25.10.2012 Views

Download PDF - Banesto

Download PDF - Banesto

Download PDF - Banesto

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Annual Report<br />

2008


Highlights<br />

EARNINGS PER SHARE +3%<br />

ROE 16.6%<br />

EFFICIENCY 39%<br />

NON-PERFORMING<br />

LOANS RATIO 1.62%<br />

Earnings per share*<br />

euros<br />

1.10<br />

0.67<br />

0.82<br />

0.97<br />

1.13<br />

ROE<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

*Recurrent *Before discontinued operations<br />

Gross operating income<br />

million euros<br />

2,462<br />

2,271<br />

1,696 1,789<br />

1,983<br />

+3 %<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

Attributable profit<br />

million euros<br />

458<br />

570<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

(%)<br />

18.3<br />

19.0<br />

Efficiency<br />

(%)<br />

606*<br />

*Before discontinued operations<br />

48.1 45.0<br />

765<br />

15.6*<br />

42.5<br />

+2 %<br />

17.1<br />

780<br />

16.6<br />

40.5 39.0<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

Operation costs/Gross operating income


Index<br />

Chairman’s Letter 2<br />

Governing bodies 6<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> in 2008<br />

Business model 9<br />

The customer and quality 12<br />

Managing talent 14<br />

Risk control 18<br />

Technology 20<br />

Business units<br />

Retail banking 22<br />

Company banking 26<br />

Wholesale banking 28<br />

The <strong>Banesto</strong> share 30<br />

Corporate social responsibility 32<br />

Corporate governance 36<br />

Financial information 38<br />

Risk management 62<br />

Audit and compliance committee 74<br />

Internal control model 81<br />

Audit0r’s report and<br />

annual financial statements 82<br />

Auditor’s report 83<br />

Consolidated financial statements 85<br />

Management report 178<br />

Corporate governance report according<br />

to the CNMV model 185<br />

Noteworthy figures 186<br />

General information and<br />

regional offices 187<br />

1


2<br />

Chairman’s Letter<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> is ready to<br />

Successfully weather An<br />

environment like The<br />

current one.<br />

We know our market,<br />

Understand our customers<br />

And have a business Model<br />

that works.<br />

Ana P. Botín<br />

Executive Chairman


Dear Shareholder,<br />

In an exceptional year like 2008, which will be<br />

remembered as one of the most complicated in<br />

the history of the international financial sector,<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s results underscored its solid position<br />

and capacity to generate recurrent and quality<br />

revenues, with sustainable spreads, even during<br />

times of crisis.<br />

Performance and results<br />

Attributable profit was 2% higher than in 2007<br />

at €779 million. With the prudence demanded<br />

by the current economic situation, we decided to<br />

make a one-time €60 million loan loss provision<br />

charged against results. It has not been assigned<br />

for anything in particular. But for this provision,<br />

profit would have risen 7.5%.<br />

The financial crisis, which began in August 2007,<br />

deepened during 2008 and fed through to the<br />

real economy. Economic and banking activity fell<br />

sharply. Despite this, gross operating income<br />

increased 8.4% to €2,461 million.<br />

A key element in the current environment is our<br />

traditional discipline in costs. This enabled the<br />

efficiency ratio to improve yet again to 39%,<br />

making <strong>Banesto</strong> one of the most efficient<br />

Spanish and European banks.<br />

It is essential in this environment to maintain an<br />

appropriate balance between growth in lending<br />

and risk assumption. Our policy enabled many of<br />

our customers, both companies and individuals, to<br />

receive the necessary financing for their projects.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> distributed:<br />

- 46,500 loans to SMEs amounting to €3,540<br />

million,<br />

- 20,400 mortgages totalling €2,860 million<br />

and<br />

- 87,900 personal loans amounting to €1,800<br />

million.<br />

The credit quality deterioration is a natural<br />

consequence of the economic downturn.<br />

Nevertheless, rigorous control of risks,<br />

improvements in the way they are managed and a<br />

clear strategy of anticipating them led <strong>Banesto</strong> to<br />

outperform the Spanish banking sector. Our nonperforming<br />

loans ratio was 1.62% at the end of<br />

2008 and coverage stood at 105.4%.<br />

Given the current liquidity crunch, particular<br />

attention was paid to attracting deposits. And we<br />

were successful, as they grew 8.4%, a faster pace<br />

than the banking sector, and produced a gain in<br />

market share of 0.36 p.p.<br />

In short, the results were good in a complicated<br />

year, and very good when compared to other<br />

Spanish and European banks. This was ratified by<br />

3


4<br />

all financial analysts and the market in general.<br />

Although the <strong>Banesto</strong> share could not escape the<br />

plunge in all equity markets, its performance was<br />

relatively better than European markets in general<br />

and the banking sector in particular.<br />

The 3% rise in earnings per share was very<br />

notable compared to the rest of European<br />

banks. This increase, based on comparative<br />

figures for the first nine months of 2008 (the<br />

latest available), was higher than all its European<br />

competitors.<br />

The dividend per share in 2008 was €0.56, the<br />

same as in 2007, and maintained a policy of<br />

distributing around 50% of profits. Based on the<br />

share price, it represents a return of 8%.<br />

As a result of all these achievements, the<br />

magazine Euromoney recognised <strong>Banesto</strong> as<br />

the best bank in Spain, due to its high quality<br />

growth, the rise in net operating income and our<br />

leadership in attributable profit and customer<br />

funds.<br />

Strategy and strengths<br />

In 2006 we laid the foundations of a strategy to<br />

make <strong>Banesto</strong> the best commercial bank in Europe.<br />

We aim to be the leaders in consumer credit and<br />

cards, value-added businesses in wholesale<br />

banking and become the bank in Spain for<br />

companies, especially SMEs.<br />

In order to achieve this, we must continuously<br />

improve the quality of service and increase our<br />

business strength. We have successfully<br />

surmounted these challenges, and done so despite<br />

an economic environment that has radically<br />

changed and become more complex. Becoming<br />

the best bank in Spain is the first step towards<br />

becoming the best commercial bank in Europe.<br />

The road will not be easy; 2009 will be no less<br />

complicated than 2008. Developed countries are<br />

now in recession and the pace of growth in<br />

emerging economies is declining, all of which is<br />

affecting banking activity.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> is in a position to weather this<br />

environment successfully. We know our market,<br />

understand our customers and have a business<br />

model which:<br />

- seeks an ongoing improvement in customer<br />

and employee satisfaction;<br />

- is based on innovation and customer service;<br />

- and strives to have an impact on society<br />

beyond that of banking.<br />

It is a model which<br />

- focuses on rigorously managing risks and<br />

capital and<br />

- generates recurrent, quality revenues and with<br />

sustainable spreads.<br />

And its operational efficiency enables us to adapt<br />

to a changing environment.<br />

Our starting point is very solid: in the talent and<br />

commitment of our employees, in risk<br />

management, in efficiency and in the speed of<br />

response to customers’ new needs. The current<br />

crisis is a great opportunity for <strong>Banesto</strong> to keep<br />

on growing and move further ahead of its<br />

competitors.


Corporate Social Responsibility<br />

We continue to back the professional development<br />

of our employees as one of the fundamental<br />

elements of our management style. We launched<br />

the Human Resources Master Plan which makes<br />

involvement, identity and impetus the strategic<br />

lines. This strategy was put into effect during<br />

2008, and we advanced in the idea of mutual<br />

commitment with more training, tailored career<br />

development plans and creating a more flexible<br />

working environment that facilitates the<br />

appropriate balance between professional and<br />

family life.<br />

In today’s environment, our management must go<br />

hand in hand with a greater commitment to<br />

society. <strong>Banesto</strong>’s Corporate Social<br />

Responsibility focuses on fostering<br />

entrepreneurship and supporting small firms,<br />

thereby fomenting a new concept of socially<br />

responsible companies.<br />

More than 4,000 SMEs took part in courses run<br />

by the Banespyme school and the Solidarity and<br />

Sustainable Tourism project already operates in 20<br />

African countries.<br />

Future priorities<br />

We have very clear ideas. The management<br />

priorities for 2009 are:<br />

- Risks: we have always been noted for a rigorous<br />

risks policy, which, in periods of growth, has<br />

distinguished us from our competitors. During<br />

a crisis, it is of vital importance.<br />

- Productivity: we have the means, the<br />

technology, the management model and the<br />

talent to be an even more productive and<br />

efficient bank. There is always room for<br />

improvement and we will continue to be<br />

particularly watchful in costs.<br />

- Customers: the focus on them will be<br />

maintained. Our model is based on forging<br />

stable, lasting and increasingly close relations<br />

with customers, on being on their side, as has<br />

always been the case: both in good times and<br />

the not so good like now. We will continue this<br />

strategy of capturing customers in all<br />

segments.<br />

If we have learned anything from previous crises it<br />

is that they offer opportunities.<br />

An opportunity we are in a position to seize,<br />

because we have a business model that<br />

generates value for our customers and because<br />

the market always offers opportunities.<br />

It is easy to grow when the going is good. In<br />

difficult periods, however, only those who<br />

combine the best staff with the best position in<br />

the market prosper. And <strong>Banesto</strong> offers this<br />

combination.<br />

We also have the backing of its shareholders,<br />

whom I would like to thank once again for placing<br />

their trust in us.<br />

Ana P. Botín<br />

5


6<br />

Governing bodies<br />

Board of Directors<br />

Executive Chairman<br />

Ana P. Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O´Shea<br />

Executive Director<br />

Vice-Chairman<br />

Víctor Manuel Menéndez Millán<br />

Non-executive Director (independent)<br />

Chief Executive Officer<br />

José García Cantera<br />

Executive Director<br />

Secretary<br />

Jaime Pérez Renovales<br />

BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />

Directors<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers / Executive<br />

José María Nus Badía / Executive<br />

José María Fuster Van Bendegem / Non-executive, proprietary<br />

Matías Rodríguez Inciarte / Non-executive, proprietary<br />

David Arce Torres / Non-executive, proprietary<br />

Carlos Pérez de Bricio / Non-executive, independent<br />

Belén Romana García / Non-executive, independent<br />

Rafael del Pino y Calvo-Sotelo / Non-executive, independent<br />

Francisco Daurella Franco / Non-executive, independent<br />

José Luis López Combarros / Non-executive, independent<br />

Carlos Sabanza Teruel / Non-executive, independent<br />

From left to right and starting at the front: Francisco Daurella Franco, Belén Romana García, José García Cantera,<br />

José Luis López Combarros, David Arce Torres, Carlos Sabanza Teruel, Matías Rodríguez Inciarte,


Committees of the Board of Directors<br />

Executive Committee<br />

Chairman<br />

Ana P. Botín-Sanz de Sautuola<br />

y O´Shea<br />

Members<br />

Víctor Manuel Menéndez Millán<br />

José García Cantera<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers<br />

José María Nus Badía<br />

José María Fuster Van Bendegem<br />

Carlos Sabanza Teruel<br />

Secretary (not a Board member)<br />

Jaime Pérez Renovales<br />

Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

Chairman<br />

Belén Romana García<br />

Members<br />

Víctor Manuel Menéndez Millán<br />

Matías Rodríguez Inciarte<br />

José Luis López Combarros<br />

Secretary (not a Board member)<br />

Jaime Pérez Renovales<br />

Appointments and Remuneration Committee<br />

Chairman<br />

José Luis López Combarros<br />

Members<br />

Víctor Manuel Menéndez Millán<br />

Belén Romana García<br />

Secretary (not a Board member)<br />

Jaime Pérez Renovales<br />

Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea, Víctor Manuel Menéndez Millán and Carlos Pérez de Bricio.<br />

Rafael del Pino y Calvo-Sotelo, José María Fuster Van Bendegem, José María Nus Badia, Juan Delibes Liniers and Jaime Pérez Renovales.<br />

Standing Committee on Risks<br />

Chairman<br />

José María Nus Badía<br />

Members<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers<br />

Carlos Sabanza Teruel<br />

Secretary (not a Board member)<br />

Jaime Pérez Renovales<br />

7


8<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> in 2008<br />

Business Model 9<br />

The customer and quality 12<br />

Managing talent 14<br />

Risk control 18<br />

Technology 20<br />

Business units<br />

Retail banking 22<br />

Company banking 26<br />

Wholesale banking 28<br />

The <strong>Banesto</strong> share 30<br />

Corporate social responsibility 32<br />

Corporate governance 36


Business Model<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> has a proven<br />

business model which<br />

generates value in all<br />

phases of the economic<br />

cycle. The winning banks<br />

in the current<br />

environment will be<br />

those that are<br />

customer-focused<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s business model focuses on supplying the<br />

products and services that customers want at each<br />

phase of the cycle, continuous improvement in the<br />

quality of service, capturing, developing and retaining<br />

talent, prudent management of risks and constantly<br />

striving for the highest efficiency through operational<br />

excellence that contributes cutting-edge technology.<br />

The customer is the<br />

focal point of our<br />

business model.<br />

José García Cantera<br />

CEO<br />

9


10<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s business model is based on the<br />

following pillars:<br />

1. Customer satisfaction via the quality of service<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> is convinced that continuous improvement in its standards of quality enhances customer satisfaction and strengthens their<br />

loyalty and linkage. In 2004 we established our Q10 management of quality model which today uses more than 2,200 indicators to<br />

gauge the quality of service throughout the bank and the level of customer satisfaction.<br />

We continued to develop this model during 2008 with new projects such as the <strong>Banesto</strong> Responde Centre, which manages, on a multi<br />

channel basis, incidents and complaints, the Q10 Branch Model and the creation of Quality Committee in each of the zones into which<br />

the retail banking network is divided.<br />

All of this enables us to increase the degree of customer satisfaction. The number of complaints received in 2008 by the Customer<br />

Attention Service was 5% lower.<br />

A further step in our commitment to continuously improving the quality of service and striving for excellence was taken in December<br />

2008 when <strong>Banesto</strong> obtained the stamp of approval from the European Foundation for Quality Management (EFQM) for excellence with<br />

500+ points, the highest level certified by the Excellence Club in Management. This recognition is based on the impact of the bank’s<br />

achievements on customers, employees and society.<br />

2. Management of talent<br />

Talent is a scant asset and a critical factor for success. One of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s basic lines of management is to find, develop and retain the best<br />

talent.<br />

In 2007 we launched our Human Resources Master Plan which defines involvement, identity and drive as the strategic lines of<br />

management. This strategy was implemented during 2008 through different projects including those for Quality Management, Knowledge<br />

of People, Career Plan, Talent Map, Improving Productivity, Value Proposal and Diversity.<br />

A basic objective of our policy is to have the most skilled employees in banking. In order to achieve this, <strong>Banesto</strong> continues to be fully<br />

committed to training. Employees in 2008 spent 65 hours on average in training courses, much higher than the average for banks in<br />

Spain.<br />

As a result of this long-term policy, <strong>Banesto</strong> was again selected in 2008, for the fifth straight year, as one of the five best companies to<br />

work for in Spain (Actualidad Económica ranking). And for the first time <strong>Banesto</strong> was chosen by Euromoney as the best bank in Spain.<br />

3. Prudent management of risks<br />

One of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s hallmarks is its culture of prudence in risk management, particularly credit and liquidity risks. This principle in the<br />

current environment has acquired an importance not known since 1993 when the Spanish economy was last in recession.<br />

The strategic objective is to maintain a quality of risk higher than the average of the banking sector. In a year when there have been major<br />

differences because of the complicated environment, we again achieved this goal: at the end of 2008 <strong>Banesto</strong>’s ratio of non-performing<br />

loans was 1.62%, which is almost half the ratio of the whole financial system. Coverage of non-performing loans by provisions stood at<br />

105%, well above the sector’s average.<br />

Such a performance is only possible with the best admission, monitoring and recovery systems, whose structure were strengthened in<br />

2008 with 389 people. Management anticipates the risks.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> significantly improved its liquidity position during 2008, aided by a change of business mix to one more focused on capturing<br />

deposits, and on the bank’s capacity to make new wholesale issues (€6,981 million in 2008), even in the most adverse market<br />

conditions.


4. Efficiency and operational excellence<br />

Operational excellence based on continuously optimising processes with a notable impact on costs, but without quality suffering, coupled<br />

with improvements in commercial efficiency enabled <strong>Banesto</strong> to increase its productivity more than that of its competitors.<br />

In 2008, operational efficiency (gross operating income as a percentage of total operating costs, including depreciation, improved by<br />

1.5 p.p. to 39%, meeting the target for the year. This was achieved with growth of 8.4% in gross operating income and only 3.4% in costs.<br />

Efficiency improvements are producing an increasingly less bureaucratic structure and one focused more on the customer. The measures<br />

to improve efficiency are in the Menara Plan and its various projects. Thanks to them, 100 employees were released in 2008 from<br />

back-office tasks to concentrate on customer management. Back-office teams were reduced in 2008 from 3.5% to 2.8% and intermediate<br />

structures from 6.3% to 5% of the branch network’s total employees.<br />

5. Cutting edge tecnology<br />

One of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s competitive advantages is cutting edge technology that is customer-focused as well as economies of scale that provide<br />

the use of a common platform in Grupo Santander, making <strong>Banesto</strong> a unique model.<br />

Technology has also enabled us to continue to develop a multi channel offer of products and services. During 2008 a new online broker<br />

was launched and i<strong>Banesto</strong>.com and the <strong>Banesto</strong> Responde Centre were developed.<br />

As a result of all these factors, the proportion of operations through channels other than branches was 33%, and the business volume<br />

24%. Furthermore, the migration of transactions to more economic channels reduced unit costs per transaction to €0.03, 3.7% less than<br />

in the year 2000.<br />

11


12<br />

The customer and quality<br />

The q10 model covers everyone<br />

and has more than 2,200<br />

indicators of quality<br />

for all the bank.<br />

In an environment of maximum competitiveness, quality of service and<br />

customer attention are key aspects in each business with customers.<br />

Established in 2004, the main objective of the Q10 Model is to<br />

improve customer satisfaction. The Q10 indicators have made <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

a reference in the sector and consolidate the most important aspects<br />

regarding customers, incorporating their view via a model of multi<br />

channel quality.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> obtains the stamp of<br />

gold for european excellence<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> obtained the European Excellence stamp of gold +<br />

500 points from the Excellence Club in Management which<br />

evaluates and fosters European business management quality.<br />

This recognition, the highest granted by the European<br />

Foundation for Quality Management (EFQM), rewards the<br />

level of excellence achieved in corporate strategy, leadership,<br />

policies developed, management of employees, funds,<br />

processes and relations with the bank’s various stakeholders.<br />

EFQM assessment team, Excellence Club in Management and S.G.S.


THE Q10 MODEL CONTRIBUTES THE FOLLOWING<br />

ADVANTAGES:<br />

• A global model: the quality of the whole organisation is<br />

managed strategically, influencing, in turn, those key aspects<br />

related to customers through the use of more than 2,200<br />

indicators.<br />

• Multichannel: it measures the quality of customer service in all<br />

channels (branches, telephone and Internet) and enables us to<br />

integrate the internal and external views of quality.<br />

• Provides efficient management: the system identifies the<br />

indicators where improvements and/or measures have to be<br />

made.<br />

• Systematic and reliable: it monitors every month the results<br />

at all levels and conducts audits in order to ensure the model is<br />

reliable.<br />

New projects were launched in 2008 to improve customer quality<br />

and service:<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Responde Centre<br />

In order to keep on improving one of the most important<br />

customer-related aspects, this centre was launched so as to<br />

guarantee a quick and efficient solution to any problem arising in<br />

any channel.<br />

This new centre manages problems and complaints in all the<br />

channels and speeds up the response to them. Complaints were<br />

down 5% in 2008.<br />

Q10 Branch Model<br />

In order to ensure the same excellent level of service in all our<br />

branches, a customer management and attention model was<br />

established which standardises a high level of service.<br />

In order to assess the model, as well as the level of service<br />

provided, “mysterious customer” visits are made every month to<br />

branches. More than 1,100 such visits were made in 2008,<br />

enabling the pulse of customer service to be taken continuously.<br />

The index of the quality of service improved by more than 0.56<br />

points.<br />

Q10 Challenge<br />

A programme was developed for all customer attention managers in<br />

order to improve service from behind the counter, one of the<br />

functions with a significant impact on the perception of customers.<br />

Self-evaluation of the quality of service<br />

Every month the teams in all branches meet to assess the service<br />

provided to customers and suggest ways to improve it.<br />

Quality committees<br />

Those responsible for quality in branches meet every month with<br />

the manager of their zone to work on improving the indicators of<br />

quality and transmit good practices.<br />

Domina programme<br />

This programme improves the information provided to customers<br />

by obtaining better knowledge of products.<br />

THE PATH TO EXCELLENCE: BANESTO MAKES<br />

THE FIRST EFQM SELF-ASSESSMENT<br />

Thanks to the improvement achieved in the last few years in quality<br />

for customers, in processes and in results we began to work with<br />

the EFQM Excellence Model in 2008. The first self-assessment was<br />

carried out on the basis of nine criteria so that an improvement<br />

plan could be drawn up.<br />

BANESTO AWARDED THE CUSTOMER<br />

CONFIDENCE PRIZE<br />

In April 2008 the Fundación Madrid para la Excelencia awarded<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> its customer confidence prize for the Madrid region. The<br />

following aspects were taken into account:<br />

• Leadership and coherence with quality.<br />

• Focusing on the customer.<br />

• Customers’ confidence.<br />

• Results with customers.<br />

The prize recognises<br />

the efforts made by<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> in<br />

survey<br />

developing,<br />

Scale 0-10<br />

implementing and<br />

continuously<br />

improving its Q10 7.84<br />

Management of<br />

Quality Model, which<br />

is applied to<br />

everyone and<br />

enabled the whole<br />

bank to be customer-<br />

2007<br />

focused and<br />

continuously<br />

improve the quality<br />

of service.<br />

Growth in linked<br />

customers<br />

(with more than 4 products)<br />

2%<br />

1T<br />

Recommendation of customers<br />

76.3%<br />

2005<br />

9%<br />

2T<br />

76.5%<br />

2006<br />

Service quality<br />

12%<br />

3T<br />

77.0%<br />

2007<br />

7.97<br />

2008<br />

15%<br />

4T<br />

78.2%<br />

2008<br />

13


14<br />

Management of talent<br />

Women/total<br />

employees<br />

26%<br />

Female executives/<br />

total executives<br />

15%<br />

36%<br />

2002 2008<br />

28%<br />

2002 2008<br />

Our main competitive advantage<br />

lies in our employees<br />

Commitment is at the heart of our management of human resources. It<br />

is a key factor for attaining our strategic business objectives.<br />

9,718 employees<br />

41.2 Average age<br />

91% dedicated to commercial activity<br />

65 hours of training / 2008<br />

11.8 adherence to the measures of the “banesto x ti” programme


MANAGEMENT OF TALENT AT BANESTO<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s commitment to its staff is based on two premises: on the<br />

one hand, knowledge of employees in order to identify their needs<br />

and provide tailored management and, on the other, the value<br />

proposal comprising those products and services that strengthen<br />

the commitment: training, career path, competitive remuneration<br />

and programmes to reconcile family and working life, equality of<br />

opportunity and diversity.<br />

The Human Resources Master Plan has three strategic lines:<br />

involvement (commitment to employees), identity (commitment<br />

with the sense of belonging) and drive (commitment to business<br />

results).<br />

Seven projects were launched in 2007 and 2008:<br />

• iCRM <strong>Banesto</strong>: managing employees as if they were customers.<br />

• Quality Management: manage the commitment of employees.<br />

• GPS Professional <strong>Banesto</strong>: guide of sustainable professional<br />

progression for professional orientation.<br />

• <strong>Banesto</strong> Value Proposal: communicate everything that <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

makes available to its employees.<br />

• Improving Productivity: commitment to results.<br />

• Talent Map: develop the pool of possible people to fill key<br />

posts.<br />

• “<strong>Banesto</strong> x ti”: diversity and reconciling work and family life<br />

programme.<br />

THE TEAM<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s 9,718 employees combine youth and experience (more<br />

than 43% are under the age of 40 and 59% have worked for the<br />

bank for 10 years or more), diversity (26 different nationalities), a<br />

desire to be up-to-date in everything (more than 65 hours of<br />

training per employee/year), expectations of professional<br />

development (9.67% of staff were promoted to positions of<br />

greater responsibility) and determination (74.27% of new<br />

appointments achieve their results). The working environment is<br />

flexible and allows for the reconciliation of professional and family<br />

life (11.8% of employees adhere to elements of the “<strong>Banesto</strong> x ti”<br />

programme), all of which made <strong>Banesto</strong> one of the five best<br />

companies to work for in Spain for the fifth year running according<br />

to the ranking of Actualidad Económica.<br />

REMUNERATION<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> launched a Flexible Remuneration System for executives<br />

which enables part of the salary to be exchanged for various<br />

products with competitive prices and significant tax advantages.<br />

Every year we increase by 10% the executives included in this<br />

system as a way to ensure commitment and motivation.<br />

The Top 10 Executives Programme was consolidated in 2008. It<br />

covers those executives whose performance, results, capacity and<br />

potential require special treatment. There are currently 500<br />

executives in it. Forming part of it depends on meeting the criteria<br />

established.<br />

ASSESSMENT PROCESS<br />

A new assessment process was put into effect in 2008 for all staff,<br />

706 of them in the 360 o method and the rest in the System of<br />

Skills. This process is a new version of the former systems and puts<br />

the emphasis on interviews with line managers.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s employees combine<br />

Youth, experience and<br />

Diversity<br />

A total of 9,189 interviews were held and the corresponding<br />

improvement plans defined. As a result, 14,041 steps to improve<br />

results were identified, 11,518 for improving knowledge and 11,941<br />

for skills.<br />

TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT<br />

The main focus in 2008 was on improving management quality,<br />

seeking a management style more in tune with the times so as to<br />

make executives feel responsible for the commitment of their staff.<br />

All the bank’s executives participated in the programmes.<br />

As regards branches, the training for new managers and deputy<br />

managers was strengthened in the areas of credit quality and<br />

monitoring and negotiating and management skills.<br />

In line with the bank’s strategy for risks (culture and practice;<br />

selective growth in lending; proactive management of loans and<br />

optimising recovery management), an ambitious project of<br />

mentoring was incorporated to the training programme in order to<br />

improve knowledge of risks. Experts in this field also participate in<br />

the programme and give practical advice.<br />

15


16<br />

SME account managers were trained in 2008 in risk quality and<br />

optimising the spread on loans, as well as in the quality of service<br />

and closing sales.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> has quickly adapted to the new digital area, incorporating<br />

just-in-time learning and offering employees the maximum flexibility<br />

via high impact e-learning (more than 56,000 on-line courses and<br />

over 200,000 on-line training hours).<br />

The key elements of our<br />

management style are knowledge<br />

of people, permanent<br />

improvement through training<br />

and constant evaluation of<br />

quality<br />

In personal and private banking, we continued to provide the most<br />

qualified advice to clients on their portfolios and wealth. Training<br />

programmes increased executives’ knowledge of markets and<br />

helped them in the search for new business opportunities.<br />

We continued to work with the best Spanish and international<br />

business schools to develop the potential of our executives.<br />

RECONCILING WORK AND FAMILY LIFE, EQUALITY<br />

OF OPPORTUNUTY AND DIVERSITY<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s commitment to equality of opportunity and reconciling<br />

work and family life was given shape in a plan signed in December<br />

2007. It sets out the main lines for guaranteeing and fomenting<br />

equality of opportunity (training, remuneration and development)<br />

right from the moment when someone joins the bank. The existing<br />

measures for facilitating the reconciliation of work and family life<br />

and the range of solutions for all types of situation and profiles<br />

were strengthened.<br />

The main steps taken in 2008 were aimed at communicating the<br />

programme (22% rise in the degree of knowledge of the “<strong>Banesto</strong><br />

x ti” programme), as well as fomenting the measures that benefit<br />

male employees (98% of fathers made use of the five days off and<br />

81% requested paternity leave).<br />

The second Open Day was held in July in <strong>Banesto</strong>’s main offices<br />

for all employees and their families. More than 2,500 people took<br />

part.<br />

Open Day<br />

BANESTO OLYMPICS<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> held its first Olympics in 2008. More than 1,700<br />

employees participated in seven activities: seven-a-side football,<br />

3x3 basketball, paddle tennis, golf, ping pong and athletics. There<br />

were regional finals and then a national final in Barcelona. The<br />

winners received their trophies at the executives’ convention in<br />

Barcelona.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Olympics<br />

Olympic winners at the <strong>Banesto</strong> Convention with the Chairman, Ana P. Botín, and Rafa Nadal


Management data<br />

dec-08 dec-07 dec-06 dec-05<br />

PROFESSIONAL CAPITAL (CURRENT PROFILE)<br />

Total number of employees 9,718 9,923 9,708 9,468<br />

Average age 41.12 40.41 41.08 41.25<br />

Number of years at <strong>Banesto</strong> 17 16.34 17.42 18.49<br />

Diversity (women as % of total employees) 36.41% 35.77% 33.35% 33%<br />

Diversity (number of different nationalities) 28 25 23 25<br />

% of staff with a university degree 54% 53% 60% 58.8%<br />

Number of different degrees 93 87 82 104<br />

% of staff with the three most frequent degrees 38% 35.00% 35.14% 31.61%<br />

(% of employees with degrees) 76% 71%<br />

Internal promotion: promotions/total employees 13.59% 13.57% 14.58% 8.77%<br />

Average number of years in current post 3.79 3.53 3.2 3.56<br />

Average number of years in current centre 4.46 4.18 4.04 3.92<br />

% of employees with variable remuneration 100% 100% 100% 71.32%<br />

% of employees in commercial tasks in branches 84% 83% 79.37% 77%<br />

Internal functional rotation 15% 15.57% 12.57% 20.18%<br />

HUMAN POTENTIAL (CAPACITY TO IMPROVE)<br />

New employees/total employees 5.27% 15.38% 9.46% 5.03%<br />

Training hours per employee 65 71 63 55<br />

Training costs/personnel costs 1.82% 1.73% 1.54%<br />

% of employees with evaluation of skills 100% 100% 100% 100%<br />

Number of online training hours 226,735 205,912 177,488 135,000<br />

Number of e-learning courses completed 56,898 79,884 111,775 63,000<br />

Employees/total employees users of online training 80% 86% 87% 90%<br />

Employees in training/total employees 88% 88% 86% 85%<br />

Evaluation of the satisfaction of participants in training courses 8.7 8.6 8.6 8.5<br />

Index of application of training in the post occupied 8.49 8.42 8.34 8.00<br />

SOCIAL QUALITY (SOCIAL POLICIES)<br />

% of employees on a permanent contract 99.59% 98.45% 96.54% 96.50%<br />

SOCIAL RETURN (RETURN ON THE HUMAN FACTOR)<br />

Human factor cost: personnel costs/total operating costs 75.58% 77.16% 74.43% 77.20%<br />

ROI of human capital: gross operating income less operating costs per<br />

employee/personnel costs per employee 2.4 2.21 1.91 1.94<br />

Value added of human capital: gross operating income less operating<br />

costs/average number of employees 161.8 142.28 121.20 119.56<br />

Efficiency of wage bill: personnel costs/total revenues 26.62% 27.96% 30.63% 30.89%<br />

TRAINING<br />

By posts<br />

Commercial 63% 83.00% 68.86% 82.08%<br />

Technicians and other executives 36% 12.00% 27.88% 10.66%<br />

Support 1% 1.38% 3.26% 7.26%<br />

By age<br />

Under 30 43% 48.76% 41.45% 33.00%<br />

30-39 33% 28.77% 29.31% 26.00%<br />

40-49 18% 17.88% 22.98% 36.00%<br />

Over 50 6% 4.59% 6.26% 5.00%<br />

Resources for reconciling professional and family life<br />

Mobile phones 2,148 1,675 1,285 1,151<br />

PCs 3,939 2,411 2,575 2,296<br />

Selection process<br />

CVs managed 130,330 119,431 109,524 103,588<br />

Indices of quality<br />

Internal customer June 6.57 6.59 6.68 6.64<br />

Internal customer December n.d. n.d 6.58 6.86<br />

Employees in 360 o assessment 860 707 n.d 290<br />

Average number of evaluators per person evaluated 10 10 n.d 10<br />

17


18<br />

Risk Control<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> has a solid culture of<br />

risks firmly rooted in all<br />

employees<br />

The basic principles of risk management coupled with advanced tools<br />

and techniques for analysis and assessment enable us to face<br />

unfavourable changes in the environment with excellent credit quality.<br />

Our risk monitoring system predicts, anticipates and minimises on a<br />

sustained basis the impact of any deterioration in the portfolio of<br />

customers.<br />

Risk Control<br />

Non-performing loans ratio 1,62%<br />

NPL coverage 105,4%


anesto attaches great importance to quality in risk management,<br />

something that is consistent with a strategy of growth and<br />

financial soundness<br />

Our prudent management of risk and predictable levels over the last few years give us a competitive advantage in the current economic<br />

environment. Our mortgage risk admission policies of not participating in loans with high levels of leverage and focused on first home<br />

buyers – both real estate developers and individuals -, as well as a management style that anticipates risks, has made the quality of our<br />

portfolio excellent.<br />

Risk management is a competitive advantage for being close to customers, measuirng the risk that has to be assumed and setting an<br />

appropriate price. Thanks to the quality of our admission, monitoring and recovery systems, together with active and anticipative<br />

management of risks, <strong>Banesto</strong>'s risk quality continued to be excellent in 2008.<br />

BASIC PRINCIPLES OF BANESTO’S RISK<br />

MANAGEMENT:<br />

1. The risks function is INDEPENDENT of business when<br />

decisions are taken. The Risks Committee, which reports to the<br />

Board of Directors, defines the risk policies and validates the<br />

management tools which are adapted to the new Basel II<br />

capital accord.<br />

2. SENIOR MANAGEMENT IS INVOLVED in risk<br />

management and plays an active role in admitting and<br />

monitoring risk, as well as supervising the exposure of the main<br />

customers, economic sectors and types of risk in a systematic<br />

way in order to avoid the risk of concentration.<br />

3. ANTICIPATION through monitoring risks, assessing<br />

customers constantly and updating information on them. This<br />

enables us to minimise the impact in the event of high risk<br />

situations.<br />

4. PRUDENCE IN ADMISSION, setting new policies<br />

adapted to the market. Portfolios are actively managed and<br />

focused on improving <strong>Banesto</strong>’s risk profile in terms of quality.<br />

5. QUALITY SERVICE externally and internally, through<br />

the Q10 quality model which speeds up responses and<br />

coordination between the business area and the customer.<br />

6. ADVANCED MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES<br />

based on a methodology of analysis, evaluation and specific<br />

measurement of each customer segment.<br />

7. DEFINITIVE ADJUSTMENT to the New Basel Capital<br />

Accord (Basel II) through validation of our capital requirement<br />

model and development of methodologies and models which<br />

give us parameters for measuring and quantifying that facilitate<br />

global and efficient management of risk.<br />

8. The Risks Area COMPLEMENTS the different business<br />

areas. Risk management is fundamental for designing pricing<br />

policies.<br />

The Bank of Spain approved our internal risk control and capital<br />

consumption models.<br />

19


20<br />

Technology<br />

Our technolgy’s agility and<br />

flexibility to adapt, which enables<br />

processes to be continuously<br />

redesigned, is a key competitive<br />

advantage<br />

In an era where telematics and critical business processes are<br />

increasingly part of day-to-day activity, efficient and customer-focused<br />

information is a vital element for being able to attain a leadership<br />

position.<br />

The objective set by the Resources Area in its strategic Menara Plan is<br />

to ensure the business areas have powerful and cutting-edge systems<br />

(applications, operational models and processes) that give <strong>Banesto</strong>, in<br />

a scenario of flat costs, competitive advantages.


The Menara Plan maximises productivity and makes the<br />

distribution of resources efficient, thanks to its structure of<br />

automation, centralisation and optimisation of key processes, and<br />

the use of common “factories” with service contracts that ensure<br />

excellent levels of quality with low costs, in line with the best<br />

market prices. This model has become a best practice reference<br />

among banks.<br />

The Menara Plan, in its second year, is based on commercial<br />

efficiency (giving the bank a sales force and eliminating<br />

administrative tasks from the branches), efficiency in production<br />

(producing at low cost thanks to operational synergies and<br />

strategic IT platforms) and quality of service.<br />

COMMERCIAL AND PRODUCTIVE EFFICIENCY<br />

A new structure was approved in 2008 for the Retail Banking Area<br />

in order to anticipate the market’s requirements in the next cycle.<br />

The main objective of this reorganisation is to achieve a better<br />

alignment of business, segments and products at a time when the<br />

method and commercial systematics are crucial for achieving<br />

targets.<br />

The processes and structures of the network (regional and zones)<br />

have moved toward a more business focused model with lighter<br />

structures and a greater focus on customer management.<br />

Intermediate structures employed 5% of staff in branches in 2008,<br />

down from 13% in 2001. As regards the commercial force, more<br />

than 60% of posts in branches are sales jobs, with the consequent<br />

increase in customer attention.<br />

8%<br />

13%<br />

7.2%<br />

9%<br />

7.4%<br />

7%<br />

6.3%<br />

4.7%<br />

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

Back office staff as a proportion of total employees<br />

Intermediate structures as a proportion of branch staff<br />

6.3%<br />

5% 5%<br />

4.3% 3.5%<br />

2.8%<br />

Progress continued to be made on reducing the proportion of<br />

employees in back office tasks (from 8% in 2001 to 2.8% in<br />

2008). These advances enabled <strong>Banesto</strong> to produce with better<br />

quality and controls at a lower cost, using simple and streamlined<br />

processes.<br />

QUALITY<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> strives to have the best technology as the basis for<br />

commercial success, innovation and achieving recurrent cost<br />

savings. Significant investments were made in 2008 in technology<br />

in order to foster high added value and strategic projects aligned<br />

with the bank’s objectives, including among them:<br />

Ibanesto.com<br />

The new portal of the online bank (ibanesto.com) strengthens the<br />

multi channel relation and the service and contracting channels. Its<br />

more modern design follows the latest standards of usability which<br />

enable the user to carry out a dynamic and efficient management<br />

of contents and have their own specialised telephone center.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Broker<br />

The new <strong>Banesto</strong> Broker portal was installed in 2008 which has<br />

real time information on market prices, latest generation graphs<br />

and a wide range of tools: technical analysis of value and<br />

fundamentals, analysis of portfolios, virtual portfolio, watch list,<br />

prices, ranking and searcher of warrants, simulators of volatility,<br />

hedging and speculation, etc.<br />

Security<br />

The establishment of a new IT security via OTP authentication for<br />

online banking transfers provided customers with tranquillity,<br />

security, comfort and reliability.<br />

CRM<br />

Improvements were made to the customer relationship<br />

management (CRM) system by giving it commercial intelligence on<br />

the basis of the type of customer and a range of tailored products<br />

and services.<br />

Management of risks and recoveries<br />

Substantial improvements were made to risk and recovery systems,<br />

adapting them to the new business trends, strengthening the<br />

systems for analysing customers’ risks and controlling admission,<br />

and developing the factoring of processes and analysis systems.<br />

As regards the call centre for recoveries, where <strong>Banesto</strong> has<br />

benchmark methodology, a system known as Cobra was launched<br />

to control the process.<br />

Document Quality<br />

Measurement of document quality was incorporated to processes,<br />

backed by digitisation projects in order to improve the efficiency of<br />

the critical commercial processes and maintain the highest<br />

standards.<br />

Telephone service<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> has a telephone platform with very advanced CRM<br />

technology, CTI (integration of telephony and computers),<br />

recording of calls, OCM, etc. This platform has a dual multi<br />

discipline culture in calls with customers and non-customers and<br />

manages calls, e-mails, faxes, mail, SMS. Call blending was<br />

incorporated so that outbound calls can be handled while<br />

receiving inbound calls.<br />

The results of the quality plan were excellent: <strong>Banesto</strong> was ranked<br />

second in customer attention (telephone and mail) by AQMetrix<br />

and first in e-mails. In short, <strong>Banesto</strong> today is a reference bank in<br />

efficiency and quality of service.<br />

21


22<br />

Retail Banking<br />

Our customer relationship model<br />

is ahead of developments and the<br />

market<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s striving to become the best bank in customer relations was<br />

recognised by Euromoney which named it the best bank in Spain in<br />

2008.<br />

The launch of nine plans and 38 projects related to customers<br />

produced a significant increase in the number of customers and the<br />

launch of innovative products to meet their needs.


INDIVIDUAL CUSTOMERS<br />

A broad range of products and services was created, which are<br />

noteworthy for their simplicity and clarity and stand out from<br />

those of our competitors.<br />

Mortgages are the main source of our new customers. The payroll<br />

account and the domiciling of receipts increased the volume of<br />

transactions. A relationship model was created around these<br />

products that goes beyond that of a one-off campaign:<br />

• Connecting households to communication networks via the gift<br />

of an HP Compaq PC.<br />

• Gift of a 32 inch Toshiba TV.<br />

This way of working for and with customers has produced<br />

significant results and helped to manage household economies.<br />

Particularly noteworthy is that the number of customers in the<br />

“Tarifa Plana” account surpassed 900,000 and almost 400,000<br />

new payrolls were domiciled in accounts, bringing the total to<br />

900,000. We continued to increase the number of linked<br />

customers (those with four or more products); the average number<br />

rose from 4.4 to 4.6 and the number of receipts domiciled grew by<br />

more than 900,000.<br />

COLLECTIVES<br />

The <strong>Banesto</strong> Justice Club has 30,000 customers between judges,<br />

magistrates, lawyers and secretaries of courts. The Colegio<br />

Nacional de Secretarios Judiciales awarded <strong>Banesto</strong> a prize for the<br />

technological excellence of its management of the courts’<br />

accounts.<br />

Our offer of products and<br />

services stands out from those<br />

of our competitors for their<br />

simplicity and clarity<br />

PERSONAL BANKING<br />

Personal banking continued to advance and secure a model that<br />

puts the emphasis on personalised advice through total coverage<br />

of needs by all our branches. Their management capacity was<br />

strengthened by the incorporation of 100 specialised<br />

managers who, together with the branch managers, guarantee<br />

permanent contact with the segment’s more than 70,000<br />

customers.<br />

The Personal Banking Services Centre was consolidated.<br />

This has 45 specialised managers and ensures that all<br />

customers have a financial advisor and the best tools for achieving<br />

the maximum return on investments. Our ability to anticipate the<br />

market and take advantage of opportunities enables us to provide<br />

a very attractive range of products and services for our customers.<br />

Of note among them are new structured deposits with the capital<br />

fully or partially guaranteed, depending on the demands and<br />

investor profile, and the “Gama Selecta”: the most competitive<br />

mortgage, the “Selecta” card for the most demanding customers,<br />

personal loans and exclusive insurance.<br />

PRIVATE BANKING<br />

Our objective in private banking is to achieve greater proximity<br />

through a customer relationship model that is largely based on our<br />

extensive network of branches and managers. In addition, we<br />

increased the number of account managers and created a new<br />

team of investment specialists. We also established a larger and<br />

better level of information by setting up new channels such as<br />

“reports of market expectations” or “management of portfolios”,<br />

depending on customers’ preferences.<br />

SMES<br />

Our model in this area focuses on the branches with a greater<br />

potential, where our specialised sales force is concentrated. We<br />

manage portfolios using the Banespyme concept: SMEs are seen in<br />

the full context of relations with suppliers, customers, employees<br />

and partners. This strategy enabled the number of new customers<br />

to surpass 28,000.<br />

This model, which incorporates innovative proposals and<br />

cooperates with various public and private sector institutions,<br />

enables SME clients to develop their businesses.<br />

Of note are:<br />

• Learning to Export Programme, organised by ICEX, which helps<br />

first-time exporters.<br />

• “ICO Pymes” Line and ICO “Avanza”, which finance improvements<br />

made by SMEs in technology and communications.<br />

• <strong>Banesto</strong> Enisa Sepi Desarrollo<br />

venture capital fund, focused on<br />

investing in high growth<br />

potential SMEs. In three<br />

years it has taken stakes in<br />

16 companies.<br />

• Development of a<br />

project within the<br />

framework of the<br />

Excellence in<br />

Management Club in<br />

cooperation<br />

with the EOI,<br />

which aims to<br />

transfer to the<br />

world of SMEs<br />

the management<br />

models of Spain’s<br />

leading<br />

companies.<br />

23


24<br />

SHOPS<br />

Integral products and services to foster the growth of shops and<br />

help their day-to-day management through the branch network.<br />

More than 32 agreements were signed with the main franchises in<br />

Spain and 63 cooperation agreements with associations of local<br />

shops.<br />

These actions enabled <strong>Banesto</strong> to increase its presence in sectors<br />

such as pharmaceuticals, good, health, cosmetics, cars and beauty.<br />

Our support for technological development and modernisation<br />

made <strong>Banesto</strong> the leader in GPRS point-of-sale terminals in the 4B<br />

system (market share of 26.9%).<br />

We captured 21,000 new customers in 2008.<br />

THE SELF-EMPLOYED<br />

This segment also enjoys products and services tailored to their<br />

needs. Actions in 2008 included:<br />

The gift of a 32 inch LCD TV to all those who domicile regular<br />

income of more than €800 a month and three main receipts.<br />

Those who domicile payment of their taxes or the receipts of the<br />

special regime of self-employed workers (RETA) and contribute<br />

€3,000 to their pension plan or a mutual fund can select a gift.<br />

Agreements were made with various business groups that<br />

contribute added value by offering other non-financial services<br />

that cover needs. Of note among them are communication with<br />

Orange and labour risk prevention with the MGOP Group.<br />

Agreements were also made with professional groupings and<br />

associations, such as OPA Extremadura, the Association of Madrid<br />

Taxi drivers and the Association of Andalusian Taxi Drivers, that<br />

provide financial services to all their members.<br />

Thanks to these agreements, <strong>Banesto</strong> incorporated more than<br />

23,000 new customers (market share of 4.6%, one point more<br />

than in 2007).<br />

Sube<br />

a la red<br />

BANESTO NATURA<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Natura, which specialises in the rural world, continued to<br />

offer products and services to the whole sector. Of particular note<br />

were the agreements with leading public and private sector<br />

institutions to install new information and communication<br />

technologies and improve farming through latest technology<br />

machinery.<br />

The steps taken in 2008 included:<br />

• CAP development throughout Spain. More than 45,000<br />

operations consolidated <strong>Banesto</strong> as the leader.<br />

• Development of new information and communication<br />

technologies through agreements with the Industry and Energy<br />

Ministry and eight events attended by more than 10,000 people.<br />

• Joint lines of action with various official institutions (Agriculture<br />

Ministry and ministries in regions) to finance the cattle sector in<br />

exceptional conditions (2,400 loans for a total of more than<br />

€51 million).<br />

• Cooperation agreements with suppliers of machinery to facilitate<br />

financing in special conditions.<br />

INSTITUTIONS<br />

More than 2,300 public institutions (town councils, town halls, etc)<br />

and 4,350 private institutions (foundations, professional colleges,<br />

religious congregations) are provided with products and services.<br />

MARKETING AND PRODUCTS<br />

This area developed measures and plans which made 2008 the<br />

year of the “Winning Spirit.”<br />

Innovative products associated with the tennis champion Rafa<br />

Nadal were created, such as “Ofertas Nómina” (payroll cheques<br />

deposited in accounts), consumer loans and the Match Point card.<br />

The payroll campaigns established a new type of relation with<br />

customers with the launch of two very attractive products: “Sube a<br />

la Red” campaign (customers who domicile their salary and bills<br />

receive a HP Compaq personal computer) and the TV 32”<br />

campaign (gift of a Toshiba 32” TV with TDT).<br />

Both campaigns were driving forces behind the capturing of new<br />

customers and positioned <strong>Banesto</strong> as the bank with the best<br />

payroll offer. More than 400,000 people signed up.


FUNDS<br />

Of note was the gain in market share of 30 b.p., with a<br />

contribution from sight deposits of 40 b.p., mainly backed by the<br />

payroll campaigns and a considerable rise in transactional business.<br />

The “Sobre Ruedas” deposit was launched. This is a unique time<br />

deposit with a remuneration in kind – a car or a motorbike<br />

depending on the amount and the maturity period.<br />

Other innovative and tailored products launched in 2008 were the<br />

“Titanio” and “Titanio Plus” deposits and mutual funds such as<br />

“Fondepósito” and “Liquidez deuda Pública”, leaders in capturing<br />

funds.<br />

CONSUMER LOANS<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> was one of the first banks to launch a revolving credit, the<br />

“Préstamo 15-30-40”, which using the points of a tennis match<br />

and the image of Rafa Nadal offers customers the possibility of<br />

being able to avail themselves of their money at the maturity of 15,<br />

30 and 40 months.<br />

The Match Point card was also created. This provides significant<br />

benefits for cardholders through one of the best points<br />

programmes in the market; the <strong>Banesto</strong> Premium Class points<br />

programme offers flights and access to VIP lounges in airports<br />

around the world via Priority Pass. More than 150,000 cards were<br />

issued during 2008.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> continued its revolving credit strategy through the “Tarjeta<br />

Diez en Una”. More than 200,000 of these cards were issued.<br />

The total stock of our cards is more than 2.3 million (1.23 million<br />

credit cards and more than 1.1 million debit).<br />

CUSTOMER RELATIONS<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s strategy is a multi channel one in order to increase the<br />

capacity of contact with our customers and be able to make major<br />

improvements to the products and services offered via<br />

www.banesto.es, our telephone banking service, ATMs and banking<br />

through a mobile phone. Of note was the launch of a new platform<br />

for securities, futures and options.<br />

Banesnet, our online bank, increased the number of its active<br />

customers by 40%. Transfers through this channel represented<br />

45% of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s total and securities operations 20%.<br />

The telephone platform received 1.5 million calls, 93% of which<br />

were tended to in less than 20 seconds. More than 200,000 emails<br />

were answered, 74% more than in 2007.<br />

IBANESTO.COM<br />

The online bank ibanesto.com changed both its aspect and its<br />

strategy of direct banking in order to become a reference in this<br />

market. Its whole structure was revised:<br />

• The portfolio of products so as to offer the most competitive<br />

ones.<br />

• The corporate image, the blue products and low cost banking,<br />

transmitting to customers the message that ibanesto “spends less<br />

in order to give more.”<br />

• The website, making it simpler in contents and how to surf it.<br />

• The processes of contracting products, introducing contracting<br />

by telephone and strengthening all the internal processes.<br />

The impact was quickly seen: more than 50,000 new customers in<br />

2008 and leading the capturing of funds in the direct banking<br />

market (more than €700 million).<br />

25


26<br />

Banking for companies<br />

Anticipation is a key factor in<br />

management<br />

2008 was the second year of the 2007-09 Strategic Plan for this<br />

segment. Our strategy of anticipating developments enabled <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

to successfully face a year of uncertainty in the markets. The progress<br />

made in previous years to improve the quality of products and services<br />

as well as ensure the selection and training of the best teams<br />

enhanced customer satisfaction and linkage and set <strong>Banesto</strong> apart<br />

from its main competitors.<br />

Growth in gross operating income maintained<br />

This strategy was endorsed by the significant rise in business volumes:<br />

both lending and funds grew by 16% and gross operating income was<br />

20% higher.


<strong>Banesto</strong>’s strategy for companies is based on differentiation,<br />

speed, agility, flexibility, effectiveness and innovation. Market<br />

conditions also underscored our capacity to adapt and anticipate.<br />

The following areas were worked on during 2008:<br />

• Risks. While the focus in previous years was to speed up circuits<br />

and processes in order to respond more quickly and with higher<br />

quality to customers, in 2008 it was on managing a fast-changing<br />

environment.<br />

• The joint work of commercial teams and risk management<br />

specialists helped customers to anticipate many situations arising<br />

from market tensions. The success of this policy is well reflected<br />

in the quality of our lending portfolio.<br />

• Management of spreads. The excessive liquidity generated in<br />

previous years triggered distortions in price-setting which were<br />

often not reflected correctly in risk premiums. This phenomenon<br />

put well managed companies at a disadvantage as they saw how<br />

their less qualified competitors were able to obtain similar<br />

conditions. In 2008, greater emphasis was placed on the policy<br />

of prices in order to adjust them to activity and each company’s<br />

business volume.<br />

• Products. <strong>Banesto</strong> maintained its commitment to provide the<br />

best products, updating and improving them.<br />

Continuous improvement in<br />

products and management<br />

processes to achieve greater<br />

customer linkage and<br />

satisfaction<br />

We continued to grow at a faster pace than our peers in syndicated<br />

loans, project finance, electronic banking, foreign trade, confirming,<br />

leasing, renting and factoring.<br />

In capital markets, <strong>Banesto</strong> remained the leader in structured loans<br />

for companies and led most of the operations, contributing a<br />

differential value to customers in sectors such as renewable energy,<br />

health, shipping and industry.<br />

In mergers and acquisitions, the bank consolidated itself in 2008<br />

as one of the leaders in Spain of buying/selling medium-sized<br />

companies. We advised more than 40 clients.<br />

The excellent acceptance of confirming, coupled with the<br />

magnificent work by teams of specialists, produced growth of 36%<br />

in this product.<br />

Factoring continued to grow at a much faster pace than that of our<br />

main competitors (30% vs. 18%), enabling the bank to consolidate<br />

its third position in the ranking. Our online bank BanesNet<br />

continued to capture new customers. At the end of 2008, 90% of<br />

our customers used BanesNet for their normal transactions.<br />

New foreign trade functions were incorporated in 2008, enabling<br />

online customers to easily conduct sophisticated operations such<br />

as opening import documentary credits or financing payments<br />

abroad, as well as obtain information on all their transactions.<br />

We will continue to grow and<br />

strive to become the reference<br />

bank for spanish companies<br />

A public foreign trade portal was launched in order to help<br />

strengthen the international development of our customers,<br />

facilitating commercial contacts as well as other personalised<br />

services, such as: the regulations for labelling products in all<br />

countries, standardisation rules and customs duties.<br />

More than 12,000 companies already use the foreign trade<br />

products and services; the rates of growth in 2008 were double<br />

the market’s which meant we continued to gain market share<br />

(+0.40 p.p.).<br />

The range of treasury products continued to provide customers<br />

with solutions for risks arising from interest rates, currency and raw<br />

materials and to increase the generation of revenues.<br />

• Customers. We continued the steps taken in 2007 to focus<br />

activity on the largest customers and with a turnover of more<br />

than €10 million.<br />

The cooperation of all levels of the commercial network with<br />

regional managers, centre managers and branch managers was very<br />

important.<br />

More than 900 companies with high growth potential were<br />

captured as clients.<br />

A considerable effort is made to<br />

ensure the best people are<br />

selected to work for <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

and trained<br />

• Employees. One of the main factors of success in 2008 was<br />

active management of employees and development of training<br />

and motivation programmes.<br />

The main challenge in 2009 is to continue growing at a faster pace<br />

than the rest of the market, both in business volumes and results.<br />

27


28<br />

Wholesale Banking<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> is a global supplier of<br />

products and services and helps<br />

to implement and develop new<br />

financial solutions in order to be<br />

in the vanguard of banking<br />

In a complex market environment, the Wholesale Banking Area’s<br />

activity and earnings continued to grow, as well as creating value for<br />

the bank and customers. All the area’s units contributed to this<br />

improvement, met their goals and continued to strictly control risk.


MARKETS<br />

This unit is responsible for resolving clients’ needs in all matters<br />

related to the capital and stock markets and treasury products.<br />

More than 20,000 operations<br />

were conducted with clients<br />

in 2008<br />

More than 20,000 operations were carried out during 2008,<br />

underscoring the success of the usefulness of our products. The<br />

Markets’ Unit generated €223 million of revenue for the bank,<br />

22% more than in 2007.<br />

The Capital Markets Unit led xx lending operations for Spanish<br />

companies. Of note was the xx% increase in loans to finance the<br />

international expansion of clients.<br />

The capital markets unit took<br />

part in the main operations to<br />

finance spanish companies<br />

abroad<br />

Also noteworthy was <strong>Banesto</strong>’s increasing participation in the<br />

structuring and financing of renewable energy projects (wind<br />

power, photovoltaic and solar). A total of 37 operations were<br />

conducted amounting to €400 million.<br />

Sept. 2008<br />

CAD 1,094,000,000<br />

Availability / Toll Road<br />

Mandated Lead Arranger<br />

Jun. 2008<br />

$ 246,000,000<br />

Syndicated Loan<br />

Mandated Lead Arranger<br />

Jun. 2008<br />

$ 150,000,000<br />

Syndicated Loan<br />

Mandated Lead<br />

Arranger<br />

The Corporate Finance Unit was particularly active during 2008,<br />

responding to the needs of clients whose operations affected the<br />

capital of their companies (search for partners, sale, acquisitions,<br />

etc).<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Bolsa, <strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring and our New York office worked<br />

with the Wholesale Banking Area, thereby ensuring the widest<br />

range of products.<br />

CORPORATE BANKING<br />

Another wholesale banking activity is corporate banking. This unit<br />

meets the needs of those companies which because of their size,<br />

singularity and complexity require tailored solutions.<br />

The range of products complement those of other wholesale<br />

banking units such as treasury, capital markets and corporate<br />

finance.<br />

Its earnings were 7.7% higher in 2008 at €170 million. These<br />

results were achieved with a more efficient management of the<br />

balance sheet and of the unit’s funds.<br />

Corporate banking continued<br />

to grow and with a lower risk<br />

exposure<br />

The wholesale banking model delivers products quickly, enabling<br />

clients to adapt rapidly to the changing needs and opportunities<br />

of markets.<br />

International Operations of Capital Markets with Corporate Banking Clients<br />

Feb. 2008<br />

$ 399,000,000<br />

Toll Road<br />

Arranger<br />

Jun. 2008<br />

$ 400,000,000<br />

Syndicated Loan<br />

Mandated Lead Arranger<br />

Jun. 2008<br />

$ 1,110,000<br />

LNG Regasification Plant<br />

Mandated Lead Arranger/<br />

Syndicated Agent<br />

29


30<br />

The <strong>Banesto</strong> Share<br />

January 08<br />

The return on the <strong>Banesto</strong> share<br />

was 60% in the last six years<br />

(From january 1, 2003 to december 31, 2008<br />

including dividends)<br />

The downturn in the international macroeconomic environment and<br />

particularly the global financial crisis caused all stock markets to fall in<br />

2008. Despite its good results and solid fundamentals, the <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

share ended the year at €8.08, down 39.29% over 2007. The Dow<br />

Jones Stoxx 600 Banks Index plummeted 64%.<br />

THE BANESTO SHARE PRICE PERFORMANCE COMPARED TO THAT OF THE DOW<br />

JONES STOXX 600 BANKS INDEX IN 2008<br />

June 08<br />

December 08


CAPITAL STOCK<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> reduced its capital stock in 2008 by €5,485,207 by<br />

redeeming 6,943,300 shares owned by the bank, previously<br />

acquired after obtaining approval from the Shareholders’ Meeting<br />

at the beginning of the year.<br />

The capital stock stood at €543,035,570,42 (five hundred and<br />

forty three million thirty five thousand five hundred and seventy<br />

euros and forty two cents), represented by 687,386,798 shares of<br />

79 cents nominal value each, numbered from one to 687,386,798<br />

inclusive and which are fully subscribed and disbursed and<br />

constitute a single series.<br />

The shares are traded on the continuous market of the four<br />

Spanish stock exchanges (Madrid, Barcelona, Valencia and Bilbao).<br />

SHAREHOLDER REMUNERATION<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s Board of Directors approved the dividend policy to be<br />

implemented provided there are no extraordinary circumstances.<br />

The policy is as follows:<br />

1. Pay-out of around 50% of the bank’s recurrent profit.<br />

2. Payment of quarterly dividends charged to the year’s earnings<br />

in August, November and February, and a final one agreed at<br />

the AGM.<br />

Each dividend will be distributed under a specific agreement of the<br />

Board, which will be taken once it is known there are sufficient<br />

profits and liquidity for payments, in accordance with the prevailing<br />

regulations.<br />

The dividend per share in 2008 was €0.56.<br />

DISTRIBUTION OF THE CAPITAL STOCK<br />

MARKET CAPITALISATION<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s market capitalisation at the end of 2008 was €5,554<br />

million, making it the xx largest Spanish company in the benchmark<br />

Ibex 35 index and the fourth biggest bank.<br />

COVERAGE OF THE SHARE<br />

We continued to foster the growth and trading of the share by<br />

maintaining active communication with analysts and investors, etc.<br />

There are currently 23 analysts covering the <strong>Banesto</strong> stock on an<br />

ongoing basis.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> was one of the most recommended shares to buy among<br />

Spanish and European banks. The average daily volume of shares<br />

traded was €8.6 million.<br />

RATINGS FROM AGENCIES<br />

S&P<br />

Moody’s<br />

Fitchratings<br />

Long term Short term<br />

AA A-1+<br />

Aa2 P-1<br />

AA F1+<br />

Shareholders Shares % of Capital Stock<br />

Board of Directors 14 704,908 0.10<br />

Institutional* 122 649,627,069 94.51<br />

Individuals 85,496 37,054,821 5.39<br />

85,632 687,386,798 100.00<br />

* Including Banco Santander, the majority shareholder, which holds directly and indirectly 89.28% of capital stock.<br />

DISTRIBUTION OF CAPITAL STOCK BY NUMBER OF SHARES<br />

Number of shares Shareholders Shares % of Capital Stock<br />

1 to 250 59,253 5,509,062 0.80<br />

251 to 500 11,955 4,283,616 0.62<br />

500 to 1.000 7,767 5,591,433 0.81<br />

1,001 to 5,000 5,596 11,360,688 1.65<br />

more than 5,000* 1,061 660,641,999 96.11<br />

85,632 687,386,798 100.00<br />

31


32<br />

Corporate social<br />

responsibility<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s csr is based on a well<br />

defined strategy and policy that<br />

guarantees responsible<br />

management, a beneficial impact on<br />

society and contributes to a more<br />

sustainable environment<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s CSR provides an integral focus based on its vision and values<br />

and a strategy and policy approved by the Board. These aspects are the<br />

starting point for harmonising the business objectives and needs and<br />

expectations of stakeholders, creating constant and balanced value in<br />

conditions of social and environmental sustainability.


Responsible management entails complying with legislation and<br />

commitments acquired and focuses on quality in managing<br />

customers, transparency with shareholders, the importance of<br />

employees, control of risks and responsible behaviour throughout<br />

the supply chain. This framework lays the foundations for<br />

increasing the impact of CSR on society and contributing to a<br />

more sustainable environment.<br />

COMMITMENT TO OUR STAKEHOLDERS<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s corporate social responsibility (CSR) represents a<br />

commitment to all our stakeholders to create constant and<br />

balanced value and in conditions of social and environmental<br />

sustainability.<br />

It is based on two main principles:<br />

1.- aligning the bank’s vision and values and generating internal<br />

synergies between foundations and business areas in order to<br />

make social and economic objectives complementary and<br />

2.- cooperating with other companies and institutions in order to<br />

increase the impact of the measures taken via networks with<br />

public and private agents.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s CSR framework<br />

Dialogue with<br />

stakeholders<br />

Fostering the<br />

entrepreneurial<br />

spirit<br />

HALLMARKS OF OUR CSR STRATEGY<br />

The hallmark of our CSR strategy is the fostering of an<br />

entrepreneurial spirit together with innovation, dissemination of<br />

new technologies and protecting the environment.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> believes that a country’s prosperity is linked to the<br />

entrepreneurial capacity of its citizens. This philosophy is behind<br />

our support for SMEs and is coherent with the bank’s strategy of<br />

becoming the bank for companies.<br />

Access to new technologies is a key element for society’s<br />

modernisation and competitiveness. For this reason, their<br />

dissemination among collectives who have difficulties doing this is<br />

a priority area of our CSR.<br />

Respect for environmental sustainability in all our actions is<br />

another important part of our CSR. The Ecobanesto plan to<br />

protect the environment and the fight against climate change limits<br />

defines our scope.<br />

Dialogue with<br />

stakeholders<br />

Vision and Values<br />

Strategy and Policy<br />

Strategy Policy Organisation<br />

Responsible Management<br />

Compliance Risks Quality Value for<br />

Shareholders<br />

People Suppliers<br />

Impact on Society Sustainable Environment<br />

Innovation<br />

and new<br />

technologies<br />

Rural<br />

Development<br />

Humanitarian<br />

Actions<br />

Strategy,<br />

Policy and<br />

Management<br />

Ecobanesto<br />

Plan<br />

Environmental<br />

Financing<br />

33<br />

Dialogue with<br />

stakeholders


34<br />

Main advances in CSR<br />

in 2008<br />

Measures were taken in 2008 to consolidate the<br />

path of CSR<br />

STRATEGY AND POLICY<br />

• The Board approves the CSR policy at the proposal of the<br />

Sustainability Committee.<br />

• Consolidation of the Sustainability Committee, coordinated by<br />

the Chairman’s Office and comprising all areas with an impact on<br />

sustainability.<br />

• Adherence to the ethical principles of the United Nations Global<br />

Compact.<br />

• Entry into the selective FTSE4Good Ibex, which only covers<br />

those companies that meet the most exacting standards in CSR.<br />

• Publication of the CSR<br />

Report drawn up on the<br />

basis of the Global<br />

Reporting Initiative<br />

(GRI) at it’s A+ level.<br />

optional obligatory<br />

RESPONSIBLE MANAGEMENT<br />

• Development of the Regulatory Compliance Model. MiFID<br />

regulations applied.<br />

• Launch of the <strong>Banesto</strong> Responde Centre, Q10 Model Branch,<br />

Q10 Challenge, self-assessment of the quality of service, Quality<br />

Committee and Domina Programme.<br />

• Improvement of 0.56 in the Q10 indicator of quality.<br />

• Launch of the “Depósito Sostenible”, a socially responsible<br />

investment project.<br />

• Greater communication with shareholders and investors. 658<br />

consultations resolved, 10 road shows, attendance at the main<br />

international banking conferences and more than 200 meetings.<br />

• Consolidation of the environmental rating and launch of new<br />

tools.<br />

• Human Resources Master Plan put into effect.<br />

Rating level A+<br />

Self-declaration<br />

• New process for evaluating the performance of employees.<br />

IMPACT ON SOCIETY<br />

• 4,000 SMEs trained via the Banespyme School.<br />

�<br />

Gri verification �<br />

• More than 370 entrepreneurial experiences and 2 million videos<br />

seen on the Internet TV channel emprendedorestv.com. The<br />

channel emprenedorstv.com was launched in October in<br />

cooperation with the Industry Ministry and the government of<br />

Catalonia and the support of Microsoft. It received more than<br />

160,000 visits in the first two months.<br />

Presentation of emprenedorstv.com<br />

• Investment in two new companies by the Enisa Sepi Desarrollo<br />

venture capital firm, bringing the total number to 16 and<br />

providing direct employment to 312 people.<br />

• Solidaridad x 2. Plumpy Nuts Christmas campaign with Unicef,<br />

which enabled employees to buy a food product that helped to<br />

feed more than 17,000 children in Africa.<br />

- Employees’ contributions: €57,400<br />

- Solidaridad x 2 contribution: €57,400<br />

- TOTAL: €114,828<br />

• Solidarity and Sustainability Tourism project: 250 establishments<br />

certified and more than 20 alternative routes drawn up in 11<br />

African countries. Thirty seven <strong>Banesto</strong> employees worked in the<br />

project.<br />

First programme of Volunteers in Solidarity and Sustainable tourism in Africa<br />

• 6,551 participants in six Ciberplaza meetings to foster the use of<br />

ITCs in rural development.<br />

• Sixth edition of the Solidaridad x 2 programme.<br />

SUSTAINABLE ENVIRONMENT<br />

• Ecobanesto Plan for the Protection of the Environment put into<br />

effect.<br />

• Reduction of 9% (consumption of materials, emissions, waste).<br />

• <strong>Banesto</strong> consolidates its leadership in the Spanish market in<br />

financing environmental projects and renewable energy.


Main prizes and<br />

Recognitions<br />

• Euromoney awards for excellence to the<br />

Best Bank in Spain in 2008.<br />

• Entry into the FTSE4Good IBEX.<br />

• EFQM Excellence stamp<br />

+500 points<br />

• Cinco días prize for the most<br />

innovative initiative in corporate<br />

social responsibility.<br />

• Certification of quality and excellence and<br />

customer confidence prize from<br />

Madrid Excelente.<br />

• Banca 15 prize for the best bank in<br />

product innovation in 2008.<br />

• Excellence award for introduction of<br />

new technologies and<br />

modernisation of the justice<br />

administration of the Colegio Nacional<br />

de Secretarios Judiciales.<br />

• For the fifth year running one of the<br />

five best companies to work for in<br />

spain, according to the ranking of<br />

actualidad económica.<br />

35


36<br />

Corporate Governance<br />

Full equality of shareholders’ rights<br />

and maximum transparency<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> put into effect in 2008 the recommendations it assumed in the Code of Good Governance<br />

and, specifically, the measures taken to guarantee that all shareholders are treated equally.<br />

2008 saw the full implementation by <strong>Banesto</strong> of the<br />

recommendations assumed in the Unified Code of Good<br />

Governance published in May 2006, although most of them<br />

already formed part of the bank’s good governance procedures<br />

and practices. In other cases, changes were made in some precepts<br />

in order to improve the regulation of certain matters. In the few<br />

cases where it was decided not to fully assume the<br />

recommendations, the Board duly explained its decision.<br />

Over the last few years the Board has strengthened ways to<br />

dialogue with shareholders and has fostered and facilitated their<br />

informed participation in Shareholders’ Meetings.<br />

FULL EQUALITY OF SHAREHOLDERS’ RIGHTS<br />

The AGM held in February put into practice the measures adopted<br />

to guarantee the same treatment for all shareholders. In order to<br />

qualify to attend Shareholders’ Meetings, a shareholder only needs<br />

to hold any number of shares five days before the date of the<br />

meeting, and splitting the vote of financial intermediaries acting on<br />

behalf of various clients is allowed.<br />

As in other years, the option of attending remotely and the<br />

telematic vote is facilitated, and the various points on the agenda<br />

are voted on separately. The chairman of the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee is also called on to speak at these<br />

meetings.<br />

TRANSPARENCY<br />

One of the guiding principles of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s corporate governance<br />

model is transparent information; it is a key element for generating<br />

confidence and security in the markets.<br />

The detailed information provided by the various communication<br />

channels underscores our commitment to transparency.<br />

Since 2006 we have set out the remuneration of all directors.<br />

The AGM in 2008 presented for the first time, in accordance with<br />

the Board’s Regulations, the Annual report on the Remuneration<br />

Policy for 2007 drawn up by the Board at the proposal of the<br />

Appointments and Remuneration Committee.<br />

BALANCED BOARD OF DIRETCORS<br />

Most of the members of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s Board are non-executive<br />

directors (10 out of a total of 14), seven of whom are independent.<br />

In accordance with the Unified Code, the chairmen of the<br />

Appointments and Remuneration Committee and of the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee are independent directors.


38<br />

Financial Information<br />

ROE 16.6%<br />

Efficiency ratio 39%<br />

Non-performing loans ratio 1.62%


2008 Income Statement<br />

Net interest income<br />

40<br />

42<br />

Net fees and insurance activity 43<br />

Gains (losses) on financial transactions 44<br />

Gross operating income 44<br />

Gross operating income by business areas 45<br />

Retail Banking 45<br />

Domestic Corporate Banking 45<br />

Markets 46<br />

Non-financial affiliates net results 46<br />

Operating Costs 46<br />

Net operating income 48<br />

Asset deterioration losses 48<br />

Other net income 49<br />

Profits 49<br />

2008 Balance Sheet 50<br />

Customer loans 52<br />

Doubtful loans 53<br />

Country risk xx<br />

Foreclosed assets 54<br />

Customer funds 54<br />

Shareholders’ equity<br />

Financial information of the main<br />

56<br />

entities of the <strong>Banesto</strong> group 57<br />

2004-2008 Performance 59<br />

Highlights 59<br />

Results 59<br />

Lending 59<br />

Customer funds 61<br />

Shareholders’ equity 61<br />

39


40<br />

2008 Income Statement<br />

Banking in 2008 was conducted against a more difficult economic<br />

background than envisaged, with sharp falls in economic activity and<br />

tensions in markets, which triggered a significant slowdown in the pace<br />

of business growth and a sharp rise in the financial system’s nonperforming<br />

loans.<br />

In this complicated environment, thanks to an appropriate choice of<br />

management priorities, <strong>Banesto</strong> generated quality results. It<br />

outperformed the sector in growth in revenues, results and earnings<br />

per share, enabling it to face the next few years from a position of<br />

solid financial strength.<br />

Moreover, in order to anticipate possible effects arising from the<br />

economic downturn, €60 million was allocated to special reserves.<br />

Including this strengthening of provisions, <strong>Banesto</strong>’s consolidated<br />

profit before taxes was €1,085.7 million, 1.3% less than in 2007.<br />

Attributable profit was 2% higher at €779.8 million.<br />

ROE was 16.6% and earnings per share grew 3%.


Consolidated income statement<br />

Million euros<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Interest and similar revenues 5,443.28 4,611.47 18.0%<br />

Interest and similar expenses 3,805.64 3,150.38 20.8%<br />

Net interest income 1,637.64 1,461.09 12.1%<br />

Income from companies accounted by equity method 1.87 1.71 9.8%<br />

Net fees and commissions 562.37 574.44 -2.1%<br />

From mutual and pension funds 139.13 191.91 -27.5%<br />

From services 423.24 382.53 10.6%<br />

Insurance activity 108.25 95.91 12.9%<br />

Gains (losses) on financial transactions 151.41 137.97 9.7%<br />

Gross operating income 2,461.54 2,271.11 8.4%<br />

Non-financial affiliates net results 8.32 9.21 -9.7%<br />

Net operating costs 867.04 826.24 4.9%<br />

a/personnel 655.29 637.52 2.8%<br />

b/general 233.87 221.81 5.4%<br />

c/Recoveries -22.11 -33.09 -33.2%<br />

Depreciation and amortization of fixed and intangible assets 100.19 97.62 2.6%<br />

Other operating income and expenses -39.73 -36.35 9.3%<br />

Net operating income 1,462.89 1,320.12 10.8%<br />

Asset deterioration losses 337.01 230.23 46.4%<br />

- Loan loss provisions (net) 299.76 229.10 30.8%<br />

- Other write-offs 37.25 1.13 n,s,<br />

Other net income -40.23 10.21 n,s,<br />

Profit before taxes 1,085.66 1,100.10 -1.3%<br />

Corporate tax 306.21 335.53 -8.7%<br />

Net consolidated profit 779.44 764.57 1.9%<br />

Minority interests -0.40 0.01 n,s,<br />

Attributable profit 779.84 764.57 2.0%<br />

41


42<br />

Net interest income<br />

million euros<br />

1,461.09<br />

+12.1%<br />

1,637.64<br />

2007 2008<br />

Net interest income<br />

Net interest income was 12.1% higher than in 2007 at €1,637.6<br />

million. This increase of €176.5 million, in a very competitive<br />

environment, was due to selective growth in lending, focusing on<br />

the capturing of deposits and good management of the balance<br />

sheet and of spreads.<br />

The table sets out the structure of net interest income, with the<br />

average balances, the revenues and costs associated with them and<br />

the interest rates received and paid for the respective items.<br />

Average total assets amounted to €103,406 million, 5.2% more<br />

than in 2007. This growth, the fruit of business plans developed<br />

during the year, was focused on the most profitable assets.<br />

Customer loans accounted for 85% of the increase. They<br />

represented 68% of the total (67% in 2007) and generated 79%<br />

Average return on assets<br />

in thousands of euros<br />

Net consolidated profit<br />

million euros<br />

764.57<br />

+1.9%<br />

779.44<br />

2007 2008<br />

of total revenues (76% in 2007), while the rest of assets, less<br />

profitable, only increased by €732 million, underscoring the<br />

quality of net interest income. The growth in business was largely<br />

financed by customer deposits; they rose by €6,044 million, faster<br />

than lending, which strengthened the Group’s liquidity position.<br />

The average yield on total assets in 2008 was 5.26% compared to<br />

4.69% in 2006, reflecting the positive impact of higher interest<br />

rates during the third quarter. The average cost of funds increased<br />

from 3.20% to 3.68% and was in line with the market’s evolution.<br />

Consequently, the greater activity produced an increase from a<br />

volume effect of €118.6 million, while good management of prices<br />

and spreads produced an increase from the interest rate impact of<br />

€57.9 million.<br />

2008 2007<br />

average % av. average % av.<br />

balance int. rate revenue balance int. rate revenue<br />

Assets<br />

Cash and credit entities 17,771.95 4.32 768.29 16,841.03 4.00 674.03<br />

Customer lending 68,978.93 6.09 4,203.63 64,446.46 5.27 3,396.66<br />

Public sector 793.52 4.12 32.68 672.23 3.75 25.20<br />

Residents 66,554.93 6.16 4,097.00 62,372.66 5.31 3,310.96<br />

Non-residents 1,630.48 4.54 73.94 1,401.57 4.32 60.50<br />

Lending in foreign currency 1,717.84 5.10 87.66 1,922.95 6.00 115.42<br />

Securities portfolio and financial assets 9,666.59 3.34 323.17 11,271.55 3.16 356.59<br />

Average income-yielding assets 98,135.31 5.49 5,382.75 94,482.00 4.81 4,542.70<br />

Equity stakes 288.09 0.00 0.00 241.95 0.00 0.00<br />

Tangible assets 1,148.23 0.00 0.00 1,032.90 0.00 0.00<br />

Other assets 3,834.48 1.58 60.53 2,580.06 2.67 68.77<br />

Total average assets 103,406.11 5.26 5,443.28 98,336.91 4.69 4,611.47


Average cost of funds<br />

In thousands of euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

average % av. interest average % av. interest<br />

balance int. rate and charges balance int. rate and charges<br />

Liabilities<br />

Due to credit entities and other financial liabilities 4,798.51 4.27 204.85 7,739.01 3.63 281.18<br />

Customer funds (euros) 55,328.21 3.43 1,895.73 49,756.68 2.86 1,422.95<br />

Public sector 5,558.41 3.40 188.76 6,531.99 3.02 197.09<br />

Private sector 31,793.19 2.96 939.98 25,494.07 2.10 535.60<br />

Non-residents 8,183.27 4.60 376.77 6,568.13 3.95 259.31<br />

REPOs 9,793.33 3.98 390.23 11,162.49 3.86 430.96<br />

Customer funds in foreign currency 2,604.05 3.93 102.29 2,131.45 4.73 100.85<br />

Debt securities 30,332.42 4.75 1,440.94 27,966.17 4.28 1,197.50<br />

Subordinated debt and capital like financial liabilities 2,110.09 5.61 118.47 2,067.01 4.71 97.30<br />

Total funds with costs 95,173.28 3.95 3,762.29 89,660.33 3.46 3,099.77<br />

Other funds 3,537.59 1.23 43.36 4,138.06 1.22 50.61<br />

Shareholders’ equity 4,695.24 0.00 0.00 4,538.52 0.00 0.00<br />

Total average funds 103,406.11 3.68 3,805.64 98,336.91 3.20 3,150.38<br />

Net fees and insurance activity<br />

Net fees and insurance activity amounted to €670.6 million,<br />

slightly more than in 2007. Excluding revenue from management of<br />

mutual and pension funds, growth was 11.1%..<br />

Fee income<br />

Million euros<br />

2008 2007 % Var.<br />

Fees for services 549.58 512.90 7.2%<br />

Services charged and paid for 315.93 290.13 8.9%<br />

Credit risk 93.58 87.82 6.6%<br />

Securities services 34.32 48.22 -28.8%<br />

Other 105.74 86.73 21.9%<br />

Insurance activity<br />

Management of mutual<br />

108.25 95.91 12.9%<br />

and pension funds 139.13 191.91 -27.5%<br />

Commissions paid -126.34 -130.37 -3.1%<br />

TOTAL 670.62 670.35 0.0%<br />

Fees for services rose 7.2% to €549.6 million and growth of all the<br />

lines was balanced.<br />

Fees for services<br />

million euros<br />

Insurance activity<br />

million euros<br />

382.53<br />

+10.6%<br />

423.24<br />

2007 2008<br />

95.91<br />

+12.9%<br />

108.25<br />

2007 2008<br />

43


44<br />

Of note were commissions from collection and payment services<br />

which at €315.9 million were 8.9% higher than in 2007,<br />

particularly those from cards, as well as those from the different<br />

types of “Tarifa Plana” accounts. Those from risks, in a period of<br />

much lower demand, rose 6.6%, while those from securities, hard<br />

hit by lower activity, was lower than in 2007.<br />

Fees from mutual and pension funds amounted to €139.1 million,<br />

lower than in 2007 because of a policy focused more on capturing<br />

Gains on financial transaction and<br />

exchange-rate difference<br />

Gains on financial transactions increased 9.7% to €151.4 million.<br />

million euros<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Trading operations and hedging 7.74 8.22 -5.8%<br />

Distribution to customers 138.66 124.57 11.3%<br />

Securitization of assets 5.01 5.21 -3.8%<br />

TOTAL 151.41 138.00 9.7%<br />

Gross operating income<br />

Gross operating income was 8.4% higher than in 2007 at<br />

€2,461.5 million. Its high degree of recurrence is underscored by<br />

net interest income, net fees and earnings from the distribution of<br />

Gross operating revenue<br />

million euros<br />

2,271.11<br />

+8.4%<br />

2,461.54<br />

2007 2008<br />

deposits. The average fee, however, remained higher than at the<br />

end of 2007 at 1.27%. Insurance business was again a significant<br />

source of revenues (+12.9% to €108.2 million).<br />

Fees paid dropped 3.1% to €126.3 million. This was directly linked<br />

to activity as most of the payments were to intermediaries and<br />

agents.<br />

The main component was once again revenue from the distribution<br />

of treasury products to customers. It rose 11.3% to €138.7 million<br />

and represented 92% of the total, (denoting a high level of<br />

recurrence). Gains on financial transactions also includes fees from<br />

securitization funds which at €5 million were practically the same<br />

as in 2007.<br />

Lastly, the gains from management of positions amounted to €7.7<br />

million (€8.2 million in 2007). They accounted for 5% of the<br />

total, in line with the Group’s policy of controlling the share of this<br />

activity, but optimising opportunities that arise in the markets.<br />

treasury products to customers accounting for more than 99% of<br />

total gross operating income.<br />

Gross operating revenue<br />

by business areas<br />

(%)<br />

Corporate<br />

activities<br />

Retail<br />

1.5<br />

Corporate<br />

9.1<br />

6.9<br />

Markets<br />

82.5


Gross Operating Income by Business<br />

Areas<br />

The following table sets out the distribution and growth of gross<br />

operating income by business areas:<br />

million euros<br />

Retail Banking<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Retail 2,031.12 1,881.29 8.0%<br />

Corporate 170.17 158.01 7.7%<br />

Markets and international 223.03 183.02 21.9%<br />

Corporate activities 37.22 48.79 -23.7%<br />

million euros<br />

2,461.54 2,271.11 8.4%<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Net interest income 1,403.59 1,251.14 12.2%<br />

Net fees 556.55 564.21 -1.4%<br />

Gains on financial transactions 70.98 65.94 7.6%<br />

Gross operating income 2,031.12 1,881.29 80.0%<br />

The retail banking area enjoyed a year of profitable growth. The<br />

lower demand resulting from the downturn in the mortgage market<br />

was offset by selective growth in lending to companies and SMEs.<br />

Particular importance was attached to capturing deposits, which<br />

together with efficient management of prices led to net interest<br />

income of €1,403.6 million, 12.2% more than in 2007.<br />

Management of customers, backed by campaigns to capture<br />

payroll cheques, among them “Sube a la red”, produced greater<br />

linkage and rises of €556.6 million in fee income and €71.0<br />

million in trading gains.<br />

Corporate Banking<br />

This business segment focused on optimising the return. Balance<br />

sheet management concentrated on operations with an adequate<br />

return. As a result, net interest income was 7.3% higher than in<br />

2007.<br />

Domestic Banking (Retail, Companies and Corporate) generated<br />

€2,201.3 million, 89.4% of gross operating income, and Markets<br />

9.1%.<br />

Gross operating income from Corporate Activities, which includes<br />

asset management, dividends received, earnings from securitization<br />

and other revenues and costs not assigned to business areas, was<br />

slightly lower than in 2007, largely due to lower gains from hedging<br />

in the interest rate environment.<br />

As a result, gross operating income increased 8.0% to €2,031.1<br />

million.<br />

Gross Operating Income Retail Banking<br />

million euros<br />

million euros<br />

1,881.29<br />

+8.0%<br />

2,031.12<br />

2007 2008<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Net interest income 106.00 98.80 7.3%<br />

Net fees 51.95 47.03 10.5%<br />

Gains on financial transactions 12.22 12.18 0.3%<br />

Gross operating income 170.17 158.01 7.7%<br />

45


46<br />

The special needs of these clients led to demand for solutions<br />

tailored to suit them, which at times were very complex. This was<br />

successfully done, thanks to <strong>Banesto</strong>’s technological capacity and<br />

the profound knowledge of its managers. Revenue from services<br />

grew 10.5% and gains on financial transactions 0.3%.<br />

Gross operating income was €170.2 million, 7.7% more than in<br />

2007.<br />

Markets<br />

million euros<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Net interest income 129.08 89.43 44.3%<br />

Net fees 22.91 38.27 -40.1%<br />

Gains on financial transactions 71.04 55.32 28.4%<br />

In accordance with the Group’s strategy, the distribution of<br />

treasury products to customers and our leadership in capital<br />

markets operations were the drivers of revenue generation. The<br />

creation of products that solved customers’ needs in the capital<br />

and stock markets and treasury products also helped to generate<br />

results.<br />

Gross operating income rose 21.9% to €223 million. Net interest<br />

income increased 44.3% to €129.1 million, net fees and<br />

commissions amounted to €22.9 million and gains on financial<br />

transactions rose 28.4% to €71.0 million.<br />

Non-financial affiliates net results<br />

These are the net results from non-financial subsidiaries, basically<br />

property and technology companies and those providing nonfinancial<br />

services.<br />

In 2008 they amounted to €8.3 million, 9.7% less than in 2007<br />

and basically due to the decline in the property market.<br />

Gross operating income corporate<br />

banking<br />

million euros<br />

158.01<br />

+7.7%<br />

170.17<br />

2007 2008<br />

These results were also achieved with a noteworthy degree of<br />

customer diversification; operations were conducted in 2008 with<br />

more than 20,000 customers.<br />

Gross operating income 223.03 183.02 21.9% Gross operating income markets<br />

million euros<br />

183.02<br />

+21.9%<br />

223.03<br />

2007 2008<br />

Operating Costs<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s discipline in costs, in the current environment, is a<br />

strength and a key element of management. Operating expenses<br />

increased by only 3.4% in 2008, largely thanks to the Menara Plan<br />

launched in early 2007 to continuously improve operational and<br />

commercial efficiency.<br />

As a result of operating costs rising at a much lower pace than<br />

gross operating income, the efficiency ratio made a further gain in<br />

2008 to 39.0% (40.5% in 2007) and met the target.


Operating Costs<br />

million euros<br />

Personnel costs rose 2.8% to €655.3 million, the result of a drop<br />

in the average number of employees and an increase in the average<br />

cost of 5.1%. In 2008, 110 employees retired early, charged to the<br />

special fund established for this purpose in 2006.<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Net general administrative expenses 867.04 826.24 4.9%<br />

Personnel 655.29 637.52 2.8%<br />

Wages and salaries 479.81 467.88 2.5%<br />

Social security 122.26 118.90 2.8%<br />

Other 53.22 50.74 4.9%<br />

General expenses 233.87 221.81 5.4%<br />

Premises, installations and material 66.18 63.79 3.8%<br />

IT and communications 57.34 57.15 0.3%<br />

Advertising 16.78 17.69 -5.1%<br />

Other concepts 79.58 70.55 12.8%<br />

Taxes (excluding income tax) 13.99 12.64 10.7%<br />

Recovery of expenses -22.11 -33.09 -33.2%<br />

Depreciation 100.19 97.62 2.6%<br />

Total 967.23 923.86 4.7%<br />

Efficiency ratio (%) 39.04% 40.51%<br />

Efficiency ratio<br />

(%)<br />

40.51<br />

39.04<br />

2007 2008<br />

Operating Costs<br />

million euros<br />

826.24<br />

637.52<br />

221.81<br />

+4.9%<br />

personnel<br />

general<br />

recovered<br />

867.04<br />

655.29<br />

233.87<br />

General costs were 5.4% higher at €233.9 million, the net effect<br />

of rises in rents, taxes – in both cases mainly because of the new<br />

branches opened during 2008 – and IT (basically due to the sale<br />

in the middle of 2007 of the stake in Isban), which lowered<br />

-33.09<br />

-22.11<br />

personnel costs, and less advertising.<br />

Depreciation amounted to €100.2 million, slightly more than in<br />

2007, due to new investments in IT and fixed assets in order to<br />

2007 2008<br />

maintain the cutting edge of the Group’s operational capacity. Other revenue and costs, which cover those outside ordinary<br />

activity, amounted to €39.7 million net, 9.3% more than in 2007.<br />

The largest item and the main reason for the increase is the<br />

contribution to the Deposit Guarantee Fund (DGF), in line with the<br />

growth in customer funds.<br />

47


48<br />

Net Operating Income<br />

Higher recurrent revenue and containment of operating expenses<br />

produced a rise of 10.8% in net operating income to €1,462.9<br />

million.<br />

Losses from deterioration of assets<br />

The net impairment loss on lending amounted to €299.8 million,<br />

30.8% more than in 2007. Of this amount, €481.9 million were<br />

specific provisions made because of the increase in non-performing<br />

loans (lower than the average rise among banks) and €124.2<br />

million provisions to cover risks. Even though there was a normal<br />

evolution, <strong>Banesto</strong> believed its move was prudent because of the<br />

economic difficulties.<br />

Generic provisions, in addition to the €124.2 million, amounted to<br />

€25.2 million and corresponded solely to the evolution of lending<br />

during 2008, as recourse to it was not necessary in 2008 for the<br />

constitution of specific provisions.<br />

Loan-loss provisions<br />

million euros and %<br />

1.026,0<br />

67,5%<br />

0,9<br />

Country risk Specific Generic<br />

0,1%<br />

492,8<br />

32,4%<br />

Net Operating Income<br />

million euros<br />

million euros<br />

1,320.12<br />

+10.8%<br />

1,462.89<br />

2007 2008<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Net loan-loss provisions 332.16 272.04 22.1%<br />

Generic -149.44 157.56 n.s.<br />

Specific 481.90 115.14 318.5%<br />

Country risk -0.30 -0.66 -54.5%<br />

Loan-loss recoveries -32.40 -42.94 -24.5%<br />

Total lending 299.76 229.10 30.8%<br />

Other net write-offs 37.25 1.13 n.s.<br />

Total 337.01 230.23 46.4%<br />

Recovery of country-risk provisions made in prior years amounted<br />

to €0.3 million, and €32.2 million of risks previously classified as<br />

bad debts were recovered.<br />

Allocation adjustments resulting from the deterioration of other<br />

assets amounted to €37.3 million, basically for foreclosed property<br />

in the event of possible price falls derived from the downturn in<br />

the real estate market.


Other net income<br />

This line embraces a series of different items. The main<br />

components are:<br />

The sale of fixed assets produced a loss of €0.9 million compared<br />

to a profit of €7.4 million in 2007.<br />

Allocation to the pension fund of €4.9 million (€0.2 million in<br />

2007).<br />

Other non-recurrent income and net recoveries of special funds<br />

from the disappearance or materialisation of contingencies<br />

mentioned in previous paragraphs amounted to €25.6 million<br />

(€3.0 million in 2007).<br />

There was an extraordinary allocation of €60 million, in<br />

anticipation of the possible effects from the economic downturn.<br />

million euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Sale of fixed and financial assets<br />

Other extraordinary income<br />

-0.87 7.43<br />

and from prior years -9.22 -19.60<br />

Allocation to pension fund -4.95 -0.23<br />

Net allocation (recovery) to provisions -25.19 22.61<br />

Total -40.23 10.21<br />

Profits<br />

Profit before taxes was €1,085.7 million, 1.3% lower than in 2007. After the corporate tax charge of €306.2 million, attributable<br />

profit was 2.0% higher at €779.8 million.<br />

49


50<br />

Balance Sheet 2008<br />

One of the management priorities in 2008 was to optimise the<br />

return on the balance sheet. At the end of 2008 total assets<br />

amounted to €117,186 million. In addition, the Group managed<br />

Consolidated balance sheet<br />

million euros<br />

off-balance sheet pension and mutual funds and insurance<br />

products of €9,745 million. Total assets were 2.8% higher at<br />

€126,931 million.<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Assets<br />

Cash on hand and at central banks 1,688.15 1,412.87 19.5%<br />

Trading portfolio, derivatives and other financial assets 12,115.18 10,229.83 18.4%<br />

Customer lending 76,903.82 74,200.89 3.6%<br />

Other loans 20,127.48 19,965.72 0.8%<br />

Equity stakes 307.58 269.45 14.1%<br />

Tangible assets 1,159.55 1,128.91 2.7%<br />

Intangible assets 56.88 50.22 13.2%<br />

Other assets 4,676.51 2,709.05 72.6%<br />

Accrual accounts 151.28 100.82 50.1%<br />

Total assets 117,186.42 110,067.76 6.5%<br />

Liabilities<br />

Trading portfolio and other financial liabilities 4,870.51 3,631.00 34.1%<br />

Customer deposits 57,779.45 53,340.18 8.3%<br />

Marketable debt securities 28,315.10 28,248.97 0.2%<br />

Subordinated debt 2,185.15 2,043.91 6.9%<br />

Other financial liabilities at amortised cost 15,458.91 14,761.04 4.7%<br />

Other liabilities 384.19 336.77 14.1%<br />

Provisions 2,534.64 2,604.79 -2.7%<br />

Accrual accounts 493.74 414.03 19.3%<br />

Capital like financial liabilities 51.69 52.45 -1.5%<br />

Minority interests 1.72 1.14 51.0%<br />

Valuation adjustments 41.55 -114.42 n,s,<br />

Share capital and reserves 4,289.92 3,983.33 7.7%<br />

Profit for the year 779.84 764.57 2.0%<br />

Total liabilities 117,186.42 110,067.76 6.5%<br />

Total Assets<br />

million euros<br />

110,068<br />

+6.5%<br />

117,186<br />

2007 2008


The changes in the balance sheet reflect the management priority<br />

of strengthening liquidity and enhancing the relative share of the<br />

most profitable assets and liabilities:<br />

• Customer lending rose 3.6% to €76,904 million.<br />

• The portfolio of equity stakes amounted to €308 million, up<br />

from €269 million at the end of 2007. This increase was due<br />

to the valuation of companies accounted for by the equity<br />

method, their results, net of dividends distributed, and<br />

changes in their net worth.<br />

• The trading portfolio, derivatives and other financial assets<br />

amounted to €12,115 million in assets and €4,871 million in<br />

liabilities. Most of these amounts correspond to treasury<br />

operations with customers.<br />

• Tangible assets increased 2.7% to €31 million, largely because<br />

of IT investments and improvements to the branch network.<br />

• Customer deposits rose 8.3% to €57,779 million. Given the<br />

very strong competition to capture funds, this growth was<br />

particularly significant and resulted in a gain in market share of<br />

36 b.p.<br />

Customer Loans<br />

The Group’s volume of lending stood at €77,224 million at the end<br />

of 2008, 4.1% more than in 2007.<br />

Customer Loans<br />

million euros<br />

• Marketable debt securities amounted to €28,315 million,<br />

0.2% more than in 2007.<br />

• Subordinated debt increased by €141 million, €100 million of<br />

which corresponds to the net rise in issues made in 2008 and<br />

the rest to valuation adjustments.<br />

• Valuation adjustments at the end of 2008 amounted to €42<br />

million (€114.4 million negative in 2007). Most of the change<br />

was due to the impact on the valuation of ordinary fixedincome<br />

portfolios of the interest rate evolution.<br />

• Share capital amounted to €543.0 million, 1.0% less than at<br />

the end of 2007, after the amortisation of the treasury stock<br />

approved at the AGM on February 25, 2008 and materialised<br />

in June. Total shareholders’ funds amounted to €5,070 million,<br />

6.8% higher. This was due to the allocation of the prior year’s<br />

income, net of the dividends paid to shareholders.<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Public sector 1,447.77 958.77 51.0%<br />

Private sector 71,581.39 70,267.41 1.9%<br />

Commercial bills 5,352.15 6,583.06 -18.7%<br />

Secured loans 37,291.92 37,109.74 0.5%<br />

Other credits and loans 28,937.32 26,574.61 8.9%<br />

Non-resident sector 4,063.58 3,608.87 12.6%<br />

Total 77,092.74 74,835.04 3.0%<br />

Activos dudosos 1,396.09 398.45 250.4%<br />

Less: provisions for non-performing loans -1,417.62 -1,238.77 14.4%<br />

Valuation adjustment 152.64 206.68 -26.1%<br />

Total 77,223.84 74,201.40 4.1%<br />

This growth in lending growth took place against a backdrop of a<br />

sharp fall in demand and rigorous selection of operations focused<br />

on the private sector (+€1,314 million to €71,581 million), and<br />

with a greater share to SMEs and companies which offset the<br />

decline in lending to the property sector.<br />

The portfolio of commercial bills declined 18.7% to €5,352<br />

million, due to less use by customers of this type of financing.<br />

The pace of growth in secured loans continued to decelerate and<br />

at the end of 2008 these amounted to €37,292 million, 0.5%<br />

more than in 2007. Most of the increase was in first home loans.<br />

Other credits and loans, mainly to companies, SMEs, shops and<br />

the self-employed, rose 8.9% to €28,937 million.<br />

Lending to the public sector increased by €489 million to €1,448<br />

million and that to the non-resident sector 12.6% to €4,064<br />

million.<br />

51


52<br />

The structure of lending by amounts, type of customer and<br />

economic sector remained highly suitable, as shown below.<br />

Customer Loans<br />

million euros<br />

74.835<br />

Customer loans:<br />

customers<br />

(%)<br />

Institutions<br />

and others<br />

+3.0%<br />

77.093<br />

2007 2008<br />

46.6<br />

Individuals<br />

SMEs<br />

Large<br />

companies<br />

As well as loans, the Group has other non-lending risks<br />

(guarantees, documentary credits and other sureties) which at the<br />

end of 2008 amounted to €10,906 million, 8.9% less than in<br />

2007.<br />

Customer loans:<br />

amounts<br />

Up to<br />

€50,000<br />

Guarantee on the basis of the operation guaranteed<br />

million euros<br />

2.4<br />

34.3<br />

16.8<br />

(%)<br />

€50,000<br />

to<br />

€150,000<br />

Customer loans:<br />

sectors<br />

(%)<br />

Agriculture,<br />

cattle and<br />

fisheries<br />

Industry<br />

and Energy<br />

€150,000<br />

to<br />

€500,000<br />

Services<br />

€500,000<br />

to €5<br />

million<br />

More<br />

than €5<br />

million<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Guarantees and other sureties 10,631.29 11,543.61 -7.9%<br />

Guarantees for commercial paper and bills of exchange 205.96 402.34 -48.8%<br />

Other obligations 10,425.33 11,141.27 -6.4%<br />

Documentary credits 274.25 420.85 -34.8%<br />

Total 10,905.54 11,964.45 -8.9%<br />

18.6<br />

62,20<br />

16.9<br />

20.4<br />

3,50<br />

32.4<br />

9.9<br />

34,30


Doubtful Loans<br />

Non-performing loans (NPLs) grew significantly in 2008 because<br />

of the economic downturn. <strong>Banesto</strong>’s doubtful loans at the end of<br />

the year amounted to €1,441 million and although the NPL ratio<br />

Doubtful Loans<br />

million euros<br />

rose from 0.47% in 2007 to 1.62% in 2008 it was still well below<br />

the average of our rivals.<br />

2008 2007<br />

Non-performing loans:<br />

Balance at January 1 410.80 306.40<br />

Entries 1,577.17 419.82<br />

Recoveries -420.98 -235.82<br />

Write-offs -125.54 -79.60<br />

Balance at December 31 1,441.45 410.80<br />

Provisions:<br />

Balance at January 1 1,353.52 1,203.08<br />

Net provisions 368.15 290.75<br />

Available funds -35.69 -18.05<br />

Provisions released -167.15 -122.27<br />

Balance at December 31 1,518.82 1,353.52<br />

Detail of provisions<br />

Specific 492.82 161.11<br />

Generic 1,026.01 1,192.41<br />

TOTAL 1,518.82 1,353.52<br />

NPL Ratio (%) 1.62% 0.47%<br />

NPL coverage (%) 105.37% 329.48%<br />

New entries of NPLs amounted to €1,577 million, but thanks to<br />

firm management in tracking risks and recoveries of NPLs,<br />

anticipating operations that could cause problems, recoveries<br />

amounted to €421 million and so net entries were €1,156 million<br />

and only represented 1.3% of total risks.<br />

Doubtful loans that became write-offs totalled €126 million as<br />

against €80 million in 2007.<br />

Loan-loss provisions amounted to €1,519 million at the end of<br />

2008, 12.2% more than a year earlier and providing coverage of<br />

105%. They include both generic and specific provisions, with<br />

€124.2 million to cover risks which the bank prudently<br />

constituted, due to the economic downturn, even though the<br />

evolution was normal<br />

. Ratio of Non-performing Loans<br />

(%)<br />

0.47 +115 p.b.<br />

1.62<br />

2007 2008<br />

Coverage of Non-performing Loans<br />

(%)<br />

329.48<br />

-224 p.b.<br />

105.37<br />

2007 2008<br />

53


54<br />

Foreclosed assets<br />

An important part of tracking and recovering risks is anticipating<br />

problems. In the current context of a sharp rise in non-performing<br />

loans, the allotment of the assets of borrowers defaulting on their<br />

loans is an effective instrument for strengthening the bank’s<br />

balance sheet and improving the possibilities of total recovery.<br />

The bank was awarded assets in 2008 which served to cancel out<br />

loans, whose recovery by other means was difficult.<br />

Customer Funds<br />

million euros<br />

The policy of capturing funds, focused on optimising the mix of<br />

products and management of spreads, and in 2008 more oriented<br />

towards capturing deposits, resulted in an 8.3% rise in on-balance<br />

sheet funds to €57,779 million. Particularly noteworthy was the<br />

performance in all types of resident private sector funds.<br />

Private sector funds increased 16.3% to €44,473 million. Against<br />

a background of very strong competition, all types of deposits did<br />

well, particularly time deposits (+37.1%).<br />

Public sector and non-resident sector funds were lower than in<br />

2007, due to the policy of optimising spreads and only accepting<br />

deposits that offer an adequate return. Those of the public sector<br />

dropped 7.9% to €10,091 million and those of the non-resident<br />

sector 22.3% to €3,215 million.<br />

The net amount of these assets at the end of 2008 was €363 million.<br />

Given that the value in the books is always the lower figure between<br />

the market value and the net value of provisions of the assets applied<br />

at the time of acquisition, this should not mean any loss.<br />

Customer Funds<br />

Customer funds, including mutual and pension funds and<br />

insurance-based savings plans, amounted to €67,525 million, 1.1%<br />

more than in 2007.<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Public sector 10,091.46 10,958.99 -7.9%<br />

Private sector 44,472.90 38,244.36 16.3%<br />

Current and savings accounts 15,005.60 14,896.91 0.7%<br />

Time deposits 19,244.03 14,032.83 37.1%<br />

Repos and other accounts 10,223.27 9,314.62 9.8%<br />

Non-resident sector 3,215.10 4,136.84 -22.3%<br />

On-balance sheet funds 57,779.45 53,340.18 8.3%<br />

Managed funds 9,745.41 13,422.69 -27.4%<br />

Mutual funds 6,814.59 10,605.18 -35.7%<br />

Pension funds 1,409.66 1,626.13 -13.3%<br />

Insurance-savings policies 1,521.16 1,191.38 27.7%<br />

Total managed funds 67,524.86 66,762.87 1.1%<br />

Customer funds<br />

million euros<br />

66,763<br />

+1.1%<br />

67,525<br />

2007 2008<br />

Off-balance sheet funds, very affected by the markets’<br />

performance, and in accordance with <strong>Banesto</strong>’s policy, dropped<br />

27.4% to €9,745 million. Mutual funds managed by Grupo<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> amounted to €6,815 million. The table below itemises the<br />

type of funds.


Mutual funds<br />

million euros<br />

10,605<br />

Customer funds<br />

million euros<br />

-35.7%<br />

6,815<br />

2007 2008<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Money market 1,356.92 2,070.38 -34.5%<br />

Fixed income 2,548.49 2,183.22 16.7%<br />

Mixed 783.46 2,036.50 -61.5%<br />

Equity 107.31 367.99 -70.8%<br />

International 62.44 232.09 -73.1%<br />

Guaranteed 960.12 1,432.05 -33.0%<br />

Simcavs 253.22 428.02 -40.8%<br />

Unit linked 72.25 144.44 -50.0%<br />

Real estate 371.22 457.30 -18.8%<br />

External management 299.17 1,253.20 -76.1%<br />

Total 6,814.59 10,605.18 -35.7%<br />

The suitable structure of customer funds is shown below. The<br />

funds of individuals accounted for 63.9% of the total and balances<br />

under €250,000 for 61.3%<br />

Pension funds<br />

million euros<br />

Managed pension funds amounted to €1.410 million at the end of<br />

2008, 13.3% lower than in 2007. Individual funds have the largest<br />

share of total funds.<br />

Pension funds<br />

million euros<br />

1,626<br />

-13.3%<br />

1,410<br />

2007 2008<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Individuals 1,326.25 1,616.46 -18.0%<br />

Associated 10.27 0.38 n.s.<br />

Employment 73.15 9.30 n.s.<br />

TOTAL 1,409.66 1,626.13 -13.3%<br />

Customer funds:<br />

by customer<br />

(%)<br />

Large<br />

companies<br />

SMEs<br />

9,5<br />

3,7<br />

Individuals<br />

23,0<br />

63,9<br />

Institutions<br />

55


56<br />

Customer funds:<br />

by amount<br />

(%)<br />

Up to<br />

€5,000<br />

€5,000<br />

to<br />

€25,000<br />

€25,000<br />

to<br />

€50,000<br />

€50,000<br />

to<br />

€150,000<br />

€150,000<br />

to<br />

€250,000<br />

More<br />

than<br />

€250,000<br />

Shareholders’ equity<br />

The new regulations on equity, known as BIS II, came into force in<br />

2008 and allowed banks to use internal models to calculate the<br />

minimum capital needed, following Bank of Spain approval (which<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> achieved). BIS II represented for <strong>Banesto</strong> a saving in<br />

capital needs of around 10% with regard to the previous<br />

regulations. At the end of 2008, the new BIS ratio was 10.66%,<br />

with Tier 1 of 7.70% and core capital of 7.18%. Grupo <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

thus has a level of capitalisation and financial strength enabling it<br />

to conduct its business in coming years from a solid position.<br />

million euros<br />

38,7<br />

6,6<br />

4,9<br />

18,5<br />

2008 2007 % Change<br />

Core Capital 4,889.07 4,554.12 7.35%<br />

Tier I 5,246.01 5,056.03 3.76%<br />

Tier 2 2,009.25 2,506.09 -19.83%<br />

Total 7,255.26 7,562.12 -4.06%<br />

Our dividend policy enabled Tier 1 capital to continue to grow and<br />

reach €4,889 million at the end of 2008, up 7.4%.<br />

The capital stock was 1% lower at €543 million, as result of the<br />

amortisation of treasury stock approved at the AGM in February<br />

2008.<br />

19<br />

12,4<br />

Shareholders’ equity - Tier I<br />

5,056<br />

+3.8%<br />

5,246<br />

2007 2008<br />

Reserves were strengthened by the increase arising from the<br />

inclusion of income generated in the prior year, net of the<br />

dividends paid to shareholders.<br />

Once the Shareholders’ Meeting has approved the 2008 financial<br />

statements, the net dividend is envisaged at €0.56 per share and<br />

the rest of earnings will go to reserves.<br />

Tier 1 equity stood at €5,246 million at the end of 2008 and Tier<br />

II at €2,015 million. New net issues of subordinated debt were<br />

made in 2008 amounting to €100 million. The rest of the change<br />

in Tier II was basically due to the lower amount of generic<br />

provisions for non-performing loans, in accordance with the new<br />

method of calculation.<br />

Banco Santander Central Hispano remained the majority<br />

shareholder at the end of 2008, with a direct and indirect stake of<br />

89.28%. The section on “The <strong>Banesto</strong> share” gives detailed<br />

information on shareholders.<br />

Moody’s, Standard & Poor’s and Fitch Ibca continued to issue<br />

short-and long-term debt ratings for <strong>Banesto</strong>, as shown below:<br />

RATING AGENCIES<br />

Moody’s<br />

Standard & Poors<br />

Fitch Ibca<br />

Long term Short term<br />

Aa2 P1<br />

AA A1+<br />

AA F1+


Financial information<br />

of the main entities of<br />

the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group<br />

Banco Español de Crédito is the parent company of the<br />

consolidated <strong>Banesto</strong> Group. The group’s main activity is<br />

commercial banking in Spain, particularly retail banking for<br />

individuals, SMEs, businesses and professionals. It also carries out<br />

wholesale banking and capital markets activities.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> has direct and indirect stakes in financial, insurance,<br />

industrial, commercial and real estate companies.<br />

For its purely banking and financial activities the group used<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Banco de Emisiones, <strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring and <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

Renting in 2008.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Banco de Emisiones is the Group’s financial vehicle,<br />

capturing funds through issues of commercial paper, long-term<br />

debt and subordinated financing. These funds are loaned to<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> which uses them to finance the group’s ordinary activity.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring and <strong>Banesto</strong> Renting are two wholly owned<br />

subsidiaries of <strong>Banesto</strong>, which design and conduct factoring and<br />

renting operations, either directly or through the group’s<br />

distribution channels. Backed by the group’s technological<br />

strength and innovative capacity, they offer a wide range of<br />

products. Business growth rates have been significant year after<br />

year; in 2008 they were 9.9% and 6.7%, respectively, making<br />

them among the leaders in their fields.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Bolsa is the Group’s broker-dealer and is part of the<br />

Wholesale Banking Area. Its main activity is brokerage in domestic<br />

and international markets. It provides services to the bank’s<br />

customers and to domestic and international clients. The indices of<br />

international markets plummeted in 2008 and also trading<br />

volumes. Despite this, <strong>Banesto</strong> Bolsa continued to gain more<br />

customers and develop new tools which enhanced operations and<br />

information.<br />

Mutual and pension fund management are handled by Santander<br />

Gestión de Activos, SA and Santander Pensiones, SA part of<br />

Grupo Santander, in each of which <strong>Banesto</strong> has 20% stakes.<br />

Insurance products distributed by our network are covered by<br />

Santander Seguros, 39% owned by <strong>Banesto</strong>.<br />

The main figures of these companies are set out below.<br />

57


58<br />

Financial group information<br />

BANKS<br />

million euros<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> <strong>Banesto</strong> B. Emisiones <strong>Banesto</strong> Bolsa<br />

2008 2007 2008 2007 2008 2007<br />

Income statement<br />

Net interest income 1,626.0 1,449.1 1.5 1.8 4.4 4.1<br />

Net fees and insurance activity 567.2 569.2 - - 12.9 18.6<br />

Gains (losses) on financial transactions 97.8 98.8 - - -0.5 -0.6<br />

Gross operating income 2,291.0 2,117.1 1.5 1.8 16.7 22.1<br />

Net operating expenses 946.7 899.5 0.2 0.4 8.1 8.3<br />

Other net income -41.1 -33.7 - - - -<br />

Net operating income 1,303.2 1,183.9 1.3 1.4 8.7 13.8<br />

Net provisions 337.4 228.1 - - 0.0 0.1<br />

Other income -18.6 0.4 - - - -<br />

Profit before taxes 947.2 956.2 1.3 1.4 8.7 13.7<br />

Balance Sheet<br />

Customer loans 76,662.3 74,351.4 - - - -<br />

Lending portfolio to maturity - - - - 0.0 0.1<br />

Other financial assets 21,114.4 19,714.7 - - 124.1 117.7<br />

Due from credit entities 21,364.3 18,479.5 9,750.9 7,733.4 11.8 71.6<br />

Other assets 4,033.2 3,773.8 114.9 464.4 0.4 0.7<br />

Total assets/liabilities 123,174.2 116,319.4 9,865.8 8,197.8 136.3 190.1<br />

Customer funds 67,542.3 63,126.4 - - - -<br />

Marketable debt securities 16,503.2 19,889.0 9,135.1 6,620.4 - -<br />

Subordinated financing 2,186.9 2,075.0 514.7 1,012.9 - -<br />

Due to credit entities 19,466.5 15,551.2 - - 21.6 80.6<br />

Other liabilities 12,704.0 11,272.0 114.9 464.4 5.2 2.0<br />

Capital. reserves and earnings 4,771.4 4,405.8 101.1 100.1 109.6 107.5<br />

Other companies<br />

Million euros <strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring <strong>Banesto</strong> Renting<br />

2008 2007 2008 2007<br />

Income statement<br />

Net interest income 19.1 13.0 4.4 5.5<br />

Net fees and insurance activity 5.4 5.7 -0.1 -0.1<br />

Gains (losses) on financial transactions - - 1.8 1.0<br />

Gross operating income 24.5 18.7 6.2 6.4<br />

Net operating expenses 2.4 2.6 3.5 3.2<br />

Net operating income 22.1 16.1 2.6 3.2<br />

Deterioration of assets 6.8 6.5 0.8 0.2<br />

Other income - - -0.5 -1.6<br />

Profit before taxes 15.3 9.6 1.4 1.4<br />

Balance Sheet<br />

Customer loans 2,261.0 2,056.6 347.7 325.9<br />

Other financial assets - - 1.9 1.6<br />

Due from credit entities 5.2 4.6 - -<br />

Other assets 60.4 48.5 29.5 34.8<br />

Total assets/liabilities 2,326.6 2,109.7 379.1 362.2<br />

Subordinated financing 8.0 8.0 - -<br />

Due to credit entities 2,112.6 1,912.2 361.9 334.8<br />

Other liabilities 80.7 73.6 4.8 17.0<br />

Capital. reserves and earnings 125.2 115.9 12.4 10.4


2004-2008<br />

performance<br />

This section sets out the Group’s performance over the last five<br />

years. The tables and graphs give one a better perspective to<br />

gauge the business performance and the progress in the income<br />

statement.<br />

The International Accounting Standards (IAS) produced changes in<br />

accounting criteria and presentation. The figures for 2004 have<br />

been redrawn in accordance with the criteria set in the new<br />

regulations.<br />

All the items of the income statement performed well. Gross<br />

operating income rose 51% between 2004 and 2008 to<br />

€2,461.5 million, with significant growth in net interest income,<br />

net fees and gains on financial transactions.<br />

Personnel and general expenses and depreciation remained stable<br />

over the five year period. In current euros cumulative annual<br />

growth was only 3.9%, the result of successful efficiency plans to<br />

reduce the head count, mainly through early retirements,<br />

streamlining structures and costs and optimising branch networks<br />

and distribution channels.<br />

Net Operating Income<br />

million euros<br />

796<br />

925<br />

1,071<br />

1,320<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

Business performance<br />

1,463<br />

The business progress is shown in the following charts. Sustained<br />

growth in lending and in funds, with cumulative growth rates of<br />

98% and 58%, respectively, produced a further gain in market<br />

share of 0.6 p.p. over the period to 9.4% in 2008.<br />

The combined effect of higher revenues and contained operating<br />

costs (personnel and general) produced a constant and significant<br />

improvement in the efficiency ratio (operating costs as a<br />

percentage of gross operating income) from 48.1% in 2004 to<br />

39% in 2008. This figure is better than the banking sector’s<br />

average.<br />

Net operating income grew 86% to €1,462.9 million (cumulative<br />

annual growth of 16.8%).<br />

Over this period the Group implemented a conservative policy for<br />

loan-loss provisions as well as for special reserves. As a result,<br />

coverage of non-performing loans was 105% at the end of 2008,<br />

higher than the average for the banking sector.<br />

Lastly, net profit rose 70% to €779.8 million and more than<br />

double this pace in terms adjusted to the new regulations.<br />

Net Consolidated Profit<br />

million euros<br />

459<br />

570<br />

606<br />

765<br />

779<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

Lending<br />

Ordinary lending rose 98% to €77,093 million. The main driver, in<br />

line with our policies, was lending to the private sector whose<br />

balance at the end of 2008 was €71,581 million, more than<br />

double that in 2004. The change by components enhanced the<br />

structure of lending which was highly diversified by customer<br />

segments and types of loan.<br />

59


60<br />

Customer Loans<br />

million euros 77,093<br />

38,906<br />

48,746<br />

61,826<br />

74,835<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

The growth in lending went hand in hand with efficient control of<br />

credit risk, which gave the bank a solid financial position in the face<br />

of the change in the economic cycle that took place in 2008. The<br />

rise in <strong>Banesto</strong>’s non-performing loans was much lower than the<br />

average of other Spanish banks.<br />

• Despite the economic downturn, the non-performing loans<br />

ratio only rose from 0.63% in 2004 to 1.62% in 2008, below<br />

the banking sector’s average<br />

• NPL coverage at the end of 2008 was 105%, also higher than<br />

the average.<br />

Customer Funds<br />

Total managed funds (deposits, mutual and pension funds and<br />

insurance-based savings) rose 58% between 2004 and 2008 to<br />

€67,525 million.<br />

Deposits increased by €29,032 million and at the end of 2008<br />

were double the amount in 2004, while off-balance sheet funds<br />

dropped by €4,257 million to €9,745 million.<br />

Ratio of Non-performing<br />

loans<br />

(%)<br />

0.63 0.49<br />

2004<br />

305.9<br />

2004<br />

2005<br />

2005<br />

0.42<br />

2006<br />

2006<br />

0.47<br />

2007<br />

371.7 392.7<br />

329.5<br />

2007<br />

1.62<br />

2008<br />

Coverage of Non-performing<br />

loans<br />

(%)<br />

105.4<br />

2008<br />

Managed Customer Funds<br />

million euros<br />

Managed funds<br />

42,750<br />

14,002<br />

28,747<br />

50,853<br />

15,053<br />

35,800<br />

Mutual and pension<br />

funds and insurance<br />

60,549<br />

15,387<br />

45,162<br />

On-balance sheet funds<br />

66,763<br />

13,423<br />

53,340<br />

67,525<br />

9,745<br />

57,779<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008


Shareholders’ equity<br />

Shareholders’ equity – core capital – gradually strengthened, rising<br />

from €3,086 million in 2004 to €4,889 million in 2008. This was<br />

the result of retained earnings, net of dividends paid, and<br />

reductions of capital with the return of contributions to<br />

shareholders.<br />

The BIS ratio remained at an appropriate level. At the end of 2008,<br />

in accordance with the new BIS II regulations, it was 10.66%, with<br />

Tier 1 of 7.7% and core capital of 7.18%.<br />

Over the last five years rating agencies have recognised <strong>Banesto</strong>’s<br />

progress in business growth, profitability and solvency and this has<br />

been reflected in continuous improvements in ratings.<br />

LONG-TERM RATINGS<br />

Moody’s<br />

Standard & Poor’s<br />

Fitch Ibca<br />

2004 2008<br />

Aa3 Aa2<br />

A+ AA<br />

AA AA<br />

BIS Ratio<br />

12.34<br />

5.05<br />

7.29<br />

11.35<br />

4.29<br />

7.06<br />

11.18<br />

3.75<br />

7.43<br />

Tier II<br />

Tier I<br />

10.44<br />

3.46<br />

6.98<br />

10.66<br />

2.96<br />

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

7.7<br />

61


62<br />

Risk Management<br />

Quality is the priority in<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s risk management<br />

Thanks to our selective process of admitting risks and close<br />

monitoring of existing risk we are able to face today’s complicated<br />

environment with excellent credit quality. Our structure and<br />

monitoring tools enable us to anticipate and manage difficult<br />

situations and respond quickly to each scenario.


<strong>Banesto</strong>’s prudent and predictable risk management is a<br />

competitive advantage in any economic environment, as it assesses<br />

all implicit risks assumed with a customer – credit, market, liquidity,<br />

sovereign risk and operational, environmental and reputational<br />

risks.<br />

Performance in 2008:<br />

Credit Risk<br />

Credit risk is the possibility of default by a counterparty on<br />

contractual obligations which produce losses for a bank.<br />

1. <strong>Banesto</strong>’s risk admission is structured on the basis of customer<br />

segmentation (retail, companies, real estate and wholesale).<br />

Reatil Risk<br />

Risk admission processes in 2008 were characterised by prudent<br />

and responsible management and adjusting policies and systems to<br />

the prevailing economic context.<br />

There are different strategies for each business segment and the<br />

key element of all of them is ensuring the quality of risks.<br />

The steps taken in 2008 enabled <strong>Banesto</strong> to reach a high degree<br />

of credit quality and meet our basic objectives:<br />

• High levels of specialisation by segments and channels of<br />

provenance, with homogeneous management criteria for each<br />

one of them.<br />

• Improve productivity and the capacity to respond to<br />

customers.<br />

• Adjust the admission processes to the customer’s risk profile<br />

(rating).<br />

• Maintain high standards of quality in risk operations.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s efficient systems combining advanced models of automatic<br />

decision-making and solid teams of experienced and specialised risk<br />

analysts enable the bank to meet its risk quality goals.<br />

The Risk Analysis Centre consists of highly specialised analysts.<br />

They ensure that operations meet the required risk quality<br />

standards and provide advice to the branch network on customers’<br />

operations.<br />

The Expected Loss model for operations with SMEs has improved<br />

the risk management of our analysts and helped to adjust<br />

guarantees to the profile of the customer.<br />

As regards individual customers, we have advanced analysis tools<br />

(scores) which are part of the admission process and are an<br />

efficient instrument for evaluation and monitoring.<br />

There is a risk-value model for consumer loans that maximises the<br />

risk-return for high profile customers.<br />

Companies’ Risk<br />

Under a strict framework of prudence, in line with the economic<br />

situation, which is maintaining the credit quality of our portfolio at<br />

high levels, the risk admission process for companies begins in<br />

Company Centres and Regional Headquarters. They have certain<br />

levels of risk laid down and delegated by the bank’s Executive<br />

Committee.<br />

In Central Services, also under criteria of maximum quality, risk<br />

admission is carried out by the Company Risks Unit which channels<br />

the proposals that exceed the delegated attributions, and the<br />

Large Clients and Capital Markets Unit , which manages a portfolio<br />

comprising the main companies. This gives greater proximity to the<br />

client and speeds up the decision-making process, as well as<br />

integral management (analysis, admission and monitoring) of loans.<br />

The specialisation of the teams and the use of admission circuits<br />

and tools for analysis and assigning specific ratings for each<br />

segment ensures homogeneous treatment of risk classification<br />

proposals and customers’ operations.<br />

Real Estate Risk<br />

2008 saw a change of cycle in the real estate sector and a bursting<br />

of its bubble.<br />

The sector is facing a much more demanding scenario and the best<br />

managed companies will have considerable competitive advantages.<br />

With the creation eight years ago of a specific segment for real<br />

estate risks, <strong>Banesto</strong> has been preparing for this change of cycle. It<br />

assumes controlled risks based on mortgages and adequate<br />

guarantees (85% of the bank’s risks are backed by real<br />

guarantees).<br />

Nevertheless, in order to manage real estate risks better and more<br />

efficiently, we reinforced the Risks Area with more specialists and<br />

new tools to manage and analyse risks.<br />

Wholesale Risk<br />

The process of admitting wholesale risks is based on the<br />

classification or global limit of each economic group, financial or<br />

sovereign institution, as well as strict monitoring and control of the<br />

classification permitting internal management of risk limits and<br />

positions at all times. The Wholesale Risk Unit also specialises in<br />

analysing the risk of our clients’ investment projects.<br />

The expert teams of analysts specialised by sectors draw up<br />

reports and assess the risks with a rating based on credit quality.<br />

Our strict policy of risk admission has given us a portfolio of<br />

diversified and high credit quality clients.<br />

A key element for risk and business decisions in corporate banking<br />

are price simulators and measurements of historic Risk Adjusted<br />

Return on Capital (RAROC).<br />

63


64<br />

Environmental Risk<br />

For many years now <strong>Banesto</strong> has been applying a methodology<br />

that assesses the environmental risk of corporate banking clients.<br />

Assessing this risk is one more variable in credit risk analysis.<br />

Environmental risk arises from the category of sector of activity<br />

and a series of variables ranging from the level of emissions and<br />

waste generated to fulfilling the specific regulations of each sector,<br />

the existence or not of lawsuits or complaints and the corrective<br />

measures taken and homologated certifications obtained.<br />

In short, by evaluating the environmental risk of a client we can<br />

select business opportunities in “clean” investment projects and<br />

forego those with a high environmental content.<br />

2. We closely supervise the loans granted and the existing risk.<br />

This tracking process enables us to anticipate difficult situations<br />

and respond quickly to them.<br />

The monitoring system is based on the following pillars:<br />

• Risk Anticipation System which reads every month 120<br />

variables representing credit risk, including internal and<br />

external information. Its use identifies counterparties requiring<br />

a special watch (FEVE).<br />

• Regular review of internal ratings of clients.<br />

• Tracking of irregular contracts.<br />

• Specialised staff in branches in Spain’s regions.<br />

• Tracking Committees covering branches, company centres,<br />

retail banking units, regional headquarters and central services.<br />

• Use of tools to obtain precise information on the state of our<br />

portfolio.<br />

• Monitoring covers all business channels in order to maintain<br />

quality.<br />

3. Loan recovery activity has known how to adapt to the more<br />

complex economic environment, creating instruments that respond<br />

rapidly to new needs, producing recovery policies, implementing<br />

specialised management by customer segment and all of this<br />

supported by cutting-edge technology and strengthening<br />

resources.<br />

The traditional policy of segmentation of loans above a certain<br />

amount was strengthened by increasing the number of managers<br />

involved in recoveries, in accordance with the current economic<br />

situation. This focuses the recovery strategy depending on the<br />

type of debt and immediate attention when called for. There are<br />

managers specialised in companies whose objective is to manage<br />

technically and efficiently creditors’ meetings which are<br />

increasingly happening in this segment; specific recovery<br />

strategies for SMEs have been established and through individual<br />

business plans segmented individual customers are managed. Of<br />

note is the high recovery capacity in mortgages.<br />

Contracts below a certain amount and consumer loans are handled<br />

by an extensive range of companies and external recovery<br />

managers, with efficiency ratios measured every six months. These<br />

structures also handle bad debts to which <strong>Banesto</strong> has always<br />

provided attention different from that of the rest of the banking<br />

sector, highlighting its recovery capacity and contribution to the<br />

income statement.<br />

The introduction in 2005 of the new model, now consolidated, for<br />

managing judicial proceedings, articulated in the Astrea tool and<br />

monitored by a specialised centre, put <strong>Banesto</strong> in a clear<br />

advantage over its competitors in these issues and enables the<br />

bank to face future challenges from a position of strength.<br />

A new version of the Recovery Management System was put into<br />

effect in 2008 which will make recoveries more efficient and quick.<br />

Lastly, another factor that distinguishes <strong>Banesto</strong> from other banks<br />

is the integration of recovery activity with the management and<br />

selling of assets assigned for non-payment of loans, which<br />

optimises the disinvestment process and focuses recovery activity<br />

on obtaining liquidity. The new and ambitious model for managing<br />

assigned real estate will help as of 2009 to boost these sales and<br />

significantly increase efficiency.<br />

The non-performing loans figures in 2008 were:<br />

NPL ratio % % EAD<br />

Corporate and Companies: 1.37 52<br />

Mortgages: 1.39 25<br />

SMEs: 2.35 15<br />

Consumer: 3.78 8<br />

TOTAL: 1.62 100


Market Risk<br />

This stems from the uncertainty over the future performance of<br />

markets, inherent in financial activity. In order to measure and<br />

control this risk, <strong>Banesto</strong> makes a distinction between risk<br />

management inherent in the bank’s structural position and<br />

management of treasury risks.<br />

1.- Structural Risks of the Balance Sheet<br />

1.1 Interest rate Risk<br />

In banks that simultaneously conduct trading and commercial<br />

activities, balance sheet management tends to be divided between<br />

the trading book – managed by the Markets Area – and the<br />

banking book managed by the Assets and Liabilities Committee<br />

(ALCO).<br />

Structural interest rate risk consists of any exposure to risk<br />

inherent in commercial banking activity (banking book). This risk<br />

can be defined as the mismatch in the calendar of repricing created<br />

between assets and liabilities by a bank’s activity, mainly deposits<br />

and loans, which make the balance sheet sensitive to movements in<br />

the curve of market interest rates.<br />

The main objective of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s ALCO is to manage the impact of<br />

the swings in interest rates and other variables included in the net<br />

interest margin and in the economic value of capital. This requires<br />

active management of interest rate risk based on monitoring the<br />

bank’s exposure and taking positions to ease that exposure.<br />

This requires detailed knowledge of the balance sheet positions<br />

and involves the development and maintenance of technologies to<br />

know the performance of each one of the balance sheet contracts.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> has experts and IT systems solely dedicated to providing<br />

all the information needed for structural risk management.<br />

Measures to improve the management processes were put into<br />

effect which reduced the time needed to know all the information<br />

of the systems and conduct simulations useful for structural risk<br />

management.<br />

A dynamic focus is used to measure the sensitivity of the net<br />

interest margin and of the economic value of capital. With<br />

previously established limits, significant variables are incorporated<br />

(reinvestment periods, early cancellations, new business, customer<br />

spreads, etc) to deterministic and stochastic models to verify the<br />

possible effects on the balance sheet of interest rate variations.<br />

These simulations also enable <strong>Banesto</strong> to analyse possible risk<br />

hedging strategies and aggregate to its balance sheet the most<br />

efficient operations, regardless of their nature (fixed income or<br />

derivatives) and always in strict compliance with prevailing rules<br />

and regulations (IAS-39 and Bank of Spain circular 4/2004).<br />

The ALCO uses different interest rate scenarios to predict the net<br />

interest margin and the economic value of capital, based on the<br />

forward curve of the market. In deterministic models, for example,<br />

the sensitivity of results arising from parallel shifts in all tranches of<br />

the market curve or movements in the slope is verified.<br />

At the end of 2008, the sensitivity of the net interest margin for<br />

the first year was -3.35% in the face of interest rate cuts, with a<br />

coverage ratio of more than 61%, while the sensitivity of the<br />

economic value of capital was at only -1.18%.<br />

In stochastic models, the bank conducts studies on the basis of<br />

neutral risk methodologies such as those specified in Hull & White.<br />

Tests were carried out in 2008 with multifactor models which<br />

reflect in the most reliable way the behaviour of interest rates in<br />

long-term scenarios, such as the Rebonato semiparametric<br />

methodology.<br />

1.2 -Liquidity Risk<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s basic strategy in liquidity risk management is to ensure<br />

there are no imbalances in complying with the bank’s<br />

commitments. Particularly attention is paid to the cost and to<br />

maintaining a conservative policy in keeping positions in liquid<br />

assets.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> improved its net monetary position during 2008, thanks<br />

to optimum management of funding and of liquidity. Wholesale<br />

financing generated ¤6,500 million.<br />

Of note in short-term wholesale financing was the opening of the<br />

Euro Commercial Paper programme, keeping the programme of<br />

institutional domestic paper and increasing assets that can be<br />

discounted in the European Central Bank via securitisation of<br />

loans.<br />

Noteworthy in the medium and long term were private placements<br />

of senior debt and mortgage bonds, and the programmes of<br />

structured issues. This improvement in liquidity together with a<br />

positive commercial gap reduced <strong>Banesto</strong>’s dependency on<br />

wholesale financing.<br />

2. Treasury Risk<br />

Measuring the risks of treasury activity are mainly concentrated in<br />

loans (or counterparty) and the market. <strong>Banesto</strong> has a Market Risk<br />

Activities Unit which monitors and measures these risks. This unit<br />

has an area for risk analysis and one for quantitative and valuation<br />

aspects. Under this structure it is possible to group the<br />

measurement of all treasury risks with an integrated focus and<br />

systems. In 2008 a very detailed monitoring of risks in treasury<br />

activities was required as a result of the financial crisis, intensified<br />

in the second half of the year.<br />

2.1. Credit Risk<br />

Credit risk in treasury activities is measured as the positive value<br />

that any financial instrument could potentially acquire in the event<br />

that the counterparty fails to meet their contractual obligations.<br />

This would produce a drop in value for <strong>Banesto</strong> as the replacement<br />

cost of an instrument with a positive value would represent a loss.<br />

65


66<br />

Exposure of treasury<br />

activities by segments<br />

wholesale<br />

banking<br />

company<br />

banking<br />

0.27<br />

5.52<br />

0.45<br />

retail<br />

banking<br />

93.76<br />

Credit Risk management of Treasury<br />

As a result of the surge in wholesale banking activity in the last few<br />

years, the number of operations with clients related to treasury<br />

products has increased notably. The Market Risk Activities Unit<br />

Profile of exposure and limits<br />

billions<br />

Today<br />

real estate<br />

(MRAU) manages and controls the credit risk of treasury products.<br />

The potential values of each financial instrument during their life<br />

are estimated with a confidence level of 97.725%. In the event of a<br />

non-payment, <strong>Banesto</strong>’s loss would be less than the estimated loss<br />

in 97.725% of cases<br />

The MRAU introduced new credit risk measurement systems in<br />

2008, which calculate the exposure to each client on the basis of<br />

various time frames. This analysis facilitates greater control and a<br />

more dynamic and efficient management of the limits set by the<br />

admission units. Every day these units and wholesale banking are<br />

informed of the credit risk positions with each client and given a<br />

detailed breakdown. Every week the Risks Committee is given<br />

detailed information of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s exposures by segment, product,<br />

rating, maturities and risk factors.<br />

The average exposure in 2008 was €7,450 million. Wholesale<br />

banking accounted for 93.7%, company banking 5.5%, real estate<br />

0.45% and retail banking 0.3%.<br />

The consumer profile during 2008 was concentrated on short-term<br />

maturities of up to a month and low levels of use of the assigned<br />

limits (see the graph).<br />

Market conditions made close monitoring of the limits necessary.<br />

The limits were reviewed for those counterparties in which the<br />

perceived credit quality could have suffered significant<br />

deterioration. <strong>Banesto</strong> was thus constantly alert to changing<br />

situations in the market and closely tracked the limits approved for<br />

the various counterparties for operations with financial<br />

instruments, particularly derivatives<br />

Exposure<br />

Limits<br />

1 1 1M 3M 6M 9M 1Y 18M 2Y 30M 3Y 42M 4Y 54M 5Y 6Y 7Y 8Y 9Y 10Y 12Y 15Y 20Y 25Y 30Y Inf<br />

Day Week


2.2. Market Risk<br />

The market risks that affect treasury activity (interest rates,<br />

exchange rates, equities, spreads on loans, Implicit volatilities,<br />

correlations, etc) are managed and controlled with the standard<br />

methodology of Value at Risk (VaR) through historic simulation.<br />

The VaR provides a homogeneous risk figure that represents the<br />

maximum expected loss in the face of adverse market movements,<br />

with a level of confidence of 99%. The VaR is calculated and<br />

reported to senior management every day, and is controlled<br />

through a system of limits that affect the total positions as well as<br />

each of the portfolios. Senior management is continuously<br />

informed and involved in market risk management through weekly<br />

meetings of committees under the Board’s Risks Committee, as well<br />

as via the Assets and Liabilities Committee.<br />

The average daily VaR in 2008 remained at around €4.9 million, of<br />

which €2.2 million reflected the level of market risk really assumed<br />

and €2.7 million other technical market risks which are<br />

systematically covered by provisions, in accordance with <strong>Banesto</strong>’s<br />

policy.<br />

As well as market risk measurement via VaR tension scenarios are<br />

VaR distribution in 2008<br />

Number of days (%)<br />

11.6<br />

4<br />

10.9 11.6<br />

4.25<br />

4.50<br />

12.4 12.8<br />

4.75<br />

5<br />

5.25<br />

VaR in millions of euros<br />

Operational Risk<br />

5.50<br />

5.75<br />

6<br />

6.25<br />

6.5<br />

and<br />

more<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s operational risk management model was created in line<br />

with the requirements of the BIS II agreement, the EU directive on<br />

the capital of banks and Bank of Spain circular 3/2008 on<br />

solvency.<br />

The main objectives in this sphere are:<br />

• Identify and eliminate points of operational risk before they lead<br />

to problems.<br />

• Reduce operational risk losses and establish plans to ease them<br />

6.2<br />

3.1<br />

5.0<br />

7.4<br />

5.4<br />

1.2<br />

analysed in which the impact on the value of portfolios of certain<br />

extreme events is simulated. Historic and hypothetical scenarios<br />

are evaluated with various degrees of severity and probability, and<br />

the conclusions drawn are regularly discussed by senior<br />

management through the mentioned reporting cycles. <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

also regularly estimates the average extreme losses that could<br />

occur in the event of exceeding the VaR level, through the<br />

statistical conditional VaR, which is reported to senior management<br />

on a daily basis and analysed by the committees. The conditional<br />

VaR in 2008 was maintained at around €7 million.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s market risk measurement model is being assessed by the<br />

Bank of Spain for its use as the internal model for determining the<br />

minimum equity for this concept. The relevant audits of the model<br />

were satisfactorily conducted in 2008 before being presented to<br />

the Bank of Spain, whose inspection is underway. Internally,<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> traces and continuously fine tunes the quality of the<br />

model through a backtesting programme, which systematically<br />

compares the model’s predictions with the actual results of<br />

treasury activities. The results of the retrospective tests have been<br />

verified by the Group’s auditing departments, and by rating<br />

agencies, meeting the requirements recommended by international<br />

regulators.<br />

VaR evolution during 2008<br />

8.000.000<br />

6.000.000<br />

4.000.000<br />

2.000.000<br />

0<br />

-2.000.000<br />

-4.000.000<br />

-6.000.000<br />

-8.000.000<br />

-10.000.000<br />

-12.000.000<br />

VaR / EaR 2008<br />

Total VaR Total EaR Result<br />

Jan-08 Feb-08 Mar-08 Apr-08 May-08 May-08 Jun-08 Jul-08 Aug-08 Sep-08 Oct-08 Nov-08 Dec-08<br />

on the basis of the type of risk and the business affected.<br />

In order to cover these objectives in 2008, we finished putting into<br />

effect a wide series of qualitative and quantitative operational risk<br />

management tools, taking full advantage of the bank’s advanced<br />

technology and information system.<br />

We launched the NORMA project. It is based on five elements<br />

(cash management, operational and documentary normalisation,<br />

security, order and image, and other operational risks), and other<br />

measures which aim to:<br />

• Improve the practices and performance of the project.<br />

67


68<br />

• Reduce to an efficient threshold the events and losses of each<br />

type of risk.<br />

• Incorporate the business direction vision to operational risk<br />

management of the network.<br />

• Consolidate the results in a series of indicators valid for all levels.<br />

We have increased the coverage of operational risk indicators,<br />

doubling their number in our data base. Measurements of these<br />

indicators are regularly and automatically obtained, facilitating a<br />

warning system through the corresponding analysis of the<br />

appropriate intervals for each indicator. A study will be made at<br />

some point on the relation between these indicators and the losses<br />

from operational risk.<br />

The creation in 2008 of Regional Committees of Operational Risk<br />

helped to deepen knowledge and management of operational risk.<br />

The Central Committee of Operational Risk, established in 2004 to<br />

reduce this risk and support the implementation of measures to<br />

ease it, has been successful in its tasks, particularly in risks related<br />

to execution, practices with customers and incidents in systems.<br />

Our data base of losses has already been operating for five years.<br />

Its level of automation and detail enables all the bank’s centres and<br />

Distribution of losses<br />

by type of risk (%)<br />

accumulated data 2008<br />

Retail<br />

Banking<br />

10.3<br />

3.7<br />

6.0<br />

0.7<br />

3.6<br />

Central<br />

Services<br />

Company<br />

Banking<br />

Wholesale<br />

Banking<br />

Treasury<br />

75.8<br />

Channels and<br />

dedicated office<br />

branches to immediately know operational risk incidents. This data<br />

base has also enabled us to draw up reports comparing <strong>Banesto</strong> to<br />

other Spanish banks in the Operational Riskdata Exchange<br />

Association (ORX). The main objective of ORX is to exchange<br />

anonymously operational risk losses, which are used to make a<br />

model of this risk and validate internal capturing. ORX, which<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> joined in 2005, currently has 49 members, and is a<br />

leading forum for research and development of standards within<br />

operational risk management.<br />

The information obtained through self-assessment questionnaires<br />

during 2008 is enabling us to draw up in greater detail <strong>Banesto</strong>’s<br />

risks map, and define the priorities for each of the areas evaluated.<br />

The bank’s operational risk department is also responsible for the<br />

project to draw up a Business Continuity Plan based on the critical<br />

processes detected for the various areas and their requirements to<br />

keep on operating in the event of serious problems. This plan is<br />

being developed in accordance with the banking sector’s<br />

regulations and best practices. <strong>Banesto</strong> is a member of the Spanish<br />

Consortium of Business Continuity and actively participates in the<br />

Working Groups of Definitions and Coordination with Critical<br />

Sectors and Institutions..<br />

Distribution of losses<br />

by business line (%)<br />

accumulated data 2008<br />

Execution, delivery<br />

and management of<br />

processes<br />

Practices with<br />

customers,<br />

products and<br />

businesses<br />

36.0<br />

9.3<br />

External fraud<br />

2.9 2.0<br />

0.4<br />

Damage to<br />

material assets<br />

Internal fraud<br />

Incidents and<br />

failures on systems<br />

18.3<br />

31.0<br />

Labour relations


Global risk management<br />

1. Risk Cuantification.<br />

One of the basic elements of risk management is correct<br />

measurement and quantification.<br />

Global and efficient risk management requires the development of<br />

methodologies and models that the enable basic parameters of<br />

measurement to be quantified, such as expected and unexpected<br />

loss. Moreover, it is vital to have tools that allow adequate<br />

protection measures to be established in order to identify business<br />

growth areas. The bank’s appetite for risk, however, is always taken<br />

into account.<br />

For several years <strong>Banesto</strong> has been using quantitative models that<br />

estimate these parameters, on the basis of four basic elements: the<br />

probability of default (PD), the exposure at default (EaD), the loss<br />

given default (LGD) and asset correlation (AC).<br />

A significant step was taken in 2008 when a model was made of<br />

these parameters which reflected the current situation of the<br />

macroeconomic cycle from a point of time perspective (PiT). Each<br />

parameter is estimated on the basis of macroeconomic variables<br />

such as GDP, interest rates, unemployment, housing prices, growth<br />

in lending, etc and incorporated to risk and return management<br />

according to the bank’s prospects for the coming months.<br />

In addition, the behaviour of portfolios/customers in the face of<br />

the change in the environment makes it necessary for these models<br />

to be increasingly more granular, in order to support management<br />

tailored to each customer’s requirements and not implement the<br />

same policies for different risk profiles.<br />

Rating through the cycle<br />

Corporate Banking<br />

Probability of default (PD)<br />

All our rating/scoring models (corporate, banks, companies, real<br />

estate promoters, SMEs, consumer credit, mortgages, cards and<br />

individuals) are calibrated for default probabilities.<br />

This measurement is based on a statistical process which, drawing<br />

on the bank’s history of defaults with customers/operations,<br />

assigns to each risk category (rating/score) a probability of<br />

suffering a default of more than 90 days over the course of a year.<br />

These default probabilities are the homogeneous term that enable<br />

comparisons to be made between customers from different<br />

segments, and which also serve as an objective measurement for<br />

comparing banks’ risk profiles.<br />

In line with making models subject to the impact of<br />

macroeconomic effects, our probabilities of default are adjusted by<br />

corrective coefficients according to the objective of their use<br />

(pricing, internal provisions, regulatory and economic capital, etc)<br />

and the scenarios set by senior management.<br />

Final models of PD adjustment were developed, which are based on<br />

structural credit risk models and are a very important qualitative<br />

addition as they enable the deficiencies that sometimes come from<br />

adjustment models (from regression in macroeconomic trends) to<br />

be improved.<br />

All these models connect to our stress test models, enabling the<br />

default rates to be assessed in the event of adverse<br />

macroeconomic variables, and analyse the sensitivity of our<br />

portfolio to each of the effects separately and together.<br />

Promoters<br />

Medium Companies SMEs<br />

Self-employed Mortgages Personal<br />

Rest Retail<br />

69


70<br />

Rating point in time<br />

Corporate Banking<br />

Promoters<br />

Medium Companies SMEs<br />

Self-employed Mortgages Personal<br />

Rest Retail<br />

Exposure at default (EaD)<br />

This measures the potential risk by estimating the use a contract<br />

will have at the point of going into default. It is calculated on the<br />

basis of committed lines of credit, such as credit accounts or<br />

commercial discount.<br />

In a world that is increasingly using financial instruments, the<br />

challenge has been to precisely model the exposure of our<br />

customers in these products (hedging of interest rates, currency,<br />

structured products, etc).<br />

Loss Given Default (LGD)<br />

After knowing the probability of occurrence of default and the<br />

amount exposed, LGD enables the definitive loss to be measured<br />

after recovery of interest and capital, including the direct and<br />

indirect recovery costs. This process is conducted on the basis of<br />

the historic experience of customers in recovery management. As in<br />

the case of PD, the LGD is determined by the moment of the<br />

economic cycle, as bad debts, asset prices and other factors<br />

significantly affect non-payment recoveries and hence the loss.<br />

In order to incorporate this cyclical effect the models take into<br />

account those variables that most affect the final loss such as the<br />

recovery time, the probability of legal proceedings, the recovery<br />

distribution in the event of proceedings, etc.<br />

Using the same factors as for PD enables us to assess the<br />

correlation between PD and LGD and the joint impact on expected<br />

loss of specific stress scenarios of both parameters.


Losses in corporate<br />

portfolio (at dec. 08)<br />

% LGD<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

Guarantees Loans Commercial Leasing<br />

discount<br />

Loan with Personal<br />

real loan<br />

guarantee<br />

Expected Loss: this comes from the combination of the three<br />

previous concepts and is the annual risk cost associated with our<br />

credit exposure, which shows up in the income statement.<br />

As in previous cases, this expected loss depends on the<br />

management objective and the scenario foreseen for it.<br />

On the basis of our internal estimates, <strong>Banesto</strong>'s average expected<br />

loss (point in time) is 0.67% and the through cycle 0.41% (0.30%<br />

in 2007).<br />

Risk adjusted exposure<br />

Losses in retail<br />

portfolio (at dec. 08)<br />

% LGD<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

(%) (%)<br />

4<br />

5<br />

17<br />

23<br />

Corp. Banking<br />

Med size<br />

companies<br />

3<br />

Promoters<br />

9<br />

Small Comps<br />

and shops<br />

10<br />

Self-employed<br />

Mortgages<br />

Personal<br />

29<br />

Rest<br />

Loans<br />

Mortgage<br />

Personal<br />

loan<br />

Cards<br />

Asset correlation and diversification: this is the fourth factor. It<br />

measures the contribution that the joint movement of financial<br />

assets makes to the distribution of credit risk losses.<br />

The key element in capital models and thus of their appropriate<br />

measurement depends on ensuring the bank’s solvency during<br />

extreme moments of an adverse cycle.<br />

In an environment like the current one it is a very important<br />

competitive advantage to have a diversified portfolio. <strong>Banesto</strong> pays<br />

particular attention to measuring and managing this parameter and<br />

for this reason created a post for constant analysis of the portfolio<br />

and controlling concentrations by individuals and sectors and<br />

setting limits for them.<br />

Every year <strong>Banesto</strong> reviews the correlation models, checking the<br />

prior estimates and the methodologies used.<br />

Expected loss<br />

Corp. Banking<br />

Med size<br />

companies<br />

11<br />

4<br />

Promoters<br />

15<br />

17<br />

Small Comps<br />

and shops<br />

6 6<br />

Self-employed<br />

Mortgages<br />

Personal<br />

21<br />

20<br />

Rest<br />

71


72<br />

Economic Capital (EC): although the expected loss is one of the<br />

key elements of credit risk management, it is not sufficient because<br />

these losses are not stable. A tool is therefore needed which<br />

provides information on the variability of these losses. This<br />

information is provided by the economic capital, which seeks to<br />

measure the impact on the bank of these losses in exceptional<br />

situations. <strong>Banesto</strong> has two objectives: on the one hand, to<br />

minimise this volatility and ensure the best return for shareholders<br />

and, on the other, maintain a maximum level of solvency during<br />

stress situations.<br />

Economic Capital/risk adjusted capital Expected Loss/risk adjusted exposure<br />

8%<br />

7%<br />

6%<br />

5%<br />

4%<br />

3%<br />

2%<br />

1%<br />

0%<br />

3.31<br />

Corp. Banking<br />

7.57<br />

3.57<br />

Med size<br />

companies<br />

Promoters<br />

Small Comps<br />

and shops<br />

5.22<br />

Self-employed<br />

2.67<br />

Mortgages<br />

1.71<br />

5.34<br />

Personal<br />

3.23<br />

Rest<br />

Economic Capital<br />

4%<br />

3.5%<br />

3%<br />

2.5%<br />

2%<br />

1.5%<br />

1%<br />

0.5%<br />

0%<br />

(%)<br />

Corp. Banking<br />

0.24<br />

0.12<br />

Corp. Banking<br />

Med size<br />

companies<br />

0.47<br />

Med size<br />

companies<br />

2<br />

13<br />

Promoters<br />

11<br />

% PE/EAD TTC<br />

% PE/EAD PIT<br />

1.34<br />

20<br />

0.74<br />

0.24<br />

Promoters<br />

Small Comps<br />

and shops<br />

5<br />

1.15<br />

0.75<br />

Small Comps<br />

and shops<br />

4<br />

Self-employed<br />

Self-employed<br />

0.90<br />

0.63<br />

Mortgages<br />

0.32<br />

Mortgages<br />

16<br />

Personal<br />

0.22<br />

29<br />

2.76<br />

1.95<br />

Personal<br />

Rest<br />

0.82<br />

0.60<br />

Rest


2. Integration in risk management<br />

Risk quantification is not an end in itself, but provides tools which,<br />

incorporated to daily activity, are vital for modern risk management<br />

at both the individual and portfolio levels.<br />

Incorporating expected loss and capital estimates as basic<br />

management elements has been one of the challenges in recent<br />

years and more so now in a market environment that requires a<br />

much more advanced management and one able to anticipate.<br />

In corporate banking and companies the price simulators and<br />

measurements, both for historic and projected RAROC, are the key<br />

elements for taking decisions on risks and businesses.<br />

In the case of retail portfolios the risk premium is incorporated to<br />

the income statement at all levels. This step has made all<br />

employees aware of anticipative risk management and the need for<br />

correct measurement. This means quality management in elements<br />

such as customer rating and taking additional guarantees.<br />

One of the spheres at the strategic level that is very important for<br />

us is defining and monitoring the risk profile based on our risk<br />

appetite. This profile is the projection/estimation that the bank<br />

makes every year for each portfolio on the basis of business issues<br />

and forecasts for the main risk parameters. These projections made<br />

for various time scales enable us to anticipate and manage changes<br />

(in the cycle, migration from portfolios, structural change in the<br />

population, etc) and so detect shifts in the risks profile well before<br />

they produce a deterioration in the quality of our lending portfolio.<br />

Stress Test: Various analyses with an impact on the income<br />

statement were conducted in 2008, using “once every three years”<br />

or “once every five years” interest rate scenarios, as well as general<br />

stress models for the banking sector as a whole using unlikely<br />

events (once in every 10,000 years).<br />

The big challenge in 2008 was to define a stress model that as well<br />

as incorporating all types of possible or extreme scenarios and<br />

assessing their global impact, gives us information by product,<br />

customer, sector, geographic area, credit quality and the sub<br />

portfolios most exposed to a specific scenario and the impact.<br />

This again became a tool for anticipating risk which identifies<br />

customers susceptible to problems as well as those with a good<br />

risk profile and draw up management strategies based on this<br />

information.<br />

Strategic management of risk: One of the important tasks of the<br />

Global Risk Unit is risk intelligence, probably the factor that<br />

contributes most value added.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s risk intelligence architecture, based on developing<br />

advanced decision-making models, has three specific lines of<br />

analysis:<br />

• Support for decision-making, detecting performance changes.<br />

• Backing the bank in strategic business areas, bearing in mind<br />

the advances in financial markets: transfer and movement of<br />

risk among others.<br />

• Co-operation with universities and other agents, keeping us in<br />

touch with the financial world and fostering new developments<br />

in methodologies.<br />

These three lines were strengthened in 2008 through:<br />

• The management structure for the Risks Area.<br />

• Strengthening the Management Analysis Area whose task is to<br />

ensure strategic management by globally tracking the portfolio<br />

of loans and analysing the main risk/return magnitudes.<br />

Internal validation: A critical element of global risk management is<br />

the role played by internal validation as an independent control<br />

team. Its main mission is to issue opinions on whether the models<br />

work as has been envisaged and whether the results obtained<br />

(methodology, data bases, qualitative and quantitative aspects, use<br />

test) are appropriate for the different uses to which they are<br />

applied, both internal and regulatory, and question in an effective<br />

way the work of all the areas.<br />

Internal validation reviewed in 2008 all the advanced models and<br />

detected areas for improvement, contributing greater value and<br />

benefiting management of the various risks.<br />

3. New Capital Accord – Basel ii<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> won approval in 2008 for its internal model for estimating<br />

capital and informed the Bank of Spain, according to this model, of<br />

its requirements in June and September.<br />

We thus completed the Basel II project and it became an integral<br />

part of our daily management of risks and capital.<br />

It is increasingly important to continue to make progress in those<br />

aspects that sustain the spirit of the accord and which entail<br />

considerable efforts in methodology, processes, control and<br />

internal validation, technology and incorporation of all these<br />

elements into management.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> developed a plan during 2008 to enable us to adapt to<br />

future requirements in all spheres of our business and anticipate<br />

possible future needs from increasingly demanding regulations.<br />

73


74<br />

2008 report of the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> created its Audit and Compliance Committee on December 18, 2002. It is regulated by the<br />

18th additional disposition of the Securities Market Act (introduced by article 47 of Law<br />

44/2002), in article 18 of the corporate by-laws and article 14 of the Board’s Regulations.<br />

The functions of the Audit and Compliance Committee are set out<br />

in Appendix 1, and are summarised as follows:<br />

Shareholders<br />

- Inform Shareholders’ Meetings<br />

- Reply to questions regarding matters within its sphere.<br />

Internal auditing<br />

Supervise the Internal Auditing services by<br />

- Annual planning of work.<br />

- Reports on activities.<br />

- Monitoring the conclusions and recommendations of its<br />

reports.<br />

External auditing<br />

- Propose the appointment of the auditing firm and the<br />

conditions of the contract.<br />

- Supervise compliance with the contract and assess the results.<br />

- Act as a channel of communication between the Board and the<br />

auditing firm.<br />

- Seek to obtain clear and precise reports.<br />

- Vouch for the auditing firm’s independence.<br />

Compliance<br />

Supervise compliance with:<br />

- The Group’s Code of Conduct in the Securities Markets.<br />

- The manuals and procedures for the prevention of money<br />

laundering.<br />

- The actions and measures that are the result of the steps taken<br />

by the supervision authorities.<br />

- The rules and procedures of corporate governance.<br />

Financial information<br />

- Review the annual financial statements.<br />

- Vouch for compliance with the legal requirements.<br />

- Vouch for the correct application of accounting principles.<br />

- Be familiar with and supervise the drawing up of financial<br />

information.<br />

- Review, before dissemination, the regular financial information<br />

supplied to the National Securities Market Commission.<br />

- Receive, treat and keep the complaints (internal and external)<br />

received by the Bank on issues related to the process of<br />

generating financial information, auditing and internal controls.<br />

Internal control systems<br />

- Be familiar with and supervise the internal control systems.<br />

- Be familiar with and supervise the risk management control<br />

systems.<br />

- Report on, before approval by the Board or the Executive<br />

Committee, the creation or acquisition of participations in<br />

special purpose entities or those domiciled in tax havens.<br />

- Report on linked operations submitted for the Board’s<br />

approval.


Composition of the committee<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee consisted of three directors<br />

and a Secretary (not a director) at the end of 2008. Of the four<br />

members, three are independent directors and the other is a<br />

proprietary director:<br />

Chairman: Belén Romana García<br />

Members: José Luis López Combarros<br />

Víctor Manuel Menéndez Millán<br />

Matías Rodríguez Inciarte<br />

Secretary: Jaime Pérez Renovales<br />

The changes during 2008 in the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

were as follows<br />

1.) The Board at its meeting on March 25, 2008 approved, at the<br />

request of the Appointments and Remuneration Committee,<br />

the incorporation to the Board of Belén Romana García as an<br />

independent director. Her inclusion in the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee was also approved.<br />

2) On July 22, 2008, the Board agreed, at the request of the<br />

Appointments and Remuneration Committee, to appoint Belén<br />

Romana García as chairman of the Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee, to replace José Luis López Combarros who had<br />

been in the post for the maximum period of four years set in<br />

the law regulating the Securities Market, article 18 of the Bylaws<br />

and article 14 of the Regulations of the Board of Directors.<br />

Activties during 2008 of the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee met 14 times during 2007<br />

in order to carry out the tasks entrusted it by the Board of<br />

Directors. There were also frequent contacts with the external<br />

auditors, the internal auditors, the Directorate of Corporate<br />

Development and Finances, the Group’s financial controller, the<br />

Directorate of Internal Control and Compliance, as well as with<br />

most of the Bank’s executives in order to obtain information and<br />

explanations about the Group.<br />

A brief summary is given below of the aforementioned functions.<br />

Shareholders<br />

At the Shareholders’ Meeting in February, 2008 the work of the<br />

Audit and Compliance Committee was explained and replies were<br />

given to the questions raised regarding matters that are its<br />

responsibility. The Meeting in February 2009 will report on the<br />

activities in 2008.<br />

Internal Auditing<br />

The maximum executive of Internal Auditing met three times with<br />

the Committee during 2008 to inform it of the work plan for the<br />

year, the recommendations and conclusions reached and the<br />

monitoring and implementation of these recommendations<br />

In addition, Internal Auditing also informed the Bank’s Board of the<br />

work done and their conclusions.<br />

The Committee expressed its satisfaction with the work carried out<br />

by the services of Internal Auditing as regards supervising<br />

compliance, the effectiveness and efficiency of the Group’s internal<br />

control systems, as well as the reliability and quality of the<br />

accounting information.<br />

External Auditing<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee proposed at its meeting on<br />

January 21, 2008 the re-election of Deloitte S.L. as the auditing<br />

firm of the Bank’s and the Group’s financial statements during<br />

2008, and the scope of its mandate.<br />

The Committee held six meetings with its external auditors during<br />

2008 at which it was informed of the process of auditing the<br />

2008 financial statements, and the inherent aspects, problems and<br />

considerations.<br />

The auditors attended the presentation to the Committee of the<br />

public information on the quarterly and annual results given by the<br />

Financial Controller and the Directorate of Corporate Development<br />

and Finances.<br />

The audits on the 2007 individual statements of the Bank and the<br />

consolidated ones were clean (without qualifications) and the<br />

auditors stated that<br />

a) the annual financial statements faithfully reflect, in all<br />

significant aspects, the Bank’s and the Group’s shareholders’<br />

equity and financial situation at December 31, 2008, the<br />

results of the Bank’s and the Group’s operations, the changes<br />

in net worth and their cash flows and<br />

b) the Bank’s and the consolidated Group’s annual financial<br />

statements contain the necessary and sufficient information<br />

to be interpreted and adequately understood, in accordance<br />

with the International Financial Reporting Standards adopted<br />

by the European Union (for the consolidated Group), and in<br />

accordance with the principles and accounting rules in Bank<br />

of Spain Circular 4/2004 (for the Bank), and are in<br />

conformance with the rules used to draw up the previous<br />

year’s statements.<br />

In accordance with Royal Decree 1362 of October 19, 2007, which<br />

regulates the financial information that the bank, as a listed<br />

company, has to approve and send to the National Securities<br />

Market Commissions, consolidated and summarised half yearly<br />

financial statements were drawn up and sent to the supervisor,<br />

corresponding to the first half of the year, whose submission to the<br />

auditing firm is voluntarily decided by each company.<br />

The Bank’s Board decided that this half yearly information should<br />

be subject to auditing, and the firm issued the corresponding audit<br />

(without qualifications).<br />

The Committee was told by the partner responsible for auditing<br />

that during the work the team had access to the necessary<br />

information and received full cooperation from the Group’s<br />

employees. The external auditor also reported on compliance with<br />

the rules of independence established in the Auditing of Accounts<br />

Act.<br />

75


76<br />

Article 39 of the Board’s Regulations does not allow an auditing<br />

firm to be hired when the fees it charges to the Group represent<br />

more than 2% of its total fees. This article also establishes that the<br />

partner responsible for the auditing team allocated to the Group<br />

must be replaced every seven years and services other than those<br />

of auditing which could put at risk the firm’s independence will not<br />

be contracted.<br />

Regarding these stipulations in the regulations, we would like to<br />

point out that<br />

1. The bill for auditing the Group in 2008 and other nonauditing<br />

services provided by the auditor is duly set out in<br />

note 42 in the section on the annual financial statements.<br />

2. The auditing fees of Deloitte, S.L for services other than<br />

auditing amounted to €1,221,000 (€254,000 for work<br />

required by supervisory bodies and which can be done by the<br />

same auditor).<br />

3. The partner responsible for responsible for the team auditing<br />

the Group began in 2007, making it the second year auditing<br />

the accounts of the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group.<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee also verified that the work<br />

contracted with the auditor and requested by supervisory bodies<br />

complied with the requirements of independence established in<br />

Law 19 of July 12, 1988 on Auditing of Accounts.<br />

The fees charged to the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group by Deloitte worldwide<br />

represented 0.015% of their global total and those charged by<br />

Deloitte (Spain) 0.69% of its turnover.<br />

As a result, the Audit and Compliance Committee concludes there<br />

are no objective reasons for questioning the auditing firm’s<br />

independence.<br />

The Committee agreed at its meeting on January 19, 2009 to<br />

propose to the Board the re-election of Deloitte, S.L. as the firm to<br />

audit the Bank’s and the Group’s financial statements for 2009.<br />

Compliance<br />

In order to verify the existence of procedures for complying with<br />

regulations, the Audit and Compliance Committee held meetings<br />

with those in charge of:<br />

- Implementing the EU’s Markets in Financial Instruments<br />

Directive (MiFID)<br />

- Prevention of money laundering<br />

- Compliance with the Code of Conduct in the Securities<br />

Market.<br />

- Areas subject to the control and inspection of the<br />

administrative authorities.<br />

- Compliance with the rules and procedures of corporate<br />

governance.<br />

The MFID directive, incorporated to Spanish law by Law 47 of<br />

December 19, 2007, established the requirements which certain<br />

companies and financial institutions have to adapt in order to<br />

develop their activity of providing investment services.<br />

During 2008, the Bank implemented all the regulations, via various<br />

policies and internal procedures. A new map of regulations in risks,<br />

integrated into the internal control model, was installed in order to<br />

be able to monitor the correct implementation of the new<br />

procedures.<br />

In order to adapt the commercial processes with customers, the<br />

internal regulation on the marketing and distribution of products<br />

and services, marketing and publicity actions with customers and<br />

the circuit for creating and launching new products were updated.<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee was informed of the<br />

adaptation tasks in order to verify compliance with the<br />

requirements set in the new regulations and with the date of<br />

implementation. This supervision will continue during 2009.<br />

In money laundering, information was received on the new<br />

developments in the regulatory framework which came into effect<br />

during 2008, the training courses developed, the compliance of<br />

manuals and internal procedures, as well as the contents of the<br />

external expert’s report on the Group’s procedures to prevent<br />

money laundering, required by article 11, item 7, of Royal Decree<br />

325/1995.<br />

The Committee also supervised compliance with the Code of<br />

Conduct in the Securities Market , which affects 654 people in<br />

Grupo <strong>Banesto</strong>. Compliance executives reported on the control<br />

activities, the results, the training courses given, as well as the<br />

improvements being made.<br />

The Committee was also informed of the communications received<br />

from the supervision and control authorities, as well as the<br />

measures taken to comply with the requirements and<br />

recommendations of these bodies.<br />

The Corporate Governance report, which is included in the annual<br />

public information, was also reviewed. We acknowledged there are<br />

reasonable rules and procedures to meet the requirements, and the<br />

contents of this report, which will be submitted for the Board’s<br />

approval, were favourably reported on.<br />

The Committee received information on linked operations and the<br />

measures underway regarding appropriate documentation and<br />

information.<br />

Financial information<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee held several meetings with<br />

the Group’s financial controller in order to know in detail the<br />

process for drawing up the Bank’s and the Group’s annual and<br />

quarterly financial statements.<br />

The Group’s controller and the auditing firm reported on the<br />

regular public information sent to the supervisory authority during<br />

2008 and on the individual and consolidated financial statements<br />

for 2008, which were drawn up in accordance with the Bank of<br />

Spain Circular 4 of December 22, 2004 and with the International<br />

Financial Reporting Standards adopted by the European Union,<br />

which follow criteria consistent with 2007.


Information was also requested to verify the adjustment of the<br />

criteria used to the applicable accounting regulations and<br />

principles and so ensure that the financial statements reflect the<br />

Group’s financial and net worth situation as well as the results of<br />

its operations. The Committee reported favourably on the<br />

definitive texts of the annual statements for 2008, as well as the<br />

regular information published as a listed company during 2008.<br />

The Group’s lawyers were also asked to provide information on the<br />

legal and fiscal eventualities and confirm they were appropriately<br />

treated in the financial information.<br />

As reported at the Shareholders’ Meeting in 2008, the Regulations<br />

of the Board, were modified and included among the functions of<br />

the Audit and Compliance Committee the following:<br />

“Adopt the necessary measure to: (i) receive, treat and keep the<br />

complaints received by the Bank on matters related to the<br />

process of generating financial information, auditing and internal<br />

controls; and (ii) enable employees, confidentially, and, if<br />

considered appropriate, anonymously, to communicate<br />

irregularities of potential importance, especially financial and<br />

accounting ones, they see in the sphere of the company.”<br />

In order to fulfil this mandate, the Committee called for a Circular<br />

to be drawn up which regulates the procedure for receiving these<br />

communications, which was disseminated throughout the group.<br />

Internal control systems<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee dedicated several meetings<br />

to knowing and evaluating the internal control systems of the<br />

Group’s operating areas, especially the credit, market and financial<br />

areas as well as the systems, computer processes and the policies<br />

and procedures for risk control, mainly credit, market, liquidity and<br />

operational.<br />

Given their importance, we would like to mention the following two<br />

projects which are having a significant impact on improving internal<br />

control of the Bank, as well as summarising the actions taken by<br />

the Bank during 2008 in the sphere of credit risks.<br />

Requirements of the Sarbanes Oxley Act<br />

The Bank, by belonging to the Group of Banco Santander S.A.<br />

which is listed on the US market, has to meet the requirements of<br />

the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of July 2002. Among its objectives are to<br />

foster and favour the transparency and reliability of financial<br />

statements by promoting the review and systemisation of the<br />

internal controls established for mitigating the risks associated<br />

with financial information.<br />

The internal control model is a dynamic one which reviews and<br />

updates the risks and, consequently, the controls constantly<br />

associated. During 2008, 75 new controls for new documented<br />

activities were incorporated, regarding the MiFID regulations,<br />

control of the activities of financial agents, the activity of <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

Bolsa and the outsourcing of processes.<br />

Critical and non-critical controls were identified during 2008<br />

(classified on the basis of four parameters: economic, financial,<br />

legal and reputational impact), with no significant incidents<br />

observed.<br />

The model covers almost 99% of the Bank’s financial statements,<br />

so the documented controls guarantee their correct drawing up.<br />

As in 2007, the model was certified without qualifications. Some<br />

250 people took part in this process, among them the Bank’s<br />

senior financial and management executives, as well as all the<br />

General Directorates. This assessment was ratified by Internal<br />

Auditing in various reports as well as the external auditing firm in<br />

its report on May 22, 2008.<br />

Basel II<br />

2008 saw the entry into force of Basel II, with implementation for<br />

regulatory purposes of a model which until then had been solely<br />

used for internal management purposes. The Bank of Spain<br />

authorised <strong>Banesto</strong> in July to use its advanced Internal Rating<br />

Based (IRB) model to estimate the requirements of equity capital<br />

corresponding to credit risk.<br />

The main tasks undertaken related to the following aspects:<br />

• Improving all the methodologies and systems: on the basis of<br />

continuous work by the internal validation teams and the<br />

reports of auditors and the Bank of Spain, all relevant aspects<br />

of the existing model were improved. The model is a dynamic<br />

one which needs to be continuously fine tuned.<br />

• Estimating the capital: since June estimates have been made in<br />

parallel of the capital requirements applying Basel II under its<br />

IRB focus with the results of using Basel I.<br />

• Improved processes to increase the test of use: management<br />

processes were reviewed incorporating more intensely all the<br />

estimates of risk supporting the capital model. A decisive step<br />

was the incorporation of the risk premium to all levels in the<br />

income statement.<br />

• Self-evaluation of capital: lastly, and in line with the<br />

requirements of regulations, we assessed the capital in order to<br />

ensure sufficient coverage levels for the next few years, both in<br />

foreseeable situations as well as in others under severe crisis<br />

scenarios.<br />

The measures to be taken during the first half of 2009 include<br />

publishing, for the first time, information with prudential relevance<br />

which will represent a significant advance in transparent<br />

information about the management model and the risk profile of<br />

our business.<br />

As anticipated in our 2007 report, Basel II is no longer a project<br />

and has been implemented, both for estimating equity as well as<br />

integrating it into all the risk management processes.<br />

77


78<br />

Credit risk<br />

Given the economic and financial situation in 2008, the<br />

Committee dedicated several of its meetings to credit risk<br />

management, evaluating non-performing loans, tracking risks and<br />

recoveries.<br />

This is an activity of maximum priority to which the Bank’s<br />

Executive Committee and the Risks Committee are dedicating a lot<br />

of time. The Audit and Compliance Committee will continue to<br />

supervise the credit risk control systems during 2009.<br />

Conclusion<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee informed the Board in detail<br />

of its work during 2008 on two occasions and held 14 meetings. It<br />

was in close contact with those running the various areas<br />

mentioned in this report, enabling the committee to fulfil the<br />

functions assigned to it by the Board of Banco Español de Crédito,<br />

S.A.<br />

APPENDIX 1<br />

REGULATIONS OF THE AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee is regulated by the 18th<br />

additional regulation of the Securities Market Act (introduced by<br />

article 47 of Law 44/2002) and articles 18 of the corporate bylaws<br />

and 14 of the Board’s Regulations, which are as follows<br />

Article 18 of the by-laws<br />

The Board will appoint from among its members its Chairman and<br />

one or more Vice-Chairmen, determining, if appropriate, the order<br />

of preference. If the Chairman is not available, the Board will be<br />

chaired by one of the Vice-Chairmen, on the basis of the order of<br />

preference determined, and, if none of them are available, by the<br />

oldest director.<br />

It can also appoint one or more Chief Executive Officers, and an<br />

Executive Committee and as many Committees or Commissions as<br />

are deemed necessary or convenient for the Company’s smooth<br />

running.<br />

If the Board makes use of the power conferred in the previous<br />

paragraph, it will specify the responsibilities of the Chief Executive<br />

Officers and the Committees and Commissions designated.<br />

The Board will appoint a Secretary and a deputy Secretary who<br />

does not have to be a director but can be. If the Secretary or the<br />

deputy Secretary meets the legally required conditions they can<br />

also be the Board’s Legal Advisor. If the Secretary is not available<br />

the deputy Secretary will exercise the functions and if he is not<br />

available then the Board will appoint a director to do this from<br />

among those attending the meeting. Unless there is a Board<br />

decision, the Secretary will also be the Secretary of the<br />

Committees set up in the Board’s sphere.<br />

The Chairman, Vice-chairmen and, if appropriate, the Secretary<br />

and/or deputy Secretary of the Board who are re-elected members<br />

of the Board by agreement of the Shareholders’ Meeting will<br />

continue to hold the posts they previously had in the sphere of the<br />

Board without the need for new election and without detriment to<br />

the power of revoking those posts which corresponds to the<br />

Board. This rule will not apply to the Chief Executive Officers or to<br />

members of the Executive Committees.<br />

The Board will always appoint an Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee.<br />

This Committee will consist of a minimum of three and a maximum<br />

of five members, all of them non-executive directors. The minimum<br />

powers of the committee are as follows:<br />

a) To report, through its Chairman or Secretary, to the<br />

Shareholders’ Meeting on any matters raised thereat by the<br />

shareholders on which the committee has authority.<br />

b) To Propose to the Board for submission to the Shareholders’<br />

Meeting the appointment of an external auditor.<br />

c) To supervise the internal auditing services.


d) To be familiar with the financial reporting process and the<br />

Bank’s internal control systems.<br />

e) To take charge of the relations with the external auditors in<br />

order to receive information on any issues which might<br />

jeopardise the independence of the auditors and any other<br />

matters related to the process of auditing, as well as other<br />

communications envisaged in the legislation on auditing and<br />

in the technical rules of auditing.<br />

f) To examine compliance with the Group’s Code of Conduct<br />

relating to the securities markets, with the anti-money<br />

laundering manuals and procedures and, in general, the Bank’s<br />

rules of governance, and to make the required proposals for<br />

their improvement. In particular, the committee must receive<br />

information and, if appropriate, issue reports on disciplinary<br />

measures for members of senior management.<br />

The Board will appoint the Chairman of the Audit and Compliance<br />

Committee and he or she will be replaced every four years. The<br />

outgoing Chairman can be re-elected a year after departing the<br />

post.<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee will meet, at least, four<br />

times a year and as many times as deemed necessary by its<br />

Chairman or as required by agreement of the committee or at the<br />

request of at least two of its members. All members of the<br />

management team or employees are obliged to attend its meetings,<br />

if so required, and collaborate with it and provide access to the<br />

information they have. The auditing firm can also be required to<br />

attend. One of its meetings will be used to evaluate the efficiency<br />

and compliance with the rules and procedures of governance and<br />

prepare the information that the Board has to approve and include<br />

within its annual public documentation.<br />

The Audit and Compliance committee, via its Chairman, will inform<br />

the Board at least twice a year.<br />

The Board’s Regulations will develop and complement the previous<br />

rules. As regards everything not envisaged in laws, the corporate<br />

by-laws and the Board’s regulations, the Board’s functioning will be<br />

governed by the Board’s rules to the extent they are compatible<br />

with the nature of the committee and with the independence of its<br />

activities.<br />

Article 14.- The Board’s Regulations on the Audit and<br />

Compliance Committee<br />

Article 14. The Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

1. The Audit and Compliance Committee consists of a minimum of<br />

three and a maximum of five members, all of them non-executive<br />

directors. They are appointed by the Board, bearing in mind,<br />

particularly for the Chairman, their knowledge and experience in<br />

accounting, auditing or risk management<br />

The Committee’s Chairman must be independent, and will be<br />

replaced every four years. The outgoing Chairman can be reelected<br />

one year after departing the post.<br />

2. The Committee’s functions are as follows<br />

a) To report, through its Chairman or Secretary, at the Annual<br />

General Meeting, to whom approval of the annual financial<br />

statements is submitted, on any matters raised thereat by<br />

the shareholders on whom the committee has authority. The<br />

Committee is responsible for knowing and, where<br />

appropriate, responding to initiatives, suggestions or<br />

complaints raised by shareholders on its sphere of functions,<br />

and those submitted by the Bank’s Secretary General.<br />

b) To propose to the Board for submission to the<br />

Shareholders’ Meeting the appointment of the auditors, the<br />

terms of their engagement, the scope of their services and,<br />

if appropriate, their revocation or non-renewal.<br />

c) To review the Bank’s financial statements and the Group’s<br />

consolidated financial statements, vouch for compliance with<br />

legal requirements and correct application of generally<br />

accepted accounting principles, as well as report on<br />

proposed changes to these principles and criteria suggested<br />

by management.<br />

d) To supervise the internal auditing services. They must<br />

present every year to the Committee their work plan and<br />

inform it directly of events during its development,<br />

submitting a report at the end of the year. In order to make<br />

this supervision possible, the Bank’s Internal Auditing<br />

services will tend to the Committee’s information<br />

requirements.<br />

e) To be familiar with and supervise the drawing up and the<br />

integrity of the Bank’s financial information and, where<br />

appropriate, the Group’s, reviewing compliance with the<br />

regulatory requirements, the appropriate delimiting of the<br />

perimeter of consolidation and correct application of the<br />

accounting criteria.<br />

f) To serve as communication channel between the Board of<br />

Directors and the auditing firm, and assess the findings of<br />

each audit and the replies of the management team to the<br />

firm’s recommendations and mediate in cases of<br />

discrepancies between it and the Board concerning the<br />

applicable principles and criteria when drawing up financial<br />

statements.<br />

g) To monitor fulfilment of the auditing contract, ensuring that<br />

the opinion on the annual financial statements and the main<br />

contents of the auditing report are clearly and precisely<br />

written.<br />

h) Keep watch over the auditing firm’s independence, paying<br />

attention to those circumstances or issues that could put it<br />

at risk and to anything else related to the auditing process,<br />

as well as receive information and maintain with the auditor<br />

the communications envisaged in the legislation on auditing<br />

and on the technical rules of auditing. And, specifically:<br />

79


80<br />

i. require information on the percentage that the fees<br />

charged for all concepts represent against the total<br />

worldwide fees of the auditing firm and on the number of<br />

years that the partner responsible for the auditing team<br />

providing service to the Bank has spent with it, as well as<br />

warn the firm of the limit referred to in article 39 of these<br />

regulations.<br />

ii If the auditing firm quits, examine the reasons for this.<br />

iii. Ensure that the change in the auditing firm is<br />

communicated as a relevant fact and, where appropriate,<br />

disseminate a communiqué on the existence of<br />

disagreements with the outgoing firm in the event that<br />

this is the case.<br />

i) To review, before dissemination, the regular financial<br />

information which, as a listed company, the Bank must make<br />

public and ensure it is prepared in accordance with the same<br />

principles and practices as those used for the annual<br />

financial statements, for which purpose the auditing firm can<br />

revise the information to a limited extent.<br />

j) To supervise compliance with the Group’s Code of Conduct<br />

in the securities markets, with the anti-money laundering<br />

manuals and procedures and, in general, the Bank’s rules of<br />

governance, and make the required proposals for their<br />

improvement. In particular, the Committee must receive<br />

information and, if appropriate, issue reports on disciplinary<br />

measures for members of senior management. All of this<br />

without detriment to the rules approved for prevention of<br />

money laundering.<br />

k) To be familiar with the reports and inspection activities of<br />

the supervision and control authorities and review<br />

compliance with the actions and measures that emanate<br />

from them.<br />

l) To adopt the necessary measures to: (1) receive, treat and<br />

keep the complaints received by the Bank on issues related<br />

to the process of generating financial information, audits and<br />

internal controls; and (ii) make it possible for employees,<br />

confidentially and, if considered appropriate, anonymously<br />

to report irregularities of potential significance, especially<br />

financial and accounting ones, detected within the sphere of<br />

the Bank.<br />

m) To inform on the proposed changes to these regulations<br />

before their approval by the Board.<br />

n) To supervise the internal control and management risk<br />

systems so that the main risks are identified, managed and<br />

known in sufficient time.<br />

ñ) To report on, before approval by the Board or the Executive<br />

Committee, the creation or acquisition of participations in<br />

special purpose entities or domiciled in tax havens.<br />

o) To report on linked operations submitted for the Board’s<br />

approval.<br />

p) To report on the process of assessing its functioning.<br />

3. The internal auditing services are within the Board’s sphere and<br />

report to it. Without detriment to this, the Committee will vouch<br />

for the independence and effectiveness of internal auditing,<br />

reporting on the proposals regarding the election, appointment,<br />

re-election and dismissal of the person in charge of the Bank’s<br />

internal auditing service. The Committee will receive regular<br />

information on the activities of internal auditing and will verify<br />

that senior management takes into account the conclusions and<br />

recommendations of its reports.<br />

4. The Committee will meet, at least, four times a year and as many<br />

times as called by its Chairman or as required by agreement of<br />

the committee or at the request of at least two of its members.<br />

All members of the management team or employees are obliged<br />

to attend its meetings, if so required, and collaborate with it and<br />

provide access to the information they have. The auditing firm<br />

can also be required to attend. One of its meetings will be used<br />

to evaluate the efficiency and compliance with the rules and<br />

procedures of governance and prepare the information that the<br />

Board has to approve and include within its annual public<br />

documentation.<br />

5. The Committee can obtain external advice under the terms of<br />

article 23 of the Regulations.<br />

6. The Committee, via its Chairman, will inform the Board of its<br />

activity at the meetings called for this purpose, or in the first<br />

one afterwards when the Committee’s Chairman considers it<br />

necessary. The minutes of the meetings are available to all<br />

members of the Board who request them.


Internal Control Model<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s Internal Control Model is<br />

continuously evolving and adapting to the most<br />

demanding international regulatory<br />

requirements, and it provides customers and<br />

shareholders with maximum security.<br />

It meets international guidelines<br />

This demanding framework guarantees compliance with the guidelines of the Committee Of<br />

Sponsoring Organizations (COSO) of the Treadway Commission within the Enterprise Risk<br />

Management Integrated Framework (1)<br />

Structure of the model<br />

The main processes and sub processes related to the generation of financial information in each of our activities are identified and<br />

documented. Other relevant procedures developed by the support areas have also been documented.<br />

The risks inherent in these processes and sub processes that could generate material errors are identified, in accordance with the Basel<br />

classification.<br />

Lastly, the necessary controls to ease risks are defined in the most effective way.<br />

All this information is available on line via an IT tool that provides management and treatment (maintenance, supervision, updating,<br />

consulting, etc.) in real time.<br />

Internal processes of supervision and contrasting<br />

In order to ensure the quality, consistency and updating of the model, the bank has a specialised unit to care for and supervise it. Senior<br />

management and the Board of Directors are informed of the results.<br />

There are also certifications and twice yearly assessments of the staff, as well as validations by Internal Auditing of the model’s<br />

functioning.<br />

Certification of the auditing firm<br />

The model was examined by the auditing firm in 2008, in compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley Law whose purpose is to reduce the risk<br />

that published information is insecure, incomplete or mistaken. It imposes obligations on all those involved in the process of producing,<br />

certifying and analysing financial information.<br />

In the opinion of the auditing firm, “<strong>Banesto</strong> maintains effective internal controls on the generation of financial information contained in<br />

the consolidated annual financial statements drawn up in accordance with the international regulations of financial information adopted<br />

by the European Union”<br />

(1) International committee created in 1985 to establish a methodology for identifying risk factors that could give rise to the presentation of false or fraudulent financial<br />

information, as well as issue recommendations that guarantee the maximum transparency.<br />

81


82<br />

Auditor’s Report and<br />

Consolidated financial<br />

statement<br />

Auditor’s Report and Consolidated<br />

financial statement 83<br />

Consolidated financial statement 85<br />

Management report<br />

Corporate Governance report<br />

178<br />

according to the CNMV model 185


84<br />

Responsibility for the information<br />

The Board of Directors of Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. expressly<br />

undertakes the general function of supervision of the Group's<br />

operations and discharges its duties in this respect directly and on<br />

a non-delegation basis.<br />

Its Audit and Compliance Committee is entrusted, inter alia, with<br />

the following duties in the areas of information, accounting control<br />

and assessment of the compliance system:<br />

1. To report, through its Chairman or Secretary, to the Annual<br />

General Meeting on any matters raised thereat by the<br />

shareholders on which the Committee has authority.<br />

2. To propose the appointment of the auditors, the terms of<br />

their engagement, the scope of their services and, if<br />

appropriate, their revocation or non-renewal.<br />

3. To review the Bank's financial statements and the Group's<br />

consolidated financial statements, monitoring compliance with<br />

legal requirements and the proper application of generally<br />

accepted accounting principles.<br />

4. To serve as a communication channel between the Board of<br />

Directors and the auditors, and assess the findings of each<br />

audit and the replies of the management team to the auditors'<br />

recommendations.<br />

5. To be familiar with the financial reporting process and the<br />

internal control systems.<br />

6. To monitor any situations which might jeopardise the<br />

independence of the auditors and, specifically, to check the<br />

percentage that the fees paid to them in all connections<br />

represents with respect to the auditors' total revenues. The<br />

fees paid must be disclosed publicly<br />

7. To review, before public disclosure, the periodic financial<br />

information furnished by the Bank and Group to the markets<br />

and to their supervisory bodies, making sure that this<br />

information is prepared in accordance with the same principles<br />

and practices as those used for the financial statements.<br />

8. To examine compliance with the Group's Code of Conduct<br />

relating to the securities markets, with the anti-money<br />

laundering manuals and procedures and, in general, with the<br />

Bank's rules of governance, and to make the required<br />

proposals for improvement.<br />

For these purposes, the Audit and Compliance Committee meets<br />

whenever it deems it appropriate with the persons in charge of the<br />

Group's business areas and with those in charge of the support<br />

and risk management areas, in particular with the Controller and<br />

with the Group's Internal Audit Division, and with the external<br />

auditors to analyse their reports and recommendations.<br />

Our external auditors, Deloitte, examine each year the financial<br />

statements of substantially all the companies composing the<br />

Group to issue their professional opinion thereon. The external<br />

auditors are regularly informed of our controls and procedures;<br />

they define and perform their audit tests with full freedom and<br />

have free access to the Bank's Chairwoman, Deputy Chairman and<br />

CEO, to set forth their conclusions and discuss their<br />

recommendations for improving the efficiency of the internal<br />

control systems.<br />

The Audit and Compliance Committee meets periodically with the<br />

external auditors to ensure the effectiveness of their audit and to<br />

analyse any situations which might jeopardise their independence.<br />

In this connection, following the most advanced practices in<br />

shareholder information transparency (as described in Note 42 to<br />

the consolidated financial statements), it is hereby reported that in<br />

2008 the fees paid for the financial audits performed by the<br />

Deloitte worldwide organisation amounted to EUR 1,524<br />

thousand, those paid for other reports required by the supervisory<br />

bodies amounted to EUR 254 thousand and those paid for other<br />

work amounted to EUR 967 thousand.<br />

To facilitate analysis of the situations which might jeopardise the<br />

independence of our auditors from a quantitative and qualitative<br />

standpoint, we set forth below significant information relating to<br />

the criteria established by the O'Malley Panel and in other relevant<br />

international documents for the purpose of evaluating the<br />

effectiveness of the external audit function:<br />

1. In 2008 the ratio of the amount billed by our main auditor<br />

for non-attest work to the fees for financial audits and for<br />

other reports required by the supervisory bodies was<br />

54.41%.<br />

The services commissioned from our auditors meet the<br />

independence requirements stipulated by Law 44/2002, of<br />

22 November, on Financial System Reform Measures and by<br />

the Regulations governing the Bank's Board of Directors.<br />

2. The relative importance of the fees generated by a given<br />

customer with respect to the total fees of the audit firm:<br />

The Group has adopted the policy of not engaging audit<br />

firms if the estimated fees for all services exceed 2.0% of their<br />

total revenues.<br />

In the case of Deloitte and the Deloitte worldwide<br />

organisation, this ratio was 0.69% and 0.015% of their total<br />

revenues.<br />

Based on the foregoing, the Audit and Compliance Committee<br />

considers that there are no objective reasons to question the<br />

independence of our auditors.


Consolidated Financial<br />

Statement<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

and Companies composing the<br />

Banco Español de Crédito Group<br />

(<strong>Banesto</strong> Group)<br />

Consolidated Financial Statements and Directors' Report for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2008, together with Auditors' Report<br />

85


86<br />

Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group<br />

Consolidated balance sheets At 31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Assets<br />

Note 2008 2007(*)<br />

CASH AND BALANCES WITH CENTRAL BANKS 1,688,153 1,412,871<br />

FINANCIAL ASSETS HELD FOR TRADING: 5,083,815 4,605,807<br />

Debt instruments 7 402,154 781,542<br />

Equity instruments 8 472,996 1,636,069<br />

Trading derivatives<br />

OTHER FINANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE<br />

9 4,208,665 2,188,196<br />

THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS 2,191,162 1,492,762<br />

Loans and advances to credit institutions 6 1,793,839 905,291<br />

Loans and advances to customers - 504<br />

Debt instruments 7 253,887 285,474<br />

Equity instruments 8 143,436 301,493<br />

AVAILABLE-FOR-SALE FINANCIAL ASSETS: 6,742,582 5,969,913<br />

Debt instruments 7 6,620,409 5,605,166<br />

Equity instruments 8 122,173 364,747<br />

LOANS AND RECEIVABLES: 98,209,587 94,711,217<br />

Loans and advances to credit institutions 6 19,700,685 19,118,526<br />

Loans and advances to customers 10 77,772,663 75,066,531<br />

Debt instruments 7 736,239 526,160<br />

HELD-TO-MATURITY INVESTMENTS - -<br />

CHANGES IN THE FAIR VALUE OF HEDGED ITEMS IN PORTFOLIO HEDGES OF INTEREST RATE RISK - -<br />

HEDGING DERIVATIVES 11 1,194,849 537,352<br />

NON-CURRENT ASSETS HELD FOR SALE 14 1,556,174 102,730<br />

INVESTMENTS 12 16,722 16,258<br />

INSURANCE CONTRACTS LINKED TO PENSIONS 22 248,025 257,633<br />

REINSURANCE ASSETS 13 199,411 121,162<br />

TANGIBLE ASSETS: 14 1,225,546 1,193,896<br />

Property, plant and equipment<br />

Property, plant and equipment for own use 1,154,954 1,128,088<br />

Investment property 70,592 65,808<br />

INTANGIBLE ASSETS: 15 58,524 51,828<br />

Goodwill - 3,924<br />

Other intangible assets 58,524 47,904<br />

TAX ASSETS: 23 1,099,929 1,102,996<br />

Current 205,235 62,861<br />

Deferred 894,694 1,040,135<br />

OTHER ASSETS: 16 964,494 369,566<br />

Inventories 566,876 206,755<br />

Other 397,618 162,811<br />

TOTAL ASSETS 120,478,973 111,945,991<br />

Memorandum items:<br />

Contingent liabilities 30 10,896,866 11,994,698<br />

Contingent commitments 30 16,218,347 16,300,288<br />

(*) Presented for comparison purposes only.<br />

The accompanying Notes 1 to 49 and Appendixes I to V are an integral part of the consolidated balance sheet at 31 December 2008.


Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group<br />

Consolidated balance sheets At 31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Liabilities and equity<br />

LIABILITIES<br />

Note 2008 2007(*)<br />

FINANCIAL LIABILITIES HELD FOR TRADING: 3,950,718 2,628,898<br />

Trading derivatives 9 3,913,573 2,532,019<br />

Short positions<br />

OTHER FINANCIAL LIABILITIES AT FAIR VALUE<br />

37,145 96,879<br />

THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS - -<br />

FINANCIAL LIABILITIES AT AMORTISED COST: 103,445,656 98,432,494<br />

Deposits from central banks 17 1,952,343 1,955,660<br />

Deposits from credit institutions 17 10,454,275 10,341,441<br />

Customer deposits 18 57,589,628 52,747,448<br />

Marketable debt securities 19 28,315,103 28,737,082<br />

Subordinated liabilities 20 2,236,835 2,124,980<br />

Other financial liabilities 21 2,897,472 2,525,883<br />

CHANGES IN THE FAIR VALUE OF HEDGED ITEMS IN PORTFOLIO HEDGES OF INTEREST RATE RISK 31 440,135 (516,725)<br />

HEDGING DERIVATIVES 11 577,091 1,090,616<br />

LIABILITIES ASSOCIATED WITH NON-CURRENT ASSETS HELD FOR SALE - -<br />

LIABILITIES UNDER INSURANCE CONTRACTS 13 3,435,629 2,226,588<br />

PROVISIONS: 22 2,532,290 2,614,307<br />

Provisions for pensions and similar obligations 2,215,208 2,301,205<br />

Provisions for contingent liabilities and commitments 102,092 115,923<br />

Other provisions 214,990 197,179<br />

TAX LIABILITIES: 23 394,822 76,305<br />

Current 326,095 37,856<br />

Deferred 68,727 38,449<br />

OTHER LIABILITIES 16 548,442 713,312<br />

TOTAL LIABILITIES 115,324,783 107,265,795<br />

SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY: 26 5,069,766 4,747,892<br />

Capital<br />

Registered 27 543,036 548,521<br />

Reserves 28 4,055,165 3,769,902<br />

Accumulated reserves 4,052,869 3,768,093<br />

Reserves of entities accounted for using the equity method 2,296 1,809<br />

Other equity instruments 29 - 1,778<br />

Other - 1,778<br />

Treasury shares 29 (36,074) (86,917)<br />

Profit for the year attributable to the Parent 779,844 764,567<br />

Dividends and remuneration (272,205) (249,959)<br />

VALUATION ADJUSTMENTS: 25 41,541 (114,424)<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets (48,614) (13,505)<br />

Cash flow hedges 90,115 (100,868)<br />

Exchange differences 40 (51)<br />

MINORITY INTERESTS:: 24 42,883 46,728<br />

Other 42,883 46,728<br />

TOTAL EQUITY 5,154,190 4,680,196<br />

TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY 120,478,973 111,945,991<br />

(*) Presented for comparison purposes only.<br />

The accompanying Notes 1 to 49 and Appendixes I to V are an integral part of the consolidated balance sheet at 31 December 2008<br />

87


88<br />

Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group<br />

Consolidated income statements For the years ended<br />

31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Income/(Expenses)<br />

Note 2008 2007(*)<br />

INTEREST AND SIMILAR INCOME 33 5,471,597 4,638,611<br />

INTEREST EXPENSE AND SIMILAR CHARGES 34 (3,756,531) (3,156,765)<br />

RETURN ON EQUITY REFUNDABLE ON DEMAND - -<br />

NET INTEREST INCOME 1,715,066 1,481,846<br />

INCOME FROM EQUITY INSTRUMENTS 35 59,237 55,814<br />

SHARE OF RESULTS OF ENTITIES ACCOUNTED FOR USING THE EQUITY METHOD 36 1,874 1,707<br />

FEE AND COMMISSION INCOME 37 705,699 741,965<br />

FEE AND COMMISSION EXPENSE 38 (144,025) (161,314)<br />

GAINS/LOSSES ON FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES (net) 39 109,400 84,924<br />

Held for trading 80,848 89,036<br />

Financial instruments not measured at fair value<br />

through profit or loss 29,260 (6,051)<br />

Other (708) 1,939<br />

EXCHANGE DIFFERENCES (net) 41,867 34,866<br />

OTHER OPERATING INCOME 40 2,189,420 1,497,959<br />

Income from insurance and reinsurance contracts issued 2,000,274 1,284,950<br />

Sales and income from the provision of non-financial services 75,401 162,758<br />

Other 113,745 50,251<br />

OTHER OPERATING EXPENSES 40 (2,199,840) (1,420,563)<br />

Expenses of insurance and reinsurance contracts (2,027,516) (1,259,195)<br />

Changes in inventories (18,107) (86,686)<br />

Other (154,217) (74,682)<br />

GROSS INCOME 2,478,698 2,317,204<br />

ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES (921,049) (930,693)<br />

Personnel expenses 41 (673,383) (664,598)<br />

Other general administrative expenses 42 (247,666) (266,095)<br />

DEPRECIATION AND AMORTISATION 14, 15 (102,317) (99,542)<br />

PROVISIONS (net) 2-v, 22 (16,271) 16,671<br />

IMPAIRMENT LOSSES ON FINANCIAL ASSETS (net) (321,922) (233,699)<br />

Loans and receivables<br />

Other financial instruments not measured at fair value<br />

10 (299,799) (228,974)<br />

through profit or loss 8 (22,123) (4,725)<br />

PROFIT FROM OPERATIONS 1,117,139 1,069,941<br />

IMPAIRMENT LOSSES ON OTHER ASSETS (net) (6,882) 1,951<br />

Goodwill and other intangible assets 15 4 53<br />

Other assets<br />

GAINS/(LOSSES) ON DISPOSAL OF ASSETS NOT CLASSIFIED<br />

14 (6,886) 1,898<br />

AS NON-CURRENT ASSETS HELD FOR SALE 43 (455) 13,027<br />

NEGATIVE GOODWILL IN BUSINESS COMBINATIONS<br />

GAINS/(LOSSES) ON NON-CURRENT ASSETS HELD FOR SALE<br />

- -<br />

NOT CLASSIFIED AS DISCONTINUED OPERATIONS 14 (28,515) 14,191<br />

PROFIT BEFORE TAX 1,081,287 1,099,110<br />

IMPUESTO SOBRE BENEFICIOS 23 (306,278) (335,654)<br />

PROFIT FOR THE YEAR FROM CONTINUING OPERATIONS 775,009 763,456<br />

PROFIT FROM DISCONTINUED OPERATIONS (net) - -<br />

CONSOLIDATED PROFIT FOR THE YEAR 775,009 763,456<br />

PROFIT ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE PARENT 779,844 764,567<br />

PROFIT ATTRIBUTABLE TO MINORITY INTERESTS (4,835) (1,111)<br />

EARNINGS PER SHARE:<br />

Basic earnings per share (euros 4 1,14 1,10<br />

Diluted earnings per share (euros) 4 1,14 1,10<br />

(*) Presented for comparison purposes only.<br />

The accompanying Notes 1 to 49 and Appendixes I to V are an integral part of the consolidated income statement for 2008.


Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group Consolidated statements of recognised income and expense for the<br />

years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007(*)<br />

A) CONSOLIDATED PROFIT FOR THE YEAR 775,009 763,456<br />

B) OTHER RECOGNISED INCOME AND EXPENSE 155,965 (118,101)<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets (28,659) (84,101)<br />

Revaluation gains/(losses) 11,016 (64,604)<br />

Amounts transferred to income statement (39,675) (19,497)<br />

Cash flow hedges 264,609 (79,118)<br />

Revaluation gains/(losses) 245,420 (71,351)<br />

Amounts transferred to income statement 19,189 (7,767)<br />

Hedges of net investments in foreign operations - -<br />

Exchange differences 91 (43)<br />

Revaluation gains/(losses) 91 (43)<br />

Non-current assets held for sale - -<br />

Actuarial gains/(losses) on pension plans - -<br />

Entities accounted for using the equity method (4,553) (3,207)<br />

Revaluation gains/(losses) (4,694) (3,207)<br />

Amounts transferred to income statement 141 -<br />

Other recognised income and expense - -<br />

Income tax (75,523) 48,368<br />

TOTAL RECOGNISED INCOME AND EXPENSE (A + B) 930,974 645,355<br />

C 1) Attributable to the Parent 935,809 646,466<br />

C 2) Attributable to minority interests (4,835) (1,111)<br />

(*) Presented for comparison purposes only.<br />

The accompanying Notes 1 to 49 and Appendixes I to V are an integral part of the consolidated statement of recognised income and expense for 2008.<br />

89


90<br />

Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group<br />

Consolidated statements of changes in equity<br />

Consolidated statements of total changes in equity for the years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

EQUITY ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE PARENT<br />

SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY<br />

Reserves of<br />

Entities<br />

Accounted Profit<br />

for Using Other Less: Attributable Less: Total<br />

Share Accumulated the Equity Equity Treasury to the Dividends and Shareholders’ Valuation Minority<br />

Capital Premium Reserves Method Instruments Shares Parent Remuneration Equity Adjustments Total Interests Equity<br />

Balance at 01/01/08 548,521 - 3,768,093 1,809 1,778 (86,917) 764,567 (249,959) 4,747,892 (114,424) 4,633,468 46,728 4,680,196<br />

Adjustments due to changes in accounting policy - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

Adjustments made to correct errors - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

Adjusted beginning balance 548,521 - 3,768,093 1,809 1,778 (86,917) 764,567 (249,959) 4,747,892 (114,424) 4,633,468 46,728 4,680,196<br />

Total recognised income/(expense) - - - - - - 779,844 - 779,844 155,965 935,809 (4,835) 930,974<br />

Other changes in equity<br />

Capital reductions (5,485) - (78,321) - - - - - (83,806) - (83,806) - (83,806)<br />

Distribution of dividends - - - - - - - (411,071) (411,071) - (411,071) - (411,071)<br />

Transactions involving own<br />

equity instruments (net) (Note 29) - - (12,088) - - 50,843 - - 38,900 - 38,900 - 38,900<br />

Transfers between equity items - - 375,255 487 - - (764,567) 388,825 - - - - -<br />

Equity-instrument-based payments (Note 29) - - - - (1,778) - - - (1,778) - (1,778) - (1,778)<br />

Other increases/(decreases) in equity - - (215) - - - - - (215) - (215) 990 775<br />

Balance at 31/12/08 543,036 - 4,052,869 2,296 - (36,074) 779,844 (272,205) 5,069,766 41,541 5,111,307 42,883 5,154,190


Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Group<br />

Consolidated statements of changes in equity (cont)<br />

Consolidated statements of total changes in equity for the years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

EQUITY ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE PARENT (*)<br />

SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY<br />

Reserves/<br />

(Losses)<br />

of Entities<br />

Accounted for<br />

Using the Other Less: Profit Less: Total<br />

Share Accumulated Equity Equity Treasury Attributable Dividends and Shareholders’ Valuation Minority Total<br />

Capital Premium Reserves Method Instruments Shares to the Parent Remuneration Equity Adjustments Total Interests Equity<br />

Balance at 01/01/07 548,521 - 2,633,138 (1,055) - (4,554) 1,451,264 (312,449) 4,314,865 3,677 4,318,542 53,700 4,372,242<br />

Adjustments due to changes in accounting policy - - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

Adjustments made to correct errors - - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

Adjusted beginning balance 548,521 - 2,633,138 (1,055) - (4,554) 1,451,264 (312,449) 4,314,865 3,677 4,318,542 53,700 4,372,242<br />

Total recognised income/(expense) - - - - - - 764,567 - 764,567 (118,101) 646,466 (1,111) 645,355<br />

Other changes in equity<br />

Distribution of dividends - - - - - - - (249,959) (249,959) - (249,959) (5,156) (255,115)<br />

Transactions involving own equity instruments (net) - - (996) - - (82,363) - - - - (83,359) - (83,359)<br />

Transfers between equity items - - 1,135,951 2,864 - - (1,451,264) 312,449 - - - - -<br />

Increases/(Decreases) due to business combinations - - - - - - - - - - - (644) (644)<br />

Equity-instrument-based payments - - - - 1,778 - - - - - 1,778 - 1,778<br />

Other increases/(decreases) in equity - - - - - - - - - - - (61) (61)<br />

Balance at 31/12/07 548,521 - 3,768,093 1,809 1,778 (86,917) 764,567 (249,959) 4,747,892 (114,424) 4,633,468 46,728 4,680,196<br />

(*) Presented for comparison purposes only.<br />

The accompanying Notes 1 to 49 and Appendixes I to V are an integral part of the consolidated statement of total changes in equity for 2008.<br />

91


92<br />

Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group<br />

Consolidated cash flow statements<br />

For the years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007(*)<br />

1. CASH FLOWS FROM OPERATING ACTIVITIES 982,724 (2,197,170)<br />

Profit for the year attributable to the Parent 775,009 763,456<br />

Adjustments made to obtain the cash flows from operating activities:<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 102,317 99,542<br />

Other adjustments 2,027,167 1,240,540<br />

Net increase/decrease in operating assets:<br />

Financial assets held for trading- 478,008 (635,874)<br />

Debt instruments (379,388) (553,235)<br />

Other equity instrumentsl (1,163,073) 60,376<br />

Trading derivatives 2,020,469 (143,015)<br />

Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss- 698,400 556,984<br />

Loans and advances to credit institutions 888,548 703,480<br />

Loans and advances to customers (504) 504<br />

Debt instruments (31,587) 18,384<br />

Other equity instruments (158,057) (165,384)<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets- 828,806 (275,234)<br />

Debt instruments 1,071,380 (259,691)<br />

Other equity instruments (242,574) (15,543)<br />

Loans and receivables- 3,096,279 9,244,260<br />

Loans and advances to credit institutions (119,731) (4,604,331)<br />

Loans and advances to customers 3,005,931 13,322,431<br />

Debt instruments 210,079 526,160<br />

Other operating assets 2,148,724 258,318<br />

Net increase/decrease in operating liabilities:<br />

Financial liabilities held for trading- 1,321,820 (59,579)<br />

Trading derivatives 1,381,554 (59,398)<br />

Short positions (59,734) (181)<br />

Financial liabilities at amortised cost- 4,706,884 4,805,089<br />

Deposits from credit institutions 112,834 (7,750,674)<br />

Deposits from central banks (3,317) 805,312<br />

Customer deposits 4,842,180 8,312,644<br />

Marketable debt securities (421,979) 4,360,167<br />

Other financial liabilities 177,166 (922,360)<br />

Other operating liabilities (564,422) 977,960<br />

Collections/Payments of income tax (135,834) (875,724)<br />

(*) Presented for comparison purposes only.<br />

The accompanying Notes 1 to 49 and Appendixes I to V are an integral part of the consolidated cash flow statement for 2008.


Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> group<br />

Consolidated cash flow statements<br />

For the years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007 (notes 1 to 4)<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007(*)<br />

2. CASH FLOWS FROM INVESTING ACTIVITIES (154,753) 3,514,682<br />

Payments<br />

Tangible assets (276,709) (487,689)<br />

Intangible assets (48,708) -<br />

Investments - (18)<br />

Collections<br />

Tangible assets 168,562 188,382<br />

Intangible assets 2,102 -<br />

Investments - 1,705<br />

Held-to-maturity investments - 3,812,302<br />

3. CASH FLOWS FROM FINANCING ACTIVITIES (371,944) (200,955)<br />

Payments<br />

Dividends (403,656) (249,959)<br />

Subordinated liabilities (500,000) (105,817)<br />

Redemption of own equity instruments (5,485) -<br />

Acquisition of own equity instruments - (82,363)<br />

Other payments related to financing activities (75,648) (13,421)<br />

Collections<br />

Subordinated liabilities 611,855 -<br />

Other collections related to financing activities 990 250,605<br />

4. EFFECTS OF CHANGES IN EXCHANGE RATES 10,276 (26,117)<br />

5. NET INCREASE/DECREASE IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS (1+2+3+4) 466,303 1,090,440<br />

6. CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT BEGINNING OF YEAR 1,923,740 833,300<br />

7. CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT END OF YEAR 2,390,043 1,923,740<br />

MEMORANDUM ITEMS<br />

COMPONENTS OF CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT END OF YEAR<br />

Cash 263,073 258,489<br />

Cash equivalents at central banks 1,425,080 1,154,382<br />

Other financial assets 701,890 510,869<br />

Less: Bank overdrafts refundable on demand - -<br />

TOTAL CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT END OF YEAR 2,390,043 1,923,740<br />

(*) Presented for comparison purposes only.<br />

The accompanying Notes 1 to 49 and Appendixes I to V are an integral part of the consolidated cash flow statement for 2008.<br />

93


94<br />

Translation of consolidated financial statements originally issued in Spanish and prepared in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the European Union (see Notes 1 and 49).<br />

In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Group<br />

Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements for the year ended 31<br />

December 2008


1. Introduction, basis of presentation of<br />

the consolidated financial statements,<br />

estimates made, basis of consolidation<br />

and other information<br />

a) Introduction<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. (“the Bank” or “<strong>Banesto</strong>”) is a<br />

private-law entity subject to the rules and regulations applicable to<br />

banks operating in Spain. The bylaws and other public information<br />

on the Bank can be consulted on the website of the Group<br />

(www.banesto.es) and at its registered office at Gran Vía de<br />

Hortaleza, 3, Madrid.<br />

In addition to the operations carried on directly by it, the Bank is<br />

the head of a group of subsidiaries that engage in various business<br />

activities and which compose, together with it, the Banco Español<br />

de Crédito Group (“the Group” or “the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group”).<br />

Therefore, the Bank is obliged to prepare, in addition to its own<br />

individual financial statements, the Group's consolidated financial<br />

statements.<br />

b) Basis of presentation of the consolidated financial<br />

statements<br />

The consolidated financial statements for 2007 were prepared by<br />

the Bank's directors at the Board meeting on 22 January 2008 in<br />

accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards as<br />

adopted by the European Union and with Bank of Spain Circular<br />

4/2004, of 22 December, using the basis of consolidation,<br />

accounting policies and measurement bases set forth in Note 2 to<br />

the 2007 consolidated financial statements, which were approved<br />

by the shareholders at the Annual General Meeting held on 26<br />

February 2008.<br />

The Group’s consolidated financial statements for 2008 were<br />

prepared by the Bank's directors at the Board meeting on 20<br />

January 2009 in accordance with International Financial Reporting<br />

Standards as adopted by the European Union and with Bank of<br />

Spain Circular 4/2004, of 22 December, as amended by Bank of<br />

Spain Circular 6/2008, of 26 November, and, accordingly, they<br />

present fairly the Group's equity and financial position at 31<br />

December 2008, and the consolidated results of its operations,<br />

the changes in consolidated equity and the consolidated cash<br />

flows in the year then ended. These consolidated financial<br />

statements for 2008 have not yet been approved by the<br />

shareholders at the Annual General Meeting. However, the Bank's<br />

Board of Directors considers that the aforementioned financial<br />

statements will be approved without any changes.<br />

The consolidated balance sheet, consolidated income statement,<br />

consolidated statement of recognised income and expense,<br />

consolidated cash flow statement and consolidated statement of<br />

total changes in equity for 2008 and 2007 presented in these<br />

consolidated financial statements were prepared using the formats<br />

contained in the aforementioned Bank of Spain Circular 6/2008,<br />

of 26 November. These formats differ, only as regards the basis of<br />

presentation of certain items and margins, from those presented in<br />

the statutory consolidated financial statements for the year ended<br />

31 December 2007, and, accordingly, the comparative figures were<br />

reclassified for presentation purposes<br />

The main presentation differences between the two financial<br />

statement formats are as follows:<br />

1. Consolidated balance sheet: : the consolidated balance sheet<br />

format presented in these consolidated financial statements<br />

differs from the consolidated balance sheet format presented in<br />

the statutory consolidated financial statements for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2007, in the following respects<br />

a) “Other Assets”, on the asset side, groups together the line<br />

items “Prepayments and Accrued Income” and “Other<br />

Assets” which were included on the asset side of the<br />

consolidated balance sheet in the Group’s statutory<br />

consolidated financial statements for 2007, except for<br />

inventories, which are presented under “Other Assets –<br />

Inventories”.<br />

b) “Loans and Receivables” on the asset side no longer includes<br />

“Other Financial Assets”. The items which composed this<br />

heading are now included in “Loans and Advances to Credit<br />

Institutions” and “Loans and Advances to Customers” under<br />

“Loans and Receivables”, on the basis of the institutional<br />

sector to which they relate.<br />

c) The breakdown by nature of the assets included under “Non-<br />

Current Assets Held for Sale” is eliminated.<br />

d) “Other Liabilities” on the liability side groups together the<br />

line items “Accrued Expenses and Deferred Income” and<br />

“Other Liabilities” which were included on the liability side of<br />

the consolidated balance sheet in the statutory consolidated<br />

financial statements for 2007..<br />

e) Finally, it should be noted that the name of certain equity<br />

items has been changed, with no substantial changes in the<br />

content (e.g. “Profit Attributed to the Group” has changed to<br />

“Profit for the Year Attributable to the Parent”).<br />

2. Consolidated income statement: the consolidated income<br />

statement format presented in these consolidated financial<br />

statements differs from the consolidated income statement<br />

format presented in the statutory consolidated financial<br />

statements for the year ended 31 December 2007, in the<br />

following respects::<br />

a) A new margin is introduced, the so-called margen de interés<br />

(“Net Interest Income”), which is calculated as the difference<br />

between “Interest and Similar Income” and “Interest Expense<br />

and Similar Charges”. The former margen de intermediación<br />

(which was also translated as “Net Interest Income” and<br />

included “Income from Equity Instruments”) is eliminated.<br />

b) Income and expenses from the Group’s insurance activity are<br />

not longer grouped together as a separate item and are<br />

recognised, according to their nature, under the various<br />

consolidated income statement items, with the consequent<br />

effect on each margin and item in this statement.<br />

Specifically, insurance and reinsurance premium income and<br />

reinsurance income are included in “Income from Insurance<br />

and Reinsurance Contracts Issued” under “Other Operating<br />

Income” in the consolidated income statement; and the<br />

amount of claims paid and other insurance-related expenses,<br />

the reinsurance premiums paid to third parties and the net<br />

95


96<br />

provisions for insurance contract liabilities are included in<br />

“Expenses of Insurance and Reinsurance Contracts” under<br />

“Other Operating Expenses” in the consolidated income<br />

statement presented in these consolidated financial<br />

statements.<br />

c) The gains or losses on financial assets and liabilities<br />

measured at cost, at amortised cost or available for sale,<br />

other than changes in fair value hedges on these items, are<br />

now recognised in “Financial Instruments Not Measured at<br />

Fair Value through Profit or Loss” under “Gains/Losses on<br />

Financial Assets and Liabilities (Net)” in the consolidated<br />

income statement.<br />

d) A new margin entitled margen bruto (“Gross Income”) is<br />

presented, which is similar to the former margen ordinario<br />

(which was also translated as Gross Income), except,<br />

basically, for the fact that the new margin includes other<br />

operating income and other operating expenses, which were<br />

not previously included in gross income, and for the effect of<br />

including interest and financial charges from non-financial<br />

activities according to their nature. The former margen<br />

ordinario ("Gross Income”) is eliminated.<br />

e) “Sales and Income from the Provision of Non-Financial<br />

Services” and “Cost of Sales” are eliminated from the<br />

consolidated income statements and are recognised,<br />

basically, under “Other Operating Income – Sales and<br />

Income from the Provision of Non-Financial Services” and<br />

“Other Operating Expenses – Changes in Inventories”,<br />

respectively, in the consolidated income statement.<br />

f) “Personnel Expenses” and “Other General Administrative<br />

Expenses” are grouped together under ”Administrative<br />

Expenses”.<br />

g) The balance of “Impairment Losses (Net)” is split into two<br />

line items: “Impairment Losses on Financial Assets (Net)”,<br />

which includes net impairment losses on financial assets<br />

other than equity instruments classified as “Investments”;<br />

and “Impairment Losses on Other Assets (Net)”, which<br />

includes the net impairment losses on equity instruments<br />

classified as “Investments” and on other non-financial assets.<br />

h) “Finance Income from Non-Financial Activities” and “Finance<br />

Expenses of Non-Financial Activities” are eliminated and<br />

included basically in “Interest and Similar Income” and<br />

“Interest Expense and Similar Charges”, respectively, in the<br />

consolidated income statement.<br />

i) “Net Operating Income“ is eliminated and “Profit from<br />

Operations” is created. The difference between the two<br />

margins is basically that the latter includes the finance income<br />

and costs from the Group’s non-financial activities, the net<br />

charge to impairment losses on financial instruments and the<br />

net charge to provisions.<br />

j) The line items “Other Gains" and "Other Losses” are<br />

eliminated.<br />

Instead, three new line items are created: “Gains/Losses on<br />

Disposal of Assets not Classified as Non-Current Assets Held<br />

for Sale”, “Negative Goodwill in Business Combinations” and<br />

“Gains/Losses on Non-Current Assets Held for Sale not<br />

Classified as Discontinued Operations”, which include mainly<br />

the balances of the two eliminated line items mentioned<br />

above.<br />

“Gains/Losses on Non-Current Assets Held for Sale not<br />

Classified as Discontinued Operations” includes, inter alia,<br />

the net impairment losses on these assets, when current<br />

regulations do not stipulate that they must be recognised in<br />

a different line item, and the gains or losses on the sale of<br />

equity instruments classified as available for sale which are<br />

strategic investments, even if they were not classified as noncurrent<br />

assets held for sale in a former balance sheet.<br />

The remaining gains or losses which were recognised in the<br />

two eliminated line items and are not now included in the<br />

aforementioned three new line items have been classified<br />

according to their nature in the consolidated income<br />

statement.<br />

3. Consolidated statement of recognised income and expense<br />

and consolidated statement of total changes in equity: the<br />

consolidated statement of changes in equity and the detail of<br />

the changes in consolidated equity disclosed in the notes to the<br />

Group’s consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31<br />

December 2007 are replaced by the consolidated statement of<br />

recognised income and expense and the consolidated statement<br />

of total changes in equity, respectively, which are included in the<br />

consolidated financial statements for 2008 and present,<br />

basically, the following significant differences:<br />

a) The consolidated statement of total changes in equity and<br />

the consolidated statement of recognised income and<br />

expense presented in these consolidated financial statements<br />

for 2008 should be understood as the two parts of the<br />

former consolidated statement of changes in equity and<br />

replace the aforementioned statements presented in the<br />

statutory financial statements for 2007. The statement of<br />

recognised income and expense does not include “Other<br />

Financial Liabilities at Fair Value” and the related balance is<br />

recognised under “Other Recognised Income and Expense”.<br />

b) The statement of recognised income and expense includes<br />

“Actuarial Gains/(losses) on Pension Plans”, for the<br />

recognition of changes in equity resulting from the recording<br />

of such actuarial gains and losses, if appropriate, against<br />

reserves; “Entities Accounted for Using the Equity Method”,<br />

which includes the changes in consolidated equity valuation<br />

adjustments arising from the application of the equity<br />

method to associates and jointly controlled entities; and<br />

“Other Recognised Income and Expense”, for the recognition<br />

of the items recorded as consolidated equity valuation<br />

adjustments and not included in any other specific line item<br />

in this statement.<br />

c) The statement of recognised income and expense includes the<br />

line item "Income Tax" for the recognition of the tax effect of<br />

the items recognised directly in equity, except for "Entities<br />

Accounted for Using the Equity Method", which is presented<br />

net of the related tax effect. Accordingly, each item recognised<br />

in equity valuation adjustments is recognised gross.<br />

All the items recognised as valuation adjustments in the<br />

format of the consolidated statement of changes in equity<br />

included in the consolidated financial statements for 2007<br />

were presented net of the related tax effect.


d) The consolidated statement of recognised income and<br />

expense no longer includes the effect on equity of<br />

changes in accounting policies or of errors allocable to<br />

prior years.<br />

4. Consolidated cash flow statement: the format of consolidated<br />

cash flow statement included in these consolidated financial<br />

statements contains, at the end of the statement, a detail of the<br />

items composing cash and cash equivalents, which was not<br />

included in the consolidated cash flow statement presented in<br />

the Group’s statutory consolidated financial statements for the<br />

year ended 31 December 2007. Also, certain disclosures<br />

relating to certain operating assets and liabilities, adjustments<br />

to profit or loss and cash flows from financing activities are<br />

eliminated; the wording and disclosures relating to certain items<br />

which compose the cash flows from investing activities are<br />

changed.<br />

All the figures relating to 2007 included in these notes to the<br />

consolidated financial statements are presented for comparison<br />

purposes only.<br />

The following standards and interpretations adopted by the<br />

European Union and by the Group came into force in 2008,<br />

without having a material effect on the consolidated financial<br />

statements<br />

- Amendments to IAS 39: the amendments permit<br />

reclassifications from financial assets held for trading to<br />

available-for-sale financial assets, under certain conditions.<br />

This amendment in turn affects IFRS 7, which requires<br />

additional disclosures on these reclassifications.<br />

- Interpretation IFRIC 11 of IFRS 2 “Group and Treasury Share<br />

Transactions”: this intepretation clarifies whether certain<br />

transactions must be accounted for as equity-settled or as<br />

cash-settled, as set forth in IFRS 2. It also stipulates how to<br />

recognise share-based payment arrangements involving two or<br />

more entities in the same group.<br />

At the date on which these consolidated financial statements<br />

were authorised for issue certain new standards had been<br />

adopted by the Europan Union that will come into force for the<br />

Group in 2009. The directors consider that the entry into force<br />

of these standards will not have a significant impact on the<br />

Group’s consolidated financial position:<br />

- IFRS 8 Operating Segments (January 2009):): this standard<br />

replaces IAS 14. The main new development introduced by<br />

this new standard is that it requires an entity to adopt a<br />

management approach when reporting on the financial<br />

performance of its business segments. The information to be<br />

reported will generally be that used internally by management<br />

to assess the profit or loss of the segments and to allocate<br />

resources among them.<br />

- Amendment to IAS 23 Borrowing Costs (January 2009): the main<br />

change in the new revised version of IAS 23 is the elimination<br />

of the option of the immediate recognition as an expense of<br />

borrowing costs relating to assets that take a substantial<br />

period of time to get ready for use or sale. This new standard<br />

may be applied prospectively.<br />

- Amendment to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment (January 2009): the<br />

objective of the amendment to IFRS 2 is basically to clarify<br />

the concepts of vesting conditions and cancellations in sharebased<br />

payments.<br />

- Interpretation IFRIC 13 Customer Loyalty Programmes (January<br />

2009): this interpretation indicates how to recognise certain<br />

loyalty awards granted to customers in the form of points that<br />

provide discounts on future purchases of other goods or<br />

services.<br />

- Interpretation IFRIC 14 on the scope of application of IAS 19<br />

(January 2009): provides general guidance on how to assess<br />

the limit in IAS 19 Employee Benefits on the amount of the<br />

surplus that can be recognised as an asset. It also explains<br />

how pension assets or liabilities can be affected when there is<br />

a statutory or contractual minimum funding requirement and<br />

establishes the need to recognise an additional liability if the<br />

entity has a contractual obligation to make additional<br />

contributions to the plan and its capacity to recover them is<br />

restricted. The interpretation will standardise the practice and<br />

ensure that the entities recognise an asset in relation to a<br />

surplus on a consistent basis.<br />

- Amendments to IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements<br />

(January 2009): the purpose of the new version of this<br />

standard is to improve users' ability to analyse and compare<br />

the information provided in financial statements. These<br />

improvements will enable users of consolidated financial<br />

statements to analyse changes in equity arising from<br />

transactions with owners acting in their capacity as owners<br />

(e.g. dividends and share buy-backs) separately from “nonowner”<br />

changes (e.g. transactions with third parties or income<br />

and expenses recognised directly in equity). The revised<br />

standard provides the option of presenting income and<br />

expense items and components of other comprehensive<br />

income either in a single statement of comprehensive income<br />

with subtotals or in two separate statements (a separate<br />

income statement followed by a statement of recognised<br />

income and expense).<br />

IAS 1 also introduces new reporting requirements when the<br />

entity applies an accounting change retrospectively, makes a<br />

restatement or reclassifies items in previously issued financial<br />

statements, as well as changes in the names of certain financial<br />

statements with a view to reflecting their function more clearly<br />

(e.g. the balance sheet will be called the statement of financial<br />

position). The impacts of this standard will basically be at<br />

presentation and disclosure level.<br />

Set forth below are the Standards and Interpretations not yet<br />

adopted by the European Union, together with the expected date<br />

of adoption for the Group based on the application date required<br />

by the Standard. The impact of the application of these Standards<br />

has not yet been assessed:<br />

- Interpretation IFRIC 12 Service Concession Arrangements (January<br />

2009): indicates how to recognise the obligations and rights<br />

of a private-sector entity that obtains a contract as a public<br />

services provider.<br />

- Amendment to IAS 27 Consolidated and Separate Financial<br />

Statements and to IFRS 3 Business Combinations (July 2009):<br />

these standards were issued as a result of the project for the<br />

convergence of international standards relating to business<br />

combinations with US accounting standards. The revised IFRS<br />

3 and the amendments to IAS 27 give rise to significant<br />

changes in several matters relating to accounting for business<br />

combinations which, in general, place greater emphasis on the<br />

use of fair value. Since the changes are significant, set forth<br />

below are certain of these changes, merely for illustration<br />

97


98<br />

purposes: acquisition costs must be expensed, as opposed to<br />

the current accounting treatment of recognising them as an<br />

increase in the cost of the business combination; in step<br />

acquisitions the acquirer must remeasure its investment at fair<br />

value on the date that control is obtained; or there is an option<br />

to measure at fair value the minority interests of the acquiree,<br />

as opposed to the single current treatment of measuring them<br />

as the proportionate share of the fair value of the net assets<br />

acquired.<br />

- Amendments to IAS 32 and IAS 1 (January 2009): the changes<br />

approved relate to the classification of certain financial<br />

instruments issued which, although because of their<br />

characteristics it might be concluded that they evidence a<br />

residual interest in the entity, in accordance with current IAS 32<br />

they should be classified as financial liabilities since their<br />

features include that of being redeemable. The amendments will<br />

permit the classification of certain of these financial instruments<br />

as equity, provided they meet certain criteria, including that of<br />

being the most subordinated class, and provided they evidence<br />

a residual interest in the net assets of the entity.<br />

- Amendments to IFRS 1 and IAS 27 (January 2009): these<br />

amendments propose that, when adopting IFRS for the first<br />

time in the separate financial statements of an entity, the<br />

entity may opt to use a deemed cost to account for its<br />

investments in subsidiaries, joint ventures and associates,<br />

which can be determined as either the previous GAAP carrying<br />

amount of the investment at the date of transition or the fair<br />

value of the investment in the subsidiary, determined in<br />

accordance with IFRS, at the date of transition.<br />

- Amendment to IAS 39 (June 2009): the aim of this amendment<br />

to IAS 39 is to clarify two specific hedge accounting issues:<br />

(a) when inflation can be designated as a hedged item and (b)<br />

in which cases purchased options can be designated as a<br />

hedging instrument. Under the amendment, inflation can only<br />

be designated as a hedged item if the inflation portion is a<br />

contractually specified portion of the cash flows to be hedged.<br />

With respect to options, only the part related to the intrinsic<br />

value, and not that related to the time value, can be<br />

designated as a hedging instrument.<br />

- IFRIC 15 Agreements for the Construction of Real Estate (January<br />

2009): this interpretation indicates when revenue from the<br />

construction of real estate should be recognised, on the basis<br />

of whether the agreement involves a construction contract, a<br />

sale of goods or the rendering of services.<br />

- IFRIC 16 Hedges of a Net Investment in a Foreign Operation<br />

(March 2009): this interpretation clarifies three main issues.<br />

Firstly, the risk between the functional currency of the foreign<br />

operation and the presentation currency of the parent does<br />

not qualify for hedge accounting and only the risk arising from<br />

the functional currencies of the two entities may be<br />

designated as a hedged risk. It also clarifies that the hedging<br />

instrument in a hedge of a net investment in a foreign<br />

operation may be held by any entity within the group, not<br />

necessarily by the parent holding the net investment. And<br />

lastly, the interpretation addresses how an entity should<br />

determine the amounts to be reclassified from equity to profit<br />

or loss on disposal of the foreign operation.<br />

- IFRIC 17 Distributions of Non-Cash Assets to Owners (June<br />

2009): this interpretation addresses the accounting<br />

treatment of the distribution of non-cash assets to owners<br />

(“dividends”), although its scope does not include<br />

distributions of assets within a group or between jointly<br />

controlled entities. The interpretation requires an entity to<br />

measure the dividend payable at the fair value of the assets to<br />

be distributed and to recognise any difference with respect to<br />

the carrying amount of the asset in profit or loss.<br />

The principal accounting policies and measurement bases applied<br />

in preparing the Group's consolidated financial statements for<br />

2008 are described in Note 2. All mandatory accounting policies<br />

and measurement bases with a material effect on the consolidated<br />

financial statements for 2008 were applied in their preparation.<br />

c) Estimates made<br />

The consolidated results and the determination of consolidated<br />

equity are sensitive to the accounting policies, measurement bases<br />

and estimates used by the directors of the Bank in preparing the<br />

consolidated financial statements. The main accounting policies<br />

and measurement bases are set forth in Note 2.<br />

In the Group's consolidated financial statements for 2008<br />

estimates were occasionally made by the senior executives of the<br />

Group and of the consolidated entities, later ratified by the<br />

directors, in order to quantify certain of the assets, liabilities,<br />

income, expenses and commitments reported herein. These<br />

estimates relate basically to the following:<br />

- The impairment losses on certain assets (see Notes 6, 7, 8, 9,<br />

10 and 12);<br />

- The assumptions used in the actuarial calculation of the postemployment<br />

benefit liabilities and commitments (see Notes<br />

2-v and 2-w);<br />

- The useful life of the tangible and intangible assets (see Notes<br />

14 and 15); and<br />

Although these estimates were made on the basis of the best<br />

information available at 2008 year-end, future events might make<br />

it necessary to change these estimates in coming years. Changes in<br />

accounting estimates would be applied prospectively in accordance<br />

with the requirements of IAS 8, recognising the effects of any<br />

change in estimates in the related consolidated income statement.<br />

d) Basis of consolidation<br />

i. Subsidiaries<br />

“Subsidiaries” are defined as entities over which the Bank has the<br />

capacity to exercise management control; this capacity is, in<br />

general but not exclusively, presumed to exist when the Parent<br />

owns directly or indirectly half or more of the voting power of the<br />

investee or, even if this percentage is lower or zero, when, for<br />

example, there are agreements with other shareholders of the<br />

investee that give the Bank control. Control is the power to govern<br />

the financial and operating policies of an entity so as to obtain<br />

benefits from its activities.


The financial statements of the subsidiaries are fully consolidated<br />

with those of the Bank. Accordingly, all material balances and<br />

transactions between consolidated entities and between<br />

consolidated entities and the Bank are eliminated on consolidation.<br />

On acquisition of a subsidiary, its assets, liabilities and contingent<br />

liabilities are recognised at fair value at the date of acquisition. Any<br />

positive differences between the acquisition cost and the fair<br />

values of the identifiable net assets acquired are recognised as<br />

goodwill (see Note 15). Negative differences are charged to<br />

income on the date of acquisition.<br />

Additionally, the share of third parties of the Group's equity is<br />

presented under “Minority Interests” in the consolidated balance<br />

sheet (see Note 24) and their share of the profit for the year is<br />

presented under “Profit Attributable to Minority Interests” in the<br />

consolidated income statement.<br />

The results of subsidiaries acquired during the year are included in<br />

the consolidated income statement from the date of acquisition to<br />

year-end. Similarly, the results of subsidiaries disposed of during<br />

the year are included in the consolidated income statement from<br />

the beginning of the year to the date of disposal.<br />

ii. Interests in joint ventures (jointly controlled entities)<br />

“Joint ventures” are deemed to be ventures that are not<br />

subsidiaries but which are jointly controlled by two or more<br />

unrelated entities. This is evidenced by contractual arrangements<br />

whereby two or more entities (“venturers”) undertake a business<br />

activity which is subject to joint control so as to share the power<br />

to govern the financial and operating policies of an entity, or<br />

another business activity, in order to benefit from its operations.<br />

Therefore, any strategic financial or operating decision affecting<br />

the joint venture requires the unanimous consent of the venturers.<br />

The financial statements of investees classified as joint ventures are<br />

proportionately consolidated with those of the Bank and,<br />

therefore, the aggregation of balances and subsequent<br />

eliminations are made only in proportion to the Group's ownership<br />

interest in the capital of these entities.<br />

iii. Associates<br />

“Associates” are entities over which the Bank is in a position to<br />

exercise significant influence, but not control or joint control,<br />

usually because it holds 20% or more of the voting power of the<br />

investee.<br />

In the consolidated financial statements, investments in ssociates<br />

are accounted for using the equity method, i.e. at the Group's<br />

share of net assets of the investee, after taking into account the<br />

dividends received therefrom and other equity eliminations. In the<br />

case of transactions with an associate, the related profits or losses<br />

are eliminated to the extent of the Group's investment in the<br />

associate.<br />

iv. Acquisitions and disposals<br />

Appendixes I, II and III contain salient information on the<br />

subsidiaries, jointly controlled entities and associates, respectively.<br />

Note 3-b provides information on the most significant acquisitions<br />

and disposals in 2008 and 2007.<br />

e) Challenges of corporate resolutions<br />

In 1995 and 1996, the former directors of the Bank who had been<br />

replaced by decision of the Bank of Spain's Executive Council on<br />

28 December 1993 filed claims challenging certain corporate<br />

resolutions adopted by the shareholders at the Annual General<br />

Meetings in 1994 and 1995, which approved, inter alia, the Bank's<br />

financial restructuring plan and the 1994 financial statements of<br />

the Bank and the Group. In 2000 Madrid Provincial Appellate<br />

Court decisions dismissed all the appeals filed by the plaintiffs in<br />

connection with the claim filed challenging the legality of the<br />

resolutions adopted by the Annual General Meeting approving the<br />

financial restructuring plan; the plaintiffs subsequently filed<br />

cassation appeals against these decisions. The claim filed against<br />

the approval of the 1994 financial statements was also dismissed in<br />

2000 by the Court of First Instance and this decision was<br />

subsequently appealed against by the plaintiffs. In 2003 the<br />

Provincial Appellate Court dismissed in full the appeal and the<br />

notice given by the appellants of their intention to file a cassation<br />

appeal. The appellants subsequently filed an appeal for<br />

reconsideration, which was again rejected by the Provincial<br />

Appellate Court, and, consequently, they filed an appeal against<br />

the denial of leave to appeal before the Supreme Court. The<br />

Bank's directors and its legal advisers consider that these claims<br />

will not have any effect.<br />

f) Capital requirements<br />

Bank of Spain Circular 3/2008, of 22 May, on the calculation and<br />

control of minimum capital requirements, regulates the minimum<br />

capital requirements for Spanish credit institutions –both as<br />

individual entities and as consolidated groups– and how to<br />

calculate them, as well as the various internal capital adequacy<br />

assessment processes they should have in place and the<br />

information they should disclose to the market.<br />

This Circular is the final implementation, for credit institutions, of<br />

the legislation on capital and consolidated supervision of financial<br />

institutions, which was contained in Law 36/2007, of 16 November,<br />

amending Law 13/1985, of 25 May, on the investment ratios,<br />

capital and reporting requirements of financial intermediaries, and<br />

other financial regulations, which also includes Royal Decree<br />

216/2008, of 15 February, on the capital of financial institutions.<br />

Bank of Spain Circular 3/2008 also culminates the process of<br />

adaptation of Spanish legislation to Directive 2006/48/EC of the<br />

European Parliament and of the Council, of 14 June 2006, and<br />

Directive 2006/49/EC of the European Parliament and of the<br />

Council, of 14 June 2006. The minimum capital requirements for<br />

credit institutions and their consolidable groups were thoroughly<br />

revised in both Directives, based on the new Capital Accord<br />

adopted by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (“Basel<br />

II”).<br />

Bank of Spain Circular 3/2008, of 22 May, establishes the<br />

elements that should be classified as capital for the purpose of<br />

compliance with the minimum capital requirements set forth<br />

therein. Under this Circular, capital is classified into core capital<br />

99


100<br />

and Tier 2 capital and differs from the capital calculated in<br />

accordance with EU-IFRSs, since the Circular considers certain<br />

items as capital and establishes certain mandatory deductions from<br />

capital which are not provided for in the aforementioned EU-IFRSs.<br />

Additionally, the consolidation and measurement bases to be<br />

applied to investees for the purpose of calculating the Group’s<br />

minimum capital requirements pursuant to current standards differ<br />

from those applied in the preparation of these consolidated<br />

financial statements, which also gives rise to differences in the<br />

calculation of capital under Bank of Spain standards and EU-IFRSs.<br />

The minimum capital requirements established by Bank of Spain<br />

Circular 3/2008 are calculated on the basis of the Group’s<br />

exposure to credit risk and dilution risk (on the basis of the assets,<br />

obligations and other memorandum items that present these risks,<br />

depending on their amounts, characteristics, counterparties,<br />

guarantees, etc.), to counterparty risk and position and settlement<br />

risk in the trading book, to foreign exchange risk (on the basis of<br />

the overall net foreign currency position) and to operational risk.<br />

Additionally, the Group is subject to compliance with the risk<br />

concentration limits established in the aforementioned Circular<br />

and with the requirements concerning internal corporate<br />

governance, internal capital adequacy assessment, measurement of<br />

interest rate risk and information to be disclosed to the market<br />

also set forth therein. With a view to guaranteeing compliance with<br />

the aforementioned objectives, the Group performs integrated<br />

management of these risks, in accordance with its internal policies<br />

(see Note 48).<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, and throughout these years, the<br />

eligible capital of the Group and of the Group entities subject to<br />

this requirement at individual level exceeded the minimum required<br />

under the regulations then in force.<br />

The calculation of the minimum regulatory capital requirements<br />

under the new standards, the so-called Pillar 1, is supplemented<br />

with an internal capital adequacy assessment and supervisory<br />

review process, also called Pillar 2. The Group’s internal capital<br />

adequacy assessment process is based on the internal model for<br />

the quantification of the economic capital required on the basis of<br />

the Group’s overall risk profile to maintain a target rating of AA.<br />

Finally, Basel II standards establish, through Pillar 3, strict<br />

transparency requirements regarding the information on risks to be<br />

disclosed to the market.<br />

g) Deposit Guarantee Fund<br />

The Bank participates in the Deposit Guarantee Fund. The<br />

contributions made to this Fund amounted to EUR 17,296<br />

thousand in 2008 and this expense is recorded under “Other<br />

Operating Expenses” in the consolidated income statement for<br />

2008 (see Note 40).<br />

h) Environmental impact<br />

In view of the business activities carried on by the Group entities,<br />

the Group does not have any environmental liability, expenses,<br />

assets, provisions or contingencies that might be material with<br />

respect to its consolidated equity, financial position or results.<br />

Therefore, no specific disclosures relating to environmental issues<br />

are included in these notes to the consolidated financial<br />

statements.<br />

i) Customer Care Service Annual Report<br />

As required by Article 17 of Ministry of Economy Order<br />

ECO/734/2004, of 11 March, on Customer Care Departments<br />

and Services and the Customer Ombudsmen of Financial<br />

Institutions, the Annual Report presented by the Head of the<br />

Service to the Board meeting held on 20 January 2009 is<br />

summarised in the Directors' Report.<br />

j) Events after the balance sheet date<br />

The following significant events took place from 1 January 2009 to<br />

the date on which these consolidated financial statements were<br />

authorised for issue.<br />

Acquisition of Metrovacesa, S.A. shares<br />

As a result of the partial debt restructuring at certain Cresa-<br />

Sacresa Group companies, on 3 December 2008, the Sanahuja<br />

Group reached an agreement with the creditors, including the<br />

Bank, whereby it will deliver the shares owned by it securing the<br />

aforemented debt to these creditors. Under this agreement, the<br />

Bank will receive 6,356,191 Metrovacesa, S.A. shares, representing<br />

9.56% of its share capital, together with the cash amount which,<br />

added to the debt repayment amounts, determines the per<br />

exchange value of the dation in payment at EUR 57.<br />

Additionally, the Bank will acquire 1,250,000 Matrovacesa, S.A.<br />

shares, representing 1.78% of its share capital, at EUR 57 per<br />

share, and will grant to the shareholders of the Cresa-Sacresa<br />

Group an option to purchase these shares over four years. The<br />

option is exercisable at any time within that period at an exercise<br />

price of EUR 57 per share.<br />

This agreement is subject to certain conditions precedent. The<br />

Sahanuja Group and the creditors have agreed to extend the<br />

period for the performance of these transactions as soon as these<br />

conditions precendent are met, which will foreseeably be the case<br />

in January 2009.<br />

Plan for the merger of <strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring, E.F.C., S.A.U., <strong>Banesto</strong>,<br />

S.A.U. and Gedinver e Inmuebles, S.A.U. into the Bank<br />

In accordance with Articles 234 and 250 of the Consolidated<br />

Spanish Companies Law, the Boards of Directors of Banco Español<br />

de Crédito, S.A., <strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring, E.F.C., S.A.U., Gedinver e<br />

Inmuebles, S.A.U. and <strong>Banesto</strong>, S.A.U., at their meetings on 20<br />

January 2009, prepared a merger plan for the merger by<br />

absorption of the last three entities (the absorbed companies) by<br />

the Bank (the absorbing company), with the dissolution without<br />

liquidation of the absorbed companies and the resulting transfer<br />

en bloc, by universal succession, of their assets and liabilities to<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S.A., which would acquire, by universal<br />

succession, the rights and obligations of the absorbed companies.<br />

The merger plan will be submitted for approval by the shareholders<br />

of the Bank at the Annual General Meeting and by the respective<br />

sole shareholders of the absorbed companies. Since the Bank is<br />

the sole owner of all the share capital of the absorbed companies,<br />

no capital increase or exchange process is required.<br />

The main features of the merger plan are as follows:<br />

1. The justification for the merger is that the Bank, as the sole<br />

shareholder, understands that the reasons for which Gedinver<br />

e Inmuebles, S.A.U. and <strong>Banesto</strong>, S.A.U. were created no


longer exist and that it is more sensible to carry out the Group’s<br />

factoring business at the Bank itself, as a way of joining together<br />

the operations of the two groups of professionals with expertise<br />

in this industry. Additionally, the merger is also intended to give<br />

continuity to the Group’s corporate structure rationalisation<br />

policy, simplify its management and reduce administration and<br />

management costs<br />

2. The transactions of the extinct companies will be deemed, for<br />

accounting purposes, to have been performed for the account<br />

of Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. from 1 January 2009.<br />

3. The required authorisation will be requested from the<br />

Thousandss<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring, E.F.C., S.A.U. of Euros<br />

ASSETS-<br />

Cash and balances with central banks 2<br />

Loans and receivables 2,281,458<br />

Hedging derivatives 170<br />

Tangible assets 27<br />

Tax assets 1,315<br />

Other assets 974<br />

Total assets 2,283,946<br />

LIABILITIES AND EQUITY-<br />

Financial liabilities at amortised cost 2,124,162<br />

Hedging derivatives 1,163<br />

Tax liabilities 2,972<br />

Other liabilities 30,415<br />

Share capital 19,500<br />

Share premium 97,086<br />

Reserves (947)<br />

Profit for the year 9,595<br />

Total liabilities and equity 2,283,946<br />

2. Accounting policies and measurement<br />

bases applied<br />

The accounting policies and rules and measurement bases applied<br />

in preparing the Group's consolidated financial statements were as<br />

follows::<br />

a) Definitions and classification of financial instruments<br />

i. Definitions<br />

A “financial instrument” is any contract that gives rise to a<br />

financial asset of one entity and to a financial liability or equity<br />

instrument of another entity.<br />

An “equity instrument” is any agreement that evidences a<br />

residual interest in the assets of the issuing entity after<br />

deducting all of its liabilities.<br />

Ministry of Economy and, therefore, the merger plans relating<br />

to the aforementioned entities will be adopted subject to the<br />

sole condition precedent, applicable to the merger with<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Fáctoring, E.F.C., S.A.U., that the required<br />

authorisation be granted. Also, the intended merger<br />

transaction must be notified to the Ministry of Finance to<br />

qualify for the special regime provided for mergers under Law<br />

43/1995, of 27 December.<br />

The detail, by main items, of the condensed balance sheets at 31<br />

December 2008 of the absorbed companies is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Gedinver e<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Inmuebles,<br />

S.A.U. S.A.U.<br />

ASSETS-<br />

Property, plant and equipment - 43<br />

Trade and other receivables - 433<br />

Current financial assets 1 2<br />

Current prepayments and accrued income - 3<br />

Cash and cash equivalents 48 6,152<br />

Total assets 49 6,633<br />

EQUITY AND LIABILITIES-<br />

Capital 60 3,348<br />

Reserves (10) 2,805<br />

Profit (loss) for the year (2) 135<br />

Long-term provisions - 161<br />

Non-current payables to Group companies and<br />

associates - 86<br />

Trade and other payables 1 27<br />

Current accruals and deferred income - 71<br />

Total equity and liabilities 49 6,633<br />

A “financial derivative” is a financial instrument whose value<br />

changes in response to the change in a specified variable,<br />

sometimes called the underlying (such as an interest rate,<br />

financial instrument price, commodity price, foreign exchange<br />

rate, credit rating or index thereof), whose initial investment is<br />

very small compared with other financial instruments with a<br />

similar response to changes in market factors, and which is<br />

generally settled at a future date.<br />

“Hybrid financial instruments” are contracts that simultaneously<br />

include a non-derivative host contract together with a derivative,<br />

known as an embedded derivative, that is not separately<br />

transferable and has the effect that some of the cash flows of the<br />

hybrid contract vary in a way similar to a stand-alone derivative..<br />

101


102<br />

“Compound financial instruments” are contracts that<br />

simultaneously create for their issuer a financial liability and an<br />

own equity instrument (such as convertible bonds, which entitle<br />

their holders to convert them into equity instruments of the<br />

issuer).<br />

The following transactions are not treated for accounting<br />

purposes as financial instruments:<br />

- Investments in associates (see Note 12).<br />

- Rights and obligations under employee benefit plans (see<br />

Notes 2-v and 2-w).<br />

- Rights and obligations under insurance contracts (see Note<br />

13).<br />

- Contracts and obligations relating to transactions involving<br />

payments based on own equity instruments (see Note 41).<br />

ii. Classification of financial assets for measurement purposes<br />

Financial assets are generally included for measurement<br />

purposes in one of the following categories:<br />

- Financial assets held for trading (at fair value through profit<br />

or loss): this category includes the financial assets acquired<br />

for the purpose of generating a profit in the near term from<br />

fluctuations in their prices and financial derivatives that do<br />

not meet the definition of a financial guarantee contract and<br />

have not been designated as hedging instruments.<br />

- Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss: this<br />

category includes hybrid financial instruments containing<br />

one or more embedded derivatives that do not significantly<br />

modify the cash flows that otherwise would be generated by<br />

the instrument and whose separation is prohibited. These<br />

instruments must be assigned to this category from their<br />

initial recognition, and can only be assigned thereto if this<br />

reduces accounting mismatches or if they are part of a group<br />

of financial instruments whose performance is evaluated in<br />

accordance with a documented risk management or<br />

investment strategy.<br />

- Financial instruments classified in this category are<br />

permanently subject to an integrated and consistent system<br />

of measuring, managing and controlling risks and profit or<br />

loss that enables all the financial instruments involved to be<br />

monitored and identified and allows the effective reduction<br />

of risk to be checked. Financial assets may only be included<br />

in this category on the date they are acquired or originated.<br />

- Held-to-maturity investments: this category includes debt<br />

instruments traded in an active market, with fixed maturity<br />

and fixed or determinable cash flows, for which the Group<br />

has, from inception and at any subsequent date, both the<br />

intention and proven financial ability to hold to maturity.<br />

- Available-for-sale financial assets: this category includes debt<br />

instruments not classified as “held-to-maturity investments”<br />

or as “at fair value through profit or loss”, and equity<br />

instruments issued by entities other than subsidiaries,<br />

associates and jointly controlled entities, provided that such<br />

instruments have not been classified as “financial assets at<br />

fair value through profit or loss”.<br />

- Loans and receivables: this category includes financing<br />

granted to third parties, based on the nature thereof,<br />

irrespective of the type of borrower and the form of<br />

financing, including finance lease transactions in which the<br />

consolidated entities act as the lessors.<br />

The Group may not classify or continue to classify any financial<br />

asset as “held-to-maturity” if during the current year or the two<br />

preceding years it has sold or reclassified assets included in this<br />

portfolio for a significant amount.<br />

iii. Classification of financial assets for presentation purposes<br />

Financial assets are presented in the consolidated balance sheet<br />

classified into the various categories used for management and<br />

measurement purposes (section ii. above), unless they have to<br />

be presented as “non-current assets held for sale” or they relate<br />

to “cash and balances with central banks”, “hedging derivatives”<br />

or “investments”, which are reported separately.<br />

Financial assets are classified by type of instrument into the<br />

following items in the consolidated balance sheet:<br />

- Cash and balances with central banks: cash balances and<br />

deposits with the Bank of Spain and other central banks.<br />

- Loans and advances to credit institutions: credit of any<br />

nature in the name of credit institutions.<br />

- Loans and advances to customers: all credit granted by the<br />

Group, other than that represented by marketable securities,<br />

money market operations through central counterparties,<br />

finance lease receivables and loans and advances to credit<br />

institutions.<br />

- Debt instruments: bonds and other securities that create a<br />

debt for their issuer, that generate an implicit or explicit<br />

interest return at a contractually agreed rate, and that are in<br />

the form of certificates or book entries, irrespective of the<br />

issuer.<br />

- Other equity instruments: financial instruments issued by<br />

other entities, such as shares and non-voting equity units,<br />

which have the nature of equity instruments for the issuer,<br />

unless they are investments in subsidiaries, jointly controlled<br />

entities or associates. Investment fund units are included in<br />

this item.<br />

- Trading derivatives: includes the fair value in favour of the<br />

Group of derivatives which do not form part of hedge<br />

accounting.<br />

- Changes in the fair value of hedged items in portfolio hedges<br />

of interest rate risk: includes the net balance of the positive<br />

or negative changes in the fair value of the hedged amount<br />

of financial assets included in portfolio hedges of interest<br />

rate risk, attributable exclusively to such risk.<br />

- Other financial assets: other debit balances in favour of the<br />

Group in respect of transactions which do not have the<br />

nature of credit (such as cheques drawn on credit<br />

institutions, the amounts receivable from clearing houses<br />

and settlement agencies for transactions on the stock<br />

exchange and organised markets, bonds given in cash, capital<br />

calls, and fees and commissions receivable for financial<br />

guarantees).


- Hedging derivatives: includes the fair value in favour of the<br />

Group of derivatives designated as hedging instruments in<br />

hedge accounting.<br />

iv. Classification of financial liabilities for measurement purposes<br />

Financial liabilities are classified for measurement purposes into<br />

one of the following categories::<br />

- Financial liabilities held for trading (at fair value through<br />

profit or loss): includes financial liabilities issued with the<br />

intention to repurchase them in the near future, assumed for<br />

the purpose of generating a profit in the near term from<br />

fluctuations in their prices, financial derivatives that do not<br />

meet the definition of a financial guarantee contract and<br />

have not been designated as hedging instruments, and<br />

financial liabilities arising from the outright sale of financial<br />

assets purchased under resale agreements (reverse repos) or<br />

borrowed (“short positions”).<br />

- Other financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss:<br />

this category includes all hybrid financial instruments<br />

containing one or more embedded derivatives that do not<br />

significantly modify the cash flows that otherwise would be<br />

generated by the instrument and whose separation<br />

therefrom is prohibited. These financial instruments must be<br />

assigned to this category from their initial recognition, and<br />

can only be assigned thereto if this significantly reduces<br />

accounting mismatches or if they are part of a group of<br />

financial instruments whose performance is evaluated in<br />

accordance with a documented risk management or<br />

investment strategy.<br />

- Financial liabilities at fair value through equity: financial<br />

liabilities associated with available-for-sale financial assets<br />

arising as a result of transfers of assets in which the<br />

consolidated entities, acting as transferors, neither transfer<br />

nor retain substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership<br />

of the assets.<br />

- Financial liabilities at amortised cost: financial liabilities not<br />

included in any of the above categories which arise from the<br />

ordinary borrowing activities carried on by financial<br />

institutions, irrespective of their instrumentation and<br />

maturity.<br />

v. Classification of financial liabilities for presentation purposes<br />

Financial liabilities are presented in the consolidated balance sheet<br />

classified into the various categories used for management and<br />

measurement purposes (see section iv. above), unless they have to<br />

be presented as “liabilities associated with non-current assets held<br />

for sale” or they relate to “hedging derivatives” and “equity having<br />

the substance of a financial liability”, which are reported<br />

separately.<br />

Financial liabilities are classified by type of instrument into the<br />

following items:<br />

- Deposits from central banks and from credit institutions:<br />

deposits of any nature, including credit and money market<br />

operations received from the Bank of Spain or other central<br />

banks, and credit received and money market operations in<br />

the name of credit institutions.<br />

- Customer deposits: includes all repayable balances received<br />

in cash by the Group, other than those represented by<br />

marketable securities, money market operations through<br />

central counterparties and subordinated liabilities.<br />

- Marketable debt securities: includes the amount of bonds<br />

and other debt represented by marketable securities, other<br />

than those that have the substance of subordinated<br />

liabilities. This item includes the component considered to<br />

be a financial liability of issued securities that are compound<br />

financial instruments.<br />

- Trading derivatives: includes the fair value of the Group's<br />

liability in respect of derivatives which do not form part of<br />

hedge accounting.<br />

- Short positions: includes the amount of financial liabilities<br />

arising from the outright sale of financial assets purchased<br />

under reverse repurchase agreements or borrowed.<br />

- Subordinated liabilities: amount of financing received which,<br />

for the purposes of payment priority, ranks behind ordinary<br />

debt.<br />

- Other financial liabilities: includes the amount of payment<br />

obligations having the substance of financial liabilities not<br />

included under any other item.<br />

- Changes in the fair value of hedged items in portfolio hedges<br />

of interest rate risk: includes the net balance of the positive<br />

or negative changes in the fair value of the hedged amount<br />

of financial liabilities included in portfolio hedges of interest<br />

rate risk, attributable exclusively to such risk.<br />

- Hedging derivatives: includes the fair value of the Group's<br />

liability in respect of derivatives designated as hedging<br />

instruments in hedge accounting.<br />

- Capital refundable on demand: amount of the financial<br />

instruments issued by the consolidated entities which,<br />

although capital for legal purposes, do not meet the<br />

requirements for classification as equity.<br />

b) Measurement of financial assets and liabilities and<br />

recognition of fair value changes<br />

In general, financial instruments are initially recognised at fair value<br />

which, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, is deemed to be<br />

their acquisition cost, and are subsequently measured at each<br />

period-end as follows:<br />

i. Measurement of financial assets<br />

Financial assets are measured at fair value, without deducting<br />

any transaction costs that may be incurred on their sale or other<br />

form of disposal, except for loans and receivables, held-tomaturity<br />

investments, equity instruments whose fair value cannot<br />

be determined in a sufficiently objective manner and financial<br />

derivatives that have those equity instruments as their<br />

underlying and are settled by delivery of those instruments.<br />

The “fair value” of a financial instrument on a given date is taken<br />

to be the amount for which it could be bought or sold on that<br />

date by two knowledgeable, willing parties in an arm's length<br />

transaction acting prudently. The most objective and common<br />

103


104<br />

reference for the fair value of a financial instrument is the price<br />

that would be paid for it on an organised, transparent and deep<br />

market (“quoted price” or “market price”).<br />

If there is no market price for a given financial instrument, its fair<br />

value is estimated on the basis of the price established in recent<br />

transactions involving similar instruments and, in the absence<br />

thereof, of valuation techniques commonly used by the<br />

international financial community, taking into account the<br />

specific features of the instrument to be measured and,<br />

particularly, the various types of risk associated with it. However,<br />

the inherent limitations of the valuation techniques used and the<br />

possible inaccuracies of the assumptions made under these<br />

techniques may result in a fair value of a financial instrument<br />

which does not exactly coincide with the price at which the<br />

instrument could be bought or sold at the date of measurement.<br />

All derivatives are recognised in the balance sheet at fair value<br />

from the trade date. If the fair value is positive, they are<br />

recognised as an asset and if the fair value is negative, they are<br />

recognised as a liability. The fair value on the trade date is<br />

deemed, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, to be the<br />

transaction price. The changes in the fair value of derivatives<br />

from the trade date are recognised in “Gains/Losses on Financial<br />

Assets and Liabilities” in the consolidated income statement.<br />

Specifically, the fair value of standard financial derivatives<br />

included in the portfolios of financial assets or liabilities held for<br />

trading is deemed to be their daily quoted price and if, for<br />

exceptional reasons, the quoted price cannot be determined on<br />

a given date, these financial derivatives are measured using<br />

methods similar to those used to measure OTC derivatives.<br />

The fair value of OTC derivatives is taken to be the sum of the<br />

future cash flows arising from the instrument, discounted to<br />

present value at the date of measurement (“present value” or<br />

“theoretical close”) using valuation techniques accepted in the<br />

financial markets: “net present value” (NPV), option pricing<br />

models and other methods.<br />

“Loans and Receivables” and “Held-to-Maturity Investments” are<br />

measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method.<br />

“Amortised cost” is understood to be the acquisition cost of a<br />

financial asset or liability plus or minus, as appropriate, the<br />

principal repayments and the cumulative amortisation (taken to<br />

the income statement) of the difference between the initial cost<br />

and the maturity amount. In the case of financial assets,<br />

amortised cost furthermore includes any reductions for<br />

impairment or uncollectibility. In the case of loans and<br />

receivables hedged in fair value hedges, the changes in the fair<br />

value of these assets related to the risk or risks being hedged are<br />

recognised in the consolidated income statement.<br />

The “effective interest rate” is the discount rate that exactly<br />

matches the initial amount of a financial instrument to its<br />

estimated cash flows during its estimated life, based on the<br />

contractual terms, but disregarding future credit losses. For fixed<br />

rate financial instruments, the effective interest rate coincides<br />

with the contractual interest rate established on the acquisition<br />

date plus, where applicable, the fees that, because of their<br />

nature, can be equated with a rate of interest. In the case of<br />

floating rate financial instruments, the effective interest rate<br />

coincides with the rate of return prevailing in all connections<br />

until the next benchmark interest reset date.<br />

Equity instruments of other entities whose fair value cannot be<br />

determined in a sufficiently objective manner and financial<br />

derivatives that have those instruments as their underlying and<br />

are settled by delivery of those instruments are measured at<br />

acquisition cost adjusted, where appropriate, by any related<br />

impairment loss.<br />

The amounts at which the financial assets are recognised<br />

represent, in all material respects, the Group’s maximum<br />

exposure to credit risk at each reporting date. Also, the Bank has<br />

received collateral and other credit enhancements to mitigate its<br />

exposure to credit risk, which consist mainly of mortgage<br />

guarantees, cash collateral and insurance.<br />

ii. Measurement of financial liabilities<br />

In general, financial liabilities are measured at amortised cost, as<br />

defined above, except for those included under “Financial<br />

Liabilities Held for Trading” and financial liabilities designated as<br />

hedged items (or hedging instruments) in fair value hedges,<br />

which are measured at fair value.<br />

iii. Valuation techniques<br />

Following is a summary of the various valuation techniques used<br />

by the Group to measure the financial instruments recognised at<br />

fair value at 31 December 2008:<br />

The main techniques employed in the “internal valuation models”<br />

are as follows:<br />

Percentage<br />

Market Value Based on Assets Liabilities<br />

Public price quotations in active markets<br />

Internal valuation models with observable<br />

64% 19%<br />

market data 36% 80%<br />

Internal valuation models with non-market data - 1%<br />

100% 100%<br />

- In the valuation of financial instruments permitting static<br />

hedging (basically, forwards and swaps) the “present value”<br />

method is employed.<br />

- In the valuation of financial instruments requiring dynamic<br />

hedging, the Black-Scholes model is mainly employed.<br />

- In the valuation of financial instruments exposed to interest<br />

rate risk, the Heath-Jarrow-Morton model is employed to<br />

analyse the correlation by currency.<br />

- Credit risk is measured with dynamic models similar to those<br />

used in the measurement of interest rate risk.


The Bank's directors consider that the financial assets and<br />

liabilities recognised in the consolidated balance sheet and<br />

the gains and losses arising from these financial instruments<br />

are reasonable and reflect their market value.<br />

The breakdown of the financial instruments, by valuation<br />

method, is as follows<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Public Price<br />

Quotations<br />

in Active Internal<br />

Markets Models Total<br />

Financial assets held for trading 860,411 4,223,404 5,083,815<br />

Other financial assets<br />

at fair value through<br />

profit or loss 2,189,943 1,219 2,191,162<br />

Available-for-sale<br />

financial assets 6,709,546 33,036 6,742,582<br />

Hedging derivatives (assets) - 1,194,849 1,194,849<br />

Financial liabilities held for trading 609,214 3,341,504 3,950,718<br />

Hedging derivatives (liabilities) - 577,091 577,091<br />

Liabilities under insurance contracts 930,694 2,504,935 3,435,629<br />

iv. Recognition of fair value changes<br />

As a general rule, changes in the fair value of financial<br />

instruments are recognised in the consolidated income<br />

statement. A distinction is made between the changes resulting<br />

from the accrual of interest or dividends, which are recognised<br />

under “Interest and Similar Income”, “Interest Expense and<br />

Similar Charges” and “Income from Equity Instruments”, as<br />

appropriate; those arising from the impairment of asset quality;<br />

and those arising for other reasons, which are recognised at<br />

their net amount under “Gains/Losses on Financial Assets and<br />

Liabilities (net)” in the consolidated income statement.<br />

Exceptionally, adjustments due to changes in fair value arising<br />

from “Available-for-Sale Financial Assets” are recognised<br />

temporarily in consolidated equity under “Valuation<br />

Adjustments”, unless they relate to exchange differences on<br />

monetary financial assets, in which case they are recognised in<br />

the consolidated income statement. Items charged or credited to<br />

“Valuation Adjustments” remain in the Group's consolidated<br />

equity until the asset giving rise to them is derecognised, at<br />

which time they are recognised in the consolidated income<br />

statement.<br />

v. Hedging transactions<br />

The consolidated entities use financial derivatives for the<br />

purpose of trading with customers who request these<br />

instruments in order to manage their own market and credit risks<br />

and for their structured financial transactions; for the purpose of<br />

managing the risks of the Group entities' own positions and<br />

assets and liabilities (“hedging derivatives”); or for the purpose<br />

of obtaining gains from changes in the prices of these<br />

derivatives.<br />

A derivative qualifies for hedge accounting if all the following<br />

conditions are met:<br />

1. The derivative hedges one of the following three types of<br />

exposure:<br />

a. Changes in the fair value of assets and liabilities due to<br />

fluctuations in, inter alia, the interest rate and/or exchange<br />

rate to which the position or balance to be hedged is<br />

subject (“fair value hedge”);<br />

b. Changes in the estimated cash flows arising from financial<br />

assets and liabilities, commitments and highly probable<br />

forecast transactions (“cash flow hedge”);<br />

c. The net investment in a foreign operation (“hedge of a net<br />

investment in a foreign operation”).<br />

2. It is effective in offsetting exposure inherent in the hedged<br />

item or position throughout the expected term of the hedge,<br />

which means that:<br />

a. At the date of arrangement the hedge is expected, under<br />

normal conditions, to be highly effective (“prospective<br />

effectiveness”).<br />

b. There is sufficient evidence that the hedge was actually<br />

effective during the whole life of the hedged item or<br />

position (“retrospective effectiveness”).<br />

The consolidated entities ascertain the prospective and<br />

retrospective effectiveness of their hedges as follows:<br />

In fair value hedges, the ratio of the change in the fair value of<br />

the hedged item during the measurement period to the<br />

change in the fair value of the hedging instrument during the<br />

same period is calculated retrospectively. The hedge is<br />

deemed to be effective if this ratio is within a range of 80% to<br />

125%. Prospective effectiveness is calculated by comparing<br />

the sensitivity of the hedged item (to changes in the interest<br />

rate curve) with the sensitivity of the hedging instrument. The<br />

hedge is deemed to be effective if this comparison shows that<br />

the two sensitivities offset each other.<br />

In order to measure the effectiveness of fair value hedges of<br />

the interest rate exposure of a portfolio of financial<br />

instruments, the Group compares the amount of the net asset<br />

and/or liability position with the hedged amount designated<br />

for each one. The hedge is deemed to be ineffective when the<br />

amount of this net position is less than the hedged amount, in<br />

which case the ineffective portion is recognised immediately in<br />

the consolidated income statement.<br />

105


106<br />

In cash flow hedges, retrospective effectiveness is assessed by<br />

calculating the ratio of the interest cash flows generated by<br />

the hedged item during the measurement period to the<br />

interest cash flows generated by the hedging instrument<br />

during the same period. The hedge is deemed to be effective<br />

if this ratio is within a range of 80% to 125%. Prospective<br />

effectiveness is calculated by comparing the future interest<br />

cash flows (obtained from the related market interest rate<br />

curve) of the hedged item and the hedging instrument. The<br />

hedge is deemed to be effective if the related cash flows offset<br />

each other.<br />

3. There must be adequate documentation evidencing the<br />

specific designation of the financial derivative to hedge<br />

certain balances or transactions and the manner in which this<br />

effective hedge was intended to be achieved and measured,<br />

provided that this is consistent with the Group's management<br />

of own risks.<br />

The changes in value of financial instruments qualifying for<br />

hedge accounting are recognised as follows:<br />

a. In fair value hedges, the gains or losses arising on both the<br />

hedging instruments and the hedged items (attributable to<br />

the type of risk being hedged) are recognised directly in the<br />

consolidated income statement.<br />

In the case of fair value hedges of the interest rate exposure<br />

of a portfolio of financial instruments, the gains or losses<br />

due to changes in the fair value of the hedged amount<br />

(attributable to the hedged risk) are recognised in the<br />

consolidated income statement with a balancing entry under<br />

“Changes in the Fair Value of Hedged Items in Portfolio<br />

Hedges of Interest Rate Risk” on the asset or liability side of<br />

the balance sheet, as appropriate..<br />

b. In cash flow hedges, the effective portion of the change in<br />

value of the hedging instrument is recognised temporarily in<br />

equity under “Valuation Adjustments - Cash Flow Hedges”<br />

until the forecast transactions occur, when it is recorded in<br />

the consolidated income statement, unless, if the forecast<br />

transactions result in the recognition of non-financial assets<br />

or liabilities, it is included in the cost of the non-financial<br />

asset or liability. The ineffective portion of the change in<br />

value of the hedging derivatives is recognised directly in the<br />

consolidated income statement under “Gains/Losses on<br />

Financial Assets and Liabilities (net)”.<br />

When fair value hedges are discontinued, the adjustments<br />

relating to the hedged item previously recognised under<br />

“Valuation Adjustments” are transferred to profit or loss at the<br />

effective interest rate re-calculated at the date of hedge<br />

discontinuation. The adjustments must be fully amortised at<br />

maturity.<br />

When cash flow hedges are discontinued, any cumulative gain or<br />

loss on the hedging instrument recognised under “Valuation<br />

Adjustments” in consolidated equity (while the hedge was<br />

effective) continues to be recognised in equity until the hedged<br />

transaction occurs, at which time it is recognised in income,<br />

unless the transaction is no longer expected to occur, in which<br />

case the gain or loss is recognised immediately in income.<br />

Derivatives embedded in other financial instruments or in other<br />

host contracts are accounted for separately as derivatives if their<br />

risks and characteristics are not closely related to those of the<br />

host contracts, provided that the host contracts are not<br />

classified as “Other Financial Assets/Liabilities at Fair Value<br />

through Profit or Loss” or as “Financial Assets/Liabilities Held for<br />

Trading”.<br />

Financial derivatives that do not qualify for hedge accounting<br />

are treated for accounting purposes as trading derivatives.<br />

c) Derecognition of financial assets and liabilities<br />

The accounting treatment of transfers of financial assets depends<br />

on the extent to which the risks and rewards associated with the<br />

transferred assets are transferred to third parties:<br />

1. If the Group transfers substantially all the risks and rewards to<br />

third parties -unconditional sale of financial assets, sale of<br />

financial assets under an agreement to repurchase them at their<br />

fair value at the repurchase date, sale of financial assets with a<br />

purchased call option or written put option that is deeply out of<br />

the money, securitisation of assets in which the transferor does<br />

not retain a subordinated debt or grant any credit enhancement<br />

to new holders, and other similar cases-, the transferred financial<br />

asset is derecognised and any right or obligation retained or<br />

created in the transfer is recognised separately.<br />

2. If the Group retains substantially all the risks and rewards<br />

associated with the transferred financial asset -sale of financial<br />

assets under an agreement to repurchase them at a fixed price<br />

or at the sale price plus interest, a securities lending agreement<br />

in which the borrower undertakes to return the same or similar<br />

assets, and other similar cases-, the transferred financial asset is<br />

not derecognised and continues to be measured by the same<br />

criteria as those used before the transfer. However, the following<br />

items are recognised:<br />

a. An associated financial liability, which is recognised for an<br />

amount equal to the consideration received and is<br />

subsequently measured at amortised cost, unless it meets the<br />

requirements to be classified as a financial liability at fair value<br />

through profit or loss.<br />

b. The income from the transferred financial asset not<br />

derecognised and any expense incurred on the new financial<br />

liability.<br />

3. If the Group neither transfers nor retains substantially all the<br />

risks and rewards associated with the transferred financial asset<br />

-sale of financial assets with a purchased call option or written<br />

put option that is not deeply in or out of the money,<br />

securitisation of assets in which the transferor retains a<br />

subordinated debt or other type of credit enhancement for a<br />

portion of the transferred asset, and other similar cases-, the<br />

following distinction is made:<br />

a. If the transferor does not retain control of the transferred<br />

financial asset, the asset is derecognised and any rights or<br />

obligations retained or created in the transfer are recognised<br />

separately.


. If the transferor retains control, it continues to recognise the<br />

transferred financial asset for an amount equal to its exposure<br />

to changes in value and recognises a financial liability<br />

associated with the transferred financial asset. The net<br />

carrying amount of the transferred asset and the associated<br />

liability is the amortised cost of the rights and obligations<br />

retained, if the transferred asset is measured at amortised<br />

cost, or the fair value of the rights and obligations retained, if<br />

the transferred asset is measured at fair value.<br />

Accordingly, financial assets are only derecognised when the cash<br />

flows they generate have been extinguished or when substantially<br />

all the inherent risks and rewards have been transferred. Similarly,<br />

financial liabilities are only derecognised when the obligations they<br />

generate have been extinguished or when they are acquired (with<br />

the intention either to cancel them or to resell them)..<br />

In 2008 financial instruments totalling approximately EUR 4,300<br />

million were transferred but not derecognised (see Note 10).<br />

d) Offsetting of financial instruments<br />

Financial asset and liability balances are offset, i.e. reported in the<br />

consolidated balance sheet at their net amount, only if the<br />

subsidiaries currently have a legally enforceable right to set off the<br />

recognised amounts and intend either to settle on a net basis, or<br />

to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously.<br />

e) Impairment of financial assets<br />

i. Definition<br />

A financial asset is considered to be impaired –and, therefore, its<br />

carrying amount is adjusted to reflect the effect of impairmentwhen<br />

there is objective evidence that events have occurred which:<br />

- In the case of debt instruments (loans and debt securities),<br />

give rise to an adverse impact on the future cash flows that<br />

were estimated at the transaction date.<br />

- In the case of equity instruments, mean that their carrying<br />

amount cannot be fully recovered.<br />

As a general rule, the carrying amount of impaired financial<br />

instruments is adjusted with a charge to the consolidated income<br />

statement for the year in which the impairment becomes evident.<br />

The reversal, if any, of previously recognised impairment losses is<br />

recognised in the consolidated income statement for the year in<br />

which the impairment ceases to exist or is reduced.<br />

Balances are deemed to be impaired when there are reasonable<br />

doubts as to their full recovery and/or the collection of the related<br />

interest for the amounts and on the dates initially agreed upon,<br />

after taking into account the guarantees received by the<br />

consolidated entities to secure (fully or partially) collection of the<br />

related balances. Collections relating to impaired loans and<br />

advances are used to recognise the accrued interest and the<br />

remainder, if any, to reduce the principal amount outstanding. The<br />

amount of the financial assets that would be deemed to be<br />

impaired had the conditions thereof not been renegotiated is not<br />

material with respect to the Group’s financial statements taken as a<br />

whole.<br />

When the recovery of any recognised amount is considered<br />

unlikely, the amount is written off, without prejudice to any actions<br />

that the consolidated entities may initiate to seek collection until<br />

their contractual rights are extinguished due to expiry of the<br />

statute-of-limitations period, forgiveness or any other cause<br />

ii. I Debt instruments carried at amortised cost<br />

The amount of an impairment loss incurred on a debt instrument<br />

carried at amortised cost is equal to the difference between its<br />

carrying amount and the present value of its estimated future cash<br />

flows, and is presented as a reduction of the balance of the asset<br />

adjusted.<br />

Impairment losses are assessed as follows:<br />

- Individually, for all significant debt instruments.<br />

- Collectively: the Bank classifies transactions on the basis of the<br />

nature of the obligors, the conditions of the countries in which<br />

they reside, transaction status and type of collateral or<br />

guarantee, age of past-due amounts, etc. For each risk group, it<br />

establishes the impairment losses that are to be allocated to<br />

specific transactions. In addition, the Group identifies any<br />

homogenous groups of debt instruments and contingent<br />

liabilities which, although not classifiable as impaired, evidence<br />

weaknesses that may give rise to losses higher than those for<br />

the categories described above, since they belong to a group<br />

that is experiencing difficulties. In this case, the impairment<br />

losses are determined as the difference between the amount<br />

recognised in assets for these instruments and the present<br />

value of the cash flows expected to be received, discounted at<br />

the average contractual interest rate.<br />

The total allowances recognised at any given time are the sum of<br />

the allowances for losses on specific transactions, for losses on<br />

transactions of homogenous groups of debt instruments<br />

evidencing weaknesses, and for inherent impairment losses (losses<br />

incurred at the date of the financial statements, calculated using<br />

statistical methods), and the allowance for the risk exposure of<br />

groups experiencing difficulties.<br />

Interest accrual is suspended for all debt instruments individually<br />

classified as impaired and for the instruments for which impairment<br />

losses have been assessed collectively because they have payments<br />

more than three months past due.<br />

iii. Debt or equity instruments classified as available for sale<br />

Impairment losses on these instruments are the difference between<br />

the acquisition cost of the instruments (net of any principal<br />

repayment or amortisation, in the case of debt instruments) and<br />

their fair value less any impairment loss previously recognised in<br />

the consolidated income statement.<br />

When there is objective evidence that the losses arising on<br />

measurement of these assets are due to impairment, they are no<br />

longer recognised in equity under “Valuation Adjustments -<br />

Available-for-Sale Financial Assets” and are recorded in the<br />

consolidated income statement. If all or part of the impairment<br />

losses are subsequently reversed, the reversed amount is<br />

recognised in the consolidated income statement for the year in<br />

which the reversal occurs (with a balancing entry under “Valuation<br />

Adjustments - Available-for-Sale Financial Assets” in the<br />

consolidated balance sheet).<br />

107


108<br />

iv. Equity instruments carried at cost<br />

The impairment loss on equity instruments carried at cost is the<br />

difference between the carrying amount and the present value of<br />

the expected future cash flows discounted at the market rate of<br />

return for similar securities.<br />

Impairment losses are recognised in the consolidated income<br />

statement for the period in which they arise as a direct reduction<br />

of the cost of the instrument. These losses can only be reversed<br />

subsequently if the related assets are sold..<br />

f) Repurchase agreements and reverse repurchase agreements<br />

Purchases (sales) of financial assets under a non-optional resale<br />

(repurchase) agreement at a fixed price (“repos”) are recognised in<br />

the consolidated balance sheet as financing granted (received)<br />

based on the nature of the debtor (creditor) under “Loans and<br />

Advances to Credit Institutions” or “Loans and Advances to<br />

Customers” (“Deposits from Credit Institutions” or “Customer<br />

Deposits”).<br />

Differences between the purchase and sale prices are recognised as<br />

interest over the contract term.<br />

g) Non-current assets held for sale and Liabilities associated<br />

with non-current assets held for sale<br />

“Non-Current Assets Held for Sale” in the consolidated balance<br />

sheet includes the carrying amount of individual items, disposal<br />

groups or items forming part of a business unit earmarked for<br />

disposal (“discontinued operations”), whose sale in their present<br />

condition is highly probable and is expected to occur within one<br />

year from the date of the accompanying consolidated financial<br />

statements. Therefore, the carrying amount of these items (which<br />

can be of a financial nature or otherwise) will foreseeably be<br />

recovered through the proceeds from their disposal. Specifically,<br />

property or other non-current assets received by the consolidated<br />

entities as total or partial settlement of their debtors' payment<br />

obligations to them are deemed to be non-current assets held for<br />

sale, unless the consolidated entities have decided to make<br />

continuing use of these assets.<br />

Similarly, “Liabilities Associated with Non-Current Assets Held for<br />

Sale” includes the balances payable arising from the assets held for<br />

sale or disposal groups and from discontinued operations.<br />

Non-current assets held for sale are generally measured at the<br />

lower of fair value less costs to sell and their carrying amount at<br />

the date of classification in this category. Non-current assets held<br />

for sale are not depreciated as long as they remain in this category.<br />

The gains and losses arising on the disposal of assets and liabilities<br />

classified as held for sale, as well any related impairment losses<br />

recognised or reversed, are recorded under “Gains (Losses) on<br />

Non-Current Assets Held for Sale not Classified as Discontinued<br />

Operations”. All other income and expenses relating to these assets<br />

and liabilities are classified in the corresponding income statement<br />

items based on their nature.<br />

h) Reinsurance assets and Liabilities under insurance contracts<br />

“Reinsurance Assets” in the consolidated balance sheet includes<br />

the amounts that the consolidated entities are entitled to receive<br />

for reinsurance contracts with third parties and, specifically, the<br />

reinsurer's share of the technical provisions recorded by the<br />

consolidated insurance entities. In the event of impairment of<br />

these assets, the related loss is recognised directly in the<br />

consolidated income statement against these assets.<br />

“Liabilities under Insurance Contracts” in the consolidated balance<br />

sheet includes the technical provisions recorded by the<br />

consolidated insurance entities to cover obligations arising from<br />

insurance contracts in force at year-end.<br />

In accordance with standard accounting practice in the insurance<br />

industry, the consolidated insurance entities credit to the income<br />

statement the amounts of the premiums written and charge to<br />

income the cost of the claims incurred on final settlement thereof.<br />

Insurance entities are required to accrue at year-end the unearned<br />

revenues credited to their income statements and the accrued<br />

costs not charged to income.<br />

At each reporting date the Group assesses whether the insurance<br />

contract liabilities recognised in the consolidated balance sheet are<br />

adequately measured. For this purpose, it calculates the difference<br />

between the following amounts:<br />

- Current estimates of future cash flows under the insurance<br />

contracts of the consolidated entities. These estimates include<br />

all contractual cash flows and any related cash flows, such as<br />

claims handling costs; and<br />

- The value recognised in the consolidated balance sheet for<br />

insurance liabilities (see Note 13), net of any related deferred<br />

acquisition costs or intangible assets, such as the amount paid<br />

to acquire, in the event of purchase by the entity, the economic<br />

rights held by a broker deriving from policies in the entity's<br />

portfolio.<br />

If the calculation results in a positive amount, this amount is<br />

charged to the consolidated income statement.<br />

i) Tangible assets<br />

“Tangible Assets” includes the amount of buildings, land, furniture,<br />

vehicles, computer hardware and other fixtures owned by the<br />

consolidated entities or acquired under finance leases. Tangible<br />

assets are classified by use as follows:<br />

i. Property, plant and equipment for own use<br />

Property, plant and equipment for own use are presented at<br />

acquisition cost revalued, where appropriate, pursuant to the<br />

applicable legislation, less the related accumulated depreciation<br />

and any impairment losses (net carrying amount higher than<br />

recoverable amount).


Depreciation is calculated, using the straight-line method, on the<br />

basis of the acquisition cost of the assets less their residual value.<br />

The land on which the buildings and other structures stand has an<br />

indefinite life and, therefore, is not depreciated.<br />

The tangible asset depreciation charge is recognised in the<br />

consolidated income statement and is calculated basically using<br />

the following depreciation rates (based on the average years of<br />

estimated useful life of the various assets):<br />

Anual Rate<br />

Buildings for own use 2.0%<br />

Furniture 7.7%<br />

Fixtures 7.0%<br />

Office and IT equipment 25.0%<br />

Leasehold improvements 7.0%<br />

The consolidated entities assess at the reporting date whether<br />

there is any indication that an asset may be impaired (i.e. its<br />

carrying amount exceeds its recoverable amount). If this is the<br />

case, the carrying amount of the asset is reduced to its recoverable<br />

amount and future depreciation charges are adjusted in proportion<br />

to the revised carrying amount and to the new remaining useful life<br />

(if the useful life has to be re-estimated).<br />

Similarly, if there is an indication of a recovery in the value of a<br />

tangible asset, the consolidated entities recognise the reversal of<br />

the impairment loss recognised in prior periods and adjust the<br />

future depreciation charges accordingly. In no circumstances may<br />

the reversal of an impairment loss on an asset raise its carrying<br />

amount above that which it would have if no impairment losses had<br />

been recognised in prior years.<br />

The estimated useful lives of property, plant and equipment for<br />

own use are reviewed at least at the end of the reporting period<br />

with a view to detecting significant changes therein. If changes are<br />

detected, the useful lives of the assets are adjusted by correcting<br />

the depreciation charge to be recognised in the consolidated<br />

income statement in future years on the basis of the new useful<br />

lives.<br />

Upkeep and maintenance expenses relating to property, plant and<br />

equipment for own use are recognised as an expense in the period<br />

in which they are incurred.<br />

ii. Investment property<br />

“Investment Property” in the consolidated balance sheet reflects,<br />

at acquisition cost, the net values of the land, buildings and other<br />

structures held either to earn rentals or for capital appreciation.<br />

The fair value of the investment property does not differ<br />

significantly from its carrying amount.<br />

The criteria used to recognise the acquisition cost of investment<br />

property, to calculate its depreciation and its estimated useful life<br />

and to recognise the impairment losses thereon are consistent with<br />

those described in relation to property, plant and equipment for<br />

own use.<br />

j) Accounting for leases<br />

i. Finance leases<br />

Finance leases are leases that transfer to the lessee substantially all<br />

the risks and rewards incidental to ownership of the leased asset.<br />

When the consolidated entities act as lessors of an asset, the sum<br />

of the present value of the lease payments receivable from the<br />

lessee plus the guaranteed residual value (which is generally the<br />

exercise price of the purchase option of the lessee at the end of<br />

the lease term) is recognised as lending to third parties and is<br />

therefore included under “Loans and Receivables” in the<br />

consolidated balance sheet.<br />

When the consolidated entities act as lessees, they present the<br />

cost of the leased assets in the consolidated balance sheet<br />

according to the nature of the asset forming the subject-matter of<br />

the contract and, simultaneously, recognise a liability for the same<br />

amount (which is the lower of the fair value of the leased asset and<br />

the sum of the present value of the lease payments to be made to<br />

the lessor plus, if appropriate, the exercise price of the purchase<br />

option). The depreciation policy for these assets is consistent with<br />

that for property, plant and equipment for own use.<br />

In both cases, the finance income and finance expense arising from<br />

these contracts is credited or debited, respectively, to the<br />

consolidated income statement so as to achieve a constant rate of<br />

return over the life of the lease contracts.<br />

ii. Operating leases<br />

In operating leases, ownership of the leased asset and substantially<br />

all the risks and rewards incidental thereto remain with the lessor.<br />

When the consolidated entities act as the lessors, they present the<br />

acquisition cost of the leased assets under “Tangible Assets” in the<br />

consolidated balance sheet. The depreciation policy for these<br />

assets is consistent with that for similar property, plant and<br />

equipment for own use, and income from operating leases is<br />

recognised in the consolidated income statement on a straight-line<br />

basis.<br />

When the consolidated entities act as lessees, lease expenses,<br />

including any incentives granted by the lessor, are charged to the<br />

consolidated income statement on a straight-line basis.<br />

k) Intangible assets<br />

Intangible assets are identifiable non-monetary assets (separable<br />

from other assets) without physical substance (including customer<br />

lists, patents, leasehold assignment rights, computer software, etc.)<br />

which arise as a result of a legal transaction or which are developed<br />

internally by the consolidated entities. Only intangible assets<br />

whose cost can be estimated reliably and from which the<br />

consolidated entities consider it probable that future economic<br />

benefits will be generated are recognised.<br />

Intangible assets are recognised initially at acquisition or<br />

production cost and are subsequently measured at cost less any<br />

accumulated amortisation and any accumulated impairment losses.<br />

Intangible assets can have an indefinite useful life -when, based on<br />

an analysis of all the relevant factors, it is concluded that there is<br />

no foreseeable limit to the period over which the asset is expected<br />

to generate net cash inflows for the consolidated entities- or a<br />

finite useful life, in all other cases.<br />

Intangible assets with indefinite useful lives are not amortised, but<br />

rather at the end of each reporting period the consolidated<br />

entities review the remaining useful lives of the assets in order to<br />

109


110<br />

determine whether they continue to be indefinite and, if this is not<br />

the case, to take the appropriate steps. Intangible assets with finite<br />

useful lives are amortised over those useful lives using methods<br />

similar to those used to depreciate tangible assets.<br />

The intangible asset amortisation charge is recognised under<br />

“Depreciation and Amortisation - Intangible Assets” in the<br />

consolidated income statement.<br />

In both cases the consolidated entities recognise any impairment<br />

loss on the carrying amount of these assets with a charge to<br />

“Impairment Losses on Other Assets - Goodwill and Other<br />

Intangible Assets” in the consolidated income statement. The<br />

criteria used to recognise the impairment losses on these assets<br />

and, where applicable, the reversal of impairment losses recognised<br />

in prior years are similar to those used for tangible assets<br />

Internally developed computer software<br />

The costs of internally developed computer software are<br />

recognised as an intangible asset if, among other requisites<br />

(basically the capacity to be used or sold), the software can be<br />

identified and its ability to generate future economic benefits can<br />

be demonstrated. These assets are amortised over three years.<br />

Expenditure on research activities is recognised as an expense in<br />

the year in which it is incurred and cannot be subsequently<br />

capitalised..<br />

l) Tax assets<br />

“Tax Assets” in the consolidated balance sheet includes the<br />

amount of all the assets of a tax nature, distinguishing between:<br />

“Current” (amounts of tax to be recovered within the next twelve<br />

months) and “Deferred” (amounts of tax to be recovered in future<br />

years, including those arising from tax loss and tax credit<br />

carryforwards).<br />

m) Other assets and Other liabilities<br />

“Other Assets” in the consolidated balance sheet includes the<br />

amount of assets not recorded in other items, which relate<br />

basically to the following:<br />

- Inventories: this item includes the amount of assets, other than<br />

financial instruments, that are held for sale in the ordinary<br />

course of business, that are in the process of production,<br />

construction or development for such purpose, or that are to<br />

be consumed in the production process or in the provision of<br />

services. Inventories are measured at the lower of cost and net<br />

realisable value at year-end, which is the estimated selling price<br />

of the inventories in the ordinary course of business, less the<br />

estimated costs of completion and the estimated costs<br />

required to make the sale. Any impairment losses are<br />

recognised as adjustments for the year in which the impairment<br />

or loss occurs. Subsequent reversals are recognised in the<br />

consolidated income statement for the year in which they<br />

occur.<br />

- Prepayments and accrued income, excluding accrued interest,<br />

which is recognised in the same item as the financial<br />

instruments giving rise to it.<br />

- Other: the amount of guarantees provided mainly as a result of<br />

operations in organised markets and the amount of other<br />

assets not included in other items.<br />

“Other Liabilities” includes the payment obligations having the<br />

substance of financial liabilities not included in any other category<br />

and accrued expenses and deferred income.<br />

o) Provisions and contingent liabilities<br />

Provisions are present obligations arising from past events which<br />

are clearly specified as to their nature at the reporting date but are<br />

uncertain as to their amount or settlement date. The settlement of<br />

these obligations on maturity will foreseeably give rise to an<br />

outflow of cash embodying economic benefits for the Group.<br />

Contingent liabilities are possible obligations that arise from past<br />

events and whose existence will be confirmed only by the<br />

occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more future events not<br />

wholly within the control of the Group. They include present<br />

obligations of the Group when it is not probable that an outflow of<br />

cash resources embodying economic benefits will be required to<br />

settle them or when their amount cannot be quantified in a<br />

sufficiently reliable manner.<br />

The consolidated financial statements include all the material<br />

provisions with respect to which it is considered that it is more<br />

likely than not that the obligation will have to be settled.<br />

Contingent liabilities are not recognised in the consolidated<br />

financial statements, but rather are disclosed in the notes to the<br />

financial statements.<br />

Provisions, which are quantified on the basis of the best<br />

information available on the consequences of the event giving rise<br />

to them and are reviewed and adjusted at the end of each year, are<br />

used to cater for the specific obligations for which they were<br />

originally recognised. Provisions are fully or partially reversed when<br />

such obligations cease to exist or are reduced.<br />

Provisions are classified according to the obligations covered as<br />

follows<br />

- Provisions for contingent liabilities and commitments and other<br />

provisions: includes the amount of the provisions made to<br />

cover contingent liabilities, which are defined as transactions in<br />

which the Group guarantees the obligations of a third party,<br />

arising as a result of financial guarantees granted or contracts<br />

of another kind, and contingent commitments, which are<br />

defined as irrevocable commitments that may give rise to the<br />

recognition of financial assets; and the amount of other<br />

provisions made by the consolidated entities.<br />

- Provisions for pensions and similar obligations: includes the<br />

amount of all the provisions made to cover post-employment<br />

benefits, including commitments to early retirees and similar<br />

obligations.


p) Litigation and/or claims in process<br />

In addition to the disclosures made in Note 1, at the end of 2008<br />

certain litigation and claims were in process against the<br />

consolidated entities arising from the ordinary course of their<br />

operations. The Group's legal advisers and directors consider that<br />

the economic loss, if any, that may derive from litigation and claims<br />

will not have a material effect on the consolidated financial<br />

statements (see Note 22).<br />

q) Foreign currency transactions<br />

i. Functional currency<br />

The Group's functional currency is the euro. Therefore, all balances<br />

and transactions denominated in currencies other than the euro<br />

are deemed to be denominated in “foreign currency”.<br />

The equivalent euro value of the total assets and liabilities<br />

denominated in foreign currency held by the Group at 31<br />

December 2008 amounted to EUR 4,326,264 thousand and EUR<br />

5,947,715 thousand, respectively (EUR 2,511,004 thousand and<br />

EUR 5,153,034 thousand, respectively, at 31 December 2007).<br />

Approximately 79% of these amounts relate to US dollars and the<br />

remainder mostly to currencies quoted in the Spanish market.<br />

ii Translation of foreign currency balances<br />

Foreign currency balances are translated to euros in two<br />

consecutive stages:<br />

- Translation of foreign currency to the functional currency<br />

(currency of the main economic environment in which the<br />

Group operates), and<br />

- Translation to euros of the balances held in the functional<br />

currencies of entities whose functional currency is not the<br />

euro.<br />

Translation of foreign currency to the functional currency<br />

Foreign currency transactions performed by consolidated<br />

entities not located in EMU countries are initially recognised in<br />

their respective currencies. Monetary assets and liabilities in<br />

foreign currency are subsequently translated to their functional<br />

currencies using the closing rate, which is defined as the<br />

average spot exchange rate prevailing at the date of the<br />

consolidated financial statements.<br />

Furthermore:<br />

- Non-monetary items measured at historical cost are<br />

translated to the functional currency at the exchange rate<br />

at the date of acquisition.<br />

- Non-monetary items measured at fair value are translated<br />

at the exchange rate on the date when the fair value was<br />

determined.<br />

- Income and expenses are translated at the exchange rate<br />

on the transaction date or using the average exchange rate<br />

for the period for all the transactions performed during the<br />

year.<br />

- The balances arising from non-hedging forward foreign<br />

currency/foreign currency and foreign currency/euro<br />

purchase and sale transactions are translated at the closing<br />

rates prevailing in the forward foreign currency market for<br />

the related maturity<br />

Translation of functional currencies to euros<br />

If the functional currency is not the same as the reporting<br />

currency, the debit and credit balances denominated in the<br />

functional currency are translated to the reporting currency as<br />

follows:<br />

- Assets and liabilities, at the average exchange rate<br />

prevailing on the Spanish spot foreign exchange market at<br />

year-end.<br />

- Income and expenses, at the exchange rate on the<br />

transaction date or using an average exchange rate for the<br />

period for all the transactions performed during the year.<br />

- Equity items, at the historical exchange rates.<br />

iii Recognition of exchange differences<br />

The exchange differences arising on the translation of foreign<br />

currency balances to the functional currency are generally<br />

recognised in the consolidated income statement.<br />

The exchange differences arising on the translation to euros of the<br />

financial statements in functional currencies other than the euro<br />

are recognised under “Valuation Adjustments - Exchange<br />

Differences” in the consolidated balance sheet until the related<br />

item is derecognised, when they are recognised in profit or loss.<br />

r) Own equity instruments<br />

Own equity instruments are those meeting both of the following<br />

conditions:<br />

- The instruments do not include any contractual obligation for<br />

the issuer: (i) to deliver cash or another financial asset to a<br />

third party; or (ii) to exchange financial assets or financial<br />

liabilities with a third party under conditions that are<br />

potentially unfavourable to the issuer.<br />

- The instruments will or may be settled in the issuer's own<br />

equity instruments and are: (i) a non-derivative that includes<br />

no contractual obligation for the issuer to deliver a variable<br />

number of its own equity instruments; or (ii) a derivative that<br />

will be settled by the issuer through the exchange of a fixed<br />

amount of cash or another financial asset for a fixed number of<br />

its own equity instruments.<br />

Transactions involving own equity instruments, including their<br />

issuance and cancellation, are deducted directly from equity.<br />

Changes in the value of instruments classified as own equity<br />

instruments are not recognised in the consolidated financial<br />

statements. Consideration received or paid in exchange for such<br />

instruments is directly added to or deducted from equity<br />

111


112<br />

s) Recognition of inc


the consolidated income statement the amount resulting from<br />

deferring over five years the net amount of the cumulative actuarial<br />

gains and/or losses not recognised at the beginning of the year<br />

which exceeds 10% of the present value of the obligations or 10%<br />

of the fair value of the plan assets at the beginning of the year,<br />

whichever amount is higher.<br />

Post-employment benefits are recognised in the consolidated<br />

income statement as follows:<br />

- Current service cost, i.e. the increase in the present value of<br />

the obligations resulting from employee service in the current<br />

period, under “Administrative Expenses - Personnel Expenses”.<br />

- Interest cost, i.e. the increase during the year in the present<br />

value of the obligations as a result of the passage of time,<br />

under “Interest Expense and Similar Charges”.<br />

- The expected return on plan assets and the gains or losses on<br />

the value of the plan assets, less any plan administration costs<br />

and less any applicable taxes, under “Interest and Similar<br />

Income”.<br />

- The actuarial gains and losses calculated in accordance with<br />

the corridor approach are recognised under “Provisions (Net)”,<br />

unless the Entity opts to recognise them directly in equity.<br />

ii. Defined contribution plans<br />

The ordinary and extraordinary contributions made in this<br />

connection in each year are recognised under “Personnel<br />

Expenses” and “Provisions (Net)”, respectively, in the consolidated<br />

income statement. The amounts not yet contributed at each yearend<br />

are recognised, at their present value, under “Provisions -<br />

Provisions for Pensions and Similar Obligations” on the liability<br />

side of the consolidated balance sheet.<br />

In 2008 the Group contributed EUR 8,521 thousand to defined<br />

contribution plans (EUR 1,026 thousand in 2007; see Note 41).<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, there were no accrued<br />

contributions to be made in this connection.<br />

w) Other long-term employee benefits<br />

Commitments to early retirees -defined as those who have ceased<br />

to render services at the entity but who, without being legally<br />

retired, continue to have economic rights vis-à-vis the entity until<br />

they acquire the legal status of retiree-, long-service bonuses,<br />

commitments for death of spouse or disability before retirement<br />

that depend on the employee's length of service at the entity and<br />

other similar items are treated for accounting purposes, where<br />

applicable, as established above for defined benefit postemployment<br />

plans, except that all past service costs and actuarial<br />

gains and losses are recognised immediately in the consolidated<br />

income statement.<br />

x) Transactions involving payments based on equity<br />

instrumentsl<br />

Equity instruments delivered to employees in consideration for<br />

their services, if the instruments are delivered once the specific<br />

period of service has ended, are recognised as an expense for<br />

services (with the corresponding increase in equity) in the period<br />

the services are rendered by employees. At the grant date the<br />

services received (and the related increase in equity) are measured<br />

at the fair value of the equity instruments granted.<br />

When the requirements stipulated in the remuneration agreement<br />

include external market conditions (such as equity instruments<br />

reaching a certain price), the amount ultimately to be recognised<br />

in equity will depend on the other conditions being satisfied by the<br />

employees, irrespective of whether the market conditions are<br />

satisfied. If the conditions of the agreement are met but the<br />

external market conditions are not satisfied, the amounts<br />

previously recognised in equity are not reversed, even if the<br />

employees do not exercise their right to receive the equity<br />

instruments.<br />

y) Termination benefits<br />

Under current legislation, the Spanish entities are required to pay<br />

termination benefits to employees terminated without just cause.<br />

There are no redundancy plans making it necessary to record a<br />

provision in this connection.<br />

z) Income tax<br />

The current income tax expense is recognised in the consolidated<br />

income statement, except when it results from a transaction<br />

recognised directly in equity, in which case the related tax effect is<br />

also recognised in equity, or from a business combination in which<br />

the related deferred tax is recognised as one of its assets or<br />

liabilities.<br />

The current income tax expense is calculated as the tax payable<br />

with respect to the taxable profit for the year, adjusted for the<br />

amount of the changes in the year arising from temporary<br />

differences, tax credits and other tax benefits and prior years’ tax<br />

loss carryforwards effectively used in 2008.<br />

Deferred tax assets and liabilities include the temporary differences<br />

arising from the different bases used for accounting and tax<br />

purposes to measure the assets, liabilities and certain of the<br />

entity’s own equity instruments, insofar as they have an impact on<br />

the future tax charge.<br />

Temporary differences are classified as: taxable temporary<br />

differences, which will give rise to larger amounts of tax to be paid<br />

or smaller amounts of tax to be refunded in future years; and<br />

deductible temporary differences, which will give rise to smaller<br />

amounts of tax to be refunded in future years.<br />

113


114<br />

Deferred tax assets (deductible temporary differences, the right to<br />

offset tax losses in future years, unused tax credits and other<br />

unused tax benefits) are only recognised to the extent that it is<br />

probable that the Group will have sufficient future taxable profits<br />

against which these assets can be utilised.<br />

Deferred tax liabilities are always recognised except when goodwill<br />

is recognised or they arise in accounting for investments in<br />

subsidiaries or associates or interests in joint ventures where the<br />

investor is able to control the timing of the reversal of the<br />

temporary difference and, in addition, it is probable that the<br />

temporary difference will not reverse in the future. Notwithstanding<br />

the foregoing, deferred tax assets and liabilities are not recognised<br />

if they arise from the initial recognition of an asset or liability other<br />

than a business combination that at the time of recognition affects<br />

neither accounting profit nor taxable profit.<br />

The deferred tax assets and liabilities recognised and unrecognised<br />

are reassessed at year-end either in order to ascertain whether<br />

they still exist, and the appropriate adjustments are made on the<br />

basis of the findings of the analyses performed (see Note 23), or<br />

in order to recognise any deferred tax asset not previously<br />

recognised, provided that it is probable that the Group will have<br />

sufficient future taxable profit against which the deferred tax asset<br />

can be utilised.<br />

Income and expenses recognised directly in equity are accounted<br />

for as temporary differences.<br />

aa) Consolidated cash flow statements<br />

The following terms are used in the consolidated cash flow<br />

statements with the meanings specified:<br />

- Cash flows: inflows and outflows of cash and cash equivalents,<br />

which are short-term, highly liquid investments that are subject<br />

to an insignificant risk of changes in value<br />

- Operating activities: the principal revenue-producing activities<br />

of credit institutions and other activities that are not investing<br />

or financing activities.<br />

- Investing activities: the acquisition and disposal of long-term<br />

assets and other investments not included in cash and cash<br />

equivalents.<br />

- Financing activities: activities that result in changes in the size<br />

and composition of the equity and liabilities that are not<br />

operating activities.<br />

In preparing the consolidated cash flow statement, short-term<br />

highly liquid investments that are subject to an insignificant risk of<br />

changes in value were classified as “cash and cash equivalents”.<br />

Accordingly, the Group classifies as cash and cash equivalents the<br />

balances recognised under “Cash and Balances with Central Banks”<br />

in the consolidated balance sheet and the cash balances<br />

recognised under “Loans and Advances to Credit Institutions”.<br />

ab) Consolidated statement of changes in equity<br />

The consolidated statement of changes in equity presented in<br />

these consolidated financial statements shows the total changes in<br />

consolidated equity in the year. This information is in turn<br />

presented in two statements: the consolidated statement of<br />

recognised income and expense and the consolidated statement of<br />

total changes in equity. The main characteristics of the information<br />

contained in the two parts of the statement are explained below::<br />

Consolidated statement of recognised income and expense<br />

This part of the consolidated statement of changes in equity<br />

presents the income and expenses generated by the Group as a<br />

result of its business activity in the year, and a distinction is made<br />

between the income and expenses recognised in the consolidated<br />

income statement for the year and the other income and expenses<br />

recognised, in accordance with current regulations, directly in<br />

consolidated equity.<br />

Accordingly, this statement presents:<br />

a) Consolidated profit for the year.<br />

b) The net amount of the income and expenses recognised<br />

temporarily in consolidated equity under “Valuation<br />

Adjustments”.<br />

c) The net amount of the income and expenses recognised<br />

definitively in consolidated equity.<br />

d) The income tax incurred by the items indicated in b) and c)<br />

above, except for the valuation adjustments arising from<br />

investments in associates or jointly controlled entities<br />

accounted for using the equity method, which are presented<br />

net.<br />

e) Total consolidated recognised income and expense, calculated<br />

as the sum of the items in a) to d) above, presenting<br />

separately the amount attributable to the Parent and the<br />

amount relating to minority interests.<br />

The amount of the income and expenses relating to entities<br />

accounted for using the equity method recognised directly in<br />

equity is presented in this statement, irrespective of its nature,<br />

under “Entities Accounted for Using the Equity Method”.<br />

The detail of the changes in income and expenses recognised in<br />

equity under “Valuation Adjustments” is as follows:<br />

a) Revaluation gains/(losses): includes the amount of the<br />

income, net of the expenses incurred in the year, recognised<br />

directly in consolidated equity. The amounts recognised<br />

under this line item in the year remain there, even if in the<br />

same year they are transferred to the consolidated income<br />

statement, to the initial carrying amount of other assets or<br />

liabilities or are reclassified to another line item.


) Amounts transferred to income statement: includes the<br />

amount of the revaluation gains and losses previously<br />

recognised in consolidated equity, albeit in the same year,<br />

which are recognised in the consolidated income statement.<br />

c) Amount transferred to the initial carrying amount of<br />

hedged items: : includes the amount of the revaluation gains<br />

and losses previously recognised in consolidated equity, albeit<br />

in the same year, which are recognised at the initial carrying<br />

amount of the assets or liabilities as a result of cash flow<br />

hedges<br />

d) Other reclassifications: includes the amount of the transfers<br />

made in the year between valuation adjustment items in<br />

accordance with current regulations.<br />

The amounts of these items are presented gross and, except as<br />

indicated above for the items relating to valuation adjustments of<br />

entities accounted for using the equity method, the related tax<br />

effect is recognised in this statement under “Income Tax”.<br />

Consolidated statement of total changes in equity<br />

This part of the consolidated statement of changes in equity<br />

includes all the changes in equity, including those due to changes<br />

in accounting policy and those made to correct errors.<br />

Accordingly, this statement presents a reconciliation of the<br />

carrying amount at the beginning and end of the year of all the<br />

consolidated equity items, and the changes made are grouped<br />

together on the basis of their nature into the following items:<br />

a) Adjustments due to changes in accounting policy and<br />

adjustments made to correct errors: include the changes in<br />

consolidated equity arising as a result of the retrospective<br />

restatement of the balances in the consolidated financial<br />

statements due to changes in accounting policy or to the<br />

correction of errors.<br />

b) Income and expense recognised in the year: includes, in<br />

aggregate form, the total of the aforementioned items<br />

recognised in the consolidated statement of recognised<br />

income and expense.<br />

c) Other changes in equity: includes the remaining items<br />

recognised in equity, including, inter alia, increases and<br />

decreases in the endowment fund, distribution of profit,<br />

transactions involving own equity instruments, equityinstrument-based<br />

payments, transfers between equity items<br />

and any other increases or decreases in consolidated equity.<br />

115


116<br />

3. <strong>Banesto</strong> Group<br />

a) Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> is the parent of the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group. At 31 December<br />

2008, the Bank's assets represented substantially all the Group's<br />

consolidated assets; the Bank's equity represented 93.33% of the<br />

Group's equity, and the Bank's net profit for 2008 represented<br />

86.09% of the consolidated net profit for the year attributed to<br />

the Group.<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, the Bank conducted its business<br />

in Spain through 1,914 and 1,946 branch offices, respectively,<br />

located throughout the country and had 128 agents to which Bank<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S. A.<br />

Condensed balance sheets at 31 december 2008 and 2007<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

of Spain Circular 5/1995 was applicable (the detail is shown in<br />

Appendix V). As additional support for its international activities,<br />

the Bank also has one branch abroad and controls certain financial<br />

institutions which operate exclusively outside Spain.<br />

The Bank's condensed 2008 and 2007 balance sheets, income<br />

statements, statements of recognised income and expense,<br />

statements of total changes in equity and cash flow statements are<br />

as follows:<br />

ASSETS 2008 2007<br />

CASH AND BALANCES WITH CENTRAL BANKS 1,688,142 1,412,860<br />

FINANCIAL ASSETS HELD FOR TRADING 5,677,350 5,517,853<br />

OTHER FINANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE<br />

THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS - 504<br />

AVAILABLE-FOR-SALE FINANCIAL ASSETS 10,992,558 9,858,716<br />

LOANS AND RECEIVABLES 98,762,850 94,379,377<br />

HEDGING DERIVATIVES 1,196,011 537,621<br />

NON-CURRENT ASSETS HELD FOR SALE 355,821 92,902<br />

INVESTMENTS 659,720 766,071<br />

INSURANCE CONTRACTS LINKED TO PENSIONS 1,496,732 1,500,282<br />

TANGIBLE ASSETS 1,111,582 1,081,599<br />

INTANGIBLE ASSETS 55,981 44,231<br />

TAX ASSETS 879,866 1,048,619<br />

OTHER ASSETS 297,601 83,362<br />

TOTAL ASSETS 123,174,214 116,323,997<br />

Memorandum items:<br />

Contingent liabilities 11,026,642 11,993,742<br />

Contingent commitments 16,904,405 16,961,201


Banco Español de Crédito, S. A.<br />

Condensed balance sheets at 31 december 2008 and 2007<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

LIABILITIES AND EQUITY 2008 2007<br />

LIABILITIES<br />

FINANCIAL LIABILITIES HELD FOR TRADING 4,447,440 3,499,984<br />

FINANCIAL LIABILITIES AT AMORTISED COST 109,658,146 104,675,980<br />

CHANGES IN THE FAIR VALUE OF HEDGED ITEMS<br />

IN PORTFOLIO HEDGES OF INTEREST RATE RISK 440,136 (516,725)<br />

HEDGING DERIVATIVES 577,261 1,090,740<br />

PROVISIONS 2,477,127 2,563,792<br />

TAX LIABILITIES 347,751 17,382<br />

OTHER LIABILITIES 454,979 587,033<br />

TOTAL LIABILITIES 118,402,840 111,918,186<br />

EQUITY<br />

VALUATION ADJUSTMENTS 39,625 (151,275)<br />

SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY 4,731,749 4,557,086<br />

TOTAL EQUITY 4,771,374 4,405,811<br />

TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY 123,174,214 116,323,997<br />

117


118<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S. A.<br />

Condensed income statements For the years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Income/(Expenses)<br />

2008 2007<br />

INTEREST AND SIMILAR INCOME 5,638,283 4,715,105<br />

INTEREST EXPENSE AND SIMILAR CHARGES (4,091,918) (3,351,986)<br />

NET INTEREST INCOME 1,546,365 1,363,119<br />

INCOME FROM EQUITY INSTRUMENTS 79,676 85,976<br />

FEE AND COMMISSION INCOME 681,680 686,075<br />

FEE AND COMMISSION EXPENSE (114,498) (116,866)<br />

GAINS/LOSSES ON FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES (net) 57,405 45,595<br />

EXCHANGE DIFFERENCES (net) 40,329 35,005<br />

OTHER OPERATING INCOME 27,041 41,140<br />

OTHER OPERATING EXPENSES (55,974) (61,589)<br />

GROSS INCOME 2,262,024 2,078,455<br />

ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES (866,348) (837,483)<br />

DEPRECIATION AND AMORTISATION (101,879) (94,268)<br />

PROVISIONS (net) 3,527 (438)<br />

IMPAIRMENT LOSSES ON FINANCIAL ASSETS (net) (349,957) (224,924)<br />

PROFIT FROM OPERATIONS 947,369 921,341<br />

IMPAIRMENT LOSSES ON OTHER ASSETS (net) (5,438) (3,908)<br />

GAINS/LOSSES ON DISPOSAL OF ASSETS NOT CLASSIFIED<br />

AS NON-CURRENT ASSETS HELD-FOR SALE 7,481 37,970<br />

GAINS/LOSSES ON DISPOSAL OF NON-CURRENT ASSETS HELD-FOR SALE<br />

NOT CLASSIFIED AS DISCONTINUED OPERATIONS (2,233) 762<br />

PROFIT BEFORE TAX 947,179 956,165<br />

INCOME TAX (275,791) (295,879)<br />

PROFIT FROM ORDINARY ACTIVITIES 671,388 660,286<br />

PROFIT FOR THE YEAR 671,388 660,286


Banco Español de Crédito, S. A.<br />

Condensed statement of changes in equity<br />

Condensed statements of recognised income and expense For the years ended 31<br />

december 2008 and 2007<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

RPROFIT FOR THE YEAR 671,388 660,286<br />

OTROS INGRESOS Y GASTOS RECONOCIDOS 190,900 (102,927)<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets 1,721 (75,053)<br />

Cash flow hedges 264,657 (79,193)<br />

Income tax (75,478) 51,319<br />

TOTAL INCOME AND EXPENSES FOR THE YEAR 862,288 557,359<br />

119


120<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S. A.<br />

Condensed statement of changes in equity<br />

Condensed statements of total changes in equity<br />

For the years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY<br />

Other Less: Profit Less: Total<br />

Share Equity Treasur for the Dividends and Shareholders Valuation Total<br />

Capital Premium Reserves Instruments Shares Year Remuneration Equity Adjustments Equity<br />

Balance at 01/01/07 548,521 - 2,421,468 - - 1,487,484 (312,449) 4,145,024 (48,348) 4,096,676<br />

Total recognised income/(expenses) - - - - - 660,286 - 660,286 (102,927) 557,359<br />

Other changes in equity - - 1,174,992 1,778 - (1,487,484) 62,490 (248,224) (102,927) (248,224)<br />

Balance at 31/12/07 548,521 - 3,596,460 1,778 - 660,286 (249,959) 4,557,086 (151,275) 4,405,811<br />

Total recognised income/(expenses) - - - - - 671,388 - 671,388 190,900 862,288<br />

Other changes in equity (5,485) - 193,070 (1,778) - (660,286) (22,246) (496,725) - (496,725)<br />

Balance at 31/12/08 543,036 - 3,789,530 - - 671,388 (272,205) 4,731,749 39,625 4,771,374


Banco Español de Crédito, S. A.<br />

Condensed cash flow statements For the years ended 31 december 2008 and 2007<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

A. CASH FLOWS FROM OPERATING ACTIVITIES 1,221,867 (2,187,674)<br />

Profit for the year 671,388 660,286<br />

Adjustments made to obtain the cash flows from operating activities:<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 101,879 94,268<br />

Other adjustments 620,914 500,946<br />

Net increase/decrease in operating assets:<br />

Financial assets held for trading- 159,497 (103,544)<br />

Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss (504) 504<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets- 1,134,795 (245,215)<br />

Loans and receivables- 4,466,549 9,424,235<br />

Other operating assets 156,095 429,367<br />

Net increase/decrease in operating liabilities:<br />

Cartera de negociación- 1,011,221 371,587<br />

Financial liabilities at amortised cost- 5,531,382 5,416,357<br />

Other operating liabilities- (997,940) 1,105,446<br />

Collections/Payments income tax (132,823) (831,217)<br />

B. CASH FLOWS FROM INVESTING ACTIVITIES (335,943) 3,609,020<br />

Payments<br />

Tangible assets (275,341) (482,578)<br />

Intangible assets (45,710) (34,516)<br />

Investments (86,094) (74,036)<br />

Other payments related to operating activities (214,239) -<br />

Collections<br />

Tangible assets 167,948 185,404<br />

Investments 117,494 57,225<br />

Held-to-maturity investments - 3,812,302<br />

Other collections relating to investing activities - 145,219<br />

C. NET CASH FLOWS FROM FINANCING ACTIVITIES (360,935) (355,167)<br />

Payments<br />

Dividends (403,656) (249,959)<br />

Subordinated liabilities (500,000) (106,850)<br />

Redemption of own equity instruments (5,485) -<br />

Other payments related to financing activities (63,560) -<br />

Collections<br />

Subordinated liabilities 611,766 -<br />

Other collections related to financing activities - 1,642<br />

D. EFFECT OF CHANGES IN EXCHANGE RATES (3,779) 3,033<br />

E. NET INCREASE/DECREASE IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS (A+B+C+D) 521,210 1,069,212<br />

F. CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT BEGINNING OF YEAR 1,795,498 726,286<br />

G. CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT END OF YEAR<br />

MEMORANDUM ITEMS<br />

COMPONENTS OF CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT END OF YEAR<br />

2,316,708 1,795,498<br />

Cash 263,062 258,478<br />

Cash equivalents at central banks 1,425,080 1,154,382<br />

Other financial assets 628,566 382,638<br />

TOTAL CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT END OF YEAR 2,316,708 1,795,498<br />

121


122<br />

b) Group structure<br />

The salient changes and events in the Group in relation to its<br />

scope of consolidation in 2008 and 2007 were as follows:<br />

2008<br />

1. Promodomus Desarrollo de Activos, S.L.<br />

On 6 June 2008, Intursa, S.A. and Dudebasa, S.A. acquired<br />

3,599 shares and 1 share, respectively, of Global Marhabat,<br />

S.L. for EUR 3,600. At the Annual General Meeting of Global<br />

Marhabat, S.L. on 6 June 2008, the shareholders resolved to<br />

change its name to Promodomus Desarrollo de Activos, S.L.<br />

On 11 July 2008, Intursa, S.A. acquired the shareholding of<br />

Dudebasa, S.A. and approved a capital increase of EUR 1,996<br />

thousand at Global Marhabat, S.L. through the issue of<br />

1,996,400 shares of EUR 1 par value each, 980,000 of<br />

which were subscribed and paid by Reyal Urbis, S.A. after<br />

Intursa, S.A., which subscribed and paid for the remaining<br />

1,016,400 shares, waived its pre-emptive subscription rights.<br />

2. Cambios Sol, S.A.<br />

On 31 July 2008, Hualle, S.A. and Dudebasa, S.A. sold their<br />

shareholding (50,093 and 1 shares, respectively) in Cambio<br />

Sol, S.A., which constituted all of the company’s share capital,<br />

to Moneygram Payment Systems Inc. for EUR 2,905<br />

thousand.<br />

3. Liquidation of Proyecto Europa, S.A.<br />

On 3 June 2008, Banco Español de Crédito, S.A., as the sole<br />

shareholder of the Company, approved the dissolution and<br />

simultaneous liquidation thereof since there were no<br />

creditors. This dissolution was registered in the Mercantile<br />

Register on 29 July 2008<br />

4. Distribution of the Bank's profit and<br />

Earnings per share<br />

a) Distribution of the Bank's profit<br />

The distribution of the Bank's net profit for 2008 that the Board<br />

of Directors will propose for approval by the shareholders at the<br />

Annual General Meeting is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Dividends 384,936<br />

Voluntary reserves 286,452<br />

Net profit for the year 671,388<br />

4. Sale of Desarrollo Informático, S.A<br />

On 14 October 2008, the Bank sold 2,768,838 shares of<br />

Desarrollo Informático, S.A. which constituted all of its share<br />

capital to Suministros, Importaciones y Mantenimientos<br />

Electrónicos, S.A. and Imesapi, S.A., who acquired 2,768,831<br />

and 7 shares, respectively, for EUR 1,800 thousand.<br />

5. Liquidation of <strong>Banesto</strong> Delaware Inc. in October 2008.<br />

6. Liquidation of <strong>Banesto</strong> Isuances Ltd in November 2008.<br />

7. Change in the name of Larix Ltd to Larix Spain S.L. and<br />

relocation of its registered office from the Isle of Man to<br />

Spain..<br />

2007<br />

1. Absorption of Corporación Industrial y Financiera de <strong>Banesto</strong>,<br />

S.A. by Banco Español de de Crédito, S.A.<br />

2. Absorption of Grupo Golf del Sur, S.A.U., Aparcamientos y<br />

Construcciones, S.A.U. and Inmobiliaria Laukariz, S.A.U. by<br />

Elerco, S.A.<br />

3 .Absorption of Crinaria, S.A.U., Deposoltenegolf, S.A.U. and<br />

B2C Escaparate, S.L. by Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

4. Disposal of Ingeniería de Software Bancario, S.L.<br />

5. Liquidation of <strong>Banesto</strong> e-Business, S.A.U.<br />

6. Liquidation of <strong>Banesto</strong> Finance, Ltd.<br />

At its meetings on 22 July, 6 October and 17 December 2008, the<br />

Board of Directors of the Bank resolved to distribute three interim<br />

dividends out of 2008 profit, of EUR 0.132 per share each, for a<br />

total of EUR 272,205 thousand. The dividend declared at the<br />

Board of Directors Meeting on 17 December 2008 will be paid on<br />

2 February 2009 and, accordingly, it is recognised under “Other<br />

Financial Liabilities” on the liability side of the accompanying<br />

consolidated balance sheet (see Note 21).<br />

The provisional accounting statements prepared on each of the<br />

dates indicated below by the Board of Directors of Banco Español<br />

de Crédito, S.A., pursuant to Article 216 of the Consolidated<br />

Companies Law, to evidence the existence of sufficient liquidity for<br />

the distribution of the interim dividends are as follows:


At their meeting on 20 January 2009, the Bank’s Board of<br />

Directors agreed to submit for approval by the shareholders’ at the<br />

Annual General Meeting a final dividend of EUR 0.164 per share,<br />

for a total of EUR 112,731 thousand, which will be paid out on 4<br />

May 2009.<br />

b) Earnings per share<br />

Thousands of Euross<br />

22-07-2008 6-10-2008 17-12-2008<br />

Profit before tax at 30 November, 30<br />

September and 30 June 2008 (*) 557,638 838,764 1,001,099<br />

Less:<br />

Estimated income tax (149,928) (219,447) (277,039)<br />

Dividends paid - (90,735) (181,470)<br />

Liquidity 407,710 528,582 542,590<br />

Interim dividend to be distributed (90,735) (90,735) (90,735)<br />

Gross dividend per share (euros) 0,132 0,132 0,132<br />

Date of payment 1-8-08 3-11-08 2-2-09<br />

(*) The latest balance sheet at the date of each Board of Directors meeting.,<br />

i. Basic earnings per share<br />

Basic earnings per share are calculated by dividing the net profit or<br />

loss attributable to the Group by the weighted average number of<br />

ordinary shares outstanding during the year, excluding the average<br />

number of treasury shares held in the year.<br />

Accordingly:<br />

2008 2007<br />

Net profit for the year attributed to the Parent (thousands of euros) 779,844 764,567<br />

Net profit for the year from ordinary activity attributed to the<br />

Parent (thousands of euros) 779,844 764,567<br />

Weighted average number of shares outstanding 685,211,431 692,523,374<br />

Basic earnings per share (euros)<br />

Of net profit for the year 1.14 1.10<br />

Of net profit from ordinary activities 1.14 1.10<br />

ii. Diluted earnings per share<br />

In calculating diluted earnings per share, the amount of profit<br />

attributable to ordinary shareholders and the weighted average<br />

number of shares outstanding, net of treasury shares, are adjusted<br />

to take into account all the dilutive effects inherent to potential<br />

ordinary shares (share options, warrants and convertible debt<br />

instruments).<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, the Group had no issues<br />

outstanding of debt instruments convertible into Bank shares or<br />

conferring privileges or rights which might, due to any contingency,<br />

make them convertible into shares. The Bank's share-based<br />

incentive plans outstanding at 31 December 2008 and 2007 (see<br />

Note 41) have a dilutive effect on the earnings per share equal to<br />

an increase of 245,907 and 531,206 shares, respectively.<br />

Accordingly, 2008 and 2007 diluted earnings per share were<br />

calculated as follows:<br />

2008 2007<br />

Net profit for the year attributed to the Parent<br />

(in thousands of euros) 779.844 764.567<br />

Dilutive effect of changes in profit for the year arising from<br />

potential conversion of ordinary shares 779.844 764.567<br />

Weighted average number of shares outstanding 685.211.431 692.523.374<br />

Dilutive effect of:<br />

Share options 245,907 531,206<br />

Adjusted average number of shares for the calculation 685,457,338 693,054,580<br />

Diluted earnings per share (euros) 1.14 1.10<br />

123


124<br />

5. Remuneration and other benefits paid<br />

to the Bank's directors and senior<br />

executives<br />

a) Remuneration of directors<br />

Following is an individualised detail of the remuneration earned in<br />

2008 and 2007 by the Bank's directors, in their capacity as such,<br />

in respect of the by-law-stipulated share of profits and attendance<br />

The foregoing table shows the amounts earned in 2008 by<br />

Federico Outón del Moral and Isabel Polanco Moreno, who at 31<br />

December 2008 were not members of the Board, and who have<br />

earned attendance fees for the meetings that they attended and all<br />

other remuneration to which they are entitled in proportion to the<br />

amount of time served by them as members the Board.<br />

The other members of the Bank's Board of Directors did not<br />

receive any remuneration.<br />

At the Bank's Annual General Meeting on 28 February 2006 the<br />

shareholders approved a medium- to long-term Incentive Plan to<br />

grant options on shares of Banco Santander, S. A. to the<br />

beneficiaries and, if the terms of the plan are met, shares of Banco<br />

Español de Crédito, S.A. will be delivered to the senior executives<br />

and an amount in cash will be paid to the other beneficiaries.<br />

fees corresponding to them for the supervisory and decisionmaking<br />

functions discharged as members of the Board of Directors,<br />

in accordance with Article 27 of the bylaws:<br />

2008 2007<br />

Bylaw-Stipulated Directors’ Emoluments Attendance Fees<br />

Audit and Other<br />

Executive Compliance Risk Attendance<br />

Directors Board Committee Committee Committee Board Fees Total Total<br />

José Antonio García Cantera 59,400 26,100 - - 13,500 ,- 99,000 102,500<br />

Víctor Manuel<br />

Menéndez Millán 59,400 26,100 26,100 - 12,000 13,500 137,100 149,500<br />

José María Nus Badia 59,400 26,100 - 26,100 13,500 - 125,100 131,500<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers 59,400 26,100 - 26,100 13,500 - 125,100 131,500<br />

Federico Outón del Moral 34,650 - - - 6,000 - 40,650 79,500<br />

Isabel Polanco Moreno 14,850 - - - 1,500 - 16,350 76,500<br />

Rafael del Pino y<br />

Calvo-Sotelo 59,400 - - - 10,500 - 69,900 78,000<br />

Francisco Daurella Franco 59,400 - - - 9,000 - 68,400 76,500<br />

José Luis López Combarros 59,400 - 37,650 - 13,500 13,500 124,050 142,500<br />

Carlos Sabanza Teruel 59,400 26,100 - 26,100 13,500 - 125,100 137,500<br />

Carlos Pérez de Bricio<br />

Olariaga 24,750 - - - 3,000 - 27,750 -<br />

Belén Romana García 44,550 - 27,825 - 10,500 9,000 91,875 -<br />

Total 2008 594,000 130,500 91,575 78,300 120,000 36,000 1,050,375<br />

Total 2007 660,000 145,000 80,000 87,000 109,500 24,000 1,105,500<br />

EUROS<br />

As the terms of the Plan were met, the detail of the shares of<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. delivered to the members of the<br />

Board of Directors of the Bank is as follows:<br />

Medium-/long-term Incentive Plan:<br />

Number of Shares<br />

Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea 54,166<br />

José Antonio García Cantera 16,920<br />

Federico Outón del Moral 43,834<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers 26,015<br />

José María Fuster Van Bendegem 18,570<br />

José María Nus Badía<br />

(*) See Note 41.<br />

15,566<br />

175,071 (*)


The detail of the options on shares of Banco Santander, S.A.<br />

granted to members of the Board of Directors of the Bank, and the<br />

number of options exercised, is as follows:.<br />

On 27 June 2007, the Bank’s Extraordinary General Meeting<br />

approved an Incentive Plan which entails the delivery, if the terms<br />

of the plan are met, of shares of Banco Español de Crédito, S. A. to<br />

certain executives, including executive directors and senior<br />

executives (see Note 41).<br />

The maximum number of shares of Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

to be delivered, no later than 31 June 2010, to each of the<br />

executive directors who are beneficiaries of the Plan is as follows:<br />

Number Date of Date of Number<br />

of Exercise Commencemen Expiry of of<br />

Share Price of Exercise Exercise Options<br />

Options (Euros) Period Period Exercised<br />

Medium-/long-term Incentive Plan:<br />

Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea 293,692 9,09 2-3-2008 15-1-2009 -<br />

José Antonio García Cantera 91,743 9,09 2-3-2008 15-1-2009 91,743<br />

Federico Outón del Moral 237,672 9,09 2-3-2008 15-1-2009 237,672<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers 141,055 9,09 2-3-2008 15-1-2009 141,055<br />

osé María Fuster Van Bendegem 100,688 9,09 2-3-2008 15-1-2009 100,688<br />

José María Nus Badía 84,403<br />

949,253<br />

9,09 2-3-2008 15-1-2009 -<br />

Medium-/long-term Incentive Plan:<br />

Additionally, the aforementioned Extraordinary General Meeting<br />

approved the first cycle (2007-2008) and the second cycle<br />

(2007-2009) of the Target-Based Share Plan and the first cycle<br />

(2008-2010) of the Obligatory Investment Share Plan of Banco<br />

Santander, S.A., which entails the delivery, if the terms of the plans<br />

are met, of the following number of shares of Banco Santander, S.A.<br />

to Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea:<br />

Price Number<br />

(Euros per of Delivery<br />

Share) Shares Deadline<br />

First cycle of Target-Based Share Plan 13.46 (*) 27,929 31 de julio 2009<br />

Second cycle of Target-Based Share Plan 13.46 (*) 41,835 31 de julio 2010<br />

First cycle of Obligatory Investment Share Plan (**) 13,610 1 de abril 2011<br />

(*) Average market price of the shares of Banco Santander, S.A. weighted by daily volume in the 15 trading days prior to 7 May 2007.<br />

(**) The obligatory investment had an average price of EUR 11.80 per share.<br />

Maximum Number of Shares<br />

Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea 22,798<br />

José Antonio García Cantera 39,729<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers 37,457<br />

José María Nus Badía 20,148<br />

120,132<br />

125


126<br />

b) Remuneration of executive directors and senior executives<br />

The detail of the remuneration of the Bank's executive directors<br />

and senior executives in 2008 and 2007, including the fixed<br />

remuneration in 2008 and 2007 and the variable remuneration<br />

recognised in income for those years is as follows::<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Salary<br />

Number of Other<br />

Year Persons Fixed Variable Total Remuneration Total<br />

2007 15 6,356 7,072 13,428 56 13,484<br />

2008 16 6,300 6,909 13,209 5,621 18,830<br />

The figures in the foregoing table include the amounts, by item,<br />

corresponding to Ana P. Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea, José<br />

Antonio García Cantera, Juan Delibes Liniers, José María Fuster Van<br />

Bendegem and José María Nus Badía for the provision of services<br />

other than those of directors, pursuant to the last paragraph of<br />

Article 27 of the bylaws. Bank of Spain Circular 4/2004 only<br />

requires that the remuneration received by the executive directors<br />

be indicated in aggregate form, together with the remuneration of<br />

the other senior executives, as shown in the foregoing table.<br />

However, set forth below are the individualised amounts<br />

corresponding to the executive directors at 31 December 2008 for<br />

the provision of services other than the supervisory and decisionmaking<br />

functions discharged by them in their capacity as directors:<br />

2008<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2007<br />

Salary<br />

Fixed Variable Total<br />

Other<br />

Remuneration Total Total<br />

Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea 1,269 1,786 3,055 613 3,668 3,123<br />

José Antonio García Cantera 704 756 1,460 762 2,222 1,447<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers 573 769 1,342 910 2,252 1,333<br />

José María Nus Badía 484 414 898 176 1,074 885<br />

Total 2008 3,030 3,725 6,755 2,461 9,216<br />

Total 2007 2,764 4,008 6,772 16 6,788<br />

The foregoing tables include, under other remuneration, the<br />

income arising from the delivery of shares of Español de Crédito,<br />

S.A. the exercise of options on shares of Banco Santander, S.A. and<br />

the amounts received in cash under the Plan approved by the<br />

shareholders at the Annual General Meeting of 28 February 2006.<br />

As beneficiaries of the Plan, non-director executives exercised a<br />

total of 348,668 options on Banco Santander, S.A. shares and in<br />

2008 they received a total of 70,836 Banco Español de Crédito,<br />

S.A. (see Note 41) shares and EUR 514 thousand in cash.<br />

The maximum number of shares of Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

to be delivered to the non-director executives who are beneficiaries<br />

of the Incentive Plan approved by the Extraordinary General<br />

Meeting of the Bank on 27 June 2007 is 150,113 shares (see Note<br />

41).<br />

Following is a detail explaining the changes in the remuneration of<br />

executive directors, by item, in relation to the Bank’s profit and<br />

share price (Article 25.2 of the Regulations governing the Bank’s<br />

Board of Directors):


c) Pension, insurance and other obligations<br />

The actuarial liability recognised in connection with postemployment<br />

benefits earned by current and former senior<br />

executives and directors of the Bank amounted to approximately<br />

EUR 43,005 thousand at 2008 year-end (EUR 42,824 thousand<br />

at 31 December 2007). Approximately EUR 3,018 thousand were<br />

The capital guaranteed by life insurance policies for executive<br />

directors amounted to EUR 4,174 thousand and EUR 3,854<br />

thousand at 31 December 2008 and 2007, respectively..<br />

d) Loans<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, the direct risk exposure to<br />

directors of the Bank amounted to EUR 206 thousand and EUR<br />

256 thousand, respectively.<br />

e) Termination benefits<br />

The executive directors have indefinite-term employment contracts.<br />

However, executive directors whose contracts are terminated<br />

voluntarily or due to breach of duties are not entitled to receive<br />

any economic compensation. If the contracts are terminated for<br />

reasons attributable to the Bank or due to objective circumstances<br />

(such as those affecting the executive directors' functional and<br />

organic statute), the directors will be entitled, at the date of<br />

termination of their employment relationships with the Bank, to<br />

the following:<br />

1) In the case of Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O'Shea,<br />

to receive a termination benefit of up to five years' annual<br />

fixed salary payments, as established in the related contract,<br />

based on the date on which the contract is terminated.<br />

2) In the case of José Antonio García Cantera, to receive a<br />

termination benefit of two years’ annual fixed salary<br />

payments, as established in the related contract.<br />

3) In the case of Juan Delibes Liniers, to receive a termination<br />

benefit equal to half of 80% of the annual fixed salary<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Overall remuneration of executive directors for the<br />

supervisory and decision-making functions discharged by them<br />

Overall remuneration of executive directors for functions discharged by them other than<br />

349 366<br />

those discharged in their capacity as directors 9,217 7,457<br />

Total remuneration of executive directors 9,566 7,823<br />

Profit attributed to the Group 779,844 764,567<br />

Change in share price (39,3%) (20,6%)<br />

charged to the income statement in this connection in 2008 (EUR<br />

3,083 thousand in 2007).<br />

The following table details the defined benefit pension obligations<br />

to executive directors at 31 December 2008 and 2007:<br />

Euros<br />

Vested Obligations<br />

2008 2007<br />

Ana Patricia Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O’Shea 21,736,799 17,975,347<br />

José Antonio García Cantera 2,396,917 1,612,304<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers 8,598,210 8,031,893<br />

José María Nus Badía 5,193,608 1,701,960<br />

multiplied by the number of years of recognised service in the<br />

banking industry, as established in the related contract.<br />

4) In the case of José María Nus Badía, to receive a termination<br />

benefit of EUR 811,366.<br />

In all cases these amounts are incompatible with the receipt of any<br />

other pension supplement.<br />

Additionally, other members of the Bank's senior management have<br />

contracts which entitle them to receive benefits in the event of<br />

termination for reasons other than voluntary redundancy,<br />

retirement, disability or serious breach of duties. These benefits<br />

are only recognised as personnel expenses when the employment<br />

relationship between the Bank and its directors is terminated<br />

before the normal retirement date.<br />

f) Detail of the directors' investments in companies with similar<br />

business activities and performance by directors, as<br />

independent professionals or as employees, of similar<br />

activities<br />

Pursuant to Article 127 ter.4 of the Spanish Companies Law, in<br />

order to reinforce the transparency of listed companies, set forth<br />

below are the ownership interests held by the members of the<br />

Board of the Directors in entities whose company object is to<br />

engage in: (i) banking, financing or lending; (ii) insurance; (iii)<br />

management of collective investment undertakings; or (iv)<br />

securities brokerage; and the management or executive functions, if<br />

any, that the directors discharge thereat:<br />

127


128<br />

Director Corporate Name Line of Business % of Ownership Functions<br />

Ana P. Botín-Sanz de Sautuola y O’Shea Banco Santander, S.A. Banking 0.113 Director<br />

Assicurazioni Generali, S.P.A. Insurance - Director<br />

Santander Investment Services, S.A. Banking - Director<br />

Banco Santander de Negocios Portugal Banking - Director<br />

Matías Rodríguez Inciarte Banco Santander, S.A. Banking 0.011 Third Deputy Chairman<br />

and Executive Director<br />

Rafael del Pino Calvo-Sotelo Pactio Gestión, SGIIC, S.A. CIU management company 22.30 -<br />

Banco Pastor, S.A. Banking 1.12 -<br />

The Blackstone Group Internacional Ltd. Investments Member of the European<br />

Advisory Board<br />

David Arce Torres Banco Santander, S.A. Banking 0.022 General Managerl<br />

Juan Delibes Liniers Santander Seguros<br />

y Reaseguros, Cía. Aseguradora, S.A. Insurance - Director<br />

Víctor Manuel Menéndez Millán Banco Santander, S.A. Banking 0.019 -<br />

BBVA Banking 0.012 -<br />

José Luis Lopez Combarros Bankinter, S.A. Banking 0.006 -<br />

Corporación Mapfre, S.A. Insurance 0.002 -<br />

Francisco Daurella Franco Banco Vitalicio de España, S.A. Insurance - Director<br />

Carlos Sabanza Teruel Banco Santander, S.A. Banking 0.006 -<br />

José María Fuster Van Bendegem Banco Santander, S.A. Banking - General Managerl<br />

Abbey National Bank Banking - Directoro<br />

Sistemas 4B, S.A. Means of payment - Director<br />

Certain members of the Board of Directors hold ownership<br />

interests of less than 0.001% in the following listed companies:<br />

BBVA, Allianz, Banco Popular and Banco Santander.<br />

None of the members of the Board of Directors perform,<br />

as independent professionals or as employees, activities similar to<br />

those detailed above. Additionally, as required by Article 114.2 of<br />

the Securities Market Law, it is hereby stated that in 2008 and<br />

2007 the Bank's directors did not perform, either on their own<br />

behalf or through an intermediary, any transaction with the Bank or<br />

with other Group companies other than those conducted in the<br />

ordinary course of operations or on an arm's length basis


6. Loans and advances to credit<br />

institutions<br />

The breakdown, by classification, type and currency of the<br />

transaction, of the balances of “Loans and Advances to Credit<br />

Institutions” on the asset side of the consolidated balance sheets<br />

is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Classification:<br />

Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss 1,793,839 905,291<br />

Loans and receivables 19,700,685 19,118,526<br />

21,494,524 20,023,817<br />

Type:<br />

Reciprocal accounts 165 2,118<br />

Time deposits 9,951,882 4,776,284<br />

Reverse repurchase agreements 8,737,545 13,600,703<br />

Other 2,468,039 1,518,918<br />

21,157,631 19,898,023<br />

Add- Valuation adjustments 336,893 125,794<br />

Of which:<br />

Accrued interest 335,943 125,811<br />

Impairment losses (1) (99)<br />

Other 951 82<br />

21,494,524 20,023,817<br />

Currency:<br />

Euro 19,468,799 19,386,801<br />

Foreign currencies 2,025,725 637,016<br />

21,494,524 20,023,817<br />

The impairment losses on financial assets classified as loans and<br />

receivables are disclosed in Note 10.<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these assets<br />

at 2008 year-end and of the average interest rates in 2008.<br />

129


130<br />

7. Debt instruments<br />

The breakdown, by classification, type and currency, of the<br />

balances of “Debt Instruments” on the asset side of the<br />

consolidated balance sheets is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Classification:<br />

Financial assets held for trading 402,154 781,542<br />

Other assets at fair value through profit or loss 253,887 285,474<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets 6,620,409 5,605,166<br />

Loans and receivables 736,239 526,160<br />

8,012,689 7,198,342<br />

Type:<br />

Spanish government debt securities-<br />

Treasury bills 163,291 444,509<br />

Government bonds 4,363,750 2,997,930<br />

Accrued interest 24,368 20,725<br />

Foreign government debt securities 137,632 311,769<br />

Issued by financial institutions 1,353,576 1,556,464<br />

Other fixed-income securities 1,986,373 1,881,207<br />

8,028,990 7,212,594<br />

Valuation adjustments (16,301) (14,252)<br />

Of which:<br />

Impairment losses (16,301) (14,252)<br />

8,012,689 7,198,342<br />

Currency:<br />

Euro 7,958,682 7,141,617<br />

Foreign currencies 54,007 56,725<br />

8,012,689 7,198,342<br />

At 31 December 2008, the nominal amount of debt instruments<br />

assigned to certain Group or third-party commitments amounted<br />

to approximately EUR 10,660 thousand (EUR 10,660 thousand at<br />

31 December 2007).<br />

The impairment losses on available-for-sale financial assets are<br />

disclosed in Note 8-d.<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these assets<br />

at 2008 year-end and of the average interest rates in 2008.


8. Other equity instruments<br />

a) Breakdown<br />

The breakdown, by currency, classification and type, of the balance<br />

of “Other Equity Instruments” in the consolidated balance sheets<br />

is as follows:<br />

b) Acquisitions and disposals<br />

The main acquisitions and disposals effected in 2008 and 2007<br />

relate to changes in financial assets held for trading and to<br />

purchases and sales of investment fund units and shares.<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Currency:<br />

Euro 726,667 2,282,157<br />

Foreign currencies 11,938 20,152<br />

738,605 2,302,309<br />

Classification:<br />

Financial assets held for trading 472,996 1,636,069<br />

Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss 143,436 301,493<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets 122,173 364,747<br />

738,605 2,302,309<br />

Type:<br />

Shares of Spanish companies 466,937 1,634,591<br />

Shares of foreign companies 61,432 261,020<br />

Investment fund units and shares 72,413 109,624<br />

Other securities 143,436 301,493<br />

744,218 2,306,728<br />

Less- Impairment losses (5,613) (4,419)<br />

738,605 2,302,309<br />

c) Notifications of acquisitions of holdings<br />

The notifications made by the Bank, in compliance with Article 86<br />

of the Spanish Companies Law and Article 53 of Securities Market<br />

Law 24/1988, of the acquisition and sale of holdings in investees<br />

are listed in Appendix IV.<br />

d) Impairment losses<br />

Following is a summary of the changes in the impairment losses in<br />

the foregoing table and those on debt instruments classified as<br />

available-for-sale (see Note 7) in 2008 and 2007::<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Balance at beginning of year 18,671 15,439<br />

Impairment losses charged to income for the year 2,123 4,725<br />

Other changes 1,120 (1,493)<br />

Balance at end of year 21,914 18,671<br />

131


132<br />

9. Trading derivatives<br />

(assets and liabilities)<br />

The detail, by type of inherent risk, of the fair value of the trading<br />

derivatives arranged by the Group at 31 December 2008 and<br />

2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2088 2007<br />

Balance Balance Balance Balance<br />

Receivable Payable Receivable Payable<br />

Interest rate risk 2,325,533 2,289,170 940,529 1,049,146<br />

Currency risk 370,139 322,882 167,815 289,545<br />

Price risk 1,460,110 1,249,750 812,742 1,190,061<br />

Credit risk 51,575 50,463 (2,483) 3,266<br />

Other 1,308 1,308 269,593 1<br />

4,208,665 3,913,573 2,188,196 2,532,019


10. Loans and advances to customers<br />

The detail, by loan type and status, borrower sector, geographical<br />

area of residence and interest rate formula, of the balance of<br />

“Loans and Advances to Customers” on the asset side of the<br />

consolidated balance sheets is as follows::<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these assets<br />

at 2008 year-end and of the average interest rates in 2008.<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, there were no loans and<br />

advances to customers for material amounts without fixed maturity<br />

dates.<br />

In 2008 and 2007 the Bank securitised loans in its portfolio<br />

amounting to approximately EUR 4,300 million and EUR 2,750<br />

million. All the securities issued were subscribed by securitisation<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

By loan type and status:<br />

Commercial credit 5,905,809 6,939,383<br />

Secured loans 37,614,501 37,788,047<br />

Reverse repurchase agreements 4,873,678 2,953,070<br />

Personal loans 14,842,798 12,512,504<br />

Credit accounts 7,489,257 9,735,996<br />

Other term loans 2,258,037 1,589,018<br />

Finance leases 2,271,165 2,162,650<br />

Receivable on demand and other 1,398,485 1,037,536<br />

Impaired assets 1,396,085 398,460<br />

Other 988,800 983,020<br />

79,038,615 76,099,684<br />

Less: Valuation adjustments (1,265,952) (1,032,649)<br />

Of which:<br />

Prepayments and accrued income and other adjustment 151,668 206,118<br />

Impairment losses (1,417,620) (1,238,767)<br />

77,772,663 75,067,035<br />

By borrower sector:<br />

Public sector - Spain 1,466,929 975,419<br />

Other resident sectors 72,233,071 70,478,261<br />

Non-residents 4,072,663 3,613,355<br />

77,772,663 75,067,035<br />

By geographical area:<br />

Spain 75,730,528 72,882,332<br />

European Union (excluding Spain) 1,934,819 2,115,630<br />

United States and Puerto Rico 258,507 102,053<br />

Other OECD countries 481,402 347,169<br />

Latin America 425,328 511,516<br />

Rest of the world 208,031 140,984<br />

79,038,615 76,099,684<br />

By interest rate formula<br />

Fixed interest rate 21,129,858 19,961,030<br />

Floating interest rate 57,908,757 56,138,654<br />

79,038,615 76,099,684<br />

vehicles set up by Santander de Titulización, Sociedad Gestora de<br />

Fondos de Titulización, S.A. This securitisation did not give rise to<br />

the derecognition of the loans from the balance sheet (see Note<br />

2-c).<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, outstanding securitisation bonds<br />

issued by these SPVs (the total face value of which amounted to<br />

EUR 523,887 thousand and EUR 714,745 thousand, respectively)<br />

were owned by the Group.<br />

133


134<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, the Group had recognised loans<br />

amounting to EUR 24,149 thousand and EUR 29,338 thousand,<br />

respectively, relating to the financing granted to its employees for<br />

the acquisition of shares of the Bank and of Banco Santander, S.A.<br />

In addition, the Bank has in certain cases financed acquisitions of<br />

its own shares by third parties, and has granted loans to third<br />

parties secured by shares of the Bank or of Banco Santander, S.A.<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, these financing and guarantee<br />

arrangements, net of the related impairment losses, amounted to<br />

EUR 1,732 thousand and EUR 1,844 thousand, respectively, and a<br />

restricted reserve was recorded for the carrying amount thereof,<br />

net of the related impairment losses, where appropriate, as<br />

required by Articles 75, 79, 80 and 81 of the Consolidated<br />

Companies Law (see Note 28).<br />

Impairment losses<br />

The changes in 2008 and 2007 in the balance of the impairment<br />

losses in the foregoing table and of those on “Loans and<br />

Receivables - Loans and Advances to Credit Institutions” (see Note<br />

6) were as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Balances at beginning of year 1,238,866 1,092,713<br />

Impairment losses charged to income for the year<br />

Individually assessed 393,998 133,630<br />

Collectively assessed 10,693 156,801<br />

Impairment losses reversed with a credit to income (72,491) (18,516)<br />

Net impairment losses for the year 332,200 271,915<br />

Net write-off of impaired balances and other changes (153,445) (125,762)<br />

Balances at end of year 1,417,621 1,238,866<br />

By method of assessment:<br />

Individually 486,883 156,846<br />

Collectively 930,738 1,082,020<br />

Written-off loans recovered in 2008 amounted to EUR 32,401<br />

thousand (EUR 42,941 thousand in 2007), and this amount is<br />

presented as a reduction of the balance of “Impairment Losses on<br />

Financial Assets - Loans and Receivables” in the consolidated<br />

income statements.<br />

Impaired assets<br />

Following is a detail of the financial assets classified as loans and<br />

receivables and considered to be impaired due to credit risk at 31<br />

December 2008, and of the assets which, although not considered<br />

to be impaired, include any past-due amount at that date, classified<br />

by age of the oldest past-due amount:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

With Balances Past Due by<br />

Up to 6 Months 6 to 12 12 to 18 18 to 24 More than 24<br />

Months Months Months Months Total<br />

699,455 340,548 115,074 20,982 220,026 1,396,085<br />

Of this amount, 99.1% related to residents in Spain..


11. Hedging derivatives<br />

The detail, by type of risk hedged, of the fair value of the<br />

derivatives qualifying for hedge accounting is as follows:<br />

Cash flow hedges are used to reduce the cash flow fluctuations<br />

(attributable to the interest rate) generated by the hedged items<br />

(loans and receivables tied to a floating interest rate). These<br />

hedges use interest rate derivatives to convert the floating interest<br />

rate on the loans and receivables to a fixed interest rate.<br />

In 2007 the Bank arranged a fair value hedge of the interest rate<br />

risk of a portfolio of financial instruments. The purpose of the<br />

hedge is to maintain the economic value of the hedged assets,<br />

which are fixed-interest marketable debt securities with original<br />

maturities at long term, hedged mainly by IRSs<br />

12. Investments<br />

This heading includes equity instruments issued by associates<br />

owned by the Bank.<br />

Associates are entities over which the Caja is in a position to<br />

exercise significant influence, but not control or joint control,<br />

usually because it holds 20% or more of the voting power of the<br />

investee.<br />

Appendix III contains a detail of the investments in associates,<br />

indicating the percentage of direct and indirect ownership and<br />

other relevant information.<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Assets Liabilities Assets Liabilities<br />

Fair value hedges<br />

Micro-hedges 58,450 177,036 67,662 79,781<br />

Portfolio hedges 866,721 337,296 398,143 826,178<br />

Cash flow hedges 269,678 62,759 71,547 184,657<br />

Of which:<br />

Recognised in equity (Note 25 - 90,115 - (100,868)<br />

1,194,849 577,091 537,352 1,090,616<br />

The changes in 2008 and 2007 in the balance of “Investments” in<br />

the consolidated balance sheets were as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Balance at beginning of year 16,258 29,142<br />

Purchases and capital increases - 18<br />

Ventas y reducciones de capital - (166)<br />

Exchange differences and other 464 (12,736)<br />

Balance at end of year 16,722 16,258<br />

Following is a summary of the financial information on the<br />

associates (obtained from the information available at the<br />

reporting date):<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Total assets 371.238 295.772<br />

Total liabilities (268.662) (235.543)<br />

Net assets 102.576 60.229<br />

Group's share of the net assets<br />

of associates 23.027 16.685<br />

Total income 210.103 139.822<br />

Total profit 52.909 6.649<br />

Group's share of the profit<br />

Group's share of the profit of associates 1.874 1.707<br />

135


136<br />

13. Liabilities under insurance contracts<br />

and Reinsurance assets<br />

The breakdown of the balances of “Liabilities under Insurance<br />

Contracts” in the consolidated balance sheets at 31 December<br />

2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Direct Inward Direct Inward<br />

Technical provisions for: Insurance Reinsurance Total Insurance Reinsurance Total<br />

Unearned premiums and unexpired risks 110,920 65,910 176,830 82,121 43,380 125,501<br />

Life insurance:<br />

Unearned premiums and risks 85,112 9,316 94,428 32,390 8,603 40,993<br />

Mathematical provisions 797,630 - 797,630 478,290 - 478,290<br />

Claims 112,723 15,644 128,367 93,831 9,429 103,260<br />

Bonuses and rebates 4,881 2,315 7,196 4,674 4,538 9,212<br />

Life insurance policies where the investment<br />

risk is borne by the policyholders 2,181,312 - 2,181,312 1,424,557 - 1,424,557<br />

Other technical provisions - 49,866 49,866 12,912 31,863 44,775<br />

3,292,578 143,051 3,435,629 2,128,775 97,813 2,226,588<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, the consolidated insurance<br />

entities had balances receivable from reinsurance companies<br />

amounting to EUR 199,411 thousand and EUR 121,162 thousand,<br />

respectively, which are recognised under “Reinsurance Assets” in<br />

the consolidated balance sheets..


14. Tangible assets and Non-current<br />

assets held for sale<br />

Tangible assets<br />

a) Changes<br />

The changes in 2008 and 2007 in the balance of “Tangible<br />

Assets” in the consolidated balance sheets were as follows<br />

Cost:<br />

Direct write-downs due to the impairment of tangible assets<br />

amounted to EUR 7,199 thousand in 2008 (EUR 1,732 thousand<br />

in 2007). .<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Property,<br />

Plant and<br />

Equipment Investment<br />

for Own Use Property Total<br />

Balances at 1 January 2007 1,451,734 71,911 1,523,645<br />

Additions 503,648 3,661 507,309<br />

Disposals (267,104) (165) (267,269)<br />

Exchange differences (net) 4 (135) (131)<br />

Transfers and other 7,661 (35) 7,626<br />

Balances at 31 December 2007 1,695,943 75,237 1,771,180<br />

Additions 273,828 5,076 278,904<br />

Disposals (300,070) (81) (300,151)<br />

Exchange differences (net) 41 (4) 37<br />

Transfers and other (138) - (138)<br />

Balances at 31 December 2008 1,669,604 80,228 1,749,832<br />

Accumulated depreciation:<br />

Balances at 1 January 2007 573,665 3,713 577,378<br />

Disposals (83,138) (13) (83,151)<br />

Charge for the year 74,427 353 74,780<br />

Exchange differences, transfers and other 2,901 - 2,901<br />

Balances at 31 December 2007 567,855 4,053 571,908<br />

Disposals (130,557) (47) (130,604)<br />

Charge for the year 77,872 413 78,285<br />

Exchange differences (520) - (520)<br />

Balances at 31 December 2008 514,650 4,419 519,069<br />

Impairment losses:<br />

At 31 December 2007 - (5,376) (5,376)<br />

Amounts used and other net changes - 159 159<br />

Balance at 31 December 2008 - (5,217) (5,217)<br />

Tangible assets, net:<br />

Balances at 31 December 2007 1,128,088 65,808 1,193,896<br />

Balances at 31 December 2008 1,154,954 70,592 1,225,546<br />

b) Property, plant and equipment for own use<br />

The breakdown, by type of asset, of the balances of “Property,<br />

Plant and Equipment for Own Use” in the consolidated balance<br />

sheets at 31 December 2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

137


138<br />

Al 31 de diciembre de 2008 y 2007 el Grupo tenía contraídos At<br />

31 December 2008 and 2007, the Group had rights on assets<br />

used under finance leases amounting to EUR 20,821 thousand and<br />

EUR 19,166 thousand, respectively.<br />

c) Investment property<br />

In 2008 and 2007 the rental income earned from investment<br />

property owned by the consolidated entities amounted to<br />

approximately EUR 2,005 thousand and EUR 2,006 thousand,<br />

respectively, (see Note 40) while the operating expenses of all<br />

kinds related to such investment property amounted to<br />

approximately EUR 254 thousand (approximately EUR 256<br />

thousand in 2007).<br />

Non-current assets held for sale<br />

The breakdown of the balance of “Non-Current Assets Held for<br />

Sale” is as follows<br />

Accumulated<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Carrying<br />

Cost Depreciation Amount<br />

Buildings 791,840 132,893 658,947<br />

Furniture 103,616 76,426 27,190<br />

Fixtures 428,869 157,659 271,210<br />

Office and IT equipment 264,344 180,666 83,678<br />

Other 107,274 20,211 87,063<br />

Balances at 31 December 2007 1,695,943 567,855 1,128,088<br />

Land and buildings 820,776 147,474 673,302<br />

Furniture 103,540 73,390 30,150<br />

Fixtures 469,369 185,834 283,535<br />

Office and IT equipment 148,299 75,084 73,215<br />

Other 127,620 32,868 94,752<br />

Balances at 31 December 2008 1,669,604 514,650 1,154,954<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Investment property 1,192,331 -<br />

Foreclosed assets 363,728 102,615<br />

Assets recovered from finance leases 115 115<br />

1,556,174 102,730<br />

n 2008, the Bank and other Group companies acquired assets<br />

amounting to EUR 1,192 million with the aim of settling certain<br />

loan transactions.<br />

Impairment losses of EUR 110,548 thousand and EUR 42,738<br />

thousand were deducted from the balance of “Non-Current Assets<br />

Held for Sale” at 31 December 2008 and 2007, respectively. The<br />

net charges for 2008 amounted to EUR 28,258 thousand (net<br />

reversals amounted to EUR 1,629 thousand in 2007) and were<br />

recognised under “Gains/(Losses) on Non-Current Assets Held for<br />

Sale not classified as Discontinued Operations”. Also, the balance<br />

of this item in the income statement includes the net gain arising<br />

from the sale of these assets, which amounted to EUR 257<br />

thousand (EUR 12,562 thousand in 2007).<br />

The fair value of the non-current assets held for sale was estimated<br />

as follows:<br />

- The fair value of assets appraised by a valuer authorised by the<br />

Bank of Spain was deemed to be the value obtained from this<br />

appraisal pursuant to Ministerial Order 805/2003.<br />

- The fair value of the assets included in the foregoing table<br />

which were not appraised by a valuer authorised by the Bank of<br />

Spain was calculated based on estimates made by the Group,<br />

taking into account data from the mortgage market in relation<br />

to the changes in the price of tangible assets of similar<br />

characterstics to those of the Group.


15. Intangible assets<br />

a) Goodwill<br />

The balance of “Goodwill” at 31 December 2007 relates in full to<br />

Cambios Sol, S.A. The change in the balance thereof in 2008<br />

relates to the sale of the aforementioned company (see Note 3).<br />

b) Other intangible assets<br />

The breakdown of the balance of “Other Intangible Assets” in the<br />

consolidated balance sheets is as follows<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Estimated<br />

Useful Life 2008 2007<br />

With finite useful life:<br />

IT developments 3 years<br />

3 to<br />

111,936 166,212<br />

Concessions and other 50 years 4,405 6,963<br />

Less-<br />

116,341 173,175<br />

Accumulated amortisation (57,659)(125,109)<br />

Impairment losses (158) (162)<br />

Total, net 58,524 47,904<br />

16. Other assets and Other liabilities<br />

The breakdown of the balances of “Other Assets” and “Other<br />

Liabilities” in the consolidated balance sheets is as follows:<br />

Changes<br />

The changes (gross amounts) in “Other Intangible Assets” in the<br />

consolidated balance sheets in 2008 and 2007 were as follows:<br />

Cost:<br />

Thousands of Euross<br />

2008 2007<br />

Balance at beginning of year 173,175 150,104<br />

Net additions (disposals) (56,834) 23,071<br />

Balance at end of year 116,341 173,175<br />

Accumulated amortisation:<br />

Balances at beginning of year (125,109) (99,988)<br />

Net charges (24,032) (24,762)<br />

Disposals and other changes 91,482 (359)<br />

Balance at end of year (57,659) (125,109)<br />

Impairment losses<br />

Balances at beginning of year (162) (228)<br />

Net reversals 4 53<br />

Amounts used and other changes - 13<br />

Balance at end of year (158) (162)<br />

Net balance at end of year 58,524 47,904<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Assets Liabilities<br />

2008 2007 2008 2007<br />

Inventories 566,876 206,755 - -<br />

Guarantees on futures transactions and other 130,271 1 245 -<br />

Unmatured accrued income/expenses 128,553 70,991 263,740 124,425<br />

Prepayments 19,608 10,319 78,121 -<br />

Financial guarantees - - - 30,924<br />

Accrued expenses - - 196,901 205,849<br />

Other 119,186 81,500 9,435 352,114<br />

964,494 369,566 548,442 713,312<br />

139


140<br />

17. Deposits from central banks and<br />

Deposits from credit institutions<br />

The breakdown, by classification, counterparty, type and currency,<br />

of the balances of “Deposits from Central Banks” and “Deposits<br />

from Credit Institutions” on the liability side of the consolidated At<br />

31 December 2008 and 2007, the limit established by the Bank of<br />

Spain for the Group for the system of loans guaranteed by public<br />

debt securities and other assets amounted to EUR 3,468,931<br />

thousand and EUR 3,221,040 thousand, respectively. The amount<br />

drawn down at those dates corresponds to that recognised under<br />

“Central Banks” in the foregoing table.<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Classification:<br />

Financial liabilities at amortised<br />

cost 12,406,618 12,297,101<br />

Counterparty:<br />

Central banks 1,952,343 1,955,660<br />

Credit institutions 10,454,275 10,341,441<br />

12,406,618 12,297,101<br />

Type:<br />

Reciprocal accounts 825 1,332<br />

Time deposits 6,369,261 6,410,419<br />

Hybrid financial liabilities 2,150 2,150<br />

Repurchase agreements 5,272,125 5,455,534<br />

Other 609,668 365,711<br />

12,254,029 12,235,146<br />

Add- Valuation adjustments 152,589 61,955<br />

Of which::<br />

Accrued interest 152,426 62,090<br />

Other 163 (135)<br />

12,406,618 12,297,101<br />

Currency:<br />

Euro 9,705,371 11,867,818<br />

Foreign currencies 2,701,247 429,283<br />

12,406,618 12,297,101<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these<br />

liabilities at 2008 year-end and of the average interest rates in<br />

2008.<br />

18. Customer deposits<br />

The breakdown, by currency, classification and type, of the balance<br />

of “Customer Deposits” in the consolidated balance sheets is as<br />

follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Classification:<br />

Financial liabilities at amortised<br />

cost 57.589.628 52.747.448<br />

Type:<br />

On demand-<br />

Current accounts 13.543.773 13.775.479<br />

Savings accounts 6.204.063 5.709.310<br />

Other demand deposits 320.284 335.714<br />

Time deposits-<br />

Fixed-term deposits 17.718.068 11.970.654<br />

Home-purchase savings accounts 58.161 58.581<br />

Discount deposits 246 246<br />

Hybrid financial liabilities 3.853.773 4.047.098<br />

Other time deposits 12.824 460<br />

Repurchase agreements 15.671.107 16.642.048<br />

57.382.299 52.539.590<br />

Add- Valuation adjustments 207.329 207.858<br />

Of which:<br />

Accrued interest 208.747 144.080<br />

Other (1.418) 63.778<br />

Currency:<br />

57.589.628 52.747.448<br />

Euros 54.970.183 50.590.093<br />

Foreign currencies 2.619.445 2.157.355<br />

57.589.628 52.747.448<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these<br />

liabilities at 2008 year-end and of the average interest rates in<br />

2008.


19. Marketable debt securities<br />

a) Breakdow<br />

The breakdown, by classification and type, of the balance of<br />

“Marketable Debt Securities” in the consolidated balance sheets is<br />

as follows:<br />

Classification:<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these<br />

liabilities at 2008 year-end and of the average interest rates in<br />

2008.<br />

b) Bonds and debentures outstanding<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Financial liabilities at amortised cost 28,315,103 28,737,082<br />

Type:<br />

Bonds and debentures outstanding 5,894,424 8,434,905<br />

Hybrid securities 3,339,757 2,790,601<br />

Mortgage-backed bonds<br />

(“cédulas hipotecarias”) 14,917,885 14,958,239<br />

Promissory notes 2,602,478 498,034<br />

Other securities associated with<br />

transferred financial assets (Note 10) 716,457 1,298,597<br />

Mortgage bonds (Note 10) 435,450 367,057<br />

27,906,451 28,347,433<br />

Add- Valuation adjustments 408,652 389,649<br />

Of which:<br />

Accrued interest 437,002 406,306<br />

Adjustments due to hedges (28,350) (16,657)<br />

28,315,103 28,737,082<br />

The breakdown, by issue currency and interest rate, of the balance<br />

of “Bonds and Debentures Outstanding” in the foregoing table is<br />

as follows:<br />

Annual<br />

Thousands of Euros Interest Maturity<br />

Currency of Issue 2008 2007 Rate Date<br />

Euro:<br />

Non-convertible bonds issued by the Bank 1,000,000 2,500,000 3-month Euribor +0.12% Until June 2009<br />

Non-convertible bonds issued by <strong>Banesto</strong> Issuances, Ltd. - 1,000 6-month Euribor Until June 2008<br />

Non-convertible bonds issued by <strong>Banesto</strong> Banco de Emisiones, S.A. 1,000,000 1,000,000 3-month Euribor +0.05%<br />

3-month Euribor +<br />

February 2010<br />

Non-convertible bonds issued by <strong>Banesto</strong> Financial Products<br />

US dollar:<br />

Floating rate-<br />

3,660,897 2,896,000 floating spread February 2038<br />

Non-convertible bonds issued by the Bank 233,527 2,037,905 3-month Libor -0.01% Until April 2012<br />

Balance at end of year 5,894,424 8,434,905<br />

141


142<br />

c) Mortgage-backed bonds (cédulas hipotecarias)<br />

The breakdown, by currency of issue and interest rate, of the<br />

balance of “Mortgage-Backed Bonds” is as follows:<br />

Annual<br />

Thousands of Euros Interest Maturity<br />

Currency of Issue 2008 2007 Rate Date<br />

Euro:<br />

March 2002 issue 1,000,000 1,000,000 5.75% March 2017<br />

May 2003 issue 1,500,000 1,500,000 4% May 2010<br />

February 2004 issue 2,000,000 2,000,000 3.75% February 2011<br />

September 2004 issue 1,695,000 1,750,000 4.25% September 2014<br />

January 2005 issue 2,000,000 2,000,000 3.50% January 2015<br />

September 2005 issue 2,000,000 2,000,000 2.75% September 2012<br />

January 2006 issue 2,000,000 2,000,000 3.50% January 2016<br />

July 2006 issue 935,000 1,000,000 4.25% July 2013<br />

February 2007 issue 1,687,885 1,708,239 4.25% February 2014<br />

February 2008 issue 50,000 - 6-month Euribor +0.12% February 2010<br />

February 2008 issue 50,000 - 6-month Euribor +0.25% February 2013<br />

Balance at end of year 14,917,885 14,958,239<br />

Mortgage-backed bond issuers have an early redemption option<br />

solely for the purpose of complying with the limits on the volume<br />

of outstanding mortgage bonds stipulated by mortgage market<br />

regulations.


20. Subordinated liabilities<br />

a) Breakdown<br />

The detail, by currency of issue and interest rate, of the balance of<br />

“Subordinated Liabilities” in the consolidated balance sheets is as<br />

follows:<br />

b) Other disclosures<br />

For debt seniority purposes preference shares are junior to all<br />

general creditors and to subordinated deposits. The payment of<br />

dividends on these shares, which have no voting rights, depends on<br />

the obtainment of sufficient distributable profit and on the limits<br />

imposed by Spanish banking regulations on equity. If for these<br />

reasons remuneration is not paid on the preference shares, the<br />

Bank will not pay dividends on its ordinary shares. Subject to<br />

authorisation by the Bank of Spain, the issue launched by <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

Preferentes, S.A. can be redeemed as from December 2008 and<br />

the issues launched by the Bank can be redeemed as from<br />

November 2009 and April 2011.<br />

The other issues are subordinated and, therefore, for debt<br />

seniority purposes they are junior to all general creditors. The<br />

issues launched by subsidiaries are guaranteed by <strong>Banesto</strong> or by<br />

restricted deposits arranged at <strong>Banesto</strong> for this purpose.<br />

At 31 December 2008, no issues were convertible into shares of<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> or granted privileges or rights which, in certain<br />

circumstances, make them convertible them into shares.<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007 Currency Interest Rate/ Dividends Maturity<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.:<br />

Subordinated deposit 600,000 600,000 Euros 3-month Euribor + 0.32%,<br />

+0.5% from the fifth year<br />

June 2014<br />

Subordinated deposit 600,000 - Euros 3-month Euribor + 2.50% June 2018<br />

Preference shares Floating CMS + 0.125%<br />

(fixed coupon of 6% in the<br />

125,000 125,000 Euros first year) Perpetual<br />

Preference shares<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Banco Emisiones, S.A.:<br />

200,000 200,000 Euros Fixed coupon of 5.5% Perpetual<br />

September<br />

Subordinated debentures - 500,000 Euros 3-month Euribor + 0.4% 2013<br />

Subordinated debentures<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Preferentes, S.A.:<br />

500,000 500,000 Euros Mid IRS at one year + 0.6% March 2016<br />

Subordinated deposit<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Holding, Ltd.:<br />

131,145 131,145 Euros 3-month Euribor + 0,2% Perpetual<br />

Preference shares 51,684 52,452 Dólares 10.5% (a)<br />

2,207,829 2,108,597<br />

Add- Valuation adjustments<br />

Of which:<br />

29,006 16,383<br />

Accrued interest 32,120 21,357<br />

Hedge accounting (3,114) (4,974)<br />

Balance at end of year 2,236,835 2,124,980<br />

(a)Redeemable at the discretion of the issuer, with the prior consent of the Bank of Spain.<br />

The preference shares issued by <strong>Banesto</strong> Holding Ltd. relate to the<br />

issue launched in 1992 for USD 100 million and guaranteed by<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>. The preference shares do not carry voting rights, pay a<br />

fixed dividend of 10.5% per annum and are fully or partially<br />

redeemable at the discretion of the issuer, with the prior consent<br />

of the Bank of Spain. The outstanding balance at 31 December<br />

2008 amounted to EUR 51,684 thousand, equivalent to USD<br />

77,285,400 (31 December 2007: EUR 52,452 thousand<br />

equivalent to USD 77,285,400).<br />

The interest accrued on subordinated liabilities amounted to<br />

approximately EUR 121,350 thousand in 2008 (EUR 110,508<br />

thousand in 2007).<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these<br />

liabilities at 2008 year-end and of the average interest rates in<br />

2008.<br />

143


144<br />

21. Other financial liabilities<br />

The breakdown of the balances of “Other Financial Liabilities” in<br />

the consolidated balance sheets is as follows:<br />

Note 44 contains a detail of the terms to maturity of these<br />

financial liabilities at 2008 year-end.<br />

22. Provisions<br />

a) Breakdown<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Trade payables (*) 1,470,806 891,170<br />

Public sector 432,892 603,397<br />

Other 993,774 1,031,316<br />

2,897,472 2,525,883<br />

(*) Including EUR 90,735 thousand and EUR 83,320 thousand relating to the unpaid<br />

interim dividends declared by the Bank’s Board of Directors at 31 December 2008<br />

and 2007, respectively (see Note 4).<br />

The breakdown of the balance of “Provisions” in the consolidated<br />

balance sheets is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Provisions for pensions and similar<br />

obligations (Notes 2-v and 2-w) 2,215,208 2,301,205<br />

Provisions for contingent liabilities<br />

and commitments 102,092 115,923<br />

Other provisions 214,990 197,179<br />

Provisions 2,532,290 2,614,307<br />

b) Changes<br />

The changes in “Provisions” in 2008 and 2007 were as follows:<br />

c) Provisions for pensions and similar obligations<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Balance at beginning of year 2,614,307 2,779,391<br />

Period provision charged to income 121,656 94,814<br />

Of which:<br />

Finance expense (Note 34) 95,050 96,229<br />

Personnel expenses (Note 41) 12,658 15,256<br />

Additions to provisions 13,948 (16,671)<br />

Provisions for pensions and<br />

similar obligations 4,946 228<br />

Other provisions 9,002 (16,899)<br />

Payments to retired employees (84,214) (70,137)<br />

Payments to early retirees (122,807) (146,270)<br />

Insurance premiums paid (7,748) (6,199)<br />

Provisions used, exchange differences<br />

and other changes 11,096 (37,292)<br />

Balance at end of year 2,532,290 2,614,307<br />

The detail of the present value of the Group's post-employment<br />

benefit obligations at 31 December 2008 and 2007, showing the<br />

funding status of these obligations, the fair value of the plan assets<br />

funding them and the present value of the unrecognised<br />

obligations at those dates, is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Present value of the obligations:<br />

To current employees 361,885 343,421<br />

To retired employees (vested) 1,470,807 1,480,049<br />

1,832,692 1,823,470<br />

Fair value of plan assets 193,106 191,823<br />

Unrecognised actuarial losses 108,476 97,280<br />

Unrecognised past service cost 6,951 4,246<br />

Provisions - Provisions for pensions 1,276,134 1,272,488<br />

Insurance contracts linked to pensions 248,025 257,633<br />

1,832,692 1,823,470


Al 31 December 2006, 2005 y 2004, the present value of the<br />

obligations amounted to EUR 1,821,116 thousand, EUR<br />

1,829,954 thousand and EUR 1,824,719 thousand, respectively;<br />

the fair value of the plan assets amounted to EUR 203,244<br />

thousand, EUR 211,289 thousand and EUR 212,421 thousand,<br />

respectively; and the unrecognised actuarial losses amounted to<br />

EUR 73,245 thousand, EUR 80,387 thousand and EUR 77,338<br />

thousand, respectively.<br />

The amount of these obligations was determined by independent<br />

insurance actuaries using, under their own responsibility, the<br />

following valuation criteria, inter alia:<br />

1. Valuation method: projected unit credit method, which sees<br />

each period of service as giving rise to an additional unit of<br />

benefit entitlement and measures each unit separately<br />

2. Actuarial assumptions used: unbiased and mutually compatible.<br />

Specifically, the most significant actuarial assumptions used in<br />

the calculations were as follows:<br />

3. The estimated retirement age of each employee is the first at<br />

which the employee is entitled to retire or the agreed-upon age,<br />

as appropriate.<br />

The fair value of insurance contracts was determined as the<br />

amount of the mathematical provisions made by the related<br />

insurer, taking into account the following assumptions:<br />

The changes in 2008 and 2007 in the cumulative net<br />

unrecognised actuarial losses were as follows:<br />

2008 2007<br />

Discount rate 4% 4%<br />

Mortality tables PERM/F 2000 PERM/F 2000<br />

Cumulative annual CPI growth 1.5% 1.5%<br />

Annual salary increase rate 2.9% 2.9%<br />

Annual social security pension increase rate 1.5% 1.5%<br />

2008 2007<br />

Expected rate of return on plan assets 4.0% 4.0%<br />

Expected rate of return on reimbursement<br />

rights 4.0% 4.0%<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Balance at beginning of year 97,280 73,245<br />

Increases due to:<br />

Net actuarial losses arising in the year 11,196 24,035<br />

Balance at end of year 108,476 97,280<br />

d) Other long-term employee benefits<br />

In 2008 and 2007, <strong>Banesto</strong> offered certain employees the<br />

possibility of taking early retirement. Accordingly, provisions were<br />

made in both years to cover the obligations (in terms of both<br />

salaries and other employee welfare costs) to early retirees from<br />

the date of early retirement to the date of effective retirement,<br />

amounting to EUR 48,270 thousand and EUR 49,773 thousand,<br />

respectively.<br />

Additionally, at its meeting on 20 December 2006 the Board of<br />

Directors of the Bank approved an Extraordinary Early Retirements<br />

Plan that started in 2007 and ended in 2008. At 31 December<br />

2007, the provision recognised in this connection amounted to<br />

EUR 57,070 thousand and was assigned in full to the early<br />

retirement obligations in 2008.<br />

The present value of the obligations and the fair value of the plan<br />

assets and the reimbursement rights at 31 December 2008 and<br />

2007, were as follows:<br />

The amount of these obligations was determined by independent<br />

actuaries using, under their own responsibility, the same<br />

techniques as those applied to quantify defined benefit obligations<br />

(see Note 22-c).<br />

e) Other provisions<br />

The balance of “Provisions - Other Provisions”, which includes, inter<br />

alia, provisions for restructuring costs and tax and other litigation,<br />

was estimated using prudent calculation procedures in keeping<br />

with the uncertainty inherent in the obligations covered. The<br />

definitive date of the outflow of resources embodying economic<br />

benefits for the Group depends on each obligation; in certain<br />

cases, these obligations have no fixed settlement period and, in<br />

other cases, are based on litigation in progress.<br />

f) Litigation<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Present value of the obligations:<br />

To early retirees 687,853 710,703<br />

Long-service bonuses and other benefits 3,196 3,311<br />

Extraordinary Early Retirements Plan - 57,070<br />

691,049 771,084<br />

Provisions - Provisions for pensions 691,049 771,084<br />

691,049 771,084<br />

i. Tax litigation<br />

The main tax litigation affecting <strong>Banesto</strong> at 31 December 2008<br />

can be divided into two groups according to its origin: firstly, that<br />

arising from a difference in the criteria used by the State Tax<br />

Agency and that used by the Entity for the regularisation of the<br />

relevant taxes; and secondly, that arising from the introduction by<br />

the Extremadura Autonomous Community Government of the tax<br />

on deposits at credit institutions, against which an appeal has<br />

been filed at the Spanish Constitutional Court.<br />

145


146<br />

A) Difference in the criteria used by the State Tax Agency and the<br />

Bank.<br />

a) Litigation arising from the calculation of the VAT pro rata: the<br />

difference in the criteria used relates to the type of services<br />

which it is considered must be included in the VAT calculation.<br />

The amount relating to this litigation, for all the years, is<br />

approximately EUR 3,779 thousand.<br />

b) Withholdings from income from movable capital: the litigation<br />

arose from a difference in the criteria used for the inclusion of<br />

income from movable capital and the withholdings applicable<br />

to certain amounts paid by the Bank. The potential liability of<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> in this connection is approximately EUR 6,505<br />

thousand.<br />

B) Tax on deposits at credit institutions introduced by the<br />

Extremadura Autonomous Community Government.<br />

The Extremadura Autonomous Community Government approved a<br />

tax on the deposits held by credit institutions in its territory, which<br />

was applied for the first time in 2002.<br />

An appeal against the tax has been filed at the Spanish<br />

Constitutional Court. Consequently, the Bank files its returns in<br />

due time, challenges the self-assessment, posts a bond for the<br />

related amount and then files an appeal. The Extremadura High<br />

Court decided not to consider the merits of the case until the<br />

Constitutional Court hands down a decision on the<br />

unconstitutional nature or otherwise of the tax.<br />

The amount relating to this litigation totals EUR 20,004 thousand.<br />

The above amount includes the enforced collection surcharges<br />

that the Bank was unable to avoid, except the enforced collection<br />

surcharge for 2007, which had not yet been issued by the tax<br />

authorities.<br />

If the Spanish Constitutional Court were to declare that the<br />

legislation establishing this tax is constitutional, since the debt is<br />

suspended the late-payment interest would fall due. This interest<br />

amounted to EUR 2,769 thousand at 31 December 2008.<br />

ii. Other litigationl<br />

In addition to the challenges of corporate resolutions (see Note 1e),<br />

the main non-tax litigation affecting the Bank at 31 December<br />

2008, on the basis of the amount thereof, was as follows:<br />

− Trustees in the bankruptcy of Ágora, Corporación de<br />

Inversiones Inmobiliarias, S.A. The insolvency of this entity and<br />

the related bankruptcy order has given rise to several lawsuits<br />

and ancillary proceedings related mainly to the backdating of<br />

the bankruptcy order and, as a result thereof, the intention to<br />

terminate certain financing agreements and debt repayments.<br />

The most noteworthy in this respect is the claim to annul the<br />

collection of a debt of EUR 5,409 thousand received by the<br />

Bank in 1994.<br />

− Claims filed against the Bank by companies which received<br />

supplementary income tax returns from the tax authorities of<br />

the Navarra Autonomous Community Government with respect<br />

to transactions performed with the Bank. One of the two<br />

ongoing proceedings concluded with a firm court decision<br />

which dismissed in full the claim of the plaintiff company. In<br />

the other proceeding, in which a favourable decision for the<br />

Bank has been handed down, a claim was made totalling EUR<br />

1,812 thousand.<br />

− Claim filed by American Express Bank Limited (“Amex”) against<br />

Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. at the United States District<br />

Court in New York in respect of certain counterguarantees<br />

given by a company financed by the Bank in 1995. The Bank is<br />

being petitioned to pay USD 3,557,143 and PKR 10,873,000<br />

plus costs and damage or loss incurred by American Express in<br />

this connection. The disputed guarantees were issued by<br />

Amex’s branch in Pakistan to the Pakistani company WAPDA,<br />

with the related counterguarantees of Banco Español de<br />

Crédito, S.A. (all by order and for the account of the<br />

company) to Amex (the “counterguarantees”). The guarantees<br />

and counterguarantees were executed in 2004 but Banco<br />

Español de Crédito, S.A. was unable to pay due to an<br />

injunction issued by a court of first instance of Madrid initially<br />

served on the Bank and subsequently extended in June 2006<br />

to Amex, which prohibited the payment of any amount to<br />

WAPDA or to any third party in connection with the<br />

guarantees until an award had been rendered by the<br />

International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) in the arbitration<br />

taking place in Paris between the parties concerning the<br />

commercial agreement for which the guarantees were given. In<br />

February 2007, the Court of Arbitration of the ICC rendered<br />

an award ordering WAPDA not to execute the guarantees given<br />

to it. <strong>Banesto</strong> notified the New York court of the content of<br />

the aforementioned award and a decision has yet to be<br />

handed down.<br />

− Claim for the execution of a decision filed by Malce, S.L. and<br />

others against Corporación Industrial y Financiera de <strong>Banesto</strong>,<br />

S.A., currently Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. In the claim filed<br />

on 25 April 2007 at the Court of First Instance no. 2 of El<br />

Ejido, Malce S.L. and others requested the execution of the<br />

decision handed down by the Supreme Court on 14 December<br />

2006 which, by overturning the decision of the Almería<br />

Provincial Appellate Court, upheld the cassation appeal filed<br />

by the plaintiffs and ordered Quash S.A. and Área de Servicios<br />

Agrícolas S.A. (currently Banco Español de Crédito S.A. due to<br />

the absorption of Corporación Industrial y Financiera de<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> S.A. which, in turn, had taken over the<br />

aforementioned companies) to execute the sale transaction in<br />

a public deed and to transfer the water wells, auxiliary facilities<br />

and the property on which the wells and facilities are located<br />

to the plaintiffs, to whom they had been sold by the<br />

aforementioned companies in the agreement dated 27<br />

November 1995 and the supplementary agreement of 8<br />

January 1994. The Supreme Court clarified that its decision of<br />

14 December 2006 did not include and were accordingly not<br />

deliverable, the water wells and auxiliary facilities required to<br />

establish the Comunidad de Regantes (association of irrigation<br />

water users) in accordance with the agreement of 8 January<br />

1994. By interlocutory order of 2 April 2008, the Supreme<br />

Court clarified that its decision of 14 December 2006 did not<br />

include and were accordingly not deliverable, the water wells<br />

and auxiliary facilities required to establish the Comunidad de<br />

Regantes de Almeria (association of irrigation water users of<br />

Almeria) to which they were sold by Quash S.A. and Área de<br />

Servicios Agrícolas S.A. in a deed dated 2 November 1995 (in<br />

which reference was made to the lawsuit described), being the<br />

only water wells and auxiliary facilities referred to in the<br />

contingency.


− Complaint in an ordinary proceeding filed by a former Bank<br />

employee claiming EUR 5,003 thousand in consideration for<br />

the professional services which the plaintiff declared to have<br />

provided to the Bank. Currently, the hearing to be held prior<br />

to the court proceeding has not been set. The plaintiff’s<br />

relationship with the Bank was terminated through a justified<br />

dismissal resulting from a firm court decision.<br />

− Claim filed by an association called “Grouping of the<br />

Shareholders of <strong>Banesto</strong>” against Mario Conde, Enrique<br />

Lasarte Pérez Arregui and the Bank. With respect to the Bank,<br />

certain third-party liability claims were filed relating to the<br />

actions of the other two defendants which gave rise to the<br />

intervention of the Bank of Spain on 28 December 1993 in<br />

what is known as the “<strong>Banesto</strong> case”. The claim did not specify<br />

the amount in question. The proceeding was initially allocated<br />

to the Court of First Instance no. 2 of Alicante. However, the<br />

defendants filed a declinatory exception with the Court<br />

arguing that it did not have regional jurisdiction. The<br />

declinatory exception was upheld as the jurisdiction was<br />

deemed to correspond to the Courts of First Instance of<br />

Madrid which motivated the referral of the court orders to the<br />

Senior Court of Madrid. The claim was allocated to the Court<br />

of First Instance no. 41 of Madrid. By court order of 10<br />

October 2008, the Court refused leave to proceed with the<br />

claim and dismissed the proceedings due to the lack of<br />

standing of the plaintiff association. The plaintiff has filed an<br />

appeal against this court order which is currently being<br />

processed.<br />

At 31 December 2008, there were other less material lawsuits of a<br />

tax and legal nature. At 31 December 2008 and 2007, the Bank<br />

had recognised reasonable provisions to cover any payments it<br />

may be required to make as a result of all of the aforementioned<br />

litigation.<br />

23. Tax matters<br />

a) Consolidated Tax Group, reconciliation and other<br />

information<br />

Since 1999 the Bank has filed consolidated tax returns as part of<br />

the corporate Group of which Banco Santander, S.A. is the parent<br />

(see Note 27).<br />

The balance of “Financial Liabilities at Amortised Cost - Other<br />

Financial Liabilities” in the accompanying consolidated balance<br />

sheets includes the liability for the various applicable taxes.<br />

At 31 December 2008 deferred tax assets amounted to EUR<br />

894,694 thousand (EUR 1,040,135 thousand at 31 December<br />

2007). In 2008, EUR 33,268 thousand, EUR 105,091 thousand<br />

and EUR 21,961 thousand relating to payments to pensioners and<br />

early retirees were credited to deferred tax assets, unused tax<br />

credits and other items, respectively. These items relate basically to<br />

income directly recognised in equity due to valuation adjustments.<br />

EUR 9,292 thousand and EUR 5,587 thousand of provisions for<br />

pensions and provisions for inherent losses in the outstanding loan<br />

portfolio, respectively, were charged to deferred tax assets.<br />

The deferred tax liabilities recognised at 31 December 2008<br />

amounted to EUR 68,727 thousand (EUR 38,449 thousand at 31<br />

December 2007). They relate basically to income directly<br />

recognised in equity due to valuation adjustments.<br />

Law 35/2006, of 28 November, on personal income tax and<br />

partially amending the Spanish Corporation Tax, Non-Resident<br />

Income Tax and Wealth Tax Laws, establishes, inter alia, a reduction<br />

over two years of the general income tax rate, which until 31<br />

December 2006 was 35%, so that the tax rate for 2007 was<br />

32.5% and 30% for 2008 and subsequent years.<br />

Since 1999 the companies which until 1998 were part of the<br />

consolidated tax group headed by Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

have filed consolidated tax returns together with the consolidated<br />

tax group headed by Banco Santander, S.A. Following is the<br />

estimated reconciliation of the accounting profit to the income tax<br />

for the year prepared on the assumption that the consolidated tax<br />

group headed by Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. still existed at 31<br />

December 2008 and 2007:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Consolidated profit before tax::<br />

From ordinary activities 1,081,287 1,099,110<br />

1,081,287 1,099,110<br />

Income tax at 30% (32.5% in 2007)<br />

Decreases due to permanent<br />

324,386 357,211<br />

differences<br />

Increases due to permanent differences<br />

(5,376) (11,981)<br />

Due to other permanent differences 13,772 23,950<br />

Elimination of the tax effect of dividends<br />

paid between Group companies<br />

Elimination of the tax effect of the results<br />

(7,832) (10,761)<br />

of intra-group transactions 3,623 (4,290)<br />

Other, net (22,295) (18,475)<br />

Current income tax 306,278 335,654<br />

Ordinary activities 306,278 335,654<br />

Discontinued operations - -<br />

This calculation includes the dividends of approximately EUR<br />

26,107 thousand at 31 December 2008 received from companies<br />

belonging to the consolidated tax group and other positive and<br />

negative adjustments to be made amounting to approximately EUR<br />

26,409 thousand and EUR 14,333 thousand, respectively, since<br />

they will be eliminated from the consolidated tax group's return.<br />

For the purpose of determining the income tax expense recognised<br />

by the Group, regard should be had to the fact that the tax losses<br />

incurred at the Group companies before the extinction of the<br />

consolidated tax Group headed by Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

can only be carried forward for offset by the entities at which they<br />

arose. After filing the 2008 and 2007 tax returns, the tax loss<br />

carryforwards at the Banco Español de Crédito Group companies<br />

amounted to approximately EUR 61,950 thousand and EUR<br />

67,103 thousand at 31 December 2008 and 2007, respectively.<br />

147


148<br />

In 2008 and 2007, the Group obtained gains of EUR 33,182<br />

thousand and EUR 54,925 thousand on the transfer of assets for<br />

consideration, to which the tax credit for reinvestment of<br />

extraordinary income stipulated in Article 42 of Legislative Royal<br />

Decree 4/2004, of 5 March, approving the Consolidated Income<br />

Tax Law as drafted by law 16/2007, of 4 July is applicable.<br />

The Bank has the years from 2003 to date open for review by the<br />

tax authorities in relation to income tax and the other main taxes.<br />

The varying interpretations which can be made of certain tax<br />

regulations applicable to the Bank's operations might give rise to<br />

contingent tax liabilities which cannot be objectively quantified.<br />

However, the Bank's directors and its tax advisers consider that the<br />

tax charge, if any, which might arise from future inspections by the<br />

tax authorities or from inspections already performed pending final<br />

resolutions, would not have a material effect on the Group's<br />

consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December<br />

2008.<br />

The Banco Español de Crédito Group companies included in the<br />

consolidated tax group, the parent of which is Banco Santander,<br />

S.A., are Banco Español de Crédito, S.A., <strong>Banesto</strong> Bolsa, S.A., S.V.B.,<br />

and 26 and 29 other companies, respectively, at 31 December<br />

2008 and 2007.<br />

The other Group companies will file individual tax returns in<br />

accordance with the tax regulations applicable in their countries of<br />

residence.<br />

24. Minority interests<br />

The balance of “Minority Interests” in the consolidated balance<br />

sheets shows the net amount of the equity of subsidiaries<br />

attributable to equity instruments that do not belong, directly or<br />

indirectly, to the Bank, including the portion attributed to them of<br />

profit for the year.<br />

a) Breakdown<br />

The detail, by Group company, of the balance of “Equity - Minority<br />

Interests” in the consolidated balance sheets is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Alcaidesa Holding, S.A. 33,875 38,519<br />

Costa Canaria de Veneguera, S.A. 3,816 3,870<br />

Clínica Sear, S.A. 2,339 2,561<br />

Aljarafe Golf, S.A. 1,136 1,135<br />

Other 1,717 643<br />

42,833 46,728<br />

b) Changes<br />

EThe changes in 2008 and 2007 in “Minority Interests” in the<br />

consolidated balance sheets are summarised as follows:<br />

25. Valuation adjustments<br />

The balances of “Valuation Adjustments” in the consolidated<br />

balance sheets include the amounts, net of the related tax effect,<br />

of adjustments to the assets and liabilities recognised temporarily<br />

in equity through the statement of changes in equity until they are<br />

extinguished or realised, at which point they are recognised<br />

definitively as shareholders’ equity through the consolidated<br />

income statement. The amounts arising from subsidiaries, jointly<br />

controlled entities and associates are presented, on a line by line<br />

basis, in the appropriate items according to their nature.<br />

Valuation Adjustments” includes the following items:<br />

a) Available-for-sale financial assets<br />

“Valuation Adjustments - Available-for-Sale Financial Assets”<br />

includes the net amount of unrealised changes in the fair value of<br />

assets classified for measurement purposes as available-for-sale<br />

financial assets.<br />

b) Cash flow hedges<br />

“Valuation Adjustments - Cash Flow Hedges” includes the net<br />

amount of changes in the value of derivatives designated as<br />

hedging instruments in cash flow hedges, for the portion of these<br />

changes considered as “effective hedges” (see Note 11).<br />

The consolidated statement of recognised income and expense for<br />

2008 and 2007, which is an integral part of the consolidated<br />

statement of changes in equity, shows the changes in this item in<br />

the consolidated balance sheets in 2008 and 2007.<br />

26. Shareholders’ equity<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Beginning balance<br />

Change in proportion of ownership<br />

46,728 53,700<br />

interest 980 (644)<br />

Dividends paid to minority interests - (5,156)<br />

Attributed profit for the year<br />

Of which:<br />

(4,835) (1,111)<br />

Alcaidesa Holding, S,A, (4,647) (501)<br />

Other (188) (610)<br />

Other changes 10 (61)<br />

Ending balance 42,883 46,728<br />

“Shareholders’ Equity” in the consolidated balance sheets includes<br />

the amounts of equity contributions from shareholders,<br />

accumulated profit or loss recognised through the income<br />

statement, and components of compound financial instruments<br />

having the substance of permanent equity. Amounts arising from<br />

subsidiaries and jointly controlled entities are presented in the<br />

appropriate items based on their nature.


27. Issued capital<br />

At 31 December 2007, the share capital of Banco Español de<br />

Crédito, S.A., the only share capital included in the consolidated<br />

balance sheet as a result of the consolidation process, consisted of<br />

694,330,098 fully subscribed and paid book-entry shares of EUR<br />

0.79 par value each, all with identical voting and dividend rights<br />

and listed on the Spanish stock exchanges.<br />

At the Annual General Meeting held on 26 February 2008, the<br />

shareholders resolved to reduce capital by EUR 5,485,207,<br />

through the redemption of 6,943,300 treasury shares with a<br />

charge to voluntary reserves. This capital reduction was registered<br />

in the Madrid Mercantile Register on 20 June 2008 and a reserve<br />

for retired capital was recognised for an amount equal to the par<br />

value of the redeemed shares. Therefore, at 31 December 2008,<br />

the Bank’s share capital consisted of 687,386,798 shares of EUR<br />

0.79 par value each.<br />

At 31 December 2008 the Bank's majority shareholder was the<br />

Santander Group, which held 89.28% of the Bank's share capital<br />

(88.39% at 31 December 2007).<br />

At the Annual General Meeting on 26 February 2008, the<br />

shareholders authorised the Board of Directors to implement the<br />

derivative acquisition of shares of the Bank and its parent by the<br />

Bank and its subsidiaries within the legally stipulated limits.<br />

Accumulated reserves:<br />

At 31 December 2008 and 2007, the Group held 3,863,230 and<br />

6,272,646 treasury shares with an acquisition cost of EUR 36,074<br />

thousand and EUR 86,917 thousand, respectively (see Notes 28<br />

and 29).<br />

28. Reserves<br />

a) Definitions<br />

The balance of “Shareholders’ Equity - Reserves - Accumulated<br />

Reserves” in the consolidated balance sheets includes the net<br />

amount of the accumulated profit or loss recognised in previous<br />

years through the income statement that, in the distribution of the<br />

profit, was assigned to equity. The balance of “Shareholders' Equity<br />

- Reserves of Entities Accounted for Using the Equity Method” in<br />

the consolidated balance sheets includes the net amount of the<br />

accumulated profit or loss generated in previous years by entities<br />

accounted for using the equity method, recognised through the<br />

consolidated income statement.<br />

b) Breakdown<br />

The breakdown of the balances of “Shareholders’ Equity - Reserves<br />

- Accumulated Reserves” and “Shareholders’ Equity - Reserves of<br />

Entities Accounted for Using the Equity Method” at 31 December<br />

2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Restricted reserves-<br />

Legal reserve 216,460 216,460<br />

Reserve for treasury shares (Notes 29 and 31) and for loans for the purchase<br />

of shares of the Bank and of Banco Santander, S.A. (Note 10) 43,770 96,652<br />

Revaluation reserve Royal Decree-Law 7/1996 2,480 2,480<br />

For retired capital 5,485 -<br />

Unrestricted reserves-<br />

Voluntary reserves 3,521,335 3,280,868<br />

Consolidation reserves attributed to the Bank (109,229) (72,364)<br />

Reserves at subsidiaries 372,568 243,997<br />

4,052,869 3,768,093<br />

Reserves of entities accounted for using the equity method:<br />

Associates-<br />

Of which<br />

Sistemas 4B 886 886<br />

Other 1,410 923<br />

2,296 1,809<br />

4,055,165 3,769,902<br />

149


150<br />

Legal reserve<br />

Under the Consolidated Companies Law, Spanish entities must<br />

transfer 10% of net profit for each year to the legal reserve. These<br />

transfers must be made until the balance of this reserve reaches<br />

20% of the share capital. The legal reserve can be used to increase<br />

capital provided that the remaining reserve balance does not fall<br />

below 10% of the increased share capital amount.<br />

Reserve for treasury shares<br />

Pursuant to the Consolidated Companies Law, a restricted reserve<br />

has been recorded for an amount equal to the carrying amount of<br />

the Bank shares owned by subsidiaries. The balance of this reserve<br />

will become unrestricted when the circumstances that made it<br />

necessary to record it cease to exist. Additionally, this reserve<br />

covers the outstanding balance of loans granted by the Group<br />

secured by Bank shares.<br />

Revaluation reserve Royal Decree-Law 7/1996, of 7 June<br />

The balance of “Revaluation Reserve Royal Decree-Law 7/1996”<br />

can be used, free of tax, to increase share capital. From 1 January<br />

2007, the balance of this account can be taken to unrestricted<br />

reserves, provided that the monetary surplus has been realised.<br />

The surplus will be deemed to have been realised in respect of the<br />

portion on which depreciation has been taken for accounting<br />

purposes or when the revalued assets have been transferred or<br />

derecognised.<br />

If the balance of this reserve were used in a manner other than that<br />

provided for in Royal Decree-Law 7/1996, of 7 June, it would be<br />

subject to taxation.<br />

Reserves for retired capital<br />

Pursuant to the Consolidated Companies Law, a restricted reserve<br />

has been recorded for an amount equal to the par value of the<br />

redeemed Bank shares (see Note 26).<br />

Reserves at subsidiaries<br />

The detail, by company, of the balance of these reserves, based on<br />

the subsidiaries' contribution to the Group (considering the effect<br />

of consolidation adjustments) is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Elerco, S.A. 152,181 132,241<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Bolsa, S.A., S.V.B. 67,511 58,250<br />

Dudebasa, S.A. 9,021 20,256<br />

Oil-Dor, S.A.<br />

Santander Seguros y Reaseguros<br />

27,125 24,096<br />

Compañía Aseguradora, S.A. 97,673 66,933<br />

Santander Pensiones, E.G.F.P., S.A. 5,060 11,227<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Holding, Ltd.<br />

Grupo Inmobiliario La Corporación<br />

(5,719) (6,623)<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>, S.A. (8,397) (10,873)<br />

Inversiones Turísticas, S.A. (487) (13,217)<br />

Desarrollo Informático, S.A. - (36,924)<br />

Other companies 28,600 (1,369)<br />

Total 372,568 243,997<br />

29. Treasury shares and other equity<br />

instruments<br />

Treasury shares<br />

The balance of “Shareholders’ Equity – Treasury Shares” in the<br />

consolidated balance sheets includes the amount of equity<br />

instruments held by the Group entities.<br />

Transactions involving own equity instruments, including their<br />

issuance and cancellation, are deducted directly from equity, and<br />

no profit or loss may be recognised as a result of them. The costs<br />

of any transaction involving own equity instruments are deducted<br />

directly from equity, net of any related tax effect.<br />

The Bank shares owned by the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group entities accounted<br />

for 0.56% of issued capital at 31 December 2008 (0.90% at 31<br />

December 2007).<br />

The average purchase price of the Bank shares was EUR 10.9 per<br />

share in 2008 and the average selling price was EUR 11.08 in that<br />

year (EUR 16.20 and EUR 16.67, respectively, in 2007).<br />

The net gains or losses on transactions involving Bank shares<br />

(losses of EUR 11,943 thousand in 2008 and EUR 996 thousand<br />

in 2007) were recognised as a reduction of/addition to reserves.<br />

Other equity instruments<br />

At 31 December 2007 “Other Equity Instruments” includes the<br />

increase in equity due to personnel remuneration (see Note 41).<br />

30. Off-balance-sheet items<br />

“Off-Balance-Sheet Items” includes balances representing rights,<br />

obligations and other legal situations that in the future may have<br />

an impact on net assets, as well as any other balances needed to<br />

reflect all transactions entered into by the consolidated entities<br />

although they may not compromise their net assets.<br />

a) Contingent liabilities<br />

“Contingent Liabilities” includes all transactions under which the<br />

consolidated entities guarantee the obligations of a third party and<br />

which result from financial guarantees granted by the entities or<br />

from other types of contract. The breakdown of this item is as<br />

follows:<br />

Guarantees<br />

Guarantees are the amounts that would be payable by the<br />

consolidated entities on behalf of third parties as a result of the<br />

commitments assumed by those entities in the course of their<br />

ordinary business, if the parties who are originally liable to pay<br />

failed to do so.<br />

The breakdown of “Guarantees” at 31 December 2008 and 2007<br />

is as follows:


Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Bank guarantees and other indemnities<br />

provided 9,798,966 10,719,593<br />

Credit derivatives sold 780,000 804,250<br />

Irrevocable documentary credits 317,898 420,846<br />

10,896,864 11,944,689<br />

A significant portion of these guarantees will expire without any<br />

payment obligation materialising for the consolidated entities and,<br />

therefore, the aggregate balance of these commitments cannot be<br />

considered as an actual future need for financing or liquidity to be<br />

provided by the Group to third parties.<br />

Income from guarantee instruments is recognised under “Fee and<br />

Commission Income” in the consolidated income statements and is<br />

calculated by applying the rate established in the related contract<br />

to the nominal amount of the guarantee.<br />

Other contingent liabilities<br />

This includes the amount of any contingent liability not included in<br />

other items (EUR 2 thousand in 2008 and EUR 9 thousand in<br />

2007).<br />

b) Contingent commitments<br />

“Contingent Commitments” includes those irrevocable<br />

commitments that could give rise to the recognition of financial<br />

assets.<br />

The breakdown of “Contingent Commitments” at 31 December<br />

2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Drawable by third parties<br />

(undrawn credit facilities)<br />

Regular way financial asset<br />

12,897,760 11,237,115<br />

purchase contracts 1,410,793 2,807,648<br />

Other contingent commitments 1,909,794 2,255,525<br />

16,218,347 16,300,288<br />

:31. Notional amounts of trading and<br />

hedging derivatives<br />

The breakdown of the notional and/or contractual amounts of the<br />

trading and hedging derivatives held by the Group at 31 December<br />

2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Notional Market Notional Market<br />

Amount Value (*) Amount Value (*)<br />

Trading derivatives:<br />

Interest rate risk-<br />

Forward rate agreements 650,000 (2,218) 4,117,000 (11)<br />

Interest rate swaps 132,121,853 27,368 150,262,729 (10,574)<br />

Options and futures<br />

Currency risk-<br />

102,992,447 108,024 100,123,193 34,244<br />

Foreign currency purchases and sales 4,930,523 48,311 5,086,030 (42,488)<br />

Foreign currency options 1,409,096 (4,859) 1,548,551 (389)<br />

Currency swaps 3,687,841 3,806 2,410,902 167<br />

Securities and commodities derivatives 18,734,249 114,660 16,899,830 (324,772)<br />

Hedging derivatives:<br />

Interest rate risk-<br />

264,526,009 295,092 280,448,235 (343,823)<br />

Interest rate swaps 23,206,508 551,746 23,369,725 (454,057)<br />

Options and futures 7,191,839 66,012 4,397,061 (99,207)<br />

Securities and commodities derivatives 20,838 - - -<br />

30,419,185 617,758 27,766,786 (553,264)<br />

Total<br />

(*) See Notes 2-a and 2-b.<br />

294,945,194 912,850 308,215,021 (897,087)<br />

151


152<br />

The Group manages the credit risk exposure of these contracts<br />

through netting agreements with its main counterparties and by<br />

taking assets as collateral of its risk function.<br />

The fair value of hedging derivatives, by type of hedge, is as<br />

follows:<br />

Millions of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Fair value hedge 410,389 (440,154)<br />

Cash flow hedge 206,919 (113,110)<br />

617,758 (553,264)<br />

As stated in Note 2-b, the fair value of hedging derivatives is taken<br />

to be the sum of the future cash flows arising from the instrument,<br />

discounted to present value at the date of measurement.<br />

Following is a description of the main hedges (including the results<br />

of the hedging instrument and the hedged item attributable to the<br />

hedged risk):<br />

i. Fair value hedges<br />

The Bank basically hedges the interest rate risk of the issues<br />

secured by it. At 2008 year-end, the Bank held IRS contracts with<br />

a nominal value of EUR 17,572 million. The accumulated gains on<br />

these transactions amounted to EUR 440 million, which was offset<br />

by the losses of the same amount on the hedged items, and this<br />

amount is recognised under “Changes in the Fair Value of Hedged<br />

Items in Portfolio Hedges of Interest Rate Risk” in the consolidated<br />

balance sheet.<br />

iI. Cash flow hedges<br />

The Bank hedges the interest rate risk arising from the fluctuations<br />

in the cash flows from mortgage loans tied to floating interest<br />

rates.<br />

Following is a detail of the years in which the flows hedged by the<br />

cash flow hedges will foreseeably take place:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 >2013<br />

1,840 61,247 24,544 5,948 5,271 4,645<br />

The notional and/or contractual amounts of the aforementioned<br />

contracts do not reflect the actual risk assumed by the Bank, since<br />

the net position in these financial instruments is the result of<br />

offsetting and/or combining them. This net position is used by the<br />

Bank basically to hedge the interest rate, underlying asset price or<br />

currency risk.<br />

32. Off-balance-sheet funds under<br />

management<br />

The detail of off-balance-sheet funds managed by the Group at 31<br />

December 2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Investment funds 6,838,078 11,228,947<br />

Pension funds 1,409,663 1,626,128<br />

Assets under management 1,521,157 1,191,376<br />

9,768,898 14,046,451<br />

33. Interest and similar income<br />

“Interest and Similar Income” in the consolidated income<br />

statement comprises the interest accruing in the year on all<br />

financial assets with an implicit or explicit return, calculated by<br />

applying the effective interest method, irrespective of<br />

measurement at fair value; and the rectifications of revenue as a<br />

consequence of hedge accounting. Interest is recognised gross,<br />

without deducting any tax withheld at source.<br />

The breakdown of the main items of interest and similar income<br />

earned by the Group in 2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Balances with central banks 37,873 30,593<br />

Financial assets held for trading 53,861 46,334<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets 234,027 189,215<br />

Loans and receivables 4,988,016 4,166,506<br />

Held-to-maturity investments<br />

Adjustments to financial assets as<br />

- 50,043<br />

a result of hedging transactions 5,482 9,565<br />

Insurance contracts linked to pensions 58,837 58,893<br />

Insurance activity income 93,501 87,429<br />

Other assets - 33<br />

5,471,597 4,638,611


34. Interest expense and similar charges<br />

“Interest Expense and Similar Charges” in the consolidated income<br />

statement includes the interest accruing in the year on all financial<br />

liabilities with an implicit or explicit return, including remuneration<br />

in kind, calculated by applying the effective interest method,<br />

irrespective of measurement at fair value; the rectifications of cost<br />

as a consequence of hedge accounting; and the interest cost<br />

attributable to pension funds.<br />

The breakdown of the main items of interest expense and similar<br />

charges accrued by the Group in 2008 and 2007 is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Financial liabilities held for trading 7,277 9,366<br />

Financial liabilities at amortised cost<br />

Adjustments to financial liabilities as<br />

3,450,008 3,074,161<br />

a result of hedging transactions 197,346 (34,476)<br />

Provisions for pensions (Note 22) 95,050 96,229<br />

Insurance activity expense (Note 40) 3 6,006<br />

Other liabilities 6,847 5,479<br />

3,756,531 3,156,765<br />

35. Income from equity instruments<br />

“Income from Equity Instruments” includes the dividends and<br />

payments on equity instruments out of profits generated by<br />

investees after the acquisition of the equity interest.<br />

The breakdown of the balance of this item is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Equity instruments classified as:<br />

Financial assets held for trading 55,438 50,255<br />

Available-for-sale financial assets 3,799 5,559<br />

59,237 55,814<br />

36. Share of results of entities<br />

accounted for using the equity<br />

method<br />

“Share of Results of Entities Accounted for Using the Equity<br />

Method” comprises the amount of profit or loss attributable to the<br />

Group generated during the year by associates, as well as by jointly<br />

controlled entities when the equity method has been chosen for<br />

The breakdown of the balance of this item is as follows:<br />

37. Fee and commission income<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Associates:<br />

Compañía Concesionaria del Túnel<br />

de Soller, S.A 476 491<br />

Grupo Agres, S.A. 145 123<br />

Carnes Estelles, S.A. 14 110<br />

Aguas de Fuensanta, S.A. (8) 410<br />

Sistemas 4B, S.A. 1,217 601<br />

Other 30 (28)<br />

1,874 1,707<br />

“Fee and Commission Income” comprises the amount of all fees<br />

and commissions accruing in favour of the Group in the year,<br />

except those that form an integral part of the effective interest rate<br />

on financial instruments.<br />

The breakdown of the balance of this item is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Fee and Commission Income Arising from: 2008 2007<br />

Financing granted to third parties:<br />

Commitment fees<br />

Management and administration services:<br />

20,157 19,857<br />

Investment funds and other collective<br />

investment undertakings 123,564 186,878<br />

Pension funds and plans 34,093 36,009<br />

Assets owned by third parties 2,297 7,068<br />

Investment services:<br />

Underwriting and placement of securities<br />

159,954 229,955<br />

issued by third parties 5,681 2,342<br />

Securities market brokerage 18,142 29,516<br />

Custody services 8,078 9,294<br />

Other:<br />

31,901 41,152<br />

Foreign exchange 1,772 1,340<br />

Financial guarantees 73,192 67,900<br />

Collection and payment services 366,382 329,741<br />

Other fees and commissions 52,341 52,020<br />

493,687 451,001<br />

705,699 741,965<br />

153


154<br />

38. Fee and commission expense<br />

“Fee and Commission Expense” shows the amount of all fees and<br />

commissions paid or payable by the Group in the year, except<br />

those that form an integral part of the effective interest rate on<br />

financial instruments.<br />

The breakdown of the balance of this item is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Fees and commissions assigned<br />

to third parties 86,876 102,984<br />

Other fees and commissions 57,149 58,330<br />

144,025 161,314<br />

40. Other operating income and Other<br />

operating expenses<br />

“Other Operating Income” includes the income and expenses from<br />

other operating activities of the Group’s credit institutions not<br />

included in other items..<br />

39. Gains/losses on financial assets and<br />

liabilities (net)<br />

“Gains/Losses on Financial Assets and Liabilities (net)” includes<br />

the amount of the valuation adjustments of financial instruments,<br />

except those attributable to interest accrued as a result of<br />

application of the effective interest method and to allowances,<br />

recorded in the consolidated income statement, and the gains or<br />

losses obtained from the sale and purchase thereof.<br />

The breakdown of the balance of this item, by type of instrument,<br />

is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Fixed-income (8,103) 4,800<br />

Equities 191,357 73,921<br />

Financial derivatives and other (73,854) 6,203<br />

109,400 84,924<br />

The breakdown of the balances of “Other Operating Income” and<br />

“Other Operating Expenses” in the consolidated income<br />

statements is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Income Expenses<br />

2008 2007 2008 2007<br />

Insurance and reinsurance premium income 1,960,455 1,262,304 - -<br />

Reinsurance premiums paid - - 71,490 58,330<br />

Reinsurance income 39,819 22,646 - -<br />

Claims paid and other insurance-related expenses - - 574,614 514,759<br />

Net provisions for insurance contract liabilities - - 1,381,412 686,106<br />

Sales and income from the provision of non-financial services 73,396 160,752 - -<br />

Cost of sales - - 35,375 86,686<br />

Exploitation of investment property and operating leases (Note 13)<br />

Commissions on financial instruments that compensate for related<br />

2,005 2,006 - -<br />

direct costs<br />

Expenses recovered through their inclusion in the selling price of goods<br />

21,513 33,088 - -<br />

and services 78,805 6,037 - -<br />

Other 13,427 11,126 - 29,386<br />

Contribution to the Deposit Guarantee Fund (Note 1-g) - - 17,296 15,103<br />

Investment property and other expenses - - 119,653 30,193<br />

2,189,420 1,497,959 2,199,840 1,420,563


Insurance activity income<br />

The breakdown of the net amount of the contribution to gross<br />

income from subsidiaries that are insurance or reinsurance<br />

companies, is as follows<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Life Non-Life Total Life Non-Life Total<br />

Premiums collected 1,935,271 25,184 1,960,455 1,202,591 59,713 1,262,304<br />

Reinsurance premiums paid (68,473) (3,017) (71,490) (51,946) (6,384) (58,330)<br />

Net premiums 1,866,798 22,167 1,888,965 1,150,645 53,329 1,203,974<br />

Claims paid and other insurance-related<br />

expenses (550,365) (24,249) (574,614) (458,419) (56,340) (514,759)<br />

Reinsurance income 4,448 35,371 39,819 5,002 17,644 22,646<br />

Net provisions for insurance contract<br />

liabilities (1,361,910) (19,502) (1,381,412) (683,341) (2,765) (686,106)<br />

Finance income 87,179 6,322 93,501 84,077 3,352 87,429<br />

Finance expense (Note 34) (3) - (3) (6,006) - (6,006)<br />

Sales and income from the provision of non-financial services<br />

and Cost of sales<br />

“Sales and Income from the Provision of Non-Financial Services”<br />

and “Cost of Sales” show, respectively, the amount of the sales of<br />

assets and income from the provision of services that constitute<br />

the typical activity of non-financial entities and the related costs of<br />

sale. The main lines of business of these entities are as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Sales/ Cost of Sales/ Cost of<br />

Line of Business Income Sales Income Sales<br />

Real estate 46,068 28,713 103,542 80,143<br />

Services 3,667 607 4,050 637<br />

IT and other 23,661 6,055 53,160 5,906<br />

73,396 35,375 160,752 86,686<br />

41. Personnel expenses<br />

“Personnel Expenses” comprises all the compensation of the<br />

personnel on the pay-roll, whether permanent or temporary,<br />

irrespective of their functions or activity, accruing in the year for<br />

whatever reason, including the current service cost in respect of<br />

pension plans, remuneration based on own equity instruments and<br />

expenses capitalised as part of the value of assets.<br />

a) Breakdown<br />

The breakdown of “Personnel Expenses” is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Wages and salaries 493,897 489,673<br />

Social security costs<br />

Charges to in-house pension<br />

106,890 106,364<br />

provisions (Note 22)<br />

Contributions to external pension<br />

12,658 15,256<br />

funds (Note 2-v) 6,198 1,026<br />

Other personnel expenses 53,740 52,279<br />

673,383 664,598<br />

155


156<br />

b) Headcount<br />

The average number of employees in the Group, by professional<br />

category and gender, was as follows:<br />

2008 2007<br />

Headcount<br />

Men Women Men Women<br />

Senior executives 13 1 13 1<br />

Other line personnel 5,252 2,723 5,342 2,561<br />

Clerical staff 827 744 966 857<br />

General services personnel 7 4 7 6<br />

Staff at subsidiaries and companies abroad 37 25 42 28<br />

Other non-financial companies 438 249 600 324<br />

c) Equity-instrument-based employee remuneration<br />

At the Extraordinary General Meeting on 27 June 2007, the<br />

shareholders approved a three-year Bank share-based Incentive<br />

Plan, which is tied to the achievement of several targets and<br />

divided into two tranches:<br />

f) Top A: appreciation of the Bank’s share price; appreciation of<br />

the share price of Banco Santander S.A. and growth in<br />

earnings per share. 55 Group executives are covered by this<br />

tranche of the plan, including those belonging to the<br />

Management Committee and executive directors (see Notes<br />

5-a and 5-b).<br />

g) Top 10: growth in gross income and the average amount of<br />

the net charge for impaired loans and receivables assessed<br />

individually. 170 Group executives are covered by this tranche<br />

of the plan.<br />

The shares must be delivered no later than 31 July 2010. The<br />

maximum number of <strong>Banesto</strong> shares to be delivered under this plan<br />

was 1,041,495 (0.15% of share capital).<br />

In 2007 the amount recognised in this connection with a credit to<br />

equity amounted to EUR 1,778 thousand (see Note 27). In 2008<br />

since the targets were not achieved, the Bank proceeded to writeoff<br />

this amount with a credit to income.<br />

On 28 February 2006, the Bank's Annual General Meeting<br />

approved a medium- to long-term Incentive Plan, which basically<br />

entailed the grant to the beneficiaries of options on shares of<br />

Banco Santander, S.A. and, if the terms of the plan are met, the<br />

delivery of shares of Banco Español de Crédito, S.A. to senior<br />

executives and the payment of an amount in cash to the other<br />

beneficiaries. The number of beneficiaries, including directors and<br />

senior executives was 271. The Plan led to the grant of 5,084,000<br />

options on Banco Santander, S.A. shares and the delivery of the<br />

245,907 <strong>Banesto</strong> shares referred to in Notes 5-a and 5-b. The<br />

number of options exercised was 3,551,819.<br />

6,574 3,746 6,970 3,777<br />

42. Other general administrative expenses<br />

The breakdown of the balance of “Other General Administrative<br />

Expenses” in the consolidated income statements is as follows::<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Technology, systems and communications 60,396 85,422<br />

Advertising and technical reports 24,295 26,919<br />

Property and fixtures 68,159 65,936<br />

Taxes other than income tax 15,289 15,517<br />

Surveillance and cash courier services 11,575 11,208<br />

Insurance premiums 1,248 1,444<br />

Other administrative expenses 66,704 59,649<br />

247,666 266,095<br />

The detail of the fees paid to the respective auditors for the audits<br />

of the Group companies (see Appendixes I, II and III) is as follows:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

udit of the individual and consolidated annual<br />

financial statements of the Group (*)<br />

audited by the Deloitte worldwide organisation 1,524 1,413<br />

Work required of auditors by Spanish supervisors<br />

and performed by Deloitte 254 350<br />

Other work and reports by Deloitte 967 406<br />

Fees for audits performed by other firms 59 47<br />

Other services provided by other firms 32 110<br />

2,836 2,326<br />

(*) Including the fees paid for the internal control audit required by the US Sarbanes-Oxley Act, with which<br />

the Santander Group is obliged to comply (see Note 27).


43. Gains/(losses) on disposal of assets<br />

not classified as non-current assets<br />

held-for sale<br />

“Gains/(Losses) on Disposal of Assets Not Classified as Non-<br />

Current Assets Held for Sale” in the consolidated income<br />

statement include the income and expenses arising from nonordinary<br />

activities not included in other items. This basically<br />

includes the net gain/loss on the sale of tangible and intangible<br />

assets and investments.<br />

This table does not reflect the Group's liquidity position since it<br />

considers demand deposits and other customer deposits as any<br />

other liability, whereas their stability is a typical feature of<br />

commercial banking. Considering this effect, the differences<br />

44. Residual maturity periods and average<br />

interest rates<br />

The breakdown, by maturity, of the balances of certain items in the<br />

consolidated balance sheet at 31 December 2008, and of the<br />

average interest rates thereon in 2008 is as follows:<br />

THOUSANDS OF EUROS<br />

Average<br />

Annual<br />

Within 1 1 to 3 3 to 12 1 to 5 After 5 Interest<br />

Demand Month Months Months Years Years Total Rate (%)<br />

ASSETS:<br />

Cash and balances with<br />

central banks<br />

Loans and receivables-<br />

Loans and advances<br />

263,073 1,425,080 - - - - 1,688,153 3,24<br />

to credit institutions<br />

Loans and advances<br />

701,890 6,927,529 6,473,772 3,689,019 359,345 1,549,130 19,700,685 4,41<br />

to customers<br />

Debt instruments-<br />

Financial assets held<br />

2,512,189 3,119,406 6,160,379 10,910,999 13,576,362 41,493,328 77,772,663 5,70<br />

for trading<br />

Available-for-sale<br />

- 5,578 15,832 176,325 191,642 12,777 402,154 3,43<br />

financial assets - 60,163 10,360 106,083 3,041,520 3,402,283 6,620,409 4,36<br />

Loans and receivables - - - - - 736,239 736,239 4,54<br />

LIABILITIES:<br />

Financial liabilities<br />

at amortised cost--<br />

Deposits from central<br />

3,477,152 11,537,756 12,660,343 14,882,426 17,168,869 47,193,757 106,920,303<br />

banks and credit institutions 101,447 8,438,192 2,951,605 695,554 13,432 206,388 12,406,618 4,29<br />

Customer deposits 20,252,872 17,935,619 13,344,980 4,992,067 385,203 678,887 57,589,628 3,56<br />

Marketable debt securities 40,065 931,645 2,217,268 4,318,652 10,037,747 10,769,726 28,315,103 4,80<br />

Subordinated liabilities - - - - - 2,236,835 2,236,835 6,10<br />

Other financial liabilities 1,772,688 555,574 93,032 115,868 322,342 37,988 2,897,472 -<br />

22,167,052 27,861,030 18,606,885 10,122,141 10,758,724 13,929,824 103,445,656 -<br />

between assets and liabilities for each of the maturity periods are<br />

within reasonable thresholds in view of the business volume<br />

managed. Note 48 contains a detailed description of the liquidity<br />

management function performed by the Group.<br />

157


158<br />

45. Business segment reporting<br />

Basis of segmentation<br />

Segment reporting is structured by the Group's various business<br />

segments. The distribution by geographical segment is not<br />

significant, since substantially all the profit is obtained in Spain.<br />

The business segments described below were defined on the basis<br />

of the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group's organisational structure at 2008 year-end,<br />

taking into account the nature of the products and services offered<br />

and the customer segments targeted.<br />

In 2008 the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group focused its activities on the following<br />

business segments:<br />

- Commercial Banking (households and SMEs)<br />

- Corporate Banking (large companies)<br />

- Markets and International.<br />

Income and expenses that cannot be specifically attributed to any<br />

operating line or that are the result of decisions affecting the<br />

Group as a whole including, inter alia, expenses incurred in projects<br />

or activities affecting several business segments, income from<br />

strategic investments, impairment losses recognised for goodwill,<br />

etc. are attributed to a “Corporate Unit” to which the reconciling<br />

items arising from the reconciliation of the result of integrating the<br />

financial statements of the various business segments (prepared<br />

using a management approach) to the Group's consolidated<br />

financial statements are also allocated.<br />

Basis and methodology for business segment reporting<br />

The segment information below is based on monthly reports<br />

prepared using the data provided by a management control<br />

computer application.<br />

The reporting structure is designed as if each business segment<br />

were a stand-alone business and had its own separate equity that<br />

is distributed on the basis of the risk to which the assets allocated<br />

to each segment are subject, based on an internal cost percentage<br />

allocation system.<br />

The net interest income and ordinary income of each business<br />

segment are calculated by applying to the related assets and<br />

liabilities transfer prices that are consistent with current market<br />

rates. Interest from the securities portfolio is distributed among<br />

the various business segments in proportion to their participation.<br />

Administrative expenses include direct and indirect costs and are<br />

allocated among the lines of business and support service units on<br />

the basis of the internal use of these services.<br />

Assets allocated to the various business segments include financial<br />

assets held for trading, investment securities and loans and<br />

advances to credit institutions and customers, net of the related<br />

impairment allowance. The liabilities and shareholders' equity<br />

allocated to the various business segments include deposits from<br />

credit institutions, customer deposits and shareholders' equity.<br />

The other asset and liability items and the items reconciling the<br />

total assets, liabilities and shareholders' equity allocated to the<br />

various business segments to those shown in the Group's<br />

consolidated balance sheet are allocated to the Corporate Unit.


THOUSANDS OF EUROS<br />

Markets and<br />

Commercial Banking Corporate Banking International Corporate Unit Total Group<br />

2008 2007 2008 2007 2008 2007 2008 2007 2008 2007<br />

Interest and similar income 3,526,983 2,899,879 564,492 479,466 968,206 724,830 411,916 534,436 5,471,597 4,638,611<br />

Interest expense and similar charges 2,123,389 1,648,740 458,491 380,666 894,717 687,971 279,934 439,388 3,756,531 3,156,765<br />

Net interest income 1,403,594 1,251,139 106,001 98,800 73,489 36,859 131,982 95,048 1,715,066 1,481,846<br />

Income from equity instruments - - - - 55,588 52,570 3,649 3,244 59,237 55,814<br />

Share of results of entities accounted for using<br />

the equity method - - - - - - 1,874 1,707 1,874 1,707<br />

Net fee and commission income 556,549 564,213 51,946 47,030 22,910 38,266 (69,731) (68,858) 561,674 580,651<br />

Gains/(losses) on financial assets and<br />

liabilities and exchange differences 70,975 65,940 12,218 12,183 71,042 55,322 (2,968) (13,655) 151,267 119,790<br />

Other operating income/(expenses) 4,287 16,882 (318) (452) (282) (184) (14,107) 61,150 (10,420) 77,396<br />

Gross operating income 2,035,405 1,898,174 169,847 157,561 222,747 182,833 50,699 78,636 2,478,698 2,317,204<br />

Expenses and depreciation and amortisation (843,317) (808,300) (21,874) (21,520) (42,032) (40,882) (116,143) (159,533) (1,023,366) (1,030,235)<br />

Provisions - - - - - - - - (36,271) 16,671<br />

Asset impairment (276,883) (211,350) (23,142) (17,369) (2,623) (1,513) 726 (3,467) (301,922) (233,699)<br />

Profit/loss from operations 915,205 878,524 124,831 118,672 178,092 140,438 (64,718) (84,364) 1,117,139 1,069,941<br />

Other net gains/losses - - - - - - (35,852) 29,169 (35,852) 29,169<br />

Profit/loss before tax 915,205 878,524 124,831 118,672 178,092 140,438 (100,570) (55,195) 1,081,287 1,099,110<br />

Income tax (256,257) (267,950) (34,953) (36,195) (49,866) (42,833) 34,798 11,324 (306,278) (335,654)<br />

Profit for the year from continuing operations 658,948 610,574 89,878 82,477 128,226 97,605 (65,772) (43,871) 775,009 763,456<br />

Profit/loss attributable to minority interests - - - - - - (4,835) (1,111) (4,835) (1,111)<br />

Profit/loss attributed to the Group 658,948 610,574 89,878 82,477 128,226 97,605 (60,937) (42,760) 779,844 764,567<br />

Assets by segment-millions of euros 58,237 58,940 11,833 9,963 32,039 26,851 18,370 16,192 120,479 111,946<br />

Liabilities by segment-millions of euros 36,719 33,910 1,772 1,550 33,222 26,838 48,766 49,648 120,479 111,946<br />

159


160<br />

Substantially all the total income for 2008, which includes interest<br />

and similar income, income from equity instruments, fee and<br />

commission income, net gains on financial assets and liabilities held<br />

for trading and other ordinary income, was obtained in Spain. It<br />

should be noted, however, that 1.6% of total income for 2008 was<br />

generated in the USA (0.5% in 2007).<br />

95.8% of loans and advances to customers relate to borrowers<br />

resident in Spain (95.7% in 2007), 2.5% to borrowers resident in<br />

other EU countries (2.8% in 2007) and 0.9% to residents in other<br />

OECD countries (0.6% in 2007).<br />

46. Related-party transactions<br />

a) Transactions with companies in the Banco Español de<br />

Crédito Group and the Santander Group (Parent,<br />

subsidiaries and associates)<br />

All significant inter-company balances at 2008 year-end and the<br />

effect of inter-company transactions during the year were<br />

eliminated on consolidation. The detail of the Group's most<br />

significant balances with associates and Santander Group<br />

companies (see Note 27) and of the effect on the income<br />

statements of transactions performed with them is as follows:<br />

Assets:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

2008 2007<br />

Loans and advances to credit institutions 9,244,875 4,313,526<br />

Loans and advances to customers 517,714 22,789<br />

Impairment allowance - (10)<br />

Liabilities:<br />

Deposits from credit institutions 3,067,146 449,501<br />

Customer deposits 523,254 49,498<br />

Income statement:<br />

Debit-<br />

IInterest expense and similar charges (95,037) (73,820)<br />

Fee and commission expense (329) (1,113)<br />

General administrative expenses (72,895) (62,610)<br />

Credit-<br />

Interest and similar income 227,645 157,216<br />

Income from equity instruments 560 520<br />

Fee and commission income 70,091 24,054<br />

Off-balance sheet items:<br />

Contingent liabilities 245,279 346,718<br />

Commitments 1,666,631 9,429<br />

b) Transactions with Board members and executives (key<br />

executives of the Bank and its parent)<br />

The information on the remuneration payable to the Bank's key<br />

executives is detailed in Note 5.<br />

The balance of direct lending transactions to key executives of the<br />

Bank and of its parent amounted to EUR 4,485 thousand at 31<br />

December 2008 and to EUR 4,175 thousand at 31 December<br />

2007.<br />

Additionally, the transactions currently performed by the Bank's<br />

key executives are those characteristic of a normal commercial<br />

relationship with a bank.<br />

c) Transactions with other related parties<br />

At 31 December 2008, the positions with other related parties as<br />

defined in the applicable regulations were as follows:<br />

1. Financing transactions (trade discount, credit, mortgage and<br />

other loans and other lending transactions): EUR 415 million.<br />

2. Riesgos de firma (avales y créditos documentarios): 225<br />

millones de euros.<br />

3. Deposit-taking transactions (customer deposits): EUR 3.6<br />

million.<br />

The transactions included in the aforementioned categories were<br />

performed in the normal course of the Bank's business with its<br />

customers (most of the balances relate to the Ferrovial Group) and<br />

on an arm's-length basis.<br />

Notwithstanding the foregoing, certain individuals and legal<br />

entities that are defined as related parties ordinarily perform with<br />

the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group transactions which are characteristic of a<br />

normal commercial relationship with a financial institution, for<br />

amounts which are not material and under market or employee<br />

conditions, as appropriate.<br />

47. Fair value of financial assets and<br />

financial liabilities not measured at<br />

fair value<br />

As discussed above, the financial assets owned by the Bank -except<br />

for loans and receivables and held-to-maturity investments, equity<br />

instruments whose market value cannot be estimated reliably and<br />

derivatives that have these instruments as their underlyings and<br />

are settled by delivery thereof- are measured at fair value in the<br />

accompanying balance sheets.<br />

Similarly, the Bank’s financial liabilities -except for financial<br />

liabilities held for trading, those measured at fair value and<br />

derivatives having as their underlyings equity instruments whose<br />

market value cannot be estimated reliably- are measured at<br />

amortised cost in the accompanying balance sheets.<br />

Some of the assets and liabilities recognised under “Loans and<br />

Receivables” and “Financial Liabilities at Amortised Cost” in the<br />

balance sheet at 31 December 2008 are included in the fair value<br />

and cash flow hedges managed by the Bank and, therefore, are<br />

measured in the balance sheet at their fair value in respect of the<br />

risk being hedged (interest rate risk - see Note 11).


Most of the other assets and certain liabilities earn or bear interest<br />

at a floating rate which is adjusted each year; therefore, their fair<br />

value resulting from the variations in market interest rates does not<br />

differ significantly from the amount at which they are recognised in<br />

the accompanying balance sheet.<br />

The remaining assets and liabilities earn or bear interest at a fixed<br />

rate; and, since a significant portion of them mature within one<br />

year, their market value resulting from the variations in market<br />

interest rates does not differ significantly from the amount at which<br />

they are recognised in the accompanying balance sheet.<br />

Accordingly, the fair value of the assets and liabilities at fixed rates,<br />

with residual maturity of more than one year and not hedged<br />

against variations in market interest rates, does not differ materially<br />

from the amount recognised in the accompanying balance sheet.<br />

48. Risk and capital management<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> sees risk and capital management as a means of obtaining<br />

competitive advantages for the creation of shareholder value, and<br />

considers that implementation of the related policy must be<br />

compatible with a sustainable growth strategy. This can only be<br />

achieved by maximising the risk-return ratio and, accordingly, a set<br />

of modern structures, information systems, procedures, tools and<br />

methodologies are required to facilitate advanced risk<br />

management.<br />

Basic principles<br />

The basic principles underpinning the Bank's risk management are<br />

as follows:<br />

- Involvement of senior management personnel, who define the<br />

risk policy, set the limits for the powers conferred on decisionmaking<br />

bodies and take decisions on transactions. The<br />

Chairman of the Risk Standing Committee reports directly to<br />

the Executive Committee and to the Board of Directors.<br />

- Independence of the risk function, without detriment to the<br />

commitment to supporting the business, in line with the Bank’s<br />

criteria and general objectives. Key importance of risk<br />

management in <strong>Banesto</strong>'s pricing and capital allocation<br />

policies.<br />

- Commitment to maintain a medium-low risk profile.<br />

Accordingly, risks are assumed on the basis of collective<br />

decisions focused on predictable and scantly volatile risks.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> also seeks diversification in terms of customer, group,<br />

industry and product, thus avoiding a high concentration of<br />

risk.<br />

- Anticipation and active monitoring through the ongoing<br />

assessment of risk by means of monitoring systems to avoid<br />

any unexpected deterioration in the credit quality of the<br />

portfolio.<br />

- The daily use of management tools, including internal rating,<br />

scoring and risk-adjusted returns, as well as expected loss and<br />

economic capital in risk management at both individual and<br />

portfolio level.<br />

- To this end, advanced risk measurement, assessment, analysis<br />

and management methodologies are in place to enable the<br />

automation of processes, which are complemented by our team<br />

of highly-qualified, experienced professionals. The internal<br />

ratings-based approach (IRB) adapted to Basel II enables<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> to optimise the management of risk and capital<br />

requirements and the creation of shareholder value.<br />

- Quality of internal and external service, which implies swiftness<br />

of response.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> assumes risks as a result of its lending business, its offbalance-sheet<br />

transactions and the hedging and proprietary<br />

trading activities it performs. In addition to credit, interest rate,<br />

liquidity and foreign currency risk, <strong>Banesto</strong> is exposed to<br />

operational, environmental and reputational risk.<br />

a. Global risk management<br />

1.Risk quantification<br />

The detail, by type of risk, of the Group's risk profile in 2008,<br />

taking into account all its activities and measured in terms of use of<br />

economic capital, is shown in the table below:<br />

Credit risk 93%<br />

Market risk 2%<br />

Operational risk 5%<br />

In 2008 this capital model was substantially revised to enhance its<br />

sensitivity to changes in the various elements that reflect the<br />

global risk profile: the quality of individual exposures, volatility,<br />

concentration/diversification, correlation, maturity, hedges, etc.<br />

As illustrated, the greatest exposure is to credit risk and,<br />

accordingly, credit risk has been the focus of most of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s<br />

efforts from the standpoint of quantification as regards capital,<br />

expected losses and stress scenarios.<br />

Credit risk quantification<br />

Effective global risk management requires the development of<br />

methodologies and models that enable the quantification of the<br />

basic measurement parameters, i.e. expected and unexpected loss.<br />

It is also essential to have in place the tools that enable the<br />

establishment of adequate risk protection measures and systems<br />

that facilitate the identification of areas of business growth, always<br />

bearing in mind the Bank’s risk appetite.<br />

Several years ago <strong>Banesto</strong> implemented quantitative models that<br />

estimate these parameters on the basis of four main components:<br />

the probability of default associated with each customer/contract<br />

(PD), the Bank’s exposure to this customer at the date of default<br />

(EAD), loss severity or loss given default (LGD) and asset<br />

correlation (AC).<br />

The major development in 2008 was the modelling of these<br />

parameters so that they reflect the current macroeconomic<br />

situation from a point-in-time (PiT) approach. In this connection,<br />

161


162<br />

each of the parameters was estimated on the basis of certain<br />

scenarios of macroeconomic variables such as GDP, interest rates,<br />

unemployment, housing prices, growth in lending, etc. to enable<br />

them to be included in risk and return management based on the<br />

Entity’s outlook for the coming months.<br />

Probability of default (PD): all the rating/scoring models (corporate,<br />

banks, businesses, developers, SMEs, consumer loans, mortgages,<br />

cards and behaviour of loans to individuals) are calibrated on the<br />

basis of the probability of default.<br />

This calibration is supported by a statistical process which, based<br />

on the internal default history of the various<br />

customers/transactions, assigns each risk category (rating/score) a<br />

probability of experiencing a 90-day or more default over a oneyear<br />

time horizon.<br />

As is the case with modelling subject to the impact of<br />

macroeconomic effects, <strong>Banesto</strong>’s probabilities of default are<br />

adjusted by correction coefficients depending on the purpose they<br />

are used for (pricing, internal provisions, regulatory capital,<br />

economic capital, etc.) and the scenarios defined by senior<br />

management.<br />

It was with this objective in mind that the final PD correction<br />

models were developed. These models are based on structural<br />

credit risk models and constitute a very significant qualitative<br />

supplement, since they enable us to improve the occasional<br />

shortcomings of models that use regression on macroeconomic<br />

trends.<br />

All of these models are connected to the Bank’s stress test models,<br />

which allows us to assess the default rates of the macroeconomic<br />

variables in adverse scenarios and to analyse the sensitivity of our<br />

portfolio to each impact taken separately and to combinations<br />

thereof.<br />

Exposure at default (EAD): this concept measures the potential risk<br />

exposure by estimating the amount that will have been drawn down<br />

against a given contract at the date of default. EAD is calculated<br />

on the basis of committed lines of credit, such as credit accounts<br />

or trade discounting lines.<br />

In a world in which financial instruments are increasingly used by all<br />

types of customers, the major challenge has been to precisely<br />

model the exposure of our customers' positions in these products<br />

(interest rate and foreign currency hedges, structured products,<br />

etc.).<br />

Loss given default (LGD): after ascertaining the probability of<br />

default and the amount of exposure at default, loss given default<br />

makes it possible to measure the definitive loss incurred by the<br />

Bank following the recovery of debt principal and interest,<br />

including direct and indirect recovery costs. This process is<br />

performed on the basis of <strong>Banesto</strong>'s historical experience of<br />

customer debt recovery management. As in the case of PD, LGD is<br />

affected by the position in the economic cycle, since nonperforming<br />

loans, asset prices and other factors have a significant<br />

impact on recoveries of defaulted loans and, accordingly, on<br />

severity.<br />

With a view to incorporating this cyclical effect, <strong>Banesto</strong> used the<br />

aforementioned factors to model the variables with the greatest<br />

impact on final severity such as recovery time, the probability of<br />

court proceedings, the distribution of recoveries in the event of<br />

court proceedings, etc.<br />

The fact that <strong>Banesto</strong> uses the same factors as in the case of PD<br />

enables it to measure the correlation between PD and LGD and the<br />

combined effect on expected loss of specific stress scenarios of<br />

the two parameters.<br />

Expected loss (EL): which is obtained by combining the three<br />

concepts mentioned above, is the cost of the annual risk<br />

associated with the Bank's loan exposure and is taken to the<br />

management income statement of the entire Entity.<br />

As in the foregoing cases, the expected loss will depend on the<br />

management objective and on the scenario established for this<br />

purpose.<br />

Asset correlation (AC) and diversification: in the current climate the<br />

Bank’s diversified portfolio represents a very significant<br />

competitive edge and, accordingly, the Bank pays particular<br />

attention to the measurement and management of this parameter.<br />

To this end it has created the position of concentration manager<br />

who regularly analyses the composition of the portfolio, and<br />

controls individual and industry concentrations and establishes<br />

maximum concentration limits.<br />

Economic capital (EC): although expected loss is a key component<br />

of credit risk management and pricing, it is not sufficient if we<br />

consider that this loss is not constant over time. Therefore, a<br />

measure is required that will provide information on the variability<br />

of expected losses. This information is furnished by economic<br />

capital, which is intended to measure the potential impact on the<br />

Entity of the volatility of these losses in exceptional situations.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> pursues a two-fold objective in this respect. Firstly, it<br />

seeks to minimise this volatility, thus guaranteeing maximum<br />

returns for shareholders, and, secondly, it aims to maintain<br />

maximum solvency in such stress situations.<br />

2. Integration in risk management<br />

Risk quantification is not an end in itself, but rather it provides the<br />

Bank with the tools which, when used in its day-to-day business,<br />

play an essential role in ensuring adequate risk management at<br />

both individual asset and portfolio level.<br />

The inclusion of estimates of expected loss and capital as basic<br />

management tools has been <strong>Banesto</strong>'s main priority in recent<br />

years, and this is especially the case in the current market climate<br />

that requires much more advanced and anticipatory management.<br />

In Corporate and Business Banking, price simulators and historical<br />

and projected RAROC calculations are of vital importance in the<br />

risk and business decision-making process.<br />

In the case of retail portfolios, the approach adopted is to include<br />

the risk premium in the management income statement at all levels.<br />

This step has made the Organisation aware of the importance of<br />

proactive risk management and of the need for the correct<br />

measurement of risk, as a result of which it is essential to achieve<br />

absolute quality in elements of risk management such as customer<br />

ratings and the arrangement of additional collateral.<br />

At a strategic level, one of the most important areas for the Bank is<br />

the definition and monitoring of the risk profile based on our risk<br />

appetite. This risk profile is the estimate/projection that the Bank<br />

makes every year for each portfolio using business plans and the<br />

forecasts of the main risk parameters. These projections over<br />

various time horizons make it possible to anticipate and manage<br />

behavioural changes (by cycle, portfolio migration or structural<br />

change in the population) and, accordingly, to detect variances in<br />

the risk profile long before they lead to a deterioration in the<br />

quality of <strong>Banesto</strong>’s investment portfolio.<br />

Stress test: in 2008 a stress model was defined which, in addition<br />

to facilitating the inclusion of any manner of possible or extreme<br />

scenarios and the assessment of their global impact, enables the


Bank to analyse the balance sheet in greater detail, by product,<br />

customer, industry, geographical location, credit quality, etc., to<br />

ascertain which sub-portfolios are most exposed to a given<br />

scenario and its impact thereon.<br />

Once again this serves as an anticipation tool which enables the<br />

Bank to identify niches of customers likely to encounter problems<br />

and customers with good risk profiles and, on the basis of this<br />

information, to define different management strategies.<br />

Strategic risk management: a very important part of the work<br />

performed in the Global Risk Unit concerns “risk intelligence”. This<br />

is probably the component that creates most value added.<br />

The architecture of the risk intelligence used at <strong>Banesto</strong>, which is<br />

based on the development of advanced decision-making models,<br />

has three specific lines of analysis:<br />

• To support decision-making by detecting behavioural changes<br />

in the laboratory.<br />

• To support the Bank in strategic business areas by taking into<br />

account advances in financial markets, such as, inter alia, the<br />

transfer and movement of risk.<br />

• To cooperate with universities and other players, keeping the<br />

Bank up to date and fostering new methodological<br />

developments.<br />

Internal Validation: a critical element of global risk management is<br />

the role performed by Internal Validation as an independent<br />

control team. The fundamental function of this unit is to issue a<br />

well-founded, up-to-date opinion as to whether the models<br />

function as predicted, whether the results obtained (methodology,<br />

databases, qualitative and quantitative matters, usage test) are<br />

appropriate for the different internal and regulatory purposes for<br />

which they are applied, and whether they effectively question the<br />

work of all the areas involved.<br />

In 2008, Internal Validation completed a review of all the advanced<br />

methods and detected areas for improvement which would lead to<br />

greater value for the Entity and its management of the various<br />

risks.<br />

3. New Basel Capital Accord - Basel II - Economic Capital<br />

In 2008 the Bank’s internal-ratings based capital circulation model<br />

(IRB) was approved and it reported its capital requirements to the<br />

Bank of Spain in accordance with this new model in June and<br />

December.<br />

This signifies that in this period the project phase of Basel II was<br />

concluded at the Entity and Basel II became a real part of<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s day-to-day risk and capital management.<br />

In this respect it is becoming increasingly important to continue to<br />

make progress in the matters that underpin the spirit of this<br />

regulation and that require major efforts in the following areas:<br />

methodology, processes, internal control and validation,<br />

technology and the inclusion of all these components in<br />

management.<br />

Accordingly, in 2008 <strong>Banesto</strong> implemented a plan that enabled it<br />

to adapt to the demands that this regulation will impose on all the<br />

areas of its business in the future and to anticipate any possible<br />

future requirements of this dynamic and increasingly demanding<br />

regulation.<br />

The Group's capital management is performed at both regulatory<br />

and economic level.<br />

Regulatory capital management is based on the analysis of the<br />

capital base and the capital ratios (core capital, Tier 1, etc.) using<br />

Basel (“BIS”) and Bank of Spain criteria. The aim is to achieve a<br />

capital structure that is as efficient as possible in terms of both<br />

cost and compliance with the requirements of regulators, ratings<br />

agencies and investors. Active capital management includes<br />

securitisations, sales of assets, and preferred and subordinated<br />

issues of equity and hybrid instruments.<br />

From an economic standpoint, capital management seeks to<br />

optimise value creation at the Group and at its different business<br />

units. To this end, the economic capital, RORAC and value creation<br />

data for each business unit are generated, analysed and reported<br />

to the Management Committee on a quarterly basis.<br />

In order to adequately manage the Group's capital, it is essential<br />

to estimate and analyse future needs, in anticipation of the various<br />

phases of the business cycle. Projections of regulatory and<br />

economic capital are made based on reference to the budgetary<br />

information (balance sheet, income statement, etc.) and to<br />

macroeconomic scenarios defined by the Research Service. The<br />

Group uses these estimates to plan the management measures<br />

(issues, securitisations, etc.) required to achieve its capital targets.<br />

In addition, certain stress scenarios are simulated in order to<br />

assess the availability of capital in adverse situations. These<br />

scenarios are based on sharp fluctuations in macroeconomic<br />

variables such as GDP, interest rates, the stock market, etc. that<br />

mirror historical crises that could happen again.<br />

The Group’s capital management, as regards conceptual<br />

definitions, is in keeping with Bank of Spain Circular 3/2008. In<br />

this connection, the Group considers eligible capital to be that<br />

specified in Rule Eight of Bank of Spain Circular 3/2008.<br />

b. Credit risk<br />

Credit risk is defined as the possibility of a credit institution<br />

incurring a loss stemming from the failure of counterparties to<br />

meet their contractual obligations.<br />

The table below details the distribution, by segment, of the credit<br />

risk exposure to customers in terms of EAD at 31 December 2008.<br />

Millions of Euros EAD %<br />

Corporate banking 16,786 20%<br />

Business banking 31,073 36%<br />

SMEs 5,470 6%<br />

Independent professionals 2,254 3%<br />

Individuals 25,814 30%<br />

Sovereign 4,327 5%<br />

Total 85,724 100%<br />

b.1 Risk acceptance<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s risk acceptance process is structured on the basis of<br />

customer segmentation:<br />

163


164<br />

Retail risk<br />

The risk acceptance processes have been characterised by prudent<br />

and responsible risk management and the adaptation of policies<br />

and systems to the current economic climate.<br />

The strategies established are differentiated by business segment,<br />

which enabled <strong>Banesto</strong> to achieve a high degree of credit quality<br />

and meet its basic operating targets in 2008.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> has in place efficient systems which combine advanced<br />

automatic decision-making models with sound teams of highly<br />

experienced and specialised risk analysts, with a view to achieving<br />

the risk quality objectives the Bank requires.<br />

The Risk Analysis Centre (RAC) is formed by highly specialised<br />

analysts who ensure that the transactions meet the required risk<br />

quality standards and who provide ongoing advisory services to<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s Branch Network regarding the approach to customer<br />

transactions.<br />

The expected loss model in the acceptance of SME transactions<br />

led to an improvement of the analysts’ risk management and<br />

enabled collateral to be adapted to the customer profile. In the<br />

case of Individual Banking, advanced behaviour analysis tools<br />

(scores) are incorporated in risk acceptance and represent an<br />

effective risk assessment and monitoring instrument. In addition, a<br />

value-at-risk model was implemented in Consumer Banking aimed<br />

at maximising the risk-return ratio for high profile customers.<br />

Business banking risk<br />

In accordance with the principle of utmost prudence, which is<br />

appropriate to the current economic situation and is enabling the<br />

Bank to maintain the highest levels of credit quality in the<br />

portfolio, the acceptance of Corporate Network risk commences in<br />

the Business Banking Centres and Regional Offices, which are<br />

delegated certain risk responsibilities by the Bank’s Executive<br />

Committee.<br />

In Central Services the acceptance of business banking risk is<br />

performed, on the one hand, through the Business Banking Risk<br />

Unit, which channels the risk proposals which exceed the scope of<br />

the powers delegated to the Corporate Network, and, on the other<br />

hand, through the Major Customers and Capital Market Unit,<br />

which performs the integral management of a portfolio comprising<br />

the main companies in the segment, thus facilitating a closer<br />

relationship with the customer, greater flexibility in the decisionmaking<br />

processes and the integral management (analysis,<br />

acceptance and monitoring) of investment projects.<br />

The degree of specialisation of the teams and the use of risk<br />

acceptance circuits and rating analysis and assignment tools<br />

specific to the segment ensure the uniform treatment of proposals<br />

for classifying customers’ risks and transactions.<br />

Wholesale risk<br />

The wholesale risk acceptance process focuses on the classification<br />

or assignment of a global limit for each economic group, financial<br />

institution or sovereign debtor and the strict monitoring and<br />

control of this classification, which enables the risk limits and<br />

positions to be managed internally at all times. Also, the Wholesale<br />

Risk Unit specialises in analysing the risk of the investment projects<br />

carried out by the Bank’s customers.<br />

To this end, the team of industry-specialist analysts prepares a risk<br />

report and measures the customer risk by means of a rating based<br />

on the customer’s creditworthiness.<br />

As a result of the strict risk acceptance policy, <strong>Banesto</strong> has a<br />

diversified customer portfolio with a high credit quality.<br />

Accordingly, price simulators and historical and projected RAROC<br />

calculations are of vital importance in the risk and business<br />

decision-making process.<br />

b.2 Risk monitoring<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s risk monitoring process is based on the close monitoring<br />

of the loan transactions granted and of the outstanding risk<br />

exposure. This enables problematic situations to be anticipated<br />

using <strong>Banesto</strong>'s risk monitoring systems and the provision of a<br />

flexible response adapted to each scenario.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s risk monitoring systems are based on the following<br />

cornerstones:<br />

- Risk Anticipation System (SAR), which each month reads 120<br />

representative credit risk variables, including in-house and<br />

external information. This system makes it possible to identify<br />

counterparties requiring special surveillance (the so-called<br />

“FEVE”).<br />

- Periodic review of internal customer ratings.<br />

- Monitoring of non-performing loan agreements.<br />

- Staffing of Regional Offices with specialist professionals.<br />

- Inclusion of risk monitoring tasks in our modus operandi<br />

through various Monitoring Committee meetings held at<br />

Branch, Business Centre, Retail Banking Unit, Regional Office<br />

and even Central Services level.<br />

- Use of tools that enable precise data to be obtained on the<br />

performance of the portfolio.<br />

The risk monitoring process is applied to all the business channels<br />

in order to safeguard the quality of the risks accepted.<br />

b.3 Recovery<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s loan recovery efforts have been adapted to the more<br />

complex economic climate through the creation of instruments<br />

that provide a swift response to new demands, the development of<br />

recovery policies, the application of management specialised in<br />

serving the various customer segments, all of which is underpinned<br />

by cutting-edge technology and the boosting of the resources<br />

allocated to this activity.<br />

The traditional classification policy for cases exceeding a certain<br />

amount was reinforced with an increase in the number of loan<br />

recovery managers -in view of the current economic situation- who<br />

are very goal-oriented, which also enables <strong>Banesto</strong> to focus its loan<br />

recovery strategy on the basis of the type of debt and to pay<br />

immediate attention to each occurrence of default as soon as it


arises. To this end there are managers specialised in Business<br />

Banking whose objective is to technically and efficiently manage<br />

cases of insolvency that are increasingly common in this segment;<br />

specific loan recovery strategies focused on SMEs have been<br />

established and, through individual business plans, <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

manages the individuals who are classified into portfolios, with a<br />

notably high recovery capacity in the mortgage segment<br />

supported by a differentiated management model.<br />

Agreements below a given amount and consumer financing are<br />

handled with the support of an extensive network of external<br />

collection companies and managers, which are evaluated every six<br />

months on the basis of efficiency ratios and are encouraged to<br />

achieve success. These structures underpin the significant recovery<br />

levels of written-off loans to which <strong>Banesto</strong> has always paid special<br />

attention, which demonstrates their capacity to recover loans and<br />

contribute to the income statement.<br />

In 2005 <strong>Banesto</strong> implemented the legal proceedings management<br />

model articulated in the Astrea tool and monitored by the<br />

Procedural Management Centre. In 2008 a new version of the<br />

Loan Recovery Management System was implemented, which will<br />

enhance the efficiency and swiftness of the recovery of loans.<br />

Lastly, the inclusion of the loan recovery activity in the<br />

management and marketing of foreclosed assets enables the Bank<br />

to optimise the divestment process, focussing its recovery efforts<br />

on the obtainment of liquidity. In this connection, a new ambitious<br />

foreclosed property management model is projected for 2009,<br />

which will help intensify the marketing thereof and considerably<br />

enhance efficiency.<br />

b.4 Concentration risk<br />

The Group constantly monitors the degree of concentration, by<br />

geographical area, economic sector, product and customer group,<br />

of its credit risk portfolios and establishes the risk policies and<br />

exposure limits required to ensure adequate management of credit<br />

risk portfolio concentration.<br />

c. Market risk<br />

Market risk is that arising from the uncertainty regarding the future<br />

performance of the markets, which is inherent to the financial<br />

business. In order to measure and control this risk, <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

distinguishes between the management of the risk relating to its<br />

own structural position and the management of its trading<br />

portfolio positions (fixed income and equity securities and<br />

derivatives).<br />

c.1 Interest rate risk<br />

Structural interest rate risk is inherent to the banking business and<br />

arises because the Bank’s balance sheet comprises assets and<br />

liabilities with different repricing and maturity dates. This risk<br />

means that changes in interest rates cause fluctuations in the net<br />

interest margin and the economic value of its capital. <strong>Banesto</strong> aims<br />

to stabilise the net interest margin and, in turn, to maintain the<br />

economic value of its capital. This requires the active management<br />

of interest rate risk by monitoring the Bank’s exposure and taking<br />

positions aimed at mitigating such exposure.<br />

The monitoring of structural risk involves detailed knowledge of the<br />

balance sheet positions and requires the development and<br />

maintenance of systems and models that enable the Bank to<br />

ascertain the behaviour of the aggregates in different interest rate<br />

scenarios. <strong>Banesto</strong> has technological systems that provide all the<br />

salient structural risk information (dates, rates, accruals, etc.) for<br />

each contract on the balance sheet. Also, the Bank has followed a<br />

policy of investing in applications and systems that facilitate the<br />

development of models that provide considerable capacity for risk<br />

analysis. In this connection, in 2008 <strong>Banesto</strong> updated the models<br />

it uses, making it possible to determine the risk of each of the<br />

Bank’s contractual positions in a multidimensional way by<br />

management line, thus providing an additional level of risk<br />

reconciliation with other areas of the Bank.<br />

As a result of the above, the Asset-Liability Committee (ALCO),<br />

which is responsible for structural risk management, uses a<br />

dynamic approach to measure the sensitivity of the net interest<br />

margin and economic value and includes all the simulation factors<br />

in deterministic and stochastic models (reinvestment periods, early<br />

repayment, customer spreads, etc.), so that the simulation models<br />

encompass all the variables with a direct impact on the<br />

measurement of interest rate risk.<br />

The monitoring performed by the Bank focuses on analysing the<br />

behaviour of asset aggregates in different scenarios:<br />

Deterministic models: calculate the sensitivity of the net interest<br />

margin and the economic value to shifts in the interest rate curve.<br />

The sensitivity is calculated as the difference between the net<br />

interest margin and the economic value of capital obtained using<br />

the market curve and other curves that have been subjected to<br />

parallel shifts in all their sections or to changes in the slope, and<br />

focuses mainly on the second year, since this shows the exposure<br />

more clearly once the balance sheet as a whole has been repriced.<br />

Stochastic models: calculate the VaR (Value at Risk) and MaR<br />

(Margin at Risk) as the maximum expected loss with a 97%<br />

confidence level, by randomly creating interest rate scenarios. To<br />

date, the Bank has carried out studies on these simulations on the<br />

basis of the risk-neutral methodologies such as those specified in<br />

the Hull & White model. However, in 2008 the Bank performed<br />

tests with multifactor models which represent more faithfully the<br />

behaviour of interest rates over longer time horizons, such as<br />

Rebonato’s semi-parametric approach.<br />

As a result of the ALCO’s active management of structural balancesheet<br />

risk, <strong>Banesto</strong> has a diversified portfolio of fixed income and<br />

derivative hedging instruments.<br />

Since <strong>Banesto</strong>'s balance sheet is expressed 96.5% in euros, 2.8%<br />

in US dollars and the remaining 0.7% in other currencies, interest<br />

rate risk management focuses on the positions in euros.<br />

The following table shows the maturity and repricing gaps of<br />

assets, liabilities and off-balance-sheet transactions at 31<br />

December 2008:<br />

165


166<br />

c.2 Liquidity risk<br />

The aim of <strong>Banesto</strong>'s basic liquidity risk management strategy is to<br />

ensure that no imbalances arise in meeting the Bank's payment<br />

obligations.<br />

This strategy is complemented by the access to funds at the lowest<br />

possible cost at medium and long term through the maintenance<br />

of an optimum level of liquid assets. Thus, the Bank applies a highly<br />

conservative policy to its positions.<br />

The methodology used by <strong>Banesto</strong> comprises various tools and<br />

measurement systems. These include mainly the preparation of gap<br />

tables, on a daily basis for the shorter terms and with larger<br />

groupings for longer terms.<br />

The Bank always seeks to maintain its net position in money<br />

markets at reasonable levels through the early scheduling of the<br />

financing required in the capital markets and the adoption of<br />

balance-sheet management measures.<br />

Within 3 3 Months 1 to 2 2 to 5 After 5<br />

Millions of Euros<br />

Not<br />

Months to 1 Year Years Years Years Sensitive Total<br />

ASSETS<br />

Money market 10,977 3,340 53 126 62 - 14,558<br />

Credit system 42,417 26,058 2,534 2,894 2,633 - 76,536<br />

Securities portfolio 1,466 3,227 2,490 789 2,923 - 10,895<br />

Other assets - - - - - 10,958 10,958<br />

Total assets<br />

LIABILITIES<br />

54,860 32,625 5,077 3,809 5,618 10,958 112,947<br />

Money market 10,905 6,204 2,287 318 3 - 19,717<br />

Deposit market 18,088 15,257 2,567 5,456 5,272 - 46,640<br />

Issues 10,842 2,263 1,682 5,873 8,775 - 29,435<br />

Other liabilities - - - - - 17,155 17,155<br />

Total liabilities 39,835 23,724 6,536 11,647 14,050 17,155 112,947<br />

Off-balance-sheet transactions (12,422) (3,766) 1,001 5,073 10,114 -<br />

Simple gap 2,603 5,135 (458) (2,765) 1,682 (6,197)<br />

Cumulative gap 2,603 7,738 7,280 4,515 6,197 -<br />

Sensitivity ratios:<br />

Assets-liabilities/total assets 13,30% 7,88% (1,29%) (6,94%) (7,47%) (5,49%)<br />

Simple gap/total assets 2,30% 4,55% (0,41%) (2,45%) 1,49% (5,49%)<br />

Cumulative gap/total assets 2,30% 6,85% 6,45% 4,00% 5,49% -<br />

Coverage ratio:<br />

Sensitive assets/sensitive liabilities 137,72% 137,52% 77,68% 32,70% 39,99% 63,88%<br />

Additionally, interest rate and liquidity risk management is<br />

supplemented with stress-testing scenarios which offer information<br />

on the interest rate and liquidity risks in the event of extreme<br />

situations or market crises. In this connection, in a year in which<br />

market liquidity was somewhat restrictive, extensive simulations<br />

were performed on the Bank’s funding requirements on the basis of<br />

the financing from current accounts and deposits, and the Bank<br />

reanalysed the main concepts of the contingency plans established<br />

to cater for possible liquidity crises in the markets.<br />

The following table shows the maturity gaps of assets and liabilities<br />

in millions of euros at 31 December 2008, which can be used as a<br />

basis for the analysis of liquidity.


These gaps reflect a typical commercial banking structure with a<br />

high percentage of demand deposit financing.<br />

c.3 Other market risks<br />

In addition to interest rate and liquidity risk, the Group is exposed<br />

to the effects of future fluctuations in exchange rates. However, as<br />

a result of its strategic approach, the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group's currency<br />

positions are scantly material and it adopts a policy of hedging any<br />

structural currency positions.<br />

c.4 Capital market risk<br />

The market risks affecting capital markets activity (interest rates,<br />

exchange rates, equities, credit spreads, implicit volatilities,<br />

correlations, etc.) are managed and controlled by the Market Risk<br />

Unit using a standard historical simulation Value-at-Risk (VaR)<br />

methodology. VaR provides a standardised risk figure which<br />

represents the maximum expected loss as a result of adverse<br />

fluctuations in the market with a confidence level of 99%. At<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>, VaR is calculated and reported to senior management<br />

every day and is controlled by a system of limits that affect the<br />

overall position and each of the portfolios that constitute the<br />

operations. Senior management is permanently informed of and<br />

involved in market risk management through fortnightly committee<br />

meetings under the auspices of the Risk Standing Committee and<br />

through the ALCO.<br />

In 2008 the levels of risk remained at all times within the approved<br />

limits, even at times of greater instability in the financial markets.<br />

The daily average VaR during the year was around EUR 4.9 million,<br />

of which EUR 2.2 million reflect the level of market risk actually<br />

assumed and EUR 2.7 million relate to other technical market risks<br />

that are systematically covered by provisions pursuant to <strong>Banesto</strong>’s<br />

policy.<br />

Within 3 3 Months 1 to 2 2 to 5 After 5<br />

Millions of Euros<br />

Not<br />

Months to 1 Year Years Years Years Sensitive Total<br />

ASSETS<br />

Money market 10,368 3,340 53 126 672 - 14,559<br />

Credit system 13,051 16,019 9,229 15,339 22,896 - 76,534<br />

Securities portfolio 527 3,232 2,549 834 3,754 - 10,896<br />

Other assets - - - - - 10,958 10,958<br />

Total assets<br />

LIABILITIES<br />

23,946 22,591 11,831 16,299 27,322 10,958 112,947<br />

Money market 10,905 6,204 2,287 318 3 - 19,717<br />

Deposit market 9,468 15,993 6,529 8,614 6,022 14 46,640<br />

Issues 2,480 5,067 3,281 8,002 10,605 - 29,435<br />

Other liabilities - - - - - 17,155 17,155<br />

Total liabilities 22,853 27,264 12,097 16,934 16,630 17,169 112,947<br />

Simple gap 1,093 (4,673) (266) (635) 10,692 (6,211)<br />

Cumulative gap 1,093 (3,580) (3,846) (4,481) 6,211<br />

The measurement of market risk using VaR is supplemented by an<br />

analysis of stress scenarios in which the impact of certain extreme<br />

events on the value of the portfolios is simulated. This enables<br />

historical and hypothetical scenarios with various degrees of<br />

severity and plausibility to be assessed, and the conclusions drawn<br />

are discussed with senior management on a regular basis through<br />

the aforementioned reporting cycles. <strong>Banesto</strong> regularly estimates<br />

the extreme losses that might occur if the VaR level were to be<br />

exceeded by using the statistical conditional VaR, which is also<br />

reported to senior management on a daily basis and analysed in<br />

depth by the aforementioned committees. Throughout 2008<br />

conditional VaR remained at around EUR 7.0 million.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s market risk measurement model has been submitted for<br />

approval by the Bank of Spain with a view to being used as an<br />

internal model for calculating minimum capital in this area. The<br />

pertinent audits of the model prior to its submission to the<br />

supervisor were conducted successfully in 2008, and the related<br />

inspection is in progress. <strong>Banesto</strong> internally monitors and refines<br />

the quality of the model on an ongoing basis using back testing<br />

techniques which systematically compare the model’s predictions<br />

with the actual results of treasury activities. The results of the back<br />

testing were checked by the Group’s audit departments and by<br />

ratings agencies, and complied with the requirements<br />

recommended by international regulators.<br />

Risks and results in 2008<br />

a) Trading<br />

The average VaR profile assumed in 2008 was EUR 4,900<br />

thousand.<br />

167


168<br />

b) Balance sheet management<br />

At 31 December 2008, the sensitivity of the net interest margin at<br />

one year to parallel falls of 100 b.p. was negative by EUR 60<br />

million (4.0%).<br />

For the same timeframe the sensitivity of economic value to parallel<br />

increases of 100 b.p. in the curve amounted to EUR 106 million at<br />

31 December 2008 (1.2%).<br />

d. Operational risk<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>'s operational risk management model was defined in<br />

accordance with the Basel II Accord, the EU directive on capital<br />

requirements for credit institutions and Bank of Spain Circular<br />

3/2008.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s main operational risk management objectives are:<br />

- Identify and eliminate any clusters of operational risk before<br />

they give rise to losses.<br />

- Reduce operational risk losses by establishing mitigation plans<br />

based on the type of risk and the business in question.<br />

In order to fulfil these objectives, in 2008 the Bank concluded<br />

the implementation of a wide range of qualitative and<br />

quantitative operational risk management tools, taking full<br />

advantage of the advanced technology and information<br />

systems available to it.<br />

In 2008 the Bank defined and implemented the NORMA<br />

project which covers five areas of operational risk of the<br />

commercial network (cash management, standardisation of<br />

operations and documentation, security, order and reputation<br />

and other operational risks) and establishes a series of<br />

measures with the following objectives:<br />

- Improve the practices and behaviours of the key areas of the<br />

project.<br />

- Reduce the events and losses of each type of risk to an<br />

efficient threshold.<br />

- Incorporate the business management view in the operational<br />

risk management of the network.<br />

- Consolidate the results in a series of indicators suitable for all<br />

the echelons of the organisation.<br />

As illustrated in the preceding paragraph, the scope of the<br />

Operational Risk Indicators tool has increased and the number of<br />

these indicators in the database has doubled. The measurements<br />

of these indicators are automatically obtained on a regular basis,<br />

which enables the Bank to establish a system of alerts through the<br />

corresponding analysis of the appropriate intervals for each<br />

indicator. In the future a study will be carried out on the<br />

relationship between these indicators and the effective losses<br />

arising from operational risk.<br />

In 2008 the knowledge and active management of operational risk<br />

in the entire organisation was enhanced through the creation of<br />

Regional Operational Risk Committees. Additionally, the work of<br />

the Central Operational Risk Committee, the body created in 2004<br />

to reduce operational risk and support the implementation of<br />

mitigation measures, was rewarded by a decrease in operational risk<br />

losses, which was especially notable in the following types of risk:<br />

execution, customer practices and systems incidents.<br />

The Loss Database was implemented five years ago and, as a result<br />

of its level of automation and detail in capturing data, all the Bank’s<br />

centres, in particular all the branches, are immediately aware of all<br />

operational risk events affecting them. This database has also<br />

enabled <strong>Banesto</strong> to prepare reports on a comparative basis with<br />

other entities and, in particular, with the Spanish entities forming<br />

part of the international consortium known as the Operational<br />

Riskdata eXchange Association (ORX).<br />

The information obtained through the self-assessment<br />

questionnaires performed in 2008 is enabling the Entity to<br />

prepare its risk map in greater detail and to prioritise the actions<br />

to be taken in each area assessed.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>’s Operational Risk Department is also responsible for the<br />

project to prepare a Business Continuity Plan on the basis of the<br />

critical processes detected by the various areas and their<br />

requirements to continue operating in the event of a serious<br />

contingency. This Plan is being developed in accordance with<br />

industry regulations and best practices. In this connection,<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> is a member of the Spanish Business Continuity<br />

Consortium and participates actively in the Definitions and<br />

Coordination with Critical Industries and Institutions Working<br />

Groups.<br />

e. Environmental risk<br />

For several years <strong>Banesto</strong> has applied a methodology that assesses<br />

a customer’s environmental risk in its corporate banking business.<br />

The environmental assessment of a customer acts both as an<br />

opportunity, enabling the Bank to finance investment projects that<br />

aim to protect the environment, and as a threat, since it assesses<br />

the risk of a customer that ignores the environmental implications<br />

of its business.<br />

Environmental assessment attaches weights to both the industry<br />

category and a series of variables that involve a greater or lesser<br />

degree of risk. Such variables range from compliance with the<br />

profuse specific environmental legislation for each industry to<br />

litigation and claims in progress, levels of waste emissions,<br />

discharges and production, the corrective measures adopted and<br />

the environmental quality certifications obtained.<br />

The ultimate aim of this methodology is to identify, within the<br />

credit risk analysis process, the environmental risk factors and the<br />

measures adopted by our customers to mitigate and eliminate<br />

them. Environmental risk is measured using a rating system that<br />

analyses these factors. At present, the Bank’s main corporate<br />

customers have an environmental rating assigned to them to be<br />

taken into account in the analysis of the risks of each of these<br />

customers.<br />

f. Reputational risk<br />

At <strong>Banesto</strong> reputational risk is considered to be a very important<br />

factor in our decision-making processes.<br />

Reputational risk can be defined as the possible impairment of the<br />

image, prestige or reputation of an entity resulting from the<br />

perception held by third parties of its actions.<br />

This risk is independent from the credit and/or economic risks<br />

inherent in the Bank's operations and from the legal risk that may<br />

arise in the performance and instrumentation thereof. It is<br />

therefore to be regarded as a risk that is additional to any other<br />

risk borne.


g. Risk concentration<br />

Although <strong>Banesto</strong> has positions that are deemed to be “large<br />

exposures”, they are far below the maximum risk concentration limit<br />

set by Bank of Spain Circular 3/2008.<br />

The distribution of the loan portfolio by customer segment is<br />

included in Note 48-b and the distribution by geographical area is<br />

included in Note 10.<br />

Other disclosures<br />

In light of the exceptional circumstances that arose in the<br />

international financial markets, mainly in the second half of 2008,<br />

European governments undertook to adopt the appropriate<br />

measures to seek to resolve the banks’ financing difficulties and<br />

their impact on the real economy, with a view to preserving the<br />

stability of the international financial system. The main objectives<br />

of these measures were as follows: to ensure the appropriate<br />

liquidity conditions for the functioning of the financial institutions;<br />

to facilitate financial institutions’ access to financing; to establish<br />

the mechanisms that will make it possible, where appropriate, to<br />

provide additional capital resources to the financial institutions<br />

that guarantee the functioning of the economy; to ensure that<br />

accounting regulations are sufficiently flexible to take into account<br />

the exceptional market circumstances; and to reinforce and improve<br />

the mechanisms for coordination between European countries.<br />

Within this general framework, in the last quarter of 2008 the<br />

following measures were approved in Spain:<br />

- Royal Decree-Law 6/2008, of 10 October, creating the Fund<br />

for the acquisition of financial assets (“FAAF”), and Ministry of<br />

Economy and Finance Order EHA/3118/2008, of 31 October,<br />

implementing the aforementioned Royal Decree-Law. The<br />

purpose of the FAAF, which is under the auspices of the<br />

Ministry of Economy and Finance and was allocated an initial<br />

contribution of EUR 30,000 million, extendable to EUR<br />

50,000 million, is to use Public Treasury money and market<br />

criteria to acquire, by means of the auction procedure, financial<br />

instruments issued by Spanish credit institutions and<br />

securitisation special-purpose vehicles, backed by loans<br />

granted to individuals, companies and non-financial entities.<br />

- Royal Decree-Law 7/2008, of 13 October, on Urgent<br />

Economic Measures in relation to the Concerted European<br />

Action Plan of the Euro Area Countries, and Ministry of<br />

Economy and Finance Order EHA/3364/2008, of 21<br />

November, implementing Article 1 of the aforementioned Royal<br />

Decree-Law, which includes the following measures:<br />

• On the one hand, the grant of State guarantees to the issues<br />

of promissory notes, bonds and debentures launched on or<br />

after 14 October 2008 by credit institutions resident in<br />

Spain which meet certain requirements: they are individual<br />

transactions or part of issue programmes; they are not<br />

subordinated debt or debt secured by other types of<br />

collateral; they are admitted for trading on official Spanish<br />

secondary markets; they mature at between three months<br />

and three years, extendable to five years on the basis of a<br />

report from the Bank of Spain; the interest rate is fixed or<br />

floating, although there are special requirements for issues<br />

with a floating interest rate; they must be redeemed in one<br />

single payment and they must not include options or other<br />

financial instruments, and the nominal value must not be<br />

below EUR 10 million. The period for granting guarantees will<br />

end on 31 December 2009 and the maximum total amount<br />

of guarantees to be granted in 2008 will be EUR 100,000<br />

million.<br />

• On the other hand, the exceptional authorisation, until 31<br />

December 2009, for the Ministry of Economy and Finance to<br />

acquire securities, including preference shares and nonvoting<br />

equity units, issued by credit institutions resident in<br />

Spain which need to strengthen their capital and request as<br />

such.<br />

The Bank’s directors, in accordance with their risk management<br />

policies, have the possibility of adopting the aforementioned<br />

measures.<br />

49. Explanation added for translation to<br />

English<br />

These consolidated financial statements are presented on the basis<br />

of IFRSs as adopted by the European Union. Certain accounting<br />

practices applied by the Group that conform with IFRSs may not<br />

conform with other generally accepted accounting principles.<br />

169


170<br />

Appendix I<br />

Subsidiaries Composing the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group at 31 December 2008<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Company Data at<br />

Percentage of Ownership 31 December 2008<br />

Profit<br />

Entity Location Line of Business Direct Indirect Total Assets Liabilities Equity (Loss) (*)<br />

Agrícola Tabaibal, S.A. Gran Canaria Agriculture - 74.18 74.18 1,440 1,293 86 61<br />

Alcaidesa Holding, S.A. Cádiz Real estate - 50.00 50.00 116,146 48,396 77,045 (9,295)<br />

Alhambra 2000, S.L. Madrid Vehicle wash - 100.00 100.00 3,347 2 3,149 196<br />

Aljarafe Golf, S.A. Seville Real estate - 89.41 89.41 14,264 332 14,004 (72)<br />

Bajondillo, S.A. Madrid Real estate 74.00 26.00 100.00 384 359 26 (1)<br />

Banco Alicantino de Comercio, S.A. Madrid Banking 99.99 0.01 100.00 9,119 24 9,088 7<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Banca Privada Gestión, S.A. S.G.I.I.C. Madrid Investment fund manager 99.99 0.01 100.00 2,999 569 2,414 16<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Banco de Emisiones, S.A. Madrid Banking 99.99 0.01 100.00 9,865,798 9,764,737 100,412 919<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Bolsa, S.A., Sdad. Valores y Bolsa Madrid Stock market 99.99 0.01 100.00 479,111 367,092 103,453 8,566<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Factoring, S.A Establecimiento Financiero de Crédito Madrid Factoring 99.97 0.03 100.00 2,283,946 2,158,712 115,639 9,595<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Financial Products, PLC. Ireland Finance 99.94 0.06 100.00 7,510,201 7,509,811 314 76<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Holdings, Ltd Guernsey Securities investment 100.00 - 100.00 47,733 218 47,430 85<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Preferentes, S.A. Madrid Finance 99.76 0.24 100.00 131,724 131,523 159 42<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Renting, S.A. Madrid Finance 99.99 0.01 100.00 379,204 366,790 10,381 2,033<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> Securities, Inc. New York Finance - 100.00 100.00 3,328 146 2,575 607<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong>, S.A. Madrid Finance 74.00 26.00 100.00 49 1 50 (2)<br />

Beta Cero, S.A. Madrid Finance 74.00 14.00 88.00 26 1 37 (12)<br />

Caja de Emisiones y Anualidades Debidas por el Estado Madrid Finance 62.87 - 62.87 69 18 62 (11)<br />

Clínica Sear, S.A. Madrid Healthcare 50.58 - 50.58 15,047 10,295 5,185 (433)<br />

Club Zaudin Golf, S.A. Seville Services - 85.03 85.03 20,822 6,048 14,986 (122))<br />

Corpoban, S.A. Madrid Securities investment - 100.00 100.00 76,471 2 73,477 2,992<br />

Costa Canaria de Veneguera, S.A. Gran Canaria Real estate 37.08 37.10 74.18 16,127 2,705 13,468 (46)<br />

(*) The companies' results at 31 December 2008 have not yet been approved by the respective Annual General Meetings.<br />

Note: The directors have opted to omit the net amounts of these investments recognised in the Bank's books on the grounds that, since certain of these companies are undergoing restructuring and/or a sale process, the disclosure of such information might be prejudicial both for the Bank and for the companies<br />

themselves.


Appendix I (cont.)<br />

Subsidiaries Composing the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group at 31 December 2008<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Company Data at<br />

Percentage of Ownership 31 December 2008<br />

Profit<br />

Entity Location Line of Business Direct Indirect Total Assets Liabilities Equity (Loss) (*)<br />

Depósitos Portuarios, S.A. Madrid Services 99.95 0.05 100.00 823 528 458 (163)<br />

Diseño e Integración de Soluciones, S.A. Madrid IT 99.99 0.01 100.00 2,982 310 2,601 71<br />

Dudebasa, S.A. Madrid Finance 99.99 0.01 100.00 46,456 14,199 46,088 (13,831)<br />

Efearvi, S.A. Madrid Real estate - 100.00 100.00 2,010 2,525 (447) (68)<br />

Elerco, S.A. Madrid Leasing 53.38 46.62 100.00 818,562 557,009 284,810 (23,257)<br />

Formación Integral, S.A. Madrid Training 99.99 0.01 100.00 1,779 482 1,286 11<br />

Gedinver e Inmuebles, S.A. Madrid Finance 99.99 0.01 100.00 6,633 345 6,153 135<br />

Gescoban Soluciones, S.A. Madrid Finance 99.99 0.01 100.00 8,969 3,966 3,344 1,659<br />

Grupo Inmobiliario La Corporación <strong>Banesto</strong>, S.A. Madrid Securities investment 99.99 0.01 100.00 50,952 43,059 11,706 (3,813)<br />

Hualle, S.A. Madrid Securities investment 99.99 0.01 100.00 84,149 2,549 46,618 34,982<br />

Inversiones Turísticas, S.A. Sevilla Hospitality - 100.00 100.00 945,717 925,506 4,910 15,301<br />

Larix Chile Inversiones, Ltd. Chile Real estate - 100.00 100.00 94 189 32 (127)<br />

Larix Spain, S.L. Isle of Man Real estate - 100.00 100.00 1,249 75 1,323 (149)<br />

Mercado de Dinero, S.A. Madrid Securities investment 74.00 26.00 100.00 500 206 293 1<br />

Merciver, S.L. Madrid Shipping 99.91 0.09 100.00 1,147,643 1,147,633 101 (91)<br />

Oil-Dor, S.A. Madrid Service stations 99.99 0.01 100.00 152,833 123 148,876 3,834<br />

Programa Hogar Montigalá, S.A. Madrid Real estate 0.05 99.95 100.00 374,194 372,633 7,674 (6,113)<br />

Promodomus Desarrollo de Activos, S.L. Madrid Real estate - 51.01 51.01 589,189 587,977 2,000 (788)<br />

Sodepro, S.A. Vitoria Finance 99.99 0.01 100.00 15,659 1 15,067 591<br />

Wex Point España, S.L. Madrid Services 99.98 0.02 100.00 2,092 1,086 1,177 (171)<br />

(*)The companies' results at 31 December 2008 have not yet been approved by the respective Annual General Meetings<br />

Note:The directors have opted to omit the net amounts of these investments recognised in the Bank's books on the grounds that, since certain of these companies are undergoing restructuring and/or a sale process, the disclosure of such information might be prejudicial both for the Bank and for the companies<br />

themselves.<br />

171


172<br />

Appendix II<br />

The <strong>Banesto</strong> Group's Joint Ventures at 31 December 2008<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Company Data at<br />

Percentage of Ownership 31 December 2008<br />

Profit<br />

Entity Location Line of Business Direct Indirect Total Assets Liabilities Equity (Loss) (*)<br />

Espais Promocat, S.L. Barcelona Real estate - 50.00 50.00 27,636 26,574 1,375 (313)<br />

Habitat Elpi, S.L. Barcelona Real estate - 50.00 50.00 7,296 6,151 5,894 (4,749)<br />

Inmobiliaria Sitio de Baldeazores, S.A. Madrid Real estate - 50.00 50.00 4,300 8,981 2,264 (6,945)<br />

Kassadesing 2005, S.L. Madrid Real estate - 50.00 50.00 63,502 53,271 12,771 (2,540)<br />

Prodesur Mediterráneo, S.L. Alicante Real estate - 50.00 50.00 63,596 44,471 20,106 (981)<br />

Proinsur Mediterráneo, S.L. Alicante Real estate - 50.00 50.00 75,712 52,887 30,244 (7,419)<br />

Santander Asset Management, S.A., S.G.I.I.C. Madrid Investment fund manager 20.00 - 20.00 306,982 212,827 45,247 48,908<br />

Santander Pensiones E.G.F.P., S.A. Madrid Pension fund manager 20.00 - 20.00 81,621 31,643 35,955 14,023<br />

Santander Seguros y Reaseguros, Cía. Aseguradora Madrid Insurance 39.00 - 39.00 13,271,450 12,810,958 367,844 92,648<br />

(*) The companies' results at 31 December 2008 have not yet been approved by the respective Annual General Meetings..<br />

Note:The directors have opted to omit the net amounts of these investments recognised in the Bank's books on the grounds that, since certain of these companies are undergoing restructuring and/or a sale process, the disclosure of such information might be prejudicial both for the Bank and for the companies<br />

themselves.


Appendix III<br />

Associates of the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group 31 December 2008<br />

The major companies (representing 100% of direct investments in associates and 99% at Banco Español de Crédito Group level) are included in this list:<br />

Thousands of Euros<br />

Company Data<br />

Percentage of Ownership at 31 December 2008<br />

Profit<br />

Associate Location Line of Business Direct Indirect Total Assets Liabilities Equity Loss) (*)<br />

Agres, Agrupación Restauradores, S.L. Madrid Restaurants - 43.01 43.01 3,669 1,255 2,050 364<br />

Aguas de Fuensanta, S.A. Asturias Food 36.78 5.43 42.21 35,080 25,931 9,460 (311)<br />

Carnes Estellés, S.A. Valencia Food 21.41 - 21.41 35,633 26,313 9,049 271<br />

Cartera del Norte, S.A. Asturias Finance 36.10 - 36.10 1,064 13 1,053 (2)<br />

Centro Desarrollo Invest. Apli. Nuevas Tecnologías Madrid Technology 49.00 - 49.00 1,124 109 1,012 3<br />

Compañía Concesionaria del Túnel de Soller, S.A. Palma de Mallorca Construction 32.70 - 32.70 47,234 27,920 18,886 428<br />

Grupo Alimentario de Exclusivas, S.A. Asturias Food 40.46 - 40.46 6,784 6,497 277 10<br />

Sistemas 4B, S.A. Madrid Services 14.70 - 14.70 228,673 169,927 7,053 51,693<br />

(*)The companies' results at 31 December 2008 have not yet been approved by the respective Annual General Meetings.<br />

Note:The directors have opted to omit the net amounts of these investments recognised in the Bank's books on the grounds that, since certain of these companies are undergoing restructuring and/or a sale process, the disclosure of such information might be prejudicial for the Bank.<br />

173


174<br />

Appendix IV<br />

Notifications of Acquisitions of Investees at 31 December 2008<br />

(Art. 86 of the Consolidated Companies Law and Art. 53 of Securities Market Law 24/1988):<br />

THOUSANDS OF EUROS<br />

Percentage of Net<br />

Ownership<br />

Line of Acquired At Year<br />

Date of<br />

Notification<br />

Investee Business in the Year End to Investee<br />

Acquisitions in 2008:<br />

Promodomus Desarrollo de Activos, S.L. Real estate 100.00% 51.00% 06/06/08


Appendix V<br />

List of agents to whom Bank of Spain Circular 5/1995 is applicable<br />

Location Area of Activity<br />

A.L.M. Finanzas y Créditos de La Mancha, S.L. Manzanares Castilla-La Mancha<br />

Abu Road, S.L. Marbella Andalucía<br />

Agencia Financiera Ulloa, S.L. Culleredo Galicia<br />

Agentes Financieros Reunidos, S.L. Motril Andalucía<br />

Agility Financial S.L. Xirivella Valencia<br />

Alpasugui Agente Financiero, S.L. Roquetas Mar Andalucía<br />

Alto Quintana, S.L. El Barraco Castilla-León<br />

Anagan Financiera, S XXI S.L. Sabiñánigo Aragón<br />

Anagan Gestión S XXI S.L. Agreda Castilla-León<br />

Ancuegar, S.L. Palencia Castilla-León<br />

Arespa Gijón Asociados, S.L. Gijón P. de Asturias<br />

Arión Financial Services, S.L. Madrid Madrid<br />

Arjona Financiaciones, S.L. Arjona Andalucía<br />

Asefisco Palma, S.L. Palma del Río Andalucía<br />

Asemar Financiera, S.L. Rojales C. Valenciana<br />

Aser Financieros, S.L. Galdácano País Vasco<br />

Asesores Financieros de Almendralejo, S.L. Almendralejo Extremadura<br />

Asesoría Tilco, S.L. Zamora Castilla-León<br />

Azorva Patrimonio e Inversión, S.L. Yecla C. Valenciana<br />

Balance Activo, S.L. Lliria C. Valenciana<br />

Bamarval 2008 Zaragoza Aragón<br />

Banefinsa, S.L. Santa Fé Andalucía<br />

Banescomtf, S.L. S.C.Tenerife Canarias<br />

Banesfinance S.L. Sabadell Cataluña<br />

Banest Blanes, S.L. Blanes Cataluña<br />

Banfortunia, S.L. Alcalá de Henares Madrid<br />

Bangencia Aranjuez S.L. Aranjuez Madrid<br />

Banking Solutions, S.L. Rivas Madrid<br />

BNT 2008 Agentes Financieros S.L. Almansa Castilla-La Mancha<br />

Bopecon Inversiones S.L. Sevilla Andalucía<br />

Botello Ollero, Ricardo Majadahonda Madrid<br />

Business Rokers, S.L. Alhaurín de la Torre Andalucía<br />

Bustos Zamora, Miguel Angel Madrid Madrid<br />

BW Capnorth Servicios Financieros y Banc Barbastro Aragón<br />

Carramigal, S.L. Madrid Madrid<br />

175


176<br />

Appendix V (cont.)<br />

List of agents to whom Bank of Spain Circular 5/1995 is applicable<br />

Location Area of Activity<br />

Cerda Gil, Miguel Angel Elche C. Valenciana<br />

Cetinve S.L. Dos Hermanas Andalucía<br />

Charuma, S.L. Sevilla Andalucía<br />

Codelva Gestión S.L. Burgos Castilla-León<br />

Conejos Sánchez, José Ramón S.Antonio Benageber C. Valenciana<br />

Consultores Financieros Leoneses, S.L. León Castilla-León<br />

Credelia, S.L. Murcia Murcia<br />

División Servicios Financieros, S.L. Cáceres Extremadura<br />

Drimty, S.L. Mutxamiel C. Valenciana<br />

Ema Villatorrada 2007 S.L. Sant Joan de Vilatorrada Cataluña<br />

Esteve Gilera, Albert Gelida Cataluña<br />

Financeres Aro, S.L. Alcarras Cataluña<br />

Financiaciones Las Cabezas S.L. Las Cabezas de San Juan Andalucía<br />

Fínanlex, S.L. Llombai C. Valenciana<br />

Finansando, S.L. Algaba Andalucía<br />

Finanzas Boadilla, S.L. Boadilla del Monte Madrid<br />

Finanzas y Servicios de Pueblo López, S.L. Fuengirola Andalucía<br />

Franquicies Financeres Lleida, S.L. Lleida Cataluña<br />

G.S.G. Grupo Corporativo de Servicios, S.L. Madrid Madrid<br />

Garcia Bejar, Francisco Terrassa Cataluña<br />

Garrido Garrido, Pedro Villarrubia Ojos Castilla-La Mancha y Extremadura<br />

Gessinelx, S.L. Elche C. Valenciana<br />

Gestión 5 Servicios Financieros, S.L. Málaga Andalucía<br />

Gestión Financiera Madrid Norte S.L. Alcobendas Madrid<br />

Gestión Financiera Malacitana 2007, S.L. Málaga Andalucía<br />

Gestiones e Inversiones Alper, S.L. Salceda de Caselas Galicia<br />

Gesvalor Financiación y Vida, S.L. Tarazona Aragón<br />

Gil Senis, Francisco Javier Benisano C. Valenciana<br />

González y Naves, S.L. Oviedo Asturias<br />

Grup Arca Oliana, S.L. Oliana Cataluña<br />

Grup Bbr Gestio Privada, S.L. Mora D’Ebre Cataluña<br />

Grupo Bruvimar Asesores, S.L. Palafolls Cataluña<br />

Inficlunan, S.L. Málaga Andalucía<br />

Interalde 2003, S.L. Valle de Trapaga País Vasco<br />

Inversiones Martuchi S.L. Madrid Madrid<br />

Inversiones Utreranas, S.L. Utrera Andalucía<br />

Inversiones y Finanzas Tres Cantos, S.L. Tres Cantos Madrid<br />

Inveya S.L. Alicante Alicante<br />

Isalos Agente Financiero S.L. Málaga Andalucía<br />

Isamer Financieros, S.L. San Pedro de Alcántara Andalucía<br />

Joluanca 2006, S.L. Bormujos Andalucía<br />

José Manuel García Morante, S.L. Granada Andalucía<br />

Julia López García, S.L. Miguel Esteban Castilla-La Mancha<br />

Lagrebas S.L. Madrid Madrid<br />

Lap Asturias, S.L. Nava Asturias<br />

Lastras Audismar, S.L. Pelayos de la Presa Madrid<br />

Marcos Sánchez, Antonio Palencia Castilla-León


Appendix V (cont.)<br />

List of agents to whom Bank of Spain Circular 5/1995 is applicable<br />

Location Area of Activity<br />

Martínez Martínez, Vicente Demetrio Valencia C. Valenciana<br />

Meda Financiera, S.L. Arteixo Galicia<br />

Mejia Lancharro, Antonio Móstoles Madrid<br />

Molina Cortés, Nicolás Plasencia Extremadura<br />

Moraleda Zúñiga, Mario Piedrabuena Castilla–La Mancha<br />

Muñoz Rodríguez, Segundo Mazarrón Murcia<br />

Navarro Gopar, Juan Teodosio Las Palmas de G.C. Canarias<br />

Nubarpol S.L. Gelves Andalucía<br />

Ocendihe Servicios Integrales Financiero Las Palmas de G.C. Canarias<br />

Oliver Sanso, Mateo Ciudadela Baleares<br />

Palmero e Hijos, S.L. La Laguna Canarias<br />

Pelaez García, José María Rute Andalucía<br />

Perea Sierra, José Pilas Andalucía<br />

Plaza Fernández, Rosario Casas de Benítez Castilla-La Mancha<br />

Premiun Corredor Henares S.L. Alcalá de Henares Madrid<br />

Pujol Carrera, Ramón Bellver de Cerdanya Cataluña<br />

Rc 2007 Financieros, S.L. Benahavis Andalucía<br />

Reig Mascarell, Fernando Denia C. Valenciana<br />

Rodríguez Cals Financiera, S.L. Estepona Andalucía<br />

Romero Carmona, Manuel Puebla del Río Andalucía<br />

Rusalea Finance S.L. Madrid Madrid<br />

Sánchez Cañadell, Carlos Terrassa Cataluña<br />

Sánchez Cuñado, Mercedes Viator Andalucía<br />

Sánchez Garzón, José Granada Andalucía<br />

Sánchez Hernández, Alexis La Minilla Canarias<br />

Sánchez Solera, Felipe Hontanaya Castilla-La Mancha<br />

Serarols Associats, S.L. Berga Cataluña<br />

Serban Marbella, S.L. Marbella Andalucía<br />

Sercon Asfico Agentes Financieros, S.L. Oleiros Galicia<br />

Sersaf, S.L. Sevilla Andalucía<br />

Servicios Financieros Mantua S.L. Villamanta Madrid<br />

Servicios Integrales Nase S.L. Naquera C. Valenciana<br />

Seva Hernández, Francisco Antonio Alicante Alicante<br />

Sismoint, S.L. Esparraguera Cataluña<br />

Soluciones de Patrimonio e Inversión, S.L. Colmenar Viejo Madrid<br />

Soluciones Finan 2 S.L. Capellades Cataluña<br />

Suarez Saudinos, Antonio Peñacastillo Cantabria<br />

Tevar Marcilla S.L. Quintanar Rey Castilla-La Mancha<br />

Tinto Santarosa, S.L. Huelva Andalucía<br />

Tomás Berlango, Antonio Jesús Sant Boi de Llobregat Cataluña<br />

Torres Financiación S.C.A. Dos Torres Andalucía<br />

Tramygest Financiera, S.L. Guardamar del Segura C. Valenciana<br />

Trezavilla, S.L. Sevilla Andalucía<br />

Tribaldos Villar del Saz, María Josefa La Alberca de Záncara Castilla–La Mancha<br />

Unión Gestora Extremeña S.L. Badajoz Extremadura<br />

Zisco Finanzas S.L. Alcorcón Madrid<br />

177


178<br />

Translation of a report originally issued in Spanish. In the event of a discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails..<br />

Banco Español<br />

de Crédito Group<br />

Business performance and situation of the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group<br />

2008 proved to be a much more challenging year in economic<br />

terms than forecast, with significant declines in economic activity<br />

and tension in the markets that triggered a considerable drop in<br />

the pace of business growth, together with a sharp increase in<br />

default rates in the financial system.<br />

Against this difficult backdrop, because it chose the right<br />

management priorities, <strong>Banesto</strong> obtained an excellent set of<br />

commercial and financial results, which will enable it to face the<br />

coming years with a very strong equity position.<br />

<strong>Banesto</strong> obtained profit before tax of EUR 1,081,287 thousand,<br />

1.6% less than in 2007. After deducting the income tax expense,<br />

the consolidated profit for the year was EUR 775,009 thousand,<br />

up 1.5%. Lastly, after deducting minority interests, profit<br />

attributable to the Group amounted to EUR 779,844 thousand,<br />

2.0% more than in the previous year.<br />

The changes in the income statement items were as follows:<br />

Net interest income rose by 15.7% to EUR 233,220 thousand.<br />

Amidst a highly competitive environment, this improvement is the<br />

result of selective investment growth, an emphasis on attracting<br />

deposits and sound management of margins and the balance<br />

sheet.<br />

Net fees and commissions were 3.3% lower as a result of a decline<br />

in investment fund and pension fund management fees, due to the<br />

shift in commercial policy towards attracting on-balance-sheet<br />

deposits and a significant increase in fees and commissions for<br />

services, which recorded year-on-year growth of 8.7%. Together<br />

with the gains on financial assets and liabilities and exchange<br />

differences, resulting mainly from the distribution of cash products<br />

to customers, this led to 7.0% growth in gross income.<br />

The trend in personnel expenses and other general administrative<br />

expenses, which fell by 1.0%, and depreciation and amortisation,<br />

which rose by 2.8%, resulted in an overall decline in operating<br />

costs of 0.7%, in keeping with the Bank’s cost control policy.<br />

Directors' Report for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2008<br />

Impairment losses amounted to EUR 321,922 thousand, of which<br />

EUR 299,799 thousand related to loans and receivables, 30.9%<br />

more than in 2007, as a consequence of the provisions made for<br />

the industry-wide increase in non-performing loans in 2008.<br />

Lastly, the Bank recognised net provisions of EUR 16,271<br />

thousand, compared to a net recovery in this connection of EUR<br />

16,671 thousand in 2007.<br />

As a result of all the above, profit from operations rose by EUR<br />

47,198 thousand, an increase of 4.4%, which we regard as very<br />

satisfactory given how the economy performed in 2008.<br />

Other operations generated net losses of EUR 35,852 thousand,<br />

compared to a net profit of EUR 29,169 thousand in 2007. As a<br />

result, profit before tax was EUR 1,081,287 thousand. After<br />

deducting income tax and profit attributable to minority interests,<br />

profit attributable to the Group in 2008 was EUR 779,844<br />

thousand, up 2.0% on the previous year.<br />

The most significant changes in the consolidated balance sheet<br />

were as follows:<br />

1. Total assets amounted to EUR 120,479 million at 31<br />

December 2008, up 7.6% on 2007.<br />

2. Loans and advances to customers increased by 3.6% to EUR<br />

77,773 million. Of the total balance of this item, loans and<br />

advances to the private sector amounted to EUR 72,233<br />

million, up 2.5%.<br />

3. Customer deposits totalled EUR 57,590 million, representing<br />

a year-on-year increase of 9.2%.<br />

Research and development<br />

In the technology field, efforts were aimed mainly at continuing<br />

with the resource optimisation policy, leading to improved<br />

efficiency and enhanced process rationalisation. The Group<br />

continued to develop software, enabling it to achieve cost savings<br />

and enhance customer service quality whilst preparing it to meet<br />

new technological and functional renewal needs.


2008 saw a continuation of the development of the efficiency<br />

drive called the Menara Plan, which was launched in 2006. This<br />

plan pursues a threefold objective, namely to attain:<br />

- Increased operating efficiency, to enable the Bank to combine<br />

growth with cost control.<br />

- Heightened commercial efficiency, to improve the time devoted<br />

by branches to their commercial business.<br />

- Improved quality of service to customers.<br />

In order to carry out the aforementioned R&D work and to expand<br />

the microcomputer platform used by its personnel, in 2008 the<br />

Group incurred expenses and made investments in IT systems<br />

amounting to approximately EUR 108 million.<br />

This endeavour is not only the result of an individual effort to<br />

capitalise on in-house resources, but it also reflects our willingness<br />

to place our potential at the disposal of society to facilitate its<br />

response to the new challenges posed by information technologies.<br />

In this respect, in 2008 the Bank entered into agreements with<br />

official agencies aimed at providing citizens and businesses with<br />

easy access to new technology.<br />

Capacity for technological innovation and the ability to convert<br />

progress into improvements accessible to society are part of our<br />

corporate management model. Our commitment has led us to go a<br />

step further in this respect, as shown by the actions undertaken in<br />

2008 by the <strong>Banesto</strong> Foundation for Society and Technology,<br />

which is a benchmark in Spain for organisations of its kind.<br />

This Foundation is one of several channels through which <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

shares its technological expertise with society but not the only<br />

one. In the performance of its business activities, <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

implemented a series of innovative commercial initiatives, such as<br />

campaigns to attract new customers who agree to have their salary<br />

paid directly into the bank, thanks to which over 300,000<br />

personal computers were distributed in 2008, thus helping to<br />

promote technological development in our society.<br />

The Group continued to train its workforce and to adapt it to the<br />

new business requirements and to the need for ongoing<br />

professional development. To facilitate this process, a training<br />

development strategy focusing on continuous learning,<br />

professional development and the harnessing of the advantages of<br />

new technologies was implemented.<br />

Treasury shares<br />

In 2008, the Bank and two consolidable Group companies<br />

acquired and sold 33,367,629 and 35,777,045 Banco Español de<br />

Crédito, S.A. shares, respectively. The par value of the shares<br />

acquired was EUR 26,360,426.91 and that of the shares sold was<br />

EUR 28,263,865.55. The acquisition cost was EUR 363,742<br />

thousand and the selling price was EUR 396,522 thousand.<br />

At 31 December 2008, the Bank did not own any treasury shares.<br />

A Group company held 3,863,230 shares of Banco Español de<br />

Crédito, S.A. with a par value of EUR 3,051,952. The carrying<br />

amount of these shares at 31 December 2008 was EUR 36,074<br />

thousand.<br />

Outlook<br />

As explained in the 2007 Directors’ Report, the targets set by the<br />

Bank focus on medium-term achievements, namely for <strong>Banesto</strong> to<br />

become the leading commercial bank in Europe among its peers<br />

and the first-choice financial institution for its customers.<br />

- The Bank's medium-term growth, efficiency, risk and<br />

profitability targets are as follows:<br />

- Business growth in terms of both customer deposits and<br />

lending.<br />

- Increases in productivity and cost control, leading to an<br />

ongoing improvement of the efficiency ratio.<br />

- A non-performing loans ratio below that of the industry as a<br />

whole, coupled with a non-performing loans coverage higher<br />

than the industry-wide figure.<br />

- A concomitant sustained increase in profitability.<br />

The economic environment in 2009 is forecast to be difficult.<br />

Public and private agencies predict a decline in economic activity<br />

with a knock-on effect on employment, rising public-sector deficit<br />

and falling interest rates.<br />

Against this backdrop, <strong>Banesto</strong>'s financial targets for 2009 are as<br />

follows:<br />

- To improve on the 2008 efficiency ratio of 39%, with sufficient<br />

flexibility so as to be able to manage costs as much as is<br />

necessary.<br />

- A non-performing loan ratio below the average for the industry<br />

and that of our major peers.<br />

- To achieve better results than the industry and our peers,<br />

measured as the change in net recurring profit.<br />

Events after the balance sheet date<br />

From 1 January 2009 to the date on which this Directors' Report<br />

was prepared, no events occurred that might significantly affect it,<br />

other than those described in the note to the consolidated<br />

financial statements on events after the balance sheet date.<br />

Risk management at the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group<br />

The notes to the consolidated financial statements include a broad<br />

description of the <strong>Banesto</strong> Group's risk management.<br />

Customer care service<br />

As stipulated by Article 17 of Ministry of Economy Order<br />

ECO/734/2004, of 11 March, on Customer Care Departments<br />

and Services and Consumer Ombudsmen of Financial Institutions,<br />

following is a summary of the Annual Report submitted by the head<br />

of the Customer Care Service to the Board of Directors at its<br />

meeting held on 20 January 2009.<br />

a) Statistical summary of the claims and complaints handled<br />

2,808 complaints were filed with the Customer Care Service in<br />

2008, a decrease of 5% compared with 2007, all of which were<br />

admitted for consideration (without prejudice to the existence of<br />

grounds for not admitting complaints for consideration in the<br />

Service's Rules). 89% of the matters handled (2,505 complaints)<br />

179


180<br />

were resolved and concluded within the year, whereas a total of<br />

303 complaints had not yet been analysed at 31 December 2008.<br />

The detail of complaints and claims handled, by the subject of the<br />

claim, is as follows:<br />

• Lack of diligence....................................................................... 63%<br />

• Means of payment................................................................... 1%<br />

• Campaigns................................................................................. 9%<br />

• Transactions .............................................................................. 4%<br />

• Poor service............................................................................... 3%<br />

• Insurance.................................................................................... 3%<br />

• Internet banking....................................................................... 2%<br />

• Other claims.............................................................................. 2%<br />

• Reversals..................................................................................... 2%<br />

•Recalculations............................................................................ 1%<br />

b) Summary of resolutions:<br />

• In favour of the complainant: .......................... 1,303 (52%)<br />

• In favour of the Bank:........................................ 1,027 (41%)<br />

• No pronouncement made:............................... 175 (7%)<br />

c) Detail of the complaints filed through the Bank of Spain and<br />

the Spanish National Securities Market Commission<br />

(CNMV)<br />

Of the total number of complaints and claims handled by the<br />

Customer Care Service, 327 were filed through the Bank of Spain<br />

and 59 through the CNMV, the detail being as follows:<br />

Bank of Spain<br />

Claims resolved ............................................................. 196<br />

In favour of the customer......................................... 100 (51%)<br />

Claim accepted ........................................................... 58 (30%)<br />

In favour of the Bank ................................................. 18 (9%)<br />

No pronouncement made ........................................ 20 (10%)<br />

Claims unresolved......................................................... 131<br />

CNMV<br />

Claims resolved ............................................................. 39<br />

In favour of the customer......................................... 19 (46%)<br />

In favour of the Bank ................................................. 18(46%)<br />

No pronouncement made ........................................ 2 (5%)<br />

Claims unresolved......................................................... 20<br />

d) General decision-making criteria<br />

The decision-making criteria used by the Customer Care Service<br />

are taken mainly from the resolutions issued by the Bank of Spain,<br />

the CNMV and the Directorate-General of Insurance and Pension<br />

Funds in similar cases (approximately 80% of cases), and in those<br />

cases in which this type of reference does not exist, the response is<br />

given taking into account the advice provided by the Bank's Legal<br />

Department on the basis of the particular circumstances giving rise<br />

to the complaint.<br />

e) Recommendations or suggestions deriving from the<br />

service's experience, with a view to better attaining the aims<br />

of its work<br />

In 2007, <strong>Banesto</strong> created a Quality Committee. This Committee,<br />

chaired by the CEO and in which all the Areas concerned<br />

participate, is responsible for defining <strong>Banesto</strong>'s quality strategy,<br />

monitoring the balanced scorecard for quality and improving<br />

results (customer satisfaction surveys, objective service quality<br />

indicators and levels of service provision attained), authorising and<br />

prioritising improvements that require investment, and monitoring<br />

the impact of the most significant enhancement projects. This<br />

Committee holds monthly meetings and established the criteria to<br />

be employed to improve the quality of customer service.<br />

Another Committee meets every two weeks to analyse all the<br />

complaints and claims in respect of which, based on the<br />

aforementioned criteria, the Customer Care Service experts have<br />

proposed a resolution against the claimant. The aim of this<br />

Committee is to attempt to obtain a mutually satisfactory solution.<br />

As a result of the work performed by these two Committees,<br />

various measures were introduced to improve the quality of<br />

customer service, which led to a reduction in the number of<br />

complaints and claims handled by the Customer Care Service.<br />

Information required under Article 116 bis of the Securities<br />

Market Law<br />

In conformity with Article 116 bis of the Securities Market Law<br />

24/1988, of 28 July, introduced by Law 6/2007, of 12 April, the<br />

Board of Directors of Banco Español de Crédito, S.A., at its<br />

meeting on 20 January 2008, resolved to make available to<br />

shareholders this Report explaining the matters that, in conformity<br />

with this Article, were included in the 2008 Directors’ Report<br />

supplementing the 2008 financial statements.<br />

a) Structure of the share capital, including any securities not<br />

traded in a regulated EU market, indicating, where<br />

appropriate, the various classes of shares and, for each<br />

class, the rights and obligations conferred and the<br />

percentage of share capital represented<br />

As stipulated in Article 5 of the bylaws, the Bank's share capital<br />

consists of 687,386,798 fully subscribed and paid shares of EUR<br />

0.79 par value each, of a single series, which confer the same<br />

rights and obligations. It is not necessary to hold a minimum<br />

number of shares in order to attend and vote at the General<br />

Meetings. No securities have been issued that are convertible into<br />

shares of Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

b) Any restriction on the transferability of securities<br />

There are no bylaw-stipulated restrictions on the transferability of<br />

the shares representing the share capital, without prejudice to the<br />

application of certain rules, which are set forth below.<br />

The shares representing the share capital are freely transferable,<br />

without any restriction, unless the volume of shares acquired<br />

surpasses the threshold of a significant ownership interest, in which<br />

case the provisions established in Law 26/1988, of 29 July, on<br />

Discipline and Intervention of Credit Institutions shall apply. Under<br />

this Law, anyone intending to acquire an equity interest or voting<br />

power of more than 5% of the total capital or voting rights must<br />

notify the Bank of Spain, which will have three months in which to<br />

object to the acquisition. The only permissible ground for this<br />

objection is the unsuitability of an acquirer that fails to meet the<br />

suitability requirements of Article 43.5 of the aforementioned Law.<br />

The Bank of Spain must also be notified of any intention to acquire<br />

ownership interests equal to or in excess of the following limits:<br />

10%, 15%, 20%, 25%, 33%, 40%, 50%, 66% or 75%.


As <strong>Banesto</strong> is a listed company, the acquisition of certain<br />

significant ownership interests must be notified to the issuer and<br />

to the Spanish National Securities Market Commission (CNMV),<br />

pursuant to Article 53 of Spanish Securities Market Law 24/1988,<br />

Royal Decree 1362/2007, of 19 October, and CNMV Circular<br />

2/2007, of 19 December, which establish as the first notification<br />

threshold 3% of the share capital or voting rights (or 1% if the<br />

notifying party is resident in a tax haven or in a tax-free country or<br />

c) Significant direct or indirect ownership interests in the share<br />

capital<br />

d) Any restriction on voting rights<br />

The restrictions on the exercise of voting rights are those common<br />

to any company, and the bylaws do not contain any specific<br />

restrictions on these rights.<br />

e) Side agreements<br />

There are no side agreements at Banco Español de Crédito, S.A.<br />

f) Rules governing the appointment and replacement of<br />

members of the managing body and the amendment of the<br />

Company's bylaws<br />

1. Appointment and removal of members of the Board of Directors.<br />

Articles 15, 16, 19 and 32 of the bylaws and Articles 15, 18, 19<br />

and 20 of the Board of Directors Regulations govern the<br />

procedures for the appointment, re-election, evaluation and<br />

removal of directors, which can be summarised as follows:<br />

a. Appointment, re-election and ratification..<br />

- Competent body: the General Meeting, as provided for in the<br />

Consolidated Spanish Companies Law (as enacted by<br />

Legislative Royal Decree 1564/1989, of 22 December) and in<br />

the bylaws. Nevertheless, in the event of a vacancy due to the<br />

resignation or death of one or several directors, the Board may<br />

designate, by virtue of the powers of co-optation attributed to<br />

it by law, another or several other directors, whose<br />

appointment must be confirmed at the earliest General<br />

Meeting. In this case, the directors thus appointed shall<br />

discharge their duties for a period not exceeding the time that<br />

remained for their predecessors to complete their term of<br />

office.<br />

- Appointment requisites and restrictions: shareholder status is<br />

not a requisite for appointment as a director, except in<br />

appointments by co-optation, in which case this status is<br />

required. Persons who are subject to any legally established<br />

prohibition or incompatibility that would bar them from<br />

holding office cannot be appointed as directors.<br />

territory or with which there is no effective exchange of tax<br />

information in accordance with current legislation).<br />

Lastly, also as a listed entity, the acquisition of 30% or more of the<br />

capital or voting rights of the Company entails the obligation to<br />

present a takeover bid under the terms established in Article 60 of<br />

Securities Market Law 24/1988.<br />

Name or Company Name of Direct Holder of the Ownership Interest Number of % of Total Voting<br />

Direct Voting Rights Rights<br />

BANCO SANTANDER, S.A.<br />

CANTABRO CATALANA DE INVERSIONES, S.A.<br />

606,345,55 88.21%<br />

(participación indirecta de Banco Santander, S.A.) 7.350.543 1.069%<br />

The Appointments and Remuneration Committee, at its meeting on<br />

17 December 2003, expounded the requisites established in the<br />

Board Regulations for the proposal of candidates for the office of<br />

director and, accordingly, the persons designated as directors must<br />

be of renowned competence, experience and solvency and must<br />

have an honourable reputation gained by virtue of a personal<br />

history marked by observance of commercial and corporate laws<br />

and other regulations governing economic activity and the<br />

business world, and of good commercial, financial and banking<br />

practices.<br />

Another of the requisites established by the Committee is that a<br />

majority of the Board members must have discharged, for a period<br />

of not less than five years, senior administration, management,<br />

control or advisory functions for financial institutions, or functions<br />

of a similar degree of responsibility at other public or privatesector<br />

entities of a size at least similar to that of the Bank, in<br />

keeping with the requirements of the legislation governing credit<br />

institutions.<br />

Lastly, the Board Regulations set forth the circumstances under<br />

which designation as an independent director is prohibited; these<br />

circumstances are included in the recommendations of the Unified<br />

Code, in which independent directors are considered to be persons<br />

who, designated on the basis of their personal and professional<br />

conditions, are able to discharge their functions without being<br />

influenced by any relationships with the Bank, its main<br />

shareholders or its executives. Independent director status cannot<br />

be granted to directors who:<br />

a) Have been employees or executive directors of Group entities,<br />

unless three or five years, respectively, have elapsed since this<br />

relationship was terminated.<br />

b) Receive from the Bank or from its Group any amount or<br />

benefit other than remuneration as directors, unless this<br />

amount or benefit is not material.<br />

c) Are, or have been in the last three years, a partner at the<br />

external auditors or the partner in charge of the auditors'<br />

report, either that relating to the audit for the year of the<br />

listed entity or that of any other entity in its group.<br />

d) Are executive directors or senior executives of another<br />

different entity in which one of the Bank's executive directors<br />

or senior executives is a non-executive director.<br />

181


182<br />

e) Have, or have had during the last year, a significant business<br />

relationship with the Bank or with any entity in its Group,<br />

either in their own name or as a significant shareholder,<br />

director or senior executive of an entity that has or has had<br />

such a relationship.<br />

“Business relationship” shall be taken to be that of a supplier<br />

of goods or services, including financial, advisory or<br />

consulting services.<br />

f) Are significant shareholders, executive directors or senior<br />

executives of an entity that receives, or has received in the last<br />

three years, significant donations from the Bank or from its<br />

Group. This definition shall not include those persons who are<br />

merely trustees of a foundation that receives such donations.<br />

g Are spouses, spousal equivalents, or relatives of up to the<br />

second degree of kinship, of an executive director or a senior<br />

executive of the Bank.<br />

h) Have not been proposed, for either appointment or renewal,<br />

by the Appointments Committee.<br />

i) Are currently, with respect to a significant shareholder or a<br />

shareholder represented on the Board, in one of the situations<br />

described under letters a), e), f) or g) above. In the case of the<br />

kinship referred to under letter g), the restriction shall apply<br />

with respect not only to the shareholder, but also to its<br />

nominee directors at the investee.<br />

Any director who has a shareholding in the Bank may hold the<br />

position of independent director, provided they meet all the<br />

related conditions and, in addition, their ownership interest is not<br />

material.<br />

On taking office, the designated directors must formally agree to<br />

fulfil all the obligations and perform all the duties established by<br />

law, in the bylaws and in the Board Regulations.<br />

- Term of office: six years. However, outgoing directors can be reelected<br />

one or several times. The term of office of directors<br />

appointed by co-optation and ratified at the earliest<br />

subsequent General Meeting shall be the same as that of the<br />

director whom they are replacing.<br />

Article 17 of the bylaws provides for the annual renewal of onefifth<br />

of the Board of Directors.<br />

It was not considered necessary to establish an age limit for<br />

appointment as a director or for the discharge of duties as a<br />

director, or to limit the possibility of re-election of directors.<br />

- Procedure: proposals for the appointment, re-election and<br />

ratification of directors submitted by the Board of Directors to<br />

the General Meeting and appointment decisions adopted by<br />

the Board itself by virtue of its co-optation powers must be<br />

preceded by the related proposal from the Appointments and<br />

Remuneration Committee.<br />

If the Board objects to the Committee's proposal, it must give the<br />

reasons for its decision and place these reasons on record in the<br />

minutes to the related meeting.<br />

The directors whose appointment, re-election or removal has been<br />

proposed shall refrain from attending and participating in the<br />

related deliberations and ballots of the Board and of its<br />

Committees.<br />

Once an appointment has been made, it is made effective by the<br />

acceptance of the director and registration at the Bank of Spain's<br />

Registry of Senior Officers and at the Mercantile Registry.<br />

b. Vacation of office or removal<br />

Directors shall cease to hold office when the term for which they<br />

were appointed elapses, unless they are re-elected, or when the<br />

General Meeting so decides by virtue of the powers conferred<br />

upon it. Furthermore, directors must place their office at the<br />

disposal of the Board and give the related notice of resignation if<br />

the Board, after receiving the report of the Appointments and<br />

Remuneration Committee, should deem this appropriate, in those<br />

cases in which the directors might have an adverse effect on the<br />

functioning of the Board or on the Bank's credit and reputation<br />

and, in particular, when they are subject to any incompatibility or<br />

prohibition provided for by law that would bar them from holding<br />

office.<br />

Directors who stand down from the Board prior to the end of their<br />

mandate, due to resignation or any other cause must submit a<br />

letter to all the members of the Board explaining their reasons for<br />

vacating their office. The Annual Corporate Governance Report will<br />

disclose the reasons that prompted directors to leave the Board.<br />

Nominee directors shall resign when the shareholder they<br />

represent sells its entire ownership interest or when that<br />

shareholder reduces its ownership interest to a level that requires a<br />

reduction of the number of its nominee directors, without<br />

prejudice to the possibility of their being re-elected as executive<br />

directors, independent directors or nominee directors representing<br />

another shareholder.<br />

In the event of the removal, notice of resignation, disability or<br />

death of members of the Board or of its Committees, or of the<br />

removal or notice of resignation of the Chairman of the Board of<br />

Directors, of the Chief Executive Officer and of the other officers<br />

of these bodies, at the request of the Chairman of the Board or, in<br />

his absence, the highest-ranking Deputy Chairman, a meeting of<br />

the Appointments and Remuneration Committee shall be convened<br />

in order to organise the succession or replacement process in an<br />

orderly fashion and to propose a replacement to the Board of<br />

Directors. This proposal shall be communicated to the Executive<br />

Committee and subsequently submitted to the Board of Directors<br />

at the next meeting planned in its annual schedule or at any<br />

extraordinary meeting that, if deemed necessary, might be called.<br />

2. Amendment of bylaws.<br />

The procedure for the amendment of the bylaws is regulated in<br />

Article 144 of the Spanish Companies Law, which, common to all<br />

companies, requires the approval by the shareholders at the<br />

Annual General Meeting, with the majorities stipulated in Article<br />

103 of the aforementioned Law. As a credit institution, the<br />

amendment of the Bank's bylaws is subject to the procedures for<br />

authorisation by the Ministry of Economy and Finance contained in<br />

Royal Decree 1245/1995, of 14 July, on the creation of banks,<br />

cross-border activity and other matters relating to the legal regime<br />

of credit institutions, which provides (Article 8) that the<br />

amendment of the bylaws of banks is subject, with certain<br />

exceptions relating to minor changes, to the authorisation and<br />

registration procedure established in Article 1 of the<br />

aforementioned Royal Decree.


The powers of the Annual General Meeting contained in Article 32<br />

of the bylaws and Article 3 of the Regulations of the Annual<br />

General Meeting expressly include that to amend the bylaws<br />

without being subject to any majorities other than those provided<br />

for by law.<br />

a) Powers of the members of the Board of Directors and, in<br />

particular, those relating to the possibility of issuing or<br />

repurchasing shares.<br />

The Chairwoman and the Chief Executive Officer of Banco Español<br />

de Crédito, S.A. have been delegated all the powers of the Board of<br />

Directors, except for those which cannot be delegated by law, per<br />

the bylaws or per the Board Regulations, which establish (Article<br />

3) the exclusive powers of the Board of Directors in a plenary<br />

session. Furthermore, the executive directors have the powers<br />

habitually conferred by the Bank on its senior executives.<br />

The shareholders at the Annual General Meeting held on 26<br />

February 2008 authorised the Board, with power of delegation, to<br />

increase share capital as provided for in Article 153.1.b) of the<br />

Spanish Companies Law. The Board of Directors meeting held<br />

immediately after this Annual General Meeting, availing itself of this<br />

power, resolved to delegate to the Executive Committee, in the<br />

broadest terms required by law, all powers that may be legally<br />

delegated so that, pursuant to Article 153.1.b) of the Spanish<br />

Companies Law, it may increase share capital on one or several<br />

occasions and at any time, within five years from the date of the<br />

aforementioned Annual General Meeting. The amount of the<br />

increase may be up to EUR 274,260,388.71 (par value), i.e. half<br />

the share capital of the Bank at the date of the aforementioned<br />

Annual General Meeting, and may be performed through the<br />

issuance of new shares, with or without share premium and with or<br />

without voting rights; the consideration for the new shares to be<br />

issued will be monetary contributions. The Executive Committee<br />

may set the terms and conditions of the capital increase and the<br />

characteristics of the shares and may offer freely the new<br />

unsubscribed shares within the pre-emptive rights period or<br />

periods. The delegated powers include being able to establish that,<br />

if the issue is undersubscribed, share capital is only increased by<br />

the amount of the shares subscribed, and to revise the wording of<br />

the article in the bylaws relating to share capital. The available<br />

limit at any given time of the aforementioned maximum capital<br />

increase amount shall be deemed to include the amount of any<br />

capital increases that may be made to cater for the conversion of<br />

debentures under Resolution Six of the Annual General Meeting of<br />

26 February 2008. Also, the Executive Committee was empowered<br />

to disapply pre-emptive subscription rights, fully or partially, in<br />

accordance with Article 159.2 of the Spanish Companies Law.<br />

The Board of Directors also delegated to the Executive Committee<br />

the power to perform all the necessary tasks for the new shares<br />

issued in the capital increase or increases to be admitted to trading<br />

on the stock exchanges on which the Bank’s shares are listed in<br />

Spain and other countries, in accordance with the procedures laid<br />

down by each of these stock exchanges.<br />

Neither the Board of Directors nor the Executive Committee has<br />

exercised the powers delegated to them.<br />

Similarly, the shareholders at the Annual General Meeting held on<br />

26 February 2008 authorised the Board of Directors, with power<br />

of delegation, to issue debentures convertible into or exchangeable<br />

for Bank shares. As with the case of the powers delegated to the<br />

Board to increase share capital, the Board of Directors Meeting<br />

held immediately after the aforementioned Annual General<br />

Meeting, availing itself of the powers delegated to it, agreed to<br />

delegate to the Executive Committee, in the broadest terms<br />

required by law, the power to execute and implement the<br />

resolutions adopted by the aforementioned Annual General<br />

Meeting.<br />

Neither the Board of Directors nor the Executive Committee has<br />

exercised the powers delegated to them.<br />

As regards the power to purchase shares, the Board of Directors,<br />

availing itself of the powers delegated to it by the Annual General<br />

Meeting of 26 February 2008, at its meeting held immediately<br />

after the aforementioned Annual General Meeting, resolved to<br />

delegate powers to the Executive Committee so that, within<br />

eighteen months following the adoption of the resolution to<br />

reduce share capital by EUR 5,485,207, through the retirement of<br />

6,943,300 treasury shares, it could implement this resolution. This<br />

included determining the conditions that had not been expressly<br />

defined in the resolutions adopted at the aforementioned Annual<br />

General Meeting in relation to the capital reduction and the<br />

matters that may arise as a consequence of the resolutions. The<br />

Executive Committee was also empowered to revise the wording of<br />

Article 5 of the bylaws to reflect the new amount of share capital.<br />

At its meeting on 25 March 2008, the Board of Directors of the<br />

Bank, availing itself of the aforementioned powers, pursuant to<br />

Articles 163, 164 and 167 of the Consolidated Spanish Companies<br />

Law and Articles 170 and 172 of the Regulations of the Mercantile<br />

Registry, adopted the resolution to reduce the Bank’s share capital<br />

by EUR 5,485,207, through the retirement of 6,943,300 treasury<br />

shares previously acquired under authorisation of the Annual<br />

General Meeting, within the limits set forth in Articles 75 et seq<br />

and Additional Provision One.2, of the Spanish Companies Law.<br />

Article 5 of the bylaws was amended accordingly.<br />

The capital reduction was carried out with a charge to voluntary<br />

reserves and the corresponding amount was deducted from the<br />

restricted reserve to which Article 79.3 of the Spanish Companies<br />

Law refers and a reserve for retired capital of EUR 5,485,207 (the<br />

same amount as the par value of the retired shares) was recorded.<br />

This reserve will be unrestricted under the same conditions as for<br />

the share capital reduction, in accordance with Article 167.3 of the<br />

Spanish Companies Law. Consequently, in accordance with the<br />

provisions of the aforementioned Article, the Company’s creditors<br />

did not have the right, referred to by Article 166 and the Spanish<br />

Companies Law, to contest the agreed capital reduction.<br />

Given that the Company was the holder of the retired shares, the<br />

capital reduction did not entail the reimbursement of<br />

contributions. The purpose of the capital reduction was therefore<br />

to retire treasury shares in order to increase the value of the<br />

shareholders’ interest in the Company.<br />

The resolution to reduce share capital was subject to the condition<br />

precedent that the legally required administrative authorisations<br />

be obtained. Authorisation from the Directorate General of the<br />

Treasury and Financial Policy for the capital reduction resolved by<br />

the Annual General Meeting on 26 February 2008 was obtained<br />

on 29 May, 2008. On 2 June, 2008, the Executive Committee<br />

declared that the condition precedent, to which the resolution to<br />

reduce share capital was subject, had occurred.<br />

Also, the shareholders at the Annual General Meeting held on 26<br />

February 2008 authorised the Board of Directors to implement, in<br />

conformity with Article 75 and related provisions of the Spanish<br />

Companies Law, the derivative acquisition of shares of Banco<br />

Español de Crédito, S.A. The maximum number of shares to be<br />

183


184<br />

acquired, when added to the number of shares already owned by<br />

the acquiring Entity and its subsidiaries, shall not exceed the<br />

legally stipulated limit, set at 5% of share capital in Additional<br />

Provision One of the Spanish Companies Law, without prejudice to<br />

the application of any lower limits which, within the legal limit<br />

approved at the aforementioned Annual General Meeting, may be<br />

(or may have been) approved by the Board of Directors. The<br />

duration of this authorisation is 18 months from the date of the<br />

Annual General Meeting. A similar resolution was proposed to the<br />

Annual General Meeting called for 25 February, 2009.<br />

b) Significant agreements entered into by the Company which will<br />

come into force, be modified or terminate in the event of a<br />

change in control of the Company resulting from a takeover bid,<br />

and their effects, except when dissemination thereof may be<br />

seriously detrimental to the Company. This exception shall not<br />

apply when the Company is required by law to publish this<br />

information.<br />

The Company has not entered into any significant agreements that<br />

will come into force, be modified or terminate in the event of a<br />

change in control of the Company resulting from a takeover bid.<br />

c) Agreements between the Company and its directors,<br />

management personnel or employees which provide for<br />

termination benefits when the latter resign or are dismissed<br />

without justification or if the employment relationship ends as a<br />

result of a takeover bid:<br />

The legal and conventional effects that may result from the<br />

termination of the services relationship between <strong>Banesto</strong> personnel<br />

and the Bank are not uniform, but rather vary, logically, on the<br />

basis of the personnel in question, the office or job position held<br />

by the employee, the type of contract entered into with the Bank,<br />

the regulations governing the employment relationship, and<br />

various other factors. Nevertheless, the following cases can<br />

generally be distinguished:<br />

a) Employees: in the case of employees who have a common<br />

employment relationship with <strong>Banesto</strong>, which is the case of<br />

substantially all the personnel working for the Bank, the<br />

employment contracts between these employees and the Bank<br />

do not generally contain any clause providing for benefits in the<br />

event of the termination of the employment relationship.<br />

Therefore, employees shall be entitled to receive the benefits<br />

applicable under labour legislation in their particular case,<br />

depending on the cause of termination of their contract.<br />

In certain common employment relationships with the Bank, the<br />

employees' contracts entitle them to receive a benefit in the event<br />

that the relationship is terminated on appraised grounds (generally<br />

only in the event Sof unjustified dismissal). The amount of the<br />

termination benefit is normally determined on the basis of the<br />

gross annual fixed salary of the employee in force at the date on<br />

which the contract is terminated.<br />

b) Senior executives: among personnel who have special senior<br />

executive employment relationships with <strong>Banesto</strong> (special senior<br />

executive contracts), there are cases in which their contracts do<br />

not provide for any benefits in the event of termination of the<br />

employment relationship and, therefore, the executive in<br />

question shall be entitled, where appropriate, to the benefit<br />

provided for in the regulations governing special senior<br />

executive employment relationships. For these purposes, it<br />

should noted that Article 10.3 of Royal Decree 1382/1985, of<br />

1 August, regulating the special senior executive employment<br />

relationship, provides that the senior executive may terminate<br />

the special employment contract with entitlement to the<br />

agreed-upon benefits or, in the absence thereof, those<br />

established in these regulations in the event of termination due<br />

to withdrawal of the employer on the grounds, inter alia, of an<br />

important change in the ownership of the company, resulting in<br />

the renewal of its governing bodies, or in the content and<br />

rationale of its core business activity, provided that the<br />

termination takes place within the three months following the<br />

occurrence of these changes.<br />

In addition to these, there are other executives whose contracts do<br />

entitle them to receive a benefit in the event of termination of the<br />

employment relationship on certain grounds. This benefit is<br />

normally determined individually for each senior executive on the<br />

basis of their professional circumstances and the importance and<br />

responsibility of the position they hold at the Bank.<br />

c) Executive directors: the contracts regulating the discharge by<br />

executive directors of executive functions other than the<br />

supervisory and decision-making functions inherent to<br />

membership of the Board of Directors are indefinite-term<br />

contracts. Nevertheless, termination of the relationship due<br />

either to the executive directors’ failure to fulfil their obligations<br />

or to their own free will does not entitle them to any economic<br />

compensation. If the relationship is terminated for reasons<br />

attributable to the Bank or due to prevailing objective<br />

circumstances, such as those which, as the case may be, affect<br />

the executive directors' functional and organic statute, the<br />

director in question shall be entitled to receive the benefit<br />

envisaged in the respective contract, which will be determined<br />

not by general criteria but rather by the personal and<br />

professional circumstances of the director and by the date on<br />

which the contract was signed. The detail of these circumstances<br />

is contained in the notes to the consolidated financial<br />

statements and in the Report on Remuneration Policy that was<br />

made available to shareholders at the Annual General Meeting<br />

on 25 February 2009.


Corporate Governance<br />

Report according to the<br />

CNMV model<br />

The Corporate Governance Report access on the web is:<br />

http://www.banesto.es/igc<br />

185


186<br />

Noteworthy figures<br />

Balance sheet<br />

Million euros Absolute %<br />

2008 2007 Change Change<br />

Total assets 117,186.42 110,067.76 7,118.66 6.5%<br />

Shareholders’ equity 5,069.77 4,747.89 321.88 6.8%<br />

Total managed funds 67,524.86 66,762.87 762.00 1.1%<br />

On-balance sheet customer funds 57,779.45 53,340.18 4,439.27 8.3%<br />

Managed funds 9,745.41 13,422.69 -3,677.28 -27.4%<br />

Lending 77,223.84 74,201.40 3,022.45 4.1%<br />

Bad and doubtful loans 1,441.45 410.80 1,030.65 250.9%<br />

Non-performing loans ratio (%) 1.62% 0.47% - -<br />

% coverage of NPLs 105.37% 329.48% - -<br />

BIS capital ratio 10.66% 10.43% - -<br />

Tier 1 7.70% 6.98% - -<br />

Income statement<br />

Millon euros Change Change<br />

2008 2007 Absolute %<br />

Net interest income 1,637.64 1,461.09 176.55 12.1%<br />

Gross operating income 2,461.54 2,271.11 190.42 8.4%<br />

Net operating costs 989.35 956.95 32.40 3.4%<br />

Net operating income 1,462.89 1,320.12 142.78 10.8%<br />

Operating costs/Gross operating income 39.04% 40.51% - -<br />

Profit before taxes 1,085.66 1,100.10 -14.44 -1.3%<br />

Net attributable profit 779.84 764.57 15.27 2.0%<br />

ROA 0.71% 0.75% - -<br />

ROE 16.56% 17.05% - -<br />

Data per share<br />

Earnings per share in the year 1.13 1.10 0.03 3.0%<br />

Theoretical book value per share 7.38 6.84 0.54 7.9%<br />

PER 7.12 12.09 - -<br />

Price/theoretical book value 1.10 1.95 - -<br />

Other information<br />

Employees 9,718 9,923 -205 -2.1%<br />

Branches 1,915 1,946 -31 -1.6%


General information and<br />

Regional Headquarters<br />

General Information<br />

GENERAL INFORMATION<br />

Telephones: +34 91 338 31 00<br />

+34 91 338 15 00<br />

RELATIONS WITH SHAREHOLDERS<br />

Avda. Gran Vía de Hortaleza, 3<br />

28043 Madrid Spain<br />

Telephone: 902 123 230<br />

e-mail: accionistas@banesto.es<br />

RELATIONS WITH INVESTORS AND ANALYSTS<br />

Avda. Gran Vía de Hortaleza, 3<br />

28043 Madrid Spain<br />

Telephone: +34 91 338 22 44<br />

Fax. +34 91 338 25 58<br />

e-mail: relacionesconinversores@banesto.es<br />

CUSTOMER ATTENTION<br />

Avda. Gran Vía de Hortaleza, 3<br />

28043 Madrid Spain<br />

Telephone: 902 303 630<br />

RELATIONS WITH THE MEDIA<br />

e-mail: prensa@banesto.es<br />

Telephone: +34 91 338 24 08<br />

PRESS ROOM<br />

www.banesto.es/webcorporativa<br />

CORPORATE WEBSITE<br />

www.banesto.es/webcorporativa<br />

BANCO ESPAÑOL DE CREDITO, S.A.<br />

The bank was constituted on May 1, 1902 through a notarised deed in Madrid, inscribed in the Mercantile Registry of<br />

Madrid on May 14,1902, number 1,595, folio 177, first inscription of volume 36 of Companies. Its by-laws were<br />

brought into line with the Limited Companies Act through a notarised document on August 16, 1991, inscribed in the<br />

Mercantile Registry volume 1,582, folio 1, page M- 28968, inscription 4,417 on October 8, 1991. It is inscribed in the<br />

special Registry of Banks and Bankers with the number 0032, and the bank’s tax identification number is A-28000032.<br />

The bank is a member of the Deposit Guarantee Fund.<br />

Registered office<br />

The Corporate by-laws and other public information can be consulted at Avda. Gran Vía de Hortaleza 3, Madrid.<br />

Additional information on <strong>Banesto</strong>’s Corporate Social Responsibility:<br />

• Annual Report: www.banesto.es/informe_anual<br />

• CSR Report: www.banesto.es/rsc<br />

• Corporate Governance Report: www.banesto.es/igc<br />

• ibanesto.com: www.ibanesto.com<br />

• Banespyme School: www.banespyme.org<br />

• Ciberplaza: www.ciberplaza.es<br />

187


188<br />

Regional Headquarters<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

retail banking<br />

ANDALUCÍA AND CANARY ISLANDS<br />

Director: Alberto Delgado Romero<br />

Avda. de la Palmera, 25 • 41013 • Sevilla<br />

Telephone: 954.93.27.00 / Fax: 954.93.27.03<br />

CANARY ISLANDS<br />

Director: Virginia Martínez de Murguía<br />

BASQUE COUNTRY, NAVARRE AND<br />

LA RIOJA<br />

Director: María Carmen Aracama Municha<br />

Postas, 22 • 01001 • Vitoria<br />

Telephone: 945.16.33.31 / Fax: 945.16.33.58<br />

CASTILLA-LA MANCHA AND EXTREMADURA<br />

Director: Carmen González Moya<br />

Pza. de Zocodover, 4 • 45001 • Toledo<br />

Telephone: 925.28.02.53 / Fax: 925.28.01.33<br />

CASTILLA-LEÓN AND CANTABRIA<br />

Director: Matías Francisco Sánchez García<br />

Constitución, 10 1o • 47001 • Valladolid<br />

Telephone: 983.21.74.09 / Fax: 983.21.74.08<br />

CATALONIA AND BALEARICS<br />

Director: Eduard Miró Contijoch<br />

Gran Vía Corts Catalanes, 583 • 08011 • Barcelona<br />

Telephone: 93.214.45.91 / Fax: 93.214.46.90<br />

company banking<br />

CATALONIA AND BALEARICS<br />

Director: Pedro Alonso Juncar<br />

Gran Vía Corts Catalanes, 583 • 08011 • Barcelona<br />

Telephone: 93.214.45.44 / Fax: 93.214.46.96<br />

INSTITUTIONAL RELATIONS<br />

IN CATALONIA<br />

Director: Pere Estruch Jane<br />

Gran Vía Corts Catalanes, 583 • 08011 • Barcelona<br />

Telephone: 93.214.45.41 / Fax: 93.214.46.96<br />

LEVANTE<br />

Director: José Miguel Lorente Ayala<br />

Pintor Sorolla, 17 3a planta • 46002 • Valencia<br />

Telephone: 96.399.62.11 / Fax: 96.399.61.31<br />

MADRID<br />

Director: Octavio Ramírez Romero<br />

Princesa, 25 2a pta. • 28008 • Madrid<br />

Telephone: 91.758.60.01 / Fax: 91.758.60.33<br />

NORTH (ARAGON, ASTURIAS, CANTABRIA,<br />

CASTILLA-LEÓN AND GALICIA)<br />

Director: José Antonio Portugal Alonso<br />

Princesa, 25 2a pta. • 28008 • Madrid<br />

Telephone: 91.758.60.10 / Fax: 91.758.60.03<br />

3<br />

4<br />

1<br />

6 GALICIA AND ASTURIAS<br />

Director: Vicente Pantoja Camacho<br />

Plaza de Vigo, 2 • 15701 • Santiago de Compostela<br />

Telephone: 981.55.34.66 / Fax: 981.59.27.91<br />

7<br />

6<br />

LEVANTE<br />

Director: Félix Subies Montalar<br />

Pintor Sorolla, 17 4˚ • 46002 • Valencia<br />

Telephone: 96.399.62.10 / Fax: 96.399.62.12<br />

8 MADRID<br />

Director: José Luis Fernández Fernández<br />

Alcalá, 14 1˚ • 28014 • Madrid<br />

Telephone: 91.338.15.55 / Fax: 91.338.13.50<br />

5<br />

6<br />

5<br />

4<br />

8<br />

3<br />

SOUTH<br />

Director: José Antonio Hernani Goldaracena<br />

Avda. de la Palmera, 25 • 41013 • Sevilla<br />

Telephone: 954.93.27.04 / Fax: 954.61.56.64<br />

6<br />

BASQUE COUNTRY, NAVARRE AND LA RIOJA<br />

Director: José María Bilbao Urquijo<br />

Navarra, 3 • 48001 • Bilbao<br />

Telephone: 944.23.18.14 / Fax: 944.23.97.80<br />

2<br />

2<br />

7<br />

5<br />

1


The 2008 Annual Report and the Corporate Social Responsibility Report are published in digital and not paper form,<br />

in order to respect the environment. <strong>Banesto</strong> saved more than seven tonnes of paper with this measure.<br />

® Februray 2009 <strong>Banesto</strong><br />

Design, creative concept and production:<br />

See the change / Álvaro Reyero Pita<br />

Photos: Fernando Moreno Amador/Andrea Savini<br />

Jorge Giacomuzzi / Toño Morales (photo. page 8)<br />

Printing : TF Artes Gráficas<br />

Translation: William Chislett<br />

Legal deposit:<br />

189


www.banesto.es<br />

Global Compact FTSE4Good Euromoney EFQM<br />

GRI

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!