Preventing Laminitis - Dr Jennifer Stewart
Preventing Laminitis - Dr Jennifer Stewart
Preventing Laminitis - Dr Jennifer Stewart
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Preventing</strong> <strong>Laminitis</strong> in Horses:<br />
Dietary Strategies for Horse Owners<br />
Christine King, BVSc, MACVSc, MVetClinStud, and Richard A. Mansmann, VMD, PhD<br />
Although diet is only one of many factors that cause or contribute to the development of<br />
laminitis in horses, it is by far the most important overall. Thus, implementing the dietary<br />
strategies outlined in this paper can substantially decrease a horse’s laminitis risk. These<br />
strategies can be distilled into one simple phrase: less calories, more exercise. In the words<br />
of <strong>Dr</strong>. Ric Redden, a veterinarian and farrier, and one of the world’s foremost experts on<br />
laminitis in horses, “<strong>Laminitis</strong> that is directly associated with obesity is quite easy to<br />
prevent. It’s a simple formula, one I have heard so many times from old horsemen. It’s a<br />
great line for maintaining a healthy horse: ‘The fat ones get less and the thin ones get<br />
more.’”<br />
Clin Tech Equine Pract 3:96-102 © 2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.<br />
KEYWORDS laminitis risk, dietary strategies, lush pasture, preventable disease, obesity,<br />
insulin resistance, fructan, non structural carbohydrate<br />
Of all the adjectives and epithets that veterinarians have<br />
used to describe laminitis in horses, preventable is not<br />
one that springs readily to mind for most of us. Yet laminitis<br />
is largely a preventable disease. The first step in preventing<br />
laminitis is being aware of all the possible causes and contributing<br />
factors and determining which are most important<br />
in a particular setting. A wide variety of conditions and situations<br />
can cause laminitis or increase the potential for it to<br />
occur (Table 1). Some of these factors are supported by research,<br />
others are suggested by clinical experience. Some can<br />
cause laminitis on their own; in other cases laminitis is caused<br />
by a combination of contributing factors which may not<br />
cause laminitis on their own but, when present together, have<br />
an additive effect.<br />
In 2000, the USDA National Animal Health Monitoring<br />
System published the results of an extensive nationwide survey<br />
on lameness and laminitis in horses in the United States.<br />
Access to lush pasture was the most common single factor,<br />
being attributed as the cause of laminitis in 46% of all cases<br />
(Fig. 1). Grain overload accounted for another 7% of cases,<br />
bringing the contribution of dietary factors to at least 53%.<br />
The results of this survey indicate that, of all the known or<br />
suspected causes and contributing factors, diet is the most<br />
important overall. Fortunately, it is also one we can readily<br />
control and manipulate to substantially decrease a horse’s<br />
risk for developing laminitis.<br />
The key to decreasing the incidence of laminitis in horses is<br />
client education. We must inform our clients—ie, the people who<br />
Address reprint requests to <strong>Dr</strong>. Christine King, PO Box 1771, Cary, NC<br />
27512. E-mail: christineking@sprintmail.com<br />
96 1534-7516/04/$-see front matter © 2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.<br />
doi:10.1053/j.ctep.2004.07.010<br />
are managing the horses on a day-to-day basis (horse owners,<br />
trainers, farm/barn managers, and even farriers)—of the risk<br />
factors for laminitis, and assist them in devising and implementing<br />
management strategies which address the factors that are<br />
relevant for the horses at their particular facilities.<br />
This paper focuses on dietary strategies for reducing the<br />
laminitis risk in horses, ponies, and other domestic equids<br />
(hereafter referred to simply as horses). Strategies for minimizing<br />
the incidence or impact of the other risk factors listed<br />
in Table 1 are fairly intuitive and begin with an awareness<br />
that a risk exists. The remainder of this paper is written as a<br />
clinical tool that veterinarians can use for client instruction.<br />
The information can be used as-is or adapted as needed, in<br />
client education materials such as practice newsletters and<br />
fact sheets.<br />
Dietary Strategies for<br />
Reducing <strong>Laminitis</strong> Risk<br />
Diet is the single most important risk factor for laminitis, and<br />
should therefore be the centerpiece of any program aimed at<br />
reducing a horse’s laminitis risk. The critical component of<br />
the diet is the amount of soluble carbohydrates the horse consumes.<br />
These carbohydrates are the starches and simple sugars<br />
found in plant material that are easily broken down by<br />
enzymes in the horse’s small intestine and/or rapidly fermented<br />
by microbes in the horse’s large intestine. Excess<br />
intake of these starches and sugars, whether in a single meal<br />
or over time, greatly increases a horse’s risk for developing<br />
laminitis.<br />
These readily digestible/fermentable carbohydrates are<br />
also referred to as nonstructural carbohydrates (NSC) or non-
<strong>Preventing</strong> laminitis in horses 97<br />
Table 1 Known or Presumed Factors that Can Cause or Contribute to the Development of <strong>Laminitis</strong> in Horses, Ponies, and Other<br />
Domestic Equids<br />
Causes Contributing Factors*<br />
unrestricted access to improved pastures during periods of<br />
high fructan content (eg, spring, fall, cold stress)<br />
grain overload (ingestion of large quantities of dietary starch)<br />
fiber carbohydrates (NFC), as distinct from the fibrous structural<br />
carbohydrates (cellulose, lignin, etc.) which give plants<br />
their structural integrity and support (ie, the plant’s skeleton).<br />
Nonstructural carbohydrates are produced by the plant<br />
during daylight hours (via the process of photosynthesis) and<br />
are used by the plant as an energy source for growth and<br />
reproduction. Any excess NSCs are stored in the leaves and<br />
stems for later use, and, once the plant flowers, in the seeds to<br />
history of laminitis (even if previous episode was mild)<br />
high-grain diet (>5 lb of grain-based feed for the average<br />
sized horse)<br />
severe intestinal disease (eg, “surgical” colic, enterocolitis) consumption of endophyte-infested tall fescue<br />
other serious systemic illness (eg, pleuropneumonia,<br />
overweight (BCS of 6 or greater); the greater the BCS, the<br />
Potomac horse fever)<br />
greater the laminitis risk<br />
endo/metritis secondary to retained placenta pony or Morgan<br />
untreated equine Cushing’s disease (older horses) inactivity<br />
severe hypovolemia (eg, severe dehydration, severe blood occasional strenuous exercise (“weekend warriors”)<br />
loss, toxemia)<br />
exercise at speed on a hard surface (“road founder”)<br />
sustained, nonweight-bearing lameness in one limb (ie, glucocorticoid administration (the higher the total dose,<br />
contralateral limb laminitis)<br />
the greater the risk)<br />
exposure to black walnut heartwood (usually as wood<br />
stress (eg, high-stress occupation or environment,<br />
shavings used for bedding)<br />
transportation, hospitalization?)<br />
small feet for the size or weight of the horse (usually<br />
linked to BCS >6)<br />
flat or thin soles, or excessive trimming of the wall or sole<br />
(ie, less-than-optimal protection for palmar/plantar<br />
digital vasculature)<br />
BCS body condition score (see Table 2).<br />
*These factors, while they may not cause laminitis on their own, appear to increase the risk for laminitis and may cause laminitis when two or<br />
more are present concurrently.<br />
lush pasture<br />
46%<br />
grain overload<br />
7%<br />
unknown<br />
15%<br />
colic or diarrhea<br />
3%<br />
other known<br />
27%<br />
retained placenta<br />
2%<br />
Figure 1 Causes of laminitis identified in a recent nationwide survey<br />
(from Lameness and <strong>Laminitis</strong> in U.S. Horses. USDA: APHIS: VS,<br />
CEAH, National Animal Health Monitoring System. USDA, 2000).<br />
“Other known” causes included feed problems and complications of<br />
injury, obesity, or pregnancy. Each comprised less than 2% of all<br />
cases, so these diverse factors were combined into one group for this<br />
chart.<br />
fuel germination and sustain the seedling until it can produce<br />
sufficient NSCs of its own.<br />
Grains such as oats, corn, barley, wheat, and millet—<br />
which actually are the seeds of grasses—are high in starch<br />
and simple sugars. Pasture grasses also are high in sugars at<br />
certain stages of their growth cycle and during times of environmental<br />
stress (eg, cold weather). These two feed sources,<br />
grain and grass, must therefore be fed with care in horses.<br />
The circumstances in which excess carbohydrate intake<br />
can lead to laminitis can be divided into two categories:<br />
1. carbohydrate overload—ie, a large meal that is high in<br />
starches or sugars (whether grain or grass)<br />
2. chronic overfeeding (usually coupled with relative inactivity),<br />
resulting in a horse that is overweight.<br />
Either circumstance increases a horse’s laminitis risk.<br />
When both are present, the horse’s risk for developing laminitis<br />
greatly increases, particularly when other triggers (eg,<br />
illness, injury, stress) occur. Following are some dietary strategies<br />
that, when consistently followed, can substantially decrease<br />
a horse’s laminitis risk.<br />
Pasture Management<br />
Access to lush pasture is the single most important risk factor<br />
for laminitis on farms where pasture is available for grazing.<br />
While pasture grasses contain a wide variety of structural and<br />
nonstructural carbohydrates, the ones that appear to be most<br />
important, with respect to laminitis risk, in many of the pasture<br />
grasses in the U.S. are called fructans. Fructans are NSCs<br />
that cannot be broken down by enzymes in the horse’s small<br />
intestine; they bypass digestion and absorption in the small<br />
intestine and reach the large intestine, where they are rapidly<br />
fermented by the resident microbes.
98 C. King and R.A. Mansmann<br />
Mechanism of Pasture-Associated <strong>Laminitis</strong><br />
The exact mechanism by which pasture-associated laminitis<br />
occurs is still being researched. What is known is that intake<br />
of a large amount of fructans causes the pH in the large<br />
intestine to drop (ie, become more acidic), as lactic acid is<br />
produced by the fermentation of fructans. The now-acidic<br />
environment in the large intestine kills off the more acidsensitive<br />
microbes and allows the more acid-resistant<br />
microbes to multiply. Certain of these bacteria produce substances<br />
which can activate enzymes (matrix metalloproteinases,<br />
or MMPs) in the hoof wall that break down the cellular<br />
bond which anchors the hoof wall to the pedal bone.<br />
While this step remains to be fully investigated, it is assumed<br />
that these bacterial products reach the tissues of the<br />
hoof via the bloodstream, after being absorbed from the large<br />
intestine into the circulation. The net result is partial or complete<br />
separation of the hoof wall from the pedal bone, and<br />
possibly displacement of the pedal bone under the weight of<br />
the horse’s body and the pull of the deep flexor tendon on the<br />
pedal bone. Pain and distortion of the hoof are the two most<br />
obvious manifestations and hallmarks of laminitis.<br />
Fructan Content of Pasture Grasses<br />
The fructan content of pasture grasses varies greatly with<br />
plant type (species and variety), stage of growth, and growing<br />
conditions, including soil composition, rainfall, temperature,<br />
and hours and intensity of sunlight. Some generalizations can<br />
be made, but it is important to understand that they are by no<br />
means hard-and-fast rules.<br />
1. In general, the fructan content is highest during periods<br />
of active plant growth, such as during the spring and<br />
early summer months. However, it can increase anytime<br />
soil moisture content, sunlight, and daytime temperatures<br />
are sufficient for fructan production. All that<br />
is required for the fructan content to increase in a pasture<br />
is for the rate of production (ie, photosynthesis) to<br />
exceed the rate of use (ie, growth or reproduction). In<br />
many parts of the country, pasture-associated laminitis<br />
is just as common in the fall as it is in the spring; in fact,<br />
it is perhaps more common in the fall, as many horse<br />
owners don’t consider their pasture to be high-risk<br />
once the spring flush has passed. A “green-up” after a<br />
drought is another potentially dangerous period any<br />
time of the year it occurs.<br />
The fructan content may also increase in response to<br />
plant stress, particularly cold stress (temperatures below<br />
40°F). On a bright but chilly autumn day, for example,<br />
the amount of fructans produced by the plant<br />
may exceed the amount used for growth (which is inhibited<br />
by cold temperatures); as a result, fructans accumulate.<br />
Thus, pastures may continue to be a laminitis<br />
risk in the late-fall and even during the winter<br />
months in areas of the country where conditions are<br />
mild enough for horses to graze year-round. It is a dangerous<br />
misconception that only lush spring pasture is a<br />
problem.<br />
2. In general, the fructan content is highest during the day<br />
(when the plant is actively photosynthesizing carbohydrates)<br />
and lowest at night and in the early morning<br />
hours (when the plant is using the carbohydrates for<br />
growth). However, on cool, overcast or rainy days this<br />
pattern may be off by half a day, or more.<br />
In a study in Great Britain, researchers evaluated the<br />
fructan content of a perennial ryegrass pasture on a<br />
warm, sunny day in May and on two cool, overcast or<br />
rainy days in July. On each day, they measured the<br />
fructan content at several different times over a 24-hour<br />
period. As might be expected, the fructan content on<br />
the warm, sunny day was highest between mid-morning<br />
and mid-afternoon, peaking around midday, and<br />
was lowest late at night and in the early morning hours.<br />
In contrast, on the cool, overcast or rainy days, the<br />
fructan content was highest in the afternoon and<br />
evening; it remained high overnight, and was lowest<br />
between dawn and midday.<br />
In that study, the fructan content of the pasture<br />
ranged from 0 to 30% dry matter (which can be enough<br />
to cause laminitis if grazing is unrestricted). On one<br />
overcast day it ranged from 0 to 22% within a 10-hour<br />
period! This study illustrates an important fact: even in<br />
the same pasture, the fructan content can vary greatly<br />
over the course of a day, and it cannot necessarily be<br />
predicted based on the time of day.<br />
3. In general, grass that has already flowered and gone to<br />
seed has a low fructan content. Mature seed heads and<br />
dry, stemmy or “woody” stalks usually are a good indicator<br />
that the grass is low in fructans and other NSCs.<br />
However, flowering grass (ie, grass in the process of<br />
producing seed heads) can be quite high in fructans.<br />
4. In general, the fructan content of pasture grasses is<br />
higher in the stems than in the leaves, particularly in the<br />
lower part of the stems. Overgrazing should therefore<br />
be avoided. Not only does overgrazing cause plant<br />
stress (potentially resulting in an increase in fructan<br />
storage), it means the horse is forced to eat more of the<br />
stem material than when the grass is taller (when more<br />
leaf than stem is eaten). What constitutes “overgrazing”<br />
depends on the grass species (ie, its hardiness and<br />
growth characteristics). With the more upright-growing<br />
pasture grasses, it may be best to suspend use of a<br />
pasture once the grass is grazed down to a height of 4 to<br />
6 inches.<br />
5. In general, native pastures and unimproved grass varieties<br />
are safer for grazing horses than are “improved”<br />
pasture varieties. Among other attributes, many improved<br />
pasture varieties have been selected and bred<br />
for a high NSC content because of the requirements of<br />
dairy farmers for high milk yields in their cows. Some<br />
varieties of improved pasture grasses are very high in<br />
NSCs, including fructans, making these pastures a considerable<br />
laminitis risk for horses at certain times of the<br />
year. In addition, these improved varieties are often<br />
sown as a single pasture crop (a monoculture), whereas<br />
native pastures typically consist of several different<br />
grass species and a variety of other plants.<br />
However, intensive irrigation and fertilization of native or<br />
unimproved pasture varieties can result in NSC levels that<br />
approach those of improved grass varieties, making these<br />
pastures a considerable laminitis risk, particularly for laminitis-prone<br />
horses. Pasture grasses adapted to warm climates
<strong>Preventing</strong> laminitis in horses 99<br />
(ie, those that grow well in the southern states) tend not to<br />
store fructans as do grasses from more temperate or colder<br />
areas. They can, however, be high in starch and other NSCs<br />
under the right conditions, so they too are a potential laminitis<br />
risk. Tall fescue may present an additional risk if it is<br />
infested with a common endophytic fungus (Neotyphodium<br />
coenophialum). Endophyte-infested fescue has been shown to<br />
increase the risk for laminitis in both horses and cattle.<br />
Grazing Management<br />
<strong>Preventing</strong> pasture-associated laminitis begins with accurately<br />
assessing each horse’s laminitis risk and managing its<br />
pasture access accordingly. In horses that have had laminitis<br />
in the past, particularly pasture-associated laminitis, and in<br />
those that are overweight, it is best to avoid any grazing of<br />
improved pastures during periods in which the fructan content<br />
is likely to be high. Limited access to native or unimproved<br />
pastures may be less problematic in these horses.<br />
Intake of fructans and other NSCs during high-risk periods<br />
can be limited in a number of ways, depending on the<br />
particular horse’s laminitis risk and on the type and condition<br />
of the pasture:<br />
● limit the amount of time a horse is turned out on pasture<br />
each day (from 30 minutes to several hours, depending<br />
on the risk)<br />
● allow grazing only during relatively low-risk times of the<br />
day (eg, late at night, early morning)<br />
● limit the size of the available pasture by using moveable<br />
fences to create small paddocks (Note: avoid overgrazing)<br />
● use a grazing muzzle which limits the amount of grass<br />
the horse can eat while turned out.<br />
Daily activity is very important for the health and wellbeing<br />
of every horse, but particularly for those that are overweight.<br />
When pasture turnout must be limited or prevented<br />
altogether, the horse should be turned out into a dry lot (ie, a<br />
grassless area) to allow several hours of activity every day.<br />
Inactivity increases a horse’s laminitis risk, especially when<br />
combined with excess body weight.<br />
There are several forage testing laboratories that will test<br />
pasture samples and report on the levels of NSC or NFC in<br />
the grass. When performed periodically throughout the year,<br />
this approach may assist owners or farm managers in identifying<br />
the periods when their pastures are at greatest risk.<br />
However, it is by no means foolproof, as environmental conditions<br />
during any given month can change dramatically<br />
from year to year, even from day to day. Measurement of<br />
NSCs in hay, though, can be very useful in determining<br />
whether a particular batch of hay is suitable for laminitisprone<br />
horses (see below).<br />
Feeding Grain<br />
There are two general scenarios in which grain feeding can<br />
cause laminitis or significantly increase the potential for it to<br />
occur: (1) grain overload and (2) feeding grain to an overweight<br />
horse. The classic example of grain overload is of a<br />
horse that gets into the grain bin and gorges on several<br />
pounds of grain at once. The sequence of events leading to<br />
laminitis are similar to those of pasture-associated laminitis.<br />
The starch in grain can be broken down by enzymes in the<br />
small intestine and absorbed before it reaches the large intestine.<br />
However, with a large grain meal, the amount of starch<br />
consumed by the horse exceeds the ability of the small intestine<br />
to digest and absorb it all, so some of the starch spills<br />
over into the large intestine. Starch is readily fermented by<br />
the microbes in the large intestine, with potentially the same<br />
consequences as those described for fructans.<br />
This problem doesn’t just occur with whole grain; it can<br />
occur with any grain-based feed—ie, any feed in which any<br />
type of grain forms the principle ingredient(s), regardless of<br />
whether or how it is processed. For the average sized horse, it<br />
usually takes at least 5 lbs of starch in one meal to cause<br />
spillover into the large intestine; in small ponies or Miniature<br />
Horses it may take only a pound or two. However, spillover<br />
of starch into the large intestine doesn’t always lead to laminitis;<br />
it depends on how much starch reaches the large intestine—the<br />
greater the starch intake, the greater the laminitis<br />
risk.<br />
<strong>Preventing</strong> <strong>Laminitis</strong><br />
Caused by Grain Overload<br />
Grain overload is a medical emergency. The horse may not<br />
show signs of laminitis for up to 48 hours after overindulging<br />
in grain, by which time it is too late to prevent the damage.<br />
<strong>Preventing</strong> laminitis in this situation involves calling the veterinarian<br />
immediately it is discovered that the horse has consumed<br />
an excess of grain. Disaster can often be averted by<br />
administering mineral oil or activated charcoal by stomach<br />
tube, if done early enough. Cold therapy (standing the horse<br />
in ice water until 48 hours have passed since it consumed the<br />
grain) may also be an effective means of preventing severe<br />
laminitis in this situation, and well worth the time and effort<br />
it takes.<br />
<strong>Preventing</strong> this situation in the first place is simply a matter<br />
of being aware of the risk and preventing unlimited access to<br />
grain. Grain storage areas should be secured with a system<br />
that has a built-in back-up (eg, a lockable latch on the feed<br />
room door and latches or bungee cords on the feed bin lids).<br />
Simply making a habit of keeping the feed room door securely<br />
closed, and impressing on everyone who uses the area<br />
to do the same, can prevent a tragedy.<br />
Less commonly, other high-carbohydrate feedstuffs can<br />
cause laminitis when fed in excess. These items include<br />
bread, other bakery products or byproducts, sweet fruits<br />
such as apples and water melons, and lawn clippings. These<br />
feedstuffs are more likely to be fed in large amounts by new<br />
horse owners or well-meaning neighbors who are unfamiliar<br />
with horse management. <strong>Preventing</strong> laminitis caused by<br />
these feeds is simply a matter of limiting their intake to only<br />
the occasional treat, although lawn clippings should never be<br />
fed to horses.<br />
Overfeeding and High-Grain Diets<br />
The second scenario in which grain feeding can increase a<br />
horse’s laminitis risk is all too common: feeding grain to<br />
horses that don’t need the extra calories and, as a result, are<br />
overweight. This problem is discussed further in the next<br />
section on weight management.
100 C. King and R.A. Mansmann<br />
Table 2 Body Condition Scoring System for Horses<br />
BCS Ribs Spine Pelvis & tail head<br />
Bones of the wither,<br />
shoulder, & neck<br />
1 very prominent very prominent very prominent very noticeable<br />
2 prominent prominent prominent noticeable<br />
3 very noticeable tops of vertebrae very pelvic bones noticeable; faintly noticeable<br />
noticeable<br />
tail head prominent<br />
4 faintly noticeable slight ridge along back pelvic bones covered; can<br />
feel fat at tail head<br />
not obviously thin<br />
5 not visible but back is flat; no crease pelvic bones well covered; rounded withers; shoulder &<br />
easily felt<br />
or ridge<br />
spongy fat at tail head neck blend into body<br />
6 spongy fat over may have slight crease pelvic bones well covered; some fat deposits on withers,<br />
ribs; can feel<br />
individual ribs<br />
down back<br />
soft fat around tail head neck, & behind shoulders<br />
7 obvious filling may have crease down pelvic bones well covered; fat deposits on withers, neck,<br />
between ribs;<br />
can feel ribs<br />
back<br />
soft fat around tail head & behind shoulders<br />
8 hard to feel ribs crease down back very soft fat at tail head; fat fills wither area & behind<br />
fat on inner thighs<br />
shoulders; thickened neck<br />
9 dimpled fat over obvious crease down bulging fat at tail head & bulging fat on withers, neck,<br />
ribs<br />
back<br />
inner thigh; flank filled<br />
with fat<br />
& behind shoulders<br />
Regardless of the horse’s age, gender, breed, height, and body weight, a body condition score (BCS) of 4 or 5 is ideal. Horses with a BCS of<br />
6 or greater are overweight.<br />
In horses that require high-grain diets to meet their energy<br />
needs (eg, those in intense athletic training and competition;<br />
mares nursing young foals), feeding a high-grain diet can<br />
increase the horse’s laminitis risk by altering the environment<br />
in the large intestine, thereby making the resident population<br />
of microbes more susceptible to minor changes in feed composition,<br />
water intake, stress, and other variations in diet and<br />
routine these horses may experience from time to time. Furthermore,<br />
horses on high-grain diets tend to be those in<br />
high-stress occupations—a risk factor on its own for laminitis.<br />
Weight Management<br />
Overweight horses are more likely to develop laminitis when<br />
other risk factors are present than are horses in more ideal<br />
body condition. There are at least three possible reasons why<br />
overweight horses are at increased risk: (1) their greater body<br />
weight puts more load on their feet than when they are in<br />
ideal body condition; (2) overweight horses tend to be fairly<br />
inactive (which on its own is a risk factor for laminitis); and<br />
(3) an excess of body fat often goes hand-in-hand with a<br />
metabolic state in which the horse is less sensitive to the<br />
effects of insulin, a state which interferes with glucose metabolism<br />
(a possible trigger for breakdown of the cellular bond<br />
between hoof wall and pedal bone).<br />
The syndrome of insensitivity to insulin, or insulin resistance,<br />
has received much attention lately as a risk factor for<br />
laminitis in horses. It is sometimes referred to as equine metabolic<br />
syndrome or peripheral Cushing’s syndrome. Typically,<br />
horses with this problem are mature horses that are<br />
overweight (ie, carrying an excess of body fat) and have characteristic<br />
fat deposits along the crest of the neck (“cresty<br />
neck”), over the rump (“apple rump”), and, in some cases, on<br />
the side of the shoulder and in the sheath (males) or in front<br />
of the udder (mares). These tell-tale fat deposits often remain<br />
despite dietary restrictions. Blood tests can be used to confirm<br />
that a horse is insulin resistant, but these tests usually are<br />
unnecessary, as the visual clues are enough.<br />
The propensity for insulin resistance in horses is, in part,<br />
genetically determined. Insulin resistance has been found in<br />
Thoroughbred weanlings and yearlings (especially rapidly<br />
growing foals that are predisposed to developing osteochondrosis)<br />
and in ponies, even ponies in moderate body condition.<br />
So, in at least some of the overweight adult horses and<br />
ponies with insulin resistance, genetics may have played a<br />
significant role, and may even hamper weight loss attempts.<br />
However, simply being overweight causes insulin resistance<br />
(a situation not unlike type II diabetes in humans). So,<br />
whether or not a horse has a genetic propensity for insulin<br />
resistance, overfeeding—ie, providing more calories than the<br />
horse needs to maintain its ideal body condition—is enough<br />
to cause excess fat accumulation, lead to insulin resistance,<br />
and increase the horse’s laminitis risk.<br />
Body Condition Score<br />
What constitutes “overweight” must consider more than just<br />
the horse’s body weight. As is the case in people, body weight<br />
alone can be misleading, as it does not take into account the<br />
height, build, and fitness level (ie, muscle mass) of the individual.<br />
The critical factor in determining whether an individual<br />
is overweight is the amount of fat stored in the body.<br />
In horses, body condition score (BCS) is used to evaluate<br />
the amount of body fat by assessing fat stores in visible areas<br />
of the horse’s body (Table 2). Body condition is graded on a<br />
scale from 1 (emaciated) to 9 (obese). Regardless of the<br />
horse’s age, gender, breed, height, and body weight, a BCS of<br />
4 or 5 is ideal. Horses with a BCS of 6 or greater are overweight.<br />
Obesity (BCS of 8 or 9) is obvious to all but those owners<br />
who are in denial. However, what most horse owners don’t
<strong>Preventing</strong> laminitis in horses 101<br />
realize is that obesity is a very unhealthy state. Not only is the<br />
obese horse teetering on the brink of laminitis, requiring the<br />
barest nudge to push it over the edge, if that horse does<br />
develop laminitis the prognosis for recovery is far worse than<br />
for a horse in ideal body condition. Although it can be a long<br />
and frustrating process, weight reduction must be a medical<br />
imperative in obese horses if laminitis is to be avoided.<br />
More common, but almost as problematic because the risk<br />
is less obvious, are horses with a BCS of 6 or 7. These overweight<br />
horses are at increased risk for laminitis and other<br />
health problems, yet many owners simply consider these<br />
horses to be well cared for, pleasantly plump, or “easy keepers”;<br />
they are unaware of the health risks, laminitis being<br />
chief among them. It is important that we readjust our perceptions<br />
of what a well-cared-for horse looks like. A horse<br />
with a BCS of 6 or more is not well cared for; it is overfed and<br />
overweight! Weight reduction must be a medical priority in<br />
these horses if the laminitis risk is to be reduced.<br />
Weight Reduction<br />
The approach to weight reduction in an overweight horse is<br />
essentially the same as it is in overweight people. It is simple,<br />
but not necessarily easy. The key is this: calories in must be<br />
less than calories out. In other words, the body must consume<br />
fewer calories than it is using.<br />
Feeding fewer calories is very important, but in many cases<br />
it is not enough on its own. That approach does nothing to<br />
use up the extra calories already stored as fat on the horse’s<br />
body, unless the ration provides significantly fewer calories<br />
than are required to meet the horse’s maintenance energy<br />
needs. However, feeding a horse “starvation rations” (ie, less<br />
than maintenance energy needs) sends the body into survival<br />
mode—ie, preservation mode—which makes weight loss even<br />
more difficult, as the preservation of energy stores becomes a<br />
metabolic priority. Furthermore, feeding severely calorie-restricted<br />
diets to overweight horses (especially ponies and<br />
Miniature Horses) can cause a metabolic condition called<br />
hyperlipemia, which can be life-threatening, and increases<br />
the laminitis risk.<br />
For effective and healthy weight loss, the horse must also<br />
perform more daily activity than it has been doing. The objective<br />
is to use up the extra calories already stored on the<br />
body as fat. This aspect of weight management can be quite a<br />
challenge in overweight horses that already have laminitis or<br />
that are lame for other reasons. However, it is not impossible.<br />
The exercise does not need to be high intensity or high impact;<br />
simply walking the horse each day can be beneficial<br />
(provided the horse’s medical condition allows).<br />
Of course, the more daily exercise the horse performs, the<br />
better for weight loss, but the horse’s current fitness and<br />
comfort must be the guide as to how much exercise (how far<br />
and how fast) to perform at a time. Alternatives to riding<br />
include hand-walking (ie, leading the horse), longeing, free<br />
schooling in a round pen or arena, ponying (ie, leading the<br />
horse while riding another horse), driving, ground driving<br />
(ie, long-lining from the ground), and swimming or wading.<br />
Paddock or dry lot turnout generally is not enough, as most overweight<br />
horses just stand around when turned out.<br />
Grain should not be fed to overweight horses. For one<br />
thing, they do not need the extra calories. In addition,<br />
in some very carbohydrate-sensitive (ie, insulin-resistant)<br />
horses, even a small amount of grain can cause metabolic<br />
alterations that interfere with effective weight loss and laminitis<br />
management. For the same reasons, sweet treats (eg,<br />
those containing molasses or other sugary taste enhancers or<br />
binding agents) and other starchy foods should be avoided.<br />
Grass hay cubes can be a good alternative to sweet treats,<br />
provided the hay cubes do not contain molasses or other<br />
sweeteners, and treats are offered only occasionally and only<br />
in small amounts.<br />
High-fat feeds also should not be fed to overweight horses,<br />
no matter how low their content of starch and sugars. These<br />
feeds do not present the laminitis risk that high-carbohydrate<br />
feeds do, but overweight horses simply do not need the extra<br />
calories. It is stating the obvious to point out that it is counterproductive<br />
to feed fat to a horse that needs to lose fat!<br />
Some veterinarians and horse owners opt to “micromanage”<br />
overweight horses by monitoring insulin resistance using<br />
blood tests and by analyzing every component of the diet<br />
and manipulating the NSC and mineral content accordingly.<br />
While this detailed approach may be needed in some cases, it<br />
is not necessary in the majority of overweight horses. Good<br />
results can usually be achieved simply by eliminating grain<br />
and other high-carbohydrate feeds from the diet, feeding<br />
grass hay of moderate nutritional quality, offering a vitaminmineral<br />
supplement appropriate for that part of the country,<br />
restricting pasture access (as discussed in the earlier section<br />
on pasture management), and providing some type of structured<br />
exercise every day.<br />
Hay Quality and Quantity<br />
The bulk of the fructans and other NSCs in grass persists<br />
during the haymaking process, so some grass hays may be<br />
inappropriate to feed to overweight horses, particularly those<br />
that already have laminitis. These tend to be the hays harvested<br />
from improved pastures and cut fairly early in the<br />
growth cycle of the plant (ie, hay containing few or no seedheads).<br />
Having the hay analyzed at a forage testing laboratory<br />
that offers measurement of NSC or NFC can identify hay that<br />
may be best avoided or fed in limited quantities to these<br />
horses. In general, hay that has a NSC content of less than<br />
15% is most appropriate for these horses.<br />
The hay should be of good overall quality (ie, clean, dry,<br />
and free of mold, weeds, and other debris), but of only moderate<br />
nutritional quality. Mature native or unimproved pasture,<br />
cut after the grass has produced seedheads, is recommended.<br />
Hay cut in the fall should be used with caution, as<br />
cold stress before harvesting may increase the fructan content<br />
of the grass, and thus of the hay.<br />
For horses with little or no pasture access, hay should be<br />
fed at a rate of approximately 2% of the horse’s ideal body<br />
weight per day. For a horse whose ideal body weight is<br />
around 1000 lbs, 2% of body weight means 20 lbs of hay per<br />
day. Some horses need less than that to achieve or maintain<br />
their ideal body weight, but the amount of hay per day should<br />
not drop below 1% of body weight (ie, minimum of 10 lbs of<br />
hay per 1000 lbs).<br />
Supplements<br />
Magnesium supplementation has become a popular tool for<br />
managing weigh reduction and insulin resistance in horses.
102 C. King and R.A. Mansmann<br />
However, while balancing an individual horse’s diet for all<br />
macrominerals may be beneficial, simply adding magnesium<br />
to the diet is unlikely to be of value unless a deficiency of that<br />
mineral exists. It is a commonly perpetuated fallacy that<br />
horse feeds often are low in magnesium. Deficiency of magnesium<br />
in pasture or hay is very regional, and may vary from<br />
farm to farm even within a region. It is best to test pasture and<br />
hay samples for mineral content, and determine that a deficiency<br />
or imbalance exists, before adding magnesium to the<br />
horse’s diet. Adding magnesium is unlikely to be of benefit if<br />
the horse is already receiving adequate amounts of magnesium.<br />
Furthermore, supplementing with magnesium is not a<br />
suitable substitute for exercise as a weight reduction tool.<br />
Supplementing the diet with a source of omega-3 fatty<br />
acids such as flax seed may be helpful in improving the<br />
horse’s overall health and metabolic function, including tissue<br />
repair (eg, recovery from laminitis). Whether or not longterm<br />
supplementation reduces a horse’s laminitis risk<br />
remains to be critically evaluated. Supplementation of microminerals<br />
such as chromium and vanadium appears to be<br />
of little value in managing weight reduction and minimizing<br />
laminitis risk in horses.<br />
Thyroid hormone supplements are sometimes prescribed<br />
by veterinarians to aid in weight reduction for overweight<br />
horses. However, unlike the situation in dogs, in which hypothyroidism<br />
occurs spontaneously and causes weight gain,<br />
overweight horses got that way by being overfed; they have<br />
normally functioning thyroid glands, even if blood tests show<br />
that the level of thyroid hormones (T 4 and/or T 3) in the circulation<br />
is low. (Incidentally, measuring the serum concen-<br />
tration of T 4 or T 3 in any form is not an accurate means of<br />
assessing thyroid function in adult horses nor of determining<br />
the need for thyroid supplementation.)<br />
If thyroid hormone supplementation helps in weight reduction,<br />
it is via an increase in the horse’s basal metabolic<br />
rate, not because the supplement is correcting a thyroid deficiency.<br />
Long-term supplementation (ie, months) with thyroid<br />
hormone must be avoided, as it can suppress normal<br />
thyroid function and lead to relative hypothyroidism if the<br />
supplement is suddenly withdrawn.<br />
Thyroid hormone supplements are not a suitable substitute<br />
for dietary management and daily exercise, and they<br />
should not be used as such. There are no shortcuts to healthy<br />
weight reduction! If thyroid hormone supplementation is<br />
used, it should be in conjunction with, not instead of, dietary<br />
management and daily exercise. It is also important to realize<br />
that giving thyroid hormone supplements does not decrease<br />
the horse’s laminitis risk. Although diet is only one of many<br />
factors that cause or contribute to the development of laminitis<br />
in horses, it is by far the most important overall. Thus,<br />
implementing the dietary strategies outlined in this paper can<br />
substantially decrease a horse’s laminitis risk. These strategies<br />
can be distilled into one simple phrase: less calories, more<br />
exercise. In the words of <strong>Dr</strong>. Ric Redden, a veterinarian and<br />
farrier, and one of the world’s foremost experts on laminitis<br />
in horses, “<strong>Laminitis</strong> that is directly associated with obesity is<br />
quite easy to prevent. It’s a simple formula, one I have heard<br />
so many times from old horsemen. It’s a great line for maintaining<br />
a healthy horse: ‘The fat ones get less and the thin<br />
ones get more.’”