30.06.2013 Views

Folie 1 - TU Berlin

Folie 1 - TU Berlin

Folie 1 - TU Berlin

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

December 6th, 2009<br />

May 6th, 2011<br />

Qasr al-Mushatta<br />

research and<br />

restoration project<br />

A common effort of<br />

Jordan and Germany<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


The famous desert castles in Jordan – more are available<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles:<br />

Qastal and Kharana<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Kharana<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qusair Amra<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qusair Amra<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qasr al-Tuba<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qasr al-Tuba<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castles: Qasr al-Tuba<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Desert castle: Qasr al-Mushatta.<br />

The site before 1903 in the<br />

steppe with no human<br />

settlements around<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


The site next to Amman Queen Alia<br />

International Airport from the airplane<br />

threatened by industrial building<br />

activities<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Qasr al-Mushatta -<br />

shared heritage in Jordan and Germany<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


1. Research strategies<br />

- Evaluation of historic documents<br />

- Surveying<br />

- Documentation<br />

- Archaeology<br />

- Buildings archaeology<br />

- investigation of the surface<br />

- collection of the graffiti<br />

- research in the emerging Islamic art history<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Now in the new National Museum<br />

More in Kuwait, Jerusalem and<br />

Marocco; some disappeared<br />

Identification of dispersed elements<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


What has been done since 1903:<br />

clearance work<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


aerial archaeology and landscape survey<br />

geodetic survey, mapping of the entire<br />

surfaces<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


exact drawing of the remains: south façade in Jordan<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


exact drawing of the remains: south façade in <strong>Berlin</strong><br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


exact drawing of the remains: Detail south façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Archaeology in order to<br />

identify the original<br />

ground plan<br />

Yellow: Bujard 2000<br />

Magenta: <strong>TU</strong> <strong>Berlin</strong> 2010<br />

Mosaic tesserae<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Trench I_03_a.<br />

Foundation East-West.<br />

Looking east; Oct. 2010<br />

Foundations and finds<br />

Axonometric drawing of the foundations in trench I_03_a<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Excavation in the quarter of the mosque<br />

Foundation of partition wall; Oct.<br />

2010<br />

Trench VIII_08_a.<br />

Looking southwest and<br />

south; Oct. 2010<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Historic building techniques: brickwork and limestone masonry<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


ickwork: two different<br />

sizes of the bricks<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


lime stone masonry: headers and stretchers<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Detailed study of the construction<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


High quality surface of the brickwork with one brick<br />

showing an inscription of unknown message<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the limestone masonry:<br />

Embellishment of the joints found<br />

throughout the entire castle<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the brickwork:<br />

Numerous remains of plaster<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of<br />

the walls and<br />

flooring:<br />

colourful mosaic<br />

tesserae<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the flooring: big green<br />

marble slabs<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Refinement of the decoration: red colour in the rosettas of the palace<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Numerous fragments of<br />

sculpture in the palace<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Results of the research project<br />

- Complete documentation of the actual situation of the ruin<br />

- Archaeological evidence concerning ground plan<br />

- The palace did not remain a ruin but was finished and used<br />

in the central area<br />

- Reconsidering the dating of Mushatta<br />

Foundations<br />

finished<br />

Definitely<br />

completely<br />

finished<br />

Eventually<br />

finished<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project<br />

Only<br />

trenches<br />

of foundations<br />

finished


Excavation in the central court of the castle<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Location of the excavation<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Earthquake has thrown down the arches<br />

of the facade and twisted the pillars<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Coin of around 760<br />

under the pavement of<br />

the court and under the<br />

stones of the arches<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


2. Restoration strategies<br />

- Safeguarding the existing fabric by conservation<br />

- Stop further loss of precious works of art<br />

- Improve the understanding of the ruin for visitors by<br />

° Rebuilding the facade of the palace<br />

° Rebuilding the inner arch of the audience hall<br />

° Closing the gap of the main gate<br />

° Site management and visitor center<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project:<br />

repair of the old brickwork in the elevation with old bricks<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Mortar is produced from lime,<br />

sand, crushed bricks, a bit of<br />

clay and with lots of ashes –<br />

the use of cement in a<br />

historic monument is a<br />

crime against heritage<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project:<br />

repair of the brickwork in the wall tops with new bricks<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


How to produce<br />

new bricks:<br />

First study the<br />

old ones: brick<br />

with special<br />

traces; bricks<br />

with stamp –<br />

unique find<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production is not easy: numerous ingredients like clay, sand, straw<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production: forming the adobes<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production: filling the kiln<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Brick production in a very traditional way:<br />

Kiln before firing bricks for two full days,<br />

after this the kiln will cool down for<br />

another 10 days – slow production.<br />

100.000 bricks needed 18 months.<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Selection of old bricks – numerous different colors<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Old and new brick – color is similar<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Old bricks inside, new<br />

bricks on the surface as<br />

sacrifice layer<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project: repair of the brickwork – results achieved<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Future Project 1: raising<br />

the western elevation in order<br />

to obscure the ugly industrial<br />

zone<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Hedjaz railway track<br />

Mushatta is threatened<br />

by a growing industrial<br />

zone approaching the<br />

ruin – the visual integrity<br />

is highly endangered<br />

Air cargo access<br />

to the airport<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Environmental aspects 1: Plants and flowers<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Environmental aspects 2:<br />

Animals - various birds and lizzards<br />

falcon<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Current restoration project: Anastylosis of the facade of the palace<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


location of various<br />

line drawings<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Line drawings –<br />

sketch of the<br />

arcade, not to scale<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


econstruction of the colonnaded court,<br />

superimposed with the line drawings<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


lime stone masonry: headers and stretchers<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing for a decoration inside the palace, scale 1:1<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing of a design for a decoration, scale 1:1,<br />

superimposed on the south façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing of an arch, scale 1:1<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


line drawing, scale 1:1, superimposed on the three-arched façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


layout superimposed on the realized reconstruction<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Detailed planning for the scaffolding<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Reinforced brickwork<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Sophisticated technology<br />

inside the brickwork:<br />

reinforcement against<br />

earthquake challenges<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Rosetta reassembled from<br />

five different fragments<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Rosettas reassembled<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


New stones are brilliant<br />

white as the old ones have<br />

been more than thousand<br />

years ago. New stone glued<br />

to an old one.<br />

New stones for the arches<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Continuous use of traditional<br />

techniques: liquid mortar<br />

filled into the masonry –<br />

channels prepared for fill-in<br />

in the stones for the arches<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Future Project 1: Rebuilding the inner arch of the reception hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Stones of the arch of the audience hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Stones are reduced and<br />

looted in various ways<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Unfinished decoration of<br />

the inner arch of the<br />

audience hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Rebuilding the arch of<br />

the audience hall<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Future Project 3: Closing the gap of the main gate. Situation as today<br />

and in 1903 before dismanteling the western wing for transport to Germany<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Present situation after anastylosis of the palace façade<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Solution 2: volume of the 1903 situation<br />

rebuilt in solid limestone masonry with<br />

abstracted decoration including original<br />

elements still found on the site<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Solution 3: augmented reality as app for smartphone<br />

current situation superimposed with photograph of before 1903<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Thank you for your attention<br />

Thanks to everybody who supported the project, namely the<br />

Department of Antiquities of Jordan, and the entire staff of Jordan,<br />

Germany, <strong>Berlin</strong> National Museums and <strong>Berlin</strong> Institute of<br />

Technology together with those who provided the financial means:<br />

German Research Foundation and German Foreign Office<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project


Bauwerke zum Thema, die man<br />

gesehen haben sollte (5)<br />

Fachhochschule Wildau<br />

Anderhalten Architekten<br />

War: Lokomotivenfabrik<br />

Ist: Hochschulgebäude<br />

Johannes Cramer, Barbara Perlich Qasr al-Mushatta research and restoration project

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!