Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
ananJayarao Gadgd Library<br />
<strong>I~~~</strong> <strong>mllll~mm</strong> <strong>m~m~</strong> 1m ~<br />
GIPE-PUNE-014985
n<br />
.<br />
No. I-Vol. XXIII.<br />
1f<br />
2nd. 1925.<br />
RegIstered at the G. P: O. as a Ne..." ....<br />
Pale" FouuAu<br />
BOR<br />
OUGHS OR t<br />
~~d 'ANCE 1924 (NATAL) . ,~,~_,~)<br />
. 'U.~-----<br />
lIE following pl'oclamation, appears ?h<br />
fTnion Gowmmmt (}auliIJ dated 19th e<br />
bel' 192-1 :_<br />
si<br />
Whereas an Ordinance J,6 'eonsohdate aUt h<br />
the law relating to the constitution of<br />
boronghs elections and general authority<br />
councils and to define the powers of town<br />
was passed by tbe Natal Provincial Council<br />
presented by the Administrator of Nata P<br />
Oovern01'-General-in-Council for assent in aeco I<br />
with section mllel" of the South Africa Ac ;~('e<br />
tb(> second day lJf August, 1924; • ~u \<br />
An4 whereas the Governor-General-in-C \<br />
accordance with the said section reserved I "n'<br />
Ordinance for further consideration; . 'said<br />
And whereas the Governor-General-i<br />
has determined that the said Ordmance sha neil<br />
bis aRsent ;<br />
eive<br />
Now, therefore, under and by virtue ot th<br />
vel:!tetJ in me by sectIOn ninety of the Sout ve;1l<br />
Act, 1909, I do hereby declare, proclaim rica<br />
known that the said Ordmance the short tit lake<br />
of is ., The Boroughs Ordinance 1924," P erethe<br />
Provincial Council of Natal, and pres by {<br />
atoresald, has recelv~d the assent of the i as ~<br />
General-in-Council, .<br />
GOD ~A VE THE KING<br />
•. Given under my Hand and the Great Se<br />
Union of South Africa at Pretoria, this Tw<br />
of December, One' thousand Nine hune<br />
'rwellty-ioUl·.<br />
ATHLONE, fl
M Jahuary 2nd, 192.5,<br />
2 j' . INDIAN Or'~----~--~--~~-<br />
( 1-:-, --------.....--.....<br />
~../ ; ush;ed th)'ough and p:W!e
~ .January~~d;' I9!.5_-____ I_N_D_l_A_li_r-0_P_I_N_l_O_N __________<br />
,<br />
"'mit t~jlJ s~p will he worth taking only if we are<br />
,)'l'flpar,ed to fight the OrdiP!'nce in any event. It<br />
shoul!} not be forgotten that this Ordinance is not<br />
the first of its kind that strikes a blow at the remnants<br />
of 'Our existing lights to live as self-respecting British<br />
citiiens in ~1J.is country which were promised by<br />
the UI]lon Government not to l}e interfered with.<br />
Sever," - Ordinances have preceded the present<br />
one depriving Indians 'of their rights in Some<br />
way or oth~r ~nd the leJ,.al,ity of whIch does not<br />
require to be tefltell. this Ordinance embodies<br />
practIcally ~}l the ,evils of the other Ordinances and<br />
,in addition takes away -the mnnicipal franchise<br />
I hitherto enjoyed by the Indian commnnity of this<br />
Pr(\virrce; and in th!1 reSi)ect it is more Venolll(\us<br />
than the rest. What we wish to point out. how.<br />
~ver, is thai the SlUS of this -Province are sufficient<br />
I eveu without this Ordinance to jUstify the Indian:<br />
~CQIllJ.JUlUity..J.o--ad0Pt- ,passive Resistance right away.<br />
I But there is no b,artn in letting 'Constitutional means<br />
l'~ thoroughly exhansted and hence we approve of<br />
(pe step proposed to test the legality of the present<br />
tOr
4 INDIAN OPINION Jannary ~nd. J925-~<br />
reason for this was that his lease had expired, and went to show that by neglect and. a\lowln'S the CO"<br />
Mr. W. North had purchased the old premises, and gr~gation of undeSirable NatiVE'S and others. J<br />
which were now delapldated. Applicant submitted nUIsance had developed of whICh the residents hal<br />
a number of references, one frQm the Manager of from time to time cOIllplamed to the pollce. E,\<br />
the Standard Bank, Durban, and the others from dence by the objectors showed that Northdene w.,<br />
Durban merchants, and saId that he aad been a dIstinctly European area, that the numher of SUCl<br />
trading twenty years in the old premises.<br />
resIdents W firm admitted having a retail licence application be refused.<br />
at Umlaas; which he explained had been taken out<br />
by him four _years ago. He dpnied threatening to<br />
NotIce of appeal wasl odged.-Nalill j["rew11.<br />
Close or freeze Mrs. Taylor out. He did not attempt<br />
to undersell her; "in fact," said he, "I do not'trade<br />
- CABLE TO INDIA J(<br />
with Europeans."<br />
The following is a copy of a Cable message f!e~<br />
In 'reply to CoL LeWis, witness said tha.t the plan m connection WIth the Natal Boroughs Ordillan<br />
tlRbmitted was a complete plan of the premises. 1924 to H. E. The Viceroy ot Imha.<br />
The'y did 'not cook any food in the eating, house for by the Natal Indian Congress :-<br />
the Nati\7cs.' ,<br />
"Borougps Ordinance No. 1~ Natal ansenteu 1<<br />
This closed ,the caSe for the applicants.<br />
by Go"Vernor General notwithsldnding vehernen<br />
Walter G. North, thecliief objector to the transfer protest from Indian community. Ordinance de<br />
of the licence, said that fie had lived at Northdene prlves Indians long-enjoyed municipal fr£\llchitll<br />
for the last fifty years. He objectedJo the transfer and imposes other disablllhes rellncing Indians ~<br />
of the licence or the continuance of that business. a condition of helotry. Future of Inllians ill Natal<br />
He eontended that numerous Natives and Indians<br />
congregated at that pla$)e. There were generally<br />
crIcket and football matyhes going on on the m~in<br />
:road opposite; and also horse -racing. He (WItness)<br />
had personally made complaints to the police on the<br />
offensive meat o:ffer~d for sale' by the meat sellers<br />
who came to the store and who displayed their<br />
meat wlthin fifteen yards of the premises; He felt<br />
that Noithdene was essentially a European settlement,<br />
and apphcants were the only Indians holding<br />
property in the place.,<br />
There wel'e going to be filter beds near N orthdene,<br />
proceeded the witness, which meant that large_<br />
numbers of Natives would be employed there, and<br />
to abandon the Native eating house would not<br />
remedy the matter.<br />
- In reply to Mr. Renaud, witness stated that applicants<br />
did not sell the ID{'at, bufthey allowed hawkers<br />
across the road to' hang It up.<br />
In reply to the Board, witness thought the grant·<br />
ing of the new licence would be very pr~judic1a1 to<br />
'European residents in the district. .<br />
Jame~,:Turner, a resident of Northdene, and a<br />
memb,er of the Malvel;n Health Committee. objected<br />
to the granting of the licence.<br />
lb.- reply to Mr. Renaud, witness said he had<br />
'er objected to the renewal of the licence though<br />
,d remarked on the existing conditions time<br />
.in. He dId not know that he could object<br />
",nsfer of the licence- until six months ago.<br />
'itnesses, _including William A. -Hmes,<br />
-'l!.lter and Albert Young, also gave evit,he<br />
granting of the licence.<br />
'ld Mr. Dyrnes then addressed the<br />
illD'S DECISION<br />
'. Bernard Hodson, m giving<br />
'id the premises for which re<br />
~use licences are presently<br />
i had become unfit for<br />
'uiscs" and the eVlucllce<br />
doomed. Earnestly appeal to Government to up<br />
hold India's honour and prestige by seeking tht<br />
King Emperor's disallowl\llce .to the Ordinance ...<br />
A Copy of the above message haS been for warde<br />
t6 Mr. Gandhi and other leaders in India d.ml<br />
Mr. H. S. L. Polak 1D London.<br />
THE 'ADVERTISER' AGAIN ON THE ORm<br />
ANCE<br />
" INOFF_ENSIVE-UNPRO'fECTED-POWERLEHH "<br />
The Natal adverltser has the following leadlllg<br />
article under the above headline 1D its iSbue of Dec.<br />
22:-<br />
The passing of the Natal Boronghs Ordmance hat1<br />
raised a storm of protest wherever Indld.llB are to be<br />
found in the Empire. This was to have been expected.<br />
It was also to have been expected that<br />
" wild and whirling words" would be used by the<br />
protestors, nor has the publIc had to walt long<br />
for these. The South AfrIcan Indian Congress h31:1<br />
passed four resolutions protestmg against the Ordinance,<br />
and these framed in terms that IMve httle to<br />
be imagined. • The Ordinance is descrihed as<br />
"m6diaevlll, reactionary and unjust," and 18 said to btl<br />
directed against an "moffenslve, unprotected amI<br />
powerless people purely on account of their race."<br />
The protest goes on to talk about deliberatel~, rob-,<br />
bing the rifling and future generAtions of their<br />
sacred rIghts of mUDlcipal franchise," and leavmg<br />
them "to the mercy of men who will not deal justly<br />
with them." It conclulles by threatening pd.Ssivc<br />
resistance or, as the thIrd resolution euphemistically<br />
puts it, "whereas other ra
~~u~ry:_?nd. ~~_:_ ' INDIAN OPINION 5<br />
y ~n sUffrage": wht'n by no means self-evident. We do not think., 3S a<br />
. "'Llks about the Ordinance being promulgated matter of fact. justice has anrthinl{ to do with thf><br />
lW'inst an "inoffensive, nnprott'cted and powet'lt'flfI franchi:if> one way or another. Expt'diency has:<br />
people pUI'(,I) on account of thE-ir race," it indulges and as evpnts have proved, it is palpably int'xin<br />
a most deJiciouiI hgging of the whole i:ihue. pedient m the first inst.mc£' to give the Asiatic any<br />
Uriah HeE'p was a very 'umble person: none 'umbler. franehise rights at all in this country. He got them<br />
.. I am very well aware that I am the 'umblest from people who were foolftih enough to thillk he<br />
perflOll goin/.:. let the other be who he may. My would Europeanise hImself. Instead he has mulmother<br />
is likewise a vet'y 'umble pE-rflOn. We tiphed amazingly and insisted on building up a little<br />
lJ'.'e in an 'umble abode, Master Copperfield, but Asia in South Africa. -Nothing remains but to<br />
we have muchJo be thankful for. My father's correct the inexpediency of a generous and informer<br />
calling was 'umble-he was a sexton. " dUlgent step taken years ago; and even if the<br />
'Umble-yes. But he came within an ace of heavens themselves thunder about justice or in-<br />
~I'inging abont the downfall anll rl}in of Mr. Wick- justice, the. Europeans in Natal must not be moved.<br />
5eld. No less have the "inoffensive, unprotected and There are a dozen ways by which the Indian pro-<br />
)owerless people," whose reflOlution we are discuss- blem in Natal could be solved with practical advanlng,<br />
brought grave peril to European civilisation in tages to all concerned that wonld ontweigh any<br />
Natal. Cannot the Indian see that, shorn of all the sentimental affront done to the doctrinaires or the<br />
lialectics of the politIcians, what has inspired this protestors on one side or the other. Bnt if we<br />
Ordinance i!lfun~rcal and imminent fear that, un- listen to abstractions affairs will drift from worse to<br />
less the creeping tide of Asiatic penetration in worse until it will be the European and not the In-<br />
Natal is withstood, the painfully and labo~ously dian in Natal who will lift his eyes to the Govern-<br />
Imilt fabric of Western civihsation must go for IDent and beg for repatriation and domicile along-<br />
'laught, and topple a ruin and a reproach to those: side his own people at the other side of the world.<br />
who called.it illl.o--Lcing. Does not the Indian under-<br />
~tan
has adopted a resolutIon ratifying the pact<br />
betwtlen Q:andhl and the S,~arajists, which prov\des<br />
fOJ; the i;'l1J,spe~siol;l of ~th,e non.:co-operation movemt'lnt,<br />
and allowing the SWIl.~ajiets to represevt the<br />
Congr~s irt the Leglsla,tures The l\.hilafat Comel'<br />
en
. -<br />
1f<br />
;'f',,,<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
HE .'ratal .tdtlert""er Louuon correspondent is ultImately one brotherhood of WI all,-the Brotherstates<br />
:-Ml'. J. H. Thomas is- contributmg a hood of Man.<br />
series of articles to Answers on .. Our Empire:<br />
\Vhat it really IDl'ans."<br />
tn the 'first article the ex-Oolomal OeCH'kl/'Y ue • BCl'll.trd Houghton gives it aB his OpllllOlJ in the<br />
('I.wes that Indta's ueIllanu for Helf-goverument barne reVIew that '-<br />
.. IiOlUe uay !llUtit uU'Iuestioll,tlJly be gl"anteu, WIth Wal'S iLre not. as the hlstorl('S and newspapers<br />
all that it Involves."<br />
preleiHl, llJAde lrom some Buddl'n quarrels between'<br />
Hefel'l'lIIg to the native 'lll('l>iIolI In .Ullca, MI'. st,ltesUlen or from breiLch of a treiLty. They ret!t.lt<br />
Thomali saytl, .. Our black fello \V so bjects must 1)6 flOru the cla"h of economic interestB. Brittin's'<br />
de,tit with justly, - pat~cntIy 'and paternally. tWo<br />
hayt' aecepted 11 brJ'('aL trullt which we must faithfully<br />
dIscharge, It CMlllot he shir'ked, amI mnst not he<br />
lIegleeteu. Our only jUlStl~atlO11 for attachml,r these<br />
landti to OUl' Crown It; the heneficMI nature ot our<br />
admimstration, and the fact that no exploitation of<br />
native races is pOHsible tmuel' our fl,!'\(. We, in fact,<br />
by our own choice, aI'e 'guide, phlloHopbel lIntl<br />
friend' of the UiHleveio[,Jed races of the earth, aUfl It<br />
thnr. hecomes ot\r duty, ceJ,tainly to lea.} and to[lc,h<br />
them, amI occal'lionully to scold them,<br />
.. And all this has Lut, olle ("!HI III view-not exploitation<br />
for • Imperial pnrpmws ' Hf these Immature<br />
races, but rather theIr progress towards hIgher<br />
rorm~ of life. "<br />
ent!'y into the recent, war had as much to do with<br />
thc GermJ.1l lJlvasion of Belgium as with a' solar<br />
eclipse .• NOl' lbd the Cur's Government order a<br />
general moLlhZ.ttlOll _ 011 July 30 th, 1911, thereby<br />
giving the signal for war uecause of the wl'ongs<br />
of little SerblJ.. It bec.l.Ine the wol'll! slaughter III<br />
01(11'1' to SeIze .1jonslantIp.ople, the way to whlCh<br />
the Stel"t·t counCIl in Petl'ogl"iLU in February hau<br />
accUJ'ately stated to be through llcrhn. The immeruate<br />
cause WhICh • brought in Brita.in was the secret<br />
ur,llerstandmg of MI'. Afquith'l'l innel' ciLbmet WIth<br />
the Prench Government, the ultimate cause - the<br />
ri, ,tlry betwt'en the British and German iI·onm.tsters<br />
and exploiters of tl'OPICal peoples. The war was<br />
the conflict ot rival ImperiiLlisms for the exploitation-<br />
of the world, -<br />
------ ----------- - ----------<br />
No.2-Vol. XXIII. Friday, January 9th, ~ 1925.<br />
llogistered at the G.P.o. as • He_papar<br />
Palea FOUDBRea<br />
A Reuter's message from Calcutta dated Dec, 2~)<br />
states :-<br />
The llengal Legislative CounCIl will meet ou .Jan.<br />
7 to consider a Bill to give e!frct to the Ordmance<br />
promulgatell on Oct, 25, under the Emergency<br />
Powers by the Viceroy, who was s,ltisfied that the<br />
anarchical movement was deep seated and dangerous,<br />
8 INDIAN OPINION January 9t h, J 925<br />
Pal'\Y ~1 l II ~ i. ' ! ,~ \ ~ t "<br />
duce the same measure but we presume that they<br />
~~~t~n;ipl~te bringiIzg in at 'not a distant date something<br />
different and '£a:r more drastIc in Its oPeration.<br />
We are fumly conVinc'ed'that t;hey in aavisin'g the<br />
G~v~~~no~\!g~~~i-a~, tOl~\~e '1ii,S c~ty!el~'t t? the passing<br />
Qt. ~e ~~tal, :aO!~Ug9'i Cpnsolidat~d Ordinance,<br />
which was,the llext shot fired l:j.t us for our ultimate<br />
undoing, nave done it with a view to ascertain how<br />
far 'the community Is iire'pared'io 'go 'in resistIng it<br />
and w'hat result it I~ likely ~to produce, whether of<br />
its oWn volItion or through 'th~ mter-ventioll of<br />
either the Imperial 01' _the Indian Governments, so<br />
that they mi~ht be MUlded in :tJ!eir own ,time jn,<br />
dealing with the bogie of "Asiatic menace." There<br />
will be further attempts by the local, Provincial and<br />
_ ~ t ~ "- _ _ ~ ~) •<br />
Central Governments at cribbing our right to remain<br />
in thill country as peaceful and law-abiding citizens,<br />
there is_not the least doubt; unless saner cou'usels<br />
prevail and. the Infinite Justice of God,'makes tliem<br />
"; (\U' ' '"<br />
Wlser in IDeir 'generation.<br />
!,-','<br />
LiKe the sword<br />
,<br />
of<br />
:6~~ocles, a gre~t suspense hangs over the c~~m:unt~y<br />
nq~ 'more than eve~. What- IS iII store for<br />
pur degradation and slow but sure extermjnation,<br />
durIng th}s "year, can best be imagined than 'predicted.<br />
What the Indians have done to merit this<br />
treatfueht 'paiJses ob.r Ilnderstanding. Are they to<br />
be itesp~~ed bJd~use ~f thei'r indu~~y, frngalityaud<br />
j).....;.~ ... I .. I'-Ull~\" ,I I<br />
simplicity?, A~e t~ese I\ot the qualities that ought<br />
to appeal and commend themselves to a God-fearin[£<br />
-.eople, whose worship of the one, true and living<br />
1 inculcates'the umversal brotherhood of man?<br />
'countiimen we say 'be tinlted, be evel' on<br />
! • Ii tit ,<br />
bear ye one 1\nother's burdens. Your<br />
I :his cO~litry will, depend a great deal<br />
'lOndl;tct yourselves, morally, socially,<br />
oolitically. To the leaders of the<br />
sink -your illfferences, come<br />
'd means of taking concerted,<br />
., to safeguard and pre-<br />
THE A:::iIATIC pnOHLE)I<br />
THE Ev'o:\'O:lfic A"PECT: bA~Glm OF RACIAL<br />
DETE~UORA.TION<br />
The following artIcle has been con tl'l Luted specl
january 9th. 1925 INDIAN OPINION 9<br />
In 1889, the IndIan PQPulatioll of Durban was<br />
:,J, t~ey owned properties vdlned at £28,840;<br />
~~O l,!dldns b~ . become l'atep.tyers (i.e., burgel:lSel!<br />
with 'l-obng priVIleges), and 12-1 licences were held<br />
: 'J Asiatks. The following figures show the gr'
approximate, the European deteriorates. There<br />
must either be a small white aristocl"dCY with a large<br />
black or coloured population or a large white population<br />
with a small cqloured one if the two races are<br />
to live together under the same climatic condItions,<br />
KHILAFAT CONGRESS WEEK CONCLUDED<br />
Reuters message from Be:lgaum dated Dec. 29.<br />
reads as follows :-<br />
The Khila£at Congress week concludes to-morrow<br />
with the departure of Gandhi, who has practically<br />
dictated the political programme of the Congress.<br />
Although many sincerely believe in his "message to<br />
his su,Pporters to use the spinning wheel, as the only<br />
alternative to ~olence, others, mainly \Sw~rajists,<br />
have a~eed to the proposal for reasons of expediency,<br />
The measure of success which Gandhi<br />
'wIll achieve lU promoting the productiOn of<br />
"Khaddar" or homespun cloth, in 1925, wIll probably<br />
determine his,future hold on the_Congress,<br />
The chief feature of the week has been the<br />
iced ~helr feelings in this connection,<br />
From statements made, It appears that aU-the communities<br />
are preparing to receive the full benefit of<br />
any future transference of power to the Indians.<br />
With the l'esult that the movement in favour- of independence<br />
has lost adherents,<br />
This, possibly, was responsible for the re;:ngnation<br />
from Congress of Hasrat Mol)ani, hitherto the<br />
leader of the movement.<br />
l'N!HANS IN EAS'!' ~\J!'RICA<br />
SUIC~~AL D1lICIS!O~<br />
BY CO~GRESS<br />
Nairobi, Dec. 29th (Reuter).-The East AfrIcan<br />
Iridian National Congress, -after a two-day's stormy<br />
session at Nairobi, placed on record an epoch-making<br />
[ sUlcidal in our opinion.-':'Ed.] decision which had<br />
been engineered by the new President. Abdul<br />
Wahe(l, a Kenya mel'chant pioneel' who, after 25<br />
years' reside:fic~ in the Colony., is now its w..ealthiest<br />
IndIan citizen with very great interests,<br />
It is interesting to note that Wahed origmally<br />
met the Hon. Ormsby Gore, the present Under<br />
Secretary for the Colonies, lfi London, and-.again<br />
during his recent visit in Nairobi,<br />
In t.h-e course of pis presidential address, he urged<br />
that lndians should make peace with Emopeans for<br />
the next three years in the hope that thereafter it<br />
would be productive ot ever-lasting amity,<br />
In t~e course of subsequent debate, the - non-cooperatIve<br />
element was elu;nmated" and eventually<br />
Congress passed a resolution deciding to abandon<br />
the policy of non-co-operation in Kenya,<br />
In accurdance with this decision it was agreed,<br />
first, to accept the five nominated Inaian seats in<br />
the Legislative-Council. to acquiesce in the payment<br />
of a poll-tax, and, thirdly, to accept repreeentation<br />
'"In municipal bodies"on the basis or-five Asiatics to<br />
-'en Europeans.<br />
~urther resolution was -adopted advising Indians<br />
,~to accept the proposal thdt one Indian<br />
(}ve be 'nominated to the Uganda Legis-<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
"~ next thr~e years (the Indiantl are<br />
t..-.-~peration with Europeans in the -<br />
"Ill meet wit~_"reciprocity from<br />
re l~ 'collaboration _ ill the<br />
January 9th, J92S~r<br />
TURKEY OF TO-D'\' Y r --<br />
In the course 'of his interestlllg lecture on till I<br />
above subject in ,the Aligarh Univerbity, Sved H,Ij.:<br />
~yder, the RegIstrar of the lluslim t:nh'Plsi',<br />
IS reported to have said :- l (<br />
.. I h<br />
ave been a student of TllI'kish aif,urs all<br />
ill<br />
I<br />
~ovem~nts for a, very long time. I spent :J yea,l;<br />
m TurkIsh ArabIa, and visited Constantinople twicll'<br />
and havi~g some acquaintance with the language \<br />
the TurkIsh, I h~~ good opportunities of meetmb a',\<br />
class~s and, CO~dltIO?S of men and having a comr<br />
paratlVely mttmate mtercourse with them,<br />
I have seen Turkey under the absolutest aut~"<br />
cracies, I Dlean during the days of Sultdn Abdt(<br />
Hamid; during the ~al'ly days ,of constitutional,:<br />
monarchy and lastly when Turkey is one of tl~'<br />
youngest and most thorough-going of Hepublics. ,<br />
I happened to met't a Gel"Illl\l1 'Professor,' a,1<br />
Ol'lpntaiIst in Berlin, \\ho had just returned fro~<br />
Constantinople, and I put a question to him: "Wb I<br />
struck you most during yom' visit to Turkey? II<br />
at once unhesitatingly rephed .<br />
.. The great wave of nationahsm that is passin<br />
~ over Turkey at present, "<br />
After'visiting Turkey, I endorse eval'Y wOI'd 0<br />
what he said. The present-day Turk is an out an<br />
out nationalist, lie is Turk, first, second aul! las<br />
He may have been something else some time ago<br />
Pan-Isldmist or Pan-Asiatic for example. but he- i<br />
no longer so now, My belief is that he is not muc<br />
even of a Pan-'!'lIl'3.nian at the present mOIDl'nt,<br />
He was a Pan-IRlaulll'4t jll~t helOl'e and ,It th<br />
beginning of the Gredt War. ther became a fenid<br />
Pan-Turanian, but has finally tleWed down as 8,<br />
Turk, of the little Englander type. 1I.. does noli<br />
think in terms of empire or 'of expansion or ofl<br />
conqu~st or of suzerainty or spiritual 01' tempOI'd!. I<br />
His only care is to consoliddte the {{{'public that hl~<br />
has set up and of which he is inknsely proud.",<br />
After dwellmg in detail on tIl(' awakening of'<br />
national consciousness among the Turks and theu'<br />
political evolutIOn, the lecturer referred to th~<br />
emancipation of Turkish Womanhood as a strikin<br />
feature of modern Turkey and said :-<br />
"Turkish women were never accustomed to 8ue<br />
strict seclusion as is observed by or imposed on Indian<br />
ladies, They went about in the bazaars and<br />
did their shopping but they went out veiled and<br />
shrouded. True, the veil was more often than not<br />
a transparent one, hut it was II necessary IMI t of till'<br />
outdoor dress of a Turkish latly.<br />
Now, however, all this is changed, There is<br />
generally no veil now and, not only that, they mo,'e<br />
about with greater freedom and less reserve than<br />
heretofore. The traDl-cars used to have the portion<br />
reserved for ladies screened off; the screens have<br />
been taken away.<br />
These are howe\er only the outwald SIgns of the<br />
Feminist movement in Turkey which is going forward<br />
with a great momentum. Women are invaUing<br />
all departments of life. they are working in offices,<br />
-in firms, banks, hospitals and scores of other pIdces.<br />
It was a revelation to me to find in the Stamboul<br />
University lady students studymg ill the same cLuls<br />
with young men., '. _<br />
Then again, every girl of good breedlllg in Turkey<br />
tries to learn MUSIC and paintmg. There is a college<br />
of music called Darul-al-han where both the theory<br />
and practice of advanced musIC are taught."<br />
The lecturer then refeJ:red to the rapid educational<br />
advancement of the people of Turkey and drew<br />
special attention to an institution SUbSIdised by tht'<br />
Government for tI'3.ining p£'\lple for the stage. After<br />
~eferl'ing to the :Military lCn?l. Medical Colleges and<br />
to the professional skill of the Turks in Burgery,<br />
:Mr. Syed Sajjad Hyder. in concluding, sa.id;-<br />
"1 must here also note a great change. The Turk<br />
who w",; dt'picted, antl not I1njustly, us Pl~'I"ling hh,<br />
'I
INDIAN OPINION<br />
• ,January 9th, 1925<br />
- '<br />
--------------------------------------------~<br />
- y<br />
time in leisured case, smoking his narbtilah and existing system has Ii ved on terrorism and Viceroy<br />
'pinking of houris. present and prospective, has afier Viceroy as a rule has shut his eyes to the<br />
8l1d~enly become, an ardent spOl1sman. Yachting, Obvious necessity of consultation with Indian<br />
l'owmg, ho.l'sC raCeR, shikar; football, hockey, tennis, opinion. The obduracy proves not the uselessness<br />
are llttractmg tl;ie Turkish young men in their of the advice, it provesthe worthlessness of the<br />
t~OI1FI:Ul!ls. hilt with all theh'_ forwardnell8 I have system, under which snch systematic defianc of public<br />
opinion is possible. No wonder the Viceroy, in<br />
not.spen ladics playing any outdoor game. Unlortnnately<br />
the Turk has also become a great winebibber.<br />
He drinks openly, and urges his women -thought he should have had, is obliged to face severe<br />
stead of obtaining the public support which he<br />
folk to quaff from the cup. Perhaps my audience condemnation from practically the whole Indian<br />
will be Burprised to learn that balls and dances have opinion.<br />
uf.'en introduced in Turkish Social life aud are just<br />
now the craze. The fact is that the Turk has deliberately<br />
and definitely turned his face towards the<br />
west, an from criticilDXl, al); pdy i:1.~.J<br />
, thaH ;<br />
had to take his share, hnt if we were/ ' .t ~ "Wtl<br />
.. . / /U1en. level<br />
compare wlth him other Indian merCl /fi he sam;<br />
same financial position, we find ho"';::", .<br />
was. And it will not be out of r:~~ bftoP WHITE<br />
some of"the wealthy Ind71'an ~ P,'''''. ,<br />
/':" pl('k('tt'w'<br />
they are doing for thfc'ir ',- .<br />
of the<br />
<br />
~../ J&.<br />
the way of giying ther j<br />
tion in improving tb l<br />
/<br />
rr
INDIAN OPINION January 9th, 1925<br />
FAIR BREEZE INDIAN SCHOOL<br />
/' TONGAAT<br />
The ann~al prize distribution of the above school<br />
was held on Tuesday the 23rd Decemher 1924. The<br />
sch.oo~-room was artIstically decorated and a platform<br />
was erected by the skilful hands of the members<br />
of ·the school-staff. At 11 a.m. the RE-v. J.<br />
Metcalf the grantee of the school wIth the ~ev.<br />
Hodges the Superintendent of the Westeyan Indian<br />
Mission motored down from Durban to distribute<br />
the pnzes.<br />
The school-room was crowded with children and<br />
friends of the school to its utmost capacity. The<br />
Rev. J. Metcalf occupied the chaIr. The following<br />
is an \~~tract f~pm. his speech "How ~leaBed I feel<br />
to express my appreciation to the donors of these<br />
beautiful bookil and toys. I also verY heartily congratulate<br />
the Headmaster and "staff upon the very<br />
successful work of the past year. Thts IS OIl!) of our<br />
( oldest schooIs and it continues to be one of our<br />
ID,ost I,mccesl'lful o;nes.- I am (lE,llighted to thmk that<br />
you boys and gIrls are here to receive mstructjons<br />
wInch will be of tAe highest value in your future<br />
life." _ _<br />
His speech was followed by a well arranged ll,rogramme<br />
or dialogues, drills' and, recitatiolOls. Prizes \<br />
were then distributed.. 'rhe ReV.' Hodges in his<br />
short ad\lress spoke highly of the discipline of the<br />
sohool and the good work dqne by the Headma~ter<br />
and his staff.<br />
During the latter part of the day sports were held<br />
and all tne winners were aw~rded ~prizes. The<br />
school in the evening was once again crowded when<br />
some of the ~uropean friends were also present<br />
among'whom were Dr. Q. Bonfa, Mr. and Mrs.<br />
Bower and others. Mr. Captain Hastibeer opened<br />
the function with prayers. Itllv. R. Choonoo was<br />
el~cte~ to the ctJ-air. Short speeches were made by<br />
some.9f the ~riends. Mr.,A, R. Singh in his speech<br />
promised £3 towards the necessity of a tank for the<br />
school. The function terminated with a vpte of<br />
thanks to the chair.-Oontribnted.<br />
~:td\\ ~i~<br />
~l~ 'l«~'-ll 't~q.<br />
~r~-l~ltt<br />
~k<br />
'-1l..J\<br />
~l ~ ... 0"'1",.'-;'1 1'11-
~pitti.on·<br />
----------<br />
NO.3-Vol. XXIII. Friday, January 16th, '925.<br />
R-llstereci al tbe G. P.O. a •• Ne ... paper<br />
Ptica louO'slfca<br />
n<br />
'l' III lUOrit interet:ltmg to note that while on the<br />
one hand repatriatIOn of Indians is going on at<br />
full swing on the other not less than 2,5000<br />
~ndu1ll8 are being recruited for the new cotton<br />
plalltations north of ,the TugeIa. The Marltzburg<br />
correspondent of the Natal JferCuT!I in a message<br />
dated .Jan. 8 says :-<br />
Recently much activity was witnessed locally in<br />
connection with the reCI uitmg" of .AFliatlCs for the<br />
cottOll plantations ill Zululand. A representative<br />
of a very well known company informed your .~epl'esentative<br />
that 25,000 Indmns were to be recruite~<br />
, for .the new cotton plantatiolls north of the Tugela.<br />
I understand, ijowever, that there IS a hitch in this<br />
regard, and tbat polihcal influences have been at<br />
wOI'k. as a result of which there is to be nO despatching<br />
of-Indians to Zululand until certain repre<br />
Iwntations .have been made to the Union Government.<br />
and the latter has given its decision, At any<br />
rdte, a halt has been called, af.ld according to information<br />
gleaned from influential Indian quarters<br />
in thp City, no Indians are going forward until<br />
('ertam points have been dedIt with.<br />
Accordmg to a tltatement published in a later<br />
issue of the l\Tatal JlIfrcur!llt appearli! that the above<br />
was only II. l'umour.<br />
The statistical lltdtemen( of the Public Health<br />
Depart.ment of the Borough of Durban tor the<br />
montb of November 192,1 gives the followmg iniormation<br />
:-<br />
During the month th· total numLer of deaths<br />
among the Borough resiJenls was 136 comprised of<br />
Asiatio 38, Europ€'an 58, Coloured 9, Native 31, the<br />
death rate per 1000 being 2K24. 13.68, 24.16 and<br />
9.75 respectively as against 13.0, 8.53 (Euyo. & Col.)<br />
and 12.1 in the previous yelu'._<br />
Births registered during November 192,1 were as<br />
follows :-Asiatic 73 comprising of 42 male and 31<br />
ft'male, European 77 comprising of 38 male and 39<br />
female, Coloured 5 comprilling of, 3 male and 2<br />
female, Native 3 comprising of 1 male and 2 ft'riuue.<br />
Birth rate being respectively 52.88. 18.89. 13.14, 1.02.<br />
There were 15 notified cases ot infectious disease<br />
during the same month of 15 ASiatic as against 32<br />
European, ;, Coloured and 23 Native.<br />
The revenue rect'ivl'ld from Lhe Dluban Indun Mar-~<br />
kel durmg the month of November 1!l24 was<br />
-1;:841-10-0 which in comparison With the same<br />
month last year shows '1 increase of t112-6-2.<br />
The particulars of the rec 'pts are as follows:<br />
Stalls £5;}2, Stands 1:75. l:) "\tters £1-!.J, Baskets;<br />
£131-7, Carts £4X-17. Tran~fer s £32-17.<br />
. ,~<br />
The Borouj,{h :rolice_~tIDJ:lht s. Ol't shows<br />
that 81 In~i~pj.,.l.tJ;~)!;Ulope~ns aud j( ~tiyeS<br />
were, proceedl'(t7a~mst durmg the mon~<br />
}l'ovembel' 1921 for conhaventions of the BOl'ough<br />
By-Ia\\s. The lollowing aI'l" some of the c~ntraventiOllS<br />
and the number of Europeans, Inlh.ms and<br />
Nat.lves dt'al{ \~j,th :-<br />
NOTES'AND NEWS<br />
q,~<br />
Animals, CI'ueIty to<br />
Breach of Peace<br />
Drunkenness<br />
Gambling<br />
"<br />
E.<br />
1<br />
1<br />
30<br />
I.<br />
~<br />
7<br />
19<br />
Licence Defaulters 1 10<br />
Obstructmg Police 1 1<br />
Registration of Native!:! 10 2<br />
Sanitary... 3 17<br />
Traffic<br />
Shqp Hours' Act<br />
1<br />
:1<br />
:3<br />
2<br />
N.<br />
6<br />
74<br />
59<br />
1<br />
3<br />
2<br />
127<br />
11'<br />
IS<br />
Motor Car Coutraventions 40 6· 11<br />
Other ContraventIOns 6:3 27<br />
The amount of fines and bails pind to thf> Town<br />
Treasurer durlllg the month was £532-15-5, being<br />
. a decrease of £214-3-!l. as compared with rthl'<br />
COl respondmg month of last year. There was also a<br />
decrease of 360 in the number of CdSes dealt with.<br />
Dut'jng the month of November 1924 the Durban<br />
CorporatIOn received £4909-9-3 as revenue {I'om<br />
BeeI' sold to NatIves -aUlI £271:3-7-0 was received<br />
from trailing With Natives in the different Eating<br />
Houses, Location, B.l!'racks etc, accommodatIOn<br />
given to N.ltlves ill the ditl'eren~ BarrackR, LocatIOn<br />
and Native Women's Hostel, Licences given to<br />
Rickshd pullers. Washmen etc. and from Registration<br />
of Natives. ' Tl1e tot.tl revenue r.eceived during<br />
the month of November 1924 was, thel'efore,<br />
£7622-16-3,<br />
The following anpears in the InwrlU'twnat -dd.tell<br />
Jan, 9:-<br />
.. The latetit example of callous brutality to a<br />
native servant comes from the Free State. A farmer<br />
suspecting a native of theft tied him to his horse<br />
and pl'oceeded to take him to the police station. The<br />
horse, it IS s.Litl, thl'('w the farmer and galloped oft.<br />
dragging the unfortunate native along the ground,<br />
and when -cut loose the boy died. It is probable<br />
that this brulal act wIll be hushed up, as so many<br />
similar cases have been before, but i~ IS not snrprising<br />
that the cumulative effect of these frequent<br />
tragedies is to widen -the gulf between the natives<br />
and whites of South Africa. Common decency<br />
demands that an enquiry shall be conducted into<br />
the wholeaft'dll' by some 'outside impartial authOrity.<br />
and not left in the hands of the local authorities ...<br />
who tslr obvious reasons caunot be expected to gI\'e<br />
an unbidSed Judgmenl. "<br />
At a meeting of the Turfl'ontein Ratepayt:rs' Association<br />
it was announced (says the Johannesburg<br />
cOITespondent ot the NfS/f4l .UerrUT!/), tb.lt Dr. ~falaD<br />
had -consented to receive a dep.tation from,p "v~,:I<br />
Southern Europ~~tioD to discuss the A~~,;<br />
ques~on. 'Un!' PreSident of the lat~r body Et~;ll " "We<br />
AsiatIc qlleEtlou W.lS gettmg' so bIg that..a," level,<br />
afraid it was too l:>ig for the Governmen t ji-", [he same<br />
I Ira' .<br />
-"Inly be sohed by the peOI' e. , ; .;/<br />
---..to"- :/ :;WW WHITE<br />
_ One of ,l-,e spe~h!.~. at, til". l1li.f, .... ~ickett;n6<br />
porWtt to h,\Vt;, .:."'t~ t~'l,.t~].U
14 iNDIAN OPINION January 16th. 19 2 5<br />
--------~----~~-------.--------------~---~~~~~<br />
make theIr mOltey go as far as It could. anI,ll Emau~ Abdurahman Gamieldie:q,<br />
a,t p!:esent, in Qah:o, to t:Q.e effect that the<br />
Caliphate C9mmitt.ee at Cl;l,i,o would be very pleased<br />
to receive ~legates ¥om t,l;te Ctlpe to the Caliphate<br />
Conference at
J_anuaiy ~~h, ·1925_____<br />
I_N_D_l_A.Nr-0_P_J-:N..::..tO..:..:..:N ________--.:.:I5<br />
~'. A MESSAGE FROM MR. POLAK<br />
. Whilt> going to press we have received the follow.<br />
". ing letter from Mr. H. S. JA Polak :_ '<br />
To the Editor, •• INDlAN OpIl'nON, "<br />
Sir,-I have only just learnt of the passing away<br />
of my dear old friend. Parst>e Rustomjee. But<br />
though he hlUl disappeared in the flesh, the real<br />
Rustomjee still lives, and will live in our hearts so<br />
~ng all we have remembrance. He was an<br />
affectionate and loyal friend and coIleguE', and one<br />
of the bI".1vCI!t and truest men r have known~ How<br />
South African Indians will pursue their taBk of<br />
cOlnmlln&l defence without his daily physic.11<br />
pretrence tQ cheer and encourage them, I cannot say.<br />
But the pr~sent position is so desperate that I feel<br />
that, in the spirit of Parsee Rustomjee's courage and<br />
sacrifice, the people should organise their forces to<br />
resist the encroachments that now threaten them so<br />
formidably. It is the day of the younger· men, of<br />
the new generation, and particnlarly the Colonialbortl,<br />
to take inspiration from Parsee Rnstomjee's<br />
Ilplendidly vigorous exampl'~, and do their duty to<br />
the community as selflessly and whole·b.eal'tedly as<br />
he ever did hill, Salvation lies in self.help. Tt:af.<br />
was always his ('reed, and only by recoguising its<br />
truth and following this doctrine will outside help<br />
be forthcoming and effective.<br />
Yours truly.<br />
n. S. 1.. POLAK.<br />
Bombay, Dec. tS.<br />
SAI.E OF CORPORATION LAND<br />
INDIANS DERARRED<br />
We take the- following from the. report of the<br />
Finance Committee of the Dnrban Town Council of<br />
its. Jru>eting held on. j;he 18th DecembeJr 1924 at<br />
which. were puesent: Councillors Johnstone (Vice<br />
Chairman, in the chair), Burma{lJ, Kemp, Shearer~<br />
Hutt, Buzzaru. Eaton, Brisker, Mrs. Benson anw the<br />
Mayor, an(l also, present Councillor Mrs. Kuight<br />
and! Smith :-<br />
On.'. the Sth Novembe;r, 1924:. at a sale of leasehold<br />
properties, the lease qf IJol! 11, Block B. -Point. was<br />
submitted to, pUblic eompetition, on the application<br />
of Messl's. Sparks & Young, Ltd. This lbt is sitl1atecl'<br />
at the COl'n~r of Southamption' Street and Albert.<br />
Roold. The fixed rental was £-12 pel,"- annum and<br />
_ the upset bcmus £5. 'rhs bonus was bid up to £110.<br />
at which figu1:e the' apphcanb3 dropped out and left<br />
the bid with Mr. Sorabjee Rustomjee, acting ·on<br />
behalf of 1\1008a Ismail & Co~, of 175, Grey Street.<br />
The purchaser was then notified that the Vendue<br />
lWll could not be signed until the authol.ity of the<br />
'l'own Council had been obtained.<br />
Section 2 of the conditions of sale reads as<br />
follows :-<br />
.. No person will be accepted or recognised<br />
who is in arrear with, Corporation rents, and<br />
the Town Council reserves- the right to cancel<br />
the Sc'l.le in any case where a person sha.ll bid<br />
for himself, or on behalf of any principal<br />
w hom the Town Council may be- un willing to<br />
aocept as Lessee. ..<br />
. •<br />
The- matter wal> refu ... Q".~ to the Town Solicitors<br />
for their advice as to the Ooili..~l's authority under<br />
the above condition, and they a
,6 INDIAN OPINION .<br />
January 16th, 1925<br />
at sOllle futUre date without the complicating in<br />
feeling and rdcial antagonism arousel! by the Bill<br />
itself.<br />
We Indians have a short memory. 'l'he announcement<br />
of Mr. Thomas though it was practically the I<br />
same as that of the Duke of Devonshire did not<br />
arouse even one-hundredth part of the indignation<br />
aroused by the White Paper. If after three years a<br />
sort of mildly-worded Indian Immigration Bill is<br />
tJassed in Kenya it will not cause any agitation<br />
here. For the Present the Indian people in Kenya<br />
and India may well go to sleep comfortably assured<br />
that the Immigration Bill has been killed. They<br />
will wake up some day to realIse that it was not the<br />
Indian ImD;ligration Restriction Bill that was killed<br />
by :Mr. Tholnas but it,was the Indian agitatioJ;l, for<br />
, equal rights in Kenya!<br />
Indians read a dlfl'erent meallill:
January 16th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 17<br />
:n, llay after da\', an.l he nevt'l' ilhrunk hack from<br />
the !lUl'tIN"<br />
l'arsi Hustomjec'i1 generosity Wll.tl great. llUI silent<br />
charity towards individuals exceeded even his public<br />
beni'factior,s. The library, which he built in Durban,<br />
was only one of the many tributes of his love \for tbe<br />
whole Indian commnnity, When I was with him in<br />
, !I2(), he waR tht'n t'arneatly !leeking for tIle best means<br />
of 11sing the money which he bad saved in business,<br />
for the intereRif! of the public. Att.his time, he went'<br />
over in his mind many plans with me. He had also"<br />
tiej('rmined to do what' he could for the cause of<br />
freE-dom in his motherland, India. Yery slowly,<br />
bis mind was mad I:' up; h~ gavp his gifts judici'onsly<br />
anl\ with the greatest care, not recklessly and in<br />
a f!plendid manner,<br />
When I was returning to South Africa, after<br />
many years' ahsencl:', the one person to whom my<br />
hl:'art most turned, with the eagerness of long.<br />
expecW wE-leome, was Parsee Rustomjee. My (lwn<br />
dear friend, Willie Pearson, had wished to co\De<br />
out with me again, but he had been prevented. He<br />
had a special place of affection in Parsee Rustom.<br />
jee's heart. After speaking of Mahatma Gal1f1hi and.<br />
asking aftE'J' hill hl:'altb, it was Willie Pearson's<br />
name which .came next in his enquiries, when 'We<br />
met. If Willie had been ali ve to·day, his grief, at<br />
the deaHI Of. Parst'e Rustomjee would have no less<br />
than my own; for he loved him very deeply iq<br />
return, and l1I~erl to speak to me constantly about<br />
),lim.<br />
One ~weat event stood out in Parsee Rustomjee's<br />
life and made it what it was. This was his. devotion<br />
to Mahatma Gaudhi. He owed to him more than<br />
any -one eIRe his powers of sacrifice. For, apart<br />
from Mahatma Gandhi, he might indeed. have been<br />
a generotls lDerchant, but he would hardly have<br />
reached thE' h('.ights of sacrifice and devotion in his<br />
cOllniry's ('~nule wh,ich he· actually attained. He<br />
""118 a trnllted cOftlt'ad,,"--and fwend,of lIlahatmajee<br />
throughout the wholo South African struggle; and<br />
it was this friendship that maqe bim rise to heroic<br />
deeds. Of all th(\ friends that M:.hatma Gandhi had<br />
with him during the passive resistance mbvement,<br />
WiUl its imprisonments and hardships innumerable,<br />
Parsee Rustomjee was among the most faithful and<br />
most truE'.. \<br />
======<br />
TllE WAY TO PEACE<br />
Not to him who falters, not to him who fears,<br />
Doth the visiol\ splEC'ndid flash across the years.<br />
Not by him who idly dr~s a dream of good<br />
Oan the great world problem e'er bE! nndEC'rstood.<br />
Toil and high endeavour, head and band and heart,<br />
Unto noble iasues lIoU must do their part.<br />
For the liation's healing, for the gift of peacEC',<br />
Bl'otherhood must conquer, hate and discord cease.<br />
Who with cheerful COUl"dge strives the wrong to right<br />
'Mid the deepest Slllldows shetIs a ray of light.<br />
He, who danger scorning. leads a hope forlorn,<br />
Oth('l' hearts inspiring ope's t1}e gates of morn.<br />
Selfish aims must perish, trutll anu righteonsness<br />
Build on !'lure foundations a\l man¥ind to bless.<br />
Sacrifice and service still for aye most be<br />
Unto allUfe's problems the one golden key!<br />
ANNIE E. WOODCOCK.<br />
By the ~ourtesy of UnilPl.l Empire.<br />
.<br />
It was not; declarfd the Bishop of Limerick (Most<br />
Rev. Dr. Keane), thfoo.gh the operation of a great<br />
al'my or navy that they were going to cut a figure<br />
in the world, nut through Chrisian ideals anti.<br />
pricciph's. which mU!lt he manife&tt'd in the doml:'s~<br />
t.ic, S0cial. and national life of the people: '<br />
Plinted and Publiah'eoi. 'b, Manilal M, Gandhi at l'~<br />
'ctt-.a." .. b.-uta. ~_l.<br />
Business for Sale<br />
l::IighJy profitable Confectio nary and Grocery<br />
in a busy locality. A snip. Long lease whole<br />
of rent returned from subletting, Owner<br />
going to Europe. Purchaser must have<br />
£750 cash. No agents. Apply:<br />
[9, Market Street, Johannesburg.<br />
l<br />
~f:tt~~f<br />
«l~~<br />
.n~rti ~~i!l d~~ ~ ~lUi(t 9l1~1'~· "ll:tl<br />
b1lrt ~.:4l~ \R~ a~l!!· ~l ~!r' ~~~<br />
,~~ ·~·oll~ ~l~~l ~WU ~::t 'ldlrtl ~~t1!-.<br />
~la~lti :tl.9l~ li('U ~w.u.~. rt!-l~ wlo:ta<br />
~'ll~L qL~~ ~ lrltdl ~'U(d ~ltl~~' GV~·<br />
U ~::t quQ a lt~l!J'l::t ~~t1 h(l
a<br />
9<br />
P<br />
Ii<br />
o<br />
"P<br />
iii ii, " ....... A -)fill<br />
!:l ,., .t1 -'{,j'qi'l..\<br />
·s<br />
~ SY!SlJ3AO PUll NOINn 3Hl !(lIS1nO<br />
L A[.rna.\.-n1!H<br />
n<br />
At-I1!a..!.<br />
Oil '"l" > : NOIRfl aHl NIHII.M<br />
°S;)l8H DOJldp:)sqnS<br />
II NQINJdQ NHIONI;,<br />
I , -,<br />
n.-~ ?1-h<br />
}h-~ £l1.-h<br />
:?h.-\ 'n-h<br />
'h-\ 'n1.-h i<br />
;'h-~<br />
n<br />
h.1<br />
,R.1.<br />
n<br />
',R.1.-11. I H<br />
~h.-\ n-hl \1.<br />
07h.-\ \U-h.; ~1.<br />
I -I<br />
./ lit of j°Ut •<br />
, ,<br />
.Ii I 1.~1:1.<br />
\'l: £1<br />
h'l: H<br />
1.1: 01.<br />
" IH<br />
,1. 'l:<br />
" 10 'l:<br />
n l'j<br />
" \~\<br />
e'l: ] " '1<br />
H- 6'1 ,. 16'11.<br />
0): % Yb\n<br />
cml~<br />
l;l]1'\VI<br />
f:,R.t\<br />
l;.l~<br />
I<br />
-1l}1~ I<br />
l-t~~l<br />
\H\ \h.1:~\\<br />
"~'!:-~ fb"!:-~; ~c'1I. ""k~~f:t 3~ I~~<br />
e 0<br />
\ \<br />
o e<br />
£" 1:<br />
~ \<br />
e ],<br />
o ],<br />
\ e<br />
., ~<br />
o<br />
,R.<br />
o \<br />
., \<br />
~ p<br />
\ ],<br />
., I.<br />
, \.<br />
.. e<br />
o ],<br />
o 0\<br />
\ \<br />
o ~<br />
., \<br />
., ],<br />
\ .<br />
\ \<br />
~ .,<br />
•<br />
l}rt0 ll'Vl1l. "'1a'~11.1~<br />
~rc<br />
I::fQ<br />
1»le1;t<br />
l\'~<br />
lPC<br />
U-"<br />
.1\<br />
ell><br />
SCfilR: }'~ ?~,~<br />
l}'tiilJ:l!'e Ilt)l'lt~<br />
C~ J1R:) " " "<br />
(l'fl fVIlf» ~ loll ~ It; t ~1<br />
"'~tii<br />
hlt~li<br />
- PltI ffifi<br />
~I~~(-\ 'tt;)1l!Iij)~ '''''I("lJI~ fi!ll~p<br />
l~lPlb fcIlc: \}'bl~lh.I(Th: ~~~ela'<br />
~Jh.R: tlft .)h7tltl~ '1fI.~<br />
- '~l?~le ''''belH><br />
"'b~l~t ,..,,It.<br />
ll-cl.: lYeh§) ~Ip~ -1l-1l}tcUc<br />
t" ~I~ lil}>'lt. 'tlp Ill\}(<br />
4? l' Idle (~ ~1lt. hoI'll. Wi. 'o~)<br />
~ ... Idle ~fcI~ 1~ ~?'lft<br />
,<br />
el]:>I'lt tlft: ~fQ<br />
U'lbl}lt<br />
llt~<br />
ljl-t\U' \y1~ft-~.~ t?'l!:<br />
(l.-'II'lJ U~~) 1Ih..t: ll'!i!~<br />
It.lJrJh t~ pH,<br />
e'h:l-d t~ Plt. Il>!i~\)l el1l1c.tc 1D'ltl<br />
(lltt}.~J) ~I( I, ll" tl~ fu" It.lc ll~ijt~fJ<br />
l-lbh oJ;e~~<br />
l>'I1-,tt<br />
M!~"<br />
l-I?l!i ''''.!jlr<br />
o 1.<br />
~!i l}'tlPJt)~ ~~<br />
~ 1.<br />
U-lhl~~h. };'1};'1fI~<br />
\ 11.<br />
" •• 1}JI'>!.At.rc 16-tr)c~<br />
\ 11.<br />
l}H~ 7U~ n-~~ \}'I'>!hft<br />
o e<br />
" .. ijt.l-1R:<br />
- ---------- ---<br />
St61 'l{191 A.nmu~f<br />
~ ~<br />
~ ~<br />
~ \<br />
o \<br />
~ 0<br />
% 0<br />
~ e<br />
~ e<br />
6 t!<br />
\ \<br />
, t.<br />
o \<br />
\ Q<br />
~ Q<br />
~ - 0<br />
~ .0<br />
~ 0<br />
~ .,<br />
\ .0<br />
.<br />
~ .0<br />
\<br />
" \<br />
\ .0<br />
.0 \<br />
.t - ~<br />
~ \<br />
,R. •<br />
~ .<br />
~ ~<br />
~ ~<br />
2 ~<br />
? \0<br />
\ \. -<br />
\ \.<br />
0 E'<br />
" ,<br />
\ ,R.<br />
~ e<br />
o<br />
e<br />
~ .0<br />
o<br />
e<br />
~ e<br />
o<br />
e<br />
\ .0<br />
o \<br />
~ \<br />
\ I.<br />
JIjI 0<br />
\ \<br />
\ -\<br />
-? \<br />
, .<br />
NOINldO NVlaNI<br />
:nnnt<br />
..<br />
"<br />
l~~<br />
l~\1h."<br />
" "'"<br />
" 1]10<br />
" l}th:lh.<br />
"<br />
"<br />
~1JG<br />
a~<br />
\J~I~ ~~l\<br />
~h!~b lP'eh~<br />
'ltl~>I:<br />
, ~H. lflh~ ~I~ I~nl!f<br />
]..\J,<br />
..... e " " " "<br />
1~ 1. IclH> "'1~ l;~lltl1-C ~l8 htll;.l~<br />
~ -- e 'tlH> 'I ,,-.,<br />
~~" " ""<br />
h~J;ffi: '1:::~~ 1l;.llt<br />
Itlhlf) I~I~I~?:<br />
lfl~l-hW;<br />
'~P.li& ~ I"'~ t~ hleln..tfi<br />
- \11H»~ l}'~ 1:::ke 1l;.ll1b ''t\)lh.~ elfl6-<br />
7J111c 'iljC~"t<br />
I~ 1. fcllf) iJl!l? .fCl}-;C..f.t ~?~<br />
h-:.lll \"'v..~<br />
lGh 1'J::l.11.. R:~'( 1-1~lt l!.)tt 3~~ li~<br />
.;t. o~'h<br />
71i~ R:,b~ h.lli };'11o.R:!1<br />
" ''If nfi' l'i1h<br />
~:ffi.l> )I,l! 1~ 1)-n'h. lh:llf<br />
1}r.' It l)A It R:"1l<br />
1c1~ ;)ltlI<br />
Unl"'!!'tte '\JUt ;'Melt> ;'It.~<br />
Jltph,~<br />
tiilPUc<br />
'lc:lh \}'~omlt)l§, I::'tte Rlb~ 11:::b~llt~<br />
~~0R:<br />
tlR: '''''\J?) ,,'fQ<br />
p~~<br />
\}'I~~<br />
lPre~rc l}hll' ~~)<br />
~1'j}li\<br />
itq"<br />
1c o<br />
t}1l<br />
la-~b<<br />
lPO<<br />
\}>~Iblel!f<br />
~~ \t11 ~~<br />
ftl}' ft 'tfVII llt 11'lt lie<br />
~ e 1cl~ " "<br />
I~ 1. 1!;1~ R:I'~(-\ 't'~~ 1fi!ll\Iffi:<br />
1M \}>U~l'h. Ill/Iii<br />
\}'11'ti~, \}>tiilJ:I1'c<br />
W h 11lQ th--IM;~<br />
,..~1ti<br />
\ll~<br />
~h hl(~<br />
8 1
NO.4-Vol. XXII 1. Friday, Janu.l.ry 23rd, [9~5.<br />
•<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
R.egl",tered at the G. P.O. 8S a Newspaper<br />
PRICS FouRFEMes<br />
------- ------------<br />
'7"~<br />
HE Indwl Milling FederatIOn have made a JOMllneaburg MuniClpality at cost of £21,000 for<br />
11<br />
Htrolll,( represenwtion to the Govel'l1ment ot the creatIOn of a township for Coloured people<br />
India on the subject of the recent purchase ant! ASIatics.<br />
of GO,OOO tons of Honth Atrican coal for the Sukkur<br />
Barrage requirements. The letter RdYS that the actIOn<br />
of authl.ntlf's IS franght With lI11pOI tant considerations<br />
of publiC policy and not only constitutes an outrage<br />
on the 'Inrli,U} coal indubtl y~ but an insult of the<br />
Inllian r4egisiaLure which pas~cd the l'e801utIOn<br />
,urging a countervailing duty on South African coa!.<br />
and is a flagrant VIOlation of the Government's<br />
/Jecl.lred intention that )Jothing wouhl be ,lone<br />
,to tliJ'f'ctly 8t1l11111.IOO fOI'dgn coal g:unlTlg adlhtlOnal<br />
/" promoters of lhe<br />
schE'me that the Zulu people w'onld conttibnte to the<br />
fund. We don't think so. It is suggested thRt the<br />
Princ{1's ownershi~ of ground ill Zululand woulll<br />
illiluct> 'fownshlp h.lS been made to the<br />
At the enJ of 1923, there were l,n 7,926 more<br />
women than men in the United Kingdom. an increase<br />
ot 20.IH2 over the previous year. according<br />
10 the RegIstrar General's l:;tatistIcal Review of<br />
England and Wales, just issued, which estimates<br />
the populatIOn of the UJliterl Kmgdom at the end cf<br />
last year at 41.717,100, of which 24.932,~13 were<br />
women. There were 2!l2.408 marriag6fl in England<br />
and Wales, 12,41:J brlliegrooms were bachelors<br />
under 21, and one gave hiS age as 83. The youngest<br />
married people were a wife of 15, whose<br />
husband was 16; 2G girls of 15 were married during<br />
the year, aLd one to a man of 32, and one girl of 16<br />
marfled a man of 70.-Natal adverhser<br />
--<br />
Messrs A. l:;allie and G. S. Rasdlan are duly<br />
apPointed by the Nasena Moslem School Board<br />
(Johanneshurg) to collect funds for-the School and<br />
will be leavinlo( Johannebburg on the 21th of Janua!'y<br />
on a tour of the Western and Eastern<br />
Pl'ovmces including Grtqualand West. Messrs. Hajee<br />
l\1ahomed Buddar and Mahomed Alli SahIb will at<br />
a later date toUI' the Natal Pl·ovince.<br />
It is earnestly<br />
hopell by the Board that the above gentlemen will<br />
be grven the support that the cause deserves.<br />
----->--<br />
From January to September. 1921, there were<br />
1,4a3 msolvencies in the Union, as against 1,669 in<br />
the tirst Illlle m~mths of ) !l2.t There were decl'eases<br />
11\ all the Pl'ovinces, but 1Il the case of the Cape and<br />
NatA there wele mcrew;es m the number of Asiatic<br />
c~s. ~<br />
The occupations of lllsolventi:! showed that in the<br />
Union, durmg the -period January to September,<br />
192-1, there was a decrease in the commercial. Pl'OkSlllonal.<br />
,lgl·jcultural, and miscellaneous groups,<br />
and .an mCl ease in the industrial and wage-earners<br />
groups. The agricultural ~'fOup tohowed lower insolvency<br />
figures 1ll each of the Provinces, the commercl,,1<br />
group showed an increase in Natal and the<br />
Orange FJ'ee Stelle. ant) in the wage-earners group a<br />
considerable increase in the Transvaal and a slight<br />
inclease in the C,lpe.<br />
A mCf'ting of bet" ('en -J ,noo and 5,000 non-Europeam;<br />
ill reported to hJvt' beeD hpld 011 the Gr,lDd<br />
Par,hle, Capetown, last Hunday. It was addressed<br />
by Prof. James Thae1e. president of the Cape Afri·<br />
• can National Con!,'fess 1ll the Western, Proviu' w<br />
when a'solutlOns well' p.lilsed urging the GOY • Ie<br />
ment til 1 1 1 t " I " "eve<br />
111110< Ut(, t'l-'1to ,1 IOn ma ,mg 11lal'I1fh I<br />
'<br />
l\\lPIl ,\hite :llHl bl.tek people J\I;>g,II, I~ e same<br />
.1galJt~t Ill(' inbo\lnt tHIJI nl tll(' par,.; laY'<br />
to nnmdllleu KatiYe "nm('ll, aUtI uri /;f{()P 'V/lITE<br />
('rument to mtrodJl(e a BIll restrif"<br />
alcohohc drinks to Natives regist~ pickf'ttin;; of the
20 INDIAN OPINION January 23rd, 1925<br />
------~~----------------------~.-----------------~-----<br />
THAT ROlTXD TABLE CO:-l"FEHENCE<br />
fI""\ll; UIXl4 :"1t'" ~.\l'O ,m Xd),lu., \ iSlt to South<br />
ll.,~U AtJlca m the begllllllug ot l""t yeal' atter<br />
grnng mto the IlHh.m 'qtH:dtIOll tully With<br />
the Ulllon 1'Ihmsteu-l a &nggestlOll WdS made by her<br />
that .1 Round 1"tble COlltel'C'nce, constituted of l'epl'eilentatI\'es<br />
of the Lmon Pdllldmcnt, reples~ntaliyes<br />
of Imha .lll,l ot the ltllh.tn Government and<br />
rel)l'eilentahvcs ot lhe In(lhl1l colUmunity of South<br />
Afnca shoulol be callpd tf) lhscnss the whole queshon.<br />
In wh,lt light the snggestIOn was taken by<br />
Genc).d Smtlb ,\110 W,IS thf'n ,It the heaJ. of the<br />
GOVe'I ntll~'nt wa., not q LUte de,t!' but no note of<br />
1't'sentme1t \Ias i'tltull1erl b, the Government. or the<br />
EUlopean l'ress Slllce then, howevel" a sudden<br />
change was eiJ:ectod in the Government-which<br />
change has so LIt' not been for the better tor any<br />
sectIon of the cOllunlluity ,md ct·rtamly not for, the<br />
• Indi.m cOl11m11Inty who hal'\' 11,111 hittpr experience<br />
01 It all ('rt,!\'-and that GOyernlllPl1L has not con<br />
!:l],1t;>1 ellll Mhlsable to follow any precedents but<br />
bas hM1Il~ own way, Hl d.E'dlmg "ith questIOns, as it<br />
W
INDIAN OPiNtON<br />
Municipal Franchise which "'£IS guaranteed to the<br />
• Indians at the time they were deprived of Parliamentary<br />
franchise committed a breach of faith that<br />
willl'esult in grave dl:laster to the Indldn population<br />
of South Africa mostly local bot'n." Suppol'lin~ all<br />
this is true, and we believe it is true, and nothmg<br />
but the truth, what of thdt ? What mattels It if there<br />
is a breuh of faith or "here IndlJ.ns are concerned<br />
there is a dowm ight breac.,h of all the commandiDents<br />
from the Bible: Indeed. thiS is not the first<br />
instance ont of many when the South Afri~n Government<br />
haH openly dn.l in a IllObl ::;hdllle-faced<br />
manher broken faith "ith the Imharus. To dll<br />
intents and purpOSNi it might be truly fklid tlMt<br />
!loath African Indian history II! a long recoill of<br />
broken promiscs and a long scrie8 of breaches of<br />
faith. One lnore anel one lebs makeR no diffel€'nce<br />
wbatsoevel'. ' Mr. Polak points ~nt that the new<br />
measure will degrade the Stdtus of Natal Infiians by<br />
depriving thcm of civic rights long exercise.!,<br />
wllilst it will take all hope tlOIll the 'l'lallsvaal India'n~<br />
who uo not po~'!e;;l'l thlS franchlse dnu will<br />
arouse the utmost aLu'ni among the Cape Indians<br />
\\ ho do. The exerCHle of the Natal ~IllIlldp,II fl"cJtchisc<br />
was the only Wt'dpon even p,utially eftedl\e<br />
tQ proteLt Indian trdlhng I'lghbl agamst the lllunidpalities<br />
tb"t have been seeking theIr UClltructlOll'<br />
AU this means tbdt IudJaDH in South AfIiea WIll no<br />
longer Le h'ed.teu a;; human belllgs lJ\lt as sdvages<br />
and benats, Deprived long ago of parlidlllenldrr<br />
franchise and now being depl'lved ot municlp.ll<br />
rights, they are rendered absolntely dumb, only fit,<br />
tQ be driven by theIr domineenng masters, The<br />
passing of the new Drdinance makes the Indian!>'<br />
position wOJ'se than mere words conld adequately<br />
describe. King Stork who sncceedeu King Log'<br />
(indeed. he was anything but a log) has £It last<br />
shown his own hand, He has struck and struck<br />
l'lome. What will the Indians do? But above all<br />
what will the Indian Government t10? Will the<br />
latter eat the humble pie and thus show that it is<br />
in reality a subol'dltlutf' branch of the Brltlsh Governmedt<br />
or will it take up cudgels for the Indians in<br />
'~' right earnest and stand up for Indians' rigLts ?<br />
SUGGEHTED ROUND TABLE CONFERENCl'~<br />
A reCl'nt uumber of Net" IlIIlvt (Ma.has) h,\I:I th('<br />
folJowmg IC'ading arLicle Ull Il1lh;'l\~ 1Il tiouth<br />
.\fflca,-<br />
Speaking at UIlI Abicdll ~oclety DIIIUel, ~Ir, J,<br />
11. Thomas, t'x-\:.:t'cI'et,\I'~· llf Hl.th· i'm' thf'l ('01001"",<br />
JD tile Laboul' Govorlllllt'llt, 1'>1,1tctilhat whell be WaS<br />
in l:;oulh Africll, he h"tl otlici.llly sugge"ted " H.OllUJ.<br />
T"bIo Coufel'enco of repl'csent.ltives of the Imperlcll<br />
Goverument, South Africa and Imhll to wscntlll tilt'<br />
In~idll question, emp~a.'1isillg th~t it was ~mpos"lbk<br />
to dhorce that questIOn from Its Impel'l.-I1 aspect.<br />
The reference to this wide I' aspect might evoke the<br />
suspicion that Gn'at Britain desirell to mterfefe<br />
with the Unioll Government't! uecision oJ} a questIOn<br />
which was exclusively uomestic in char,lcter. But<br />
it is rot tQ be supposed that Mr, Thomas meant anything<br />
of the kind. What he appal'ently wauted to<br />
be understood as saying was that t'ach of the Dominions<br />
had an Indian problem, ilwJuumg Grt'.lt<br />
nritain in its Colonies. anu that d. pohcy hold to be<br />
evolved which woul\l enable a pe.'lce~ul anu lastiug<br />
solution to be arrIved at. It lS clear fro!?<br />
'his Bloemfontein speech that he -wl"hed thIS<br />
, fmln on policy t~ ~e bas~d on a ,iust r('coglliho~ of<br />
dian rights of Cltlzenshlp. It IS some weeks smce<br />
, {e SUggestion was ~aoile:, but we have, not ~eal'd<br />
,ything about it elthf:.r lD India or from ::sol~th<br />
frica It is a pity th,\t Ult'lllbers ot the E:-.pcutJve<br />
I ouncils do not t,\}w the public into th~'J1' l'ollti,leUl:e.<br />
flveu on the Ulost mgent pI'oUlem8, \Hth the re"ult<br />
n~at misIinaerstcmding fr6quC'ntly .mses lwtwe('n !ht><br />
eopl@ and the Government, the tor mel' Sl1Spectlllo<br />
~<br />
that everythlllg that can be done III not being done •<br />
and the latter contenting themselves WIth their<br />
own self-Sdtisfaction at their duties well and duly<br />
perfol'Dleu, If we had Responsible Government,<br />
then mE'mbers of the Cabinet woald bE> obliged to<br />
tell thelr constItuents as to the developments in<br />
nohcws, an,l they woulu-get to know how the pubhc<br />
Vlt>WS the contemplated measures. Thls advantage<br />
is entIrely absent nnder the present system of<br />
worklllg in secret We have no news from South<br />
Ah iea either about the attitude of the Xationahst<br />
Government towards the proposal tor holding a<br />
Round Table Confel'ence, What little we know is<br />
to the effect that the authorities intend to bring fo\,<br />
warll a Bill for further l'estricting the nghts of Inlhant!,<br />
India has nothmg to lose by .such a conference,<br />
it possesses already the moral support of the<br />
Impel'ial Conference, and is prepared to argue out<br />
her eIl"e agam bE'iore any tril.unal. The hesitation<br />
of !:Iouth Africol IS due to its unwillingness to diseu&S<br />
the eluestlOn. but we hope that SaroJlnl Den'"<br />
optimism regdl'lhng South Africa wIll be JustIfied<br />
by-HI! d.greeing to meet and have d frank. free and<br />
tull tollk. General Smutll, it will be remembered,<br />
tlle,llo VelSllddc the last Imperial COllfN'ence to<br />
cancel the resolutIOn on equality ddopted at the<br />
t:esslOli held 1Il 1~121. Indld would be pleased. If the<br />
present Prime :\lim,,!cr ",onM have the long-stand<br />
Illg elispute Ilettled by lllutual :tl'rangemt>nt aud<br />
accOInmodatlon,<br />
VERENIGING WHITE::; AT WORK<br />
We have received a leatlet from a wrlespondent<br />
£It Vereniging whIch is printed on one side in the<br />
English lan~uage awl on the other in Aflicans and<br />
is Sdid to be uistJ'lbuted broadcast in that town, The<br />
text of the leaflet IS as follows ~ -<br />
EIGHT REA'>os:'\ WHY You SHOULD SHOP WHITE<br />
1. To make the Union ol White :Man's Country,<br />
2. To maml.tlD the White Standard anLl keep<br />
lrita( t the prQBtlge of the White Races,<br />
,3, Bec,mse the European CIrculates money aud<br />
i~ ,In aflset to the Nation, whereas the Indian<br />
1:0('11,1>, Illll lll"IH'Y to India, allli has Il6.I P{'l'-<br />
1U.JIlt,Ut iukll'bt 111 is, Al l'ic..! ,<br />
4, The WI111e :-\t.)r .. 1:oepe1' filld:; ell11Jloyment<br />
tor yOUl' cllIldn'll ,It st..Ulddl'd rate of par.<br />
\\ herem! the Imh,tO employs only IndldnB,<br />
& pays thelll the lowest Id.tes of wdges.<br />
,j, 10U Uldy thUlk you Cdn t.J.lk to ,m IndIan as<br />
dn mferlOl', but when you buy from him<br />
) 011 treat him as an equal.<br />
G. You don't ,tllow IndidDs to traLle by your<br />
side in trades and professions, therefore why<br />
support them at the expense of White<br />
Traders ;;<br />
i, If you want a job you- don't ask an Inwan<br />
for it .uo natuT'dlly it is beneath your dignity<br />
to wOlk fol' him, Why not also make it<br />
beneath your rugnity to buy from ,hun r<br />
~. If ASiatics .ire supported much longer "we<br />
shMI eventu,llly come down to their level.<br />
and a white man cannot live on the sam.,<br />
economIc st.mdal'll rt.~ an ASlanc, - -<br />
Tl1l~K WIILT!'; .\C'l' WHI fE. !:IltelP "'lUTE<br />
AU'oJ dlllg to the correspon(lt>nt pickt>tt;n~ of the<br />
IndIan shOl;;' is aLo threatened.
22<br />
-- ,<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
INDIA AND ~NDIANS IN THE COLONIES<br />
f,waraJya (Madras) wrItes as follows .-<br />
The position of Indians abroad is one of acute<br />
politieal and SOCIal subservience which has not Improved<br />
with the make-believes of post-war state<br />
craft. All agItation for better status in this con<br />
J;lection has in IndIa been necessarily handicapped<br />
by distance and the accidents of the political situation.<br />
Even these, however. could not totally blunt<br />
the edge of natIOnal resentment at the degrading<br />
treatment meted out to Indians abroad. We are<br />
familiar with the widespread outbursts of protest<br />
and;mger whlCh like a conflagration have time and<br />
again lighted up the sensibilities of vast masses WIth<br />
rage and\ humiliation. Such demonstrations have,<br />
as was natural, welled up to the surface, m the wake<br />
of some perpetrated Insult more outrageotls and unbearable<br />
than its Predecessors. About' the real<br />
tenour of IndIan opinion as regards tbe lot of our<br />
fe110w-countrymen abroad tliere has never been any<br />
'occaslon fur the slIghtejlt pretext 'of doubt. 'ThIS<br />
sign of helotry wrought in the name of Empire has<br />
sunk deep mtp national consciousness and so<br />
--intensely painful is Its stI~a that we can well<br />
afford to dispense with both pr-Opaganda and<br />
demonstratIOn to keep intact the spirIt of revolt<br />
against wrong. Already, we have an abundance of<br />
thIS spirIt. The question IS, how, under Its inspIration<br />
th6> politIcal consciousness 'of the people<br />
chafing under degrading restramts, can be led into<br />
a purposeful programme. The goal IS clear; It is<br />
install the power of nationhood on a pedestal ofsuch<br />
recogmsed worth that by itself it ~an protect<br />
Indian settlers overseas from insult and outrage in<br />
the same manner in which a Frenchman or an<br />
American is immune from them. But how have<br />
the champions overseas sought so far to relate this<br />
goal ttl the means or achieving it? We'have ,before<br />
us for instance a defimte suggestIOn (rom Mr. Polak.<br />
He wants Indians to shoulder the burden of the<br />
problem by sendmg abroad social workers and<br />
teachers. 'The-suggestion visualises the urgency for'<br />
a remedy. -It is the proposal of a man whom contact<br />
with distress has whipped into a deSIre to be- up<br />
-and dOlllg. But in political! values. intense subjective<br />
einotIon, although it constitutes the motor<br />
power of reform~ does not by itself constitute the<br />
solutIon of a national problem, it has, in addition,<br />
to be related to the scheme of irksome impediments<br />
that forms for the time being, the reality to be faced.<br />
Considered in thiS light, MI'. Polak's suggestioll<br />
even,if fully acted npon can only fructify mto a<br />
mmor alleViation of a 'rQ.ajor malady. And after<br />
all, the~ilupply of workers that we have is not overabnndant,<br />
such as it is being fully absorbed by the<br />
demands oLthe internal national struggle. And tbe<br />
necessity for amelioration in the conditIon of Indians<br />
abroad is immense -indeed covering as it does<br />
almd"st the whole of the EmpIre mcluding FIji,<br />
Malaya, Ceylon, Mauritms, Kenya and South Africa.<br />
It might seem superficially a connsel of indifference<br />
but the most direct I>.pproach to the correction of<br />
Indian status abroad is the cohsolidation- of national<br />
p6wer m India,. Piecemeal constructivity can grapple<br />
wit!). local economi
January 23rd, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 23<br />
------~-----------------------~----------------------~--<br />
timid I,O()() rupcE'fl. The Magistrate declal"ed, "I<br />
have nevf'1' hf'ard of finch' hrutality in all my expt'riPllce,"<br />
and hoth the GovE'rnol" of the Colonr and<br />
Lord M!lnf'1' ('x pressed l"ej.,'1'et at the I'esult of the<br />
tl"ial.<br />
'I'he l"emarkaLle ruannel" in which these charges<br />
of homicide al"e I"educed to varring degrees of<br />
"Hurt" is best illustrated by the mORt recent case,<br />
·of which details are now available. The accused<br />
was Jaspar Abraham of 101010. and the native flogged<br />
to death was named Kitosh. The jury returned a<br />
verdict of "GflevouS Hurt," and the Judge sentenced<br />
the accused to the appropriate penalty of two years'<br />
'imprisonment. The flogging took place in June.<br />
1!l2:J, and the trinl only recently concluded. It was<br />
alleged that the Dlhn Kltosh had" ridden a mare in<br />
foal, but the Assistant Huperintendent of the Police<br />
stated that he examined the horse, but found no<br />
signs of injnry., Kitosh was thrown on the ground<br />
and then flogged by Abraham until he was too<br />
"flogged" to continue; then he called three natives,<br />
one after another, to carryon the flogging. Kit~sh<br />
was unconscious during the last flogging, but eoven<br />
thl:'n his sufferings were not ended, for upon recovering<br />
consiousnt.
INDIAN OPINION January 23rd, 1925<br />
, News in Brief<br />
Whllp performmg a gipsY dll1ce at a party, Mrs,<br />
~{al'\' P.11'fett (ag('--)J-J)"<br />
o.:J~.Jb; I,./~J-ft':' ..,.;\;'<br />
Business for Sal~<br />
Highly profitable Confectionary an~ Groc~ry ,I<br />
in '1 bus)' 1ocality. A snip. I,.ong lease whole<br />
of rent returnr:d from s'uBJetting. Owner<br />
l-!ojl1;;! to Europe. Purchaser m~st ba\,(><br />
,(.7fi'~ ,..;\~h. :-':0 Rgt'nt,~. Apply,<br />
l "~=-.--...1'..:;;'-;:;c. 0;9: !\!prf~l ~t~~:~1 "'-)!1!~~~~~~)~_";~<br />
f
ll-gis,.,eelat the G.P.O. as • N ......_<br />
• No. 5-Vol. XXIII. Friday, Janu Iry- 30th, 1925 •<br />
Pale .. f'OUR •• KCS<br />
------______________ ------------r-------------<br />
•<br />
IT<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
4r~'<br />
N an interview Lord Sinha, who, .u; Uu
Guiana, and few less developed owing to the lack of<br />
capital and population. He was glad to think that<br />
the ~overnkent and the peopl~ ot Illdla were 1)(':<br />
comin~, aware of. the fact that British Guiana<br />
provided a favourable opening for, Indians of all<br />
classes, free trom t,he political dlfficu ltles and<br />
objections which stood m the way ot emlgratlon to<br />
other parts of the Empire. LJeut Colunel Amery<br />
said he understood that the Governm~mt of IndIa<br />
were making a final investlgatlOn. Lhrongh a<br />
CommlsSlOner, into the prospecttl for Indians. He<br />
cxpressd the hop8- that the ontcome would be a<br />
steady flow of settlers, and a marked stimulus In<br />
the development of the Colony, in which he antlCipated<br />
a great development m Rugal' production and<br />
the ncc Cl'Op. The developlUg of the remarkable<br />
diamond discoverles might led,t to oLh,)]' !levelopments.<br />
.<br />
In the CouncIl of State I"ord Rawlmson, Commal1der-ll1-Chief<br />
of the Indian Army, accepted an<br />
Indlan mqtlOn nrging the British GovernIllent to<br />
remove the bar against the admission of IndIail<br />
student.'1 to the UniverSity O/fi{)er's Trallling Corps<br />
says a Renter's IJlOS8ai:le from DelhI. Thp b.lr was<br />
adopted by the ImperIal Parliament recently UII tho<br />
recommendations of the Lytton Committee.<br />
A prominent missionary m ClIina has infor'med<br />
Reuter "that the mihtary authoritieS in Fnkien are<br />
compeUillg farmers to grow opium. One thousanu<br />
nve huudred Christian families refused, and 200<br />
head of tamili(>s have b~en beheaded." Who says<br />
barbarIc days are over' They seem to us to h(' jusl<br />
beginning.<br />
The New Leader (London) While referring to the<br />
work of the tabour Party III the New ParlIament<br />
admits the fact "that the Lsbour Government dId<br />
nothiI1g eftective for Indian SPlf-government or<br />
even for the protection of Indian workers"<br />
"Even 1f It were to mean," prot:eeds the Journal,<br />
"a iJostponement of our return to office, we should<br />
disl'npate the belif'f which our inaction may have<br />
tostercd that we are sound Impenalists as other<br />
palties are." The jonrual advises the Jndipendent<br />
LaboltI' Party fo concentrate all its efforts ~n India,<br />
which it characterises as the "gravest of all OUr<br />
Imperial problems"<br />
A Laboul' Women's Conference recently held In<br />
England passed tIle tollowing resolutlOn on India's<br />
claIm to Home Ilule -That the Conference expresses<br />
the ho~e that the Government will support<br />
any turther legl!1lation in order to 'secure for the<br />
people of India the same measure of selt-Government<br />
whICh is m operation m Canada, Austraha,<br />
aml South Africa.<br />
It iii reported 1Il the recent exchanges fl'om IndIa<br />
that Mr C. R. Das has made over all hiS prO"lert18s<br />
includmg hiS present residence to a board of tJ'lIstees.<br />
The whole ebtate is to be utlhsed for charitable and<br />
philanthropic purposes after paymg off hIS (lebts<br />
Sf'cured and nnElecured Among the prmClpal<br />
purposes for which the estate IS to be tlsefl IS included<br />
the establishment of a college 101' Indian women,<br />
religlOllEi education for Rmdu boys, etc.<br />
Every Indian cannot but view WIth the greatC'tlt<br />
admnalton the great sacrifice MI. C. R. Das has<br />
made lor the sake of his country and his people<br />
Few such examples as so nobly set by Mr. C. R. Das<br />
aro to llO f\(,pn in thl' prf1st'nt t'lfisll world.<br />
INDIA:N Ol'JN ION<br />
------------------<br />
January 30th, I9~S<br />
THE ASIATlfJ PROBLEM<br />
\\ AVE reprqduce in ano)ther colnlUll all al'tHllr<br />
\1.\1 appearing in the Natal .\rel'( ttl!J Imder the<br />
nom de plnme " Townsman" on the Asiatic<br />
questlOn wherein the Writer makes SOIlle ~mggeshons<br />
as to the solutlOll of thiS burnmg qu('shon<br />
Everyone is anxIOUs to see thiS problem solved once<br />
and fo!' all and any suggestions towards that directIon,<br />
are naturally welcomed. Of cours(', a great deal ot<br />
vltuperabou lR indulged 111 by anti-ASiatICs but they<br />
hardly come fOI war,l "lth S0111(; senslblr Emggestions<br />
which woulu be worth consldel'lng. The writer<br />
of the artIcle in questlOll seems to have maue a<br />
study ot the ASiatic question an!l he deserves ('reuit<br />
for the attempt he has ma.de at suggestmg :.1. solution<br />
In our opinioll, howevet·, his suggestions are llighly<br />
selfish and narrowminded.<br />
TIlt' writer admits that the Indldll lahonrer has<br />
plaYE'd no inconSiderable part III the development 01<br />
the; various mdustries o± tIllS country He has<br />
nothmg ag,uns~ the IndlJ.n, " J,S a l,tboUler pure nu(l<br />
Simple. "<br />
He IS agamL the''' Arab trader" who, he ~ays,<br />
" had no partin the development of the muustry, but<br />
simply came along and b3,ttened on it." Then h~<br />
complainR of the competItion of the Indian WIth the<br />
European bemg unfair and" that because of hiS 1Ilfenor<br />
scale of living, IH'C8tlSltating much lowe I' expenditure,<br />
the Indian can sell his goods and labom'<br />
~,t a much lower rate than his European competitor."<br />
Now III Buggestll1g a solution the WrIteI' says,<br />
., consideratIOn of the question must be fair to all<br />
partIes." The presence of the Indtan labourer, he<br />
thmks, IS shU necossary but not tlO with the Asiatic<br />
trader, who, he sug~estfi, ShOlllrl be reasonahly compeIlBated<br />
and" he must go at all costs. "<br />
The bIggest stumbling block III the way of a<br />
settlement of this problem, howclver, appears to him<br />
in the question of the Natal-horn Indian. He<br />
admits, he eannot be depo~·ted. Bllt With regard<br />
to him he suggests, that he could be dealt With<br />
along ecouGmic lllles by forcing' hIm to adopt a<br />
hIgher standard of hvmg; but this, he says, ,. IS<br />
about as far as we can go" and suggests that It he<br />
witlhes to be repatrmted so much the better but<br />
that, if he deSires to stay 111 South Africa he must<br />
be compensated and then segregated'<br />
This is the solutIOn the Wl'lter of the article in<br />
([UesiLOn_ suggests and ad vises the legHliators not to<br />
tmker with the subject any longer but to take this<br />
drastIC measure and, "like all dl':1StlC measures,"<br />
he says, " there IllllSt be some degree of untmrness,<br />
bnt With the reasonable compensatIOn Pl'oposed the<br />
bItter pIll will be made more palatable" If this<br />
step IS not immediately t,£lken. the writer Sees war in<br />
the near future with the" yellow hords 1" He dreams<br />
of a white Sunny ~outh AfrICa and asks his fellowmen<br />
to be np and domg' towards the reahsatio~ 01:<br />
that dream.<br />
Well, we do think this IS but a pOOl' solutlOll of<br />
thIS great question Sem3e of justice and eqmty<br />
does not come in it at all. The writer IS not fust<br />
even to those born in thiS country whose only home,<br />
he admits, IS her('; and yet he would keep even them<br />
lD servile conditions. The complamt of the writer<br />
that the Indian trader had corne and Simply<br />
battl'l1f'rl Oil thp mdnRt.ry of thIS C011l1try IS not ilt all
January 30th, 192 5 INDIAN OPINION 27<br />
fair. The Indian trader had come here just as any<br />
other had done to seek a livelihood and, moreover,<br />
he being a Entish subject had a better rIght to be<br />
here than many ahen~ III tlllS cOllIltry who are left<br />
unmolested.<br />
I~the root of the whole question IS. as It IR declared<br />
to be, the unfaIr (Jompebbon of the IndIan<br />
with phe European there Citll be but one solutIOn<br />
and that is, to standardise tlw RYHt!'m of trade so<br />
that the same standard may apply to IrW-Jan as<br />
applies to Enropmn<br />
The talk of I epatriation, Regregation, deprivation<br />
of the I'lght to trade ancl to own properties etc.<br />
although denied, IS nevelt heless WO]'f,e than Bolshevism,<br />
for the lattf'r hring'! instant tleath and IS<br />
therefore less barbarOllR than slow pOlsolllng by<br />
means of sugar-coated PIUS<br />
THE ASIATIC IN NATAL<br />
A VEXED PROBLEM<br />
SOME SUGGESTION" RY "'l'owKSMAN"<br />
The following al tIele appears In the Nidal N en W /I<br />
dated January 24. under the nom de plume "'l'owns<br />
'mar" '-<br />
, Apart tr9ill the qllestlf)n of the MUIllClpal fIaf,<br />
< chise, winch only touches the fringe of the problem,<br />
A there has lately been qmte a lull III what IS faml<br />
\ harl,}' known as the ASIatIC agitatIOn, m tact three<br />
) seems to be a dlSposltIOn to relax efforts m the guld-<br />
~'ance of pubhc opmion on thIS all absorbing tOpHl.<br />
) Why we should be qUIte content to leave this vItal<br />
'\lwatter III the hands of the Government it; not at all<br />
t~rent in view oJ: past experIence. It WIll be re<br />
~£
.<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
we can go. The segregation provided for in the costs \1S now. it is my firm conviction that nnlef'~;!i<br />
Olass Areas Bill may possibly be the only way out, we Europeans in this country t,wkle the matter IInlllP,<br />
but we must only segregate those born jn the settle it once and for all, right now, thel'e IS onl>1l<br />
country; the others must go-there is no other one alternative, which I can already see Ioomm .. in<br />
course. Then thereis the trader, what IS to be done the mists on the horizon. It may be a long rim~1J<br />
with him? He came into the country of his own coming, or it may be close at h,md, but It is un tl<br />
free will by the open door in the first place. He doubtedly going to take the shape of WAR. LetT<br />
now has vested inta-ests which cannot lightly be us take drastic actIOn now and not wait until thl/;<br />
interfered with, but III the wider interests of the yellow hordes are fully awakened for the fray. cLe:~<br />
country at large there must be interference coupled us make thiS entirely a white man's country, for i "<br />
with just and ~ir treatment. Any seizure of the is good logic that the yellow peril as it exista for UI<br />
property or interests of any class of our pOp'ulation, will disappear in exact ratio as we fill t1us snnn x' 1<br />
withQqt due compensation, would· be reducing our South AfrIca of ours with white men! In th:"<br />
scheme of government to a state of Bolshevism. words ofa famous reCl'Ulting t1peaker-" Let thadJ<br />
TJlerefore, if the Indian trader is to lose' his property,<br />
his licence; and tiis goodwIll, it is a sine qua<br />
sink in. " ,~<br />
non that reasonable compensation must be paid to<br />
him. If he is a Colomal-born, then he should, after<br />
OUR LONDON LETTER<br />
such compensation, be segregated with the o~hers if<br />
he desires to stay in South Africa.<br />
[ By OUR OWN CORRERPONDENT ]<br />
"<br />
The compensation paid for goodwill, or the purchase<br />
price paid for the various propertIes and<br />
1st Jann,lry, 1 ~12'1111<br />
January 30th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 29<br />
,". \ The Guildhall Banquet by the Mayor of London<br />
, ''''I'l to be remembered (or the utterance of :Mr.<br />
\... /Oltanley Baldwin on the question of India. The<br />
speeches at the Banquet were broadcast and this is<br />
what ~fr. Baldwin was heard to say : .. The Govern<br />
~ent will b~ face~ with problems of difficulty and<br />
lmportance 10 Indla. There are unmistakable signs<br />
in many parts of India that the tension between the<br />
Hmdu and Mahommedan commumties is more acute<br />
thll.ll at any time for years past. The political extremists<br />
have adopted tactics designed to wreck the<br />
existing form of Constitution and in Bengal terrorist<br />
orgr.nisations are at wQl'k which have made it<br />
necessary for the Viceroy to issue an Ordinance reoently<br />
conferring special powers jor the suppression<br />
of violont crime. The Government will support<br />
with their full authorlty .the Government of India<br />
in suPwessing crimes of that nature by whomROever<br />
or upon whatsover motive they are committed.<br />
One matter which will receive our earliest attention<br />
, is the relief of the anxieties and financial difficulties<br />
of the Services in India but for whose loyalty and<br />
unewerving service our task would be impossible of<br />
j<br />
~chievement. Here we have available the advice of:<br />
,he Uoyal Commission presided over by Lord Lee<br />
. , /,f Fareham and I hope we shall be in a position to<br />
.. lake a commencement at any early date."<br />
,. The Government has since given effect to the recommendations<br />
of Lord Lee's Commission-the<br />
same recommendations which we~e rejected by the<br />
Indian Legislative Council at Delhi.<br />
The New Year's Honours which are out to-day<br />
announce a G.C.S.I. for Lord Lee; K.C.I.E. for<br />
~r. R. E. Holland who lately succeeded Sir C. S.<br />
Bayley on the Council of India; K.C.I.E. for Mr.<br />
ChatterjeEl, the High Commissi6ner designate for<br />
India. Thf're are many honours for Indians in the<br />
list. .<br />
The year just passed is said to have been the<br />
wettest year for many yearli!. The' rains are on, as<br />
this letter is being written. The river Thames has<br />
lrerflOYffl its banks at places and at SUCh places the<br />
) ~ "
INDIAN OPINION January 30th, 1925<br />
-NATIVE PASS ORDINANCE<br />
DEPurATlol; RECEIVED BY GI!t.ERAL HERT70G<br />
Pretolla, Jan. 20 (ReMer) -Some time ago the MIDlster of<br />
J u,tice ordered that the Native Night Passes Ocdmance of 1902,<br />
m,its,appucation to fem.les. should be enforced as on Feb. l-<br />
To-day the Pnme M~olster 10 IllS capacity as MInister of Native<br />
Allans, received a, large ilnd influential deputation of lhe Jomt<br />
Eurdpe':m and Native Council, churches and other bodies Oil this<br />
question. /<br />
The members of the deputation urged delay lD putting the<br />
order into operation on the grounds t/lat the best means of deahng<br />
With the admitted evil 9f 199se Native women in the towns had<br />
not b~en properly investtgated, n9r had N ahve opinion been<br />
consulted.<br />
Mr. Howard hm and olhers IIrged .that the pass system would<br />
not attalll Its object , _<br />
The deputation was m9st sympathetically received by Gen ral<br />
HertzoDg wh:>; It IS understood, said that'the law must be carned<br />
out<br />
He wou;d\ hOVlever, consult With the Mmister of Jusllce, and<br />
ask for the postponemev.t of t\,le operation of the order for sj,,-<br />
, months -<br />
• He asked the joint Counc,I't9 submit t9 him wit"in three<br />
months ~ rep9rt suggestmg, the best method to be adopted with<br />
~ega)d tQ the cqn~rQI of Native women In tbe towns.<br />
tUROPEAN WOMKN'~ DEPUrATION<br />
Pretoria, Jan 23 (Reuter) -A deputation consishng of represeutatl.eo<br />
of the ,Wo!pan's FederaltOIl, The Yo omen's S. A. P.<br />
and ,he Women's N ahona\)st Par1y, "'1-lted on the Prime MIDlSter<br />
to,day, -and assur¢4 111m of \heir strongest support In the<br />
~nflbrcem mt of the proposed La\)' regard)~ Dlgbt passes for<br />
N atlve Wom~ll.<br />
]l;frs De Waal, on behalf of tile 'Vomen's FederatIOn, urged<br />
that the-Government ~h9uldr compel Native girls to carray monthl?<br />
passes" and to be,mechcally exammed.<br />
In con ectlOn ;'lIth thIS matter It WiS learned ID Pretoria this<br />
morDlng that the Government had dectdcd to po.tpone the operation<br />
of the \ct tIlt May I, and not for SIX m9nlhs a.< preVlOusly<br />
stated<br />
News in Brief<br />
Ge')rge DJugla;. a South Afncan m Dl"g englOeer wh~<br />
accordmg to hiS record'came to thIS couutr.l at the ge of five<br />
• and was co wlcted 16 tIme'; for theft,_ frau i and forgery and<br />
finally',deported and wh' has recently been ~ente'ced at th~<br />
Nottlnltham Quarter Se stOns at Rltford 10 fo~~ year,,' p!na\<br />
servitude for a Ii~mllar off~ce 'is r,eport"d to ,have m de an<br />
arnuslD't sts'ernent IV the cOllrt, "that once a nan 'fas down<br />
ID S"utb Afnca" whether black or white, It was very difficult fvr<br />
him to flse again I"<br />
ACCOldtng to a Geneva message a telegram was sent by Mr.<br />
Gandhi [rom IndIa to Mr. Alex:ai!(ler repr
No. 6-VoJ. XXIII. Friday, February 6th, 1925.<br />
R.eglstered at the G. P.O ••• a Newspaper<br />
Pilies ron. s.c •<br />
•<br />
INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS<br />
I<br />
M<br />
MAHATMA GANDHI'S PRESIDE,NTIAL ADDRESS<br />
E publish the following extracls from the preSidential<br />
address delivered by Mahatma Gandhi at the 39th<br />
Indian Nallonal Congress, Belgaum, on the z6th<br />
December 1924:-<br />
'rom the September of 1920 the Congress has been pnncipally<br />
IOslitullon for developing strength from' wlthm It has ceased<br />
function by means of resolutions addressed to the Government<br />
redress of grievanres. It did so because it ceased to bebeve<br />
he bene/iclal character of the eXisting system of Government.<br />
the Special Session - of the Congress at Calcutta 10- 19z0 •<br />
boycott of Government titles, law-courts, educational InstItu.·<br />
l~, legl8la'ive bodies and foreign cloth was resolved upon<br />
the I,oyeotts were more or less ta'ken up by the parttes con<br />
~ed. ThOle who could not or would not, retlled from the<br />
Dgress. I do not propose to trace the ehequered career of the<br />
I-co-operallon movement. Though not a smgle boycott was<br />
'where near complellon, everyone of them had undoubtedly<br />
effect of dlmlDlshlng the prestige of the partICular IOshtutlOn<br />
'cotted.<br />
VHAT NON-VIOLENT NON.CO.OP'KRAfJON HA, A,ClIIBvED<br />
~he most Important boycott was the boycott of violence<br />
,Jist It appeared at one time to be enbrely successful, It was<br />
,n discovered that the non-vIolence was only skm-deep It<br />
I the passIve non-vlolenc' of helpless"ess, not the enlightened<br />
I-violence of resourcefulness. The result was an eruption 01<br />
~Ieranee agamst those who dId n,t non-co-operate. ThiS was<br />
lenee of a subtler type. In spite, however, of this grave defect<br />
lake bold to say that the propaganda of non.vlolence checkedoutbreak<br />
of phYSIcal Violence which- would ..cerlamly have<br />
Iken out, had not non.vlolent non-co-operation come mto<br />
ng. It is my deliberate conviction that non.vloleot non-co<br />
~ralion has given to tl-je people a oonsciousness of their<br />
:ngth. It has brought to the snrface the hidden powers in<br />
~eople of ,reSIstance- through suffering. It has caused an<br />
akenlng among the masses which perhaps no other - method<br />
lid have. ,<br />
rhough, therefore, non-violent non·co.operatlon I has not<br />
lught us SwaraJ, Ibough It ha. broyght about certam deplor<br />
Ie resulls- and though tbe mslJtulJons that were sought 10 be<br />
ycotted are shll flourishing, in my humble opimon, non-vIolent<br />
n.co-operatinn as a means of altammg pohtlcal freedom has<br />
me losta' and that even its partial success has brought us nearer<br />
,araJ There 19 no mlstakmg the fact that the capaclly for<br />
~erlng for Ihe sake of a cause mnst advance It<br />
, FAILURB OF BOYCOrTS<br />
But we are face to face with a sltuatJon that compels \IS to cry<br />
,It. For whilst indIviduals hold f.rmly to tbell beltef in non<br />
-operation the lIlaJority of those who are immedIately concerned,<br />
ve prl\chcally lost faith In It, wllh the excephon of boycott of<br />
reIgn clolh Scores of lawyer. have resumed practice. Some<br />
en regret havmg ever glven.,Jt up. Many who had given up<br />
lunclis have relurned to them and the number of tho;e wiw<br />
heve In CouncIl enlry is on the increase. Hundreds of boys<br />
,d gills who have gIVen up Government schools and colleges<br />
lve repented of thelf aellon and have returned to them. I hear<br />
at Government schools and colleges can hardly cope With the<br />
:mand for adml!Sion. In these clfcumstances these boycotts<br />
,~not be worked as part of the Nahonal programme, unless the<br />
ongress is prepared to do without the classes d"ectly affected<br />
ut I bold it to be Ju~t as imprachcable to keep these classes out<br />
the Congress as It would be now to keep the non-co-operators<br />
11. They must both remalD in the Congress, wltbout either<br />
uty mtertenng with or hastily cnticlsmg Ihe otber. What IS<br />
pplicable to Hmdu-Muslim unity is, I feel, apph£able~o unity<br />
mong dllterent pohtical groups. We must tolerate eacb other<br />
~d trust to time to convert the ooe or tbe other to the opposIte<br />
ehef. We must go further. We must plead with the LIberals<br />
~d olhers who have seceded to reJoIn the Congress. If non-coperatlon<br />
is suspended, tber~ IS no reason wby they should keep<br />
7: The. advance must be from us Congressmen. We must<br />
~rdlally mvite them md make it easy fOf them to come m.<br />
You are perhaps now able t. see .. hy I entered into the agreelent<br />
with tbe SwaraJists. ,,'<br />
BOYC011 OF FROEIGN CLOTK<br />
You will observe that one boycott has been retamed. Out of<br />
egard for the senllment of an Enghsh friend the \\ord • noycott',<br />
as been changed in the agreement 1010 'refusal to use foreign<br />
loth.' For me II is an effective substitute for Violent methods.<br />
ust as certain acts such as personal abuse, iffllatmg conduct,<br />
ylng, causing hurt and murder ar& symbols of VIolence, Similarly<br />
comte.y. moffenslve conduct, truthfulness, etc., are symbols of<br />
Don-VIOlence. And so to me I~ boycott of foreign cloth a sym_<br />
bol of non-VIOlence. RevolutIOnary crime IS mtended to exert<br />
pressure. But It is the insane pressure of anger and IlI·wlll. I contend<br />
that Don-VIOlent acts exert pressure far more effectIve than<br />
Violent acts, for that pressure comes from good-Will and gentleness.<br />
Boycott of foreign cloth exerts such pressure. We Import<br />
the largest amount of foreign cloth from Lancashlfe It IS by far<br />
the lartrest of all our imports, Bugar bemg next. Bntam's chief<br />
mterest centres round the Lancashire trade WIth India. It IS<br />
the one thlDg more than any other that has ruined the Indlaif<br />
peasant and imposes partial Idlene~s upon b,m by depllvmg hUD<br />
of the one supplementary occupahon he had. Boycott of foreign<br />
cloth IS therefore'a necessity if he IS to bve. The plan, therefore,<br />
IS not merely to mduce the peasant to refuse to buy the cheap and<br />
mce-Iookmg foreIgn fabriC but also by teachmg him tn utlhze hIS<br />
spare houls ID cardmg and spmmng cottbn and gettmg It woven<br />
by the Village wewers \ to dress himself in Khaddar<br />
so woven and thus to save him the cost of buymg foreign<br />
and for that matter even Indian _ mill-made cloth.<br />
Thus boycott ~f foreign cloth by means 01 hand-spmning<br />
and hand-weavlDg, I.e.. khaddar, nof only saves the<br />
peasant's money but It enables us workers to render d,!ect touch wuh<br />
the Vlllagers It enables us to give them real pohtlcal educalJon<br />
and teach them to become sdf-sustamed aDd self-rehant.<br />
Orgamutlon Qf khaddar IS thus m/imtely better than co.opera-<br />
I tlve SOCIeties or any other form of VIllage orgamsation. It IS<br />
fraught with the highest pohtlcal consequences, because It removes<br />
the greatest Immoral temptation from Bntam's way. I<br />
call the LancashIre trade immoral, because It was raised and is<br />
sustamed on the rum of millions of Ind,.'s peasants And as<br />
one Immorahty leads to another, the many proved Immoral acts<br />
of Bnt.m are traceable to -11us one immoral traffic, If, therefore,<br />
thIS one great templalJon is removed from Blitam's path by<br />
Tndla'~ voluntary effort, It would be good for India, good for<br />
Brllam and, as Brltam IS tooday the predommant world-power,<br />
good even for humanity.<br />
THB SPIl\NING WHEBL<br />
I wish, too, you would dISmISS from your mmds the VIew,<br />
attTlbuted to me about machmery. In the first instance I am no<br />
more trymg to preseot for nahonal acceptance all my views on<br />
machmery, than 1 am presentmg the whole of my belief 10 non<br />
VIolence. The spinDlog wheelIS 10 Itself an exquiSIte piece of<br />
machmery. My head dally bows m reverence to ils unknown<br />
Inventor What r do resent is the wanton and wicked destruchan<br />
of the one cottage industry of India that kept the wolf from<br />
the do,,, of thousands of homes scattered over a surface 1900<br />
miles long and I JOO miles broad.<br />
1 have thus dilated upon tbe spmning wheel because I have no<br />
better or other message (or the nabon. I know no olher effective<br />
metbod for the attamment of SwaraJ If It IS to be by 'peaceful<br />
and legitimate means.' As I have already remarked It is the<br />
only subs Itute for VIolence that can be accepted by the whole<br />
natron. I swear by CIvil Disobedience. But Civil DisobedIence<br />
for the attainment of Swaraj IS an Impossiblhty unless and until<br />
we have attamed the power of achlevmg boycott of foreign<br />
-cloth. You will now easily perceIve why I should be a useless<br />
gl\lde for the Congless if my vIews about the spmoing wheel are<br />
not acceptable to you Indeed, you would be Jusb/ied In regard-<br />
109 me, as some fnends do, as a hmdrance to natronal progress,<br />
if you consider me to be wrong in my expoSItion ol-the doctnne<br />
underlymg the spinmng wheel. If it does not appeal to your<br />
head~ as well 8..4 your hearts, you will be wantlllg in your duty 10<br />
not reJ"ctmg my lead. Let it DO longer b~ ~Id, -as Lord<br />
Wtlhngdon very properly saJd of ns; that we had not the strength<br />
and courage to say" No.' Indeed your rejection of my proposal<br />
If you do not beheve m itt Will be a step towards SwaraJ.<br />
HINDU-MUSLIM UNITY<br />
Hmdu-Muslim uDily is not less 'important than the spmOlng<br />
wheel It IS the breath of our hft:. I do not need to occupy<br />
much of yo.r time on thIS question, because Ih4: neceSSlty of It<br />
fo,. SwaraJ JS almost uDlversaJly accepted. _ Tbe KhiJafat agitation<br />
10 ",hieb Hmdus made common cause WIth theIr Mussalman<br />
bre'hren and the non co-operatIon that followed it, caused an<br />
awakenmg among the hitherto slumbering masses II has given<br />
a new consciollsness to the classes as well as the ,masses.<br />
Interested persons who \\ere dlsappomted dUring the palmy days<br />
of non-co_operation, now that it has lost the charm of Dovelty,<br />
have found their opportuDlty and are tradmg upon the rehglOus
INDIA~' Ul'lN 1UN February 6th, 1925<br />
bigotry or the selfishness of both the commuOltle~. The result IS<br />
wntten m the history otthe feuds of the past two years. Rehgion<br />
has been travested' Tnfles have been dlgmlil!i by the name of<br />
rehglOus tenets which, the fanatics claim, must be ob.erved at<br />
any cost. Economic and political cause. have been brought mto<br />
play fo< the sake of fomentmg trouble. The culminating pomt<br />
was reached in Kohat The tragedy was aggravated by the<br />
callous mdlfferenne of the local authority I must not tarry to<br />
examme the causes or to distnbute the blame<br />
The UOlty Conference at Deihl has paved the way for a settle.<br />
ment ofrehgious differences. The Committee of the AIl·Partles'<br />
Conference IS among other thmgs expected to fiOd a workable<br />
and Just solution of the pollttcal differences not only between<br />
Hmdus and Mussalmans but between all classes and all castes,<br />
sects or denominattons. Our goal must be regloval, at the<br />
earl est possible moment, of communal or sectIOnal re,Pre.entation.<br />
A common electorate mllst 'Impartially elect its represental1ves on<br />
the sole ground of merit. Our selVlces must be hkewlse 1m·<br />
partIally manned by the most quahfied men and women. But<br />
till that lIme comes and communal Jealousies or preferences be·<br />
Lome a tbing of ,*,e past, minonties who suspect the motives of<br />
maJontles must be allowed thell way. The maJontles must set<br />
the example of self.sacnfice.<br />
UN rOUCHABILlTY A HINDRANCE TO SWARAJ<br />
U ntonchablltty i. another hmdrance to Swaraj. Its removal<br />
IS Just as essential for Swara] as the attamment of Hmdu-Muslim<br />
uUlty. ThIS IS an essenhally Hmd]1 questtoll and Hmdus cannot,<br />
claim or take $waraJ till they have restored the 1iberty of the<br />
suppressed claSses:; they have sunk wIth the latter's suppression.<br />
I would however warn the Hmdu brethren against the'tendency<br />
which one sees now.a-days of exploIting the suppressed classes<br />
for a pol1ttcal end. To remove untouchablhty IS a penance that<br />
caste Hmdus owe to Hmduism and to themselves. The punfi:<br />
catton requited IS not of untouchables but oC the so·caUed.<br />
supellor castes. There is no vice that is special tQ the untoucha<br />
-hIes, not even dllt and msaUllatlon. It IS our arrogance which<br />
bhnds us 'superio)"' Hmdus to our own blemlShe~ and which<br />
magmfies those.of our down.troClden brethren whom we have<br />
suppressed and whom we keep under suppressIon. RehglOns<br />
like natIOns are bemg welghed.m the halance. God's graqe and<br />
revelation are the monopoly of no 'race or natIon They ilescend<br />
equally upon all who walt ueon God That rehglOn and that<br />
natlO" Will be blotted out -of the face of the earth whIch pms Its<br />
faith to inJusttce, untruth or violence God IS lIght, not darkness.<br />
God IS love, not hate. God is truth, uot untruth. God<br />
alone IS great We, HIS c!.eat!!les, are but dust Let ,us be<br />
humble and recogmse the place; of the lowliest of H,s creatures<br />
MAHATMA GANDlll'S SWARA] SCHEME<br />
I have long professed my converslOu to the vIew pressed upon<br />
the pubbc by Babu Bhagvan Das that the pU.blic must know the<br />
end, not vaguely but preCIsely They must know the full defiuitlOn<br />
of S\\araJ, 1 e., the scheme of Swaraj whlcn All IndIa<br />
wants arid must fight for., Happdy- the Colt)mlttee appOInted<br />
by 'the AH.-Partles' Conferenc~ fs charged WIth that mlsslOIl and<br />
let us hope Qtat the CommIttee mIll be !\hle to produce a scheme<br />
that WIll be acceplable to all parties. May I suggest for Its<br />
conSIderatIon the followlIlg pOInts?<br />
'---..<br />
I. The qushficatlOn for the franchIse should be neIther property<br />
nor pOSItion but manual work, snch for example as suggested<br />
for the Congress Franchise. Literary or property te.t has<br />
ptoved to be elUSive Manual work gives on opportumty to all,<br />
who wish, to take part In the government and the well· baing of<br />
the State.<br />
2. The rumous mIlitary expendIture should be curtaIled ~to the<br />
proportton necessary Jor protectIOn of hfe and property in<br />
normal hmes. ,<br />
3. Admmis.tratlon of ]ushc:e should be cheapened and With<br />
that end In view the final court of appeal should be not in Lon.<br />
don but In DeIhl. Parties to civtl SUitS must be compelled in<br />
maJonty of cases to refer theIr dlsplltes to arblttrahon, the deelcion<br />
of these Panchayats to be final except III cases of corruption<br />
or obvious ml.apphcatlon of law. Multlphcity of mtermedlate<br />
courts should be aVOIded. Case law qhould be Abohshed and the<br />
general procedure should be slmphfied. We have slaVIshly<br />
followed the cumbrous "nd worn out Enghsh procedure The<br />
tendency III the ColollJes IS to simphfy the procedure so as to<br />
make it easy for htlgants to plead theu own cases,<br />
4. Revenues from mtoxlcatmg hqllors and drugs .hould be<br />
abolished ~/<br />
5 ~alane of CIVIl and MIlItary Service should be brought<br />
down to a level compatible WIth the general condition of the<br />
countr· .<br />
6. There sholjld be re.dlstllbullon of-provinces on a hngulstic<br />
basIS With as complete,autonomv as pOSSible for every provlllce<br />
for ItS internal ad_mmlstratIon and growth.<br />
7. Appomtment (,f' a commiSSIon to examme all the monopohes<br />
gIven to forelgne~ and, subject to the findmgs of the commlssiq.n,<br />
full guarantees to be given for atl vested lights Justly<br />
acquued. . •<br />
8 Full guarantee of then status to the India., Chiefs Without<br />
any hindrance from the, Central Government subject to the right<br />
of asylum to subjects of these states who, not bemg offenders<br />
against the Penal Code, may seek it m se'lf.govl:rnmg IndIa.<br />
9. RepeAl of all arbItrary powers. -<br />
- 10. The highest post to be open to all who may be otherWise fit.<br />
Exammatlons of the CIVil and MIlItary Services to be in India<br />
I I. RecogmtioD of c9mplete rehglOlls freedom to vanous<br />
JenOll1inatlon~ subject (.\ mutual forbearance<br />
12 The offiCial language for provlOclal governments, legiSlators<br />
and courts, Wlthm a definite penod, to be the vernRcular<br />
of the provmee; of the Pnvy Council, the final court of app~al,<br />
to he Hmdustanl; the scnpt to be either Devanagan or Persian.<br />
The language of the Central Government and of the Central<br />
Leglslatu~e to be also HlOd"stam. The language of internatIOnal<br />
diplomacy to be Enghsh.<br />
I trust you WIll not laugh at what may appear to you to be<br />
extravaganc' of thought In the foregomg .ketch of 'Ome of the<br />
requllements of Swaral as I would have It Wo m3Y not have<br />
he power to-day to take or recelvP or do the tlungs I have men_<br />
honed Have we the will? Let us at least cultivate the deSire<br />
Before I leave thiS highly attrachve, because speculative, theme<br />
let me assure the Committee In charge of the draftmg of a<br />
SwaraJ scheme, that I claim for my suggestIOn no more attentIOn<br />
than it would give to any smgle mdlvldual's I have mcorpora.<br />
ted them m my address only to gam greater currency for them<br />
than they would perhaps otherWise receIve.<br />
The above sketch presupposes the retention of the Bnltsh COil.<br />
nectlOn on perfectly honourable and absolutely equal terms<br />
But I know that there IS a section IiImong Congressmen who<br />
want under every conceivable Circumstances mdependence or<br />
Brltam. They WIll not have even an equal partnership In my<br />
oplmon I( the Br tlsh Government mean what they say and<br />
honestly help llS to equahty, It would be a great tnumph than a<br />
complete severance of the BritIsh connection I would therefore<br />
stnve for SwaraJ Within the Empne but would not heSItate to<br />
sever all connection, If severance became a necessity through<br />
Brltam's own fault. I would thus throw the burden of separatIon<br />
on the Bntlsh people. The better mmd of the world deSires<br />
to.day'/tot absolutely Independent States warnng one agamst<br />
another but a federalton of mter-dependent States. The consumation<br />
of that event may be far off I want to make no grand<br />
claIm (or our country. But I see nothmg grand or impo""lble<br />
about our expressing our readiness for umversal mterdcpendence<br />
rather than IUdependence. It should rest With Bntam to say<br />
,that she WIll not have real alliance With India. I deSire the<br />
ahthty to be totally mdependent without a.sertmg the indepen.<br />
dence. Any scheme that I would frame, while Bnr aln declares<br />
lier goal about India to be complete equahty Wlthm the Empire.<br />
would be that I of alhance and not of Independence<br />
wltho!lt alhance. I would urge every Congressman not<br />
to be mSlstent on mdependenc~ In each and every case, not<br />
because there IS anythmg Imposslhle about It, but because it 10<br />
wholly unnecessary Itll It has become perfectly manifest that<br />
Bntam reallf means subjugatIon In spite of her declaration to<br />
the contrary<br />
Notes and News<br />
1\\ T a meeting of the PublIc Health Committee of<br />
ru -the South Coast Junction area held on Jau.<br />
23. a letter dated Jan. 20 was read from the<br />
South Coast Junction Area Indian Committee<br />
in reply to a letter from the Public Health<br />
Committee, dated November 20, 192,1, whereIn<br />
the latter complamed of the aforesaid CommIttee<br />
styling themselves the South Coast Area Indian<br />
Health CommIttee. It was pointed out in this<br />
letter that thGre was only one properly constituted<br />
Health CommIttee in the area, and that that<br />
Committee took exception to the word "health"<br />
being included, as It would prejudice the efforts of<br />
the South Coast Junction Public Health Committee.<br />
and that misunderstandmgs were bound to arise.<br />
The IndIan Committee have in thclI' letter agreed<br />
to withdraw the word "health" as requel!led, and<br />
WIll in future be known as the South Coaf:!t Area<br />
Indian Committee.<br />
Discussion arose as to this Committee's attitude in<br />
calling a mass meeting of Indians at Clairwood on<br />
January 17, the outcome of which was that the Indian<br />
community in the area was instructed to withhold<br />
payment of rates, and to contest the Public<br />
Health ComIJlittee's Ordinance. It was agreed that<br />
it was useless for the Committee to deal further with<br />
an assoCIation whose- hostilIty was so apparent.<br />
At a recent meeting of the Malvern Public<br />
Health CommIttee the Chairman (Rev F. E. Long)<br />
reported that in conjucnction wIth,Mr. Gray and the<br />
Secretary he had attended a mMtir.g of the Indian&<br />
of this area and .explained fully the services and<br />
object of the Ordinance under which the Commlttee<br />
was formed making it clear that although not wishmg<br />
to he harcl on anyont) of whatRver l-ace in
February 6th: 1925 INUIAN OPINION 33<br />
the area. the Committee were there to ('arrr on the<br />
work entrusted tD them without [plH' or tavour.<br />
Those present-some!)O in numbpr-Mr. Long said.<br />
took a keen inter~8t in the meeting Ill! was bhown<br />
by the very pertinent questions put to him. and be<br />
~ai.l he felt sure that if it was not for certain agItators<br />
that were working outside this area the Indians<br />
here were prepared to fall in with the reqmrementB<br />
from a health point that the Committee may fin.L<br />
ne('t'88ary to impose on the area.<br />
A complaint was received by several storekeepers<br />
in Malvf'rn of the nuisances caused by the In<br />
dIem fruit sellprs In the vicimty of the station, There<br />
appears to be no law to deal with this matter at<br />
prespnt. but the Committee have noted the complaints<br />
for reference when drafting fllrther<br />
regulations. In the meantime 'the Secretary was<br />
instructed to wrIte to the District Commandant of<br />
Police asking if anything can be done in the matter.<br />
---- .<br />
Giving evidence recently before the Co~ittee<br />
of Intlulltry and -Tradel Mr. Hammersley. on behalf<br />
of the PrOVIsional Emergency Cotton Committee. is<br />
reportf'rl to have advoeated the estahliRhment of a<br />
BoarJ, consillting of "eprpflentatives oC employers<br />
and employeefl, to control the whole of thp cotton<br />
industry and, mter alia. regulate supplies and avoid<br />
r(,Cllrrent booms and fllllms, the decisions of such<br />
Boarfl to be binding. The Committee is, moreover,<br />
reporterl to have urged that steps should be taken to<br />
make the industry independent of America. where<br />
the tarmers who were financed and highly organised<br />
were holding up supplies. and also to have suggested,<br />
that India be concentrated upon to provIde raw<br />
cotton of th-e reqlliflite staple and grade.<br />
,Our ,cot}t~m_porary the Natal AfercuT!I seems to he<br />
flomewhat purturbed at this last suggestion of the<br />
above committee. for it says'-"With the hopes of<br />
80 many people in Natal and Zululand centred on<br />
cotton production, it is distinctly 4isconcerting to<br />
find that in highly important investigation of this<br />
nature, where the steps necessary to secure indepenclE-nce<br />
from American supplies wrte under discussion.<br />
no reference was made to South Africa. On the eontrary,<br />
it was suggested, "our contemporal'Y bemoans,<br />
"that India flhonld 1;.>e concentrated upon to provide<br />
raw cotton of the reqnisitp staple and grade." Our<br />
rontemporar)- wishe:; somebody hall been there at<br />
the time to advertise South African cotton !<br />
Johannesburg Jan. 20 (Reuter).-Two Indians<br />
alleged to liave been prohibIted immigrants left Lourenco<br />
Marques in a motor car and crossed the Swaziland<br />
border. The car evaded the police at Mbabane<br />
and Ermelo. but was brought to a standstill yesterday<br />
in Ermelo. wh('re the police had barred the road.<br />
The Indians were arrested.<br />
Speaking recently at the Wesleyan Synod at<br />
Queenstown ~Cape) the President the Rev. J. W.,<br />
Houseman, asked how many politicians knew the<br />
meaning of segrag8tion as applied to the Natives.<br />
As a geographical idea. the drawing of a line dividing<br />
whIte from black, the proposal was absurd and<br />
impossible. The only feasible segregation was mental<br />
and spiritual rathE-r than physical and material-a<br />
segregatioll of national ethics, pure and simple. It<br />
was the segree,rahtm' of nationality which needed<br />
preservation-working out a national destiny on<br />
national lines.<br />
We are informed by Mr. V. Lawrence, Hon.<br />
Secretary of the M. K. Gandhi Library that a<br />
lecture on "The Sex Problem as it alIects Health"<br />
for men only will bf' dl'livered by Dr. F. G. Cawston<br />
10 the Parsee RnstomJee Han. HI) Queen Street.<br />
Durban. on Tuesday next the 10th aay of February<br />
1925 at 8 p. m. and after the lecture difK'ussion will<br />
be inVIted.<br />
THE VIC'EROY'S REPLY<br />
~ HE speech delivered by His Excellency the<br />
II \"iceroy on the Indlan question at the openlUg<br />
of the Indian I,egis13tul'e as well as hIS<br />
reply to the deputation that recently waited upon<br />
His Excellency on the same qnestion are both most<br />
,disappomting. On a very serlOus occasion such as<br />
the present one when the status of British Indians<br />
in thIS oountry is being reduced to helotage.<br />
when their very existence as self-respecting citizens<br />
~f the British Empire is Joopardized it was expected<br />
that His Excellency the Viceroy of India would not<br />
be dictated by anyone but by his own constience<br />
and that feeling the hmmbation himself he wonld<br />
not hesitate to speak out hIS mind with<br />
force and without fear. as did Lord Hardinge on a<br />
similar occasion in 1913 when the position wa.~ not<br />
any the less serious than it is _now, when he said,<br />
"I feel that if the South African Government<br />
desires to justify itself in the eyes of India and the<br />
world, the only conrse open IS to appoint a strong<br />
impartial committee. whereon Indian mterestB will<br />
be represented, to conduct the ll\.Ost searcbmg inquiry,<br />
and you may rest assured that the Raj will<br />
not cease to urge these considerations on the Imperial<br />
Government." On the contrary, our present VIceroy,<br />
the Lord Chief Justice, in whose speech there is neither<br />
spil;it nor force, counsels paiJence when the house<br />
'ison fire and at the same time decides, that in view<br />
of the powers of the Dominions in domestic affairs<br />
the position IS delicate and a solution would not be<br />
easy. Further more. instead of recognifling the llldignation<br />
felt by Indians and Indicl at the extraordinary<br />
attitnde of the South African Government<br />
towards their nationals and denouncing such attitude<br />
as being unworthy of a country claiming to be<br />
civilized, His Excellency tells the deputation that<br />
.. denunciations and threats could onlf produce<br />
injurious consequences and embarrass the Union<br />
Government." In other words this is but a threat<br />
to the Indian people that if they indulge In<br />
denouncing and threatemng the Union Government<br />
they will be given DO .consideration at alL But have<br />
not the Union Government sufficiently embarrassed<br />
India and the Indian Government yet? It is difficult<br />
to express in adequate terms how keenly disappointed<br />
we are with Lord Reading's reply.<br />
One thing His Excellency has said to the deputation<br />
and that too is most indefinite. - That is about<br />
the suggestion of a non-party confvrence which, the<br />
Viceroy said, .. had rec('ived the full oonsideration<br />
of his Government which was having delicate<br />
negotiations with the Imperial Government," and that<br />
he was not, therefore, able to say more in that connecbon<br />
at present. It is difficult to know how long<br />
we will have yet to linger before a definite reply is<br />
received.<br />
It now remains to be considered ail to what hteps<br />
we are to take lin this country. To expect help<br />
coming from India is futile, and it would be unwise<br />
to depend on any outside help. Mr. Gandhi tells
----'3:....:4~___'__________ I_N_D_IA_N_;___O-P-I-N-I-O-N----~ ebrua,">:_ 6th, 1925<br />
•<br />
us definitely, and it IS too true, that we can have<br />
little help from India until India has secured her own<br />
freedom. How can we expect help from India when<br />
..,lndia is engaged m and is unilergoing her own free-<br />
, dom's 'battle by untold suffenng. We have to do the<br />
same either in India or in this country, and that, by<br />
standing on our own feet and depending on the<br />
help!f no one but having ImpliCit faIth in the One<br />
Supreme Bemg who alone can help us and ,give us<br />
justice.<br />
In the meantime we have to consider what immediate<br />
steps are necessary to be taken. It will not, we<br />
think, hE\ untimely on our part to suggest that while<br />
Parliament is in Session we should demonstrate by<br />
holding protest meetmgs throughout the Umon our<br />
sense of indignation at the unnessary humiliations<br />
we are subjected to, and with one voice, we should<br />
send a joint petitipn to the Governinent and the Parliament<br />
impressing upon them the urgent necessit~, m<br />
fairness to the Indian community, of takiug immedia~e.-steps<br />
to appoint a non-party committee to inquire<br />
into the present positIOn. Will the Indian community<br />
rise before i~is too late"<br />
DEPUTATION TO THE VICEROY<br />
Delhi, Jan. 28, CReuter).-The VICeroy received<br />
this evening an mfluential and representative deputation<br />
mcludmg leading Indians and European members<br />
of the Indian Legislative on the position of<br />
Indians III South Afrioa.<br />
The spokesman of the deputatlOnr In reviewing<br />
the situation, referred to the speech l;Jy Mr. J. H.<br />
Thomas, former Coloniftl Secretary, at Marltzburg,<br />
in which he expressed the opinion, that the IndIan<br />
question should be considered, not merely from its<br />
local, but from a~ Imperial aspect: The 'deputation<br />
urged the Immediate need of securing the Umon<br />
GovBrnment~s assent,to Mr. Thomas' suggestion' to<br />
hold a non-party conference to re-examineJhe Indian<br />
question m a spirit of tolerance with a vie~ to findmg<br />
a solution. ,<br />
The Maharaja of Blkaner (Chancellor of the Chamber<br />
of Indian Princes) telegraphed associatmg him<br />
self and the Princes wIth the objects of the deputation.<br />
'<br />
The members of the deputation mchided SIr Dinshaw<br />
Petit, Sir Purshotamdas ,Thaktlrdas, Sir Campbell-<br />
Rhodes (representative of European Commerce),<br />
Colonel Crawford (Secretary of the European Association<br />
of India), Ra?gachal'lar and Roy, (members'<br />
of the Indian Colomes CommIttee).<br />
The Viceroy, in reply, characterised the deputation<br />
as representatIve and infiuentIal to an unusual and<br />
remarkable degree. lIe saId the questIOn which had<br />
been raised was one of utmost 'importance to the<br />
Empire. He aduuttbd that a feeling of dlssappomtment<br />
had invaded the country owing to the ullexpected<br />
failure of the Smnts-Gandhi agreement whICh thIS<br />
country had thought to llave solved the controversy.<br />
The situation m Natal and elsewhere suggested<br />
that the POSltIOll of Indians m South Africa had<br />
reached a crisis, and that the Union _ Government<br />
were leaving the Provinces to solve the Indian<br />
question as seemed best to them. ~ The Viceroy<br />
ex,pressed his deep concern at the turn of events,<br />
and at the possible re-action whICh the matter might<br />
have on Imperial relationship. He would not conceal<br />
the difficulties that confronted them in dealIng<br />
with a self-govermng Domimon whose Government<br />
had its own difficulties and embarrassments. The<br />
suggestIon of a non-party conference had received<br />
the full consideratIon of his Government which was<br />
having delicate negotIations With the Imperial GOYernment.<br />
He could not, therefore, say more at<br />
present. DenunCIations and thrt'ats conld onlv<br />
produce mjurjous conseq'uences and embarrass th~<br />
Union Government. TheIr nurpose was to reconCIle<br />
llldividual interests with the collective interests<br />
of the Empire.<br />
OUSTING THE ASIATIC<br />
SUCCESSFUl, CAMPAIGN IN JOHANNESBUR~<br />
The Johannesburg correspondent of the Nalal<br />
JlfercU1 y in a message dated Feb. 2 savs ,-<br />
"Our campaIgn is havmg splend;J resnlta," "all<br />
the reply of 1\11'. Kirby, Se(,l'l'tary of the Southern<br />
Suburbs European AssociatIOn, when askell this<br />
morning as to the progress of a determined attempt<br />
to rid the southern subnrbs 'Of the ASIatic tradt'r<br />
"Already we know that 25 per cent, of the pe~ple<br />
to whom we have presented the serionsness to<br />
themselves and to the white community 10 general<br />
which must follow through tJ'ading WIth IndIans,<br />
are giving their orders-to the shops owned by the<br />
Buropeans."<br />
·"Do you send out your Circulars to all classes, or<br />
do you discrimlllate?" \<br />
"We are only concerned with people who are in a<br />
position that does not compel them to deal with the<br />
ASiatic. Poor residents \ are not interfered with in<br />
any way. In their case the necessity for obtaining<br />
supplies from the very cheapest market is rl'cognised.'"<br />
,<br />
.For two months the Southern Suburbs Ellropean<br />
Association, with Mr. Kirby acting as hon. secretary.<br />
- has been operatlllg. and all concerned are justly<br />
proud of what they have accomplished. Their<br />
particular mission has been to point out to householders<br />
that if the Indian trader in their midst ill<br />
supported by them, their husbands. brothers, daughters<br />
and sisters must eventually be thrown out of<br />
employment.<br />
"We are now expecting II large exodus of ASiatic ,<br />
traders from Turffontein and Forest HIll," contmllw"<br />
Mr. Kirby, -"and we are anxious that Ophirton m<br />
particular shoulu protect Itself agamst an invasion 01<br />
~hose people who have left our districts. For a<br />
long time past residents have waited and done<br />
nothing, believm~ that the Government would take<br />
action. They ha"*e found, however, that unless they<br />
first make an effort to help themselves the Government<br />
is not hkely to give them any assistance, but<br />
now they wIll formally ask for the help, and at an<br />
early date. Householders, too, are daily recognising<br />
the dangel' to theIr own employmeut whICh is<br />
bound to follow their support of the Asiatic. and<br />
that this campaIgn IS not being waged solely in the<br />
interests of the white trader,;."<br />
[Note :-From friends who came hue last w~ek<br />
from the Rand to embark for India we have been<br />
informed that the Turffontem dIstrict is inhabited<br />
to a very large extent by membprs, of the so-called<br />
White League and it is not sdfe for any Indian or<br />
coloured person to enter some parts of the dIstrict<br />
by night espeCially, as stones are being hurled<br />
mvariably and revolver shots are also occasionally<br />
heard. Several Instances of Indians haVing been<br />
thus attacked .have occured but where IndIans or<br />
Natives are concerned even the Pohce anthnnties<br />
are loath to take any notice. This would g\ ve sOme<br />
idea as to the methods adopted In some parts<br />
by anti-Asiatics to solve the ASIatic problem.-Ed.]<br />
, c<br />
Port Said, .Jan. 29.-The AkalKhan arrived here<br />
from AlexandrIa, and was met at the station by the<br />
Governor and other officials. He left for Suez today,<br />
where he will jom the steamer Dumbea for<br />
Mombasa and ZanZIbar. The Aga Khan IS on visit<br />
to his followers on the East Coast.,
..<br />
February 6th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 3S<br />
!\IIt H. ~<br />
L. POL.\K'S LECTURE<br />
...lY TII~: "o ... nll''' 01" lXDUX"; Is THE Cor,ONIE';<br />
Durin..: hllol rev,lt \I,,:t to IIII,,~ 'fro It ~. L.<br />
1'01.1k til'll \ el'Cti an inte'l e;,tiog It·ctare on Ih· POSItion<br />
of In.li.lns in the Colonies at a largely attended<br />
public meeting in !\J..Idras with Dr. Beil.1nt in the<br />
"ajl, ndyas:J~r l'anolt,l. Dr C.<br />
~)..Itesa !\IulLlhar. T. R. Venkptar,lm.l Sa'ltn awl<br />
.. Dewan, B.lh..l.lur 1'. KeA.l\.l PilI,lI amoll;,{ othel ri<br />
"ere present.<br />
The lecturer at the out,.,ct tbdnJ,ed the org-allJ""1 s of<br />
the meetmg for th€' kind \\ elcolUt' lhp,· o[ered t.)<br />
him and sai.j that he had Leen in Indid ~ often thdt<br />
h(' atldched \~self to the' p{«)ple of Indhl. although<br />
he Wat! not gh1tn the cItizenshIp.<br />
Although he had very fre(I'lentir spok .... n of Indians<br />
oversoas, he felt that \er)" many 'luestions<br />
oecnrred to hIm flom time to time thdt th"r(' was<br />
sull enough to lMrn. ·Ur. Polak 6.\1.1 th,\t among<br />
the very many things that \\ ere not nsually known<br />
h{'rt' was that nearly 20 lacs of Intii.lns lived wlthm<br />
\ the British Empire outside India in Bl'ltbh Guian.t.<br />
" Wellt Imhes, South Africa, E.lst Afnca. )Ialaya,<br />
Strdits Settlements, Austral!.1 and New Zeaunu. In<br />
I the'l~ pl3("es the problem conccrmng Indi,mll differell<br />
aecorlhng to the lll(l€'ntllr€' or f'ome othrr contract or<br />
whether they w('nt m,icpl'lluently by their own<br />
means. The problem ,lg.\in <br />
were m,llie S'lIlH' slIght dlIlC'1ll1uwntl'l wert' mtrouucell.<br />
But there Wi18 110 s,ltt!lfolct
INDIAN OPINION<br />
February 6th, t'I' S<br />
came forVl(a.rd thfY i~slsted that they should be consulted.<br />
With the advent of the new adminIstratIon<br />
they should be definitely on their guard lest a further<br />
attempt to introduce fresh penal legislation<br />
shotlld be made. The time had come for the recOI'l~titt1tidn<br />
of tHe bb10tties Oohifuitt~e beC'at1se the<br />
Cdmmisaion had just Hbw gone to East Africa 1n<br />
order to ct1l'lsider certai1l econOl:ilic prbhfems. There<br />
wiiS no IndHttt represerltatioh dit that Comnuttee.<br />
Thet'e Was no public occas10n fot InUiatul to ptesent<br />
thell' economic caSe. The GovertimeHt ot Indhi<br />
should scrutimse its report throngh It.'l representatives.<br />
I~ Ne'f Zealand there were new possibilIties open<br />
for Indlah population. There Wf>re no posmblhtiefl<br />
for perIl)anent emigration. Rut there wete opporttlDlttes<br />
for temporary residence. Some of the disabllitle!l<br />
which were brought to the botice of the<br />
Australian Government by ,Mr. V. S, Sruilvasa Sastri<br />
were removed by them.<br />
The only way in which dlsabdities would be removed<br />
was by giving CltIzenship to the people.<br />
In,dlans were laboUring under disabIlIties in C,mada<br />
-where they had :Defther provincial franchise nor the<br />
Domimon franchise.<br />
SOUTH AFltICA,<br />
The teal danger was in So\ith Africa whICh was<br />
also It self-g(ivei'ilirig d6:irl1lfWh. The Union is<br />
diVided into 4 provinces each haHng differerit laws<br />
and dIfferent typeS df t>diJultitiSn, IndIans had<br />
living franchise and provincial franchIse. But they<br />
were D,ot eligible fo:.;. m~mbershifJ of the Dominion<br />
Assembly., In the Transvaal Indians had bo franchIse<br />
at aU. - Every attempt was being made to<br />
restrict t'p~ir X;ig!lts as regllrds ownership _of b)li14-<br />
ings and lands, ,Many qf them W\lre actnally born in<br />
South AfrICa, They knew India oldy l:Jy tradition..-<br />
sYI¥pathy and sent~mellt. That population<br />
cOll\d not be absorbed becaUfl!\ they were aCCltsnomed<br />
to Enrope;tn conditIOns, They 'would not spttle<br />
down ~nd.fqr~ part of the population of this country.<br />
r.rhll~'efol'e Fhe speaker did nQt like the attempt<br />
made br Jhe Jnc).lan Qovernment m askmg the IndIans<br />
of Squt!J. Afl'l weIght of Indian puhhc opinion behio,l<br />
me." It was the message of the Ihuidn n.ltion which<br />
she carried to the people there, the message ot morai<br />
help thlit brought eourdge to the hea.rts of Indian!! in<br />
South Atrica and Kenya. She condemned the action<br />
of the Natal Government tor pasl:live fmnctil)(l to the<br />
Orchnance which deprived the people of Mnlllcipal<br />
franchise, as a betrayal of the agI'eemellt between<br />
Mr. Gandhi and Genl'ral Smuts. a betr,lyal of those<br />
human and uhalienable human rights, lndians hdd<br />
as much right to the tdrnchIl'!e as any WhIte Colnmal<br />
In the face of this oetI'dyal of agreement the<br />
Indian Government should not be academic in theil'<br />
PIty and compassion but must effectively protect the<br />
mterests ot the Inuians abroR,l, even since her<br />
return, she had been prt'1'!9ing for a Round 'fdble<br />
Cohference ancI sh(l had sllggellted the same to General:!'<br />
Hertzog and 8mut,,;, but the Indians here hall<br />
not wken up the Ruggestion of their own Amhaso;d,<br />
dol'. ·Were they- gomg merely to- pass resolutIOns of<br />
helplt'ss and chedp sympathy and s..y all the tronblelo ..<br />
of tlJ81r compatl'iots abrootd wel'e due to race prejudlCe<br />
of the Oolomal Whitcst" .. ll.1 passing this resolution<br />
I ask yon to make it_POSli\1}It1>so that having won<br />
Swal'aj by strcngth of united a~i,oA )Yeill~ll d4re to<br />
lay down the l.tw to the GoverlHllPn(tI.i(L t{).c:.Co1oAlcbl<br />
anti tdl tlll'm: "If you WIll tOllch (,Vl'r: lh~hai';fJ~<br />
my bl'other, you wtll tIo so a~ your own l'lsk." '
,t, 'I.<br />
February 6th, 1925 lN1JIJ\N OPiNION 31<br />
;'Ir. Sharnbuknm Chettl,u' lLL.A. Heconoled the re- tlwmselve ... mol the poopie of jhi.; counu-y to Dldke<br />
rlIOlntlOn, He 11011ngly protests against the<br />
~rr, BamtrdiJas ChaturveJi thOllgh not a delig,ltu<br />
enactment I>f Ihe Noltal Buroughs Ord.narce t1epnvlng<br />
lndlans \>( Municlp.lI franchIse and Ihereby nol only creal<br />
Ing a new CIVIC d"ablhty but rumously hampereng t 'em in<br />
Ihelr Dccupaliun as trad-l'8.<br />
(bJ Llbctal Federalfl>D urges y.,v rnm~nt of India to.<br />
1IIIII\ed1ately send an Officer of theus and a nOll,officlal 100<br />
~out.h Afnca 10 enqulfa1i:;ed<br />
th-e dlfficnlt position of the Government of IndIa in<br />
that mattel' but the Government 'of Iowa. owed it to<br />
of the Feueration spoke in support of the resolutltJll<br />
giving hi~ expel'lences reg-drdill~ the trf>atment of<br />
,Indians III Kenya and other Colonies. The ('e"olntion<br />
was passed.<br />
OUR LONDON LETTER<br />
[ By OUR OWN CORRE~PONDEY·.r ]<br />
Sth JaUlld.ry, U12,:i,<br />
the LIberal PartY-Which is the smallest part,,<br />
in the British Parli.lment is up anu stil'l'mg, ,lIlU the<br />
work of ~eorganisd.tion is going apa~e, W.lthlll the<br />
next few weeks the p,uty Will be holdmg d conference,<br />
1\lr. Asquith, who, UJough Without ,L bNt III<br />
theJItoube, is still the lead.f>r of the Llher,11:;, He IS<br />
011 his way to England trom Egypt anll \\ III no<br />
doubt take hiS place in the Confel'el~ce, There W,l";<br />
some t.tlk in the press of hls -probable elevatIOu to<br />
the peerage but this was folloWlilg immedlatel y hi ..<br />
defeat at the las~ general elections, He is a personality<br />
repl'esentative of the Victorian el".l of which he<br />
may be saHt to be the last, Sneh men al'e the l.ln(imarks<br />
of Brlt'lin's greatness, Mr, Lloyd ?eOl'ge 11:l,<br />
in the absence of Mr. AsqUith in the House, the<br />
leader of the Liberal Party within the House, His<br />
appointmeI}t. WitS not altogether populdr in hi" party.<br />
Sir John l:;imon, the gl'< l.t\vJ'er. who IS of the<br />
party, Col. Wedgwdod, Benn, Mr, Runsciman aUllothers,<br />
it would appear, reluctantly actluiesced m<br />
the appointment, 'In any case, Mr, Lloyd George w<br />
,I.S active as ever, eager to seize evel'y opportunity<br />
.tor the belle fit of his party.<br />
There are not any signs of Labom adivity a" thiS<br />
letter is being written, Both MI', &lmsay ~I.tCdOllald<br />
anti Mr. J, It. Thomas are aWdY in Jd.md,tCcl<br />
on holiday bent.<br />
The party in power, the Consen-ative, are alJ()I}t<br />
pItfl.Sllre or business. Loru Birkenhead, better known<br />
as F, E. Smith, the famous t~wyer, who holds the Ile::,<br />
tiny ()f India ir. his hands as the Secretary oC St,lle<br />
for India, is spending his holiday In Madeira-that<br />
bedlltifnl island In th"e sea-to attempt to doscl'lbe It<br />
would be futile, 1t were a. task for the poet an(i the<br />
artist.' Mr. Winston Churchill. the most vel satile<br />
man in the British fiousea of Pal'hament. as the<br />
Chancellor of the Exchequer IS III Paris enga',;"J iu<br />
th~ Allied Conferimc~ f.q,r fue .. d,jjustnu>nt of the P:1Ymenta<br />
of (1) the receJ.Pts oLtdmed by the occupation<br />
of Rum and (2) the amenities to be paid by the Germ.a4ltsnnder<br />
the Dawes ~cheme. . He is also there<br />
to raise the question. though not at the Confereuce<br />
itself, but outsiJe of it hy way of conversations with<br />
the representatives of France for the payments towarus<br />
the allielf debts to Gredt Britain. It wa;;<br />
dUI ing the war that Britain ma(le the debts with<br />
America in the purchase of war material for the<br />
alli"s aud in re:pect of these dt>bts she is pa)-ing<br />
Americ.lllltfjrest which i~ said to_ be born by the<br />
Brltxsh-t.iipayer to thtt extenfof 2[. in the £. There
is a talk.of France paying America the debts dire;:tly<br />
contracted with that country, and Britain feels and<br />
asks that France in paying America should also remember<br />
towards the debt to her.<br />
Two of the Directors of the Bank of England,<br />
1\1r. Montague Newton and Sir Anderson, are in the<br />
United States-some say to bring about the recognition<br />
of the gold standard-others that they are<br />
there In connection with the allied war debt. -<br />
The Royal Commission on Foodstuffs, with Sir<br />
Eric Geddes, as chairman is sitting and taking evidence.<br />
Much of it, as published, is interesting. The<br />
cost of living in this country is still very high. For<br />
instance in 1914~at the time of the outbreak of the<br />
Great War-the 4 lb. loaf cost the consumer 5td.<br />
but gm;ing the past year: it rose to 8td., in February,<br />
to 9d., in July.tQ 9td., in August to 10d., In October<br />
and to-day it stands at-lotd. The price of bread,<br />
in other words, now costs the consnmer pI'actically<br />
double its co~t just immediately- beforE' the war.<br />
The London County Council with the New Year<br />
has introduced an all-day ticket available on 'Saturdays-and<br />
Sundays at 1/. With this ticket holder of<br />
it can travel in its trams over a track of 164 miles,<br />
aad by choosing some of the longer routes he
February (jth, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 39<br />
,unflible people throughout the oountry are reo<br />
""'i'eiving POllt pamplilets entitled "Revolutionary,"<br />
and fOl'eshadowini( a campai/.,'U to counter terrorisDl,<br />
accompanied hy a series of threatt!. Unlike the<br />
previous epidemic of seditious literature. this reo<br />
volutionary pamphlet ill written in excellent Englisb,<br />
~d If! printNl on good paper.<br />
t<br />
News in Brief<br />
Writing in support of the "Townsman's" sugges.<br />
tion;; for a flolution of the Asiatic problem. which we<br />
reproduced from the Nai
~''PUt' l~'.)1tl' lJ-ofe.l)'Ut '~1-~ct ~Pl"" ~ t~ ~<br />
lh~ ~fQi \~.),1~1~ 1~11\}t ~k t't! ~.lJ:P \p~Jf;ljI~<br />
~l-lr.u l;.tn.h ~~ 1!!lt lcL?'ijt llt1-lr.e'i' ~1I~_, kl'\ lJ..ltl~<br />
~ljl~ t~ 1{"~ l~I1r!If~lhI}tIjJh li~7t \}'\l?lJ..<br />
.~ l}~ l~ta~ l!1~?i~ lJ.tlb~" ~~.~ ~!ilim ~~1~<br />
1l-1i1',lelt \)-'Plil1lt1 ~ !It.l-\~\}te3 tin: ~ ~!'I ~ f\lt<br />
\)-'1~.1R1.f~ ~ l.n~ R1~ It R~ jkl-lh.. ~ ~lfI.h lP~'ti<br />
, 1~1~1~ lhl- ~lfUti ~h. lttl- l~,\h. It.~llt \~W~ re~<br />
\ l ~1lila- f\~ l~lch. B.ll 'P.>1~ lltl-llt.1Wi Ilfl1 '~Rh! ~\R~'<br />
_ "@h1lfl1 !k.lbe~ - ~e t::t?I}t.~ y..1l:1~ 'Pe~ It"cl}n 1~'m'kl! ?S~ l}L'il<br />
~~~ Jcl.?I~; \y1~lj~lf l-h1h.lt~. lJll-l1llt. !lt~I~. \.06)17 lltil}~p l}l-l~(~ lfi\eP It''l-1~3 llll~ ,,1~bl~ lkll:):'l~ j~hl!f - ~cl:t l\.o\p~e3,p tt?~1i l~\}l~ l~lP~ Hn: l,~ hl~ l<br />
llt.~'le Wblln: \::Ihei el l~l}'\tll'P ij)'ih. \J:.hlcl~ I IJ.lHi .~llt l:': l~jl-t\Vihtllk ~i~?( l;"~''ilk: { 1~ .. !I~'<br />
'~1>~lt ~h1}l.1~~ l}p!l\ ~~ t\;'hl?ihl)~~ Plt \t~l~ lc:!~ l\J,b l~il i~l'~ ~~\lt. 1~~~ N:e<br />
!1t~171l-,. !It!f'~ fole 1}7 .. ~!J.;1h. el~l\ el~ltl1-" 1~'C1l !It.PWilWi ~ lli~h.II::~l't l}a~(h IilJ.;?{ 1~~1~'f\<br />
, - :~, _'~I'h ~Itl~ ~ ~ p~ 1~lf:~ -'cnl~ !It.iJ~J.7~ "'@I'h. lPpl\o:PltN: t3~ 't~~1-lil~ - ~ .,W' t fllltij:>. If\}tli-' lin:<br />
u c , IJI ~ t.: ,'" .... bE Jh.l/l 1'\...:0 Iltf, 17'11 Jjln- Iq"'ll~ '- ~ 1.1"- -,.... ," '
JJtt!littlt @piltiolt<br />
~v .<br />
• NO.7-Vol. XXIII. Friday, February 13th, 1925.<br />
Registered at lbe G. P.O. as a Newspaper<br />
Palcs I'OOIl'BBCB<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
- 4i~<br />
t\ViT AHAT:MA Gandhi writes in Young India We are no advocates of inflammatory propaganda.<br />
11 V 11 dated Dec. 26 :-The serpentine coil round But we do not see any difference between Mr.<br />
the Indian_ settlers of South Africa IS Clements Kadales speech and the white man's pro·<br />
daily tightening. Now in Natal they are deprived pagand against the black. The only difference we<br />
n of the municipal franchise. This was said - do see is that while the outspokenness of the form'e!;<br />
have been protected. When the ath-mpt was is somewhat justifiable the action of the latter is'-,<br />
:Ie to take away from them- the political totally injustifiable. "The Native must be segralchise,<br />
the Natal Government declared that tltey gated;" "the_ Native must be given no more la?,d;"<br />
I no design upon the enjoyment by Indians "the Native women must carry night passes;" 'the<br />
the municipal franchil!le. But no promise Katfir must be kept in his place," "the Asiatic is<br />
!Ie to a weak party is sacred in the estima- a menace to the white man;" "we mnst oust the<br />
1 of modern Governments. Each party must be Coolie;" "we must not support the Coolie;" "wee<br />
to defend its rights by its own mherent must segragate' him;" "we must drive him out of<br />
mgth. The Government of India's vaunted the country;" "we must take the law in our own<br />
tlteeship fails at the crucial moment. I know hands.~· Are these statements not provocative?<br />
.t the settlers look to us for help and protection. and yet they are commonly heard from the white<br />
t they should know that they can have little help propagandiat agaiJ;lst the black, and it is a wonder to<br />
m India for the present. She herself is engaged us that no voice of protest is raised against such a<br />
a life and death struggle. Years ago the late propaganda nor have the authorities considered it<br />
. Pheroze!lhah prophesied that India would be of advisable to put a stop to it. But the white man<br />
.le help to the Indians overseas, 80 long 3$ she can say and do as he wills. It is a heritage apparent·<br />
I not acquired the a~ility to assert herself. The ly bequeathed to him by his skin. But should a<br />
e Pestonji Padsha was even disgusted with me black man make his voice slightly heard, Action!<br />
. going to South Africa. He thought _every In- Action! is shouted ont from the houlJ~-tops.<br />
Ln worker going out of India was so much<br />
momic wa~te. I think his clear brain partially A Bill gazetted on January 22, restrjcts the issue<br />
led Mr. Padsha. My residence in South Africa of certificates of competency in the mining industry<br />
to "persons other than Natives or -Asiatics," and<br />
provides for the apportionment of occupations on<br />
mines and works "between Natives and Asiatics and<br />
.s not an economic waste of power. But is there<br />
t much truth underlying Mr. Padsha's burning<br />
gire first to secure IndIa's freedom ? Till we have<br />
luired it, we must send Ollr countrymen across<br />
3 seas such comfort as newspaper and other symthy<br />
can give them.<br />
-----<br />
At a Native meeting held recently in the Waar<br />
,ck Location near Bloemfontein Clements Kadala,<br />
neral secretary of the Industrial and Commercial<br />
orker's Union of South Africa, is reported to have<br />
Ildulged in a provocative speech, in which he<br />
reatened that the Natives would hold up the raillY<br />
service and the mining industry if th~<br />
)vernment refused to bring in a Minimum Wage<br />
11 for them." In the course of a violent attack on<br />
e English people the speaker is reported to have<br />
id that in the Cape the Natives were all ~ation<br />
Ists and the talk about British ideals was pure<br />
rpocricy." He is reported further to have urged<br />
s hearers "to make such an agitation everywhere<br />
at Parliament House will tremble and to<br />
11 the white man be has robbed you for the<br />
gt 200 years, robbed -you in the land ?f your<br />
thers. Kick up such a row that the white man<br />
5., ..'1ot seep. 1 "<br />
The Bloemfontdn COlTespondent of the Natal<br />
ercur!J sa3'S: Indignation is expressed that Native<br />
dtators from the Cap~ should be allowed to come<br />
:re and disturb tte minds of the local Native<br />
;pulation which numbers over 20,000 in Bloe~?nin<br />
alone without any check from the authorltles.<br />
is felt that if he intends calTying his inflammatory<br />
~opaganda into places like Basutoland, which is<br />
dd to be his object, the authorities should pnt a<br />
op to it.<br />
other persons." The object is to give legality to<br />
those mining regulations which were ruled by the<br />
,lower and higher courts to be ultra v,res, and 1.0<br />
render Natives legally incompetent to follow such<br />
skilled and semi·skilled occupations as are enumerated<br />
in the Mines and Works Act of 1911. Mr.<br />
Justice Krause described the colour bar regulations<br />
as "prima jaCl(J repugnant to the law of the land.<br />
• • • • ~ unreasonable, and even capricious and<br />
arbitrary." The proposal to make the regulations<br />
mtra. vires, to strengthen the colour bar and make it<br />
a. permanent institution, says the Umteteli JYa BlIrttu,<br />
affords another illustration of the Pact attitude towards<br />
the Native people.<br />
At a mass meeting of the Indians of Pinetown<br />
held last Sunday, the following resolution was<br />
carried unanimously: "That this mass meeting' of<br />
the Indians of Pinetown hel'eby resolve to orJ:tllnise<br />
and form themselves into a body under the name of<br />
Pinetown Indian ProgressiTe Asociation."<br />
The objects of the above Association are, we<br />
understand, to protect and safeguard the true interests<br />
politically, socially and educationally of the<br />
Indian community of Pinetown.<br />
A further resolution was carried requesting the<br />
Association's officials to take immediate and necessary<br />
steps for the establishment of an English School<br />
in Pinetown and for that purpose to move the<br />
Administration of Natal in the matter as they may<br />
think advisable. ..
I N PI -\N OPIN ION February 13th, 19:15<br />
The Kanamia Moslem League in Capetown has<br />
decided to raise £:1,000 to meet the requirements<br />
of the rismg geneIatlOl1 of IndIans III Capetown<br />
They have secured a plot of ground, on whIch thej·<br />
propose to erect a school, 111 whIch provIsion IS to<br />
be made for the edncatJon of theIr chIldren in<br />
EnglIsh, Ul'ciu and Gnjdl'dtJ. A SnbSCl'lptlOn list<br />
has been opened, aml IS headed WIth a donation of<br />
£100 Over £700 have b,t'en subS"cnbed to the<br />
fund already.<br />
QUEshON OF MAHOMEDAN WIVES<br />
Off HE judgmellt given by the Supreme Court<br />
11 ('Natal Pro~incial DIvIsion) -in the case of<br />
{mmigrants Appeal Board vs. Ayesha, the report<br />
of which 18 reproduceu elsewhere in this Issue.<br />
is of very great interest to the Ifiulan community.<br />
It brings to our memory vividly the PaSSIVe Resistance<br />
struggle; with all its _woes, that resulted -from<br />
the j'adgment of Mr. Justice Searle in March 1913,<br />
in the lllaj,ter of an appeal by Hassen Esop against<br />
the Minister of the InterlOr for an order restraining<br />
the respondent £rom deporting to India Bai Miriam.<br />
the lawfuJ wife of the aPl?licant. It was thIS judgmtmt<br />
that, for th-e first time, opened the eyes C?f the<br />
IndIan community to the fact that _according to the<br />
then existing law the wife of every HIndu and<br />
M;ahomedan was in South Africa fnegaUy, and;<br />
therefore, at the mercy of the Goverriment, whose<br />
grace alone could enable her to remain in this<br />
country. The said law did not admit the<br />
legality of marrIages celebrated - according to therecognized<br />
Indian religions.<br />
This was natnrally<br />
received with a severe shQck by the community, for<br />
it n.B an insult not only to the womanhood of<br />
India but to ;the Indian nation -hi so far as non<br />
Christia,ns were concerned; and as no steps to amend<br />
the law were 4tken by the Government the community<br />
had no other course but to resort to<br />
Passiv.? ResistaI\ce in which women also participated<br />
and Valiamma, whose name will never pe forgotten<br />
by the Indian commumty in South Africa,<br />
sacrificed h,el~ life. It was after this offering of a<br />
life and much suffering that the Government condescended<br />
to bend and a settlement was arrived at<br />
between the Government-and the Indian community<br />
with the passing of the 'lndJan Relief Act of 1914,<br />
which Act amended Section 5 (g) of_ the Immigrants<br />
Regulation Act 22 of 1913 which was the ca.use of<br />
all the trouble.<br />
The question' asked by the IminigrantB Appeal<br />
Bolird in the present case we are referring to in this<br />
article waS: ., Is the Indian woman Ayesha a prohibtted<br />
lmmigra~t 'in view of the provisior.s of<br />
Section 5 (g) of the Irp.migrants Regulation A~t 22_<br />
of 1913, as amended by Section 3 (2) of the Indians<br />
Relief Act 22 of 1914. "<br />
The Section referred to above, in so far as it affects<br />
the present case, reads as follows :-<br />
" , the wife' shall include anyone woman'<br />
between whom and the exempted person melltioned<br />
therein there exists a union recognized<br />
as a marriage under the tenets- of an Indian<br />
_ religion notwithstandiI)g that by those tenets<br />
the union of that exempted person with other<br />
-women at the same time would be recognized<br />
as ~ marriage : Provided that no woman shall<br />
be deemed to be the wife of such exempted<br />
pel'son-(a) If such a nlllon existf! bdween Ilim<br />
anu any other woman \"d1O resitle,. in any 1'1'0-<br />
YlllCe, or (b) If such eX"Illptetl l'r "~on 'has III<br />
allY Pl'ovince otI~pring IlY any otlier \\ !Jlll.1n<br />
,,110 is stIll living '(<br />
In answering the qnt',-tlOll Pilt hy the Bndnl Il,<br />
the negatlve .Tudge-Pres1dent ~1I John Do\(' \\"11"01/<br />
stnd the language of the sectIOn ",\'i pl.ulI and<br />
obvions, and MI'. JustIce Carler conclllled Hut<br />
Mr. Jushce Tatham was doubtful as to the lllt\1111l1g<br />
of the section and thought that tIlt' Sl'dlOl1 waambignonsly<br />
wordell. IllS LorcblllP tllOlll'ht "that<br />
the Act really meant that an Il1llt,m couM only<br />
Introduce a Wife If he kept one WOll1,m to be tredt"li<br />
as his wife III terms of the Imnllgl'a!Jon 1a\\s." It<br />
this would be the interpretation gl\ en to the Act it<br />
would agam mean that marrIages accol'Jing tn<br />
Ma,homedan Law are not recognized. 'Vhethel' two<br />
or four a Mabomedan's wives are h1s Ltwfnl WIve"<br />
accordmg to the tenets of his religion and as 'Inch<br />
they mnst be recognized. That should be the purpose<br />
of the law. The restrictIOn, however. is J1I<br />
regard to the IntroductIOn ot snch WIves, and that,<br />
as the Judge President has s,lid, is YeI'Y clear,<br />
i.e., it allows the person to select only one of his<br />
wiws, at a time, to bring into thiJ country, and that<br />
too not in all circumstances, for, the prOVISOS in the<br />
section prevents him from doing so jf at the time<br />
of the attempten introduction 'a wife by a similar<br />
union is residing in South Africa, 01' if there<br />
are children from a similar union allve in South<br />
Aftica. This is the present P9sition of the law.<br />
:t\1AHOMEDAN WIVES AND IMMIGRATION"'<br />
ST~TED CASE BEFORE SUPREME COURT<br />
AN INTERESTING JUDGMEST<br />
The case of Immigrants Appeal Board vs: AYerlha<br />
was brought before Sir John Dove Wilson, Judge<br />
President; 1\11'. Justice Carter; and Mr. Justice<br />
Tatham in the Supreme Court (Natal Provincial<br />
Division). /<br />
This was a case stated by the Board for the<br />
decision of the Supreme Court. The Board<br />
found that Ayesha was born in Imlia and is not<br />
entitled to enter South Africa unless she can prove<br />
that she is the wife of Cassim Ebrahim, an Indian<br />
domiciled in Natal. In 1915 Cassim Ebrahim contracted<br />
a marriage with one Fatima at Dundee under<br />
Mahommedan rites. Fatima in 1921 was allowed to<br />
go to In:dia on a visit, with the right to return, and<br />
she is still in India. Cassim Ebrahim went in 1923 on<br />
a visit to India and married Ayesha there III Januray,<br />
1924. He brought her out and apPlied for<br />
her admission into Natal.<br />
The Board found that the existing union between<br />
Cassim and Fatima precludes the recognition of any<br />
other woman as his wife. The question asked of<br />
the Court by the Board was this: "Is the Indian<br />
woman Ayesha a prohibited immigrant in view (jthe<br />
provisions of Section 5 (g) of the Immigrant.<br />
Regulations Act 22 of 1913, as amended by Section 3<br />
(2) of the Indians relief Act 22 of 1914,"<br />
Mr. J. J. J- Sisson instruc;ted by Messrs. C. P.<br />
Robinson and Goulding, appeared for the woman,<br />
and Mr. W. S- Bigby, K. C., Attorney-General,<br />
instructed by Messrs. D. A. Shaw and Co., for thp<br />
Board. The question in dispute was really thIS<br />
Under the- 1913 Act a wife of a domiciled person<br />
was not a prohibited immigrant provided that ihe<br />
was married to the husband by a monogamous.<br />
marriage. This excluded all Hindu and ~Iahomme-
I<br />
February J 3th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 409<br />
~<br />
-------<br />
~<br />
-------.<br />
-------------.-------------------------~~~<br />
'. wiv('s, as HlOnn ~nli MahommetlAn 1.1\\ allows<br />
"'l'olygalllou.; ll11rl··.t~I'. TllIJ In' hans Helif l Act of<br />
1~14 l"P(IJ~II1"(- t i 01' t/lP pllrpose:'! 1)( irnnll~r'LtiO!l<br />
HindI! all11 ~Llh()1J1I1l ,1111 wiveH WI wive!!, but (JlllvlIled<br />
thltt no :-.lleh Wlft' "'lonid bE' I'ec()~nh,~ 1 it fluch<br />
'a union already eXlsteci between the husband and<br />
~ 'othpr woman residing in any Province, Fatilllil.<br />
s('~rr. Hlssnn argued, WdS not re8idin~ in the Gillon<br />
llo\r and HO thE'refnl'p A ~ e"ha WdS entltle,l to eut""<br />
as a wife. JIe quotell :\lm v .. Principal ImmgralOn<br />
Officer 1921J C. P. D. :a7 and Marialll v. Immil-!rank:<br />
! Appeal Ho,mI, N. 1'. JP. :~>\2<br />
Mr. Bigby quoted Kulsum Blbi'!l case, 191:l,<br />
N.P.D. 4:37, to show that beforo thIS Inlli,lJls Rehef<br />
Act of 1914, a Hindu or Mahomed,m WIfe was no<br />
WIfe at all in the eye of the law. He argned that<br />
the provisos to Section a (2) of Act 22 of 1914 could -<br />
not increase the rights of an Indian wife, anu that<br />
the sub-section itself WaR the dommant art. He<br />
Clte!l Cr,nes 8tatue Law on this point.<br />
In giving Judgment. Sir John Dove WJlson narrated<br />
the f:JCt;l above !let out. Ill' then detailed the<br />
provhnons of the two sectIOns 111 the Acts of 191;):<br />
and 1\)14 which govern the question in this case.<br />
I l'olygamouH marriages are not re('ogmsed as<br />
marriages in Homan Dutch IJ.w, and the, effect of<br />
the 1!Jl:J Act was to exclude all IndIan WIves<br />
married under Hindu or Mahomedan law. The Act<br />
of H114 amended the 191:f Act flO afl to give an In.<br />
dian the right to bring in a Wife by Hmdu or Mahomedan<br />
law into this country. Dealing With thIS<br />
section :l of Act 2~t 19H. IllS Lordship fJc\id that<br />
the legislature I'ecognitled tlldt It was going too br<br />
to say that a pulygamous marrIage was never a<br />
marriage at all. It allowed an Indian to solect. one<br />
of his wives, otherwise :\ prohibited Immigrant, and<br />
bl'ing her into NatJ.l. ~u~ he had not thiS right in<br />
all circLUnstancel!. There were two provIsos. He<br />
could not du this if at the bme of the attempted int,'olIuction<br />
a Wife by a similar umon was residing<br />
hl South Africa. nor if there wel'e children from a<br />
IIbUar union alive in South Afr1ca. These provi-<br />
'!llons do not, however, effect Ayesha, since Fatlma<br />
IS resilhng in India and is childless Ayesna is, in<br />
torms of Section 3 (2), a WIfe by Mahomedan law,<br />
anll by the terms of that Section the husband has<br />
a free hJ.nu in bringing in which of his.. Mahomedan<br />
wi ves he pleases. It was said that he had no lliscretioll<br />
because -"one of his Mahomedan wIves formerly<br />
lived with him in Natal. There was nothing<br />
in the SectIOn to take away the husband's discretion<br />
III circumstances like thes£'. The wordmg of the<br />
'irst prOVISO, in thE:' present tenst!, was ngamt snch<br />
~ contention. AyeshJ. was, then-fon-, pl.unly eD<br />
,Hled to enter Natal. }'atim,\ is indepen.lently of<br />
IeI' huslJUnu a domiciled Nat.1Iia.n. ,lnlL mav as sl1ch<br />
)e entitled to t-nter Nat.tl. IllS LorJ5hll; gn,mled<br />
limself agmnst expresslIlg iilny opinion as to Fahnn's<br />
rights to return. It m,l)' 1)l' that the I,eglslatul'e<br />
did not fOl'see the result of these St'Chons<br />
when enacting th(;,Ill. Cll.~"iDl hl!" been eno.lbled to<br />
mtrouuce a second wlte into N,ltaJ, .Ilthollgh Le already<br />
has n wife in exi:-.tcnce. But thiS cannot<br />
.tffect the interpretatIOn of the pl.nn and obvious<br />
language of the Statute. l\h. JU8tice C,wter concurred.<br />
Mr. Jnstict' Tatb,tUl sdicl he W,\S Itouhtflll<br />
flS to the UloMing of Section :~ (2) of Act 22 of In.!,<br />
and thought that the Section was amblgqously<br />
Wt~'I1. He. theleforf'. lookf'd to the tlttte ot the<br />
law when Act 22 of l!lH was p.u;"eJ. At that date<br />
all wives marnt>Ll under polrgamolls systpmR of l.1w<br />
'\vpre not wi\t'S at, all. ,lIld no IndulU could introduce<br />
any "Olll.lll 1I:'1 Illst ,,'ifp, eYf'1l If she W,\;l his<br />
ouly wlf(', If his religion permitted polyg.lUIY. In<br />
f \)11 Parh.lment introducP({ ,I rellH'd~·. awi his LOI'11-<br />
[hip thought that the Act l'E'ally meant th.lt .m Indian<br />
could only introdnce a WIfe if he kept one<br />
Iwom:t.n to be trc:ltell as bll; wifl' in tt'l'lIlR of the<br />
immigratIOn la"s. HHo C.Issim W,IS tlt'.ltlllg" two<br />
women as IllS wivps for. the purpose of the immigration<br />
law. His Lords 1 11p did not dissent, but concUFred<br />
With great hesltalloo.<br />
The question put was answered in the negative.<br />
The woman Ayesha wa" givpn her costs against the<br />
BOJ.rll.-i\!alol Jlercury.<br />
W.\NTED LES~ AN'.(I-NATIONALISM .AND<br />
~IURE PRO-HU~IANITY<br />
To SOLVE THE PRESENT ECml'OMIC PROBLEM<br />
The follo'wing letter representing a very sane<br />
view of the Asiattc question appeared in a recent<br />
I""lle of the NaJal Af~CU,.y :-<br />
Sir,-Letters appeanog III your columns npon the<br />
ASlatIc question are more or less in the nature of an<br />
intermittent flow, but in spite of all thJ.t has been<br />
written and said concerning this economically importJ.llt<br />
sectton of N~tal's population, we, as a people,<br />
do not seem to make auy defiUlte move towards discl)vering<br />
a solution ~ the problems arising out of<br />
the existence of the Asiatic m South Africa.<br />
No doubt many people are in sympathy with th~<br />
pomts of vif'w as expressed by .. Townsman" and<br />
.. A Countryman" in your recent columns, and<br />
there may be various reasons why thy are so, but<br />
we may safely suppose that the dominating reasons<br />
may be traced to '-<br />
(a) Race and colour prejudice.<br />
(b) A partial realisation of economic differences.<br />
(c) A beltef that ASiatics in the industry and_commerce<br />
of Africa are occupying jobs which should<br />
nghtIy belong to the present white population of<br />
the Union, and,<br />
(d) The fact that the majol'ity of ,people a.re more<br />
01' le~~ totally Ignorant of the economic workings of<br />
the system under whICh we live.<br />
It.is rather dIfficult to confine this matter to the<br />
restrlCted colnmns of the Press, but it is of such<br />
paramount importance as to warrant considerable<br />
time being spent upon it, even to the extent ot<br />
darmg to fly in the 'face of public opmion, for there<br />
mnst be qUIte a number of peopJe to whom it is<br />
glaringly apparent, that in order to cure the evils<br />
popularly ascribed to the presence of the AsiatIC, we<br />
must be prepared to go to much greater lengths than<br />
the mere curtailing or refusal of licences.<br />
One may be sympathetically mclined towards<br />
those who advocate the repatrIation of the whole<br />
AsIatic population, but even these must give way to'<br />
the stubborn fact that the South African-born Asiatic<br />
is a South African subject of the King, geogI-aphically,<br />
of COUl'Re, and IndIa bas as much right to<br />
-treat one RO born as a foreigner to Ihdia, as England<br />
would have ill refusing recl'>gnition to the South<br />
Afr1C.l,n horn of EUJ..(lish parents.<br />
In this connection I may mentiou that Geneml<br />
Smuts, when dealmg with the m,ltter ot the deportment<br />
of Emoppans from South Africa Some years<br />
a;.;o, when questioned as to why he had not deported<br />
the Routh African colleague!'! with the deportees,<br />
replied to the effect that South Africa toust cor.<br />
sume its OWn smoke. III any case, we may take<br />
it as an acct'pted fact that South Africa is the home<br />
of people hoi'll in the country, and t.hat being the<br />
ca.,e, we 1 annot legally expel those IruJians _who<br />
were hom hel't'. Thl:'! fact is a poser to the advocate<br />
of - lock, stock and b,m'el" repatriation, but unf::rtnnatfoly,<br />
the anti-Asiatic Will not accept this<br />
tact, and is consequently led mto worse confnsion.<br />
The scheme next in favour to repatriation is<br />
!\egregation, aml this too appeals strongly to those<br />
who do not stay to consider all that it may mean.<br />
~oo m,m}" Em'opeans ! YJ.C.lte.l by the ,Iep,lI'tl'ti In.han. For many who<br />
ddvvc,\tt: t,lli.s step, it would .1PP(;',t,r that they Wt'l't.l
INDIAN OPINION February 13th, 1925<br />
firm beilevers of .. out of sight, out of mllld," bnt<br />
ASIatIc segregation would not work out So tllmply us<br />
that, out of sIght they rUlght be, but so long as they<br />
were in SOllt):J. Atnca they could never be out of<br />
mmd, dnd for variolls reasons, but chiefly becduse<br />
no system of segregatIon Cdll cut them off from<br />
competmg agaulflt the reklt of, our populatIon or<br />
from competlllg against the best ot the worM.<br />
.. A Countrymen" ,tppeal'S to be chiefly cOllcelned<br />
wIth the ASIatic as d
February 13th, 1925. JNUIAN OPINION .45 '<br />
TH~ CONTRAST IN INDIA<br />
BRITISH OrUII'IOIi ON !NDUN POLITICS<br />
The fQllowing \$ an editorial artide in a' recent<br />
hltme of Tlte Natlll'" and Athenaeum -<br />
It ;s rar() for any eouutry to dillPlay so striking a<br />
eontraHt between commerciaJ prOSPel ity and politic.<br />
: distress as that which Iwlla I1ffords to-day. If<br />
we are to take the Vicerof's word for it, (and there<br />
can be" no reasoJ). why we shoul£! not). Indian<br />
ecopomic cOJ)d).tions }lave not for many years been<br />
call).parable with those of the prellent winter. The<br />
AHElociated Cbambers of Commerce, which have<br />
been meetiQ/l in C,llclltta, are 'theijlselves a sign of<br />
the till).es. They repre&,ent the cO-Qrdmated businei\li<br />
(orces of Britjsh India. n was to this hody<br />
that Lord Reading presented his "prosperity" report<br />
of the Indian year. Abounding crol?/!. the railway<br />
earnip8s leaping up by crores of rupees, and II<br />
Reaborne tra,de rapidly overtaldngtJIe highest rej}Ords;<br />
jute and tea "bMWng in the sunllhine Of an abundant.<br />
pI'oflperjty;" an expected B\}dget SUrphli! bringin"<br />
relict o! taxation-sucb are ~he principal items iIf<br />
t~e VjceroY'i! ilurvey. The reCItal of theD;l. is,<br />
inveitably, bnked With certain fjtatements ~ULl<br />
in;IpliGations conceming the change of GovernJIlent<br />
ill London and the ~ssumption that the direction of<br />
Imperial _II-ffairl\l mar not be altered within a term<br />
of five years W' so. Tbat is as mllY b~; but it<br />
should be remarkf'd that the Brjtjs4 commercIal<br />
community in India rejlards tbe contlitioJ)s descnbed<br />
by Lord Reading I1S being bound up with the<br />
return to a more resolute temper iu the Administrati9U,<br />
an
'1!.:t1.f::!4:.:.6_-----------IN-D-IA-~_.U-1'-I-N-l-U-N-----P.!bru~ry 23th, 192~<br />
permanency to the terms of the coercion Ordinance.<br />
It is peI'fectly plain that there is no peace to be<br />
obtained by such means. The Governmen,t would<br />
be wise to limit the scope of the summary procedure<br />
iii the tltrictest fashion; to aim at the quickest<br />
possible release of snch prIsoners as may be able<br />
io clear themselves of the cllarges of sedition and<br />
conspiracy; and above a11, ,to return, as rapIdly as<br />
lllay be, to l'el1anCe upon the ordinary. law .. Lord<br />
Reading as we know IS convlllced that hIS Ordmance<br />
was neces~ar~T. Hutmo Government that is strong<br />
and whm call attempt to rule by emergency<br />
lileasures.<br />
\<br />
GANDHI<br />
, [By EDWARD B. HOOPER" M. A.,<br />
VICAR OF NORT.lWRPE]<br />
_ We take the following very interesting article from<br />
tlie bncolnshire Clzr(Jntl'ie dated 22nd Nov. 1924 :-<br />
One of the most remarkable world personahtles<br />
of to-day is Gandhi, possibly at once one of the bestloved<br />
men and the most hated and detested, a sure<br />
SIgn of greatness.<br />
It will be a good thmg if Englishmen try and<br />
understand this strange indIvidual; we have inherited<br />
a great empire, and of that empire India i.s<br />
by far the greatest part, measured not in area,_ of<br />
course, but by population. In the past. many<br />
imposing empIres have come and gone: in the near<br />
,Past we have seen three great European empires<br />
pass away, is this British Empire of ours also to<br />
pass away? That question raises many problems.<br />
Have we the statesmen and the understanding to<br />
know how to _treat India with s~1mpathy, justice<br />
and goodwill?<br />
Should the -Empire-builder of to-day approach<br />
this problem in the spirit of racial domination, or<br />
with any Idea or sentiment for white superIOrity,<br />
then our EmpIre IS doomed.<br />
_~,_____ lm~W::a:L'J:E '~SUl'J\lRJOlU'lY:' _<br />
I fancy that the ,study of a man like Gandhi may<br />
-help us very considerably, If we fail to understand<br />
him we shall fail to understand Indla; but lf<br />
we, on the other hand, begin to understaud, such a<br />
man, it will inevitably cure us of any sense of<br />
white superiority.<br />
This Gandhi at one time held a lucratIve post'in<br />
So,uth AfrIca, but infiuenced by the writIngs of<br />
Tolstoi. and through Tolstofbecoming acquiainted<br />
With the famous "Sermon on the Mount," he began<br />
to take a warm interest in the couditions of his<br />
countrymen in that colony of the Empire to which<br />
he belonged.- With him religion and politics naturally<br />
went hand to hand-and he led au herote<br />
Passive Resistance Crusade In South AtrlCa 011<br />
b'ehalf of the Indians III that colony. when he returned<br />
to-inma he was reCeIved as a naho,nalleader<br />
and a saint, and to-day he is almost worshipped by<br />
millions of Hindus and Moslems, and surely we<br />
may aud loved by countless Christians too, In many<br />
lands.<br />
A MAN THE WORLD NEEDS<br />
He is a type Of the inter:national man that the<br />
world needs so badly III these days. He has discovered<br />
that "patriotism is not eno,ugh," and he has<br />
no hatred for any rae!' Df man.<br />
Just recently he has come into the hme-lIght<br />
thl'ough the completion of a fast o,f 21 days and<br />
nIghtS and was. the recipient of a great welcome<br />
organised by the Calcutta Co,rporahon. Tens of<br />
thousands were there to welcome him, and this<br />
demonstration III hIS honour was a most impressive<br />
spectacle.<br />
These events cannot be ignored, they are essentially<br />
Indian, and it is not easy lor prDsaic<br />
Enghshmen to 11ll(lerstand them., India is essentially<br />
a religiulls cuuntry, amI the Sd.IDe Cdnnut be said<br />
of England. English Dfficials are t'asily, too easily,<br />
inclined to look askance at these events-it IS so,<br />
unlike any of our English national habits, and they<br />
feel uncertain where it may }t'ad, and therefDre this<br />
great Indian is somewhat "sl1spect" hy our lcading<br />
ImperialIsts, but it is imparative to Uti tu try and<br />
understand. Gandhi is India's "man Df rt'hgioll,"<br />
and one of theIr master-mmds. (<br />
WHY HE FARTED ?<br />
liut, we ask ourselves, why dld Gandhi fast, and<br />
what was the purpose of thitl particular fdst' Fast.<br />
ing is an indlspensable feature of all Orumtal rehgions;<br />
here in the West it is prdctically unknown;<br />
a few Catholics talk about fasting, but it is nothing<br />
very serious; the only fastilig in England i1'l com.<br />
pulsory. due t~ unemployment or destitution, and as<br />
such has no value at all; it is different in the East.<br />
There it is an essentially relIglOus act.<br />
Gandhi has an abhorence of all acts of violence.<br />
and because of these deeds of violence perpetrated by<br />
his fellow-countrymen, he voluntal'i1y undertook<br />
this fast as an act of national penance: everyone<br />
kf)ew why he underwent this ordeal. During his<br />
fast he was visited by many religious and political<br />
It'.aders, IDen and women, Hindu and Moslem. and<br />
a remarkable Christian priest, C. F, Andrews has<br />
also been in constant attendance; in fact he is the<br />
great friend o,f this wonderful Gandhi, whom we<br />
hardly know whether to call Hindu or Christian Dr<br />
-Moslem, for he so perfectly invites in his perso,n the<br />
best spiritual and ethical principles for all three religions,<br />
as unique as it is unusual.<br />
~ A strange man undoubtedly. but his influence in<br />
India is immense, and surely it was an act of incredible<br />
stupidity for a former Government to<br />
lmprison snch a character. Fortunately, we relel>Sed<br />
hIm.<br />
A DISA'!TER<br />
But it is deplorable that at such a time as to-.day,<br />
with-India seething with discontent, but capable of<br />
being led by statesmen of real insight an(1 sympathy,<br />
'and possessed of lofty ideals, we shOttld ha V6 CUoIlt't}r'.<br />
a man like I,ord Birkenhead, of all men, as our new I,<br />
Secretary of State for India. a man who is a cynical<br />
disbeliever in all idealism, and thereby disqualified<br />
for any Indian post. Such an appointment is a<br />
disaster ot the first magnitude and a peril to the<br />
Empire.<br />
We shall never hold thc millions of India by the<br />
swo,rd-it is both impossible and undesirable-bot<br />
if we win the loyal affection and adherence of a<br />
Gandhi, the links of the Empire will be firmly<br />
welded, to the lasting benefit of India and Engl.md<br />
and mankind.<br />
======<br />
INDIAN QUESTION IN THE COUNCIL OF<br />
STATE<br />
A WITHDRA 'WN MOTlo.N<br />
Delhi, Feb. 9 (Reutel).-A lively dlscuBBion on<br />
the questio,n of the position of Indian subjects overseas<br />
was anticipated to-day in the Council of State<br />
- on the motion of Sir Deva Prasad Sarbadhikari, unofficial<br />
member of Calcutta, who tabled a requeet<br />
for the appointment of a Committee of members of<br />
the Central Legislatme and officials to repo,rt on th{~<br />
steps necessary to impro,ve the condit~on of Indianll<br />
overseas.<br />
Slnce the motIon was sent in, however, Lo,,_,<br />
Reading, in the cOUl'!!e of a sympathetic reply to a I<br />
represt'ntative deputatiol1 headed by Slr Dinshaw<br />
Petit, advised patience, and deprecated anything iike<br />
acrimony thdt might embarf'38t' the delIcate nf't;otiations<br />
now proceeding.<br />
In view ~f this advice, Sir Deva PI'aB.ld Sarba/lhikari<br />
withdrew his resolution, reserving, however,<br />
tht' right to mDve it later when the results of the<br />
nt'gotiations were known.<br />
::In' Mnhallou H ... lJibull ... h, ncw member in charg-t:
February 13th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 47<br />
of Emigration, infOl'med Sir D. P. Sarbadhikari that<br />
it would not he in the public interest to publish at<br />
this stage the correspondence with the South Afri-<br />
, can Go\'ernment, while correspondence I'elating to<br />
K"n~ a and Tau,L(anyika was only routine in charactf'r,<br />
News In Brief<br />
The Hmtlu (Madras) understands that Lady Sada!.<br />
siva Irer (wife of Sir T. Sadasiva Iyer) bas been<br />
offered and hall accepted a seat as Honorary M:agis~<br />
trate in the Children's Coart which will be established<br />
nnder the new Children's Act.<br />
-0-<br />
The late, Mr, Montagu took up ornithology -&; a<br />
hobby, and had one of the best stuffed collectionll<br />
in Europe. It is lI
.... ~, ~,""I~ l"t16~te'l<br />
l"'~lcl'ltl ,\h~ 0061 'Ill. !ktp.fl Cl~kI:. ~~ .~ ftll~~ , !~lch. fa' lkt~,H1,~ llolc.~ loRh lk1:~ l::1n: h,11c lJ?t h<br />
.(fi 00\ It. "'tr 11·!~n~; !loe ~blk1: !It toh In: i ~Mi~ 'J.ol~\)1~ IJ.t{.l}P 'JU:~l'a' lJ-.P~11a-J-.~1a- :Wie~ l]l,l))<br />
~~ltJ. tPr~hfe \::~ leE) ~~,~ tl~1'e~10 llt\J)~1:J ij6'eP ~~~ @ 'e'~l:j ~,~,11: PlJ lhJ"t 1~\1>~ Sil]'.l?t<br />
lin: ~ ~lC, '~I~R Ii l"'~!~ \n1l~~ li\!; ,~~ 1'" ~ ~1~ llslHl l~~ 13fiD ~1J-.P91116''''~1a- It!!=(P"{ 1~~11~11:<br />
~ l]'.Ie." ~ J;.Ut~ • ~ ~ ~e ~ It!1i 1ole1 It'pe~ '''lPl~ llUtl[ 0 {},l}Ohll-J.a ltl~fC ~~~ l~ lh~l-n:<br />
l1lj~ 'i'~lh 000 t: 1:: I "'i'I1\ li'fl l!:, lh li£,1$ lyl{Jo,T?, \y1l:~1' ~l' li 1t e le1 1i lYlPhob\e li'J~lel1!: ll'el'i:<br />
\)l" 1l-I-§)1?h,{ ~l]'.I lt~~l~~hUtl-llf lltJ.§)l?h{ I l~~ GiilJn !kll1~llfl: ~~3 { ~ ~li e~~ lhU:\<br />
'Ie' 1~li 1~.1l-h'ln: lP-11: 1Y1bU 't 'In:~c tc?~< I clhli~ hll)l.}fJ1n: ll::ll.llt!: lll}tlf '~'E;lffi: !~lhcl[ loll[<br />
-IJ'\It.'i'~ \)o~ h'fcl~ ~€,1$ lltJ.>J.all1l ~ tlfl: 1~''''~li , lilln: m.llR: ~ll- l::~lP ,lhlPk,~ 1f.>lf;1hln:' l::lt ... lolll~<br />
r1"12 1~lth l- ~f> tl~1~~ltln: lloJ.lf~~I~~ tlbhl~< ; 1lfl: \'CP ~ 15~ !to:)l~ !ltlhj\llfl: l-Rh ~ p~, t: I If,<br />
lin 1160 W~,M: t~ 1k"~1?l-f11h lh~f Ij~ ~I}a I ~J.o lltl~~''ft. "Ik. \)1 ch, H,Ii'il ~h~tr'flt 1l-Ija:Vl,~<br />
lit \;;7\ '0 l~rt e~~ l~h:~~ '1:'.IP'~ \eP 1~1"'}q<br />
_ 'e·' Itlbel[ !lfc!A ~l}n 1):,J!; 1~eJ.a !kP?)lla-"~I6- stlclfl: ellt>l-n:<br />
fM?e rl~l~ lPlc~ J::~h\J)t tift. ~l}I~pb-:> 'h~~\~ ! ~\iUtr: t ~ellf 1[ 6<br />
lo tP~ e£,1$l}>I}oPiftitl-D ?:C(I1~ P~11:<br />
!I-klt Vl.~ \},l-g)I;l-.",lh p~ ll::l->l~~~It!~ ~h€) 't'l.ll~ ~llt Ilt'l.lffi: \P11..~ l!ll"""lJ<br />
'<br />
la: fl?lJ.o<br />
'I~~ l~tl hJ'e7 ;e,lhhltl< l~~,R lP1tll- l:;e"'~ el-Cl:lc ll-jlf1J1lfl: l'c€)I~ tnttltRlb 'Il- \Jut ll<br />
"I-Q~~Il!~ l~~l~ l-la:~:J'~ J..~lr"'f\lh II lkkL?1}t lfl-la-~~I~~ ~?,11:ek ~kelPll2l{, loM'~f\ la-llUn"<br />
~lk ~lQlt ~l1:.\)oc lhlt lPl~\)L'l) 11->1->€)I?J.oRlh , 'l~~ ,~~,,~, 114'V-t<br />
--- Ite)P lt~lltl'\ ~t}. !1tl:\,H1.lt 11->\.c·"'lJl~ !C1~m ~1?llo<br />
.~ ,,~ lJti Ia-U6'I\ ll'lb~lf ~" ~~~~fillb l::la: \::ellfcH: \)~ ~I~ctl~ ~13ltPI~ch. ~H: ffi.~~1 ;J.of.*~~<br />
lYl~);'II-J.a cl-tthl1 elHR t1etl:\ ~ 'e';l 'l~~ l~ol~ ~1~~ 11:?)l:elt ~lfl:lPl~lt I->h\}6 1~\iL~ en(~ f\J.alt<br />
=-~=-=-=-~~-- ------<br />
eln:lltle t lre Rlt<br />
" i.ffl: h.\~\ t}1lfl:~\ f.:\ M.l)IP '~tb'~ 'fl:1~1) t.lt f.:\ ~P~t\.<br />
l·lnlre11J~1!re ~lre~S1
-----<br />
(~pitti.Olt<br />
--------- ------- --c----- -------<br />
No.8-Vol. XXIII. Friday, February 20th, 1925-<br />
Registered at the G. P.O. as a Newspaper<br />
PalQs fouua.c.<br />
4 ""\"--- -~~~--~ - ----- -------~~- - - - --- - ----- --- -- ----------------<br />
'0' '<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
'1\l CORRE!::!PONDEN'f informt! us trom Johan<br />
L!'il ne!'hllrg that tl'e agitation (If the Soulhclll<br />
SllDurhs European ASl!ociatwn hal! gone so<br />
tar that the Indian storekcepel'f! In that District<br />
Ilave bad to comnder the lves mto fin ASBocldtlon to comb.!t the evil.<br />
With that view a Ine'etlllg was recently helil and<br />
III AssociatIOn has heen formed, 'fhere are in tha><br />
~jHtrict twenty-five to thlrtv Indian Htores, •<br />
'fhe following is the text of It recent leaflet<br />
muhtlhed bv the S, S, European ASSOCiation and<br />
mnted by Bake')', 'fhompson & Co, of Johannes<br />
JUrg -<br />
"Are you trading WIth the Coolie'" If so, YOll<br />
"ill realize the comleqllC'nce when YOlI find your<br />
lUl'lhalld and son disllliSHt'tl from theil' billets and<br />
'eplatf!ll hy Asiatics. Thj~ is It very Impodant<br />
,Jlleslioll tor (:very housewife to COntH,ler, When<br />
rOll deal wILh the Coolie yon IllUl:lt remember you<br />
tl'e l't'illoving the colour bar to deprl ve your own<br />
~hiltlren of employment, If you are btlll tradmg,<br />
IVlth the Coohe remember: we havtl your name on<br />
tho !Jst of defaulters to the wIllte btandar!l, and we<br />
'P8p('ctflllly solicit your co-operation in our enle'avonr<br />
to mamtuin a whIte suburb and put an<br />
'!loll to thiH sOCIal and. economic menace,"<br />
l . --- -.- .<br />
! 1.'60 1 ifllhannetlb\lrg cot'respond~nt of tile Xl/telt<br />
~/,.r,'b·1j givt"s an exa'mple of the \hovemlh't on"tl'JOt<br />
)f'lnaking South Africol a white mrlll'K eonntry.<br />
ren Native memberll of the Cat'lton Hotel staff.<br />
110 saYEl, have been dlsrH1ssed. and ten white boys<br />
I.akap on in their pl,lct', 'fhe m~nagement 6K the<br />
botel 111 onthusiastitl' over the '''White S~~~~ Arlri~a"<br />
I)Os~i~lities. ,i":rhey cost U~'t 1:.!1?,.fe, ·these ~oung<br />
\vhi~ l~ys/' it IS sta}e~ by thenl, but we have the<br />
~hanctl of making somethmg of them, and at the<br />
~dffie time they have the chance of becoming- good<br />
waiters and ('Ooks. Theil tlJey may earn thE'll' ,tl<br />
~very
50 INDIAN OPINION February 20th, 1925<br />
last Saturday. The boys ran into the compound.<br />
Van Wyk fell from his horse and. rising, fired three<br />
shots with his revolver, killing one of the boys<br />
instantly. Good $hootiIl.g, but what had the natives<br />
done?<br />
No EXPLOITATION<br />
Referring to the native question In Afrjca Mr. J.<br />
R. Thomas says: " OUT black fellow-subJects must<br />
be dealt with justly, »~tl!.lJltly, paternaJly. , We<br />
have accepted a great trUst which we must faithfully<br />
discharge. It cannot be shirked, an~ must not be<br />
neglected. Our only ,justIficatIOn for attaching<br />
these lands to our Crown is the beneficial nature Of<br />
our adminlistration, and the fact that 110 ex.ploita~ion<br />
of natIve races IS possible under our flag. "<br />
The canting humbug.-<br />
--~-,<br />
CIVILISING THE ARABS<br />
Lord Thomson, Air Minister m the late British<br />
Labour Government, in a speech to a select<br />
crowd 'of British cap'italists, described a bombing<br />
expedition ~~ainst drab tribesmen in Arabia.<br />
n Th'e effect of our air attack was appallIng," he<br />
saia.. " Some 700 ~ibest'neIl. 'Were ldll'ed, and the<br />
rest, seized with panic, fled into the desert, whet;e<br />
hundrl'lds inore must have p~ru~hed from thirst. "<br />
So dId the pious pacifult Ramsay MacDonald do<br />
the work of bls CIlpitalist m.astel'S.<br />
We beg to mform oar readers. ,subscrIbers<br />
and friends that our representative Mr: Ardeshir<br />
Dinshaw is at present touring the Cape and the<br />
Transvaal jn connection WIth INDIAN OPINION<br />
work and'we earnestly hope that he will be given<br />
every assista:hce as In the past for which we are<br />
ever grateful.<br />
THE TOWN HALL MEETING<br />
THE Town Hall meeting of the lith instant l)f<br />
'11 ~ tbe'bur~esses o'fDllrban wllien was o-rganized<br />
by Counci'n
__ P_e_b_r_u~~ry~_20_t_h_'_f~~?,~!S~ ________ lN __ U_l_A_N-.U __<br />
burgesses, while also he insisted that to preside did<br />
not mean taking an active part in the meeting.<br />
The Mayor restricted his remarks to the first<br />
resolution in connection with the propo.red remo.val<br />
of cert ... in licence revenues from the Natal MOUldl'~litlell<br />
anll said it was desu'ed that by thf'lf vote the<br />
l>OOple of Durhan would that evening bhow clearly<br />
tD the Government that thf'Y sl.l:ougly rtxp~ed regret that polIticians of<br />
other ProvmcCR. when speaking of this matter,<br />
always matie the remdl'k that it WdS the people of<br />
Natal who broug-ht the Indians to this countl'Y. The<br />
speakt'f denied thill aut.! SllltI, as he holU 8.1i£ tme<br />
only in tile number of licences III Durb.ln-the<br />
Asiatil'$ could not bq jU8t as pleased as the Europe,\n<br />
traders at this, he allded,<br />
_<br />
Finally Generdl Wylie saiil tl11 m~eting .could not<br />
do better than b,ICk np the Governml'nt in its published<br />
views of the qnestion-than a;lk the Gon-mlIleut<br />
to give effect to its statemE'nt-and ill thiS<br />
c6nnectiori he quoted !It len!{th from a 8prE'ch upon<br />
the subjeot by the Mmister of the Intel'1ol'.<br />
anothE'r staunch advoe Lte of the III tlotenallce of<br />
EllropeJ.n SlllJl'elU-\cy in DI'. MrKerv:ie, sPc'mlle.} the<br />
resolution, an.1 initi,ll\y I\sslwed the .\;I\,ltICS that<br />
Enropoons did not - object to tl1em as a mce.<br />
l\rknowlei1ging that th~y w~re It \E'IY fine, noble,<br />
and olltt;talHiing raoe with a gre&t hi"torJ', But<br />
they -din eret. frol)l Europeans, dltrer('ll in ev(>!'y<br />
way, and,it w,tS not concelVable th,\t they should be<br />
, uccepted on an eqllal le\el.<br />
He dwelt nt length upon the enormOllS popnl.t-<br />
'tion of Inthd. that couM be l'eleasetI upon al1~' I<br />
country wbel·!.' their tOUlpatriots g..lillt'd the SlIpl e<br />
macr, hoMing this up :1.'> a l11en:I('O that lIIH"t n.lt ht'<br />
an~v~l to M
is that for the time being I am c-alled upon to smk<br />
my own views and be prep .. reu to presIde at any<br />
prop~rly convened public meeting. and that I am<br />
called up to exercise a spirit oflimpar~Iality in such<br />
matters irrespective of the displeasure I may incur<br />
in any quarter."<br />
GANDHI AND SOUL-FORCE<br />
A..L~<br />
AMERIC.ll '1,'RIBUTE<br />
What has led a people, mll-de up of divergent religions.<br />
clashing social classes and lany shades of<br />
political opinion, to unite in calling him J\fahatmaji?<br />
Many disagfee 'Wlth him on political and other<br />
matters, but I know 'Of none who refuse hIm the<br />
title. The writer finds hImself among tlIose who<br />
cordially disagree with him in a good many things<br />
and yet who gladly and whole-heartedly call hIm<br />
Mahatma. He has gone through the stages of misunderstanding.<br />
calumny and abuse. and yet by<br />
sheer force of character has compelled universal<br />
acklIowl(tlgment that he IS a Mahatma. "the great<br />
!lOuled." This is " soul-force" of no ~n calibre.<br />
It h1ts brought hIm the largest personal following of<br />
alii" hVlllg man III the world to-day. -What IS the<br />
secret of it?<br />
Any attempt to analyze him or to ClasSIfy him is<br />
.. nigh fntile and impossible for Gandhi IS made<br />
up of- very diverse and sometimes seemingly inconsistent<br />
element Dr Rabindranath Tagore was<br />
asked by a lady, m the West/to fill ont a questionnaire<br />
card and give hIS weak point and his strong<br />
point; under each he wrote one word "InconSistency.<br />
" Gandhi could have written that with ev~m<br />
more truth'than Tagore. Bllt as a French philosopher<br />
has remarked that" no man is strong unless<br />
he bears within his character antitheses strongly<br />
marked. " so GandhI IS strong because he does bear<br />
tlIese antitheses within himself in a -remarkable<br />
blend.<br />
He iSthe meetinJ:(place of a good many scattered<br />
ideals and movements going through India to-day.<br />
For'inst'l.nce he sums, :up -the diverse ideals of<br />
ascetiHsm and service. -' The one IS an old ideal to<br />
IncUa. the other- newer o-n~ that is gripping the soul<br />
of th~ people. ;<br />
, " POWER OF SOUL POROE<br />
G ..mdhi has realised that m th~s giving up of<br />
things lies power. He MIls it .. 1\0nl-fo1'ce. " It is<br />
a sublj.matiou and modIficatiQn of the old t pa.~/JJ or<br />
undergoing of austerities m order to gam "ower<br />
ovet· "gals" and" over all -the worlds." But in<br />
GJ.ndhi it is more than that. and finel". During the<br />
terI'ible hme ot his twentY-Qne days' fast because of<br />
the' dlVlsio?s _o~"i" his people, ¥r. C. E:. A~re,,:s<br />
writes of hIm: M''S'zgaze tllrrt~ 'pack to the frad<br />
wasted, tortured spIrit on' the' 1:el:r11ce, by .my side.<br />
bea.ring-the sins anci"sQTrUWS of hIS people: With a<br />
rush"Of.emotion there came to memory the passage<br />
fl'om th~ Book of Lamentations. • It is nothing to<br />
you, all "l'e that pass by? Behold ~nd see. if there<br />
is any s(n"t'Qw like unto my sOl·row.' And in that<br />
hour of vls1on. I knew more deeply, m my own<br />
,personal lif&t~~lle meaning of the 9ross." Many d<br />
Hmdu unabl~to umlerstand doctrinally the meaniug<br />
of tlIe CroS~ has seen it as by a flash in Gandhi.<br />
One of the leaders of the national Il\Ovempnt excloaimed<br />
: " J never understood wh,tt your missionarIes<br />
were talking about until I saw the meanIng of<br />
the Cross in Gandhi." The le~dIng SOCial thinker<br />
of India when Gandhi was Jaded wrote in his paper:<br />
.. What the missional'Ies have not been able to do in<br />
fifty years. Gandhi by his tridl and incarceration has<br />
done, he has turne.l the eyes of India toward the<br />
Cross." He realises that m this way of thinking<br />
and acting there lies power-the finest amI final<br />
type of power.<br />
INDIAN O!,INION February 20th, 1925<br />
When he was in E" outh Afried fighting the battle<br />
for IndIan liberties lind rlghts by his passive resI~tance<br />
movement the~,imlentnr('d ()oohes got out of<br />
haml and did things that greatly pained him. He<br />
remonstrated with tltem to no avail. Then Without<br />
a word he went off 3nd~egan to fast. He hau f,lsted<br />
for two days when word went around among the<br />
coolies that he was ~fasting because of what they<br />
were doing. That ~changed the Situation. They<br />
came to him wlth fdded hands and begged him tf~<br />
desist. assuring him that!they wonld dD anythmg r<br />
he \vould only stop this infhctlOn of sutTering OIl<br />
himself. That was prowess.<br />
When in the Ashram::One of the boys told Gandhi<br />
something tllat he believed. but which ldter he<br />
found out to be a he. Gandhi called the school together<br />
and said ... I am SOl'ry to find out that one of<br />
you is a liar. As punishnumt I am gomg to<br />
fast to-day." That boy could never get ovel' the<br />
fact that the man who RO cared for him WdS sl1fftring<br />
on his own account. Long after any physic.ll<br />
pain would have died away this mental and spmtudl<br />
pain persisted .and punished him. That is power.<br />
His asceticism is thus tOllched by a very tine unseillsh<br />
quility. The old Wlcetlc seldom or llewr<br />
served. ,To him it was largely a matwr of :.,ramlllg<br />
power for himself by asceticism. But Gandhi ble-nds<br />
ascptiClsm and service. One without the other is<br />
weak; taken together. as m Gandhi. they are tl"t.llll(llldously<br />
strong. Gandhi is a servant. He has never<br />
bid for power. It has come to him through service.<br />
A crisis came to him in South Africa when after<br />
reading Ruskin's" Unto This Last," he renouncl"d<br />
everything for the sake of and .. unto this Id.bt."<br />
The least and the last are constantly in his thonght.<br />
He is a serving asc~tic.<br />
A BLEND OF HINDU AND CHRISTIAN ELEMENTS<br />
But to understand Gandhi we must know him<br />
in regard to the source of his mOl"dl and spIrItual<br />
life. He is a blend of Hmdu and Christian elements.<br />
He is a deeply religions man. Thls can be<br />
seen by a glimpse into his soul at ,the t\ill~ Qf two<br />
great crISiS in his life. One was when he was ahout<br />
to begin civil disobedIence on a large scale. I ft,It.<br />
there would be a chaos and a bl'cakup If he should<br />
begin it. so I wrote hIm II letter begging him not to<br />
do. Out of that crltical momeut came b.\ck this<br />
letter ... :'flay I assure YOIl I WIll not emb .., k on<br />
civil disobedience without just c.'l.use. wlthout pl'oper<br />
- precautions an,l wh.1t if! mOI'e without COPIOUi PI'dY<br />
.ing. I !lin. pr-aying lllght ana .1 ~y for light and<br />
gUIdance in the matter. You hwe pel'haps no<br />
notion of the wrong that th18 Government has done<br />
and is still doing to the vital part of onr being. But<br />
I mtlst not argue. I invite YOIl to Pl-ay Wit'l and for<br />
me." ThIS reveals an lUtensely religious !I'>ul.<br />
Another instance. Neal' the end of Ins fast h~<br />
WrItes: .. To-day istthe twentieth day 01 my penance<br />
and prayer. Presently from th(~ \\IOI·ld of pe;,,~e<br />
I shall enter tllf' world of strife. The more I think<br />
of it the more, hefpless I feel. So mAny expect m ...<br />
to bring togetheJ' the political partIes. I know I c.m<br />
do nothing. God can do everything. 0 God. mdke<br />
me a fit mstrument and n,;e m·~ as Thou wilt." _<br />
He said when he came out of jail that hIS inten,t.ion<br />
was to" e~t1.hhsh the Kin~~lom of God in In4,lll. '"<br />
Now Gandhi 18 a Hindu." He c1.11s hhI\¢f' on~.<br />
He has s,"11 -that there wa» a tIme wlliA' he .... ~<br />
wavermg betweE!n all iilleglance to ChrIstianity or<br />
Hinduism. and he d~ted that" tor me s,lIvation<br />
lay Within Hinduism." Bilt Hinduism is a very I<br />
wide terro. One c.m beheve in almost anything and<br />
still be a Hlllllu P,l.Iltheism or d.theism. transmigration<br />
or no trLlnsmigration, caste or no caste. karma<br />
or forgiveness. -But because (}aendhi is a Hindu it<br />
does not mean that he could not be ChrIstian in the<br />
very springs of hIS ch lracter and dl".1W up a b'l"e'
FehrlJ.1ry ~nth, 1925 INUJAN OPINION . S3<br />
Sf'rrnon on lite ~[()llnt cOUlpe~s almo;!t on eqnal<br />
tel-mil \\ Ith the Bh.1g"J.va.1 Glta fill' the domination of<br />
my heart_ " -<br />
Thl' 1l'.tJing social thinker of India, a Christian<br />
editor an. I ~fahatma Gandhi were takl'n together<br />
whton the first named said" Well, it is very difficult<br />
for nil to lIay wh8re our Hinduism ends and where<br />
,our Chrilltianity beginll_" And turning to Mahatma<br />
Flandhi he said, "Iso't that so, Mahatma Gandhi i'''<br />
After a moment's thought he replied: .. Yes. that 19<br />
110_ • Our Hinduism __ •. Our Christianity_ ..<br />
FoB.l! VITAL THINGS<br />
How thoroughly be grasped some of the essentials<br />
of Chl-istianity is revealed in one of the talks the<br />
writer had with him. I suggested to him that I<br />
was very (lDxious to see Christianity naturalized in<br />
Inllia not a foreign thing but a part of the national<br />
life and contributing its power to the uplIft of Iudia.<br />
I asked him what he would suggest that we should<br />
do ill order to make that pOSSIble. He thoughtfully<br />
r
-2,4 __ _<br />
fronted, along the great borderland of the OCCIdent<br />
ami the Ol'lent extending throQgh NOJ,thel'n. Aj 1'I('.t<br />
and acrOSf! Weiltern anel l<br />
Cen.t,l'at' "\>11.1, trolll tlw<br />
Nort,hwesterl1 Atlantic to the "horeR oj the Intlutn<br />
Ocean, and even beyond." .<br />
OF ,INTEREST TO THE SPORTSMAN<br />
., W1:IEl't 1{AN.JI'li<br />
was intel'vIewed by the neWSPaPE'rs on the no-balling<br />
of ~jrnest ,Jones bv Jim PhIllips He supported the<br />
\lmplI'C lU a few nice httle remad{s. Of course It<br />
would have be"Em,bettm' it the hinous Imhan had reo<br />
m CE'mett>ry.<br />
A. O. JONES.<br />
Town Clerk.<br />
TO"wn Ole['k's OfficE',<br />
])m1>an, l.'ith .January. 1!12:l.<br />
:ttl~'lYrll.!- !I~~(,\ltt~l ~ ~~l:~ (':t J .)!,.c d. ':;'J- ~.:;'r' \:J~" ss keeplng him ohl. of the TE'st nutch tW9 days J. ,}, .... ,,,, ,::>. r.( ~.Jl.. ~(J4) .:;.\ ... "~! ~-5J1t rlj<br />
ahe
urging the submission to the League of Nations<br />
,of t?e g-rie"!ances of ~he Indians in Tanganyika,<br />
pa!hcularly III connectIOn with the law requiring<br />
them to keep their acconnts in English. Mr. Rangach.'lriar,<br />
as a mE'mber of the Colonies Committee<br />
and Sil' Siva Swamy Alyer (India's representativ~<br />
to' the Leag'qe of ':tfations) llupporwd .the resolution.<br />
The supporter,s of the motion uttered a warning<br />
tJ( t India was likE'ly to a,bandon the League unless<br />
she bene~tted from her membership.<br />
BRITISH INDIAN COJ"ONIAL MERCHANTS<br />
\ ASSOCIATION " '<br />
DJ'I'HIS Associatton w~s fOll~ded in the yea!' 1920<br />
11 at Bombay and Its obJects are to' safeguard<br />
the commercial rights and interests of Indian<br />
merchants and secure for them the· same rights'<br />
and priVileges as those of other subjects in the<br />
Colomes of the British Empire and to protect<br />
the civil and political rights of Indians resident<br />
in thc Colonies. The first annual report of<br />
this Association' relates tht> history of events<br />
that led to the formation of the body. For some<br />
years past !he Indiaxi merchants resIding and<br />
trading m the Colonies and especially in East Africa<br />
found themselves confronted with the various, disabilities<br />
in conducting their business and the events<br />
came to such a stage that Indian merchants -in East<br />
Africa decided to get-their grit>van~es' ~earessed 9Y<br />
sending a deputation to H.E. the Vicemy of Indi.a.<br />
This deputation consisted of leading Indians,of EaSt<br />
Africa. On' the deputation returning to Bombay<br />
the memberS felt the necessity of an.organisation of<br />
Indian merchants representing those trading in or<br />
WIth the Colonies and a general meeting was called<br />
for the pUJ:pose on the 13th August 1920 of all those<br />
interested in the' problem and an association was<br />
duJ.y formed and nltmed the British Indian Colonial<br />
Merchal)ts AssoClation. The President,of this association<br />
is the Hon'ble Mr. Purshottamdas Thakord~<br />
C.I.E., M.llE., whose active work in the interests of<br />
Indians In the Colmlies in the Indian Legislative<br />
Assembly and otherwis~ IS well known. A peruilal<br />
of its annual reports gives us an idea of the in~<br />
valuable services rendered by the As!!ociation since<br />
its inceptlOn to Indians especially in East and South<br />
Africa in the shape of protests and representations<br />
to the Government on matters affectlllg their commerCIal<br />
anq.political interests.<br />
'<br />
One of the latest acts of the Association is highly<br />
p:Q.i1anthropic as will be seen from the following<br />
extract of a"circular letter addressed to the Edito~'~'<br />
and Proprietors o{ the newspapers conducted, bi<br />
Indiaps in the various parts of the E""mpire by the<br />
President of the Association The lette!' IS dated<br />
20th January 1925 :-<br />
"Dear Sir,~At the t.st general meetin~ of the members<br />
of this ASSOCiation held 10 my o'ticelon the 3d instant the<br />
members of the Associalion vol'lDtarily raised a subscriptlO';<br />
in order to send a small slim to various neWl>papers conducted<br />
by Indians in the various parts of the EIIl lire. The Idea of<br />
thIS was to communlclle to the editor; of '·arlOus plpers the<br />
approval of tbls Association 1D the wo!k they bave b!en<br />
dOing blllloW fo~ the betterment of the condition of Indum<br />
in the various parts of the Empire. I have pleasure in<br />
enclOSing h(.rewith a Bank duCt for a Slim of £50, as II<br />
small mark of our appreciation oC your work till now and I<br />
beg to convey to you the best wishes of my ASSOCIation for<br />
your ultimate success in the calise of Indl!!-ns you have so<br />
well espouied. • • • • Any other 'IIssi$tance that this<br />
INDIAN OPINION February 27th, 1925<br />
~soclation can render to you alld to IndIan. in your area.<br />
~I.ll recelv~ the most careful attention of the CommIttee! of<br />
hIS A'lSoclahon. • • • • Assuring you of tbe keenest<br />
mterest of. tbe Committee 01 my Assoclatlol in 1011•<br />
welfare.-\ ours Trnly.-(Sgd.) PURSHOTrA.'fDAS THAR<br />
KURDAS, President, Britlsb Indian ColonIal Merchants<br />
AssoCiatIon. "<br />
Thi~ practical example of the moral and material<br />
help 111 the cause of their fellow-countrymen out.<br />
side lndia redounds greatly to the credit of thE> ~<br />
Association.<br />
We beg to express onr sincere appreciation and<br />
our deep sense of gratitude to the President and<br />
members of the British Iudian Colonial Merchants<br />
Association for their kind contribution and for the<br />
interest they are taking in our cause, and whil ....<br />
heartily thanking the Association for its good wi8hes<br />
we wish to reciprocate the same to the Association.<br />
" YET ANOTHER ORDINANCE<br />
N anot~er column we reproduce from the Kllla(<br />
IT Plol'Jf/,raal Gazelle a section of the Draft Ordinance<br />
to amend the Local Township LJW Xo. 11.<br />
1881, in respect of the qualification of vot€rs, intend-<br />
-ed to be tntroduced into the Provincial Council<br />
dUring the Ilext Session. This will be the fourth<br />
attempt in the Natal Provincial Council to disfranchise<br />
Indians residing in Townships. The first<br />
attempt was made in the year 1921 when a Privatt><br />
Draft Ordinance was introduced by Mr. G. ll. Hnlett<br />
M. P. C" The intention of the Ordinance was<br />
the same as that of the present one, but the form of<br />
~he Ordinance was different. In letter and in spirit<br />
It was openly racial. It disqualified a person wh()" not<br />
being of European origin was a native or desc€'ndant<br />
in the male line of Ndtives of countries which<br />
have not, prior to the coming into- force 'of the<br />
~outh Africa Act, 1909, possessed elective representative<br />
institutions founded on the P~rliam€'ntay<br />
franchise." Under the Clrcumstances the Ordinauce<br />
failed to receive the assent of the Gov€'rnor<br />
General-in-Council. .Mr. Hulett, however was a<br />
hard nut and he re-introduced the Ordinance in<br />
,the same form in the year 1922 and it again failed<br />
to receIve the assent of the Governor-General-in<br />
Council. Notwithstanding his failure, however, on<br />
his l'e-introducing his Ordinance in the year 192:5-<br />
for the third time Mr. Hulett had the satisfaction<br />
of knowing that his persistency was not entirely<br />
fruitless; for, the Provincial COQncil had on this<br />
occasion introduced on its own a Draft Ordmance<br />
having the same object as that of Mr. Hulett's but<br />
in a greatly improved form in that it was completely<br />
shorn of its racial character. This Ordinance.<br />
however, had not the very far-reaching effect as did<br />
Mr. Hulett's Ordinance for it disqualified only those<br />
who were" unable, by reason of deficient education<br />
to read and write at least one of the offidallangnag~<br />
of the Union to tM sali'!!arfl.n oftlv per.ool/ prt-parmg<br />
flU' Town Roll." (Italics are ours). But this Ordinance<br />
as also Mr. Hulett's Private Ordinance were<br />
both, however, ill-fated and were rejected. Then.<br />
last year came the Dr.ut Boruughs Ordinance which<br />
was venomous to the extreme and tackled the questIon<br />
of franchise at its very- root. That that Ordm-<br />
! ance would be assented to br the Governor-Generdl<br />
J.n-Council was beyond all our expectations. But
February 27th, 1925 -INDIAN OPINION 57<br />
to our utter astonishment and keen disappointment<br />
the Ordinance was ass('nted to and -thns the<br />
the Indians have heen deprived of their municipal<br />
f~chise. The preSt-nt Draft Ordmance now is, a.-l<br />
VoVpre, to merely cut the hranches after the root hd8<br />
be!n entirely dis pOlled of. The Ordinallce is drafted<br />
on the Ilame lines as the Boroughs Ordinance anti<br />
there is hardly any doubt that it WIll pass through<br />
the Provincial Council. And as to its bf>ing IhlnctlOned,<br />
it would be inconsistent on the part of the<br />
• Govprnor-General-in-Council not to sanction it having<br />
once sanctioned the Notal Boroughs Ol·dmance.<br />
After the passing of the Ordinance into ldw, to the<br />
delight 'of the Anti-Asiatics their noble task of<br />
ditlfranclusing Indians in Nat rnment in Inulcl whicl: l is so ['otten that while<br />
. llch as those of S' "'r' 'I art' I. II' .ul( 'hd.el O'Dwyer and Dyer<br />
~<br />
poss osslble tleahng out jusb' 'ce unadlliterd.ted is im<br />
" hIe. T!H~ present COllrt d of justice In Imli,\ arE'<br />
Irt of tlMt system dU'..! ;evt: 'I"dl instclnces hd.ve shown<br />
~<br />
learl,Y that even the judges 'lare not able to nse their<br />
wn Judgment but are alway )s guided by the sy8kxu<br />
. ~<br />
which feeds them. Hence it is as diffi.:mlt in India<br />
to get justice as it is for the black man to get justice<br />
in this country. The Privy Council, on the other hand,<br />
is not under the inftuence of this system and is an<br />
institutIOn away from and Unpolluted by any prejudICes.<br />
Hence the only hope of getting adjusted the<br />
-wrongs done under the system prevalent in India<br />
is to go to the Privy Conncil. This is why Pundit<br />
)IoWal ~ehru saill it was useless to think of establishing<br />
a Supreme Court in India without attdining<br />
freedom, and this is why the SWaJ'd.jists expl'estled the<br />
op'mion that it wlllt impossible to obWn in (the<br />
present) India that healthy atmosphere, free from<br />
10Cc11 prejudICe such as was possible in England.<br />
We would remind our contemporary that the<br />
Bwarajists or the Non-co-operators in India have<br />
nothing against the British or the British institutions<br />
as such but the)' are against the perverteJ systeul<br />
nnder which tholle institutio.ns are being run. Moreover,<br />
India is fighting for the same freedom as that<br />
enjoyed at present by South Africa. Misconstrumg<br />
of facta by our contemporary is, therefore, either Intentional<br />
or, as we have said above, onr contemporary<br />
is living in a fool's paradise. As to the "abysmal<br />
state of affairs India would at once return the<br />
moment the last trdnsport carrying British soldiers<br />
and officials left Bombay," we think that India<br />
would prefer that "abysmal state of affairs" to<br />
the present system that governs them, for they<br />
would at least have the satisfactIOn that in a fight<br />
between two parties there is not a third' one under<br />
the guise of protection eating out the vit
INDIAN OPINION . February 27th, 192 5<br />
'Provided also however that no' person who at the<br />
1st day of January. 1~)2,5, was E'nrolle(l liS a \ ol('1'<br />
upon the Town Roll of any township shall be tb.squalIfied<br />
for or disentitled to such enrolment I!I<br />
that townshIp merely by reason of not bemg a Br.ltish<br />
subject, or for non-comphanc~ wIth the for,;<br />
golU'" provislOh In regard to parlIamentary qnalfi<br />
CjltlO~), or on accollnt 01 ihe racial (llsqnalificntlOll<br />
ahove mentlOn(ld,<br />
MINES AND WORKS AOT AMENDMEN1' BILL<br />
The following BIll "to amend sectIOn (our of the<br />
Mines and Wor~ Act 1911 (Act No. ]2 of 1~11), flO,<br />
as to enable the grant of certIficates· of competency<br />
nnder the regulatIOns made under that section to be<br />
restricted III certain areas and 'circumstances to persons<br />
other than NatIves or AsiatIcs to enable such<br />
re"ulations to impose,d\lties and responsibIlities on<br />
p;'sons otller than, Natives or A:inatICs and 'to<br />
apportion work on mines, l~ work8 and on machm,~<br />
PI y between NatiyeS and ASIatICS ,lnd other pE'rsons,<br />
to '~)fl Introdnced by the l\:hlll~tcr of Mllles and IndustrIes,<br />
appears in' the [Jmon Gazette Eclrafj?dIIW? IJ<br />
dated January 22 ,-<br />
Be it enacted by the King-'s Most Excellent MaJe~ty,<br />
the Senate and the House of Assembly of the DnlOn<br />
of South Afrwa as follows :-<br />
1. 8ectionJqur of the Mmes and Works Act 1\111<br />
(Act No. 12 of 1911), is hereby amended by the><br />
addItIon to the end of sOrb-sectIOn (1) of the following<br />
words -<br />
"The regulatIOns under paragraph (n) may<br />
provlde t.hat In such provmces or ,lreas as may<br />
be speCIfied in the regulatIOns, certIficates or<br />
compe,tency in any occupatIOn referred to III<br />
that paragraph shall nof. be granted to Natives<br />
or ASlaticb and the regulatlOns under any othE'r<br />
paragraph of this sub-sectIOn may restrIct certam<br />
classes of work to, and impose duties ami 1'"3' of work m thl' }OIlI1eS .1n'\ tJ1'dn-.tl'h's<br />
whICh Llw Govel rlOl'-Genel',lJ-J'1-()onncll mdY P:II'_<br />
, 1l1,wk ffH' Y;;urop>-':ln'1. It IS proposP' I to /,(1\ r' tIlt'<br />
Gov\'rnor-Gpn"l,d-I1l-COllllCII, 1n otl\l'l' word'l t h,<br />
:'IIIl1I;-!ter of llillP>!, ,I (;,11'\" tltmch. ""<br />
Lpt u'! go a liltle furtbE'I' .llld c,ln·fullr (".. 1111111".<br />
the mterpretatlOn whwh the ::-;tatutl' pIM~l's IlPOll thp<br />
word.s, "mine" allt! "works,"<br />
"The interpret.ltiol1 clause 1>11,lIl c\wIUle,ll<br />
works. metallurgical works, reductIOn WOI ks,<br />
oredressing works, petrol~>nm works, salt w
_F_e~~!ry<br />
27th, 1925~ ___ I:..::N_U_IJ\_N....-;-O_P_IN_IO_N _________ ~5-,9F_"<br />
THE I((XG'3 WRIT I~ INDH<br />
I The Nillul J/enltJ!I holi the f ... llowmg leadmg no~ Id<br />
its is-ue of the toLlI J08tan~:-<br />
It Jj seldom indped ~hat the SwaraJllit 6nds anything<br />
complimentary to say abont British Institutions ID IndIa<br />
or elsewhere, but it would appear that the JodlcialOommittee<br />
of the Privy CouncIl II an l'Xception to this &Im~t<br />
/llvereal condemnation. The 6ual conrt of Empi.e apptd.l,<br />
which recently aroused considerable discus.-.fon in<br />
C~nada on acconnt of a deci>!ion which I~ gave in a case<br />
involvin" Tra1e UnLOnism, has received the bleasillga of<br />
the pror:illenti non-I'operatin~ lawypr ant} one time co~leagoe<br />
of Gao/Jhl, Pondlt Mo~i1al Nehrn. ~oreover, ~18<br />
opwion walt endorsed by all h18 f~llow SwaraJI~ts w~o, In<br />
the Legililative Al!88mbly at Deihl, !oted en bloc m oppositioo<br />
to a p r opll8aJ for the es~~\>h8hment of ~ Supre.me<br />
Court of Appeal in I·ldIB. Tbl~ Ij B very mtere.atmg<br />
revt:lation of S"arajlst. mentality SIOce it showl! f'xscty<br />
how mnch justice the H;ndu or ,Moslem expects ~ get<br />
from his religious or racial opponents. The partiality. of<br />
most Indiana towards litigation of every sort aod description<br />
is Bufficiently well known 10 Natal, but it, ha, remained<br />
for ooe of the bitterest enemies of British ru~<br />
to mltke the a~tonishin(J' arimission that without that pn7t"<br />
an appellant won d be denie I access to an Impartial tribunal.<br />
Such a statement ill nothing more nor It'89 t.han<br />
a complete acknowledgment of the failnrc of SwaraJ to<br />
a~~ert itself a~ ma~ter in its own honse, for, although Mr.<br />
MoWal Nehl'u was careful t., cover his tracks by suggest.<br />
In/r that under the wise and be~evolent ";lIe which be<br />
and his Jriends proposed to gIve to india, a Supreme<br />
Dourt might be established in ~hat country, the more ca~dId<br />
of his colJea"ues at once discounted the val de of thiS<br />
assertion by exp~essing the opinion that it is impossible<br />
to obtain in India that "healthy atmosphere free from<br />
local prejndice tpa~ is prevalent i~ ~ngl.lnd." "~I pre-<br />
- Jodlce" is an ple"ant way of descrlbmg the pubhc morality<br />
of a couotry °where, before the advent of th.e British,<br />
the modest ~um of one rupee would procure the early<br />
decease of an inconvenieut adversary. To that abysmal<br />
etatll of affairs Iodia would at onc~ retnrn tne moment<br />
the la31i tran~port carrying Bl'Illl:!h s'lidiers and officials<br />
bf, ilombay. The Swaraji'lts know this perf~t1y well,<br />
and for once in a way tbey have oot been afraid to say<br />
so.· .<br />
[\V e deal with the above in our leadlDg columna-Ed.]<br />
I<br />
PRIVY COUNOIL APPELS<br />
SYSTEM UPRELt} By ~IV ARA..J1SfS<br />
Delhi, Feb. 17.-A IItriking tribu',e to the respect III<br />
which the Judicial Committee of t"e Privy Conncil i~<br />
held was paid in the Legislative A!Bembly, when, for' the<br />
first time siuce the beginning or the 8eg-ion, the Swarajist.s<br />
voted en bloc with the G:>vlll'nment, ill oppo~in!( a reso<br />
lution by SIr Hari Sin"h Glur, a wdl·known Nagpur<br />
lawyer alld first Vice-Pr~sident of the J)elbl UniverSity,<br />
who I'e~mmended the establi:j}ur.eot·of a Suprllme Court<br />
or ll}dia, to dispose of appcalli nu referred to the Privy<br />
CounCil in I,ondou, ..<br />
The motion was defeated by 56 vote~ to 15. ,<br />
Pundit MoWal Nehru. a prominent non-cJ-operating<br />
lliwyer and Swarajist leader, said that incouvemence and<br />
expanse was not high Pflce to pay- for the justice which<br />
could be obtained from the Privy Conncii.<br />
He had known of several instllnc.H where the htigant3,<br />
, "\t reaiollable cost, had obt>uned jWl~il.'e before the Privy<br />
~:"4'l1lnctl in caSllS they had loat fro:» the lowe3t to the<br />
~tcm:rhest Court in IndIa.<br />
iuesti "'rhe Privy Council hid down important princi~li. of<br />
)Ollitiaw in caslls which were nserul bero!.<br />
MorC')ver, It was<br />
}pemseless to think 01 e.ta?Ji'lhing II Sllr .. em~ Court \~jtbO:ltr<br />
Jo\'~-dwaraj. _.' . W<br />
ts (hher SwaraJist3 expr~t!d L'B ""IOt'll thlit. It wa~<br />
.c 'imposoible .tq obtain. in In ~Ia ,th,}r. 'he
60 tNDIAN OPINION February 27th, 1925<br />
--------------------------------~-------------------<br />
MR. ASQTJ IT"H<br />
Mr. Asquith, who has retur:'ea :rom Europe, hall<br />
accepted the offer of-an EarldcTI.' and will take the<br />
title of "Earl of Oxford" wlth the sub-title of<br />
Viscount Asquith of Morley<br />
THE I~DIAN DLP"CTATION<br />
Reports appear here of W:J.'l' deputation' of all<br />
parties, Indian and EUJ'Opear Jexcept the Swarajists,<br />
that waIted on the Viceroy a t Delhi yesterday for<br />
the purpose of asking the IndIan Government to<br />
make an effort to get the Sou~h AfrIcan Government<br />
to give an undertaking that no (urther steps tlhould<br />
be taken in regard to -Indiau ''Uterests in South<br />
Africa until th~ whole posltica has been eKamin€)d<br />
by a non-party confet'ence as was suggested by Mr.<br />
J. H. Thomas,' when, as CL'lonial Secretary, he<br />
VIsited South Africa. The l>-lggestioIlB of the deputation<br />
are not advan'ced by Indians for the first time.<br />
Mr. Thomas it IS true gave expression to the same ,<br />
view. But it WilS not many months before his<br />
arrival in South Africa, Mrs. Sarojini Naidu, the<br />
President of the South AfrIcan Indian Conference<br />
Ul'i'e~ at the request oC 'the Indian community the<br />
lame 8ug~estion-in terms that such a couference<br />
Ih
February 27th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 61<br />
patiw'~' Nor mw,t more IU'!tt\f'rR h(' amnittpd to any<br />
01\1' d."ll'lct tll..lll th!' lotal idhour m1' mineral wealth."<br />
--0-<br />
The American correspondent of the NI'll' I,/ilia<br />
(Madl'as) writes :-<br />
The Attorney.Ger.eral of California has renuerE'U<br />
a decision making it impossible for Asiatics to hold<br />
valid cropping contrilcts. Japanese, being excluded<br />
from land-ownership and from the 1 ight to make<br />
contracts for the lease or land, thought that they<br />
might be allowed to contnCt to buy fruit on the<br />
~"cII"', -n..~ ...,t."~ \~IIt'\'" J.~"IJ~ ,..~_~ ".., ,.<br />
.. I> 50 ~. \ ,
.----~--------,--<br />
tNOIAN Ol'fN ION February 27th, 1925<br />
we have risen and to winch we shall return anu<br />
that we should be bound by R ",rong be of common'<br />
citizenship which no fetishism uu ever .bre..tll: ?"<br />
-0-<br />
The Government of Boml .. y :tas·!liI.llctioned the<br />
Bombay MUnicipality's decisL''l to put up an- iron<br />
fence of ten by six feet rouDl~1 dlEl place where the<br />
late Mr. THall: was crematE.l Oil the Chowpatty<br />
sands.<br />
-0-<br />
India has a sixth Secretary of 8tH.tes in the space of<br />
ten years: the Marquis 01.' Crewe, Mr. Austen<br />
,Chamb,erlain, Mr. Edwin ~amuel Montagu, Viscount<br />
Peel, L~rd Olivier and the Ef.rl of Birll:enh~ad.<br />
-0-<br />
The Governor of Bombay, while unveilmg a<br />
memorial tablet to Dr. Turn'J!', the late Health<br />
Officer of the City, spoke of the importance of adopting<br />
measures for the prevention of diBeases~ HIS<br />
Excellency said: "It has always struck me as rather<br />
strange that while we say that prevention is better<br />
\ than cure, we have been slow even in Europe to<br />
.recognise the vah,e of preventive medicine. It is·<br />
only compara.tively recently that this lJranch of<br />
medical science has received the attention it deserves."<br />
-0-<br />
Chicago holds an' unenviable murder record. The<br />
l'Mnes' Chicago correspondent says that officia.l statistics<br />
show that in less than six months more murders<br />
have been committed than in the whole of<br />
1923. In October, the latest month on which figures<br />
are avaihlble, murders have been committed at the<br />
rate of more than one a day.<br />
The Jam Saheb of Nawanaga.r, famous the world<br />
over as "Ranji" stIll reta~ns not a little of his old<br />
time agiflty. During the recent panther shoot of<br />
His Excellency the Viceroy at Samana, he escaped a<br />
nal'row accident on account of his pluck and cool<br />
WIt. .<br />
In the South Pacific is an islcmd called Bardoo,<br />
which IS ruled over by a widow. She went there<br />
originally in the hope that misslOnary work would<br />
assuage her grief ovel' thp-Ioss of her husband. She<br />
IS now ruler of t.he Islana, which contains only<br />
t.hree other whit.e inhahit.ant.
______________ 0 ______ 0_ 0<br />
tDpiltiott<br />
No. IO-Vol. XXIII. Friday, March 6th, 1925.<br />
Rl!gi.:.tered at tbe G. P.O J a Newspaver<br />
Pale a FoultP f..r, ft<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
"""<br />
1\t T qllf'slion time m the Union Hou~e of ..\s- • hvpen this countl'y and Japan has been a source of<br />
Ltil ,,!'mbly l.lilL 'l'uNlllav Mr. N"l (~,A.P,. Nt'w- surprise to Mr. OtLl dUl'ing the course of his VIsit,<br />
e,liltle) IUIk('11 the 1\[1I11"tPI' of the Intt'I'lOr. arld lw llls["ls th.1t much mutual benefit would re-<br />
(I) '1'0 what extput, It at all, uoc.:! thp Government suIt from a ft-ee tr.111e policy. Whel'evel' he has<br />
lntcwl IlllIing UlI' prc'I'ol'lIt beb'JlOll to eUIIY out thc vIsited III South Afrlca he has seen Japanese goods<br />
prOllllh., of the :!I.ll!1lHt('r (A the Intel'lOt· to mtlOdlwc on sale at PIW(,S that he said could be reduced by<br />
Il·~tHlatlOll to dc.II with the AsiatIC questwn on the hal1 were-It possible for a Japanese firm ot repute to<br />
Iint'li of the motIOn mtroduced by the hon. member °cstablish It.~elf III this country, and thiS, says the<br />
fOl' 111ovo tiUl'lIlg the la;;t SCbHlon of PdIlldlllent,lanl1 X,,(ltt .Ilellllry, urought hun to the question
64 INDIAN OPINION . :\tarch 6th, 19'5<br />
--.:....-r--~----'~--------.---------------.- --<br />
not pile on the'l}g!)ny, and make the position of the<br />
white mall intolerable by bringing on hitl} the hatred<br />
, .t' I H' .~j "<br />
of other peoples.<br />
Th~s 41d ~he ex-fr~~e ~pnj.~~~r o~po~e the estap11SBing<br />
of the colour bar ill pre UI~.lOn. If only<br />
tp.r~~~~igp" 1!ie~}~ ~~te prif.fice
March 6th, 192$<br />
tNOlAN OPINI\JN<br />
he Bp~ke l.a:;t week apparently left the wrong Impression<br />
oh tlle' ~nnlsWr's mind, that he (General<br />
·l;;m"l1tsJ was threatening the Uovernment. This waR<br />
, roatt-cr which cut deeper than any -rarties. There<br />
'might Ile'members on either sHle who
66 INDIAN OPINION March 6th, 1925<br />
dren -would not regret it, atI it would bring evil<br />
results beyond the foresIght 01 any ID:ln living.<br />
Mr. SAMPSON (Lab., Jeppee) remdrked that General<br />
Smuta had not declared wll )ther hl\ was in<br />
favour of the principle of thir,; Bill or not. The<br />
late Government had had p}('nty of opportumty of<br />
pctssing legislation:. He wondered whether the<br />
i:\Tatives were sonsulted befOl,; the original nolour<br />
ftar"\Vas determined. He reg;p'ded thIS measure as<br />
'restormg to the white workf'l1'J on the Rand what<br />
llad been taken from them by force of arms (hear<br />
hear). In Europe, where people were almost<br />
'equally clhlised, it was eailY to talk about the<br />
.'ights of man, but not so in this country wheh' the<br />
(:1vilised man worked alongside savages. Until<br />
I~ome attempt was made to protect the standaru of<br />
tlfe of the white man, what protection was there<br />
,bat fl'w 'W hite man 'was not gomg to t" dragged<br />
Jown to the very low levt'l of the Nat17c wages.<br />
'rhe Factory A Ctil were for the protection of the<br />
K~kerl3, and of the property c,f the employer: His<br />
1 _'(-
March 6th, 1925<br />
INUIAN OPINION<br />
onH LONDON LETTER<br />
[ By OUR O~N COltRERPONDENT ]<br />
5th February 1925.<br />
The fifth anniversary of the Indian Student:.!<br />
Union and Hoste! was, under the chairmanship of<br />
Sir Atnl Chandra Chatterjee, High Commissiont'r<br />
for India. celebrated during Mail week.<br />
,_ Sir Chatterjee was recently the guest of the Royal<br />
Colonial Institute, of which he is a member and in<br />
responding to the toast said that he took his appointmt'nt<br />
not as a personal honour but as a compliment<br />
u> India. He had found since his rptnrn to England<br />
that it:.! pt'ople were taking a greater interest in Indian<br />
commerce and pohtics and welcomed this<br />
change in the attitude of the heart of the Empire<br />
towards India. It was not always realised how vast<br />
India was and what an important position it did and<br />
ought to occupy in the Councils of the Empire.<br />
They had now established before the League of N a<br />
tions the fact that Inoia was among the eight chief<br />
industrial nations of the world. Its exports and<br />
imports together entitled India to the -sixth pll\w<br />
among the foremost commercial nations of the<br />
world. Since the war their import:.! and exports<br />
had recovered wonaerfully~the total now exceedf'd<br />
£400,000.000. India took more than half her<br />
imports from Great Britain, but regretted that<br />
Great Britain took less than one-quarter of Indian<br />
exports. India had a monopoly in jute, hpr tea was<br />
popular, but she would like to see attention given<br />
also to numerous other prodncts such as wheat, oil<br />
sef'ds, manganese, tobacco, hides and skins, and<br />
wool. India was doing all she could to increase the<br />
extent of her cotton cultivation. At present she<br />
~rrew only short staple cotton but an organisation<br />
was now trying to grow long staple cotton. Trial<br />
h3ils were being tested in England With the assistance<br />
of the Institute and other interested associations.<br />
Pre-war average was only four million bales<br />
but the forecast of the present crop exceeded six<br />
million bales. Much of the material for the irri<br />
-,r::'ion and railway development llOW in progress<br />
had to be bought in England. Thus they were furthering<br />
one of the objects of the Institute. the development<br />
of Empire resources and the utilisation<br />
of these resources within the Empire and that while<br />
he was High Commissioner he would do his best to<br />
carry out the objects of the Institute.<br />
Mr. H. S. L. Polak has now returned from his<br />
tour in India. He is here-as he is in India and in<br />
Soath Africa-looked upon as an authority on qu~stions<br />
relating to Oversea India.ns.<br />
At an Ilome by Mr. and Mrs. Polak, it. was a<br />
pleasure to meet Capt. Hugh M. Meylel' who was a<br />
member of the .Uniqu Parliament and well known<br />
in South AfJica. Indians will remember that he<br />
'VdS of t.he few who, in thE> days of Passive Resistance<br />
in South Africa. stood for a fair adjustment of<br />
the claims of the 'Indian community.' And the<br />
Natives of South' A:frica, too, will recall his stand<br />
in the Union Pa.rliament a~Q.St the provisions of<br />
the Natives Lana Act. For a l time he sat in the<br />
British Parliament arl.
INDIAN OPINION March 6th. '9l 5<br />
tilat the ya1ue I~" lildTh:' to ,Gr~at Bri~n W Il~ost<br />
, jl I ,l "l.J J •<br />
ev}dep.~, fAI' I.tl, la l~l
'ttLlinn ®pinilltt<br />
~r\No. II-VOl. XXIII. -Friday, March 13th, 1925.<br />
R.g' .... red aube G.P.O. as a Newspaper<br />
Parcs rOURPEN,.<br />
1T<br />
DEPUTATION'TO THE VICEROY<br />
ON THE INDIAN QUESTlON<br />
HE following if! the full text of the statement<br />
presented to thA Viceroy by the Indian<br />
Jeputation that recently waitpd on His Excellency<br />
in connection with the Indian question in<br />
South Africa and the reply given to the lteputatioll<br />
hy. the Viceroy '- I f<br />
Many deputations have waited from time to time<br />
upon ;l1our Excellency and your predecessors in<br />
otfh:e in order to convey to the Government of India<br />
and through it to his MajestY'1I Government the<br />
intense feeling aroused in the nunds of the people<br />
of India at the treatment accorded to IndlanH in<br />
~outh Africa by the Government of the Union. We<br />
remember with satisfaction the sympathetic response<br />
of the Viceroy of the day and of your Excellency<br />
to the representatIons made on those 'occasions,<br />
and in particular we recall with thankfulness anll<br />
prIde how in 1913, when the situation in 80uth<br />
Afnca had rf'acheu a dangerous crisis and pu bHc<br />
sentiment had. been outraged by the bittel' persecution<br />
of Indians in the Union, your preJecessor Lord<br />
Hardinge placed himself at the head of the people<br />
of InjUn and voiced theh' alarm and indi~,.'nation ir.<br />
terms that extorted universal apprecmtion.<br />
, " To·day a crisis of another kind has beel\ reached.<br />
I(~f; true that the circumstances of the Passive<br />
Resistance struggle in Natal for just and equitahle<br />
trE'atmE'nt are not actually being reproduced in<br />
South Africa. Nevertheless a veiled warfrue is undoubtedly<br />
heing carried on again~t the rebident Indi.m<br />
population and steps ~re being tnkell and policies<br />
framed having for thE'ir object. if possible. th",<br />
expulsion and certainly the ruin and dt'gradatlOn of<br />
the unhappy Indian residents therE'. now Virtually<br />
lelldel'less owing to the departure, death or misfortune<br />
of those upon whom they have hItherto rf'hell<br />
for counsel, guid.mce and exmnple. ,<br />
l'IETTLEMEN'r OF l~lU<br />
When the Settlement of 19i-t was reached between<br />
the Indian community and the Govel'l1ment of thE'<br />
Union, it was generally felt in this country that In<br />
I\hmt! there pal! sEleuretl no more than their mini-<br />
- Hltlln cl!].im ntHl fAr that tqey ha.l tQ nlake enormous<br />
~~cf\qee~-'Ylth t~e ~ynw~thYi ~uppqrt allll practical<br />
1I~8i~tance Af the ~pqple of mli4-Rnll thE'Y Itad<br />
Cj'qne tq Ow utmQst limit 0.£ hQT\QU1'uble concesslon~<br />
lly (lAnatmtilla "IlI'tl~eJ'vedly to the olnlitlflt restriotjon<br />
uf IndIan lmmiC1l'ntion Int" the Unlon in orllpl' tel<br />
"llay th(l r.~n~ IUlll hOlltllity ot thtolr tt}lloW'¥'!ll(fI<br />
()o\ollhlls, 'l'M 1I1"ttlelnelit WaS bnililil uplln publlc<br />
~oognltion by th~ Union Government of the aancU·<br />
, \y of the vested rlg~ts of the, Indian resiuent!l,<br />
wbetht'l' individually or as a community, and Mr,<br />
-Gandhi clt'.trly intimatell \0 the Government that<br />
though his counh'ymen had nccepteu the terms ot<br />
t)le settll>mtml as regar~s rillltteis theI1 actuollly in<br />
111splHe BehveE'n the partie~, Utey, 1lE'\'erthcletlS, rer~flll~<br />
of ~lt!.llltl\hltl III ~\1h!b. th\l)lIH\'t \'(~h deprhll'.l~<br />
Ched the right and intcl1di:.!uJn Jue course til claim<br />
hit relltorllt\QIl ot lh' ,,\\HOlltl ll1!;ld,mU IUld prif!'<br />
-<br />
1J~1I1, il ItllI. tI'Ill'llIl( b~ ~i'!I,t. bitt ill.aHfl!i' rl.:!!ijlath1tl ~I,<br />
• J"\llhIlM~"h ~~UWl'h'. liMI\. 'Utili b~;j Il~V!tlll~ fllr<br />
fV~,*!~,!vt' ~kt ~~'!'Jl"tl ~~~I{~ ~~ ~'l!l! ~. ~hf!!~r.~I~<br />
thronghout the Union.<br />
With the outbreak of the War the antl-IUllian<br />
~ampajgn of an important and influential section of<br />
the white population remained III abeyance, But<br />
scarcely had the Armistice been sil-,'1led when It<br />
Imn,t iorth again with incre.u.;ed violence, and In<br />
1:I1H m spite of the definite undertaking ot the<br />
Ulllon Government five years earlier to respect Indian<br />
vested rights and mterf'sts. the Union Parhament<br />
passed leg1t.;lation depriving the Tlansvaal<br />
Indums of even the legal right mdirectly to acquire<br />
and own lllllllov.lble plOpel'ty whIch With the<br />
knowledge and encouragement Ol'lgmally of the<br />
old South AfrlCd.n Govel'llment they had eXE'rcised<br />
freply for over thirty Yl'ars.<br />
THE ASIATIC COMMIRt>ION<br />
I ,<br />
Encour.lgeu by this btrlklllg success the anti<br />
Indian prop,'\gandists began to extend their operation<br />
to Natal. l'he Union Government thereupon set up<br />
a CommitlSioll prE'8ided over by Mr, Justice Lange<br />
to examllle the whole rnd1.ln pOSItion 111 the Ulllon.<br />
It was at this stage that your Bx(,!'Uency's predeces<br />
SOl', Lord Chelmsford, who had persu;ttmtly advocated<br />
the Indian causE' in South Atrica, sought and<br />
obtained from the Union Government an invitation<br />
for a representative of the Government of IndIa to<br />
proceE'd to South Airica to assist the Commisbion by<br />
representing the Indian case to confer WIth the<br />
Cabinet of Gelwl'al HmntH. -8lr Bl'IlJ.lmin Robertson's<br />
able pI'e:.;enlatIoll of IlHli.l's C,ISe- and hIS<br />
pelletr.lting crItIcism of the eviuence led by the<br />
antl-Im\Mn party resulted m a tindlllg of tacts by<br />
the COIillDis~lOlIel s ~ubst.lntlally auoptlllg the IndIan<br />
point of view llml discrediting on grounds of vagueness.<br />
hMccuracy or exaggeration, the main hostile<br />
allegation.<br />
HOSTILE LEGISLATION<br />
It was hoped as a rt'snlt of this effort that the<br />
Union GovernmE'nt would tdke step~ to correct<br />
popular misconceptions :tnd corr!'spondmgly to improvJ,the<br />
Indian statuR, But the insecurity of<br />
General Smuts' GoVel'11iDent render{'ll it peculmrly<br />
Suscf'ptible to pressure from the anti-Indian party<br />
in the Assembly, wit4, the result that the Natal<br />
Provill'Cial CounCil was encOlll'agE'J to enact certam<br />
QrlUMllces prn!tibitiJHi In.lianil III the Durb,ln muni·<br />
cipfi.llaIl,l, t.lepriving Natal Inlh,m. of thl,) right to<br />
(llC!lfCl\l!Q tba municipal fr:lliChi>lti lind M'\"!'£'!Y rra·<br />
tl'\cUn,:r thilir 1I1tNIIlr prl'{Jarluna ii"I.tin4' I'i~htl!. 1n<br />
ilpite {If Indian PI'utt'lItd th~ Utilt OI'uiIIUnct> Ui?\Jfl \116<br />
advio" of bta ~ini"ter8 was 8Q&ent~d by the GOvI'l'n A<br />
or-General. thU!! for tht> tirst time introclucing in<br />
Natal the practice of racial sl'grE'gation.<br />
The other<br />
OrdinancE'S wel'e du'allowE'ol Ill' !I:'tRt'nt withheld.<br />
~ever.ll attempts h.lvel:Hnce Leen llull,' to :-eCllle the<br />
acceptance of these or Sllllil.lr Ordinances Lr the<br />
Union Government anu the news has recently<br />
reachell IUlli.! that in "pite of I'''peatell protest!! the<br />
Oovprnol,.(ll1net>\l haA bow IV\,'''/lte.l t, .. Ille O,.,lInancoo!<br />
depllvhlil l,t
70 INotAN OPINION March 13th, 192$<br />
by the Natal Government when in 11\91) the Indians<br />
were deprived of the pal'hanH'ntary franchlse.<br />
GENERAL 811WT~' DECLARATION<br />
, At the 1917 Imperlal War Conference when the<br />
questIOn of the lhsalJIhtJes of the Government of<br />
India came up General Smnts, flpeakmg" on behalf of<br />
the Union Government. p"(j)resply held on L the hope<br />
that wlth the rC'IDoval, by the ('nactment of the<br />
UIllon lmmigratlOn Acts, or the fear of an Indtm<br />
invasIOll of South Afrlca the' grievances of the 1eRident<br />
lndmns should be gradually remedied. And<br />
at the 1918 'war Conference, Mr. Burton, the South<br />
African spokesman. paid a warm tnbute to the' law<br />
abiding character of the IndIan population and admftted<br />
that It was entItled to humane and just treat·<br />
ment. TIle South AfrIcan delegatIOn accepted th"<br />
resolntIOn passed unaIllmously by- the Conference<br />
recommenumg- to the various dom111ion Governments<br />
concerne(l the m,vestigahon of IndIan dIS·<br />
abIlities with a VIew to theIr removal.<br />
The Lange Commission'in 1920 reported thai the<br />
allegatIOns of unlawful IndIan llnmigration on a<br />
'large scale were not substantmted and thIS finding<br />
was supported by the Union c€'nsns fignres 111 1921<br />
whICh showed not only that the IndIan populationtwO-thIl"lls<br />
of which was bot'll 111 South AfrIca, was<br />
virtually stationers but that the_whIte po-pulatlOn III<br />
the Union had enormously Increased. In Natal<br />
where the complamts of nnf,llr competItion were<br />
the 101.1c1est, though the Indian population had m<br />
creased by the small amonnt of ;; -pel' cent., the<br />
European popnia,.tiol). had mcreafled hy 40 'per cent.<br />
In 1\)21 the ImperIal ConfE\rence- adopted it reso·<br />
lnhon recommemhng to the varlonR dOlllll1ion Goverllments,<br />
in VlCW of the changc in the con~titutlOnal<br />
status ot In-ella uncler the RelOrmtl, tbe l1esirability<br />
of conferr111g CltlZeI\ship l'lgllts upon
I<br />
M arch 13th, *92$ INDIAN OPiNION 71<br />
------------------~----~---------------<br />
t~a' ftcatmMt (,f one class (.0 b;', ~I" je Y',1 '!n!Jject contemplate thp neCpsf;,t, nf impo~ing lIOI" fI e,.h<br />
III the domllllonR h:v; unfort~lr..LtJ;ly p"l'cra'a I. - restrictlOtlR on In.hans alr!'d,ly III the conntOn', a~ J<br />
The deputation consisted of the following ;- nnderstrltirred are the feelings of the whole<br />
conntry in l'egaril to the cOl1lhtions of Iwlians 111<br />
South Africa. Although no Ruling Prince is<br />
acfually with you to-day yet I observe that YOIl<br />
have receiveli meA8ages of sympathy ft'om IIiH HighneHIl<br />
the Maharaja of BIkaner the Chancellor of the<br />
Vhamber of Princes and His High ness deslI es It to<br />
be known that the princes am in agreement with<br />
the object of this deputatIOn. I welcome also the<br />
presence of the distinguished representatives of the<br />
non official communities and it is especially notewortllY<br />
that Indians and Europeans are assocIated<br />
together in this deputation aud WIth the Bltme purposo<br />
in VlCW. The question hefore ns is of the<br />
Ihmost importance to the future of the Empire and<br />
it is well that the British in IUllia should Bhow ill<br />
this unmistakable way that they identify thems('lws<br />
with those qUestions which affect seriously<br />
the interest anll the pOllition of India in the Eu{.<br />
pire.<br />
In your address you have' given a concise histori<br />
("t! survey of this complicated problem and it must<br />
be admitted that that survey leaves on the mind an<br />
iD?pression of deep disnppointment. On the conclusioll<br />
of the I~U tlettlement, as it is termed in<br />
your add redS, it appeared that the (',mses of futUre<br />
fl'ichon between the Government of South Atrica<br />
and the Imhans l'('sitlent within its bordel's h,ttl<br />
bN.'n moved, .At the conclusion of the negotIations<br />
of 1m!, a letter was written on heh.'If of<br />
General Smuts to Mr. G.mdlli, in which thE' tollowing<br />
passage occurs witli regard to the administratIOn<br />
of the existing law: ., The Mini~ter desi.res me to<br />
say that it is always, has been and will continue to<br />
be the desire of the Go\'ernm( nt to see that they<br />
are I\lhnmistered in a just manner with
INDIAN OPINION March 13th, 1925<br />
with increasmg misgiving at this moment whell the<br />
actron now taken in Natal 1:o11owmg that pro.posP(l<br />
in,Na.tal or elsewhei'e, snggests tlldt the po~ition of<br />
Indians ,in South Afrwa has reac1wd tlle criSIS, I<br />
should be unresponsrve, 1I1(1f'6<br />
of luchJ.ns resIdent 111 Somll Africa, Fr6in my own<br />
pel'sonal 1l;ndwledge I can assnre you that tlir Nar as-,<br />
imha Sal'ma, when :m ,charge of the {iepartment,<br />
laboured devotedly to 1!epl'f'Sent anef uphold the<br />
:tndl~n cause and I am CO(l vlllced that Sir M,thomeJ<br />
Habibullah'will not be benllld hIm III the eM'nestness<br />
of his endeavours to the same end, As a<br />
Govtirn1Ue~t- W&, have eonSlstenLly antI p'erslstently<br />
strli\ten to the utmoSL of OUl; capaClhes for this<br />
purpose,<br />
THORNS IN 'rUE PATH<br />
But I must not conceal from you that the dIfficulties<br />
which confront us are great, Your obJC't a"<br />
phc~¥car ~en IS-tO find a practical method oi<br />
achieving some result of removmg the dange!' to<br />
the whole position' of Iridlans III South Afl'lca,<br />
FeelIngs are deeply stirred, but It IS not suffiCIent<br />
to tehe}>'e them by resol\.ltlOL1S 01' speeches, We<br />
seek, yon seek, all seek a practical solution, I there-<br />
,£ore turn wl,th speCial interest to the suggestIOJl<br />
made by you at the end of your address, You<br />
propose that my ssarily<br />
"'-p~:,,'p~ ,~ d~llcate chal'acte!'. Nation,a~<br />
\ susceptib.ilitw!' ,1/>1'SJlfl&Hy;arttused nQt onl~~ in In(lia,<br />
but e1$ewhere. -T,he Pll'~ we sl}al~ ~ye Jo :trE!1id, is-.<br />
dIfficult. South Afrioa has alrl"flqy ;tuh responsiOle<br />
Self-Government as a Dom.llllon wlthir,:'the. "Elllmli<br />
an11iiyouca'l'l:' a'Pprised' of tt,le,strength of ~he. feellllg<br />
an·l ,of th13 agits.tlOl1 ~in 'Sonth Afl'lca upon tHese<br />
ql11"~o 1 (lllSI EliUll tio"~l'Jimetit hall>its o~n problem,<br />
1\1l.l .., •• t'l;atfdllni~nUil :.tlR(,~ P'
,<br />
March 13th, 1925 INuf.~N OPINION 73<br />
and the Ilame objection holds in his case also. But<br />
thE.'re woul,l have bpen a 10nJ;l'er interval ill his CdBe<br />
l,Ietween the GovernorRhip and the Viceroyalty. amI<br />
on other grounos also'he would Bel'm tQ be the most<br />
suit,lhlp f'dndidate (If thp three for tile place when<br />
it l)('olmps ,acant. 'Vhf) knOWN hnt that next year<br />
the Ikiti.dl (}o\el nmcnt m"y bnd that Lord l1eadlllg<br />
Ahonlt on,this gl'Ollllll ag.lim,l the<br />
in' con:-.nlfation ,with my hrothcr Prim'e~, ' I as<br />
Chanc~Hor of the Chambt'r of PrineI'll w.ts<br />
privil ('lIhjects of Indian tit.ttes an<br />
wonhl vield. 110 I c s,LtilifddOl-Y 1'~'''lllttl anti secnre to<br />
am1 have declded to test the. legahty of the Ordl-<br />
honoureti positIOn 1n..all parts of th~ Emplre in
74 ____________ 1 N D IA~-,-v \\..)..N_I O_N_. ____ l\_la_r_ch_I..:..3t_h_, _1~9....::2 5:...-<br />
keepmg '''Ith India's nghtful plAce in the Bntish<br />
C,)llllllOnwe,lU\1 antI 1\1 confollnIty _ With the assij\lom;<br />
anll constant effoet" of His Excellency the<br />
Viceroy and the'Governmellt of India. Th18 meR<br />
S:1ge WitS puhlished In all t.l1O' lea1lmg Indian ll!:'WSplpers<br />
to v.:mls the end 01 Oclobel', 1~1'2;1, throngh a<br />
comrnn1l1qlle Ifl'll1eQby the Ch,lncellor't! Office an,I<br />
which or conrs!:' h,l(1 'spedD I reference to Routh<br />
Afnca and Kenya, and yon ,we at liberty to refer<br />
to these Lwts In )'ollr a(l,ll'('~s ,IS also lherl'tOl'e, to<br />
add that the PI'lUee::; are m agreement with the<br />
object of yoUt' depntatIOn and to pubhHh tlns<br />
telegram."<br />
INDIAN QUESTION IN THE HOU8E OF<br />
COMMONS<br />
LABOUR ~ UGGESTS RECIPROCrry -<br />
London, l\J\trch 9.-In the Honse of Commons<br />
this afternoon, Mr. Lansbury (Labour. Bow and<br />
_Bromley) asked ,vhich of the Rntlsh DommlOnlil<br />
and ColOl:tLes prolubltf'd I'll' restrictf'd the entry Qf<br />
Indians, and whether India restrlCted the 'entry and<br />
domicile of Britishers<br />
Mr. Amery. Secretary fo~ the Colonies, gave'<br />
partJcnlurs. whereupon Col. Wedgwood (LabQur,<br />
Newcastlp-under-LymC:') asked whether Kenya was<br />
the f'uly Crown ColQny that I'Pstricted the IUlmlgrailOn<br />
of 'British Inchans?<br />
1\11'. AlUC:'ry repIled that Kenya dId not Impose<br />
restrictIOlls.<br />
-,'<br />
Ml' LRl1sbury asked If Indll1ns were I'efused the<br />
I'lglit of domICile in 80nth Afncn, Canada, and<br />
Australia. He' proceedru to contend t,he Iu(lians<br />
should have an eqnal right WIth the Dominions to<br />
exclude whih's, when the ~peakel~ intervened, saying<br />
t,hat It was impossible to have a debate on the<br />
Bubject.-ReutC:'r.<br />
======<br />
lNDIA AT WEMBLEY<br />
ApPRECIA'rION By PRINCE OF WALES<br />
'1'he following correspondence has passed betweC:'n<br />
QJe Prmce of Wales and the High CommIssIOner<br />
Gf Ipdm regardmg India's dIsplay at Wembley<br />
Park.-<br />
From His l{oyal- Highness to the Higli Com<br />
UllSSJOner -<br />
"As PreSident of the British EmpJl'e Jal't'in ln~la's diS plat, 't)e vC:'ry'lh'lll-erous<br />
appreciatiQn of ih~ r£l{;ult~<br />
of theii 1 ;>Wo.rk. eX1Y,I'~~sed<br />
by Your Royal Hlghn~ss, 'vh~ch w11r~ a{t6ttf\1.l,t-!p<br />
tile'! gr~~te~t poslHbllO, ~laf1J?tiqn aritl7~~\.q9u~l1f~<br />
~P~llt,.~ .. :lrtp'!(il~& 1: '\' ' , .-<br />
'to ' ~r_ M':':h. ....., .. "<br />
BO~OUGH OF DU~BAN<br />
MUIOMEDAN SECTION -<br />
GENERAL CEMETERY<br />
All persons claiming ownC:'rship of gran> lots In<br />
the Mahomedan St'chon of the General C('metery<br />
!lltllated' at Brook 8treet are reqn('sled to pro,lllce<br />
thpir receipts or othel' evidence 111 RIlPPOI t of thell'<br />
chums t.o the Chief S,mitary Inspector, Old Court<br />
House, Durban. On productIQn of satiRfactory<br />
evidence of own(,losl ip, the own('1"s name will be<br />
- registered in the block book which has bet'll prt'<br />
pared in conjunction with a pJ,1I1 of that p~rtion of<br />
the Cemetery.<br />
A. O. JONES.<br />
Town Clerk.<br />
Town Clerk's Oifice,<br />
DurlxlI1, 15th Jannal'Y. 1!l25.<br />
. '<br />
~~6t~<br />
~l~:t<br />
.. ~lo:t~,"[h !~H(\Lrl~l ~,«l.+l (":4.CHL:lL.<br />
uq!- :t-ll~+ll ~l~~L ~l ~ 'lY..fi;. !-/~~C1lrlrtl<br />
~~«l.+l (e.tQtPl+ll !-·Jt~e.tltJ(llt(.nrt..fi +ll~{l~L<br />
~lctt Hrtlotl ~q(JH ~l~t~ 'tl(tlrlt ~":4.l ~le.tlrll<br />
I ~!t+li 'tLru..fi '4~l~l ,~~':ll ~r~ ~~L~L<br />
~O('Jtrt..[l ~..[l !I~~rtl ~Hrl~l ~~ f«..fi~{l<br />
I 1:f .. ~'tH~ ~'4iet ;,~ H':lL..fi (-trl'd\ H11'4il<br />
~l~~. ~t~~~l ~'al"tH'{!r ~~l~l O(~ ~>-tl~<br />
!-~:tctlrtrtL ~ r-:-I.Q.lPlrtl \~Urt..fi ~l~ ('\f:f~L~<br />
H'lll+tL ~~~«l. t)o~l.& ~;+tl +tl(1!-!!' rtl+l ~l'1'll<br />
~l ~l·-t~.<br />
it. ~l. ~r:U,<br />
r!l~'l<br />
t(11~~.<br />
.&J;'_ J,;J~) .,.,.l.e \}.i._;u,~ 4.1 )~ ..:),f,J ,.t.;<br />
,!J j ..:),.1\» I~J).e.> J. \;I,y:1 £ ..:),;1; 1.:/1 ... &4.,. ..... ll_' .!<br />
\.. l uyJ £ '-,.e,j ?J "': I a, ,( L ~t"'"" .....(',j ,JIb}<br />
--"...,.. . )(t.3 l - ""t " L<br />
11."" (",,,.1,,,,,.o),j..D \:I~l'> toN V~-),) _ ..:r'·~-)<br />
c..r; Ib ~;,( J,J)J) 4il); bS ..:-JI~£: (..... i~-!,· ,J.~-j'<br />
\;II! J~ ~':<br />
( Il~l.)<br />
.!. -:",!l", )~ L ,f JI'-! ':;)..ltl'i ....}"'!-j ~,./<br />
/ t- r "'t '(.. .. " " I<br />
~ .. :) I¥oJ;U ,:t.. ch .~U ~ ~ ,1-7'-) -:)~ ~J \. -t I<br />
+ ~ t~( t.,.( ;l~ .!..it ... j ,..:.:..il· - ...."J<br />
" I.,/""".,~~,J-JJ"<br />
\:J'~ .. ~~,I '>I;'VJ-J-r':' ~~
f;-<br />
IltOt!<br />
'No. I2-VOl. XXIII. Friday, March 20th, 1925.<br />
l{l\hnl! on til(' "etion of tht> FIl101I Gn\ elll<br />
IIWlIt III ~,ll1ctj(m1l1g the N,ttoll B')l'OlI~h:'l O,'dllllllC'1'<br />
the 11/11'/11 ('tl,ll'm;) \\'llt(>;; -' It enlY PI()\1!lC'I' 111<br />
the Dtltllilltoh 1Il,IY, as N,ltoll h.l>1 (ILlIH'. ,h'pll\t' lll<br />
Ihall8 ot tll\'lr tll't'rlr Cli11'181w,\ right., 01H' by OIH,<br />
t1H'n.wIMtlsthe(},mdlti-Smuh P,Il't ""llh' Th,lt<br />
l'.ld lll'IY, in th,lt l,lf;t', lll' shol1\ n1 ,til It., bl\b~t.\IH l'<br />
lJy PI'ovlnt'iaT legb).ItlOll ulll!!'r tbe tlwory th,lt provinCIal<br />
antonomy IS sacrosanct; and who 1.110WS<br />
tlhlt, unlIt'l' tho guiRe of upholding that autonomy.<br />
the white Africa policy will not bl' gra,ln,IU"\'.<br />
stL'lllltlr ,m,l tnllr realisE'll to thc (Idriment of tl~p<br />
Intlhlll popn1.lhon? ThiR IS the ,tIn gel' tlL It n,m<br />
ill'sets IIltlUI\8 In th,lt DOlllllHon aillllt i:; up te) till'<br />
A>l,;elllbly to see tlltlt thell' light:; ,lit' protrdl',l<br />
agalll~t till'! IWW DWI.,.lce,"<br />
'1'hu8 the llllldil (U,Ldr.ls) ·-Hulldl'edR of monk .. ,;;<br />
HI'e bein!{ expol'ted fl'om thil'l pountry tor til., PI;'-<br />
1111 ... 11 flf \\ h!j( lit "1411(". th)'t!,l.' ~'III1IJ IIl'U!/lH't1t 1/1<br />
111'ltaill /.\n40 C]tlrmall)', 'l'It" qUI'IiUlll\ ari'it'li, (H\<br />
,IWI. 0\PI1 hO, It h,t" h,lttlll llP011 proy,'.1 tl1
spirit and sacrifice, they will have the people of India,<br />
the Government of India and the world helping and<br />
fighting for them. .<br />
'l'here IS a passage in the VICeregal pronoun.cement<br />
which needs supplementing. His Excellency s:qa, "It<br />
is stated in your address tha.t 'the Mumclpal Fr,wchlse<br />
was solemnly assured to Indians by' the Natal Government<br />
when in 1896 Indian!! were deprived of the Parliamentary<br />
Franchise.' But you have not IlldlC"tRJ the<br />
exact source or the nature of th~ assurance. My 001'<br />
ernment aN qJ.aking the necessary enquiries to verif.y tb('<br />
positIOn." 'l'he stat~ment ma'ie by tb.e DeflutatiC\n i~<br />
substantially correct. It was, however, not III 1896 but<br />
probably in 1894 that- the assurance was given. I am<br />
writmg from memory. 'l'he facts are these. It was 111<br />
1894 thl\t the first disfranchislDg bill was passed by tlfe<br />
Natal Assembly. Whilst It \Va'! pas5fllg through that<br />
assembly a petitIOn was preseptrd to it on behalf 01 Indians<br />
wherem It was stated thaL the Indians enjoyed the<br />
Mllm~ipal and induectly even the political franchIse.<br />
Fear wa"! also expressed that the deprivation of the' politIcal<br />
ftanchise was likely to be a preclude to that of the<br />
l\'luniClpal Franchise. It was m answer to tillS petition<br />
that the late' Sir John Robinson, the. Premier of Nat>J.l,<br />
and the late Mr. Escombe, the Attorney Geoeral, gave<br />
the a~surance that there was no mter~tioll to go further<br />
and deprive the IndIans'of the MUlllcipal FranchIse at a<br />
future {late. The disfranchismg bill was dIsallowed by<br />
the superlor Government but another nQn-rar:laJ in<br />
character was passed. The assnrance referred to by<br />
me Was several times repeated by Mr. Escombe who<br />
had charge 'of all the bills and who was virtually the<br />
dictator of Natal's policy whIlst he wa~ 1D oliice.<br />
VICEROY'S SPEECH AT THE INDIAN<br />
LEGISLATURE<br />
ON INDIANS OUTSIDE INDIA<br />
The followmg il:! the text of the portion of H. B.<br />
the Viceroy's speech at the op'ening~ of the Imhan<br />
Legislature ou the 20th of January dealing With<br />
Indians ontslde India ,-<br />
When consldermg the affairs outside India, attention<br />
naturally and mevitably turns to Indlftns overseas.<br />
When I addressed the Legislature in Janua.ry<br />
last the pOSltion of Indla.ns m Kenya was crihcal,<br />
and I foreshadowed the appomtment of a Committee<br />
to make representations -on behalf of the Government<br />
of India regarding the Immigration Or dinance<br />
in Kenya in particnlar and other ques~ions relatmg<br />
to Indians in the Colomes. The personnel of the<br />
Committee was announced in March last, and the<br />
Committee began their labours III London in Aprtl.<br />
They had a number of interviews with the Secretary<br />
of State for the Colonies' anu the officials of the<br />
Colonial Qffice and made representations regarding<br />
many Important matters affecting Indians in Kenya.<br />
Fiji and the mandated tel'l'ltol'les of Tanganyika. I<br />
cannot too highly praise the thoroughness and abihty<br />
with which they performed theIr delicate task, and<br />
I am grateful for the very patient hearing whlCh tlw<br />
representative of His Majesty's Government. Mr.<br />
Thomas, and the officers of his _departmel}t accorded<br />
to them. As regards Kenya, the conclusions arrived<br />
at by Mr. Thomas were announced m the House of<br />
Commons on August 7th last. On the questlOn of<br />
franchise and the Highlands there was no ,change in<br />
the position, "but as regards immil..'TatlOn His<br />
Majesty's 8ecretary of State f6r the Colonies after<br />
hearing our representatives was ,not satisfied WIth<br />
tht) Il~ts fr\ 11·<br />
ment upon all mMtel"s comiug withlll thew<br />
purVIew.<br />
NATAL BORoUnu'l OROINANl'E<br />
, . If the pendulum hds swnnl! in the dit'l;'ction<br />
de"sired by IUllIa on tilE'S;' questIOns, lhe pO'lition<br />
III South Africa, on the other h,Ulll, h'l~ been leRi!<br />
fa.vourable, Towards the ('nct of Decf'mbpr, the<br />
news was received t1ut the Govel'nor-Gent'ral ot<br />
ihe UnIOn of South AfrlC
March 20th, 1925 INDIAN OPIN ION 71<br />
thfl powprR of Dominion Govl'rnments in internal draft of pobce to fOl'cf' thebe people to Le vaccinated<br />
anu domestic affairs, the position llf one or" delicacy at a time when hit! in:,pectors haU found cases of<br />
and a solution will not be easy to find_ Patience small-pox, in many (,\l!P~ the p:ttJentR beIng hidden.<br />
will again bft necessary. I may remind you that away: to ,lvoill dE'kcbon. TIH' COllntrT IS thrroteDed<br />
with anolh,"l otlt-brt'uk of p!a£:ui. and whlh,t<br />
wben the position in Kenya heelllt'Ai 110t nnfavourahll',<br />
temperate argnments and full and frank our health officers ari.' doing their ntmo"t to pI'f'vent<br />
(,.Rcussion resulted in a better understanding of the it spreading. thongLtIellB white cltJzens are enCOUFagiDg<br />
these plpgne-carIIPI!l 10 roam about in their<br />
,'>Indian point of view and in a measure of relief to<br />
the disabilities felt by the Indians. I hope that. as midst, handltng eatables and mlxmg freely with<br />
in the case of Kenya so also in this case, r.ome remecly<br />
themselvps and their children.<br />
may be devised.<br />
Regal'dmg a decent standard of livin-g, many years<br />
of experii.'nce has taught us that the ASiatic prefers<br />
(0 continue uouer the comlitions he has been ac-<br />
ANTI-ASIATIC AGITATION IN THE customed to from birth. As a trader, he is Dot an aql'!t't<br />
TRANSVAAL - to this country. He adopts methods which no<br />
reliable white haUer h,iS any uesire to adopt.<br />
We take the following from the &nd Daily The losolvency comt has proved this times with-<br />
JIail :-<br />
out number,<br />
The picketing of Indian stores in the Southern They employ only theil' own class, because they<br />
Aubllrhs by youths and men in bIcycles has had a re- can- get them for next to nothin2, and yet some<br />
markable effect on Asiatic traders in the district. • people Sdy: .. Let the whIte storekepeer reduce his<br />
L'lIit year the Municipality issued over ~)O licences' prices equivalent to the ASiatic." •<br />
to Indians in the Southern Subnrbs. This year, it I can give you an I'xce!lent example of two shops<br />
:! stated, there has been a reduction in the numbcr that trade in simIlar Imps. one owned by a white<br />
tlO'llcences issued of about 33 per cent. trader anfl the othc·r 1'
INDIAN OPINION March 20th, 1925<br />
IndIan can complain if white p~ople make up thC'lr<br />
minds only to support men and women of theIr<br />
own colour.<br />
. It IS Important to remember, af] Mr, ROBtl pomts<br />
out in his excellent letter, that this is not simply a<br />
storekeepers' movement, If the AEllatIcl q\1e8tion<br />
concerned them alone they might be left, perhaps,<br />
to ,find their'own remedy, But -the future of the<br />
whIte race 111 South AfrlCa IS vitally affected, and<br />
the sooner that truth is recogmsed by ~very European,<br />
man or woman, the better WIn It he for the<br />
country, The Asiatic standard of hvmg 18 much<br />
lower thaf\ that 9f the Whites, Europeans cannot<br />
.reasonably\object to that, but they carl, and\ mUlSt '<br />
ensure the elimination of conditions which, 111 the<br />
long rnn, WIll bring about the lowering of t!Ie<br />
European standard, 'fhat IS a duty which they owe<br />
to themselves, to then' chIldren, and to their country,<br />
if thBY wish to se~ Eill'opJ;*tIL ci.vllisation permanently<br />
estabhshed, Moreover, they dare not<br />
overlook that the more they-snpp~rt Asi"hc tretmg,' It~ prPHHlent,<br />
MI', Ah,lnl \V,lhl'l, IS entlf'elr unknown to mt', an.i<br />
I tIC) not tlllnk tint .\ meetmg of >!ncl, a tIm 111 nnrnbel'<br />
ot pellplt:' nnder !J I;:, P\ e;:;i,lency c Ul pO'!'!I!'ly repl'e"enL<br />
the> whole of In.lIall OlJllIlOIl III E bt Atl'ICa,<br />
lUll' ll'l :;tJlll L t!J,lt ~Il)mbas,l. Z !Il/'Ib II' ,mel Tang,lnnkcl<br />
III h,m le_t leI'" luH' J.ltCt Lv ,h'~')(51J.k,l thems'l<br />
n''! 11 "Ill ft~ (Jonclll.,IOIl-,l, ~o lI" ,v.; h:J
M:Hch 20th. 'Me; ~NUIJ\N OPINlqN 79<br />
~(INDlA;{ HIGHER E()UCATIO~ IN NATAL<br />
(By COUlIlCILJ.OR THE REV. A. },.U:Olllf 1I.A., U.D.)<br />
It is now five rears ago since that humauitarian and<br />
true friend of the Indian CommuDity III Nat
, 80 INDIAN OPINION March 20th, 1925<br />
given the Go,,:ernment of Imha full creult fOl' firm<br />
and thorough gomg advocacy or onr canse. Let us<br />
hope that It will do notluug 1l0W to fOJ'felt thIS<br />
claim. I am a \yd-re that til
~pittillU<br />
No. 13-Vol. XXIII. Friday, March 27th, 1925.<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
4l\"<br />
Registered., the O. P.o •• s • News,.,..<br />
Pales rouuRll(..<br />
------------------------------------<br />
THE sewnd seSSlon of the Fifth PrOVlDCldl COUll- tually OJ'dered out of the Court. The accused, who<br />
II cl1 ot Natal was opened on Tuesd.1y the 2-1th stattd that the child had told him to "voetsak" and<br />
instant and. as we harl expeded, the Draft had called him a "blooming nigger," was ordered to<br />
Ordinance to amend the TowDship Law, No. 11 of receive four strokes with the cane ....<br />
IIlSI whkh aims at depriving IndMns of the vote ____<br />
in Townships was rushed through all the stages and<br />
pasiled.<br />
The Natal Provincial Gazette of th~ 19th of<br />
March contains a Draft Orrlinance " tor the estabb."hment<br />
of Townships." It is divitled into elevtm<br />
chapters and consolidates the defferent legislative<br />
acts concerning Townships into one. In the chapter<br />
dealmg with the qualification ot voters a similar<br />
clause is contained as thateontdineltin the Boroughs<br />
Ordinance and the Townships Fl'anchif.e Draft<br />
Ordinance indirectly disqualifying Indians from<br />
being enroled as voters. Among the various Laws<br />
and Ordinancetl which the present Draft Ordinance<br />
seeks to repeal are induded the Townships Law<br />
No, 11, 1881 ailtl the Townships FranehlHe Ordinance<br />
192.5.<br />
The Yolksl'ust Town Council havE' granted the<br />
local Indian Sports Club a portIOn of ground fOl'<br />
sports on condition that there should be no Sunday<br />
playing. The Conncil's I warning having, becn repeatedly<br />
disrE'gardell by Indians t~e fOl')nE'r is<br />
J'eported to have passed the following 1'E'801ution<br />
:-" The Indian Spot'ts Olnb having cbsrc/:,'llr(led<br />
the warning of the Council re Sunday sports on<br />
municipal lands, the priVllege granted the club be<br />
withdrawn for a perIod of three months. Any<br />
person found trespassing by playing on the ground<br />
ill question will be prosecuted." In reply to Councillor<br />
Payne's qUE'stion as to why Sunday sports<br />
were prevented, the answer was: .. Because the<br />
l\Iunicipabty has steadfastly upheld Sunday observance,<br />
and refused to s.mction 8un(hy games on<br />
Municipal gronnd. Peoph> could play on thE'l1' own<br />
ground if ther chose.<br />
'1'h9 Volksrust Town Council bemg It staunch<br />
follower of Christ;.m principles we are hopeful that if<br />
properly approached. and given an assurance that<br />
the Sunday rulE> would not be brokE'n in future the<br />
Conncil will forgive the Indian Sports Clnb and<br />
rescjntl the above rE'solution.<br />
~re is a rema;,~~::-:;:-wmg<br />
c1l'arly how<br />
the ~'lck man ~E'ts:-\\stlCE." in this country -<br />
"I &nnot underst.\\lll how some parents bring up<br />
their children," Bald Mr. Atkinson, when an unlfaau<br />
was charged with having as.l1mltCl.l a. little European<br />
bor of -1 yt'I\I'S of age hy thl'OWlil~' a stick at him.<br />
The child stated th.lt he said "vot't,s,lk" \0 the<br />
accused. ,,,ho threw a piece of wood whl(;h struck<br />
him on thl~ hend. "This chillI evidently thought he<br />
was qmte entitled to say ""oet&lk" to anyone. remarked<br />
the maglsh~l~. At this stage the child's<br />
father, "ho evidently rpsented the !I[agistl'.,te'J:j remarks.<br />
intel'l'upted the proceedings, and was even-<br />
By punishmg the Native the Magistrate has estabhshed<br />
it as a prinCIple that even a European<br />
chIld may URe abusive language towards a black<br />
man bnt the latter may, under no circumstances,<br />
retaliate. We should have thought the parent of<br />
the child deserved to be punished, rather than 'the<br />
Native, for brmgmg his children up so badly._ But.<br />
of course, where there is a questiou of white prestige<br />
to be considered:the question of justice, even in the<br />
Courts of Justice, is completely thrown over board.<br />
At a farewell luncheon given to the Prince of<br />
WalE'S at Savoy Hotel undE'r the presidentship of<br />
the new Union High Commissioner, Mr. Smit,<br />
replying to the toast the Prince of Wales Iii<br />
reported to have humorously referred to his<br />
hdblt of bringing back anything to which he took d<br />
fancy, and pictured hImself blocking the traffic ot<br />
London by driving an ox wagon through the streets.<br />
lIe is rt'pol'ted to have concluded by expressing the<br />
hopp that" he would gain first-hand knowledge of<br />
South Africa's "problems, and see for himself how<br />
these wt're bE'ing faced by the two great virile<br />
peoplE'S constituting the great Union."<br />
In the Indian Legislative Assembly the debate on<br />
the Fmauce Bill, which was carried by 75 votes<br />
to 40, was very animated, says Reuter, the Swarajlsts<br />
violently attacking the Government's policy,<br />
'saying the present administration must end. as it<br />
was condemned by the majority of the pM pie.<br />
Sir, AIE'xanJer l'tIuddiman (Leader of the House)<br />
sE'vE'rdy reprovE'd an Indian membE'r for alluding<br />
to the Govetnment as .. a devil's GovernmE'nt."<br />
)!.Ihomed Alli Jinnah had a brisk duel with Pandlt<br />
MotHal Nehru, who declared he intended to obstruct<br />
and wreck the Government. Mr. Jinnah argued<br />
that the country could not make the Government's<br />
pOSItion impossible while the Indians themselves<br />
were (lisorl.'llnised and powE'rless. He challenged<br />
PandlLNehru's statement that the Swarajists had<br />
a mandate from the majority of the onntry.<br />
8ir Alexander ?tluddiman announced in the Indian<br />
Legislative Assembly that his Majetlty-in-Conncil<br />
had assented to the Bengal Ordinance Act for the<br />
suppression of crime in Bengal. The Assembly<br />
(,~\rried l1[.,oainst the Govemment by 71 vott'S to 4;)<br />
Mr. P,Itel'S Bill proposing the repeal of certam<br />
special enactments, including the Bengal Regulation<br />
of SeditiOUS Meetings Act the Swarajists and IndepE'ndents<br />
voting togE'ther.<br />
Th(' E.lrl of Oxford and Asquith (Lord .-\.sqlllth)<br />
hdS been appoint~d .\ memher of the J udkiul COIUmittee<br />
of the Privy Council.
'INDIAN OPINiON March 27th, 1925<br />
A London message published in the Natal Mer-run!<br />
states ;-<br />
tord Readinglll retll.ri1 to Englartd may mean his<br />
retiretil.eht or rertewl11 o£ oflice for another period of<br />
two years, but it is considered improbable that even<br />
if a renewal is made he will rema.in for the full<br />
period of the e:l(tension. Two names have been<br />
prominently mentioned l'('garding the appointmenlr-Lotd<br />
Ronaldshay, who ~ was (}overnor of<br />
Bengal, and Sir George Lloyd, a former ('}overnor of<br />
Bombay, and a ,prominent Conservative member of<br />
Parliament. A third name being b1entionetl iE<br />
Lord Birkenhead, who IS credIted wIth a desire to<br />
succeed Lord Reading in India.<br />
... h .k t ~<br />
LORD CURZON<br />
"<br />
"I'r HE death of Lord CUl'zon after a brief illness,<br />
II which wat!" announced by Renrer on tlw 20th<br />
intltaht, is rto small blow to the British people<br />
and the British Parliatil.~nt. His Parliamentary<br />
career is considered td have been very brilliant. :tte<br />
enteTed Parliament III ~889 as COllllervative member<br />
fOl' the Southport DivisioU\of Lancashite and speedily<br />
made for hIMself a. reputation ill the House of<br />
Commons. Re was Under-Secretary of State for<br />
India UI~1-92 ahd pnder-Se'cretary for FOrtlign<br />
Affairs 1895-98, botli«)f which posts' gave hini experiencre<br />
for1;h~ two s'phe;es in ~~hich \l~ made bis<br />
name ramous in later, years.. lIe heid office in<br />
various capacities during the 'War and in 1919<br />
b~mtme Secretary of State for Foreil9nAffairs in<br />
Mr, Lloyd tloorge's Mministratioo. After tho down~<br />
faU of the Coalition he accepted the same office<br />
under Mr. Bonar Law, and. earned \vide l:enoWIi for<br />
the manner in which. he 'Conducted the negotiations<br />
with the victorious Ta.rks at Paris .~nc! ~~!:J.sanne._<br />
:m; was one ,of tbi skongeSt sPeakers do bis party.<br />
The name of Lo'l'd 'Citll'ZoI1 is dosely 'Connected<br />
with India and her people 'Owing to his viceroyalty<br />
in 1899. lTnfortunately he -W1\S lctOked upon as a<br />
tietTor. Ne~r, pp,rhatJl;l, it -is believed, has there<br />
been:a mure diaapipoi'l'ttrug ~gilI1e 1n India tban that,<br />
of Lutd -Cui'ZOli, !lToiWith'sfufidil1g hill uhdonbted,<br />
good qilalities o~ heaft a~ well as ~is Imques'ticruable,abHity<br />
the feeling in 1nula hJls been thal:. he had<br />
trodd@n und~r foot every principle of sober~ statesmanshipMld<br />
very'Ofteu,justice, tact, and fOl'eS'lghtin<br />
deaHng'with the gTeat Dependency. HIS final<br />
Aut wllS tbe Part.i~on 'Of l3EJ11gal 1\-t the time of the<br />
Partition, the people of 13enfol reasoned with" Lord<br />
Curzon, h1iI.t in the pride of power, he disregarded<br />
all their prayers::--l1e took \ it for granted that Indians<br />
could oniy prattle, tfuat they could neve.: take<br />
any effective t!'teps. Ire used insulting lllngttage,<br />
and in the teeth of all opposition, partitioned<br />
Bengal. ,However ungracious his act may have<br />
atJl>ea'l'e~ ~ be at t}le time there is ,not t~ least<br />
ao'libt tMt in 'later "years it hal! proved a ):Jlessmg.<br />
For, it was that very a.ct that roased once again the<br />
national feeling In India which was put to almost<br />
e"\Tt3r-'lasting sleep atter 'the advent of the Brithlh<br />
rule. The sternness, the unkindness of Lord<br />
Curzon has, whether consciously or unconsciously<br />
been like that hf a teacher to his pupils and the<br />
loss of Lord Curzon to India can be likened that of<br />
a preceptor.<br />
WARNING TO FARMERS<br />
MAIZE SPECULATotts METHODS<br />
PreM'ta. March 20 (Rettter),-The tollowmg<br />
o1fici~l statement hQ8 Wert issued by the Laud<br />
BaItk. :-It appears that speculators are at preseltt<br />
travelling round the mail:e producing district;!,<br />
purchasmg from the farmers theIr pI'o,",pective crops.<br />
It is believed that, in certain cases, they pm'chat;e<br />
the crop outright, but in most cases they offer 8(\<br />
much per bag for the C1'Op when re.\ped.<br />
Farmers should be very careful liS to the nature of(<br />
the agreement they enter into in thiS connection. as<br />
past experience has shown that the farmel' IS very<br />
liable to lose on the transaction. It is known that.<br />
in many cases the farmer has aol(l in ad\'ance, say.<br />
at lOs. a bag, The crop is estimated at, say, ;.1\10<br />
bags at lOs. a bag. This would mean .!:2;){l. The<br />
buyer pays the farmer, aay, £50 on aoool1nt.<br />
When the crop is reaped the buyer comes along<br />
wlth a bag of what he calls good maiTR, probably<br />
the best he can buy. He compares it with that of<br />
the farmer, and says: "No' YonI' maize is not<br />
up to slandard, I can only give you tis. for it."<br />
And the farmer frequently has lo accept it.<br />
,1'he obvioue remedy is. of conrse, for the farmer<br />
to eo-operate. lIe can then get an advance as soon<br />
as his crop is reaped, but if.he doos not co-operate.<br />
he should be very careful about selling in 3IlvJ.nce.<br />
If he Is ofl'ered a g?od price, let him sell by an<br />
aU meahs, but then he must be sme that he gete II<br />
written:cQntract with the buyer, making it ci('ar<br />
that the maize sold is maize reaped from certain<br />
landa, alid. hot maize of a cerlain quality.<br />
I The contract should also bind the buyer to take<br />
deUtery a.nd pay for the maille by a certain date, on<br />
pain of cancellation of sale and forfeiture of any<br />
amount paid in advance.<br />
It seems that these speculatol's are urging farrnerli<br />
to sen new, on the gtoun« that maize mIl be chcs,per<br />
later on. If that is so, why' do they buy? They<br />
argue that there will Ire a big SUl'ptus for export.<br />
thi.s 'y~ear ~ and that the ovel1l6ll1J price wiU fa.l~ ()I)IIlsequently<br />
local prices will be low. .<br />
As a matter of fact, whether the expottabll'J £'l1'<br />
plus is 4,OOO,.()()O, bags or 14,{)O(),OOO bagp, it ""n<br />
make no appreciable difference in the 'WotU'fj<br />
market price fOt' mai7Al.<br />
INtnA ANb SELF-OOVERN~mNT<br />
. ['he "ihbltne (lahore) in commenting on Dr. J. T.<br />
Sunderland's new book, "India, America and World<br />
Brotherhood," published by Messrs. Ganem and Co ..<br />
of Madras, gives prominence to the author's rep-Iv<br />
to the two usual arguments against the gnmt of<br />
self-government to India. One is that India 18 a<br />
land of many races and communities and of a<br />
variety of langues. "Why do these numbers make<br />
it necessary for the land to be ruled by foreigners<br />
and. atrangel!a?" 1!aYII Dr. Sunderland. "The need<br />
seems to be Just the opposite," a.nd he proceeds<br />
to show that the exIstence of the same or even<br />
greater diversity has never; yet been made an<br />
argument in other countries for depriving their<br />
peonle of self-government. The specific cases cited<br />
by him are those of Russia, of t~ fJoited States and<br />
of Canada. The first'two. he says,."'nave demonstrll.bly<br />
more languages and natienalities than India, while<br />
third has a greater diVersity, considering the nnmbel'<br />
of its population. And yet in none of these<br />
cases does any OIlfl assert that the people concerned<br />
are on this account incapable af exeJ'cising self-rule.<br />
The other argument is that if the BritJhli withdrew<br />
from India the whole peninsula would become Il<br />
chaos of bloodshed and \'1alence. This would undoubtedly<br />
be so, says the writer: if the BritiJsh were<br />
to go suddenly and to-morrow, without making any<br />
provision for successors, or tor any Government at<br />
all 'to take their place. But the same would be the
iNDIAN OPINION<br />
ca'lO in the BUlle ('on(lition in London and ~ew<br />
York.<br />
'The 'ib/lillie flfl'i alS/) rept'O,Lncetl from Dr. ~ltnd(~r-<br />
1,11)11'. 'JHU\C th" opinions of two eminent iluthfllltIPK<br />
wbiJ hllve ¥lealt witb the question of Til'Cparalion for<br />
Kclf·govf'fJUmmt either With dil'ect referet.ce to<br />
Indut'ot' In a genel'at way. One II! the G~rmdn<br />
Amel"ic.lIl slateHman, Mr. Kchvrz. "One of the most<br />
~ntet'c81ing experiments of my lIfe," he Itlys in hi~<br />
l'emini!C(fnCCil, ','was the oiJscrvation of the educa.<br />
tional irrflnence clU'I'Clscd upon IUcn by the actnal<br />
[1)'a,cticO' of self;government. What is somt'tmw8<br />
call6jl tbe art of lelf-IIovernment is not learned by<br />
maSBe8 ()f people- theoretwally or even by the mel'll<br />
repre.entatlOn of the other people's experience:! hy<br />
way of instrtlctlve example. Practice is the (lnly<br />
rCfllly effective teacher." Ag.lin: "There is not<br />
any iustance In history of ';\ people having been<br />
taught to govern themllClvell by a tuteldry power<br />
acting upon the prinCiple that its wards should not<br />
be glvpn the power of self-goTernment \lntil they<br />
h.lve shown theIDeclves fit for It." The other quo·<br />
t.ltion is from the historian ChArles FranCIS AdaJlf!.<br />
"I submit" says this authority, "that there is not an<br />
instance ill all the recorded hililtory from the earliest,<br />
timCf! until now where Ii so-called inferior lace or<br />
commltnity hal9 been elevated in It~ character or<br />
made self-governing or even put on the way to that<br />
result through 8 condItion of dependency or tlttlage.<br />
I might Without much danger assert that the condition<br />
of dependency even for communities of the<br />
same race and bloo(l always exerCises an emasculating<br />
and deterioratmg influence. I wouhl undertake<br />
if called tlpon, to show that this is invariable-that<br />
from the inherent and fundamental condItions of<br />
human natnro it -has known and "'Can lcnow no exceptions."·<br />
Speakmg with particlliar refercnce_ to<br />
India, Mr. AU.tms added, in the lUost explicit terms<br />
tha~ notwithstandtng any or all material or other<br />
improvBRleutil made in tho country by the British<br />
llinM the E,\st India Company began its carf)er of<br />
eKplOitation and conquest of the land, British RuJe<br />
hal been a.n absolute faihlre as a means for incre.lsing<br />
the capacity or fitness of Indi,\n people for selfgovernrnt'nt;<br />
it had not incre.tsed that capacity or<br />
that fitness in the slightest degree but on the C011-<br />
trary it had actuall~ lessened it.<br />
'rnE PRom.EM IN EAST AFRICA<br />
This ill what Dt', Norman ley, an Englishman<br />
writE'S in his lately published book on "Kenya" on<br />
the nature of the problem in that Colony :-<br />
"Ellropean immigration has not filled and cannot<br />
fill the spaces in Africa left ('mpty by the slave wars<br />
and by the kind of exploration which since slavery<br />
WQS abolit;hed has prevailed in the }'rench and Belgian<br />
Congo as well as in Kenya Indtan immIgration<br />
c(mId fill these enlpty spaces. Also, our Empire<br />
contains immense scantily populate
INDIAN OPINION<br />
wood (Newcastle-under-Lyme, Labour), who askt'd<br />
whether the Secretary of State or the GoVel'llment<br />
of India had made any representations as to the proposed<br />
colour bar legislation in South Africa and the<br />
possible effect upon th& amicable relations of the<br />
Union and India, ,Earl Winterton said, my noble<br />
friend, Lord.Birkenhead, has authol'is~d the Government<br />
of India to comnlunicate with the Union Government<br />
on the subject.<br />
Earl Winterton in reply to Sir F. Nelson (Strond,<br />
Unionist) said the pending legislation necessary to<br />
give effect to the, findings of the Lee, Commission<br />
would take the form of an amending Bill to the<br />
existing Government of India Act.<br />
In the cou~se Qt the discussion on Trade FaCllitles,<br />
Mr. G. Pilcher (Pe'Yryu and Falmouth) said there<br />
were only two inshlhceEl of money'advances to'wartls<br />
Indian schemes: :H~ knew of at least' one very bigscheme<br />
waiting for development in India and If the<br />
Indian authorities were approached by the India<br />
Office on behalfof the Trade Facilities Committee,<br />
they would find a really good reception for any<br />
proposal they put forward. He referred to the<br />
How,rah Bridge Scheme m Calcutta, The only<br />
obstacle to the erection of this very necessary bridge<br />
was the lack of moblle capital. The Bengal Chamber<br />
of Commerce had dlscufsed the possibility of getting<br />
mop.ey under the Trade Facilities Scheme, and if<br />
that initiative fOD which Mr. YUton had pleaded for<br />
were forthcoming from the'India Office
March 27th, 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
lltated that it was not pl'opoHed to proceed with the<br />
question 01 transfer during the prCHeut 8cI!8ioIl of<br />
Parliament. That, he thought, dh,posed of the<br />
qUE'stion at the preRent time. The matter hall Hilt<br />
yet reach('(l the stage at which his ~lajeRY'b Governmf'nt<br />
coulil announce any decision. It waR obviollsly<br />
premature to make any statement 8JI tq what conditions<br />
should be attached to any transfer. if and<br />
·when any such tr-.msff'r as was referred to in the<br />
qllf'Stion took plact': but, generally speaking, he<br />
could assure Lord Buxton that the provisions of<br />
Hf'('tion 151 of the South Afl'ica Act would be carefully<br />
adhered to. A pl9l1ge was ~rivt'n when th!'<br />
Act was being pal!8ed that, in the event of any proposed<br />
transfer, steps would be taken to ascertdin the<br />
views of tht' population, both native and white, in<br />
the territories affected. To that pledge the G()vernment<br />
adhered. They would not make any decision<br />
in regard to any transfer until the population had<br />
had a fnll opportunity of exprel!8ing their views,<br />
and any representations which they wished to make<br />
wonld J'eceive the most careful considt'ration of ~he<br />
Government before a final deCision was given. •<br />
Lord Arnold said he desired to press on the Govt'mment<br />
the extreme importance of making quite -<br />
flure that the natives themselves, and not merely<br />
the chiefs, were given the opportunity of expressing<br />
their views before any decision was made, and that<br />
their int£'rests in the land, labour conditions, and so<br />
forth were safeguarded.<br />
The motion for papers" as by leave withdrawn.<br />
And .in the House of Commons in reply to<br />
Colom'l Wedgwood (Newcastle-under-Lyme, Lab.),<br />
Und£'r-Secretary for the Colonies. Mr. Ormsby-Gore<br />
(Stafford) said :-In accordance with. the pledges<br />
given when the South Africa Bill was before Parliament,<br />
the House will have the fullest opportunity<br />
of discllssing, and, if they wish, of disapproving<br />
aDY prllpose(l transfer' of Bechnanaland, Basntoland,<br />
or,H-wa"ihmd to- th& "Union.<br />
ASIATIC IMMIGRATION TO AMERICA<br />
(By V. V. OKA, CLARKE UNIVERSITY,<br />
WORCESTEU, MASS-U.S.A.),<br />
There has b£'en a considerable misunderstandmg<br />
in India about the Immigration Act that was pass£'d<br />
in this conn try this year. This misunderstanding is<br />
further heightened by a few misleading articles<br />
appeal'iog in some magazines. I intend to dl:al<br />
with this question in all its aspects, because I do<br />
bplieve there is no country in the worM. which<br />
offers such 1\ nice place for students as this cOlin try.<br />
EARLY HI~TORY<br />
Had it llOt been for the rise of modern Japan, the<br />
eastern nations would have been regarded as entirely<br />
unfit for Self-Govel'nment on the lines of western<br />
political theory. The awakeniug of Turk£'y has alsoenhanced<br />
the prestige of Asia, known in this country<br />
as a "land of mysticism, witchcraft, orthodoxy,<br />
polygamy, etc."<br />
Dnring the closing decade of the last century, and<br />
following the discovery of gold mines in California<br />
when the new land on the Pacific coast was to be<br />
changetl {1'Om "wild deserts" into "smiling farms,"<br />
not only 'was Asiatic immigration not prohibited, but<br />
it was directly encouraged. Bnt as soon as this was<br />
:lone and aU cultivabl£' land was occupied by the<br />
Americans, they b£'gan to show a hOEtile attitude<br />
towards the Asiatics because of the gradual attempts<br />
made by them to rise from their low statns to. that<br />
of farm£'rl'l Or businelt'l-men. On account of their<br />
industriouR and thrifty life their low standard of<br />
lhing and their exceptional agricultural skill the<br />
Japanese and th€' Hindus became a menacing £'COnomic<br />
factor. As ear1y as 1882 anti-Chinese !aws<br />
'W~re pasfled but'by ttl07 It irtl'Ong anti-Asiatic a~ha-<br />
,/<br />
tion was LtUncheJ Oil the PaCific cQast· which iit the<br />
main centre of AlliatiC immigl"'duts. A law wall<br />
p'dB8ed in that year prohibiting the entry of Asiahc<br />
labourers into thi'l country. .Japan, to saVA her face<br />
from the hnmiliating impoflition of being oorr£'d as<br />
unfit for entry into thE' Fniteol Stdtes, agreed of her<br />
own accord not to grant passportR to any labourers or<br />
oth£'rwise nndesirable perbOnB to come to this country.<br />
This compact was known as the "Gentleman's<br />
Agreement."<br />
LATER DEVELOPMENTS<br />
In 1916, attempt was made to exclude all Asiatics,<br />
including even travellers and students. from entering<br />
into the States, but thanks to th9 efforts of Lala<br />
Lajpatrai and others who were here at that time,<br />
the Bill was modified, allowing stude~ts, travellera,<br />
and businessmen to enter freely for a temporary<br />
visit. Th£' "Gentleman's Agreement" with Japan<br />
was not cancelled.<br />
Last year, however, Ca1ifornia, one of the Pacific<br />
States, once more started the anti-Jdpanel!e agitation,<br />
She passed a law in the State J~egislatnre prohibiting<br />
any alien, ineligible for cItizenship, to own L'lnd in<br />
that state or acquire a lease over t.hree years. This<br />
cannot be at all called a drastic measure as is often<br />
sought to make. The State of California was perfectly<br />
justified in not granting nght to own lands to<br />
aliens who had been debarred already since 1907<br />
from becoming citizens of the United States by the<br />
Federal Government, and which alone had the<br />
p
, 86 . INDI~N OPINION March 27th~ 1925<br />
--!..----------- ---------"-- - ----- - .----<br />
,<br />
Agreement" by allowing labourers to eonfe over to<br />
thIS cOllhtl'Y under the prete;xt of stuuents or travellerll.<br />
l thE; offer df the<br />
Durban, Corporation to the Indhn community<br />
to celebrate thiS l vent. -<br />
As the matter I::> of tllm6st importance<br />
all. Indlall3~ are earnestly req~ested to' elt:<br />
tend.<br />
_AMOD BAYAT, Cbair~an.<br />
SORABJEE RU6T01\UEE ) Jf. 11011.<br />
v. s. C.PATHE~ f Secretaries.<br />
. N.I.C.<br />
-,--..--<br />
__ tl. :(~l~G'4~l",1 ~lq,Jl ~~l,!lq<br />
~Hi +tllhl<br />
rlp.l~ ~r.:t~t~ q~ttI ~~h~,.fi ~~~ tlb tiltl~<br />
t4.L~~ ~ctt 'Uil~ (tlrl'tt'l H~L~i ~Uq ~.<br />
~~~~
J!ttfliatt ~pilliolt<br />
','" No. 14-VOl. XXIII, Friday, April 3rd, 1925.<br />
RegIStered at tbe G P.O. d£ a Yew.paper<br />
PIllC. rOVil"~lfC...<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
~J...sI circumstances<br />
be accepted. aud as to that, there is no<br />
difference of opinion. But it is suggested by Borne<br />
, that, if the sum were augmented and facilities given<br />
on anywhere near equal terms with the Enropeans,<br />
the community should accept the offer of the Corporation.<br />
.<br />
There are others, however, who are doubtful as<br />
to whether Indians should at all particiPate in the<br />
jollification evenif offered complete equality. They<br />
feel that their position iu this sub-continent h' by no<br />
metmB 80 bright as to encoD1'Ilge them to indulge in<br />
any jollification. They feel that Wlitica11y and<br />
socially they nave been dragged down to the level<br />
of helots and towards that direction the Government<br />
of this cQllntry have not yet stayed their hands.<br />
There are already Acts in the Statute books' of this<br />
conntry that humiliate Ull. They have placed ns in
INDIAN OPINION April 3rd. 1925<br />
a position that cannot be" envied by any self· DR. MOLL'S OPINION OF THE PRo-ASIATIC<br />
respectjng people. And that is. not the end of it. Such '\The man who is pro-Asiatic in this country is a<br />
fUrther legisration is before tp.e Provincial Council and peril to the future of South Africa," said Dr: Moll<br />
the Union Parliament in the course of being passed<br />
of Johannesburg, in a speech to the N'orwoOlI Anti.<br />
~iatic Association recently. All over the world<br />
without heedihg to the voice of those against whom tue white races were fighting against the menace.<br />
it iff directed and stilr more is under preparation. Australia, Canada and the United States had closed<br />
And what is the reason for all this? Are Indians their doors to the Asiatics, and South Africa should<br />
in this country such treacherollli people? Are they not forget her duty to her future generatIons. The"<br />
so wild that they require all this control? Are The Indians, Dr. Moll declared, looked on Africa i::<br />
their tenjtory in all seriousness, and he urged that"<br />
they nOf law-abiding? Are they seditious? Are<br />
everything should be done to fight the menace. The I<br />
they crhhinal? To that the authorities rep~y: "Oh movement should spread from the small townships<br />
no, they are the most law-abiding and peaceful into the provinces and throughout the length and ,<br />
citizens: they have rendered llseful service iI\ the breadth of the land. One good pomt diseernible in' I<br />
development of this country." What then is the the effects of the menace was that it would be the I<br />
matter With them? They are very industrious; means of uniting the white population of this coun- i<br />
their requirem~nts are meagre and hence they are<br />
try. It was a most scandalous thing that the race :<br />
should be divided about little things when this I<br />
progressing much faster in every ,direction. But storm was gathering. There should be on(' big l<br />
they have not shown any inclination of becoming w,ute stream directE'd against the menace.<br />
rulers of thisCOl.1lltry, have they? Oh no, not in<br />
the lealit. _<br />
And this is why Indians ill" thIS country strongly<br />
CHRISTIANITY VS. RACIALISM 1<br />
feel that the treatment they are sub)·ected to is A striking sermon was recently delivQred by the<br />
Rev. E. F. Paget, of Betloni, in the Palladium<br />
totally unwarranted. They feel that as subjects of Theatre;, i<br />
His l\fa;eaty: the King their lot in this country is Love, he said, as exemplified by the actions of j<br />
-anything but pleasant and therefore they feel that Christ was not the "weak and silly lientimental ,:<br />
tqIS is not a tlffi'e for them to rejoice.' stuff" which was being "dished out to the world." t:<br />
But w-hat has this got to do with the Prince? it That sort of love did not encourage anyone to acts II'<br />
- of sacrifice. "- :,<br />
is argued. / Chriet did not come to get rich ,quick. He was II<br />
The unJustifiable acts committed by the Govern- not looking fo~· poplIlarity, votes or brioos. He had ;!<br />
ment of this country agaiJist -a section of His no axe to grmd. He merely cami to Berve his H<br />
Majesty's_subjects are committed in his name and it fellow-men. jH<br />
is felt that in so far a.s His Royal lIighness is con-. The gospel of Christ was a revolutionary onE'. He'<br />
loved the humble. "He kept compant with the;,<br />
nected wIth this system he has to bear the responsi- sort of people you w9uld cut dead in the str('et be- 'i<br />
bility.<br />
._ ~ callse you did not want to be seen I'Ipeaking to them,''' ,I.<br />
Moreover It is felt that by refraining from.Arl1 add€d Mr. Paget. , t"<br />
jollifications we do/not in fIielOOst"'mean (6 c~~V"ey Any fool could: merely love nis friends and hate<br />
to His Royal Highness that we are lacking in our his enemies. The teaching of Christ demanded,<br />
f h<br />
'-' 11· to th Th' however, that any enemy should be treated as a I<br />
respect or 1m or m our a eglance e rone. friend. i<br />
What we wish to convey to" him is this that he "You can ridicule as much as you like about the: I<br />
should not be misgmded into the belief that all his tlieory of turning the other cheek and you can say' I<br />
father'S subjects are happy and contented; for it is a mug's game," declared the speaker. "If thad<br />
there are some of his lllOst l{)yal subjects who are is so, then Christ is a mug and you believe in and I<br />
b . .• 1 d d th . - h -1 f<br />
emg crus 1e un er e Jron ee s<br />
d t follow a mug."<br />
0 a espo lC R f . to th 1 b h ·.1<br />
., . - e errmg e co our aI', e salt
April 3rd, 1925 INDIAN OPINION a9<br />
--- ---~~~~------------------~----------------------------~<br />
they wm'e the servar.tg of RighteousneBB and the mittee" and shdll consist of five- members of the<br />
Kmgdom of God.<br />
Council. 3 of whom shall form a quorum.<br />
"We "fe not." he said. "golllg to find a deliverance 6. Allliceuces iBBued under these By-Laws shall<br />
lir the way of sloppy sentiment. but by bravely be subject to all Laws amI Regulations promulgdted<br />
f,wing the situation. thmking justly. and recogDllling by competent authority. 3d well 118 to these Bythat<br />
every man. no matter what his colour or race.<br />
h..uJ a right to the greatest opportunity for full development,<br />
lIen have come to recognise that it IS<br />
'1I1)t pJ'ofiwlJle to be unjust. aud that reprClll:!ion only<br />
,..!I[Jclls pdin an,1 menaco in the futuI'e."<br />
J. Refel'J'mg tu the LI.L1ne that Wall often pl
90 INDIAN OlJlNION<br />
mittee shall be granted if applied for by the applicant<br />
in order to m"et such ?bjection.<br />
10. For the transfer of any licence from any per<br />
,SOIl or premIses to any other person or premises<br />
application shall be made in like manner as the<br />
applicants for the grant or renewal of licences.<br />
11. The pr~cedul'e to be followed by the Licensing<br />
Committee at its sitting shall mutatts mutanais<br />
be the same as those appertaining to the procedure<br />
in respect of the grant of Kamr eating-house licences.<br />
12. No licences shall be ~anted in respect of any<br />
premises un~ess they shall comply with the following<br />
conditIons to the satisfaction of the Licensing<br />
Co~mittee viz \-<br />
(a) All fruit, l'egetables and all food and nonintoxicating<br />
beverages intended for sale: aha!}<br />
be stored in a room set apart for that purpose<br />
~nd such room shall be well ventilated<br />
to the open air and shall be rodrnt proof, and<br />
shall at allJ,imes be kept in a cleanly and<br />
healthy condition and there shall be no immediate<br />
communication with any Hving or<br />
'sleeping apartment, and no sll,ch fruit, vege<br />
April. 3rd, 1925 INDIAN UPINION 91<br />
Wladyslaw Heymont is little known even by n:lI11e<br />
in England though his magterpiece The Pheat!:lnls,<br />
which td.rned him the prize this. year, has been<br />
tr.lnslated into several other languages.<br />
The preYioull Polish Nobel Prizewinner, H. Sienkiewicz<br />
has just died; his novel Quo Vatlis. a story<br />
of. early Christianity in Rl)me, was once very<br />
popular. .<br />
• Among the candit1l.tes nominated for 192i had been<br />
,thomas Hardy, the Russian Ma~im Gorki, and the<br />
Spanish ~ovellist, BlaHco Ibanez, well known to Englit;h<br />
frequenters of the Picture hoube tor his Four<br />
Hot'semen of the ApocalYPile. The prize 18 awarded<br />
annually out of a fund left in IS91; by Alfred Nobel,<br />
a Swedish millionaire and the invpntor of dynamite,<br />
to "those who have contributed most to the Cl)mmOrl<br />
good dlll'ing the year." The Swediilh Academy of<br />
Liwl'atur'l is responsible ior the award in litel'ature,<br />
there are four other prizes, three for science and one<br />
for work for the preservation of peace, each prize is<br />
worth about £ (j500.<br />
Dr. Rabindranath Tagore WIlS on a previous<br />
occatlion awarded the Nobel prize for literature: ••<br />
MAHATMA ~ANDHI'S }WHAT'S VI81T<br />
REFUSED BY VICEROY<br />
The tollowing is the interesting telegraphic correspondence<br />
that took place between the Vic~roy<br />
and Mahatma Gandhi and Mahatma Gandhi's com~<br />
ment thereon appea"ing in the Youllg Ind/o' dated<br />
Feb.2!.i:-<br />
TELEGRAM TO THE PRIV A'fE SECRETARY ,<br />
To THE VICEROY -<br />
10-2-1:15.<br />
"Doesl1is Excellency now consider it_possible to<br />
pet'mit me and my colleagues to visit Koha~ during<br />
beginning March."<br />
REPLY TO THE ABOVE<br />
13-2-25.<br />
"His Excellency the Viceroy desir('~ me to thank<br />
\ 3'Otr for your telegram and the courtesy that<br />
prompted it. His Excellency would have been glad<br />
to be able to fall in with your wishes. But his<br />
attention has been called to the advice you have just<br />
given in }' oung Indl" to the Kohat Hindus not to<br />
return to Kohat'unless the Muslims-make honourable<br />
peace with them Without Government intervention.<br />
The only construction Ilis Excellency can<br />
put on thitj article is that if you went to Kohat yOUI'<br />
influence would be directed towal'di the breakdown<br />
of the recent settJement. the effecting of which was<br />
a matter of great concern to His Excellency and<br />
from which he hopes and bolieves an epdurmg reconciliation<br />
will spring, His Excellency is Sure<br />
thel'efore that 16U yourself will appreciate how im-<br />
, potlsible it is for him to faU in with your wishes."<br />
SECOND TELEGRAM TO PRIVATE SECRETARY<br />
To THE VICEROY<br />
1!l-2-25.<br />
"Thanks telellram. In Youn,q Iml/o' mE'ntioned<br />
your telegram I have stated ideal .. but have no desire<br />
to disturb, withdrawal prosecution. My purpose is<br />
to estabhtlh real peace which I hold is 'almost impOSSible<br />
with Government jnterventiCUl or bE\!:ter<br />
_till with0t!~private and spontaneous effort. Intervention<br />
of m"!' friends and self can only assist Government<br />
effort so far as it promotes substantial<br />
/ ,~ce. PIE'ase reply Sabarmati."<br />
, ftEPLY TO THE ABOVE<br />
22-2-2,').<br />
"His Excellency desire" me to th411k you for your<br />
telegram. The agree~nt which has now been<br />
laboriously reached was only pOSSible with tlle<br />
spontaneous help of private pel'80ns of both communities.<br />
It is of course of the nature of a compromise<br />
6etweell the two communities and any alteration<br />
iu its tel'md would upset the whole settJt!ment.<br />
Moreover it is only on the basis of this -settlement<br />
that His Excellency consented after much hear~<br />
searching to
low. The burden of the land tax is very much<br />
lower that what it ought to be. Land revenUE;<br />
in IndIa is burdensome when the holding is<br />
sm,lller than an economic holding.<br />
"LE'gIslation as necessary for abdtrshing utleconomlC<br />
holdings. The present legislation was<br />
putting a premium on small farmlllg. The sille<br />
of a holdmg is seldom sufficIently large for the<br />
use of labour-saving machmeIY. The present<br />
state of leglslation is making all economic<br />
boldings to become a number of uneconomic<br />
holdmgs. There IS absence of a proper system<br />
Of vi11ag~ industries to take care of the su:plus<br />
people. \!
·~ lillian ar11& + +<br />
~'ttttgU<br />
No. J,5-Vo1 •. XXIII. Friday, April loth, 1925.<br />
llegiatered at the O. P.O •••• N .... p.p.r<br />
Pales "OU"l!~S<br />
A correspondent with the nom de plume, "Neutrality"<br />
writing to the fltar (Johannesburg) rephes<br />
to BOme of the allegations by anti-ASiatics against<br />
Indians :-<br />
"Thol1j;(h Mr. Kirkby has promised to tel'ln Indians<br />
or Chinese "coolie~," he talks of the so-called<br />
"ASIatic menace." :Mr. HOBS says the ASIatic "as a<br />
, trader is no aSSf't to this country." As a trader the<br />
Asiatic is the gredtest asset to this cot\ntry, whose<br />
wholesale stores (white) get customers in Indians,<br />
keeping money in the' country where they are<br />
settled, and are a boon to the poor -whiles owing to<br />
their reasonable prices and fair dealing. He further -<br />
argues that the Asiatics employ their own class of<br />
men for next to nothing. This is very tdr from<br />
hdug the case. Asiatic servants are never cheap.<br />
"I'hou&mds of whites, girls and boys, are employed<br />
by the white firms at monthly wages of £3 or so,<br />
excluding clothing and food, whJle it is impossible<br />
to get an Indian servant at the minimum salary of<br />
£5, including food. :Mr. Ross dwells a\ length on<br />
the "appalling conditions that exist in the Maiay<br />
location," I\S related. by Dr. Porter, the Chief Medical<br />
Officel' of Johannl'sburg. I will ask DI·. Porter<br />
and Mr. Hoas whose fault is this? Three years ago<br />
the Asiatic Inquiry Commission criticised the local<br />
municipality keeping Iltlch a shun in the centre of<br />
this city and. displaying utter indifference towards<br />
its health condition. Has the Johannesburg Municipality<br />
ever t.l.ken a step to improve the conditIOns?<br />
The Indians are not to be blamed. because they al'e<br />
ever, ready to follow the dictates of their "city<br />
fathers." There has been' II severe outbreak of<br />
pl,lgue in the Ol"ange FI'ee State. Is it due to the<br />
Asiatics?<br />
... MI·. G. Kam,llU', of Christiand (Transv.).lI) is informed<br />
by the Priucipal Immigration Officer of the<br />
Province of Natal in reply to his letter of the 26lh<br />
August, addressed to the Secretary fol' the Interior,<br />
that Article 12 of Chapter 22 of tho Or,mge Free<br />
, 8t.lte Laws provides that the restrictlolls on the<br />
entry ami rt'sidence' in the Orange Freo State shall<br />
• not apply to the inhabitants of the Cape Colony<br />
known under the IlIlme of Malays.<br />
~!r. P. Anjaneyulu P, !Dembet· of the Indidll Lt:'gislative<br />
Council, writes ;- '<br />
Soyeral friends have uRked me why I ha.ve taken<br />
to ()hal'~:) V;pinning). and wp,cthcr it is not. a '{.11!.'<br />
NOTES 'AND NEWS<br />
~,~<br />
?\l MEETING of Indians. ulldr the auspices of To them my reply is this ;-<br />
Llil the Natal Indian Congress. Wal! held on (1) I thought it was a 'fad' but now I am learning<br />
Sunday to discnss certain matters in COIl- it is not.<br />
llel,LJOn with the penoing. viSit of the Prince of' (2) It is the L.C.M. and G.C.1tI. that could be con-<br />
Wales to Durban. and a rl'solution to the following<br />
effect was adopted ;-<br />
ceived for all classes and conditions of men, women<br />
and children of this country.<br />
"That the offer of .£200 for Indlaft ct'lebrations (;~) It: teache/J the first lessons in humility,<br />
by the COl'pOI'aUoD of Durban to the Indian com- patience, and develops a sense of fellowship and of<br />
munity be not accepted, and that a committee of ten common brotherhood.<br />
members of the Natal Indian Cor.gJ·ess be for~d, (4) It serves as the fil'it, and the foremost 'tep<br />
With power to negotiate with the Corporation, fbr towards the solution of the economic problems of the<br />
better and more hononrable terms." country. .<br />
(5) It is the symbol of self-reliance.<br />
(fj) It helps towards the concentration of the<br />
mind with the music of the 'whirl', and one may<br />
feel as the thread is drawn, that one is contributing<br />
towards the weaving of 'the web of Indian life.'<br />
(7) Religiously viewed, the thread we make is<br />
the 'Yegnopavitha' (the sacred thread) of the country<br />
and the functIon is the 'Gayatri japam' of its<br />
votarIes; through it alone we become the "twiceborn"<br />
-the regenerate.-SwaraJya.<br />
The following discussion took place in the Imperial<br />
Parliament on India ;-<br />
Colonel Wedgwood (Newcastle-under-Lyme, Lab.)<br />
asked the Prime Minister whether Sir John Kerr<br />
had been appointed Deputy-Governor of Bengal;<br />
and. If so, why the Senior Executiv{' Councillor, Sir<br />
Abdul' Rahman, was not appointed, in view of the<br />
general practice in such matters.<br />
Earl Winterton, Under-Secretary for India (Horsham<br />
and Worthing). who replied, said ;-No<br />
"general practice" can be said to exist in respect of<br />
, the allministration of an Act which has only been a<br />
few months- in operation. The right hOIl. gentleman,<br />
presumably, has in mind the provisions relating<br />
to the filling of temporary vacancies, but these provisions.<br />
have no application to ths selection of<br />
substitutes for Governors proceeding on leave.<br />
Replying to supplementar:y questions by Colonel<br />
Wedgwood, Earl Winterton was understood to say<br />
that the Act of last year could not be said to have<br />
altered a practice which did not previously exist.<br />
The practice with regard to the filling of an ordinary<br />
vacancy was not analogous to the SItuation which<br />
had arisen under the Act of last year, which, for the<br />
fil'St time, gave power to the Secretary of State in<br />
Council to grant leave to a Governor which had<br />
never previously been allowed. It was Dot correct<br />
to say that they were imporLing a new principle into<br />
that Act...<br />
Earl Winterton. Under-SeQretary for IndIa, in<br />
reply to Mr. Lansbury (Rowand Bromley. Lab.,)<br />
8.1hl that Hyndman's "The Awakening of ASIa,"<br />
Bryan's "British Rule in India," M. N. Roy's<br />
"Evolution of Economic Organization of India"<br />
and L'll.l Lajpat Rai's "England's debt to India:"<br />
had been prohibited entry 'into In(lia by notHic,.tions<br />
ulltlcr the SE"d Customs Act. The reason<br />
in the case of three of them was that the publicatiullll<br />
con\..Wloo ~ and maliciflU~ misrepre-
94 INDIAN OPIt-lION April 10th, 1925<br />
sentations of the' British Administrati.on in India.<br />
Roy's book was proscribed becaul!e all his wfltings<br />
and those of his wife were prohibited, in view of<br />
their complicity in a foreign orgamzed conspiracy<br />
to overthrow Brjtisb rule in India. He had no definite<br />
informatlOn regar
April 10th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 95<br />
wished to exprefiS his views. Aftpr the Licl'nsinll<br />
Officer pronounc.cu his IleOI .. lOn, and before the<br />
Council could hl!tl'l'} tp the merltl! of the caB"'.<br />
hldivldual COllnClUors Wl'r(' approdc.hetl by intel rsted<br />
pUl'tiell Bunce their decision? Y ct that waf! the pnslliun ill<br />
which memhers of tile ClilinCiI founu LhC'uuj('lvell<br />
when deahng with the&'l licl'n8111g appealil. It was<br />
time the Council took .lra.;tic action. for it was olll~T<br />
fair tlll'lt membel·tJ sbould be protectl'd from this<br />
canv8>18ing. lIe 8uggested that the Town Clerk<br />
sbolJld be ailkell to submit a memoranJum on the<br />
subject. Perhapf! tbey cOlilJ Ilave a similar Idw to<br />
that which disqualified canrli(L'Itl's for billets if thl'Y<br />
canvafiBed members of the Conncil.<br />
"1 have sat at this hOI seshoe for six an.l a halt<br />
) ears. and I have never been approachell by anyone<br />
in connection with a licensing appeal," ob::;erved<br />
Councillor Mitchell. ~<br />
Councillor SmIth: Councilor Mitchell can nevet<br />
he found.<br />
Th!.' Mayor aaitl apart from what Mr. Mitchell had<br />
sllid, thal'a were very few of them who had llot had<br />
the experien'te of being approached by someone<br />
interested in a licence. 'fhe Town CI!.'rk would<br />
submit a memorandum at! slll{gested.<br />
'rhe first appeal was made by Mr, Goulding on<br />
behalf of Moosa Brothers. who hdQ apphed tor the<br />
transfer of a retail licence from the corner of Berea<br />
and UmbiIo Hoads to premises at No. 121 Berea<br />
Road. One of the gl'onnds of -appeal was that the<br />
applicants, who had heM a licence fol' many years<br />
at the corner of Umbilo and Berea RoaJs, had been<br />
compelled to move from the premises b~ reason of<br />
the ground heing reb"lU'iled by the Durban Corporation<br />
tor town improvement purposes (road widening).<br />
It was also stated that there were several<br />
lief'nces held by Indians III the immedIate vicinity<br />
ot-12t. Berea Road.<br />
EUROPEANISING BEREA ROAD<br />
The Licensing Officer sahl 20 years ago DereR<br />
Road all the way up WRS occupied by IndIan shopkeepal'E\f<br />
bnt the number had been reduced to five.<br />
and this was now a European street. Referring to<br />
Councillor Smith's remarks ou canvassing. Colonel<br />
Molyneux. said he had been approached by several<br />
people about this licence. The pm'chaser of the<br />
pI'operty hall seen him and ,told him what Ii good<br />
fellow the Indian was. Yet when he (the Ucensing<br />
Officer) suggested that the purchaser shcmlJ have<br />
the Inllian in hiD own buildmg he was indignant.<br />
Colonel Molyneux addell that he was Willing to<br />
grant· the applicant a licence in an Indian area.<br />
Councillor Smith, who said he was in a pecnli.\r<br />
position, movt'd that instead of' considering tlie<br />
appeal in committee. in accordance with the usual<br />
practice. the Council proceed to consider the matter<br />
in publi"c.<br />
Councillor Eaton seconded the motion.<br />
On being put to the vote. however. the motion<br />
waa defeated and the Council accordingly retired.<br />
On reassembling. CounciUol' Hult moved that the<br />
Licensing Officer's appeal be upheld, COllncillor<br />
Kt'mp being his seconder.<br />
INFLICTINCI A HARDSHIP<br />
In the course of a long speech Bb...unst this proposition<br />
CounCillor SmiUl Baill he wanted the matter<br />
discUS8l'd ill public becauso he wantetl to give the<br />
I'easons which prompt~d him t. vote for or against<br />
a lict'nee. and thought other Councillors should do<br />
the same. He was in the peculIar position that if<br />
htl votel! !J.g'd.iulit a lioeuce be W'dS tolJ he did wrong.<br />
and if be yoted for he was still wrong. He did not<br />
want people to thmk he was looking for th.e votes<br />
of the big Mahomedan merchants; he did not want<br />
their votes. But in tIllS case he did think the<br />
Council would be inflicting a hardship on the dpplicant,<br />
who had had to move because pdrt of the<br />
building he occupied WdS wanted for street widening.<br />
This type of Inrlian was not a men.l.ce,<br />
Mrs. Siedle abo thought the CouuCII would be<br />
inflicting a hardship ou the applicant. •<br />
"I do not consider that the Licensing Offiler's<br />
decisions are always just alld fail'," said CounCillor<br />
Mrs. Kllight in support of her frank admission that<br />
she often voted against the Licensing Officer's decisions.<br />
The MaYOI': "Mrs. Knight. you IUust wlthdrdw<br />
that remark."<br />
Mrs: Knight contmued to speak to the appeal. and<br />
the Mayor again asked "Do you Withdraw, Mrs.<br />
KnighV"<br />
"Well, I don't know." she replied.<br />
Agai~ pre!ised by the Mayor and by cries of<br />
"WithdraW." Mrs. Knight agreed to withdraw. but<br />
she added that she dId not think the deCISIOn under<br />
diSCUSSIOn was just and fall' and she would vote<br />
against it.<br />
•<br />
No INJUSTICE<br />
CounCIllor Johnstone did not see where the injlJstice<br />
came in. They must recoglllse the facts, he<br />
said, and -the thinking Indians were recognismg<br />
that Indian licences could not be gl'anted III European<br />
areas. The Licensmg Officer had already<br />
expressed his wllhngness to give the applicant a<br />
licence in an Indian area.<br />
Councillor Kemp. with the remark "onr fnends<br />
protest too much." said he was voting on principle.<br />
Only recently an Indian purchase
I<br />
they WE're l\Ot rpprebented m the Con neil.<br />
He had !'loped, ho continued, tJl
2pril loth, 1925 ______ 1 N_V_I A_N-:O~P-IN_IO-N-----------=.:97:...-.<br />
"$ Reforms. which is just out. consists of'Majority anli<br />
Minority Rt'ports. The former inclulips the vipw!><br />
of Sir A.lexander Muddiman. !:iiI' Mahomed Shafi,<br />
Sir Arthur Froom. Sir H. Mancrielf Smith and the<br />
Maharaj of Rurdwan, who SL'lte that thfl Act hlUl not<br />
hPfln In operation wng enough to affortl mattrial for<br />
l .,Idgment and that there is no /lround for the con-<br />
• J c1:wlion that it is a (aHUI'e. The Minorit)' Repm't<br />
~ive8 the view8 of Sir Tej Bahadur Sapro, *1' Sivatlamy<br />
Aiyer, Dr, Paranjpye and Mr. ,JlOn\lh who<br />
contest the viE'WS of the majority.<br />
The British Exchequer W88 rei'pllnsihlt' for tilt'<br />
cost of employing InlUan troops in the field ollt;udt'<br />
Ind.\a and ht'r fr9ntiers to the t'xteut to which it<br />
exceeded the normal pt'ace charge for Indian Contingents.<br />
This rule applied also to the Contingents of<br />
the Indian States. It ~ been recently announced<br />
that the Maharajahs of several In lian States had<br />
decided to waive their claims on the Bdtlflh Exchequer.<br />
The remission from the State of Hyderabad<br />
alone amounts to over .t:l,OOO,OOO. "<br />
Mr. G. n. Shaw, Sir AI,thur Pinero and otht'1"<br />
dramatists are demanding fees from literary societies<br />
which announce readings of ijleil' plays. They say<br />
they will suffer pecuniarly if the practice contmne!!<br />
to spread, all it is spreaoing, and that author!! i!holl.ld<br />
not be penalised in order that the masses may be<br />
educated!<br />
}:I. H. THE AGA KHAN IN ZANZIBAR<br />
During his recent visit to Zanzibar in rE'ply to an<br />
address presented to him by the National ASSOCIation<br />
under the presidf'ntship of the Sultan of Zanzibar<br />
lL H. the Aga Khan is reported to have made<br />
the following reply :-<br />
Your Highness, Your Excellency and my Countrymen,-I<br />
tl).ank Y9JJ very much. for yout: ldud. wPJ<br />
,come and biautiful address.<br />
, 71 ~J.aIll..iDdeed grateful to yon for so many referenct's<br />
,- l.Jwhat humble services I have been aHe to render<br />
to my countrymen and Islam. r have dOlle nothing<br />
beyond my duty. It was so kind of the Council<br />
of State in India and other Governments to recomwend<br />
me for the Noble Prize for peace for my<br />
efforts to have the Treaty of Sevres altered for the<br />
establishment of peace in the Near East.<br />
You have touched uP9n so many burning prohlems<br />
in these province~ and for Indians overseas in<br />
general. I Deel} hardly say that this question has<br />
been burning in the hearts of all Indians in India<br />
and elsewhere. We are at present swimming<br />
through a stream. we are fighting a strong b,lttle,<br />
we have neither crossed the stream, nor llave we<br />
lost or won the battle. Bnt we should not leave<br />
the ~trnggle either tnrol1gh over confidence or<br />
pessimism. It is not advisable for me to commit<br />
myself to any opinion as it is probable that a new<br />
committee would soon start its worj{ on the question.<br />
Only during the last fortnight a very influential<br />
deputation waited on His Excellency the<br />
Viceroy headed by Sir DiDshaw Petit. IUs H1ghness<br />
the l\faharaj,\ of Bikaner s11pported the cause<br />
on behalf of all the ruling princes in India. You<br />
will therefore see that all in India even the Government<br />
of India have been watching this pro Diem<br />
with very great sympathy and care and you need<br />
not lose hopes.<br />
The questlOn of 1'anganyika. gentlemer.. ill on a<br />
ditrt'rent basis. It is a mandated territory. and India<br />
is a member of the League of Nations. The pOilitiun<br />
of Indians there cannot be in any \V,\y atrt'cted so<br />
long as India is in the League. Ol.ly the otht'r day<br />
my frit'nd and colleague, Mr. Ranga Chariar moved<br />
a resolution in the Assembly stating either the disabilities<br />
to Indians there should be removed, (lr<br />
I~dl" Ih9~\tcl ,'lit (1\\\ (I( tJ\., l~Il\10, Thill Is, alii it<br />
'h~I1}ll brl '<br />
The question of German debts has been more a<br />
It'gal question than a political one and solution of<br />
lelall quehhons as you know takes longer time than<br />
that of pohtlCal ones. The advice of the best lawyers<br />
in London h.ls bE'E'n taken and the excellent secretaryof<br />
your Indians Ovt'I"Beafl ASSOCIation In London<br />
watcht's the de~elopmt'nt WIth a very gre,lt care. I<br />
hope the question won .. l soon be satlsfactOl'Uy<br />
solved.<br />
As to your domesltc needs for a High School or- a<br />
Hospital it is rE'ally the Iluestioll for your aRsociation<br />
to take up. If locallt'aders bring 10rw,II'u d. pr.lcltcal<br />
propOSition It will Ill' snrely htlPPOI t .... l by all.<br />
As long all the leaders In ZaDzll.hlf do Dot do that,<br />
you wlll aumlt, it is very dlflicult for tho,e who do<br />
not stav in the Isl.lnd to give a leM1, howsot'ver 111-<br />
flnential they m.ly be, You can count upon<br />
their help and also help fl'om India as soon as you<br />
yourselveil 41ke the question up.<br />
The Indlans have played a very prominent part<br />
in -the development of thls country. Men lik"<br />
Stanley have mentioned the part pbyell by<br />
them in theil' books and I rejoice to see them still<br />
doing the Solme. The Hmdu-Moslem unity h! a<br />
Bettled fact here, and I am glad to seE' that in all<br />
congresses and committees Hmdu Mosleui umt.y is<br />
very stl'ong, I WIsh you success in your actIvities'<br />
and a still brighter ana pl'OSperOll"l career to yonI'<br />
AsSOCiation. Gt'utlemen, I oncE' agam th,mk yon<br />
for the hQJlour yon havE' done to me tlllS afternoon.-Zmmblll<br />
VOll'l', ,<br />
..<br />
*~.*.~~.~~~~~.~.*,<br />
... ..<br />
JIl 11<br />
~ ~~~.~.~~~ ~<br />
~ Original Correspondence .~<br />
~ ~<br />
~ The EdItor, INDIAN OPINIO", ,:<br />
DUNDEE IlINDOOS REQtrIRE HINDU<br />
BUTCHER<br />
Sir,-Whilst one must unfortunatt'ly a(tmit thE'<br />
prevalence of the eXlstmg race prejudIce between<br />
the European and the ASiatic, one however shU<br />
looks for fair and reasonable treatment from the<br />
hands of those who are cntruflteu WIth power-such<br />
a persotJ. is our local LlCensmg Officer Mr, H.lrdy<br />
who has refused a Butcher's hcence to an In,han .1\1.<br />
M. Karim.<br />
I will merely sidte the facts and leave the Dunuee<br />
Burgesses to say how tar they approve of our<br />
Licensing Officer's deciSIOn from whoRt' aeClSlOn an<br />
appeal, in these parttcular circumstances, only ht's<br />
to the Town CouncIl. '<br />
The facts are that 1\1. M. K,mm l.UlpliE'd for a<br />
Retail Bntcher's liclillce for prell!lsPs at the corner of<br />
Wilson Strert and Ladysmith Road, Dundee. -It<br />
was oppos_ed by the Dundee ChambeI' of Chambt'r<br />
of Commt'rce And two locolilmhan Butchers on the<br />
ground that it was not \\ithm the Asiatic area nor<br />
was it necessary.<br />
The applicant stated that he desirt'd to onen this<br />
Butcher shop to supply the needs of the Hindu<br />
community who were not able to buy meat from the<br />
European or Indian Butchers in town as they also<br />
Bold beef. The Indian Butchers had been domg so<br />
for the p.\St eight montlls and consequently the<br />
Hin,du community as snch were not able to purchase<br />
meat because their religion forbids the killing<br />
of cows or the eatmg of beef.<br />
The applicant had been approache,l by the Hindu<br />
community to open thIS bUiomess as they themselves<br />
had no member who because of religlOus scruples<br />
would und .. rt.lke the killmg of animals. The apphcant<br />
put in a petltion signeu by li7 leading Hindus<br />
supporting the application. A number of Hindus<br />
also gave ('vldenc!.'. The applicant stated his WIllingne811<br />
to confine h1msdxtQ supplying, tbe Hmdu<br />
J\~ed .. amletatl}
INDIAN OPINION April loth, 1925<br />
reasonable necessity of the IIinull cOllllllllnit,y and<br />
tha granting of such lice!lce would affect the preser.t<br />
Emopean or Indian Butchers as the IIl11du trade<br />
was not enjoyed by them. '1'hl:l eVidence showell<br />
that the Hmdus out.numbered the :r.LthoulPuans<br />
here and there are about l!iO in town.<br />
The objectors did not appeal' nor lijd they hi in(!<br />
any evidence at all to snpport thdl objections. It<br />
was pointed out to th~ Li(;eJlS111~ Oalcel' that every<br />
reason eXisted to Jushfy hiS gl'antl11g tlus licence<br />
and an authority was pOUlted out to him Ilnupr<br />
whICh he could at the renewal of tIm! licence refuse<br />
sqme If thy applwani failed to confine himself to the<br />
Hindu trakle. )<br />
The Licensing Officer Tefused the apphcation<br />
stating that it was neither desirable nor necessary.<br />
This means that the whole of the Hindu community<br />
except those who are prepared to break caste prejudICes,<br />
are precluded from obtaimng mutton m this<br />
Borough and the Hmdu commumty are very milch<br />
disturbed in nunC\. owmg to this deClsioll- and still<br />
beheve that the appeal It IS mtendclI to bring brfol'G<br />
the- Town Council WIll be ::.ympathetlcally con<br />
SIdered.<br />
I feel cerlain that it IS not the WIsh or cleHire of<br />
the burgesses of this town that the Hmdu commttn<br />
Ity should be made to suffer and be depl'lved o{<br />
their necessities, more so when the grantmg of this<br />
applicatIOn will not iu any way affect -the Europeun<br />
community and WIll not be ~n cornpetillOll WIth any<br />
other trade, The objectors are not Sl1pplYlllg thIS<br />
necessIty and will not permit thl'ough the Llcensmg<br />
Officer that thIS necessIty be sllpplieu. Is tIllS iau ...<br />
or reasonable? Can one beheve t.hat III thl'se enlightened<br />
days men could so fat, forget thl'ir own<br />
manhood and commit thes(! wrongs It is s,\{d that<br />
"God IS great and God is goorl," "ask III My name<br />
and ye shall recillve" and lfi HIS name we Will<br />
approach the Town COllncillors believmg that they<br />
WIll do what IS right.<br />
Yours faithfully.<br />
N. K. N AIDOO.<br />
Secretary, Dundee Hindu Temple and<br />
RepresentatIve of the Hindu commll'mty.<br />
ls~April1925.<br />
et
No. 16-VoI. XXIII. Friday, April 17th, 1925.<br />
I .<br />
RegIStered at the G. p.O. as a Newspapar<br />
Pales Foo .... ",s<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
'7'~<br />
treJJ OMM1+:NTING on General Smuts' recent speech Dealing with the ASIatic question Or.lUge Grove<br />
~ in the Union nouse of Assembly on the and District (Transvaal) branch of the SAP<br />
Colour Bar Bill Mr. Gandhi writes as follows moved - . . .<br />
in his l'OUfllj [mlla.-<br />
"That iLlioit1cs be repatriated."<br />
General Smuts has cOITcdJy given tho substance ___<br />
of my conversation with him. My point was that<br />
wyi1st administrative difference thel'o was bouml to<br />
On the motion being formally secomled a delegate<br />
be so~g as human natul·e~remained what It was<br />
moved, as an amendment .-<br />
anil so long as the1·0 was a contlict between European<br />
culture and tho Indian, a legal recognition of<br />
"That, in the oplllion of this Congress the Asiatic<br />
-pI'oblem is one of the gl'eatest problems' fd.cing this<br />
the difference in the shape of the introduction of<br />
country, and as a Dleans of solution suggests that a<br />
the Rd.r sinister in the laws of. the country was an<br />
National Convention be summoned to discuss thiS<br />
intolerable burden, 'fho settlement of I!Jl! chiefly<br />
matter on a non-party basis, and make its reCODlmendation..s."<br />
'fhe motion wat! withdrawn in favouI'<br />
conslste4 in the vindication of the Indian pObition.<br />
With General Smuts' opposition we may hopt:' that<br />
of the amendment, which became the l:lUbtltd.ntive<br />
motion.<br />
the Bill will now be dropped. But let us not<br />
deceive ourselves. 'rhe Natal Disfranchising Bill<br />
recently passed is an extension of the 'Bar Sinister.'<br />
General Smutl!' opposition therefore means only a<br />
protest against the bar beIng introduced even in the<br />
matter of employment, not against the bar altogether.<br />
However I tender my congratulations to General<br />
Smuts on his plain speech at the risk of still further<br />
weakening his pohtical position in his country. We<br />
may not be satisfied till the South African Statute<br />
Book is purged of all legal inequality as between<br />
Whites I1nd Asiatics or better still as between White<br />
und coloured people.<br />
The second annual Oongress of the Union of the<br />
Junior South African Party was held at Durban last<br />
we'ok delegates, many of whom were ladit:'s. being<br />
present from all parts of the Union, The following<br />
message was sent to the Congress by General Smuts,<br />
the leader of the S. A. P.:- •<br />
"Wish your Congtess every success. ·Regret Parliamentary<br />
duties prevent me from being present.<br />
Remember you are the men and women of tolllQrrOW,<br />
and the duty of citIz(,Dship is a great<br />
responsibllity which even the young mt:'ll must<br />
share. -South Africa has gl'eat problems before it.<br />
Let the indll:lp.l1lt!able spirit which was ~howll at the<br />
National COllvention which sat at DUl ban in 1~108<br />
pI·evail."<br />
In el..horting the white people in this country not<br />
to quarrel, Sir Chas. Smith said, here they were<br />
overwhelmed with a non·European population and<br />
latcl' they would have the invasion of the yellow<br />
men,<br />
In the course of his rt:'marks His Worship the<br />
Mayor (Councillor T. M, Wadley) said: Youth was<br />
the time when they were going to get the best results<br />
out of a. man or woman. During the neit 50<br />
years the proportion of the population at the present<br />
rate of incrt:'ase would be something like 25.000,000<br />
coloured. people and. :3,500,000 whites, and this \V,IS<br />
tlomethillg for tht:'1ll \0 face in the futmf'. lIe hoped<br />
that their inUueuce would be felt in the proper<br />
Quarter.<br />
An Ermelo delegate said it was a cruel thing fur<br />
white pt:'ople to have to travel in the same trams as<br />
ASlatics,<br />
A Greyville delt:'gate said he thought this matter<br />
had never been tackled by all the Parties sitting<br />
together, because there was too much personal influence<br />
at play. The big business houses in West<br />
S,tx:eet would go smash to-morrow if the Asiatic<br />
trader were prevented from trading, and the speaker<br />
proceeded to comment upon people who would<br />
sacrifice their country for filthy lucre, and had too<br />
deeply ingrained a love of personal gain to trouble<br />
about their own countrymen. A lengthy debate<br />
followed, and the motion was eventually adopted<br />
A-NON-PARTY INQUIRY<br />
HE recently held Junior South African Party<br />
1f Congress has passed a resolution in con.<br />
nection with the Asiatic question, suggest_<br />
ing the holding of a National Convention tl) dis<br />
CUbS the matter on a non-party basis. A resolu<br />
tion .. that. ASIatics be repatriateu" was wit 1..<br />
drawn ill I,woul" of the above 'fhe latter 1esol u.<br />
lion was, of course, totally impracticable and the<br />
adoption of the former one proves that the Con_<br />
gress was guided by saner COllnsel. But thoug h<br />
the resolution is comparatively a milder one it<br />
cannot by any means be credited with bt:'ing<br />
inspired by broad minded ness. The meaning of<br />
the resolution is that all parties should combine<br />
together and make Common cause in finding ways<br />
and meaus whereby to get rid of what is called the<br />
':Asiatic Menace." But even in Courts of Justice<br />
the accml"d are given a fair chance of defending<br />
~heir case'before sentence is passed and it is onlt<br />
Just and fair to gh·e the Indian -community a<br />
f,lir and full oppr)rlullity to defend their case<br />
before a final sentence is passed on titem by th<br />
rulers of tLis country. Hence it is that the Indian<br />
community have asked for the holding of an
100 iNDIAN (jPINtON April 17th, 1925<br />
inquiry i.nto t4e ARiatic cplestion on a non-party<br />
basis with replesentatirJIl on it of the Indian Government<br />
and Indian leaders of India and of South<br />
Africa. This request does not, however, seNd to<br />
have leceived any consideration from the Government,<br />
and if it has, no definite reply has yet been<br />
given.<br />
The Indian Government seems to ,be stIll<br />
negotiating with the Union Government on the<br />
Asiatw question and wbile the Asiatw edifice in<br />
this country 1S ablaze and no steps whatsoever<br />
have been taken even to prevent the fire from<br />
spreading any fqrther no results of the negotIations<br />
have ht been known t \<br />
We feel that we would have at ,leac;t had one<br />
satisfaction from the Smuts Government had it<br />
beell in existence to-day, and that is of a definite<br />
reply as to its pohcy. It is not yet too late to hold<br />
such an inquiry on the lines suggested ana it will<br />
redound to the cro(ilt of the preseut Government<br />
itt t4at It was sincere in giving a fail' chance to<br />
the Indian community to defend their case.<br />
WHITE LABOUR POLICY<br />
A MOST DANGEROUS WEAPON<br />
D;a. ABDURAHMAN CONDEMNS COLOUR .BAR BILL<br />
Capetown, Apnll:3 (Reute.)-Delivering his pre<br />
Bldential address to the Conference of the AfrICan<br />
Peoples' Orgamsation, opened this evening in Capetown,<br />
Dr. Abdnrahman, M.P.C., saHl that simultaneously<br />
with the accession to power of the Pact<br />
Government, the great Native and Coloured probTem<br />
hacl gaineu considerable prominence, and the at<br />
-tempts that were bemg made to solv(' it werE' such<br />
that the whole of the non-European popnlatlOn were<br />
gravely appt'ehensive of their future.<br />
The SPll'lt in whlCh- the non-European problem<br />
was being dIscussed was producmg further dIscord<br />
between the EuroPElan- and non-Enropeal! sections,<br />
and boded III for the future peace and happiness of<br />
the country,<br />
He said the Act of Union .had faIled to bring the<br />
fusIOn of the two white races, and had made a wide<br />
gap between black anu whIte, whICh was due ma1l11y<br />
to the perniCIOUS prinCIples of the North having<br />
insiduously Cl'ept 111to the Cape. which was the<br />
home of the colol}l'ed people.<br />
Dr. Abuurahman dll'ccted the attention of the<br />
Conference to the ll1l1ustrIaI warfare which was<br />
bell1g waged against non-Europeans, even III the.<br />
Cape ProvIllce. A most c1,mgerous weapon against<br />
them was the passionate propd.ganda for a wlllte<br />
labour policy-a p01icy which had Its bIrth In the<br />
Transvaal, and was now bemg open ely belauded<br />
even III Capetown. Apparently the leaders of the<br />
"civilIsed labour" movement thougnt that coloured<br />
men had advanced far enough, anu that the Natives<br />
must be prevE'ntf'd from rlsmg at all. The Industrialavenues<br />
along which they could attain their -ambitions<br />
were being closed. The Minimum Wage Bill<br />
was deSIgned- solely to give effect to Clvilised labour<br />
and WQuid press hardly on coloured farm labourers,<br />
who were excluded, and would contlllue to be exploited<br />
for a miserable pittance.<br />
The Colour Bar BIll would sound the death-knell<br />
of Natives and Asiatics in the Union.<br />
lIe had no hesltation in saymg that if it became<br />
law the industrial colour b.1r would be the most<br />
inirlmtous and immoral piece of legislation whlch<br />
----------------_.-<br />
had ever defaced and besmirched the Statute Book<br />
of any civilised country since the abohtIOn of slavery.<br />
The coloured man, although omitted from the Bill,<br />
was already effectively kept out of every trade on<br />
the Rand by white trade uniomst.'l, and was not<br />
lIkely to be given certificates of competency to drive<br />
an engine when white trade unionists prevente(l<br />
him from doirg skilled work in the bUlldmg trades.<br />
- A demand was now, in fact, being made to solve the<br />
vast industrial problem of South Africa on a narrow<br />
racial basis.<br />
Dr. Abdltrahman held that a CIvIlised l.tbour<br />
voliey was impracticable, because the dt'wlopment<br />
of the country would be impossible without Colomed<br />
and Native labour. The work of the country<br />
could not be carried on bY,the handful of Europeans<br />
now here, most of whom were non-workers.<br />
Dr. Abdurahman maintained that the dominant<br />
position of the European population was not to be<br />
maintained by any spasmodic attempt to oust Native<br />
and Coloured labourers from work hitherto done by<br />
them. The sullen acceptance of such unjust treatment<br />
might last for a little while, but deep resentment<br />
would mevitably be engendered, and then woe<br />
bet~!/e those who had been authors of the injustice.<br />
The tiJUe had come, he maintained, when the<br />
making of laws should no longer be in the hands of<br />
one class or section, or one race, and he u,rged the<br />
Orgamsation boldly and fearleflsly at once to assert<br />
its just claims to full political rightl'.<br />
NEW COLOURED ORGANISATION<br />
CABINET MINISTERS ON PACT POLICY<br />
Oapetown, April 14 (Reuter).-The Afrikander<br />
National Bond of Coloured People, which is a new<br />
Coloured organisation, formed in opposition to the<br />
African People's OrganisatIon, opened in Capetown<br />
to-night. There was a crowded attenUancl', and<br />
amongst those on the platform were three Oahinet<br />
Ministers, Dr. Malan, Mr. Tielman Roos, and Mr.<br />
C. W. Malan, all of whom delivered speecheR. ., ~<br />
Dr. Malan adversely criticifled Dr. Abclurahman'lI<br />
address on the previous evening to the Afric.tu<br />
People's Organisation. The Mlllister held that it ill<br />
the policy -of the Government that Coloured people<br />
must develop alongSIde EuropeanS on the EUropean<br />
standard, -and were not to be claased with Natives.<br />
He instanced the Colour Bar Bill all an attempt to<br />
carry
.....<br />
~I'<br />
April J7th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION t()I<br />
------------~------------------.----------------------------<br />
THE LOWLANDS OF KENYA<br />
hecome imperialistic imaders of Africa and are<br />
Mr. C. F. Andrf'ws Writes as foJ1ows in Young<br />
cL'lSseu as such in the Sdme cdlegory with the Europeans.<br />
Though feeling the iron yoke of subjectIOn<br />
Inclil! ddtelJ 1t~"rch J2 :-<br />
themselves. they are rrolly to bring others into subjectIOn.<br />
They do not any longer stancl out on the<br />
At~er ~ f('cen~ vifut to pelhi, I feel it to he of the<br />
uiff1o!lt 11llport,lnce to JluJ,ke plain. b(')'onu any<br />
side of the oppressed. hut th~mselveB take the side<br />
Hhadow of Tllislln4en1tawJlng, how ('Inphdtically J<br />
"houl.1 objoct to anyone ht'mg sent ont from India<br />
otfi'\ldlly to investigate an nrea in the Lowlantls of<br />
Kpnya in whIch larue fl'ee j..'I'3nts of crown I.mds<br />
~jjhoultl be uiven to Jl}tlil1ns for co~qnh~at\On pnrposes.<br />
In the tirtlt placl'. to accept even wntatively snch<br />
an offer, or even to examine It with a view to<br />
~rprovdl. is to 8tl~}tifr the whole InlHan position.<br />
1< or the InUIUIl t/aiJ)l is not to Jl)celve free h'I"41}ts of<br />
CrQW11 lan'Ji! anywpere, but to recover the I!,gal<br />
rigMs ot SIl~e ~nt~ purchaHe ot laut) in the Highlamls<br />
whic4 have been illegally taken away after a Rolemn<br />
prDJn~e ha4 been m3q.e that they Ehould remain int,act.<br />
Indians are asklOg for aJ1 elementary pght of<br />
cltjr.en.,hip. 'l'h('y I,Ire asking to be pldced on a<br />
b.,Lllli! of e'luabty w~th othe1' citi~ens in the eyes of<br />
the laW. It therefore can ea.sUy be 8een thd.t i~ Inulans<br />
evep exatlline t}:le propoRdI tbat they tlhould be<br />
g)yen ,grants 111 the Lowlands, it will ve certainlY<br />
\U)IJel's,too!}. ,",8 tJ,eir final ~bandonmeJlt of legal<br />
I rights elH('where, J rIo not thin)! that it can be<br />
made too plain, tha.t t4e very qrt of sending an Indian<br />
otficial to examine an area in the Lowlands Will<br />
be interpret~d as a givjng np of IndJ;;l.1).. legal rights<br />
in the Highlands altogether.<br />
In the second place, for Inqial).B to use the Brithlh<br />
military force to take possession of a large area in<br />
the J,owlands. thl1s d('pl'iving the natives of still<br />
futher territory, it} addition to the 12,000 squar~<br />
llllleB of fel'llie BOil that has been taken from them<br />
in the Highlands by the whites, is to commit all<br />
injustice. It means that IOflia, for the first time,<br />
by It definite Rct, is prepared to enter upon ,a pohey<br />
of imperial 'grilb,' whel'ever an opportunity occurs.<br />
That the Afri~n natIves. as far i,lS they have any<br />
voke o,r power, will P108t strongly object to any<br />
such llUlky of ·grab.' on the part of India, goes without<br />
saying. Ii they 4tre VOICeless -and powerless,<br />
then the wrong done to them will De all the greater.<br />
It mnst be rememb('red that Kenya is not an empty<br />
oounu'Y, WitJl 'no native inhabitants. It is a large<br />
territory. with only a very amall traction of gooli<br />
weU·waterQd agricultural Jand. If it had not been<br />
to.- the a..A.1.lour exploita.tion tJmt has been going on.<br />
with its inevltablo dmnoralisation, the natIve population<br />
wonld alroady have spr(IUd over the oultivable<br />
soil and occupied it. Even to-dar. in SPite of the<br />
exploitatIOn that has hlken place. the native 'reserves'<br />
are already provin2 too s,mall. It wOl,lld be an act of<br />
gfdve injus,t.ice, therefore. ~f Indhms were to seize.<br />
under the cover of Jkitish anll Indian bilyonets, a<br />
great slice of the territory stIll remaining open tor<br />
native occupation.<br />
In the tblrd place, tJle Indian claim to free immigratic.n<br />
into Kenya and UI-!'ant!a is based entirely on<br />
the ground that Indians al'e helping and not hiudering<br />
the native advancement. There is no other<br />
clauu than this. What is put forward is thiS, that<br />
for two thou:il.\n~l yellrlil the tratle between E.lst<br />
Atric!\ ant~ India h.\s gOlh> on. hlt11l\ns h;ne come<br />
Creely to Bj1st Africa and }liwe beeu hospitably ro<br />
~£'h-ed because they came in p('ace and not for war;<br />
hecause the tr
102 INDIAN OPINION April 17th, 1925<br />
Indians m this country For instance, an IndIan'<br />
can now, for the first tmle in the history of South<br />
-Africa, pl'ep3re for and obtam either his B.A, or<br />
B.Sc., and any other University degree~ without<br />
eIther incurring t~e expense ot going to England or<br />
India for the necessary 'education. ThIS college lS<br />
turthermore an offiClal centre of the College of Pre-<br />
ceptors, l .. on(lon, whose cel'tificares and (liplomas are<br />
known anu j'ecogmsed- throughout the world. '1'he,<br />
College Hostel, whIch was open'ed about SIX weeks<br />
ago, has not already justified Its eXIstence, but its<br />
iuture Sl1ccess IS absolutel V' assured This 18 all the<br />
'more \remarkable when I add that 1 h~vc not<br />
appealed to anyone lndlan or any sectlqn of tfie<br />
Indian community for funds, and I have no intemon<br />
ot doing so tor thel pt'esent, although IndIa hel'seH<br />
has assured me of her ready and full support, s'honld<br />
I at'any tIme conslder It necessary.<br />
The IndIan people WIll reJOICe wIth me, when I<br />
state that arrangements ha VEl -been made for a fm ther<br />
15 bOYS to be receIved at the College at the 1st of<br />
• May.<br />
In concluslOn, I appeal to evel'Y sectIOn 01 thee<br />
'IndIan community to support and take full ltdvantage<br />
of this unique opportumty t-OI' raising the<br />
standard of educatIOn of tile lndmns, and thus lemove<br />
forever one of the prmcipal pomts of contention<br />
so often put forward Ly ,the Enropeans aE a<br />
weapon to be used for the furtherance of their own<br />
desires and for the furthel' su ppreSSIOll of the Indian<br />
commumty of the Umon of South A.frica. As the<br />
, result of repeated and 1l1creasmg requests from all<br />
parts of South Afr'ica, arrangements are bemg made<br />
for me to visit all the bIg centres and CIties through<br />
-out the Union Immeduttely my "pl'esent -public work<br />
\\7111 enable me to do so, for the purpose of addressing<br />
mass meetIngs on mattels ot VItal interest to the<br />
Indians as a whole, Includmg our educational work<br />
and, tl;te creation of a Scont organisatIOn throug'hout<br />
tlie UnIon as already exi-sts In the-Transvaal turough<br />
my efforts.' Most ImpOI:tant of aU, matters affecting<br />
the -future of the Indians as an Integl'al part of the<br />
people of Sotlth Africa. -<br />
INDIAN STUDEN'1'S IN A1IERICA<br />
DEPORTED FOR EARNING WAGES<br />
Lala Babu Ram, Clel'k, Ferozepore Cantonment<br />
writes to TIM} 1'nbune (Lahore) -<br />
My y;ounger brothel' proceeued to AmerIca In<br />
19,22 with the sole object of gettmg higher educatIOn<br />
there. He tooli: Us. 2,000 from home, out of which<br />
Rs. 1,000 was required to dt'tray hiS .)ot1l·ney expenses,-and<br />
when he landed at .\'luel·lcd he had<br />
Rs. 1,000, with hIm He Joined the Mechanical'<br />
Engmeering class, ,the course of winch extends for'<br />
4 ye3fs~ In ordm' to do someth~ng by W
April 17th, 19%5 INDIAN UPINION 103<br />
---.-----------<br />
News in Brief<br />
DUI ing the recent l'ar}idlLental y l)y·",leltilJn<br />
('nmpnign at Klerksllorp Mr. .hthnr Barlo~ a<br />
~dtior alist member in the course of a speech Sdid<br />
tIle (;overnment was dmwing up a Bill whkh<br />
woulu enable the Municipalities to uillCriwlhdte In<br />
gr\ntir g licences against Asiatics. There was on<br />
the slotks a ~mprehenf,ive Bill dealing with the<br />
l\'holE' AHiatic qnefition.<br />
cil~ l~~~1ti ~tlie -q~i:ql~"'l~l<br />
-0-<br />
~~1~~l<br />
Gpneral regul"tlons fromed uUfIE'r the Health<br />
f'ommittt'N! Ordinance for Bellair anu Hillary<br />
and Rydf'nham Public Health Art>aIl have been publilihE'd<br />
in the Kalal Prol"Jnflal Gazette datt>d April ~.<br />
~ll. "bl~lltlal "<br />
-0-<br />
On the evening of the birthday of Mr. Dunning<br />
~\t'la dl. ~i9.n~ ~·Q{Y (!y'U ~'utl.<br />
thej'rincipal of the Union Collt-ge at Johannesburg ~~r\L-'3dqiitliit ,{letlrtl itlll ~pnrtl ~l.{l
!'~~ It"!lt ,,'l~h~ ~h. ~W'( llfl: "ll~~<br />
c'~h. ),.JH lIih. ltlll: l}tIl~ 31lr. '~-~lR"P tlp~ \}I.lln: liR~blln: l~~lplPlr. !:::mb )"\OI~.~ R~1';'1'e !~~lt lk\.ola.h:) t'l!!~ filI1. lYl~-,Il~l1~~ l"'lPl~ }\.oI~~ .~ \}'lbbWs> ~h. ~ltl~ ~ { ~ l):13lnlbh 1]1~'t<br />
~ In: I!! ~t' 11~ Thlh.l).~l6- '1!1'\ lln:U~ ~lfl: ll11Eh:<br />
{. ~ 'l'!",ie ~b tR~ 3~ 1f.7ltl: k;1~ tp\All (kltll-' t '- \.1.1'.... ' {lit lhlo ~~G1~ )It'll'1'l l::1}t~ ~1H: I!!I~h _ t1}P ]kl;:lti ite: J"'~ lhe~ l}-lbbl"'la J..Jli~k tL1lh.<br />
1r/"~ t Pl.;ll.r. l~ {~1 ~Isl~t 'it!: lJ..~ij:.~ l~!ilJ'lfl: 1'6§)1».: JJlh. 1\n: 'l~';t ~l"b )lt~ It1'rt Ie<br />
- ----- : "e!JeC lP~ tp.n~ l)hJl~ ~l(1d~t lhllt~hlY~ lm.lla:<br />
; 0 lfiPlh .• nt~ tp~ lj.lt 'l::)h~ rlr.e)' JklbtJlb~hI: Ihk lHl~<br />
~ 'i"h r~~ l::'~l),'~ llt1-t11 )S.~ hl( 'Pchlb ltl1 ;~lp a~ '}>J..nl}-.j? 1),,)]%, \.o!f:.Jlh. k§)'~ ~hl}fiD<br />
~ H.l[ln1J6'tr; It r""lfi:.l)~ t~1}1t ~ 1I"~~~~ - ---<br />
~J.. ~'r!lR~ l~ tUnlb ~~.H: ThI~h.'hI: lJ:I~ l~<br />
'l!:'il 1~"",J.n: lltl};p'l-M l:-le[ ',fjel~ll'\~ Ilfl: tlfl:<br />
l1-!'b12 Jje!~ 1~1h. )'lc7 1~~h. lPtU,:' 1~1l-.j~ 1l1!: .I!!p.~ .<br />
pll-J;llie H.~ po l?11·, Ie lj~ t'be~ l~ltl1=il~) 1}lI'l}l:,? @e'G<br />
~hl-!}n 1ft P"',1);; lli?: tl):P kl~A 1\.o1}:.h1j:) pl~l11.~ F~<br />
~In: 0 ~1b~ 1(1(t. hl~PJIa: 4~ le1~~ IhI: I!! 1=iln ~'<br />
~tJIRUf~ ~lltl( Pit 1)'-~~!{ l~" :t~?l l~lf'it 1~1"~<br />
@lUtk' ~'}> (~U-)t ~l}a ?nil lhJJlt. It~ ~"_1(? tt:<br />
"Ie.' 1~~'ft. 1-,ler 1~1!! 'ft. ~l1ll'i: lP/.!) 1P1:I):' 1101fc-·k?l .~<br />
hlil~ l):.\Jl~ h!kJ:ll.np ''''lY''''~ U'1~~ l~li'm~~ lel~<br />
lltl~m lhllt~ t l.Eh: '{ ~':.lfe,h' ,..n"l}tt~ ~Ml+><br />
hlht J.o e~ l\!!!B~llf . :''h:~lP\.olh ~loA: 1:§~h Itl~ l\Jlllf<br />
em: le.lls lP~ ~lR l};hthl: ~'l!b 1}tlhIR~1!! eli?: 1Cl~<br />
lhlI'tTh'~}-pl~ j}>ll'i1j I-ti: tfI~ lh~ ,.~ 'f\.lk l}Un<br />
-Hlla'it 1::11.1: ~ ~Jlt ~ 'GO lP'\Jl~,H:c ~lj: (lh1: Plt<br />
't1P'!! ~.~l) lJ.r, ~1-tl:: ~h ~l-n.~ t'hel( llplr.1:: ~h<br />
~lM~ ~ tP]I},lJ)lc tylP'!! !11.l~~ ''''''P'~ lPG1 '~""'~§)<br />
l!"j!h ~lt~ ).~1H: )ppl~ "'"\~lj ~h It1=ill1:~ 1\.ot;W,lt t<br />
tla- J.~ ~'Ifl: }Pl~?~ ltl11~~ 1101;t~ t'lt -!l>lh'l.o 1~<br />
rt!: 0 ~llt Jl'.elf \Jl'itelj ~k.l)-tl1~\.oj l-t?k.1: ~elo~<br />
'0 C1P~~ k11::, "~Ij 15J£l, llfl: P-l}n ~~~ H~h<br />
1J)!~lt' 1j}->~ >>-101.f~ 1?' ~eH;hlhl: -Pk lit 1=ilWl\.o lell!!<br />
-l}l'}l '~lfilc,AII \.0 1~ t}P0 tlPl~ t~hlHl:; f8hllfl:<br />
~h. ~~1~~ f3~h ~MJ 11ft: \J11h. l11~hJ l\.o~i'k-'l:<br />
17H"~ ~'}l.{ ~t}(\1c n~11n: @h.llfl: 'P'}l 1 @tllt1\<br />
~hl/ft: Thlh. ,!!!:w.1t Unl}'l. Unh Th\J.~lh. ~lfl: ~l0 Ihle l?;tl--!lt ,111t'i::.JR 1(t!, ~tRl1c lk)l~k lPelt llfll ell.<br />
f\1~ ,'I> Rl"~J11t Th\)J~b hl}'l.l~t-lfl: f8h.1J.n: lit fto~ lJ.n: ~ ~ 'P~ ~"!:,~ ~lh... ~tJ P\p:Plb ~~1'6 elPl~ 1! lH:<br />
'P?l ~~lfiql.rl Mtt ~~,?1R: H~ jPhllfl: ~ltlmlJ~ \}'Ih~ ~IJ,dle '11. blt~ l\t~ ~ ~h1~ ~~~ ~h§l p=.'ft. If? ]k<br />
l}1~ rIP}> lHhlHlt!: tl~lY)p 1~1~ lj.>la-~ lJ.n: ?~~l~lh, PhU't ~?lt.(: 17,!:plJ) th5) 1
~ ndiatt .C®pittiIlU<br />
No. 17-VoJ. XXIII. Friday, April 24th, 1925.<br />
Registered al the G. P.O •••• Ne .. ,., ..<br />
PRICR 1'00.'''11(.8<br />
l\\.KT R. G. H. Hulett is introducing a draft Ordi-<br />
11 V II nance in the present session of the Provincial<br />
Council to amend Ordmanc,e No. 4<br />
of 1923 which is .. The Rural Dealers' Lioensing<br />
I.aw Amendment Ordinance." The text of the<br />
Draft Ordinance is reproduced elsewhere in this<br />
issue from the Xu!al Provmcial Gazetk. It seeks to<br />
limit the duration of the Licensing Boards to one_<br />
year only instead of three, and to restrict their rights<br />
iu connection with the granting of new li'l:~nses.<br />
According to section 3 of the above Draft Ordinance,<br />
if after the hearing of an application for a new license<br />
the lloard m'e of opinion that the licence ouglit to be<br />
granted they shall recommend accordingly to the Adminilltr provi£les that the Administrator<br />
shall have a discretion to decide that the<br />
licence shall be granted or that it be not granted.<br />
Section 7, further, provides that the decision of the<br />
Administrator _ will be in the same position as a<br />
decision of the Board and all provisions of the<br />
Ordinance in regard to appeal and otherwise shall<br />
apply in respect thereof as if they were decisions of<br />
the Board, which means, that from the decision of<br />
the Administrator there will be the right of appeal to<br />
a Rural Licensing Board of Appeal provided for in<br />
Ordinance No.4 of 1923-a body to be appointed<br />
by the Administrator for the whole Province' or~ for<br />
any specific part of the Province.<br />
The Draft Ordinance "To amend the Public Health<br />
Committees Ordinance 1923" which was passed recently<br />
by the Natal Provincial Council has been<br />
assented to by the Governor-General-in-Council and<br />
has beel' promulgated in the l'rol'ilwlal Ga.zetk<br />
of the 16th instant.<br />
At a special meeting of the Durban Town Council<br />
held. on Monday the 20th instant, Councillor<br />
Smith's motion .. that for the purpose of municipal<br />
elections in future the Borough of Durban be treate4<br />
as one ward " was defeated after a lengthy discussion<br />
by nine voWs to seven. The Mme mover moved<br />
auother motion .. that in order to promote public<br />
interestin the civic work of the Borough all Council<br />
meetings be in future held in the evenio/l" which<br />
was carried by eight votes to seven.<br />
At a meeting of the Transvaal British Indian<br />
Association held on Saturday the 11th mstant Mr.<br />
E. S. Asvat waS elected chairman and Mes...,rs. A. A.<br />
1\Iirza and D. 1\1. Nursoo joint hone secretaries. Mr.<br />
Cassim Adam was chosen as chairman by the<br />
majority by means of nominati,ons sent in, but<br />
owing to his departure shortly to Europe he expressed<br />
his inabihty to accept the position at present,<br />
and thanked the community for its appreciation.<br />
Mr. I. I. Hazaree, the retiring hoh. secretary, submittRd<br />
his report and declared that owing to Dlany<br />
reru;ons he could nol possibly take over the secretarial<br />
position again. III.' l'(\(}uestetl thl.' community<br />
not to re-elect him as sllch, but he promised to assist<br />
the (''ODlUlUDity to Lb.e. best of his ability in all<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
'71" •<br />
matters affecting his countrymen. The meeting was<br />
adjourned sins dl~ for the election of other officers.<br />
At the annnal conference of the Industrial and<br />
Commercial Workers' Union of Africa (natives) held<br />
recently at Johannesburg the pass law question led<br />
to a lengthy discussion, and the following resolution<br />
was adopted :-<br />
.. This conferen,\e is of opinion that all P8SJles, no<br />
matter in what shape or form, are nothing more or<br />
less than an institution of the present- capitalistic<br />
system of government to reduce the African wOl'kers<br />
to a state of abject servility so as to facilitate<br />
their uttermost explQitation. '<br />
.. Furthermore, the conference condemns ill toto the<br />
proposals of the Joint Councils of Europeans and<br />
Natives intended for submission to the Prime Minister,<br />
and, in the opinion of this conference, the only<br />
alternative is the abolition of the pass system, and<br />
shonld the Government insist on perpetuating the<br />
system this organisation resolves to embark on a<br />
passive resistance movement to the measure, with<br />
the ca-operatIon of other organised bodies of the<br />
African peoplE:s, particularly the African National<br />
Congress. "<br />
At the fourteenth annual conference of the African<br />
Native National Congress held in Johannesburg<br />
last week and attended by delegates from all over<br />
the Union, Mr. S. M. Magatho (acting president),<br />
in the course of his speech, explained that the fact<br />
of holding a conference at aU was due to the nativeil<br />
being unable to understand why they should be<br />
treated with injustice. "We are not extremists, not<br />
exaggerators," he con tinned, "bu~ we are agitators<br />
who will agitate until we get our just rights."<br />
They, he went on to say, were born in Africa, and<br />
they -would die in Africa. It was for the rights or<br />
the native people. and the freedom of their conntry<br />
that they would fight. Whatever money the natives<br />
earned was spent in this country, but the Indians<br />
whQ were given the right to trade here and were<br />
treated a thousand-fold better than the nnfortunate<br />
aboriginals, carried their money ont of the country.<br />
Referring to the enforcement of. the ordinance<br />
whereby native women wonld be compelled to<br />
carry night. passes, he said that if, as was represented,<br />
that would prove a cure for immorality, the regulation<br />
should be m6de applicable to aU womenfolk-European.<br />
Indian, and Native.<br />
A native boycott of His Royal Highness the<br />
Prince of Wales when he visits South Africa Wc18<br />
advisetl by Mr. Sidney Bunting recently, when, as<br />
reported by the Communist paper, the I"ternalwnal<br />
of which he is the Editor, he addressed a meeting<br />
of 1,500 natives convened by the Industrial and<br />
Commercial Workers' Union. Referring to the<br />
enemy of the native people Mr. Buntill$ is reported<br />
to have said :-" Yom: enemy, too, is not merely:<br />
local -South African. natives ofwn appeal to Britain<br />
as a protector, when. as a matter of fact, British imperi.ilism.<br />
wh~ re.presentatiy~ is abouL to tour.
106 INDIAN OPINION<br />
South Africa, is largely responsible for 'your exploitation.<br />
You will be only asking for your bosses led them to ,do so. •<br />
or with any sinetl'ltv. SOUle ulteJ'ior motive" have<br />
to remr.m your booses for ever if you are so foolIsh<br />
as to turn out m the Prlllce's honour; instead of . 'fhose tllat are not IMrticipatlllg are doing b(ls it has been<br />
freely expressed among all classes of the community. remedied to some extent, But there are othel<br />
In the course of a speech at Madras on the present much more important, reasons for them not t(:<br />
situation Mr. Gandhi is reported to have saId :- participate, and in tbis connecthn, it IS mr)st<br />
" You will not expect me to.speak on what may necessary that the attitude of the Iudi III COIllm;lDity<br />
should not be taken amiss by Bis noyal<br />
be termed the l~\>litical side of the question. I am<br />
uninterested in it. Whllst It is aIJ. integral part of<br />
the Congress organisation, I have purposely refrainE}d<br />
from mterfering with it. I have no aptitude We wish to assure Bis Royal Ilighness tha~ we<br />
Il1ghnesfl or by the members of the 1 uling class<br />
for it, and I have no faith in,it. "<br />
British Indians in South Africa, are not lacklllg i~<br />
The opening ceremony of the 1\1. K. Gandhi our loyalty to the 'fbrone nor 'in our respect for<br />
Senthamil School generously built by the Bai Jerbai Bis Royal Highness's person. The peaceful and<br />
Rustomjee :£,rust in May Street, Durban, WIll be law-abiding manner in which Indians have lived<br />
performed by Mr. S. B. Pather on Sunday the 26th in tp(S country, quietly suffering the ever-increasing<br />
political dIsabilities and assi~ted the BI itish<br />
instant at 9 a.m. All are cordially invited by the<br />
han. Secretary to attend.<br />
Empi.re whenever it was in difficulty -is ample<br />
proof of their unswerving loyalty. But the reward<br />
WELOOME-TO HIS ROYAL BIGHNESS Iorthat is that with- the granting of Self-Govern-<br />
11J) EFORE our next lssue is out it lS hoped ment tQ_ tills country HIS Majesty's British Indian<br />
1..1.2) that the soil of South Africa will have subjects have been sold to the rulers of this<br />
been sanctified by the gracious footsteps country. Such (lcts have been committed by the<br />
of Ilis Royal Highness the Pliuce of Wales. We, Union Government in the name of Bis Majesty<br />
therefore, take ,this opportunity of extending to the King that would stain the fail' name of fhe<br />
His Royal Highness a very hearty welcome on Britis~ ~mpi~e. British. fair-play and justice do<br />
behalf oj the Indian community of South AfrlCa. not .exIst In t~l,) co~ntry In so fa.r as the dal ker<br />
We hope that his tour will be a very interesting __ subjects of HIS Majesty are concellled. We need<br />
and an enjoyable one and that when he goas back not enumerate here the various disabilities under<br />
it will bring to him happy recollections of Sunny which \ve are suffering. In a word, we are not.<br />
South Africa. • treated in this country as citizens of the British<br />
Now si Ice His Royal Highness is on an official Empire. We are treated as helots and that is the<br />
tour and siuca he hdli1 come to see with his own status we are offered and special laws for the<br />
eyes th} extent of tha great Blltish Empire and purpose have already been enacted in the name of<br />
the cOldLiJn of the British subj~cts rtsilent ill His Majesty the King and furthermore are under<br />
~h~t Empire of whom he is to be the future King, prep~ratio~. We have no voicl} to oppose these<br />
It 13 only nght thclt he should go with a kUJW- acts III thIS country We were, however, hopeful<br />
le,dge of the true state of affairs It is th3 poJtey th~t. as ~oyal citizens ot the British Empire the<br />
of Governments, especially of countries where there Bfltlsh G
, IJCtln un occ I"io 1 for jny to U'i if it were to J edress<br />
-,' I;\'eu a few of our vital griI.lV,lllCC., and IJring us<br />
peac) and happiness Lilt Lluder the existmg state<br />
(Jf alT,1ll8 it is Illl occasion fol' grief and sorrow.<br />
DHAFT ORDINANCE<br />
• .. To AMEND ORDINANCE No.4 OF' 1!'23 "<br />
. , The above Draft Orumance proposed to be mtroduced<br />
mto the Natal Profincidl Council during the<br />
preKent Session, has been publitlhed tor general information<br />
in the PrOI'MIIIIJ.1 Gazeltp ot the Hjth<br />
instant. The Draft readi! as follows:~<br />
Be it enacted by the 'Pr1>vmcial CounCil of the<br />
Province of Natal, as follows :-<br />
1. The wordli occurrmg in SectIOn set'en, Sub·<br />
lIectlOn 1, t/tree yertTB, are hereby deleted, and "one<br />
year" substItutoo, and the term of office of members<br />
of the exitlting Boards l:!hall expire at the end of<br />
I~'25.<br />
2. All references in Ordinance No.4, lUtZ, to the,<br />
powers of Licensing Boards and appeals are to be<br />
constrned subject to the provisions of tIllS Ordmance.<br />
3. LicenSing Boards shall not have power to grant<br />
an applicatIOn for a ne\) licence. Lut if at the hearing<br />
of an apphcatlOn for a new' hcenc. the BoaI d<br />
are of the opinion that the licence ought to be granted<br />
with Ot' without any such suspension as is prOVided,<br />
they 8h,t11 recommend accordmgly to the Administrator.<br />
A minute shall be >»»»»>J>>»»n~ ~o<br />
~ OUR- LONDON LETTER i<br />
~ [ FROM OUR OWN C03RESPONDEST ] ~<br />
~ 21~th March 192."). ' ~<br />
o ::::~E(E«'~~~ »»»»~~ ~~o<br />
The death of I,ord Curwn for the moment over<br />
ShldoW8 everythmg III London. Yesterday a service,<br />
solemn "lliI it was ImpreSSIve, wa
108 INDIAN OPINION April 24th, 1925<br />
The appeal 'of Robinson against the Midland Bank<br />
otherwise known as the "A" case, has been dismissed.<br />
Many will be happy to hear the last of this case. It<br />
attracted at the trial ullparalleled attention and was<br />
far from edifying. /' '<br />
Signs of early spring are everywhere-daffodils<br />
and crocuses-and promises of a new life for a<br />
short space to the vegetation of/ the country-such<br />
as t.hrive but during the season.<br />
To sit on the httl€\ piel'S Oil the banks of the<br />
Thames and watch the smaller ocean and rivel'<br />
bO!l.t/:l is a pleasure to those who come from' seaport<br />
tqwns.<br />
\ )<br />
A NEW SPIRIT IN" INDIA<br />
Under the above caption the Natal Mercury writes<br />
the following leading note :-<br />
The proffering, wIth ,becoming hesitation, of ,an<br />
olive branch to Lord Birkenhead by Mr. -nas IS the<br />
outcome of ,ecent important developments in the<br />
political sitJlation in IndIa. Th_e failure of the<br />
n&n-co-operation movement and the extiactiou of<br />
Mr. Gandhi have brought more and more mto prominence<br />
the fundamental differences which separate<br />
Hindu from Moslem. ReligIOus bigotry and intolerance<br />
have led to fresh- outbreaks of vIolence"<br />
and such incidents as the mnrder of Mr. Day and<br />
the Bengal polIcemen, from which-many promment<br />
Swarajists emerged with reputations anything but<br />
enhanced, have been tempnrarily forgotten in the<br />
light of what oCClll"red at' Kohat and- In the Punjab.<br />
These sanguinary encounters between Hindus and<br />
Moslems show that despIte the undoubted success<br />
(from its own pomt of view) which Swaraj has<br />
achieved, it still has in it!'! paths obstacles which are<br />
formidable if not msuperable. The temporary consolidation<br />
of -all shades of Indian political thought<br />
against Lord Reagipg's "_ll11J...c.h discussed B~ngal<br />
Ordinance has ceased to be a reality, and although<br />
Mr. Das critiCIsed that measure in hilil reply to Lord<br />
Birkenhead, he alilo tacitly admilted the existence of<br />
seditIOn and unrest by inviting the Secretary .of<br />
State for India to make a searching mquiry into the<br />
revolut~onary movement. Mrs. Besant, a woman of<br />
cOl).rage and also of' advanced views, has admitted<br />
the neceSSIty of the Ordinance, even though she<br />
considers it to be regrettj:lble. It IS probable, therefore,<br />
that with the dIstinct turn in the tide which: is<br />
causing the Swarajfsts to trim thelr sails and take<br />
stock of, theIr position, the visit of Lord Reading to<br />
Engla,nd will, be of the greatest jmportance. Whether<br />
or not he will return to India IS a matter of<br />
surmise. Lord Birke_nhead is reported to be not<br />
altogether averse to filling the poSitIOn of Viceroy<br />
himself; at any- -rate he has frequently dropped -<br />
hints-alD-ce'taking office that he intends, should circumstauces'll.llow<br />
it, to visit India and gam firsthand<br />
informa'tiQn in that couutry. But when Lord<br />
Heading arrives in LondoI! there wIll be t"fo "tirst-'<br />
~lass tntellects"-we use the term in all sincerity<br />
-concentrated upon the problem of IndIa's future.<br />
Poles apart in political thonght, these two emment<br />
lawyers are,two of the clearest thinkers and most<br />
far,sighted men of their day. Perhaps it is the<br />
knowledge that they can be relIed upon to see<br />
through bluff and arrogance, and whilst pursuing<br />
the paths of progress resolutely to oppose anything<br />
in the nature of coerCIOn, that has put Mr. D.as mto<br />
a more reasol1ab,le frame of mind. There iii a sectIOn<br />
of public opinion to-day which is prone to regard<br />
IndIa ail a Dominion already well-nigh lost to the<br />
British Empire. If Lord Birkenheafl and Lord<br />
Reading can provc this pessimism to be unfounded<br />
they will have rendered an imperIal serVICe whose<br />
value it would be impOSSIble to @ver-es¥unate.<br />
INDIANS IN SOUTH AFRICA<br />
Mr. C. F. Andrews writes in YOIlII.7 Intllft dated<br />
March 12;-<br />
Things are clearly gOing from bad to worfle in<br />
South,Africa and there is no telling where they WIll<br />
eueI. In two separate measures, wjlich have been<br />
put forward by the Governm!'nt in pnwer, 'A"naticR'<br />
are discriminated against and classed with 'natIves'<br />
as contrasted WIth the 'coloured' peopl!'. It IS<br />
somewhat difficult for those who have never been !.><br />
South Africa to understand cleal-Iy "'hat such dltl- I.<br />
crimination means. What has to be realIsed is, th,lt<br />
the great bulk of the 'native' population is entirely<br />
uneducated. On the other hand, the 'coloured'<br />
people (i.e. those who have a slight mix:tnre of European<br />
blood in their veins) a/'e on the whole a<br />
'fairly literate community.' It appears that the<br />
Ipolicy of the new Government und!'r Gcnel"al Hertzog<br />
is to depress still further the 'ASIatic' and to<br />
raise the status of the 'colourf.'d' peopl!'.<br />
A further measure, is scbednle!l, ~herehy S011th<br />
African citizenshIp will be confineQ to the pure<br />
white ,population, which has been horn and bred in<br />
S'outh Africa. An Englishman coming out straight<br />
from England will not have hiB citizenship ion South<br />
Africa as an inhl'rent right on account of his EnghRh<br />
birth and origin. He will have to take ont naturalisabon<br />
papers in South Africa. Leading new~papets<br />
111 Sonth .i}frica suggest that a compact hajJ been<br />
made between the Labour Party (whicb relies chiefly<br />
on the BritIsh labour vote) and the NatIOnalIst Partv<br />
(which relies chiefly on the Dutch vot!') on the<br />
understandmg that the Nationalist will support a<br />
strong anti-Asiatic labour policy providell that the<br />
la.bourites will mpport a strong 'burgher' policy.<br />
In addItion to thIS, we have the fur~her n£'wil that<br />
a new segregation measure, of even more drastic<br />
character than the late 'Class Arens BIll,' is already<br />
being prepared. It will-be remembered that the<br />
MunICIpal Franchise Act for Natal, depriving Indians<br />
in future of Municipal Franchise, has now<br />
been passed and sanctioned by the Governor-General.<br />
If a racial Segregation Act is also passed, it will be<br />
difficult to see what will still remain of the ·'vested<br />
rights,' WhICh were to be strictly observe!} under<br />
the Smuts·GandhI Agreement of 1!l1-t.<br />
In the Transvaal, a picketting system and a boy.<br />
cott of all Indian trade has agan1 been started. This<br />
time,-in the present inflamed atmosphere,-it has<br />
met with snme measure of succetls. The repatJ'iation<br />
ot Indians in Natal by means of Government 'r'e<br />
Cl"uiters' is shll praceeding. I have personally<br />
cross-examined those in Madras who have returned.<br />
Tlaey have told me, that t3.ey have been unable to<br />
find employment in IndIa. They are therefore now<br />
to be fonnd, after great misery and privation, enter.<br />
ing the emIgration depot for Malaya, asking to be<br />
sent out of India to the rubber plantations of the<br />
Federated Malay States. Truly the whole situation<br />
of Indians in South Africa has reached the lowest<br />
pomt where even stout hearts may find it difficult to<br />
look forward to the future with hope. There is one<br />
redeemmg feature, however, which continually<br />
meets us in every fresh information that reaches us<br />
in India. The Hindu-Muslim problem out there<br />
does not exist. In face of common suffering Indians<br />
are one people,-one in heart and soul as well as one<br />
in Indian birth. -<br />
Mr_ Gandhi adds the following foot,.note on the<br />
above:- ,<br />
III view of the foregoing gloomy study of the<br />
sitllatio'· in South Africa, the remarks of General<br />
Smuts Q1Iot!'tllllst w!'ek in tIl4'so columns deriv(> an<br />
alldNI intel·est. The plcketting rpferreci w by Mr.<br />
Andrews is nothing but veiled coercion. If with all<br />
the elaborate precautions it did not remain peaceful
April 24th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 109<br />
everywhere in Im1itl in 1921, how less likely is it to<br />
be peaceful in South Africa, IInly those who know<br />
its white population can realise.<br />
INDIA IN THM UIPEHIAL PARLIAMENT<br />
~he Earl ot BirkEll'lhead, Secretary of si.lte for<br />
/ (lndia, introduced the Government of India (Civil<br />
Services) Bill, the object of which ill to amend the<br />
provisions of the Government of India Act by<br />
exempting PI'oposals for expenditure on certain.<br />
salaries, pensions, and other payment8 from sub·<br />
mil4sjoq to Indian LegislatureK, and to enab~/'t ro4's<br />
made under the Act relating to the Civil ServIces of<br />
the Crown in India to be dispensed with or reLued<br />
in certain cases,<br />
The Bill WaN read a first time.<br />
The Earl of llirkenhead moved a resolution declaring<br />
that it was desirable to appoint a Standing<br />
Joint Committee of both Houses of Parliament on q<br />
Indian Affairs. lIe said that such a Committee had<br />
been establit;hed each Se8llion since 1921. It was<br />
apparent to everyone that great advantages might<br />
be derived f['om having in existence a body representath:e<br />
of t/oth 1I0uscs, and including much Indian<br />
administrative 'experience. There were a considerable<br />
nUIT.ber of members of Parliam('nt especial.<br />
ly qualified to deal with Inditln subjects, who would<br />
be in touch with the developments from month' to<br />
month of Illdicln affairs, and available to advise on<br />
questions al'ising from time to time as to the amenu·<br />
ment of rules fI"olmeu uuder the Government of<br />
India Act. He was anxious not to make any general<br />
statement on Indian afftlirs, either to the Committee<br />
or to the Honse itself, until he ha.d had the advaqtage<br />
of a pcrsonal discussion with the Viceroy after<br />
hill arriV'cll ill this country at the eud of next montb.<br />
He hopod the 'House would agree in uue course to<br />
refer to the Joint Committee the Bill to amend the<br />
Government of India Act. which he had just introduced,<br />
and which had been framed to enable effect<br />
to be given to certain recommendations in the<br />
report of the Royal Commission on the SuperIOr<br />
Civil Services in India, presided over by Lord Lee<br />
of Fareham.<br />
The motion was agreed to.<br />
THE CAPITALISTS' -PRAYER<br />
We cull the following interesting prayer of the<br />
C..Ipitcllists from the ltl{lIf'naflOnal.-<br />
Lord from whom all blessings flow,<br />
Let the Glory all be thine.<br />
Keep us on top, and the other class below,<br />
And let all the Swag be mine.<br />
,0 Lord, ere I go out to biz,<br />
I leave with you my soul.<br />
Grant that I may draw the profits,<br />
And the other chaps the Dole.<br />
Mansions thou hast prepared for me,<br />
I thank thee for my whack.<br />
Grant, Lord, the other chap may bt'.<br />
Contented in his shack.<br />
I pray for the masses, 0 Lord, the lost sheep,<br />
And I hope that you never will find thetn.<br />
At the Labour Ex.changes they are drawing<br />
the Dole,<br />
Gracious Lord. till I'm ready to grind them.<br />
Thy curse 0 I~ord, on Bolsheviks,<br />
Those monsters (01f pollution,<br />
And guide me, 0 my Saviour, guide,<br />
Away from Revolution.<br />
My War Bonds, Lord, are 5 per cent.,<br />
I pray thee, make it ten, ,<br />
Mt needs Ilte small, God grant them alIi<br />
r r~r "'''"1' Imkl", "'1"~lJ;<br />
'q,l~ Rq~~l ~tJta -q~l=ql~-tlfl<br />
~lll\~l<br />
~ll. "al~lltlEU "<br />
~)t'la cU. ~IS~~ ~.fJ(~ ~eu (3"4.\~.<br />
~«rU-~ct'~~I~ 'tlctl-tl )tIlt EPQ"'l ~.fi«l~ "1.<br />
l!! 1l~1~ !P~ It ~ i R1~ lh!M f&h ~R lJ.}n tp,h Ie. i<br />
tHe l1ilM khl~ ~1I'fn. !~ ~\.o k~ I~ p~ 1:]116-<br />
t Jnf} ~?~ ~ 1~"'~ JPb ltlO~ ch~ '~1)1.~ ltlkP<br />
1~ !kn~ l~ elf!: ~ 1.{~.)1: fclh ~~ 1!1l!'.'C .~j}fI<br />
H,k~IHe \ylk~l-th Unh lt~ 'lJl~ lltll!lltJ:D1-th Th~<br />
t 1-Jl16- !ltl~~L'il lJel- t1): ~ ~?l!: .~ n~th Rl't felh 1~<br />
'YIP~~L~ t:1)1: '~1AJUa ltl~ 1J.1t~~ ~ lhJ.. pm'<br />
R~ ~ ~ ~ ftc 1}~ l~IRJHe !107t tl7l-n tlr,H'h~f}<br />
tla: 1~~lt l1i'bl~ ~lc 1Yla- l1.He ~ lk31t 1l-1~)1:<br />
l!"" ~ ~c \Jllt !}nJ:D):' ~ l::ll:.}nlc \FIll? l::~ t~ 0<br />
Wt'te l1H W~h ~""'c 16\jtln '(,J'" ,.,£~_ 't \.lJ,I~<br />
~lhr:}$ ft.Ih "It '~ fIC~!lt ffi4h lc,lt,'h.<br />
~~~~EiC(C(C'E(~~~~~~~1<br />
! 'UH Io-R nt.rt~ /(~ 'I)) '~1"'1i .<br />
g . If "'~~1}\.1l! "'~l...)ft"<br />
.~~~~~~~~r~~~~O<br />
'~ ~lla: !ltll:>H fcl'lh.~ {ft.ffi.l~ ~ tlt!! ~):'11« l1tlbflqll:' .Attn))<br />
131l(~ ll-ol~l'te \I!= 1~1~~ H~c7~:CIYUt'l~ 55 0 rt1l:>lfclJ.ll<br />
k'fe lltk~r; UtPl~ Unh .~ lP'~ !klhnlkl: lU.~<br />
tcr~~~\}t~~ 11-'I}:.n'~ 1~'S:~ lt~ 1~h..1He ~l- t<br />
'l:.nl~ l~lh~n!!: lhlt~!\ 1}tlt]h tlC1: lPef{, Thllt.'~ltl<br />
tC?«U~1}ti~ It,J.Dh ~ olt'l!! ~ ~Fi~ i~h.llt!! 'e1bcn<br />
~ hll't Pk 'e~ 't}l~ ~ \ft1h lnJlltll~ liieltt ~l~lloen<br />
ll'.~ ~:H It.~~ lii1r- lYlS"e"" c~A£k \'! ltlhel('P~lhk<br />
lU.~ U-lt'~ 1c.L~~~hli? !It l1 ffi.)1: 1l-1):.nllllloch lbl><br />
t~ 't,J:;ell ~lteh ~l!: ~~ffi t~ 0 lPllR! llt.llo~le<br />
lYIHl:> ~lc IltR:J#1J1lt! I .. E'C-")'I, (;: l-l3it \J-'ltl~_<br />
1c1.~"~lllJ.:> tl~ 1~~ '~\fl ~l}I.l~ ~l't~ b.o~ ~~<br />
l~J.:>J- \ylnln. ~ .~ cl~U ~ln.l~ 'tclrl. lt~"l>lll~<br />
~~ l~l~c' '~l~~ ll1\t'n l\t~ ~ 'ibiS( '~.ll>c'~it<br />
~l'Ah'~ IPlt~ ~n·-h.lh1S '~lloH\ H"~Ih.f! lkl~littlle<br />
l~l",,\I)l\!! ~1l> 1::" R.l>JJ'l~ f~~;"'~~ 1~ \cU~'~Rl~<br />
.)~~lJ ~H I, lj - 1, :.)., H:"J.>1J1~ l~ ~H'I, l>lb<br />
-Ute3 ~tl!! 't$lh: lY~~~ll( ~l(J!l\ l>l?l .. '(~~ "Ut<br />
-~~-<br />
.~tp, _ !!:ljhf\ llo~<br />
lli~H:P ~ \p~ ~~ 33k !k\'>\IIR! ~tn \pl~ chg)<br />
~l~~ 13TO. tit!! ~\fl ~Rl't \,)~1)1: ~He !1tliil~~:B !!:<br />
l1tl,1:C ~ l}"'ffi'l:~ lh\H) 7'Il Rl't cmh ~lt. ,He "ShJ : c\}&.lc lla: ~th. lP'Ht! eng) lU~llt lJ.>~ tl-a: ij)~<br />
PI~ P:c1lr,(3 ll-a: • l;lllt !1tlloH~ ~!R !lth,l:)ltl I ~~ lYl1tll!;lJ>~ 1)l~ ij)U~~ lY~171p lf~ -~31~1~<br />
l~llUt ~~\}l~lr; CPIJ.n. 1~7~ tit Fi~ ltc \. ~ll-a: !klb~\A£ ~'il t&eli<br />
ct\A£ !1t}ll~ IPlc).;. tc~l) "'ffie~" '{ W~ lfi~ \p~ , ~lcl~ 'P'il rtlt-- l}!:k. \-1:, k ~ P1cn§) Ilon ~llt~~<br />
P~sH ~Sll? Hd'l \ltl~ 1c'lC1: tHe lJ.:>th. m'k; Thlh. 't}$~ tkl: WhIt!:<br />
....--_ .) lPlc~ tl-lli3 llil};'l~ mc~ ltl~ lkHi3 ~!)1: l~follk.<br />
.~ l~tt ~~K c13lt.lt>J.D ll-pH3 {. ~ hll:ltcw lt~ .~ l;11n: !ltll:.?R<br />
~lJP 13bl~ l! !lt7t~ .y':J!~ l"'Ut n °lP t~ 0 -~lIe lh1cl>lli~<br />
~'h. ~~~'li ~PJ!l\ ~1?1~ h5i P?>h i? ~ ~J"'JJI~ • ~P}nlo ll>~ ;l.LU~R \J?'f.llt!! ell. 'lIt rf\~ ll->n\}l
t12 INDIAN OPINION May 1st, 1925<br />
\<br />
nise their oWQ kith and kin there tan be no<br />
complaint. while real lIrogreBII will be made<br />
tmvat'ds the solution of a difficult problem ...<br />
The editor'g sermOn on seH-help really amazes<br />
Uli! Seli-help in its real sense is indeed a virtue<br />
but in the present instance, we think, the term is<br />
wi'ongl), ut'ed, It is not self-help bl.t~ I'lelfishness.<br />
Europeans are tluJir own mal:ltel'B, and for that<br />
matter every individual is his own mast~r and is<br />
entitled to do what his consoience dictp,te8. By<br />
buying goods from the indian the Em'Opean is bi<br />
no mean~ rendering any great service to the Indian.<br />
H~ buys because he finds the goods cheaper<br />
and so does service to himself by saving hi'<br />
money f(\1' his growing childre~. If, on the other<br />
hand, he chooses 110t to buy from the Indian, the<br />
indian is surl:'ly not going to dtag hini in his store<br />
~mi compel him to buy fl'OD;l him. 1£ the Indian<br />
finds that the prospect$ are no~ favourable he will,<br />
all. his ow~ Ilccord, leave ttDd find some other<br />
occllpatioll. This is tlie natural Murse and each<br />
individual should bit allowed unhinder~d to follow<br />
the natlwo.l oourse. But to boycott the Indian and<br />
to shut every avenue of occupation that too Indian<br />
might possibly enter and then ta.lk 01 self-help icJ<br />
the height of hypoCJ;isy. If the anti-Asiatic propagandists<br />
and the Editor o£ the Rand Daily<br />
MaiL think they ,1.1:e thus doing sel'vi~ to their<br />
own "kith and klD," and to the British EIIlPil'e. we<br />
would venture to suggest that they are grel\tly<br />
wista.ken. They are zuisleading the poo~'er class<br />
of peopb by fo:rcibly directing them to the pat1,l o£<br />
ext~'~vagancel'"nd, thus bringi!lR aboHt their eady<br />
ruination<br />
"Kith and Kin !" Are not Briti&h I"di
May 1st, 1925<br />
JNDJAN OPINION<br />
then presented with beautiful boqueta and ~Ir.<br />
Makan tbe Contractor was prescntc.>.u on behalf of<br />
the Trust With a .mall cheque in appreciation of his<br />
5plendhl work.<br />
The proccooingil were rendered interesting with<br />
nahonal songil sweetly Bung at intervals by the<br />
acbool children.<br />
Prizea were then diatribute(1 to the children imd<br />
thll very deUgh" I fJnction terminated with a vote<br />
t of Uumks to the chair at 12 p.m.<br />
BLOEMFONTEIN NATIVES<br />
How 'tHE WHITE MAN EXACTS OBEDIENCE<br />
To HIS ADMINISTRA1'ION<br />
1'116 I'pportil of the shooting expedition that took<br />
place at the Bloemfontein N~tive Location on last<br />
week's Sunday and l\Iooday make painful reading.<br />
Whilst reading it one cannot belp but rpcall the<br />
Dulhoek tl'"tlgedy in which about three hundred innocent<br />
and armless Natives were shot down in cold<br />
blood, The whole trouble at Bloemfontein, according<br />
to repOI'ts, arOSe as a result of an attempt by a<br />
European constable accompanied by a Native p>Jice<br />
body to arrest llome women who were drinking or<br />
brewing kafir beer in a hut in the location. The<br />
women appal'cntly called together a crowd who<br />
attacked the ~on8table. with the result that both he<br />
and the pollce boys had to turn and run. A 'report<br />
was made- to the police hE'adquartel'8, where the incident<br />
walt regarded in a serious bght, and ~ strong<br />
detachment of about twenty police was immediately<br />
dispatched to the s.cene of the trouble, By thia<br />
time 3n angry crowd of Natives had gathered, and<br />
when the police arrived they were met with<br />
showeJ's of stones, while sticks were brandished in<br />
a threatening way. The position began to look<br />
u,mgerous. anel the officer in charge of the police<br />
ordered his men to fire a volley over the heads of<br />
the mob. The climax was'reached when a rifle<br />
bullet mortally wounded one Nathe.<br />
By this time the Deputy Commissioner of Police.<br />
Colonel Beer, and the Supermtendent of the Location,<br />
Mr, Cooper, had arrived UPOIl the scene, and<br />
endeavoured to get the Natives to disperse to prevent<br />
'further bloodshf'd. The .Na.tive leaders said<br />
that they would get their people to disperse provided<br />
the police first retired. This was not agreed<br />
to. Fortunately a welcome interlude occurred when<br />
a heavy shower of rain. followed by Ii hailstorm,<br />
, helped tG disperse the (:rowd. Afterward" the<br />
Native. decided that they would not attewpt ferree.<br />
but that they would ca.ll a strike of aU the Natives<br />
in the Lm,"II.tion to express their indignation of the<br />
killing of one of their number by the police. '<br />
The news had by this time filtered through thl<br />
the town, and alarmist reports went round. with the<br />
reiliuli that n(unerol'lS I
II4 INDIAN OPINION May 1st, 1925<br />
Natives chose, delibel'ately and after 2-1 hours in<br />
which to consider the pOSItion, to oppose tile represeptatives<br />
of the white man's Govel'UQl,ent. ThIll<br />
choice they made with their eyes open. The consequences<br />
were inevitable, It will always be so<br />
whenever men, white or black, ,attempt to thwart<br />
the authority of the Government. 'l'he Native mnst<br />
learn that he cannot take such action as he did<br />
yesterday' without the ,conseqnences falling heavily<br />
upon himself. -Until he does learn that he cannot<br />
act in an illegaf way, we are afraid that happelllngs<br />
like those of yesterday afternoon, regrettJ.ble amI<br />
tragic-as they are, will be bound to occur. Theil'<br />
non-recurrence lies in the hands of the Natives<br />
themselves, for, as we have said, so long Il:S the<br />
white II;lan remains in South Africa, the whIte man<br />
is going to go'yern the country, and he will have to<br />
exact obedience to his administration." \<br />
GOVERNMENT TO -HOLD AN INQUIRY<br />
Renter's Agency is informed that th~ Government<br />
have decided to appoint a, Commission to inquire<br />
into the circumstances in connection with the above<br />
trouble.<br />
o~~EE
- May 1St, 1925 INDIAN OPINION<br />
. ,<br />
1902. For 1 y~~ ~~ wbrk~~ as an official in Natal<br />
hilt in IllR3 !Ie was or~t'CI by the Bishop of<br />
Maritzhurl{ (Dr. ]\facl'orie) 3lf B\!lhop's A8~i8t.ant for<br />
Indian Mi8l!iollll in the DioceSE', becomihg, later<br />
Diocesan Superintendent of Indian Milll:lions and<br />
Canon of Maritzburg. In HIOO he was appointed J<br />
Dean of 8t. John's Kaffraria and Rector of Umtata,<br />
"einA' alll() at various times, Vicar-General of the<br />
Diocesce.<br />
In 1912 he remo\'ed to Capetown where<br />
be was for a short time Vicar and Sub-Dean of St.<br />
George's Cathedral and was appointed Rector of St.<br />
rarnabas, Capeto'wn, in l!na. In the South African<br />
"ar he served as medical officer of the Natal Indian<br />
Ambulance raised by l\faha'ma Gandhi, and re-<br />
Of iwd the Queen's Medal with. two clasps. In the<br />
Gleat War he served in France as a Captain in the<br />
H.A.:U.C. His only son, who was in the S.A.M.V"<br />
was killed in }
-llt~t!! ~(~ ~ 1ll1:RJ ThJ>lt 3;lt m'eP m~~- .?~~ ~c1',\D lP~ tft' ~tllt (.1lt 1l:/1:~ ~c l\lt~<br />
'~~e Uoml}t Slh h~~1ce 1l:::3~lt.hllA: • tl~Ulln: i ?~~l~'h R{ 1l:::~{1~ "~(} ~,k~ '@ lc,P,\Dlc F~l~<br />
h~p 1~1~ \~lt; 1:::lI>! 1:::~1~.R!1 .1clt;HY.l~" I PK~-l;'ii lRlt> l}>l~~ ~11ft: t<br />
, : { ~ l!!~ I 'P71 ~clf c~ \A» !Pcli U~1tllt t lit. 1'nh: Ilt7f.~ l~ 1:::1ft:<br />
~ lltl,l~ ~~ @ y:t$l\ tl~w, n H ~hflttr ll-'~ fc.1h. \» lbR11 ~1?11' 1)..'1:: l::la: t'lt cl~~IPlt ll-h{. 1l-1{1~<br />
~J.o 'J~7l!! 0 ~l~ H.~ J ik 1:::l';llt~lJ' ITIl: ,~t O't pUc,' ~'l"\ ~clol~ '\t ''P~ ~J)~ 1::'.lc ~n~ }:lIe\.>J.o<br />
~ .. ~. ~h ~1""lc e"ltlit..-D 'j),~k>: li~ h'(l..Rl}>l~tJ) \'>ll>.~ l'l~ ~16t'fh.t Ss~ fltt.~ "'Uc,e lIl~~ ~Mp<br />
t ~~ "hli ~.t~fti: b=lij ~iiC €~ ~.th 'IP~ l1-t.ltt~Ho('.\fl: It l;lp~'Th lh1e @ l~c \}li Rln~ l;ll€l<br />
i~hllft \JIb .al\Flh ~1(ln: ~lI>! l:::~ )1. G'\ lhl~ 1~~ ~~ lptli e3 'l!!:3 1l-IP\~ \tl~ l-Uc.c Wln. ,1-~l?M<br />
l~A l:)t~ (lit n l~ ~~1p, t1\.> Plr.J§ ~lnR Flh~ '@ lJ' lP.1'~Jl:::'WeR_ 1'tilJ~In:' t'lt.<br />
!ltlch ~h JI,tf 11'1P~'Ij?1n: l::e l t' t~ f! n\1:.1~b: 11:.liit \J'~ l::1:'1:11~ Mcllt 'Ut lJ.)~ 1\'>1~lJ6'~ lJ.)~ltIl-l!<br />
lh\cJ.) l~lcl1s ~ln.H) fC11- ln ,le ~'" ~~ 1,\:!l't>,sf{ I(l~?t 11t~~ \}',)~l~~" 1:::1n: 1}q ~"'~h. pte, 1~1*<br />
~1b:~\i' 11ft: { lP: Ih-.llce 1P"'llt lt~ ~k lh~ ,\Dlln: 1::.41:>;1 l\.>lPl~ j.)!~h.§ Ike ~~1{ .~ l~~ elRlI.<br />
:t:1ft \t!l}1.1&> thllt ,~~ ~t ~ .. ~, V,)n-~. ltl f\~ c~~ ~1ln. A,~ UsRPl~ 1~~mli\1o lla:<br />
~~ l}> 0 oo'o;t.'l. ~l~ll1>! l~"fI.,~ ll-'ltlllblJ~~ l::~~ {. ~ l}Jlk ~lt,ln. l:: i1}t~tk, '~ -h'pl~,\D fln'Jllft: ]It<br />
It"th1tJl 000'6'1£1\ ~14-1lte !ltr.1711- '0 ljIe JP):' lhhlln: 'R1'lle all. 'I§llh ~I) If.'l?~ tift: 0), ~~lh ?lJ<br />
k§l ~11'ib ~h. Th~ lHllte .at-~?~ • ~~lk l::'~e. '~ l~lltt !ltlb~ l}ti l1'lb): \'>IP~~L~<br />
lH~!?l~ lIll:lIlb: ~ ~h. !)i\ Th'" lJ??~ !Gn:..e'h.l~ l!'~"l~ \ a ~ \)lJ'¥t l\lIllln ,\::M: ,'~L~ lk\}o't~klft:<br />
(la- ~llR ~h ~~~ ~!hli tyijl-Cl:. l)> t ~"k'h.lltlr \It\y< ~llt.\J)lc,lt lnlll ~E U-lj..~I~ \}>\'>1~~l1~\}<br />
~1?1'" t))~1:. lY911,h~l!'! !\ lclk lIl~lIlR 'J>~~ ~\ilhU6'l$ lal~k (J..~lH kU~h t))ij> ~ :h1Sfla- ~1- ,\D~le 1)1~<br />
<strong>I~~~</strong>E*.~~~~~~~")::I t))tp ~ hl~ ~~ ij-J.olk !kJ.)l"!:-~ 11'1_l:~ lhp(;O t(;O\}n<br />
! ·h.~n ,..~ ~ 'I. 'Il> ~n.t~ ,\::ltc IH(;o ~lh lPll' ~ l::'ltc hl~ U:Ml\1( ]It.\}t\~ft<br />
t ." "'la:U'Th.l~ "'kel~J.R" 1:::tP~h U'll! l}>'I~lY)b U~~l-l~~ ~~ ~ll-' ~<br />
Ic:*~~~~~~~~~~<br />
'l;lf ~J.o<br />
'1~~ l~\llfl1 RIle 1,l::It.. ~h. J1.lf rl\:.~I~ l::R,lr.,~ Jl:1~ ll-bl~ HLla ~llfe~<br />
-~~l\ ~elh l::1l::Ullf~lla; feI~s .~ l::n~ lP~ -l.t~h Rli l}ljJe1l:i"ft e.lt~<br />
\} ~lcllt l}>1~.l:.'l!! ~k~ ?J~l~lh. \}'1'Ht~l:lflln: 'It p.,~ l~e ~ { @ .l~c \}li fcln6 ~!J-' lJo~ l~e t ~):lti<br />
~_lte "\ W ~~ \.> h.lh. 'ltc -l::I\!! U~! b:131 l.h~ {k{. ~ '~R~ ~JJ.t lPbl1~ li,l~ ~~ e.)..i1-I~ l€lTh lY'6'~<br />
f-1l'-~l: ~bl~ ~Iltl ~ltl'.lhl~~ !P.!D ltH It fkl: fell\. P. ~1~p' > ~ ~'Cf\ 11:>~-i l~(;o1i !!'~ lti~lke ta~p<br />
1!~ \Jh. l:,~lt. 1\.'l1 t))H~ l:::ffi: \Jllh" 11-1tl~ 1'Uf ,'t 1~~ { ~1~,\D ~k~ ;'1h.Ut~3 icllv l€l \1'lPlh 1:ln.1o e<br />
U. e 1::lI>! ~ (lJ..l:-lltc lk?"~!~l1~ pIC? liljJeli l~~l ,'P~ ~o'lfl: ]ltll:>h.llfl: jtIl)·rt iJa\U> ltIr.~ 1)l:-lf.> \}'1''I,}:)<br />
It~IM~ U?;~ !kHc~ ijJP1}(?: t l~J)lb .... ,lh,\D ~)~ I l:::?Ut~ )t~.~ 'Ut c\.>1tUtlf l~b I\'>WUlkt: ~§1~<br />
~ \<br />
C lle llt le l-: lre 111tn<br />
'.M h.\~l. ~ 1. 1(1.1]:11> 'ell:t:n- '1ClflJ-tU •. ~ ~a ~V-e'fi.<br />
T -- --.----r-----.--.. -_. -_ .. ,<br />
·~lretn~11re "lre~S1<br />
v
itegi.toor.dattheG.P.O. as a Newspaper<br />
No. 19-Vo1. XXIII. Friday, May 8th, 192 5-<br />
PRICR FOIIR"''''.<br />
, ----~----------------------~----------------------~~--------<br />
;or,,,<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
TlnJ Nalill Pl01'tI/f wl (]a£etle of Uie :mth April have been showing deep concern in the cause of<br />
II (the .Iate of thn arrival of Iht! Roy.tl IItghness their fellow·countrymen overseas. We note that the<br />
the l'rin~(l of Wales) contdins the Ordinance Inclitm &'(Vti Reformer, a well-known journal publish-<br />
"'fo amend the lJOcal Township L,~w :No. n, HPH, cd in Bombay, has commenced pnbhshing an Overin<br />
resped of the QuaitficatioJ} of Voter~" dnly soos Monthly Supplement to be devoted especially<br />
!lI!!lf'nted to Lv His Excellency the Governor-Gene.·al- to questions relating to the condItion and status of<br />
in.Council. Thil! Ordmance tltsqllahfies Inthaus m Indians in foreign lands. It is intended to publish<br />
the Townships of Natal from exercising thetr votp. this 811pplement WIth the third number of the<br />
Reformer every month. The first pubhcatioq to<br />
".<br />
While the Durban CorporatIOn has otTered a gift<br />
of t:200 to the Indian commumty on the happy<br />
occasion of the visit of HIS ROYell Highness the<br />
Prince of Wales, His Excellency the Govemor.<br />
Qenerell hels been pleased to present the Indian com<br />
Illumty with the above mentioned Ordinance in<br />
remembrance of that aUl\picions occasion. The gift<br />
of the Durban COl"pOratlOn Indtans have IJeen strong<br />
enongh to reject. But what abont the Governor<br />
General's gift which hal! been thrown upon the<br />
Indians whether they mayor may not like to accept<br />
it. Are they Ktrong enongh to rejent that" It is<br />
high time that they were.<br />
.\. ;\Jceting \V;lEhcll of tht, hurgeflf!cl'1 .•\ resolutIOn waf! then~fore<br />
pa~>lt!tl to the ('tred th,lt, III VIt'W of e\lnal status not<br />
Ldng granted Indiaus could not parht"lpate in the<br />
official ct>lebrationt!. The resolutIOn was passed by<br />
a majority. A furtht'l" re~olution, that negotiatiomJ<br />
wlth the Town Council be t:lttll continued was also<br />
pafl,.'~{'d ant! the meeting was a1ijourned till next<br />
Hundar·<br />
Oil Monti,ly,morning, having receivetl a e:lll from<br />
JIis Worship the l\I,lyor, 1\[r. V. L,twrence, the vicept·esitlent<br />
aut! )h·. S. HllstomjCf', the Hecretary. N.1tal<br />
Intlian ('ongTess w(Ont to the Town OtJiee and were<br />
tlefinitel~' infmuwd by Ills WOlship the )1a:;or that<br />
lllIliallt! will not he allowed to partiCIpate in the<br />
Chic Dinm'r in honour of H. R. J1. nor wIll they<br />
he allov. ed to enter the Town H
liS INDIAN OPINION May 8th, 1925<br />
\<br />
was ao essential tor illccess Ilt the bar. A.bQve everything<br />
else they bad to be vareful tba' thef . did flot<br />
sell their c()nsoi~no. fOl' a mesa Qf pot~e. lit wi.hed<br />
they should lulve aa t4~f<br />
Meal a lawye., like<br />
Manomohan Ghose who was a fl'lend of the poor<br />
and did so muoh for them. They should not be<br />
meroenary and had to devote themselves to the service<br />
of their oountry and htunamty at large, He<br />
had given up his prt\ctioe as he found it difficult t9<br />
secure justioe in law oourts and. he oould help the<br />
poor and the distressed better even 11 he did not<br />
practice as a lawyer.<br />
---<br />
At the Bombay Legislative Council a reply Wa,t!<br />
given in the\uegative to a question vut by Mr. K. F.<br />
Nariman whether the Government could give 'anf<br />
idea. as to how long they propose to continue tbe<br />
ban against Mr, B. G. Horniman (the able and fear-,<br />
less editor of the BrJ.mba!/ Chronicle who was devol'ted<br />
owmg to his fearl~sness in exposing the wrongs of<br />
the Goverrunent.) A further question bemg put as<br />
to whether, the Goverllment pro~Qsed to oQDtinue<br />
the ban perpetually the reply given by Sir M.<br />
H~yward was; "1 have nothing to adct to my<br />
answer."<br />
DURBAN INDIANS AND THE PRINCE'S VISIT<br />
-'f will be remembered by oQr :readers that the<br />
IT Dw:b3ol\ Indians wer~ offered a $Uln 01 £200<br />
by the Town Oouncil to celebrate the occa.sion<br />
of the visit of His Royal Highness the Prince of<br />
Wales. As 8. self-respecting section of the bur ..<br />
geS&1es Indians considered thls action· on the part<br />
of the Town Council to be insulting, and they could<br />
have, without much ado. refused the offe:r awl sat<br />
quietly. But out of loyalty to the Throne and<br />
reapect for His Royal Highne~ they felt. it was<br />
their duty to participate in the general celebrations<br />
if they eQuId do so in an honourable way and<br />
without ill any way losing theit self-respect. With<br />
this object in view they wen. out.of their way to<br />
ask, tlu'ough their Oongress, jor a deputation to<br />
be heard by His Worship the Mayor. ' The' deputation<br />
expressed their willingness to participate_ in<br />
the general celebrations l:mt pointed out that 'the<br />
S,UD;l. of £200 o!ie\'oo fOf the purpose by t~ Council<br />
was m08$. humiliating ~nd they could not accepli<br />
it. If, however, they were treated on equal terms<br />
in every respect with other sections of the burgesses<br />
they would tab part in the general<br />
celebratio'n~. From the report of the deplJtation<br />
we are able to see that His WOl:Srop the MayO!' was<br />
himself very sympa.thetic and was willing to meet<br />
the requirements of Indians in every way; but the<br />
Oouncil members were not all of the same mind.<br />
-Of courS'.} th& methods of the Town Oouncil blotrring<br />
~ few individual members whose voice is in<br />
the wilderness-notwithsta,ndiuS(, liowever, whose<br />
sympathy the. commu.nity much appr~iates-al'&<br />
w6J1.known, and Indians have suffered quite sufficient<br />
humiliations at their hands. But, it was felt<br />
that, on a most important occasion like ~his, when<br />
the Heir AppareIl;t was COn;ling to visit Hi~<br />
Majesty's sti1!joots. they wQuld be moved, if bynothing<br />
else, by their BritiSh bi.rth to give way aad.<br />
tl"e;.lt Indians With equa.lity to which they were ~ntitled.<br />
It would not only have redotUtded to their<br />
creait, but whatever their past actions. may ha"e<br />
....... been and ~~eir future are going to be, they would<br />
have for once been uble to show to the highly<br />
honour~lt anrlmost ftSpected rep~eutative of HiS'<br />
Majesty the King how truly British they were and<br />
how they belived in the British principles of freedom,<br />
justice and fair-pl.lY and how they practised<br />
those principles. 'fbi~ was, however. not to IJe.<br />
Race prajudice -is deeply rooted in tllPm and lhey<br />
are determined to show to His Royal lIighne..s (<br />
that it is not only the Boer element in this country,<br />
as h is boUeved, that ill-treats Indians, but it<br />
iii th6 B"i\i~h (80 called in our opinion) element<br />
that is up in arms against His Majebty's British<br />
Indian subjeCts, They have ~ot seen theh way to<br />
meeting the requests of the Iudians even by an<br />
inch, -<br />
From the fulal reply given by His Worship the<br />
llayo!' to the officials of the Natal Indian Congress<br />
we 16am that Indians are totally debarrE'd from<br />
all civic functions to be held in honour of Ilis<br />
Rnyal Htghness-although they are held with<br />
their mOney and in their name!<br />
It should be clearly understood by our people IIoi<br />
well a& by the au~horities that when we ask fol'<br />
I'e presentation in all the general functions 8uch as<br />
the Civie Dinner etc., it does not neces-.;arily mean<br />
that Iridialls are anxious, or seeking the honour,<br />
to dine with the Prince. It is the principle of<br />
eq-uality that iliey wish to be maintained by the<br />
a.uthorities:<br />
-There may be public prejudice. That there iii<br />
we are fully aware. But it is for Indians to under<br />
.,tand that and til give way wherever it is possible<br />
to do so without losing their self-j'(lspect, and this<br />
the Indiana have been doing aU a.long. It is however<br />
wrong for the _uthoritielil to be guided by public<br />
prejudice._ This attitude of the local authorities is<br />
much to be regretted. It only amounl~ to thili,<br />
that ~ey refuse h recognise Indians as burgeS8e3,<br />
aud thia sla.p in the face given unhesitatingly by<br />
the Council on a Blost important occasion in the<br />
history of Durba.n should be sufficient to awaken<br />
the Tndians from their slu.mber. No sel£-respect-o<br />
ing I~dia.n can even think. in the ci~uU1stanCe8, of<br />
participating iu the genoml celebrations or to have<br />
anything to do with any nltenl1tive offer made by<br />
the Council. Last Sunday's meeting has passed<br />
a resolution to the effe~t that in view of equal<br />
statu'i not beinet' granted IDdian~ cannot. pal'f.icipate<br />
in the official celebrations. It is to be hoped<br />
tha.t everJ Indian will abide hy this deeision. Our<br />
non-participation does not mean that we are dig..<br />
loyal, nor that we are l.wking in our l'ebpect for<br />
HUI Roy.u Highness. Durban Indians have soot<br />
a welcome message to His Royal HighnetlS on hi3<br />
arrival at Capetown and they may l're&en~ him<br />
with an address on his arrival here if the authorities<br />
will allow that to be done. 110re than that,<br />
aa we have already stated previoualy, this is not a<br />
time for Indians in South Africa for jollification '-.<br />
but for mourning for all the humiliations they are<br />
being subjected to, and the tatest of them is in<br />
the shape of the Local To\Vnsh.i~ L~w Amendment<br />
Ordinance passed by the Natal Provincial<br />
Oouncil and just assenteQ to by His Exoolleacy<br />
the Governor-General-in-Council.
, May 8th, 1925 lN1J1AN OPINION 119<br />
WELCOME TO H. R. n, THE PRINCE OF<br />
WALES<br />
NATAL INlJIAXs<br />
The Natdl Indian CongreSl! telegrdphed the following<br />
welcome to His ROYdl Highness the Prince<br />
of Wales on his arrival at Cdpetowll :-<br />
"Private Secretary, Pl'inc~ or Wales, Capetown,<br />
N.dal Indian community join other sections of<br />
~Houth Afriwu community in extending heattiest,<br />
sincere and corcllal WE'lcomll to His Royal Higbness<br />
the l'tirtce of Wales, the future King Emperor, to<br />
the Union, and confidently hope and pray that his<br />
first visit to this portion of his Majesty's Dominions<br />
will be happy and pleallant, and will be conducive<br />
to the happir1es8, peace and prosperity of the cosmopolitan<br />
community of thIS Sub-Continent."<br />
The followmg reply has been received from the<br />
Private Secretary to His Hoy-al IIighness :-<br />
.. Prince of Wales mueh appreciates the message<br />
of 'Welcome from the Natal Indian Congress and<br />
thanks them all for thelr good wishes."<br />
CAPB INDIANt!<br />
A welcome address was pres~nteci to His Ro}al<br />
IIIghness by the Cape Indians.<br />
~NDIANS OVERSEAS<br />
The ilUlum SO()J[Il Reformer in its Indians Overseas<br />
Supplement dated March 21 writes:---:-<br />
Among the problems which claim the earnest and<br />
immedlate attention of the Indlan public are those<br />
which relate to our countrymen in foreign countries<br />
within and without the British Commonwealth .•••<br />
• •• India and Indlans have a long tradition of<br />
successful colonisation in dlstant lands. 'rhe torch<br />
of tndian religion and civilIsation was carried all<br />
over Asia and beyond by Hindn and Buddhist and,<br />
in later centuries, also by Mahomedan merchants<br />
and missionarles. l'hii/ expansive phasCII of Indla's<br />
national history ceased not much more than a<br />
thousand years ago when the country had to conserve<br />
all her resources to defend herself from foreign<br />
invasions. The l·e-establishment·of internal peace<br />
and external security under British rule, has enabled<br />
us to presume the interrupted process of national<br />
evolution in many directions. One of the most important<br />
of these is the settlement of Indians in<br />
foreign lands.<br />
Whatever may be the circumstances<br />
which led to their emIgration from India. they re.<br />
present her culture and civilisation, and it lS laid<br />
upon us in the Motherland as an imperatlve duty to<br />
see that they are in.. a position to do it well and<br />
worthily. It has been said that we OdD do little or<br />
nothing to help them against oppression and humiliation<br />
till we get Swaraj. But the only way of<br />
getting Swaraj is to stand up for the rights of our<br />
people especially of those whll, either through ignorance,<br />
racial custom or social antagonism. are in a<br />
position of disadvantage as compared With their<br />
fellow-citi..:ens, whether at home or abroad. In the<br />
case of our countrymen abl'oad OUl' duty is all the<br />
greater as the distance from the Motherland is a<br />
special disadvant..'\ge demanding special efforts on<br />
OUl' part. In the Imperial Indian Cltizenship Association,<br />
we have the nucleus of a great organisation<br />
which is needed to keep watch and ward over the<br />
intel'ests of om' fellow-countrymen overseas. It.is<br />
our purpose in this Supplement to focus Indian<br />
I public opinion on this important national duty. In<br />
conveying OUl: greetings to our countrymen abroad<br />
we invite their co-operation in our endeavour to be<br />
8 living link between them and the Mother-conntry.<br />
'l'he Iniuall Sot'ltd RR/orl1lM" is especl8l1y concerned<br />
with the social evolution of the country which,<br />
after all, is the most secnre basis of national solldarity.<br />
That evolution, will have to take account of<br />
the needs and conditione not only of the communities<br />
at borne but alsu of those abroad, in order to be<br />
worthy of Great and Greater India. In fact our<br />
countrymen abroad with their wider outlook upon<br />
the world can tnakl' more valuable contributi
120 INDIAN OPINION May 8th, 1925<br />
about its busine~ in the main undisturbed by political<br />
forces that secure so much publicity. The reports<br />
of the Reforms Enquiry Commlttee serve to<br />
show that there are, as there must be, in so novel a<br />
system as Dyarchy, many points which call for consideration;<br />
if the system has worked -badly, the<br />
explanatiofl is that extremists. have sought to discredit-<br />
It in the hope of securing immediately the<br />
complete me~ure of Swaraj favoured by the Minority<br />
report. ~ord Rawlinson (who is to be succeeded as<br />
Co~mander-in-Chief by F. 'M. SIr William Birdwood)<br />
in a speech on the IInclian Army evinced<br />
genuine sympathy with Indian (aspirations, but<br />
pointed out the perils of forcing the pace. What is<br />
true of the Army is tru'e of the Government itself.<br />
Racial-consh\erations complicate the problem of<br />
Indianisation on the military as on the political<br />
and administrative ,sIde, and Lord Rawlinson refused'<br />
to be,a party _to'measures WhlCh might be fraught,<br />
with "vital consequences."<br />
BISHOP ON "N"ATIVE PROBLEM<br />
EVILS OF THE PASS SYS'rEM<br />
The BIshop of Johannesburg, Dr. Karney, made<br />
an important reference to native problems at the<br />
Diocesan Native Conference held at- Potchefstroom.<br />
He $poke of the principle of the Colour Bar Blll as<br />
being absolutely un-ChrIs,tran, expressing the hope<br />
that it would not go through Parliameut.<br />
- 'fhe present, said his lordship, was a time of great<br />
anxiety and uncertainty, as they dId not/know whaL<br />
was gomg, to be the results of certain Acts andmeasures<br />
b~fo.fe Pa.rliament, in. addition to which<br />
there was much poverty and unemployment among<br />
the nahve populatIOn, ,/<br />
N~thing was so bad for {luy country as UIlcertaintx,<br />
but it Was clear that greater opportunity<br />
shouJ.d be given to J3antu peopl~, both for educa.tion<br />
and-f-()p
May 8th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION UI<br />
LORD llLRKESHEAD'~ HEPLY<br />
'1'he Earl of Birkenhead (Secretary of State, India),<br />
"n replying, said that Lord Olivier tm.l not exaggerated<br />
the !\everity of the course which he and his<br />
colleagues in the Labour Government had authorised<br />
tht' Yiceroy to take. When he (Lord Btrkenhl'lld)<br />
,first hpcame aware of the drastic nature of that<br />
COl1l'se, he felt it his duty cart'fully to examine the<br />
justification which was alleged lOT the authorisation<br />
of powers so remarkable----almost unprecedentedin<br />
India, and he had been Il9.tisfied that Lord Olivier<br />
was abso~utely jUEti6.ed, having rt'gard to the nature<br />
of the evidence which was before him.<br />
Hevolutionary conspiracy existed in Bengal be.<br />
twet'n H112 and 1917. It was only successfully repressed<br />
when the leaders were confined nnder<br />
Regulation :1 of 1l'!1l'!, and many of its subordinjlte<br />
members were dealt with nnder the Deft'nce of<br />
India Act. Most of those persons were relt'ased<br />
after the Hoyal Proch,lmation of 1919. and it was<br />
psychologically inter('Hting to note that JIlany of<br />
them had since abHtained from revolutionary ac'L.<br />
'1'0 the remainder ap amnesty was gradually extended.<br />
but a large number of those IIpeedily retnrnt'd<br />
to their previous methods and reDrganised<br />
tht'ir old association. By the'end of 1922 two main<br />
terrorist organisationil had been revived. Arms and<br />
ammunition, mostly smuggled fl'om abroad, were<br />
collected, and a new type of bomb was monufactured<br />
and elaborate and carefully conceived projects for<br />
aStlassination were devised. During 1923 and 1~124<br />
outrages took place and plaus for assassination continued<br />
to be made. Lord Lytton, the Governor of<br />
Bengal, from the first took an enlightened view of<br />
the situation, but that view did not immediately reqommend<br />
itself to the Viceroy or to the Government<br />
of the day. Some of the ringleallt'ril were a~rested<br />
parly in 1924, nnder Regulation :3 of 1~18. That<br />
did not
tl.'ll\ "'h:'b ~~,~~ ~I"_"'\; t~lt lE~ t1o. t- n~t~ fJ fila \j,"'~ 1l:,.~t l~w elt~ lh\~)) '~1J1"~<br />
Poll ~'Rh lti'\e~ !tl~ ~~I~ tin: I- UUHt}t\}>f.'t --<br />
UJk~ '~n, 'l.\I! t ~ J"'~1t» l1..{ c~tp§ll~ l:.:lfl: '~J"'. ~l:.'}n: lltlb~ lh~ ~w..l~ ~h. tlfP 1\.~~ llt~l~<br />
~I:!";) i~?lj,c !lm~ ~.~ 16,:lh ~ ~,~h 1l-~ l~elM:: 1 H)li' t m.h kIt-' l"l~lJ~l6- It\: ~,.. ~hl1~ 'ltlh~<br />
n\ll.~it blej"ell:.~1 ~e'~e'R r h'l'-l~ ~~1~ l~hll( I ,):.~ ,le 'k) lltl~~m. 'l--l~~$}~ ~ll!!:~.~ t l~~ l~l~<br />
1h.~.R ~liR tijthlfil1lh\cp lir!~tJ~l\ ll-Jtlf.rc?tJ~ !ltll:.hlJn:: ffil,h~ ll::?h~. lh\:~ ffitn~ eR~ l!'~~<br />
i~"'ftl!! U' 1~~ 1\" U'U- YIlt ~1?'" ~ltt1-t. t llt\ ~~R'~ t:. ~ lP~ IhTt !~ "l?l1~ y.,®\,? I;iltP~a Ciffihl'~<br />
..... :-- 'Ut t)(t~ l!1R ~"'l~ 'tp 'Ut h\ftfit~8 '''»llll<br />
- l!~ ~\f.tr\ \~~l!nl If Uf\ ti'~"~~ lj..):.'~ ""~t '}.\~l) l!I~l~ l"~ ~\M\ \\~""l:S'<br />
Iklh.'- \!on.)a ~~ ~'" 1}·.1'" ~lc'\e If'~ 1411~ t).)'Iri " -----<br />
I~Vl" ~~t 11ft: ~11t l::~ e ~,tJt PhlltU' ~ , 'f3~ ~~ Q>Pl7fi tR~ tlJ:,lP~ IP101h'!! *t,lt<br />
IM"Np~l. ~ tY~Il:.M: Ulklrt: ~'R ,.,~t "".~1iJ~ lh flt,1JUt ~'lfl ~1~ 'l~~ ,~~ RIll. 1~~ tpln,\c ~ik<br />
~~11 ;p.1tt t lJtl~'R l~lkla ~}R: " ~l;1 ~lJi fci'l\ltlla- ~~ p).; Rlt lh.ffi.~ ~ ~1~ lr~~ .. g)ll( l-g)l? Mc~<br />
l!~ tl~ttlm ~IS.~~ Itl~~ lk~lh" l~lltke lpn·.~ qlt ~~ t'l}h '~J~ ~H~ ~~ \d~ !lti~U"cJ);,h§ It'"nH~<br />
\pl &i ~~ ~~\:, Ut~~nt l-.Wt: 1l1!~ ~ltt I\:.(t l-~.h lf 1 ,." '!kl-Ilt. \l-~.~ 'Il- 1t.l{ \}L~ lhllllhlfl: ~t-'<br />
-kJlq tl1!:"'~ lHltlfl: '\>~'lIlll~~ ,. t ~ ~~ Ut'~~~ ~»c~ l>,\t~' \ 't~) i~\ ~lh ~1-t.~\Q p'~ 'elt.~<br />
}I\tlfc lltl;.t~~ ''''Wl~ 0 1~1Wt: ll~-'''c~ ,~~ ·jok ll-~ ~l:Ut t,hllit 'l).Ji~l> lMla- t)~ It--11:c 1l!!~<br />
t~1r.n~ ~ t\ftl It:~ '1~~ !lt~.1r.'" t"~I1~ tyllt!ijL~ t! ~~ Ua~l)tt,t tyl~h.'~ fo!lI\.I'Ii~ l.!'~ l}>'~l)tt~<br />
tHb !?tI~lH 1t .. 1ft: tl.?! rtli·~ 'I'~e 'alf "~lJl\n: h"~ \!ltl\ l}l~ P,q, lP' \Pl1>M ~1&V>!J ~~t ~ \:':0<br />
Jt.~J3 In~tr{ eM: ~~tcWt: ~~ !k~ {: '~eH~ !lt~WI \!:'t:lll c~~ 'f,!, ,~~ ~n~lltj ~It~){t l~ HI'H li\lt1\<br />
11.1ttla: ~lfclk,) ~ l~,p.h T~~\\ ~~ ,'~ l~I~R I~ll'-~lh 'W";! Unlt n c~ cl~t.J I\::1:: 11'-~ !~kh. ~ ~l~\}t~<br />
H~\t ~ II-( \}>~ ,lR \N~ '''~llt c, '~\~~. 1M: '~!~r: !k~,M.l1: lp'l;;~ Ie ~ jlt '1:!:U~k~§l ~IH~ !ltl-llt ll>lte<br />
t-le, 1l;1l:.'Ci ''tll'i l~l~h )tl'tn. ~ 1:!: ~~'lt (Ilt l~ll: eJh.b ~H\;I'k tyJ..ffici' \,pisl" lY~"Ll\: 'll-- \!ih. ffi'):>1D<br />
1}'~'l.R n·k~ t~~U tla: ~tt~ \}>1~l1Lll IPR't> ll'~k lfi';tP tll~ !k~l~ p):,\,!: ~lh1P:C 'Ilk ltl,?Ut<br />
I~~i.h @)e '~ ~h ~lJ''''t.-e h~k~!ft: ~~ ~~ ~RJl\]lt 4~ \}>\~t)tf ltl~~ l(~l1tt 11.oVttf.lt l-m$'-:)f\ ~I?l'"<br />
~ffih t! .'e klt~ ~lPl~'l;i'tt lVRLft emt'''' ):l~~ll1Clt "'ffie~<br />
l}-k~ '~Jhlc V\'tt 1\~nll f(.)~ lI,6'llh. lrlPI~ k~elt ---'--<br />
.~ lM~ ''IF'''P'''~ \}.ttl~ Udl\t l}ql~ ~ll:1>.fii n'll1tI~ '@ l~l\.1l'.>l~~ llRl~'''' tl}P e?le t'~\}L'fl<br />
'}-'hte \fcllkt\fclt1 lHky 'k~ .~ 'Ut If'h.~ IPU~~ l\')~b !t'tlb,UGJ.>§l17 R"~L~I~ 1~ '@ 1~~ 1>l!JK \lJ:P<br />
M·lt,~~ 't ~lJi lh'ti ~Ut~~ ""f&~ U~\.o.o ~ln:' lir. llf ~l»: tJ.'k,»: U--~l}C5lI11-l-fi-~e).>ID-'l:l-eh't H~ltl'"<br />
-- ~"1->JJ1~ u l~''''elt'\'It l::1l~ h'tl'6'l-B\? ~lll~ n"effi,l-<br />
'~\nlt ~\h O~-E' ~l~ffi lk \\ 1l- 1, n1, !ltl''\.ffi,~ '1->Pl~hl~ lr~l~~1Plt"<br />
Jlt~l~ PUc 'l-""t,~l' ~l}1. 01, 'II> cl"'tpc 'Phlkt telJUt tlt7~~ l(~!K ,~11'\J.. ,,.. (m.lJ:/P ltfi, ~ p.~ ~lt<br />
lr~~!t "la:~:).f\ »1?1'" \);,l~e \};.p~'tt ll'elh1}>c 'hIe t -,e~l). !kll~tt I~ lrH\AII~I1t 'Il-) ~U\~ Ut fa S' 'IP<br />
----------------------<br />
e 1re llt ~ . tJ.a lee ~ 1).-<br />
,<br />
1 uililn<br />
Itegittered at the G. P.O .... N ...,.,..<br />
No. 2o-VOI. XXIII. Friday, May 15th, 1925. PRleB FOUUIIJI1\d.. a mall as a<br />
man. In taking the.slep they"'p.ave- taken the resignationists<br />
have committed a very serious blunder.<br />
. . --<br />
It has come to orir knowledge that the Indian<br />
ewployees of the Durban Corporation and, other<br />
ignorant people are being thre:ltened that If they do<br />
not participate in the P).'ince's .... celebI·,\tiolls they<br />
w'duld be .. kicked out of Uteir jobs and kicked out<br />
of the counby." We ,~y~ot know to what extent<br />
this is true and who is l·esponsible for such a propaganda.<br />
We are certainly not inclined to believe<br />
that. tb.Q CQrpoIation Otliei.al& would 00 a. p;u:ty to<br />
ALL'S WELL TlIAT ENDS 'WELL<br />
"J'r'HE visit of His Royal Highness the Prince of<br />
11 Wales has 'uQused considerable interest and<br />
enthusiasm among the Indian community<br />
of Durban and we feel sure that if such keenness<br />
would be sholVn by them in all matters concerning<br />
their well'lre in this country they would be enjoying<br />
better conditions of life than they are at present.<br />
The_Congres
INOIAN OPINION May 15th, 1925<br />
mention of a boycott at any time or at aIlY place;<br />
aM it was Well for the Secretary of the Congress<br />
to hll.Ve tminted put thi$ gross error.<br />
Orl. Tuesd.ayjs Mercury there were reports belittling<br />
the_ work of the Oongress in connection<br />
with the Prince's visit which was again the result<br />
of hasty and thtHightless action of SUm\:) of our<br />
brethren and anothE:lr cloud hljvered over the<br />
Congress as a circular.was being distributed call-<br />
ing a, "Mass Meettng" of, the merCl1l1tiie community<br />
for that evening in connection witli the Prinoo'B<br />
visit and "to pa~s a vote of no confidence" in-the<br />
_offiCials of t1LE~ Natal lndlan Congress, the lattell<br />
being the main purpose. The officials of the Congress<br />
h!J.d made it ,their business to be presont at<br />
the meeting and after the Secretary had fully explained<br />
what had been done up-to-date the idea of<br />
passing a vote of no confidence was thrown entirely<br />
overboard ang a resolution to participate in the<br />
general- ~elebratlons_ was_defeated aIld one to<br />
Mcord a reception independently ttltt lUI. was<br />
passed- and a comt.dittee was fdtnied for the<br />
purpose. This resoiution has onbe mora uplield the<br />
principle for whidh the Congress has all along<br />
been fighting and sO let us hdpe tlJat all's well<br />
that has ended Well.<br />
PRINC~ TO ATTEND JNlHA,N CELEBRATIONS<br />
The Maydr has beeri nqw tlfficiilily adV'ise~d by ,the<br />
Prime Minister's Secretll.I'y that thllPrince of Wa.les<br />
will attend the Indian celebratiQns· in Durban oil<br />
June 4.' -<br />
The venue for the Indian I celebrations wh~ch<br />
are tl't take place mdependently 'of -t,hEl Corporation<br />
who has n'Ot acceeded to the jr resolves that<br />
in the eV'ent of the Indian community holding any<br />
special function such as a children's demonstration.<br />
it shall be incumbent that His Royal Highness shall<br />
grace stich fnl1ctiofil! with his pt'esence."<br />
The meeting wWch co~JiJ.enced at 3 p.m. terminated<br />
a~ 1 p.m. with a vote of much deserved thanks<br />
to the chair.<br />
A MISREPRESENTATION<br />
l'he jt. Iton. Secretary, Nata1 indian Congrese,<br />
addressed the following letter to the Natal Mercury I<br />
"Sir,~Ih publishing a report of the Indian mass<br />
meeting in your issue of to-day, you do so under the<br />
sub-heading of "Proposed Boycott."<br />
May we point out that neitl1el' in. the resolntlot1s<br />
passed nor in any of the speecbes has there beeI1<br />
,any suggestion or thonght of boycotting the visit of<br />
Ilis Itoyal Highn'lBB. The simple truth is that in<br />
view of his Worship the :Mayor'. inabihty to accord<br />
the Indian community its just due and proper status<br />
ih the furthcoming celebllations, the mass meeting<br />
has, after ths nio!rt; thoughtful deliberations, decided<br />
to abstain from participating in its official celebra.-<br />
tions.<br />
_<br />
But 011 the otlrer hand, trrle to Indian instinct and<br />
our respect for the Throne and for the .heir to the<br />
Throne. Indians will certainly adoRt many means<br />
and measures to give expression to their sentiments.<br />
Yours faithfully,<br />
801UnJEE RUSTO:M:JEE.<br />
Joint Ron,'Secretary, Natal Indian Congl'ess'
.<br />
iNDIAN OPINION<br />
'-, - NATATJ INDlA'liS AND THE PHINCE<br />
r' the Natal Jfercur!l has the following leading<br />
ar~lcl(' in lis i&!ljf! of the 12th llIstant :-<br />
H ha.'l been left to the Natal Indian Congl"e
126 INDIAN OPINION May 15th, 1915<br />
\<br />
counted ,at great length the circumstances leading<br />
up to the meeting, and detailing communications<br />
from the Mayor of Durban. He spoke for more<br />
, than an Jtour and a half in Gujarati and followed it<br />
with a brief summary in English for the benent of<br />
the prej;js representatives.<br />
Mr. Rustomjee opposed the ,following resolution,<br />
which was proposed by the ChaIrman and seconded<br />
by Mr. M. A. Motala.<br />
I<br />
" 'l'hat this meetmg of the Indian COmmtlnity of<br />
Durban hereby resolves to participate together with<br />
other sections of the community in all the celebra<br />
/ tions in honoUl' of the visit of the his Royal Highness<br />
the Pl\ince of Wales to Durban."<br />
Mr. Rusflomjee endeavonred to make an a~endment,<br />
but this was disallowed by the Chau'Illan.<br />
Mr. Rllstomjee stated that the honour of<br />
300,000,000 in India was at stake and that the local<br />
Indians should be careful how it dealt with the<br />
question.<br />
'<br />
" Do not dig your own~ graves, but stand by the<br />
Congress and do not participate in the celebrations."<br />
The followdng resolution was framed, proposed<br />
by ,Mr. ~ooknoodeen and seconded by Mr. M. A.<br />
Motala :-This mass meeting of the Indian 'community<br />
of Durban and district hereby resolves to<br />
accord to H.R.H. the Prince of Wales a reception<br />
npon the occasion of J;!.is arrival withm the Borough<br />
of Durban.<br />
Mr. Rustomjee and other representatives of the<br />
Congress declared themselves satisfied w,ith the<br />
proposal, which was carried unanimously.<br />
Mr. A. 1. K~jee in the ,course of' his speech<br />
strongly condemned the action of some of the members<br />
of the Congress Committee who' have sent In<br />
their resignation.<br />
The no-confidence proposal was apparently thrown<br />
over board.<br />
The following committee was elected to, make the<br />
arrangements for, the visit of the Prince .-Messrs.<br />
E. M., Paruk, M. A. Motala, Rooknoodeen, Abdul<br />
Hack, Ismail, Mahomed "Haffejee, Bhawani Dayal,<br />
K. R. Nayanah. Lep. R. Gopaul, D. P. Desai, V. M.<br />
.Jooma, :o\.jam Haffeje,e" ll., ~lJlasun~rum,- SO!'abjee<br />
RustomJee, Jack M60dley, R. 'IL' Naidoo,,~M. 1.<br />
~Majoo, P. S. Aiyar, Joseph Royeppen, Ismail Gora,<br />
V. Lawrence, A, M. Lockhat, M. Bethasee, S. K.<br />
Pather, S. R. Pather, D. S. Chetty, S. Emmamally,<br />
M. 1. Kajee, C. M. Anglia, A. 1. Kajee, John 1_.<br />
Roberts, P. R. Pather and V. 'So C. Pather.<br />
A~YAN BENEVOLEN~,HOME<br />
FOURTH ANNIV~RSARY<br />
The foUrth anniversary 'of, thtj aboTe Home was<br />
celebrated on Suuday, April 3: IH2.5, at the Home<br />
ground!'!, Mayville. :A fair mustel' of the Indian<br />
population-mere present,~and many febcitous speeches<br />
were m~depl.'ii~~:.tJ:1e actIvities 'Of.. fh~ ~ome"il!<br />
succourlllg the poor';1'rrd< needy. .'<br />
The secretary's annual relJo'r~tated ,that during<br />
the year the :f.[9me accomD;lodated 48, persons, ofwhom<br />
37 were claimed by their relations on the<br />
strict understanding that th'ey were not ,allowed to<br />
beg. on the streets. ,Thil Home had also, sheltered<br />
-nnd. provided elothing for 11 destitute and aged<br />
women. ' At the present time there were-13 inmates.<br />
TJae Provincial Authorities had recognised the usefulness<br />
of the Society py making a grant (Jf £100.<br />
and .the Immigration Departvnent had": shdwn an<br />
inter~t in the iristitutioI!, which was greaily<br />
appreCfa.w.d. It was7~wmg to the activities of the'<br />
Society th'"a't'Alle profe~si6nal element of beggars ~as<br />
on the decreaSe, and the Society's thanks were dne<br />
to the police authorities for whole-hearted co-operation.<br />
The report also thanked the stall holders and<br />
squatters at the Indian Market and the Indian<br />
grocers, etc7; for gifts in kind which had kept the<br />
expeI\s~s of the Home at the minimum.<br />
~~~~~~~~l'»»»»»"»» ~o<br />
~ OUR LONDON I,ETTER t<br />
\Ii [ FROM OUR OWN CORRESPONDEN r ] i<br />
\If 9th April, 192;). ~<br />
o~~E
May 15th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 127<br />
started a geological survey in India an,I wonderfully<br />
good work had been Ilone. It bad been followed up<br />
by very fine enterpri'''m the part private individuals<br />
IlO that they cot. ·~~onfidently claim that India<br />
wall in the forefront in many respects of mining and<br />
" ,metallqrgical enterpriee in the Empire. Their PTOtluction<br />
of coal was only second to that of the<br />
United Kingdom in the Empire. while their iron<br />
deposits were known to everyone. In 1!IOS, the<br />
mineral production of India totalled about £X,OO 1,000,<br />
in 1920 it amounted to over £:30,000,000. They<br />
hoped to make even greater progress in the future.<br />
They were sending young Indians to this country<br />
for training and he was gLtd to know there was a<br />
fair number of Indians among the associate s~udents<br />
of the Institution. .They were making every effort<br />
for industrial progress and they realised that that<br />
could only b~ done with the aid of science and by<br />
Indians attaining a high professional standard. They<br />
had found it necessary to start a mining college, and<br />
he hoped that the college, when it was establishef,J,<br />
would be a feeder institution to the ImpeAd<br />
College of Science here.<br />
The Government is seriously alarmed at - thlldifficulty<br />
of staffing the Indian Civil Service with<br />
Its due propol'tion of Englishmen and is taking<br />
.teps to l'etriEVe the position, for it bas recently<br />
materially improved the conditions of service. Sir<br />
Robect Horne speaking of this "tragedy" the other<br />
day declared that if things continue as at pl'esent<br />
the great work the British had donel in India will<br />
disappear entirely without any conversion, revolution,<br />
or uprising of Indian people demanding forms<br />
of native government.<br />
Mrr R. K. Khan, of Durban, Natal, Advocate, an<br />
ex-Secretary of the Natal Indian Congress, has<br />
arrived in London from the Continent and is staying<br />
at the Regent's Palac~ Hotel in Pi.ccadily.<br />
16th April 1925.<br />
The Maharajah of Jodhpur who has arrived in<br />
England on a five months' visit is ,staying at a<br />
private house at Wimbledon. He is aC!;lompanied<br />
by his four wives and a large entourage of secretaries<br />
and scrvants. The primary object of the<br />
Mahru'ajah's viEit. is to match his famous Pol.o telWl<br />
against th,.e finest British players at Hurlingbatn,<br />
Rochampton and other Polo centres. He has bl'ought<br />
over seven players, including Rajah Hamat Singh,<br />
who is the captain and a celebrated pla}er. Seventy<br />
Jodhpur ponies have been transported from India<br />
, and they are stabled at Minehead, with Capt. A. H.<br />
Williams in charge. The Stud far exceeds in number<br />
and also in quantity the ponies which the<br />
Americans brought over for the international match<br />
with Britain two years ago, tlO whatever else may be<br />
lacking the team is rich in horseflesh. As a matter<br />
of fact the Jodhpur side consists of experts.<br />
- The Secretary of State for India has appointed<br />
Sir C, W. Rhodes a member of the Council of State<br />
for India in Lonuon in succession to Sir M. Hogg.<br />
whose tenure of office upires at the end of April.<br />
Sir Rhodes has sel'ved on several civic bodies in<br />
India including the Bengal Chamber of Commerce.<br />
Bengal Lt'gislative 90uncil and the Indian Legislative<br />
Assembly.<br />
The death has occurred in India of Risaldar<br />
Mazhar Ali Khan of 1st Skinner's Horse, who in<br />
1879 saved Lord Robert's life during a march in the<br />
Chardeh Yalley, and twas for his bravery awarded<br />
the Order of Merit and promot.f'd to Indian Officer<br />
l'lmk.<br />
Lord Lytton formally assumed the acting office of<br />
Viceroy arid Governor-Genepl of India on thE!' 10th<br />
April in Delhi. Mr. Crear, the Secret.'!ry to. the<br />
Home Depm-tnlent. read His Majesty's Warrant and<br />
Sir Brod Bahadnr Shadi LaI, Chief Justice of Lahore,<br />
administered the oaths of allegiance and of office.<br />
Blackheath, which at other times is one of the<br />
quietest spots in England, was, during the Eastel'<br />
holi~ays, a scene of attraction. Every imaginable<br />
kind of amusement was there and tens of thousands<br />
of men, women and children indulged themselves to<br />
their heart's (Oltent.<br />
But the writer was not a<br />
little amllsed to see among the palmists and the<br />
phenologists an Indian-who claimed to be "Singa,<br />
the Indian Hindu Gypsy." Dressed in the fashion<br />
of this country but for his headdress, which was a<br />
turbau, and a coloured coat. he nE!'ither spoke nor<br />
made signs of any kind but just looked at the lines<br />
on the palm of the band or ran his fingers over the<br />
head in search of the bumps and 10 r in a few<br />
minutes his report was in the bands of his subject<br />
and the insignificant fee in pence was in his pocket.<br />
The Eastel' weather has been exceptionable and<br />
the Seaside resorts and places of interest in the<br />
country were crowded by lAndon's millions.<br />
•<br />
INDIA IN THE IMPERIAL PARLIAMENT<br />
Mr. LansbllrY'(Bow and Bromley, Lab.) asked if<br />
it was the iutention of the Secretary for India to<br />
invite Mr. C. R. Das and Mr. Gandhi, together with<br />
other representatives of Indian opinion. such as<br />
Messrs. Sastri, Lajpat Rai and Dr. Besant, to<br />
come to this country for a conference on the best<br />
methods for secnring full co-operation between ~ll<br />
classes m India for the re-establishment of social_and<br />
industrial peace in that country. -<br />
Earl Winterton. Under-Secrctary for India (Horsham<br />
and WOl'thing).-His Majesty's Government<br />
will receive with sympathy any concrete proposal<br />
put before them by the lndian political parties with<br />
the support of the Government of India and the<br />
local governments concerned, but if is not their<br />
intention to give such invitations as the hon. member<br />
suggests, fol' two reasons:-(l) The direct con".<br />
duct of policy and administration in India bas been<br />
entrusted by ParliamEfnt to the Government of<br />
India and.the local governments, and it is therefore<br />
with these authorities that any discussion or negotiation<br />
of this kind must take place, and no useful<br />
pUl'pose would be served by the intervention or<br />
pal·ticipatioll at this stage of !Iis Majesty's Government<br />
in matters which must ultimately come Qefore<br />
them for decision, and for the decision of which<br />
they are responsible to Parliament. (2) Though the<br />
Viceroy is about to visit this country for the purpose<br />
(among othel's) of discussing with his Majesty's<br />
Government the political situation in India, it<br />
-would be placing both him and the Government Q.f<br />
India in an entirely false position if his presence<br />
hel'e were mad" the occasion for negotiations with<br />
(he Indian political parties. -<br />
(tt~ :>Jll'(eu~ ~<br />
~rLtj4h ttlull ~!lrL rL°. "1't il ·~lll. aIt~<br />
~t:{lrL ~tt~ !l~rL~ ~lli ~\~lli UU ~l~lll~<br />
~l~(i ~ a' (il. ,,~ ~rL ,,~\ ... tll l .. ~~tfi<br />
~l~h ~Lltfi altNttl..n~. ~l",,~i ~li)L<br />
·aIt~ttl tt!!lll tt!! ll~ 't~ '"t .. .&~ ~q&l~qL l<br />
rlr~ a lll~f~l..n llrt~ (§'t\ ~~(l. '"t .. .&lL<br />
(il. \ l .n ~ "~'t~ 't~ai lluCl «t~i i4~~.<br />
~u(L ~~«l lt~l:-<br />
~l. ~
Jl'lPl", (~lt' ~thll!! 'Ut l-1r..'1\ ll:01\.)llt1., H\.)-l?lh?<br />
,~, ~1ft: ~ltlllt.,~ f5i1o. ~'e ~'e'ltt ~.)H \. 0<br />
bll-lt lt~ '~ ~'eHt ~ .. H "'lr~1t I-Dlj~ 't'\)'1o. ~lfl<br />
lht ~I';l '0 ell-Ul-R: !ltlM h. ,3f;P f51m. ~f;Dlt tw-e<br />
f51ln. ~}~e. \. 0 1] e '~"h: ~ ll'> u.~ 'en" )'§)l?h.t •<br />
'l£t..llte Iltlblt~<br />
L?\}t~'ln~<br />
~~ l::\'t-lttt 'i!:.\rka \l-'~ tht ~tt lIlrt! b~l~<br />
"'~Tt.~ 1~~II~I~ U-"'-~;" ~,tJ llR \jUt' ~~\P<br />
ttp\>t t),\\}.\n~I,1t \t",l\IJ~ \It> '.~ ,Pol"t t:n .. l\:\clP<br />
\l1lM~ l M.b fml~fi ~~~ ~~t.~ J!!t1tr ~ ~~'?,fi:<br />
!ltlclYl}t t},~\b 'c.~ fblh rl-, lh~ H~p ~ ';\ \nM re<br />
'Qt-llfe !ltll:.e1 tJ'~ 1:.,PH lhl-~~l~tlt lh,pl~ lJli~l~<br />
~jS !IS t\~~ltllt l}nAlllb \}-ftl\ t1,'U l::'~~ ~):It<br />
it\:.\lIl~ 11ft: 'l£hl~ U:Aoi" !ltl1hI1ll~ \J.tJ !It'j..Ki~~<br />
"-Ui" '\\.) ,.~ ~t~ ~\~ ~~l~ {. ~ Unli ~lf,'"<br />
\lbl~~ t~h~ ll-,.lr.et th\~p If?\~ ,p\.t\~', lik.<br />
~lltl) 'foJfn M~ U:'lt.ln: '~lfo l~e. ~1 ~lcnt ~h.'\n:.<br />
\plHl~hU hlr'l!J lh~n! ~~ le~i'cl}:. t ,ij;~ l::Pl~~<br />
l1"''l->1->nt~ ln~lh u..ltC:" \,0, t~ll:t ~~lhl1iR ~h<br />
lnl-- ~lR lAJll) "h1.h.l~l? Pl\? U~hlfd: \::l-R: 0 ~ltR<br />
pIt ~R ~ 0 h~ 1\::.1:Ib 16'~~lc:.~ 11tlthl}l.l~fl<br />
,<br />
1'0 ~~~ ft ~~lt ~\§:'d t l\l~<br />
thl$ tlcW- i tl&- ~l~ 15'I~ ~, ""'cl lPlt 'MtI.l~<br />
~lH' J..llt ,f.'~t tlti ~1t U-l~~ ~ki: 'p'~ t~<br />
t1lt l:::!t~~ !pIhlb '''I!!!~ U>lt.~ @ 'al~~ b)'!J'1~1t<br />
,f;lt~ N~!t ftl~lc ~1- ~M~t ~ ~~fi lJll\tt l:h~<br />
1J .. I-t~ 1~ b11:.~' ~M ef):,):f\ ~ "@ l~G1} t}'e~ 11'11<br />
{. '~l~Gt} lh'~ lc ~ ~'1!:~ ll::lt~ 1M 1~<br />
lli..1~ e 0 lalel:! p)t,]ljl?J~ Ilr;~ ,f;ltl~ ~ t'~ 1~1f<br />
k,'1+l 1l::151'?~ lb~ 11->~~]{ ~1~AI'J+) lhl~<br />
IJ..IP1~ t ~R~ J4u.'~ ~lf.m. Ie ~ l::'~~1~ lellt,loIe<br />
I~Ml1," ftl~~l~ tLeP t~WIt~ ~\~}"\b~ I~\i\lt~ ~l&l{<br />
.Iloc~ \tlb '~Jlf hRl~la- R~ ~It'k ~l}ri Rlb~ ~ lh'~~ llJP<br />
tt~l>~1JI1' l}lt\ t'~R''''' l--1~1R l::~ w.~lc: ll--ll>lh. ll"t~ ~ e.l~Ki~pAll li~ tffi: ~ ).Gl}nl-Olf. I:! ~ ~b~<br />
~ll!:~ t 0 h\\ 1r\~!,I\e ~~R l!1\1: 11310'15;,'; ~Idl. t:: ~~lt t @ ~~ "fni "~, lP~ 'r..e.~ -~l-<br />
~ll;b l~h'ln: 1~ ltl~ 1J1M l? ~h 'nl~ Il-- l}:lrt. ''e'l 't" .. ,~ l\-~~lt l~~ t ~ \tr~ 1~~ ~h l),l!:<br />
\lnln. wlQ~ ~»'kt: t ~~ ~\}o.\~ ,1I~1l!t ~1fl: '\ht.. Unb 'f1!!;~" ~1~' Il->ltL?~ \},ellOV"'e IntI:<br />
tl~::Il~P~ ~lP1Pl~ e t t.l~ ih'c Th:!th ~f\11~~ t}6l-- f.Sllil~ CiltR fah\}n~:b ~h ~5 ~~ jltl,l;~l~<br />
UHlr; ~h I\}\.' ~\t he ·~\te~ e. t.~ ~~\tl}n l;:lb\-llt. lit!: bl~'t ~lt~ U-$!~~lM ?j t ~~ }.jj~'~<br />
\!"- 1~ It\!! hl~ lclHl 1~1\!!~11l'll1n: ' .... IGtl~~lt ~h ~hw.l-Olb liB,S! ~~ !It.l~lch !}:.~ ~1H: l!1 ~h<br />
\lt1t\' l'~' 1\0'.1," 'lh\.t \?~W ~\t& ~ 0 ~l~~il~k - ~ ~~ 1l1t~ 'tl~~Ph ft...,~ ~<strong>I~~~</strong> \\.t,I'6I\Il:l1.lti l~l\)\~<br />
~lt t'lt t~lttJ.; It lP~ l::lft ~ Uln. ~1!e3 ~?t l>lb l::,..~f.;lt ~~~ '~~h I-O~~~ ~'fG~ ~11tKi: 1t~ ~ tl-O<br />
1~ '~bl\tt !Il1J:.l1'it lilt ft\h It(l1tI''~ 1m: hHP - ~~,~ ~fQ \}lh\ft tlhhlt~ ft.)h'~'1 Pll-tlcn ~ ,~,~~<br />
lh~k ~~It t't!;~ \~ hIli 'cl'" ~~n( !It\lt:~bk~ ~h 'lh~ "'V~ ,\o[i,ll \~ !k~ t1~ ~tj~ IJllfjh.<br />
~~ .. ~ 1~~ f! .. @ ,,~ \plln! !lllbhlke tfiltl:! lP~ 1M end~J P"f\.h ~M~ PhtH: p'~ ~1~~IR t\li: -<br />
~l~\}l')l l-I,:r~ tift: KiUlc lAfl}n IJlltl: l::1~~1l:: bL'<br />
, .... ,a-~l~~lt 1--lnet t ~ ~l\fl: !lt1l:hlt~ 1):lkhi:<br />
'~ ~'!:R -l15h.lk: Hlt<br />
1~~ l::U~lcl~ l}>lthl}l.l~~ !hPJ:nlln Iffi.: tl
~ d+<br />
.. UulHn<br />
,<br />
No. ~I-VO). XXIII. Friday, -May Z2nd, 1925.<br />
• egl!.hreo Ji<br />
PRIGS Fou ....".<br />
." n ..... o . ••• New.paper<br />
T<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
" i ~! 1<br />
HE Ceylon InJepenJent writes:- Tbe news I tog for and not :merely the parlitipalion in the<br />
is current In official circles 10' Londoq dinner.<br />
aod Calcutta tbat His Majesty ,tbe King Mr. Josep4 Baptista has bf'en elected President<br />
will in aU probability visit India during tbe of the Bombay Munici.pal Corporation. He has long<br />
A"tumn of tbls ye~r. If tbe report be coo..: championed the cause of Labour, BIlys Nell' India, and<br />
f<br />
• d tit d t ft tb t I may be trusted to nse hill pO!lition to improve the<br />
IfDJe a, a a er a e,.......a er e re urn 0 lot of the labouring classes in the City. There is a<br />
His Majesty from his beaUb cruise iO tbe good deal that needs to be done for them in ,many<br />
Mediterraoeao..,.....we gatber from latest mail directions. 'In politics, Mr. Baptista believes in the<br />
advlces tbat opportunity. will be taken of tbe pl'inciple of ReSponsive Co-operation advocated 'by<br />
visit lor His Majesty to be prescnt at the' State his leader the late 'R. ~. TUak.<br />
opening of tbe new capital Delbi, and to preside The Natal Jfmurg through its "Man in the Moon"<br />
at tbe inauguration ceremony" of tbe 'Imperial columns conveys Ow following to the Indian com-<br />
Parliament tbere, His Majesty's second visit to munjtr ;- :<br />
India will no doubt be ' bailed with delight by It it) to be hoped that the Indian community will<br />
many millions of his subjects and the sover ..:.tns<br />
compose their dlff('rences and unite in giving a real<br />
"'b and genuine ea.'1tern welcome 'to the son of the<br />
of the various native states wbo will fie witb King-Emperor. It certainly is not the occasion to<br />
each other in offering tbeir King-Emperor a accentuate their differences With the whites, because,<br />
most loyal and bearty welcome.. ,It is not they have nothing to do with the matter in hand.<br />
possible at this early date to sarmise' waat Is Moreover, the,.. know perfectly well that a mixed<br />
.. I g I d ' gathering at a ci1ic luncheon would wreck the whole<br />
~e 0 p anne. " business, and woutd 1ead to considerable fraction<br />
In the course of his recen't address to the Women's<br />
South African Party Oongress held at Worcester<br />
General Smuts is reported to have said :-<br />
With illiterate peopl~'one h,ad to be honest, there<br />
was no place f9r slyness. Mr. rielmaIi Roos had<br />
said at Kterksdorp, speaking of the Wages Bill, that<br />
the standard of wages in: the' town~ woutd be iilcreased<br />
so much that' Coloured people would have no<br />
hope of getting employment and would rush to the<br />
{arms, but addressing the Africander National Bond<br />
Association of Coloured, People, formed by Nationalist<br />
agents, Mr. Tielman Roos had ,said that white<br />
and oolour!ld 'would be placed on a footing of absolute<br />
equality as ci'rilised beings. Those, pointed<br />
ont General Smutf!, were two 'Voices of the Pact: one<br />
for the oity and the other for the country. These<br />
were all matters which would alienate Colqured<br />
people and make them lose all trnst in the worq of<br />
the white man. " , '<br />
and bitterness. Much all some of' us may and do<br />
~ deplore racial divisioJ;ls and religious cleavages, yet<br />
we have to work w$th thin~s as they are, and the<br />
Indians are by no means wJthdut their distinctions<br />
and 'their castell. Would tliey consent 'and agree<br />
upon half a dozen Indian representatives drawn<br />
from every section of the Indian population from<br />
the so-called coolie to the Imam. They wQuld never<br />
select seven to carry' out the scheme. Tpere would<br />
be worse bickerings and culuminations about the<br />
choice than there is about the exclusion. The lhdiane<br />
kno1V thiS; but Ifome of them seek to rrulke<br />
political' capital out of 'the aifait. Personally' I<br />
should have been ilad if there could have been Bome<br />
pectlliarly Jndiau f\lnction wpicjl tpe ~ince could<br />
have at~nded foX' a few minuj;es, bt/-~ bis time ilt 110<br />
1imited that every section of the J'0p\llation must<br />
inake some sacrifice. 'No doubt the Freemasons, for<br />
exatnple,. would liave been happ'Y had he' attended<br />
lodge or the Anglicans had he been present at a<br />
church service, but the Prince has to remember that<br />
his father's subjects «omprise all and every JiKle and<br />
-We have received a letter signed by Bhawani colour, and it is no easy task for him to steer cl~ar<br />
Dayal, B. A. Meghraj and M. aeethasee Mahartij of 'all prejudices. Everyone of uS should therefore<br />
supposed to be in reply to our comment on unite in BD'loothing' his' path and not throw up<br />
thelit resignation from the Natal Indian OongreBS barrierS', lind I believe the majority of 'the Indians<br />
Oommittee. The letter has not made us any .ee thie. 1t i~ a few malcoiltenti wl\o have been<br />
the wiser 8S to the justification of their action and spoiled in Oxford or somewhere who are 11lising the<br />
we do not believe our readers will be any the wiser equali~y stunt. '<br />
by it. The letter is a lengthy one and it is more an •<br />
attack on the editor personally and also on other<br />
individual!! than an explanation of their attitude.<br />
As to their argument abQut half-au-hours dinl16rtable<br />
equality which they are not out for we have<br />
repeatedly stated and do not mind stating it once<br />
again that it is not that equality that the Congress<br />
has been fighting for but fol' the reoogllition of the<br />
P1iJltiple of equality where the commnnity B8 'a<br />
whol~ i, tloncel'ned.<br />
1t i. the duht to J>e i~vit~d<br />
.\". \~,O ~lv!o ttlnnu ,t~lAt t~ •• Oonir'l!~ bl\. been flsbt~<br />
That"Indians are not without their distictions and<br />
casl.a .has now-a-days become a very oonvenient<br />
argumentofor Europeans jn defence bf an ever growing<br />
evil amongst them, but at the ~me time it is<br />
constantly dinne4 into our ears that the European<br />
civilisation is far advanced. The fact is that while<br />
the Indian civilisation is rising the European is<br />
sinking lJecause the Indian is working towards the<br />
abolition of a deep-rooted evil whioh the lilutopaan<br />
t. apRl\rontlr too !!6Ber to adopt. '
INDIAN OPINION' May 22nd, 1925<br />
Of course Oxford and these places are also monuments<br />
of the real European civilisation that teach vent to personal grudge even at the cost of the<br />
work of the Congl'es, and not only th,lt but to give<br />
the principle of equality but they too ~ppear to have<br />
community's honour. At a time when WI:' are<br />
grown too old for our South African intellectuals<br />
who would rather have the superiority stunt taught fighting for our rights With the authol'ities it grie\ e8<br />
than the equality. But'Indlans cannot be expected us much to say some bltter words to some of 0111'<br />
to unlearn what,they have already learnt.<br />
own brethren who clal-m to be educated and yet<br />
cannot realIse the harm they are doing to their /<br />
-fellow-countrymen by cl'e.lting fnction am on gilt<br />
Another taunt to the Indians by the ]Jlf3rcttry<br />
through its "Man in the Moon" columns is that themselves wlth base motiv('s, The eXisting COIllmittee,<br />
however obstinate it may be to carryon Its<br />
"they (the Indians) changed their minds as much as<br />
any woman could." We should be grateful to the work, has at nQ time represented the community<br />
"Man" for tl:ij.s at~vlC,e whlCh should serve as a gUlde and it does not now represent the cOllllllunity an
May 22nd. 1925 INDIAN OPINION 13 1<br />
a1.low it. the Prince will readily and as heartily condl'scend<br />
to accept the reception. Hut unless the<br />
Indians are united such a thing is not conceivable<br />
and even if it were they could not and would not<br />
sllcleed.<br />
NATAL I~DIANS AND VOTE<br />
'rh~ yearly votel'il roll will be pUblished shortly<br />
in all the Municipahties and Townships of Natal.<br />
This mOHt important right of Indians baH been taken<br />
Ilwsy by the pa88ing of the Municipal Consolidated<br />
Ordinance and the Townshipill Ordinance. Counsels<br />
opinion has already been obtained by the officials of<br />
the Natalllldian Congress, which is favourable to.<br />
wards Indians cause. It is intended to dispute the<br />
right of the local Provincial Authorities in the form<br />
of a test ease.<br />
Qualifications required for a Voter are as follows;<br />
(1) Owner of Landed Property in a Borough or a<br />
Township. e.<br />
(2) A tenant paying a yearly rental of £10, or<br />
more.<br />
We al"e requested by tile officials of the Congress<br />
to inform the Indian pu blic that all Indians having<br />
the necessary qnalifications will see that If they are<br />
on the last years roll that their names goes on to the<br />
new voters roll. Those Indians not on the roll but<br />
having the quahfications are asked to submit their<br />
names to the local authorities or make necessal:y inquil'ies<br />
through the following gentlemen, who in<br />
due course are asked to communicate with the Head<br />
Office of Congre88, P. O. Box G70, Durban.<br />
DURBAN-Mr. V. S. C. P.
132 INDIAN OPINION May 22nd, 1925<br />
Yve<br />
of it.<br />
That Mr. Beyers himself has some doubts as to its<br />
ultimate wisdom and is not without some twinges<br />
of politillal conscience seems indicated by his concluding<br />
remarks. - Although lie is "more than ever<br />
convinced that the Government is acting on right<br />
lines" he frankly confessed that "he looked forward<br />
to a time when such legislation would be rendered<br />
unneoessary by the force of circumstances." The<br />
inference is that in Mr. Beyers's' opinion the draft<br />
Bill is rendered necessary by circumstances to-day.<br />
What is the justification for this view? The Minister<br />
of Mines declares (1) that "the argument that a<br />
colour bar should not be put into a statute but<br />
should be enforced by custom is an unworthy one";<br />
and (2) that "it was absurd to Mly on the good will<br />
of the Chamber of Mines." as regards the first<br />
point, we can see nothing unworthy in 3 dlaincli~a.,)<br />
tion on the part of a Governlllent 01' a Parliament<br />
to take legislative cognisance of custom, wh~ther<br />
trade custo~ or otherwise. The less the LegislatuTe<br />
irite~feres in these matters the better, jf only ,on the<br />
principle of letting ~sleeping dog'i lie. There are<br />
variQus customs bearing \1Pon the employment anu<br />
relations of white and naQve labour in all parts of<br />
South AfrICa, but no one in his senses luts eve!' sug.<br />
gested that these cuetoml'l, whether of' the taetorYI
May und, 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
the workshop, the garage. the stable, the fields or the<br />
boutlchold, should receive fltatutory sanction. This<br />
was one reason why in th~ Act of HIll the qU('tltion<br />
of the c01l>ur pat ,Walt left. to he dealt with Ly regulation.<br />
We oUJ'l!elves did not approve even of that<br />
method of dealing with it, but it was infinitely preferable<br />
to the method now adopted by the Governmellt.<br />
In the United Htatcs, where there is much<br />
l;t!!er coloured population than in South Africa, no<br />
i_ ..,ll c()lonr bar exist!!, either by L'lW or ,regulation,<br />
but ,in practice cer~in occupations arc usually reserved<br />
for Europeans and others for coloured men<br />
in mixed. com~tlnititlS. Neitb,er in AJnerica nor in<br />
South Africa is a large employer of labour going to<br />
risk; serious trouble with his men, with attendant<br />
lOBS and, i~efficienc'y, by flagrantly disregarding<br />
custom and pnbhc opinion in matters of this kind.<br />
As regards :Mr. Deyers's second point. we can only<br />
repeat what We have just said, and add that subsequent<br />
events have ampl~ confirmed the statement<br />
we made ill 1!}23. In commenting on the HUdick<br />
Bmitn calle~ wa wrote: "The ratio of white to coloUl'ad<br />
is not likely to be disturbed. . . " The<br />
trades apd industries in the Transvaal In which the<br />
largest proportion of white laqour is employed have<br />
never come under these colour bar regulations at<br />
all. . . In the case of the mines there has been<br />
a colour bar of sorts ever since the Anglo-Boer War<br />
and before it, a\ld w~ venture Ito pre~icj. that this<br />
colo'ur bar of custom and conveni~nce will not<br />
apprec;iably be \\ffec;tlld hy the Supreme Court's<br />
decision." , bur preiIlction was right. The.. ratio on<br />
the minps tQ-~y js m()re favourable fQr Europeans<br />
than it was before the colour bar regulations were<br />
declared ultra vires.<br />
With ~egard to Mr. Delers's Qt;her statewents l ~va<br />
can only refer him t6 the ferms of Mr. Justic'e<br />
Krap.ae'a J,u~ment "i1\ Nov~tp.be~., ~923. R~flIJing<br />
to the law of 18t1.3 he said that while it ditterentmted<br />
aga~ the llatilp peca~se of hi~ lack of ~viUsation,<br />
in pollcy it "seemed to contemplate his gradual<br />
emancipation," wherpas "the polic.y of the rtlguIa~<br />
tion" (the policy which the Government now proposes<br />
to extriuJ and to make statutory) "deprived<br />
the natJve from enjoying the very fruits of his<br />
advancement," ,.In other words, the majority in the<br />
Union Parliament to-day is proposing to do something<br />
f
134 __________________ I_N_D __ IA_N __ o~P-IN--IO-N------------M~ay--2-2n-d-,-1_92_5 __<br />
\<br />
\ News in Brief<br />
Writmg in rOlmg Ind!a on the pl'actice of Indian<br />
National Congress organisations to accept money<br />
in lieu ,of yarn for membership, Mr. Gandhi says ;<br />
As a member myself and as Editor, I have no<br />
hesitation in saying that the practice is illegal.<br />
Whether it is so in fact or not, only the Working<br />
Oommittee can decide. I have no desire as "'President<br />
to give rulings 'in such matters, but as a common<br />
Sense man writing for a commonsense people, I<br />
remind the' Congress-men that the idea of importing<br />
mbney payment as an alternative was discllssed and<br />
rejected. __<br />
H. H. tJ\e Maharaja of Gaekar came to the throne in<br />
May 1875 and the 50th anniversary of that 'event<br />
falls on' 27th May 1925. As His Highness is in<br />
Europe: the Golden Jubilee. cannot be celebrated this<br />
summer. The I .. egislative Council has passed a<br />
resolution to celebrate the Golden Jubileo this year<br />
when HlS Highness may be in Barodl!.<br />
The Bombay Chronicle says that a strange child has<br />
been born at Multan with two heads, two noses, fmw<br />
eyes and four ears with only one body. :people l!-re<br />
flocking to seE' the strange child.<br />
It is annonnced that Sir George Lloyd has accepted<br />
the offer of the High CommIssionership of.<br />
Egypt in successioQ to Lord Allenby.<br />
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA.<br />
(WITWATERSRAND LOCAL DIVISION).<br />
BEFOl!.E THE I{ONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEW AAL<br />
JOHANNESBURG, Monday, the 18th day of May 1 1925.<br />
In the matter between :-<br />
THE TRUSTEE IN THE INSOLVENT ESTATE OF<br />
LEWIS WALTER RICH.<br />
. ApPLICANT.<br />
and<br />
HAJEE SULIMAN AHMED ABED, MAHOMED<br />
SULlMAN KATHRADA, AMOD SULIMAN<br />
ASWAT, SULIMAN AMOn BAKHARIA, MOOSA<br />
MAHOMED MOOTAWALI and MAHOMED<br />
'ESSOPJI BULRULIA.<br />
RESPO~E~TS.<br />
Upon the motion of Mr. N, E. Rosenberg, of<br />
Counsel. for the Applicant and upon reading the<br />
Petition filed.<br />
IT Is ORDERED :-<br />
1. That a Rule Nisi be, and is hereby, issued<br />
calling upon the Respondents to shew canSt" i(any,<br />
in this Cpurt on the 9th day of June, Ul25, why<br />
they should not hand over the 'l'itIe Deeds in respect<br />
of Stand No. 4192 in the Township of Johannesburg, '<br />
formerly No. 120, Township of Burgersdol'p, to the<br />
Trustee in the Insolvent Estate of LEWIS WALTER<br />
RITCH, failing which or in the alternative, why the<br />
Rand Townships RegistI-ar shall not issue dUPlicate<br />
Title Deeds in respect of the property aforemen<br />
'tioned.<br />
2. ,That service of this Rule Nisi be effected by<br />
publication once in an Indian Newspaper, circuJating<br />
in Johannesburg and once in the Uni(}n Gau:tte.<br />
By order of the Court,<br />
(Sgd.) J. C. HlNSB1!:ECK.<br />
Registrar.<br />
Brie R. Ritch.<br />
Applicant's Attorney,<br />
14/16, Asher's Buildings,<br />
Joubert Street, Johannesburg.<br />
NOTICE<br />
Nation and Languag~<br />
,<br />
A Lectur~ on the above Subject will be<br />
delivered by Pundit Bhawani Dayal, Edito;:"<br />
," Hindi" Jacobs, at the M. K. Gandh{<br />
Library and Parsee Rustomje~ Hall, 140,<br />
,Queen Street, Durban, on Monday the<br />
25th May at 7 p.m. sharp.<br />
Public are kindly requested to attend.<br />
O. H. A. JHAVBRI,<br />
Chairman.<br />
B. M. PATEL.<br />
Secretary.<br />
'The M. K. Gandhi library and Parsec<br />
Rustomjee Han Committee<br />
(\l~"Ut ~~ ~ ~';\ ~llle(l:t ~i~r\l ~l(\<br />
etl!it 't.~o ~~r\ :ttll.lll ~l~al' ~ ~ll.<br />
l. ~ll~ ~u~~~ ~!\ "l'
~ ndiatt (fJ pitt inn<br />
No. 22-Vol. XXIII. Friday, May 29th, 1925.<br />
R.e,.sured ., the G_ P. o •••• N •• spa,"<br />
1'.'cs 1'0u ....... ,.<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
~l"<br />
T liE following f.·om the Datll/ Herald will be two Indian 'bus driver;! were charged, one with<br />
11 educative to those who profeSB to be well- having stopped in a posItion other than one of those<br />
willhers of tbe British Empire and think they specified under the regulations, and the other with<br />
are working k\wards its solidification but are actually traverlling streets in which Indian 'bus traffic was<br />
we,,-king towards its ruination :- not allowed under these same regulations. Mr.<br />
The events in India and Egypt have brought us Mitchel, who appeared for both the ac and Indians in Kenya has i?een<br />
reached in the elections fO,r, and the first meeting of,<br />
the new Municipal Council says a Nairobi report.<br />
The European community actually produced ten<br />
candidates for five seats, and heavy polling took<br />
place. Those elected, in a ~eeting With the Indiall<br />
members, voted another European as the eleventh<br />
Councillor, thus ensuring a European nmjol-lty in a<br />
fully attentled Council. No Indian was proposed as<br />
the new Mayor, but a gt:eat efIQct was matle to make<br />
all Indian Deputy l\I,wor, and this was only defeated<br />
l)y the casting vote of the newly-elected Mayor.<br />
Thus Europeans have won the first skirmish, but<br />
the narrow majority proves that the IndIans Will<br />
win th~ day if the white Councillors get sl.\ck.<br />
Replying to Sir Robel't Hamilton (Libel'''!) in the,<br />
Hom!6 of Commons, the Hon, Qrmsby-Gore, Undt'rl:)eCl'tltary<br />
for the Colonies, said in accordance with<br />
the decil,ion set forth in a White Paper in July,<br />
192:1, areas had been reserved in Lowbnds of Kenya<br />
"with a view to ascertaining the Iudi,lUs' demand for<br />
'agricultural laud. The matter was in a swte of suspenSlOn<br />
pending the examination of the land by representatives<br />
of local Indian interests and the Gov<br />
E'rnment of Iudi'l, or both. He was not aware thdt<br />
the Government of ~lJia had taken any action in<br />
the mat.tel'.<br />
'<br />
A peculiar judgment waS given in the DIu-ban<br />
Court by Mr, U. U, Wallace iu the c.lses in wh.ich<br />
asked for a remand m order that he might have<br />
tlme to look up authorities on the subject_ He<br />
intimated that he would endeavour to prove that<br />
the municipal by-law was directly opposed to the<br />
statute that on the payment of the general hcence of<br />
£1 the owner of a car could travel in any pat-t of<br />
the Province_ For the purposes of his case, he was<br />
going to argue that Durban was part of the Provmce.<br />
He would also challenge the validity of<br />
making the additional tax retrospectiYe. In this<br />
case the actual tax had been paid in January last,<br />
and the additional tax was passed on Feb. 18. "It<br />
should not," he contended, "have come into force<br />
until January, 1926."<br />
May 2!.l,<br />
Remand was granted until<br />
• The total number of deaths during the month of<br />
March in the Borough of Durban were 79 of which<br />
3:3 were European and ao Asiatic and the rest Col<br />
OUl'tld and Native. Cases of infectious disease<br />
totalled 38 of which 27 were Eurgpean and.t Asiatic<br />
and the remaining were imported and Coloured and<br />
N,ltive.<br />
Total revenue from the Inditm }'lo\rket for the<br />
mouth of 1\1"rch W,lS £1,012 3:3_ ld. an incl·ease of<br />
£277, /'is. 1d. as compared WIth the corresponding<br />
month of !a.st year. .<br />
Revenue received by the Corporation during the<br />
month of ~fdrch from Natives totals £7-149 6s. Id.<br />
of which £-1547 !.ls. 9J.. is del'ived from the &l,le of<br />
beer. '<br />
Preaching at the Clifton Wesley'an Clx11rch, Johannesburg,<br />
recently on the "Statesmanship of<br />
Missions," the Rev. J. GIyndwr Davies is reported<br />
to have stated that mission work was never more<br />
needed in Africa than at the present time. He was<br />
!Uraul the black m.m had ~" fai,th in the white<br />
~ .~~ .:> ""
INDIAN ()~INt()N<br />
man, and the ~\l'ty of the (Jhurch wl1~ \Q ilee V~at he<br />
-lid n,ot lose fa}t.h il), the w!;lite ml!-'Q.'s re,li~on. "The<br />
!lJ.i~~on tie}d W.day f~qu)res ~l thJ;l best FIilQ and<br />
;W0Plell- ~v,~~lab\e becll:,!se t!J.e respons)l>ility lS ~eat,"<br />
he I?(l,id. W 9 J'eq~ir.~ a t~\le allq ~ne inlerIlfetation<br />
of the Gospel. We must plant a,t this sf!lge of the<br />
economical, social and spiritual transition in the<br />
native life the best Christian ideas and ideals."<br />
'TJter!~ FllTy t}V~ t.p.t:lt~ t4~t played s.tr?p,gly 2~ t~~<br />
lives of the natives in'this continent-the Mahomedan,<br />
like an avalanche from the north, with all his<br />
corrupting influences, and the W.l,~.,tlJ' }:n W1tlve<br />
centres, who frequently showe4 ID"Qe(! ~njl «;l i~ ct;lI~!li
~ principle!,! of justice and fairplay. It is ~n ev~ry<br />
.}.tY elPcl'icnce of l1lany anunfortulWte Indi,m and<br />
'it is merely by a stroke of luck tlwt an isolated<br />
case readies the Courts of justice. What is noteworLhy<br />
is that whenever sueh a ca'>Cl has rel}cbed<br />
the Courts of justice it ha'! almost illvariabJycaus~d<br />
.<br />
s~vere criticism to' be passeq against the Immigf!l~n<br />
,. Department. .This would prove the rotll'uness<br />
of the ways of the Dopartment. Each such<br />
criticism, althoQgp has not the effec~ aD, the Depar~<br />
meut Whose hi~l1-handedness ~s aa -.bad a~ ever is<br />
~evertheless worth recording,<br />
•<br />
,Hi<br />
Wallaub all£>l£ei.! that hp hal! bef!U in SOllt4 AfrlCJ.<br />
'20 years. aner Wallabh, was described in the Supreme aud c9unsel described'the action of the official as<br />
pouli to-daY. illeg~l. The alllount was subsequently subscribed<br />
I Accordillg to Wallabh, he had been domiciled by Wallabh't! friends, I;>ut was then rejected.<br />
in t\le country since 1902, and it was not until he f'l cannot understand the ImmigratIon Departc\aiO'!ed<br />
,flOO aJ:'rears of wages from a eompatriot, ment at all," o\Jserved Mr" Justice Gardiner, comtllat<br />
tJil! r~ght to be heJ:'e was questioned. His debtor, menting on tbe absence of affidavits from the<br />
he) a'l~ge(l. gave false'information about him to the authptities. "Ii frequently acts in the most un-<br />
ImmigraUOl\ Department, who promptly arrested reasonable manner anq gives the Court no assistance<br />
l;\\~ ~nq proceeded to ship him to India as a pro-, at all. It is the mo:;!t high-handed department 1<br />
~ib\teq immigrant. 'l'he ship had already left when<br />
hi,S attorn~Yil lluccee
whole questiOn, and it it is at all possible I hope to<br />
introduee the measure right at the end of the session.<br />
Mr. Nel (S.A.P., Klip 'River) : Cannot you, publish'the<br />
Bill before the end of the session:<br />
The Minister: No. It is not ready.<br />
INDIAN OPINION - May 29th, 1925 {!<br />
with Lord MiJ.leton. The btter was a C~llege-chun::~1<br />
of the "superior pnrzon," but in abihty he was fal] \ If<br />
inferior to hIS friend. But by a strange freak ot ,'}.,<br />
fortune when Cllrzon was India's mighty MogUII;,,~<br />
over the head of this Mogul WaS sitting in WhitehallLw<br />
Mr. St. John Brodrick as Lord 1I1ldleton then W,18:'W<br />
the Secretary of State for India' What a gt'caIJ'J'<br />
LORD CURZON AND' SANJ V ARTMAN' humiliation for so "great" a Vicllroy to tdke hia I<br />
Following is an article from San) Vartman on Lord orders from one whom he looked down upon t!; his I : I<br />
inferior in every posslble way?, Friction, umlell.d<br />
Curzon:-<br />
l<br />
In many respects tl}e late Lord Curzon was- a such circumstances, was inevitable and this develop I ,VI,<br />
puzzlin.i p~rsonality. Genius he had, no doubt. He ing with the course of time ended in open enmity Ii L<br />
had Elllergy, he had pl!lCk and, above all, he had No wonder, in the quarrel that soon d!'veloped l)el t<br />
what is po,pularly c~ned an inexhaustiblsamoun! of tween the Viceroy and the late Lord Kitchener, th4t f<br />
cheek. He was the son of a British pe~r-though Secretary 'of State sided with the Commander-in I,,,'<br />
that peer was a clergyman and poor-but he rectified Chief, aud ~urzon had to leave India, as we 11.1.,<br />
the fatal mistake of, being bom pOOr by mal'1'Y'ing-a know, in a most ignominious mann!'r. Lord Curzom:'j<br />
rich American heiress. At the very threshold of his never excused Brodrick for this official defeat ~n(j,<br />
life he found sy:tD.pathetic _ponsors to baok pim up in his pompously childish fashion he il.i8ued hill<br />
in his fu,tm'e political career, and aided by his own magniloquent proclamation that henceforth Wher(!l"<br />
" , h 1 k' the mighty Lord Curzon condesc"ended to attend Mrl4<br />
,talents and personal gIl ~~ear y made a mar III St. John Brodrick must be absent! This showef,~,<br />
the House of Commons, a very stern and discerning.<br />
critic of aspirmg politicltl debutants. His friend!; most conclusively that Lord "Curzon WdS incapabl,lll{<br />
found him a "sincere pat.riot. He was warm-hearted,' of rising superior to petty jealousies and quarrelf'l'J<br />
transparent almost naive, indomitable in effprt and Seven years of "mogulilJm" in Inuia hau SPOil~lt"~1<br />
very loyal to hisJriends. When in lively mood he him and in England though he lived subsequentl )['<br />
was the best of good company and would keep J1 for nearly twenty years he was like a fi~h out !,<br />
woole dinner-party in laught~ and ,admiration at_ water. Mr. Lloyd George spoke well when he 8.Li Je,)<br />
his brilliant ~llies." A.ud yet strange to say, with "George Nathaniel Curzon may suit the mild Hind~I)1<br />
d but not England." But Curzou did not perhapi L<br />
all thIS sup,erabundancc of personal chal'1ll of hea realise that his inordinate vanity, his self-consciou~~»<br />
and heart George Nathalian Curzon, was III the<br />
practical contse-,nf, his'life, a failure. "He never ness, anri his vaunting ambition to shine above al II ,<br />
brought off anything successful. In Indla at first - and at all times, were so many naIls in the coffin 0 I<br />
, his life's failure. There is no doubt, that he wante')r<br />
with great ideas for th':} benefit of the native races, to serve his Qountry, but he wdnted to serve himsell'l1<br />
he alienated the Engljsh populatIOn, and, later, in° at the same time. He, in fact, wanted to serve tWit<br />
attempts to conCIliate Anglo-Indian opinion, he masters and ended by serving neither well. Whelr~<br />
alisnated -all the native feeling. He became the very aeronautics was not so well developed he wanted t, L$<br />
type of the prancing pro-consul, with a kjnd of in- fly and little wonder, he soon came to grief. Thal'l'\<br />
soJence and- ar!,ogance, of speech which lost him the was the real secret of his failure. , '<br />
~atitude he desarved for much genuine bard work"<br />
and many efforts, of p~manent value. )t was to<br />
have been the most brilliant reign that India had<br />
ever I!leen, But on his departure ther~ was none S(l<br />
poor as to do him reverence, and even the usual<br />
native ceremonial farewell was boycotted. lIistory<br />
will trace from this disastrous rule all those increasing<br />
storms of unrest and discontent which have<br />
made India an abnost desperate problem." This is<br />
an accurate thumb-nail snmmary of Lord Curzon's<br />
character, but it doe':! not say in waat way or by the<br />
POSSession of what fatal quality so lavishly endowed<br />
a man failed in life and, brought disaster to everything<br />
,that he j;ouched. We think the ego in' him<br />
was inordinately developed. He 'was feverishly selfconscious.<br />
'EarlY' sUCCess had spoiled, Jiim and -the<br />
constant homage paid to his genius. had turned his<br />
'head. 'Like the constitutional courtesy,that prompts<br />
fu! to' say 'that the "King does no c wrong," he had,<br />
by his early success in life, had -come to believe that<br />
George Nathalian CurlllOn, too, can do nothing wrong.<br />
He had a genuine love for the Ea,st, no doubt. But<br />
it was a selfish love. For him, a kindly God had<br />
created the whole East for the' sole purpose of expiQitingfLord-Cu~zon's<br />
supeJ'ior genius! The East,<br />
for him, ,was a vast playing ground for~his own selfglorification<br />
with India as a happy hunting-ground<br />
for the mighty Jupiter to hurl his devastating<br />
thunderbolts at the poor and meek mortals of this<br />
under-world. -Lord Curwn, even in his Oxford<br />
days, was a "very superior purzon" and all his life<br />
he walked erect with hls head always touching the<br />
clouds. And here we find the true key of Lord<br />
Curzon's failure. Arrogance was the dominating<br />
rule of his life. It was this al'l'ogance that kept him<br />
apart fro~ his fellow men and though a loveable<br />
Dlan in his own way, h.e was more feared than loved<br />
by those who came in tusiness contact with him.<br />
Everyone ~ow knows the personal quarrel he had<br />
CECIL RHODES A"N'D ASIAN INDEPENDImC:;d<br />
, I<br />
Af~er describing the imperialistic aims of Ceed<br />
Rhodes in The Chinese Student~' Montld!!, Dr. Taral.· Jf<br />
nath Das observes .- - :<br />
Cecil Rhodes held that it is the will of God tw; J<br />
Great Bl'itain through the co-operation of the UniW)[~<br />
States of America and through the superior genilitrt<br />
of the Anglo-Saxon peoples would dominate tJ1" ,<br />
world for justice, peace and liberty. We find tmJ J<br />
Great Britain is ruhng India and dominating majt(.It<br />
parts of Asia and other sections of the world keef"~<br />
ing hundreds of millions of people nnder subjectimiJ:)<br />
denying simple justice and freedom; and we c
_ ~~y _2.9th J _1~25 INDIAN OPINION 139<br />
----------- --------------------:~well-calclllatf'd<br />
manner, particularly by spreading<br />
p,lucation, and with the co-operation of all peoples<br />
Dnder flubjection to !lecure freedom of the oppressed<br />
people" of the world? A few Cecil Rho,le.! of new<br />
typ£' are hadly need£'(l in all countries of ASia awi<br />
Africa. They should inscnbe in their heart, the<br />
ideal of Asian independence, equal opportnnity and<br />
III} discrimination against any peoplf', bN!llul'e of<br />
rac p • to be achieved through concerteJ action in all<br />
pa~~ of the world.<br />
'1'heir ideal cannot be achieved within a year or<br />
two nor can it be achie\'ed by mer£'ly delivering<br />
speecht's. by adopting resolutions 01' by rousing<br />
racial bitterness between the F.ast and the West.<br />
... Life-Iong consecration to the ideal. untiring work<br />
,to 8pr~ the Irospt'l of freedom, augmenting wealth<br />
!by deveolping national intelligence and efficit'ncy.<br />
industrial and economic strength and proper inter-<br />
. national understandings are needed to win the<br />
victory. None with a light heart and hasty judg<br />
,ment should respond to thiB call. Only those who<br />
have a vision and sllstained energy should undertake<br />
to perform the duty of crowning humon freedom<br />
through many-sided activitie&-World Peace<br />
with Justice and Liberty tn All Peoples to be<br />
Achieved Through Asian Independence.<br />
~~~!I<br />
:,"S RETURN<br />
(By :MR. ~ F. ANDREW~ IN .. YOUNG INDIA"<br />
At the time when e poet, Rabindranath Tagore'<br />
left Inllia fOI' South America in September, 1924, we<br />
had very great anxiety about his health. In China,<br />
earlier in the year, when- I was wit..~ him, I had<br />
witneslied his extreme weakness. But the invitation<br />
that had. come from South America asking for his<br />
presence as the representative of! Asia at the<br />
Centenary of South American Independence, outweighed<br />
with him all considerations o( physical in-<br />
J firmity. The spirit was willing, even though the<br />
physical body was aU too weak., _<br />
With an eagerness that astonished us all, he<br />
hastened on from Europe by the earliest 'pol58ible<br />
steamer and arrived at Buenos Aires very early in<br />
, November. although the {lantanary celebration was<br />
I not to be held until December 10th. He felt that<br />
any stay in Europe, where the crowd would preM<br />
upon him. might consume what little strength hehad<br />
and make the further voyage to South America<br />
impossible.<br />
In the middle of the stormy Atlantic Ocean he<br />
wrote in Bengali a remarkable poem. He refers to<br />
this in a letter, which he hail written to me; and he<br />
~13S given me permill8ion to publish it. When I<br />
received the letter. with its poem, I recalled at once<br />
the hymn, which we had been singing again and<br />
again at Delhi during the fast:<br />
The pathway of the T..ord is to be trodden by<br />
" heroes; it is not meant for the timi(t:<br />
, ...... He that would drink the cup of the Lord<br />
mUilt abandon his all.<br />
In his letter he told me that at the time of writing<br />
he was visited with a u-rrible oppresl5ion of soul.<br />
more mental than physical, and his poem revews the<br />
p'!:thway of release that he found.<br />
The Tempest.' It runs as follows:-<br />
'. , Half asleep on the shore,<br />
.<br />
' -<br />
You dreaded the voice of the Tempest.<br />
When he thundered in your ears his.'No.'<br />
.~• .j You had said to one another,<br />
That the store had its plenty,<br />
The house had its comfort.- -<br />
When suddenly, grinding his flashing ~th,<br />
The Tempest growled. 'No.'<br />
But I made the Tem\,est my comrade,<br />
and left my shore,<br />
'<br />
He has named it<br />
With tny ship tossing on the sea.<br />
I hal'e trtllted the rettible.<br />
I h". 811e4 !D, W1a with btl bteatb,<br />
An,l my heart with his assurance,<br />
- that the shore is there.<br />
He crit'll to me : "8 vagrant you are, even as I.<br />
Yictory to you ?"<br />
Things are s1!attered to pieces, scattered by the<br />
wind.<br />
The timid murmur i. despair:<br />
"This is the end of Time !"<br />
The Tempest cries: "Only that remains.<br />
Which is utterly given away."<br />
With trust in him, I march forward:<br />
I look not back,<br />
While the hoarded heap is swept away by the<br />
-&od •<br />
My traveller's reed iii tuned<br />
With the tune of his ioud laughter.<br />
It sings: .. Away with the lures of desire,<br />
With bonds that are fixed,<br />
With achievement that is past,<br />
And hope that is idle. -<br />
Learn, for. your drum, the dance of the reckless<br />
waves,<br />
.Beating against the rocks.<br />
Away with greed and fear,<br />
And Power's banner borne by slaves.<br />
Come, divine Destruction,<br />
Drag us away from the house,<br />
Lead qs away from safety's path,<br />
Come with the flutter of your wings of death,<br />
Spread upon the wind your cry, 'No.'<br />
No rest, no languor, no ease,<br />
No load of feebleness weighing down the<br />
head.<br />
Knock and break open the miser's door I<br />
Scatter away the gloom of storage!<br />
Banish the self distrust,<br />
that seeks a whole wherein to hide,<br />
Let your trumpet proclaim in the wind<br />
Your terrible, 'No.'<br />
"I Every time that I have read over this poem, it<br />
has brought back to my mind, by some inner asRO- ?? ,<br />
~a:ti~canthe days of the faat at Delhi and thee,·oI.~~II.Mt.<br />
ne ymn that have still in my own recollection.<br />
especially aStlOCiated with it. Tht're are also the<br />
parallel words of Christ, which have gained an<br />
added meaning for me each year as I have grown<br />
older.<br />
, "He that will save his life sb.'\ll lose it,<br />
But he that loseth his life, the same shall save it."<br />
After the poet. Rabindranath Tagore. had reached<br />
the Argentine Republic his health failed him again.<br />
The kindly people of that country treated him with<br />
the utmost consideration and conrtesy. Seeing how<br />
ill he was, they demanded nothing from him except<br />
that he would remain in their conntry and get better.<br />
, They came to him for spiritual comfort and he was<br />
very happy with them. '<br />
The same thing qccurred over a.,aain in Italy, after<br />
his return to Europe. He appeared only once in<br />
public, at Milan; and after that he was obliged to be<br />
in bed for many days. The doctors at last consented<br />
that he should go back to the warmer and sunnier<br />
climate of his own motherland for a short time. A<br />
sea voyage is to him the greatest restorative of all,<br />
and he is a splendid sailor. But the doctors urged<br />
very strongly indeed. that he show,", not spend the<br />
'hot weather this year in a tropical clima~ A home<br />
is waiting for him near Bellagio, on lake COmo, in<br />
northern Italy, and our earnt'JIt prayers and hopes<br />
are, that with perfect repose, in one of the most,<br />
restful places in the world, he may regain his<br />
physical strength and give the world c.nce more<br />
some new poems of matchless beauty.<br />
,<br />
WORDS OF THE WISE<br />
When a man gives yon a piece of his mind, give<br />
him in return only a piece of your heart.<br />
'there ia a waf that 1IeGl:t18tb right unto II mad. btrt<br />
the e%!4 thereof are tb' .,. CfI 'eatb -
INDIA IN IMPERIAL PARLIAMENT<br />
'The Earl of BiI'kenhead, Secretary for India,<br />
moved the second reading of ~ne Government of<br />
Ihdia (CIvil Servioes) Bill, which he said would<br />
haVe great consequences in India. The provisions<br />
of the Bill wer1:) limited in scope. bnt they were<br />
essential if the Government were to carry ont the<br />
declsi'On already arnlOnllC(fcl to accept and put into<br />
force the main recommendatIons' of the Royal Commission<br />
on the Superior Orltil SEll'vices in India, presided<br />
over by I.ord Lee of Farehit'I:tI. The recommendations<br />
aimed on the one hand at re1I1oving<br />
certrdu anxIeties, financial and otherwi1!E:1, from the<br />
services,\and, on ~he ~the~ hand, s~tisfYitl.? Indian<br />
opinion that the prinOlples tlnderlymg- the ~eform<br />
Scheme wou:ld'De observed in the ServICes. 'fhe recommendations<br />
wel~e a deliberate compromIse /between<br />
the Indian point of view and Service opihlOn.<br />
No useful purpose was gaIned by Ignoring the fact<br />
that thete we)~e ,two poInts of' view ·~tnid which<br />
those who were responsible for the Government of<br />
India, whether m India or in 'thifl country, must<br />
~teer a prudent middle courSe. The recom1I1etldations<br />
which blmefitteli the Services were tile granting<br />
of small mcreases in overseas ptty ahd issning<br />
overseas pay in sterling at 2s. a .rupee as a rit'otectlOn<br />
against the fluctUating rate- of ef(change. That<br />
meant an additwn of about £135 a year to the pay<br />
of an officer iti the middle yeai's of his liIervice. In<br />
the seoond place, there was an iUCl'ease efl:~cted In<br />
the pensions of members of the uncovenanted ServiceS<br />
from 5,000 rupees (£437 lOs.) to 6,000' rupees<br />
(£525) for 25 yeitrlil' service, and ft'om 6,QOO rupees<br />
to 7,000 rupees for 30 yeats' servitle. Thet'e was a<br />
grant to all officers of non-Asiatic domltl11e in the<br />
conrse of theIr service of four return first-class<br />
passages and one sihgle passage for ('ath child. The<br />
total cost of the relief under the various heads<br />
w6uld be oue ctote of rupees, 01' £150,000 a Ye.1r. -<br />
The atlCeleratetLlndianisation of the Servicel:! was<br />
accepttJd as !Ii prinmple with a VlliIW to producing, in '<br />
the case of IndIan Oivil Service recl'tlits, a cMre onehalf<br />
E~'ropean and one-half Indilln. In 1924 Iudians<br />
iii the Indi.an Civil Service constituted 17 per<br />
cent. of the toml number of officers. Ih the police<br />
the percentage was 11. Although.time alone co~'Lld<br />
show, an increase of Irldfans in 15 3 r ears in the Clvi1<br />
Service and'in 25 yeat's in the -ponce to 50 bel' cent.,<br />
should not prove too ~api:d progress. The pOl:!slbility<br />
of maintaill1ng that b!1lance and relying< on -it to<br />
provide a eoilipeterlt and reliable civil administration<br />
in In'iha must dep~nd on the cbhtribut(ofl by<br />
Great BrItaih of the very bi3s~ of the young men<br />
produced, by her schools and univel'sitieli. Ilis<br />
greatestaml!ety at the present moment, looking at<br />
the matter in cool perspective, was not mOYllments<br />
arrd tendilncies in India, grave and- menacing as<br />
some.of them, had beenl hut tua fact that the finest<br />
CivIl Service il'l the world .had snown, e!in~e 1914,<br />
m!l.ny, signs of liick of iln);tulal'ity. We should nevel'<br />
have kept our. position In In4ia had It not, been for<br />
thG' dev_otionj abihty, and c.haracte~\of the Givil.$.et'.<br />
vice. He could not e1rpla.in why tI!.e attractlOri'
®piuinn<br />
No. 23-VoJ, XXIII. Friday, June 5th. 1925.<br />
Reg.'terellallhe G,P.O. as a Newspaper<br />
PaIC. "OOIl'EN~.<br />
IHI<br />
of Parties, I feel confident of an assured and honour-<br />
able p1lCe for her in the Councils of the Elllpire.<br />
IS Highness the Maharajah of Kutch, who<br />
in 1921 represented India on the League of<br />
Nations, an(l Sir John l,ane Harrington,<br />
formerly an otlicer in the Indian Army, are<br />
arranging an expedition to Africa, for the purpose<br />
of big game shooting and making scientific collectionll<br />
for the Royal Geographical Society and the<br />
Natural History Museum. The party, which will<br />
include Lady Hat'rington, will [tart from Khartoum,<br />
apd proceed first. to l\Iongalla, return t9 the<br />
~abat River, and explore the Ajuba River. 'fhen<br />
it will ascend the Baro River as far as possible,<br />
after -which the expedition will attempt to motor<br />
-to Kassal via Rossires. The expedItion WIll be<br />
~uipped with a shallow draught and fast motor<br />
boat, and three caterpillar cars, ,complete with wireless<br />
installation. The actual journey in Central<br />
Africa will oCl;lupy about three months.<br />
Speaking recently at the ceremony of the laying<br />
of the corner-stone of Y. M. C. A., Madura, the Rt.<br />
Hon. ~rinivasa Sastci fn the oourse of his speech is<br />
reported to have said ~-"In England I have often<br />
been to the institution popularly known as Shake<br />
"peare Hut, but whose real name is Indian Students'<br />
Union and Hostel mainhined by the y, M. ,C. A.<br />
A good deal has been said by slanderous tongues<br />
about SOlne thing or other attaching to the work for<br />
~he students done by that institution. 'There is<br />
absolutely no foundation whatever for any criticism<br />
of the character that one hears now and I have<br />
always esteemed it a great privilege to be able to<br />
recommend this institution so useful,' 60 indispensable<br />
and. really so conducive for the modern<br />
spiritual welfare of the hundreds and. thousands of<br />
our young men)Vho find themselves adrift, nearly<br />
helpless, in London. I say I have always be-en<br />
proud and I have esteemed it a privileg& to bear<br />
testimony to the absolutely unsectarian and cosmopolitan:<br />
nature of the service rendered by that<br />
institution,"<br />
.' ,<br />
J n view of the various cables coming through to<br />
the effect that Prohibition has faUed., it may- be<br />
interesting to note that the "Wpts" were utterly<br />
rounded at the recent American elections, and Prohibition<br />
.stands to~ay supported by the strongest<br />
"dry" Congl'ess and Senate Legislatures ever elect69,<br />
The final results show: The Senate, 73<br />
"dry" members, 21 "wet" members, and 2 vacancies;<br />
the House of Representatives, 319 "dry" .members,<br />
111 "wet" members, and five uncertain.<br />
These, it must be admittell, are great '''dry'' gains in<br />
both the Senate ami. House of Repl·escntatives.<br />
Dewan Bahadur Vijiaraghavachariar. India's Trade<br />
Exhibitioner, in the course of a speech in India is<br />
reported to have said :-<br />
If India continu)s to exhibit the' same attitude<br />
towards the British Empire as she did during the<br />
War, an attitude'I noticed, often referred to with<br />
~'l'atitude \loUd pride b~, ~l Englishmen, irrespective<br />
_<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
7iN'<br />
Commenting on the above New Indue writes :-'<br />
Since there is no War going on India cannot<br />
" bleed herself white," Quite in the sense that Lord<br />
Hardinge described in 1m!. But she 'c.tn provide<br />
-markets for the Empire's goods, supply it with her<br />
raw materials, help it to develop remote territories<br />
with cheap labour until it is not Wanted, and then<br />
bring it home again, maintain a huge Army at her<br />
own expense, and thus lighten its burden, find an<br />
outlet for its children in her own higher Services,<br />
and willingly tmbmit to all the oppression and<br />
injustice and humiliation of a subject race. Then.<br />
we also have no doubt that references to India by<br />
Englishmen will again be tinged with pride an(l<br />
gratitnde. But the pride and gratitude have not<br />
materialised into the Freedom India hoped for,<br />
hence, her attitude is that of keen resentment. She<br />
was recognised as equal on the battlefield in death,<br />
but not as equal in hfe in her own land.<br />
Saya the Zanz,bal' Vou-e -The Colonial Secretary<br />
has -approved, it appears, of the recommendation<br />
made by the late Governor of Kenya as to the composition<br />
of the MUDlcipal Council of Nairobi, tho<br />
capital of the Colony. 'fhe Councll is to consist of<br />
twelve members, of whom five are to be Europeans<br />
elected by the European community, four Indians<br />
elected by the Indian commuDlty and nominated<br />
by the Governor, one Goan elected by the Gminese<br />
community, one official and one European, co-opted.<br />
by tlie other members. This arrangement has been<br />
accepted by the Ind.iall8. the protest agamst election<br />
by commnnal electorates being maintained in the<br />
provision that the Indian elected members will sit<br />
in the Council, not by virtue of the election, but uy<br />
virtue of appointm(mt by the Govern9r !<br />
In a recent issue of the "N.C.W. of Great Britain"<br />
it was noted that an effort. was being made to bring<br />
India into the I.C. W. and that a small committee,<br />
with the Marchioness of Aberdeen as its chairman,<br />
had been formed in London. Indian radies passing<br />
through London are asked for their advice. about<br />
their various Provinces, and several of them have<br />
gone back to lod13 anxious to work towards the<br />
formation of local or Presidency Councils. When a<br />
tertain number of these have been formed, it may<br />
then be possible to establish a National Council for<br />
all India. There is already an established Council<br />
of Women in Bombay, re'ldy to affihate; Miss Cornelia<br />
Sorabji, Hon. Yice:-President for the I.C.W. in<br />
India, from her headqllaters in 28, Chowringhee,<br />
Calcutta, is in correspondence with several willing<br />
helpers in Calcutta and in the as yet untouched<br />
Provinces; and there seems a good prospect that a<br />
National Council for India may come into existence<br />
ere long. The Secretary of the London ProviSiOnal<br />
Committee is Mrs. Gray, 200,. Palf\Ce Chamber!!,<br />
Bridge Street, Westminster.- ...."
Reuter's tnessage understandil that official intimation<br />
wilf shortly be published in India that<br />
certain powers which, nnder the Government of<br />
India Act, were given to the Bengal Legislative<br />
Council, will revert to the Governor of Bengal in<br />
Council. It is pointed out in well-informed circles<br />
in London that under the Dyarchy certain powers<br />
were deleg~ted to lnwan Ministers in the Legislative<br />
Council. The Swarajist Party, thinking probably<br />
they had not received sufficient concessions, refused<br />
to vote .the salaries of the Ministers. A deadlock<br />
ensued,-and as certain sections of the public busi·<br />
ness came to a standstill it became necessary to take<br />
action.<br />
---<br />
A Retl~r's tI1essage ftom Pretoria. repor~ that<br />
four IndIans have been arrested on a charge under<br />
the Gold Law. It is aneged that tJiey were 'found<br />
in possession of gold to the value of '£250' When<br />
arrested three Of the accused were about to board<br />
the Johannesburg train. On visiting the Asiatic<br />
bazaar the'police found a goldsmith's p~t.<br />
WELCOME TO OUR ROYAL GUEST<br />
~J.\yE extend,a hearty welcome, to His Itoyal<br />
\'1\1 Itighness the Prince of Wales to this<br />
Province and especially to Durban·<br />
Much as Indians were ahxious to participate<br />
in celebrating this; unique and happY oacilsion<br />
together with the other sec::tions of the burgesses<br />
of this Town tney are not able to do so<br />
unanimously because they have unjustifiably been<br />
refused an _honourable position as It seIf.respecting<br />
section of the burgesses by the Corporation.<br />
Anti~Asiatic feeling in this Town is very high and<br />
strange to say most of our City Fathera eveh are<br />
not void of that leelipg. If they had any respect<br />
for His Royal Highness it was their duty to 'put,<br />
aside all such feelings and to act harmoniously<br />
with every section of the burgesses irrespective of<br />
cJ,ass, colour or creea,-U not for anything else for<br />
the sake of expediency as we have already stat~d<br />
in a. previous article. But 1 no, they have not been<br />
ahle to sacrifice that feeling and yet they profess<br />
to be the m.ost loyal citizens of the llritish Empire<br />
and are most anxious to accord a right royal welcome<br />
to the Prince of Wales. It is sheer hypocricy.<br />
It is true _that we are responsible to a cet·<br />
tain extent ,fo~ the presen:t. state of affairs as we<br />
were not able-to stand unitedly. There are a few<br />
irresponsible individuals in our community whO,<br />
for reasons known to themselves- have not hesitated<br />
to sacrifice the interests of the whole" Mmmunity<br />
to ,gain their own ends, and have gone<br />
a.gainst the Congress who has ever been :lighting<br />
fo1' the just rights of our '6rethrell and have on<br />
their own a~d without, any mandate from the<br />
{Jom.rnunity expressed their willingness to accept<br />
the humiliating terms ofiered by the Mayor. The<br />
-Mayor has taken advantage of this division in our<br />
community and totally ignoring the voice of the<br />
Congress has taken into cO'l:6.dence these lew<br />
irresponsible men who have neTer at any time represented<br />
the community and has forced On the<br />
community a programme which- is considered by<br />
a large section to· be humiliating'. Nor self-res·<br />
pecting Indian nor any fair-minded :E!uropean can<br />
INotAN OPINION June 5th, 1925<br />
consider the qelllands made by the Congress<br />
in an1way nnjust. Out' friends"who have chosen<br />
to become the pets of the Corporation too in their<br />
innetmost heart rE'a1i-:e' that tlie -cause for which<br />
the Congres's was fighting was right but the idea<br />
of t1eir_ becoming the pets of the Corporation has<br />
apparently blinded thell1 to their duty to their<br />
fellow-countrymen. ,1.1<br />
We wish to point out at this stage that we have\<br />
the hlghest esteem for His Royal Highness the<br />
PrinCe of Wales but we hold our sell-respect. to be<br />
sacred above everything else. Our fight is with<br />
the Durban Corporation who has obstinately refused<br />
to accord tha.t status to us and has thus<br />
pre'tented us from celebra.ting this occasion unanim.ously.<br />
As repre~~ting those who are against<br />
participating in the celebrd.uons on the present<br />
terms we wish His Royal Highness will not misundel1ltand<br />
our delicate position. We wi&hed<br />
there had been no jarring note in 8
June 5th. 192~ tt.:DIAN OPINION i..ij<br />
----------~~----~.-----~--~----~~~------~<br />
his august rank as future Emperor of India. / This<br />
" he smilingly accepted and retained in his hanlls<br />
when the Royal motor car proceeded on its way<br />
amid a final salvo of applause.<br />
The incident, completely unrehearsed though it<br />
was, passed off with great eclat, and will create a<br />
splendid feeling of pride and gratification throughout<br />
the local Indian community.<br />
, r: WHAT PRINCE THOUGHT OF INDIANS'<br />
WELCOME<br />
ALBERT PARK FuNCTION<br />
Durban's welcome to the Plince has been sincere<br />
an4 deep, and the Indian community, no whit behind<br />
the Europeans, gave His Royal Highness a<br />
magnificent reception on the Albert Polrk this mornjng.<br />
From an flarIy hour Indians had been pouring<br />
into the park, and by the time the Prince arrived it<br />
was computed that 15,000 of them were present,<br />
there beiDi no less than 7,000 school-children lined<br />
up in front of the dais. The orchestra of the Natal<br />
:Musicians" Society, an Indian organisation, led Ute<br />
music. and from a very early hour the park Wal!! gay<br />
with banners and vividly-coloured dresses. By<br />
noon the whole area of the Oval was covered with<br />
people, and from the dais as far as the eye could<br />
see was a Burging mass of humanity, waiting exp,ectanUy<br />
for their Prince.<br />
DRlVE ROUND THE PARK-<br />
Exactly at 12.30 the Royal cars were seen entering<br />
the park, and on the instant the whole concourse<br />
burst into a roar of cheering, such cheering as has<br />
not yet been surpassed in Durban. The Prince<br />
drove slowly twice round the park so that the<br />
people on the fringe of the crowd had an excellent<br />
vlew.<br />
He reached the dais through a long line of some<br />
100 ex-service men. who were drawn lip in two<br />
ranks, and his appearance was the signal for the<br />
orowd, led by the band, to sing "For He's a Jolly<br />
Good Fellow." Mr. E. M. P~ruk, the chairman of<br />
the Indian Reception Committee, welcomed His<br />
Royal Highness, who was accompanied by the<br />
Mayor. on the dais, and said: "May it please your<br />
Royal Highness, I welcome you in the name of the<br />
Indian community. I wish you long life, and pray<br />
that you may be one day OU1' Emperor. We hope<br />
you willl'etnrn safely and tell our King that we are<br />
his loyal subjecta. May God bless you."<br />
A LITTLE HINDUSTANI<br />
The Prince, who was in mufti, smiled happily.<br />
"Thank you very 1l11lch, for your kind welcome,"<br />
he said, and turned to face the crowd, to be garlanded<br />
at the same moment, and presented with a<br />
bouquet ()f carnations. His Royal Highness, still<br />
smiling, handed the bouquet to someone else, and<br />
inquired anxiously whether he should address the<br />
crowd in English. "I know a little Hindustani,"<br />
he said, but on Mr. Paruk assuring him that the<br />
people spoke English, he turned to them.<br />
"I thank you all for your very kind welcome," he<br />
began, "and I wish you a prosperous futnre." The<br />
crowd roared. and the Pl'ince smIled agdin.<br />
• "Splendid," he remarked.<br />
.Another boUquet. this tiIfl6 from a tiny Indian<br />
girl, who was lifted up to the dais, and then the<br />
---.. waiting children broke into "God Bless the Prince<br />
of Wale.s," singing it with wonderful enthusiasm.<br />
Three tremendous cheers followed, and then the<br />
Prince was presented to the members of the Reception<br />
Committee, shaking hands with e~h of them.<br />
On the dais, in addition to Mr. Parnk, w('l'e Messrs.<br />
H. L. Paul, C. M. AAglia and A. Ra.i.<br />
The Prince chatted for a few miuutes with Mr.<br />
Paruk, asking whence the majority of ~ crow"l<br />
hailed, and displaying a considerable knowlet4e of<br />
India and its inhabitants, and then he left tOO dail!<br />
to be driven away amid a continued roar from<br />
15,000 throats. It was a great recpption, and Durban's<br />
Indian community have every reason to be<br />
proud of the way in which they greeted their<br />
future Emperor.<br />
M. K. GANDHI LIBRARY AND PARSEE<br />
RUSTmlJEE HALL<br />
ILLUMINATED WITH eOLOURED I.IGHTS<br />
INDIAN DECORATIONS<br />
It is evident that in spite the dissention that arose,<br />
probably largely through misunderstanding, amongllt<br />
the members of the Indian community, they have<br />
risen to the occasion welL<br />
Grey Street has been Waily decorated by ownerll<br />
of premises in the street and by general subscriptions<br />
In Queen Street, the Bai Jerbbai RUltomjee Trust.<br />
has liberally decorated the M. K. Gandhi Library<br />
and Parsee Rustomjee Hall, coloured lights standing<br />
out in the words "Long live the future Emperor of<br />
Iridia," the whole couonr scheme being in green,<br />
red a white.<br />
It is in similar colours that the individual d.·<br />
corations are carried out, Taken from the flag of<br />
India the motto .. Heaven's Light our Guide," i.<br />
freely used, and there is also emblazoned .. Swara.j<br />
is our birthright."<br />
THE COLOUR BAR<br />
PROTEST OF JOINT COUNCIL<br />
The Johannesburg Joint Council of Europeans<br />
and Natives has forwarded a memorandum to the<br />
Minister of Mines and Industries in which it<br />
opposes the Mines and Works (Colour Bar) Blll "by<br />
all the.means in its power."<br />
Among the reasons adduced for its attitude are<br />
the following:-<br />
"The principle of a colour bar in industry is<br />
economically unsound aud morally unjust, and is<br />
without precedent in any ciVilised country. The<br />
application of this new and dangerous prineIple is to<br />
be wholly in the discretion of the Government of<br />
the day (by very wide powers of regulation), whereas<br />
Parliament itself is in duty bound to control and<br />
tQ make itself responsible in detail for every applicatiGn<br />
of a principle WhICh may involve such seriolls<br />
social consequences. This dangerous measure is proposed<br />
at a time when there il!! no evidence whatever<br />
that the Hildick-Smith judgment has beell followed<br />
by any considerable substitution of natives for Ea-.<br />
ropeans on the gold-mines.<br />
"So far as the openi.ng up of new places for Europeans<br />
is concerned, the numbel1l of natives employed,<br />
even in unskilled occupations, is comparativelr<br />
small (ou the go1d mines, which are primarily eoncerned,<br />
only a matter of hundreds). To replace<br />
these by Europeans will do very little to relieve<br />
EUropean unemployment,- aud that little at an<br />
absurdly dispropor\ionate cost. It will adversely<br />
affect the relatiS>Ds of Europeans and Natives, and<br />
will create a seUBe of grievc1nce. !f.- every opportunity<br />
of development is denied to the natives, all<br />
sections of native opinion will inevitably be drawn<br />
together on anti·Eutopean and extremist lines. The<br />
Bill is bound to cause a fundamental disturbance of<br />
existing conditions, the extent of which cannot now<br />
be accurately estimated.<br />
"The displacement of Europeans by Natives is<br />
effectively prevented by trade union vigilance and<br />
by the pressure of public opinion. But displaced<br />
Natives are powerless, and can only cherish a sense<br />
of injustice and resentment against their white<br />
rul_era.<br />
AsUTId V. COLOURED<br />
"The Bill, in differentiatin~ between eoloUTed
144 INDIAN OPINION June 5th• 1925<br />
\<br />
people on one hand and Asiatics on the other,<br />
threatens to provide new antagonisms in the alrea'1y<br />
much divided South Ahicanl,ody politic.<br />
Impressions that will inevitably take their place<br />
in tl1e minds of the Natives if the Bill becomes law<br />
are: (a) That Europeall laboul' is unable to compete<br />
With native labOUI', however civilised, without unfair<br />
extraneolls aid; (b) '],hat the Bill is a conscious,<br />
though clumsy application of the Imperialist plinciple<br />
pivide et impera; (c) Newly formed native<br />
labour unions are frigtttening the Government to<br />
take protective measures. )<br />
The Colour Bar< Bill stands with other mcasllres<br />
s11ch a~ the' Mimmum Wage ,Bill and the 1913 Land<br />
Act (still applied for the most part only so far as It<br />
Imposes restrIctions on Natives), as part of an UI1-<br />
defined policy of segrega:tIOn. There can be no<br />
justificati\)ll for the one-sided application of' sllch a<br />
policy by measures imposmg serious restrictions<br />
upon NatiVes, without any compensating privileges,<br />
or any protectIOn wha~ever for just native int~l·esb:!.<br />
"TIED TO THE ·LAND"<br />
The repoet alludes to the thoroughly unsatiSfactory<br />
conditio,ns prevailing on many farms before<br />
more natives, 01 natives now employed in industry,<br />
ate fOl'ced into farm labour. 'rhe very low 'ltandarJ<br />
of native farm wages (agl;iculture being excluded<br />
from the operation both'of the Colour Bar and of<br />
the Minimum Wage Bills), is proof that,in spite of<br />
occasional local shortage, native farm labour is, on<br />
the whole, a wasted asset. Observation 'shows that<br />
the operation of the 90-day labour.ten,ant system<br />
immobilises large numbers of potential native la.bourers<br />
who are in effect "tieLl to the land," nndel'<br />
employed and under-trained, so much so that<br />
natives are Justified in resentmg a policy ,vhich<br />
aims at pushmg them on to the El1l'opean farm'l<br />
where they have no prospects of i91provmg their<br />
standard of livmg.<br />
No provision whatever has been macle for natives<br />
already displaced in the pursui.t ot the Government's<br />
"civilised labour" policy-nor- foJ' the relIef ot<br />
natlves suffel'1ng fr-om severe economic pressure in<br />
congested native areas. The m1rnant is singllbrly<br />
inopportune for legislation /which much tenu to<br />
aggravate the seriousnesS of this sltualion ..<br />
"Failing an equitable policy ,of segregation," says<br />
the report, "the only sound pr9tectlOn for legitimate<br />
white interests IS to raise native standa.rds. The<br />
present measure IS calculated to depress the native<br />
standard and to aggravate the evil. This rednces<br />
the 'natIOnal dividend' and circumscribe;! a m)stimportant<br />
mal'ket, for the products ot South Afrio.1n<br />
agrlCultuve and iudustl'les." Experience shows (e.g.,<br />
in the Transkei. where virtual segreg.1tion is seen in<br />
practice) that the material 0(' economic pl'ogl'ess of<br />
the native population creates wants such as bl'idgebuilding<br />
01' motor or agricultural m:l.Chinery rep.lir<br />
shop1', which are, and C.1n to-day, only be ,snppheJ<br />
by the initiati~e of E9ropeans and by an iRfiltration<br />
of Europeans IptO the segregatIon are.1. ':I,,isbtion,<br />
like the Colom, Bar Bill, will close avenues to<br />
natives and prevent them from learning to meet<br />
tuese needs ,for themselves in their own al=eas.<br />
THE MINIMUM WAGE<br />
While in Enropean countr~es the pt'inciple of a<br />
minimum wage may hav~much. to commend. it, its<br />
application to South African conditions ne6ds most<br />
careful scrunity. When to a niinimnm wage Bill<br />
is added an undisguised Colour B.1r Bill the injustice<br />
becomes obvious.<br />
'rhe Joint Council resolved .-<br />
That immediate representa~ions be made to the<br />
Prime Minister (a) cOJlveying the Conncil's opposition<br />
to the measure,' (b) dl'awing attention to the<br />
fact that native opinion has not been constllted on a<br />
measure profonndly affecting all Mtive interests;<br />
Co) requesting that inasmuch as the Prime Minister<br />
has himself stated that the announcement of his<br />
complete programme is postponed for at lea9t a year<br />
the restl'ictions Oil natives proposell in the C ~lou~<br />
Bar Bill should not be considered before that programme<br />
is announced. ' :<br />
:phat the Counct! take steps to place its vIews before<br />
any Select Committee that mar be applintel.<br />
EVILS OF NATIVE PASS SYSTEM ,.<br />
JOIN"f COUNCIL'S FINAL RECOMME~DA"l'IONS '\<br />
"The pass system is. no doubt, an MKy means of<br />
controlling those who are subject to it. but It is<br />
uevertheless crude and repulSive. It shoultl not. he<br />
beyond human wit to organise onr soci.!I system to<br />
give the native liberty ill the lan,l of hi'! hirth. Few<br />
Enropeans realise the irritations and fier'ce rC'Helltments<br />
caused by' the pass system. The thrcJ.t to extend.it<br />
to women inflames the n.ltl ve to resistanoe.<br />
We have had to respect these feelings. B:lt. even<br />
the proposals now submittl:'d (ellpecially Cl.LUse 2 (a),<br />
(b), are regarded with dislike and feal·. This clause<br />
tries to control the influx into the towns and to<br />
meet the demand for more parental control. The<br />
'itati¥e people deplore the ease With wI1ich native<br />
girls are able to escape home dlsciplme and are<br />
enticed into the towns. But, while there is an<br />
almost' unanimous desire for p.1rel}ta\ contl'ol,<br />
Clanse 2 is not as unanimously supported, largely<br />
because of the fear that it will proviue an easy<br />
means of introducmg a form of pass."<br />
"Our inquiries have confirmeu our conVICtion<br />
that the reintroduction of the Night PaSS Ordin.mco.)<br />
in respect of native women would bil to tmlCh the<br />
evils which stirred the Mimster of Jllstice and ,. "11'<br />
selt to actIon, and would add anothel' pow 'ul<br />
irritant to those which ah'eady CJ,llse unrest among<br />
the native people."<br />
The above are extracts from the covel'ing letter to<br />
a memorandum submitted to the Prime Millitlter<br />
by the .J()iut Conncil of Enropeans and Nativei.l. The<br />
letter is signed by the Bishop of JohanneOlbnru,<br />
H. S. Msimang, Rev . .Ray E. PhIllipi, Mr. J. D.<br />
Rheinallt Jones and Mr. R. V. Selope Them 1.<br />
The_ memorandum which is the result of the<br />
Joint CounCil's deliberations aHel' consllltJ,tioll With<br />
the native welfare societies, native chieft:1 and other'<br />
organisations, iu'ges upon the Pl"im3 Minister not to-<br />
, alter the present position until a native conferen~e<br />
has been convened under the Native Affaird Act<br />
1920, to consider the propo3ed scheme or any mojifications.-'rIM<br />
Star (,J ohannesbllrg.)<br />
TURN INDIA INTO IRELAND<br />
1\1;R. NATESAN'S GRAVE WARNING<br />
In the Council of State India recently Mr. CI'erar<br />
moved for a consideration of the Bengal Ordinance<br />
SJ.pplementry-Bill and mlde It clelr that it was inten<br />
(led to clear the obstacles which stooll in the way<br />
of India ad vancing on the road of responSible Government.<br />
Mr. Yamin Khan said the fact on which the Governor-General<br />
had proceeded to take the entire respO'lsibihty<br />
for th} promulgatIOn of the Ordinanc3<br />
and this bIll, were not before the House and that in<br />
the circumstances he would leave the Bill to be pJSl!<br />
ed or rejected by those members of Council whe<br />
know the facts. He (1\11'. Yamin Kb.all) woultl not<br />
take the responsib~lity.<br />
1\Ir. Natesan asked Government not to turn India<br />
into another Ireland. By this Bill the Government<br />
wJs thinning the ranks of co-operators. He regretted<br />
he COl11d not respond to the appeal of 1\Ir. Crerar.<br />
Sir D. P. Sarbadhlk.1ri theu qpposed the BIU.<br />
Sardar Chlranjit Singh supported the Bill aud asked<br />
the Council to trust the Viceroy.<br />
111'. Vedaml1rthi after a short speech - walked out
_ J une 5th, 1925, ______=_1 N:...:...::.U_l_A_N-.O-P-I-N-I-.O-N __________ 1-:..45<br />
of the Clumber as a protest 81-(ilinst the passing of<br />
the mIl which he C0l1111 not honestl,.. Rl1pport and<br />
t1l
{NOlAN OPINION June 5th, 1925<br />
problem!! the British democracy is called upon to<br />
solve. Much as we learn from all these, there are<br />
few among us who are able to -aay with any degrfle<br />
of certamly that we know what the people of India<br />
want.<br />
WESTERN EXPLOITATION<br />
We understand clearly that in spite of all the<br />
efforts of our beloved frlend Gandhi, Western commorClalism<br />
with all its sordid horrors is surely fastening<br />
its grip on portions of the country and upon<br />
large groups of the people. We also know that socalled<br />
rel\gious differences sometimes-cause rlOts and<br />
bloodshed; and 'fie know all that is vocal il1 India<br />
cries aloud for Swaraj, or Home Rule. Up till the<br />
other day nobody had said exactly what was m6l\nt<br />
by Home Rule. Now \ve have received in this<br />
-country a set of proposals put forward. by'a conference<br />
held in India which goes to show that)£ the<br />
British Parliament is wise enough to give heed, the<br />
people of India maY be sent ,forward, many steps<br />
forward, on the road to absolute self-government<br />
and peace.<br />
'<br />
CONVENTION BI,LL THE ONLY SCHEME KNOWN<br />
We understand the need which exists for starting<br />
th" new constitution by re-establishing the village<br />
commune. All true self-government starts with the<br />
mdivldual anti fpom him spreads to village, township<br />
'ani city but before these proposals can be intellIgently<br />
dlscussed on this slde, very much propaganda<br />
work, must be done. There need be no doubt at all<br />
as to what the British people wlll do once they understand.<br />
We who are engaged in 'this work are<br />
but fe..y in number; in addition we are h!l:,ndicapped<br />
'Pecause we are British and the shoe does not pinch<br />
us as it does our brothers in India. India must<br />
send lots of more missionaries to these shores and<br />
they, should come determined to work and efficiently<br />
equipped for the work.<br />
'<br />
MUTUAL AID<br />
I have -no faith in those who say India can work<br />
out her own salvation unaided and alone. She needs<br />
us and we. need her. It may be said Britain needs<br />
the wealth of India more ~han India needs the ,organising<br />
skill and domination of Britain. Domination<br />
is abhorrent to me. I want not a forced unity<br />
but a unity as among equals. The WQrId ge~ smaller<br />
every day owing to the annihilation of space. If<br />
the resourCeS of India ,are to be developed, we may<br />
be quite sure that this will eventually mea)l the<br />
entry of India into the world'!! markets I1S a competitOl'<br />
WJth nations of, Western Europe. There will<br />
be no pea,ce, no har!p.ony, when this situatioll arises.<br />
Westerners cannot and WIll not allow their standard.<br />
of hfe to be pulled down and 'wrecked simply to<br />
enable sets of grasping, greedy capitalists to wax fat<br />
at the expenee of millio!).s of people, whom they<br />
may grind down to the lowest level of subsistence<br />
in order to build uy huge profits.<br />
What, after this, have I, a Britisher friend of tmlia,<br />
to say to my comrades ana friends in all pal·ts of the<br />
great Indian -dominions,? Simply this let us each<br />
agree that we are, desplte the colour of our skins,<br />
brothers and .Sisters and as snch let us strive to evol Vt:l<br />
or thinl£. (Jut the sort of social indusLt'ial org.lnisation<br />
which wVl enable us to overcome all economic difficulties<br />
aud establish true co-opet'ation l:!etween two<br />
grent nations. To this end ihe British Tl'ade Union<br />
Movl'ment must help our Indian brothers in their<br />
task of organising trade unions. We know how<br />
hard and difficult a job thiS is, but we also know<br />
th3.t as we have overooDle ,tqese difficulties, so also<br />
wlll our brothef!'\ ill 11).dia Qvercome thelll. But they<br />
I\eetl h·)lp,. 3,d ,lllust ask qs tQ give it tq th~m. The<br />
gI1Ql\t"f} ~~w:-. 'ft;a,4e~ 'Unioq OQngre~fj WQ~lq WilliQgly<br />
~e!1~ ~nt, ~ff'nim~ tg 8@lp it th~f ~W~ tllVlt9
~ ndiatt t1fA + •<br />
\WptltlllU<br />
N(', 24-Vo). XXIII. Friday, Junf! 12th, 1925.<br />
JI. gi.tered IIube G. p.o. a •• Ne ....... r<br />
PUCB Fou ..... c..<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
"7l~<br />
THE Maharani Regent of Travancore has chosen TheTanjore District Board haB passed a resolution<br />
II an Anglo-Indian gentleman belonging to a to teach Hindi in aU schools under its management.<br />
family long domiciled in the State. A Reuter's __,<br />
telegram from London statei that Mr. F. E. Watts<br />
hopes to proeee\! to Travancore in May to assume<br />
duties of the Diwan at the end of Jnne. Mr. Watts, who<br />
is a Barrister and has been practising in London and<br />
Midlandl' for the PaBt five years, is reported to have<br />
said that the appointment came to him as a IlUrp'rise<br />
and was entirely unsonght for. He eODsiderea he<br />
was selected on personal grounds in view of his<br />
family's century-old connection with Travancore.<br />
Mr. Watts' selection. foreihadows the separation of<br />
the connection between "Church and State" which<br />
has been so long traditional in Travancore. The<br />
Hmdu residents of Trivandrnm are protesting<br />
Ilgdinst the appointment of Mr .. Watts as Dewan of<br />
Travancore since the Hindn religious institutions aB<br />
well as olher oopartments of the State were under<br />
the administration of the Dewan and the appointment<br />
of a non-Hindu would not be practicable so<br />
long as the religious inlltitutions were under the<br />
control of Government.<br />
Mr. Gandhi during his visit to Trivandrum where<br />
he was State guest visited Maharaja's College of<br />
Scienoe where students presented him with an<br />
addriss. In reply he is reported to have said there<br />
were limitations to Rcience and scientific research<br />
aI4d that they had to explore where they shou1d restrain<br />
themselves and where they should let themselves<br />
go. He deprecated the idea of students seek-'<br />
inl.( scientific knowledge for obtaining means of<br />
livelihood and exorted them to take to it for its own<br />
sake amI emulate the examples of such eminent<br />
scientists as Sir J. C. Bose and P. C. Ray. He referred<br />
to unfortunate circumstance that students in<br />
India were mosUy drawn from middle classes who<br />
ha~l oonsequenUy lost nse of their handil and did not<br />
l'ealise dignity t>f manual labour. He advised them<br />
to place their practical knowledge at its disposal of<br />
vilL'lges to 8SIIist in introduction of spinning wheel<br />
into every household.<br />
In reply to an advice of. a reYolutionary to l'etire<br />
from public life. :Mr. Gandhi writes in Young<br />
/litilfl :-"1 caunot always have it my own way. If<br />
I have had my share of 1air weather. I must face<br />
foul too. I must not abandon the field of battle so<br />
long as I feel that I am wanted. When my ,,"ork is<br />
done anu I have become IY disabled or worn-out<br />
soldier I shall be put away. Till then, I must continue<br />
to do my work and endeavour to neutralise in<br />
all ways accessible to me- the poison of revolutionary<br />
-activity."<br />
Mr. Gandhi then advises the revolutionaries to<br />
spread out into villages and try to bring sunshine<br />
into the dark dungeons of millions of their countrymen.<br />
That would be worthier of their ambition<br />
and love of land thfln the existing unquenchable<br />
thirst for the blood 01 English offici, lIs and those<br />
who are assisting them. It is nobler to try to change<br />
their spirit than to take 'their lives.<br />
It is understood that the MadraB Medical College<br />
Council has unanimously resolved to recommend to<br />
Gov~rnment that L. M. S. Degree of the MadraB<br />
. University should be abolished only after a suitable<br />
medical diploma to replace the degree is established.<br />
.<br />
The term of office of Mr. C. R. Das and Mr. H. S.<br />
Suhrawardy as Lord Mayor and Deputy Mayor of<br />
C'dlcutta respectively having expired recently the<br />
Calcutta Corporation have re-elected Mr. Das 'as<br />
Lord Mayor and Mr. Suhrawardy aB Deputy Mayor.<br />
The Academic Council of the MadraB University<br />
considered the report of the Committee appointed<br />
to inquire into the qUistion of encouragement of<br />
Oriental languages and accepted the proposals of the<br />
Committee for the establishment of an University<br />
Institute of advanced Ol'iental Studies and Research<br />
in dir!.~~ and close connection with the Oriental<br />
Manuscripts Library. They alllo agreed to the proposal<br />
for instituting fellowships for thEe' promotjon<br />
of Oriental studies and the appointment of a PublicatIOn<br />
Committee by the Syndicate for encouraging<br />
and 1;lndertaking the publishing of important works<br />
connected with Oriental studies ....<br />
Mr. C. V. Venketaramana_ Iyengar, :rtf.L.C., ,who<br />
ga.ve notice of introducing local option, Bill in the<br />
MadraB Council has recei ved a reply from the<br />
revenue Secretary informing that His Excellency<br />
Governor has declined under Section GOO Goyernment<br />
of India Act to accord sanction for the introduction<br />
of the Bill.<br />
The news that H.R.H. the Prince of Wales is to<br />
stand as one of the sponsors for the little dau&rhter<br />
of Mr. and MrS. T. M. Wadley (Mayor and Mayoress<br />
of Durban), whose birth wail announced on Tuesday,<br />
has come 3f' a pleasant surprise to Durban. His<br />
ROJal Highness has suggested "1\lary" ail the name<br />
for the lIttle lady.<br />
Sir William Snowden. Chief President for five<br />
years of the State of South Australia who is touring'<br />
round the world enquiring into the administration<br />
of jails and forest conservation by the various Governments<br />
arrived in Madras recently on his way to<br />
ColomLo 611 route to AustraliA on the completion of<br />
his tour In India. In Iln interview with the Associated<br />
Pre!!s, Sir William referring to Australia and<br />
Indian immigl'"dnts said:-"1 found in travelling<br />
through India that there is an impression here that<br />
Australia legislates espe&ially against the entrance of<br />
Indians. The fact is there is no more discrimination<br />
in onr immigration ldws against the admission of<br />
Indians 8S there is against Germans. Americanll,<br />
Russians or any other nationalities. The only test<br />
applied, apart from health and finaztcial qnalifjea-
148 INDIAN OPINION june 12th, 1925<br />
'------~~-------------------.--------------------<br />
tions so that nO mlin shall be admitte4 if he be a<br />
c~r!>ni~ ~nJah4 or 4~~~ifut~ per~.~?,. ~s th~ la?guage<br />
~BqO rh,?h e1' er r n?~ c~Fer 1~ \la~le."<br />
MR. . ANDREWS AND UNION PREMIERS<br />
tf~NE of my most vivid recollections was the<br />
~ - tl1e fir~t ci4lis -of South Af~~~an S-~~!Igg~<br />
in thJ beginning of the year 1!:l14. Ofr.<br />
C. F. Andrews writes in a contemporary) General<br />
Smuts had let Mr Gandhi and "Mr. P?Ta'jr' and lIfo<br />
Kallenback out of prison in order ~o COme ~o terms<br />
if possible with the leaden on the Indian side:<br />
The news h.d spread round Durb~n lik~ 'Wild fire<br />
that there were 'negotiations about to' begin and<br />
t,here was a~useIDent in many faces as ~opl~<br />
said: "Gandhi will' beat"Sinuts again !,n<br />
'An ultiinatuk had b'eeD. launchM"from the"Tngia_h<br />
si4~' th~f ~ie~s ~he i~iq~it9~~ ~fltax ~_f}i'e<br />
~bolished the whole Indian {:ommunity 'ill Nata~<br />
woUld offer passive resistance by ~arching into<br />
the Xransvaal -and getting tnemselves anested.<br />
~r. ~it~~hi w~s ~re~~ri.n¥,\to ~ea'd '~~eu: ~n~' ~~<br />
d~t~ had peefl ~xea. The m~r~l+ ~~~ tq ?e~w on<br />
JanuarY 16, :JW4.<br />
I think it was January 8th when the telegram<br />
VoW lJeneral. Smuts readleg Mahatma GandlIi. He<br />
was staying quietly at Phoenix Settl~ment on that<br />
day about l4 iniles away -froni Durb'itn. When't'he<br />
tei~gr~m arrive4'askrpg 1ft. f1did~i '~'~eei<br />
p~~e~'ar ~~uj;~ in :r,retofia, t'here )v~s j~~ time to<br />
ca.tcP. the afternoon train into Ddj-ban, ~21hurried<br />
to the country'railway station. When @ g'6t ' to<br />
Du'roan'e were just g01lig out of ehtr~nc~ 'to the<br />
s~~tjon 'rpeu'tn.e /?tatj9')l '1f~ster st~PRe~r~ll(l' s~fd:<br />
~~lIelio, ,Gan.(U)~; '!low are ,y,ou get!i.{lg along with<br />
General Smuts ?'~ , ' "<br />
Mah8,tmaji said: "I am g
favour with the white man by srllrtUD~ the black<br />
Ulan 'wfo t~ oUI' brother.'" , , .' '"<br />
Q~nerdr Uertz~)g i~ no~<br />
l!kelY to remain long in<br />
power, Even nmv his Go\ernment cannot show<br />
It \n.ljonty withdut relying' on the La.bour<br />
vote, He is a's oleai~y as possible'the inferIor of<br />
General Smut,s iIi'abiluy' a:itd 'imaginlltioll and<br />
even ,vhile 'General Smuls is out or office.' he Will<br />
guide 'tWa countWl'n an emergency' as M haS done<br />
I J (I f 1 ~ t I ,1' I r ,.<br />
qurfp,q' thestqa.,t mO!ltlls C9~cerning t~e Indian<br />
question, The tact that General Hertzog has<br />
beeil ready to listen' to' llim reveals a true greatil~S<br />
of titinitity in" hilll also and ~ves one ~ope<br />
... 1 i I II ", j • '<br />
for the ut!1!e of s country ~ftai can proquce t ree<br />
such men as th "lISe I have tried to descri/:>e -Geneml<br />
Botha. Gen:nsl Smuts, General Hertzog,<br />
--:. . ~ - : -: - .<br />
. ~.<br />
~... ~.. "I • ,'....<br />
AMERICA l' M{E~ NOTICE OF INDIAN<br />
LlW1SLATUHE<br />
INDIA SHouin bitL'\-SEI'l!'AR EASTERN<br />
, ,;. '1M'AllOttA irION CO\s'FER'ENCE' i<br />
, ..t).lJ jmpo~~i K~erlca:~ papers have taken notic~ of<br />
the pass~~o 9f 4Ie pill. by the 4sse!Dbly at pathi, pro.<br />
posing reciprocal treatment for ,the Untted States<br />
ar(d l~e' CdlcrnieJ whicH treat tndians as an inferior<br />
x'a(:~.' 'jJle' New "y,ur'A: lfven.rtfl f OBt makes the -foUow~<br />
itig' cOnlinent :_' " I , , "<br />
- .1iThe' ~ctlon of the Indian Legislature at DelfIi in<br />
adopting :a' reciprocity' ltteastll'e on inferiority is<br />
tlatrl~thing' neW in the 1ine of internal relations.<br />
Gd'Vernments Ilke' 'the 'United States Which treat,-the<br />
Hindus as'ihfet"tor people wi11 in'tt1rn to be put' on<br />
tJie !nfel'ioriiy'fi~t by'tliem. I The act scems plausible.<br />
Among'tlle wCbfern nations it seems quite all<br />
rig\lt to appif to alt.otttel' nations anq peoples a sliding<br />
scate of disparaging' appra:isal.....:.Mck~al''d 'peoples<br />
liere, arrest~d 'development there, 'corrupted, 'in~<br />
dompetent at1d the'lIM:- By the new Hindu' Act the<br />
rule'will be made'ttl work both' ways:"-lVelv Yor.t<br />
£CMdlf/ P,ost,!Febrtiary 5, 1925.<br />
'<br />
i!;tOf course, the. Indian pe'opl~ must not forget. that<br />
thef Cannot expect equ'al tr'ea'tmen"t'in Atnenca 'un;<br />
leBS they can acquire equal status within the -British<br />
Empire and in' their 'own 'Connttt. ' In their 'own<br />
oountl'y the Indian' people are held to be inferior<br />
and incompetent! by (he' British ovariol'de 'and thus<br />
they have not full .hare in' their own government.<br />
Indeed, the Viry sense of self~respect of the 'People<br />
of India has forced them' to' adopt reciprocity legislatiun:<br />
I 13ut'-this Inimigration question has a tremenll~us<br />
sigfiifiCllll'Ce'in international relationS'. 'Indian<br />
statesmen should take'noto that 'the Immigration dis~<br />
cl'itnination hi the' '.#tnglo-Saxon wodd iB directed<br />
against India, China and 'Japan: It is' dll'ected<br />
aialnst Eastern Asla'whl're abont 900,OOO,OOo-people<br />
n'Vl'. The '.questiorl will n'eve.. be '1lO1ved unless<br />
Chhm recovers hcr fnli sovereignty by abolishing<br />
aU forml! of extra-territorial' jllrisdiction and Inwa<br />
achieves. at;least the sallIe kind 'Of independence as<br />
Canalia br' Australia enjoys. "It is n.othing unnsual<br />
to suggest. that because China, 'Japan and India have<br />
common 'in~est8 'invol'ted in' 'World 'affairs, flU'<br />
Sighted Indian statesmen Rnd 8chola11l of these COUlltries<br />
should co-operate in solving these p'roblelll.9 in<br />
a way \vhtdh will lead to better understanding between<br />
the East and the W cst.<br />
, As u'matter of concrete'suggestion for Indian<br />
statesmen who are 'diSdUssing the probability of<br />
holding a congress of all 'Asiatic nations in India,<br />
possibly through the leadership_of the Poona Sarvanltmik'Sabha<br />
(as suggested in the JIarhalla), in the<br />
llear futur~, we rC'opOS& that lnditl shOUld call for a<br />
a }tal' Eastt>rn Immigpation COllf~ren()e to l)e held in<br />
149<br />
Cawnpore durmg the session of All-India National<br />
CoIlgN'SS ~uring the Cl1rlt!tmaa week of 1925 in<br />
which aU the peoples of the Far East partlCularly<br />
are to be invite4. Of course, other lldtions will be<br />
allowed to participate. Jhpan is' going to hold a Far<br />
~tern Meilieal Conference ill Tokio in 1926. Is it<br />
too mUch to expect that India will take the leadership<br />
in calhng the Far Eastern Immigration Conference<br />
in the near future Y<br />
COCHIN AGAIN LEADS<br />
In certam directions 80 quickly dOeB the women's<br />
movement advance in Inmd. that each month Sees<br />
Bome new and noteworthy step forward being taken.<br />
This month we are happy to record that a woman<br />
has been nominated to an Indian Legislative Council<br />
f01'l the first time ilt ber own right. The Government<br />
of eocMn has nominated Mrs. T, Madhavi Amma as<br />
a member for its new Legislative Council. It will<br />
be rembered that the sister State of' Travancore was<br />
the first to' include a woman member; but Dr:<br />
Lukhose Poonen, the fady in question got her seat<br />
iIi the Council by virtue of hel' 'appointment as ~<br />
'substitute for the Darbar ppysiCian, a man. Now<br />
Mrs.' ~Iadhavi 4.mma is the first- woman' dtl8Cfly<br />
appointed as a memJjer of lm important' J.,egishitive<br />
Douneil, 'We congratulate hf'l' on bemg the recipient<br />
of the historic 'honour amI hope she will be the<br />
forerunner of many Indian wOllien ~I.L,C·B. Cochin<br />
State has been ever in the van as reg~rds women's<br />
progress, which is what'one wouhl expect to a State<br />
where matriarchy still holds sway, where the rate bf<br />
female 'htet'acy ia the highest in India and wnere<br />
the wife of the Maharajah wields very great political<br />
influence,<br />
THE ACTING GOVERNORSHIP OF BENGAL<br />
EARL WINTERTON SEVERELY HECKLED<br />
In the House of Commons recently Col, Wedgwood<br />
asked wby Sir Abdur Rahim, Semor Executi\'6<br />
-Councillor was not 'appointed Acting G(}'vernor<br />
of Bengalm vie,v of the geneml practlee in suo!1<br />
matter~ (<br />
Earl Winterton replied that',no general Pl"dCtiO&<br />
could be said to exist in'respect of administration of<br />
the act which had been into operatIOn only tor a few<br />
months.<br />
'<br />
Col. Wedgwood presumably had in mind the<br />
provisions relating to the filling of tempOI'al';r<br />
"Vacancies but these did not apply to the selection of<br />
substitutes for Governors proceeding on Jffive~ ><br />
001. Wedgwood asked whether there was anything<br />
in the Act passed last year authoriSIng the<br />
change o['prdctIce which had been usual for thi! last<br />
sixty years and whether there was a single precedent<br />
for the place of a Governor being taken ·by anybodr<br />
not 011 the spot except the Senior Executive Councillor.<br />
'<br />
Earl Winterton rephed that last year's Act could<br />
not have possibly altered a practice' that' did Jiot<br />
exist and ha\'e statutory authority to a situation<br />
which did no\ prevaIl before. No precedent could<br />
be found ia what was done in filling O'rdinaty<br />
-vacancies temporarIly. .<br />
Col. Wedgwood asked whether Ear} Winterton<br />
suggested that the filling of vacancies in the past<br />
never-occurred and that there had never been any<br />
practice other than the one indicated in the question.<br />
• Earl Winterton replied that the practice of iilling<br />
ordinary vacancies could not be col1sidered anaIogous<br />
to the Act of last year because it was the first time<br />
in British India that it permitted the Secretary of<br />
State and Governor-Gene~! to give Governors leave.<br />
Col. Wedgwood asked: Are you importing into<br />
that Act new the prin?!ple which will be permanent?"<br />
\ Earl Winterton: No,"
EUROPEAN ASSOCIATION AND MR. DAS<br />
The following statemen~ has been issued by the<br />
European Association :-<br />
" Althougn.,recognising that a reservation may be<br />
con:sidered-t-o lie in Mr. C. R. Das's declaration that<br />
his abhorrence for polibcal crimes pf violence is<br />
only equal to his abhorrence for their inevItable<br />
antidote in the shape of repressive legislation, the<br />
Council of the European Association views his manifesto<br />
with satisfaction as an nne!Iuivocal condemnation<br />
of the use of violent endr.J. The Council cannot<br />
ignore the atmosphere of deep mistrust that uudoubtedly<br />
exists in the Indian pohtical hfe to the<br />
serious detriment of the successful solution of<br />
India's difficult political problems. They do not<br />
desire to emphasise the r~asons for it or apportion<br />
blame, but welcome the manifesto as an authoritative<br />
announcement that the party of MI'. Das deprecates<br />
any bitt clean methods in the fight for their<br />
objective. That the speed of progress to the goal<br />
$et forth in the, Government of India Act will cauSe<br />
difference of Qpinion is certain, but with the goal<br />
itself a,ccepted by the British Parliament and by ·the<br />
British and lndian people's political progre'lS should<br />
be pOSSIble wlthout the inflammation of racial feeling.<br />
In inviting the Europeans to co-operate in<br />
resis~lUg the repressive legislation Mr. Das asks for<br />
a degree of confidence which is not yet possible in<br />
the light of the past experience. The Council is<br />
confident, however, that, if the policy set forth in<br />
Mr. Das'l}manifesto is to govern the future political<br />
activities, an improved atmosphere of good wIll<br />
aUlong all the communities will facilitate the sucGesful<br />
removal of those obstacles, which, at present,<br />
hamper India's progress.<br />
'<br />
"1'AM AT THE END OF IT."<br />
'RT. HON. SASTRI, AND LIBE1!,Aus'\.<br />
WILL~HE BECOME A SWARAJIST?<br />
At an inform.al talk' with the citizens of Kumbahakonam,<br />
Rt. Hon. V. S. Srinivasa Sastri., expressed<br />
himself on the attempts made in India at<br />
present at unifying t~ various com~unal forces by<br />
means of an all partles conferenct' at which the<br />
.. leaders confabulated and found differences insuperable."<br />
The disuuion and suspicion found in<br />
the country were naturally reflected on the floor of<br />
the Assembly. Mr. M. A. Jinnah who was regarded<br />
as the most effective ambassador betweeu the two<br />
communities, Hindus and Mahomedans, ana who<br />
was a thorough.,going nationalist at one time was<br />
now an advocate of special Muslim claims and admitted<br />
that his views had undergone a change.<br />
Hmdus and' Mahomedans were weaker to-day on<br />
account of their dissensions than they were before.<br />
In consequence of ,these dissensions, Government<br />
had grown stronger and dni not hesitate to supersede<br />
Sir Abdul' Rahimjn tile matter oLthe Governorship<br />
of Bengal. Sir Abdul' Rahim's claim by law and<br />
justice was good but it was ridiculously dismissed.<br />
The Indiau Civil Service felt entrenched. in an Impregnable<br />
position due to the Lee Recommendations.<br />
It was the way of British statesmant he said, when<br />
he had done a wrong to cover it up with the forms<br />
of law, no matter how. ,<br />
Speaking on the idea of a deputation to England<br />
at the time of Lord Reading's ViSlt,_ Mr. SJ.Stl'i said<br />
that there was no USe sending auy deputation" unless<br />
all parties were represented or all parties<br />
sent separate deputations. He could not say<br />
whether th~ Swarajists wonlJ agree to the proposalof<br />
a deputation since Pundit Motnal 'Nehru<br />
had already shut his doors against all such ideas<br />
until an invitation came from Whitehall for a deputation.<br />
,}Ir. C. R. Das' statement l\lr. Sastri said was<br />
June 12th; 19'25<br />
hOPQ{ul, bn' Lord Birkenhead over-interpreted Mr.<br />
Das. Referring to his own (Mr. ~astri's) place III<br />
the LIberal Party, Mr. Sastri said he was at the end<br />
of it whwh meant that he was very near the Swaovajists.<br />
He was inclined to be a Swarajist if the<br />
SwaraJMs dl'opped from their plan one or two<br />
things such as wreckmg the constitution.<br />
. A CORRECTIO-S<br />
The Rt. Hon. Mr. V. S. Srinivasa Sastri makes the<br />
following correction of his speech reported in<br />
Madras papers. The sentence in my Knmbakonam<br />
talk havmg been reported wrongly, I have been<br />
much misunderstood. I said that in the Liberal<br />
Party, I occupied that end which was nearest to<br />
SWl!rajlsts. The report splits the sentence at the<br />
word "end" and represents me to have said that I<br />
was at the end of the Liberal Party and was prepared<br />
to join the Swarajists.<br />
THE NATIONAL CONVENTION<br />
PLEDGE MODIFIED<br />
DR. ANNI~ BESANT ON THIS YEAR'S SESSION<br />
Dr. Annie 'Resant before leaving Cawnpore for<br />
llolJl.'uay explained to a press representative tho<br />
work which had been done by the session of the<br />
National Convention which came to an end.<br />
SIr Tej Bahadur Sapru who presided ove~ its deliberations<br />
was ,selected president and the Righ"t<br />
Hon'ble V. Srinivasa Sastri, Vice-PI'esidenr, whlle<br />
Dr. Besant would continue as General Secretary and<br />
Mr. Ranganatham l\Indaliar treasnrer. The Bill as<br />
she stated in the lecture was now ready in the final<br />
'form and she was planning agitation 011 a large scale<br />
in support both in India and in England. So far<br />
the convention had been confined to the members of<br />
the Legislature and representative bodies, but that<br />
the drafting of the measure was over, she saH the<br />
general council of National Convention had directed<br />
its members in each province to form a provincial<br />
sabna with Sl1Ch subsidiary bodies as it may find<br />
necessary for enrolment of members of the Convention<br />
sabha in order to(} carryon a widespread an I<br />
persel'vering agitation in support of the BIll. The<br />
constructive period is over. The period of agltation<br />
now begins .<br />
'Subscription to the Sabha will be one rupee a year<br />
or a lump sum of Ri!. 5. Persons with income of<br />
Rs. 30 a month and nnder will b3 enrolled at annal!<br />
four -only. Clubs Associations and branches of all<br />
Inaia organisa~ions will be enrolled at Rs. 2 a year.<br />
, Secretaries of each will receive a copy of the<br />
monthly convention bullettin which will be the<br />
medIUm of communication with the members when<br />
agitation begins on a large scale.<br />
The original pledge for joining the National Convention<br />
has now been modified in order to enable<br />
the movement to grow round the Bill since the firilt<br />
pledge was intended for ca!ldidates standing for<br />
election. It now runs as follows :-<br />
•<br />
"1 promise to support the establishment in India<br />
of a free commonwealth with the King Emperor as<br />
its head WIth central and provincial G)vernments<br />
each consistiug of the King's representative, a cabinet<br />
responsible to the elected Legislature antl a judiciary<br />
, with a provision for amendment of the constitution<br />
similar to that possessed by self-Governing dominions<br />
with a providion al90 for such tr.1nsitional<br />
arrangements for army navy and air force as will<br />
bring them under Central Legislature when the<br />
Cabinet supported by Legislature declares its readi.<br />
ness to assume responsibility for the defence of the<br />
commonwealth. _<br />
I promi.se not to engage in any secret conspiracy<br />
and not to Uie any hut' peaceful (lud law-abiding<br />
means to gain the above objects."
June -12th, 192 5<br />
IN1JIJ\N OPINION<br />
Pel'8Ons not familiar with 'political details wilT be<br />
enrolled on making tl e fonowing promille8 :-I<br />
promise to work with my fellow countrymen to<br />
obtain Swaraj and to use only peaceful means for<br />
~inning it."<br />
MR. PATEL AND THE PRESIDENTS HIP<br />
OF THE ASSEl\fDLY<br />
We are somewhat surprised to learn on very good<br />
authority that Mr. V. J. Patel is a candidate for' the<br />
post of President of the Legislati ve Assembly. The<br />
election takes place, we think, next Angust when<br />
the Assembly 'Will meet for the autumn session at<br />
Simla. But already very active canvassing is Nlid<br />
to be going on. The post carries with it a monthly<br />
honorarinm of rupees four thousand and from the<br />
pecnniary point of view it is certainly something to<br />
tempt even very capable men. But at the sam8.<br />
time, acceptance of this position will mean the<br />
death of the political life of the Honourable member<br />
who may be induced to do 110. Mr. Patel is one of<br />
the stalwarts of the Swarajya Party. He is about<br />
the most uncompromising opponent of the present<br />
system of administration in thill country. He has<br />
been the most outspoken advocate of mass civil disobedience<br />
through which he believes India will<br />
achieve her political emancipation withont striking<br />
a single blow or shedding one drop of blood. For<br />
such a man to seek the presidential chair of the<br />
A8flembly means political suicide for himself and an<br />
irreparable loss of driving force to the Party· of<br />
which he is one of the most prominent leaders.<br />
Yet we hear that even his own Party is ready to<br />
vote him into this place. Perhaps the motive here<br />
is to get this inconvenient part1san Ollt of the way.<br />
J!'or it is notorious that Mr. Pat~l made Pandit<br />
Motilal's position anything but pleasant dUI'ing the<br />
passage q~, the Tariff, Act- last summer. Be >tnat<br />
however as it may, this readiness on the part of so<br />
strong 8 Swal'ajist to accept office, though it may be<br />
an elective one, does not indicate a healthy tendency<br />
in the Swarajist Party. No one who wants to fight<br />
for SW8rllj can afford just now to bury himself in<br />
the presidential chair of the legislature. If Mr.<br />
l~tel be really elected the Assembly will certainly<br />
be the pOOl'er for the loss of his fighting speeches<br />
amI his unconscious humour.<br />
MH. GANDHI'S SW ARAJ SCHEME.<br />
In the course of his presidential address at Belgaum<br />
Mr. Gandhi gave the following points for a<br />
~cheme of Swamj :-<br />
1. The qualificatiou for the franchise should be<br />
leither property nor position but manual work. such<br />
'or example as suggested for the Congress franchise.<br />
.. iterarY or property test proved to be elusive.<br />
danual wOl'k gives an opportunity to all who wish<br />
o take pru't in the government and the well-being<br />
If the State.<br />
2. The ruinous military expenditure shant.! be<br />
urtailed to the proportion necessary for protection<br />
f life and property in normal times.<br />
;1. Administration of jnstice should be cheapened<br />
£ld with that end in view the final court of appeal<br />
Ionid be not in London but in Delhi. Parties to<br />
viI suits be-compelled in the majority of cases to<br />
.fer their disputes to arbitration' the decisions of<br />
lese Panchayats to be final fXQept in cases of corlption<br />
or obvious misapphcation of law. Multiicity<br />
of intermediate courts should be avoided.<br />
LBe law should be abolished and general procedure<br />
onld be simplified. We have slavishly followed<br />
!l cumbrous and worn out English procedure. The<br />
ldency in the Colonies is to simplify the pralure<br />
110 as to make it. t.aa; tor litijltnt8 to plead<br />
I!~ l1~fi llk!elJl . ,<br />
1. Revenues from intoxicating liquors and drugs<br />
should be abolished.<br />
5. Salaries of the Civil and Military Service<br />
llhould be brought down to a level compatible with<br />
the general condition of the country.<br />
Ii. There should be re-uistribution of provinces on<br />
a lingoistic basis with as complete autonomy as<br />
possible for every province for its i~ternal administration<br />
and growth. ,<br />
7. Appointment of a commi88ion to examine aU<br />
the monopolies given to foreigners and, subject to<br />
the findings of the commi88ion. full guarantees to be<br />
given for all-vf'sted rights justly acquired.<br />
l'I. Full 'guarantee of their status to the Indian<br />
Chiefs without any hindrance from the Central Government<br />
subject to the right of asylum to subjects<br />
of these States who, not being offenders against the<br />
Ppnal Code, may seek it in Self-Governing India.<br />
, 9. Repeal Of all arbitrary powers.<br />
10. The highest post to be open to- all who may<br />
be otherwise fit. Examinations for Civil and Mili.<br />
tary Services to be in India.<br />
11. The official language for provincial govern.<br />
ment, legislatures dnd courts, within a definite<br />
period. to be the vernacular of the province: of the<br />
Privy Council, the final court of appeal, to be in<br />
Hindustani: the script to be either Devanagari or<br />
Persian. Tho language of the Central Government<br />
and of the Central Legislature to be also Hmdustani.<br />
The language of international diplomacy to be<br />
English. _<br />
~~«««~;:.~~~::~;;;:~»»> ~t<br />
iV E FROM OUR OWN CORRESPOYDENT ] .<br />
iV 14th May, 1925. i<br />
o «EE«««««
15~_~,~,~, _______________<br />
IM __ b_iA_\_N~O_P_I_N_t_O_N __________ ~Ju_n_e __<br />
i2_lt_n. __ i~_'~_~_<br />
not bnt! be impl'(>sf;Cd thai, dl,H'UetCl' in the individuals<br />
of a comlllunily makes for its FIlth at.1on and its<br />
happines:!l ~t\st as the Japanese have realised in their<br />
nation-buildmg.<br />
The Geddes Food Enqniry CommisslOn in its ,report<br />
l'ellgIDmeT).ds. the esta~lishment of a Food<br />
COllttcIJ to, supel'vise, the staple food traue, to illvestigate<br />
in consultation with local bakers' asso\!iat~(;ms<br />
thE:' fPpal'ent ,ovel'lappi ng wit,h waste of . energy<br />
and e~p~ihture in, the l;lakmg trade, to ,consider<br />
v:rhethei' consumers who have their .bread delivered<br />
should not pay for, the ~ervic.e so that bread soid<br />
accross the counter m;l.Y be ,cheaper, to IDll.iutam<br />
clos~ anll co~tinulI~g supervision on the system of<br />
fixiJ?gj the price, of br@ari by ,bakers' associations and<br />
to intervene when prIces tend to become unreasonable,<br />
to wa~ch the operations of pnce fi,xing ip. CQl,1-<br />
flectlOn with milling .by associatipns and to. mterv~ne<br />
if necessary in the in'~~;t";ests ,of ,the consumer. ,The<br />
CommissioI1 also recommends the {)ompulsory registration<br />
of all retaU butchers subject ~ the corulltions<br />
of reg:istl'y year Tor tue glittering London<br />
seaseu, In Mayfair they call him "The man with<br />
the Fairbanks smile."<br />
The Maharaflil~, of, Jodpur is busy w~t1i his polo<br />
team-the te!l;m thatwon recently both the P~ince<br />
of Wales Cnp at Delhi aud the Chamionship Cup in<br />
Calcutta.' Early in Jime their first important match<br />
will be played at Rochampton. The Maharajah has<br />
l'eeei;ved an m"9'itation'l'roru lthe Uhlted States Pvlo<br />
Associatwn to"ta.ke ht$ teani' to Airterrcil afteto the<br />
U)hdon Season, to coinpet& in the,tournameht", tlitl'l'tiI<br />
but it is not yet known whether the inVItation will<br />
be acnepted.<br />
K S. Duleepslllghjl, it hepllew of Princ.e Hanjitsinghji,<br />
the Jam ofiNa:WnagJ.r, has won il place- for<br />
h'imseWin the Cambridge UniverSity Cricket Eleven.<br />
He 'has been doing weli WIth the bat antI there are<br />
prophets whO declare thab he will yet be another<br />
Ranji-others are more wary anfl refuse' to pl'cdif't<br />
itS sul:Jh~hbldIrig1 thn.t bar -Dr. W. G. Graoo, Rlllji<br />
was the greatest liutsinan fnd' ther€'fol'e one coulJ<br />
not safely prBdict anoth(;r-Ranji. -<br />
Welt\bley is once mOl'e't4e great attraction. Thou.<br />
sands wend their way to'it byaay and in the evening.<br />
But it'is not on exhibition that one ~.m walk<br />
th~oiigliln It day. 1t 'can only be done in l,itswhich'mettns<br />
to'See it thoroughly one has to visit it<br />
a good l~any times,<br />
•<br />
'The first public employment exchange in Inaia<br />
l~a's Men ~set up in Madras accol'ding to a' report received<br />
by the International I .. abour Office of the<br />
League 'of Nations,at Geneva: , _ ,<br />
thIS is the first step in 'carrying out a pal·tiewar<br />
provision of the Internat~onal' L1lb06r C()llve'ntibIi<br />
011 unemp!uynient which has' been ratine(l by the<br />
Government of1ndia.<br />
This Convention was adoHtect hy the fir:;t. ail;~ua!<br />
se'l~ion of the Intemational Labonr Oonf"'l'enca hel11<br />
at Washi.ngton in 19H1 and prOVIdes for the ealss. to guat,) then!<br />
from injury, to observe til) cQnBtit\l~ion, and tho<br />
laws of tbe Fe~eration. to fulfill PlY ltntleK con,<br />
scientiously. and to do justice to, every ,man:'1 ~.~<br />
help me God." FrOl;I1 all accounts. jt w~s ,a ,tluit,e<br />
affair. The accession o( ,HiUltenbufl~ to power ha~<br />
been rooeive(l without enthutliaslU on the Contment<br />
and ~n lj:ngland. ,<br />
••<br />
The 'London County, Coancil is probably ,the<br />
largest Corporation in the wortd. Recently th~y<br />
sat throllgh the night-conttllnonsly for 21 bours in i<br />
all-mid yesterday from 2.30 p .. m. in the afternoon I<br />
to 1-30 a.m.·nithe morning;' The members of the'<br />
Council evidently are no shirkers.<br />
I ( ;- f ~ I '. • ,. , ... ' I<br />
WJtb the,passmg ..attvay.of. Juord..~IiIn.er •. yet(llnother'l?;reat<br />
figure has been removed from the. B.d.<br />
tish Empire.l i Lord Milner, wire) WillI-, 71. ' was a<br />
bachelor. unhlltheage.of 61,. when he ma.rl'ied .the "<br />
widow of,Lord Edwa.rd Oecil.., He li?a.TeB ntl-' hell U<br />
and by' his death tile- Vi~county VeOOIDIPS ex1inct
3t"lian<br />
,_/<br />
@viniolt<br />
.. rNo. 2S-Vol. XXIII. Friday, June 19th, 1925.<br />
Recistered ."be o. P. o •••• Ne ..... per<br />
PalC", Fou..,.".,",<br />
NOTES<br />
4,,,<br />
AND NEWS<br />
------------------- to fight with: the British have kept them from<br />
'1\\ CABLEGRAl\I from Darjeeling reports the sad getting any arms.<br />
&1\ news of the death of the Lord Mayor of Ca1- But I assure you the British know that if India<br />
cut13 Mr. C. R. DdS. the great Indian leader flames into revolt. if all the three huntlred minion<br />
an,l pnblic wOJ·ker. The. forward movement in tonk to cutting the railroads an,l the telegraph lines.<br />
In,lia rpcpivell a Hpt-1Jack hy snch a g1'f'at loSE!. We aud burning down the factori(>8 and the government<br />
hope in our next iflilue to refer to the life and \"ferk buildings. the little handful of white pf'ople w"uld<br />
of the late Mr. Dati. find their military force perilously inatiequatf'. ~<br />
We are compelled. whether we wIlLor- not. to·<br />
The funeral of the late Mr. Wm. Hosken took recognise that in the Hindu we are de-alillg with a<br />
place in Johannesburg. The Natal Indian Congress great people, having a very old civilisation. and an<br />
placed It wreath on his grave and also sent the intellectual and spiritual tradition as high as our<br />
following telegr,lm to his family in Johannesburg :- own and in some ways higher. _ ,<br />
"Natal Indianll deeply grieved your great lOBS That is what Gandhi's soul force is doing; it is<br />
pray 00,1 rl'store pl'ace on his soul."<br />
making all of us stop and think. It has made some<br />
The death occurrpd at Paris of the famous In(lian<br />
Prince. in the person of Hia HighneilS l\Iaharajah<br />
8indhia of GWaIiol'. Hon. Lieut..General in the British<br />
Army and Hon. and Extra Aid-de-Camp to the<br />
King. ,puring t,he Great War the Prince rendered<br />
Biuna! Bervice by organising the hospital ship<br />
T..o)·alty. in 1!H4. and financing it for the duration<br />
of the War, lind. in addition, his troops fought with<br />
distinction in Francl'. East Africa, Egypt aud Mesopatamia.<br />
His beir. to whom the King stood sponsor,<br />
Id only nine Yl'ars oL age.<br />
There paS.'led away on the It.ith instan,t" after a<br />
krief ilInl's.'!. at the Ilge of eighteen years. Wilfred<br />
J.auril'l Sigamoney, the eldest son _of Mr. B. L, E.<br />
8iWlmoney, at 8ydenham antI his mortal remains<br />
wt>rEl laid to rest at the Christ Church Cemf'tery on<br />
the 17th instant at a~lO p.m. in the presence or'a<br />
large numbl'r of relatives and friends, among whom<br />
were many prominf'nt members of the Indian community,<br />
amid mnnifestations of general grief. The<br />
cortege proc{l('ded from his father's resi
154 INDIAN OPIN ION June 19th, 1925<br />
----------------------~--~--------~~~~~sta~i.on,<br />
decorated with flags, bunting anu evergreens,<br />
whICh was admired by young and old. On the arch<br />
~ere the following words, beautifully written.<br />
Welcome to Colenso, Indian Communitv." H.R.H.<br />
arrived on Tuesday evening and passed throngh the<br />
archway, and after inspecting the ex-ServICemen,<br />
Mr. Ebrahim R. Ismail (of NIzamoodeen Coy.)'<br />
was. introduced as the representative of the IndIan<br />
community by Mr. Moyers, of the' electrification.<br />
Mr. Ismail presented, in the name of the Indian<br />
community, a beautiful address of welcome, and<br />
added a few well chosen worus WhICh R.R H. duly<br />
acknowled~d. He inquired whether the IndIan<br />
community was large in Colenso. after receiving a<br />
fqr:mal -reply H.R.H. moved off towards the stahon<br />
amidst the cheering of the large crowd assembl@d to<br />
pay their homage to their future King.<br />
Wil1i~m HoskE'n showed 11irn'leH to he Ollr great(>'lt<br />
friencl in our time of greatest need. We (',m<br />
never forget hig friendship. To hi~ re1.\tiveQ WE'<br />
offer, on behalf {)f our Iellow-coUlotrympn throughout<br />
South Africa, and many now in India, h(>artfeh<br />
sympathy. Only Mr Gandhi himself ('ouM T;,.~~ ~~\'''' ~\e,<br />
:roUes b,ut ~e ~as bUlJt a ~:"e sun shone. .., The i\1r HO'lken alon lY with snch' well-kn ·wn Ell npean<br />
, P> 0 1 .<br />
is said to ('clip,e every ~ covel' and walked boldly fnends aq ~fr. Albert C,utright, Rev. J, .J. au',<br />
'the MaharMah o!-fT The Prince conld not Will Mr H. Kallenbach, Rev. Chas PhllJip~, Mr David<br />
>l'""<br />
in L()(ie.nn. -Pollack, Rev ,Tobn H'Jf\vard, and others, formee!' a<br />
~<br />
, ,<br />
Comm ttee of Sympathisers which exerted II trelTIPnriolls<br />
po"er fqr good. As chairman (If that<br />
TIlE LATB MR. WiLLIAM nOSKEN<br />
,1~NE by one the old staunch fl iends nf the<br />
'&)J Indian coIIl,munity pass away. In the<br />
death of Mr. William HosKen, ono of t,:e<br />
best of our very :goou. friends and helpet~, .the<br />
Indian people, especially of the Transvu,ll, ha\Oe<br />
suffered irrep1l'uble loss Well d(r we rememhpr his<br />
noble endeavo'urs on behalf ot anI' community<br />
when it Was in tbe tbl'oes of a tcrlIble strnggle for<br />
\Self-respect and very existence, ~Iany tllnes he<br />
aoted as mediatol' and, spent a great deal of his<br />
time, as chairman of the Enropean Committee of<br />
Sympllthisers, in battling with the clifficlllt qne'ltions<br />
which a' the time of tl,e Pas'live Re'li.tance<br />
Struggl,t},were SO,aCll e. Not only did hI' tlRe his<br />
great inaue Ice and tl10ral qnalities in fightll1g, on<br />
tJ-tri' behalf, General EilJt1IlIS and a Stu1lbol"n (fov·<br />
ernttlent, but he frecj,Uf'otly did ~l'eat eervi .. e by<br />
~tandlng alongside Mr, Ganrlhi and the [n,li.1n<br />
leaders on pUQlio platforms, and t,here put forth<br />
his persuasive powers in c~lming and reasoning<br />
',N'ith SOIlW·,ot ou~ countrym!1n who sometimes were<br />
slo\V ~ I follow the somewhat delicate nl'gr)tiation'l<br />
which were being carrieo on be. ween the Indian I<br />
leaders and the Minister rf'presenting the Government<br />
With perhaps the one eKception of the<br />
late Mr. Doke, we can safely say thlit the late Mr,<br />
I Committee, JMr. Hosken took a b()ld st
, Jqn~' 19th. 19.25 INDIAN OJ1INJON I5S<br />
-- ~-------~-------------------~~--.-~------------~--------------------~<br />
t~ my ~ery conviotion, if, in a time JikG thill. wMn' gaol" during the passive lesit and West is West. He has also<br />
Nevertheless he dill not hesit.tte to boldly speak suggested, as is well-known all over the world, that<br />
for justice and fairplay After stating his reasons , the twain shall not meet. Professor Chu admits<br />
why he could not support the Chamber's resr]ution,<br />
Mr, Hosken went an to'speak of p'l8sive resis<br />
the Chinese professor holds that, although it IS true<br />
the first part and rejects the second, In other words,<br />
tance OR a'weapon':- ,<br />
that there are clear-cut distinctions between the<br />
civilisations of East and West, the two civilisations<br />
Passive resistance' had ever been the defence, must meet in bmes to come. But how is it true that<br />
especially in their own nation, of those who had these two ci vilisatlOns are entIrely dIfferent from each<br />
he en legislated agaim t unfairly. and wit/lout their other? First of all, the Western civihsation began<br />
consent and approval. He thought that passIve near the sea. Greece founded her national greatness<br />
reslstance'was dl:-lItined to De t4e ,great' weapon of upon navigation, and her greatee!: adivities were on<br />
democracy, destined' Iiot "only to bring about an the sea, The sea is 'uncontrollable. To struggle<br />
ameHoraUon of the exploited ploletliriat of the world, with the sea is a most trYing and hardening exercise.<br />
but also 'to' brinli about the 'universal peace of tq.6 Consequently, to one who-attempts it, it means the<br />
worM. ,RuBsia Had' given tis an eX~J1lple of passive reqllirements of vigour and force: it develops group<br />
resiBtance; England at: the present moment-"'Was a-ction, expedition and commerce. Roman civihsation,<br />
as..every other European civilisation, was the<br />
showing DS an example of pa!JBivf resist'ance .('egarding<br />
the education movemerH:, ,A~ be ,lo95ed a~ it it fnlition of thIS process of growth. On the other<br />
was tht noblest ot every nation who were organised hand. thE: Eastern CIvilisation was an inland one,<br />
into passive rel!istance, at'! oeing th'e most effective As a whole, Western civilisation has developed<br />
weapen to,'llleet the difficulties in front of them. through an active struggle with men and nature,<br />
'{'hey were toW it wasa dangeJ' becau$e'of the native while the East has been nourished and nurtured by<br />
people. They must also beat' 'in mthd that unless nature, fostering in time philosophy and tradition.<br />
they tried to treat these natives faIrly 'and righteously The Hindus in art and philosophy, teptesent a distinct<br />
type of Eastern civilisation, Due to fertile<br />
they would drive them Into pa!!sive ,reflistance, and<br />
he thought it would, come, if in the flltllre they soil and warm climate and abundance of nature's<br />
went on administrating as'they were doing to-day. !lUpply. India is naturally a home for leisure, medi·<br />
THB MESSAGE OF, GENERAL BOTHA tation and mlstioism. Wells in pis "Outline of History"<br />
says: 'The history of India for many centu<br />
Mr. Hoakeu, though' a friend of the oppressed,<br />
was at one despondent. He thOught that we were ries had been happier, less fierce and more dreamlike<br />
than of any other country." It is the circum<br />
fighting for a forlon battle and 'hE', out Of regard and<br />
love for \lit, addre~ the historic meeting of 31st stances and environment which have made West'<br />
July. l!l07, at PI'etoria. He ,Ielivrred to the meetinu<br />
the mes..'l.'lge of General ~o~ha that. whilst that vigour, restlessness, agi'rE'ssi\'enes,'l, mtolerance, group<br />
masculine. Not only is the West marked by force and<br />
~ent1eman felt for us, he was sure that we wer!J organisation and action. but even in art the West is<br />
"kicking a~aiust the pricks," ,Th~ General, tbrou~h masculine. The East il feminine, and because it is<br />
Mr. Hosken, advised 11S to abandon the straggle and faminine her people have never been aggressive.<br />
how to the Inevi!al;!le., Mr. Hosken emphasised the The weak side of the Eastern civilisation is its inefficiency<br />
in handling the practical phases of human<br />
point by declaring tha~ Gen~1i'lLl BoJha could not reo<br />
peal the Asiatic Act even if he wisped. That most enthusiastic<br />
meeting held in th~"coinpound and under intrinsic merits. The Eastern people did not ex<br />
lift'. Bllt the Eastern civilisation has its many<br />
the shadows nf the sacred I\{osqu'e respectfully de plore the ocean extensively I nor did they dIscover the<br />
CliI eu to I\CCel"t Mr, Hoske.n's advice amI unauimou!!l),<br />
l'$!-afflrmed .its re$Olntion to continue the ful. pasSive and tolerant, they seldom committed<br />
new wovld. But as they were careful ami thollgh~<br />
IItJ'uggle l\ntll the obnoxious Act was repealed. The· serious blunderl! OJ' crimes. It. ill the writer's belief<br />
lIame !\Ir. Uoaken. When he realiSed our IItrength of that the :Ealtteru oivilil!8tion is on the whole more<br />
purpoRt'\ expresiled bie regret that he evE'l' advised hnmape and more Wholesome than the Weetern.<br />
us to abandon snoh a great IItruggle.<br />
• China for example, has asaimilated manr raceSI )'e'<br />
,~R. HOSKEY HO~OURED<br />
there has been DO hann done, to any. Mio and Yio,<br />
the two abori8lnal tribes of China have been living<br />
for more'than four thol.sand years in the interior of<br />
China enjoyin'g their self-govE'rnment and citizenship<br />
privileges; bnt it is well-known what has 1:1ecome<br />
of ~Re
INDIAN OPINION<br />
organisation and co-operation are manifest in India<br />
and China. And if the East is changing, surely the<br />
Western civilisation cannot last in its present form.<br />
If it goes on unmodified, it will ultimately result in<br />
self-destruction. We need not allude to another<br />
world war for a warning. Let us take only industry<br />
for discussion. Most of the Western Powers are<br />
struggling for a world market. Big capitali~ts and<br />
corporations are no longer Ilatisfied WIth local or<br />
national exploitation. All are looking for world<br />
control. The present rate of production is tremendous;<br />
the rate of consumption of natural resources is<br />
also astonishing. For the next hundred years, even<br />
allowing that the r.1te of consumption remains the<br />
same, lumber, oil, rubber and even coal wIll suffer<br />
considerable loss, if not near-exhaustion. Would<br />
not this be a big catastrophe to the people of the<br />
twenty-first century? Granted that the natural resources<br />
be sufficient to last for ever, the industrial<br />
progress still cannot go on Inchecked. The We&t<br />
needs a temple bell to rest; and the East will provid.e<br />
her with it. On the other hand, the East needs<br />
the bugle call to action, and she will have it from<br />
the West. The twain shall indeed meet if the twain<br />
shall hve.<br />
THE PRESENT LULL AND ITS CAUSE<br />
The present political lull in the country is now<br />
universally noticed. What does it signify? Is it<br />
the lull that precedes the storm or is it the lull that<br />
settles down in the country after a terrific storm?<br />
Or are the people tired of making seemingly fruitless<br />
efforts and thus allow things to drift as best<br />
they may? Or are they waiting for a powerful<br />
lead and a powerful programme to rouse them from<br />
their present apathy or is the lull the final word<br />
symptomatic of a state of helplessness without an)'<br />
future, WIthout any gain? Who will ~ive us the<br />
right answer to all these querries! Personally we<br />
are of the opinion that not one but several causes<br />
have contributed towards the present state of<br />
national listlessness. The nation was subjected in<br />
the past five years to a state of high pressure.<br />
"Swaraj within one year," was the slogan that, U11-<br />
doutedly, lifted the country off its feet. The prospect<br />
of the future was too allurmg and bright and<br />
the prize was worth the natlon's best (Jfforts. To its<br />
credit these efforts were ~oon forthcoming, but the<br />
expected Swaraj dld not materialise. The expected<br />
happened. The raging storm of high hopes yoked<br />
to high efforts was ilucceeded by a state of exhaustion<br />
and hopelessness. You cannot keep a racer for<br />
a long hme under the reim.. The leaders made th&<br />
nation run like a racer, with the rEsult that the<br />
latter got soon exhausted. This lost ground the<br />
nation has never been able to recover and from the<br />
initial defeat subsequent disasters have followed.<br />
That state of implicit confidence and hope on the<br />
part of the nation that always is the most valuable<br />
asset possessed by leaders, once lost was lost for<br />
ever. Subsequent f'iforts, following ever-changing<br />
programmes, grew weaker and weaker till the present<br />
state of complete inertia was reached. In the<br />
meantime, Gandhiji 'Tas sent to gaol, and we all<br />
know what followed his involuntary incarceration.<br />
We have always pronounced the great political<br />
awakening as a one man's show. It was Mahatma<br />
Gandhi here, Mahatma Gandhi there and Mahatma<br />
Garidhi everywhere. Gandhiji, practically, for the<br />
time being, had become the nation's head, eyes, ears,<br />
hands, feet-everything I It was a picture of most<br />
wonderful personal triumph ever achieTed by a<br />
singl~ndividual in any part of the world. But<br />
few reali~' d that the picture WdS most humiliating<br />
fQr a natio 1 of 300 millions of people who were a<br />
bllimoUl'in with all their mi'iht and ~al11 that the,<br />
were fit for Swaraj and yet could show to the world<br />
only one m.1n who was capable of being the nation's<br />
leader. No wonder, the enemies of India, were not<br />
slow in taking hold of this fact as a valuable handle<br />
to turn against Indians for their Swarajic pretf'llsioDs.<br />
And sad to say when Gandhiji was in prison, the<br />
condition of other leaders was such as to provide a<br />
powerful justification for the adverse criticisms of "<br />
India's opponents for Rwaraj. Let us say that!.<br />
Gandhi jI'S sndden illness in prison was a God-sent<br />
event. It was a blessing in disguise, for it provided<br />
the Government with a welcome excuse to f'et free<br />
their illuitrious prlsoner with a show of grace and<br />
favour. Gandhiji's liberty revised the drooptn/t<br />
.spIrits of the nation, but it' was only a temporary<br />
'revival. The lost ground was' never regained and<br />
the process of drift proceeded slowly but surely.<br />
In the meantime, let it b61 frankly acknowlf'dged.<br />
that the coming into life of the Swarajic Party un·<br />
del' Mr. C. R, Das was a great blow to Gandhiji's<br />
prestige and position. Peace was patched np betw~n<br />
the two great leaders. but there is not the<br />
least manner of doubt, that both are tilling their<br />
own furrows in their own sweet way and pleasure.<br />
Gandhiji's faith in khaddar is sublime. He swears<br />
by khaddar, he lives for khaddar and is prepared to<br />
die for khaddar. On the other hand Mr. Das's faith<br />
in Council-destruction is no If'ss sublime. He<br />
visualises Swaraj by methods of destruction and his<br />
political BIble teaches him to give no quarter to<br />
Government. Obviously, Mr. DdS'S new and dynamic<br />
programme was grasped by the nation with<br />
enthusiastic avidity, and for the time being, everybody<br />
was a Swarajist in the sense of Councils-destruction.<br />
But Council destruction was a nine-days'<br />
wonder and very soon the new toy lost its primary<br />
shine. Councils were destroyed and yet the whef'ls<br />
of Government turn.ed with Swaraj as distant as<br />
ever. Even the firmost advocates of DdSian politics<br />
are now convinced that once again the nation must'<br />
acknowledge Dasian political tactics as a failure. The<br />
ratSOI& d'eire of Council-destruction IS to paralyse the<br />
Government in its administrative capacity and as<br />
long as this consummation is not reached or reali~ed,<br />
the Dasian programme must and ought to be as a<br />
failure. In the meantime, Dr. Annie 8l'sant has<br />
been concocting her special medicine, her own<br />
special panacea for winning Swaraj. We are sorry<br />
to say that hel' 10ng-\1atched Convention-Scheme ha'l<br />
fallen fiat in the country. Very few take it seriously,<br />
and indeed it is whispered on all hands that the<br />
proverbial mountain has been in labour and has<br />
been brought to bed of a tiny mouse. This then, is<br />
a short summary of the country's present political<br />
situation. Gandhiji's political force has visibly<br />
diminished, Swarajists have cantered forcibly in the<br />
field of action but they have not achieved much,<br />
and Dr. Besant's much-advertised panacea bids fair<br />
to be nothing better than a polical quackery. To<br />
make confusion worse confounded, leadf'rs of lesser<br />
lustre, but highly useful all the sa'me, have fallen<br />
out with one another. It is a wise and true saying<br />
that when doctors differ, the .patient is ?ound to<br />
Buffer, and poor India, a political invalid. is now<br />
suffering because her political doctors are fighting<br />
and trying to find out in a most meticulous the difference<br />
between twiddled om and twiddledee! Before<br />
a round-table conference between Indian leaders<br />
and the Government nominltcs ever materialises,<br />
there is now far greater need for Indian leaders of<br />
all pohtical parties to meet at a round-table conference<br />
and after revising the past to ooncert an united<br />
programme for a joint action In the future.
June 19t~1925 __________ I_N_D __<br />
INDIA'S nSE TO TIlE EMPIRE<br />
While Lord l'tIt'8ron and the other "friends" of<br />
India are doing their best to prevent collapse of the<br />
administration by recruiting campaigns at the Univerllitie8,<br />
less ~
-"V~nd~mataram" and received Mahatma Gandhi as<br />
the' prophet of a new age, India's leader and the<br />
politlca~ saviour. All communities were fully represente'd<br />
at the station.<br />
A large number of Europeans eagerly watched<br />
the moat dramabc scene and probably considered it<br />
a glorious moment in. their hfe, remembermg that<br />
in no country in the world a living personahty<br />
was so much honoured as the Mahatma. Calcutta<br />
offered a' princely reception to Mahatma<br />
Gandhi whlCh wlll be remembered for a long time<br />
to come. '<br />
A UNIQUE HONOUR TO ONE OF INDIA'S<br />
SONS<br />
On December 5th "The Grasselli Medal" of the<br />
Societ~ of Chemical Industry was awarded to Dr.<br />
Bairam D. Saklatwalla, at the Chemist's Club meetmg<br />
in New York. About 100 prominent chemists<br />
attended the meeting. The presentation address was<br />
made by Dr. Wilham H. Nichols, himself a noted<br />
chemist and chairman of the board of directors of<br />
the Allied Dye & ChemlCal Oorporation.<br />
• Dr. Saklatwalla went to Germany with a Tata<br />
techmcal scholarship and recelved the degree of<br />
Eng. D. from the Royal Politechnicum Charlottenberg<br />
III 1908. He was a Oarnegic Research scholar<br />
at the British Iron & Steel Instltute during 1908-<br />
1909. In 1910 he came to the Umted States. He<br />
is a member of many sClentIfic societies. He is one<br />
of the only two IndIans whose name appears in the<br />
biographies of the "American Men of Science."<br />
Dr. Saklatwalla first acted as Research chemist at<br />
the VanadIUm Oorporation of America where lie<br />
later became the General Superintendent. Recently<br />
he has been elected to be the Vice-President of the<br />
company.<br />
Dr. Saklatwalla is perhaps the first and only Indian<br />
who has distingUIshed himself internationally<br />
in the Industrial chemical field. HIS achievement<br />
marks the begiuning of a new era in India in the<br />
conquest of India's most needed problem-the industria1-<br />
economlC problem. His accomplishment is<br />
of great sigmficance to modern IndIa. It is extremely<br />
unfortqnate that a man "whose achievements alone<br />
made possible the Vanadium Industry III America."<br />
could not have utlhsed for the service of hls Motherland.<br />
~'t =tct~lGJ'1.4. ("Utt{l~l ~i&l~i'<br />
~. :llil:fl~rll ~lat-tl :/J{~~~i ~'l.l~~)<br />
" ~tli' ~a'<br />
~(1~!H :tUi' ~.<br />
jUHi(4!H "Utl~d ~~.<br />
'tL~t1it ~i;q,rf, ~lULl ~~ tIt\
Friday, June 26th, 1925.<br />
iteci.teredaltheG.P.O._ aN_po<br />
PIIlC. Foa ... "".<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
~,\'<br />
l\\.VOT even G .. ndhi or Tilak was ever the centre bnted something distinctive." Every Race and<br />
A'\! of such a demonstration as markl'd the Cune- Nation has, of course, "something distinctive" but<br />
ral procession of Das on Thursday, says the why does not BI'itain import Ii proportion of each<br />
Morn;,,,/ /'osl'8 Calcutta correspon.lent. It is im- into her Civil Service?<br />
, possible to estimate the crowd, and it can only he<br />
said that countless thousdnds assembled in thA<br />
- - -<br />
In connection with the South African Asiatic<br />
vicinity of the station at six o'clock in the moming.<br />
They came from the outlying districts. some m ex-<br />
Policy the New IndUl writes :-<br />
-. The statement by Dr, ,)falan, Minister of Interior<br />
pensi ve motors, others using lorries, bicycles, tr.vp-· in t?e Unio~ Go,vern.ment. of South Africa, forel<br />
cars and carts. The arrangements for a procession castmg the mtroductlon of legislation embodying<br />
rnlIdpHecI immediately the train bringing the coffin the Government's Asidtic policy at the end of the<br />
al'rived. The handful of police alld volunteers in' present session of the Soutb Afrjcdn Pdrliament will<br />
attendance were hopeleasly swamped, and progress' ~ause nq surprise. While the Government of India<br />
became impossible. Of the scores of aged Indians' IS ~attering it~el~ by thin~ing that it is engaged in<br />
with whom the correspondent talked, not olle failed, dehcate negotIatIOns, the South African Government<br />
10 remark that he had never seen anythlnl4 approach-,<br />
ing the sight pr(senwd by this vast and ,motley<br />
merrIly goes Its way with tvmahawk in hdnd. If<br />
the proposal for a Ronnd Tdble Conference had any<br />
collection of humanity. It had been arrangl'd that chance of accep~ce, the. Union O..overnment \yould<br />
the procesl!lion should make a seven-mile detour to surely have deCIded to WIthhold legislation till after<br />
the blnping Gh'st, and it was expectt'd that the the Conference had beeu held. '115: there no limit<br />
jourpey, would OQcuPy three honrs. But the first<br />
two miles occllpied, an hour each, progl'ess being<br />
w?ic~ a Do~iDlon Oavern~ent' rna'y not overstep<br />
~Ith ImpuDlty, even in the exercise, of its rights in<br />
made'by inches. Gdndhi came specially to Cdlcutta, domestic" matters?<br />
and, wearing only a loincloth, WIlS carried on the'<br />
Mr. A. P. Chou.dr~e of Dnrban writ~s dwlo),ing<br />
sholllders of 'volunteers immediately behind the·<br />
the apatby of IndIan community of Durba.n, particularly<br />
mentioning the Sold demise ~t 'tile Idte Mr.<br />
bier, on which.wreaths werf'l thrown by the hundred.<br />
Every vantage point alonll the route was occupied, C. R. DdS.<br />
wilJdows being crowded while traffic was completely<br />
suspended. In the markets most of the shops were<br />
closed, indeed the CIty was in a state of chaos. From<br />
all parts of the cOllntry rep'orts are coming of hart,lIs<br />
&nil condolem;e meEltinQs, A most extraordinary'<br />
DEATH OF MH. DAS<br />
atmosphere prevails. ~.
!NDIAN OPINION<br />
June 26th, 19z5<br />
fate of all who strive to lead our nation into free<br />
'dom. ".<br />
We 'have no doubt that others will be found to<br />
tako up the work Mr. Das has laid down Just as<br />
we say: "The King is dead, long live the King ;"<br />
so must we say' "A great leader is dead, long<br />
live the leaders." While the nation mourns a<br />
great 108"!, it must look to the next man' take up<br />
the burden until we reach the goal,<br />
On behaH of the Indian community of South<br />
Africa, we extend to the relatives, friends and coworkers<br />
of t\J.e late Mr D.ls, our heartfelt sympathy,<br />
and pray that the same spirit of sacrifice and<br />
publIo service may fiU the hearts of those "ho<br />
follow in his footsteps.<br />
THE LATE MR. C. R. DAS<br />
BRIEF SKE1'CH m' HIs LIFE<br />
, From the C .ngress Diary, 1923, we learn the<br />
following interestlllg facts concerning the life of<br />
the late Mr. 0. R. Das ,-<br />
Ohitta Ranjan. Dlls was born liLt Calcutta on 5th<br />
November,1870 He was the second child of his<br />
pate ltS. He was educated first in the T...ondon<br />
Missionary Colle,ge, Rhowanipore, whence he<br />
matncubted in 1886, ang subRequently m the<br />
Pl esidency Oollege Calcutta, whence he took his<br />
B A. degree in 1890 After taking his degree he<br />
went to England originally with tile idea of competing<br />
for the 1. C. S. ~ut events happened which<br />
saved his being drafted into "the heaven-born service"<br />
He,took an active part in the electioneering<br />
campaign of Dadabhai Naoroji and his speeches<br />
-attracted attention both 'in England and India.<br />
Later on, when Mr. John Maclean, M. P, in the<br />
course of a lecture made certain extremely off~JUsive<br />
remarks against tho Hindus and the Mussulmans,<br />
Chitta Ranjan Das. organised a meeting of<br />
Lhe Indians in England to prote'lt again-.t Mr<br />
Maclean's cOllduct and made a 'powerful speech, as<br />
a result of which Mr. Maclean was forced to apolog'Se<br />
and 'resign his seat in_ Parliament. Soon after<br />
he was lped now by God Himself." His sacrifice<br />
is so great that it has elicited admiration even<br />
from high-s'"'uled Englishmen. Sir Michael Sadler,<br />
the late President of the Calcutta University<br />
Commission, wrote in the London Times: -''Chitto<br />
Ranjan's wonderful sacrifice (Rs. 6fXXJ01- a<br />
month) is unparalleled in the history of the world.<br />
Indians would do well to follow him"<br />
Chitta Ranjan's entry into Bengali Legislature<br />
dates fl'om 1895 when he published a volume of<br />
Beng (Ii lyrics calJed Malancha. He started in 1915<br />
a new Bengali monthly' The Narayana.' He has<br />
published Ma.la, Antaryami, Kishore-Kishori and<br />
Sagar Saugit. Iu religious views he is a Vaishnavita<br />
of the Chaitanya school. He retaio.s some of<br />
his f..ther's views of the Brahmo Samaj.<br />
From his ea.Tly days of his life Chitt..l. Ranja.n<br />
took an abated interest in the development of &If<br />
Government in his land and had been an active,<br />
thou,gh not a vociferous member of the aflnual<br />
gatherings of the Congress and of the provincial<br />
organisatlOns. But hiS real entry into practical<br />
politics dates from the internment of Mrs Annie<br />
Besant. He-addressed many meptingl to protest<br />
against the inu-rnment of many yOWlg men under<br />
the Defence of India Act. In response to ,be Premier's<br />
appea' for more rpcruitment to tlJe army he<br />
spoke again and again urging the release of t1~<br />
interned. Henceforward iu all his political SPeeches<br />
he emphasi~ed our cla.ims to resp'lusible Government<br />
He is a stauDch believer in the immediate<br />
fitness of India for Swaraj. Of all the ~er\\ in<br />
Bengal Chitta Ranjan was the first to rally roU1~d<br />
\fahatma Ganrlhi in preaching the Satyagraha.<br />
He was a. membAr of the Committee deputsi by<br />
the Indian Noltiona.l Con~ress til conduct an independent<br />
inquiry of the Pu.njab disturbances. As<br />
Mr. Das was convinced that the nf)W Reforms did
, - .<br />
DQt":.tna'tetially~ -!t!ter" the situation, he oePo3ed<br />
C()4)[Mtati)'D with tnen\ al the A mritsar C()Dgres"!<br />
thouJ:,ih l'host"" o£ 'the leadets including M.Lhaim:i<br />
G1l.til:lhr,,'efe ih IIavour' of the Reforms<br />
,<br />
tNblAN btttNtu~<br />
'Alld in<br />
a,V ,rr21.)~hiUty be wO!Jld hav!-l kept back,~r6m Ji?lit'f.'~~.~\lt<br />
vnpt~lN .ev~,n~ f1~~pf,lr!ld, which lletermined<br />
,tlie, ne~t rftagp, In hljl'p'Jl!tlf'a career. ttnat event<br />
• .,! ~,8 J ~~~: r~~. 9£ Npn-qG-operation movement, i In<br />
t~~lYl~nnU?,g lie w3s,i¥>t.in f.lVQur of withdrawing<br />
st],la.egtl, !rolJl.scn~Is aD4 Coil gl'8 and boycotting<br />
LilW·.QO\ltt'J. ~I,l.t QtjNagp~.r, a prplf"lDged discus.<br />
s¥Jl:v,.ithIMa\lat¥13 .,Oqnnhj convil\
)62 , INDIAN OPINION June 26th, III 5 ,i-<br />
I<br />
The articie of faith of this party was to enter the<br />
Council, and' oppose on 'the floor' of the house all<br />
He abandoned his flourishing practice which ex-;\<br />
ceeded £5000 a month. He disposed of his furniactions<br />
of the Gov8l'hmet1t which were deemed to tares and properties and devoted aU the proceeds t()<br />
curtail the 'rights, Jjrivileges and powers of the charitable purposes. Born and hrl'd in the lap of 1<br />
people.. The central idea of this Party was to dis- fortune, he took the vow of simplicity and became I<br />
organise the system of Govern'tnent so as to compel the prince of patriots. ' ,<br />
it to expedite the gra.nt of a full responsible Govern- When the call of India [m· Non-eo-operation j<br />
ment on 'a Dominion status; and the sea.t of this reached Bengal, he courted imprisrmtnoot followl'tl<br />
cousti£uti0nal fight 'Was waged in Bengal. The late by 30,000 students whose sfJul he ver\y W.lS. He'<br />
Mr. Das was ()ffered the Premiership of Bengal, became the leader of India in 1921 after M.lhatmawhich<br />
he refused. He was elected as the Lord Mayor Gandhi had been sent to prison. He was elected<br />
of 'Calcutta and was re-elected this' year to that President of the Indian N.ltil)nal Congress, at G\ya,)<br />
unique civic post.<br />
the highest honour which Hindl\stan can confer on<br />
Although 'he deferred ft'om Mahatma Gandhi, he her children. He was many times elected Presi,lent<br />
loved an,d-admired him for his sincerity Of purpose of the Bengal Provincial Con~r'ess and w,~ virtu ,lIy<br />
as also, fQr his:matchIess patriotism. ' - \ - , "the uncrowned 'King" 'uf Bang.d.! H3 I was' the<br />
Das 'was a man of iron will and lately he openly leadei- '6f the Swar.ljistlf and J.t)rl M l~or of Cahmtta.:<br />
conuemned acts of anal'chism, which raised it head It was he who brought about the -(l~d\ock in the<br />
her
•<br />
June 26th. 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
dll parties in that country is necel!8al"Y for the preservation<br />
of a White South Afrim. should be sanctioned<br />
by statute or by subsidiary legislation nnder<br />
statute. If a policy of colour discrimination is to be<br />
followetl. it matters little whether the policy is embodied<br />
in law or in mere regulations; but in one<br />
rellpect it is mucA better to have sppcific legislation<br />
"~'ng Ilanction to this policy J".\ther than keep up an<br />
nppearancp /'If equality'in the laws of the country<br />
RntI proville for every kind of (listinction in regulationa.<br />
to which public attention is not 80 easily<br />
drawn. Since the best means of obtaining redreB8 of<br />
an injustice is to expose it to the ~rntiny of the<br />
worIJ. An all its nakedness. the native of Sonth Africa<br />
will.lostt pothil)g bnt gain ~ethil\gJ by having th~<br />
coIQ'r. b~ inserted in the I\'"ry, laws of the country<br />
In.~ 9f wJ'll.ppizw it, up in l'Pgulations. Already<br />
the ~onscience otJCood Christian men has spoken ont<br />
verf!st~nglv ag.unstthis idea of keeping out natives<br />
from certain occupations merely because they wear<br />
black SkillS. but the idea has nothing new about it:<br />
it is being consistently put in effect for several years<br />
past. ,Yet the main point in the denunciation of th~<br />
Churc4es is that the measure is "a disastrOus innovation."<br />
etc.. It is neW only in the sense that it has<br />
attracted attention now in quarters where it had BO<br />
far escaped notice.<br />
Asiatics too are specifically mentioned in this<br />
legislatio~. They may be excluded just li}ce natives<br />
from any of the occupations which the Union<br />
GOYernmrnt wish to kecp as a preserve for the<br />
whites. Gen~l Smuts has cnriously enough esponsed<br />
the cause of Indiana on this point and has<br />
already earned the encomiuJDs of superficial observers.<br />
But anyone who carern~ly reads the speech<br />
which G~"eral Smuts made on the Bill in the Union<br />
Pllrliament will see that he is not opposoo. by any<br />
means to EliscriPlil)ating against Asiatics if such discrimination<br />
is neQesBary in order to maiptain white<br />
SUPl'PQlac1'J~~~.!ltJ1.f~!Cla'li !ll ~ha~ he ohjects is<br />
tha~!,lruliall4 'Art,AsJlliiCl}! sho~ld ,be mentioned eo<br />
nom~, iJ\. th~<br />
legis,ation. ".oenenij, Smuts has no<br />
doubt cM8is~nUy ,avoide4 a reference to Asiatics as<br />
suob in all antj-Asiatic legislation that he promoted.<br />
The Class Areas mll. for instance. which was<br />
directed against Indians and which was infinitely<br />
more drastic in its reaction on them thirn the present<br />
Colonr Bar Bm. still did not directly mention InlUans.<br />
III, it seriously meant that our opposition<br />
should b.e, less strong to this Bill which does not<br />
mention Ind,ians by name but' 'tho very object of<br />
which is to drive Indians out of the country by<br />
making it impossible fo~ them to trade in important<br />
centres than to the Colour Bar Bill. which makes a<br />
direct D\ention of Asiatics but which after all will<br />
not be so injurions to Indian interests as the other<br />
Billilponsored by General,Smllbl?<br />
We for our ,part<br />
wou\d much Pfe(et:!' law which is discriminatory<br />
both in f
,<br />
,Anptl\er gFe\i~ figqr~ of tpe (treat War, G~n~ral, sl~c.c.~SE\flll, went on stril~e~ an,d for m~ny .dan tlwre<br />
Fr:~nch, w)lq'fo~ 4is serviceli! was lljlade :{i;al'l of Ypres. were scem'A of disprt<br />
whU~ Agnes b'eC(i.me·l,ady Poynter, WIfe 'Qf aoqther dlscusl;led 25 year~ ~Wo by ~he Zionif;;t Cong~ess, \\na(i'Y'PeeI{ f§['ves 1-\1,s impreSsions in th'e ID,a:n decla~ed t~at, while the ~ew ,Ur\lversi~f W~iI<br />
10ckl1>te~ of ''Il~ca'r.in·1f cIties a,nd ~ig~ prices ±of - me~rit tl) be a nmfying centre of Jewry'ij sc~ttere!1<br />
p06\:"g60ds>ilj'th~ SOVIet couritr~r:'<br />
elements and to, fOfJ;ll. the {ocn~ of the reha'QiI\\\\\1Qn<br />
lnqm ll.jill ~.Jft~,?-ol1. kbowl~uge,of the w.orktngs ot .)no !flner. w..Q6f;h,~ J<br />
of Intel'Ulltional. },;aw.. The 5tt.ld~nts who b.a.d ,SOlU1t.,. tl)e adrnmlstraLive lUachll'lel;Y ollllat. to W Ike hiIJll,ft,<br />
prac.~ta fol' ex.oee.tin, tbo"ot~Ol' ~dt1lat.e. ·1,0 bJi a ~ormidable ~i~10 olt, th, G,GVew.~Mt •... - . -:y .
~piniott<br />
No. 27-:"'Vol. XXIII. Friday, July 3rJ, 1925.<br />
R. &islered al the G.P.O. aa a Ne_per<br />
Puc. rooa ••• ,.<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
~."<br />
'1tt T a meeting of the Southern Subnrbs EurQ- H. H. t~e Maharaja of Jodpur, H. H. the Maharaja<br />
Ln..\ pean Association htftd on the 17th June a of Gwahor anil H. H. the Maharaja of Mysore will<br />
resolution was passed unanimously protesting be ~ntel'tained du~ing t.he summer months by the<br />
against Asiatics presenting their address to the PrInce Umon. A receptIon wIll be given during June by<br />
at the same place as Europeans, in view of the fact Lady Mond. who is lending her drawing-room in<br />
Milner Park had been set aside for colourerl people. the afternoon for that purpose.<br />
"It is not in accordance with the spirit of the conntl'y<br />
that Indians shonld be allowed to present their<br />
addrt'ss with ours," declared Councillor J. H,Qatson,<br />
"in view of the fact that the Indian is trying so hard<br />
to obtain t'qual rights with Europeans, I do not<br />
think we should give him this opportunity of<br />
placing himself on the same level as we are." Mr.<br />
H. M. Ross declared that Natal had set Johannesburg<br />
a bad example in dealing with Indians.<br />
[We refer to the a;ove in our leading article .....:..<br />
Ed. 1.0.1<br />
The Ladies' Committee of the Southern Suburbs<br />
European Association held their first concert and<br />
dance at the Masonic Hall, Kenilworth, on Saturday.<br />
There was a large attendance. During the interval<br />
thf\ President of the Association said: "Therp Beems<br />
to be some misapprehension; some people think we<br />
are out to prosecute or persecute the Asiatics. This<br />
is entirely wlOng. We believe there is plenty of<br />
room in this country for all, but we do object to the<br />
intermingling of white and coloured in a white rt'sidential<br />
district such as ours. Our movement airnp<br />
at the education of white residents to support and<br />
trade with their own kith and kin. We have in<br />
this district men living with, and in some instances<br />
married, to colourod women, which is a stan,ling<br />
~isgrace."<br />
The Fellowship of Reconciliation-a. body started<br />
by Pacifists during the War, is holding a summer<br />
Conference this year in Yorkshire. The programme<br />
promises to be an interesting one. Dr. Henry T.<br />
Hodgkin, whose work in connection with the Peace<br />
Movement is so well-known, is retnrning to England<br />
in July and will speak at the Conference on his<br />
work in France. The general subjpct of the papers<br />
and disCllssions will be the relations of Eallt and<br />
West as illustrated by studies of conditions in China<br />
and India, and their reactions in Europe and America.<br />
Dame Adelaide Anderson, formerly Chief<br />
Inspector of Factories in this country, and an<br />
authority on industrial conditions in China, will be<br />
present. Mr. Shoran Singh has consented to speak<br />
abont India, and Mr. C. F. Andrews is also expected<br />
to be at the Conference. The Conference will be<br />
held from July 31st to August 7th, and further<br />
particulars may be obtained from the Fellowship of<br />
Reconciliation, 16, Red Lion Square. London,<br />
W.C 1.<br />
The summer programme of the BrItish Indian<br />
Unionjs now being arranged and will include luncheons<br />
between May and July to Lord Reading and I<br />
LordJBirktnheod. ,:<br />
A correspondent discussing this subject in Young<br />
India writes:-Tbe foreign imports of cloth 'totalled<br />
1,~7! million yards in 1922. In the same year 58<br />
mIllIon pounds of yarn was also imported. Taking<br />
that this latter was converted into 400 million yards<br />
or seven yards per pounll the total foreign cloth<br />
would be 1,977 milhon yards or nearly 20 crores of<br />
yards. One crore of Cbarkhas or one Charkha for<br />
every thirty men and women in IndIa would be our<br />
need to replace this cloth. The number of handlooms<br />
would be about 12 to 15 lakhs calculated on<br />
the average given above. The same correspondent<br />
points out that in tbe eight years from 1914 to 1922<br />
the mills have increased their spindles by 600 thousand<br />
and looms by 30 thousand and the improvement<br />
in. the production has been 600 million yards.<br />
The capItal has also increased by over eight to nine<br />
crores ~n fifteen years. To replace the total import<br />
of foreIgn cloth and yarn a mill programme even<br />
under the most favourable circumstances would<br />
prob~bly take not less than thirty to forty years.<br />
~ut . the fig\lre~ about wear and tear and deprecia~<br />
tlOn In the Indian mIlls are striking. They come to<br />
nearly 170 lakhs a year. Once ill 20 years the<br />
depreciation amounts probably to as much capital<br />
dS is invested. Further the taxes (Super Tax and<br />
Income Tax) the Excise duty, Rlilway freight and<br />
local and Mnnicpal rates paid by the mills amount<br />
nearly to 337 lakhs a year. These 3~ crores every<br />
ypar are bemg borne by the consumers. Under the<br />
Charkha and handlooms scheme a considerable part<br />
of thIS would be saved for the people and be available<br />
for industl·Y."<br />
His Highness the Maharaja of Rljpipla, an Indian<br />
State, bas announced that primarY education will be<br />
henceforward free in his state and has offered Ri!.<br />
7,500 per annum for technical and higher education.<br />
It is good to r.otice tbdt Indian news is filling a<br />
larger E pace in foreign newspapers than it has ever<br />
occupied before. Tlte Inl.ernational Women Suffrage<br />
News draws attention to the appointment of Lad!:<br />
Sadasiva Iyer (wifb of Sir T. Sadasivd Iyer) who has<br />
bepn made Hon. Preslliency Magistrate for the City<br />
of Madras, will be hailed with satisfaction by the<br />
public of that Province, for she is respected by all<br />
for her faithful service in all good causes, and her<br />
outstanding ability as an eloquent speaker and wise<br />
leader. The Fort S. George Gazelle announces the<br />
same appointment for Mrs. V. Panduranga Rao, a<br />
native of Mangalore, that city noted for the advancement<br />
of its women; and for Mrs. Bume Stanford.<br />
recently of South Africa, where she had a~ extel;l~'l.e<br />
experience in the working of Children's Courts and<br />
vigJlance work. Tbus, Madras City has taken a.
166 I NOlAN OPINION July 3rtl, ') 5<br />
longpr step forwa.rd than Bombay, which gave ouly<br />
, the mOl"e limited powera of JttsUce ot the PMce to<br />
foul' WOll1en first, but the Madras PresIdency Magistrlltes<br />
lnclud@' this tille wIth the nt'st clMs Bench<br />
pOwers. Lad.y Sadasiva Iyer \$ a nl.emb~r of the<br />
Central Committee of the Women's IndIan Association,<br />
and President of the IndIan Ladies' Samaj, and<br />
Mrs. Stanford is the -CommIssioner of the<br />
Women'a lnQ,ian Associatl()n for ~rk aonnected<br />
with the Children's Act. The othpr Women MagIstrates<br />
of thE' Prf'sidpTIcy, \{,·s "\1. E Cousins, B.Mus.,<br />
for S lioldpet, an I 1V[r'l. Javalakshmi A.nima, B.A., for<br />
M,I,lmapalle, arE' also membprs of tb\'l Women's Indian<br />
ASSOClatlOn. It IS only a couple of m(;lnths<br />
since the ASSOCIation of Honorary Magistrates, and<br />
the \\fomeh's, \Inl:lian Association, memoralised the<br />
Law M€ll1ber that II ChIldren's Court should Ibe<br />
estabI\shed in MMi'lIll, in whleh it was desirab~e that<br />
both men and \vornen Magistrates should work t()<br />
gethpr and therf for(;' requpsted that more womeh<br />
Magistrates should be appointed. It must be hIghly<br />
gratifying to both Associations that their request has'<br />
b-een granted so e~peditely.<br />
.<br />
TIlat :the Mahottl'edan menace WIn be one of the<br />
.gravest t)'rob'Jil'ttIS 'of the Iuture III 'this country was<br />
tWe assettilm of a 'speaker at the Rotary Olub lucheotI.<br />
~st'erda~, 1\Ir. ,~. J. 'Sawyer, a local business man<br />
*ho has spt3n't Over years in 'the }jjas't. He dId<br />
not anticlpa'te much trouble riSIng from the Indmn<br />
'ql1~stioh owing to the low-class-the l1ntouchable<br />
·type which came here. It was in the question of<br />
relIgion 'Would hot race that the danger lay. He<br />
l'o1nt~d 'Oilt that wh{Je the H:indu would usually<br />
mart-y titre 'Of his OWn people, the M:ahomedan<br />
\Te1'y Gften ifitetttlarr~ed among his co-religionists~<br />
the Malays.<br />
Both \'Vete better 'physically than the<br />
Hihdtl, and in 'tillS 'there was the promise of a strong<br />
'3.iid 'virile race 'I3piingin~ up here. "Religion before<br />
naftionallty wlll be theIr watchword,11 declared Mr.<br />
'8aw'yet-, ~'an'd ~nyoiie who reads the signs of the<br />
t.imes ~rl'ght Knows that it is one of the aims of 'the<br />
'Mussttiman bith to make A.frica a Mahommedan<br />
'Co'ri.'tineut right from the Mediterranean down to the<br />
. Cape. The speaker main'tained that the Indian<br />
" 'trader prefBrred doing a credit trade, especiatty,<br />
With the Government empl'Oyee 01' one in constant<br />
'templ.oyril'en't, smce it efiabled. him to get his cusl!\Ome\os<br />
ilhd-er his tht'tttIb. 'The key to the whole<br />
sitll'ation waS the tact 'that he thrived. on the poverty<br />
l\tld i"J.1'lj,)l."ovi'
.., ~".<br />
dehherdtions. ~[r. SnraLj"e Hllstomjee h,i" specidlly<br />
exten(le a SUCCQISf\1.1 event. , . • 0" ." 0 .'<br />
i .... l· 'i1i ' , I r •• ' "f'i& ' ,<br />
--'Ii;~H I; "(.' ,,,,~ , I·'} f •<br />
:, ,J ,"',:f f .' ...<br />
.~, .r~" . ~ .\B.ll.OWMltWEDN,ESS.<br />
1\\ T the meeting' of ·the' So.athern Suburbs'<br />
n<br />
European 'AssbCiatioli' (joh&Dnesburg) held<br />
on -tbe H'th '.hme; a. tesolution· protesting<br />
:lgainst 'Asiatics ~esentin~' an iidd~es~i to the<br />
Prince of Wales At the sam& pla'~ as Europeans<br />
was passed. 'rhe PriDC~ has p~8Se;! thl'ough J 0-<br />
hannesburg, and the incident lfefetJ;oo to tends to<br />
show the nario\Vmindedlwbs of tJ{~<br />
iN l:>lAN OPINION<br />
Europeans in<br />
J olumnesb urg and its iru~(;undlng' ~illtricts.<br />
~ ~~ in S~ .A!rica' have sufficient experience<br />
of the pin pricking policy as pursued b,..<br />
the EuropeaIIB, a.nd the ~eSolution passed by the<br />
S6iti&~iJ :Suburbs EUrop~ail ~&Sdt!iauon ~s the<br />
latest insult hurled against the hdia~s.<br />
We 'oanntlt ,understand the mentality -of the<br />
Gentlemen-if they may be termed as such-who<br />
passed this resolution, suffice jt ,to lSay howe~r<br />
that no person with any sense of decency will<br />
ever ~her sueh a .. esolution, How tIle presentatib.a',w"n''aHdrils~<br />
to tlie Pricioo by tbEr Indian"! at<br />
thb 'sa-t.rI~ plaC& as Eu~6Veans, can be' treated as a<br />
damour for ~Q.ufIl ~g\lts,,~rtaWl PfLSSes o~r comprehension.<br />
{"<br />
,']Jhe'addl!ess,w$S t6' be preS®ted to no less' a<br />
persona~e than. His Royal Highness the 'Prince of<br />
Wates~the\ ":fu.t~~' '~in.percU· 01 India.. The India~<br />
w6J;e trying ~o pay homage to t;he most'popular<br />
young man in the world. They desired to<br />
show their loyalty to the Throne, just as much a'l<br />
did the European~. For the tim~ being they ha.d<br />
f~goti~u the "lp.juatices ,t~y wefe continuously<br />
sulj~cted 'to, they had, f~rgotten. the repress,ive<br />
laws that were passed wIth 'a Vlew to mamng<br />
their progress, in order'that'a fitting welcome ~a.y<br />
be givim 1'9 the Pcirice. Tha Eur9pean~ did not<br />
appreciate this action on the part of the lnuians,<br />
but dirty ~l!.(ltics were 'Pul'sued b,y the Europeans<br />
w,ith' & view to preVenting the Indians hont presentih8<br />
a:rl) addres~. Is there a more glaring<br />
example of ».a,n:owmindedq.ess ? , '<br />
What would ~ave been the consequence if the<br />
Indians, as 'n direct answer, to the resolution l'&<br />
fused' ·to· ;proc6l'd with' 11.e presentation of the<br />
address and COl.lveyed their rea~Qn to the Prince?<br />
w.', ,wodld ,have thought that the occasion of<br />
the visit of the Prince of Wales would be too great<br />
~n 'acbaston to brltlg into play the hatred against<br />
the Indians. The incide~t referred to js one<br />
of t.hQse1 infi ta.nces where gross inj\lstice is 'being<br />
intlictied to indians -in this oountry. We hope<br />
the Printe of W'a1es will have seen sufficient in<br />
this, cOun~ so that a true 'picture of the condition<br />
oUndiw in South -.Africa will be presented to<br />
him ..<br />
ZEERUST COUNCIL REBUFF<br />
CotrR!' ORDERS LlCE~CB FOB .Air A.su.TIC<br />
An interesting jndgmeJlt. iOVQhing th& y,reaent<br />
eitortB III the W t'li'tern l'ratulvaa) &0 limil t.M al!tirities<br />
of "bidtif traJeI;S. ~ given bJ tlla ma.giBtrate<br />
at Zeerust, who fonnd that the local council bad not.<br />
, exercised its discretion properly in r.eftu;Uig to aa<br />
1n.lidn a licence to trade as a butcher. ,<br />
The latha.n. G. ¥ohideeu, appli~ I:c1r ILlietm08. on<br />
May I), and on lIay lIJ the Mfdical OBker ollIealtll<br />
inspected the premises. He r.epdrtsIl llOu·<br />
day, a move-ment is on foot to 9l'~ ~ ,publiC<br />
testimoni~l on his behalf.<br />
, Nawdb Khan, who hIlS lougJlt, in ml\UY ~~<br />
: ana who, liuring the Bt)er war Wail. meQlbel'.Of t1a.e<br />
body,nard of Lor-l R"berts, LQrd ,KjtcllRet•.,aa(!<br />
bter uu J :'.hlller, W3S diBCharg~l «m thtt' co.ru:lasioli<br />
of the c.wlp,ligll. rooeinng a pCll3l61l ~f£lO. t:llo.tUll<br />
and in l'(>CogUItion of meritormtls jlel'yj,ce. an _ward<br />
of J-lUd In his Dative plAce. J{a.sbmir. . .<br />
])uring the Gandhi passi"e rooilltaace movement.<br />
Ito was arrested, aad 81l~qlu~nU'y his peDillan ..<br />
I .lodeit~d alld hia lap,d .. ~tt~ Since. tkeD A ...
168 INDIAN OPINION<br />
has been dependent upon the charity of the Indian<br />
community to support himself and his large family.<br />
Sir William Dalrymple, Mr. Richard Hosken,<br />
Mr. A. V.' Lindherg, and many other prominent<br />
citizens are taking a practical interest in the proposed<br />
testimonial, contributions to which will be publicly<br />
acknowledged.<br />
It is understood that the question of the forfeiture<br />
of-the Jamadar's pension, etc., will be considered by<br />
the B.E.S.L., with the view to making representations<br />
for its restoration.<br />
Through inability to secure employment, Nawab<br />
Khan is in destitute circumstances.<br />
the w~y to Paris, the German hosts would in all<br />
probability have swept the major portion of France I<br />
within a very few weeks, and the fate of the War \<br />
been decided ere it had scarcely begun. Yet to.&y<br />
her position is, in spite of the advances recently,<br />
mqde, substantially similar to what it was, with'<br />
the added prospect of being doomed to remain in a<br />
position of servitude in a mighty Empire direct~d<br />
by six white partners. Far from being treated witlt·<br />
respect by th~ Dominions, her position will ere long'<br />
be moch worse than the preeent, if she does not. in<br />
the meanwhile, make hasttl to alter it.<br />
THE DOMINIONS AND INDIA<br />
Since\the WaJ;, ,tli~ status of the Self-Governing<br />
Dominioos has undergone a remarkable transformation.<br />
'They are no 'longer content to be regarded as<br />
daughters of the Motper-Co)lntry with a I!ubordinate<br />
status in the Imperial hpusehold, but claim to be<br />
treated in every respect as a partner and an equal.<br />
British statesmen of every party recognise this claim,<br />
and are seeking means to satisfy It. The Conservative<br />
Government is introducing Imperial Preference<br />
in order to bind thereby the Dominions more<br />
c~osely to Britain. The Labour Party believes in<br />
the ideal of an Imperial Federation of Free Nations<br />
with a common aim and mi8sion sufficiE'ntly to look<br />
upon it as the strongest bond between the c9nsli:<br />
tuent parts of the Empire. It is only in the region'<br />
of foreign policy that the Mother-Country has at<br />
present exclusive control. So it is in the direction<br />
of this policy that the Dominions are attempting to<br />
gain a voice. They have made it clear that in<br />
future, in a war precipitated against their wishes,<br />
Britain could not rely on their co-operation. Th'ere<br />
is not the slightest doubt whatever that sooner or<br />
later, sooner rather than -later, machinery will be<br />
devised for continuous consultation with them, paving<br />
the way for joint direction of affairs. In the<br />
meanwhile, recognition 'O~ the new stature attained<br />
by the Dominions is showing in various ways. The,<br />
Slilcre,tary of State for the Colonies is busy,' we are<br />
told, closely studying the future organisation of the<br />
Colonial Office. It is expected that a Bill will<br />
shortly be introdqced in the House of Lords-why<br />
the House of Lord, we do not know-providing for<br />
the appoiD~ment of an additional Under-Secretary<br />
of Sta.~e. It is suggested that the new man (or<br />
~oman) should deal ;with the Dominions, the present<br />
Under-Secretary dealing with the Colonies,<br />
Protectorates, and Mandated Territories. rhe title<br />
of the Colcnial Office is also to be ,changed, in order<br />
to emphasise the closer relationship with the Dominions.<br />
The proposed bifurcation of the Colonial<br />
Offiee is not being made to confer any new advantages<br />
upon the Self-Governing Dominions or to free<br />
them from any existing restrictions. For, in the<br />
domestic sphere they already enjoy the fullest freedom<br />
possible, and,the powers of Disallowance and<br />
Veto, vested in His Majesty the King, are never<br />
e\Xercised. The Secretary of State for the Colonies<br />
is for them only a channel of communication with<br />
His Majesty's Government. The proposed re-organisation<br />
is only meant as a concession to sentiment,<br />
the Self,Governing Dominions disliking the idea of<br />
theil' affairs being handled in an office with the<br />
traditions and outlook of the British Colonial Office,<br />
which has still very large autocratic powers over<br />
the affairs of the ColQrll!:'s and Protectorates. While<br />
eocmuch deference a,}~nxiety to placate Dominion<br />
sentiment is displayed, llow is India being treated?<br />
Her sacrifices in the War wefe greater and more<br />
valuable than those of all the Self-Governing Dominions<br />
put together. If her soldiers, flung into the<br />
fighting line at a time when the troops of Britain,<br />
and the Dominions were not ready. had not barred'<br />
AN UNREPORTED INT~RVJEW<br />
BETWEEN READING AND BJRKENHEAD<br />
-( B1J B. F. BHARVCRA}<br />
B.-Well, Reading, how are we?<br />
R.-Not too good, 'not. too bad.<br />
B. - Why, Reading you are really modest 1<br />
Haven't you killed non-eo-operation?<br />
R-Not quite.<br />
B.-But haven't you divided the Non-co-operc1-<br />
ters ? ' , 'r<br />
, H.-Yes, in a way.<br />
B.-And are not tbe Swarajists and Independents<br />
fighting amongst themselves?<br />
R.-Yes, to an ~xtent.<br />
B.-And are not the Hindus and Muslims quarrelling<br />
amongsHhemselves?<br />
1l.-Yes, at times. '<br />
13 ....... ls it; not all to the good?<br />
R.--Yes, to a point.<br />
B.-Then what is the bad feature of this show?<br />
R.-It is this, Birkenhead: that whilst the SWc1rc1-<br />
jists and Imlependents are fighting, they have no<br />
love fOl our present system.<br />
B.-Hm! But what about the Moder ltell?<br />
R.-Even they are SilO wing their teeth!<br />
B.-Hm! Then what about the Muslims? Tht!Y _<br />
are veer.ing ~ound to UB. - ,<br />
R. -Some of them are; but there are large ,sections<br />
of Muslims, who are very hostile to us.<br />
B,.-What? Are theY' more hostile to liS, than those<br />
, howling Hindu agitators?<br />
R.-Yes, Birkenhead, Yes.<br />
B.-How can that be, Reading?<br />
R.-Why, our Foreign Policy in Egypt, in Iraq,<br />
in Hedjaz is greatly resented by llrge sections of<br />
thoughtful Muslims.<br />
B.-What about Palestine?<br />
R.-Well, that is included also.<br />
B.-But, Reading, I can't understand you at all,<br />
as regards Muslims in India. Why, Malcolm Hailey ~<br />
iEi showered with ,Muslim Addresses!<br />
R.-Yas, but they arEl from the Publicity Com-,<br />
mittees. which are Hailey's own babies!<br />
- B.-Hm ! But is not Mr. G.mdhi a broken reed?<br />
R.-We may think so, or say so; but truly speaking,<br />
he is neither a reed, nor is he broken.<br />
B.-Don't you think Lytton has shown his iron<br />
hand?<br />
I<br />
R.":"'yes, he has; but that has only deepered the<br />
old wounds.<br />
B.-Well, Reading, according 19 yont reprasen. i<br />
tation, the sitllation''is neither too good, nor too baol<br />
, in India, so why should we worry? , ,<br />
R.-Worry! Worry we must. unless we are pre·~.<br />
pared to lose India in near future.<br />
B.-How can we do that, Reading-with 8uch'<br />
terrible unemployment in Britain, with economic<br />
rivalry and hostility springing all round how can 'Y~<br />
let India slip out of our hands? Surely R~ing, a<br />
shrewd financier like yoo don't need a tip from me.<br />
B.-I fully realise the position here ana in India,<br />
and hence have come aU the way to have a heart-toheart<br />
talk.<br />
B.-But, tell me Reading, what do our Governors<br />
'.
, July 3rd, 192 5 INDIAN OPINION<br />
and officials recommend 01 to do?<br />
, 'H.-They are so hope]eBSly divided and yet in a<br />
"y onited!<br />
" B.-How's that. Reading?<br />
H.-You see, they are nearly all onited, that there<br />
shall be no radical change before 1929. But meantimE'.<br />
some lIoggest repreBSion and division, and few<br />
ot~J'I1 to wait and watch and to throw a few<br />
c1'u'fubs!<br />
B.-What's YOllr view, Reading?<br />
H.-Jostice and statesmanship demand a bold<br />
move and recognition ot India's right to govern herself.<br />
B.-But, what aboot our Capital, our trade, our<br />
industry, our rich markets in India?<br />
H.-Well, I have brought 'Blackett- here to IBfaggard<br />
that.<br />
B.-Then, what you mean is to make a grand<br />
political gesture and retain all economic hold and<br />
\power in oor own hands?<br />
I<br />
, R.-WelI, that at least, if nothing else cau be I<br />
jdone.<br />
'_<br />
I H.-Why, we can request His Majesty to proceed I<br />
,to India, hold a gl'3nd Dllrbar, announce ,a collple of<br />
Governorsl)ips for Indians, and a Maharaja as Chief,.<br />
of the St&c!<br />
Some one knocks at the door, and enters Lord ,<br />
Hardinge.<br />
H. Friends, I have just over-heard your last··<br />
words. You can't hold India now by Durhars and,<br />
decorations. Spare His Majesty and deal with<br />
India with prudence and eqnity; or else we shall<br />
Boon rue our present po~icy of drift and division.<br />
i~EE
( \ ~.,,'<br />
_ INDIAN Ol'lNION<br />
.. J'" I J _ \ I I I I<br />
rights are in Jeopa~y in that ~ou:ntn' and tbey have<br />
to look tQ the Gov.ernor alii the Kmg's r?presentative<br />
t6 ~dld thEr~cale$ (jf iusttee in, the midst ot
,3tlL[iun<br />
. .... -<br />
No. 28-Vot. XXIII. Friday, July loth, 1925.<br />
RegIStered at the G. p.O • ••• J!l ..... per<br />
PRiC" 100 ......<br />
DURBAN CORPORATION AND ASIATICS<br />
SUGGESTED ROUND TABLE CONFERENCE<br />
~N the Gth instant, the Durban Town Council,<br />
~ on the initiative of Conncillor n. H. Kf'mp,<br />
who had addresoled a letter to the Town<br />
Clerk on the snbject, diRcusfed the ASIatic question<br />
at lenuth.<br />
The recommendation submitted by :Mr. K('mp was<br />
as follows :- ,<br />
.. That the Government of the Union of SOllth<br />
Africa be informed that in the opmion of the Dnl"<br />
han Town Council, the only true method of solving.<br />
the Asiatic 'Qnestion in so far as it relates "L'O this<br />
country, and particularly Natal, lies in the directIOn<br />
of a round table conference bE'tween representatives<br />
of the Union, Britain and IndIa; further, that the<br />
Union Government and the Union Parhament hE'<br />
asked to take sllch steps as may be necPRRary f,)r<br />
convening such a Conference in this coantt'S without<br />
delay."<br />
Speaking to this the mover said the Union had<br />
nevpr formulated any definite policy on the Asiatic<br />
question. Even only a few days ago a Minister<br />
indicated that a certain section would not be meluded<br />
in his proposed legislative measures. They<br />
happened to be from the Cape; but how about<br />
Natal? A numbE'r of public people believed that<br />
any resolute attempt to faca the Asiatic question in<br />
Natal was making a situation whICh would be<br />
dangerous, or to say the least of it, would h'ad to<br />
rashness. They told us the matter conld not be<br />
hurried, and wonld como in due tune like rain 1rom<br />
heaven, and conld be att..'1ined Without efftll't on the<br />
part of the people, Great measnres were !lewr<br />
achievt>d in that way. 'l'ht>y were tLe r
(NOlAN OPINION 1 uly' loth. 1925 .<br />
I\IltP.l'essing the hope th",t the mover would not press<br />
the motio~l CouncillQr Eaton said he was jealous of<br />
the dignity of the Council, and would rather see<br />
such a motion dropped.<br />
Support was accorded by Councillor Mrs. Benson.<br />
His Worship the Mayor. whilst not disagreeing<br />
with the m.otion entirely, thought that it dId not<br />
come within the province of the CouncIl, and he<br />
feared that they stood an excellent chance of being<br />
told ~ JI\inC\ their own, business. .<br />
Fwl0Win,g a r(lply by Oouncillor Kemp, the motIOn<br />
was put and carried on the following voteR: For.<br />
Councillors Lamon.t, Smith, Shearel,', Mrs. Knight,<br />
Mrs. Seiedle, Kemp, and Mrs. Benson. Against: The<br />
¥a~oJ'. Cou:t:).c.illors l\Lrs. Fahey, Eat.on, Clark, and<br />
13;p~z~d .•<br />
\<br />
AUSTF,ALIA PLAYS FAIR<br />
TUE cableg,ram fro,m Melbourne, Australia,<br />
II stating that the Committee of the Senate<br />
h.as Pa.!'l'100 a Bill, givi'lg British IndIan<br />
residents full electoral rights of citizenship, is a<br />
piece'of very welcome information. If this means<br />
that. the Bill ha,s successfully pGtssed both Houses<br />
0:£ P~J~a.meI),t and ~ now law, British Indians,<br />
domiciJ.ed iIll AustJiaJ.i.a are to be congratulated. It<br />
would appear that the people of A ustralia are<br />
posses'led of a sense of fairness and justice, and<br />
that they al'e not afraid of lining up along~ide<br />
"$~Qj~t" :r~. At a time whell SQuth Africa is<br />
going :from bad to worse in its anti-colour leglslatit)ll,<br />
1ihis examI?le of straight forward recognition<br />
Q~ J;n.dif!,'s claim, as an ~qual partner in the great<br />
t\,ntish Empire, 1S most refreshing. Logically,<br />
there is nothing to be surprised at in thIS news.<br />
But~ unrortnnately, we are so accustomed to Wltl!essing<br />
H,agrant acts of injustic.e and spoliation,<br />
~b~1i Sa mea~ul1e of bare justice causes us to exclaim.<br />
Australi3!. l,t is. t);u_e, has not a large Indian populationi<br />
and It may, therefore, be said that its position<br />
~s not On all fours with that of the Union of<br />
South Africa;. Th.e grap,ting of the pol~tical fran<br />
Qhisj:t tf}l;J;J,d,ians ilJ .a us~alia, however SlI ·all the<br />
population, ia of the highest importance because<br />
ill establishes- a precedent The British self-governjng<br />
1)pmini0ns have hitherto refused such<br />
righ~j al!.
ights in the country. Mr. Kemp leprf'8I>ntf' 1 1 th~<br />
,moat (Iang~l'ou
t74 INDIAN OPINION July loth. 1925<br />
African Government has not been slow in taking<br />
. advantage o~ it and they are working out in a most<br />
intensive and, vigorous manner. Up to now about<br />
35 000 Indians have been turned out of South Africa<br />
and-they are all the victims of those false statements<br />
that is India is prosperous, that labour is scarce, that<br />
prices are low and that all of them could be absorbed<br />
in the country and could easily seUle th~mselves.<br />
But as we all know the majority of them have been<br />
stranded here and their condition is simply deplorable.<br />
There is not one amongst them ~ho, if<br />
allowed, would not go back to South Afnca. At<br />
present, there is great unemplo~ment. thro~ghout<br />
the country, rice is se-lling at scarcIty prIces, dls~re~s<br />
is acute. Still the Government of South Africa s<br />
false allnrements have been left to pass unchallenged.<br />
The Government of India's share and Sir B. N.<br />
Sarmacs toq-in this sin of negligence an!l of eV~Il,-',<br />
tnal ilu1f-eri!llg~is very~great. 'Have th~y' no u~(?asy'<br />
conscience when even a few weeks back, 403 repatriates<br />
have been dumped on India and every quarter<br />
the steamer would bring about 500 of the-se unfortunate<br />
people? Unless they are a party to the<br />
deception or nnless they wink at the idea that Indians<br />
would all do well to come back to India, their<br />
silence is inexplicable.<br />
• SIR B. N. SARMA'S F AIr.URE<br />
The first step i~ for the Government to tell them<br />
that.conditions are not favourable in India for their<br />
settlement and that they should come to India at<br />
their own risk. It will be the sheerest humanity to<br />
do this and the Government of India should not be<br />
lax as they qad been- all these years. Of course, the<br />
greatest disappointment is Sir B. N. Sarma who,<br />
though he held the portfolio fOl JI. long pe-riod, had<br />
utterly failed to grasp the mi~chief aad suffering<br />
caused by the repatriation sche-me. It is to be hoped<br />
that the new member in charge of the portfolio will<br />
do something to see that the poor Indians are not<br />
turned out of South Africa on false hopes. Let them<br />
cume at their own risk by all means. But the Government<br />
of India's responsibility for these 35,000<br />
Indian/! ~nd for those .cOining: hereafter is very great.<br />
Nothing seems to have bepn done to provide suitable<br />
employment for them or their return "home" comfortable<br />
and happy.<br />
It is therefore,' essential that some non-official<br />
Indian' who knows two or three vernaculars is sent to<br />
South Africa either by the Government or by private<br />
philanthropic men and associations to tell the people<br />
there that they can come here at their own risk and<br />
that cpnditions of trade, industry and agriculture are<br />
not very bright and promising, especially in Southern<br />
India to Which, unfortunately, most of these repatriates<br />
belong. .. . .<br />
Even though like sItuations are developmg lD<br />
East Africa and there is a possibility of somebody<br />
bringing or making indiscreet admissions in East<br />
African affaIrs, the urgent 'question i$ now that of<br />
South, Africa. While the Class Areas Bill, Ordinances<br />
and Franchises are aimed at impoverishing<br />
the Indian well-to-do element, the repatriation<br />
scheme is aimed at driving out labourers and humble<br />
folk. Unless some strong steps are taken, we shall<br />
not be surprised if in course of time even these weIlto-do<br />
merchants and traders are slowly pulled down<br />
to the scale of repatriation.<br />
We have been asked' by the Secretary of the<br />
Young Men's Vedic Society to announce that the<br />
weekly meeting of the Society hitherto he-Id on<br />
Sundays will, as from the 15th instant, be held on<br />
Wednesdays. The first of these meetings will be<br />
held on Wednesday next at 7 p.m. at the Hindu<br />
Tamil1nstitute Oross Street, when a general discussion<br />
on how best to b~tter the condition of Indians<br />
in SQuth Africa will. take place.<br />
EUROPEANS IN INDIA<br />
Mr. Wentworth Stanly's speech at the European<br />
Association's meeting at Karachi shows elements of<br />
liberality not usually. conspicuoull at- -such gatlier-'<br />
ings.<br />
He stressed, of course, the words "gradual<br />
realisation of Self-Government," but recognised<br />
that t4e Indian aspiration was perfectly legitimate',<br />
that Britain was pledged to satisfy it. He (lil .. ted<br />
on the importance of ,British capital to India, but<br />
urged that the non-official European should show..<br />
"that he is as keen as the nor.-official Indian for tb '<br />
betterment of the masses amonlt whom he lives."<br />
The implication, we hope, is that the keenness is a<br />
quahty which has yet to be cultivated, and is not<br />
to be claimed as a mere adjnnct of the British<br />
"trusteeship." Briti&h capital is invested all ovei'<br />
the world, and because of that factj Britain does ~6t<br />
claim a ,share in the :direction of: aU ,tlUier coun'trl'elf'<br />
affairs. The British commnnity in India is certainly 1 ,<br />
entitled to fair play, but being a small minority, it<br />
mllst be content to let India be governed by Indian~.<br />
The weather remains unchanged. For the moment<br />
one forgets that he is in England and well mly<br />
he believe he is in sunny South Africa. The high.<br />
est reaiing this summer is 85 in the shade.<br />
The death of the Maharajah Scindia of Gwalior is<br />
reported to have tabn place on the 5th inst., in<br />
Paris. The Maharanee and ber two children aged<br />
twelve and eight were with the Maharajah at the<br />
end. His heir is George Jivavi Rao, about 9 years<br />
old, for whom the King stood sponsor. The cremation<br />
ceremony was held at the cemetery of pere.<br />
La Chase. Among those, a~t~,n,di~g ,wrr~."W~1AP.,<br />
Khan the Maharajan')'Gaekviar' of Bargda, ana the<br />
Maha~jah of Kolkapui. ' " ,<br />
The Maharajah of Gwalior was one of the' fi ve<br />
Indian Princes entitled to a salute of 21 guns. In.<br />
recognition of his enlightened rule over his cpu,ntry,<br />
among other honours, the hon01:ary, degree!,! of L.~ ..nc<br />
of Cambridge and D.O.L. of Oxford were conferred<br />
on him. He was born on the 20th October 1876<br />
, and at the age of 10 I!ucceeded his father as a rnlel'<br />
of a country with an area of some 26,000 sqnare<br />
miles, a population of over 3,000,000 people, producing<br />
a revenne to the State of about £1,500,000.<br />
He was brought up as a soldier and in 1901 at the<br />
age of 25 !laW service in Ohina as orderly offi~I' to<br />
General Gaselee. On this occasion he fitted out at<br />
his own expense the hospital Ship Gwalior which<br />
was found to be very serviceable. He was one of<br />
the most loyal subjects of the King. To mark the<br />
Coronation of the King, he gave £8,000 for distri~<br />
bution among the charitable institution's in England j<br />
which the King described as noble. He sent ~m ~<br />
outbreak of the Great War, troops to the a8SIstan~e,<br />
of the British. He advanced to the Indian Govet;n.<br />
ment a' loan of 5,000,000 rupees, free of interest; ~!t/<br />
would not accept the immediate p~~ent ,!>r. ,~AAt ,<br />
Uovernmtmt of 3,800,000 rupE!es and' inves.te
_ ._~J~ul~Y_I_o_th~'~'9~2~S ________ ~JN~D~IA~N~O~P~I~N~I~O~N~ ______________ ~!_ 175<br />
< .' anll motOr-crcles• In short he placed the entire resources<br />
of h18 State at tRe disposal of the Viceroy<br />
T~e th~n Viceroy of India, Lord Hardinge said of<br />
hl.m: That !>ne can hardly epen the newspaper<br />
wIthout reading of some fresh instance of the<br />
,~~6i:1arajah's generosity"-and the papers are full<br />
of stories of his humanity. Whenever he came to<br />
London, he wonld, dreMed iu old clothes, slip out<br />
of his hotel ip the evening and board a 'bus and<br />
• pass the hours in riding round the city. London by<br />
night, seen froJll an omnibus top, fascinated him.<br />
A~ th~ pmt!, ~f a national rejoieing, he was in<br />
• LooQAJ,l,.y •. pnatt~4ed.he,mingled in the crowd at a<br />
firewor~.dlsplay"coming by chance upon a working<br />
l'DJ,ln and his wife with a child, which should<br />
ne~er have brought out on such a night. It had<br />
grown too tired to walk, it was carried by the man<br />
and sometimes by the woman. All three were tired<br />
ou~ The Maharajah offered help in carrying the<br />
cbdd. After a moment's hesitation the offer was<br />
accepted. The Maharajah stayed o';t the fireworks.<br />
with the child asleep in his arms. On the return<br />
journey, the Maharajah did his share of the work<br />
of carrying and on reaching the palotial house in<br />
Park Lane in which he was living, without thinking<br />
he stopped and said Goodnight to the pair adding<br />
that he had reached his home. The man e~ed him<br />
narrowly and indicated his disbelief. "Oh" said the<br />
1.1aharajah. "I'm only engaged in the stables"<br />
"Well" said the man, "you ain't our English sort, ~f<br />
C011rse, but you are a damn good fellow."<br />
In his own dominions he also loved to play<br />
Haronu-al-Raschid. Once after a night ramble in<br />
disguise he was returning to his place when he was<br />
challenged by a sentry. He explained who he was<br />
but his tail was not good enough for the soldier.<br />
The end of it.was that the Maharajah was kept in<br />
the'g1lllfdl'OOm till his ',private .secretary came.-land<br />
identified him. ' The sentry expected to be instan~ly<br />
beheaded. But the monarch pleased with his discipline,<br />
gave him a step un in rank!<br />
With the aid of an Irrigation Department, he enabled<br />
many thousands of barren acres of land being<br />
brought under cultivation. He was considered to<br />
be a benevolent ruler. He had a collection of<br />
jewels believed to be one of the finest in the world.<br />
He had a dozen ropes of pearls alone worth a million,<br />
But he preferred to go about unrecognised<br />
among his people in ordinary Indian dress.<br />
An error crept into a previous letter about the<br />
Maharajah of Jodpp.r. He is in England with his<br />
only Maharanee.<br />
The chief points in the Allied Note to Germany<br />
are: The Allied Governments consider it of capital<br />
importance to declare that the defaults in disarmament<br />
would if not promptly rectified, enable<br />
the German Government to reconstitute an army<br />
modelled on the principles of a nation of arms. The<br />
totality ot disarmament defaults is a serious menace<br />
to peace. It noW resta with the German Government<br />
to create the conditions in which evacuation<br />
of C1ologile can speedily be effected. It is they<br />
\~enlseJveft with 'profit by the readiness with which--<br />
.~e1 'give effect to the rectifications demanded. The<br />
\Ilie~ Governm.ents again. appeal earnestly to the<br />
German Government to liquidate with the necessary<br />
'goodwill the outstanding matters, the settlement of<br />
which the gravity of the situation demands.<br />
TO' teach pupils of forty nationalities in one<br />
secondary school is a task to fascinate the most<br />
ardent pedagogist. The experiment is to be made<br />
in Geneva for the heneJit of the families of the<br />
Secretariats of the League of Nations and the International<br />
LabOllr Office.<br />
English and French will<br />
be the teaching languages employed, the headmaster<br />
will be an Englishman, and the system adopted will<br />
be a combination of the lateat edueational methods<br />
of ' Europe al:d A.mari.<br />
M",. tJsl .. ' ell. mil" mJaohl •• whb wldob &)a., Ill. I<br />
generally credited lurks in the brain of apes and in<br />
a new bo?k, The Mentality of Apes, Prof~r W.<br />
Kohler glVtlS some remarkable instances of their<br />
cleverness. One Chimpanzee would pile boxes-On<br />
one another in order to reach some fruit· one day<br />
the Keeper offered his bent. back as a s~l, taking<br />
care to stoop too low to bnng the fruit in reach<br />
"whereupon the disappointed ape came quickl;'<br />
do~n and tried very en~~eti~IlY to raise the keeper<br />
mto a more erect potIltlon. _ -Another s"""imen<br />
"SaIl " ed t'~ ,<br />
y, ns to hand her teacher four straws when<br />
as~ed for that number. Clearly the expressio1l<br />
"brainless I!B Chimpanzee," used by the Cambridge.<br />
Poet, Calverley, was a gross slander. -<br />
MAHATMA GANDHI AND MR. FORD<br />
A STUDY IN CONTRAST<br />
1.1r. Arthur J. Penty writes in "G. K. Weekly" :<br />
Of all the prophets of our world to-day perhapa.<br />
the two most notable because the most extreme are<br />
Henry Ford and Mahatma Gandhi. Both of fuem<br />
are remarkable men, and yet they would lead the<br />
world in precisely opposite directions. Ford stand.s<br />
!or ~e externalisation, the mechanisation of life. It<br />
IS hIS boast that he has filled the streeta with motorcars.<br />
He is planning now, so I read, to fill the air<br />
w!th aeroplanes, and if he lives long enough he will<br />
WIthout a doubt fill the sea with submarines. At<br />
any rate, such would appear to be the logical outcome<br />
of his activities. To Gandhi all such attivities<br />
or developments are anathema. He does not talk<br />
about the D~ed of controlling machinery,-but is cont~nt<br />
~ sa~ represents a great sin." Machinery to<br />
hIm IS an mstrument of the devil essentially destructive.<br />
It is the wrecking force in society and<br />
_ ~erd~re. he ~eks to banish it from India precedent<br />
to llaDlshmg It from the world. There is to' be no<br />
compromise with it.<br />
Which of these two men is right. To answer this<br />
J question it is necessary to discuss other things in<br />
addition to machinery. It is necessary to come to<br />
conclusion about the final aims of life. But this is<br />
a big order about which it seems difficult for most<br />
people to reach any conclusion. Let us, therefore,<br />
seek to test by reference to some more proximate'<br />
idPal-say human eqnality. In his 'Autobiography'<br />
Henry Ford expresses himself very frankly on this<br />
point. He says:-<br />
"Repetitive labour-the doing of one thing over<br />
and over again and always in the same way-is a<br />
terrifying prospect to a certain kind of mind. It .is<br />
terrifying to me. I could not possibly do the same<br />
thing day in and day out, but to other mind.s, perhaps<br />
I might say to the majority of mind.s, repetitive<br />
operations hold no terrors. In fact some types of<br />
mind thought is absolutely appalling. To them the'<br />
ideal job is one where the creative instinct need not<br />
be exprePsed. The jobs where it is necessary to put<br />
in mind as well as muscle have few takers-we al- •<br />
ways need men who like a job because it is difficult.<br />
,The average worker,I am sorry_to ~y, wants a job<br />
in which ho does -not have to put forth much<br />
physical exertion above all, he wants a job in which<br />
he does not have to think. Those who have what<br />
may be called the creative type of mind and who<br />
thoroughly abhor monotony are apt to imagine that<br />
all other mind.s are similarly restless and therefore<br />
to extend quite unwarranted sympathy to the labouring<br />
man who day in and day out performs almost<br />
exactly the same kind of operation.<br />
REPETITIVE LABOUR<br />
Now is this true or is it false? I do not hesitate<br />
to say FortI's judgment is superficial. That there<br />
are great differences between men there is no denying.<br />
. One man's meat may be another man's poison,<br />
but there are sOme poil'(JQs that d~1 all men, and<br />
&Il. mtolwalgtloH 0& labout I. on. 0& thCMt, W.
lNDIAN OPINION July -loth,. 1925--<br />
conclude thll-t this division of mankind into creative<br />
there !s any peril it will be,.because th.e East adopt~<br />
an,pportunities<br />
there would be fot creative work, as'1\1:1'8: Bernard<br />
The South MagaliE'sburg Farmel'B' ASSO\)j,ltion has<br />
Shaw supposes, but practically it does not work out<br />
rooffirmed an hnpOi·tant resolution on the ABl~:':<br />
thil'! way: Repetitive'labour destroys the taste In a<br />
question. The memb(>rs J~ave again hound' themselves<br />
not to buy fyom Jndians in MlY cit~umstmnK'6.<br />
oomn;t'lmitY' for culture, and 'the reason for this IS<br />
that the attempt to discrIminate between melf as<br />
and they have IIntiertaken to advise oth!'" 'farmers<br />
creative'and repetitive.is nY are to !o-ve!'<br />
fIDiti?'Jtl£1..1l1H'el'eJl,~eS. "The greatest induatl'lahst in<br />
come what IS, after all, a genuine menace., It -)I! no<br />
goo~<br />
tl}1I world tells uS ,tha~ induilklahsm is lUcoIUpatible<br />
making long speeches an,l waitin!! y-ear after<br />
with l!.~aJl equ-aJlty.an\l firm lU hIS belIef m the<br />
yrar for the Government to move. 'J:he Il()\.ntw-rt<br />
'\;;Ieneflc~nce of m.ac-hlUery comes to deny hnman<br />
of the problem, as we have said bEfore, lieB ~ocy<br />
eqnality, The greatest, saint m the world affirms<br />
, largely in their own hands.<br />
human equality and is the uneompromising ~ enemy<br />
of industrialism. That if$ the first difference between<br />
ford and Gandhi.<br />
News in Brief<br />
:BOTH :P ACJFIS'rS<br />
T~t tbis mass meeting of tl,1e Tr,ansvaal Indians<br />
We have seeu how fundainentall~ Ford: -and again strongly protests flgainst 'tne ..,Colonr Bar<br />
Gandhi differ in theIr outlook. They haye, how ~m " as ll: plege of legIslatIOn contrary to the 'P) inclple<br />
of rIght ancI justice aT)d as one placing great<br />
'~"V1:I1,', ilne thing in (,lommon. They are both paClfi.sts.<br />
lI~re ia something by which we may test;, them a.'l oconomic hardshIp Oil those affected under it. That<br />
practltlal IIl-en; which wIll bring out stIll mol'e ,fup- " this meetmg respectfully urges the Senate to reject<br />
~m~PJa.l 1i,1fferencefl. Gandhi's paCIfism il>' ,.of! his same. "<br />
~sen,ce. It is all oJ; a piece WIth his othe,r ldeals. Proposed, by Mr: R. M. Sodha. seconden by<br />
'fh,el'e if! J,l0 (lonfiict between, h~s paclfism ,and tJ:w Bhhp.'''i Natal, supported by'C Poonen, and unanimousl<br />
Y carri~d by the meetmg.<br />
'Qt}:).~r ~hip~s Ae believes in, for 1f ~.n, coulo, be per<br />
S'qa{l.ed to follow him entirely peace would entIrely ------<br />
reign UPOll e~rth. But with Ford it iff. flijIerent. 'Speaking at it dinner of the Central Asian Societr,<br />
His paciqsm is not something that_aruu.s, ff(),In lIis Lord Birkenliead, in a brief reference to InQla', declared<br />
emphatically that Britain mUdt 'continue to<br />
b!!U~f in in
'~" +<br />
_______ ~ ndttttt ~pitl 1011<br />
•<br />
No. 29-Vo). XXIII. Friday, July lith, 19 2 5. Rq .. te ...... ttheG.p.o .... N ..... _<br />
J _________________________________ ~~~ __ ~~ __ ~~ ____________ ~P~.:~~.~':oo:u:mK~.~ __ __<br />
~,~<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
;r&~<br />
~ URBAN readers are ~eminded that the Appeal have to give a casting vote. In the end there was •<br />
J..L.lI Court to hpar Objections to the Burgess Roll sits majority of 27. Bot Gladstone's pl'E'btige Bnlfered.<br />
. at the CoQrt I1onllt', Dnrban on 20tb, 21st and great deal.<br />
22Qd lOst. From a glance of the Borge88 Roll a good -<br />
nomber of Indian Votera who appeared last year are removed<br />
and it behoves every voter who is entitled to be<br />
on the Roll to make certain that his name appears on<br />
the new Roll and if left ont to sce that his name is put<br />
on. Any voter who wiphes to enrol or to know whether<br />
his name appears on tbe Roll, mlly call on Mr. SorabJee<br />
Itnatomjee at 110 Field Street or at Messrs. Pat her' &·Co.<br />
Fonndry Lane, who will render all assistance necessary.<br />
We understand that the subjects of Bbavnagar State<br />
are stliltiDg a Women's University after the model of<br />
Prof. K8rve's University. Three professors from the<br />
Surat Mahila Vidyalaya have promieed to offer their<br />
,erviccs to thill institntion. It i8 expected tbat the<br />
Bhavnagar State will come forward to help this movemenL<br />
by mnniflcent contribntion to its finances.<br />
In India political life bas been unnsually qniescent<br />
dnring t,be last month. Lord Reading has ~one on<br />
Igiilatores<br />
and of Dominion Parlillments. Mr. Ramaswamy<br />
Mudalier, member of the Madras Legislative Council.<br />
spoke on the position in the provinces.-Reuter.<br />
THE SAME _ OLD 1'ALE<br />
Tl:D EUTER has been very busy last week rell~<br />
porting the speech gi,'en by Lord Birkenheael,<br />
the SeCletary of State for India, on<br />
the Indian qll. stion The speech was the most<br />
disappointing one tlver f.!iven by any responsible<br />
Minister of State. We must confess that we could<br />
fi'ld nothing in the speech that would suggest an<br />
improvement in the condition of Indhns in India.<br />
His L'lrdship di,;pl \yed a Jack of kllowledge of<br />
Indial' affairR His speech is a dirdCt insult to tlu~<br />
conciliatory 110te sounded by tile late Mr. C. Rr<br />
Das at FariJpur last May. When the Jate Mr.<br />
C. R. DJS madA his memorable speech at Faridpur,<br />
India appeared to be with him in his condemnation<br />
of violence, so thnt the attainm~nt of Swaraj<br />
within the Empire may be accelerated. It is indeed<br />
regrettable that Lord Birkenhead should<br />
almost immediately after the lamented death of<br />
Mr. C. R. Das seize th-, occasion to use threatning<br />
language. For, we can import nothing further<br />
in his speech than a veilpd threat.<br />
LOld Bil kenhead's speech brings us back to the<br />
question as to thf' add·nbility of the Secretary of<br />
State for India making periodical visits to India.<br />
How T,ord Birkenhead could have gra~ped' the<br />
conditions as oh'aining in India by being thousands<br />
of miles away, we certain!y cannot understand.<br />
Surely the ViCE'roy is n1 authority on<br />
Indi.lD aff.urs, on whom the Secretary of State lor<br />
India C
__ I~7S~ ________________ t_N_D<br />
present mo-inent nor an intimate knowledge of<br />
:;if( i' /,0 '" \<br />
J.g.~~!n ~~a~rs.<br />
As the napers very aptly described. the speech<br />
wa~:;'ery liis'appoiniiog a~d no student of Indian<br />
politics would have ventUled such a statement.<br />
Irrespon,sible statements suC'h as the one made by<br />
Dord Bitltenhead nuiICe it all the more necess;lry<br />
that the Secretary for InQ.ia to make periodiCal<br />
visits to India in order that a true picture of the<br />
position may be presented to him.<br />
Indian leader!; of all parties had hoped to hear<br />
.. 1111 , I' I I ,<br />
from hi,; Lordship the Imperial Gover71ment's<br />
1 'I) 'I<br />
int~nt~o,n to ral~e t9.~ ~e£oqns Act of HlJ 9 befOle<br />
th~ statutc\:y date in 1929. Their hopes have<br />
evidently been "shattf'red to pieces" as it were.<br />
W!i $~~4t,4ave thought ~hat the recenj; evpnt!'! in<br />
lnpia }Youl4 h~YE! had an effect upon Lord Birkenhead<br />
as to suggest a revision of the ll,pforms Act.<br />
But it would 'aPpear that ~othing would deter the<br />
pn~~li~l G~ve~n.rpent fr?m pu~s~ing thel~ policy<br />
9J1~!).v;ffig the, IndIans where they are This is a<br />
d!l.rigerous policy for !l.ny government t0 pursue<br />
arid Lord Birkeuhead's veiled threat will not<br />
prevent the Indians from pursumg their fight for<br />
Swaraj.<br />
We do no~ 1esire ,to 'Y+vpess in, tndia Rimilar<br />
events as are obtaining in China, but we are<br />
afraia Lord Birke'nhead'~ speech is not' ~t all conbmkioty<br />
in ione but 'will tend to b~lllg back to<br />
play that bittei:n~ss w:Lich had of late been for<br />
~~tten: I<br />
THE EMPIRE AND INDIA<br />
BRfT~~~'S ~IG~ OBLI~A~IONS<br />
J\f)\l:E'nNG OF SECRETARY AND VICEROY<br />
GOVERNMENT No'T TO BE INTIMIDATED<br />
, OPEN TO EARNEST REPRESENTATIONS<br />
to~do'n.-Lord B~rkenhead made au important<br />
sl:ateiliell't in the House' 6f Lords thls ev~mn~<br />
in Te'gard to his confererlces with the VlCpi'oy,<br />
L:OI;q. R~ding, on the Indian proble!ll.<br />
. all stat.eayS. "The Government<br />
of IndIa by anyone presents almost insuperable<br />
dIfficultIes. The Dmrchy offers a chan6e to those<br />
who claIm 'IndIJ. 11 natibn' for their watchword to<br />
learn somethIng of its limitations. Is thIS chance
, to, ~e completely neglected? 'We can hardly think<br />
80. .,.<br />
,<br />
I<br />
::Y.e~ it remain.s the fact t!'tat two-thirds of ,lhe ,<br />
trial p.er~o4 pas pASsed witfiput reveal~ng any organ.<br />
iMtion ,capaLle of r\ll~ng, although it has shown a<br />
very vigorous organisat,ion for wrecking.', " "<br />
"1.01'(\ Birken~ead a44ed little, to our knQwledg~<br />
1,ast ni"~t. btlt at ),east h,e show,ed some compr(jhe~.<br />
.. :!.J. o~ tIle ditficulties of toe Ql1etltklO: aT!d iliA 110~<br />
at~empt to rf7m~v~'tp.e t:~pon!!ibilitr of 4s so~ution<br />
from ~he panels 9f the people of IndJa.-Reuter.<br />
¥ I .... .:-,<br />
THE,CHALLENGE Of SOUTH AFRICA<br />
The position' of India in the Drifis'h Empire is a<br />
pecnH'ar'¢ne. FOr Indllln's lite tb~ (lnly non-White<br />
race~aI1lobg'\l. gtotip 'bi white D6minions having a<br />
civilisation of their own and claiming equal civjc<br />
aria naVtmal tights with' felldw-citizens of the Em.<br />
pirl'.' Btit the' cb}dnr issue sharPly di~ides the tmpira<br />
rettder!yjg Indians not e!f/lal rp'etnbers but the<br />
underdogs nt parts;<br />
ahd't'h'e 'deal of a gloridus,imperiaf.federation seems<br />
a'brt1t'l mockel-Y to Indicln!! who have no place consiste"t<br />
with' s(>lf-respeCt in: atly quarter of the Empire<br />
wllfch turns theJii' Ollt after bU,ilding its prosperity'on<br />
their 'labour. South Africa is the crux of<br />
the hhpElr,ia:t prdblent so far'as the racidl question ~s<br />
cOl'wtJl'bed; I c01dur hatred, economIc hostility, and<br />
pblitical 'prejUibce have there debrived Indians, of<br />
their'~vic's~ttts, sociai'rights and economic l~bhty.<br />
RepelitedlY It fias' pronounced the verdict on. the<br />
sta,tus to which Indian cittzens are doomed in the<br />
EtHpire' whUe the Iqlperial Goverill~ent<br />
have te:<br />
mumed callously neutral and the Go'Vernment of<br />
Iridl'a 'criminally apathetic and inllctive.<br />
r Witbil\ the s}loi't "'space of a weeki news has come<br />
from Sont~ :Aftica'wbicli, wefe India ail autonom6us<br />
an'd sett-teliant' natiOn! would constitute enbh~~<br />
prOvOc.'lti,bn'for ,her taking ,the stronRes~ mf~n~e8<br />
possiblE! to safeguard hel' natiqnals abroad. For a.ccetftuat'ing<br />
a~ the \'egishtti'Ve propbsals and action do<br />
the l \>oli~y Of ~iff~rent1ation' and humiliation, they<br />
r'edl'lcd fndiaus tQ the state of pu're helotry. yron.<br />
sid!>r the position:' Indian immigratIOn has been<br />
Stopped and :Vil;o~OWl efforts are' being made to hidl1'ce<br />
1ndillM to l'ep!ttrhite'the'Ulselves. The Inrlians<br />
residing in Airic.'\ are depriV'ett of parliamentary<br />
l'tl\nchis'e, sbut Ol)t from ptlblic life and t;ociai interco'Orr¢,1<br />
prohlbited' from phrch'asing land ~nd dellied<br />
dddC3tibn~t frl,cilitil>s 'amI c)rdlItary munlc1pal ament<br />
~'v(j: '~v{deiltly this is not enbugh for the Whites.<br />
"~t week Gandhlf~e~eivect a cab~e, ih~Ormi:hg ~fin<br />
t}iat a."mn Wli!! bewg 'll~troddced, in the Un,ion AS 7<br />
s'~Inb1f 'by'polone1:901lins ~rohibitin~ th'e grant or<br />
renhval" of "tra'dipg or 'bu"SineSs licences. J6 :':lnt<br />
AsIatics within six miles of thll Thinsva..ll Municipal<br />
Or 'T6wrlilhip' areas. On the '6th l\IJ.rch w'hi-n Colonel<br />
COl\U1S was to in:troduce this Transvaal fnrthd Ref!<br />
ftlc~io~s'~ASiatic) Bill; .he withdrew it oh th~ gr6un~<br />
that 'the Government Itself 1ntendeil to Qrni,!! in a.<br />
comprehensive measure de~ling 'with the -subject;<br />
The retteat 6f'the"gtillant Colonel, ho~ever, was a<br />
f " ;., I<br />
reprieve~ Dot a final del~"\\'~rance, for the fndians" f01;<br />
he is again proposing to in~roduce the meaSure. lin.<br />
order to l'e~lisp the, manner in which th& ~m ,'Yill<br />
prove detrimental to the f'coJ;lomic interests. of Tndians.<br />
it ~s necebsary to under!jtan'd its implicationS<br />
,... hich have been, well pointed o!lt in. t,* -rf.fF.I(;(Jn"<br />
Cltro'mde. If the Bill is p,assed, nQ lndjall wID,,bi)<br />
entih~d to l'ivE' or trade hi l1rb~n, area OJ; bJ;lY land<br />
anY\\!'h.e~e; if, for example, an Indian, is dyiug !J,~<br />
will have to ,walk sIx miles in cw;;e an In~ Auctor<br />
is noi available. ;t'he hip. /is GaAdhiji, emi>~si~ea,<br />
i is a manifes,t breacQ o~ the ,S/llntB-Ga~dh~ "gree~epj;<br />
in ~914, and i.s pmch, m9r6 in.\mical tq IQdial}.<br />
interests than, the C13.i!8 Areas ~~~l ~'hicp 'Iap~d.<br />
owing' to the fa!l o~ the Smuts. ~overJlJDent. p~~<br />
what the Class Areas BiI~ faileq to do \)y ,means of<br />
"pro,claiming" areal!! has been accomplished,in 'Nat8.1<br />
through the Natal Township Franchise OrQ.inance to<br />
wlii~ck how<br />
the Bill spens e1conomlc ruin for the Jndian ,lI.n~<br />
milita~e!,l'against ilis lJaHonal llonour. ,It,.throo.~ns<br />
to oust from employment ,bamero.lls Indian ,wage~<br />
earners, voice~ess ltlJd voteless as th~y are, w,it;p. Ii<br />
stroke of the 'Minister's pen and, disallows .. the em.<br />
ployment of Indians save, perhaps, ,as' ~nn3l ,41>ourer.<br />
As tliough the coloul; bar were not sWficlentlr<br />
wide. haviJlg been extenonl',~'<br />
South J\,fl.'ican ~atio~aJity .J3ilJ. or t~e lIf!nim:uUL<br />
Wages BilJ or varlQus executiveregulabons prq:mpt~<br />
tid anti~Asiahc LeagUe&: which, "in th", guise of'<br />
achieving /jome refprm,..are calqulat.ed to ;hit ~he IIh<br />
dIan. citizen or tlfloder: Wba~ is, the Governmen,~.of<br />
~ud,ia' retort to tb,is.~nerj,re}ie 'poUC~"9~ .p~r8.e.c~4<br />
anit insult of ,~ne,u: nat!QII~lo/. Genera,! ~erjrzOg<br />
, laconicdlly men,hoTle4 l~ a. speecn, that. lie hl..d l'e~<br />
ceived a propos&l 1()J;' a Ronnd. 'raQle~_ Con&ereno/;l<br />
with'lIle reprE's\lr{t,ltlves o! the Inuia.n qovernment<br />
and then passed on to other 8U!?)ects. That is the
180 .ffblf1~ OPlNJON July 17th, 1925<br />
total result o~' ,t4e furtive negotia.tionlil and eaJ;IWst<br />
representations of Lor~ Reading. We are not Sl1rpHsed'at<br />
the General's snub because a lIubordin~te<br />
branch of His Majesty's Government can har(jly elJ:<br />
p,ect a more fruitfu,l reliPpnse. Lord Birkenheq.d<br />
apd T.ord Reading cannot ~eel the pumiliation which<br />
their IndiaJl fellow-subjects, f,eel: they can at best<br />
srmpathise with, and at worst, ignore the popular<br />
feeling of inuignati,ion' and exacerbation. It is not<br />
possible to appeal fO the sense of justice of General<br />
1¥rtzog who in his reply to General SllJuts pleaded<br />
for discarding'ethical principles. The subject having<br />
been lifted from what 'Nietzsche would ,call<br />
"'slave-moral~ty" into the higher and practical<br />
atmosphere of economic self-interest backed - by<br />
physical' f6rce aim~ng at the pr£'servation of the<br />
civilisation of superman, even intellectual virtlles<br />
like honesty are of little account since solemn<br />
-pledgeSjIl'e wantonly and repeatealy broken. There<br />
is 'oDly one thing South Africa can understandresolute<br />
action. Palmerston in a famous utterance<br />
said that "as the Roman in
July 17th, 1925 INI>fAN OPINION 18i<br />
use mast be given an opportunitl to exploit it. How<br />
does the qUestIOIl present itself wben viewed (rom tbil<br />
aspect? The answer is given bI tbe aut)lor' in t.he<br />
following words: "A people at preseot lewet in Dumber<br />
tllan the population of London JlOIlI!e!l8 A ustralia, a continent<br />
almost of the size of Enrope." The autbor at aoy<br />
rate bas a lively recognition of duties which tbe right,<br />
claimed by Australia, of self-realisation 88 a membPr or<br />
'_~e oations of the world, entails npou her. "The world<br />
oeeds tbe supplies that it would receive if the reJ!Oorces<br />
of Anstralia were folly developed. 00 Australia's williognees<br />
and ability to develop th('se resource. within a<br />
reasonable time seems to depend her r ght to relaiu her<br />
identity b, the f'xclusion of people who would be qnit4a<br />
lVi/IJng to enter her country and do this work." And<br />
-si~ thit coooition, of caurse. sbe cannot. pOI!sibly folfil,<br />
it is-c1ear that from tbe point of "jew of'flUllwuty 8S<br />
a whole the dilemma of either choosing to keep AUII~ralia<br />
purely British in colture, but undeveloped; or else riskiog<br />
a new and largely Asiatic cultore to develop tbere<br />
wllich however woold eusore the Continent making its<br />
fnll contribution to the needs of the world : can only be<br />
IIOlved b, boMly and nnflinchingly declaring for the<br />
latt(r alternative.<br />
COMMONWEALTH BILL<br />
INDIA. UNDER AN INDIAN CONS'l'lTUTION<br />
" The most striking featur. 01 the presf'nt constitution<br />
is the vast power wielded by the Secretary of<br />
St&te tof India. Seated six thousands of miles away,<br />
he has complete authority over the administration<br />
and the revenues of India. He is a member of the<br />
British Cabinet, responsible to Parliament alone for<br />
the manner in which he exertJises his powera of<br />
superintendence, direction and control over the<br />
affairs of India. All these powers are swept away<br />
by the Commonwealth of India Bill. The Secretary<br />
of State is l1arely mentioned, except for the pur.{>ose<br />
of trlllUi£
~ pa4 J.o!llJ?~ratiVely' -\itjJ~.)~a!'Qefgi;jd~~, betWE'Bn<br />
:: 1¥6 !.I?I;l~ ·If i~ lS tr~E'., ~hl}t, the, yo~mg, "Maha~m~"<br />
'ffo~ no,'mp.rfl t-RIW BOme ten thousand .rp.pees alii ,hiS<br />
¢}af~ i* IIp¥aklil, :W~U fOrJl~8 courage tLud con8.dence<br />
tP hi~e}.f. tp~~ he; !lhcmld. baYlJ shared \ the kalapani<br />
. ~4:iitl~~$~·tlir,~~ y~rs'dstuqy, in Ellgla)"ld, in order<br />
','to;ll!!1ca;t.lefJ, tQ ,~~ Ba:r 14~ ,80 small a, capit!l;l., Be<br />
''fP8f ali\~t'IJ1~lh he,~~s 9al}~Q, 'to tbe Bar. 1 and re<br />
~rueq. ffi Kathiaw~, int~nding to pr~otice<br />
. ~ INDIAN QPINION<br />
tj:J.? pro<br />
'~(H~~d m.~rcenll-rY· prO~eBSIOn. qf the law In, the<br />
" Agency, CmLrts. ; 4,.nd that is when ~ met bIm.<br />
. fnQei¢ he mu~~ ha"Vf;! mag€! hi~ (iebut in ;the ChIef<br />
:p~m;t .l?~ore., me, ,soIl!~where about 1893. As j:J.e<br />
¥..sleyolv~d:. ,t 18 ~ 1ittl~, di.ffioult to picture, him, a<br />
"f~t~nlilt)\lS cQDlIpetltor in. tbat mllndane and most<br />
'*Pi3Piritua\lu·ena. , But qis' qestiny' soon called, hIm<br />
elsewhere. Assuredly, he wou)q never have -peen<br />
I!> ~_uqc~!jSful hq.rrlster·"<br />
I >4- " .. ~ ., ,-.. >. .., ,.. j~ , J<br />
'j~S~"«;:(·:E~~(~(~~ ~~~~1i'~)~~, ~)~~)~~~)~~'~~~~<br />
,'. OUR LONDON 1,ET'PER ' ~<br />
. ,~, "E FROl\i OUR 'OWN CORRESPONDENT] .<br />
• • r 19th ;)"une; 1925:' ~<br />
, c:«(e '!i'1l4news of tne' suddeYll de-atb' df :J\lr. 0:' R. Das ,<br />
'ha'i1 COJD!~'l!.S l!'shl:>clir t(bJ Indians, particlllady ''Of 'the<br />
lM'iclentl(:lk/.ss, tb whom' hel was> 'r&pieseI1tative hi his<br />
l1eraoill ol,the aspinitiomi of India. I ~ , ,tI<br />
L'-W'Irer~et-tonetgoes, b'ne i is' strnck with the many<br />
anno\&#e'm\:lnt~ lof thl~ ~ti6us fdfms' of 'auiuse1ll,eht',<br />
IiIi'd :p1Sib~ tif iht&eat 'one'\nay 'visit. whether in the<br />
Brih'sh Isle's, bl- -on. 'tli~ . contim!nt. 'The' neople 'of<br />
$hgf;ind'krlbw not onit how 'to' w;orlt/'but' to tak~<br />
th~1r"h01id~yJ:l. Life'M them j is not a question Of<br />
pt~t-'e 'ii16hdy inaIting...!.tl.t'represent!! to t.bem iii means<br />
_ -'s' {1' " ,IH £ t j '.I J ,1 ( •<br />
to the appreciation of the better' things of' this lif-f',<br />
and this no doubt to a grpat extent aCCOtlflta ~or the<br />
blQoyancy of the spirit, and the confidence of the<br />
British in themselves. 'i'<br />
"'Expectations in J~gard to the attendances at the<br />
Wembley ~xhibition. has not bpen ftllfilltld. tbMkh<br />
the claim :&as been made that the WerI'llil(>y 'of ' this<br />
year is better an.d brighter than last year's. ' The aJmission<br />
charged jnolul;live o{ the tram fare fl'o:':;;'<br />
places, within' a radius of 20 ',miles from Wem\-)le,V.<br />
has been reduced tb two shillings from two shillIngs<br />
and 'nine pence-in the nopE' 'of attracting 'larger<br />
crowds. " ""', '<br />
" ,<br />
, It is a matter of thankflllnes!I. that the Dawes<br />
Scheme for tIle. reparation ,payments by G€Il'lnanr,<br />
to the Allies, hl}S d\1ring the last eight WO)l\Us<br />
worked sahsfactorily, and thel'e 18 every' iDtlicat1~n<br />
that' this scheme will ac~ieve its hlgPly l~e8irable<br />
imKPoses.<br />
II<br />
The first a4journecJ annual general meeting<br />
of the above Association will take place<br />
place at the l 'Tamil tl1s'titute, ,Cross Street,<br />
on Sunday the .l6th day of July '19.5 comniencmg<br />
at 2-3 ,.p"~ when Lhe following<br />
business will be transacletl. I ,<br />
, i.. I, I I) V ' 1 B'I'<br />
~. t~lf~Ule!? ~. nepqrt. 3. "a,anc~<br />
$reet. ". Ah€ralrlon ana Revision of rules.<br />
s. Elections. . 6. General.<br />
Members onlr WIll be able to participate<br />
in the'dehberdtltms. ' ". I r I I<br />
"<br />
_, - I ,; •<br />
NOTICE<br />
r I( , r. 'J t<br />
. , '<br />
TJlE REGENERHION OF INOIAN YOUTH.<br />
, '<br />
1<br />
A l--
~ttdian<br />
®pinitltt<br />
No. 3Q-Vol. XXIII. Friday, July 24th, 1925.<br />
TRIBUTES TO DESHBANDHU DAS<br />
BRITISH LABOUR PARTY'S RENEWED PLEDGE TO CO-OPERATE<br />
\\i\YE give below SODle of the tril:>utes paid to<br />
\1~ the late Mr. C. R. Das by prominent people<br />
in I ndia and England :-<br />
Deshbandhu is gone. God's will be done. He<br />
alone is great.<br />
GANDHI.<br />
The National Conncil of the Indepl"ndent Labour<br />
Party has Bent a message to Pandtit MotHai Ne'hru<br />
expressing great regret at the death of Mr. Das and<br />
declaring that Mr. Das was one of the most sincere<br />
and able leaders the Indian people ever had and if<br />
the British Government had respon'.ied to his recent<br />
appcal it might have been the means for bridging<br />
the gulf between the two nations. "We express our<br />
warm sympathy with India in its loss and renew our<br />
pledge to co-operate in working for full political and<br />
economic liberty of the Indian people .... ~R~uter.<br />
Sir Hubert Carr, President of the European Assoeiation,<br />
in an interview with a representative of the<br />
,statesman says: Standing under the death shadow,<br />
opposing and critical thoughts ara silenceu and all<br />
well-wishers of the province and land of Mr. Das<br />
will gljitefully cherish his memory. Towards the<br />
end of a tragically shortened life he made clear signs<br />
of substituting for the policy of uncompromising<br />
hostility towards those with whom he diS.lgreed the<br />
policy of conciliation. I sincerely regret that Mr.<br />
Das was not spared to carry it into effect. One may<br />
express the hope that all parties may adhf're to and<br />
develop that policy of goodwill by which alone the<br />
dream of Mr. O. R D.ls's life will be realiileu."<br />
I am positively certain that the whole of Mushm<br />
India shnres with Mrs. O. R. Das the grpat national<br />
Borrow. We have lost the next best mln we hall<br />
after Mahatma Gandhi. But "God's will be done"<br />
88 the Mahatma says. Mahatma sent me the news<br />
from Khulna. His words of consolation would<br />
carry conTiction and courage to many of hiu coworkers.<br />
I am proud to think that like another soldier Hi<br />
Amma, Deshbandhu Das died in harm'ss. As a<br />
hum'-1e co-worker of his nothing would please me<br />
better than to pass away while working h,lrd for<br />
Islam and India. I appeal to both Muslims and<br />
Hindus that in view of Deshbandhu D,lS'S death,<br />
they ought to see that there be no quarrels during<br />
the coming Id. Deshbandhu Das was a staullch believpr<br />
in and worker for Hindu-Muslim heart to<br />
heart unity. Can we not in the loving memory of<br />
this dear departed brother of ours show this rE-lpect<br />
to his memory? Mere words and resolutions would<br />
do no good. In deeds antI srtions we mnst show to<br />
l the enemies and opponents of India that we mean<br />
business.<br />
By Deshbandhu D.l8's death Inaia has lost a great<br />
leader, and we a dear brother anli co-worker. Men<br />
like Deshbandhu Das never dIe. Thl"Y always live.<br />
Only I feel that at a time when the big struggle is<br />
r to begin soon Deshbandhu Das will not be with us<br />
to lead us to victory and triumph. "God is great."<br />
Bengal alone will produce many more men to take<br />
up his place. We must not accept defeat. One<br />
soldier is gone; God will give us many mOle. At<br />
least let us do our best.<br />
SHAUKAT ALI.<br />
The sudden and untimely death of Mr. C. R. Dail<br />
is a great loss to India. His death takes awaf a<br />
great personality and a most powerful influence<br />
from public life, espeCially in Bengal. Although-I<br />
did not share his views particularly since the Nagpur<br />
Congress-J have lost in him a personal friend and<br />
India a great patriot who was selflessly devoted to<br />
the cause which he tried to serve at a great sacrifice;<br />
which commanded the respect and admiration of<br />
even those who did not see eye to eye with him.<br />
This moment I can only say that all India must<br />
feel the shock and deeply mourn the terrible loss<br />
and offer their most heartfelt sympathy to his<br />
family in their bereavement.<br />
M. A. JIYNAH.<br />
The news of the death of De!lhband!J.u Das came<br />
to me ail a bolt from the blue. I knew that he was<br />
aIling for some time past but I never thought that<br />
the end was so near. HlS death at this juncture of<br />
our national struggle creates a void which it is very<br />
dlfficu It for a long long time to fill. Deshbandhu<br />
Dols was a dynamiC and organising force in our<br />
national actiVity. When the Non-co-operation movement<br />
was on its wane, the Deshbandhu gave a new<br />
turn to our national struggle. He was a terror and<br />
a nightinare to the bureaucracy. For the last two<br />
years he was really the uncrowned king of Benjlal.<br />
Lord Lytton was nominally the ruler of Bengal but<br />
the real ruler of Bengal was Deshbandhu Das. What<br />
Lokmanya Tllak was to Moharashtra Deshbandhu<br />
was to Bengal. What the Lokmanya was to all<br />
India the Deshbandhu was to India of his time. His<br />
sacrifice for the cause of freeaom was unparalleled.<br />
In fine he lived and died for his country.<br />
V. J. PATEL.<br />
The Deshbandhu is dead and with him has disappear.:d<br />
if not the greatest, undoubtedly the most<br />
aetive, inspiriug and outstanding political figure of<br />
modern India. The shock has come so suddenly<br />
and so terribly that we can hardly rll8lise, either the<br />
immensity of the loss or the gravity of its effect<br />
upou the future pohticalsituation in India.<br />
No other lealieI', ~xcept perhaps the Mahatma.<br />
had, of IdtE', instilIf'd so milch enthusiasm, spirit and<br />
hE'althy vigour in "Young India," as this depart.ell<br />
"ldE'al of Yonth." His glorious career, his undyjng<br />
tlE'votion, his tremt'ndous sacrifices and abovlfJ"t hie<br />
fearlf'ss independence and love of tru~"'lldd endeared<br />
him to hlS countrymen to su~h an extent<br />
that he was an ever-living and all insPiring example<br />
to whole political India. Without the least exaggeration<br />
hE' was 'h.diau Nationalism' personmed. When<br />
he liv
Freedom, and alas I to the very altar he has ultimately<br />
sacrifib,ed his life. His name will rank<br />
amongst the foremost of the great generals who<br />
have laid down their lIves in the field of battle is<br />
the very thing of the struggle and the only fittmg<br />
memorial that the country can raise to perpetuate<br />
his undying memory is not by crE'ating here and<br />
there a bronze or a marble statute, but by dlffusmg<br />
throughout the country the true Dassite spitit, so<br />
that though the hero is physically dead and gone<br />
still politically he may live as strong and inspiring<br />
as ever, till the goal, for which he fought so heroically<br />
and for which he died so valIantly, is finally<br />
reached.<br />
KHURSHED F. NARIMAN.<br />
The sudde'p death of Mr. C. R. Das is a staggering<br />
blow to the national cause. His outstanding quality<br />
was courage. When he realised that the boycott of<br />
Councils was a mIstake, he advocated its abandonment<br />
in his presidential address to the Gaya Congress,<br />
though he knew that it will expose him to<br />
misunderstanding and misr~pJesentatlOn. He threw<br />
himself heaI't and soul into the movement in favour<br />
of Counci11lntry and in a short six months, h1l had<br />
brought round the majority of the Congress to his<br />
view. His last pronouncement at Faridpur, is a<br />
stronger proof of his dauntless spirit. That address<br />
has now become his last messal,"9 to his people. And<br />
I for one, think that It is a message full of wise reflection<br />
and guidance to us in all the main issues of<br />
Indian politics.<br />
K. NATARAJAN.<br />
Interviewed by a representative of the H~ndu Mr.<br />
Yakub lIassan, promment Moslem Congress leader<br />
said the death of Deshbandhu C. R. Das at this<br />
particular moment when he had secured that<br />
amount of confidence of the entire country that was<br />
D0cessary to back him up m the next move that he<br />
was con.templating and espeCIally when the Government<br />
was evidently trying to find ways and means<br />
of negotiating wIth him without loss of prestlge, was<br />
a national calamity of a very great magnitude.<br />
Whatever might be the fate of the Swarajya Party<br />
and~hatever part it might play in the future in the<br />
winning of Swaraj, Mr. Das's own bl'lef, alas too<br />
brief career, had been of sufficiently galvamzmg<br />
force and character to ensure for hImself a place in<br />
the 'history of India as one of the foremost nation<br />
builders.<br />
--<br />
BOMBAY CORPORATION'S TRIBUTE<br />
A meeting of the Municipal Corporation was held<br />
on Wednesday, 17th June, Mr. Joseph BaptIsta presldiug.<br />
The President said:<br />
Comradea.-The angel of death has once more<br />
stricken us with sorrow. This tIme he has snatched<br />
away from us one who bore the heat and purden of<br />
the day as Mayor of the Calcutta Corporation and<br />
leader of the Swaraj party. Inscrutable are the ways of<br />
Divine Providence. It IS impossible for the fimte<br />
mind of ULan to fathom the mfinite wIsdom of God.<br />
But one may be permitted to hope that our departed<br />
friend's famous gesture for peace wIth honour, and<br />
progress with goodwill will not be bUrled and<br />
cremated wlth his mortal remains. In tl.is moment<br />
gf mourning when the heart of India is bleedlllg a<br />
great opportunity affords Itself to the British people<br />
and the British statesmen to filoothe the sorrow of<br />
India by, some consoling act of high-minded states<br />
IDMlship and righteousoess. May England have the<br />
wisdom :to seize the 'Opportunity which Providence<br />
hal aiven ,her!<br />
INDIAN OPINION 1 uly 24th, 1925<br />
------------.:--------<br />
It is superfluous for me to say that l3..tbu Chitta<br />
RanJan Das was one of the brightest stars in the Indian<br />
firmament, a mornmg star in the hour of darkness.<br />
He was endowed ,Vtth brreat talents, remforced<br />
and sharpened hy acquired knowledge, and I'efined<br />
by the culture of a scholar and a lawyer. Two<br />
ways lay before hIm, the way of wealth with honour<br />
and all the comforts and JOYS which wealth can purchase<br />
and the way of duty With honour atlll all the<br />
sacrifices which duty dE'mands. It is to his etern,\l<br />
credit that after havlDg tested the secrets of wealth<br />
with honour and comfort he forsook them for the<br />
vale of tears for he felt that the vale of tears was<br />
the only path of duty open to a true and devoted·<br />
sou of India in the state of her Bubjection. But he<br />
tried the vale of tears with courage and fortitude<br />
and he sought to clear the path of thorns and<br />
obstacles willi peacetul weapons as a true apolltle of<br />
Ahlmsa. He is gone With work half done, hut he<br />
will live in our memory as an example of an upright<br />
man acting according to the dIctates ot his<br />
conSCIence and convictlOn without foar or favour.<br />
He IS now before the bar of hiS CI'eator and there<br />
can be little doubt that he Will be welcompd in the<br />
words of St. Mathew the Apostle "Well uone. thon<br />
gooU and faithful servant; PosRess you the kingdom<br />
prepared far from the foundation of the world."<br />
GREATEST POLITICAL LEADER<br />
Mr. V. J. Patel said they had met there under the<br />
shadow of a great calamity. Deshbandhu DJ.S, the<br />
greatest political leader of IndIa, had gone. He was<br />
the Mayor of Calcutta under the new Municipal<br />
ConstitutlOn and he sacrificed his all in the caUf
Juty !4t~0:ZS iNbiAN OPltHON 18S<br />
----------------~_r~~_~_~_7_~__----~----------------~-<br />
A WELCOME APPOINTYENT<br />
. l\\yEWS has been received of tl.e appointment<br />
A ~ of Pundit Motilal Nehru to the Presidentship<br />
of Swaraj Party We can think of<br />
no moro popular appointment. Pundit Motilal<br />
Nelau is the U 06t poPlllal· pe11lOn in India a[fRr<br />
Mahatma Gandhi and the late Mr. C It Das, a8<br />
his selection to tlu' Presidentship must be acclaimed<br />
with ('very satisfa.ction. The destiny of the<br />
.nature of India lies with the Swaraj Party, and it<br />
is therefore all the more pleasing to hear that the<br />
reins of the Party are in the capable hands of tbe<br />
Pundit.<br />
The Pundit holds a Vt'ry prominent position in<br />
the Indian political world, and his action in sacri·<br />
fioing a huge legal practice for the sake of India is<br />
very 101gb1y commendable. His foresightedness is<br />
beyond reproach, and his matured advice to the<br />
ra.nk and file 01 the Swaraj Party will tend to bring<br />
harmony within the folds.<br />
Mahatma. Gandhi has advised the Pundit tha\<br />
he intends approaching the All India Congress<br />
Committee with a view to placing the whol" or the<br />
machinelY of the Congrefls ai tbe disposal of the<br />
SVlarll1j Party. The step taken by Mahatma<br />
Gandlti is a commendable one, and this will tend<br />
to increase the authority of the Swaraj Party.<br />
.As Pundit Motilal Nehru 1as very rightly remarked<br />
that despite the late Mr. Das's offer of<br />
co-operation, there still appears to be many<br />
obstacles placed before us by iJl"esponsible authorities.<br />
Lord Birkenhead's speech has roused the susplclons<br />
'
186 INDIAN OPINION July 24th, 1925<br />
"NO NATI inimICal to Great Britain? There is<br />
none.<br />
Inter·dependence is a great ideal. But it can be<br />
truly realised only by independent natIOns and only<br />
so long as they are mdependent.<br />
INDIANS AND AMERICAN CITIZENSHIP<br />
We have referred on previous occasions to the<br />
ignoble decision of the Supreme Court of the United<br />
States, revoking the citizenship rights of Indians<br />
residing in that country. News now comes of pl'Oceedings<br />
pending before the United States District<br />
Court for the revocation of citIzenship rights in the<br />
case of Mr. Bisham Singh Mattu and thit,ty and odd<br />
other naturalIsed Hmdus (m AmerICa "Hmdu"<br />
means only "Indian") of Cahfornia. Accordmg to<br />
reports in American papers, .Mr. Mattu became a<br />
naturalised American citizen in 1921. He has<br />
acquired property. established a pl'ofitable ImpOl ting<br />
business and has married an American WOllllLn. He<br />
is the president of the Indian Company Inc, 149,<br />
California Street. It is reported that, when he<br />
talked of the prospect of expatriation that awaIts<br />
him, "Mattu who is a substantIal man of business,<br />
known throughout San Francisco's COmlllf'I'Clal dIStrict<br />
as a leading oriental imporLer, was on the verge<br />
of tears." Commenting on this the Htndu ot Madras<br />
writes in the course of its leadmg article 001 the 15th<br />
instant under the heading "Benevolent Dominion" ,-<br />
The pathetic stol'y ot the threatened expatrution<br />
of Bisham Singh Mattu, a prominent Hmdu natural.<br />
ised citizen of the United States, is evidently the<br />
1'esult of such propa&'Rnda as is referred in the above<br />
letter, (the letter received by Mr. C. Andrews whic'l<br />
was pubhshf'd In )'0111111 I,trila,) and the r.lcial virns<br />
thus lUJected lUtO the minds of the AmericlDS. We<br />
referred in t1ll'se columns, a tew days ago, to the<br />
movement started under olJiclal allspices to deprive<br />
IndmnB in U,S.A. of the nghts of citizenship by a<br />
smister interprl't,ltlOn of the laws under which the<br />
rights were orlglUallv acqllired, This weck's mail<br />
brings In l'vidence of the I'elentle~~ pursuit of the<br />
anti-Indian camp,lign, of which Maltl1'9 inst,mce is<br />
bnt one. Another episode IS the reported u
July 24th, 1
~88 ·rNOIAN OPINION July 24th, 1925 .<br />
subjeot tbereafter, but only wish them well. Sectional<br />
and oommonal aim. should not hamp8r India's onward<br />
m!l.l'Ch towards proQ'ress.<br />
Again thev a~keil frr certain irrigation facilities to be<br />
investigated and explored. Such facilitil's were essent.ial<br />
ID an agflcultural cOuntry as South India and It was the<br />
first and forem~t quty of t,he IItata to increase irrigation<br />
facilities. Tftis matter ha,d been sprung on him and be<br />
had not'thougllt over what they had suggested in the<br />
addreliil nor had he oonsnlted the Encntive Engineer<br />
awtlb it and its possibilities to lay anythinl!' deflnitely on<br />
the subject. In tho pl'ogreas of Irrigation lay the salvation<br />
of tbe QQuntry. There were &"1'10 directIons in which<br />
thoy oould~work. The first waa stata..aid and the otber<br />
wM the nee of chellp power by availing themllelvel of the<br />
nit watt'f power whioh existed in that part of the oountry<br />
f"l' industrial progress. Then he dealt with the<br />
qll{l6tion of tha lOORtion of Courts wbich he said was a<br />
(lonUlntious one and a matter fol' admmistrative sorutiny.<br />
The Hon'ble Member was then entertained at an<br />
"Evening party at the r(li1ldelloo of Mr. P. K. S. A. Mny:mgo,8wami<br />
Nadar, M.L.D. which Willi well att.ended.<br />
Later in the night he left Siv!lkasi for Sattul' en route to<br />
Madras.<br />
SIR B. N. 8ARMA'3 HUCCES80R<br />
SPECULATION IN SlMLA CIl\CLES<br />
'fbe question of Sir Narashnha Sarma.'s succesaor is<br />
~gain being made the subject of flpeoulation. Tbis time<br />
Sir ChuDllal Mehta's llame il'l bell~g mentiQned fr~ly.<br />
,Si.r CQunllal' was kni\{hted only a month a~o. and<br />
htl seems to be on good. terms with the bureaucracy and<br />
also not quite unpopular. It is probablt' that Governmept<br />
m!lY decide ~o have him because It is detennlDed if<br />
it can, ~o hltve a Bombayite to sa"\"e itself from the fury<br />
of the viefercu~ ~ombay Prt'es.<br />
At on~ tlme the name of Mr. S, R. Das Advocate<br />
General, Bengal, was menlioned 1111 the most hkely, bnt<br />
t~e presen~ of Ii Bengalee, SiI' B.N. Mitra, has hitherto<br />
stood in his way. If Sir Ohunilal is I\PPOillWd, there<br />
will \1gatu be ,a resbuflling I>f pOl'tfql ios.<br />
Sir ChunUal is 1)0W in Europe and this may help him<br />
to smoothen his way to the higber post.<br />
j -"= _; ;; 4<br />
BANANA PRODUCTION IN THE EMPIRE<br />
Tl~e A{lrwultural JOllrnal Q( Inlitre pnbliilhlll'3 t4e<br />
foliQwing:~ , ,<br />
A.lthough many people in the United Kingdom.<br />
associate the banana pl\l'tlCularly with Jamaica 11I1Q<br />
the Canary lslands, not lllQre tnan two·fiftha ot th~<br />
fruit impo.r;tlld into the country coml's from those<br />
cQunt.riell. the remamidg three-firths being stlPphed<br />
by Oolom.bia, Costa Rica anq the Eepllbhc of<br />
Honduras.<br />
ln 19~2, baniJ.nas were imported into the United<br />
Kingq.on;l to the value of OVer £5.300.0JO o( wllHlh<br />
aInQunt only about £6,000.000 1'IlPl'IlSelltlld prodnc~<br />
of lkitillh PQsses§iQns, In view of tbe fact that the<br />
blloUlJ,U,il ca.n be grown 1)1 most trOPICal lands wher~<br />
labcmr is available, it would therefore seem advisable<br />
to consider whether a greater share in the banana.<br />
indUfltry could lI0t be nndertal\:en within the<br />
Empit:e, lllore particularly in parts of Wt'lit<br />
Mrioa. which are within a comparatlvely short dir.<br />
tanC!} of tbe "l\OUlIl )Jlarl\:et. The present position of<br />
the jl)dJ;lstry in the varioUfl Gountries of thll Empire<br />
is \ndicated in an article on "The Banana and its<br />
C'lltivl).tion with Special Rllference to the Ernpirr."<br />
pu,blil3hed ill, the I';urrent issue of thll Bulletin ~f lite<br />
Impertal I118Ml~te. which al~a gives pil,f\iClllarli of<br />
me~bQd!l ()f growing the fruit and the prePI\l'ation of<br />
vaJ;'l()Uff products, J;lUcn as banana flour and 41'ietl<br />
ballaMS Of l~tiga." Of the British West lndl~<br />
Islan
®pinitltt<br />
No.,31 Vol. XXIII. Friday, July 3Jst, 1925.<br />
Jlegutered.t tIoe o. P.o .... Ho .. ,."".<br />
PUGI: Fov ..... ,.<br />
UNION PARLIAMENT<br />
~DR. MALAN'S ASIATIC BILL.<br />
Capetown, July 23 (Heuter).-In the Honse of<br />
Assembly to-day, the Minister of the Interior (Dr.<br />
Malan) made an important statement in moving for<br />
leave to introduce a Bill, having for its object .. To<br />
make provision for the reservation of residential<br />
and trading areas in the urban areas for certain persons<br />
ha~ing racial characteristics in common· to<br />
amend the Immigrants' Regulation Act. 1913 'the<br />
Indians' Relief Act, 1914. and the Asiatic Registra.<br />
tion Amendment Act (TransvaaI). 190R. and to<br />
amend or repeal certain laws." ,<br />
The Minister pointed out at the outset that the<br />
introduction of this Bill was the fulfilment of an<br />
Undertaking he made during the last session of Par.<br />
liament about a yellr ago. On that occasion a motion<br />
was introduced by Mr. Marwick, and in the debate<br />
he (Dr. Malan) undertook to go into the whole<br />
Asiatic question during the recess as thoronghly as<br />
he could. and to introduce in the following session<br />
legislation dealing with that problem. lIe was very<br />
sorry he could not have the Bill ready before the<br />
very end of the session. because he realised.<br />
especially after having gone into U. that the Asiatic<br />
question was a very pressing one in this country<br />
(hear, hear). and that the delay would not make the<br />
solution of the question any easier. On the other<br />
hand. he was not S(lrry that it was impossible to<br />
carry this Bill further at this late stage. because<br />
during the recess the country as a whole would<br />
have the fullest opportunity of knowing what the<br />
policy of the Government was with regard to the<br />
Alliatic problem. He personally and the Government<br />
would certainly value criticism which might<br />
be brought forward in connection with this Bill,<br />
and he would be glad to adopt any helpful suggl'Stions<br />
that might be'made during the recess (hellr,<br />
hear). In his opinion the Asiatic question. like the<br />
Native question, was a problem. not for one parti.<br />
cular Party, }Jut for the whole country (hear, hear).<br />
and a question which should be held as far as<br />
possible out of the arena of Party strife. (Hear,<br />
hear.) He did not propose to make a second read·<br />
ing speech, seEling that the Bill was not in the<br />
hands of the members. but wished to make a few<br />
remarks ,of a gl'neral character.<br />
In the first place, as members would see when<br />
they came to study the Bill. it certainly would not.<br />
satisfy the extreme sections of the country. In<br />
thia'Bill he had tried to steer a safe and sane middle<br />
couTse. The radical element in the counbly would<br />
certainly think that the Bill was too weak and<br />
moderate, and on the other hand the element which<br />
was half·hearted or weak would certainly regard<br />
the Bill as going too far. as to radical. also that to a<br />
certain extent it would be oppressive. The Bill<br />
frankly started from the general supposition that the<br />
Indians as a race in this country were an alien<br />
element in the population (hear. hE'ar), and that no<br />
solution of this question 'would be acceptable to the<br />
country unless it resulted in a very considerable reduction<br />
of the Indian population (hear, hear). but<br />
on the other hanS, the method of dealing with this<br />
question would not be employment of any forcihle<br />
means, but wouIa consist of the application of the<br />
SAFE AND SANE MIDDLE COURSE<br />
Indian to leave the country. The Bill to a certain<br />
extent followed well-known lines, as in the Bill<br />
introduced by the late Government. but it went a<br />
good deal further than that measure in the direction<br />
of carrying out the recommendations of the Asiatic<br />
Inquiry Commission.<br />
In this Bill, continued the Minister. they were<br />
dealing not only with the residential and commercial<br />
~egregation, but wlth the land ownership, especially<br />
]n Natal. (Hear, hear). In addition, the Bill pro·<br />
posed in certain respects to amend the Immigrants<br />
Regulation Act. They found that there was a eonsldera~le<br />
influx of Indians still going on, especially<br />
of Indlan women. and the Amendments which were<br />
proposed in this BIll would go very far to put an<br />
effective stop to that influx. There was one omission<br />
that would certainly be noted by all members who<br />
read the Bill, and that was that It did not deal with<br />
the issue of trailing licencE'S. By another Bill which<br />
was before Parliament, the principle of uniformity<br />
of licences had been introduced, but that uniformity<br />
o,nly consisted in fixing the amounts, and the issue<br />
of licences to particular persons remained as before.<br />
in the hands of the Provincial Administrations, and<br />
so also with regard to the issue of trading licences<br />
to Asiatics. Dr. Malan further remarked that in<br />
this Blll he had tried to respect- as far as possible the<br />
susceptibilities of the Indian population and following<br />
the example of other legislation, it did ;ot mention<br />
Asiatics as a class at all. except where this had<br />
to be done in cases where reference was made to<br />
existing laws which did specifically 'refer to them as<br />
a class. In conclusion. the Minister said he wished<br />
to make himself quite clear on two points. The<br />
first point was that the introduction of this Bill<br />
must not be taken as closing the door to any negotiations<br />
or communications which might pass between<br />
the Union Government and the Government of India<br />
in regard to the Indian question. The Union<br />
Government had been approached by the Govern·<br />
ment of India with a view to holding a round-table<br />
conference on the treatment of Indians in South<br />
Africa. These negotiations had not yet closed, and<br />
they had taken a very definite course. So far as<br />
taking the introduction of this Bill as closing the<br />
doors between the two Governments, he took it that<br />
on the contrary the 'Statement of the Government's<br />
Asiatic policy as embodied in this Bill would very<br />
materially hpl~any further negotiations between<br />
the two Governments.<br />
RE'plying to an interjection by General Smuts, the<br />
Minister said he did not think it would be in the<br />
public interest for him to make any statement at<br />
present in r('gard to the negotiations hitherto.<br />
• Proceedmg, Dr. Malan said the second point he<br />
wished to emphasise was that whenever the Bill he<br />
was no\" introducing was passed it would take effect<br />
from August of this year. His reason for this was<br />
t3at the Bill respected certain vested rights. and if<br />
this step were not taken he was afraid there would<br />
be a general scramble among tlie Indian population<br />
for the creation of vested rights. and in that way the<br />
problem which they were seeking to solve would be<br />
made infinitely more complicated. Therefore th~
~ I<br />
INblAN OPINION july 31st, 1925<br />
Bill would come into operation as from August 1 of<br />
this year. (Cheers),<br />
The introduction 1)f the Bill was agreed to and 'it<br />
was read a first time. When Mr. Speaker asked the<br />
Minister to assign a day for the second reading the<br />
Minister replied "Monday next," whereat there was<br />
laughter, because there is no likelihood of the House<br />
sitting on. "hat day.<br />
DR. MALAN'S ASIATtd BILt<br />
THE death knell of the Indians in South Africa<br />
II has been sounded by Dr. Malan. Geneml<br />
Smuts attempted to sound tIle death 'knell<br />
early in the year 1924, by introducing the Class<br />
Areas Bill, and as a huge ttee is felled by a wood.:..<br />
man with th~ aid of his axe, so was the So~th<br />
.African Party Government shattered to pieces by<br />
Providence whilst the debate on the Bill was in<br />
pto~ress. We would not venture to suggest that<br />
the Nati6nalis~ Goverhment would meet its Waterloo<br />
II it attempts to introduce the Asiatic Bill. Nor<br />
will we prophesy such a calamity. We leave that<br />
to I'rovidence. And we h'tve no doubt that Providence<br />
will not anow the European community of<br />
South Africa to crush a law-abiding and peaceloving<br />
community as are the Indi9.ns. The pity<br />
of it is that the BIll lIhould be fathered by a<br />
Minister who in private life is a Minister of teligion-and<br />
a 'Christian religion at that.<br />
We have not the Blll in extenso before US f and<br />
we are therefore not in a pdsition 'to pass an opinion<br />
8U ths proposed Bill. But judging from the speech<br />
given by the 'Minister ill 'introducing the Bill, and<br />
the lirief resume given in our local contemporaries,<br />
we can only characterise the Bill, as the deadliest<br />
of all wellpons aimed at the Indian (l()mmunity.<br />
Tht'l 'Bill is 'the deadliest in na.ture in this respect<br />
tlrat its intention is to exterminate the Indians<br />
in South Africa. it is a Bill such as would only be<br />
attempted by a Government that is devoid of any<br />
sense of justice and laitplay. Every clause o'f the<br />
Bill, 80 £ar as We ha:ve been able to read, is deadly<br />
in character, and if the Bill ever goes through, we<br />
are doubtful whether it will ever go through, we<br />
a.re an-aid, it would have fat 'teaching effect on<br />
~he Indian community "of Sou'th Africa.<br />
The Europeans desire is, that the Indians<br />
should rise to their standard of living before a<br />
demand is made for equal rights. Although to<br />
bur mihd there is no necessity for the Indians to<br />
rise to t'hat st'f1ndard, but we cannot see how that<br />
desire could be fulfilled H Dr. Malan's Bill is to<br />
become law. The Indians form a~ integral part<br />
of the somewhat mixed· communities of South<br />
Mricli, t:tnd unless -equal opportunities are offered<br />
t'O th,e'm, helw they could rise to the European<br />
standard, we certainly cannot understand. Is it<br />
the intention of the Europeans that the Indians<br />
should be crushed to death? Have not the Indian~<br />
aB much right on the globe as do the Europeans?<br />
wm. 'the British Govetnment sit tight and say<br />
nothing against tl.le grave injustice that is being<br />
meted to the Indias ?<br />
The Indians in South Africa have a very datk<br />
£utul'e before them; and it behoves the South African<br />
Indian Congress to leave no stone untm'ned<br />
in resisting the onslaughts that are heing directed<br />
against the Indians. tn thpir endea .ours we<br />
have every hope they will receive every help from<br />
the S .v-arajists in India. The fight will essentially<br />
be a life and death struggle, aM the Indians may<br />
rest assured that Providence will always be with<br />
them.<br />
We do not doubt the sincerity of the Dutch in<br />
meting out justice to their subjects, and our wish<br />
is that the Government will think ere it takes tl-.;:tl<br />
the wrong turning.<br />
INDiAN YOUTHS FOR THE ARMY<br />
SWARAJ LEADER JOINS SA.NDllURST COM!.UTTEE<br />
Simla, july 22 (Reuter).-Motilal :Nehru, leMer<br />
of the Swaraj Party, has accepted membership of<br />
the Indian Sandhurst Committee which, under the<br />
chairmanship of Lieut.-General Sir Andrew Skeen,<br />
has been appointed to inquire into m.ean£! of attracting<br />
qualified Indian youths to the army and giving<br />
thed.. a military education.<br />
This is news of considerable political intel'es~. as<br />
it is the first time that tI. member of the Swaraj<br />
Party has accepted a seat on a Govetnment Committee.<br />
A Bub-committee of the Sandhurst Oommittee<br />
will visit England in the autumn to study the<br />
tlonditions of training at Sandhutst and Woolwich,<br />
and it will also probably procee4 to Kingston in<br />
Canada.<br />
INDIANS AND '1'HE ARMY<br />
SW ARAJ LEADER'S EXPLANATION<br />
Allahabad, July 28 (Reuter)........ In II statement con·<br />
cerning his acceptance of membership of the Indian<br />
Sandhurst Committee to inqUire into the means ot<br />
attracting qualified Indian youths to the Army<br />
and giving them a Military Education, Motllal Nehru<br />
(leader of the Swaraj Party) cites the rnle (If the<br />
Swaraj Party, which now enables members to Serve<br />
on any particular committee which is approveil<br />
by the Party. The terms of reference of the committee<br />
in no way limit his desite to put the (lase on<br />
'behalf of his l>eopl(l without hindrance. •<br />
·"To my mind," he says, "the ad'dition of one Indian<br />
me'mbet to the nnmber of those capable of participating<br />
in the defence of the Mantry is Worth more<br />
than the appointment of ten Indian Governors of<br />
Province."<br />
LONG LIVE DESHBANDHU<br />
{B"f :M:AltA.TM.l GAlrDHI)<br />
Calcutta demonstrated yesterday t.he hold Deshbandhu<br />
had on Bengal, nay, India. Calcutta is like Bombay,<br />
Cosmopolitan. n has people from all the prOVmce8.<br />
And all these peOple were as hearty part.icipators iu the<br />
procession as the Bengalis. The wires that are ponring<br />
in from every part of India emphasise the fact of his<br />
all-India popularity.<br />
lb could iIot Well be otherwise among a people know<br />
for t.heir grabefulness. And he deserved i~ all. His<br />
sactifice was great. His generosity had no bounds. His<br />
loving hand was opened out. to aU. He was teCklesq ill<br />
his charities. And (mly the other day when I ~ntI1<br />
remarked that he might have been discriminate, prompt<br />
came the reply, «I do not think t have lost b, my<br />
IiIdiscriminations." His board was free to the prince aod<br />
t.he pauper. His heart went ont to ever160e in distress.<br />
Where is the young ttlen in all Bengal who does not Ol\'e<br />
a debt of gratitude to Deshbandhn fn some shaPe or<br />
dther? His unrivalled ~al talents were also at the
Juiy 3 1St, 1925<br />
iNDIAN OPiNION<br />
disposal of the PLor. I uDdcntand. that h~ defended<br />
,maDY, if noli all, political prisonocil without charging<br />
them a pie. fIe went to the Punjab for the Punjab (11-<br />
qairy and paid hi. owa expensc&. Ue carried a princely<br />
household tl1 those daYII. [tla1 it from bim tha~ he<br />
spent durmg that stay in Punjab fu. 1)0,000. This large<br />
heart.ednesa towaldnesl all who BOught. hil belp' made<br />
him the undilputed raler of thonsandd of young hearta.<br />
lIe wag III! fcarlt'SQ as he was generons. His stormy<br />
speecbf'1l at Amtit~ar took my breath away. lIe wanted<br />
immediate deliverance for his country. He would not<br />
bro)l>. the alteration or removal of an adJcctive-not<br />
bc(/Jose he waf! nnreasonable but because he loved hill<br />
country 80 well, only too well. lie gave his Me for it.<br />
He Controlled enormous forces 'fIe brought pOwer to<br />
bis party by his indomitable zeal and perserverance. But<br />
tblll tremendous outpouring of energy cost hIm hIS hfe.<br />
It was wJlling 81Critice. It W88 noble. '<br />
Faridpur was bis crowning triumph. That utterance<br />
of his is a demonstration of his 8upreme reasonableness<br />
and statesmanship. It was a deliberate, unequivocal and<br />
for him (a q he sliid to me) final IIcceptanoe of noa-violence<br />
as tbe oaly policy and therefore polItical creed for India.<br />
In constructing' together With Pundit MotHal Nehru<br />
and the discipfined stalwarts from M"abarashtra the grea\<br />
and gi'owing Swaraj Party out of nothing, he showed his<br />
determination, originality, resourcefnlileSll and contempt<br />
of consequences after he had OilOf' made tip hi. mind<br />
that the thing to be done was right. And to-dRY the<br />
Swaraj Party IS a compact well· disciplined organisation.<br />
My dlfferen~es about the Council-entry were and are<br />
fundamental, but I never donbt.ed the uSI'fulneS8 of<br />
Connoil-entry for the purpose of embarrassment and<br />
continuou.ly putl.ing the Government in. the wrong. No<br />
one can deny the greatness of the work done by the<br />
Party in the Councils. And the credit for it must predominantly<br />
belong to Deshbandhu. I ent.ered into the<br />
pact with him with my eyel open. I have since done<br />
my !tttle best to help the Party. His, death renders it;<br />
doubly my duty to stand by the Party now that the '<br />
leader is gone. I shall do nothing to impede its pr.ogresS'<br />
where I may not he able t} help.<br />
But I must hark back to the Faridpur Ilpeech. The'<br />
natiOlil will appreciate the courtesy of the actmg Vioeroy<br />
in sending a message of condolence to 8hrimBti Besauti<br />
Devi Das. 1 note with gratefulness the warm tribute!!<br />
paid by the Anglo-Indian press, tQ the memory of the<br />
deoeased. The Faridpur speech seems to 'have impressed<br />
most Englishmen wiLh its transparent sincerity. I am<br />
anxious t.hat thlls death should not end with a mere display<br />
of courtesy. The Faridpur speeoh had II ~reat purpose<br />
behind it. It was a generous response to the Anglo""<br />
Indiau friend Ii who were anxious for the great patriot to<br />
make his position clear and mllke the first approach.<br />
He made it.. The cruel hand of death has removed the<br />
author of the gesture from our midst. But 1 would lIke<br />
to assure Enrrlishmen who may be still doubtful about<br />
the sincerity" of Deshbandhu'. motive that throughout<br />
my stay in Darjeeiing, the one t.hing that struck me<br />
most forcibly .was his utter I\in~~rity about that utterance.<br />
Can this glorIOUS death be utilised to heal wounds and<br />
forget distrust i I make II simple suggestion. . Will ~he<br />
Government, in honour of the memory of ChlttaranJan<br />
Das, who is no longer with us to plead the ca~lle, release<br />
the politioal prisoners wbo he protested were mncocent ?<br />
I !.lIn now asking for their discharge on' the ground of<br />
innocence. The Government may have the beRt proof<br />
01 their guilt. I simply ask for their discharge as a<br />
tribute to the deceased and without. prejudice. If the<br />
Government mean to do anything to plaoate Indian<br />
"inion there can be no more opportune tIme and no<br />
t~ter i~augul"llti()n of a favourable atmOilphere thaI! the<br />
release of these prisoners. 1 ~ave travelled practlca!ly<br />
all liver Bengal. Pnblic feelmg, not. all necessanly<br />
Swarajist is sore on the point. May the fire that burnt<br />
yesterday'the pe~ishabie· pa~t. of beshbandhn also burn<br />
the periEhable dIstrust, Sllsplclon and fear. The Gowrnment<br />
may then call A cOIlferenoe if the, will, to cOIlSlder I<br />
.'<br />
"'~-"".1!"",~'J<br />
the best mean I of meeting Ib
INDIAN OPINION July 31st, 1925<br />
A... CHRISTMAS DAY LETTER<br />
the more vividly impreBBiV'e. We can picture that<br />
club, in which this young idealist is the only manual<br />
A letter, Written on Christmas Day last year, has labouring member; and we can understand what it<br />
been sent ,from A1,Jl.el'ica. It appears to have great must I{lean, when even the professors think in terms<br />
interest for those, who are at the present time eagerly of dollars. Yet we must not judge too harshly. The<br />
looking out on the world' future and wondering great. New World of AmeriCd has heen developed at<br />
what part India herself has got to play. -It comes a marvellous speed, bnt at a tremendous cost.<br />
from a manual labourer in the Far West who tells in It is the time of youthful energy, when the physical<br />
side is certain to be uppermost. The time for re<br />
it his own life story. The letter runs as follows:-<br />
"Somehow, or for some reason, on this Christmas flection will follow in due course; and then India<br />
Day, my mind keeps turning to India. How much will be truly appreciated, not by one or two, but by<br />
I would love to be near enough to commune with multitudes. More and morl:", as the generous JPasB,<br />
the wise men of the East, who seem to have the the people of the West will come to IndIa, not,1 in<br />
hold of the Eternal!<br />
the spirit of 'dominating benevolence', but in the<br />
"You will pardon me for giving a little sketch of spirit of humility. They will come for that spiritual<br />
healing and peace, which the West in its rush'!<br />
my life. I was born 38 years ago of very poor<br />
parents, and being th,e oldest of a family of nine for material power can never give. It is neooSBary'<br />
children, 't was compelled to go tQ work in ~ large that India on her side, without any delay should<br />
manufacturing plant, when I was about twelve years obtain Swaraj, so that she may welcome them with<br />
old. I was engaged there until I was sixteen years her own welcome when they come, and not through<br />
old, when I was apprenticed to learn the cabinet the obscuring medium of an alien administrntion.<br />
making trade, which I have been working at ever It is also necessary that she should remove from her<br />
since. Although I never had but four YI:",8,rs of own life the evil nightmare of untouchability.<br />
schooling, I have been a great reader: History,<br />
Philosopy, Science anq Religion have been the subjects<br />
I have been most interested in, but especially,<br />
,I. MR. JUSTICE RANADE ON THE HINDU<br />
Religion and Philosophy. Some ten years ago, I<br />
MUSLIM PROBLEl\I<br />
started to read of that country, which I so often Persons who have observed the fate of similar<br />
heard referred to, as 'heathen' India by so many movements in Europe and in India during the last<br />
Christians. I do not know very much about 'the one hundred years, will be extremely apprehensive<br />
ancient literature of India, but I do know this, that of the consequences of the Pan-Hindu movement<br />
India had a wonderful literature long before Christ which is shaping itself in Northern India. The<br />
was born. I do not say this to depreciate Christianity,<br />
but because I have found out that there are bolised by the "Concert of Europe," has proved a<br />
oldest of such movement, the Pan-European, sym·<br />
other religions beside onrs, and also that God may miserable fiasco. The next in years, the pan-Ger.<br />
be found in more than one way. But this is apart man movement, has collapsed irretrievably shaking<br />
from 'what I want most to say, providing that I can civilisation to its foundations. The Pan-Islamic<br />
find words to express it. I have reaa and re-read movement to-day has no votaries except a handful<br />
'Creative Unity' by Rabindranath Tagore and lave of men in India in whose hands it has lost whatever<br />
read all the literature I could get hold of about of constructive potentialities it possessed. Turkey<br />
Mahatma Gandhi. I have just finished a series of , has repudiated it along with the Khilafat. Egypt_<br />
articles of Romain Rolland, on Mahatma Gandhi~ wlllhavanone of it. Persia has never shown any<br />
who I think interprets-him better than any Western concern in it. Arabia presents the spectacle of two<br />
writer that I know of. Rolland himself I believe, oposing Islamic sects fighting for the possession of<br />
inclines to the same beliefs as MI'. Gandhi,-I mean the sacred city, Mecca. Afghanistan, where it is<br />
in regard to war and international affairs.<br />
still an article of faith that the stoning of heretics to<br />
"The more I read of the things mentioned above, death is an act of homage to the Almighty, remains<br />
the more convinced am I that we are sadly lacking the sole prop of the Indian survivors from the Panin<br />
something to make our life here in the West more Islamic debacle. Persons with a very slight power<br />
complete. We have done wonders in science and of observation can see that all movements which had<br />
industry, but I am afraid that this wonderful a particularist basis in the shape either of special<br />
material progress has been purchased at a very economic, political or communal interests, have<br />
great cost.<br />
come hopelessly to grief. That it should be sought<br />
"To one in my position in life, it seems' that from at this late hour to start a movement of this exploded<br />
top to bottom we are only able to think in terms of type among the Hindus of all people, is a matter for<br />
things. I listened to a professor in a club I belong regret for all thoughtful students of Indian history.<br />
to. It was made up entirely of professional and We say "the Hindus of all people" because the<br />
bUSiness men,-I being the only manual worker in Hindu socio-religious system is fnndamentally<br />
it. They declared, that all our thinking had to be differentiated from all other systems by its lack of<br />
done in terms of the dollar. Wealth and power are a creed or dogma to serve as a rallying point for all<br />
the ever recurring phrases which they use. All Hindus in antagonism to any other system. Only a<br />
thonght of humanity is lost in the insane race for grave crisis imperilling their common right to<br />
wealth and power. Very few of our Western follow their own mode oLworship or the sanctity of<br />
writers are trying to bring to us the great world of family life, can force all Hindus into a Pan-Hindu,<br />
contemplation_and silence, where we may the still fold and even then they will not remain there a<br />
small voice of God speaking to our souls.<br />
moment longer than is absolutely needed to avert<br />
".blst now we are having a great deal of literature the danger. The only parallel to the Hindn System '<br />
on the;snpremact of the White Race; and one of in this respect is the British Commonwealth. To<br />
the phrases used quite often is "Benevolent Domination<br />
of the World." I think we have had enough is as impossible as to recast the British Common<br />
weld all Hindus into an imitation of Pan·lslamism<br />
-of any kind of 'Domination of World.' When the wealth on the pattern of the old Roman Empire.<br />
White Race cannot subdue its own passions,-as has In formulating his great scheme for a League ot<br />
been shown only too tragically by the awful European<br />
War,-how can it be dom~nant~y benevolent to as well as a great statesman, laid his finier on the<br />
Nations, President Woodrow Wilson who was a see/.<br />
others? Such a patronising dominance of the West true cause of the failure of the movem.ents named<br />
is detestable to me, and my whole heart cries out above.<br />
against it." -.<br />
"Yon know," he told the citizens of Manchester,<br />
Such is the letter. When the life history of such (England), "that heretofore the world has boon<br />
a: 'Wdter is known to us,_ it makes the 19t.1er itself all I governed, or at any 1,'ate an attempt bas been made.
_J__<br />
uJy~,~3_{S_t'_1~9_2S~ _________ I_N_D_I_A_N-.O_P_I_N_I_O_N __________________ ~19~3~<br />
to b'Overn it, by partnerships of interest, and they<br />
!lave broken down. Interest rhes not bmd men "'!I,/her,<br />
~ it .eparates men. For the moment there is the slight<br />
('st departure from the nice f>
~.I~94~~ ________________ I_N_D_I_A_N-.O_P_I_N_I_O_N __________ ~JU~]Y __ 3~~_,_I9_25_<br />
Things which are not held together organically by<br />
It cammon life eannot 'have a lasting connection.<br />
Th~fefare the British Empire is bound to disintegrate,<br />
eVE'n if it he called a commonwealth.<br />
1loreove~, the days of the dmosaur, the megalosa-urus<br />
1\.~d .other h\lge animalSoare gone. Man IS a<br />
mtlch smaHa],' creatut:(", no d01lht; hut hE' is finer and<br />
-af a bighef type, SimilaTly the ,daYfl of huge and<br />
uBwteldy empires are also numbered. StandardIsed<br />
a.nd u)liIQrm life is no hfe. The days -of small ,<br />
.stat~s with theil' dIstinct achievements, cultures and<br />
outlo,oks are in sight. They may and ought to be<br />
friendly to and co-operate with one anothpr, but of<br />
free cho~ce aJ)d independently. ,<br />
Of course, in being a part of the British ,Empire<br />
:we have' some advantages. For insL'lnce, in the<br />
.matter of defence and protection, India has n
1 ttdiatt fj pin illtt<br />
No. 32-Vol. XXIII. Friday, August 7th. 1925.<br />
Repstereclat the G. P.O ••• a Nowspaper<br />
1'11108 l'OU"'''MC..<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
--i 4"~<br />
"'frlH~l "Areas Reservation and Immigration and There is no better or more effective way in which EllJ."Oo<br />
II Registration (}
INn, l\ N OPINION August 7th, i 5<br />
some means of teconcilJatlOn between South Africa and<br />
India. There IS'tlO mom lleDsltive pomt of bonour ~t<br />
which lnd\a could \>e attacked than ~hat of raCial dlSCflminatiQIl<br />
\>Y llama in a Parhamen~ary statute. H Will<br />
be remembered that General Smuts urged m a remarkable<br />
speech a short time ago that at least the injured<br />
feelings of the IndIans should be soothed, and a formula<br />
should be found whereby the w Jrd "AsIatic" might be<br />
omitood. The S/llU'ch for such a formula bas eVidently<br />
failed. NoLhmg IS left to mldgate the blow, which has<br />
fallen for, It has been studIed and deliberate." But It<br />
seems'the presen-t rulers of South Afnca have dehberatel.y<br />
jettIsoned all sense of honour, JustICe, oblJgatlOn and falL'<br />
play and chosen the path of war with a DatlOu I () wl '<br />
olll<br />
m no ~mall a me&sure they owe their Pl'! ','nt high POSItIOn<br />
and prospElrity. It wa~ Asiatic l~bour, and IndJ.all<br />
labour In parttcuJar that helped to thrive their mdus~rles<br />
and it waS Illdia)l blQo~ PQured Unselfishly that WOII for<br />
the Britu!Q. an emplre and crushed for ever the Krq,gerlan<br />
Republic. But in il. sad $tory of raCial ar~o~anc(>, If<br />
India cannot expect much from the dommatmg Boers,<br />
sb,e could legi~lmat£ly expect muoh from the Bvitish for<br />
whom, jlS we, I:u~ve PIJ.U,J,ted out above, the Indians by their<br />
valour and blood won an empire.<br />
Indeed, throughout<br />
iUi!! sLrugg\e, we ~re firmly 9o]:lvinped, the BrItish ~ov.<br />
erD,me~~ J:iave t\tken up a qlghly pussilammous positIOn,<br />
They \l\1ve pelleq where they ouli to have commanded<br />
ap,d as for the llldl~!l ~overnl)1ent, wItb the brIght exc~ptioJil<br />
of ~he G-overnment of Lord Hardiuge, well to put<br />
It pJllinly ~t has ~mply played au abJectly subordmate<br />
par~. The SOllth AfrICan Government has &imply<br />
igJloreq t\l.e In~ial,l q-qvernment, and the latter had<br />
never ~ chance Ilf appearmg iu the pictute. If the British<br />
GoverQm(\J;l~ 4ad not forsaken lodm and left It to<br />
the ~eijder 'Pllrcieij of the evlolIr-proud and colour-blind<br />
BOElrs \l.nq if the Illdlan q-pvllrUILent had Dot been teo<br />
weak. kneed In the wNr~s of General Smuts there would<br />
nQ.~ Jititve peen £;reated a sltuatlQIl when th~re was "tha<br />
da,nger to a young na~lOn hke South Arnca of openly<br />
msultm,g the gre\lt and alICIent CIvilisatlQn of the Eait<br />
mev~tably cQmmg true." But thlS madness of Hisultmg<br />
the East IS not confined arp.pngst the Routh AfrlCatls.<br />
The present situa~lOn I!l South Afl'lC~j as ppmted out by<br />
Mr. Andrews, is no~ lIkely the studied m~ult whICh was<br />
offered by America to Japan a year ago when, m spite of<br />
the liIlost senous and empbat,lc warmngs, Japan was discrI.Ijl~uatjld<br />
agamst raclally ill the Amencan Immigration<br />
RestrictlOn Bill. Japan, of courae, not Without protest,<br />
pocteted tb.e insult, hlilt Ja[lan has a long memory and<br />
ihll wIll not forget the msult III a hlIrry. AmerICa thus<br />
m!lde, ,vlrta&lily by a stroke of the pen, a permanent<br />
en~my of Japan, as South Africa by coustant and longcop,tm_ued<br />
pUl-prioks ha~ made an equally pe manent<br />
enemy Qf India. Thus tw@ great ASiatic natlOns have<br />
b~ dehherately est:.vanged by two differently sItuated<br />
POWe,:il for no ot-h&' great fault of the A-siati1Js th,ln that<br />
of ,p,ossesiilAg a'llark or 8, yeU@,w &
August 7th, 1925<br />
INDIAN oriN ION<br />
'mOl'lI.l authority in India except with that seotion of<br />
lhillandlords and eapitalisti whose unjust privileges,<br />
" with no intention of pel·s. are made more 8Il0ure by<br />
her rule. It iii COUlmOn talk in India that the word<br />
of man)l of hel' present offic18ls is not hke the word<br />
of those who 'Werll there in earli)r dayll.<br />
It is time fol" England to realiile that thlll loss of<br />
mOJ'll.l prestige added to the increasing capacity for<br />
sabotage on the part of India meanil not slInply the<br />
dea.th of the Reform .. but the impossiWhty of the<br />
continuanoo of her control. Her Ilituation ill hke<br />
tl4t n( a man who had the bear by the tail and<br />
could naithel' hold on nor afford to let go. Unl688<br />
England wi\ll'lOou decide the time and manner of<br />
her leaving India, another Ireland is likely to<br />
develop in Bengal; and after Bengal there is the<br />
Punjab, with its mOl'O m~ti~l race, and that will be<br />
anoUler stofY.<br />
: ' i -r---- 4-...-<br />
lNDIA AND SHAKESPEARE<br />
"Shakespeare iii 9xtremely popular among Indians,<br />
although few poo~le think that his popularity iii 80<br />
great," writes Mr. R. J. MInney in the pages of thee<br />
Em/ur, l~teUi. Mr. Minney asserts that the Indian,<br />
abl .. to read and write English, is an al'lent admirer<br />
of 8hak\lilpeare just in the same way as the greatest<br />
Shakespaarean iIOholal' in England. He says the Indian<br />
ia peouharly qualified to admire Shakespeare.<br />
"The Indian mentality has a CurIOUS oraving for<br />
poeU'y. The magia of Shakespem-e's imagery that<br />
changed every garden and would into a wonderland<br />
of colour aud futries, StU8 the Indian in a strange<br />
war so that his Shakeilpeare is a book that is a!I<br />
inseparable from his bedside alJ the pions Christian<br />
Bihle. The Indian ilpendlJ little time oVt'r his own<br />
scriptures. If he is learned at all he is learned in<br />
English, and ELlglish. to him means little more than<br />
Shakespeare. That the Englishmen around him in<br />
the laEgell towns of Inllia do not set their wOl'ds<br />
after the order to be foun
part of the toWD.\ here or to hold freehold property, or<br />
admitance to the stalls of a theatre. All they get are<br />
the husks not the sunshine of hfe. To try and prove<br />
their just claIm would be called a felony.<br />
And· yet, Americans, French, German, Itahanll &c are<br />
allowed these emoluments whilst the Bnttsh Indian is<br />
barred his jnst rights. In fact, they take from him even<br />
that which he hath.<br />
There is a common saving that "The Sun never Bets<br />
on British Domains." I am not so sure that this wIll<br />
always read so. History has a way of repeatmg itself in<br />
its own good tIme.<br />
To those of your readers who lack ambition, I eay<br />
strwe for it, get it and then strive again and keep on<br />
strivin-g, alw,ays for something better, higher, and step<br />
by step you ,.,111 be strengthened and energised for your<br />
needs. You will cast a~ide the life of lethargy' and<br />
lotus eating indifference, and become a power m the<br />
world to be reckoned with, not mere puppets dancing to~<br />
a tune you do not know, do not lIke and do not want.<br />
Stretch out JOUf bands higher, and grasp firmly your<br />
star of life, and in due course WIll follow, all you have<br />
stretched, striven and grasped for.<br />
AMBER MAYO.<br />
.<br />
S'ENVOY.<br />
"Awake! you sonlless irreligious wejltern world.<br />
See fate of India knocking at thy gate.<br />
Lest, like the foolish VIfl!'ins, lamps unlit<br />
Destruction waits you. Wake, ere it be too late.<br />
AMBER MAYO.<br />
30-7-25. Johannesburg.<br />
i~~EE~~:(~~~;::~~~~;>~~~<br />
~ [ FROM OUR OWN CORRESPONDENT ] ~<br />
\lI 9th July, 1925. \If<br />
oE
Supplement to " Indian Opinion."<br />
7th Augusf,192S.<br />
UNION OF SOUTH AFRICA.<br />
Areas Reservation and Immigraton and Registration<br />
(Further Provision) Bill.<br />
(To be read a Second Time on Monday, 27th July, 1925.)<br />
BILL<br />
TO<br />
Make ProvisioIfs for the reservation of residential<br />
and trading areas in urban areas for certain<br />
persons having racial characteristics in common;<br />
to amend the Immigr!lnts Regulation Act, 1913<br />
(No. 22 of 19J.3) , the Indians Relief Act, 1914<br />
(No. 22 of 1914), and the Asiatic Registration<br />
Amendment Act (Transvaal) 1908 (No. 36 of<br />
1908); and to amend or repeal certain laws.<br />
(Introduced by the MINISTER OF THE INTERIOR.)<br />
UNIE VAN ZUID-AFRIKA.<br />
Terzijdezetting van wijken en verdere voorziening voor<br />
Immlgratle en registratle Wetsontwerp.<br />
(Ten Tweede Maal te worden gelezen op Maandag, 27 Julie,<br />
1925.)<br />
WETSON'TWERP<br />
OM<br />
Voorziening te maken voor deterzijdezetting van<br />
woon- en bezigheidswijken in stadsgebieden<br />
voor zekere personen, die gemeenschappelike<br />
raseigenschappen hebben; om de wet tot regeling<br />
van Immigraile, 1913 (No. 22 van 1913), de<br />
Indiers Verlichting Wet, 1914 (No. 22 van 1914),<br />
en de Aziaten Registratie Wijzigings Wet<br />
(Transvaal) 1908 (No. 36 van 1908) te wijzigen;<br />
en om zekere wetten te wijzigen of te herroepen<br />
(Introduced door de MINISTER VAN BINNEXLANDSE<br />
ZAKEN.)
3<br />
(To be read a Second Time on Monday, 27th -July, 1925.)<br />
BILL<br />
To make provision for the reservation of residential and<br />
trading -areas In urban areas for certain persons<br />
having racial characteristics in common; to amend<br />
the Immigrants Regulation Act, 1913 (No. 22 of<br />
1913), the Indians Relief Act, 1914 (No. 22 of<br />
1914), and the Asiatic Registration Amendment<br />
Act (Transvaal) 1908 (No. 36 of 1908); and to<br />
amend or repeal certain laws.<br />
(Introduced by the MINISTER OF THE INTERIOR.)<br />
BE IT ENACTED by the King's Most Excellent Majesty,<br />
the Senate and the.House of Assembly of the Union of<br />
South Africa, as follows:-<br />
5<br />
OHAPTER 1.<br />
RESERVATION OF AREAS.<br />
1. (1) Whenever an urban local authority shall intimate Reqlle.t by U1bao<br />
to the Minister-<br />
~~~ala::<strong>I~~~</strong>[:~~<br />
rf Chapter I<br />
(a) that any area within its limits is wholly or for the<br />
greater part occupied for residential or trading pur-<br />
10 poses or both such purposes by a particular class<br />
of persons;<br />
(b) That it is desirable that the provisions of this<br />
Chapter should be applied in respect of such area,<br />
the Minister may appoint a commission consisting of not<br />
] 5 more than three persons (hereinafter called the Commis·<br />
sion) to investigate and report upon the desirability of<br />
applying lo such area and to the urban area within which<br />
it is situated the provisions of this Chapter. .<br />
(2) One of the members of the commission shall be desi~.<br />
20 nated by the Minister as the chairman thereof, and th~<br />
Minister may make rules for the conduct of the business of<br />
the commission and governing the tenure of office of the<br />
members. In the event of the commission consisting of<br />
three members, two members shall form a quorum.<br />
25 2. (1) It shall be the duty of the commission to enquire ~;~r:D:r<br />
and report to the Minister upon the following matters:- commiSSIon<br />
(a) The extent and nature of the area which was the<br />
subject of intimation under section one;<br />
(b) the number, dimensions, situation and nature of sibs<br />
30 occupied in such area for residential or trading pu"-<br />
poses or both such purposes as the case may be;<br />
(c) whether there would be afforded by such are a proper<br />
and adequate facilities for residences or trading si~s<br />
or both as the case may be for the particular class<br />
35 of persons concerned;<br />
(d) whether due and proper provision exists or is a&9ured<br />
for water, lighting, sanitary and other necessary<br />
services within such area;<br />
(e) whether it is desirable that the provisions of this<br />
40 Chapter should be applied in respect of such area;<br />
(f) whether there is, within the limits of the urban local<br />
authority concerned, any other area which is wholly<br />
or for the greater part occupied for residentIal or<br />
trading purposes or both such purposes by the par-<br />
45 ticular class of persons concerned, and if there be<br />
lIuch other area, the extent and nature thereof, and<br />
the number, dimensions, situation and nature of sites<br />
occupIed in such other area for residential or trading<br />
purposes or for both: such purposes as the case may<br />
• 50 be j
ProclamatIOn<br />
t~n of cia ••<br />
a.reas<br />
AcqUISItIon of<br />
Immovable<br />
property lD<br />
class areas<br />
(g) whether any other area within the limits of the<br />
urban .local authority concerned is available for the<br />
exclusIve occupation for residential or tradin ... purposes<br />
or both such purposes by. the particula; class<br />
of persons concerned; and 5<br />
(h) any other matter which the Minister or the commission<br />
may deem necessary or deSIrable .<br />
. (2) The ~ommission shall have all such powers, jurisdictIOn<br />
and pnvileges as were conferred upon the commissIon<br />
referred to in Ordinance No. 30 of 1902 of the Transvaal, 10<br />
and all and several the provisions of that Ordinance shall<br />
mututis mutandis awly in respect of the commission and<br />
its proceedings.<br />
:f. (1) At any time within six months after the receipt<br />
of the report of the commIssion, the Governor-General may 15<br />
by proclamation in the Gazette declare that, on and after a<br />
date to be mentioned in the proclamation, the area defined<br />
in the proclamation shall be a class residential area, or a<br />
class trading area or a class residential and trading area<br />
within the urban area.<br />
(2) More than one area within the urban area may, by 20<br />
any such proclamation, be definedJls class residential areas,<br />
or as class trading areas, or as class residential and trading<br />
areas as the case may be.<br />
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in the PreCIOUS<br />
and Base Mmerals Act of the Transvaal (Act No. 35 of 25<br />
1908) or any amendment thereof, or In any other law, a<br />
class trading area or a class residential and trading area<br />
may be established under this Chapter on land within an<br />
urban area which, in terms of the said Act No. 35 of 1908<br />
or any amendment thereof, is proclaimed land or land held 30<br />
under mining htle.<br />
4. F!l'9m and after the date mentioned in any proclamation<br />
issued under this Chapter establishing a class residential<br />
area or a class trading area, or a class residential and<br />
trading area, it shall not be lawful, save as provided in 35<br />
section ten-<br />
(a), for any person other than a pers.on of the class CQncerned<br />
toO acquire immovable property or a, lease or<br />
renewal of lease of immoOvable proOperty within any<br />
such area; or 40<br />
(b) foOr any person of the class concerned to acquire immovable<br />
property oOr a lease or renewal of lease oOf<br />
immovable property anywhere within the urban area<br />
save within the limits of the class residential area or<br />
of the class tradmg area or oOf the class residential 45<br />
and trading area, as the case may be :<br />
ProOvided that nothing in this Chapter contained shall apply<br />
to the renewal of a lease of immovable property where the<br />
right to renewal was hera under a written lease existing<br />
at the OOItlmencement of this Act. 50<br />
yadl~g ~n 5. (1) From and after the date mentioned in any procla-.<br />
::.,~. :r a ~~:.s mation issued under this Chapter establishing a class tradt:!~~~tl::e:nd<br />
ing area oOr a class :residential and trading area within any<br />
urban area, it shall not be lawful for any licensing court,<br />
b9ard or authority, or foOr any person authorized to gra~t 55<br />
or issue licences or permits to carry .on any trade .or busIneBS<br />
within that urban area-<br />
(a) to grant or i€8Ue to any person oOther than a person<br />
of the class concerned any licence, permit .or .other<br />
authorlty to carryon any trade or business within 60<br />
the class trading area .or class residential and trading<br />
area as the case may be; or<br />
(b) to gTant or issue to any person of the cIass cQncerned<br />
any licence or permit to carry on any trade or business<br />
within the urban area elsewhere than in the 65<br />
class tradmg area or class residential and trading<br />
area as the cae may be:<br />
Provided however that if the Governor-General is satisfied<br />
that it is in iilie ge~eral interests of the public that it should<br />
be permitted to persons of the class concerned or any re- 70
5<br />
/<br />
stncted number of such persons to carry on any particular<br />
trade or business within the urban area elsewhere than in<br />
the class trading area or class residential and trading area,<br />
as the case may be, he may, by proclamation in the Gazette<br />
5 for such period as- he may therein fix, exempt persons of<br />
the class concerned or a restricted number of such persons<br />
from the operation of paragraph (b) of this sub-section in<br />
respect of that particular trade or business.<br />
(2) NothlDg in this section contained shall be deemed to<br />
lU prohibit the grant to any person holding, at the date mentioned<br />
in any proclamatIon issued under thiS Chapter establishing<br />
a class trading a,r.ea or a class reSIdential and trading<br />
area within any urban area any bcence, permit, or<br />
other authority to carry on any trade or buslDess, which is<br />
15 actually belDg earned on, or a renewal of such licence,<br />
permit or other authority.<br />
6. (1) Whenever, m the opinion of the urban local ~e~~:~~: ~;<br />
authonty concerned, any area established under this Chap- class areas<br />
ter as a class reSIdential area or a class tradlDg area or u<br />
20 class residential and trading area, proves inadequate or<br />
more than adequate for,· or unSUItable either wholly or in<br />
part to, the requirements of the population of that class in<br />
the urban area, and the urban local authority aeems it de-<br />
25 sirab1e to extend or reduce any such area or to alter the<br />
boundaries thereof, or to create a new class residential area<br />
or class trading area or class residential and trading area,<br />
the urban local authority may communicate its opinion to<br />
the Minister, who thereupon may take all s~ch ste:ps as he<br />
30 may take upon receipt of an intImation under seQilon one.<br />
(2) All and feveral the powers exercisable under thIS<br />
Chapter in respect of the establishment of a class residential<br />
area or a class tradlDg area or a class residential and<br />
trading area shall be exercisable in respect of the creation<br />
35 of a new area or the extension or reductIon of any eXIsting<br />
area of a like character or tho alteration of the boundaries<br />
thereof.<br />
(3) Nothing in this section contained shall be deemed to<br />
affect in any manner whatever any right to the renewal of<br />
40 a lease of immovable property where such right was held<br />
under a written lease existing at the commencement of thIS<br />
Act or any right to the grant to any person holding at the<br />
date mentioned in any proclamation issued in pursuance of<br />
this section any licence, pennit, or other authority to carry<br />
45 on any trade or business which is actually being earned on,<br />
of a renewal of such licence, permit or other authotity.<br />
h 7. (1)1 If at .adn y .time the Govlernor-Gd~neral is satislfied ~~~<strong>I~~~</strong>~~norf<br />
t at a c ass resl entIa l area or a c ass tra mg area or a c ass Act..<br />
residential and trading area established under this Chapter<br />
50 is inadequate for or wholly or partly unsuitable to the requirements<br />
of the population of that class in the urban area<br />
concerned, and that, by reason of the delay which would<br />
necessanly take place in removing the causes of the inadequacy<br />
or unsuitability, serious prejudice would be suffered<br />
55 by that population unless the provisions of this Chapter in<br />
respect of such inadequate or unsuitable area be suspended,<br />
he may, by proclamation in the Gazette declare that, from<br />
and after a date to be therein mentioned, the provisions of<br />
this Chapter shall be susp~nded in respect of t~e ela~s resi-<br />
60 dential area o~ class tradmg area or, class reSIdentIal and<br />
trading area concerned.<br />
(2) :From and after such tlate the provisions ot this.,._<br />
Chapter shall in all respects cease- to -apply to the- area<br />
deemed to be inadequate or unsuitable, and, in respect of<br />
65 ~uclI inadequate or unsuitable area, to the other parts of<br />
the urban area within which it is situated.<br />
(3) The Governor-Genera! mal:, whenever he maw d~em<br />
fit reproclaim as a class reSIdentIal area or a class tradmg<br />
ar~a or a «lass residential and trading ~rea, as the case ~ay<br />
i6 be, any area which has bee!! the subJec~ of a .suspendmg<br />
proclamation under sub-sectIon (1) of thIS sectIon, or pro-
6<br />
claim as a class residentIal area or a class trading area or a<br />
class residentIal and tradmg area under this Chapter any<br />
area which wholly or partly includes allY area which has<br />
been the subject of a suspending proclamation under subsection<br />
(1) of this section. 5<br />
Class area tor 8 Any class residential area or class trading area or<br />
ASlatICs to be' . .' . '<br />
deemed to be class resIdentIal and tradmg area establIshed under thIS<br />
~~~~rw£~~ 3, Chapter tor any ASIatic race shall, for the purposes of sec-<br />
18B~) (1'i ans i hon two (b) of Law No. 3 of 1885 of the Transvaal, be<br />
;::y 'ownSI~x~J deemed to be an area within which, in terma of that law, 10<br />
property fixed property may be acquIred and owned by Asiatics.<br />
Clas} adVIsory 9. (1) For every class residential area or class tradinoo<br />
board area, or ' c 1 ass reSI 'd en t' Ia I an d tra d' mg area 'bl' esta IS h e d un d er .,<br />
thIS Chapter there shall be an adVISOry board consisting of<br />
not less than thie'e persons of the class concerned resident 15<br />
WIthin the urban area, in addition to a chaIrman who in the<br />
case of a non-European class area may be a European. The<br />
mode of election or selection of members of any such board,<br />
the period and conditions of office of members, and the procedure<br />
of the board shall be defined tJy regulatIons made by 20<br />
the urban lo~al authonty and approved by the Minister.<br />
(2) It shall be the function of an advisory board established<br />
under thIS section to adVIse the urban local authority<br />
in respect of any matter referred to It by such authority for<br />
advice, and no by-laws or regulatIOns partIcularly affectmg 25<br />
the mterests of the class of persons concerned shall be<br />
made or WIthdrawn by an urban local authol'lty unless the<br />
advice of such adVISOry board shall first have been obtained<br />
m respect of the makmg or withdrawal, as the case may<br />
be, of such by-law or regulation. 30<br />
AcqUIsitIOn of 10, (1) The Governor-General may by proclamation in<br />
~~~~;::lty the Gazette declare that froll'! and after a date to be specicertam<br />
person. fred therem n'b member of any race indIcated therein shall<br />
Natal except<br />
m class areas, acqUIre Immova bIll e property or t 1e ease or renewa I<br />
0<br />
f I ease<br />
prohIbIted of Immovable piI'operty m the Provmce of Natal save in the 35<br />
coast .belt as provided in sub-sectIOn (2) of this section:<br />
Provided that nothing lD thIS sectwn contained shall be<br />
deemed to prohIbIt a renewal of a lease of immovable property<br />
held under written lease at the commencement of<br />
thIS Act. 40<br />
(2) A.IJerson who is a member of the race indicated in<br />
any proClamatIOn issued under sub-sectIon (1) of this sectIOn<br />
may acqUIre immovable property or the lease or renewal<br />
of lease of immovable property m the coast belt,<br />
from a person who is a member of the same race, but from 45<br />
no other person, except where the Immovable property or<br />
the lease or renewal of lease of the lIDmovable property<br />
acquired IS withm the hmIts of a class area establIshed<br />
under this Chapter within the coast belt.<br />
(3) From and after the date specified in any proclama- 50<br />
han Issued under sub-section (1) of this sectIon, no member<br />
of any race indicated in such proclamation shall by<br />
testamentary dispo~ition acquire any land or interest in<br />
land or the lease or occupation of any immovable P!9P€I-ty<br />
in the co~st belt, except from a member of th.e..8lime race. 55<br />
(4) For the purpose of this sf-lciion the coast belt means<br />
--SO--11r~1!:_?_Ul!&,l'].'Q.YiI!f~,9t?~atal as lies between the coast<br />
hne and a hne to be defined by the Governor-General by<br />
proclamation in the Gazette corresponding as far as ,practICable<br />
with the coast line and drawn at an apprOXImate 60<br />
dU'ltance of thIrty miles therefrom.<br />
(5) Nothing m this section contained shall be deemed to<br />
effect the operation WIthin the coast belt of any other<br />
provision of this Chapter,
5<br />
10<br />
15<br />
20<br />
25<br />
11. (1) Subject to the provisiolls of suo-section (3) of Sa Yin, ••<br />
&ection three, section eight and ~ub-bedion (3). of sectIon<br />
ten of this Chapter, nothing in this Chapwr contained<br />
&ha11 be deemed-<br />
(a)<br />
(11)<br />
(c)<br />
(d)<br />
to affed the operation of Law No.3 of 1885 of the<br />
Transvaal or any amendment thereof; of section<br />
two of Act No. 18 of 1913; of Act No. 37 of 1919; Df<br />
Cllapter CXIII of the Ol",mge Free State Law Book<br />
or any amendment thereof; or in any other law prohibitmg,<br />
restricting, regulating, or in any way.<br />
affecting, the ownership or occupation of immovable<br />
property or tradIng by persons of non-European<br />
descent; or<br />
to prohIbit the acquisItion by the Government or any<br />
urban local authorIty for educational, municipal 01'<br />
any other public purpose of the ownership or occupation<br />
of any immovable property; or<br />
to prohibit the acquisition at any time of land or<br />
interests in land or the lea~e or occupation of any<br />
immovable preperty by devolution or succession on<br />
death whether under will or on intestacy from a<br />
person of the same race; or -<br />
to prohibit any executor of a deceased eslate or any<br />
trustee in insolvency from holding any Immovable<br />
property or trading under any licence where power<br />
to do any such thing is conferred upon him by any<br />
law; or<br />
30<br />
(e)<br />
to invalidate or affect in any manner whatever any<br />
agreement or other transaction for the sale or purchase<br />
of land law~ul1y entered into prlOr to the date<br />
mentioned in any proclamation under this Chapter<br />
establishIng a class residential area or a class trading<br />
area or a class residentIal and trading area or<br />
extending or reducing any existing area of like<br />
character, or altering the boundaries thereof.<br />
12. (1) The Governor-General may grant to any person Exeml,t,oa ••<br />
a certificate exemptIng him wholly or for such penod as<br />
he may thereIn specify from all or any of the provisions ot<br />
this Chapter; and such person shall either wholly or for<br />
40 such period, as the case may he, be so exempted.<br />
45<br />
(2) NothIng in this Chapter contained shall he deemed-<br />
(a) to affect any person who is duly accredited to the<br />
UnIon by or under the authorIty of His Majesty or<br />
the Government of any foreign state, or the wife,<br />
family, staff or servants of any such person.<br />
(b) to refer to natives as that term is defined in section<br />
twenty-nine of the Native (Urban Areas) Act, 1923<br />
(Act No. 21 of 1923);<br />
(c) to refer to-<br />
50 (i) persons born in the Union and ordinarily resident<br />
in the Province of.the Cape of Good Hope<br />
who are members of the class or race known as<br />
" Cape Coloured" or of the class or race<br />
known as "Cape Malays";<br />
55 (ii) persons born in the UDlon and ordinarily resident<br />
in the Union elsewhere than in the Province<br />
of the Cape of Good Hope who would if<br />
resident in that Province, be regarded as members<br />
of either of the classes or races known as<br />
60 "Cape Coloured" or .. Cape Malays" and<br />
(iii) the people known as Mauritius Creoles or<br />
St. Helena persons OJ: their descendants born<br />
in the Union.
f:..'f!.~natlon of 13. In this Cbapter unless inconsistent with the con. text<br />
"class or class of persons" includes any person having<br />
In the oplllIOn of the MlllIster, comnion raCIal char:<br />
acteristICs, and all whIte persons shall be regarded as<br />
ha ving common raClal characterIstIcs; :)<br />
"person of a class" or "member of a race" Illcludes<br />
any oompany or association of persons whether registered<br />
under any law or not in which one 01' more<br />
persons of the class or members of the race referred<br />
to have a controllIng Illterest; 10<br />
" Minister" means the Minister of the Intenor or any<br />
other MIlllster to whom the Governor-General may<br />
assign the admillIstration of this Act;<br />
"urban area" means any area under the jurisdictIon of<br />
an urban local authonty;<br />
1')<br />
"urban local authorIty" means any municipal council,<br />
borough oounCII, town councIl or VIllage oouncil, or<br />
any town board, VIllage management board, local<br />
board or health board.<br />
OHAPTER II.<br />
2()<br />
IMMIGRANTS REGULATION.<br />
Amendment of 14 Section two of the Immigrants Regulation Act, 1913<br />
~;:lNO t~~ ~: (hereinafter III this Chapter called the PrinCIpal Act) IS<br />
1913 hereby amended by the deletIOn from sub-sectIOn (7) of the<br />
w{)rds' "sufficient m the opinion of the MInister" and the %<br />
substitution therefor of the followmg words: "fixed by the<br />
Immigration officer not exceeding one hundred pounds".<br />
15 SectIOn three of the prmcipal Act IS hereby amended<br />
(a) by the addItIOn to sub-sectIon (2) of the words:<br />
.. From any such opinion there shall be l/-n appeal to 30<br />
the Appellate DIvIsion of the Supreme Court";<br />
(b) by the deletIOn from sub-section (3) thereof of the<br />
following words:<br />
"and 'a superior court havmg JUrIsdiction' shall<br />
mean the Provincial DivISIon of the Supreme 35<br />
Court whICh has jurisdIction where the board was<br />
SittIllg or any Judge of such division or the<br />
Eastern DistrICts Local DiviSIOn having jurisdiction<br />
or any Judge thereof".<br />
Amendment of 16. SectIOn four of the principal Act is hereby amended: 40<br />
sectIOn four of<br />
Act No 22 of<br />
1913<br />
(a) by thf additIOn to paragraph (a) of sub-sectIon (1)<br />
of the following words: "ProvIded that for the<br />
purpose of thIs sectIon the N orlhern Districts of<br />
Natal, as descrIbed in sectIOn three of "The Northern<br />
DIstrICts AnnexatIOn Act, 1902" (Act No.1, 45<br />
1903, Natal) shall be deemed to be included in the<br />
Province of the Transvaal"; and<br />
(b) by the addition to paragraph (f) of sub-section (1)<br />
after the words " have been stolen" of the following<br />
words: 50<br />
"incest, sodomy, bestiality, any offence involving<br />
fraudulent conduct in connectIOn with any insolvency";<br />
and<br />
(c) by the deletion of paragraph (a) of sub-section (2).<br />
Amendment of 17. SectIOn five of the prIncipal Act as amended by sec- 55<br />
Amendment of<br />
sectIOn three<br />
of Act No 22<br />
of 1913<br />
~;:lNo.fi;~ ~~ tion three of the IndIans Rehef Act, )191d4,< is) Jtedreby<br />
1913 amended by the deletIon of paragraphs (e an g an t h e<br />
substitutIOn therefor of the followlllg new paragraphs-<br />
(e) Any person, other than an alien, who was born in any<br />
part of South Africa included III the Uni
9<br />
5<br />
10.<br />
(g)<br />
within any class of persons which~ has, in terms of<br />
paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) of section four, been<br />
deemed by the Minister to be unsuiled to the requirements<br />
of the Union or any Province thereof<br />
shall lose the protection accorded by this paragraph<br />
if he has acquired or shall acquire a domicIle in a<br />
Province of the Union other than that in which he<br />
was born;<br />
any person who is proved to the satisfaction of au<br />
immIgration officer or in the case of an appeal to the<br />
satisfaction of the board, to be the wIfe or child<br />
under the age of sixteen years of any person exempted<br />
by paragraph (f) of this section:<br />
15<br />
20<br />
25<br />
Provided:<br />
(i) that the wife or child (as the case may be) is<br />
not such a person as is described in paragraphs<br />
(d), (e), (f), (g) or (h) of sub-section (1) of<br />
sectIOn four; and<br />
(iI) that where exempted person belongs to one 1f<br />
the clasDes described in paragraph (a) of subsection<br />
(1) of section four the WIfe or child (as<br />
the case may be) enters the Union within five<br />
years after the first day of August, 1925, or<br />
WIthin ten years after the date of the first entry<br />
into the Union, whichever perIOd may be the<br />
longer, of the person so exempted.<br />
In the interpretation of this paragraph" the wife" shall<br />
iIlclude anyone woman between whom and the exempted<br />
person mentioned there exists a union recognised as a mar-<br />
30 riage under the tenets of an Indian religion notwithstanding<br />
that by those tenets the union of that exempted person<br />
with other women at the same time would also be recognised<br />
as a marriage: Provided that no woman shall be<br />
deem~d to be the wife of such exempted person-<br />
35 (i) if such a union exists between him and any other<br />
woman who has under any law relating to immigration<br />
or to Asiatic registration been recognised within<br />
the Union as the wife of such person and has resided<br />
or resides or is domiciled in any ProvlDce; or<br />
40 (ii) if such exempted person has offspring resident or<br />
domiciled in any Province by any woman who is<br />
still living;<br />
and a union shall not, for the purposes of this section, De<br />
deemed to have ceased to exist by reason only of the fact<br />
45 that aooording to the tenets of an Indian religion it has<br />
been dissolved.<br />
" Tlie child under the age of sixteen" shall mean a child<br />
who is the offspring of the exempted person and the wife as<br />
herein defined or the child of the exempted person and a<br />
50 deceased woman who if she had been alive could have been<br />
recognised at the time of the birth of the child as the wife<br />
(as herein defined) or whose union with the exempted<br />
person could have been registered at the time of the birth<br />
of the child as a marriage under section two ot the Indians<br />
55 Relief Act, 1914.<br />
18. Sect~o;n ten of the pri~cipal Act is hereby amended !.~t~~~mt':,':.t :1<br />
by the addItIon of the followmg words :-<br />
let No 22 of<br />
1913.<br />
An:y such person, may be qeclared to be a prohibited<br />
Immigrant and dealt with in terms of section nineteen<br />
60 of this Act and if such person is in possession of a<br />
Registration Certificate or a Certificate of Domicile<br />
or any other document authorising him to remain in<br />
the Union or any Province it shall be competent fOE<br />
any board to which he may appeal, if it be proved to<br />
65 the satisfaction of the board that such certificate or<br />
other document was obtained by fraudulent representations<br />
by or on behalf oi the holder, to order thlt<br />
such certificate or other document be cancelled anj
10<br />
the holder thereof be dealt with as a prohIbited ImmigTant<br />
Provided that If such person falls to appeal<br />
to a board the Prmcipal Immigration Officer concerned<br />
may exercise all such powers as to the cancellatIOn<br />
of any certificate or other document as are 5<br />
hy tlus sectIon confen-ed upon a board,<br />
.!~ti~:"i::nt~~ 19, Section twenty-two of the principal Act is hereby<br />
two of Act amended by the addition of the followmg paral!raph '-<br />
h~~~ ~ ,<br />
(d) £01' any offence under section twenty of this Act foc<br />
which imprisonment is imposed without the option 10<br />
of a fin~,<br />
Amendment sectJOo\ t'lIrty 01 20 ,ec S t' lOn th' 11' t y 0 f t h e prmClpa "l A' ct IS here b y amen d e d<br />
01 Act No 22 by the deletion of the definition of the term "domicile" and<br />
of 1913<br />
t<br />
h<br />
e su<br />
b'<br />
stitutlOn<br />
,<br />
t<br />
h<br />
erefor of the followmg definition;-<br />
" domicile" shall mean the place in which a person has 15<br />
his present permanent home, or present permanent<br />
residence or, to whIch he returns as his present permanent<br />
abode and not for. a mere special or temporary<br />
purpose; and a person shall not be deemed to have<br />
a domicile within the Union or any Province (as the 20<br />
case may be) for the purposes t>f this Act unless he<br />
has lawfully resided therein for a continuous period<br />
of three years, otherwise than under terms of conditional<br />
or temporary residence permitted by this Act<br />
or any other law or as a person under detention in 25<br />
prison, gaol, reformatory or mental hospital. and II.<br />
person shall be deemed for the purposes of this Act<br />
to have lost his domicile within the Union or anv<br />
Province (as the case may be) if he absents himself<br />
from the Union or that Province (as the rase may be) 30<br />
and does not return to the Union or that Province (as<br />
the case may be) within three years from the date of<br />
departure therefrom or in the case of a person who<br />
absented himself from the Union or any Province (as<br />
the case may be) prior to the 1st Aug-tIst, 1925, does 35<br />
not return to the Union or that Province (as the case<br />
JUay be) before the lst August, 1928; Provided that<br />
in cases where a, person proceE'ds overseas for a<br />
special or temporary purpo~e the Minister may<br />
authrize the issue of a certificate of identity under 40<br />
the provisions of sub-section (2) of section twentyfive<br />
of this Act allowinl! the ueuon concerned to return<br />
to, and resume hls reslilence in the Province<br />
named within the neriod specIfied in "uch certificate<br />
or any extension thereof not exceeding ten years in 45<br />
all,<br />
~'::::i~~m~~: ~~ 21. Section six of the Indians Relief Act, 1914, is hereby<br />
Act No ~ of amended by the addition after the words "any port in<br />
1914. India" of the words" or elsewhere",<br />
CHAPTER III,<br />
50<br />
REGISTRATION OF ASIATICS,<br />
Surrender of 2'" " 'fi ' d d h ' .<br />
ASiatiC legis- ;;:; A regIstratIon cerh cate Issue un er t e urovIsions<br />
tlon certlfi(ate of the Asiatic Law Amendment Act, 1907, of the Transvaal<br />
(Act No 2 of 1907),. or the Asiatics Regoistration<br />
Amendment Act, 1908, of the Transvaal (Act No, 36 of 55<br />
1908) may be surrendered by the holder to the Reg'istrar<br />
of Asiatics and such surrender shall be conclusive evidencE'<br />
that such Indian has abandoned any rigoht of or incidental<br />
to entry, residence. or domicile in the Transvaal Province,<br />
CIrcumstances ID "<br />
whIch apphcatlon 23, If an ASIatIc w h<br />
0<br />
h as f al 'I e d t<br />
0 ma k e app I' Ica t' IOn f or 60<br />
~~~I.~:~t~~~ cor- registration in accordance WIth the provisions of para,!p'aph<br />
tillcate may be (2) of section five of the Asiatics Registration Amendment<br />
made Act, 1908. of the Transvaal, shall satisfy the Registrar of<br />
Asiatic~ that such failure was due to some good and suffi-<br />
_ cient cause, the Minister' of the Interior may, in his dis- 65<br />
cretion, authorize the Registrar to receive an application
5<br />
11<br />
for registration from sm.h ASiatic and the apphcahon shall<br />
be dealt with in all respects as if it had been made in<br />
accordance with the provisions of the said section and all<br />
the provisions of Act 36 of 1908 of the Transvaal 3S<br />
amended by this Act whkh would have applied if the<br />
application had been fO made shall apply accordingly.<br />
24. Section seven of the Asiatics Registration Amend- ~~t~~~~~~!.:'fo'<br />
ment Act, 1908, of the Transvaal, is hereby amended by ~ ~oTse of I<br />
the deletion of the words" save as in the next succeeding 0 raDav ....<br />
10 section i'l provided".<br />
25. Section nine of the Asiatics Registration Amend- !'~t~~:m:,!~ O!f<br />
ment Ac~, 1908, of the Transvaal, is hereby amended by t::'OTr':n:: .... 1<br />
the deletion of the words:<br />
" Any Asiatic who fails upon lawful demand to produce<br />
15 such certificate shall, unless he is the lawful holder<br />
of a certificate of registration, be liable to be dealt<br />
with in manner mentioned in !'ection eight".<br />
CHAPTER IV.<br />
SUPPLEMENTARY .<br />
•<br />
20 26. The laws mentioned m the Schedule to this Act shall ~:~~al of<br />
be and are hereby repealed to the extent set out in the .<br />
fourth column of that Schedule.<br />
27. This Act may be cited as the Areas Reservation and Short title aDd<br />
Immigration and Registration (Further Provision) Act, ~~mA~~ncemeDt<br />
25 1925, and shall come mto force on the first day of August,<br />
1925.<br />
SCHEDULE.<br />
Pl'ovinoo No. and year TIUe or Subject Extent of<br />
of Law. of Law. Repeal.<br />
Natal .. Act No 28 of '1'0 protect uncove- The whole.<br />
1897. nanted Indl8llls<br />
from arrest m<br />
mistake for abscondmg<br />
mdentured<br />
Indian serva.nts<br />
Cape ...... Act No 370t The Clunese Ex- The whole.<br />
1904. elU610n Act, 1904.<br />
Transvaal. Act No. 36 of The ASiatics RegIS- Sections three, four,<br />
1908. tratlOn Amend- fIve (paragraph<br />
ment Act, 1908. one), SIX, eight,<br />
SIxteen, seventeen,<br />
(paragraphe five<br />
and SIX).<br />
Printed and Pubh8hed by International Prmtmg P!'e66, Phoemx, Natal.
~n'lian<br />
~piuitttt<br />
JlqUtered at the O.<br />
No. 33-Vo1. XXIII. Friday, August 14th, 1925. P.o. a. a N_aper<br />
PUliS I'OU ••""'8<br />
.-------------------------- -------------------------------<br />
THE ASIATIC BILL<br />
fROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE IMMIGRANTS' REGULATION ACT<br />
~OR the convenience of our readers we give below, in parallel columns, the various<br />
ll~ c:lau8es as at present existing in the Immigrants Regulation Act, 1913. together with the<br />
alterations, additions and deletions propo8ed in the " Areas Reservation and Immigration<br />
and Regi8tration ( Further Provision) Bill :-<br />
THE ACT AS IT EXISTS<br />
2. (7) No appeal shall be heard by a board unless<br />
notice thereof in the prescribed form has been given<br />
to the Immigration Officer by or on behalf of the<br />
person concerned within seventy-two hours after the<br />
refusal, detention. restriction. or arrest aforesaid., or,<br />
in case the appellant arrived by sea and the ship<br />
whereon he arrived is about to depart. unless such<br />
notice is given forthwith. In every case a deposit<br />
shall be made of an amount" Bltjficwnt, sn flu optnion<br />
0/ tlUJ Mimster .. to cover the detention expenses of<br />
the said person, the costs of bringing him before a<br />
board and of returning him to the place at which he<br />
was restricted if he desire to appear personally, and<br />
if he arrived by sea, the cost of his return passage<br />
by another ship to the place from which he came.<br />
3. (2) A board may, of its own motion, and shall.<br />
at the request of the appellant or of an immigration<br />
officer, reserve for the decision of a superior CQurt<br />
baving jurisdiction, any question of law which<br />
arises upon an appeal heard before such board nnder<br />
the last preceding section, and shall state such question<br />
in the form of a spedal case for the opinion of<br />
such court by transmitting such special case to the<br />
registrar thereof. The qnestion so stated may be<br />
argue? befor£> such court which may call for further<br />
information to be supplied by the board if the court<br />
!lhall deem sllch information necessary and may<br />
give sllch answer on such case, supplemented by<br />
such information, if any. and may make such order<br />
as to the costs of the proceedings, as it may think<br />
right.<br />
3. (3) For the purpose of this section "a qnestion<br />
of law" shall, among other questions include<br />
a question of domicile. and" a superior<br />
court having JllrisdlCtwn " shall mean IlUJ prot.inciaZ<br />
dwision oj the Supreme Court wltteh has<br />
jurisdICtion fl'ltere the board was Blttmg, or any<br />
jUdfl(J 0/ such dwiltion, itT tlte Easfern Dis/riels<br />
Local Dit.iswn having such jurisdiction or allY<br />
judge t/1.4!T'o/. and .. appellant It shall not include<br />
an alien.<br />
4. (1) (a) Any person or class of persons deemed<br />
by the Minister on economic gronnds or<br />
on account of standard or habits of life to<br />
be unsuited to the requirements of the<br />
Union or any particular Province thereof;<br />
...<br />
(continued from the bottom oC the second column)<br />
to the headwaters of the'rongolo River, and thence along lh.t<br />
nver to the border of the Utrecht District.<br />
The aforesaid Terntolles are 10 thIS Act shonly refened to as<br />
\.be NQrtbern Distncts. " • _ _<br />
... -<br />
THE ACT AS PRQPOSED '1'0 BE AMENDED<br />
2. (7) The same, excepting the ..deletion of the<br />
words italicised and the substition of the following:<br />
.. fixed by the immigration officer not exceeding<br />
Qne hundred pounds. "<br />
3. (2) The same, with the addition of the following<br />
words: .. From any such opinion there shall be<br />
an appeal to the Appellate Division of the Supreme<br />
Court. "<br />
(3) For the purposes of this section-<br />
.. a question of law" shall, among other<br />
questions, include a question of domicile ~<br />
and .. appellant" sball not include an<br />
alien.<br />
(NOTE.-Portion italicised in the opposite section<br />
is to be deleted.)<br />
4. (1) a. The same, with the addition of the<br />
following words :-<br />
.. Provided that for the purpose of. this sec.<br />
tion the Northern Districts of Natal, as<br />
described in section t/tre6 of ~ The Northern<br />
Districts Annexation Act. 1903" (Act No.<br />
1, 19~3, Natal) shall be deemed to be included<br />
in the Province of the Transvaal."<br />
[NOTB :-Act No. I, 1903. provides for the annexation to the<br />
Colony of Natal of certaIn Tenitones formlOg a part of the<br />
lransvaal Colony. Section '''"e refened to above is as follows:<br />
.. From and after the taklDg effect of this Act the nndermen.<br />
tioned Tenitories, situaltd Northwards of the Colony of Natal<br />
now frtmlDg a part of the Transvaal Colony. shall be annex£d to<br />
and shall thenceforth form a part of II e Colony of Natal, that is<br />
is to say :-The DIstrict of Vryheid, the Distnct of Utrecht. a<br />
portIon of the DIstrict of WakkelStroom lytng south of a line<br />
drawn from the North-eastern comer of Natal. East of Volksru!t<br />
(continucQ. at the bottom of the 6rst colWI\D 1
200 l~-bIAN OPINION August 14th, 19~5<br />
4. (1) (f) A~y per-aon who hit!! been convicted in<br />
any country of ~ny of the following offences<br />
(unless he has received a free pardon<br />
therefor) namely, murder, rape, arson,<br />
theft, receiving stolen goods knowing the<br />
!!3.lJle tp hl\-ve been iltolen; fraud, fQrgerf or<br />
uttering forged documents knowing the<br />
same to have been forged, counterfeiting<br />
coin or uttering coiq knowing; the sarqe to<br />
be counterfeIt, hpn\'lebl'elllqng with intent<br />
to commit an offence, burglary, robbery<br />
with vIolence, threats by letter or otherwise<br />
witl} ill tent; to Il~tort or of any at~;mpt to<br />
commIt any such offence. and by reason o~<br />
the circumstances oonnpcted with the<br />
ofi'epoe, is deemed by the Minister to-be an<br />
nnd\lsirable inhabItant of or visitor to ,the<br />
Union.<br />
4. (~) NClth,ng in 8ub-section (1) contained shall<br />
he construe\!-<br />
'(a) as enabling a pe1'llon to be deemed a prohibited<br />
immigrant jn the Cape of Good Hope br Natal,<br />
if, bemg l">t the commenoement of this Aot<br />
• lawfully entitled to reside in any Province, he<br />
shows or has shown that he is able to comply<br />
with the requirements described in section<br />
three (a) of Act No. 30 of 1906 of the Cape of<br />
Good Houe, or of sectlOnjiv8 (a) of Act No. 30<br />
of 1903 of Natal.<br />
[NOTE -Section three (a) of Act No. 30 of 1906 of the Cape<br />
of Good Hope, referred to above reads as fol1o\'ls .-<br />
(a) Any person who, when asked to do so by any duly<br />
authorIsed officer, shall be unable through deficient educatIon to<br />
himself wnte out and sIgn 10 the characters of any European<br />
language an apphcatlon to the satIsfactIon of the MInIster;<br />
prOVIded that for the purposes of thIS sub.sectlon ¥Idqish $hall<br />
be accepted as an Euwpeab langUage.<br />
SeclI~~ jiw (l!J qf Act No. 30 of 1903 !)f Natl\l referreq to<br />
\11 tb,\$ ~eCtlo..\l reads as, folloVl!~ :"""7<br />
(a) any person who when aSKed to do so by any duly !1~t~or.<br />
Ized officer, shall be unable through deficIent educatIon to hImself<br />
to wflte out and sIgn, 10 the characters of some European<br />
language, an applIcatIon to the satIsfaction of the MInIster. "<br />
5. The following persons or classes of persons<br />
shall not be prohibited Immigrants for the purposes<br />
of this .Act namely ;-<br />
(e) any person born before the commenoement<br />
of the Act lU any part of South Africa inoluded<br />
in the Union whose parents were lawfully<br />
resident therein and were not at that<br />
time restrICted to temporary or conditional<br />
residenoe by any law then in force, and any<br />
person born in any place after the commencement<br />
of thIS Aot whose parents were at the<br />
time of hi'! bIrth domICiled in a.ny part of<br />
South Africa itlcludetl in the Union.<br />
(g) any person wha is proved to the satisfaction<br />
of an ImmI~,'Tation Officer or in case of an<br />
appeal to the satisfaction of the board, to be<br />
the wife, or the ohild under the age 'of 16<br />
years, of any person exempted by paragraph<br />
(f) of thIS section, provided that the wife or<br />
the child, (as the case may be), is not such a<br />
perSQIil all is descpbed in s~b-seetion (1) (d),<br />
(e), (f), (g) or (h) of the last preceding section.<br />
4. (1) (j) The ~me, with the Jl41l1tion ,.fter ~he<br />
words" bave been Jltolen" of the follow<br />
ing;-<br />
•• incest, sodomy, bestiality, any offence<br />
involving fraudulent conduot in connection<br />
'With any insolvency. "<br />
4. (2) (a) deleted.<br />
5. The following persons or c~es of persono<br />
sqall not be prohibited immigrants for the purposes<br />
of this Act :t\ainely :-<br />
.. (e) any person, other than an l\1ien, who \VaS<br />
born in any pal't of South Africa illclude4<br />
in the Union and whose paren~ were at tile<br />
time of his birth lawfull~ res~dent therein<br />
and were not at that time fCIItricted to ~<br />
porary 01' conditional residenoe therein h-l'<br />
any law then in force; Provided that any<br />
pevSon who, if he ~ a ptel ellters<br />
the Union witmu five "~Ri aftel' Ute fill'St<br />
day of August, 1925, or withi~<br />
~ ,eart
iNDIAN OPINION<br />
20t<br />
10. No prohiMted immigrant shall be exempt<br />
from the provisiQns· of this Ac~ or be allowed to<br />
rtlmain in the Union, or in allY PrQvince wherein<br />
his residence is unlawful, Or be deemed to have<br />
acquired a domicile therein, by reason only that he<br />
had not been informed that he could not enter or<br />
remain in the Union or (as the case may be) in that<br />
Province or that he had been allowed to enter or<br />
remain through oversight. misrepresentatIOn or<br />
owing to the fact having been undiscovered that he<br />
was such a prohibited immigrant.<br />
22. Any person (not being a person born in any<br />
JlW't of SOllili Africa which has been included in the<br />
Umon) who, whether befQl'e or after the commenee<br />
:ment of this A\Jt has been sentenced kI impri8Oll<br />
ment-<br />
(a) for a contravev.tion. of provision mentionN in<br />
the first schedule to this Act or any provision<br />
hereafter amending that provision or sllbsti<br />
"'ted therefor or far any offence mentioned in<br />
sub-eect.iOQ (1) (f) o( sectioa/ImT;<br />
(b) for seHing. partering, giving or othefwiae<br />
~. supp1ying intoxicating liquor to any ~o1onred<br />
person in comra'vention of any 4w; or<br />
(c) f9r dealing in or being in possess.iOQ of<br />
nnwron~~t precious m$l or rOQgh or uucat<br />
precious stones in contraventioll of any ldw,<br />
t<br />
afttn' the date of the liMIt entry Into the<br />
Union, -whiche'\'er period may be the longer,<br />
of the pel'lOlllO exempted.<br />
[NOTE.-l'aragrapU Cti). (t), tI,; en aD e"r of auh-seetloD el)<br />
or section iour refe"ed to 10 (I) deal Wllb criminal. .Dd dqseued<br />
persona and paragrapb (a) of lub-sectlnn (I) 01 sectIOn (our<br />
r.fcorred to lD 'Ii) .. lIS Collows 1-<br />
Cal any person o. class of persons deemed by the Mwhlet' on<br />
economic grounds or on account o( standard or b.bils or life to<br />
be unsuited to the fequllementl of tbe Union or .ny particular<br />
P r0910Clt tbereof.}<br />
In the interpretation of this paragraph " the wife ..<br />
shall inclgde anyone woman between whom and<br />
the exempted person mentioned there exists a union<br />
recognised as a marriage under the tenet8 of an<br />
Indian religion notwithstanding that by those tenets<br />
the uniou of that exempted person with other<br />
women at the !arne time would also be recognised<br />
as a marriage. Provided that DO woman shall be<br />
deemed to be the wife of such E'xempted peI'8Qn-<br />
(i) if such a union exists between him and any<br />
other woman who bas under any law relating<br />
to immigration Or to Asiatic registration been<br />
recognised within the Un!on as the wife of<br />
Buch person and bas resided or resides or'is<br />
domiciled in any province ; or<br />
(ii) if such exempted person has offspring resident<br />
or domiciled in any province by any woman<br />
who is still living.<br />
and a union shall not be for the purposes of this<br />
section be deemed to have ceased to exist by reason<br />
only of the fact that according to the tenets of an<br />
Indian religion it has been dissolved •<br />
.. The child under the age of sixteen" shall mean<br />
a child who is the offspring of the exempted person<br />
and the wife as herein defined or the child of the<br />
exempted person and a deceased woman who if she<br />
had been alive could have been recognised at the<br />
time of the birth of the child a. the wife (as herein<br />
defined) or whose union with the exempted person<br />
could have been registered at the time of the birth<br />
of the child as a marriage under spction two of the<br />
Indians Relief Act, 1914.<br />
10. The same, with the following addition :<br />
Any such perBan may be declared to be a prohibited<br />
immi~ant and dealt with ill termS of<br />
section. nme/lln of this Act and if 8Ueh P6n1On<br />
is in possession of a registration oertifieate 01' a<br />
certificate of domicile or any other aoedmellt<br />
anthorizmg him to remain in th1J Union or amy<br />
province it iihall be oompt'tent for any board kI<br />
which he may appeal, if it be pl'o1'eci to tile<br />
satisfaction of the board that soch tlel'tifieate or<br />
other document waH obtained by fraudulent<br />
representations by or on behalf of the hQlder,<br />
to order that such certificate or other document<br />
be cancelled and the holder thereof be dealt<br />
with as a prohibited immigrant: Provided that<br />
if!l1lch pet'BOD fails to appml to' a; board the<br />
Principal Immigration Officer, concerned I!l1ly<br />
exercille aU such powers as to the cancellation<br />
of any certificate or other doeu.ment 88 ate by<br />
this section conferred upon a board.<br />
22. The mme, with the addition of the following<br />
new paragraph :-<br />
(d) for any offence undel' section lwenJII of thiB<br />
Act for which imprisonment baa been imposed<br />
without the option of a fine.<br />
l No'nt :-Section 20 above referred to reads as fonows l<br />
Any 'person who-<br />
(..) auis or abets any person in entering or remlllniog within<br />
the Ullbn Of any Pr
202 INDIAN OPINION August 14th, 1925<br />
\<br />
and who by teason of the circumstances connected<br />
with the offerlce, is del'lmed by the Minister to be an<br />
undesirable mhabitant of the Union, may be removed<br />
from the Union by warrant, and pending<br />
removal, may be detained in such custody as may<br />
be prescribed by regulation.<br />
30. In this Act, and in the regulations made<br />
thereunder, unless inconsistent with the context,-<br />
.. domicile" shall mean the place in which a<br />
person has his present home or in which he<br />
resides or to which he returns as his place Qr<br />
present permanent abode and not for a mere<br />
special or temporary purpose; aud a person<br />
shall not be deemed to have a domicile within<br />
the Union or any Province (as the case may be)<br />
fOi' tl-..:~ purposes of this Act unless he has resided<br />
therein for at least three years, otherwise<br />
than under terms of conditional or temporary<br />
residence permitted by this Act or any other<br />
law Qr as a person under detention in a prison,<br />
gaol, reformatory or lunatic asylum; and a person<br />
shall be deemed for the purposes of this<br />
Act to have lost his domicile within the Union<br />
or any Province (as the case may be) if he<br />
voluntarily go and reside outside the Union or<br />
the Province (except for a special or temporary<br />
'purpose) with the intention of making his<br />
home outside the Union or ~at Province (as the<br />
case may be.)<br />
Section si.c of the Indians Relief Act, 1914:<br />
The Mimster may m his discretion cause to be<br />
provided out of moneys appropriated b¥ Parliament<br />
for the purpose of a free passage from any port in<br />
the Union to any port in India (with or without free<br />
conveyance by rail to such first mentioned port) for<br />
any IndIan (ot,her than an Indian who is or may<br />
become entItled under Law No. 25 of 1861-Natal-<br />
01' any amendment thereof 10 such free passage),<br />
who makes a written request for such free passage<br />
etc.<br />
The Executive Committee had felt-that very careful<br />
steps had to be taken. It was hoped t.hat the<br />
question of Asiatic trading would have been tackled<br />
by the Union Government. The Government had,<br />
however, decided that this aspect of the Asiatic problem<br />
must be left to the provinces. In framing the<br />
Ordinance they had taken. mto consideration the recontravention<br />
of the Act, commits any fraudulent act or<br />
make~ any false representation by conduct, statement, or<br />
othuwlse,<br />
shall be gUIlty of an offence and hable on conViction to a fiDe not<br />
exceedmg one hundred pounds or, In default of payment to 1m.<br />
pnsonmeDt With or Without hard labour for a pertod not<br />
exceedtng SI'< months, or to such Imprtsonment Without the<br />
optton of a fine.]<br />
30. In this Act and in the regulations made thereunder,<br />
unless inconsistent will the context:<br />
.. domicile" shall mean the place in which a<br />
person has his present permanent home. or<br />
present permanent residence or, to which he<br />
returns as his present permanent abode and not<br />
for a mere special or temporary purpose; and a<br />
person shall not be deemed to have a domicile<br />
within the Union or any Province (as the case<br />
may be) for the purposes of this Act unless he<br />
has lawfully resided therein for a continuous<br />
period of three years, otherwise than under<br />
terms of conditior.al or temporary residence<br />
permitted by this Act or any other law or as a<br />
person under detention in prison, gaol, reformatory<br />
or mental hospital, and a person shall be<br />
deemed for the purposes of this Act to have lost<br />
his domicile within the Union or any Province<br />
(as the case may be) if he absents himself from<br />
the Union or that Province (as the case may be)<br />
and does not return to the Union or that Province<br />
(as the case may be) within three years<br />
from the date of departure then'from or in the<br />
case of a person who absented himself fl'om the<br />
Union or any Province (as the case may be)<br />
prior to the 1st August, 192.'), does not return<br />
to the Union or that Province (as the case may<br />
be) before the 1st Angust, 192~: Provided that<br />
in cases where a person proceeds overseas for a<br />
special or temporary purpose the :Minister may<br />
authorize the issue of a cm'tificate of identity<br />
under the provisions of sub.section (2) of section<br />
tweflf!l-jiv6 of this Act allowing the pm'son concerned<br />
to return to, and resnme his residence in<br />
the Province named within the period specified<br />
in such certificate or any extenSIOn thereof not<br />
exceeding tell years in all.<br />
Section .~IX of the Indians Relief Act, 1914. remains,<br />
with the addition after the words .. any<br />
port in India" of the words" or elllcwhere."<br />
ASIATIC -TRADERS IN THE TRANSVAAL<br />
In the Transvaal Provincial CounCIl in moving<br />
the second reading of the "General Dealer's (ControI)<br />
Draft Ordinance," the Administrator is reported<br />
to have said, the measure was put forward mainly to<br />
control the Asiatic tra1.e in difference to representations<br />
made to restrict the issue of general<br />
dealers' licences. These requests were made by<br />
representatives of various municipalities.<br />
quest of the Municipal Congress from lallt year and<br />
also the report of the Asiatic Commission.<br />
Mr. Geo. Hills (Lab., Benoni) said it should be<br />
stated frankly that the Draft Ordinance was intended<br />
to apply to Asiatics, if that was the intention.<br />
Mr. H. J. Lamb (S.A.P. Yeoville) was of the same<br />
opinion, and moved the adjournment of the debate,<br />
because members had not had time to consider the<br />
measure.<br />
The motion was defeated by 25 votes to 15.<br />
Mr. R. H. A. Rabbie (Nat., WakkerBtrooru) said<br />
.that through the competition of the Asiatics many<br />
white dealers had to close their business. The<br />
danger did not exist only in the large centres, ~llt<br />
also in the up-country villages. He strongly supported<br />
the second reading.<br />
The draft was read a second time and the eommitte<br />
stage fixecl for 'fue8daK tI:.e 11th instan:.
August 14th, J925 INDIAN OPINION 203<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
T is difficult to foresee what fate awaits India.<br />
IT<br />
At a time when proper guidance is most essential<br />
to the youth of India in her struggle<br />
for freedom veterans, one after another, are speedily<br />
passing away. Within the short space of ten years<br />
we have recorded the deaths of not less than five<br />
great leaders, namely, Gokhale, Tilak, Sir Subramania<br />
Aiyar, Ashutosh Mukherjee and Das, and now<br />
we receive the sad news of the death of Sir<br />
Surendranath Dannerjea. It is an nndoubted fact<br />
that the present awakening of National spirit<br />
in India is the fmit of tt e labonrs of tht'se<br />
leaders who have not had the good fortune of seeing<br />
with their own eyes the accomplishment of their<br />
self-imposed task but have departed leaving the task<br />
to be accomplished by others. Let us hope that they<br />
will be guided by the same spirit that has guided<br />
the palt leaders. It is an irony of fate that<br />
Bengal should lose within a very short period three<br />
of her great men, for, the last three mentioned all<br />
belonged to Bengal. Bengal has evt'r stood first anti.<br />
even to-day stands first in her patriotism and this<br />
loss to her will be nnbearable. Sir Surt'ndranath<br />
leaves behind him one son and five danghters to<br />
whom and to Bengal we extend our heartfelt<br />
sympathy.<br />
With this issue we present our readers with a<br />
photo supplement of the late Sir Surendranath<br />
Baunerjea whose life sketch appears in another<br />
colnmn.<br />
Mr. Jogodish Chandra Mnkherjee the managing<br />
partner of the well-known firm of Calcutta-Messrs.<br />
Kamalalaya, (Wholesale and Export Clothiers, Hatters<br />
and Outfitters), who has recently come on a business<br />
trip to, the Union has arrived at Durban last Wednesday<br />
from Johannesburg and is the guest of Mr.<br />
Sorabjee Rustomjee. The firm represented by Mr.<br />
Mukherjee is perhaps the ouly Indian firm which<br />
is doing business on a large scale with many of the<br />
South African Europl'an firms. Mr. Mukherjee is. to<br />
our knowledge, the first Bengalee gentleman that has<br />
ever visited th~se shores. Although his mission is<br />
purely a business one he will, no doubt, incidentally<br />
have the opportunity of gaining a first-hand knowledge<br />
of the Indian question, of which, from the little<br />
chat we were able to have with him, Mr. Mukherjee<br />
seems to have already had some bitter experience.<br />
Mr. Mnkherjee sails for India by the<br />
8.8. Kar(lgola on the 17th instant.<br />
A petition with about a thou-aud .,ignatures has heen submitted<br />
to His Exalted HighneilS the Nizam, Hydrabad, for<br />
J!'ranting political reforms as embodied in a Memorandum<br />
prepared by the State Reforms Association sometime ago.<br />
The vreVIOUS memorandum from the State Reforms<br />
AlSOCiatlon prayed tho Nizam to gran~ representation in<br />
the Legislative Conncil in proportion to the percentage<br />
cf classes in the State with protection of minorities. The<br />
Nizam had previously announced in a declaration that the<br />
Legisilltive CounCIl should be coustituted aud enlarged<br />
on modern lines and it was in pursuance aud conformity<br />
with the principles of this declaration that the Htate<br />
Reforms Association put in their memorandnm.<br />
Mr. R. Srinivasau, M.L.C., reprel!enting the interests<br />
of the submerged classefl in the Legislature, has made his<br />
mark as a Social Worker. He was made Rao Sahab in<br />
tim last Honours' List, on the birthd8Y of H. I. M. the<br />
King. Mr. Srinivasan, it will be remembered, returned<br />
to India after completing a foIl term in civil service<br />
in South Africa and his many local friends will be<br />
pleued to learn of t.be \Ietvi~1!I he is tendering "- ~he<br />
lIotherl,udj<br />
Que;tions have been p~1; in connection with Mabatma<br />
Gandbl as to who pays h18 expenses and whether he is<br />
expensive? Mahatma Gandhi him\lelf answers these<br />
qUE'BtioDs in Young India :-<br />
"I do make the claim, that I attempt to act<br />
as I preach. Bot I must confess that I am not as inexpensive<br />
in my wants, 8S I would like to be. My food<br />
since my illneBB costs more than it should. By no means<br />
can I caU it a poor man's food. My travels too cost<br />
more than they did before my illness. I am no longer<br />
Ilble to travel long distance third class. Nor do I travel.<br />
all I did before. withou~ a companion. All this means<br />
not simplicity and povt'rty, bot the reverse of it. I draw<br />
nothlDg from the A.I.C.C. or the Gojarat Committee.<br />
But friends find Illy travelling expenses including food<br />
and clothing. Often during my tours railway tickets are<br />
purchased by those .who invite me and my host everywhere<br />
covers me with kind attention.<br />
THE ASIATIC BILL<br />
~ HE Areas Reservation and Immigration and<br />
II Registration (Further Provision) Bill, introduced<br />
hy the Minister of the Interior in<br />
the Union House of Assemhly at the close of the<br />
session reveals the Asiatic policy of the Government.<br />
There are two important chapters, the first<br />
dealing with the reservation of class areas and the<br />
second with amendments to the Immigrants Regulation<br />
Act. Chapters III. and IV. deal with<br />
amendm('nts to the Asiatics Rf'gistration Amendment<br />
Act of the Transvaal and the repeal wholly<br />
or in part of certain laws affecting Asiatics in<br />
Natal, Transvaal and the Cape Provincf.'.<br />
Fortunately the Government have launc]led this<br />
Bill at the close of Parliament. the object being,<br />
as stated by the Minister, to enable all concerned<br />
to study the measure. 'Ve are of opinion<br />
that the Government anticipate strClng opposition<br />
on the part of the British and Indian Governments.<br />
and thought it the best policy to allow the storm<br />
to gather and hurst before the Bill is proceeded<br />
with. Be that as it may, the time that must eJapqe<br />
before the Bill can be brought before Parliament.<br />
can be made use of by the Indian commllDity,<br />
both in India and South Africa, to enliRhten the<br />
mass of the people to its provisions. That is the<br />
first step. This complicated Bill must be examined<br />
thoroughly, and in order to assist our readers<br />
we publish in this issue the amendments to the<br />
Immigrants Regulation Act side by side with the<br />
original dauses. Later on we intend to examine<br />
each clause as amended and endeavour to show<br />
what effect such amendments will have npon the<br />
rights of Asiatic residents and their descendants.<br />
The first chapter, dealing with the reservation<br />
of class areas. affects adversely Asiatics only, although<br />
they are scarcely mentioned by name<br />
Cape Malays anti half-caste races such as the<br />
.. Cape Coloured," .. Mauritius Creole" and .. St.<br />
Helena persons" are exempt from the provisioM<br />
of this Bill. There is, of course, a political reason<br />
for exempting thec;e people. They have the Parliamentary<br />
franchise and can make their voice<br />
heard. Moreover there is a growing tendency to<br />
absorb certain Europeanised coloured people into<br />
the Buropean community, as the trend of recent<br />
legtalation dealin4 with wa~ and conditions in
204 INDIAN OPINION August 14th, 1925<br />
~----------------------------~------~------~------------~~ ~----~'--~~--<br />
the industrie~ makes it impossible to place white is intended by this iniquitous measure. If this<br />
aij.d coloUJecJ -Workers on a di{'l'erent basiq.<br />
nil! ever b£'comes law, the ~ndimt cmntnnnity's<br />
~ The proce.dure adQiPt~d jn the EiH £Or bringjng p 'sition In thi~ country will be unbearable.<br />
about the reservation of ,class areas, which wiU<br />
really ibe Asiatio locations, is (,r a municipal<br />
c?ti~cll, village .or local board or health committee<br />
to it1til'Iiate,to the Ui1).1stel' that a certain a"f'U Is<br />
wholly pr 1.o;r the greater part occupied for traning<br />
Of residential purposes by a particular elass of<br />
persons (Asiatics for instanoe). A commjs"Iion<br />
ap!>olntfld by the Minister win then investigate and<br />
rep,Qrj :u.pOl;l. th.e .d~ir~bill.ty of $etting apart such<br />
ar,e,a for th~ use of a particular ci.lss of persons.<br />
Bya proclahlatiOil in the Gov£1'nment Gazett~ the<br />
Governor-General may declare a certain area t'l be<br />
either a class residential, ttading 01' combined<br />
residential and trading area within six months of<br />
the receipt of the cRf11missi,QQ,'s report<br />
Supposing an area is set apart for Asill-tjcs, no<br />
other prxsons may /tCquire or lel).se property therein<br />
uij'Jt)as ~ hOlds the right .of r~,Dew,al 01 a lease in<br />
w],"jtins at the PQmmeIlc,ement of the Act (which<br />
is Il-l:r~,!j..Qy d,efi.nit~ly {i~~ as August 1, 1925, whenever<br />
the Bill11).fl,Y J1appen to (>a.ss). Likewise no<br />
A§iatic wo»ld pe auJ.e to ncquin~ or lease property<br />
in :J. hOWn or vHm.ge cl.~e!l)hc1'c than in thfJ area act<br />
apfJ/l't unlElss If,~ t~ comrnen('ement of thl1 Act lJe<br />
is i.p. p9!?Sel'lllioJ). of ~ written l~se.<br />
Np EUfPp,ean rp.ay pe grallted a licence in an<br />
A,siatic ~reJl., an,Q. no Allia.tJp may obtain II> licence<br />
elsewhere t1-Ill~s in ~ith,er Cfl,S,e they receive a<br />
sp,ecial 'Permit granr.eeJ py the Gov~rn,or-Gf;'~eral;<br />
pr$?yi4~d, h?wever, that t~ose who at fhe time of<br />
tM proclam1!-tioll ar~ carrying on bl1siness yl).p.~ot<br />
be refused a renewal of a licence.<br />
'These special areas may 4e extende-l or reduced,<br />
after i~vpstigati()ll, or the Gove,mqr-General JI:lay<br />
by ;ptocla~\:Lt!on deeide to suspend for a perj q all<br />
thtl provisinns regardin~ a special area if found to<br />
be inadequate or ~ns~itab1e ~~ the pupulation.<br />
SpeCial areas ptoclahned in t1;1e Transvaal will be<br />
pl~ced o~, the 'sa~e J )?ting as loc~tioJS ;;tlready<br />
established ~ndet Law 3 of 1885,<br />
'T.he at11 proVid~s for !in aiivisory hoard copsisting<br />
b£ n~t le~s tl:lll'n three persons of the class<br />
con~tie!hed resident in t.he same town or vilhtge, In<br />
adaitlb~ to a ~~n ch"!i ai'e\i, may I;>e a European It is<br />
pro\Tided tb~t no by-l~ws or reguilltions part!<br />
c~1~i~y. affeCting the class of persons concerned<br />
shall be made ot tyithdrawn unless the advice of<br />
the adVi,so~ bo~rd haf'l first be~n obt~IPed '<br />
By procl,amation in the tJfLZette\ the Governor<br />
Gei}er~l may d.E:1~lare phat po Asiatic, for instance,<br />
m~y ~c
August 14th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 205<br />
High Court, who had in a case orderd the prodoction<br />
of an idol in evidence. Sir Surendranath was JrosE-cuted<br />
fOl' contempt of Court jlod was sentence by<br />
a majority of JuJietl to two lDonthlii t IDlprillOnment,<br />
though an apology was offered b, Sir Surendranath.<br />
During the exciting days of Lord Lytton, during<br />
the eventful days of Lord Ripon, during the memorable<br />
Viceroyalty of I..ord CarzoD, during tho ?tItnto<br />
Viceroralty with its reforms. repressiona ani the<br />
bomb, during all these days, the Bengll/ee has been<br />
second to none in educating, organi,iog aod moulding<br />
public opinion. Sir SureJldraoatb Bannerjea<br />
was invited to represent India on the "Imperial<br />
Pres8 Conference." A colonial delegate to the Conference<br />
was so impressed with Sir Sureqdranath'lJ<br />
abmUel that he told him that, if there were other<br />
mel) in In4ia like Sir Surendranath, self-Government<br />
ought at once to pe granted to lndia.<br />
Hm PottTlCAL OA.ltEti:R<br />
On the 26th Jul" 1876, the "Indian AMOelatioo"<br />
of Cakutta Wall usbered into being, by tbtl Q:J).ited<br />
efforts ot Messrs. Snren
a. ,.. ij ~ ,~ Itt ifil"f ~it.i itftJ rit1fl~ I ~il8f' Itlffiiff" flStf~. Mf* .~ ~ ..<br />
1l-~~ 'If': tl~~ ~lttl"Jft: !PeA ~ 1~~llte1:~ }a ~~ t~ .~ lll-~' '~1~~ ntlo!~ !1t.~ ., ~~Wl!!<br />
~'" ~I"~ 1Il):'{ Cieli~ 0l}t t ~ 'hl~ ~ll~ t~P ,,?~~ l-l~~'flt~ It?''lf\ltA " ~ I~Rlll l>~l&l}t.f\<br />
PI'I~~ \}-l-nU''fl 'fs1lt~ t 0 lcl"'lt~<br />
t~th ~ wc-iit l}t !lt31h If'k~ '0 (Ii clh~ tll~ 13hl~f\ fi!lWt ~~h '~ !"~lc~ fill~'l{ le<br />
eh€) lMh I?I~ ~1~ 'l!:l1'~ l-"'Th.l(t \}-lt~ I," ~ { ~ l1'~ ! !l>!lt~ ~ lhol~ lltlM'lh fi!lc~l\ el'h: ll>l;l}fI ~ t ~,<br />
~'l!: U'l-1P lek ~lh '? .. ~<br />
-l~lh hl\ l}1' ~ t lf1fulc: t'~ ~!jlJ ~ tl,eh '0<br />
Flt hlilJ ~ ~l~ lltlbelf 17111.13 }ltl}1f\UAI \}'? .. ~<br />
-1]:31h t\ ~'" lell\l:. 1C1lo!~ !It?~~ 7 .. ~'l"~l!:<br />
~<br />
elh:llt~ 'tlta ~1t<br />
o~~ ~lPlclt<br />
Cil~~~ Thfi!lcl(:p.," ~'" "lie'\) Pl1\ 1Il11e,ln J!'" ~cP<br />
If'~~ "0 lhlc lfitt ~l~~li1} It!h ~~ 1:::'elil} li~<br />
lnG\lh, \}'Illl~ ~Il-~ .. ~ft. t~ lt~clt '0 rlb~ l>~I't\-Ila:<br />
~tt ~l't\-bJ eh€) ~U-~ lPli ~",a-le\}> @.)hlla: Gik~ k\!<br />
~ 1~~e ~fi \11~li elP~ ~ full. \}'~ ~ 'ftic \1>1V£h:<br />
Pf~ \}'RI~ ~lkt (! l-lP.(3t' t~ 0 ~li 111~fi J1~~~ lY".ln<br />
1l-1P'~ nff\ '\fth.f\~ It)l1," ~~ 1{?1i I'" ltPe~~ lk1c:,lt1\<br />
lb~ '~ ~c \1>IPltIl}irc~ ~1lo!b Th~lt P!l{ ~~ fcIh ~l~<br />
~'" ~ file ~la- ~lhPl" lIl11r,ltI tp?(~ lY'~~ '0 Ilt~<br />
~17 ~p.la: l::P~tt Si~ ""U~h ,~ V1h li~ ~e~~ t'~~<br />
tla: IP' ~1l-Pll{ 1Ill1e,ln PSi"li felI\G 1130 ll>lh<br />
-l~'PJ! lla: 1~~lc ~1~~lc:b< { 0 ~ li"',at.,hltll,,:<br />
'\felf ~~ 1:::.lblli !~~c !c~1a: ~lA: \£li P l}lS faih 1~'P1!<br />
'''''hllc~ fl~~ lhll-~llei~~ /4)~ lP'<br />
lhli P~~ l~IP1! ''''lIl)liP~ lfuhlla: Thll'bl~3~ (! (,<br />
~Unn ~~~ @.)hlla: .~ l'hle lPhl~ 1:::'~lnl}fl 1tllt~<br />
lYlPl~ t'" 0 lhlc 1P~1'h: ll!;~ hlb~ lh-:>l," clil<br />
3~~ ~ lP' Mn.lc 3~~ \}'lbelf ,.~ e~ ~<br />
1~lP't h\}',..,lt ~ ~tl~ltli 'Q'lh hf~1i ~fQfi ~~~<br />
~ 0 1Il\ ~fl~,..~lt \}>1~lP1! ll-lIl1liP~ ~ ~~ n~e<br />
(1~ tp1c~ ~ @.)hl~ ~l," lk~l{ &"'P~ll' 0 U~~<br />
'1:11;", "klil~ \}'Rl~J(b< !l>(;iel-~ ~ll-~ .. t~ e~ ~hl1A:<br />
la' t1A: !~" t 1ct Cieli"ft 1I1l:!fi1ct 'e'h~ \}'klio~ e~ 'li~lP<br />
• ~11I.l~ '~1'" '~A~ ?1~ &l~IPt l>1~1t h:}h lG\l~<br />
!kl6'.l~ J!lt~ e~.lA: lYP~tt Sir \}'~c~ ~~ '0 l'hcl~<br />
lble lP~Ih: Sj~ ~h li~ 1~IPt 1~~1~l
ndiatt ~piltilln<br />
No. 34~Vol. XXIII. Friday, August 21st, 1925.<br />
lleciotered auhe G. p.o .•• a N.wspape<br />
PalOS I'ouaPER(.8<br />
~----------------------------~~------------------------------------<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
~l~<br />
?\t DDRESSING the Mayor of Durbau aud the Town which its importance demands. Your C )mmittee aecor-<br />
LC1l Councillori ou their dnty at St. Cyprian's Church dingl, recommends to the Provincial Council that the<br />
last Sunday after the recent Council election, enquI~y should '>e resumed in Its next ensuing Se~sion;<br />
tbe VeD. Archdeacon Hodson referring to the race pro- tbat toe Select Committee should be then reconstituted<br />
blem ill reported to h'lve .aill :-<br />
with the same membership."<br />
j, Then in this city there wa. the problem of the<br />
varions races Jivin~ witbin its borders, and unles~ the<br />
CorporatioQ acted wiRely and with perfect justice there<br />
woqld be no peace witbin tbose borders; would, in fact,<br />
be constaut strife. " 1<br />
'l'he following copy of a resolution adopted at a meeting<br />
of the Sonth African-born Indian Afsociation held<br />
in Capetown on Aug. 9, hal! been communicated to<br />
Beuter's Agt'ncy : .. That this meeting of South AfrICanborn,<br />
Indians protests most empbatically against tbe remarks<br />
of the Assistant Magistrate for C':Ipetown, Mr.<br />
Chenowe~b, in a certain case where a colon red man was<br />
charged with contraveninfl certain railny regulatIOns,<br />
reported in the Cape Argus of Aug. 7, 1925, wherein<br />
the Magistrllte is reported to have said : "I have every<br />
r~Bpect for a colQu.red Jllan like the accused, wbo has got<br />
on and, wpo knowB how to behave himself. I admire<br />
soch ',People tremendously, but if after getting on they<br />
'wish to place themselves on the level of the European,<br />
tben I tbink tbey are going to bit too far. Everybody<br />
lVilI admit tba~ it would be a very bad thing if tbe. South<br />
AfLican Railway Department allowed coloured people,<br />
howeveJ' respectable they might be, to travel with Europeanjl,<br />
and there should be some distinction made," 8S<br />
J>eing uDcalled for ..and. insulting, and calls upon the<br />
said magistrate to publicly withdraw the said remarks.<br />
Further, that copies of the above resolution be forwarded<br />
~ the said magistrate, the Hon. the Minister of Justice,<br />
and the Press.<br />
We tbink the !.ssistant Ma~istrate in the case referred<br />
to above mijst have, completely forgotten himself. It.<br />
had probably escaped his memory that he was at the<br />
moment sittiug on the Bench dealing out jnstice and, in<br />
his absent mindedness, IDUSt have thought he was on a<br />
p~bHc platfo!'m delivering a political speech. Notwithstanding,<br />
however,'it leaves a very bad impression on tha<br />
publi~ mind about a Britisu Court of justice.<br />
The freedom of the Borough of Durban was conferred<br />
on CounCillor Thomas Burman, M.B.E., au ex-Mayor<br />
and 8 mtlmber of the Council for 14 years last Saturday<br />
by the unanimous vote of the Town Council.<br />
--<br />
The Select Committee app~inted to consider pnd report<br />
upon the subject of Indian and Native Medium of hstrnotion,<br />
in the schools of Natal has reported inler alia<br />
8S follows:-<br />
,_ ·~An application from the Natal ~ndian Congress<br />
(Pletermaritzbnrg Branch) has been receIved to be .beard<br />
before your Committee, which ill de&kOlllt.~l~"'pt: ~'of>taining<br />
further information upon the matt.ar referred to it<br />
from other angles than ~hose t~!J..s far presented.<br />
The time at the dispOllal of your Comm!ttee during<br />
thill !;Iession apjJeal'll to be insufficient for according that<br />
careful collsiiIeration to the qu~tion under ref~ence<br />
The Draft Ordinance to amend The Rnral Dealera<br />
IJicensing Law Amendment Ordinance 1923 as read a<br />
third time and passed by the Natal ProvinCial Connoil<br />
reads as follows'-<br />
1. The words oecurrlDg in SectIOn set'en, Sub-section<br />
1, th,ee yean, are hereby deleted, and "one year" snbstitutpd,<br />
and fRrm vf office of members of aI' existing Boards<br />
shall expIre at 31st October, 1925.<br />
2. This Orllinance may be cited as "The Roral Dealers"<br />
Licensing Law Amentiment OrdlDance, 1925."<br />
Thus the 8warajya (Madras) on the late Colour Bar<br />
Bill :-<br />
Quite in accordance with" the forecast made In these<br />
columns a few days back, the South African Senate has<br />
turned down the MlDes and Works Act-'!eneraUy<br />
known as the Colour Bar Bill. The news will be received<br />
with great relief throughouL Iudia. It is doubtfnl,<br />
however, if the Hertzog Government WIll not try<br />
other means available to them, to get the Act placed on<br />
the Statute Book. The MlDister of limes gave unequivocal<br />
expressIOn to the intentions of the Government on<br />
this point. He wanted the Senate to believe that white<br />
ciV1h~ahon would be wiped out Simultaneously with the<br />
abondonment of the Act. He also made it plain tbat<br />
there was nei ch'mce of the Gove'nlLent altpring theit<br />
decision It looks from this that even Lord Birk"nhead's<br />
appeal to the Colonies to avoid dIscriminatory legislation,<br />
10 the interests of the Empirp, will only fall on deaf ears.<br />
The Hindu (Madras) writes as follows on India's<br />
attituile on the Sonth Afrlcau Indian question :-<br />
Tae immediate point we in India have to considpr is<br />
as to the attitude whICh we should assume towards Soutb.<br />
Africa. The Government of India have proved themselves<br />
to be a broken reed, and statesmanship has 80 far<br />
deteriorated that even the bold gestures of former Viceroys<br />
in favour of India'! nationals have disappeared. This<br />
is due to many causes: our own disunion is one; the<br />
growin!!' racial bias of the bureaucracy is a most p1tent<br />
reason, and it is a fact which cannot be got over that<br />
nnle811 the Government of the country IS our own, we can<br />
do nothing effective to protect OOf conntrymen abroad.<br />
In the meantime, the Government should be constantly<br />
nsked to be up and doing; our repre~entatives cannot be<br />
tco vigorous and alert in bringing the ntmost poi!sible<br />
pressore to bear on the autboritles to stand manfully by<br />
the despised and persecuted {ndians in the Colonies and<br />
the DomlDions aod retaliate when persuation fads, as it<br />
has now so clearly failed.<br />
K. S. Roy has been elected President of the Bengal<br />
Legislative CounCIl, in snccession to Evan Cotton. The<br />
Election was noteworthy, says Reuter, in that Roy defeated<br />
the Swarajist candidate bJ1l~ v.~to 61.
enough, a,Dd it is as diffieult for an lndian to get out<br />
of the clutches o~ the Immlgration DeMrtme,nt ..<br />
once l!aving {lQt ill itt a[:l it iJ {Qr ~ fly tq ~M. sqt w \to<br />
spider's web; and the doors of justice are opened to<br />
him very sparingly. In the circumstances! alt,hou~h<br />
IeI.'II than a qua .. ter the maximum amount provided,<br />
would suffic~ for the eXpenlltlj (>f a detaiQ.~4 ~~r~QP'<br />
as melltitihe,d abov~, it i§ fe~r.ed t4~t lR e~-e:rcil!i~~<br />
th~ l\qthority ~ive~ to. ~i~ tp.e t.JD.W,igr-lttlQl1 ()ffi~r<br />
wiU nQ~ telI\pel' j\\st!~ wi~h mercy and the maxi.<br />
mum \l:qlount for deposit will be mad& iH mosll cases<br />
the mmimum; thus maldng it very diftlc;ult for ma~r<br />
and pl'8Otically impQs.!lible fur ~oor tndi~Q.1!I- tq h~~e<br />
their casllS hearq: be~Qr(l !.I, QQ\l,.r(,'t !\Jt)l.Cll!~h, ~!;ley ml\Y<br />
hav~ Q~eJ;!. wro~gJqlIi c1e~ll!ed. qr r~tflc~@~.<br />
~ectil)J). fift~ 9t 1ilie lliH amends the nld Aet by<br />
grl!.Q~ing the right of appeal Hom the decision of a<br />
SuPreme Ceur4 on any question of law ~ril;lil\g upon<br />
an ap~eal heaPd br !\ boar\! to the {\:p!i'~U!\t~ l)\vjil~QU<br />
of the Supreme Q()\'F~. w.\lkb i~ Q ~~n to th~<br />
community. -<br />
There is venom again in Section sixteen of the<br />
Bill. J,~ aq~s \!') pa.ntgFaph (a) o:tl sub-section m of<br />
Section (4) of the pld Act the words: .. Provjde~<br />
that £01' the purpose of thlf~ sectW!!: th~ NQrthe,u<br />
Districts oj Nal:.al ..... sh~ll De Q.e~ed t~ be l~cluf (In\fY may<br />
IT U!e 4ffi\s ttesm'v~\ioq and Iwmlgratiol) and be forbtllueft b, the ~iq\§t@l"s Bpe!Q131 PQwtr from<br />
Registra~ion ( Further Provisiqn) Bill and explained<br />
lengthily how the first chapter of the Bill, be restricted by the existing law which forbids hi~<br />
exercising that right and a Transvaal Indian would<br />
deaU!lg w~tb th~ r~s~rvi!.tiQn of class areas, would to enter Nat~!. Till!! i!i M it a.ffects tho.se that are<br />
aff~~ 4!Uatl{!j!. 1n this issue we will eI\fje\l-vour ttl Q1!t~iqe t40f;1t\ :Pijltricts. Now eJ-a{Tliniqi; tbOBo tAut<br />
show to our readers what ruinous effect the amendments<br />
to the Immigrants Regulation Act, 1913, as' be precarious. Unless they hold the right to resiue<br />
are within those Districts, their position seems also to<br />
proposed in chapter II of the Bill wQqld h~ve 011 if) bo$ the ff()vinces- and many of them do<br />
Indians domiciled and otherwise in the Union or not-will also, very likely, be knocked from pillar<br />
any Province thereof.<br />
t6 post. Thus, It is indeed a very clever device on<br />
T.t!~ Qlq \~c,t provides ~ar tl\e (lsMsit qf lID th~ P~ft of thQ~~ reapoQ!lible for d",f\in~ tbi~ Bill<br />
axpOllI\t s.u@t!i,en,t ~1f t4_ 6piZlWP- oj t4f ~b.m~t", to (l~termiQatt\ "any llel'Son 0. olaas of persota at<br />
by a Nl'sqa restricted as a prohibited immigranl, ile.emed by the Minister to be unsuited from th~se<br />
should he wish to appea! to a board, to cove,r' Pistl'icts whieh are oomprise~ of to thE) District or<br />
his detention expenses, the costs of bringing him Vr¥p'ei(i, the 1)istrict of Utr~c\l.t, 1,\ portioq Qt the<br />
before a board and of returning him to the plac~, l>i!l\:rict of Walrke:rstrooIl\ lyillg I!ou\ll of 1\ lille<br />
fram whicB he came. The neW Bill would amend dra.Wll fr~ tpe ~Ql'~}l-e!\~~epn corllel' nf Natal, EaiIt<br />
this provisiop. br a~tqorililJng ~h~ iIlllA!ro-ation 9.fti.~r .f VolkBl'uet ttl the headwatel'i of the Pongolo Rive.<br />
to fix the amollnt to be deposited by !iiicp. ~ Ilpo.seq ~qqitiQ~<br />
would be that a persQ:p. tP.ol!~b dQl,ll\c\leq \n :Na.ta1 and<br />
by virtue of that right may be en1iitle-ther purposes but<br />
for the purpose of this 8echon, still belon_g to :N~~l in<br />
term~ Qf .. The ~ ortb,er!J. pif;1tricts AnJ;W~\l.tion .l\ct,<br />
1903," :m~Y' J}.P. el}\er t~eEe Distri~s if ~e is "deemed<br />
by t1Le Mini!!1ie~ t9 ~ ~"sm.teq W the r.equir.ements u<br />
qf the NotiQ~ ill ~ foU(lws:-<br />
"tJuder tlle puwera cOl\f~\'r¢ o~ {Il~ by pan graph<br />
(ll) of s\lb-~iioQ (1) Qf .e0tion fou, of the Immi.<br />
~rl\l\tIl RegulaU6,ft Aet, llna (Act N0 22 of 191.3), I<br />
4e~by deem ev6PY Asiatic person to be unsuit,ed on<br />
economic ground!!<br />
1. to $e rl¥ltlir~w.{lu\~ of th.1l Upion llI\d<br />
2. to tlw TeQui,r~:r;qeJ\t.6f of CO~lq~ree ha.v.e protested against<br />
the action of th~ COUIl,l!il iQ introduciI\g t~e I;!.b~ve<br />
Draft Ordin~nce w~thoqt giving tQ tho~ wbol\\ it is<br />
going to affect \l:n opportupity ~f stUdying t~~<br />
measure.
AugU~~.:'2Ist. 1925 INOIAN OP1N10~ ~o9<br />
------------------,------------~--------------~~<br />
EMPIRE TRADE AND. JAPANESE<br />
COMPETITION<br />
hmu's RIGHT TO FIgCAL AUTOXOMY<br />
In an address before the Manchester Chamber of<br />
Commerce recently, Sir Maneckji Dadabhoy expressed<br />
the opinion that England was slowly moving<br />
towarcis a protectionist policy and asked why<br />
India ehould not be allowed to select· a pohcy in<br />
wtich she believed with the same freedom. He dId<br />
not mean that India's commercial policy should be<br />
directed against Britain'. intereBts, It was rather a<br />
tnatter of muttlal effort fo". mntual benefits. Britain<br />
certamly had rights, which he thought IndIa ought<br />
and would recognise, but, India ehould be in a position<br />
also to protect her right.<br />
The maintenance of- the cotton excise duty was<br />
not of the slightest advantage to Manchester. The<br />
removal would not harm Manchester. There was<br />
no real competitiol) between India and Manchester.<br />
The real competition was between India and Japan,<br />
and possibly AQ1erica. The menace of the Japanese<br />
competition, not only in India but in the world,<br />
was very serious.<br />
Referring to Imperial Preference. he sugge!lted<br />
abolition of the 3 per cent. excise duty' and increase<br />
of Customil import duty on all foreign cotton goods<br />
to 20 per cent. and reduction of duty on British<br />
goods to 7 1-2 per cent.<br />
Sir Maneckji Dadabhoy suggested that Britain<br />
must redoce the cost of production in order to meet<br />
Japanese cotton trade compptition,<br />
Mr. J. H. Rodier, Chairman, Indian Section of the<br />
Chamber, declared if in order to cheapen production,<br />
the standard of living of worker~ in England must<br />
be reduced to the standard of Japan. England would<br />
prefer to lose its preponderance of cotton trade.<br />
LORD BIRKENHEAD'S INDIAN POLICY<br />
•<br />
We do not think that Lord Birkenhead is a teetotaller<br />
and the proper thing to do is perhaps to dismiss<br />
his latest post-prandial effusion on Indian<br />
affairs as the outcome of a man who had dined not<br />
wisely bnt too well. No edncated Enghshman in<br />
his sober senses would claim, as the Secretary of<br />
State is reported to have done, that "we went to<br />
India centuties ago for cQmposing with the s1 arp<br />
edge of the sword differences which would have<br />
submerged and destroyed Indian civilization." This,<br />
as a piece of history, is such a palpable fiction that<br />
It is impossible to believe that Lord Birkenhead was<br />
responsible for his words when he spoke them, if<br />
he did Ilpeak them. 'rhe English. as every schoolboy<br />
knows, came as tradt'rs to India and not as<br />
champions of Indian civili.lation. The Ilword whose<br />
sharp edge helped them to found an Empire was not<br />
theirs but that of Indians. It is the same sword<br />
which helps them to retain Inqia, and when India<br />
elects to wield it herself, Lord Blrkenbead cannot<br />
and dare not refuse to snrrender to her what is hers.<br />
We can, therefore, interpret his lordship'S words<br />
only as intended as a snub to those in this country<br />
who have made non-violence the basic principle of<br />
their mode of acquiring Swaraj. There are worse<br />
things than anarchy. and if India is to be ruled by a<br />
succession of political adventurers from London, the<br />
limit most soon be overtaken. Whether Lord Birkenhead<br />
was quite responsible or not when he made<br />
this insulting, insolent and mendacious speech. he<br />
h.\S forfeited every claim to the rpspect of Indians,<br />
and ~Ir. Baldwin will be ill-serving the interests of<br />
Britain and India if he does not find some sphere<br />
for him where his peculiar talents may be less mischievously<br />
employed.' Lord Birkenhead evidently<br />
wants to start a camp.tign against students who, he<br />
declared, were the principal enemies of the Empire<br />
whether in China, in Egypt or in IndIa •. " Something<br />
must be wrong with an Empire which has incurred<br />
the hostility of the flower of the youth of these<br />
three ancient and civihsed countrielil.-Tha IndllJn<br />
&ci4l Re/ormer.<br />
===~=<br />
THE PRICE OF FREEDml<br />
[By MR. C. F. ANDREWS IN .. YOUNG INDU."]<br />
There are certain things that are ofwn said ·in India,<br />
which are most distressing to hear. One of the<br />
saddest of these is to hear. from the lip!! of youn~<br />
men. words, spoken in despair, in some such aocents<br />
as these.<br />
" We are a subject people; and the subjectIon<br />
of centuries, un
.. # • ../'<br />
210 INDIAN OPINION August 2 ItS, 1925<br />
,<br />
There is Ii -story thnt reveals to us something of ers with all my' heart before I went away, givinl-(<br />
the secret of t'he inner greatness of these two races, them God's blessmg.<br />
which came all the way from Asia centurIes ago, No price can ever be too lllgh for Ruth a tl'easure '<br />
and are now among the most enlightened and progressive<br />
people in the world. In the time of the unablp to rise again! The greatest and noblest part<br />
No man, or peopl(;', can ever be so f.tIlen ail to be<br />
C~ars of Russia, a stranger was once talking with a of the price, which we all have to pay is this,-to<br />
school master about Russia's latest attempt, under keep our faith in God pure and bright. even when<br />
the Czar, to crush the spirit of Finland.<br />
we are in the depths of humihation .-<br />
The school master smiled, and said, qUIetly, that " He raiseth the f,lllen out of tbe UUtlt.<br />
it could not possibly succeed. He seemed absolutely To set him among Princes." I ,<br />
confident about it, as though it needed no argument<br />
to prove this point.<br />
i~~EC!E~'~~~N=:~E~;~»'»»>!<br />
" Why not ?" asked the friendly stranger, "RUSSia<br />
is all powerful."<br />
~ [ FROM OUR OWN CORRESPONDENT ] ~<br />
"But we are more powerful sbll," said the schoolmaster.<br />
\We make guns, and very big guns, here, o~(~E~«(~~~)~)~)~)~~~~~o<br />
\Ii 2:3rd July, 192.3. ~<br />
in this neighbourhood. We have an important<br />
arsenal and foundry. Haven't you seen it ? Come<br />
DR. GYE AND RESEARCH WORK<br />
with me and I 'will show it to you.<br />
The discoveries of Dr. Gye and Mr. Barol.trJ in<br />
The stranger was greatly surprised and went With the field of Cancer research are athacting worlJ-wide<br />
him. It was noon-day and the little children were attention. Dr. Gye startej life as a railway porter<br />
coming happily out of school.<br />
and worked his way to Edinburgh Ulllversity where<br />
"There !" said the Finn, pointing to the National he did well m his mediCal studies-taklll/.( his<br />
school. "That is our foundry, The great guns of degrees in due cOUl'se finiohmg up with the ~L D.<br />
bur country are 'progress and humanity.' We teach<br />
these to our children in their own mother-tongue,<br />
in these schools, which we support with our own<br />
money. No tyranny of any Emperor can ever stand<br />
against such wpapons as these."<br />
In the winter season, 1\'here there is little work to<br />
be done in the fields, classes of older people are<br />
liegree which he took in a year lI1steau of two years<br />
as is usual wlth most students after the completion<br />
of their M. B. course. HIs struggles to keep himself<br />
Oll ten shillings a week, sounds like a fairy story.<br />
This was, of course, in the days before the wflr.<br />
No less romantiC is the hfe stury of his co-worker<br />
Mr. J. E. Barnard. Mr. Hamard is head of the wellknown<br />
fil'm of hatters who bear his name, It is<br />
held in Finland and Esthonia. Handicrafts are<br />
taught. Reading and wrItmg are imparted to any the leisure from his work, every mmute of it, which<br />
of those who had not been able to learn m their he devotes to scientific research. He is a hatter<br />
youth. At this time, also, works of mutual service because it gives him the means of livehhood. And<br />
and kindness are rendered. The young' help the that from hiS youth upwards he has been interested<br />
old.<br />
in science and is regarded as one of the greatest<br />
"You should stay over to-morrow," said a Finnish authorities on microscope work. He is a Fellow of<br />
host to a guest. "For to-morrow we have a strange the Royal Society.<br />
custom to show you."<br />
The particular experiments from which the diScovery<br />
has resulted have been carried out during<br />
The guest stayed to see this strange thing. Early<br />
in the morning, from every house in the village, the past two years at the 1\f11l Hill Labor.ltories<br />
neighbours came to help. All day long, they worked<br />
under the supervision of the Medical Resnarch<br />
together happily and joyfully, repairing the Fmish Council. Dr. Gye read a paper on "The Aetiology<br />
host's house, thatching the roof afresh, cleaning up<br />
of Malignant ,New Growths" before the British<br />
his whole courtyard, willIe the good wife prepared<br />
Medical AssoClation. There is- no present que;;tion<br />
the evening meal. By the evening, every possible<br />
of a cure for cancer, what has been done is to provide<br />
experimental eVidence which appears to justify<br />
neighbourly help had been rendered, and a festival<br />
was held in honour of the host and his good Wife.<br />
certain important conclusions as to the causatiOn of<br />
That was the strange custom. At another time, the<br />
Cancer, and these conclusions should be of immense<br />
same help would be rendered to some other peasant<br />
help in fighting the disease.<br />
in turn. The poorest man would receive the same<br />
Dr. Gye's experiments are strictly in harmony<br />
assistance as the richest. They did these acts of<br />
With the opmion which T!t~ Lflluet says represervice<br />
in the name of God, who loves rich and<br />
£ents the view of almost all the pathologists of<br />
poor alike.<br />
repnte. And it can still be said in the light of hlB<br />
investigations that the pretlence of an orgaUlsm by<br />
The Finnish host told hiS friend that they had itself cannot account for cancer.<br />
brought this beautiful custom all the way from What Dr. Gye appears to have established-that<br />
Asia with them, when they wert. pllgrims and there is 'I. virus so small as to evade the ordinary<br />
wanderers on their long journey. In those days to microscope WhiCh can be cultivated. ThIS virus<br />
render service in this way often saved whole families<br />
from destruction. All through the centuries of But a second specific factor obtained from tumour<br />
alone does not produce a tumour when injected.<br />
their persl:"cutlOn in Russia, they had kept this tradition<br />
sacred. They had faith in God.<br />
enables the virus to attack them transforming them<br />
extracts-ruptures the defences of the cells and<br />
When I was at Karimganj, in Assam, I saw<br />
different building: but the one that interested me<br />
most deeply was a long narrow hut made of mud<br />
and thatch with some adJoimng huts attached.<br />
into cancer cells. Further it is apparently established<br />
that the Virus mdY be obtainecl from any animal.<br />
The specific factor denved from the tumour extracts<br />
does not operate uLless applied to an animal of the<br />
There, a National School had been kept gGing with same species al'l that from which it is t.tken. Thus<br />
great difficulty and trouble year after year. In the to produce a malignant new gr'owth in a mouge it is<br />
afternoon I watched Ii f'pinning demonstration. It necessary to use the specific factor fr'oUl a mouse<br />
was evident to me that the teachers and children tumour in connectlOn with a virus whit h may co~<br />
knew their handicraft. There was a mutual bond from any animal. The speCific f.tctor taken from anything,<br />
but a mouse will be meffectlve. Tlte<br />
of affection between the teachers and pupils. Some'<br />
of the teachers had taken their degree at a University.<br />
but they were sharing a life of poverty way for a rapid advance in the lDveshgation of<br />
Lflllr,ef says that these disloveries have deared the<br />
together with their children. As I watched this cancer along entirely new but clearly defined lines,<br />
noble struggle, the words came to my mind, "Surely that the attack on the cancer problem which has<br />
this is the price of freedom." I blessed those teach-<br />
hitht'r to hafflell medical Sllence Will IJe brought to
August 21!>l, 1925 INDJAN OPINION 211<br />
a successful conclusion, that the new telhnical<br />
Jl1t~thods available will be applicable to research<br />
• alol1g' a whole enorWQUIi front, and that dllileasetl<br />
like meaRles, small pox, and EUcephalitis foot and<br />
mouth disease, and dog's distemper may yielrl their<br />
seC'rets to workers armed with these new methods.<br />
LoRD HEADIXG<br />
Lord Reading, the Governor-General of India<br />
with'Lady Reading left London this afternoon on<br />
their return journey to India.<br />
Mr. Baldwin and Lord Blrkenhead and other<br />
members of the Cabinet were at Victoria Station<br />
to see them off. Lord Heading interviewed told a<br />
local press representative, all that he could say was<br />
thnt he was to be going back to his work. He had<br />
had a nice holiday but beyond that he could say<br />
nothing.<br />
OWEN N ARE~ ON RANJI<br />
Owen Nares one of England's leading actors, in<br />
his autobiography speaks thus of the great Indian<br />
cricketter. That the 1:,'1'eat "Ranji" was always one<br />
of his idols in the cricket world. Recently he took<br />
his son David then aged nine to the Gentlemens<br />
versus Playel's match at Lords. They were standing<br />
talking to a friend when he beheld the portly figure<br />
of the Jam Sahib of Nawanagar, himself bearing<br />
down on them he said to his son with much excitement<br />
"look D,\vid that's "Ranji." His sou replied<br />
politely, "Oh is it!" not really appreciating the<br />
joyful moment, then to Nares surprise and pleasure,<br />
"Ranji" actnally came np to speak to his friend,<br />
thus he was pI'esenterl to "Ranji" and so was David.<br />
Of the two he says, David was far more calm than<br />
he was for it was a really great moment to him;<br />
lat(lr on he acMs D.lvid will remember it with pride.<br />
INDUSTRIAL CLOUD<br />
There is an industrial cloud h
Augu!>t 21St, 1925<br />
212 INDIAN OPINION<br />
• J...... 't ) ~<br />
( t I r<br />
South African. Directory<br />
OF INDIAN MERCJiANTS AND OTHERS<br />
BALFOUR. Tvai'll ~4:<br />
Vasthahl Hlra & Co.,<br />
Genenal Merchants & Produce Buyers,<br />
Box 56. StaW~n Street.<br />
Gam Adall,l/<br />
Bo'K 46. 'Phone 28.<br />
Also Branch at:<br />
Station Street. & Leeuwlaagte<br />
A. C. Moola,<br />
·Box 36 Tel" Mdola "<br />
Branch,: Reltfontesn via Grootvlel.<br />
Gam Omar & Co.j<br />
~ox 39 'Phone 54. Tel." Oroar."<br />
Abdool Canm,<br />
Box 27. Tel." Canm."<br />
GEDARMONT T'vaal<br />
M: Leonat,<br />
General Mefchant,<br />
ERMELO, T'vaal<br />
A. S. Dangor,<br />
General.Merchant,<br />
P O. Sheepinbor StatIOn.<br />
M. A. Jassaf, •<br />
'General Merchant,<br />
P. 0 Aitlstetdani<br />
r • .-,.,..~ 8 .-.,,,<br />
pR~YLINGSTAAD T'vaal<br />
0., L Janoo & Co.,<br />
Wholesale & RetaIl Merchant,<br />
SII ver liank, Box 12<br />
Ayab Suleman,<br />
An Kmds of Produce Buyer,<br />
Box 14<br />
HE'IDELB"QRG, 'Pvaal<br />
Kalyan Hlra,<br />
, 'FrUIt M~rchant, Box 9<br />
Dayal Kara,<br />
Gfeen Grocer & FrUIterer,<br />
Box 9.<br />
A. M. Bhayat,<br />
Box 9<br />
M A. Badat,<br />
Box 59. Tel "Bad at "<br />
ROLMDENE T'vaal<br />
I. M. Karoha,<br />
General Merchant<br />
PARDEKOP, T'vaal<br />
K. Desai,<br />
Box 18.<br />
prET RBTIEF, T'vaal<br />
F'i B'Jee,<br />
it. General M erchaot.<br />
M. th·."uoovaa,<br />
General Merchant,<br />
~O" 78. 'phone 18. Tel. "thoovan."<br />
A. M. Badat & Co.,<br />
Box 49 Tel. "Badat."<br />
'Essa Ayob,<br />
Box 67. 'Phone 66 Tel" Ayah."<br />
Ragha Bawa,<br />
Fruit Merchant,<br />
2duj Buger Street<br />
Datal Naratl & Co.,<br />
FrUit Merchant,<br />
Box 44 u6, Market Sheet.<br />
E. Osman & Co.,<br />
239, Buger Street.<br />
A E Pochee,<br />
Box 123 Tel. "Pochee"<br />
Latib Ostnan,<br />
199, Buget Street.<br />
M. D. Chaya,<br />
Box 95. Tel. II Chhaya"<br />
F. ¥amoojee,<br />
Box 27 Tel. "FMamoo)ee"<br />
V. Bhagwan,<br />
TaIlor,<br />
Box 8 I. 115, Market Street.<br />
Sodma,r Motl,<br />
Wholesale & RetaIl Merchant,<br />
II 5, Market Street<br />
Essop Ebrahim Omarjee,<br />
Box 200<br />
Tel. "Omar)ee"<br />
T. H Omar,<br />
Box 124, Tel." OlIlar."<br />
E. H. Abdoola,<br />
Box 53 Tel" Abdoola."<br />
Dayarafn Bhagwatl,<br />
Tailor,<br />
Box 44. Market Street.<br />
ValIebh Bhagwan,<br />
Tailor,<br />
Box 44. i 15, Market Street<br />
Devchand Dullebh,<br />
Tailor,<br />
Box 81. Market Street.<br />
- VOL1
~u'djant' ~piniolt<br />
No. 3S-VoI. XXIII. Friday, August 28th, 1925.<br />
-"'"<br />
1le,i."",ed at the G. P.O. as a Ncwspape.<br />
PaleR I'ou •••• ,.<br />
NATAL INDIAN CONGRESS<br />
A Meeting of Natal Indians to protest against the ASIATIC BILL will be<br />
held under the auspices of THE NATAL INDIAN CONGRESS at the Durban<br />
TOWN HALL on MONDAY, 31st August 1925, at 8 p.m.<br />
Indians from all parts of Natal will attend. Prominent Europeans will also<br />
.address the meeting.<br />
, .<br />
ROLL UP in your thousands and record your protest against the obnoxious BILL.<br />
AMOD BAYAT,<br />
President.<br />
v. s. C. PATHER & SORABJEE RUSTOMJEE. Joint hon. Secretaries<br />
tiU.I~ ~r..~~rt '!i1t~rtl ~l~~ ~~tll rll!larl\ Ql{l~l..fi ~h ~lhl<br />
~Ul~I1.b tJOa..fi ~l~ ~UH (3~l
INDIAN OPiNiON August 28th, 1925<br />
ASIATIC BILL AND IMMIGRATION<br />
N our last issue we examined a few of the secn<br />
- tions under chapter II of the Asiatic Bill deal<br />
~ ing with the Immigrants Regulation Act and<br />
pointed out how its effect would be if amended as<br />
proposed by the present Bill. We shall now examine<br />
the remaining sections.<br />
The Ne,w Bm pJ.'oposes to amend the old Immigrants<br />
Regulation Act by providIng that: Any<br />
person who has been convicted in any country of,<br />
inter aha, "any offence involving traudulent conduct<br />
in connection with any insolvency shall be a prohibited<br />
immigr¥-t. " While appreciating the anXIety of<br />
the legislators to prevent fraudulent insolvencies we<br />
must remark that the punishment for tlIe crime is<br />
entirely out of proportion. . Besides, puuishmet).t ~or<br />
such a crime ba~, already been provided for in tlIe<br />
existing insolvency laws Vl(hel'eby a pellson may not<br />
only be impri~ned but refused for ever the right to<br />
trade. We therefQre fail to see the necessity for this<br />
new ·provision, but for only one reason, and that IS to<br />
prOVIde means for some little pretext whereby an Indian<br />
could be got :t;~d of from this country. Any<br />
bdian found guilty of fraudulent insolvency, or of<br />
being conuected iJ;l auy way with such Insolvency<br />
will he hable to punishmel).t under the insolvency<br />
law, and also, by the proposed amendment, he will<br />
lose his domicile in this country and be deported.<br />
It is provided, further, in the o).d A.ct, that a pers.on<br />
max not he deemed to be a pr~hibiteQ. immigrant<br />
in the C~pe of G~od HQpe o.r Natal If, " b.elllg at the.<br />
commencement of this Act lawfully entitled to<br />
reside in any Province, " he shows or has shown that<br />
he is able to I?ass the edu.cation t~t a;I provided fQr.<br />
The new Bill would delete this clause, and the effect<br />
will 00 that no Indian ooing lawfully entitled to reside<br />
in any Province wIll be able to enter the Cape<br />
or Natal by the edp.patlOn t~st, and those who h
August 28th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 215<br />
~ection to be declare
INDiAN OPINION August 28th, 19~5<br />
assod~itiollS (lId not receIve the tlUPPOl't of the co Ill<br />
Illllnity.<br />
,:\11'. H. J\1. HOtls, presltlcnt of the ASH()(~I,\tlOtl \1,18<br />
m the chall'<br />
'Dll£ BURGER' ApPEALR FOH UNITI£D FRO~'l'<br />
An appeal for the bnrYlllg of the pohtJcai hatchet<br />
and for uniteu support of the Govel nment In the<br />
tace of the Asiatic menace IS made by Dw nUn!PI<br />
says the Johannesburg Shu, 'l'hls IS apI'op0t! of<br />
Dr. Malan's proposed AtllatIC legn.:latlOn whICh.<br />
says the NatIOnalist paper, should go far not on I y<br />
towards makmg" an end to [nrhamsmg of the<br />
Transvaal and Natal especial1 y, but also to lesRemng<br />
the AsiatIC danger To this end it IS sugge~tell that<br />
reform of the ,}'r,msvaal system of handing ont<br />
licences wholesale would be oj' great asSIstance.<br />
"That the Indmns, espeClally 111 the two pro<br />
V1Ol'e8 mentwned, arE' VIOlently opposmg the<br />
measure is readlly understood," says D,P BUff/el<br />
" We feel. however, that WIth tew exceptIOns the<br />
whole of the European populdtion is determmed to<br />
prevent that we should have a large ASIatIc popnlation<br />
along WIth a greclt l1c1trve populatIon OJ tlMt<br />
ASIatIC trade methodR and 80clal ~taJl(lanls hhonld<br />
permanently ll1fiUtnce onr country, ThIS 113 not a<br />
political matter. Further .lU(l closer study of Uw<br />
Bill milY pOSSlbl) snggest Improvements, ,mrl no<br />
matter from \\ hich party theIr origin, snggestlOIH;<br />
will surely reCeive SerIOUS consHleratIOl1. BIlt above<br />
~~o<br />
* OUR LONDON LETTER ~<br />
~ l ]
Augll"t 2Rth, 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
to the champlOn~hlp of the world. dud yet refu'"e lo<br />
ngh(othel's un the gr oun,1 ot colonr. Ii they do<br />
refuse, It w"luld bll [l tarce to c,Ill tbemspl ve~ worhleh,lmplOllS,<br />
EVIH,A ,I) A LA.'
218 INDIAN OPINION . August 28th, 1925.<br />
-COURA.GE<br />
[ By AMBER MAYO]<br />
He lived in a little Bengal village, this boy I am<br />
gomg, to tell you about and who was destmed to become<br />
such a power in the land of hiS birth through courage<br />
and determinatIOn.<br />
His Southern home was very dea~ to him with .its<br />
coral painted thatched cottages, Its fore8~8 whICh<br />
sheltered rare song bird~, Its mountams and fivers and<br />
lIttle cascades._ 'l'hey were his birthflght, hand~d down<br />
through the ages to him and all true sons of India. Had<br />
he not been so very clear-sighted and level-headed he<br />
might have been a poet. As it was his head. was too<br />
concermld WIth the welfare of his country and hIS race to<br />
let day dreams which alw~ys eminate from the heart, take<br />
precedence c'JI'er down right hard facts which had ~o be<br />
faced and fought out to the bitter end.<br />
I ndla had hiS heart, and so hiS head should be u~ed to<br />
the very best with whICh the Gods had blessed him for<br />
his country's welfare. He was wont to cry out Impatiently,<br />
when taxed with stubbornness.<br />
"How can you say you love a thmg ~nd .yet you<br />
neglect it and seek not its good. Such affectIon IS worthlass."<br />
You say we are a patriotic race, I say we ca~not<br />
be. Does patriotism mean casting aSide our ?~hgatlons<br />
to our own allowing the u~urper the prIVIleges we<br />
should glory ~n perpetrating ourselves. Is it patriotIsm<br />
to offer big money to foreigners to represent us, because<br />
we are so mdolent, or lack the courage of our Just convictious.<br />
"<br />
Of course he was very young when he spoke thus,<br />
and angur ~ould shine from his fine dark eyes, and scorn<br />
made the corners of his firm mouth droop unpleasantly.<br />
HIS fatber-a hard-headed businessman, With a large<br />
foreign connection, never troubled hImself beyond his<br />
bank sheets-all else could go to rot. "Every-day contentment"<br />
was his motto after business bours. Not an<br />
hbur's sleep did he miss on accouut of his country's<br />
credit or future. His father had been the same. "Why<br />
worry, we can pay some one to worry for us" had bee!I<br />
his cry. But there he proved hImself wrong. HIS<br />
grandson recogDlsed the error and deplored this state<br />
had come to pass.<br />
"No one can worry over ones own like orwself" replIed<br />
the hoy to his father one day. These people pr?<br />
mise because your money looks good to them. TheIr<br />
flattery IS a poor asset. They would promIse you the<br />
Rulershlps of the whole Solar System, knowing full ~ell<br />
how empty and impossible such promIses are. I beheve<br />
in deeds, proof, fatber, not mere words. The man who<br />
promised me something, would have to fulfil or get out."<br />
This boy had now reached manbood and natura]Jy~<br />
his father wished him to enter the firm.<br />
"When I ' cross the great dIvide' my son" be saId<br />
one day" the business will be yours, so I want you to<br />
enter the Counting House first. From the bankmg department<br />
you will go into the buymg and foreIgn trade<br />
but of course that will take time."<br />
" I should like to please you father very milch, and I<br />
Will do my utmost to do so, but my heart IS not mit. "<br />
He bad been denied nothmg, study and affection,<br />
sports and pleasure, of whi?h he had .had hIS share. A<br />
little pang shbt throu~h hIm. ConSCIence told him to<br />
hold firni but he had a deep affectIOn for his pareut and<br />
hated to dIsplease him.<br />
Let the" Just for to-day" policy was wrong of that<br />
he was certam. He believed in to-dalj, to-morrow and<br />
for ever. Only the weak cry out" Just for to-day" and<br />
Bit down and wait and grow lean in so doing. Each unit<br />
of us each alloted life has Its work to do, else why the<br />
prIvliegE' of hfe, of human affectIon, of God-fearmg<br />
which is denied to aDlmals and soulless thmgs. Should we<br />
not have been created just a stone, a stick, an inaUlmate<br />
thmg, had not a purpose heralded our birth. Life meant<br />
so much to this boy, It was truth and love and POSSIbilities,<br />
It was worlh1Vhtle.<br />
The fathe\ the - man of commerce, looked at hfe<br />
through different eyes. Selfish eyes they were but he did<br />
not realise it. The father was annoyed and troubled at<br />
his son's words.<br />
" And why pray is your heart estranged from honourable<br />
buslDess my son ?" he asked.<br />
" Forgive me father, but plea~e beheve every word I<br />
say "-he ranted and thpn,-<br />
" My English tutor taught me to write in my copvbook,<br />
over anil over agam the wods "Live and Jet Live,"<br />
and said" that was the SpIrlt whICh made Bnghnd'~<br />
standard so honoured the world over" I beheved him<br />
then, but amce, I have proved them t!) be mere blnff<br />
words of conCiliation and deceit. lYe in India and the<br />
East Let lwe at the cost of all we shonld hold dear. We<br />
are losing honour, the right of race, caste; we shall be<br />
a people without a countrv, scattered. Our l
~ ttllinn cepininu<br />
No . .;6-Vol. XXIII. Friday, September 4th, 1925.<br />
Re,istered at the G. P.O •••• News,."",<br />
Paloa ro" .... '.<br />
--4~--------------------------------------<br />
MONSTER MASS MEETING<br />
DURBAN TOWN HALL FOUND TOO SMALL<br />
1ll MONSTER Mass Meeting of Natal Indians<br />
&-U was helJ in the Durban Town Hall last<br />
Monday night the 31st August, under the<br />
auspicE's of the Natal Indian Congress to protest<br />
againilt thE' Asiatic Bill. There was a very large<br />
attendance and the meeting was representative of<br />
all sections of the, community including delegates<br />
from the different parts of the Province. The<br />
Hall was packed from top to bottom whilst an overflow<br />
meeting of 2000 Indians was held outside<br />
under the managemE'nt of Messrs. A. I. Kajee, G. M.<br />
Patel, and Satyadev, and other speakers from the Hall<br />
also addressed the gathering from the portico facing<br />
Church Street.<br />
Mr. Amod Bayat, Prellident of the Natal Indian<br />
Congress, was in the chair. and he was supported<br />
by a number of representative Indians and several<br />
prominent Europeans, including Mr. F. A. Laughton<br />
K. 0., Councillor the Rev. A. Lamont, Councillor<br />
Dr. Sage, the Rev. Father Mangot, the Rev. Father<br />
Tangnayt, Mr. Bell, Mr. and Mrs. Linder, Miss S.<br />
M. Warner, Miss E. Knudsen, Mr. Daltdn, Mrs.<br />
Hewett, Mr. Frank Acutt, Mr. S. S. Brisker,<br />
M.P.C., Mr. W. V. Webb, Capt. Elliot. Mr. H. R.<br />
Rudder, Mr. M. Levine, and Mr. Barnett. Among<br />
the native friends were present the Rev. J. L. Dube,<br />
and Mr. C. L. Dube.<br />
The Yen. Archdeacon Hodson M.A., who was to<br />
have addressed the meeting was unfortunately· laid<br />
up with an attack of influenza and was unable<br />
to attend the meeting.<br />
DELEGATES<br />
The following delegates were present at the meet<br />
ing:-<br />
PIETERMARITZBURG.-Messrs. R. B. Maharaj,<br />
8. R. Naidoo, M. I. Kajee, R. N. MoodlE'Y,<br />
Rosenkhan, I. A. Haffejee. Guljar- khan, F. H.<br />
Hallim, Noormahomed, S. P. Vather, J'arbhoo<br />
Makanjee, Madhev Kanjee, Kushal Hansjee, D.<br />
K. Soni, Amod Mahomed, Sacoor Mahomed, A.<br />
K. Osman. Ally Hassan, ~M. E. 'fajoodeen, Shaik<br />
Dawood, D. Fakira, Hoosen AIlybhai, 8. Madrai.<br />
M. Runga Nathan, Mabomed Ebrahim. Mabomed<br />
Ismail, M. Abdoolla.<br />
UMZIMKULU.-MeSSrs. ~I. D. Barmania, Shaikji.<br />
FRAsER.-Mr. M. N. Desai.<br />
VERULAM.-Mt'ssrs. Amod Kathrada, Maiter. R.<br />
Talwantsingb. Dhanji Ramji, C. E. Vawda, Parsee<br />
Hormusjee, Doober.<br />
-~RYHEID.-Mr. p, V. Henry,<br />
NEWC.olSTLE.-Mr. I. M. Maiter.<br />
LADYSMI'l'H.-Mr. R. Singb.<br />
COI.ENsO.-Mr. R. M. Mangal.<br />
HOWICK.-Mr. Ismail Kader Mia.<br />
RWHMOND.-ME'ssrs. Maglisingh, Mahomed<br />
Majam.<br />
THORN)'ILLE JUNC'l'IOr.-.-Mr. Vanker.<br />
STANG~R.-Mtcssrs. 1. M. Amin, Advocate B.<br />
Gabrie]'lfagan]al Pate], E. M. MoalIa.<br />
Natal Indians Protest Against Asiatic Bill<br />
TONGAAT.-Messrs. Ram Fakir, M. G. Naidoo,<br />
E. J. Choonoo.<br />
After the President had led the meeting in prayer,<br />
the 8ecretary Mr. S. Rustomjee, read a few of the<br />
many mE'ssages received from friends and sympathisers<br />
throughout the Union. (The messages appear<br />
in another column)<br />
THE PRESIDENT'S SPEECH<br />
The President's speech which was contained in<br />
seven type-written full-scap pages. explaining the<br />
terms and evils of the Bill, was then read by the<br />
Secretary MI'. Sorabjee Rustomjet'. (The full text of<br />
the speech appears elsewhere in this issue).<br />
The President's speech was translated by the<br />
Joint Secretary Mr. V. S. C. Pather in Tamil and<br />
by Pandlt Bhawani Dayal in Hmdustani.<br />
The President's speech was followed by<br />
MR. F. A. LAUGHTON'S SPEECH<br />
" I want to say to you in the fir15t place, .. said Mr.<br />
Laughton, " that when asked to address you here tonight<br />
I was greatly troubled in my mind. I have taken<br />
no part in publi..: affairs for a very considerable time.<br />
I am living in peace and quietness on the banks of<br />
the Umgem, and I felt that anything I might say<br />
would be open to misconstructlOn, and perhaps hurt<br />
the feelings of my fellow-countrymen. I therefore<br />
strenuously opposed coming here to-night and I can<br />
assure you it is only an absolute sense of duty to<br />
you and also to my fellow-countrymen which has<br />
overcome my disinclination. First let me say that<br />
I deplore as much as anyone that any Indians were<br />
bronght into this country. It has led to never-ending<br />
troubles in the past. There is a great cloud of<br />
trouble looming in the future which only wise<br />
statesmanship will overcome.<br />
" Years ago before almost anyone of you in this<br />
hall was born, the Government in their wisdom, or<br />
want of it, adopted the counsel of introducing your<br />
fathers and mothers into this country to meet a want<br />
in the labour market and Its ever increasing demand.<br />
011 applIcations from almost every section of the<br />
community thousands upon thousands of Indians<br />
were brought here.<br />
"Indian traders with the full dpproval of the<br />
Government followed and established themselves<br />
here. The result is that there are now upwards of<br />
140,000 Indians in Natal. three-fourths of whom,<br />
I am told, were born here. Here is<br />
A SERIOUS POSITION<br />
A serious position for this multitude of Indians and<br />
a st'dous position for the Europeans who find<br />
themselves in competition with Indians in most<br />
branches of industrial life. The position is rendered<br />
more complicated by the fact that the great majority<br />
of tht'Ele Indians have no other country but this. They<br />
"ere born here, and. look at the matter as we may,<br />
they al e British subjects and entitled to protection<br />
the same us we Europeans. It must also be borne<br />
\
220 INDIAN OPINION September 4th, 1925<br />
------------------------------------~--- ---------------<br />
in mind that the Indians have acqum'd much landed<br />
property in Natal, have established extensive bnflinesses,<br />
and many of them have contribute!1 largely<br />
to the rates ap.d taxes without having any voice<br />
whatever in legislation<br />
" Here is a soriou~ problem before us, a problem<br />
which gets more serions as the years go by. But<br />
there is a maxim in law that there is no wrong<br />
without a remedy, a fair aud Just remedy. so there<br />
is no political problem withont a fait· and just<br />
remedy if with all our hearts we truly seek it.<br />
A MONSTROUS REMEDY<br />
" To get rid of a man who IS a nUIsance, a very<br />
quick remedy would be to shoot hIm, but few would<br />
be found to say It was falr amI just. So to get rid<br />
of Indians $O~e have been found to advocate putting<br />
them on board of ShIPS, by the pollee I presume,<br />
and deport\ng them to J ndla. Apart from everything<br />
else, 'they would be strangers in a strange<br />
land. This would be almost as monstrous a remedy<br />
a..'l the remedy of shooting a man who IS a nmsance.<br />
Yet this is the remedy In effect advocated by the<br />
Minister who introduced the Bill befOl e 11S, because<br />
he frankly admIts that he expects the effect of thc<br />
Bill to be a large reduction of the IndIan populatIOn<br />
by making thIDgS so hot for them that they would<br />
be-compelled to go without the assistance of a policeman.<br />
FREEDOM THE GUIDING STAR<br />
Freedom has ever been the gmding star of English<br />
and Dlltchmen alike. It was for freedomfll agaInst<br />
the alleged delinquenCIes of the Cape Government<br />
that started the great trek into the wIlds of Africa<br />
WhICh fills us WIth admiration It was for freedom<br />
against the alleged oppressive acts of the late Transvaal<br />
Government WhICh led to the Boer War. And<br />
are we, the staunch advocates of freedom. about to<br />
become the oppressed? Are we going to allow<br />
history to repeat itself WIth ourselves as top dogs?<br />
OPPRESSIVE LEGISLATION NEVER SUCCEEDS<br />
"Mr. ChaIrman, are you surprIsed when I say<br />
that a sense of duty and nothing but a sense of duty<br />
to myself, to mv fellow-country men-both Enghsh<br />
and Dutch-calls me here to hold np It hand of<br />
warmng to the advance of oppressive legislatIon?<br />
A study of hIstory shows that oppressive legislation<br />
IDay take its course for a time, accompanied always<br />
by the groans of the oppressed, but III the end it<br />
never has, and never WIll be, successful. Let me<br />
remmd you that in the comparatively mmor matter<br />
of money we cherIsh the pnnclple. "No taxatIon<br />
WIthout representatIOn." AI'S we, after deprlvmg<br />
the Indians of any representation whatever, going<br />
to take away from thlOm all opportumty (If advancement<br />
and happmess in hfe? The IndIans have not<br />
even been brol; ght into frlendly dISCUSSIOn as to<br />
the prOVISIons of thll=l Bill. Here they are forcel!<br />
by an overwhelmmg tide into what they consluer<br />
the culminatmg calamIty of theIr lIves. It 19 true<br />
that the mimster, after saying that the Bill will<br />
certainly pass, and after saying m effect that he<br />
antIcipates that the provisions of the BIll will make<br />
it so hot for the Indians that their numbers WIll be<br />
considerably decreased, said that he was ready to<br />
receive the remarks of IndIans on the BIll. Is he<br />
likely to have any? After a murderer is found guilty<br />
the Judge goes through the formalIty of asking him<br />
if he has any remarks to make as to sentence bemg<br />
passed against him.<br />
SUGGESTION OF A BOARD<br />
" Sir, I wish you to understand that I have not<br />
expressed an opinion as to any portion of the Bill.<br />
Anything I have said III reference to the BIll has<br />
merely gIVen the view of the Indians concerning It.<br />
You may ask me what course in my opmion the<br />
Government should adopt, and I say to you that the<br />
Government should come mto conference with the<br />
Indians over this BIll, and l1('ar thf'ir objf'ctlOns so<br />
th.lt amendments may be HlMle. To tlo thIS a board<br />
say of three Europe.\n~, 811OUI!1 be appointed. One<br />
to repreRE'llt the VI('WS of Europeans. anotlH'r th'lt of<br />
the IndIans, and a third for an impartial chairuled, I kuo'w what It IS to
September 4th, 1925 INDiAN OPINION 22!<br />
opprNIHeol. My people have been oppn""eol an
222 INDIAN OPINION September 4th, l!l"S<br />
we" make of that gentleman? He al~o said he was prepared<br />
to meet., us, yet what IS the earthly use of meetmg<br />
us If he says definitely that this BJiI will go through?<br />
Can we honestly approach him to dlSCUS3 such a measure<br />
when he has made up his mind in adv,mce. I for one<br />
would refuse to discuss It wit h a gentleman hk~ Dr.<br />
Malan. I am not prepared to' make a fool of myself."<br />
In the end the speal(er s,ud they must interest themselves<br />
in this with double force and they must send this<br />
resolution through the Indian Congress.<br />
In secondmg the resolutions proposed by Mr.<br />
Godfrey, Mr. M. Beethasee, who spoke first in Hmdi<br />
and then in English said in the courde of his remarks<br />
that we (many of us) were born m this country, but<br />
had no political rights. We were restricted even<br />
to trade and our ProvlUcial ConncIl has even deCided<br />
not to spepd any more money on Indian education.<br />
The speak\lr favoured the suggestion of a round table<br />
Conference and said he was told by many Enghsh<br />
people: "We are sons of England. We are watching."<br />
That at least, said the speaker, was some consolation.<br />
Mr. M. D. Barmauia (Amzimkulu) spoke in<br />
support of the resolution in Gu)arati and Mr. S. R.<br />
Naidoo (Maritzburg) m Tamil and before the resolut~on<br />
could be put to the meeting.<br />
THE FIRST DISCORDENT NOTE<br />
was sounded in that peaceful and enthusiastlc meeting<br />
by Mr. J. L. Roberts who proposed the following<br />
amendment to the resolution already tabled :--<br />
"That it is the considered opimon of this mass<br />
meeting of the Natal Indians assembled that an<br />
emphatic protest must be made agamst the obnoxious<br />
iniquitious, unjust and un-British new ASiatic Bill<br />
introduced by the Hon. The Minister of the InterlOr<br />
in the last session of Parliament by the four Indian<br />
political bodies, viz: The Natal Indian AssociatlOn,<br />
The Natal Indian League, The Colonial Born Indian<br />
Association, and the Natal Indian Congress, after a<br />
round table congress between them to weIgh the pros<br />
and cons in the matter and to take the necessary<br />
steps to bring about sobd unity amongst the Indian<br />
community as a. harmonious whole, and to fight the<br />
common opponent in the coming life and death<br />
struggle for our very existence in thiS, the land of<br />
our birth and adoption and to demand our rights as<br />
Briti'lh citizens unitedly."<br />
Mr. Roberts made a dramatic appeal to his<br />
audlence when speakmg on his motion, He said.<br />
he had come there that night as a Natal Indian<br />
and as a South African, and he asked them to gIve<br />
him a fair hearing. The second resolution spoke<br />
about a round table conference. They wanted a<br />
round table conference' amongst themselves before<br />
they had a round table conference wlth the Europeans.<br />
He had not come to antagonise the<br />
commumty. He had not come there to obstruct,<br />
but to assist if necessary. He dId not want to take<br />
up their tlme, and he would add this as a rider<br />
provided the seconder and proposer of the resolution<br />
agreed.<br />
Mr. Roberts had made a very lengthy appeal<br />
but he was so moved with emotion and indignation<br />
that most of what he spoke could not be<br />
understood.<br />
No assent was given and MI.'. Roberts then put<br />
his proposition as a formal amendment.<br />
It was seconded by Mr. Casim Anglia who made<br />
an eloquent-appeal in Hindustani.<br />
Mr. J. W. Godfrey as the mover of the motion<br />
in the course of a lengthy explanation denied most<br />
emphatically the suggestion that there was disumon<br />
in the community and warned the audlence agdmst<br />
approving of the proposed amendment for If they<br />
did, !!aid the speaker. they would be sowing the<br />
firil~ ,Seeds ,of d1i~gord hi tli~ Indiari cOf'1mlltlity.<br />
J!,tttl~1 ',Ilt i i \l!lAt~1 til ,Jdl\"I,' WI/'j d T J ,~'\Ib 'ttl f 11.1 I<br />
f~$~It:;a ~ ~U:.i:* ~w~ ~.tit't ~~~" itffMI ~Nrf,1tf<br />
to interfere with the legitlln:l.te work of the Ndtal<br />
Indmu Con~ress.<br />
Mr. D S, Chetty, Secl'etary of the Colonial-born<br />
Indian Assocl
_~ep~e_mber<br />
4th, 1925 ____ I_N_D_l_A_N--,-O_P_IN_IO_N _____--::.'____<br />
2_2=.3_<br />
~ther like one man and make, Congres:i a snCC8d8.<br />
I have Dlllch hope and pray the great Allah will<br />
help us. "<br />
TRAN8V AA L URITI'"lH ISDIAY A '"I'IOCIATIOY<br />
t. At a mas:J meeting of Transvaal Indians held<br />
resterJay the follOWing r~olntJon WMf nnanimoll'lly<br />
pasiled: t That this ma~ meeting of Transvaal Indians<br />
hereby strongly support the Natal Indian Congref18<br />
in its protest agalUllt the Asiatic Bill which is<br />
outrageous, iniquitous, degrading and most inhuman.<br />
Transvaal Indlalls strongly proteilt ag.linst Slme ...<br />
THe UHITl~R IYDIAY COUSCIL (CAPETOWN)<br />
.. WIshing Congress every snccess. CounCil behind<br />
you wholeheartedly. "<br />
PnOFE3soR THAELE (PRE'IIDEN'f AFRICA!II<br />
NATIONAL CONGRES")<br />
.. The African National Congress 1U the Western<br />
r.-ovince standt! in realline8s to support you ...<br />
THE INDIAN STUDENTS (FORT HARE)<br />
"Birthright negatived by pro po 'led leglslatlon.<br />
A~ept no second place amongst other commuUlties.<br />
Strongly support protest and opposition to ensure<br />
its rejection. "<br />
THE PATlDAR SOCIETY (TRANSVAAL)<br />
"Heartily supporting prote'lt against Asiatic ,BIll.<br />
In :lians must be ready for a big sacrifice to oppose<br />
the 13ill. "<br />
Messages were also l"eceived from the following<br />
Transvaal Hindu ASSOCIation, the Transvaal Colonial<br />
Born Indian ASBociation,CasslID Adam, Pretoria,<br />
Transvaal Mamom Association, Transvaal Anavil<br />
Mandai, Middelburg Indian AssoClalion" Transvaal<br />
Tamil Benefit Society, Vereenigmg British Indian<br />
ASSOCIation. Potchefstroom Association. Northern<br />
TI-ansv'lal Indian Association; Pretoria British Indian<br />
Association, Kanamla Muslim ASSOCIation,<br />
Pretoria; Pretoria Islamic Society, Transvaal IslamIC<br />
Congress, Young Muslim Association, Johannesburg,<br />
Zeerust Indian Committee, Koster Indian comumunity,<br />
Ermelo Indian community, Blremhof IndIan<br />
community, TransvJal Darjee MandaI, B.llfonr<br />
Committee, Transvaal Indian Football Asso~1dtion;<br />
Breyten community, Carolina community. Springs<br />
Association, Witbank Tamil Benefit Society, SoLlha,<br />
Johannesburg; Piet Retief community, Bethal Association,<br />
Ventersdor(ycommumty, Lichtenburg community,<br />
Grey town community, Brits Moslem Society,<br />
Por~ Shepstone, Frere, New Hved a tremend ... us<br />
triumph of organisation, and the Sp'lUSOI"S are to be congratulated<br />
0'] the splendid fa~hlOu in wluch it was orj{anilled.<br />
Despite the huge cro.vdl! who clAmonred for<br />
admlssj('n there was no overcrowdl'1~ whatiloever, a'ld the<br />
few Europeans whoa'tended weri! tr~ated With the utmos~<br />
c'lurtesy and consl ieration. All speakers were Itstencd<br />
to qUIetly alld attentlvelv. EVidently the most unlettered<br />
of tho3El pre,ent realised I he nece3sIty ror upholdin 17 the<br />
status of bis ra~, an I responded accordingly. "<br />
•<br />
Notes and News<br />
AST Monday mght's protest meeting, held<br />
under the auspICes of the Natal Indian Congress,<br />
which had caused a t!reat deal of<br />
IL<br />
anxiety to the organism's who had to work against<br />
many odds vwing to the fact that there is an ehment<br />
at present m Durban which dehghts 10 smashmg up<br />
the good work done in the mterest of the commulllty,<br />
has proved to the hilt the very representative character<br />
of the Congress aud it has also proved that<br />
when the hour of trail comes the Indian community<br />
is clpable of rising to the occasion These are<br />
bmes when thiS spirit Will have to be kept ever<br />
awake. As Dr. Malan has said. the Bill will go<br />
through. so must the community reply mostemphatically<br />
that they will fight it through. While we are<br />
hopeful that wiser counsel will prevJ.II and the<br />
LegIslators Will not take the drastIC step proposed it<br />
Will. nevertheless. be wise for us to be preparell for<br />
the worst.<br />
The work of org.lnismg the abo-ve meeting was<br />
in the hands of a Bub-committee consisting of Messr3<br />
V. Lawrence, A. I. Kaje(', Satyadev and Messrs V.<br />
S C. Pather aud SorabJee Rustomjee (Jt. hon.<br />
Secretaries of the Natal Indian Congress) together<br />
With the able assistance of Advocate ?lfr. J. W. Godfrey<br />
who hds recently opened offices 10 Du~ban .. nd<br />
has proved an asset to the local IndIan commnnity.<br />
The Committee was at work during the whole of<br />
last week daily until late
k ['he ,fourth Qlllliv.ersary of the o.pening of the M.<br />
lK.r ,,000dJh,h ,i.ib.ral"\V > andl FarseeliRdatomjee- Hall is to<br />
~ke~,'J,l~e, ,.()npWedilIesdq8,next rthe,: 9th· mstant.<br />
-!J(b.~rJl~· i~ Ir.)O (dQUlllll- ,that, rUm young as well as old in<br />
-J)UtbanrulQ .olfu1ide; Durban:.BaNenvery greatly benefitted<br />
by this most useful:institutitm which is the<br />
:iWQrk:;Of :.tihe{i late 1l3ai,iJ eJ!bai~ ,Rustomjee I Trust •. Mr.<br />
IR3Ilsee ,B.uet9DJjee"'\Yaf!l~he ,hea,tt and'sou}of this<br />
i~nstituti'lli :whew he , W.aB living and each anniversary<br />
d\'IlMJJJ1f1le"brated:,1Withl'greit Jenthilsiasm;, : .This "year<br />
71lhjJ-...ilWinrsarly.~ln.Or..donbt be: tlre,gIoomiell for,the<br />
'absence of the late Mr. Rustomjee. It is ne~ertheless<br />
. the' ,jacr.ed, ~utst oft evky, Jnaiarr in Durbati to<br />
linteres.li. hims.elf in this institl1tion,i 1.f not for 81nytbing<br />
else, to perpetuate the memory of the .late M~. ,<br />
,Rlilloo,mJeef'ilM. ,.P~9:d W'lt.l :only_, done . -great ser-,<br />
J{iotl9rio:cJthe 'OOIDIl\unity' during J.lis..-jife ,time .but<br />
lit fttiU ser'Vi~g, the con:tJn,urlityr in. spirit through t.Jn3 :<br />
~nstilt]jlti(}n.f,\We hope, the-·;..aIlniversary, will.oo'.a<br />
"I'IWleJi!$£u~ l.one anQ' ilfhaJi1 it ,wi1l bave man~ more<br />
lInM .anniversaries. J - I . : .: ... " :<br />
I I '-I I 1 I.. Ii f t ~~ \<br />
I,' THl!J PRdT~ST 'MEETING !<br />
1\1 'tL thQ(i;lfi;,o -~I1(~E! :"'~tn~~~4 ~~e~ lIJ.eeting oj.<br />
Lf'll Natal Indians held last Monday night in the<br />
Durbari-TownHalCundeTf"@ auspices of the<br />
Natal India~9,P~ss ~8.l'ote!jj~f~¥f the Asiatic<br />
13ill will ha';e to adID.it wltiloutilie ieast bit of hesihlm0n<br />
,!;thlitl 'the Id01:liisiOn? .'30 'lltriE(m; 1lM, TIle<br />
iik1l!may lliavel;oo ~a"-y ~'al'i tJ6~sioft1lbl:len: '()ro~<br />
11 A~ ~tm~,~~-c~r~~~~ .~~ If c i~s~' 9~)~,~V ~~g~t, ilw<br />
jW·~~~\le" Pl-'~, ,Mv,~ r9Jt P11t~y~~: Phlp,a~~ql;l lhl1l!R<br />
~? ~~~~~:t? ~~~m ,a' 4~,,,-~;W~9~'-!lr"J ~g!'l' ,aI', Ith~<br />
:rQw'~ ~UctQ J)E!) inJC';\ap!).bl~".I)f r3(Xlomnitldating:. il;· JaB<br />
itrwaa,:Gni ltha-t?nigh:t, -bn1r neVer ;&ave lW'~ at' any tim.e<br />
~ ~i~~,8~~dl~, (f~rlJ~,~~, iI!i~~i~? . ~~¥p€!~,~~ i~f9~i!~~<br />
JrfoiS!~y.~~ so PY,~t;:§!8Wli~.ti ~~ 1\1'~ ~p~g1l-Y'1I mer~l.~,<br />
'~9\" ~~~e~!!~4" S!l$l},1-' I' llWflIMy;w, rn¥e,r r'S~!~:pf<br />
,c!rc,lL~s~Jl.~' )CQp.\tucte4 1\0 r, p.ea,e~ull}1, ~m1y<br />
-andr~ith ~bose sYtnpa~hy we<br />
;:v.erfl~lll~,tQ ~mllllt(, ~b,e .R~v. ~mo.D.t.though ,btiug<br />
I lu.ta.unch,su.pportel' of the present ,Government- on<br />
almost every question except the Indian. queatiol'l,"<br />
hoped that,' tlie ]Jill :Woo'Id not be- 'pass\.>d, for it<br />
-\VtiV Id fjarpetnte :aldnjuSlliae.' , 1. ' ,; ,<br />
,. 'fha Rev."'\1dhIf L; Dube sympathised ~tr tpe<br />
cause of the Indians on behalf of the Natives. ,The<br />
.~a,~r~s, B.l!id ':ip.e' ,$p~~:Jt!3tJ '~~~f' ~ ',s~~~r W~pr. in<br />
~!l~tl,C~~ fI"1?1fl t):t~ R~~sep~rqO-S;Elr,l).lgeq~'f'P~r~'Y h~<br />
f/jl9. frj~nfi~ -W IWP.k t.
t~~ pref~.~ ~~'W'f;S8, ~,c It
226 INDIAN OPINION September 4th, 1925<br />
was very indistinctly heard, was understood to say<br />
that as an appeal by the Indian gaoler was pending<br />
It would be undesirable to enter mto any dl8cussion<br />
• of the details of the evidence produced in the case<br />
or of the inferences whlCh might be drawr. from<br />
them. It was ObVIOUS that the findmgs of tb.e Court<br />
were disquieting, and, whether or nol they were<br />
materially modified as a result of the appeal, it was<br />
clear that the matter reqUIred, and would certainly<br />
have, thelcJosest conslderatior. by the local Government,<br />
the Government of India, and the Secretary of<br />
State in Council. .<br />
The motion was by leave Withdrawn.<br />
CONGRESS PRESIDENT'S SPEECH<br />
The fol\owing is the full text of the Pre:mlent's<br />
speech read at the Town I-hll meeting last Mond,LY<br />
lllght,-<br />
Friends antI FeUow-Conntrymen,-We are assembled<br />
here to-night in our thousands as a first<br />
step to protest against the Areas Reserva.tion and<br />
Immigration and Registration (Further Provision)<br />
Bill popularly known as the AsiatIc Bill which is<br />
now before the Union Pa.rliament of South Africa.<br />
• It is a matter for great concern to us that a<br />
responsIble Minister of the Government has deemed<br />
it proper to refer to us as aliens and he said so<br />
becau~1'l there were many characteristics in which we<br />
differ from members of hiS race. For this reason<br />
he stateI'; that the Bill under conSideration IS necessa.ry<br />
His argument is both illogical and contrcl.uictory<br />
because he exempts the Mauritiau Creole8, St.<br />
Helenas, the Cape Coloureds, the Ca.pe M
Septem':>er 4th. 1925 INDIAN ()PINIO:-': 227<br />
the hE'rding 'Of human bE'ings with nndesirabl~<br />
conseqnencE'S of gr('3ter impoverishmt"nt. insanitation.<br />
ill-health and over-population.<br />
The Bill interferes \vitb private prQPE'rty. Indians<br />
are being deprived and are restricted directly or indirectly<br />
of their existing inherent rights as British<br />
sl1~jectll, and also in breacb of 88811ran
"S!'2'S<br />
Sefitember., 4th, 1925'.
~vinion<br />
Regl.tel'ed at .be G.<br />
No. 37-Vo1. XXIII. Friday, September I,th. 1925. p.o. u aM.,.... ..<br />
Puc. roo.pOl(..<br />
NATAL INDIAN CONGRESS<br />
ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING<br />
Committee's Report and Statement<br />
THE fol1owing is the full text of the report<br />
11 submitted by the Secretaries of the Natal<br />
Indian Congress at its general meeting h('ld<br />
in Rawat's Bio Hall, Durban, last Sunday the Gth<br />
instant :-<br />
We beg to submit herewith our report of the<br />
working of your Conyress since the last Annual<br />
General 1tfef'tinu which was held on the 2nd ~f<br />
March 1924. The periml undel' review is a very<br />
interesting one as many important matters were<br />
dealt with by your Congress. Among others we<br />
may mention the following whi.Jh are of special<br />
interest to you and the general Indian public :-<br />
MRS. SAROJINI N AIDU'S VISIT<br />
Our illustrious visitor, Mrs. Sarojini Naidu was<br />
invited by the Traosvaal British Indian Association<br />
to come to Bouth Africa while she waR in British<br />
East Africa attending the East African Indian Congress<br />
in Conference. This invitatiol! was accepted<br />
by her. The arrangements for her tour in the diStricts<br />
of Natal were in the hands of your Congress.<br />
Mrs. Naidu first entered the Province of Natal on<br />
the 9th day of March 1924 and from that day onwards,<br />
your Committee were incessantly organising<br />
meetings throughout Natal all of which were well<br />
attended. There were 7 meetings held in the Durban<br />
Town Hall at which Mrs. Naidu delivered lecilu('s<br />
011 Buch subjects as .. Ideals of Indian Life,"<br />
.. The Brotherhood of Islam" etc. She also spoke<br />
on the Class Areas Bill, the ultimate fate of which,<br />
you all know. During her stay in Natal, your Congress<br />
organised an Indian Agricultural and Industrial<br />
Show which was opened by Mrs. Naidu. This<br />
matter will be fully dealt with at. a later stage. A<br />
farewell blLnquet in her honour was held in the<br />
DrilllIall on the 24th day of May lU2-1 where<br />
eloq1lent speeches were made by prominent Indians<br />
expressing heartfelt thanks and appreciation for all<br />
that this good lady had done in the interest _of the<br />
Indian community. She sailed by the 8.S Kamgola<br />
on the following day amid scenes of enthusiasm<br />
which will ever remain fresh in the memory of<br />
those who witnessed it.<br />
We also beg to record that Mr. Jivanjee of Mombassa<br />
and Nairobi accompanied Mrg. Naidu to<br />
South Africa. This gentleman returnod to East<br />
Africa before Mrs. Naidu and yOUl" Uommittee<br />
accorded him a fitting reception in the M. K. Gandhi<br />
Hall before he left.<br />
SOUTH AFRICAN INDIAN CONGRESS<br />
An emergency Conference of the South African<br />
Indian Congress (fourth session) was held on the<br />
21st of April Ul2! and the three following days.<br />
Mrs. Sarojini Naidu was elected President. Your<br />
Congr('ss ac~eu as Reception Committee, and we are<br />
pleas('d to say that the Conferpnce was a huge suo<br />
CPIIS. Dclegat('s from all parts of South Africa<br />
attenueu the Conferenee and were well cared for by<br />
your Committee. Many matters vitally affecting<br />
the Indians in Natal came under the review of the<br />
Conference such as railway disabilities, educational<br />
disabilities, immigration disabilities, scale of salaries<br />
fixed for Indian Interpreters by the Government.<br />
witness fees payable to Indians and such other<br />
matters affecting the Indian community. The members<br />
of your Congress who were del('gates to tile<br />
Conference took a very active interest in all the<br />
deliberations aud added largely to its undoubted<br />
success. A very pronounced brotherly feeling was<br />
evinced by all the delegates who were present from<br />
various parts of South Africa. The Conference<br />
decided that the headquarters for the South African<br />
Indian Congress for the then ensuing year should be<br />
in Cape Town.<br />
INDIAN AGRICULTURAL AND INDUSTRIAL SHOW<br />
As already referrel to, the South African Indian<br />
Congress resolved that an Indian Agricultural and<br />
Indllstrial Show be held in Durban and be opened<br />
by its President, Mrs. Naidu, and that the Natal Indian<br />
Congress act as the local committee for the pnrpose<br />
of making all the necessary arrangements for<br />
the holding of the said Show. In terms of the<br />
Resolution, -your Congress organised the first Indian<br />
Show held in South Africa. The Mitchell Crescent<br />
School grounds were kindly lent for the purpose.<br />
The Show was something novel and attractive to the<br />
Indian community and as it was held on Empire<br />
Day and also the following day (21th and 25th May<br />
1924), a record crowd was registered. The admission<br />
was free and Indians from all parts of the<br />
country assembled. By fal the most successfull<br />
section of the Show was that devoted to home industries.<br />
The lo1dies entered some beautiful specimens<br />
of handiwork for competition, and local manufacturers<br />
supported this section very loyally. There<br />
were stalls for essentially Indian sweets, e.g., halwa,<br />
cakes of every description, a large array of pickles, a<br />
marvellous bride's cake of three tiel'fl, oil paintings<br />
and water colours, a sample of bricks made at Sydpnham,<br />
locally made tooth powder, wonderfully<br />
pretty handwork shawls and bed-spreadia and a<br />
variety of other articles all of which were of excel-,<br />
lent workmanship. Another room was devoted to<br />
school industries where it was evident that Indian<br />
children are taught to use their fingers deftly<br />
as an aid to mental learning particularly in regard<br />
to GdOgraphy there being many examples of<br />
maps and relief. In fact, modelling in many forms<br />
was to be seen from schools as far afield as Chaka's<br />
Kraal, Malvt'rn, Estcourt and Verulam. Among<br />
the produce and vegetables, ripe m~ngoes, p:lwpaws<br />
and betel-leaves of a size difficult to obtain, Natal<br />
grown tobacco and flowers. Some of the vegetables<br />
were grown in the vario1ls schnol gardens and were<br />
a credit to the children. The display of dogs,<br />
poultry and live stock was also promising. On the<br />
whol(', the Show was a creUit to the. Indian community.<br />
Some of the judges were Europeans
INDIAN OPINION September lIth. 1925_<br />
accustomed to such work expressed the opiniou that<br />
the exhibits equalled those usually exhibited at the<br />
1063.1 :Europ~an Shows. The prizes purchased and<br />
subscribed for this Show were not enough for all<br />
the winners and it has become a difficult matter to<br />
allocate. Bllt, however, a sub-Committee is appointed<br />
to do the best under the circumstances, and no<br />
doubt, the priZes now on hand will be distributed<br />
very soon.<br />
REVISION OF RULES<br />
A Special General Meeting was held on the 18th<br />
day of May 1924 for the revision of the Rules<br />
of the Congress which included the reduction<br />
of the subscription to two shillmgs and six pence<br />
per annum an i the provision for women auxiliaries<br />
to your Congress.<br />
CLASS AREAS BILL<br />
In con~mction with the South Afl'lcan ~ndlan<br />
Congress, your Committee took a very active part in<br />
the agitation against this BIll. Delegates from your<br />
Congress were included m the Deputation of the<br />
Smith African Indian Congress which met the<br />
Minister of the Interior at Oapetown. Your C.ongress<br />
subsequently assisted Mrs. Naidu in carrying<br />
Qn a vigorous campaign in Natal and further contri.<br />
buted a /lum of £100 sterling to the Cape BrItish<br />
lndian Council as Its share of the expenses mcurred<br />
by that body for propaganda work carried on by<br />
Mrs. Naidu against this Bill m the Cape Province.<br />
The Bill, as you know, fell through on the resignation<br />
of the Smuts Government.<br />
MR. CHRISTOPHER'S DEPARTURE FOR ENGLAND<br />
The Committee regrets indeed to record the community's<br />
loss, though for a time,.of the invaluable and<br />
able services of Mr. Albert ChrIstopher, D.C.M., who<br />
so uobly worked iu the mterest of our community<br />
for a good many years and as your honorary secretary<br />
since the resuscitation of the Congress. Your<br />
Committee however feels consoled in the thought<br />
that Mr. Christopher's departure for England was<br />
for the purpose of bettering himself in life and<br />
hopes that he will return withm the next year or so<br />
as a full fledged barrister and resume his public<br />
duties for the betterment of our commuDlty.<br />
NATAL CENTENARY CELEBRATIONS<br />
The Durban Town Council offered a sum of<br />
£200 to your Congress to enable the Indian community<br />
to celebrate the Centenary and. your Committe<br />
iuformed the Durban Corporation in no unmistakable<br />
terms that in all matters of a public<br />
natnre lI:s were the proposed celebrations. the Indian<br />
community could only participate, if at all, 0\1 equal<br />
terms with all other sections of the !community and<br />
where such recognition is in any manner denied,<br />
your CommIttee would absolutely refrain from<br />
identifying itself with all such functions. The<br />
Durban Corporation not agreeing to treat the ludian<br />
community with reasonable faIrness, your Committee<br />
felt it proper to adopt the only honourable<br />
course by strictly adhering to its deciSIOn of nonparticipation.<br />
BOROUGHS ORDINANCE<br />
Immediately the Municipal Consolidation Ordinance<br />
was published in the Provme~al G zsette, your<br />
Cp~mittee forwarded its protest against certain<br />
pl,'ovisions of the Bill which aimed at the deprivation<br />
of the 'Municipal Franchise, restriction of<br />
licences etc. and evidence was tendered by members<br />
of your Committee before the Select Committee of<br />
the Provincial Council. Notwithstanding our protest,<br />
the Bill was rushed thr:ough post-haste In all<br />
its stages at one sitting of the Provincial Council.<br />
Your Committee immediately wired its protest against<br />
this arbitrary action of the Provincial CounCIl to<br />
the Governor-General, the Prime Mmister and the<br />
Minister of the InterIOr and a request that a de-eptation<br />
of your Congress be recei ved before assenting<br />
to this measure. Your Committee In answer to the<br />
request of the Minister of the Interior submitted a<br />
statement on the 16th of August 1924 pointing out<br />
the sections of the Ordinance that would adversely<br />
affect the Indian community. Upon receipt of this<br />
statement, the Minister intimated that the whole<br />
Cabinet was prepared to meet a Deputation of your<br />
Congress to discuss the Indian question. An influential<br />
Deputation consisting of prominent members<br />
of your Congress waiterl upon the Prime<br />
Minister, MlOister of the Interior, Minister of De ... .<br />
fence and Labour, Minister of FlOance, Minister~'<br />
of Mines, Minister of Rd.ilways and the Minister of<br />
Lands, in the Union BUildings, Pretoria, on the 9th<br />
of December 1924. A very able and exhaustive<br />
statement was presented to the Government at this<br />
interview. Mr. Joseph Royeppen, B.A., acted as<br />
the spokesman and was assisted by Messrs. V. L'lwrence,<br />
Beethasee Maharaj and R loknoodeen. The<br />
Ministers gave the Deputation a sympathetic hearmg<br />
but it would appear that they had evidently<br />
made up their minds beforehand to advise the<br />
Governor-General to assent to the Bill because only<br />
two days after the interview, a notification Wd.S received<br />
from the Private Secretary to the Minister<br />
of the Interior that the Cd.binet had decided to recommend<br />
to the Governor-General-in-Council to assent<br />
to the Ordmance. Your CommIttee immediately on<br />
hearmg this despatched a number of cables to<br />
India urging upon the Government and the- leaders<br />
to strenuously protest and take action. Further,<br />
a copy of the statement submitted to the<br />
Cabinet Ministers was posted to each and every prominent<br />
leader in India. Your Committee took<br />
legal opiDlon as to the validity of this law with a<br />
VIew to testing the same in the South African<br />
Courts and if necessary to carry the matter to the<br />
PrIVY CounCIl. Mr. AdvoJate Janion was retained<br />
for this purpose and his opinion was in our favour.<br />
The Ordmance came into force on the 1st day of<br />
Augnst this year and your CommIttee approached<br />
the Electoral Officer for the Borough of Durban<br />
with a VIew to bringing about a Test Cd.se but as<br />
new names were admItted to the Burgess Roll, a<br />
case could not be brought this year. Mr. Janion<br />
was instructed to interview Mr. Mackeurtan, the<br />
Counsel for the Durban Corpol"ttion and arranged<br />
for a Test Case to be brought by consent but Mr.<br />
Mackeurtan having had to leave for England on a<br />
prolonged holiday, the matter of the Test C.lSe had<br />
to be left over for next year when most probably<br />
the three hundred new names added to the Roll this<br />
year wIll automatically drop off and will then give<br />
us grounds for a Test Case.<br />
BOROUGHS EXTENDED POWERS ORDI~ANCE<br />
This Ordinance was simply an extension of the<br />
Durban Land Alienation Ordinance to the other<br />
boroughs of the P~ovince of N 1ta1. Notwithstanding<br />
protests from your Congress by way of petition<br />
to the Provincial Council and to the Minister of the<br />
Interior, the Ordinance has received the assent of<br />
the Governor-General.<br />
TOWNSHIPS FRANCHISE ORDINANCE<br />
This Ordinance which seeks to disfranchise Indians<br />
in Towns1lips was also passed by the Provincial<br />
Council and received the assent of the Governor<br />
General notwithstandIng protests f.·om your congress.<br />
Bnt as the principle involved is exactly as<br />
that contained in the Boroughs Ordinance, this<br />
Ordinance would be subject to the same decision of<br />
the Courts as wiII apply to the Boroughs Ordinance.<br />
PUBLIC HEALTH ORDINANCE<br />
Your committee although welcoming the ohjects<br />
of this Ordinance protested (lgainst certain provisions<br />
thereof which gave the Indians no representa-
September I lth, 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
tion on the Health Committees nor were they entitled<br />
to vote for the election of members on the<br />
• Health Boards. :Members of your committee appeared<br />
before a Select Committee and gave evidence<br />
but as is customary no notice whatever was taken<br />
of our protest. The Bill has now become law and<br />
Indians have been called upon by the various<br />
Health Boards constituted under the Ordinance to<br />
pay assessment rates which are based not on the<br />
valuation of the properties but in some cases on the<br />
"Mmber of rooms and in other cases on the number<br />
t ~of buildings erected on the properties. Your committee<br />
obtained the opinion of :Mr. Advocate Van<br />
Hoytema (now deceased) of Johannesburg which<br />
opinion stated the Ordinance to be i'Ltra vires. Before<br />
further action could be taken on the regulations<br />
framed by these Health Boards, the Indians in<br />
the districts affected have taken over the matter in<br />
their own hands and are now testing the legality of<br />
same.<br />
OBITUARY<br />
THE LATE MR. PARSEE RUSTOMJEE<br />
It is indeed painful to record the death of :Mr.<br />
Parsee Rustomjee, our "Kakaji" who was a pillar of<br />
strength to our CongrESS. From the time of the rei<br />
suscitation of your congress he had taken a very<br />
great interest in its working anti was very generous<br />
with his purse when the need came for it. The<br />
irrepara~le loss to our congress by his death will be<br />
greatly felt by all for a long time to come.<br />
THE LATE MR. P. K. NAIDOO<br />
Another stalwart patriot and passive resister has<br />
gone never to return. Mr. "P. K. " as we all knew<br />
him, was the one who brought about the resuscitation<br />
of your Congrestl some five years ago and from<br />
that time up to his death htl was a keen supporter<br />
of your congress. It was indeed through his<br />
initiative as secretary of the Transvaal BrItish Indian<br />
Association that Mrs. Sarojini Naidu was invited<br />
to South Africa. He'took a very active part<br />
in the delibt'rations of the Conference held last<br />
year. The South African Indlan community in<br />
general, and the Transvaal Indians in particular,<br />
have lost a true friend and an energetic aud fearless<br />
worker in their cause.<br />
CONDOLENCES<br />
Messages of condolence to the relatives of the<br />
late Deshbandhu Das and the late Sir Surendranalh<br />
Bannerjee were sent through Mahatma Gandhi.<br />
Both these leaders were a source of great strength<br />
to our Motherland.<br />
MR. ~HOMAS' VISIT<br />
Your committee took the opportunity of the visit<br />
to South Africa of the Rt. Hon. J. H. Thomas, P.C.,<br />
Secretary of State for the Colonies under the Ramsay<br />
Macdonald Government of seeking an interview<br />
with him while he was in Durban, in the hope of<br />
laying the grievances of the Indian community before<br />
him. Unfortunately, owing to the very little<br />
time that he had at his disposal, he was not- able to<br />
meet us. Your committee therefore submitted a<br />
written statement iu which, inter alia, the Boroughs<br />
Ordinance was fully dealt with. NQ reply was received<br />
but Mr. Thomas expre&sed the opinion before<br />
he left that a Round Table Conference of those concerned<br />
would be the only meaus of solving the Indian<br />
problem in South Africa.<br />
SEPARATE COUNTER: TOWN TREASURER'S<br />
DEPARTMENT, DURBAN<br />
Your committee lodged its objection against the<br />
diserimiMtion shown by the Durban Corporation in<br />
the set,ting aside of a separate counter at the Town<br />
Treasurer's Department for Indians and Natives.<br />
Correspondence with the Municipalitr has failed to<br />
,;feo,' tb. elimination of Ulilf noial legregttion and<br />
your committee h8II decided to obtain legal opinion<br />
on the matter.<br />
IMMIGRATIOS<br />
We were approached by Mr. Amod Abdurahim of<br />
Grey town to obtain temporary permission for his<br />
sister Karimabibi to land which was already refused<br />
by the Immigration officer. Representations were<br />
made to the Minister through the Secretary of the<br />
South African Indian Congress but owing to the<br />
misunderstanding on the part of the Secretary to<br />
the Interior, the instructions to the ImmilU'8tion<br />
Officer were not correctly given and the lady had to<br />
return. Other minor matters were dealt with from<br />
time to time with the Immigration Offlcer, at the<br />
!,oint, who extended to us his nsual courtesy on all<br />
matters brought to his notice.<br />
VIsr.r OF H.R.H. PRISCE OF WALES<br />
As in the case of the centenary celebrations, the<br />
Municipality of the Borough of Durban offered your<br />
congress, a sum of .£200 for the Indian community's<br />
celebration of the visit of the Prince of Wales to<br />
Durban. Your committee refused to acquiesce in<br />
the principle of the Durban Corporation in requesting<br />
the Indian community to organise a seperate<br />
celebrations quite apart from the general celebrationa<br />
of the burgesses. A mass meeting·was held and a<br />
Deputation wdited upon the :Mayor of Durban with<br />
the result that he agreed to consider the proposal<br />
of your congress to include the Indian community<br />
in the general celebrations with the exception of the<br />
participation in the Clvic Bdnql1et aud the Ball.<br />
Your committee on a matter of principle refused to<br />
have a seperate celebration as offered by the Corporation<br />
and insisted that Indians should be invited<br />
to the Banquet as it was not a social function. The<br />
Town Council not agreeing to your request your<br />
committee decided to refrain from the official cele.<br />
brations of the Durban Corporation but arranged for<br />
the Prince of Wales to be received and welcomed at<br />
110, Field Street. Durban, the head-quarters of<br />
the congress. The celebrations of your congress on<br />
this occassion were very grand as apart from the<br />
fitting reception given at congress head-quarters,<br />
large streamers were hung up in Field and West<br />
Streets with the words .. welcome to our Prince<br />
from the Natal Indian Congress." A silk turban<br />
and a jeri shawl were presented in the name Of the<br />
congress to His Royal Highness who expressed<br />
pleasure at the loyalty shewn. Your congress also<br />
obtained the loyal co-operation of its members, in<br />
Maritzburg, Estcourt, Ladysmith and Newcastle who<br />
turned out and paid their respects to the royalvi~itor.<br />
Our decorations surpassed expectations. No<br />
expense was spared to prove that although we were<br />
not treated with equality yet our loyalty and enthuslasm<br />
could not be questioned.<br />
ASIATIC BILL<br />
As notified by the Minister of the Interior in reply<br />
to questions in the House of Assembly the Areas<br />
Reservation and Immigration Restriction (fuJ;ther)<br />
proviSions Bill was introduced by him. in the last<br />
session of the Union Parliament. The mn not having<br />
been gazf?tted in the usual way, youI' committee<br />
immediately got in touch with Cape Town but td itS<br />
surprise was informed that it would be about a month.<br />
or so before copies of the Bill could be obtained.<br />
There was a great demand locally for copies of the<br />
Bill and your committee were supplied by the International<br />
Printing Press with some two hundred<br />
copies out of the two thousand that they printed for<br />
their own llse. These were sent to~." and England<br />
to tbe prominent leaders with a hat full comment<br />
on the Blll would follow. the. following<br />
mail your committee despatch~ each pf,those to<br />
whom a copy of the Blll was se a fair comment<br />
thereon together with such ma ), 1 information 'and<br />
• Preal cllttings that anay be \l .ut to ·the" teade ....
Your committee hall further printed three thousand<br />
copies of th~ said comment and it is proposed to<br />
broadcast same throughout the world<br />
A Mass Meeting of protest of Natal Indians<br />
against the BIll was orgamsed by your committee<br />
and was held in the Durban Town Hall on the 31st<br />
of Au~ust 1925. The attendance was a record one<br />
the Hall itself containing something like 4000<br />
people and an overflow meeting of some two thousand<br />
was simultaneously held at the Church Street<br />
entrance of the Town Hall. Great enthusiasm prevailed<br />
.~"\lroughout the proceedings of the meeting.<br />
Cables/describing fully the nature of the Bill and how<br />
it adversely IIffects the Indian Community of South<br />
Africa were despatched to the prominent leaders in<br />
India and to the Government of India and it is'<br />
expected ~hat a very strong support will be forthcoming<br />
frbm our Motherland. Mr. Motilal ~ehru,<br />
the President of the Swaraj Party has already replied<br />
stating that necessary action would be taken<br />
to protect the !:'ights of Indians here and with a request<br />
to carryon the agitation relying on India's<br />
full'support. It rests with the incoming commi~tee<br />
to organise protest meetings throughout the PI'Ovince<br />
and thereby show the Government and the<br />
eructors of South Africa that the Indians are prepared<br />
to fight this Bill to the fullest extent.<br />
MASS MEETINGS<br />
Mass meetings of the Indian community were<br />
held on the following matters :-<br />
Protest against the Boroughs Ordmance, To expre1lS<br />
sympathy at the deaths of "Kakaji" (Mr.<br />
Parsee Rustomjee) and C. R. Das, Visit of the<br />
Prince of Wales and Protest against the ASIatic Rill.<br />
MISCELLANEOUS<br />
RETRENCHMENT OF CORPORATION EMPLOYEES<br />
During last year, the heads of various departments<br />
recommended to the Town Council the retrenchment<br />
of'the majority of Indian employees in<br />
their :departments. Your committee took up the<br />
matter by correspondence and as a resnlt no further<br />
action was taken by the Corporation.<br />
SMALL POX CONTACT<br />
As a result of complaints made by your committee<br />
to the Minister of Health in regard to the quarantine<br />
of Indian passengers who arrived at the Port of<br />
Natal from time to time, the Jhief Magistrate of<br />
Dnrban desired a Deputation of your congress to<br />
wait upon him and discuss matters. Accoriingly<br />
a Deputation met the Chief MagIstrate who was<br />
assisted by Dr. Fernandez, the Port Health Officer.<br />
It was suggested to the Deputation that guarantee<br />
should be given by your congress III respect of persons'<br />
who, wished to land immedIately, for their<br />
attendance each day at the office of the Medical<br />
Health Department but this assurance your congress<br />
was not in 'a position'to give owing to impracticable<br />
and uureaS'Onable conditions imposed and the matter<br />
remained ,as it were.<br />
DR.UtA IN AID OF CONGRESS<br />
'rhe Arfa Woonathee Natak MandaI staged a play<br />
in aid of the fllnds of your congress. A record<br />
crowd attended and' a sum of £71 19s. 10d. after<br />
deducting expenses was realised. Your committee<br />
appreoiated the gen~rous spirit of the .members of<br />
this MandaI for ,tbe timely assistance.<br />
PRESENTATION<br />
Presentations of attache cases were made to<br />
Mahatma Gandhi and the Ali Brothers at the farewell<br />
meeting at. the 'Durban Town Hall to Mrs.<br />
Naidu who was indly a~ked to hand the presents<br />
to the presents 00 d6rned.<br />
MAtU.'l'MA G.&::;td '<br />
-.... X#dt' Gdri.Jre~~ ,sen b, dab1e llirtltda; greetiIi.gfl td<br />
lfi£Sa tJi11WHJ<br />
INDIAN OPINION September, lIth, 1925.<br />
ANTI-AsIATIC MEETING<br />
A meeting of European burgesses organised by<br />
the al1ti-Asiatics was held in the Durban Town Hall<br />
under the cha.irma.nship of the Mayor, the object of<br />
the meeting being to request the Government to<br />
bring torth an AsiatIC BIll. Mr. Kemp, Gen. Wylie<br />
and Dr. Campbell were thl! prominent speakers. A<br />
few of the members of your congress attended this<br />
meeting and spoke placing the Indian SIde of the<br />
question before the audience. There was a very<br />
poor gathering and the result was that it had very'.<br />
little effect.<br />
BURGESS ROLL<br />
It is a pleasure to record that your committee enrolled<br />
three hundred and six Indian voters on the<br />
Burgess Roll for the year 1925-26 which is very- encouraging.<br />
INDIAN EDUCATION<br />
The Provincial Council nominated a commISSIOn<br />
to inquire as to whether Indian children should be<br />
taught the EnglIsh language through the medium of<br />
the Indian vernaculars. Your congress desired to<br />
tender evidence and show to the commitlsion that it<br />
w{)uld be detrimental to the Indian community to<br />
introduce such a system but owing to want of time,<br />
the commission adjourned its deliberati,)ns to hear<br />
the views of your congress du.ring the next session<br />
of the Provincial Council.<br />
CONGRESS PROPERTIES<br />
Your committee wishes to bring to the notice of<br />
the meeting the desirability of taking immediate<br />
steps to vest in the name of the Trustees to be<br />
appointed in terms of the Rules, the immovable<br />
property and other assets of the congress now in thE'<br />
hands of the official receiver and that the incoming<br />
committee will, as its first work, move in this<br />
direction.<br />
FINANCE<br />
At the last Annual General Meeting, your commitee<br />
took over a debt balance of £115. 125. 4d. and<br />
owing to the lack of support by the Indian community,<br />
funds have not been f017thcoming to efficiently<br />
carry out the work of the congress and to wipe off<br />
its debt. You will see from the Financial Statement<br />
by the Treasurers that a debit balance of £715. Us.<br />
2d. stands against the congress. Tb.is amount was<br />
advanced by your Secretaries and had It not been<br />
for their assistance in coming forward and financing<br />
the congress, It would have been well nigh impossible<br />
to carry .out the enoromous amount of<br />
work above enumerated.<br />
THANK~<br />
The thanks of the committee are due to the<br />
Indian Press and to those who loyally assisted it<br />
to carry out the objects of the congl·ess. With<br />
greater help and greater ser~ice much can be done<br />
to strengthen the congress and to better its position<br />
among our community. Thanks are also due to the<br />
Maritzburg Branch of the congress for the energetic<br />
work within its area and keeping an eye on the<br />
doing of the Provincial Council in regard to Indian<br />
matters. Our thanks are due to the members of the<br />
Arya Yuvuk Sa.bha wno acted as volunteers at Mass<br />
Meetings, the Superintendent of Education for<br />
kindly lending the MItchell Crescent School grounds<br />
for the show, the judges. the members of the Indian<br />
community more eSPtlcially the ladies and those<br />
who contributed the prizes in connection with the<br />
show and to Mr. A. Dookan who so kindly placed<br />
his motor car at the disposal of Mrs. Naidu during,<br />
her stay in Durban.<br />
To friends and societies whereever<br />
they may have been helpful to the Qougrel!S;<br />
its thankli arll due. , .<br />
A T4e committee desli~4 f1~p~l1-de tJd.idoord {bEt<br />
lWIJ.l+llltM ,'~~18e1 II! tHM~mtHlll ~f1H11l1l iHlt_
September 1 !th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 233<br />
energetically rendered by your Honorary Secretariell,<br />
Messrs. Sorabjee Rustomjee and V. S. C. Pather.<br />
The:period under review was a very trying oue and<br />
• it is pleasing to record that both the Secretaries rendered<br />
their secretarial duties efficiently. Your committee<br />
always found them willing and obliging and<br />
it feels that it will be failing in its duty if it did not<br />
express its sincerest thanks for their services.<br />
Notes and News<br />
p "<br />
UT should hardly. be necessary for ns to impress<br />
upon our countrymen the evergrowing seriousness<br />
of our position in South Africa. With the<br />
introduction of the Asiatic Bill a crisis has been reached.<br />
We shall have to consider seriously whether we are<br />
prepared to suffer this compnlsory rnination that is<br />
facing us in the near futnre as a result of this Bill<br />
or whether we should not be prepared to suffer<br />
voluntary ruination by fighting for a right and just<br />
cause. By doing the latter there are possibilities of<br />
avoiding our compulsory ruination as contemplated<br />
by the Government and thus also of avoiding<br />
our moral degradation.. But if on the other hand<br />
we are not prepared to suffer voluntary ruination<br />
our compulsory ruination both moral andmaterial<br />
is inevitable. Let us therefore make up our<br />
mind anrl be up and doing for the coming struggle.<br />
We note the following from ~hhatma Glndhi's<br />
note on .. The Pariahs of the Empire" appearing in<br />
Young IndUl. am.ed by last mail:-<br />
" Our countrymen in South Africa must<br />
do the very be8t they can without flinching.<br />
If they have the old 8pirit of re8i8-<br />
tance and cohe8ion in them, and if they<br />
think that the moment has arrived, they<br />
must take up the cr088 of 8uffering. They<br />
mU8t be sole judges of their fitne88 and of<br />
the p8ychological moment for taking their<br />
plunge. They mU8t know that public<br />
opinion of India i8 with them. But they<br />
will al80 realize that it i8 an opinion which<br />
is powerle8s to help them. They must<br />
therefore rely upon their own 8trength and<br />
capacity for enduring hard8hips and in the<br />
innate jU8tice of their cause.<br />
The following new officials were elected for the<br />
ensuing year at last Sunday's Annual General<br />
Meeting of the Natal Indian Congress held in<br />
Rawat's Bio Hall :-PRllBIDENT-Ma. A. M. BlY 1t,<br />
VWE-PRIBCDENra-Mes3ril. A. H. K~zi,<br />
Advo.::ate<br />
J. W. Godfrey, V. wwrence, Bhawani D.lyal, S.<br />
Emammally, M. H. Desai, S. Dorasamy. I. M.<br />
Haffejea, A. Dookhan, Charlie Nulliah; JOINT HON.<br />
SECRETARIES-V. S. C. Pdother and Sorabjee Rustomjee;<br />
JOINT HON. TRE.\SURER~.-Messrs. P. R.<br />
Pather and O. H. A. Jhaveri; COMMITTEE-A. I.<br />
Kajtle, D. S. Chetty, R. K. Naidoo, J. M. Francis,<br />
M. B. Maharaj, R. K. Kapitan, B. M. Patel, M. M<br />
Lokhat, G. M. C. Patel, M. B. Naik, E. M. Ally (of<br />
Messrs. E. A. Tayob & Co.), T. M. Naiker, S. L.<br />
Singh, B. A. Maghraj, I. A. Essack, S. A. Pillay.<br />
A. Sookhdoo, A. M. Omar, M. M. Gandhi, M. D.<br />
Barmania, L. Panday, V. D. Mehta, S. L. Richards,<br />
J. Royeppen, M. Sooboo Naidoo, '0. B. Chetty, M.<br />
B. L,.zarlls, Advocate B. Gabriel.<br />
, We are glad to note that the new election is satis<br />
, factory. The members have been wise in re-electing<br />
Mr. Amod Bayat as President. During the throe<br />
years of his office Mr. Rayat has proved ,without<br />
doubt his fitness for the honourable .'POSition. Asfor<br />
t~e Joint hon. Secretaries to ~tb.em would<br />
have practically meant the .sounding of the deathknell<br />
of the Oongr.ea.'lo 'They are the life of the<br />
Congres~ ,00 tht!1r servi~es are indispensable. The<br />
.~urets iia.~ gained the C()nfiden~ ~ the Coni<br />
gress-was also amply proved by their re-election.<br />
There are some changes in the list of vicp-presideuts<br />
a'ld we think it is a very welcome change and the<br />
Committee practiQlI.lly remains the same. The<br />
workers are representative of every section of the<br />
community and it is satisfactory to note that the<br />
nllmber of influential merchants ha9 also increased.<br />
,If the past year was strennous it is hardly n6CeBBary<br />
to say that the ensuing year will be far more<br />
strenuous, perhaps more than it has ever been.<br />
While congratulating the new officials we hope and<br />
pray that Heaven may rightly guide them in the<br />
performance of their duty to the community.<br />
BISHOP FISHER<br />
\\ 1\ VE w~lcoDe the arrival in S()u~h !frica of Bishop<br />
\1\1 an I Mra. Fish ~r of Calcnt.t~. Their object ill<br />
visiting this conntry is to ga:n first-halld<br />
knowledge of the Indl'An qnestinn. They have jnst<br />
completed a tonr of \uitralia where they have investigated<br />
the mach-talked of "Whir.e·AlutraIia policy."<br />
Bis40p Fisher bel()ng~ to the Metho:list Episcopal Chureh<br />
of America and hu spent s~veral yeara ai a MissioD!u1"<br />
and in scholatic work in the United Province and latterly<br />
in Calcutta. Bishop I
234<br />
INDIAN opINION September lith. !925<br />
"'l'r tm repo~t ()f ,th~<br />
A GLOOMY PICTURE<br />
work of the Natal Indian<br />
II Congress sllPmitted by the hop. Sooretaries<br />
at the Anr.ual General MeetlOg last Sunday<br />
should serve 9.S an eye-opener to the Indian community.<br />
The Congrllss Committee has shown a very<br />
good record of its aqtivities, p.o Q.o\lbt, aud for that the<br />
members pf the ComJUittee in 8en~r~1 and 1;4e l1pn.<br />
SIl(,lr{ltari/:3$ (A{essr~. V. S. C. Plltbel' and 80rabjee<br />
Rustomjf'.e) m particular are to be congratulated, the<br />
latter having had to bear the brunt practically<br />
wholly of financip...g the CgngreSil.<br />
The disappointing thing. hpweve\", is that most of<br />
the activi~es recorded have been fruitless. While<br />
there is not much gai.n to be shown the loss appe/l.rs<br />
to be,e~ces8ively heavy.<br />
Let Ull first ~xamine the gains.<br />
Mrs. Barojini Naidu's visit was undoubtedly a<br />
blessmg to the community and the undoubted success<br />
of 'her visit was due very greatly to the strenuous<br />
work of the Oongress Committee and that certainly<br />
stands to its credit. The succesS of the Emergency<br />
Conference of the South African Indtan Congress<br />
held under the presidentship of Mrs. SarQjipi ;Naidu<br />
is well-known and also stands to the credit of the<br />
Congress who wa!! in charge of orgal;llsing it. The'<br />
I udian AgrlCultural and Industrial Show held \n<br />
Durban dUring the period under review was the<br />
first of its kind known in the history of Indians in<br />
Sl)uth Africa and was un!1oubtedJy fl. grand succel:lS.<br />
The work of organising the Show WIU'I in the hands<br />
of the Congr~ss and t}:tat too stands to its cr~dIt. It<br />
is a matter of regret that ,this Show 1;Ias not bE;len<br />
continued. If an Agriculturlll and Industria.l Committee<br />
were to be formeq. under tp.e ~u~dallce of the<br />
Congress and a Show of that det;lcription were to be<br />
ope:t1ed annually it would no dOllb~ be great;ly 4elp~<br />
ful to the moral and .tn~terial uphftment pf the<br />
community.<br />
While these are !lome of the outstalj.ding successe!l<br />
of the Congress lmd hence stand to its credit we will<br />
now examme what the Cougress qas actu(l.lly lost,<br />
Notwithstandiqg the very strong prpt!l!lt of. the<br />
Congress the Boroughs aq.d ~he r:rown~lllPs Ordinances<br />
have b,een passed ,aIl4 Ina.n;mg thpse<br />
that are alrea.!ly on the Roll ,p.ave IOllt tQ.tl J\!llnicpal<br />
and Township .Franchise. This is a very ~r~at Ip~s.<br />
The passing of the Durban Lao,4 Alienation apq.<br />
the Boroughs Extelj.ded Powel,"~ Ordinances have<br />
deprived Indians of the right to purchase and own<br />
land-ed property wherever they may choose to<br />
and they stand as a loss to the comIPunity, The<br />
passing of the Public Health Ord,inance 1s also a di.$tinet<br />
loss to the community. It aut;b.orises the<br />
formation of Boards and the administration of the<br />
dIstricts to which the Health Ordinance is applicable<br />
is in the hands of these Boards, members of wl).ich<br />
are eleeted by the Europeans in the districts J·ovlnC\~l Council<br />
has deCIded not to incur on Indian education any ~'.(<br />
~urther expense to that already inonrre,l and whic4<br />
is insufficient in cO)D.parison with the mOlley derived<br />
~ro\ll Indians through ratail ~nd taxell. 'J'b,at WI) ~j<br />
therefore a lps~ to the comlllqnity. .4.nd now to<br />
Il-d.d to all tb.~ae I06Jl1lll we hllve th. Asmtlo Bill<br />
wh.ich depriv(lS us of p~ti~lly all the rights and<br />
privileges we are entitled to Dot only as British sub<br />
,jeets but as human beings.<br />
The reader will be able to see from the Ilbove th~t<br />
the Committee has /!Ihown cOlJlparaUve!y very little<br />
to the credIt while ~he 4ebit b,al;mce 18 very heavy<br />
Ilnd r~ndere4 all the heavier by its fin~ncial statep'ent<br />
which shows a debit b~lanee of £776 19s. 2d.<br />
The above is indeed a gloomy picture ot t~e pre<br />
!'lent position; and who is blame for It? Undoubtlldly<br />
p.ot the OpUgreSii workers. TheT have<br />
¢lone what wa.s pOtiIIJible for them to do with considerable<br />
sacrifice to thePlselves'not only in time but<br />
in money as weH. It is the la.c}{ c;>f entb1lflW3m on<br />
the v~t ot tile COIJlll:u:mity that ia to blAme for this<br />
~tate of affa.irs. Th, most hnPQft.'tnt thing the<br />
COmIPllllity bas lacked is in its finanolal support to<br />
the Congrelli. If it is roollsed, itS it shonld be even<br />
by a blind man, frDm the an\lllal report, that the<br />
Oouil"ess Committee h!lS \)E;len /loins very \UIe!ql and<br />
iIn.portant wor~ iu tbe interests of the community,<br />
it is tb.e dtIty of illl thotl6 of our countrynren who<br />
qan ~fJ'or
September 11th, 1925 INDIAN oPJNloN 235<br />
- -- ---- - -------~- --------------...;:.:-<br />
I wonder whether the true significance of Mr.<br />
Gandhi's meSHaga is appreciated. It rea']s .. If people<br />
prepareJ 8uffer they mnst win." Do those who real!<br />
the wordl! .. prepared to Buffer" realise what is<br />
involved therein? What measure of stature? What<br />
nobility of chal'acter? What Belfie3snes~, dispa.ssion<br />
amI detachment are implied in thollc words t Mr.<br />
Gandhi's meflaage simple lUI it reads, is one upon<br />
which every claimant for .. liherty and justice"<br />
woul
236 INnlAN OPINION September lith. 1925<br />
--~----------------------------.----------------<br />
India through Mahatma Gandhi and the world<br />
is prepared ,to' hear and, the speaker trusted,<br />
to receive. CQqtinmng the BishQP said he had<br />
the inestimable \ pleasure Qf persQnally meeting<br />
Mahatma Gandhi after his lQng fast and fQund him<br />
to' be full Qf JQYQUS spirit with a brilliant intellect<br />
and a mQst hQpeful dIsPQsitiQn. The SQul fQrce<br />
which characterises his principles can be said to' be<br />
almQst visibly' emenating frQm his persQnality.<br />
Every sectiQn Qf the Empire shQuld be grateful to'<br />
the silent and peaceful revQlutiQn which is in QperatiQn<br />
in India.<br />
WithQut sO' great a leader PQwerful in his SQul<br />
fQrce there WQuid have been great blQQdshed in<br />
India. The BishQP had addressed Qver 53,000<br />
Indian University students in English and these<br />
men today believe that success and victQry was<br />
O'btainable, bQ~h eCQnQmic and mQral, by SQul fQrce<br />
rather than bMte fQrce. India is ready to' deliv~r<br />
its message to the wQrld and the wQrld is ready to'<br />
receive it.<br />
The BishQP exclaimed that he was an Indian<br />
except by birth and cQIQur. He was an IndIan in<br />
mind thQught and ambitiQn. He had a message to'<br />
give to the Ic.dians here and after Qffering them<br />
greetings as frQm himself a bleached Indian he<br />
recite'd the fQllQwmg whlCh ie frQm the Whittier's<br />
English setting Qf qUQtatiQns frQm Institutes Qf<br />
Manu :-<br />
" Heed hQW thQU livest. DO' nO' act by day<br />
Which in the night will drive thy peace away.<br />
In mQnths Qf sun sO' live that mQnths Qf rain<br />
Shall still be happy.<br />
EvermQre resb.;ain evil, and cherish gQQd<br />
SO' shall there be anQther<br />
And a hapPIer life fQr thei."<br />
.. Say nQt, in evil dQing, nO' Qne sees,<br />
And sO' Qffend the cQnsciQus Qne within,<br />
WhQse eyes can see,the secret mQtives Qf miquity.<br />
Nor ~n ,t4Y,-follY,say., I am: aldoe',<br />
FQr seated in thy heart, as Qn a thrQne,<br />
,The Ancient Judge and WItness liveth still,<br />
'TO' nQte thy thQught and act,<br />
And as thy gOQd Qr ill flQWS frQm thee<br />
Far beyQnd thy reach<br />
The sQlemn dQQms-man's seal ieeet Qn each."<br />
MRS. FISHER<br />
Mrs. Fisher whO' was received with lQud applause<br />
said that the salvatiQn Qf mankind depended UPQn<br />
the activ~ties Qf WQmen. The Indian ladies present<br />
would, have to', arQuse themselves frQm their<br />
lathargy and take an active interest in the welfare<br />
O'f their children. She beheved that the mind Qf<br />
WQmen was PQtent and capable Qf great thmgs mQre<br />
especially when it was remembered that it was Qnly<br />
80 years agO' that WQmen came intO' university hfe<br />
and what did th~y find tQ-day ? WQmen were QCCupying<br />
mQst impQrtant positiQn in every branch Qf life.<br />
NQr was this peculiar to' EurQpean CQuntries Qnly<br />
but in India WQmen had excelled themselves. 'fQ-day<br />
in Calcutta the leading barrister was a lady and in<br />
Delhi the directQr Qf educatiQn department~as a<br />
lady. The speaker exhorted the Indian ladies<br />
present to' endeavQur to' see that their chIldren came<br />
to the library and imbibed the tremendQus law Qf<br />
Indian hIstory cQntaineJ in the bQQks Qn the<br />
shelves. She was Qf the QpiniQn that all racial<br />
trQuble and misunderstanding WQuld cease if Qnly<br />
mQthers WQuld try and learn sQmething Qf the<br />
mQthers and children O'f Qther races. They would<br />
becQme acquainted with the gQod that existed in<br />
O'thers and thus learn to' respect and appreciate<br />
them. IgnQrance was 'at the bQttQm of mQst Qften<br />
present day misunderstanding.<br />
Speeches -were> alSO' made by lIessrs V. S. C.<br />
Pather, ,RQQknQodeen and Pandit Bhawani Dayal.<br />
The Chairman presE'nteJ the Bishop and MIS.<br />
Fisher WIth bQquets and thanked them fQr gracing<br />
the meeting with their presence and theIr sympathetic<br />
remarks.<br />
A PQrtrait Qf the late Mr. Parsee Rnstomjee was<br />
unveiled by Mrs. Fisher and the enthusiastic meeting<br />
terminated at 9.30 p.m.<br />
~~CECECE
September I Ith, J9~5 II-- DIAN OPINioN 237<br />
The Maharajah of Patiala with his Maharanee an.l<br />
retinue is at the Savoy Hotel, occupying the suit's<br />
which were uiled t'arlier thill ye-ar, by the Maharajah<br />
of Rajpipla, and the MahaJajah of Kapurthala •.<br />
But, the snites have bt'en since converted into j<br />
a vt'rilable lit/Ie palace, lor the l\1aharajah of Paliala.<br />
The prest'nt Maharajah of Patiala succeeded his<br />
late father in 1900, wht'n he was only t'ight years<br />
old. He has a maRsive figure and a fine black bear.l.<br />
lIe wears European dress of very smart cut, bnt<br />
with a magnificent jewt'lled apricot yellow tUl'iJall<br />
with purple edges, and his pt'arl earings are sC't ill<br />
a cluster of diamonds, nef'dles 00 say the resourc('s<br />
of his estate, was at the diRposal of the British Juring<br />
the War. lIe has the reputation of a great gdDW<br />
huntt'r. much of which he does from his mooor CaJ·.<br />
He will in a few weeks time be at Geneva, as In~lia'b<br />
representative on the League of Nations. In th~<br />
interval he is said to be fully occupied in the study<br />
of qUt'stions conct'rnir.g the League and its objects.<br />
A miracle did happpn, the evil day, in the coal<br />
world has been put off at the last moment by thr<br />
intprvenlion of the Govt'rnment. But the truce is<br />
for a fortnight, and to-day the momenOOU8 discussion<br />
on the qnestion takes place in the Houst' of<br />
Commons. A White Paper was issned yesterflay,<br />
in regard to the subsidy promised by the Government<br />
to the mine owners which made the truc(<br />
pOllsiblt, ten millions is the sum referred to in the<br />
White Paper, but more may be asked of Parliamt'nt<br />
if this sum be insuffiCIent to meet the losses of the<br />
mine owners in keeping the mines working and<br />
paying the miners the wages hitheroo paid to them.<br />
It is admitted on all hands, that, the mines al'e not<br />
being worked at a profit and that the men too, are<br />
not receiving the wages they ought to get. Mr.<br />
Ramsay Macdonald claims that the only solution of<br />
the mining trouble is the nationalisation of all<br />
mines. Others have other remedies, which will no<br />
doubt find,f'xpression m the discussions on the question<br />
in the House of Commons. This industry is a<br />
matter of vital importance to the BritIsh Isles.<br />
In charing cross amidst its book shops, the<br />
writer met the Bev. H. D. Mullet, who at one time,<br />
was in charge of Christ at urch, Sydenham, outside<br />
Durb~n. He is now in London.<br />
BOOKS FOR SALE<br />
To be obtamed from the Indian Ol""on p,.ess, Ph~nlx.<br />
Natal. Postal Orders to be made payable at Durban.<br />
The Hon. Mr. G,)kh .. le aud Lhe Indenture System:l 0<br />
Indian lIome Rule, by M. K. Gandhi 1 6<br />
ABook-and its Mlsaomer 1 0<br />
Bigavad Glta. Mrs. B~saOl's Tr.1nslatlol1 :I 6<br />
ASIatics Registration Amcni.nent Act (1908)<br />
In Eoghsb and Gujaratl<br />
Hindu Social Ideals, ' y P. J. Mehta<br />
Rise aad Growtb 01 Bo..nbjy MUDlcipal GJvt.<br />
Agricultural IndusLries in India<br />
:I 6<br />
4 6<br />
:I 6<br />
The Story 9( the Ramayana, Ih Epic 01 Rama :I 6<br />
A Study in Indian Economics, by P. B1DDerjl 4 6<br />
The Indians o( South Alrica, by H. S. L. Pulak :I 0<br />
Life of M. K. Gandhi (Ill TamIl) :I 6<br />
The Golden Number of" ludlan OplDlon II<br />
Paper covers :I 6<br />
Bound in Cloth 3 6<br />
Speech.:s on India 1 Arralls, by John Morley j 6<br />
The 110...\. ~Ir, G.)"hll..'~ T"u IU ;it-u.h Alncll:<br />
SpeCial INDIAN O~INION Souvenirr. I 6<br />
Tb. Klbici of P~I.i •• MCli.iaac.l i 0<br />
Essay on Indian Economics. by Mahadev<br />
Gonnd Raoadt!<br />
Hindu Psalms ~nd Hymos<br />
V.usbavite Reformers of Ir;dl&<br />
M. K. Gandhi and the South African<br />
Indian Problem<br />
Aspeci o( the Vedantl<br />
Essays 00 Indian Art, lodustry and Education<br />
Sri Madbwacbarya<br />
Hioduism. by Dr. B.unett<br />
P"sition of the Women in the Vedas<br />
V. raaculars II Media of I nstruction in<br />
Inrliao Schools and Colleges<br />
Essentials of Hinduism<br />
D .. dabhai Naorojl" Speeches aDd Writingi<br />
Indian National Congress<br />
The Madras Congress and Conferences<br />
Allahabad .iDd Nagpur CO'lgressfs<br />
_ Tbe Surat Congress and Confc:rences<br />
The Improvemf.:nt of Indian AgrIcu'ture<br />
The Congress Conferences and Conventions<br />
India's Untouchable Saints<br />
The Governance of India. hy Govind nas<br />
For India's Uplift. by Anne Besant<br />
Sn RamanuJacharya<br />
Sri Sankaracharya<br />
Mr. Gandhi's Speeches and WfltlDgs-1896 to 1917<br />
The Indian Demancb, by G. A. Natesan<br />
In'han Industrial and Economic Problems by Prof. Kale 3<br />
Essays on National Idealism. by Dr. Coomaraswamy 2<br />
Natal Indian Congress.<br />
3<br />
I<br />
3<br />
6<br />
:I 6<br />
1 0<br />
I 6<br />
• 6<br />
I 6<br />
:I 6<br />
6<br />
4-<br />
I 9'<br />
6 0<br />
8 0<br />
I 6<br />
2 6<br />
:I 0<br />
:I 0<br />
2 0<br />
7 6<br />
3 6<br />
2 6<br />
2 6<br />
An interesting lecture on A10DE~N ~ACIAL<br />
P~OBLEM will be delivered by Bishop Fisher<br />
of Calcutta who is now louring South Africa,<br />
at the Parsee Ru!:>tomjee Hall, Queen Street,<br />
Durban, on Saturd..1Y, 12th, September<br />
1925, at 3 p.m.<br />
All are kindly invited to attend.<br />
AMOD BAYAT,<br />
President:<br />
SORABJEE RUSTOMJEE,<br />
V. S. c. PATHER,<br />
Joint Hon, Secretaries.<br />
Natal Indian Congress.<br />
MAHATMA GANDHI'S BIRTHDAY.<br />
A meeting of the Indian Community will<br />
be held at the Parsee Rustomjee Hall,<br />
Durban, on Monday, 14th. September 19Z5.<br />
at 7 p.m. to celebrate Mahatma Gandhi's fifty.<br />
sixth birthday,<br />
All are kindly invited to attend.<br />
AMOD BAYAT,<br />
President.<br />
SORABJEE RUSTOMJEE,<br />
V.IS. c. PATHER,<br />
Joint Hon. Secretaries.<br />
Note :-The Kathiawar Arya MandaI will<br />
also join in the above eelebtationsl
~ln: lkl~!t.' ~~t:~ It. ... ~ ~ltl} '~1'3.h. ll>ld;:<br />
~h,{.~\h.~ c~ 0 \J'e Wi'le<br />
.4\fc:,}:j (;: f< ~\}> t}>lh~tR~lt l>1a~~~ ~m).o<br />
U~?~ 1P~ t}tN:lt~'t<br />
'Q~l~ .)1slk"~ tkl: ~h.lk1: ____<br />
\}Jk"~ e\~~ l.l1sfl lkll l>~~ ~e' \}~)~ kIt (. l~~h l~kl.le<br />
~1fl \!fijt k 11:.; ~lft t!1R Il:.h.llft: \}Ilr.!ie\~~ t\~l~ Rll1s~ ~th.§) lfelh.le",- ~l:J'lfll}:.-l: l"~I",R Ij.ll~~_ tla:<br />
-~ltt.e lt7~,?,~ Ih'l.> 'tt..lr- ~i!i ~e nl~ ~ "t' ':J" \-;)~ ~\}>n,)l~ \}>'~~ l}>\h'tlf ,-"IjlR I~lf,~' ~,~~ lRlla:<br />
,,~ J.l-. nil: t ~ k~,~ Viti kH! ij)~: (EI-D ~~t ~ '~ P~I~'kl:- e llch.1Kl: 1'?R1~l1.: 'tl~e. Pk l!; \. ~~\"<br />
l}>Ip~ ~lh t!; l!.AG ~Ylf ~1l:\r.. }t!c1}:j lh~ jlb ~lh: I I-D~kf!: felh. ~ 1~~ n,en. '~~I:!'R: &'~e. 'Pklil~<br />
1~ kl~ ~lt fell' ~Ab PIc ~ '~ pe nli Ua-fi\. ~ 11'tl-ll-\1:!~~11 U:l~ ~ b~l(l1 ,1) I ~11-1~e. FIl=.lf!ki: h.llt Fe ?Jlo t ~ \F1lfl: U't1 U:ltI.<br />
fcll\ ~1- ""~?!a: ~ [-.I)k b)1"-jpJ?1!\ ~I~lt \Jllt-,}( I ~1):'~ltt Vllti~ t,)fc fpU~ ij>1~~ '~~~<br />
U'itfCi7,"= \Flo ~lk1t 1~1: '~ nt}e l-D~lp~ ls\~ pbll§) ?-i,~ ~I~~ 1~ kl~ l?el'f\ I~I:! ~ lt~ ~<br />
tl~ l~-f)R ll-U1}t-i ~ lhli el\e,\ ~hl~m1:.1Kl: e. {. l)?):Ih-e lJ'A \;~ t,lfl: hl~ ~~ lltl""lte ~ n~1~ 11::\l>lt<br />
t!;lf 1 ~l).ll:l ~llt 1::Hl! 0 lh~ l~rlje'\ ~1~7t Jt 1l!!-'ft.l1: lJt ne @hlJ~lffl: 3t§>l1cHt '~f\~ pCl( ~7~ l::~ lRlj.l'~e.<br />
"9 '~ 1\r-\{'~ k ll1sl=.J .~f\ ''tth~ 1~~ 1tklt 1:: t!h.lc~kI: ~l~f\l~U~! lfi!lh.lk1: Jkllf1JHa: f&~~"<br />
J.l?,~ lJeU:' ~h. ~'!a:'\}c1.o\A.lltl. '~'I.> I-D~ k~ bHla- -: ~ lJ1 \!:fI~ "'It ~la: l}>1tllt><br />
\1' ~ U~lR~lt I (lit ep~~ u.: b11tc l.}:>1'kl: 'l:h51 h~~ Ii~ Ual~ '~<br />
l::\).R~ Sk ~kI: t}t '~ fI~ !'iCli1l.1e,R ij"a?,'h: \p'" l}> ,)ltl}:.ljk!! t, .. Wi Ii:~ I-D!t~ lf~l-tlM: lJ?l1thlh. ~lhW;C\<br />
1~lP1'lllf I"H~!t { ~ hIli ~,1'1Ia: !P~ hie 'tltJ.a: U"clnlw.: Ie. !!;f li ~Jp eIRf\P 'tU,~ ~ntklh.<br />
• • ____ \)lhW;'e.lt ~ f3,eh. ~\iill: \p1li7m @In.l\fl: felh. IP~<br />
'(7tl~i~) F.ht?ols '}Iloel.i '~eSC~ 'I}a 'k~ 't}t;: ij)lc1Glfl: lf~J~ U~h.\W: \lJlh lfs~ 1::Kl: ~ ~'l: loHl,R<br />
'lt~ 'w; '~llt k\Jlli',f\ a~H '~hllo ff.~ 'k~ 1o£1@]'" 11)l:1-D tjem llilltlJilllthlh. PlhW;e~ lP~l'f\ tIlt<br />
~J.h.'hl~ '~ \~h:\): '17\f: 'R\!: 'lP~lt '1J> '0> I @Ih.lk1: ~1~ eR Ie ~J"Il1: 'l:lh1W l::ll::n ~llthlh Pl~~'l:1t<br />
'tJh. 1.o!tGl17 'lh\}ltellti lJ '1t~ 'lhl'c 'It.~ 1t~ I i ~flt. (.lbf\P 1::1Pli ~lltRlh. PlhW;clt lltl}:.i17 171ptl!<br />
I~lt~ '1t~ '~ '''~kI.~ '~ '~l}I. 'l!; 'R~ 'm~p.: I~"" ~~ t ~~ 1l-1h'l:lI 1.o~}t ~h.lla: If.llltltlh. Plh<br />
'~ 'fllkc '.A£n~~ ~ ~ 'leLf!: '~~ 'Rl'!; 'c~hl1.o I W;e~ If.l~Ih1.17 (,1~~ fsn.llfl: llt'h ~l~~h.<br />
'k\!; '\1 '(1mll> 'l~ ~ .. ~ Wih~'~ R ,)~R~) '~Kl: : 1;:F.1}a Ha: ~ ~ flhelh:l:J ~ t!hlla:~' '~l~lfft<br />
~It'illt It\Jllnf\ 'lihll- '(}o 'It~ '~th. 1}C 1t~ 'W; • U'cil,kc P1-n.lo ll::tfCikc II:! ~I}a ~lll'hU?;~ .lc1~ lP~c 'eE}o<br />
f7Hf\1~ 'k~ 'k ~ '~(h 'It\!; 'I}n '1.o?l}I.{ '~ 'elWi:: i ~~tnt) ij>lhblRf ell. l~flJltU~~ lclltkc\ ll-el}&,1t \pIA<br />
'~Iel'i-lt 1J~~!}a 'R1}C"l1-'k~ '~ '~hIP 'f, HkI: 'l?rt= : u.>l:>.b l>~tn1.oB lY~liU U"clI'I.1k1: !k:lftl'kl: fel~~<br />
·R~ '\1 'em ""'lin! '\!: »RR~ : Ul)t.-T 'U,~tI. 'cllfl: J 6 ~t~~ek t t~lG ~tk'tt\h. ~l~~~lt<br />
~:"==<br />
e Tn: llt ~ 't lee ~ l!'<br />
€It ~ "'" h.'&~ l H(;~t\ ft II It\.1)t~ 'ell .. -tn 'fl:liU-U t.ft ~e. .If~~'fI.<br />
~·~kf:1!J~~llre ~J=elre~~
llidinu ®piniott<br />
No. 38-Vo1. XXIII. Friday, September 18th, 1925.<br />
Reglltered at the G. P.O. as a Newspaper<br />
Pale_ 'OV.PI!II(.B<br />
---------------------------------<br />
llURTHER PROTEST AGAINST ASIATIC BILL<br />
'1ll N enthusiastic Mass Meeting of Pretoria and<br />
S'1l District Indians was held at the Star<br />
llioscope, Boom Street, Pretoria, 011 Sunday<br />
the 13th September 192,), at 3 p.m. The meetmg was<br />
very largely attended. Mr. HaJee C.1SSlm Adam,<br />
the chairman of the PretOl'ia British Indian Af-Bociation,<br />
presided.<br />
The chairman in opening the meeting explained<br />
that thE'Y had met that afternoon to protest against<br />
the Asiatic Bill introduced by the Interior at the<br />
close of the last Session as well as the General Dealers<br />
(control) Ordinance recently pasfled by the Tr[lt)svaal<br />
Provincial Council. He also drew the attention<br />
of the meetmg to the debate on the Asiatic Bill that<br />
took place in the Council of 8tatE's at Simla and<br />
urged that it was highly essential that a deputatlon<br />
should be sent to India from the Transvaal.<br />
Among the speakers WE're Messrs. Govindjee<br />
Bhanabhai, (hon. Secretarr of thl' Pretoria British<br />
Indian Association), A. A. Mirza, N. A. Camar,<br />
Vally ?fahomed, Mahomed Ismail, R~ l\fooloo,<br />
Suliman Ebrahim, Nana Lal, Osman Alli and others.<br />
Resolutions<br />
The following resolutions were nnanimously<br />
passed :-<br />
1. That this mass meeting of Pretoria and District<br />
Indians enters its emphatic protest against the<br />
Areas Reservations, Immigration and Registration<br />
Bill as being humiliating, degrading and detrimental<br />
to the vested and potential righs of the Indian communitr<br />
apart from the fact that it violates the<br />
Gandhi-Smuts settlement of 1914.<br />
2. That a deputation consisting of three delegates<br />
be sent to India under the aeigis of the Transvaal<br />
British Indian Association to make strong representations<br />
to the Government of India and the Indian<br />
nation with a view to urging the Imperial Government<br />
to bring about an honourable and final settlement<br />
of the Indian question in South Africa to the<br />
satisfaction of the Imperial, Indian and the Union<br />
Govel'nments aud the Indian Nation by means of a<br />
Hound Table Conference.<br />
3. That this mE.'E.'ting rpspectfully requests His<br />
Excellency the GovE.'rnor-Genl'ral to Withhold hIS<br />
aSSE.'nt to the General DealE.'rs (control) Ordmance<br />
192.') and to receive an Indian Deputation.<br />
4. That this Mass ME.'eting hereby fully supports<br />
thi! Transvaal British Indian Association.<br />
The meeting then terminated with a vote of thanks<br />
to the chair.<br />
British Indian Association Cables<br />
India and England<br />
The Transvaal British Indian Association (Johannesburg)<br />
has sent the following cable to India and<br />
England:-<br />
.. Asiatic Bill outrageous :Making Indian life<br />
impossible. Violating Smnts-Gandhi settlement.<br />
Allocating segrE.'gated areas. Necessitating abandonlllent<br />
of present businesses amI propertIes. Creatlllg<br />
atmosphere such that Indians must leave ~outh<br />
Africa ruined. immi!;,"Tatil)n Law so amended as<br />
to make Indians bona fide domiciled prohibited.<br />
~ , .. ~<br />
MASS MEETING AT PRETORIA<br />
Indians' wives and chlldren cannot enter Union<br />
after 1930. No secnrity even for South Africanborn<br />
Indians. Dual domicile forfeited. Three<br />
yeal'E absence forfeits domicile. Transvaal General<br />
Dealers' (Control) Draft Ordinance 1925 will<br />
exterminate all In.iian businesses. We respectfully<br />
bE.'g Impel"ial and Indian Governments to intercede<br />
and nE.'gotlate for Round Table Conference among<br />
the lJnion, Imperial, and Indian Government."<br />
Mr. Polak on the ASiatic Bilt<br />
., A M eas ure to Levy Blackmail"<br />
There Can be No Compromise<br />
Mr. Henry S. L. Polak has wired to India from<br />
London that the new Asiatic Blll introduced in the<br />
South African ASbembly is entirely unacceptable.<br />
The origmal Blll was nnacceptable in principle but<br />
the new Blil goes much further depriving Natal<br />
Indians of the right to own lands save for a restricted<br />
nght 10 the coastal belt. This Bill apparently<br />
further commits a breach of the GandhI-Smuts<br />
agreement t y further restrlCtmg the emigration of<br />
wives of Indlans and by extending the dlsabilities<br />
to Cape Indi.1ns. The Bill seems to be a measure<br />
to levy blackmall on the Government and the Indian<br />
people .. 1 am of 0plDlOn" writes Mr. Polak "that<br />
there can be no compromise thereon."<br />
Pariahs of the Empire<br />
Mahatma Gandhi writes as follows in Young<br />
Indue.-<br />
Lest we forget our status and proper place in the<br />
imperial economy, we reCeIve a constant reminder<br />
now from Englan
INDIAN Uf~lNION September 18th, 1925<br />
Lokamanya said much the same thing. • Seek ye<br />
first Swaraj and el'erything will be added unto you'<br />
was his refl·ain~ But Swaraj is a result of the snmtotal<br />
of India's' energy. The order of the day is<br />
work from without and work from within. It is a<br />
longdrawnout agony, but there is no new birth<br />
without the necessary pains of labour. We must<br />
pass through this inevitable life-giving, life-sustaining<br />
discipline, fiery though it is. Our countrymen<br />
in South Africa must do the very best without<br />
flinching. If they have the old spirit of resIstance<br />
and cohesion in them, and if they think that the<br />
moment has arrived, they must take up the cross of<br />
suffering. They must be sole judges of their fitness<br />
and of the psychological moment for taking the<br />
plunge. They must know that public opinion of<br />
India is with them. But they WIll also realize that<br />
it is an opinion which is powerless to help them.<br />
They must therefore rely upon their own strength<br />
and capacity for enduring hardships and in 'the<br />
innate justice of their cause.<br />
I ndian Government Still<br />
Negotiating<br />
A. Reuter's message from Simla dated Sept. 14,<br />
states ;-<br />
In the Assembly to-day, numerous Indian members<br />
bombarded the Govel·nment with questiong regarding<br />
the South African situation. Mr. Bhore,<br />
replying OIl behalf of the Government, said they<br />
were still negotiating with the Union Government<br />
for a round,table conference, and they were still<br />
hopeful of a settlement. The were fully alIve to<br />
the grave issues involved, and were trying to<br />
ascertain the wishes of the Indiau reSIdents In<br />
South Africa. The speaker added that the time for<br />
reciprocity measures had not yet arrIved.<br />
Some Interesting Statistics<br />
The following are some iuteresting statistics of<br />
migration to and from the Union for the perIOd 1!)20<br />
to March 1925 which we have extracted from the<br />
report of the Director of Census and StatIstics :-<br />
During the five years 1920-19240, the European<br />
arrivals were in excess of the departures by 31,287.<br />
On the other hand, the Union lost on the balance<br />
13,767 non-Europeans, mostly Indians returning to<br />
India.<br />
The excess of EUI·opean arrivals over departures<br />
fOI· the last two years has been as follows :-<br />
Year.<br />
No. of persons<br />
1923 1,220<br />
1924 1,816<br />
Influx of Lithuanians<br />
The most striking feature of the immigration<br />
figures is the steady and incrE'asing influx of poverty<br />
stricken Lithuanians. The majority of these return<br />
their occupation as "Uommercial" and their finances<br />
as .. below £40" or .. unspecified."<br />
During 1924 they formed 31.9 per cent. of the<br />
total non-British immigration and 9.a per cent. of<br />
the grand total. They exceeded the number of the<br />
next highest foreign nationahty by nearly 51<br />
pen...cent.<br />
'<br />
The foregoing figures are for _ the twelve months<br />
of 1924, but it was not until about the middle of the<br />
year that the restrict,IOns on certain classes of immgrants<br />
were removed. The full effects of the raising<br />
of the embargo would therefore, not be felt until the<br />
first quarter of the current year, when the percentage<br />
rose to 38.4.<br />
The proportion of Lithuanian immigrants not only<br />
1!!20<br />
1921<br />
1922<br />
192:3<br />
H)24o<br />
Europ'ns.<br />
37,IH!1<br />
32.2!!:3<br />
27,2lX<br />
2:3.\'151<br />
2X,6~10<br />
increased considerably during the perioli, but exceeded<br />
the next higbest nationality by 119 per c~nt.<br />
during the quarter.<br />
The following is a summary of all arrivals into<br />
the Union for the period 1920 to March, 1!l25:<br />
Non-<br />
Europ'ns.<br />
2AiO<br />
2,l'\16<br />
2,5~)]<br />
2,4o~l;\<br />
:1,2H<br />
Tota.l.<br />
40.31!)<br />
39,1)79<br />
28,R09<br />
2ti,4H<br />
:n,!l;a<br />
Total 15:3,07L !:J,Gl.! Hi7,.')S.;<br />
To this total must be added (i,50!! Europeans and<br />
non-Europeans for the first quarter of the present<br />
year.<br />
The departUres were:-<br />
Non-<br />
Europ'ns. ElIrop'ns. Tobl.<br />
1920 2!,GX2 -l,X:t! 2~l,5.u<br />
1921 2!,07X li,-l:3X :\0,51;0<br />
1~)22 2!,:1I!! 5,li.; :30,094<br />
1!.l23 22,7:U fi,047 2l'\,7iX<br />
19240 2li.174 4,2SH 31,Oli:J<br />
Totals 122,684 27,:381 150,06:;<br />
to ~hich must be added 7,527 for the fir&t quarter of<br />
the current year.<br />
The arrivals aS9uming domicile and the departures<br />
relinquishing domicile were:<br />
1920<br />
1921<br />
1!.l22<br />
192:3<br />
1!)2.J: •...<br />
Arrivals.<br />
22,09.)<br />
20,!!3:3<br />
13,2:3.)<br />
ll,li41<br />
5,fiOli<br />
Notes and News<br />
Departures.<br />
!!,IH6<br />
1:1,4 71i<br />
12,67;;<br />
17,lili(;<br />
5,648<br />
\\ 1:\ VE reproduce elsewhere in this issue an<br />
\l\l important judgment delivered in the<br />
Pmetown Magistrate Court in the case<br />
of the local Health Committee who sued Mr.<br />
H. M. Wahed for the non-payment of rates<br />
levied by the Committee. This is a Health<br />
Committee formed under the Public Health CommIttees<br />
Ordinance, 1923 against which the Indian<br />
community protested on the grounJs that IndIans<br />
concerned were given no representation on<br />
the Committees and while the election of these<br />
CommIttee!! was to be made from and by the<br />
residents of the DIstrICts concerned Indians in<br />
the Districts were debarred from having any voice<br />
whatsoever. Indians concerned are now testing the<br />
legality of the regulations made under the Ordinance.<br />
It was contended on behalf of the defendant in the<br />
case in qnestion that the rating regulatious were<br />
ultra vires of the powers conferred on the Committee<br />
by the Ordinauce, in that, whereas the Committee<br />
were empowered under Section 17 of the Ordinance<br />
to levy· a rate 011 immovable property ouly, they<br />
levied rates on the purposes to which the buildings<br />
were bemg put. It was fnrther contended that<br />
Section 17 did not give the Committee the right to<br />
select by regulation the type of immovable property<br />
it desired to rate but it gave power to rate genercllly<br />
all immovable properties in its area of jurisdiction.<br />
Judgment was, however, given againet Indllllls the<br />
magistrate holding that Section 17 of the Ordinance<br />
did not limit the powers of the Committee but gave<br />
them authority of a general nature to impoSt' rates;<br />
that ratmg regulations were framed in accordance<br />
with the legislati ve power granted to the Committee<br />
and were tberefore int,a t'tre8. e
September 18th, 19z5 INDIAN OPINION<br />
--~~------~~~--------------<br />
Section 17 of the Public Health Committee's<br />
Ordinance referred to in the above case reads as<br />
follows :-<br />
.. The Committee shall within its area exercise aU<br />
or any of the powers and carry out the duties conferred<br />
or imposed on local authorities onder the<br />
Public Health Act incluliing the levying of rates an,l<br />
imposition of fees and charges for services rendered<br />
• 0, and recovery of such rates, fees and charges from<br />
[<br />
he owners or occupiers of, immovable property<br />
within such arPa."<br />
The case is now on appeal and the Judgment of<br />
the Supreme Court will be awaited with interest.<br />
At a meeting of the Public Health Committee of<br />
the Durban Town Council two interesting matters<br />
relating to the district surrounding the Indian<br />
Market were discussed. In the first instance it was<br />
rPSOlved to rE'commend the Council to arraDl~e for<br />
adequate police supervision at both ends of Victoria<br />
Street for the deviation of vehicular traffic in the<br />
early hours of the morning up to 9 a. m. The<br />
second recommendation was that the Market Master<br />
and the Borough Engineer be asked to report joifItly<br />
on the utilisation of the site of the old Native<br />
Women's Hostel in Victoria StrE'et as an Indian<br />
Bazaar for the saJe of soft goods and merchandise,<br />
together with full estimate of costs.<br />
Our attention has been drawn to the omiBBion in<br />
the list of the newly E'lected officials of the Natal<br />
Indian Congress for the ensuing year published in<br />
onr last weeks iB8ue of the name of the hon. auditor<br />
Mr. Sapurjee Jivanjee who was also re-elected.<br />
It is with deep regret that we have to record the<br />
sad and sudden death which took place in Durban last<br />
Wednesday of Mr. Hajee Ismail AboohakE'l' tJle son of<br />
the late Mr. Abooliaker IIajee Amod Jhaveri the<br />
first Indian merchant to come to South Africa. The<br />
funeral of the late Mr. Hajee Ismail which took<br />
place at 5 o'clock in the afternoon was attended by<br />
a huge crowd of Indians among whom were many<br />
prominent merchants. The late Mr. Hajee Ismail<br />
leaves behind him a sorrowing widow and three<br />
children of whom the eldest is only about fifteen<br />
years of age. We extend our dE'epest sympathy to the<br />
bereaved family and other relatives including the<br />
diceased's uncle Mr. Omar Hajee Aml)d Jhaveri.<br />
THE FATE OF THE INDIAN IN THE UNION<br />
~ UR contemporary the rWlnd Daily Alail is<br />
~ startlell at the movement of the Indian<br />
community against the Asiatic Bill and evi.<br />
dently deplores the fact that no effort is being made<br />
by the white people of South Africa to counteract<br />
the movement. Speaking on the Bill itself the<br />
paper says, .. there is little doubt that it represents<br />
• • • • what may be called the moderate<br />
South African view in regard to the Indian<br />
question." This, it goes on to say, is a fact<br />
which should be made known to the world and<br />
} supported by the resolution!! of as many public<br />
bodies as possible. .. Otherwise the very great activity<br />
of the propagandists will seriously increase the<br />
difficulties of the SItuation by inflaming Indian<br />
opinion against us and possibly also by creating an<br />
unfavourable impression in other lands. "<br />
We must confess that our experience is quite<br />
different to that of our contemporary. The majority<br />
of the British people in the Union, we feE'1 sure, are<br />
thoroughly ashamed of the measure introduced by<br />
PI', lIal)fl, We "l't1tt>~ IU\re \hal .~"'''I) J) ... ~11l1an •<br />
tNt t~ •• 1I~"bn.lbul ,Ii; tlnh''!. thtj fiIIt _tl"~ hDt<br />
aware that they were ,;oIating every principle of<br />
British jnstice.~ Although they may be reluctant to<br />
IIpeak out we know that there is a large majority of<br />
Europeans in this country who will be proud to see<br />
Intlians fighting against the Bill than meekly<br />
surrE'ndering, which if they do they will have proved<br />
by th\'ir own actiou that they deservetl such a<br />
m\'a'lUre and they will have none but themselves<br />
to bLlme. Since the watchword of our contemporary<br />
is .. self-preservation" it is but natnral that<br />
jnstice and fairplay cannot be found in its vocabulary<br />
and, in the circumstances, it is not at all surpl'ismg<br />
to see it preaching counteraction to establish<br />
an injustice. Be that as it may. We have now to<br />
consider what future action we have to take. The<br />
ways of thE' Indian Govornment seem to be very<br />
mistE'rious indeed. In reply to questions put to the<br />
Government in connection with the Indian question<br />
,in South Africa the Government are reported to<br />
have said that they were still negotiating with. the<br />
Union Government for a Round Table Conference;<br />
that they were fully alIve to the grave issues involved<br />
and WE're trying to ascertain the wishes of<br />
the Inthans in South Africa. The Indian Government<br />
are lU negotiation with the Union Government<br />
now for at least a year, if not more, and not a word is<br />
known as to the result of the negotiations. While<br />
these negotiations are going on the position of Indians<br />
is growing from bad to worse. This fact bas<br />
been declared over and over again and a Round<br />
Table Conference has been asked for over and over<br />
again by the Indian community iu South Africa.<br />
The much respected President of the South African<br />
Ir.dian Congress Mrs. Sarojini Naidu has also<br />
strongly pressed for such a Conference and yet the<br />
Indian Government who profess to be alive to the<br />
grave situation do not know the wishes of Indians<br />
iu South Africa! Is this not a reply merely to<br />
evade the issue, we wonder?<br />
India has become the un favourite child of the<br />
Imperilll Government as she is asking for her rightful<br />
place in the family, and the Indian Government<br />
represents the Imperial Government in India. If,<br />
therefore, we receive a cold shoulder from both these<br />
quarters it is not at all to be wondered at. We have<br />
then, only to look to the Indian people. and they are<br />
already suffering and our cause in this country only<br />
adds to their suffering. They can only suffer for<br />
us and do no more.<br />
We, however, should not leave a single stone<br />
nntumed to get redress by constitutional means.<br />
We should approach the Indian and Imperial Governments<br />
until they are thoroughly conversant with<br />
our wishes--and what other wish could we have<br />
than to be treated as British citizens with respect<br />
due to us ? Nothing more do we ask of the Imperial.,<br />
Indian or the Union Governments. If in that we<br />
receive a cold shoulder and even in our very<br />
moderate' demand for a Round Table Conference<br />
then our last resort is to suffer relying, as Mahatma<br />
Gandhi says, upon our own strength and capacity<br />
for enduring hardships and in the innate justice of<br />
our cause.<br />
The Natal Indians have bad their protest meetinll, -<br />
the Transvaal Indians have had theirs. The CaP" In.<br />
ollllns b"u 1'0$ fet t'ai@ed .,,1Johed voj,,~, 1. ~ time<br />
i118' ,hit Cape Hrht ... ln41aft 0"."9" .'ftti1~ «~ iJltl
INOl \N OPINION September 18th. 1925<br />
matter. And then the South African IndIan Congress<br />
should hold its session wIthout delay ,md<br />
make joint representahons m the name of the<br />
Indians of the Union as a whole to the Union,<br />
IndIan and the Imperial Governments for a Hound<br />
Table Conference.<br />
Health Committees Ordinance<br />
Judgment Against Indians<br />
\ Notice of Appeal Given<br />
At the Magistrate's Court, Pinetown, on Tuesd,lY<br />
the 8th instant, Mr. J. T. Braatvedt, Assistant IvLtglstrate,<br />
delivered judgment m the case in whIch the><br />
Pmetown Health CommIttee sued an Indian H M.<br />
Wahed, agent, for the non-payment of £9 alleged<br />
to be due in respect of rates levIed by plamtIffs<br />
Mr. E. F. Wilcocks appeared for the plamtIff:;,<br />
and Mr. H. F. V. Dymes for the defendant.<br />
In giving judgment the MagIstrate saId· The<br />
Pinetown Pubhc Health CommIttee, as plamtIffs,<br />
claim a sum of £9 for rates levIed by them npon<br />
defendant as the owner of certain dwellmg" and<br />
stores wlthm the area of the jurIsdictIOn of then'<br />
committeE'. The defence of the claIm IS based upon<br />
the following grounds -<br />
(1) That the plaintiff commIttee was not lawfully<br />
constituted at the time the rates were passed or<br />
adopted, by reasou of the (act that cert",in two<br />
vacancies whICh had occurred after the cOJlJmittee<br />
had been constituted had not been filled by one or<br />
other of the two methods of oblIgatory procedure<br />
prescribed by Ordmance No.7 of 1923; and that lU<br />
any event the two'casual vacancies have never been<br />
lawfully filled, in that ProclamatIOn No. 22, 1924,<br />
purporting to appomt Messrs. Trotter and HIrst, was<br />
not promulgated as required by SectIOn 5 of the<br />
Ordinance, and is therefore of no valid effect.<br />
(2) AlternatIvely, and in the event of It, bemg<br />
held that the plaintiff commIttee was lawfully constituted,<br />
defendant demes hablhty, and contends<br />
that the ratmg regulatIOns are ultra Vlres of the<br />
powers conferred on the plaintlff commIttee by<br />
the Ordinance, as amended by Ordinance No 6.<br />
1924, 111 that, whereas the pblntiff commIttee were<br />
empowered under SectIOn 17 of the Ordmance to<br />
levy a rate on lmmovable property only, yet they<br />
have levied rates on d wellmg" and bmldmgs used<br />
for store, shop, or business purposes, thereby levymg<br />
rates not on the lmmovable property, but on the<br />
purposes to which the buildings are bemg put. And,<br />
further, contends that the regulations are unreasonable<br />
and bad in law, in that the pow.er to rate immovable<br />
property glven by SectIOn 17 does not gIve<br />
the plaintiffs the right to select by regulatIOn the<br />
type of immovable property it desires to rate, but IS<br />
It power to rate generally all immovable propertIes<br />
in its area of jurisdiction. Defendant further cont.ends<br />
that the ratmg regulatIOns are partial and unequal<br />
in their operation as between classes in the<br />
area, and are manifestly unjust by rating only<br />
dwelling houses and busmess premises, and by<br />
rating these in/an unequal and
September J~hb, 1925 INDIAN OPINION<br />
merely thieves and robbers, was one of the bitter<br />
taunts uttered against the Government whose administration<br />
practically all the Indian speakers<br />
condemned, when the TJegislative AB8embly re!!umed<br />
the debate on Sir AleLlnder l\fuddiman's resolution,<br />
proposing acceptance of the Majority Report<br />
of the R~fonns InqOlry Committee.<br />
Eventually an amendment by Pundit Motilal Nehru<br />
advocating that total responsibility should be invested<br />
in the legislature with the traditional reservatons<br />
in respect of the army and foreign affairs, WJ.8<br />
(asfled bs 72 votes to 4.'). Sir Alexauder Muddiman<br />
Uescribed the amendment as a virtual repeal of the<br />
Government of India Act, and admitted that, 8S it<br />
delloted for first time that the Swarajists and Indepedents<br />
were in agreement, it deserved the utmost<br />
attention.<br />
Simla, Sept. l3.-The Council of State by 2a<br />
votes to 7 carried the Government resolution endorsing<br />
the conclusions of the Majority Report of<br />
the Mllddiman Committee.<br />
Proposed Indianisation of High<br />
Commissioner's Office<br />
Simla. Sept. S.-The Council of State has animatedly<br />
debated a resolution put forward by .the<br />
unofficial member, Sethna, in favour of the Indianisation<br />
of the staff of the High Commissioner in London.<br />
The mover complained that at prescnt only G<br />
per cent. of the staff were Indians, despite the fact<br />
that the Department was maintained by the Indian<br />
Exchequer.<br />
Mr. Chadwick (Secretary for Commerce) pointed<br />
out that it was not a business proposition to send<br />
Indians at a huge expense to England, when better<br />
qualified Englishmen were available there.<br />
The High CommiB8ionel'. Sir chatterjee, had informed<br />
the Government that he was appointmg Indians<br />
wherevf>r possible.<br />
An amendment moved by Sir Maneckjee Dadabhoy,<br />
to the effect that Indianisation, compatible<br />
with efficiency and economy. should occur in the<br />
higher staff establishment, was carried by 26 votes<br />
to eight.<br />
The Iodiao in the U olon<br />
The RanlZ Dail!l Mail has the following leading<br />
article in its issue of the 12th instant ;-<br />
The report, published elsewhere in this issue, of<br />
the debate in the Indian Council of State on the<br />
position of Indians in South· Africa touches on a<br />
matter of really grave importance to the Union. The<br />
tone of the speeches makes plain the intensity of<br />
public feeling in India with regard to this matter.<br />
It is a feeling which may easily be fanned into a<br />
pession of resentment. In South Africa a strong<br />
Indian movement is vigorously a foot to provoke<br />
counter-action in India, and also, if possible. in Great<br />
13ritain. The question is one which. even under<br />
the very best conditions, involves serious and farreaching<br />
reactions, and it is in every sense desirable<br />
that it should rEceive the most thoughtful and<br />
'earn est consideration by the white peoples of South<br />
Africa.<br />
The problem is pie-eminently one which we must<br />
settle for ourselves. In the final resort we must decide<br />
the issue upon the basis of self-preservation. But in<br />
the meantime every possible endeavour should be<br />
made to negotiate a settlement along lines which will<br />
not unduly offend Indian susceptibilities or aggravate<br />
the difficulties of Great Britain so far as her Indian<br />
Empire is concerned. The speeches in the Indian<br />
CQ~l indicate _ that an attitude favour'd.ble to<br />
negotiation exists, and it would be a blunder of the<br />
first magnitude on our p:lrt to close the door<br />
against it.<br />
But we do not think this will be done. In introducing.<br />
at the end of last session. the areas Reservation<br />
and Immigration Bill. Dr. Malan. in a very<br />
reasonable and tactful speech, said he was not sorry<br />
f.)r its introduction at that late stage, because it<br />
would afford the country as a whole an opportunity<br />
of learning the policy 01 the Government, and aliilO<br />
of offering constructive criticism. which he personlIy<br />
would gladly welcome. We do not know what<br />
helpful suggestions, if any. may have reached the<br />
:\Iinister since he issued his invitation, bnt recent<br />
developments. both in South Africa and India, make<br />
It very plain that it is high time an earnest effort<br />
was made definitely to mObilise public opinion on<br />
this subject. Indian propaganda is being actively<br />
c')nducted over a very wide area, and. so far as we<br />
can see. no effort at all is being made by the white<br />
peoples of South Africa to counteract it. Failnre to<br />
t.lke any action along these lines may quite easily<br />
plunge us into a nasty mess of far-reaching pohtical<br />
complications before we know where we are. And<br />
-we cannot afford to blunder into a crisis of this<br />
nature with our eyes shut.<br />
•<br />
The BIll is available to the public and it shonld<br />
have the closest scrutiny in all its details, As Dr.<br />
~[alan says. it will not satIsfy the extreme section<br />
of either school of thought III South AfrIca, for very<br />
wisely, he has tried to steel' the sdfe and the sane<br />
middle course. But, broadly speaking, there is<br />
httle doubt that it represents with substantial accurdCY<br />
what may be called the moderate South Africln<br />
view with rpgard to the Indian question as it affects<br />
ns in the Union. ThiS IS a fact which should be<br />
kuown to the world and supported by the resolutIOns<br />
of as many public bodies as possible. Otherwise the<br />
very great aetivity of the propagandists will seriously<br />
increase the difficulties of the situation by inflaming<br />
Indian opinion against us, and possibly also by<br />
creating an unfavourable impression in other lands.<br />
A RepJy<br />
Mr. L. W. Ritch has sent the following reply to<br />
the Rand DiIIl y M {Itt ;-<br />
The Editor, "Rand Daily Mail" Johannesburg.<br />
SIr. - May I be allowed to expreBl! concurrence<br />
iu your opinion" that this question is one which it<br />
is desirable ...... should receive the most thoughtful<br />
and earnest consideration of the white peoples<br />
of South Africa." Also with the implIcation that<br />
so far it has not. To the avel'age South African the<br />
question app£:ars to be just a matter of putting the<br />
.. coolies" into locations. getting rid of their competition<br />
in bus' ness and gpuerally putting them<br />
.. into their place" among the colourl'd and native<br />
sections, unless better still, they can be "persuaded"<br />
to clear out of the country altogether. Now it mu~t<br />
be confessed that this is a very free and easy. and<br />
rather parochial, way of regarding a Ricia! question<br />
that is by no means {'urely a local one. but on the<br />
other hand, one which touches to the quick the<br />
amoul propre of three hundred millions of British<br />
subjects just across the Indian Ocean, not to mention<br />
several hnndreds of mIllions of Non-British Orientals<br />
represented here by only a small sprinkling of their<br />
peoples. It takes but a very tiny flame to start a<br />
most destructive conflagration. and when the elements<br />
of combustion are already well advanced bnt<br />
little additional heat for the fire to bnrst into flamE's.<br />
Racial and National pride are dangerous explosives<br />
to fool with, as Russia~learn_e$ W her cost in her<br />
collision with Japan and only' a fool could oontem.-<br />
- _ • If"
plate with il.ldiffetence the prospeot of an armed cla!lh<br />
between East and 'West. The last War ( 1914-1918)<br />
would be a more game of toy soldiers compared with<br />
such a cataclysm! It 1,\ fairly obvious, t4erefore,<br />
that consict~rat1ons of e:wed~enc¥ alone demand that<br />
this questioPr be ~ndled ,witp Athe utmpst tl\ct, and<br />
restraint and that sq fa,r ;from i~ J;)eing solely a<br />
domestiC? ma~ter touchiJ?g South Afn,caI.! ipterests.<br />
our share in it is that of a cO!p.p.<br />
and So we joined is-sue altd fought .a'l1d laid the dead<br />
bodies of our dear ohes on the altllr of Ptinciples<br />
that the enemy sneer~u at as ronialitic and unpractical.<br />
1£ 'prmciple W~l'e 'tnyn so Illucli in:~re pre"Clqus<br />
BiShop Fisher<br />
- ~~t I<br />
After spending a very busy wee\c during which<br />
they visited m~ny places in and outside Durban in<br />
connection with the Indiljon question and iu~erviewed<br />
'proinintlnt members of both European and Iqdian<br />
~<br />
mmUnities Bishop and Mrs risher sailed last Monay<br />
by the s, s. }VW,lldalla for Dem Goa &y. The<br />
( istinguished visitors were seen off by a l,u'ge crowd.<br />
icell of the Natal<br />
rdian Congress at thl) Parsee Rustq~ee Hall. Mr.<br />
dvocate J. -W. Godfrey was in the chair. After<br />
ealing at length with the nUII1erical condition of<br />
tbe dlffe!:ent races and thed' progreaa tl1e Bishod<br />
rlictur.ed the problem l!.B. a very grave one and<br />
~ound up by saying thllt he feared otllj one thine<br />
and that was 3nimolJs-it,y and mIsunderstandingS. He<br />
lIelievM that if in South Africa, IMia and Europe<br />
the~ were to see that every , man woman and child of<br />
all the races had equal opportunities. they would /la.ve<br />
fbor ,less diffi culty tha'l1 if they attempted td rel3trict<br />
$6 another iu every ",ay. Tbe onl) solution. sa.id<br />
the speaker, was to make the standard of life absol~tely<br />
universal so that one would not be higher. or<br />
one lower. ,<br />
[We hope to publish the full text of the lecture<br />
in a later issue. Ed.]<br />
SermohS<br />
dn Sonday Bishop gnd Mrs. Fisher Were in "ited bt<br />
Mr. R. K; NiUdtlo to the wedding of hil! -doughter<br />
ahd alsti to amner by the Majh1ulll Ahbab Club-an<br />
i~stitution where prominent Indian merchants 1Ulsemble.<br />
Bishop Fisher also gave very interesting<br />
ahd instructive surl110ns in the morning at the Greyville<br />
Wesleyan methodist Church, in the afternoon<br />
at the Indian We~leY!l!n Church in Grey Stroot and<br />
in the ev~rtlng a.t the West 8t\-eet WeSl'eyan Chllrch.<br />
Speaking emotionally the Bishop said that though<br />
they professed Christianity they had nothing to<br />
p~ove that they were true Christians. The image<br />
of Chirst was no longer within their hearts. Non<br />
Clllist13ns had gained, a bet.ter knowledge. of<br />
Christ and His Principles than Christians theIWlel vea<br />
a~' d they were in_ a ,position now to rebllke, the<br />
C ristians for violating the principles for which<br />
t ey professed to ,stand. If they wished to<br />
C ristaia.nize the world they would themselves have<br />
to live like trne Christians.<br />
I Indians as a rule are hot allowed in European<br />
Chuwhes but an exception was made on this<br />
occasioh and it was rendered possible. therefore,<br />
fQr a few who were anxious to hear the Bishop to<br />
attend the services.<br />
1 He' '? 1 • .. !.<br />
to us th~~ ~~p~~ienci, whf s~ould i~ be otber,W1i!e<br />
now? Or can it 1;>e that the brute ill 'Us reasserts Tqe Natal tndian 'Congr~s have puhlished the<br />
itself when we feel we aI'e safe and the Angel in Us<br />
Asiatic BIll in a book form with a fair comment on<br />
the Bill showing how adver~ely it affects t4e BritiJIh<br />
only when we feel 'the knife at Our throat!! ?<br />
Iddijln c~Innl-~nity _ in th{" Vniop. ,of South ~f,lca:<br />
Let lis pot lightly igrla~eJli'e lesson of history qut These hookle'ts are beIng sent out to Indian leaders/<br />
rather CQ~~e~iP~r'i~1s\l w~~t~~r. we ,IUaY not by and sympathisers in india. ~gland and oth,er ~rtB .....<br />
our conducf'pe ~lling on-.J4\ F~e~,' that, !,~_e ,~urr of the worJd., 1~ order to cover, the cost o~.prlntiTli<br />
destiJ.ties to "flet us yet one mote, lI.nd,\,>'iWcllt)Jice':<br />
the nogk is"pnc~d la.
September 18th, 1925<br />
Il"OlAN OPiNION<br />
i~~E(~~:(~~~)~~;t~;~~~t»;"'»>~<br />
~ [ FROM OUR OWY CORRESPOYDEXT ]<br />
~ 13th August, 1925. ~<br />
o E« 0<br />
Parliament has now voted the nece88.lry authority<br />
for the payment of the coal subsidy for the next<br />
nine monthK. during which time, it is hoped. the<br />
Hltions involvetl in the coal tlispute wIll be<br />
~ netl. The Royal Commission on the subject is<br />
not yet appointetl nor the terms of reference publitlhetl.<br />
But the subject still occupies consitlerable<br />
space in the press of the country.<br />
M. Briand, the French l\Unister, left Lontlon to-day<br />
for Paris, aftE'r having consultations with Mr.<br />
Austen Chamberlain. and other Ministers of the<br />
Crown. The object of the consultations was in regard<br />
to the proposeu Pact Treaty between Germany<br />
and the Allied Powers in connection with Western<br />
Europe. Both Ministers appear to be highly satisfied<br />
with the result of their conservations. Details,<br />
however, are not yet made public.<br />
A Hundred have passed since the birth of R. D.<br />
Blackmore, the author of several novels, the m08t<br />
famous being, Lorna Doone, A DevonshIre Ro-<br />
• mance, The Wild Men of the Wild Valleys of Exmoor,<br />
published in 1869 it was slow in attractmg<br />
attention, but it eventually gained in popularIty,<br />
which has yet to decline. The authol" was, however,<br />
prouder of his success at hIS choHen calling, that of<br />
market gardener, than of the fact that hundreds of<br />
thousands wantetl to read, what he considered the<br />
best of his novels.<br />
The great trial arising out of a breach of the State<br />
Law of Tennessee, which forbids the teaching of<br />
any matter, which questions the Bible in any way,<br />
which took place at Dayton, otherwise known as<br />
Monkeyville, presents some remarkable features.<br />
There was Dothing of tl:ie formality associated<br />
with the conduct of a Court. Counsel sat<br />
without coat or waist coat, the Judge stood<br />
up and posed in a commanding attitude at the<br />
request of press photographers, and he permitted<br />
the final session of the Court to be held in the open<br />
air. The Counsel for the defence, Mr. Darron,<br />
apologised for having "sassed" the writ Cw previous<br />
day, and the judge in ~accepting apology solemnly<br />
forgave him, on behalf of the I'C'ople of Tennessee<br />
as a Christian duty.<br />
While spectators che\\, 1 gum, S11loked and<br />
patronised the vendors of soft drInk::! Connsel for<br />
the defence called Connsel for the prosecution to<br />
the witness box and ploceeded to cross examine him<br />
on his religious beliefs, WIth the purpose of making<br />
him appear as fooh"h as pOSSIble. The judge, notwithst..'1.ndin::,<br />
being appealed to, allowed this extraordlDary<br />
procooure, but after Mr. Bryan the prosecuting<br />
Counsel had glven his views on the literal<br />
acceptance of tho book of Genesis, the farce was<br />
carrle,l a stage fllrth.::r by expunging the whole of<br />
his eviJence from the record. Such a trial in a<br />
Bl'iti"h country would have only brought those who<br />
were concerned with it into contempt. Dayton,<br />
however, seems to hJ.ve acceptt'ti them quite seriously<br />
and the idea of trying the BIble as a work of scienti<br />
.-l,refel'ence, by a Court of Law, does not appear<br />
to have had any aspect of absurdity for judge, jury,<br />
counselor spectator's, ,<br />
Mustafa Kemal Pasha, the Turkish Presi,dent, has<br />
informed his Government that he divorced his wife<br />
Latifa Hanon on August 5th, but the reason for<br />
the divorce does not appeal' in the reports publisl ed<br />
here. Madame Kemal is the daughter of one of the<br />
principal merchants of Smyrn,ll. she is a leader of<br />
the Western EmancilMtion Movement among Turkish<br />
women, educated for a time at Tudor Hall<br />
lSchOQl Qhisl~p-'urst.in England. she was brol1l,:lIt- 'Up<br />
by an English governess, and later spent some years<br />
in France. She is now only 22. When she became<br />
engagt'ti to Kemal, she ordered her brIdal robes in<br />
Paris, thus bidding goodbye to the Yashmak, and<br />
the eastern cnstom of veiling the face. She accompar.ied<br />
her husband everywhere, and frequently discarded<br />
skirts, for riding breeches and top boo~<br />
About IS months ago Madame Kemal was instrumental<br />
in saving her husband's life. A visitor<br />
called at their villa and asked to see the President.<br />
Madame became suspicious and ordered the VIsitor<br />
to wait. A moment later a bomb was thrown, and<br />
she was BOunded.<br />
DUling King Feisul's absence from Bagdad, for<br />
health reasons, in Europe, his brother. the Eniir<br />
Said, who is an undergraduate at Oxford, wIll act as<br />
Regent, and for this purpose he is now on his way<br />
to Baghdad from Oxford.<br />
•<br />
The Maharajah Singh, deputed by the Govert'.<br />
ment of India to report on the Ind18ns in Manritius,<br />
recommends the stoppage of unskilled Indian immigration<br />
to the Island. According to the census of<br />
1921, out of a total population of 37G,935 persons in<br />
MauritIUS, 248,468 were returned as Indo-Mauritus,<br />
that is. persons of Indian descent born in Mauritius<br />
and 17.506 as other Indians.<br />
'<br />
The passing away of Sir t::lurendranath Bannerjea<br />
at Barrackpore, in Calcutta, removes one of the<br />
pioneers of Indian National Movement. Though he<br />
was not of the Swarajist Party, he nevertheless was<br />
the patriot who will go down in Indian history, as<br />
one of the great sons of India. HIS autobiography,<br />
.. A Nation in the making" bemg the reminiscenoes<br />
of fifty years of publio hfe in Bengal, published by<br />
the Oxford Universlty Press, desei'ves to be read by<br />
every Indian.<br />
The projected visit of the Secretary for War, to<br />
IndIa iI! cancelled owing to pressure of offiCIal business<br />
in London. Sir S. L. Evans the Secretary, had<br />
planned to lecl.ve for Ind18 in 8eptember and to be<br />
present at the Northern Manoevres in India; returning<br />
to England early next year. It is considered that<br />
four months is too long a perIOd for the War Secretary<br />
to be absent.<br />
Mahatma Gandhi's Birthday<br />
Celebrations<br />
Mahatma Gcl.ndhl's flfty sixth birthday was cele.<br />
bra ted last monday evening at the Parjee Rustomjee<br />
Hall, Queen Street, Durban, under the joiqt auspices<br />
of Natal Indian Congress and the Kathiawad Arta<br />
MandaI. 'l'here was a large gathering of Indians<br />
and some European ladies including Mrs. Andrew,<br />
Mrs. Fernandez, Miss E. Kundsen, and Miss Warner.<br />
Mahatma Gandhi's photo decorated with flowers<br />
was placed on the plJ.tform. The procE'edings commenced<br />
with the singing of national songs by school<br />
children under the guid,mce of Mr. A. 'N. Gosalia.<br />
Pundit Bhawani Dayal who \vas in the chair then<br />
described, in the course of an eloquent sp~ech in<br />
Hindustani. the exceptional qualities of Mahatma<br />
Gandhi and the services he was rendering the Motherland.<br />
Speeches were also made by Messrs O. H. A.<br />
Jhaveri. V. Lawrence, A. H. Kazi, M. 1. Kajee .. Raghavjee<br />
Rughnath, V. D. Mehta, B. l\I. Patel," Mrs.<br />
Andrew and<br />
Miss Kundsen praising Mahatma<br />
Gandhi's work and wishing him long hfe.<br />
The meeting terminated with the singing of National<br />
songs by the children and three hearty cheers<br />
for Mahatma Gandhi.<br />
Message of Congratulations<br />
, The following cable was ssnt to Mahatma Gund4
INDIAN OPINION<br />
September 18th I Q ! S<br />
on his hirlhday, by Mr. Amou Bayat, presluent N,ttal<br />
IndIan Congress.:-<br />
" Natal Indians sends gl'eetinf,'il on yonr fiUY-Slxth<br />
birthday. Pray Almighty grant yon long life anll<br />
ha~piness."<br />
Anniversary of Gandhi Library<br />
and Rustomjee Hall<br />
A European L~dy's<br />
Appreciation<br />
Mrs. Helen Calland Andrew wrItes to us from<br />
Durban :-\<br />
It was a real pleasure to me to be prl?seqt at<br />
the above annivarsary, and to hear of the work<br />
done by the Indian community for the upliftmen~<br />
of their people. The beautiful collection of books,<br />
the many periodicals, dallies, which are placed at<br />
the disposal of the people, just shows how Indians<br />
who, instead of being the ignorant pariahs as so<br />
many Europeans think are most intelligent farseemg<br />
people, an(i are kept well posted up as to what IS<br />
hatlpening everywhere. But, what to me was the<br />
most refreshing part of that meeting, were the manly<br />
utterances made by Bishop Fisher, he boldly says, he<br />
is a blallChed Iudian f He 1
~pjllilllt<br />
ll.ecioterei at 1M G .... O' u a ...... per<br />
' .. ea ,.O .... ~UI<br />
CAMfA.lG.N AG.AINST ASlATIC BIL~<br />
~~~~~~~:~~~ .~NGAAT ~NDIANS SQJ~~~O~T ~ONGRESS<br />
N aooor&nee wiffi a reso!ntlon p8Slled by the; the Bill and in doing so said, that copies of the Bill<br />
IT<br />
Committee of -the-Natal Indian Congress the to~etlle~ wjth an explanation were sent to all the<br />
, latter has QOmmenced a vigorous campaign memberS or the rmperial Parliament and to the<br />
agaiIUlt the Asiatic, BUL<br />
l,eac)ers and sympatbisers in llidia, 'England and<br />
, IMet.tingB were organised nnder the auspices' of the elsewhere and Cables were also sent td 'the cost of<br />
,CongreB81ast Sunday lJt Stanger and l'o~t to ex- over £50., ·The speaKer exhorted 'the people to rise<br />
pla!n the. terIWt of ~he.obnoxlou.e Bjll to tbe IDdian~ l'~P fA? the ~c~ion and support the 'CongreB8 in upl'e8ldeQ,t<br />
In, those d~tnC)ts.<br />
holding the .honour of India.<br />
Stanger Meeting • . Mr. I!- ~ ~aidoo explained the terms of th.e Bill<br />
- , 10 'l'anul.<br />
AllLrge and fully representaijve mooting of Mr. S. N. Amin then moved the following 1'esolu-<br />
,Stanger lnwans was held'at 1: p.m. on the football tion :- .<br />
grounds. ' Among those present \vera 1t!essr8. W. R. "This Mass Meeting of Lower Tugela and Dis~ct<br />
BodasinJ' Rajdev Bodasingh, 8adal Shah, llampartal, Indians beld nnder the anspices of the Natal Indian<br />
~ishanslDgli-all well-known farmers and land - Congress nereby approves of all that the Natal Inowntrs,<br />
'and Messrs. EBBOP Ebrahim Gangat, M: E. d,ian CongreB8 has hitherto done with regard to the<br />
Gangat, IIiIln3U E. Gangali, A. I. Jinnah, Jil. ¥. ~O()lla, protest against the Areas Reservation' and Immi<br />
E.l\{. Ma,itller, S. N. Anrln and' other representative gration and Registration (Further Provision) Bill<br />
merchants' Q! the pistrict. There wer~ present also and .further records its confidence in the Natal In<br />
,tJie following representatives of 'the CongreBB:- dian CongreB8"<br />
.Messrs. Pandit Bhawani Dayal, Advocate J. W. Mr. Satyadev explained the resolution in Hindu-<br />
Godfre~, (Vice-Presidents), Sorabjee Rustomjee stani.<br />
(Secretary), A. t. 1\ajee, M. '13eethasee MaMraj, Mr. P.1;.uke seconded -the resolutiou and being<br />
M. Y. Gandhi, R. K. Naidoo and Satyadev. 'randit put before the meeting it was paBSed unanimously<br />
Bhawani Dayal was ~ the chair. ' amidst loud applause.<br />
'~f~i the 'chairman h3.d explaine4. the 'Qpject Of :rJi-. A. I. Kajee condemned the action of the<br />
~e meeting A4vocate J. vy. Godfrey gave a' resume, Government and the attitude of the white man<br />
of the Bill in ~ngIish and explained how detri- / fpwards the Indian. As long as' the Indian rementally<br />
it would affect the Indian communltt if p13iqed in' 'ihis country as "hewer of wood and<br />
ever it ~ere allowed to pass. He urged the people ,drawer of water" he was not objectionable, 'said the<br />
'to iptefe~~'~}lems~lv~~' in the B.ill and 'supp
'jng which was most enthusiastic throughout the<br />
~proceedings and filled with indignation against the<br />
action of the Government came to a termination<br />
with three cheers for Mahatma Gandhi.<br />
At the close of the meeting copies of the Asiatic<br />
'Bill were sold and within a few minutes the stock<br />
in hand at the moment was found to be too small<br />
for the great demand.<br />
Members of -the Congress Committee were then<br />
generously entertained by Mr. A. I. Jheena at his<br />
residence to dinner after which they motored to<br />
Tongaat to address another meeting called at the<br />
Gokhale Me'f0rial Hall at 3 p.m.<br />
Tongaat Meeting<br />
On arrival at the Hall it was found packed<br />
to overflowing by every section of the community.<br />
Pandit Bhawani Dayal took the chair and among<br />
the prominent merchants were present Messrs.<br />
Ayob Say a, Ayob Sacoor, Habib Hassan. A. A.<br />
Gandhi, M. G. _ Naidoo and others. Mr. qodfrey<br />
explained the Bill in English and the chairman<br />
spoke lengthily on the Bill in Hindustani.<br />
The chairman's speech was followed by the description<br />
by Mr. Sorabjee Rustomjee. of the work already<br />
done in connection with the Bill.<br />
Mr. R. K. Naidoo spoke in Tamil and Mr. M. M.<br />
Gandhi in Hindustani.<br />
Mr. E. J. Choonoo then moved the following<br />
resolution :-<br />
" That this Mass Meeting of Tongaat and Diatrict<br />
Indians held under the auspices of the Natal Indian<br />
Congress at the Gokhale Memorial Hall. Tongaat,<br />
hereby hpartily records its absolute confidence in all<br />
the Congress work as regards the Areas Reservation<br />
and Immigration and Registration (Further Provision)<br />
Bill. "<br />
In the conrse of his speech Mr. Ohoonoo said, he<br />
had been a Congressman since 1910. He took part<br />
in fighting against the three guineas membership<br />
fee and he was glad to find that that fee had now<br />
been reduced to 213. 6d. Speaking on the Asiatic<br />
Bill the speaker said, Bills of this kind, however<br />
bad, they were a blessing in disguise, as they united<br />
the community, and concluded with the words I "I<br />
have faith in the Oongress, in all that it has done<br />
and is going to do." The Oongress officials were<br />
not paid servants but they were voluntary w~rkers<br />
said the speaker.<br />
Mr. A. A. Gandhi seconded the resolution and<br />
Mr. M. G. Naidoo supported it speaking in Tamil.<br />
Messrs. Devchand Harakhchand, A. R. Singh,<br />
Appanna Naidoo and Molvi Essop also spoke in<br />
lupport of the resolution.<br />
Mr. Molvi Essop in the course of his remarks<br />
said it was the duty of every Indian to become a<br />
member of- the Oongress and to support it heartily<br />
in fighting against the Bill.<br />
The resolution was then'put to the meeting and<br />
was passea unanimously amidst lIce~es of great enthusiasm.<br />
Mr. A. I. Kajee in the course of his remarks said<br />
Dr. Malan was Minister of religion and the religion<br />
he 'represented said: "Thou shall not steal," but the<br />
Minister was going to steal their land through this'<br />
Bill. This country owed its present prosperous<br />
eondition to Indians. Speaking alone, said the<br />
speaker, 'Wonld not do but something else was r~quired<br />
and it was to be hoped that when the hour<br />
-came, the people would be prepared for that.<br />
Mr. M. B. Maharaj said it was time to wake up<br />
.from onr slumber or else the time would com~· for<br />
",us to leave the country bag and baggage.<br />
wa ,Mr. Satyauev exhorted ~he people to wake up and<br />
help ~rt the Oongress without flinching. '<br />
" meeting terminated with hearty votes of<br />
'l,the Tongaat ,Indians who had responded<br />
'gress and ro. the Oongress officials for the<br />
were doing. Three hearty cheers were 1<br />
~- INDIAN OPINION September 25th, 1925_<br />
give!! for Mahatma Gandhi and Shrimati Sarojini<br />
Naida.<br />
At the end of the meeting Indians were very<br />
keen on becoming members of the Oongress and<br />
arrangements were made to enrol them.<br />
Other meetings of a similar nature will be held<br />
by the Natal Indian Oongress throughout the Province<br />
of Natal to educate the Indian public and stir<br />
them to a realisation of what this Bill means and<br />
further to make united protest agaiust the Bill<br />
through the South African Indian Congress.<br />
Nates and News<br />
~ S advertised elsewhere in this issue a mass...<br />
En meeting of the Indian CQmmunity of Olairwood<br />
and Districts will be held at the Clairwood<br />
Indian School grounds on Sunday the 27th<br />
September, 1925 at 2-30 p.m. when members of the<br />
Natal Indian Congress will explain the provisions<br />
of the Asiatic Bill now before Parliament.<br />
The Natal Indian Congress officials have taken up<br />
its propaganda work in connection with the Asiatic<br />
Bill in right earnest and it is to be hoped that their<br />
efforts will be crowned with success. The SUCCeBil<br />
of their work lies solely in the hands of the community.<br />
It is the duty of every Indian to do everything<br />
in their power to prevent the Bill from<br />
passing; for prevention is better than cure. The only<br />
way to prevent the Bill from passing is to loyally<br />
support and stand by the Oongress and to respond<br />
to their call at any and every time. The protest<br />
meetings at Stanger and Tongaat last Sunday were<br />
very successful and next Sunday's meeting of the<br />
residents of Olairwood and Districts, it is expected,<br />
wilLalso be a success. Next week-end the 3rd and<br />
4th October Oongress meetings will be held in the<br />
Northern Districts of Natal and we sincerely hope<br />
that Indians in those Districts will, by their presence<br />
in large numbers, prove in no uncertain terms<br />
their strong protest against the obnoxious Bill<br />
introduced against them and show to the Government<br />
also that they are prepared to support the<br />
Oongress wholeheartedly in fighting against the Bill.<br />
We thank the Bodasingh Brothers Messrs. Woodraj,<br />
Lntchmansingh, Basdev, Rajdev. and Nariansingh<br />
each of whom have generously donated two guineas<br />
to INDIAN OPINION. While appreciating the interest<br />
taken by Messrs. Bodasingh Brothers we wish to<br />
assure them that at the present time when propaganlla<br />
work is greatly needed in the interests of the<br />
community and many copies have to be sent free of<br />
charge their gift will be very useful.<br />
On the subject of segregation. the following interesting<br />
resolutions were passed at a meeting of the<br />
executive of the Transvaal African Oongress, held<br />
on the 12th and 13th inst. at Pretoria:<br />
c'That this executive meeting of the Transvaal<br />
African Oongress in session in the Cape location, ,<br />
Pretoria, these 12th and 13th days of September/,'<br />
1925, views with alarm the spread by the Union<br />
Government of this country of the propaganda of the<br />
so-called segregation, a segregation which we consider<br />
as an indirect resuscitation of the old slavery.<br />
"That as it appears the white people do not like to<br />
live peacefully side by side with the native in their<br />
Motherland, this meeting urges that the Government<br />
should first show the native the c country in which<br />
to accOmmodate the 7,000,000 blacks of the country<br />
but not small and arid patches, as suggested iii the<br />
Native Land Act of 1913, and that in that demarcated<br />
country no white missionaries,. storekeepers nor' anT
~ptember 25th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION !49<br />
-----------,--------~----------~~<br />
European I)e allowed to settle. trade or carry on any<br />
business tranRaction.<br />
"Young Indian Improvement Society" has been<br />
formed in Pretoria MI. II. N. Keshavjee being the<br />
Chairman and Mr. R. C. Naidoo Hon. Secretary.<br />
It is our painful duty to record the death, at the<br />
age of Ra, of Latchmiamah, mother of Mr. R.<br />
Govindoo who was for fourteen years a settler and<br />
• worker at Phrenix Hettlement. The old lady, who<br />
had heen 47 years in Natal, passed away at her son's<br />
residence at Mayville, near Dorban, on Saturday the<br />
19th instant. Numerous children, grand-children<br />
and grand-grand-cbildren remain to mourn their<br />
lollS. We offer our sympathy in their JJereavement.<br />
A meeting of Indians under the auspices of the<br />
Transvaal Rritish Indian Association was held last<br />
Sunday the 20th instant at the Goldberg Bio Hall,<br />
JohannesbuJ'g to weclome Bishop and Mrs. Fisher.<br />
In addition to a large gathering of Indians there<br />
were European sympathisers present among whom<br />
were the Hev. Mr. Lucas, Messrs L, W. Ritch .. H.<br />
Kallenback, Capt. F. Trotter and others. All the<br />
European speakers disapproved of Dr. Malan's Asiatic<br />
Bill and Bishop Fisher adviced Indians as well<br />
as Europeans to strongly protest against the BIll<br />
which was unju'it and immoral. The Asiatic<br />
question, the Bishop is reported to have said was<br />
an imp(lrial: one and should be settled by means of a<br />
joint conference of all concerned.<br />
.. "W,e strongly urge," it was further reported,<br />
that lb clause 5 of the Bill a farther section should<br />
be added to prevent Asiatic traders or other persons<br />
on their behalf from evading the law by securing<br />
fresh licences to trade in European claBS area in the<br />
name of Europans or of persons exempted from the<br />
operation of the Btll. Otherwise we are of opinion<br />
that the main purpose of the Bill will be defeated."<br />
Mr. H. M. Ross, the chairmau, said that the committee<br />
bad been very moderate in the alterations it<br />
had suggested, but jf the Hill was to become the law<br />
of the land it must contain no loopholes .<br />
Councillor Hoatson said that he could see no<br />
reason why the local authority should be given the<br />
option of enforcing the provisions of the new Bill.<br />
I~,enforcement should be made compulsory.<br />
Do you think the Johannesburg Town Council<br />
has this movement at heart" he inquired. Do you<br />
thin k it will enforce those provisions? I do not<br />
think it will. You should ascertain from every<br />
candidate at the coming elections whether he will<br />
pledge himself to enforce the provisions of the Bill."<br />
It was agre~d that a sub-committee should present<br />
the report to the Minister of the Interior.-Rand<br />
lJa.l!J Al atl.<br />
Associated Chambers<br />
Of Commerce<br />
Discuss Asiatic Question<br />
•<br />
Bishop Fisher and Mrs. Fisher left Johannesburg<br />
for Capetown on Monday night.<br />
Anti-Asiatic Opinion On Asiatic<br />
Bill<br />
European Association Suggests Amendments<br />
The sub-committee of the Southern Suburbs<br />
European Association, Johannesburg, presented its<br />
report on the Areas Reservation and Immigration<br />
Registration (Further Provision) Bill, which is to<br />
come before Parliament during next session, at the<br />
monthly meeting of the As~ociation at Turifontein,<br />
Johannesburg. on the 16th Instant.<br />
The report noted with concern that no provision<br />
had been made in the Bill for the issue of trading<br />
licences to be entrusted to the urban local authority.<br />
.. We are strongly of opinion, " it was stated. "that<br />
this omission should be rectified, either in tbis Bill<br />
or in complimentary legislation such as the Licences<br />
( Consolidation) Bill. "<br />
In regard to clause 4. it was urged that in the case<br />
of Enropean residential and trading class areas the<br />
lease should in no case be renewed more than once<br />
nor for a longer period than laid down in the originallease;<br />
also that the Asiatic trader should not be<br />
, eutitled to transfer or snb-Iet bis lease in favour of<br />
any other Asiatic tradel' or in respect of any other<br />
premises within such areas.<br />
Evading The Law<br />
Regarding clause 5, the sub-committee considered<br />
its provisions should include ha"wkers and pedlars,<br />
otherwise future European residential class areas<br />
might be inl1ndate.t with Asiatics. who, being unable<br />
to secure shop pl'emisE's, will take elaborate<br />
JDeasures for trading on foot and wheel.<br />
At the annual Congress of the Associated Chambers<br />
of Commerce held last week at Durban in the<br />
Beach Pavileion the following resolution is reported<br />
to have been discuEsed :-<br />
Mr. Webster (Potchefstroom) moved :-" That<br />
this Chamber views with satisfaction the Government'ft<br />
efforts at solving the Asiatic question, as set<br />
fortb m the new Asiatic Bill to come before Parliament<br />
next session. "<br />
Mr. Webster said that at Potchefstroom and other<br />
towns in the Transvaal they felt very grateful for<br />
the practical measure which the Government were<br />
introducing during the next session to relieve the<br />
anti-Asiatic feeling in the Transvaal.<br />
Mr. Cooper (Kl'ug~rsdorp) seconded.<br />
Mr. Gundelfinger (Durban) spoke in opposition and<br />
hoped Mr. Webster would withdraw his motion until<br />
he had a full opportunity of studying the Bill.<br />
Mr. Paine (Grey town) expressed agreement with<br />
Mr. Gudelfinger's remarks.<br />
Mr. Mushet (Capetown) thought the Bill should<br />
be referred to the General Executive and that a<br />
special committee be formed to consider the measure.<br />
He did not think the Congress should vote at this<br />
stage on such an important tlubject with the little<br />
information they possessed at present.<br />
Mr. Taylor 8:lid he was rather surprised and<br />
thought it a pity that the Malay population d£ the<br />
(Jape were to b~ eliminated from the operation of<br />
the Bill.<br />
Mr. Dunkerton oppoiled the motion, and said that<br />
what was required by the Government was a COllstructive<br />
suggestion, there was nothing constructive<br />
in the resolution, which indeed was of little value<br />
he considered, either to the Congress or to th~<br />
Government.<br />
Mr. Pocock (Pretoria) thought the matter should<br />
be referred to the Executive Committee, and would<br />
move accordingly as an amendment, that "no<br />
decision be- taken on this resolution, but that it be<br />
referred to the Executive Committee to take such<br />
action thereon as they ma~ consider advisable."<br />
Mr. Webster in replying said that although he
was not a supporter of. the present Govermnent. !1e<br />
must sas he a.PJlr,eciat~ what they hal'Igh't l!IOme scheme tlPuid be devised<br />
to repatriate the Asiatie who '\'VaS 'faSt becominfl a<br />
menace to the "White popula'tiojl. If we were not<br />
careful this would hecome a second India. It waa<br />
not a f3Ct that an Indian born in 'this oonntry couh'!.<br />
not be seRt 'back to India. They eOllM not 'be sent<br />
to any other eountTY or Dominion, 'but they could<br />
alw.ays go back to their own country. lIe did not<br />
wislh to treat them hardly. Time &hould be given<br />
them to make adequate arrangements, and .compensation<br />
as wen, 'but at the expiration of the given time<br />
t4ey must go.<br />
~~««««««~ 9!»""'J>'>~~'>;;»»> 0<br />
I OUR LONDON LETTER i<br />
" [ b.Q1\l -DUJt. OWN COB1UISIPOJtDli:NI' ] •<br />
'f 20th AuguB4 1925. ~<br />
Ii) f(~«««««««~ »»l>~»~:)»>)»> 0<br />
At a meeting of the Delegate Conference of<br />
M.inel'fl hellll. yeBtooday i'B Kling8way HaJI, the terms<br />
v. Virgo. lI.nd 'by the decision in this c,onrt of 'Bbika of. reference for the Royal Commission into the<br />
Hira v. Boksburg 'Municipality. It was pontended epal industry were announced. They are to inquire<br />
that the power to m~e Drdina,nces for the plll'pose into and Teport upon 'the ecunomic position of the<br />
of direct taxa.tlOn in order to 1-'a1S0 r,evenne 0jd n01: .coal imluBtry lind 'l:b.e -condi:tjons a1fecting it and to<br />
auth.orise'the prohibiti.on in ,questj.on. It kll been make any Teoonmrend,ati.ons for fhe 'imprDvement<br />
held that the statute whiCh gave t4.e l>1jowinciaJ tihereof. These terms are wide enough to allow of.<br />
Legislatures of Canada tne 1-'ight to make .~ws in all 3Jlpeets, mc1ud;i.ng the nafion~Tisation of the coal<br />
respect of a "Snop, saloon, tavern, ,a1;lctioneer alild lndusbry 'being inquired iItto. 'The Conference has<br />
other ncences ~n order to ;rallie revenue ,did no/; ,apPIloved these terms oi reference, .and has given the<br />
authorise the passing of a "remT!lerance 40t,<br />
llLiner!l 'executive the necessary anthority to ,take all<br />
Nor did the 'FinancW Rela:ti.ons Aut mcr.ease the. sit\P$ to opresent 'the cJU!e ctf. the miner$ to the Royal<br />
powers o'f the Provi.ncial -Councn ,in t1tat r~pect.' C\ommislliar;I. ''The mine-owners 'have alsQ accepted<br />
Section 11 of the ,Adt.. read with the schedule, dea1t the \erms .of reference. The Commission, therefor.e,<br />
only Wi't'h the method of raising revenue, whlle w,Q.en frPPointed win hlfVe ti).e help of an parties<br />
Section 12 and the second sc'hedule refer to IQ.atiers .conCi8rned, hrelud'mg the prrblic in its in:vestigatioQs<br />
dealt Wltfu by 'Sub·sections 1}.n.. ,and ntt. of SectJ-on into Ithe coal industry and in the finding of a solu-<br />
85 of the 'So'nth Africa ,Act. A considena,tion o~ ,the tiOOllof the prob'lems "arising Q1lt .of it.<br />
schedules 'Strengthens the view t'hat 'Section 11 is ll'-"-e 'attnooncement by 'ehe Irish Free State Govfiscal<br />
In its object and nothing else. Section. 1 9f' .ern~ent, 1lhttt it prupos~ in the next SesSion of its<br />
the second S'ched'u'e ampowered the registration and Pa;rliamen't'to intro
September 25th, 1925<br />
quaUfledio the Co~onies. The veople in the Iril.lh Free<br />
State are collcerned with the consequences likely to<br />
follow, for, apart from the restriction referred to,<br />
the UnivenJities in the Free State will sutIer, it is<br />
fe'dred, fn refutation and otherwise.<br />
London is notable for many thinb'll, and not the<br />
least among them are its slums, not that it does not<br />
endMvour frow time to time to improve the condit10M<br />
W its sluma. or their demolioo, in order to<br />
erect better buildings ill slJch an area. At the! preflCDt<br />
mOml-lut tile !;tepney Council has a plan for the<br />
re-building of fiats in the Limehouse Fields. 8<br />
n9torio~ ,lum area, where, the conditions of the<br />
buildings, and of the life, are such that it would do<br />
a good deal of good, to anti-Asiatics in South Africa<br />
to visit, and with knowledge of such slum places,<br />
they would then look at, in the right perspective, the<br />
conditions under which non-Europeans by stresE of<br />
~conomic, and other eaules are living in South<br />
Africa. The su-ange thing about the residents in the<br />
Limehouse Fields is that they are vigorously objecting<br />
to their houses being rebuilt, and the Fields<br />
being improved, in other words, to make it no<br />
}oIlBet" a slw:t. \and. They prefer exiitiug slum<br />
conditions, for varioUI! reasons, mostly sentimental<br />
and personal. The Indians in South Africa, as 8<br />
community, have alw~ys sUPIWrted the introduction<br />
of means for the improvement for sanitary and<br />
other oonditions.<br />
Colonel Gidney at the head of an Anglo-Indian<br />
Deputation. hu heeD. making representation. to the<br />
Secretary of S~~ fo.r India, on their behalf. They<br />
ask, among other things, for admisaion into the British<br />
Units of the Indian Army or aa an auxiliary to<br />
such units and to the Indian Marine Service, including<br />
tb,e IJ;ldian Navy when it is formed. They<br />
also ask for special consideration on the Indian railways,<br />
in which they claim to have played a very<br />
large part, .and from which they say they are being<br />
ousted as Indiru;lisation of lhe Services increases.<br />
And in particular they claim that, beiug also of Indian<br />
deilcfjln~ t~1V should ,1)e coDBidered ail Indians<br />
in any scl.wQUl of IndianiBation. As it 1s they are<br />
classed for some purposes t&S Indians.<br />
In the Cl.'icketiug world, J. B. Hobbs of Surrey,<br />
is the oJ;l.e overwhelrnlng topic. His achievements<br />
in passing fth,e record. set by Dr. W. G. G.race of<br />
126 centuries, a.nd in also passing the record of<br />
Fry, Hendren and Hayward of 13 centuries in a<br />
season, have set the followers of cricket speculating,<br />
as to the future doings of Hobbs.<br />
Few English Poets are so well known as Byron,<br />
and the appeal which has just leen launched for<br />
subscriptions to the Lord Byron lntern.a.tional !femorial<br />
Fund, will doubtless meet with a response '<br />
lNDJA.t4 OPINION<br />
from many GOWltries. It iii ,Proposed &0 erect a permanent<br />
memorial. where tlte poet is bn.ried at<br />
Hucknall, Torkard in Nottinghamshire. Any sur- .<br />
plus there may be Is to be devoted to the establishment<br />
of Byron Travelling scholarships for the pursuit<br />
of humaner stuuies.<br />
King Feisul of Iraq, is now in London, staying at<br />
the Hyde park Hotel. But since his arrival, he has<br />
been confined to his bed. His visit is said to be<br />
for hel\lth NaBOl).$, to conlult the specialists in this<br />
coun~y. The l'renc,h n.ewllPapers however, think<br />
tbat his visit is not free t:rom politcal purposes.<br />
... ,To-day iIt Simila, the autumn session of the All<br />
Indian Legislature was opened by Lord Reading. In<br />
his IlPooc:h amoog otD&r matters, he referred to the<br />
setting up of a cur.rency commission, and this afternoon<br />
India Office announced the terms of reference<br />
which will be: To examine and report on the Inilian<br />
exchapge and'oDven£Y system and pl'actaae; to Gonsider<br />
whether \lny modifications are desirable in the<br />
interests of India .auti to make recommendations.<br />
The chairman of the Oommission is Lieut commandl;lr .<br />
Hilton young, Liberal M. P. considered to be, one of<br />
~e best known financial experts of the day.<br />
Public Lecture<br />
IN PARSEE RUSTOMJEE HALt<br />
"The Brothet'hood of Religions"<br />
A lecture on the above ~ubjec.t will be<br />
delivered by Miss Marguerite Warner,<br />
L.R.AM., F.T.S., at the PARSEll: Rus<br />
TOM]EE HALL, 140, Queen Street, Durban,<br />
on Wfdnesday the 30th September, 1925<br />
at 7 p.m. sharp.<br />
All are requested to attend.<br />
O. H. A • .JHAVEtU, Cb~irmaD.<br />
B. AI. PATEL, Uoo. Se~~.<br />
The M. K. Gandhi Library and Pa.rsee<br />
Rustomjee HaU Committee.<br />
BOOKS FOR SALE<br />
----"~<br />
To be obtamed from the lIUi"", Opi ....,. Press, l'hreni1,<br />
Na.tal. l'o&tal Orders to be made parable at Ollrban.<br />
The Rltn. Mr. Gokhale aDd the Indenture System 2 0<br />
Indian Home Rule, by M. K. Gandhi I 6<br />
A Book-a,t1d its Misnolller I 0<br />
Bagavad Gita. Mrs. lleaa~'s Tr~tiQ.t1<br />
Asiatics Registration A,J;DeUdOlent ACqI!)-OS)<br />
~ 6<br />
in English and Gujarati<br />
Hindu Sociallde~s, bJ P. J. M~hta<br />
Rille .and Growth of Bombay Municipal Go.n.<br />
Agricultural Industries in India<br />
~<br />
4<br />
z<br />
6<br />
6<br />
6<br />
The Story of the Ramayana, the Epic of Rama :I 6<br />
. ,<br />
A Study in Indian· EcotlOmics, by P. B~anerji 4 6<br />
The In,dia,ns oC SOllt)l Alric~. by H, S. L. Pplak _ 0<br />
Life 01 M. K. Gandhi (Ill Tamil)<br />
The GaMet) Number of" ludian Opinion"<br />
Paper covers<br />
BouDd in Cloth<br />
Speeches on Indian AtTairs, by John Morley<br />
l'~e aon. Mt. Gokhale's Tour in South Africa:<br />
Special INDIAN OPINION Souvenirr.<br />
The Ethics at Passive Resistance<br />
ES.1ay on Indian Econa)ics, by Maha,dev<br />
Govind RapJlde<br />
Hindu Psalms and Hymns<br />
Vaishavite IleforlllHs of IndIa<br />
M, K. Gandni and the South African<br />
Indian Problem<br />
Aspecs of the VedaDta<br />
Essays 00 Indian Art, Industry and Education<br />
Sri Madhwacharya<br />
Hin
September 25th, 1925<br />
~:--~------------<br />
Allahabad a.~d N agpur Congresses<br />
l! 6<br />
The Surat Congress and Conferences<br />
:2 0<br />
The Improvement of Indian Agriculture<br />
2 6<br />
The Cobgress Conferences 'and Conventions 2 0<br />
India's Untouchable SaIDts<br />
2 0<br />
The Governance of Iodla, by Govind Das 7 6<br />
For IndIa's Uplift, by Anne Besant 3 6<br />
Sri RamanuJacharya :2<br />
Sri Sankaracharya 2<br />
.Mr. Gandhi's Speeches and Wntmgs-I896 to 1977 3 6<br />
The IndIan D~mands, by G. A. Natesan :2<br />
Indian Industrial and,Economlc Problems by Prof. Kale 3 6<br />
Essays on National Ideahsm, by Dr Coomaraswamy 2 6<br />
FRIENDS\ OF INDIA SERIES: Lord Morley, Sir Wm<br />
Wedderburn, Rev. Dr. MIller, Sir Edwm Arnold,<br />
Edmund Burke, Lord Mmto, Henry Fawcett,<br />
John Bright A. O. Hume, SIr Henry Cotton, Lord<br />
Macaulay, Lord RIpon, Lord Hardmge.<br />
BIOGRAPHIES OF EMIN~NT INDIANS -<br />
Dadabhal Naorol', Gopal KrIshna Gokhale, Rabmdranath<br />
Tagore, M. K. GandhI, Budruddtn TyabJI<br />
Pundit Madan Mohan Malavlya, The Right Hon<br />
,Sayed AmlC Ali, H. H. SrI Sayajl Rao Gaekwar,<br />
Sir Sayed Ahmed Khan, H H. the Aga Khan,<br />
Swami Rama Ttrath, V. Krrshnaswaml Aiyar, Krlslo<br />
Das Pal, Dewan C. Rangacharlu, 'vV. C. BonnerJea,<br />
A. M Bose, RavI Varma, Kashtnath Trimbak Telang,<br />
Swami Vlvekanada, Toru Dutt, Ishwar Chandra<br />
Vldyasagar, SirSalar Jung, V. P Madhava Rao, D. E.<br />
Wacha, Sri Ramaknshna Paramahamsa, Sir Pherozesha<br />
Mehta, Rahimtulla Mohamed Sayani, Dr Rash<br />
Beharl Ghose, Nawab Mohsm-ul-Mulk, Sir C. Sankaran<br />
Nair, Lal Mohun Ghose, Raja Ram Mohan<br />
Roy, BehramJI M. Malaban, Mrs. Anne Besant,<br />
Babu Surendranath Banel'jea, Rao Bahadur R N<br />
Mudholker.<br />
each I<br />
"lndJan Opinion Supplemel'tts"<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
J 0<br />
We have the following supplements on art paper for uh at Olle<br />
.bilhng per dozeD. post free 1-<br />
The Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji, Soutb Afrlan Incdlln S~retcher.<br />
Bearer Com pin)" HOD. Mr. Gokhale's visit, tak:n at HeBelburg<br />
station, Mr: L. ITon. R'\; R.A. (Han. Princip,1 D. A f<br />
V. College, I'rerident Labore Arya Samaj). Oma, Jh}i Amo",!}<br />
Johari, Indian Volqnteer Strdcher.Bear" Corpl, Three Tran.; n<br />
vnl ladies a8 passive reshten (Mh. Sivprasad, Mill Minn.tj~,~<br />
8!,d Mrs. Somar). Mrs. S',eikh Mehtab, India'. Grut Loyal~."1'<br />
Cartoon), The Late Sir PberoleshalJ Mebta, Mr. Ratan J. Tata"lll<br />
Sir William Wedderbnrn, Lt., Pioneer Settlefl of Tolstoy Fanrtr t ,<br />
The Late Rev. To!eph J. Doke, The Late Mr. S. N.gappa11f'I~<br />
The Right Hon. Lord Ampthill, G.C.I.E., The TriqmphJr'"<br />
Arch outside Park Station (Mr. Gokhale's Vilit), Mr. Sorahi''II:<br />
Shspurji of Adajan, PicllIc Party at Tolstoy Farm, Shri GITi.J ti9iilJtFlii.uu(i)u,.<br />
&T iIl(l ~IT (!5 ID fG 6lI(!!I f91 &lr. (J $L..(i) iiQ 801T aTr ~fj)(J (!!Ill-.<br />
~Ul P; mUUJ,T P;<br />
aJl€RGc-_":'<br />
6lJ. aT. . UP;tblT.<br />
Q(f[J!J1Uffi' !TGfutDptD~.<br />
8ii...L..(i)ii G.WIT6lI .rtFItLJllf/€R5';':<br />
~<br />
fiJ)Ai1 U9.il/tD (!jl8;(SfUUIT61JT 8ii...L.c-lDrQl8OtLJIt6o> &T6.J(J6\ll'®tD p&l(!!lAi1 6lJ1T1i (J.~(j)" G5rwe5Q1 (!!Ju,.<br />
uaiml!J-fGi U6l1l1eJlfGtLJlI6.l eS66rlFU Al!J-.,w atMJf1j"~ €R..,<br />
.~tLJ"siufJJlI·.lTfGrL.. 19. ITITUI#r6fGti 'lieU ufillrefl<br />
jMDflf1 L.9lw~ (l •. &TID. GITL..I!J- I!J-. 6T'~. vi,,, P<br />
-f}l· I!J-. ui..!FITp; &TID. fll1,UITsa til -8; tR"';'<br />
6!JlLI>ii806.l €R 5' lNllllfR 1ifT~. Ii. (J 1-"* L... '~MJLI>u9 60> (1 fG'<br />
uvWlf-~i .ifi1(!58O l.lJ8OrJrlT~ Ii (1.i~.
No.' 4o-Vo1. XXIII. , ',Friday. Octob~r 2nd. 1925.<br />
Reli ........ ttbeG.p.o. ... H ....... "<br />
PlUCa FOD ..... a<br />
CLAIRWOOD INDIANS, ~UprORT<br />
- /<br />
PROTEST AGAINST AS,ATIC BILl;<br />
n<br />
against the 'Asiatic Bill by thlt Natal Indian<br />
CONGRESS<br />
, - -<br />
N furtherance - ~i the proPaganda carried on -COngress and aaid be I bad always stood and woula<br />
,eontinue to staud by the Congress at all times.<br />
Congress a' thorongbli representative ,Jl1eeting I Messrs. L Ganesh, and Ismail Tootla spoke in<br />
-of tlt.e Indians of Clairwood and Districts _ was held ,support of the above resolution and asked evel'f Inunder<br />
Its auspices at the ClairwOQd Indian School dian to enrol himself as' a memoor of the CongreSS<br />
grounds last Sunday at 2·30 p.m. ' ' and to fight against the iniquitoll8 Bill.<br />
There were about a thousand people present and Mr. V. S. C. Pather explained the Bill folly in<br />
among the officials of the Congresa were Messrs. Tamil after which the resolution being put to the<br />
Pandit Bhawani, Dayal, Advocate J. W. Godfrey, meeting was passed unanimously •<br />
.A. ,Dookan. M. Beetbasee, A. I. Kajee, B. A. Magh. Mr. Shabally then rose to move the following<br />
rajh, G. M. C. Patel, S, N. Richards, P. R. Pather, , ~esolution:-<br />
R. K. Naidoo, S. L Singh, D. S. Chetty, M. M. •• This mass meeting -of Indians at Clairwood hElre.<br />
Gandhi,' .A.' Sookdeo, S~ Emammally, S. A. Pinay by resolves to form a District Committee of the<br />
and the Sec)Jietariea Me8i!11l. V. S. C. Father and Natal Indian Congress at Clairwood and appoints 'a<br />
Sorabjee Rustomjee.' There were also present a Committee of the following persons with power to<br />
number of 'ladies prominent among whom was- Mrs. add to make the necessary arrangements viz :<br />
J. W. Godfrey. 'Messrs. L Ganesh, M. Shabally, Michael E. Siga.<br />
Pandit Bhawani Dayal who took the chair in his 'IW>n~y. K. M. Reddy, - B. Ramcbander, Bisnath<br />
()pe~iDg remarks expressed, hill delight at .the pre- Singh, Anoon Goordeen', Pandit Bhawani Dayal,<br />
sence of such a large gathering that day .• It ,was . ~ b B<br />
Slll'Prising to see sach a large gathering owing to f G. R. John, Harry Pillay, Rugh eer howani,<br />
the fact that there was IUl element at ,I work )i~ 'that Ismail TootJa, Kalianjee Katbad, S. Sunderjee, Daya.<br />
District that was striving bard to frustrate the 'work ram, S. C: Katbad, S. Ramoutar ...<br />
of the Congress bat the eni intentions of that ele. ;Mr. K. M.:Reddy seconded the aDove resolution<br />
men' had apparently not beeq fqlfiUed. The chair. ~king in. T~ and Mr. Sy(lney supported it<br />
man thell anDQanced that Mr. J. W. Godfrey would ~Plj3.kiDg fu-Telugq and being put to the meeting<br />
laY a few words. ' " was passe,d,unanimol18ly, ,<br />
. Mrs. Godfrey who spoke in fluent Tamil' urgeCl ' Mr . .M. ¥. Gandhl advised the people to place their<br />
the necessity of shOwing a united front against the fnD..confidence in the Congress and to stand by it<br />
A.l!Iia~o Bill which she described as a piece of .bumi- r unitedly in opposing the ·Asiatic Bill.<br />
liating legi.latio~ and with simple ,an,:! yet very 'Mr. M. B. Mabaraj addressing the gathering in<br />
BO~d ;.pstanc,s explained the Jte~ a~d benefits, of Hindustani said he would ask the people to remember<br />
nOlty. , four things. Firstly 'that It was tIme for them to<br />
I MrS'. Godfrey's speech was received with a; wake up, secondly they should put up a strong<br />
'Pleasant surprise as it was unusual- to find 'Indian figM against the Govemmen,t. thirdly they shqald<br />
-women in South Africa especially in present years stand firm against the misguidance of misguided<br />
coming to the forefront together with men, I men, and if they failed in these three things the fourth<br />
Mr. dodfrey explained in Hindustani what was I thing for them to do was to pack up and leave the<br />
said by Mrs. Godfrey in Tamil and dwelt upon the counl1'f.<br />
Bill in detail and the many clauses which woul!! Mr. A. I. Kajee in the course of his speech severely<br />
.adversely affect the Indian community.<br />
, condemned the formation of mushroom bodies and<br />
The Chairman then explained the BilUn detail in I -the action'of those,who indulged in misleading the<br />
, Hindustani and impressed apon the people present' people and antagopising them.. against the Congress<br />
that the only body that represented tJJ.e Indians'lo by making false statements an.d yet not having the<br />
Natal to.daY abd recognised, by the leaders in India courage to face them on the public platform. Jt will<br />
such as Mahatma Gandhi. Mrs. Sal'ojini Naidu, not do ,for the people to become m~mbers of the<br />
Pandit Motilal Nehru and others was the N~tal. 10. 1 Congree& alone. said the speaker, they should<br />
,dian: Congress and exhorted every Indian in the dis.; _ VOice their protest against the existence 9! mush.<br />
,trict of Clairwood to become ,. membe~ .of that body. t . room bodies for if they did not they too were I'ElS<br />
Mr. Sorabjee RustomJee being unwell- we Obairinan, ponsible for the exittenee of such bodies by their<br />
, himself gave 1m account of the work done' by the I silence. There could be one .PQliti .. • ..}
, ....<br />
• 254 ____________ ~ ______ I_N_D_I_A_N_.O--P-IN--IO--N---------O-c-t-ob-e-r_~2_n_d~,_I~92~5~<br />
N ote~ and News<br />
We welcome Mr. C. R. Naidoo who has returned<br />
last week from India. Mr. C R Naidoo ift a Colonial<br />
born Indian and during his long stay in India he<br />
WlU! carrying on an active propaganda in connection<br />
~ T a public meeting .held in Newcastle jn regard with th~ Asiatic question and especiaily in conneciion<br />
~'n 'to the' Lic~E!~ng Revenues whichl.~ve !h!~~n, ,'Yith(the Union ~overnment's ,R,epatriation ~cheme.<br />
_taken'away oy the Union Govertiment hom Latferly Mr~C. R. Naidoo wasc6Jiductiolfthtrjournal<br />
the Natal Municipalities, Mr. J. W. Whyte, a promi- "Indians Abroad" of which he-was the editor. We<br />
mnt-. looal--bu&ineBS man and ~\lRcUlor.-in. F,,mg .nll(lerstand ~ Mr. C. ~ ~aidoo...haa lost.po time i.n<br />
(1:e!!o\t!'tigli tPJt~u~~tte N ~4a!tie 'iliiIltbet,J>{!he \beeo!D-!ng}l e!e~ber of.~~ l(atal ~Juamn Courlr~<br />
Natal Provincial CouncIl to secure'1cgIslation pro- and we nave no llt>dbt thlR Wl"tfl1J.is Ind\dn"e:tp'eMedp~<br />
viding that the Natal Local Authorities Shaltretain -Mr.·-Naidoo will become a very useful and aa<br />
all Licence Revenues at ~f~~ ~PJ mfJe}yeit,:> .1-y.~~nsayl.!:nreljPj the CongreBS<br />
together with the full contrOl of. the Issue o( such - .. ===J======<br />
llicenceihadSOIiIe'i'"cll18ilkit,tofmake,that.Bet'Ahe ,I:roo r"ff~'r:f'''''1 r I, \,. 6' ~<br />
dian mind :thinking. '
October' 2nd, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 255<br />
was so criminal for a J~urr)pean lady t'l t.lke note
the press of Durban and Mariuburg had ~~ne for<br />
him, Mid h" hupllil it 'WliS not thO ~ b~oo.use be<br />
would be straying very far from tile pathway he<br />
had elected to follow if b~ ~t , IDtlMure of commendation<br />
from the Maritzburg and Durban Press.<br />
(Applause). When that happened he might as well<br />
give up UwJ large n1~t)rit7 C)f ~tI! hill t>a~tf held in<br />
the Transvaal and giv~ up the ~hQwmanship of the<br />
Nationalist Party, whlch to-day was the largest party<br />
in the Tra!lsvaal. In -spite m wjections the policy<br />
he had laid down in making allPointments would bo<br />
cartitld ont.<br />
Ultimatum To Solicitors<br />
1\1"1". R~ m\\de further retl'ltmlee to the complaints<br />
abollt ~tlm1fioI\9tl8 bein~ tAken O\1t trobl the Same<br />
ofll~ b,. 'E\1~~11 girl!, tndian13 -and ~atlves. Ite<br />
had given th~ i~t '5Olicl.tort:l l1iong pel'iod in 'Which<br />
to rtmtify thl!! vomtfOll, he te1llarke'\l, but it they<br />
pemeted it!. ~d1ng lndians to the b.w courts 'to<br />
taIte but t!U1lllfit)nl!!~ lre wonld 'S'ee if it '\VaS hot<br />
pM!il.b\~ ttl ~tld:r the ~ltioti tihde\' the ensting<br />
law. U it Was 11{)\;, htl '\Votlld itrtr'Oltuc1! legislation<br />
which would force the solicitors to go themselves 'to<br />
the cl~l'k «)f the oolirt. {Ltmd appllln13e).<br />
Only by enl1ghtoo~d po.bU-c ~l)inttln could. they<br />
deal With thi'A qll~i{)ll. Not tm.1y the solicitors<br />
we~ tb bll!.tt1'6, 'fbI' he tlllderBtood that in certain<br />
bus\rt~s ~ctl'S ttld.t~:ns dtclated l~ttm UI lll{tropean<br />
girls. II~ did 1'I.ut want to mention tllhlleEi, but any<br />
matt 'Who allowed thfit w happen W'dS Il. regenade 'to<br />
his OOfihtrjr. TQ allow afi Indian 'tt> d1ctate 00 a<br />
EUt'btlea,l1 girt WM lIli itlmllt to th~ white face.<br />
"r Ml11it It\; {)fiC0 that Dr. M:alatl'~ BtU Is hot the<br />
lasb word, but it i8 a -great ~ fot'Wll.fd, and t expect<br />
th~ Wl1PtlrttJt ~\1m'r<br />
NMn.l mem.ber 6f Par1ilJ.<br />
ment~ ~V'Im wimbfti th@il" snppurt the tml will be<br />
put th'l'b\'lgh, " fImla.tlttld Ml". noos.<br />
s<br />
BiShop Fisher's Address<br />
....".. .5f¥.· .. ~<br />
In Parsee RU'$t()mlee Hl11<br />
PIe. For Universal Stlndtrd OF Living<br />
TJ1M'e WIl!! !\ 't"el'1 lltttre '.tt~fiaaI1tle of ihdians in<br />
the ~ Ru~ HaR 1}fl the afie1'boon ot<br />
Sept. 1~ 'Whtm. Blsb.t;f1 Fret1@ri.ck FieMr of Ca).cfina<br />
delivered an interesJ.iftg-ads.<br />
Pttrcmltliflg- tht! "'Msifur "Slild ~-lfi the last two<br />
centurlal 'We fut~ lnJ.d. grim migratory movements<br />
thrtmghOttt tht! world, lt1(}\Y'elfleblS ln which for the<br />
. most pltrt \;h~ ~tlrop'ell.n n1rt.lons ha.d. been concerned.<br />
NoWth~e1tro~mtm.ts hl1ve tfitlt"easea. tne pOInts .of<br />
con~ct 'littltrfig all the rn.ees ahd in some instances<br />
have 'bro"l'1g-ht !1tl.t Ute WfirSt ~leInents in all the rac~<br />
showed. tt> dlsadwtnta@, sl:)IDetiIMs the African and<br />
som'U'ttnHlS the 'Whlte llliln. Somehow tt has tle6B.led<br />
that the bringing down of the old sooial customs haft<br />
meaftt \,httt 'the WOM ~1mneh\;S are let loOse when<br />
we itnd 1)~lv~'$ 'n-1l. !i1;t'alige plaoe. t ha.ve found<br />
in 80nth AMM that the soclal restraiBts that.' are '<br />
endured 1~ t~~/;~l !lot silifered -here; '!l'.he"y do<br />
~ J'~-~!bl:e~ ~ellli' J!~r~ m. the same walt. ~u.~<br />
66'pl"",<br />
ot Europe do not biml<br />
" '\e way as they do in •<br />
INDIAN OPINION O~tober Ind, 19'5<br />
Europe. The very fAct that we have come into ()Qntact<br />
with each other has caused a recrudescence of<br />
the social consdence. When all your fotefathera<br />
lived in Indta they were just men, and Were not<br />
cOWlGioUII of being lhditme, and cared wry Uttlt!<br />
what was· thl! col
October, 2nd, 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
.unerica again there .were 4R republics an(l to all were emptied of popul.t.tion and had to be repopl1.<br />
Jlt.ents and pUl'poaea tao popuWion of Sonth Ame- laW. First leI; WI put the population of Australia in<br />
·i~ is European and the institutions are European. and the Phillippines and the United States. Would<br />
~.IJa whole country is based on the European mode that be enongh? No. Canada. theD and all Alaaka<br />
)f culture. In Canada also the population is only and all 1tIexico and the whole of the U republica of<br />
II milhons from the Atlantic to the PacIfic. and in South America. Put them all into India. would that<br />
.he United Sates as well there are huge territories do? Not enough yet. Go across the A.tlantic and<br />
where the population is less than a million. Yet get all the isIancI. to the east of America. Not<br />
~vet'y inch of the ground could be used, and much enough. Across then to Europe and take in all the<br />
)f it is.l!uitable {or the eastern peoples. population of the British fales. No not yet enough.<br />
Now, look at the trltnation between America and Cr088 the English Channel to Europe and take all<br />
Japan to-day. The State of California has a wonder. Belgium and France. Still it is not enough and you<br />
Eul climate with sunshine more than :350 days in the must go down to South Africa and take in all the<br />
Vtar, and Where every grain of sand will grow white, black and brown population and take them<br />
mmething. All this land is marvellously rich, yet all into India before the toll is paid. I should say<br />
what Is the trltnatlon? The Japanese have a little that iii something of a problem if population and aU<br />
island In which there are 5~ million 'people and yet of them are crowded into Ii territory half the size of<br />
;he one state of CalifOl"nia which is only one-forty- the island continent of Austraha. It is my honest<br />
~jghth of the United States, has exactly the same judgment that tlu!re is only one way out of the<br />
lmOtlnt of territory. Japan has its 5R milhons but present racial problem U1 the world, and that is a<br />
in Oaliiomia there are only 4 millions and yet the world-wide will, on the part of all the peoples, to<br />
roup mUllons say : .. We cannot have any of the 5~ come to some mutual understanding as to the .re.<br />
millions coming into our territory ... So immediately sel've places of the world where people may go and<br />
you raise a barrier and create d frictioll, because the have an opportunity of developing. How it is to<br />
lape.nel!e know that the land of California would come about I realise is an extremely illfficult prowake<br />
a wonderful country in ,vhich his gardening ~lem, but we see we have come to a tima when<br />
~km could be used to the greatest advantage. It is<br />
)nly necessary to go to Japan to see what wonderful<br />
there are great restrictions. In the early days none<br />
were consciollB oi race. but now the wlute has bef'ardenera<br />
they are. They have even made mounds come more white, the black more black, and we<br />
in some places to incl'e'.;Lse their square feet of ground have become more intensely loyal to our special<br />
~nd haTe planted both sides of the raised ground group than ever before in all history. We have alwith<br />
-vegetables. They have even adopted a scientific ways exaggerated the disunity of India. When I<br />
method of fertilising their soil, whereas we western- went to India 21 years ago l found that there Went<br />
era mmply pollute the soil.<br />
many divisioWl-divislOns that staggered me, but<br />
I do Dot see how the problem is to be finally to-day there is more unity in India than there has<br />
seWed. but in all fairness the American must some- ever been before, and it mWlt be remembered that<br />
now meet the Japanese around Q peaceful table and India has been a unity for 3500 years. (Hear, hear.)<br />
find out whether there is some method by which the Sometimes I think the divisions in India have been<br />
overflow Clan be accommodated. Then there is also over-emphasised and as a matter of fact those who<br />
the problem of the teeming millions of Chms and have been in India during recent years will say that<br />
eitiulr Manchuria or Russia. will have to find a way during the years since 1914 there has grown up a<br />
ou\ fur the surplus population, otherwise the. white· dynamic unity such as India had never known in<br />
man is going to have a. difficulty which will be some all her history. As a matter of fact the unity of<br />
diffioulty indeed.<br />
India is so tremendous to-day that I can think of no<br />
I do not believe in war or force of any kind, and other word for it than dynamic, and the Mahatma<br />
vet when I look at Japan and see how she has a.rmed has been the great moving spirit in this connection,<br />
herself, I have to admit that she acted wisely. By and after all, the time must come when spirit and<br />
buUdlDg a strong naTY and maintaining an army nothing else will bind the world together. Consider<br />
she made a power of herself and consequently the your position as Indians to-d:lY compared WIth 100<br />
nations were obliged to listen to her. It may be years ago. Here is the Mahatma of whom 48 bio·<br />
wicked for Japan to develop a ,/lreat u.wy and a great graphies have been translated in the different lana.rmy,<br />
but it is DO more wickecl for ,J~pan than any guages of the world. When has India had a man like<br />
European country, and it was wise for Japan to that, speaking to the whole world in spiritual tonea.<br />
adopt western methods jlnd demand jt18tice from Thenlet us look at Tagore, a giant figure. Ail a matter<br />
the European nations. StIll it is t\ great pity that of fact his plays are being read everywhere, and he<br />
justice could not be given WIthout a display of force. stands head and shoulders above many of the great<br />
It was only by force that they got a place round the writers and authors, and he is listened to by all the<br />
peace 'table after the war, whel'eas India had only a world. India, too, has leaped iuto the position of a<br />
silent voice. She was represented by someone else, State in which half the leaders are Indians and for<br />
and so here is this vast population with no voice this we must compliment BrItain, but the trouble is<br />
simply because it has been wicked enough to remain that the white men have the feeling we were made<br />
peaceful and refuse to develop the power of the to rule. We were made to always be on top. It is<br />
western nations. I know this, that as a Christian., a strange thing and sometime!! I have felt it myself<br />
and a humanitarian and as a man living among men, ill my ecclesiastical work. I havp bef'n tempted to<br />
I can s~e no other way out for the world than that think "h~ is an Indian" and it has taken me years<br />
these nll.tions should sit down together and Bay II we to ~ rid of tha temptation. The white man thinks<br />
are going to find somEi solution that will give these M has the right to be on top, but unfortunately it.<br />
populations the outlet that they require. .. is not really trne. For the present he is in the<br />
I have orten wondered if the Indian in Natal ascendancy. and perhaps when w~ aualyse all the<br />
understands the burden of population under which difficulties and all the exploitatiolls we still find that<br />
India reets. If all the India.~s wished to go to India the total has been more for good than ill. What we<br />
it would be l\ wonderful thing for them all to live in have to do is to make an analysis and endea vour to<br />
their DWD eountt·y, but they must bear in mind that nndtll'stand one another in a wa.y that will not bring<br />
the,. 'W6'llld have to compete with the vast popnla- about war. If I do not believe in war, I fear it.<br />
tiOD already thel"l', and it is almost stifling in some WhXQ~o I ~ear the developing uni~y in ~ina? 1<br />
parts ~'f the -eGllnttr. 8Q that a man !!honld not think: kfnqy.:;1:lia£ man for man the ChlDaman 18 better<br />
of going to India unless ht) has the means of Jlv~~ . physically than the Westerner. lIe is as good a<br />
hood before hand. We westemers do not appreciate fighter ,and as good -Q worker, and well-I do not<br />
the V1L8t population of India. Let us suppose India - w~.to·fiiti\-"'-tit~ 400 ~i1lion Ohinese. (Laughter.)<br />
-~ .;, _ ...... H""~-,.,.
I have this peculiar theory, that the English-Rpeaking<br />
race is ~n the ascendancy to-day for the good of<br />
the world.' I have come to believe that if the<br />
United States and the British Empire and the various<br />
English-speaking sectionR of the world were to<br />
unite in one common ethical ideal, they could do<br />
much for the world to-day. We ought to realise<br />
th&.t in each race there are systems and customs and<br />
ideals that are good and each one should be Willing<br />
to sit down and confer with the other-"confer",<br />
yes, that is the word, "confer" and suggest a solution<br />
of the problem. We do not understand one<br />
another because we do not confer with one another.<br />
We hold our own conferences but we ought to confer<br />
together. We should confer in every local<br />
situation hke that of Durban, and in every national<br />
and inte;national situation. That, I believe, is the<br />
first fouftdation-stone that I should lay.<br />
The second thing would be modern education,<br />
and there I think your commumty in South A(rica<br />
will have to look to its lands. I have been impre'lsecl<br />
this week with the lack of an adequate edllcational<br />
system for the Indians in South Africa.<br />
Somehow, I think it there IS no possibIlity. of<br />
developing It throu~h the Governmellt. the Indians<br />
«must d~velop it for themselves. I think you have<br />
to carry your education right through to the B A ,<br />
degree and straight through to M.A. and have It<br />
not on a religious or race basis, but on the modern<br />
scientific baSIS, leading to the modern degrees, and<br />
every boy and every girl ought to be com~elled. to<br />
have an education at least up to the matrICulatlOn<br />
standard, and favourable pupils should be pushed<br />
forward into the sciences. Then If that were done,<br />
we. should not hear so much about the inferiority<br />
of the Indian.<br />
My conviction is this that Indians may say their<br />
system is the best, but It is not the most smtable for<br />
the present time. The Mahatma, speaking of the<br />
western civilisation said It had brought one good<br />
thing and that wa\1 the scientific method. I beheve<br />
that is a bl" contribution. No matter what we say,<br />
we cannot'" put the world back where it was 400<br />
years ago and for good or ill the modern sClen~ific<br />
system of education must become, to my mmd,<br />
universal and uniform, and that is the only mpans<br />
by which we shall all meet on a common platform.<br />
In other words, we have to have a culture that all<br />
the rest of tile people wilI recognise. I believe that<br />
the Orient will have to adopt the modern system of<br />
scientific education and modes of hfe. I believe<br />
that if the Indian in South Africa had the Eurqpean<br />
mode of life (I dislike the word 'standard' because<br />
in some respects your ways are better than ours)<br />
there would be no more talk o~ inequality. We<br />
ilhould remove many of our disabilities.<br />
My third aim is to raise every race. to. the hi.ghest<br />
possible position. Let Europeans, ASIatIcs, AfrIcans,<br />
all lift themselves to the highest possible positlOn,<br />
but IE't it be a uniform positIOn. Do not let India<br />
develop a system which is not in agreement With<br />
the rest of the world, but ,all work on the same<br />
lines and then there will be an end to these difficulties<br />
and animosities. There is plentv" of territory<br />
not yet occupied, and plenty of pnrsuits not ye'l<br />
opened to mankmd, and science will yet find be~ter<br />
mt-ans of providing food and water and clothmg<br />
for the people.<br />
I am fearful of only one thing,-animosities and<br />
misunderstandings. I believe that if, right here in<br />
South Africa, in bldia and in Europe, we were to<br />
see that every man, woman and chIld of all the races,<br />
bas equal opportunity, we would have far less difficulty<br />
tban if we attempt to restrict one another in<br />
every way. ThE! one solutio~ is to make the standard<br />
of life absolutely universal, so that one would not<br />
be hisher, or one lower.<br />
INDIAN OPINION October 2nd, (925<br />
o~~~~~~ ~~~»)''''>r.>~o<br />
~ OUR LONDON LETTER !<br />
~ [ FROM OUR OWN CORRESPONDENT ] ~<br />
\If 27th August, 1!l2.5. ~<br />
o ~~«(E«(~~~~~ »»'>):;>0<br />
M. Caillaux left for Paris to-day. He has done<br />
well on his mission in London. As the rflpresenta_<br />
tive of France, he came to nt-gotlate With the nritish<br />
Ministprs as to the terms of the r~payment 01<br />
France's war debt to Eogl,md amounting to<br />
£G23,OOO,OOO. 1Ifr. Winston Churchill expected<br />
payment at the rate of £20,OOO.()110 a year. M.<br />
Calliaux offered £10,000,000 a year and neither<br />
appeared to be prepared to eOllcede to the other.<br />
The French made the question of payment to be<br />
dependent on the receipts from the Germanfl, uoder<br />
the Dawes Reparation Scheme, and further advanced<br />
as a ground for consideration that from snch receipts<br />
the restoration of tbe devastated areas in France.<br />
The British on the other hand. had in view the payment<br />
of their war debt to the Umted States, as a result<br />
of what they did for the French during the war.<br />
After much negotiation, which at times looked difficult,<br />
and as If it would break down, M. C,ullalllC,<br />
.to-mght, will be laying before hiS Government the<br />
arrangement come to With the HI'itiah for the payment<br />
of the debt by amenities of £12,5000,000 in<br />
gold, spread over a period of 1)2 years, with the<br />
marotorlUm for easy terms of payment until Hl:IO.<br />
The amount now agreeJ on is, however, not to be<br />
dependent on the receipts from the Germans under<br />
the Dawes Scheme.<br />
The historic Hyde Pdrk IS to be improved in its<br />
lighting arrangements. It is to be ht by hUle clocks,<br />
inside the lamp standards automatically, and at midnight<br />
will also be turned out automatically. The<br />
men who lit the cold lamps have done so for long<br />
periods, varying from ~8 to 3:3 years, and they have<br />
many tales to tell of their experIences in Hydo<br />
Park during those many years. They and their old<br />
lamps have had to give way to new men and new<br />
lamps' the inevitable law of existence.<br />
This year is the centenary of the birth of R. M.<br />
Bd.llantyne, whose 80 books of adventure. written<br />
over a space of 40 years have held, and no doubt<br />
still hold spell-bound many thoulIl\nds of boys.<br />
"The Young Fur Traders" and "Ungava" were<br />
written after hiS lonelv and auventarOllS ilervice of<br />
seven years with the Hudson B1Y Company in the<br />
frozen WIlds. B1l1antyne then sett1ed down to<br />
storywriting in earnest, though set.~led down is<br />
hardly the phrase for a career that took him to<br />
Algiers, Norway, South Africa, to sea on a trawler,<br />
and into TID Mines In search of local colour.<br />
Early Ireland is a sphere of legend and poetry,<br />
and to most it speaks only in faint echoes of" The<br />
Harp that once thro' Tara's Halls, the soul of music<br />
shed. " In her History of the Irish State to 1014,<br />
Mrs. A. S. Green, the widow of J. R. Green whose<br />
short history of English people made thousands<br />
cease to regard history as a dull subject, tells a sober<br />
story of Ireland in the days when 'fara was a real<br />
capital of the Kmgdom of Meath, one of many Irish<br />
subordinate Kmgdoms. English people too ~~ften<br />
forget that the conversion of their ancestors owes<br />
much to Irish missionaries and Irish schools, whither<br />
the eager scholars of the newly converted<br />
English, flocked in thousands thi! teen centuries ago.<br />
By the death of Sir Ramkrishna Gopal Bhandar~<br />
kar, the world loses one of the foremost Indian<br />
Orientalists. His contributions to OrIental Research<br />
were many and varied, he founded and edited the<br />
"Indian Antiquary." He was the author of "Early<br />
History of the Deccan," the Oriental Research Institute<br />
at Poona, estal,lished in .1915 owed not a little<br />
to him. He served as a professor in several colleges,
October 2nd, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 259<br />
and was a member of the Lpgislature of &>mbay and<br />
also of the Viceregal Council. He was honoured for<br />
bis learning by the Universities, not only of India,<br />
but of Europe.<br />
The Maharajah of Patiala has been visiting places<br />
of educational interE'st, 8uch as the Institntion for<br />
the Blind, the Salvation Army and varioDs hospitals<br />
and now he bas gone with his Maharanee to Geneva.<br />
There with Lord Willingdon and Sir A. C. Chatterjee<br />
High Commissioner. he will rE-present India at<br />
the AI!Rembly of the League of Nations which is<br />
abo\lt to he held. He will specially represent the<br />
Huling Princes of India.<br />
'fhe election of Mr. V. J. Patel, the staunch<br />
Swarajist, to the Presidentship of the Indian Legislatin><br />
Assembly, his speech of acceptance of office,<br />
and the expressions of goodwill i,n the A8Bembly, on<br />
the occasion have bl'en well received in England.<br />
Pundit Motilal Nehru, the leader of the Swarajists<br />
in the Assembly has also accepted a seat on the Indian<br />
Sandhurst Commission, and Mr. Gandhi himself<br />
is agreeable to tbe machinery of the All India<br />
Congress Committee being used in the support of<br />
the t;warajlsts in the Assembly. All this appears to<br />
indicate a new era in the life of India.<br />
News in Brief<br />
The Second Vedic Conference under the auspices<br />
of the Arya Pratinidhi Sabha will be held, we are<br />
informed, on Sunday tbe 4th October 1925 at 10 a.m.<br />
at (;;1 Illinll Street, Ladysmith. Pandit Bhawani<br />
Dayal will preside.<br />
-o-<br />
We are informed by the Hon. Secretaries ( Messrs.<br />
M. R. Naidoo and K. S. Moodley ) that the Twentieth<br />
Anuiversary Cclebratior. of the Hindu Young Men's<br />
Association will take place in the Association Hall.<br />
Maritzburg on Sunday the 11th October commencing<br />
at 10 a.m.<br />
-0-<br />
Referring to the white man's burtlen, The New<br />
Rl!'pub/w says that" this burden generally consists of<br />
loot stolen from men of some other colour ...<br />
-o-<br />
We read in 7'/M World Tomorrow :-<br />
The National system of education in Japan begins<br />
at the kindergarden. taking children from three ypars<br />
of age to six. At the age of six the children are<br />
required to go to elemmtary schools and stay there<br />
till twelve. 'I'here are today about 30,000 such schools<br />
with 9,000.000 children. It is reported that 99 per<br />
cent of the boys and over ~)~ per cent of the girls of<br />
school age are now actually going to school. Very<br />
few Japan('se are found unable either to read newspapers<br />
or to write simple lettel·s.<br />
THANKS<br />
Mrs. Hajee Ismail and family and Mr. O. H. A<br />
Jha\"eri tender their heartfelt thanks to all friends<br />
for their kindly sympathy and condolence in their<br />
Mil bfIJ·Pllvpmpnt.<br />
BOOKS FOR SALE<br />
To be obtained from the Ind,a.. 01""0" Press, PhreDlx,<br />
Natal. Postal Orders to be made payable at Durban.<br />
The Hon. Mr. Gokhale and the Indenture System:l 0<br />
Indian Home Rule. b, M. K. Gandhi ~ 6<br />
A Book-aDd h' Miloomer<br />
•<br />
a"lJa.'4 Ollil Nt •• DOIa'cn'i TraD.lad~D I a<br />
Asiatics Registration Amendment Act (1908)<br />
in English and Gujarati<br />
Hindu Social Ideals, hy P. J. Mehta<br />
Rise and Growth ot Bombay Municipal Govt.<br />
Agricultural Industries in India<br />
Tbe Story of the Ramayana, the Epic of Rama<br />
A Study in Indian ECQDomics, by P. Bannerji<br />
The Indians or South Africa, by H. S. L. Polak<br />
Life of M. K. Gandhi (in Tamil)<br />
The Golden Number of ,. Judian Opinion"<br />
Paper covers<br />
Bound in Cloth<br />
Speeches on Indian Affairs, by John Morley<br />
The'HoD. Mr. Gokhale'. Tour in South Alrica:<br />
Special INDIAN OPINION Souvenirr.<br />
The Ethics of Passive Resistance<br />
Essay on Indian Economics, by Mahadev<br />
Govind Ranade<br />
Hindu Psalms and Hymns<br />
Valshavite Reformers 01 India<br />
• M. K. Gandhi and the South African<br />
Indian Problem<br />
Aspecs of the Vedanta<br />
Essays on Indian Art, Industry and Education<br />
Sri Madhwacharya<br />
Hinduism, by Dr. Barnett<br />
Position 01 the Women in the Vedas<br />
Vernaculars as Media of Instruction in<br />
Inrliao Schools and Colleges<br />
Essentials of Hiuduism<br />
Dadabhai N aorojl's Speeches and Writings<br />
India!] National Congress<br />
The Madras Congress and Conferences<br />
Allahabad and Nagpur Congresses<br />
The Surat Congress and Conferences<br />
The Improvement of Indian Agriculture<br />
The Congress Conferences and Conventions<br />
India'. Untouchable Saints<br />
The Governance of India, by Govind Das<br />
For India's Uphft, by Anne Besant<br />
Sri RamanuJacharya<br />
:I 6<br />
.. 6<br />
:I 6<br />
:I 6<br />
4 6<br />
:I 0<br />
:I 6<br />
:I 6<br />
3 6<br />
3 6<br />
2 6<br />
3 0<br />
3<br />
r<br />
3<br />
6<br />
:I 6<br />
I<br />
e<br />
I 6<br />
II 6<br />
1 ti<br />
2 6<br />
6<br />
I " 6<br />
6 0<br />
8 0<br />
I 6<br />
2 6<br />
II 0<br />
:I 6<br />
II 0<br />
II 0<br />
7 6<br />
3<br />
2<br />
6<br />
6<br />
Sri Sankaracharya 2 ,6<br />
Mr. Gandhi's Speeches and Writings-lSg6 to 1917 3 6<br />
The Indian Demancill, by G. A. Natesan 2 6<br />
Indian Industrial and Economic ProbleD15 by Prof. Kale 3 6<br />
Essays on National Idealism, by Dr. Coomaraswamy z 6<br />
BIOGRAPHIES OF EMINENT INDIANS:-<br />
Dadabhai NaoroJi. Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Rabindra.<br />
oath Tagore, M. K. Gandhi, BudruddlD Tyabji<br />
Pundit Madan Mohan Malaviya, The Rtght Hon<br />
Sayed Amir Ali, H. H. Sri Sayaji Rao Gaekwar.<br />
Sir Sayed Ahmed Khan, H. H. the Aga Khan,<br />
Swami Rama Tlfath, V. Krishnaswami Aiysr, Krista<br />
Das Pal, Dewan C. Raogacharlu, W. C. BODnerjea,<br />
A. M. Bose, Ran Varma, Kashinath Trimbak Telang,<br />
Swami Vivekanada, Toru Dutt, Ishwar Chandra<br />
Vldyasagar, SlrSaJar Jung, V. P. Madhava Rao, D. E.<br />
Wacbn, Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, Sir Phero.<br />
zesha iM I.l.l, Rahimtulla Mohamed Sayani, Dr. Rash<br />
.Behan Ghos_ Nawab Mohsln.U\.Molk, Sir C. San.<br />
karan Naif, Lal Hohun Ghose, Raja Ram Mohan<br />
Roy, Bthtamjl il. Malabarl, tthsi Anliil besanr.<br />
BllblS 8u"ndrllnatll llAollrjell, R'O IIlhwlIf a. lIT.<br />
MIl'~'"<br />
"~h
~fts~ at aiU(i~t(;t dJi~.~<br />
, ~<br />
~~rt!- ~3 ~.. ".{h~, .y.ql~, rtlfl'lJt ~ ~H);lot~ t~~'! ~.! 'to I<br />
~·~\,Cl~l WI\etl~l ~~uGV<br />
:ut1~llr :ut::t '\{lll~::t a.)11i ls~~l-t :ttll~ hl~l.{\(('J()l\'<br />
,., ~!ltl.{\ :aJt1'ldi ~l[ilr-t ::t~-ta E{l31tll ~ll~ l{l.<br />
&!J(~~. lla.iJt :ttHI~.{\' ~3tlt~rt~ ·fidltll :ut~c.t~I~'l~1<br />
R~ :ut::t ~'31'Cq~1 lIUle.tl::t rct~ )lEll!s :ttl{l lll-rtcO<br />
:ut1'lE{l~. d lr~ ~ ): 5l.1~1'fl ~':)ntl q~l-tl ~i~l::t<br />
~"l~~l H'=tl~ il !It .. ::t ~fY\ill.1 et:a.;q ~:tl\-tl~ et~~.<br />
1s'l(ll~-tlli ill. !It .. ::t ~avi~l :aJt~~'t~~ et~l~ ((~!It'~lti<br />
:utletetl?fi ~i ~:tll.{\ ill.l~ ~, ~~Irtl lsl~EI ~ ~':)n1<br />
'et~frtl ~I)I :ttlitrtl 5l.1~1-t1 'Ca.~::t ~·dGtrt :ut1'lrtHI<br />
o1~ ~I~
,Jjttdiau<br />
"'~<br />
·~pinitllt<br />
-N-o-.-4-1--V-o-1.-X-X-I-I-I-.----F-.-n-·d-:-a-y-,-::O~c-t-o-:b-e-r-9-t:-h-,-I9-2-5-.----;;ll:::,c:;:i.::ce::recl::;:.p:-:t::::;::::-;:;,-;;~:-;·U'!.:;-·-:~:-:-':.-;:;H;: ••<br />
:':"::pa·<br />
FURTHER PROTEST AGAINST ASIATIC BILL<br />
1_ r.ETINGS AT LADYSMITH, DUNDEE, DANNHAUSER AND NEWCASTLE<br />
THE oflicials of the Natal Indian Coogress in<br />
Meeting At Newcastle<br />
furtherance of propaganda against the Asiatic On the following day (Monday) the partY' motored<br />
13111 held a number of meetings in the Northern<br />
Dish'iets of Natal all of which were well attended 2-30 p.m. at the Indian School-room and by this<br />
up to Newcastle. The meeting was advertised for<br />
and a keen interest was shown by those present to time the Hall was full. and some of them had to<br />
support the Congress in fighting this obnoxious and stand for want of seating accommodation.<br />
nnjust piece of legislation.<br />
There were a few European sympathisers also<br />
Meeting At Dundee<br />
present and spoke condemning the Bill.<br />
Mr. A. I. Kajee delt in detail showing how.<br />
The first meeting was held at the Mosque grounu:, • adversely the BIll affects the Indian community<br />
in Dundee on SunddY the 3rd inst., at 2 p.m. Mr.<br />
A. I. Kajee explained in det.'lil the provisions of the<br />
Bill as it affects the Indian community and pointed<br />
out that if thIS Bill became law the position of the<br />
Indians would become intolerable. Messrs. Sorabjee<br />
Rustomjcf', B. A. Maghrajh and C. R. Naidoo also<br />
spoke at len6-.th on the 13111. The following resolution<br />
which was proposed by Mr. Cassim Meer,<br />
seconueu by Mr. Ebrahun BhamJa, and supported<br />
by 1\1:r. V. G. Naidoo was unanimously carried:<br />
" This meeting of Dundee and District Indians<br />
held ullIler the auspices of the Natal Indian Congr('s&<br />
hereby approves of all that the Natal Indian<br />
Congress has done with regard to the protest against<br />
the Areas Reservation and ImmigratIOn and Re€istrat<br />
ion (Further Provision) BIll and fUl'ther records<br />
Hs confidence in the Natal In
INDIAN OPINION October 9th, 1925<br />
''Tnis M~eting of Dall.nhallser and District Indians<br />
held under the auspices of the Natal Indian Congress<br />
hereby approves of every work that the Natal<br />
Indian Congress has hitherto done with regard to the<br />
protest against the Areas Reservation and ImmIgration<br />
and Registration (Further Provision) BIll, and<br />
further records its abaolute confider.ce in the Natal<br />
Indian Congress."<br />
Immediately at the close of all the above meetings<br />
a good number of those present enrolled as members<br />
of the Congress and the comments on the Bill published<br />
by the Congress in Engl~sh and Hindi were sold.<br />
n is pleasing to note that at Dannhauser the feeling<br />
WaS so great that the men working on night<br />
shift'at the Durban Navigation Colliery left their<br />
work to\attend the meeting and a request by letter<br />
was recelved by the officials of the Congress from<br />
the Manager of the Colliery to allow these men to<br />
return as Il'drly as possible. The members of the<br />
COngrei\8 after some persuasion succeeded in getting<br />
the men to return 'to their work in good time.<br />
Though the meetillg was held at a late honr in the<br />
evening a large number of 19,dies turned up and expresseil.<br />
their willingness if n~ be to suffer once<br />
again with their men in the struggle for freedom<br />
;1'nd justice.<br />
Those who proceeded for the above meetings<br />
were Messrs. Amod Hayat, Sorabjee Rustomjee,<br />
V. S. C. Pather, A. I. Kajee, R. K. Naidoo, P. R.<br />
Pather, Ahmed Kajee, C. R. Naidoo, B. A. Maghraj,<br />
S. A. Pillay and Pandit Bhawani Dayal.<br />
Mr. C. R. Naidoo who has recently arrived from<br />
India was welcomed by the Natal Indian Congress<br />
on Thursday night last week at the parsee Hustomjee<br />
Hall under the chairmanship of Mr. J. W. Godfrey.<br />
Mr. Naidoo gave an interesting address on India<br />
expiaining that the Englishmen's presence in Inllia<br />
had not been for India's good as a whole. They had<br />
converted their position as guarJians and trustees into<br />
that of masters and ownt-.rs. They had exploltpd<br />
India and were still domg so for their own benefit.<br />
They had killed the spIrit of Illdld-n nationalism and<br />
were to-day killing out IndIans inclustry and retarding<br />
progress. He advised the Indians here to bestir<br />
themselves into a.ct~~d fight the ASiatic BIll. \",<br />
Mr. Hajee Cassim Adam the well known merchant<br />
of Pretoria and chairman of the local British Indian<br />
Association sails with his family per 8.S. KarolJ<br />
from Lourenco Marques on the 14th instant for India<br />
where he intends staying for a short time and returning<br />
via Europe. We wish Mr. Hajee Casslm Add-m<br />
a pleasant voyage an(1 a safe return.<br />
Sir Edward Grigg the new Governor of Kenya<br />
and Lady Grigg arrived at Nairobi on the 3rd instant.<br />
(<br />
A meeting of the Young Indian Improvemant<br />
Society was recently held at Pretoria under the<br />
chairmanship of Mr. H. N. Keshavjee to protest<br />
against the Asiatic Bill and the anti-Asiatic agitatIOn<br />
carried in the Tranlilvaal.<br />
Notes and News<br />
?\l REUTER'S massage from Bombay reports .<br />
m Mrs. Sarojini Naidu President of the South<br />
African Indian Congress, has issued an appeal<br />
to all communities to observe Oct. 11 as a day set apart<br />
to express the national sentiment agaInst "harsh, rugh<br />
handed, anti AsiatIC legislation of the Union Government."<br />
She especially calls on Europeans and Indian<br />
Christians on the ground that it is their duty to<br />
protect the traditfqnal Christian ide~ls of equity and<br />
justice.<br />
It is to be hoped that Mrs. Naidu's a.ppeal will be<br />
responded to wholeheartedly. But this action in<br />
India only increases our duty in this country.<br />
Whilst our brethren in India are suffering for us it<br />
will not be meet for us to sit quiet. Our activities<br />
shmlld be redoubled. Successful meetings are being<br />
held in the different parts of the Province to protest<br />
against the Asiatic Bill. But while that is satililfactmy<br />
the delay in calling the South African Indian<br />
Congress is disappoi.nting. Any delay is going<br />
to be injurious to us in the future. It 1S high time<br />
that official representations were made to the Union,<br />
Indian and Imperial Governments before the Bill<br />
comes before Pal'liament a second time. The<br />
letters published in the Gujarati portion of our<br />
correspondence column in this issue clearly demonstrate<br />
the feelings of our brethren and their preparednesli<br />
for paesive resistance. In fact they are<br />
anxious to put it into action immediately. That iii<br />
indeed very encouraging a.nd >ve do not by any<br />
means wish t,o kill that spirit in them. But We<br />
would ask our brethren to leave that weapon a.,,'i the<br />
very last resort after all other meanil have entirely<br />
failed. We know that our patIence is being put to<br />
a severe test. Let us bear a little longer tlJld exhaust<br />
even the last ounce of our patience in"app}ying<br />
every cOfl:stitutionaI means possib.-Ie; and having.<br />
failed in t.,at our passive resistance~w1).1 be fully",<br />
justified. , \<br />
A mass meeting of Newcastle and District Indians<br />
was recently held under the chairmanship of Mr.<br />
L. C. B. Ephraim to protest against the Asiatic Bill.<br />
The following resolutions were nnanimously<br />
passed:-<br />
(1) That this ID.'\8S meeting of Newcastle Indmns<br />
hereby protests against the Areas Reservation<br />
and Immigration and RegistratIOn (Further Provision)<br />
Bill now before Parliament which has<br />
for its object our compulsory segregation, tho<br />
deprivation of proprietary and trading rights fnrther<br />
restrictons on our domiciliary rights and ultimate<br />
extinction of the Indian Community as openly<br />
declared by the Minister of Interior.<br />
(2) "That this mass meeting of Newcastle and<br />
District Indians assembled in the St. Oswald School<br />
hereby places on record its wholehearted support to<br />
the resolutions passed at the Mass Meeting of Indians<br />
held in the Durban Town Hall under the auspices<br />
of the Natal Indian Congress."<br />
It was decided to forward the first<br />
the GO'fernor General and the second<br />
Indian Congress.<br />
resolution to<br />
to the Natal<br />
I<br />
The War Resisters' International Conference recently<br />
held at Hodesdon (Herts), the following<br />
resolution was unanimously adopted :-<br />
" This conference of the War Resisters' Interna- I<br />
tional, representing 43 organisations in 19 countries l'<br />
in Europe, America, Asia, and Australia, declares "<br />
its belief in the essential unity of all peoples of<br />
whatever race, colour or creed.<br />
" It denounces all forces which make for their: I<br />
diviliion, exploitation, and enmity, and especially I j<br />
the evils of armaments, militarism, and war.<br />
pledges those whom it represents to work unceasingly<br />
for a new relationship between nati\'/ns,!,<br />
based on fraternity instead of force, and serVice iustead<br />
of subjection; and, recognising the ever-present<br />
danger of war under existing conditIOns, reaffirm!!, I<br />
in the spirit of indissoluble comradeship the deter-I<br />
mination of its thousancls of' affiliated memberr·'<br />
throughout the world to refuse tn\1itary and waIII',<br />
service under all circumstanc68 and w-!Iatever the. \<br />
c:onsequences in loyalty to: the 8upreme' elaims oj, j<br />
~he common humanity of all peoples. . ~.. .<br />
. -::....-... .. - .... .- ... --.- --:.~- -" -;--<br />
It
6ctober 9th, 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
PUBLIC HEALTH COMMITTEES AND<br />
INDIA~S<br />
Im Jurlgmcnt of the Supreme Court in the<br />
1f case of the Isipingo Public Health Committee<br />
v. A. C. Jadwat has brought a considerable<br />
amount of relief to thfl Indian community<br />
This wa'! one of a s.eries of actions brought<br />
by the vUlious Public Health Committees functioning<br />
in the 'uburban areas of Durban ag.linst re-<br />
, llJrcRentative Indians for the rates levied by them,<br />
which rates the Indians living in .those alMS had<br />
refuscd to pny. A number of exceptions were<br />
taken by defendant to the plaintiff's claim. the<br />
first of which was that the Committee was not a<br />
lawfully establiHhed body, that the Public Health<br />
Act gave the Provincial Council no power to create<br />
Public Hf'alth Committee" as it purported to do<br />
under the Public Health Committees Ordinance<br />
of 1923, and this exception has been held by tpe<br />
learned Judges t'. be quite justified. The Judges<br />
hold that the Health Committees are not one of<br />
the urban authorities to whom powers were entrnstfld<br />
by toe IIealth Act because they were not<br />
in existence at the time it was passed. The public<br />
Health Com'Dittees are not Divisional Councils nor<br />
ha·.e they been anothoritled by the Governor<br />
Gcneral to administer the Public Health Act as<br />
rural anthorities have been. "It was clear," remarked<br />
Ilis Lordship the Judge President, "that where<br />
there was no local authority in existence, the<br />
Guvernor-General, and he only, had the power to<br />
appoint a b'Xly of men to ad minster the Public<br />
Health Act. Section 8G of South Africa Act provides<br />
that Provincial legislation shall be valid and effective<br />
so long as it is not repugnant to any Union<br />
Act, and there could be no doubt that the Provincial<br />
Council, in attempting to arrogate to itself the<br />
powers expressly vested in the Gover_:or-tl-enel'al<br />
by the Public lIealth Act was acting repugnantly<br />
to the Act."<br />
Ever since ·the passing of the public Health<br />
Committees Ordinance it had l.>ecome a source<br />
(If great an'{icty to 1\ large nmnber of Indians<br />
residing in tho areas created under the<br />
Ordinance. The object of the Public Health Committees<br />
in which Indian'! were given no voice<br />
whatsoever either directly or indirectly, was, as<br />
they had provrd by thoir treatment of the Indians<br />
within their area'l, to victimis'} the Indians and<br />
ham'ls thorn as muC'h as possible, and this judgment<br />
has no doubt brought at least temporary relief<br />
to theM. We say temporary because we<br />
know that those who have a determined object·<br />
and have no scruples will find other ways and<br />
means to achieve that object Ollr contemporary<br />
thlNatal Mercury has already put fIrth a suggestion<br />
that" it the Provincial Council exceeded its<br />
powers in cre.Lting these Committees, the Governorlleneral-in-Council<br />
has certainly power so to do,<br />
and a pn damntion in the next Gazette shoulU<br />
establish them in a' position which will enable<br />
them to proceed with the WOl k which they have<br />
in hand." Wllat is amazing is that the Provincial<br />
Council should have been allowed to pass such<br />
an Ordinance ol!tside the powers conferred on it<br />
and, further more, that the Governor-General-in<br />
Council should have assented to it. Together<br />
with the creation of these Public Health Committees<br />
the Indians in the areas under the jurisdiction<br />
of those Committees had appointed their<br />
O)VIl Health Unions and it was their firm<br />
stand that had brought about the present test ease.<br />
They are to be congratulated not only 011 the success<br />
of their case but also for preventing an<br />
irregularity being perpetuated in the Provincial<br />
administration.<br />
Public Health Committees<br />
Ordinance<br />
ProvinCial Council Acting Repugnantly<br />
To Health Act<br />
The case of Isipingo Public Health Committee<br />
v. A. C. Jadwat was heard in the Supreme Court<br />
(Natal Provincial Division) on Thursday morning<br />
Oct. 1. 1925 before Sir John Dove-Wilson, Judge<br />
President, Mr. Justice Carter, and Mr. Justice<br />
Tatham.<br />
The Committee brought action in the Supreme<br />
Court for the recovery of the sum. of £19, which<br />
their declaration stated was owing by defendant in<br />
reepect of rates for which he had been asseflSed by<br />
the Committee. and which he failed to pay.<br />
The defendant excepted to the declaration on the<br />
following grounds :-<br />
(1) That it was bad in law, inasmuch as plaintiff<br />
is not a lawfully established body, the Provincial<br />
Council having no power under Act 36 of 1919. or<br />
any other law, to create the Public Health Committees<br />
which it pnrports to do under Ordinance 7 of<br />
1923.<br />
(2) Alternatively, if it be held that plaintiff i~ a<br />
vahdly constituted body, that the Provincial Council<br />
has no power to vest it with the right to impose<br />
rates.<br />
(3) Alternatively, if the above exeptions are disposed<br />
of, that the Ordinances relied upon by plaintiff<br />
do not in fact vest the plaintiff with that right.<br />
(4) Alternatively, in the event of none of the<br />
above exceptions being upheld, defendant excepts<br />
on the ground that the rate is ultra Vires, because:<br />
(a) The right to impose rates on immovable property<br />
conferred by Ordinance 7 of 1923 read with<br />
Ordinance 6 of 1924 does not entitle plaintiff to<br />
levy rates on buildings and dwellings only, nor to<br />
levy rates on business; (b) it is arbitrary and unreasonable.<br />
and the incidence of taxation unfair;<br />
(c) it is based, in respect of the residences, on a discrimination<br />
between European and non-European_<br />
Mr. J. J. L. Sisson, with him Mr. T. B. Horwood,<br />
instructed by Mr. W. L. Burne, appeared for the<br />
excipient defendants. Mr. E. A. Selke, with him<br />
Mr. Clarkson, instructed by Messrs. Clarkson and<br />
Driver, appeared for the respondent plaintiffs.<br />
On the first exception Mr. Sisson contended that<br />
the Provincial CouncIl had unwarrantably arrogated<br />
to itself a power expressly vested in the Governor<br />
Gellflral by the Public Health Act of 1919 Section<br />
7(4).<br />
Mr. Selke contended that the Provincial Council<br />
had power to legislate as it had. in terms of Section<br />
8:; of the South Africa Act. and that the legislation<br />
was not repugnant (under 8ection ~6 of the South<br />
Africa Act) to the provisions of the Publio Health
Act 1922 in Section 7 (4); that the PublIc Health I<br />
Committee was such a body as was referred to in<br />
thatsub-sectlOn, and that inasmuch as the Ordinance<br />
of 1923 was expl'essly passed, in futherance of the<br />
Public Health Act of 1919, it could not be regarded<br />
as repugnant to it; that it was not an infringement<br />
of the Governor-Gtneral's power conferred by the<br />
sub-sectIon, because his power is to appomt bodIes<br />
to administer the Public ~ealth Act only whe~e<br />
there is no body such as the present PublIc Health<br />
Committees so to administer it.<br />
The Judge-Prpsident, III givmg judgment after<br />
stating the facts, said there could be no doubt that<br />
in the Ordinance of 1923 the ProvlOCII CoullCIal<br />
sought to set up machinery for carrying out tbe provisions<br />
of t~e Public Health Act of 1919. This Act<br />
provides that the several locar authorIties shall with<br />
III their respective distrl~cts carrying out the duties<br />
provided by the Act. Section 7 (3) of the Act reads<br />
INDIAN OPINION October 9th, 1925<br />
as follows:<br />
•<br />
" An urban local authority includes any municipaloI'<br />
borough or town or village council, town<br />
Receives Governor-General's Assent<br />
board, loc~l board, vIllage management board and The promulgation of the Transvaal Proviucial<br />
ahlo any board of management or committee OL' Ordinance tor tt e control of the issue of general<br />
other body (not being a rural authority) which is dealers' hcences is contained lU last week~' Provmconstituted<br />
in accordance with any law, !lnd which CIal G."lzetie.<br />
under any law is endowed with sanitary powers for The ordinance is styled the General Dealers<br />
safeguarding the health of its inhabitants of Its distrICt.<br />
"<br />
(Control) OI'dinance, 1~2'), and WIll come iuto<br />
Section 7 (4) reads as follows'<br />
"A rural local authority means any divIsIonal<br />
council constItuted III accordance with any lJ.w and<br />
shall also include any body of pprsons which the<br />
Governor-General is hereby authOlised to cons~ltute<br />
as, and declare by proclJ.matlOn 111 the Gazette to be,<br />
a rural local authority for all or any of the purposes<br />
of this Act. "<br />
The PublIc Health (Jommittee IS not an urban<br />
authority because, ex hypotlws~, had there been<br />
such an urba.n authorIty in eXIstence 2.t the tIme of<br />
tIie Act or before the Ordmance was pa.ssed, there<br />
would have been no need for these Public Health<br />
Committees to have been created by the Provlllcul<br />
CounCIl.<br />
The Public Health CommIttee IS not a LlivlslOnal<br />
council, nor procl.:nmed by the Governor-General I.n<br />
terms of suo-sectIOn (3) of SectIOn 7 of the PublIc<br />
Health Act. It was clear that where there was no<br />
local authority In eXIstence, the Govel'nol'-Gt'nerlll<br />
and he only, had the power to appomt a body of<br />
men to admimster the PubIlC Health Act. SectIOn<br />
86 of the South Africa Act prOVIdes that Provlllcml<br />
legislation shall be valid and effective so long as it is<br />
not repugnant to any Umon Act. and there c,mld be<br />
no doubt that the ProvmcIaI CounCIl, III attempting<br />
to arrogate to Itself the powers expl essly vesteLl in<br />
the Governor-General by tbe Pubilc Health Act,<br />
was acting repugnantly to the Act, and the fil'st<br />
exception msat therefore be upheld WIth costs.<br />
Mr. JustIce Carter concurred.<br />
Mr. SIsson argued that as the Court's judgment,<br />
just gIven, ha'l the effect of holdmg that the plamtiff<br />
Committee was a person non-exi"tent III law. the<br />
order as to costs should be agamst the mdiVldual<br />
members of the CommIttee, but the Court would not<br />
make this order, as the members of the Committee<br />
were not before the Court.<br />
Sydenham Public Health Committee v L. P"udJ,Y<br />
Bellair and HillariV Pubhc Health CommIttee v.<br />
E. M. Paruk.<br />
Mayville Public Health Committee v. Bhana Parsotam.<br />
Malvern Public Health Committee v, ],,1. C. S:.tlt.:m.<br />
Greenwood Park PublIc Health Commlttt'e v.<br />
IsmaIl Kajee.<br />
South Coast JunctIOn Public Health Committee<br />
v. M. A. Karim.<br />
Each of the above cases was similar to that of the<br />
Isi~in~o PUQIic Health CommIttee v. A. C. Jadwat<br />
reported above, and the first exception taken to each<br />
of them was identical WIth the first exception in the<br />
Isipingo casp.<br />
Mr. J. J. L. Sisson, with him Mr. T. R. Horwood,<br />
Illstructe,l by Mr. L. Burne, appeal'ed. for the ex<br />
CIpIent defpndants.<br />
Mr. E. A. Selke, WIth him Mr. Clarkson. instructed<br />
by Messrs. Clarkson and Driver, appeared for<br />
respondE'nt plamtiff~.<br />
The Court upheld with COl:lts, the first exception<br />
III each case, on the grounds mdic'lted 111 the judgment<br />
reported above.-NatallJlercury.<br />
Transvaal General Dealers<br />
(Control) Ordinance<br />
operation on October 21)th and after that date. the<br />
applicant for a general dealer's licence or renewal,<br />
must produce a certificate under this ordmance.<br />
The AdmIl1lstratlOn may (a) constitute for any area<br />
outside a municipalIty a board, to be called. a rural<br />
licensmg board, consIstmg of a maglstraw, who shall<br />
be the chmrman, and not lebs thdn two 110r more<br />
than four persons; (b) increase, alter, or diminish<br />
the area of jurisdICtlOn of such board aud at any<br />
time on due caU'le being shown abolish or dlRcstabhsh<br />
such a board.<br />
Every local authority or board may refuse a certificate<br />
on the following grounds :-<br />
(1) That the premises where it IS intended that<br />
the busmess should be carried on &re not BUlbble<br />
for the purpose of the busmess whether a'3 regal'ds<br />
their samtation or situation or character of the<br />
buildings structurally or otherwise. (2) That the<br />
locahty or the premises is not one in whICh it is<br />
desirable that the busmesil contempldtea should be<br />
carried on by the applIcant or at all. (:;) That in<br />
the opimon of the local authOrity or board concerned<br />
the applicant is not a fit and proper person to hold<br />
such a licence or to carryon such a bustness, and in<br />
the case of a busmes3 where artICles of food or drmk<br />
are produced, prepared. used. or soH for hum.1n<br />
consumptIOn; also on any of the followmg gl'oundil :<br />
(a) That the ",pplicaut IS by re~on of the uncleanliness<br />
of his perdon or habLts or m~thodil unfit<br />
to be entrusted with the handling, pL'eparation, Or<br />
sale of such articles of foo.1 or drink. or is otherWise<br />
not a desirable person to hold such a lic'lnce. (b)<br />
That the granLmg of such a lic~nce in respect of the<br />
premises for which it B SOU'5ht i;~ calculate,l to cause<br />
a l1l11SanCe or annoyance to persons residmg in the<br />
neIghbonrhood.<br />
The decision of a lOcal authol'ity on the board on<br />
any apphcdtlOn for a certifiCate is final, excpt that<br />
an applicant lor the renewal of a licence m'lY appeal<br />
to the Sa[)l'emc Cu,ll't, who m.1Y grant the renew
October 9th, 1925<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
bas the power to order the renewal of the licence 01'<br />
remit the ~ase to the local authority or the bo.lrIl.<br />
If an application has been refused by a 10C'al antbor·<br />
ity or board it may not be renewed for tlix<br />
months.-TItJ' SlUT.<br />
The Marks Of Christianity<br />
Bishop Fisher's Sermon<br />
f<br />
At the Wesleyan Church, Greyville, on Sunday<br />
Sept. 1a Bishop Fisher of CAlcutta delivered the<br />
following sermon, taking his text from St. Paul's<br />
epistle to the Galatians Chapter G, verse 17: "From<br />
henceforth let no man trouble me for I bear in my<br />
body the marks of the Lord Jesus."<br />
This is the response St. Paul made to certdin<br />
accnsations, and it is similar to the response of Jesus<br />
to the doubting among the disciples, "hen he saiJ<br />
• Behold my hands and my fet't.' He suddenl;<br />
appeared before his disciples and tht'y thought hJm<br />
dead and were afraid. They thought they had seen<br />
a spirit, but he proved to them tha.t he was living in<br />
~he flesh, antI the proof was an experimental proof:<br />
Behold my hands and my feet. '<br />
St. Paul was driven by many accnsers in the<br />
Roman Empire, and particularly in those sectIOns<br />
called Asia. He grew weary of these constant<br />
accusations--' You are not like unto us; you do not<br />
follow our customs; you are not one of us you<br />
preach in a way that we cannot accept: you aI~ continually<br />
holding up ideals we will not follow, and<br />
you speak ~ith no authority.' But St. Paul remembered<br />
that he had been beaten with many<br />
strokes and had been in prison and had earned his<br />
right to be a follower of Jesus Christ, and he knew<br />
his friends, by just touching hIS back and shoulder<br />
would feel the ridges of flesh that had been mad~<br />
by the lash of the whip and therefore he said 'I<br />
care nothing for your authority or about your' reception<br />
of me. My justificatIOn comes from someone<br />
elst', it comes from Jesus Christ. I am crucified<br />
with Christ. I live, yet not I, it is Christ that liveth<br />
in me. Bother me no more and bl'mg me into court<br />
no more, speak to me in the street in dlsPaI'agin~<br />
terms no more. You cannot irritate me because I<br />
bear in my body the marks of my Lord. '<br />
Now it is a strange thing that in thIS book of Galatians<br />
we find St. Paul's spiritual decla.!'ation of independence,<br />
and the very people to whom he wrote<br />
it came later to believe in the very gospel he<br />
preached.<br />
I sometimes wonder how you and I can have it<br />
known and understood that we are disciples of the<br />
Lord Jesus. What is there about me, if someone<br />
challenges me in the streets of Durban to show that<br />
I am a Christian? Can I turn and say: Henceforth<br />
trouble me no more, for I bt'ar in my bodX the marks<br />
of the Lord Jesus? Is there any way by which a<br />
man in the street or in the shop or the mill or the<br />
office or in any of the social walks of life, will know<br />
I am a follower of Jesus Christ? In what way am<br />
I marked? I have come from a country across the<br />
Indian ocean where 320 millions of IndIans belong<br />
to Bome particular faith. He may be a Hindu he<br />
I<br />
'<br />
way be a Mahommedan, he may be a Parsee, or he<br />
may be a Sikh. No matter what hIS religion is,<br />
there is some way by which you can distiuguish the<br />
group t() which he belongs. The Hindu has his<br />
particular characteristic, the Brahman wears a string<br />
upon his shoulder, just an or,linary cotton cord, and<br />
when you see that you know that ht' belongs to the<br />
sect called Brahman'. The man in the strt'et nnderstands<br />
that he i& a Brahman, and the Brahman does<br />
not feat bein. 10 marJt,d, Or If rou turn to Ute<br />
,,"'I,"/llJ. w'61lltfll prill'4 ~tlo flUell abOtlt lill O.e1'<br />
the country teachinl; the children in tho marvellous<br />
sybtelll \~ here they l~arn the classics and the poetry<br />
that Ind1.1 has taught her children. You will find<br />
him always dh,tmguishable, and even the man who<br />
has renonnced evt'rything, who wears ashes, is<br />
known by the mark of the ashes. He wants the<br />
world to kllow. Agam the Mahomedan wears a red<br />
fez so that the world may know he belongs to the<br />
Mahomedan religion, and he does not care who<br />
knows it. Or he may be a SIkh from the nmrk and<br />
have a huge turban and he will so wrap it that no<br />
one evel' mistakes it. No one else will wrap it in<br />
t~t particular way and YOll will always distinguish<br />
hIm. 0 .. the Parsee will wear a shining cone-shaped<br />
hat so that citizens of Bombay or Western India<br />
may understand he belongs to that particular group.<br />
Even the greetings in the VIllage'! of India, I have<br />
learnt, baving something to do with tribal and roligion&<br />
connectIon. Who is itt Is the expression<br />
~hen you meet someone and the response may be,<br />
I am a Hmdoo of a particular sect, I am a Chrisban,<br />
I am a Mahomedan, I am this or that.' He<br />
belongs to something. He has lost hIS identIty, his<br />
personal identIty in the thing to whICh he belon$B.<br />
When we say' Who is it" We reply with our personat<br />
name. I do not say I am a Methodist, I do not<br />
~y, I ,am a ChrIstIan, I give my name. I retain my<br />
mdlvldual self and sometimes myself is bigger than<br />
my religion, and bigger than my society and bigger<br />
than my ideals. I make my ideals conform to me instead<br />
of conforming my own hfe to my ideals. I do not<br />
know just how I can make everybody understand<br />
that I am a Christian. We have no mark on the<br />
forehead, we have no distinctive dress. We have no<br />
distinctive salutatIOn. There IS no particular way<br />
ostensibly physical, by which a man can know I a~<br />
a ChristIan. If I walked along West Street I might<br />
pass 500 people in a few moments, yet I cannot tell<br />
which man is a Christian and which man IS not.<br />
OUI' social cUAtoms are all so much alike, that it is<br />
utterly impossible to t('ll who is a Christian. If I<br />
COUld. go aho~t all the various churches on a Sunday<br />
mornmg I mIght find out who belongs to a particular<br />
church, but so far as any actions during the week<br />
are concerned, it woulel be utterly impossible to dis<br />
~lDguish me from my friend across the way. How<br />
IS the worM to know that I am a Christian? Have<br />
rou ever thought of it or studIed it, or prayed about<br />
It on your knees, the responsibIlity of compelling<br />
the world to know through our lives the gospel of<br />
Jesns Christ. There is no mark. I remember at<br />
th; clOSE: of an address one night at Benares, a young<br />
Hmdu came rushing tt) the front of. the building and<br />
took hold of my fingers and said, 'Let me see your<br />
hands.' I showed him first the palms and then the<br />
other side, and he dropped them suddenly and said<br />
'There is no cross on them, how am I to know you ar~<br />
a Chl'istian. I see nothing about you to distir.guish<br />
you from other men: and it was borne in upon me<br />
that there were millions of people interested to<br />
know whether I bore about in my body the marks<br />
of my Lord.<br />
(TIJ /)/1 CIJnlznuld.)<br />
~ ~~~ ~1~ ~~ltn~tl~<br />
~l~ ~q ~li GtI~2J{I::t CIi\!?,llct~l'l1.l vtl~ ~, dl.<br />
\\9 ~5~1'l~ 'I.e:~'t .ur{l11~-tl ~l
~~!lllf ~ljl!'\ tln= ~l~lc c~~~ I-Dl~ hl~ ?J" 'h~J<br />
lhl~bllf iclh ~lt. 1 .... blYft. e to '~bllf lIilJ]tt felh.<br />
r~l{ '~ 0 ~:; kl?lf Ut \ I lY?~\f: Ilf"D1lfl: h®l»: 1:!~lt<br />
wI}! { ~ ... '~ lP-1t ,t,Dt~e"}b 'CHblc \J)ht U--1l:>ltlY<br />
h $)t. rl~tl\lk ~h. Rlt tnJ:ll Mt.lt:beli ~k'kl: 'l::?Sj~ ,.?~ lil}>Oh.<br />
'''~llt U--Il!!:IJ,.l.~ lrtlYc· lt~ ! hl~1t U~lt lo iclh. 1~t}l:<br />
-~llf 1?~ l~\iUt" M~ ~~.(.h. ~ \JIll:> 'w' 'tJlo lk<br />
P~'ll 'l!!\i1}tli ~ ~M.b ~ '~li cnth. ?lj~ ~??! Ut~<br />
blicllc t.o l~IJ,.l.R \}~a- ~~1lil: ]ltl):.h.llft lP-~ ~E<br />
lY?li~ li~~ 1\1:\iUtfi "'/~ 1lfl: I$. ~':l1~1-D ~~11-D<br />
'@ ll!.':lle~ l}1ll-Dlb 1:!~lbh.kI: 1ln= ll-v.:h. l:>lk11l @~'i')'!)<br />
'th.. lJ,.l.J.t U-P~ leh. Alt lh~cP ?li~ l't?~ ~~-(,h. tl?t}l:<br />
-~11 ~ \}J!1l u-n h.lla:C ~ 0 lr ~:la: lkll: h. l't:c 1~\lUtll<br />
~$~ Ij~-(.h. ~ ~~ lr~""JJ1~ tll}tt ~~~ lj~.flh.<br />
, .. £Hl. tla! lh" lls~,»: ~~lh.~c eR~ttlli \lUtll<br />
'~_ 11:' ~ ~l};'h.ln= 11~ It!k~ l~l'j~ 1~1l:.h.\ft: ~tlCl:<br />
l~h. l:>1l-'11l ~1~ lbl) 1l-\lUtt \}ll:> 'l~' l~~litt 11~<br />
l~ '1:!!ltl~lkWit lj1:!~ m~!f \::1l:>U ~ftb ~ ~tlh.<br />
, .. U-1J:.elt ~ll!!l}l.~ lP~c J]i) ~ t l~~ m~lln= llt,Il:Hl.llo<br />
eh.~ \}'1~~ c'H~ I~\)l' lP~I~ ]kl~licltel'i ~ lh~e\)<br />
1~\i1}t~ M~ 1~.flh. l}fOO l}fiQ Wl:>Il?11: \)lt~~ ]ltl~<br />
·,t!lllt~ 1l-l-11lel' .~ U/)lt<br />
P'lllc "'~h \::ltl{ \}LIil l~lJo JJ> l:!lle<br />
lhlWlt: ml;ll4t Iltl\:'h.llfl:<br />
lh\~P ,)?It 1tU\~ llt,Rt<br />
'~11\Jt~ 'tG7l! -rl]?-oh.<br />
1l-t:lMw '~ '~~h:J \It}t~ ~'i~ lfl}>Oh. 11£Lht}Cfl<br />
E+C'~~~~ ~~~»))I)~»»~.<br />
j<br />
. 'h,Hl. \>~ H01:t~lR: 'l! 'IP '\lMn i<br />
" .... ~U-u-.l~ l-~~~ft" ~<br />
.c:,-c~~~~~ ~»»)"~»I»)"»»».<br />
'l!;~ ~~'ef\ \J)\~ e\»: U-k~ ~kI:<br />
'~lcl\ \}',Ilil: l::;la: lG\lh. ~:ce hl~t l$Ti ~l? ll-~,"'e\<br />
1"'1\)1~ !]i) \::In= ~ t\"~ ll-Ib~ It~h:C l->~R lktla<br />
-~Ila l"lPl~ 1 ..\1t ,..\ 'IP lh~lln=ll£l~t !1tl~I~~ '\i~<br />
k~lk1: lt~lli ~I~ 'Ut lfl.h.l'i ll-pt~~\}Cl~~ "ktl'::Jp.<br />
n\j\~ flt}lh:C U-lltl tla: l$'h~ lP~l1-D '''lhl):ICll'i<br />
U~'~ll;.e l}-k~'lle k'R:l~ Qjl~ t\}t.<br />
ll-!l?lch. !~h.lkt '''~~l~~ \0h ~1]i) ~UbU-- \J)~q'1<br />
~1\1ln= ~lltJ.O ~h. lk~ tl-a: ~~~ pets 'f5l>~ fah.l\(!::<br />
tlbl:.\J)~ \)'f)le ~h.lke m~n~J' ll>Cltfal~'l\,lti l~?~ t~<br />
lYffl Ih~ l]i) ~c 'f\:ll rfl:>~ rp!jlt l-Iil~ U"clhllt8 "Sf<br />
",It ~I~b Pkl.b 't'l! ~'ll ~,th. lhl> tj~ }6r.,~ !lt~<br />
~ ijlc ~~ plf\J.t ~U~ls U'1~Ti \}>P~lt,,~)1: ~1\Iffi:<br />
'~~ ~ij:Ti fi!tlt ll?M tl~.f\ll+.> ntkM: \}'lblil.le 'to:1l<br />
I-D'''~ lP7l1>~ lll!: ~~I~ l!:lJb\}> \J)~'1t} \I:l~l?1}rl @.!l\'~<br />
!lttol1-~ 1~11l wl}1l l!)I61~R '''~l'cl}fJ.t l!tR ~ ~,eh.<br />
'~~ ~\k'c ~~Sl lhftile!f:p.ln= ~lil: lP~ R~ ~h<br />
~l> lU 1~ \):llt 'lsL?Ut lltlls'~ l~~ 1~~<br />
I"Pl}\ 1:!1l:>bl1~9 111~bJ ~111! tp~~ ll\lI"U~1t!:<br />
'~f\~ \Pl~~l1: l~lJ.J~l'i U~h.llft 'Rl\tl~ ~lo f~c ~~<br />
lhl}llfe~~ \::kI: lh~ll~ @2t\1ln= ~1~ hl~ 'Pbl1~ Ic\:l<br />
~lk ~h.lkl: ~llt~ lltHP~~l.' I~RI1+> '~h.na: '~f\~<br />
~~ pll~ ~h.lla.! ~ ~ th lP1ke ,-ac\ U'l~ ~1\:s't»<br />
~h.5) \folh.lkl: 1ltlt~ 'lil: !Pla llJ1>tt \}>lla: lk"lP:ctl.~<br />
~,ch. '~lIllt lt~ lh~l!\'P§) ~~h:,P! lh\cP lQtt 1:!pt~lM:<br />
1l-~R1l> U-'W;I~\t Wk~ t ~\klc ~~§) ~h.llas<br />
h~~ lfclh.l~<br />
c. '@ t}fi f<ll?~ ~thl. lbl:>lQ).,<br />
,t,Dc\ lYl~~ \}-ll:>efi fvI~e ~le!~~ W'l{ \£~ t1fClh\}tlI-Dlb J ~~lt l}-l}-Qjl~fI:! lPk~<br />
i ~<br />
e lll: llt It! ·t lre ~ 1t<br />
l?-. ~.~ h.e~\ elf.lt1lle ~ ffi.t)11l 'dll'~tff '1l:-il}-ij •• 'ft. ~e -tPC'f\<br />
~~~tre~ttrtY·Qre ·~tre~!1
®piuign<br />
No. 4Z-Vo1. XXIII. Friday, October 16th, 1925.<br />
Register..! at tbe G. P.O. a •• N_per<br />
PIllCK rOUIt ••• '8<br />
INDIAN COUNCIL OF STATE<br />
DEBATE ON SOUTH AFRICAN INDIAN QUESTION<br />
DJ'fIIl~ following is a repOl't of the debate that took<br />
11 place last month i& the Council of Stat'3 of<br />
Injia in connection with the IndIan question<br />
in South Africa which we have extracted from the<br />
Till/OS of Indl/l'-<br />
Non-otIiC1
standing ord.ers and allowed Indians to prQceed to<br />
Soutli".Mrica assuring them full rights of citizenship.<br />
Indian labourers went out there as British citizens,<br />
but the provisions of the latest Bill on the anvil of<br />
the South African Parliament were really dangerous.<br />
They must be e~lllined, so that the rights and privileges<br />
of Indians wonld be protected. Mr. 8aBtri<br />
had on a former occasion said, "If Kenya is gone,<br />
India is gone." To thilj l\Ir. Karandikar added Ii if<br />
India is gone. the British Eropirp iit gone." India<br />
had every right to follow and help Indians whereever<br />
they were settled and the Indian Government<br />
were responsible in liafeguarding the rights and privileges<br />
of Indians.<br />
Sir UIIlal,' Haya.t Khan, in 5uppol'ting the \resolution<br />
a.a amended etnphasised that His Majesty's GoverI!Ulent<br />
had a duty in holding the scales even between<br />
the various parta of the Empire. If the Britiah.<br />
Government felt helplesi, then let the GovernmeI\.t<br />
of Iu
October 16~h, 1925 INDIAN OPINION·<br />
amended by Messrs. Karandikar and IWmdas Pantulu<br />
was carried without any dissentient vOIce.<br />
Notes and News<br />
~HOM a Reuter's me .. sage publitlhed in the daily<br />
ll---" papers it would appear that Mrs. SaroJini<br />
Naidu's appealld.ijt week to Indid to "bserve<br />
the 11th of October as a day tor expressing the national<br />
sentiment against the Asiatic Bill has been well responded<br />
to, large meetings being held on that day<br />
throughout India. Mrs. Naldu presided over the<br />
meeting at Bombay, at which a message from<br />
Mahatma Gandhi was I'ead emphasising that" there<br />
can be no compromise and no repatriation, even<br />
when it is euphemistically described as voluntary."<br />
The only effective remedy, in Mahatma Gandhi's<br />
opinion, iii the diplomlltlc pressure which Lord<br />
IIardinge had applied successfully. Our contemporary<br />
the Natal ALercUI!I describes this as "Gandpi's'<br />
new slogan."<br />
It is repol ted in the latest exchanges from India<br />
that Mrs. ~arojini Naldu has oLtained the highest<br />
number of votes I1S the preSident of the forthcoming<br />
Indian National Congress to be held at Cawnpore in<br />
December. It will be the first time in the history<br />
of the Congr(>s8 that an 1ndian lady will preSide<br />
over its annual deliberations. Indians in South<br />
Africa, we have no doubt, will join our brethren in<br />
India in congratulating Mrs. Naidu on her success.<br />
Bishop and Mrs Fisher have sailed yesterday from<br />
Deira per B.S. Karoa for Mombasa and Domb.lY.<br />
Bishop Fisher hopes to be preseut at the National<br />
Christian Council which meets in Calcutta on the<br />
4th of November. Doth Bishop and Mrs. Fisher<br />
wish to express their love to all the friends they<br />
have made in gouth Africa. While reciprocating the<br />
same to them we thank them for what they have<br />
done for us ~u wish them a pleasant voyage and<br />
safe r~ urn ,0 their home.<br />
In tho course of a comment on the action<br />
of the Union Government in introducing the Asiatic<br />
Bill, 1.Ju Mahralfa (Poona) writes :-" South Afric.l<br />
mU8t be given to understand that in wounding the<br />
feelings of India, the tiny. Colony is eliminating the<br />
sympathies of a great nation lIke India. "<br />
At a mass meeting of Indians of thl' Town and<br />
District of El'welo, held on the Gth instant under<br />
the chairmanship of Mr. I. A. Jassat a resolution<br />
protesting against tho AsiatIc BiU was passed unanimously<br />
and for\~ar\led to the Minister of the Intl.'rior.<br />
A farewell meeting attl'nded by prominent Indians<br />
was held under the Transvaal Memon Association<br />
ill honour of Mr. Hajee CW3Sim Adam at the<br />
Indian Library Hall, Pretoria, on the eve of his<br />
tll.'parture for Incha. Mr. A. C. Tayob presided.<br />
~\n address enumerating the various services rendered<br />
by him was preflented to Mr. C.lssim Adam<br />
and speeches were made by Messrs. Suleman Ebrahim,<br />
Abdul C:lrim, T. M. P. Mahomed and A. A.<br />
Mirza wishing Mr. Hajee Cassim Addm a pleasant<br />
voyage and a safe return. Mr. Hajee Cassim Adam<br />
in a suitable reply thanked the Association for the<br />
honour done to him and urged the gathering to<br />
support with all their heart the Transvaal British<br />
Indiun Association, the only representative body of<br />
the,TrilDsva.U Indians which was doing everything<br />
necessary to pl'otect the interest of the Indian commnnity.<br />
Mr. Cassim Adam donated £10 to the<br />
TralUl.Vaal Memon Association.<br />
The Transvaal British Indian AssociatioR haa sent<br />
the following cable to the Associated Press, Bom<br />
bay:-<br />
"Conformably to the pronouncement of Mrs. Sarojini<br />
Naidu, president South African Indian CtmgI"C88,<br />
Transvaal Indians have resolved to observe October<br />
11 as a day of pretest against Union Government's<br />
high·han.ted, ontrageous policy against Indian&"<br />
The hon. Secretary (Mr. P. R. Pather) informs us<br />
that the Pri.le Distributien of the Hindu Tamil<br />
Institute, 17 Cross Street, Durban, will be held at<br />
the RJ.wat's Bio Hall on Sunday the 18th instant at<br />
2 p.m. All are invited to attended. Apart from<br />
the traming given in this Institute to Tamil boys<br />
and l,:ir18 the Institute has been very Ulleful to the<br />
public for holding meetings and public functions.<br />
Many Congress Committee meetings have been<br />
held at this Institute by courtesy of the management.<br />
PLIGHT OF THE TRANSVAAL INDIANS<br />
\\1\VHIL~ the Indian popula~ion in Natal calJ be<br />
\'!\l said to be somewhat large-and that is owing<br />
to the large labour populatIOn-and the com.<br />
plamt of the Province being faced With an t\.~ia.t.ic qllestion<br />
might be justifiable, we cannot possibly understand<br />
the constant cry of the Transvaal being killed by Indians.<br />
The Indian populatIOn in that Province is bu~ a<br />
handful in comparison wlth the vast white population, the<br />
former Du'mberlng not more than fifteen thotlSand at the<br />
most agam8t five hundred thousand of the latter. Moreover<br />
they have no vote nor have they the nght to own<br />
landed property. The only right. they do possess is the<br />
right to trade. EmlgratlOn into that Province 1.8 entirely<br />
closed exceptlDg that @IX educated Indians may<br />
enter annually. Thus there is not the slightest fear of<br />
that Province ever being flooded by Indians nor are Indians<br />
given the least chance to do so. And yet the<br />
anti-Asiatic cry in the Transvaal is Just as acute if DoL<br />
more than in Natal.<br />
The Transvaal ProvlDcial Council bas recent,lJ paased<br />
the General Dealers ( Control) Ordinance, With the express<br />
purpose of curtailing the right of Indians to trade<br />
in that Province, which is the only means of their livelihood<br />
there. This Ordmance wai rushed throngb the<br />
CounCil without any opportumty given tc. those concerned<br />
to even consider it or to lodge tbClr protest<br />
against it; even the European Chamber of Commerce<br />
raised a protest against it on that ground, and the Governor-General-in-Council<br />
has been pleased La give 4is<br />
assent to it. Apart from this, we nndentand, that. although<br />
the Asiluc Blll hall Dot yet been passed some of<br />
its provisious are alreildy being enforced. Tho3C who<br />
have been given exemption certificates, we learn, are<br />
bemg re-examined by the Principal Immigra'ion Officer,<br />
and t.he three year clau~e is being in~rted in the<br />
Identity Certificates iliSued to those who go on a vLiit to<br />
Ind1a. The result of this w1ll be tba~ such Indians<br />
although holding their registration certificates will be<br />
deemed to be prohibited immigrants if they arrive here<br />
a little after the term of three years and they will have<br />
to prove their domicile before they can gt't the right to<br />
enter the Province--and yet, the l'ery officer examining<br />
them may have issued to them the certificate.<br />
What a farce I And all thiS for no other reason but to
make it as dlfficulL and as inconvenient as poselble for<br />
the Indian to enter and to live in the Union so that<br />
he may get thoroughly sick of It and choose to aba'ndoD<br />
it. Truly a British policy of the twentieth century!<br />
What does this attitude on the part of the authorities<br />
point out to? It points out only to ODe thing and that<br />
is the nec~ssity of immedIate action on the' part of the<br />
!ndians. At last t1}e date for the speCial sessIOn of the<br />
South AfrIcan Indian Congress has been fixed and that<br />
date will be anxiously awaited by every Indian, for that<br />
is when the hnal issue will be decided upon. Protests<br />
on paper have\apparently no effect on the Government.<br />
They presumaOly want It in concrete form and the community<br />
Will have to be prepared to embark upon It.<br />
A Message From Bishop Fisher<br />
Bishop Fisher writes to us as follows from<br />
Rhodesia :-<br />
I have been reluctant to make any public pronouncement<br />
concerning the IndIan Situation m the<br />
Union of South Africa. 'fhls hesitation arises from<br />
the fact that the raCIal divisions and preJudICes on<br />
the African continent are the most pronounced that<br />
I have ever encountered. It IS therefore, very easy<br />
to arouse animosities, no matter what one says.<br />
Every opportumty has been given me to study the<br />
conditions. I have visited Natal, the 'fransvaal, the<br />
Cape Province, and, in addition to these provmces<br />
withm the Umon, have VlSlt01l Rhodesia and<br />
Portugese East Africa. It has been my Pl'l vilege to -<br />
interview the Prime Minister, General Hel·tzog, and<br />
to call upon the Mimster of the Interior, Dr. 'Malan.<br />
Conversations have been held With the Mayors of<br />
cities, members of CIty councils, members of Parliament,<br />
business men, Ulliversity profes'lors; clergy- •<br />
men, representatives of trade UnIons, and other informed<br />
individuals. Pubhc meetings and conferences<br />
have been convened 10 centres such as Dllrban,<br />
Johannesburg, Pl'etoria, and Lourenco Marqnes.<br />
Mrs. Fisher and I have Visited 1U the homes of Europeans<br />
and Indians; have mspected comp~unds,<br />
barracks, shops, plantations, mills, mines and communities.<br />
We have attempted to secure frank d1Scussioo<br />
ana. smcere opinions from all mdlvldllals<br />
and groups, regardless of race. We have carefully<br />
stndied the literature upon the subject, inclndmg<br />
legislative enactments, history, resolutions of responsible<br />
bQdies and assoCiations, editOrIals, books<br />
and articles.<br />
From all that we have been able t.o learn, it iii<br />
evident that the problem is difficult anel that there<br />
is no app1.rent solution for the immedIate present.<br />
The proposed anti-Asiatic Bill is not a solutIOn, but<br />
an irritant. If adopted, it will accomphsh no purpose,<br />
other than to aggravate the Indian population<br />
through persecution, to deepen Its sense of martyrdom,<br />
and to raise up fI'lends for thE' Indian community<br />
throughout the world. I sincerely trust,<br />
therefore, that true statpsmanship will prevail, amI<br />
that the Union Parliament WIll re(,QgOlse the impracticability<br />
and llnwisdom of the present proposal.<br />
If I were a white CItizen of South Africa, I would<br />
regard the Bill as a direct attack upon the bE'st<br />
interests 'of the white community, even though<br />
directed against the Indian. The indirect harm to<br />
the white commumty would be far greater than the<br />
direct harm to the Indian. Measures of repression<br />
and programs of exterminatIOn have been prOVE'n<br />
by history to mean t.le decay of the virtues and<br />
powers of the pel'peb'ators rather than of the persecuted.<br />
GI'eece, Rome, Rllssia and many other<br />
examples may be Cited, both 1U the political and<br />
the economic world,<br />
.INDIAN OPINION October 16th, 1925<br />
The In~hons, through all time, have had gl"edt<br />
capacity for suffering, and I have tried to show my<br />
European friends, that tlll' Indians of 80uth Afllca<br />
are determined, in thiS reg,lr(], to live up to the<br />
highest tra(litlOlJs of theil' race. If a ero'>.'! is forced<br />
upon them, it Will be a cross ot Vil tory.<br />
Believmg that the problem will only be alceutuated<br />
by the present tendencleg, and that It IS one<br />
of superficial Importance, I am per8ua,letl that the<br />
only satisfactory a,iiustment Will bE' forme,l thlOll!.!"h<br />
a Round Table Conference, in which rcprl'3enlltivt,S<br />
of the Empire, India, the Govprnment of SOlllu<br />
AfrICa, and the Indian commul1Ily of SOl1th Afne,l.<br />
may hear and study all phases of the questIOn. In<br />
such a way, Borne amlCable agrE'ement m,IY htl<br />
arrlved at. If Buch a Conference 1>1 hel,I, the Indians<br />
of South Africa must h,wo ~~~)o->:~O<br />
1\1r. ShapurJI Sak1.1tvala, M P. for :N"orth U,ltterlleu,<br />
was to have been of the party of Bl'lllSh M.I'tl leavlUg<br />
England on Saturrby next to attend the lnter<br />
Parhamentary Union Conferences which art' to be<br />
held In the Umted States of America durlllg next<br />
month. \Vlthm the last week, some. members of<br />
the BritIsh Inter-Pahamentary Union, ot which .Mr.<br />
Saklatv.11a IS also a member, refused to go With tho<br />
party. Their objection was to Mr. Rtkll'~vala. lIe<br />
was a Commulllst and they (lItl not hold wI~h hiS<br />
views. Unhl to· day it appeared he would go. lIe<br />
had hiS Pas~port and h18 ul'rangemf'nts wcre lI1,IJe<br />
for the Visit. Thew was nothmg III thlcl country<br />
to prevent hiS gomg. And at thiS stage the Americat;!.<br />
Secretary of State steps m to cancel Mr. ::;aklatvala's<br />
passport The obJe~tors pleatled With themselves<br />
are gomg Mr. Saklatvala remalDf'!. Wbat he<br />
may yet do, IS not evident. For he has Just reSigned<br />
from the managership of the Cotton Mills Department<br />
of Messl·s. Tata Ltd. of New Bro III Street,<br />
London, the agents of Tal'! Power Co. which supplies<br />
in Bombay and dIstrICt electrical energy<br />
generated by water pOW0r-a concern WIth an<br />
authorised cap1tal of :t4,OOO,OOO. It woulll appear<br />
trom hiS letter of re!lumatio'1 that he is soliCitous of<br />
the weible of the hushes:! all'} reahsing hiS communistIC<br />
V\eWS may pOSSIbly affect the fin.lncial<br />
stabli1ty, he IE'signs. With Commulllsls anll all<br />
those who wonltl tlown c,lpit.11ism, It seems ever to ;<br />
be the same thJ.t whIle thE'Y all
October 16th, J9~5<br />
---<br />
~ig boats has. no doubt, discomagl"li many of the<br />
seamen, especially as in sOllle C,\!iE'S new men h:we<br />
been taken on on the boats that have B.llled, WIth the<br />
conj!l)qt1en~ displdcflltiC''1t of thOse men from those<br />
. boat" wllO 1l1'8 1m Iu'!{(e: "'he IllCl:d''',,1'8 0' .,,'ft 11'llJ1<br />
INDIAN OPINION<br />
Buckingham Palace, IIho Wnt'O a m1g1lific 'nt gown men's Societi('s in Englaud has somewhat weakened<br />
of 1>lu(' flilk, an,l a black veil COV(,/'i'l:,{ h('1' fM:e, with thl' pl)sitlOu of the Rtrikers. The major society is<br />
Hhts to look tbron~a, for Bhopl\ shll adhere£{ to the a!.!Iinst the strikf'o the minor society favours the unofficial<br />
strike. Unfortunately for the seamen, an<br />
cUHtom of PUI'IL.h. On h,,1' Ilea ll boats,<br />
Home, and had it not been for the uutiring efforts<br />
A-'r a short space of time rt'ttlsed to man the<br />
of a few persons. the unfortunates at present domiciled<br />
at the Home, would have beeu on the streets<br />
boat~,<br />
d\ut they too, like a number of others on ~he bi!-!ger<br />
lVoats havo gone back, and the channel boat sernces at the mercy of everyone.<br />
l',re again in full swing. The regul.lr sailllJg of the Any contributions for the Home can be called for<br />
on the recpipt of a note addl'pssed to the Secretary,<br />
BOlt 1770, Durban.<br />
S. L. SlXOIt.<br />
dObl SIIr.riltarr,
1}J,- 'HI} {:f H!}q 1~ lh1't~ UtJl1a: t'l'i~,~ ~ t 'ls!:l§i ~l§i~f\ 1Il~~ n~ tll!:~ t~ ~V1 ~U-llt.<br />
'~fm~ V1':1 Tht:~ ItL~ ~~ ~~ 'Ut t,e?t~ n·~ ~ I elHlllfl: (Ilt t\~liP ~~I~~ t'lt ~h.lkt l!:1~~ ~1~<br />
~lIc~ !ltlheli loll!.!) ~l~p.n .. ) 1)l':l en" e~ t1h\}d~!f ~l->1tl:: lJll->lIllt JltlP.1i~li (ffi't'e,lo lR" '1P<br />
'~~~lHi: .~ !l-,l't hm~.J n-.,}I f\ffi.'it j\1't 1~1ffi.lt. llt." lktl(fi "<br />
lltlbek) !h' ~h 1~U'1Jt l1Utli \}>~~!t U~~ lR,pm~ 'l1~ Thre~ ~ll[ file e~l1i ~~Ut tHi: eli:l1i h~l}tI<br />
l}-1{\J?1lt. ll-llt11-6~ ,H: ~ln-h (;! 1)l' b~ t~ 1~1w: "'l:JIt"R el>.rfl l::\.o.P~ t~ elli'eH:<br />
t!tI llt~\~ Pt:.\c 1\nlb 7L~< Ilctt,cleli\p lslb e ~l~J.o }.Ol& ltc ~ ~~tt Ptf~ l1:>eli ltll- '~hlHi: lltlt~ 11a: llt<br />
\no" .. n 'Ill el~''I;;e \1-io~}.O ,plhhlkt ?J.t) 1-1la:'1G • • •<br />
l!'~ !ltl->H;e~ '?\1< ~1t 6\'\. filfilt lfi~ llt\t~ lla: ~h.11ft ~tR~ t1ft ~Rk. I~l~<br />
'?f ftl~<br />
!ltln.lltc \}lffiliClffiii l::1t~ \}'&il~~ 1~t~ ~,t ~I~lt lfl!: ~\b--- ell-eli lt~~ ~'H: U~h.1ln:<br />
\})It~ '~l-ffi 1~m.l~ }'ol~~l\ lie!! lkVl:l1jl~ f1 l}>H:l< '~lfilt lPl~~ t~ !:::.\p'l-ffi }:'~h. ,..bGi .lc\h.l~<br />
ll::'ti~ l-11i th~R t'flll,.. \}>tii1tH: lPktJi ~U:P H-, iil'i \hl:\1t tkle ls!: .~ l~'~ 'l:::.le~ 11ft ~ ~ I~tl.! ~h: ~lt<br />
!"'R~I\ Utl1c1\a: ty,..IP.c3J..le~ ~lln- e'KWi t l-l~lt li~ ~h~ ~h.l~ .~ rlhlnl1c tRl):ll?:hlH: ~U~~<br />
fl t" k~11t theh ~lh7 If.i~~' ~~'k1: 1}6"'1\.lllt. 'th,.. lPlilt Rl't \}l1tilkt<br />
\Jelh: lP~ IP~ lhile l):1i ~lffi~ lR1Pln'l-t lc]jelll §l\! \}>ltlt ~ 'lR'" lP~le .f1li l):l~h: \}>ltlt ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~<br />
lhtfti1te ~ \. ~ 1:: l::lil: ~ hlils!: l:llt }'ol~f\ '?Jl- '~P ~ hIlt ~1): U~ ~fQ !P~f1 'J'" ~\fJ r 1lt1H: '~<br />
~li1'1: fltt ~h ~-~ ~1\(l: Iltl1:>~~ PIkl:tiiHt. !kl111l& ~P lM 'lt~~ ~)" ~l}tI li~ '~ ~1:> It~1I H:e'h.~ekt<br />
1i1):lt.~kt 1:::.~-"'l'~L~~U: { l}-lt1lltH: ~h R.lf lit . !ltl~f\llf) Utl{ ~ ~b .~Ii !ltlltt?~ !l-Wl~ lltkl{<br />
pw.\~ 1m:" t .~'ll fiol~)JI !kllttH: 1l-1Pl~ ~&i011Ie t \AIIl'i (;! '~lJli ,,..,)ttllt ~)~ (l>.rfl ~hlln: \}>lb~l~<br />
lk l l"lt 'l~' 1~'.l1ltc !ltlt>h:!l:> llU.H: lttiiltille llt}l~lt '~IIt"H: l::1f!: \}>lbh.lla: ~lt .. \o1: '\}>lhh.lkt PUle tftilk1la:<br />
!k~ 1:::.1«: .e~ .~\)? ~U-&il~~ lPk\FI l->1l"&lh~( Uc:lnl:> th.~i.H: ~ 'lJ:II M~.H: ll::li>ci ~,... F~<br />
~f\ffi.tt '~ th. k~llt lR~h elP IH7E thP-lo.'it 1k~1:> 1bl- UtJlt 1)illt ~)l\ (~F\ elk t~~ ~ R1~<br />
lt~ ~ 1~J)lb ell~" 'O:~ Ilsl71}t \ll~ 1Ql"&~ ~~} J~~li l~)~ !?I~ '1&l!3 'lbqR 'bl~ ~~~ 'hl~ ~~'l:R<br />
~Ut '\. \ 'IP RIc ~Itl~ Il-HP~1L' 11::]o;1}I.kt ~~I[ ~fQ FP>lt 'hl~ ~~l"& l~n ic1h j\.~ ~ l-lh1}te3 ~b<br />
l::lM-l'~l t11~~ 'tl~! ~1H: \}>l!blli ~fi\h.lltc tie!! \->le 'I!:ij:~ 1~~1[.H: ltifi. l::1a: ltlR::~ l&n. ~hlWl: ~b~<br />
\}t~t;o !l-"sEt!J ~\llnU~\t! 1l-(II[(\o1: loblY'fl ~iRn. \}>Wi ltn. lie!! .~~~ ~h pl- 1t e,-?b J.\p.H: Wfl:) rl~~l.~<br />
'lt~ \}J1t~ kI.'filt 1l-H:1< l-ktl-:jR H~11fl: ttg;lR ~l}t \ n 'l\.l ~lptPe I:::.If!: U/llb!J ~Ut 6\), .~ clh\}>lt<br />
li1lbJ !klJ~J 'P~1t'fl: "SobJ ~l}Q ~H)aft ~,\C<br />
~<br />
e Tn: llt. ~ ·t lo! l11!'<br />
e?- i.1« h.~~\ ~)at?:lffi: ~"6 k\t}t'P 'e'b.~ ''fl:~u-ij ·.ft ~e ~'P~"<br />
.V;~~f!l(~~ ~~k'e~
~ niian ~piuilllt<br />
No. 4J-Vol. XXIII. Friday, O~tober 23rd, 1925.<br />
Re,illered at the G. P.o. as a Nc ... papar<br />
P.'c. 'ouaPE", •<br />
.-' IS RACE HATRED ESSENTIAL FOR NATIONALISM?<br />
MR. GANDHI'S ADDRESS IN CALCUTTA<br />
l\ViT R. M. K. Gandhi delivered an address on<br />
11. V 11 the subject • Is Race Hatred Essential for<br />
Nationalism ?' at a meeting held under the<br />
allspices of the Meccano Club at the Y.M.C.A. Overtoun<br />
Hall. We reproduce below an extract of Mr.<br />
Gandhi's addre88 from Young Ind/,(], which we have<br />
no doubt ",ill be read with very great interest in<br />
this country :-<br />
• Is it possible to love one's country and vot to<br />
hate those who rule over it, whose domination we<br />
do not want and dislike from the bottom of our<br />
hearts?' was the problem, said Mr. Gandhi with<br />
which the younger geueration wal!l faced to-day.<br />
And the answer given by many, expressed in some<br />
('ases and secretly nourished in most, was that it was<br />
impossible. As a student of the qnestion for over<br />
30 years, the speaker was there to declare his conviction<br />
that nationalism was perfectly consistent<br />
with the love of those whose ruli we did not like.<br />
The disabilities with which he had been face to face<br />
all these years in South Africa and India were really<br />
enough to make ono hate his fellow-beings if he did<br />
not preserve his sanity. • Correctly or incorl'ectly<br />
one feels he is subjected to the grossest tyrannies,<br />
for no reason but that he is not the same colour as<br />
the rulers. How is he then to love those rulera?'<br />
was the question. Love being a positive force may<br />
be considered out of the question-how could he<br />
help hating the tyrant? Illustrations were taken<br />
from recent wars and administration of law in<br />
civilised societies to prove that hl\lred seemed to be<br />
of the essence of nationalism. Nevertheless it was<br />
the grossest of delusions. .. So long as a large body<br />
of men and women retain that attitllde, the progress<br />
of this country, the progress of the world is retarded.<br />
The world is weary of hate. We see the<br />
fatigue overcoming the Western nations. We see<br />
that this song of hate has not benefitted hum1.nity.<br />
Let it be the privilege of India to turn a new leaf<br />
and set a lesson to the world. Is it necessary that<br />
three hundred millions of people should hate one<br />
hundred thousand Englishmen? That is the concrete<br />
form to which this evening's subject can be<br />
reduced. In my humble opinion it is derogatory<br />
to the dignity of mankind, it is derogatory to the<br />
dignity of India to entertain for one single moment<br />
hatred towards Englishmen." But it were wUnigh<br />
impossible for masiles of humanity to erat.licate<br />
hatred. Transfer then your hatred, said the spedker,<br />
from the evil-doer to the evil itself. Hate the evil,<br />
but not the evil-doer, was the maxim he would offer<br />
them. And in a few sentences burning with noble<br />
fervour he declared his creed: .. Heaven~knowil, no<br />
one in India, perhaps, can claim better than myself<br />
to have spoken as fiercely and as fearlessly of the<br />
many misdeeds of EnglIsh rulers and the corrupt<br />
nature of the system under which we are governeu.<br />
My freedom from hatred,-I wonld even go so tu<br />
as to claim for myself individually, my love-of<br />
those who consider themselves to be my enemies<br />
does not make me blind to their faults. That is no<br />
love which is extended simply bt'cause of the<br />
poss~ion of some virtues fancied or real in the<br />
beloved. 'u I am. true to myself, if I run true to<br />
mankind, if I am true to humanity, I must understand<br />
all the faults that humlJ,n flesh is heir to. I<br />
must nnderstand the weaknesses of my opponents,<br />
their vices, and yet inspite of them, not hate but<br />
even love them ...... I have not hesitated to call the<br />
system of Government under which we are labouring<br />
"S1.tanic," anu I withdraw naught out of it. But I<br />
know that I shall not deal with it, if I begin to<br />
devise means of punishing the evil-doer. I\fY: business<br />
is to love them and by patient and ·gentle<br />
han~ling to convert them. Non-co-opention is not<br />
a hymn of hate. I know that many who call themselves<br />
8atyagrahis or Non-co-opel'llotors do not deserve<br />
to bear that name. They have done violenoo to their<br />
own cre~d. Real non-eo-operation is non-co-operation<br />
\vith evil and not with the evil-doer." That<br />
was, however, not tht' place to go into the intricacy<br />
of that doctrine. It was a law that was applied in<br />
all well-organised families and he appealed to them<br />
to extend that law in the politic~l field. A father or<br />
a son did neither seek to punish or eucourage a son<br />
or father inclined to do evil, but tried to correct<br />
him. Of I.lourse there were father!! and sons who<br />
under a false sense of love doted ou the erring sons<br />
or fathers. But he was talking of the • love that<br />
discriminates, love that was intelligent, love which<br />
was not blind to a single fault-the love of the refOI<br />
mer.' The moment we realised the secret, that<br />
very moment evil would go out of sight.<br />
And he instanced cases in which the reformer's<br />
lova couM play and had played an effective part. It<br />
could be appli€d as between members of tha same<br />
community, not to speak of different races. There<br />
were Hinuu8 who conSidered untouchability as part<br />
anu parcel of Hinduisw, and quoteu scriptures as<br />
authority. Were the more enhghtened Hindus to<br />
hate or cut pff the heaJs of those unenlighteneti<br />
ones? No. The secret was persistent non-violeut<br />
conduct-or, b
iNDIAN OPiNION October 23rd, 1925<br />
thlJ wbole of th." co11.ntry wa, ·die, BO that the<br />
human raoes lJlat live. Th6re il no room tor race<br />
hatred thlJl'e. Let that be Ollr natiOrutlislll. "<br />
A question from Mr.Ohapman, the Labrarian of<br />
the Imperial Library, at the conclusion of the speech,<br />
drew a telling reply from Gandhiji. "Was not the<br />
insistence on political freedom and political equalIty<br />
on-the part o~ Indians. conducive to 1'0.00 hatred,<br />
when Indians themselves were not capable of rulmg<br />
themselves" was in effect Mr. Chapmau's question.<br />
" If YOll lulve drawn th
October 23rd, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 275<br />
Concerning Freedom<br />
(By I,. W. n.)<br />
'11 lIE W,ly to hberatlon is the &lme for a people as<br />
1 an inllivlIlllul. Hlnce bond.age iii the reHult of<br />
Ignl)r.1llcC'-nf IUI.,takf)n IhoughL'I, uesires anu<br />
actlOnl:l the only IMth to freedom is the dispersal of<br />
i"n'/~:ince by the lIght of true knowleuge and by<br />
('ow!ucl th'lt id wise in!ltead of fooJj"h. A man may<br />
/,,, phYHlc.111y a cIMltcl-sl.1ve yet freer far spiritually<br />
t!UIl his owner. The IIldve ownel· may be free of<br />
lI.lovC'mf'nt phYHic.llly, yet bpiritually more a bondsman<br />
tb.1n his IlI.1ve. The d..trkest IgnOl-ance is perh.lpo<br />
the iI.:nor.1nce that reslllto III wrong discriminatIOn<br />
For inRt.lI1ce, thtl appetite for worldly power and<br />
dliDlIlwtlO1l hail tilled the pages of history with record<br />
of the tltl'llggles of tl"lbes aUlI nallons. Yet we see<br />
th,lt even wh(·n utLlined the pos.-;essions so haruly<br />
won have prov('(l to Le impermanent. The unreal<br />
wit;takC'n for the real, the Hhadow mllitaken for the<br />
Eluurltance, gors the WolY of all thmgs perishable.<br />
Forces misdirected through wrong discrimination<br />
producc the results sought, the fruits, however,<br />
commence til rot almost before they are gathered<br />
lind the IUovltable reactIOn upon their source of the<br />
forel'!> ~ellel'Uted and expl'el:lileu hind the peoples<br />
from winch they emanate and the oppressor becomes<br />
tho oppr!'8~ed and learns wisuom.<br />
The temptdtion to focus human energies so liS to<br />
achieve results that are toluglble aod ljI)Dcrete by<br />
tangIble means, by the flmployment of physical force<br />
that is, IS, IUstmctIve and difficult to resist.<br />
The fruits th,lt are tangible and concrete do seem<br />
to be HO substantial, so rpal; physical force ,methoUs<br />
do serm to produce manifest results, so that to ab,mdon<br />
both for the spmtual calls for the presence and<br />
O'(l'l·ciile of a hIgh dl'grt'e of dlScl'uuinatlOll born of<br />
1~"'Bimildtod knowledge that is sometimes called Faith.<br />
Yet it ill Just towards this that human experience<br />
tends; to learn thIS 10:lsou and assimilate the wisdom<br />
80 acquireu that hves are lived-the lives of units<br />
called men and of larger UUlls called peoples.. This<br />
I believe, to be the moral that Mahatma Gandhi is<br />
trying so patiently, by example as well as by<br />
precept, to brmg home to the people of India. His<br />
succoss may mean the world's redemption; it Will<br />
certainly mean India's spiritual supremacy and<br />
leadershIp in things that alone matter'<br />
Indian Press On South African<br />
IndJan Question<br />
The l/mdu (Madras) in the course of a leading<br />
article on .. The New Menace in South Africa"<br />
crlticisos the Union Government's Asiatic policy as<br />
follows :-<br />
.. A man meets his enemy, gives him a severe slap<br />
on his f.1('e and coolly tells him that he iii pl·ep.lred<br />
for a compromisE>. General Hertzog's Government<br />
introlillces l\ most provocative and reactionary measure<br />
~ order to render the hfe of the Indian more<br />
Dlis~'rable than It is and tells this country through<br />
the Mmister of the InterIor that the door is still<br />
open for negotiatIon. If the Union Government<br />
pld.ces this outr,lgeous Bill on the Statute Book, it<br />
means war, Dot negotiation. It is now clear why<br />
the South Afrlcan Government has been delaying to<br />
reply to the suggestion of the Government of India.<br />
,'cg,lf(ling a RonIll! Table Conference. Dr. Malan<br />
hols been preparing a med.snre which, accOt·ding to<br />
hiS conception, should be the bst word in the science<br />
of extermination by starva~on. Before he entered<br />
into a talk with India.. he desired to tighten the.<br />
screw on the Indian to such an exten' as to impart<br />
an appearance of moderation to the decision arrived<br />
at after negotiation. Indians have now, say, sixty<br />
grievances in South Africa, and want some settlement<br />
of the points at issue which would reduce this<br />
number. Dr. ~Ialan is, however, an adept in the<br />
political game anu he is now consciously Increasing<br />
this number to ninety-nine, so that ultimately, after<br />
compromise, the number may be reduced from<br />
nmety-nine to, say, eighty. While the net result,<br />
when compared With the existing situation would<br />
be intolerably bad, the Union Government would be<br />
able to tell the world that they were reasonable and<br />
wanted to redress the just grievances of Indians and<br />
that they were astonished at their own moderation. OJ<br />
In the end onr contemporary asks :-<br />
.. In the face of this relentless policy, wIll the<br />
Government of India tell the public what steps<br />
they propose to take to defend the helpless commumty<br />
which is threatened by slow but sure<br />
death? It appears to us that after this gesture on<br />
Gen. Hertzog's part, there could be no more talk of<br />
a Round Table Conference from this side. That<br />
stage, if it ever existed, has long ago gone Pait by.<br />
N either is there any further room for representa.<br />
tions and protests. If the Government in India represented<br />
the people in a real sense, South Africa<br />
would not have dared to behave in the fashion it<br />
has been doing. The Union Government know that<br />
Indians are helpless, that the Reciprocity Act is<br />
lying idle, that India is not even bold to levy a<br />
countervailing duty on Natal coal. They realise<br />
that while Great Britain would not interfere in the<br />
affairs of a self-governing Dominion, she dare not<br />
countenance any retaliatory measures in India in<br />
view of the complications which would result in<br />
South Africa. India is thus between the devil and<br />
the deep sea, owing to the studied indifference of<br />
the Government which is alien. It is not surprising<br />
III the circumstances, that tltere is a movement in<br />
South Africa to revive the passive resistance<br />
struggle. Lord Hardinge sympathised with it; will<br />
Lord Reading follow that noble example? ..<br />
Mombasa Indian Association<br />
Supports South Africa<br />
The hon. Secretary of the Indian National Association,<br />
Mombasa, communicates to us the follow<br />
ing:-<br />
A mass mef-ting of the Indians of Mombasa and<br />
Kllindini was held to-day under the aUlipices of the<br />
Indian National Association to protest strongly<br />
against the .. Areas Reservation and Immigration and<br />
Registration (Further Provision) Bill" that is<br />
going to be brought for the second reading in the<br />
South African Union Parhament. Mr. R. M. Shah<br />
explained the purport of the Bill reading a telegram<br />
sent by the President of the Natal Indian Congress<br />
to India. He explained how fat the Bill affected<br />
the position of the Indians there, and showed in<br />
conclusion how the bill was directed towards the<br />
total expulsion of tha Indii\n community from the<br />
South African territories.<br />
The (oUowing resolution was then moved by Mr.<br />
D. B. Desai and seconded by Mr. M. A. Parakh and<br />
passed unanimously :-<br />
.. !'his mass meetmg of the Indians of Mombftsa<br />
and Kilindini heJJ, under the auspices of the Indian<br />
National Association strongly protests against the<br />
Areas Reservation and ImmigratIOn and Registration<br />
( Further Provision) Bill now before the South<br />
African Union Parliament and further urge thy Inilian<br />
as well as the Imperial Governments to use<br />
their utmost influence in preventing that Bill from<br />
being passed ...
INDIAN OPINION October 23rd. 1925<br />
The Marks Of Christianity<br />
Bishop Fisher's Sermon<br />
Contmued from page 265<br />
We Christians do not beheve in marks. In many<br />
ways·we do not believe m divIsions. We object to<br />
have ourselves marked in any way, then we must<br />
have QUI' dIstinctIOns in spll'it and in our hves. You<br />
and I must have the mark m our spirit. Jesus said<br />
'Behold my hands' and Paul saId 'I bear in me the<br />
marks of the Lord .Jesus.' What are the marks of<br />
the Lord Jesus? So far as I can see there were<br />
three, th~ spear-pomt in the sIde, thrust by a soldIer<br />
near ~he aeart to, SEle whether the blood as it ~shed<br />
fortb, would be blood and water, signifying' death.<br />
He had a second mark of naIl prirlts in hIS hands<br />
and feet, the prmts of the Cross, and in the third<br />
place the'marks of the thorn wounds on His brow.<br />
Just three distinguishing marks upon the bod}' of<br />
Jesus, and after His resurrectlOn everyone knew<br />
him by those marks. It is the most effectIve preach<br />
,ing in the world; It is the only preaching in the<br />
world. I mIght preach to you from the PUlPIt bht<br />
if on Monday I did not bear about me the marks of<br />
the Lord, all my ideals are naught If I do not believe<br />
and live in them. My preaching would be a<br />
mockery. DId I hear a sword print in the side?<br />
It signifies sympathy. We say our sympathIes are<br />
from the heart, then this spear-prmt beSIde the<br />
heart of Jesus causes sympathy to gush forth, love<br />
and understanding to gush forth. Sometimes I<br />
think we are all too unconscious of the need the<br />
world has for sympathy. We are all busy preparing<br />
houses for ourselves and we are all busy preparing<br />
economic conditions to be of advantage to<br />
ourselves, we are all busy thmking of our own<br />
familIes. We are busy thinkmg ot ourselves. We<br />
want to see to-day that we live well. We want to<br />
see that certain opportunities come to us. We are<br />
not anxious to die. Weare not anxlOUS to have<br />
some man nail us to the Cross and say 'there goes -a<br />
self-de~yi~g Christian, that man has nothmg, behold<br />
hIm. As a matter of fact we shrink from that<br />
type. We would rather have a mall of whom It is<br />
said 'that is hIS house and his possessions' Weare<br />
eager to acqUIre, but we are not so eager to serve or<br />
die. Sometimes I think we are not conscious of the<br />
sufferings of the world. Sometimes we are not<br />
'Conscious of the slums of the world. We are not<br />
conscious of the struggles of the world. We do not<br />
see. We are eager to live our own hves and to forg.et<br />
the need of sympathy and sometImes the worse<br />
the condItion IS, the mOre it dl'lves us away from It.<br />
We must feel with Florence Nlghtmgale, who,<br />
when she looked upon a wound, bound it up. That<br />
is the spirit we must foster. Our sympathIes are<br />
not enough even if We have the sympathy I think<br />
we have. Sometimes it IS becanse we do' not have<br />
the knowledge of the world's suffermg, bnt even if<br />
we have, we do not have the sympathy for it. We<br />
have to have the nail-prints m the hands that serve<br />
and work, the print in the feet to bring rehef to<br />
bring all sorts of kindliness to bear upon the o~en<br />
wounds of the world. We shall never be satIsfied<br />
with sympathy alone. We shall have to hd.ve not<br />
only the mark in the side but the naIl-print in the<br />
hands and feet., and we shall have to have these<br />
thol'U-prints in our brow. I should say the thornprint<br />
in the brow would typIfy faIth. Faith is the<br />
instinct of victory. Sometimes if· we look at our<br />
problems we look pl'ssimistically. We do not have<br />
that Christian attitude that leads us to beheve that<br />
Jesus Christ is able to win the VICtories if we will<br />
but trmt and follow the msiinct of faith,. Let problems<br />
come and solve them in the ChristIan way<br />
Have thl' difficulties, but have that attitude of hf~<br />
that will make victory pOSSIble m spite of it all.<br />
The spear-prints in the 8i(le tYPlty sympathy for<br />
the ?eer1s of man. The nall-prj,lts in the han,l-.<br />
serVIce fonowing Rympathy, the thorn-prints on the<br />
brow, faIth, faith in the destlnr of m,ln, faith In the<br />
outoome of the world. faIth in the redemption of<br />
promIses through Goil, pll1ngmg into it not in the<br />
~pirit of f,ltlhsm. but of dynaln{c Chrl
~' .<br />
'~ndtan<br />
~ + •<br />
~ptntott<br />
,.<br />
---------------------------------------------------------------------------<br />
No. 44-Vo1. XXIII. Friday, October 30th, 1925.<br />
Registered al the G. P.O. as a N.wspapor<br />
PRica 'ou •••• ,.<br />
THE SOUTH, AFRICAN INDIAN QUESTION<br />
BY MR. C. F. ANDREWS IN 'YOUNG INDIA'<br />
TO-DAY, the people of India are .faced with a<br />
II crisis in South Africa which is far more<br />
serious than anything that has happened lIince<br />
the year 1913. when Mahatma Gandhi led the<br />
passive resistance campaign in Natal in order to<br />
obtain justice for the Indian cause. The en
~78 __________________ IN __ O_IA_N-.O __ PI_N_I_O_N<br />
________ O_c_t_ob_e_~~3_Ot_h,~19~2~5_<br />
ployment of tile terms of this Agreement upon<br />
white South Africa itself.<br />
Thirdly, public opinion must be vocal in every<br />
province on the subject. There must be no compromise<br />
and no weakness.<br />
The Government of India,<br />
which has to act at the present juncture, must<br />
be assured in any action It takes by the certainty<br />
that public opinion in India is quite undivided on<br />
the issue.<br />
Notes and News<br />
1\\ T the Synod of the Anglican Church in the·<br />
ru Cathedral, Pretoria, Deacon Amos Mphahl~le<br />
is reported to have moved that the Synod<br />
respectfully urge upon the Government the necessity<br />
of frammg legislation which should uphold the racial<br />
purlty of the white and Bantu peoples, by prescribmg<br />
that the cohabitation ofa white man and natIve woo<br />
man be a criminal offence, as was that of a native man<br />
and a white woman. The resolutlOn was unanimously<br />
adopted. "It was a tragic fact.," the speaker<br />
urgea, "that native girls weIe proud of white husbands.<br />
I appeal to you as the superior race to<br />
protect the weaker people," he added. Mr. E. J.<br />
Kerswill said it waf> the duty of the superior race to<br />
set an example to the weaker in fall" dealing. Pumshment<br />
for assault in the case of the white offender<br />
was comparatlvely light. The native offender was<br />
hanged in most cases. Marriage between black aud<br />
white was an offence agamst the law of God, said<br />
Bishop Carey, of Bloemfontein. The Bishop of<br />
Pretoria announced the resolution would be forwarded<br />
to the Prime Minister.<br />
The above resolution is a very important one but<br />
what effect it will have is a question. To believe<br />
that the evils that existed under Smuts Government<br />
will be removed by the present Government in so<br />
far as Natives -and Indians are concerned is, we<br />
think, hopeless. There is adequate provision in the<br />
law for white men to be dealt with for crimes committed<br />
against black women and we know that they<br />
have been severely dealt with when they have<br />
managed to reach the Supreme Court by judges like<br />
Mr. Justice Krauze:- But the fact is that a very few<br />
lIuch cases do manage to reach the Supreme Court.<br />
The average white man in this country trades on his<br />
skin and the word of the white man against the<br />
black almost in every instance succeeds whereas the<br />
black man's word against the white man invariably<br />
fails and what ghost of a chance can there be for it<br />
to succeed when a white woman is concerned?<br />
In the circumstances the vast coloured population<br />
we see in this country is the result of the union<br />
between the white man and black woman and, a<br />
very few mstances do 'we see where the result has<br />
been through the union of a black man and a whIte<br />
woman. This fact goes to prove that the crimes of<br />
the white men against the black women are not<br />
considered as crimes but as their inherent. right to<br />
satisfy their passion.<br />
~' ,<br />
At a meeting of the Transvaal amber of Commerce<br />
held recently in Johannesbt g the following<br />
resolutions were adopted m cor. ection with the<br />
recently passed General Dealers C ~rol Ordinance.-<br />
(1) This meeting protests agams Clause 3 of the<br />
General Dealers' (Control) Ordman'!F which Imposes<br />
on general dealers in municipalitie~ the obligation<br />
of applying to a Town CouncIl to make provlsion<br />
for the constitution of a special board for this<br />
purpose on the same lines as for rural areas.<br />
(2) This meeting is also of opinion: that Clause 13<br />
may operate harshly and should be d'eleted.<br />
(3) this Chamber urges that amendmg legislation<br />
to give effect to the above, should be passed by the<br />
Provincial Council at the Epecial sefJsion convened<br />
for next week.<br />
The following appears in the Rrmd Dm1!J jJ[all ._<br />
At a meeting of Johannesburg Indians held on the<br />
premises of Mr. 1\1. S. Coovafha on Tnesday night,<br />
under the chairmanship of Mr. Essop ISID,tll Mia,<br />
it was resolved by a majority to estabhsh a new<br />
IndIan political organisation under the name of the<br />
Transvaal Indian Congress. After the resolution<br />
was passed, the following officers were elected:<br />
Mr. Essop IfJmail Mia, president; Mr. .Jussab<br />
Ebrahim, vice-president; Mr. M. S. Coovadia,<br />
treasurer, Mr. N. A. Camay, secretary; and at the<br />
terminatlOn of the electIOn, Mr. Essop Ismail l\Iia<br />
gave the sum of £50, which was received" ith cheers.<br />
[NoTE.-We deal with the above in our leading<br />
article.-Ed. 1.0.]<br />
The following are some questions drawn up by a<br />
sub-committee appointed by the Johannesburg<br />
Southern Suburbs European AssociatIOn at a meeting<br />
last week whIch will be circulated among the<br />
candirlates for the forthcoming municipal elections:<br />
1. Do you realise the evil arising from the<br />
invasion of the Asi:ttic trader in whlte residential<br />
areas?<br />
2. Are you in favour of the Areas Reservation<br />
and ImmigratIon and Registration Bill as drafted<br />
by the Mimster of the Interior?<br />
3. If so, would you support any application<br />
made to the Town Council to bring it into<br />
operation?<br />
4. Will you deal with this questIOn from your<br />
election platform so that the electors in your ward<br />
will know your views?<br />
5. If returned will you urge the Town Council<br />
the necessity of supporting the Government in<br />
this matter ?<br />
The Union Parliament has been prorogued to<br />
January 22.<br />
Mr. V. S. Pather Ot. hon. Secretary of the South<br />
African Indian Congress) has left for the Cape by<br />
the Union Express last Wednesday to make the prelimmary<br />
arrar.gements for the forthcoming Congress.<br />
South African Indian<br />
Congress<br />
The Fifth Session of the South African<br />
Indian Congress (in Conference) will be<br />
held in Capetown on the 10th November,<br />
1925 and the following days.<br />
Business :-<br />
1. Report and Financial StatemenL<br />
2. Deputation to Union Government<br />
re Asiatic Bill.<br />
3. Deputation to India.<br />
4. Election of Officials.<br />
5. General.<br />
A. H. GOOL,<br />
Deputy President.<br />
A. ISMAIL,<br />
Hon. General Secretary.<br />
Head bffice :<br />
28 Ayre Street,<br />
Cape Town.<br />
S. A. I. C.
October 30th, 1925<br />
'NOlAN OPINION<br />
A WORD TO OUH COUNTRTIIEN<br />
HEIlE should hardl,9 be a single Indian in the<br />
1f Union who is not aware of or concerned<br />
about the danger we are faced with as a<br />
consequence of the anti-Indian legislation already<br />
passed and proposed to be passed by the Union.<br />
Government. Under the circumstances every Indian<br />
should also know that to save ourselves from<br />
the impending ruination the only remedy is to act<br />
unitedly with one voice. We are grieved to find,<br />
instead, tll.lt some of our &>untrymen are trying to<br />
bring about divisions in the community the purpose<br />
of which must be known best to themselves. Their<br />
line of action is not different. They are out to fight<br />
against the same laws nnd on the Bame grounds as<br />
the existing representative bodil'ls. At least that is<br />
what they profess to do. But to do this instead of<br />
joining with the already existing constitutional<br />
body they have chosen to have their own bodiea to<br />
conduct the work on their own. Such a body ~lists<br />
in Durban known as the ,Natal Indian Association.<br />
It is not a constitutional body nor do we<br />
know that it represents any more than its own<br />
offiClals and perhaps a few others. Molvi Abdul<br />
Care em and Mr. E. M. Paruk are, we understand,<br />
fathering this little body. We have respect for both<br />
thel!le gentlemen in their individual capacity but we<br />
cannot congratulate them for their latest action. The<br />
only grievance that has prompted them to form this<br />
body, in so far as we have been able to judge, is<br />
that they are not able to command the confiwmce of<br />
the people. If that be so they are rendering their<br />
position in that regard all the worse. If anything<br />
is more disappointing about the so-called Natal Indian<br />
Association it is only the connection with it of<br />
Mr. E. M. Paruk. Mr. Pcl.l'uk holds a high position<br />
among the commercial class in Durban and we<br />
should have thought he would know better his responsibilities<br />
to hiS people. In so far as others cannectpd<br />
with that body are concerned, most of them<br />
are irresponsible. For pecuDiary motives or what<br />
we do not know but. they have-even during the<br />
time when Mr. M. K. Gandhi led thEl passive lesistance<br />
campaign-rendered but little service in the<br />
cause of their brethren. They only indulged in<br />
hindering the cause, and nothing more can be expected<br />
of them now. They will have to be faced<br />
and put up with by the community but not led by<br />
them. The commuDlty can be led only by the<br />
Natal Indian Congress whose services are wellknown<br />
to be reiterated here.<br />
We had thought up till now that Durban was<br />
the only unfortunate town where there was a body<br />
existing with the express motive of hindering the<br />
'good work done in the interest of the community.<br />
We now find, however, that such a body has been<br />
formed in the Transvaal too. The name of thIS<br />
body is .. Transvaal Indian Congress." With the<br />
exception of Mr. N. A. Camay who.is appointed the<br />
secretary the rest of the offiClals have been tested in<br />
communal affairs and found wanting. The president<br />
Mr. Mia who is a very fine gentleman ID his<br />
individual capacity has demonstrated but little patriotism<br />
during the passive resi:;tance campdign in<br />
the Transvaal in 1908 and all the other gentlemen<br />
were tested when they held for &. short time the<br />
reins of the British Indian Association, the only<br />
official representative body in the Transvaal. They<br />
were found wanting and the community had<br />
apparently lost confidence in them because they<br />
were boon replaced by others. This is probably the<br />
grIevance that has prompted them to form another<br />
politICal body. The action of none amazes us so much<br />
as does Mr. Camay's in this new body. Mr. Camay's<br />
sacrifice for his country's cause has been great.<br />
DUflng the passive resistance campaign under the<br />
leaderllhip of Mr. Gandhi Mr. Camay was holding<br />
the position of a postDl
INDiAN OPINION October 30th, 1925<br />
that will appoint them is representative.<br />
Let us not forget that our actions<br />
are being watched very carefully by<br />
our enemies and the slightest faltering on<br />
our part may impair our cause. Petty prejudices<br />
_if their be any should for once be<br />
put aside so that we may be able to show to<br />
the Union Government, to India and to the<br />
world that we are in earnest and that we are<br />
not going to anow our legitimate rights in<br />
this land ~f our birth and domicile to be<br />
trampled under foot without a murmur. May<br />
the Almighty guide the deleberations of our<br />
Congress and make it a success and may<br />
He guide us all in doing the right thing.<br />
Mts. -Sarojini Naidu Interviewed<br />
By Associated Press Of India<br />
S. A. Indian Congress The Only<br />
Representative Body<br />
In view of the widespread interest and<br />
agitation in India in regard to the anti-Asiatic<br />
legislation and in view of the possibility<br />
of various deputations from South Africa<br />
going to India to place their grievances<br />
before the Government and the public, Mrs.<br />
Sarojini Naidu, interviewed by the Associated<br />
Press in her official capacity as President<br />
of the South African Indian Congress<br />
stated as requested by the Indians of<br />
South Africa that she wished to make it<br />
very clear that the only organisation com·<br />
petent to represent the Indian community<br />
in South Africa was the South African Indian<br />
Congress to which are affiliated the<br />
Natal Indian Congress, the Transvaal British<br />
Indian Association and the Cape British<br />
Indian Council as representing the n:spective<br />
provinces and which are recognised by<br />
the South African Union Government as<br />
authorised to spea.k in the name of the Indian<br />
community. Other associations like<br />
the Natal Indian Association, for instance,<br />
are not affiliated to the South African Indian<br />
Congress and tepresent mainly only<br />
small groups of trading interests unconnected<br />
with the general welfare of a larger<br />
community.<br />
Referring to the anti-Asiatic legislation,<br />
Mrs. N aidu remarked, it is one of the iniquitous<br />
and barbarous acts of legislation<br />
which surely the clvilised world. can never<br />
tolerate. India will never countenance the<br />
repatriation of the Indian community under<br />
any pretext or disguise. Indian settlers are<br />
colonials with as much right to live on the<br />
soil of South Africa as the English, the<br />
Boer, the Huguenot and the Jewish colonials.<br />
Especially in Natal the Indians have<br />
built up the prosperity of the country by<br />
their very life blood and neither the arrogance<br />
'or colour prejudice nor the brutality<br />
of sheer physical strength can entitle one<br />
set of colonials to disinherit and exile an<br />
Qther set of colonials from the land that has<br />
been to them not only a fostermother<br />
but the mother itself. As she {Mrs. Naidu}<br />
had reminded the Minister of the Union<br />
Government while she was in South Africa,<br />
India is no longer the India of the folded<br />
hands and appealing eyes and now the<br />
whole strength of India will be mobilised in<br />
support and defence of the children overseas<br />
whose very existence will be menaced<br />
and whose human rights are down-trodden<br />
by the dual forces of unreasoning colour<br />
hatred and the bitter jealousy of economic<br />
cOl1]petition. The campaign of protest against<br />
the anti-Asiatic legislation will be formally<br />
inaugurated on the t I th of October when<br />
from every village and town of the great<br />
continent of India prayers will be offered<br />
for the stricken and disfranchised Indian<br />
citizens of South Africa.<br />
The Sense of Proportion<br />
• (By L. W. R.)<br />
That the Greater includes the Less, and consequently<br />
is the important is too obvious for argument.<br />
Yet in practice precedence is all too frequently given<br />
to the latter-the birth-right sold for a mess of<br />
pottage. Man's mind is like a mirror; it gathers<br />
dust while it refl6cts, and reflections are not the<br />
truer and clearer for the presence of the dust. Small<br />
minds, like small mirrors, are by reason of their<br />
limitations, prone to mislead the observer, and to<br />
Jeave him without a true sense of proportion, and<br />
when to this are perhaps added prejudIce, intolerance,<br />
bias or others of the sombre emotions which<br />
cloud truth and clarity of vision, the delusion is<br />
complete, and factions, schisms, internecine strife,<br />
and like forms of discord and disruption make their<br />
unlovely appearance.<br />
The stature of men is largely the measure of their<br />
vision; of their ability to distinguish between<br />
essentials and incidentals and to give to each of<br />
these the place or preference it deserves; and it is<br />
one of the marks whereby true leaders may be<br />
known that they possess the vision and the power<br />
to subordinate the minor to the major ev('n at the<br />
ruthless sacrifice of their own predilections. Leaders<br />
lose their qualifications for leadership 110 soon as<br />
they suffer presonal prejudices to influence an<br />
impartial outlook upon a situation, since their<br />
vlsion and judgment become thereby clouded and<br />
uncertain. Obviously danger to the cause on hand<br />
lies in treating as primary considerations that truer<br />
judgment must determine to be merely secondary.<br />
The measure of success already achieved in IndIa<br />
along the difficult and arduous path towards Nationhood-the<br />
co-ordination and harmonising of<br />
erstwhile conflicting forces and interests-was<br />
possible only by reason of the selflessness and the<br />
wide range of outl00k possessed by her great leaders<br />
and employed by them.<br />
Only by recognising and compelling recognition<br />
of the principle that sectional interests, however<br />
important in their place, must be ilubordinated to
-----------------------.--------------------------------<br />
()ctober-30th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 28!<br />
th(> int(>r('Rtll of til" greater whole, and by flO shaping<br />
pohcy and cOllillld,. could the progl'esfl mdde have<br />
Iie('n aclllevpd. AlItI the llleaSllre of advance on<br />
the rOcl111116 l\iJllistC'r 01' Mr. Tielm,\U Roos be asked to<br />
mltl"C'H3 the Synou, was negatived by the Bishop of<br />
Prl'lori.l.<br />
.. It was the duty of the Churches, .. continued the<br />
ArchLle,lCon ••, to Apeak With a de..!I' and uniteu VOICe<br />
on the fl1ndJ.Iuental prlllcipl!'s of Chrlstiamty. They<br />
were not concerned with det,uls of govel nment. but<br />
to them it was the enunciation of a vital prlIlciple.<br />
antI lhe Colour Bdr BIll was alien to the spirit of<br />
Chl'ist, It was not th€> duty of the Synoll. as such,<br />
to s,ty how these things should be dOlle, but it waf!<br />
for them to say v. bat' they believed to be the will of<br />
Christ on a snbject,<br />
They had to avoid all side<br />
issneA amI. concentrate on the fact th.lt the Colour<br />
Bar Bill was contrary to the prinCIples of Christianity<br />
...<br />
Professor Brookes<br />
PI'ofellSo\' E. H. Brookes. of the 'l'r.lDsvaal Unt<br />
.'ersitv COll.:>gll. Opposl'!l tbe resolution. ,IUd lllo'l'ed :<br />
'l'hat this Synod If'ell'l strongly that any I t'BtrictiVl'<br />
lq,(Isl.ltJoll such as the so-c,lllf>d Colour Bar<br />
131118holllll Dot pl'l'celie the legisLltion l'xtendmg<br />
to lldtiv(,1!1 tilt· 114ht to acquire l.1nd out"i,le the<br />
limit~ hull down by the Native Land Act, which.<br />
it un,lelstand8 from hlA spt·cches ill t1ie Transkei.<br />
is part of the Prime Mmibter's native ·pohcy. ,<br />
l'hat this Synod assures the PrIme l\hmster of<br />
itR fullest ~) mpJthy WIth Ids etfOl ts to formul,lte<br />
a national natIvo policy on non-p,lrty lines,<br />
l'l'ote~:ior lkook('s f.,li,l he opposed the Colour B.lr<br />
DIll in so [,U' th,lt bad he bel:'ll ill P,lrliament he<br />
would not han· mtrodnced it. In other resprds It<br />
w.as f'imply pnttinl.! into LHV a regul.1tion th.lt hat!<br />
.llways t,xIsted, un Ithl:'l'u ,\as IlO velY Wdlkcu difference<br />
between th~ new law and the old regulation.<br />
He would hke to know how many natives there<br />
were amuous to proceed to any post enumerated in<br />
the Coloor Bar BIll, and in. how far the Bill was<br />
opposed to the principle of Christianity. In those<br />
circumstances restricting Indian immigration was<br />
similarly against those principles. What the country<br />
needed. said Professor Brookes. was a scheme by<br />
which both races would be allowed to develop along<br />
their own lines, where they came as little as possiblo<br />
in contact with each other. It was the intentIOn to<br />
mtroduce a BIll for the advancement of the native<br />
franchise in some form or other to all the other provinces.<br />
It seemed to-nim-that the Synod was- condemning<br />
generally. without a word of gratitude for<br />
anything that the Government had done.<br />
Rev. S. A. Bishop msisted on absolute justice<br />
without regard to colour.<br />
Mr. C. Baber supported Mr. Brookes, and said that<br />
the Colonr Bar Bill should not be opposed on the<br />
grounds that it was a bit of piecemeal legislation.<br />
Bishop Of Pretoria<br />
The Bishop of Pretoria thought that Professot"<br />
• Brookes was he
Kazi, Sorabj~e RUBtomjee, M. B. Naik, F. Gareeb,'<br />
Molvi G. Mnstufa and the Rev. J. M. SundrllID and,<br />
the Be-v. Chunoo also addressed the gathering. The<br />
following resolutions were passed unanimously :-<br />
1. "That thi!l mass nteetlng uf btdians held in the<br />
Town Hall, Mal"itzbul"g, undar the auspices of the<br />
Natal Indian Congress (Pietermarittbnrg DIstrict<br />
Oommlttee) emphatically protests against tbe Area'J<br />
Reservation and Immigration and Registration<br />
(Furthell' ProVision) Bill in that the Bill aims at the<br />
oompull'!O'l'Y segregation of the lndians, deprives<br />
them of th-eil' existing and proprietary rights, and<br />
fnrther restricts their domiciliary rights with a view<br />
to their ~ltimate extermination frCfIIl the country.,'<br />
2. "Tfiat this mass meeting of Indian assembled<br />
at Pletermaritzburg strongly supports the reaolution<br />
passed by a representative meeting of Natal IndiaJilB<br />
held at Durban on the 31st Angust,. 1925¢ affirming<br />
the suggestion of holding a Ruund Table donfe:rence<br />
as the only solu.tion fpr a settlement of the Indian<br />
qnestion."<br />
Hindu Tamit Insdtute<br />
Prtte Distribution<br />
Record Crowd. Witness, Children's Actillg<br />
'Ehe ftl'll'ID'Wing report has been forwarded to 1!l'R by<br />
tJa.e, ken. Secretalry em the above' Instrtlite> fOt' p'o:blli ..<br />
cail10n 1-<br />
A l1ecQrd: crowli gat"fuJel1e~ at the Rarwat's BID Han<br />
e.Dl SIruJ!l!, who' fll"esi.ued,<br />
P. R. Falfuer, the S-eelletary< a.nd B-, MOO1'l'J.'8wami<br />
PIllay, the Headmasller,- tooilf thei'!' sealt'il alt ~ ta:DI-&<br />
plrn-ctl'lall¥ at the' appoontelil1 hour, ta.oe, hall}! waS' fined<br />
to overfiowing. An interestmg, fea.ture- W'aS- thai! the<br />
audien.'Ge {loInprIsedl of OiVell 51i)0' women' of' aU sectwns<br />
oLthe' In.dian eom!t'lllml)lJ,tp. At] l".m. fully<br />
20g ehildll1en headed by the C~l!I'lmlttee (1)!f tlhe- Itl'8tf~<br />
tute, marehed\from the> Ins1JiI)I~»)~»I)' 0<br />
Birmingham's ]\fedical Officer of Health. in hIS<br />
annual report, speaks of the mischievous resoIts of<br />
a KnowiJedge of birth-eontro} by young people. For<br />
Birmingham'lI birth-rate last year wa~ t'he l'owest<br />
o'n' record 19.2, as compared Vtith .30.7 twenty yearsago.<br />
A:.nd Su" James points' out tihat fol' England,<br />
as It whole, the population is almost stationer:y at<br />
, p'J'esent, a condition' which- he considers is li'lrely to<br />
, portend the decay of the' Empire, as" in' other nation!!<br />
where l.lIrthl.eontrol has' been practised for long<br />
periods. But he, however, d had a faint<br />
consciousness, though ae added, there was no need<br />
to assume that they felt pain or pleasure. Plants<br />
were also thingil oil habit., of "unconscious memory";<br />
as for instance a plant that raises its leaves to the<br />
snn's light and drops them at night time. When<br />
such plant is kept entirely in the dark, as in a<br />
cellar, it COnbnlleil to observe the times- of its habit.<br />
There have been many fine novels written about<br />
lunat1c ailylumns, and' somB' perhaps written by<br />
lunatics, but when the bibliography of madness IS<br />
compIled~ Mr. H. G. Wells will as usual find'himself<br />
in capitals. It is a hnman and a good book. If it<br />
has not the characteristics of Cha1'les Reades' .. Hard<br />
Cash. " itrsurpasses by far iJy the qualities of life
October 30th, 1925 JND1AN ONN10N 283<br />
-----.----~--------------~----------------------------~and<br />
truth, that ancwlIt anti commenddble endeavour.<br />
And if by this book Mr. Wells achieves anything in<br />
favour gf the bdter and more hnmane treatment of<br />
the lunatic. the nation will indeed be beholden to<br />
him, for apart f"om the treatment of the hmatlc.<br />
there is eve" a doubt, whethf'r one who is decldred<br />
a lunatic is really so. and it is just POBRible that<br />
those who have the power to certify others a6<br />
lnnatbs, are themselves not free from some form or<br />
other of the same mal.ldy.<br />
There is a struggle going on between the Ministry<br />
of Health and the West Holm Boalu of Guardians on<br />
the amount of relief Pdyable to thf' out-of-works in<br />
the district of W('st Ham. which owing to its situation<br />
JD the dock area on the Thames, has a very<br />
large populdtion. Some 70,000 unemployed are in<br />
receipt of poor rehef, the rate of such relief allowed<br />
hy the Guardldlls is 59/- per week per fdmily. The<br />
MlDistry of HealtlJ insist on the amount being reduced<br />
to 55/- but the Guardians refuse to accept this<br />
legal standard rate. They holJ that they are justified<br />
in allowing what they consider a living rate,<br />
regdrdless of the fact that the I'ecipient of su~h a<br />
rate of rehef, when in work, earned a lesser sum.<br />
'fhe Guardians have from time to time been<br />
financed by way of loans by the Ministry of Health,<br />
'''hich already amount to over a million pounds, and<br />
the Ministry were prepared to guarantf'o a further<br />
loan of three hundred thousand pounds if the<br />
Guardians would reduce the rate of allowance as<br />
suggested by the Ministry. As a result of the<br />
Guardians' refuSdl to fall in with the views of the<br />
Ministry, they are not in a positIon to payout any<br />
rehef. So the Ministry has taken up the relief of<br />
the out-of-works, and will no doubt later seek for<br />
the necessary Parhamentary sanctlOn. And at the<br />
same time the struggle continues between the<br />
Ministry and the Guardians. The Guardians<br />
threaten that when the pdor rates are collected in<br />
the district, they will make up the dIfference m<br />
the rate, which the Ministry IS paying, so that the<br />
rate of relief in the end would amount to the rate<br />
the GuardIans are figbting for. There is to be a<br />
deputation of the Guardians on the Ministry next<br />
week.<br />
The League of Nations at Geneva has been notIfied<br />
by the BI'itish Government that the Governor<br />
of Burma has completed an agreement in the<br />
IIukawng Valley, to emancipate about :3.000 slaves,<br />
men, women anu chIldren, by a ransom which those<br />
freed will pay in annual instalmepts. The practice<br />
of Btll1ing slaves, giving them aWdY as part of a<br />
mdrI'iage dowry, or Iq settlement of blood feuds.<br />
and breaking up f.unilies of slaves is to cease.<br />
The de,lth is announcetl to-d.\y of the ~Llbarajah<br />
of Jammu and Kashmir, Pratab. H.R. Sir Pratab<br />
Singh is in his 75th year. The Maharajah was the<br />
third of line. grandson of the founder of his<br />
dynasty. There was one chIld born to the Maharajdb<br />
in 1~04 but died from an accident the year<br />
after. He is succeeded by his nephE'w Sir Har!<br />
Singh. The dead Prince succeeded to the throne<br />
30 years ago. The area of his rule was 80,000<br />
square miles. and the population over 3,000.000.<br />
During the late war he malle a very cOluageous<br />
break from tradition in leaving his country and<br />
visiting France and the Indidn Expedition. He saw<br />
the battle of Cambrai. he was hon. lieut.-gener,d of<br />
the BI·itish Army; W,\S a frieDll of Lord Roberts.<br />
gave £100,000 to the Indi,\n Memori.ll to Queen<br />
Victoria. and waived a claim of over £11;3,000 for<br />
the use of his sohliers overseas. He was interested<br />
in History, Religion. and PolItics. When he was<br />
over 50 he won the Royal IIllm:lne Society's Meddl<br />
for saving the hfe of an Englishwoman at Isl.mibad,<br />
and he was still playing criwket after he was. sixty.<br />
But he played it under distinctive condition:!. A<br />
story is told of him that on hearing that "Ranji"<br />
was nearby, he said he would like to see him. They<br />
had a long chat about the game-then the Yaharajdh<br />
asked jf Ranji had evet made" an egg." "Oh<br />
les." was the answer. •• More than one egg'"<br />
• Of course, lots of them." .. Ah, " was the MaharajJ.h's<br />
proud reply. .. That has never happened to<br />
me. not once." The reason was !imp1e. Bowlers,<br />
wicket keepers and fieldsmen were diplomatic,<br />
everyone of them, in every conceivable way. made<br />
it possible for him to score. But that was an<br />
example of oriental politeness and grdve humour,<br />
which nobody derided. He was entItled to a Royal<br />
salute of 21 guns. Kashmir is noted as a land of<br />
romance and magnificence and travellers call its<br />
c.lpital Srinagar, the Venice of tho East, and among<br />
the many wonderous things to behold is the Royal<br />
Barge, manned by 50 oarsmen behind the canopy<br />
and 50 in front. They keep perfect time with the<br />
padtlles, and are gorgeously dressed. It is the land<br />
of the Arabian mghts.<br />
Crematioo<br />
Its Economic Advantage To The Nation<br />
Mr. Arthur E. Piggott, speaking recently on<br />
"CrematlOn" at a meeting of the Manchester Rotary<br />
Club. Johannesburg, said that cremation was a<br />
reverent treatment of the dead, and in that respect<br />
might be regarded as an advantage to the living.<br />
Its advantages from the hygienic point of view were<br />
genernlly conceded, but its great advantage was on<br />
the sc(\re of economy-not alone to individuals. but<br />
particularly in the Iilavmg of the cost of large areas<br />
of land cemeteries. Cremation reduced both the<br />
civic and the indiVidual cost; burial increased the<br />
burden of expense to the nation.<br />
Mr. Piggot claimed that cremation wa.s in entire<br />
accordance with Chl'lstian belief and interfered with<br />
no religious ceremony or rite. It avoided the<br />
dangers attendant on graveside funerals in inclement<br />
weather. It transformed corruptIOn into cleanliness<br />
and made the disposal of a dead body something not<br />
repulsive but artistic and symb'llic. Cremation<br />
could only take place after searching inquiry as to<br />
the actual cause of death, and removed all possibility<br />
of being buried alive, while the regulations made by<br />
law eliminated the risk of murder going undetected.<br />
In the course of the address Mr. Piggott pointed<br />
out that the amount required to be raised. in the year<br />
1~2:l for municipal cemeteries in Manchester amounted<br />
to £3,3H, equivalent to a rate of O.O,jd. Powers<br />
were. however, recently sought by the Corporation<br />
to acquire no less an area than 90 acres lD extent in<br />
the neighbourhood of the Southern Cemetery "and<br />
its appropridtion for bunal purposes." The Southern<br />
Cemetery already occupies an area of 98 acred<br />
and apPl'oximately some 13-1,000 dead bodies lie<br />
there. Now the scheme was to withdraw more acres<br />
of fertIle soil from the service of man, caused<br />
by improper treatment of the dispOBal of the dead.<br />
If cremated ashes were stood in an urn-which was<br />
by no means necessary-or if the ashes were pulvelised.<br />
allll scattered ,\ very few acres would suffice<br />
for the city for generations.-1 h8 Star.
* •• ~~ ••• **.***.*.~<br />
~ Original Correspondence ~<br />
~ ~<br />
~ The Editor, INDIAN OPINION. i~<br />
~.~.~.~ ••• ~ •••••• f<br />
Canon Haywood Harris At<br />
Maritzburg Meeting<br />
Sir,-It seems to me that the presence of Canon<br />
Heywood HarrIs on the platform at MarItzburg on<br />
Saturday last\requires some explanation. The meetmg<br />
was calle,l by the Indian Congress to protest<br />
against the legislation now beIng mtroduced against<br />
the ASIatic races, but an allusIOn to this was made<br />
by the Canon. Instead he repeated some common<br />
ChrIstIan platItudes about "l"lghteousness" and<br />
.. princIple, " and laId great stress on .. team-work"<br />
I.e. co-operation.<br />
Judging however, from a report of this gentleman~<br />
words in the Nalal W~/ness of 15th Oct. 192.5,<br />
his homIly on " prInciple" falls very fiat, and he<br />
hImself stands convICted of inconsIstency and insmcel"lty.<br />
HIS words as reported are: "The Indiar:,<br />
natIve and coloured people were encroaching on<br />
many of the ordInary avenues of work, and it was<br />
becommg Increasingly ddficult to place all the European<br />
boys. He wan Led the school-boy of to-day to<br />
grasp that the whILe people would only hold theIr<br />
posItIon In work and In government In this country<br />
so long as they pt'oved themselves bettE'r able than<br />
the other races to fill the vanous posts." No "teamwork"<br />
between ~he races here, but cut-throat competitIOn<br />
on raCIal lines'<br />
Box 335,<br />
Mantzburg,<br />
26th Oct. 1925<br />
I am,<br />
INDIAN OPINION October 30th, 1925<br />
-------<br />
Yours etc,<br />
CRAS. RAKER.<br />
•<br />
The Ethics of Passive Resistance<br />
Essay on Indian Economics, by Mahadev<br />
Govind Ranade<br />
Hindu Psalms and Hymns<br />
Vaishavlte Reformers of IndIa<br />
M K. Gandhi and the South Arrican<br />
Indian Problem<br />
Aspecs of the Vedanta<br />
Es,ars 00 Indlao Art, Industry and Education 2<br />
Sri M 1I1bwacbarya -<br />
HiQdu~sm. by Dr. Barnett 2<br />
Position 01 the Women in the Vedas<br />
VlInaculars as Media of In&tructlon in<br />
Jo(l,ao Sch lOis and Colleges<br />
Elsent'als of HindUIsm 1<br />
Dadlbhal Naorojl's Speeches and Wrltingl 6<br />
Indian NatIOnal Congr .ss 8<br />
Tbe Madras Corgress and Conferences<br />
Allahabad aod Nagpur Congresses :l<br />
(<br />
The Surat Congrfss and Conferences 2<br />
The ImprovelUl;;nt of Indian Agriculture 2<br />
T'le Congress Conferences and Conventions 2<br />
India's Untoucbable Saints 2<br />
For India's Uphft, by Anne Besant 3<br />
The Governance of India, by Govind Das 7<br />
Sri RamanuJacharya 2<br />
Sn Sankaracharya 2<br />
Ur. Gandhl'~ Speec;hes and Writiags-Il!96 to 1917 3<br />
The Indian Demands, by G. A.Natesan 2<br />
IndIan Industrial and Economic Problems by Pro!. Kale 3<br />
Essays on NatIOnal Ideahsm, by Dr Coomaraswamy 2<br />
FIlIENDS OF INDIA SERIES' Lord Morley, Sif Wm<br />
Wedderburn, Rev. Dr. Mliler, Sir Edwm Arnold,<br />
Edmund Burke, Lord Mmto, Henry Fawcett,<br />
John Brlgbt A O. Hume, Sir Henry Cotton, Lor
No. 4S-Vol~ XXIII. Friday, November 6th, 1925.<br />
ttecisterecl at the G. P. O. .~ • He_a.,.r<br />
PIUC. Foo .... «.<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
t\\JiT ESSR~. Parbhoouas Haribhai Patel, Nanalal<br />
11 V II M. Khanderh and Manilal G. Patel all of<br />
whom have been allowed to enter and reside<br />
in the Tran!!vaal as educated Indians and hoM.<br />
exemption certificate!! issued by the Government<br />
have been served with the following notICe declaring<br />
them prohlhited immigrants :-<br />
.. Take notico tJl
286 INDIAN OPINION November 6th, 1925<br />
!' hU: admias.ian t.o make I To this item .of<br />
n SC .i. ~Z J[mVTf/ gives the sub-lIea4iag:<br />
.. " era
November 6th, 1925<br />
INDIAN OJJINION<br />
no sensible person can doubt th&t the bringing in<br />
of another CmH!i of sea-lIIen, belonging to another<br />
lace, called Inliian lai!cars, in order to break the<br />
original slriko and force the aca.-men who have<br />
stmck work In accept 10\ller wages iii an act on the<br />
pdrt of the Shipping Companies which will stir up<br />
r,lcial hatred and p.lJI.8ions to no small uegree and<br />
comphcate the politwal situation of the world. The<br />
Routh African Indian Congress have very rightly<br />
and .widely caLled at ()nce their protest to India and<br />
• the rel'lt of the world against this action ()f the<br />
shipping companies, and they are able being on the<br />
spot, and at close £Iuarters, to know wllllt is going<br />
on and w unden!tand instinctively and immediately<br />
the serious harm which iil certain to be done by the<br />
enCollragcmcnt of such a policy of trying in India<br />
labour on behalf of the shIpping companies.<br />
Alreooy the situation in South Africa is serioUil<br />
enough. Already the raca hatred against the Indian.<br />
is incredIbly bad. Already the Indians have<br />
boon drii'en from pilla. to pGilt, and their cup of<br />
misery and bitterness is very nearly fulL Bnt if<br />
the news which the telegt'a.mil from Bombay ha.ve<br />
published of the recruiting of 700 lascars who have<br />
Leen shipped off to South Africa to break the strike<br />
is really true, then, indeed, the cuP of mieery will<br />
completely overflow, and there will be no hope<br />
whatever of any lel!8ening of the race hatred between<br />
the white and ·thpIndian races in SOllth<br />
Afl'ica. The ~our Party in South Africa, to<br />
whom an appeal has just been made in London to<br />
meet the Indian delegates of the Indian Trades<br />
Union Congress, in ord
.0<br />
INDIAN OPINION November 6th 1925<br />
so forlh tQ replace postal, telegraph, and telephone once I jumperl on him and gave him rather a caustic<br />
,. time.<br />
~~ E is for general unclassified services, m- "You coloured people" I cried, and pray what<br />
(lIDding clerical work. It will mclude women, who right hav.e yOll to let down the whole of the Orient<br />
will be registered for service in canteens, hospitals, by calling them "coloured p~ople" and then deand<br />
so on, but in no circumstances wlll women be claring that they amonnt to a Illerc fraction of value.<br />
Clllployed in places where there is any danger of "It is thIS deplorable cheapening of yourselves<br />
rough handling. that has brought about all thIS trouble. Cannot you<br />
The Home Secretary interviewed by the Press on understand that such words lower your standard and<br />
the O.M.S. is reported to have said, that the Govern- the whole of the Orient, and the old Inllia who bement<br />
had all its plans ready for the eventualities lieved that the rest of the wOI'ld revolved round<br />
following a general strike, and if necessary would their beloved land and received its substance from<br />
call upon citizens and bodies lIke the O,M,S. for it ?<br />
volunteer helpers.<br />
" Do you know, or do you not beheve, that a r(J,l'e<br />
It waS in 1893, that the Venerable Anagarlka like a man is always accepted on it's own value?<br />
Dharmapala a 'Buddist monk was last m London. But they must live np to that value.<br />
Tpe boat train that brought the Begum of Bhopal .. You, yourself Don" (his name is not D H1 bnt It<br />
al130 carried the monk. He is a ta.ll spare man WIth will serve) are "gilt-eiged" but for this f~lse lhllia<br />
keen brown aesthetic face, flashmg white teeth, dence you ticket yourself eke,p and n I~tlf. I should<br />
and curly grey hair, and clad in a vollllmnous hate to hear you continually bO.lsting yourself or<br />
ol'ang~ gown, wound round him WIth canvass shoes, your people-tho' advertisin6 always pays, bnt I do<br />
of the same hu~. He has no personal posseSSIOns want you to raise your stand.1rd which has fd.lleh so<br />
beyond a small case contaimng toilet artIcles, a few low here, that you are trea.ted and cla~sed with<br />
books of devotion, a quantity of Bndclist Literature, everyt)1ing you should not be br .... cketed wUh.<br />
and a 'portable typewriter. He travels but has no I claim you a va.lued friend and yet you try to<br />
money. He is here to consolidate the position of cheapen me by thinking I would gIve my regard to<br />
fonowers of Lord Budda, in England, with the help something wOI'Lhless-you would run my standard<br />
of such followers by establishing a ~laha-Bodhi below half-m1.st. "<br />
Society.<br />
" A man is known by the friends he keeps, so<br />
The Begum of Bhopal on her arrival was met by 'tis said, and the same theory applies to woman. I<br />
Lord Headly the Mohammedan Peer and some of want a gilt-edged friend not a shoddy acquaintance.<br />
the officials of the Mosque at W .... kmg. WIth her R~spect yonrself-your race, your abilllies. YOUI'<br />
are her so!'/. Prince Hamidullah, her daughter-Ill- work and be tnle to yourself. "<br />
law, her grand sops Syecl Lafir Khan and Raschid Bi8hop Fisher Rays .. I am myself-I am above<br />
Lafir Khan, and her Minister-in-Attendance Sir my ideals, my mdlvitll1ahty I retain." HIS Ego is<br />
Israr Hussein Khan. She has taken a house in healthy and beautiful, he is gilt-edged. "<br />
Portman Square. To-day sbe placed a wreath at Do not confound this With conceit which IS<br />
the foot of the Cenotaph. - offensive and despicable. "I wag ill New York<br />
The 1924 Nobel PrIze for Literature was awarded about three years ago and accidentally ran 3crOiS a<br />
to Vtdislas St. Reymont, a Pole. The novel which South Africln one ddY. He seemed very mIlch<br />
gave him the prize is caUed " The Peasants," and is troubled at the lack of ('ourtesy of the people, .. Oh,<br />
the first of a series of fonr of his novels. The MISS 1\1
cf)piniDtt<br />
J ·'-N-o-.-4---- '-.-X-X-I-I-I-.---F-r-id-a-y-,-N-o-v-e-m-b-e-r-.-3- 6 Vō t -: h -,-I-9- 2 -S-.---:R.::-.-:~i:-:.te-red-:-.-:~-:::.'!:-:-::::-;=~-:.!!::- ••-::",-<br />
n::l)EUTEH'S message from Cape Town rtports<br />
il\\ that the Fifth Session of the South African<br />
Indian Congress was opened by the Mayor<br />
of Cape Town in the City Hall on the 9th instant<br />
at 8 p.m. There was a large gathering of Indians,<br />
and scores of telegrams conveying messages of sympathy<br />
and cheer were received from Associations and<br />
individualfl in this country as well as India, and<br />
one from Mahatama Gandhi.<br />
The Mayor, in his address of wt'lcome,cpleaded for<br />
patience and tolerance and remarked that justice did<br />
not mean the undermining of the one section of<br />
the commnnity for the betterment of the other.<br />
After the presidental addreEs by Dr. A. H. Gool the<br />
Conference adjourned for the next day.<br />
There is at least one sphere of industrialism in<br />
Durban in which, in the eye of the law, Europeans<br />
and Indians are treated alike. This is<br />
the printing industry. This was demonstrated in<br />
the Durban Courts by a judgment delivered by Mr.<br />
A. T. Roberts when it was t!hown that Indian<br />
printers' assistants had to be paId according to a<br />
schedule adopted by the NatlOnal Industrial Council<br />
of the Printing and Newspaper Industry of South<br />
A fl'i ca. The same conditions apply equally to Europeans<br />
and Indians. If, therefore, IndIans continue<br />
to be employed it is because they are as efficient as<br />
Europeans. One might go further and say that they<br />
must be more efficient, otherwise they would not be<br />
employed, in view of the prevailing colour preJl1dlCe<br />
and active propaganda in favour of white labour.<br />
The Transvaal Nationalists, in anticipation of the<br />
Prime Minister's intention to make an epoch-making<br />
speech on the Native problem at Smithfield this<br />
week, has submitted a memorandum which is likely<br />
to provoke trouble in Government circles and which,<br />
it is prophesied, may lead to a serious ministerial<br />
orisis in the near flltnre.<br />
This memorandUm declares that .. Uniformity in<br />
Native policy is a first requirement in the? solution<br />
of the problem. In order to secure snch uniformity<br />
steps must be taken to incorporate the Bechuanaland<br />
Protectorate, Basutoland, and Swaziland. The NatIOnal<br />
Party of the Transvaal accepts segregation as<br />
a basic principle and expreSiles its opinion that there<br />
are four sub-divisions in this system, viz., territorial<br />
segrl:'gation, social segregation, industrial segrega-<br />
\,tion, and pohtical s~~<br />
It further goes on to say: .. By keepin~ the<br />
Native as far as possihle ont of f.killed amI civ1lised<br />
labour, the Wages Act is legislation that will operate<br />
in the direction of Industrial Segregation and as<br />
such it is welcomed by the Executive Committee.<br />
Anv vocations where a certllicod.tI' of competency is<br />
nec'essary shouhl not be open to Nativ{'s and Asi 1-<br />
tics, The Colour Bar Bl11 is legislation which<br />
carries out this princible,' Work or business which<br />
is liCCIlSCll by the Provincial authorities, as {or<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
~,\'<br />
•<br />
•• -:M::-."'-pa-pa-<br />
example the liquor trade and ordinary trade, should<br />
not be open to the Native or Asiatic. "<br />
On the question of the franchise the Transvaal<br />
Nationalists are no less emphatic: "The Transvaal<br />
National Party expresses its opinion that the Native<br />
should not have the franchise. as far as Parliament.<br />
Provincial Councils or Municipalities are concerned.<br />
('nder no circumstances is the Nationalist Party of<br />
the Transvaal prepared to allow the Native franchise<br />
to be extended to the north, and it feels strongly<br />
that the Native franchise in the Cape should be curtaIled.<br />
The Nationalist Party of the Transvaal further<br />
'lSSerts that they are not prepared to agree to<br />
the direct representation of the Natives in Parliament,<br />
even though such representativeR voted in an<br />
advisory capacity only, and even then the Transvaal<br />
Nationalists would not agree to it. The Committee<br />
feels that the public of the Transvaal (irrespective of<br />
parties) will never agree to give direct reoresentation<br />
to Natives in Parliament or to give them a vote<br />
in a Parhamentary election in the Transvaal. As<br />
far as the Cape Coloured are concerned the Committee<br />
is of the opmion that this question should remain<br />
in abeyance until such time as the Native<br />
question has been satisfactorily solved.<br />
We await with interest the statement of the<br />
Prime Minister who is more or less committed to a<br />
much more liberal policy towards the Natives even<br />
if he has no sympathy with Asiatics, That the two<br />
questions are practically one to the Transvaal NatIOnalists<br />
is plainly seen. It 1S a question of "whites<br />
against non-whites."<br />
The London correspondent of the Natal Advertiser<br />
cables that Mr. H. S. L. Polak, of the Indian Overseas<br />
Association, draws attention in Th8 Manch.sllt~r<br />
Guardian to the fact that October 11th was treated<br />
throughout India as a day of prayer and humiliation<br />
in protest against the Indian policy of the Union<br />
Government. He describes it as "an episode of<br />
great moment, certainly to the Indian people, and<br />
probably to the Empire at large."<br />
The Town Clerk of Durban, replying to an inquiry<br />
from the secretary of the South African European<br />
Motor Drivers' and Mechanics' As90ciation<br />
writes :<br />
.. I regret to inform you that the Town Council<br />
has no power or authority to introduce legislation<br />
whereby Europeans only shall be eligible for the<br />
'occupation of drivers of steam driven vehicles within<br />
this borough. This would imply class legislation<br />
ami on that account would be strongly opposed ...<br />
l\bss S. M. Warner, L.R.A.M., gave an interesting<br />
lecture before the Durban Lodge of the Theosophical<br />
Society on the 5th inst. on "Some Modern<br />
Composer." :Miss Warner illustrated her" lecture<br />
by giving several musical selectio'ps. aemonstrating<br />
how mnsic expressed itse~. in "Nature, Mysticism,<br />
Humour, etc.. There was an appreciative auwenee.
INDIAN OPINtON November 13th, 1925<br />
Mr. Gandhi, in a message to the Bombay Chronicle<br />
Oll the South African day says I-" Happily the<br />
question of the British Indians in South Africa is<br />
not II tJarty question. India mnst be able to avert<br />
the calamity that threatens to overtake onr countrYr<br />
men in that sub-continent.<br />
The proposed legislation<br />
is a manifest breach of the settlement of 1914.<br />
My experience of the Indian question in South<br />
Africa is one of It series of breaches, promiSe!i and<br />
declarations, which have been proved from the<br />
official records. "<br />
---<br />
" The vroposed legislation, (says Mr. Gandhi) is<br />
in effect a confiscation of almost every right that the<br />
:t3ritish Indians possess. Their sole crime consists<br />
in being good traders and not being EuropeanS.<br />
There can be no compromise in this matter, no repatriation<br />
even when euphemistically described as<br />
volUntary. tet me, however, say that retaliation<br />
will be no remedy, if only because there can be no<br />
effective retaliation. The only remedy is diplomatic<br />
pressure. Lord Hardiuge applied it successfully.<br />
Will the present Government repeat that performance<br />
?"<br />
The Bombay Oh:rrmule publishes special messages<br />
from leaders all over India on the South Africa<br />
day. Mrs. Slirojini Naidu hopes the wrongs of Indians<br />
in South AfrIca will kmdle in the heart. of<br />
India sorrow and indignatwn.<br />
Dr. Rabindranath Tagore writes that the treatment<br />
met~d out to Indians in South Africa should make<br />
them-conscious of their responsibility to the original<br />
inhabitants of the country. Provocation to inflict<br />
injury on their neighbours tor the sake of their<br />
own self-interest should be avoided. Let Indja~s<br />
win the heart of Africans through sacrifice and<br />
co-operation, and share the resources of the ,country<br />
by the glad. consent of the legitimate owners.<br />
--....-<br />
Mr. C, Rajgopala,chariar says that the price fol' a<br />
com.fortable domestic life, and indifference to the<br />
ce.lls of national duty. is dishonour at home and dishonour<br />
abroad. The remedy for pariahdom in the<br />
world is to make one's natIOn free at home. All India'.<br />
resources should be placed. at the dispoaa,l of<br />
her national lea.ders for the liberatIOn of India.,<br />
which alone ean solve the colonial problems,<br />
, 1'0 protest against the anti-Asiatic legislation now<br />
being introduced in South Africa aud to concert<br />
measures for the remova.l of the dIsabilities against.<br />
Indians who have settled in the South African<br />
Union, a public demonstration was held at Mirzapurpark,<br />
Calcutta on the 11th Oct. Speeches condemning<br />
the action of the South African Government and<br />
advocating retaliatory measnre~ in India were made.<br />
Mr. Jagadish Chandra Mookerjee, who has rec'elltly<br />
returned. to India after a short busi~ess v~sit<br />
to South AMca, gave ltu account of the dli~culties<br />
and humiliations he had to undergo. He Bald that<br />
the passport authorities in Calcutta and. ~e Cons~lar<br />
authorities in Africa could nob help a BrItIsh subject,<br />
although subjects of Faance, Portugal, etc, had the<br />
sgppori of their Governments. He said he had to<br />
leave India Oli a. passport visaged by the Portuguese<br />
Oonaul to land in Aft:ica on Portuguese territory<br />
there as the British passport officials in Calcutta<br />
oould only give a passport at the owner'~ risk. The<br />
speaker said he felt asb.amed of being a British subj~ct.<br />
At this meeting Dr. J. 1'11. D
November 13th, 1925 IND1A~ OPINION 291<br />
India's Protest Against Asiatic<br />
Bill<br />
Hindus and Muslims, Jews and Christians, Farsis<br />
antl,Hikhs, we aU may have our differences, but in<br />
our utter dett'Station of the South African Government<br />
of the laUer's treatment of our countrymen In<br />
South Africa we are all one. The public meeting<br />
held On the Cbaupatty Sandi! recently under the<br />
auspICes of the Bombay Provincial Congress Committee<br />
and several other public bodies gave unmistakable<br />
expre8Bion of the feelings that are univers-dolly<br />
held by all the Indians throughout the<br />
whole of India over a question that vitally touches<br />
India's honour and self-respect. Indeed. the South<br />
African Indian question has been simmering for a<br />
long time, till at last, slowly but lurely, it has now<br />
come to a head. 'fhe time has arrived when either<br />
it mUBt mend or end. If it cannot mend in favonr<br />
of tbe Indians let it be ended by all means in our<br />
power even the most extreme that we would com<br />
IUdntI. Those who treat Indians as brutes ought. to<br />
be treated as brutes in return. The time of argument<br />
and deputations and peaceful negotiations is<br />
long past. The South African Government has<br />
shown without equivocation or any mental reservation<br />
that it is a sort of an oligarchy that is founded<br />
on racial pride and arrogance, that falsehood and<br />
broken pledges are the sole props of that Government<br />
and that its whole Indian policy stands rooted<br />
in dishonour, in deceit aud utter disregarrl. of the<br />
Banctitr of pledged words and solemnly-signed<br />
treaties. "Scraps of paper" lie strewn broadcast<br />
throughout the whole of that country m all the<br />
controversy that has raged so long between the Indians<br />
and the South African Government. But<br />
what i. the head and front of the Indians' fault?<br />
Yes, we must admit, the Indians have their faults,<br />
the faults of their virtue! Indians, according to the<br />
South African Government's code of morality, are<br />
made to suffer because they possess certain virtues<br />
in which the Whites are grossly deficient. Indians<br />
are frugal, Indims are good traders, Indians are<br />
satisfied with small profits, and Indians are quiet<br />
and peaceful citizens. The Whites have all these<br />
qualities in a negJ.tive manner and for this reason<br />
and this only the fiJ.t has gone forth that the Indidns<br />
shouM be penalised and driven out of the country<br />
bag and baggage. To the eternal shame (if the British<br />
Government, by their quiet acquiescence in the<br />
iniquitous behaviou.r of the South African Government,<br />
the latter has practically received a free<br />
charter to do their very worst towards the IndIans.<br />
But what could be said ab.mt the Indian Government.<br />
Its present position is the most humiliating<br />
one. At the very time when the Viceroy has been<br />
constantly regaling the Indians with the assurances<br />
that negotiations were carried on with the SUCCeStlOlS<br />
of the Boer Gov",rnment and the Colonial Office in<br />
Lond()n, the South African Premier and his Ministers<br />
have been forging new chains and bringing into<br />
existence new legislations which would practically<br />
hound the Indians out of that Bub--Continent.<br />
N ever in the history of the Imperial Ooverr.ment it<br />
has shown itself off in a more subservient and<br />
slavish position. It seems it is the tail that wags<br />
the dog and not the dog the tail. In this South<br />
African controversy the respective rolls between the<br />
Imperial Government and a subordinate Government<br />
that has not even a Dominion state is quite changed.<br />
It is South Africa that rules and the Imperi,.l ColonidI<br />
Office that takes its commands from its inferior.<br />
But what about India? India no longer has any<br />
voice. Indid is merely a subordinate branch of the<br />
British Government and it is supposed to be beneath<br />
&Dr oonsideration. India is a helot country. and<br />
helots have no voice to command. The proposed<br />
legislation in Soqth Africa Is a confiscation of almost<br />
every right that the British Indians PQsseeB and ,e~<br />
they and their countrymen in India are not capable<br />
of moving their little finger to ameliorate the lot of<br />
their brethren over the seas. This is a most hu,miliating<br />
condition In which the Indians find themselves<br />
at the present moment. It is proposed to<br />
hold protest meetings throughout the whole length<br />
and breadth of the whole country, But what of<br />
that? Who Is going to listen to this protest? None.<br />
What is to be done under the circumstances ? There<br />
is only one method ani one only that will ever<br />
make India heard in the councils of the Empire.<br />
Let India be free. A free India will command respect<br />
from others and will be feared by them. Indeed,<br />
for t.he present moment, for all the Indians of<br />
whatever pOlitical colour they be. the time has<br />
arrived when lcowing aside all other questions, they<br />
should all unite to make the Sonth African question<br />
their own and through this question to devise the<br />
different ways and means to make ladia a free and<br />
a self-respecting country within the Commonwealth<br />
of British Nations. The time has certainly arrived<br />
for Great Britaip to make her choice. Are they<br />
gomg to hug South Africa to their heart and let India<br />
slip out of its hand? Or are they going to<br />
fight-yes actually to fight-for India, that is fot<br />
justice, for equity and for mO",lity, and thua by a<br />
true Imperial gesture win over India, and in this<br />
victory win India's love and India's allegiance?<br />
Let Great Britain decide before it is too late.-&nj<br />
Vartmall.<br />
Harmony And Discord<br />
(By L. W. R.)<br />
A~ no time in the history of the IndIan people.<br />
whether of the Motherland or of South Africa, hall<br />
the spirit of unity and harmony been more needed<br />
than now. The nationhood of India hangs in the<br />
balance, and on the same issue rests the fate of the<br />
Indian people of this dominion. India and her<br />
people are being Bubjected to trial by Ordeal.<br />
According to the response to that test will deliverance<br />
bo achieved or further postponed. The question to<br />
be aDilwered is: How earnestly is that liberation<br />
desired? And the teBt whereby that answer shall<br />
be judged is 'he measure of harmony attained within<br />
the body or bodies politic. That this is n~cessarily<br />
so, follows inevitably an understanding of the<br />
psychology of the situation. India's mission ill so<br />
lofty. Her shadow to-day is the darker by oorurast<br />
with the great Spiritual light Bhe shed in the days<br />
of old. and with which, if her people will she may<br />
yet again illumine the world. But ere the spirit<br />
can shine through the vehicles harmony in these<br />
mast in a measure at least be estabhshed. There<br />
must be harmony in aspiration which in turn must<br />
be untainted by sordid or selfish motives. The note<br />
of •• Brotherhood" must ring true and elea.r throughout.<br />
Not for revenge sake, nor that the fruits of<br />
victory may be plucked and enjoyed must this<br />
labour be wrought but that Liberation may itself be<br />
used to liberate otherwise where bondage is. If it<br />
b,e objected that these prerequisites are unduly high<br />
and exacting let it be remembered that India's<br />
liberation may be the prelude to the World's redemption,<br />
that India's resumption of her foretim~<br />
spiritual ascendancy may mean the spiritual regeneration<br />
of a vast field outside of India-the<br />
possible dawn of a new age for mankind---and that<br />
the higher the mission the grcater the qualifications<br />
required of the missioner. Harmony and monotone<br />
are not synonymous. The "raginis" or sub-tones<br />
shade and coloW' and enrich the "raga" or overtone.
,<br />
They are "the same, yct not the same"; they contrIbute<br />
to and s,vall the harmony. SImIlarly, differences<br />
of opinion, differences in pomts of VIews,<br />
new angles of vision, of outlook, are not neccssarily<br />
discordant with any given main purpose. On the<br />
contrary they too may" be helpful and enriching.<br />
Very dIfferent, however, IS it with calculated dISruptive<br />
opposition that has as its object the promotion<br />
of discord m order that some personal or<br />
party end may be gained or that some enemy or<br />
rival party may be defeated. The' wreckmg of a<br />
good cause for such ends IS nothmg less than<br />
satanic, and heavy mdeed lS the retributIon that<br />
must react upon the unhappy mstruments thereof.<br />
Instruments rather than authors are such, mostly,<br />
instruments lli(nding themselves, as channels. to the<br />
dark forces o~posed to harmony, opposed to the<br />
building up of that synthetlC hfe towards wh1ch we<br />
are plainfully labonfmg. Of such foolIsh ones so<br />
lending themselves to eVIl It may truly be sald;<br />
"They know not what they do." But sure it IS also<br />
that the evIl to which they are party IS greater than<br />
they know, and that if through theIr wayward folly<br />
they injufe the whole (of which they are part) the v<br />
injufe themselves most all for action and reactIOn<br />
are equal and God IS never mocked. -<br />
A Protest Meeting at East London<br />
A mass meetmg orgamsed by the British IndHlU<br />
ASSOCIatIon of East London was held m the Tannl<br />
Temple Hall on Sunday 25th Oct. at 3-:30. p.m. to<br />
protest against the Areas ReservatIOn and ImmigratIOn<br />
and RegistratIOn (Further ProvlBlOn) BIll<br />
There was a large attendance of local and chstnd<br />
IndIans. Mr. S. CasooJee preSIded. The President<br />
and a Number of ther IndIan l3peakers dealt at<br />
length WIth some of the provislOns of thIS new BIll.<br />
The folloWlllg resolutIon was carnpd amidst<br />
applause -<br />
"That thIS mass meetmg of East Lonclon and<br />
district Indians assembled at thlS Tam]l '1'e'll1ple<br />
Hall under the auspIces of the BrItIsh Indmn Association<br />
of East London hereby places Oll record Its<br />
emphatic protest agamst the Areas ReservatIOn and<br />
Immigration and Re!nstratIOn (Furthel' ProvIsion)<br />
Blll the provlslOns of whlCh are most obnOXIOU'l and<br />
humiliating to the BntIi:lh Inelmn& ot the U mon ot<br />
South AtrICa "<br />
The elec1non of delegates to the forthcommg<br />
Conference at Capetown also took place. l\Ief!!:lrs.<br />
S. C.tsoOJee and A. M Chetty were nnal1lmomlly<br />
elected to represent the Bnbsh Indian ASSOCiatIOn<br />
of East London<br />
"<br />
The Transvaal Tamil Benefit<br />
SOCiety<br />
Under thp, auspIces of the above tlO{.1e[\·, a 111,(83<br />
meetlDg was held at the Goldbf'rg 1310 Hdll, Fo'{<br />
Street, Johannesburg, at 4 p.m., on Sunday the 2;)th<br />
Oc~ober 1925, to dISCUSS the adVIsabIlity of Bll b<br />
mitting a protest to the proper anthonty agamst thR<br />
.. AsiatIC Bill." The Chairman of the SOCIety. 1\£1 ••<br />
R. 8. C. PIllay preSIded over the meetlDg and very<br />
ably -dwelt upon the outrage of the BIll to the<br />
gathering. whIch was a large one. Mr. P. S. Pather<br />
read the Bill translate,l llltO Tamil bv 1\1r. K. R P.<br />
Naidoo, the Han. Secretary of the Society, which<br />
was fully explained by Mr. C. K. '1'. N,lidoo After<br />
a lengthy discussion over the demellts of the BIll,<br />
the following fesolutlOns were unanllHously pa::l~e(l<br />
I. This Mass Meetmg of the Tamil Benellt SO';let.y<br />
held at the Goldberg BiO Hall, Fox b'tte!)t, Johannes-<br />
INDIAN OPINION November 13th, 1925<br />
lJUrg. on tho 2,jth day oC Octobel' ID2'i. hereby<br />
ron.lorses tbe actlO'l of the Tr.tn'lVa,11 BlltJsh Indl.tn<br />
ASf;ocmtJOl.1, in rcc(lr,--~,,o<br />
;~ OUR LONDON LETTER t<br />
~ ([ FROM OUR OWN CORRE~PONDFl~'r ] ~<br />
\If ~th October. In:>. 'If<br />
o
November 13th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 293<br />
---'-------~ -~~--- ------------..:...::~<br />
absolute equality, anll ghing up tbc attitude of<br />
colonr superiority. Vl"e mll"t now meet on term~ of<br />
absolute eljuallty with thosl' \\ Lrml \\ e have prevIOusly<br />
regarded afl our inferior:!.<br />
Mr. Shor" Sin~ha, of the foreign department of<br />
the Y.M.C ..A.<br />
I Ulet d nativl' btudfllt m an English<br />
town after a big football match. 'V" saw IJcfore IlS<br />
a mass of drunken swmrmg p('opl('. The student<br />
tllrn('d to me and ('xcl,lImed, Good God, II'! this the<br />
race in whosc hands God has placed the destiny<br />
of my pt'ople.<br />
Emma Goldman who iii an ananhist and revulutioDlst,<br />
was dl'ported in 1 ~ 1 ~I from Am('rica to)<br />
HnR",ia, has just brought out bel" !J.t(>bt book ('ntitleJ<br />
"My IJit,illusionment in HIl8SIJ." It HI in f-xposure<br />
of Bolshevist tyranny, but it iii qllestIOnable whether<br />
it will find its way into the hbr,tries of those who<br />
ha\e ('arJier wl"ltings as a rcvolutionll:!t.<br />
Sir Willidm Joynson lIicks the Horne SecreLlry,<br />
is reported as saying at Liverpool, that on the Commumat<br />
menace he could not ask hit; Govermnent to<br />
legi~J.lte in advance of public opmion. It ,\,~S (hflicult<br />
for an English Caumel Mmister to usc (hpl~<br />
JDatic language in refc·rrmg to a Government, wLose<br />
agents were engaged in grtting- through Bl'it.lm's<br />
bulwark of Sdmty in an ende.lvour to destl"OY the<br />
the British Empire. Hut, he coul,l say this, If<br />
necessary His Majesty's Government would be prepared<br />
to put before Parholment a revi~ion of the<br />
laws so as to bring them up to date to deal effectIvely<br />
WIth the positIOn created by the CommunIsts.<br />
Whatexer penalty Parliament mIght seek to Pllt on<br />
on the Commull1!lt game, It would have the greatest<br />
respect for the traditional freeuom of the country<br />
and the rIght of free speech,<br />
At the New Education Conference at Heidelberg<br />
in August, at whkh '2S Ndt:ons were represented,<br />
Professor Marcault (Fromce) at Its final meetlng<br />
pleaded for humanism bt'fore natlonahsm, and IS<br />
reported to have said "A httle German child pnts<br />
her hanrl into mine; at that moment I am not<br />
French, she is not German; we are just human<br />
beings united by our mutual need of love."<br />
Golden Service is a phrase no doubt famih.1r to<br />
most people, but it has now been put to a novel use,<br />
but Ilone the less in a happy sense. Mr. S. l\I.lrgetson<br />
has had ill his employ Mr. F. Williams for ,iO<br />
years. Mr. Mal·gdson has been pleased to insert a<br />
notice in the Press teslIfymg to the faithful service<br />
of his employee, as coachman, chaffeur 3THl frif'nd.<br />
as a Golden Service announcement. ~IJ-. :'.Iargetson<br />
has also in a tangible manner shown his appreCl:ltion.<br />
Mr. Wilh,lOlS has not only been boy and mom<br />
in the licnice of hiS master, but has prospeled under<br />
hiw, as the head of his own household. In these<br />
times when there is such a conflict between thb<br />
interests of Capital and r., .. bour, Master and Servant,<br />
this GoiUl'n Ser"ice Announcement comes as a<br />
timely reminder of what may be the rule rather<br />
than the exception of the relations between mJ.Ster<br />
and serv-ant. Here. there "as not merely the relationship<br />
of master and servant, but what is more<br />
they were friends. And this friendship can be hut<br />
the result of understanding, and a spirit of give .1nd<br />
take.<br />
The European Allies with Germany holye met at<br />
Locclrno, and are now bUSily engaged in "hammering"<br />
out a security Pact. for the maintenance of<br />
Peace in Europe. It will be interesting to learn the<br />
terms of the Pact, when it becomes a fact, anll the<br />
question tholt arises uppermo!'t in one's mind is, by<br />
what sanctIons will the tern:s of the PdCt be enforced,<br />
it must be either by peaceful arbitration. or<br />
by an appeal to the Go(l of battles. And yet it does<br />
seem strange thlit Brih11ll should have been the foremost<br />
party. to oppMe the proposeu Geneva Plotocol<br />
atI pdrt of th~ machinery ot tblf Lea;;ue of ~atiolls.<br />
The Protocol. if it had been adopted would have<br />
concerned the regulation of world questions, the<br />
Sec nrity Pdct "ill only regulate European questions.<br />
I:!ntolin refu"r~,l to be a party to the Protocol because<br />
to erJi
INDIAN OPINION November 13th, 192~<br />
Random Thoughts<br />
(BY • RAMBLER' )<br />
A Noble Thought<br />
Dr. Rabtndranath Tagore haa the true universal<br />
spirit, we signify the capacity to realise otherlil in<br />
one's self, or in other peoples' skin. This is not<br />
really as easy to do as it sounds. How many of us<br />
can really put ourselves in the opponent's position?<br />
If we could really do so, we shall soon be rooting<br />
out jealousy, anger and all forms of distemper born<br />
of an incapacit;1 to see the opposite viewpoint. In<br />
the Bibl~, It is reoorded of Christ at one plac~ that<br />
while his disciples and He were approaching a city's<br />
gates, they saw the carcass of a dog. The disciples<br />
saw only the ugly carcaSs and felt repulsed, whlle<br />
the Master said: What beautiful and pearl.like<br />
teeth it has I TWa is quoted as an example of how<br />
high-minded souls see heauty in all things. The<br />
same idea is attempted to he expressed hY' the<br />
c~uplet :<br />
" Two persons saw throllgh the Windows. One<br />
saw the stars and tha other the mind. "<br />
'"<br />
In the Mahabharat,-the great Hindu epic, it is<br />
recorded that the high.minded Dharmaputra was<br />
commissioned by Krishna to go round the world<br />
and find one evil-minded person. At the same<br />
time, the evil-minded Duryodhana. was commissioned<br />
by Krishna to find a single good' soul. Both Dharmaputra<br />
and Duryodhana failed in their respective<br />
missions. The former found the world full of good<br />
souls while the latter saw everywhere only evil<br />
thoughts and evil action. Who was right and who<br />
was wrong? Both were right and both were wrong.<br />
The answer may seem paradoxical but it is the only<br />
right answer; for in the world there is no unmixed<br />
evil or good. and to the extent that both Dharma<br />
Plltra and Duryodhana thought that the world was<br />
absolutely good 01' absolutely e"n they were both<br />
wrOl1g.<br />
Tagore's Poem<br />
I now give below the gem from Tagore's poems<br />
which gave ris9 to the thoughts reoorded above. No<br />
commentary is needed on Tagore's poem to draw<br />
attention to its beauty. It is beauty itself.<br />
The Scavenger<br />
Why do they shun your touch, my friend, and call<br />
you unclean<br />
Whom cleanlinells follows at ev&ry step makmg the<br />
earth and air sweet for our dwelling,<br />
and ever luring us back from return to the wild?<br />
You help USi like a mother her child, into freshness<br />
and uphold the truth, that disgust is never for man.<br />
The holy streatn 6f your ministry carries pollutions<br />
awar And ever remains pure.<br />
011ce Lord Shtva had saved the world from a deluge<br />
of poison by taking it himself<br />
And you save it every day from filth with the same<br />
divine slifterance.<br />
Come friend, oome my hllro, give us courage to<br />
sei've ttlllD, even while bearing the brand of infamy<br />
from him.-RABINDRAN.A.TH TAGORE.<br />
BOOKS FOR SALE<br />
---<br />
'tb be ebtllinlld from the Indian apinton Press, Phamix,<br />
!bti!.l. l'llstal Otdets to be m"de payable at Durban.<br />
Tho HOIi. Mr. Gokhale and the IndeDture S,stem a 0<br />
11.1111&12 110m. au II, b, 14. K. aal2dbl 'j 6<br />
'"<br />
A Book-and its Misnomer<br />
Bagavad Gita. Mrs. Besant's Translation<br />
Asiati~8 Registration Amendment Act (1908)<br />
in English and Gujarati<br />
Hindu Socialldeah, Ly P. J. Mehta<br />
Rise and Growth of Bombay Municipal Govt.<br />
Agricultural Industries in India<br />
Tbp. Story of the Ramayana, the EpIc of Rama<br />
o<br />
a 6<br />
a 6<br />
4 6<br />
2 6<br />
2 6<br />
A Study in Indian Economics, by P. Bannerji 4 6<br />
Tbe Indians of South Atrica, by H. S. L. Polak a 0<br />
Lile of M. K. Gaodhi (in Tamil) 2 6<br />
The Golden Number of" ludian Opinion"<br />
Paper covers<br />
Bound in Clotb<br />
Speeches on Indian Affairs, by J oho Morley<br />
The Hon. Mr. Gokhale's Tour in South Alrica :<br />
Special INDIAN OPINION Souven;rr.<br />
The Ethics of Passive Resistance<br />
(<br />
Essay on Indian Economics, by Mahadev<br />
Govind Ranade<br />
Hindu Psalms and Hymns<br />
Vaishavite Reformers of India<br />
2 6<br />
3 6<br />
.3 6<br />
2 6<br />
.3 0<br />
.3 3<br />
6<br />
% 6<br />
M. K. Gandhi and tbe South African<br />
Indian Problem o<br />
Aspecs of the Vedanta I 6<br />
Essays on Indian Art, Industry and Education a 6<br />
Sri Madhwacharya I 6<br />
Hinduism, by Dr. Barnett a 6<br />
Position of the WomeD in tbe Vedas 6<br />
Vernaculan as Media 01 Instruction in<br />
Ionian Schools and College,<br />
Essentials of Hinduism<br />
Dadabhai Naorojl" Speeches and Writiogg<br />
Indian National Congress<br />
The Madras Congress and Conferences<br />
Allahabad and Nagpur Congresses<br />
The Surat Congress and Cooleronco8<br />
The Improvement of Indian AgrIculture<br />
The Congress Conferences aDd Conventions<br />
India'S Untouchable Saints<br />
For India's Uplift, by Anne Besant-<br />
The Governance of India, by Govind Das<br />
Sri RamanuJacharya<br />
Sri Sankaracharya<br />
Mr. Gandhi's Speeches and Writings-Il!96 to 1917<br />
BIOGRAPHIIIS OP EMINENT INDIANS:-<br />
Dadabhai Naoroji. Gopal Krl.hna Gokhale, Rabindrll.<br />
oath Tagore, M. K. Gandhi, Budruddln Tyabjl<br />
Pundit Madan Mohan Malaviya, The RIght Hon<br />
Sayed Amlr Ali, H. H. Sri Sayaji Rao Gaekwar,<br />
Sir Sayed Ahmed Khan, H. H. the Aga Khan,<br />
Swami Rama TITath, V. Knshnaswami Alyar, Krista<br />
Das Pal, Dewan C Rangacharlu, W. C. BOnneTjea,<br />
A M. Bose, Ravi Varma, Kashmath Trimbak Telang,<br />
Swami Vlvekan"ada, Toru Dutt, Ishw., Chandra<br />
Vldyasagar, SlrSalsr Jung, V. P. Madhava Rao. D. E.<br />
Wacha, Sri Ramaknshna Paramabamsa, Sir Phemzesbll<br />
L.~ehta, Rahlmtulla Mohamed Sayan!, Dr. R""h<br />
Behar! Ghos-, Nawab l\IohslO-ul.Mulk, Sir C. San.<br />
karan Nair, Lal Mohun Gbose, Raja Ram Mohan<br />
Roy, Behramjl M. Malabari, Mrs. Anne Resant,<br />
Elihu SlItendranath nanetJtIll Rao Blhadllf R.I!N.<br />
MIIOlket.<br />
IIcb<br />
4<br />
1 6<br />
6 0<br />
8 0<br />
6<br />
II 6<br />
I 0<br />
2 6<br />
2 0<br />
2 0<br />
3 6<br />
7 6<br />
2 6<br />
:2 6<br />
3 ' 9
No. 47-Vol. XXIII. Friday, November 20th, 1925.<br />
B.·,lStered at the G. P.O ••• a H_ .. paper<br />
PalOS I'ooa.8'at..<br />
SOUTH AFRICAN INDIAI~ CONGRESS<br />
FIFTH SESSION AT CAPE TOWN<br />
"Tf'lIIl~ fifth sepsion of the Sonth AfrICan Indmn<br />
II COIl'.(Tl·IH was opened by the ~I.lyor, Mr.<br />
W. F. FIHh, at the Clty Helll, C.1pptown. A.<br />
l.uge number of Indi.1nH were pl'e"lpnt, tllf' grcdter<br />
pOI'tlOn of the main hall bem/{ filled, a'l we'll as the<br />
many tiprll of seats on the pldtform.<br />
JInndrt'tillof telegram'! conveym'..: mf~s.~ag'el of sympathy<br />
and cbeer wet'e recClved from UflNociattons and<br />
individu.1lH throughout the country as well aA Indklw<br />
A 8hmf of these cablf's and telf'grams W,1'1 exhibited<br />
and some were rpad. One cable from l\f,lhatma<br />
(j,lIldhi read: .. "VIBh Congl'cbH BUCCC'b:l ; have courage."<br />
(J,oud appl.1usf>.)<br />
Various tele/,,'Taml:! received from N.1tal RupportIn~<br />
the aims and objects of the Congrf'Ps wt're mcln,Ipd<br />
fl'om the uBKoCl.1tions find iwltvldll,lIs VIZ, MeS~ltl.<br />
O. II. A. Jhaveri, EdItor,,; 'lIlHlh,' A M. Omal',<br />
Amoll D.1wooll & Coy, Ebrahim 13 t~~ I, M D. MOtdtl,<br />
Tunal Bros, S,lyC'tI Flikroodeen, Hoosen Khan. A.<br />
H. 1\:.1)1), Tanul 1\Llha S tbha, Suburban IIll1di<br />
S.luha, l\Iiankhan anti Emmamally, I3.t~',t Ltd,<br />
Am,ou Hatrejee, 13. ]\f. Singh, ]\f. C D 111.1,<br />
Otlman I3I'OS., l\1.mlOojee l\'Iof)sa, Patielar U mon,<br />
Hurat Hindu AflAoC'iatwn, Kathiaw,\f Ary,~ l\I"nd,tl,<br />
Parsnram Tailors As~oci'ltlOu, Hmdu T,tlllil Institute,<br />
Bombay Presidency Association. Iwlt,1ll Women<br />
ARsoliation, Younl.( Mpn's Vcdic Society, Lec1c;l1El<br />
Nou-Ellrepe:m Auxlhary, .JnnctlOn Chll wool1 CongrtWl,<br />
Manning' Pl.lCe Inlli,m A~soci,ltJon, K.1kni<br />
An,iuman, Suburban Retail De,ll!'r;;, aUlI Zoroastll,m<br />
Anjnman.<br />
l\l,IllY letters of rrgrC't for abspnco were alqo rt'MI<br />
from prominent citJ)lPlls. OnC' of the It,ttf'rR was<br />
fl'om Mr. Morris Alexander 1\1 L.A. who Eul>! -<br />
•. I vt'ry Illuch rpgret, th.lt I am nnahle to be<br />
p)'esl'ut at the opening c('remony ot the Fifth SNl~\o1l<br />
of the South Afril\m In,han Conlrrl'ss on 1\fonlI.lY<br />
evening. . . .. I wish the Conference every 8UOcc~s.<br />
I am SOrI y to sce signs of tIlsllIlion among<br />
i4l'CtiullS of the Iudi,la commumty evcrywhelt.l In<br />
South Atric.1. It is .ILove all nece:lS,lry to present .1<br />
nniteu front anu to apt'olIe wlth one vOice. I hC.\1 tlly<br />
agree. with the sugg'f'stlon of a Round 'f.lble ConfC'rence<br />
at which Gn·.1t lll'ltain, India antI South<br />
Africa wIll be repl'l'sC'u.d. 'fhe solution of the<br />
pI'obIl'm mll"t be songht in the (,,11m ,ltmo~phel'e of<br />
the ConfC'rence Chamber antl a JUilt solution mllst<br />
be found ...<br />
In opcning the CongrC'tl'! the 1\I.1YQr of C,lpe Town<br />
~"tid :-<br />
.. I IMve hNm askl'd to open thIS irnport.lnt Congrpss<br />
tillS t'vening, and I have consPllteu to .10 flo) bC'<br />
C.lIIS(" as Mayor, I l'l'prE'sl'nt all claS'lt?s of lhe ('omlnunity<br />
iI 1'('''lIl'Otl\ t' of r,lC~ or crep,!. In"", I nc,t<br />
necf'stl,lI'lly be in a!-,'Tt:'C'll1ent "\\11th yon or 1,ll'lItliy<br />
myself WIth your v\Cws oC'colllse I mn Pl rf..rmlng<br />
thlS cerC'Ulony. But I know you repr'·",'nt very<br />
large vested lllterests in tht:' Union of ~outh AfrIo~<br />
I know also tholt you ,u-.~ 1'.11 t Ull(1 P,t! cd pf !l1C' IITC It<br />
lllltish Empire, and as buch-l'ecogni"lllg the huerty<br />
of the gre.lt lllltl~h Commollwl,llt h-you haH' t:'yC'l y<br />
light to disC'uss matt"I'S l'OnCernlllg your well-lwing<br />
all\l future St,ltU" in Sout.h Afric,l.<br />
•• Tho Indians have Leen ill South .\.ftieJ. :linee<br />
the year 18GO, dll,l no one will deny, they have<br />
been good and Idw-llHdmg people. They are an intplhgent<br />
anti tlll'lfty people. During the Great<br />
Wdr Illllid supphed Its full quota of men, and these<br />
men fought well and bravely. They rallied to the<br />
Empu'e 111 the hour of need, and acquitted themsE'lves<br />
like men, ,m.} hecause (If this alone they have<br />
e.lliletl the right of freely expreasing their views and<br />
pubhdy diRcussmg matters 1Il which their interest~<br />
are involved.<br />
" It is not for me to express an opinion as to the<br />
glOunds of YOlll' /lllevances; these I must leave to<br />
you to Ul.3CUSS idll'ly, and, I trust, dispassionately,<br />
for, I sllbmit, nothing is ever gained by immoder,ltf'<br />
J,mgll.1L(t'. More is achieved by diplomacy<br />
,IllU cazeflllly thr)Ught-out argument.<br />
Exercise Patience<br />
" I h,tve no dOllbt a greolt deal of the trouble is<br />
due to lack of 1I11IIel·l:!t.inumg, and whilst you ask<br />
the ::-loath Aflie LIlol to ex~rCl8e patience, may not<br />
you be reason,llJly a..,ked to practise the save virtue?<br />
Perbon.Jlly, I do not consIder onr differences are due<br />
to prejudice. I.lIn proud to number among my<br />
friends m.Juy men ot Ea.stern natlOnality for whom<br />
I iI,tve the VeJ'y WM'mest regolrd.<br />
.. The, e may b~ dIfficulties of immigration, but,<br />
surely, the"!I' .lre no more sever~ than the immigratIOn<br />
l.lws of ArnCllCd.? Who of us have not read<br />
of thp treatment which men reCClve at Ellis Island?<br />
Rightly, or wrow:;y, n.1tions consid()r they hive the<br />
right to reHtrict tlw number of immigrants to their<br />
fl'hl)L>cti ve conn trl\ 8, I t cannot be right to allow unrl'stt'ictetl<br />
iIl1rnigr,ltlon into a country. Governments<br />
mnst protect theIr pl'ople or there is the danger of<br />
an ahC'll po[ml,ltwll squeellrely, tli('y, too, must be protected against<br />
mdl::,rnmin.1te llllllugration.<br />
.. We mn"t not ue too eager to blame the Governmeot<br />
of the lolnd.<br />
This IS a difficult question. Per<br />
~9_6 __ ~,~ ________________ IN __ D_I_A_N-,O __ P_IN __ IO~N~ ____ ~N~o~ve=m~b~e~r~2o~t~h'~I9~2~5~<br />
dllty WI Md.yor to perform thil'l ceremony. 1 hope<br />
yO\1, will ha-ve a sIlcceSSfl11 OongresB-all interchllnge<br />
of {deAs iii alWa1i1 good--and I feel ceZ'u.in of this:<br />
11 \vI'ong has been done, tMt wrong will be righted.<br />
But, as I say, discuss everything in moderation. The<br />
pitiful plight of some parts in Europe to-day is due<br />
primarily to immoderate speech su pported by wild<br />
fat1a.tictsm-=-the l'(!Butt hlUJ been chaos I<br />
" I know the Indian community to be honest,<br />
sober and law-abiding. I need say no more." (Applause.)<br />
The Presidential address then followed, the fuU<br />
text of which is published elsewhere in this issne.<br />
The Vlsitmg delegates were then welcomed by<br />
Mr. M. "Y,. Hawa, President of th~ Cape British In.<br />
dian Council.<br />
Mr . .A.dvt>cll.~ J. W. Qodfrey replied on behalf of<br />
tlie Natal delegates and ill the course of his remarks<br />
sll.id that notwtthstAnding that he had the quallficatiotls<br />
ot an :fi1ngliBh barrister-at-law he was debl1rred<br />
from exercising the Parliamentary vot.e. The<br />
pOlliUan of IndiaIls, he said, was rendered very<br />
gl'aVll by the Aslatiu Bill and that a delegation would<br />
~ve t6 be sent to hldia to give our Mother-country<br />
th~ trt1th. ,. Voteless We tilay be but voiceless<br />
never !" said the speaker amid loud applause. :Mr.<br />
Godfre~ then mewed the adoption of the Presider.tial<br />
add.r'eas.<br />
:Mr. A. A. Mirza 1'apl'esenting the 'rransvaal uetegaWs<br />
seconded Mr. Godfrey'S motion.<br />
Or. A. Abdurahman<br />
Dr. A. Abdurahman, who next spoke, was enthusiastically<br />
receIved. He warned his hearers not<br />
ttl follow his Ildvice but that of their leader, Dr.<br />
Gool, as he, the speaker, was a "fil'ebl'and." Referril'l.g<br />
to the spirit uf nationality he said "When Britons<br />
sing they 'never will be sla"es,' to a very large<br />
extent that spil'it is a Very admirable one; it intends<br />
to improve a people, but. carried too fat: it tends to<br />
le:td to what hawened in Europe a. few years ago."<br />
When there was no softening and tempering m<br />
fifit'lnce ~ re'ligi:on and Christianity about. that spirit<br />
of na'tionality it aiways led to Mthing but wa.r.<br />
Itt; assltrtld his hearers that they had the full sl1Ppot't<br />
of the tlOlot1red people of this country. (Cheers).<br />
Mr. A. I. Rajee then moved a 'Vote of thanks to<br />
th~ Mayor which was passed with acclatnation.<br />
Itl !l.oool'dance ~ith a resolution pl1sse'd at last<br />
ytlat's Conference the Presidetit after ettlogising the<br />
sElrViceS 'Of Mr. V. S. C. Pather as hon. Genetll.l<br />
S~eta1'y of th-e South African Indian Oongrest;<br />
presented hitt!. in recognition thereof with a beaut!<br />
fb.i l~ther attache case.<br />
The Conference then adjottt'ned oIl the motion of<br />
Mi'. bl1Wa01l of KitnbElrly with the singing of the<br />
N1ttional Ant.hetn tin the fonoWin~ day. ,<br />
PrOteedings Of The Following Days<br />
On Tuesday aud Wednesday (10th and 11th instant)<br />
with night sittings hUll o'clock and -Thursday<br />
till 1-30 p.m. the proceedings of the Conference<br />
t60'k ~lace iii the Fidelity Hall, Primrose Street. 'On<br />
Ttlesda.~ M;jtQ :t.m. the Hall Wall filled with delegatee<br />
ail well M'6'htlsideTS who had eome to watch the prO'<br />
ceElliings. AfilN the Mintrtes of ~he previous 'Confel"ebC6!<br />
the Piaancil£l Statement and the Secretary's<br />
rept»:'t 'Ware rflad Il.nd passed 'Various matters affecting<br />
the Indlan com1nunity WiOlre discussed and resolutions<br />
passed thereon. (The 1'e5olutions appear elsewhare<br />
'l'Pl .thlS issue.)<br />
The moat important discu13!non took t>lace on the<br />
Asiatic Bill when speeches were made by the deleg81iea<br />
'9'ery ft!e'ling'ly. There was difference of<br />
opthion Bot OB the ,tn'inciple of the Bill, which was<br />
totll.lly rejected ,by every i3peakel' In the strongest<br />
terms,
November 20th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 297<br />
• South Africa, wlll strive to voice in a moder-dote and<br />
Bober manner, the grievances of our people who are<br />
left witho..t vote and power, in this land of thdr<br />
birth and adoption. We have a Just ('..anse and Wcl<br />
~;;r.ll endeavour not to jeopardise our position by<br />
VIOlent and revolutionary methods, which can only<br />
hlghtcn the tension and etimllidte the prejudice<br />
against DR.<br />
Perhaps it Is only proper, that this important<br />
8e!ll!ion of our CongreM should take place in Cape<br />
Town, the mother City of South Africa, and to a<br />
certain extent, still the home of liberty and just<br />
trootment of the non-Europe.ln. Here in the Cape,<br />
the Europeans still hold sacred the !.'feat tradItions<br />
of the BrItish people-justice and fairplay to the<br />
Coloured man-and I trust will never bow their<br />
heads In shameif-lls submission to th-) reactionary<br />
and un-Christian Doctrine of the North "No equality<br />
in State and Church between Black and White. "<br />
Unfortunately the propaganda of hate, calumny<br />
and misrepresentation against the Indian is fast<br />
spreading l':louthward. Anti-Asiatic Leagups, associations<br />
and societies, supported by the leading<br />
newspapers with glaring headlines and leading<br />
articles are doing their worst to damage the positiOa<br />
of the Indian. All over South Africa the Europeans<br />
are being awakened to a sense of grave danger, and<br />
even the sanE' and sober attitude of the Cape European<br />
is becoming slowly undermined by this spirit<br />
of prejudice and intolerance.<br />
But in IIpite of this clamour of selt-interest, in<br />
H)24 Imlians looked hopefully to the Bouth African<br />
Party Government under the able leadership of<br />
General Smuts for protection and fairplay. However,<br />
they were disappointed when Mr. Patrick<br />
Duncan brought forward hiB Class Areas BIll. The<br />
faU of the Smuts Government, howenr, prevented<br />
that Bill from bE'coming the law of the land. Hope<br />
sprung anew in the breasts of our people, when in<br />
the Mm. fE'ar the Hertzog Government was formed,<br />
but again they were doomed to disappointment.<br />
This time the death-knell of their very existence<br />
was sounded by the iniqnitous BIll fathE'red by the<br />
Rpv, Dt'. Malan Minisf.(-r of the Interior,<br />
This hydra-headed Bill enforces compuls01'Y segregation<br />
in residence and trade, restricts immigration,<br />
curtails domiciliary rights and tightens the Asiatic<br />
Registration Act of the Transvaal.<br />
First with regard to the reservation of areas as<br />
embodied in the Bill, I should hke to draw your<br />
attention to the fact that at present an Indian enjoys<br />
the right to buy, lease or lIellland in Natal and the<br />
Capo Province, unlike hi& poor unfortunate brother<br />
in the Tnlnsvaal, who can only lease property in<br />
certain reBtll'Ved areas or a location.<br />
The first chapter of this Bill compels Indians to<br />
reside and. trade in specially aUoted areas. No<br />
matter what their financial position or sOOial standing,<br />
only in these' special areas will the Indians be<br />
permitted to live, trade or buy and sell property.<br />
All businesses existing outside that area shall cease<br />
at the expiration of the prcsent lease or at the death<br />
of the present lessee.<br />
It 1urther empo,vel'S the Governor-General to<br />
proclaim. that in the Province of Natal, no Indian<br />
shall be able to buy or lease l,md, except from another<br />
Inuian, and only within 30 miles of the Coast.<br />
But it wonld appear from the wording of the Bill,<br />
that us soon as the Governor-General procl,lims this<br />
Indian belt, the Urban Authorities, outside the 30<br />
miles limit will lose the power they are glven in<br />
this very Bill to proclaim class areas, As a result<br />
Indians, in Natal, outside this zone, will lose their<br />
present vested rights to reside and trade, whether<br />
they al'e in rural or urban areas. It h.ls been estimated<br />
that nearly 700 licences wili be expropriated.<br />
It is expropriation without compensation; in other I<br />
words, simple confiscation.<br />
Besides thiS, tho Governor.General br proclama.<br />
tion can extend or reduce these class areas. This<br />
means thdt even in these locations the Indians will<br />
not enJoY,this security of tenure essential to their<br />
well-being and development.<br />
The policy of racial segregation has been rightly<br />
condemned by all truly civilised meR. It brands<br />
the segreg
INDIAN OPINION November 2?th. 1925<br />
\<br />
who actually suffer from Indian competItIon are a<br />
few of the s~all shop-keepers. Is it then for the<br />
benefit of these few that thousands of the poor are<br />
to be exploited and fieecerl? and is it because of<br />
a narrow selfish class of white traders, often<br />
foreigners and aliens themselves, that the whole<br />
foundation of the British EmpIre is to be endangered?<br />
This Bill also dbals the Indlan a cruel and unjust<br />
blow, in that drastic changes,are to be made in the<br />
Immigration laws of the country. The general<br />
question of immigration of Indians has been practically<br />
settled. With the 0xception of a few Indian<br />
teachers and priests for the Transvaal, minor children<br />
and wives of IndIan settlers, the doors of the<br />
country are barred against the Indian for ever. We<br />
sti1!::feel the injustice of this Immigration law, yet<br />
forl.he sake of those living here, we have 'tacitly<br />
submitted to it. But this Bill gives further powers<br />
to the Immigration Officer whose arbitrary and orten<br />
high-handed actIOns in the past have been severely<br />
critised by several judges.<br />
Again to keep up this form of oppression against<br />
the Indian, the distrICts of Utrecht and Vryheid,<br />
although part of Natal now, are to be consIdered, as<br />
flJr as the Transvaal, so that the Draconian laws of<br />
the Transvaal could be applied to the Indians in<br />
these distrICts. Such Gilbertian legIslation IS unheard<br />
of outside free South Africa. If it is the<br />
intention of getting rid of the Indians by hook or<br />
by crook, why not apply such hocus pocus legislation<br />
at once to Natal by enactmg that Natal should<br />
be considered part of Zululand, and as no Indians<br />
are allowed to trade in Zulu land, it follows that all<br />
Indians now in Natal, shall forfeit their right to<br />
trade. Why stop here, Transvaal could be declared<br />
a part of Lappland and all Indians not wearing<br />
heavy fur coats and living in ICe houses should be<br />
immediately deported to Kamchatka which for the<br />
purpose of this Act could be d~clared a part of India.<br />
The Government aimed at beIng dIplomatic and<br />
clever, but succeeded in being only ridICulous and<br />
spiteful.<br />
Besides all these absurdItIes, the BIll boldly<br />
inTades the precIncts of his private life. It attempts<br />
to regulate his marriages by the following clause,<br />
that if he intends marrying in India or bringing his<br />
wife and children back into the Union he must do<br />
so before August 1930 or tJefore 10 years of his first<br />
entry into th-e Union. In future no Indian could<br />
go to India marry and bring back his wife. Surely<br />
every man ha.s the right to marry whom and where<br />
he likes. Some men would sacrifice everythmg<br />
for love, but the majority would like to have their<br />
wives, as well as their businesses. Such proscrIptIOn<br />
dates back to the old days of sll1very, apparently not<br />
this completely eradicated in hIghly civilised land.<br />
The Bill further affects a large number of Inulans,<br />
In that they wIll be compelled to give up their dual<br />
domicile in the Union, a'l many persons hold a<br />
domicile, for instance, In the Transvaal by birth,<br />
and a domicle in Nalal by residence or vice vers.1.<br />
This right of dual domicle wIll cease to exist in three<br />
years, which means th1l.t large vested. mterests In one<br />
or other of the Provinces canuot be controlled by<br />
the ownei' and WIll in many ca.ses spell his financial<br />
ruin. The object of this, apparently, is to eliminate<br />
Indian businesses that m:lY have escaped the flanking<br />
attack of the class areas restrictions.<br />
Again Indians inciudIn1 those born in the Union<br />
by merely absenting themselves from the Union for<br />
a longer period than 3 y(>ars forfeit their domicilIary<br />
rights. Where is a South African born Indian to<br />
go, who absents hImself from the Union for more<br />
than 3 years? I have a brother studying in England.<br />
If he does not return to the Union before<br />
1928, he is debarred from entering the land of his<br />
peopYe. Is this not in conflict with the most elementa.ry<br />
principles of justIce and fairplay?<br />
This concludes a general analysis of this pernicious<br />
Bill, but it by no means covers all the many<br />
clauses which detrimentally aff~0t the Indian now<br />
resident in South AfrIca. .. '<br />
Why do the Europeans consider the IndIan unfit<br />
for decent society and unworthy of just aud eqUlt,-,<br />
able treatment? First they contentl that the In-'<br />
diana in Natal tire sufficiently large 10 number to<br />
become a menace, being HO,Ollo to 170,(1)(1 Ellropeans.<br />
That the small trader h:u been practically<br />
eliminated and Indians will expect to work besides<br />
Europeans in the skilletl or semi-skilled trades 01' in<br />
offices, which WIll create in their breasts a feehn" of<br />
equality with the Europeans, which IS largely'" obnoxious<br />
and against the very basis of a domlU>lnt<br />
White South Africa.<br />
1\fy answer to thiS iii that the Inllans have created<br />
by their sweat and tOll, the fou'ldation of N 11.:\1'S<br />
present prosperity. Sugar, Tea, Fruits and many<br />
other co.nmoditles have been cultivated by the Indian<br />
at miserable wages. The big profiti h,1ve gone<br />
mto the Dockets of enterprising planters an,1 other<br />
ca.pitalists and lOtO the coffers of the Province, turning<br />
it from the verge of blnkrllptcy into tn \t of<br />
great prosperity.<br />
The Indian population is practic
November 20th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 299<br />
to hordo together, rich and poor, vul~"llr and refined,<br />
, cultured and ignorant. What power has the Indian<br />
to prevent IIlums? What hope has he of keeping<br />
pace with the march of civilisation?<br />
""gain the Europeans contend that Indianfl being<br />
d a different creeli have lowpr morals than Europeans.<br />
' This kind of religious prejudice is typical of the<br />
medieval reli~,'ious intolerances, and this is no place<br />
to ~ntf'r into religIOus controvE'rsiell, suffice it that<br />
the Ilame arguments have hopn used in those times,<br />
an
300 INDIAN OPINION November 20th, 1925<br />
\<br />
Resolutions<br />
The following resolutions were passpd by the<br />
South African IndJan Congress at its fifth Sl'ssion<br />
held in Cape Town on the 9th, 10th, 11th and 12th<br />
instant under the deputy-presl
November 20th, 1925 I NDIAN OPINION 301<br />
and it is soggl'1lted that it be Fe(lacoo to such<br />
sum as i. found usually to ,..ov(>1' the costs of<br />
appeals b"fore the Immigranta' Appeal Board.<br />
(j) That women examiners to the ImmigJ'Stion<br />
DE'partment be appointed to meet thf' reHginus<br />
susceptibihties of Indians in regard to their<br />
~;I women.<br />
That Waiting Rooms be provided for women<br />
in the Immib'l"'dtion Offices.<br />
(k) That in regard to transit permits Immigration<br />
Officers be instructed to exercise their discretion<br />
in the extension of snch permits on reaaonable<br />
grounds and not on medical gronnda<br />
alolJe.<br />
(1) That 118 Will understood at the time of the<br />
passing of Immigrants' Regulation Act, Natalborn<br />
Indians and Cape-bern Indiana shonld<br />
be allowed to retum to their respe:ltive Provinces<br />
on the production of their birth<br />
c.rtificates.<br />
(m) That instructions to the Principal Immigration<br />
Officer, Durban, to restrict the time limit for<br />
the intro
302 INDIAN OPINION<br />
20. Having regard /9 evils ktcp,l to alcoholIc<br />
drink, this Congress includes in It" policy ot work<br />
the lending of activo support to au V movement for<br />
the discouragement of the consumptIOn of .1lcohohc<br />
liquor, and further that each Provincial body with<br />
its district committees be called upon to give elfect<br />
to this resolution wherever possible. (Propohed by<br />
Mr. A. H. M. Tilly and seconded by Mr. D. K. Patel.)<br />
21. That the Natal Indian CougreRs act With full<br />
powers as local committee to the Houth AfrIcan Indian<br />
Congress With the co-optratlon ot the honoran'<br />
general secretary of the South African Indun COIlgress<br />
for the purpORC of making ,lllllecessary arrangf'<br />
ments for the holdIng of an In,lt,lU Agricultural<br />
and Industrial Show III Durban. (Proposed by 1\11.<br />
Sorabjee Rustomjee and seconlled hy Mr. Jple and repre"entatlve~ of:-\ .\. 1. Congr~,'!<br />
in Older to brmg ar).)ut a final an'i amicable settlemellt<br />
of the Indun que.t~n.<br />
The MIUlsterd reply, although (h.appfllutlo;, was ,ery<br />
clear. It was III elfe·~t tIllS ,-fh'lt the S,lluts-Gandhl<br />
a'J'rcement refferred only to ttu th~n e.l:l3tlu6 11 v, ani<br />
~ , h<br />
It II ,l~ .0 put
November 20th. 1925 IN 01 AN OPINION 303<br />
the agreement, were mspecWl4 eVia ,.,J.ea aeqlAiud<br />
ille~ally ; .. hat. t1u GoverDIll'lnt. Were practically nnaoimous<br />
a' regards the principle of the Bill which therefore<br />
conld not be cbangrd; ~hat. the C.>\,ernment coold not<br />
j'igllOl'e the deaire of the Eoropeau otI!, a "ko~; ,haft all<br />
the constractive crIticism received by the GO"emmen~<br />
goes to show that the Bill does IIOt. go Car enOllgt,; that<br />
if OQIlIlt.mati V'8 luggest.Wo. wen to be made ~y the [ndian<br />
community as to the detaile of tM lbll r.hey 'ItOll:d<br />
receive ,he COllllideratioD of tbe GoVerR1DeIlG; tbar. ii WIUI<br />
t.he IOtention of the Minister of the [uteriot to refer the<br />
Bill to a Select Committee and Indians would b!! given<br />
full opportunity of stating their case.<br />
'Vith regard to the suggestion or a Rouud Table Conference,<br />
the Minister's reply was tbat the first snggestion<br />
of such a Confer.enc!! came from Mr. Thoma~, daring his<br />
vialt t4 the U Ilion, b~ that. a good maDY papers grotest.ed<br />
agaiost the auggsioo. thai; the ladiau ~ut ~en<br />
8Ilked for a. Round Table Conferf.'D~ aDd the qoeat.iOll<br />
was not settled, bat, that .IIegotiatioos hetwten the ln~<br />
dian and the U Dion Governments had not reached<br />
finality and it was therllfor!! not pOS3ibl~ to ma:re 1.,<br />
annollllcemen~ in colluection therewrth. thaL it was<br />
eIptlcted toaL the negotiations would conc/llde very<br />
sltortty and the realllt weuld t.hen be anDOI.1IIoed.. Tb<br />
Minister aiM !tated tbat the Go~rnHtent COltSi1Iered t~<br />
Iwlian qlleM1U>1I. t.o be on. which aad w be :8Qlved Ity<br />
lIhe 80llth African Government. and people wi~ outside<br />
interference but tbat representations may be made<br />
from ontllide.<br />
From this reply there ill no doubt bet as to the intention<br />
of the G01llIDJnellt ill regard to the AiiAtlC Bill,<br />
bnt there ia a tiLde doubt as to wboth.·r it. is prepared to<br />
call a Round Table Conference or not. The resnlt of<br />
the negotiaLiooa l>et1reeU the Indin and UnlOn Governments<br />
in this respect Will be awaiLE'd w.th IDterest.<br />
We respectfully beg to differ from the Minister when<br />
he 81l.18 that. the .pmt. of the 1914 Sett.lemeut. ftlrtved at<br />
with the Gortrmnellt has Dot."beim Tiolat!d. The 8pirit<br />
«If the tettlQlIlent wal t.bllt after tilt> Indian community<br />
bad agreed to the stoppage of further Indian Immigrants<br />
entering the Uaion excepting !.he entry of ten<br />
educated Indians annually. the Government would not<br />
introduce any fUither disabhug legislatIOn against the<br />
resIdent Indian populaGiOll and that the existing Is 11'8<br />
would be admiDiMte~ •• ympatbeucaUy. The Government.<br />
DOW "iah to "Ick to the litter of tilEr 8eUlelllent<br />
and to give it the narrowest iuterpretatlOn poSSible BUlted<br />
to tbeir purpose. This attitude on the part oC the Government.<br />
Ct.Ilnot be considered honourable.<br />
We respect the view of the Government that tb. internal<br />
affaira of Saut.h Africa should be settled by the<br />
South African Government aud people, but so lang as<br />
t.be Uuion remains part ot the British Empire, the<br />
Ihethod:s adopted to eettIe those affairs should be oonmteD'<br />
wit~ ahe principles and ideals of the Empire. In<br />
trying to settle the Indian question, the Government is<br />
completely ignoring the feeIingSl of a large section of la,,<br />
abiding citizeD8« 'be Empire and doing I grne injustice<br />
to that section at the bidding of aaotber section<br />
whose dem&Dds are hilil, seltlih ad nnreaPlable. We<br />
realise that the Goverument does not wish to do otherw.se<br />
as it
INDIAN OPINION<br />
November 20th, I925<br />
Petition, Submitted to Union<br />
\<br />
Government by<br />
South African Indian Congress<br />
~o the:Ho:lO~rable the Mmister of the InterIOr,<br />
Pretoria.<br />
SIr,-We, the undersigned, bemg Members of deputlttion<br />
elected at- the Fifth SessIOn of the South AfrICan<br />
Indian Congress assembled III Oonference at Cape Town<br />
from the 9th to the 12th November, 1925, deSire to express<br />
our sinncere thanks for grantlllg this interView.<br />
~'The South ,Afncan Indian Congress, which IS constItuted<br />
of electell rcpreKentatives of the various Provlllces<br />
(if the UllIon BlttIDg III Conference as aforeilald p1ssed,<br />
lIJDong others, the followlllg resJlutIOds -<br />
1. That the South AfrIcan Indian Congress in Con<br />
Conference views with alarm the Areas ReservatIOn<br />
aud ImmigratIOn and RegistratIOn (Further Provi510n)<br />
Bill, whICh IS in violatIOn of the 1914<br />
Gandhi-Smuts agreem~nt and ,vhlCh Bill has for<br />
!ts obJe~t.s the compulsory segregaf,ion of Il)(itans;<br />
the deprIVAtlOu of their propne',ary rights and the<br />
ultimate eitmHlatIOll ol the Cornmnnity as openly<br />
dedaloo by the Mllliste!' of the InterIor, and be~s<br />
to submIt to the Government that on a matter of<br />
prInCIple the Ind'an Community of South Afm .. a<br />
opposes tbif BIll ~n toto.<br />
2. That this Uongress urges upon the U Olon Government<br />
to consent to a R~lln1 Table Conference of<br />
the Union and Impenal GClvernlllent •. the representatives<br />
of India, the Indian Govelllillent and repl'e£entatI,es<br />
of the SOlltl> Afncan Indian Congress<br />
to ~o 181de1' the whole !!lo5ltlon of th3 I ndlans h~re<br />
and arrive at an honourable set~lement.<br />
The tenor of the resolutions clem I) mdICiiltes that the<br />
llillis not :wcejJtable to the Indlan commnnlty because<br />
it is agnlos~ tundamental prmciples of goal cltizenshtp.<br />
Consequenlly it ~~ felt that no good pnrpose could be<br />
served by dlscllssmg It in detail while other gr~at dJificultles<br />
eXist, whIch leqUIre a l]ustment, e.g, questIOns of<br />
Licence~, ImmIgration, E incatIOn etc.<br />
The Indian community are thoroughly dieatisfied as<br />
the Bill undoubtedly lmposes upon them a stIgma of m<br />
feriority. Furl-her the Bill IS contrary to ihe -,plrit of<br />
ue Gandhl-Smuts agreement.<br />
If there l8 an earnest desire on the part of the U mon<br />
Government to arrIve at a satI"ractory setLlement of the<br />
general pOSItIOn affectlllg Indians 1U the U man, then we<br />
feel that thiS could be best achieved bv a Ronnd Table<br />
Conference III accordance with the suggestIOn contained<br />
in the second Resolut.lOn.<br />
Thls belU6' tte view of the C~n£"tC3S, we urge I(S<br />
accrptance upon the Umon Government as a bona fide<br />
desll'e on our part to diSCUSS genclally the wbole slluatIon,<br />
aod brlOg about a thaI and honoura.ble se&tl,:ment.<br />
The Congress IS not aware of any rpa,on why the<br />
Umon Government has not formollly declmed Its llltention<br />
to agree or (hsagr~e to th~ R mnd T d ble Conference<br />
alLhou~h tv has Intimated tuat It ,,"a' III commuDlcatlOn<br />
w th the Indlalil GQ)l'erBment 10 regard thereto; and that<br />
matter.; hai Llk~n a defiat~e conroe.<br />
The C(lllgress realise .. I he n!JC",ol~y there IS for arn\'-<br />
109 at SJme satisfactory unders:anJwg on these vital<br />
qnestlOno; and is preparld to do lls sh4re in !ecurin~ a<br />
settlement consI~t"nt wleh honour.<br />
We respectfully press upon the UDl~n Government our<br />
sincere belwf in good result.s that a Round Table Conference<br />
would bnng about; and trust that the Uni0n<br />
Government Wlll accept anti accede -to the terms of<br />
the second Resolution aforementioned, and in the meantime<br />
stay further progre~, of this Bill.<br />
We have the honour to be,<br />
Sir,<br />
Yours respt'ctfully,<br />
J. \1'". GODFREY, E. M. ALLY, V,H,LEY MAIIFllED,<br />
GOOLA~I RASOOL . .-\)(OD BAYAT, 8HAIK HntEn,<br />
M. A. H. MOOSA, fl. M ~UR'lOO, S. H. ~\lDOO,<br />
MOOLJEE G. PATEl" V. R. C. PATHER, S. EnRAHDI,<br />
A. A. MIRZA, A. E. HlI.FFEJEE, 1\I. M. (1AXDIIl,<br />
SORABJEE RUS'rOllJEI".<br />
Me.nbeis of the Deput~tion of the 8.A .• I. Congr~ss.<br />
A. I. KAJEE,<br />
General Secr~tary,<br />
175, Gtey Street, Durban.<br />
We I'C6ret to announce the sad a.·mlse of ~Ir. Itosan<br />
Kha'1 a prominent Inulan \ierchant at P. M. Burg.<br />
who was one of the be~t workrs III the cause<br />
of the Indian comm.llltv aDd Ins uutimely death<br />
at thiS jun:ture IS very ugfortunate. Mr. Rosen Khan<br />
was the Victim ot the ,,"rea: fire at P. M. Blll'g ou Tuesday<br />
being very serIOusly burnel abollt the hand3 and<br />
lower portion of the body and died late W' cdne3day<br />
lllght, WI:' tender ollr eympilthy to the lelat.lves of<br />
the late 1\11'. RosJu Khan.<br />
F AR,lVI FOR SALE<br />
650 Acres, House, Large Cowsbed~, Calf~he;lg, Stables etc_<br />
20 Acres Planted to BANANAS'" Acres PINEAI'I'LKS<br />
and PAWPAWS, 40 Acres SUGAR CAXE<br />
100 Acres let out to INDIAN TENANTS<br />
2 Permanent Stl eami! of Water. :Fenced Paddoc k<br />
Good Labour Supply<br />
Only fourteen mdes from DURBAN.<br />
Four mlles from Ph
~ ntlta!t ~pittitl1t<br />
----------- -- ------------------------<br />
No. 4~-Vol. XXIII. Friday, November 27th, 192 5.<br />
Itoci.terecl.,lbe G. P.O. u • N ..... ,.<br />
Peloe POO"IUIC.&<br />
1\\ REUTER cablegram from Delhi. datetl Nov.<br />
Li1l 21, gives the information that, with the concurrence<br />
of the Government of South Africa.<br />
the Government of India have decJ(led to s"nd a<br />
deputation to South Africa. Mr. G. F. PaddisoJl,<br />
of the IndJan Civil ServICe and Commissioner of<br />
Labour for Madras will lead the deputation. Of<br />
the remainIng members, six will be announced<br />
shortly.<br />
The main purpose of the deputation, continues<br />
the commumque. will be to collect as Boon as POSSIble<br />
first hand information regarding the economIC<br />
conditIOn and general position of the resident Indian<br />
community in South Africa, and form an appreciation<br />
of their wishes and requit·ements. It is expected<br />
that their report WIll affortl valuable malenll<br />
for the Government of IndIa to lise in connection<br />
with the dlscussions now proceeding between the<br />
two Governments.<br />
------<br />
At 9 a.m. on l\fonuay, the day when the morning<br />
paper published the above pronouncement, the<br />
::;.A. Inihau Congrcbs delegates Balled from Durban<br />
on their mil;sion to India, there being a large crowd<br />
on the wharf to bid them Godspeed. We present<br />
with this issue a portrait supplement of the delegation.<br />
1\11'. E. Norouien, President of the Cape Brltish<br />
Indian Union, a body existing only In nam, inter<br />
,'iewed by Reuter's Agency, saill that the members<br />
of his organisation, while they would oppolle the<br />
108s of any of their present rlghts, and welcometl<br />
the decision of the Union Government to receive a<br />
lleputation from India to discuss the draft Asiatic<br />
Blll, yet on the olher hand they deprecated the<br />
sending of a deputation to India from South Africa,<br />
anll also the inclusion therein of one who is not<br />
himself an Inuian, viz., Dr. Abdurahman.<br />
---------------------------<br />
NOTES AND NEWS<br />
'7"~<br />
That the Ministel' of the Interior, DI. Malan, is<br />
not sati~fietl with the SUppOl t given by the people to<br />
his pro pORed Bill to deal \\ ith the ASIatics. WdS a<br />
stdtement ruatle by ]\fl'. A. F. Fordhdlll. l\I.L.A .• at<br />
a meeting of the Southern Suburbs European Association<br />
at Tnrifontein. Johannesburg. on the 18th<br />
instant, says a Xutul J/I'rt ur!/ telegram. .. Thtl Minister<br />
told me, (he said) that there had been very<br />
little support from Natal, and that the country districts<br />
did not seem to be interested. "<br />
.. It seems to me that the Indians in Natal have<br />
got their clutches so deeply into the land that people<br />
are afraid to dISCUSS them," asserted Councillor H.<br />
Crocker at the same meeting. BUSllless men go to<br />
bed secretly praying that the Bill will go through,<br />
but are afraid to express their thonghts in public.<br />
He pomted out that in the General Dealers~ Control<br />
Ordmance, which had just come into force, there<br />
was an excellent weapon of attack against the Asiatics.<br />
He urged the ASSOCIation to make a note of all<br />
Asiatics' shops in the district, and to oppose their<br />
applicahon for Hcencas under certain sections pro<br />
VIded by the Ordinance.<br />
It was proposed at. the above-tnentioned meeting<br />
to arrange for a South Africa Conference consisting,<br />
of course, entirely of Europeans, to be held in Johanneslmrg<br />
to dISCUSS the Asiatic question, and a<br />
Committee was appointed to investigate and report<br />
on the mjltter.<br />
Mr. G. Hullet, M.P.C., Natal, when asked by a<br />
pressman to state hls opinion regarding the Premier's<br />
Native proposals, said :-" General Hertzog is quite<br />
right m saying that with the Cape Native having the<br />
vote, no Government could withhold the vote from<br />
the Natives of the Transvaal, Free St¥e and Natal,<br />
. and his boldness in grasping the nettle is to be<br />
highly commenllcd. As regards the Cape Coloured<br />
vote. I apprcci.1te the difficulties, but as I am led to<br />
believe this 18 a dlminishmg qnantity, the extension<br />
of the franchise to theslil people who reBide in the<br />
Transvaal and Natal can be viewed with less concern.<br />
The term • Coloured man' mUllt be clearly<br />
defined and must not include the Asiatic or the<br />
Malay ...<br />
The Cape BrItish Indian Union fears more harm<br />
than good is hkely to result from this deputation,<br />
anll while It is entirely opposed to the Asiatic Blli<br />
it hopes to induce the Government to amend it by<br />
excluding tho Cape Province from its scope, as was<br />
done by the Smuts Government m regard to the<br />
Class Areas Bill.<br />
We are gh\d to think that the VIews of Mr. Norodien<br />
are not shared by those outsiue bis small circle.<br />
We shoulll be a"hamed of our Cape community were<br />
they to adopt such a selfish attitude as to ask the<br />
Govt'rnment to exclude the Cape Province from th~<br />
Asiatic Bill.<br />
At the Church Congress held recently in England,<br />
Lord Wilhngdon. who has had 11 years lJ{ adminis.<br />
trative work iu India, f>aid: .. I honestly believe<br />
that if the whole attitude of White races to Colonred<br />
races could be entirely altered, if the While men<br />
would always act in the spirit of giving equality of<br />
opportunity to those who are Coloured, what appeared<br />
to be the aggressive and unreasonable attitude<br />
of CoioUl ed races would entirely change, and<br />
they would be found to be ready to discuM these<br />
important matters in a fair spirit, and with a dne<br />
sense ot all the dIfficulties sUlTounding them ...<br />
Mr. J. H. Oldham. an expert and a public speaker<br />
of a high order, said that many calling them to show<br />
a united White front against people of other colour.<br />
He asserted that a solid White front certainly and<br />
ine~itably meant a solid Yellow front, and solid<br />
Br(}.wn front ... anu a solid Black front; and that in<br />
the end of the day, could have only one meaning.<br />
It meant war. A nd the only way to prevent us<br />
from drifting to that disaster was that men of COut ..
306 INDIAN OPINION November 27th, 1925<br />
age and true vIsion should refuse to be entangled in ,----______________<br />
tile Snarll(:1 of fllcialisJP. and a purely rarial way of , I THE QUEEN MOTHER -,<br />
lo()kin~ at questions, and should strive everywhere ((~ UEEN Alexandra, the Queen Mother, offln4<br />
always to enSllre thtl triuJP.ph of the claims of ~ ten spoken at as Alexandra the Good,<br />
humanity and justice, even when such striving<br />
brought them into opposition with men of theIr<br />
paseed peacefully away on the 20th<br />
own race. .. Who may more fitly take the lead in instant, at i::)andringham. Her's WdS a be .. mtiflll<br />
rendering this SerVl\)e so indispensable to the future ~lfe whlCh calls for no regrets. As Primes:! of<br />
welfare of mankind than the Ohnstian Church?" Wales, then ail Queen, and smce the death of<br />
he asked.<br />
her beloved husband, King Eu waru the Pedcemaker,<br />
as {Jueen Mother, the late Queen Alexandra<br />
endeareu herself to all alike rICh anJ<br />
poor, to all sectIOns of the peopl~, and she<br />
nobly upheld the high reputation of the Royal<br />
The following telegram was addressed by the COUlIcil<br />
of the ImperIal Indian CitizenshIp to the Government<br />
of India:-<br />
"The OouncIl of the Imperial Indian Citizenship<br />
Af'lSociation b~gs to inVIte the earnest attention of the '<br />
Governmet ot India to the strong teehng prevalent<br />
in the country that if the besis of negotIations betweep<br />
tqe Goyernj.Ile,nts of In~la and South Africa is<br />
8,~ nM.EW!ltalldhw that the question o~ rep.l.triahon of<br />
I~diflll~ froII:\ So~th Africa liihould Oil left ope.\1 for<br />
\li!lCUSI:\iOD,l It will be IltenUQsly opposep. by the whole<br />
country. The ConnCll "'Ill thank the Government<br />
if the~ are tn a Positlon to delare defirutely whether<br />
iII ftl'¥ tJ.egot,atjo.\1 they are prepared t,o compQmise<br />
0.\1 the rePlJ.tr\lj.tIOn qllestlOn."<br />
COP',tmenting on the aove on, the 5th October, the<br />
Bombay, Ohrontcle say~·-''If the positIOn of Indians in<br />
South Afica has grown worse from day to day ,It isdue<br />
in small measure to the Invertebrate attitude adopted<br />
by the Government of India To accept any compromise<br />
on the repatrIatIOn question would be an<br />
infamous betrayal of the cause of IndIans in South<br />
Afuica. The latter, the maJority of whom are cohmial-bo.rn,<br />
are as much entitled to lIve and trade in<br />
South Afrioa as any of the Whites. The_Government<br />
of India have so far refused to take the -public into<br />
confidence regarding their negotiatlOns with the<br />
South Africalll Go.vernment and if, as the telegf'am of<br />
the Imperiai Citizenship AssociatIon suggests, they<br />
aJ(e Vlobbling tm the VItal issue of repatl'io:ltion, it IS<br />
hme they were eompelled to !,>ut thel!' cards on<br />
the ta.l!>le.'"<br />
$J .",<br />
Reuter's recent message mforms that 'the deputatlon<br />
app()inted by the Government of India to pro<br />
'ceed to 8auth Africa to i~:rveliltlg>lte the posltion of<br />
Indians 'there, sailed' for the Union from Bombay 01;1<br />
the K!Il'agola on Wednesday. The members of the<br />
deJ;lutlitien are.-Mr. G. F. Padd,ison (Madras CommIssioner<br />
of labour) and ~essrs Raza Ali aJ;ld Bajpa~.<br />
CouRClllcr Mrs. Benson was a passenger aboard<br />
t\l~ ~. ,8,. K,ha:Q~al\a, which left Du,rban fol' India OLl<br />
Mo~
In the Imperial Parliament<br />
Union's Absolute Right to Legislate<br />
The Asiatic Bill<br />
---.-<br />
London, Nov. 23.-ln the Commons w-dav replying<br />
to a question by the Right Hon. Josiah W~dgwood<br />
(Labour), the Rt. lIon. the Earl of Winterton<br />
(Under Secretary of State for India) .tated that<br />
communications were still passing between the<br />
Governments of India and South Africa in regard w<br />
th~ Union's anti-Indian legislative proposals. He<br />
did not t1~ink any good purpose would be served by<br />
laving the papers on the table of the House.<br />
Mr .. Wedgwood asked for an assurance that the<br />
papers would be laid on the fable before any legislation<br />
by the Government of South Africa was<br />
passed into law.<br />
'fhe Earl of Winterton replied .that it would be<br />
quite unconstitutional for him w answer that. because<br />
the Government of South Africa bad an abso-·<br />
lute right to pass any such legislation.-Reuter.<br />
The Delegation to India<br />
Durban's Send-off<br />
He assured them t~t they would not have muse to<br />
regret the choice made by them. He would do his<br />
b~t to represent the Indian cause from all poiuts of<br />
VIew to the peoples and the Government of India.<br />
He said that the eulogy showered upon the delegabon<br />
by the enormous crowd was not all that W~ required<br />
of them. The deputation Wail leaving these<br />
shores on the following morning, and durin.!: its<br />
absence from 80uth Afri06 it behoved every true<br />
Indian to put away hiE petty differences in his cupbO'drd<br />
and to see that the entire Indian community<br />
of South Africa stood at the back of the deleg-ation<br />
as one n:.an. Unity should hi their watchword, and<br />
if his advice coming, as it was, from a tried person,<br />
were taken to hEart, he felt assured that the mission<br />
w India would be a crowmng success. He felt that<br />
judging from the enthnsiasm displayed that after:<br />
noon, the deputation was leaving for India with the<br />
entire Indian commumty at its back. He saw that<br />
there were si~ns of determination in the eye .. of<br />
every Indian present that after noon, and be was<br />
fully confident that the fight they were going to Pllt<br />
up against the Asiatic Bill would he crowned with<br />
success.<br />
Pundit Bhawaui Dayal thanked the audiim ce on<br />
behalf of himself and hll~ brother delegates. an d impressed<br />
upon those present the nooeddlty of car rying<br />
on the work with re-doubled energy.<br />
The meetmg terminated after Dr. Abdurahman<br />
wasgar4nded and the other members of the deputation<br />
wer~ each presented with a beautJ.ful bouquet.<br />
The doctor was given three hearty cheers whIch<br />
went ringing through the hall.<br />
Rawat's Bio Ball was filled to suffocation when<br />
the Natal Indian Ol>llgress convened a mass meetwg<br />
on Sunday afternoon fur tha purpose of hearing the<br />
delegate. who had returned after attending the<br />
South African IDdia.n Conferonce a.t Capetown, and<br />
of biddinll God-speed to the deleg-ates of the South<br />
Afrlcan Indian Oongress who, on Monday morning,<br />
left for India in (lOnnect.ion with the Asiatic Bill<br />
now before the HOllie of Parliament.<br />
Mr, V, Lawrence presided a.nd was supported by<br />
Mr. P. R. p~r, tb6 acting seoretary of the Natal<br />
India.n Congress, and Pl'ominant members' of the<br />
India.n ooUlmunity. The members of the deputation<br />
PI,()Ct6di.pg W Indul--Dr. A. Abdul"ahman,<br />
M.P.C., of th6 Ca.pe Provinoe, Messrs. J. W. Godfrey,<br />
V. S. O. Pather, Sorabje6 RustoUlJee, Amod &yat,<br />
Pundit Bhawsili Dayal and A.
agitation in Chma, and added that the attitude of so<br />
many pro[essmg Christians towards the colour problem<br />
was one of the greatest obstacles to the advancement<br />
of ChristIanity throughout the world.<br />
The conclusion of all the spe'lkers was that the white<br />
man must meet men of other races on terms of<br />
absolute equality.<br />
So far as India is concerned, one may safely state<br />
that white men who occupy positions similar to<br />
those held by Lord Willmgdon mvarlably act on<br />
this principle. When I was myself living in India,<br />
my Indiau friends used constantly to tell me that<br />
Indians were invariably treated with courtesy by<br />
EnglIshmen m hIgh positions It was only the inferior<br />
wh,ite man who treated tlie IndIans as inferior<br />
to hImself. \<br />
That Englishmen generally represent a stronger<br />
and more capable type of human beings than mapy<br />
of the IndIan races is mdisputable.- But that is no<br />
reason why all IndIans should be treated as inferIOrs<br />
simply because of theIr complexIOns. As a matter<br />
of fact, many Indians are intellectually and SOCIally<br />
superIOr to many whIte men, and justICe as well as<br />
good breedmg reqUIres that those who behave as<br />
glmtlemell should be treated as such, regardless of<br />
race or colour or creed.<br />
Equal Ri~hts for All Races<br />
Not only IS this t'lementary principle of good<br />
manilers largely ignored in the conduct of many<br />
white men towards coloured men, but m the DommIOns<br />
there has grown up, concurrently with the<br />
growth of democracy, a system of legislatIOn delIberately<br />
plc.lnned to deny the coloured races the<br />
elementary rights of CItIzenship. ThIs development<br />
IS totally at varIance WIth the prinCIples laId down<br />
when England was gradually bUIldmg up her great<br />
EmpIre.<br />
In Cape Colony, for example, equal justICe for all<br />
races has always been the establIshed prlnCIple of<br />
government, and when Natal was annexed m May,<br />
1843, SIr George Napier, Governor of {Jape Colony,<br />
issued the followmg proclamatIOn ;-<br />
There shall not be m the eye of the law any<br />
dlstmctIOn or disquahficatIOn whatever founded<br />
on mere dIstmctIOn of colour, origm, language,<br />
or creed.<br />
Yet wlthm 50 or sixty years the little group of<br />
white settlers who had been permitted to rule the<br />
whole of Natal began to establish r,wial barriers<br />
agaiust IndIan traders, many of whom had been in<br />
INDtAN OPINION November 27th, 1925<br />
By ignormg the prmciples of eqUIty so well laid<br />
down m the above-quoted declaration of ISla. we<br />
are allowing the Empire to drift rapidly in a<br />
dangerous direction. The supremacy of the white<br />
races must ultImately depend on the concluct of the<br />
white man. It 18 well to remember that white men<br />
are a small minOrity of the population of the British,<br />
Empire, and if we, by betrayal of our own prinCIples,<br />
create a feeling of raCIal antipathy. we. shall<br />
have to face the steadily growing hOiltlhty of the<br />
coloured races.<br />
In Austraha there is a comparatively small white<br />
population, quite unable to defend Itself against a<br />
conceivable attack from Japan. In South Africa the<br />
whites are an insignificant minority ail compared<br />
with the blacks. In India our whole pOSItion depends<br />
on the willingness of the Indians to recognise<br />
the value of services rendered to them by Englishmen;<br />
but if those services are to be accompanIed by<br />
an insolent claim of racial superiority they Will be dechnpd<br />
Without thanks. Similar considerations apply<br />
to Ceylon, to the Straits Settlements. and to the<br />
West Indies. If the 13rltish Empire is to be held<br />
together in anythlllg hke its present dlmensionR.<br />
oomplete harmony between men of dlffel'ent races it!<br />
essential.<br />
Suffering Injustice<br />
(By L. W. R)<br />
That our suffermgs are a blessing in disgUIse IS 1'1<br />
pious opmion frequently voicel at Indian protest<br />
meetmgs. It is, however, not always ql1lte as clear<br />
that the sIgmficance of the sentiment is appreciated<br />
aud its truth realised because if it were one would<br />
rather expect such appreciatIon and realIsation to<br />
become somewhat more patently manifest. Suffering<br />
is but the reaction of the "I" conscIOusness to<br />
disharmony or discord in Rome centres in the body.<br />
By identification of the" I" with the body the dil:!'<br />
cord produces in the former the emotIOn called<br />
" pain" from whICh arises the notIon of suffering.<br />
A nation or commumty is but a larger unit. an aggl'egation<br />
Of the individu.1ls composing it, Just a~ the<br />
physical body of anyone human being is an aggregation<br />
of the cells, tissnes, organs' etc. constitutlOg<br />
it and the analogy in regard to the rationale of<br />
suffering holds equally good. Not that suffermg<br />
the Colony longer than the1r white rulers Similar is a necessity following from the recognition of the<br />
measures were adopted a few yearA later by the pl'esence of dis-harmony. R
November 27th, '925 INDIAN OPINION 309<br />
--- ---- ---"--------;---------------=-~<br />
body corporate and in the individual lives that form<br />
.L to which we may quite safely ascribe much of the<br />
existent trouble from which we suffer. Let there,<br />
then, firstly be honest lIelf-examination and there<br />
after a whole-hearted effort to rtmove the evil dis<br />
('~sed. The Bishop of Calcntta. when here, expreBBed<br />
J,,-st these sentiments and he spoke not in a spirIt of<br />
criticism bot of love. None can reJ.lly believe in<br />
theIr claim to respect or honestly speak of self-respect<br />
while they entertain doubts about their olVn respectability.<br />
On the other hand respect and 3dmiration<br />
flow out irrestibly to the worthy. Nom' who knew<br />
Mahatma Gandhi, when he Ii ved here among us,<br />
not even his stol1test political opponents, could<br />
withhold from him profound respect and admiratlOn.<br />
lIe drew these out of others, frequently in spite of<br />
of them-selves, because "there lives a Master in the<br />
hearts of men" who'le very nature is Truth and<br />
Purity and who compels recognition of that Master<br />
in the hearts of others in whom truth and purity are<br />
awakened. Let, then, our first (':lore be to cease<br />
doing oUlselves "injustice" and to eradicJ.te from<br />
the communal body whatever may rightly be regarded<br />
as unhealthy and corrupt.<br />
That we may be no worse than "our friends the<br />
enemy", the instruments of our correction, In no<br />
I wise affects our duty. We have firstly to become<br />
worthy in our own sight of the liberty we claim.<br />
Recognition of our worth must then inevitably follow<br />
however tardily. Then only may we truthfully<br />
say that our aflhctions were blessings in disgUISe<br />
seeing that they moved us to attain our trne stature<br />
and to qualification for helping in turn the very instruments<br />
that, whatevel' may have Leon theIr designs<br />
and motives, were but thfl channels through'<br />
which Higher Powers led us to salvatlOn. In the<br />
divine economy all forces move to ultimate good<br />
and the purpOSi of men's activities is often other<br />
and greflter than their knowmg.<br />
Is the Lesson Still Unlearnt?<br />
(By L. W. R.)<br />
Perhaps the most momentous incident of the Great<br />
War 1914-18 was the pronouncement "NQ indemnities,<br />
no annexation," proclaiming :IS it did allegIance<br />
to an ideal and marking an advance in the ethical<br />
standards governing any prevIous conflict in modern<br />
times. Now, the ideal of actions perfomerl as duty,<br />
of 8aCl'ifice for Right sake, of the renunCIation of the<br />
fruits of action is one that has been held up to humamty<br />
from time immemorial, and is th 1 arresting moral<br />
expressed in tne lives of the world's Teachers allli<br />
Exemplars. Not infrequently It has beell adopted<br />
and advanced by way of justification of the "peaceful<br />
penetratiou" practised by nations desirous of imposing<br />
their civilisations upon others, for extending<br />
"spheres of influence" and the like. Be it conceded<br />
that the world's peoples are suffiCIently inter-depe. ,<br />
dent to preclude anyone unit living wholly unto itself;<br />
be It conceded further that a more advanced race<br />
or sub-race may justifiably feel caUei upon actively<br />
to interest itself in the affdirs of the more backwal'd<br />
\~'[lterests of the latter or of the greater whole, any<br />
\:"\oh justification automatically ceases the moment<br />
the motive prompting it is coloured by self-interest<br />
or so soon as the duty of instructing or advancing the<br />
iterests of the beneficiary is performed. Devolution<br />
is one of the commonest phenomena in nature. The<br />
seed after having been nourished by the part;nt tree<br />
enters upon its life of pseudo-independent existance<br />
and growth. The sacrificial duty done, the parent<br />
no Inger seeks to maintian contol. The rule obtains<br />
throughout nature; it should similarly govern all<br />
human polio'es, thos9 of men and those or natiolls.<br />
1AI rtgbU,o\lIll' •• e' '" \!If 4iltrabUht 'hAl It Ibo\11101<br />
be so, is retleded in practice as the missionary motive<br />
in peace an(l in such pronouncem"nts in war as that<br />
of "no indemnities, no annexations." When, however,<br />
it iii sought thJ.t such recognition shouM be carried<br />
beyond the theoretical stage, beyoud the stage of mere<br />
profession or of merE-ly partIal performance; when<br />
the trne and final test of motivfl is applied, and the<br />
final proof in action is demanded, then, alas, the canker<br />
of selfishness, hitherto hidden, asserts its presence<br />
and under cover of conntles.'1 excuses Principle is once<br />
again S.1crificed on the altAr of Expediency. It is the<br />
spirit of the jungle stIll in ascend.J.nt, stil! unconquered<br />
by ths Human. Just as it was between Phaorah<br />
and th~ Israelites, a reluctance "to let him go," to<br />
relinquish the materIal advantages of over-lordship,<br />
to "have and to hold" so-history is ever ,repeating<br />
itself!-is it to-day as between the races European<br />
and non-European notably 111 India and South Africa.<br />
The fruits of exploitation are too sweet to rehnquish;<br />
tneyare present, material. "real,,, l\Ioral, eteical, religous<br />
considerations? "All right, no doubt, in theIr<br />
way but-'" All of whICh means another lessoll to<br />
be learned, the lesson of the Dead-Sea nature of the<br />
fruit of unrighteousness, to be set when in the wisdom<br />
of the Great Ones who guide hnman destinities the<br />
time is rIpe and fittIng.<br />
O~E*i~E*i~ ~~~~~~o<br />
~ • OUR LONDON LETTER i<br />
~ [ FROM OUR OWN CORRESPONDENT ] ~<br />
\V 1.ith OctoLer, 1925. \V<br />
o~E*i~~~~~~~~~o<br />
There IS some stir in Lomlon on the question Ilf short<br />
weight and measure. \ lIegatlOns are rIfe, for 1Ostance,<br />
before the Food CounCIl therp WJS eVidence that a paper<br />
blg manufacturer, had bad ordl r~ for the heaViest paper<br />
bigs p:Jsslbll', for USe in the \lell!lI~ or ,u~dl' by retail; the<br />
Bugar would be put 10 the paper bag' hnd weighed WIth It,<br />
thu$ glvmg- the customer short, weight. Customers are help_<br />
less agam~t the retaller~, because the po\tC} Cln prosepute<br />
in cages of sho,'t 1\"l'lght 01 1U 'a~ure, only 10 re3pect of<br />
the sale of bread, t"a and coal. In all other caEes the<br />
customer alone 1$ entItled to prosecute, on Ii charge of<br />
obtainlOg money by false pretences, or for a brf ach of<br />
a celtain trade law, This of cour~e, the cll'tomer will<br />
not do, for upon hlln falls t,he burden of till' pro;ecution.<br />
There i~ a I'kehhood from whflt is now happennig in<br />
London, steps will be takpn to amend the law on the<br />
subject, so that the pohc a shall have the right to prose<br />
I ute in all case8, wheN short wei~ht or m~asure is gIven.<br />
rhe Fooll CounCil, by its investigations into the cost<br />
of production, and dl'tnboLIOIl of food~tllff", hlS so far<br />
rendered good serviCl} plrtlcularly I1l regard to the 8tlple<br />
foo dbreae!. In Stlptember the Food Council announced<br />
that was no JustIfication for the tenpenc~ qnarter loaf a~<br />
that time, and three d1Ys after the prIce was rcdnctld by<br />
the bakers to nme pence half penny following a fall of<br />
four shillings on the price of a llIlck of flour. In October<br />
the Food Council agam annouuced this tIme that nine_<br />
pence halfpenny for the loaf WdS also unjustlllabit', and<br />
asked the bakprs who were selling at less than nine lJalfpenny,<br />
to send lD their n'lmes and addre~ses for the preparation<br />
of a white list. Ou the Slme day as this actIOn<br />
was taken, the bJ.kers orgalJlsations rednced the loaf to<br />
ninepence, following a fortber fall of f(lor shillings on<br />
the price of a sack of flour. It Will be noticed that 00<br />
each occasion the Food CounCil announce 1 the loaf was<br />
too dear before the prICe of flollr fpll. And on each<br />
occasioo the bakers' organisaLiolls took a halfpellny off a<br />
loaf after the price of flour had fallen The significant<br />
fact reI Dains in the contention of the Food CounCil that<br />
fl JOr having falle'! eigbt shillmgs--four shillings 00 each<br />
occaSIOn-from forty nine &hllhngs to forty one shillin!!"s<br />
per sqck of flour, the price of the loaf ought not to be<br />
more than eight. pence halfpenny. The Food Oouncil<br />
-1.lm" to haft .yldelloe of bf,a
. 3. 10 INDIAN OPINION November 27th. lOiS<br />
)<br />
prices below ninepence, in different districts, and in one<br />
distA-iet fIB low all seven pence halfpenny. The bread<br />
organisatIOns npt 80 long AgO practICally ref II sed to give<br />
evidence before the Food CommIssion, say ng that they<br />
hod no new facts apart from the evidence tl,ey had previouslV<br />
gl\'en before the Royal Commis~ion on foodstulf~,<br />
but there is every indication now that they will seek to<br />
gi\'e evidence before the present Food CounCl!.<br />
Eugen Saindo\V that famous strong man, died yesterday<br />
suddenly at, his home in Holland Park A venue, at<br />
the age of 58. His death IS attributed to the bUrqting<br />
of a blood vessel in the brain. This is said to have been<br />
the result of shock and overqtram, which he suffered<br />
some conSiderable time ago, when, fo1\owmg a motoring<br />
accidept, he lifted hiA caf oub of a ditch smglebanded.<br />
AL tast the Governm~nt has set the machinery in<br />
ll1w in motion agaltlst CommunIsts. Some forty Reds,<br />
were accordIng to press reports. considered by the Government,<br />
a.nd eight of them were arrested on charges of<br />
conspiring to publish seditious hterature aod conspiring<br />
to incite to mutiny. The men charged are Albert Inkpin<br />
secretary of the Commumstic Party of Great Britain,<br />
John Campbell Editor of the Workprs' Weekly, Harry<br />
Pollitt seoretary of the National Minority Movement,<br />
E. Oart, LondoI! orga!l\ser of the Commumst Party,'<br />
W. Rust secretary of Young Commnnis~ League, T. H.<br />
Wintrmgham a member of the staff of the Workers'<br />
Weekly, W. Gallacher a Clyslde Commumst, and T.<br />
Bell a member of the Executive of the CommuDist Party.<br />
l'he ffrsb six were to-day released on bail of~ a £100<br />
each, Mr. George Lansbury M.P. standing surety, for Q<br />
£100 in each case. The last tWO are under pohce escort<br />
on the way to London. The caaes were adJourned for a<br />
week.<br />
With the opening of the Michelmas Sitting'S, of the'<br />
Law Courts on the 12th inot. began a New Legal Y~ar,<br />
and it was marked With aU the ceremonial attaching to<br />
the event. The Lord Chancellor, the judges and the<br />
K.C.'s and barristers attende1 s~l'vice at Westminister<br />
Abbey, ana at tbe Roman Oatholic WestmiDlster Cathedral<br />
and from th~l!Jl8 proceeded to the HOllse of Lords<br />
where they "breakfa~ted." And in dUe course ~ ended<br />
their way to the Law CourB, and walked 10 propession<br />
through the great hall between tnasse 4 of slJe
1udian<br />
No. 49-Vo1. XXIII. Friday,. December 4th, 1925.<br />
A SUCCESSFUL LICENSING APPEAL<br />
1f<br />
liE Town Council's past policy in restricting the<br />
number of Asiatic licences in Berea Road was<br />
reviewed in the Council Chamber on 20th ult.<br />
when Meaars. Moosa Bros. appealed against the decision<br />
of the Licensing Officer in refusing to grant the<br />
transfer of a retail licence in respect of premises at<br />
1:I.J, Berea Road. Appellants formerly held a licence<br />
for premises at the corner of U mbilo and Berea Roads,<br />
and had been forced to vacate the premises on account<br />
of a portion being sold to the Corporation for<br />
improvements to the corner. A previous appeal bad<br />
been refused.<br />
•<br />
The grounds of appeal were that apP6llants bad<br />
held a licence for the premises for 17 years, that<br />
they had been compelled to move, that they were<br />
the owners of the premises to which they wished to<br />
remove, that there were scverallicences held by Indians<br />
in the immediate vicinity of 123, Berea Road,<br />
and that no objections had been lodged.<br />
Mr. DouU, who appeared for the appellants, stated<br />
that they would lose £1,000 which was outstanding<br />
in book debts if the licence were refused. He argued<br />
that it was not competent for the Licensing Officer<br />
to restrict appellants' rights to continue their long<br />
established business without lawful reason. The refusal<br />
of this licence would not solve the Asiatic problem<br />
in Durban, and the granting of it would not<br />
prejudICe the rights of Europeans.<br />
The Licensing Officer said in this matter the law<br />
was quite plain, but there were other points besides<br />
those which had been mentioned which ought to be<br />
takeu into account. It. was probably not quite true<br />
that the applicants would 10S6 the whole of their<br />
book debt. if the licence were refused. It was certainly<br />
not quite true that. the applicant wonld not<br />
displace a European by moving into 123, Berea<br />
Road. One had already been displaced, a woman,<br />
to whom the applicant had shown no mercy, and<br />
who had lost her all. An Asiatic had told a tale<br />
1900 years ago of a master whose steward owed him<br />
money. The story went that although the master<br />
showed the steward mercy the steward showed none<br />
to a fellow-servant, whereupon the master tlirew the<br />
steward into prison until he had paid all the debt.<br />
And the teller of the tale had evidently thought that<br />
just, for he added that so eternal justice would deal<br />
with each and everyone who behaved in like<br />
manner. The Licensing Officer went on to argue<br />
that the law was in favour of his decision, and he<br />
knew of no higher ethical authority than the 18th<br />
chrevious visits to South Africa have fitted lam for<br />
the position of mediator. A gentleman through<br />
and through, of a quiet yet convincing personality,<br />
acceptable both in European and Indian society,<br />
Mr. Andrews can truly be described as the friend<br />
of all At a time when we are a.lso expecting the<br />
official deputation from the Government of India,<br />
and pORSibly one from the Christian churches of<br />
India, Mr. Andrews' presence in South Africa is<br />
invaluable. What is needed is quiet, coavilleing<br />
work of the type which Mr. Andrews is 80 well<br />
fitted to carryon. Any loud, blustering demands<br />
would only irritate tho'le many Europeans who are<br />
friendly disposed towards us. As a community,<br />
we are prepa.red to stand or uIt by the decision<br />
of a round table conference as has been suggested.<br />
If such a conference were to come to the decision<br />
t11at the Indiana of South Africa are a menace to<br />
the well-being of the general public and that their<br />
presence has become a curse, we shall bow to its<br />
decision. Times have changed we admit. Recent<br />
egislation tendll to level aU workers up to -the<br />
European shndJ.rd, and we must abide by the<br />
law. At the same time we would point out that<br />
we are handicapped by lack of t'liueatiou of the<br />
masses to stand clhngside Europeallil. OUf means<br />
of livelihood are verI much restricted. That bein&
~3~t2 ____________________ 1_N_D_I_A_N-.O_P_t_N_t_O_N ________ D_e_c_em __<br />
ber 4ili'~92S<br />
th$ oase, lfe naturally look: with 9.11\t'lI1 upon the<br />
pi'0p08ed legislation which wOuld confine u. &0<br />
lace.tJonti. both for llvlog and trudidg. We \Velcome<br />
the oflicial deputlttiod of the Gov~rnment of<br />
India which is nroceeding to South Africa, and we<br />
feel sure that the Congress will come forward with<br />
ey~ &OlI!iiitanOO'. Every~hing is to be gained b)"<br />
a thorongh Investigation into the poiiUtion here.<br />
Franldy, we do not expect any definite result to<br />
cdOla {rdhl Ul.l",bours of tM officisl deputation,<br />
.tI ubj~ beiDg, ",e unde~tal1d, tner'lly to gather<br />
information and report to the Government of Indill,<br />
which. of emtt~e, jot ne
December 4th, 1925<br />
lNOlAN OPINION<br />
dealt with-in the United States. in Canw. and<br />
here. We could not allow another alien race to<br />
further complieate onr problems. (Applause).<br />
The 110n. W. A. Deane, who Waf very cordially<br />
received. e.x.preBlled pride and pleasure at being pre<br />
Bent to put the position in plain language. Europcan.<br />
ill Natal were fighting for their very existence.<br />
The peril for us to-day, he said, would be the peril<br />
for South Afrim to-morrow if unchecked. (Hear,<br />
hear, and applause.) He agreed that the Bill before<br />
Parliament should be regarded as a non-Party<br />
measure. lIe quoted Mr. Shaik Hamid as saying "we<br />
had hoped that the Nationalisl Boers who had been<br />
deprived of their flag and their presidentB, and reduced<br />
to the status of subjects, wonld sympathise<br />
with another similarly-placed nation." (Laughter.)<br />
Mr. Deane warned Indians not to test the temper of<br />
Natalianll any further. Indians were well treated<br />
here.<br />
The Mayor then put the motions to the meeting,<br />
which were carried unanimously amid applause.<br />
The IndJan National Association's<br />
Resolution<br />
The Indian National Association representing the<br />
Indian community of Zanzibar expresses ite deep<br />
sympathy with its Indian brethren in South Afrioa<br />
in thE'ir troubles, and assures them of all the sup.<br />
port that is within the power of the Indian National<br />
Association to give them to maintain their poeition<br />
and self-respect in South Africa. In the opinion of<br />
the Indian National Association, India should not<br />
becODUl a. party to any scheme of repatriation whether<br />
described as voluntary or compulsory. " The<br />
Indian National AflBociation is further of opinion<br />
that the Bill proposed to be passed by the Union<br />
Parliament is manifpstly a brE'ach of the Gandhi<br />
Smuts settlement of 1914 and urges upon His<br />
Majesty's Government to take imme(bate steve to<br />
obtain redre!!s in the interest of the solidarity of the<br />
Empire.<br />
Random Thoughts<br />
(By RAMBLER)<br />
Sastri -the Man<br />
The Right Hon'ble V. S. Srinivasa Sastri, P.C.,<br />
President. Servants of India Society, delivered the<br />
Convocation address of the Mysore Universitr this<br />
year. It need hardly he stated that the Chancellor<br />
of the Univprsity-His Highness the Maharajah of<br />
MYllore,-could not have made a worthier choice.<br />
The Right Hon'ble Sastri is. what is called in political<br />
parlance, a back-number. He has had hill day'<br />
and they are over, at least for the time being. That<br />
does not, however, detract from his eminence as a<br />
speaker and a thinker. It may not be widely<br />
knQwn that before the late Mr. Gokhale rescued<br />
from oblivion the Right Hon'ble Sastri, the lattilr<br />
was a schoolmaster,-the Heaimaster of a struggling<br />
Boys' High School in Madras. The teacher's profession<br />
is always an underpaid and ill-appreciated<br />
profession. Mr. Sastri's case was no exception.<br />
During Mr. Gokhale's visit to Madras, Mr. Sastri<br />
came into contact with ' Master' and recognised in<br />
him his guru. Mr. Gokhalo similarly felt attracted<br />
to Mr. 8astri. It was a great sacrifice which Mr.<br />
SastrS made ~t the time, when, ill obedienoe to the<br />
call of service, he -resigned hiB headmastershlp and<br />
embraced voluntary poverty as the badge of Ute.<br />
A Patriot<br />
It cannot be !\aid of Mr. Saetri, not even by hiB<br />
critics,-that he belongs to that category of lll'm<br />
who have mlBged the call of the conntry. In &<br />
Dl3D'! life-time three calle come at one Hme or other,<br />
and as they are seized and made lU!e of or are let go,<br />
Dlen mould their liV68. One of the oalle ill the call<br />
of a woman's IOTe. It ie only O'ne& in a life-time<br />
dOe8 the call come to men and wOmen, when ne<br />
sacrifice is considered too great at the altar of the<br />
one being who is the object of devoted love. Then,<br />
there ill the call of the religion or of God. To 'all'<br />
thinking minds, the call of God comelt early in life.<br />
when they awaken to the iniqnities and injustices<br />
of life and to their own impotence to redress them.<br />
Few, like Buddha of old or Gandhi of our times,<br />
radically l-evise their life's waye M a reBult of snch<br />
ex:perieDce. 'Alany of us make ottr own compromises<br />
with religion and plod on. Similarly, does<br />
the call of the country also come to one surelY<br />
•<br />
enough and we respond or turn a deaf ear as we are<br />
constituted and circumstanced. Sastri is certain\y<br />
one of those woo have unerringly heard the call bf<br />
both God and Country. Opinions of Mt. Sastri may<br />
Qat agree with our own but none f!an deny Sastri's<br />
claim to speak to the youth as an elder brother.<br />
His Best<br />
Mr. Sastri gave unto the stndenta that had gatherered<br />
to bear him, his best in thought and style. He<br />
spoke sweetly. but frankly and firmly. He declined<br />
to be drawn into an expression of opinion on<br />
the proposals for nni versity reform that were on the<br />
anvil and did so with "Very good reasons. He !!aid it<br />
will be only too easy for him with the characteri!tic<br />
irresponsibility of politicians to dogmatise as to<br />
what shonld and should not be done. For during a<br />
great many yeal'll, !!laid Mr. Bastri 'politic!! has been<br />
meat and drink to me. And if anybody were to remind<br />
me that I had not the necessary local knowledge,<br />
I should reply exultingly that I hall outlived<br />
the Bimple time when ignorance was considered a<br />
disqualification for the office of • agitator.' You<br />
may be thankful that the imp in rne is not so highly<br />
developed, Mine be the homely ta!!k of an elder<br />
brothE'r who seeks in confidence and love to g\ve<br />
the benefit of Ws experienCt' to the junior m.embers<br />
of his family. Thirty seven years ago, I left mY'<br />
alma mater as most of you would presently leave<br />
fOUl'll, not without distinction. And although I<br />
cannot boast of having made fame or amassed f8rtune<br />
or acquired a wide command over men, my Ufe<br />
has enabled me to see some men and thiqgs out t>f<br />
the ordinary; and it may be that ~f you are attractin<br />
as well as silent for an hour or thereabouts 1<br />
shall impart 80me words of needed counsel a'nd<br />
warning.' No one who has perused the oonvoca·<br />
tion address of Mr. Sastri can deny that he baa fulfined<br />
his promise in full. Mr. Bastri was in Ii reflective<br />
mood. He did not set himself to beat the<br />
drum of service and sacrifice and urge the youth to<br />
set in quest of the unattainable. Instead, he Bet<br />
himself to give youth the benefit of his own lifeos<br />
disappointments and disillusionments as typioal of<br />
the disillllllionments and disappointments that beset<br />
aU seekers after practical idealism. If one had to<br />
sum lip the leasons of Mr. Sastri's life, he could<br />
aptly Bum it up in the words 'Disillusionment, thon<br />
art the Goddess.'<br />
The War Mentality<br />
Mr. Sastri has come in for adverse commenta by<br />
youthful writers in the presa for h.ia sobriety and<br />
caution. He is told that he is a man of speculative<br />
mind pitch-forked into the position of a man ~<br />
action and consequently a misfit whose experience&<br />
han no univtlrsal application. The oritic. also
I<br />
3 1 4 INDtAN opiNION December 4th, 1925<br />
argue that ethics and principles of action are poles<br />
apart and that what is ethical need not necessarily<br />
be expedient and that action reqnires a practical<br />
mind which Sees only its own side of the picture<br />
and refnses to see reason on the other side. These<br />
sentiments are voiced by the nationalist press which<br />
make it an every-day grievance of their existence<br />
that the Anglo-Indian and the civilian bnreancrat<br />
refuse to ilee the reason of the Swaraj movement.<br />
How contradictory does this pOile appear with the<br />
role of practical men they adapt where Sastri is<br />
concerned? If Indians are to subordinate expediency<br />
to reason or ethics, why should it be<br />
wrong on t~e part of Englishmen in India if they<br />
do so and re~use<br />
to see the jnstice of the Indian<br />
claim and think it to be devinely ordained that British<br />
exploItation should continue in India'il own<br />
interests.' It is this mentality of expedIency that<br />
gives rise to wars, racial, communal and international<br />
hatreds and all the ills that flow from them. The<br />
frni¥! of this philosophy of expediency call be seen<br />
in Bengal politics where the polical parties hate<br />
each other more than they object to foreign rule, in<br />
the "Punjab where hatred is the iospel of both the -<br />
Hindus and Moslems, and in Maharashtra and<br />
Madras where the Brahmins a.nd non-Brahmins are<br />
ever in a state of civil war.<br />
Only Panacea<br />
The only panacea for the communal jealousies,<br />
racial hatreds and political intrigues is the cultivation<br />
of detachment in public life. Detached thinking<br />
will lead to detached action when things are<br />
viewed and judged detachedly. It is pure reason<br />
and not sectional or narrow interests that will influence<br />
the decisions of the mind. The great need<br />
of the coUntry is detachment which is another name<br />
for selflessness. Mr. Sastri's entire address iii a plea.<br />
for this ideal and it is for this clarion call that the<br />
writers in the nationalist press haul Mr. Sastri over<br />
the boaIS. Mr. Sastri hail reached an age in hili cwn<br />
life imd an eminence in public life when he oon<br />
afford to forego the cheap laurel of a irowd'il applause<br />
for worshipping in the market place. The<br />
loss that arises from the omilililion to see the main<br />
current of thought m Mr. Sastri's address is the 10ils<br />
not of Mr. Sastri but of those who know no language<br />
but that uttered in terms of ilelf,-the individual<br />
self, the communal self, the national self, bnt<br />
not the universal Self which sees itself in other<br />
selves and having the vision to realise the nnity of<br />
selves seeks to serve not by aggrandisement but by<br />
self-~bnegation. To say this is not necessarily to set<br />
the seal of approval on all the political achievem~nts<br />
and, fa.ilures of the Right Hon'ble Srinivasa Sai!tri,<br />
the politician. That would be unfair both to the<br />
distinguished lecturer and the humble scribe. Mr.<br />
Sastri came unto the students as an elder brother<br />
and he spoke to them not of himself but of his perception<br />
of the basi9 principles that govern right condnct<br />
as he has seen and tested on the touch-stone of<br />
life.<br />
It is therefore but right that the principlef!<br />
should be weighed Qn the scales and not the lecturer.<br />
Verities of Life<br />
Mr. Sastri spoke the eternal veritlelil of life in<br />
language simple and form familiar to the students<br />
that had gathered to him. All honour to Mr. Sasb'i<br />
for the kindliest service that he had done to the<br />
student-mind by his frank and fearless utterance,<br />
heedleBli of the unkindly critic, he knew sure<br />
enough, waited to tear him to pieces -for all the<br />
omissions and commissions of a life-time of dedicat~d<br />
service in the country's canse. Like Tagore<br />
in another sphere, like his guru Gokhale in politics<br />
Mr. Sastri's is the unique distinction to be milil~<br />
understood by his own countrymen. But this very<br />
misunderstandi~g is the salt of life. Posterity, detached<br />
from the ~eart and passions of the moment,<br />
will judge him more truly and kiu,lly. These pel'<br />
sonal aspects apart, it is worth whIle to rCVlew<br />
briefly,the first principles of conduct to whICh Mr.<br />
Sastri drew attention In hIS remal k.\ble a
December 4th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 3 1 5<br />
---- - - ----- --~-----.,-----=....:..:....:....::,-=--------.:!.:.::!.-<br />
thod'l of a~taining Hwaraj and followed it up with<br />
an a Hl'f'sS on • Culture an.l Public Life' by the<br />
IIon'ble Sir C, P. I{,lml-iwdmi Iyer, L'1w Member of<br />
the G()VCrnmClnt of Ma lrdl!. Mr. BhuLlbhai J.<br />
DC8a: pre~i'l(Jd. Thp- chOice of the Chairman W.1S<br />
apprOpll,\t'> to th" OCI: IIH()'l. )'lr. Dasai wail an<br />
aI")f'nt Homo-rill,'" in the days of the home-rule<br />
a~itatlOll of Df' H'~lnt'!4 br,m,l. So Wil.'! Sir (then<br />
Mr.) Rollna'lW,lml lyer. The Chairman lell Rombay<br />
while the IpGtllrer led Ma.lra!!. Both are IJ.wyers,<br />
and eminent in their c,lhn~. Both are young. The<br />
chairman, If Dame Rllrnf)Ur spoke truly, wooed the<br />
LIW Mflmbcl'lIhip of the Guv('rnmf'nt of India, or<br />
was woood in tlllt b,.h,lf, whlle the lecturer WJ.S<br />
led captive into the Law ~Iembert4hip of the Madras<br />
Government by Lorll and Vvly Willingdon. Nonco-operatlOn<br />
drove both the chairman and lecturer<br />
out of poht\C~ by its int()lol\mC..l of oPPQsite viewil,<br />
-one into tho arms of the proft'saion and the other<br />
other into an olllbrance of th,., burP-aucracy. It. was<br />
thercfOl"e only to be expect",l that when an attractive<br />
subject as 'culture an. I pnblic life' WJ.S proposed,<br />
the lecturer Bhould make it a pea for a sermon and<br />
an apology. If non-co-operatIOn had not produce!!<br />
intolerance, wf'll,-thc lecturer may not have left<br />
public life. Wh,lt wa::! puhlic liCe without tolerance?<br />
Cultivate toleJ"lnce bofore all other virtues. That<br />
was the burden of the lectmer, although he omitted<br />
all references to non-co-operatIon.<br />
Pros<br />
The address was excellent in its dIction, elegance<br />
and imagery. Sir Rtmaswami is a cultured man in<br />
the sense that he is a mll'l of accomplhhmentil. His<br />
desertian of politics had. not lost him the cunning of<br />
speech. Hlr R.Lma3wami referred to religious persecutions<br />
ill IIindu religious history which are relics<br />
of a barbarous age and to tolerance that has sinoe<br />
markcd the spiritual growth of this ancient land<br />
whieh is rightly acclaimt'tl the 'cradle of religions-'<br />
lIe quoted eminent men of lettprs who rightly 'laid<br />
emphasis on the neell for htlDllhty and tolerance ail<br />
inalienable characteristics of culture. Sir Ramaswami<br />
also referred to the dogmatism of the journalists<br />
tending to give a fundamental aspect to the immelhate<br />
and evanasccnt. In conclusion, the lecturer<br />
plelldell not for the extinction of aU dogmatism<br />
bllt for the co-existence of a respect for the opposite<br />
view point. l\h', Desai endorsed, the appeal of the<br />
lecturer and asked the youth to learn to win without<br />
conct'lt and loso Without rancour. lIe claimed that<br />
Bombay was f.lst re-establillhing its claim to be a<br />
city With a large fund of tolerance and as~ured the<br />
lecturer that he would always bo welcome, whatever<br />
views ho held or may have ceased to hold since the<br />
Home-mil' days. The last repartee was a doubleedged<br />
weapon in this casE', as Mr, Desai is equally in<br />
Sil' Ramaswami's plight. The audience, however,<br />
was not critlCal and MI'. Des,\i eilcaped.<br />
Cons<br />
It is but fair that tho other side of the case should<br />
be stated. Advocates of tolerance do concede that<br />
there is room for a lImlted amount of dogmatism, as<br />
all Rections C.lU inill.Lte only from a positivity of convlCtion<br />
that one side of the C,LSe is for the time being<br />
the right viewpoint. Tho recognition conceded to<br />
dogmatism is however nominal. The emphasi~ of<br />
tolerance is real. What the advocates of tolerance<br />
have In mind is the intolerance of the non-co-operation<br />
days. Now that non-co-operation has failed.<br />
its critics are able to s.L1 "we told you so." But let<br />
us eraase from our mind the failure of the non-co-_<br />
opel'ation movement and only remember the intensity<br />
of national feeling during the p:limy dayS of<br />
non-eo-operation. The country was ilgething with<br />
feelin!,'S of anger an,l illthgnation. The Punjab and<br />
Khilafat wronllS wt'l'1.cnough to try the patieuce of<br />
pn, ,nlbJeo\ people. 4"ldW tn " orlU(!M etatt Uk. thatt<br />
)'" Gandbi rlRbU, Cll' wrCl!1li11, of!81'eQ a proRra!UD111<br />
of action which caught popular fancy. Many calculated<br />
mind. laW the seeds of failure in the movement<br />
and iltood aloof and they had to bear the<br />
opprobrium of their aloofness. It hall been argued<br />
that if BO one had stood aloof non-co-operation<br />
wonld have encceeded. It is an argument that does<br />
not compellJympathy. If non-co-operation did not<br />
appeal to the reason of a section of people they had<br />
every ri,;-ht to refrain from participation and even to<br />
attack it. The i88uI for consideration, howevet, is<br />
whether the exe&I!I!IM of the people in the heat of<br />
non-co-operation which resulted in the temporary<br />
ecliplJe of anti-non-co-operationists, were really of<br />
8nch a character lUI Tiuted the atmosphere of public<br />
lite.<br />
Dadabhai N aoroji<br />
A Reminiscence<br />
By RT. HON'BLJI V. S. SRINlVASA SASTRI, P. C.<br />
Twiee I wae privilf'ged to meet Dadabhai Naoroji.<br />
The first oCOOllion Wall in the very end of 1906, after<br />
he had presided over the famous Congress of that<br />
year and for the first time used the fatefnl word<br />
.. Swaraj." Gokhale had arranged that the yonng<br />
men who had joined the Servants of India Society<br />
or were about to join it ihould wait on the Nester<br />
of Indian Nationalism and receive his blessing on<br />
their life-mission. I had not been sworn, but I had<br />
resigned from my profell8ion and come to Calcutta<br />
to be admitted in form to the Society. Mr. C. Y.<br />
Chintamani too wal there, for then he contemplated<br />
joining the Society. Mr. (now Sir) Dinshaw Wacha<br />
was the only stranger present. We were introduced<br />
in a few words by Gokhale, whose behavionr on the<br />
occasion I remember as a pattern or reverence or<br />
self-respect in Ratural and attractive combination.<br />
The GM\nd Old Man gave us impressive advice. One<br />
interesting IJtatement is perhaps worthy of being recorded.<br />
He had himself contemplated the formation<br />
of a body of workers eimilar to the Servants of<br />
India Society and congratulated Gokhale on his<br />
good luck in realilling that which to him had only<br />
been a dream.<br />
The other time was in 1IHO. The Society had<br />
held a bnsy and frnitfnlsession. We had resolved<br />
to open branches in Bombay and Madras, and to<br />
enable me to llSSume command of the Madras<br />
Branah, my training had been as a special measure<br />
terminated at the end of three years and a half, and<br />
I had been declared Ordinary Member. The Madras<br />
contingent left Poona like men adventuring forth<br />
on a rlaring enterpriiJe and resolved to fortify themselTes<br />
at the start by a draught of inspiration at the<br />
very fonntain of patriotism. So we went by previous<br />
appointment to Versova, where Dctdabhai was<br />
surrounded by the loving care of his family. We<br />
were seated in a small ~oom and promised not to tire<br />
the venerable patriarch. He entered in full dress<br />
and occupied a large chair. I broken the silence by<br />
a short speech explaining our presence and praying<br />
for just one word of collnsel an~ encouragemenL<br />
He Mid a few words in reply by which we felt<br />
more than rewarded. A conversation ensued, in<br />
which he showed solicitude for onr comfort and<br />
satisfied himself that arrangem,ents had been made<br />
for dne hospitality to us. We also succeeded i~<br />
pertiuading him that his yaluable library should bjf<br />
left as a legacy to our Society, wher~ we had already<br />
a r~peQtable collection of books on politics, hi8tory<br />
and euonomtoa and o~ I'arliaDlentart .t'e90t'd. Be<br />
ll#J1ttaUt pve fn,mzatidU' far the ... maw 01 Us,
316 INDIAN OPINION December 4th, 1925<br />
,<br />
volumes. But owing to causes beyond our control, The Hon. Mr. Gokhale's Tour in South Africa:<br />
the transfer could not be effectuated.<br />
Sp~iaIINDIAl!l OPIKION Souvenirr.<br />
I<br />
It so h.o.ppened that I was in Bombay the day he<br />
passed away. Among the theusandli and thousands<br />
The Ethics ot Passive Resistance<br />
3<br />
of m~n and women who carne to pay their last respecUi<br />
I was one of the few who were permitted to<br />
Govind Ran&de 1<br />
ESlay 00 Indian Econollics, by Mahldev<br />
stay Mwnstairlil. In spit~ of the vastness of crowds Hindu Psalms and Hymas<br />
J<br />
the hush was nearly universal and impressive. and<br />
Vaisbavite Re/orlXlers of India<br />
2<br />
tbe solemnity was deepened by the chant of some<br />
Verlles from the Zend Avestaa in the room where the M. K. Gandhi and the South Afr:can<br />
!leJ\d lay, which rounded to me strangely like our<br />
Indlao Problem I<br />
own £lama Veda recited in the ilouthern style, which Aspecs of the Vedanh<br />
I<br />
Qnes hea.rd. can never be forgotten and has the<br />
power ()f mirring one to one's depths.<br />
Essays 00 lndiaa Art, I ndustry and Education :I<br />
~tI Madhwacharya<br />
J<br />
\<br />
The Late Mrs. Soobee Ellary<br />
HInduism, by Dr. BUllett<br />
PositIon of the Women in the Vedas<br />
II<br />
6<br />
0<br />
3<br />
6<br />
6<br />
0<br />
6<br />
6<br />
6<br />
6<br />
6<br />
I<br />
I,'<br />
I<br />
I'<br />
! I I ,<br />
I ,<br />
On Fridat last the 13th ultimo, after a short, and<br />
patient suffering there passed away at her home<br />
"Cato Manor," the wife pf late V. Ellary. The late<br />
Mrs. Soobee Ellary was greatly esteemed throughout<br />
the whole district, and her loss will be much<br />
f~lt. ~n the days befQre Mrs. S. Ellar:r became ill.<br />
her reputation as aJ),olltess stooq very high out and<br />
valueq }:tel' friendship. The d'eep sympathy of many<br />
go O'Ut f.!,t ~his time to her I) sons and five daughters<br />
itt their sad bereavement.<br />
The f-aneral serflce was of impressive nature.<br />
After a preliminary serVICe at the house, according<br />
to Hindu ()ustom, the body of the late Mrs. Soobee<br />
Ellary was laid to rest alongside her husband's grave<br />
who predeceased 18 years ago, in the beautiful<br />
private cemetery at CJato Manor. The Bons and<br />
daughters were the chief mom-ners, and a large<br />
nUD),bel' of relatives, and representative number of<br />
residents gathered to pay their last tribute to a<br />
highly valqed !Uember of the Indian community.<br />
"""Cdn tribllted.<br />
Mr. E. Mohamed's application for a greengrocer's<br />
licences in respect of the premises lately occupied<br />
by'Mr. Wessels van Wyk in Churoh St,reet, Cape<br />
T6w'11, was not granted.<br />
BOOKS FOR SALE<br />
Til be obt31D"~ froll) the Ind'an OJ;n,Qn Press, PhceDlx,<br />
N~tal. Postal Otders til pe mlldo: payable at Durban.<br />
'the Hott. Mr. Gokhale and the Indenture System. II<br />
tl1diaq itQIU\! i(ute, b, M. K. G.lndhi t 6<br />
.. nQok~l:l~ it:! M'iJl:lotD~r I Q<br />
lhs .. yad Gi", Mr •• B .. arn'. TrallllatiPIl ,IS<br />
Aslatle~ ae~!st~atlan 4mendment Act (1908)<br />
in gngli~b jln4 Gujar,.ti<br />
1Iindq ~p~aJ I4@al" by r. J. MehtlJ II 6<br />
Rise and Gtowth of Bombay Municipal Govt. 4 1$<br />
4~ri~uitH;~1 tRdu~~rl~s ip In41a ' z 6<br />
rb~ ji~Qry of th", ~~Ql~)'ana, \he Epic (II R~Qll! 11 (j<br />
4 ~<br />
, q<br />
No. 50-Vol. XXIII. Friday, December 11th, 1925. a ........ tIlMoG.p.o. ........... '<br />
1'aJeI. r_ .. .<br />
. ( ------~<br />
MR. ~NDREWS~ IN DURBAN<br />
--------~~-----<br />
1\\Ji1 R. C. F. ANDREWS who arrived at Durban I came out with my dearest friend, Willie Pear<br />
.Ll V II from Pretoria and Johannesburg last Mon- son.-he gave me then a man/ram to carry with me,<br />
day. at 11 a.m .• was met at the Central which we all, Hindus, MusaImans and Christians<br />
Station by a large number of prominent members of alike can repeat; for it speaks of God as One. Again,<br />
the Indian community and by European friends. this time, he wOl,lld wish me to carry the same<br />
lIe was garlanded on behalf of the Natal Indian mantram, which is the motto of our ABram at Santi<br />
CongreHs by Mr. V. Lawrence, Vice-President of that niketan. It runs as follows :-<br />
Lody. ]'Ilr. Andrews was first taken to the late Mr. ., SIuJ,ntam, Shivam, Advailnm."<br />
P.m;eo }{ustomjee's premises in Field Street, where<br />
,l crowd was anxiously waiting to greet him and to Its-meaning is, that God is th.., All Peace, the All<br />
h€dr hIm speak. He looked very tired at the end Good. the One without a second.<br />
of his journey, but at once rose and addressed those· .. He told me to carry that message of divine peace,<br />
aSAemblcd as follows :-<br />
divine goodness, divine unity, to all South African<br />
I .. I have comA to you, at this critical time, for two Indians. He said, that we who were engaged in this<br />
special rl'USODS. The former is, that Mahatma critical struggle should. be fu 11 of peace from. God;<br />
Gandhi himself WIshed me to come out to you. He we should also be full of goo dness; we should also<br />
told me, that it was my duty, if possible, to leave be united one with another in the Divine Unity.<br />
Imha for that purpose. The second reason is, that .. I have now told you the message of my Gurndev,<br />
the Poet, Rabindranath Tagore, whom I call my and I have given you Mah atmaji'a ow. love and<br />
Gllrudcv, in Iilpite of<br />
blessing. Through you,<br />
his very serious ill-<br />
who are assembled here<br />
ness, has allowed me Mr. C. F. Andrews' Message this morning from every<br />
to ('ome out and bas<br />
province in South Aftinot<br />
WIshed me to re-<br />
ca, I would wish to<br />
main. Therefore I have<br />
send this message of<br />
come to you with the On coming again the third time to South my Gurn~v and this<br />
blessings of two Asrams, Africa, to help in the' Indian cause, I have love and blessing of<br />
-the Asram at Sabar- brought with me from the Poet, Rabindranath Mahatmaji, to every<br />
mati, and the ABram at Tagore, the very same message which I brought single Indian, down to<br />
Santiniketan. At both with me on each previous occasion. The Poet the tiniest Indian baby<br />
of thE'se relIgious re- bids us put all our trust in the child, in South Africa.<br />
treats, where prayer to<br />
May God bless you all,<br />
God is offered daily by • Shantam. Shivam. Advaitam' and also bless the work<br />
all the inmates of the in 'God, the All-Peace, the All-Good, the One.' which I have come out<br />
Asram, I was sent out In the midst of all our trials and diEficulties, to do in His Name."<br />
to you with their loving let that be our daily prayer and remembrance. At the close of the<br />
prayers and blessings. We are not trusting in ~wnan strength to give gathering, it was de-<br />
Mah.ltma Gandhi and us the victory, but in God. Mahatma Gandhi cidecl to send at once<br />
the Poet, Rabindranath<br />
cablegrams to the Poet,<br />
Tagore, the founders of sends the same word of faith and hope and Rabindranath Tagore;<br />
these two Asrams, have love, Let us therefore remember, day by day, to Mahatma Gandhi;<br />
also sent me with their the and also to the Imperial<br />
own prayers and bless- Shantam. Shivam. Advaitam. Citizenship Association,<br />
ings. Therefore, I come Bombay, which had<br />
to you with what I dare ,f;:' . pro'rided the steamer<br />
to hope is the divine blessing to 10U all from India.<br />
e and sent Mr. Andrews as its representative<br />
.. I want to say one thing more. Mahatma Gandh'~ to South Africa.<br />
said ~ me, '~h~n he ~sked .m~ to go,-" Do not go An Important Correction<br />
out tIll the dIVIDe VOIce wlthin tells you that you<br />
Ulust go out." At that time, the Poet, Rabindranath<br />
Tagore was so ill, th.lt I did not wish to leave hi<br />
amI I told Mahatmaji that I could not leave him. \<br />
But later on. the inner voice became so clear, that<br />
I could resist it no longer. Then, when I went to<br />
my Gllrmlev and told him that the inner voice was<br />
so clear, that I could not resist it any longer, he said<br />
to me: .. Now you mllSt go; aud you shall carry my<br />
blessings with you." Later on, when I went to<br />
Habarm.lti, to Mahatma Gandhi, he gave me his<br />
blessings also. Therefor!', I do not come emptyhanded.<br />
I feel that I come both with the divine<br />
voice leading me, and with the divine blessing to<br />
offer to ron anll to your children.<br />
.. The Poet, Rabindranath TagorE", gave me, on my<br />
first ,isit to Natal nearly twelve years ago,-when<br />
An unfortunate mistake was made by the reporter<br />
of the Johannesburg Star which was repeated in the<br />
other papers. It was said, that Mr. C. F. Andrews had<br />
been • delegated by the Government of India.' This<br />
is not the case. Mr. Andrews was sent by Mahatma<br />
Gandhi and by the Poet, Rabindranath Tagore, and<br />
his steamer passage was provided by the Imperial<br />
Citizenship Association, Bombay. He comes out at<br />
the unanimous wish of all the leaders of Indian<br />
public opinion and is in no way connected with the<br />
depotation of the Government of India, which is<br />
now on its way to South Africa, and is a purely<br />
official deputation.<br />
Mr. Andrews has been asked by the S. A. Indian<br />
Congress Deputation, which is now _on its way to<br />
India. to be present. ~ Durban to~ \lrelQODl6 t.b~
, ' ,<br />
Government of India Deputation on its arrival, and<br />
to rellder them any necessary assistance. Thill has<br />
been confirmed by the Executive Committee of the<br />
S. A. Indian Congress at their meeting on December<br />
6th. It is necessary to make quite clear that this<br />
reception of the official deputation in Durban in no<br />
WIlY' tmpli~ apy preyioua eonnexion between Mr.<br />
C. F. Andrews and the Government of India Deputation.<br />
They are independent of one another and<br />
have (!'ollI.~ Q'tlt indepenObserved. It is use'Ies8,<br />
however,. to argue ,alii; tlilll wbDle ~n't &gilin. Sn~ly it<br />
-.ir\u be etottgh -tb Mr :t~ Mr. Gandhi's own statement<br />
~bmlt',;he :n~w !BrIl, in YlfUng Indw. where he emphati-<br />
-c,aliy d~cla~!l ,that the 'pr~sent Bill, and the Colour Bar<br />
'6li PliEic~ding it, ,a.re 5'f suoh a charac~er? that tl;1e carr'ying<br />
of them out into law would wreck the wllOle settJement<br />
of 1914,lmd leayP nQthing whatever llIltouched in<br />
the agreement tha"t 'he then made with General Smnts.<br />
It 'is 1mpo~lble, therefore, to be!,ieve that Dr. ¥alan is<br />
re~llv setlQlls. Ill, bis contention wlth regard to the<br />
Ga.u4hi-S.r.rmta. Agreement, when he declares that his<br />
prat!('.l.Lt AAlidJ;ie Bill IS 110 breach ~f its term&. U mor<br />
WLate.ly, it i's ellfWllly ~ble ro hehev.e .that he i6<br />
seriollS' ill his cmtt.el!ltion, when .he 4eclal'9B that this<br />
Asiatic Bill is merely 'a {aithfnl carrying ont of the<br />
reoorruoendations of the Lange Commission. For the<br />
J;,anp 'Co~n's .Recommendations ,have been<br />
fiagmntly yi,elatea in ev,erl11art of abe Bill.<br />
Let us here explain this matter ill
December 11th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION SIt}<br />
--~~~--------------r---------------------------~~<br />
movable property as well as agricultnral land (ii) it<br />
proposes no compensation whatever for takIng away<br />
from Indians existing righta (iii) it pays no att.ention to<br />
the ~linority Report, in the Lange CommiBllion itself,<br />
which is printed and published against the WlthdJaw~1<br />
of an, existiu~ right., of land-purchase from the Indian<br />
oommunitr, because i~ would be • oontrory to the interests<br />
of goqd ffelmg ~nd the I\E!QljEl of fair-plaf.<br />
Thus, the preBeJlt Ed! is no more a carrying ou~ of the<br />
recommendation. of the Lange Oommiasion shan it ia a<br />
carrying out of the ter~s of the Gandhi-BmutA Agreement.<br />
DR. MALAN'S PRONOUNCEMENT<br />
fN\ n.. 1faJaij b~8 POIf publir:ly !D,.de his pJ'ononncel..Lt'<br />
ment flonoerning Lhe Round Table Cpnference.<br />
Speaking lit CapetowD, he stated that the Indian<br />
Government bad asked for a Round Table Conference on<br />
the Asiatic Question, but the Upipu GoveTl~ment had<br />
decldeiI t41l~ ~4ey pouhl pot 8gree; becanse ~ ~nd<br />
'Tlble CQQferl!llctl would lJl,Qan m~killg oow:el¥!ions oq<br />
the e8ilential principlea of the Bill, and the Government<br />
were not prepared to do that They, however, welCOlLed<br />
the Deputatio/l froQ} the Government of India, which<br />
was CO/lllog tp Sou~h Mrica to investigate the 4sjatiC<br />
question. If t}le am were ~~, It would \Ie J'ef~rre
320 INDIAN OPINION December I. tho 19.25<br />
not aspire to any political ambition, they, the<br />
Europeans, will see the justice and indeed the<br />
necessity of my countrymen being granted the<br />
rights I have just referred to. "<br />
, It seems to us that the intention and spirit of the<br />
Agreement was that the vested rights of the Indians<br />
should be protected and that in future the law<br />
should be sympathetically administered and also<br />
that although that agreement only settled matters<br />
existing at that time, my countrymen thought there<br />
were other matters that required consideration, but<br />
Mr. Gandhi did not think it proper to press for any<br />
more. He made it clear that although they were<br />
not pressing for them then, he thought it best to<br />
leave it until \the good sense of the European public<br />
should see fit\to grant them more elbow room, to<br />
progress.<br />
1. wish you to remember that we are South :Africans.<br />
A lot of us do not know India, except geographically.<br />
We are bred and born hllre. We hav"<br />
no other home. We speak the language, English<br />
being spoken. Some of the Indians do not know'<br />
the Iniian language. We live and think and move<br />
about exactly as the Europeans do. Weare to a<br />
large"extent South Africans and we expect that in<br />
any legislation that will be introduced that some<br />
consideration will be given as regards our faith, so<br />
that when we- have said in that statllment that it IS<br />
a breach of the -Smuts-Gandhi Agreement we do<br />
feel that all the legislation is being introduced in<br />
direct violation of vested rights and the spirit of the<br />
Agreement, which was that we should be sympathetically<br />
treated and that the other matters still<br />
to be considered would be sympathetically dealt<br />
with. Legislation is being introduCl~d -which cer-<br />
1ainly has the impression of restricting us. I think<br />
it was the view of the then Government, with Mr.<br />
Smuts at its head, that this should not be so.<br />
On the question of immigration for Indians, the<br />
Smuts-Gandhi Agreement to a very large extent<br />
said that the qUE.'stion of immigration was practically<br />
settled as at that date. Ldon't want to enter into a<br />
discuBSlon of this Bill as I attended the Conference<br />
Rnd the Conference did not wish me to enter<br />
into discussion of this Bill. I think it is right<br />
to say, however, that in this Bill you have<br />
been pleased to introduce you are restricting our<br />
personal movement, for instance, wives should be<br />
brought in within a certain period, and the increasing<br />
of the immigr-dtion bail that was required<br />
from about £30 to £100. I think this is unreasonable.<br />
There are further restrictions. Then of course<br />
there is the question of domicIle which is now defined<br />
in the Bill, which practically says that an -absence<br />
from the Oolony of three Yllars means the los9 of<br />
domicile. These are things which perhaps will<br />
appeal to you as showing that the spirit of the<br />
Agreement that we relied upon is not being carried<br />
out. Those are further restrictions, a repressive<br />
policy against the Indians, which we feel ought not<br />
to be the case. That is as much as I wish to say at<br />
present.<br />
DR. MALAN: I think before we go furthQr it is<br />
just as well that we come to some clear idea as to<br />
what was in the Smuts-Gandhi Agreement and<br />
what was not. As you will know the Alliatic Enquiry<br />
Commission was appointed in 1921, or rather<br />
the Report was published in 1921. That Commission<br />
went very exhaustively into the whole question<br />
of what the -so-oallell Smuts-Gandhi Agreement<br />
really contained and what not. Now on page Iii of<br />
the Report. In the first place you will see there<br />
that that so-called Smuts-Gandhi Agreement which<br />
was to put an end to all these differences between<br />
tile Government and the Indian population, was<br />
/based on the definite understanding that after that<br />
(agreement there should be no further agitation on<br />
J -he part of the Indian population in regard to the<br />
laws of t4e (.ount)'y. Now, as you will see from ~Ir.<br />
./<br />
Gandi's letter, Mr. Gandhi did not acoept that. It<br />
was definitely understood that there was to be an<br />
end to the agitation against Ilegislation.<br />
[The Minister then read over again the whole<br />
passage qrwted above by Mr. Godfrey from ]\1r.<br />
Gandhi's letter.]<br />
The second point is this-that the nndertakIng of<br />
General Smuts at that hme rel-ltl:'d ouly to the<br />
administration of the existing laws. As r.11" as I can<br />
see no undertaking was given or could have been<br />
given by any Government that the laws would not<br />
be changed or that any laws with regard to any<br />
question would not in future be introduced. Couditions<br />
are continually changing in every country<br />
and it is an impossibility for any Government to gi ve<br />
an undertaking that no additional laws will be made<br />
in respect of a certain subject or that existing laws<br />
will not be changed. General Smuts said .-<br />
" With regard to the administratiou of eXlsting<br />
laws, the Minister desires me to say that it<br />
always has been and will continue to be the<br />
desire of the Government to see that they are<br />
administered in a just manner anfl with dne<br />
~egard to vested rights."<br />
Now we come to the point of vested rights.<br />
Vested rights, General Smuts said, would alw,\ys be<br />
protected. Now I find in tho report of the Asiatic<br />
Enquiry Commission that Mr. Gandhi took the<br />
precaution before leaving South AfriCiL to put on<br />
paper what he thought WelS included in that pl·omise,<br />
what vested rights really meant. Now I think this<br />
is very different from what h" says here :-<br />
"DEAR MR. GORGES,-I have now got a<br />
moment to submit my note 011 the Gold Law.<br />
As you know, after mature consideration, I<br />
refrained from pressing for the insertion of a<br />
special clause defining "vested rights" in connection<br />
with the Gold La.w and Townships<br />
Amendment Act, because I felt that any defimtion<br />
in the correspondence might result in<br />
restricting the futnre action of my countrymen.<br />
However, so far as my interpretttion of • vested<br />
rights' is concemed, I thiuk I should reduce<br />
it to writing. GenE.'ral Smuts was good enough<br />
to say that he would enrleavour to protect vested<br />
rights as defined by me. The fol\owing is the<br />
definition I submitted to SIr Benjamin Robertson,<br />
who, I understood, submitted it to General<br />
Smuts. My letter to Sir Belljamin Robertson<br />
containmg among other matters the definition,<br />
is dated the 4th March 1914: • By vested rights<br />
I understand the right of an Indian and his<br />
successors to live and trade in the township in<br />
which he was living and tradmg, no matter how<br />
often he shifts his residence or business from<br />
place to place in the Slme township. I am<br />
fortIfied in my interpretdtion by the answer<br />
glVen by :Mr. Harcourt III connection with the<br />
matter, in the Honse of Commons, on the 27th<br />
June 1911:-<br />
, Complaints against that legislation (the Gold<br />
Law and Townships Amendment Act) have<br />
been made and are now being investig-
December J uh, 1925 INDIAN OPINION . - 321<br />
old Transvaal Law, they were protected in 1908,<br />
the Transvaal Gold Law.<br />
Vested interests, even though they were acquired<br />
illegally, even though they were acquired contrary<br />
to the spirit of the exi .. ting laws, were protected in<br />
1 ~Il !', and you will find that throughout this Bill that<br />
1 have introdl1ced exi .. ting rights, vllsted interellts,<br />
of Indians are also protected. If the protection of<br />
vested rights whenevt'r le(,.-islation is introduced is<br />
meant by the protection of vested interests, I think<br />
we have kept to the spirit and to the leltt>r of the<br />
Smuts-Gandhi Agreemoot.<br />
Now coming to the question the chief qUiStion<br />
that you have raised here this morning, viz. of a<br />
Round-table Conference between the Government of<br />
India, the British Government and the Government<br />
of the Union, in regard to Indian matters geuerally<br />
in the Union, I can just say that of course a suggestion<br />
was made h~ this cennection by Mr. Thomas<br />
when he visited South Africa. I think that was the<br />
first suggestion made. Now, if I remember rightly,<br />
at that time when Mr. Thomas made his l.'uggestion<br />
it certainly did not meet with the approval 01 the<br />
European popl1lation of the country. A good many<br />
newspapers at that tIme, voicing the opinion of the<br />
public, prott>sted against that. They thought it was<br />
rather an interference on the part of Mr. Thomail,<br />
visiting our country, on a question which is very<br />
difficult and delicate. Any way, it was "'merely a<br />
suggestion on his part. Now the Indian Government,<br />
starting from i hat sUggestion, entered into negotiation<br />
with the Union Government and they definitely<br />
asked whether it would not be possible to have a<br />
Round-table Conference. Now that question with<br />
reference to a Round-table Conference is practically<br />
settled between the Government of India and the<br />
Union Government, but the negotiations have not<br />
yet rt'ached finality, that is to say, the Government<br />
of India and the Union Government are still<br />
negotiating with regard to Indian affairs in ~outh<br />
AfriCd. As I say, the whole quesm.
INDIAN OPINION<br />
ment again and refe~ed to Select Committee, to lay<br />
an the OOde'fl.ee ytfu c!ttt gtn. !tgair1st the vltriotIs<br />
ol/ttt~ M. the :aill hefdre tha Select Comtilittee, rOll<br />
if'lH b~ very W'eIcottie to do Sd. .<br />
Anel' Mr. GbdfNI'V had inlide his reply the Mitiister<br />
It!tain referred t6 hi!! o:ffet to htmt critic!st!1S In delxtil<br />
abtlttt the Bm and ttte Dep;:ttation departed.<br />
;~~~~~~.~~)~~~~O<br />
~ OUR LtiNDON L:E'fTER I<br />
~ t FROM QUR OWN CORRESPONDENT 1- ~<br />
tI .. '" 5th November, 1925. ,<br />
1l<strong>I~~~</strong>~~~~~~'~~O<br />
Mr. E. L; j!'. Wood the Minister of Agriculture in<br />
the present Oonservakve Government of Great BrItain,<br />
has been appointed to succeed Lurd Reading as<br />
"siceroy of India, He is a son of Lord Hahfax, and<br />
grandson of the first Viscount Halifax, who was<br />
Secretary of State for India from 1859 b) 1866. Mr.<br />
Wood is 44 years. He is a High Ohurchman like<br />
his father. He has never exerclsed himself in<br />
or!entai pt:oble:m,s and pursuits. He belongs to the<br />
school o~ Lord Grey of F.tlIodon :as will go to<br />
lndia with au open mind. The new VlCereine Lady<br />
Dorothy Wood, was before her marriage Lady,<br />
Dorothy dnslow,<br />
The political I .. evee is uM "tVithtiut its liot/seqtHl11cl:lS.<br />
Labout'ites who atemem.bers of the CCIUsanative<br />
and Liberal Partias; from tittle to tirt1e<br />
object to paying the Levee to tha Trade Unit/ns tlJ<br />
whioh they belongl on the ground that it it! tistid tor<br />
thead .. ancement of the J.A:l.bonr Part~. The obj{Jeting<br />
Labourites ha\Te the right of statutory exl:lmVtiotl<br />
frum sUllh a paymentj and l30rne of them ar~ exctltdiaing<br />
it, Mr. Macquiston and other Cotil3et'''ative~<br />
are ui'ging the Goverilment to intra1uce fttrthl:lt<<br />
legialatibn on the question. .<br />
Amb!th IiI Chief Of thr~e million subjects on the<br />
Gtnd Coast 6J AftitJa hal:! arrived in England.<br />
Ht3<br />
dt~§e!l in El1f'opMh cldthel:!, aM s):Jeliks English<br />
HtHmtiy. He Ms btltne ttl study the inethods of<br />
Mdcatittn. itl ttl€! Untver.3ities, with the view to<br />
at1p,lt1ng tlielti to Ii Oollege, otiened riot 136 long alto<br />
ttb Acrlra for WliSt Afticarls. He has bMii to the<br />
Uhited Statile tln a Similar i:t1i!Jsiorl, wMre lie VIsitM<br />
8tJveral ceftttea of learning delivering atldteslles ttt<br />
(Ju1umbib. Utliverlnty, and Haihptoll CoHege. The<br />
0611eite at Atlci-!l "Wall Milt at a cost or £500,000,<br />
-w:liicl1 waif! l/jafied froth the Britisli Govet'h1lietlt<br />
!itld ,.m btl paid ]jack by means {If taxes collected<br />
iil. the nlffi.n1li'~. ThI! f3taff tlf tlie cOliege will consist<br />
6f Bh~lsli and Afueridaii Masttlre, about 4~ goirtg<br />
ft'tilli Bt1tai'n. The Vibe Priiloil'al of the College<br />
wM i~ tlo'¥ 111 Ltihdoh ill Dr. Aggr'ay, ",lio it will be<br />
i'e1fiEftt1l:l@rEld. Was Olitl tJf tli€! PMlp§ stokes tJ01tltliis~idii.<br />
Whitlli vi!!ited Afillelin Otilbnies hi tlia<br />
liUI:ii'e!t 6f tiRe tldufllffidft tlf Mrtdl1tifj.<br />
" U.~~!nWal1aei'. H}ltdf1 ¥thill&i, }t.tI" chairman of<br />
the fi6yai dtJlntilisslbf.t ott It1dll~fi dut'fencr and<br />
ll'lMhcij with lils M11eagh.es trtlm Ehg1aIid Sir<br />
Henry Strakosch, Sir Reginald Mant and Mr. W. E.<br />
Pl-esWtl, iett J,..d1illdfi to-day tor Ii1dla where they<br />
\\flU 11~ jOihed l:Iy tlitlif 6tlH:1¥ cCll1e!1gI1es :ProfE'ssof<br />
fl. 0; Cojflijee, SW Mllnecitji badabohy, Sir Ra.nden<br />
{ifl1naili Mlitfaarjea, elit Alexaiidet Mul-ray, sir flurshotAtnciag<br />
TttkUt'das and ~M' Nbtc(}t W.tN·en. The<br />
Cbfurliissitlft wHl fillsl Like evidehcl! ih termS of its<br />
l'efett'llice, arid ~htltl proceeti to LUhd.6tt to take evlt1erl6e<br />
Ui~re alit! foff:b.hlate its fltlditigs and recomfilelitiaUoiUl.<br />
'turKey is betng rapid.iy westerntsed. It has now<br />
made. the w~ari.ng of the Fez iitegai, and has got thll<br />
Muit} to 4ec1are that the Fez has no religious<br />
Bai:J.dU~ti, \ tin the oocasion of the celebratiqn of the<br />
thiJ!d I1Iifl. ¥~i'~liri.t~t th\l procl~mation ot Tu.rkE'Y as<br />
II lte~Uij1.d, Wi :.r~lihlelit ;M"'tat~ l~{lIilal l:'~still<br />
arrived wearing evening dress and a tophat. The<br />
depnties were so attired, 01' woN\ morning coats.<br />
The dIplomabc corps wore uniform. til the e\>'cnilig<br />
nt the state Rlll, men alHI wotnen drE'fli!otl In the<br />
fashiont, of _Ettrope danco,t to WE'stern t11l1sic. Men<br />
il1 thE! Services atilt in the Police, We,ll" pNlk('(l anlt<br />
other forms of Western headgear. Madame Sattlt<br />
Be~ who came to London with her httsband, who is<br />
a dl!lttnguished Turkish official, is the first Turkish<br />
woman to broadcast her Bubject was the Turkish<br />
Lady of Yesterday and 1'o-diY, and gave s'e1ections<br />
of getiilihe iJ:furkish mnslc arrAnge(l for the plano.<br />
It would appear that the characterli1tics tn drl!s~ lma<br />
manner, which distinguished the 1'urks from other<br />
peoples, will be matters of the Plst These changcs<br />
will be regretted by all lovers, not only of tho<br />
spectacular, but of natIOnal traits.<br />
1'he closing scene at the Wembley was a!l triumph.<br />
ant as its opening was magnificent. Over 27 OOO,O()()<br />
people visited Wembtey. They came not on'11 from<br />
the British tsles, but from every part of the worlJ,<br />
to see the producHons of the British Empire, and<br />
none 'has left it without a deep impression of the<br />
potentialities of the 13ritish Empire.. The King wae<br />
pleased to say that the Exhibition has stimnlatE'd a<br />
legitimate pride in Britam's past achievements, as<br />
well as an increased sense of responsibilties, for the<br />
years to come. And the Duke of York, in declaring<br />
the British Empire ExhibitlOn closed/ said that he<br />
was confident that its resnlt!! would endure for the<br />
benefits of the :Empire, and its peaceful mis3\On in<br />
the world,<br />
Miss Enid Russell Smith and M:iss Alb H. Kilroy<br />
have the distinction of being the first wotnen to pass<br />
a civil service exa.mihation under the new conditions,<br />
which admit women to the higher Government<br />
posts.. They will stltrt at salaries frOIl1 .£200<br />
to £400 a yeat, WIth added bonusl nud there is<br />
nothing to prevent them in tIue conrse, from rising<br />
to th~ topmost heIghts, in any Brltisb State Departfuents,<br />
from salaries of £3000 00 £2500 a year. Any<br />
woman With the zieoesssary qnflhflcatlons may become<br />
permanent Secretary to the Treasury an(l<br />
head of the Cn'll Servioe, or perlllanant Under<br />
Secretary of 8fate fot War, 01' for foraign Ilfhlrs, or<br />
for the Dominions, or fol' India, ot' Head of the<br />
Board of Trade, the Post Office, the Ministry of<br />
Health or anf other Government offiCI! in Whitehall.<br />
TbeslJtls of Prime :Ministel's do ttot ahV,\Yd fo11ow<br />
itt tM footsteps of their fltthel's. Mr. Artthony<br />
Asquith I11l1ys (jfi the fillns. llI'iga,ller-Genel'.i1<br />
AI'thtll:' ASQUltli is !ttl mdllslrialist, Mr. Cyril AsquIth<br />
is a laWyer. MI'. Lloyd (jearge'll l\\Ttl sans lU"a in<br />
bllsif1t!!!IEl. Mr. BonM L1w's soH tllchard Is stddylllg<br />
law. Mr. RltlI1!1ay MacDonaldls (lldest BOn 1s ltt1<br />
atchitect. ms yortnget' sod Matcolm is wrIUr1!t II<br />
Uoolt bn his recent ti'ip i'dllnd th~ wOl'ld. MI'. OliVe!'<br />
Balt1wifi, tli@ soh tjf thE! present dl1tiServll.tlVe Prifile<br />
Minister, is a labour parW uiili, add gtow!f ~e!t~~<br />
tliUlefj "fld tears tjhicltehs,<br />
:Il!vei'ywhate to.day boy. Itt-a playing It~ Uti)'<br />
rcl.wkes, btlt it lack!! the "at-ieW Ilfid,llhthust:l.l!nl. th:l.t<br />
Were mafiif(!st yeafe agd. Tliet'E! is ted ilintlh 5f<br />
aetionl!tlt'lll~ iii ihtl {loutitI'Y, :ilid. it ll.J:t6Cts natinliat<br />
Mlebrat,iotlS, which was in'lfketl Wlt.1i tlia mirtli il.tid<br />
ffeedon1 of a happy tJ~6t:Jla.<br />
,. INDIAN 0PiNI0N it<br />
SUMtripti6fl Rate!l.<br />
Wi'l'iUN tltt~ UNIoN: B. d.<br />
%early ••• 20 {1<br />
Half-Yearly 10 6<br />
OUTSIlJE tHE UNION and OVERSEAS I<br />
8.<br />
I,. 20<br />
'tI 11<br />
«.<br />
o<br />
6
~ ndiatt<br />
./<br />
~piuion<br />
No. 51-Vol. XXIII. Friday, December 18th, 1925.<br />
Re, stored.t tbe G. P.O ••• a N ..... per<br />
PRIGS I'OUU."'8<br />
MQ. C. F. ANDQEWS' WELCOME IN DUI{BAN<br />
'1\l MASS MEETING was held in Durban on<br />
LMl Sunday Dec. 13th to welcome ~rr. C. F.<br />
Andr8ws. The Rawat Bio Hall was crowded<br />
to its utmost capacity and the welcome was of the<br />
most enthusiastic character throughout. Mr. Andrews<br />
had pleaded that there should be no public meetings<br />
so that more time might be given to hard work but<br />
consented to one meeting being held !lO that he<br />
might specially meet the poor people who are to li'e<br />
found in great numbers round Durban. 'l'he gathering<br />
was a truly remarkable one and will be long remembered<br />
by the Durban and district Indian community.<br />
On the day before Mr. Andrews had spent<br />
the day motoring as far as Stanger and meetiug the<br />
Indian community both at that place and at Tongaat.<br />
Thertl had been also many long discussions concerning<br />
the critical situation that had arisen, owing to<br />
Dr. Malan's fateful announcement that there would<br />
be no Round Table Conference, but only the oppor·<br />
tunity given to discuss the terms of the Bill in Select<br />
Committee. All the members of the Executive of<br />
the S.A. Indian Congress had accompanied Mr<br />
Andrews throughout Saturday and had held conferences<br />
at every available moment.<br />
Mr. C. F. Andrews was enthusiastically cheered<br />
as he entered the Hall and he was received by Mr.<br />
V. Lawrence, Vice-Chairman of the Natal Indian<br />
Congt:ess, who is acting as President in the absence<br />
of Mr. Amod Bayat on deputation. He looked very<br />
tired, but was evidently deeply touched by his reception.<br />
and shook hands heartily with those who<br />
were near him and seemed to Le at home at once<br />
with all who were present recognising many old<br />
friends.<br />
Mr. V. Lawrence said that thera was no need<br />
whatever to • introduce' Sadhn C. F. Andrews in<br />
Durban where he was known' and loved by the<br />
whole Indian community on account of his devotion<br />
to humanity. Wherever Indians had trouble Mr.<br />
Andrews was certain to be the first to arrive on the<br />
scene to help.<br />
Other speakers followed one after the other who<br />
struck the same note of welcome. The word 'Sadhu'<br />
was used again and again by those who spoke to<br />
describe what they felt concerning the nature and<br />
character of his visit.<br />
Mr. Andrews in reply begnn by quoting the Sdnshit<br />
man/ram, which the Poet, Rabindranath Tagore<br />
had given to him on this as well as on former occasions<br />
to carry to the Indian people in South Africa.<br />
It spoke from first to last of God. It gave the vision<br />
of God. It directed the thought away from the<br />
world to God. The name of God was first and last<br />
itl it, and all in all, In the same way, in accord.mce<br />
with the spirit of this mantrnm, in obedIence to the<br />
6haIJlam. /)/tivam, Adt'allalll,<br />
he had come out again to South Africa. It was true<br />
as the Chairman had sald, that Mahatma Gandhi and<br />
the Mahakavi, Rabindrnnath Tagore, had sent him.<br />
but it wall still more true (though he said it with the<br />
utmost humility and reverence and awe) that he had<br />
been sent to them by God. FOl' it WdS only when ~t<br />
last the 'nner voice within was so strong that he<br />
could not resist it that he came, and that inner voice<br />
was not from man but God.<br />
Therefore, Mr. Andrews said. in the struggle<br />
which was before them,-a struggle which was the<br />
most serious to the community of any in which<br />
they had ever been engaged,-they must remember<br />
God an.1 put their trust in God alone.<br />
The audience were very deeply moved by this<br />
opening of his speech, which Mr. Andrews with<br />
great emotion spoke first in Sanskrit (while giving<br />
the words of the mantram) and then in Urdu. He<br />
then went on to tell the story of the Prophet Muhammad<br />
and his noblest follower Abu Bekr in the<br />
Cave how when thousands of enemles were all<br />
round and they were in the cave, Abu Bekr said,<br />
• We are only two' but the great Prophet had rebuked<br />
him and saiel • No. A Third iii with us,-God<br />
Himself.' Even so, if God was with the Indian<br />
community then however great, their opponents<br />
might be, God was greater still and He would give<br />
the victory.<br />
Mr. Andrews went on to tell in most touching<br />
words the story of Mahatma Gandhi's suffering dnd<br />
loss of health in India and also about the Poet,<br />
Rabindrnnath Tagore, his own Gurudev, how ill he<br />
was, and how very hard it had been to part with<br />
him and come over to South Africa. He wished if<br />
possible, in accordance with Mahatma Gandhi's injunctions,<br />
to have very few meetings and receptions,<br />
so that there might be time for quiet work both by<br />
seeing people personally, Indian and European,<br />
and also by writing. They must learn to regard him<br />
rather as a writer than as a speaker and must give<br />
him the time neetled to get his writing done.<br />
Mr. Andrews has been studying the conditions of<br />
the poor people among the Indian community along<br />
the coast and in Durban itself and has laid constant<br />
stress on the rE'markable desire for further educational<br />
facilitirs , .. hich he has found everywhere to<br />
prevail. of all thl' needs of the community he feels<br />
that this spiritual need of higher education of an<br />
tnnobling character is the greatest and he is d8voting<br />
lUuch attention to this subject.
iNptAN OPINION t>ecernber 18th, 1925<br />
::7"2 -.. _<br />
[))<br />
A DISGRAOEFUL SPEECH<br />
It. MALAN'R utlieratitJe Ih inkOOuoitlg t~~ new<br />
Asiatic BIll has given rise ~ a bumber bf<br />
speeches uttered in a similar tofte, but none of<br />
those we have read has come qUIte up to ~bat of the Rev.<br />
M. L. Fick; M.L.A.; for Its brutally an-Christian sptrit.<br />
Addre;~iI1g a largl! ib~fetIi\g hi ttle Potcbefstfifafu Tol\it1<br />
Hall btl the fmmlgrlttlOtl and Registration BIll (lili it is<br />
called by the speaker), he explained its exact me~nin~ to<br />
the audieh~. iliA Wb~Bhip tlrtl Mayof ~~~sided. It iii<br />
interesting to note that the meeting was "entirely free<br />
from party I\olitics." We take the authentic telegraphic<br />
accoBnt 8ent 'to bbe newilpapers fr6m Potcbefstroom.\<br />
Mr. Fick saId ~hat the main ob~ect of the ~Ill was to<br />
make provisIOn for the reservatIon of residential and<br />
trading quat1ers il1 urluln at-eas for t:ertaln (1e1'8OJlS hat_<br />
ing raee rharabteristms different from white p-eople. Thtl<br />
onl! p'etlple whB at preKent wol\ld -bt! llffeeled WUilld be<br />
the AeialiiOlY.<br />
&z now we knbw quite -definitely fl'dm Mt: Fick that<br />
all the elaborately an'atlged camoufiage tJrepal'OO by Dr~<br />
Mal!tn for avoidmg the word I ASiatic' in nrdel' to aMd<br />
wonnding Indtan ettsCeptiibthtres will dedliite B6 mre at<br />
all. The Bill has become rIglftlt (!alied The AIlITl.ti'b Bill<br />
and the only people to be affected by it are AsiatICS. It<br />
is well that Governmenb supporters are now making that<br />
point aosolutely clear.<br />
l"he n.ev. M. 'L. Fick goes on to say, that the Government,<br />
aia hot wanL tile "coolie II to become part and<br />
parcel of the popUlation of South AfrICa t for social, commlH'Oilll<br />
lurd ~oon'on.llo ~easolIM.' It i~ dIffict.ilt W kJt6w<br />
what to do wtien peo~e, wIto o1:l~ht to 1t~ow l1ette1',<br />
delibWclltely USe ah iillllllting Word sucii all "Cdcli'e" to<br />
delft!Hbe 1l. wMle dOIfimflblty, ~l1'd thll inl!l1~t b'ffel'E!d by<br />
thIS tt!ve1'\lfid g'eilttedJlan bed~$ ~n the wtn'se "'hell It is<br />
rertltiJbbM'ed ~hat lte pl'O~& t~ b~ the to1M'Wer aM<br />
wotthiptJer'6f O\'J.~<br />
Mfu m -A'Sla, ivb6m ho d6ublt he<br />
wotHd ha~ 'M,lllid a "'OdOhe, rl if Chri'st had lived. ih ihm<br />
lan-d \llong wHh His ASl.atrc bMlre'ts an'd stst~.<br />
II W'e do Mt *all.t, '" /saId MI". FICk, \I lid tlttCdut'a'g'e<br />
tra'ding \+hf'Clh 'suck-\! tM Wry life-Wood '6f'th'e people ilttd<br />
lea~e'S il.dthHIg at 'alL We do iiOt want a pa~sitlc'al comm~ia.l<br />
MM'lffiinfty iii Uli§ oobntry."<br />
It IS mtere'lting to remember that the charge 'o~ befng<br />
a parasiticlH oommunity is exactly the on.e whidh Dt.<br />
In~e, President of tbe Eugenist Society, LOB600, ~evels<br />
against the white community in SoutJh Africa., beoause<br />
they refuse to do manual labour and inS1st 011 hving<br />
upon the labour of the natiVllS, coloured people- ~lld lBdialis.<br />
Mr. Fick, iu the course of further remarks, pointed<br />
out that the ilpread of Mohammedamsm among the<br />
natives wall to undermine the tn:fl.llenee of ChristIanIty<br />
and to be wbversive of whIte oivilisa.tion. 11ldiafl&,<br />
being Bl'ltish subjects, eould not. be summarily ifeftt e\1t,<br />
of the cmmtry, as wete the Cbinese; there.fOJ.'e they mU8t<br />
regulate the IndiaR aud place Slii>h teat-rict.Ions upon 'him<br />
that he would find it impossible to live In South AfrICa.<br />
We have, in these words, the echo 01 Dr. Millan's<br />
speE!cb, in introducing the new AsiatlJ Bill, when he<br />
said. 't'hat pressure wOllld be applted under the "BIll to lDduce<br />
as many Indians as pOSSible to leave the country.<br />
Dr. Malan's sentences are a IILtie smoother, but the<br />
meaning is tbe same.<br />
tn reply to this, it will 'be best to give, not our OWll<br />
words, but the words of the newspaper In Calcutta calced<br />
1he .statesman. This paper represents English opinIOu in<br />
India and is IIsuall! ift regard ho British Interests antI<br />
AsiatIC. Yet \l{ith tegarJ to thtl l'tesett bm it wtites in<br />
its edItorial as folluw8 I-<br />
I< The worst feature of this measure is its rlIshonesty.<br />
It propo~es to aim at proviihng special reservations to<br />
wbicb ASiatICS are to be restricted but its reftl Objl'Ct, at!<br />
was calmly adlnittt~lJ by Dr. lila/an; the M:ltlister of the<br />
f utl'rior, 18 to fol'oo as many Indhlll!l lUI possible to lellve<br />
the country through sheer nabilitl to. tolerate the new<br />
conchtiMA to be lbl~&!ed upon t.!efn.<br />
.1 Ii; is bad erlough that Indian citizens of the Empire<br />
snould be denied the ordinary rights of cItizensbIp by<br />
theIr fellow-eitlzens is S6UtAl Afrlcli : bttl. tlrere h \(ome"<br />
thmg almost diabolical m the crtJelty wtllch would ~lpel<br />
them, not by 8UOllllar, ClI:proptlltt.lOb, hut by tl procesil<br />
6f slow rorture."<br />
If the paflsag'e which we have ~UQted from tim Rev.<br />
M. Fick'e addres8 is eMeflll~ IItudied, it will be ~ft tbut.<br />
rhe remarks of the 8ta-[(Jsman ediboi'ifsl are m:mtl too<br />
Strong abaat it.<br />
a the course ()f th~ di1lellMiOB wbich followed we rtlSd<br />
tbat Mi'. Fick Baid that tile term!! gf tlie Bill were retroo<br />
lipeotive te AllgUll't, lIJ2[h The \Vo\'d I 8eqYlire' precluded<br />
Indians frem tnheriti9tJ property, fot ml!ltaB1le, in<br />
municipal MeM. A li&w,yl!l' itt the l:Il1Ul~rrct! iflj!i~ted that<br />
this should bemaliesblwll1teIYdear.MI.. FfCk., thete.<br />
lipoll, nndeftook to mo..e ill that diteeLiOll t\'ben the BIll<br />
Was before Pat'lra.'Il1ellt ..<br />
Iii this crosiltg iICl\Jtle at tb'e Poteb"efsU'oom nnAAli'1g we<br />
cart ahxrost see t.hts tiI~ting, t\'bUih \Vas 'efltir\lly tree<br />
from party vohtirs\ ' (betmfse Ol! the Indian qlleeti
December 18th, 1925<br />
tNDtAt4 OPI~lON<br />
ber. lie i. the Aroham~edan member on the tmpel'ial<br />
Council of Stat. tor the United Provinces,<br />
represenwng the Mohammedans of ()udh. The third<br />
member is Sir Deviprasad Sarvaralkari, who i. also<br />
a memher of the Couneil of State. representing the<br />
non-Mohammedan community in Bengal. ite is an<br />
old man and if! accompanied b, his 8On. II. will<br />
arrive hr the next boat on becember 30, and will<br />
join the Ilepntation immediately on arrival.<br />
Mr. Paddison acts sa an official member on the d0-<br />
patalion whiH! the lIon. Byed Raza Ali and Sir Dev ..<br />
prasad Sarvardikari act aa non-official members.<br />
Mr. G. s. Bajpai, who has boon acting 38 beputy<br />
Secretarl' or the GovernmeJlt of india in the 1m·<br />
perlal Searetariat at Delhi on this emigration subjeat,<br />
aooempaniM the deputaUoD as its secretary. Mr. C.<br />
s. ,ftickett ada as hil usistanl<br />
fJ'he main llurpOlle ot the deputation" will be<br />
.. to collect 38 soon .. pOl!8ible first-hand information<br />
regarding the economic oonditioD.l and the general<br />
poBiUon 01 the resident Illdian oommunity in South<br />
Africa and to form an appreciatioll of the wishes and<br />
requirements ot the Indian community in South<br />
Mrica."<br />
•<br />
~very read.r of Indian 0l'znwn is rOQ,lI61ted to fur- -<br />
nish eith.8I' the gener .. l secretary of tile South African<br />
Indiatl Oo~reslll 175 Ore, Street, Durban. from aUf<br />
part 01 the Union. or the secretanes of the provincial<br />
bodies namely, 'rhe Niltal Indian OOllgreSi,<br />
Foulldi.1 Lane. Durban, The Tmnavaal British 10.<br />
dian As8ociatio~ Box 6522. Johannesburg and The<br />
Cape llrHish lndian Council. 28 A,vre Street, Capetown,<br />
with lull part;iculan of 31lf licenliDg or other<br />
cases in which an Injustice may have been done and<br />
ot which he may be aware. These particulars<br />
will then be laid before the deputatJol1. It is essential<br />
thai such particulars should be full and facts<br />
contained therein absolutely correct.<br />
Rev. M. L. Fick on ASiatics<br />
Friday.-Tke Rev. M. L. Fick,<br />
Potchefstroo~<br />
M.L.A., addressed a well-attended meeting in the<br />
Town Halllalilt night aod explained the Immigrat.i.on<br />
and negistration ami which the Qovernment propoAes<br />
to introduce early in the next sesllion of Parliament.<br />
The meeting was called by requisitioning<br />
the Mayor, who presided. 1t was entirely free of<br />
part, politiOi.<br />
_<br />
~r. Fick said !:.he main obieck 01 the Bill was to<br />
make provision for the reservation of residential and<br />
trading quarters in urban areas lor certail'J. personil<br />
having race characteristics different lrom whioo<br />
people. The only people who at present would be<br />
affected were AsIatics. 'rhe (lQvernment did no,<br />
want ~ t.he cooUe" to become part and parcel of the<br />
po{>ulaUon
Right of ent~y and residence in anyone Province<br />
does not include right to enter or remain in any<br />
other Province. There is no right of inter-provincial<br />
migration and a person lawfully domiciled in<br />
anyone Province may be a prohibited immigrant in<br />
any other and liable to the statutory penalties.<br />
Persons convicted of certain specified offences are<br />
liable to removal from the Union (Sec. 22).<br />
O,tus probandt is on the accused to prove his innocence<br />
(Sec. 23).<br />
The legal wife of an exempted person is not entitled<br />
to admission, if SUCD. person has in any Province<br />
offspring by any other woman who IS still<br />
living (22 of 1914, Sec. :3 (2) (b) ).<br />
In the ~atal<br />
and Cape Provinces domiciliary<br />
rights and right of educational tests under Act 30 of<br />
1906 Cape of Good Hope and Act 30 of 1903 of<br />
Natal are preserved to such persons as were lawfully<br />
entitled to reside in the said Provinces at the commencement<br />
of Act 22 of August 1913.<br />
The Orange Free State J~aws prohibit immigration<br />
or resIdence of Indians within that Province, save as<br />
as domestic servants and the like under contract.<br />
The Smuts-Gandhi agreement of 1914 provided<br />
that the Indians should accept the principle of restriction<br />
upon further Indian Imigration to this extent<br />
that ten new comers per annum for each Province<br />
(excluding Free State) should be admitted,<br />
apart from temporarv visitors such as priests, teachears,<br />
etc., so that the resident population should<br />
have the benefit of the mfusion of some new blood.<br />
It was also understood, that such new comers must<br />
be recommended by the official representative Body<br />
of the Indians and be snch as that Body should<br />
select on the ground of their usefulness to the community.<br />
Such new comers were to enjoy all the<br />
privileges allowed by law to holders of registration<br />
certificates.<br />
Restrictions upon the Freedom of Indians<br />
recognised as Lawful Residents of the Union<br />
including those born in South Africa.<br />
TRANSVAAL;<br />
Indian disabilities have their root in the Grondwet<br />
(Constit.ution) of the Old Transvaal Republic<br />
which declares that there must be no equalIty III<br />
Church or State between whites and non-whites.<br />
The doctrine is still preserved.<br />
REGISTRATION<br />
(LAW 3 OF 1885, ACT 2 OF 1907, ACT 36, OF 1908)<br />
All male adult Indians lawfully residing in the<br />
Transvaal must hold and produce on demand to any<br />
police or other officer a registration certificate lawfully<br />
issued under Act 3{} of 1908 or a letter of<br />
Exemption issued under the Smuto-Gandhi agreement.<br />
Temporary visitors such as priests, teachers,<br />
etc., must similarly produce their anthority to be in<br />
the Province. Women and children under the age<br />
of 16 years may be called upon to prove their relationship<br />
as wives or children to one or other of<br />
above classes of adulls. The statutes above cited<br />
disclose a gradually increasing stringency. The original<br />
note struck by the S.A. Republic is not only<br />
sllbtained, bnt has been amphfied by st:.l.tnte by<br />
every succeeding Government. Adult ma.le Indians,<br />
other than holtlers of registration certificates,<br />
letters of exemption or temporary permIts are prohibited<br />
immigrants and are h of fixe,] property<br />
can in law only be acqull'ed through proccss of<br />
registmtion of such property in the Deeds Register.<br />
Such Wards, Locations, etc, as above ref('rreJ to are<br />
MUUlclpal property, and residence thl'l!'in by ASiatics<br />
confers no fiXIty ot tenure. Orulll,mly a<br />
monthly rent.'tlls paid (mel the ten,mcy IS a monthly<br />
one.<br />
Prior to the 1st of May, 1!}1!\ fixed property<br />
might be held by hmited lIabilIty companIes forme,l<br />
of India &hareholders, or mIght be hl:'ld by a European<br />
trustee for the benefit of an IndIan or Inumns.<br />
The practice was for such European holders to P,lSS<br />
a bond in favour of the beneficiary or benefiCl,lries<br />
and to grant powers of attorney to ('ruble the actual<br />
owner to deal with snch property. Ad:n of l!H!)<br />
specifically depnves limIted halllhty comp,IUles controlled<br />
by AsiatICs of the right to h-\ve fi "{cd property<br />
registered in thelr names and applIes the prohibItion<br />
under L'lw :3 of 1885 to such companies. The practice<br />
of a European holder takmg snch property in<br />
trust and passing a mortgage bond by W,ly of secunty<br />
is likeWIse made impOSSible. Any such company<br />
controlled by Asiatics as shall have acqlllred the<br />
ownership of fixed property smce the 1st of 1\1 Ly.<br />
1919, is compelled to dispose of same WIthin two<br />
years from the :lrd July, 1919, or by Order of Court<br />
(Sec. 2 i~id.) The 3rd of July, l!H!), is the date of<br />
the commencement of this Act.<br />
The Johannesburg location known a~ the "!\I,ILIY<br />
L'lcation," the local hahltat of ASIatic residents Ii<br />
notorIously the shIm of Johannesburg and for ye,lrs<br />
was unspeakably neglected by the l\Iunicip,llity.<br />
More recently, probably through fC,lr of infeclious<br />
disE-ase breaking out m that Ilnartcr, this location<br />
has received more attention and its conditions are<br />
now slightly Improved.<br />
(7"0 oe COItflHurd )<br />
Things in India<br />
(By MR. C F. ANDREIVS )<br />
I<br />
It is quite natllral that I should be asked, immediately<br />
on my arrival in Sonth Africa, by every<br />
onl'I meet,,-'How are thmgs in In,fia?" There is<br />
always a freshness in what is heard at first hand,<br />
compared with what one reads in ,listdnt nf>Wllpapers<br />
which are already sevel'al weeks olel when they arrIve.<br />
The first questIOn of all. Uldt everyone WIshes to<br />
know and that I WIsh t? answer, IS WIth reg,ml to<br />
Mahatma Gandhi's health. It IS nece~,l.Iry for all<br />
Indians in South Africa to reahse. that the stram of<br />
the last seven years has been almo~t more than he<br />
could hear. In the year l!I1X, he h,l,l an Illness<br />
which brought him very near to cle,ltll indeed.<br />
Dnrmg the year 191!'J, he was partly rf>covel·ing<br />
from this almost fatal attack of elysentry; anti yet<br />
towards the end of that year, oWlIlg to the Pnnj,Lb<br />
disturbances and the Congres:i Investig.ltion which<br />
followed, he had no c111nc9 of lll,lkln~ a inll and<br />
complete recovery. Therefol"{', when the gre.lt national<br />
movement began, called Non-co-operation, he was<br />
still very weak In bo,ly. I c LIl rememb'lr how<br />
prostl"
December 18th, 1925 INDIAN OPINION 327<br />
--- --------------------------------------------<br />
llifp, which served to increase his ill health; an4 he<br />
oVl'riltrained hims~lf again mntally by his extraordinary<br />
absorption in study and reading; for this<br />
nu'ntai enrgy now took the phce of his former<br />
activity in outward things. Whatever might be the<br />
callRe, in prison be hecame at i.u;t very unwell; and<br />
at a mOAt critical moment, when his hfe itself was at<br />
stak. the operation for appendicitis was performed.<br />
Then a conval('scE'nce for some months ensued. This<br />
convalescence wa'! all too soon brought to a· ... close.<br />
and o/Jce more tbe round of outward activities began.<br />
whkh l,ecame almost never ending. Day and<br />
night wel'e alike taken up With the demands, which<br />
were made upon him for 'dmRhan' and for special<br />
ViRUS to every part of the country. Only those who<br />
have hpl'll with him on thoRe journeys can have any<br />
Idea how tcrllLle the iltrain WaS! One after another<br />
of his companiollR who accompanied him broke<br />
down under it. bnt he himself seemed never to give<br />
way. As I have said, It was only his inner spirit<br />
that, sustained him.<br />
Again, last year. came all the agony of the Hindul\fuAlim<br />
rIOts and disturbances, which reached such<br />
a pitch at last. that MahatmaJi felt It impossible. to<br />
endure the anguish of them any longer. Night<br />
after night he lay aW.J.ke. ql1lte sleepless, seeking for<br />
some light to gmde him III the darkness. Then<br />
sudddenly there came to him, as it. a Vision direct<br />
from God, a flash of illumination. He declared his<br />
determination to fast for twenty-one days both as a<br />
penance and as a means of healing the terrible<br />
brt;ach between the two communitIes, which had<br />
grown wider and WIder.<br />
All through that fabt,-as also through his previous<br />
illncl'''''s,-lt was my very gre,ltest privilege to<br />
be with him. It is not possible here fully to record<br />
all that happened: and it h:ts been told many times<br />
before. But it may eaSily be understood. how<br />
serious the physlc"l strain was, when I write, that<br />
on the twelfth day of the fast the doctors regarded<br />
hiS life as in serious danger and implored him to<br />
break the fast itself. IllS charactenstic reply was<br />
'Have fdlth in God.' In that faith. he conqnered his<br />
physical illness ancl came through triumphant.<br />
At the end of the fast, his recovery of health was<br />
quite remarkable. After a few weeks he was cert,liniy<br />
better, both in body and mind, than he had<br />
been for many years Even his remarkable walkin~<br />
poweri came back again. and he would start out,<br />
WIth his long stick in hand, at such a pace, that itwas<br />
cl:fficnlt fOI' those with him sometimes to<br />
keep up with him I Indeed, at this time, he was<br />
able to accomplish as much as ten DlIies a day; and<br />
he kept up his stt'pngth all through the cold weather<br />
of 1924-1\)25.<br />
But suddenly, about April, 1925, came a most unexpected<br />
attack of malarMI fever: and though he<br />
appeared to throw it off QUickly, it is clear that the<br />
malarial poison still remdined in his blood. Yet<br />
even then he began all too soon, at an extremely<br />
early date, to go on tour again after the attack; and<br />
when he came to Bengal in order to meet with<br />
Deshbandhu C. R. Das, it was clear to me that the<br />
strength, whICh he had regained all through the<br />
cold weather. was rapidly bClDg dissipated. .<br />
FiullUy came one of the greatest sorrows he has<br />
ever had. Deshbandhu died quite suddenly at<br />
Darjeeling; and in a moment all tho cares and responsibihties<br />
fell upon him alone. which Deshbandhn<br />
C. n. Das had carried before. He remained in<br />
Calcntta and BElngal for three full months collecting<br />
for the Df>shbandhu Memorial Fund. He wore himself<br />
out, day after ddY, WIth an energy and devotion<br />
that never tired. At last. ill the month of September,<br />
even hiS own amazing vitdlity began to show<br />
signs again of weakening. He pleadell to be 'lllowed<br />
to cancel the tellt of his viSit in Behar and the<br />
t1n1tG4 l'rgv!t1dc:_,1II1l that hu, ftll"M fett1l't1. \I'! hili<br />
I'1wn ABram, The (loIlRre •• l"cal leadsn of \he Hortb<br />
frl'ely and gladly gave him leave: and he went b'I.Ck<br />
to Western Inllia in the hope of obtaining some rest.<br />
But the people of Kutch had made up their minds<br />
to have him with them: and they implored him not<br />
to cancel his Kutch visit. They promised him a<br />
complete holiday. if he would only remain in the<br />
KIJtch State as their revered and venerated guest.<br />
Mahatma Gandhi agreed to this; but the idea of<br />
giving him a 'holiday' was hardly understood in its<br />
proper sense by the Kutch pea pie. Indeed, instead<br />
of any reRt and repose, he was compelled to undergo<br />
the most physically t>xhausting time of the<br />
whole year over the rongh Kuth roads. Not only<br />
was he physically tired out; bnt his mind also was<br />
shocked and pained by what he saw of UntouchabilIty<br />
in all its evil effects in that corner of India.<br />
Perhaps the mental strain he endured in Kntch was<br />
greater even than the physical. He lost ei"ht<br />
pounds in weight in a fortnight's time, and when he<br />
reached Sabarmati at last he was entirely exhausted.<br />
But his marvellons spiritual vitality still sustains<br />
him; and when I went to se') him, just before I left<br />
for South Africa, he had again wonderfully recovered.<br />
He was very bright and cheerfnl; and he<br />
was again able to do his work right on throughout<br />
the day. He sent his love and deep affection to all<br />
both Indians and Europeans who remember him in<br />
South Africa.<br />
His day's work in India begins at 4: a.m. with his<br />
prayer and worship of God. He goes on with hia<br />
different engagements throughout the day. He lives<br />
mainly on two thJngs,-oranges and goat's milk. It<br />
is not possible alas! now to assert that his old physical<br />
vigour has all returned; for he gets easily tired<br />
in body and a short walk is quite enough for him.<br />
Nevertheless, his mental and intellectual energy is<br />
as fresh as ever: and his spiritual hold over the<br />
masses of the people of India,-Hindu and Musalman<br />
alike,-is by no means abated. Wherever he<br />
goes, the whole countrysid, for miles round, flocks<br />
to see him; and in homely simple ways he drives<br />
home the lesson, (0 of getting rid of untouchability,<br />
(ii) of healing the breach between Hindus and Mos<br />
It'ms, (iii) of never touching drink or drugs. and last<br />
and most enthusiastically of all (iv), the duty of<br />
wearing homespun khaddar cloth and thus reviving<br />
Indian village hfe on itA economic side.<br />
~~~~~~ »o,»)o,>l;>,»;»;»;>.,);»> ~<br />
~ OUR LONDON LETTER !<br />
, [ FROM OUR OWN CORRESPONDENT] .:<br />
! 12th November, 1925. i<br />
o~E(E(E );>~);»> 0<br />
The Begum of Bhopal is still in London. On hAr<br />
visit to the Mosque at Weking, she was presented<br />
with an address by Lord Headly, on behalf of the<br />
British Muslim Society. In reply she declared that<br />
she was proud to belong to the British Empire,<br />
which stood for the toleration of all religions. Her<br />
visit, apart from her being a Muslim, was of peculiar<br />
interest, for her descendants had largely contribnted<br />
to the building of the Mosque, and she herself had<br />
promised to help in t.he extension of the Mosque,<br />
the better to enable it to accommodate ifs increasing<br />
worshippers.<br />
The Bl'gum was a deeply interested spectat or of<br />
the proceedings, during the two minutes silence at<br />
the Cenotaph on Armistice Day. She was so impressed<br />
with the significance of it all : the memory<br />
of the fallen, the widows, the orphans, and the disabled.<br />
anJ. what was due to them all by those who<br />
live, that to mark her sense of appreciation she sent<br />
a cheque for £5,000 to Earl Haig's Fund for the<br />
British Legion. But this was not all, she allowed<br />
her graud daughters clad in Highland dress to sell<br />
poppies on Poppy Day in London.<br />
Emile OOlle the rttlneb p~(lbolo!Jiet. dill
INDIAN OPINION December 18th. 1"5<br />
an interested audience on Sunday last. His theme<br />
was based on auto-suggestion, in his well-known<br />
tormula.: "Day by day, and in every way I am<br />
getting better and better." And dUring the evening<br />
he-gave demonstrations of the effect of autosuggestion,<br />
manifesting that the formula comprehensive<br />
in its terms and beneficial in its general<br />
effects was susceptible to variations to meet cases of<br />
differing natures. Coueism is really nothing new.<br />
It is simply anto-Bugge8tion. And within the last<br />
decade the Bame teaching found expression in America<br />
ap.d was known as "The New Thought" It. system<br />
of positive affirmation.<br />
Anto-sllggestion hal! come to stay. There is much<br />
in it to cymmend itself. The Archbishop of Oanterbury<br />
is appointing a commission of six clerical and<br />
six medic.a.l members on a permanent commission to<br />
in~estigate faij;h-healing, in order to separate the<br />
functions IS of the cJergy and the physicians in cases<br />
where faith-healing is possible. The seuaration of<br />
functions to help the physician to tend the body<br />
and the clergy the mind of the patient· in other<br />
words each recognising the ntility and necessity of<br />
t~e l!ervices of the other, so that they act in co-ordination<br />
working for the same purpose.<br />
The Home Secretary's announcement that as soon<br />
as the stock-in-hand IS exhausted prisoners' clothes<br />
will no longer be marked witli tlte broad arrow, wiU<br />
be well received by all those who are interested in<br />
the WOrk of giving the man who comes out of prison<br />
a living chance of a new life. The broad arrow is the<br />
sign of government ownership, but used to mark the<br />
prisoners' clothes it has come to mean a degradation<br />
to those who wear it, a stigma which seems to cling<br />
to the wearer. Its disappearance will set film wrij;ers<br />
and producers thj.uking; for without it pictUres of<br />
daring escap/tdes of prisoners would lack much<br />
of bhe thrill. Perhaps tlle,. will resort to the<br />
stripes on prisoners' clothes which are in vogue in<br />
American prisons, or the imagination of the :t51m<br />
men may produce something sensational in this line<br />
for convict pictures.<br />
Mr. James Oliver Curwood, the American author<br />
whol3e novels are full of the wild and simple life,<br />
was recentlr in London. It was his first visit. And<br />
this is how he expressed himself to a pressman:<br />
"Hardly had I been twenty-four hoult's in this city<br />
than my Indian blood cried out for the wilderness,<br />
tbe wilds, the thousands of miles lilnmapped, Un.<br />
charted, w4ere thlil most beautiful :flowers in the<br />
world grow, where you meet real white men. It<br />
~n't that I don't like London. For what little I have<br />
seen of It I love immensely, but I love the cold<br />
fightmg North where the pack on your back is the<br />
l'Iole barrier to sta.rvat.ion for months on end, and<br />
where the cut of your clothes don't count; where<br />
you can't preSs a button to light a fire and where<br />
there is not 8ufficiel1t wood to build a match within<br />
a thousand miles of y011. On the ... vay over I s').w<br />
three whales in the ooean, and ther ma.de me homesick<br />
fol' mY' trozen north seas." He 1. It quarter Indian,<br />
his grandmother was It full blooded, Mobawk Indian,<br />
and one ot his grandfathers was Oharles Marriot,<br />
so the wild places are in his blood. Over 150,000<br />
copies of his bookS were sold in Ohina last yea,.<br />
Professor A. Zimmern is at the head of II. school<br />
~tarted at Geneva, the- City of Lost Hopes and<br />
Causes. The school aims to give its pupIls the<br />
tllternationai student mind and itself pnrposes to<br />
learn about and think out those problems which<br />
affect every citizen as a social unit. whether he be-<br />
longs to a sovereign state, a. colony or a mandated<br />
territorY; but Professor Horace Lamb recently remind·<br />
ed the world that Science could not alter human nature<br />
Ilnd yet Socrates held that Virtue is Kllowledge.<br />
1M Assembly of the League of Nations this year<br />
has devdt~d Much time to education. it realises that<br />
edddatidd is tHE! greatest 111t!.uetide in the world to<br />
@feM.8 ttl. ~12»~l p,t.tl~",!lll Q.a~~r, ,,," the Bcldev,,><br />
ment of ita objects. A world CongreRS of Bchool<br />
teachers will probably be convened In the near<br />
future to consider the best methods to educate the<br />
you~h of aU countries in the ideals or world peaC8<br />
so that solidarity may be further dt'veloped and<br />
str(ingthened. A resolution at the Assembly Invited<br />
tbe members to undertake the reVision of their<br />
history manuals so as gradually to r£>dnce the number<br />
ot pages devoted to military events and especially<br />
those pages in which wars of c~nquel!!t are<br />
justified and beld np for admiration. The Intellectoal<br />
Co-operative Committee which deals with eJucatjonal<br />
problems has its Chairman Prof. Henry<br />
Bergson and among its members PrOfessors EinsteIn<br />
and Gilbert Murray.<br />
The King has approved the grant ot a Royal<br />
Charter to the League of Natlonlt Union. Tho<br />
Charter is granted on the petition ot Lord Grey of<br />
Fallodon. and I .. ord Cecil of Chelwood-the two<br />
Presidents of the Union,-Professor Gilbert Morray<br />
Chairman of the Executive Committee, Lord Lueenboroug,<br />
treasurer, Mr. David Davies M.P. and Mr.<br />
Reginald McKema.<br />
=<br />
Racialism<br />
(ay L. w. R.)<br />
Selfishness, sometimes euphemistically styled<br />
" Self-preservation" Is one of 'IJl unholy trinity.<br />
Its two companions are ignorance and intolerance.<br />
Merging, the three synthesise, prodUCing, aI! It were,<br />
the compound known as RaciaUllm. Racialism Is<br />
morally a virus that, once innoculated, spreads contagion<br />
broadcast.<br />
Its symptoms are hatred and<br />
blindness to any virtue in the unhappy objects of ita<br />
hatred. Its victims, like those of hydrophobia go mad<br />
and run amok, before themselves meeting destruction.<br />
Raos hatred is bitterest where ignorance Is deepest;<br />
tolerance is the brlg}:J.t offspring of Knowledge even<br />
as Selflessness is the child of Wisdom. The true<br />
Knower sees the One in all aDd all in the One. rocognises<br />
the pseudo-infinite variety of the Many as<br />
but appearances, on the screen of consciousness, of<br />
That which is the Limitless, Beginningless, Changeless<br />
Reality, the Substratum of all that is or seems.<br />
;Every oppo~ite is Been to be complementary of some<br />
othir that is oppol!lite to it, as is positive to negative.<br />
In the Cosmic economy every fraction ot the limitlass<br />
divetsity has its pla.ee and function; reflects.<br />
however modestly, l!Iome aspect of the Infinite<br />
Absolute Perfection. Attraction and repulsion have<br />
likewise their place and in their place are natural<br />
and proper; they too subserve the Law and Purpose<br />
that make for Harmony. But Hate is Evil, of all<br />
evils most evil. Stygian darkness fills the heart<br />
wherein bate dwells. The Spark of God within the<br />
heart, wherefor man is more than beast and whereby<br />
he may become mOt-e than man, cannot abide<br />
\'there hate rulel!!. Either the usurper must be cast<br />
Ol1t or the Spark abandon the man to the fate that is<br />
the beasts', "There ill no grief like Hate." And ..<br />
with man, 110 with manldnd-nations and 1'!l
Jttdian ~pinion<br />
No. 52~Vol_ XXIII. Friday, December 25th, 1925-<br />
J1eciotend.t tile o.p.o •••• Iir_<br />
Patall FolH!I'RC.II J<br />
. ,-<br />
MR. C. F. ANDREWS IN JOHANN·ESBURG'~·<br />
irUJ':i tolluwins add .. _ WIlQ given in Johannes- 1<br />
II burg at a meeting' ot c1ergy·and·--lait". .0--<br />
December 21st, 1925, and its substance was<br />
altlo delivered at St. Mary's Cathedral after evening<br />
on Snnday. December 20th. It was listened to by<br />
these European audiences with remarkable attention.<br />
"I will begin by repeating what my father, who<br />
was a devout Christian, used to call the Psalm of the<br />
Christian gentleman. It runs as follows:- •<br />
"Lord who shall dwell in thy tabernacle, or who<br />
shall rest upon thy holy hill?"<br />
"EveylClie that leadeth an uncorrupt life; and doeth<br />
the thing which is right ILnd speaketh the truth<br />
from -his.' heart.<br />
"He that hath used no deceit in his tongue, nor<br />
done eVlI to his neighbours; and hath not slandered<br />
his neigliliour.<br />
"Be t.hat setteth not by himself, but is lowly in<br />
his ~yesi and maketh much of them that fear the<br />
Lord. '<br />
~'He ·tbat promiseth unto his neighbour, and disappofntet:b.!<br />
him not; though it were to his own hindraMK",<br />
'''He that hath not given his money upon usury:<br />
nor taken reward against the innocent.<br />
"Whoso doeth these things shall never fall."<br />
In thio pidu,,, ot tbe true gentleman 1 want<br />
especially to note this one verse :-<br />
"lIe that promiseth to hili neighbour and disappointeth<br />
him not, though it were to his own<br />
hindrancJ\."<br />
For my position to-night is, that we who belong to<br />
the British Race and who are Christians, are in<br />
serions danger of doing the very opposite of this verse<br />
towards the Indian neighbour, who is in our midst;<br />
we are in danger of arguing from the immoral principle,<br />
that we are obliged to break our promises to<br />
India, because self-preservation, as a White Race,<br />
must come before anything else.<br />
Let me explain the pOSltion by historical facts,<br />
which cannot be disputed.<br />
When thE' first Indian immigrants came to Natal,<br />
in 18(;0, they were brought out from India at the<br />
special request of the Natal Government under<br />
pressure from the Dnrban Corporation. The desire<br />
WaS so great to keep them in the country, that in<br />
1870 it was t'nacted, that any indentured Indian at<br />
the expiry of 10 years residence in Natal might receive<br />
a crown grant of land instt>ad of his return<br />
passage. The terms on which they came were those<br />
of fnll domicile, with freedo:n to t>l;lgage in agricultural<br />
antI commercial pursuits as soon as their indenture<br />
was ovpr. The Government of India<br />
would not have allowed them under any other conuition.<br />
Mr. J. R. Saunders, speaking before the<br />
Natal Comniission of ISS.!, stated as follows ;-<br />
.. If we look back to 1859, we shall find that<br />
the assureu promise of Indian labour resulted<br />
in an immediate rise of revenue which increasei<br />
mise of renewed Indian immigration,,' and ' u,'p<br />
...again. went.. wages. 'revenue and eaIariee;" :, -<br />
From such contemporary records it. is clear, fhat<br />
Natal was brouglJ,i flom, the verge of banktUptCy<br />
more than once by the supply 'of Indian' indentured<br />
labour. Europeans HOCKed into Natal wnen each<br />
four-fold in a few years. Mechanics found<br />
their wages more than doubled. But, a few<br />
ypurs later, alarm arose lest Indian labour<br />
"ould be suspt:'nded. Simultaneously, down<br />
went revenue ana wages. Then came a protime<br />
of prosperity returned.<br />
' " , '<br />
The Asiatic Enquiry Commill8ion of 1921 adds<br />
another fact which it is n~ to bear in minlC<br />
The indenture system, under which they were<br />
brought out, was very little better than slaveri.<br />
The Lange Report rightly says ;-"It should be emphasised<br />
that there has been very little spontaneous<br />
emigration of the labouring classes from India to<br />
South Africa. They were recruited with difficlllty<br />
and not infrequently by methods which were CODlmonly<br />
known in India as "Coolie catching."<br />
Thn~ these thousands of Indian I3bou""" -{vho<br />
with their desce..ndants ,comprise ,by- far the ~i'<br />
proportion of In.dians in ~outh Afri
330 INDIAN OPINION<br />
,<br />
becember 25~h. __ 19 2 5 it<br />
traders sfill continued.<br />
So the sore remained open<br />
on both sidei!.<br />
Mr. O:okhaltl clUne out tn 1912, and by a statesm8tlliktl<br />
act llgreed that 110 objection would b') raised<br />
if the door of Natal was finally closel1 against all<br />
Indian ir?migration in the future, provided only<br />
that Indlans already domiciled in Natal received<br />
sympa~eti(}' treatment. The pltldge 01 such sympathetlc<br />
trellbfl.eht wouid be the immediate abolItion<br />
of the obnoxious £3 tax.<br />
General Smuw immeQiately tOGk itdvantage of this<br />
agreEmJeld ~lthMr, Ga1:ullle to pltBs thtJ ItullligratlOu<br />
Restrictfon Act of 1913, by which Indians of all<br />
classes were finally prohibited from entering ~outh<br />
Africl!,., No objection was raised against this eIther<br />
1W Mt. (iokMte, or Mr. Gandhi, or hy the Ihdian<br />
GovernmetJt, in MC'Ol'dllttce with wllltt was regarded<br />
as fn1 ggtee1nent t-eached by MI'. Gokhale1s visit to<br />
So'ttth AIrfoil.. Bat when It was aSked itt return<br />
that the £3 Gt:it shdu1d. be abolIshed no action in<br />
that direct.fon was taken. Mr. Gokhaie was the very<br />
soul of honour.<br />
He had taken that journey to<br />
South Altfca whHe In :IH health; it wM altogether<br />
agttlttBt the doc'torls
,7<br />
O~tember 25th, 1925 INUIAN OPtNIt)~ 331<br />
Imperial Conference in 1926, he coulurhood of New<br />
York. Roast beef and plum-pudding, tnrkey and bam,<br />
feasting in abundance,-these material things wcre everywhere<br />
in evidence; but not the spirit of the lowl)' Christ,<br />
born in a manger, in povertl and Buffering, del!tined to<br />
a lite of tJerpetual jacrlfice whose en~ was the Cross. He<br />
\\'t:ut~ to tnt!: .. These lJllople in tbe West are materi8lis~<br />
even in their most solemn religious teati,ail'."<br />
That scene ne witnessed in America was so entirely<br />
different from the quiet, joyous thanksgiving with whicb<br />
we celebrate Christmas at &ntini1i:etah! Therl', long<br />
before dawn, the boys of the Asram walk iu procession<br />
slowly throngh the mango groves singing their morning<br />
hymn,<br />
, Awake, A wake. the ti~ht is breaking.'<br />
Then follows the gathering of our househotd,-Hindns,<br />
Buddhists, Muslims, Parsecs, Jews and Chri!lLillns,<br />
rejo.clDt; tlog\ltlrer\ lJIll'cefully and t'everent,ly\ with<br />
methtlltloll, because of t.he birth of Christ. RabindranaLh<br />
Tag-ore himself giVe\! the setmon in the Mander at. our<br />
Christmans thanksgiving and in the afternoon the poor<br />
are ft!d aud thO$6 who do the hnmble wOI'k of sweepeJ'll<br />
for our Asram are specially honoured. One of my keen<br />
regrets, while I am writlDg tbese Word'!, is t.hall I shall<br />
miss t.his yelll' my Christma~ Day at. the Asram; and a<br />
holtle-aickn'es~ cr,\Ues over me at the thought<br />
But the Poot has sen~ me out to South Arncl with<br />
bls 0Wll mantram,-<br />
Sht\ntam, Shivam, Advaitam,<br />
and Mahat.ma Gandhi h1l.s bade me become a me>St.>ftger<br />
of pt>ace. tberefore t know that by obedience to their<br />
expressed wish l bave
__ 3_j~2~ __________________ I_N_D<br />
__ IA __<br />
N~O~P~I~N~I~O~N~ ____ ~n~e~ce~ber~?~h,<br />
I~~5<br />
ppcially Concerning Rabindranath Tagore. In the in ~leep, I seemed in my JI'eams to be stru~ghng<br />
Nearer.East also, among Arabs, Syrians and Egyptians<br />
whom I bave met, the two names which were<br />
~ga\J)st It. B~t the oppres~ion became overpow
/'December 25 th, 1925 INDIAN. OPINION 333'<br />
~1 pfl nor to coloured per<br />
Bon'i lawfully in occupation at the commencement<br />
of the Act.<br />
Act :\7 of 1m!) Sec. 1 amendd the above to the extellt<br />
that it acceptfl any BritiRh Indian, who, on the<br />
Il:1t dar of May, EllS, WdS l
INDJAN orIN ION<br />
December 25th. '9~S<br />
made to the African Govprnment. We may be<br />
call~d l1PDI1 by force to Rnrren,ll'l' our right~, but let<br />
ns glV~ nothmg away by weak conces"ion Let us<br />
never negotiate' concerning H~patl'i'ltion.<br />
thpm, not by summary expropriation, but by a process<br />
,of slo..y torture."<br />
An iQspection of tile ter~s of thp Bill itself<br />
shows that the word,s used above are none too strong;<br />
for abe clause after /.I.Ilotb.-er strikes at the root of all<br />
th~ truly ;rema.r/rnble growth, under lI)credIbJe hardsh!ps,<br />
Which th~ Indian CQml)lunity has made in Natal I ndian Congress<br />
Natal. That which has been gained by slow a,pd<br />
steady indu,stry and patiepce is to be cut dowI). in Il A request is being mad