09.04.2013 Views

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION IMO STATE & ANOR. V. GODWIN ...

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION IMO STATE & ANOR. V. GODWIN ...

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION IMO STATE & ANOR. V. GODWIN ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

hereby quashed:<br />

(b) Whether the court was right to suo motu extend<br />

the life of an application which was brought out of<br />

time with out any application for extension of time?<br />

(c) Whether the trial court was right in holding that<br />

the Respondent, who had been retired on grounds<br />

of public interest under the pension Act, be<br />

restored to his office and for all his emolument to<br />

be paid.<br />

On his own part, the Respondent has in the Brief<br />

thereof (dated l4/7/06) filed on 18/7/06, inter alia,<br />

raised a preliminary objection challenging the<br />

competence of the appeal on the ground that it<br />

"was not brought within time and is an abuse of the<br />

process of this Honourable court".<br />

The Respondent has also identified 3 issues therein<br />

to wit:<br />

"(a) whether the trial court was not right in holding<br />

that the certiorari was applicable in his case.<br />

(b) Whether the trial court was not right in<br />

regularizing the application before it.<br />

(c) Whether the order to pay Respondent's unpaid<br />

emoluments was not proper.<br />

In response to the Respondent's brief, the Applicant<br />

filed a Reply Brief (dated 28/7/06) on 10/8/06. I<br />

have deemed it expedient to first deal with the<br />

issue of preliminary objection raised by the<br />

Respondent in the Brief thereof and replied thereto<br />

in the Appellant Reply Brief in question.<br />

As it were, the argument of the learned senior<br />

counsel on the preliminary objection is predicated<br />

on the grounds that:<br />

13

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!