03.06.2013 Views

Establishing a kiln drying schedule for Paulownia fortunei lumber ...

Establishing a kiln drying schedule for Paulownia fortunei lumber ...

Establishing a kiln drying schedule for Paulownia fortunei lumber ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

<strong>Establishing</strong> a <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Paulownia</strong> <strong>for</strong>tunei <strong>lumber</strong> with<br />

thickness of 5 cm<br />

Seyeid Mahmoud Miri Tari 1 * & Mehrab Madhoushi 2<br />

1 Former M.Sc. Student, Dep. of Wood Engineering and Technology, Gorgan University of Agricultural<br />

Sciences and Natural Resources, Golestan, Iran<br />

2 Associate Prof., Dep. of Wood Engineering and Technology, Gorgan University of Agricultural<br />

Sciences and Natural Resources, Golestan, Iran<br />

*: Corresponding Author, Email: Miry.Mahmood@gmail.com<br />

Abstract: In order to establish a local <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> based on FPL recommendation <strong>for</strong> paulownia<br />

wood (<strong>Paulownia</strong> <strong>for</strong>tunei) commercial sawn <strong>lumber</strong> with thickness of 5 cm, two standing trees were<br />

randomly cud down from Shasta-Kola region in Iran. Final moisture content was considered equal to 8±2<br />

<strong>for</strong> all <strong>kiln</strong> loads and totally three separate <strong>kiln</strong> loads were per<strong>for</strong>med. Three different <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong><br />

<strong>schedule</strong>s were employed namely, T6E3, T6E4 and T7E4. The severity of warping (bowing, crooking and<br />

twisting) and checks (surface and end checks) in the <strong>lumber</strong> were measured be<strong>for</strong>e and after the <strong>drying</strong><br />

process. Finally, quality control methods and also statistic analysis were used to choose the best <strong>schedule</strong>.<br />

Results showed that <strong>drying</strong> with <strong>schedule</strong> T6E3 led to low warping amounts and more smooth final<br />

moisture profile, compared to the other <strong>schedule</strong>s. So, <strong>schedule</strong> T6E3 can be recommended as an optimum<br />

program <strong>for</strong> <strong>drying</strong> of <strong>Paulownia</strong> <strong>lumber</strong> at commercial scale. From quality control viewpoint (Q.C), no<br />

undesirable phenomenon was occurred and all defects were inside the acceptable levels, but in mild<br />

<strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> like T6E3 amount of warp variation after <strong>drying</strong> and distribution around mean line had<br />

more suitable condition.<br />

Keywords: Kiln Schedule, <strong>Paulownia</strong> Fortunei, Drying Defects, FPL Recommendation<br />

1. Introduction<br />

The industry of wood products plays a key role in the economy of various countries. In some<br />

countries such as Canada, this industry uses about 1% of the total energy consumed, excluding the pulp<br />

and paper industry (Dincer, 1998). On the other hand, the <strong>lumber</strong> <strong>drying</strong> is one of the most important<br />

stages in the primary processing of wood which influence extensively the quality of the final product (Da<br />

Silva et al, 2010). Green (freshly cut) wood may have moisture content as low as 30% to as high as 250%.<br />

To increase the strength and rigidity of wood, as well as to protect it against biological damage, most of<br />

the moisture must be removed (Baronas et al 2001). The most important reasons <strong>for</strong> <strong>drying</strong> of wood can<br />

be mentioned as: increase of dimensional stability, improvement of mechanical properties, prevention<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

25


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

from rotting and fungal attacks, preparation <strong>for</strong> application of some treatments (gluing, penetration by<br />

protective materials, fire retardant), improvement of dye ability and trimming, reducing timber<br />

transportation costs and reducing weight of the manufactured artifacts (Wenger, 2006). Lumber <strong>drying</strong> is<br />

one of the most time and energy consuming steps in processing wood products. The anatomical structure<br />

of wood limits how rapidly water can move through and out of wood. Hence, rapid <strong>drying</strong> cause's defects<br />

such as surface and internal checks, collapse, splits, and warp. Furthermore, the variability of wood<br />

properties complicates the <strong>drying</strong> process. Each species has unique properties, and even within species,<br />

variability in <strong>drying</strong> rate and sensitivity to <strong>drying</strong> defects impose limitations on the development of<br />

standard <strong>drying</strong> procedures. The interactions of wood (species, dimensions), water, <strong>drying</strong> method and<br />

stress during <strong>drying</strong> are very complex (Simpson, 1998). The main goals of wood <strong>drying</strong> programs may<br />

include reduced energy consumption, increased <strong>drying</strong> rate, better quality, and finally reducing <strong>drying</strong><br />

costs (Korkut and Guller 2007).<br />

In Iran, research on wood <strong>drying</strong> started by Madhoushi (1996) who studied the <strong>drying</strong> behavior of<br />

Iranian beech (Fagus orienatalis). He could introduce a local <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> (T5-D1) based on FPL<br />

recommendations. Their method was used by means of other researchers and some <strong>schedule</strong>s were<br />

introduced <strong>for</strong> some other Iranian wood species. Table 1 summarize the most important studies and <strong>kiln</strong><br />

<strong>schedule</strong>s in this regard.<br />

Table 1. The most important studies on Iranian wood species and suggested <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

Researcher Date<br />

Madhooshi<br />

Tamjidi & Ebrahimi<br />

Ashouri & Ebrahimi<br />

Saadat<br />

Madhooshi et al.<br />

Korkut et al<br />

Suggested<br />

Schedule<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

Nominal<br />

Thickness (cm)<br />

Species<br />

1996 T5-D1 5 Beech<br />

1998 T8-E4 5 Alder<br />

1999 T4-D3 2.5 Oak<br />

2000 T3-B1 5 Hornbeam<br />

2006 T4-B2 5 Hornbeam<br />

2007 Mild <strong>schedule</strong> 5 Red-bud Maple<br />

Korkut and Guller 2007 Mild <strong>schedule</strong> 5<br />

Rafiei & Ebrahimi<br />

Tazakor Rrezaei &<br />

Ebrahimi<br />

Korkut et al.<br />

Shahverdi et al.<br />

European<br />

Hophornbeam<br />

2007 T4-B2 7.5 Hornbeam<br />

2010 T6-C4 7.5 Beech<br />

2010 Mild <strong>schedule</strong> 5 Rowan<br />

2012 T5-D2 7 Poplar<br />

26


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

Also, studies on <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> of other wood species which are belonging to Mediterranean area have<br />

been done in Turkey (Korkut et al, 2007, Korkut et al, 2010). This shows the importance of research on<br />

<strong>drying</strong> behavior of wood in this area.<br />

Nowadays, the necessity of conservation and preservation of native <strong>for</strong>est in Iran and also responding<br />

to required resources <strong>for</strong> use in the wood-related industries has drawn attention to the plantation of fastgrowing<br />

species. <strong>Paulownia</strong> is one of these important fast growing species which no <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> properly<br />

<strong>drying</strong> of it has ever been introduced in Iran. Many excellent characteristic of paulownia wood besides its<br />

growing rate made it exceptional species <strong>for</strong> wood industries. In China and some of the other Asian<br />

countries, paulownia wood is used <strong>for</strong> a variety of applications such as furniture, construction, musical<br />

instrument, shipbuilding, aircraft, packing boxes, coffins, paper, plywood, cabinetmaking, and molding<br />

(Flynn and Holder, 2001; Clad and Pommer, 1980). With considering all of these profits the aim of this<br />

study was establishing a <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> plantation-grown <strong>Paulownia</strong> <strong>for</strong>tunei in Iran based on<br />

FPL recommendations in order to continue the previous studies and try to complete the puzzle of <strong>kiln</strong><br />

dying <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> Iranian wood species.<br />

2. Material and Methods<br />

2.1. Preparation of experimental samples<br />

Freshly-cut logs of paulownia (P. <strong>for</strong>tunei) from two standing tress with approximately of 40–50 cm<br />

diameter, belonging to the educational <strong>for</strong>est of Gorgan University from Shast-Kola in Iran were selected.<br />

Samples were prepared commercially with a nominal thickness of 5 cm, a length of 150 cm and a width<br />

of 10 cm. Then their end-sections were covered with oil paint immediately in order to prevent <strong>for</strong>mation<br />

of local cracks. A semi-automatic conventional <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> (a lab <strong>kiln</strong>) with 1m 3 capacity was used <strong>for</strong><br />

research.<br />

To survey moisture reduction process related to time, in order to change <strong>schedule</strong> steps, 4 control<br />

samples were set among <strong>lumber</strong>s in <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong>. From each side of the control samples, test specimens of<br />

humidity indication with 2.5 cm length were cut. The remaining planks of 75cm were considered as the<br />

control samples. The control samples after cross section covering were weighed and put in the designated<br />

place in the <strong>kiln</strong> stack.<br />

2.2 Kiln <strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

Three different <strong>schedule</strong>s were used <strong>for</strong> <strong>drying</strong> (Tables 2 to 4) based on FPL recommendation. At<br />

first the most moderate <strong>schedule</strong> (T6-E3) per<strong>for</strong>med due to high moisture content in <strong>lumber</strong>s. With<br />

reduction of moisture content the severity of <strong>drying</strong> was increased and two other <strong>schedule</strong>s (T6-E4 and T7-<br />

E4) were per<strong>for</strong>med respectively. The regime of change in dry and wet bulb temperatures is shown in Fig<br />

2.<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

27


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

According to F.P.L proposed method, the beginning point was set based on the initial moisture<br />

content (MC) of <strong>kiln</strong> load and the program continued until MC reached to 8 ± 2 %. In order to determine<br />

the new condition of <strong>schedule</strong> at different steps of the work, the control samples, depending on <strong>kiln</strong> stack<br />

moisture draining rate, were weighed at least once a day. The stack moisture was calculated and the<br />

program’s steps were changed based on the average MC of the wettest half of the control samples<br />

(Simpson, 1991).<br />

Moisture<br />

content (%)<br />

Table2. T6-E3 Kiln Drying Schedule <strong>for</strong> P. <strong>for</strong>tunei Lumber with 5 cm Thickness.<br />

Dry bulb<br />

temperature<br />

(°C)<br />

Wet bulb<br />

temperature<br />

(°C)<br />

Wet bulb<br />

temperature<br />

depression<br />

(°C)<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

Relative<br />

Humidity (%)<br />

MC > 60 49 46 3 85 18.4<br />

60 49 45 4 79 16<br />

50 49 43 6 68 13.3<br />

40 49 39 10 52 9.8<br />

35 49 30 19 23 5.1<br />

25 54 26 28 18 2.1<br />

Final<br />

moisture<br />

54 26 28 18 2.1<br />

Moisture<br />

content (%)<br />

Table3. T6-E4 Kiln Drying Schedule <strong>for</strong> P. <strong>for</strong>tunei Lumber with 5 cm Thickness<br />

Dry bulb<br />

temperature<br />

(°C)<br />

Wet bulb<br />

temperature<br />

(°C)<br />

Wet bulb<br />

temperature<br />

depression<br />

(°C)<br />

Relative<br />

Humidity (%)<br />

MC > 60 49 45 4 79 16<br />

60 54 49 5 74 14.5<br />

50 60 52 8 64 11.9<br />

40 65 51 14 48 9<br />

35 65 43 22 28 5.9<br />

25 65 43 28 28 5.9<br />

Final moisture 65 43 28 28 5.9<br />

Equilibrium<br />

moisture<br />

Content (%)<br />

Equilibrium<br />

moisture<br />

Content (%)<br />

28


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

Moisture<br />

content (%)<br />

Table4. T7-E4 Kiln Drying Schedule <strong>for</strong> P. <strong>for</strong>tunei Lumber with 5 cm Thickness<br />

Dry bulb<br />

temperature<br />

(°C)<br />

Wet bulb<br />

temperature<br />

(°C)<br />

Wet bulb<br />

temperature<br />

depression<br />

(°C)<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

Relative<br />

Humidity (%)<br />

MC > 60 54 50 4 80 16.3<br />

60 60 55 5 76 14.9<br />

50 65 57 8 68 12.7<br />

40 71 57 14 52 9.6<br />

35 71 49 22 33 6.6<br />

25 76 43 28 24 5.2<br />

Final<br />

moisture<br />

76 43 28 24 5.2<br />

Equilibrium<br />

moisture<br />

Content (%)<br />

The <strong>kiln</strong> stack was 60 cm wide. Furthermore, 2×2 cm 2 stickers from the same species were used in<br />

this study. Air movement speed was also about 2 m.s -1 provided by internal fans, and air was horizontally<br />

circulated in the <strong>kiln</strong>.<br />

2.3 Drying Defects<br />

Residual stresses intensity in dried <strong>lumber</strong> was determined using the prong response method. Prong<br />

response test samples with dimensions equal to <strong>lumber</strong> ’ s full thickness and width, and a length of 20 mm<br />

were cut from each of the dried control samples using a band saw. Then, remaining stresses were<br />

calculated from the equation below (Fuller, 1995):<br />

PR = ˊ<br />

(1)<br />

In this equation PR is prong response of test sample (mm -1 ), x is the distance between outer prong<br />

edges be<strong>for</strong>e cutting (mm), ˊ is the distance between outer prong edges after cutting (mm), and l is the<br />

length of each test sample’s prong (Shahverdi et al, 2012.)<br />

29


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

(a): Test Sample Preparation (b): Shell and core test<br />

Fig.1. Cutting method of specimens <strong>for</strong> measurement of Casehardening (a) and MC gradient (b) (Simpson, 1991).<br />

To determine dried wood’s MC gradient, shell and core test was used. First, pieces with dimensions<br />

equal to board’s thickness and width, and a length of 20 mm were cut from each of the dried control<br />

samples. Then, further cuts are made into the shell and core portions, as shown in figure (1-b). The shell<br />

and core are weighed separately and then oven dried so that the moisture content can be calculated<br />

according to equation 2 (Simpson, 1991).<br />

Moisture content in percent (%) = Original weight Ovendry weight/Ovendry weight × 100 (2)<br />

The intensity of warping in dried woods of each <strong>kiln</strong> stack, including twist, bow and crook was<br />

measured according to DIN-EN 1310 standard. Length and depth of checks measured be<strong>for</strong>e and after<br />

<strong>drying</strong> in each program.<br />

2.4 Quality control methods<br />

To investigation <strong>drying</strong> defect intensity based on quality control methods, each row of <strong>lumber</strong>s were<br />

assumed as a quotient and the amount of warp variation be<strong>for</strong>e and after <strong>drying</strong> were measured. After<br />

that, upper and lower control level assessed. Distribution around mean line and being in acceptable level<br />

are two main factors to choose the best programs. In order to show total defect occurred in each program,<br />

C quantitative graph was used. Equation 3 to 5 shows how these data obtained (Ebahimi, 1991).<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

30


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

CL= (3)<br />

UCL= + A2 (4)<br />

LCL =- A2 (5)<br />

Where, is average of means, UCL is Upper Control Level, LCL is Lower Control Level, A2 is<br />

Constant Coefficient and is Average of Ranges.<br />

As mentioned be<strong>for</strong>e, C quantitative graph that con<strong>for</strong>m from Poisson distribution was used to show<br />

total defect occurred in each program. . Equation 6 to 9 shows process of calculation:<br />

(6)<br />

(8)<br />

(9)<br />

/ ℎ C = (7)<br />

= C+3SD UCL<br />

Where, C is average of Poisson distribution and SD is Standard deviation.<br />

3. Results and discussion<br />

3.1 Drying Rate and Moisture Gradient<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

LCL = C – 3SD<br />

= √ SD<br />

The <strong>Paulownia</strong> <strong>lumber</strong> <strong>drying</strong> rates in all the three <strong>schedule</strong>s are shown in Fig 2. In T6-E3, the initial<br />

MC was within the range of 130-180%, in T6-E4 within 120-160%, and in T7-E4 between 105 and 135%.<br />

In T7-E4 due to use of higher dry bulb temperature and wet bulb temperature depression, the <strong>drying</strong> rate<br />

was higher. In fact, in T6-E3 initial MC was higher and more moderate program considered. Contrary, in<br />

T7-E4 initial MC was lower than other <strong>schedule</strong> and more intensity program established. Consequently,<br />

wood <strong>drying</strong> rate increased from T6-E3 to T7-E4. It can be seen that the wood <strong>drying</strong> (6 days) rate under<br />

the <strong>schedule</strong> T7-E4 was higher compared to the other <strong>schedule</strong>s, and this was due to severity wet bulb<br />

depression in this <strong>schedule</strong>.<br />

31


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

Temprature (°C)<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

T 6E 3<br />

Dry bulb temperature Wet bulb temperature<br />

Average MC<br />

0 50 100 150 200 250 300<br />

Time (h)<br />

Temprature (°C)<br />

Fig. 2.Changes in dry- and wet bulb temperatures and the average MC of <strong>Paulownia</strong> <strong>lumber</strong> vs. time during the<br />

whole <strong>drying</strong> process in the three <strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

MC (%)<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

90<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

0<br />

180<br />

160<br />

140<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

0<br />

MC (%)<br />

T 7E 4<br />

Temperature (°C)<br />

Fig.3. Reduction of MC according to time under the three <strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

0<br />

T 6E 4<br />

Dry bulb temperature Wet bulb temperature<br />

Average MC<br />

Dry bulb temperature Wet bulb temperature<br />

Average MC<br />

0 50 100 150 200<br />

Time (h)<br />

0 2 4 6 8 10 12<br />

Time (day)<br />

0 50 100 150 200 250<br />

140<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

0<br />

Time (h)<br />

MC (%)<br />

T6E3<br />

T6E4<br />

T7E4<br />

160<br />

140<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

0<br />

MC (%)<br />

32


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

Fig. 3, shows as was expected wood’s <strong>drying</strong> rate under the program T7E4 was higher compared to the<br />

other two <strong>schedule</strong>s (6 days), and this was due to higher wet bulb depression of this program.<br />

3.2 Moisture content gradient<br />

MC gradient through the thickness of boards under the three <strong>schedule</strong>s (Fig. 4.) showed that MC<br />

gradient in the T6-E3 <strong>schedule</strong> had more homogeneity in comparison with the T7E4 <strong>schedule</strong> and it seems<br />

moderate condition during <strong>drying</strong> is very important <strong>for</strong> uni<strong>for</strong>m MC gradient. These finding are also<br />

reported by (Shahverdi et al, 2012; Wenger, 2006 and Simpson, 1991).<br />

MC (%)<br />

3.3 Residual <strong>drying</strong> stresses<br />

12<br />

10<br />

8<br />

6<br />

4<br />

2<br />

0<br />

Surface Core Surface<br />

Fig. 4. MC gradient through board’s thickness under the three <strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

Moisture variation between the board surface and its interior sections causes <strong>drying</strong> stress,<br />

consequently increase <strong>drying</strong> defects. For restriction of this undesirable phenomenon, it is necessary to<br />

make control the <strong>kiln</strong> temperatures and relative humidity particularly when the moisture content of the<br />

load is close to final desire amounts. Increase of moisture gradient through the thickness of board will<br />

result in greater wood <strong>drying</strong> stresses. If stresses exceed wood strength, superficial and internal cracks<br />

will occur easily.<br />

The intensities of remaining stresses in dried boards under tress <strong>schedule</strong>s are shown in Fig. 5.<br />

Statistical analysis showed that in terms of remaining stresses in dried woods, there was a significant<br />

difference ( 0/05 between the <strong>schedule</strong>s. In addition, data analysis with Duncan test showed that<br />

the two <strong>schedule</strong>s T6-E3 and T6-E4 could be placed into one group.<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

T6E3<br />

T6E4<br />

T7E4<br />

33


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Ap pri l-Special Issue<br />

3.4 Checks<br />

Fig. 5.Intensity of residual stresses in dried boards under the three three <strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

<strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

Since in in all all programs, programs, no no kind kind of of checks checks type type occurred occurred or or developed, developed, in in these these cases all <strong>schedule</strong>s had<br />

had<br />

similar condition. It seems due to individual characteristic and morphologic trait of <strong>Paulownia</strong> species<br />

they are are not not susceptible susceptible <strong>for</strong> <strong>for</strong> checks checks or or cracks cracks during during wood wood <strong>drying</strong> <strong>drying</strong> and and except except very small small checks checks around<br />

hollow pith pith or or checks checks due due to to knot knot and and decay, decay, no no significant significant checks checks have have been been seen. seen. This This is is consistent with<br />

with<br />

results lts achieved by Flynn and Holder (2001), Clad and Pommer (1980).<br />

3.5 Warps<br />

Warp in in <strong>lumber</strong> <strong>lumber</strong> is is any any deviation deviation of of the the face face or or edge edge of of a a board board from from flatness flatness or or any edge edge that that is not at<br />

right angles to the adjacent face or edge (Simpson, 1991). Different types of warping often are a result of<br />

difference in in tangential, tangential, radial, radial, or or longitudinal longitudinal shrinkage, shrinkage, spiral spiral grain, grain, fiber fiber deviation, deviation, present present of juvenile<br />

wood, density density changes changes in in board’s board’s different different parts, parts, or or stresses stresses and and strains strains due due to tree growth (Wood<br />

handbook, 2010). Results of of statistical statistical analysis analysis showed showed that that in in terms terms of of bowing bowing defect at 0/05<br />

there weren’t significant difference between T6E3 T and T6E4 programs and Duncan test put them into one<br />

group and T7E4 in a distinct group. Also similar result obtained <strong>for</strong> crooking defect. In terms of twisting<br />

defect there there was was no no significant significant difference difference between between the the Schedules Schedules and and Duncan Duncan test test put put all all programs programs in in one<br />

group (Table 5).<br />

Defect type<br />

Bow (mm)<br />

Crook (mm)<br />

Twist (mm)<br />

*: Standard Deviation<br />

CASEHARDENING<br />

(%)<br />

Table.5. Average intensity of warps in dried boards under the three <strong>schedule</strong>s<br />

Schedule<br />

T6E3<br />

0.18 b<br />

(0.02)<br />

0.14 b<br />

(0.02) *<br />

(0.03)<br />

.08 a<br />

(0.03)<br />

0.2<br />

0.15 0<br />

0.1<br />

0.05 0<br />

0<br />

b<br />

T6E4<br />

0.19 b<br />

(0.03)<br />

0.15 b<br />

(0.03)<br />

.07 a<br />

(0.04)<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

b<br />

T6E3 T6E4 T7E4<br />

Schedule<br />

a<br />

T7E4<br />

0.31 a<br />

(0.07)<br />

0.22 a<br />

(0.05)<br />

.05 a<br />

(0.04)<br />

ISSN 2307-3071<br />

34


Crook<br />

Bow<br />

World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

According to (Straze et al, 2010), spiral grain and distance from the pith to the centre of the crosssection<br />

of the board, which is an indirect expression of the annual-ring curvature, are two main factors in<br />

twisting defect among boards. The results show that when a better quality is necessary, the mild <strong>drying</strong><br />

<strong>schedule</strong> should be applied and <strong>for</strong> high quality T6E3 program proposed. To reduce <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> cost, T6E4<br />

program can be alternative case because it is similar to T6E3 program. If high quality is necessary, T7- E4<br />

program shouldn’t be used.<br />

3.6 Quality control analysis<br />

From quality control viewpoint (Q.C), no undesirable phenomenon was occurred and all defects were<br />

among acceptable level, but in mild <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> like T6-E3 amount of warp variation after <strong>drying</strong> and<br />

distribution around mean line had more suitable condition. In addition, total defects that occurred during<br />

<strong>drying</strong> process shown with C quantitative graph and in that case T6E4 program had better condition. It<br />

seems initial moisture content and severity of <strong>drying</strong> process had significant effect on warp occurrence<br />

(Fig 6).<br />

T6E3<br />

0.40<br />

0.30<br />

0.20<br />

0.10<br />

0.00<br />

-0.10 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

0.40<br />

0.30<br />

0.20<br />

0.10<br />

0.00<br />

-0.10<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

T6E4<br />

0.40<br />

0.30<br />

0.20<br />

0.10<br />

0.00<br />

0.50<br />

0.40<br />

0.30<br />

0.20<br />

0.10<br />

0.00<br />

-0.10<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

T7E4<br />

0.70<br />

0.60<br />

0.50<br />

0.40<br />

0.30<br />

0.20<br />

0.10<br />

0.00<br />

0.45<br />

0.35<br />

0.25<br />

0.15<br />

0.05<br />

-0.05<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

35


Twist<br />

Total(C)<br />

World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

0.20<br />

0.15<br />

0.10<br />

0.05<br />

0.00<br />

-0.05<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

Fig. 6. Characteristic quantitative curve used <strong>for</strong> average of warp variation intensity in each program. Horizontal<br />

axis is row number and vertical axis in each defect is base on (mm) & <strong>for</strong> (c) base on number.<br />

4. Conclusion<br />

Besides genetic and growth characteristics that are individual <strong>for</strong> every species, two main factors<br />

during wood <strong>drying</strong> are temperature and MC. During <strong>Paulownia</strong> <strong>drying</strong>, undesirable events are not<br />

expected but its high initial MC can be as an obstacle <strong>for</strong> increasing <strong>drying</strong> rate. Consequently, pre-<strong>drying</strong><br />

can be very helpful <strong>for</strong> species like <strong>Paulownia</strong> and it plays a key role <strong>for</strong> energy saving in additional<br />

increasing wood <strong>drying</strong> quality. As result show when MC is high, moderate <strong>schedule</strong> lead better quality<br />

and intense programs may cause wood defects increasing. Generally, <strong>Paulownia</strong> species can be dried very<br />

fast with high quality if proper <strong>schedule</strong> is chosen. This result is compatible with Wenger (2006) and<br />

(Shahverdi et al, 2012). According to them to obtain better quality and prevent serious defects mild<br />

<strong>schedule</strong> should be used and when initial MC is high, intense <strong>schedule</strong> may cause defects occurrence.<br />

References<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

0.25<br />

0.20<br />

0.15<br />

0.10<br />

0.05<br />

0.00<br />

-0.05<br />

-0.10<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

1) Ashouri, A., and Ebrahimi, Gh. (1999). <strong>Establishing</strong> <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> oak <strong>lumber</strong>, J.<br />

Agric. Sci. Natur. Resour. 3, 31-37.<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

0.15<br />

0.05<br />

-0.05<br />

-0.15<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7<br />

36


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

2) Baronas, R., Ivanauskas, F., Juodeikiene, L., and Kajalavicius, A. (2001). Nonlinear Analysis ;<br />

Modelling and control, N.6, No.2, 3-14<br />

3) Clad, W. and Pommer, E. (1980). Manufacture of particleboard from kiri (Palownia tomentosa,<br />

Fam. Scrouphulariaceae). Holz Roh Werkst. 38. 385-391.<br />

4) Dasilva,W.P,. Dasilva, L.D,. Esilva, M.D and Nascimento, L.P. (2010). Optimization and<br />

simulation of <strong>drying</strong> processes using diffusion models: application to wood <strong>drying</strong> using <strong>for</strong>ced<br />

air at low temperature. Wood Sci<br />

5) Technol. DOI 10.1007/s00226-010-0391-x.<br />

6) Dincer, I. (1998). Moisture transfer analysis during <strong>drying</strong> of slab woods. Heat Mass Transf.<br />

34(4):317–320.<br />

7) DIN EN 1310 (1997). Round and sawn timber - Method of measurement of features.<br />

8) Ebrahimi, Gh. (1983). Air Drying of Lumber, Elmi va Phan publication, Iran.<br />

9) Ebrahimi, Gh. (1991). Quality Control, Tehran University publication, Iran.<br />

10) Ebrahimi, Gh., and Faezipour, M. (1994). Kiln Drying Lumber, University of Tehran Publication,<br />

Iran.<br />

11) Flynn, H and Holder, C. (2001). Useful wood of the world. Forest Products Society. Madison,<br />

WI.<br />

12) Fuller, J. (1995). Modeling Prong Test Response during Conditioning of Red Oak Lumber, U.S.<br />

Department of Agriculture, Forest Product Laboratory, Madison, WI.(Res. Rep. No.FPL-RP-<br />

540).<br />

13) Korkut, S., and Guller, B. (2007). Comparison of two <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong>s <strong>for</strong> European Hophorn –<br />

beam (Ostrya carpinifolia Scop.) <strong>lumber</strong>, Drying Technology. 25(12), 1977- 1984.<br />

14) Korkut, S., Guller, B., and Budakci, M. (2007). Kiln <strong>drying</strong> properties of red-bud maple(Acer<br />

trautvetteri Medw.)<br />

15) Lumber,” In: Proceedings of 10th IUFRO International Wood Drying Conferences, August 26-<br />

30, Orono, Maine, USA.<br />

16) Korkut, S., Keskin, H., Unsal, O., and Bajraktari, A. (2010). Kiln <strong>drying</strong> properties of Rowan<br />

(Sorbus aucuparia L.)<br />

17) Lumber, In: Proceedings of 11th International IUFRO Wood Drying Conference, January 18-22,<br />

Skellefteå, Sweden.<br />

18) Madhooshi, M., Kazemi-Veisari, A., Omidvar, A., and Ebrahimi, Gh. (2007). Kiln <strong>drying</strong><br />

<strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> Carpinus betulus, J. Agric. Sci. Natur. Resour. 13(6), 155-163.<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

37


World of Sciences Journal; 2013-Apri l-Special Issue ISSN 2307-3071<br />

19) Madhooshi, M. (1996). <strong>Establishing</strong> <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> Beech <strong>lumber</strong> of 5 cm in thickness,<br />

Dissertation, Tarbiat Modares University.<br />

20) Rahimi, S. (2008). <strong>Establishing</strong> <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> aspen (Populus nigra) <strong>lumber</strong> with 5 cm<br />

in thickness, Dissertation, University of Tehran.<br />

21) Rafiei, F.,and Ebrahimi, Gh. (2007). Adjustment of <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> conditions <strong>for</strong> hornbeam<br />

(Carpinus betulus L.) wood of 7.5 cm thickness, Journal of the Iranian Natural Res. 60(2),<br />

607-616.<br />

22) Saadat, P. (2000). <strong>Establishing</strong> <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> hornbeam (Carpinus betulus) <strong>lumber</strong> of<br />

50 mm in thickness, Dissertation, Islamic Azad University.<br />

23) Shahverdi, M., Dashti, H., and Hossein, M.A. (2012). <strong>Establishing</strong> a Kiln Drying Schedule <strong>for</strong><br />

Poplar (populous Alba) <strong>lumber</strong> of 7 cm thickness. BioResources 7(1), 26 – 37.<br />

24) Simpson, W. T. (1991). Dry Kiln Operator's Manual, USDA Forest Service, Agriculture<br />

Handbook 188.<br />

25) Straze, A., Kliger, R., Johansson. M., and Gorisek, Z. (2010). Development of twist on boards of<br />

Norway spruce during <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong>. COST E 53 conference - Quality Control <strong>for</strong> Wood and Wood<br />

Products.<br />

26) Tamjidi, A., and Ebrahimi, Gh. (1998). <strong>Establishing</strong> <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> alder (Alnus<br />

subcordata) with 5 cm thickness, Dissertation, Tarbiat Modares University.<br />

27) Tazakor Rrezaei, V., and Ebrahimi, Gh. (2010). <strong>Establishing</strong> <strong>kiln</strong> <strong>drying</strong> <strong>schedule</strong> <strong>for</strong> Beech<br />

(Fagus Orientalis) at 7.5 cm thickness from Kelardasht region, In: Proceedings of 53 rd<br />

International Convention of Society of Wood Science and Technology, October11-14, Geneva,<br />

Switzerland.<br />

28) Wenger, M.C. (2006). Principles and Practices of Drying Lumber. Lignomat. USLTD.<br />

www.engineerspress.com<br />

38

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!