28.06.2013 Views

Wigmore, Toulmin and Walton: The Diagramming Trinity and their ...

Wigmore, Toulmin and Walton: The Diagramming Trinity and their ...

Wigmore, Toulmin and Walton: The Diagramming Trinity and their ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

¦¨§©¥¦¨¤ ¡ £¦¨©<br />

¡£¢¥¤<br />

¤ ¡¢ §¡¡ ©¡§¡¡¦¨ ¡<br />

¡£¢¨§¤<br />

©¢§¡©<br />

¥<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

£¨<br />

¨¥<br />

£<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¨¨¥¥¥<br />

£¨¥<br />

¥¥££<br />

££££££<br />

££¨¨¨<br />

££¥¥££££<br />

¥£¨¥¨¨<br />

¨£££<br />

£££<br />

££££¨<br />

£<br />

£¡ £¢¡¤¦¥£§¡¨©¡¦©¡©¡ <br />

<br />

¡¦¥§¨©¡¦©¡©¡ <br />

£ ¡¦


¥£¥¨¨¥¨¨<br />

<br />

££¨<br />

££¥£¨¨¨<br />

£<br />

¥£<br />

£<br />

¨¥¨£<br />

£¥¥££¥<br />

£££¥<br />

<br />

¨¥¥<br />

¨¥£¥<br />

¨£<br />

¨££¥<br />

£¨¨<br />

£¥££¨£££¨£<br />

££££¥£<br />

<br />

£££<br />

£¥¨ <br />

¥££<br />

£££<br />

<br />

¨£¨<br />

££<br />

¨<br />

¥££¨¨<br />

£¨ <br />

<br />

¨£¡ ££<br />

£<br />

£££¥¨£<br />

¨¨££¥££<br />

££¨<br />

<br />

¥<br />

¨£¥££££<br />

££££¨£¥¥<br />

£¨<br />

¨<br />

¨<br />

£<br />

£¨


¥£¨<br />

¥ ¥£<br />

<br />

£ ¨ <br />

<br />

¨¨<br />

££<br />

£¥¨¥£<br />

£¨<br />

£££££¨<br />

¨££¨£¥<br />

££¥£<br />

££<br />

<br />

£<br />

££¨


¨££¥<br />

£££¨¨¨<br />

££££££¨<br />

£¥<br />

<br />

¥£¥<br />

££££<br />

£¨<br />

£¥¥¨££<br />

¥¨£<br />

££¨<br />

¨££¥££££<br />

££¥££¥<br />

<br />

£<br />

¥¨<br />

£<br />

¨¨<br />

¨£¨£¥<br />

<br />

£¨<br />

¥¨¥£<br />

¨<br />

££ <br />

£¨££<br />

<br />

££££<br />

££¨££<br />

££¨<br />

<br />

£ <br />

<br />

£¥¥¥¨£¨


£ <br />

<br />

¥££<br />

¨<br />

£££££<br />

£¥¥<br />

¥£¥£¥<br />

¨¥£<br />

<br />

£¨¥£<br />

£<br />

<br />

¥£¨<br />

¥<br />

£¥£££¥£ <br />

<br />

<br />

¥£ £ ¨£<br />

£¨¥¨<br />

<br />

££¥£<br />

££<br />

£¨<br />

££<br />

¨£££¨£¥¥£<br />

££<br />

£¨£<br />

<br />

¥£¥<br />

£<br />

¨¨ ¨<br />

<br />

¥ <br />

<br />

<br />

¨£<br />

££<br />

<br />

£ £ £<br />

<br />

¥<br />

¨£¥£<br />

£<br />

¨ £ ££ ¨ £<br />

<br />

£ <br />

¥£<br />

££¥£<br />

£


£ <br />

£<br />

<br />

<br />

¨¨¨<br />

¨¨££<br />

£¨£<br />

£<br />

<br />

£¨¥<br />

¥££<br />

¨¥£<br />

££££¨£<br />

¨¨<br />

£¨¨££<br />

¥¥£££¥¨<br />

<br />

<br />

¨ <br />

<br />

£ ¥¥<br />

¥<br />

£££¥<br />

¨¨£<br />

£<br />

£<br />

<br />

¨¥¨£¥¨¥£<br />

¨¨£¨<br />

¥¨£<br />

<br />

¥¨¨¨¥£££<br />

<br />

£<br />

£¥£<br />

¨£¨£¥£<br />

£¨¨£<br />

¥££¥££¥<br />

£¥£<br />

£££££¨£<br />

££¨£¥<br />

£¥££¨£<br />

¨£<br />

£¥£££<br />

£££¥£¨££¨<br />

£££<br />

££££££


£¥<br />

<br />

££<br />

£¥£¨£¨<br />

£££<br />

£££¥££<br />

£<br />

£¥££¨££¨<br />

<br />

££<br />

<br />

¨¨£<br />

££¨¨<br />

£££¨<br />

£¥£££¨<br />

£££¥£££<br />

£¥¨<br />

££<br />

<br />

<br />

£¨¨<br />

¨¥<br />

¥<br />

£££££¨<br />

£££<br />

££££¨<br />

£<br />

£<br />

¨¥£


¨£££<br />

£££<br />

£<br />

¨£¨£<br />

££<br />

¥<br />

<br />

¨£<br />

£<br />

£££¨<br />

¨£<br />

¥£££<br />

£££££<br />

££¥<br />

££<br />

<br />

£¨£<br />

¥£££¥£¥<br />

¨££<br />

<br />

£<br />

£¨¥¨<br />

££<br />

¥£¥££<br />

£¨<br />

¨<br />

<br />

<br />

££££££<br />

£££<br />

£¥<br />

¥£<br />

£¥£<br />

¨¥£¥<br />

¨<br />

£<br />

<br />

£ <br />

<br />

£<br />

<br />

£££<br />

£¨££<br />

¨££¨<br />

<br />

£¥£<br />

<br />

¨¨¥£¥<br />

£££¨<br />

£¥<br />

¥£<br />

££¥¥£<br />

£<br />

£ <br />

<br />

£<br />

<br />

¨¥¥££


¨£££<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

££<br />

££<br />

££££<br />

¥£<br />

£¨<br />

£<br />

¥££ £¨¥¨<br />

<br />

¡¥£¨£¨¥£<br />

£¥£¥£<br />

£¥<br />

¨£¥¥££<br />

££££££<br />

££££<br />

££<br />

£¥<br />

<br />

<br />

££££<br />

£ ¨<br />

<br />

¥¨¥¨<br />

<br />

£¥£££<br />

££¨<br />

££<br />

£ £<br />

£¥<br />

¥¥<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

£<br />

¨££¥£<br />

£¥£££<br />

£ ££<br />

£££¨£<br />

¨££<br />

££¥<br />

££££££<br />

££¥£££<br />

¥£££<br />

£¥¨<br />

£


¥¨£<br />

¡<br />

£<br />

<br />

¥¥¥¥¨¨¥£<br />

<br />

£¥¥£¥£<br />

<br />

£££¥¨£<br />

£££¨¨££<br />

¨<br />

¥£¨¥££¨<br />

£££<br />

<br />

£¥¨¨<br />

¨¥<br />

<br />

¥ £<br />

<br />

<br />

¨¨<br />

££¨¨¥<br />

£¥£<br />

<br />

££¨¥£¨<br />

£ <br />

¥££<br />

£££¥¥¨¨<br />

¨¨¥ <br />

¥£<br />

¨<br />

<br />

¥ <br />

¨£<br />

<br />

£¥<br />

£££££<br />

<br />

¨<br />

¥£<br />

¥¨<br />

¥¥¨<br />

¨¨


££¨¨<br />

£¨¨££¥ <br />

<br />

¨£¥<br />

£<br />

¨¦££<br />

¥£¥¨¨<br />

¨£¥£¥<br />

£<br />

£¨<br />

¥££<br />

£¥££¥¥<br />

£¨<br />

££££<br />

¨££<br />

¨££¥£<br />

£¨¥<br />

£¨££¥<br />

¥£¨£¥£<br />

£¨££¥<br />

££££<br />

¨¥¨¨¨¥£<br />

£££¥£¨<br />

¨££¨¨£<br />

£¨£¥¥<br />

£¨¨<br />

¥£


£££¨<br />

<br />

¥£¨¨££<br />

£££<br />

££<br />

¥£<br />

£¥££<br />

£¨<br />

¨¥¨<br />

¨£<br />

<br />

¥£<br />

£¥£¥<br />

¨¥¨ ££££<br />

<br />

£££¨¨££¥<br />

£<br />

¨¨¨£¥<br />

¨¨<br />

£¨£<br />

<br />

¨£<br />

£¨<br />

£<br />

£¨£¨<br />

¨¨¨<br />

£££¨<br />

££¥££££<br />

¨£¨¨<br />

<br />

£¨¨<br />

£¨£¨¥<br />

¨¨¥<br />

<br />

¨£££<br />

<br />

¥<br />

¥£<br />

¨£££££<br />

£¨¨¨£<br />

£¨¨ <br />

¥<br />

¥£¨<br />

£<br />

¥ £¥¥£<br />

<br />

£¥££<br />

¨¨¨¥¨££¥£¨<br />

¥££¨££¨<br />

¨¥<br />

¥<br />

££


¨¨¨ <br />

<br />

£ <br />

<br />

¨£ <br />

<br />

¥£¥£¨£<br />

££££<br />

¥¥££££<br />

£¥£¨££ ¥<br />

<br />

£¨<br />

<br />

£¨£¨£¨£<br />

¨<br />

££<br />

<br />

¥£¥¥¥<br />

£¨£¡¨¥£<br />

¨££¨£<br />

£¨¥¨<br />

¥£¨¥£<br />

¨<br />

<br />

£££<br />

£££<br />

£¡


¨¨<br />

¨££<br />

£<br />

£ <br />

<br />

£¥£¨¨£<br />

¥£<br />

££<br />

¨£<br />

£<br />

££¥¦<br />

¨£<br />

¥££<br />

£ <br />

<br />

¥¨¥¨<br />

£¥££<br />

££ <br />

¨¥££¥<br />

£££<br />

£¨¨£<br />

¥£¨¨¨¥£ <br />

<br />

¨££<br />

¥£¥£££££<br />

¨££<br />

¨<br />

<br />

<br />

¨£¥£¨¥¨£<br />

££¨¨<br />

££<br />

£<br />

¥<br />

£<br />

¨££<br />

<br />

££¨<br />

£££¨<br />

¨£¨¨£<br />

¥£££<br />

£<br />

¨¨<br />

£<br />

£¨<br />

£¥¨££££<br />

£¥<br />

<br />

¥£¥£¨£<br />

£¨£££<br />

¥£¨¥£¨<br />

££££<br />

¨£££¥¨<br />

¥¥¥


£¨¥£¥<br />

¥¦££¥£<br />

¨££<br />

¨¥££<br />

£££¥££<br />

¥£<br />

¨¨£<br />

¥ £ <br />

<br />

£££<br />

<br />

£££¨££<br />

££¥££¨¨£¥<br />

£¥<br />

¨£<br />

£¨£<br />

£<br />

££¨¨¥<br />

£££¨<br />

¨£¥<br />

££<br />

£<br />

£££¨<br />

££££<br />

£¨££¨£<br />

<br />

££££<br />

£<br />

££<br />

¥<br />

<br />

£¥ ¥£¥<br />

££¥<br />

££££££<br />

¨££<br />

££<br />

£££<br />

£¨¨¥£<br />

¦


£¥££<br />

£¥<br />

££<br />

£¨¨£££<br />

£¨<br />

£££££<br />

££<br />

£<br />

¥££¥£<br />

££<br />

£££¥¥££<br />

££¥<br />

¥£¥¨<br />

£¥£<br />

££¥££¥<br />

££¨<br />

<br />

¨¨¥£¥<br />

££££<br />

<br />

<br />

¨£££<br />

££¨£¥£<br />

¥<br />

£££<br />

££¨¨<br />

£¥¨¥£<br />

<br />

£¥¨£<br />

¨££¥£<br />

¥£¨¥¨¥££<br />

££¨¨¨¨¥£<br />

¨¥¨¥¥£<br />

£¨£¥£<br />

££<br />

£¥¥¨£<br />

££¨£<br />

<br />

¥<br />

££¥£<br />

¨££¥££<br />

£££¨¥££¥£¥<br />

¥£¥£¥¨


£<br />

¥£¥¨<br />

¨£<br />

£¨£<br />

¥¨£¥¨¨<br />

££¨£££<br />

££¥<br />

¨££¥££<br />

££¥£¨£££<br />

£¥<br />

¨¨££¥£¥<br />

££ £ ¨<br />

<br />

£¨£¨££¨££¥<br />

£ <br />

£££¨£¨<br />

£¨¨£ <br />

¨<br />

¨¥¨£¥<br />

¥£<br />

¥¥¨¥£<br />

£¥<br />

£££<br />

<br />

¥£¥£££¥<br />

£££<br />

£¨££<br />

<br />

£<br />

£ ¨£ <br />

<br />

£¨<br />

¥£¥£<br />

£¥£££¥£¨£££<br />

££££<br />

¥£¨¨£¨££<br />

££££¥<br />

¥£<br />

¡ <br />

£¨¨£¥<br />

<br />

£¥¨<br />

££££££<br />

££ ¨££££<br />

£<br />

¨£££¥<br />

¨¨¥££¨<br />

¦


¨£££<br />

££££££££<br />

¨¨<br />

£¥£<br />

¥£££££££<br />

¥¨¨££¥£<br />

<br />

¥¥£ £<br />

¨£¥££<br />

¨¨¥<br />

<br />

¥<br />

¨¥£££<br />

£££££¥¥££<br />

£¨£<br />

£¥<br />

¥<br />

£¥££¨<br />

¨<br />

£<br />

£¥£¨£¥<br />

£¨<br />

££<br />

¥£¥£¥£¥<br />

£ £££¥£ <br />

£<br />

¨£¥¨£<br />

££¨£££<br />

¨£¥¨££<br />

£ <br />

¨<br />

<br />

£¨££¨<br />

££<br />

££ ££££<br />

¥£<br />

£¥£¨¨¨<br />

¡££¨<br />

¨¨¨¥££<br />

<br />

¨¥£¥£<br />

¥¨¥


£¨¥ ¨<br />

¨<br />

£££<br />

££<br />

£¥¨¨<br />

<br />

<br />

£¨£¥¨<br />

£<br />

¨ <br />

<br />

¥£<br />

¥<br />

£<br />

£<br />

¥££<br />

¥<br />

¨¥£££<br />

£<br />

¨<br />

£££¨£<br />

£<br />

¥££££¥<br />

¨¥££££¨<br />

¥¨£££¨<br />

££¥£ £<br />

<br />

£¨¥£<br />

<br />

£<br />

¥£<br />

££<br />

¨£ <br />

¥<br />

¨¨£<br />

£<br />

¨£¨<br />

££¥£££<br />

££££<br />

£<br />

££¨¥¥¥<br />

£££¥¥<br />

¨££¨¨<br />

£¥<br />

£¥ <br />

<br />

££££¥<br />

<br />

<br />

£¥££¥<br />

<br />

££££<br />

¨££££<br />

¥¨


¡ £¢ <br />

£¨£¨¨¥<br />

<br />

¥£££££<br />

¥£¨¥£<br />

££¥¥£<br />

¨<br />

¥£££¨£¥<br />

¥£¥<br />

¨£¨<br />

£ <br />

¥¨£<br />

¨££<br />

££¨¨£<br />

¥<br />

£¦£<br />

<br />

£<br />

¡ <br />

¨<br />

¨££<br />

£<br />

££¥££<br />

£¥¨£££<br />

¨££££<br />

££¥£££<br />

<br />

¨¨¥¥<br />

¥¥¥££<br />

£<br />

££¨££<br />

¨¨£¥££¨¥<br />

£¨££<br />

£<br />

¨£¥££££¨<br />

££<br />

£<br />

£¥¨¥<br />

¨¥<br />

£<br />

¨<br />

£¨£<br />

<br />

¨¨¥¥¨£ £<br />

<br />

££¨¦¤<br />

£¥¤<br />

£££ £££<br />

<br />

<br />

¥£<br />

¥¨£ <br />

§£<br />

¥££¥¥£££<br />

£<br />

<br />

£¥<br />

¨££¨


£¨<br />

¥¥£ £¨¥£<br />

¨<br />

¥£¨£¨££<br />

£¨£££¥£¥<br />

££<br />

<br />

££¨¨<br />

¨£<br />

££¨<br />

£¨£¥¨¨<br />

££¥<br />

£££££<br />

££<br />

<br />

£££<br />

¨© ¦<br />

££<br />

££¨<br />

¥<br />

<br />

£¨<br />

£££<br />

£¥£¨<br />

¨££<br />

¨¥¨£££ ¨<br />

<br />

£££¥<br />

££¥<br />

<br />

£¥¥£<br />

£¨¨<br />

<br />

<br />

£<br />

¥£¨¨£¨¨<br />

¥£¥¥<br />

¨£££<br />

££¨£<br />

¨¥£<br />

£<br />

¨¡ ¦<br />

¨£¨¥£¥<br />

££££¥££¥<br />

¨¨<br />

£<br />

£¥<br />

££<br />

£££¥£¥£


¡£ <br />

<br />

<br />

¨££¨<br />

£<br />

££££¨¨£¥<br />

££¨£¥£<br />

£¥££¥<br />

£££¥£££<br />

£¨££<br />

£££<br />

£¨£¨<br />

¨<br />

£¨£ <br />

£<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

£¥£¥¥<br />

££<br />

<br />

¨<br />

£ ¥ <br />

£¥£<br />

£¨<br />

£<br />

¥£¨<br />

£¨£¨<br />

¥£¥££¥¨<br />

£¥£££<br />

¥¥£ ¥<br />

¨<br />

¥¨£¥¨£<br />

£¥£¥£<br />

£¨¨¨<br />

£¨££<br />

¨¥¥¥<br />

<br />

¨£¨<br />

¨¨<br />

<br />

££<br />

£¥<br />

££££<br />

£¨<br />

£¨£¥£


£<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

£¨¥<br />

£¨£<br />

£¨¥£<br />

£¨<br />

¨£¨<br />

¨¨£¥£<br />

¨£<br />

¥£¨<br />

£¨£¨¨¥<br />

¨££¨<br />

£<br />

¨<br />

¨¥¨¥<br />

¨<br />

<br />

¨¨¥¨¨<br />

¨££¥¨<br />

£


¥¨££££<br />

¨££££<br />

£ ¡ ¡¡<br />

£<br />

£¥¡£¡<br />

£<br />

£<br />

¨¥££<br />

£<br />

¥¥£¥<br />

£¨£££¥£<br />

££¨£££<br />

£££££¥££<br />

££¨¨££¥£¨<br />

£<br />

¡<br />

£<br />

¥¦£<br />

£¨¥££<br />

££¨<br />

¥££¨£<br />

¨£££¥¥£££¥£<br />

¥££££<br />

£¥£¥¨<br />

¥££¥£<br />

£¨£<br />

<br />

<br />

£¥¨¨¨¥<br />

£¥£¨¥¥<br />

££¥£<br />

¥£¥¥¥<br />

££<br />

<br />

£¥¨£<br />

<br />

£¨£<br />

£<br />

¥££¥££<br />

££¥£<br />

¨£<br />

©<br />

¡¨ <br />

<br />

¨¥£<br />

££<br />

£¥£££¨<br />

¥¦¡


£<br />

£££¥£¨£<br />

£ £<br />

££¥£<br />

¨ ¥¨<br />

¨<br />

£££¥¨<br />

¥££<br />

¨£¨<br />

¥££¥¨<br />

¥¨¨¨£¨<br />

£ £<br />

¥£<br />

£¥¥£££¥£¨<br />

££¨¨££<br />

£¨¨££<br />

¥<br />

£¥<br />

¨£¥££<br />

£¨¨<br />

¥¨£££<br />

£¥£¨¨£<br />

£¥££<br />

£<br />

£¨£¡<br />

¥£¨£<br />

<br />

£££¥£<br />

¥£¨££<br />

¨¨¥££<br />

£¨££<br />

££¥¨£ £<br />

¨£<br />

£¨¡¥<br />

¨¨¨£¥££<br />

¡¨£<br />

££¥£<br />

££<br />

£¥£<br />

£¨¨£¥<br />

¨¨<br />

¨££££¥<br />

¨¥¥¥£¥£¥<br />

££¨<br />

<br />

£¦£<br />

¥£¨£<br />

£¨£<br />

¡


¦<br />

<br />

¨<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¨ <br />

<br />

¦<br />

<br />

<br />

¨£¦<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¨¦<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¥<br />

<br />

£<br />

<br />

¥ <br />

<br />

¨ ¥<br />

¦¦<br />

£<br />

<br />

¦<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¥ ¡<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¦¦<br />

<br />

¦ <br />

<br />

<br />

¦<br />

<br />

£ <br />

<br />

¦ ¦<br />

<br />

¥ ¥<br />

<br />

<br />

£


£<br />

<br />

¦ ¡£<br />

<br />

£ <br />

<br />

<br />

¡ £ ¡<br />

<br />

¥ <br />

<br />

¡<br />

£¦<br />

<br />

<br />

£ <br />

<br />

¨<br />

¨¨ <br />

<br />

¦¦<br />

<br />

¨ ¥<br />

<br />

¥ ¦<br />

<br />

¦ <br />

<br />

¨<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¦£<br />

¦ <br />

<br />

¨<br />

¨¦¦ <br />

¨ ¨ <br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¥ ¦<br />

<br />

¦<br />

£ <br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

¦<br />

¥<br />

¡

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!