16.11.2013 Views

GMEC Manual Rev 052212 - Greenville Hospital System

GMEC Manual Rev 052212 - Greenville Hospital System

GMEC Manual Rev 052212 - Greenville Hospital System

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE (<strong>GMEC</strong>)<br />

Policy <strong>Manual</strong><br />

<strong>Rev</strong>iewed and Amended: September 2009<br />

Edited: November 2010<br />

<strong>Rev</strong>iewed and Amended: September 2011


TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

I. INSTITUTIONAL ORGANIZATION AND RESPONSIBILITIES ................................................................ 3<br />

GME Program Overview ................................................................................................................... 4<br />

GHS Commitment Statement ........................................................................................................... 5<br />

GHS Policy Compliance .................................................................................................................... 6<br />

II. INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES FOR RESIDENTS ......................................................................... 7<br />

Resident Recruitment and Appointment ......................................................................................... 8<br />

Resident Contracts ........................................................................................................................... 9<br />

Resident Change of Residency Program ........................................................................................ 10<br />

Resident Dismissal and Grievance (w/ process) ............................................................................ 11<br />

Resident Participation in <strong>Hospital</strong>/OMS Committees and Initiatives ............................................ 13<br />

Moonlighting .................................................................................................................................. 15<br />

Duty Hours ..................................................................................................................................... 16<br />

Resident Duty Hour Compliance Oversight.................................................................................... 17<br />

House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> ........................................................................................................................ 19<br />

Transitions of Care ........................................................................................................................ 24<br />

Sleep Deprivation and Fatigue ....................................................................................................... 25<br />

International Electives ................................................................................................................... 26<br />

III. GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE (<strong>GMEC</strong>) ............................................................... 27<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Role w/ Organization Chart ................................................................................................. 28<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Responsibilities .................................................................................................................... 32<br />

DIO Delegation ............................................................................................................................... 34<br />

Vendor Interactions ....................................................................................................................... 35<br />

GME Vendor Interactions ............................................................................................................... 36<br />

Residency Closure/Reduction in Size ............................................................................................. 40<br />

Disaster and GME ........................................................................................................................... 41<br />

Program Annual Reports w/ Format .............................................................................................. 42<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Rev</strong>iew ....................................................................................................................... 50<br />

IV. INTERNAL REVIEW .......................................................................................................................... 51<br />

Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews ............................................................................................................................. 52<br />

2


I. INSTITUTIONAL ORGANIZATION AND RESPONSIBILITIES<br />

3


GME PROGRAM OVERVIEW<br />

The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> (GHS) is a voluntary, community, nonprofit organization owned and operated<br />

by an independent, self‐perpetuating Board of Trustees. Upon this Board rests the full responsibility for the<br />

operation of the <strong>Hospital</strong>, the quality of care rendered, and the relationship with the entire community.<br />

The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> is an Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME)<br />

accredited Graduate Medical Education (GME) teaching institution. The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> (GHS)<br />

Medical Staff accepts responsibility for assuring supervision of all resident educational activities including<br />

patient care. Through its by‐laws the GHS Medical Staff has delegated this responsibility to Academic Services.<br />

Academic Services fulfills this responsibility through its full time and volunteer faculty teaching staff.<br />

Faculty members have the dual obligations of training residents progressively to independence and assuring<br />

provision of safe patient care. In order to fulfill these obligations all patients admitted to GHS have an<br />

attending physician who is a member of the Medical Staff. Residents participate in the care of these patients<br />

with the agreement and at the invitation of the attending physician. It is understood that residents have no<br />

independent Medical Staff privileges within the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong>. Therefore, a resident may perform<br />

only those cares and procedures for which the patient’s attending physician has privileges.<br />

Fundamental to the GME process is the tenant that residents must be supervised in such a manner that allows<br />

them to assume progressively increasing responsibility and autonomy commensurate with their individual<br />

levels of education, ability, and expertise. While the resident credentialing process is implicit within the<br />

program description of resident responsibilities at each year level of training, it is a fact that resident peers<br />

progress at different rates due to individual abilities and variable experiences determined by timing of<br />

educational rotations. Consequently, only the attending physician is qualified to determine the capabilities of<br />

any individual resident at any given time. This requires that the teaching staff on‐call arrangements be<br />

structured to ensure that appropriate supervision is readily available at all times to residents on duty.<br />

Accordingly, uncertainty regarding the qualifications of a resident to provide specific care for a patient should<br />

be addressed to the attending physician or his/her medical staff designee.<br />

Academic Program descriptions are provided to the residents and are intended to provide an overview of all<br />

residents’ experiences by year and rotation. All residency programs maintain a departmental manual specific<br />

to their requirements. This <strong>GMEC</strong> policy manual defines policies and procedures relative to resident education<br />

oversight in general.<br />

4


Institutional Requirements: I.B.2<br />

Common Program Requirements: I.A<br />

Graduate Medical Education Institutional Commitment<br />

<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> recognizes the value of and enthusiastically supports the provisions of medical<br />

education and, consequently, has included this commitment in the Bylaws of the GHS Board of Trustees under<br />

Article II, Section 2.6‐1(j) “To provide teaching and instruction programs and schools for nurses, hospital<br />

technicians, hospital employees, medical students, and physicians during internship and residency.” In accord,<br />

<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> is committed to providing the necessary educational, financial, and human<br />

resources support to graduate medical education. Further, <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> is committed to and<br />

responsible for promoting patient safety and resident well‐being and to providing a supportive educational<br />

environment.<br />

Signature on File<br />

Jerry R. Youkey, M.D.<br />

Vice President, Medical and Academic Affairs<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Designated Institutional Official<br />

Signature on File<br />

Michael C. Riordan<br />

President and Chief Executive Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Jerry Dempsey<br />

Chairman, GHS Board of Trustees<br />

October 21, 2011<br />

5


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # I‐01‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.D.4.l | II.D.4.m | II.D.4.n<br />

Common Program Requirements: N/A<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

GHS Policy Compliance<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that all Graduate Medical Education<br />

programs will adhere to applicable GHS policies; including sexual and other forms of harassment, disabilities<br />

accommodation, and physician impairment including that due to substance abuse. Applicable GHS policies will<br />

be highlighted during new resident orientation.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

6


II. INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES FOR RESIDENTS<br />

7


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐01‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.A<br />

Common Program Requirements: III<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Resident Recruitment and Appointment<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the policy/criteria for acceptance of<br />

Resident staff at the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> will be directed as:<br />

- Criteria for applicant consideration – make proper application through ERAS or universal application<br />

provided by NRMP, meet criteria as set forth by Essentials of Accredited Residencies and specialty<br />

boards, complies with application procedures, participates in NRMP, and eligible for licensure in South<br />

Carolina. It is the policy of Academic Services to employ physician trainees (residents and fellows)<br />

requiring immigration authorization only under the J‐1 Exchange Visitor Program sponsored by the<br />

Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates (ECFMG) and permanent visa status. No<br />

exceptions will be made to this provision except as defined by the Vice President, Medical Services and<br />

Dean, Academic Services.<br />

- Criteria for selection – GHS participates in the NRMP program, Selection Committee reviews all<br />

applications, consideration is given to the applicant’s medical school Dean’s Letter, letters of<br />

recommendation, grades and class rank, USMLE or ECFMG scores, and recommendations of GHS<br />

physicians who personally interviewed the applicants. Program Selection Committee reviews the<br />

applications, develops a rank list in order of preference, and submits a match list to NRMP in<br />

accordance with the rules and regulations of that organization. Positions available after the Match are<br />

filled using the same criteria, with appointment being made directly by the program director.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

8


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐02‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.D<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Resident Contracts<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that residents will be provided a written<br />

agreement of appointment/contract outlining the terms and conditions of their appointment. The<br />

agreement/contract will contain and/or reference those institutional policies as required in the ACGME<br />

Institutional Requirements. No restrictive covenants will be included in any resident or fellow contract.<br />

Academic promotions and renewal of a resident’s contract will be based upon the performance evaluation<br />

process of the primary residency program of the resident. Non‐renewal of a contract is an act of termination<br />

and will be exercised only for unsatisfactory performance.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

9


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐03‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: III.B.7<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Resident Change of Residency Program<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that a resident desiring to change Residency<br />

Program after commencing his/her residency training must obtain a Change of Residency Form from the office<br />

of the Designated Institutional Official and follow the applicable rules as detailed in the GHS House Staff<br />

<strong>Manual</strong>.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

10


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐04‐11<br />

Page 1<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.D.4(e)<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Resident Dismissal and Grievance (w/process)<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that all resident staff who enter residency<br />

training programs at GHS should graduate. Non‐renewal of contracts or termination of employment will be<br />

exercised only for cause. A house staff member may be suspended from duty or terminated from the program<br />

for cause by the Academic Services Department Chair responsible for the performance of the house officer, or<br />

by the DIO, Vice President, Medical Services and Dean, Academic Services, or Chief Executive Officer of the<br />

<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong>. Resident Staff are subject to GHS employment policy and procedure standards.<br />

Due Process<br />

Non‐renewal of a contract is an act of termination and will be exercised only for unsatisfactory performance.<br />

Termination of a resident for unsatisfactory performance or for cause will originate with the program involved.<br />

Each program will have a policy stating acceptable behavior and describe the procedure by which residents are<br />

evaluated on performance and what corrective actions will be taken when appropriate. When the level of<br />

performance is determined to warrant termination, a written request will be forwarded to the DIO. The Vice<br />

President of Medical and Academic Services will then present the findings and recommendations to the<br />

members of the Academic Services Graduate Medical Education Committee (<strong>GMEC</strong>) at a called meeting. If a<br />

majority of the <strong>GMEC</strong> agrees with the recommendation, the Assistant Dean of Graduate Medical Education will<br />

notify in writing the resident of his/her termination.<br />

Appeal Process<br />

Appeal of this decision by the resident will be in writing to the DIO within ten (10) days of receiving the written<br />

notice of termination. Such notice will be delivered by registered mail. Upon receipt of an appeal, the DIO will<br />

appoint a committee consisting of a Professor or Associate Professor from the residency program involved and<br />

a Professor or Associate Professor from two other residency programs. Within five (5) days of appointment of<br />

the committee, the committee will meet to review all recorded performances of the resident involved,<br />

including appropriate personal interviews of the faculty and residents who have been responsible for the<br />

written evaluations and comments. Upon written request to the DIO, the resident may request that he/she<br />

and any advocates of his/her position have the opportunity to be heard by the Committee. The Committee will<br />

determine the extent of involvement in the committee process of any advocate. The minutes of committee<br />

meetings will be recorded by a court reporter and reflect documentation of the resident’s notification and<br />

response.<br />

The Committee will reach a decision within ten (10) days of appointment of the committee. The Committee’s<br />

majority recommendation will be binding and without recourse.<br />

11


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐04‐11<br />

Page 2<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Resident Dismissal and Grievance (w/process)<br />

If a majority of the committee does agree to termination of the resident, the Assistant Dean of Graduate<br />

Medical Education will notify the resident of his/her termination. If the majority of the committee does not<br />

agree to termination of the resident, any recommended course of action or recommended reprimand(s) of the<br />

resident by the committee will be communicated in writing to the department chairman and program director<br />

for follow‐through.<br />

Prior to resident notification, the President & CEO and Chairman of the Board of Trustees will be notified in<br />

writing of the committee’s final action. The resident will be notified of the committee’s decision in writing<br />

within five (5) days following the conclusion of the committee meeting.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

12


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐05‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.E.2.a<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Resident Participation in <strong>Hospital</strong>/OMS Committees and Initiatives<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that Residents will be encouraged to be<br />

membership active on applicable committees that will include:<br />

Pediatrics Code Stat<br />

Adult Code Stat<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> (President, Vice President & Secretary – elected Officers)<br />

Pharmacy & Therapeutics<br />

Information Technology<br />

Metabolic Adult Support Task Force<br />

House Staff Liaison – (Chief Residents and elected Officers)<br />

Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew – (per policy)<br />

Jackson Award – (per Award description)<br />

Research Award – (per Award description)<br />

Simulation Advisory Committee – (per Advisory Committee By‐laws)<br />

Except for ex officio membership and DIO appointment, resident selection/appointment to specific<br />

committees will be processed via the GHS House Staff Liaison Committee whose membership consists of each<br />

program’s Chief Resident, universal elected officers (President, Vice President, and Secretary) and a<br />

representative from the 3 rd and 4 th year USC Medical Students.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

13


SYSTEM COMMITTEES: RESIDENT REPRESENTATION<br />

Academic Year 2012<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

Committee (<strong>GMEC</strong>)<br />

Bethany Bessom, MD (House Staff Pres–(Pediatrics)<br />

Lionel van der Westhuizen, MD (House Staff VP–(Surgery)<br />

Deanna Ball, MD (House Staff Secretary‐(Pediatrics)<br />

Pediatrics Code Stat<br />

Amanda O’Kelly, MD (Pediatrics)<br />

Adult Code Stat<br />

Brett Murphy, MD (Orthopaedic Surgery)<br />

Chris Vaughan, MD (Med‐Peds)<br />

Pharmacy & Therapeutics<br />

Cary A. Sanders, MD (Med/Peds)<br />

Information Technology<br />

Ben Barden, MD (Orthopaedic Surgery)<br />

J. D. Adams, MD (Orthopaedic Surgery)<br />

Metabolic Adult Support Task Force<br />

Brandon Smith, MD (Surgery)<br />

House Staff Liaison Committee<br />

Chief Residents/Elected Officers/Committee Representatives/<br />

3rd and 4th Year Medical Student Representatives<br />

Simulation Center<br />

Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

As selected per policy<br />

Jackson Award<br />

As selected per policy<br />

GHS/UMC Outstanding Faculty and House Staff Research Award ‐ As selected per policy<br />

14


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐06‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.D.4.j<br />

Common Program Requirements: V1.G.2.a‐c<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Moonlighting<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that GHS residents may moonlight so long<br />

as a moonlighting obligation does not interfere with that resident’s educational program. In addition, if a<br />

proposed moonlighting activity is to take place in a GHS facility or in connection with a GHS program, the<br />

resident must demonstrate competence to furnish the moonlighting services and be granted appropriate GHS<br />

Medical Staff clinical privileges in accordance with this policy. Resident staff are not required to moonlight.<br />

Moonlighting activities will be closely monitored by the Department Chairs and Residency Program Directors<br />

for signs of fatigue and will guarantee sufficient time for rest and relaxation in order to promote the residents’<br />

educational experience and safe patient care. Further, resident moonlighting activities will count as part of the<br />

80‐hour work week.<br />

Specific qualifications and procedural requirements will be detailed in the GHS House Staff <strong>Manual</strong>.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

15


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐07‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: III.B.3<br />

Common Program Requirements: V1.A.5.d<br />

V1.G.1<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Duty Hours<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that, in compliance with ACGME<br />

Institutional requirements and applicable ACGME RRC requirements, resident working hours shall not exceed<br />

an average of 80 hours per workweek averaged over a 4 week period. House staff are considered to be on duty<br />

at all times when in the hospital and are subject to call at all hours.<br />

Each residency program is responsible for the ongoing monitoring of resident duty hours and must have a<br />

documented monitoring tool. Each program will specifically address duty hours compliance and<br />

documentation at the Program’s Annual Report to <strong>GMEC</strong> and the <strong>GMEC</strong> Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew process.<br />

The GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee does not recognize exceptions to the ACGME Resident Duty<br />

Hours guidelines.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

16


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐08‐11<br />

Page 1<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.D.4.i<br />

Common Program Requirements: V1.A.5.d<br />

POLICY TITLE: Resident Duty Hour Compliance Oversight<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that each program will have written policies<br />

and procedures consistent with the Institutional and Program Requirements for resident duty hours. These<br />

policies will be distributed to the residents and the faculty.<br />

Procedures:<br />

1) Monitoring of duty hours is required with frequency sufficient to ensure an appropriate<br />

balance between education and service and to meet ACGME Common Program<br />

Requirements. Those program requirements define duty hours as all clinical and<br />

academic activities and do not include reading and preparation time spent away from the duty<br />

site. The requirements state that duty hours be limited to 80 hours per week, and that continuous<br />

on site duty, including in‐house call, must not exceed 24 consecutive hours. Residents may remain<br />

on duty for up to six additional hours to participate in didactic activities, transfer care of patients,<br />

conduct outpatient clinics, and maintain continuity of medical and surgical care. No new patients<br />

may be accepted after 24 hours of continuous duty. Residents must be provided with one day in<br />

seven free from all educational and clinical responsibilities, averaged over a four‐week period,<br />

inclusive of call. Adequate time for rest and personal activities must be provided with adherence of<br />

10 hours off between duty shifts.<br />

Residents will use the New Innovations Web‐based <strong>System</strong> to document duty hours. If<br />

documented hours exceed the 80 hour compliance and violate the ACGME requirement, the<br />

resident must use the New Innovations duty hours comments section to document the specifics<br />

regarding the non‐compliance. Program Directors will use the same New Innovations reporting<br />

system for weekly duty hours compliance monitoring for their respective programs. <strong>GMEC</strong> will use<br />

New Innovations reporting to determine compliance. Programs will be monitored for duty hours<br />

compliance during the academic year and during annual reporting. Programs out of compliance<br />

will be monitored with a frequency to be determined by <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />

2) Directors of programs that are out of compliance with the Resident Duty Hours Policy will<br />

determine a plan and timeline to be in compliance and submit that plan and time line to the <strong>GMEC</strong><br />

for review and approval.<br />

3) Each resident will be responsible for providing accurate and timely data using New Innovations<br />

regarding their individual compliance with the <strong>GMEC</strong> Resident Duty Hour Policy and the ACGME<br />

Duty Hours requirements. Failure to comply may result in penalty action(s) to include the GHS<br />

Human Resources discipline cycle of verbal and written warnings, suspension, and dismissal.<br />

Non‐compliance Discipline:<br />

Resident duty hours documentation in a timely manner is a requirement. Residents document duty hours<br />

using the GHS New Innovations Web‐based <strong>System</strong>. Residents are required to complete duty hours<br />

17


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐08‐11<br />

Page 2<br />

POLICY TITLE: Resident Duty Hour Compliance Oversight<br />

documentation daily. When in non‐compliance of duty hours requirements, residents must complete<br />

documentation regarding the specifics of the situation within New Innovations comments section. Any<br />

resident unable to complete his/her duty hours documentation because of the following reasons, 1) vacation,<br />

2) sick, 3) or educational leave, must have approval from their Program Director.<br />

Failure to complete duty hours documentation is a demonstrated behavior of lack of the ACGME<br />

Professionalism general competency. Non‐compliance and failure to meet the duty hours documentation as<br />

required may result in the following disciplinary actions:<br />

First Offense:<br />

Second Offense:<br />

Third Offense:<br />

Fourth Offense:<br />

Fifth Offense:<br />

Process & Procedure Coaching<br />

Verbal Warning<br />

Written Warning<br />

Suspension<br />

Termination from Residency Program<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

18


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐09‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: III.B<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

House Staff <strong>Manual</strong><br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the <strong>GMEC</strong> will review and affirm the<br />

House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> revisions annually. The House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> reflects <strong>GMEC</strong> policy and is incorporated into<br />

the <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Manual</strong> by this reference and current Table of Contents attachment.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

19


2011 <strong>Manual</strong> of Policies and Procedures<br />

Medical Education Resident Staff<br />

TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

Foreword and Purpose ................................................................................................................................... I<br />

Graduate Medical Education Institutional Commitment .............................................................................. II<br />

Resident Physicians/House Staff Teaching‐Learning Commitment ............................................................. III<br />

Section I: Programs Overview<br />

GME Program Overview ................................................................................................................................ 1<br />

Program Policy <strong>Manual</strong>s ................................................................................................................................ 2<br />

GHS Mission, Vision, & Values ..................................................................................................................... 3<br />

Facilities of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> ........................................................................................................... 4<br />

<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Organizational Structure............................................................................................ 5<br />

Graduate Medical Education Operational Structure ............................................................................................. 6<br />

Organizational Chart ‐ Medical Staff Flow Chart ................................................................................................... 7<br />

Medical Staff ........................................................................................................................................................... 8<br />

Medical Staff Supervision of Resident/Fellow Patient Care Activities .................................................................. 8<br />

Patient Care Chain of Command ............................................................................................................................ 9<br />

Physicians Notification Sequence – Appendix A .................................................................................................. 11<br />

Teaching Staff ........................................................................................................................................................ 11<br />

House Staff Liaison Committee ............................................................................................................................. 12<br />

<strong>System</strong> Committees: Resident Representation .......................................................................................... 12<br />

Section II: Education & Competency Requirements<br />

Licensure ................................................................................................................................................................ 13<br />

Advanced Cardiac Life Support ............................................................................................................................. 13<br />

Research Requirements ........................................................................................................................................ 15<br />

CITI Training ........................................................................................................................................................... 17<br />

Mandatory Trainings ............................................................................................................................................. 18<br />

Electronic Clinical Works (eCW) Training ............................................................................................................. 18<br />

Conferences ........................................................................................................................................................... 19<br />

Educational Rotations ............................................................................................................................................ 19<br />

International Electives ........................................................................................................................................... 19<br />

Patient Simulation Center ..................................................................................................................................... 20<br />

Performance Evaluations ...................................................................................................................................... 20<br />

Learning Portfolio .................................................................................................................................................. 20<br />

Certificates ............................................................................................................................................................. 21<br />

Section III: <strong>System</strong>s‐based Practice / Communication / Medical Information / Other<br />

Electronic Clinical Works (eCW) Training ............................................................................................................. 18<br />

<strong>System</strong> Communication Models ........................................................................................................................... 22<br />

Hand‐off Communication and Responsibilities .................................................................................................... 23<br />

Communication and Hand‐offs Policy .................................................................................................................. 23<br />

Pager Assignments ................................................................................................................................................ 24<br />

Communication Device ......................................................................................................................................... 24<br />

Social Media and Social Networking .................................................................................................................... 26<br />

20


Table of Contents ‐ Page 2<br />

Telephone Calls ...................................................................................................................................................... 28<br />

Emergency Code Procedures for House Staff ...................................................................................................... 28<br />

Emergency Paging Codes for <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> ................................................................................... 30<br />

Official Abbreviations “Do Not Use” List .............................................................................................................. 31<br />

Call Schedule .......................................................................................................................................................... 31<br />

Language Services .................................................................................................................................................. 31<br />

eNet – Employee Information/Payroll Self‐Service Access ................................................................................. 32<br />

Keys ........................................................................................................................................................................ 32<br />

Legibility of Handwriting ...................................................................................................................................... 32<br />

Loan Deferments ................................................................................................................................................... 33<br />

Medical Information Procedures for Residents/Fellows ..................................................................................... 33<br />

Procedure for Completion of Delinquent Medical Records ................................................................................ 34<br />

Corrections in Medical Records .................................................................................................................. 36<br />

Transcription Services ................................................................................................................................. 37<br />

Section IV: Policies & Procedures<br />

Consultation/Referral Policy ................................................................................................................................. 38<br />

Selection Criteria .................................................................................................................................................... 38<br />

Change of Residency/Fellowship Program Procedure ........................................................................................ 39<br />

Conflict of Interest ................................................................................................................................................. 39<br />

Controlled Substance Registration ....................................................................................................................... 40<br />

Promotion .............................................................................................................................................................. 40<br />

Discipline and Termination ................................................................................................................................... 40<br />

Resignation and Due Process ................................................................................................................................ 40<br />

Appeal Process ....................................................................................................................................................... 41<br />

Educational Leave and Travel Policy ..................................................................................................................... 41<br />

Lodging ............................................................................................................................................................... 42<br />

Meals ................................................................................................................................................................. 42<br />

Air Travel ............................................................................................................................................................ 42<br />

Automobile Travel ............................................................................................................................................. 42<br />

Registration Fees ............................................................................................................................................... 43<br />

Rental Cars ......................................................................................................................................................... 43<br />

Other Miscellaneous Expenses ......................................................................................................................... 43<br />

Travel Reimbursement ..................................................................................................................................... 44<br />

Travel to Present Paper .................................................................................................................................... 44<br />

Educational Allowance Fund ................................................................................................................................. 44<br />

Moving Allowance ................................................................................................................................................. 45<br />

Employee Health Requirements ........................................................................................................................... 45<br />

Fitness for Duty and Drug Free Work Environment &Testing ............................................................................. 46<br />

Harassment ................................................................................................................................................. 46<br />

Hepatitis B Vaccine Policy ..................................................................................................................................... 46<br />

Infection Prevention and Control ........................................................................................................................ 47<br />

DHEC Reportable Conditions ................................................................................................................................ 48<br />

Moonlighting Policy and Procedures for Residents/Fellows ............................................................................... 50<br />

Patients Rights and Responsibilities ..................................................................................................................... 54<br />

Patient Safety ......................................................................................................................................................... 56<br />

Resident Responsibilities During Local Extreme Emergent Situations and Disasters ................................. 56<br />

House Medical Staff Disaster Response ...................................................................................................... 58<br />

21


Table of Contents ‐ Page 3<br />

Duty Hours ............................................................................................................................................................. 59<br />

Sleep Deprivation and Fatigue .............................................................................................................................. 59<br />

Uniforms ................................................................................................................................................................. 60<br />

Vendor Policy ......................................................................................................................................................... 60<br />

Section V: Resources & Benefits<br />

Credit Union ........................................................................................................................................................... 61<br />

Direct Deposit of Paycheck ................................................................................................................................... 61<br />

Employee Accident Report .................................................................................................................................... 61<br />

Employee Insurance Highlights<br />

Insurance Highlights .......................................................................................................................................... 62<br />

Health Insurance Plan ....................................................................................................................................... 62<br />

Silver and Gold Plans Comparison .................................................................................................................... 62<br />

Prescription Drug Benefit ....................................................................................................................... 63<br />

Cost of Health Care Coverage ........................................................................................................................... 63<br />

Dental Insurance ............................................................................................................................................... 64<br />

Vision Plan ......................................................................................................................................................... 65<br />

Flexible Spending Accounts ............................................................................................................................. 65<br />

Health Services Benefit ..................................................................................................................................... 65<br />

Basic Group Term Life Insurance/AD&D Insurance ........................................................................................ 65<br />

Supplemental Group Universal Life Insurance ................................................................................................ 66<br />

Voluntary AD&D Insurance ............................................................................................................................... 66<br />

Business Travel Accidental Insurance .............................................................................................................. 66<br />

World‐wide Travel Assistance .......................................................................................................................... 67<br />

Pre‐paid Legal Plan and Identity Theft Shield Benefit ..................................................................................... 67<br />

Long Term Disability Insurance ........................................................................................................................ 67<br />

Short Term Disability Insurance ....................................................................................................................... 67<br />

Long Term Care (LTC) Insurance ....................................................................................................................... 67<br />

Allstate Supplemental Health Options Plan (SHOP) ........................................................................................ 68<br />

Retirement Savings Plan ................................................................................................................................... 68<br />

Section 529 Plan “Future Scholar Program” .................................................................................................... 68<br />

Adoption Benefit Assistance ............................................................................................................................. 68<br />

Paid Time Off (PTO) ........................................................................................................................................... 68<br />

Other Benefits ................................................................................................................................................... 68<br />

Professional Liability ......................................................................................................................................... 69<br />

Leave & PTO Policies<br />

Compassionate Leave ....................................................................................................................................... 69<br />

Court Appearances ............................................................................................................................................ 70<br />

Family and Medical Leave Act Policy ............................................................................................................... 70<br />

Jury Duty ............................................................................................................................................................ 78<br />

Maternity Leave ................................................................................................................................................ 78<br />

Military Leave .................................................................................................................................................... 78<br />

PTO‐Paid Time Off (PTO) ................................................................................................................................... 79<br />

Vacation ............................................................................................................................................................. 79<br />

Holiday PTO Policy for Resident Staff/Fellows ................................................................................................ 79<br />

Educational Leave ............................................................................................................................................. 79<br />

Procedure for Requesting PTO ......................................................................................................................... 79<br />

Severance Pay ................................................................................................................................................... 80<br />

22


Table of Contents ‐ Page 4<br />

Illness ................................................................................................................................................................ 81<br />

Meals ...................................................................................................................................................................... 81<br />

Personal Problems and Concerns/Reporting Anonymity/Employee Assistance Program ................................ 81<br />

Risk Management .................................................................................................................................................. 82<br />

Salary ...................................................................................................................................................................... 82<br />

Section VI: Forms<br />

Request for Change of Residency/Fellowship ...................................................................................................... 83<br />

Education or Vacation Leave Request .................................................................................................................. 84<br />

Communication Device ........................................................................................................................................ 85<br />

GME Communication Device(s) Authorization – IPAD ........................................................................................ 86<br />

GME Communication Device(s) Authorization – Telephone .............................................................................. 87<br />

Application for Moonlighting Privileges ............................................................................................................... 88<br />

International Electives Rotation Request Form ................................................................................................... 93<br />

GHS Resident Waiver Statement .......................................................................................................................... 95<br />

International Program Letter of Agreement Template ....................................................................................... 96<br />

23


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐10‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />

Common Program Requirements: V1.B.1‐4<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Transitions of Care<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the faculty and resident physicians will<br />

adhere to the standardized Communication and Hand‐offs policy as reflected in the GHS Medical Staff Policies<br />

and detailed in the <strong>Manual</strong> of Policies and Procedures for Medical Education Resident Staff (House Staff<br />

<strong>Manual</strong>).<br />

Specialty‐specific processes that are compliant with the Medical Staff Communication and Hands‐off policy are<br />

within each of the Residency Program's written policies and procedures.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

24


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐11‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />

Common Program Requirements: VI.C.1‐3<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Sleep Deprivation and Fatigue<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that faculty and residents and fellows will be<br />

educated to recognize the signs of fatigue and sleep deprivation and must adopt and apply policies to prevent<br />

and counteract its potential negative effects on patient care and learning.<br />

Each GME Program will assure the GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> through audit and annual reporting that such curriculum and<br />

supervision are formalized within the respective GME program. Unique policies and/or procedures per<br />

program will be in compliance with this policy and the policy and guidance from respective RRC’s and the<br />

ACGME.<br />

Education may be unique to the individual program or conducted GME‐wide as the Program Directors<br />

Committee so directs.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

25


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐11‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements:<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE: International Electives<br />

It is the policy of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Graduate Medical Education Committee that residency<br />

programs may provide elective educational opportunities at international sites. Each rotation must be<br />

acceptable within the individual residency program curriculum and the related ACGME/RRC requirements.<br />

Approved residents:<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

Must meet minimum competency‐based academic standards as determined by the related residency<br />

program.<br />

May be required to present her/his experience to the Department.<br />

Are responsible for obtaining all appropriate vaccinations as designated by an international health<br />

clinic and providing certification of emergency of‐of‐country medical care coverage.<br />

Are responsible for formal medical clearance by their personal physician for travel to the specific area.<br />

May use their individual education allowance money at the discretion of the Program Director. Any<br />

remaining finances beyond the education allowance resource will be the responsibility of the resident<br />

physicians.<br />

A formal application located in the House Staff <strong>Manual</strong> (supplied through the residency program office) will be<br />

completed and will preferably be submitted three (3) months prior to the anticipated beginning of the<br />

international elective but must be submitted at least one (1) month prior to the rotation. The application must<br />

receive signatory approval by the Program Director and the Designated Institutional Official. The resident<br />

physician will not be insured through the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> malpractice coverage and must obtain<br />

separate malpractice coverage, if available.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

26


III. GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE (<strong>GMEC</strong>)<br />

27


<strong>GMEC</strong> ROLE w/ Organization Chart<br />

The <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Graduate Medical Education Committee has oversight authority and<br />

responsibility for all aspects of residency education. Voting membership includes the DIO, Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education (Chair), Program Directors (Associate Program Directors are non‐voting members<br />

except by Program Director proxy), the House Staff Officers elected by the House Staff – (President, Vice<br />

President, Secretary), the Academic Services Administrator, and others as deemed by DIO appointment.<br />

Departmental Faculty Directors for Education and the Vice President for Academic Development also serve as<br />

non‐voting members. Other non‐voting faculty or members may be appointed by the DIO.<br />

The GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> will establish and implement policies and procedures regarding the quality of education and<br />

the work environment for the residents and fellows in all programs.<br />

The GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> will conduct its oversight responsibilities in compliance with ACGME institutional requirements,<br />

ACGME common program requirements and applicable RRC guidelines.<br />

28


GREENVILLE HOSPITAL SYSTEM<br />

GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION PROGRAMMATIC STRUCTURE<br />

Organized<br />

Medical<br />

Staff<br />

GHS<br />

Board of Trustees<br />

GHS<br />

President & CEO<br />

Assistant Dean<br />

Graduate Medical<br />

Education<br />

GHS<br />

VP, Medical & Academic Services<br />

(DIO)<br />

Program Directors<br />

Committee<br />

Graduate Medical<br />

Education Committee<br />

Academic Services<br />

Administration<br />

Family<br />

Medicine<br />

Internal<br />

Medicine<br />

Medicine‐<br />

Pediatrics<br />

General<br />

Surgery<br />

Obstetrics &<br />

Gynecology<br />

Orthopaedic<br />

Surgery<br />

Pediatrics<br />

Sports<br />

Medicine<br />

Vascular<br />

Medicine<br />

Vascular<br />

Surgery<br />

Minimal<br />

Access<br />

Surgery<br />

Total Joint<br />

Arthroplasty<br />

Dev/Behav<br />

Pediatrics<br />

* A dotted line denotes a non‐ACGME accredited program<br />

<strong>Rev</strong>ised: November 2011<br />

29


GREENVILLE HOSPITAL SYSTEM<br />

PHYSICIAN AFFAIRS OPERATIONAL STRUCTURE<br />

GHS<br />

President & CEO<br />

* Associate VP &<br />

Chief Medical Officer<br />

(CMO)<br />

GHS<br />

VP, Medical & Academic Services<br />

* Associate VP &<br />

Designated Institutional<br />

Official (DIO)<br />

GHS UMG Chief<br />

Administrative<br />

Officer & Executive<br />

Director, Ambulatory<br />

Services<br />

UMG<br />

Medical<br />

Director<br />

Medical<br />

Staff<br />

Office<br />

Department of Clinical<br />

Integration<br />

Clinical Integration Responsibilities<br />

Physician Compensation &<br />

Service Expansion Responsibilities<br />

UMG Medical<br />

Services Offices<br />

Center for<br />

Teaching & Learning (CTL)<br />

Academic Integration Responsibilities<br />

GHS Chairs<br />

* Associate VP, Executive VP, or just VP <strong>Rev</strong>ised: October 2011<br />

30


GREENVILLE HOSPITAL SYSTEM<br />

GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION OPERATIONAL STRUCTURE<br />

GHS<br />

President & CEO<br />

GHS Executive VP, Medical & Academic Services<br />

and Dean, USC School of Medicine‐<strong>Greenville</strong><br />

VP & DIO for Academics<br />

and Executive Medical Director UMG<br />

GHS Department<br />

Chairs Academic<br />

Responsibilities<br />

Assistant Dean<br />

Graduate Medical<br />

Education<br />

Associate Dean<br />

USCSOM‐Columbia<br />

GHS VP, Academic<br />

Development<br />

Center for<br />

Teaching &<br />

Learning (CTL)<br />

Offices<br />

UMG Department<br />

Operations<br />

Directors<br />

1<br />

GME Residency Program<br />

Coordinators<br />

GME Residency<br />

Program<br />

Directors<br />

2<br />

3<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong><br />

Administrator<br />

Academic Services<br />

Curriculum<br />

Development<br />

GME &<br />

Curriculum<br />

Development<br />

Officer<br />

GME<br />

Operations<br />

MedEx<br />

Academy<br />

Note 1: This reporting relationship is for daily activities<br />

of the residency program within the UMG Clinical Department.<br />

Note 2: Required ACGME reporting relationship for support of<br />

academic components of the individual program.<br />

Note 3: This relationship is for the overriding academic corporate<br />

support activities and ACGME policy and procedure oversight<br />

requirements.<br />

* Associate VP, Executive VP, or just VP <strong>Rev</strong>ised: May 2012<br />

31


<strong>GMEC</strong> RESPONSIBILITIES<br />

In accordance with the ACGME Institutional Requirements, the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> Graduate Medical<br />

Education Committee will:<br />

1. Annually review and recommend resident stipends, benefits, and funding for resident positions to<br />

assure an equitable and fair allocation process.<br />

2. Ensure effective communications between <strong>GMEC</strong> and appropriate system‐wide committees and the<br />

effective communication between program directors and clinical teaching sites.<br />

3. Ensure compliance regarding resident duty hours requirements (see <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # II‐07‐11).<br />

4. Monitor programs’ supervision of residents and assure that supervision is consistent with ACGME<br />

requirements.<br />

5. Communicate with the leadership of the Organized Medical Staff regarding the safety and quality of<br />

patient care.<br />

6. Provide oversight to assure a curriculum and an evaluation system that ensures that residents<br />

demonstrate achievement of the ACGME general competencies.<br />

7. Ensure appropriate oversight for the selection, evaluation, promotion, transfer, discipline, and/or<br />

dismissal of residents in compliance with the Institutional and Common Program Requirements (see<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #’s II‐01‐11, II‐02‐11, II‐03‐11).<br />

8. <strong>Rev</strong>iew all ACGME program accreditation letters of notification and monitoring of action plans for<br />

correction of citations and areas of non‐compliance.<br />

9. <strong>Rev</strong>iew the GHS ACGME Institutional Accreditation letter of notification from the IRC and monitoring<br />

of action plans for correction of citations and areas of noncompliance.<br />

10. Prior to submissions to the ACGME by program directors, provide oversight of program changes<br />

through review and approval of:<br />

a. All applications for ACGME accreditation of new programs;<br />

b. Changes in resident complement;<br />

c. Major changes in program structure or length of training;<br />

d. Additions and deletions of participating institutions;<br />

e. Appointments of new program directors;<br />

f. Progress reports requested by any <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee;<br />

g. Responses to all proposed adverse actions;<br />

32


<strong>GMEC</strong> Responsibilities<br />

Page 2<br />

h. Requests for exceptions to resident duty hours requirements;<br />

i. Voluntary withdrawals of programs accreditation;<br />

j. Requests for an appeal of an adverse action;<br />

k. Appeal presentations to a Board of Appeal or the ACGME.<br />

11. Provide oversight of all phases of educational experiments and innovations that may deviate<br />

from Institutional, Common, and special/subspecialty‐specific Program Requirements.<br />

12. Provide oversight of program reductions and closures (see <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐04‐11).<br />

13. Monitor interactions of residents and GME programs with vendor representatives (see <strong>GMEC</strong><br />

Policy # III‐02‐11).<br />

14. Present an annual report to the organized Medical Staff and the GHS Board of Trustees that reviews<br />

the activities of the <strong>GMEC</strong> during the past year with attention to the impact of GME on patient safety<br />

and quality of care, resident supervision, resident responsibilities, resident evaluation, and<br />

compliance with duty‐hour standards.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

33


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐01‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: I.B.4.a<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

DIO Delegation<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that in the absence of the Designated<br />

Institutional Official, the Assistant Dean for Graduate Medical Education will have the authority and<br />

responsibility to review and cosign all program information forms and any documents or correspondence<br />

submitted to the ACGME by Program Directors.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

34


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐02‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: III.B.13<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Vendor Interactions<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that each residency program will be in<br />

compliance with the GHS CME policies regarding education sponsorship and comply with its own program –<br />

specific vendor interaction policy that is compliant with GHS Vendor policy and procedures.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

35


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />

Page 1<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

GME Vendor Interactions<br />

Policy and Guidelines for Interactions between the Faculty, Residents, Medical Students and Educational<br />

Staff of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center and Commercial Vendors.<br />

Purpose of Policy<br />

The purpose of this policy is to establish guidelines for interactions with industry representatives for medical<br />

staff, faculty, staff, students, and trainees of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center.<br />

Interactions with industry occur in a variety of contexts, including marketing of new pharmaceutical products,<br />

medical devices, and research equipment and supplies on‐site, on‐site training of newly purchased devices, the<br />

development of new devices, educational support of medical students and trainees, and continuing medical<br />

education. Faculty and trainees also participate in interactions with industry off campus and in scholarly<br />

publications. Many aspects of these interactions are positive and important for promoting the educational,<br />

clinical and research missions of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center. However, these<br />

interactions must be ethical and cannot create conflicts of interest that could endanger patient safety, data<br />

integrity, the integrity of our education and training programs, or the reputation of either the faculty member<br />

or the institution.<br />

Statement of Policy<br />

It is the policy of the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center that interactions with industry<br />

should be conducted according to the highest ethical standards and so as to avoid or minimize conflicts of<br />

interest. When conflicts of interest do arise they must be addressed appropriately, as described herein.<br />

Scope of Policy<br />

This policy incorporates the following types of interactions with industry. It does not include faculty research and<br />

related activities, which are included in the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center Medical Staff Policy<br />

on Conflict of Interest (http://ghsnet.ghs.org/Medstaff/WebDocuments/Policies/Conflict_of_Interest_Policy.pdf).<br />

I. Gifts and compensation<br />

II. Site access by sales and marketing representatives<br />

III. Provision of scholarships and other educational funds to students and trainees<br />

IV. Support for educational and other professional activities<br />

V. Disclosure of relationships with industry<br />

VI. Training of students, trainees, and staff regarding potential conflict of interest in industry interactions<br />

I. Gifts and Compensation<br />

A. Personal gifts from industry may not be accepted anywhere at the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong><br />

University Medical Center or at any other clinical facility operated by GHS UMC, such as<br />

physicians’ practices and outlying hospitals. In addition, GHSUMC faculty, staff and trainees<br />

may also not accept gifts at any non‐GHSUMC clinical facility such as other hospitals, outreach<br />

clinics and the like. Non‐faculty medical staff members are strongly discouraged from<br />

accepting gifts at non‐GHSUMC‐operated clinical facilities but are not proscribed by this policy<br />

from doing so.<br />

B. Individuals should be aware of other applicable policies, such as the AMA Code of Ethics<br />

Opinion 8.061 – Gifts to Physicians from Industry<br />

(http://www.ama‐assn.org/ama/pub/physician‐resources/medical‐ethics/code‐medicalethics/opinion8061.page)<br />

and the Accrediting Council for Continuing Medical Education<br />

Standards for Commercial Support (www.accme.org).<br />

36


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />

Page 2<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

GME Vendor Interactions<br />

C. Individuals may not accept gifts or compensation for listening to a sales talk by an industry<br />

representative.<br />

D. Individuals may not accept gifts or compensation for prescribing or changing a patient's<br />

prescription.<br />

E. Individuals must consciously and actively divorce clinical care decisions from any perceived or<br />

actual benefits expected from any company. It is unacceptable for patient care decisions to be<br />

influenced by the possibility of personal financial gain.<br />

F. Individuals may not accept compensation, including the defraying of costs, for simply<br />

attending a CME or other activity or conference (that is, if the individual is not speaking or<br />

otherwise actively participating or presenting at the event).<br />

G. Textbooks and items of educational value may be provided to the institution if approved by<br />

the department Chair/ program director and if consistent with department educational goals<br />

and institutional policies.<br />

H. Pens, pads, educational brochures which feature specific product names and information are<br />

not to be accepted and are not to be left on the premises.<br />

II.<br />

III.<br />

Site Access by Sales and Marketing Representatives<br />

A. Sales and marketing representatives are not permitted in any patient care areas except to<br />

provide in‐service training on devices and other equipment and then only by appointment.<br />

B. Sales and marketing representatives are permitted in non‐patient care areas by appointment<br />

only. Appointments will normally be made for such purposes as:<br />

1. In‐service training of GHSUMC personnel for research or clinical equipment or devices<br />

already purchased.<br />

2. Evaluation of new purchases of equipment, devices, or related items.<br />

C. Appointments to obtain information about new drugs in the formulary will normally be issued<br />

by the hospital pharmacy or by Pharmaceutical and Therapeutics Committees. The acceptance<br />

of pharmaceutical samples will be governed by the GHS Pharmacy policy.<br />

D. Appointments may be made on a per visit basis at the discretion of the faculty member, his or<br />

her division or department, or designated hospital personnel issuing the invitation and with<br />

the approval of appropriate Department Chair.<br />

Provision of Scholarships and Other Educational Funds to Students and Trainees<br />

A. Industry support of students and trainees should be free of any actual or perceived conflict of<br />

interest, must be specifically for the purpose of education and must comply with all of the<br />

following provisions:<br />

1. The educational department, program or division selects the fellow, student or<br />

trainee.<br />

2. The funds are provided to the department, program, or division and not directly to<br />

student or trainee.<br />

3. The department, program or division has determined that the funded conference or<br />

program has educational merit.<br />

4. The recipient is not subject to any implicit or explicit expectation of providing<br />

something in return for the support, i.e., a "quid pro quo."<br />

37


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />

Page 3<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

GME Vendor Interactions<br />

B. This provision may not apply to national or regional merit‐based awards, which are considered<br />

on a case‐by‐case basis.<br />

IV.<br />

Support for Educational and Other Professional Activities<br />

A. Individuals should be aware of the ACCME Standards for Commercial Support. They provide<br />

useful guidelines for evaluating all forms of industry interaction, both on and off campus and<br />

including both GHSUMC‐ sponsored and other events. The Standards may be found by going to<br />

the website: www.accme.org.<br />

B. All education events sponsored by the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center<br />

must be compliant with ACCME Standards for Commercial Support whether or not CME credit<br />

is awarded.<br />

1. Educational grants that are compliant with the ACCME Standards may be received<br />

from industry but must be administered by departments or divisions and not by<br />

individual faculty.<br />

2. Divisions and departments must maintain records of compliance with the ACCME<br />

Standards.<br />

C. Vendors shall not sponsor any educational programs without approval by the Department<br />

Chair, Program Director or Section Chief. In all cases the selection of speakers and assurance of<br />

the educational integrity of the program is the responsibility of the GHS faculty member,<br />

program director or department chair. While the support of venders may be acknowledged<br />

vendors may not speak or present product information in conjunction with educational time.<br />

There can be no activities to promote or market specific products in educational time.<br />

D. Meals or other types of food directly funded by industry may not be provided at the <strong>Greenville</strong><br />

<strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center or for GHS educational events off campus.<br />

E. Faculty and medical staff should evaluate very carefully their own participation in meetings<br />

and conferences that are fully or partially sponsored or run by industry because of the high<br />

potential for perceived or real conflict of interest. This provision does not apply to meetings of<br />

professional societies that may receive partial industry support, meetings governed by ACCME<br />

Standards, and the like.<br />

F. Individuals who actively participate in meetings and conferences supported in part or in whole<br />

by industry (e.g., by giving a lecture, organizing the meeting) should follow these guidelines:<br />

1. Financial support by industry is fully disclosed by the meeting sponsor.<br />

2. The meeting or lecture content is determined by the speaker and not the industrial<br />

sponsor.<br />

3. The lecturer is expected to provide a fair and balanced assessment of therapeutic<br />

options and to promote objective scientific and educational activities and discourse.<br />

4. The GHSUMC participant is not required by an industry sponsor to accept advice or<br />

services concerning speakers, content, etc., as a condition of the sponsor's<br />

contribution of funds or services.<br />

5. The lecturer makes clear that content reflects individual views and not the views of<br />

<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong> University Medical Center.<br />

6. The use of the GHSUMC name in non‐GHSUMC event is limited to the identification of<br />

the individual by his or her title and affiliation.<br />

38


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐03‐11<br />

Page 4<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

GME Vendor Interactions<br />

V. Disclosure of Relationships with Industry<br />

A. Individuals are prohibited from publishing articles under their own names that are written in<br />

whole or material part by industry employees.<br />

B. In scholarly publications, individuals must disclose their related financial interests in<br />

accordance with the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors<br />

(http://www.icmje.org).<br />

C. Faculty with supervisory responsibilities for students, residents, trainees or staff should ensure<br />

that the faculty's conflict or potential conflict of interest does not affect or appear to affect his<br />

or her supervision of the student, resident, trainee, or staff member.<br />

D. Individuals having a direct role making institutional decisions on equipment or drug<br />

procurement must disclose to the purchasing unit, prior to making any such<br />

decision, any financial interest they or their immediate family have in companies that might<br />

substantially benefit from the decision. Such financial interests could include equity<br />

ownership, compensated positions on advisory boards, a paid consultancy, or other forms of<br />

compensated relationship. They must also disclose any research or educational interest they<br />

or their department have that might substantially benefit from the decision. The purchasing<br />

unit will decide whether the individual must excuse him/herself from the purchasing decision.<br />

1. This provision excludes indirect ownership such as stock held through mutual funds.<br />

2. The term "immediate family" includes the individual's spouse or dependent children.<br />

E. For disclosure requirements related to educational activities, see the ACCME Standards for<br />

Commercial Support (www.accme.org).<br />

VI.<br />

Training of Students, Trainees, and Staff Regarding Potential Conflict of Interest in Interactions with<br />

Industry<br />

B. All students, residents, trainees, and staff shall receive training regarding potential conflicts of<br />

interest in interactions with industry.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

39


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐04‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: II.D.5<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Residency Closure/Reduction in Size<br />

GHS is committed to facilitating completion of training by any resident who has matriculated. GHS will inform<br />

the <strong>GMEC</strong>, the DIO, and residents as soon as possible when it intends to reduce the size of or close one or<br />

more programs, or when GHS intends to close. In practice this means that closure of residencies, reduction of a<br />

resident complement, or institutional closure is done in a proactive planned manner such that the reductions<br />

are timed with program completion. Reductions are to be accomplished during the recruiting phase rather<br />

than through elimination of matriculated residents. In the event that crisis would preclude such an approach,<br />

GHS would be committed to maintain the program until the residents were enrolled in an ACGME accredited<br />

program elsewhere to continue their education. This approach is in conformity with the institutional<br />

requirements of the ACGME.<br />

In the event that GHS intends to reduce the size or close either a program or the Institution itself, GHS will<br />

inform the <strong>GMEC</strong>, the DIO, and the residents as soon as possible.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

40


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐05‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: 1.B.8<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Disaster and GME<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that in the event of a local extreme<br />

emergent situation, natural disaster or cataclysm that all appropriate steps will be made to continue<br />

compliance with all applicable ACGME and RRC rules. GME will be in compliance with the GHS disaster policy<br />

and procedures (GHS Emergency Operations Plan ‐ EOP). In the event that such disaster prohibits timely<br />

continuance of Graduate Medical Education programs at the <strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong>, the ACGME and RRC’s<br />

will be contacted to ensure an orderly transaction to other ACGME accredited residency programs.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

41


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐06‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />

Common Program Requirements: N/A<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Program Annual Reports w/Format<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that each program will present to the GHS<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> a written annual report per the attached outline and schedule. The Annual Reports will become a part<br />

of the <strong>GMEC</strong> meeting minutes.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

42


Annual Report Presentation Schedule<br />

SEPTEMBER<br />

OCTOBER<br />

NOVEMBER<br />

DECEMBER<br />

Orthopaedics Surgery<br />

OB/GYN<br />

General Surgery<br />

Vascular Surgery<br />

Minimal Access Surgery<br />

Internal Medicine<br />

Vascular Medicine<br />

Family Medicine<br />

Sports Medicine<br />

Pediatrics<br />

Developmental Pediatrics<br />

Combined Internal Medicine/Pediatrics<br />

43


<strong>Greenville</strong> <strong>Hospital</strong> <strong>System</strong><br />

Residency Program<br />

Annual Report:<br />

[Type Name of Program]<br />

Program Director:<br />

2011<br />

Academic<br />

Year<br />

44


2011 Residency Program Annual Report Template<br />

Program:<br />

Department Chair:<br />

Program Director:<br />

Program Coordinator:<br />

RRC accreditation status:<br />

Date of last RRC site visit:<br />

Date of last internal review:<br />

Date of next RRC review:<br />

Faculty: List all faculty members with USCSOM – G faculty appointments (* - the asterisk<br />

indicates new faculty since last report). Indicate core faculty members as designated within<br />

the Program’s RRC PIF guidelines. Document average hours per week applied to each<br />

performance item below.<br />

Name (Position)<br />

Core<br />

Faculty<br />

(Y/N)<br />

Based<br />

Mainly<br />

at Site<br />

Primary and Secondary<br />

Specialties / Fields<br />

Original<br />

Specialty Cert Cert Cert<br />

Field (Y/N) Year Status<br />

Re-cert<br />

Year<br />

No. of<br />

Years<br />

Teaching<br />

in This<br />

Specialty<br />

Average Hours Per Week Spent On<br />

Clinical<br />

Supervision<br />

Didactic<br />

Admin Teaching<br />

Research<br />

45


Faculty awards/recognition:<br />

National/Regional Committees & Positions of Recognition:<br />

<strong>Hospital</strong> Committees:<br />

Other:<br />

House Staff:<br />

Resident positions by year:<br />

Number of positions filled by year:<br />

Residents terminated during prior year:<br />

Status of any other disciplinary/probation action:<br />

Awards/recognition:<br />

In-training exam results:<br />

Graduating resident plans:<br />

Specialty Board Pass Rate:<br />

<strong>Hospital</strong> Committees:<br />

Match results:<br />

Total positions:<br />

Rank order matched:<br />

Open positions:<br />

# IMG matched:<br />

# Minority matched:<br />

# Positions filled outside of match:<br />

Scholarly Activity: (Faculty & Residents)<br />

46


Faculty & Resident/Fellow Scholarly Productivity Chart<br />

Complete summative chart and list citations of scholarly activities below.<br />

Publications:<br />

Peer <strong>Rev</strong>iewed:<br />

Non-Peer <strong>Rev</strong>iewed:<br />

Books & Book Chapters Published:<br />

Members of Nat’l Study Sections or Committees:<br />

Journal Editors:<br />

Faculty<br />

Number of: Number of: Number of Departmental Members Who Are:<br />

Articles in Books & Members of<br />

Members<br />

Peerreviewed<br />

Chapters Sections or<br />

Extramural<br />

Book Nat’l Study<br />

working on<br />

Journal Editors<br />

Journals Published Committees<br />

Grants<br />

Residents/<br />

Fellows<br />

Regional/national presentations:<br />

Local presentations:<br />

Extramural Grants: PI’s, Description, Funding Agency, Funding Amount, and Length<br />

Ongoing research initiatives:<br />

Other:<br />

Issues/concerns:<br />

Status of RRC citations:<br />

Status of Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew concerns:<br />

Other:<br />

47


Documentation Requirements with Comments<br />

Written Recruitment Policy: (provide policy)<br />

Written Competency-based Goals and Objectives: (provide curriculum<br />

documentation)<br />

General Competencies Curriculum and Measurement Compliance: (provide one<br />

example per ACGME general competency of curricula and assessments)<br />

Simulation Center Activities: (list learning modules used and numbers participating<br />

with each activity)<br />

Resident Responsibilities: (describe the process for graduated responsibility and<br />

autonomy with supervision appropriate to the level of resident expertise and seniority)<br />

Resident Supervision: (provide a narrative describing relationships and levels of<br />

resident supervision within the program)<br />

Formal Resident and Faculty Evaluation Policy and Process: (provide policy and<br />

describe processes)<br />

Formal Rotation Evaluations: (with examples)<br />

Learning Portfolio: (describe the tool(s) used to document an organized collection of<br />

past and current learning accomplishments and scholarly activities used to reflect and<br />

assess general competencies and progressive practice capabilities. Provide one<br />

learning portfolio example and describe the process for reviewing resident/faculty<br />

academic performance)<br />

Residents/Fellows:<br />

Faculty:<br />

Master Affiliation Agreements & PLA’s: Provide a copy of each ACGME-defined<br />

required agreement.<br />

Definition: There must be a program letter of agreement (PLA) between the program and<br />

each participating site providing a required assignment. The PLA must be renewed at least<br />

every five years.<br />

48


For each required PLA complete the following table by marking an “X” in the appropriate<br />

column. Copy and repeat table as needed.<br />

Agreement with:<br />

Does the agreement identify faculty with<br />

supervisory responsibilities?<br />

Does the agreement specify responsibilities for:<br />

Teaching<br />

Supervision<br />

Formal Evaluation<br />

Does the agreement specify the duration and<br />

content of the educational experience?<br />

Does the agreement state the policies and<br />

procedures that will govern resident education<br />

during the assignment?<br />

Please answer the following question by<br />

inserting the word Yes, No, or N/A in the<br />

appropriate column.<br />

Has the program made all RRC required<br />

additions or deletions through ACGME ADS?<br />

Explain below.<br />

Last renewal<br />

Date:<br />

YES<br />

YES/NO<br />

NO<br />

N/A<br />

Duty Hours Compliance with Documentation: Provide description of process<br />

through which you monitor compliance with duty hour standards. Include New<br />

Innovations summative report including list of exceptions and responses)<br />

Resident Fatigue Policy, Monitoring, and Education: (provide departmental policy<br />

and list training initiatives)<br />

Patient Safety & Quality of Care Education: (provide a narrative describing resident<br />

participation in patient safety and quality of care education)<br />

Hand-off Process: (provide a narrative describing transition of care and attach written<br />

policy regarding hand-offs)<br />

Department Evaluation & Plan: (provide evaluation summary and improvement<br />

plans)<br />

Future Initiatives Based Upon Department Evaluation and Plan:<br />

49


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy # III‐07‐11<br />

Institutional Requirements: N/A<br />

Common Program Requirements: N/A<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that the <strong>GMEC</strong> Policy <strong>Manual</strong> and policies<br />

will be reviewed for affirmation and/or amendment at least every two years.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

50


IV. INTERNAL REVIEWS<br />

51


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />

Page 1<br />

Institutional Requirements: IV.A‐B<br />

Common Program Requirements:<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />

It is the policy of the GHS Graduate Medical Education Committee that an internal programmatic review of<br />

each graduate medical education residency program will be conducted on a regular basis by the Graduate<br />

Medical Education Committee (<strong>GMEC</strong>) through an appointed internal review committee.<br />

Procedures:<br />

1. Internal reviews must be in process and documented in the <strong>GMEC</strong> minutes by<br />

approximately the midpoint of the accreditation cycle. The accreditation cycle is<br />

calculated from the date of the meeting at which the final accreditation action was taken to the<br />

time of the next site visit. The internal review is considered complete when the report is accepted<br />

by <strong>GMEC</strong>. Probation‐designated or programs with significant RRC deficiencies may be reviewed<br />

with required action plans more frequently.<br />

2. When a program has no residents enrolled at the mid‐point of the review cycle, the<br />

following circumstances apply:<br />

a. The <strong>GMEC</strong> will demonstrate continued oversight of those programs through a<br />

modified internal review that ensures the program has maintained adequate<br />

faculty and staff resources, clinical volume, and other necessary curricular<br />

elements required to be in substantial compliance with Institutional, Common and<br />

specialty‐specific Program Requirements prior to the program enrolling a resident.<br />

b. After enrolling a resident, an internal review will be completed within the second sixmonth<br />

period of the resident's first year in the program.<br />

3. The residency program's Program Director is notified by Academic Services<br />

Administration that an internal review will be scheduled. The Academic Services<br />

Administration will coordinate all appropriate logistics for the internal review process.<br />

4. The internal review committee is appointed by the GHS <strong>GMEC</strong> Chairperson. (See<br />

Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Format.)<br />

5. The designated Residency Program will be provided a copy of the specific steps for the internal<br />

review process. (See Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Format.)<br />

6. Upon the resolve of the review process, the results will be reported to the <strong>GMEC</strong>. (See Internal<br />

<strong>Rev</strong>iew Format.)<br />

7. Upon identification of program deficiencies and/or issues, the residency program will<br />

submit a written action plan within 60 days to the <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />

8. The designated residency program may be required to provide periodic action plans to<br />

the <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />

52


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />

Page 2<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />

GHS Graduate Medical Education <strong>Rev</strong>iew Format<br />

1. For each internal review, the <strong>GMEC</strong> chairperson will appoint an Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

Committee consisting of:<br />

a. A Department Chair or Program Director from a residency program other than the<br />

program under review.<br />

b. Faculty member(s) from residency programs not being reviewed.<br />

c. Resident(s) from residency programs not being reviewed.<br />

d. A Residency Program Coordinator from a program not being reviewed.<br />

e. Designated Institutional Official is an ex‐officio member without vote.<br />

f. The Administrator for Academic Services will serve as the process coordinator and a voting<br />

member.<br />

g. Manager, GME Curriculum is an ex‐officio member without vote.<br />

h. The Assistant Dean for Graduate Medical Education serves as Chair .... unless<br />

the program reviewed is within his/her discipline. In that event, the Academic<br />

Services Administrator will serve as process coordinator and Chair.<br />

i. Additional internal or external reviewers may be included on the internal review<br />

committee. Administrators from outside the program may be included.<br />

2. <strong>Rev</strong>iew protocol:<br />

A. The Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee will study, review applicable documentation, and assess<br />

the following:<br />

1. Compliance with the Common, specialty/subspecialty‐specific Program, and<br />

Institutional Requirements;<br />

2. Educational objectives and effectiveness in meeting those objectives;<br />

3. Educational and financial resources;<br />

4. Effectiveness in addressing areas of non‐compliance and concerns in previous<br />

ACGME accreditation letters of notification and previous internal reviews;<br />

5. Effectiveness of educational outcomes in the ACGME general competencies;<br />

6. Effectiveness in using evaluation tools and outcome measures to assess a<br />

resident's level of competence in each of the ACGME general competencies;<br />

Annual program improvement efforts in:<br />

a) Resident performance using aggregated resident data;<br />

b) Faculty development;<br />

c) Graduate performance including performance of program graduates on<br />

the certification examination; and<br />

d) Program quality.<br />

7. Policies on selection, evaluation, and promotion of residents, disciplinary action,<br />

supervision of residents, duty hours, and moonlighting.<br />

53


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />

Page 3<br />

POLICY TITLE: Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />

Materials and data to be used in the review process will include:<br />

a. The ACGME Common, specialty/subspecialty‐specific Program, and<br />

Institutional Requirements in effect at the time of the review;<br />

b. Procedures and documentation regarding compliance with duty hours<br />

requirements.<br />

c. Accreditation letters of notification from previous ACGME reviews and<br />

progress reports sent to the respective RRC.<br />

d. Reports from previous internal reviews of the program;<br />

e. Resident evaluations of the faculty and the overall program;<br />

f. Previous annual program evaluation; and<br />

g. Results from internal and external resident surveys, if available.<br />

B. The Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee will conduct interviews with the program director, key<br />

faculty members, at least one peer‐selected resident from each level of training in the<br />

program, and other individuals deemed appropriate by the committee.<br />

C. Interview session(s) with the residents and faculty of the program being reviewed will be<br />

conducted and documented on behalf of the committee.<br />

D. Questionnaires will be developed and distributed separately to the reviewed<br />

program's faculty and residents.<br />

E. The Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Committee will discuss and analyze the results of the faculty and<br />

resident interviews and received questionnaires.<br />

F. Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iew Report<br />

1. The written reports of the internal review committee for each program will<br />

contain, at a minimum:<br />

a. The name of the program reviewed, the date of the assigned midpoint, the<br />

status of <strong>GMEC</strong> oversight of the internal review at the midpoint, and the<br />

date the written report is approved by the <strong>GMEC</strong>;<br />

b. The names and titles of the internal review committee members;<br />

c. A brief description of how the internal review process was conducted,<br />

including the list of the groups/individuals interviewed and the documents<br />

reviewed;<br />

d. Sufficient documentation to demonstrate that a comprehensive review<br />

followed the <strong>GMEC</strong>'s internal review protocol; and<br />

54


<strong>GMEC</strong> Policy #: IV‐01‐11<br />

Page 4<br />

POLICY TITLE:<br />

Internal <strong>Rev</strong>iews<br />

e. A list of the citations and areas of non‐compliance or any concerns or<br />

comments from the previous ACGME accreditation letter of notification<br />

with a summary of how the program and/or institution subsequently<br />

addressed each item.<br />

2. The DIO and the <strong>GMEC</strong> will monitor the response by the program to actions<br />

recommended by the <strong>GMEC</strong>.<br />

3. The <strong>GMEC</strong> may request follow‐up progress reports at specified intervals.<br />

September 24, 2009<br />

Date of Initial <strong>GMEC</strong> Approval<br />

Signature on File<br />

Spence M. Taylor, M.D.<br />

Graduate Medical Education DIO and<br />

Chief Academic Officer<br />

Signature on File<br />

Edward W. Bray III, M.D.<br />

<strong>GMEC</strong> Chair and Assistant Dean for<br />

Graduate Medical Education<br />

September 22, 2011<br />

Date of Last <strong>GMEC</strong> <strong>Rev</strong>iew<br />

55

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!