06.06.2013 Views

THE EFFECTS OF INTRASPECIFIC AND INTERSPECIFIC

THE EFFECTS OF INTRASPECIFIC AND INTERSPECIFIC

THE EFFECTS OF INTRASPECIFIC AND INTERSPECIFIC

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

different niches could cooperate. The stalk length was too variable to place a trend upon,<br />

so for that the null hypothesis can be accepted, meaning there is no significant difference<br />

in pea stalk height based on competition. Eventually, though, plants with longer roots<br />

will do better competitively than plants with shorter roots, for they can reach more<br />

nutrients and have more surface area to absorb water, so if the experiment was continued<br />

past 17 days, these plants with longer roots could have grown longer stalks as well.<br />

The conclusions reached in this lab verify the statement put forth in 1970 by<br />

Alexander et al. that intraspecific competition is more damaging, for plants of the same<br />

species have the exact same needs and adaptations. The wheat root lengths were hurt<br />

more by increased density among other wheat plants than among the same number of<br />

peas. For example, the mean root length of 5 wheat seeds per pot was 9.86 cm, which<br />

was less than the mean root length of 3 wheat and 2 pea seeds per pot (10.55 cm). It is<br />

the same density, but that addition of peas instead of wheat yields longer roots. The<br />

increase in root length in one pea grown with one wheat seed versus one pea grown alone<br />

supports Sullivan’s statement that intercropping can be beneficial. However, this<br />

increase could be inflated because there was not enough pea data.<br />

When retrying such an experiment, there are several design changes that should<br />

be made. First, fresh seeds that have a higher probability of germination should be used.<br />

In this study, two year old Alaskan pea seeds that had been stored in a plastic bag had<br />

been used, and not very many actually germinated. Also, learning how to lightly add pot<br />

soil on top may help, for it may have been too packed for some seeds to grow in this<br />

experiment. In addition, it would be more controlled to have all the pots on one tray<br />

under the same light, so the resources being received are the same. To create more<br />

10

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!