23.10.2014 Views

A: Marie - Licensing Executives Society USA and Canada

A: Marie - Licensing Executives Society USA and Canada

A: Marie - Licensing Executives Society USA and Canada

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

The Newsletter of the <strong>Licensing</strong> <strong>Executives</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

Viewpoints<br />

(U.S.A. <strong>and</strong> <strong>Canada</strong>), Inc.<br />

Vol. XIX No. 4 November 2012<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) President Tanya Moore<br />

Shining The Light On Our Dedicated Team<br />

Tanya Moore began her term as LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) President by thanking all in attendance<br />

at the 2012 LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) Annual Meeting in Toronto. Her remarks,<br />

which are stated below, included gratitude to those members retiring from the Board of<br />

Trustees <strong>and</strong> the LES administrative staff.<br />

I<br />

look forward to the<br />

next year as President<br />

of your <strong>Society</strong>.<br />

It is a tremendous<br />

opportunity to contribute<br />

to our profession.<br />

I'd like to start by<br />

Tanya Moore<br />

thanking the outgoing<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) President Trustees. You've been<br />

seeing their names <strong>and</strong><br />

photos on the screen. What you may not know is how dedicated<br />

these folks are to LES. Let me give you a couple of<br />

examples.<br />

Gary Nath joined LES in 1982. He started the Sponsorship<br />

program, through which we now raise half a million<br />

dollars a year to help offset our costs. Over the years, Gary's<br />

firm alone has contributed over a million dollars to LES.<br />

Just think about it … over a million. Another trustee is Phil<br />

Barnett. Phil has been our VP of Education for many years.<br />

He has had a profound impact on our Education curriculum<br />

<strong>and</strong> CLP program. Phil has talked about <strong>and</strong> dreamt of a<br />

knowledge management system for a long time, <strong>and</strong> we are<br />

finally in a position to make his dream a reality. You will be<br />

seeing the fruits of that dream starting next year.<br />

In addition to our tireless volunteers exemplified by these<br />

individuals, I want to thank our executive director Ken<br />

Schoppmann <strong>and</strong> our fabulous staff. These are folks with<br />

many years of experience in running all aspects of our <strong>and</strong><br />

other like organizations. Without them, none of this would<br />

be possible. I look forward to working with each person on<br />

our staff closely throughout next year.<br />

My personal LES story is not unlike many of you here<br />

today. I joined LES in 1998, a year after joining the Corporate<br />

IP <strong>Licensing</strong> group at IBM. After many years in<br />

software development <strong>and</strong> OEM Sales, IP <strong>Licensing</strong> was<br />

new to me, <strong>and</strong> I started looking for some form of ongoing<br />

education, particularly for an organization focused<br />

on business professionals. I found that most of my IBM<br />

colleagues at the time were members of LES. At first, I<br />

attended some meetings, read the materials <strong>and</strong> talked<br />

with peers. I later got sucked into the volunteer vortex,<br />

first through the service on the LES Foundation <strong>and</strong> later<br />

on the LES Board. As one of my LES colleagues recently<br />

said: people join LES for the education, but they stay for<br />

the networking <strong>and</strong> connections. And this is truer today<br />

than it's ever been.<br />

And now let me say a few words about 2013. The theme for<br />

next year is “Intellectual Property Matters in Every Deal.”<br />

We will focus on all forms of IP in our meetings <strong>and</strong> make<br />

sure that all members from every industry find something<br />

of interest to listen to <strong>and</strong> to discuss. We will have three<br />

meetings next year: our IP100 Executive Forum in February<br />

in sunny Phoenix, followed by a general Spring Meeting<br />

in May in Seattle for the first time ever since 1965 <strong>and</strong> the<br />

Annual Meeting in Philadelphia in late September. We will<br />

work to enhance your online <strong>and</strong> face-to-face experiences,<br />

infuse more international flavor <strong>and</strong> focus on exciting topics<br />

to spark conversations.<br />

I look forward to contributing to LES in 2013 <strong>and</strong> look<br />

forward to seeing many of you at one of the meetings <strong>and</strong><br />

in my hometown in the Spring.<br />

Thank you.<br />

What did you miss at<br />

the Annual Meeting?<br />

Pages 8 & 9<br />

Exciting Deals of Distinction,<br />

See Award Winners,<br />

Pages 4-5, 7<br />

Crowdsourcing anyone?<br />

Session breaks new ground,<br />

Page 11<br />

Royalty Rates Revealed:<br />

Workshops help with trends<br />

in all sectors, Page 3


Viewpoints<br />

Officers<br />

President: Tanya Moore<br />

President-Elect: Russell Levine<br />

Past-President: Thomas Filarski<br />

Secretary: Paul A. Roberts<br />

Treasurer: Bob Goldman<br />

Vice-Presidents:<br />

Brian O’Shaughnessy - Regional, <strong>USA</strong><br />

Peter M. Ross - Regional, <strong>Canada</strong><br />

Art Rose - International<br />

Bill Elkington - Membership<br />

Jeff Whittle - Education<br />

Pamela Demain - Communications<br />

Caroline Rockafellow - Local Chapters<br />

Stasia Ogden - Meeting Programming<br />

Trustees:<br />

Kevin Arst<br />

Rich Baker<br />

Ned Barlas<br />

Cheryl Cejka<br />

Linda Chao<br />

Don Drinkwater<br />

Gary Fedorochko<br />

Bob Held<br />

Panagiota "Betty" Koutsigiannis<br />

Cat Oyler<br />

Hilton Sue<br />

Jack Tupman<br />

Counsel: John Paul<br />

Membership inquiries <strong>and</strong> contact<br />

changes should be sent to:<br />

E-mail: info@les.org<br />

Web site: www.lesusacanada.org<br />

Editorial inquiries <strong>and</strong> contributions<br />

should be addressed to:<br />

LES VIEWPOINTS<br />

25125 Detroit Road, #110<br />

Westlake, OH 44145-2500<br />

TEL: 440-871-0571<br />

FAX: 440-871-5218<br />

E-mail: carla@designinterface.com<br />

Editor: Carla J. Blackman<br />

Writers: Linda Corcoran, Lydia Steck<br />

The quarterly newsletter is published by<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) <strong>and</strong> is mailed to all<br />

<strong>Society</strong> members. Views expressed in articles<br />

are solely those of the respective authors.<br />

Article deadlines for LES Viewpoints:<br />

February 2013: Deadline-Dec. 21, 2012<br />

April 2013: Deadline-Feb. 16, 2013<br />

August 2013: Deadline-July 20, 2013<br />

November 2013: Deadline-Oct. 24, 2013<br />

Copyright © 2012<br />

<strong>Licensing</strong> <strong>Executives</strong> <strong>Society</strong> (U.S.A. <strong>and</strong> <strong>Canada</strong>), Inc.<br />

Pamela Demain Receives<br />

2012 Frank Barnes Mentor Award<br />

By Lydia Steck<br />

Merck Executive Director for Corporate<br />

<strong>Licensing</strong>, Pamela Demain, was honored<br />

with the Frank Barnes Mentor Award during<br />

the LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) 2012 Annual Meeting<br />

in Toronto.<br />

Now in its 12th year, the Frank Barnes Mentor<br />

Award recognizes individuals who have made significant<br />

contributions to the field of licensing through<br />

professional mentorship.<br />

“Pam was nominated by four LES veterans—two<br />

former Barnes Mentor Award winners <strong>and</strong> two former<br />

LES Presidents—who have watched her in action,<br />

mentoring LES members <strong>and</strong> assuming important<br />

leadership roles in the <strong>Society</strong>, all while working as a<br />

key executive at Merck. Quite a balancing act,” said<br />

Bill Mattson, Chair of the Frank Barnes Award Nominating<br />

Committee. “Pam joins a long <strong>and</strong> distinguished<br />

line of winners who, like Frank Barnes himself, have<br />

generously shared their time <strong>and</strong> talents to support their<br />

colleagues <strong>and</strong> to help advance the mission of LES.”<br />

Joe Dillon presents Pamela Demain<br />

with the Frank Barnes Mentor Award<br />

at the Annual Meeting in Toronto.<br />

Over the years, Ms. Demain has mentored countless LES <strong>and</strong> other colleagues both formally<br />

<strong>and</strong> informally. “I believe that mentoring is an important way to give back to LES for all that<br />

it has given me,” she said.<br />

In addition to her contributions of mentorship, Ms. Demain has also served LES as Regional<br />

Vice President, U.S.A, <strong>and</strong> several years as Vice President for Communications, where she has<br />

overseen a major refocusing <strong>and</strong> tailoring of LES messages <strong>and</strong> br<strong>and</strong>ing, the launch of the<br />

LES Insights weekly e-newsletter, <strong>and</strong> the creation of the first LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) Editorial<br />

Board. She has also been responsible for the development of the first LES Policy Manual. In<br />

addition, she was 2011 Annual Meeting Plenary Chair <strong>and</strong> as Trustee for Partnering in 2006-<br />

2007, she spearheaded the Power Networking initiative. She has been a member of the Health<br />

Care Committee since 2003, involved in planning for the Health Care Sector at LES (<strong>USA</strong> &<br />

<strong>Canada</strong>) meetings <strong>and</strong> in Viewpoints, <strong>and</strong> has worked on a number of strategic initiatives with<br />

the Membership <strong>and</strong> Sponsorship teams. She has been an active LES speaker <strong>and</strong> attendee at<br />

seasonal, annual <strong>and</strong> New Jersey Chapter meetings for many years.<br />

As Executive Director for Corporate <strong>Licensing</strong> at Merck, she is responsible for negotiating<br />

transactions with companies, universities <strong>and</strong> institutions worldwide. She also heads up relationship<br />

development for licensing. During her more than 30-year career with the company, she<br />

has also worked in Merck’s Global Marketing Division with positions ranging from leading<br />

the Business Information & Research Group to Product Management <strong>and</strong> Marketing Communications.<br />

Her pharmaceutical career began in the laboratories of Gruppo Lepetit, an Italian<br />

pharmaceutical company, which was then a subsidiary of Dow Chemical Company.<br />

Ms. Demain is a graduate of the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, holds an MBA<br />

in international business from American University in Washington, D.C. <strong>and</strong> is a Certified<br />

<strong>Licensing</strong> Professional (CLP).<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) Annual Report 2012<br />

Look for the 2012 LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) Annual Report on the Web<br />

site by going to www.lesusacanada.org.<br />

The document includes reports from the President, President-Elect,<br />

Vice-Presidents of Communications, Education, Member Interests,<br />

Membership, International, <strong>and</strong> the LES Foundation.<br />

As always, the report includes the financial state of the <strong>Society</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />

biographical sketches of the Board of Trustees.<br />

Printed versions are available by request from the LES (<strong>USA</strong> &<br />

<strong>Canada</strong>) office.<br />

2 LES Viewpoints


Royalty Rates Revealed In Annual Meeting Workshops<br />

Global<br />

Life Sciences<br />

Royalty Rates<br />

And Deal Terms<br />

By Lydia Steck<br />

A<br />

panel of members<br />

released its highlyanticipated<br />

2012 Global<br />

BioPharma Royalty Rates <strong>and</strong><br />

Deal Terms Survey during a session<br />

at its Annual Meeting.<br />

The new survey builds on<br />

the highly successful surveys<br />

in 2008 <strong>and</strong> 2010 <strong>and</strong> was<br />

conducted globally by the LES<br />

(<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) Life Sciences/<br />

Health Care Sector in coordination<br />

with the LES International<br />

Life Sciences Sector. It targeted<br />

LES <strong>and</strong> LESI members in the<br />

biotechnology <strong>and</strong> pharmaceutical<br />

industries, with international<br />

participants representing 17<br />

LESI national societies around<br />

the world.<br />

The final Survey Report, to<br />

be released in November, will<br />

provide exclusive industry-specific<br />

data <strong>and</strong> detailed analysis<br />

of fixed royalties, tiered royalties,<br />

deal terms <strong>and</strong> valuation<br />

methods. A robust data set drawing<br />

from this <strong>and</strong> the previous<br />

surveys provides the opportunity<br />

to individually review deals for<br />

therapeutics, diagnostics, <strong>and</strong> delivery<br />

innovations. This is highly<br />

valuable information for those<br />

looking for a better underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />

of the market <strong>and</strong> to enhance<br />

their own deal strategies <strong>and</strong><br />

negotiations.<br />

“This new survey represents<br />

an important expansion of the<br />

data set we began with the<br />

2008 <strong>and</strong> 2010 surveys,” said<br />

Ben Bonifant, Chair of the LES<br />

Global BioPharma Royalty Rates<br />

<strong>and</strong> Deal Terms Survey. “We<br />

now have enough information to<br />

look at deal trends over time <strong>and</strong><br />

to explore important factors affecting<br />

deals for diagnostic <strong>and</strong><br />

delivery innovations.”<br />

See Rates, continued on Page 12<br />

Workshop panelists: Robert Held (left),<br />

Ben Bonifant, Jiaqing Lu <strong>and</strong> Hal Craig.<br />

Comparison Of Royalty Rates, Deal Terms, And Best Practices<br />

Across The CEEM, High Tech And Life Sciences Sectors<br />

By Hal Craig<br />

Drawing on their collective experience <strong>and</strong> data from LES' Royalty Rate & Deal Terms surveys,<br />

the panelists compared <strong>and</strong> contrasted licensing across the three sectors <strong>and</strong> explained differences<br />

<strong>and</strong> similarities based on the underlying dynamics of each sector <strong>and</strong> its component industries. This<br />

workshop provided an underst<strong>and</strong>ing of the underlying sector value drivers <strong>and</strong> their potential impact<br />

on licensing transactions.<br />

The panel examined the ideas of "convergence,” a subject of increasing importance as intellectual<br />

property developed for one industry or application finds uses outside its originally intended area. One<br />

of the challenges of convergence is that companies approach licensing <strong>and</strong> perceive the value of IP<br />

based on the underlying dynamics of their own industry <strong>and</strong> their perception of less familiar industries.<br />

Interpreting Royalty Rate And <strong>Licensing</strong> Trends To Protect Your Position<br />

By David Jarczyk<br />

Session attendees learned<br />

about licensing trends<br />

from the past 10 years for<br />

the pharmaceuticals, software,<br />

consumer products, telecommunications,<br />

<strong>and</strong> chemicals<br />

industries with the goal of<br />

interpreting past trends for future<br />

advantage. The researchers<br />

analyzed data from over<br />

4,000 licenses obtained from<br />

complete agreements filed in<br />

the public domain, <strong>and</strong> presented<br />

the following key takeaways:<br />

In the pharmaceutical industry<br />

there is a trend to licenseout<br />

manufacturing intangibles.<br />

IP owners often provide exclusive<br />

rights, but generally grant<br />

the licensee non-exclusive<br />

rights in non-primary fields.<br />

Most agreements favor net<br />

sales as a royalty base <strong>and</strong> incorporate<br />

milestone payments<br />

with well-defined triggers.<br />

In software, over 90% of<br />

agreements involved commercial<br />

licensors. In this industry, the<br />

context of the software license<br />

drives the deal terms. For example,<br />

software licenses in the<br />

telecom industry generally have<br />

higher royalties than those in the<br />

chemicals industry.<br />

In consumer products, licenses<br />

combining manufacturing <strong>and</strong><br />

marketing intangibles had the<br />

highest royalty rates, exclusive<br />

rates were significantly higher<br />

than non-exclusive. Analysis<br />

shows that royalty rate increases<br />

faster as patent count increases<br />

from a smaller base; <strong>and</strong> that<br />

portfolio licensing is an effective<br />

way to reduce royalty stacking.<br />

In telecommunications, there<br />

is a trend to license manufacturing<br />

intangibles <strong>and</strong> offer minimal<br />

rights to sublicense perhaps to<br />

protect against infringement or<br />

unintended sharing of secrets.<br />

There is a propensity to limit<br />

exclusivity to certain markets,<br />

while allowing non-exclusive<br />

rights in other fields. There is a<br />

preference for royalties based<br />

on net sales.<br />

In the chemicals industry,<br />

industry consolidation <strong>and</strong> low<br />

production costs will likely lead<br />

to lower than average royalty<br />

rates in the future. Additionally,<br />

licensed know-how bundled with<br />

marketing intangibles tends to<br />

garner the highest royalty rate.<br />

Viewpoints<br />

Future issues of Viewpoints will<br />

be sent to members via an<br />

e-mail link starting in 2013. It<br />

will be in full color <strong>and</strong> open in<br />

a page-turning software. This<br />

will be the last printed copy<br />

delivered by US Mail.<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) wishes<br />

everyone Happy Holidays!<br />

November 2012 3


Sector Spotlight<br />

2012<br />

Deals of<br />

Distinction<br />

Awards<br />

High Technology Sector Winner<br />

AOL, Microsoft & Facebook<br />

The 2012 Deal of Distinction Award for the High Technology<br />

Sector was presented to three of the world’s technology<br />

titans—AOL, Microsoft <strong>and</strong> Facebook—for a<br />

groundbreaking deal that encompassed a complex series of patent<br />

transactions.<br />

On April 9th, AOL (AOL) sold over 800 of its patents <strong>and</strong> their<br />

related patent applications to Microsoft (MSFT) <strong>and</strong> granted<br />

them a non-exclusive license to its retained patent portfolio in<br />

a $1.056 billion cash deal. Soon after, on April 23rd, Facebook<br />

announced it would buy 650 of these patents from Microsoft for<br />

$550 million, leaving the company with 275 of the originally<br />

purchased AOL patents.<br />

The deal is highly advantageous for all involved, but for different<br />

reasons. The transaction allowed AOL to unlock significant<br />

value for its shareholders enabling the company to continue to aggressively<br />

execute on its strategy to create long-term shareholder<br />

value, while maintaining a valuable patent portfolio. Microsoft<br />

<strong>and</strong> Facebook, meanwhile, received some of the world's earliest<br />

web-related patents—providing important legal protection <strong>and</strong><br />

ensuring that those patents did not fall into unfriendly h<strong>and</strong>s. The<br />

acquisition also allowed Facebook to significantly bolster its patent<br />

portfolio at an important time in the company’s development.<br />

“This is a great example of an IP license transaction akin to<br />

some legendary chess moves,” said Bob Held, 2012 High Tech<br />

Sector Deals of Distinction Coordinator. “The strategic benefits<br />

to all three parties far exceeded the monetary component.” ■<br />

By Lydia Steck<br />

A<br />

gigantic patent deal by AOL, Microsoft <strong>and</strong> Facebook was one<br />

of five extraordinary intellectual property licensing deals that<br />

received LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) 2012 Deals of Distinction<br />

Awards during the <strong>Society</strong>'s Annual Meeting.<br />

Now in their 8th year, the awards are presented annually to companies<br />

that orchestrate the most outst<strong>and</strong>ing IP-based licensing <strong>and</strong> business<br />

deals in five industry sectors including: High Technology; Chemicals/<br />

Energy/Environment <strong>and</strong> Materials; Industry-University-Government<br />

Interface; Life Sciences; <strong>and</strong> Consumer Products. Here are details on the<br />

winning deals.<br />

Consumer Products Sector Winner<br />

McNeil-PPC Inc. & Insight<br />

Pharmaceuticals LLC<br />

The Consumer Products Sector presented its 2012 Deals<br />

of Distinction Award to McNeil-PPC Inc. <strong>and</strong> Insight<br />

Pharmaceutical for their asset purchase agreement <strong>and</strong><br />

associated licensing.<br />

In August 2011, Insight Pharmaceuticals, a portfolio company<br />

of Sw<strong>and</strong>er Pace Capital, acquired the MONISTAT ®<br />

North American br<strong>and</strong> portfolio from McNEIL-PCC, Inc.<br />

MONISTAT ® , the leading br<strong>and</strong> in the vaginal antifungal<br />

category, joined Insight Pharmaceuticals’ family of over-thecounter<br />

(OTC) women's health <strong>and</strong> personal care products,<br />

including br<strong>and</strong>s such as e.p.t ® , Nix ® , Bonnie ® , <strong>and</strong> Sucrets ® .<br />

The MONISTAT br<strong>and</strong> was the first prescription product<br />

launched in the vaginal antifungal class in 1974 <strong>and</strong> established<br />

a category, switching to OTC status in 1991. The acquisition<br />

signals Insight’s increased dedication to the category<br />

of women’s health.<br />

Also, in connection with the transaction, Ontario Teachers’<br />

Pension Plan, through its private equity group, Teachers’<br />

Private Capital, has joined Sw<strong>and</strong>er Pace Capital as an equity<br />

investor in Insight Pharmaceuticals.<br />

“We felt this deal was exceptional because it was transformational<br />

for Insight given its size,” said Consumer Product<br />

Sector Deals of Distinction Chair Susan B. Levy. “This was<br />

a multifaceted transaction that included intricate trademark,<br />

patent <strong>and</strong> know-how licensing, as well as regulatory <strong>and</strong><br />

financing complexities.” ■<br />

Bob Held (left), Rich Baker, Annemarie Meike, Tanya Moore of<br />

the LES High Tech Sector present award to Julie Jacobs, Sarah<br />

Harris, Brian Malm <strong>and</strong> Matt Garber of AOL.<br />

Jim Berwick (left), Insight Pharmaceuticals, <strong>and</strong> Carlos Forer, Johnson<br />

& Johnson (second from right) accept award from LES Consumer<br />

Products Sector, Susan Levy (left), Robin Sitver <strong>and</strong> Gail Roth.<br />

4 LES Viewpoints


Industry-University-Government Interface (IUGI)<br />

National Institutes of Health, Univ.<br />

of Illinois–Chicago, Gilead Sciences<br />

& The Medicines Patent Pool<br />

The 2012 Deals of Distinction Award in the Industry-University-Government<br />

Interface Sector (IUGI) was presented to National Institutes of<br />

Health (NIH), University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC), Gilead Sciences<br />

(Gilead), <strong>and</strong> the Medicines Patent Pool, a newly established initiative of UNI-<br />

TAID, an international organization established for the purchase of drugs against<br />

HIV/AIDS, Malaria, <strong>and</strong> Tuberculosis.<br />

The Medicines Patent Pool, established by UNITAID in July 2010, is the first<br />

of its kind for HIV medicines. The primary objective of the Medicines Patent<br />

Pool is to improve access to affordable, appropriate HIV medicines in developing<br />

countries through the voluntary licensing of critical intellectual property from<br />

pharmaceutical companies. By streamlining licensing processes for the production<br />

of generic versions of patented HIV medicines for distribution <strong>and</strong> sale in<br />

the developing world, the Pool aims to serve as a one-stop shop that will speed<br />

up the pace at which newer medicines reach patients, <strong>and</strong> will help bring prices<br />

down by encouraging competition among multiple producers. It will also spur<br />

innovation, helping to facilitate the development of needed new HIV medicine<br />

formulations for children <strong>and</strong> of ‘fixed-dose combinations’ that combine several<br />

medicines into one pill, thereby simplifying treatment for patients.<br />

NIH <strong>and</strong> Gilead are the first licensors to join the Pool <strong>and</strong> will pave the way<br />

for additional public <strong>and</strong> private patent holders to help improve the availability of<br />

medicines in developing countries.<br />

The patents licensed by NIH/UIC relate to the protease inhibitor class of HIV<br />

medicines, which are used to treat drug-resistant HIV infection or patients with<br />

high viral loads, as best exemplified to date by the drug darunavir.<br />

The license agreement between Gilead <strong>and</strong> the Pool in July 2011 includes<br />

patents covering two backbone HIV treatments (disoproxil fumarate <strong>and</strong> emtricitabine)<br />

together with future rights to patents covering elvitegravir, an investigational<br />

integrase inhibitor; cobicistat, an investigational antiretroviral boosting<br />

agent; <strong>and</strong> Stribild, which combines tenofovir, emtricitabine, cobicistat <strong>and</strong><br />

elitegravir in a once-daily, single-tablet regimen. Stribild has since been approved<br />

by the FDA in August 2012, <strong>and</strong> was previously referred to as “Quad.”<br />

“The IUGI Sector is pleased to recognize this model partnership between the<br />

NIH, UIC, Gilead Sciences <strong>and</strong> the Medicines Pool. This is truly an innovative<br />

endeavor in facilitating access to HIV treatment in developing countries.<br />

It showcases the success of public-private partnerships to improve availability<br />

of medicine,” said IUGI Sector Chair Ida Shum. “Many thanks to our Deals of<br />

Distinction Committee members: Vasu Pestonjamasp, Thierry Musy-Verdel <strong>and</strong><br />

John McEntire.” ■<br />

Chemicals, Energy,<br />

Environment <strong>and</strong> Materials<br />

(CEEM) Sector Winner<br />

Sabine Pass Liquefaction,<br />

LLC & ConocoPhillips<br />

Company<br />

The Chemicals, Energy, Environment<br />

<strong>and</strong> Materials (CEEM) Sector's 2012<br />

Deals of Distinction Award was presented<br />

to Sabine Pass Liquefaction <strong>and</strong> ConocoPhillips.<br />

The award was in recognition of a<br />

technology agreement that will allow for the<br />

practice of ConocoPhillips Optimized Cascade<br />

® Process for natural gas liquefaction in<br />

two liquefaction trains. The trains will have a<br />

combined capacity of nominal 9.0 mtpa <strong>and</strong><br />

will be located in Cameron Parish, Louisiana<br />

as part of the Sabine Pass LNG Project.<br />

“This is the first world-scale natural gas<br />

liquefaction facility to be built in North<br />

America in more than 40 years,” said CEEM<br />

Deals of Distinction Chair Anne Culotta.<br />

“The two companies worked closely to ensure<br />

that the proprietary aspect of the technology<br />

was maintained while successfully obtaining<br />

the necessary government approvals <strong>and</strong> project<br />

financing for this $4.5-$5 billion dollar<br />

natural gas export project.”<br />

The technology is premised on the process<br />

used in the only other world-scale natural gas<br />

liquefaction plant in North America, the Kenai<br />

Alaska LNG facility, which was designed<br />

by Phillips Petroleum Company (now ConocoPhillips<br />

Company) <strong>and</strong> has been in operation<br />

since 1969. The technology is currently<br />

being used in 10 liquefaction trains located in<br />

Alaska, Trinidad, Egypt, Equatorial Guinea,<br />

Australia <strong>and</strong> Angola. An additional 10 trains<br />

are under construction in the United States<br />

<strong>and</strong> Australia. ■<br />

Claire Driscoll (left), (NIH) National Institutes of Health; Chan Park,<br />

Medicines Patent Pool; Gregg Alton, Gilead Sciences, Inc.; <strong>and</strong> Chair of<br />

the IUGI Sector, Ida Shum, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory.<br />

Anne Culotta, LES CEEM Sector (left) <strong>and</strong><br />

Gary Haag, accepting for ConocoPhillips<br />

<strong>and</strong> Sabine Pass Liquefaction.<br />

See Page 7 for the Life Sciences Deal of Distinction. November 2012 5


Foundation FOCUS By Lydia Steck<br />

Past Competition Volunteers Tell It Like It Is!<br />

The 2013 Graduate Student Business Plan Competition<br />

officially kicked off on November 12th, <strong>and</strong> as student<br />

registrations continue to roll in, the LES Foundation<br />

invites you to share your knowledge <strong>and</strong> expertise by volunteering<br />

this year.<br />

Worried about the commitment? Don’t be. Here is what past<br />

Competition volunteers had to say about their experiences:<br />

How will you choose to contribute<br />

to the success of Competition 2013?<br />

• Raise Awareness by encouraging<br />

participation from a graduate<br />

school program in your area.<br />

• Mentor a team by phone. Provide<br />

expertise <strong>and</strong> input for a participating<br />

team.<br />

www.lesfoundation.org<br />

• Judge a h<strong>and</strong>ful of business plans in<br />

your area of expertise.<br />

• Teach an IP & <strong>Licensing</strong> Basics<br />

Course for teams in your area.<br />

• Donate cash or an in-kind prize<br />

for the Competition.<br />

• Contact us at bplan@lesfoundation.<br />

org if you’d like to get involved!<br />

Judge <strong>and</strong> Mentor<br />

Ada Nielsen,<br />

Past President,<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>)<br />

“The Business Plan Competition<br />

puts us in the<br />

lead for attracting some<br />

of the brightest <strong>and</strong> the<br />

best around the world<br />

to learn the language <strong>and</strong><br />

the importance of inventions,<br />

IP, <strong>and</strong> licensing in<br />

creating value in business<br />

enterprises. This event<br />

really energizes us to<br />

work with local teams<br />

of graduate students <strong>and</strong><br />

professors <strong>and</strong> to interact<br />

with the participants at<br />

the Finals."<br />

Judge <strong>and</strong> Mentor<br />

Les Goff, Former<br />

LES Foundation<br />

Board Member <strong>and</strong><br />

Chair of the Competition<br />

Mentor Program<br />

“I really enjoy mentoring<br />

the teams. But<br />

I have to admit, it’s<br />

a little self-serving<br />

because the process<br />

offers me an opportunity<br />

to meet some of<br />

the best students from<br />

top graduate programs<br />

across the globe <strong>and</strong><br />

to see fresh ideas <strong>and</strong><br />

leading entrepreneurship<br />

trends.”<br />

2012 Final Round Judge<br />

Cheryl Cejka, LES (<strong>USA</strong><br />

& <strong>Canada</strong>) Trustee<br />

“It was really fun to do.<br />

We had six teams in<br />

the final round <strong>and</strong> they<br />

were all excellent. I have<br />

judged a lot of business<br />

plan competitions <strong>and</strong> this<br />

was definitely the highest<br />

caliber competition I have<br />

been involved with. It was<br />

also great because we<br />

had the opportunity to<br />

interact with the individual<br />

students <strong>and</strong> teams <strong>and</strong> to<br />

provide them with mentoring<br />

<strong>and</strong> connections to<br />

help get them going onto<br />

their next level.”<br />

2011 On-site Mentor<br />

Karen Sinclair,<br />

Past President of<br />

LES Australia <strong>and</strong><br />

New Zeal<strong>and</strong><br />

“Being a mentor<br />

brought a new dimension<br />

to the meeting.<br />

Now there was also<br />

the enthusiasm <strong>and</strong><br />

adrenalin of the team<br />

to ride, the excitement<br />

of the Competition, <strong>and</strong><br />

involvement in a process,<br />

which provoked<br />

thoughts about how I<br />

‘give back’ <strong>and</strong> pass my<br />

knowledge along to the<br />

next generation.”<br />

2011 Final Round<br />

Judge<br />

Mark Wilson,<br />

Past President of<br />

LES Britain <strong>and</strong><br />

Irel<strong>and</strong><br />

“The Competition<br />

was a very positive<br />

experience. I<br />

enjoyed interacting<br />

with the participants.<br />

Here was an<br />

opportunity for the<br />

students to talk to<br />

senior industrialists<br />

<strong>and</strong> to discuss<br />

what’s really<br />

required to build<br />

viable businesses.”<br />

The LES Foundation Board gathers in Toronto:<br />

Patrick O’Reilley (back left), Arthur Rose, Thomas<br />

Britven, Rob McInnes; (front left) Linda Chao,<br />

Annemarie Meike <strong>and</strong> Laura O'Shea.<br />

Key Dates:<br />

2013 LES Foundation Competition<br />

Nov. 12, 2012–Jan 31, 2013 IP Mentoring Support Registration<br />

Feb. 1–Feb 28, 2013<br />

Business Plan Submission<br />

March 10–16, 2013 First Round Judging Phase 1<br />

March 18–24, 2013<br />

First Round Judging Phase II<br />

April 7–10, 2013<br />

Finalist Announcement, 2013 LESI Annual<br />

Conference, Rio de Janeiro<br />

May 13 & 14, 2013<br />

Final Round <strong>and</strong> IP & <strong>Licensing</strong> Basics<br />

May 14–16, 2013<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) Spring Meeting, Seattle<br />

LES Foundation Board 2012-2013<br />

President – Tom Britven<br />

Secretary – Peter Ross<br />

Treasurer – Michael Samardzija<br />

(assisted by Jeremy Hamblen)<br />

Vice Presidents<br />

• Patrick O’Reilley, Europe<br />

Outreach<br />

• Annemarie Meike – Chair of<br />

2013 Competition<br />

• Linda Chao – Competition<br />

Advisor, High Tech Outreach<br />

• Mark Nawacki – Mentoring Program, Life<br />

Sciences Outreach<br />

• Peter Ross – LES <strong>USA</strong>/<strong>Canada</strong> Outreach,<br />

Americas/<strong>Canada</strong> Outreach<br />

• Rob McInnes – LESI International<br />

Outreach, Asia/Australia Outreach<br />

• Tom Filarski – Past LES President Advisor<br />

Advisors<br />

• Lydia Steck – Communications<br />

• Les Goff – Mentoring Program<br />

6 LES Viewpoints


CLP Website<br />

Gets New Look<br />

And Layout<br />

By Cynthia Allen<br />

The CLP Website has a new<br />

look <strong>and</strong> layout to help exam<br />

c<strong>and</strong>idates <strong>and</strong> current certificants<br />

access the information they<br />

need to navigate the certification<br />

<strong>and</strong> recertification processes. Visit<br />

the new website at www.licensingcertification.org<br />

<strong>and</strong> check out<br />

these features:<br />

• Access the most popular links<br />

on the Web site from any page<br />

on the site using the “Top Links”<br />

navigation bar. The most popular<br />

links on the CLP site are the eligibility requirements, c<strong>and</strong>idate h<strong>and</strong>book,<br />

practice test, application <strong>and</strong> FAQs.<br />

• Review the News section features the certificant-only newsletter, CLP<br />

Connection, <strong>and</strong> announcements about the CLP program <strong>and</strong> certificants.<br />

CLP Connection is printed two times annually. The next issue comes in<br />

December via email to all current certificants.<br />

• Download helpful resources to help you promote your achievement<br />

including a sample press release, marketing tips, <strong>and</strong> guidelines for using<br />

the CLP credential.<br />

• Download the CLP practice test if you are considering taking the CLP<br />

exam. The practice test includes 50 multiple-choice questions that are representative<br />

of the questions on the CLP certification exam.<br />

Remember the CLP exam will be offered again in April 2013. Applicants<br />

receive two testing opportunities within a 13-month window. Visit the new<br />

CLP Website at www.licensingcertification.org to learn more about the CLP<br />

certification process. ■<br />

CLP Elects New Governors And Officers<br />

The CLP Board of Governors has elected new Governors <strong>and</strong><br />

Officers for 2012–2013. They met in Toronto to discuss plans<br />

for the upcoming year.<br />

Deals of Distinction TM<br />

Life Sciences Sector Winner<br />

Eli Lilly &<br />

Boehringer Ingelheim<br />

Strategic Alliance<br />

The global population of people with diabetes<br />

is expected to explode from the current level<br />

of 366 million to 600 million by 2030. Never<br />

has there been a more urgent need for new solutions<br />

to address the diverse requirements of people with<br />

diabetes. The Life Science Sector honored Eli Lilly<br />

<strong>and</strong> Company (Lilly) <strong>and</strong> Boehringer Ingelheim with<br />

the 2012 Deals of Distinction Award for their efforts<br />

to combine their substantial scientific expertise <strong>and</strong><br />

business capabilities to deliver solutions by jointly<br />

developing <strong>and</strong> commercializing four new promising<br />

medicines in diabetes care by 2016. Through<br />

the alliance, Lilly is building its presence in the<br />

fast-growing market for oral agents to treat diabetes,<br />

while Boehringer Ingelheim will gain access to the<br />

insulin market.<br />

The deal is unique not only because of its value, but<br />

also because of its creative structure, which merges<br />

pipelines from two companies allowing both to<br />

maximize their development <strong>and</strong> commercialization<br />

resources. The alliance molecules include two oral<br />

treatments, the DPP-4 inhibitor Linagliptin <strong>and</strong> the<br />

SGLT2 inhibitor Empagliflozin, contributed by Boehringer<br />

Ingelheim <strong>and</strong> two insulin basal analogues,<br />

LY2605541 <strong>and</strong> LY2963016, contributed by Lilly.<br />

“The Boehringer Ingelheim-Lilly deal structure<br />

creates a remarkably impressive strategic alliance<br />

with bold risk-sharing <strong>and</strong> outst<strong>and</strong>ing upside<br />

potential unique to the industry. The alliance has<br />

been engineered to boost both companies’ presence<br />

in a highly competitive market while meeting the<br />

complex needs of a large <strong>and</strong> growing global patient<br />

population,” said Life Science Sector Chair Joseph<br />

Dillon. The deal also makes both companies more efficient<br />

in the competitive diabetes-care marketplace. ■<br />

The CLP Board: back row (left to right) - Cynthia Allen; Mike Lee, Vice-<br />

President; Paul Stewart, President; Ernie Posner; Laurent Mieville<br />

Front Row (left to right) - Robin Rasor, Secretary; Lesley Millar; Sue Patow;<br />

<strong>and</strong> François Painchaud, Treasurer.<br />

Jack Tupman (right), Eli Lilly, accepts the award from<br />

Life Sciences Sector Chair Joe Dillon.<br />

November 2012 7


Connecting And Collaborating With A Canadian F<br />

By Linda Corcoran<br />

When Canadian Mountie (Meeting Chair Tim Lowman)<br />

<strong>and</strong> Her Majesty The Queen (Susan Peacock) took<br />

center stage in Toronto, more than 800 meeting attendees<br />

roared with expectations that this was going to be a meeting<br />

to remember – Canadian style, eh! The LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>)<br />

2012 Annual Meeting proved to be a success on every level, from<br />

groundbreaking speakers to engaging workshops <strong>and</strong> networking<br />

events that literally had everyone looking up! Yes, all eyes were<br />

skyward as Cirque du Soleil performed their unique acrobatic feats<br />

at the Opening Reception. Tim Lowman elicited a few smiles as he<br />

introduced Cirque as <strong>Canada</strong>’s top export.<br />

Keynote: Dr. Eric Topol, author of “The Creative Destruction of Medicine”<br />

Dr. Eric Topol delivered a dynamic keynote address, “Connecting<br />

& Collaborating: The Convergence of Life Sciences <strong>and</strong> High<br />

Tech,” as he spoke of his work to bring a new kind of medicine<br />

into widespread practice, one where physicians<br />

monitor <strong>and</strong> respond to their patients’<br />

vital signs from anywhere in the world. His<br />

examination regarding the convergence of<br />

pharma, high technology <strong>and</strong> diagnostics<br />

<strong>and</strong> its potential to revolutionize healthcare<br />

was not only heard by Annual Meeting<br />

attendees, but is also being heard around<br />

the world through various blogs, podcasts,<br />

magazine articles <strong>and</strong> interviews, most recently featured on NPR’s<br />

Science Friday. Named the Most Influential Physician Executive in<br />

Health Care by Modern Healthcare <strong>and</strong> a Rock Star of Science by<br />

GQ magazine, Dr. Topol provided an entertaining, educational <strong>and</strong><br />

thought-provoking session that did not disappoint.<br />

He cut right to the chase by showing high-tech gadgets helping<br />

to individualize medical care <strong>and</strong> allowing physicians to monitor<br />

patient conditions from a remote location. As he displayed the<br />

Zio sleep monitor, Dr. Topol spoke of the importance of sleep in<br />

regards to learning, performance <strong>and</strong> preventing obesity. He cited<br />

sleeps effects on top athletes, referring to Lebron James who gets<br />

twelve hours of sleep a night!<br />

Dr. Topol continued unveiling other high-tech tools for patients<br />

<strong>and</strong> doctors:<br />

•AliveCor, which performs <strong>and</strong> sends an EKG using a smartphone.<br />

•EyeNetra mobile phone attachment that delivers on-dem<strong>and</strong><br />

eye care by diagnosing certain conditions<br />

•Blood sugar meters that transmit information from a patient’s<br />

“patch” to their doctor through a mobile phone.<br />

Dr. Topol stated that he hasn’t used a stethoscope in more than<br />

two years. Instead, he prefers an ultrasound scanner that fits in his<br />

pockets. Referring to wireless gadgets, smartphones, <strong>and</strong> the new<br />

immediacy of information, Dr. Topol begs the question: Why do<br />

we need hospitals when everything can be done virtually?<br />

The session broke through the boundaries of traditional medicine,<br />

an area that Dr. Topol is quite familiar with his 14-year<br />

background as chief of cardiovascular medicine for the Clevel<strong>and</strong><br />

Clinic <strong>and</strong> his current position as director of the Scripps Translational<br />

Science Institute. Richard Razgaitis summed up this inspirational<br />

session by stating, “Thank you for bringing our plenary<br />

sessions to a whole new level.”<br />

Read on for capsule reviews by our team of roving reporters.<br />

“How Outcomes of Patent Fights have Changed<br />

the Course of History”<br />

A highlight of the 2012 Annual Business Meeting<br />

was an address by renowned author <strong>and</strong><br />

historian Maury Klein, professor Emeritus of History,<br />

University of Rhode Isl<strong>and</strong>, who discussed<br />

how the outcomes of patent fights have changed<br />

the course of history. In Mr. Klein’s view, historical<br />

patterns are repetitive in nature, <strong>and</strong> while it<br />

may feel as though today’s behemoth patent wars<br />

are a new frontier, the fact is that such wars span<br />

the ages beginning with the development of the<br />

patent system itself in the 1600s <strong>and</strong> continuing<br />

though the advent of embattled technologies such<br />

as the steam engine, the cotton gin, the telephone,<br />

the air machine <strong>and</strong> others. —Lydia Steck<br />

“Growing the Value of Your Technology Prior<br />

to <strong>Licensing</strong>, Next-Stage Funding or Next-<br />

Round Financing”<br />

This Life Sciences Sector workshop presented<br />

the application of a proven risk management<br />

approach to growing the value of a technology<br />

portfolio, or venture. The premise of the<br />

framework, which was the first layer of a full<br />

methodology, described a pre-revenue venture,<br />

where the value of the venture is primarily a<br />

function of risk. Most participants were technology<br />

transfer personnel actively involved in<br />

the management of technology spin-offs; a case<br />

scenario provided lively discussion among the<br />

group. —Jackie Csonka-Peeren<br />

Bob Branson (left), Tom Filarski, Eric Topol &<br />

Chuck Neuenschw<strong>and</strong>er<br />

▲<br />

▲<br />

▲<br />

“Convergence in the C<br />

Bringing Innovative Pro<br />

The need for strong, g<br />

is growing according to<br />

Senior Director, Strate<br />

Merck & Co., Inc. <strong>and</strong><br />

own consulting firm. L<br />

of convergence” <strong>and</strong> ad<br />

can serve as a critical t<br />

extend br<strong>and</strong> equities<br />

zone” into new channe<br />

potential to endure. Pa<br />

how to extend br<strong>and</strong>s<br />

bining to create more<br />

“Russia Joins the WTO - C<br />

Tech Climate Coming”<br />

This Hot Topics Works<br />

Toronto <strong>and</strong> Sergey Medv<br />

implications for LES memb<br />

Federation recently becom<br />

(August 22, 2012). Russia’s<br />

results in what is called th<br />

respect to foreign investm<br />

Russian government has a<br />

reforms, <strong>and</strong> these negativ<br />

warranted. Medvedev the<br />

ties, including grants, at Sk<br />

under development. Both<br />

of Russian IP law <strong>and</strong> prov<br />

8 LES Viewpoints


lair<br />

LES 2012 Annual Meeting Recap • October 14-17, 2012 • Toronto, ON, <strong>Canada</strong><br />

“Benches Unleashed: Judicial Views on Fixing the Systems”<br />

Wednesday morning kicked off with an informative<br />

session featuring Honourable Judge Roger Hughes of<br />

the Federal Court of <strong>Canada</strong> <strong>and</strong> Honorable Paul Michel,<br />

retired Chief Judge of the United States Court of<br />

Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Brian O'Shaughnessy,<br />

Shareholder at RatnerPrestia, acted as moderator<br />

for this lively session. The discussion spanned a wide<br />

range of topics, including the role of IP in advancing<br />

the economy, the America Invents Act, the way in<br />

which the Courts have interpreted the laws passed by<br />

Congress, <strong>and</strong> what can be done to promote sound IP<br />

policies. —Brian Frizzell<br />

▲<br />

onsumer Products:<br />

ducts to Market”<br />

lobal br<strong>and</strong> equities<br />

Susan Levy, former<br />

gy Development for<br />

current founder of her<br />

evy examined the “issues<br />

dressed how licensing<br />

ool to strengthen <strong>and</strong><br />

beyond their “comfort<br />

ls that can provide the<br />

rticipants brainstormed<br />

into other areas, combr<strong>and</strong><br />

equity.<br />

▲<br />

“Advanced Negotiations - A Walk on the People Side”<br />

In the “Advanced Negotiations: A Walk on the People<br />

Side” workshop, Dr. Robert Fisher emphasized that in<br />

any negotiation, differing perceptions can drive dramatically<br />

different negotiation outcomes. Since individual<br />

<strong>and</strong> team psychology shape perceptions, they also drive<br />

how choices are made, how decisions are formed <strong>and</strong><br />

how we negotiate. Essentially, there are negotiating<br />

behaviors, which can be observed, chosen <strong>and</strong> changed<br />

to competitive advantage. Fisher introduced TASC-T,<br />

an assessment tool to evaluate <strong>and</strong> make those choices.<br />

The Advanced Negotiations Workshop was lively <strong>and</strong><br />

informative <strong>and</strong> included seasoned panelists Cheryl Cejka,<br />

Lenny Terry <strong>and</strong> S<strong>and</strong>eep Agarwal. —Robert Fisher<br />

▲<br />

“Is High Tech Crazy? Are We Experiencing a Patent Bubble?”<br />

A panel moderated by Chuck Neuenschw<strong>and</strong>er of IPLC<br />

<strong>and</strong> comprised of Joff Wild of IAM Magazine, Joe Dillon of<br />

BIO, Dooyong Lee of Acacia Research, <strong>and</strong> Mike Lasinski<br />

of 284 Partners, discussed whether or not the market<br />

for IP-based transactions is in the midst of an irrational<br />

expansion <strong>and</strong> overvaluation. Among other topics, the<br />

panel addressed the difficulties inherent in the real-time<br />

detection of market "bubbles," the various indicators of<br />

diligent <strong>and</strong> rational portfolio evaluation by Rockstar <strong>and</strong><br />

Google, the misunderst<strong>and</strong>ing of the IP marketplace by<br />

mainstream media <strong>and</strong> the wider investment community,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the risks <strong>and</strong> opportunities to the IP community in<br />

light of the recent focus on IP-based transactions.<br />

—Chris Schulte<br />

hanges in the Russian IP &<br />

hop, led by Paul Jones of<br />

edev of Moscow, addressed<br />

ers regarding The Russian<br />

ing a member of the WTO<br />

negative perception often<br />

e “Russian discount” with<br />

ent. As Jones discussed, the<br />

continuous track record of<br />

e perceptions are not fully<br />

n described the opportuniolkovo,<br />

a major science park<br />

speakers discussed the state<br />

ided deal tips.<br />

▲<br />

▲<br />

Networking at the Four Seasons Centre for the<br />

Performing Arts<br />

The Annual Meeting was rich with networking opportunities.<br />

On Tuesday evening attendees were awestruck<br />

by the contemporary spaces inside the Four Seasons<br />

Centre. Food <strong>and</strong> drinks were available on three levels<br />

accessible via glass staircases.<br />

At the Opening Reception, the Cirque du Soleil acrobats<br />

delighted <strong>and</strong> entertained, as all wondered, “How is<br />

that possible?”<br />

The Tech Fair also provided networking <strong>and</strong> access to<br />

new technologies <strong>and</strong> services from a variety of sponsors<br />

<strong>and</strong> service providers.<br />

November 2012 9


Local Chapter Awards<br />

In celebration of the hard work <strong>and</strong> dedication of so many volunteers<br />

at the local level, LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) presented its<br />

Local Chapter Awards during the recent Annual Meeting in<br />

Toronto. Congratulations to the following award-winning chapters:<br />

• Toronto Chapter (Charles Boulakia, Chair):<br />

Excellence in Leadership<br />

• Montreal Chapter (Annie Gauthier, Co-Chair <strong>and</strong> Natacha Mongeau,<br />

Co-Chair): Small Chapter Award,<br />

Most New Members in 2012<br />

• New York City Chapter (Arnold Burstein, Chair; Viviane Martin,<br />

Co-Chair, Christine T. Fischette, Co-Chair, Barbara A. Sawitsky):<br />

Large Chapter Award, Most New Members in 2012.<br />

• New Jersey Chapter (Linda Webb, Chair, <strong>and</strong> Lori Waldron, Co-<br />

Chair): Large Chapter Award, Highest Single Event Attendance.<br />

• Silicon Valley Chapter (Damon Matteo, Chair): Most Meetings in<br />

2012, accepted by Craig Smith.<br />

• Houston Chapter (Anne Culotta, Chair): Most Creative Award. ■<br />

Notice from Linda Webb, New Jersey Chapter Chair:<br />

Due to Hurricane S<strong>and</strong>y, the LES New Jersey Chapter meeting<br />

scheduled for Oct. 30th had to be cancelled. The topic of “Investing<br />

in Entrepreneurs” will be rescheduled sometime next year. Our next<br />

scheduled meeting in 2012 is Dec. 13 for the annual holiday gathering.<br />

In the meantime, the chapter leadership team wishes everyone a<br />

safe recovery <strong>and</strong> we hope your hardships will soon be overcome.<br />

Chapter Chair Award winners celebrate, from left,<br />

Linda Webb, Christine Fischette, Barbara Sawitsky <strong>and</strong><br />

Annie Gauthier.<br />

Lorraine Fleck<br />

(incoming Chapter<br />

Chair, Toronto) accepts<br />

the Excellence<br />

in Leadership Award<br />

from Hilton Sue.<br />

Alaya Bettaieb<br />

Champions IP for<br />

Rebuilding Tunisia’s<br />

Economy<br />

By Linda Corcoran<br />

What does it take to rebuild a<br />

country? Alaya Bettaieb knows<br />

that rebuilding the economy in<br />

Tunisia presents plenty of challenges <strong>and</strong><br />

opportunities for international intellectual<br />

property partnerships. Speaking at the<br />

Annual Meeting, Bettaieb introduced the<br />

situation in post-revolution Tunisia <strong>and</strong><br />

the surrounding area, describing how the<br />

Michael Martin introduces Alaya Bettaieb<br />

at the Annual Meeting in Toronto.<br />

10 LES Viewpoints<br />

ensuing Democratic process has created a<br />

freedom of expression <strong>and</strong> a freedom of<br />

entrepreneurship.<br />

Mr. Bettaieb is the Secretary of State to<br />

the Ministry of Investment <strong>and</strong> International<br />

Cooperation of Tunisia <strong>and</strong> is an LESI<br />

Certified <strong>Licensing</strong> Practitioner (CLP). A<br />

successful Venture Capitalist, Bettaieb has<br />

provided first seed <strong>and</strong> corporate venture<br />

funds in Tunisia targeting high value added<br />

technology projects in Northern Africa. In<br />

2005, he gained the trust of the U.S. government<br />

to lead a North Africa Innovation<br />

program launched to value technology in<br />

innovative SMIs in the region. He directed<br />

UAE, an Academic Technology Transfer<br />

program assessing the commercialization<br />

of research results in Arab Universities <strong>and</strong><br />

created 10 Technology Transfer Offices<br />

in 10 Arab countries, an ambitious project<br />

badly affected by the world financial<br />

crisis in 2008. In 2010, he moved to Saudi<br />

Arabia to coach a team from KAU in the<br />

validation of research results in treating<br />

the reject of brackish water desalination<br />

plants crowned by the creation of a startup<br />

commercializing the result. In August<br />

2011, he came back to Tunisia to set up a<br />

Technology Fund targeting the acquisition<br />

of clean technologies for Northern African<br />

markets.<br />

“There is new hope in building a new<br />

country,” says Bettaieb. “Today Tunisia is<br />

writing a new constitution <strong>and</strong> new legal<br />

reforms around issues such as IP.” In his<br />

presentation, “The Role of IP in Rebuilding<br />

Economies Following the Arab Spring,” he<br />

spoke of Tunisia’s technology upgrading<br />

as “food” for business activities from one<br />

country to another. The luncheon presentation<br />

was an intellectual opportunity for<br />

participants to tie together current issues<br />

<strong>and</strong> gain a realistic image of North Africa,<br />

how they are using IP, <strong>and</strong> where international<br />

assistance is needed.<br />

Current challenges facing Tunisia include<br />

more than 200,000 unemployed university<br />

graduates <strong>and</strong> the disparity of wealth by<br />

regions. The transition to build a better<br />

model for the country’s economy is driven<br />

by technology, which Bettaieb says, “brings<br />

both challenges <strong>and</strong> opportunities.”<br />

In his presentation, Bettaieb emphasized<br />

the need for international partnerships<br />

as well as crucial policymaking, which<br />

would allow investors to feel safe <strong>and</strong><br />

comfortable.<br />

In a country crushed under a 20+ year<br />

dictatorship, post-revolution freedoms are<br />

opening the door to initiatives that have<br />

long been forbidden. The country is starting<br />

to brim with entrepreneurs, who need<br />

the encouragement <strong>and</strong> guidance of IP<br />

professionals. “We cannot do it alone,” says<br />

Bettaieb. “There is a need for expertise.” ■


Crowdsourcing Session Examines Commercial Space<br />

Strategies And Trade-Offs While Breaking New Ground<br />

By Linda Corcoran<br />

Texts <strong>and</strong> tweets infused the conversation<br />

as LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) Annual<br />

Meeting goers in Toronto broke new<br />

ground in a session that invited participants<br />

to augment the conversation using their<br />

Blackberries, iPhones, <strong>and</strong> the like. The topic,<br />

“Carving Out Your Commercial Space—<br />

Strategies <strong>and</strong> Trade-Offs,” was centralized<br />

around three big questions <strong>and</strong> looked to the<br />

crowd for unique perspectives on alternative<br />

strategies that ensure their companies’<br />

freedom to successfully carve out space in<br />

the marketplace.<br />

Tim Lowman acted as the “Oracle” (the<br />

voice of texts <strong>and</strong> tweets), <strong>and</strong> provided the<br />

session overview as Kathleen Denis, Associate<br />

VP, Office of Technology Transfer<br />

at Rockefeller University, <strong>and</strong> Richard<br />

Razgaitis, Senior Advisor for Charles River<br />

Associates, led the discussion from the stage.<br />

Question #1: To search or not to search?<br />

Denis posed the first big question: Company<br />

cultures used to grow organically, but now<br />

that is changing. Most pharma companies<br />

have scouts visiting other small companies<br />

looking for technology to bring home. Many<br />

other industries have not adopted those strategies;<br />

instead, they go out <strong>and</strong> conquer. Should<br />

these other companies go out <strong>and</strong> search?<br />

The conversation quickly centered on<br />

sourcing products in DICE (Digital Information<br />

Computing Electronics) as an audience<br />

member commented that there were “tens of<br />

thous<strong>and</strong>s” of open innovation products in<br />

this space <strong>and</strong> noting their longer than usual<br />

timeline in bringing technology to market.<br />

A question was entertained regarding a<br />

parallel system being set up in other social<br />

media in order to ascertain who is out searching<br />

<strong>and</strong> who is not. Razgaitis interjected that<br />

Kodak, which is now in bankruptcy, may<br />

have had a different fate if they had been<br />

scouting outside their walls. “Could DICE<br />

take some advice from that?” he asked.<br />

A member of the audience commented that<br />

people in the DICE space weren’t even aware<br />

of licensing practices until they came to LES<br />

<strong>and</strong> heard various presentations. Another<br />

audience member’s comments stated, “If I<br />

want to develop a drug I know it is going<br />

to cost $10 million <strong>and</strong> take 10 years. You<br />

don’t need to wait for that in social media or<br />

Internet areas.”<br />

A poignant tweet came in: “If you want to<br />

find the next big thing,<br />

don’t go to a university.<br />

Go to Berkeley<br />

coffee shops <strong>and</strong> talk<br />

to students.”<br />

Some distinctions<br />

were made regarding<br />

DICE looking for<br />

opportunities that are<br />

fused to technology<br />

that is already in place<br />

versus Life Sciences<br />

technology, which is<br />

more st<strong>and</strong>-alone.<br />

Further comments<br />

on this key question<br />

included considering<br />

changing a company<br />

culture to be more<br />

open to looking for<br />

opportunities as well<br />

as creating a doorway<br />

at LES meetings by<br />

introducing yourself<br />

to people who may hold a strategic advantage<br />

for your company.<br />

Question #2: Is there value in<br />

IP collaborations?<br />

A second key question was posed by<br />

Razgaitis: Is the participation in IP collaborations—for<br />

the purpose of freedom of action,<br />

or new business opportunities, or both—an<br />

important strategic opportunity for Life<br />

Science companies? If so, what research or<br />

communications are most attractive for such<br />

collaborations <strong>and</strong> what are the associated<br />

high-importance IP/<strong>Licensing</strong> issues?<br />

An audience member quickly jumped into<br />

the conversation citing the chemical space’s<br />

use of upstream opportunities as an example<br />

of well-managed collaborations. It was noted<br />

that Life Science would have to change its<br />

culture to have a similar positive experience.<br />

Denis mentioned that several universities <strong>and</strong><br />

pharma collaborations are already doing so.<br />

Concern for NPEs (Non-Practicing Entities)<br />

participation in collaborations was<br />

voiced, mentioning that NPEs might gain<br />

access to patents, but collaborations might<br />

head off the purchase by NPEs. Other areas<br />

of collaboration were recalled, including 3M<br />

Ventures, plastics <strong>and</strong> the auto industry, <strong>and</strong><br />

the DICE industry.<br />

Kathleen Denis (left) <strong>and</strong> Richard Razgaitis lead the Crowdsourcing<br />

session in Toronto.<br />

Question #3: Advice for First To File?<br />

The final question was in regard to the<br />

America Invents Acts: What can our Canadian<br />

<strong>and</strong> other non-U.S. colleagues tell<br />

us about strategy <strong>and</strong> tactics under First<br />

To File? With a university exception to the<br />

prior user rights defense, will companies<br />

rethink their filing strategy?<br />

An attorney in the crowd submitted,<br />

“Under the America Invents Act, everyone<br />

files provisional applications. The<br />

grace period has eviscerated the one-year<br />

waiting period.”<br />

Others stated that there should be a race<br />

to the patent office with people getting<br />

their provisional patents on file <strong>and</strong> that<br />

there is a need to file before inventions<br />

are mature. A Canadian attorney stated,<br />

“Many are looking globally <strong>and</strong> examples<br />

of First to Invent are available globally. I<br />

don’t think this will change too many of<br />

my clients’ strategies.”<br />

Different industries were examined<br />

throughout the conversation. It was mentioned<br />

that universities would be impacted<br />

on smaller projects with upfront expenses.<br />

DICE industries will be impacted by First<br />

To File <strong>and</strong> will be taken aback by their<br />

longer time frames for development. ■<br />

November 2012 11


<strong>Marie</strong> Escobar:<br />

Front <strong>and</strong> Center for LES Education<br />

By Linda Corcoran<br />

<strong>Marie</strong> Escobar, adding value through<br />

quality programming<br />

The Annual Meeting in<br />

Q: Toronto proved to be quite a<br />

success. What was your role at the<br />

meeting?<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: If you’ve ever attended<br />

A: an LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) annual<br />

or seasonal meeting, you may<br />

have noticed staff members from LES<br />

Headquarters working from morning<br />

to night to ensure that every attendee<br />

walks away with a high value, high<br />

quality experience. In Toronto, I was<br />

personally responsible for providing<br />

Sunday’s educational programming,<br />

which was comprised of six workshops<br />

focused on CLP (Certified <strong>Licensing</strong><br />

Professional) domains. I also coordinated<br />

the day long <strong>Licensing</strong> Basics<br />

Course. I also worked with our Annual<br />

Meeting speakers <strong>and</strong> managed our<br />

Virtual Annual Meeting offering.<br />

What do you enjoy most about<br />

Q: attending annual <strong>and</strong> seasonal<br />

meetings?<br />

A:<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: The main benefit of<br />

meetings <strong>and</strong> what I personally<br />

enjoy the most is interacting with<br />

members. I cultivate so many relationships<br />

throughout the year without ever<br />

meeting the Individuals. The Annual<br />

Meeting is a great time to put a face<br />

<strong>and</strong> a name with the voice <strong>and</strong> to actually<br />

develop those relationships.<br />

Most of the time you are<br />

Q: working out of the LES (<strong>USA</strong><br />

& <strong>Canada</strong>) headquarters in Alex<strong>and</strong>ria,<br />

Virginia. What are your day-today<br />

responsibilities?<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>)<br />

A:<br />

Headquarters is the engine that<br />

supports the day-to-day operations of<br />

the <strong>Society</strong>. My responsibilities include<br />

overseeing all professional development<br />

initiatives, including education<br />

programs, from Basics to Best Practices,<br />

LES University, webinars <strong>and</strong> new<br />

virtual options, as well as working with<br />

meetings teams on program design.<br />

What is the most interesting<br />

Q: aspect of your job?<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: LES is interesting just<br />

A:<br />

because of the diversity of the<br />

membership. Not only am I able to<br />

assist members through association<br />

management, but I am also learning<br />

efficient business practices <strong>and</strong> tools<br />

from the members themselves. On a<br />

personal level, the skill sets that the<br />

members bring have made me better at<br />

my own job.<br />

What are the challenges that<br />

Q: you face in your role with LES?<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: In the current business<br />

A:<br />

climate, it is important to balance<br />

the traditional values of membership<br />

with new learning devices <strong>and</strong> principals.<br />

Tightened travel budgets make it<br />

more difficult for members to come out<br />

to educational meetings <strong>and</strong> programs.<br />

In turn, we’ve begun to offer hybrid<br />

meetings where plenary sessions are<br />

An interview with <strong>Marie</strong> Escobar, LES Education<br />

<strong>and</strong> Program Content Manager.<br />

broadcast to members. The challenge is<br />

to bring content to people who cannot<br />

attend meetings <strong>and</strong> to balance that<br />

with the value of networking, which<br />

makes membership in LES unique.<br />

What are some of your goals<br />

Q: for education <strong>and</strong> programming<br />

in the coming year?<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: My main goals are to offer<br />

more hybrid meetings <strong>and</strong> to<br />

A:<br />

make education more available at the<br />

Chapter level.<br />

What past experiences have<br />

Q: prepared you for your role<br />

with LES?<br />

A:<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: Prior to joining LES,<br />

I was the Foundation Director<br />

for the American Chiropractic Association<br />

(ACA). Through my tenure, I<br />

established certification programs <strong>and</strong><br />

supplemented their education programs<br />

with resources <strong>and</strong> learning materials.<br />

What was it like to work with<br />

Q: chiropractors?<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: The benefits were great.<br />

A:<br />

The chiropractors used to offer<br />

“free” stress-reducing adjustments at<br />

ACA annual meetings!<br />

How do you spend your time<br />

Q: when you are not working in<br />

the LES office or on-the-road at an<br />

LES meeting?<br />

A:<br />

<strong>Marie</strong>: I enjoy spending downtime<br />

with my husb<strong>and</strong> at our<br />

home in Northwest D.C. I am also a<br />

part-time student at American University<br />

<strong>and</strong> will be graduating in May<br />

with an MBA in Emerging Markets. ■<br />

Rates, continued from Page 3<br />

A total of 120 completed surveys were incorporated into<br />

the final Global BioPharma Survey Report with almost half<br />

of the reported deals from outside North America. Of those<br />

who responded, 31% were from pharmaceutical companies,<br />

22% were from biotech companies, 9% were from academic<br />

institutions, 6% were from government, <strong>and</strong> 32% were<br />

from other organizations.<br />

The surveys were designed by committees of experienced LES<br />

members within the Life Sciences Sector who worked alongside an<br />

independent team from Veris Consulting, LLC, on design, dissemination,<br />

data collection <strong>and</strong> analysis <strong>and</strong> ensuring confidentiality.<br />

The final Global BioPharma Royalty Rates <strong>and</strong> Deal Terms<br />

Survey Report will be made available online exclusively to LES<br />

members worldwide in November. For more information, visit<br />

www.lesusacanada.org. ■<br />

12 LES Viewpoints


SAVE THE DATE<br />

FOR 2013 LES<br />

MEETINGS<br />

© Copyright Greater Phoenix CVB<br />

IP100 Executive Forum<br />

February 11–12<br />

Phoenix, AZ<br />

Spring Meeting<br />

May 14–16<br />

Seattle, WA<br />

© Copyright Tim Thompson<br />

Annual Meeting<br />

September 22–25<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Photo by B. Krist for GPTMC<br />

More details coming soon. Check in at www.LES<strong>USA</strong><strong>Canada</strong>.org<br />

November 2012 13


Acceptance to membership<br />

in LES (<strong>USA</strong> &<br />

<strong>Canada</strong>) will be effective<br />

30 days from the date<br />

of publication herein<br />

unless, in the meantime,<br />

notice has been given to<br />

the Membership Committee<br />

of an objection<br />

to the membership of a<br />

listed applicant.<br />

Andrew Adler<br />

Citrin Cooperman<br />

Jeffrey Adams<br />

Ray Adams<br />

MOSAID<br />

Douglas Adams<br />

The City Univ. of New York<br />

Franklin Akomeah<br />

Melissa Alcorn<br />

Oklahoma Medical<br />

Research Foundation<br />

Edward Allen<br />

Lockheed Martin Corp.<br />

Richard Allison<br />

Hudson Bay Capital<br />

Management LP<br />

Uzi Aloush<br />

SynPat - Syndicated Patent<br />

Acquisitions Corp.<br />

James Alva<br />

Tech Futures Group<br />

Dmitriy Andreyev<br />

Flagship IP, P.C.<br />

Robert Andris<br />

Ropers Majeski, Kohn &<br />

Bentley<br />

Benjamin Anger<br />

Knobbe, Martens, Olson<br />

& Bear, LLP<br />

Steven Arnold<br />

Micron Technology, Inc.<br />

Tony Asseiro<br />

British Columbia Institute<br />

of Technology<br />

Mark Austin<br />

Ch<strong>and</strong>ler Reed, LLC<br />

Jessica Avery<br />

New Hampshire Ball<br />

Bearings, Inc.<br />

Michael Banco<br />

S.C. Johnson & Son, Inc.<br />

Steve Banet<br />

UCB Inc<br />

Audrey Banks<br />

Henry M Jackson<br />

Foundation<br />

Luke Barbin<br />

Cardinal Intellectual<br />

Property, Inc.<br />

Tom Barnett<br />

Masco Corporation<br />

Paul Barone<br />

Inspirion Pharmaceuticals<br />

14 LES Viewpoints<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) New Members<br />

Due to space constraints, new member addresses can be found on the LES Web site, www.lesusacanada.org<br />

Rishi Batra<br />

Innovate Calgary<br />

Laura Becker<br />

Procter & Gamble<br />

Matthew Behan<br />

KPMG LLP<br />

Brinda Bellur<br />

Laxminarayan<br />

David Bennett<br />

Western Michigan<br />

University<br />

William Berg<br />

Novartis Pharmaceuticals<br />

Elana Bertram<br />

Michaud-Kinney Group,<br />

LLP<br />

Samik Bhattacharyya<br />

VICIS Consulting Group<br />

LLC<br />

Michael Binz<br />

Deloitte Financial Advisory<br />

Services LLP<br />

Anna Bley<br />

Innovation Accelerator<br />

Mark Blomquist<br />

L<strong>and</strong>mark Financial<br />

Corporation<br />

Richard Boudreault<br />

Veronique Bougie<br />

Gestion Univalor, LP<br />

Charles Boulakia<br />

Ridout & Maybee LLP<br />

Francois Boulianne<br />

Besner Attorneys &<br />

Business Advisors<br />

Johan Brag<br />

INNOVA LAW, LLC<br />

Tony Brazzale<br />

Melanovus Oncology<br />

Garold Breit<br />

University of Louisiana<br />

Odd Bres<br />

University of Manitoba<br />

Ryan Buckmaster<br />

UW Center for Commercialization<br />

Danielle Bush<br />

Chitiz Pathak LLP<br />

Steven Cahn<br />

Cahn Litigation Services<br />

Pamela Carey-Mackenzie<br />

P&G<br />

Sean Carroll<br />

Robert Carruthers<br />

Innovate Calgary<br />

Meredith Carter<br />

Rembr<strong>and</strong>t IP Management,<br />

LLC<br />

Ping Cheng<br />

Merck Sharp & Dohme<br />

Corp.<br />

Dan Chicoine<br />

Nuvo Research Inc.<br />

Elvina Chow<br />

Forrest Chumley<br />

Heartl<strong>and</strong> Plant Innovations,<br />

Inc.<br />

<strong>Marie</strong> Clark<br />

Cosmederm Bioscience,<br />

Inc.<br />

Gavin Clarkson<br />

University of Houston<br />

Law Center<br />

Mattie Clay<br />

Richard Conroy<br />

Navigant Economics<br />

Jeff Cope<br />

RTI International<br />

Rick Covington<br />

Halliburton<br />

Regina Culbert<br />

Merchant & Gould<br />

Brian Cummings<br />

OSU Technology<br />

Commercialization &<br />

Knowledge Transfer<br />

Skip Cynar<br />

University of California<br />

- San Diego<br />

Paul Cyr<br />

The University of British<br />

Columbia<br />

Lane Czekala<br />

That Corporation<br />

Brian Darville<br />

Brocadiant Legal PLLC<br />

Debarshi Das<br />

Intellectual Ventures<br />

Janice Davis<br />

Bracewell & Giuliani<br />

LLP<br />

Anton Dawson<br />

Virginia Commonwealth<br />

University<br />

Steve De Brab<strong>and</strong>ere<br />

University of Guelph<br />

Paul Debbie<br />

Boyce Thompson Institute<br />

for Plant Research,<br />

Inc.<br />

Mark DeLong<br />

EMD Serono<br />

Yasmin Dennig<br />

S<strong>and</strong>ia National Labs<br />

Richard Deschenes<br />

INO<br />

Lisa Desjardins<br />

Esperanza Diaz<br />

Christine Dixon Thiesing<br />

Charles Donohoe<br />

Charles R. Donohe, P.C.<br />

Kristine Dorward<br />

Aptalis<br />

Glenn Dourado<br />

Lig<strong>and</strong> Pharmaceuticals<br />

Inc.<br />

Tim Doyle<br />

Christopher Ekren<br />

Sony Electronics Inc.<br />

Gerard Eldering<br />

Technology, Patents &<br />

<strong>Licensing</strong><br />

Patrick Ellisen<br />

Greenberg Traurig LLP<br />

Priscille Ernotte<br />

Institut National de la<br />

Recherche Scientifique<br />

Jerome Etwaroo<br />

University of Victoria<br />

Paul Eynott<br />

The University of<br />

Arizona<br />

Debra Fin<br />

Dow Corning Corp.<br />

Jeffrey Finn<br />

Sidley Austin LLP<br />

Robert Fisher<br />

Fisher Leadership<br />

Strategy Execution<br />

Christopher Flores<br />

UVic Industry Partnerships<br />

Brian Foley<br />

NeoStrata<br />

Norby Foss<br />

CBI<br />

Tom Foust<br />

National Renewable<br />

Energy Laboratory<br />

Gregory Frank<br />

XBiotech <strong>USA</strong>, Inc.<br />

Keith Fredlake<br />

Roberts Mlotkowski<br />

Safran & Cole P.C.<br />

Adam Fromm<br />

Cardinal Intellectual<br />

Property<br />

Camelia Galos<br />

Pratt & Whitney<br />

Jane Garrity<br />

NUtech Ventures<br />

Carl Genberg<br />

N8 Medical<br />

Jason Ghie<br />

IP Research Group<br />

Jon Gibbs<br />

Lowndes, Drosdick,<br />

Doster, Kantor & Reed,<br />

P.A.<br />

Sharon Gibson<br />

Visa, Inc.<br />

Glenna Gilbert<br />

Larkin Hoffman Daly &<br />

Lindgren Ltd.<br />

Siok Goh<br />

MOSAID Technologies<br />

Inc<br />

Joel Goldman<br />

SIPCO, LLC<br />

Ed Gomez<br />

Furnace Brook LLC<br />

Iranzu Gonzalez<br />

Digna Biotech L.L.C<br />

Robert Gould<br />

Husch Blackwell LLP<br />

Carol Greve-Philips<br />

Pronota NV<br />

Francisco Guerra<br />

License My Product<br />

Carl Gulbr<strong>and</strong>sen<br />

Wisconsin Alumni Research<br />

Foundation<br />

Michael Gulker<br />

TPR International<br />

Mengjuan Guo<br />

University of Lethbridge<br />

Charanjeet Guron<br />

Tina Ha<br />

Benaroya Research<br />

Institute<br />

Attila Hajdu<br />

GlaxoSmithKline<br />

Cory Hallam<br />

The University of Texas<br />

at San Antonio<br />

John Han<br />

Ericsson Inc.<br />

Josh Hartmann<br />

Gina Haschke<br />

Haschke Law PLLC<br />

Dennis Haszko<br />

LettersPatent.com<br />

Christie Hatges<br />

DRI Capital<br />

James Heitner<br />

Ripple Management, Inc.<br />

Meg Helms<br />

Morgan Wallace Associates,<br />

LLC<br />

Lisa Herron-Olson<br />

Syntiron<br />

Chad Hilyard<br />

Rockstar Consortium<br />

US LP<br />

David Hobson<br />

University of Guelph<br />

Tom Hochstatter<br />

Fluid Innovation<br />

James Holcombe<br />

Rockwell Collins, Inc.<br />

David Huffaker<br />

Intellectual Ventures<br />

Ted Ira<br />

Davita<br />

Amit Jhas<br />

MaRS Innovation<br />

Bozhena Jhas<br />

University of Toronto<br />

Steven John<br />

Major, Lindsey & Africa<br />

Gary Johnson<br />

Perception Partners, Inc.<br />

Frank Jones<br />

Whiteford, Taylor &<br />

Preston LLP<br />

Michael Jones<br />

Pepper Hamilton LLP<br />

Heajin Jung<br />

Heajin Jung Law Firm,<br />

PLLC<br />

Kimberly Justice<br />

Deloitte Financial Advisory<br />

Services LLP<br />

Jeewan Jyot<br />

NUtech Ventures<br />

Donald Kakuda<br />

UCSD Technology<br />

Transfer Office<br />

Matthew Kalnik<br />

Nabi Biopharmaceuticals<br />

Maki Kanayama<br />

Kanayama Law Office<br />

Steven Karski<br />

Efrat Kasznik<br />

Foresight Valuation<br />

Group LLC<br />

Anant Kataria<br />

Sagacious Research<br />

Wendy Kearns<br />

Snodgrass & Kearns,<br />

PLLC<br />

Mike Keenan<br />

WI-LAN Inc.<br />

Mark Keith<br />

IEC & Associates<br />

Brian Kelly<br />

Cornell Center for<br />

Technology Enterprise &<br />

Commercialization<br />

Matthew Kelly<br />

CME Group Inc.<br />

Brian Kemp<br />

Boeing Intellectual Property<br />

<strong>Licensing</strong> Co.<br />

Nicoletta Kennedy<br />

Roberts Mlotkowski<br />

Safran & Cole<br />

Ahsen Khan<br />

Intermountain Healthcare<br />

(Intermountain<br />

Invention Management<br />

LLC)<br />

Heather Khassian<br />

Bracewell & Giuliani<br />

Gaby Khouri<br />

RPX Corporation


Jin Kim<br />

IP Navigation Group<br />

Chang Kim<br />

CJ America, Inc.<br />

Don Kirksey<br />

Clearside Biomedical<br />

Kevin Kleespies<br />

The Clorox Company<br />

Bruce Koch<br />

Schmidt LLC<br />

Christopher Koch<br />

Techquity Capital Management<br />

Alon Konchitsky<br />

http://ip-consult.net/<br />

Pieter Kooiman<br />

AstraZeneca <strong>Canada</strong><br />

Inc.<br />

Ann-<strong>Marie</strong> Koss<br />

Invotex Group<br />

Ronnie Koss<br />

IdeaPoint<br />

Brad Krawczyk<br />

Apotex<br />

Marcus Kuizenga<br />

James Hardie<br />

Jason Kulick<br />

Indiana Integrated Circuits,<br />

LLC<br />

Winston Lam<br />

Caris Life Sciences<br />

Courtney Lambert<br />

Emergent Technologies,<br />

Inc<br />

Jessica L<strong>and</strong>acre<br />

Intellectual Property<br />

Owners Association<br />

Gail Langer<br />

St Teresa Medical Inc.<br />

Sun Lee<br />

Heajin Jung Law Firm,<br />

PLLC<br />

James Lee<br />

Novo Nordisk <strong>Canada</strong><br />

John Leja<br />

Polsinelli Shughart PC<br />

Mauro Leos<br />

Illinois Institute of<br />

Technology<br />

Per Lindell<br />

Novadigm Consulting<br />

Group<br />

Jeffrey Lindgren<br />

Vasquez Benisek &<br />

Lindgren LLP<br />

Martin Lindsay<br />

Bowers & Wilkins<br />

Br<strong>and</strong>on Lloyd<br />

Duff & Phelps LLC<br />

Ling Loerchner<br />

University of Waterloo<br />

- WatCo<br />

Due to space constraints, new member addresses can be found on the LES Web site, www.lesusacanada.org<br />

Mark Lopes<br />

TSC<br />

John Lopez<br />

Axiom Global<br />

Ethan Lovell<br />

Janus<br />

Drew Lowery<br />

Global Prior Art<br />

Bette Lyons<br />

Saskatchewan Research<br />

Council<br />

Anastasia Magoulias<br />

Life Technologies Corporation<br />

Mahmoud Mahmoudian<br />

Ferring Pharmaceuticals<br />

Barry Markowsky<br />

Convergent Healthcare<br />

Jim Martin<br />

SmartAnalyst, Inc.<br />

Christine Mayer<br />

Vaxlnnate Corporation<br />

Alan McClure<br />

Texas Instruments Incorporated<br />

David McClure<br />

Michael McGovern<br />

Matson Driscoll &<br />

Damico<br />

Sean McIntyre<br />

Robert McSorley<br />

Ocean Tomo<br />

Ian Mehr<br />

Kowa Research Institute<br />

Douglas Meier<br />

Finnegan Henderson<br />

Farabow Garrett & Dunner,<br />

LLP<br />

Sheila Mikhail<br />

Life Sciences Law PLLC<br />

Jonathan Minnaert<br />

Teva Pharmaceutical<br />

Miguel Mireles<br />

Xolve, Inc.<br />

Alex Modelski<br />

Ater Wynne LLP<br />

Katherine Moldave<br />

AlcheraBio<br />

Beverley Moore<br />

Borden Ladner Gervais<br />

LLP<br />

Richard Moses<br />

Pachira IP Inc.<br />

Chris Murphy<br />

UBM TechInsights<br />

Richard Murphy<br />

Brian Musa<br />

Pilar Najarro<br />

Digna Biotech L.L.C<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>) New Members<br />

Thomas Nealssohn<br />

Masco Corporation<br />

Research & Development<br />

Joseph Nguyen<br />

Intellectual Ventures<br />

Nam Nguyen<br />

Quick-Med Technologies,<br />

Inc.<br />

Michelle O’Brien<br />

O’Brien Jones, PLLC<br />

Koki Ohashi<br />

Kissei America<br />

Ellie Okada<br />

Boston Cancer Policy<br />

Institute, Inc<br />

Lowell Oster<br />

AppliCote Associates,<br />

LLC<br />

Veronique Page<br />

Mosaid Technologies Inc.<br />

Suchismita Pahi<br />

Ricardo Palacios<br />

Digna Biotech L.L.C<br />

David Paratore<br />

The NanoSteel<br />

Company Inc.<br />

Jae Park<br />

Kile Park Goekjian<br />

Reed & McManus PLLC<br />

Kaushik Patel<br />

University of Toronto<br />

Mihir Patel<br />

Allied Security Trust<br />

Marc Perron<br />

Alizem Inc.<br />

Mike Pisterzi<br />

PanOptis IP<br />

Robert Piston<br />

Francis Plati<br />

Sughrue Mion PLLC<br />

Jeff Pootoolal<br />

DRI Capital<br />

Jill Powlick<br />

BioFire Diagnostics, Inc.<br />

Joanna Preston<br />

TEC Edmonton<br />

Christopher Price<br />

LifeScience Consultancy<br />

Anthony Provitola<br />

Anthony I. Provitola,<br />

P.A.<br />

Richard Purcell<br />

DNA Healthlink, Inc.<br />

Samir Raiyani<br />

Dolcera<br />

Ramesh Rajaduray<br />

Stratford Managers<br />

Vicki R<strong>and</strong>all<br />

The Clorox Company<br />

Francois Ravenelle<br />

Oncozyme Pharma Inc.<br />

Frank Razavi<br />

Purdue Research Foundation,<br />

OTC<br />

Scott Rediker<br />

Merrill Corporation<br />

Bryan Repetto<br />

Applied Research Works<br />

David Richards<br />

N8 Medical, Inc.<br />

Sean Ricks<br />

Vivint, Inc.<br />

Alan Ritchie<br />

James Roberts<br />

Rembr<strong>and</strong>t Virginia<br />

Management<br />

Isabelle Robitaille<br />

Norton Rose <strong>Canada</strong><br />

LLP<br />

Michael Ronning<br />

Purdue Pharma, LP<br />

Stuart Rosove<br />

Irdeto<br />

Christopher Roth<br />

Shire Pharmaceuticals<br />

Sam Rothstein<br />

University of Pittsburgh<br />

Steven Rowan<br />

Seabreeze Ltd.<br />

Israel Rozen<br />

Broad Institute of Harvard<br />

& MIT<br />

Adam Rubenstein<br />

Andrea Rush<br />

Heenan Blaikie LLP<br />

Kashinath Sadalapure<br />

Phyton Biotech LLC<br />

Rade Sajic<br />

Andrews Robichaud<br />

Intellectual Property<br />

Lawyers & Business<br />

Law<br />

David Sasso<br />

Intellectual Ventures<br />

LLC<br />

George Sawyer<br />

Evalueserve<br />

Scott Scaramastro<br />

Agilent Technologies,<br />

Inc.<br />

David Schatz<br />

WiTricity Corporation<br />

Thorsten Schmidt<br />

Schmidt LLC<br />

Jennifer Schrader<br />

Counterpoint Systems, Inc<br />

Orit Segev<br />

Genome BC<br />

Madhu Sharma<br />

Univ. of California, Davis<br />

Bradley Shaw<br />

Michigan State University<br />

Anthony Shull<br />

Sunovion Pharmaceuticals<br />

Leticia Silva<br />

Tyler Sims<br />

Sims Strategies LLC<br />

Raja Singh<br />

Innovate Calgary<br />

Scott Smedresman<br />

SorinR<strong>and</strong> LLP<br />

Linda Smibert<br />

Kowa Pharmaceuticals<br />

America, Inc.<br />

Andrea Sotak<br />

DRI Capital Inc.<br />

Mark Stallion<br />

Husch Blackwell LLP<br />

Judith Stein<br />

Vaccine Research Center/NIAID/NIH<br />

Justin Stewart<br />

Micron Technology, Inc.<br />

Carrie Stroup<br />

Summersby Intellectual<br />

Property Consulting<br />

Suresh Sunderrajan<br />

United Technologies<br />

Corporation<br />

Michael Swan<br />

Global Royalty Audits,<br />

Inc.<br />

Lawrence Tedesco<br />

DRC, LLC;<br />

U.S. Ethernet Innovations,<br />

LLC<br />

Jason Teller<br />

Intellectual Ventures<br />

Dan Templeton<br />

Brooks Kushman PC<br />

Jon Tepp<br />

Laurits R. Christensen<br />

Associates, Inc.<br />

Ray Throckmorton<br />

R3T Consulting Group,<br />

LLC<br />

Michael Thumm<br />

Pachira IP Inc.<br />

Mike Tobin<br />

Parker Poe Adams &<br />

Bernstein LLP<br />

David Tollen<br />

Tech Contracts Chalkboard<br />

Thomas Tolpin<br />

Tolpin & Partners, PC<br />

Peter Tong<br />

IP Ventures, Inc.<br />

Elo Tulving-Blais<br />

Tulving-Blais International<br />

& Tech Law<br />

Antonio Turco<br />

Blake, Cassels & Graydon<br />

LLP<br />

Nathan Valverde<br />

Sanofi- Aventis, Franklin<br />

Pierce Center for<br />

Intellectual Property<br />

Vikram Venkataramani<br />

Global <strong>Licensing</strong> Audit<br />

Services, Inc.<br />

Annemarie Vicere<br />

Osha Liang LLP<br />

Lester Vincent<br />

Blakely Sokoloff Taylor<br />

Zafman LLP<br />

Eve Wahn<br />

WahnLaw<br />

Rob Warner<br />

FTI Consulting<br />

Lel<strong>and</strong> Webster<br />

Tetraphase Pharmaceuticals,<br />

Inc.<br />

Peter Weinstein<br />

One3 IP Management<br />

Annette Weissbach<br />

Roche<br />

James Weyhenmeyer<br />

Georgia State University<br />

GSU<br />

Renee Whynes<br />

Energizer Personal<br />

Care<br />

Timothy Willis<br />

UNH-ORPC<br />

Hugh Wilson<br />

Russell Wilson<br />

Novavax, Inc.<br />

James Windsor<br />

Emergent Technologies,<br />

Inc.<br />

Jeffrey Witcher<br />

AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals<br />

LP<br />

Joe Wyse<br />

Wyse Innovations<br />

Xin Xu<br />

Princeton University<br />

David Zembower<br />

Rehabilitation Institute<br />

of Chicago<br />

Adrianna Zhang<br />

TSRI<br />

Chunyu Zheng<br />

Jingyu Zhou<br />

Comcast<br />

Christopher Ziegler<br />

Ken Zinda<br />

Inspherion<br />

November 2012 15


ADDRESS SERVICE REQUESTED<br />

PRSRT STD<br />

U.S. POSTAGE<br />

PAID<br />

ZIP CODE 44101<br />

PERMIT NO. 1501<br />

LESEvents<br />

2012 LES Annual Meeting Committee<br />

2013<br />

January 21-22<br />

Global Technology Impact<br />

Forum (GTIF)<br />

Geneva, Switzerl<strong>and</strong><br />

February 11-12<br />

IP100 Executive Forum<br />

Arizona Biltmore<br />

Phoenix, Arizona<br />

March 14-16<br />

LES Australia <strong>and</strong> New Zeal<strong>and</strong><br />

Annual Conference (LES ANZ)<br />

Brisbane, Australia<br />

April 5-7<br />

LES International Management &<br />

Delegates' Meeting (IMDM)<br />

Rio de Janerio, Brazil<br />

April 7-10<br />

LESI Annual Conference<br />

Windsor Atlantica Hotel<br />

Rio de Janeiro, Brazil<br />

May 14-16<br />

LES (<strong>USA</strong> & <strong>Canada</strong>)<br />

Spring Meeting, Keynote Speaker<br />

David Kappos, Director of USPTO<br />

W Hotel<br />

Seattle, Washington<br />

June 23–25<br />

LES International<br />

Pan-European Conference<br />

Davos, Switzerl<strong>and</strong><br />

September 22-25<br />

LES 2013 Annual Meeting<br />

Philadelphia Marriott Downtown<br />

2014<br />

May 21-23<br />

LES International Annual<br />

Conference<br />

Moscow, Russia<br />

October 5-8<br />

LES 2014 Annual Meeting<br />

San Francisco, California<br />

February 11-12, 2013<br />

Arizona Biltmore<br />

Phoenix, Arizona<br />

The IP100 Executive Forum is a unique<br />

<strong>and</strong> exclusive gathering of senior<br />

executives charged with the IP decision-making<br />

responsibilities within their organizations.<br />

The IP100 focuses on strategic<br />

issues related to IP business, including IP<br />

valuation, best practices in deal structure, IP<br />

strategy <strong>and</strong> organizational alignment.<br />

Held annually, the event explores the<br />

business dynamics of IP <strong>and</strong> organizational<br />

strategy through panel <strong>and</strong> small, facilitated<br />

Special thanks to the<br />

LES 2012 Annual Meeting<br />

Committee: Tim<br />

Lowman (front left),<br />

Gary Fedorochko, Tom<br />

Filarski; (back left) Hilton<br />

Sue, Mitch Charness,<br />

Bob Held, Chuck Neuenschw<strong>and</strong>er<br />

<strong>and</strong> (top)<br />

Carolyn Rockafellow.<br />

group discussions, where the focus is on<br />

peer-to-peer interactions, thought-provoking<br />

engagement <strong>and</strong> valuable takeaways<br />

to implement <strong>and</strong> integrate immediately<br />

into your organization. Attendance<br />

is limited to experienced, managementlevel<br />

professionals from various types of<br />

organizations of all sizes <strong>and</strong> industries.<br />

Visit www.IP100.org for more information<br />

<strong>and</strong> to request an invitation. Space is<br />

limited to 100. ■<br />

Printed on Recycled Paper

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!