claritas_sample_chapter_1
claritas_sample_chapter_1
claritas_sample_chapter_1
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
CHAPTER 1<br />
THE INVESTMENT INDUSTRY:<br />
A TOP- DOWN VIEW<br />
by Ian Rossa O’Reilly, CFA
LEARNING OUTCOMES<br />
After completing this <strong>chapter</strong>, you should be able to do the following:<br />
a<br />
Explain how an economy benefits from the existence of the investment<br />
industry;<br />
b Explain how an individual benefits from the existence of the investment<br />
industry;<br />
c<br />
Describe types and functions of participants that collectively comprise<br />
the structure of the investment industry;<br />
d Describe forces that affect the evolution of the investment industry.
Introduction 3<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
1<br />
People work to sustain themselves and their dependents. Often, they earn money for<br />
their labor and use that money to purchase goods and services. If they spend less than<br />
they earn, they have savings. If they expect to earn a return on their savings, they<br />
are investing. For example, an individual might lend her savings to a neighbor who is<br />
starting a new business. If she realistically expects to get more money back than she<br />
lent, she is making an investment.<br />
One reason why the financial services industry exists is to provide a link between<br />
savers (also called lenders or investors) that have funds to invest and spenders (also<br />
called borrowers) that need funds. After all, not all savers have savvy neighbors who<br />
are starting promising businesses. As a result, they have to look elsewhere for opportunities<br />
to earn a return on their money.<br />
Lenders invest their savings in a wide range of assets. Assets are items that have value<br />
and include real assets and financial assets. Real assets are physical assets, such as<br />
land, buildings, cattle, and gold. In contrast, financial assets are claims on real assets.<br />
For example, a share of stock represents ownership in a company. This share gives its<br />
owner, called a shareholder (or stockholder), rights to some of the company’s assets<br />
and earnings.<br />
Financial assets that can be traded are called securities. The two largest categories<br />
of securities are debt and equity securities:<br />
■<br />
■<br />
Debt securities are loans that lenders make to borrowers. Lenders expect the<br />
borrowers to repay these loans and to make interest payments until the loans<br />
are repaid. Because interest payments on many loans are fixed, debt securities<br />
are also called fixed- income securities. They are also known as bonds, and<br />
investors in bonds are referred to as bondholders. More information about debt<br />
securities is provided in Chapter 10.<br />
Equity securities are also called stocks, shares of stock, or shares. As mentioned,<br />
shareholders have ownership in the company. The company has no<br />
obligation to either repay the money the shareholders contributed or to make<br />
regular payments, called dividends. However, investors who buy stocks expect<br />
to earn a return by being able to sell their shares at a higher price than they<br />
bought them and, possibly, by receiving dividends. Equity securities are discussed<br />
further in Chapter 9.<br />
Places where buyers and sellers can trade securities are known as securities markets or<br />
financial markets. A distinction is sometimes made within financial markets between<br />
money markets, for securities that have a maturity shorter than a year, and capital<br />
markets, for securities that have a maturity longer than a year. How securities are<br />
issued, bought, and sold is explained in Chapters 13 and 15.<br />
Copyright © 2012 CFA Institute
4<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
The primary role of financial markets is to channel funds from savers to spenders.<br />
Savers include individuals (households), companies (firms), and governments with<br />
excess money to invest. Note that in this <strong>chapter</strong> and in the rest of the curriculum,<br />
the terms money, cash, funds, and financial capital (or capital) may be used interchangeably.<br />
Savers provide capital to spenders.<br />
Spenders include individuals, companies, and governments. For example, individuals<br />
borrow to pay for houses, tuition, and unforeseen expenses. Companies borrow to<br />
invest in real assets, such as land, buildings, or machinery. These real assets represent<br />
a company’s means (or factors) of production, and they are sometimes referred to as<br />
physical capital. Governments borrow when their current tax receipts are insufficient<br />
to fund their current spending plans.<br />
Savers and spenders sometimes interact through financial markets. The movement<br />
of funds from those who have funds to invest (the savers who become providers of<br />
capital) to those who need funds (the spenders who become users of capital) through<br />
financial markets is called direct finance. Savers and spenders often rely on individuals<br />
in the investment industry to help them navigate financial markets. The investment<br />
industry is a subset of the financial services industry. It comprises all the players that<br />
are instrumental in helping savers invest their money and borrowers get the funds they<br />
require. The major investment industry participants, such as exchanges, investment<br />
brokers (brokers), investment dealers (dealers), financial advisers, and investment<br />
analysts (analysts), are introduced in Section 4 of this <strong>chapter</strong> and discussed further<br />
in Module 5.<br />
Savers and borrowers often rely on financial intermediaries to find each other and to<br />
channel funds between each other. This is indirect finance. Financial intermediaries<br />
act as “middlemen” between those who have funds to invest and those who need funds.<br />
Credit institutions, such as banks, are a typical example of financial intermediaries.<br />
They collect savings from lenders and transform them into loans to borrowers. This<br />
transformation process is known as financial intermediation, hence the reason why<br />
banks are called financial intermediaries. Other types of financial intermediaries are<br />
discussed in Chapter 13.<br />
Financial intermediaries and the investment industry play important roles in the<br />
financial services industry. Many savers do not have the time or the expertise to identify<br />
and select individuals, companies, and governments to lend to or invest in. Once<br />
savers have lent money, they have to monitor the borrower’s behavior and financial<br />
health to ensure that they will get their money back—a task that is time- consuming<br />
and costly. Matching savers and borrowers and monitoring borrowers are functions<br />
that financial intermediaries can perform better and more cheaply than most investors<br />
can do on their own. The investment industry helps investors evaluate the behavior<br />
and financial health of the companies and governments they invest in.<br />
Because savers are assigning responsibilities to financial intermediaries and participants<br />
in the investment industry, trust is essential to the proper functioning of the financial<br />
services industry. Savers should have confidence that they will earn a return on their<br />
investments and that they will be treated fairly by borrowers, financial intermediaries,<br />
and investment industry participants. If trust is lacking, savers will be reluctant to<br />
invest, and the economy will suffer.
How Economies Benefit from the Existence of the Investment Industry 5<br />
Exhibit 1 summarizes graphically how funds can be channeled between savers and<br />
spenders, either directly through financial markets or indirectly through financial<br />
intermediaries.<br />
Exhibit 1<br />
Overview of the Financial Services Industry<br />
DIRECT FINANCE<br />
Savers/<br />
Lenders/<br />
Providers of Capital<br />
Funds<br />
Financial Markets<br />
<br />
<br />
Funds<br />
Spenders/<br />
Borrowers/<br />
Users of Capital<br />
Funds<br />
Funds<br />
Financial Intermediaries<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
INDIRECT FINANCE<br />
Funds<br />
Source: Based on data from the European Central Bank (http://www.ecb.int/mopo/eaec/structure/<br />
html/index.en.html).<br />
HOW ECONOMIES BENEFIT FROM THE EXISTENCE OF THE<br />
INVESTMENT INDUSTRY<br />
2<br />
Economic systems can take many forms, from pure capitalism with free markets to<br />
planned economies with centralized authority. The goal of all economic systems is the<br />
efficient allocation of scarce resources to their most productive uses.<br />
Resources, such as labor, real assets, and financial capital, are necessary to produce<br />
goods and services. People have an unlimited desire for goods and services, but<br />
resources are limited. To illustrate this concept of scarcity, assume that an individual<br />
has a limited budget; his financial capital is scarce. Should he spend his money on<br />
buying food, paying his mortgage, purchasing a new car, or going on an expensive<br />
holiday? Similarly, should governments spend money on health care, education,<br />
defense, or infrastructure?<br />
Because resources are scarce, decisions must be made regarding the allocation of these<br />
resources. All economic systems must address three questions: (1) Which goods and<br />
services should be produced? (2) How should the goods and services be produced?
6<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
(3) Who should receive the goods and services that are produced? The allocation of<br />
scarce resources is efficient if the scarce resources are used to produce goods and<br />
services that best satisfy the needs of consumers.<br />
2.1 Market Economies<br />
Capitalism is an economic system that favors private ownership as the means of production<br />
and markets as the means of allocating scarce resources. Markets are places<br />
where buyers meet sellers to trade. Markets include goods and services markets as<br />
well as financial markets.<br />
In a pure, free market, capitalistic economy, there is no central authority, such as a<br />
government, directing economic activity. Instead, individuals and companies make<br />
their own decisions about what goods and services to manufacture and provide, and<br />
they get to keep the profits from their activities. If everything goes according to plan,<br />
scarce resources are deployed in the most efficient manner through the markets and<br />
the economy grows at a healthy rate.<br />
Pure free market capitalism is something that exists only in theory. In the real world,<br />
governments play a role in all economies. In some capitalistic economies, such as in<br />
Western economies, the government’s role in business is fairly minimal. In countries<br />
largely based on extraction of natural resources, such as some former Soviet Republics,<br />
some Middle Eastern countries, and some South American countries, the government<br />
maintains significant control over key national industries. In transition economies,<br />
which are moving from socialist planned economies to market economies, the government<br />
plays a significant role in the economy and business. China’s economy is often<br />
described as state capitalism because the Chinese central and local governments have<br />
significant ownership of many businesses. In China, however, people can create and<br />
invest in businesses and a great deal of market competition exists.<br />
2.2 Benefits Provided by the Investment Industry<br />
The investment industry brings several benefits to the economy. It facilitates lending<br />
and borrowing. As mentioned above, the investment industry is instrumental in<br />
channeling funds between savers who have money but no immediate use for it and<br />
spenders who have projects to finance but insufficient capital to do so.<br />
The investment industry contributes to the efficient allocation of resources in the<br />
economy. Without the investment industry, suppliers and users of capital would have<br />
to spend significant resources finding each other. These resources would be expended<br />
on the search rather than on more productive uses, resulting in less efficiency.<br />
The investment industry plays an important role in providing and processing information<br />
about investment opportunities. Many investment industry participants help<br />
investors collect and analyze macroeconomic data and information about individuals,<br />
companies, and governments’ capital needs and asset values. Some of the tools and<br />
inputs these participants use are described in Module 3.
How Individuals Benefit from the Existence of the Investment Industry 7<br />
Investment industry participants package investment opportunities so that they satisfy<br />
the needs of lenders and borrowers. The investment industry offers a wide range<br />
of products and services that make it easier for savers to invest and for spenders to<br />
access the funds they need. These investment products and services are discussed in<br />
Modules 4 and 5.<br />
The investment industry also provides liquidity. Liquidity refers to the ease of buying<br />
or selling an asset without affecting its price. Some assets, such as real estate, are<br />
inherently illiquid. For example, if you wish to sell a house, it will likely take some time<br />
to sell even if it is priced fairly compared with other houses in the market. If you want<br />
to sell a house quickly, you may have to sell it at a lower price than you think is fair.<br />
Other assets are more liquid, such as shares that trade actively. However, an investor<br />
may hold such a large position (i.e., so many shares) that the sale of her position may<br />
alter the price in the market. For example, if an investor owns 100 shares in a company<br />
with actively traded shares, she will likely be able to sell her shares quickly and<br />
without affecting the stock price. However, if she owns 100,000 shares, she may not<br />
be able to sell those shares quickly without affecting the price in the market. Liquidity<br />
is a very important aspect of well- functioning financial markets because highly liquid<br />
markets allow investors to complete a transaction quickly (and to reverse it quickly if<br />
they change their minds) and to have confidence that they are getting the best price<br />
at that particular moment.<br />
All these benefits increase the willingness of suppliers of capital to provide funds<br />
to those who need them. Capital put to better use fosters growth, which ultimately<br />
benefits the economy.<br />
HOW INDIVIDUALS BENEFIT FROM THE EXISTENCE OF THE<br />
INVESTMENT INDUSTRY<br />
3<br />
In a well- functioning investment industry, investors are treated fairly and honestly.<br />
As a result, they have confidence to commit their savings to investments. Investment<br />
industry participants compete fairly for investors’ business, and they are competent<br />
and trustworthy in managing investment products and portfolios, executing investment<br />
transactions, and advising on investment matters.<br />
3.1 Benefits Provided by the Investment Industry<br />
Below are some of the most important features that define a well- functioning investment<br />
industry and, in turn, benefit investors.<br />
The first important feature that characterizes a well- functioning investment industry<br />
is the availability of a broad range of investment products and services that meet<br />
investors’ needs. Investment products are not limited to the debt and equity securities<br />
already presented. Other investment instruments, such as derivatives and alternative<br />
investments, are described in Chapters 11 and 12, respectively.
8<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
Investment industry participants may also buy and sell various real and financial<br />
assets and then package them to create new investment products (frequently referred<br />
to as investment vehicles) and structures that suit the needs of investors better than<br />
the original assets. Mortgage- backed securities provide an example. They represent<br />
a claim on the cash flows that are expected to materialize not from a single mortgage<br />
but from a large number of mortgages that have been grouped together in a process<br />
called securitization. Other examples of investment vehicles and structures are provided<br />
in Chapter 14.<br />
In addition to being able to choose from a broad range of investment products, investors<br />
benefit when they have access to a broad range of investment services that help<br />
them make better decisions and implement those decisions. The investment industry<br />
offers financial advisory, information, and trading services that are valuable to investors.<br />
How investment industry participants assess and serve the needs of investors is<br />
discussed further in Module 7.<br />
Investors benefit when financial markets are competitive. Markets in general and<br />
financial markets in particular are competitive if a large number of players compete<br />
with one another without any one of them having an undue influence on supply or<br />
demand. Supply refers to the quantity of a good or service sellers are willing and able<br />
to sell, whereas demand refers to the quantity of a good or service buyers desire to buy.<br />
More information about supply and demand and how the interaction of supply and<br />
demand affects prices of goods and services is presented in Chapter 6. Competitive<br />
markets promote higher production efficiency and help keep prices of goods and<br />
services, including investment products and services, down.<br />
Investors also benefit when financial markets are liquid and transaction costs are low.<br />
As mentioned earlier, liquidity ensures that investors can quickly buy or sell an asset<br />
without affecting its price. Transaction costs are the costs associated with trading.<br />
Because transaction costs reduce the return savers make on their investments, the<br />
lower the transaction costs, the better. The combination of liquidity and low transaction<br />
costs ensures that investors can trade as much (or as little) as they wish under<br />
the best possible conditions.<br />
To make reasonable judgments about their investments, investors need information<br />
about the companies and governments to which they provide or may provide capital.<br />
Therefore, access to relevant and reliable financial information is important. By helping<br />
collect and process financial information, investment industry participants provide<br />
benefits to investors. Timely access to this information is also critical because securities<br />
prices may change quickly in response to new, relevant information. For example, the<br />
stock price of an oil company that announces it has discovered a large new oil field<br />
will likely increase at the prospect of higher revenues and profit.<br />
Another important feature that characterizes a well- functioning investment industry<br />
is the ability to transform and transfer risk. Risk is defined as the effect of uncertain<br />
future events on an organization or on the outcomes the organization achieves; risk<br />
is discussed in greater detail in Chapter 17. Risk is an inherent element of investing,<br />
and investors should always consider both return and risk when they make investment<br />
decisions. For example, the individual who lent her savings to her neighbor faces the<br />
risk that her neighbor’s business fails and she never gets her money back. Although<br />
the prospect of investing in the next Apple, Google, or Microsoft may be appealing,<br />
the investor may finally decide not to lend her money to her neighbor if losing her<br />
entire savings would have a devastating effect on her lifestyle. The investment industry
How Individuals Benefit from the Existence of the Investment Industry 9<br />
offers those who want to reduce risk the opportunity to do so. For example, products<br />
that represent some form of insurance may be available for purchase. Those who are<br />
willing to take on risk may sell insurance or offer investments that allow others to<br />
reduce their risks.<br />
3.2 Laws, Regulations, and Trust<br />
Laws and regulations are necessary to ensure that investors are treated fairly and<br />
honestly. Usually, laws are passed by a legislative body, such as Congress in the United<br />
States, Parliament in the United Kingdom, or the Diet in Japan. Regulations are created<br />
by agencies, such as the Canadian Securities Administrators in Canada, the Autorité<br />
des Marchés Financiers in France, or the Securities & Futures Commission in Hong<br />
Kong. Both laws and regulations are enforceable, and enforcement is critical for laws<br />
and regulations to be effective.<br />
The form and extent of laws and regulations vary between countries and change<br />
over time, but there are some general principles that apply consistently. Laws and<br />
regulations are designed to<br />
■<br />
■<br />
■<br />
prevent fraud;<br />
protect investment industry participants, in particular investors; and<br />
promote and maintain the integrity, transparency, and fairness of financial<br />
markets.<br />
For example, trading based on nonpublic information that could affect a security’s<br />
price, called insider trading, is generally forbidden across most jurisdictions. An analyst<br />
who learns during a private meeting with a company’s management that the company<br />
is about to acquire a competitor is not allowed to buy or sell shares in the company<br />
or its competitor until the company has officially announced the acquisition. If the<br />
analyst were to trade before this information is available to all market participants, he<br />
could gain from his inside information and the integrity and fairness of the financial<br />
market would be compromised.<br />
Although the investment industry is subject to laws and regulations, these laws and<br />
regulations cannot cover every situation and cannot prevent fraud or market abuse<br />
from happening. This is why it is important that<br />
■<br />
■<br />
individuals who work in the investment industry behave ethically, in accordance<br />
with a set of moral principles, and act professionally; and<br />
organizations that employ these individuals promote cultures of integrity.<br />
Ethical behavior on the part of investment industry participants is paramount to<br />
protecting the reputation of the industry and to maintaining trust in the industry.<br />
Without trust, savers may be less likely to make investments, which would ultimately<br />
be detrimental to the economy.<br />
We return to the discussion of ethics and regulation in Chapters 2 and 3, respectively.<br />
Chapter 17 also addresses the issue of compliance with laws and regulations.
10<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
4<br />
INVESTMENT INDUSTRY PARTICIPANTS<br />
There are many investment industry participants who help savers invest their funds<br />
and help lenders get the funds they require. Anybody working in the investment<br />
industry or using services provided by the investment industry is bound to come in<br />
contact with several of these players.<br />
4.1 Major Players<br />
To introduce some of the major players, consider the example of a Canadian company<br />
that needs funds to support its growth. The company may generate funds from its<br />
current operations, but if the funds are not enough to support its growth plans, it will<br />
have to turn to providers of capital. The investment industry can help the company<br />
raise the funds it needs and allow investors to participate in the company’s growth.<br />
We first discuss investment industry participants that may help the Canadian company<br />
to raise funds. Then we discuss investors and investment industry participants that<br />
may help them to invest funds.<br />
4.1.1 Raising Funds and Investment Industry Participants<br />
The Canadian company wants to issue shares to raise additional equity capital. Until<br />
now, it has been private; it has not raised funds by issuing shares publicly. It wants to<br />
take the equity issuance opportunity to become a public company and have its stock<br />
listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange. Stock exchanges are organized and regulated<br />
financial markets that allow buyers and sellers to trade shares with each other.<br />
The company contacts an investment bank. Investment banks have expertise in helping<br />
companies and governments raise funds globally. The investment bank will organize<br />
the company’s first equity issuance, called an initial public offering (IPO). Chapter 9<br />
provides more details about IPOs and equity issuances in general.<br />
The investment bank will help determine the price at which the new shares will be<br />
issued. To do so, it not only has to assess the company’s value, but it also has to gauge<br />
investor interest in purchasing shares of the company. The investment bank’s analysts—often<br />
called sell- side analysts because they work for the organization selling<br />
the securities—will collect and analyze information about the company and prepare<br />
detailed reports that can be shared with potential investors.<br />
Once the investment bank has determined the price of the new shares, the IPO will<br />
take place in the primary market—that is, the market where new securities, IPOs,<br />
and subsequent offerings are issued and sold to investors. In exchange for providing<br />
money to the company, investors will receive shares in the company. Companies get<br />
funds when they issue new securities in primary markets. After the IPO, the company’s<br />
shares will be traded in the secondary market—that is, the market where investors buy<br />
and sell securities to each other. The Canadian company will not receive any capital<br />
from the trading of its shares in the secondary market.
Investment Industry Participants 11<br />
Now that the Canadian company is a public company, it will have to comply with the<br />
rules set forth by the Toronto Stock Exchange and with relevant Canadian laws and<br />
regulations. One typical rule is related to financial reporting; the Canadian company<br />
will have to file quarterly financial statements and audited annual financial statements.<br />
Auditors, who evaluate a company’s accounting and internal controls, play<br />
a very important role. They ensure that investors receive reliable information, a key<br />
feature of a well- functioning investment industry. More information about financial<br />
statements is provided in Chapter 4.<br />
4.1.2 Investing Funds and Investment Industry Participants<br />
The Canadian company may have sold its shares to many investors. When investors<br />
want to buy (sell) shares in the secondary market, they need to find another investor<br />
who is willing to sell (buy) shares. Brokers and dealers are very important investment<br />
industry participants who facilitate trading between investors. Brokers act as agents.<br />
They do not trade directly with market participants; they only help buyers and sellers<br />
find one another and trade with each other. In contrast, dealers act as principals.<br />
They use their own accounts and their own capital to trade with buyers and sellers in<br />
what is known as proprietary trading. They “make markets” in securities by acting as<br />
buyers when investors want to sell and as sellers when investors want to buy. Brokers<br />
and dealers provide liquidity and help reduce transaction costs; as mentioned earlier,<br />
liquidity and low transaction costs are beneficial to investors.<br />
There are also investment industry participants that provide trading support. They<br />
include clearing and settlement agents that confirm and settle trades after they<br />
have been arranged. Custodians also provide trading support by holding money and<br />
securities on behalf of their clients.<br />
There are different categories of investors, which are discussed further in Chapters 13<br />
and 19. Institutional investors are typically organizations that invest for themselves to<br />
advance their mission or invest for others to meet the others’ needs. For example, pension<br />
funds manage portfolios for the benefit of current and future retirees. Institutional<br />
investors usually rely on their own analysts to review a potential investment. These<br />
analysts are called buy- side analysts because they work for the organization buying<br />
the securities. They rely on investment information service providers, such as data<br />
vendors and investment research providers, to gather data about the company and<br />
its environment.<br />
Individual investors often do not have the time, the inclination, or the expertise to<br />
perform their own analysis. Some of them, such as wealthy individuals called highnet-<br />
worth investors, may seek the help of investment professionals, such as financial<br />
advisers (also called investment advisers). Financial advisers help their clients understand<br />
their future financial needs and the risks they face when investing as well as<br />
provide advice about investments. High- net- worth investors very often give authority<br />
to their advisers to manage the investments on their behalf. These advisers are called<br />
investment managers or asset managers.<br />
Many investors may be willing to invest but lack sufficient financial resources to<br />
contract an asset manager to look after their investments. These investors, called<br />
retail investors, very often buy investment products created and managed by banks,<br />
insurance companies, or investment management firms. For example, an individual
12<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
who wishes to plan for her retirement may need a convenient and inexpensive way<br />
of investing money regularly. She may buy shares in a mutual fund, a professionally<br />
managed vehicle that has investments in a range of securities.<br />
Exhibit 2 summarizes the investment industry participants introduced in this section.<br />
They are grouped into categories that are discussed further in Chapter 13. The rest<br />
of the curriculum provides more information about how these participants operate<br />
and how they interact with one another and with investors.<br />
Exhibit 2<br />
Investment Industry Participants<br />
Investment<br />
Information Service<br />
Providers<br />
Investment<br />
research providers,<br />
analysts<br />
Financial Advisory<br />
Service Providers<br />
Financial advisers<br />
Investment<br />
Management<br />
Service Providers<br />
Asset managers<br />
Savers/<br />
Lenders/<br />
Providers of Capital<br />
Retail, high-networth,<br />
and<br />
institutional<br />
investors<br />
Trading Service<br />
Providers<br />
Funds<br />
Exchanges,<br />
brokers, dealers,<br />
clearing and<br />
settlement agents<br />
Custodial Service<br />
Providers<br />
Custodians<br />
Financial<br />
Markets<br />
Funds<br />
Investment Banks<br />
Spenders/<br />
Borrowers/<br />
Users of Capital<br />
Individuals,<br />
companies,<br />
governments<br />
All these players can affect trust in the investment industry through their relationships<br />
with one another and with their clients. Trust in the investment industry is only as<br />
strong as the trust in its weakest link; it is thus critical that all players act with integrity.
Investment Industry Participants 13<br />
4.2 Duty of Care<br />
As presented above, there are different types of investment professionals, such as<br />
financial advisers and asset managers, who provide advice to investors. Investment<br />
professionals are held to different duties of care to their clients. Duty of care refers to<br />
the legal obligations that investment professionals have when acting for or on behalf of<br />
their clients. The level of care depends not on the title of the investment professional<br />
but on the laws and regulations where the investment professional is based and the<br />
role the investment professional plays when advising his clients.<br />
In the United States, there are two levels of care: a high standard of care, called the<br />
fiduciary standard, and a lower standard of care, called the suitability standard. To<br />
differentiate these two levels of care, consider the example of a financial adviser who<br />
has to recommend an investment product to her client. Whether the adviser is held to<br />
a fiduciary or suitability standard, she must understand her client’s objectives in terms<br />
of risk and return and any constraints her client may have. The process of identifying<br />
an investor’s needs and constraints is described in Chapter 19. If the investment adviser<br />
is held to the fiduciary standard, she is required to recommend the best investment<br />
product. In contrast, if the investment adviser is held to the suitability standard, she<br />
has to recommend an investment product that meets her client’s objectives and constraints,<br />
but it does not have to be the best investment product. It is sufficient for the<br />
investment product to meet the client’s objectives and constraints even if there is a<br />
better alternative available. The distinction between the fiduciary and the suitability<br />
standard is particularly important if the adviser represents certain funds or products.<br />
Laws and regulations across Asia vary greatly, but in some places, such as Singapore<br />
and Hong Kong, the legal concept of fiduciary duty is based on the British legal system.<br />
Duties of care, similar to the suitability standard described earlier, are usually defined<br />
by laws and regulations that are country specific.<br />
Duty of care in the European Union is governed by the Markets in Financial Instruments<br />
Directive (MiFID). The options in the EU are either a suitability standard or an appropriateness<br />
standard. The appropriateness standard only requires investment professionals<br />
to assess a client’s level of understanding, not to review the client’s objectives<br />
and constraints. The suitability standard is the higher standard and requires the<br />
investment professional to review and consider the client’s objectives and constraints.<br />
Investors seeking advice from investment professionals should understand the laws<br />
and regulations that apply to these investment professionals and the duty of care these<br />
investment professionals hold with regard to their clients. These issues may influence<br />
investment professionals’ advice significantly. In particular, investors must assess when<br />
the interests of investment professionals may not be aligned with their own interests,<br />
which is known as a conflict of interest. For example, an investment manager might<br />
have a monetary incentive to invest a client’s money in a particular investment product<br />
or to buy and sell assets more actively than is justified for the client.
14<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
5<br />
KEY FORCES DRIVING THE INVESTMENT INDUSTRY<br />
The four key forces that drive the investment industry are competition, computerization,<br />
globalization, and regulation.<br />
Competition in the investment industry is based on innovative investment product<br />
offerings. It is also based on pricing, service, and performance.<br />
Over the years, technological advancements have allowed investment industry participants<br />
to reduce operating costs. Computerization, in particular, has dramatically<br />
decreased trade processing costs and increased trade processing capacity. It has also<br />
spurred the development and analysis of innovative types of investment products.<br />
Globalization is another force driving the investment industry. Investors look outside<br />
their domestic markets to diversify their investments and generate higher returns.<br />
Emerging markets, in particular, hold the promise for higher rates of growth. For<br />
example, China, Brazil, and India are emerging economies that are growing faster<br />
than developed economies. Furthermore, such countries as China, Saudi Arabia, and<br />
Russia, which have trade surpluses, use those surpluses to invest abroad in a variety<br />
of opportunities. These foreign investments contribute to economic development as<br />
well as to the overall profits of the investment industry.<br />
Globally, there has been a growing trend toward greater regulation of the investment<br />
industry. Regulation is needed to protect investors and safeguard their investments.<br />
By promoting disclosure and transparency, it is hoped that regulation will prevent the<br />
kinds of mistakes and frauds that have cost investors significant amounts of money over<br />
the years. International cooperation among financial regulators has played and should<br />
continue to play an important role in raising global standards of securities regulation.<br />
SUMMARY<br />
■<br />
■<br />
■<br />
■<br />
The financial services industry exists to provide a link between savers/lenders/<br />
providers of capital that have funds to invest and spenders/borrowers/users of<br />
capital that need funds.<br />
Financial intermediaries help channel financial capital efficiently between savers<br />
and spenders.<br />
The investment industry comprises all the players that are instrumental in helping<br />
savers invest their money and borrowers get the funds they require.<br />
Capitalism takes different forms, but two important characteristics are that it<br />
favors private ownership as the means of production and markets as the means<br />
of allocating resources.
Summary 15<br />
■<br />
■<br />
■<br />
■<br />
■<br />
The investment industry provides several benefits to the economy, including<br />
the efficient allocation of scarce resources, better information about investment<br />
opportunities, products and services that are appropriate for suppliers and<br />
users of capital, and liquidity.<br />
The benefits for investors of a well- functioning investment industry include a<br />
broad range of investment products and services that meet their needs, competitive<br />
markets that provide liquidity and keep transaction costs low, timely<br />
and efficient disclosure of information, and the ability to modify their risk<br />
exposures.<br />
Laws and regulations are necessary to protect clients and ensure the integrity,<br />
transparency, and fairness of financial markets.<br />
Ethical behavior is critical to protecting the reputation of and maintaining trust<br />
in the investment industry.<br />
Investment industry participants include the following:<br />
Categories Participants Key Characteristics<br />
Investors Retail investors Individual investors with the least<br />
amount of assets<br />
Financial advisory<br />
service providers<br />
Investment management<br />
service<br />
providers<br />
Investment information<br />
service providers<br />
High- net- worth<br />
investors<br />
Institutional<br />
investors<br />
Financial advisers<br />
Asset managers<br />
Data vendors<br />
Investment research<br />
providers<br />
Analysts<br />
Individual investors with a higher<br />
amount of assets<br />
Organizations that invest to advance<br />
their mission or to provide financial<br />
services to their clients<br />
Professionals that provide advice<br />
about investments and help clients<br />
understand their needs and the risks<br />
they face<br />
Professionals that manage investments<br />
on behalf of their clients<br />
Organizations that provide information<br />
resources<br />
Organizations that produce information<br />
reports<br />
Professionals who produce research<br />
reports<br />
(continued)
16<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
Categories Participants Key Characteristics<br />
Trading service<br />
providers<br />
Custodial service<br />
providers<br />
Exchanges<br />
Brokers<br />
Dealers<br />
Clearing and settlement<br />
agents<br />
Custodians<br />
Financial markets that allow investors<br />
to trade<br />
Professionals and their firms that<br />
facilitate trading between investors,<br />
acting as agents (do not trade with<br />
their clients)<br />
Professionals and their firms that<br />
facilitate trading between investors,<br />
acting as principals (trade with their<br />
clients)<br />
Organizations that confirm and settle<br />
trades<br />
Organizations that hold money and<br />
securities on behalf of their clients<br />
■<br />
■<br />
Investment professionals are held to varying standards of care based on regulatory<br />
jurisdiction and the investment professional’s role. Some are held to a high<br />
level of care (fiduciary standard), whereas others are held to a lower level of<br />
care (suitability standard or appropriateness standard).<br />
The four key forces that drive the investment industry are competition, computerization,<br />
globalization, and regulation.
Chapter Review Questions 17<br />
CHAPTER REVIEW QUESTIONS<br />
Test your knowledge of this <strong>chapter</strong> at cfainstitute.org/<strong>claritas</strong>study.<br />
1 The financial services industry benefits the economy by providing a link<br />
between providers of capital and:<br />
A<br />
savers.<br />
B lenders.<br />
C<br />
borrowers.<br />
2 The investment industry benefits the economy by:<br />
A<br />
increasing risk.<br />
B decreasing liquidity.<br />
C<br />
increasing efficiency.<br />
3 Which of the following best describes a benefit of a well- functioning investment<br />
industry from the perspective of an individual investor?<br />
A<br />
Risk transformation<br />
B Scarce resource allocation<br />
C Fewer financial intermediaries<br />
4 A major benefit of competitive markets for the individual investor is:<br />
A<br />
risk transfer.<br />
B lower prices.<br />
C<br />
greater integrity.<br />
5 Which of the following would most likely assist high- net- worth individuals in<br />
arranging their financial affairs?<br />
A<br />
Financial advisers<br />
B Investment dealers<br />
C<br />
Investment bankers<br />
Copyright © 2012 CFA Institute
18<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
6 Which of the following is least likely to facilitate trading and help reduce transaction<br />
costs?<br />
A<br />
Stock exchanges<br />
B Investment dealers<br />
C<br />
Investment analysts<br />
7 Relative to the suitability standard of care for investment professionals, the<br />
fiduciary standard of care is:<br />
A<br />
lower.<br />
B higher.<br />
C<br />
equivalent.<br />
8 Which of the following forces that drive the investment industry promotes<br />
transparency of financial markets?<br />
A<br />
Competition<br />
B Computerization<br />
C<br />
Regulation<br />
9 Globally, regulation of the investment industry has:<br />
A<br />
increased.<br />
B decreased.<br />
C<br />
remained stable.
Answers 19<br />
ANSWERS<br />
1 C is correct. The financial services industry exists to provide a link between<br />
providers of capital (also called savers, lenders, or investors) that have funds to<br />
invest and users of capital (also called spenders or borrowers) that need funds.<br />
A and B are incorrect because savers and lenders are providers, not users, of<br />
capital.<br />
2 C is correct. The investment industry helps savers invest their money and helps<br />
borrowers get the funds they require. In doing so, it reduces the resources that<br />
would be expended on the search rather than on productive uses, thus increasing<br />
efficiency. A is incorrect because the investment industry helps transform<br />
and transfer risk, not increase it. B is incorrect because the investment industry<br />
increases rather than decreases liquidity.<br />
3 A is correct. In a well- functioning investment industry, risks can be transformed<br />
and transferred. Individuals who want to reduce risk can do so—for<br />
example, by buying insurance. B is incorrect because the efficient allocation<br />
of scarce resources through a well- functioning investment industry is a primary<br />
benefit for the economy, not the individual. C is incorrect because a<br />
well- functioning investment industry is characterized by competitive markets.<br />
Competitive markets are made up of a large number of financial intermediaries<br />
(e.g., banks or insurance companies) that compete with one another.<br />
Competitive markets keep prices of investment products and services down.<br />
4 B is correct. Competitive markets promote higher production efficiency and<br />
help keep prices of investment products and services down. A is incorrect<br />
because risk transfer, although it is a benefit for the individual investor, deals<br />
with transferring risk from those that want to reduce risk to those that are willing<br />
to take on risk; risk transfer does not deal with competition. C is incorrect<br />
because greater integrity is achieved by effective laws and regulations and not<br />
through competition.<br />
5 A is correct. Financial advisers typically provide high- net- worth individuals<br />
with advice about how to manage their investments. B is incorrect because<br />
investment dealers facilitate trading between investors. C is incorrect because<br />
investment bankers help companies and governments raise funds globally.<br />
6 C is correct. Investment analysts are primarily engaged in analyzing investment<br />
opportunities and providing recommendations about the investments they<br />
follow. A is incorrect because stock exchanges facilitate trading of new and<br />
existing securities and, as such, help reduce transaction costs. B is incorrect<br />
because investment dealers facilitate trading by acting as buyers when investors<br />
want to sell and as sellers when investors want to buy. By doing so, they help<br />
reduce transaction costs.<br />
7 B is correct. Investment professionals who have a fiduciary responsibility to<br />
their clients must act in their clients’ best interests. The fiduciary standard is<br />
a higher standard of care than the suitability standard. A and C are incorrect
20<br />
Chapter 1 ■ The Investment Industry: A Top- Down View<br />
because investment professionals who have a fiduciary responsibility to their<br />
clients have a higher, not lower or equivalent, standard of care than investment<br />
professionals who must meet the suitability standard of care.<br />
8 C is correct. Regulation promotes transparency. Increased transparency is<br />
designed to prevent mistakes and fraud. A is incorrect because competition,<br />
although one of the four forces, does not promote transparency. B is incorrect<br />
because computerization, although it is one of the four forces, does not promote<br />
transparency. Regulation is the only one of the four forces that promotes<br />
transparency.<br />
9 A is correct. Globally, there has been a growing trend toward greater regulation<br />
of the investment industry. B and C are incorrect because globally, there has<br />
been a growing trend toward increased regulation of the investment industry,<br />
not a trend of decreased or stable regulation.
G-1<br />
GLOSSARY<br />
Analysts Analysts select, evaluate, and interpret information<br />
to arrive at an opinion.<br />
Asset managers<br />
See investment managers.<br />
Assets Resources that a company controls as a result of past<br />
events and that are expected to provide future economic<br />
benefits.<br />
Auditors An external auditor is an independent accountant<br />
that examines financial statements and provides a written<br />
opinion on them. An internal auditor is employed by<br />
the company and evaluates a company’s accounting and<br />
internal controls.<br />
Bond<br />
A formal contract that represents a loan from an investor<br />
(bondholder) to an issuer. The contract describes the key<br />
terms of the debt obligation such as the interest rate and<br />
the maturity.<br />
Brokers Agents who execute orders to buy or sell securities<br />
for their clients and provide trading services in exchange<br />
for a commission.<br />
Capital markets Financial markets for securities that have a<br />
maturity longer than a year.<br />
Capitalism An economic system that favors private ownership<br />
as the means of production and markets as the means of<br />
allocating scarce resources.<br />
Clearing and settlement agents Investment industry participants<br />
that confirm and settle trades after they have been<br />
arranged.<br />
Conflict of interest When either the employee’s personal interests<br />
or the employer’s interests conflict with the interests<br />
of the client (conflicts of interest can also arise when<br />
employee’s and employer’s interests conflict).<br />
Custodians Entities that hold money and securities on behalf<br />
of their customers, help arrange trade settlements, and<br />
collect interest and dividends for their customers.<br />
Dealers Financial intermediaries that allow their clients to<br />
trade when they want to trade by standing ready to buy<br />
(sell) when their clients want to sell (buy) by acting as<br />
principals in trades.<br />
Demand The desire for a good or service coupled with the ability<br />
and willingness to pay for the desired product.<br />
Duty of care The legal and professional obligations that investment<br />
professionals have when acting for or on behalf of<br />
their clients.<br />
Financial advisers Investment professionals who provide both<br />
financial planning and investment advisory services to<br />
their clients.<br />
Financial assets Claims on other assets and on future cash<br />
flows; for example, a share of common (ordinary) stock<br />
represents ownership in a company or a claim on the<br />
residual value of the company.<br />
Financial capital Funds provided to corporations and governments<br />
that allow them to purchase physical capital, to hire<br />
labor, and to acquire other inputs necessary to produce<br />
goods and services.<br />
Financial intermediaries Financial institutions—such as banks,<br />
securitizers, and insurance companies—that channel funds<br />
from savers to spenders; they transform deposits made by<br />
savers into loans to borrowers.<br />
Financial intermediation Process of collecting savings from<br />
lenders in one form, such as deposits, and transforming<br />
them into another form, such as loans, for borrowers.<br />
Financial markets Places where buyers and sellers can trade<br />
securities; also called securities markets.<br />
Fixed- income securities Loans that lenders make to borrowers;<br />
also called debt securities and bonds.<br />
High- net- worth investors Individual investors who have investable<br />
assets over a certain amount (e.g., USD1 million or<br />
CNY10 million) and who are often, but not always, more<br />
sophisticated investors.<br />
Initial public offering The first issuance of common shares to<br />
the public by a formerly private corporation.<br />
Insider trading Trading while in possession of material nonpublic<br />
information.<br />
Institutional investors Companies, trusts, and governments<br />
that invest to advance their missions or to provide financial<br />
services to their clients.<br />
Investment banks Financial intermediaries that typically<br />
provide capital raising and strategic advisory services,<br />
brokerage and dealing services, and research services to<br />
companies and governments.<br />
Investment industry All the players that are instrumental<br />
in helping savers invest their money and lenders get the<br />
funds they require.<br />
Laws Rules passed by a legislative body, such as Congress in<br />
the United States, Parliament in the United Kingdom, or<br />
the Diet in Japan.<br />
Liquidity Measure of the ease of buying or selling an asset<br />
without affecting its price.<br />
Money markets Financial markets for securities that have a<br />
maturity shorter than a year.
G-2 Glossary<br />
Mutual fund Investment company that holds portfolios of<br />
investment securities and assets.<br />
Pension funds Institutional investors who hold investment<br />
portfolios for the benefit of future and current retirees.<br />
Physical capital The means of production; tangible goods such<br />
as equipment, tools, and buildings.<br />
Primary market The market where new securities, IPOs, and<br />
subsequent offerings are issued and sold to investors.<br />
Proprietary trading When dealers trade using their own<br />
accounts and their own capital with buyers and sellers.<br />
Real assets Physical assets such as land, buildings, cattle,<br />
and gold.<br />
Regulations Rules that set standards for conduct and that<br />
carry the force of law.<br />
Retail investors Individual investors who have the least amount<br />
of investable assets and who are often, but not always, less<br />
sophisticated investors than institutional investors.<br />
Risk<br />
The effect of uncertain future events on an organization<br />
or on the outcomes the organization achieves.<br />
Secondary market Market in which traders of a security trade<br />
with each other but not with the original security issuer;<br />
market in which investors buy and sell securities with<br />
each other.<br />
Securities<br />
Financial assets that can be traded.<br />
Stock exchanges Organized and regulated financial markets<br />
that allow buyers and sellers to trade securities with each<br />
other.<br />
Stocks Ownership in a company; also called equity securities,<br />
shares of stock, or shares.<br />
Supply The quantity of a good or service sellers are willing and<br />
able to sell at a given price.<br />
Transaction costs Costs that accrue from brokerage commissions,<br />
bid–ask spreads, and market impact; the costs<br />
associated with trading.
version 1.3<br />
www.cfainstitute.org/<strong>claritas</strong><br />
The Claritas mark is registered in several countries around the world.