GMEC Manual Rev 052212 - Greenville Hospital System
GMEC Manual Rev 052212 - Greenville Hospital System
GMEC Manual Rev 052212 - Greenville Hospital System
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE (<strong>GMEC</strong>)<br />
Policy <strong>Manual</strong><br />
<strong>Rev</strong>iewed and Amended: September 2009<br />
Edited: November 2010<br />
<strong>Rev</strong>iewed and Amended: September 2011
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
I. INSTITUTIONAL ORGANIZATION AND RESPONSIBILITIES ................................................................ 3<br />
GME Program Overview ................................................................................................................... 4<br />
GHS Commitment Statement ........................................................................................................... 5<br />
GHS Policy Compliance .................................................................................................................... 6<br />
II. INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES FOR RESIDENTS ......................................................................... 7<br />
Resident Recruitment and Appointment ......................................................................................... 8<br />
Resident Contracts ........................................................................................................................... 9<br />
Resident Change of Residency Program ........................................................................................ 10<br />
Resident Dismissal and Grievance (w/ process) ............................................................................ 11<br />
Resident Participation in <strong>Hospital</strong>/OMS Committees and Initiatives ............................................ 13<br />
Moonlighting .................................................................................................................................. 15<br />
Duty Hours ..................................................................................................................................... 16<br />
Resident Duty Hour Compliance Oversight.................................................................................... 17<br />
House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> ........................................................................................................................ 19<br />
Transitions of Care ........................................................................................................................ 24<br />
Sleep Deprivation and Fatigue ....................................................................................................... 25<br />
International Electives ................................................................................................................... 26<br />
III. GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE (<strong>GMEC</strong>) ............................................................... 27<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Role w/ Organization Chart ................................................................................................. 28<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Responsibilities .................................................................................................................... 32<br />
DIO Delegation ............................................................................................................................... 34<br />
Vendor Interactions ....................................................................................................................... 35<br />
GME Vendor Interactions ............................................................................................................... 36<br />
Residency Closure/Reduction in Size ............................................................................................. 40<br />
Disaster and GME ........................................................................................................................... 41<br />
Program Annual Reports w/ Format .............................................................................................. 42<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Rev</strong>iew ....................................................................................................................... 50<br />
IV. INTERNAL REVIEW .......................................................................................................................... 51<br />
Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews ............................................................................................................................. 52<br />
2
I. INSTITUTIONAL ORGANIZATION AND RESPONSIBILITIES<br />
3
GME PROGRAM OVERVIEW<br />
The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> (GHS) is a voluntary, community, nonprofit organization owned and operated<br />
by an independent, self‐perpetuating Board of Trustees. Upon this Board rests the full responsibility for the<br />
operation of the <strong>Hospital</strong>, the quality of care rendered, and the relationship with the entire community.<br />
The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> is an Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME)<br />
accredited Graduate Medical Education (GME) teaching institution. The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> (GHS)<br />
Medical Staff accepts responsibility for assuring supervision of all resident educational activities including<br />
patient care. Through its by‐laws the GHS Medical Staff has delegated this responsibility to Academic Services.<br />
Academic Services fulfills this responsibility through its full time and volunteer faculty teaching staff.<br />
Faculty members have the dual obligations of training residents progressively to independence and assuring<br />
provision of safe patient care. In order to fulfill these obligations all patients admitted to GHS have an<br />
attending physician who is a member of the Medical Staff. Residents participate in the care of these patients<br />
with the agreement and at the invitation of the attending physician. It is understood that residents have no<br />
independent Medical Staff privileges within the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong>. Therefore, a resident may perform<br />
only those cares and procedures for which the patient’s attending physician has privileges.<br />
Fundamental to the GME process is the tenant that residents must be supervised in such a manner that allows<br />
them to assume progressively increasing responsibility and autonomy commensurate with their individual<br />
levels of education, ability, and expertise. While the resident credentialing process is implicit within the<br />
program description of resident responsibilities at each year level of training, it is a fact that resident peers<br />
progress at different rates due to individual abilities and variable experiences determined by timing of<br />
educational rotations. Consequently, only the attending physician is qualified to determine the capabilities of<br />
any individual resident at any given time. This requires that the teaching staff on‐call arrangements be<br />
structured to ensure that appropriate supervision is readily available at all times to residents on duty.<br />
Accordingly, uncertainty regarding the qualifications of a resident to provide specific care for a patient should<br />
be addressed to the attending physician or his/her medical staff designee.<br />
Academic Program descriptions are provided to the residents and are intended to provide an overview of all<br />
residents’ experiences by year and rotation. All residency programs maintain a departmental manual specific<br />
to their requirements. This <strong>GMEC</strong> policy manual defines policies and procedures relative to resident education<br />
oversight in general.<br />
4
Institutional Requirements: I.B.2<br />
Common Program Requirements: I.A<br />
Graduate Medical Education Institutional Commitment<br />
<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> recognizes the value of and enthusiastically supports the provisions of medical<br />
education and, consequently, has included this commitment in the Bylaws of the GHS Board of Trustees under<br />
Article II, Section 2.6‐1(j) “To provide teaching and instruction programs and schools for nurses, hospital<br />
technicians, hospital employees, medical students, and physicians during internship and residency.” In accord,<br />
<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> is committed to providing the necessary educational, financial, and human<br />
resources support to graduate medical education. Further, <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> is committed to and<br />
responsible for promoting patient safety and resident well‐being and to providing a supportive educational<br />
environment.<br />
Signature on File<br />
Jerry R. Youkey, M.D.<br />
Vice President, Medical and Academic Affairs<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Designated Institutional Official<br />
Signature on File<br />
Michael C. Riordan<br />
President and Chief Executive Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Jerry Dempsey<br />
Chairman, GHS Board of Trustees<br />
October 21, 2011<br />
5
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # I‐01‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.D.4.l | II.D.4.m | II.D.4.n<br />
Common Program Requirements: N/A<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
GHS Policy Compliance<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that all Graduate Medical Education<br />
programs will adhere to applicable GHS policies; including sexual and other forms of harassment, disabilities<br />
accommodation, and physician impairment including that due to substance abuse. Applicable GHS policies will<br />
be highlighted during new resident orientation.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
6
II. INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES FOR RESIDENTS<br />
7
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐01‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.A<br />
Common Program Requirements: III<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Resident Recruitment and Appointment<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the policy/criteria for acceptance of<br />
Resident staff at the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> will be directed as:<br />
- Criteria for applicant consideration – make proper application through ERAS or universal application<br />
provided by NRMP, meet criteria as set forth by Essentials of Accredited Residencies and specialty<br />
boards, complies with application procedures, participates in NRMP, and eligible for licensure in South<br />
Carolina. It is the policy of Academic Services to employ physician trainees (residents and fellows)<br />
requiring immigration authorization only under the J‐1 Exchange Visitor Program sponsored by the<br />
Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates (ECFMG) and permanent visa status. No<br />
exceptions will be made to this provision except as defined by the Vice President, Medical Services and<br />
Dean, Academic Services.<br />
- Criteria for selection – GHS participates in the NRMP program, Selection Committee reviews all<br />
applications, consideration is given to the applicant’s medical school Dean’s Letter, letters of<br />
recommendation, grades and class rank, USMLE or ECFMG scores, and recommendations of GHS<br />
physicians who personally interviewed the applicants. Program Selection Committee reviews the<br />
applications, develops a rank list in order of preference, and submits a match list to NRMP in<br />
accordance with the rules and regulations of that organization. Positions available after the Match are<br />
filled using the same criteria, with appointment being made directly by the program director.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
8
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐02‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.D<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Resident Contracts<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that residents will be provided a written<br />
agreement of appointment/contract outlining the terms and conditions of their appointment. The<br />
agreement/contract will contain and/or reference those institutional policies as required in the ACGME<br />
Institutional Requirements. No restrictive covenants will be included in any resident or fellow contract.<br />
Academic promotions and renewal of a resident’s contract will be based upon the performance evaluation<br />
process of the primary residency program of the resident. Non‐renewal of a contract is an act of termination<br />
and will be exercised only for unsatisfactory performance.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
9
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐03‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: III.B.7<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Resident Change of Residency Program<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that a resident desiring to change Residency<br />
Program after commencing his/her residency training must obtain a Change of Residency Form from the office<br />
of the Designated Institutional Official and follow the applicable rules as detailed in the GHS House Staff<br />
<strong>Manual</strong>.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
10
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐04‐11<br />
Page 1<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.D.4(e)<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Resident Dismissal and Grievance (w/process)<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that all resident staff who enter residency<br />
training programs at GHS should graduate. Non‐renewal of contracts or termination of employment will be<br />
exercised only for cause. A house staff member may be suspended from duty or terminated from the program<br />
for cause by the Academic Services Department Chair responsible for the performance of the house officer, or<br />
by the DIO, Vice President, Medical Services and Dean, Academic Services, or Chief Executive Officer of the<br />
<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong>. Resident Staff are subject to GHS employment policy and procedure standards.<br />
Due Process<br />
Non‐renewal of a contract is an act of termination and will be exercised only for unsatisfactory performance.<br />
Termination of a resident for unsatisfactory performance or for cause will originate with the program involved.<br />
Each program will have a policy stating acceptable behavior and describe the procedure by which residents are<br />
evaluated on performance and what corrective actions will be taken when appropriate. When the level of<br />
performance is determined to warrant termination, a written request will be forwarded to the DIO. The Vice<br />
President of Medical and Academic Services will then present the findings and recommendations to the<br />
members of the Academic Services Graduate Medical Education Committee (<strong>GMEC</strong>) at a called meeting. If a<br />
majority of the <strong>GMEC</strong> agrees with the recommendation, the Assistant Dean of Graduate Medical Education will<br />
notify in writing the resident of his/her termination.<br />
Appeal Process<br />
Appeal of this decision by the resident will be in writing to the DIO within ten (10) days of receiving the written<br />
notice of termination. Such notice will be delivered by registered mail. Upon receipt of an appeal, the DIO will<br />
appoint a committee consisting of a Professor or Associate Professor from the residency program involved and<br />
a Professor or Associate Professor from two other residency programs. Within five (5) days of appointment of<br />
the committee, the committee will meet to review all recorded performances of the resident involved,<br />
including appropriate personal interviews of the faculty and residents who have been responsible for the<br />
written evaluations and comments. Upon written request to the DIO, the resident may request that he/she<br />
and any advocates of his/her position have the opportunity to be heard by the Committee. The Committee will<br />
determine the extent of involvement in the committee process of any advocate. The minutes of committee<br />
meetings will be recorded by a court reporter and reflect documentation of the resident’s notification and<br />
response.<br />
The Committee will reach a decision within ten (10) days of appointment of the committee. The Committee’s<br />
majority recommendation will be binding and without recourse.<br />
11
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐04‐11<br />
Page 2<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Resident Dismissal and Grievance (w/process)<br />
If a majority of the committee does agree to termination of the resident, the Assistant Dean of Graduate<br />
Medical Education will notify the resident of his/her termination. If the majority of the committee does not<br />
agree to termination of the resident, any recommended course of action or recommended reprimand(s) of the<br />
resident by the committee will be communicated in writing to the department chairman and program director<br />
for follow‐through.<br />
Prior to resident notification, the President & CEO and Chairman of the Board of Trustees will be notified in<br />
writing of the committee’s final action. The resident will be notified of the committee’s decision in writing<br />
within five (5) days following the conclusion of the committee meeting.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
12
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐05‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.E.2.a<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Resident Participation in <strong>Hospital</strong>/OMS Committees and Initiatives<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that Residents will be encouraged to be<br />
membership active on applicable committees that will include:<br />
Pediatrics Code Stat<br />
Adult Code Stat<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> (President, Vice President & Secretary – elected Officers)<br />
Pharmacy & Therapeutics<br />
Information Technology<br />
Metabolic Adult Support Task Force<br />
House Staff Liaison – (Chief Residents and elected Officers)<br />
Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew – (per policy)<br />
Jackson Award – (per Award description)<br />
Research Award – (per Award description)<br />
Simulation Advisory Committee – (per Advisory Committee By‐laws)<br />
Except for ex officio membership and DIO appointment, resident selection/appointment to specific<br />
committees will be processed via the GHS House Staff Liaison Committee whose membership consists of each<br />
program’s Chief Resident, universal elected officers (President, Vice President, and Secretary) and a<br />
representative from the 3 rd and 4 th year USC Medical Students.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
13
SYSTEM COMMITTEES: RESIDENT REPRESENTATION<br />
Academic Year 2012<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
Committee (<strong>GMEC</strong>)<br />
Bethany Bessom, MD (House Staff Pres–(Pediatrics)<br />
Lionel van der Westhuizen, MD (House Staff VP–(Surgery)<br />
Deanna Ball, MD (House Staff Secretary‐(Pediatrics)<br />
Pediatrics Code Stat<br />
Amanda O’Kelly, MD (Pediatrics)<br />
Adult Code Stat<br />
Brett Murphy, MD (Orthopaedic Surgery)<br />
Chris Vaughan, MD (Med‐Peds)<br />
Pharmacy & Therapeutics<br />
Cary A. Sanders, MD (Med/Peds)<br />
Information Technology<br />
Ben Barden, MD (Orthopaedic Surgery)<br />
J. D. Adams, MD (Orthopaedic Surgery)<br />
Metabolic Adult Support Task Force<br />
Brandon Smith, MD (Surgery)<br />
House Staff Liaison Committee<br />
Chief Residents/Elected Officers/Committee Representatives/<br />
3rd and 4th Year Medical Student Representatives<br />
Simulation Center<br />
Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
As selected per policy<br />
Jackson Award<br />
As selected per policy<br />
GHS/UMC Outstanding Faculty and House Staff Research Award ‐ As selected per policy<br />
14
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐06‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.D.4.j<br />
Common Program Requirements: V1.G.2.a‐c<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Moonlighting<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that GHS residents may moonlight so long<br />
as a moonlighting obligation does not interfere with that resident’s educational program. In addition, if a<br />
proposed moonlighting activity is to take place in a GHS facility or in connection with a GHS program, the<br />
resident must demonstrate competence to furnish the moonlighting services and be granted appropriate GHS<br />
Medical Staff clinical privileges in accordance with this policy. Resident staff are not required to moonlight.<br />
Moonlighting activities will be closely monitored by the Department Chairs and Residency Program Directors<br />
for signs of fatigue and will guarantee sufficient time for rest and relaxation in order to promote the residents’<br />
educational experience and safe patient care. Further, resident moonlighting activities will count as part of the<br />
80‐hour work week.<br />
Specific qualifications and procedural requirements will be detailed in the GHS House Staff <strong>Manual</strong>.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
15
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐07‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: III.B.3<br />
Common Program Requirements: V1.A.5.d<br />
V1.G.1<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Duty Hours<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that, in compliance with ACGME<br />
Institutional requirements and applicable ACGME RRC requirements, resident working hours shall not exceed<br />
an average of 80 hours per workweek averaged over a 4 week period. House staff are considered to be on duty<br />
at all times when in the hospital and are subject to call at all hours.<br />
Each residency program is responsible for the ongoing monitoring of resident duty hours and must have a<br />
documented monitoring tool. Each program will specifically address duty hours compliance and<br />
documentation at the Program’s Annual Report to <strong>GMEC</strong> and the <strong>GMEC</strong> Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew process.<br />
The GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee does not recognize exceptions to the ACGME Resident Duty<br />
Hours guidelines.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
16
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐08‐11<br />
Page 1<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.D.4.i<br />
Common Program Requirements: V1.A.5.d<br />
POLICY TITLE: Resident Duty Hour Compliance Oversight<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that each program will have written policies<br />
and procedures consistent with the Institutional and Program Requirements for resident duty hours. These<br />
policies will be distributed to the residents and the faculty.<br />
Procedures:<br />
1) Monitoring of duty hours is required with frequency sufficient to ensure an appropriate<br />
balance between education and service and to meet ACGME Common Program<br />
Requirements. Those program requirements define duty hours as all clinical and<br />
academic activities and do not include reading and preparation time spent away from the duty<br />
site. The requirements state that duty hours be limited to 80 hours per week, and that continuous<br />
on site duty, including in‐house call, must not exceed 24 consecutive hours. Residents may remain<br />
on duty for up to six additional hours to participate in didactic activities, transfer care of patients,<br />
conduct outpatient clinics, and maintain continuity of medical and surgical care. No new patients<br />
may be accepted after 24 hours of continuous duty. Residents must be provided with one day in<br />
seven free from all educational and clinical responsibilities, averaged over a four‐week period,<br />
inclusive of call. Adequate time for rest and personal activities must be provided with adherence of<br />
10 hours off between duty shifts.<br />
Residents will use the New Innovations Web‐based <strong>System</strong> to document duty hours. If<br />
documented hours exceed the 80 hour compliance and violate the ACGME requirement, the<br />
resident must use the New Innovations duty hours comments section to document the specifics<br />
regarding the non‐compliance. Program Directors will use the same New Innovations reporting<br />
system for weekly duty hours compliance monitoring for their respective programs. <strong>GMEC</strong> will use<br />
New Innovations reporting to determine compliance. Programs will be monitored for duty hours<br />
compliance during the academic year and during annual reporting. Programs out of compliance<br />
will be monitored with a frequency to be determined by <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />
2) Directors of programs that are out of compliance with the Resident Duty Hours Policy will<br />
determine a plan and timeline to be in compliance and submit that plan and time line to the <strong>GMEC</strong><br />
for review and approval.<br />
3) Each resident will be responsible for providing accurate and timely data using New Innovations<br />
regarding their individual compliance with the <strong>GMEC</strong> Resident Duty Hour Policy and the ACGME<br />
Duty Hours requirements. Failure to comply may result in penalty action(s) to include the GHS<br />
Human Resources discipline cycle of verbal and written warnings, suspension, and dismissal.<br />
Non‐compliance Discipline:<br />
Resident duty hours documentation in a timely manner is a requirement. Residents document duty hours<br />
using the GHS New Innovations Web‐based <strong>System</strong>. Residents are required to complete duty hours<br />
17
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐08‐11<br />
Page 2<br />
POLICY TITLE: Resident Duty Hour Compliance Oversight<br />
documentation daily. When in non‐compliance of duty hours requirements, residents must complete<br />
documentation regarding the specifics of the situation within New Innovations comments section. Any<br />
resident unable to complete his/her duty hours documentation because of the following reasons, 1) vacation,<br />
2) sick, 3) or educational leave, must have approval from their Program Director.<br />
Failure to complete duty hours documentation is a demonstrated behavior of lack of the ACGME<br />
Professionalism general competency. Non‐compliance and failure to meet the duty hours documentation as<br />
required may result in the following disciplinary actions:<br />
First Offense:<br />
Second Offense:<br />
Third Offense:<br />
Fourth Offense:<br />
Fifth Offense:<br />
Process & Procedure Coaching<br />
Verbal Warning<br />
Written Warning<br />
Suspension<br />
Termination from Residency Program<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
18
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐09‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: III.B<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
House Staff <strong>Manual</strong><br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the <strong>GMEC</strong> will review and affirm the<br />
House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> revisions annually. The House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> reflects <strong>GMEC</strong> policy and is incorporated into<br />
the <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Manual</strong> by this reference and current Table of Contents attachment.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
19
2011 <strong>Manual</strong> of Policies and Procedures<br />
Medical Education Resident Staff<br />
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
Foreword and Purpose ................................................................................................................................... I<br />
Graduate Medical Education Institutional Commitment .............................................................................. II<br />
Resident Physicians/House Staff Teaching‐Learning Commitment ............................................................. III<br />
Section I: Programs Overview<br />
GME Program Overview ................................................................................................................................ 1<br />
Program Policy <strong>Manual</strong>s ................................................................................................................................ 2<br />
GHS Mission, Vision, & Values ..................................................................................................................... 3<br />
Facilities of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> ........................................................................................................... 4<br />
<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Organizational Structure............................................................................................ 5<br />
Graduate Medical Education Operational Structure ............................................................................................. 6<br />
Organizational Chart ‐ Medical Staff Flow Chart ................................................................................................... 7<br />
Medical Staff ........................................................................................................................................................... 8<br />
Medical Staff Supervision of Resident/Fellow Patient Care Activities .................................................................. 8<br />
Patient Care Chain of Command ............................................................................................................................ 9<br />
Physicians Notification Sequence – Appendix A .................................................................................................. 11<br />
Teaching Staff ........................................................................................................................................................ 11<br />
House Staff Liaison Committee ............................................................................................................................. 12<br />
<strong>System</strong> Committees: Resident Representation .......................................................................................... 12<br />
Section II: Education & Competency Requirements<br />
Licensure ................................................................................................................................................................ 13<br />
Advanced Cardiac Life Support ............................................................................................................................. 13<br />
Research Requirements ........................................................................................................................................ 15<br />
CITI Training ........................................................................................................................................................... 17<br />
Mandatory Trainings ............................................................................................................................................. 18<br />
Electronic Clinical Works (eCW) Training ............................................................................................................. 18<br />
Conferences ........................................................................................................................................................... 19<br />
Educational Rotations ............................................................................................................................................ 19<br />
International Electives ........................................................................................................................................... 19<br />
Patient Simulation Center ..................................................................................................................................... 20<br />
Performance Evaluations ...................................................................................................................................... 20<br />
Learning Portfolio .................................................................................................................................................. 20<br />
Certificates ............................................................................................................................................................. 21<br />
Section III: <strong>System</strong>s‐based Practice / Communication / Medical Information / Other<br />
Electronic Clinical Works (eCW) Training ............................................................................................................. 18<br />
<strong>System</strong> Communication Models ........................................................................................................................... 22<br />
Hand‐off Communication and Responsibilities .................................................................................................... 23<br />
Communication and Hand‐offs Policy .................................................................................................................. 23<br />
Pager Assignments ................................................................................................................................................ 24<br />
Communication Device ......................................................................................................................................... 24<br />
Social Media and Social Networking .................................................................................................................... 26<br />
20
Table of Contents ‐ Page 2<br />
Telephone Calls ...................................................................................................................................................... 28<br />
Emergency Code Procedures for House Staff ...................................................................................................... 28<br />
Emergency Paging Codes for <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> ................................................................................... 30<br />
Official Abbreviations “Do Not Use” List .............................................................................................................. 31<br />
Call Schedule .......................................................................................................................................................... 31<br />
Language Services .................................................................................................................................................. 31<br />
eNet – Employee Information/Payroll Self‐Service Access ................................................................................. 32<br />
Keys ........................................................................................................................................................................ 32<br />
Legibility of Handwriting ...................................................................................................................................... 32<br />
Loan Deferments ................................................................................................................................................... 33<br />
Medical Information Procedures for Residents/Fellows ..................................................................................... 33<br />
Procedure for Completion of Delinquent Medical Records ................................................................................ 34<br />
Corrections in Medical Records .................................................................................................................. 36<br />
Transcription Services ................................................................................................................................. 37<br />
Section IV: Policies & Procedures<br />
Consultation/Referral Policy ................................................................................................................................. 38<br />
Selection Criteria .................................................................................................................................................... 38<br />
Change of Residency/Fellowship Program Procedure ........................................................................................ 39<br />
Conflict of Interest ................................................................................................................................................. 39<br />
Controlled Substance Registration ....................................................................................................................... 40<br />
Promotion .............................................................................................................................................................. 40<br />
Discipline and Termination ................................................................................................................................... 40<br />
Resignation and Due Process ................................................................................................................................ 40<br />
Appeal Process ....................................................................................................................................................... 41<br />
Educational Leave and Travel Policy ..................................................................................................................... 41<br />
Lodging ............................................................................................................................................................... 42<br />
Meals ................................................................................................................................................................. 42<br />
Air Travel ............................................................................................................................................................ 42<br />
Automobile Travel ............................................................................................................................................. 42<br />
Registration Fees ............................................................................................................................................... 43<br />
Rental Cars ......................................................................................................................................................... 43<br />
Other Miscellaneous Expenses ......................................................................................................................... 43<br />
Travel Reimbursement ..................................................................................................................................... 44<br />
Travel to Present Paper .................................................................................................................................... 44<br />
Educational Allowance Fund ................................................................................................................................. 44<br />
Moving Allowance ................................................................................................................................................. 45<br />
Employee Health Requirements ........................................................................................................................... 45<br />
Fitness for Duty and Drug Free Work Environment &Testing ............................................................................. 46<br />
Harassment ................................................................................................................................................. 46<br />
Hepatitis B Vaccine Policy ..................................................................................................................................... 46<br />
Infection Prevention and Control ........................................................................................................................ 47<br />
DHEC Reportable Conditions ................................................................................................................................ 48<br />
Moonlighting Policy and Procedures for Residents/Fellows ............................................................................... 50<br />
Patients Rights and Responsibilities ..................................................................................................................... 54<br />
Patient Safety ......................................................................................................................................................... 56<br />
Resident Responsibilities During Local Extreme Emergent Situations and Disasters ................................. 56<br />
House Medical Staff Disaster Response ...................................................................................................... 58<br />
21
Table of Contents ‐ Page 3<br />
Duty Hours ............................................................................................................................................................. 59<br />
Sleep Deprivation and Fatigue .............................................................................................................................. 59<br />
Uniforms ................................................................................................................................................................. 60<br />
Vendor Policy ......................................................................................................................................................... 60<br />
Section V: Resources & Benefits<br />
Credit Union ........................................................................................................................................................... 61<br />
Direct Deposit of Paycheck ................................................................................................................................... 61<br />
Employee Accident Report .................................................................................................................................... 61<br />
Employee Insurance Highlights<br />
Insurance Highlights .......................................................................................................................................... 62<br />
Health Insurance Plan ....................................................................................................................................... 62<br />
Silver and Gold Plans Comparison .................................................................................................................... 62<br />
Prescription Drug Benefit ....................................................................................................................... 63<br />
Cost of Health Care Coverage ........................................................................................................................... 63<br />
Dental Insurance ............................................................................................................................................... 64<br />
Vision Plan ......................................................................................................................................................... 65<br />
Flexible Spending Accounts ............................................................................................................................. 65<br />
Health Services Benefit ..................................................................................................................................... 65<br />
Basic Group Term Life Insurance/AD&D Insurance ........................................................................................ 65<br />
Supplemental Group Universal Life Insurance ................................................................................................ 66<br />
Voluntary AD&D Insurance ............................................................................................................................... 66<br />
Business Travel Accidental Insurance .............................................................................................................. 66<br />
World‐wide Travel Assistance .......................................................................................................................... 67<br />
Pre‐paid Legal Plan and Identity Theft Shield Benefit ..................................................................................... 67<br />
Long Term Disability Insurance ........................................................................................................................ 67<br />
Short Term Disability Insurance ....................................................................................................................... 67<br />
Long Term Care (LTC) Insurance ....................................................................................................................... 67<br />
Allstate Supplemental Health Options Plan (SHOP) ........................................................................................ 68<br />
Retirement Savings Plan ................................................................................................................................... 68<br />
Section 529 Plan “Future Scholar Program” .................................................................................................... 68<br />
Adoption Benefit Assistance ............................................................................................................................. 68<br />
Paid Time Off (PTO) ........................................................................................................................................... 68<br />
Other Benefits ................................................................................................................................................... 68<br />
Professional Liability ......................................................................................................................................... 69<br />
Leave & PTO Policies<br />
Compassionate Leave ....................................................................................................................................... 69<br />
Court Appearances ............................................................................................................................................ 70<br />
Family and Medical Leave Act Policy ............................................................................................................... 70<br />
Jury Duty ............................................................................................................................................................ 78<br />
Maternity Leave ................................................................................................................................................ 78<br />
Military Leave .................................................................................................................................................... 78<br />
PTO‐Paid Time Off (PTO) ................................................................................................................................... 79<br />
Vacation ............................................................................................................................................................. 79<br />
Holiday PTO Policy for Resident Staff/Fellows ................................................................................................ 79<br />
Educational Leave ............................................................................................................................................. 79<br />
Procedure for Requesting PTO ......................................................................................................................... 79<br />
Severance Pay ................................................................................................................................................... 80<br />
22
Table of Contents ‐ Page 4<br />
Illness ................................................................................................................................................................ 81<br />
Meals ...................................................................................................................................................................... 81<br />
Personal Problems and Concerns/Reporting Anonymity/Employee Assistance Program ................................ 81<br />
Risk Management .................................................................................................................................................. 82<br />
Salary ...................................................................................................................................................................... 82<br />
Section VI: Forms<br />
Request for Change of Residency/Fellowship ...................................................................................................... 83<br />
Education or Vacation Leave Request .................................................................................................................. 84<br />
Communication Device ........................................................................................................................................ 85<br />
GME Communication Device(s) Authorization – IPAD ........................................................................................ 86<br />
GME Communication Device(s) Authorization – Telephone .............................................................................. 87<br />
Application for Moonlighting Privileges ............................................................................................................... 88<br />
International Electives Rotation Request Form ................................................................................................... 93<br />
GHS Resident Waiver Statement .......................................................................................................................... 95<br />
International Program Letter of Agreement Template ....................................................................................... 96<br />
23
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐10‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />
Common Program Requirements: V1.B.1‐4<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Transitions of Care<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the faculty and resident physicians will<br />
adhere to the standardized Communication and Hand‐offs policy as reflected in the GHS Medical Staff Policies<br />
and detailed in the <strong>Manual</strong> of Policies and Procedures for Medical Education Resident Staff (House Staff<br />
<strong>Manual</strong>).<br />
Specialty‐specific processes that are compliant with the Medical Staff Communication and Hands‐off policy are<br />
within each of the Residency Program's written policies and procedures.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
24
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐11‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />
Common Program Requirements: VI.C.1‐3<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Sleep Deprivation and Fatigue<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that faculty and residents and fellows will be<br />
educated to recognize the signs of fatigue and sleep deprivation and must adopt and apply policies to prevent<br />
and counteract its potential negative effects on patient care and learning.<br />
Each GME Program will assure the GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> through audit and annual reporting that such curriculum and<br />
supervision are formalized within the respective GME program. Unique policies and/or procedures per<br />
program will be in compliance with this policy and the policy and guidance from respective RRC’s and the<br />
ACGME.<br />
Education may be unique to the individual program or conducted GME‐wide as the Program Directors<br />
Committee so directs.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
25
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐11‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements:<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE: International Electives<br />
It is the policy of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Graduate Medical Education Committee that residency<br />
programs may provide elective educational opportunities at international sites. Each rotation must be<br />
acceptable within the individual residency program curriculum and the related ACGME/RRC requirements.<br />
Approved residents:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Must meet minimum competency‐based academic standards as determined by the related residency<br />
program.<br />
May be required to present her/his experience to the Department.<br />
Are responsible for obtaining all appropriate vaccinations as designated by an international health<br />
clinic and providing certification of emergency of‐of‐country medical care coverage.<br />
Are responsible for formal medical clearance by their personal physician for travel to the specific area.<br />
May use their individual education allowance money at the discretion of the Program Director. Any<br />
remaining finances beyond the education allowance resource will be the responsibility of the resident<br />
physicians.<br />
A formal application located in the House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> (supplied through the residency program office) will be<br />
completed and will preferably be submitted three (3) months prior to the anticipated beginning of the<br />
international elective but must be submitted at least one (1) month prior to the rotation. The application must<br />
receive signatory approval by the Program Director and the Designated Institutional Official. The resident<br />
physician will not be insured through the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> malpractice coverage and must obtain<br />
separate malpractice coverage, if available.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
26
III. GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE (<strong>GMEC</strong>)<br />
27
<strong>GMEC</strong> ROLE w/ Organization Chart<br />
The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Graduate Medical Education Committee has oversight authority and<br />
responsibility for all aspects of residency education. Voting membership includes the DIO, Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education (Chair), Program Directors (Associate Program Directors are non‐voting members<br />
except by Program Director proxy), the House Staff Officers elected by the House Staff – (President, Vice<br />
President, Secretary), the Academic Services Administrator, and others as deemed by DIO appointment.<br />
Departmental Faculty Directors for Education and the Vice President for Academic Development also serve as<br />
non‐voting members. Other non‐voting faculty or members may be appointed by the DIO.<br />
The GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> will establish and implement policies and procedures regarding the quality of education and<br />
the work environment for the residents and fellows in all programs.<br />
The GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> will conduct its oversight responsibilities in compliance with ACGME institutional requirements,<br />
ACGME common program requirements and applicable RRC guidelines.<br />
28
GREENVILLE HOSPITAL SYSTEM<br />
GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION PROGRAMMATIC STRUCTURE<br />
Organized<br />
Medical<br />
Staff<br />
GHS<br />
Board of Trustees<br />
GHS<br />
President & CEO<br />
Assistant Dean<br />
Graduate Medical<br />
Education<br />
GHS<br />
VP, Medical & Academic Services<br />
(DIO)<br />
Program Directors<br />
Committee<br />
Graduate Medical<br />
Education Committee<br />
Academic Services<br />
Administration<br />
Family<br />
Medicine<br />
Internal<br />
Medicine<br />
Medicine‐<br />
Pediatrics<br />
General<br />
Surgery<br />
Obstetrics &<br />
Gynecology<br />
Orthopaedic<br />
Surgery<br />
Pediatrics<br />
Sports<br />
Medicine<br />
Vascular<br />
Medicine<br />
Vascular<br />
Surgery<br />
Minimal<br />
Access<br />
Surgery<br />
Total Joint<br />
Arthroplasty<br />
Dev/Behav<br />
Pediatrics<br />
* A dotted line denotes a non‐ACGME accredited program<br />
<strong>Rev</strong>ised: November 2011<br />
29
GREENVILLE HOSPITAL SYSTEM<br />
PHYSICIAN AFFAIRS OPERATIONAL STRUCTURE<br />
GHS<br />
President & CEO<br />
* Associate VP &<br />
Chief Medical Officer<br />
(CMO)<br />
GHS<br />
VP, Medical & Academic Services<br />
* Associate VP &<br />
Designated Institutional<br />
Official (DIO)<br />
GHS UMG Chief<br />
Administrative<br />
Officer & Executive<br />
Director, Ambulatory<br />
Services<br />
UMG<br />
Medical<br />
Director<br />
Medical<br />
Staff<br />
Office<br />
Department of Clinical<br />
Integration<br />
Clinical Integration Responsibilities<br />
Physician Compensation &<br />
Service Expansion Responsibilities<br />
UMG Medical<br />
Services Offices<br />
Center for<br />
Teaching & Learning (CTL)<br />
Academic Integration Responsibilities<br />
GHS Chairs<br />
* Associate VP, Executive VP, or just VP <strong>Rev</strong>ised: October 2011<br />
30
GREENVILLE HOSPITAL SYSTEM<br />
GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION OPERATIONAL STRUCTURE<br />
GHS<br />
President & CEO<br />
GHS Executive VP, Medical & Academic Services<br />
and Dean, USC School of Medicine‐<strong>Greenville</strong><br />
VP & DIO for Academics<br />
and Executive Medical Director UMG<br />
GHS Department<br />
Chairs Academic<br />
Responsibilities<br />
Assistant Dean<br />
Graduate Medical<br />
Education<br />
Associate Dean<br />
USCSOM‐Columbia<br />
GHS VP, Academic<br />
Development<br />
Center for<br />
Teaching &<br />
Learning (CTL)<br />
Offices<br />
UMG Department<br />
Operations<br />
Directors<br />
1<br />
GME Residency Program<br />
Coordinators<br />
GME Residency<br />
Program<br />
Directors<br />
2<br />
3<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong><br />
Administrator<br />
Academic Services<br />
Curriculum<br />
Development<br />
GME &<br />
Curriculum<br />
Development<br />
Officer<br />
GME<br />
Operations<br />
MedEx<br />
Academy<br />
Note 1: This reporting relationship is for daily activities<br />
of the residency program within the UMG Clinical Department.<br />
Note 2: Required ACGME reporting relationship for support of<br />
academic components of the individual program.<br />
Note 3: This relationship is for the overriding academic corporate<br />
support activities and ACGME policy and procedure oversight<br />
requirements.<br />
* Associate VP, Executive VP, or just VP <strong>Rev</strong>ised: May 2012<br />
31
<strong>GMEC</strong> RESPONSIBILITIES<br />
In accordance with the ACGME Institutional Requirements, the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Graduate Medical<br />
Education Committee will:<br />
1. Annually review and recommend resident stipends, benefits, and funding for resident positions to<br />
assure an equitable and fair allocation process.<br />
2. Ensure effective communications between <strong>GMEC</strong> and appropriate system‐wide committees and the<br />
effective communication between program directors and clinical teaching sites.<br />
3. Ensure compliance regarding resident duty hours requirements (see <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐07‐11).<br />
4. Monitor programs’ supervision of residents and assure that supervision is consistent with ACGME<br />
requirements.<br />
5. Communicate with the leadership of the Organized Medical Staff regarding the safety and quality of<br />
patient care.<br />
6. Provide oversight to assure a curriculum and an evaluation system that ensures that residents<br />
demonstrate achievement of the ACGME general competencies.<br />
7. Ensure appropriate oversight for the selection, evaluation, promotion, transfer, discipline, and/or<br />
dismissal of residents in compliance with the Institutional and Common Program Requirements (see<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #’s II‐01‐11, II‐02‐11, II‐03‐11).<br />
8. <strong>Rev</strong>iew all ACGME program accreditation letters of notification and monitoring of action plans for<br />
correction of citations and areas of non‐compliance.<br />
9. <strong>Rev</strong>iew the GHS ACGME Institutional Accreditation letter of notification from the IRC and monitoring<br />
of action plans for correction of citations and areas of noncompliance.<br />
10. Prior to submissions to the ACGME by program directors, provide oversight of program changes<br />
through review and approval of:<br />
a. All applications for ACGME accreditation of new programs;<br />
b. Changes in resident complement;<br />
c. Major changes in program structure or length of training;<br />
d. Additions and deletions of participating institutions;<br />
e. Appointments of new program directors;<br />
f. Progress reports requested by any <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee;<br />
g. Responses to all proposed adverse actions;<br />
32
<strong>GMEC</strong> Responsibilities<br />
Page 2<br />
h. Requests for exceptions to resident duty hours requirements;<br />
i. Voluntary withdrawals of programs accreditation;<br />
j. Requests for an appeal of an adverse action;<br />
k. Appeal presentations to a Board of Appeal or the ACGME.<br />
11. Provide oversight of all phases of educational experiments and innovations that may deviate<br />
from Institutional, Common, and special/subspecialty‐specific Program Requirements.<br />
12. Provide oversight of program reductions and closures (see <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐04‐11).<br />
13. Monitor interactions of residents and GME programs with vendor representatives (see <strong>GMEC</strong><br />
Policy # III‐02‐11).<br />
14. Present an annual report to the organized Medical Staff and the GHS Board of Trustees that reviews<br />
the activities of the <strong>GMEC</strong> during the past year with attention to the impact of GME on patient safety<br />
and quality of care, resident supervision, resident responsibilities, resident evaluation, and<br />
compliance with duty‐hour standards.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
33
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐01‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: I.B.4.a<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
DIO Delegation<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that in the absence of the Designated<br />
Institutional Official, the Assistant Dean for Graduate Medical Education will have the authority and<br />
responsibility to review and cosign all program information forms and any documents or correspondence<br />
submitted to the ACGME by Program Directors.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
34
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐02‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: III.B.13<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Vendor Interactions<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that each residency program will be in<br />
compliance with the GHS CME policies regarding education sponsorship and comply with its own program –<br />
specific vendor interaction policy that is compliant with GHS Vendor policy and procedures.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
35
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />
Page 1<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
GME Vendor Interactions<br />
Policy and Guidelines for Interactions between the Faculty, Residents, Medical Students and Educational<br />
Staff of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center and Commercial Vendors.<br />
Purpose of Policy<br />
The purpose of this policy is to establish guidelines for interactions with industry representatives for medical<br />
staff, faculty, staff, students, and trainees of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center.<br />
Interactions with industry occur in a variety of contexts, including marketing of new pharmaceutical products,<br />
medical devices, and research equipment and supplies on‐site, on‐site training of newly purchased devices, the<br />
development of new devices, educational support of medical students and trainees, and continuing medical<br />
education. Faculty and trainees also participate in interactions with industry off campus and in scholarly<br />
publications. Many aspects of these interactions are positive and important for promoting the educational,<br />
clinical and research missions of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center. However, these<br />
interactions must be ethical and cannot create conflicts of interest that could endanger patient safety, data<br />
integrity, the integrity of our education and training programs, or the reputation of either the faculty member<br />
or the institution.<br />
Statement of Policy<br />
It is the policy of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center that interactions with industry<br />
should be conducted according to the highest ethical standards and so as to avoid or minimize conflicts of<br />
interest. When conflicts of interest do arise they must be addressed appropriately, as described herein.<br />
Scope of Policy<br />
This policy incorporates the following types of interactions with industry. It does not include faculty research and<br />
related activities, which are included in the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center Medical Staff Policy<br />
on Conflict of Interest (http://ghsnet.ghs.org/Medstaff/WebDocuments/Policies/Conflict_of_Interest_Policy.pdf).<br />
I. Gifts and compensation<br />
II. Site access by sales and marketing representatives<br />
III. Provision of scholarships and other educational funds to students and trainees<br />
IV. Support for educational and other professional activities<br />
V. Disclosure of relationships with industry<br />
VI. Training of students, trainees, and staff regarding potential conflict of interest in industry interactions<br />
I. Gifts and Compensation<br />
A. Personal gifts from industry may not be accepted anywhere at the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong><br />
University Medical Center or at any other clinical facility operated by GHS UMC, such as<br />
physicians’ practices and outlying hospitals. In addition, GHSUMC faculty, staff and trainees<br />
may also not accept gifts at any non‐GHSUMC clinical facility such as other hospitals, outreach<br />
clinics and the like. Non‐faculty medical staff members are strongly discouraged from<br />
accepting gifts at non‐GHSUMC‐operated clinical facilities but are not proscribed by this policy<br />
from doing so.<br />
B. Individuals should be aware of other applicable policies, such as the AMA Code of Ethics<br />
Opinion 8.061 – Gifts to Physicians from Industry<br />
(http://www.ama‐assn.org/ama/pub/physician‐resources/medical‐ethics/code‐medicalethics/opinion8061.page)<br />
and the Accrediting Council for Continuing Medical Education<br />
Standards for Commercial Support (www.accme.org).<br />
36
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />
Page 2<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
GME Vendor Interactions<br />
C. Individuals may not accept gifts or compensation for listening to a sales talk by an industry<br />
representative.<br />
D. Individuals may not accept gifts or compensation for prescribing or changing a patient's<br />
prescription.<br />
E. Individuals must consciously and actively divorce clinical care decisions from any perceived or<br />
actual benefits expected from any company. It is unacceptable for patient care decisions to be<br />
influenced by the possibility of personal financial gain.<br />
F. Individuals may not accept compensation, including the defraying of costs, for simply<br />
attending a CME or other activity or conference (that is, if the individual is not speaking or<br />
otherwise actively participating or presenting at the event).<br />
G. Textbooks and items of educational value may be provided to the institution if approved by<br />
the department Chair/ program director and if consistent with department educational goals<br />
and institutional policies.<br />
H. Pens, pads, educational brochures which feature specific product names and information are<br />
not to be accepted and are not to be left on the premises.<br />
II.<br />
III.<br />
Site Access by Sales and Marketing Representatives<br />
A. Sales and marketing representatives are not permitted in any patient care areas except to<br />
provide in‐service training on devices and other equipment and then only by appointment.<br />
B. Sales and marketing representatives are permitted in non‐patient care areas by appointment<br />
only. Appointments will normally be made for such purposes as:<br />
1. In‐service training of GHSUMC personnel for research or clinical equipment or devices<br />
already purchased.<br />
2. Evaluation of new purchases of equipment, devices, or related items.<br />
C. Appointments to obtain information about new drugs in the formulary will normally be issued<br />
by the hospital pharmacy or by Pharmaceutical and Therapeutics Committees. The acceptance<br />
of pharmaceutical samples will be governed by the GHS Pharmacy policy.<br />
D. Appointments may be made on a per visit basis at the discretion of the faculty member, his or<br />
her division or department, or designated hospital personnel issuing the invitation and with<br />
the approval of appropriate Department Chair.<br />
Provision of Scholarships and Other Educational Funds to Students and Trainees<br />
A. Industry support of students and trainees should be free of any actual or perceived conflict of<br />
interest, must be specifically for the purpose of education and must comply with all of the<br />
following provisions:<br />
1. The educational department, program or division selects the fellow, student or<br />
trainee.<br />
2. The funds are provided to the department, program, or division and not directly to<br />
student or trainee.<br />
3. The department, program or division has determined that the funded conference or<br />
program has educational merit.<br />
4. The recipient is not subject to any implicit or explicit expectation of providing<br />
something in return for the support, i.e., a "quid pro quo."<br />
37
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />
Page 3<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
GME Vendor Interactions<br />
B. This provision may not apply to national or regional merit‐based awards, which are considered<br />
on a case‐by‐case basis.<br />
IV.<br />
Support for Educational and Other Professional Activities<br />
A. Individuals should be aware of the ACCME Standards for Commercial Support. They provide<br />
useful guidelines for evaluating all forms of industry interaction, both on and off campus and<br />
including both GHSUMC‐ sponsored and other events. The Standards may be found by going to<br />
the website: www.accme.org.<br />
B. All education events sponsored by the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center<br />
must be compliant with ACCME Standards for Commercial Support whether or not CME credit<br />
is awarded.<br />
1. Educational grants that are compliant with the ACCME Standards may be received<br />
from industry but must be administered by departments or divisions and not by<br />
individual faculty.<br />
2. Divisions and departments must maintain records of compliance with the ACCME<br />
Standards.<br />
C. Vendors shall not sponsor any educational programs without approval by the Department<br />
Chair, Program Director or Section Chief. In all cases the selection of speakers and assurance of<br />
the educational integrity of the program is the responsibility of the GHS faculty member,<br />
program director or department chair. While the support of venders may be acknowledged<br />
vendors may not speak or present product information in conjunction with educational time.<br />
There can be no activities to promote or market specific products in educational time.<br />
D. Meals or other types of food directly funded by industry may not be provided at the <strong>Greenville</strong><br />
<strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center or for GHS educational events off campus.<br />
E. Faculty and medical staff should evaluate very carefully their own participation in meetings<br />
and conferences that are fully or partially sponsored or run by industry because of the high<br />
potential for perceived or real conflict of interest. This provision does not apply to meetings of<br />
professional societies that may receive partial industry support, meetings governed by ACCME<br />
Standards, and the like.<br />
F. Individuals who actively participate in meetings and conferences supported in part or in whole<br />
by industry (e.g., by giving a lecture, organizing the meeting) should follow these guidelines:<br />
1. Financial support by industry is fully disclosed by the meeting sponsor.<br />
2. The meeting or lecture content is determined by the speaker and not the industrial<br />
sponsor.<br />
3. The lecturer is expected to provide a fair and balanced assessment of therapeutic<br />
options and to promote objective scientific and educational activities and discourse.<br />
4. The GHSUMC participant is not required by an industry sponsor to accept advice or<br />
services concerning speakers, content, etc., as a condition of the sponsor's<br />
contribution of funds or services.<br />
5. The lecturer makes clear that content reflects individual views and not the views of<br />
<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center.<br />
6. The use of the GHSUMC name in non‐GHSUMC event is limited to the identification of<br />
the individual by his or her title and affiliation.<br />
38
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />
Page 4<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
GME Vendor Interactions<br />
V. Disclosure of Relationships with Industry<br />
A. Individuals are prohibited from publishing articles under their own names that are written in<br />
whole or material part by industry employees.<br />
B. In scholarly publications, individuals must disclose their related financial interests in<br />
accordance with the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors<br />
(http://www.icmje.org).<br />
C. Faculty with supervisory responsibilities for students, residents, trainees or staff should ensure<br />
that the faculty's conflict or potential conflict of interest does not affect or appear to affect his<br />
or her supervision of the student, resident, trainee, or staff member.<br />
D. Individuals having a direct role making institutional decisions on equipment or drug<br />
procurement must disclose to the purchasing unit, prior to making any such<br />
decision, any financial interest they or their immediate family have in companies that might<br />
substantially benefit from the decision. Such financial interests could include equity<br />
ownership, compensated positions on advisory boards, a paid consultancy, or other forms of<br />
compensated relationship. They must also disclose any research or educational interest they<br />
or their department have that might substantially benefit from the decision. The purchasing<br />
unit will decide whether the individual must excuse him/herself from the purchasing decision.<br />
1. This provision excludes indirect ownership such as stock held through mutual funds.<br />
2. The term "immediate family" includes the individual's spouse or dependent children.<br />
E. For disclosure requirements related to educational activities, see the ACCME Standards for<br />
Commercial Support (www.accme.org).<br />
VI.<br />
Training of Students, Trainees, and Staff Regarding Potential Conflict of Interest in Interactions with<br />
Industry<br />
B. All students, residents, trainees, and staff shall receive training regarding potential conflicts of<br />
interest in interactions with industry.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
39
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐04‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: II.D.5<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Residency Closure/Reduction in Size<br />
GHS is committed to facilitating completion of training by any resident who has matriculated. GHS will inform<br />
the <strong>GMEC</strong>, the DIO, and residents as soon as possible when it intends to reduce the size of or close one or<br />
more programs, or when GHS intends to close. In practice this means that closure of residencies, reduction of a<br />
resident complement, or institutional closure is done in a proactive planned manner such that the reductions<br />
are timed with program completion. Reductions are to be accomplished during the recruiting phase rather<br />
than through elimination of matriculated residents. In the event that crisis would preclude such an approach,<br />
GHS would be committed to maintain the program until the residents were enrolled in an ACGME accredited<br />
program elsewhere to continue their education. This approach is in conformity with the institutional<br />
requirements of the ACGME.<br />
In the event that GHS intends to reduce the size or close either a program or the Institution itself, GHS will<br />
inform the <strong>GMEC</strong>, the DIO, and the residents as soon as possible.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
40
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐05‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: 1.B.8<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Disaster and GME<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that in the event of a local extreme<br />
emergent situation, natural disaster or cataclysm that all appropriate steps will be made to continue<br />
compliance with all applicable ACGME and RRC rules. GME will be in compliance with the GHS disaster policy<br />
and procedures (GHS Emergency Operations Plan ‐ EOP). In the event that such disaster prohibits timely<br />
continuance of Graduate Medical Education programs at the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong>, the ACGME and RRC’s<br />
will be contacted to ensure an orderly transaction to other ACGME accredited residency programs.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
41
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐06‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />
Common Program Requirements: N/A<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Program Annual Reports w/Format<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that each program will present to the GHS<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> a written annual report per the attached outline and schedule. The Annual Reports will become a part<br />
of the <strong>GMEC</strong> meeting minutes.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
42
Annual Report Presentation Schedule<br />
SEPTEMBER<br />
OCTOBER<br />
NOVEMBER<br />
DECEMBER<br />
Orthopaedics Surgery<br />
OB/GYN<br />
General Surgery<br />
Vascular Surgery<br />
Minimal Access Surgery<br />
Internal Medicine<br />
Vascular Medicine<br />
Family Medicine<br />
Sports Medicine<br />
Pediatrics<br />
Developmental Pediatrics<br />
Combined Internal Medicine/Pediatrics<br />
43
<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong><br />
Residency Program<br />
Annual Report:<br />
[Type Name of Program]<br />
Program Director:<br />
2011<br />
Academic<br />
Year<br />
44
2011 Residency Program Annual Report Template<br />
Program:<br />
Department Chair:<br />
Program Director:<br />
Program Coordinator:<br />
RRC accreditation status:<br />
Date of last RRC site visit:<br />
Date of last internal review:<br />
Date of next RRC review:<br />
Faculty: List all faculty members with USCSOM – G faculty appointments (* - the asterisk<br />
indicates new faculty since last report). Indicate core faculty members as designated within<br />
the Program’s RRC PIF guidelines. Document average hours per week applied to each<br />
performance item below.<br />
Name (Position)<br />
Core<br />
Faculty<br />
(Y/N)<br />
Based<br />
Mainly<br />
at Site<br />
Primary and Secondary<br />
Specialties / Fields<br />
Original<br />
Specialty Cert Cert Cert<br />
Field (Y/N) Year Status<br />
Re-cert<br />
Year<br />
No. of<br />
Years<br />
Teaching<br />
in This<br />
Specialty<br />
Average Hours Per Week Spent On<br />
Clinical<br />
Supervision<br />
Didactic<br />
Admin Teaching<br />
Research<br />
45
Faculty awards/recognition:<br />
National/Regional Committees & Positions of Recognition:<br />
<strong>Hospital</strong> Committees:<br />
Other:<br />
House Staff:<br />
Resident positions by year:<br />
Number of positions filled by year:<br />
Residents terminated during prior year:<br />
Status of any other disciplinary/probation action:<br />
Awards/recognition:<br />
In-training exam results:<br />
Graduating resident plans:<br />
Specialty Board Pass Rate:<br />
<strong>Hospital</strong> Committees:<br />
Match results:<br />
Total positions:<br />
Rank order matched:<br />
Open positions:<br />
# IMG matched:<br />
# Minority matched:<br />
# Positions filled outside of match:<br />
Scholarly Activity: (Faculty & Residents)<br />
46
Faculty & Resident/Fellow Scholarly Productivity Chart<br />
Complete summative chart and list citations of scholarly activities below.<br />
Publications:<br />
Peer <strong>Rev</strong>iewed:<br />
Non-Peer <strong>Rev</strong>iewed:<br />
Books & Book Chapters Published:<br />
Members of Nat’l Study Sections or Committees:<br />
Journal Editors:<br />
Faculty<br />
Number of: Number of: Number of Departmental Members Who Are:<br />
Articles in Books & Members of<br />
Members<br />
Peerreviewed<br />
Chapters Sections or<br />
Extramural<br />
Book Nat’l Study<br />
working on<br />
Journal Editors<br />
Journals Published Committees<br />
Grants<br />
Residents/<br />
Fellows<br />
Regional/national presentations:<br />
Local presentations:<br />
Extramural Grants: PI’s, Description, Funding Agency, Funding Amount, and Length<br />
Ongoing research initiatives:<br />
Other:<br />
Issues/concerns:<br />
Status of RRC citations:<br />
Status of Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew concerns:<br />
Other:<br />
47
Documentation Requirements with Comments<br />
Written Recruitment Policy: (provide policy)<br />
Written Competency-based Goals and Objectives: (provide curriculum<br />
documentation)<br />
General Competencies Curriculum and Measurement Compliance: (provide one<br />
example per ACGME general competency of curricula and assessments)<br />
Simulation Center Activities: (list learning modules used and numbers participating<br />
with each activity)<br />
Resident Responsibilities: (describe the process for graduated responsibility and<br />
autonomy with supervision appropriate to the level of resident expertise and seniority)<br />
Resident Supervision: (provide a narrative describing relationships and levels of<br />
resident supervision within the program)<br />
Formal Resident and Faculty Evaluation Policy and Process: (provide policy and<br />
describe processes)<br />
Formal Rotation Evaluations: (with examples)<br />
Learning Portfolio: (describe the tool(s) used to document an organized collection of<br />
past and current learning accomplishments and scholarly activities used to reflect and<br />
assess general competencies and progressive practice capabilities. Provide one<br />
learning portfolio example and describe the process for reviewing resident/faculty<br />
academic performance)<br />
Residents/Fellows:<br />
Faculty:<br />
Master Affiliation Agreements & PLA’s: Provide a copy of each ACGME-defined<br />
required agreement.<br />
Definition: There must be a program letter of agreement (PLA) between the program and<br />
each participating site providing a required assignment. The PLA must be renewed at least<br />
every five years.<br />
48
For each required PLA complete the following table by marking an “X” in the appropriate<br />
column. Copy and repeat table as needed.<br />
Agreement with:<br />
Does the agreement identify faculty with<br />
supervisory responsibilities?<br />
Does the agreement specify responsibilities for:<br />
Teaching<br />
Supervision<br />
Formal Evaluation<br />
Does the agreement specify the duration and<br />
content of the educational experience?<br />
Does the agreement state the policies and<br />
procedures that will govern resident education<br />
during the assignment?<br />
Please answer the following question by<br />
inserting the word Yes, No, or N/A in the<br />
appropriate column.<br />
Has the program made all RRC required<br />
additions or deletions through ACGME ADS?<br />
Explain below.<br />
Last renewal<br />
Date:<br />
YES<br />
YES/NO<br />
NO<br />
N/A<br />
Duty Hours Compliance with Documentation: Provide description of process<br />
through which you monitor compliance with duty hour standards. Include New<br />
Innovations summative report including list of exceptions and responses)<br />
Resident Fatigue Policy, Monitoring, and Education: (provide departmental policy<br />
and list training initiatives)<br />
Patient Safety & Quality of Care Education: (provide a narrative describing resident<br />
participation in patient safety and quality of care education)<br />
Hand-off Process: (provide a narrative describing transition of care and attach written<br />
policy regarding hand-offs)<br />
Department Evaluation & Plan: (provide evaluation summary and improvement<br />
plans)<br />
Future Initiatives Based Upon Department Evaluation and Plan:<br />
49
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐07‐11<br />
Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />
Common Program Requirements: N/A<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Manual</strong> and policies<br />
will be reviewed for affirmation and/or amendment at least every two years.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
50
IV. INTERNAL REVIEWS<br />
51
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />
Page 1<br />
Institutional Requirements: IV.A‐B<br />
Common Program Requirements:<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />
It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that an internal programmatic review of<br />
each graduate medical education residency program will be conducted on a regular basis by the Graduate<br />
Medical Education Committee (<strong>GMEC</strong>) through an appointed internal review committee.<br />
Procedures:<br />
1. Internal reviews must be in process and documented in the <strong>GMEC</strong> minutes by<br />
approximately the midpoint of the accreditation cycle. The accreditation cycle is<br />
calculated from the date of the meeting at which the final accreditation action was taken to the<br />
time of the next site visit. The internal review is considered complete when the report is accepted<br />
by <strong>GMEC</strong>. Probation‐designated or programs with significant RRC deficiencies may be reviewed<br />
with required action plans more frequently.<br />
2. When a program has no residents enrolled at the mid‐point of the review cycle, the<br />
following circumstances apply:<br />
a. The <strong>GMEC</strong> will demonstrate continued oversight of those programs through a<br />
modified internal review that ensures the program has maintained adequate<br />
faculty and staff resources, clinical volume, and other necessary curricular<br />
elements required to be in substantial compliance with Institutional, Common and<br />
specialty‐specific Program Requirements prior to the program enrolling a resident.<br />
b. After enrolling a resident, an internal review will be completed within the second sixmonth<br />
period of the resident's first year in the program.<br />
3. The residency program's Program Director is notified by Academic Services<br />
Administration that an internal review will be scheduled. The Academic Services<br />
Administration will coordinate all appropriate logistics for the internal review process.<br />
4. The internal review committee is appointed by the GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> Chairperson. (See<br />
Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Format.)<br />
5. The designated Residency Program will be provided a copy of the specific steps for the internal<br />
review process. (See Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Format.)<br />
6. Upon the resolve of the review process, the results will be reported to the <strong>GMEC</strong>. (See Internal<br />
<strong>Rev</strong>iew Format.)<br />
7. Upon identification of program deficiencies and/or issues, the residency program will<br />
submit a written action plan within 60 days to the <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />
8. The designated residency program may be required to provide periodic action plans to<br />
the <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />
52
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />
Page 2<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />
GHS Graduate Medical Education <strong>Rev</strong>iew Format<br />
1. For each internal review, the <strong>GMEC</strong> chairperson will appoint an Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
Committee consisting of:<br />
a. A Department Chair or Program Director from a residency program other than the<br />
program under review.<br />
b. Faculty member(s) from residency programs not being reviewed.<br />
c. Resident(s) from residency programs not being reviewed.<br />
d. A Residency Program Coordinator from a program not being reviewed.<br />
e. Designated Institutional Official is an ex‐officio member without vote.<br />
f. The Administrator for Academic Services will serve as the process coordinator and a voting<br />
member.<br />
g. Manager, GME Curriculum is an ex‐officio member without vote.<br />
h. The Assistant Dean for Graduate Medical Education serves as Chair .... unless<br />
the program reviewed is within his/her discipline. In that event, the Academic<br />
Services Administrator will serve as process coordinator and Chair.<br />
i. Additional internal or external reviewers may be included on the internal review<br />
committee. Administrators from outside the program may be included.<br />
2. <strong>Rev</strong>iew protocol:<br />
A. The Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee will study, review applicable documentation, and assess<br />
the following:<br />
1. Compliance with the Common, specialty/subspecialty‐specific Program, and<br />
Institutional Requirements;<br />
2. Educational objectives and effectiveness in meeting those objectives;<br />
3. Educational and financial resources;<br />
4. Effectiveness in addressing areas of non‐compliance and concerns in previous<br />
ACGME accreditation letters of notification and previous internal reviews;<br />
5. Effectiveness of educational outcomes in the ACGME general competencies;<br />
6. Effectiveness in using evaluation tools and outcome measures to assess a<br />
resident's level of competence in each of the ACGME general competencies;<br />
Annual program improvement efforts in:<br />
a) Resident performance using aggregated resident data;<br />
b) Faculty development;<br />
c) Graduate performance including performance of program graduates on<br />
the certification examination; and<br />
d) Program quality.<br />
7. Policies on selection, evaluation, and promotion of residents, disciplinary action,<br />
supervision of residents, duty hours, and moonlighting.<br />
53
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />
Page 3<br />
POLICY TITLE: Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />
Materials and data to be used in the review process will include:<br />
a. The ACGME Common, specialty/subspecialty‐specific Program, and<br />
Institutional Requirements in effect at the time of the review;<br />
b. Procedures and documentation regarding compliance with duty hours<br />
requirements.<br />
c. Accreditation letters of notification from previous ACGME reviews and<br />
progress reports sent to the respective RRC.<br />
d. Reports from previous internal reviews of the program;<br />
e. Resident evaluations of the faculty and the overall program;<br />
f. Previous annual program evaluation; and<br />
g. Results from internal and external resident surveys, if available.<br />
B. The Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee will conduct interviews with the program director, key<br />
faculty members, at least one peer‐selected resident from each level of training in the<br />
program, and other individuals deemed appropriate by the committee.<br />
C. Interview session(s) with the residents and faculty of the program being reviewed will be<br />
conducted and documented on behalf of the committee.<br />
D. Questionnaires will be developed and distributed separately to the reviewed<br />
program's faculty and residents.<br />
E. The Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee will discuss and analyze the results of the faculty and<br />
resident interviews and received questionnaires.<br />
F. Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Report<br />
1. The written reports of the internal review committee for each program will<br />
contain, at a minimum:<br />
a. The name of the program reviewed, the date of the assigned midpoint, the<br />
status of <strong>GMEC</strong> oversight of the internal review at the midpoint, and the<br />
date the written report is approved by the <strong>GMEC</strong>;<br />
b. The names and titles of the internal review committee members;<br />
c. A brief description of how the internal review process was conducted,<br />
including the list of the groups/individuals interviewed and the documents<br />
reviewed;<br />
d. Sufficient documentation to demonstrate that a comprehensive review<br />
followed the <strong>GMEC</strong>'s internal review protocol; and<br />
54
<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />
Page 4<br />
POLICY TITLE:<br />
Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />
e. A list of the citations and areas of non‐compliance or any concerns or<br />
comments from the previous ACGME accreditation letter of notification<br />
with a summary of how the program and/or institution subsequently<br />
addressed each item.<br />
2. The DIO and the <strong>GMEC</strong> will monitor the response by the program to actions<br />
recommended by the <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />
3. The <strong>GMEC</strong> may request follow‐up progress reports at specified intervals.<br />
September 24, 2009<br />
Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />
Signature on File<br />
Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />
Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />
Chief Academic Officer<br />
Signature on File<br />
Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />
<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />
Graduate Medical Education<br />
September 22, 2011<br />
Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />
55