27.03.2013 Views

SUICIDAL CUT THROAT - A CASE REPORT - medIND

SUICIDAL CUT THROAT - A CASE REPORT - medIND

SUICIDAL CUT THROAT - A CASE REPORT - medIND

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

were present in the intestines.<br />

Death was opined as due to haemorrhagic<br />

shock resulting from incised wound on the neck<br />

produced by sharp weapon. Suicidal in nature. Time<br />

since death was given as 12-18 hours<br />

(approximately) at the time of autopsy. Injuries were<br />

antemortem in nature and fresh at the time of<br />

death.<br />

DISCUSSION<br />

Under Section 306 IPC, if any person commits<br />

suicide, whoever abets the commission of such<br />

suicide, shall be punished with imprisonment of<br />

either description for a term, which may extend to<br />

ten years, and shall be liable to fine. Under Section<br />

309 IPC, whoever attempts to commit suicide and<br />

does any act towards the commission of such<br />

offence, shall be punished with simple<br />

imprisonment for a term, which may extend to one<br />

year or with fine or with both[5]. Suicide is a problem<br />

with many facets from the psychiatric and<br />

psychological point of view on one hand and to the<br />

mechanic of the mode of death on the other. For<br />

every suicide there is a far larger number of<br />

attempted suicides and suicidal gesture, so that<br />

the successful suicides are merely the tip of the<br />

proverbial iceberg. According to WHO estimate,<br />

approximately 8,14,000 people died by suicide in<br />

the year 2000. In the past 45 years suicide rates<br />

have increased by 60% in some countries and<br />

suicide is now one of the three leading causes of<br />

death among those aged 15 - 34 years worldwide.<br />

This data clearly indicate that suicide is a serious<br />

public health problem[6]. In the present case study<br />

the victim was a 28-year-old male with a history of<br />

depression for the last few years. Suicidal deaths<br />

are attracting increasingly more attention from the<br />

medical professional and public health agencies.<br />

The common methods used for committing suicide<br />

in our country are hanging, consumption of poison,<br />

burns, jumping from height, drowning, firearms,<br />

stabbing etc. The choice of method used to commit<br />

suicide depends upon the availability of means,<br />

knowledge about lethal effectiveness and the<br />

victims' motivation and intent[7]. Regardless to any<br />

real or suspected trend, suicide is a public health<br />

problem by virtue of the present incidence[8].<br />

Agnihotri AK[9] stated that incised wounds are<br />

usually suicidal while chopped wounds (i.e. type of<br />

261<br />

JIAFM, 2005 : 27 (4). ISSN 0971-0973<br />

incised wound) and stab wounds are usually<br />

homicidal. They found the stab wound to be more<br />

common compared to cut throat in males as well<br />

as females. Suicidal incised wounds were found<br />

most commonly in the neck and wrist. The<br />

hesitation marks, which were superficial, were<br />

associated with the main wound in the neck region.<br />

The suicidal victims were found dead in their home.<br />

Injuries on the back and genitalia were uncommon<br />

in suicidals. According to Karisson T[10] stab<br />

wounds on the chest (horizontal) were commonest<br />

cause of suicide followed by cut in the wrist.<br />

According to his study, irrespective of sex, majority<br />

of both suicide and homicides took pace in the<br />

victim's home. In this present case the suicidal<br />

victim was found dead in his home with an incised<br />

wound in the neck and associated with hesitational<br />

wounds.<br />

CONCLUSION<br />

Cut throat is not the commonly preferred<br />

method for committing suicide. Homicidal cut throat<br />

injuries are more commonly found in others studies.<br />

The gravity of the situation that makes a person to<br />

commit suicide need to be dealt with and medical<br />

help should be provided once the person shows<br />

any symptoms and signs of suicidal tendency.<br />

Attempts should be made to reach out to this<br />

individuals and proper counseling should be done<br />

so as to enable them to cope with the situation.<br />

The public should also be made aware of Section<br />

306 and 309 IPC; because abetment of suicide is<br />

punishable under Sec. 306 IPC for a term, which<br />

may extend to 10 years and attempt to commit<br />

suicide is punishable under Sec. 309 IPC5 for a<br />

term, which may extend to 1 year, with fine or with<br />

both. The purpose of psychological autopsy are to<br />

identify factors that contributed to suicides, helps<br />

professional who work with suicidal client, prevent<br />

suicide in future and supplement findings on<br />

physical autopsy.<br />

References<br />

1. Horswell J. Suspicious Deaths,<br />

Encyclopedia of Forensic Sciences. Jay A<br />

Siegel, Pekka J Saukko and Geoffrey C<br />

Knupfer: Academic Press, San Diego, 2000,1:<br />

463.<br />

2. John P. Friel. Dorland's Illustrated Medical

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!