Download Biological Diversity - New York State Museum
Download Biological Diversity - New York State Museum
Download Biological Diversity - New York State Museum
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Biological</strong> <strong>Diversity</strong>:<br />
T H E O L D E S T H U M A N H E R I T A G E<br />
By<br />
Edward O. Wilson<br />
NEW YORK STATE MUSEUM
<strong>Biological</strong> <strong>Diversity</strong>:<br />
T H E O L D E S T H U M A N H E R I T A G E
THE UNIVERSITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK<br />
R EGENTS OF THE U NIVERSITY<br />
Carl T. Hayden, Chancellor, A.B., J.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Elmira<br />
Diane O’Neill McGivern, Vice Chancellor, B.S.N., M.A., Ph.D. . . . . <strong>State</strong>n Island<br />
J. Edward Meyer, B.A., LL.B. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chappaqua<br />
R. Carlos Carballada, Chancellor Emeritus, B.S. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rochester<br />
Adelaide L. Sanford, B.A., M.A., Ph.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hollis<br />
Saul B. Cohen, B.A., M.A., Ph.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . <strong>New</strong> Rochelle<br />
James C. Dawson, A.A., B.A., M.S., Ph.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Peru<br />
Robert M. Bennett, B.A., M.S. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tonawanda<br />
Robert M. Johnson, B.A., J.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lloyd Harbor<br />
Peter M. Pryor, B.A., LL.B., J.D., LL.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Albany<br />
Anthony S. Bottar, B.A., J.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Syracuse<br />
Merryl H. Tisch, B.A., M.A. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Harold O. Levy, B.S., M.A. (Oxon.), J.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Ena L. Farley, B.A., M.A., Ph.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Brockport<br />
Geraldine D. Chapey, B.A., M.A., Ed.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Belle Harbor<br />
Ricardo E. Oquendo, B.A., J.D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
PRESIDENT OF THE UNIVERSITY AND COMMISSIONER OF EDUCATION<br />
Richard P. Mills<br />
CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER<br />
Richard H. Cate<br />
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER FOR CULTURAL EDUCATION<br />
Carole F. Huxley<br />
DIRECTOR FOR THE STATE MUSEUM<br />
Clifford A. Siegfried<br />
The <strong>State</strong> Education Department does not discriminate on the basis of age, color, religion, creed,<br />
disability, marital status, veteran status, national origin, race, gender, genetic predisposition<br />
or carrier status, or sexual orientation in its educational programs, services and activities.<br />
Portions of this publication can be made available in a variety of formats, including Braille,<br />
large print or audiotape, upon request. Inquiries concerning this policy of nondiscrimination<br />
should be directed to the Department’s Office for <strong>Diversity</strong>, Ethics, and Access, Room 152,<br />
Education Building, Albany, NY 12234.
<strong>Biological</strong> <strong>Diversity</strong>:<br />
T H E O L D E S T H U M A N H E R I T A G E<br />
By<br />
Edward O. Wilson<br />
Pellegrino University Research Professor and<br />
Honorary Curator in Entomology at Harvard University<br />
N e w Y o r k S t a t e M u s e u m<br />
E d u c a t i o n a l L e a f l e t 3 4<br />
A Publication of The <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Biodiversity Research Institute<br />
The University of the <strong>State</strong> of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
The <strong>State</strong> Education Department<br />
NEW YORK STATE MUSEUM
Copyright © 1999 by The <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Biodiversity Research Institute<br />
Printed in the United <strong>State</strong>s of America<br />
Published in 1999 by:<br />
The <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Biodiversity Research Institute<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong><br />
Cultural Education Center<br />
Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> 12230<br />
(518) 486-4845<br />
http://www.nysm.nysed.gov/bri.html<br />
Requests for additional copies of this publication may be made by contacting:<br />
Publication Sales<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong><br />
Cultural Education Center<br />
Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> 12230<br />
(518) 449-1404<br />
http://www.nysm.nysed.gov/publications.html<br />
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 99-70195<br />
ISBN: 1-55557-210-3<br />
ISSN: 0735-4401
Contents<br />
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii<br />
<strong>Biological</strong> <strong>Diversity</strong>: The Oldest Human Heritage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1<br />
Appendix I (Glossary) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36<br />
Appendix II (Suggested Reading) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46<br />
Appendix III (Discussion Questions) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52<br />
Appendix IV (Geologic Time Table) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56
Preface<br />
This book is based on a manuscript written by Edward Osborne Wilson<br />
following the first <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Natural History Conference at the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong><br />
<strong>Museum</strong> in Albany on June 20-22, 1990. Wilson, who was the keynote speaker,<br />
opened the conference with a talk titled “Biodiversity and the Future of the Global<br />
Environment.” He described how the extinction of species caused by habitat<br />
destruction has increased to a rate that may be 10,000 or more times greater than<br />
the rate prior to human intervention. This mass extinction, according to Wilson, is<br />
the most destructive global environmental change occurring at this time, and it is<br />
critical that we reverse the process. Following his keynote address at the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
<strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>, Wilson put together a manuscript based on the topics covered in<br />
his talk to be used as the basis of this educational book. Although this manuscript<br />
was written in 1990, the ideas presented are of great value and will continue to be<br />
important for many years to come.<br />
Edward Osborne Wilson is a world-renowned scientist and researcher. He<br />
currently works at Harvard University as Pellegrino University Research Professor<br />
and as Honorary Curator in Entomology. Wilson is also a distinguished writer;<br />
he has written or edited 20 books, including two that have won Pulitzer Prizes in<br />
general non-fiction, On Human Nature and The Ants (with co-author Bert<br />
Hölldobler). Over a career of nearly 50 years, Wilson has focused on a wide range<br />
of topics from population biology to sociobiology and, most recently, biodiversity<br />
issues. His career has always centered on the study of his lifelong passion—ants—<br />
and he is recognized as the world’s leading authority on the kingdom of ants.<br />
His major contributions to the field of myrmecology include the discovery of<br />
B i o l o g i c a l vii D i v e r s i t y
pheromones that direct specific ant activities and the discovery of many previously<br />
unknown species of ants from around the world. He has also begun to unravel and<br />
describe some of the complex social behaviors of these insects.<br />
Although Wilson’s career continues to involve research on ants, he has also<br />
recently assumed a new role as a leader in the crusade to save the world’s biodiversity.<br />
In his book Biodiversity, he states: “… every scrap of biological diversity is priceless,<br />
to be learned and cherished, and never to be surrendered without a struggle.” In<br />
the pages that follow, Wilson describes why this is true. He explains how all aspects<br />
of human well being are dependent on preserving the remaining biological resources<br />
of our world, and why we can no longer ignore increased extinction rates that are<br />
the result of anthropogenic activities. In the final pages of this book, Wilson offers<br />
recommendations and a multi-disciplinary approach for the successful<br />
conservation and use of biodiversity.<br />
This book has been printed using funds from the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Biodiversity<br />
Research Institute (BRI). The BRI was created during a time of increasing awareness<br />
of the urgent need to preserve global and local biodiversity. <strong>State</strong> Education Law<br />
(Section 235-a (2, 3)) of 1993 mandated the establishment of the BRI within the<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong> to meet these demands. The BRI is funded through the<br />
Environmental Protection Fund and includes a number of collaborators, including<br />
the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Department of Environmental Conservation, the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Natural Heritage Program, and the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Office of Parks, Recreation and<br />
Historic Preservation. Activities of the BRI are guided by an executive committee,<br />
which is appointed by the legislature and the governor of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>. The major<br />
objectives of the BRI include the following:<br />
• promote and sponsor cooperative scientific and educational efforts to increase<br />
our knowledge and awareness of biodiversity within <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> state;<br />
• advise the governor and officials of governmental agencies on biodiversity issues<br />
within <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> state;<br />
• develop a comprehensive and readily accessible database on the status of<br />
biodiversity within <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> state; and<br />
• identify areas within the state that lack adequate biodiversity information and<br />
promote research in such areas.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l viii D i v e r s i t y
Additional information on the activities of the BRI along with databases related<br />
to <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> state’s biodiversity can be found by accessing the BRI’s Web site at<br />
http://www.nysm.nysed.gov/bri.html. By making this information readily available,<br />
natural resource managers will be better able to minimize potentially negative<br />
impacts on local biodiversity. Ultimately, however, the successful conservation of<br />
biodiversity will also depend greatly upon increasing public concern and awareness—especially<br />
by future generations—of local and global biological diversity.<br />
In recognition of this situation, the BRI published this book with the intent of<br />
educating primarily high school students on the values of biodiversity. However,<br />
considering the urgency and importance of the issues discussed, this book will,<br />
we believe, be of value to a much broader audience.<br />
We wish to acknowledge all the people who have assisted us in the publication<br />
of this book. Above all, we owe the most thanks to the author, Edward O. Wilson,<br />
who has graciously offered his writing to us. We are also grateful for all the effort<br />
Patricia Kernan has put into creating the drawings that illustrate the pages of this<br />
book and the cover. Finally, we extend our thanks to all those who have worked on<br />
editing the text, including Erin Davison, Jeanne Finley, Karen Frolich, Patricia<br />
Kernan, Norton Miller, Shannon Murphy, David Steadman, Gordon Tucker and<br />
Lisa Wootan.<br />
Ronald J. Gill<br />
Biodiversity Research Specialist<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Biodiversity Research Institute<br />
Clifford A. Siegfried<br />
Director<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong><br />
Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
February 1999<br />
B i o l o g i c a l ix D i v e r s i t y
T<br />
HE ROSY PERIWINKLE (CATHARANTHUS ROSEUS )<br />
IS THE SOURCE OF ALKALOID CHEMICALS THAT<br />
ARE USED TO TREAT TWO OF THE MOST DEADLY<br />
FORMS OF CANCER: HODGKIN’S DISEASE AND<br />
ACUTE LYMPHOCYTIC LEUKEMIA.
<strong>Biological</strong> <strong>Diversity</strong>:<br />
T H E O L D E S T H U M A N H E R I T A G E<br />
By<br />
Edward O. Wilson<br />
In the northeastern United <strong>State</strong>s, as in most of the remainder of the country,<br />
about one plant species in five is threatened with significant reduction in numbers<br />
or even with total extinction. Here are the names of several: <strong>New</strong> England boneset,<br />
Furbish’s lousewort, threadleaf sundew, fairy wand and hairy beardtongue. Many<br />
people still ask the vexing question: Of what possible value, except to a few<br />
botanists, is a plant with a name like hairy beardtongue? Why should money and<br />
effort be spent to save this and other bits of floristic esoterica?<br />
Let me tell the ways. Consider periwinkles of the genus Catharanthus, flowering<br />
plants that live on Madagascar, a great island off the East Coast of Africa. Inconspicuous<br />
in appearance, located all the way around the world, the six species of periwinkles<br />
would seem to be even less worthy of attention than beardtongues and louseworts.<br />
But one of them, the rosy periwinkle (Catharanthus roseus), is the source of alkaloid<br />
chemicals vinblastine and vincristine, used to cure two of the most deadly forms of<br />
cancer: Hodgkin’s disease, especially dangerous to young adults, and acute lymphocytic<br />
leukemia, which, before the periwinkle alkaloids, was a virtual death sentence<br />
for young children. These anti-cancer substances are now the basis of an industry<br />
earning more than 100 million dollars a year. Ironically, the other five periwinkle<br />
species remain largely unexamined for their medical potential. One of them is near<br />
extinction due to the destruction of its habitat on Madagascar. On a global scale,<br />
one out of ten plant species has been found to contain anti-cancer substances of<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
1 D i v e r s i t y
S<br />
OME NORTHEASTERN PLANTS HAVE PROVIDED<br />
PEOPLE WITH FOLK REMEDIES, SUCH AS<br />
JEWELWEED SAP USED IN TREATING THE RASH<br />
POISON IVY CAUSES. OTHER SPECIES—FOR<br />
EXAMPLE, GINSENG AND GOLDEN-SEAL—ARE<br />
GATHERED COMMERCIALLY AND CULTIVATED<br />
TO A LIMITED EXTENT IN NEW YORK STATE.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
2 D i v e r s i t y
some degree of potency. A much higher percentage yield pharmaceuticals and other<br />
natural products of potential use as well as basic scientific information. If we dismiss<br />
beardtongues and louseworts, we may be doing ourselves a considerable disservice.<br />
Simple prudence dictates that no species, however humble, should ever be allowed<br />
to go extinct if it is within the power of humanity to save it. Take another—even<br />
repugnant—example, the leech. We would certainly be better off without these<br />
miserable bloodsuckers, right? Wrong. The medicinal leech of Europe has proved to<br />
be of great value to modern medicine. To prevent the blood of its victims from<br />
clotting, it secretes a powerful anticoagulant called hirudin. This substance is used to<br />
treat contusions, thrombosis, hemorrhoids and other conditions in which clotting<br />
blood can be painful or dangerous. Thousands of lives are saved annually by hirudin.<br />
The leech uses a second substance, the enzyme hyaluronidase, to disperse cells and<br />
hasten the penetration of hirudin. Surgeons adapt this material in the same way to<br />
spread injected drugs and anesthetics. Leeches also contain antibiotics and substances<br />
that enlarge the diameter of blood vessels, which might someday lead to a cure<br />
for migraine headaches. Medicinal leeches are now the basis of a $4 million annual<br />
business. They are so much in demand that the European species is threatened by<br />
overcollecting in its natural habitat.<br />
With the aid of other specialists (my own special group is ants), I have estimated<br />
the total number of kinds of plants, animals, and microorganisms known to science<br />
to be about 1.4 million. By “known to science” we mean characterized anatomically<br />
and given a scientific name, such as Canis familiaris for the domestic dog, Hirudo<br />
medicinalis for the European medicinal leech, and Homo sapiens for humans. But<br />
the actual number of kinds is estimated to fall somewhere between 10 million and<br />
80 million, depending on the statistical method used and the degree of conservativeness<br />
on the part of the scientist making the estimate. The truth is that we don’t<br />
know even to the nearest order of magnitude the amount of diversity. In other words,<br />
we cannot say whether the figure is closer to 1 million, 10 million or 100 million.<br />
When scientists fail to make a measurement to the nearest order of magnitude,<br />
it is fair to surmise that the subject is still poorly known. The truth is that life on<br />
planet earth has only begun to be explored. Every time I go to a rainforest site in<br />
Central or South America, I find new species of ants within several hours of searching.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
3 D i v e r s i t y
S<br />
OME SPECIES OF LEECHES CONTAIN THE<br />
CHEMICAL HIRUDIN AND THE ENZYME<br />
HYALURONIDASE, BOTH OF WHICH ARE USED<br />
IN MEDICINE.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
4 D i v e r s i t y
Some groups of organisms, such as fungi and mites (small spider-like organisms<br />
that abound in the leaf litter and soil) are so poorly studied that it is possible to find<br />
new species within a few miles of almost any locality in the United <strong>State</strong>s, including<br />
the most densely populated urban areas. In the Chocó region of Colombia, as many<br />
as half the plant species, including trees and shrubs, still lack a scientific name.<br />
Even new species of mammals still turn up occasionally. In the past several years, a<br />
new deer, a kind of muntjac, was found in western China, and a new monkey, the<br />
sun-tailed guenon, was discovered in Gabon.<br />
We know less about life on earth than we know about the surface of the moon and<br />
Mars—in part because far less money has been spent studying it. Taxonomy, the<br />
study of classification and hence of biological diversity, has been allowed to dwindle,<br />
while other important fields such as space exploration and biomedical studies have<br />
flourished. Like glass-blowing and harpsichord manufacture, taxonomy of many<br />
kinds of organisms has been left in the hands of a small number of unappreciated<br />
specialists who have had few opportunities to train their successors. To take one of<br />
hundreds of examples, two of the four most abundant groups of small animals of<br />
the soil are springtails and oribatid mites. Marvelously varied, having complex life<br />
cycles, and teeming by the millions in every acre of land, these tiny animals play<br />
vital ecological roles by consuming dead vegetable matter. Thus they help to drive<br />
the energy and materials cycles on which all of life depends. Yet there are only four<br />
specialists in the United <strong>State</strong>s who can identify springtails—one is retired—and<br />
only one is an expert on oribatid mites. The reason that so little is heard about<br />
these important organisms in the scientific literature and popular press is that there<br />
are so few people who know enough to write about them at any level.<br />
The general neglect of expertise in the face of overwhelming need and<br />
opportunity rebounds to the weakness of many other enterprises in science and<br />
education. <strong>Museum</strong>s are understaffed, with too few biologists to develop research<br />
collections and prepare exhibitions. Systematics, the branch of biology that employs<br />
taxonomy and the study of similarities among species to work out the evolution of<br />
groups of organisms, is able to address only a minute fraction of life. Biogeography,<br />
the analysis of the distribution of organisms, is similarly hobbled. So is ecology,<br />
the extremely important discipline that explores the relationships of organisms<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
5 D i v e r s i t y
“<br />
E<br />
VERY TIME THAT I GO INTO THE RAINFOREST<br />
IN CENTRAL OR SOUTH AMERICA, I FIND<br />
NEW SPECIES OF ANTS WITHIN SEVERAL HOURS<br />
OF SEARCHING.”<br />
—EDWARD O. WILSON<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
6 D i v e r s i t y
to their environment and to one another. A great deal of the future of biology<br />
depends on the strengthening of taxonomy, for if you can’t tell one kind of plant<br />
or animal from another, you are in trouble. Some kinds of research may be held<br />
up indefinitely. As the Chinese say, the beginning of wisdom is getting things by<br />
their right names.<br />
The study of classification and expertise on “obscure” groups of organisms<br />
such as periwinkles, leeches, springtails and mites may receive the needed boost by<br />
association with what has come to be known as biodiversity studies. Biodiversity<br />
studies constitute a hybrid discipline that took solid form during the 1980s. They<br />
can be defined (a bit formally, I admit, but bear with me) as follows: the systematic<br />
examination of the full array of organisms and the origin of this diversity, together<br />
with the technology by which diversity can be maintained and utilized for the<br />
benefit of humanity. Thus biodiversity studies are both scientific in nature, a branch<br />
of pure evolutionary biology, and applied studies, a branch of biotechnology.<br />
Two events during the past quarter-century brought biodiversity to center<br />
stage and encouraged the deliberately hybrid form of its analysis. The first was the<br />
recognition that human activity threatens the extinction of not only a few “star”<br />
species such as giant pandas and California condors, but also a large fraction of all<br />
the species of plants and animals on earth. At least one-quarter of the species on<br />
earth are likely to vanish due to the cutting and burning of tropical rainforests<br />
alone if the current rate of destruction continues. The second reason for the new<br />
prominence of biodiversity studies is the recognition that extinction can be slowed<br />
and eventually halted without significant cost to humanity. Extinction is not a price<br />
we are compelled to pay for economic progress. Quite the contrary: As the examples of<br />
the rosy periwinkle and medicinal leech suggest, conservation can promote human<br />
welfare. Ultimately conservation might even be necessary for continued progress in<br />
many realms of endeavor.<br />
The connection between the biodiversity crisis and economic development<br />
has been an important element in the reawakening of environmentalism in 1990,<br />
which reached a peak when Earth Day II was celebrated on April 22—20 years<br />
after the original event. The new environmentalism continues to endure. It arose<br />
with auspicious timing at the end of the Cold War, as Eastern Europe abandoned<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
7 D i v e r s i t y
M<br />
ARVELOUSLY VARIED, HAVING COMPLEX<br />
LIFE CYCLES, AND TEEMING BY THE MILLIONS<br />
IN EVERY ACRE OF LAND, SPRINGTAILS PLAY<br />
VITAL ECOLOGICAL ROLES BY CONSUMING<br />
DEAD VEGETABLE MATTER.<br />
communism and Russian-U.S. relations entered their most cooperative period<br />
since the Second World War. The industrialized countries could now, it seemed,<br />
turn more of their energies to domestic reform, including improvement of the<br />
environment.<br />
It appeared to many scientists, the public and political leaders that this opportunity<br />
was realized not a moment too soon. What were previously viewed as mostly<br />
local events such as pollution of a harbor here or landfilling of a marsh there, had<br />
coalesced into secular global trends. Through advances in technology, scientists were<br />
able to make precise measurements of changes in the atmosphere and of the rates<br />
of deforestation and other forms of habitat destruction. And when the iron curtain<br />
lifted, the environment was revealed to be even worse off in socialist countries than<br />
in the capitalist West. Action to reverse the decline was demanded everywhere.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
8 D i v e r s i t y
N<br />
EW YORK’S BIODIVERSITY IS THREATENED MAINLY BECAUSE OF<br />
HUMAN ACTIVITY. HABITAT DESTRUCTION AND/OR PESTICIDES HAVE<br />
CAUSED SPECIES SUCH AS THE KARNER BLUE BUTTERFLY (PICTURED<br />
BELOW), LOGGERHEAD SHRIKE AND BLACK TERN TO BECOME ENDANGERED.<br />
MISMANAGEMENT, SPECIFICALLY OVERHUNTING, HELPED BRING THE<br />
PASSENGER PIGEON TO EXTINCTION AND EXTIRPATED THE MOUNTAIN<br />
LION, GRAY WOLF AND ELK FROM THE NORTHEAST. PLANT SPECIES LIKE<br />
LEATHERFLOWER (CLEMATIS OCHROLEUCA ), SHORTLEAF PINE (PINUS<br />
ECHINATA ), AND LONG’S BULRUSH (SCIRPUS LONGII ) ONCE OCCURRED<br />
IN THE NEW YORK METROPOLITAN AREA, BUT DISAPPEARED AS THE CITY<br />
EXPANDED AND DESTROYED WOODLANDS AND WETLANDS.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
9 D i v e r s i t y
A N e w Y o r k C a s e S t u d y :<br />
The Decline of an Endangered Species<br />
By Timothy L. McCabe<br />
Senior Scientist and Curator of Entomology<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong><br />
The Karner blue butterfly serves as an indicator of the environmental health<br />
of the Albany pine barrens. The Karner blue larvae are dependent on a single<br />
host plant—the blue lupine. Lupine requires a complex mix of fire, low graze<br />
pressure from herbivores, and disturbance. The butterflies have equally complex<br />
needs for winter snow cover, nectar sources, ant symbionts and traffic-free areas.<br />
In preserves, deer and rabbit populations are protected from exploitation,<br />
enabling them to build large populations. The resulting increased browsing puts<br />
unnatural pressure on selected plants, particularly the lupine, thus reducing host<br />
availability.<br />
The Karner blue butterflies disperse across the landscape, taking advantage<br />
of unexploited habitat. They may stay in an area for 20 years, then disappear as<br />
the area becomes more overgrown and shaded. Managing the habitat is important<br />
for the future of this species. Currently, unused suitable habitat necessary for<br />
establishing new populations is being destroyed. The delicate balance between<br />
the butterfly and habitat has been exemplified by its extirpation from four states.<br />
The Karner blue is found in Albany, Schenectady and Warren counties.<br />
Originally, the Albany pine barrens comprised 25,000 acres. Now there are<br />
less than 2,800 acres of undeveloped land. Loss of pine barrens habitat through<br />
development has resulted in a corresponding decline in butterfly abundance.<br />
Figure 1 is an example of a site that has experienced a severe decline with the<br />
population apparently being extirpated. However, at most other sites in the Albany<br />
pine barrens, the decline has not been as severe as in this example. This decline<br />
became well known in the late 1970s and early ’80s through a city-sponsored<br />
Environmental Impact <strong>State</strong>ment.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
10 D i v e r s i t y
12<br />
10<br />
Number of Butterflies Observed<br />
8<br />
6<br />
4<br />
2<br />
0<br />
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998<br />
Survey Year<br />
F i g u r e 1 .<br />
Data were collected by observing and counting adult butterflies at one site in the Albany<br />
pine barrens. This visual survey method gives researchers a relative population index<br />
number, which, although it is not the actual population size, is very useful for monitoring<br />
some organisms such as butterflies. Each bar on the graph represents the total number of<br />
butterflies counted on different days. There were no butterflies observed on surveys in<br />
1997 and 1998. (Data courtesy of the Albany Pine Bush Preserve Commission.)<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
11 D i v e r s i t y
I<br />
SOLATED AREAS OF SOUTHEASTERN NEW<br />
YORK STATE ARE THE HABITAT OF THE EASTERN<br />
WOODRAT. IT WOULD SEEM THESE AREAS’<br />
INACCESSIBILITY WOULD PROTECT THE WOODRAT<br />
FROM EXTINCTION, AND YET INEXPLICABLY<br />
IT DECLINED IN NEW YORK STATE IN RECENT<br />
DECADES, AND FINALLY DISAPPEARED FROM<br />
THE STATE IN 1989.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
12 D i v e r s i t y
It is possible that the next hundred years will become known as the “Century<br />
of the Environment.” If in the fullness of time that prophecy comes true, the<br />
beginning of this era might be marked by historians by environmental disasters,<br />
such as the 11 million-gallon Exxon Valdez oil spill off the coast of Alaska, the 350<br />
tons of depleted uranium weapons still lying on Persian Gulf War battlefields, and<br />
the continued exploitation of precious ecosystems like the Brazilian Amazon, where<br />
deforestation, mining and over-development continue to flourish.<br />
I would like to summarize the whole picture by classifying global trends into<br />
four categories:<br />
1. Ozone depletion in the stratosphere, allowing increased penetration of<br />
ultraviolet radiation to reach ground level.<br />
2. Global warming due to the greenhouse effect, in which increased levels of<br />
carbon dioxide, methane and a few other gases trap growing quantities of heat.<br />
3. Toxic pollution, including acid rain.<br />
4. Mass extinction of species by destruction of habitats, especially tropical rainforests.<br />
The first three trends are dangerous to health and the economy—but they can<br />
be reversed. It is a matter of converting to cleaner forms of energy, changing our<br />
patterns of production and consumption, and above all, reversing population<br />
growth with an aim toward reaching supportable levels country by country. However,<br />
extinction cannot be reversed. No species can be called back. Extinction of species, or<br />
the reduction of biodiversity, is the one process<br />
that is being perpetrated not only on our children<br />
and grandchildren but also on our descendants<br />
10,000 years from now and beyond—as far into<br />
the future as can be imagined.<br />
With that somber but essential theme as<br />
background, let me now review some of the key<br />
facts about global biodiversity. The world is at<br />
or close to its highest level of biodiversity in the<br />
history of life, spanning 3.75 billion years. This<br />
buildup has been associated with changes in the<br />
ACIDIFICATION REDUCES THE DIVERSITY<br />
OF AQUATIC LIFE, BECAUSE FEW SPECIES<br />
CAN SURVIVE IN WATER WITH A LOW pH.<br />
THE pH LEVEL CAN BE RESTORED<br />
THROUGH LIMING; SOME OF THE PLANT<br />
SPECIES LOST MAY RE-ESTABLISH FROM<br />
SEED SOURCES IN NEARBY LAKES.<br />
atmosphere, the most important of which were caused by organisms and their<br />
innovations as they adapted to the changing atmosphere and other parts of the<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
13 D i v e r s i t y
T<br />
HE DIVERSITY OF THE POWDERY MILDEW IS DEMONSTRATED BY THE<br />
SHAPES OF THEIR APPENDAGES. THIS ENGRAVING WAS DONE IN 1861 BY<br />
CHARLES TULASNE.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
14 D i v e r s i t y
environment. For almost 3 billion years, life was limited to the oceans and consisted<br />
of bacteria, blue-green algae, and other relatively simple one-celled forms. Then<br />
complex cells evolved, incorporating organelles such as nuclear membranes, chloroplasts,<br />
and cilia. Soon afterward, these cells evolved into still more complex multicellular<br />
animals and plants. About 600 million years ago, the concentration of<br />
oxygen in the atmosphere climbed rather quickly (by geological standards) to near<br />
its current level, destroying most of the anaerobic life in the oceans and on land<br />
surfaces. A shield of ozone accumulated in the stratosphere, protecting life from<br />
harmful ultraviolet irradiation. For the first time, substantial numbers of larger<br />
animals filled the seas, and the global variety of life climbed sharply. Plants invaded<br />
the land, then animals, represented first by small arthropods and other invertebrates,<br />
then jawless fishes. The diversity of life continued to rise. Biodiversity stalled on a<br />
plateau during most of the Mesozoic Era, then climbed gradually to its current<br />
high level. It is a supreme irony that mankind, the great destroyer of life, began as<br />
one of the products of the living world’s maximum proliferation.<br />
A second major principle of biodiversity is that smaller organisms are generally<br />
more diverse than larger ones. The reason appears to be simply that they fit into<br />
smaller spaces, consume less food individually, complete their life cycles more quickly,<br />
and hence are able to divide the habitats in which they live into smaller and more<br />
numerous niches. And the more numerous the niches, the more species that can be<br />
packed into the same location. Take a typical epiphyte-laden tree in the rainforest<br />
of Peru. It may be the home of several hundred species of beetles, 40 species of ants,<br />
and as many as 50 species of orchids and other epiphytes. But it can only be the<br />
partial home for a flock of parrots, which must range over portions of the forest that<br />
contain many thousands of such trees in order to obtain enough food for survival.<br />
Among smaller animals, insects dominate diversity. About 750,000 of the 1 million<br />
animal species described to date are insects, and some estimates have placed the<br />
actual number as high as 80 million. The reason for this amazing disproportion is<br />
uncertain. It seems likely due to the metamorphosis experienced by the majority of<br />
kinds of insects during the individual life cycle: egg to larva to pupa to adult, with<br />
the egg and pupa as passive transitional stages and the larva and adult as the active<br />
stage. Larvae and adults are radically different in appearance (recall the caterpillar<br />
and butterfly), typically feed on different foods, and even live in different sites. As<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
15 D i v e r s i t y
T<br />
HE MARINE TURTLES, SUCH AS THIS GREEN<br />
SEA TURTLE, ARE MOST OFTEN KILLED<br />
BECAUSE THEY ARE LARGE AND SLOW AND ARE<br />
CONSIDERED GOOD EATING. ALL SIX SPECIES<br />
ARE NOW IN DANGER OF EXTINCTION.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
16 D i v e r s i t y
W<br />
ITH ITS WISPINESS AND LIGHT-AND-DARK<br />
COLORATION, THE PHANTOM CRANE FLY<br />
MIMICS COBWEBS AS IT FLIES THROUGH THE<br />
AIR. IF CAUGHT, IT CAN EASILY LOSE A LIMB,<br />
A CHARACTERISTIC KNOWN AS AUTOTOMY.<br />
a result, still more niches are generated by the combinations of life cycles. Another<br />
reason for the megadiversity of insects may be pre-emption. Insects were among the<br />
first small animals to adapt well to the land environment in early Paleozoic times,<br />
some 400 million years ago, and this advantage allowed them to expand their<br />
populations and species to an extreme degree while holding their own against rival<br />
groups among the land invaders. The pre-emption hypothesis gains some support<br />
from the fact that oribatid mites invaded the land about the same time, and today<br />
they too are exceptionally diverse and abundant.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
17 D i v e r s i t y
T<br />
HE MASSASAUGA IS A SMALL SPECIES OF<br />
RATTLESNAKE THAT IS ENDANGERED. IT IS<br />
KNOWN IN NEW YORK FROM ONLY TWO<br />
SWAMPS IN THE CENTRAL AND WESTERN<br />
PARTS OF THE STATE.<br />
If insects and other small invertebrate animals are so much more diverse than<br />
vertebrates and larger invertebrates due to size alone, is it true by extension of the<br />
same principle that still smaller creatures such as roundworms, fungi, and bacteria<br />
are even more diverse? The conventional answer is that for some unknown reason,<br />
they are not. But the conventional answer may prove to be wrong. The truth is<br />
that we know very little about the smallest of organisms. Because of their microscopic<br />
size and the difficulty of collecting and preserving them, they tend to be collected<br />
less frequently. Furthermore, many of the species can be distinguished only by<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
18 D i v e r s i t y
sophisticated microscopic and biochemical techniques. Take the roundworms, for<br />
example. Vast numbers occur throughout the world, with untold varieties of species<br />
living free in the soil or in the bodies of insects and other animals. Since roundworms<br />
can specialize in particular species of hosts, which are excessively diverse<br />
themselves, or even certain parts of the bodies of their hosts, they have the potential<br />
for spectacular diversification. We simply have no idea how many kinds of roundworms<br />
live on earth. The same is true for fungi and bacteria. The number of<br />
recognized bacterial species is about 4,000, but most specialists on the subject agree<br />
that this is only a tiny fraction of the real number. Bacterial species usually exist in<br />
numbers too low to detect by direct inspection, and become apparent only when<br />
given the right nutrients, temperature, and chemical environment to create obvious<br />
population blooms. Many also flourish in very odd places, such as thermal springs<br />
or the intestines of termites. In the late 1980s, deep drilling in South Carolina<br />
uncovered an entire new flora of bacteria living 1,000 feet or more below the soil<br />
surface on nutrients carried to them by water seepage. The terra incognita of the<br />
smallest organisms is the reason why students of biodiversity, in giddier moments,<br />
are sometimes willing to entertain the idea of 100 million or more species of<br />
organisms on earth.<br />
Yet another peculiarity of global biodiversity is its inordinate concentration in<br />
tropical rainforests. This habitat, or biome-type as it is called by ecologists, is defined<br />
as a forest growing in tropical areas with 80 inches or more of annual rainfall,<br />
allowing the growth of broad-leaved evergreen trees that form several layers of dense<br />
canopies. Tropical rainforests today cover only about 6% of the land surface (9 million<br />
square kilometers), but they are generally thought to contain more than half the<br />
species of organisms on earth. The diversity of rainforest organisms is legendary,<br />
the common stuff of gossip among field biologists. For example, as many as 300<br />
species of trees have been identified in a single hectare (2.5 acres) in the Peruvian<br />
Amazon; this compares with 700 native species found in all of North America. Each<br />
tree harbors as many as a thousand species of insects. One tree that I analyzed yielded<br />
43 kinds of ants, approximately the same number found in the entire British Isles.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
19 D i v e r s i t y
A<br />
MONG MANY OF THE ENDANGERED FISH<br />
IN NEW YORK STATE ARE THE SHORT-NOSED<br />
STURGEON (PICTURED BELOW) AND THE<br />
EASTERN SAND DARTER. THE NOW-EXTINCT<br />
BLUE PIKE LOOKS VERY MUCH LIKE THE STILL-<br />
ABUNDANT WALLEYE, AND AS RECENTLY AS<br />
THE 1970S IT WAS A MAJOR COMMERCIAL FISH.<br />
The reason for the concentration of terrestrial diversity in rainforests and their<br />
marine equivalent in the coral reefs is one of the great unknowns of ecology. The concentration<br />
is actually the result of a more or less continuous increase in diversity<br />
encountered while traveling from the poles to the equator, the so-called latitudinal<br />
gradient of biodiversity. When biologists say “unknown” in this particular case, they<br />
really mean “not known with certainty.” Several hypotheses have been advanced,<br />
any one of which—or all of which—could be true to some extent. I am going to<br />
take a deep breath and try to impart the most likely explanation from a synthesis<br />
of these hypotheses, with due respect to current evidence:<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
20 D i v e r s i t y
The tropical zones generally have a more congenial climate for life,<br />
providing it with longer growing seasons, an even distribution of solar<br />
energy, and freedom from freezing and other extreme, unpredictable, shortterm<br />
changes in temperature. The rainforest, moreover, offers a humidity<br />
regime and tree structure (that is, prevalence of broad, nearly horizontal<br />
branches) favorable to epiphytes such as orchids and bromeliads. This<br />
“elevated swampland” with its little pools of water and moist root masses<br />
offers vast numbers of additional living sites for animals. The delicate<br />
life cycles of the epiphytes and their co-evolved animal populations are<br />
pre-eminently tropical. It is unlikely that the organisms could endure the<br />
freezes of the Temperate Zone. The stability of the climate and the layering<br />
of vegetation allows division of the ecosystem into large numbers of niches<br />
and a corresponding number of plant and animal species, many bound<br />
together by intricate and finely tuned symbioses. A small shift from one<br />
part of a tree to another, or from one species of tree to another, or from<br />
one elevation on a mountainside to another, opens an opportunity for the<br />
evolution of yet another kind of animal or plant. The entirety of evolution<br />
has built the equivalent of a house of cards: vast numbers of species propped<br />
and leaning on one another and dependent on a steady environment to<br />
avoid collapse. It used to be thought that diversity created stability; in<br />
other words, the more species were locked together by co-evolution, the<br />
less likely any one of them could be extirpated. This diversity-stability<br />
hypothesis has gradually given way to its exact reverse, the stability-diversity<br />
hypothesis, wherein external, climatic stability is thought to allow the<br />
buildup of biodiversity. In the Temperate Zones, plant and animal species<br />
must adapt to a more drastically and unpredictably shifting environment.<br />
As a consequence, each Temperate Zone species is, on the average, likely to<br />
occur in a greater range of habitats, elevation and so forth than individual<br />
tropical species. In short, Temperate Zone species occupy a broader niche.<br />
Fewer species can be fitted together, resulting in lower biodiversity in<br />
temperate climates.<br />
Destructive human activity, including habitat removal, pollution, and excessive<br />
exploitation, have reduced large numbers of plant and animal species in the Temperate<br />
Zones even though they are “tougher” in the sense of having wider ranges on the<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
21 D i v e r s i t y
F<br />
RANKLINIA ALATAMAHA, A SHRUB OF THE TEA FAMILY, WAS DISCOVERED<br />
IN GEORGIA IN 1765 BY JOHN BARTRAM AND HIS SON WILLIAM, WHO<br />
MADE THIS WATERCOLOR PAINTING. IN SPITE OF MANY ATTEMPTS TO FIND<br />
IT AGAIN, THE FRANKLINIA HAS NOT BEEN SEEN IN THE WILD SINCE<br />
1803, ALTHOUGH IT CONTINUES TO THRIVE HORTICULTURALLY IN MANY<br />
PLACES OTHER THAN ITS ORIGINAL HABITAT, INCLUDING NEW YORK.<br />
WHY IT DID NOT OCCUR NATURALLY ELSEWHERE REMAINS AN ENIGMA.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
22 D i v e r s i t y
average as well as greater ecological flexibility. In rainforests and other tropical<br />
environments with their legions of finely adapted species, degradation of this kind<br />
has deepened into catastrophe. Rainforests occupy about 9 million square kilometers<br />
currently, down some 45% from the original cover before the coming of man. The<br />
current area, then, is roughly equal to that of the United <strong>State</strong>s. The forest is being<br />
cut and burned at the rate of 100,000 square kilometers a year, roughly the area of<br />
South Carolina—or, to use a more vivid measure, an area equal to a football field every<br />
second. Employing simple models based on the<br />
known relation of the area of islands and habitat<br />
patches to the number of species that can coexist,<br />
I have conservatively estimated that on a worldwide<br />
basis the ultimate loss attributable to<br />
rainforest clearing alone is from 0.2% to 0.3%<br />
of all species in the forests per year. Taking a very<br />
conservative figure of 2 million species confined<br />
to the forests, the global loss that results from<br />
deforestation is thus at least 4,000 to 6,000 species<br />
a year. That, in turn, is on the order of 10,000<br />
times greater than the naturally occurring background<br />
extinction rate that prevailed before the<br />
appearance of human beings.<br />
Although 4,000 species a year extinguished<br />
or doomed is a shocking figure, it is still almost<br />
certainly a gross underestimate. When we consider<br />
that the true number of plant and animal species<br />
limited to the rainforests may well be in the tens<br />
of millions, and that many, or even most, species<br />
in these areas are very limited in distribution, even<br />
small reductions in forest coverage can make them<br />
MICRANTHEMUM (MICRANTHEMUM<br />
MICRANTHEMOIDES ), A TINY RELATIVE OF<br />
THE GARDEN SNAPDRAGON, ONCE<br />
FLOURISHED ON THE MUDDY SHORES<br />
OF ESTUARIES ALONG THE EAST COAST,<br />
INCLUDING NEW YORK’S HUDSON<br />
RIVER. IT HAS NOT BEEN SEEN IN SEVERAL<br />
DECADES, AND IS PRESUMED TO BE<br />
EXTINCT. ANOTHER RELATIVE OF THE<br />
SNAPDRAGON, CHAFFSEED (SCHWALBEA<br />
AMERICANA ), HAS A LIMITED RANGE<br />
IN THE NORTHEAST AND HAS NOT BEEN<br />
SEEN IN NEW YORK SINCE THE EARLY<br />
NINETEENTH CENTURY, WHEN IT WAS<br />
FOUND IN THE ALBANY PINE BUSH.<br />
vulnerable to extinction. Add to this the species extinctions occurring in other habitats<br />
worldwide, and the animal extinction rate could easily be 10 times higher—that is,<br />
2% or more of all rainforest species, 50,000 or more species worldwide. A common<br />
estimate among biodiversity specialists, one to which I subscribe, is that one-fourth<br />
of the species of organisms on earth are likely to be eliminated outright or doomed to<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
23 D i v e r s i t y
T<br />
APIRS ARE HERBIVORES THAT LOOK VAGUELY<br />
SIMILAR TO THE PIG BUT ARE MOST CLOSELY<br />
RELATED TO RHINOCEROSES. THEY ARE SHY,<br />
NOCTURNAL ANIMALS THAT SPEND THE HEAT OF<br />
THE DAY IN THE SHADOWS AND SHALLOW POOLS<br />
DEEP IN THE FOREST. ALL FOUR SPECIES OF<br />
TAPIRS IN THE WORLD ARE NOW SCARCE AND<br />
EXIST ONLY IN EXTENSIVE AREAS OF REMAINING<br />
TROPICAL FOREST.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
24 D i v e r s i t y
early extinction within the next 30 years if current<br />
rates of habitat destruction continue unabated.<br />
RAINFORESTS OCCUPY ABOUT 9 MILLION<br />
Habitat destruction is far from the whole<br />
picture. It represents most of the problem in warm<br />
climates, but global climatic warming due to the<br />
greenhouse effect is a potentially major second<br />
force in cold temperate and Polar Regions. A poleward<br />
shift of climate at the rate of 100 kilometers<br />
or more per century, which is considered at least a<br />
possibility, would leave wildlife reserves and entire<br />
species ranges behind. Many kinds of plants and<br />
SQUARE KILOMETERS CURRENTLY, DOWN<br />
SOME 45% FROM THE ORIGINAL COVER<br />
BEFORE MAN. THE FOREST IS BEING CUT<br />
AND BURNED AT THE RATE OF 100,000<br />
SQUARE KILOMETERS A YEAR … AN AREA<br />
EQUAL TO A FOOTBALL FIELD EACH SECOND.<br />
animals simply could not spread fast enough to keep up. The Englemann Spruce,<br />
for example, has an estimated natural dispersal capacity of from 1 kilometer to 20<br />
kilometers per century, so that massive new plantings would be required to sustain<br />
the size of the geographical range it currently occupies. Some kinds of plants and<br />
less mobile animals occupying narrow ranges might become extinct altogether.<br />
Entire arctic ecosystems might be endangered, because the warming will be greatest<br />
nearest the poles, and the organisms composing the ecosystems have no northward<br />
escape route to follow.<br />
People often ask, why should man-induced changes be thought apocalyptic or<br />
even very serious? After all, environmental change is perpetual, and organisms have<br />
always adjusted to it in past geological times. Isn’t the human impact just one more<br />
form of environmental change? Certainly over millions of years species adapted to<br />
alternative climatic warming and cooling, the expansion or shrinkage of continental<br />
shelves and the invasion of new competitors and parasites. Those that could not<br />
change became extinct, but at such a relatively slow rate that other better-adapted<br />
species evolved to replace them. In the midst of endless turnover, the balance of life<br />
was sustained. But now the velocity of change is too great for life to handle, and<br />
the equilibrium has been shattered. It has reached precipitous levels within a single<br />
human life span, merely a tick in geological time. Humanity is creating a radical<br />
new environment too quickly to allow the species to adjust. Species need thousands<br />
or millions of years to assemble complex genetic adaptations (see Appendix IV,<br />
Geologic Time Table). Most of life is consequently at risk. We are at risk.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
25 D i v e r s i t y
S<br />
MALL POPULATIONS OF MUSK OXEN LIVE IN ARCTIC REGIONS, IN SOME AREAS<br />
DUE TO REINTRODUCTION. THEY HUDDLE TOGETHER WHEN THREATENED, AN<br />
EFFECTIVE DEFENSE AGAINST PREDATORS SUCH AS WOLVES, BUT ONE THAT<br />
ALLOWED EASY SLAUGHTER OF WHOLE HERDS BY HUMANS IN THE 18TH AND<br />
19TH CENTURIES.<br />
There have been five previous episodes of mass extinction during the past<br />
500 million years, the time in which large, complex organisms flourished in the<br />
seas and on the land. These occurred at intervals of 20 million to 140 million<br />
years, during brief periods when the equilibrium between species formation and<br />
species extinction was upset. The most recent occurred at the end of the Mesozoic<br />
Era, the Age of Dinosaurs, 65 million years ago. Scientists generally agree that<br />
some major physical event was responsible, most likely a giant meteorite strike or<br />
abnormally heavy volcanic activity. Life required more than 5 million years to<br />
restore its original diversity by additional evolution. We are now in the midst of a<br />
comparable extinction spasm, almost entirely by our own actions. If a remedy is not<br />
found, we could continue on to approach the greatest crisis of all, the Permian<br />
crash of 240 million years ago, when 77% to 96% of all marine animal species<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
26 D i v e r s i t y
perished. As the paleontologist David Raup put it, at that time “global biology<br />
(for higher organisms, at least) had an extremely close call.” There is an additional,<br />
sinister note in the current extinction spasm. For the first time ever, plant species<br />
are dying in large numbers. The world’s flora survived the end of the Mesozoic Era<br />
more or less intact, but now it is being eroded swiftly—with eventual consequences<br />
impossible to predict.<br />
Let me now shift gears abruptly, by saying that catastrophe can be replaced by<br />
a bright future if the world’s fauna and flora are saved and put to use for the benefit<br />
of humanity. This new enterprise, which should command our attention as fully as<br />
biomedical science and space exploration, will require the revitalization of “classical<br />
biology” and the unification of the best efforts of scientists, political leaders and<br />
business entrepreneurs. Much of future biology, I predict, will focus on biodiversity<br />
studies, carried down to the level of species and genetic strains. The study of biodiversity<br />
comprises several levels, each of which must be understood to protect and<br />
make full use of species and genetic strains. These levels correspond roughly to the<br />
conceptual levels of biological organization employed in basic research, which are<br />
used to illuminate pattern and process all the way from DNA replication to energy<br />
flow in ecosystems. The disciplines attending the levels are hierarchical. Starting<br />
with systematics, each feeds vital information to those up the line. In turn, the most<br />
comprehensive among them, community ecology and ecosystems studies, offer the<br />
broad vistas that guide biodiversity studies as a whole.<br />
T<br />
HE AMERICAN ALLIGATOR WAS ON THE VERGE<br />
OF EXTINCTION, BUT THROUGH A MAJOR<br />
REHABILITATION PROGRAM, ITS POPULATION<br />
HAS REBOUNDED.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
27 D i v e r s i t y
A N e w Y o r k C a s e S t u d y :<br />
Why <strong>Biological</strong> Inventories Are Important<br />
By Robert A. Daniels<br />
Chair of <strong>Biological</strong> Survey and Curator of Ichthyology<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong><br />
Surveys and inventories of organisms provide the basic data used in research<br />
projects. Studying such changes as population size, species composition and<br />
distribution of organisms requires baseline data to which new information can<br />
be compared. <strong>Biological</strong> systems are dynamic; organisms living in a specific<br />
geographic area, often called a community, respond to physical, chemical and<br />
biological factors. As these factors change on a daily, seasonal, annual or long-term<br />
basis, the organisms in the community also change. To understand the effects of<br />
changes on these organisms, the biologist must first understand the various<br />
components that affect the community. Too often, the baseline data needed for<br />
this comparison are nonexistent because no early survey of the biological<br />
resources was conducted. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> has taken a lead in inventorying its natural<br />
resources with the establishment of the <strong>State</strong> Geological and Natural History<br />
Survey in 1836. Modern field surveys, documented by careful notes and voucher<br />
specimens, can be used to protect rare or unusual species, to define and map<br />
their habitats and to meet government regulations for building or other permits.<br />
Because both the environment and communities are dynamic, repeated surveys<br />
or long-term monitoring of specific sites provides the greatest amount of information<br />
and allows the researcher to observe and predict the response of the<br />
community to potential environmental changes.<br />
For example, biologists examine change in fish communities by comparing<br />
current information on fish abundance and distribution to information collected<br />
during past surveys. The simple comparison, as shown in Figure 2 describing<br />
fish communities in the Wallkill River, indicates that the composition and relative<br />
abundance of the fish community has changed markedly in this stream in the<br />
six decades between surveys. The chart shows that there were 22 species of fish<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
28 D i v e r s i t y
collected in the stream in 1936 and only 16 species in 1992. Factors contributing<br />
to the loss of species and change of community composition are unknown. Had<br />
the stream been surveyed regularly, these mechanisms would be more obvious to<br />
the modern researcher, and they would be better able to understand the changes<br />
and to predict the effects of change.<br />
Tessellated Darter<br />
Spotfin Shiner<br />
Spottail Shiner<br />
Golden Shiner<br />
Smallmouth Bass<br />
Largemouth Bass<br />
White Sucker<br />
Redbreast Sunfish<br />
Pumpkinseed<br />
Common Shiner<br />
Rock Bass<br />
Brown Bullhead<br />
Cutlips Minnow<br />
Creek Chubsucker<br />
Fallfish<br />
Creek Chub<br />
Redfin Pickerel<br />
Chain Pickerel<br />
Bluegill<br />
Margined Madtom<br />
Eastern Silvery Minnow<br />
Black Crappie<br />
Yellow Bullhead<br />
Sand Shiner<br />
Log Perch<br />
1936<br />
1992<br />
0 20 40 60 80 100<br />
Number of Fish Collected<br />
F i g u r e 2 .<br />
Community composition of fishes in the riverine section of the lower Wallkill River, <strong>New</strong><br />
<strong>York</strong>. The comparison is based on fishes collected at four sites during 1936 and 1992<br />
between Dashville and Montgomery. The 1992 sites were selected to match, as closely<br />
as possible, the habitats sampled in 1936. This chart shows the decline in the relative<br />
abundance and diversity of fish that has occurred in the Wallkill River.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
29 D i v e r s i t y
T<br />
HERE ARE SUCCESS STORIES IN NEW YORK,<br />
WHERE THE STATE BIRD, THE EASTERN BLUEBIRD,<br />
HAS MADE QUITE A COMEBACK MOSTLY DUE TO<br />
CITIZENS PLACING AND MANAGING NEST BOXES<br />
IN SUITABLE HABITATS. THESE BOXES ALLOW<br />
BLUEBIRDS TO BETTER COMPETE WITH INTRO-<br />
DUCED SPECIES LIKE THE HOUSE SPARROW AND<br />
THE EUROPEAN STARLING.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
30 D i v e r s i t y
Systematics, or taxonomy, is at the base of biodiversity studies for the simple<br />
reason that if species cannot be identified they cannot be studied or marked for<br />
preservation. Systematics creates two key products, monographs and inventories.<br />
Monographs are complete classifications of particular groups of organisms for some<br />
larger part of the world, such as the ferns of tropical America or the Danaid butterflies<br />
of the world. The ideal monograph describes the species in the group, presents<br />
the available information on their distribution and natural history and interprets<br />
their evolutionary history. When appropriate monographs are available, inventories<br />
can be conducted of particular sites, including the hot spots of greatest interest<br />
in conservation. Typical inventories might include lists of the ferns, butterflies, or<br />
ideally all the species found in a rainforest on Cape <strong>York</strong> or the Chocó region of<br />
Colombia. The urgency in the need for systematics research comes from the fact<br />
that few appropriate monographs actually exist, forestalling inventories of any but<br />
a small number of relatively well-known groups such as flowering plants and birds<br />
and other vertebrates. As I noted earlier, the vast majority of species of invertebrates,<br />
fungi and microorganisms have not even been discovered, let alone described.<br />
There is a great need to promote monographic work on selected groups that are so<br />
different from flowering plants and vertebrates in their biology as to occupy unique<br />
places in the ecosystem and require special techniques in conservation. For adventurous<br />
scientists, these other groups await exploration in the field in the same way<br />
that elephants, gorillas and rhododendrons awaited exploration in the last century.<br />
Organismic biology moves us one level of organization down from systematics,<br />
rather than up. It comprises the physiology, genetics and life cycle studies of<br />
individual organisms. Once species have been distinguished taxonomically, those<br />
of most importance can be determined on the basis of whether they are keystone<br />
species, or close to extinction, or of potential economic importance, or offer extraordinary<br />
new biological phenomena for scrutiny. Detailed analysis can assess their<br />
status and role in the ecosystem.<br />
The next logical link in the chain is population biology, moving us back to<br />
the level of the species. Here we study the traits of whole populations, species by<br />
species, including the detailed distribution of each (selected) population, its fluctuation<br />
in size through time and hence its susceptibility to local extinction, and its<br />
internal genetic diversity—also important as a factor in potential extinction.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
31 D i v e r s i t y
A<br />
T ONE TIME THE PEREGRINE FALCON WAS ON THE VERGE OF EXTINC-<br />
TION. THROUGH EXTENSIVE REHABILITATION EFFORTS, IT HAS RETURNED<br />
TO LARGE PARTS OF ITS ORIGINAL RANGE. IT HAS BEEN INTRODUCED INTO<br />
NEW YORK AND OTHER LARGE CITIES TO HELP CONTROL THE PIGEON<br />
POPULATION. THIS PAINTING IS BY LOUIS AGASSIZ FUERTES, A FAMOUS<br />
BIRD ILLUSTRATOR OF THE EARLY TWENTIETH CENTURY WHO LIVED AND<br />
WORKED IN ITHACA, NEW YORK.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
32 D i v e r s i t y
Community ecology addresses the manner in which species are linked in local<br />
environments. One of the most important problems in modern biology, as well as in<br />
conservation practice, is the tightness and reach of such linkages. We know how small<br />
sets of species, such as pairs and triplets, closely interact as partners in symbiosis,<br />
competition, predation and prey. What we do not know to any extent, especially<br />
in the most species-rich, endangered communities, is the range of linkages for<br />
individual species. How many species, for example, are keystone species whose<br />
elimination would bring down, say, 100 or more other species? This kind of scientific<br />
research is as basic and subtle as any in molecular biology or physics.<br />
In ecosystems studies, the highest level of organization is the ecosystem, the<br />
combined biological and physical components of circumscribed domains such as<br />
islands, patches of forest and lakes. The emphasis at this level is on the properties<br />
of energy and material flow, and (for our purposes) the relation of these properties<br />
to species composition. When environments are disturbed, energy and material<br />
flows are shifted, and humidity and temperature are altered. As a consequence,<br />
some species flourish while others decline and die out.<br />
Economic analysis of local ecosystems becomes practical to the extent that<br />
knowledge of the fauna and flora increases. One very promising approach is biochemical<br />
prospecting, the screening of natural products of wild species, a relatively<br />
inexpensive procedure that can follow closely upon systematic inventories and<br />
other early biological studies. The aim of this approach is to create new pharmaceuticals<br />
and commercial products from the wildlands and to encourage the<br />
creation of extractive reserves as an alternative to habitat destruction.<br />
In conclusion, here is the way these several fields of study can be fit together<br />
in the service of conservation and use of biodiversity:<br />
• Promote monographic studies of the poorest known groups, especially those<br />
likely to display novel population traits and conservation needs.<br />
• Encourage inventories of “warm areas,” i.e., species-rich areas under considerable<br />
environmental assault, to identify the true hot spots within them that<br />
are both species-rich and most threatened, with an aim toward early remedial<br />
action. The inventories should cover flowering plants and vertebrates, which<br />
are taxonomically in the best shape, and should be extended as soon as<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
33 D i v e r s i t y
possible to selected groups of smaller organisms likely to display different<br />
population traits and conservation needs. Inventories should be directed<br />
from some of the best-established field laboratory sites, such as the tropical<br />
forest stations on Barro Colorado Island, Panama, and La Selva in Costa<br />
Rica, as well as the many local stations and field laboratories throughout<br />
North America.<br />
• Focus on selected groups of species for those physiological and genetic studies<br />
most likely to identify the causes of population decline and extinction. Such<br />
studies are also best conducted at well-established field laboratory sites.<br />
• Select groups of organisms for studies of species linkages, the most basic level<br />
of community organization, aimed at disclosing the reach of such linkages<br />
and the nature of keystone species. Again, this kind of study is generally best<br />
conducted at well-established field laboratory sites.<br />
• Promote studies of ecosystem changes in natural habitats under assault, as<br />
these changes affect community cohesion and threaten the safety of keystone<br />
species.<br />
Finally, given that this conceptual structure is close to the mark, the best way<br />
to promote biodiversity studies and conservation would seem to be to strengthen<br />
our experimental field stations and museums while promoting the very best studies<br />
ranging from systematics to ecosystems analyses. Our brightest young people should<br />
consider careers in biodiversity studies; our government and foundations should<br />
promote their enterprise in the service of national interest. We already know what<br />
needs to be done and the first important steps to take.<br />
Now is the time to act.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
34 D i v e r s i t y
<strong>Biological</strong> field stations<br />
from four parts of the world:<br />
1. Sirena <strong>Biological</strong> Field Station<br />
Osa Peninsula, Costa Rica<br />
Latitude: 8° 29´ North<br />
Longitude: 83° 30´ 30´´ West<br />
2. Palmer Station<br />
Antarctic Peninsula<br />
Latitude: 64° 46´ 30´´ South<br />
Longitude: 64° 04´ West<br />
3. Fu-Shan Station<br />
Northeastern Taiwan<br />
Latitude: 24° 46´ North<br />
Longitude: 121° 43´ East<br />
4. Edmund Niles Huyck Preserve<br />
& <strong>Biological</strong> Research Station<br />
Rensselaerville, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, USA<br />
Latitude: 42° 31´ 30´´ North<br />
Longitude: 74° 9´ 30´´ West<br />
There are many other biological field stations and preserves in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> state,<br />
including the Adirondack Ecological Center (<strong>New</strong>comb), Bard College Field Station<br />
(Annandale), Beaver Lake Nature Center (Baldwinsville), Betty Matthiessen Preserve<br />
(Fishers Island), Cranberry Lake <strong>Biological</strong> Station (Cranberry Lake), Mohonk<br />
Preserve (<strong>New</strong> Paltz), and Tift Farm Nature Preserve (Buffalo).<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
35 D i v e r s i t y
A p p e n d i x I<br />
Glossary<br />
Acid rain Precipitation that is acidic due to the chemical reaction of nitrous<br />
oxides (NO x ) or sulfate (SO 4 ) with water (H 2 O), forming nitric or sulfuric<br />
acid. These chemicals are picked up by clouds over industrial areas that burn<br />
fossil fuels. The acids formed can be carried long distances and deposited<br />
far away from their origin. Acid rain is thought to be killing some of the<br />
trees and polluting water in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, Vermont and <strong>New</strong> Hampshire.<br />
Anatomy A branch of biology that deals with the physical structure of an<br />
organism.<br />
Anesthetic A substance that causes insensitivity and/or loss of consciousness.<br />
For example, novocaine or ether may be used during medical or dental<br />
operations, causing the patient to feel no pain.<br />
Antibiotic A substance, such as penicillin or erythromycin, that inhibits or<br />
stops the growth of bacteria or other microorganisms.<br />
Arthropod 1 A member of the Phylum Arthropoda, such as an insect, spider,<br />
or crustacean, bearing an articulated, external skeleton.<br />
Bacteria 1 Microscopic organisms (Kingdom Monera) that are prokaryotic, or<br />
lacking nuclear membranes around the genes.<br />
Biochemical Involving the chemical reactions of living organisms.<br />
Biodiversity 1 The variety of organisms considered at all levels, from genetic<br />
variants belonging to the same species through arrays of species to arrays<br />
of genera, families, and still higher taxonomic levels; includes the variety<br />
of ecosystems which comprise both the communities of organisms within<br />
particular habitats and the physical conditions under which they live.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
36 D i v e r s i t y
Biogeography 1 The scientific study of the past and present geographical<br />
distribution of organisms.<br />
Biome 1 A major category of habitat in a particular region of the world, such<br />
as the tundra of northern Canada or the rainforest of the Amazon Basin.<br />
Biomedicine Developments in medical science using biological sources.<br />
Antibiotics and organ transplants are examples.<br />
Biome type An organism that is a characteristic species of a particular environment<br />
or biome.<br />
Biotechnology Developments using knowledge of biology for the benefit<br />
of humanity. For example, genetic engineering of more productive crop<br />
plants was developed through biotechnology.<br />
Blue-green algae Any of a division (Cyanophyceae) of unicellular, prokaryotic,<br />
aquatic organisms having chlorophyll masked by bluish-green pigments.<br />
They are more closely related to bacteria than to other algae and many<br />
scientists refer to them as blue-green bacteria.<br />
Broad-leaved evergreen trees Woody plants that have broad green leaves,<br />
not needles, all year. Those with needles are coniferous evergreens. The<br />
opposite of evergreen, deciduous woody plants grow new leaves and shed<br />
them each year.<br />
California Condor Near extinction, this large vulture-like bird is restricted<br />
in distribution today to small mountainous parts of southern California.<br />
It inhabited <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> state in the Tertiary Period.<br />
Canopy The high leafy layer formed by the trees in a forest. In the tropics,<br />
many plants and animals live in the thick canopy where there is more<br />
water and sun than on the forest floor.<br />
Cell The basic structural unit of organisms which, alone or interacting with<br />
others, can perform the fundamental functions of life. Some organisms<br />
consist of a single cell, while others are multicellular.<br />
Chloroplast The part of a plant cell that contains chlorophyll, which captures<br />
light and is involved in photosynthesis.<br />
Cilia Tiny hair-like structures that enable unicellular creatures to move and that<br />
help other cells (for example, those in our lungs) to move particles around.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
37 D i v e r s i t y
Classical biology The study of organisms based on comparative morphology<br />
(physical structure).<br />
Classification Systematic arrangement into groups or categories according to<br />
established criteria.<br />
Coagulant A substance which causes a fluid to thicken to a solid. For example,<br />
platelets, found in red blood cells, are coagulants that cause a blood clot<br />
to form.<br />
Coevolution 1 The evolution of two or more species due to mutual influence.<br />
For example, many species of flowering plants and their insect pollinators<br />
have coevolved in a way that makes the relationship more effective.<br />
Competition Active demand by two or more organisms or kinds of organisms<br />
for a resource. For example, male white-tailed deer could compete for<br />
food, territory or mates.<br />
Conservation 1 To sustain biodiversity in the face of human-caused environmental<br />
disturbance.<br />
Continental shelf A shallow underwater plain of various widths that forms<br />
a border to a continent and that typically ends in a steep slope to the<br />
oceanic abyss.<br />
Danaid butterfly A type of butterfly, the best known example of which is the<br />
Monarch butterfly.<br />
Deforestation The cutting of a high percentage of trees and the clearing of<br />
most of the shrubs and brush in a forest.<br />
Degradation A decline to a low, destitute state with regard to a lower quality<br />
of resources.<br />
Dioxide A chemical compound with two molecules of oxygen. An example is<br />
CO 2 (carbon dioxide). This is vital to plants, which use it to produce energy<br />
and O 2 (oxygen). The O 2 provided by plants is used by other forms of life,<br />
including humans. Dioxides can be harmful to the environment. When<br />
combined with sulfur or nitrogen, these chemical compounds contribute<br />
to air and water pollution.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
38 D i v e r s i t y
Dispersal In biology, the way a species can spread into the environment. For<br />
example, dandelion seeds may disperse by wind or be carried on an animal<br />
that brushes against the plant.<br />
<strong>Diversity</strong> 1 See Biodiversity.<br />
DNA 1 A double helix of deoxyribonucleic acid. The fundamental hereditary<br />
material of all living organisms, the polymer composing the genes.<br />
Ecology 1 The scientific study of the interactions of organisms with their<br />
environment, including the physical environment and the other organisms<br />
living in it.<br />
Energy flow The path of energy from the environment that is used and<br />
returned by an organism.<br />
Energy and materials cycle The origin, movement, and recycling of energy<br />
and nutrients through an organism or several organisms through an<br />
ecological system back to the environment.<br />
Environment 1 The surroundings of an organism or a species, the ecosystem<br />
in which it lives, including both the physical environment and the other<br />
organisms with which it comes in contact.<br />
Environmentalism An awareness and concern for the natural environment.<br />
This may lead to actions such as reusing, recycling and composting.<br />
Enzyme A protein that causes chemical reactions in cells. Some enzymes are<br />
secreted in the digestive system to aid in the absorption of nutrients. Others<br />
may be extracted and used in making bread or cheese.<br />
Epiphyte 1 A plant specialized to grow on other kinds of plants in a neutral or<br />
beneficial manner, not as a parasite. Examples: most species of orchids,<br />
bromeliads, and many mosses and lichens.<br />
Evolution 1 In biology, any change in the genetic material of a population of<br />
organisms. Evolution can vary in degree from small shifts in the frequency<br />
of minor genes to the origin of complex genes of new species. Changes of<br />
lesser magnitude are called microevolution, and changes at or near the upper<br />
extreme are called macroevolution. Evolution is also a theory or model to<br />
account for diversity of life on earth through these genetic changes.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
39 D i v e r s i t y
Extinction 1 The termination of any lineage of organisms, from subspecies to<br />
species and higher taxonomic categories from genera to phyla. Extinction<br />
can be local, in which one or more populations of a species or another<br />
unit vanish but others survive elsewhere, or total (global), in which all the<br />
populations vanish. When biologists speak of extinction without further<br />
qualifications, they mean total extinction.<br />
Extirpate A species no longer occurring where it once lived; to entirely<br />
remove from an area. For example, the mountain lion has been extirpated<br />
from the Northeast, but is still found in much of the western U.S.<br />
Extractive reserves 1 A wild habitat from which timber, latex and other natural<br />
materials are taken on a sustained yield basis with minimal environmental<br />
damage and, ideally, without the extinction of native species.<br />
Fern A flowerless, seedless lower vascular plant that reproduces by spores.<br />
Field laboratory site A temporary or permanent place where scientific research,<br />
usually having to do with the environment, is prepared and/or carried out.<br />
Flowering plant A plant that produces flowers, fruit, and seeds and is more<br />
complex than non-flowering plants, such as conifers (evergreens) or fungi.<br />
Fungi A group of plants, such as mushrooms, molds, rusts, and mildews,<br />
which derive nutrients from decomposing organic matter instead of<br />
through photosynthesis because they lack chlorophyll.<br />
Genetic adaptation A change in genetic composition that occurs naturally over<br />
time so that an organism is more efficient and competitive in its environment.<br />
Genetics A branch of biology that deals with the heredity and variation of<br />
DNA in organisms.<br />
Genus 1 A group of similar species of common descent. Examples: Canis, comprising<br />
the wolf, domestic dog, and similar species; and Quercus, the oaks.<br />
Geological time Time periods throughout the history of the earth.<br />
Giant panda A mammal that resembles the bear but is actually related to the<br />
raccoon. It is found only in isolated parts of China and now in some zoos.<br />
It eats mainly bamboo and small rodents or fish.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
40 D i v e r s i t y
Global warming An increase in the climatic temperature of the earth over a<br />
period of time.<br />
Greenhouse effect A gradual warming of the earth’s atmosphere due to an<br />
increase in carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) in the air coming from industrial smoke,<br />
car exhaust and the destruction of vegetation that uses carbon dioxide<br />
to produce oxygen. The excess CO 2 traps the sun’s energy radiating from<br />
earth, causing the warming.<br />
Habitat 1 An environment of a particular kind, such as a lake shore or tall-grass<br />
prairie; also a particular environment in one place, such as the mountain<br />
forests of Tahiti.<br />
Habitat island 1 A patch of habitat separated from other patches of the same<br />
habitat, such as a glade separated by a forest or a lake separated by dry land.<br />
Habitat islands are subject to much the same ecological and evolutionary<br />
processes as “real” islands.<br />
Hodgkin’s disease A cancer that involves the enlargement of the lymph glands,<br />
spleen and liver. There is no known cure, but there are successful treatments.<br />
Host An organism providing something (for example, food, transportation, etc.)<br />
for another. The relationship can harm, benefit or have no discernable<br />
effect on the host.<br />
Humidity The concentration of moisture in the air. If it is raining, there is<br />
100% humidity.<br />
Hybrid 1 The offspring of parents that are genetically dissimilar, especially of<br />
parents that belong to different species.<br />
Invertebrate 1 Any organism lacking a backbone of bony segments that<br />
enclose the central nerve cord. Most organisms are invertebrates, from sea<br />
anemones to earthworms, spiders and butterflies.<br />
Keystone species 1 A species, such as the sea otter, that affects the survival and<br />
abundance of many other species in the community in which it lives. Its<br />
removal or addition results in a relatively significant shift in the composition<br />
and sometimes even the physical structure of the community.<br />
Latitudinal diversity gradient 1 The trend, widespread but not universal<br />
among plants and animals, toward greater diversity with closer proximity<br />
to the equator.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
41 D i v e r s i t y
Lymphocytic leukemia A cancer that causes enlargement of the lymph<br />
glands. While there is no known cure, there are successful treatments.<br />
Mesozoic Era 1 The Age of Reptiles or Age of Dinosaurs, extending from 245<br />
million to 66 million years ago. It is divided into the Triassic, Jurassic and<br />
Cretaceous Periods.<br />
Meteorite A meteor that is not completely vaporized by friction with the<br />
atmosphere and reaches the surface of the earth.<br />
Methane gas A chemical product (CH 4 ) of the decomposition of organic<br />
matter (in marshes, mines and garbage dumps) or of the carbonization of<br />
coal. It has no color or smell and is flammable.<br />
Muntjac A small deer (of the genus Muntiacus) found in southeastern Asia<br />
and the East Indies.<br />
Myrmecology The branch of entomology dealing with the study of ants.<br />
Niches 1 A vague but useful term in ecology, meaning the place occupied by<br />
the species in its ecosystem—where it lives, what it eats, its foraging<br />
route, the seasonal activity and so on. In a more abstract sense, a niche is<br />
a potential place or role within a given ecosystem into which species may<br />
or may not have evolved.<br />
Nucleus 1 In biology, the dense central body of the cell, surrounded by a<br />
double nuclear membrane and containing the chromosomes and genes.<br />
Nutrient A substance taken in by an organism that is used to produce energy<br />
and matter.<br />
Order of magnitude A range of estimation extending from a given value to<br />
10 times that value.<br />
Organelle A specialized cellular structure that is analogous to an organ. For<br />
example, chloroplasts and mitochondria are organelles.<br />
Organism A living thing or creature, including plants, animals, invertebrates,<br />
fungi, etc.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
42 D i v e r s i t y
Ozone A form of oxygen (O 3 ) that is created in the earth’s upper atmosphere<br />
by a photochemical reaction with solar ultraviolet radiation (UV). This<br />
ozone layer protects the earth from receiving too much UV. It is also a<br />
byproduct of industrial reactions and is a major contributor to smog.<br />
Paleontology 1 The scientific study of fossils and all aspects of extinct life.<br />
Paleozoic Era A geologic time period starting with the Cambrian Period 620<br />
million years ago and ending with the Permian Period 245 million years ago.<br />
Parasite An organism that lives by using another organism, returning no<br />
benefits to the host.<br />
Permian Period 1 The last period of the Paleozoic Era, extending from 290<br />
million to 245 million years ago and closing with the greatest extinction<br />
event of all time. Somewhere between 77% and 96% of all marine animal<br />
species perished during this period.<br />
Pharmaceutical Having to do with the drugs and medications used in<br />
medical science.<br />
Physiology A branch of biology that deals with the physical and chemical<br />
functions of an organism.<br />
Population 1 In biology, any group of organisms belonging to the same species<br />
at the same time and place.<br />
Population biology The study of the population dynamics, or the changes in<br />
population distribution and density that occur over time, for a particular<br />
species.<br />
Pre-emption hypothesis Those species that established themselves in an area<br />
first and which have a more likely chance of thriving and evolving into<br />
diverse and abundant species.<br />
Replication The process of making an exact duplicate. For example, DNA<br />
uses replication to make more DNA.<br />
Roundworm A member of the Phylum Nematoda, an organism (can be a<br />
micro- or macroscopic species) with an unsegmented body that often lives<br />
in the soil or in host animals.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
43 D i v e r s i t y
Sociobiology The study of the biological bases of social behavior in animals<br />
and how this behavior is influenced by the processes of natural selection.<br />
Initially, sociobiology was quite controversial because it was applied to<br />
explain human behavior.<br />
Species 1 The basic unit of classification, consisting of a population or series of<br />
populations of closely related and similar organisms. In sexually reproducing<br />
organisms, a species is more narrowly defined by the biological species<br />
concept: a population or series of populations of organisms that freely<br />
interbreed with one another, but not with members of other species, in<br />
natural conditions.<br />
Square kilometers A metric form of measurement of area; one square kilometer<br />
is equal to .3844 square miles.<br />
Statistical The collection, analysis and interpretation of numerical data. An<br />
opinion poll is statistical.<br />
Strain A group of organisms from a common ancestor with different hereditary<br />
characteristics. For example, there are many strains of lab mice, some that<br />
look different and others that are only physiologically different.<br />
Stratosphere The upper layer of the earth’s atmosphere, approximately seven<br />
miles from the surface.<br />
Symbiosis 1 The living together of two or more species in a prolonged and<br />
intimate ecological relationship with no harmful effect, such as the<br />
incorporation of algae and cyanobacteria within fungi to form lichens.<br />
Synthesis A combination of thoughts, concepts, or materials constituting a<br />
logical process.<br />
Systematics 1 The scientific study of the diversity of life. Sometimes used<br />
synonymously with taxonomy to mean the procedures of pure classification<br />
and reconstruction of phylogeny (relationship among species); on other<br />
occasions it is used more broadly to cover all aspects of the origins and<br />
content of biodiversity.<br />
Taxonomy 1 The science (and art) of the classification of organisms. See also<br />
Systematics.<br />
Temperate A moderate climate characterized by distinct seasons. There are<br />
northern and southern temperate zones.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
44 D i v e r s i t y
Termites A group of insects that is socially structured like bees, with sexual<br />
forms, sterile workers and sometimes soldiers. There are several species living<br />
from the tropics to northern regions. Many species live in or feed on wood.<br />
Terra incognita Latin: incognita: unknown or unexplored; terra: place or territory.<br />
Terrestrial An organism that lives on or in or grows from the ground, as<br />
opposed to living in the water or air.<br />
Thrombosis The formation of a blood clot in a blood vessel.<br />
Trait An inherited characteristic.<br />
Tropical rain forest 1 Also known more technically as tropical closed moist forest:<br />
a forest with 200 cm of annual rainfall spread evenly through the year and<br />
which supports broad-leaved evergreen trees, typically arranged in several<br />
irregular canopy layers dense enough to capture more than 90% of the<br />
sunlight before it reaches the ground.<br />
Ultraviolet radiation The rays of the sun that are of shorter wavelength than<br />
the spectrum visible to human eyes.<br />
Wildlife reserve An area of habitat(s) left undeveloped and supposedly safe<br />
from other human activities, designed to help wildlife flourish.<br />
1 From the Glossary in E.O. Wilson’s The <strong>Diversity</strong> of Life, 1992, Belknap Press of<br />
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 391-407.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
45 D i v e r s i t y
A p p e n d i x I I<br />
Suggested Readings<br />
B o o k s<br />
Cohen, Joel E. 1995. How Many People Can the Earth Support? W.W. Norton and<br />
Company, Inc. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
“... the definitive work on the global population problem.”<br />
—Edward O. Wilson<br />
The Earthworks Group. 1995. 50 Simple Things You Can Do to Save the Earth.<br />
Andrews and McMeel. Kansas City, Missouri.<br />
“To commemorate the twenty-fifth anniversary of Earth Day, an updated<br />
guide to environmental awareness encompasses the latest research into such<br />
issues as global warming, ozone depletion, and endangered species and<br />
offers advice on how readers can help the environment.”<br />
—from Amazon.com<br />
NOTE: This book is out of print.<br />
The Earthworks Group. 1991. The Next Step: 50 More Things You Can Do to Save<br />
the Earth. Andrews and McMeel. Kansas City, Missouri.<br />
“It goes beyond simple, individual actions, and focuses on ways of expanding<br />
community participation and awareness, ways of empowering people to<br />
create an impact beyond their own homes.” —from Amazon.com<br />
Ehrlich, Paul R., and A. H. Ehrlich. 1998. Betrayal of Science and Reason: How<br />
Anti-Environment Rhetoric Threatens Our Future. Island Press. Washington, D.C.<br />
The most recent work by well known authorities on the problems of overpopulation<br />
and related environmental problems.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
46 D i v e r s i t y
Grifo, Francesca, and J. Rosenthal (eds.). 1996. Biodiversity and Human Health.<br />
Island Press. Washington, D.C.<br />
Until recently, the direct effects of declining biodiversity on human health<br />
have not been greatly discussed. This publication addresses some of these<br />
concerns while offering strategies for the sustainable use of biodiversity.<br />
Mackintosh, Gay (ed.). 1989. Preserving Communities and Corridors. Defenders of<br />
Wildlife. Washington, D.C.<br />
A thorough report that shows how the preservation of connections between<br />
natural communities can help to maintain biodiversity.<br />
Myers, Norman. 1983. A Wealth of Wild Species: Storehouse for Human Welfare.<br />
Westview Press. Boulder, Colorado.<br />
This book discusses the “utilitarian benefits” of preserving biodiversity. It is<br />
a classic text on the economic aspects and the questions continuously asked<br />
in ecological discussions.<br />
Myers, Norman. 1992. The Primary Source: Tropical Forests and Our Future.<br />
W.W. Norton & Company, Inc. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
Dr. Myers describes not only the condition of these forests and what needs<br />
to be done to preserve them, but also how these forests influence the lives of<br />
all people on earth.<br />
Office of Technology Assessment. 1987. Technologies to Maintain <strong>Biological</strong><br />
<strong>Diversity</strong>. Government Printing Office. Washington, D.C.<br />
This report identifies some potential opportunities and also some constraints<br />
to maintaining biodiversity.<br />
Platt, Rutherford H., R.A. Rowntree, and P.C. Muick (eds.). 1994. The Ecological<br />
City: Preserving and Restoring Urban Biodiversity. University of<br />
Massachusetts Press. Amherst, Massachusetts.<br />
“The symposium on ‘Sustainable Cities: Preserving and Restoring Urban<br />
Biodiversity,’ which led to this volume, was devoted to a reconnaissance of<br />
(1) the functions of biodiversity within urban areas, (2) the impacts of<br />
urbanization upon biodiversity, and (3) the ways to design cities compatibly<br />
with their ecological contexts.” —from the introduction and overview.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
47 D i v e r s i t y
Reid, Walter V., and K.R. Miller. 1989. Keeping Options Alive: The Scientific Basis<br />
for Conserving Biodiversity. World Resources Institute. Washington, D.C.<br />
“In a way, Keeping Options Alive is a ‘how-to’ publication. Its timely premise<br />
is that the biological sciences can help policy makers identify the threats<br />
to biodiversity, evaluate conservation tools, and come up with successful<br />
management strategies to the crisis of biotic impoverishment before it is<br />
full-blown.” —from the foreword.<br />
Soulé, Michael E. (ed.). 1987. Viable Populations for Conservation. Cambridge<br />
University Press. Cambridge, England.<br />
“This book addresses the most recent research in the rapidly developing<br />
integration of conservation biology with population biology.” —from the<br />
back cover.<br />
Thorne-Miller, Boyce, and S.A. Earle. 1998. The Living Ocean: Understanding and<br />
Protecting Marine Biodiversity—2nd edition. Island Press. Washington, D.C.<br />
A valuable primer for understanding the threats to marine biodiversity and<br />
the conservation needs of this important ecosystem.<br />
Western, David, and M.C. Pearl (eds.). 1989. Conservation for the Twenty-First<br />
Century. Oxford University Press. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
This collection of writings from a diverse group of authors outlines<br />
approaches to nature conservation and it also reviews some possible future<br />
outcomes for habitats and wildlife.<br />
Wilson, Edward O. (ed.), and Frances M. Peter (photographer). 1989. Biodiversity.<br />
National Academy Press. Washington, D.C.<br />
This book is a collection of papers from a major conference that highlights<br />
the causes of biodiversity loss followed by a systematic analysis of the<br />
approaches to preserving biodiversity.<br />
“Anyone concerned with biodiversity should own this book …”<br />
—from the journal Science.<br />
Wilson, Edward O. 1992. The <strong>Diversity</strong> of Life. W.W. Norton & Company, Inc.<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
“In this book a master scientist tells the great story of how life on earth<br />
evolved. Edward O. Wilson describes how the species of the world became<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
48 D i v e r s i t y
diverse and why the threat to that diversity today is beyond the scope of<br />
anything we have known before.”<br />
—from the back cover.<br />
Wyman, Richard L. (ed.). 1991. Global Climate Change and Life on Earth.<br />
Chapman and Hall. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
“Global Climate Change and Life on Earth focuses on the greenhouse effect<br />
and its relation to such crucial issues as deforestation, overpopulation and<br />
hunger, pollution, sea-level changes, and the loss of biodiversity. These<br />
environmental threats now facing us could have so much momentum that<br />
unless steps are taken now to reverse them, they may soon overwhelm our<br />
ability to respond.” —from the back cover.<br />
P e r i o d i c a l s<br />
<strong>Biological</strong> Conservation<br />
Monthly publication on theoretical and applied science, research and<br />
commentary on conservation issues; worldwide in scope.<br />
The Conservationist<br />
Monthly publication of the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Department of Environmental<br />
Conservation. Lots of artwork; non-technical articles associated with<br />
wildlife management and outdoor recreation.<br />
National Geographic<br />
Monthly magazine. Non-technical; lots of color photographs; good coverage<br />
of wildlife refuges, national parks, rare species, unusual ecosystems.<br />
Natural History<br />
Monthly magazine. Non-technical; lots of photographs; emphasizes natural<br />
diversity of the landscape and diversity of organisms.<br />
Nature<br />
Weekly British scientific journal. Short, highly technical articles reporting<br />
original research on all scientific subjects.<br />
Nature Conservancy<br />
Bimonthly magazine of the Nature Conservancy, an organization dedicated<br />
to saving unique natural areas primarily by buying and preserving them.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
49 D i v e r s i t y
<strong>New</strong> Scientist<br />
Weekly British publication. Brief, non-technical, often “chatty” articles on a<br />
wide range of recent scientific discoveries, controversies, and public policy<br />
issues; excellent coverage of biological and conservation issues.<br />
S e l e c t e d P u b l i c a t i o n s<br />
P e r t a i n i n g t o N e w Y o r k S t a t e<br />
Daniels, Robert A. 1996. Guide to the Identification of Scales of Inland Fishes of<br />
Northeastern North America. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
This book presents a comprehensive source of information to assist<br />
researchers in identifying the scales of inland fishes of the Northeast.<br />
Mills, Edward L., M.D. Scheuerell, J.T. Carlton, and D.L. Strayer. 1997.<br />
<strong>Biological</strong> Invasions in the Hudson River Basin. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>.<br />
Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
“The purpose of this study is to present a comprehensive inventory of<br />
the introduced flora and fauna of the Hudson River drainage basin.”<br />
—from the introduction.<br />
Mitchell, Richard S., and C.J. Sheviak. 1981. Rare Plants of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong>. <strong>New</strong><br />
<strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
“Through this publication we seek to reach the interested public as well as<br />
professionals in conservation and biology. The book is not intended to be a<br />
purely technical botanical document, but a practical guide and introduction<br />
to the subject of rare plants in the state.” —from the foreword.<br />
Mitchell, Richard S., and G. Tucker. 1997. Revised Checklist of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong><br />
Plants. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
Revised compilation of all vascular plant species known to grow, independently<br />
of cultivation, within the state of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
50 D i v e r s i t y
Mitchell, Richard S., L. Danaher, and G. Steeves. 1998. Northeastern Fern<br />
Identifier. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
This innovative software package allows identification of fern species from<br />
the northeastern United <strong>State</strong>s by simply pointing and clicking. Each species<br />
is illustrated with a color photograph. This PC-compatible software is<br />
available only on CD-ROM.<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Department of Environmental Conservation. 1987. Checklist of<br />
Amphibians, Reptiles, Birds and Mammals of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong>, Including their<br />
Protective Status. NYSDEC, Division of Fish, Wildlife and Marine<br />
Resources. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
Available from the NYSDEC Web site: www.dec.state.ny.us<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> Department of Environmental Conservation. 1987. Endangered,<br />
Threatened and Special Concern Fish & Wildlife Species of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong>.<br />
NYSDEC, Division of Fish, Wildlife and Marine Resources. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
A checklist. Available from the NYSDEC Web site: www.dec.state.ny.us<br />
Reschke, Carol. 1990. Ecological Communities of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong>. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Natural<br />
Heritage Program. Latham, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
“The primary objective of this report is to classify and describe ecological<br />
communities representing the full array of biological diversity of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
<strong>State</strong>.” —from the introduction.<br />
Siegfried, Clifford A. 1986. Understanding <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Lakes. <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong><br />
<strong>Museum</strong>. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
“This pamphlet serves as a starting point for the general reader who is interested<br />
in lakes. It is intended as an introduction to what lakes are and how<br />
they function, and to some of the problems that must be faced by resource<br />
managers in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong>.” —from part I.<br />
Strayer, David L., and K.J. Jirka. 1997. The Pearly Mussels of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong>. <strong>New</strong><br />
<strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>. Albany, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
Illustrations, descriptions and keys of the shells of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>’s pearly mussels.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
51 D i v e r s i t y
A p p e n d i x I I I<br />
Discussion Questions<br />
1. What is biodiversity?<br />
2. Why is biodiversity important?<br />
3. What recent worldwide events have made the importance of biodiversity and<br />
the health of the environment more widely recognized?<br />
4. Is there more or less diversity now than 100 million years ago?<br />
5. How long ago did the diversity start to increase? Why?<br />
6. Is there more or less diversity among small organisms? Why?<br />
7. How much do scientists know about all the plants and animals on earth?<br />
8. What is the science of systematics? Taxonomy? Classification?<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
52 D i v e r s i t y
9. Is an ecologist the same as a taxonomist? How are they the same or different?<br />
Do they work together?<br />
10. Why is it important to know the name of an organism?<br />
11. Do scientists have a name for every plant and animal on earth?<br />
12. How many plants and animals are there on earth? What are scientists’ best<br />
guesses?<br />
13. Can you name five plants that are used medicinally?<br />
14. What can a leech do for humans?<br />
15. Why are insects useful? Give two examples.<br />
16. What areas of the world are called tropical?<br />
17. What is unique about the way plants grow in the tropics?<br />
18. Why are the tropics particularly rich but fragile environments?<br />
19. Where is Madagascar?<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
53 D i v e r s i t y
20. Why do so many of the plants and animals live in the tropical rainforest?<br />
Why do many of them live in the canopy of the forest?<br />
21. What is extinction?<br />
22. Can extinction be reversed?<br />
23. When did much of the current environmental destruction and change start<br />
to occur?<br />
24. Have there been other times in history of the earth when mass extinction<br />
occurred? When? Why?<br />
25. What possible conditions caused the disappearance of the dinosaurs?<br />
26. What is the major difference between environmental changes now and<br />
environmental changes 300 years ago?<br />
27. What is the greenhouse effect?<br />
28. What are the major causes of rainforest destruction?<br />
29. Do you see signs of environmental destruction in your home area?<br />
What are they?<br />
30. Do you know of a wildlife preserve near your home?<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
54 D i v e r s i t y
31. Do you know of a biological research station or institution in your area?<br />
Have you been to visit it? Is there a scientist on its staff? What does he or<br />
she study?<br />
32. Can you list five areas in which biological scientists specialize?<br />
33. Are there plants and animals threatened with extinction in the northeastern<br />
United <strong>State</strong>s? Can you name some of them?<br />
34. Name some animals that are not threatened with extinction in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
Why are they not considered threatened or endangered?<br />
35. Can you name two environmental groups dedicated to saving biodiversity?<br />
36. What are some things we each can do to help preserve biodiversity?<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
55 D i v e r s i t y
A p p e n d i x I V<br />
Geologic Time Table<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
56 D i v e r s i t y
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
57 D i v e r s i t y
Credits<br />
A r t w o r k<br />
The drawings throughout the book, except for those pieces noted below, are original<br />
graphite drawings by Patricia Kernan. Patricia has been a scientific illustrator<br />
at the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong> since 1988.<br />
Cover artwork and design are also by Patricia Kernan.<br />
O t h e r A r t i s t s<br />
Powdery mildew (p. 14), 1861 print from a copper plate engraving of a drawing by<br />
Charles Tulasne, printed by permission of Farlow Reference Library, Harvard<br />
University.<br />
Franklinia alatamaha (p. 22), watercolor (circa 1788) by William Bartram, printed<br />
by permission of the British <strong>Museum</strong>, Natural History.<br />
Peregrine Falcons (p. 32), watercolor by Louis Agassiz Fuertes, originally printed in<br />
1914 by the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>.<br />
F i e l d S t a t i o n P h o t o s<br />
Sirena <strong>Biological</strong> Field Station, taken in 1988 by Patricia Kernan, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong><br />
<strong>Museum</strong>.<br />
Palmer Station, taken in 1998 by Dean S. Klein, Antarctic Support Associates.<br />
Fu-Shan Station, taken in 1996 by John H. Haines, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>.<br />
Edmund Niles Huyck Preserve & <strong>Biological</strong> Research Station, taken in 1998 by<br />
Ronald J. Gill, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>.<br />
G e o l o g i c T i m e t a b l e<br />
The geologic time table is a publication of the Geological Survey at the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
<strong>State</strong> <strong>Museum</strong>.<br />
B o o k D e s i g n<br />
Design by: Documentation Strategies, Inc., Rensselaer, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
In cooperation with Kristine Fitzgerald, 2k Design, Clifton Park, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>.<br />
B i o l o g i c a l<br />
58 D i v e r s i t y
THE NEW YORK STATE MUSEUM IS A PROGRAM OF<br />
THE UNIVERSITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK<br />
THE STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT<br />
ISBN: 1-55557-210-3<br />
ISSN: 0735-4401