arizona military museum courier - Department of Emergency ...
arizona military museum courier - Department of Emergency ...
arizona military museum courier - Department of Emergency ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
ARIZONA MILITARY MUSEUM<br />
COURIER<br />
Published by the Arizona National Guard Historical Society, Inc.<br />
The Arizona National Guard Historical Society is a<br />
private non-pr<strong>of</strong>it corporation established under the laws <strong>of</strong><br />
Arizona and consistent with the Internal Revenue Code. It<br />
is the sponsor <strong>of</strong> the Arizona Military Museum. The Historical<br />
Society’s purposes are: “To enhance the appreciation<br />
<strong>of</strong> the <strong>military</strong> history <strong>of</strong> Arizona and the contributions<br />
<strong>of</strong> the Militia <strong>of</strong> Arizona and the Arizona National Guard to<br />
the State <strong>of</strong> Arizona and to the Nation…” (Bylaws, Article<br />
I, Section 1). To accomplish its purposes, the Historical<br />
Society shall strive: “…to discover and memorialize the<br />
history <strong>of</strong> the Military <strong>of</strong> Arizona, the Arizona National<br />
Guard, and the general <strong>military</strong> history <strong>of</strong> Arizona, and to<br />
establish and maintain a <strong>museum</strong> on land leased, owned, or<br />
otherwise controlled by the Society.” (Id.). The policy<br />
statement states that the Historical Society is “…to portray<br />
events, persons, and other historical information relating<br />
to…the <strong>military</strong> service <strong>of</strong> Arizonans in wars and other<br />
<strong>military</strong> actions in Arizona and around the world.”<br />
The Articles <strong>of</strong> Incorporation for the Arizona National<br />
Guard Historical Society were executed on March 28,<br />
1975.<br />
The Historical Society was incorporated on April 25,<br />
1975 with the aforementioned purposes and the added purpose<br />
as stated in its policy statement: “…to portray events,<br />
Fall 2008 Issue 34<br />
HISTORICAL SOCIETY AND ARIZONA<br />
MILITARY MUSEUM HISTORY<br />
persons, and other historical information relating …the<br />
<strong>military</strong> service <strong>of</strong> Arizonans in wars and other <strong>military</strong><br />
actions in Arizona and around the world.”<br />
On July 14, 1978 the Arizona National Guard General<br />
Staff dedicated a portion <strong>of</strong> the old arsenal building for a<br />
<strong>museum</strong> for the Historical Society.<br />
In January 1980 the director and <strong>of</strong>ficers were elected<br />
who were committed to creating the <strong>museum</strong>. They did<br />
most <strong>of</strong> the demolition and construction to establish the<br />
<strong>museum</strong>.<br />
In December 1980 the Adjutant General designated the<br />
<strong>museum</strong> an <strong>of</strong>ficial permanent historical activity <strong>of</strong> the Arizona<br />
National Guard.<br />
In April 1981 the General Staff dedicated the space for<br />
the East Room <strong>of</strong> the <strong>museum</strong>.<br />
On September 12, 1981 the Arizona Military Museum<br />
had is Grand Opening.<br />
On July 13, 1999, the Arizona National Guard Historical<br />
Society and the Arizona National Guard executed a<br />
Memorandum <strong>of</strong> Understanding reaffirming their historical<br />
relationship and mutual support.<br />
On September 30, 2006, the Arizona Military Museum<br />
celebrated the 25th anniversary <strong>of</strong> its opening.
Courier page 2<br />
Published by the Arizona<br />
National Guard Historical<br />
Society, 5636 E<br />
McDowell Rd, Bldg<br />
M5320, Phoenix, AZ<br />
85008-3495<br />
President/Director:<br />
Joseph Abodeely<br />
Vice President:<br />
Thomas Quarelli<br />
Secretary:<br />
Carolyn Feller<br />
Treasurer:<br />
Klaus Foerst<br />
Board <strong>of</strong> Director<br />
Members:<br />
Jean McColgin<br />
Anna Kroger<br />
Dan Mardian<br />
Harry/Mary Hensell<br />
Rick White<br />
Eugene Cox<br />
George Notarpole<br />
Jon Falk<br />
Robert Lutes<br />
Trudie Cooke<br />
Ex-Officio Board Member:<br />
MG David Rataczak<br />
Museum Hours:<br />
The Arizona Military<br />
Museum is temporarily<br />
closed pending ro<strong>of</strong><br />
repairs.<br />
How to Contact Us:<br />
Write or call<br />
Phone: 602.267.2676<br />
Or: 602-253-2378<br />
Fax: 602.267.2632<br />
DSN: 853-2676<br />
Editors: Joseph<br />
Abodeely and Trudie<br />
Cooke<br />
Submit address<br />
changes and articles to<br />
the Arizona Military<br />
Museum, 5636 E<br />
McDowell Rd, Phoenix,<br />
AZ 85008-3495.<br />
Arizona National Guard<br />
Historical Society<br />
“Lest We Forget”<br />
REPORT TO THE MEMBERSHIP<br />
I have good news and bad news. The bad news is that<br />
the <strong>museum</strong> is still closed to the public. The Facilities<br />
Management Office (FMO) determined that the <strong>museum</strong> should be closed right after he<br />
saw the two cracked trusses in November 2007, and the engineers hired by the FMO<br />
said to close the <strong>museum</strong>. Risk management has concurred based on the information<br />
presented by their report. I complained to no avail about only the <strong>museum</strong> being singled<br />
out to be closed down while the RTI classrooms (immediately to the west) and the<br />
dining facility (immediately to the right) remained open because all three areas are under<br />
the same ro<strong>of</strong> in the north building <strong>of</strong> the RTI. The FMO engineers and an independent<br />
engineer we hired said the shoring up <strong>of</strong> the trusses was sufficient to hold them<br />
in place; but the engineers have taken the position to keep the <strong>museum</strong> closed supposedly<br />
for safety reasons. The RTI classroom area, on the west side <strong>of</strong> the <strong>museum</strong>, is<br />
still open to the public. And, the supposedly emergency situation is still not resolved.<br />
The engineers report to the FMO took about six months to recommend repairing the<br />
entire ro<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong> the north building for a cost <strong>of</strong> $1.9 million. The Guard applied for<br />
funds from National Guard Bureau to fix the building. We made the recommendation<br />
that it take a more conservative approach and make only necessary repairs. On September<br />
3, the Guard informed the Board that there was no money allocated for the repairs<br />
at this time, and the Guard would not allow the <strong>museum</strong> to reopen to the public<br />
relying on the engineers’ recommendation to Risk Management.<br />
On September 10, I was given 45 minutes notice to attend a meeting with the engineers,<br />
the FMO, the Chief <strong>of</strong> Staff, and the Army Assistant AG. Dan Mardian and I<br />
were informed that the Guard just got money from NGB to do the major project—the<br />
$1,900,000. The discussion dealt with whether it was a viable option to repair only the<br />
broken trusses in the <strong>museum</strong> and the dining facility or fix all the trusses and the ro<strong>of</strong>.<br />
It appears the Guard will do all the repairs now to avoid potential problems in the future.<br />
The <strong>museum</strong> may have to remove all <strong>of</strong> its artifacts during the construction. In<br />
other words dismantle the <strong>museum</strong>. The FMO and the Chief <strong>of</strong> Staff assured me they<br />
will work closely with us during construction and the likely removal <strong>of</strong> <strong>museum</strong> items.<br />
Dan Mardian expressed our belief that the trusses were cracked due to A/C units on the<br />
ro<strong>of</strong>, but the engineers were adamant that the other trusses were at risk due to wear.<br />
The engineers favored the total-repair option. We have been closed to the public for<br />
the past ten months, and nobody on the Board believes an emergency exists only in<br />
the <strong>museum</strong> to require its closure. But that is a moot point now. I asked the FMO<br />
about the time frame, and he said that demolition would commence soon and that the<br />
<strong>museum</strong> should be completed by around May 2009. I am taking the position <strong>of</strong> let’s<br />
take lemons and make lemonade. We will have a new building for the <strong>museum</strong> when<br />
all is done. But we’ve got to open soon. A <strong>museum</strong> not open to the public is merely<br />
a collection.<br />
The good news is that we are still working to keep one <strong>of</strong> the finest <strong>military</strong> <strong>museum</strong>s<br />
in the country alive. On February 14, 2008 (Valentine’s Day and Arizona Statehood<br />
Day), the Arizona Military Museum participated in the annual Museums on the
Letter to Membership continued.<br />
Courier page 3<br />
the Mall event held on the grounds <strong>of</strong> the State Capitol. We had two tables with artifacts on display. Harry<br />
and Mary Hensell and I attended. Rick White and Jon Falk helped transport our artifacts to and from the<br />
event. Numerous other <strong>museum</strong>s also participated, and the event always gives your <strong>museum</strong> great visibility.<br />
The <strong>museum</strong> received a $1700.00 grant from the Arizona Historical Society which we used to purchase a<br />
firepro<strong>of</strong> lateral file cabinet. We preserve important documents in it such as the original muster rolls <strong>of</strong> the 1 st<br />
Arizona Volunteer Infantry. We really appreciate the continued support from AHS. We did not ask for a grant<br />
this year since the <strong>museum</strong> was still closed. On March 2 and 3, I attended the Arizona Library, Archives, and<br />
Public Records Convocation in Tucson. It was informative about records collections, preservation, and conservation.<br />
In April, three Board members (George Notarpole, Trudie Cooke, and me) attended the Museums<br />
Association <strong>of</strong> Arizona (MAA) annual convention in Wickenburg. I spoke about the creation, maintenance,<br />
and operation <strong>of</strong> the Arizona Military Museum. The convention was very informative about <strong>museum</strong> governance<br />
and procedures.<br />
Also, in April your Board <strong>of</strong> Directors was selected for the year. The Officers and Board <strong>of</strong> Directors are<br />
Col. Joseph Abodeely (USA Ret.)-President; BG Thomas Quarelli (ANG Ret.)-Vice President; LTC Carolyn<br />
Feller (USAR Ret.)-Secretary; Klaus Foerst-Treasurer; and the Directors are Jean McColgin, Anna Kroger,<br />
Dan Mardian, CSM Harry Hensell (Ret.), Mary Hensell, Rick White, Eugene Cox, George Notarpole, Jon<br />
Falk, Robert Lutes, and Trudie Cooke.<br />
MG David Rataczak serves as an ex-<strong>of</strong>ficio member <strong>of</strong> the Board <strong>of</strong> Directors. He will be retiring this<br />
year, and we wish to thank him for the support he has given us in the past.<br />
While the <strong>museum</strong> has been closed, Board members installed slat walls in the display cases to facilitate<br />
hanging artifacts from the walls. We have conducted inventories <strong>of</strong> USPFO weapons and vehicles, and also <strong>of</strong><br />
our own weapons and artifacts. Trudie Cooke and Nancy Goodson have been working on the library; and<br />
George, Nancy, Trudie, and I have been working on specific inventories <strong>of</strong> the items displayed in each display<br />
case.<br />
I attended a MAA workshop on August 18 in Tucson at AHS about the changing population growth in Arizona<br />
and how it will affect <strong>museum</strong>s. Arizona will double its population by 2030 with many more retirees and<br />
Hispanics. There will be a rise <strong>of</strong> the “creative class” which will be 30% <strong>of</strong> the population with 50% <strong>of</strong> the<br />
population’s income.<br />
On Saturday, November 8, we will celebrate Veterans’ Day. We will have artifacts from the <strong>museum</strong> on<br />
display in the quadrangle and <strong>military</strong> motor vehicles, provided by the two <strong>military</strong> motor vehicle clubs in the<br />
Valley. We will also have a book sale. Come and visit with us. We need the morale booster. Of course, admission<br />
is free.<br />
We are looking forward to the Arizona’s centennial celebration in 2012, and we are hoping to be a focal<br />
point <strong>of</strong> interest because <strong>of</strong> our portrayal <strong>of</strong> Arizona’s <strong>military</strong> history. We are applying for the Arizona Centennial<br />
Commission’s Legacy Project certification. We are pleased and proud to honor Arizona’s veterans,<br />
militia and National Guard members who have served in the past and present. We are extremely pleased to<br />
have guest articles in this Courier from Marshall Trimble, the Official State Historian, Jim Turner, the Historian<br />
from the Arizona Historical Society, and John Langellier, Director, Sharlot Hall Museum.<br />
The Officers and Directors <strong>of</strong> the Historical Society have kept the <strong>museum</strong> going, and we would like to<br />
continue to do so. We do it voluntarily to provide the Arizona National Guard and the public one <strong>of</strong> the best<br />
<strong>military</strong> <strong>museum</strong>s in the United States. We could not do what we do without your support and the support <strong>of</strong><br />
MG Rataczak and his staff. As the state’s centennial is approaching, the <strong>museum</strong> is gearing up to be the showcase<br />
for the Arizona National Guard. We hope you’ll help.<br />
Joseph E. Abodeely<br />
Colonel (USA Ret)<br />
President, AZNG Historical Society
Courier page 4<br />
Geronimo’s Last Campaign<br />
By Marshall Trimble, Official Arizona State Historian<br />
There were stretches <strong>of</strong> country picturesque<br />
to look upon and capable <strong>of</strong> cultivation, especially<br />
with irrigation; and other expanses not<br />
a bit more fertile than so manmade brickyards,<br />
where all was desolation, the home <strong>of</strong><br />
the cactus and the coyote. Arizona was in<br />
those days separated from “God’s country”<br />
by a space <strong>of</strong> more than fifteen hundred<br />
miles, without a railroad, and the <strong>of</strong>ficer or<br />
soldier who once got out there rarely returned<br />
for years. (p. 3)<br />
….During this campaign we were <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
obliged to leave the warm valleys in the<br />
morning and climb to the higher altitudes and<br />
go into bivouac upon summits where the<br />
snow was hip deep, as on the Matitzal (sic.),<br />
the Mogollon plateau, and the Sierra Ancha.<br />
To add to the discomfort, the pine was so<br />
thoroughly soaked through with snow and<br />
rain it would not burn, and unless cedar could<br />
be found, the command was in bad luck. (p.<br />
185)<br />
Captain John G. Bourke, On the Border<br />
with Crook, 1971<br />
In the years following the Civil War, the Frontier Army was<br />
charged with the thankless task <strong>of</strong> keeping the peace in the<br />
West. That meant not only protecting the whites from the Indians<br />
but protecting the Indians from the Whites. Playing peacemaker,<br />
the Army was caught between a rock and a hard place.<br />
There were some 2,600 soldiers to police about 200,000 Indians.<br />
Many times the natives were better armed than the soldiers.<br />
The Army was also caught in the middle between eastern<br />
politicians and activists who believed the Army was too harsh<br />
in its treatment <strong>of</strong> Indians and the westerners who insisted the<br />
Army mollycoddled the natives.<br />
Deaths resulting from such diseases as cholera and yellow<br />
fever killed far more than those resulting from fighting Indians.<br />
Between the years 1860 and 1886, 1,993 soldiers were killed or<br />
wounded in the Indian Wars. In 1886, 1,217 soldiers died from<br />
cholera alone.<br />
Harsh living conditions, fatigue, poor pay, poor rations, and<br />
little appreciation from his fellow countrymen were the grim<br />
prospects the soldiers faced. They were <strong>of</strong>ten sent into battle<br />
with obsolete weapons and equipment as well as under strength<br />
in numbers. Desertion, alcoholism and suicide rates were high<br />
on the isolated <strong>military</strong> posts. Loneliness and boredom was the<br />
soldier’s constant companion. Typical meals on the posts consisted<br />
<strong>of</strong> such culinary delights as beef hash, dry bread, and<br />
c<strong>of</strong>fee for breakfast. Evening meals were just simply bread and<br />
c<strong>of</strong>fee.<br />
Punishment was harsh especially for acts such as drunkenness<br />
and desertion. Yet these men became good soldiers. Under<br />
the pr<strong>of</strong>essionalism <strong>of</strong> the corps <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>ficers and noncommissioned<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficers, along with the rigid discipline instilled,<br />
Geronimo, circa 1886.<br />
the small Spartan army made up largely <strong>of</strong> Irish and German<br />
immigrants became veteran, reliable and even efficient. It was<br />
admired and understood by foreign <strong>military</strong> observers who ventured<br />
west to observe them.<br />
Following General George Crook’s successful 1872-1873<br />
campaign against the Apache in the rugged mountains <strong>of</strong> central<br />
Arizona, the tribes were located on reservations after agreeing<br />
to the federal government’s promise to provide provisions.<br />
Trouble began almost immediately after the Chiricahua were<br />
relocated to San Carlos in 1876, and thrown in with other<br />
Apache groups who regarded them as enemies. Also, leaders<br />
like Juh, Chatto, Chihuahua, and Victorio were unhappy with<br />
reservation life and continued bolting the reservation, leading<br />
raids in Arizona and Mexico. This initiated the so-called<br />
“renegade” period in the Apache Wars where soldiers would go<br />
in pursuit <strong>of</strong> those who left the reservation.<br />
Two issues led to the final outbreak. The Apache men had a<br />
custom <strong>of</strong> biting <strong>of</strong>f the nose <strong>of</strong> the unfaithful wife, a practice<br />
General Crook had strictly forbidden. They insisted he had no<br />
business interfering with their customs. The other was the<br />
drinking <strong>of</strong> tiswin, a beer made <strong>of</strong> fermented corn. Mangus’s<br />
wife was a maker <strong>of</strong> excellent tiswin and she hated Whites. She<br />
goaded her husband, the son <strong>of</strong> the legendary chief, Mangas<br />
Colorados, constantly. Chihuahua was one <strong>of</strong> her best customers.<br />
He liked to drink and complain but wasn’t too interested in<br />
bolting the reservation again. The consummate malcontent<br />
Geronimo took advantage <strong>of</strong> the situation to stir up trouble.<br />
In May, 1885, a group <strong>of</strong> Apache decided to test the policy<br />
against tiswin. They got drunk and confronted the <strong>of</strong>ficer in<br />
charge, Lieutenant Britton Davis. Davis informed them he was<br />
wiring General Crook for instructions. The wire was sent to a<br />
Captain Francis Pierce; an <strong>of</strong>ficer new to the area failed to<br />
grasp the gravity <strong>of</strong> the situation and determined it wasn’t important<br />
enough to bother the general. Meanwhile, the Apache<br />
grew restless wondering what kind <strong>of</strong> wrath the general would<br />
bring upon them for their drunken binge and bolted once again<br />
for Mexico.<br />
Thus began the last campaign to end the Apache Wars. In<br />
January, 1886, Captain Emmett Crawford defeated Geronimo
and band in the Sierra Madre. Two months later the Apache<br />
leader met with General Crook at Canon de los Embudos, and<br />
agreed to surrender. Thus began the last campaign to end the<br />
Apache Wars. In January, 1886, Captain Emmett Crawford<br />
defeated Geronimo and band in the Sierra Madre. Two months<br />
later the Apache leader met with General Crook at Canon de los<br />
Embudos, and agreed to surrender. That night bootleggers<br />
came into the Apache camp and sold them booze, at the same<br />
time telling them the soldiers planned to kill them once they<br />
were in Arizona.<br />
Geronimo and warriors bolted once again causing Crook’s<br />
superior in Washington, General Phil Sheridan, also his roommate<br />
at West Point, to suggest he was placing too much trust in<br />
the Apache. Crook asked to be replaced and General Nelson<br />
Miles was sent to relieve him.<br />
Camels in the Southwest Desert?<br />
Photograph and story by Marshall Trimble, Official Arizona<br />
State Historian<br />
Arizona has always been a place where bizarre events were<br />
accepted as normal. But perhaps the strangest <strong>of</strong> all occurred in<br />
1857 when a caravan <strong>of</strong> camels looking like something out <strong>of</strong><br />
the Arabian Nights trekked across northern Arizona.<br />
At the time, the federal government was planning to survey<br />
a wagon road along the 35 th Parallel from New Mexico to California<br />
and wanted to test the feasibility <strong>of</strong> using camels as<br />
beasts <strong>of</strong> burden. The camel experiment was the pet project <strong>of</strong><br />
Secretary <strong>of</strong> War, Jefferson Davis, who believed that camels<br />
were the solution for transporting cargo across the arid lands <strong>of</strong><br />
the American West.<br />
The man chosen to lead the experiment was a colorful adventurer<br />
named Lieutenant Edward F. “Ned” Beale <strong>of</strong> the Army<br />
Corps <strong>of</strong> Topographical Engineers. Beale, a former Navy <strong>of</strong>ficer,<br />
had been a hero at the Battle <strong>of</strong> San Pasquel in California<br />
during the Mexican war when he and Kit Carson sneaked<br />
through the enemy lines to bring a relief force from San Diego<br />
to General Kearny’s Army <strong>of</strong> the West, under siege by Mexican<br />
forces.<br />
Following the discovery <strong>of</strong> gold in California in 1848, Beale<br />
took a sack full <strong>of</strong> gold nuggets and traveled across Mexico<br />
disguised as a Mexican. He eventually reached Washington<br />
D.C. and presented the gold to President James Polk, proving<br />
that rumors <strong>of</strong> the gold strike in California were indeed true.<br />
Courier page 5<br />
The campaign was nearly over by the time Miles arrived.<br />
He continued Crook’s policy <strong>of</strong> using Apache scouts, durable<br />
pack trains and relentless pursuit. The Army also rounded up<br />
the Chiricahua on reservations and shipped them to Florida.<br />
That summer five thousand U.S. troops or some 20% <strong>of</strong> the<br />
U.S. Army were chasing less than two dozen warriors. In August<br />
Lieutenant Charles Gatewood, an <strong>of</strong>ficer known and respected<br />
by Geronimo, Tom Horn, along with two Apache<br />
scouts named Martine and Kayitah undertook a dangerous mission<br />
to Geronimo’s camp. They held a parley with Geronimo<br />
and his band. After some haggling, Gatewood dealt the warriors<br />
his ace card. Their relatives had been exiled to Florida and<br />
if they wanted to see them again they would have to surrender.<br />
On September 3, 1886, the wily war chief surrendered and the<br />
Apache Wars were finally over.<br />
Beale’s Camel expedition nearly a decade later was<br />
unique<br />
in the annals <strong>of</strong> exploration in the American West. The<br />
camel’s amazing ability to travel great distances without<br />
water, and thriving on natural forage along the trail made<br />
them a natural for hauling cargo.<br />
Although Beale championed his illustrious camels, referring<br />
to them as the “noblest brute alive,” his muleskinners<br />
scorned them. They were especially upset when entire<br />
herds <strong>of</strong> mules stampeded at the mere site <strong>of</strong> the homely<br />
creatures. The camels propensity to be extremely stubborn<br />
and spit at the muleskinners certainly didn’t endear them to<br />
their American handlers. The problem handling the animals<br />
was solved when camel drivers were imported from the<br />
Middle East. A Syrian named Hadji Ali was the most famous.<br />
His name was quickly Americanized to “Hi Jolly.”<br />
The camels passed a supreme test when Beale was challenged<br />
to pit them against the packers’ mules on a 60-mile endurance<br />
trek. Using six camels against twelve mules, a 2.5 ton<br />
load was divided among the camels, and a like amount was<br />
loaded on two Army wagons, drawn by six mules. The camels<br />
finished the trip in two and a half days while the mules took<br />
four days.<br />
Beale and his camels managed to successfully open the<br />
wagon road along the 35 th Parallel. That road later became the<br />
storied Route 66 and is today Interstate 40. He persisted in<br />
naming the various rivers, passes and mountains after his fellow<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficers in the U.S. Navy. The names usually didn’t stick and if<br />
they had, most <strong>of</strong> the geographical features in western Arizona<br />
would today sound like a battleship’s roster.<br />
Hi Jolly remained in Arizona, got married and became a<br />
prospector. He is memorialized on a pyramid-shaped monument,<br />
topped <strong>of</strong>f with a lone camel, at Quartzsite, Arizona.<br />
This brief, but romantic event in Arizona history came to an<br />
end just before the Civil War began and was overshadowed by<br />
the great events that took place in the East. As for the camels,<br />
they were turned loose to roam the deserts <strong>of</strong> western Arizona.<br />
One, “Red Ghost,” became the stuff <strong>of</strong> legends. When pranksters<br />
tied a dead body on his back the animal went insane and<br />
attacked a woman, killing her. Over the next few years the<br />
camel, with a skeleton tied to its back, was seen at various parts<br />
<strong>of</strong> Arizona, causing havoc when it came around humans and<br />
became the subject <strong>of</strong> many a campfire story.
Courier page 6<br />
By Trudie Cooke<br />
By Trudie Cooke<br />
Down Range: To<br />
Iraq and Back<br />
speaks to the hearts<br />
<strong>of</strong> our <strong>military</strong> men<br />
and women<br />
Down Range: To Iraq and Back, by Bridget C. Cantrell,<br />
Ph.D. and Chuck Dean, Word Smith Publishing, Seattle, WA<br />
98168, 2005, is a small paperback book that <strong>of</strong>fers help to all<br />
the men and women who have served in combat.<br />
This book is a surprise in such a compact form. The message<br />
is timely, and to some veterans <strong>of</strong> past wars, long overdue.<br />
Down Range is dedicated to bringing the troops home and addresses<br />
the challenges <strong>of</strong> the re-integration process from combatant<br />
to civilian.<br />
On the back cover is written, “Bridget Cantrell, Ph.D. and<br />
Vietnam veteran, Chuck Dean have joined forces to present this<br />
vital information and resource manual for both returning troops<br />
and their loved ones. Here you will find answers, explanations,<br />
and insights as to why so many combat veterans suffer from<br />
flashbacks, depression, fits <strong>of</strong> rage, nightmares, anxiety, emotional<br />
numbing, and other troubling aspects <strong>of</strong> Post-Traumatic<br />
Stress Disorder (PTSD).”<br />
The Springfield 1903 Rifle and<br />
those daring Bushmasters<br />
An interesting comment on the famed Bushmaster’s M1903<br />
rifle used during World War II:<br />
Briefly, the 158th Infantry became the 158th Regiment<br />
Combat Team and separated from the 45th Division <strong>of</strong> Oklahoma<br />
on Sep 16, 1940. They spent a year in the Panama Canal<br />
Zone where they earned their nickname “Bushmasters.” By Jan<br />
16, 1943, they were at Port Moresby, New Guinea. They remained<br />
in the Philippines for the remainder <strong>of</strong> the war.<br />
They were equipped with the M1903 Springfield rifle prior<br />
to departure for the Panama Canal Zone. While in the Canal<br />
Zone , they modified their issued M1903 rifle. Lt. Col. William<br />
S. Brophy, USAR, Ret., says in his book The Springfield 1903<br />
Rifles, (1985), “Frequently brave souls in the <strong>military</strong> perform<br />
unauthorized modifications to standard equipment. However,<br />
the fear <strong>of</strong> the discipline meted out, and the possible attachment<br />
<strong>of</strong> pay for the cost <strong>of</strong> the item, prevented many worthwhile and<br />
inventive ideas from being tried….However, if high authority<br />
blessed the project, it was not uncommon for ideas to be tried<br />
and, in some cases, put to use….A good example <strong>of</strong> equipment<br />
Some excepts from the book are:<br />
“War forces its participants to go beyond the paradigms <strong>of</strong><br />
ordinary life, pushing them beyond what one would think are<br />
humanly possible. When we assertively take the life <strong>of</strong> another<br />
human being we are catapulted far beyond the range <strong>of</strong> normal<br />
human behavior. As terrible as killing is, it is still not the worst<br />
outcome <strong>of</strong> war. Cruelty to the souls <strong>of</strong> the soldiers who fight<br />
is war’s greatest casualty….<br />
At the end <strong>of</strong> each battle, and when the war is over, the images<br />
and sounds <strong>of</strong> combat are still present in the minds and<br />
hearts <strong>of</strong> those who engaged in it—and these will never go<br />
away….Now comes the full realization that you willingly participated<br />
in something so unnatural to the mind and<br />
spirit” (page 24 and 25).<br />
“We should never again blame the individual soldiers (like<br />
so many did during the Vietnam War) for fighting in a war that<br />
was decided upon by government leaders” (page 25).<br />
This book also provides contact sources for help that include<br />
such places as the Veterans Administration, the Vietnam<br />
Veterans <strong>of</strong> America, the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline,<br />
the National Veterans Foundation, and many other groups that<br />
specifically handle PTSD.<br />
The whole point <strong>of</strong> this book is to be an educational guide, a<br />
spiritual guide, a source guide—all rolled into one small paperback<br />
book. The warrior and his family are not alone. Help is<br />
out there.<br />
This book may be obtained from the Arizona National<br />
Guard Personnel Readiness Center, Frank Sandell, Transition<br />
Assistance Advisor, Papago Park Military Reservation, 5636 E<br />
McDowell Rd, Phoenix, AZ 85008 at 602-629-4421. It is free<br />
while supplies last.<br />
for a particular use in a specific area is the Bushmaster ’03 rifle.”<br />
(page 82)<br />
“By order <strong>of</strong> Major General Robert H. Lewis, Commanding<br />
General <strong>of</strong> the Panama Mobile Force Command in 1942, Model<br />
1903 rifles were shortened six inches for use by the Jungle Security<br />
Platoon [the Bushmasters] while conducting missions in<br />
heavy jungle foliage.” (page 83)<br />
Alterations were done by the Ordnance Shops in the Canal<br />
Zone once permission was granted by the Army Chief <strong>of</strong> Ordnance.<br />
The altered M1903 was used by the Bushmasters in the<br />
Canal Zone and also in the Philippines.<br />
From The Springfield 1903 Rifle, William S. Brophy, 1985,<br />
page 82.
The 1st Arizona Infantry fights Apaches:<br />
Arizona Indian Wars 1865 to 1866<br />
By Jim Turner, Historian for the Arizona Historical<br />
Society—Tucson, AZ<br />
(Editor’s note: With the Civil War still going on<br />
and Carleton still fighting the Navajos, the U.S. War<br />
<strong>Department</strong> authorized Governor John Noble Goodwin<br />
<strong>of</strong> Arizona to raise five companies <strong>of</strong> Arizona<br />
Volunteers in 1864. Recruitment was delayed for a<br />
year, but by the fall <strong>of</strong> 1865, more than 350 men had<br />
been issued into service under the command <strong>of</strong> nine<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficers. The overwhelming majority was Mexicans,<br />
many <strong>of</strong> them from Sonora, or O'odham and Maricopas<br />
from the Gila River villages, who had grown up<br />
fighting Yavapais and Apaches, as had their fathers<br />
and grandfathers. Many never received shoes or<br />
warm clothing. They lived in hovels and marched for<br />
days on beef jerky and parched cornmeal. They carried<br />
.54-caliber (14 mm) rifles with plenty <strong>of</strong> ammunition,<br />
in addition to bows, arrows, and war clubs.<br />
For the next year, these frontiersmen guarded wagon<br />
trains between Prescott and La Paz and campaigned<br />
relentlessly across central Arizona. The following<br />
excerpt and description <strong>of</strong> the 1 st Arizona Volunteer<br />
Infantry was presented by Jim Turner, Historian for<br />
the Arizona Historical Society—Tucson—in an article,<br />
“Pima Villages”, the Journal <strong>of</strong> Arizona History<br />
1998. The article was too lengthy to include in the<br />
Courier, but we highly recommend that the reader<br />
seek out and read the entire article to learn some<br />
important Arizona history.)<br />
Governor John N. Goodwin, 1863—1866, received<br />
permission from the United States Provost<br />
Marshal James B. Fry to “raise within the Territory<br />
<strong>of</strong> Arizona one regiment <strong>of</strong> Volunteer Infantry to<br />
serve for three years or the duration <strong>of</strong> the war.” The<br />
War <strong>Department</strong> intended that the recruitment <strong>of</strong> native<br />
Arizonans would supplement the California Volunteers,<br />
who hesitated to go on long scouting missions<br />
against the Apaches because their Civil War<br />
enlistment would soon be up. The Arizona Volunteers<br />
served for one year, and gave Mexicans, Pimas<br />
and Maricopas an opportunity to avenge the losses<br />
they received at the hands <strong>of</strong> the Apaches while acquiring<br />
much-needed guns from the government.<br />
Courier page 7<br />
Goodwin appointed Thomas Ewing, a teamster<br />
from the Pima Villages, to recruit Maricopa Indians,<br />
and former sergeant John D. Walker to recruit the<br />
Pimas. (This is not the same John Walker who was<br />
previously Indian Agent.) On October 2, 1865, First<br />
Lieutenant William Tompkins <strong>of</strong> the Third California<br />
Infantry arrived at Maricopa Wells and commissioned<br />
First Lieutenant Ewing, Second Lieutenant<br />
Charles Reidt, who was fluent in the Maricopa language,<br />
and Captain Juan Chevereah, chief <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Maricopas. He also mustered in 94 Maricopa recruits,<br />
designated as Company B, Arizona Volunteer<br />
Infantry. By May 16, 1866 there were 103 men in the<br />
company. John D. Walker was commissioned as first<br />
lieutenant and William A. Hancock as second lieutenant<br />
<strong>of</strong> Company C, made up <strong>of</strong> Pima Indians.<br />
Their chief, Antonio Azul, was made a sergeant and<br />
89 Pimas were recruited to fill out the company. Five<br />
more Pimas were added later at Sacaton.<br />
A unique Arizona character, John D. Walker was<br />
part Wyandotte Indian, born in Nauvoo, Illinois<br />
about 1840. He arrived at the Pima villages as a<br />
wagon master in the California Volunteers, and was<br />
charged with expediting the distribution <strong>of</strong> the Pimas’<br />
surplus wheat and corn to California Volunteer<br />
posts as far away as the Rio Grande. When his enlistment<br />
was up, Walker married a Pima woman and<br />
settled in the Pima village <strong>of</strong> Sacaton. Quick to learn,<br />
he compiled the first written grammar <strong>of</strong> their language<br />
and became a leader in Pima councils. He<br />
studied medicine and was something <strong>of</strong> a scientist.<br />
Such a background makes the other side <strong>of</strong> his character<br />
even more unusual. According to historian<br />
James McClintock, "It is said that when they were in<br />
the field you could not tell him from the other Indians.<br />
He dressed like them, with nothing but a breechcloth,<br />
and whooped and yelled like his Indian comrades."<br />
The native Arizonans enlisted just as Apache raiding<br />
reached new heights, and their orders — to destroy<br />
Apache camps, crops and supplies and kill resisters<br />
— coincided with their attitudes toward their<br />
traditional enemies. The Indian soldiers received a<br />
blue blouse, trimmed in red for the Maricopas and<br />
blue for the Pimas, one pair <strong>of</strong> blue pants, one pair <strong>of</strong><br />
shoes and one yard <strong>of</strong> flannel for a headdress. Most
Courier page 8<br />
<strong>of</strong> them wore “teguas” — shoes <strong>of</strong> untanned hide<br />
with broad soles turned up at the toes with a hole to<br />
admit air and remove dirt. Scouts were <strong>of</strong>ten carried<br />
out on foot with packs containing a canteen, a blanket,<br />
and some dried beef and pinole, a food made <strong>of</strong><br />
one part sugar to two parts roasted ground corn or<br />
wheat mixed with water. The Indians were expected<br />
to provide their own horses, but allowances were<br />
sometimes made for feed. Although these were the<br />
intended provisions, circumstances did not always<br />
afford them and the Indians <strong>of</strong>ten endured the cold<br />
without benefit <strong>of</strong> warm clothes, bedding or shoes.<br />
The Pimas and Maricopas were used to hardship,<br />
however; they were familiar with the country and<br />
knew the Apaches.<br />
The two new volunteer companies left Maricopa<br />
Wells with Colonel Clarence E. Bennett’s California<br />
Volunteers on September 4, 1865 to establish a fort<br />
seven miles north <strong>of</strong> the confluence <strong>of</strong> the Verde and<br />
Salt rivers. Both companies helped construct Camp<br />
McDowell to protect farms along the rivers from<br />
Apaches. The Tonto and Pinal Apaches inhabited the<br />
Tonto Basin, bordered by the Mazatzal and Sierra<br />
Ancha Mountains on the east and west and the<br />
Mogollon Rim to the north. These were some <strong>of</strong> the<br />
last Apache tribes to be subdued, and the Arizona<br />
Volunteers became their first considerable foe. The<br />
Indians at Camp McDowell lived in brush shelters.<br />
Military reports said their morale was high and they<br />
were allowed to return to their villages almost as <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
as they pleased. Although Hispanic and Anglo<br />
volunteers suffered various forms <strong>of</strong> typhoid from<br />
continuous attacks <strong>of</strong> fever caused by rain and humidity,<br />
not a single individual from Indian companies<br />
B or C was reported sick on post returns.<br />
The Indian volunteers began their first foray on<br />
September 8, 1865, led by Lieutenant Reidt. They<br />
traveled northeast for several days into the Tonto Basin.<br />
Maricopa guides took them up the east side <strong>of</strong><br />
the Mazatzal Mountains up Tonto Creek, 110 miles<br />
up steep banks, across canyons, and through arroyos<br />
thick with underbrush. “It was a trying, sorry march,<br />
and the animals and men suffered from the cactus.”<br />
When one Pima was accidentally shot in the hand, all<br />
but fifteen returned to camp with him. The volunteers<br />
eventually surprised an Apache ranchería just<br />
east <strong>of</strong> Payson. One Apache was killed, several were<br />
wounded and their crops and houses were burned.<br />
The Indian volunteers proved their valor in battle<br />
after battle. On October 15, 1865, Cuchavenashak,<br />
a Company B Maricopa charged an Apache. The<br />
Apache's first arrow went through his horse's ear, the<br />
second hit the Maricopa's belt plate and the third hit<br />
him in the forehead and glanced <strong>of</strong>f, causing a flesh<br />
wound. Cuchavenashak leaped <strong>of</strong>f his horse,<br />
clinched the Apache to him and killed him. This<br />
alarmed a ranchería <strong>of</strong> about 20 families <strong>of</strong> Apaches<br />
nearby. A volley <strong>of</strong> 100 shots were fired into the<br />
Apaches as they retreated.<br />
The Arizona Volunteers were an experiment in<br />
cultural coexistence. For the good <strong>of</strong> the mission, the<br />
Indians were allowed to practice their traditional war<br />
customs without interference from white soldiers. On<br />
March 6, 1866, Lt. Ewing took a party near the Polos<br />
Blancos [sic] Mountains, on Rattlesnake Creek “The<br />
night being quite dark, it was decded to await the rising<br />
<strong>of</strong> the moon. During the wait, the Indian soldiers<br />
consulted a prophet or tobacco mancer. A circle was<br />
formed around the prophet who began to smoke<br />
"cigarettes." As soon as one was consumed another<br />
was furnished him by an attendant. After some time,<br />
he began to tremble and fell "dead" (stupefied). He<br />
lay there for several minutes, during which time not<br />
a sound was heard from command. When he arose,<br />
he said that his spirit had followed the trail, that the<br />
command was on, towards the "Massasahl" and there<br />
under the peak it saw two large rancherías with a<br />
great many warriors. His spirit then followed the trail<br />
north, where it found a ranchería that had been abandoned<br />
because <strong>of</strong> the death <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the occupants.”<br />
When he finished, the Indians slept. When the moon<br />
had risen high in the sky, Walker and Ewing led their<br />
men up the mountain in search <strong>of</strong> the ranchería.
Halfway up the mountain they found an abandoned<br />
ranchería and later a large camp <strong>of</strong> Apaches, just as<br />
the tobacco mancer predicted.<br />
On March 27, Lieutenant Walker led the largest<br />
expedition <strong>of</strong> Arizona Volunteers on record; an estimated<br />
260 Papagos and Pimas and 40 Maricopas<br />
from Company B left the Pima villages. Those from<br />
Company B left the Pima villages. Those without<br />
rifles or muskets fashioned war clubs while they established<br />
a temporary supply depot on Tonto Creek.<br />
In a fight four days later, 25 Apaches were killed and<br />
16 taken prisoner. Three Pimas were wounded, one<br />
<strong>of</strong> whom eventually died. Because they were in<br />
Apache country, the Pima warrior’s body was burned<br />
along with the mourners’ clothes instead <strong>of</strong> his own<br />
belongings as was the custom in the villages. Although<br />
most warriors left the Pima villages well clad,<br />
many returned naked. This is also probably the expedition<br />
where the miners were shocked by the smashing<br />
<strong>of</strong> heads. Conner relates that the Pimas would lift<br />
a heavy stone above their heads and drop it on a dead<br />
or wounded Apache, crushing the skull <strong>of</strong> their enemy.<br />
Sometimes they placed the head <strong>of</strong> the victim<br />
on a flat rock to suitably cave in his face, perhaps so<br />
it would not be recognized in the next world. The<br />
Apaches, possibly learning it from the Pimas, followed<br />
this custom. Conner said he was more disgusted<br />
that the Whites looked on with approval, musing<br />
that “savage civilized men are the most monstrous<br />
<strong>of</strong> all monsters.”<br />
In late Aug, 1866, Colonel Charles S. Lovell became<br />
commander <strong>of</strong> District <strong>of</strong> Arizona. He did not<br />
appreciate the Pima and Maricopa custom <strong>of</strong> living<br />
in their villages when not in the field and not being<br />
subject to the post commanders’ orders. General Mason<br />
had promised the Indians that they could do as<br />
they pleased, and the spirit <strong>of</strong> cooperation had served<br />
all parties admirably. As was <strong>of</strong>ten the case with<br />
army/Indian relations, just as the vastly different cultures<br />
began to understand each other, personnel<br />
changed, previous arrangements were nullified and<br />
once again the Indians had to adapt. Official feelings<br />
were not unanimous on the subject <strong>of</strong> Indian soldiers,<br />
however. In May, while still commander at Fort<br />
McDowell, Colonel Bennett asked the Arizona’s Adjutant<br />
General to extend the volunteer enlistment or<br />
create a regular native regiment. If these options<br />
proved unworkable, he proposed that the volunteers<br />
be allowed to keep their arms when discharged so<br />
they could continue fighting Apaches effectively.<br />
Courier page 9<br />
1907 Portrait <strong>of</strong> Antonio Azul, last hereditary chief <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Pima Indians. Died at Sacaton, AZ, October 20, 1910 at<br />
the age <strong>of</strong> about 76. He was a 2nd Lieutenant, 1st Arizona<br />
Infantry, Company C, National Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona<br />
during the 1866 Indian Wars. Photograph courtesy <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Pima-Maricopa Indian Community.<br />
At Fort McDowell on September 11, 1866, because<br />
<strong>of</strong> the legalities <strong>of</strong> retaining them, Maricopa<br />
Company B was discharged from service by First<br />
Lieutenant Ewing and now Captain Juan Chevereah.<br />
The records indicated that Maricopas McGill, Yose,<br />
Goshe Zep, and Duke were killed in battle. The same<br />
day, Pima Company C was mustered out by Captain<br />
John D. Walker. Hownik Mawkum, Juan Lewis and<br />
Au Papat were Pimas listed as killed in battle. All the<br />
men were allotted $50 pay and allowed to keep their<br />
firearms and equipment. Many volunteers who believed<br />
they would get no pay found that all at once<br />
they had more money than they had ever had at any<br />
time in their lives. In honor <strong>of</strong> the Arizona Volunteers,<br />
in the fall <strong>of</strong> 1866 the Third Arizona Territorial<br />
Legislature passed a memorial for their outstanding<br />
service.<br />
The services <strong>of</strong> Arizona Volunteers were definitely<br />
missed. In November <strong>of</strong> 1866, General<br />
McDowell let it be known that any Indians enlisting<br />
as scouts would be treated as when they served in the<br />
Volunteers. They would not be required to drill or<br />
fight with army methods and could stay in their villages<br />
when not on patrol. Pimas and Maricopas continued<br />
to work with the <strong>military</strong>, but the practice<br />
peaked in 1869 as more Apaches became willing to<br />
serve as scouts.
Courier page 10<br />
Buffalo Soldiers served in Arizona during the Indian Wars <strong>of</strong> 1888<br />
By John Langellier, Director, Shalot Hall Museum, Prescott,<br />
AZ<br />
Last February at the Museums<br />
on the Mall event, I was<br />
talking to John Langellier,<br />
Director, Sharlot Hall Museum,<br />
about the actions <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Buffalo Soldiers in Arizona. I<br />
told him that some people told<br />
me that they never were in<br />
Arizona during the Indian<br />
Wars era. John, who is an<br />
expert <strong>military</strong> historian, said<br />
he would send me some information.<br />
Here is what he sent:<br />
The 10th U.S. Cavalry<br />
regiment transferred from the<br />
<strong>Department</strong> <strong>of</strong> Texas to the<br />
<strong>Department</strong> <strong>of</strong> Arizona in 1886 with the regimental headquarters<br />
at Ft. Whipple under Colonel Benjamin Grierson<br />
and the various companies assigned to forts all over the<br />
territory including Forts Apache and Grant. The 10th participated<br />
in the final Apache campaigns, and the name<br />
“Buffalo Soldiers” first appeared in print for a widespread<br />
audience when Fredrick Remington wrote and illustrated<br />
an article in Arizona in 1888 titled “Scout with the Buffalo<br />
Soldiers.” The 24th Infantry also reported to Arizona<br />
soon aft the arrival <strong>of</strong> the 10th, and two <strong>of</strong> their men received<br />
the Medal <strong>of</strong> Honor for the incident cited below.<br />
Thus, black troops have been stationed continuously in<br />
Arizona since 1886 and continue to play a role in the<br />
armed forces here to this day.<br />
He also sent a story written by Paul L. Allen published<br />
in the Arizona Republic on July 29, 2006:”Lookin' Back:<br />
Safford-area Treasury Ambush Stuff <strong>of</strong> Legends”:<br />
When you mix an audacious crime with goodly a<br />
amount <strong>of</strong> loot and a sizable dollop <strong>of</strong> whodunit, you've<br />
got a ready-made Old West legend.<br />
Such is the Wham payroll robbery <strong>of</strong> May 11, 1889,<br />
which bears the added distinction <strong>of</strong> being likely the most<br />
frequently mispronounced incident name in the Southwest.<br />
It is pronounced Wham (like "bomb") and not<br />
Wham (like "Bam!").<br />
Here's what happened:<br />
Army Maj. Joseph W. Wham and an escort <strong>of</strong> 11 Buffalo<br />
Soldiers from the 24th Infantry and 10th Cavalry were en<br />
route from Fort Grant to Fort Thomas, but northwest <strong>of</strong><br />
present-day Safford on the Gila River.<br />
Wham rode in an ambulance that also carried a strongbox<br />
containing $28,345 in gold and silver coins, much <strong>of</strong><br />
it still in Treasury <strong>Department</strong> sacks. An escort wagon<br />
followed the ambulance.<br />
They were forced to stop at Cedar Springs because a<br />
large boulder blocked the roadway<br />
where it passed through a<br />
narrow defile. Men in the escort<br />
set about moving the obstacle,<br />
but were immediately<br />
fired upon from both sides <strong>of</strong><br />
the road. Eight were wounded<br />
in the melee.<br />
Their attackers numbered -<br />
depending on whose account is<br />
to be believed - from eight to<br />
20.<br />
Wham, in reporting the incident<br />
to the Secretary <strong>of</strong> War,<br />
wrote that the "party was am-<br />
“Proud to Serve,” oil painting by Don Stivers, Waterford, VA,<br />
bushed and fired into by a number<br />
<strong>of</strong> armed brigands, since<br />
estimated by U.S. Marshal (W.K.) Meade at from twelve<br />
to fifteen, but to myself and entire escort, two noncommissioned<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficers and nine privates, at fifteen to<br />
twenty."<br />
He indicated a signal shot was followed by a barrage<br />
<strong>of</strong> gunfire, and a battle lasting more than 30 minutes ensued.<br />
Two soldiers involved, one shot in the abdomen but<br />
continuing to fire until shot again through both arms, and<br />
another who, though wounded, walked and crawled<br />
nearly two miles to Cottonwood Ranch to give the alert,<br />
later were awarded the Medal <strong>of</strong> Honor.<br />
The rancher who brought some <strong>of</strong> his cowboys to the<br />
scene <strong>of</strong> the battle arrived after the attackers had fled with<br />
the loot. They sent a <strong>courier</strong> to Fort Thomas to alert the<br />
commander, and a surgeon and hospital ambulance were<br />
dispatched to tend the wounded.<br />
Lt. Powhattan H. Clarke and detachments from Troop<br />
K, 10th Cavalry, and Company I, 24th Infantry, went in<br />
pursuit <strong>of</strong> the attackers.* Eventually eight suspects<br />
(another account indicates nine) were identified and arrested--all<br />
Mormon ranchers and farmers from the Safford<br />
area. The missing money was not found.<br />
At the trial convened Nov. 11, 1889, in Tucson, they<br />
were defended by attorney Marcus Aurelius Smith, a colorful<br />
attorney and perennial congressional delegate Ben<br />
Goodrich, and Frank Hereford. Prosecution attorneys included<br />
U.S. Attorneys Harry Jeffords, William Herring,<br />
Herring's Tucson-based son-in-law Selim M. Franklin.<br />
(Both Hereford and Franklin were members <strong>of</strong> Tucson's<br />
bachelor enclave known as "the Owls.")<br />
The defense attorneys worked to attribute blame to a<br />
dozen unidentified drifters alleged to have been in the<br />
area at the time <strong>of</strong> the robbery. It is likely, the jury was
told, that they escaped into Mexico with the purloined<br />
payroll.<br />
Because <strong>of</strong> the confusion during the battle, neither<br />
Wham nor any <strong>of</strong> his escort troops were able to identify<br />
any <strong>of</strong> the defendants in court, and after a marathon 33day<br />
parade <strong>of</strong> courtroom histrionics, the defendants were<br />
acquitted.<br />
Hearsay <strong>of</strong> the time indicated all those charged were<br />
on good terms with the acting territorial governor, and<br />
that he exerted political pressure to have them acquitted.<br />
The Wham payroll robbery has become an enduring<br />
legend in the Safford area and beyond, with some insisting<br />
the accused were, indeed, innocent, and others noting<br />
that times were hard in the area in 1889, and that government<br />
money would have provided welcome relief.<br />
Wham died Dec. 21, 1908, in Washington, D.C., and<br />
is buried at Wham Hill Cemetery, Marion County, Ill.<br />
*This is the same Second Lieutenant Powhattan H.<br />
Clarke, Company K and who received the Medal <strong>of</strong><br />
Honor for rescuing Corporal Scott while under heavy fire<br />
from Apaches at Pinito Mountains, Sonora, Mex., 3 May<br />
1886. Entered service at: Baltimore, Md. Birth: Alexandria,<br />
La. Date <strong>of</strong> issue: 12 March 1891. Citation: Rushed<br />
forward to the rescue <strong>of</strong> a soldier who was severely<br />
wounded and lay, disabled, exposed to the enemy's fire,<br />
and carried him to a place <strong>of</strong> safety.<br />
According to the June 15, 2007 “An Arizona Buffalo<br />
Soldier,” Arizona Capitol Times article, Lt. Powhatan H.<br />
Clarke referred to the soldiers <strong>of</strong> the black 10th Cavalry<br />
Regiment under his command by racially derogatory<br />
names. However, at the same time he wrote, “No men<br />
could have been more determined and cooler.” A commander<br />
in the Civil War, he met his end in the most famous<br />
Indian battle in American history. His death at the<br />
Little Bighorn might have prevented him from becoming<br />
the only goat to be elected president <strong>of</strong> the United Stares.<br />
Pickett, <strong>of</strong> course, has his name attached to one <strong>of</strong> the<br />
world's most famous charges.<br />
Much thanks to John for this colorful information<br />
which helps put history in perspective and helps me win<br />
arguments with people who think they know Arizona’s<br />
<strong>military</strong> history when they don’t. The Director<br />
8 November 2008<br />
9am to 4pm<br />
Come visit us at the Arizona Military<br />
Museum<br />
Displays <strong>of</strong> <strong>military</strong> vehicles, artifacts from<br />
the <strong>museum</strong>, and books for sale.<br />
Bring your children and grand-children to see<br />
the old vehicles and weapons.<br />
Enjoy Veterans Day With Us!<br />
Survival<br />
By Anonymous (worldwide web)<br />
Courier page 11<br />
Some Thoughts about Survival, Firearms, and Protecting<br />
Yourself<br />
This is the law:<br />
The purpose <strong>of</strong> fighting is to win.<br />
There is no possible victory in defense.<br />
The sword is more important than the shield;<br />
skill is more important than either.<br />
The final weapon is the brain.<br />
All else is supplemental.<br />
These are the rules:<br />
1. Don't pick a fight with an old man. If he is too old to<br />
fight, he will just kill you.<br />
2. If you find yourself in a fair fight, your tactics suck.<br />
3. I carry a gun 'cause a cop is too heavy.<br />
4. America is not at war. The U.S. Military is at war.<br />
America is at the Mall.<br />
5. When seconds count, the cops are just minutes away.<br />
(Yep, shoot first, then call 911)<br />
6. A reporter did a human interest piece on the Texas<br />
Rangers. The reporter recognized the Colt Model 1911 the<br />
Ranger was carrying and asked him "Why do you carry<br />
a .45?" The Ranger responded with, “Because they don't<br />
make a 46."<br />
7. The old sheriff was attending an awards dinner when a<br />
lady commented on his wearing his sidearm. "Sheriff, I<br />
see you have your pistol. Are you expecting trouble?"<br />
"No Ma'am", answered the Sheriff. "If I were expecting<br />
trouble, I would have brought my rifle." (Winchester<br />
Model 94, 30-30 Cal. and loaded with Winchester Silver<br />
Tips, no doubt.)<br />
8. Beware the man who only has one gun.... HE PROBA-<br />
BLY KNOWS HOW TO USE IT!!!<br />
Some thoughts about being armed:<br />
I was once asked by a lady visiting if I had a gun in the<br />
house. I said "I did." She said, "Well I certainly hope it<br />
isn't loaded!" To which I said, "Of course it is loaded."<br />
She then asked, "Are you that afraid <strong>of</strong> someone evil coming<br />
into your house?" My reply was, "No, not at all. I am<br />
not afraid <strong>of</strong> the house catching fire either, but I have fire<br />
extinguishers around, and THEY ARE ALL LOADED,<br />
TOO."
Courier page 12<br />
Editorial:<br />
America’s Global War on Terrorism:<br />
Success or Failure<br />
By Joseph Abodeely, Director<br />
For several years, America has been engaged in what<br />
has been called the “Global War On Terrorism” (GWOT).<br />
The cost in lives and treasure has been tremendous, and<br />
other tangential costs to America in loss <strong>of</strong> international<br />
prestige, the devaluation <strong>of</strong> the dollar, the decline <strong>of</strong> the<br />
economy, the diversion <strong>of</strong> attention to preserving the U.S.<br />
infrastructure, and the over taxing <strong>of</strong> American armed<br />
forces and related resources—all have a negative impact<br />
on U.S. national security. Since September 11, 2001,<br />
more than 4,600 Arizona National Guard soldiers and<br />
airmen have been ordered to federal active duty in support<br />
<strong>of</strong> Operation Noble Eagle, Enduring Freedom, and Iraqi<br />
Freedom. It is essential that the American public and<br />
those whose duty it is to combat “terrorism” truly understand<br />
what it is.<br />
The RAND Corporation is a nonpr<strong>of</strong>it research organization<br />
providing objective analysis and effective solutions<br />
that address the challenges facing the public and private<br />
sectors around the world. RAND's publications do not<br />
necessarily reflect the opinions <strong>of</strong> its research clients and<br />
sponsors. Recently, the RAND Corporation presented a<br />
monograph relating to a study <strong>of</strong> how terrorist organizations<br />
reached their demise. This research in the public<br />
interest was supported by RAND, using discretionary<br />
funds made possible by the generosity <strong>of</strong> RAND's donors,<br />
the fees earned on client-funded research, and independent<br />
research and development (IR&D) funds provided by<br />
the <strong>Department</strong> <strong>of</strong> Defense. All RAND monographs undergo<br />
rigorous peer review to ensure high standards for<br />
research quality and objectivity.<br />
For those who believed that the so-called GWOT was<br />
ill-conceived and ill-implemented—not because <strong>of</strong> pacifistic<br />
tendencies or political motives—but from a clearer<br />
understanding <strong>of</strong> the nature <strong>of</strong> the threat <strong>of</strong> “terrorism”<br />
than the political slogans which persuaded the majority <strong>of</strong><br />
the American public to believe, the RAND monograph<br />
entitled, How Terrorist Groups End: Lessons for Countering<br />
al Qa'ida, by Seth G. Jones and Martin C. Libicki,<br />
is vindication. The full monograph can be obtained<br />
online by Googling RAND Corporation, but the salient<br />
points in summary about the monograph follow.<br />
The research showed that all terrorist groups eventually<br />
end. But how do they end? The evidence since 1968<br />
indicates that most groups have ended because (1) they<br />
joined the political process (43 percent) or (2) local police<br />
and intelligence agencies arrested or killed key members<br />
(40 percent). Military force has rarely been the primary<br />
reason for the end <strong>of</strong> terrorist groups, and few<br />
groups within this time frame have achieved victory.<br />
This has significant implications for dealing with al<br />
Qa'ida and suggests fundamentally rethinking post-9/11<br />
U.S. counterterrorism strategy: Policymakers need to understand<br />
where to prioritize their efforts with limited resources<br />
and attention.<br />
The authors report that religious terrorist groups take<br />
longer to eliminate than other groups and rarely achieve<br />
their objectives. The largest groups achieve their goals<br />
more <strong>of</strong>ten and last longer than the smallest ones do. Finally,<br />
groups from upper-income countries are more<br />
likely to be left-wing or nationalist and less likely to have<br />
religion as their motivation. The authors conclude that<br />
policing and intelligence, rather than <strong>military</strong> force,<br />
should form the backbone <strong>of</strong> U.S. efforts against al<br />
Qa'ida. And U.S. policymakers should end the use <strong>of</strong><br />
the phrase “war on terrorism” since there is no battlefield<br />
solution to defeating al Qa'ida.<br />
America needs to set its priorities and use its <strong>military</strong><br />
and law enforcement resources wisely or it will be ineffective<br />
in dealing with either international terrorism or<br />
domestic terrorism. "Terrorism" is defined as "The calculated<br />
use <strong>of</strong> violence or threat <strong>of</strong> violence to inculcate<br />
fear; intended to coerce or to intimidate governments or<br />
societies in the pursuit <strong>of</strong> goals that are generally political,<br />
religious, or ideological.” The actions <strong>of</strong> al Qa'ida<br />
have fit into that definition, but the Islamic world would<br />
argue that the actions <strong>of</strong> the U.S. in invading and occupying<br />
Iraq would also meet that definition. The point is that<br />
the U.S. policy makers have not displayed a keen understanding<br />
<strong>of</strong> “terrorism.” Similarly, “domestic terrorism”<br />
must be recognized in order to effectively deal with it.<br />
"Domestic Terrorism" is defined as "Terrorism perpetrated<br />
by the citizens <strong>of</strong> one country against fellow countrymen.<br />
That includes acts against citizens <strong>of</strong> a second<br />
country when they are in the host country and not the<br />
principal or intended target.”<br />
The Pentagon in 1992 considered this problem as evidence<br />
by a memorandum circulated by the legal <strong>of</strong>ficer<br />
for the U.S. Army Military Police Operations Agency.
CONCLUSION<br />
Since 9/11, U.S. policy on national security has<br />
changed drastically in many ways. America invaded Iraq,<br />
and is still an occupation force. Counterinsurgency or<br />
antiterrorism <strong>military</strong> operations are being conducted in<br />
Afghanistan. The Homeland Security agency has been<br />
created to provide domestic security in the continental<br />
U.S. Local federal and state law enforcement agencies<br />
have the primary responsibility to deal with local criminal<br />
acts which can include acts <strong>of</strong> terrorism in the U.S., but<br />
after 9/11 combating terrorism has become a national priority.<br />
Military units, including activated National Guard<br />
units or personnel could be tasked to deal with terrorism<br />
in the U.S. if the President so orders. As the RAND research<br />
shows, policing and intelligence, rather than<br />
<strong>military</strong> force, should form the backbone <strong>of</strong> U.S. efforts<br />
against terrorism.<br />
If National Guard personnel were to act in a quasi law<br />
enforcement role to deal with terrorist acts or a broader<br />
terrorist threat in the U.S., hopefully they would be sufficiently<br />
trained to perform their duties consistent with<br />
Constitutional protections afforded the American populace.<br />
Many “pr<strong>of</strong>essional” police are caught on tape committing<br />
assaults.<br />
The <strong>military</strong> needs to be used judiciously and only<br />
when necessary to combat “terrorism” or it will become<br />
over-extended as it is now at a time when Russia is invading<br />
former members <strong>of</strong> the old USSR. Local police and<br />
intelligence agencies should be relied on to arrest or kill<br />
key members <strong>of</strong> terrorist groups. Lastly, U.S. policymakers<br />
should end the use <strong>of</strong> the phrase “war on terrorism”<br />
since there is no battlefield solution to defeating al<br />
Qa'ida.<br />
Courier page 13<br />
The above photographs are from the worldwide<br />
web. The upper two photograph show the Los<br />
Angeles riot and a California National Guardsman<br />
on patrol duty during the Los Angeles, California<br />
Riots. The photograph immediately above<br />
shows the Murrah Building in Okalahoma City,<br />
Okalahoma, after the bombing. All dramatically<br />
illustrate domestic terrorism in the United States.<br />
Proper training <strong>of</strong> National Guard members will prevent<br />
acts <strong>of</strong> uncontrolled violence. This Los Angeles Times photograph<br />
to the left depicts <strong>of</strong>ficers arresting an individual<br />
during the riots.
Courier page 14<br />
Documents Supporting the Editorial:<br />
“Lest We Forget”<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> September 11, 2001, we remember<br />
those who lost their lives that day that changed forever<br />
the way Americans look at themselves and the<br />
world.<br />
We also take this time to honor the <strong>military</strong> men<br />
and women who have lost their lives in the service <strong>of</strong><br />
their country since that day, and for all the other wars<br />
and <strong>military</strong> actions before 9/11.<br />
We take this time to thank all <strong>military</strong> men and<br />
women who have served in the past, who serve now<br />
and who will serve in the future to keep our great<br />
country free.<br />
Freedom is not free.
From the Report <strong>of</strong> the Adjutant General <strong>of</strong> Arizona 1891,<br />
Edwin S. Gill, The Adjutant General<br />
Dated January 1, 1892<br />
To Hon. John N. Irwin,<br />
Governor and Commander-in-Chief:<br />
Sir:<br />
I have the honor to submit the annual report <strong>of</strong> the Adjutant<br />
General for the year ending December 31, 1891, as follows:<br />
(This report contained 26 pages.)<br />
The National Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona now consists <strong>of</strong> one regiment<br />
<strong>of</strong> Infantry, composed <strong>of</strong> nine companies, organized<br />
into three battalions. The annual returns for the year show a<br />
present force <strong>of</strong> 288 <strong>of</strong>ficers and enlisted men. This report<br />
embraces only seven companies and the regimental and two<br />
battalion organizations. Companies A and C having failed to<br />
comply with orders issued, Colonel Brodie directed them to<br />
turn in their arms and equipment. Efforts are now making to<br />
re-organize both companies upon a firm basis, and I hope to<br />
be able to report success in a short time. The remaining companies<br />
are now recruiting and expect to soon have an enrollment<br />
<strong>of</strong> from 45 to 55 men each..<br />
Previous to March 19, 1891, Arizona had no Military<br />
Code, hence the present organization really dates subsequent<br />
to that time. Seven independent companies were organized<br />
during the summer and fall <strong>of</strong> 1890, but the lack <strong>of</strong> State aid<br />
caused the members to lose interest, and from December,<br />
1890, until April, 1891, hardly a drill was had. Another company<br />
known as “H” had been organized at Yuma, in January,<br />
1891, but pending the action <strong>of</strong> the Legislature nothing was<br />
done towards equipping it.<br />
The Code as adopted provides that “The organized militia<br />
shall consist <strong>of</strong> ten companies, *** <strong>of</strong> which the companies<br />
now formed shall form a part. *** Infantry companies may be<br />
organized into battalions <strong>of</strong> not less than two nor more than<br />
six companies, and such battalions into regiments <strong>of</strong> not less<br />
than two nor more than three battalions. To each regiment<br />
there shall be one Colonel, one Lieutenant-Colonel, three<br />
Majors, *** who shall be commissioned by the Commander-<br />
In-Chief. *** Each company duly organized under the provisions<br />
<strong>of</strong> this Code shall receive $30 per month to defray the<br />
expenses <strong>of</strong> maintaining each company, said amount payable<br />
monthly out <strong>of</strong> any funds in the Territorial Treasury not otherwise<br />
appropriated. The said monthly installment to be paid<br />
upon the requisition <strong>of</strong> the commanding <strong>of</strong>ficer <strong>of</strong> such company,<br />
the same being accompanied by vouchers approved by<br />
the Adjutant General.”<br />
General Orders, No. 1, the first ever issued to the National<br />
Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona, were promulgated from this <strong>of</strong>fice, April<br />
23, directing the then existing companies to be mustered in<br />
under the new Code. This resulted in a virtual reorganization,<br />
the different companies completing their muster<br />
by May 30.<br />
[Further on in the report--]<br />
While the Code adopted was a start towards a <strong>military</strong><br />
organization, it is but just<br />
to the guard to say that the<br />
zeal <strong>of</strong> those in the organization<br />
has more to do with<br />
keeping it alive than aid<br />
derived from the Territory.<br />
Excepting the small sum <strong>of</strong><br />
$30 per month allowed<br />
each company, not one<br />
penny is appropriated for<br />
<strong>military</strong> expenses. No<br />
provisions whatever are<br />
made for the pay or transportation<br />
<strong>of</strong> troops if called<br />
Courier page 15<br />
Edwin S. Gill, The Adjutant General<br />
<strong>of</strong> Arizona, 1892.<br />
out, for encampments or inspections, for court-martials, for<br />
headquarters, regimental or battalion <strong>of</strong>fice expenses, nor for<br />
necessary <strong>of</strong>ficial transportation, nor in short for anything.<br />
The utter inconsistency <strong>of</strong> the law is especially shown in the<br />
Article governing the Adjutant General’s <strong>of</strong>fice. It provides<br />
that “The Adjutant General shall also be ex-<strong>of</strong>ficio Quartermaster<br />
and Commissary General and Chief <strong>of</strong> Ordnance; that<br />
he shall furnish commissions, without charge, to all <strong>of</strong>ficers,<br />
issue and transmit all order, furnish blanks, muster rolls, certificates<br />
<strong>of</strong> election, oaths <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice, returns and copies <strong>of</strong> the<br />
<strong>military</strong> code, and such other supplies as may be authorized<br />
by law.” And yet no money is appropriated for this work and<br />
expense.<br />
The lack <strong>of</strong> funds has greatly hampered the organization<br />
in its very department. Some blanks have been furnished<br />
from this <strong>of</strong>fice, but not what there should have been, as the<br />
Adjutant General is not a Croesus.<br />
[Further on in the report--]<br />
There is now considerable call upon the time <strong>of</strong> the Adjutant<br />
general, by veterans <strong>of</strong> the Civil and Mexican wars, who<br />
ask for the assistance <strong>of</strong> this <strong>of</strong>fice in securing copies <strong>of</strong> lost<br />
discharges, etc., in seeking admission to Soldiers’ Homes and<br />
in other work. While it is not incumbent upon the Adjutant<br />
General to do this work, it would certainly not be humane to<br />
refuse any possible assistance to these aged veterans.<br />
In short the <strong>of</strong>fice has now become one <strong>of</strong> importance, and<br />
should be recognized accordingly. There is no other State in<br />
the Union which pays this <strong>of</strong>ficer less than $1,000 per annum,<br />
from that to $10,000, besides providing an <strong>of</strong>fice, pay for<br />
clerks, etc. An examination <strong>of</strong> the work <strong>of</strong> the <strong>of</strong>fice will<br />
show that it is greater than that devolving upon any other Territorial<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficial excepting the Governor and Secretary.<br />
[The remainder <strong>of</strong> the report contains reasons why Arizona<br />
needed the National Guard and why the Territorial legislature<br />
needed to fund the troops. This is an interesting document<br />
to read and compare to today’s National Guard needs.<br />
The National Guard <strong>of</strong> Arizona today faces many <strong>of</strong> the same<br />
problems with the state legislature that were experienced in<br />
1892; i.e. lack <strong>of</strong> building funds to repair existing armories.<br />
This document may be found the Arizona Military Museum<br />
Library.]
ARIZONA MILITARY MUSEUM COURIER<br />
(Published by the Arizona National Guard Historical Society, Inc.)<br />
MUSEUM LOCATION AND HOURS<br />
The Arizona Military Museum is located on the northeast corner <strong>of</strong> 52 nd Street and McDowell Road. Enter at the main entrance<br />
at 5600 East McDowell. The admission is FREE. The <strong>museum</strong> is open on Saturdays and on Sundays from 1:00 pm to 4:00 pm.<br />
Since our <strong>of</strong>ficers and directors are volunteers, the <strong>museum</strong> hours are related to their (volunteers’) availability. Please call the <strong>museum</strong><br />
to schedule tours beforehand to insure we’re not closed for holidays or the summer or for some other reason. The Arizona<br />
Military Museum number is 602-267-2676 or you may call (602) 253-2378.<br />
A FEW GOOD MEN AND WOMEN<br />
You can help the Arizona National Guard Historical Society by becoming a member, by making a tax-deductible donation,<br />
soliciting funds, by making the Historical Society a beneficiary in your will, or by donating historical artifacts. We<br />
invite you to serve on the Board if you are interested in Arizona <strong>military</strong> history and if you are willing to give <strong>of</strong> your time<br />
and effort to prioritize the <strong>museum</strong> activities in your already busy schedule. Call us if you are interested in becoming a<br />
board member at (602) 267-2676.<br />
Arizona National Guard Historical Society<br />
Arizona Military Museum<br />
5636 East McDowell Road<br />
Phoenix, Arizona 85008-3495