REGIONAL MEETINGS - Natural History Museum

prefers acid fens. And for a fern that favours more of a continental climate, what was it doing
in the west of Scotland in the first place? There are still a lot of unanswered questions that will
require some further research to resolve. That should keep us busy over the winter months.
Ben Lui, Ciochan Crags (27/262274) and Stob Garbh (27/272271), Perthshire/
Argyllshire – 13 August Frank McGavigan
(Participants: Frank Katzer, Frank McGavigan, David Pickett.)
In the event only two of us could make it for the return visit, but we were joined by David
Pickett who is the SNH Manager of the Ben Lui Nature Reserve. Was it his presence, the
smaller group, the absence of botanists, or just the rain that spurred us on to move faster
than on our first visit and consequently get more done? This time we found three more
Woodsia alpina sites (and revisited the one we had been to last time), located lots of
Cystopteris montana, and added two more ferns (Asplenium trichomanes and A. rutamuraria)
and two clubmosses (Diphasiastrum alpinum and Lycopodium clavatum) to our list. I
can lay claim to finding one of the C. montana sites (not too difficult as this ‘rare’ fern is
here comparatively plentiful) but as always it was Frank Katzer who located the W. alpina.
He claims that first you need to identify the kind of rock it likes (deeply fissured cliff faces
where it can tuck itself under a protective overhang while still enjoying the free drainage
that it needs). Then it is just a matter of scanning the rock face for Woodsia fronds. All I can
say is that he must have considerably better eyesight than most of us, for the plants are often
growing in inaccessible places, too risky to reach for a closer look.
Indeed this whole area is not for the faint-hearted and is downright dangerous in wet and
windy weather. The cliff faces are steep, with a lot of loose rock, which is in a continuous
process of breaking away from the crags, sometimes in enormous pieces. It was on one of
these boulders, which had fallen several years previously and come to rest considerably
further down the hillside, that we found our last Woodsia site. In fact we had been told
previously by John Mitchell, who had conducted a Woodsia survey in Scotland, that he had
recorded this site but we were please to find it for ourselves. Also on this boulder were
Asplenium viride, A. ruta-muraria and Cystopteris fragilis – a little fern paradise.
Later, back at the car, while we poured the water from our boots, we contemplated what a
successful trip it had been. We had located four Woodsia sites, we had counted the number
of fronds, taken GPS readings, photographed the locations, and contributed to Scotland’s
leading conservation body’s programme for preserving this rare fern. Only later did David
discover that only two of these sites were the ‘official’ SNH locations marked on his map.
So there are two more yet to be rediscovered. Another trip anyone?
Arran, Firth of Clyde – 24-25 September Frank McGavigan
(Participants: Liz Doig, Roland Ennos, Mary Gibby, Tim Godfrey, Yvonne Golding, Angus
Hannah, Frank Katzer, John & Margaret Lyth, Frank McGavigan, Christine Nicholson, Martin
Rickard, Tony Smith, Ken Trewren, Alastair Wardlaw.)
Arran is the largest of the Clyde Isles and is of such varied topography that it is often called
‘Scotland in miniature’. Its flora, including the fern flora, is equally diverse and has been
meticulously recorded by Tony Church and Tony Smith: The Arran Flora, 2005 edition,
published by the Arran Natural History Society. However, with only two days at our
disposal we inevitably had to be selective about sites and we confined ourselves in the main
to the raised beach that forms the coastal strip on the east side of the island.
On Saturday morning we set off from Lochranza (16/938502) for the Cock of Arran in the
north. However, we never actually reached our destination as there were so many ferns to find,
particularly on the old sea cliffs, that we ran out of time. As well as the ubiquitous bracken and
315