Combat Secularism - Dr. Th Chowdary
Combat Secularism - Dr. Th Chowdary
Combat Secularism - Dr. Th Chowdary
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
RNI No. APENG/2003/10308<br />
(Pseudo)<br />
" <strong>Secularism</strong> "<br />
Truth on the Scaffold Patriotism Re-asserting<br />
Vol. 4 No.7 Editor: <strong>Dr</strong>. T.H. <strong>Chowdary</strong> JULY, 2006<br />
Inside ...<br />
- Christian Evangelism<br />
In Tirumala Tirupati<br />
- <strong>Th</strong>e Conspiracy of<br />
Selective Silence<br />
- Excerpts from the Petition for<br />
Formation of United Hindu<br />
Dharma Samsthan<br />
- ‘Christians Under Siege’:<br />
A Missionary Ploy<br />
- Rewarding Conversions<br />
- Exclusive Glorification of Nehru<br />
- Readers Write<br />
* * *<br />
Editor : <strong>Dr</strong>. T. H. <strong>Chowdary</strong><br />
Associate Editor : Smt. P. Parijata<br />
APPEAL<br />
5 years’ contribution : Rs.400/-<br />
DD/Local Chqeque payable in Hyd<br />
may please be drawn in favour of<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong><br />
Annual Contribution : Rs.100/-<br />
* * *<br />
Editor, Printer & Publisher:<br />
<strong>Dr</strong>. T.H. <strong>Chowdary</strong><br />
for “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong><br />
8, P&T Colony,<br />
Karkhana (Secunderabad),<br />
Hyderabad - 500 009.<br />
Phone : +91 (40) 2784-6137<br />
Fax : +91 (40) 2789-6103<br />
E-mail : thc@satyam.com<br />
Legal Adviser: Sri CVL Narasimha Rao<br />
All that is necessary for evil<br />
to triumph is for good men<br />
to do nothing<br />
- Edmund Burke<br />
Rs.100/- PA or Rs.400/- for 5 Years<br />
(<strong>Th</strong>e Peril we need to)<br />
<strong>Combat</strong><br />
CHRISTIAN EVANGELISM<br />
IN TIRUMALA TIRUPATI<br />
Please visit us at: http://intellibriefs.com/sec_combat_JULY_06.pdf<br />
S Shyam Kumar<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e author brings into focus the Christian propaganda in Tirumala<br />
Hills as reported in the local Telugu Newspapers<br />
Hindu society is holding its head high with self-respect because<br />
of people who are practicing sadachara. Even so the attacks<br />
mounted by other religions on Hinduism are repeated day after day.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>is is most painful to note.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e recent events that took place in Tirumala Tirupathi are<br />
disheartening to every Hindu. It is stunning to find that nearly 50<br />
Christian families are settled on Tirumala hill, and no less than 20<br />
persons of Christianity are employed in TT Devastanam.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ese families conducted Christmas prayers on the Tirumala Hill;<br />
which goes to prove the complacency of the TTD Board. <strong>Th</strong>ese<br />
Christian elements are audacious enough to distribute Christian<br />
pamphlets to devotees going to Tirupathi Temple. What is the<br />
Devastanam’s vigilance department doing? Such brazen acts on the<br />
part of Christians make one suspect that these people are willynilly<br />
supported by the TTD Board.<br />
Added to this sad state of affairs is the latest move by the<br />
authorities recognizing Tirumala as a township with the temple<br />
jurisdiction restricted to 27.5 sq.km. <strong>Th</strong>is move it is widely believed<br />
is meant to make way for construction of Church(es?) on Tirumala<br />
hills. Above events lend evidence to this belief. Otherwise what is<br />
the reason to reduce the sacred seven hills area of 243 sq.km<br />
to 27.5 sq. km? <strong>Th</strong>ey’re drastically reducing the jurisdiction of<br />
Devastanams? Reducing Lord Venkateswara’s seven hills to two hills<br />
is an affront to religious sentiments of Hindus.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Vice-Chancellor, Dean and other functionaries of Padmavati<br />
University are believing Christians and they are forcing the students<br />
to participate in Christian Prayers, taking them to Church in vehicles<br />
owned by the University, conducting Christian religious propaganda
in SV University Hostels,<br />
distributing Christian literature in<br />
educational institutions.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e offerings made by devotees<br />
in Lord Balaji’s Hundi should be<br />
used only for Hindu religion,<br />
spiritual activities. With that object<br />
in view the Hindu Dharma Prachara<br />
Samstha was started in the year<br />
1968. But later in the year 1982<br />
the word Hindu was removed from<br />
its name changing it to Dharma<br />
Prachara Parishat. <strong>Th</strong>e motive<br />
behind the change in name is to<br />
divert the huge funds offered by<br />
the devotees to Lord Sri<br />
Venkateswara as token of their<br />
religious devotion to populist<br />
Government schemes.<br />
As part of that move Rs. 500<br />
crores worth of Hundi money is<br />
ought to be diverted in the name<br />
of “Irrigation Bonds”. How the<br />
religious funds are going to be<br />
spent is any one’s guess. <strong>Th</strong>us<br />
to divert the money offered by<br />
devotees with specific religious<br />
motives to non-religious purpose<br />
is a clear case of subversion of<br />
Hindu religion.<br />
Tirumala is the most sacred<br />
place. To convert it into a tourist,<br />
recreational center as the Govt. is<br />
planning, is the sure way to<br />
ultimately make it into a pleasure<br />
resort. <strong>Th</strong>is is reprehensible.<br />
If the sacred Tirumala Temple<br />
Township is degraded in this<br />
fashion, where is the place left for<br />
Hinduism? What is the fate of<br />
Hindu Society?<br />
Let us all wake up before it is<br />
too late. Let us resolve to fight out<br />
to protect the sanctity and property<br />
of sacred TT Kshetram through all<br />
possible democratic means. Let<br />
us resolve to denote all our mite<br />
and might in this regard.✰<br />
CHRISTIAN EVANGELISM<br />
IN TIRUMALA TIRUPATHI<br />
Some Evidence from Telugu News Papers<br />
Distribution of Christian<br />
pamphlats in Tirumala - Bus<br />
No. AP11 Z 1130 belonging to<br />
RTC left Tirumala at 5.30 P.M. on<br />
Sunday 9.4.06 for Tirupathi. One<br />
Balaraju boarded the bus along<br />
with three others. <strong>Th</strong>ey carried a<br />
handbag full of Christian Literature<br />
and started distributing the same<br />
to the passengers. <strong>Th</strong>e passengers<br />
objected to the distribution of<br />
Christian Pamphlets. Among those<br />
who objected was one Mr. Aravind<br />
a resident of Parimala Apartments<br />
of Kothapet, Hyderabad. (Andhra<br />
Jyothi – 10 April, 2006)<br />
Christian Propaganda in<br />
S.V.University – Students confront<br />
the Pastor: on 11th April 2006<br />
students belonging to TNSF and<br />
ABVP students unions obstructed<br />
the Christian carrying on<br />
propaganda within University<br />
campus. <strong>Th</strong>e enraged students<br />
vehemently opposed pastor<br />
Devasahayam and his cohorts.<br />
For the past two years a student<br />
inmate of room no. 126 of<br />
University Hostel E-Block has been<br />
conducting Christian gatherings by<br />
inviting priests. He is inducing<br />
some students to join the<br />
meetings. Offended by this<br />
unbecoming action, other students<br />
demanded the instigator to stop<br />
the activity. On Tuesday (12 th ) the<br />
Christian propagandist came to<br />
conduct meeting as usual.<br />
Students confronted him and told<br />
him to stop evangelism. Heated<br />
exchanges took place and the<br />
students expelled the intruder.<br />
(Andhra Jyothi – 12 April, 2006)<br />
Search for Christians in TTD<br />
Employees Quarters : Christians<br />
residing in Tirumala are under<br />
surveillance. <strong>Th</strong>ey were asked to<br />
leave Tirumala. As per the rules<br />
of TTD, Non-Hindus are barred<br />
from taking part in the work of<br />
Tirumala Temple or other Hindu<br />
religious programmes. Non-Hindus<br />
cannot be employed in Tirumala<br />
Temple establishment. Further as<br />
per the rules conduction non-<br />
Hindu religious propaganda or<br />
programmes in Tirumala will be<br />
considered an offence. In view of<br />
this, the TTD Officials have started<br />
identifying those employees who<br />
converted themselves to other<br />
religious after taking up job with<br />
TTD and such persons are mooted<br />
to be moved away from Tirumala.<br />
So far the officials identified some<br />
20 non-Hindus staying in TTD<br />
employees quarters. (Andhra<br />
Bhoomi – 15 April, 2006)<br />
Sleepy Vigilance… TTD top<br />
brass displeased on Christian<br />
propaganda in Tirumala :<br />
Higher Officials of TTD feel that<br />
the failure of vigilance department<br />
led to the recent spurt in Christian<br />
propaganda in Tirumala. It came<br />
to their notice that some TTD<br />
employees converted to<br />
Christianity under various<br />
allurements played host to the<br />
evangelist activities. As such they<br />
are investigating the details of<br />
employee converts. Devasthanam<br />
Executive Officer Mr. Narayana<br />
Sarma and special officer Mr.<br />
Dharma Reddy are reviewing the<br />
situation of Christian activities in<br />
2 “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>,July 2006
Tirumala. ( Andhra Jyothi – 11<br />
April, 2006)<br />
Another burst of Christian<br />
propaganda : A fresh round of<br />
Christian propaganda led to tense<br />
situation in Tirupathi. Christian<br />
evangelists swarmed on different<br />
institutions belonging to SV<br />
University, Padmavathi women’s<br />
University and other TTD run<br />
colleges on <strong>Th</strong>ursday conducting<br />
aggressive propaganda. Reacting<br />
to this predatory activity, students<br />
and general public confronted the<br />
evangelists under the leadership of<br />
Ramesh Naidu, the ABVP National<br />
Executive Committee member. As<br />
a result tense situation prevailed<br />
at various colleges. Nearly 30<br />
women and 10 males were going<br />
round colleges to conduct Christian<br />
propaganda right inside college<br />
premises. <strong>Th</strong>ey specially chose<br />
EAMCET exam centers to conduct<br />
their propaganda.<br />
(Eenadu... 5 May,2006)<br />
Christian Propaganda by<br />
TTD’s Asst. Excutive Officer<br />
(AEO) – A Devotee Complains<br />
to EO : “<strong>Th</strong>e TTD is one of the<br />
largest religious institutions in the<br />
world. A top official of a famous<br />
institution, like the AEO is resorting<br />
to Christian religious propaganda”<br />
– complains a Hindu devotee<br />
named Ramana hailing from<br />
punganur to the EO of TTD Mr.<br />
APVN Sarma. Ramana made the<br />
complaint while participating in the<br />
“Dial your EO” programme<br />
conducted by Television. He<br />
complained that Mr. Jayaram, AEO<br />
of TTD is propagating Christian<br />
religion.” A person in high rank in<br />
TTD working against TTD pains<br />
me” says Ramana. (Vaartha… 6<br />
May, 2006)<br />
Ropeway Proposal Cleared<br />
by TTD : <strong>Th</strong>e proposal of<br />
constructing a ropeway from Alipiri<br />
to Tirumala Hills to facilitate tourist<br />
is cleared by the TTD Board. <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
Board allocated two acres of land<br />
to the Tourism Department over<br />
the objections of the Agama<br />
advisory committee. <strong>Th</strong>us, the way<br />
is cleared for the Ropeway.<br />
(Eenadu Daily)<br />
Govt. Covets Balaji’s wealth<br />
– attempts afoot to divert Rs.500<br />
crores : <strong>Th</strong>e Government is eyeing<br />
the huge funds of Lord<br />
Venkateswara to finance its<br />
popular schemes. It is trying to<br />
divert Rs. 500 crore of TTD funds<br />
into Irrigation Bonds. In the past<br />
Government passed some statutes<br />
to prevent such diversion of TTD<br />
funds. <strong>Th</strong>e present Government<br />
seeks to change those statutes.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Government proposes to<br />
change the name of “Hindu<br />
Religious Endowment” to “Religious<br />
Endowment” to remove hurdles to<br />
its proposed diversion of TTD funds.<br />
(Eenadu Daily)<br />
Surveillance on non-Hindu<br />
Religious Propaganda on<br />
Tirumla surroundings – E.O. :<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e EO of TTD Mr. APVN Sarma<br />
said that as per rule 196 of TTD<br />
Act, no religious propaganda other<br />
than Hinduism is allowed within<br />
10.33 Sq miles area of the<br />
Kshetram. As per rule 197, those<br />
who reside in Tirumala Kshetram<br />
and those who work for TTD must<br />
be Hindus by religion, he said.<br />
(Vaartha… 12 April, 2006)<br />
Note : <strong>Th</strong>e total area covered<br />
by the Seven Hills collectively<br />
called Tirumala are Seshachala,<br />
Vedachala, Garudachala,<br />
Anjanachala, Vrushabhachala,<br />
Narayanachala, Venkatachala, is<br />
about 100 Sq.miles (250sq.kms).<br />
whereas the Rural Development<br />
Department of Panchayatraj’s<br />
prohibits non-Hindu religious<br />
propaganda only in 10.33 sq. miles.<br />
Why so?<br />
Anti Hindu propaganda on<br />
Simhachalam – Villagers<br />
Oppose : Religious conversion is<br />
carried on surreptitiously on<br />
Simhachalam Temple vicinity.<br />
Some persons belonging to a<br />
foreign religion have been<br />
conducting evangelism among the<br />
tribals of Simhachalam and other<br />
localities for four days a week.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ey are carrying religious<br />
conversions not only among the<br />
tribals but also among the<br />
devotees visiting the Simhachalam<br />
Temple. (Andhra Jyothi…<br />
9 May, 2006)<br />
Anti Hindu Posters in<br />
Bhadrachalam Ramalayam :<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Temple authorities are<br />
perturbed to find posters<br />
propagating (non-Hindu) religion<br />
within the Rama Temple premises.<br />
On the festival occasion of<br />
Hanumat Jayanthi, devotees<br />
gathered in huge numbers found<br />
these obnoxious posters and<br />
informed the temple authorities.<br />
(<strong>Th</strong>e author canbe contacted at<br />
shyam_rss2004@yahoo.com)✰<br />
Winston Churchill’s<br />
Forecast<br />
“Power will go into the<br />
hands of rascals, rogues<br />
and freebooters. Not a bottle<br />
of water or a loaf of bread<br />
shall escape taxation. Only<br />
the air will be free and the<br />
blood of these hungry millions<br />
will be on the head of Mr<br />
Attlee. <strong>Th</strong>ese are the men<br />
of straw of whom no trace<br />
will be found after a few<br />
years”.<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>,July 2006 3
THE CONSPIRACY OF SELECTIVE SILENCE<br />
When a mosque was<br />
demolished in India there was an<br />
international outcry, but nothing<br />
when a temple was destroyed in<br />
Malaysia<br />
A century-old Hindu temple was<br />
demolished in Malaysia despite<br />
devotees pleading with the<br />
authorities to stop the operations.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ough the Malaysian Hindus were<br />
understandably upset, the Hindus<br />
in India did not react, which is fine.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Government of India did not<br />
react, which might have been right,<br />
had it not officially objected to the<br />
Danish Government about the<br />
publication of the Prophet’s cartoons<br />
in a Danish newspaper. <strong>Th</strong>e UPA<br />
Government had even suggested the<br />
Danish Prime Minister to postpone<br />
his visit to India.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e International Herald Tribune<br />
published a cartoon depicting US<br />
President George Bush as Lord<br />
Shiva. <strong>Th</strong>ough an organisation,<br />
Indiacause, did find the cartoon<br />
offensive, most Hindus did not react<br />
to it. When Mohammed’s offensive<br />
cartoons were published, Muslims<br />
all over the world, including in India,<br />
protested. One must not forget that<br />
the cartoons were first published in<br />
September and the protests<br />
occurred months later.<br />
Hindus did not react similarly<br />
when the Malaimel Sri Selva<br />
Kaliamman temple was destroyed<br />
in Malaysia, nor when a Krishna<br />
temple was demolished in Moscow.<br />
Hindus are not obliged to react like<br />
Muslims when such incidents<br />
occur. Even many Muslims, though<br />
they might have been offended by<br />
the Danish cartoon, did not<br />
participate in the protests. But<br />
should not have the Government of<br />
India reacted in similar manner to<br />
these religious incidents?<br />
<strong>Secularism</strong> means treating all<br />
Seema Sarin<br />
religions equally. If the Government<br />
can officially object to the point of<br />
postponing a prime ministerial visit<br />
on cartoons of the Prophet being<br />
published in a Danish newspaper<br />
(which had nothing to do with the<br />
Government), how can it claim to<br />
be secular when it says nothing to<br />
another (Malaysian) country about<br />
demolition of a Hindu temple - an<br />
act which done by the Malaysian<br />
authorities?<br />
Perhaps the best policy would<br />
be not to react to religious incidents<br />
abroad, be it related to Hindus or<br />
Muslims. Religious occurrences<br />
abroad are not the affair of the<br />
Government of India, whether they<br />
involve the publication of offensive<br />
cartoons or demolition of Hindu<br />
temples. <strong>Th</strong>e UPA Government<br />
does seem to observe that policy,<br />
except in the case of Muslims. Is it<br />
fair to have different policies for<br />
different religions in a secular<br />
country?<br />
As for the world and the media,<br />
these too seem to have double<br />
standards when it comes to religion.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ere was a huge outcry when an<br />
unfrequented mosque was<br />
demolished in India, but nothing<br />
happened when a well-frequented<br />
temple was destroyed in Malaysia.<br />
Never mind that the temple was<br />
destroyed at a time when 300<br />
devotees were praying there.<br />
Now the Indian press has found<br />
some justification for reacting to the<br />
first incident, while ignoring the<br />
second - because the former<br />
incident happened in India, while the<br />
second occurred in a foreign country.<br />
But why should the global media<br />
create such a hue and cry over the<br />
destruction of a mosque in India, but<br />
remain silent over the demolition of<br />
a temple in Malaysia? ✰<br />
Source: <strong>Th</strong>e Pioneer<br />
EXCERPTS FROM<br />
THE PETITION FOR<br />
FORMATION OF<br />
UNITED HINDU<br />
DHARMA SAMSTHAN<br />
by <strong>Dr</strong> T R N Rao, USA<br />
• India is under siege today by<br />
many forces, and many people<br />
do not even realize the gravity<br />
of the situation.<br />
• <strong>Th</strong>e enemies of India are<br />
networking effectively bonded<br />
by their common animosity<br />
towards Hinduism.<br />
• Inimical forces have taken<br />
control of the media,<br />
Bollywood, and political<br />
parties.<br />
• While Pujya Swamy<br />
•<br />
Sankarachrya of Kanchi<br />
Peetham was incarcerated<br />
and humiliated, the entire<br />
English and Tamil media went<br />
celebrating while concocting<br />
fraudulent stories.<br />
When Pujya Swami Ramdev<br />
is blatantly attacked by Brinda<br />
Karat, and Pujya Satya Sai<br />
Baba tarnished with unfounded<br />
accusations, the same media<br />
was in glee.<br />
• If one Swamiji is attacked it<br />
must be treated as an attack<br />
on all the Acharyas.<br />
• If Aksharadham or Ayodhya<br />
is sprayed with bullets and<br />
grenades, it is an all out<br />
attack on entire Hindu<br />
Samajam.<br />
• Modern versions of<br />
Duryodhana and Duhs’asana<br />
are conversionism and<br />
terrorism with their onslaughts<br />
to besiege Bharat.<br />
4 “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006
• Mass Christian conversions<br />
and the covert/overt support it<br />
receives from “secular” political<br />
parties and media is very<br />
alarming.<br />
• Marxists hate everything that<br />
is sacred and beautiful in the<br />
Hindu heritage of our<br />
civilization.<br />
• <strong>Th</strong>e enemy is more dangerous<br />
because the methods used<br />
are highly sophisticated and<br />
there is an invisible network<br />
of apparently divergent groups<br />
but united in undermining the<br />
Hindu Samaajam.<br />
• Whatever enemy subjugated<br />
the nation, did it not because<br />
of their superior strength, but<br />
because they were helped by<br />
Hindus who did not realize<br />
the nature of the intolerant<br />
faiths who were governed by<br />
adharma.<br />
• In the guise of neo-liberalism,<br />
globalization has become the<br />
present-day mantra and<br />
westernization is eating at the<br />
very roots of Hindu society.<br />
• <strong>Th</strong>e intellectuals of India and<br />
our politicians today need<br />
dependable guidance to get<br />
out of the false glorification of<br />
Western ways of life and<br />
money as the measure of<br />
success. <strong>Th</strong>ey have to be<br />
brought back to their age-old<br />
beautiful traditions of simple<br />
life and Seva to the poor.<br />
• Only Sanatana Dharma can<br />
offer a sustainable world order<br />
without perpetuating clashes<br />
in the name of faiths.<br />
• Hindu Acharyas should speak<br />
with one united voice.✰<br />
REWARDING CONVERSIONS<br />
We reproduce below a letter<br />
written by the famous columnist<br />
and educationist Smt Sandhya<br />
Jain to the Chairman of the National<br />
Commission for Religious and<br />
Linguistic Minorities, Government<br />
of India, New Delhi<br />
<strong>Th</strong>is is to urge you strongly to<br />
kindly reject the motivated and illconsidered<br />
proposal to extend<br />
privileges provided under the<br />
Constitution for Scheduled Castes<br />
and Scheduled Tribes to converts<br />
to non-Hindu faiths.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e demand by Christian groups<br />
for special privileges to so-called<br />
‘Christian Dalits’ are a fraud on the<br />
Dalits and a ruse to finance<br />
conversions to Christianity through<br />
the public exchequer. <strong>Th</strong>e Supreme<br />
Court in a landmark judgment of<br />
1977 (Chief Justice AN Ray) had<br />
noted that, “if a person purposely<br />
undertakes the conversion of<br />
another to his religion, that would<br />
impinge on the freedom of<br />
conscience guaranteed to all<br />
citizens of the country alike”.<br />
You would be aware that the<br />
Christian missionaries spread<br />
serious disaffection in society by<br />
their blasphemy against Hindu<br />
divinities, and divide society into<br />
warring factions by promoting illwill<br />
and distrust amongst various<br />
groups, so as to win converts. A<br />
key argument made in this process<br />
is that they are promoting equality<br />
and the brotherhood of man. Yet<br />
this equality vanishes the moment<br />
the low caste converts leave their<br />
old family, culture and social group<br />
behind and seek to enter the<br />
churches as equals. <strong>Th</strong>en they are<br />
given separate churches and even<br />
cemeteries! And now the<br />
responsibility for all this evil<br />
Sandhya Jain<br />
perpetrated by the church is placed<br />
at the door of Hindu society which<br />
is doing much to mitigate the lot<br />
of these groups.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e church is keeping all its<br />
foreign funds for further<br />
evangelization, rather than the<br />
economic upliftment of the<br />
converted from poor sections of<br />
society. <strong>Th</strong>us, it willfully aggravates<br />
social unrest and inequality.<br />
Any extension of privileges<br />
guaranteed under the Constitution to<br />
Scheduled Caste and Scheduled<br />
Tribe converts will doubly reward<br />
Church duplicity. It will be nothing<br />
short of State sponsored or State<br />
financed evangelization, which is<br />
blatantly unconstitutional. It will<br />
completely destroy the social fabric<br />
of the nation and will divide the nation<br />
on communal lines. In this regard,<br />
one is compelled to ask to what<br />
extent the Catholic affiliation of UPA<br />
chairperson Ms. Sonia Gandhi is<br />
responsible for the consideration of<br />
such a disastrous proposal at this<br />
moment in history.<br />
It is well known that the term<br />
‘Dalit’ is a political invention with no<br />
sanction in Indian tradition. ‘Dalit’<br />
theology is specifically invented by<br />
Christian evangelical and<br />
proselytizing groups funded by<br />
America, whose administration is<br />
taking undue interest in India’s<br />
internal matters, to which UPA is a<br />
silent spectator.<br />
In the name of national unity<br />
and integration, I urge the Hon’ble<br />
Commission to reject any moves<br />
to provide for special privileges to<br />
converts to Christianity.<br />
Sandhya Jain, Columnist, <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
Pioneer can be contacted at<br />
jsandhya@gmail.com ✰<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006 5
‘CHRISTIANS UNDER SIEGE’:<br />
A MISSIONARY PLOY<br />
- <strong>Dr</strong>. David Frawley<br />
Missionaries in India are using<br />
their age-old tactic of posing as<br />
victims to camouflage their<br />
aggression<br />
Background: Christianity and<br />
intolerance: Christianity does not<br />
have a notable reputation for<br />
tolerance and respect for other<br />
religions. <strong>Th</strong>e Christian need to<br />
convert the entire world has been<br />
an historical obsession that<br />
continues in major Christian groups<br />
today, both Protestant and<br />
Catholic. <strong>Th</strong>e Christian failure to<br />
honor other religions, particularly<br />
non-biblical traditions, is well<br />
known, with Christians still<br />
denigrating the sophisticated yogic<br />
traditions of Asia as mere<br />
superstition, idolatry and<br />
polytheism. Christian missionaries<br />
have had a reputation for using<br />
methods to promote conversion<br />
that are not always honest,<br />
including employing military and<br />
political force during the colonial<br />
era. <strong>Th</strong>eir targeting of the poor<br />
and illiterate for conversion, shows<br />
that they don’t like open debates<br />
in the light of day. Yet Christians<br />
like to ignore such inconvenient<br />
facts while posing as peaceful<br />
people concerned with human<br />
welfare, not with conversion.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ey are surprised if members<br />
of other religions are suspicious of<br />
them, even if they look at these<br />
religions and condemn them as<br />
works of the Devil. <strong>Th</strong>ey feel<br />
easily hurt and insulted should<br />
anyone question their motives or<br />
their actions that they would<br />
certainly not allow other religious<br />
groups to practice in their own<br />
Christian communities.<br />
In the modern secular world,<br />
Christians now demand conversion<br />
as a democratic right, even<br />
though their religion is<br />
authoritarian, not democratic,<br />
accepting only one way, and not<br />
honoring pluralism in approaching<br />
the Divine. Christianity and its<br />
Churches have always been<br />
despotic institutions. <strong>Th</strong>ey offer no<br />
freedom of choice about the savior,<br />
the book or the creed that can<br />
bring salvation and there is little<br />
tolerance for those who chose<br />
another way outside their faith.<br />
Europe had to reject the church<br />
and Christian dogma in order to<br />
become democratic over the past<br />
several centuries. So Christian<br />
churches are the last people on<br />
earth who should be talking about<br />
‘democratic rights’. It is merely a<br />
smokescreen for promoting their<br />
own agendas, spreading their<br />
authoritarian and exclusivist beliefs,<br />
recklessly eliminating other<br />
cultures and religions along the<br />
way.<br />
Posing as ‘victims’<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Christians of India continue<br />
to harbor attitudes hostile to the<br />
other religions of their country.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ey want a freedom to convert<br />
others but they are not willing to<br />
accept the other religions of the<br />
land as valid. <strong>Th</strong>ey have abused<br />
Hindu tolerance and respect for all<br />
religions, which allows Hindus to<br />
honor Christ and Christian mystics,<br />
and used it as a pretext to<br />
promote Christian superiority, not<br />
to reciprocate with honoring<br />
Hinduism and its great sages and<br />
yogis. <strong>Th</strong>ey say Christ must be<br />
great because Hindus honor him.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ey don’t honor Hindu teachers<br />
in return.<br />
Today Christians in India are<br />
highlighting minor attacks on<br />
Christians done by unidentified<br />
groups as a concerted Hindu<br />
campaign against them, while they<br />
themselves are actively working to<br />
change Hindu India into a Christian<br />
nation by all available means.<br />
While Christians have a long history<br />
of aggression against other faiths<br />
that certainly has not come to an<br />
end, they are quite offended if their<br />
religion faces minor obstructions<br />
or even criticism from the groups<br />
they have long maligned and, not<br />
long ago, actively oppressed. In all<br />
this they assume an aggrieved<br />
posture and claim to be victims<br />
of the very type of persecution that<br />
they themselves have historically<br />
practiced.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>is came to the fore soon<br />
after the arrest of the members of<br />
a Muslim organization showing it<br />
to be responsible for serial church<br />
bombings in South India. It proved<br />
that the charges made by Christian<br />
leaders against Hindu<br />
organizations for the bombings<br />
were unfounded, if not malicious.<br />
However, instead of admitting their<br />
mistake Christian leaders and<br />
organizations started a propaganda<br />
campaign, again blaming the Hindu<br />
organizations for ‘creating an<br />
atmosphere’ that led to these<br />
crimes!<br />
Recent arrests in Karnataka<br />
and Andhra Pradesh have shown<br />
that, Deendar Anjuman, a Muslim<br />
organization led by a Pakistani<br />
national was behind most of the<br />
bomb blasts and attacks on<br />
6 “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006
Christian groups in South India.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Christian response has been<br />
to ignore or deny the report,<br />
though it is quite well documented<br />
and occurred in states of<br />
Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh,<br />
not ruled by the so-called Hindu<br />
BJP party. (See ‘Church Blasts:<br />
Truth and Propaganda’ by S.V.<br />
Seshagiri Rao) In fact many<br />
Christians in India - especially its<br />
so-called ‘leaders’ - are defending<br />
the ISI, the Pakistani intelligence<br />
agency that has long tried to<br />
destabilize India, by absolving it of<br />
responsibility in the affair even<br />
without any investigation. <strong>Th</strong>is<br />
would be like an American religious<br />
minority defending the KGB during<br />
the Cold War. Whether the ISI is<br />
directly involved in such efforts to<br />
cause communal conflicts in India,<br />
we must recognize that it is a<br />
project it would certainly support<br />
and would be likely to promote.<br />
To dismiss their involvement out<br />
of hand, as Christian leaders in<br />
India are doing, is highly<br />
suspicious. Christians are publicly<br />
blaming Hindu organizations for<br />
attacks for which they have no<br />
evidence, let alone proof, and<br />
which no court has found them<br />
guilty of. (<strong>Th</strong>e latest evidence<br />
does suggest official Pakistani<br />
involvement, possibly of the ISI.)<br />
Christians in India exaggerate such<br />
minor incidents into a national and<br />
even an international anti-Hindu<br />
propaganda campaign. More<br />
churches have been burnt in<br />
America in recent years than in<br />
India. Several dozen black<br />
American churches were burnt to<br />
the ground, not merely slightly<br />
damaged like the few Indian<br />
churches that have been attacked.<br />
Christian priests and ministers are<br />
also robbed, assaulted and<br />
sometimes killed in all Western<br />
countries in numbers not unlike<br />
what occurs in India. We should<br />
also note that many more priests<br />
in America have been arrested for<br />
sexual molestation of children than<br />
have priests been assaulted in<br />
India. Should we use that to make<br />
conclusions about the nature of<br />
Christianity?<br />
<strong>Th</strong>at a few priests or ministers<br />
have been harmed in a country of<br />
one billion over a period of several<br />
years is not surprising even if we<br />
only consider ordinary crimes like<br />
robbery. Such things are law and<br />
order problems not an attack on<br />
one religion in particular. Many<br />
more Hindu religious workers are<br />
killed in India each year than<br />
Christians are in many years. <strong>Th</strong>at<br />
Christian missionaries have run<br />
into difficulties in sensitive tribal<br />
areas where there is not much<br />
government or police control is<br />
also not surprising, particularly<br />
given their hostility to tribal culture<br />
and tribal religions. <strong>Th</strong>e main<br />
purpose in all this drama is to<br />
whip up a propaganda campaign<br />
in order to bring international<br />
pressure on India to give Christians<br />
more freedom in their conversion<br />
efforts. Many Christians seem to<br />
prefer this to dealing with the<br />
Hindus in a spirit of give and take.<br />
What makes this affair<br />
especially distasteful is that even<br />
when there is a systematic<br />
cleansing of Christians in Pakistan,<br />
Indian Christian leaders are<br />
prepared to ignore their plight for<br />
their propaganda purposes against<br />
the Hindus. Even the Pope, while<br />
condemning Indonesia and India,<br />
refused to mention the atrocities<br />
against Christians in Pakistan.<br />
His equating of Indonesia where<br />
hundreds of Christians have been<br />
killed in recent months to India,<br />
where only a few have died over<br />
several years, also highlights the<br />
propaganda urge behind his<br />
statements. It was as though<br />
Christians wanted the situation in<br />
India to be worse and are trying<br />
to promote communal disharmony<br />
to highlight their presence in the<br />
country.<br />
Christians almost seem<br />
desperate to make a scene in<br />
India to highlight to the world<br />
media.<br />
All this is enough to make one<br />
wonder if Christians are staging<br />
some of these attacks to pose as<br />
victims of persecution. Whether or<br />
not this proves to be the case,<br />
certainly they are exaggerating<br />
such incidents out of all proportion.<br />
Christianity has had a long history<br />
of using victimization in order to<br />
promote conversion. We know of<br />
the stories of Christians being fed<br />
to the lions in Rome. We are not<br />
told that many more pagans were<br />
killed by Christians, and thousands<br />
of pagan temples were destroyed<br />
throughout Europe. <strong>Th</strong>e great Greek<br />
(Neo-Platonic) Academy in<br />
Alexandria was destroyed and its<br />
scholars like Hypatia killed by<br />
‘Saint’ Cyril and his followers. <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
number of native Americans killed<br />
or forcibly converted by Catholics<br />
was also in many millions, and<br />
yet the Catholics emphasize a few<br />
priests martyred by the native<br />
Americans as being the real<br />
victims.<br />
Such stories of Christian<br />
oppression are good ploys to gain<br />
donations in Western countries.<br />
India as a pagan country, where<br />
image worship is common, is an<br />
easy target for such conversion<br />
sentiments.<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006 7
<strong>Th</strong>e Indian scene<br />
Mother Teresa’s successor,<br />
Sister Nirmala, claims that Hindu<br />
fears that conversion is being<br />
done by force, deception or<br />
propaganda are not true and are<br />
ridiculous. But she should well<br />
know that ‘such devices have long<br />
been used in Christianity’ We can<br />
find native peoples all over the<br />
world whose cultures have been<br />
destroyed and even whose<br />
populations have been decimated<br />
by the missionaries and by the<br />
colonial armies that they<br />
supported. <strong>Th</strong>e Indian public is by<br />
and large unaware of the magnitude<br />
of destruction caused by<br />
Christianity, which may. exceed<br />
the destruction due to Islam and<br />
its Jihads. Until recently, any<br />
discussion of even the Goa<br />
Inquisition was taboo, and it is still<br />
barely mentioned in Indian history<br />
books. <strong>Th</strong>is is due to the fact that<br />
Christian (colonial) institutions<br />
practically control the education<br />
agenda in India, especially in<br />
history and other humanities. In<br />
fact Christianity in India is much<br />
more conservative than that in the<br />
West where most Catholics violate<br />
the main tenets of the church<br />
about contraception and divorce<br />
and fail to attend church and take<br />
its rituals in any regular way.<br />
Christianity in India is still<br />
projecting a medieval view of the<br />
church triumphant that has long<br />
been discarded in the West.<br />
Even if the Hindu fear of<br />
missionary mischief is<br />
exaggerated, it is entirely<br />
understandable. We should<br />
remember that the Pope in his<br />
recent visit to India himself threw<br />
down the gauntlet, stating a<br />
renewed church policy to convert<br />
Asia to Christianity in the coming<br />
years. To dismiss the Hindu fear<br />
as baseless only shows that it is<br />
not. If Christians were really sincere<br />
they would acknowledge that<br />
missionary activity has used such<br />
questionable methods in the past<br />
and work to insure that it does not<br />
do so in the future, and not simply<br />
ignore the issue. In the<br />
circumstances, it is prudent and<br />
proper for Hindus to view Christian<br />
activities and statements with<br />
suspicion.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e missionaries have altered<br />
their tactics to what is possible<br />
in the post-colonial era, but that<br />
is not a change of heart. <strong>Th</strong>ey<br />
have not opened to Hindus,<br />
dialogued with them sincerely, or<br />
sought a common ground with<br />
them for social harmony or for<br />
seeking true knowledge of God.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ey have aimed at the poor and<br />
displaced of Hindu society to<br />
promote a conversion effort that<br />
has failed with the educated and<br />
affluent of the country. <strong>Th</strong>ey are<br />
striking below the belt and then<br />
complain of unfairness if their<br />
efforts are exposed.<br />
Politics, not Spirituality<br />
What is most surprising is that<br />
Christian missionaries have more<br />
freedom of operation in India than<br />
in the rest of Asia. <strong>Th</strong>ey are<br />
banned in Islamic countries,<br />
including Pakistan, and strictly<br />
monitored in China, which has its<br />
own nationalist Catholic Church<br />
apart from Rome. Even Russia<br />
under Putin has recently come out<br />
against Christian missionaries as<br />
causing mischief in the country<br />
and often being agents of the<br />
American government. Christians<br />
are under direct attack in Indonesia<br />
where thousands of Christians have<br />
been killed in recent years.<br />
Neighboring Pakistan does not<br />
allow the missionaries the freedom<br />
they have in India and routinely<br />
oppresses its Christians. A few<br />
years ago a Catholic Bishop<br />
committed suicide in a Pakistan<br />
court to protest the issue.<br />
But it is India that being called<br />
to task in the world forum for its<br />
oppression of Christians! Mexico,<br />
which used to be part of the<br />
‘Catholic Empire of Spain’, does<br />
not allow missionaries the kind of<br />
freedom they enjoy in India. Only<br />
in some so-called ‘Banana<br />
Republics’ of Latin America do we<br />
find missionaries being so powerful.<br />
Even this, as has been revealed<br />
by recent hearings in the US<br />
Congress, was often financed by<br />
the CIA, with priests serving as<br />
CIA agents.<br />
Such information suggests that<br />
Christian leaders have given up<br />
most countries of the world as<br />
beyond their reach but<br />
concentrated on India as the US<br />
did on the Banana Republics.<br />
Missionaries and Christian<br />
organizations are very much on<br />
the defensive in most of the world<br />
today, where they are simply trying<br />
to hold their ground.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e West continues to discard<br />
Christianity. <strong>Th</strong>e Islamic world will<br />
not let it in and China is keeping<br />
it at a safe distance. In America<br />
such missionary groups, which<br />
would still like to ban the teaching<br />
of evolution in the schools,<br />
complain how the country has all<br />
but abandoned real Christianity.<br />
But in India the missionaries<br />
remain aggressive. <strong>Th</strong>e reason is<br />
simple. India allows missionary<br />
activity and so is a soft target.<br />
Islamic countries and China are<br />
hard targets. <strong>Th</strong>e missionaries are<br />
targeting India because they feel<br />
8 “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006
they can make headway in India,<br />
not because India is a place<br />
where they are particularly under<br />
siege!<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e hypocrisy of the whole<br />
thing is easy to see. It shows the<br />
condescending attitude that<br />
missionaries have towards Hindus,<br />
thinking that they can bully them<br />
or appeal to their tolerance by a<br />
feigned persecution. It proves that<br />
Christians are still promoting a<br />
medieval religion that will not honor<br />
other religions and is still seeking<br />
world domination by any means,<br />
fair or foul. If we count the victims<br />
of Christian aggression on one<br />
side and the Christians themselves<br />
who have been victimized we will<br />
find that the victims of Christianity<br />
are overwhelmingly in the majority.<br />
While some Christians have<br />
apologized to African and Native<br />
American groups for such<br />
missionary misdeeds, the Hindus<br />
have so far not received any such<br />
apology, though they have suffered<br />
from the same methods. <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
reason is that the missionaries<br />
have not yet triumphed in India.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e apology, like crocodile tears,<br />
comes only after the victim is<br />
dead.<br />
In the nineteenth and the early<br />
twentieth century, Christian colonial<br />
governments used their influence<br />
to promote conversion in the<br />
countries they ruled.<br />
Now Christians want to use<br />
freedom and democracy, which<br />
they didn’t allow under their<br />
rulership, to continue the<br />
conversion process. And all without<br />
an apology or explanation for this<br />
about face! If Christians want to<br />
be honored and respected let<br />
them first proclaim that Christianity<br />
is not the only true religion and<br />
Jesus is not the Only Son of God.<br />
Let them say that Hinduism,<br />
Buddhism, Sikhism, J ainism,<br />
Zoroastrianism and other Indian<br />
religions are as good as<br />
Christianity. Let Christians say<br />
clearly that members of other<br />
religions will not go to hell but will<br />
gain immortality in the presence<br />
of God by following what is good<br />
in their own teachings.<br />
Major Christian groups, however,<br />
will certainly not make such<br />
statements, though they may cover<br />
over their exclusivism with<br />
platitudes about human peace,<br />
brotherhood and Divine love.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>eir, failure to honor other<br />
religions shows an intolerance that<br />
naturally breeds conflict and<br />
inevitably leads to communal<br />
tension.<br />
Christians wouldn’t even accept<br />
a Mahatma Gandhi and worked to<br />
convert him, while the Mahatma<br />
described missionary activity as a<br />
great danger and as spiritually and<br />
ethically flawed.<br />
As a former Catholic I know in<br />
what little esteem the Church<br />
holds Hinduism and Buddhism<br />
with all their great sages and<br />
yogis.<br />
Christianity, like Islam, sees<br />
tolerance not as a virtue to be<br />
emulated but as a weakness to<br />
be exploited. Were Christians to<br />
really honor Hinduism as a valid<br />
religion all Hindu-Christian hostility<br />
could easily come to an end. As<br />
long as Christians hold that theirs<br />
alone is the True Faith and are<br />
working to convert the members<br />
of other religions in one way or<br />
another, they should not be<br />
surprised if members of other<br />
religions do not welcome their<br />
presence.<br />
It is only a matter of time<br />
before missionary Christianity is<br />
seen for what it is-imperialism in<br />
the name of God and Christ, the<br />
proverbial wolf in sheep’s clothing.<br />
It is a political, worldly movement<br />
with little spirituality in it.<br />
Unfortunately such Christians<br />
confuse the real Divine work, which<br />
is improving ourselves through<br />
introspection, with the institutional<br />
work of imposing a single belief<br />
upon all humanity. <strong>Th</strong>is political<br />
view of religion has no place in the<br />
global age of consciousness that<br />
is dawning in enlightened minds<br />
all over the world today. <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
quicker it comes to an end, the<br />
better it will be for all humanity.<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
<strong>Dr</strong>. Frawley (Vamadeva Shastri)<br />
is one of the few Westerners ever<br />
recognized in India as a<br />
Vedacharya or teacher of Vedic<br />
wisdom. His field of study includes<br />
Ayurveda, Vedic and Vedantic<br />
philosophy Tantra and Yoga. His<br />
influential book, Gods, Sages and<br />
Kings is recognized as a<br />
pioneering effort that set the stage<br />
for a revolution in the study of<br />
ancient history. His several books<br />
on the Vedas including his poetic<br />
translation of the Vedic hymns,<br />
Wisdom of the Ancient Seers<br />
have been published both in India<br />
and the west. He is the author of<br />
numerous books on Veda. Indian<br />
spirituality and current affairs<br />
“<strong>Th</strong>ose who carry on great public schemes must be proof against the most fatiguing delays, the most<br />
mortifying disappointments, the most shocking insults and what is most of all, the presumptuous judgement<br />
of the ignorant.” - Edmund Burke<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006 9
including Arise Arjuna. Awaken<br />
Bharata, Hinduism. <strong>Th</strong>e Eternal<br />
Tradition and many more. He lives<br />
in Santa Fe in the United States<br />
where he is the Director of the<br />
American Institute of Vedic<br />
Studies.✰<br />
* * *<br />
‘SECULAR’ TOWARDS<br />
MUSLIMS AND<br />
CHRISTIANS BUT<br />
INTERFERING WITH<br />
HINDUS<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e ‘secular’ government of the<br />
Samajwadi Mulayam Singh in Uttar<br />
Pradesh is planning to enact a law<br />
which would enable it to monitor<br />
the activities of temples, mutts<br />
and religious trusts, and also have<br />
a big say in their management .<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e ‘secular’ Minister, Ashok<br />
Bajpai of the UP government wants<br />
to ensure a fool-proof arrangement<br />
for keeping a close watch on the<br />
management of the religious places<br />
as not only were the sewadars<br />
and workers exploited by the<br />
mahants and pujaris, dispute over<br />
property owned by the mutts and<br />
temples has often led to the<br />
murder of priests.”<br />
He says that temple towns are<br />
tourist center Varanai, Ayodhya and<br />
Chitrakoot. He asserted that proper<br />
management of temples would<br />
promote tourism in the state. And<br />
that the income from the temples,<br />
mutts and religious trusts will be<br />
ploughed back for the welfare of their<br />
workers. For the purpose of the<br />
legislation, temples and mutts have<br />
been divided into 3 grades: temples<br />
of international and national fame;<br />
temples of State fame; regional and<br />
local level temples, mutts and<br />
religious trusts.<br />
[Readers may note that these<br />
UP Samajwadi ‘secular’<br />
government dare not any legislation<br />
in regard to the proper<br />
management of churches or<br />
mosques but it would want to<br />
manage the Hindus’ temples only.<br />
In the south where there are<br />
already laws about Hindu temples,<br />
the concerned department are being<br />
infiltrated by crypto Christians that<br />
is Harijans who have converted to<br />
Christianity but do not disclose<br />
the facts to enjoy Reservations.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ese crypto Christian infiltrators<br />
are conspiring to and conniving at<br />
the alleviation of temples property<br />
in favour of the ‘poor’,<br />
overwhelmingly crypto Christians.<br />
Varanasi Prayaga, Mathura<br />
Ayodhya are mere tourist cities for<br />
the ‘secularists’, but they are<br />
sacred places for Hindus. <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
‘secular’ government wants to<br />
exploit the fame of these holy<br />
towns for making money through<br />
tourists. <strong>Th</strong>is is a despicable<br />
intention. Will anybody agree that<br />
Mecca and Madina should be<br />
developed as tourists spots<br />
attracting the Americans and<br />
Japanese and others? <strong>Th</strong>e ‘secular’<br />
government’s move once again<br />
exposes the inactivity and<br />
helplessness and defeatism of<br />
Hindus.] ✰<br />
Source: <strong>Th</strong>e Hindu<br />
PROMOTING URDU<br />
A Laxmi<br />
One Sudhip Bandopadhyay,<br />
formerly a Trinamul Congressmen<br />
now a Sonia Congress MLA from<br />
the Bow Bazar constituency of<br />
Kolkatta proposed in the West<br />
Bengal Legislative Assembly that<br />
Urdu must also be made the<br />
medium of instruction in all state<br />
schools. Of course, they will then<br />
make a law that the private schools<br />
must fall in line in this regard. He<br />
says that the Muslim population<br />
in Bengal is 25%; but he did not<br />
say that the Hindu population of<br />
Bangladesh had come down from<br />
30% in 1947 to less than 10% by<br />
now. He ignores the fact that less<br />
than 10% of West Bengal’s<br />
Muslims declared Urdu as their<br />
mother tongue.<br />
One of reasons why the then<br />
East Pakistan (now Bangladesh)<br />
broke away from Pakistan and<br />
became Bangladesh, is the foisting<br />
of Urdu on Bengali speaking east<br />
Pakistan’s Muslims. one of the<br />
reasons for east Bengal‘s Muslims’<br />
struggle for freedom was the<br />
demand for primacy of Bengali<br />
language. Nazrul Islam was a<br />
great Muslim poet in Bengali. He<br />
wrote not in Urdu but always only<br />
in Bengali. Not withstanding that<br />
Urdu is not the beloved tongue of<br />
Bengal’s Muslims, ‘secular’<br />
Congressmen are demanding that<br />
Urdu should be promoted among<br />
the Bengali-speaking Muslims in<br />
India. Can there be a more<br />
appeasing and ignoble conduct.<br />
Among any Indian, especially<br />
those who give their religion as<br />
Hinduism? <strong>Th</strong>e fact is that<br />
everybody angling for Muslims’<br />
votes, every ‘secularist’ tries to<br />
please and appease Muslims even<br />
in regard to issues that Muslims<br />
themselves are not interested.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Trinamul Congress got 17%<br />
of the Muslim votes; the Congress<br />
got 10% and the CPM got 73%.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e former two parties are engaged<br />
in competition to please Muslims<br />
to wean them away from the<br />
CPM. <strong>Th</strong>is is ‘secularism’!✰<br />
10 “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006
EXCLUSIVE GLORIFICATION OF NEHRU<br />
(AND HIS DYNASTY)<br />
‘Secularist’s and leftists and of<br />
course Sonia’s devotees are<br />
faulting the government of Madhya<br />
Pradesh for replacing one lesson<br />
about Nehru by another in one of<br />
the text books for schools in that<br />
state. In defence of their action,<br />
the government of Madhya Pradesh<br />
said that besides Jawaharlal Nehru,<br />
there were so many great freedom<br />
fighters and extolling Nehru to the<br />
exclusion of Bhagat Singh or<br />
Sardar Vallabhai Patel etc., is not<br />
proper. <strong>Th</strong>e Madhya Pradesh<br />
government also said not only<br />
Jawaharlal Nehru but millions of<br />
people made sacrifices in India’s<br />
freedom struggle.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Government of Madhya<br />
Pradesh deserves to be<br />
congratulated for stating truths<br />
which needed to be told much<br />
earlier and more extensively. It<br />
is only in communist states that<br />
the current ruler is almost deified<br />
and the histories of the party and<br />
the country re-written to show that<br />
that the current ruler only strove<br />
for the glory of their country. In<br />
democratic countries and open<br />
societies, histories are written not<br />
by government but by professors<br />
and scholars. <strong>Th</strong>ey present<br />
different views in contention with<br />
one another, all based upon the<br />
same facts for, the purpose of<br />
history writing is to educate the<br />
current generation so that they<br />
don’t repeat the mistakes of the<br />
past.<br />
When Sri N Sanjiva Reddy was<br />
the President of India, he wrote a<br />
letter to the Prime Minister, Indira<br />
<strong>Dr</strong> T H <strong>Chowdary</strong><br />
Gandhi, drawing her attention to<br />
increasing corruption in the<br />
government and urging her that<br />
she could do to arrest this<br />
cancerous growth of corruption.<br />
Indira Gandhi reacted very violently<br />
and instantly replied to this<br />
message from Sri N Sanjiva Reddy.<br />
She wrote back saying that the<br />
sacrifices of her father and<br />
grandfather were immense and<br />
that she should not be insinuated<br />
for corruption.<br />
Sanjiva Reddy was a great,<br />
self-respecting man of not<br />
inconsiderable integrity and robust<br />
courage. He was one of the few<br />
Congressmen who opposed Indira<br />
Gandhi’s Emergency (25 June<br />
1975) and went to jail. Reddy,<br />
the Rashtrapati wrote back to<br />
Indira Gandhi reminding her that<br />
Nehrus were not the only people<br />
who made sacrifices and that<br />
there were thousands of them who<br />
made great sacrifices and whose<br />
children and grand-children are not<br />
as fortunate as Nehrus in the<br />
enjoyment of power and prosperity.<br />
We reproduce below relevant<br />
extracts from the correspondence<br />
between Sri Sanjeeva Reddy and<br />
Indira Gandhi.<br />
When Sri N Sanjiva Reddy<br />
wrote to Indira Gandhi about the<br />
wide-spread talk of corruption in<br />
government, he made a specific<br />
mention of the extorted collections<br />
by Antulay’s Indira Pratibha<br />
Pratishtan Trust and concluded,<br />
‘... as the leader of the party in<br />
power at the center and in most<br />
of the States a great<br />
responsibility rests on you to<br />
initiate suitable steps for<br />
cleansing our public life.” Indira<br />
Gandhi reacted very angrily,<br />
presuming that the President was<br />
insinuating against her. She wrote;<br />
“My family has always been<br />
against corruption. Our record of<br />
disinterest in worldly goods is<br />
known to the world. My<br />
grandfather and father gave up<br />
exceptionally brilliant and<br />
lucrative careers, our old home,<br />
our land and cottages. <strong>Th</strong>ere<br />
was no circumstance compelling<br />
me to donate, not merely the<br />
home I loved and the lands<br />
belonging to it, but even most<br />
valuable collections of books,<br />
papers and other articles.”<br />
Sri N Sanjiva Reddy was not<br />
a V V Giri or a Fakhruddin Ali<br />
Ahmed to be a rubber stamp<br />
President. He displayed his usual<br />
bluntness, characteristic of selfemployed<br />
farmer-managers of India<br />
and wrote to Indira Gandhi on<br />
11.10. 1981;<br />
“I am aware about the<br />
contribution of your grand- father<br />
and father to the cause of India’s<br />
Independence, who under the<br />
leadership of Mahatma Gandhi,<br />
along with men like Sardar Patel,<br />
Rajaji, Rajen Babu, Subhash<br />
Chandra Bose, gave up lucrative<br />
careers and joined the freedom<br />
struggle. <strong>Th</strong>e place your family<br />
has in the country’s recent history<br />
is very well known. We should<br />
also not forget men like<br />
Prakasam, who had given up<br />
his flourishing practice at the<br />
bar to join the non-cooperation<br />
movement and thousands of<br />
unknown men and women all<br />
over the country but for whose<br />
wholehearted participation in the<br />
freedom struggle, in response<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006 11
to Gandhiji’s call the country<br />
might not have achieved<br />
independence at all. Many of<br />
them had to sell their properties<br />
to support themselves and their<br />
families; not only had they to<br />
undergo privation in their life<br />
time but their families are now<br />
living in penury. On the other<br />
hand some of US who are living<br />
today have the good fortune of<br />
reaping the benefit of their<br />
sacrifice”.<br />
Sonia Gandhi and the history<br />
- ignorant, self-respect – lacking<br />
Congressmen talk of the<br />
“sacrifices” of Sonia Gandhi –<br />
living in palatial 10 Janpath in<br />
Delhi at the cost of the poor<br />
people of India.<br />
What is the sacrifice of the<br />
Nehrus and this lady Sonia is<br />
talking of compared to the great<br />
people that Sanjiva Reddy spoke<br />
of? Truly, while the sons and<br />
grand-sons of those who fought<br />
for freedom and made more<br />
sacrifices than Motilal and<br />
Jawaharlal are mere citizens of<br />
India with no privilege and are<br />
eking their livelihood on their own<br />
and unsubsidized and unprotected<br />
by the State, Nehru, his daughter<br />
and his grandson had become<br />
Prime Ministers; his sister Vijaya<br />
Laxmi Pandit was India’s<br />
Ambassador to the former USSR<br />
and leader of India’s delegation to<br />
the United Nations. And now the<br />
widow of Rajiv is the de facto ruler<br />
of India. She has been living in<br />
10, Janapath, a government house,<br />
protected and guarded by hundreds<br />
of policemen. She is presiding for<br />
life, over Rajiv Gandhi Foundation<br />
for which hundreds of crores of<br />
Rupees were collected from the<br />
people of India. Her daughter<br />
married to a businessmen making<br />
profits is given a government house<br />
and provided high-class security.<br />
How many sons and grandsons of<br />
freedom fighters like Sardar Patel,<br />
Rajaji, Rajendra Prasad, Maulana<br />
Abul Kalam Azad or Subhash<br />
Chandra Bose are housed,<br />
protected and profited in the<br />
manner of the Nehru-Gandhi clan?<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e claims of successive people<br />
of the Nehru dynasty that they<br />
made sacrifices for India’s freedom<br />
as if none others had made are<br />
hollow. <strong>Th</strong>ey are compensated by<br />
the most lavish conferment of<br />
power and pelf. It is sheer<br />
arrogance and denigration of all<br />
other Indians. <strong>Th</strong>e innocent and<br />
ignorant Italian-born lady may do<br />
well to remember what Vijaya<br />
Laxmi Pandit, Nehru’s sister herself<br />
said about the extra-ordinary<br />
compensation that the Nehru clan<br />
has appropriated for itself in return<br />
for Motilal and Jawaharlal<br />
sacrifices. Vijaya Laxmi Pandit<br />
told the nation immediately after<br />
the Emergency (1977), while giving<br />
an interview to pressmen, that<br />
Nehru family received much<br />
more from the nation than it<br />
gave to the nation. Questioned<br />
by Indira Gandhi whether she truly<br />
said these worlds, Vijaya Laxmi<br />
Pandit boldly and unhesitatingly<br />
reiterated what she said.<br />
It may be that Congressmen<br />
who as hangers on; and<br />
sycophants and pigmies do not<br />
have any self-respect and may<br />
acquiesce in the claims and<br />
assertions of this Italian-born Rajiv’s<br />
widow. But Indians who know the<br />
history of Bharat that isIndia and<br />
who feel for their countrymen and<br />
who are witnesses to the simple<br />
ordinary life of the descendants of<br />
freedom fighters other than Nehru<br />
know that the Nehru family is<br />
wanting to establish a Dynasty<br />
and would be too happy if<br />
somebody can crown them.<br />
Congressmen are clamouring to<br />
make Sonia’s son, Rahul (whose<br />
fiancée is a foreign girl),General<br />
Secretary of Congress, preparatory<br />
to his assumption of Prime<br />
Ministership. Lenin and Stalin are<br />
gone from the history, legend and<br />
statuary in Russia. Mao Tse Tung<br />
is going out in China. Mahatma<br />
Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi is<br />
more or less gone in India. Only<br />
Nehru-Indira-Rajiv-Sonia are<br />
currency. Will they also not go the<br />
way of Lenin-Stalin-Mao? ✰<br />
TWO PROJECTS TO<br />
HARVEST HINDUS INTO<br />
CHRISTIANITY<br />
Project <strong>Th</strong>essalonica is<br />
a sub-project of Joshua<br />
Project II. Joshua Project<br />
II set the scope and<br />
strategy for converting the<br />
“heathen” of the world in<br />
10-40 window (regions<br />
that lie between the<br />
latitudes of 10 and 40<br />
degrees north) whereas<br />
project <strong>Th</strong>essalonica<br />
(called PT) prioritizes the<br />
tasks to be taken. Joshua<br />
Project II strategized the<br />
methodology called ‘Adopta-peoples’<br />
wherein every<br />
mission agency or church<br />
adopted a ‘people group’.<br />
12 “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, June 2006
Oppressed under<br />
Islam<br />
Priyadarsi Dutta<br />
It is not without an ulterior<br />
motive that N Jamal Ansari takes<br />
up the cause of the OBC in his<br />
article, “Upper caste regression”<br />
(June 21). It has less to do with<br />
the fact that Ansaris (weavers) are<br />
OBCs, and more to do with<br />
fragmentation of Hindu society so<br />
that Islam prevails.<br />
Did Brahminical Hinduism really<br />
cause “stratification” in society?<br />
<strong>Th</strong>is question cannot be studied<br />
in isolation from the 700-year<br />
Muslim rule. From the Slave to<br />
Mughal dynasty, India was under<br />
tyrannical foreign rule. <strong>Th</strong>ey<br />
imposed a system that was<br />
spiritually foreign to the ethos of<br />
India. <strong>Th</strong>e Muslims who streamed<br />
into India from West and Central<br />
Asia were favoured children of the<br />
state.<br />
François Bernier, who visited<br />
Mughal India between 1656 and<br />
1668, discovered the ‘reservation’<br />
during the Mughal rule. “<strong>Th</strong>e people<br />
of Great Tartary called Mogols; a<br />
name which they have<br />
communicated to the foreigners<br />
who now govern Indoustan, the<br />
country of the Indous, or Indians.<br />
It must not, however, be inferred<br />
that offices of trust and dignity are<br />
exclusively held by those of the<br />
Mogol race, or that they alone<br />
obtain rank in the army. <strong>Th</strong>ese<br />
situations are filled indifferently by<br />
them and strangers from all<br />
countries; the greater part by<br />
Persians, some by Arabs and<br />
others by Turks. To be considered<br />
a Mogol, it is enough if a foreigner<br />
has a white face and professes<br />
Mahomentanism; in contradistinction<br />
to the Christians of<br />
Europe, who are called Firanguis,<br />
and to the Indous, whose<br />
complexion is brown, and who are<br />
Gentiles” (Travels in Mughal<br />
Empire, p 3).<br />
Paradoxically, the Hindus who<br />
carved out a political space for<br />
themselves in Muslim India on dint<br />
of sword were often the ones who<br />
are OBCs today. Harihar and<br />
Bukka, founders of Vijayanagara,<br />
were Yadavs. Whether Shivaji was<br />
a Kshatriya is doubtful; he was<br />
suspected of being a Shudra. Raja<br />
Suraj Mal and Maharaja Ranjit<br />
Singh were Jats (OBCs by the<br />
current reckoning). Hemu (Hem<br />
Chandra), who fought the Mughals<br />
in the second battle of Panipat,<br />
was a Teli. In 1320, a lower-caste<br />
Hindu converted to Islam by force,<br />
Khusrao (later Nasiruddin),<br />
upturned the Delhi Sultanate and<br />
revived Hindu rule for a year. <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
upper-caste Hindus were the most<br />
oppressed under Islam.<br />
Source: <strong>Th</strong>e Pioneer ✰<br />
Consolidating a mighty Hindu<br />
Nation...<br />
A Hindu of this place (Pune)<br />
is as much a Hindu as the one<br />
from Madras or Bombay.....<strong>Th</strong>e<br />
study of the Gita, Ramayana<br />
and Mahabharata produce the<br />
same idea throughout the<br />
country.....If we lay stress on it<br />
forgetting all the minor differences<br />
that exist between different sects<br />
then by the grace of Providence,<br />
we shall ere long be able to<br />
consolidate all the different sects<br />
into a mighty Hindu nation.<br />
- Loka Manya Bal Gangadhar Tilak<br />
READERS WRITE:<br />
India home for ISI agents<br />
A L Sujatha, Secunderabad<br />
Md Salem Junaid is Pakistan’s<br />
ISI agent, trained and sent to India<br />
in order to foment communal<br />
trouble and also plan for the<br />
blasting of men and buildings. He<br />
was caught in Andhra Pradesh<br />
and was in jails for more than five<br />
years. <strong>Th</strong>e law took its own course<br />
and after about of five years, he<br />
was sentenced to five years jail.<br />
However, since he has spent five<br />
years already “under trial”, he is<br />
released. Government is trying to<br />
repatriate him to Pakistan.<br />
According to a report in the<br />
Indian express of 25.6.2006 he is<br />
doubtful whether Pakistan would<br />
accept him as in that case,<br />
Pakistan would have to own up<br />
the guilt of injecting saboteurs<br />
and terrorists into India. But Sri<br />
Junaid is not worried. He thinks<br />
India is very good and very<br />
hospitable. If Pakistan does not<br />
take him back, he has decided to<br />
settle in India. <strong>Th</strong>e ‘secularists’,<br />
especially the Marxists and human<br />
rightswalas would welcome one<br />
more warrior of composite culture<br />
for their army of Bharat todo-fodo.<br />
Scores of ISI agents had been<br />
arrested by some patriotic<br />
policemen in Andhra Pradesh. But<br />
many of them have disappeared<br />
while in transit between Jails and<br />
courts and between two jails. <strong>Th</strong>at<br />
is why Junaid and Islamists of his<br />
kind are very happy in India, as<br />
they find a congenial atmosphere<br />
and friendly supporters who give<br />
them safe houses, finances,<br />
facilities and most importantly,<br />
legal aid.<br />
* * *<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006 13
Telangana and Qubec (Canada)<br />
Smt. Usha Balaji, Malkajgiri<br />
In Canada, the eastern province<br />
of Qubec is French -speaking and<br />
fiercely francofile. <strong>Th</strong>ere is a<br />
Qubec Party (Parti Quebeqois)<br />
which had been campaigning for<br />
the secession of Qubec from<br />
Canada to become an Independent<br />
sovereign French speaking state<br />
in north Americas. <strong>Th</strong>at party<br />
wins the provincial elections but in<br />
any referendum for secession and<br />
independence, it does not get a<br />
majority. <strong>Th</strong>erefore it uses the<br />
threat of secession in order to get<br />
the maximum concessions from<br />
the central government.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Telangana Rashtra Samithi<br />
(TRS) appears to be one like the<br />
Party Quebecois. <strong>Th</strong>e TRS holds<br />
to the threat of separation from<br />
Andhra Pradesh and for a new<br />
state to get ministerships in the<br />
Union Cabinet and by the grace<br />
of the AP Congress, ministerships<br />
in AP also.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e Muslim majority<br />
secessionist Kashmir has been<br />
able to wrest financial packages<br />
of Rs.11,000 cr form the NDA<br />
government and Rs.26,000 crores<br />
from the UPA government for<br />
‘development’. <strong>Th</strong>is is the<br />
“bakshis” they seek and get, by<br />
holding the threat of separation.<br />
At Rs.37,000 per capita, the<br />
separatist Kashmir has received<br />
the highest munificence from the<br />
Union government. And it is now<br />
wanting utmost autonomy so that<br />
the money extracted from the<br />
Union government can be used by<br />
those in power to quit poverty and<br />
become opulent.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e “minorities” in India are<br />
also succeeding in holding the<br />
union government to ransom by<br />
their furiously proliferating numbers<br />
and so vote power. Every party in<br />
the country is trying to bid the<br />
highest price like reservations,<br />
minority college, separate welfare<br />
grants and development funds and<br />
housing, more subsidies for Haj<br />
etc., to win their favours and<br />
votes.<br />
* * *<br />
Infertility in Congress<br />
David Raju, Hyderabad<br />
When animals or men are<br />
infertile, artificial insemination is<br />
resorted to produce a progeny.<br />
Also in animal breeding<br />
improvements are effected by<br />
artificial insemination by using<br />
semen from the best breed of the<br />
species. Similarly, it may be<br />
worthwhile that the Dynasty be<br />
asked to improve and upgrade the<br />
caliber of Congressmen. We may<br />
then have a large number of Nehru<br />
-like leaders. <strong>Th</strong>ere can still be<br />
doubt whether it will be the Nehru -<br />
like generation or Firoz Gandhi type<br />
of generation that would ensue. Yet,<br />
it may be worthwhile so that the<br />
National Congress of more than 100<br />
years history is rejuvenated.<br />
* * *<br />
Ethnic Cleansing In J&K<br />
Sowmya <strong>Th</strong>omas, Kajipet<br />
Let us be truthful. Ethnic<br />
cleansing has been the continuous<br />
and open practice in Muslim<br />
majority areas in this Indian subcontinent<br />
when once the Moslems<br />
are empowered to do so.<br />
Pakistan’s 18% Hindu -Muslim<br />
population in 1947 has been<br />
cleansed down to about 1% now.<br />
Bangladesh’ s Hindu-Buddhist<br />
population has been cleansed from<br />
13% to 9%. In the Kashmir Valley<br />
within India, through terrorism<br />
almost all the Hindus have been<br />
ethnically cleansed and they are<br />
refugees in other places in India.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e same exercise not being<br />
carried out in the Hindu majority<br />
Jammu and Buddhist majority<br />
Laddakh. <strong>Th</strong>ese two areas are<br />
having to suffer ethnic cleansing<br />
because thy are part of the over<br />
all Muslim majority J&K State.<br />
Muslims and Christians have<br />
become Chief Ministers and<br />
Governors of Hindu majority States<br />
but no Hindu has become either<br />
a CM in a Christian or Muslim<br />
majority State in this country.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e BJP –led coalition had<br />
been in power for almost six years<br />
between 1998-2004. From the Jana<br />
Sangh days onwards, the<br />
widespread demand of Hindus has<br />
been that unless Jammu and<br />
Laddakh are given autonomy like<br />
J&K or unless they are separated<br />
out into a Jammu State which<br />
has clear Hindu majority and<br />
Laddakh a Buddhist majority area<br />
as a Union Territory, the Hindus<br />
and Buddhists would become<br />
minority very soon in Jammu and<br />
laddakh areas also. Did the BJPled<br />
NDA government do anything<br />
to avert this calamity which has<br />
been afflicting the Hindus and<br />
Buddhists in J&K since the 1950s.<br />
Is it that only when the BJP<br />
is out of power it would talk of<br />
ending the temporary Art-370 and<br />
fully integrate J&K with the rest<br />
of the country? Is it that only<br />
when it is out of power, it will<br />
agitate about the peril of ethnic<br />
cleansing in Jammu and Laddakh?<br />
It is unfortunate that the BJP in<br />
power has not even attempted to<br />
what it advocated and stood for<br />
over for five decades.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ere are several BJP-ruled<br />
States some of them with more<br />
than two thirds majority. Within<br />
the powers that are available in<br />
the realm of the State, why does<br />
not the BJP implement its policies<br />
14 “<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006
in regard to protection of Hindu<br />
temples; conversions; reclaiming<br />
Hindus temples converted into<br />
mosques; promote Sanskrit and<br />
true history of India in the<br />
schools in their States? Why<br />
don’t they start National<br />
Universities which will bring out<br />
the true history and culture of<br />
India through the ages instead<br />
of the history being manufactured<br />
in the Marxist madrasas, by its<br />
Imams namely the Jawaharlal<br />
Nehru University and its “eminent”<br />
historians.<br />
If the BJP is to espouse the<br />
principles and the ideologies for<br />
which it was founded only when<br />
it is in the opposition, and not<br />
implement them when in power,<br />
then it is no different from the<br />
Congress party. <strong>Th</strong>roughout the<br />
history of India Hindus had been<br />
betrayed by Hindus. <strong>Th</strong>at is how<br />
this country fell prey to foreign<br />
rule.<br />
* * *<br />
Sonia’s Spin Doctors<br />
Lingam Yadav, Hyderabad<br />
<strong>Th</strong>e petrol and kerosene prices<br />
are to be increased, quite<br />
justifiably. <strong>Th</strong>e Petroleum Minister<br />
increased them by a certain<br />
amount against which the non-<br />
Congress parties mainly the CPM<br />
and some regional parties like<br />
TDP are holding demonstrations<br />
and haranguing denunciations.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>en there is an appeal to Her<br />
Majesty Sonia Gandhi, the<br />
Supremo of the Congress (and<br />
of the country courtesy CPM).<br />
Her heart bleeds at the extra<br />
burden imposed by a thoughtless<br />
and heartless Minister. She<br />
imperiously tells the government<br />
to reduce the increases by a<br />
rupee.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>is is very good drama. Her<br />
Majesty, Soniaji sees in some of<br />
her Ministers capitalist stooges<br />
and even agents of the World<br />
Bank. <strong>Th</strong>e great and<br />
compassionate Sonia is for the<br />
people, for the poor owners of<br />
automobiles and poor and downtrodden<br />
kerosene users. So in a<br />
dramatic way, the people’s burden<br />
is reduced by an appeal to her.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>at is how a legend and<br />
mystique is built around this great,<br />
silent, unaccountable queen<br />
mother of this country. Indira<br />
Gandhi used to reshuffle her<br />
Cabinet very frequently for dropping<br />
some and picking up some others<br />
conveying the message that she<br />
wants to do good but what can<br />
she do if the men in her flock<br />
are useless. Soniaji has taken a<br />
great lesson from the great Indira<br />
Gandhi.<br />
* * *<br />
Create a Sindhu State<br />
Pradip Jain, RR Dist<br />
When the partition of India to<br />
create the Islamic State of Pakistan<br />
became inevitable, leaders like<br />
Shyama Prasad Mukherji said that<br />
if Jinnah divides India, we will divide<br />
Pakistan i.e Punjab and Bengal,<br />
whole of each of which Jinnah was<br />
claiming for Pakistan. So we have<br />
saved for India the Punjab and West<br />
Bengal States which had Hindu-Sikh<br />
majorities. It was unfortunate that<br />
the leaders at the time of partition<br />
did not like -wise think of dividing<br />
Sindh which also had a few districts<br />
with Hindu majority. Notable<br />
among them is the <strong>Th</strong>ar Parkar<br />
District. Its population was 90%<br />
Hindu. which It is adjacent to the<br />
Kutch area of Gujarat and<br />
Rajasthan. Just as Punjab and<br />
Bengal were divided to salvage the<br />
Hindu districts we should have<br />
insisted to get <strong>Th</strong>ar Parkar and<br />
called eh east Sindh state eastern<br />
Sindh, just as we are having West<br />
Bengal. Chittagoan was not a<br />
Muslim majority but an<br />
overwhelmingly Buddhist majority<br />
area in east Pakistan, now<br />
Bangladesh. It is adjacent to<br />
Triupura. <strong>Th</strong>e Indian leaders did not<br />
have the foresight and the boldness<br />
and integrity to demand that<br />
Chittagaon should become part of<br />
Tripura.<br />
No borders are permanent. We<br />
must hope that one day a strong<br />
resurgent nationalist India will<br />
reclaim both <strong>Th</strong>ar Parkar and<br />
Chittagaon for India. In the mean<br />
while, it would be most patriotic to<br />
create Sindh state comprising of<br />
Kutch and Anjar in Gujarat. <strong>Th</strong>e<br />
Sindhu -Saraswathi Valleys area<br />
was the mother of Vedic civilization.<br />
In order to keep our memories<br />
undying, it is great that during NDA<br />
rule an annual festival, “Sindhu<br />
Darshan” was initiated and Indians<br />
are going to that portion of the river<br />
Sindhu which is flowing through<br />
Kashmir. Similarly, the creation of<br />
a Sindhu state would keep up our<br />
historic links and memories with<br />
the birth of our Vedic civilization.<br />
Luckily, most people in Kutch and<br />
around speak Sindhi as well as<br />
Gujarat. And Gujarat has a<br />
nationalist government under the<br />
leadership of Sri Narendra Modi.<br />
Patriotic people should demand<br />
that just as new states Uttaranchal<br />
and Chattisghar and Jharkhand<br />
(Telengana, in future) are created,<br />
a new state East Sindh should be<br />
created and in that process,<br />
Gujarat State Assembly must pass<br />
a resolution in favour of the creation<br />
of the new state and request the<br />
center to complete the necessary<br />
formalities.<br />
All Sindhi people in India and<br />
outside the country must unitedly<br />
work for the creation of a Sindh<br />
state. In our National Anthem the<br />
second area to be mentioned is<br />
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong>, July 2006 15
“<strong>Secularism</strong>” <strong>Combat</strong> July, 2006 Postal Regd. No. H/SD-06/06-08<br />
Sindh and it ill behooves us not to have a Sindhu<br />
state of which we are singing in the National<br />
Anthem.<br />
* * *<br />
Backwardness of the OBCs<br />
G Padma Reddy, Hyderabad<br />
Sri Jamal Ansari (an indefatigable Islamist<br />
intellectual, a former professor) faults (Pioneer<br />
06/06/06) Brahmins for the backwardness of the<br />
OBCs . He says that the Brahmins got various<br />
positions of power reserved for themselves . But<br />
did not the Muslims, a small minority get all<br />
superior positions when they ruled this country<br />
for hundreds of years? For example; in the<br />
Nizams’ dominions Muslims were only 9%. Over<br />
90% of all jobs were open to them only. Not<br />
Telugu, not Marathi, not Kannada languages of<br />
90% of the people was the medium of instruction<br />
even at the primary school stage. It was Urdu all<br />
the way from primary to the university. <strong>Th</strong>is is<br />
the worst inequality and discrimination that was<br />
practised by help of the sword by Muslims in<br />
India. And now they say they are backward<br />
and that positions in government including the<br />
armed forces and admissions to educational<br />
institutions and representation in Legislatures<br />
should be on the basis of the population of these<br />
backwards. <strong>Th</strong>eir backwardness is in fact due to<br />
large families, madrassa and not modern<br />
education and no interest in educating the girl<br />
children.<br />
<strong>Th</strong>ere was no caste discrimination by<br />
Brahmins on other castes namely OBCs in<br />
Hinduism. Castes, in the past were based on<br />
professions; they were hereditary because of<br />
frozen technologies, non-urbanisation and brutal<br />
rule of aliens and their converted stooges and<br />
centuries-long resistance to whom did not<br />
conduce to social, economic and cultural<br />
developments and reforms. Hinduism’s sin was<br />
foisting untouchability and denying the right to<br />
education to the SCs. For this crime, they<br />
are paying reparations by giving reservations.<br />
Neither against the OBCs nor against the<br />
To<br />
disadvantageous discrimination. It is obvious from what Ansari<br />
writes that people of his like and converts to Christianity are<br />
wanting to inflame inter-caste strife and thereby disintegrate<br />
the Hindu society and country .<br />
It is ridiculous for him to fault the doctors for the death of<br />
many a patient in the hospitals. By that same standard, can<br />
Jamal Ansari and Muslims of his thinking be blamed and<br />
condemned for the death and destruction that Islamic jihadi<br />
terrorists are causing in this country and elsewhere in the<br />
world? Have these Ansaris ever advised, much less organized<br />
any movement against the Muslim terrorists carrying out<br />
the ethnic cleansing of Hindu Pandits from Kashmir ?<br />
* * *<br />
Jana Vignana Vedika and Fish<br />
Medicine for Asthma<br />
Smt T Mani <strong>Chowdary</strong>, Secunderabad<br />
Jana Vignan Vedika (JVV), a front organisation of<br />
Communist Parties in AP has held several press<br />
conferences and issued statements ridiculing the unscientific<br />
nature of the fish medicine administered for Asthma<br />
patients in Hyderabad, year after year. Yet the popular<br />
belief in this cure remains unabated.<br />
It is however strange that while the JVV characterizes<br />
the fish medicine as unscientific, its leaders tout “Marxism<br />
and Communism as Scientific Socialism”. In science,<br />
words have got definite meanings and the properties of<br />
the matter described by science are unique and can be<br />
verified anywhere in the world. But can the JVV or its<br />
principals, the communists explain the scientific nature<br />
of socialism as practised in the former USSR, Peoples<br />
Republic of China, North Korea, Cuba, Vietnam and now<br />
in Venuzvela. JVV’s idea of science is as phoney as<br />
Socialism of the Marxist/Communist variety. ✰<br />
* * *<br />
Muslims did the Hindus practise<br />
.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
All Copy rights renounced to facilitate propagation of facts and truth. Articles in the Journal may be freely reproduced.<br />
Just give credit to the Journal(s)<br />
Printed and Owned by <strong>Dr</strong>. T.H. <strong>Chowdary</strong> and Edited & Published by him from Plot No. 8, P & T Colony, Karkhana, Secunderabad - 500009.<br />
Telephone : +91 (40) 2784-6137, Fax : +91 (40) 2789-6103, E-mail : thc@satyam.com<br />
Printed at Baabu Printers, Hyderabad. Ph: (0) 92 465 07989