download as a PDF
download as a PDF
download as a PDF
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
DEKHO<br />
Conversations on design in India<br />
DOCUMENTATION OF<br />
DIPLOMA PROJECT<br />
SEMESTERS 8–11<br />
GRAPHIC DESIGN.<br />
2011–12<br />
NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF DESIGN.
2<br />
3
4 DEKHO<br />
Conversations on design in India.<br />
5
6<br />
•<br />
☛<br />
✍<br />
•<br />
☀<br />
☏<br />
♥<br />
Acknowledgements.<br />
Thanks to the team at Codesign and Quicksand for all their<br />
guidance, support, contributions and the belief in me.<br />
Thanks to Mr. Suresh Immanuel, my project guide, and the<br />
graphic design faculty and staff at the National Institute of<br />
Design for course-correction and preparing me to face up to<br />
the challenges that come my way.<br />
I am grateful to the contributors for their time—late Professor<br />
Joshi, Wolfgang Weingart, M.P. Ranjan, Amar Deep Behl of the<br />
ADB Design Habit, Lakshmi Murthy at Vikalp Design, Ram<br />
Sinam and Sarita Sundar of Trapeze design, C<strong>as</strong>ey Re<strong>as</strong>, Stefan<br />
Sagmeister, Neelak<strong>as</strong>h Kshetrimayum, Orijit Sen and Gurpreet<br />
Sidhu at People Tree—and allowing me to give shape to their<br />
exciting stories.<br />
Thanks to Irma Boom for the insights into pacing the book,<br />
Steven Heller and Prof. H Kumar Vy<strong>as</strong> for kindly penning<br />
the forewords.<br />
Thanks to friends and batch-mates at NID for their<br />
encouragement and interest in the project that saw me through<br />
the few dull days.<br />
Thanks and respect to the staff at NID academic office for their<br />
<strong>as</strong>sistance and support all along.<br />
Thanks to the members of the extended family for all the love.<br />
7
8<br />
CON-<br />
TENTS<br />
Section 1 Section 2<br />
Section 3 Section 4<br />
Synopsis<br />
+ Codesign_11<br />
+ Dekko_12<br />
+ Why do a publication project + Why do<br />
this project_14<br />
+ Brief description of the<br />
project process._16<br />
+ The timeline_18<br />
The Brief<br />
+ Initial project brief_21<br />
+ Reading, research and redefining the brief_22<br />
+ Re-looking at the stories_24<br />
+ Aspirations_26<br />
+ Indian design versus design in India_28<br />
C<strong>as</strong>e studies_30<br />
PROCESS<br />
1 Content_35<br />
+ New Stories / Inclusion / Exclusion<br />
+ Decisions on the structure/format of articles<br />
+ Example process of developing the form of a story<br />
2 Design_30<br />
3 Physical format_42<br />
4 Treatment of articles_45<br />
+ Example of design process illustrated with selected pages_49<br />
5 Paper and printing_74<br />
6 Typeface(s)_76<br />
7 The Grid_80<br />
8 Details of the printed book_80<br />
Infr<strong>as</strong>tructure concerns<br />
+ Sponsors_92<br />
+ Pitching and fundraising_92–93<br />
+ Printing, publishing, distribution_95<br />
The Journey_96<br />
References_99<br />
Colophon_100<br />
Contact Information_101<br />
9
10<br />
Section 1<br />
This section is an<br />
overview of the entire<br />
diploma project.<br />
It describes the project<br />
background, the process,<br />
and describes the<br />
experiences and learning.<br />
SYN-<br />
OPSIS<br />
Client And Sponsor: Codesign<br />
Codesign is an independent brand communication studio b<strong>as</strong>ed in Gurgaon, founded<br />
when a few NID graduates got together, collaborating on a handful of projects and now<br />
works with people across disciplines and domains of specialisation. The studio is headed<br />
by Rajesh Dahiya and Mohor Ray, graduates from NID.<br />
The studio occupies one of the very few remaining green patches in the otherwise<br />
overbuilt Gurgaon landscape, works in close collaboration with Quicksand, a product<br />
innovation and research studio housed in the same building. Apart from client projects,<br />
Codesign also works on self initiated projects of contemporary relevance. Along with<br />
Quicksand and few other collaborators, the studio organises Unbox Festival, a multidomain<br />
conference that hosts discussions and workshops on design, among other<br />
subjects—entrepreneurship, social responsibility, urban development, food and the arts.<br />
Having completed my internship at Codesign the previous summer, the work<br />
environment and people were familiar, and there w<strong>as</strong> no “breaking in” period. Being<br />
a self-initiated project by the studio, everyone w<strong>as</strong> familiar with the premises and<br />
<strong>as</strong>pirations of the project, and thus, ready with suggestions and help all along.<br />
11
12 Dekho!<br />
Initiated<br />
<strong>as</strong> journal documenting inspiring stories of design, and<br />
practitioners of design in India, Dekko had ambitiously sought<br />
to—and continues to—meet the need for a design publication/<br />
platform that did not resort to presenting designer portfolios<br />
in accordance to the trends of the time, but related stories of<br />
people and institutions behind the exemplary work. At the<br />
time of its conception, there were hardly any platforms with a<br />
similar intent. The design blog phenomenon had not happened<br />
yet. Then, the platform w<strong>as</strong> thought of <strong>as</strong> a periodic journal,<br />
which demanded a set of recognisable visual features in terms of<br />
presenting the content. It h<strong>as</strong> been four years since the project’s<br />
ideation and the media discussing design h<strong>as</strong> undergone a sea<br />
change. There are a number of regularly updated design blogs,<br />
magazines that concentrate on <strong>as</strong>pects of design. Owing probably<br />
to time constraints, most of them remain product showc<strong>as</strong>es and<br />
most of the visual design leave much to be desired. So, when the<br />
studio decided to start work again on the publication, the format<br />
and content had to be redefined and there were a new set of<br />
parameters.<br />
The Name<br />
13
14 WHY<br />
DO A PUBLICATION PROJECT?<br />
WHY this PROJECT?<br />
Rajesh<br />
j<br />
Dahiya had mentioned this publication when I w<strong>as</strong><br />
interning and suggested I think about taking it up while I<br />
complete the academic projects. My interests were torn between<br />
designing a display typeface in Malayalam and taking up a<br />
studio-sponsored project by the end of the second academic<br />
project. By then, I had also nurtured a love for content related<br />
to design, reading every single project description posted on<br />
Experimental Jetset’s website, consuming all kinds of content<br />
offline on practitioners of design and the work that goes behind<br />
constructing the impressive pieces in each portfolio, in addition<br />
to the projects themselves. Then, on one of his visits to the<br />
institute, Dahiya mentioned that the studio considered it a<br />
good time now to bring the project back to life, with possible<br />
sponsorships and some infr<strong>as</strong>tructure for distribution in place.<br />
The fact that the project, unlike a typical publication, demanded<br />
more than a layout or even a system of displaying periodic<br />
content—there w<strong>as</strong> the possibility of generating content itself<br />
and visuals—and the possibility of total creative freedom—since<br />
the “clients” were people who shared the final-year-designstudent’s<br />
(often utopian) visions of graphic design—convinced<br />
me this w<strong>as</strong> one of the few opportunities of a lifetime that would<br />
come a diploma student’s way.<br />
I had not done a full-fledged publication project not limited<br />
by budgetary or technical constraints (the ones I had, were<br />
optimised for very economic modes of production, being notfor-profit<br />
projects) and had never dealt with content in the way<br />
I always wanted to, and this one ticked all the right boxes. I w<strong>as</strong><br />
also looking for an extended educational experience, which I<br />
knew this studio environment could provide.<br />
Deciding on a diploma project is defining the next six months of<br />
one’s working life. It w<strong>as</strong> also a time to decide on what medium<br />
I wanted to concentrate on. Apart from the obvious screen-orsubstrate,<br />
independent-studio-or-in-house-design-team choices,<br />
the larger picture, for me, w<strong>as</strong> about where to position myself<br />
in the process of making something. This project offered ample<br />
opportunities to be part of generating content, editing and<br />
generating visuals that would form a whole.<br />
The apparent creative freedom and opportunity for exploring<br />
unconventional formats and visual styles when working on a<br />
self-funded, self-published project is what helped me decide on<br />
working with Codesign on Dekho.<br />
At a time when the publishing industry is torn between the<br />
screen and the printed page, with economic conditions not-sofavourable<br />
for putting big money into expensively produced,<br />
well crafted books, it made—probably <strong>as</strong> a response, however<br />
subconsciously—perfect sense to see how viable it is to put<br />
efforts into making and financing a book, to know whether it is<br />
a sustainable enough practice to want to continue publishing a<br />
series eventually.<br />
15
16<br />
IN BRIEF:<br />
PRO-<br />
CESS<br />
Brief description of the project<br />
process. Find the process in detail<br />
discussed from Page 23 onwards.<br />
I began the project going through design magazines and blogs,<br />
Indian and international. Also available w<strong>as</strong> an unfinished<br />
version of Dekko 1, which could not be published. Some of the<br />
stories for my project were to be borrowed from this version,<br />
while the content would undergo re-writing and updating, with a<br />
second round of interviews<br />
We began by emailing, calling up, and visiting people who had<br />
contributed to the first version and searching for new stories.<br />
As replies trickled in, I started defining features of the finished<br />
product. At this point, however, I had failed to understand the<br />
nature of the format and pace of the publication, and had formed<br />
a mental image of a recurring magazine in its place. The layout<br />
w<strong>as</strong> designed—at this point—to be flexible, space-saving and<br />
generic enough to accomodate a variety of content and styles. The<br />
version I produced w<strong>as</strong> also genenric, lacking the flavours and<br />
pacing of the stories being told.<br />
The decisions of how the content w<strong>as</strong> to be distributed across the<br />
pages had thus become a matter of economy and a fixed style.<br />
After a guide visit, talking to Mr. Suresh, and listening to people<br />
who have devoted a lifetime to creating publications led me to<br />
rethink the format and pacing of the magazine, after having<br />
spent four months and considerable design-time on the project.<br />
I could re-use some of the artwork I had done for the first draft,<br />
but the page size and the philosophy of the book w<strong>as</strong> not the<br />
same anymore. The magazine had become a book at l<strong>as</strong>t, an object<br />
designed to reflect the nature of its content, even at the cost of<br />
being a more time-and-money consuming exercise. The studio,<br />
thankfully, w<strong>as</strong> fully supportive of my decision to scrap all the<br />
work up to that point and head in a different direction.<br />
From that point on, I let the content dictate most <strong>as</strong>pects of page<br />
design, focusing on giving enough space for each idea to sink in.<br />
After finishing few articles, the printers were contacted so that<br />
they can give us an estimate and show some samples of similar<br />
(in volume and production quality) books.<br />
With the finished articles, we approached potential sponsors<br />
(most of them cultural institutions) and vendors who could<br />
subsidise the production cost.<br />
The project overshot my initial target of six months by about a<br />
year, owing also to the nature of collecting stories.<br />
At DesignYatra 2012, the Codesign team<br />
met Irma Boom, who commented that<br />
the book needed to do justice to the<br />
importance of the content and respect the<br />
pacing of it.<br />
17
18<br />
TIME-<br />
The Project<br />
LINE<br />
April 18<br />
25<br />
May 2<br />
9<br />
16<br />
23<br />
30<br />
June 6<br />
13<br />
20<br />
27<br />
July 4<br />
11<br />
18<br />
25<br />
August 1<br />
8<br />
15<br />
22<br />
29<br />
September 5<br />
12<br />
19<br />
26<br />
October 3<br />
10<br />
17<br />
24<br />
31<br />
November 7<br />
14<br />
21<br />
28<br />
December 5<br />
12<br />
19<br />
26<br />
January 2, 2012<br />
9<br />
16<br />
23<br />
30<br />
February 6<br />
13<br />
20<br />
27<br />
March 5<br />
12<br />
19<br />
26<br />
April 2<br />
9<br />
16<br />
23<br />
30<br />
May 7<br />
14<br />
21<br />
28<br />
June 4<br />
11<br />
18<br />
25<br />
July 2<br />
9<br />
16<br />
23<br />
30<br />
August 6<br />
13<br />
20<br />
27<br />
September 3<br />
Understanding the Brief, Analysis of Dekko 1, Precedent Studies<br />
Finding People & Stories, Information Collection<br />
Interviews and Further Research<br />
Making Transcripts, Editing and Creating Finished Copy<br />
The time-line I had prepared at the<br />
beginning of the project could not<br />
completely be adhered to. The project<br />
started in April 2011 and the publication<br />
went to print in October 2012, taking<br />
close to seventeen months. This includes<br />
revising the structure midway, gathering<br />
the content and proof-reading the<br />
revised material.<br />
= Two-week Units, proposed timeline at the beginning of the project<br />
= Extended, actual timeline<br />
Design Stage:<br />
Illustrations and Additional<br />
Visual content + Layout,<br />
Refinements (Two stages)<br />
Documentation<br />
Some stories had to be dropped at this<br />
point, owing to deadline complications<br />
and second thoughts on relevance of these<br />
stories. A process of filling the gaps—both<br />
in numbers and in content—began.<br />
This particular time schedule w<strong>as</strong> b<strong>as</strong>ed on the studio’s concern<br />
over ending up spending too much time on the preparation of<br />
content and, <strong>as</strong> a result, little time finetuning the actual visual<br />
design. However, gathering stories and visuals for each article<br />
took up more than eighty percent of the duration of the project,<br />
beyond all anticipation and planning.<br />
The design w<strong>as</strong> executed in at le<strong>as</strong>t two ph<strong>as</strong>es of iteration.<br />
This helped ensure there w<strong>as</strong> always something to work on<br />
while waiting for replies from different (often busy and out of<br />
town) people. In the first stage, I divided and fitted the content<br />
into pages and executed a b<strong>as</strong>ic layout, with artwork and type<br />
treatments more or less in place. At this stage I added only b<strong>as</strong>ic<br />
elements to help navigation and the flow of each article. The<br />
entire book w<strong>as</strong> completed in that f<strong>as</strong>hion. Since each article w<strong>as</strong><br />
treated differently and worked on over a long period of time, there<br />
were jarring inconsistencies in style. The pages were put up on<br />
a softboard (for weeks) and we noted down what could be added/<br />
removed or changed from the version. The differences that crept<br />
up over time could thus be more or less evened out.<br />
The design stage doesn’t end until the<br />
proof from the offset printer arrives<br />
and is signed off. To realise this, it took<br />
me countless all-nighters, including<br />
ones at Thomson Press, Okhla, where<br />
we waited for the digital proofs to be<br />
printed and bound, at three in<br />
the morning.<br />
19
20<br />
Section 2<br />
This section describes the<br />
client brief, the philosophy<br />
in terms of positioning the<br />
book <strong>as</strong> well <strong>as</strong> its visuals<br />
and content.<br />
BRIEF<br />
The<br />
THE STUDIO’S<br />
INITIAL BRIEF.<br />
CREATE A PUBLICATION<br />
JOURNALING INSPIRATIONAL<br />
STORIES OF DESIGN IN INDIA.<br />
Codesign h<strong>as</strong> engaged in curation of<br />
content from early on. With Dekho, the<br />
studio wanted to create a platform for<br />
discussion of design in India and the people<br />
behind work done in the domain. Initiated<br />
<strong>as</strong> a journal focusing on communication<br />
design, the plan w<strong>as</strong> to expand its reach<br />
to include all design disciplines. The<br />
publication had to be a well designed object,<br />
and the studio wanted it to be a statement<br />
on Indian design, attempting to transcend/<br />
redefine the popular definitions and skewed<br />
perceptions of the same.<br />
The project targeted design enthusi<strong>as</strong>ts,<br />
students and professionals from India<br />
and abroad. It could also be of interest<br />
to the general public <strong>as</strong> an object<br />
well crafted. The content, styled after<br />
conversations, helped get rid of the<br />
heavy-handed-ness of speaking<br />
about design.<br />
The format, production methods and<br />
content were flexible enough, <strong>as</strong> long <strong>as</strong><br />
it adhered to the initial vision.<br />
The original idea of creating a periodical<br />
did come with some definitions on the<br />
visual language. In the first version of<br />
the publication, I used these <strong>as</strong> grounds<br />
for making most decisions, <strong>as</strong> opposed<br />
to the content dictating design in the<br />
finished version.<br />
21
22<br />
REDEF-<br />
INING<br />
&THE<br />
BRIEF.<br />
READING,<br />
RESEARCH<br />
The first few weeks at the studio were spent going through<br />
old drafts of the publication, diploma documents that dealt<br />
with the process and articles both online and offline which<br />
discussed publication design and editorial design in depth. My<br />
l<strong>as</strong>t project being an interactive one dealing with rudimentary<br />
code and hardware <strong>as</strong>pects, I had ended up taking a long<br />
break from designing publications and working with editorial<br />
responsibilities. To revision the studio’s effort, one needed to have<br />
a clear picture of where to position the product in a shelf-full of<br />
design-showc<strong>as</strong>e publications and research journals.<br />
Reading the old version of the publication and the documentation<br />
of its making helped make a list (and later, a spreadsheet) of<br />
things I would like to avoid and things that had merit in them.<br />
There were screen (<strong>PDF</strong>) and printed versions of the initial effort.<br />
Comparing the <strong>PDF</strong> and the printed book, I could see how some<br />
decisions must have made sense on a screen preview and, in<br />
print, could not make the same impact. This is a mistake I had<br />
been making all along, working in the safe zone of the computer<br />
screen, ignorant to how it translates to ink on paper. For the<br />
studio, the project w<strong>as</strong> but an exercise which tested my (and<br />
their) abilities in gathering and presenting the content. More<br />
than a tangible product at the end, the learning and experiences<br />
from that effort mattered. Being able to reflect on these in the<br />
visual design w<strong>as</strong> an added advantage. As for me, this helped set<br />
rough estimates <strong>as</strong> to what the studio’s expectations are and<br />
how extensive the work is going to be. (But these estimates were<br />
constantly being broken and rebuilt, <strong>as</strong> the stories grew and<br />
influences changed.)<br />
The later ph<strong>as</strong>es of precedent research focused on changes in<br />
the media environment and target audience. The internet h<strong>as</strong><br />
made accessing designer portfolios and related content e<strong>as</strong>ier,<br />
with the added advantage of being able to draw references from,<br />
and point to multiple sources. Since 2005, a number of design<br />
blogs catering specifically to Indian design (according to their<br />
own definitions) have come to existence, along with a handful<br />
of design magazines (lion’s share of them design showc<strong>as</strong>es) and<br />
conferences on design. Dekho <strong>as</strong> a magazine w<strong>as</strong> not a unique<br />
(or viable) idea anymore, unless the content and presentation<br />
filled the gaps left by the volley of new products on bookshelves.<br />
In this c<strong>as</strong>e, however, we were looking at an extended shelf-life<br />
for the publication, beyond that of a monthly magazine or a<br />
journal (which would be read once and shelved with no chances<br />
of recovery) and making it something the reader would want<br />
to go back to, time and again. Technological barriers have been<br />
broken since, and the reader’s attention span is said to have been<br />
reduced. But, before printed matter migrated to touch devices,<br />
features of on-screen media had found their way into the printed<br />
page. Magazines like Wired have long since adapted symbols and<br />
elements of interaction from screen.<br />
See the timeline.<br />
23
24<br />
Revision of old content.<br />
The content structure from the studio’s<br />
first effort and my remarks.<br />
Letters From the E<strong>as</strong>t. Amar in the Making.<br />
Current Structure<br />
History<br />
Recent Developments<br />
Neelak<strong>as</strong>h<br />
His Experiences<br />
Possible Additions/Modifications<br />
Better image content including sketches from the development<br />
stage of the typeface, images of Meetei Mayek in use in today’s<br />
Manipur<br />
More recent developments including the further development on<br />
the script and the Government policies, how the script is being<br />
used and promoted<br />
More backgroundd information from research, some political<br />
situations<br />
Similar stories, references, adds to the RESOURCE part of the<br />
publication<br />
Mayek projects. What Meetei Mayek h<strong>as</strong> done to Neelak<strong>as</strong>h’s<br />
ventures since<br />
/ Other work<br />
Money versus soulful design / <strong>as</strong>k meaningful questions<br />
Future / what happens now<br />
Needs much more information on neelak<strong>as</strong>h's experience<br />
of designing the typeface <strong>as</strong> a student. We need to find more<br />
questions to get more information from him on his experience?<br />
Perhaps the other factual information on the script should be<br />
isolated from Neel's dialogue?<br />
Would be nice to add a small note at the end with what he and<br />
others have been doing with the script lately."<br />
Remarks<br />
Pull out quotes <strong>as</strong> a standalone thing/ not pulled out of the text.<br />
Refer to eyemagazine.<br />
Image captions and tagging issues. Placing images and the<br />
captions together/colour-tagging them.<br />
Negative light on typeface design/the script. The text makes it<br />
sound <strong>as</strong> if the design process happened at the cost of major<br />
personal pain(s).<br />
The 10 point comparison is misleading? If at all there needs to be<br />
a comparison, b<strong>as</strong>e it on same x height?<br />
Wrong pullout quotes<br />
Notes<br />
Add intricacy and complexity / Indian<br />
The article <strong>as</strong> a conversation starter / “Here is some stuff, see<br />
what you want to make of it”<br />
Tone of voice needs to be more authoritarian/looking at the<br />
reference <strong>as</strong>pects of it/maybe offset it with a more playful visual<br />
language<br />
Look at colours in a subjects website/book/body of work to b<strong>as</strong>e<br />
the colours and embellishments in each story<br />
Parallels<br />
Design Issues<br />
The Ride magazine<br />
The Art of Looking Sideways<br />
Current Structure<br />
Influences<br />
NID, CEPT, JNU, Interests<br />
About Exhibition Design<br />
USSR Exhibition, Experiences<br />
World of TVS, working on models<br />
Film Production / Partition<br />
Possible Additions<br />
Design Habit’s work on MUSEUMS and permanent spaces<br />
? Talk to Ajoy David<br />
Permanent spaces v/s temporary corporate exhibitions. What<br />
Amar talks about in all other interviews about a possible burnout<br />
and plans for a retirement.<br />
Materials and processes/some quirky ones like the butterfly<br />
canopies at the Mahindra expo. (ref: Story from one of the online<br />
articles)<br />
Introduce NID and CEPT somewhere? Talk about Exhibition<br />
Design department in NID and earlier exhibitions?<br />
Not clear how JNU enters and exits the story in relation to NID.<br />
Amar's issues with NID on return are not clear.<br />
What w<strong>as</strong> amar's award-winning final project?<br />
Maybe we can add Amar's viewpoint on design education while<br />
he is reminiscing about his student days?<br />
Re-consider choice of project for production design.<br />
Showc<strong>as</strong>e one project (maybe ongoing) for a permenant museum?<br />
Remarks<br />
Better information breakdown.<br />
Reformat the timeline of projects <strong>as</strong> an infographics in one whole<br />
spread. (why)<br />
Project choices can be b<strong>as</strong>ed more on involvement/experiences +<br />
popularity, the production design project in particular<br />
Notes<br />
Old Photographs<br />
Sketches from all museum work instead of 3D renders<br />
Talk about the exposure to the medium bringing in lowered<br />
attention spans. Screen is no more enough to grab attention<br />
Signages versus spaces debate<br />
Spirituality / Amar gets interested in spirituality at some point<br />
while in NID<br />
The poem Mahindra and Mahindra wrote about Oriole after the<br />
IEFT exhibition<br />
Parallels<br />
Le Corbusier, Charles Correa, Laurie Baker<br />
25
26<br />
AS<br />
PIRA<br />
TIONS.<br />
“Moore and Gibbons designed Watchmen to showc<strong>as</strong>e the unique<br />
qualities of the comics medium and to highlight its particular<br />
strengths. In a 1986 interview, Moore said, “What I’d like to<br />
explore is the are<strong>as</strong> that comics succeed in where no other media<br />
is capable of operating,” and emph<strong>as</strong>ized this by stressing the<br />
differences between comics and film. Moore said that Watchmen<br />
w<strong>as</strong> designed to be read “four or five times,” with some links<br />
and allusions only becoming apparent to the reader after several<br />
readings. Dave Gibbons notes that, “<strong>as</strong> it progressed, Watchmen<br />
became much more about the telling than the tale itself. The<br />
main thrust of the story essentially hinges on what is called<br />
a macguffin, a gimmick… So really the plot itself is of no great<br />
consequence… it just really isn't the most interesting thing about<br />
Watchmen. As we actually came to tell the tale, that’s where the<br />
real creativity came in.” Wikipedia: Watchmen.<br />
With the publication, I wished to create an object that celebrated<br />
features unique to the printed book, emph<strong>as</strong>ising its nature <strong>as</strong><br />
a thing to behold. Ideally, this would mean a book that cannot<br />
be read <strong>as</strong> well in <strong>PDF</strong> or <strong>as</strong> an ebook, <strong>as</strong> in print. One of the main<br />
sources of inspiration and a thing that set the initial direction<br />
for visual design w<strong>as</strong> a book compiling select issues of U&lc—the<br />
design magazine from International Type Company—which<br />
used to be in circulation from 1973 to the autumn of 1999. In<br />
addition to Herb Lubalin’s way of treating type being a personal<br />
favourite, the magazine’s strikingly modern use of fluid grids<br />
(the grids were almost never present, in a sense) w<strong>as</strong> suggesting,<br />
I thought, a fitting way to present stories from individuals who<br />
were so different from each other in terms of the work-output<br />
and their philosophies relating to life and work. The question of<br />
what it means to have an Indian aesthetic approach, however,<br />
<strong>as</strong> a student of design who grew up idolising western graphic<br />
design giants and having almost taken for granted the outlook<br />
of Experimental Jetset on work, would be a difficult one for me<br />
to find answers to, but is a question worth spending months<br />
mulling over. The constant feedback from team-members at<br />
the studio, the project guide, people who were approached for<br />
funds, designers from India and abroad and the discovery of illfitting<br />
elements after taking breaks from visual design to design<br />
content—all of this played a major role in shaping my <strong>as</strong>pirations<br />
along the way. With the p<strong>as</strong>sing of each deadline, I w<strong>as</strong>n’t upset<br />
at time lost, but w<strong>as</strong> hoping for that resonance of content with<br />
design to happen.<br />
A year after starting the project, the stakes were higher, with<br />
changes in the bookshelves, and on the public sphere in relation<br />
to content around design. TAKE had an issue on design for sale,<br />
with commendable texts on design, design blogs in India had<br />
started discussing design beyond the visual presentation of<br />
finished pieces.<br />
Pages of U&lc, photographed from<br />
Mr. Immanuel Suresh’s collection.<br />
We are firm believers in the utopian<br />
dimension of design. It’s something we’re<br />
absolutely convinced of. It’s our main<br />
drive. But we aren’t sure if this utopian<br />
dimension can be found in utilitarianism,<br />
or social messages. Those particular forms<br />
of engagement can be strong sources of<br />
inspiration for the designer, and in that<br />
sense they certainly play an important<br />
role, but they often lack a real dialectical<br />
potential. In our view, a true utopian<br />
design should change people’s way of<br />
thinking, not just their opinions.<br />
If we are indeed living in a fragmented<br />
society (and we believe we are) then<br />
perhaps the only way to shock us out<br />
of this alienation is to counter the<br />
fragmentation of society with the<br />
wholeness of design. In that sense, the<br />
utopian dimension is to be found in the<br />
internal organization of the designed<br />
object, its inner-logic.<br />
Quoted from:<br />
http://www.experimentaljetset.nl/archive/dripdry-shirts.html<br />
27
28<br />
INDIAN<br />
DESIGN<br />
An autorikshaw? the dabbawallah? steaming chai? (supposedly)<br />
street typography? the ubiquitous bindi? references to Bollywood<br />
posters of yesteryears?<br />
versus Design In India<br />
A Google image search for Indian design brings up myriad<br />
instances of mehndi patterns. Intricacy and ornamentation seem<br />
to be the key elements throughout.<br />
It is saddening to see how often design from india is preconceived<br />
to border on functionless aesthetic supplements, and nothing<br />
much else. More often than not, unfortunately, work produced in<br />
India fails to have an identity of its own beyond those demarkated<br />
by popular perception. Part of the exercise I wished to undertake<br />
w<strong>as</strong> to arrive at an interpretation that respected functional<br />
<strong>as</strong>pects of design in India. In a country where a vernacular word<br />
that equals design doesn’t exist, it is natural to turn to texts and<br />
people from beyond its boundaries for guidance and inspiration.<br />
It w<strong>as</strong>, therefore, an editorial decision to preempt kitsch from<br />
the compilation of stories. This doesn’t mean I had taken up the<br />
mission of redefining Indian design. What it meant to me w<strong>as</strong><br />
that the presentation needed to be authentic, devoid of anything<br />
that doesn’t add to the no-frills perception of the book <strong>as</strong> a well<br />
designed object.<br />
Kitsch causes two tears to flow in quick succession. The first tear says:<br />
How nice to see children running on the gr<strong>as</strong>s! The second tear says: How<br />
nice to be moved, together with all mankind, by children running on the<br />
gr<strong>as</strong>s! It is the second tear that makes kitsch kitsch.<br />
This internal discussion on Indian sensibilities of design and the<br />
apparent lack of local written accounts on design practitioners<br />
helped define the context and decision to include inspirational<br />
and intelligent design (and practitioners) from India and abroad.<br />
In our opinion, the addition of stories from outside our sociocultural<br />
boundaries complement our on views on form and<br />
function, while serving <strong>as</strong> stories of inspiration and contr<strong>as</strong>t.<br />
As a nation that h<strong>as</strong> undergone colonial rule for two centuries,<br />
the vestiges of longing to ape a different civilisation are everpresent<br />
in our societal and cultural leanings, which reflect in our<br />
art and design philosophies <strong>as</strong> well. Turning to mindless kitsch<br />
serves only <strong>as</strong> a vehicle to m<strong>as</strong>s appeal, however short-term. In<br />
reality (or my version of it) intelligent design practice in India<br />
h<strong>as</strong> long since severed its ties to kitsch. Possibly, design education<br />
b<strong>as</strong>ed on models of western origin brought about this change, but<br />
the results are far from alien or lacking in authenticity. Dekho<br />
subscribes to this view of design in India, and presents the stories<br />
that inspire, rather than lull us into a sense of belonging.<br />
Internationally, there is a big gap in the understanding of the<br />
“Indian” in Indian Design, largely because of a lack of context.<br />
NID projects that I later went through, while compiling MP<br />
Ranjan’s interview for Dekho cemented my belief in indigenous<br />
design intelligence.<br />
From the introduction to Dekho:<br />
Identity, being closely linked to culture, is a complicated matter<br />
in a country <strong>as</strong> profusely diverse <strong>as</strong> India. Across the country,<br />
manmade rituals of language, celebration, food and apparel<br />
change every few hundred kilometers. For centuries, India h<strong>as</strong><br />
nurtured a culture of <strong>as</strong>similation and integration—absorbing<br />
and creating hybrid expressions from the heritage of its<br />
conquerers, travellers and other settlers. This makes it difficult to<br />
separate what is truly Indian, and what is adopted. Furthermore,<br />
a rich heritage of craft heavily influences the perception of<br />
identity in design. The familiarity of what we know <strong>as</strong> Indian and<br />
traditional, sometimes poses a steep challenge to deviation<br />
and innovation. There are likely to be multiple answers to this<br />
debate around the Indian identity—and it is quite in the spirit of<br />
a multi-cultural society that several answers will find acceptance<br />
in parallel. The key is to look at the search for “an Indian way” not<br />
<strong>as</strong> a definitive solution-finding exercise, but a long-term, multipronged<br />
effort to build a body of knowledge around design in<br />
India that can serve <strong>as</strong> valuable reference for discourse.<br />
Much later, in his foreword to the book,<br />
this is something Steven Heller mentions.<br />
Parallels to the sentiment could also be<br />
drawn from the book Eames Primer by<br />
Eames Demetrios, where he recalls the<br />
idea of being able to build cardboard<br />
computers indigenously, instead of<br />
importing IBM machines.<br />
"Kitsch is the absolute denial of shit."<br />
29
30<br />
CASE<br />
STUDIES<br />
This is a selection of few<br />
examples from the pool of<br />
c<strong>as</strong>e-studies prior to the<br />
design stage.<br />
To acquire a broad perspective on documentation of design that<br />
h<strong>as</strong> been done before in India, I went through design blogs and<br />
publications (even showc<strong>as</strong>es), seeing how the content w<strong>as</strong><br />
written and supported by images and diagrams. Something to pay<br />
special attention to w<strong>as</strong> the physical properties—size, weight and<br />
materials—that made one object more covetable than the other.<br />
In the process, I came to conclusions b<strong>as</strong>ed on personal and peergroup<br />
perceptions, often making dummies to see how decisions<br />
of size and format work, while actually reading it <strong>as</strong> a book.<br />
On looking back, I realise how I could have made a mistake by<br />
looking at magzines <strong>as</strong> parallels to this project. It w<strong>as</strong> much later<br />
into the project (four months) that I figured the pace of the book<br />
resembled that of a recurring magazine more than it should have.<br />
This happened after my first guide-visit, talking to Suresh about<br />
the vision and being able to browse through his collection of<br />
U&lc, Emigre and other influential pieces of design, and meeting<br />
Irma Boom at a design conference in Goa.<br />
Eye: The International Review of Graphic Design (Issue 78)<br />
Issues Per Year<br />
Quarterly<br />
Price<br />
£ 75 / £ 40 (Students)<br />
Size cm (w x h x spine)<br />
33.7 x 38.7 x .9<br />
Pages<br />
112 + cover<br />
The page number varies 88 and 96<br />
Ads<br />
12, including subscription ad. Varies to 17-18 pages.<br />
All are design related. type foundries, image banks and paper/<br />
print providers<br />
Binding<br />
Perfect<br />
Content Structure<br />
Features - 3<br />
Cover story / Theme of the issue -19<br />
Uncoated : 1 column + Reviews<br />
Content Treatment<br />
Front cover: Blown up image relating to the issue’s theme, no<br />
textual information on the content<br />
Back cover: Contents from any three articles, with no page<br />
number or indexing information. Even recent issues had<br />
indication to which article the quote is pulled from. Older issues<br />
(60) had indexes with writers and cover-lines(article titles)<br />
mentioned on the back cover<br />
Interviews have commentaries added on the opening spreads.<br />
Articles are well researched, with references mentioned within<br />
the text. Still, the opening spreads remain true to a set style<br />
and layout.<br />
Image Treatment<br />
Each image h<strong>as</strong> a detailed caption. Explaining the project,<br />
significance, etc.<br />
Books and objects are photographed against a neutral<br />
background. Never shown <strong>as</strong> held by hands or clipped. The<br />
featured books’ sides are aligned to the grid, not the background<br />
space. When possible, they are shown at real size/in a full page.<br />
Notes<br />
Extensive colophon (take an image reference)<br />
Issues numbered sequentially, making it e<strong>as</strong>y to search and locate<br />
Different stocks and printing techniques for inserts making full<br />
use of the perfect binding<br />
Grid<br />
6 and 8 columns overlayed<br />
The grid is strictly followed across all issues and articles<br />
31
32<br />
ID: The International Design Magazine (Discontinued since)<br />
Issues Per Year<br />
8 times a year<br />
Price<br />
$ 7.99<br />
Size cm (w x h x spine)<br />
33 x 37.4 x .5<br />
Pages<br />
128 (88 to 128)<br />
Ads<br />
26 Including back cover and inside covers<br />
Binding<br />
Perfect<br />
Content Structure<br />
Cover story 1 / Features - 10 / Departments (columns)<br />
Columns: letters, update(id story developments fro the year<br />
before), note, expo(stuff to buy), q+a, rant(design philosophy +<br />
theory), eco, new and notable, crit, back story(on daily objects/<br />
history)<br />
Content Treatment<br />
Most are reports and essays on work. Interviews are given <strong>as</strong> is or<br />
interspersed with commentary<br />
Content treated somewhat according to content, utilising infographics<br />
at places where required<br />
Opening spreads designed to suit the content (typography and<br />
image treatment both)<br />
Each article h<strong>as</strong> a title and subtitle in the beginning, which gives<br />
a better understanding of the content at a glance.<br />
Links below each article point to the studios and people whose<br />
work is discussed<br />
Front cover: Image from a story inside/relating to a story inside,<br />
plus index on top.<br />
Back Cover: Ad<br />
Image Treatment<br />
Images are treated <strong>as</strong> if in a showc<strong>as</strong>e, even when they are<br />
discussed for their design merit/part of a story. Well maintained<br />
tagging structure with colour codes and shapes.<br />
Portraits include meaningful parts of the studio or working<br />
environment. Shots are specifically arranged for each story, fitting<br />
to the format and layout.<br />
Notes<br />
Discontinued Since Jan/Feb issue 2010<br />
Three typefaces throughout<br />
No colophon mentioning typefaces and printer/paper<br />
Grid<br />
6 and 8 columns overlayed<br />
Kyoorius Magazine (Issue 7)<br />
Issues Per Year<br />
Quarterly<br />
Price<br />
Rs 500 per issue<br />
Size cm (w x h x spine)<br />
21.4 x 39 x 1.2<br />
Pages<br />
136 pages + cover<br />
Subscription card inside<br />
Ads<br />
7 Ads including 1 call for entries<br />
Binding<br />
Sections of 16 pages + 20 pages<br />
Content Structure<br />
Studio Profiles 3<br />
Feature Interview<br />
New Work: Design 2 / Advertising 4<br />
Special Report 3Dutch DFA<br />
C<strong>as</strong>e Study<br />
Illustrator<br />
Education (graduates’ perspective)<br />
Snapshots (gallery of event kdy 2010)<br />
Content Treatment<br />
Front cover: Changes with each issue: typographic, different<br />
coloured stock+printing in 1 colour<br />
Back cover: typographic, borrows style from the front, lists all<br />
content with page numbers. More like a weekly magazine than a<br />
repository of information<br />
project Showc<strong>as</strong>e with little insight to the individual stories<br />
behind each artist/designer<br />
Layout not governed by the type or content of the story. fixedgrid-b<strong>as</strong>ed<br />
layout<br />
Outright portfolio-like showc<strong>as</strong>e of designers/studios and their<br />
work<br />
Image Treatment<br />
Image content is provided by individual studios. No consistency,<br />
but similar to the ones in the studio websites.<br />
Grid<br />
3 and 4 columns overlayed<br />
33
34<br />
Section 3<br />
PRO<br />
CESS<br />
1. CONTENT New Stories And The Process Of Inclusion And Exclusion.<br />
As a general theme/filter for choosing the right content,<br />
we decided to focus on people who have transcended their<br />
chosen academic domains to create a body of work relevant to<br />
contemporary Indian social/economic/creative sensibilities.<br />
This meant there w<strong>as</strong> already a “story” of transformation<br />
inherent in each person/organisation and would thus make the<br />
content that much richer.<br />
This being the first issue to be published, we had the luxury of<br />
acquiring some stories from witnhin the studio’s network of<br />
friends and their friends. These were people with an experience<br />
of being “in business” for more than fifteen years. Interviewing<br />
people with that quantity of inspiring bodies of work and the<br />
<strong>as</strong>sociated stories seemed to me a good opportunity. We listed<br />
down potential people (more than the number that could be<br />
included in a publication within the given time) and <strong>as</strong>sociated<br />
them with generalised keywords, so that we could look at a<br />
larger picture that showed us the amount and extent of variety<br />
within. The stories also formed connections with each other,<br />
which helped me structure the publication later on. This also<br />
served <strong>as</strong> a secondary filter to decide on which stories would<br />
suit the format better. The initial idea w<strong>as</strong> to redefine Dekho <strong>as</strong> a<br />
publication that transcends visual communication and presented<br />
other disciplines <strong>as</strong> well. The variety of the stories, we hoped,<br />
would more than compensate for the apparent lack of inclusion<br />
of other disciplines in this volume. So, <strong>as</strong> a platform for telling<br />
stories, the existing ones work well. Furthermore, the discussion<br />
on what kind of filters and modes to set in place so that acquiring<br />
of stories become less time/energy consuming and more<br />
streamlined, aided limiting the number of stories per issue, so<br />
that enough emph<strong>as</strong>is could be given on each individual article.<br />
Also, from a studio infr<strong>as</strong>tructure point of view, attempting a<br />
hundred-page publication seemed doable compared to churning<br />
out a three-hundred-page-thick book every year. The resources<br />
required—both human and financial—would be immense, and<br />
prohibitive, otherwise.<br />
This w<strong>as</strong> not the c<strong>as</strong>e, when, after a few<br />
emails and phone conversations, some<br />
stories had to be dropped, either because<br />
we felt they had not ripened enough to be<br />
part of the book, or because the deadlines<br />
were constantly being ignored.<br />
35
36<br />
The People Tree<br />
shop at Hauz Kh<strong>as</strong><br />
village, New Delhi .<br />
What keeps you going even<br />
after 20 years?<br />
Gurpreet It is other people’s energies. It is the<br />
response of the world—when I am feeling<br />
down and I meet somebody…<br />
The other day I met somebody at our<br />
first shop in Connaught Place. He w<strong>as</strong> an<br />
American guy, who had been living in India<br />
for a long time. He said, “I have been coming<br />
here for so long. I tre<strong>as</strong>ure everything I have<br />
bought from you. Particularly one Batik<br />
T-shirt I bought long time ago, it is still<br />
so beautiful and so nice to wear, I may<br />
have to stop wearing it, but I am going to<br />
keep it forever.”<br />
This kind of thing really makes you feel OK.<br />
Decisions On The Structure/Format Of Articles. The Introductory Texts.<br />
This w<strong>as</strong> influenced by the overall “feel” expected of the finished<br />
product <strong>as</strong> well <strong>as</strong> precedent studies. The idea w<strong>as</strong> to let content<br />
guide the design of each article, keeping minimum amount of<br />
visual features constant to hold the book together. The obvious<br />
bits are the body text that follows the same style throughout the<br />
book—Greta Text Regular, 9pt on a 11pt b<strong>as</strong>eline grid—and the<br />
Pantone 805 highlights and accents. The other thread that ties the<br />
complete book together is the conversational <strong>as</strong>pect of the textual<br />
content. Most of it is edited to retain the flavour of listening to<br />
someone talk p<strong>as</strong>sionately about something they live by, over<br />
a chai. The overwhelming vibes of being inspired, humbled and<br />
then ending up <strong>as</strong>king questions about the nature of work one<br />
is doing, w<strong>as</strong> something I w<strong>as</strong> sure couldn’t be missing from<br />
the finished product, however intense the temptation of neatly<br />
aligned rows of text w<strong>as</strong> going to be.<br />
The structure of each article, therefore had the extra role of a<br />
unifying element. Presenting all stories <strong>as</strong> interviews (questions<br />
followed by answers) with pulled-out pieces and an introductory<br />
text not only solved this problem, but also reflected the visual<br />
structure, in that the design took cues from each studio/designer<br />
and the work (if any) shown.<br />
Excerpt from the People Tree story:<br />
Sometimes I meet some people that I have<br />
of lost touch with. They say, “Didi, jo kaam<br />
apke sath seekha tha, woh ham bhulenge nahi.”<br />
(Sister, the work we learnt with you, we will<br />
never forget it.) So then I feel like it matters.<br />
Someone coming and saying this space is<br />
an iconic space, it is a symbol for certain<br />
things—then I feel like it matters.<br />
It would be really nice to go and set up shops<br />
like our space in CP, in various little colonies.<br />
We would love to work with a much more<br />
People tend to slot us, but we don’t slot<br />
ourselves. People get a surprise sometimes<br />
when they say, “So you work with natural<br />
dyes” and we reply saying “No, we never<br />
saidwe were going to work only with<br />
natural dyes”. We don’t take these thing<br />
and carry it like a load on our backs.<br />
“You don’t work with chemicals?”<br />
“Bullshit, we do. Who said we don’t? ”<br />
Or “You must be not eating any meat?”<br />
“Nonsense, I do, what are you saying?”<br />
We are human beings, we have the right<br />
to enjoy and engage with everything <strong>as</strong><br />
much <strong>as</strong> possible.<br />
middle cl<strong>as</strong>s audience and see if we can<br />
compete with the products that are being<br />
used there currently. That is where the most<br />
sub-standard, ghatiya (horrible) stuff is going.<br />
People tend to slot us, but we don’t slot<br />
ourselves. People get a surprise sometimes<br />
when they say, “So you work with natural<br />
dyes” and we reply saying “No, we never said<br />
we were going to work only with natural<br />
dyes”. We don’t take these thing and carry it<br />
like a load on our backs.<br />
“You don’t work with chemicals?”<br />
“Bullshit, we do. Who said we don’t? ”<br />
Or “You must be not eating any meat?”<br />
“Nonsense, I do, what are you saying?”<br />
We are human beings, we have the right<br />
to enjoy and engage with everything <strong>as</strong><br />
much <strong>as</strong> possible.<br />
In conversation with<br />
Gurpreet Sidhu<br />
People Tree<br />
132_Of The Head, Hand And The Heart 133<br />
of FACES DEKHO.<br />
12<br />
80<br />
204<br />
134<br />
These were drafted, put next to each other so that differences<br />
could be evened out. Each one referenced the interview directly<br />
with sentences alluding to the content inside and indirectly<br />
adding a flavour of each person’s body of work. The introductory<br />
texts were to never reveal the whole content, but act <strong>as</strong> an<br />
anchoring bit of text to pull the reader in. Later, the content page<br />
would acquire this responsibility and move away from revealing<br />
any dry facts.<br />
P8 Foreword: Prof. H Kumar Vy<strong>as</strong><br />
P9 Foreword: Steven Heller<br />
P12–P267 The Conversations<br />
P270 Credits<br />
P271 Colophon, Imprint<br />
38<br />
58<br />
226<br />
102<br />
164<br />
242<br />
In 12 , MP Ranjan reflects on his experiences <strong>as</strong> a design educator<br />
Learning Ground<br />
and evangelist, driven by his deep conviction in the fact that designled<br />
intervention can bring wonderful changes for India. In 38 , the<br />
late Professor Raghunath K Joshi makes a c<strong>as</strong>e for sound <strong>as</strong> a precursor<br />
Spoken Words<br />
to written word and talks of the Deshanagari project—an ambitious<br />
undertaking which explored the possibilities of type-setting in Indian<br />
languages b<strong>as</strong>ed on the way they are spoken. Neelak<strong>as</strong>h Kshetrimayum<br />
Letters From The E<strong>as</strong>t<br />
takes us on a personal journey to the hills of Manipur in 58 , where<br />
a dying native script Metei Mayek, is finding a new life with design<br />
interventions like his type design projects. Lakshmi Murthy, 80 , does<br />
By The People. For The People.<br />
not subscribe to a top-down, generalised approach to developmental<br />
communication. She offers valuable insights through her work in<br />
rural India—co-designing effective, localized models for social<br />
communication with the user. In 102 , Orijit Sen and Gurpreet Sidhu,<br />
Of The Head, Hand And The Heart<br />
founding partners of the iconic Indian brand—People Tree, celebrate<br />
the intelligence of the head and the hand, and talk about craft <strong>as</strong> their<br />
approach to design. Ram Sinam and Sarita Sundar look beyond the<br />
Kerning Space<br />
brief at their design consultancy Trapeze in 134 —elevating dialogues in<br />
spatial design from what is said to how it is said. Amardeep Behl wants<br />
Amar In The Making<br />
you to be uncomfortable in 164 . Restlessness, he says, is the mother of<br />
all design, and in the course of the conversation, walks you through<br />
the intricate spatial narratives created by his practice DesignHabit.<br />
In 204 , Wolfgang Weingart, known for his explosive rejection of the<br />
Through Hot Metal<br />
Swiss Style and radical experiments, continues to inspire new forms of<br />
expression. Stefan Sagmeister, despite the absence of an introduction<br />
Stefan Sagmeister Needs No Introduction<br />
in 226 , shares his life’s lessons with honesty and zeal, tinged <strong>as</strong> always<br />
with his inimitable sense of humour. 242 is C<strong>as</strong>ey Re<strong>as</strong> sharing his<br />
Process<br />
f<strong>as</strong>cination with the idea of emergence, and taking us along a journey<br />
exploring the binaries of naturally evolving and synthetic systems.<br />
6 7<br />
The Contents Page, Forewords, Introduction, etc.<br />
The contents page is the first page where the reader encounters<br />
all the stories at once. I felt it would be an injustice to the<br />
conversational nature of the book to have a contents page just<br />
listing the various sections, interviews and such. The rough<br />
draft I wrote in the thumbnail w<strong>as</strong> meant to spark the reader’s<br />
interest with catchy phr<strong>as</strong>es derived off the quotes and pull-outs<br />
from each article—in effect, the main themes of each story. It<br />
contained crude lines like “C<strong>as</strong>ey Re<strong>as</strong> lets the dot go on a walk of<br />
its own.” The second, edited version, <strong>as</strong> it appears in the book is a<br />
much evolved, informative version that retains the flavour of<br />
the first draft.<br />
37
38<br />
Introduction Forewords<br />
The introduction is left extremely long, since that reflects the<br />
project history the best. The format w<strong>as</strong> predecided to make the<br />
reader hold the book like a long scroll, emph<strong>as</strong>ising the lengthy<br />
process and ensuring enough attention is paid to the text before<br />
moving on to visually richer sections of the book.<br />
This plays the double-role of being a mission statement and a<br />
how-to of consuming the book <strong>as</strong> an object.<br />
In recent times, conversations and questions around “What is Indian design” have begun to feature prominently in<br />
design & innovation forums across the country. Design interventions, visible in products, services, brands, and<br />
communication, are being examined closely by users and the creative community, to determine their suitability<br />
and sensitivity to the Indian context.<br />
Identity, being closely linked to culture, is a complicated matter in a country <strong>as</strong> profusely diverse <strong>as</strong> India. Across the<br />
country, manmade rituals of language, celebration, food and apparel change every few hundred kilometers. For<br />
centuries, India h<strong>as</strong> nurtured a culture of <strong>as</strong>similation and integration—absorbing and creating hybrid expressions<br />
from the heritage of its conquerers, travellers and other settlers. This makes it difficult to separate what is truly<br />
Indian, and what is adopted. Furthermore, a rich heritage of craft heavily influences the perception of identity in<br />
design. The familiarity of what we know <strong>as</strong> Indian and traditional, sometimes poses a steep challenge to deviation<br />
and innovation. There are likely to be multiple answers to this debate around the Indian identity—and it is quite in<br />
the spirit of a multi-cultural society that several answers will find acceptance in parallel. The key is to look at the<br />
search for “an Indian way” not <strong>as</strong> a definitive solution-finding exercise, but a long-term, multi-pronged effort to<br />
build a body of knowledge around design in India that can serve <strong>as</strong> valuable reference for discourse.<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
As a design studio working with local and international brands for a predominantly Indian audience, we are often faced<br />
with comments like “This does not look Indian,” or references to cliches <strong>as</strong> “This is Indian,” and “This works for<br />
India.” A fair percentage of widely available and consumed design products in India work on accepted cliches<br />
of “Indianess,” thereby further perpetuating these beliefs in the eyes of the market, clients and the design<br />
community. Despite the emergence of multiple forums for showc<strong>as</strong>e for design in India, there is little knowledge<br />
of the behind-the-scenes stories of designing in and for India. Dialogue only around a few, finished examples of<br />
design, precludes knowledge-sharing about experiences, alternative viewpoints, failures and revelations that<br />
inspire. For students and young practicing designers, there is little access to the real-life experiences of designers<br />
in India. To understand the fine connections between tradition, culture, modernization and design, and to inspire<br />
a truly “Indian” way of design, it is imperative that we nurture and create repositories of knowledge. This body of<br />
knowledge should provide room for introspection, for reflection. It should provoke new questions. Most of all, it<br />
needs to be real—honest and bold from the experiences of practitioners in India.<br />
Dekho is an anthology of inspirational conversations with designers in India, probing their stories for cues to the<br />
development of design in India and highlighting approaches that are unique to designing for India. In 2007,<br />
Dekho began <strong>as</strong> an idea, fuelled by constant conversations within the studio about the lack of Indian heroes<br />
for young design students. For the next few months, working through an intimate network of contacts within<br />
the community, we travelled—meeting and recording conversations with designers, whose thoughts and work<br />
struck a chord with our quest to understand the unique context of Indian design. The selective addition of<br />
international voices for the publication came about with the desire to present stories that contained relevant<br />
cues for contemporary design developments in India. The experience of the raw content that we gathered w<strong>as</strong><br />
overwhelming in parts. With the first prototype of Dekho <strong>as</strong> a publication in our hands, we paused to consciously<br />
think about our role <strong>as</strong> curators and creators in this. In the next 3 years, there w<strong>as</strong> a great surge of activity in<br />
design forums and platforms in India, yet most of these continued to be showc<strong>as</strong>e-b<strong>as</strong>ed, and lacking the voice of<br />
the designer. This w<strong>as</strong> in part due to the lack of writers with a good understanding of design, and the absence of<br />
connections between design and the world/issues at large. After an extended break, the effort behind Dekho w<strong>as</strong><br />
revived with greater clarity. People, places and stories were revisited—for stories within their stories, for contexts<br />
that had changed in the interim, and for new people who had inspired us. The conversations were re-captured to<br />
focus on issues and ide<strong>as</strong> that are pertinent to the maturing of design in India, ranging from inclusive approaches<br />
to developmental communication, revival of dying Indian scripts, to the future of design education and the<br />
building of an iconic Indian brand by design entrepreneurs.<br />
The conversational format of Dekho, stems from the latent richness that is at the core of conversations, <strong>as</strong> opposed to a<br />
commentary or report. Conversations have the innate quality to break boundaries, meander through seemingly<br />
unrelated territories and converge at <strong>as</strong>tonishing points of relevance, and most importantly, open up ide<strong>as</strong> for<br />
interpretation. While editing and creating formats for the stories, we have been conscious of retaining quirks of<br />
the spoken word—which may not always conform to norms of written language—but are expressive and laden<br />
with the speaker’s intent.<br />
Book design in India h<strong>as</strong> been largely relegated to two extremes—academic and textual, or showc<strong>as</strong>e-b<strong>as</strong>ed, “coffee-table”<br />
publications. Dekho explores possibilities in print design—driven by the voices and their stories. Design for Dekho<br />
is a rich visual narrative that creates an experience of the unique context of each person, their work and their<br />
ideology. The book is designed to not just be read from start-to-finish; but with multiple layers of image + text, it is<br />
meant to be experienced anew, with each new story and each new page.<br />
4 5<br />
Dekho means “To See” in Hindi. At the outset, it is a simple word, <strong>as</strong> is the intention behind the project—to build context<br />
for design in India not by imposing a set of characteristics or rules, but simply sharing real, personal experiences<br />
of designing for/in India.<br />
On deeper scrutiny, “See” can mean a dozen different acts of recognition—discern, spot, notice, catch sight of, glimpse,<br />
make out, pick out, spy, distinguish, detect, perceive, watch, look at, view, inspect, view, look round, tour, survey,<br />
examine, scrutinize, understand, gr<strong>as</strong>p, comprehend, follow, take in, realize, appreciate, recognize, work out, get the<br />
drift of, find out, discover, learn, <strong>as</strong>certain, determine, establish…<br />
That is what we hope the experience of Dekho will achieve for the reader—multiple take-aways and interpretations,<br />
making for a larger, diverse and richer view of design in India.<br />
8<br />
Charting A New Path In<br />
India’s Design Journalism<br />
Prof. H Kumar Vy<strong>as</strong><br />
The forewords were planned to reflect the diversity inside the<br />
book, penned by two eminent authors who are giants in their<br />
respective fields. It w<strong>as</strong> also interesting to see the viewpoints of<br />
somebody inside the country looking at its design <strong>as</strong> well <strong>as</strong> an<br />
external observer.<br />
Email exchanges were promptly responded to, and both the<br />
people agreed to write forewords b<strong>as</strong>ed on work-in-progress <strong>PDF</strong>s<br />
we could send at that time.<br />
There h<strong>as</strong> been a long felt need among the Indian design fraternity for a<br />
platform to share each other’s work, not just <strong>as</strong> narratives of design solutions,<br />
but at the deeper level of concept building and problem solving process. It is<br />
good to know that Dekho is going to do exactly that.<br />
It is interesting that the editorial team should select this particular name for<br />
the journal. The conventional meaning of ‘dekho’ may convey the impression<br />
of having to do only with seeing or looking at. And hence in the extended<br />
context of design, confined to visual communication. Dekho, a Hindi verb<br />
in imperative mood originates from Sanskrit root verb drish which may<br />
primarily mean ‘to see or behold’. But in its secondary and more profound<br />
meaning it begins to suggest acts of ‘seeing with the thinking eye’, of<br />
examining and learning and even of composing—implying composition of<br />
poetic hymns.<br />
And <strong>as</strong> its contents rightly suggest, Dekho does not confine itself to<br />
visual communication only. Right from the word go, it promises a much<br />
wider reach—embracing all the modern disciplines of design and their<br />
practitioners. It sets out to challenge the hitherto held stereotypical notions<br />
about Indian design everywhere. The re<strong>as</strong>on for this, <strong>as</strong> it rightly points out,<br />
is largely the lack of right kind of documentation of the context and the<br />
process behind design projects. Dekho h<strong>as</strong> embarked on the formidable t<strong>as</strong>k<br />
of meeting this vey lacuna.<br />
The graphic format of Dekho charts out hitherto unexplored avenues of<br />
visual communication. It informs copiously; at the same time excites and<br />
challenges the imagination of the reader.<br />
Referring once again to the present contents of Dekho, it seems to hold<br />
a promise for exciting future possibilities. It h<strong>as</strong> provided an excellent<br />
platform for designers to converse freely about their inspirations, endeavours<br />
and learning. At the same time it holds promise of expanding into a<br />
repository of meticulously recorded c<strong>as</strong>e studies of selected design projects to<br />
inspire young practitioners and design learners.<br />
FORE WORD<br />
Together We Are One (Sometimes)<br />
Steven Heller<br />
So many things could link all humankind together. Yet so few opportunities<br />
arise to make these connections. We share music and art, sports and movies,<br />
but too often these shared p<strong>as</strong>sions are experienced without connecting to<br />
others. Even with social media <strong>as</strong> our current glue, we are still far away – and<br />
many prefer it so or there wouldn’t be so many obnoxious pseudonyms in use.<br />
Graphic design h<strong>as</strong> magnetic powers. Since graphic designers are so often<br />
misunderstood and misperceived, when we find and commiserate with<br />
others who do more or less what we do, and we become instantly engaged. Is<br />
it like “you’re a freak too? Let’s be freaks together!”? Of course not. Graphic<br />
design is not a freakish practice, nor is it entirely invisible and unknown. As<br />
designers we enjoy the tribal <strong>as</strong>pect of being a graphic “person.” And even<br />
more than enjoyment, we yearn to be with others like ourselves, even if they<br />
are thousands of miles and cultural boarders away.<br />
So when Rajesh Dahiya <strong>as</strong>ked me to contribute this brief introduction to<br />
Dehko, I felt like I w<strong>as</strong> invited on a journey beyond anywhere I have ever<br />
travelled. In truth, I sit in my noisy office in New York, listening to the street<br />
being torn up yet again, while scanning through the material I received. And<br />
it reveals to me an <strong>as</strong>pect of Indian design I haven’t known before. My only<br />
point of reference for the Indian design field is work that I’d seen come out of<br />
the National Institute of Design in the Seventies. At the time, I w<strong>as</strong> bored by<br />
orthodox modernism in America. Helvetica had taken the joy out of design.<br />
Swiss design fit like a glove into the austere stereotype. Corporate America<br />
had co-opted the Typographic International Style for the same re<strong>as</strong>on the<br />
CIA embraced Abstract Expressionism—it w<strong>as</strong> safe. Modernism had lost its<br />
radical raison d’être <strong>as</strong> Abstract Expressionism had become institutionalized.<br />
I may be very wrong, I know designers who would not be where they are<br />
today were it not for NID. But I have also seen work that convinced me the<br />
National Institute of Design fell for the trappings of the modernism, while<br />
the products of modernism, in fact, were not <strong>as</strong> good.<br />
Dehko offers me, at le<strong>as</strong>t, a different view and more hopeful feeling.<br />
It incorporates rather than segregates, it embraces rather than pushes away.<br />
It accepts the old and new, the modern and vernacular – in short it seeks<br />
to harness the power of design through the joy of design. When Rajesh<br />
<strong>as</strong>ked me to write my thoughts, I thought this is will be a link to foreign<br />
culture and fellow designer. The only difference between us is water and air<br />
(and perhaps the colour of our hair). More publishing efforts like this,<br />
which p<strong>as</strong>sionately and honestly confront stereotypes through eclectic and<br />
eccentric belief should occur in the world. They may just bring us together,<br />
if only for a moment.<br />
9<br />
39
40<br />
The process of developing the form of a story.<br />
Interview 1 » Transcript+Notes » Interview 2 » Transcript+Notes » Drafts » Verification+Approval » Article<br />
Background Research And The First Draft Of Questions. First Round Of Answers And The Second Draft Of Questions.<br />
I went through each person’s work (the parts we thought the<br />
article should focus on, when talking about design practice) in<br />
all available forms—web, print and in the form of audio/video<br />
interviews and presentations, when available—making notes<br />
and drafting questions where relevant. The questions were<br />
intended to supplement the available information and highlight<br />
the “journey” <strong>as</strong>pect of each person’s work and process. We had<br />
discussions after each draft of questions were made, where they<br />
were analysed from a potential target-audience-point-of-view.<br />
The questions were crafted to ensure that a “yes” or “no” w<strong>as</strong><br />
never generated <strong>as</strong> an answer, but the idea w<strong>as</strong> discussed in<br />
detail. To this end, we added cues (which were later removed from<br />
or incorporated to the edited content, depending on relevance)<br />
and broke the questions up so that each part would be looked at<br />
in detail. For example, a question about Amar’s work-philosophy<br />
would cite an instance from a project where it shows through,<br />
often getting rich and awe-inspiring stories behind creation of<br />
that particular project. The questions were circulated within the<br />
editors, the creative head and a studio member, before they were<br />
mailed to the interviewee or presented at a meeting. This ensured<br />
no redundant information got through and the story <strong>as</strong> a whole<br />
w<strong>as</strong> clear.<br />
Editing in space.<br />
In most c<strong>as</strong>es, the first set of replies were to-the-point, but<br />
not lacking in vital information. I highlighted the parts which<br />
could be explained further, framed questions b<strong>as</strong>ed on the first<br />
set of replies and started highlighting sections to be supported<br />
by images. If these images were available online, I would make<br />
a collection of screengrabs, with the URI wherever possible,<br />
and send them over so that higher resolution images could be<br />
arranged for. The process of discussion, reframing and adding<br />
cues w<strong>as</strong> repeated at each step. A second round of questions—in<br />
some questions, this w<strong>as</strong> happening after years of finishing the<br />
first interview, which enabled us to include the latest bits of<br />
the stories and refine the older version with new discoveries,<br />
realisations and hindsight.<br />
The iterative process of generating content helps not only in<br />
rectifying things and adding to it, but the layered stories get<br />
much richer with time. So each article also becomes a marker of<br />
time, and in some c<strong>as</strong>es, space.<br />
Compilation, correction, pull-outs and notes.<br />
I would cut-up the printed out content, put it up on the studio<br />
wall and create a simple narrative out of the answers by moving<br />
them around. Image content that I had thought of including<br />
would be marked with Post-Its in place, adding or substracting to<br />
fit the new flow of content. The edited content would be put into<br />
the design software, a b<strong>as</strong>ic framework of text-space and imagespace<br />
would be figured out with grey (4:3) rectangles for images.<br />
This b<strong>as</strong>ic flow of text+images serves <strong>as</strong> a starting point<br />
in figuring out more information (captions, notes, credits,<br />
acknowledgements, etc.) and I would start looking for the sources<br />
and references to be mentioned, if any. After receiving the images,<br />
this is the first thing we do, sending a low resolution copy of the<br />
<strong>PDF</strong> to people interviewed or their studios, <strong>as</strong>king to add relevant<br />
comments and notes for the images. It w<strong>as</strong> a matter of great joy<br />
for most people to go through these images from their p<strong>as</strong>t, make<br />
unexpected discoveries and recall incidences which would later<br />
make the image captions richer than I imagined.<br />
41
42 “What a commited reader h<strong>as</strong> with a book is a relationship. And<br />
like most relationships, it is sustaining, volatile, vulnerable…<br />
the question is—does the book remain the same book the second<br />
time around? Are we even the same readers when we revisit<br />
these books? …it seems to me that our experience alters the book<br />
even <strong>as</strong> the book alters our experience.”<br />
The Groaning Shelf<br />
Pradeep Seb<strong>as</strong>tian<br />
2. PHYSICAL FORMAT<br />
The book <strong>as</strong> an object wants to be picked up, held and carried<br />
along. To decide what kind of an object Dekko ought to be, I<br />
looked through bookshelves (both at the studio and the nearby<br />
Landmark) to see what sizes appealed to me, while constantly<br />
reminding myself to not arrive at an average that would end<br />
up invisible among books in a shelf. The final dimensions were<br />
calculated b<strong>as</strong>ed on these experiences and in a way so that there<br />
is minimum of paper getting w<strong>as</strong>ted after the trim.<br />
The book, opened, h<strong>as</strong> proportions close to 4:3, which corresponds<br />
to the proportion of still photographs from most digital/film<br />
camer<strong>as</strong>. This would later allow me to control the pace of the<br />
publication with full-spread images whenever required, without<br />
losing important parts of the image. The revision of paper size to<br />
half of that of the original made the book double <strong>as</strong> thick, which<br />
added to differentiating it from the familiar magazine format.<br />
The book, closed, me<strong>as</strong>ures less than a 15 inch laptop, which<br />
would enable it to fit into most laptop bags/c<strong>as</strong>es and be carried<br />
around with e<strong>as</strong>e.<br />
The decisions were b<strong>as</strong>ed on analysis of the target audience’s<br />
environment, resources available at the studio’s disposal, modes<br />
of funding the project and most importantly, the desired “feel” of<br />
the finished product.<br />
Proportions / Page Size / Number of Pages / Economics<br />
The opened spread me<strong>as</strong>ures 310<br />
millimetres in width and 225 millimetres<br />
in height.<br />
43
44<br />
3. IMPOSITION AND PAGE PLANNING<br />
An initial estimate allocated around<br />
seventeen pages per article, and an<br />
additional sixteen pages for information<br />
on people featured, credits, foreword, page<br />
seperators and the lot. This gave a total of<br />
220 pages, which could be section bound.<br />
Printing thirty two pages per a sheet<br />
me<strong>as</strong>uring 70 by 100 centimeters, one copy<br />
of the publication would take seven such<br />
sheets to complete, leaving some margin<br />
for error.<br />
After the “pacing” happened and new<br />
stories were added, the total number of<br />
pages stood at 270, rounded off to 272, with<br />
enough breathers in between stories,<br />
sections and heavy content.<br />
4. VISUAL TREATMENT, DESIGN Blooming Late. The next few pages will describe the<br />
<strong>as</strong>pects of visual design of the book,<br />
including page-layout process for some<br />
of the articles, with sample spreads<br />
discussed at length.<br />
How a magazine and a book are/can be different. What (if) makes a<br />
book more covetable compared to a magazine. Also looking at e<strong>as</strong>e of<br />
access to information online/in libraries and how the publication’s tone<br />
of ‘reporting from the field’ dictates the visual language to have some<br />
<strong>as</strong>sociation with/with the work of the person in the article.<br />
Introduction of electronic means of distributing content h<strong>as</strong><br />
made possessing books a more nuanced experienced than what<br />
it used to be. Arguably, design trumps content when it comes to<br />
making a decision to pick up and hold onto a book. The nature<br />
of the book’s audience demanded that I offer ple<strong>as</strong>ant surprises<br />
when it came to presenting content.<br />
On one of the evenings at the studio, looking at the pages pinned<br />
to the board, a colleague <strong>as</strong>ked me whose work is it that w<strong>as</strong> in<br />
the spreads discussing Weingart’s story. This is something I have<br />
<strong>as</strong>ked myself n number of times during the project. The apparent<br />
freedom over content and design, and the enthusi<strong>as</strong>m with which<br />
the studio encouraged tinkering with the “normality” of design<br />
convinced me the book is to be “mine” first, and talking about the<br />
people and places later. I saw it <strong>as</strong> a way of bringing authenticity<br />
to the pages. My way of dealing with this is to let the content<br />
inform all <strong>as</strong>pects of design, often treating each page <strong>as</strong> a separate<br />
entity, disconnected with the rest of the book. All this w<strong>as</strong> later<br />
visually tied together with the common element of a fifth, special<br />
ink that ran across pages.<br />
45
46<br />
I began working on the project imagining Dekho <strong>as</strong> a magazine.<br />
Naturally, I w<strong>as</strong> concerned with saving space on paper, rigidness<br />
of content hierarchies and grids, etcetera. The first-first draft<br />
of the publication, thus, had its leanings toward a recurring<br />
magazine in terms of overall visual language. This did not allow<br />
enough “mental” space for thoughts that demanded their fair<br />
share of the page and pauses, after them. “Pacing” the read w<strong>as</strong><br />
what I failed to accomplish with the version. During my first<br />
guide visit, Mr. Suresh suggested I might want to look at each<br />
story with a different “philosophy” in mind and develop the<br />
visual structure accordingly. After four months of working on the<br />
project, I had the opportunity to show the work-in-progress pages<br />
to Irma Boom—the Dutch designer who is considered one of the<br />
most original and experimental book designers alive who pointed<br />
out the issue of pacing <strong>as</strong> she read through the article on<br />
Professor Joshi. These two events made me redefine my goals and<br />
set new directions, and eventually, scrap the first four months<br />
worth of work down to the format and number of pages per<br />
article. The first-first-draft w<strong>as</strong> not a failure in itself—the page<br />
size w<strong>as</strong> calculated considering the target group’s surroundings<br />
(it w<strong>as</strong> a tad smaller than a 13 inch MacBook Pro, <strong>as</strong> mentioned<br />
earlier), <strong>as</strong>pirations (big images, enough width to make an array<br />
of column-widths possible) and production constraints (economy<br />
when made from a 70x100 sheet of offset paper)—but failed to<br />
best represent the content.<br />
This section would—mostly—discuss the second version drafts<br />
after the format change.<br />
Page layouts of the article Spoken Words,<br />
before and after the first revision for pacing.<br />
Major influences during<br />
this period were<br />
Alan Fletcher’s<br />
The Art Of Looking Sideways<br />
and Weingart’s Typography.<br />
Pictured is half of my desk<br />
during Through Hot Metal.<br />
47
48<br />
4.1 EXAMPLE OF DESIGN PROCESS ILLUSTRATED WITH SELECTED PAGES<br />
49
50<br />
The opening spread <strong>as</strong> a b<strong>as</strong>ic digital<br />
composition (right) and the finished<br />
version (bottom). These quick sketches<br />
helped me decide whether it w<strong>as</strong> worth<br />
pursuing an idea. These spreads were often<br />
designed at the end, after a visual language<br />
could be derived from the inside pages.<br />
I worked with separate software files<br />
for each story, thus ensuring one article<br />
doesn’t take visual cues from the other.<br />
On hindsight, this feels extreme, but<br />
it helped me tremendously during the<br />
design process.<br />
1<br />
Learning Ground<br />
The opening spread (and most of the inside pages) focus on MP<br />
Ranjan’s role <strong>as</strong> an influential academic, and his belief in doing<br />
hands-on design, preferably in the field.<br />
The illustration is intended to show the person <strong>as</strong> a multifaceted<br />
(referencing the mythical Brahma, the four-headed god of<br />
creation) hub of inspiration, ide<strong>as</strong> and action.<br />
The inner spreads reflect the visual richness of the diagrams<br />
Ranjan uses to illustrate his design ide<strong>as</strong>. I requested him to<br />
illustrate one of the ide<strong>as</strong> discussed, lending a layer of authenticity<br />
to the article. The questions are often enclosed in boxes that<br />
resemble parentheses, again referring to the connections,<br />
diagrams and bringing an air of friendliness to the mix, rendering<br />
serious ide<strong>as</strong> on design education and thinking approachable.<br />
I w<strong>as</strong> very happy with the images Ranjan had to offer. They spoke<br />
of the amount of dedication that went into making each piece of<br />
design, often by handcrafting and making prototypes along the<br />
way. The photographic documentation, I hope, would serve <strong>as</strong> a<br />
nice thing to go back to and be inspired by, constantly.<br />
51
52<br />
2<br />
Spoken Words<br />
In the conversation with late professor RK Joshi, the sound-wave<br />
graphic element plays a key role, often rendering words inverted<br />
out of them, in white. The spoken sound renders words. The effect<br />
also is a node to the craftsmanship with which a calligrapher<br />
brings forms into existence, aided only by a strategic positioning<br />
of lines and the spaces between them.<br />
The article uses a refined digital rendering technique to<br />
illustrate the tools of a calligrapher’s tools, bringing in the<br />
idea of traditional knowledge meeting the electronic, digital<br />
counterparts in a seamless way.<br />
The treatment of images is fiercely contemporary, highlighting<br />
meaning. The images-<strong>as</strong>-words were given enough space to sink<br />
into the viewer’s conscience, making sure the beauty of each<br />
letterform is conveyed without loss in transition.<br />
Some spreads play on mirroring, referencing the duality of spoken<br />
and written word mentioned in the conversation at length, and<br />
blending in with some of the pieces being shared.<br />
The finishing<br />
spread uses writing<br />
instruments with<br />
their caps about to be<br />
put on (or removed)<br />
paying homage to<br />
the professor, who<br />
died shortly after<br />
the Dekho team’s<br />
interview with him.<br />
53
54<br />
3<br />
Amar In The Making<br />
Amar’s conversation is his love-affair with spaces and immersive<br />
narratives. The opening spread w<strong>as</strong> laid out in the conventional<br />
way before glitching it, generating a composition that played<br />
with spaces, volumes and slants. The word-play w<strong>as</strong> an added<br />
bonus and w<strong>as</strong> enhanced later with design-tweaks.<br />
I decided to use Sujay’s illustration of Amar, with cropping and<br />
distortions to gel it well with the new layout. The typeface took<br />
the distortions rather well, prompting me to make use of them in<br />
the inside page to evoke a sense of space.<br />
There is a (sometimes forced) effort to make sure the reader<br />
notices the spaces and pauses in between the pages. lines are<br />
broken by spreads that celebrate white space, occ<strong>as</strong>ionally<br />
featuring words that instil a sense of lowered pace through time.<br />
The graphic elements are borrowed from space-design vernacular,<br />
directional signs, figures and forms to enhance the “drama” built<br />
into the conversation.<br />
The quotes are treated literally <strong>as</strong> “conversations in space,”<br />
referencing a thought Amar shared, with respect to<br />
exhibition design.<br />
the 3D software<br />
simulated spreads<br />
act <strong>as</strong> breaks in the<br />
narrative, forcing one<br />
to stop and think.<br />
55
56<br />
4<br />
For The People. By The People.<br />
This w<strong>as</strong> one of the most difficult stories to give a visual<br />
expression to. The visuals in use were raw portrayals of<br />
surroundings and observations in a powerful way, often achieved<br />
<strong>as</strong> simple sketches with a visual orientation that w<strong>as</strong> difficult to<br />
figure out. The break came when I realised that I needed to just<br />
focus on the “simple” and “clear communication” <strong>as</strong>pects of it.<br />
The layout focuses on communicating the story <strong>as</strong> effectively<br />
<strong>as</strong> intended and celebrates the sense of austerity and control<br />
exhibited in most of the supporting images.<br />
The opening spread features a sketch of Lakshmi Murthy by one<br />
of her trained youth volunteers. The lettering is tweaked to suit<br />
the illustration, attempting to create ample harmony between<br />
the “designed” and the “drawn.”<br />
The above spread is the article in a nutshell. It w<strong>as</strong> designed to<br />
bring the contr<strong>as</strong>t in the ways we visually communicate, which<br />
would be backed by the discussion around the spread on why<br />
generalised communication programmes just don’t work for rural<br />
are<strong>as</strong>. The project’s nature allowed me to explore the use of white/<br />
negative space in ways which could have met with disapproval in<br />
a client meating.<br />
The photography w<strong>as</strong><br />
done after a draft of<br />
the article w<strong>as</strong> made.<br />
This helped me plan<br />
the shoot around the<br />
layout, improving the<br />
overall relationship of<br />
things in each spread.<br />
The holdall (left,<br />
above) folds along the<br />
spine, making sense<br />
of its placement in<br />
the layout.<br />
57
58<br />
5<br />
Of The Head, Hand And Heart<br />
People Tree story is a riot of colours, textures and quirky image<br />
treatments, like their products. The title threw some light on<br />
how the cover treatment should be, and the T-shirt is an object<br />
to e<strong>as</strong>ily <strong>as</strong>sociate with the studio/shop. The finished graphic is a<br />
pun on “People+Tree” while at a glance, it celebrates the freedom<br />
and excitemet of wearing one’s self.<br />
In a way, the conversation is not about clothes, while a thousand<br />
references suggest otherwise. It is about people and individuality<br />
and dreams and holding hands and speaking one’s heart. The<br />
graphic suggests the human form inside the garment, replacing<br />
the actual being with an abstraction of these ide<strong>as</strong>.<br />
Some layouts were redesigned after rotating the printed firstdrafts<br />
at angles, looking at them on a light box, looking for<br />
arrangements I could e<strong>as</strong>ily have missed if I w<strong>as</strong> hell-bent on<br />
working within the grids. The second spread underwent many<br />
such changes (top) and became the b<strong>as</strong>is for the entire story.<br />
The Kaladera trip is something the duo talks about, with visible<br />
excitement. It w<strong>as</strong> obvious when the folder contained countless<br />
images from on the road, which, w<strong>as</strong> later used to bring that<br />
journey in between the covers of Dekho.<br />
“We chose not to<br />
work in regimented<br />
work spaces…”<br />
w<strong>as</strong> a comment<br />
I went back to,<br />
time and again,<br />
course-correcting<br />
the design process<br />
and keeping the<br />
liveliness of the<br />
conversation intact.<br />
59
60<br />
6<br />
Kerning Space<br />
Trapeze excels in using multiple techniques, materials, narratives<br />
and qualities of space efficiently. The visual design of Trapeze’s<br />
story is b<strong>as</strong>ed on this confluence of materials and processes,<br />
bringing the “inside story” of each supporting graphic to the<br />
front.<br />
The bespoke typo-graphic treatments allude to this being in<br />
space, with material textures, geometry and fine lines pointing to<br />
the detailing and t<strong>as</strong>teful selection of tactile materials in<br />
their work.<br />
This is the only conversation that directly talks about projects<br />
while showing some of the spaces designed. The images, however,<br />
are placed so <strong>as</strong> to not take the juice away from the text. They<br />
reveal themselves <strong>as</strong> one interacts with the book, often making<br />
one pause and go back to take the beauty of details in the images<br />
in, in a better way.<br />
It w<strong>as</strong> nice to deal with the physicality of the paper in a way that<br />
added to the message.<br />
The paper becomes<br />
a design element,<br />
playing the role of<br />
the bridge <strong>as</strong> well<br />
<strong>as</strong> the divider at the<br />
same time<br />
61
62<br />
7<br />
Letters From The E<strong>as</strong>t<br />
The opening spread plays on the metaphor of sunrise-in-thee<strong>as</strong>t<br />
(signifying a new beginning). The use of space to bring in a<br />
sense of ambition, is a nod to the scope of the project, while it<br />
also makes for a well-deserved break after the two articles that<br />
precede it.<br />
The pull-out quotes are treated the way type-specimens are<br />
treated, visually mimicking meaning. The letters from the project<br />
have a prominent place in the page-layout, putting the emph<strong>as</strong>is<br />
where it belongs.<br />
In an attempt to keep the focus on the<br />
letters at all times, spacious chunks in<br />
each page are occupied by the letters<br />
themselves. In addition to documenting<br />
the project process, this, I hope, makes<br />
sure that the instances of the script’s<br />
occurrence stays on.<br />
63
64<br />
8<br />
Through Hot Metal<br />
This is the text I started designing with. This is an awed tribute to<br />
the m<strong>as</strong>ter typographer, borrowing from his aesthetic sensibility<br />
and introducing fresh ways of looking at an otherwise linear text.<br />
The opening spread tries to instill the sense of being inside a<br />
metal workshop, bending typesetting rules and setting type in<br />
a galley to see a bunch of unusual forms emerge from the other<br />
side of the press. Some authenticity is compromised by replacing<br />
Akzidenz Grotesk by Gotham, owing to copyright issues. I<br />
would have loved to do the setting in a letterpress machine, but<br />
Weingart, Dahiya would remind me, w<strong>as</strong> all about breaking away<br />
from stereotypes and rules.<br />
The quotes are often a direct descendants of the influential<br />
typographic experiments by Weingart, which I thoroughly went<br />
through during the initial stages of design <strong>as</strong> I read a copy of<br />
Typography.<br />
These spreads use the fifith colour to<br />
create continuity while completing the<br />
portrait when held in a specific way, which<br />
is initiated by the use of white space<br />
around the face and the symmetry in<br />
cropping the image.<br />
65
66<br />
9<br />
Stefan Sagmeister Needs No Introduction<br />
The Sagmeister article went through a number of revisions (not<br />
all of them shown) before I settled on a nod to his work with<br />
banan<strong>as</strong> and time. The initial ide<strong>as</strong> included a word-play on<br />
“meister,” an array of CCTV monitors that would be filled with<br />
webcam shots of Sagmeister and Walsh studio, which is available<br />
online, and dissected rats.<br />
The title is a play on Sagmeister’s apparent irreverence to rules in<br />
general and is along the lines of his philosophy about work and<br />
life. The cock reference in the first sketch didn’t really evoke the<br />
response I w<strong>as</strong> angling for.<br />
The brush-stroke type helps pace the article which would<br />
otherwise have been laden with work from Sagmeister, which<br />
didn’t really make sense given the popularity of his work and the<br />
self-imposed thematic constraints of Dekho.<br />
67
68<br />
10<br />
Response<br />
This is an opening spread that celebrates itself. It takes the idea<br />
of response <strong>as</strong> its re<strong>as</strong>on of existense—a response to code, a<br />
response to movement and response <strong>as</strong> in dialogue between the<br />
photographer and the photographed. This is an opening spread<br />
that h<strong>as</strong> time embedded in it, like most of C<strong>as</strong>ey’s processing<br />
generated artwork.<br />
The work that led up to this image w<strong>as</strong> <strong>as</strong> enjoyable <strong>as</strong> the final<br />
product itself for me, and we decided it apt to show the minor<br />
imperfections in the type and not hide them with an image<br />
editing program.<br />
The layout tries to be “interactive” in the sense that it elicits some<br />
input from the reader to be completely understood, be it turning<br />
the book around, folding pages, matching marks or finding a<br />
sentence’s way around a collection of dingbats.<br />
This section w<strong>as</strong> designed in constant consultation with the<br />
physical, printed paper, folding, twisting, sliding one over the<br />
other and cut-p<strong>as</strong>ting. The physical format of the book thus gets<br />
exploited for the sake of evoking response from the reader.<br />
69
70<br />
11<br />
The Cover<br />
The cover went through multiple<br />
iterations, two of which were taken to the<br />
final stages. The first one dealt with the<br />
variety of stories inside in a more direct<br />
way, referencing it with a gradient of<br />
colours and an array of symbols.<br />
This approach, while time-consuming<br />
and very rewarding <strong>as</strong> a creative process,<br />
failed to resonate with the idea of Dekho<br />
being a “smart” publication that engages<br />
its reader in a conversation. It w<strong>as</strong> a pretty<br />
object out of context, offering no meaning<br />
beyond what w<strong>as</strong> written.<br />
DEKKO<br />
VOLUME 1<br />
This version tries to put the reader back in<br />
the riding seat, playing with the cliché of<br />
seeing, with a geometric twist that makes<br />
the cover appear to be moving with each<br />
movement of his/her head.<br />
A perfect distance between the black<br />
lines, and a perfect thickness of the lines<br />
themselves, w<strong>as</strong> found after nights of<br />
staring at slightly headache inducing<br />
prints on paper in all shades of neon.<br />
Dekho, in writing, appears to replace the<br />
highlight on the iris, and when the book<br />
is opened, the eyes seem to be lost in<br />
thought. A good iris size w<strong>as</strong> also found<br />
out, which made the stare a lot calmer<br />
than the other explorations.<br />
DEKKO<br />
VOLUME 1<br />
DEKHO<br />
<br />
My softboard at the studio, during one of the<br />
nights working on the cover image.<br />
Dekho<br />
Conversations on design in India.<br />
DEKHO<br />
71
72<br />
12<br />
The Contents Page<br />
The only place where photographs of the interviewees feature,<br />
the contents page integrate the images into the story with the aid<br />
of the fifth ink and graphic devices.<br />
of FACES DEKHO.<br />
12<br />
80<br />
204<br />
134<br />
P8 Foreword: Prof. H Kumar Vy<strong>as</strong><br />
P9 Foreword: Steven Heller<br />
P12–P267 The Conversations<br />
P270 Credits<br />
P271 Colophon, Imprint<br />
38<br />
58<br />
226<br />
102<br />
164<br />
242<br />
In 12 , MP Ranjan reflects on his experiences <strong>as</strong> a design educator<br />
Learning Ground<br />
and evangelist, driven by his deep conviction in the fact that designled<br />
intervention can bring wonderful changes for India. In 38 , the<br />
late Professor Raghunath K Joshi makes a c<strong>as</strong>e for sound <strong>as</strong> a precursor<br />
Spoken Words<br />
to written word and talks of the Deshanagari project—an ambitious<br />
undertaking which explored the possibilities of type-setting in Indian<br />
languages b<strong>as</strong>ed on the way they are spoken. Neelak<strong>as</strong>h Kshetrimayum<br />
Letters From The E<strong>as</strong>t<br />
takes us on a personal journey to the hills of Manipur in 58 , where<br />
a dying native script Metei Mayek, is finding a new life with design<br />
interventions like his type design projects. Lakshmi Murthy, 80 , does<br />
By The People. For The People.<br />
not subscribe to a top-down, generalised approach to developmental<br />
communication. She offers valuable insights through her work in<br />
rural India—co-designing effective, localized models for social<br />
communication with the user. In 102 , Orijit Sen and Gurpreet Sidhu,<br />
Of The Head, Hand And The Heart<br />
founding partners of the iconic Indian brand—People Tree, celebrate<br />
the intelligence of the head and the hand, and talk about craft <strong>as</strong> their<br />
approach to design. Ram Sinam and Sarita Sundar look beyond the<br />
Kerning Space<br />
brief at their design consultancy Trapeze in 134 —elevating dialogues in<br />
spatial design from what is said to how it is said. Amardeep Behl wants<br />
Amar In The Making<br />
you to be uncomfortable in 164 . Restlessness, he says, is the mother of<br />
all design, and in the course of the conversation, walks you through<br />
the intricate spatial narratives created by his practice DesignHabit.<br />
In 204 , Wolfgang Weingart, known for his explosive rejection of the<br />
Through Hot Metal<br />
Swiss Style and radical experiments, continues to inspire new forms of<br />
expression. Stefan Sagmeister, despite the absence of an introduction<br />
Stefan Sagmeister Needs No Introduction<br />
in 226 , shares his life’s lessons with honesty and zeal, tinged <strong>as</strong> always<br />
with his inimitable sense of humour. 242 is C<strong>as</strong>ey Re<strong>as</strong> sharing his<br />
Process<br />
f<strong>as</strong>cination with the idea of emergence, and taking us along a journey<br />
exploring the binaries of naturally evolving and synthetic systems.<br />
6 7<br />
The Partition Pages<br />
These reveal the grid <strong>as</strong> a maze, a field of possibilities and works<br />
<strong>as</strong> a reminder that the book is a celebration of graphic design<br />
<strong>as</strong> well. The page before the international voices is designed to<br />
follow the visual language of the grid-page.<br />
10 11 1<br />
73<br />
This section of Dekho features a selection of voices from across the world, presenting relevant, inspirationa
74<br />
5. PAPER, PRINTING<br />
Meant for the person with enough exposure to finely crafted<br />
books on design (and other subjects) the paper is guilt-free (made<br />
of fruit pulp), h<strong>as</strong> a subtle texture that adds to the tactility. The<br />
slight translucency<br />
THE<br />
adds to a fine interplay and layering (physical) This also works <strong>as</strong> a metaphor for the<br />
of content across pages. This, combined with a religious following stories being interwoven and seamless<br />
of the grid for body text, makes for a compelling presentation. within themselves.<br />
In this c<strong>as</strong>e, a highly refined sensibility from the print partner<br />
becomes a major, defining <strong>as</strong>set.<br />
Being from Kyooriyus Papers’ budget paper portfolio, the choice<br />
reduced financial burden on the studio <strong>as</strong> well.<br />
MAKIN<br />
Paper-text block: Shiro Fruit Cocoa<br />
Weight: 100 GSM<br />
Dimensions: 70 x 100 cms<br />
75<br />
Paper-cover: Magna Carta<br />
Weight: 250 GSM*<br />
Dimensions: 64x92 cms*<br />
Vendor: Kyoorius Fine Papers<br />
Range: Budget Portfolio<br />
Printing: Offset CMYK + Special Ink (Pantone 805)<br />
Vendor: JAK Printers, Mumbai<br />
*Proposed, at the time of publishing this document<br />
AMAR<br />
Many of the layout and design decisions were also meant to While at the first draft stage, we ordered a<br />
exploit possibilities in print. The fifth—special—ink, Pantone 805 few samples from the vendor and test-<br />
plays a crucial role in tying the whole project together visually, <strong>as</strong> printed pages to check showthrough and<br />
well <strong>as</strong> elevating some key design elements (the story beginnings colour variations on actual paper.<br />
and endings, for instance).<br />
IN<br />
AMAR THE<br />
MAKING AMAR<br />
IN THE<br />
164_Amar In The Making<br />
IN THE<br />
MAKING
76<br />
6. TYPEFACES, TYPOGRAPHY<br />
B<strong>as</strong>ed also on how the articles were<br />
intended to be treated, size, leading and<br />
other technical details. The decision on<br />
using a unique typeface per article. Budget<br />
constraints and the typefaces the studio<br />
h<strong>as</strong> previously licensed.<br />
In an attempt to cut costs, it w<strong>as</strong> decided to stick to typefaces the<br />
studio had acquired rights for. There were quite a lot to choose<br />
from, and I didn’t want to choose. Keeping with the idea of going<br />
where the content took the design to, I decided I would use <strong>as</strong><br />
many typefaces <strong>as</strong> i can, while a uniform body text could be used<br />
to keep the visual language from becoming a Frankenstein’s<br />
monster. With its generous X-height and open counters, Greta<br />
appears to maintain an even grey tone over considerable lengths<br />
of text laden with acronyms, names in italics (one h<strong>as</strong> to expect a<br />
great many of them in a publication dealing with Indian names)<br />
and short paragraphs interspersed with line breaks (common<br />
in an interview format). For each article, I would choose an<br />
appropriate typographic expression b<strong>as</strong>ed on the content and use<br />
that to highlight sections that needed to be highlighted. Some of<br />
them would be hand-drawn forms, some photographed and some<br />
bespoke, constructed in Illustrator and Photoshop.<br />
“The economics of the newspaper<br />
environment also requires type which is<br />
highly space-efficient; Greta uses maximal<br />
shape counters to improve performance<br />
in lower-quality printing and at very small<br />
sizes. Although the typeface w<strong>as</strong> created<br />
to function in the extreme conditions<br />
of newspaper production, it is also ideal<br />
for other modern typographic situations<br />
such <strong>as</strong> print and electronic editions of<br />
magazines or books.”<br />
Greta Text Concept, Typotheque.<br />
Body text set in Greta Text<br />
Designed by Peter Bilak (2007)<br />
Learning Ground<br />
Torque<br />
Designed by Tal Leming (2009)<br />
Spoken Words<br />
Greta Display<br />
Designed by Peter Bilak and Nikola Djurek (2008)<br />
Letters From The E<strong>as</strong>t<br />
Greta Grande<br />
Designed by Peter Bilak and Nikola Djurek (2008)<br />
For The People. By The People.<br />
Hand-drawn letters<br />
Of The Head, Hand And Heart<br />
Output from a Travelriter typewriter<br />
Kerning Space<br />
Hand-crafted letters<br />
Amar In The Making<br />
Stag Stencil<br />
Designed by Christian Schwartz (2008)<br />
Through Hot Metal<br />
Gotham<br />
Designed by The Hoefler Type Foundry (2000)<br />
Stefan Sagmeister Needs No Introduction<br />
Hand-drawn letters<br />
Response<br />
Pro55ing<br />
Designed by YouWorkForThem (2001)<br />
Devanagari title on the back cover<br />
set in Kohinoor Devanagari<br />
Designed by Satya Rajpurohit (2010)<br />
77
78<br />
6.1 TYPEFACES, TYPOGRAPHY<br />
The interview with C<strong>as</strong>ey Re<strong>as</strong> uses Pro55ing, a typeface created<br />
to be used in the processing IDE, and a typeface generated using a<br />
simple Arduino programme b<strong>as</strong>ed on persistence of vision.<br />
An array of seven LEDs were lit intermittently aided by a simple<br />
arduino program, while being dragged across space and captured<br />
with a camera on very low shutter speed.<br />
The conversation with Amar Deep Behl Design Habit uses a<br />
stencilled typeface (Stag) simulated to appear painted on spaces,<br />
evoking a sense of being inside Amar’s head, floating in space<br />
amidst the words. The stencilled faces also reference graffiti on<br />
walls, again bringing spaces into the picture.<br />
The pages on Vikalp design employs hand-written letters. This<br />
w<strong>as</strong> an obvious choice <strong>as</strong> it visually reinforces the nature of<br />
communication materials designed at Vikalp.<br />
MP Ranjan’s interview features Torque, a no-nonsense sans serif<br />
that makes statements, enhanced by the use of all caps. Often<br />
seen <strong>as</strong> a hindrance to reading, the copy here reflects strong<br />
convictions and makes their c<strong>as</strong>e in an unforgattable way.<br />
The conversation with Gurpreet and Orijit of People Tree<br />
uses textured letters produced from a Remington Travelriter<br />
typewriter, referring to the hands-on, hearts on approach<br />
to design and life. The letters are more physical in a sense,<br />
their individuality reinforced by slight imperfections and<br />
misregistrations, and mistakes left <strong>as</strong> they are, corrected by<br />
typing over them wherever necessary.<br />
The Sagmeister interview features a set of letters, made sensuous<br />
by the use of a wet round brush loaded with paint, letterforms<br />
overlapping each other and giving language, forms.<br />
Can good design be copied?<br />
Yes, it can, but why would you want to? I<br />
have found that if I copy an idea, it winds up<br />
to be not really my baby. I am reduced from a<br />
parent to a babysitter. Babysitters tend to do<br />
Lakshmi Murthy is the<br />
Murthy says,<br />
founder of Vikalp Design. For<br />
on design for the rural audience:<br />
over twenty years she h<strong>as</strong> been tirelessly In distinguishing between the urban and<br />
working with the rural population<br />
rural audience, the latter is wrongfully<br />
in Raj<strong>as</strong>than and Gujarat <strong>as</strong> a commu- regarded <strong>as</strong> visually illiterate. The rural<br />
nication designer, to develop effective, audience h<strong>as</strong> a sharper perception of their<br />
localized models for social communication. environment and are keener to infer from<br />
In doing so, she h<strong>as</strong> uncovered a new indexical traces that the urban individual<br />
way of seeing and conversing<br />
would neglect. In fact it is the city-bred<br />
with her audience.<br />
individual who may be “illiterate” in the<br />
rural environment, lacking their visual<br />
knowledge. While an urban designer will<br />
draw in proportion and orientation of what<br />
Then from T-shirts this went to other things.<br />
they see <strong>as</strong> “known,” a villager would rely on<br />
Some people made other stuff; so they<br />
vernacular knowledge to draw, displaying a<br />
would come and talk about it and if we liked<br />
keen unlettered intelligence.<br />
it we would say, “Okay, let’s do something<br />
together.” And, then it started growing from<br />
there. In the early years, it w<strong>as</strong> a very organic<br />
and unplanned kind of a thing. We were<br />
doing what we thought w<strong>as</strong> interesting,<br />
and were open to engage with people who<br />
thought the same and had something to<br />
contribute. Along the way, the name—People<br />
Tree—also happened. It w<strong>as</strong> partly inspired<br />
A participatory<br />
by the big<br />
process<br />
pipal<br />
of<br />
tree<br />
self-expression<br />
outside the NID gate,<br />
where holds everybody—design one answer. Encouraging students, auto<br />
people rickshaw to draw h<strong>as</strong> and been camel-cart looked upon drivers, <strong>as</strong> eunuchs<br />
an on empowering their rounds, process sabzi-wallahs, that leads teachers and<br />
to students inclusion from of notions the school otherwise across the road—<br />
would come. Everybody difficult to express. could have chai and<br />
a conversation. A lot h<strong>as</strong> happened since then. ‘Branding’<br />
82_For The People. By The People. Moving forward, what do you envisage <strong>as</strong> the<br />
greatest motivator or need<br />
to create and sustain design<br />
schools in India?<br />
THE GREATEST<br />
MOTIVATOR IS OUR<br />
BELIEF THAT DESIGN IS<br />
What is your “design process” once you get the brief?<br />
Since we design for so many different<br />
projects and purposes, the process changes A POWERFUL FORCE.<br />
<strong>as</strong> well.<br />
h<strong>as</strong> happened in an organic way over the 83<br />
years. The spirit of openness that we started<br />
the place with, is really what I think makes it Each of these contribute to making the<br />
what it is today. People Tree h<strong>as</strong> been shaped<br />
by many people and that h<strong>as</strong> only been respective stories unique within the<br />
possible because we were open for that to<br />
happen. We didn’t say “no, no, Vision no, this First is is our a citizen design<br />
concept and this is how we do initiative it”. We actually context of the publication <strong>as</strong> a whole.<br />
that came together<br />
said, “let us get rid of our ‘designerly’ spontaneously notions in response<br />
of how things are done and to how Government things of India’s<br />
should be done, and let us actually decision try to to set up four new<br />
make it a collaborative process”. NIDs and took shape in the<br />
social networking space.<br />
Many design teachers,<br />
researchers and activists—<br />
all NID alumni, came<br />
together when the matter<br />
w<strong>as</strong> discussed in online<br />
lists. These experienced<br />
practitioners and teachers<br />
were shocked by the fact that<br />
Yes, new design schools are needed<br />
A process I use in India. often We and are which calling h<strong>as</strong> for been a serious<br />
extremely helpful rethink to <strong>as</strong> me, part w<strong>as</strong> of our described Vision First* by<br />
Design—our understanding of it<br />
and what it can do, is going through<br />
a sea of change. The touch and<br />
the initiative, though clearly<br />
needed, w<strong>as</strong> being undertaken<br />
without any review of the<br />
Edward DeBono initiative in a book to try called and influence Thinking the involvement of design is at the<br />
situation and context, 50 years<br />
Course. Edward Government DeBono is of a India philosopher and NID itself from heart of many qualities that get<br />
after the setting up of the<br />
Malta. He wrote to do a these lot of reviews books about <strong>as</strong> part thinking. of the 50 embedded into products, services <strong>as</strong><br />
National Institute of Design<br />
year celebrations of the setting up of<br />
He shows many exercises about how you<br />
the institute. The greatest motivator<br />
can improve<br />
is<br />
your<br />
our<br />
thinking.<br />
belief that<br />
There<br />
design<br />
are<br />
is a<br />
a<br />
powerful<br />
good<br />
number of tricks force. in It there can shape that Indian I use all society the<br />
time, that help and me we come can get up others with in ide<strong>as</strong>. power He to<br />
well <strong>as</strong> policies that shape the lives<br />
of our people. Design represents<br />
an ability and knowledge b<strong>as</strong>e that<br />
deals with the synthesis of all these<br />
services and offerings—in Health<br />
at Ahmedabad b<strong>as</strong>ed on a<br />
seminal report by Charles and<br />
Ray Eames. It w<strong>as</strong> felt that<br />
a sustained dialogue with<br />
stakeholders must precede<br />
says, our brain participate is an incredibly in our conviction sophisticated in the services the quality of experience<br />
108_Of The Head, Hand And The Heart such a move, so that the real<br />
109<br />
computer which days is that at lie its ahead. best in The thinking opportunities in that the patient, doctor or other<br />
needs and insights from half<br />
repetition. It are h<strong>as</strong> both to be regional that way, <strong>as</strong> well otherwise, <strong>as</strong> sectoral, if participants have, would be largely<br />
a century of practice could<br />
and this kind of domain-specific<br />
you want to pick up, say, a business card, and<br />
approach will create many new<br />
if the brain would be creative all the time, I<br />
schools that would be uniquely rooted<br />
would have to in think: the Indian oh, hands reality. go India forward, is a land go<br />
down, fingers, of move, great opportunity now lift it up. <strong>as</strong> far It <strong>as</strong> would design<br />
decided at the stage of design of these<br />
offerings. Similarly, Banking and<br />
Finance are facing severe issues of<br />
inclusion and exclusion of poor and<br />
underprivileged. New approaches<br />
inform the new initiative.<br />
be too complicated. thought The and brain, action by are necessity, concerned— need to be innovated and here<br />
is very good at there thinking is so much automatically. to be done there But too design can play an important<br />
when it comes across to creative <strong>as</strong> many ide<strong>as</strong>, <strong>as</strong> 230 the sectors. brain role. Transportation, Education,<br />
also wants to think in repetition. So DeBono<br />
shows you some ways to trick the brain out<br />
of thinking in repetitions, to throw it out of<br />
its regular paths.<br />
Agriculture and many other sectors,<br />
are all in need of urgent innovation<br />
of products, services, processes and<br />
policies that can be achieved with the<br />
use of design at many levels—tactical,<br />
The experimental 70s at NID.<br />
A light play orchestrated by<br />
Vik<strong>as</strong> Satwalekar and enacted by<br />
MP Ranjan in the photography studio,<br />
application, and strategic.<br />
with a lighted torch in hand.<br />
My favorite one consists of thinking about And, one of my most frequent sources of<br />
an idea with 16_Learning a starting Ground point that makes inspiration is a newly occupied hotel room.<br />
17<br />
no sense. Say, I need to design a tea pot. I find it e<strong>as</strong>y to work in a place far away<br />
Normally I would think of tea, other tea pots from the studio, where thoughts about the<br />
historically, the desire of consumers when implementation of an idea don’t come to<br />
drinking tea etc. Instead, I think of a teapot mind immediately but I can dream a bit<br />
starting with, say, a toe nail. So, lets see: A toe<br />
nails needs to be clipped, is there something<br />
with the idea that the teapot gets smaller<br />
when there is less tea in it? Is it possible to<br />
have a teapot like a balloon, where its larger<br />
when full of tea and smaller with a smaller<br />
amount. Maybe possible with some of the<br />
new rubber materials, maybe even an idea<br />
worth pursuing and I just thought of it right<br />
here (I swear I did not cheat…).<br />
more freely.<br />
79
80<br />
7. THE GRID<br />
“The grid is like the lines on a football field.<br />
You can play a great game in the grid or a lousy<br />
game. But the goal is to play a really fine game.”<br />
Wim Crouwel.<br />
Margins: 15, 15, 17.913, 15 mm<br />
Six Columns<br />
Gutter Space: 4 mm<br />
B<strong>as</strong>eline every 5.5 pt<br />
The b<strong>as</strong>ic six-column grid w<strong>as</strong> arrived at b<strong>as</strong>ed on word-count<br />
when Greta at 9 points w<strong>as</strong> used (on a 11 point b<strong>as</strong>eline). The<br />
grid, used in a controlled manner, is something I have tried to<br />
avoid adhering too rigidly to. This decision is often b<strong>as</strong>ed on<br />
how content flows, the order in which I would want a reader to<br />
go through the text. Often, I have tried to break the common<br />
left-right-top-bottom reading order to bring interest back to the<br />
content (and design) of the book. Initially, I w<strong>as</strong> of the opinion<br />
the design should be invisible and the content should speak<br />
for itself. The p<strong>as</strong>sion with which each interviewee responded<br />
to the questions, recalling experiences and incidents from the<br />
work-period w<strong>as</strong> something that I had to reflect in the design.<br />
I w<strong>as</strong> having a hell of a time talking to these people. I wanted<br />
the design to do that to the reader—bring them to a chair<br />
opposite the person being interviewed. Sharing the happiness<br />
w<strong>as</strong> a major concern, often overtaking the logical, sober route<br />
of communication. For example, in the Weingart article, the<br />
quotes hidden behind rules were more than a homage to his<br />
experiments with type. They were my attempts at making the<br />
c<strong>as</strong>ual browser stop and take in the excitement of being able<br />
to play with language and letters in such a simple, direct, and<br />
effective way. The proofreaders sometimes left these pages<br />
unchecked for errors.<br />
The grid becomes a breather before the conversations begin.<br />
With a slight subversion (of opening it at two places, turning the<br />
apparent mundane-ness literally into an adventure) this brings<br />
the structure back into limelight, with hopes of reminding<br />
how the perceived chaos is only a possible expression of the<br />
order within.<br />
It w<strong>as</strong>, at times, difficult<br />
to contain the emotions,<br />
listening to the interview<br />
recordings in loop,<br />
seeing how involved each<br />
of these people were with<br />
whatever they<br />
were doing.<br />
81
82<br />
7. DETAILS OF THE PRINTED BOOK<br />
The book is dedicated to “Designers who find joy in reading.”<br />
The non-conventional format of the contents page owes its<br />
origins to the conversational nature of the book’s content.<br />
83
84<br />
The opening spreads are distinctly treated, with chapter names<br />
appearing in the special ink to highlight beginning of stories.<br />
All photographs are treated so that each spread would function <strong>as</strong><br />
an independent visual (like a poster) if left off context.<br />
The visual treatment of typography plays with the word<br />
meanings appropriate to the context each treated word<br />
appears in.<br />
A second layer of meaning is achieved by b<strong>as</strong>ing the artwork on<br />
sound clip of Prof. RK Joshi’s voice.<br />
85
86<br />
Each article h<strong>as</strong> its own visual and illustration treatment that<br />
aligns with the content, and referencing the work/philosophies of<br />
the person being interviewed.<br />
The structure of the book lends visual expression to some<br />
of the pages, ensuring that the “book-experience” is unique<br />
to the printed version and cannot be achieved in an<br />
on-screen presentation.<br />
87
88<br />
The pull-out quotes and core ide<strong>as</strong> within the text are<br />
supplemented by appropriate graphic elements. In the c<strong>as</strong>e of a<br />
pull out quote that also appears within the body of text, an effort<br />
is made to present it only once.<br />
Keeping with the idea of the “book-<strong>as</strong>-a-design-object,” physical<br />
transformations during reading are used to add a layer of surprise<br />
to the content, which may be discovered on a second reading.<br />
89
90<br />
Text is treated <strong>as</strong> image in places where appropriate. The studio<br />
gave complete creative control on the editorial <strong>as</strong>pects of the<br />
book if it appeared to compliment the story in ways otherwise<br />
not possible.<br />
Visual surprises are hidden in many parts of the book. This made<br />
a lengthy project (almost a year-and-a-half) enjoyable every day.<br />
I would look forward to making these E<strong>as</strong>ter eggs every<br />
working day.<br />
91
92<br />
INFRA-<br />
STRUC-<br />
TURE<br />
CON-<br />
CERNS<br />
FINDING SPONSORS<br />
Dekho<br />
Documenting<br />
inspiring stories of<br />
design in India.<br />
Since the publication is funded by the studio, financial help needed to be sought from<br />
sponsors. The process of negotiating and convincing people to part with their money<br />
is time consuming and laden with long periods of waiting. This section also describes<br />
making a preview/mockup for presenting to the sponsors, halfway through the<br />
design process.<br />
The studio had already spent a lot of time, money and energy before I started working, on<br />
the project. Now, for publication, we were looking for sponsors from cultural institutions<br />
who would want to be part of the initiative. They would later become ideal partners to<br />
help with distribution <strong>as</strong> well. Internal discussions on why anyone would be interested<br />
in such an endeavour provided enough insights into what each presentation should<br />
contain. In addition we also tried to get paper and print vendors to subsidise production.<br />
The pitch:<br />
There is a shallow, misguided<br />
view of communication<br />
design in India.<br />
Why? \ Lack of documentation.<br />
\<br />
\<br />
\<br />
\<br />
Current platform are showc<strong>as</strong>e driven—lack<br />
voice of people behind the work.<br />
Lack of writers with a good understanding<br />
of design.<br />
Several finer <strong>as</strong>pects of communication<br />
design—like type design—are never covered.<br />
Lack of connection between communication<br />
design and the world/issues at large.<br />
Internationally, there is a big<br />
gap in the understanding of the<br />
‘Indian’ in Indian Design, largely<br />
because of a lack of context.<br />
93
94<br />
MP Ranjan is a world-renowned design<br />
thinker, educator, author of several<br />
books and papers on these subjects and<br />
p<strong>as</strong>sionately talks about bringing<br />
change through design.<br />
Dekho is an anthology of<br />
conversations with designers<br />
in India—capturing stories of<br />
inspiration, endeavor and learning;<br />
and presenting them through<br />
visually rich narratives in print.<br />
Voices of Dekho. Professor Raghunath K Joshi w<strong>as</strong> a<br />
one-man institution on language and<br />
writing systems. His work with digital<br />
typography brought together<br />
knowledge of tradition and technology.<br />
Typographer and graphic designer<br />
Neelak<strong>as</strong>h Kshetrimayum recounts his<br />
experiences and shares his hopes on the<br />
revival of the Metei Mayek script of Manipur.<br />
Book design in India is largely<br />
relegated to 2 extremes—academic<br />
& textual, and showc<strong>as</strong>e-b<strong>as</strong>ed,<br />
‘coffee-table’ publications.<br />
Moving forward, what do you envisage <strong>as</strong> the<br />
greatest motivator or need<br />
to create and sustain design<br />
schools in India?<br />
Readers.<br />
Design/creative community—students<br />
and professionals—within India<br />
and abroad.<br />
The general public with an interest in<br />
design in India and its development.<br />
THE GREATEST<br />
MOTIVATOR IS OUR<br />
BELIEF THAT DESIGN IS<br />
A POWERFUL FORCE.<br />
Yes, new design schools are needed Design—our understanding of it<br />
in India. We are calling for a serious and what it can do, is going through<br />
rethink <strong>as</strong> part of our Vision First* a sea of change. The touch and<br />
initiative to try and influence the involvement of design is at the heart<br />
Government of India and NID itself of many qualities that get embedded<br />
to do these reviews <strong>as</strong> part of the 50 into products, services <strong>as</strong> well <strong>as</strong><br />
year celebrations of the setting up of policies that shape the lives of our<br />
the institute. The greatest motivator people. Design represents an ability<br />
is our belief that design is a powerful and knowledge b<strong>as</strong>e that deals with<br />
force. It can shape Indian society the synthesis of all these services<br />
and we can get others in power to and offerings—in Health services<br />
participate in our conviction in the the quality of experience that the<br />
days that lie ahead. The opportunities patient, doctor or other participants<br />
are both regional <strong>as</strong> well <strong>as</strong> sectoral, have, would be largely decided at the<br />
and this kind of domain-specific stage of design of these offerings.<br />
approach will create many new Similarly, Banking and Finance are<br />
schools that would be uniquely rooted facing severe issues of inclusion<br />
in the Indian reality. India is a land and exclusion of the poor and<br />
of great opportunity <strong>as</strong> far <strong>as</strong> design underprivileged. New approaches<br />
thought and action are concerned— need to be innovated and here<br />
there is so much to be done there too design can play an important<br />
across <strong>as</strong> many <strong>as</strong> 230 sectors. role. Transportation, Education,<br />
Agriculture and many other sectors,<br />
are all in need for urgent innovation<br />
of products, services, processes and<br />
policies that can be achieved with the<br />
use of design at many levels—tactical,<br />
application, and strategic.<br />
Vision First is an citizen<br />
design initiative that came<br />
together spontaneously in<br />
response to the Government<br />
of India’s decision to set up<br />
four new NIDs and took shape<br />
in the social networking<br />
space. Many design teachers,<br />
researchers and activists—<br />
all NID alumni, came<br />
together when the matter<br />
w<strong>as</strong> discussed in online<br />
lists. These experienced<br />
practitioners and teachers<br />
were shocked by the fact that<br />
the initiative, though clearly<br />
needed, w<strong>as</strong> being undertaken<br />
without any review of the<br />
situation and context, 50 years<br />
after the setting up of the<br />
National Institute of Design<br />
at Ahmedabad b<strong>as</strong>ed on a<br />
seminal report by Charles and<br />
Ray Eames. It w<strong>as</strong> felt that<br />
a sustained dialogue with<br />
stakeholders must precede<br />
such a move, so that the real<br />
needs and insights from half<br />
a century of practice could<br />
inform the new initiative.<br />
PRINTING, PUBLISHING, DISTRIBUTION*<br />
The printer could be persuaded to provide thier services at a<br />
discounted rate, the paper distributor agreed for a late payment,<br />
and the Goethe Institut could contribute some money towards<br />
the effort.<br />
One advantage of being in a multi-studio environment is<br />
knowing more people in decision-making positions in financially<br />
stable companies who could be approached for the necessary<br />
funds.<br />
The distribution is planned to happen through social networking<br />
channels, online bookshops and niche shops stocking design/art<br />
books. We are also looking forward to using academic institutions<br />
<strong>as</strong> launching grounds for the effort.<br />
95
96<br />
THE<br />
JOUR-<br />
NEY<br />
It h<strong>as</strong> been an roller co<strong>as</strong>ter ride full of ple<strong>as</strong>ant discoveries, disturbing uncertainties,<br />
moments of elation at finding solutions and journeys both real and imaginary,<br />
full of surprises.<br />
The absence of much pressure on deadlines or the visual style—or even the content—<br />
made me too self-conscious in the beginning, and I ended up second-guessing every<br />
other iteration after moving on to a different story. Things started to go into endless<br />
loops, draining my enthusi<strong>as</strong>m <strong>as</strong> they did. It tested my ability to manage writing,<br />
creating visuals and dealing with the structure of the book at the same time, often<br />
leaving me no choice but to stay back at the studio till odd hours of the (often next) day.<br />
The exercise taught me how to deal with time not only of my own, but also the people<br />
interviewed and people working at the studio. Coordinating content over the internet<br />
and the local network, engaging studio colleagues in the discussions and accepting<br />
suggestions and contributions, w<strong>as</strong> a new set of experiences after working on cl<strong>as</strong>sroom<br />
projects all alone. Realising the importance of multiple perspectives, listening to<br />
opinions (often conflicting) of people, channelling them in a way that benefitted<br />
both parties and learning that dependence goes a long way towards creating<br />
something beyond the monotonous, are all things I am grateful to be able to take away<br />
from the project.<br />
The most fulfilling <strong>as</strong>pect of the project w<strong>as</strong> being able to work in a way that let me<br />
treat each article like a different undertaking, shifting from one material and technique<br />
to another in a span of days, often leading to accidentally discovering new ways to<br />
make things. So, while the project let me put to use whatever techniques, theories<br />
and philosophies I could internalise during my cl<strong>as</strong>sroom projects, it demanded fresh<br />
experiments and risking these very b<strong>as</strong>ics.<br />
I hope the publication brings a smile<br />
to the minds of whoever happens to go<br />
through its pages, and that a lot of people<br />
happen to go through its pages. I could<br />
consider nine months of my working life<br />
well-spent, then.<br />
I also have a toothbrush-and-toothp<strong>as</strong>te<br />
set next to my drawing tablet on my desk<br />
at the studio.<br />
97
98<br />
REFERENCES<br />
Typography<br />
Wolfgang Weingart<br />
Lars Muller Publishers<br />
Processing<br />
C<strong>as</strong>ey Re<strong>as</strong>, Ben Fry<br />
MIT Press<br />
The Art Of Looking Sideways<br />
Alen Fletcher<br />
Phaidon<br />
U&lc : Influencing Design & Typography<br />
John Berry<br />
Mark Batty Publisher<br />
The Designer And The Grid<br />
Lucien E. Roberts, Julia Thrift<br />
Rockport Publishers<br />
How To Be A Graphic Designer Without Losing<br />
Your Soul<br />
Adrian Shaughnessy<br />
Laurence King Publishing<br />
Learning From The Field: Experiences in<br />
Communication<br />
Lakshmi Murthy, Amita Kagal,<br />
Ashoke Chatterjee<br />
United Nations Population Fund<br />
Things I have Learnt In My Life So Far<br />
Stefan Sagmeister<br />
Abrams<br />
Typography<br />
Wolfgang Weingart<br />
Lars Muller Publishers<br />
Processing<br />
C<strong>as</strong>ey Re<strong>as</strong>, Ben Fry<br />
MIT Press<br />
The Art Of Looking Sideways<br />
Alen Fletcher<br />
Phaidon<br />
U&lc : Influencing Design & Typography<br />
John Berry<br />
Mark Batty Publisher<br />
The Designer And The Grid<br />
Lucien E. Roberts, Julia Thrift<br />
Rockport Publishers<br />
How To Be A Graphic Designer Without Losing<br />
Your Soul<br />
Adrian Shaughnessy<br />
Laurence King Publishing<br />
Learning From The Field: Experiences in<br />
Communication<br />
Lakshmi Murthy, Amita Kagal,<br />
Ashoke Chatterjee<br />
United Nations Population Fund<br />
Things I have Learnt In My Life So Far<br />
Stefan Sagmeister<br />
Abrams<br />
99
100<br />
COLOPHON<br />
Set in 9pt Greta Text<br />
Section titles in Stag Stencil<br />
3 September 2012<br />
CONTACT INFORMATION<br />
Abhijith KR<br />
Thanappatta House<br />
Nanmanda<br />
Kozhikode 673613<br />
abhijith@keyaar.in<br />
Codesign<br />
Ground Floor C 2/4<br />
Sushant Lok Ph<strong>as</strong>e 1<br />
Gurgaon 122009<br />
design@codesign.in<br />
101
© 2013<br />
ABHIJITH KR<br />
abhijith@keyaar.in