Download - Downbeat
Download - Downbeat
Download - Downbeat
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Wynton Marsalis Quintet &<br />
Richard galliano<br />
From Billie Holiday To<br />
Edith Piaf<br />
WYNTON MARSALIS ENTERPRISES 19457<br />
★★★½<br />
If you scan the list—surprisingly long, actually—of<br />
jazz recordings that have used the accordion,<br />
you will find that probably 95 percent<br />
were foreign-born, coming from such distant<br />
datelines as Paris, Italy and Istanbul. So domesticating<br />
the instrument’s romantic Left Bank<br />
melancholy into an American vernacular has<br />
proved elusive, even for those as varied as Duke<br />
Ellington, Buddy DeFranco, Benny Goodman<br />
and Anthony Braxton. Now add to the list Wynton<br />
Marsalis, whose quintet joins with French<br />
accordionist Richard Galliano to reflect on two<br />
very different national legacies, both bronzed in<br />
the special immortality of victimization and early<br />
tragedy. Recorded at the 2008 Jazz in Marciac<br />
Festival in southern France, the CD is accompanied<br />
by a DVD of the same performance.<br />
This is the second Billie Holiday remembrance<br />
to be treated in these columns this year<br />
(Dee Dee Bridgewater’s To Billie With Love, February<br />
issue), confirming the singer as perhaps the<br />
most persistent object of posthumous tribute in<br />
jazz. Many of her songs might have disappeared<br />
years ago but live on in a repertoire often sung in<br />
her name today—a pattern paralleled in France<br />
herbie hancock<br />
The Imagine Project<br />
HANCOCK RECORDS 0001<br />
★★★★<br />
Nostalgia doesn’t cut it for me,<br />
particularly when it concerns<br />
the ’60s, a transformational era<br />
that valorized looking forward,<br />
not backward. But I find Herbie<br />
Hancock’s grandly global<br />
re-imagining of that era’s<br />
communitarian, visionary and<br />
utopian ideals timely and appealing.<br />
Though Hancock himself seems to have<br />
become something of a pop music impresario in<br />
the manner of Quincy Jones—assembling stars<br />
for presentation rather than truly collaborating<br />
with them—he interacts with them quite a bit on<br />
this album. Recorded all over the world, it showcases<br />
some of my favorite performers, including<br />
slide blues guitarist Derek Trucks and his wife,<br />
blues singer/guitarist Susan Tedeschi; Brazilian<br />
singer Céu; Celtic headliners The Chieftains;<br />
sitarist Anoushka Shankar; and Los Lobos, to<br />
name a few, so no doubt a coincidence of personal<br />
taste has influenced my judgment on an<br />
album some may find merely a revue of marquee<br />
names meant to sell records. But the content and<br />
integrity here would argue otherwise.<br />
John Lennon’s “Imagine” has endured well,<br />
and India.Arie, Pink and Seal do it more than<br />
46 DOWNBEAT OCTOBER 2010<br />
by Edith Piaf. Holiday’s songs are the ones that<br />
fit the Marsalis Quintet most naturally, especially<br />
“Them There Eyes,” which Walter Blanding<br />
opens with three wonderfully relaxed choruses<br />
and then returns to take it out with a surprising<br />
tranquility. “What A Little Moonlight Can Do”<br />
gives us two brisk choruses from drummer Ali<br />
Jackson, who used his sticks like tap shoes, first<br />
on the snare rims and then on the hi-hat. Marsalis<br />
is needle sharp in his fastest and fiercest flights of<br />
pearly eighth-notes on the CD.<br />
Dan Nimmer treats “Sailboat In The Moonlight”<br />
almost as a mischievous parody of Erroll<br />
Garner with long, weeping tremolos playing<br />
catch-up with the beat. Marsalis, on the other<br />
hand, reverts to tradition. With Blanding curling<br />
around him on soprano, New Orleans-style, he<br />
justice as the song<br />
moves from dreamy<br />
contemplation to<br />
a rolling Afro-pop<br />
feel. Lennon’s caveat<br />
that he’s not<br />
the only “dreamer”<br />
is recapitulated in<br />
Peter Gabriel’s reassuring<br />
lyric to<br />
“Don’t Give Up,”<br />
sung inspirationally<br />
by John Legend, that<br />
“you can fall back<br />
on us,” even if the world has gone to hell. But<br />
Céu’s alluring whisper, answered by Hancock’s<br />
lushly impressionist piano, warns gently in Vincius<br />
de Moraes’ “Tempo Do Amor” that to have<br />
love and peace, one also must suffer. Tedeschi<br />
spurs a rousing vocal chorus of “learning to live<br />
together,” as Trucks’ guitar oozes ’60s ecstasy. A<br />
surprise highlight is Colombian superstar Juanes’<br />
“La Tierra,” which reminds us to love the earth as<br />
well as our “brothers” with an irresistibly danceable<br />
beat. You gotta have nerve to remake the<br />
Beatles’ “Tomorrow Never Knows,” but Dave<br />
Matthews somehow pulls it off with a gang of<br />
others, careening through a controlled, multi-directional<br />
chaos over a nervous beat. Clever to include<br />
Sam Cooke’s “A Change Is Gonna Come,”<br />
in that it refers to personal rather than social salvation,<br />
but James Morrison nicely evokes Cooke<br />
looks to Louis Armstrong as he builds simply<br />
and directly to a cathartic break and resolution.<br />
On “Strange Fruit” broad strokes of demonic<br />
instrumental imagery, fraught with whoops and<br />
growls, replace the lyric’s evil irony. Though<br />
over-emoted a bit here and there, the song becomes<br />
a dramatic, film noir dirge of New Orleans<br />
at its darkest and most demented.<br />
Of the four Piaf pieces, all are rendered with<br />
respect to their Frenchness. Marsalis seems<br />
most comfortable on “La Vie En Rose,” imported<br />
into the American jazz repertoire in 1950<br />
by Armstrong. But he avoids all Armstrong<br />
references, choosing instead a soft cup mute<br />
sound. “La Poule” and “Padam” are all Paris,<br />
but Marsalis finds plenty of smart, clever corners<br />
to work in the material. Co-star Richard Galliano<br />
contributes the European sensibility and one<br />
lovely original, “Billie,” which he has recorded<br />
twice before. He is every bit the nimble virtuoso<br />
on his hand-held keyboard, whose sound represents<br />
a part of the French heritage that remained<br />
largely in France rather than make the voyage<br />
with everything else French to New Orleans and<br />
the New World. This combination reunites them<br />
very nicely, indeed. —John McDonough<br />
From Billie holiday To Edith Piaf: la Foule; Them There Eyes;<br />
Padam ... Padam; What A little Moonlight Can Do; Billie; Sailboat<br />
In The Moonlight; l’homme A la Moto; Strange Fruit; la Vie En<br />
Rose. (69:55)<br />
Personnel: Wynton Marsalis, trumpet; Richard Galliano, accordion;<br />
Walter Blanding, saxophone, reeds; Dan Nimmer, piano;<br />
Hervé Sellin, piano (9); Carlos Henriques, bass; Ali Jackson, drums.<br />
ordering Info: wyntonmarsalis.com<br />
without imitating him and Hancock finishes off<br />
the track with some creamy piano alluvials.<br />
A couple of tracks don’t quite make the mark.<br />
Bob Dylan’s “The Times, They Are A’ Changin’”<br />
was a call to political action that warned oldsters<br />
to get out of the way, certainly not the gently<br />
sweet nudge suggested here by Lisa Hannigan<br />
and The Chieftains, though the fiery mix of kora<br />
and Irish fiddle at the end is brilliant. I didn’t find<br />
much to chew on during the ticking drone of Tinariwen’s<br />
“Tamatant Tilay/Exodus,” either.<br />
—Paul de Barros<br />
The Imagine Project: Imagine; Don’t Give Up; Tempo de Amor;<br />
Space Captain; The Times, They Are A’ Changin’; la Tierra; Tamatant<br />
Tilay/Exodus; Tomorrow Never Knows; A Change Is Gonna<br />
Come; The Song Goes On. (66:16)<br />
Personnel: Herbie Hancock, piano; larry Goldings (1, 2), Kofi Burbridge<br />
(4), Hammond B-3 organ; George Witty (2, 10), larry Klein<br />
(3), Pete Wallace (6), keyboards; Anoushka Shankar, sitar (10);<br />
Wayne Shorter, soprano saxophone (10); Matt Molloy, flute (5); Seán<br />
Keane, fiddle (5); Jeff Beck (1), lionel loueke (1, 5), Dean Parks<br />
(2), Derek Trucks (4), Fernando Tobon (6), Abdallah Ag lamida (7),<br />
Alhassane Ag Touhami (7), Abdallah Ag Alhousseyni (7), Elaga Ag<br />
Hamid (7), Danny Barnes (8), Michael Chaves (8), Dave Matthews<br />
(8), Dean Parks (9), guitar; Danny Barnes, banjo (8); Marcus Miller<br />
(1, 6), lucas Martins (3), larry Klein (1, 5, 7, 10), Danny Barnes (8),<br />
Tal Wilkenfeld (9) bass; Paddy Moloney, Uilleann Pipes, Tin Whistle<br />
(5); Toumani Diabate, kora (5); Vinnie Colaiuta (1, 2, 4, 6, 9, 10),<br />
Visi Vincent (1), Curumin (3), Manu Katché (5), Matt Chamberlain<br />
(8), drums; Alex Acuña (1, 2, 7), Mbiyavanga Ndofusu (1), Rodrigo<br />
Campos (3), Rhani Krija (5), Richard Bravo (6), Paulinho Da Costa<br />
(9), percussion; Said Ag Ayad djembé (7); Kevin Conneff, bodhrán<br />
(5); Bhawai Shankar, pakhawaj (Indian drum) (10); Sridhar Parthasarthy,<br />
mridangam (10); Satyajit Talwalkar, tablas (10); Augustin<br />
Makuntima Mawangu (1), Makonda Mbuta (1), likembé (thumb<br />
piano); Oumou Sangare (1), India.Arie (1), Fatoumata Diawara (1),<br />
Seal (1), Pink (1, 2), John legend (2), Céu (3), Susan Tedeschi (4),<br />
Kofi Burbridge (4), Mike Mattison (4), lisa Hannigan (5), Juanes (6),<br />
K’NAAN (7), Alhassane Ag Touhami (7), David Hidalgo (7), Conrad<br />
lozano (7), louie Pérez (7), Dave Matthews (8), James Morrison (9),<br />
Chaka Khan (10), K.S. Chitra (10), vocals; Hancock, Jessica Hancock,<br />
larry Klein, Alan Mintz, Maria Ruvalcaba, background vocals<br />
(6); Said Ag Ayad, Abdallah Ag lamida, Abdallah Ag Alhousseyni,<br />
Elaga Ag Hamid, Ibrahim Ag Alhabib, background vocals (7).<br />
ordering Info: herbiehancock.com