages, but were adapted in a<br />

kaleidoscopic variety of derivative, allusive, and original forms. And<br />

the Renaissance did not "rediscover" the orders - for they had never<br />

been lost - but found in them new metaphors and new varieties of<br />

meaning.<br />

•Culture and Comfort: People, Parlors, and Upholstery, 1850-1930, by<br />

Katherine Grier (Amherst, MA: <strong>University</strong> of Massachusetts Press,<br />

1989). 448 pp., illus. ISBN 0-87023-664-4. Paper. $27.95 US.<br />

Victorian Americans were fascinated with parlour upholstery and<br />

drapery. In exploring the ideals of comfort and refinement that gave<br />

rise to the parlour, Katherine Grier discusses the financial and cultural<br />

limits that governed a family's ability to realize these goals and shows<br />

how the visual and tactile qualities of parlour furnishings reflected<br />

middle-class sensibilities. She also examines the role of manufacturing<br />

in making middle-class gentility more accessible by offering upholstery<br />

and drapery to a broad range of incomes. Last, she looks at the<br />

replacement of the Victorian parlour by the modern living room.<br />

Annual General Meetings And Conferences, 1989<br />

As compiled by Heritage Canada<br />

May 15-17<br />

ICOMOS International: Recording the Historic Urban Environment,<br />

an ICOMOS Canada symposium. Quebec City. Contact: Robin<br />

Letellier, Recording and Documentation Committee, ICOMOS<br />

Canada, P.O. Box 1482, Stn. B, Hull, PO J8X 3Y3. (819) 997-0146.<br />

May 17-20<br />

"Sacred Trusts II: Money, Materials and Management," a conference<br />

on the stewardship and preservation of historic religious buildings<br />

sponsored by City of Detroit Historic Designation Advisory<br />

Board, National Centre for the Stewardship and Preservation of<br />

Religious Properties, and the National 1tust for Historic Preservation.<br />

Contact: Sacred Trusts II Conference, H.D.A.B., 202 City-Council<br />

Bldg., Detroit, MI 48226. (313) 224-3487.<br />

May 23-27<br />

"Conservation and Industrial Development." Fourth World Congress<br />

on the Conservation ofBuilt and Natural Environments. <strong>University</strong><br />

of Toronto. Contact: Heritage Trust, 79 Cambridge St., London<br />

SWIV 4P5 England.<br />

May 25-28<br />

"Heritage and Tourism: A Delicate Balance." Heritage Society of<br />

British Columbia's 11th Annual Conference. Kelowna, B.C. Contact:<br />

Robert Hobson, HSBC, 411 Dunsmuir, Vancouver, B.C. V6B 1X4.<br />

(604) 861-1139.<br />

May 31-July 23<br />

"Viewpoints: 100 J'ears of Architecture in Ontario." Ontario Association<br />

of Architects Centennial Exhibition. Agnes Etherington Art<br />

Centre, Kingston, Ontario. Contact: OAA, 50 Park Road, Toronto,<br />

Ontario M4W 2N5. (416) 968-0188.<br />

fin mai, debut join (a confirmer)<br />

L 'assemblee generale annuelle. Conseil des monuments et sites du<br />

Quebec. Montebello, Quebec (a confirmer). Personne ressource:<br />

France Gagnon-Pratte, CMSQ, C.P. 279, Haute-Ville, PO G1R 4P8.<br />

(418) 694-0812.<br />

June 1-3<br />

AGM Manitoba Heritage Federation. Neepawa, Manitoba. Contact:<br />

Maryann Haddad, MHF, 434-167 Lombard Ave., Winnipeg,<br />

Manitoba R3B OT6. (204) 943-4568.<br />

14:1 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 25


June3<br />

AGM and Awards Banquet. Federation of Nova Scotian Heritage.<br />

Wolfville (tentative). Contact: Elizabeth Ross, FNSH, 305 - 5516<br />

Spring Garden Road, Halifax, N.S. B3J 1G6. (902) 423-4677.<br />

June 6-10<br />

"Collaboration." Canadian Museums Association Annual Conference.<br />

Hull, Quebec. Contact: CMA, 280 Metcalfe St., Ottawa,<br />

Ontario K2P 1R8. (613) 233-5653.<br />

June 9-12<br />

"Flight Path, 2()()()." 52nd annual conference of the Federation of<br />

Canadian Municipalities. Hyatt Regency Hotel, Vancouver, B.C. Contact:<br />

Alderman George Puil, City Hall, Vancouver, B.C.<br />

June 11-14<br />

18th Annual Conference. Canadian Nature Federation. Charlottetown,<br />

P.E.I. Contact: CNF Conference, P.O. Box 265, Charlottetown,<br />

P.E.I. C1A 7K4. (902) 566-9150.<br />

June 15-17<br />

"Towards 1992." National Capital Commission conference.<br />

Ottawa Congress Centre. Contact: Sylvia Fan jay. (613) 239-5058.<br />

August 6-10<br />

"Planning: More Than Controls I l'urbanisme au-delii des<br />

controles." Canadian Institute of Planners. Saint John, N.B. Contact:<br />

CIP, 404- 126 York St., Ottawa K1N 5T5.<br />

Sept 4-8<br />

"Make no Little Plans." Association for Preservation Thchnology.<br />

Chicago, IL. Contact: Debora Slaton, Wiss Janny Elstner Associates,<br />

29 North Wacker Dr., Suite 555, Chicago, IL 60606. (312) 372-0555.<br />

Sept 10-17<br />

"Our World." The Summit on the Environment in the Don Valley,<br />

Toronto. Contact: 1be Summit on the Environment, 999 Danforth<br />

Avenue, Toronto, Ontario M4J 1Ml. (416) 462-3250.<br />

Sept 14-17<br />

"Managing Development and Preservation Conflicts." Symposium<br />

sponsored by Canadian Centre for Livable Places, Queen's <strong>University</strong>,<br />

and York <strong>University</strong>. Kingston, Ontario. Contact: John Weiler, CCLP,<br />

P.O. Box 1358, Stn. B., Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5R4. (613) 237-1066.<br />

Sept 18-22<br />

"Splash '89: Interpreting Our Marine and Freshwater Heritage."<br />

Interpretation Canada and Museum Association of Atlantic Canada.<br />

National workshop for natural and cultural interpreters. St. John's,<br />

Nfld. Contact: Penny Houlden (709) 722-9034.<br />

Sept 29-30<br />

AGM : Strategic Planning. Association of Museums of New<br />

Brunswick. Kingston Peninsula (near Saint John). Contact: Wendy<br />

Robb, AMNB, 503 Queen St., Fredericton, N.B. E3B 1B8. (506)<br />

452-2908.<br />

mid-October (tentative)<br />

Annual Conference. Federation of Nova Scotian Heritage. Halifax<br />

(tentative). Contact: Elizabeth Ross, FNSH (902) 423-4677.<br />

Oct 26-28<br />

"Diversitas: Understanding Ethnic Diversity in the Built Environment."<br />

Heritage Canada. Hotel Vancouver, Vancouver, B.C. Contact:<br />

Connie Johnson, P.O. Box 1358, Stn. B., Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5R4.<br />

(613) 237-1066.<br />

Oct 26-29<br />

Alberta Musewns Conference '89. Grand Prairie, Alberta.<br />

Nov 2-4<br />

"Forging Links:" linking built and natural environment groups.<br />

Heritage Saskatchewan. Contact: Jacqueline Bliss (306) 975-2655.<br />

Nov17-19<br />

Education and Conservation. ICOMOS Canada. Ottawa. Contact:<br />

ICOMOS Canada, P.O. Box 737, Stn. B, Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5R4.<br />

Nov 12-20<br />

International Conference of National Trusts. Bermuda. Contact:<br />

WS. Zuill, Director, The Bermuda National Trust, P.O. Box HM 61,<br />

HM AX, Bermuda. (809) 236-6483.<br />

May 26- June 1, 1990<br />

"Culture and Technology." Ordre des architectes du Quebec and<br />

I'Union internationale des architectes World Congress. Montreal.<br />

Contact: Architecture 1990, 640, rue St-Paul ouest, Suite 102,<br />

Montreal, PQ. (514) 393-1500.<br />

26 SSAC BULLETIN SEAC 14:1


14:1<br />

Martin Eli Wei I Award<br />

of the Society for the Study of Architecture in Canada<br />

The Society for the Study of Architecture in<br />

Canada is a learned society devoted to the<br />

examination of the role of the built environment in<br />

Canadian society. Its membership includes<br />

structural and landscape architects, architectural<br />

historians, urban historians and planners,<br />

sociologists, folklorists, and specialists in such<br />

fields as heritage conservation and landscape<br />

history.<br />

Founded in 1974 under the leadership of heritage<br />

architect Martin Eli Wei/, the Society is currently<br />

the sole national society whose focus of interest<br />

is Canada's built environment in all of its<br />

manifestations.<br />

The Society is therefore pleased to invite<br />

submissions for the Martin Eli Wei/ Award.<br />

Submissions are to take the form of an original<br />

essay (in either official language) suitable for<br />

publication, from full- or part-time students<br />

enrolled at the graduate or undergraduate level at<br />

Canadian universities.<br />

The Wei/ Award consists of a certificate and an<br />

expenses-paid trip to the Annual Meeting and<br />

Conference of the Society so that the winning<br />

essay may be delivered as part of the<br />

programme. The Society undertakes to provide<br />

return airfare, ground transportation, up to four<br />

nights accommodation, and a meal allowance.<br />

The award also includes the publication of the<br />

winning essay by the Society.<br />

Rules of the Competition<br />

1 Submissions for the Wei/ Award shall take the<br />

form of an essay, in either French or English,<br />

suitable for publication. The paper must be of<br />

3000 to 5000 words on a subject which explores<br />

the role of the built environment in Canadian<br />

society. This may deal with a single structure,<br />

either modern or historical, proposed or extant; a<br />

complex of related structures, either modern or<br />

historical, proposed or extant; a type of structure<br />

(examined for its historical, functional, structural,<br />

or aesthetic significance); cultural landscapes<br />

(for example, parks, cemeteries, farmsteads,<br />

etc.); a biographical sketch of a person who has<br />

influence the built environment; or a<br />

philosophical, sociological, or historical problem<br />

related to the built environment. Architectural<br />

projects may not be submitted unless they<br />

conform to the above requirements.<br />

SSAC BULLETIN SEAC<br />

2 Submissions must be typewritten,<br />

double-spaced. Visual materials, not exceeding<br />

8" by 10", may be included, either integrated into<br />

the text of the paper or included at the end.<br />

Submissions must be supported, where<br />

appropriate, by documentation in the form of<br />

notes, bibliography, or suggestions for further<br />

reading.<br />

3 Papers must be received by the Society, at the<br />

address below, postmarked on or before<br />

31 JANUARY 1990.<br />

4 The Society will submit each essay to its<br />

Editorial Board for assessment. The decision of<br />

the Editorial Board shall be final. The Society<br />

reserves the right not to award the prize. Every<br />

effort will be made to inform the winner by 15<br />

March 1990.<br />

5 The paper judged the winner of the award will<br />

be included in the programme of the Annual<br />

Meeting of the Society, which will take place in<br />

Edmonton in May 1990.<br />

6 If the author of the winning paper is not able to<br />

be present at the Annual Meeting, the address<br />

will be delivered in his/her absence. In lieu of the<br />

trip to the Annual Meeting, the winner will receive<br />

a cash award of $100.<br />

7 AI/ submissions will be considered for possible<br />

publication. The Editorial Board will inform all<br />

authors of its decision by 15 Apri/1 990.<br />

8 Submission must be sent to:<br />

Chairman<br />

Editorial Board<br />

Society for the Study of Architecture in Canada<br />

P.O. Box 2302, Station D<br />

Ottawa, Ontario<br />

K1P5W5<br />

27


THE SOCIETY FOR THE STUDY OF ARCHITECTURE IN CANADA<br />

SOCIETE POUR L 'ETUDE DEL 'ARCHITECTURE AU CANADA<br />

P.O. BOX 2302, STATION D/C.P. 2302, SUCC. D<br />

OTTAWA, ONTARIO K1P 5W5<br />

ISSN 0228-0744<br />

Produced with the technical assistance of Heritage Canada @ Realise avec /'aide technique d'Heritage Canada

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!