FACTUAL REPORT AVIATION - L-39 Enthusiasts
FACTUAL REPORT AVIATION - L-39 Enthusiasts
FACTUAL REPORT AVIATION - L-39 Enthusiasts
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Aircraft Registration Number:<br />
N6<strong>39</strong>25<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
Most Critical Injury: Fatal<br />
Investigated By: NTSB<br />
Location/Time<br />
Nearest City/Place<br />
Titusville<br />
Airport Proximity: On Airport/Airstrip<br />
Aircraft Information Summary<br />
Aircraft Manufacturer<br />
Aero Vodochody Aero. Works<br />
State Zip Code Local Time Time Zone<br />
FL 32780 1443<br />
EDT<br />
Distance From Landing Facility: 0<br />
Model/Series<br />
L-<strong>39</strong>C<br />
Type of Aircraft<br />
Airplane<br />
Revenue Sightseeing Flight: No<br />
Air Medical Transport Flight:<br />
Narrative<br />
Brief narrative statement of facts, conditions and circumstances pertinent to the accident/incident:<br />
HISTORY OF FLIGHT<br />
No<br />
On March 16, 2007, about 1443 eastern daylight time, an Aero Vodochody L-<strong>39</strong>C Albatros, N6<strong>39</strong>25,<br />
registered to and operated by Best Jet Services LC, crashed while performing at the TICO Warbird<br />
Airshow, Space Coast Regional Airport (KTIX), Titusville, Florida. Visual meteorological conditions<br />
prevailed, and no flight plan was filed. The airline transport-rated pilot, the sole occupant of<br />
the airplane received fatal injuries, and the airplane was destroyed. The flight originated in<br />
Titusville, the same day, about 1430.<br />
A witness stated that while the pilot of the accident airplane was performing his solo routine at<br />
the airshow, the airplane ascended and penetrated a scattered cloud layer at the top of a loop. The<br />
airplane then came back into view out of the loop, and continued to roll right while descending in<br />
a steep nose-low attitude, at a high speed. The witness further stated that during the loop the<br />
angle of descent became progressively shallow as the airplane neared the ground, as if the pilot<br />
was attempting to pull out of the dive at too low an altitude. The airplane impacted the terrain<br />
just north of the tree-line along runway 09-27.<br />
During the course of the accident airplane’s maneuvers, several members of public audience made<br />
video recordings of the accident flight immediately prior to, and during the impact. The video was<br />
examined, and it showed the airplane had reached the top of a Cuban eight maneuver, inverted in a<br />
cloud, and then descended inverted out of the cloud in a nose low attitude. The airplane then<br />
rolled to the right, and while still nose low and pointed towards the crowd, continued the roll to<br />
the right to a more westerly heading. The aircraft continued its descent to a slight nose low, left<br />
wing slightly low, near level upright attitude, impacting the terrain.<br />
PERSONNEL INFORMATION<br />
The 58 year old pilot possessed an FAA airline transport pilot certificate with airplane single and<br />
multiengine land ratings, issued in February 12, 2007. He also possessed type ratings in the<br />
BE-400, CE-500, CE-525, CE-525S, and MU-300, and had been granted authorization to operate<br />
experimental aircraft, specifically the AV-L<strong>39</strong>, with a level 4 limitation of 800 feet.<br />
He had completed a flight review on February 12, 2007, and stated that he held a letter of<br />
authorization for surplus military turbine powered aircraft. He also stated to the FAA inspector<br />
supervising the airshow, that he possessed a statement of aerobatic competency, and a low altitude<br />
waiver.<br />
The pilot also held an FAA first class medical certificate dated Nov 28, 2006, with the stated<br />
limitation that he must wear corrective lenses. According to the information the pilot provided at<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
Page 1
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
Narrative<br />
(Continued)<br />
his last medical examination, the accident pilot indicated that he had accumulated a total in<br />
excess of 6,000 hours of flight experience, with over 100 hours having been accumulated within the<br />
last 6 months.<br />
AIRCRAFT INFORMATION<br />
The accident airplane, an Aero Vodochody, L-<strong>39</strong>C, Albatross, serial number 031803, was manufactured<br />
by Aero Vodochody of the Czech Republic in 1980. According to the airplane’s flight manual it was<br />
designed as a basic, and advanced trainer, as well as for use in light attack missions, when so<br />
configured. The airplane was powered by an Ivchenko AI-25TL, turbofan engine, rated at 3,800 lbs<br />
trust. The airplane is certificated in the experimental class, and in the exhibition category, and<br />
was equipped with twin tandem ejection seats.<br />
The airplane was registered to Best Jet Services LLC., of Gainesville, Florida, with the<br />
certificate being issued on March 14, 2006. It was also marketed for airshow purposes by the pilot,<br />
and was equipped for flight in day visual flight rules conditions. On the day of the accident the<br />
airplane had been given a ramp check, and the results of the ramp check were recorded on an Airshow<br />
Technical Inspection Form, in which no discrepancies were noted with either the accident airplane<br />
or the pilot.<br />
METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATION<br />
Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time of the accident. The Spacecoast Regional<br />
Airport (TIX) 1842Z (1442EDT), surface weather observation was: winds from 260 at 24 knots,<br />
visibility 7 statute miles, cloud coverage 3,000 feet scattered 10,000 broken, temperature 74<br />
degrees F, altimeter 29.81 inHG.<br />
WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION<br />
Postcrash examination of the accident site revealed information consistent with the airplane having<br />
impacted the terrain at high velocity, and in a relative flat attitude. The debris field consisted<br />
of an area of about 368 feet long, oriented east to west, and about 184 feet wide. The east end of<br />
the impact area began at a geographic position of 28 degrees 30.987 minutes North latitude, and 080<br />
degrees, 48.216 minutes West longitude.<br />
The accident site consisted of wooded soft muddy level terrain. The vegetation at the site<br />
consisted of a mixture of palm trees, willow trees, maple trees, live oak trees, palmettos, ferns<br />
and other scrub vegetation, which varied in height from knee-level to about 60 feet, and varied in<br />
density from being relatively open to being dense and overgrown.<br />
The impact crater and debris field were located at the eastern end, and were aligned east-to-west<br />
approximately 800 feet north of the centerline of runway 09 - 27, approximately 150 yards in length<br />
on an approximate magnetic direction of 270 degrees. The impact crater had an elliptical shape and<br />
was about 4 feet deep, about 60 feet wide at its widest point, and about 100 feet long. There was a<br />
mixture of aircraft debris and liquid which appeared consistent with that of a mixture that<br />
included water, fuel and oil deposited in the crater.<br />
On the south side of the crater, a major portion of the left wing was found. Several large palm<br />
trunks had been uprooted and lay in a westerly direction consistent with witness accounts of the<br />
last observed heading within the FAA approved airshow box. The debris field down stream of the<br />
impact crater was generally a conical propagation pattern. To the immediate south of the debris<br />
field the area was densely wooded and less debris was noted.<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
Page 1a
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
Narrative<br />
(Continued)<br />
The aircraft was destroyed by impact forces, impact related explosions, and the postcrash fire.<br />
Sections of the aircraft wreckage were generally distributed with the heavier sections propagating<br />
generally to the west along the centerline of the airshow box. The largest portions, including the<br />
empennage, engine core, burned out cockpit, and sections of airframe were distributed along a<br />
narrow westerly path from the crater and comprised about three quarters of the length of the debris<br />
field. Smaller pieces of aircraft structural debris as well as well as airshow related marketing<br />
literature were observed throughout the debris field, but they were not distributed in any distinct<br />
pattern.<br />
All aircraft gages had been destroyed by impact forces and/or the postcrash fire and the few gauges<br />
that were discernable among the debris were unreadable and/or unreliable. Recovered gauges included<br />
an altimeter which read 1,900 feet, and its Kollsman window which read 29.69 inHg; a combination<br />
instrument to measure the turn rate and coordination, angle of bank, and vertical speed was also<br />
found. The instrument showed about 10 degrees left wing down, with no other indications directly<br />
discernible. An airspeed indicator was found and it showed "300" but no units were shown. An<br />
instrument was located with a reading of 7 and a quarter, and it exhibited markings consistent with<br />
an aircraft accelerometer. There was also an instrument with dual needles labeled 1 and 2, and<br />
gauge face markings from 0 to 100 percent posessing markings consistent with those of a tachometer.<br />
There was also the gage face plate with symmetrical left and right scales consistent with the wheel<br />
brake pressure indicator.<br />
On October 17, 2007, the NTSB examined the engine and noted evidence consistent with all engine<br />
damage being related to the impact. There was ingestion of dirt shrubs, grass and other impact<br />
related debris, and the rotational damage noted was in the direction opposite of rotation. Dirt,<br />
leaves, and shrubs were found downstream in the engine, consistent with power being produced at<br />
impact.<br />
During the course of the on-scene examination, burnt and fragmented sections of the airplane’s two<br />
ejection seats and cockpit canopy were among the debris, and they exhibited characteristics<br />
consistent with the presence of explosive charges. As a result, the NTSB halted the investigation,<br />
and requested assistance from members of the Titusville Police Bomb Disposal Unit. The Titusville<br />
Police Department consulted with Patrick Air Force Base’s Explosive Ordinance Disposal (EOD) team,<br />
who confirmed that the seats and canopy were armed with explosive devices. EOD personnel removed<br />
the explosive devices from the accident scene, and neutralized the explosive charges.<br />
MEDICAL AND PATHOLOGICAL INFORMATION<br />
Post mortem examination of the pilot was performed by a pathologist with the District 18 Medical<br />
Examiner’s Office, Rockledge, Florida. The cause of death was attributed to be due to massive<br />
multiple blunt force injuries. No findings, which could be considered causal, were reported.<br />
The FAA Toxicology Laboratory, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, conducted toxicology studies on specimens<br />
from the pilot. The specimens were tested for ethanol and drugs, and none were found to be present.<br />
TESTS AND RESEARCH<br />
The NTSB received two digital video files on a CD media. The video had been filmed by spectators at<br />
the airshow using hand held video cameras, and they captured the accident sequence. Both videos<br />
followed the accident airplane while it was maneuvering prior to and during the accident. See the<br />
NTSB Video Recording Factual Report.<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
Page 1b
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
Narrative<br />
(Continued)<br />
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION<br />
On March 19, 2007, the NTSB released the airplane wreckage to Mr. David Gourgues, Regional Manager,<br />
CTC Services Aviation (LAD) Inc.<br />
Updated on Nov 17 2010 1:56PM<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
Page 1c
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
Landing Facility/Approach Information<br />
Airport Name<br />
Airport ID:<br />
Airport Elevation<br />
Runway Used Runway Length Runway Width<br />
Space Coast Regional Airport<br />
KTIX<br />
Ft. MSL<br />
09<br />
5000<br />
100<br />
Runway Surface Type: Asphalt<br />
Runway Surface Condition: Dry<br />
Approach/Arrival Flown:<br />
NONE<br />
VFR Approach/Landing:<br />
None<br />
Aircraft Information<br />
Aircraft Manufacturer<br />
Aero Vodochody Aero. Works<br />
Model/Series<br />
L-<strong>39</strong>C<br />
Serial Number<br />
031803<br />
Airworthiness Certificate(s):<br />
Experimental (Special); Acrobatic<br />
Landing Gear Type: Retractable - Tricycle<br />
Amateur Built Acft? No<br />
Number of Seats: 2<br />
Engine Type:<br />
Turbo Jet<br />
- Aircraft Inspection Information<br />
Type of Last Inspection<br />
- Emergency Locator Transmitter (ELT) Information<br />
Certified Max Gross Wt.<br />
Engine Manufacturer:<br />
Ivchenko<br />
Date of Last Inspection<br />
10360 LBS Number of Engines: 1<br />
Model/Series:<br />
Rated Power:<br />
AI-25TL<br />
3800 LBS<br />
Time Since Last Inspection Airframe Total Time<br />
Hours<br />
488 Hours<br />
ELT Installed?/Type No<br />
Owner/Operator Information<br />
Registered Aircraft Owner<br />
Best Jet Services LLC<br />
Operator of Aircraft<br />
Best Jet Services LLC<br />
Operator Does Business As:<br />
- Type of U.S. Certificate(s) Held: None<br />
Air Carrier Operating Certificate(s):<br />
No<br />
ELT Aided in Locating Accident Site? No<br />
Street Address<br />
824 University Avenue<br />
City<br />
State<br />
Gainesville<br />
FL<br />
Street Address<br />
824 University Avenue<br />
City<br />
State<br />
Gainesville<br />
FL<br />
Operator Designator Code:<br />
Zip Code<br />
32601<br />
Zip Code<br />
32601<br />
Operating Certificate:<br />
Regulation Flight Conducted Under: Part 91: General Aviation<br />
Type of Flight Operation Conducted: Air Race/Show<br />
Operator Certificate:<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong> Page 2
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
First Pilot Information<br />
Name<br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
City<br />
State Date of Birth Age<br />
On File<br />
On File<br />
On File<br />
On File<br />
58<br />
Sex: M<br />
Seat Occupied: Front<br />
Occupational Pilot?<br />
No<br />
Certificate Number: On File<br />
Certificate(s):<br />
Airline Transport<br />
Airplane Rating(s):<br />
Multi-engine Land; Single-engine Land<br />
Rotorcraft/Glider/LTA:<br />
Instrument Rating(s):<br />
Instructor Rating(s):<br />
Airplane<br />
Airplane Single-engine<br />
Current Biennial Flight Review?<br />
Medical Cert.: Class 1<br />
02/2007<br />
Medical Cert. Status: With Waivers/Limitations<br />
Date of Last Medical Exam: 11/2006<br />
- Flight Time Matrix<br />
All A/C<br />
This Make<br />
and Model<br />
Airplane<br />
Single Engine<br />
Airplane<br />
Mult-Engine<br />
Night<br />
Actual<br />
Instrument<br />
Simulated<br />
Rotorcraft<br />
Glider<br />
Lighter<br />
Than Air<br />
Total Time<br />
6000<br />
Pilot In Command(PIC)<br />
Instructor<br />
Instruction Received<br />
Last 90 Days<br />
Last 30 Days<br />
Yes<br />
Yes<br />
Yes<br />
No<br />
Flight Plan/Itinerary<br />
Type of Flight Plan Filed: None<br />
Departure Point<br />
State<br />
Airport Identifier<br />
Departure Time<br />
Time Zone<br />
Same as Accident/Incident Location<br />
TIX<br />
1430<br />
EDT<br />
Destination<br />
State<br />
Airport Identifier<br />
Local Flight<br />
TIX<br />
Type of Clearance:<br />
None<br />
Type of Airspace:<br />
Weather Information<br />
Source of Wx Information:<br />
Unknown<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong> Page 3
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
Weather Information<br />
WOF ID<br />
Observation Time<br />
Time Zone<br />
WOF Elevation<br />
WOF Distance From Accident Site<br />
Direction From Accident Site<br />
TIX<br />
1450<br />
EDT<br />
34 Ft. MSL<br />
NM<br />
Deg. Mag.<br />
Sky/Lowest Cloud Condition: Scattered<br />
3000 Ft. AGL<br />
Condition of Light: Day<br />
Lowest Ceiling: Broken<br />
10000 Ft. AGL<br />
Visibility:<br />
7<br />
SM<br />
Altimeter:<br />
29.81<br />
"Hg<br />
Temperature:<br />
24 ° C Dew Point:<br />
°C<br />
Weather Conditions at Accident Site: Visual Conditions<br />
Wind Direction: 260<br />
Wind Speed: 24<br />
Wind Gusts:<br />
Visibility (RVR):<br />
Ft.<br />
Visibility (RVV)<br />
SM<br />
Precip and/or Obscuration:<br />
Accident Information<br />
Aircraft Damage: Destroyed<br />
Aircraft Fire: Ground<br />
Aircraft Explosion<br />
Ground<br />
- Injury Summary Matrix<br />
Fatal Serious Minor None TOTAL<br />
First Pilot<br />
Second Pilot<br />
Student Pilot<br />
Flight Instructor<br />
Check Pilot<br />
Flight Engineer<br />
Cabin Attendants<br />
Other Crew<br />
Passengers<br />
- TOTAL ABOARD -<br />
Other Ground<br />
- GRAND TOTAL -<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong> Page 4
This space for binding<br />
National Transportation Safety Board<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong><br />
<strong>AVIATION</strong><br />
NTSB ID: MIA07FA060<br />
Occurrence Date: 03/16/2007<br />
Occurrence Type: Accident<br />
Administrative Information<br />
Investigator-In-Charge (IIC)<br />
John W. Lovell<br />
Additional Persons Participating in This Accident/Incident Investigation:<br />
Robert Jex<br />
FAA FSDO<br />
Orlando, FL<br />
<strong>FACTUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> - <strong>AVIATION</strong> Page 5