27.10.2013 Views

ANNUAL ACTIVITY REPORT FOR 2011 - Gamesa

ANNUAL ACTIVITY REPORT FOR 2011 - Gamesa

ANNUAL ACTIVITY REPORT FOR 2011 - Gamesa

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE<br />

COMMITTEE OF GRUPO GAMESA<br />

<strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>ACTIVITY</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />

<strong>FOR</strong> <strong>2011</strong><br />

March 21, 2012


AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE OF GRUPO GAMESA<br />

Annual report on the activities of Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee for <strong>2011</strong>, drawn up at its meeting held on<br />

March 20, 2012 and approved by the Board of Directors of <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />

Corporación Tecnológica, S.A. at its meeting held on March 21,<br />

2012 in accordance with Article 18 of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación<br />

Tecnológica S.A.’s Board of Directors Regulations and Article 11 of<br />

<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee Regulations.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

2


TABLE OF CONTENTS – THE AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE<br />

A- Introduction<br />

B- The Committee’s Relevant Data - <strong>2011</strong><br />

C- Composition<br />

D- Profiles of the Committee’s Members and Secretary<br />

E- Meetings Held in <strong>2011</strong> (Activities)<br />

F- Functions Performed in <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Functions Concerning External Auditing<br />

• Functions Concerning the Company’s Management and the Internal<br />

Control and Risk Management Systems<br />

• Functions Concerning Processes to Draw Up Economic and Financial<br />

Reporting<br />

• Functions Concerning the General Meeting<br />

• Functions Concerning the Corporate Governance Area and Other<br />

Functions<br />

• Functions Concerning Internal Auditing<br />

G- Conclusion<br />

H- Lines of Action Foreseen for 2012<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

3


A.- INTRODUCTION<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica S.A.<br />

(hereinafter indistinctly referred to either as the “Company” or as “<strong>Gamesa</strong>”) has<br />

drawn up this Annual Activity Report for <strong>2011</strong> so that it may be placed at the<br />

shareholders’ disposal for the General Shareholders’ Meeting after its approval by<br />

the Board of Directors, as set forth in Article 18 of the Board of Directors<br />

Regulations and in Article 11 of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s<br />

Regulations. It consists of a summary of the work performed by the Committee.<br />

The Committee’s basic organizational and operational scheme is determined by<br />

both the Corporate Bylaws (Article 43) and the Board of Directors Regulations<br />

(Article 18). In its constant adaptation to the rules and recommendations of good<br />

governance, it has had its own regulations since 2004.<br />

At its own initiative and exercising the powers vested in it, the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee within this context proceeded to draft the revised text of its<br />

own Regulations in <strong>2011</strong>, which were approved by a resolution of the Board of<br />

Directors on April 15, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

The amendment of the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations was<br />

convenient in order to incorporate the legislative amendments that had come<br />

about, which in turn led to the approval by <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s Board of Directors of the<br />

Revised Text of the Board of Directors Regulations at its meeting held on<br />

December 15, 2010. All of the above was done within the framework of continuing<br />

to enhance the Company’s Rules of Corporate Governance by adapting them to the<br />

most widespread trends and practices in the markets.<br />

Following the practice that had already been put into place in preceding years,<br />

<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Audit and Compliance Committee is<br />

submitting and publicly disclosing its Annual Activity Report for <strong>2011</strong>, thereby<br />

meeting the requirements of best practices and contributing to the ratification of<br />

the trust that has been placed on our organization by its stakeholders, particularly<br />

the Spanish and international markets. The Report has been published since 2005,<br />

and this is its eight edition.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

4


Like in preceding years, the Audit and Compliance Committee’s members have<br />

maintained a high level of activity and dedication in <strong>2011</strong>, as is evidenced by the<br />

fact that they held ten (10) meetings, each of which lasted an average of between<br />

three to four hours.<br />

We will report on the activities performed the throughout year in this Annual<br />

Report, which aims to summarize the activities carried out by Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee over the entire course of the year to fulfill its obligations in<br />

the different spheres within its competence, including among others: (i)<br />

supervision of periodic publicly available financial and economic reporting; (ii)<br />

overseeing relevant risks; (iii) compliance with the rules and corporate<br />

governance; and (iv) monitoring the independence of the external auditors of<br />

accounts.<br />

In any case, it should be stated that setting an effective internal control system<br />

does not in itself ensure the attainment of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s<br />

strategic objectives. It does, however, ensure an appropriate internal control<br />

structure that reduces the likelihood of decisions and procedures existing which are<br />

not in line with the guidelines and criteria set by the Board of Directors.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

5


B.- THE COMMITTEE’S RELEVANT DATA - <strong>2011</strong><br />

Meetings 10<br />

Reports/Notices to the Board of Directors<br />

19<br />

Appearances of Senior Management 28<br />

Appearances of external professionals 5<br />

Number of notices filed before the National<br />

Securities Market Commission on relevant<br />

disclosures regarding the Committee’s activities<br />

8<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee’s members attended all the meetings held in<br />

<strong>2011</strong>.<br />

A report for the Board of Directors is drawn up at the end of each meeting of the<br />

Audit and Compliance Committee in order to bring the most significant matters and<br />

conclusions regarding the points dealt with on the relevant agenda before the<br />

Board. The reports and notices brought before the Board of Directors by the Audit<br />

and Compliance Committee are the result of its analyses during the course of such<br />

meetings. Whenever it is considered necessary, the organization’s Senior<br />

Management, its other executives, its external auditors and other external<br />

independent professionals are called upon to appear before a plenary meeting of<br />

the Audit and Compliance Committee, as is the work performed by the Internal<br />

Auditing unit, an area functionally dependent on the Committee.<br />

Within the context of the Board of Directors’ assessment process and that of its<br />

Committees, which began in previous years, the Audit and Compliance Committee,<br />

at its meeting held on May 5, <strong>2011</strong>, resolved to bring before the Board of Directors<br />

for its approval at the Board meeting held on May 25, <strong>2011</strong> a report on the way it<br />

is run in order to evaluate the quality of its work, assess the efficiency of its rules<br />

and, if necessary, correct any aspects that turned out to be barely functional.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

6


C.- COMPOSITION<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee is an internal body of the Board of Directors<br />

made up of at least three and at most five Non-Executive Directors, one of whom<br />

must be an Independent Director. The Board of Directors will endeavor to ensure<br />

that the members of the Audit and Compliance Committee, and particularly the<br />

Independent Director appointed to it, have knowledge and experience of<br />

accounting, auditing or risk management matters.<br />

The composition, status and offices of the Audit and Compliance Committee as of<br />

December 31, <strong>2011</strong> are set out below:<br />

Chairman: Mr. José María Vázquez Egusquiza Non-Executive Independent<br />

Director<br />

Members: Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso Non-Executive Nominee Director<br />

Mr. Luis Lada Díaz Non-Executive Independent Director<br />

Secretary: Mr. Carlos Rodríguez-Quiroga Menéndez (Non-member)<br />

All the members of the Committee are deemed as Non-Executive Directors on the<br />

basis of their experience, training, professionalism and efficacy, and those<br />

classified as “Independent” meet the requirements of independence set forth in<br />

Article 8 of the Board of Directors Regulations.<br />

At its meeting held on December 14, <strong>2011</strong>, <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica,<br />

S.A.’s Board of Directors accepted the resignation tendered by Mr. Pedro Velasco<br />

Gómez as a member of Board and of the Audit and Compliance Committee and<br />

resolved to appoint Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso as a member of the Board’s Audit<br />

and Compliance Committee within the category of Non-Executive Nominee<br />

Directors after having duly received a report from the Appointments and<br />

Remuneration Committee.<br />

The profiles of each of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s members are set out<br />

further below and show that each of them possesses the knowledge and expertise<br />

needed to efficiently perform the responsibilities entrusted to them.<br />

<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Corporate Bylaws and Board of Directors<br />

Regulations promote the Audit and Compliance Committee’s independence by<br />

setting forth that it should be comprised of Non-Executive Directors and above all<br />

to fulfill the Recommendations on the Audit Committee set forth by the Unified<br />

Code of Good Governance under the terms which appear in the Company’s Annual<br />

Corporate Governance Report, which has been approved and published.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

7


D.- PROFILES OF THE COMMITTEE’S MEMBERS AND SECRETARY<br />

Mr. José María Vázquez Egusquiza<br />

Mr. José María Vázquez Egusquiza was born in Bilbao in the province of Vizcaya<br />

and is currently a member of the Board of Directors and the Chairman of GAMESA<br />

CORPORACIÓN TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.’s Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />

He holds degrees in Industrial Metallurgy and Business Studies from the<br />

Universidad del País Vasco and completed his studies doing several Masters in the<br />

United States and Sweden.<br />

His professional career has mainly taken place in the metallurgical sector. He<br />

began his career in Babcock and Wilcox, S.A. as a materials and welding engineer<br />

in the valve department for nuclear power plants. He then went on to hold<br />

management positions in different business groups in the Basque Country<br />

dedicated to the metallurgical, machine tools, shipping and construction sectors.<br />

More specifically, he is currently the Chairman of the Bizkaia Business<br />

Confederation (Confederación Empresarial de Bizkaia – CEBEK), the Chairman of<br />

the Board of Directors of GIROA (Grupo Dalkia), a Director of the Bilbao Port<br />

Authority, a member of the Strategy Committee of the IK4 Research Alliance and a<br />

member of the Board and of the Strategy Committee of the Gipuzkoa Technical<br />

Studies and Research Center (Centro de Estudios e Investigaciones Técnicas de<br />

Gipuzkoa – CEIT).<br />

He has also held the offices, among others, of Chairman of CONFEBASK’s<br />

Industrial Policy Committee, member of the Management Board of the Spanish<br />

Confederation of Business Organizations (Confederación Española de<br />

Organizaciones Empresariales – CEOE), Chairman of the CEOE’s Business Board for<br />

the Information Society, Director of the Biscay Industrial Design Centre (Centro de<br />

Diseño Industrial de Bizkaia), member of the Executive Committee of the Spanish<br />

Association for the Development of Welding (Asociación Española para el<br />

Desarrollo de la Soldadura) and member of the SEOPAN Management Board.<br />

He has been fully involved in teaching and awareness-raising activities.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

8


Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso<br />

Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso was born in Segovia and is currently a member of<br />

GAMESA CORPORACIÓN TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.’s Board of Directors, Executive<br />

Committee and Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />

She holds a degree in Economics and Business Studies granted by the Universidad<br />

Autónoma de Madrid.<br />

She subsequently did post-graduate courses at institutions like the ICEA, the IESE<br />

or the Center for Financial Studies. Additionally, she is a qualified Quality<br />

Assurance Officer, a Certified Internal Auditor and a Certified Fraud Examiner.<br />

Her professional career has essentially taken place in the field of internal auditing<br />

at companies like Repsol YPF, S.A. (1995-1999), Holcim (Spain), S.A. (1999-2008)<br />

and Iberdrola (2008-<strong>2011</strong>). She is currently the Head of Internal Auditing of<br />

Iberdrola, S.A.’s Renewable Energy Business.<br />

She has been a Member of the Institute of Internal Auditors’ Steering Committee<br />

since May 2007, the Secretary General of its Steering Committee since May 2009<br />

and the Secretary and a Member of its Audit Committee since November <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

Over the course of her career, she has published articles, given lectures and taught<br />

as a professor of the “Creation and Management of an Internal Auditing<br />

Department” seminar since 2009.<br />

Mr. Luis Lada Díaz<br />

Mr. Luis Lada Díaz was born in Mieres, Asturias and is currently a member of the<br />

Board of Directors, of the Executive Committee and of the Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee of GAMESA CORPORACIÓN TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.<br />

He holds a Telecommunications Engineering Degree from the Universidad<br />

Politécnica de Madrid, where he is an Honorary Professor, and is also a full<br />

member of the Royal Academy of Engineering.<br />

After a brief spell at the Council for Scientific Research (Consejo Superior de<br />

Investigaciones Científicas), he joined Telefónica’s Research and Studies Center in<br />

1973 and spent most of his professional career at Telefónica. He was appointed<br />

General Manager for Planning and Technology in 1984, a position of maximum<br />

technical responsibility. He then went on to work for Grupo Amper between 1989<br />

and 1993 as General Planning and Control Manager, after which he rejoined<br />

Telefónica, holding responsibility for its Group of Subsidiaries and Associate<br />

Companies. He was appointed as the Chairman of Telefónica Móviles Spain In<br />

1994 and in August of 2000 went on to become a Director of Telefónica, S.A., a<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

9


member of its Executive Committee and the Executive Chairman of Telefónica<br />

Móviles S.A. In August 2003, he became the head of Grupo Telefónica’s<br />

Development, Planning and Regulation Division and was the Executive Chairman of<br />

Telefónica de España between December 2005 and July 2006.<br />

He is currently the Director General of Ribafuerte S.L., as well as a Director of<br />

Indra Sistemas, Telefónica I+D and Ydilo AVS. He is also a member of the Círculo<br />

de Empresarios and of the Bankinter Innovation Foundation, and an advisor to<br />

Telefónica, Teldat and ASSISA Inc.<br />

He has been a member of the Governing Board and Deputy Chairman of the<br />

Spanish Association of Telecommunications Engineers, as well as a director in a<br />

variety of companies in the information technologies sector. Mr. Lada Díaz has<br />

additionally received several professional and business awards.<br />

Mr. Carlos Rodríguez-Quiroga Menéndez<br />

Mr. Carlos Rodríguez-Quiroga Menéndez was born in Madrid. He currently holds<br />

the offices of Member and Secretary to the Board of Directors and Non-Voting<br />

Secretary of the Executive Committee, of the Audit and Compliance Committee and<br />

of the Appointments and Remuneration Committee of GAMESA CORPORACIÓN<br />

TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.<br />

He holds a Law Degree from the Universidad Complutense de Madrid.<br />

He is a Diploma holder of Employment Law from the Legal Practice School of<br />

Madrid.<br />

He has also been granted Diplomas in Comparative Industrial Relations and in<br />

European Community Relations from the Secretariat of State for Relations with the<br />

European Community.<br />

He is a practicing lawyer.<br />

Over the last few years, he has held the offices of Director or of Secretary to the<br />

Board of Directors, among other positions, in the following companies: Audiovisual<br />

Española 2000, S.A., Diver Karting, S.L. and Rodríguez-Quiroga Abogados, S.L. He<br />

is likewise a Trustee of the Spain-Equatorial Guinea Foundation.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

10


E.- MEETINGS HELD IN <strong>2011</strong> (ACTIVITIES)<br />

The meetings held throughout <strong>2011</strong> and the main issues dealt with in them were<br />

as follows:<br />

January 25, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Risk Management and Control System: Technology risks.<br />

• Analysis of the tax and legal situation.<br />

• Forecast on the FY 2010 year-end.<br />

February 22, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• External Auditors: Presentation on the work performed on the 2010<br />

annual accounts.<br />

• Information on the FY 2010 year-end to be filed before the National<br />

Securities Market Commission.<br />

• Analysis of the individual and consolidated accounts, as well as of the<br />

management report and the allocation of profits corresponding to the<br />

accounts to be drawn up by the Board of Directors.<br />

• Dividend policy.<br />

• Market presentation on the FY 2010 year-end.<br />

• Annual Corporate Governance Report 2010.<br />

• Summary of Internal Auditing activities in 2010, proposal for the Internal<br />

Auditing Plan <strong>2011</strong> and the Committee’s Work Plan.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

11


March 22, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Work in progress in wind and solar farm development and sales.<br />

• Analysis of the Risk Management and Control System: Updating of the<br />

risk map.<br />

• The Audit and Compliance Committee’s Activity Report.<br />

• Corporate Defense: Criminal Prevention and Anti-Fraud Policy.<br />

• Proposal to amend the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations.<br />

April 7, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Presentation of the bids submitted by the external auditing firms invited<br />

to take part in the tender to appoint the auditors of accounts.<br />

April 15, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Risk Management and Control System: G10X Platform Business Plan.<br />

• Sustainability report.<br />

• Appointment proposal on the external auditors of accounts.<br />

• Proposal to amend the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations.<br />

• Preliminary review of the Board of Directors’ resolutions on the agenda<br />

for the General Shareholders’ Meeting affecting the Committee.<br />

May 5, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Legal surveillance and control program.<br />

• Operational audit: Provision for wind turbine warranties.<br />

• Reporting to be filed before the National Securities Market Commission<br />

(CNMV) and market presentation for the first quarter of <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

July 21, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Presentation by the external auditors on the work done to conduct a<br />

limited review on the interim consolidated financial statements for the<br />

first half of <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

12


• Presentation on the information to be filed before the National<br />

Securities Market Commission (CNMV) and market presentation for the<br />

first half of <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

• Half-yearly report of the Legal Compliance Unit.<br />

• Proposal to update the “Regulatory Framework Governing the<br />

Relationships between the Audit and Compliance Committee and the<br />

Auditors of Accounts”.<br />

• Transaction with a significant shareholder.<br />

September 20, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• External auditors’ presentation on the procedures they have<br />

implemented to safeguard their independence from the organization<br />

audited.<br />

• Study of draft Internal Rules of Conduct Regarding the Securities<br />

Markets and of the Code of Conduct.<br />

• Analysis of the legal and tax situation.<br />

November 8, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• Risk Management and Control System: Updating of the risk map.<br />

• Audit on the obligatory information to be posted on the website.<br />

• Reporting to be filed before the National Securities Market Commission<br />

(CNMV) corresponding to the third quarter of <strong>2011</strong> and market<br />

presentation.<br />

• Internal Rules of Conduct Regarding the Securities Markets and Code<br />

of Conduct.<br />

December 13, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />

• External Auditors: Most relevant aspects identified in their preliminary<br />

work.<br />

• External Auditors: Analysis of the memorandum of recommendations.<br />

• Half-yearly report of the Legal Compliance Unit.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

13


F.- FUNCTIONS PER<strong>FOR</strong>MED IN <strong>2011</strong><br />

Without prejudice to other tasks it may be assigned with by the Board, the<br />

Corporate Bylaws, the Board of Directors Regulations and the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee Regulations (hereinafter “ACCR”) set forth several basic<br />

responsibilities for the Committee, which can be summarized as a series of<br />

functions concerning:<br />

External Auditing. (Art. 6 of the ACCR)<br />

Internal Auditing. (Art. 7 of the ACCR)<br />

Process to draw up economic and financial reporting. (Art. 8 of the ACCR)<br />

Internal control and risk management systems. (Art. 9 of the ACCR)<br />

Corporate Governance and other functions. (Articles. 10 and 11 of the<br />

ACCR)<br />

General Shareholders’ Meeting<br />

The most significant functions/activities performed in this context by the<br />

Committee in <strong>2011</strong> are summarized below:<br />

F.1.- Functions Concerning External Auditing.<br />

In accordance with the Committee’s internal regulations, it has been assigned<br />

responsibilities concerning the following matters, among others:<br />

- Proposing the appointment of the external auditors of accounts, as<br />

well as their contracting conditions, the scope of their professional<br />

mandate and, should it be the case, their renewal, dismissal or nonrenewal<br />

to the Board of Directors for submission to the General<br />

Shareholders’ Meeting.<br />

- Ensuring the external auditors’ independence and, for such purpose,<br />

ensuring that the Company, its group and the external auditors<br />

comply with prevailing legislation on the provision of services other<br />

than auditing services, the concentration constraints on the auditors’<br />

business and, in general terms, any other rules laid down to ensure<br />

the external auditors’ independence.<br />

- Maintaining the relationship with the external auditors to receive<br />

information on any matters that could place their independence at<br />

risk and regarding any other matters connected with the performance<br />

of the account auditing process, as well as on any other disclosures<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

14


laid down by account auditing legislation and technical auditing<br />

standards.<br />

- Serving as a channel of communications between the Board of<br />

Directors and the auditors, assessing the results of each audit and<br />

the responses of the management team to their recommendations<br />

and mediating in the event of discrepancies between the auditors<br />

and the management team regarding the standards and criteria that<br />

should apply to draw up the financial statements.<br />

- Reviewing the contents of the audit reports before issuing them,<br />

endeavoring to ensure that such contents and the opinions expressed<br />

therein about the annual accounts are drafted clearly, accurately and<br />

without qualifications.<br />

- Ensuring that the consolidated group’s external auditors take on the<br />

responsibility of auditing the companies that comprise it.<br />

- Receiving written confirmation on an annual basis from the auditors<br />

of accounts of their independence from the Company and its<br />

reporting group, as well as information on any additional services of<br />

any kind provided to such organizations by the external auditors or to<br />

any company forming part of its group, along with any other<br />

information or documents required by prevailing legislation.<br />

- Issuing a preliminary report on the auditing of accounts on an annual<br />

basis which expresses an opinion on the independence of the<br />

auditors of accounts and on the possible provision of any additional<br />

services by the auditors.<br />

In keeping with the foregoing and in compliance with such responsibilities, the<br />

most significant actions, among others, performed in <strong>2011</strong> are set out below:<br />

- Appointment, Reappointment or Removal<br />

1.- Within such framework and fully respecting the practices of “Good<br />

Governance”, the Committee resolved to rotate the auditing firm and undertook to<br />

lead this process in order to ensure the appointment process’s transparency and<br />

equality.<br />

A tendering procedure was chosen as the most transparent, efficient and equitable<br />

formula in accordance with the existing internal rules set forth in the “Regulatory<br />

Framework Governing the Relationships between the Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee and the External Auditors of Accounts”.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

15


At the meeting held by the Committee on April 15, <strong>2011</strong>, it put forward<br />

PriceWaterhouseCoopers, Auditores, S.L. (hereinafter PwC) as the new auditing<br />

firm for the individual and consolidated annual accounts for the period covering<br />

<strong>2011</strong>-2013 to the Board of Directors for its subsequent submission to the General<br />

Shareholders’ Meeting.<br />

The Committee has played an active role aimed at overseeing the auditing firm’s<br />

transition plan process after its appointment by the General Shareholders’ Meeting<br />

on May 25, <strong>2011</strong> in order to ensure the effective rotation of auditing firms and to<br />

maximize the opportunities offered by the process of change.<br />

- Meetings Held with External Auditors<br />

1.- Deloitte, S.L., the auditing firm responsible for Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s individual and<br />

consolidated accounts for 2010, appeared before the Committee at its meeting<br />

held on February 22, <strong>2011</strong> in order to present the most significant aspects and<br />

conclusions of their auditing work regarding the aforementioned year.<br />

2.- The interim consolidated financial statements of Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong> as of June 30,<br />

<strong>2011</strong>, which were filed before the National Securities Market Commission, were<br />

subjected to a limited review by the external auditors, as were the statements of<br />

the same period in the preceding year. The new external auditors of accounts,<br />

PwC, appeared before the Committee at the meeting held on July 21, <strong>2011</strong> in<br />

order to present the most significant aspects, conclusions and a report on the work<br />

they had performed.<br />

3.- The external auditors also appeared before the Committee at its meeting held<br />

on December 13, <strong>2011</strong> to present the most significant aspects arising from the<br />

preliminary stage of auditing the annual accounts for FY <strong>2011</strong>. This involved<br />

monitoring the external auditors’ work, receiving preliminary reports and an<br />

overview on the external auditing process of the accounts.<br />

4.- Fulfilling the responsibility taken on by the Committee to receive regular reports<br />

from the external auditors on the results of their work, PwC was called upon at the<br />

meeting mentioned in the paragraph above to appear before the Committee at its<br />

meeting to be held on February 21, 2012 – before this Annual Activity Report was<br />

drawn up – to submit their final conclusions on the audit conducted on the<br />

financial statements at the year-end of FY <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

5.- As is indicated further below in this Audit and Compliance Committee Activity<br />

Report, the external auditors appeared before the Committee at its meeting held<br />

on December 13, <strong>2011</strong> to present their recommendations to improve internal<br />

controls resulting from their work as the Group’s auditors of accounts.<br />

6.- In addition, the Chairman of the Audit and Compliance Committee holds work<br />

meetings throughout the year with the external auditors, whenever he may deem<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

16


appropriate, on matters lying within the Committee’s responsibilities. The Chairman<br />

then informs the rest of the Committee’s members about the contents of such<br />

meetings.<br />

- Fees for Auditing Services<br />

The fees for financial auditing services provided to the various companies<br />

comprising Grupo GAMESA and its subsidiaries by the principal auditors and by<br />

other organizations related to them amounted to €1,149,000 in <strong>2011</strong> (€1,434,000<br />

in 2010). Similarly, the fees paid for this same item to other auditors who took part<br />

in auditing several of the group’s different companies amounted to €69,000<br />

(€155,000 in 2010).<br />

In addition, the principal auditors and other organizations linked to them provided<br />

other accounting review and verification services for the amount of €9,000<br />

(€17,000 in 2010), along with the provision of other professional services in <strong>2011</strong><br />

to the different companies comprising the Group for the amount of €35,000<br />

(€266,000 in 2010). Likewise, the fees paid for the services provided by other<br />

auditors that took part in auditing the different companies belonging to the Group<br />

for these same items amounted to €2,161,000 (€2,110,000 in 2010).<br />

- Certifying Independence and Other Aspects<br />

Pursuant to the provisions set forth in the Board of Directors Regulations and in<br />

Article 6 of the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations, “Ensuring” the<br />

external auditors’ independence is among the functions entrusted to the<br />

Committee by the Board of Directors. To such a purpose, it should ensure that the<br />

Company and the external auditors comply with prevailing regulations concerning<br />

the provision of the different auditing services, the concentration limits on the<br />

external auditors’ business and, in general terms, all the other regulations laid<br />

down to ensure the external auditors’ independence.<br />

1.- Within this context, the Audit and Compliance Committee requested the<br />

external auditors to:<br />

* Issue a written statement on their independence from Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />

regarding the performance of the auditing of accounts in accordance with<br />

prevailing legislation, and additionally a confirmation that the amount of the fees<br />

received by the external auditors did not exceed 5% of their total income.<br />

* Issue an additional statement that the services of any kind rendered by<br />

the external auditors other than the auditing of accounts are in accordance with<br />

the provisions set forth in legislation on the auditing of accounts and that they are<br />

not involved in any kind of incompatibility.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

17


2.- Likewise, at the meeting held by the Audit and Compliance Committee on<br />

September 20, <strong>2011</strong>, the external auditors responsible for the individual and<br />

consolidated annual accounts appeared before the Committee at the its request in<br />

order to present any internal procedures they had implemented to safeguard their<br />

independence from the organization being audited, any threats that may<br />

jeopardize their independence and the security measures adopted to mitigate such<br />

factors for the Committee’s subsequent analysis.<br />

3.- In accordance with the internal regulations of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación<br />

Tecnológica, S.A., which are aimed at developing and enhancing Corporate<br />

Governance rules by adjusting them to the most common trends and practices in<br />

the markets, we would like to highlight that the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

issued a preliminary report on the auditing of accounts for the second year in a<br />

row. Such report expresses a favorable opinion on the independence of the<br />

auditors of accounts. It is attached hereto as an Annex.<br />

4.- It should also be highlighted that, over the course of the external auditors’<br />

different appearances, the Committee’s members actively urged the external<br />

auditors to undertake the responsibility of auditing the companies making up the<br />

Group as the consolidated Group’s external auditors. In this regard, once the<br />

necessary scope of the work that would allow the principal auditors to review and<br />

assess the work of other auditors was defined, no constraints were placed on their<br />

responsibility concerning expressing an opinion on the consolidated annual<br />

accounts for <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

F.2.- Functions Concerning the Company’s Management and the Internal<br />

Control and Risk Management Systems<br />

The Committee has been entrusted with the responsibility of overseeing the<br />

efficiency of the Company’s internal control systems and their appropriateness and<br />

integrity with regard to the business’s relevant risks, as well as setting and<br />

reviewing of the risk map and levels the Company considers as acceptable.<br />

The integrated risk management approach adopted by the Group involves a<br />

process in which the Board of Directors, Senior Management and the rest of the<br />

Group’s workforce are involved, and it is in turn integrated into the way corporate<br />

strategy is set.<br />

<strong>Gamesa</strong> uses a Risk/Opportunities Management and Control model across the<br />

entire organization (divisions, departments and companies) that covers all the<br />

geographical areas where it operates to contribute to the attainment of the<br />

Business’s objectives, the creation of shareholder value and sustainable profitable<br />

development.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

18


Within this context, the Committee regularly supervises the internal control and<br />

risk management system in order to ensure the following are identified:<br />

o The different kinds of risks facing the Company, including contingent<br />

liabilities and other out-of-balance risks among the financial and<br />

economic risks;<br />

o The setting of the risk level which the Company considers acceptable;<br />

o The measures foreseen to mitigate the impact of any risks identified<br />

should they come about; and<br />

o The information and internal control systems used to control and<br />

manage the aforementioned risks, including contingent liabilities and<br />

out-of-balance risks.<br />

At its meetings held on March 22 and November 8, the members of the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee assessed the general risks/opportunities map, which<br />

includes the key processes to be monitored, to ensure that the most relevant<br />

aspects that could jeopardize the attainment of the business’s objectives are<br />

monitored on a continuous basis, as they could affect the Company’s economic<br />

profitability, its financial solvency, its corporate reputation, the integrity of its<br />

employees, the environment and compliance with legislation.<br />

The above-mentioned risk and opportunities map was updated before this Activity<br />

Report was drawn up, as it one of the Committee’s periodic activities.<br />

In keeping with the line of action initiated in previous years, the Group’s senior<br />

executives were called upon to make a series of appearances before the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee in <strong>2011</strong> to provide it with an overview of the situation from<br />

their standpoint of the specific risks facing their activities with respect of the<br />

Company’s Strategic Plan.<br />

More specifically, several appearances took place in <strong>2011</strong>, which are described<br />

below:<br />

Date<br />

Date Department Presentation<br />

January 25 Manager of the Tax Area Analysis of the tax situation<br />

January 25 Legal Area Analysis of the legal situation<br />

January 25<br />

January 25<br />

Chief Technology Officer<br />

General Manager of Management Control<br />

Technology risks<br />

Forecast of the FY 2010 year-end<br />

March 22 General Manager of Internal Auditing Work in progress on the promotion and sale of wind farms<br />

March 22<br />

March 22<br />

April 15<br />

May 5<br />

B.R.C.and Internal Auditing Manager<br />

Chief Legal Counsel<br />

Sales and Projects<br />

General Manager of Internal Auditing<br />

Risk control and management system. Risk map<br />

Criminal prevention and anti-fraud policy<br />

Risk control and management system. New Business Plan platforms<br />

Operational audit: Provision for wind turbine warranties<br />

September 20 Manager of the Tax Area<br />

Analysis of the tax situation<br />

September 20 Legal Area<br />

Analysis of the legal situation<br />

November 8 B.R.C.and Internal Auditing Manager Risk control and management system. Risk map<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

19


The Managers of the Tax and Legal Areas appeared before the Committee at its<br />

meetings held on January 25 and September 20, <strong>2011</strong> to inform it of any tax and<br />

legal aspects identified as potential risks for the Group, along with their<br />

occurrence, impact and evolution.<br />

In addition, as indicated above, the external auditors appeared before the<br />

Committee at its meeting held on December 13 in order to present and assess<br />

their internal control recommendations arising from their auditing work and the<br />

management team’s responses.<br />

F.3.- Functions Concerning Economic and Financial Reporting<br />

Overseeing the process used to draw up financial reporting on the Company and<br />

its Group and the integrity of such information, as well as reviewing the<br />

information that the Company periodically and/or obligatorily discloses to the<br />

markets and to their supervisory bodies with the necessary thoroughness to ensure<br />

its accuracy, reliability, sufficiency and clarity are among the most important<br />

functions entrusted to the Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />

The Committee additionally ensures that periodic financial reporting is drawn up<br />

with the same accounting criteria as the annual financial reports. To such a<br />

purpose, it considers the appropriateness of proceeding with a limited half-yearly<br />

review of such reporting by the external auditors, safeguards compliance with legal<br />

requirements and ensures that generally accepted accounting standards are<br />

properly applied, informing the Board of Directors of any significant changes in<br />

accounting criteria.<br />

Its work provides an additional safeguard and foresees any risks that could lead to<br />

the existence of future qualifications resulting from non-compliances with<br />

accounting criteria in the external auditors’ audit report.<br />

For this reason, the activities performed in <strong>2011</strong> included the following, among<br />

others:<br />

1.- The Audit and Compliance Committee holds regular recurrent work meetings<br />

with the General Managers of the Management Control and Internal Auditing Areas<br />

in order to make a preliminary assessment of the economic and financial<br />

information that will be disclosed to the markets and regulatory bodies. At its<br />

meetings held on February 22, May 5, July 21 and November 8, the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee supervised the different presentations made to the market,<br />

as well as the reporting filed before the National Securities Market Commission.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

20


2.- One of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s responsibilities is to supervise<br />

and assess any especially critical processes in the preparation of financial<br />

reporting.<br />

That is why the Manager of Internal Auditing and the General Management of the<br />

Group’s Management Control Area appeared before the Committee at its meetings<br />

held on March 22, May 5, and November 8 in order to set out the most significant<br />

accounting standards applied, as well as any assumptions and estimates made that<br />

had a significant effect on the financial statements.<br />

3.- In addition, opinions were interchanged with the external auditors of accounts<br />

on several occasions in <strong>2011</strong> concerning the application of several accounting<br />

standards under both Spanish and international rules.<br />

F.4.- Functions Concerning the Corporate Governance Area and Other<br />

Functions<br />

- General Shareholders’ Meeting.<br />

Article 43 of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Corporate Bylaws sets forth<br />

the Audit and Compliance Committee’s basic responsibility of informing the General<br />

Shareholders’ Meeting about any matters shareholders may broach at the meeting<br />

concerning the matters that lie within its competence.<br />

At the <strong>2011</strong> General Shareholders’ Meeting, the Annual Activity Report of the Audit<br />

and Compliance Committee was placed at the shareholders’ disposal as in<br />

preceding years. The aim of this is to promote the accountability of the activities<br />

performed during 2010.<br />

The Chairman of the Audit and Compliance Committee attended the <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />

General Shareholders’ Meeting held on May 25, <strong>2011</strong>. The shareholders did not<br />

raise any questions lying within the Committee’s competence.<br />

For its part, Article 21.3 of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s General<br />

Shareholders’ Meeting Regulations sets forth the possibility of the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee’s Chairman reporting or making clarifications in any of the<br />

circumstances laid down by the Law, so as to respond to requests for information<br />

made by shareholders at the General Meeting.<br />

The General Shareholders’ Meeting’s documents remain at the disposal of all<br />

shareholders and the general public on the Company’s website in the “Investors<br />

and Shareholders” section. The contents of such documents comply with the<br />

requirements laid down by Act 26/2003 of July 17 – otherwise known as the<br />

“Transparency Act” –, Ministerial Order ECO 3722/2003 of December 26 and<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

21


Circular 1/2004 of the National Securities Market Commission (CNMV) of March 17,<br />

which was amended by Circular 4/2007.<br />

This eight edition of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s Activity Report will be<br />

made available to shareholders at the General Shareholders’ Meeting to be held in<br />

2012.<br />

- The Audit and Compliance Committee’s Self-Assessment<br />

As in previous years, this Committee issued a report aimed at assessing the way it<br />

functions and the quality of its work in accordance with the internal regulations of<br />

<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A. and in keeping with best practices on<br />

corporate governance. This report allows the Committee to correct any aspects<br />

that may have turned out to be barely functional.<br />

The conclusions set out in this report were debated and unanimously approved by<br />

all the members of the Committee at its meeting held on the May 5, <strong>2011</strong>. It was<br />

then brought before the Board of Directors for its consideration and approved by<br />

means of a Board resolution on May 25, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

The Committee initiated the process aimed at assessing its activities in <strong>2011</strong> before<br />

this Activity Report was drawn up.<br />

- Conflicts of Interest and Transactions with Shareholders Holding<br />

Significant Stakes<br />

According to the Corporate Bylaws, one of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s<br />

basic responsibilities consists of reporting on any transactions that involve or could<br />

potentially involve Conflicts of Interest or any transactions with Shareholders<br />

holding a significant stake. It is also responsible for approving any transactions<br />

that involve a Conflict of Interest or transactions with a Shareholder holding a<br />

significant stake, whenever it is requested to do so by the Board’s Chairman.<br />

For these purposes, the Audit and Compliance Committee assessed the proposals<br />

put forward by Management concerning transactions with a shareholder holding a<br />

significant stake at its meetings held on July 21 and December 13. It issued<br />

favorable reports and subsequently brought them before the Board of Directors.<br />

It should also be pointed out that the Director and Committee member until<br />

December 14, <strong>2011</strong>, Mr. Pedro Velasco Gómez, did not take part in any Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee meetings at which resolutions concerning transactions with<br />

Iberdrola, S.A. and/or companies belonging to its Group (Transactions with<br />

Shareholders Holding Significant Stakes) were deliberated on or approved. He<br />

therefore did not take part in the deliberations, voting, decision-making or<br />

execution of the relevant resolutions.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

22


- Supervision of the Legal Compliance Unit<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee’s responsibility includes overseeing<br />

compliance with the Internal Code of Conduct Regarding the Securities Market,<br />

with the Board of Directors Regulations and, in general terms, with the Company’s<br />

rules of governance, as well as putting forward the proposals needed for their<br />

improvement.<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee is particularly responsible for receiving<br />

information from the Legal Compliance Unit regarding the aforementioned matters<br />

and, if necessary, issuing reports on disciplinary matters to members of the<br />

Company’s Senior Management and Executives for not complying with their<br />

Corporate Governance obligations and/or the Internal Code of Conduct Regarding<br />

the Securities Market, as well as resolving any questions the Legal Compliance Unit<br />

may raise concerning Corporate Governance and its compliance pursuant to the<br />

Internal Code of Conduct Regarding the Securities Market.<br />

In accordance with the provisions set forth in Article 17 of the Internal Code of<br />

Conduct Regarding the Securities Market, the Legal Compliance Unit should<br />

periodically submit a report to the Committee on the application of such rules and<br />

the decisions adopted to put them into practice on at least a half-yearly basis.<br />

Fulfilling this mandate, the Manager of the Legal Compliance Unit appeared before<br />

the Audit and Compliance Committee at its meetings held on July 21 and<br />

December 13 to inform the Committee about the compliance levels of confidential<br />

operations and the registration of securities. A computer solution developed in<br />

previous years is available aimed at the “Automation of the Procedure on<br />

Confidential Operations and the Registration of Securities”.<br />

In this regard, the Audit and Compliance Committee monitors any qualifications<br />

thus observed throughout the year in order to ensure they are suitably corrected.<br />

In addition, <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Code of Conduct lays down<br />

that the Legal Compliance Unit should assess and draw up an annual report on the<br />

level of compliance with the aforementioned Code, which should be filed before<br />

the Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee may receive notices of any breaches from<br />

the Legal Compliance Unit, and it issues the instructions or adopts any measures<br />

that may be necessary.<br />

More specifically, the Manager of the Legal Compliance Unit informed the Audit<br />

and Compliance Committee about the Code of Conduct’s level of compliance at his<br />

appearances before the Committee on July 21 and December 13.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

23


Furthermore, the Legal Compliance Unit is entrusted with implementing and<br />

monitoring the legal surveillance and control program, whose function essentially<br />

consists of safeguarding and mitigating any risks arising from the application of the<br />

legislation on the different sectors to the Company and its Group.<br />

More specifically, the Manager of the Legal Compliance Unit informed the Audit<br />

and Compliance Committee about the effective implementation of the program and<br />

its results at his appearances before the Committee on July 21 and December 13.<br />

Lastly, with respect of the Company’s ethics and compliance plans, the Chief Legal<br />

Counsel set out the work carried out concerning the corporate defense program at<br />

his appearance on March 23, <strong>2011</strong>. He presented a proposal for a Criminal<br />

Prevention and Anti-Fraud Policy and a positive report was issued thereof prior to<br />

its subsequent approval by the Company’s Board of Directors at its meeting held<br />

on March 24, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

- Annual Corporate Governance Report and Sustainability Report<br />

The 2010 Annual Corporate Governance Report was approved and ratified by the<br />

Audit and Compliance Committee at its meeting held on February 22, <strong>2011</strong>. The<br />

Committee unanimously resolved to approve the report and submit it to the Board<br />

of Directors’ consideration, which approved it at its meeting held on February 23,<br />

<strong>2011</strong>. It was the subject of a relevant disclosure filed before the National Securities<br />

Market Commission in accordance with prevailing legislation.<br />

At its meeting held on April 15, the Audit and Compliance Committee examined the<br />

wording given to the matters lying within its competence contained in the <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />

Sustainability Report 2010. The Committee likewise resolved to approve such<br />

matters and bring them before the Board of Directors.<br />

In order to verify the information and contribute to the principle of transparency,<br />

the Spanish Standardization and Certification Association (Asociación Española de<br />

Normalización y Certificación – AENOR) was commissioned to conduct an<br />

independent review of the sustainability report, which received such association’s<br />

conformity.<br />

- The Company’s website<br />

Act 26/2003 on Transparency, which was implemented through Order<br />

ECO/3722/2003 and Circular 1/2004 of the National Securities Market Commission<br />

of March 17, lays down the minimum obligatory reporting contents that the<br />

websites of listed companies should contain. As in the previous years and in<br />

compliance with the mandate issued by the Committee, the Internal Auditing<br />

Department conducted a website audit in 2010 to ensure the minimum legally<br />

required contents were met.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

24


The findings of the aforementioned internal website audit on the “Investors and<br />

Shareholders” section were presented to the Audit and Compliance Committee at<br />

its meeting held on November 8 <strong>2011</strong> and deemed to be satisfactory.<br />

- New Revised Text of the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

Regulations<br />

As a consequence of the legislative amendments which have come about and the<br />

approval by <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s Board of Directors of the Revised Text of the Board of<br />

Directors Regulations at its meeting held on December 15, 2010, it became<br />

necessary to amend certain articles of the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

Regulations. In order to do so and after the appropriate analysis by the Directors,<br />

the members of the Committee drew up a report justifying the amendments at its<br />

meeting held on April 15, <strong>2011</strong> and brought it before the Board of Directors.<br />

Given that a thoroughgoing change of the Regulations was made, such<br />

amendment was deemed as the approval of a revised text of the <strong>Gamesa</strong> Audit<br />

and Compliance Regulations.<br />

Continuing with the process of revising and updating the Company’s internal<br />

regulations, the drafts which updated the Internal Rules of Conduct Regarding the<br />

Securities Markets and the <strong>Gamesa</strong> Code of Conduct were brought before the Audit<br />

and Compliance Committee at its meeting held on September 20, <strong>2011</strong>. After the<br />

relevant contributions were made by the Committee’s members at its meeting held<br />

on October 8, such drafts were brought before the Board of Directors, which<br />

approved both texts at its meeting held on November 10, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

F.5. Functions Concerning Internal Auditing<br />

According to the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations, the Internal<br />

Auditing Department hierarchically reports directly to the Board of Directors and,<br />

on its behalf, to the Board’s Chairman. However, it functionally depends on the<br />

Audit and Compliance Committee. The main function of this Department is to<br />

inform, provide advice and report directly to the aforementioned Committee about<br />

any aspects concerning the internal control system, financial reporting and any<br />

issues lying within the Committee’s competence as regards external auditing, the<br />

annual Corporate Governance Report, the annual Corporate Social Responsibility<br />

Report, third-party transactions that may involve a conflict of interest and<br />

transactions with shareholders holding significant stakes, etc.<br />

The Manager of Internal Auditing attends all of the Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee’s meetings as a guest and appeared before it several times throughout<br />

<strong>2011</strong>, some of which have already been mentioned in this Annual Activity Report.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

25


As a result, the Audit and Compliance Committee has had access to, reviewed and<br />

approved the most relevant reports issued by Internal Auditing Department’s<br />

Management, which place special emphasis on aspects connected with financial<br />

reporting and internal control, as well as on monitoring the implementation of any<br />

recommendations proposed by either the internal or the external auditors.<br />

Subsequently, but before this Activity Report was drawn up, the Manager of<br />

Internal Auditing submitted the findings of the Annual Internal Auditing Activity<br />

Plan for <strong>2011</strong> and the Annual Plan Proposal for 2012, which sets out activities<br />

related to the economic situation’s risks as priority lines of work linked to financial<br />

reporting risks. Within this context, the Audit and Compliance Committee sets its<br />

own Work Plan for 2012.<br />

********************************************************<br />

All the aforementioned activities of the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

throughout the ten meetings it held in <strong>2011</strong> were aimed at making a contribution<br />

to the basic principles adopted by the Board of Directors that lie behind the<br />

functions entrusted to the Committee, which include:<br />

• The efficient functioning of the internal control system for relevant risks<br />

• The reliability of financial reporting<br />

• Compliance with policies, procedures, rules and legal provisions<br />

• Good Corporate Governance<br />

All of the above is aimed at reasonably ensuring the attainment of the objectives<br />

set by the organization in order to preserve the value of its assets and,<br />

consequently, the value of its shareholders’ investment by providing shareholders,<br />

stakeholders and the markets in general with the maximum guarantees.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

26


G.- CONCLUSION<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee deems that is was reasonably informed of all<br />

the issues within its sphere of competence in <strong>2011</strong> and therefore considers that it<br />

satisfactorily fulfilled the responsibilities assigned to it by the Corporate Bylaws, the<br />

Board of Directors Regulations and its own Regulations.<br />

The Committee maintained direct ongoing contact and collaborated with the<br />

Group’s different Divisions, the Legal Compliance Unit and the Internal Auditing<br />

Area, as well as with the external auditors of accounts.<br />

The process aimed at selecting the external auditors of accounts and the<br />

subsequent proposal for the appointment of the auditors of accounts, the<br />

monitoring of their work, the review of their conclusions and the assessment of<br />

their independence have rigorously complied with the strict policies laid down on<br />

such matters. The auditors of accounts’ positive conclusions regarding both the<br />

consolidated annual accounts and interim consolidated financial statements as of<br />

June 30, <strong>2011</strong> endorse the suitability of the financial reporting and internal control<br />

systems for relevant risks.<br />

Lastly, the Committee considered that the Company strictly complied with the rules<br />

and recommendations of good governance.<br />

H.- LINES OF ACTION <strong>FOR</strong>ESEEN <strong>FOR</strong> 2012<br />

New challenges and opportunities face the Committee in the performance of its<br />

functions and responsibilities in 2012. It will therefore keep up the same pace of<br />

activity it has had to date. In this regard, the schedule of meetings set for 2012<br />

includes around ten meetings.<br />

The current economic climate will require special attention to be placed on<br />

financial risks, which will be dealt with preferentially in the Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee’s scheduling.<br />

Likewise, the lines of action foreseen for 2012 will have an incidence on overseeing<br />

the process of drawing up financial and economic reporting.<br />

As a especially relevant function, the Committee will continue to ensure that the<br />

Group and the external auditors of accounts fulfill prevailing rules on the provision<br />

of services other than auditing, the constraints placed on the auditors’ business<br />

and, in general terms, any other rules set to ensure the external auditors’<br />

independence, requesting them to issue the relevant report to the Committee<br />

expressing an opinion on such independence.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

27


On the basis of its contribution to the Company maintaining a high level of<br />

monitoring regarding the best practices of corporate governance, the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee, as in previous years, has established as one of its priorities<br />

the ongoing adaptation to and fulfillment of any recommendations set forth on<br />

such matters<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee’s work and efforts, which are disclosed<br />

throughout this Annual Report, are the best guarantee offered to shareholders<br />

regarding the responsibilities that have been entrusted to it.<br />

Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

28

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!