26.03.2013 Views

arizona military museum courier - Department of Emergency ...

arizona military museum courier - Department of Emergency ...

arizona military museum courier - Department of Emergency ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ARIZONA MILITARY MUSEUM<br />

COURIER<br />

Published by the Arizona National Guard Historical Society, Inc.<br />

The Arizona National Guard Historical Society is a<br />

private non-pr<strong>of</strong>it corporation established under the laws <strong>of</strong><br />

Arizona and consistent with the Internal Revenue Code. It<br />

is the sponsor <strong>of</strong> the Arizona Military Museum. The Historical<br />

Society’s purposes are: “To enhance the appreciation<br />

<strong>of</strong> the <strong>military</strong> history <strong>of</strong> Arizona and the contributions<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Militia <strong>of</strong> Arizona and the Arizona National Guard to<br />

the State <strong>of</strong> Arizona and to the Nation…” (Bylaws, Article<br />

I, Section 1). To accomplish its purposes, the Historical<br />

Society shall strive: “…to discover and memorialize the<br />

history <strong>of</strong> the Military <strong>of</strong> Arizona, the Arizona National<br />

Guard, and the general <strong>military</strong> history <strong>of</strong> Arizona, and to<br />

establish and maintain a <strong>museum</strong> on land leased, owned, or<br />

otherwise controlled by the Society.” (Id.). The policy<br />

statement states that the Historical Society is “…to portray<br />

events, persons, and other historical information relating<br />

to…the <strong>military</strong> service <strong>of</strong> Arizonans in wars and other<br />

<strong>military</strong> actions in Arizona and around the world.”<br />

The Articles <strong>of</strong> Incorporation for the Arizona National<br />

Guard Historical Society were executed on March 28,<br />

1975.<br />

The Historical Society was incorporated on April 25,<br />

1975 with the aforementioned purposes and the added purpose<br />

as stated in its policy statement: “…to portray events,<br />

Fall 2008 Issue 34<br />

HISTORICAL SOCIETY AND ARIZONA<br />

MILITARY MUSEUM HISTORY<br />

persons, and other historical information relating …the<br />

<strong>military</strong> service <strong>of</strong> Arizonans in wars and other <strong>military</strong><br />

actions in Arizona and around the world.”<br />

On July 14, 1978 the Arizona National Guard General<br />

Staff dedicated a portion <strong>of</strong> the old arsenal building for a<br />

<strong>museum</strong> for the Historical Society.<br />

In January 1980 the director and <strong>of</strong>ficers were elected<br />

who were committed to creating the <strong>museum</strong>. They did<br />

most <strong>of</strong> the demolition and construction to establish the<br />

<strong>museum</strong>.<br />

In December 1980 the Adjutant General designated the<br />

<strong>museum</strong> an <strong>of</strong>ficial permanent historical activity <strong>of</strong> the Arizona<br />

National Guard.<br />

In April 1981 the General Staff dedicated the space for<br />

the East Room <strong>of</strong> the <strong>museum</strong>.<br />

On September 12, 1981 the Arizona Military Museum<br />

had is Grand Opening.<br />

On July 13, 1999, the Arizona National Guard Historical<br />

Society and the Arizona National Guard executed a<br />

Memorandum <strong>of</strong> Understanding reaffirming their historical<br />

relationship and mutual support.<br />

On September 30, 2006, the Arizona Military Museum<br />

celebrated the 25th anniversary <strong>of</strong> its opening.


Courier page 2<br />

Published by the Arizona<br />

National Guard Historical<br />

Society, 5636 E<br />

McDowell Rd, Bldg<br />

M5320, Phoenix, AZ<br />

85008-3495<br />

President/Director:<br />

Joseph Abodeely<br />

Vice President:<br />

Thomas Quarelli<br />

Secretary:<br />

Carolyn Feller<br />

Treasurer:<br />

Klaus Foerst<br />

Board <strong>of</strong> Director<br />

Members:<br />

Jean McColgin<br />

Anna Kroger<br />

Dan Mardian<br />

Harry/Mary Hensell<br />

Rick White<br />

Eugene Cox<br />

George Notarpole<br />

Jon Falk<br />

Robert Lutes<br />

Trudie Cooke<br />

Ex-Officio Board Member:<br />

MG David Rataczak<br />

Museum Hours:<br />

The Arizona Military<br />

Museum is temporarily<br />

closed pending ro<strong>of</strong><br />

repairs.<br />

How to Contact Us:<br />

Write or call<br />

Phone: 602.267.2676<br />

Or: 602-253-2378<br />

Fax: 602.267.2632<br />

DSN: 853-2676<br />

Editors: Joseph<br />

Abodeely and Trudie<br />

Cooke<br />

Submit address<br />

changes and articles to<br />

the Arizona Military<br />

Museum, 5636 E<br />

McDowell Rd, Phoenix,<br />

AZ 85008-3495.<br />

Arizona National Guard<br />

Historical Society<br />

“Lest We Forget”<br />

REPORT TO THE MEMBERSHIP<br />

I have good news and bad news. The bad news is that<br />

the <strong>museum</strong> is still closed to the public. The Facilities<br />

Management Office (FMO) determined that the <strong>museum</strong> should be closed right after he<br />

saw the two cracked trusses in November 2007, and the engineers hired by the FMO<br />

said to close the <strong>museum</strong>. Risk management has concurred based on the information<br />

presented by their report. I complained to no avail about only the <strong>museum</strong> being singled<br />

out to be closed down while the RTI classrooms (immediately to the west) and the<br />

dining facility (immediately to the right) remained open because all three areas are under<br />

the same ro<strong>of</strong> in the north building <strong>of</strong> the RTI. The FMO engineers and an independent<br />

engineer we hired said the shoring up <strong>of</strong> the trusses was sufficient to hold them<br />

in place; but the engineers have taken the position to keep the <strong>museum</strong> closed supposedly<br />

for safety reasons. The RTI classroom area, on the west side <strong>of</strong> the <strong>museum</strong>, is<br />

still open to the public. And, the supposedly emergency situation is still not resolved.<br />

The engineers report to the FMO took about six months to recommend repairing the<br />

entire ro<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong> the north building for a cost <strong>of</strong> $1.9 million. The Guard applied for<br />

funds from National Guard Bureau to fix the building. We made the recommendation<br />

that it take a more conservative approach and make only necessary repairs. On September<br />

3, the Guard informed the Board that there was no money allocated for the repairs<br />

at this time, and the Guard would not allow the <strong>museum</strong> to reopen to the public<br />

relying on the engineers’ recommendation to Risk Management.<br />

On September 10, I was given 45 minutes notice to attend a meeting with the engineers,<br />

the FMO, the Chief <strong>of</strong> Staff, and the Army Assistant AG. Dan Mardian and I<br />

were informed that the Guard just got money from NGB to do the major project—the<br />

$1,900,000. The discussion dealt with whether it was a viable option to repair only the<br />

broken trusses in the <strong>museum</strong> and the dining facility or fix all the trusses and the ro<strong>of</strong>.<br />

It appears the Guard will do all the repairs now to avoid potential problems in the future.<br />

The <strong>museum</strong> may have to remove all <strong>of</strong> its artifacts during the construction. In<br />

other words dismantle the <strong>museum</strong>. The FMO and the Chief <strong>of</strong> Staff assured me they<br />

will work closely with us during construction and the likely removal <strong>of</strong> <strong>museum</strong> items.<br />

Dan Mardian expressed our belief that the trusses were cracked due to A/C units on the<br />

ro<strong>of</strong>, but the engineers were adamant that the other trusses were at risk due to wear.<br />

The engineers favored the total-repair option. We have been closed to the public for<br />

the past ten months, and nobody on the Board believes an emergency exists only in<br />

the <strong>museum</strong> to require its closure. But that is a moot point now. I asked the FMO<br />

about the time frame, and he said that demolition would commence soon and that the<br />

<strong>museum</strong> should be completed by around May 2009. I am taking the position <strong>of</strong> let’s<br />

take lemons and make lemonade. We will have a new building for the <strong>museum</strong> when<br />

all is done. But we’ve got to open soon. A <strong>museum</strong> not open to the public is merely<br />

a collection.<br />

The good news is that we are still working to keep one <strong>of</strong> the finest <strong>military</strong> <strong>museum</strong>s<br />

in the country alive. On February 14, 2008 (Valentine’s Day and Arizona Statehood<br />

Day), the Arizona Military Museum participated in the annual Museums on the


Letter to Membership continued.<br />

Courier page 3<br />

the Mall event held on the grounds <strong>of</strong> the State Capitol. We had two tables with artifacts on display. Harry<br />

and Mary Hensell and I attended. Rick White and Jon Falk helped transport our artifacts to and from the<br />

event. Numerous other <strong>museum</strong>s also participated, and the event always gives your <strong>museum</strong> great visibility.<br />

The <strong>museum</strong> received a $1700.00 grant from the Arizona Historical Society which we used to purchase a<br />

firepro<strong>of</strong> lateral file cabinet. We preserve important documents in it such as the original muster rolls <strong>of</strong> the 1 st<br />

Arizona Volunteer Infantry. We really appreciate the continued support from AHS. We did not ask for a grant<br />

this year since the <strong>museum</strong> was still closed. On March 2 and 3, I attended the Arizona Library, Archives, and<br />

Public Records Convocation in Tucson. It was informative about records collections, preservation, and conservation.<br />

In April, three Board members (George Notarpole, Trudie Cooke, and me) attended the Museums<br />

Association <strong>of</strong> Arizona (MAA) annual convention in Wickenburg. I spoke about the creation, maintenance,<br />

and operation <strong>of</strong> the Arizona Military Museum. The convention was very informative about <strong>museum</strong> governance<br />

and procedures.<br />

Also, in April your Board <strong>of</strong> Directors was selected for the year. The Officers and Board <strong>of</strong> Directors are<br />

Col. Joseph Abodeely (USA Ret.)-President; BG Thomas Quarelli (ANG Ret.)-Vice President; LTC Carolyn<br />

Feller (USAR Ret.)-Secretary; Klaus Foerst-Treasurer; and the Directors are Jean McColgin, Anna Kroger,<br />

Dan Mardian, CSM Harry Hensell (Ret.), Mary Hensell, Rick White, Eugene Cox, George Notarpole, Jon<br />

Falk, Robert Lutes, and Trudie Cooke.<br />

MG David Rataczak serves as an ex-<strong>of</strong>ficio member <strong>of</strong> the Board <strong>of</strong> Directors. He will be retiring this<br />

year, and we wish to thank him for the support he has given us in the past.<br />

While the <strong>museum</strong> has been closed, Board members installed slat walls in the display cases to facilitate<br />

hanging artifacts from the walls. We have conducted inventories <strong>of</strong> USPFO weapons and vehicles, and also <strong>of</strong><br />

our own weapons and artifacts. Trudie Cooke and Nancy Goodson have been working on the library; and<br />

George, Nancy, Trudie, and I have been working on specific inventories <strong>of</strong> the items displayed in each display<br />

case.<br />

I attended a MAA workshop on August 18 in Tucson at AHS about the changing population growth in Arizona<br />

and how it will affect <strong>museum</strong>s. Arizona will double its population by 2030 with many more retirees and<br />

Hispanics. There will be a rise <strong>of</strong> the “creative class” which will be 30% <strong>of</strong> the population with 50% <strong>of</strong> the<br />

population’s income.<br />

On Saturday, November 8, we will celebrate Veterans’ Day. We will have artifacts from the <strong>museum</strong> on<br />

display in the quadrangle and <strong>military</strong> motor vehicles, provided by the two <strong>military</strong> motor vehicle clubs in the<br />

Valley. We will also have a book sale. Come and visit with us. We need the morale booster. Of course, admission<br />

is free.<br />

We are looking forward to the Arizona’s centennial celebration in 2012, and we are hoping to be a focal<br />

point <strong>of</strong> interest because <strong>of</strong> our portrayal <strong>of</strong> Arizona’s <strong>military</strong> history. We are applying for the Arizona Centennial<br />

Commission’s Legacy Project certification. We are pleased and proud to honor Arizona’s veterans,<br />

militia and National Guard members who have served in the past and present. We are extremely pleased to<br />

have guest articles in this Courier from Marshall Trimble, the Official State Historian, Jim Turner, the Historian<br />

from the Arizona Historical Society, and John Langellier, Director, Sharlot Hall Museum.<br />

The Officers and Directors <strong>of</strong> the Historical Society have kept the <strong>museum</strong> going, and we would like to<br />

continue to do so. We do it voluntarily to provide the Arizona National Guard and the public one <strong>of</strong> the best<br />

<strong>military</strong> <strong>museum</strong>s in the United States. We could not do what we do without your support and the support <strong>of</strong><br />

MG Rataczak and his staff. As the state’s centennial is approaching, the <strong>museum</strong> is gearing up to be the showcase<br />

for the Arizona National Guard. We hope you’ll help.<br />

Joseph E. Abodeely<br />

Colonel (USA Ret)<br />

President, AZNG Historical Society


Courier page 4<br />

Geronimo’s Last Campaign<br />

By Marshall Trimble, Official Arizona State Historian<br />

There were stretches <strong>of</strong> country picturesque<br />

to look upon and capable <strong>of</strong> cultivation, especially<br />

with irrigation; and other expanses not<br />

a bit more fertile than so manmade brickyards,<br />

where all was desolation, the home <strong>of</strong><br />

the cactus and the coyote. Arizona was in<br />

those days separated from “God’s country”<br />

by a space <strong>of</strong> more than fifteen hundred<br />

miles, without a railroad, and the <strong>of</strong>ficer or<br />

soldier who once got out there rarely returned<br />

for years. (p. 3)<br />

….During this campaign we were <strong>of</strong>ten<br />

obliged to leave the warm valleys in the<br />

morning and climb to the higher altitudes and<br />

go into bivouac upon summits where the<br />

snow was hip deep, as on the Matitzal (sic.),<br />

the Mogollon plateau, and the Sierra Ancha.<br />

To add to the discomfort, the pine was so<br />

thoroughly soaked through with snow and<br />

rain it would not burn, and unless cedar could<br />

be found, the command was in bad luck. (p.<br />

185)<br />

Captain John G. Bourke, On the Border<br />

with Crook, 1971<br />

In the years following the Civil War, the Frontier Army was<br />

charged with the thankless task <strong>of</strong> keeping the peace in the<br />

West. That meant not only protecting the whites from the Indians<br />

but protecting the Indians from the Whites. Playing peacemaker,<br />

the Army was caught between a rock and a hard place.<br />

There were some 2,600 soldiers to police about 200,000 Indians.<br />

Many times the natives were better armed than the soldiers.<br />

The Army was also caught in the middle between eastern<br />

politicians and activists who believed the Army was too harsh<br />

in its treatment <strong>of</strong> Indians and the westerners who insisted the<br />

Army mollycoddled the natives.<br />

Deaths resulting from such diseases as cholera and yellow<br />

fever killed far more than those resulting from fighting Indians.<br />

Between the years 1860 and 1886, 1,993 soldiers were killed or<br />

wounded in the Indian Wars. In 1886, 1,217 soldiers died from<br />

cholera alone.<br />

Harsh living conditions, fatigue, poor pay, poor rations, and<br />

little appreciation from his fellow countrymen were the grim<br />

prospects the soldiers faced. They were <strong>of</strong>ten sent into battle<br />

with obsolete weapons and equipment as well as under strength<br />

in numbers. Desertion, alcoholism and suicide rates were high<br />

on the isolated <strong>military</strong> posts. Loneliness and boredom was the<br />

soldier’s constant companion. Typical meals on the posts consisted<br />

<strong>of</strong> such culinary delights as beef hash, dry bread, and<br />

c<strong>of</strong>fee for breakfast. Evening meals were just simply bread and<br />

c<strong>of</strong>fee.<br />

Punishment was harsh especially for acts such as drunkenness<br />

and desertion. Yet these men became good soldiers. Under<br />

the pr<strong>of</strong>essionalism <strong>of</strong> the corps <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>ficers and noncommissioned<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficers, along with the rigid discipline instilled,<br />

Geronimo, circa 1886.<br />

the small Spartan army made up largely <strong>of</strong> Irish and German<br />

immigrants became veteran, reliable and even efficient. It was<br />

admired and understood by foreign <strong>military</strong> observers who ventured<br />

west to observe them.<br />

Following General George Crook’s successful 1872-1873<br />

campaign against the Apache in the rugged mountains <strong>of</strong> central<br />

Arizona, the tribes were located on reservations after agreeing<br />

to the federal government’s promise to provide provisions.<br />

Trouble began almost immediately after the Chiricahua were<br />

relocated to San Carlos in 1876, and thrown in with other<br />

Apache groups who regarded them as enemies. Also, leaders<br />

like Juh, Chatto, Chihuahua, and Victorio were unhappy with<br />

reservation life and continued bolting the reservation, leading<br />

raids in Arizona and Mexico. This initiated the so-called<br />

“renegade” period in the Apache Wars where soldiers would go<br />

in pursuit <strong>of</strong> those who left the reservation.<br />

Two issues led to the final outbreak. The Apache men had a<br />

custom <strong>of</strong> biting <strong>of</strong>f the nose <strong>of</strong> the unfaithful wife, a practice<br />

General Crook had strictly forbidden. They insisted he had no<br />

business interfering with their customs. The other was the<br />

drinking <strong>of</strong> tiswin, a beer made <strong>of</strong> fermented corn. Mangus’s<br />

wife was a maker <strong>of</strong> excellent tiswin and she hated Whites. She<br />

goaded her husband, the son <strong>of</strong> the legendary chief, Mangas<br />

Colorados, constantly. Chihuahua was one <strong>of</strong> her best customers.<br />

He liked to drink and complain but wasn’t too interested in<br />

bolting the reservation again. The consummate malcontent<br />

Geronimo took advantage <strong>of</strong> the situation to stir up trouble.<br />

In May, 1885, a group <strong>of</strong> Apache decided to test the policy<br />

against tiswin. They got drunk and confronted the <strong>of</strong>ficer in<br />

charge, Lieutenant Britton Davis. Davis informed them he was<br />

wiring General Crook for instructions. The wire was sent to a<br />

Captain Francis Pierce; an <strong>of</strong>ficer new to the area failed to<br />

grasp the gravity <strong>of</strong> the situation and determined it wasn’t important<br />

enough to bother the general. Meanwhile, the Apache<br />

grew restless wondering what kind <strong>of</strong> wrath the general would<br />

bring upon them for their drunken binge and bolted once again<br />

for Mexico.<br />

Thus began the last campaign to end the Apache Wars. In<br />

January, 1886, Captain Emmett Crawford defeated Geronimo


and band in the Sierra Madre. Two months later the Apache<br />

leader met with General Crook at Canon de los Embudos, and<br />

agreed to surrender. Thus began the last campaign to end the<br />

Apache Wars. In January, 1886, Captain Emmett Crawford<br />

defeated Geronimo and band in the Sierra Madre. Two months<br />

later the Apache leader met with General Crook at Canon de los<br />

Embudos, and agreed to surrender. That night bootleggers<br />

came into the Apache camp and sold them booze, at the same<br />

time telling them the soldiers planned to kill them once they<br />

were in Arizona.<br />

Geronimo and warriors bolted once again causing Crook’s<br />

superior in Washington, General Phil Sheridan, also his roommate<br />

at West Point, to suggest he was placing too much trust in<br />

the Apache. Crook asked to be replaced and General Nelson<br />

Miles was sent to relieve him.<br />

Camels in the Southwest Desert?<br />

Photograph and story by Marshall Trimble, Official Arizona<br />

State Historian<br />

Arizona has always been a place where bizarre events were<br />

accepted as normal. But perhaps the strangest <strong>of</strong> all occurred in<br />

1857 when a caravan <strong>of</strong> camels looking like something out <strong>of</strong><br />

the Arabian Nights trekked across northern Arizona.<br />

At the time, the federal government was planning to survey<br />

a wagon road along the 35 th Parallel from New Mexico to California<br />

and wanted to test the feasibility <strong>of</strong> using camels as<br />

beasts <strong>of</strong> burden. The camel experiment was the pet project <strong>of</strong><br />

Secretary <strong>of</strong> War, Jefferson Davis, who believed that camels<br />

were the solution for transporting cargo across the arid lands <strong>of</strong><br />

the American West.<br />

The man chosen to lead the experiment was a colorful adventurer<br />

named Lieutenant Edward F. “Ned” Beale <strong>of</strong> the Army<br />

Corps <strong>of</strong> Topographical Engineers. Beale, a former Navy <strong>of</strong>ficer,<br />

had been a hero at the Battle <strong>of</strong> San Pasquel in California<br />

during the Mexican war when he and Kit Carson sneaked<br />

through the enemy lines to bring a relief force from San Diego<br />

to General Kearny’s Army <strong>of</strong> the West, under siege by Mexican<br />

forces.<br />

Following the discovery <strong>of</strong> gold in California in 1848, Beale<br />

took a sack full <strong>of</strong> gold nuggets and traveled across Mexico<br />

disguised as a Mexican. He eventually reached Washington<br />

D.C. and presented the gold to President James Polk, proving<br />

that rumors <strong>of</strong> the gold strike in California were indeed true.<br />

Courier page 5<br />

The campaign was nearly over by the time Miles arrived.<br />

He continued Crook’s policy <strong>of</strong> using Apache scouts, durable<br />

pack trains and relentless pursuit. The Army also rounded up<br />

the Chiricahua on reservations and shipped them to Florida.<br />

That summer five thousand U.S. troops or some 20% <strong>of</strong> the<br />

U.S. Army were chasing less than two dozen warriors. In August<br />

Lieutenant Charles Gatewood, an <strong>of</strong>ficer known and respected<br />

by Geronimo, Tom Horn, along with two Apache<br />

scouts named Martine and Kayitah undertook a dangerous mission<br />

to Geronimo’s camp. They held a parley with Geronimo<br />

and his band. After some haggling, Gatewood dealt the warriors<br />

his ace card. Their relatives had been exiled to Florida and<br />

if they wanted to see them again they would have to surrender.<br />

On September 3, 1886, the wily war chief surrendered and the<br />

Apache Wars were finally over.<br />

Beale’s Camel expedition nearly a decade later was<br />

unique<br />

in the annals <strong>of</strong> exploration in the American West. The<br />

camel’s amazing ability to travel great distances without<br />

water, and thriving on natural forage along the trail made<br />

them a natural for hauling cargo.<br />

Although Beale championed his illustrious camels, referring<br />

to them as the “noblest brute alive,” his muleskinners<br />

scorned them. They were especially upset when entire<br />

herds <strong>of</strong> mules stampeded at the mere site <strong>of</strong> the homely<br />

creatures. The camels propensity to be extremely stubborn<br />

and spit at the muleskinners certainly didn’t endear them to<br />

their American handlers. The problem handling the animals<br />

was solved when camel drivers were imported from the<br />

Middle East. A Syrian named Hadji Ali was the most famous.<br />

His name was quickly Americanized to “Hi Jolly.”<br />

The camels passed a supreme test when Beale was challenged<br />

to pit them against the packers’ mules on a 60-mile endurance<br />

trek. Using six camels against twelve mules, a 2.5 ton<br />

load was divided among the camels, and a like amount was<br />

loaded on two Army wagons, drawn by six mules. The camels<br />

finished the trip in two and a half days while the mules took<br />

four days.<br />

Beale and his camels managed to successfully open the<br />

wagon road along the 35 th Parallel. That road later became the<br />

storied Route 66 and is today Interstate 40. He persisted in<br />

naming the various rivers, passes and mountains after his fellow<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficers in the U.S. Navy. The names usually didn’t stick and if<br />

they had, most <strong>of</strong> the geographical features in western Arizona<br />

would today sound like a battleship’s roster.<br />

Hi Jolly remained in Arizona, got married and became a<br />

prospector. He is memorialized on a pyramid-shaped monument,<br />

topped <strong>of</strong>f with a lone camel, at Quartzsite, Arizona.<br />

This brief, but romantic event in Arizona history came to an<br />

end just before the Civil War began and was overshadowed by<br />

the great events that took place in the East. As for the camels,<br />

they were turned loose to roam the deserts <strong>of</strong> western Arizona.<br />

One, “Red Ghost,” became the stuff <strong>of</strong> legends. When pranksters<br />

tied a dead body on his back the animal went insane and<br />

attacked a woman, killing her. Over the next few years the<br />

camel, with a skeleton tied to its back, was seen at various parts<br />

<strong>of</strong> Arizona, causing havoc when it came around humans and<br />

became the subject <strong>of</strong> many a campfire story.


Courier page 6<br />

By Trudie Cooke<br />

By Trudie Cooke<br />

Down Range: To<br />

Iraq and Back<br />

speaks to the hearts<br />

<strong>of</strong> our <strong>military</strong> men<br />

and women<br />

Down Range: To Iraq and Back, by Bridget C. Cantrell,<br />

Ph.D. and Chuck Dean, Word Smith Publishing, Seattle, WA<br />

98168, 2005, is a small paperback book that <strong>of</strong>fers help to all<br />

the men and women who have served in combat.<br />

This book is a surprise in such a compact form. The message<br />

is timely, and to some veterans <strong>of</strong> past wars, long overdue.<br />

Down Range is dedicated to bringing the troops home and addresses<br />

the challenges <strong>of</strong> the re-integration process from combatant<br />

to civilian.<br />

On the back cover is written, “Bridget Cantrell, Ph.D. and<br />

Vietnam veteran, Chuck Dean have joined forces to present this<br />

vital information and resource manual for both returning troops<br />

and their loved ones. Here you will find answers, explanations,<br />

and insights as to why so many combat veterans suffer from<br />

flashbacks, depression, fits <strong>of</strong> rage, nightmares, anxiety, emotional<br />

numbing, and other troubling aspects <strong>of</strong> Post-Traumatic<br />

Stress Disorder (PTSD).”<br />

The Springfield 1903 Rifle and<br />

those daring Bushmasters<br />

An interesting comment on the famed Bushmaster’s M1903<br />

rifle used during World War II:<br />

Briefly, the 158th Infantry became the 158th Regiment<br />

Combat Team and separated from the 45th Division <strong>of</strong> Oklahoma<br />

on Sep 16, 1940. They spent a year in the Panama Canal<br />

Zone where they earned their nickname “Bushmasters.” By Jan<br />

16, 1943, they were at Port Moresby, New Guinea. They remained<br />

in the Philippines for the remainder <strong>of</strong> the war.<br />

They were equipped with the M1903 Springfield rifle prior<br />

to departure for the Panama Canal Zone. While in the Canal<br />

Zone , they modified their issued M1903 rifle. Lt. Col. William<br />

S. Brophy, USAR, Ret., says in his book The Springfield 1903<br />

Rifles, (1985), “Frequently brave souls in the <strong>military</strong> perform<br />

unauthorized modifications to standard equipment. However,<br />

the fear <strong>of</strong> the discipline meted out, and the possible attachment<br />

<strong>of</strong> pay for the cost <strong>of</strong> the item, prevented many worthwhile and<br />

inventive ideas from being tried….However, if high authority<br />

blessed the project, it was not uncommon for ideas to be tried<br />

and, in some cases, put to use….A good example <strong>of</strong> equipment<br />

Some excepts from the book are:<br />

“War forces its participants to go beyond the paradigms <strong>of</strong><br />

ordinary life, pushing them beyond what one would think are<br />

humanly possible. When we assertively take the life <strong>of</strong> another<br />

human being we are catapulted far beyond the range <strong>of</strong> normal<br />

human behavior. As terrible as killing is, it is still not the worst<br />

outcome <strong>of</strong> war. Cruelty to the souls <strong>of</strong> the soldiers who fight<br />

is war’s greatest casualty….<br />

At the end <strong>of</strong> each battle, and when the war is over, the images<br />

and sounds <strong>of</strong> combat are still present in the minds and<br />

hearts <strong>of</strong> those who engaged in it—and these will never go<br />

away….Now comes the full realization that you willingly participated<br />

in something so unnatural to the mind and<br />

spirit” (page 24 and 25).<br />

“We should never again blame the individual soldiers (like<br />

so many did during the Vietnam War) for fighting in a war that<br />

was decided upon by government leaders” (page 25).<br />

This book also provides contact sources for help that include<br />

such places as the Veterans Administration, the Vietnam<br />

Veterans <strong>of</strong> America, the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline,<br />

the National Veterans Foundation, and many other groups that<br />

specifically handle PTSD.<br />

The whole point <strong>of</strong> this book is to be an educational guide, a<br />

spiritual guide, a source guide—all rolled into one small paperback<br />

book. The warrior and his family are not alone. Help is<br />

out there.<br />

This book may be obtained from the Arizona National<br />

Guard Personnel Readiness Center, Frank Sandell, Transition<br />

Assistance Advisor, Papago Park Military Reservation, 5636 E<br />

McDowell Rd, Phoenix, AZ 85008 at 602-629-4421. It is free<br />

while supplies last.<br />

for a particular use in a specific area is the Bushmaster ’03 rifle.”<br />

(page 82)<br />

“By order <strong>of</strong> Major General Robert H. Lewis, Commanding<br />

General <strong>of</strong> the Panama Mobile Force Command in 1942, Model<br />

1903 rifles were shortened six inches for use by the Jungle Security<br />

Platoon [the Bushmasters] while conducting missions in<br />

heavy jungle foliage.” (page 83)<br />

Alterations were done by the Ordnance Shops in the Canal<br />

Zone once permission was granted by the Army Chief <strong>of</strong> Ordnance.<br />

The altered M1903 was used by the Bushmasters in the<br />

Canal Zone and also in the Philippines.<br />

From The Springfield 1903 Rifle, William S. Brophy, 1985,<br />

page 82.


The 1st Arizona Infantry fights Apaches:<br />

Arizona Indian Wars 1865 to 1866<br />

By Jim Turner, Historian for the Arizona Historical<br />

Society—Tucson, AZ<br />

(Editor’s note: With the Civil War still going on<br />

and Carleton still fighting the Navajos, the U.S. War<br />

<strong>Department</strong> authorized Governor John Noble Goodwin<br />

<strong>of</strong> Arizona to raise five companies <strong>of</strong> Arizona<br />

Volunteers in 1864. Recruitment was delayed for a<br />

year, but by the fall <strong>of</strong> 1865, more than 350 men had<br />

been issued into service under the command <strong>of</strong> nine<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficers. The overwhelming majority was Mexicans,<br />

many <strong>of</strong> them from Sonora, or O'odham and Maricopas<br />

from the Gila River villages, who had grown up<br />

fighting Yavapais and Apaches, as had their fathers<br />

and grandfathers. Many never received shoes or<br />

warm clothing. They lived in hovels and marched for<br />

days on beef jerky and parched cornmeal. They carried<br />

.54-caliber (14 mm) rifles with plenty <strong>of</strong> ammunition,<br />

in addition to bows, arrows, and war clubs.<br />

For the next year, these frontiersmen guarded wagon<br />

trains between Prescott and La Paz and campaigned<br />

relentlessly across central Arizona. The following<br />

excerpt and description <strong>of</strong> the 1 st Arizona Volunteer<br />

Infantry was presented by Jim Turner, Historian for<br />

the Arizona Historical Society—Tucson—in an article,<br />

“Pima Villages”, the Journal <strong>of</strong> Arizona History<br />

1998. The article was too lengthy to include in the<br />

Courier, but we highly recommend that the reader<br />

seek out and read the entire article to learn some<br />

important Arizona history.)<br />

Governor John N. Goodwin, 1863—1866, received<br />

permission from the United States Provost<br />

Marshal James B. Fry to “raise within the Territory<br />

<strong>of</strong> Arizona one regiment <strong>of</strong> Volunteer Infantry to<br />

serve for three years or the duration <strong>of</strong> the war.” The<br />

War <strong>Department</strong> intended that the recruitment <strong>of</strong> native<br />

Arizonans would supplement the California Volunteers,<br />

who hesitated to go on long scouting missions<br />

against the Apaches because their Civil War<br />

enlistment would soon be up. The Arizona Volunteers<br />

served for one year, and gave Mexicans, Pimas<br />

and Maricopas an opportunity to avenge the losses<br />

they received at the hands <strong>of</strong> the Apaches while acquiring<br />

much-needed guns from the government.<br />

Courier page 7<br />

Goodwin appointed Thomas Ewing, a teamster<br />

from the Pima Villages, to recruit Maricopa Indians,<br />

and former sergeant John D. Walker to recruit the<br />

Pimas. (This is not the same John Walker who was<br />

previously Indian Agent.) On October 2, 1865, First<br />

Lieutenant William Tompkins <strong>of</strong> the Third California<br />

Infantry arrived at Maricopa Wells and commissioned<br />

First Lieutenant Ewing, Second Lieutenant<br />

Charles Reidt, who was fluent in the Maricopa language,<br />

and Captain Juan Chevereah, chief <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Maricopas. He also mustered in 94 Maricopa recruits,<br />

designated as Company B, Arizona Volunteer<br />

Infantry. By May 16, 1866 there were 103 men in the<br />

company. John D. Walker was commissioned as first<br />

lieutenant and William A. Hancock as second lieutenant<br />

<strong>of</strong> Company C, made up <strong>of</strong> Pima Indians.<br />

Their chief, Antonio Azul, was made a sergeant and<br />

89 Pimas were recruited to fill out the company. Five<br />

more Pimas were added later at Sacaton.<br />

A unique Arizona character, John D. Walker was<br />

part Wyandotte Indian, born in Nauvoo, Illinois<br />

about 1840. He arrived at the Pima villages as a<br />

wagon master in the California Volunteers, and was<br />

charged with expediting the distribution <strong>of</strong> the Pimas’<br />

surplus wheat and corn to California Volunteer<br />

posts as far away as the Rio Grande. When his enlistment<br />

was up, Walker married a Pima woman and<br />

settled in the Pima village <strong>of</strong> Sacaton. Quick to learn,<br />

he compiled the first written grammar <strong>of</strong> their language<br />

and became a leader in Pima councils. He<br />

studied medicine and was something <strong>of</strong> a scientist.<br />

Such a background makes the other side <strong>of</strong> his character<br />

even more unusual. According to historian<br />

James McClintock, "It is said that when they were in<br />

the field you could not tell him from the other Indians.<br />

He dressed like them, with nothing but a breechcloth,<br />

and whooped and yelled like his Indian comrades."<br />

The native Arizonans enlisted just as Apache raiding<br />

reached new heights, and their orders — to destroy<br />

Apache camps, crops and supplies and kill resisters<br />

— coincided with their attitudes toward their<br />

traditional enemies. The Indian soldiers received a<br />

blue blouse, trimmed in red for the Maricopas and<br />

blue for the Pimas, one pair <strong>of</strong> blue pants, one pair <strong>of</strong><br />

shoes and one yard <strong>of</strong> flannel for a headdress. Most


Courier page 8<br />

<strong>of</strong> them wore “teguas” — shoes <strong>of</strong> untanned hide<br />

with broad soles turned up at the toes with a hole to<br />

admit air and remove dirt. Scouts were <strong>of</strong>ten carried<br />

out on foot with packs containing a canteen, a blanket,<br />

and some dried beef and pinole, a food made <strong>of</strong><br />

one part sugar to two parts roasted ground corn or<br />

wheat mixed with water. The Indians were expected<br />

to provide their own horses, but allowances were<br />

sometimes made for feed. Although these were the<br />

intended provisions, circumstances did not always<br />

afford them and the Indians <strong>of</strong>ten endured the cold<br />

without benefit <strong>of</strong> warm clothes, bedding or shoes.<br />

The Pimas and Maricopas were used to hardship,<br />

however; they were familiar with the country and<br />

knew the Apaches.<br />

The two new volunteer companies left Maricopa<br />

Wells with Colonel Clarence E. Bennett’s California<br />

Volunteers on September 4, 1865 to establish a fort<br />

seven miles north <strong>of</strong> the confluence <strong>of</strong> the Verde and<br />

Salt rivers. Both companies helped construct Camp<br />

McDowell to protect farms along the rivers from<br />

Apaches. The Tonto and Pinal Apaches inhabited the<br />

Tonto Basin, bordered by the Mazatzal and Sierra<br />

Ancha Mountains on the east and west and the<br />

Mogollon Rim to the north. These were some <strong>of</strong> the<br />

last Apache tribes to be subdued, and the Arizona<br />

Volunteers became their first considerable foe. The<br />

Indians at Camp McDowell lived in brush shelters.<br />

Military reports said their morale was high and they<br />

were allowed to return to their villages almost as <strong>of</strong>ten<br />

as they pleased. Although Hispanic and Anglo<br />

volunteers suffered various forms <strong>of</strong> typhoid from<br />

continuous attacks <strong>of</strong> fever caused by rain and humidity,<br />

not a single individual from Indian companies<br />

B or C was reported sick on post returns.<br />

The Indian volunteers began their first foray on<br />

September 8, 1865, led by Lieutenant Reidt. They<br />

traveled northeast for several days into the Tonto Basin.<br />

Maricopa guides took them up the east side <strong>of</strong><br />

the Mazatzal Mountains up Tonto Creek, 110 miles<br />

up steep banks, across canyons, and through arroyos<br />

thick with underbrush. “It was a trying, sorry march,<br />

and the animals and men suffered from the cactus.”<br />

When one Pima was accidentally shot in the hand, all<br />

but fifteen returned to camp with him. The volunteers<br />

eventually surprised an Apache ranchería just<br />

east <strong>of</strong> Payson. One Apache was killed, several were<br />

wounded and their crops and houses were burned.<br />

The Indian volunteers proved their valor in battle<br />

after battle. On October 15, 1865, Cuchavenashak,<br />

a Company B Maricopa charged an Apache. The<br />

Apache's first arrow went through his horse's ear, the<br />

second hit the Maricopa's belt plate and the third hit<br />

him in the forehead and glanced <strong>of</strong>f, causing a flesh<br />

wound. Cuchavenashak leaped <strong>of</strong>f his horse,<br />

clinched the Apache to him and killed him. This<br />

alarmed a ranchería <strong>of</strong> about 20 families <strong>of</strong> Apaches<br />

nearby. A volley <strong>of</strong> 100 shots were fired into the<br />

Apaches as they retreated.<br />

The Arizona Volunteers were an experiment in<br />

cultural coexistence. For the good <strong>of</strong> the mission, the<br />

Indians were allowed to practice their traditional war<br />

customs without interference from white soldiers. On<br />

March 6, 1866, Lt. Ewing took a party near the Polos<br />

Blancos [sic] Mountains, on Rattlesnake Creek “The<br />

night being quite dark, it was decded to await the rising<br />

<strong>of</strong> the moon. During the wait, the Indian soldiers<br />

consulted a prophet or tobacco mancer. A circle was<br />

formed around the prophet who began to smoke<br />

"cigarettes." As soon as one was consumed another<br />

was furnished him by an attendant. After some time,<br />

he began to tremble and fell "dead" (stupefied). He<br />

lay there for several minutes, during which time not<br />

a sound was heard from command. When he arose,<br />

he said that his spirit had followed the trail, that the<br />

command was on, towards the "Massasahl" and there<br />

under the peak it saw two large rancherías with a<br />

great many warriors. His spirit then followed the trail<br />

north, where it found a ranchería that had been abandoned<br />

because <strong>of</strong> the death <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the occupants.”<br />

When he finished, the Indians slept. When the moon<br />

had risen high in the sky, Walker and Ewing led their<br />

men up the mountain in search <strong>of</strong> the ranchería.


Halfway up the mountain they found an abandoned<br />

ranchería and later a large camp <strong>of</strong> Apaches, just as<br />

the tobacco mancer predicted.<br />

On March 27, Lieutenant Walker led the largest<br />

expedition <strong>of</strong> Arizona Volunteers on record; an estimated<br />

260 Papagos and Pimas and 40 Maricopas<br />

from Company B left the Pima villages. Those from<br />

Company B left the Pima villages. Those without<br />

rifles or muskets fashioned war clubs while they established<br />

a temporary supply depot on Tonto Creek.<br />

In a fight four days later, 25 Apaches were killed and<br />

16 taken prisoner. Three Pimas were wounded, one<br />

<strong>of</strong> whom eventually died. Because they were in<br />

Apache country, the Pima warrior’s body was burned<br />

along with the mourners’ clothes instead <strong>of</strong> his own<br />

belongings as was the custom in the villages. Although<br />

most warriors left the Pima villages well clad,<br />

many returned naked. This is also probably the expedition<br />

where the miners were shocked by the smashing<br />

<strong>of</strong> heads. Conner relates that the Pimas would lift<br />

a heavy stone above their heads and drop it on a dead<br />

or wounded Apache, crushing the skull <strong>of</strong> their enemy.<br />

Sometimes they placed the head <strong>of</strong> the victim<br />

on a flat rock to suitably cave in his face, perhaps so<br />

it would not be recognized in the next world. The<br />

Apaches, possibly learning it from the Pimas, followed<br />

this custom. Conner said he was more disgusted<br />

that the Whites looked on with approval, musing<br />

that “savage civilized men are the most monstrous<br />

<strong>of</strong> all monsters.”<br />

In late Aug, 1866, Colonel Charles S. Lovell became<br />

commander <strong>of</strong> District <strong>of</strong> Arizona. He did not<br />

appreciate the Pima and Maricopa custom <strong>of</strong> living<br />

in their villages when not in the field and not being<br />

subject to the post commanders’ orders. General Mason<br />

had promised the Indians that they could do as<br />

they pleased, and the spirit <strong>of</strong> cooperation had served<br />

all parties admirably. As was <strong>of</strong>ten the case with<br />

army/Indian relations, just as the vastly different cultures<br />

began to understand each other, personnel<br />

changed, previous arrangements were nullified and<br />

once again the Indians had to adapt. Official feelings<br />

were not unanimous on the subject <strong>of</strong> Indian soldiers,<br />

however. In May, while still commander at Fort<br />

McDowell, Colonel Bennett asked the Arizona’s Adjutant<br />

General to extend the volunteer enlistment or<br />

create a regular native regiment. If these options<br />

proved unworkable, he proposed that the volunteers<br />

be allowed to keep their arms when discharged so<br />

they could continue fighting Apaches effectively.<br />

Courier page 9<br />

1907 Portrait <strong>of</strong> Antonio Azul, last hereditary chief <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Pima Indians. Died at Sacaton, AZ, October 20, 1910 at<br />

the age <strong>of</strong> about 76. He was a 2nd Lieutenant, 1st Arizona<br />

Infantry, Company C, National Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona<br />

during the 1866 Indian Wars. Photograph courtesy <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Pima-Maricopa Indian Community.<br />

At Fort McDowell on September 11, 1866, because<br />

<strong>of</strong> the legalities <strong>of</strong> retaining them, Maricopa<br />

Company B was discharged from service by First<br />

Lieutenant Ewing and now Captain Juan Chevereah.<br />

The records indicated that Maricopas McGill, Yose,<br />

Goshe Zep, and Duke were killed in battle. The same<br />

day, Pima Company C was mustered out by Captain<br />

John D. Walker. Hownik Mawkum, Juan Lewis and<br />

Au Papat were Pimas listed as killed in battle. All the<br />

men were allotted $50 pay and allowed to keep their<br />

firearms and equipment. Many volunteers who believed<br />

they would get no pay found that all at once<br />

they had more money than they had ever had at any<br />

time in their lives. In honor <strong>of</strong> the Arizona Volunteers,<br />

in the fall <strong>of</strong> 1866 the Third Arizona Territorial<br />

Legislature passed a memorial for their outstanding<br />

service.<br />

The services <strong>of</strong> Arizona Volunteers were definitely<br />

missed. In November <strong>of</strong> 1866, General<br />

McDowell let it be known that any Indians enlisting<br />

as scouts would be treated as when they served in the<br />

Volunteers. They would not be required to drill or<br />

fight with army methods and could stay in their villages<br />

when not on patrol. Pimas and Maricopas continued<br />

to work with the <strong>military</strong>, but the practice<br />

peaked in 1869 as more Apaches became willing to<br />

serve as scouts.


Courier page 10<br />

Buffalo Soldiers served in Arizona during the Indian Wars <strong>of</strong> 1888<br />

By John Langellier, Director, Shalot Hall Museum, Prescott,<br />

AZ<br />

Last February at the Museums<br />

on the Mall event, I was<br />

talking to John Langellier,<br />

Director, Sharlot Hall Museum,<br />

about the actions <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Buffalo Soldiers in Arizona. I<br />

told him that some people told<br />

me that they never were in<br />

Arizona during the Indian<br />

Wars era. John, who is an<br />

expert <strong>military</strong> historian, said<br />

he would send me some information.<br />

Here is what he sent:<br />

The 10th U.S. Cavalry<br />

regiment transferred from the<br />

<strong>Department</strong> <strong>of</strong> Texas to the<br />

<strong>Department</strong> <strong>of</strong> Arizona in 1886 with the regimental headquarters<br />

at Ft. Whipple under Colonel Benjamin Grierson<br />

and the various companies assigned to forts all over the<br />

territory including Forts Apache and Grant. The 10th participated<br />

in the final Apache campaigns, and the name<br />

“Buffalo Soldiers” first appeared in print for a widespread<br />

audience when Fredrick Remington wrote and illustrated<br />

an article in Arizona in 1888 titled “Scout with the Buffalo<br />

Soldiers.” The 24th Infantry also reported to Arizona<br />

soon aft the arrival <strong>of</strong> the 10th, and two <strong>of</strong> their men received<br />

the Medal <strong>of</strong> Honor for the incident cited below.<br />

Thus, black troops have been stationed continuously in<br />

Arizona since 1886 and continue to play a role in the<br />

armed forces here to this day.<br />

He also sent a story written by Paul L. Allen published<br />

in the Arizona Republic on July 29, 2006:”Lookin' Back:<br />

Safford-area Treasury Ambush Stuff <strong>of</strong> Legends”:<br />

When you mix an audacious crime with goodly a<br />

amount <strong>of</strong> loot and a sizable dollop <strong>of</strong> whodunit, you've<br />

got a ready-made Old West legend.<br />

Such is the Wham payroll robbery <strong>of</strong> May 11, 1889,<br />

which bears the added distinction <strong>of</strong> being likely the most<br />

frequently mispronounced incident name in the Southwest.<br />

It is pronounced Wham (like "bomb") and not<br />

Wham (like "Bam!").<br />

Here's what happened:<br />

Army Maj. Joseph W. Wham and an escort <strong>of</strong> 11 Buffalo<br />

Soldiers from the 24th Infantry and 10th Cavalry were en<br />

route from Fort Grant to Fort Thomas, but northwest <strong>of</strong><br />

present-day Safford on the Gila River.<br />

Wham rode in an ambulance that also carried a strongbox<br />

containing $28,345 in gold and silver coins, much <strong>of</strong><br />

it still in Treasury <strong>Department</strong> sacks. An escort wagon<br />

followed the ambulance.<br />

They were forced to stop at Cedar Springs because a<br />

large boulder blocked the roadway<br />

where it passed through a<br />

narrow defile. Men in the escort<br />

set about moving the obstacle,<br />

but were immediately<br />

fired upon from both sides <strong>of</strong><br />

the road. Eight were wounded<br />

in the melee.<br />

Their attackers numbered -<br />

depending on whose account is<br />

to be believed - from eight to<br />

20.<br />

Wham, in reporting the incident<br />

to the Secretary <strong>of</strong> War,<br />

wrote that the "party was am-<br />

“Proud to Serve,” oil painting by Don Stivers, Waterford, VA,<br />

bushed and fired into by a number<br />

<strong>of</strong> armed brigands, since<br />

estimated by U.S. Marshal (W.K.) Meade at from twelve<br />

to fifteen, but to myself and entire escort, two noncommissioned<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficers and nine privates, at fifteen to<br />

twenty."<br />

He indicated a signal shot was followed by a barrage<br />

<strong>of</strong> gunfire, and a battle lasting more than 30 minutes ensued.<br />

Two soldiers involved, one shot in the abdomen but<br />

continuing to fire until shot again through both arms, and<br />

another who, though wounded, walked and crawled<br />

nearly two miles to Cottonwood Ranch to give the alert,<br />

later were awarded the Medal <strong>of</strong> Honor.<br />

The rancher who brought some <strong>of</strong> his cowboys to the<br />

scene <strong>of</strong> the battle arrived after the attackers had fled with<br />

the loot. They sent a <strong>courier</strong> to Fort Thomas to alert the<br />

commander, and a surgeon and hospital ambulance were<br />

dispatched to tend the wounded.<br />

Lt. Powhattan H. Clarke and detachments from Troop<br />

K, 10th Cavalry, and Company I, 24th Infantry, went in<br />

pursuit <strong>of</strong> the attackers.* Eventually eight suspects<br />

(another account indicates nine) were identified and arrested--all<br />

Mormon ranchers and farmers from the Safford<br />

area. The missing money was not found.<br />

At the trial convened Nov. 11, 1889, in Tucson, they<br />

were defended by attorney Marcus Aurelius Smith, a colorful<br />

attorney and perennial congressional delegate Ben<br />

Goodrich, and Frank Hereford. Prosecution attorneys included<br />

U.S. Attorneys Harry Jeffords, William Herring,<br />

Herring's Tucson-based son-in-law Selim M. Franklin.<br />

(Both Hereford and Franklin were members <strong>of</strong> Tucson's<br />

bachelor enclave known as "the Owls.")<br />

The defense attorneys worked to attribute blame to a<br />

dozen unidentified drifters alleged to have been in the<br />

area at the time <strong>of</strong> the robbery. It is likely, the jury was


told, that they escaped into Mexico with the purloined<br />

payroll.<br />

Because <strong>of</strong> the confusion during the battle, neither<br />

Wham nor any <strong>of</strong> his escort troops were able to identify<br />

any <strong>of</strong> the defendants in court, and after a marathon 33day<br />

parade <strong>of</strong> courtroom histrionics, the defendants were<br />

acquitted.<br />

Hearsay <strong>of</strong> the time indicated all those charged were<br />

on good terms with the acting territorial governor, and<br />

that he exerted political pressure to have them acquitted.<br />

The Wham payroll robbery has become an enduring<br />

legend in the Safford area and beyond, with some insisting<br />

the accused were, indeed, innocent, and others noting<br />

that times were hard in the area in 1889, and that government<br />

money would have provided welcome relief.<br />

Wham died Dec. 21, 1908, in Washington, D.C., and<br />

is buried at Wham Hill Cemetery, Marion County, Ill.<br />

*This is the same Second Lieutenant Powhattan H.<br />

Clarke, Company K and who received the Medal <strong>of</strong><br />

Honor for rescuing Corporal Scott while under heavy fire<br />

from Apaches at Pinito Mountains, Sonora, Mex., 3 May<br />

1886. Entered service at: Baltimore, Md. Birth: Alexandria,<br />

La. Date <strong>of</strong> issue: 12 March 1891. Citation: Rushed<br />

forward to the rescue <strong>of</strong> a soldier who was severely<br />

wounded and lay, disabled, exposed to the enemy's fire,<br />

and carried him to a place <strong>of</strong> safety.<br />

According to the June 15, 2007 “An Arizona Buffalo<br />

Soldier,” Arizona Capitol Times article, Lt. Powhatan H.<br />

Clarke referred to the soldiers <strong>of</strong> the black 10th Cavalry<br />

Regiment under his command by racially derogatory<br />

names. However, at the same time he wrote, “No men<br />

could have been more determined and cooler.” A commander<br />

in the Civil War, he met his end in the most famous<br />

Indian battle in American history. His death at the<br />

Little Bighorn might have prevented him from becoming<br />

the only goat to be elected president <strong>of</strong> the United Stares.<br />

Pickett, <strong>of</strong> course, has his name attached to one <strong>of</strong> the<br />

world's most famous charges.<br />

Much thanks to John for this colorful information<br />

which helps put history in perspective and helps me win<br />

arguments with people who think they know Arizona’s<br />

<strong>military</strong> history when they don’t. The Director<br />

8 November 2008<br />

9am to 4pm<br />

Come visit us at the Arizona Military<br />

Museum<br />

Displays <strong>of</strong> <strong>military</strong> vehicles, artifacts from<br />

the <strong>museum</strong>, and books for sale.<br />

Bring your children and grand-children to see<br />

the old vehicles and weapons.<br />

Enjoy Veterans Day With Us!<br />

Survival<br />

By Anonymous (worldwide web)<br />

Courier page 11<br />

Some Thoughts about Survival, Firearms, and Protecting<br />

Yourself<br />

This is the law:<br />

The purpose <strong>of</strong> fighting is to win.<br />

There is no possible victory in defense.<br />

The sword is more important than the shield;<br />

skill is more important than either.<br />

The final weapon is the brain.<br />

All else is supplemental.<br />

These are the rules:<br />

1. Don't pick a fight with an old man. If he is too old to<br />

fight, he will just kill you.<br />

2. If you find yourself in a fair fight, your tactics suck.<br />

3. I carry a gun 'cause a cop is too heavy.<br />

4. America is not at war. The U.S. Military is at war.<br />

America is at the Mall.<br />

5. When seconds count, the cops are just minutes away.<br />

(Yep, shoot first, then call 911)<br />

6. A reporter did a human interest piece on the Texas<br />

Rangers. The reporter recognized the Colt Model 1911 the<br />

Ranger was carrying and asked him "Why do you carry<br />

a .45?" The Ranger responded with, “Because they don't<br />

make a 46."<br />

7. The old sheriff was attending an awards dinner when a<br />

lady commented on his wearing his sidearm. "Sheriff, I<br />

see you have your pistol. Are you expecting trouble?"<br />

"No Ma'am", answered the Sheriff. "If I were expecting<br />

trouble, I would have brought my rifle." (Winchester<br />

Model 94, 30-30 Cal. and loaded with Winchester Silver<br />

Tips, no doubt.)<br />

8. Beware the man who only has one gun.... HE PROBA-<br />

BLY KNOWS HOW TO USE IT!!!<br />

Some thoughts about being armed:<br />

I was once asked by a lady visiting if I had a gun in the<br />

house. I said "I did." She said, "Well I certainly hope it<br />

isn't loaded!" To which I said, "Of course it is loaded."<br />

She then asked, "Are you that afraid <strong>of</strong> someone evil coming<br />

into your house?" My reply was, "No, not at all. I am<br />

not afraid <strong>of</strong> the house catching fire either, but I have fire<br />

extinguishers around, and THEY ARE ALL LOADED,<br />

TOO."


Courier page 12<br />

Editorial:<br />

America’s Global War on Terrorism:<br />

Success or Failure<br />

By Joseph Abodeely, Director<br />

For several years, America has been engaged in what<br />

has been called the “Global War On Terrorism” (GWOT).<br />

The cost in lives and treasure has been tremendous, and<br />

other tangential costs to America in loss <strong>of</strong> international<br />

prestige, the devaluation <strong>of</strong> the dollar, the decline <strong>of</strong> the<br />

economy, the diversion <strong>of</strong> attention to preserving the U.S.<br />

infrastructure, and the over taxing <strong>of</strong> American armed<br />

forces and related resources—all have a negative impact<br />

on U.S. national security. Since September 11, 2001,<br />

more than 4,600 Arizona National Guard soldiers and<br />

airmen have been ordered to federal active duty in support<br />

<strong>of</strong> Operation Noble Eagle, Enduring Freedom, and Iraqi<br />

Freedom. It is essential that the American public and<br />

those whose duty it is to combat “terrorism” truly understand<br />

what it is.<br />

The RAND Corporation is a nonpr<strong>of</strong>it research organization<br />

providing objective analysis and effective solutions<br />

that address the challenges facing the public and private<br />

sectors around the world. RAND's publications do not<br />

necessarily reflect the opinions <strong>of</strong> its research clients and<br />

sponsors. Recently, the RAND Corporation presented a<br />

monograph relating to a study <strong>of</strong> how terrorist organizations<br />

reached their demise. This research in the public<br />

interest was supported by RAND, using discretionary<br />

funds made possible by the generosity <strong>of</strong> RAND's donors,<br />

the fees earned on client-funded research, and independent<br />

research and development (IR&D) funds provided by<br />

the <strong>Department</strong> <strong>of</strong> Defense. All RAND monographs undergo<br />

rigorous peer review to ensure high standards for<br />

research quality and objectivity.<br />

For those who believed that the so-called GWOT was<br />

ill-conceived and ill-implemented—not because <strong>of</strong> pacifistic<br />

tendencies or political motives—but from a clearer<br />

understanding <strong>of</strong> the nature <strong>of</strong> the threat <strong>of</strong> “terrorism”<br />

than the political slogans which persuaded the majority <strong>of</strong><br />

the American public to believe, the RAND monograph<br />

entitled, How Terrorist Groups End: Lessons for Countering<br />

al Qa'ida, by Seth G. Jones and Martin C. Libicki,<br />

is vindication. The full monograph can be obtained<br />

online by Googling RAND Corporation, but the salient<br />

points in summary about the monograph follow.<br />

The research showed that all terrorist groups eventually<br />

end. But how do they end? The evidence since 1968<br />

indicates that most groups have ended because (1) they<br />

joined the political process (43 percent) or (2) local police<br />

and intelligence agencies arrested or killed key members<br />

(40 percent). Military force has rarely been the primary<br />

reason for the end <strong>of</strong> terrorist groups, and few<br />

groups within this time frame have achieved victory.<br />

This has significant implications for dealing with al<br />

Qa'ida and suggests fundamentally rethinking post-9/11<br />

U.S. counterterrorism strategy: Policymakers need to understand<br />

where to prioritize their efforts with limited resources<br />

and attention.<br />

The authors report that religious terrorist groups take<br />

longer to eliminate than other groups and rarely achieve<br />

their objectives. The largest groups achieve their goals<br />

more <strong>of</strong>ten and last longer than the smallest ones do. Finally,<br />

groups from upper-income countries are more<br />

likely to be left-wing or nationalist and less likely to have<br />

religion as their motivation. The authors conclude that<br />

policing and intelligence, rather than <strong>military</strong> force,<br />

should form the backbone <strong>of</strong> U.S. efforts against al<br />

Qa'ida. And U.S. policymakers should end the use <strong>of</strong><br />

the phrase “war on terrorism” since there is no battlefield<br />

solution to defeating al Qa'ida.<br />

America needs to set its priorities and use its <strong>military</strong><br />

and law enforcement resources wisely or it will be ineffective<br />

in dealing with either international terrorism or<br />

domestic terrorism. "Terrorism" is defined as "The calculated<br />

use <strong>of</strong> violence or threat <strong>of</strong> violence to inculcate<br />

fear; intended to coerce or to intimidate governments or<br />

societies in the pursuit <strong>of</strong> goals that are generally political,<br />

religious, or ideological.” The actions <strong>of</strong> al Qa'ida<br />

have fit into that definition, but the Islamic world would<br />

argue that the actions <strong>of</strong> the U.S. in invading and occupying<br />

Iraq would also meet that definition. The point is that<br />

the U.S. policy makers have not displayed a keen understanding<br />

<strong>of</strong> “terrorism.” Similarly, “domestic terrorism”<br />

must be recognized in order to effectively deal with it.<br />

"Domestic Terrorism" is defined as "Terrorism perpetrated<br />

by the citizens <strong>of</strong> one country against fellow countrymen.<br />

That includes acts against citizens <strong>of</strong> a second<br />

country when they are in the host country and not the<br />

principal or intended target.”<br />

The Pentagon in 1992 considered this problem as evidence<br />

by a memorandum circulated by the legal <strong>of</strong>ficer<br />

for the U.S. Army Military Police Operations Agency.


CONCLUSION<br />

Since 9/11, U.S. policy on national security has<br />

changed drastically in many ways. America invaded Iraq,<br />

and is still an occupation force. Counterinsurgency or<br />

antiterrorism <strong>military</strong> operations are being conducted in<br />

Afghanistan. The Homeland Security agency has been<br />

created to provide domestic security in the continental<br />

U.S. Local federal and state law enforcement agencies<br />

have the primary responsibility to deal with local criminal<br />

acts which can include acts <strong>of</strong> terrorism in the U.S., but<br />

after 9/11 combating terrorism has become a national priority.<br />

Military units, including activated National Guard<br />

units or personnel could be tasked to deal with terrorism<br />

in the U.S. if the President so orders. As the RAND research<br />

shows, policing and intelligence, rather than<br />

<strong>military</strong> force, should form the backbone <strong>of</strong> U.S. efforts<br />

against terrorism.<br />

If National Guard personnel were to act in a quasi law<br />

enforcement role to deal with terrorist acts or a broader<br />

terrorist threat in the U.S., hopefully they would be sufficiently<br />

trained to perform their duties consistent with<br />

Constitutional protections afforded the American populace.<br />

Many “pr<strong>of</strong>essional” police are caught on tape committing<br />

assaults.<br />

The <strong>military</strong> needs to be used judiciously and only<br />

when necessary to combat “terrorism” or it will become<br />

over-extended as it is now at a time when Russia is invading<br />

former members <strong>of</strong> the old USSR. Local police and<br />

intelligence agencies should be relied on to arrest or kill<br />

key members <strong>of</strong> terrorist groups. Lastly, U.S. policymakers<br />

should end the use <strong>of</strong> the phrase “war on terrorism”<br />

since there is no battlefield solution to defeating al<br />

Qa'ida.<br />

Courier page 13<br />

The above photographs are from the worldwide<br />

web. The upper two photograph show the Los<br />

Angeles riot and a California National Guardsman<br />

on patrol duty during the Los Angeles, California<br />

Riots. The photograph immediately above<br />

shows the Murrah Building in Okalahoma City,<br />

Okalahoma, after the bombing. All dramatically<br />

illustrate domestic terrorism in the United States.<br />

Proper training <strong>of</strong> National Guard members will prevent<br />

acts <strong>of</strong> uncontrolled violence. This Los Angeles Times photograph<br />

to the left depicts <strong>of</strong>ficers arresting an individual<br />

during the riots.


Courier page 14<br />

Documents Supporting the Editorial:<br />

“Lest We Forget”<br />

In honor <strong>of</strong> September 11, 2001, we remember<br />

those who lost their lives that day that changed forever<br />

the way Americans look at themselves and the<br />

world.<br />

We also take this time to honor the <strong>military</strong> men<br />

and women who have lost their lives in the service <strong>of</strong><br />

their country since that day, and for all the other wars<br />

and <strong>military</strong> actions before 9/11.<br />

We take this time to thank all <strong>military</strong> men and<br />

women who have served in the past, who serve now<br />

and who will serve in the future to keep our great<br />

country free.<br />

Freedom is not free.


From the Report <strong>of</strong> the Adjutant General <strong>of</strong> Arizona 1891,<br />

Edwin S. Gill, The Adjutant General<br />

Dated January 1, 1892<br />

To Hon. John N. Irwin,<br />

Governor and Commander-in-Chief:<br />

Sir:<br />

I have the honor to submit the annual report <strong>of</strong> the Adjutant<br />

General for the year ending December 31, 1891, as follows:<br />

(This report contained 26 pages.)<br />

The National Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona now consists <strong>of</strong> one regiment<br />

<strong>of</strong> Infantry, composed <strong>of</strong> nine companies, organized<br />

into three battalions. The annual returns for the year show a<br />

present force <strong>of</strong> 288 <strong>of</strong>ficers and enlisted men. This report<br />

embraces only seven companies and the regimental and two<br />

battalion organizations. Companies A and C having failed to<br />

comply with orders issued, Colonel Brodie directed them to<br />

turn in their arms and equipment. Efforts are now making to<br />

re-organize both companies upon a firm basis, and I hope to<br />

be able to report success in a short time. The remaining companies<br />

are now recruiting and expect to soon have an enrollment<br />

<strong>of</strong> from 45 to 55 men each..<br />

Previous to March 19, 1891, Arizona had no Military<br />

Code, hence the present organization really dates subsequent<br />

to that time. Seven independent companies were organized<br />

during the summer and fall <strong>of</strong> 1890, but the lack <strong>of</strong> State aid<br />

caused the members to lose interest, and from December,<br />

1890, until April, 1891, hardly a drill was had. Another company<br />

known as “H” had been organized at Yuma, in January,<br />

1891, but pending the action <strong>of</strong> the Legislature nothing was<br />

done towards equipping it.<br />

The Code as adopted provides that “The organized militia<br />

shall consist <strong>of</strong> ten companies, *** <strong>of</strong> which the companies<br />

now formed shall form a part. *** Infantry companies may be<br />

organized into battalions <strong>of</strong> not less than two nor more than<br />

six companies, and such battalions into regiments <strong>of</strong> not less<br />

than two nor more than three battalions. To each regiment<br />

there shall be one Colonel, one Lieutenant-Colonel, three<br />

Majors, *** who shall be commissioned by the Commander-<br />

In-Chief. *** Each company duly organized under the provisions<br />

<strong>of</strong> this Code shall receive $30 per month to defray the<br />

expenses <strong>of</strong> maintaining each company, said amount payable<br />

monthly out <strong>of</strong> any funds in the Territorial Treasury not otherwise<br />

appropriated. The said monthly installment to be paid<br />

upon the requisition <strong>of</strong> the commanding <strong>of</strong>ficer <strong>of</strong> such company,<br />

the same being accompanied by vouchers approved by<br />

the Adjutant General.”<br />

General Orders, No. 1, the first ever issued to the National<br />

Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona, were promulgated from this <strong>of</strong>fice, April<br />

23, directing the then existing companies to be mustered in<br />

under the new Code. This resulted in a virtual reorganization,<br />

the different companies completing their muster<br />

by May 30.<br />

[Further on in the report--]<br />

While the Code adopted was a start towards a <strong>military</strong><br />

organization, it is but just<br />

to the guard to say that the<br />

zeal <strong>of</strong> those in the organization<br />

has more to do with<br />

keeping it alive than aid<br />

derived from the Territory.<br />

Excepting the small sum <strong>of</strong><br />

$30 per month allowed<br />

each company, not one<br />

penny is appropriated for<br />

<strong>military</strong> expenses. No<br />

provisions whatever are<br />

made for the pay or transportation<br />

<strong>of</strong> troops if called<br />

Courier page 15<br />

Edwin S. Gill, The Adjutant General<br />

<strong>of</strong> Arizona, 1892.<br />

out, for encampments or inspections, for court-martials, for<br />

headquarters, regimental or battalion <strong>of</strong>fice expenses, nor for<br />

necessary <strong>of</strong>ficial transportation, nor in short for anything.<br />

The utter inconsistency <strong>of</strong> the law is especially shown in the<br />

Article governing the Adjutant General’s <strong>of</strong>fice. It provides<br />

that “The Adjutant General shall also be ex-<strong>of</strong>ficio Quartermaster<br />

and Commissary General and Chief <strong>of</strong> Ordnance; that<br />

he shall furnish commissions, without charge, to all <strong>of</strong>ficers,<br />

issue and transmit all order, furnish blanks, muster rolls, certificates<br />

<strong>of</strong> election, oaths <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice, returns and copies <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>military</strong> code, and such other supplies as may be authorized<br />

by law.” And yet no money is appropriated for this work and<br />

expense.<br />

The lack <strong>of</strong> funds has greatly hampered the organization<br />

in its very department. Some blanks have been furnished<br />

from this <strong>of</strong>fice, but not what there should have been, as the<br />

Adjutant General is not a Croesus.<br />

[Further on in the report--]<br />

There is now considerable call upon the time <strong>of</strong> the Adjutant<br />

general, by veterans <strong>of</strong> the Civil and Mexican wars, who<br />

ask for the assistance <strong>of</strong> this <strong>of</strong>fice in securing copies <strong>of</strong> lost<br />

discharges, etc., in seeking admission to Soldiers’ Homes and<br />

in other work. While it is not incumbent upon the Adjutant<br />

General to do this work, it would certainly not be humane to<br />

refuse any possible assistance to these aged veterans.<br />

In short the <strong>of</strong>fice has now become one <strong>of</strong> importance, and<br />

should be recognized accordingly. There is no other State in<br />

the Union which pays this <strong>of</strong>ficer less than $1,000 per annum,<br />

from that to $10,000, besides providing an <strong>of</strong>fice, pay for<br />

clerks, etc. An examination <strong>of</strong> the work <strong>of</strong> the <strong>of</strong>fice will<br />

show that it is greater than that devolving upon any other Territorial<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficial excepting the Governor and Secretary.<br />

[The remainder <strong>of</strong> the report contains reasons why Arizona<br />

needed the National Guard and why the Territorial legislature<br />

needed to fund the troops. This is an interesting document<br />

to read and compare to today’s National Guard needs.<br />

The National Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona today faces many <strong>of</strong> the same<br />

problems with the state legislature that were experienced in<br />

1892; i.e. lack <strong>of</strong> building funds to repair existing armories.<br />

This document may be found the Arizona Military Museum<br />

Library.]


ARIZONA MILITARY MUSEUM COURIER<br />

(Published by the Arizona National Guard Historical Society, Inc.)<br />

MUSEUM LOCATION AND HOURS<br />

The Arizona Military Museum is located on the northeast corner <strong>of</strong> 52 nd Street and McDowell Road. Enter at the main entrance<br />

at 5600 East McDowell. The admission is FREE. The <strong>museum</strong> is open on Saturdays and on Sundays from 1:00 pm to 4:00 pm.<br />

Since our <strong>of</strong>ficers and directors are volunteers, the <strong>museum</strong> hours are related to their (volunteers’) availability. Please call the <strong>museum</strong><br />

to schedule tours beforehand to insure we’re not closed for holidays or the summer or for some other reason. The Arizona<br />

Military Museum number is 602-267-2676 or you may call (602) 253-2378.<br />

A FEW GOOD MEN AND WOMEN<br />

You can help the Arizona National Guard Historical Society by becoming a member, by making a tax-deductible donation,<br />

soliciting funds, by making the Historical Society a beneficiary in your will, or by donating historical artifacts. We<br />

invite you to serve on the Board if you are interested in Arizona <strong>military</strong> history and if you are willing to give <strong>of</strong> your time<br />

and effort to prioritize the <strong>museum</strong> activities in your already busy schedule. Call us if you are interested in becoming a<br />

board member at (602) 267-2676.<br />

Arizona National Guard Historical Society<br />

Arizona Military Museum<br />

5636 East McDowell Road<br />

Phoenix, Arizona 85008-3495

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!