ANNUAL ACTIVITY REPORT FOR 2011 - Gamesa
ANNUAL ACTIVITY REPORT FOR 2011 - Gamesa
ANNUAL ACTIVITY REPORT FOR 2011 - Gamesa
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE<br />
COMMITTEE OF GRUPO GAMESA<br />
<strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>ACTIVITY</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>FOR</strong> <strong>2011</strong><br />
March 21, 2012
AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE OF GRUPO GAMESA<br />
Annual report on the activities of Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee for <strong>2011</strong>, drawn up at its meeting held on<br />
March 20, 2012 and approved by the Board of Directors of <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />
Corporación Tecnológica, S.A. at its meeting held on March 21,<br />
2012 in accordance with Article 18 of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación<br />
Tecnológica S.A.’s Board of Directors Regulations and Article 11 of<br />
<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Audit and Compliance<br />
Committee Regulations.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS – THE AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE<br />
A- Introduction<br />
B- The Committee’s Relevant Data - <strong>2011</strong><br />
C- Composition<br />
D- Profiles of the Committee’s Members and Secretary<br />
E- Meetings Held in <strong>2011</strong> (Activities)<br />
F- Functions Performed in <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Functions Concerning External Auditing<br />
• Functions Concerning the Company’s Management and the Internal<br />
Control and Risk Management Systems<br />
• Functions Concerning Processes to Draw Up Economic and Financial<br />
Reporting<br />
• Functions Concerning the General Meeting<br />
• Functions Concerning the Corporate Governance Area and Other<br />
Functions<br />
• Functions Concerning Internal Auditing<br />
G- Conclusion<br />
H- Lines of Action Foreseen for 2012<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
3
A.- INTRODUCTION<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica S.A.<br />
(hereinafter indistinctly referred to either as the “Company” or as “<strong>Gamesa</strong>”) has<br />
drawn up this Annual Activity Report for <strong>2011</strong> so that it may be placed at the<br />
shareholders’ disposal for the General Shareholders’ Meeting after its approval by<br />
the Board of Directors, as set forth in Article 18 of the Board of Directors<br />
Regulations and in Article 11 of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s<br />
Regulations. It consists of a summary of the work performed by the Committee.<br />
The Committee’s basic organizational and operational scheme is determined by<br />
both the Corporate Bylaws (Article 43) and the Board of Directors Regulations<br />
(Article 18). In its constant adaptation to the rules and recommendations of good<br />
governance, it has had its own regulations since 2004.<br />
At its own initiative and exercising the powers vested in it, the Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee within this context proceeded to draft the revised text of its<br />
own Regulations in <strong>2011</strong>, which were approved by a resolution of the Board of<br />
Directors on April 15, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
The amendment of the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations was<br />
convenient in order to incorporate the legislative amendments that had come<br />
about, which in turn led to the approval by <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s Board of Directors of the<br />
Revised Text of the Board of Directors Regulations at its meeting held on<br />
December 15, 2010. All of the above was done within the framework of continuing<br />
to enhance the Company’s Rules of Corporate Governance by adapting them to the<br />
most widespread trends and practices in the markets.<br />
Following the practice that had already been put into place in preceding years,<br />
<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Audit and Compliance Committee is<br />
submitting and publicly disclosing its Annual Activity Report for <strong>2011</strong>, thereby<br />
meeting the requirements of best practices and contributing to the ratification of<br />
the trust that has been placed on our organization by its stakeholders, particularly<br />
the Spanish and international markets. The Report has been published since 2005,<br />
and this is its eight edition.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
4
Like in preceding years, the Audit and Compliance Committee’s members have<br />
maintained a high level of activity and dedication in <strong>2011</strong>, as is evidenced by the<br />
fact that they held ten (10) meetings, each of which lasted an average of between<br />
three to four hours.<br />
We will report on the activities performed the throughout year in this Annual<br />
Report, which aims to summarize the activities carried out by Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee over the entire course of the year to fulfill its obligations in<br />
the different spheres within its competence, including among others: (i)<br />
supervision of periodic publicly available financial and economic reporting; (ii)<br />
overseeing relevant risks; (iii) compliance with the rules and corporate<br />
governance; and (iv) monitoring the independence of the external auditors of<br />
accounts.<br />
In any case, it should be stated that setting an effective internal control system<br />
does not in itself ensure the attainment of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s<br />
strategic objectives. It does, however, ensure an appropriate internal control<br />
structure that reduces the likelihood of decisions and procedures existing which are<br />
not in line with the guidelines and criteria set by the Board of Directors.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
5
B.- THE COMMITTEE’S RELEVANT DATA - <strong>2011</strong><br />
Meetings 10<br />
Reports/Notices to the Board of Directors<br />
19<br />
Appearances of Senior Management 28<br />
Appearances of external professionals 5<br />
Number of notices filed before the National<br />
Securities Market Commission on relevant<br />
disclosures regarding the Committee’s activities<br />
8<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee’s members attended all the meetings held in<br />
<strong>2011</strong>.<br />
A report for the Board of Directors is drawn up at the end of each meeting of the<br />
Audit and Compliance Committee in order to bring the most significant matters and<br />
conclusions regarding the points dealt with on the relevant agenda before the<br />
Board. The reports and notices brought before the Board of Directors by the Audit<br />
and Compliance Committee are the result of its analyses during the course of such<br />
meetings. Whenever it is considered necessary, the organization’s Senior<br />
Management, its other executives, its external auditors and other external<br />
independent professionals are called upon to appear before a plenary meeting of<br />
the Audit and Compliance Committee, as is the work performed by the Internal<br />
Auditing unit, an area functionally dependent on the Committee.<br />
Within the context of the Board of Directors’ assessment process and that of its<br />
Committees, which began in previous years, the Audit and Compliance Committee,<br />
at its meeting held on May 5, <strong>2011</strong>, resolved to bring before the Board of Directors<br />
for its approval at the Board meeting held on May 25, <strong>2011</strong> a report on the way it<br />
is run in order to evaluate the quality of its work, assess the efficiency of its rules<br />
and, if necessary, correct any aspects that turned out to be barely functional.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
6
C.- COMPOSITION<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee is an internal body of the Board of Directors<br />
made up of at least three and at most five Non-Executive Directors, one of whom<br />
must be an Independent Director. The Board of Directors will endeavor to ensure<br />
that the members of the Audit and Compliance Committee, and particularly the<br />
Independent Director appointed to it, have knowledge and experience of<br />
accounting, auditing or risk management matters.<br />
The composition, status and offices of the Audit and Compliance Committee as of<br />
December 31, <strong>2011</strong> are set out below:<br />
Chairman: Mr. José María Vázquez Egusquiza Non-Executive Independent<br />
Director<br />
Members: Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso Non-Executive Nominee Director<br />
Mr. Luis Lada Díaz Non-Executive Independent Director<br />
Secretary: Mr. Carlos Rodríguez-Quiroga Menéndez (Non-member)<br />
All the members of the Committee are deemed as Non-Executive Directors on the<br />
basis of their experience, training, professionalism and efficacy, and those<br />
classified as “Independent” meet the requirements of independence set forth in<br />
Article 8 of the Board of Directors Regulations.<br />
At its meeting held on December 14, <strong>2011</strong>, <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica,<br />
S.A.’s Board of Directors accepted the resignation tendered by Mr. Pedro Velasco<br />
Gómez as a member of Board and of the Audit and Compliance Committee and<br />
resolved to appoint Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso as a member of the Board’s Audit<br />
and Compliance Committee within the category of Non-Executive Nominee<br />
Directors after having duly received a report from the Appointments and<br />
Remuneration Committee.<br />
The profiles of each of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s members are set out<br />
further below and show that each of them possesses the knowledge and expertise<br />
needed to efficiently perform the responsibilities entrusted to them.<br />
<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Corporate Bylaws and Board of Directors<br />
Regulations promote the Audit and Compliance Committee’s independence by<br />
setting forth that it should be comprised of Non-Executive Directors and above all<br />
to fulfill the Recommendations on the Audit Committee set forth by the Unified<br />
Code of Good Governance under the terms which appear in the Company’s Annual<br />
Corporate Governance Report, which has been approved and published.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
7
D.- PROFILES OF THE COMMITTEE’S MEMBERS AND SECRETARY<br />
Mr. José María Vázquez Egusquiza<br />
Mr. José María Vázquez Egusquiza was born in Bilbao in the province of Vizcaya<br />
and is currently a member of the Board of Directors and the Chairman of GAMESA<br />
CORPORACIÓN TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.’s Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />
He holds degrees in Industrial Metallurgy and Business Studies from the<br />
Universidad del País Vasco and completed his studies doing several Masters in the<br />
United States and Sweden.<br />
His professional career has mainly taken place in the metallurgical sector. He<br />
began his career in Babcock and Wilcox, S.A. as a materials and welding engineer<br />
in the valve department for nuclear power plants. He then went on to hold<br />
management positions in different business groups in the Basque Country<br />
dedicated to the metallurgical, machine tools, shipping and construction sectors.<br />
More specifically, he is currently the Chairman of the Bizkaia Business<br />
Confederation (Confederación Empresarial de Bizkaia – CEBEK), the Chairman of<br />
the Board of Directors of GIROA (Grupo Dalkia), a Director of the Bilbao Port<br />
Authority, a member of the Strategy Committee of the IK4 Research Alliance and a<br />
member of the Board and of the Strategy Committee of the Gipuzkoa Technical<br />
Studies and Research Center (Centro de Estudios e Investigaciones Técnicas de<br />
Gipuzkoa – CEIT).<br />
He has also held the offices, among others, of Chairman of CONFEBASK’s<br />
Industrial Policy Committee, member of the Management Board of the Spanish<br />
Confederation of Business Organizations (Confederación Española de<br />
Organizaciones Empresariales – CEOE), Chairman of the CEOE’s Business Board for<br />
the Information Society, Director of the Biscay Industrial Design Centre (Centro de<br />
Diseño Industrial de Bizkaia), member of the Executive Committee of the Spanish<br />
Association for the Development of Welding (Asociación Española para el<br />
Desarrollo de la Soldadura) and member of the SEOPAN Management Board.<br />
He has been fully involved in teaching and awareness-raising activities.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
8
Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso<br />
Ms. Sonsoles Rubio Reinoso was born in Segovia and is currently a member of<br />
GAMESA CORPORACIÓN TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.’s Board of Directors, Executive<br />
Committee and Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />
She holds a degree in Economics and Business Studies granted by the Universidad<br />
Autónoma de Madrid.<br />
She subsequently did post-graduate courses at institutions like the ICEA, the IESE<br />
or the Center for Financial Studies. Additionally, she is a qualified Quality<br />
Assurance Officer, a Certified Internal Auditor and a Certified Fraud Examiner.<br />
Her professional career has essentially taken place in the field of internal auditing<br />
at companies like Repsol YPF, S.A. (1995-1999), Holcim (Spain), S.A. (1999-2008)<br />
and Iberdrola (2008-<strong>2011</strong>). She is currently the Head of Internal Auditing of<br />
Iberdrola, S.A.’s Renewable Energy Business.<br />
She has been a Member of the Institute of Internal Auditors’ Steering Committee<br />
since May 2007, the Secretary General of its Steering Committee since May 2009<br />
and the Secretary and a Member of its Audit Committee since November <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
Over the course of her career, she has published articles, given lectures and taught<br />
as a professor of the “Creation and Management of an Internal Auditing<br />
Department” seminar since 2009.<br />
Mr. Luis Lada Díaz<br />
Mr. Luis Lada Díaz was born in Mieres, Asturias and is currently a member of the<br />
Board of Directors, of the Executive Committee and of the Audit and Compliance<br />
Committee of GAMESA CORPORACIÓN TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.<br />
He holds a Telecommunications Engineering Degree from the Universidad<br />
Politécnica de Madrid, where he is an Honorary Professor, and is also a full<br />
member of the Royal Academy of Engineering.<br />
After a brief spell at the Council for Scientific Research (Consejo Superior de<br />
Investigaciones Científicas), he joined Telefónica’s Research and Studies Center in<br />
1973 and spent most of his professional career at Telefónica. He was appointed<br />
General Manager for Planning and Technology in 1984, a position of maximum<br />
technical responsibility. He then went on to work for Grupo Amper between 1989<br />
and 1993 as General Planning and Control Manager, after which he rejoined<br />
Telefónica, holding responsibility for its Group of Subsidiaries and Associate<br />
Companies. He was appointed as the Chairman of Telefónica Móviles Spain In<br />
1994 and in August of 2000 went on to become a Director of Telefónica, S.A., a<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
9
member of its Executive Committee and the Executive Chairman of Telefónica<br />
Móviles S.A. In August 2003, he became the head of Grupo Telefónica’s<br />
Development, Planning and Regulation Division and was the Executive Chairman of<br />
Telefónica de España between December 2005 and July 2006.<br />
He is currently the Director General of Ribafuerte S.L., as well as a Director of<br />
Indra Sistemas, Telefónica I+D and Ydilo AVS. He is also a member of the Círculo<br />
de Empresarios and of the Bankinter Innovation Foundation, and an advisor to<br />
Telefónica, Teldat and ASSISA Inc.<br />
He has been a member of the Governing Board and Deputy Chairman of the<br />
Spanish Association of Telecommunications Engineers, as well as a director in a<br />
variety of companies in the information technologies sector. Mr. Lada Díaz has<br />
additionally received several professional and business awards.<br />
Mr. Carlos Rodríguez-Quiroga Menéndez<br />
Mr. Carlos Rodríguez-Quiroga Menéndez was born in Madrid. He currently holds<br />
the offices of Member and Secretary to the Board of Directors and Non-Voting<br />
Secretary of the Executive Committee, of the Audit and Compliance Committee and<br />
of the Appointments and Remuneration Committee of GAMESA CORPORACIÓN<br />
TECNOLÓGICA, S.A.<br />
He holds a Law Degree from the Universidad Complutense de Madrid.<br />
He is a Diploma holder of Employment Law from the Legal Practice School of<br />
Madrid.<br />
He has also been granted Diplomas in Comparative Industrial Relations and in<br />
European Community Relations from the Secretariat of State for Relations with the<br />
European Community.<br />
He is a practicing lawyer.<br />
Over the last few years, he has held the offices of Director or of Secretary to the<br />
Board of Directors, among other positions, in the following companies: Audiovisual<br />
Española 2000, S.A., Diver Karting, S.L. and Rodríguez-Quiroga Abogados, S.L. He<br />
is likewise a Trustee of the Spain-Equatorial Guinea Foundation.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
10
E.- MEETINGS HELD IN <strong>2011</strong> (ACTIVITIES)<br />
The meetings held throughout <strong>2011</strong> and the main issues dealt with in them were<br />
as follows:<br />
January 25, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Risk Management and Control System: Technology risks.<br />
• Analysis of the tax and legal situation.<br />
• Forecast on the FY 2010 year-end.<br />
February 22, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• External Auditors: Presentation on the work performed on the 2010<br />
annual accounts.<br />
• Information on the FY 2010 year-end to be filed before the National<br />
Securities Market Commission.<br />
• Analysis of the individual and consolidated accounts, as well as of the<br />
management report and the allocation of profits corresponding to the<br />
accounts to be drawn up by the Board of Directors.<br />
• Dividend policy.<br />
• Market presentation on the FY 2010 year-end.<br />
• Annual Corporate Governance Report 2010.<br />
• Summary of Internal Auditing activities in 2010, proposal for the Internal<br />
Auditing Plan <strong>2011</strong> and the Committee’s Work Plan.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
11
March 22, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Work in progress in wind and solar farm development and sales.<br />
• Analysis of the Risk Management and Control System: Updating of the<br />
risk map.<br />
• The Audit and Compliance Committee’s Activity Report.<br />
• Corporate Defense: Criminal Prevention and Anti-Fraud Policy.<br />
• Proposal to amend the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations.<br />
April 7, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Presentation of the bids submitted by the external auditing firms invited<br />
to take part in the tender to appoint the auditors of accounts.<br />
April 15, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Risk Management and Control System: G10X Platform Business Plan.<br />
• Sustainability report.<br />
• Appointment proposal on the external auditors of accounts.<br />
• Proposal to amend the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations.<br />
• Preliminary review of the Board of Directors’ resolutions on the agenda<br />
for the General Shareholders’ Meeting affecting the Committee.<br />
May 5, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Legal surveillance and control program.<br />
• Operational audit: Provision for wind turbine warranties.<br />
• Reporting to be filed before the National Securities Market Commission<br />
(CNMV) and market presentation for the first quarter of <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
July 21, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Presentation by the external auditors on the work done to conduct a<br />
limited review on the interim consolidated financial statements for the<br />
first half of <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
12
• Presentation on the information to be filed before the National<br />
Securities Market Commission (CNMV) and market presentation for the<br />
first half of <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
• Half-yearly report of the Legal Compliance Unit.<br />
• Proposal to update the “Regulatory Framework Governing the<br />
Relationships between the Audit and Compliance Committee and the<br />
Auditors of Accounts”.<br />
• Transaction with a significant shareholder.<br />
September 20, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• External auditors’ presentation on the procedures they have<br />
implemented to safeguard their independence from the organization<br />
audited.<br />
• Study of draft Internal Rules of Conduct Regarding the Securities<br />
Markets and of the Code of Conduct.<br />
• Analysis of the legal and tax situation.<br />
November 8, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• Risk Management and Control System: Updating of the risk map.<br />
• Audit on the obligatory information to be posted on the website.<br />
• Reporting to be filed before the National Securities Market Commission<br />
(CNMV) corresponding to the third quarter of <strong>2011</strong> and market<br />
presentation.<br />
• Internal Rules of Conduct Regarding the Securities Markets and Code<br />
of Conduct.<br />
December 13, <strong>2011</strong>:<br />
• External Auditors: Most relevant aspects identified in their preliminary<br />
work.<br />
• External Auditors: Analysis of the memorandum of recommendations.<br />
• Half-yearly report of the Legal Compliance Unit.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
13
F.- FUNCTIONS PER<strong>FOR</strong>MED IN <strong>2011</strong><br />
Without prejudice to other tasks it may be assigned with by the Board, the<br />
Corporate Bylaws, the Board of Directors Regulations and the Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee Regulations (hereinafter “ACCR”) set forth several basic<br />
responsibilities for the Committee, which can be summarized as a series of<br />
functions concerning:<br />
External Auditing. (Art. 6 of the ACCR)<br />
Internal Auditing. (Art. 7 of the ACCR)<br />
Process to draw up economic and financial reporting. (Art. 8 of the ACCR)<br />
Internal control and risk management systems. (Art. 9 of the ACCR)<br />
Corporate Governance and other functions. (Articles. 10 and 11 of the<br />
ACCR)<br />
General Shareholders’ Meeting<br />
The most significant functions/activities performed in this context by the<br />
Committee in <strong>2011</strong> are summarized below:<br />
F.1.- Functions Concerning External Auditing.<br />
In accordance with the Committee’s internal regulations, it has been assigned<br />
responsibilities concerning the following matters, among others:<br />
- Proposing the appointment of the external auditors of accounts, as<br />
well as their contracting conditions, the scope of their professional<br />
mandate and, should it be the case, their renewal, dismissal or nonrenewal<br />
to the Board of Directors for submission to the General<br />
Shareholders’ Meeting.<br />
- Ensuring the external auditors’ independence and, for such purpose,<br />
ensuring that the Company, its group and the external auditors<br />
comply with prevailing legislation on the provision of services other<br />
than auditing services, the concentration constraints on the auditors’<br />
business and, in general terms, any other rules laid down to ensure<br />
the external auditors’ independence.<br />
- Maintaining the relationship with the external auditors to receive<br />
information on any matters that could place their independence at<br />
risk and regarding any other matters connected with the performance<br />
of the account auditing process, as well as on any other disclosures<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
14
laid down by account auditing legislation and technical auditing<br />
standards.<br />
- Serving as a channel of communications between the Board of<br />
Directors and the auditors, assessing the results of each audit and<br />
the responses of the management team to their recommendations<br />
and mediating in the event of discrepancies between the auditors<br />
and the management team regarding the standards and criteria that<br />
should apply to draw up the financial statements.<br />
- Reviewing the contents of the audit reports before issuing them,<br />
endeavoring to ensure that such contents and the opinions expressed<br />
therein about the annual accounts are drafted clearly, accurately and<br />
without qualifications.<br />
- Ensuring that the consolidated group’s external auditors take on the<br />
responsibility of auditing the companies that comprise it.<br />
- Receiving written confirmation on an annual basis from the auditors<br />
of accounts of their independence from the Company and its<br />
reporting group, as well as information on any additional services of<br />
any kind provided to such organizations by the external auditors or to<br />
any company forming part of its group, along with any other<br />
information or documents required by prevailing legislation.<br />
- Issuing a preliminary report on the auditing of accounts on an annual<br />
basis which expresses an opinion on the independence of the<br />
auditors of accounts and on the possible provision of any additional<br />
services by the auditors.<br />
In keeping with the foregoing and in compliance with such responsibilities, the<br />
most significant actions, among others, performed in <strong>2011</strong> are set out below:<br />
- Appointment, Reappointment or Removal<br />
1.- Within such framework and fully respecting the practices of “Good<br />
Governance”, the Committee resolved to rotate the auditing firm and undertook to<br />
lead this process in order to ensure the appointment process’s transparency and<br />
equality.<br />
A tendering procedure was chosen as the most transparent, efficient and equitable<br />
formula in accordance with the existing internal rules set forth in the “Regulatory<br />
Framework Governing the Relationships between the Audit and Compliance<br />
Committee and the External Auditors of Accounts”.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
15
At the meeting held by the Committee on April 15, <strong>2011</strong>, it put forward<br />
PriceWaterhouseCoopers, Auditores, S.L. (hereinafter PwC) as the new auditing<br />
firm for the individual and consolidated annual accounts for the period covering<br />
<strong>2011</strong>-2013 to the Board of Directors for its subsequent submission to the General<br />
Shareholders’ Meeting.<br />
The Committee has played an active role aimed at overseeing the auditing firm’s<br />
transition plan process after its appointment by the General Shareholders’ Meeting<br />
on May 25, <strong>2011</strong> in order to ensure the effective rotation of auditing firms and to<br />
maximize the opportunities offered by the process of change.<br />
- Meetings Held with External Auditors<br />
1.- Deloitte, S.L., the auditing firm responsible for Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s individual and<br />
consolidated accounts for 2010, appeared before the Committee at its meeting<br />
held on February 22, <strong>2011</strong> in order to present the most significant aspects and<br />
conclusions of their auditing work regarding the aforementioned year.<br />
2.- The interim consolidated financial statements of Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong> as of June 30,<br />
<strong>2011</strong>, which were filed before the National Securities Market Commission, were<br />
subjected to a limited review by the external auditors, as were the statements of<br />
the same period in the preceding year. The new external auditors of accounts,<br />
PwC, appeared before the Committee at the meeting held on July 21, <strong>2011</strong> in<br />
order to present the most significant aspects, conclusions and a report on the work<br />
they had performed.<br />
3.- The external auditors also appeared before the Committee at its meeting held<br />
on December 13, <strong>2011</strong> to present the most significant aspects arising from the<br />
preliminary stage of auditing the annual accounts for FY <strong>2011</strong>. This involved<br />
monitoring the external auditors’ work, receiving preliminary reports and an<br />
overview on the external auditing process of the accounts.<br />
4.- Fulfilling the responsibility taken on by the Committee to receive regular reports<br />
from the external auditors on the results of their work, PwC was called upon at the<br />
meeting mentioned in the paragraph above to appear before the Committee at its<br />
meeting to be held on February 21, 2012 – before this Annual Activity Report was<br />
drawn up – to submit their final conclusions on the audit conducted on the<br />
financial statements at the year-end of FY <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
5.- As is indicated further below in this Audit and Compliance Committee Activity<br />
Report, the external auditors appeared before the Committee at its meeting held<br />
on December 13, <strong>2011</strong> to present their recommendations to improve internal<br />
controls resulting from their work as the Group’s auditors of accounts.<br />
6.- In addition, the Chairman of the Audit and Compliance Committee holds work<br />
meetings throughout the year with the external auditors, whenever he may deem<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
16
appropriate, on matters lying within the Committee’s responsibilities. The Chairman<br />
then informs the rest of the Committee’s members about the contents of such<br />
meetings.<br />
- Fees for Auditing Services<br />
The fees for financial auditing services provided to the various companies<br />
comprising Grupo GAMESA and its subsidiaries by the principal auditors and by<br />
other organizations related to them amounted to €1,149,000 in <strong>2011</strong> (€1,434,000<br />
in 2010). Similarly, the fees paid for this same item to other auditors who took part<br />
in auditing several of the group’s different companies amounted to €69,000<br />
(€155,000 in 2010).<br />
In addition, the principal auditors and other organizations linked to them provided<br />
other accounting review and verification services for the amount of €9,000<br />
(€17,000 in 2010), along with the provision of other professional services in <strong>2011</strong><br />
to the different companies comprising the Group for the amount of €35,000<br />
(€266,000 in 2010). Likewise, the fees paid for the services provided by other<br />
auditors that took part in auditing the different companies belonging to the Group<br />
for these same items amounted to €2,161,000 (€2,110,000 in 2010).<br />
- Certifying Independence and Other Aspects<br />
Pursuant to the provisions set forth in the Board of Directors Regulations and in<br />
Article 6 of the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations, “Ensuring” the<br />
external auditors’ independence is among the functions entrusted to the<br />
Committee by the Board of Directors. To such a purpose, it should ensure that the<br />
Company and the external auditors comply with prevailing regulations concerning<br />
the provision of the different auditing services, the concentration limits on the<br />
external auditors’ business and, in general terms, all the other regulations laid<br />
down to ensure the external auditors’ independence.<br />
1.- Within this context, the Audit and Compliance Committee requested the<br />
external auditors to:<br />
* Issue a written statement on their independence from Grupo <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />
regarding the performance of the auditing of accounts in accordance with<br />
prevailing legislation, and additionally a confirmation that the amount of the fees<br />
received by the external auditors did not exceed 5% of their total income.<br />
* Issue an additional statement that the services of any kind rendered by<br />
the external auditors other than the auditing of accounts are in accordance with<br />
the provisions set forth in legislation on the auditing of accounts and that they are<br />
not involved in any kind of incompatibility.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
17
2.- Likewise, at the meeting held by the Audit and Compliance Committee on<br />
September 20, <strong>2011</strong>, the external auditors responsible for the individual and<br />
consolidated annual accounts appeared before the Committee at the its request in<br />
order to present any internal procedures they had implemented to safeguard their<br />
independence from the organization being audited, any threats that may<br />
jeopardize their independence and the security measures adopted to mitigate such<br />
factors for the Committee’s subsequent analysis.<br />
3.- In accordance with the internal regulations of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación<br />
Tecnológica, S.A., which are aimed at developing and enhancing Corporate<br />
Governance rules by adjusting them to the most common trends and practices in<br />
the markets, we would like to highlight that the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />
issued a preliminary report on the auditing of accounts for the second year in a<br />
row. Such report expresses a favorable opinion on the independence of the<br />
auditors of accounts. It is attached hereto as an Annex.<br />
4.- It should also be highlighted that, over the course of the external auditors’<br />
different appearances, the Committee’s members actively urged the external<br />
auditors to undertake the responsibility of auditing the companies making up the<br />
Group as the consolidated Group’s external auditors. In this regard, once the<br />
necessary scope of the work that would allow the principal auditors to review and<br />
assess the work of other auditors was defined, no constraints were placed on their<br />
responsibility concerning expressing an opinion on the consolidated annual<br />
accounts for <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
F.2.- Functions Concerning the Company’s Management and the Internal<br />
Control and Risk Management Systems<br />
The Committee has been entrusted with the responsibility of overseeing the<br />
efficiency of the Company’s internal control systems and their appropriateness and<br />
integrity with regard to the business’s relevant risks, as well as setting and<br />
reviewing of the risk map and levels the Company considers as acceptable.<br />
The integrated risk management approach adopted by the Group involves a<br />
process in which the Board of Directors, Senior Management and the rest of the<br />
Group’s workforce are involved, and it is in turn integrated into the way corporate<br />
strategy is set.<br />
<strong>Gamesa</strong> uses a Risk/Opportunities Management and Control model across the<br />
entire organization (divisions, departments and companies) that covers all the<br />
geographical areas where it operates to contribute to the attainment of the<br />
Business’s objectives, the creation of shareholder value and sustainable profitable<br />
development.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
18
Within this context, the Committee regularly supervises the internal control and<br />
risk management system in order to ensure the following are identified:<br />
o The different kinds of risks facing the Company, including contingent<br />
liabilities and other out-of-balance risks among the financial and<br />
economic risks;<br />
o The setting of the risk level which the Company considers acceptable;<br />
o The measures foreseen to mitigate the impact of any risks identified<br />
should they come about; and<br />
o The information and internal control systems used to control and<br />
manage the aforementioned risks, including contingent liabilities and<br />
out-of-balance risks.<br />
At its meetings held on March 22 and November 8, the members of the Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee assessed the general risks/opportunities map, which<br />
includes the key processes to be monitored, to ensure that the most relevant<br />
aspects that could jeopardize the attainment of the business’s objectives are<br />
monitored on a continuous basis, as they could affect the Company’s economic<br />
profitability, its financial solvency, its corporate reputation, the integrity of its<br />
employees, the environment and compliance with legislation.<br />
The above-mentioned risk and opportunities map was updated before this Activity<br />
Report was drawn up, as it one of the Committee’s periodic activities.<br />
In keeping with the line of action initiated in previous years, the Group’s senior<br />
executives were called upon to make a series of appearances before the Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee in <strong>2011</strong> to provide it with an overview of the situation from<br />
their standpoint of the specific risks facing their activities with respect of the<br />
Company’s Strategic Plan.<br />
More specifically, several appearances took place in <strong>2011</strong>, which are described<br />
below:<br />
Date<br />
Date Department Presentation<br />
January 25 Manager of the Tax Area Analysis of the tax situation<br />
January 25 Legal Area Analysis of the legal situation<br />
January 25<br />
January 25<br />
Chief Technology Officer<br />
General Manager of Management Control<br />
Technology risks<br />
Forecast of the FY 2010 year-end<br />
March 22 General Manager of Internal Auditing Work in progress on the promotion and sale of wind farms<br />
March 22<br />
March 22<br />
April 15<br />
May 5<br />
B.R.C.and Internal Auditing Manager<br />
Chief Legal Counsel<br />
Sales and Projects<br />
General Manager of Internal Auditing<br />
Risk control and management system. Risk map<br />
Criminal prevention and anti-fraud policy<br />
Risk control and management system. New Business Plan platforms<br />
Operational audit: Provision for wind turbine warranties<br />
September 20 Manager of the Tax Area<br />
Analysis of the tax situation<br />
September 20 Legal Area<br />
Analysis of the legal situation<br />
November 8 B.R.C.and Internal Auditing Manager Risk control and management system. Risk map<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
19
The Managers of the Tax and Legal Areas appeared before the Committee at its<br />
meetings held on January 25 and September 20, <strong>2011</strong> to inform it of any tax and<br />
legal aspects identified as potential risks for the Group, along with their<br />
occurrence, impact and evolution.<br />
In addition, as indicated above, the external auditors appeared before the<br />
Committee at its meeting held on December 13 in order to present and assess<br />
their internal control recommendations arising from their auditing work and the<br />
management team’s responses.<br />
F.3.- Functions Concerning Economic and Financial Reporting<br />
Overseeing the process used to draw up financial reporting on the Company and<br />
its Group and the integrity of such information, as well as reviewing the<br />
information that the Company periodically and/or obligatorily discloses to the<br />
markets and to their supervisory bodies with the necessary thoroughness to ensure<br />
its accuracy, reliability, sufficiency and clarity are among the most important<br />
functions entrusted to the Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />
The Committee additionally ensures that periodic financial reporting is drawn up<br />
with the same accounting criteria as the annual financial reports. To such a<br />
purpose, it considers the appropriateness of proceeding with a limited half-yearly<br />
review of such reporting by the external auditors, safeguards compliance with legal<br />
requirements and ensures that generally accepted accounting standards are<br />
properly applied, informing the Board of Directors of any significant changes in<br />
accounting criteria.<br />
Its work provides an additional safeguard and foresees any risks that could lead to<br />
the existence of future qualifications resulting from non-compliances with<br />
accounting criteria in the external auditors’ audit report.<br />
For this reason, the activities performed in <strong>2011</strong> included the following, among<br />
others:<br />
1.- The Audit and Compliance Committee holds regular recurrent work meetings<br />
with the General Managers of the Management Control and Internal Auditing Areas<br />
in order to make a preliminary assessment of the economic and financial<br />
information that will be disclosed to the markets and regulatory bodies. At its<br />
meetings held on February 22, May 5, July 21 and November 8, the Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee supervised the different presentations made to the market,<br />
as well as the reporting filed before the National Securities Market Commission.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
20
2.- One of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s responsibilities is to supervise<br />
and assess any especially critical processes in the preparation of financial<br />
reporting.<br />
That is why the Manager of Internal Auditing and the General Management of the<br />
Group’s Management Control Area appeared before the Committee at its meetings<br />
held on March 22, May 5, and November 8 in order to set out the most significant<br />
accounting standards applied, as well as any assumptions and estimates made that<br />
had a significant effect on the financial statements.<br />
3.- In addition, opinions were interchanged with the external auditors of accounts<br />
on several occasions in <strong>2011</strong> concerning the application of several accounting<br />
standards under both Spanish and international rules.<br />
F.4.- Functions Concerning the Corporate Governance Area and Other<br />
Functions<br />
- General Shareholders’ Meeting.<br />
Article 43 of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Corporate Bylaws sets forth<br />
the Audit and Compliance Committee’s basic responsibility of informing the General<br />
Shareholders’ Meeting about any matters shareholders may broach at the meeting<br />
concerning the matters that lie within its competence.<br />
At the <strong>2011</strong> General Shareholders’ Meeting, the Annual Activity Report of the Audit<br />
and Compliance Committee was placed at the shareholders’ disposal as in<br />
preceding years. The aim of this is to promote the accountability of the activities<br />
performed during 2010.<br />
The Chairman of the Audit and Compliance Committee attended the <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />
General Shareholders’ Meeting held on May 25, <strong>2011</strong>. The shareholders did not<br />
raise any questions lying within the Committee’s competence.<br />
For its part, Article 21.3 of <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s General<br />
Shareholders’ Meeting Regulations sets forth the possibility of the Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee’s Chairman reporting or making clarifications in any of the<br />
circumstances laid down by the Law, so as to respond to requests for information<br />
made by shareholders at the General Meeting.<br />
The General Shareholders’ Meeting’s documents remain at the disposal of all<br />
shareholders and the general public on the Company’s website in the “Investors<br />
and Shareholders” section. The contents of such documents comply with the<br />
requirements laid down by Act 26/2003 of July 17 – otherwise known as the<br />
“Transparency Act” –, Ministerial Order ECO 3722/2003 of December 26 and<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
21
Circular 1/2004 of the National Securities Market Commission (CNMV) of March 17,<br />
which was amended by Circular 4/2007.<br />
This eight edition of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s Activity Report will be<br />
made available to shareholders at the General Shareholders’ Meeting to be held in<br />
2012.<br />
- The Audit and Compliance Committee’s Self-Assessment<br />
As in previous years, this Committee issued a report aimed at assessing the way it<br />
functions and the quality of its work in accordance with the internal regulations of<br />
<strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A. and in keeping with best practices on<br />
corporate governance. This report allows the Committee to correct any aspects<br />
that may have turned out to be barely functional.<br />
The conclusions set out in this report were debated and unanimously approved by<br />
all the members of the Committee at its meeting held on the May 5, <strong>2011</strong>. It was<br />
then brought before the Board of Directors for its consideration and approved by<br />
means of a Board resolution on May 25, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
The Committee initiated the process aimed at assessing its activities in <strong>2011</strong> before<br />
this Activity Report was drawn up.<br />
- Conflicts of Interest and Transactions with Shareholders Holding<br />
Significant Stakes<br />
According to the Corporate Bylaws, one of the Audit and Compliance Committee’s<br />
basic responsibilities consists of reporting on any transactions that involve or could<br />
potentially involve Conflicts of Interest or any transactions with Shareholders<br />
holding a significant stake. It is also responsible for approving any transactions<br />
that involve a Conflict of Interest or transactions with a Shareholder holding a<br />
significant stake, whenever it is requested to do so by the Board’s Chairman.<br />
For these purposes, the Audit and Compliance Committee assessed the proposals<br />
put forward by Management concerning transactions with a shareholder holding a<br />
significant stake at its meetings held on July 21 and December 13. It issued<br />
favorable reports and subsequently brought them before the Board of Directors.<br />
It should also be pointed out that the Director and Committee member until<br />
December 14, <strong>2011</strong>, Mr. Pedro Velasco Gómez, did not take part in any Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee meetings at which resolutions concerning transactions with<br />
Iberdrola, S.A. and/or companies belonging to its Group (Transactions with<br />
Shareholders Holding Significant Stakes) were deliberated on or approved. He<br />
therefore did not take part in the deliberations, voting, decision-making or<br />
execution of the relevant resolutions.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
22
- Supervision of the Legal Compliance Unit<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee’s responsibility includes overseeing<br />
compliance with the Internal Code of Conduct Regarding the Securities Market,<br />
with the Board of Directors Regulations and, in general terms, with the Company’s<br />
rules of governance, as well as putting forward the proposals needed for their<br />
improvement.<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee is particularly responsible for receiving<br />
information from the Legal Compliance Unit regarding the aforementioned matters<br />
and, if necessary, issuing reports on disciplinary matters to members of the<br />
Company’s Senior Management and Executives for not complying with their<br />
Corporate Governance obligations and/or the Internal Code of Conduct Regarding<br />
the Securities Market, as well as resolving any questions the Legal Compliance Unit<br />
may raise concerning Corporate Governance and its compliance pursuant to the<br />
Internal Code of Conduct Regarding the Securities Market.<br />
In accordance with the provisions set forth in Article 17 of the Internal Code of<br />
Conduct Regarding the Securities Market, the Legal Compliance Unit should<br />
periodically submit a report to the Committee on the application of such rules and<br />
the decisions adopted to put them into practice on at least a half-yearly basis.<br />
Fulfilling this mandate, the Manager of the Legal Compliance Unit appeared before<br />
the Audit and Compliance Committee at its meetings held on July 21 and<br />
December 13 to inform the Committee about the compliance levels of confidential<br />
operations and the registration of securities. A computer solution developed in<br />
previous years is available aimed at the “Automation of the Procedure on<br />
Confidential Operations and the Registration of Securities”.<br />
In this regard, the Audit and Compliance Committee monitors any qualifications<br />
thus observed throughout the year in order to ensure they are suitably corrected.<br />
In addition, <strong>Gamesa</strong> Corporación Tecnológica, S.A.’s Code of Conduct lays down<br />
that the Legal Compliance Unit should assess and draw up an annual report on the<br />
level of compliance with the aforementioned Code, which should be filed before<br />
the Audit and Compliance Committee.<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee may receive notices of any breaches from<br />
the Legal Compliance Unit, and it issues the instructions or adopts any measures<br />
that may be necessary.<br />
More specifically, the Manager of the Legal Compliance Unit informed the Audit<br />
and Compliance Committee about the Code of Conduct’s level of compliance at his<br />
appearances before the Committee on July 21 and December 13.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
23
Furthermore, the Legal Compliance Unit is entrusted with implementing and<br />
monitoring the legal surveillance and control program, whose function essentially<br />
consists of safeguarding and mitigating any risks arising from the application of the<br />
legislation on the different sectors to the Company and its Group.<br />
More specifically, the Manager of the Legal Compliance Unit informed the Audit<br />
and Compliance Committee about the effective implementation of the program and<br />
its results at his appearances before the Committee on July 21 and December 13.<br />
Lastly, with respect of the Company’s ethics and compliance plans, the Chief Legal<br />
Counsel set out the work carried out concerning the corporate defense program at<br />
his appearance on March 23, <strong>2011</strong>. He presented a proposal for a Criminal<br />
Prevention and Anti-Fraud Policy and a positive report was issued thereof prior to<br />
its subsequent approval by the Company’s Board of Directors at its meeting held<br />
on March 24, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
- Annual Corporate Governance Report and Sustainability Report<br />
The 2010 Annual Corporate Governance Report was approved and ratified by the<br />
Audit and Compliance Committee at its meeting held on February 22, <strong>2011</strong>. The<br />
Committee unanimously resolved to approve the report and submit it to the Board<br />
of Directors’ consideration, which approved it at its meeting held on February 23,<br />
<strong>2011</strong>. It was the subject of a relevant disclosure filed before the National Securities<br />
Market Commission in accordance with prevailing legislation.<br />
At its meeting held on April 15, the Audit and Compliance Committee examined the<br />
wording given to the matters lying within its competence contained in the <strong>Gamesa</strong><br />
Sustainability Report 2010. The Committee likewise resolved to approve such<br />
matters and bring them before the Board of Directors.<br />
In order to verify the information and contribute to the principle of transparency,<br />
the Spanish Standardization and Certification Association (Asociación Española de<br />
Normalización y Certificación – AENOR) was commissioned to conduct an<br />
independent review of the sustainability report, which received such association’s<br />
conformity.<br />
- The Company’s website<br />
Act 26/2003 on Transparency, which was implemented through Order<br />
ECO/3722/2003 and Circular 1/2004 of the National Securities Market Commission<br />
of March 17, lays down the minimum obligatory reporting contents that the<br />
websites of listed companies should contain. As in the previous years and in<br />
compliance with the mandate issued by the Committee, the Internal Auditing<br />
Department conducted a website audit in 2010 to ensure the minimum legally<br />
required contents were met.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
24
The findings of the aforementioned internal website audit on the “Investors and<br />
Shareholders” section were presented to the Audit and Compliance Committee at<br />
its meeting held on November 8 <strong>2011</strong> and deemed to be satisfactory.<br />
- New Revised Text of the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />
Regulations<br />
As a consequence of the legislative amendments which have come about and the<br />
approval by <strong>Gamesa</strong>’s Board of Directors of the Revised Text of the Board of<br />
Directors Regulations at its meeting held on December 15, 2010, it became<br />
necessary to amend certain articles of the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />
Regulations. In order to do so and after the appropriate analysis by the Directors,<br />
the members of the Committee drew up a report justifying the amendments at its<br />
meeting held on April 15, <strong>2011</strong> and brought it before the Board of Directors.<br />
Given that a thoroughgoing change of the Regulations was made, such<br />
amendment was deemed as the approval of a revised text of the <strong>Gamesa</strong> Audit<br />
and Compliance Regulations.<br />
Continuing with the process of revising and updating the Company’s internal<br />
regulations, the drafts which updated the Internal Rules of Conduct Regarding the<br />
Securities Markets and the <strong>Gamesa</strong> Code of Conduct were brought before the Audit<br />
and Compliance Committee at its meeting held on September 20, <strong>2011</strong>. After the<br />
relevant contributions were made by the Committee’s members at its meeting held<br />
on October 8, such drafts were brought before the Board of Directors, which<br />
approved both texts at its meeting held on November 10, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />
F.5. Functions Concerning Internal Auditing<br />
According to the Audit and Compliance Committee Regulations, the Internal<br />
Auditing Department hierarchically reports directly to the Board of Directors and,<br />
on its behalf, to the Board’s Chairman. However, it functionally depends on the<br />
Audit and Compliance Committee. The main function of this Department is to<br />
inform, provide advice and report directly to the aforementioned Committee about<br />
any aspects concerning the internal control system, financial reporting and any<br />
issues lying within the Committee’s competence as regards external auditing, the<br />
annual Corporate Governance Report, the annual Corporate Social Responsibility<br />
Report, third-party transactions that may involve a conflict of interest and<br />
transactions with shareholders holding significant stakes, etc.<br />
The Manager of Internal Auditing attends all of the Audit and Compliance<br />
Committee’s meetings as a guest and appeared before it several times throughout<br />
<strong>2011</strong>, some of which have already been mentioned in this Annual Activity Report.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
25
As a result, the Audit and Compliance Committee has had access to, reviewed and<br />
approved the most relevant reports issued by Internal Auditing Department’s<br />
Management, which place special emphasis on aspects connected with financial<br />
reporting and internal control, as well as on monitoring the implementation of any<br />
recommendations proposed by either the internal or the external auditors.<br />
Subsequently, but before this Activity Report was drawn up, the Manager of<br />
Internal Auditing submitted the findings of the Annual Internal Auditing Activity<br />
Plan for <strong>2011</strong> and the Annual Plan Proposal for 2012, which sets out activities<br />
related to the economic situation’s risks as priority lines of work linked to financial<br />
reporting risks. Within this context, the Audit and Compliance Committee sets its<br />
own Work Plan for 2012.<br />
********************************************************<br />
All the aforementioned activities of the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />
throughout the ten meetings it held in <strong>2011</strong> were aimed at making a contribution<br />
to the basic principles adopted by the Board of Directors that lie behind the<br />
functions entrusted to the Committee, which include:<br />
• The efficient functioning of the internal control system for relevant risks<br />
• The reliability of financial reporting<br />
• Compliance with policies, procedures, rules and legal provisions<br />
• Good Corporate Governance<br />
All of the above is aimed at reasonably ensuring the attainment of the objectives<br />
set by the organization in order to preserve the value of its assets and,<br />
consequently, the value of its shareholders’ investment by providing shareholders,<br />
stakeholders and the markets in general with the maximum guarantees.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
26
G.- CONCLUSION<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee deems that is was reasonably informed of all<br />
the issues within its sphere of competence in <strong>2011</strong> and therefore considers that it<br />
satisfactorily fulfilled the responsibilities assigned to it by the Corporate Bylaws, the<br />
Board of Directors Regulations and its own Regulations.<br />
The Committee maintained direct ongoing contact and collaborated with the<br />
Group’s different Divisions, the Legal Compliance Unit and the Internal Auditing<br />
Area, as well as with the external auditors of accounts.<br />
The process aimed at selecting the external auditors of accounts and the<br />
subsequent proposal for the appointment of the auditors of accounts, the<br />
monitoring of their work, the review of their conclusions and the assessment of<br />
their independence have rigorously complied with the strict policies laid down on<br />
such matters. The auditors of accounts’ positive conclusions regarding both the<br />
consolidated annual accounts and interim consolidated financial statements as of<br />
June 30, <strong>2011</strong> endorse the suitability of the financial reporting and internal control<br />
systems for relevant risks.<br />
Lastly, the Committee considered that the Company strictly complied with the rules<br />
and recommendations of good governance.<br />
H.- LINES OF ACTION <strong>FOR</strong>ESEEN <strong>FOR</strong> 2012<br />
New challenges and opportunities face the Committee in the performance of its<br />
functions and responsibilities in 2012. It will therefore keep up the same pace of<br />
activity it has had to date. In this regard, the schedule of meetings set for 2012<br />
includes around ten meetings.<br />
The current economic climate will require special attention to be placed on<br />
financial risks, which will be dealt with preferentially in the Audit and Compliance<br />
Committee’s scheduling.<br />
Likewise, the lines of action foreseen for 2012 will have an incidence on overseeing<br />
the process of drawing up financial and economic reporting.<br />
As a especially relevant function, the Committee will continue to ensure that the<br />
Group and the external auditors of accounts fulfill prevailing rules on the provision<br />
of services other than auditing, the constraints placed on the auditors’ business<br />
and, in general terms, any other rules set to ensure the external auditors’<br />
independence, requesting them to issue the relevant report to the Committee<br />
expressing an opinion on such independence.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
27
On the basis of its contribution to the Company maintaining a high level of<br />
monitoring regarding the best practices of corporate governance, the Audit and<br />
Compliance Committee, as in previous years, has established as one of its priorities<br />
the ongoing adaptation to and fulfillment of any recommendations set forth on<br />
such matters<br />
The Audit and Compliance Committee’s work and efforts, which are disclosed<br />
throughout this Annual Report, are the best guarantee offered to shareholders<br />
regarding the responsibilities that have been entrusted to it.<br />
Annual Activity Report <strong>2011</strong><br />
28