31.10.2014 Views

energy audit report prepared for - Pennsylvania Convention Center

energy audit report prepared for - Pennsylvania Convention Center

energy audit report prepared for - Pennsylvania Convention Center

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

ENERGY AUDIT REPORT<br />

PREPARED FOR:<br />

PENNSYLVANIA<br />

CONVENTION CENTER<br />

1227 RACE STREET<br />

PHILADELPHIA, PA 19107<br />

ATTN: MR. JAMES K. LEWIS<br />

GENERAL MANAGER<br />

PREPARED BY:<br />

CONCORD ENGINEERING GROUP<br />

520 S. BURNT MILL ROAD<br />

VOORHEES, NJ 08043<br />

TELEPHONE: (856) 427-0200<br />

FACSIMILE: (856) 427-6529<br />

WWW.CEG-INC.NET<br />

CEG CONTACT:<br />

JESSE OHM, PE, LEED AP<br />

LEAD ENERGY AUDITOR<br />

EMAIL: JOHM@CEG-INC.NET<br />

REPORT ISSUANCE: FEBRUARY 22, 2010


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Table of Contents<br />

I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................. 3<br />

II. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 10<br />

III. METHOD OF ANALYSIS................................................................................................ 12<br />

IV. HISTORIC ENERGY CONSUMPTION/COST ............................................................... 15<br />

A. BASELINE ENERGY USAGE ......................................................................................... 15<br />

B. TARIFF ANALYSIS: ........................................................................................................ 18<br />

C. ENERGY USE INDEX (EUI): .......................................................................................... 20<br />

V. FACILITY DESCRIPTION .............................................................................................. 22<br />

VI. MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST ............................................................................................ 27<br />

VII. ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES ..................................................................... 28<br />

VIII. RENEWABLE/DISTRIBUTED ENERGY MEASURES ................................................ 65<br />

IX. ENERGY PURCHASING AND PROCUREMENT STRATEGY .................................. 67<br />

X. INSTALLATION FUNDING OPTIONS.......................................................................... 70<br />

XI. ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS ............................................................................... 71<br />

Appendix A – ECM Cost & Savings Breakdown<br />

Appendix B – Major Equipment List<br />

Appendix C – Electrical Analysis Report – Burris Engineers<br />

Appendix D – PECO Energy HT Electric Tariff<br />

Appendix E – ECM#1-10 Reference Data<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 1 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

REPORT DISCLAIMER<br />

The in<strong>for</strong>mation contained within this <strong>report</strong>, including any attachment(s), is intended solely <strong>for</strong><br />

use by the named addressee(s). If you are not the intended recipient, or a person designated as<br />

responsible <strong>for</strong> delivering such messages to the intended recipient, you are not authorized to<br />

disclose, copy, distribute or retain this <strong>report</strong>, in whole or in part, without written authorization<br />

from Concord Engineering Group, Inc., 520 S. Burnt Mill Road, Voorhees, NJ 08043. If you<br />

have received this <strong>report</strong> in error, please notify the sender immediately. Thank you <strong>for</strong> your<br />

cooperation.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 2 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY<br />

This <strong>report</strong> presents the findings of the <strong>energy</strong> <strong>audit</strong> conducted <strong>for</strong>:<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

1101 Arch Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA 19107<br />

Contact Person:<br />

Title:<br />

Facility Contact Person:<br />

Title:<br />

James Lewis<br />

General Manager<br />

Bob Lester<br />

Engineering Director<br />

The average annual <strong>energy</strong> costs at this facility are as follows:<br />

Electricity $ 2,125,602<br />

Natural Gas $ 869,915<br />

Total $ 2,995,517<br />

The <strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> has requested Concord Engineering Group to per<strong>for</strong>m an<br />

<strong>energy</strong> <strong>audit</strong> on its facility. The purpose of this <strong>energy</strong> <strong>audit</strong> is to provide a benchmark <strong>audit</strong> to<br />

be used as guide when considering future changes to the building to improve <strong>energy</strong> efficiency.<br />

The goals of PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> is to establish baseline <strong>energy</strong> usage profiles and<br />

recommended <strong>energy</strong> conservation measures (ECMs) in order to understand the building’s<br />

overall potential and costs associated with <strong>energy</strong> and cost reduction improvements. The<br />

potential annual <strong>energy</strong> cost savings <strong>for</strong> each ECM included in this <strong>report</strong> is shown below in<br />

Table 1.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 3 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Table 1<br />

Financial Summary Table<br />

The estimated demand and <strong>energy</strong> savings <strong>for</strong> each ECM and REM is shown below in Table 2.<br />

The descriptions in this table correspond to the ECM’s and REM’s listed in Table 1.<br />

ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES (ECM's)<br />

ECM NO.<br />

DESCRIPTION<br />

NET<br />

INSTALLATION<br />

COST<br />

ANNUAL<br />

SAVINGS A<br />

SIMPLE<br />

PAYBACK<br />

(Yrs)<br />

ECM #1 Condensing Boiler $239,431 $21,575 11.1<br />

ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade $812,365 $180,657 4.5<br />

ECM #3<br />

Lighting System Upgrade<br />

with Light Controls<br />

$114,400 $42,463 2.7<br />

ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller $499,938 $71,266 7.0<br />

ECM #5<br />

Centrifugal Chiller VFD<br />

Retrofit<br />

$632,500 $5,113 123.7<br />

ECM #6<br />

Demand Response<br />

Controls<br />

$68,850 $58,322 1.2<br />

ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls $102,190 $51,927 2.0<br />

ECM #8<br />

ECM #9<br />

ECM #10<br />

Notes:<br />

Domestic Water Booster<br />

Pump Package<br />

Chilled Water Thermal<br />

Ice Storage<br />

Demand Control<br />

Ventilation & VFD Fan<br />

$107,781 $5,328 20.2<br />

$969,813 $121,541 8.0<br />

$1,862,700 $417,721 4.5<br />

A. Savings takes into consideration applicable maintenance savings.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 4 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Table 2<br />

Estimated Energy Savings Summary Table<br />

ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES (ECM's)<br />

ANNUAL UTILITY REDUCTION<br />

ECM NO.<br />

DESCRIPTION<br />

ELECTRIC<br />

DEMAND<br />

(KW)<br />

ELECTRIC<br />

CONSUMPTION<br />

(KWH)<br />

NATURAL GAS<br />

(THERMS)<br />

ECM #1 Condensing Boiler 0.0 0 14,558<br />

ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade 451.6 1,415,945 0<br />

ECM #3<br />

Lighting System Upgrade with<br />

Light Controls<br />

134.1 317,736 0<br />

ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller -244.0 -344,164 96,513<br />

ECM #5<br />

Centrifugal Chiller VFD<br />

Retrofit<br />

-66.0 103,104 0<br />

ECM #6 Demand Response Controls 439.0 24,888 5,267<br />

ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls 0.0 232,391 17,656<br />

ECM #8<br />

ECM #9<br />

ECM #10<br />

Domestic Water Booster Pump<br />

Package<br />

Chilled Water Thermal Ice<br />

Storage<br />

Demand Control Ventilation &<br />

VFD Fan Control<br />

-244.0 -111,773 114,169<br />

0.0 0 5,283<br />

-244.0 -111773.0 119452.0<br />

The PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> has proven to be a facility with very large potential <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong><br />

conservation improvements. The ECMs above represent a wide range of applications <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong><br />

and cost savings. Some ECMs are mutually exclusive and require evaluation when implemented<br />

together. Most ECM savings are not simply additive due to their interrelation with one another.<br />

When considering a combined package, the most advantageous ECMs should be evaluated<br />

together to determine the packaged savings and overall benefit. It is important to consider the<br />

operating characteristics of each ECM and potential benefits and drawbacks.<br />

A. ONE FOR ONE REPLACEMENT ECMs<br />

ECMs such as Condensing Boiler, Light Retrofits, Kitchen Exhaust Controls, and Domestic<br />

Water Booster Pump Package, are straight <strong>for</strong>ward options with savings based on efficiency<br />

increases. These ECMs are more easily comparable through the <strong>energy</strong> savings and up-front<br />

costs. The straight <strong>for</strong>ward, one <strong>for</strong> one style ECMs that provide very favorable paybacks<br />

include:<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 5 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

• ECM #2: Lighting System Upgrade<br />

• ECM #7: Kitchen Exhaust Controls<br />

These ECMs provide less disputable savings with more firm installation costs. The simple<br />

paybacks <strong>for</strong> both ECMs are within 5 years making them a priority <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> savings at the<br />

<strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>.<br />

A lighting system retrofit is a must at this facility. The <strong>energy</strong> use from the incandescent fixtures<br />

and T-12 fluorescent tubes is extremely high. The <strong>energy</strong> use due to the inefficiency of the<br />

fixtures is compounded by the lighting levels which are far above today’s standards (based on<br />

ASHRAE’s Energy Standard 90.1-2007). Replacement of the 4 lamp T-12 fixtures to 2 lamp T-8<br />

fixtures will allow a slight decrease in overall light output (31%) with a large reduction in power<br />

consumption (70%). In addition to the fluorescent fixtures, the 90 watt incandescent bulbs<br />

throughout the facility are proposed to be replaced with LED bulbs. The one <strong>for</strong> one replacement<br />

of 90W down lights with LED down lights provides equal light output with a 73% reduction in<br />

power, and overall savings on maintenance costs.<br />

Kitchen exhaust controls provide the ability to limit the quantity of exhausted air through the<br />

building’s two large commercial kitchens. This ECM provides control of the kitchen exhaust<br />

fans through variable speed drives and limits the exhaust air through the large kitchen hoods<br />

automatically when the kitchen equipment is not being used. This ECM not only provides<br />

savings through the exhaust fan <strong>energy</strong> but also through the <strong>energy</strong> required to make up the<br />

kitchen air in the heating and cooling seasons. Due to the operational hours of the kitchen, this<br />

ECM provides a very short payback of approximately 2 years.<br />

B. OPERATIONAL ECMs<br />

ECMs such as the Lighting Controls, Supplemental Chiller, Demand Response Controls, Chilled<br />

Water Thermal Ice Storage, and Demand Control Ventilation & VFD Fan Control, are more<br />

complex with respect to the building’s operational requirements. These ECMs can provide great<br />

savings, however they are heavily dependent on the existing operating assumptions and proposed<br />

changes. For example implementation of a thermal ice storage system has the potential to<br />

significantly reduce electrical utility costs by reducing on peak demand, however the savings is<br />

greatly impacted by how and when the thermal <strong>energy</strong> is stored and discharged. Incorrect<br />

implementation of these types of ECMs can even increase utility costs. The more complex<br />

operational ECMs have shown to save considerable operating costs based on the existing and<br />

proposed assumptions within the <strong>report</strong>. The ECMs that provide very favorable paybacks<br />

include:<br />

• ECM #3: Lighting Controls (combined with the Lighting Retrofit)<br />

• ECM #4: Supplemental Chiller<br />

• ECM #6: Demand Response Controls<br />

• ECM #9: Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 6 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

• ECM #10: Demand Control Ventilation and VFD Fan Control<br />

These ECMs are more subject to interpretation and more affected by changes in the building<br />

operations. The simple paybacks <strong>for</strong> all ECMs listed above are within 10 years, and should be<br />

strongly considered <strong>for</strong> implementation.<br />

Lighting controls were evaluated as an additional measure included with the lighting system<br />

retrofit. As detailed in the ECM section of this <strong>report</strong>, the control savings are based on a 20%<br />

average savings <strong>for</strong> facilities with controls over facilities without. Based on interviews and<br />

witnessing the lighting operation throughout the building, it is estimated that 20% light <strong>energy</strong><br />

savings is a conservative approach. The implementation of lighting controls in combination with<br />

the lighting system retrofit decreases the lighting system retrofit payback period by<br />

approximately 1.7 years.<br />

Demand response controls is one of the most versatile ECMs available <strong>for</strong> the facility. This ECM<br />

takes advantage of the central plant’s ability to switch chilled water production from electric to<br />

gas as it pleases to limit excess KW usage. The controls and equipment required <strong>for</strong> this ECM<br />

are extremely minimal along with the upfront costs, and the potential savings are great. As<br />

detailed below in section IV, Energy Conservation Measures, this approach utilizes fuel<br />

switching to ensure a limit on the maximum annual building demand. The result is substantially<br />

reduced utility costs. The demand response controls allow <strong>for</strong> the entire savings simply through<br />

the alteration of the central plant <strong>for</strong> only a few weeks in the summer. This ECM gives the PA<br />

<strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> the best tools available to lower operating costs as well as procure low<br />

electric <strong>energy</strong> utility rates in the future open <strong>energy</strong> market.<br />

The supplemental chiller option allows the building to utilize electric driven chilled water<br />

production <strong>for</strong> all part loads in the building. Currently, the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> uses<br />

absorption chillers to provide the majority of the part load chilled water production. It has been<br />

shown that the cost <strong>for</strong> making chilled water through the natural gas absorption chillers is<br />

approximately 3 times more expensive than the electric chillers. The supplemental chiller will<br />

enable the facility to eliminate operation of the absorption chillers <strong>for</strong> part load cooling. The<br />

savings in gas cost more than pays <strong>for</strong> the increase in electric cost along with the installation in<br />

approximately 7 years. This ECM also gives the facility additional redundancy on the plant<br />

cooling side.<br />

Chilled water thermal ice storage is similar to the supplemental chiller ECM however, the work<br />

of the additional chiller would be dedicated to making ice during off peak periods to be utilized<br />

during on peak, high load, conditions. The thermal storage provides similar advantages to the<br />

demand control in that it limits peak demand in order to save on utility costs. Although the<br />

overall electric consumption is increased, the shifting of on peak to off peak usage saves enough<br />

on utility costs to pay <strong>for</strong> the entire installation in approximately 8 years. Since the thermal<br />

storage system contributes to demand reduction as well as natural gas reduction, the annual<br />

savings is approximately 70% percent greater than the savings from the supplemental chiller<br />

alone. This equates to more profitability in the long run compared to the supplemental chiller<br />

ECM.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 7 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

The demand control ventilation ECM is the largest potential reduction in <strong>energy</strong> use of any other<br />

ECM evaluated. The occupancy in the facility ranges from approximately a dozen people to over<br />

50,000 people during large conventions. The quantity of occupants requires extreme amounts of<br />

outside air to be introduced <strong>for</strong> ventilation. The existing system does not adjust ventilation based<br />

on actual occupancy and there<strong>for</strong>e introduces the same outside air percentage when there is a<br />

small event or a large event. Demand control ventilation allows the building to reduce outside air<br />

to only the amount needed at any given time. The <strong>energy</strong> savings of this ECM is due to the<br />

reduction of <strong>energy</strong> needed <strong>for</strong> heating and cooling coils in the air handling units through the<br />

building. The majority of the savings is in the heating season; however there is still valuable<br />

savings in the summer months as well. This ECM is very dependent on the estimation of the<br />

current outside air percentage that exists today. The input data should be verified through testing<br />

and balancing prior to its implementation.<br />

C. OPERATIONAL CHANGES:<br />

In addition to the ECMs, there are maintenance and operational measures that can provide<br />

significant <strong>energy</strong> savings and provide immediate benefit. The ECMs listed above represent<br />

investments that can be made to the facility which are justified by the savings seen overtime.<br />

However, the maintenance items and operational changes below are typically achievable with on<br />

site staff or maintenance contractors and in turn have the potential to provide substantial<br />

operational savings compared to the costs associated. The following are recommendations which<br />

should be considered a priority in achieving an <strong>energy</strong> efficient building:<br />

• “Lights Out” Initiative Program - In lieu of installation of a central lighting control<br />

system with occupancy sensors throughout the building, there is substantial <strong>energy</strong><br />

savings available simply by making the staff more active in <strong>energy</strong> reduction. Lighting<br />

throughout the facility is often left on in unoccupied spaces and could very easily be<br />

turned off without any compromise to operations.<br />

• Chiller Plant Optimization – The electric centrifugal chillers should be utilized as the<br />

first stage of cooling where ever possible. As shown in the supplemental chiller ECM, the<br />

savings seen by utilizing the electric chillers over the absorption chillers decreases the<br />

operating cost to produce chilled water by 3 times over. The existing chillers without any<br />

modification have the capability to modulate down to 15-20% reliably. Below this<br />

capacity the chiller will cycle on and off to meet load. It is beneficial to limit cycling of<br />

large chilled water equipment however not utilizing the low capacity potential of the<br />

chillers results in high gas utility costs. If low capacity operation results in unreliable<br />

operation of the chillers, then servicing of the equipment is needed and the equipment<br />

vendor should be contacted to provide service.<br />

• Retro Commissioning - The facility is primarily conditioned with large air handling units<br />

equipped with VAV boxes and large outside air dampers <strong>for</strong> ventilation. These systems<br />

are prone to loosing calibration failing. The result of outside air dampers stuck open or<br />

not closing fully during unoccupied periods can be a major contributor to <strong>energy</strong><br />

consumption. Commissioning will ensure all systems are operating correctly as well as<br />

provide valuable data <strong>for</strong> base-lining the building’s <strong>energy</strong> use.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 8 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

D. FUTURE LIGHTING CONSIDERATIONS:<br />

Lighting technologies are continuously changing <strong>for</strong> the better. Compact fluorescent fixtures and<br />

LED lighting have become the standard in the industry <strong>for</strong> low and medium lighting needs. The<br />

existing lighting throughout the main convention halls is primarily high bay metal halide<br />

fixtures. The downfall of these fixtures is the color and overall light quality combined with the<br />

slow warm up and re-strikes characteristics. Relatively new to the industry are high powered<br />

compact fluorescent bulbs and LED fixtures. These fixtures and bulb replacements are intended<br />

to become the standard <strong>for</strong> high output lighting retrofits. These fixtures are not capable of<br />

replacing high bay metal halide fixture such as the 400 watt and 1000 watt fixtures in the exhibit<br />

halls. The technology however is evolving in this direction and soon could prove to be an ideal<br />

solution <strong>for</strong> these types of spaces.<br />

E. CONCLUSION:<br />

Overall, CEG is pleased to present the findings of the <strong>energy</strong> <strong>audit</strong> and subsequent <strong>energy</strong><br />

calculations in order to provide a whole building approach to <strong>energy</strong> saving opportunities at the<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>. The opportunities uncovered have shown to be impressive with respect<br />

to <strong>energy</strong> and cost savings. We expect moving <strong>for</strong>ward with large scale <strong>energy</strong> upgrades as<br />

described in this <strong>report</strong> will be very profitable and allow the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> to become a new<br />

symbol in Philadelphia.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 9 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

II.<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

The <strong>energy</strong> <strong>audit</strong> is intended to provide a benchmark <strong>audit</strong> <strong>for</strong> the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>. It is<br />

expected to be used as guide <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> efficiency improvements available <strong>for</strong> the facility. The<br />

process to establish a facilities baseline includes a variety of resources and in<strong>for</strong>mation gathering<br />

tools. The following is an outline <strong>for</strong> the process utilized <strong>for</strong> this facility:<br />

Electrical and natural gas utility in<strong>for</strong>mation is collected and analyzed <strong>for</strong> three full year’s <strong>energy</strong><br />

use of the building. The utility in<strong>for</strong>mation allows <strong>for</strong> analysis of the building’s operational<br />

characteristics; calculate <strong>energy</strong> benchmarks <strong>for</strong> comparison to industry averages, estimated<br />

savings potential, and baseline usage/cost to monitor the effectiveness of implemented measures.<br />

A computer spreadsheet is used to calculate benchmarks and to graph utility in<strong>for</strong>mation (see the<br />

utility profiles below).<br />

The Energy Use Index (EUI) is established <strong>for</strong> the building. Energy Use Index (EUI) is<br />

expressed in British Thermal Units/square foot/year (BTU/ft 2 /yr), which is used to compare<br />

<strong>energy</strong> consumption to similar building types or to track consumption from year to year in the<br />

same building. The EUI is calculated by converting the annual consumption of all <strong>energy</strong><br />

sources to BTU’s and dividing by the area (gross square footage) of the building. Blueprints<br />

(where available) are utilized to verify the gross area of the facility. The EUI is a good indicator<br />

of the relative potential <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> savings. A low EUI indicates less potential <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong><br />

savings, while a high EUI indicates poor building per<strong>for</strong>mance there<strong>for</strong>e a high potential <strong>for</strong><br />

<strong>energy</strong> savings.<br />

Existing building architectural and engineering drawings are analyzed <strong>for</strong> additional background<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation. The building envelope, lighting systems, HVAC equipment, and controls<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation gathered from building drawings allow <strong>for</strong> a more accurate and detailed review of<br />

the building. The in<strong>for</strong>mation is compared to the <strong>energy</strong> usage profiles developed from utility<br />

data. Through the review of the architectural and engineering drawings a building profile is<br />

defined that documents building age, type, usage, major <strong>energy</strong> consuming equipment or<br />

systems, etc.<br />

The preliminary <strong>audit</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mation is gathered in preparation <strong>for</strong> the site survey. The site survey<br />

provides critical in<strong>for</strong>mation in deciphering where <strong>energy</strong> is spent and opportunities exist within<br />

a facility. The entire site is surveyed to inventory the following to gain an understanding of how<br />

each facility operates:<br />

• Building envelope (roof, windows, etc.)<br />

• Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning equipment (HVAC)<br />

• Lighting systems and controls<br />

• Operation and occupancy schedules<br />

• Facility-specific equipment<br />

The building site visit is per<strong>for</strong>med to survey all major building components and systems. The<br />

site visit includes detailed inspection of <strong>energy</strong> consuming components. Summary of building<br />

occupancy schedules, operating and maintenance practices, and <strong>energy</strong> management programs<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 10 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

provided by the building manager are collected along with the system and components to<br />

determine a more accurate impact on <strong>energy</strong> consumption.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 11 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

III.<br />

METHOD OF ANALYSIS<br />

A. ANALYSIS AND GENERAL DESCRIPTION:<br />

Post site visit work includes evaluation of the in<strong>for</strong>mation gathered, researching possible<br />

conservation opportunities, organizing the <strong>audit</strong> into a comprehensive <strong>report</strong>, and making<br />

recommendations on HVAC, lighting and building envelope improvements. Data collected is<br />

processed using <strong>energy</strong> engineering calculations and <strong>energy</strong> modeling to anticipate <strong>energy</strong> usage<br />

<strong>for</strong> each of the proposed <strong>energy</strong> conservation measures (ECMs). The actual building’s <strong>energy</strong><br />

usage is entered directly from the utility bills provided by the owner. The anticipated <strong>energy</strong><br />

usage is compared to the historical data to determine <strong>energy</strong> savings <strong>for</strong> the proposed ECMs.<br />

It is pertinent to note, that the savings noted in this <strong>report</strong> are not additive. The savings <strong>for</strong> each<br />

recommendation is calculated as standalone <strong>energy</strong> conservation measures. The intent of this<br />

<strong>audit</strong> is to compare each ECM to the baseline conditions and existing operational characteristics.<br />

Implementation of more than one ECM may in some cases affect the savings of each ECM. The<br />

savings may in some cases be relatively higher if an individual ECM is implemented in lieu of<br />

multiple recommended ECMs. For example implementing reduced operating schedules <strong>for</strong><br />

inefficient lighting will result in a greater relative savings. Implementing reduced operating<br />

schedules <strong>for</strong> newly installed efficient lighting will result in a lower relative savings, because<br />

there is less <strong>energy</strong> used by the more efficiency fixtures. If multiple ECM’s are recommended to<br />

be combined <strong>for</strong> a specific ECM implementation, the combined savings is calculated and<br />

identified appropriately.<br />

ECMs are determined by identifying the building’s unique properties and deciphering the most<br />

beneficial <strong>energy</strong> saving measures available that meet the specific needs of the facility. The<br />

building construction type, function, operational schedule, existing conditions, and <strong>for</strong>eseen<br />

future plans are critical in the evaluation and final recommendations. Energy savings are<br />

calculated base on industry standard methods and engineering estimations. Energy consumption<br />

is calculated based on manufacturer’s cataloged in<strong>for</strong>mation when new equipment is proposed.<br />

B. ECM COST CALCULATION DESCRIPTION:<br />

Cost savings are calculated based on the actual historical <strong>energy</strong> costs <strong>for</strong> the facility. Installation<br />

costs include labor and equipment costs to estimate the full up-front investment required to<br />

implement a change. Costs are derived from Means Cost Data, industry publications, and local<br />

contractors and equipment suppliers. Maintenance savings are calculated where applicable and<br />

added to the <strong>energy</strong> savings <strong>for</strong> each ECM. The life-time <strong>for</strong> each ECM is estimated based on the<br />

typical life of the equipment being replaced or altered. The costs and savings are applied and a<br />

simple payback, Internal Rate of Return and Net Present Value is calculated. See below <strong>for</strong><br />

calculation equations:<br />

The evaluations are based on engineering estimations and industry standard calculation methods.<br />

Pricing in<strong>for</strong>mation is based on budgetary equipment pricing and estimated labor costs. More<br />

detailed cost analyses require, hard equipment specifications, and contractor bid pricing. Due to<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 12 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

the changes in pricing based on location and other market driven factors, the installation<br />

engineering estimate included in this <strong>report</strong> should not be used <strong>for</strong> final budgetary numbers.<br />

C. ENERGY MODELING CALCULATION DESCRIPTION:<br />

The ECM <strong>energy</strong> calculations and results are provided by excel calculation programs and <strong>energy</strong><br />

modeling software when applicable. The modeling software utilized is the comprehensive <strong>energy</strong><br />

analysis software by Trane (software model - Trace 700 ver. 6.2.4). The <strong>energy</strong> savings or loss<br />

<strong>for</strong> each ECM is established based on an existing building model (baseline building) and<br />

compared to the proposed building model. The net difference between the two models<br />

establishes the <strong>energy</strong> savings or loss <strong>for</strong> each ECM.<br />

Historical utility data is average <strong>for</strong> the three previous years (2006-2008) and used to set the<br />

baseline utility in<strong>for</strong>mation. The net difference between the existing and proposed models is<br />

subtracted from (or added to) the baseline utility in<strong>for</strong>mation. This final annual <strong>energy</strong> profile<br />

establishes the expected utility usage <strong>for</strong> the building based on the implementation of the ECM.<br />

D. ELECTRIC COST CALCULATION DESCRIPTION:<br />

The net utility usage and demand profile is applied to an <strong>energy</strong> cost calculator. The calculations<br />

are per<strong>for</strong>med according to the utility tariff Peco, rate HT service. The calculation <strong>for</strong> electric<br />

utility costs includes the following:<br />

• Meter Charge<br />

• Estimated Tax Rebate<br />

• Demand charge (KW)<br />

• 80% Demand Ratchet applied to the previous and remain non summer months<br />

• Floating cut-off usage (KWH) charges (Tiered rate structure.) Usage cut-offs based on<br />

the current month’s billed demand<br />

• On Peak Usage charge and Off Peak Usage credit adjusted <strong>for</strong> Summer and Winter<br />

• Night Rider service allowance <strong>for</strong> off peak demand credit.<br />

The resulting electric cost is shown in the “Savings Calculations” in the Energy Savings<br />

Calculations <strong>for</strong> each applicable ECM.<br />

E. GAS COST CALCULATION DESCRIPTION:<br />

The gas utility costs are calculated based on the latest average year’s utility pricing. The average<br />

cost per Therm of natural gas is applied to the proposed ECM <strong>energy</strong> savings to establish the<br />

cost savings. The resulting natural gas cost is shown in the “Savings Calculations” in the Energy<br />

Savings Calculations <strong>for</strong> each applicable ECM.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 13 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

F. ECM FINANCIAL CALCULATION EQUATIONS:<br />

The following equations are utilized <strong>for</strong> the financial models included <strong>for</strong> each ECM calculation.<br />

The ECM summary and financial in<strong>for</strong>mation is shown in the ECM Cost and Savings<br />

Breakdown Appendix.<br />

Simple<br />

Payback<br />

⎛ Net Cost<br />

= ⎜<br />

⎝ Yearly Savings<br />

⎞<br />

⎟<br />

⎠<br />

Internal<br />

Rate of<br />

Re turn<br />

=<br />

N<br />

∑<br />

⎛ Cash Flow of<br />

⎜<br />

⎝<br />

n=<br />

0 1<br />

( + IRR )<br />

Period<br />

n<br />

⎞<br />

⎟<br />

⎠<br />

Net<br />

Pr esent Value<br />

=<br />

N<br />

∑<br />

⎛ Cash Flow of<br />

⎜<br />

⎝<br />

n=<br />

0 1<br />

( + DR)<br />

Period<br />

n<br />

⎞<br />

⎟<br />

⎠<br />

Net Present Value calculations based on Interest Rate of 3%.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 14 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

IV.<br />

HISTORIC ENERGY CONSUMPTION/COST<br />

A. BASELINE ENERGY USAGE<br />

The <strong>energy</strong> usage <strong>for</strong> the facility has been tabulated and plotted in graph <strong>for</strong>m as depicted within<br />

this section. Each <strong>energy</strong> source has been identified and monthly consumption and cost noted<br />

per the in<strong>for</strong>mation provided by the Owner.<br />

The electric usage profile represents the actual electrical usage <strong>for</strong> the facility. PECO Energy<br />

provides electricity to the facility under its High Tension rate structure. The electric utility<br />

measures consumption in kilowatt-hours (KWH) and maximum demand in kilowatts (KW)<br />

during On and Off Peak. One KWH usage is equivalent to 1000 watts running <strong>for</strong> one hour. One<br />

KW of electric demand is equivalent to 1000 watts running at any given time. Detailed<br />

description of the utility rate structure is below in the facility description. Rates used in this<br />

<strong>report</strong> reflect the historical data received <strong>for</strong> the facility.<br />

The gas usage profile shows the actual natural gas <strong>energy</strong> usage <strong>for</strong> the facility. Public Gas<br />

Works (PGW) provides natural gas to the facility under the Interruptible Transportation rate<br />

structure. Gas is also supplied to the facility <strong>for</strong> commercial kitchen uses through the General<br />

Service rate structure. The gas utility measures consumption in cubic feet x 100 (CCF), and<br />

converts the quantity into Therms of <strong>energy</strong>. One Therm is equivalent to 100,000 BTUs of<br />

<strong>energy</strong>.<br />

The overall cost <strong>for</strong> electric utilities is calculated by an <strong>energy</strong> cost calculator modeled<br />

specifically <strong>for</strong> PECO’s HT rate structure. The average cost <strong>for</strong> electric usage is calculated by<br />

dividing the total cost by the total usage (KWH). The cost <strong>for</strong> natural gas utilities is based on the<br />

utility history provided <strong>for</strong> the most recent year’s data. The average cost <strong>for</strong> natural gas is<br />

calculated by dividing the total cost by the total usage (Therms). The average cost <strong>for</strong> the two<br />

major sources of <strong>energy</strong> (Electric & Gas) at this facility are as follows:<br />

Description<br />

Electricity<br />

Natural Gas<br />

Average<br />

11.1¢ / KWH<br />

$1.482 / Therm<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 15 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Table 3<br />

Electric Utility Data<br />

AVERAGED ELECTRIC UTILITY HISTORY (BASELINE)<br />

Month<br />

On Peak Off Peak<br />

On Peak Off Peak Billed<br />

Total Use<br />

Use Use<br />

Demand Demand Demand<br />

Total Cost Rate<br />

KWH KWH KWH KW KW KW $ $/KWH<br />

Jan 579,366 1,123,695 1,703,061 4,062.3 4,140.7 4,231.4 $171,384 $0.101<br />

Feb 671,002 1,168,981 1,839,982 4,585.7 4,429.8 4,585.7 $185,764 $0.101<br />

Mar 625,365 1,011,698 1,637,063 4,614.5 4,768.1 4,614.5 $180,565 $0.110<br />

Apr 522,462 838,766 1,361,228 3,689.6 3,886.4 4,231.4 $161,329 $0.119<br />

May 598,150 968,869 1,567,020 4,603.2 3,996.9 4,603.2 $178,097 $0.114<br />

Jun 703,863 1,007,045 1,710,908 4,849.5 4,572.9 4,849.5 $192,215 $0.112<br />

Jul 758,086 1,159,560 1,917,646 5,289.3 4,728.1 5,289.3 $211,018 $0.110<br />

Aug 617,682 870,013 1,487,695 4,663.9 4,126.3 4,663.9 $179,857 $0.121<br />

Sep 612,934 918,926 1,531,860 3,787.1 3,607.9 4,231.4 $168,822 $0.110<br />

Oct 580,605 966,410 1,547,014 3,929.6 4,051.2 4,231.4 $166,911 $0.108<br />

Nov 561,816 1,049,996 1,611,812 3,892.8 3,497.6 4,231.4 $168,690 $0.105<br />

Dec 494,589 857,632 1,352,221 2,776.0 2,721.6 4,231.4 $160,951 $0.119<br />

Total / Max 7,325,919 11,941,591 19,267,510 5,289 4,768 5,289 $2,125,602 $0.111<br />

Figure 1<br />

Electricity Usage Profile<br />

2,500,000<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Average Electric Usage & Demand Profile<br />

Jan-06 through Dec-08<br />

8000<br />

2,000,000<br />

7000<br />

Usage (kWh)<br />

1,500,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

6000<br />

5000<br />

4000<br />

Demand (kW)<br />

500,000<br />

3000<br />

0<br />

2000<br />

Month<br />

Usage KWH<br />

Demand KW<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 16 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Table 4<br />

Natural Gas Billing Data<br />

MOST RECENT NATURAL GAS UTILITY HISTORY (BASELINE)<br />

Month Usage Delivery Cost Supply Cost Total Cost Rate<br />

Therms $ $ $ $/Therm<br />

Jun 10,189 $959 $16,017 $16,975 $1.666<br />

Jul 11,308 $4,160 $21,013 $25,173 $2.226<br />

Aug 19,955 $7,169 $24,820 $31,989 $1.603<br />

Sep 21,887 $7,842 $23,668 $31,509 $1.440<br />

Oct 37,513 $13,279 $38,219 $51,499 $1.373<br />

Nov 52,381 $18,454 $59,678 $78,131 $1.492<br />

Dec 72,105 $21,415 $86,357 $107,772 $1.495<br />

Jan 109,391 $32,489 $124,351 $156,840 $1.434<br />

Feb 87,482 $39,387 $99,285 $138,672 $1.585<br />

Mar 79,641 $28,736 $86,288 $115,024 $1.444<br />

Apr 46,069 $16,718 $50,039 $66,756 $1.449<br />

May 39,098 $14,222 $35,352 $49,574 $1.268<br />

Total 587,017 $204,830 $665,086 $869,915 $1.482<br />

Figure 2<br />

Natural Gas Usage Profile<br />

120,000<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Gas Usage Profile<br />

Jun-08 through May-09<br />

100,000<br />

80,000<br />

Usage (Therms)<br />

60,000<br />

40,000<br />

20,000<br />

0<br />

Month<br />

Therms<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 17 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

B. TARIFF ANALYSIS:<br />

Electric Utility<br />

Electrical <strong>energy</strong> is purchased from PECO Energy under its High Tension (13.2KV) electric<br />

service rate. Electrical power is supplied by two service lines and two sets of usage and demand<br />

meters (one set <strong>for</strong> each supply line). The electric utility costs include the following charges:<br />

• Meter Charge<br />

• Estimated Tax Rebate<br />

• Demand charge (KW)<br />

• 80% Demand Ratchet applied to the previous and remain non summer months<br />

• Floating cut-off usage (KWH) charges (Tiered rate structure.) Usage cut-offs based on<br />

the current month’s billed demand<br />

• On Peak Usage charge and Off Peak Usage credit adjusted <strong>for</strong> Summer and Winter<br />

• Night Rider service allowance <strong>for</strong> off peak demand credit.<br />

The meter charge and tax rebate are minimal charges per electric bill. The demand charges are<br />

calculated based on the maximum demand measured per month at $7.13 / KW. The billed<br />

demand is established based on an 80% ratchet structure. The ratchet sets a minimum billing<br />

demand value not less than 80% of the highest measured demand during the summer months<br />

June through September. The billed demand is charged at the 80% ratchet or actual measured<br />

demand whichever is greater.<br />

Electric usage is charged based on a floating cut-off (tiered) rate structure. The tiers are broken<br />

down as follows (Pricing below is representative of the latest utility bill pricing):<br />

• 1 st Tier - $0.0932 / KWH<br />

• 2 nd Tier - $0.0618 / KWH<br />

• 3 rd Tier - $0.0308 . /KWH<br />

The total measured usage (KWH) is applied over the three tiers based on the billed demand <strong>for</strong><br />

each month. The billed demand is multiplied a set value of hours (150 hrs) <strong>for</strong> each tier to<br />

establish the portion of electric usage charged at each tier. The calculated usage is applied to the<br />

upper (1 st ) tier first, with the same usage applied to the middle (2 nd ) tier, and remaining usage is<br />

applied to the bottom tier. Tiers are filled based on the calculated usage until all electric usage<br />

has been charged. The higher the billed demand, the larger portion of the usage is applied to the<br />

upper tiers (more costly tiers), and the remaining usage is applied to the lower tiers (less costly<br />

tiers). The floating cut-off structure is designed to “tax” the users that use <strong>energy</strong> all at once,<br />

versus the users that use <strong>energy</strong> spread out. Higher billed demand with the same overall usage<br />

will increase the usage costs.<br />

The HT rate structure includes “On Peak” and “Off Peak” charges and discounts as well as an<br />

optional “Night Rider Service.” The On Peak charge is a seasonally changing increase per KWH<br />

that is applied <strong>for</strong> all electrical usage that is consumed during on peak. The Off Peak credit is<br />

fixed reduction per KWH that is applied <strong>for</strong> all electrical usage that is consumed during Off<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 18 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Peak. Off Peak hours are defined as all hours that are not On Peak. The On Peak schedule is as<br />

follows:<br />

8AM through 8PM on weekdays (except Friday only to 4PM)<br />

The building also utilizes the optional Night Rider Service. This service allows <strong>for</strong> Off Peak<br />

demand to be ignored <strong>for</strong> the purposes of billed demand. Only on peak demand is measured and<br />

calculated <strong>for</strong> billing purposes even if Off Peak demand is greater. The Night Rider provides<br />

<strong>for</strong>giveness <strong>for</strong> buildings with higher Off Peak usage, since the utility company typically is<br />

experiencing lower electric load. The Off Peak usage <strong>for</strong>giveness is bound by upper and lower<br />

contractual limitations.<br />

Natural Gas Utility<br />

Natural Gas is purchased from a third party supplier UGI Energy Services Inc. (UGI). The gas is<br />

delivered through PGW at three separate meters. One meter serves the main kitchen. A second<br />

meter serves the 2 nd floor retail restaurant. Both of the facility cooking meters are billed under<br />

the standard commercial service rate. The third gas meter is the primary meter <strong>for</strong> the building’s<br />

central heating and cooling plants. The utility rate structure <strong>for</strong> the third meter is the<br />

“Interruptible Rate” structure available through UGI. The Interruptible rate structure allows the<br />

utility company to request the facility to shut down its gas usage in times of very high demand.<br />

The cost <strong>for</strong> natural gas is reduced from the typical rate <strong>for</strong> this flexibility. Natural gas is used <strong>for</strong><br />

the gas fired absorption chillers and gas fired boilers. In the event of gas interruption, the facility<br />

utilizes stored #2 heating oil as the fuel source.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 19 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

C. ENERGY USE INDEX (EUI):<br />

Energy Use Index (EUI) also known as “Energy Use Intensity,” is a measure of a building’s<br />

annual <strong>energy</strong> utilization per square foot of building. This calculation is completed by<br />

converting all utility usage consumed by a building <strong>for</strong> one year, to British Thermal Units (BTU)<br />

and dividing this number by the building square footage. EUI is a good measure of a building’s<br />

<strong>energy</strong> use and is utilized regularly <strong>for</strong> comparison of <strong>energy</strong> per<strong>for</strong>mance <strong>for</strong> similar building<br />

types. The Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) Buildings Technology <strong>Center</strong> under a<br />

contract with the U.S. Department of Energy maintains a Benchmarking Building Energy<br />

Per<strong>for</strong>mance Program. The ORNL website determines how a building’s <strong>energy</strong> use compares<br />

with similar facilities throughout the U.S. and in a specific region or state.<br />

Source use differs from site usage when comparing a building’s <strong>energy</strong> consumption with the<br />

national average. Site <strong>energy</strong> use is the <strong>energy</strong> consumed by the building at the building site<br />

only. Source <strong>energy</strong> use includes the site <strong>energy</strong> use as well as all of the losses to create and<br />

distribute the <strong>energy</strong> to the building. Source <strong>energy</strong> represents the total amount of raw fuel that is<br />

required to operate the building. It incorporates all transmission, delivery, and production losses,<br />

which allows <strong>for</strong> a complete assessment of <strong>energy</strong> efficiency in a building. The type of utility<br />

purchased has a substantial impact on the source <strong>energy</strong> use of a building. The EPA has<br />

determined that source <strong>energy</strong> is the most comparable unit <strong>for</strong> evaluation purposes and overall<br />

global impact. Both the site and source EUI ratings <strong>for</strong> the building are provided to understand<br />

and compare the differences in <strong>energy</strong> use.<br />

The site and source EUI <strong>for</strong> this facility is calculated as follows:<br />

Building<br />

Site EUI<br />

=<br />

( Electric Usage in kBtu + Gas Usage in kBtu)<br />

Building Square Footage<br />

Building<br />

Source<br />

( Electric Usage in kBtu X SS Ratio + Gas Usage in kBtu<br />

EUI =<br />

Building Square Footage<br />

X<br />

SS<br />

Ratio)<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 20 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Table 5<br />

Facility Energy Use Index (EUI) Calculation<br />

ENERGY USE INTENSITY CALCULATION<br />

SITE SITE-<br />

BUILDING USE<br />

ENERGY TYPE<br />

ENERGY SOURCE SOURCE ENERGY<br />

kWh Therms Gallons kBtu RATIO kBtu<br />

ELECTRIC 19267510.3 65,779,280 3.340 219,702,796<br />

NATURAL GAS 587016.8 58,701,677 1.047 61,460,656<br />

FUEL OIL 0.0 0 1.010 0<br />

PROPANE 0.0 0 1.010 0<br />

TOTAL 124,480,957 281,163,452<br />

*Site - Source Ratio data is provided by the Energy Star Per<strong>for</strong>mance Rating Methodology <strong>for</strong> Incorporating Source Energy Use document<br />

issued Dec 2007.<br />

BUILDING AREA 1,000,000 SQUARE FEET<br />

BUILDING SITE EUI 124.48 kBtu/SF/YR<br />

BUILDING % ELECTRIC 52.8%<br />

BUILDING SOURCE EUI 281.16 kBtu/SF/YR<br />

The EUI calculation shows the overall <strong>energy</strong> use of the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>. Based on the<br />

utility data above, the percent electric of the facility is approximately 53% which is typical <strong>for</strong><br />

public assemblies. The overall <strong>energy</strong> usage <strong>for</strong> the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> however, is<br />

approximately two times that of the average <strong>for</strong> public assemblies. For comparative purposes the<br />

2003 CBECS national average source EUI per<strong>for</strong>mance data <strong>for</strong> Social / Meeting: Meeting Hall,<br />

<strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> is shown below in Figure 3. Overall these comparisons represent a large<br />

potential <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> improvement at the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>.<br />

Figure 3<br />

Average Energy Use Intensities: Public Assembly<br />

2003 CBECS NATIONAL AVERAGE SOURCE ENERGY USE AND PERFORMANCE<br />

COMPARISONS BY BUILDING TYPE<br />

BUILDING USE<br />

DESCRIPTION<br />

Average Source EUI<br />

(Kbtu/SF)<br />

Average Percent<br />

Electric (%)<br />

Average Site EUI<br />

(Kbtu/SF)<br />

Public Assembly 143.0 57% 66.0<br />

Social / Meeting: Meeting<br />

Hall, <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

102.0 57% 52.0<br />

EUI data provided by EPA Energy Star <strong>for</strong> the Entertainment Industry Presentation<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 21 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

V. FACILITY DESCRIPTION<br />

A. GENERAL BUILDING CHARACTERISTICS<br />

The comprehensive <strong>energy</strong> <strong>audit</strong> covers the existing 624,000 SF <strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong><br />

<strong>Center</strong>. The <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> includes the following saleable spaces:<br />

440,000 SF of Exhibit Hall Space<br />

123,000 SF of Meeting Rooms & Banquet Space<br />

35,000 SF Grand Hall<br />

32,000 SF Ballroom<br />

In addition to the saleable space, the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> includes approximately 100,000 SF of<br />

entrance hallways as well as support spaces which serve the events. Support spaces include two<br />

full commercial kitchens, elevated loading dock, mechanical and electrical equipment rooms,<br />

event and staff storage spaces, maintenance shops, and security / engineering offices.<br />

This facility is the largest contiguous exhibit space in the Northeast. Currently underway is an<br />

expansion project <strong>for</strong> an additional 376,000 SF of exhibit halls, main floor area, ball room, and<br />

meeting rooms totaling approximately 1,000,000 SF of saleable floor space spanning three city<br />

blocks.<br />

Scheduling:<br />

Occupancy of the convention center is event dependent and changing throughout the seasons.<br />

The approximate schedules throughout the year are as follows:<br />

Summer:<br />

100% occupancy <strong>for</strong> 30% of days per month<br />

20% occupancy <strong>for</strong> 70% of days per month<br />

Fall - Spring: 50% occupancy <strong>for</strong> 65% of days per month<br />

20% occupancy <strong>for</strong> 35% of days per month<br />

The building construction is block walls with a brick façade. The roof construction is a steel<br />

supported barrel roof over the exhibit halls. The roof weatherproofing is made of a vinyl<br />

membrane. The main vestibule area of the roof is skylights. Windows throughout the facility are<br />

double pane glass supported by an aluminum curtain wall system. Windows in the train shed<br />

portion of the building are double pane windows with old painted wood frames.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 22 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

B. AIR SIDE SYSTEMS:<br />

Heating and cooling in the exhibit halls is provided by<br />

large air handling units (AHUs) with chilled water<br />

cooling coils and hot water heating coils. AHUs are<br />

operated manually from the building operators based on<br />

event needs <strong>for</strong> each hall / space. AHUs in the exhibit<br />

halls are large constant volume AHUs located on the<br />

North side of the building, outside on the upper level<br />

above the loading dock. The AHUs utilize chilled water<br />

and hot water coils fed from the central plant. The control<br />

valves are two-way control valves. The AHUs include<br />

outside air mixing boxes <strong>for</strong> ventilation and economizer<br />

control <strong>for</strong> “free cooling.” Occupied / Unoccupied operation <strong>for</strong> this facility is as follows:<br />

Picture #1 – Typical Exhibit Hall AHU<br />

Occupied mode: the AHUs provide conditioned air to the space and supply a constant minimum<br />

outside air quantity to the space <strong>for</strong> ventilation.<br />

Unoccupied mode: AHUs supply fans are turned off and only run to satisfy the unoccupied set<br />

back temperature set points of 85°F (summer), and 55°F (winter). Outside air dampers are<br />

closed. In extreme heat and humid conditions, AHUs are manually overridden to provide cooling<br />

in the summer to control humidity.<br />

The meeting rooms in the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> are conditioned with large variable air volume<br />

(VAV) air handling units. The meeting room AHUs provides variable volume supply air to<br />

downstream VAV boxes. VAV control is provided through inlet vane dampers in the AHUs. The<br />

AHUs fan speeds are constant. The control valves are two-way control valves. The AHUs<br />

include outside air mixing boxes <strong>for</strong> ventilation and economizer control <strong>for</strong> “free cooling.”<br />

The majority of the Terminal Market is independent of the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> regarding utilities<br />

with the exception of the kitchen make-up air handling unit. The kitchen make-up air handling<br />

unit operates continuously year round to make up the air exhausted by the kitchen exhaust hoods.<br />

This AHU preconditions the outside air with chilled water and heating water from the<br />

<strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> central plant.<br />

One AHU is dedicated <strong>for</strong> the building operations. This AHU operates continuously to provide<br />

cooling <strong>for</strong> the command center, offices, and housekeeping area.<br />

The computer room is conditioned by a dedicated computer room unit with chilled water cooling<br />

coil. This unit requires year round cooling and demands the central plant to be operating in<br />

cooling mode year round.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 23 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

C. CENTRAL COOLING PLANT:<br />

The facility has undergone a major mechanical systems<br />

upgrade in 2005. The major mechanical equipment<br />

including the centrifugal chillers, absorption chillers, and<br />

pumps were replaced in this upgrade. The facility has two<br />

1,700 Ton electric water cooled centrifugal chillers, and<br />

two 700 ton direct fired water cooled absorption chillers.<br />

The absorption chillers provide hot water in addition to<br />

chilled water in intermediate seasons where the building<br />

heating load is small.<br />

Picture #2 – Central Plant Typical<br />

Centrifugal Chiller<br />

Chilled water is pumped to the facility AHUs through a<br />

primary / secondary pumping system. Each chiller has a<br />

dedicated operating and standby primary chilled water<br />

pump that operates at constant flow. The secondary<br />

pumping system supplies chilled water to the AHUs with<br />

variable speed chilled water pumps. The secondary<br />

chilled water pumps are controlled by multiple<br />

differential pressure sensors in the chilled water piping<br />

loop that respond to the facilities chilled water flow<br />

needs.<br />

Picture #3 – Central Plant Typical<br />

Absorption Chiller<br />

The centrifugal electric chillers are only utilized in the<br />

summer months when the demand <strong>for</strong> chilled water is high. Under low load conditions the<br />

smaller absorption chillers are utilized due to the instability of the large centrifugal chillers at<br />

low load. The centrifugal chiller compressors are driven by single speed motors. The single<br />

speed drives limit the lower end operational capacity of the centrifugal chillers to approximately<br />

50% load. Below this load or approximately 900 tons, the building is required to utilize the<br />

absorption chillers <strong>for</strong> cooling. The hours of operation of the centrifugal chillers are very<br />

minimal due to this limitation. The centrifugal chillers<br />

are rarely utilized overnight even during the height of the<br />

cooling season.<br />

The chillers are cooled by three cooling towers (two<br />

cells each) on the mechanical room roof. The cooling<br />

towers are made by BAC. The mechanical upgrade did<br />

not include new cooling towers. The cooling tower fans<br />

include VFD drives <strong>for</strong> variable speed control. The<br />

existing cooling towers are in poor condition, however<br />

still adequate <strong>for</strong> the cooling load. Reliability of the<br />

cooling towers and leakage rate is continually reduced<br />

with age.<br />

Picture #4 – Central Plant Typical<br />

Cooling Tower Cells<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 24 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

D. CENTRAL HEATING PLANT<br />

The facility has undergone a major mechanical systems<br />

upgrade in 2005, which included the two central heating<br />

boilers. The boilers are 500 HP each supplying heating<br />

hot water to the facility. The boilers are 4 pass fire-tube<br />

Boilers made by Cleaver Brooks with 10 to 1 turndown.<br />

The boilers include the latest controls <strong>for</strong> combustion<br />

efficiency and low emission standards. The combustion<br />

air fan is a variable speed fan motor. The boilers produce<br />

heating hot water which is distributed throughout the<br />

facility by constant volume heating water pumps. Each<br />

boiler has a dedicated operating boiler water pump. The<br />

boilers are in excellent condition and well maintained.<br />

Picture #5 – Central Plant Typical Fire-<br />

Tube Boiler<br />

E. CONTROL SYSTEM<br />

The HVAC systems are controlled by a central DDC control system made by Siemens. The<br />

control system has the capability to automate the building’s operations, however due to the<br />

unpredictability of the convention center events and occupied / unoccupied schedules, the<br />

majority of the system and its major components are manually operated by the building<br />

operations personnel. The following system operations are manually controlled:<br />

• AHU Occ / Unocc fan operation<br />

• Chiller selection (centrifugal or absorption) based on low load conditions<br />

• Overriding cooling operation <strong>for</strong> humidity control<br />

• Peak demand load reduction strategies.<br />

The DDC system controls some of the facilities operations such as the economizer operation<br />

based on outside/return air enthalpy, operating / standby cycling <strong>for</strong> the chillers and pumps,<br />

boiler set point. The control system does not include a method <strong>for</strong> monitoring system <strong>energy</strong><br />

output or utility <strong>energy</strong> input usages.<br />

F. LIGHTING<br />

The lighting throughout the facility is a combination of<br />

metal halide fixtures, fluorescent T-12 fixtures with<br />

magnetic ballasts, and incandescent fixtures. Exhibit<br />

halls are lit with 1000W high bay metal halide fixtures.<br />

The ball rooms and meeting rooms are lit with<br />

fluorescent fixtures <strong>for</strong> general lighting and dimmable<br />

incandescent fixtures <strong>for</strong> presentation lighting. Hallways<br />

are lit with a combination of recessed incandescent<br />

fixtures <strong>for</strong> accent lighting, T-12 fluorescent fixtures, and<br />

recessed metal halide down lights <strong>for</strong> general lighting.<br />

The lighting is controlled by multiple control systems as<br />

follows:<br />

Picture #6 – Exhibit Hall Lighting<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 25 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

1. Lutron control system serving the 1 st and 3 rd floor meeting rooms.<br />

2. GE TLC control relays <strong>for</strong> the high bay metal halide fixtures throughout the exhibit halls<br />

3. ILC Enercon control relays <strong>for</strong> the concourses throughout the Train Shed<br />

4. Lehigh Electic control system <strong>for</strong> the 2 nd floor meeting rooms.<br />

The majority of the control systems are experiencing more and more frequent failures and in<br />

need of replacement due to availability of the system components.<br />

G. DOMESTIC WATER<br />

Domestic water is provided by the city. Domestic water<br />

pressure is boosted within the building by multiple<br />

booster pumps as a result of low water pressure<br />

supplied by the city. The booster pumps are comprised<br />

of one jockey pump and two main booster pumps which<br />

stage to maintain building pressure at approximately 75<br />

PSI. A third booster pump is available <strong>for</strong> standby. All<br />

domestic water pumps are constant volume and cycle<br />

continuously to meet the needs of the building.<br />

Domestic hot water is provided <strong>for</strong> bathroom lavatories<br />

and sinks by small electric hot water heaters in close<br />

proximity to the plumbing fixtures. Domestic hot water<br />

Picture #7 – Domestic Water Booster<br />

Pumps<br />

is supplied to the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> central kitchen fixtures by a large dedicated gas fired hot<br />

water heater within the kitchen.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 26 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

VI.<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

The equipment list contains major <strong>energy</strong> consuming equipment that through implementation of<br />

<strong>energy</strong> conservation measures could yield substantial <strong>energy</strong> savings. The list shows the major<br />

equipment in the facility and all pertinent in<strong>for</strong>mation utilized in <strong>energy</strong> savings calculations.<br />

An approximate age was assigned to the equipment in some cases if a manufactures date was not<br />

shown on the equipment’s nameplate. The ASHRAE service life <strong>for</strong> the equipment along with<br />

the remaining useful life is also shown in the Appendix.<br />

Refer to the Major Equipment List Appendix <strong>for</strong> this facility.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 27 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

VII.<br />

ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES<br />

A. ECM #1: CONDENSING BOILER INSTALLATION<br />

Description:<br />

The existing boilers are new fire-tube boilers made by Cleaver<br />

Brooks. The boilers include the latest control technologies <strong>for</strong><br />

combustion efficiency and minimal excess air mixture capability. The<br />

combustion fan is variable speed controlled by a unit mounted VFD.<br />

The boiler configuration is a four pass fire-tube boiler. Turndown<br />

ratio is a high 10 to 1 allowing the boiler to operate at low partial<br />

loads. The efficiency of the existing boilers ranges from 80% to 84%<br />

depending on the firing rate and heating water supply temperature.<br />

The boilers are turned on when the building’s heating load is<br />

sufficient to keep the boilers running continuously. As a result the<br />

typical turn on point <strong>for</strong> the boilers is approximately in mid<br />

December. The building heating load in the mild months of the fall<br />

and spring is satisfied by the absorption chillers operating in either<br />

heating mode or simultaneous heating / cooling mode. The efficiency<br />

of the absorption chillers operating in heating mode is approximately<br />

82%.<br />

Picture #8 – Example<br />

Condensing Boiler<br />

This ECM includes the installation of two modular condensing pony boilers which could provide<br />

the building a heating source in the moderate months at an average efficiency of 89%-90%. This<br />

is achieved by reducing the supply heating water temperature to allow the pony boiler to operate<br />

in condensing mode. The condensing pony boilers will replace the need to use the absorption<br />

chillers in heating or simultaneous heating and cooling mode, however the absorption chillers<br />

will remain piped into the loop as a backup source of heat. The condensing boilers will reduce<br />

overall gas usage due to the substantial improvement in heating efficiency during part load<br />

conditions.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 28 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

The condensing boiler <strong>energy</strong> savings is based on the <strong>energy</strong> analysis software by Trane (Trace<br />

700 v 6.2.4). The <strong>energy</strong> models are based on the installation of two 3000 MBH condensing<br />

boilers. The basis <strong>for</strong> the calculations includes utilization of two condensing boilers as the first<br />

stage of heating <strong>for</strong> the building heating water supply loop. The absorption chillers and or firetube<br />

boilers are utilized <strong>for</strong> all additional heating required above 6000 MBH.<br />

CONDENSING BOILER CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

Existing System<br />

New Condensing<br />

Boilers<br />

Heating System Efficiency 82% 90.0%<br />

Heating System Input<br />

Capacity (MBH)<br />

6,000<br />

Energy Model Annual Gas<br />

Usage (Therms)<br />

587,017 572,459 14,558<br />

Average Gas Cost ($/Therm) 1.48 1.48<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Gas Energy Cost ($) $869,959 $848,384 $21,575<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*ECM is based on reduced HWS temperature in moderate heating season<br />

<strong>for</strong> estimated condensing boiler efficiency of 90% average. See Energy<br />

Model Results Appendix <strong>for</strong> detailed <strong>energy</strong> savings in<strong>for</strong>mation.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 29 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #1 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $239,431<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $21,575<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $21,575<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 25<br />

Simple Payback 11.1<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 8%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $136,257.41<br />

The condensing boiler ECM provides an efficient way to provide heating hot water to the<br />

building during part load conditions. The increase in efficiency saves approximately 18,000<br />

Therms of natural gas per year with a savings of $26,000 per year. The boiler’s life expectancy is<br />

approximately 25 years. The savings pays <strong>for</strong> the installation within the first 12 years of its life.<br />

The simple payback close to 10 years warrants this ECM to be considered <strong>for</strong> the facility.<br />

Implementation of this ECM provides additional redundancy <strong>for</strong> the existing central plant<br />

heating boilers.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 30 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

B. ECM #2: Lighting System Upgrade<br />

Description<br />

The facilities lighting is primarily made up of T-12 light<br />

fixtures with magnetic ballasts, recessed incandescent<br />

down light fixtures, and high bay metal halide light<br />

fixtures. The lights are controlled by an on/off lighting<br />

control system. With the exception of the high bay metal<br />

halide fixtures, the existing lighting is inefficient<br />

compared to today’s standards. The standard T-8 light<br />

fixtures with electronic ballasts can be directly substituted<br />

<strong>for</strong> T-12 fixtures with a 30%-40% reduction of input<br />

wattage.<br />

Picture #9 – Exhibit Hall Lighting<br />

This ECM includes replacement of the existing fixtures<br />

containing T12 lamps and magnetic ballasts with fixtures containing T8 lamps and electronic<br />

ballasts. New <strong>energy</strong> efficient, T8 fixtures provide superior light quality and will save on<br />

electrical costs due to the better per<strong>for</strong>mance of the lamp and ballasts. Maintenance savings can<br />

be expected through the reduced number of lamps replaced per year. The expected lamp life of a<br />

T8 lamp is approximately 30,000 burn-hours, in comparison to the existing T12 lamps which is<br />

approximately 20,000 burn-hours. The facility will need 66% less lamps replaced per year.<br />

Currently the meeting rooms within the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> contain a set of 2x4 4 lamp fixtures<br />

and incandescent fixtures. It is assumed that only one set of lights are active at one time.<br />

This ECM also includes replacement of all incandescent bulbs to LED bulbs. Self contained<br />

LED fixtures with dimmable power supplies provide controllable light with four times less<br />

<strong>energy</strong> use. LED bulbs are available in a variety of temperatures to produce different light colors.<br />

In addition to the <strong>energy</strong> savings, dimmable LED bulbs burn-hours are approximately 24 times<br />

longer than incandescent fixtures.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 31 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

The ECM calculations are broken down by room or space. The calculations are shown in the<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit Appendix. Maintenance costs as well as operating costs are<br />

included <strong>for</strong> this ECM.<br />

Light fixture retrofits have many options to consider specifically <strong>for</strong> the incandescent fixtures<br />

throughout the facility. For comparative purposes the breakdown <strong>for</strong> the two major retrofit<br />

options are as follows:<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

DOWNLIGHT REPLACEMENT CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED PROPOSED<br />

Par 38 Incandescent<br />

Down Light<br />

Par 38 CFL Bulb<br />

Replacement<br />

Par 38 LED Bulb<br />

Replacement<br />

Bulb Wattage (Watts) 90 23 24<br />

Lumen Output per Bulb<br />

(Lumens)<br />

1,310 1,200 1,260<br />

Lighting Density (W/SF) 1.72 - 0.46<br />

Lifespan (Hrs) 2,500 8,000 60,000<br />

Color Temp (°K) 2,700 2,700 3,000<br />

Color Rendering Index (CRI) 100 82 87<br />

Bulbs Replaced per Yr 3.5 1.1 0.15<br />

Maintenance Cost per Bulb<br />

($/Bulb)<br />

$2.00 $2.00 $2.00<br />

Replacement Cost per Bulb<br />

($/Bulb)<br />

$4.95 $9.95 $89.90<br />

Average Elec Cost ($/KWH) 0.11 0.11 0.11<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Maintenance Cost per Yr ($) $24.35 $13.09 $13.42<br />

Energy Cost per Yr ($) $88 $22 $23<br />

Total Cost per Yr ($) $112 $35 $37<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

Calculation is based on a 8,760 Hrs of bulb use per year <strong>for</strong> comparative<br />

purposes (On 24/7). Electric costs are fixed at the average baseline value of<br />

$0.111/KWH. Actual costs <strong>for</strong> reduction in demand are dependent on<br />

demand savings per month and overall demand reduction. Watts per<br />

square foot based on current incandescent lighting an replacement LED<br />

lighting in the meeting rooms.<br />

The standard light fixture retrofit <strong>for</strong> the 2 foot by 4 foot T-12 fluorescent fixtures throughout the<br />

facility is to utilize a T-8 fluorescent fixture. For comparative purposes the breakdown <strong>for</strong> the<br />

standard retrofit is as follows:<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 32 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

2X4 FLUORESCENT REPLACEMENT CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

4 Lamp T-12 40W 2 Lamp T-8 32W<br />

Fluorescent Fluorescent<br />

Bulb Input Wattage (Watts) 188 58<br />

Lighting Density (W/SF) 1.90 0.58<br />

Lumen Output per Bulb<br />

(Lumens)<br />

7,688 5,266<br />

Lifespan (Hrs) 20,000 30,000<br />

Bulbs Replaced per Yr 0.44 0.29<br />

Maintenance Cost per Bulb<br />

($/Bulb)<br />

$2.00 $2.00<br />

Replacement Cost per Bulb<br />

($/Bulb)<br />

$3.99 $3.99<br />

Average Elec Cost ($/KWH) 0.11 0.11<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED<br />

Maintenance Cost per Yr ($) $2.62 $1.75<br />

Energy Cost per Yr ($) $183 $56<br />

Total Cost per Yr ($) $185 $58<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

Calculation is based on a 8,760 Hrs of bulb use per<br />

year <strong>for</strong> comparative purposes (On 24/7). Electric<br />

costs are fixed at the average baseline value of<br />

$0.111/KWH. Actual costs <strong>for</strong> reduction in demand<br />

are dependent on demand savings per month and<br />

overall d<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 33 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #2 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $812,365<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $23,487<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $157,170<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $180,657<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15<br />

Simple Payback 4.5<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 21%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $1,344,306.54<br />

The summary below is based on the Investment Grade Lighting Audit proposed retrofits.<br />

A major lighting retrofit <strong>for</strong> the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> has many options to consider. The Proposed<br />

lighting retrofit above in general utilizes T-8 electronic ballast fluorescent fixtures to replace the<br />

existing T-12 magnetic ballast fluorescent fixtures as well as LED Par 38 bulbs to replace the<br />

existing 90W incandescent bulbs. The retrofit installation cost represents a considerable up-front<br />

investment with very profitable savings to be realized in the long run. The approach <strong>for</strong> this<br />

ECM is a conservative one <strong>for</strong> one approach to the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> lighting retrofit options.<br />

Due to the high installation cost of any proposed lighting retrofit at the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>,<br />

further design considerations need to be evaluated. The existing lighting levels in the building<br />

meeting rooms are far above the typical code maximum light levels of new convention centers.<br />

The <strong>energy</strong> standard <strong>for</strong> maximum allowable lighting power density <strong>for</strong> a convention center is<br />

1.2 Watts/SF. Currently, the lighting power density <strong>for</strong> the convention center meeting rooms is<br />

approximately 2.76 Watts/SF but with the implementation of this ECM, the new lighting power<br />

density will be approximately .44 Watts/SF.<br />

The existing incandescent lighting in many of the spaces throughout the <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> are<br />

very inefficient and have a relatively short life of 2,500 hours, yet when compared to other<br />

lighting options, incandescent contain superior light quality, color and dimming ability.<br />

Comparatively speaking, CFL’s and LED’s are both viable options <strong>for</strong> incandescent fixture<br />

replacements. Although compact fluorescent lighting does not hold the same lighting quality as<br />

an incandescent fixture, they are superior in bulb life ranging from 8,000 to 12,000 hours.<br />

CFL’s do not have the ability to sustain a constant color temperature while dimming. In<br />

addition, the minimum capacity range of CFL’s is 15-20% of their full capacity. The LED<br />

lighting has far superior lighting quality and a lifetime ranging from 50,000 to 60,000 hours, and<br />

the LED’s lumen output in comparison to incandescent fixtures is approximately equal.<br />

The meeting rooms are the target <strong>for</strong> highest <strong>energy</strong> savings due to their immense <strong>energy</strong> usage<br />

and lighting density. Since the meeting rooms have two types of lighting arrangements,<br />

incandescent lighting <strong>for</strong> presentations and T-12 lighting <strong>for</strong> general use, the fixtures need to be<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 34 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

the most efficient in these areas. The standard maximum lighting density <strong>for</strong> a <strong>Convention</strong><br />

<strong>Center</strong> is 1.2 watts per square foot per ASHRAE Energy Standard 90.1-2007. Although it is<br />

assumed that one set of lights is only on at any given time, the average lighting density within<br />

each meeting room far exceeds the maximum lighting density in a convention center by 73%<br />

with incandescent lighting and 69% with T-12 fluorescent lighting. Reducing the amount of<br />

watts used per fixture and maintaining adequate light levels will ultimately save over one million<br />

KWH per year which equates to approximately $180,000 in <strong>energy</strong> savings annually. See the<br />

detailed lighting upgrade summery in the ECM #2 Appendix <strong>for</strong> a more details on this analysis.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 35 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

C. ECM #3: Lighting Controls Upgrade<br />

Description<br />

Currently the meeting rooms and offices within the convention<br />

center use manual on/off lighting controls which are wired to<br />

the front end. Most of the time the lights are left on while these<br />

rooms are unoccupied and a large amount of <strong>energy</strong> is being<br />

wasted. With the implementation of ceiling occupancy sensors,<br />

these rooms will be able to turn on/off automatically when<br />

people enter or leave the room.<br />

The U.S. Department of Energy sponsored a study to analyze<br />

<strong>energy</strong> savings achieved through various types of building<br />

system controls. The referenced savings is based on the<br />

“Advanced Sensors and Controls <strong>for</strong> Building Applications:<br />

Market Assessment and Potential R&D Pathways,” document<br />

posted <strong>for</strong> public use April 2005. The study has found that commercial buildings have the<br />

potential to achieve significant <strong>energy</strong> savings through the use of building controls. The average<br />

<strong>energy</strong> savings are as follows based on the <strong>report</strong>:<br />

• Occupancy Sensors <strong>for</strong> Lighting Control - 20%.<br />

Picture #10 – Example Ceiling<br />

and Wall Mount Occupancy<br />

sensors<br />

The ECM includes installation of ceiling occupancy sensors <strong>for</strong> individual offices, meeting<br />

rooms, storage areas and mechanical areas. The occupancy sensors would be integrated into the<br />

existing lighting control system.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 36 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

Lighting controls implementation to the system will give more controllability to the front end<br />

and as a result help maximize the electricity savings. The following is a comparison of the<br />

current system without lighting occupancy sensors to the new ceiling mounted occupancy sensor<br />

system.<br />

LIGHTING CONTROLS CALCULATIONS<br />

EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

No Lighting Ceiling Mounted<br />

Occupancy Sensors Occupany Sensors<br />

Consumption (KWH) 8,231,448 7,913,712 317,736<br />

Yearly Electricity Cost ($) $1,291,551 $1,249,088 $42,463<br />

Electric Cost ($/KWH) 0.11 0.11<br />

HOURS OF OPERATION<br />

Meeting Rooms & Restrooms<br />

Offices & Admin Areas<br />

Closets & Storage Rooms<br />

Hallways & Corridors<br />

2920 Hours per year<br />

2920 Hours per year<br />

2190 hours per year<br />

8760 hours per year<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*Calculation is based on specific room occupany predictions. Refer to<br />

Lighting Controls Appendix <strong>for</strong> further calculations. Electric costs are<br />

fixed at the average baseline value of $0.111/KWH. Actual costs <strong>for</strong><br />

reduction in demand are dependent on demand s<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 37 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #3 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $114,400<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $42,463<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $42,463<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15<br />

Simple Payback 2.7<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 37%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $392,520.54<br />

The lighting control ECM provides an opportunity to reduce the run time of all the lighting<br />

within areas where it is being utilized. Additionally, the ceiling mounted lighting sensors in the<br />

convention center meeting rooms and office areas will allow the conservation of almost 318,000<br />

kWh per year.<br />

ECM #3 Appendix of this <strong>report</strong> includes the summary of lighting controls implemented in this<br />

and outlines the proposed controls, costs, savings, and payback periods. The calculations adjust<br />

the lighting power usage by 20% <strong>for</strong> all areas that include occupancy sensors.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 38 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

D. ECM #4: Supplemental Chiller Installation<br />

Description<br />

The existing centrifugal chillers in the facility are size <strong>for</strong> the<br />

building’s cooling load during maximum occupancy. The<br />

building operation includes significant periods of partial<br />

loading. The maintenance staff operates the centrifugal<br />

chillers only when significant load is available to avoid<br />

cycling of the centrifugal chillers. As a result the absorption<br />

chillers are utilized to operate <strong>for</strong> the majority of the<br />

building’s cooling hours. The cooling operation also includes<br />

all season operation <strong>for</strong> the building’s telephone and<br />

computer equipment.<br />

Picture #11 – Example 450 Ton<br />

Screw Chiller<br />

The absorption chillers operate at an approximate efficiency of 1.162 COP (IPLV). Typical small<br />

water cooled electric chillers operate at efficiencies far superior to that of any absorption chiller.<br />

Approximately 0.526 KW/TON (6.7 COP). The efficiency increase <strong>for</strong> this change of equipment<br />

is approximately 1/3 less cost per ton of cooling with an electric chiller versus an absorption<br />

chiller. The added electric load from the “pony” chiller will increase the peak electric demand<br />

and there<strong>for</strong>e have a negative effect on the demand ratchet electric utility costs. However the<br />

significant decrease in the gas utility costs more than pays up <strong>for</strong> the increase in demand charges.<br />

The net savings is considerable.<br />

This ECM includes the installation of a small electric supplemental Chiller, to provide cooling<br />

<strong>for</strong> the building <strong>for</strong> all operating hours between 0 tons and 450 tons of building cooling load.<br />

Since the building cooling load is continuous throughout the year, a pony chiller would eliminate<br />

the operating hours of the absorption chiller <strong>for</strong> cooling. The pony chiller would utilize the<br />

primary chilled water pumps originally dedicated to one of the absorption chillers, however<br />

maintaining flexibility to utilize the absorption chiller <strong>for</strong> back-up. This ECM also includes<br />

altering the sequencing of chillers to ensure that the second and third stage of cooling is provided<br />

by the two large centrifugal chillers in lieu of the existing absorption chillers. With the partial<br />

loads cooled by the Pony chiller, the large centrifugal chillers can operate reliably without<br />

cycling once the building cooling loads climb above the pony chillers capacity. This ECM<br />

includes installation of a one 450 ton water cooled screw chiller. A screw chiller provides<br />

excellent reliability and versatile per<strong>for</strong>mance.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 39 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

The supplemental chiller <strong>energy</strong> savings is based on the <strong>energy</strong> analysis software by Trane<br />

(Trace 700 v 6.2.4). The <strong>energy</strong> models are based on the installation of a new 450 ton water<br />

cooled screw chiller. The basis <strong>for</strong> the ECM calculations includes substituting the operation of<br />

the absorption chiller with the proposed supplemental (“pony”) electric chiller. The existing<br />

absorption chiller is modeled only as a backup and there<strong>for</strong>e not contributing to <strong>energy</strong><br />

consumption. All remaining load on the chilled water plant above the supplemental chiller is<br />

provided by the two large single speed centrifugal chillers. The two large centrifugal chillers are<br />

modeled based on the existing centrifugal chillers. There<strong>for</strong>e natural gas consumption is<br />

eliminated from the cooling plant in the proposed ECM model.<br />

This ECM represents a fuel switching option. Electrical <strong>energy</strong> is the proposed replacement <strong>for</strong><br />

natural gas <strong>for</strong> chilled water production. With this fuel switching ECM, the electrical <strong>energy</strong><br />

cost will increase and the natural gas costs will decrease. The savings from the gas <strong>energy</strong> utility<br />

subtracted by the electrical increase is the overall savings utilized <strong>for</strong> all <strong>energy</strong> savings<br />

calculations.<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

SUPPLIMENTAL CHILLER CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Absorption Chillers<br />

1st Stage of Cooling<br />

New Pony Chiller<br />

1st Stage of Cooling<br />

Cooling System Efficiency 1.162 COP 0.634 KW/Ton<br />

On Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

7,325,940 7,468,741 -142,801<br />

Off Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

11,941,591 12,142,954 -201,363<br />

Peak Electrical Demand (KW) 5,289 5,533 -244<br />

Gas Usage (Therms) 587,017 490,504 96,513<br />

Average Gas Cost ($/Therm) 1.48 1.48<br />

Electric Cost ($/KWH) Peco HT Rate Peco HT Rate<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Gas Energy Cost ($) $869,959 $726,927 $143,032<br />

Electric Energy Cost ($) $2,125,602 $2,197,368 -$71,766<br />

Total Energy Cost ($) $2,995,561 $2,924,295 $71,266<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*ECM is based on operation of the "pony" chiller as the first stage of<br />

cooling and eliminating chilled water production through the gas fired<br />

absorption chillers.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 40 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #4 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $499,938<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $71,266<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $71,266<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 23<br />

Simple Payback 7.0<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 13%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $671,932.70<br />

The supplemental chiller ECM represents an opportunity <strong>for</strong> substantial savings <strong>for</strong> the PA<br />

<strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>. The current natural gas utility costs are higher than expected <strong>for</strong> the<br />

interruptible rate structure. The inefficiency of the absorption chillers combined with the high<br />

gas costs points to reducing as much gas cooling operation as possible. The supplemental chiller<br />

allows <strong>for</strong> considerable part load chilled water production to be transferred from the gas utility to<br />

the electric. Although electric pricing in Philadelphia are high, the efficiency increase of a<br />

supplemental electric chiller far outweighs the added electric costs.<br />

The increase in electrical costs of approximately $72,000 is paid <strong>for</strong> by the natural gas savings of<br />

approximately $143,000. The net savings of $71,000 per year pays <strong>for</strong> the installation of a<br />

supplemental chiller in approximately 7 years.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 41 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

E. ECM #5: Centrifugal Chiller VFD Retrofit<br />

Description<br />

The existing centrifugal chillers in the facility are size <strong>for</strong><br />

the building’s cooling load during maximum occupancy.<br />

The building operation includes significant periods of<br />

partial loading. The maintenance staff operates the<br />

centrifugal chillers only when significant load is available<br />

to avoid cycling of the centrifugal chillers. As a result the<br />

absorption chillers are utilized to operate <strong>for</strong> the majority of<br />

the building’s cooling hours. The cooling operation also<br />

includes all season operation <strong>for</strong> the building’s telephone<br />

and computer equipment; however this load is very small.<br />

Picture #12 – Example Large<br />

Centrifugal Chiller <strong>for</strong> Retrofit<br />

The absorption chillers operate as the first stage of cooling <strong>for</strong> the plant. The primary cooling <strong>for</strong><br />

the building during events is provided by the large centrifugal chillers. The existing centrifugal<br />

chillers are single speed and operate at an average efficiency of 0.488 KW/Ton (IPLV). The<br />

efficiency of the centrifugal chillers increases <strong>for</strong> all part load conditions with the installation of<br />

a variable frequency drive (VFD). The VFD improves the chillers average efficiency to 0.361<br />

KW/Ton (IPLV).<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 42 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

The VFD Chiller Retrofit <strong>energy</strong> savings is based on the <strong>energy</strong> analysis software by Trane<br />

(Trace 700 v 6.2.4). The <strong>energy</strong> models are based on the retrofit of both of the 1700 ton<br />

centrifugal chillers with variable frequency drives. The basis <strong>for</strong> the calculations assumes the<br />

same operational style of the proposed chilled water plant as the existing chilled water plant. One<br />

of the absorption chillers is utilized as the first stage of cooling. The VFD retrofitted chiller is<br />

compared to the existing chiller <strong>for</strong> all chilled water load from the building above the capacity of<br />

one of the existing absorption chillers. The efficiency curves <strong>for</strong> the existing chillers and<br />

retrofitted chillers are shown in the VFD Chiller ECM Appendix.<br />

VFD CHILLER RETROFIT CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

Non VFD Chillers<br />

New VFD Retrofit<br />

Chillers<br />

Cooling System Efficiency<br />

(IPLV)<br />

0.488 KW/Ton 0.361 KW/Ton<br />

On Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

7,325,940 7,283,080 42,860<br />

Off Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

11,941,591 11,881,347 60,244<br />

Peak Electrical Demand (KW) 5,289 5,355 -66<br />

Electric Cost ($/KWH) Peco HT Rate Peco HT Rate<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Electric Energy Cost ($) $2,125,602 $2,120,489 $5,113<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*ECM is based on ARI part load efficiency curve data by Johnson<br />

Controls. Efficiency shown above is IPLV. Energy savings is based on<br />

Model calculations<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 43 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #5 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $632,500<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $5,113<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $5,113<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 17<br />

Simple Payback 123.7<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) -16%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) ($565,181.64)<br />

The savings above is minimal compared to the cost of the retrofit and does not pay back within a<br />

reasonable time period. The reason <strong>for</strong> the long payback of this ECM is due to the lack of part<br />

load cooling hours of the large centrifugal chillers. Currently the large centrifugal chillers are<br />

only used during summer events, or periods of high ambient conditions. The majority of the part<br />

load conditions are provided by the absorption chillers. In this scenario, the centrifugal chillers<br />

are used <strong>for</strong> higher loads, but not lower part loads. The reduction in part load conditions hinders<br />

the primary benefit of the VFD retrofit. As a result the model calculated a relatively small<br />

electrical usage savings, where other building types would be seeing a much greater savings.<br />

The effects of this ECM on the building electrical demand decreased savings. Since the VFD is<br />

an electrical drive <strong>for</strong> the chiller compressor motor, the full load efficiency is actually reduced<br />

compared to the constant speed chiller. The VFD incurs losses due to the changing frequency of<br />

the power, and there<strong>for</strong>e can never be as efficient as a constant speed motor at 100% capacity.<br />

This slight loss of efficiency at full load (approximately 3.6%), has a more dramatic effect on<br />

utility demand costs than the usage associated due to the operating hours. The demand is<br />

measured based on the maximum KW usage at any given point in time. The VFD model showed<br />

a relatively small increase in demand (66KW) due to the higher losses at full load. This increase<br />

in full load consumption incurred higher costs due to the 80% demand ratchet. The increase in<br />

cost was distributed throughout the entire year due to the rate structure. Without the effects of<br />

demand charges throughout the year, the savings would have been approximately 2.5 times<br />

higher.<br />

This option is not recommended with the existing operation as a basis <strong>for</strong> plant operations. If the<br />

part load operating hours of the large centrifugal chillers were significantly increased, the<br />

relative savings by implementing a VFD retrofit would also significantly increase. In this event it<br />

is important to realize that the existing conditions and plant operating costs would be<br />

significantly reduced just by the utilization of the existing constant speed chillers over the<br />

operation of the absorption chillers. The savings as a result of switching to electric chilled water<br />

production would be comparable to the savings shown in ECM #4 with a supplemental chiller.<br />

The drawback would be the increase in operational wear and tear as well as increased starts and<br />

stops on the large centrifugal chillers.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 44 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

F. ECM #6: Demand Response Controls<br />

Description<br />

The central cooling system currently utilizes two <strong>for</strong>ms of<br />

chilled water production. The centrifugal chillers operate<br />

when the building cooling loads are large enough to keep<br />

the machine online reliably. The absorption chillers are<br />

utilized <strong>for</strong> all operating cooling hours below the<br />

centrifugal chillers minimum operation capacity. A large<br />

factor in the pricing <strong>for</strong> electricity under PECO’s “High<br />

Tension” rate structure is the billed KW demand. The<br />

building’s demand (or peak electric draw) is usually set<br />

under high cooling load in the summer months. Due to the<br />

nature of the building’s operation, the electric demand is<br />

only peaked <strong>for</strong> a very short amount of hours per year<br />

Picture #13 – Example Demand<br />

Response Graphic and Controller<br />

relative to the cooling hours of the building. The peak demand is typically set during an event<br />

when the building is close to full occupancy while simultaneously coinciding with high ambient<br />

conditions. Demand Control Limiting could limit the building demand by switching cooling<br />

production from electric to gas during the few hours of high building demand. A building’s<br />

demand charge is carried throughout the year based on the highest demand set in the summer<br />

months. There<strong>for</strong>e a reduction in building demand would reduce the overall cost of electricity <strong>for</strong><br />

the year.<br />

A demand monitoring system tracks the building’s electric demand and responds when the<br />

building electric use starts to climb to a high rate. The operational changes automated by the<br />

demand monitoring and control system would include offsetting load from the centrifugal<br />

chillers to the two 700 ton absorption chillers. Although the operating cost of absorption chillers<br />

is approximately 3.3 times higher than the electric chillers, a reduction in demand charges over<br />

the course of a year would outweigh the temporary increased operating cost of the absorption<br />

chillers.<br />

For the purpose of this ECM’s comparison the retrofit includes installation of a demand response<br />

control system integrated into the central cooling plant including chillers, respective chilled<br />

water pumps. Electric demand meters are retrofitted on the entrance electric gear and wired back<br />

to a front end that monitors and controls the HVAC equipment.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 45 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

Demand response controls have a wide range of applicability equipment that can be controlled.<br />

The calculations are based on an example scenario to show the impact and potential savings of<br />

demand response. The following calculations are based on the a reduction in billing demand in<br />

the single highest electric demand month <strong>for</strong> the building’s baseline. The demand limiting<br />

control will reduce demand (KW) equal to the difference between the highest month’s reading<br />

and the next highest month’s reading based on the average baseline monthly data. This will<br />

simulate a relatively small amount of time in which the demand response controls actually<br />

change the current operation of the building. The baseline demand measurements are as follows:<br />

• 5,289 KW – July (Highest demand month)<br />

• 4,850 KW – August (Second highest demand month)<br />

The savings are based on the switching of chilled water production from one centrifugal chiller<br />

to the operation of both absorption chillers to reduce building demand during peak electric usage.<br />

The calculation summary below shows the potential demand reduction of (740KW) due to the<br />

switching of chilled water equipment. The demand response controls <strong>for</strong> this ECM simulates a<br />

maximum setting of 4850 KW in which the central control system reduces building demand<br />

during peak demand periods. The resulting reduction in demand is follows:<br />

Demand Reduction – 5,289 KW – 4,850 KW = 439 KW.<br />

439 KW of demand reduction is utilized <strong>for</strong> this scenario, however chiller switching represents a<br />

740 KW potential reduction, which can be utilized <strong>for</strong> more aggressive possibilities. The savings<br />

resulting from the demand reduction include reduced demand charges <strong>for</strong> the month of July, as<br />

well as a reduction in the 80% demand ratchet applied to the rest of the year based on the electric<br />

rate structure. Although electrical usage and demand is reduced the gas usage is increased <strong>for</strong> the<br />

short duration of demand shedding.<br />

The demand response calculations are based on the switching of chilled water production to<br />

avoid the operation of two simultaneous centrifugal chillers during a large convention center<br />

event in July. Based on the in<strong>for</strong>mation provided by operations personnel, the frequency of large<br />

events during the month of July would typically not exceed 1 week in duration. In order to<br />

estimate the gas usage, absorption chillers are simulated <strong>for</strong> continuous use to provide 1700 tons<br />

of cooling <strong>for</strong> 6 hours per day <strong>for</strong> 1 week. The calculations are as follows.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 46 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

DEMAND RESPONSE CONTROLS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

No Demand Control -<br />

Max Demand Set w/<br />

Multiple Chiller<br />

Operation<br />

Demand Response<br />

with Temporary<br />

Absorption Chiller<br />

Operation<br />

Chiller Efficiency 0.488 KW/Ton 1.162 COP<br />

Chiller Electric Draw 830 KW 90 KW 740<br />

Temp Hours of Operation<br />

(Hrs)<br />

30 30<br />

Capacity (Tons) 1,700 1,700<br />

Total Ton Hours (Ton*Hrs) 51,000 51,000<br />

BTU / Therm 100,000<br />

BTU / Ton*Hr 12,000<br />

Chiller Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

24,888 0 24,888<br />

Peak Electrical Demand (KW) 5,289 4,850 439<br />

Added Chiller Gas Usage<br />

(Therms)<br />

0 5,267 -5,267<br />

Average Gas Cost ($/Therm) 1.48 1.48<br />

Electric Cost ($/KWH) Peco HT Rate Peco HT Rate<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Gas Energy Cost ($) $0 $7,805 -$7,805<br />

Electric Energy Cost ($) $2,125,602 $2,059,475 $66,127<br />

Total Energy Cost ($) $2,125,602 $2,067,280 $58,322<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*ECM is based on operation of the two absorption chillers as the demand<br />

response sequence to stay below a maximum of 4850KW building demand.<br />

Maximum estimated utilization of this sequence is 5 days, 6 hrs per day to<br />

offset one 1700 ton centrifugal chiller's operation.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 47 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #6 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $68,850<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $58,322<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $58,322<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15<br />

Simple Payback 1.2<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 85%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $627,394.25<br />

The annual savings of this ECM compared to the installation cost is considerable. A single<br />

week’s worth of operational changes is able to reduce the annual electrical cost to pay <strong>for</strong> the<br />

majority of the system’s installation. The PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> is in the unique position where<br />

two <strong>for</strong>ms of chilled water production is available to be utilized at any time. This advantage is<br />

utilized through this ECM and can be an extremely valuable tool in the future <strong>energy</strong> markets.<br />

The scenario shown above represents only a single approach to reducing building demand. In the<br />

scenario above, the demand reduction was a result of switching fuel sources temporarily to<br />

natural gas to reduce electric draw. Other demand response approaches can be implemented<br />

without any additional use of <strong>energy</strong> such as, equipment sequencing, motor speed reduction,<br />

lighting fixture dimming, & space temperature re-set. Light fixture control is a particularly<br />

valuable option <strong>for</strong> demand response when combined with occupancy sensors. Spaces being<br />

monitored with no-occupancy can have lighting reduced or turned off to satisfy demand<br />

reduction needs. This approach not only uses no additional fuel, but also provides a reduction in<br />

heat generated due to light fixtures.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 48 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

G. ECM #7: Kitchen Exhaust Controls<br />

Description<br />

The PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> houses two (2) commercial<br />

kitchens; the ground floor main kitchen and the ballroom<br />

kitchen. The ground floor kitchen has approximately<br />

eight (8) large Type 1 kitchen exhaust hoods on the<br />

ground floor, while the ballroom kitchen has seven (7)<br />

Type 1 kitchen exhaust hoods. The typical operating<br />

hours of the kitchen exhaust system is approximately 18<br />

hours per day. The hoods are all connected to a common<br />

exhaust duct with a single constant volume exhaust fan<br />

that discharges to the outdoors. A make-up air handling<br />

Picture #14 – Example Kitchen Exhaust<br />

Hood with Controls <strong>for</strong> Variable Speed<br />

unit is dedicated <strong>for</strong> providing outside are to the kitchen and operates whenever the kitchen<br />

exhaust system is running.<br />

The installation of kitchen exhaust controls would significantly reduce the total kitchen exhaust<br />

and make-up air quantity. The conditioned make up air and exhausted air savings are achieved<br />

by monitoring the exhaust hoods and exhaust based on the actual use of the kitchen equipment.<br />

Temperature sensors and optical lasers monitor the heat and smoke production at each exhaust<br />

hood to reduce the exhaust and make-up airflow based on the need of the kitchen equipment.<br />

This ECM includes installation of kitchen exhaust controls <strong>for</strong> the kitchen exhaust hoods and<br />

VDF’s <strong>for</strong> the main kitchen exhaust fans. The hoods would be retrofitted with temperature and<br />

laser sensors to monitor the activity of each of all equipment installed below the hoods.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 49 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

A calculation by the MELINK representatives has been utilized <strong>for</strong> the analysis of this ECM.<br />

Refer to the following chart <strong>for</strong> additional in<strong>for</strong>mation regarding the MELINK exhaust hood<br />

system. A comparison of the new MELINK exhaust system to the old uncontrolled method is<br />

shown below.<br />

KITCHEN EXHAUST CONTROLS CALCULATION<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

Existing<br />

New MELINK<br />

Uncontrolled<br />

Kitchen Exhaust<br />

Kitchen Exhaust<br />

Controls System<br />

System<br />

Fan Power Usage (kWh) 238,718 79,566 159,152<br />

Gas Usage (kbtu) 47,084 29,451 17,633<br />

Cooling Usage (kWh) 197,082 123,843 73,239<br />

Average Gas Cost ($/Therm) 1.48 1.48<br />

Electric Cost ($/KWH) 0.11 0.11<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Gas Energy Cost ($) $69,778 $43,647 $26,131<br />

Electric Energy Cost ($) $47,938 $22,375 $25,563<br />

Total Energy Cost ($) $117,716 $66,022 $51,694<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*ECM is based on calculations done by MELINK Intelli-hood controls<br />

manufacturer. Please review ECM #7 Appendix <strong>for</strong> further details.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 50 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #7 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $102,190<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $51,927<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $51,927<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15<br />

Simple Payback 2.0<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 51%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $517,711.16<br />

The MELINK kitchen exhaust controls system provides a large amount of gas savings and a<br />

moderate amount of electrical savings. With a low installation cost <strong>for</strong> this system and such a<br />

high reduction in costs during the course of a year, the implementation of this ECM will payback<br />

in approximately 2 years.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 51 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

H. ECM #8: Domestic Water Booster Pump Package<br />

Description<br />

The Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> uses multiple domestic water<br />

booster pumps to provide adequate domestic water pressure<br />

throughout the facility. The existing pumps are staged to support<br />

the variable flow requirements. The flow requirement ranges from<br />

very minimal usage during non event periods to significant usage<br />

during large conventions. The majority of the operating hours are<br />

when the flow is very minimal. The current pump operation is<br />

inefficient at low flow conditions due to the nature of constant<br />

volume pumps. Variable pumping allows the domestic water flow<br />

to match the building’s demand. During low flow conditions the<br />

variable speed drives slow pumps to match the limited load.<br />

During high demand the pump package not only increases pump<br />

speeds, but also matches the operating pumps which are most suitable to the load to optimize<br />

efficiency. This optimization is utilized throughout the entire range of flow conditions.<br />

This ECM includes installation of a variable speed pump package.<br />

Picture #15 – Example<br />

Variable Speed Pump Package<br />

with Controls<br />

The <strong>energy</strong> savings is based on estimated system full load operating characteristics as shown<br />

below. The proposed pump packaged<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 52 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

The domestic water booster pump package savings is based on the VFD savings calculator by<br />

ABB (PumpSave Ver. 4.2). This program calculates the savings between the existing throttling<br />

control method and the proposed variable speed booster pump package. The Calculations are<br />

broken down into three different operational periods as follows:<br />

Stage 1 - 5694 Hrs per Yr Flow (0 - 200 GPM)<br />

This stage represents only the 15 HP jockey pump running to satisfy the building<br />

domestic water loads. The operating hours <strong>for</strong> this stage is estimated to be 65% of the total<br />

running hours of the domestic water booster pumps. This operation represents flow requirements<br />

at non event low occupancy periods. These hours are estimated to satisfy conditions such as<br />

evening hours and staff only periods. The flow distribution over the hours represented in stage 1<br />

is shown below.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 53 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Stage 2 - 876 Hrs per Yr Flow (200 - 850 GPM)<br />

This stage represents the operation of the 15 HP jockey pump and the 50 HP stage 2<br />

pump running to satisfy the building domestic water loads. The operating hours <strong>for</strong> this stage is<br />

estimated to be 10% of the total running hours of the domestic water booster pumps. This<br />

operation represents flow requirements above low occupancy periods, but still less than event<br />

operating hours. These hours are estimated to satisfy conditions such as event preparation and<br />

small event periods. The flow distribution over the hours represented in stage 2 is shown below.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 54 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Stage 3 - 5694 Hrs per Yr Flow (850 - 1700 GPM)<br />

This stage represents the operation of the 15 HP jockey pump and two 50 HP pumps<br />

(stage 3) running to satisfy the building domestic water loads. The operating hours <strong>for</strong> this stage<br />

is estimated to be 25% of the total running hours of the domestic water booster pumps. This<br />

operation represents flow requirements <strong>for</strong> medium and large event occupancy levels. These<br />

hours are estimated to satisfy event conditions and commercial kitchen use. This period would<br />

also represent small to medium event periods with high cooling loads and significant cooling<br />

tower make-up water usage. The flow distribution over the hours represented in stage 3 is shown<br />

below.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 55 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

VARIABLE SPEED PUMP PACKAGE CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

Constant Volume<br />

Pumps<br />

VFD Pumps<br />

Total Flow (GPM) 1700 1700<br />

Head (Ft) 140 140<br />

Pump Efficiency (%) 82% 82%<br />

Motor Efficiency (%) 92% 92%<br />

Elec Energy Stage 1 (KWH) 29,000 11,000 18,000<br />

Elec Energy Stage 2 (KWH) 22,000 14,000 8,000<br />

Elec Energy Stage 3 (KWH) 120,000 98,000 22,000<br />

Elec Energy Total (KWH) 171,000 123,000 48,000<br />

Elec Cost ($/kWh) 0.111 0.111<br />

ENERGY SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Electric Energy Cost ($) $18,981 $13,653 $5,328<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

VFD pump <strong>energy</strong> is based on ABB <strong>energy</strong> savings calculator <strong>for</strong> pumps,<br />

"Pump Save," version 4.2. Flow rate <strong>for</strong> VFD Pump calculation is<br />

summarized in the operating profile shown in the Pump Save output.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 56 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #8 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $107,781<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $5,328<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $5,328<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 20<br />

Simple Payback 20.2<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 0%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) ($28,514.06)<br />

The VFD pump package ECM represents a moderate reduction in electrical <strong>energy</strong>. The <strong>energy</strong><br />

savings alone pays <strong>for</strong> the installation cost roughly in the time frame of the equipment life span.<br />

When considering equipment in need of replacement due to failures, the increased cost <strong>for</strong> a<br />

variable speed system versus a constant speed package is well justified. It is highly<br />

recommended to consider a variable speed domestic water booster package in the future when<br />

the existing pumps are at the end of its life.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 57 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

I. ECM #9: Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage<br />

Description<br />

The existing system utilizes absorption chillers<br />

in lieu of electrically driven chillers <strong>for</strong> the<br />

majority of the chilled water production <strong>for</strong> the<br />

facility. The large centrifugal chillers are<br />

utilized when the cooling load is too high <strong>for</strong> the<br />

absorption machines. As a result, the facility is<br />

taxed with high demand charges from the<br />

operation of the centrifugal chillers. A chilled<br />

Picture #16 – Example Thermal Ice Storage Tanks<br />

water thermal storage system is capable of<br />

storing thermal <strong>energy</strong> in the <strong>for</strong>m of ice which<br />

can be utilized at peak cooling load periods. The electric utility rate structure includes an off<br />

peak rider, which allows <strong>for</strong> increased electric draw during off peak at no increase in the billed<br />

electric demand. The reduction in the actively produced chilled water during high peak periods<br />

will reduce the building electric demand and save on electric <strong>energy</strong> charges. Thermal storage<br />

allows <strong>for</strong> the transfer of chilled water production from on-peak to off-peak periods. The chiller<br />

produces chilled water at off-peak periods when the ambient temperatures are favorable <strong>for</strong><br />

producing sub-freezing chilled water temperatures.<br />

This ECM includes twenty 162 Ton-Hour thermal ice storage tanks and a plate and frame heat<br />

exchanger to transfer the thermal <strong>energy</strong> from the chilled water loop to the ice making brine<br />

solution. For the basis of these calculations, the location of the ice storage tanks is proposed on<br />

the loading dock next to the mechanical room mezzanine in order to minimize piping runs to the<br />

storage tank. However the thermal storage tanks can be located further away from the central<br />

plant at a slight loss in <strong>energy</strong> due to pipe loss, and an increase in installation cost. The source of<br />

ice production is provided by a 450 nominal Ton screw chiller (325 Tons in ice making mode)<br />

capable of producing 20°F chilled water (brine solution). The addition of this supplemental<br />

chiller will produce ice <strong>for</strong> thermal storage to be utilized during peak periods and high load<br />

conditions.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 58 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

The Thermal Ice Chiller <strong>energy</strong> savings is based on the <strong>energy</strong> analysis software by Trane (Trace<br />

700 v 6.2.4). The <strong>energy</strong> models are based on the installation of a new 450 nominal ton water<br />

cooled screw chiller. This ECM is based on a dedicated water cooled ice chiller to produce subzero<br />

chilled water temperatures through a brine solution (approximately 40% glycol.) The full<br />

load capacity of the proposed chiller during ice production is 325 tons at efficiency of 1.05<br />

KW/Ton. The calculations assume ice production to be limited to off peak periods. The thermal<br />

storage is utilized base on an optimized usage schedule provided by the modeling software. This<br />

ECM does not include demand response or real time utility monitoring. The existing chillers are<br />

modeled based on the existing model and staged accordingly; however the thermal storage is<br />

discharged during periods of high building cooling load on a load priority basis. All additional<br />

load on the chilled water plant above the thermal storage capability is provided by the absorption<br />

chiller and the two large single speed centrifugal chillers. Structural analysis is required to<br />

determine applicable location <strong>for</strong> thermal storage tanks.<br />

ICE CHILLER CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

Ice Chiller Operation<br />

Existing Chiller<br />

with Off Peak<br />

Operation<br />

Production<br />

Cooling System Efficiency 0.488 KW/Ton 1.05 KW/Ton<br />

On Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

7,325,940 6,994,247 331,693<br />

Off Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

11,941,591 12,689,768 -748,177<br />

Peak Electrical Demand (KW) 5,289 4,748 541<br />

Gas Usage (Therms) 587,017 564,429 22,588<br />

Average Gas Cost ($/Therm) 1.48 1.48<br />

Electric Cost ($/KWH) Peco HT Rate Peco HT Rate<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Gas Energy Cost ($) $869,959 $836,483 $33,475<br />

Electric Energy Cost ($) $2,125,602 $2,037,536 $88,066<br />

Total Energy Cost ($) $2,995,561 $2,874,019 $121,541<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*ECM is based on operation of the Ice Chiller during off peak periods<br />

only. Thermal storage utilization is based on Trane Trace 700 optimization<br />

schedule <strong>for</strong> peak load condition shaving.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 59 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #9 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $969,813<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $121,541<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $121,541<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 23<br />

Simple Payback 8.0<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 12%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $1,028,760.11<br />

The calculation results show a clear shift of <strong>energy</strong> usage from on-peak to off-peak. In addition<br />

the building electric demand shows the same transition. The combination of reduced demand<br />

during on peak as well as a transfer of electric usage from on-peak to off-peak results in<br />

extremely favorable <strong>energy</strong> cost savings. In addition to the electrical <strong>energy</strong> savings, the thermal<br />

storage provides added chilled water production during the day that otherwise would have been<br />

provided by the absorption chiller. The shedding of load from the absorption chiller also results<br />

in lower gas consumption and reduced natural gas costs.<br />

As expected the overall electrical <strong>energy</strong> increased, however the usage was shifted from on to off<br />

peak. The shift in electrical usage resulted in a net electrical savings of $88,000 per year.<br />

Approximately 45% of the electrical savings is due to the reduction in peak <strong>energy</strong> use. These<br />

savings are a result of the lower cost of off peak <strong>energy</strong> use versus on peak in the cooling<br />

months. The majority of the electrical savings (approximately 55%) is a result of the reduction in<br />

demand charges due to the 80% ratchet structure during the non cooling months. The result of<br />

demand shaving through this ECM shows the substantial impact on cost that the demand charges<br />

incur on a facility. An additional $33,000 per year is saved by the reduction in natural gas use<br />

through the existing absorption chillers. This ECM shows the successful implementation of both<br />

fuel switching and optimized <strong>energy</strong> use. This ECM is highly recommended to be considered <strong>for</strong><br />

implementation and further evaluation.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 60 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Description<br />

J. ECM #10: Demand Control Ventilation & VFD Fan Control<br />

The convention halls and meeting rooms are<br />

conditioned by large air handling units (AHUs)<br />

with outside are dampers <strong>for</strong> ventilation. The air<br />

handling units are running when there is an event.<br />

During events the outside air quantity is constant<br />

since the existing AHUs are constant volume units.<br />

The outside air quantity is set to provide enough<br />

outside air <strong>for</strong> the full occupancy of the space.<br />

Many events throughout the year have occupancies<br />

which are less than maximum occupancy. The<br />

result of over ventilation is increased <strong>energy</strong> use<br />

and difficulty in providing humidity control.<br />

Picture #17 – Typical Exhibit Hall AHU<br />

Demand control ventilation provides control of the outside air quantity introduced into a space.<br />

The implementation of this control would reduce the outside air heated and cooled by the AHU<br />

and as a result, reduce the heating and cooling load on the central plants. Demand control<br />

ventilation regulates outside air based on the actual occupancy of the space. CO2 sensors provide<br />

accurate control of the rate of outside air needed at any given time. This control is beneficial <strong>for</strong><br />

spaces which have been unoccupied <strong>for</strong> long periods prior to an event, or <strong>for</strong> spaces which are<br />

only occupied <strong>for</strong> short periods. The system would respond to CO2 levels rather than when an<br />

event starts.<br />

This ECM also includes installation of variable speed drives on each AHU fan motor. The<br />

proposed VAV system AHUs includes variable speed drives to control supply air volume in lieu<br />

of the existing inlet vane dampers. The meeting rooms, offices, and common space AHUs<br />

supplies air to downstream VAV boxes that require variable air volume due to changes in the<br />

space load. The meeting rooms AHUs currently control the supply air volume through inlet vane<br />

dampers. The variable speed drives would control air volume by reducing fan speed and to<br />

reduce fan horse power.<br />

The ECM includes retrofit of the exhibit hall AHUs as well. Variable speed drives are proposed<br />

<strong>for</strong> all exhibit hall fan motors to allow variable volume control of the supply air. This includes<br />

control of the fan speed in response to lower levels of activity measured from the CO2 sensors.<br />

This <strong>for</strong>m of control allows <strong>for</strong> a significant reduction in <strong>energy</strong> from the conditioning of outside<br />

air as well as the system fan horse power by slowing fan speeds in response to the space<br />

occupancy.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 61 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Calculations<br />

This ECM includes installation of CO2 sensors installed in the return ductwork of each AHU<br />

serving the exhibit halls. CO2 sensors would be installed directly in the space <strong>for</strong> each meeting<br />

room. A VFD would be installed <strong>for</strong> the supply fan and return fan where applicable of each<br />

AHU. The inlet vanes would be eliminated <strong>for</strong> all AHUs serving the meeting rooms.<br />

The baseline ventilation rate is based on 15 CFM per person ventilated continuously during<br />

occupied periods. 15 CFM is the calculated ventilation rate totaled from the existing system<br />

design drawings. The DCV ventilation rate is based on the 15 CFM per person <strong>for</strong> full<br />

occupancy only and a linear reduction in outside air <strong>for</strong> all occupancies less than 100%. The<br />

reduced ventilation rates are modeled based on the occupancy profile schedule rather than a<br />

constant volume number. The existing ventilation rates should be verified through testing and<br />

balancing to ensure accuracy of the outside air quantities. The ECM calculations are based on the<br />

design outdoor air ventilation rate being introduced into the space at all times that occupancy is<br />

greater than 5%. System monitoring could be utilized to establish actual run-hours of AHU<br />

equipment and outside air damper operation. This along with current air – balancing readings<br />

will allow <strong>for</strong> an accurate measurement of the existing conditioned outside air quantity.<br />

DEMAND CONTROL VENTILATION CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

ECM INPUTS<br />

Existing Constant<br />

Volume and Inlet<br />

Vane AHUs<br />

Demand Control<br />

Ventilation & VFD<br />

Drives on all AHUs<br />

On Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

7,325,940 6,781,658 544,282<br />

Off Peak Electrical Usage<br />

(KWH)<br />

11,941,591 11,346,687 594,904<br />

Peak Electrical Demand (KW) 5,289 4,575 714<br />

Gas Usage (Therms) 587,017 405,100 181,917<br />

Average Gas Cost ($/Therm) 1.48 1.48<br />

Electric Cost ($/KWH) Peco HT Rate Peco HT Rate<br />

SAVINGS CALCULATIONS<br />

ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS<br />

Gas Energy Cost ($) $869,959 $600,358 $269,601<br />

Electric Energy Cost ($) $2,125,602 $1,958,782 $166,820<br />

Total Energy Cost ($) $2,995,561 $2,559,140 $436,421<br />

COMMENTS:<br />

*ECM is based on CO2 based demand control ventilation operation <strong>for</strong> all<br />

existing air handling units and sensors installed in all occupied zones.<br />

Ventilation rates is based on <strong>energy</strong> model real time occupancy levels in<br />

lieu of existing system with minimum ventilation rate . This ECM is based<br />

on replacement of all AHU fan motors with variable frequency driven<br />

premium efficiency motors as well as integration into the existing control<br />

system.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 62 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

Energy Savings Summary<br />

ECM #10 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

Installation Cost ($): $1,862,700<br />

Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): ($18,700)<br />

Energy Savings ($/Yr): $436,421<br />

Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $417,721<br />

Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15<br />

Simple Payback 4.5<br />

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 21%<br />

Net Present Value (NPV) $3,124,026.18<br />

The demand control ventilation option minimizes conditioning of outside air when ventilation<br />

requirements are below design conditions. Conditioning of outside air is typically the largest load<br />

on any facility’s central heating and cooling plant. Limiting the quantity of outside air to be<br />

conditions provides significant savings in the cooling season and even larger savings in the<br />

heating season. Based on the assumptions above, a CO2 monitoring strategy could lower outside<br />

air ventilation rates to reduce the overall utility bills by approximately 15%.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 63 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

K. ECM #11: Chilled Water Economizer<br />

Description<br />

The cooling towers provide the heat rejection <strong>for</strong> the central<br />

cooling plant. This system typically provides condenser<br />

water at approximately 70°F-85°F in the cooling season. The<br />

building load is such that there is some cooling required year<br />

round. The cooling towers continue to provide a source of<br />

heat rejection year round <strong>for</strong> the chillers. Although the<br />

system adequately cools the chillers in the winter months,<br />

the cooling tower is capable of providing chilled water<br />

temperatures without the need <strong>for</strong> mechanical cooling. A<br />

heat exchanger installed between the condenser water<br />

system and chilled water system could take advantage of the<br />

“free cooling” provided by the cooling towers in the winter.<br />

Picture #18 – Typical Condenser<br />

Water Pumps and Piping.<br />

This ECM includes the installation of a plate & frame heat exchanger piped into the condenser<br />

water loop and chilled water loop to provide chilled water <strong>for</strong> the facility in cold ambient<br />

conditions. The ECM also requires the insulation of all condenser water piping to avoid<br />

condensation in the mechanical room.<br />

The <strong>energy</strong> model was simulated to take advantage of the<br />

cooling tower’s free cooling throughout the winter months.<br />

The model however was not able to account <strong>for</strong> any<br />

substantial cooling load in the winter months where “free<br />

cooling” could be utilized. The primary reason <strong>for</strong> these<br />

results is due to the facility’s use of air side economizers on<br />

the majority of the AHUs throughout the building. The<br />

savings was there<strong>for</strong>e negligible and no further calculations<br />

were per<strong>for</strong>med.<br />

Picture #19 – Example Plate &<br />

Frame Heat Exchangers<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 64 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

VIII.<br />

RENEWABLE/DISTRIBUTED ENERGY MEASURES<br />

Description:<br />

The PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> power requirements are substantial. Compared to the usable roof area<br />

available, the electrical needs of the building far surpass<br />

the potential <strong>for</strong> a solar PV system to provide a<br />

significant portion of the building’s usage. Despite the<br />

limited capability <strong>for</strong> gross electric production, there is<br />

some potential to shed peak demand draw of the facility<br />

especially during summer operation. Globally, renewable<br />

<strong>energy</strong> has become a priority affecting international and<br />

domestic <strong>energy</strong> policy. A renewable <strong>energy</strong> source can<br />

greatly reduce a building’s operating expenses while<br />

producing clean environmentally friendly <strong>energy</strong>. CEG<br />

has assessed the feasibility of installing renewable <strong>energy</strong><br />

measures <strong>for</strong> the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> utilizing<br />

renewable technologies.<br />

The <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Main Hall roof structure is a barrel roof slopping east to west. A<br />

difficulty which arises with this roof is the steepness of the down slope on the barrels; the curve<br />

is very steep until it reaches closer to the apex of the curve at which it is nearly flat. In light of<br />

this, roof penetrations will be necessary to secure the panels. Each barrel has an approximate<br />

width of 10 to 12 feet to install panels, and will allow a maximum row of approximately eight (8)<br />

panels across. These rows can be installed the entire length of the roof, which is approximately<br />

172 feet, including the avoidance of mechanical equipment and setbacks. The panels would be<br />

set with no pitch angle to maximize the number of panels that can be installed. In addition the<br />

roof truss system will also need to be rein<strong>for</strong>ced to accommodate the roof loading from the panel<br />

installation, which is can range from 30 to 40 pounds per panel.<br />

The most beneficial installation of a solar PV system would need to utilize the maximum roof<br />

area available. The system size based on preliminary review of the area and available slow<br />

slopped barrel roof is approximately 400 KW. This<br />

system represents a reduction in peak demand of<br />

approximately 100 KW (estimated <strong>for</strong> simultaneous<br />

peaks). The reduction of peak electrical draw will<br />

reduce the utility demand and usage charges as well<br />

as lower the 80% demand ratchet set point <strong>for</strong> non<br />

summer month electric usage.<br />

Solar <strong>energy</strong> produces clean <strong>energy</strong> and reduces a<br />

building’s carbon footprint. This is accomplished via<br />

photovoltaic panels which will be mounted on all<br />

south and southwestern facades of the building. Flat<br />

Picture #20 – Typical Barrel Roof<br />

Structure<br />

Picture #21 – Example Flat Roof Solar PV<br />

Array<br />

roof, as well as sloped areas can be utilized; flat areas will have the panels turned to an optimum<br />

solar absorbing angle. (A structural survey of the roof would be necessary be<strong>for</strong>e the installation<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 65 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

of PV panels is considered). Although many different types of solar panels are available, our<br />

experience has proven success with the use of mono-crystaline photovoltaic solar panels due to<br />

its reliability and efficiency.<br />

Further analysis is required to quantify <strong>energy</strong> production and savings as a result of the<br />

installation of a solar photovoltaic system. Per the direction of the owner our preliminary<br />

analysis satisfies PCCA’s requirements <strong>for</strong> this <strong>energy</strong> <strong>audit</strong>.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 66 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

IX.<br />

ENERGY PURCHASING AND PROCUREMENT STRATEGY<br />

A. LOAD PROFILE:<br />

Load Profile analysis was per<strong>for</strong>med to determine the seasonal <strong>energy</strong> usage of the facility.<br />

Irregularities in the load profile will indicate potential problems within the facility. The load<br />

profile provides a basis <strong>for</strong> recommendations and ultimate effectiveness of ECMs. For this<br />

<strong>report</strong>, the facility’s <strong>energy</strong> consumption data was gathered in table <strong>for</strong>mat and plotted in graph<br />

<strong>for</strong>m to create the load profile. Refer to The Electric and Natural Gas Usage Profiles included<br />

within this <strong>report</strong> to reference the respective electricity and natural gas usage load profiles.<br />

Electricity:<br />

The Electric Usage Profile demonstrates a fairly typical demand load profile with a non-typical<br />

usage profile. The summer (June-September) demonstrates increased demand with decreased<br />

consumption. This counter intuitive profile is the result of fewer events being held in the summer<br />

months compared to the other seasons. Despite the decrease in overall usage, the building still<br />

manages to set the highest demand (KW) values in the summer months. This is due to the use of<br />

the large electric centrifugal chillers. Even though overall occupancy is down, there are still a<br />

few events which require significant cooling load <strong>for</strong> short periods of time. Demand<br />

measurements are set 15 minute intervals, so the effect of a building’s load however short will be<br />

quite enough time to max out demand.<br />

There is a fairly steady yearlong electric usage profile which points to large continuous loads that<br />

operate year long. Lighting throughout the building represents a significant load that contributes<br />

to overall usage. Non-heating and cooling equipment such as the commercial kitchen electric<br />

steamers and ovens also contribute to the building’s base loads.<br />

Currently the electric utility is regulated and follows the fixed guidelines of PECO’s electric<br />

tariff. Deregulation will provide third party suppliers to compete <strong>for</strong> end user <strong>energy</strong> supply.<br />

When shopping <strong>for</strong> third party supply <strong>energy</strong> a flat load profile will allow <strong>for</strong> more competitive<br />

<strong>energy</strong> prices. The characteristic of a flat load profile is consistent use of <strong>energy</strong> year round<br />

(blocks of <strong>energy</strong>). Due to the reduction in <strong>energy</strong> use in the summer months, the PA <strong>Convention</strong><br />

<strong>Center</strong> is situated in a more advantageous position <strong>for</strong> purchasing third party <strong>energy</strong> supply.<br />

Natural Gas:<br />

The Natural Gas Usage Profile demonstrates a very typical natural gas (heat load) profile. The<br />

summer months demonstrate lower but not eliminated consumption (May through September).<br />

There is an increase in consumption in November through April. The summer gas usage is a<br />

result of the absorption chillers being utilized <strong>for</strong> the part load cooling condition of the building.<br />

Natural gas boilers in the central heating plant are primarily responsible <strong>for</strong> the heating season<br />

natural gas load. A base-load shaping (flat profile) will secure more competitive <strong>energy</strong> prices<br />

when procuring <strong>for</strong> a third party supplier.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 67 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

B. TARIFF ANALYSIS:<br />

Electricity:<br />

The facility electric service is provided to PECO Energy under its HT Rate Structure. (See the<br />

Utility Summary under the Facility Description). This rate structure in combination with the<br />

Night Rider Service is designed to tax facilities which use power draw during On Peak Summer<br />

months. Conversely, <strong>energy</strong> pricing is greatly reduced during Off Peak and Winter months. The<br />

major factor in <strong>energy</strong> prices is a result of the demand charges. The demand measurements set<br />

the ratchet value as well as the usage costs based on the tiered structure. Time of day usage is an<br />

important component as well based on the peak schedule. The Night Rider Service effectively<br />

allows users to draw high demand loads without incurring any additional demand or demand<br />

ratchet penalties. The overall analysis of this rate structure suggests minimizing the facilities use<br />

of electricity during On Peak periods and move to Off-Peak.<br />

Natural Gas:<br />

This facility receives natural gas service through Philadelphia Gas Works under its Interruptible<br />

Rate Structure (See the Utility Summary under the Facility Description). This rate structure<br />

provides a more favorable gas price to the end user with the requirement that the utility may<br />

request an interruption of gas service to the facility. Under this rate structure the facility is<br />

required to possess an alternative means of heating in the event of gas interruption. Customers<br />

may either purchase gas supply from a Third Party (TPS) or from PGW default service as<br />

detailed in the rate schedule.<br />

The customer can elect to have the Supply Charge (Commodity Charge) serviced through the<br />

utility or by a Third Party Supplier (TPS). Note: Should the TPS not deliver, the customer may<br />

receive service from PGW under Emergency Sales Service. Emergency Sales Service carries an<br />

extremely high penalty cost of service. Should the TPS un-deliver to the utility on behalf of the<br />

client, the utility will automatically supply this default service to the client.<br />

Imbalances occur when Third Party Suppliers are used to supply natural gas, full-delivery is not<br />

made, and when a new supplier is contracted or the customer returns to the utility. It is important<br />

when utilizing a Third Party Supplier, that an experienced regional supplier is used. Otherwise,<br />

imbalances can occur, jeopardizing economics and scheduling.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 68 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

C. RECOMMENDATIONS:<br />

The average cost <strong>for</strong> electricity in PA is $0.0908 per KWH. The PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong>’s<br />

average cost <strong>for</strong> electricity is $0.111 per KWH. The overall analysis of the electric rate structure<br />

suggests minimizing the facilities use of electricity during On Peak periods and move to Off-<br />

Peak. In the future unregulated electrical market, the best approach <strong>for</strong> the facility is to prove that<br />

the building has the tools available to tailor the electric profile the most advantageously <strong>for</strong><br />

<strong>energy</strong> suppliers.<br />

PECO Energy Smart Returns program is another option available <strong>for</strong> this facility to take<br />

advantage of reduced <strong>energy</strong> costs. The Smart Returns program offers the end user to take<br />

advantage of the high cost of <strong>energy</strong> during peak demand spikes in the grid by reducing the<br />

building’s demand when notified by the utility. The sale of excess <strong>energy</strong> at these periods of<br />

heightened <strong>energy</strong> costs are shared with the end user as a result. The program is available <strong>for</strong> all<br />

through either a volunteer program or mandatory program. The volunteer program also known as<br />

“Voluntary Load Reduction – VLR” is a flexible cost saving program based on participation<br />

during high wholesale <strong>energy</strong> market pricing. The mandatory program also known as<br />

“Interruptible Load <strong>for</strong> Reliability – ILR” offers guaranteed savings through an up-front <strong>energy</strong><br />

cost price reduction (High savings).<br />

The average price <strong>for</strong> natural gas in <strong>Pennsylvania</strong> was $1.41 per Therm in 2008. The average<br />

price <strong>for</strong> natural gas in <strong>Pennsylvania</strong> in the second half of 2009 was approximately $1.12 per<br />

Therm. Based on the current market pricing and comparison to the facility’s current cost of $1.48<br />

Therm, the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> could improve its natural gas costs by up to 25%. It is<br />

recommended that the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> receive further advisement on these prices through<br />

an <strong>energy</strong> advisor to assist procurement of <strong>energy</strong> (natural gas) through third party suppliers.<br />

It is also recommended that the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> schedule a meeting with the current<br />

utility providers to review their utility charges and current tariff structures <strong>for</strong> electricity and<br />

natural gas. This meeting would provide insight regarding alternative procurement options that<br />

are currently available. Through a meeting with the Local Distribution Company (LDC), the<br />

facility can learn more about the competitive supply process. A list of approved Third Party<br />

Suppliers should be reviewed. PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> should consider using a billing-<strong>audit</strong>ing<br />

service to further analyze the utility invoices, manage the data and use the in<strong>for</strong>mation <strong>for</strong><br />

ongoing demand-side management projects. Furthermore, special attention should be given to<br />

credit mechanisms, imbalances, balancing charges and commodity charges when meeting with<br />

the utility representative. It is important to fully understand all of the billing options available,<br />

such as consolidated billing when utilizing the service of a Third Party Supplier. If the supplier<br />

<strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> (natural gas) is changed, closely monitor balancing, particularly when the contract is<br />

close to termination. This could be per<strong>for</strong>med with the aid of an “<strong>energy</strong> advisor”.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 69 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

X. INSTALLATION FUNDING OPTIONS<br />

CEG has reviewed various funding options <strong>for</strong> the facility owner to utilize in subsidizing the<br />

costs <strong>for</strong> installing the <strong>energy</strong> conservation measures noted within this <strong>report</strong>. Below are a few<br />

alternative funding methods:<br />

• Guaranteed Energy Savings Act (GESA) – Public Law Act 77 (2003) authorizes<br />

government entities to make <strong>energy</strong> related improvements to their facilities and<br />

par <strong>for</strong> the costs using the value of <strong>energy</strong> savings that result from the<br />

improvements. The Program provides a procurement tool that to be utilized<br />

between the public entity and a qualified Energy Service Company (ESCO). The<br />

GESA process is intended to assist public entities with the decision to select the<br />

best qualified company that provides the maximum benefit to the owner. The<br />

program provides a flexible approach that can allow the agencies in<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> to improve and reduce <strong>energy</strong> usage with minimal expenditure of<br />

new financial resources. The end result is a per<strong>for</strong>mance contract where the<br />

ESCO provides design build services and guarantees the <strong>energy</strong> savings<br />

including maintenance costs <strong>for</strong> a period of up to 15 years.<br />

• Municipal Bonds – Municipal bonds are a bond issued by a city or other local<br />

government, or their agencies. Potential issuers of municipal bonds include<br />

cities, counties, redevelopment agencies, school districts, publicly owned<br />

airports and seaports, and any other governmental entity (or group of<br />

governments) below the state level. Municipal bonds may be general obligations<br />

of the issuer or secured by specified revenues. Interest income received by<br />

holders of municipal bonds is often exempt from the federal income tax and from<br />

the income tax of the state in which they are issued, although municipal bonds<br />

issued <strong>for</strong> certain purposes may not be tax exempt.<br />

• Power Purchase Agreement – Public Law 2008, Chapter 3 authorizes contractor<br />

of up to fifteen (15) years <strong>for</strong> contracts commonly known as “power purchase<br />

agreements.” These are programs where the contracting unit (Owner) procures a<br />

contract <strong>for</strong>, in most cases, a third party to install, maintain, and own a renewable<br />

<strong>energy</strong> system. These renewable <strong>energy</strong> systems are typically solar panels,<br />

windmills or other systems that create renewable <strong>energy</strong>. In exchange <strong>for</strong> the<br />

third party’s work of installing, maintaining and owning the renewable <strong>energy</strong><br />

system, the contracting unit (Owner) agrees to purchase the power generated by<br />

the renewable <strong>energy</strong> system from the third party at agreed upon <strong>energy</strong> rates.<br />

CEG recommends the Owner review the use of the above-listed funding options in addition to<br />

utilizing their standard method of financing <strong>for</strong> facilities upgrades in order to fund the proposed<br />

<strong>energy</strong> conservation measures.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 70 of 71


<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Energy Audit<br />

XI.<br />

ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS<br />

The following recommendations were reviewed as part of the preliminary evaluations; however<br />

the savings were not substantial, and or adequate to justify the installation costs. These items<br />

although not suitable to self sustain with regards to the savings, can be considered as part of a<br />

bundled package. Other ECMs with substantial savings can be used to help fund other<br />

investment projects.<br />

• Cooling Tower Replacement - Due to the age and wear and tear, the existing cooling<br />

towers are at their approximate end of life. Efficiency improvements from new cooling<br />

towers are very minimal. The major savings is in water consumption; however these<br />

savings are not large enough to support a cooling tower replacement project.<br />

• Envelope Improvements - Window replacements and other envelope improvements<br />

typically well exceed the <strong>energy</strong> saving improvements. The PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> has<br />

double pane clear glass windows as part of a curtain wall system. Due to the use of the<br />

building and condition of the existing envelope, replacement of this system to a new<br />

envelope with higher thermal and reflective properties, would be a considerable first cost<br />

and expected to have small overall <strong>energy</strong> savings.<br />

• In addition to the recommendations above, implementing Retro-Commissioning would be<br />

beneficial <strong>for</strong> this facility. Retro-Commissioning is a means to verify your current<br />

equipment is operating at its designed efficiency, capacity, airflow, and overall<br />

per<strong>for</strong>mance. Retro-Commissioning provides valuable insight into systems or<br />

components not per<strong>for</strong>ming correctly or efficiently. The commissioning process defines<br />

the original system design parameters and recommends revisions to the current system<br />

operating characteristics.<br />

Concord Engineering Group, Inc.<br />

1C09067<br />

February 22, 2009 Page 71 of 71


APPENDIX A<br />

1 of 1<br />

ECM COST & SAVINGS BREAKDOWN<br />

CONCORD ENGINEERING GROUP<br />

ECM ENERGY AND FINANCIAL COSTS AND SAVINGS SUMMARY<br />

PA CONVENTION CENTER<br />

ECM NO.<br />

DESCRIPTION<br />

MATERIALS & LABOR<br />

INSTALLATION COST<br />

MISC<br />

NET<br />

INSTALLATION<br />

COST<br />

YEARLY SAVINGS<br />

ECM<br />

LIFETIME<br />

SIMPLE PAYBACK<br />

ENERGY MAINT. TOTAL (Net cost / Yearly Savings)<br />

INTERNAL RATE OF<br />

RETURN (IRR)<br />

NET PRESENT VALUE<br />

(NPV)<br />

($) ($) ($) ($/Yr) ($/Yr) ($/Yr) (Yr) (Yr) ($) ($)<br />

ECM #1 Condensing Boiler $191,545 $47,886 $239,431 $21,575 $0 $21,575 25 11.1 7.55% $136,257.41<br />

ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade $812,365 $0 $812,365 $157,170 $23,487 $180,657 15 4.5 20.96% $1,344,306.54<br />

ECM #3<br />

Lighting System Upgrade with Light<br />

Controls<br />

$114,400 $0 $114,400 $42,463 $0 $42,463 15 2.7 36.78% $392,520.54<br />

ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller $399,950 $99,988 $499,938 $71,266 $0 $71,266 23 7.0 13.48% $671,932.70<br />

ECM #5 Centrifugal Chiller VFD Retrofit $550,000 $82,500 $632,500 $5,113 $0 $5,113 17 123.7 -16.49% ($565,181.64)<br />

ECM #6 Demand Response Controls $51,000 $17,850 $68,850 $58,322 $0 $58,322 15 1.2 84.70% $627,394.25<br />

ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls $102,190 $0 $102,190 $51,927 $0 $51,927 15 2.0 50.71% $517,711.16<br />

ECM #8 Domestic Water Booster Pump Package $86,225 $21,556 $107,781 $5,328 $0 $5,328 20 20.2 -0.11% ($28,514.06)<br />

ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage $775,850 $193,963 $969,813 $121,541 $0 $121,541 23 8.0 11.51% $1,028,760.11<br />

ECM #10<br />

Demand Control Ventilation & VFD Fan<br />

Control<br />

$1,490,160 $372,540 $1,862,700 $436,421 ($18,700) $417,721 15 4.5 21.17% $3,124,026.18<br />

Notes:<br />

1) The variable Cn in the <strong>for</strong>mulas <strong>for</strong> Internal Rate of Return and Net Present Value stands <strong>for</strong> the cash flow during each period.<br />

2) The variable DR in the NPV equation stands <strong>for</strong> Discount Rate<br />

3) For NPV and IRR calculations: From n=0 to N periods where N is the lifetime of ECM and Cn is the cash flow during each period .


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 1<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Boilers<br />

Tag Boiler-1 & 2<br />

Unit Type<br />

Hot Water - 4-Pass Fire<br />

Tube<br />

Qty 2<br />

Location<br />

Area Served<br />

Central Plant<br />

Mezzanine<br />

Whole Building<br />

Manufacturer<br />

Model #<br />

Cleaver Brooks<br />

CB-LE-500<br />

Serial #<br />

Input Capacity (MBH) 20,415<br />

Rated Output Capacity<br />

(MBH)<br />

16,740<br />

Approx. Efficiency % 82%<br />

Design GPM 1,675<br />

Design EWT / LWT 160°F / 180°F<br />

Fuel<br />

Nat Gas, Oil (backup)<br />

Approx Age 4<br />

Ashrae Service Life 25<br />

Remaining Life 21<br />

Comments<br />

High 10:1 turndown, VFD<br />

drive on combusion fan, Lo-<br />

NOx burner at 30 PPM, 20<br />

HP Fan, 7.5 HP Comb Air<br />

HP.


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 2<br />

Chillers<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Tag CH-1 & 2 CH-3 & 4<br />

Direct Fired Absorption Water Cooled<br />

Unit Type<br />

Chillers Centrifugal Chillers<br />

Qty 2 2<br />

Location Central Plant Mezz Central Plant Mezz<br />

Area Served<br />

Chilled Water Loop /<br />

Heating Water Loop<br />

Chilled Water Loop<br />

Manufacturer York York<br />

Model #<br />

YPC-FD019S-46-H-S-<br />

D<br />

YKWHVDJ4-DEF<br />

Serial #<br />

Cooling Type<br />

Absorption - Lithium<br />

Bromide<br />

Centrifugal - R-134A<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 705 1,700<br />

Cooling Efficiency (Full<br />

Load)<br />

1.0 (COP) 0.562 (KW/Ton)<br />

Cooling Efficiency (IPLV) 1.162 (COP) 0.490 (KW/Ton)<br />

Design GPM (Chilled<br />

Water)<br />

1,055 2,550<br />

Design EWT / LWT<br />

(Chilled Water)<br />

60°F / 44°F 58°F / 42°F<br />

Design GPM (Condenser<br />

Water)<br />

2,700 5,000<br />

Design EWT / LWT<br />

(Condenser Water)<br />

58°F / 42°F 85°F / 94.4°F<br />

Heating Type Gas Direct Fired None<br />

Heating Input (MBH) 8,348 NA<br />

Heating Output (MBH) 6,866 NA<br />

Efficiency % 82% NA<br />

Fuel Nat Gas Electric<br />

Approx Age 4 4<br />

Ashrae Service Life 23 23<br />

Remaining Life 19 19<br />

Comments<br />

Heating and ventilation unit<br />

only. Dedicated <strong>for</strong> gym<br />

entrance hallway<br />

3 pass chilled water, 2 pass<br />

condenser water, single<br />

speed compressor motor.


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 3<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Cooling Tower Units<br />

Tag CT-1 CT-2 CT-3<br />

Unit Type<br />

Counter Flow Draft<br />

Induced<br />

Counter Flow Draft<br />

Induced<br />

Counter Flow Draft<br />

Induced<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Central Plant Roof Central Plant Roof Central Plant Roof<br />

Area Served CH/H-1 CH/H-2 CH/H-3<br />

Manufacturer<br />

Model # BAC IMT 1250-2 BAC IMT 1250-2 BAC IMT 975-2<br />

AMB. WB 78 78 78<br />

EWT 100 100 100<br />

LWT 85 85 85<br />

GPM/Cell 3000 (2945 future) 3000 (2945 future) (2360) Future<br />

MHP/Fan 75 75 50<br />

Fan V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Heater KW/Cell 5/cell @ 16KW 5/cell @ 16KW<br />

Heater V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 20 20 20<br />

Remaining Life 3 3 3<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 4<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Pumps<br />

Tag P-1 P-10 & P-11 &P-12 P-13 & P-14<br />

Unit Type<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal Double<br />

Suction<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal Double<br />

Suction<br />

In-Line<br />

Qty 1 3 2<br />

Location Central Plant Central Plant Fan Room 1A<br />

Area Served Condenser Water/CH-2 Secondary CHWS & R HWS & R<br />

Manufacturer B&G Aurora Aurora<br />

Model #<br />

HSC 8x10x12L Model<br />

150<br />

410 - 6x8x18B ES 380-2x2x9A<br />

Horse Power 100 200 2<br />

GPM 2800 2000 56<br />

FT Head (TDH) 100 250 50<br />

Motor Info ODP ODP ODP<br />

Electrical Power 460 V, 3 PH 480V, 3PH 480 V, 3 PH<br />

RPM 1775 1750 1750<br />

Motor Efficiency %<br />

Approx Age<br />

Ashrae Service Life 20 20 20<br />

Remaining Life 20 20 20<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 5<br />

Pumps Continued<br />

Tag P-15 & P-16 P-17 & P-18 P-19 & P-20<br />

Unit Type In-Line In-Line In-Line<br />

Qty 2 2 2<br />

Location Fan Room 5 Fan Room 8 Fan Room 1B<br />

Area Served HWS & R HWS & R HWS & R<br />

Manufacturer Aurora Aurora Aurora<br />

Model # ES 380-2x2x9A ES 380-2x2x9A ES 380-2x2x9A<br />

Horse Power 2 3 3<br />

GPM 46 90 93<br />

FT Head (TDH) 50 50 50<br />

Motor Info ODP ODP ODP<br />

Electrical Power 480 V, 3 PH 480 V, 3 PH 480 V, 3 PH<br />

RPM 1750 1750 1750<br />

Motor Efficiency %<br />

Approx Age<br />

Ashrae Service Life 20 20 20<br />

Remaining Life 20 20 20<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 6<br />

Pumps Continued<br />

Tag P-21 & P-22 P-4 & P-7 P-23<br />

Unit Type<br />

In-Line<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal Double<br />

Suction<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal Double<br />

Suction<br />

Qty 2 2 1<br />

Location Fan Room 4 Central Plant Central Plant<br />

Area Served<br />

HWS & R<br />

Condenser Water/CH-3<br />

& CH-4<br />

Condenser Water/CH-1<br />

Manufacturer Aurora B&G B&G<br />

Model #<br />

ES 380-2x2x9A<br />

HSC 10x12x12 Model<br />

150<br />

HSC 8x10x12L Model<br />

150<br />

Horse Power 2 150 100<br />

GPM 69 5000 2800<br />

FT Head (TDH) 50 96 100<br />

Motor Info<br />

ODP<br />

Electrical Power 480 V, 3 PH 460 V, 3 PH 460 V, 3 PH<br />

RPM 1750 1775 1780<br />

Motor Efficiency %<br />

Approx Age<br />

Ashrae Service Life 20 20 20<br />

Remaining Life 20 20 20<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 7<br />

Pumps Continued<br />

Tag P-2 & P-24 P-5 & P-8 P-3 & P-25<br />

Unit Type<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal Double<br />

Suction<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal Double<br />

Suction<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal Double<br />

Suction<br />

Qty 2 2 1<br />

Location Central Plant Central Plant Central Plant<br />

Area Served<br />

Primary Chilled<br />

Water/CH-1<br />

Primary Chilled<br />

Water/CH-3 & CH-4<br />

Primary Hot Water/CH-<br />

2 & CH-1<br />

Manufacturer B&G B&G B&G<br />

Model # HSC 6x8x12L HSC 6x8x12<br />

HSC 6x8x12l Model<br />

150<br />

Horse Power 25 60 50<br />

GPM 1055 2700 672<br />

FT Head (TDH) 60 60 125<br />

Motor Info<br />

Electrical Power 460 V, 3 PH 460 V, 3 PH 460 V, 3 PH<br />

RPM 1755 1765 1775<br />

Motor Efficiency %<br />

Approx Age<br />

Ashrae Service Life 20 20 20<br />

Remaining Life 20 20 20<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 8<br />

Pumps Continued<br />

Tag P-6 P-9 P-B-1 & P-B-2<br />

Floor Mount Floor Mount<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Unit Type<br />

Centrifugal Double Centrifugal Double<br />

Centrifugal<br />

Suction<br />

Suction<br />

Qty 1 2 2<br />

Location Central Plant Central Plant<br />

Area Served Primary Hot Water/B-2 Primary Hot Water/B-1 Hot Water/B-1 & B-2<br />

Manufacturer B&G B&G B&G<br />

Model #<br />

HSC 8x8x12S Model<br />

150<br />

HSC 8x8x12S Model<br />

150<br />

4x4x7 Series 80-SC<br />

Horse Power 75 75 2<br />

GPM 1675 1675 250<br />

FT Head (TDH) 115 112 20<br />

Motor Info<br />

Electrical Power 460 V, 3 PH 460 V, 3 PH 460 V, 3 PH<br />

RPM 1780 1780 1750<br />

Motor Efficiency %<br />

Approx Age<br />

Ashrae Service Life 20 20 20<br />

Remaining Life 20 20 20<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 9<br />

Pumps Continued<br />

Tag<br />

Unit Type<br />

P-FP-29A<br />

Floor Mount<br />

Centrifugal<br />

Qty 1<br />

Location<br />

Area Served<br />

Manufacturer<br />

Hot Water/AHU-29A<br />

B&G<br />

Model # 2x2x7 Series 60<br />

Horse Power 2<br />

GPM 167<br />

FT Head (TDH) 20<br />

Motor Info<br />

Electrical Power<br />

460 V, 3 PH<br />

RPM 1750<br />

Motor Efficiency %<br />

Approx Age<br />

Ashrae Service Life 20<br />

Remaining Life 20<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 10<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Packaged Rooftop Units<br />

Tag AHU-1 AHU-2 AHU-3<br />

Unit Type Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location<br />

Fan Room - 1A, Elev.<br />

37<br />

Fan Room - 1B, Elev.<br />

37<br />

Area Served 12th and 13th St. Conc. Mtg Rms - 101,102,103<br />

Type<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Fan Room - 1B, Elev.<br />

37<br />

Mtg Rms -<br />

104,105,106,017,108<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Manufacturer York York York<br />

Model # CS 402 SH (XF) CS 402 SH CS 402 SH<br />

Cooling Type Chilled Water Chilled Water Chilled Water<br />

CFM 21,800 18,700 20,000<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 55 114 122<br />

GPM 83 171 183<br />

ΔT 16 16 16<br />

Heating Type Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 519 782 836<br />

GPM 52 78 84<br />

ΔT 20 20 20<br />

Approx. Age 5 5 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life 10 10 10<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 11<br />

Packaged Rooftop Units Continued<br />

Tag AHU-4 AHU-5 AHU-6<br />

Unit Type Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location<br />

Area Served<br />

Type<br />

Fan Room - 1A, Elev.<br />

37<br />

Meeting Room 108,<br />

Lecture 114<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Fan Room - 1A, Elev.<br />

37<br />

Mtg Rooms 108-112<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Fan Room - 2, Elev. 37<br />

W. Arch Street<br />

Concourse<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Manufacturer York York York<br />

Model # CS 490 SH CS 402 SH CS 402 SH<br />

Cooling Type Chilled Water Chilled Water Chilled Water<br />

CFM 22,300 19,100 20,700<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 137 117 49<br />

GPM 206 176 74<br />

ΔT 16 16 16<br />

Heating Type Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 826 798 322<br />

GPM 83 80 32<br />

ΔT 20 20 20<br />

Approx. Age 5 5 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life 10 10 10<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 12<br />

Packaged Rooftop Units Continued<br />

Tag<br />

AHU-7<br />

AHU-8A&B Thru<br />

14A&B<br />

AHU-15<br />

Unit Type Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Fan Room - 4, Elev. 50 Roof, Elev. 76 Fan Room - 5, Elev.89<br />

Area Served<br />

Admin, E. Arch Street<br />

Concourse<br />

Exhibit Hall A-C<br />

W Arch Street<br />

Concourse, Mtg.<br />

Type<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Custum Rooftop Blow<br />

Through<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Manufacturer York Air Enterprises York<br />

Model # CS 578 SH CS 402 SH<br />

Cooling Type Chilled Water Chilled Water Chilled Water<br />

CFM 26,700 54,550 18,800<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 67 209 76<br />

GPM 101 314 114<br />

ΔT 16 16 16<br />

Heating Type Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coils Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 532 456 / 960 245<br />

GPM 53 46 / 96 25<br />

ΔT 20 20 / 20 20<br />

Approx. Age 5 5 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life 10 10 10<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 13<br />

Packaged Rooftop Units Continued<br />

Tag AHU-16 AHU-17 AHU-18<br />

Unit Type Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Fan Room - 6, Elev.89 Fan Room - 8, Elev.89 Fan Room -7, Elev.89<br />

Area Served<br />

E Arch Street<br />

Concourse, Mtg.<br />

E Arch Street<br />

Concourse, Mtg.<br />

E Arch Street<br />

Concourse, Mtg.<br />

Type<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Manufacturer York York York<br />

Model # CS 402 SH CS 336 SH CS 336 SH<br />

Cooling Type Chilled Water Chilled Water Chilled Water<br />

CFM 18,400 17,300 16,800<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 66 69 91<br />

GPM 99 104 137<br />

ΔT 16 16 16<br />

Heating Type Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 248 281 293/325<br />

GPM 25 28 29/33<br />

ΔT 20 20 20<br />

Approx. Age 5 5 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life 10 10 10<br />

Comments<br />

High Efficiency Mixing<br />

Box. Up requirements


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 14<br />

Packaged Rooftop Units Continued<br />

Tag AHU-19 AHU-20 AHU-21<br />

Unit Type Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Fan Room - 3, Elev. 37 Fan Room - 3, Elev. 37 Fan Room - 8, Elev.89<br />

Area Served Lockers, BOH Shops Kitchen (Elev. 38)<br />

Type<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Reg. Bridge, Café<br />

Diner<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Manufacturer York York York<br />

Model # CS 336 DH CS 490 SV CS 578 SH<br />

Cooling Type Chilled Water Chilled Water Chilled Water<br />

CFM 15,400 25,000 28,300<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 57 108 123<br />

GPM 86 162 185<br />

ΔT 16 16 16<br />

Heating Type Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 188 592 549/552<br />

GPM 19 59 55<br />

ΔT 20 20 20<br />

Approx. Age 5 5 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life 10 10 10<br />

Comments<br />

High Efficiency Mixing<br />

Box.<br />

High Efficiency Mixing Box High Efficiency Mixing<br />

Box. Up requirements


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 15<br />

Packaged Rooftop Units Continued<br />

Tag<br />

AHU-22 AHU-23 thru AHU-26 AHU-27<br />

Unit Type Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location<br />

Fan Room - 9, Elev.89<br />

Fan Room - 10, Elev.<br />

37<br />

Fan Room - 14, Elev.<br />

37<br />

Area Served Exhibit Hall D Exhibit Hall D Exhibit Hall D<br />

Type<br />

Builtup Horizontal<br />

Blow Through<br />

Builtup Horizontal<br />

Blow Through<br />

Builtup Horizontal<br />

Blow Through<br />

Manufacturer<br />

Model # Miller Picking 21-48 Miller Picking 21-48 Miller Picking 21-48<br />

Cooling Type Chilled Water Chilled Water Chilled Water<br />

CFM 42,800 43,900 39,400<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 177 181 163<br />

GPM 266 272 245<br />

ΔT 16 16 16<br />

Heating Type Hot Water Coils Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 467 / 777 479 / 797 433 / 715<br />

GPM 47 / 78 48 / 80 43 / 72<br />

ΔT 20 20 20<br />

Approx. Age 5 5 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life 10 10 10<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 16<br />

Packaged Rooftop Units Continued<br />

Tag AHU-28 AHU-29 HV-1<br />

Unit Type Heating and Cooling Heating and Cooling Heating Only<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Shed, Elev. 81 Central Plant Fan Room-3, Elev. 37<br />

Area Served Kitchen, Elev. 81 Central Plant Kitchen, Elev. 38<br />

Type<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

Manufacturer York York York<br />

Model # CS 270 SH CS 666/754G CS 402 FO<br />

Cooling Type Chilled Water Chilled Water NA<br />

CFM 12,900 35,000 26,200<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons) 45 174 NA<br />

GPM 68 221 NA<br />

ΔT 16 16 NA<br />

Heating Type Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 695 668 1470<br />

GPM 70 67 147<br />

ΔT 20 20 20<br />

Approx. Age 5 5 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life 10 10 10<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 17<br />

Packaged Rooftop Units Continued<br />

Tag<br />

HV-2<br />

Unit Type<br />

Heating Only<br />

Qty 1<br />

Location Fan Room-8, Elev. 89<br />

Area Served Kitchen, Elev. 88<br />

Type<br />

Manufacturer<br />

Model #<br />

Cooling Type<br />

Packaged Horizontal<br />

Draw Through<br />

York<br />

CS 156 FO<br />

NA<br />

CFM 12,975<br />

Cooling Capacity (Tons)<br />

GPM<br />

NA<br />

NA<br />

ΔT<br />

NA<br />

Heating Type<br />

Hot Water Coil<br />

Heating (MBH) 728<br />

GPM 73<br />

ΔT 20<br />

Approx. Age 5<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15<br />

Remaining Life 10<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 18<br />

Packaged AC Units<br />

Tag<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

AC-1 & AC-2<br />

AC-3<br />

AC-4, AC-5, AC-6, &<br />

AC-7<br />

Qty 2 1 4<br />

Location Rm. 36E058 & 36E059 Rm. 36E071 Rm. 36E072, 75, 81<br />

Area Served Retail Retail Retail<br />

Type<br />

Packaged Draw<br />

Through<br />

Packaged Draw<br />

Through<br />

Packaged Draw<br />

Through<br />

Manufacturer York York York<br />

Model # D1HH-096 D1HH-060 D1HH-120<br />

Serial #<br />

Total CFM 3,000 2,000 3,200<br />

Evap. Coil MBH 73 51 85<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Total Amps 25 16 33<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 19<br />

Packaged AC Units Continued<br />

Tag<br />

AC-8<br />

AC-9 & AC-10<br />

Qty 1 1<br />

Location Rm. 36E082 37 E 041 & 63 W 088<br />

Area Served Retail Trash Comp<br />

Type<br />

Packaged Draw<br />

Through<br />

Packaged Draw<br />

Through<br />

Manufacturer York BSC<br />

Model # D1HH-060 ACS-3<br />

Total CFM 2,000 1,500<br />

Evap. Coil MBH 51 34<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Total Amps 16 8<br />

Approx Age 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15<br />

Remaining Life (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 20<br />

MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

<strong>Pennsylvania</strong> <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

Fans<br />

Tag EF-1 EF-2 EF-3<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Electric Room 5 Electric Room 7 Electric Room 3<br />

Area Served Electric Room 5 Electric Room 7 Electric Room 3<br />

Type Propeller Propeller Utility<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Penn Vent<br />

Model # BF36 BF24 TC BAF SW 402<br />

Total CFM 14,200 3,200 14,600<br />

SP (IN/WG) 0.50 0.30 3.00<br />

MHP 3.00 1.00 10.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,568<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 21<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag EF-4 EF-5 EF-6<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Electric Room 1 E.G.(Electric Room 1) Electric Room 2<br />

Area Served Electric Room 1 E.G.(Electric Room 1) Electric Room 2<br />

Type Propeller Roof Centrif. Exh. Propeller<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Penn Vent Penn Vent<br />

Model # BF48 LC12A BF48<br />

Total CFM 23,300 1,000 23,300<br />

SP (IN/WG) 0.30 0.25 0.30<br />

MHP 5.00 0.25 5.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining i Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 22<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag<br />

EF-7<br />

EF-8<br />

EF-<br />

9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,<br />

17,18,19,20<br />

Qty 1 1 12<br />

Location E.G.(Electric Room 2) Electric Room 4 Exhibit Hall A Roof<br />

Area Served E.G.(Electric Room 2) Electric Room 4 Exhibit Hall A<br />

Type Roof Centrif. Exh. Roof Centrif. Exh. Roof Centrif. Exh.<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Penn Vent Penn Vent<br />

Model # LC12A LC48A LC54A<br />

Total CFM 1,000 22,200 27,300<br />

SP (IN/WG) 0.25 0.30 0.50<br />

MHP 0.16 5.00 10.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 23<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag<br />

EF-<br />

21,22,23,24,25,26,27,2<br />

EF-<br />

29,30,31,32,33,34,35,3<br />

EF-37 & EF-38<br />

Qty 8 8 2<br />

Location Exhibit Hall B Roof Exhibit Hall C Roof Electric Room 6<br />

Area Served Exhibit Hall B Exhibit Hall C Electric Room 6<br />

Type Roof Centrif. Exh. Roof Centrif. Exh. Propeller<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Penn Vent Penn Vent<br />

Model # LC54A LC54A BF36<br />

Total CFM 27,300 27,300 10,800<br />

SP (IN/WG) 0.50 0.50 0.30<br />

MHP 10.00 10.00 2.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 24<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag EF-39 EF-40 EF-41,42,43,44,45,46<br />

Qty 1 1 6<br />

Location Fire Pump Room Gas Meter Room Exhibit Hall D<br />

Area Served Fire Pump Room Gas Meter Room Exhibit Hall D<br />

Type Propeller In-Line Cabinet DWDI Centrifugal<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Penn Vent<br />

Model # VF24 Z12 TDA T.C. BAF-DW365<br />

Total CFM 1,500 500 20,000<br />

SP (IN/WG) 0.50 0.50 0.50<br />

MHP 0.50 280 Watts 5.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining i Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 25<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag EF-47 TE-1 TE-2<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Elev. Mach. Rm. Level 63 Roof Level 89 Roof<br />

Area Served 37 E 005 Toilets -El. 63 Toilets -El. 36,50,63,76<br />

Type In-Line Cabinet Roof Centrif. Exh. Utility<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Penn Vent Twin City<br />

Model # Z15 TDA LC20A BCV270<br />

Total CFM 975 2,320 6,000<br />

SP (IN/WG) 0.50 1.00 2.00<br />

MHP 0.50 1.00 3.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining i Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 26<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag TE-3 TE-4 TE-5<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Level 89 Roof Level 63 Roof Level 89 Roof<br />

Area Served Toilets -El. 36,63,76 Toilets -El. 63 Toilets -El. 36,63,76<br />

Type Utility Roof Centrif. Exh. Utility<br />

Manufacturer Twin City Penn Vent Twin City<br />

Model # BCV270 LC40A BCV300<br />

Total CFM 5,670 5,620 6,185<br />

SP (IN/WG) 2.00 1.00 2.00<br />

MHP 3.00 3.00 3.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining i Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 27<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag TE-6 TE-7 TE-8<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location Level 63 Roof Level 89 Roof Shed Roof<br />

Area Served Toilets -El. 63 Toilets -El. 36,63 Toilets Bridge<br />

Type Roof Centrif. Exh. Utility Roof Centrif. Exh.<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Twin City Penn Vent<br />

Model # LC40A BCV300 LC20A<br />

Total CFM 4,410 8,445 3,285<br />

SP (IN/WG) 1.00 2.00 1.00<br />

MHP 2.00 5.00 2.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining i Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 28<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag<br />

TE-<br />

9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16<br />

VF-1,2<br />

Qty 8 2 1<br />

VF-3<br />

Location 36 E 058 12th St. Tunnel L 37 Loading Dock<br />

Area Served Retail Toilets 12th St. Tunnel Dock Exhaust<br />

Type In-Line Cabinet Vane Axial Vane Axial<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Joy Joy<br />

Model # Z6 TDA 34-16-1770 27 1/4-14-1770<br />

Total CFM 75 33,600 7,200<br />

SP (IN/WG) 0.25 2.20 1.50<br />

MHP 0.10 15.00 5.00<br />

RPM 737 1,770 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 29<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag VF-4 RF-7 KE-1<br />

Qty 1 1 1<br />

Location EH-D Dock Fan Room 4 Roof<br />

Area Served Dock Exhaust AHU-7 Return/Relief Kitchen Hoods - L 37<br />

Type Vane Axial Tubular Centrifugal SWSI centrifugal<br />

Manufacturer Joy Twin City Twin City<br />

Model # 36-21-1150 ASL445 BAF SW445<br />

Total CFM 13,200 23,400 42,575<br />

SP (IN/WG) 2.00 1.50 4.50<br />

MHP 10.00 10.00 40.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining i Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix B Major Equipment List -Page 30<br />

Fans Continued<br />

Tag KE-2,3,4 DWE-1 DWE-2<br />

Qty 3 1 1<br />

Location Level 89 Roof Roof Roof<br />

Area Served Kitchen Hoods - L 89 Dishwasher Exh. - L37 Dishwasher Exh. - L89<br />

Type Upblast Utility Roof Centrifugal Exh.<br />

Manufacturer Penn Vent Twin City Penn Vent<br />

Model # FMX 36 BFT BCV165 FMX18B<br />

Total CFM 14,615 1,000 2,000<br />

SP (IN/WG) 3.00 2.00 1.00<br />

MHP 15.00 2.00 1.00<br />

RPM 1,750 1,750 1,750<br />

V-PH-HZ 480-3-60 480-3-60 480-3-60<br />

Approx Age 17 17 17<br />

Ashrae Service Life 15 15 15<br />

Remaining i Life (2) (2) (2)<br />

Comments


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 1<br />

BURRIS ENGINEERS, INC.<br />

180 S. Main St, Suite 203<br />

Ambler, PA 19002<br />

(215) 643‐4465<br />

www.burrisengineers.com<br />

1/25/2010<br />

Concord Engineering Group<br />

520 S Burnt Mill Road<br />

Voorhees, NJ 08043<br />

Attention:<br />

RE:<br />

Jesse Ohm, P.E., Lead Mechanical Engineer<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project – Electrical Engineering Report<br />

Dear Mr. Ohm:<br />

Burris Engineers, Inc. (BEI) has been requested to per<strong>for</strong>m a feasibility analysis and summary of<br />

findings <strong>for</strong> four (4) specific Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs) that Concord Engineering plans to<br />

propose to the PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Authority (PCCA). As a note, the feasibility analysis and<br />

summary of findings is from an electrical engineering and installation perspective, and BEI did not<br />

verify if the proposed ECMs will necessarily conserve <strong>energy</strong>. The ECMs are as follows:<br />

1. Condensing Boiler Installation<br />

2. Supplemental Chiller Installation<br />

3. Demand Response Controls<br />

4. Measurement and Verification<br />

Assumptions<br />

The following is a list of assumptions used to create the <strong>report</strong>:<br />

1. The <strong>report</strong> is based on supplied as-built/record drawings. However, field visits were per<strong>for</strong>med<br />

to verify spacing requirements, and overall feasibility of installation<br />

2. The equipment and installation assumptions are based on a preliminary/schematic level of<br />

design, and there<strong>for</strong>e are high level estimates. Exact requirements, details, proposed locations of<br />

new equipment, etc. would be needed to provide better estimates<br />

3. The assumed man-hour rate <strong>for</strong> installation estimates is $100/man-hour. This assumes union<br />

labor per<strong>for</strong>ms the required installations in the City of Philadelphia<br />

4. All conductors are THHN copper, and the copper conductor cost is based on Southwire<br />

Commercial Distribution List Price Sheet – Copper Building Wire, dated January 7 th , 2010<br />

5. The average cost of an Emon Dmon meter with three (3) current trans<strong>for</strong>mers (CTs), CT wire<br />

leads, etc. is $800<br />

6. The estimated time to install one meter set-up (includes mounting of meter, CTs, EMT conduit,<br />

etc.) is 2 men/4 hours => 8 man-hours x $100/man-hour = $800


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 2<br />

Page 2 of 8<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report<br />

January 25 th , 2010<br />

7. The estimated cost of ¾” EMT conduit (assumes 50’ max) and miscellaneous materials <strong>for</strong> each<br />

meter installation is $100<br />

Condensing Boiler Installation<br />

The installation of a condensing boiler from an electrical engineering perspective is straight-<strong>for</strong>ward.<br />

Based on the provided equipment catalog cuts, the electrical power requirements <strong>for</strong> a typical gas-fired<br />

condensing boiler is minimal (15A @ 460V, 3PH). The power required <strong>for</strong> this installation is readily<br />

available on the main floor of the Mechanical Penthouse via one of the spare MCC cubicles. One of the<br />

spare MCC cubicles can be modified as required to have a 15A over-current protective device (OCPD)<br />

supply conductors that feed over to a new boiler installed somewhere on the main mechanical penthouse<br />

floor (the assumed total conduit run is 200’ max).<br />

The estimated electrical cost <strong>for</strong> this ECM is $2500, based on the following:<br />

1. 2 men/8 hours to modify MCC cubicle, install EMT conduit to boiler location (selected by<br />

others), and install conductors = $1600<br />

2. Conductor cost of (4) #12AWG conductors x 200’ x $0.453/ft = $365<br />

3. ¾” EMT @ $1/ft x 200’ = $200<br />

4. $335 in miscellaneous material, including 15A/3P breaker or fuse set-up<br />

5. BEI does not believe it is worthwhile to install a meter <strong>for</strong> this ECM since the electrical usage is<br />

small. However, if a meter is needed, add $1700 to the above total cost<br />

Figure 1 – Spare Cubicle in MCC-C4 (Typical <strong>for</strong> MCCs on Main Mechanical Penthouse Floor)


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 3<br />

Page 3 of 8<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report<br />

January 25 th , 2010<br />

Supplemental Chiller Installation<br />

The installation of a new 450 Ton chiller is more involved then the boiler, but is feasible. Based on the<br />

provided equipment catalog cuts, the electrical requirements <strong>for</strong> this size chiller is 329kW maximum,<br />

with maximum running load amps (RLA) of 455A. Assuming 80% power factor as worst case scenario,<br />

this translates into 411.25kVA or 495A at 480 3PH. Based on the National Electrical Code (NEC)<br />

Article 430, the minimum conductor size is based on 125% of full load amps (FLA) as dictated by the<br />

FLA tables of the Article. The FLA in those tables is determined by the motor’s horsepower (HP).<br />

However, since the HP is not given in the catalog cuts, and since the chiller may fall under NEC Article<br />

440 (Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Equipment) which allows the use of manufacturer nameplate<br />

data, the size of the conductors and OCPD will be determined by the amps stated above based on<br />

calculated kVA.<br />

The minimum circuit conductor ampacity <strong>for</strong> the proposed chiller based on a FLA of 495A is 619A.<br />

This ampacity can be achieved by 2 sets of 350kcmil conductors per phase <strong>for</strong> a total ampacity of 620A.<br />

The maximum OCPD <strong>for</strong> the motor circuit based on the use of an inverse-time circuit breaker is 250%<br />

of FLA per NEC Table 430.52. There<strong>for</strong>e, the maximum OCPD would be 1238A circuit breaker.<br />

Rounding down to the next lower standard size breaker provides a 1200A circuit breaker.<br />

Substations #7 & #8, which are located above the mechanical penthouse’s main floor, have many spare<br />

cubicles that can accommodate a 1200A breaker. There are even spare 1200A breakers that were used<br />

<strong>for</strong> temporary installations. From interviewing PCCA staff, BEI believes that the temporary is no longer<br />

needed. There<strong>for</strong>e, we will assume that the existing 1200A spare breaker can be used <strong>for</strong> the proposed<br />

chiller installation. We also believe that there is plenty of electrical capacity on each substation to<br />

accommodate the new chiller based on the previous use of temporary 1200A feeders.<br />

The estimated electrical cost <strong>for</strong> this ECM is $52,000, based on the following:<br />

1. 2 men/40 hours to install (2) 3” EMT conduits (including junction boxes, pull rope, etc.) from<br />

Substation #7 or #8 (which is above the main floor of the mechanical penthouse) to main floor<br />

and prepare <strong>for</strong> cable pull = $8000. This assumes the existing ceiling penetrations below each<br />

substation are available <strong>for</strong> use.<br />

2. 3 men/16 hours to install conductors, splice in any junction boxes installed, and make<br />

terminations on either side of pull = $4800<br />

3. Six (6) conductors (350kcmil) x 200’ x $21.55/ft = $25,860<br />

4. Two (2) conductors (3/0kcmil Ground) x 200’ x $10.46/ft = $4184<br />

5. 3” EMT @ $12/ft x 400’ = $4800


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 4<br />

Page 4 of 8<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report<br />

January 25 th , 2010<br />

6. Installation of a meter = $1700<br />

7. $2656 in miscellaneous materials, including cleaning and preparing the existing 1200A breaker<br />

<strong>for</strong> re-use<br />

Figure 2 – Spare 1200A Breaker and cubicles in Substation #7 (similar <strong>for</strong> Substation #8)<br />

Figure 3 – Ceiling Penetration below Substation #7 & Substation #8<br />

Demand Response Controls<br />

As requested, we reviewed the feasibility of using the existing utility meters to monitor electric usage<br />

and demand. The meters provided by PECO Energy, the electric utility currently serving the PCCA, do<br />

have the capability to provide output signals via “demand contacts.” These are devices that PECO will<br />

install <strong>for</strong> use with a customer-owned Energy Demand/Management System (such as Siemens, Andover,<br />

etc.). The output signal is not in<strong>for</strong>mation per se, but pulses that an Energy Demand/Management<br />

System would be able to interpret and use to track electrical usage throughout the day.


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 5<br />

Page 5 of 8<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report<br />

January 25 th , 2010<br />

The output would be transmitted over a two (2) wire twisted pair to the input of the Energy<br />

Demand/Management System. The pulse would provide kWH and an end of interval pulse, which could<br />

be used to sync up with PECO intervals, making direct comparison with PECO billing data possible.<br />

In speaking with a PECO employee about the topic of demand contacts installed on the existing meters,<br />

he stated that the process starts with the owner contacting their PECO Large Account Representative<br />

and requesting the demand contacts be installed. The contacts will be ordered, and PECO charges<br />

$1500 to $1800 <strong>for</strong> the contacts. There is currently a piece of equipment located at the meter location<br />

that may be a demand contacts device (based on the name on the cover) being used <strong>for</strong> PECO’s normal<br />

metering process. If this is correct, and the PCCA is able to tap into the existing demand contacts with<br />

PECO’s permission, the $1500 to $1800 <strong>for</strong> new demand contacts may not be needed. However, since<br />

BEI could not determine exactly what that piece of equipment is, we went with the conservative<br />

approach and assumed that demand contacts would need to be ordered.<br />

With the installation of an Energy Demand/Management System connected to a Building Automation<br />

System (BAS), data obtained from the existing meters can be used to make <strong>energy</strong>-related and<br />

operational decisions throughout the day.<br />

As a note, the PECO Representative in<strong>for</strong>med me that PECO will be rolling out a rebate program <strong>for</strong><br />

<strong>energy</strong> conservation work in March of this year. He stated to take be<strong>for</strong>e and after pictures, save<br />

receipts, etc. in order to provide proof of work per<strong>for</strong>med. The rebate program will accept <strong>energy</strong><br />

conservation work per<strong>for</strong>med back to July 2009.<br />

The estimated electrical cost <strong>for</strong> this ECM is $12,000, based on the following:<br />

1. 2 men/40 hours to install 1000’ ¾” EMT conduit (assumed distance from Main Electric Room<br />

where meters are located to Engineering Department Offices), pull conductors, terminate, etc. =<br />

$8000<br />

2. Conductor cost of two (2) #14AWG conductors x 1000’ x $0.315/ft = $630<br />

3. ¾” EMT @ $1/ft x 1000’ = $1000<br />

4. PECO Energy Demand Contact Charge = $1800<br />

5. $570 in miscellaneous material, junction boxes, etc.


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 6<br />

Page 6 of 8<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report<br />

January 25 th , 2010<br />

Figure 4 – PECO Energy Utility Metering Equipment located in Main Electric Room<br />

Measurement and Verification<br />

BEI understands the importance of not only providing theoretical <strong>energy</strong> saving methods, but<br />

quantifiable proof of the savings that can be presented to the client. This can be accomplished by<br />

installing electric meters at key locations. BEI was asked to recommend metering device locations <strong>for</strong><br />

the ECMs previously presented, which can be easily installed with the work described above. An ECM<br />

that was not explicitly requested to be reviewed <strong>for</strong> metering was the Lighting System Upgrade. BEI<br />

believes that this is one of the most important ECMs to measure and included it in our scope of work.<br />

The work required to meter all lighting panels is extensive. BEI reviewed the lighting plan views to see<br />

what circuits and corresponding panelboards were noted as being used to feed lighting throughout the<br />

facility. We also reviewed the single line diagrams and noted the “LP” designated panelboards, which<br />

feed lighting almost exclusively @ 277V. We also noted from the plan view analysis that some lighting<br />

is 120V, and there<strong>for</strong>e fed from “RP” designated panelboards. Also, light fixtures designated to be used<br />

as emergency lighting are fed from “ELP” designated panelboards backed-up by multiple generators<br />

located throughout the facility.<br />

With that in mind, please see the attached single line diagrams which show recommended locations <strong>for</strong><br />

metering. The GREEN meters indicate locations where mostly all lighting load is served and will be<br />

metered. In our opinion, these locations are “required” to be metered in order to determine <strong>energy</strong><br />

savings from implementing the planned lighting upgrades. The RED meters indicate panelboards that<br />

serve mostly receptacle or other power loads, and only have a few lighting circuits. We have designated<br />

them as “optional” meters due to the high cost of each meter and the minimal amount of lighting load<br />

served as compared to the total lighting load being measured. However, to be 100% complete with the<br />

measurement and verification goal, the individual circuits of the designated panelboards must be


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 7<br />

Page 7 of 8<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report<br />

January 25 th , 2010<br />

metered. For estimating purposes, BEI assumed one meter at each panel, and assumed that multiple CTs<br />

monitoring different circuits could be used to supply one (1) meter. The “Required” and “Optional”<br />

installations were broken out <strong>for</strong> comparison.<br />

Locations were chosen based on load served and consolidation of load in order to minimize how many<br />

meters were needed to achieve the goal. With that in mind, please see the following tables summarizing<br />

the cost:<br />

INSTALLATION PHASE # of “Required” Meters # of “Optional” Meters TOTALS<br />

Main Building 74 meters ($125,800) 29 meters ($ 49,300) 103 meters ($175,100)<br />

Train Shed (Subs 22 & 23) 24 meters ($ 40,800) 15 meters ($ 25,500) 39 meters ($ 66,300)<br />

TOTALS 98 meters ($166,600) 44 meters ($ 74,800) 142 meters ($241,400)<br />

REMOVAL PHASE # of “Required” Meters # of “Optional” Meters TOTALS<br />

Main Building 74 meters ($7,400) 29 meters ($2,900) 103 meters ($10,300)<br />

Train Shed (Subs 22 & 23) 24 meters ($2,400) 15 meters ($1,500) 39 meters ($ 3,900)<br />

TOTALS 98 meters ($9,800) 44 meters ($4,400) 142 meters ($14,200)<br />

The estimated electrical costs shown above were developed based on assuming $1700 <strong>for</strong> the installation<br />

of each meter (please review assumptions at the beginning of the <strong>report</strong>), and $100 <strong>for</strong> the removal of<br />

each meter after measurement and verification is over, if desired. Each of the electric rooms containing<br />

substations provides plenty of space <strong>for</strong> the installation of meters. The electric rooms that contain<br />

Substations #22 and #23 are smaller, but space can be found. The electric rooms that contain equipment<br />

fed by Substations #22 & #23 are tight on space, but we believe room on the walls can be obtained.<br />

Figure 5 –Typical Wall Space <strong>for</strong> Substation Electric Rooms in Main Building


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 8<br />

Page 8 of 8<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report<br />

January 25 th , 2010<br />

Figure 6 –Typical Wall Space <strong>for</strong> Electric Rooms fed from Substations #22 & #23<br />

If there are any questions or comments, please do not hesitate to contact us. Thank you <strong>for</strong> the<br />

opportunity to provide and present this in<strong>for</strong>mation to you.<br />

Submitted by,<br />

Burris Engineers, Inc.<br />

James I Burris, Jr., P.E.<br />

President and CEO<br />

ATTACHMENTS (01 through 09)<br />

(Single Line Diagrams showing Proposed Meter Installations)


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 9


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 10


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 11


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 12


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 13


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 14


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 15


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 16


Appendix C Electrical Analysis -Page 17


Appendix D Peco HT Electric Tariff - Page 1<br />

Supplement No. 99 To<br />

Tariff Electric Pa. P.U.C. No.3<br />

Twentieth Revised Page No. 49<br />

PECO Energy Company Superseding Nineteenth Revised Page No. 49<br />

RATE-HT HIGH-TENSION POWER<br />

AVAILABILITY.<br />

Untrans<strong>for</strong>med service from the Company's standard high-tension lines, where the customer installs, owns, and<br />

maintains, any trans<strong>for</strong>ming, switching and other receiving equipment required.<br />

CURRENT CHARACTERISTICS.<br />

Standard high-tension service.<br />

MONTHLY RATE TABLE.<br />

FIXED DISTRIBUTION SERVICE CHARGE: $291.52<br />

METERING AND BILLING CREDITS A customer receiving Advanced Meter Services from a AMSP other than the<br />

Company will receive a credit on the Fixed Distribution Service Charge equal to the Total Metering Credit set <strong>for</strong>th <strong>for</strong><br />

this Base Rate in Appendix B to the Joint Petition <strong>for</strong> Full Settlement. A customer receiving Consolidated EGS Billing<br />

will receive a credit on the Fixed Distribution Service Charge equal to the Billing and Collection Credit set <strong>for</strong>th <strong>for</strong> this<br />

Base Rate in Appendix B to the Joint Petition <strong>for</strong> Full Settlement.<br />

VARIABLE DISTRIBUTION SERVICE CHARGE:<br />

$1.68 per kW of billing demand<br />

0.90¢ per kWh of the first 150 hours’ use of billing demand<br />

0.53¢ per kWh of the next 150 hours’ use of billing demand,<br />

but not more than 7,500,000 kWh<br />

0.17¢ per kWh <strong>for</strong> additional use.<br />

COMPETITIVE TRANSITION CHARGE:<br />

$5.82 per kW of billing demand<br />

3.12¢ per kWh <strong>for</strong> the first 150 hours' use of billing demand<br />

1.85¢ per kWh <strong>for</strong> the next 150 hours' use of billing demand,<br />

but not more than 7,500,000 kWh<br />

0.59¢ per kWh <strong>for</strong> additional use.<br />

ENERGY AND CAPACITY CHARGE: The following Energy and Capacity Charges will apply to the customer if the<br />

customer receives Default PLR Service. These charges are not applicable to the customer if it obtains Competitive<br />

Energy Supply.<br />

$6.03 per kW of billing demand<br />

4.87¢ per kWh <strong>for</strong> the first 150 hours' use of billing demand<br />

3.55¢ per kWh <strong>for</strong> the next 150 hours' use of billing demand,<br />

but not more than 7,500,000 kWh<br />

2.24¢ per kWh <strong>for</strong> additional use.<br />

ENERGY EFFICIENCY CHARGE: $0.91 per kW of Peak Load Contribution<br />

(C)<br />

TRANSMISSION SERVICE FOR CUSTOMERS RECEIVING DEFAULT PLR SERVICE: Unless such a customer is able<br />

to obtain transmission service on its own, PECO Energy will provide transmission service, and will impose charges on<br />

such a customer <strong>for</strong> such transmission service.<br />

TIME-OF-USE ADJUSTMENT:<br />

Customers with measured demand of 2,000 kW or greater will be given a credit <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> use during off-peak hours and<br />

will be subject to an additional charge <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> use during on-peak hours. On-peak hours are defined as the hours<br />

between 8:00 am and 8:00 pm, Eastern Standard Time or Daylight Savings Time, whichever is in common use, daily<br />

except Saturdays, Sundays and holidays; except that the on-peak hours will end at 4:00 pm on Fridays. Off-peak hours<br />

are defined as the hours other than those specified as on-peak hours. The credits and charges are as follows:<br />

Summer Months Winter Months<br />

(June through September) (October through May)<br />

Off-peak credit............ 0.21¢ per kWh<br />

0.21¢ per kWh<br />

On-peak charge.......... 0.58¢ per kWh<br />

0.22¢ per kWh<br />

If the customer receives Default PLR Service, the rate adjustments shall apply. They shall not apply if the customer<br />

obtains competitive <strong>energy</strong> supply.<br />

HIGH VOLTAGE DISTRIBUTION DISCOUNT:<br />

For customers supplied at 33,000 volts: 7¢ per kW of measured demand.<br />

For customers supplied at 69,000 volts: 28¢ per kW <strong>for</strong> first 10,000 kW of measured demand.<br />

For customers supplied over 69,000 volts: 28¢ per kW <strong>for</strong> first 100,000 kW of measured demand.<br />

STATE TAX ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE, NUCLEAR DECOMMISSIONING COST ADJUSTMENT, PROVISION FOR RECOVERY<br />

OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CONSERVATION PROGRAM COSTS and PROVISION FOR THE RECOVERY OF<br />

CONSUMER EDUCATION PLAN COSTS APPLY TO THIS RATE.<br />

(C)<br />

(C) Indicates Change<br />

Issued December 21, 2009 Effective January 1, 2010


Appendix D Peco HT Electric Tariff - Page 2<br />

Supplement No. 60 To<br />

Tariff Electric Pa. P.U.C. No. 3<br />

Fourth Revised Page No. 50<br />

PECO Energy Company Superseding Third Revised Page No. 50<br />

DETERMINATION OF BILLING DEMAND.<br />

RATE-HT HIGH-TENSION POWER - CONTINUED<br />

The billing demand will be computed to the nearest kilowatt and will never be less than the measured demand,<br />

adjusted <strong>for</strong> power factor in accordance with the Rules and Regulations, nor less than 25 kilowatts. Additionally,<br />

during the eight months of October through May the billing demand will not be less than 40% of the maximum<br />

demand specified in the contract nor less than 80% of the highest billing demand in the preceding months of June<br />

through September (applied on an unbundled basis). There will be a one-time waiver of the application of the<br />

previous sentence as it relates to minimums associated with PLR Energy and Capacity charges the first time a<br />

customer at a service location elects to receive Competitive Energy Supply. This one-time waiver is specific to a<br />

particular service location unless a new entity has assumed operation of the service location from a customer which<br />

has ceased operations at that location as a result of dissolution provided the new entity was not created through<br />

merger, partnership, joint venture, acquisition and/or any other type of combined business structure with the <strong>for</strong>mer<br />

customer.<br />

DELIVERY POINTS.<br />

Where the load of a customer located on single or contiguous premises becomes greater than the capacity of the<br />

standard circuit or circuits established by the Company to supply the customer, an additional separate delivery point<br />

may be established <strong>for</strong> such premises upon the written request of the customer with billing continued as if the<br />

service were being delivered and metered at a single point, provided such multi-point delivery is not advantageous<br />

to the Company.<br />

(C)<br />

MINIMUM CHARGE.<br />

The monthly minimum charge shall be the Fixed Distribution Service Charge, plus the charge per kW component<br />

of the Variable Distribution Service Charge, the CTC, and the Energy and Capacity Charge, less the high voltage<br />

discount where applicable.<br />

TERM OF CONTRACT.<br />

The initial contract term shall be <strong>for</strong> at least three years.<br />

PAYMENT TERMS.<br />

Standard.<br />

(C) Indicates Change<br />

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________<br />

Issued October 20, 2004 Effective November 5, 2004


Appendix E - ECM #1 Condensing Boiler -Page 1<br />

MONTHLY ENERGY CONSUMPTION<br />

By Concord Engineering Group<br />

------- Monthly Energy Consumption -------<br />

Utility Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total<br />

Alternative: 1<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - Baseline<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 523,333 603,157 563,492 546,913 645,504 278,124 371,027 263,659 553,982 561,678 533,086 426,024 5,869,980<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 889,165 846,732 776,269 828,262 791,432 685,862 767,225 700,082 814,553 846,347 834,901 763,196 9,544,026<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,352 3,371 3,513 3,636 5,686 6,550 6,665 6,672 6,168 3,914 3,660 3,355 6,672<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,253 3,274 3,267 3,438 3,996 6,612 6,940 6,698 6,432 3,669 3,267 3,250 6,940<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 59,414 88,181 18,022 15,806 19,638 20,956 30,327 17,986 25,004 17,341 22,964 84,216 419,855<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 288 365 175 139 84 84 85 84 94 131 151 218<br />

365<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 181 1,852 1,416 2,459 1,387 1,770 374 156 0<br />

9,593<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 92,748 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 33,708,360 lbm/year<br />

Source 198,093 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 260,612 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

52,383 gm/year<br />

Alternative: 2<br />

Condensing Boiler<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 516,311 595,722 557,243 541,535 642,588 278,124 368,487 263,659 550,549 555,752 527,343 419,913 5,817,225<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 875,750 833,328 765,704 818,815 789,488 685,862 762,489 700,082 809,036 837,382 824,580 748,050 9,450,566<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,329 3,348 3,491 3,620 5,686 6,550 6,665 6,672 6,168 3,914 3,638 3,332 6,672<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,219 3,224 3,244 3,416 3,974 6,612 6,940 6,698 6,432 3,669 3,245 3,226 6,940<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 56,520 84,836 16,650 14,862 19,627 20,956 30,286 17,986 24,834 16,523 21,579 80,638 405,297<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 282 359 168 132 84 84 85 84 93 124 145 211<br />

359<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 181 1,852 1,416 2,459 1,387 1,770 374 156 0<br />

9,593<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 90,831 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 33,011,748 lbm/year<br />

Source 195,122 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 255,227 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

51,300 gm/year<br />

Savings<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 2,894 3,345 1,372 944 11 0 42 0 169 818 1,385 3,578 14,558<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 7 7 7 7 0 0 0 0 1 7 7 7<br />

442


Appendix E - ECM #1 Condensing Boiler -Page 2<br />

ECM #1 - COST ESTIMATE SUMMARY<br />

DESCRIPTION MATERIALS LABOR QTY / % TOTAL<br />

Condensing Boiler ($/Unit) $49,500 2 $99,000<br />

SS Vent (8" Dia) ($/Ft) $150 100 $15,000<br />

HW Inline Pump ($/Unit) $4,100 $1,450 2 $11,100<br />

HW Piping & Fittings $27 $53 200 $15,900<br />

HW Piping Insulation $19 $30 200 $9,900<br />

Gas Piping & Fittings $7 $9 300 $4,545<br />

Condensate Drain $1,000 $1,500 1 $2,500<br />

Controls $10,000 1 $10,000<br />

Boiler Electrical Work $900 $1,600 2 $5,000<br />

Pump Electrical Work $1,350 $1,700 2 $6,100<br />

Construction Extras (Equipment Lift, site work) $12,500 1 $12,500<br />

Subtotal $191,545<br />

Engineering 10% $19,155<br />

Insurance 10% $19,155<br />

Permitting 5% $9,577<br />

TOTAL $239,431


Appendix E - ECM #1 Condensing Boiler -Page 3<br />

International, Inc.<br />

Boiler Thermal Efficiencies<br />

Benchmark 3.0 Low NOx<br />

Benchmark 3.0 Low NOx Efficiency Curves<br />

As a condensing boiler, the BMK3.0LN boiler maximizes operating efficiency when applied in a<br />

system that leverages cold return water temperatures. As pictured below, the colder the<br />

incoming water temperature, the greater the boiler’s thermal efficiency.<br />

100<br />

Thermal Efficiency of BMK3.0LN<br />

99<br />

98<br />

97<br />

96<br />

95<br />

7% Input<br />

20% Input<br />

40% Input<br />

60% Input<br />

80% Input<br />

100% Input<br />

Efficiency (%)<br />

94<br />

93<br />

92<br />

91<br />

90<br />

89<br />

88<br />

87<br />

86<br />

70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170<br />

Return Water Temperature (°F), with 20° Rise<br />

In addition, the BMK3.0LN boiler shares the same type of inverse efficiency profile as its<br />

Benchmark counterpart. In simple terms, the lower the boiler’s firing rate, the greater it’s<br />

operating efficiency. At its lowest firing rates (or BTU/hr. inputs), the BMK3.0LN heat<br />

exchanger becomes greatly oversized in proportion to the load – allowing greater thermal<br />

transfer to take place. This means that the BMK3.0LN boiler saves the most <strong>energy</strong> during part<br />

load operations that characterize the majority of the heating season. And with the ability to<br />

perfectly match load anywhere between 3,000,000 and 200,000 BTU/hr., the unit will be<br />

operating at its greatest efficiencies when less robust equipment starts to cycle on and off<br />

repeatedly.<br />

Rev. 03/12/08 C301.4


Appendix E - ECM #1 Condensing Boiler -Page 4<br />

BURRIS ENGINEERS, INC.<br />

180 S. Main St, Suite 203<br />

Ambler, PA 19002<br />

(215) 643‐4465<br />

www.burrisengineers.com<br />

Condensing Boiler Installation<br />

The installation of a condensing boiler from an electrical engineering perspective is straight-<strong>for</strong>ward.<br />

Based on the provided equipment catalog cuts, the electrical power requirements <strong>for</strong> a typical gas-fired<br />

condensing boiler is minimal (15A @ 460V, 3PH). The power required <strong>for</strong> this installation is readily<br />

available on the main floor of the Mechanical Penthouse via one of the spare MCC cubicles. One of the<br />

spare MCC cubicles can be modified as required to have a 15A over-current protective device (OCPD)<br />

supply conductors that feed over to a new boiler installed somewhere on the main mechanical penthouse<br />

floor (the assumed total conduit run is 200’ max).<br />

The estimated electrical cost <strong>for</strong> this ECM is $2500, based on the following:<br />

1. 2 men/8 hours to modify MCC cubicle, install EMT conduit to boiler location (selected by<br />

others), and install conductors = $1600<br />

2. Conductor cost of (4) #12AWG conductors x 200’ x $0.453/ft = $365<br />

3. ¾” EMT @ $1/ft x 200’ = $200<br />

4. $335 in miscellaneous material, including 15A/3P breaker or fuse set-up<br />

5. BEI does not believe it is worthwhile to install a meter <strong>for</strong> this ECM since the electrical usage is<br />

small. However, if a meter is needed, add $1700 to the above total cost<br />

Figure 1 – Spare Cubicle in MCC-C4 (Typical <strong>for</strong> MCCs on Main Mechanical Penthouse Floor)


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 1<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

CEG Job #: 1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - 1st Floor West<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address: 12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Building SF: XXXXX<br />

Lighting Upgrade - General<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Retro-Unit Watts Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Maintenance Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

24 8760 8 1<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

50 0.40 3,504.0 $388.94 8 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.07 630.72 $70.01 $27.90 $223.20 0.33 2873.28 $87.42 $406.36 0.55<br />

Security 1st Flr<br />

18 West 8760 4 3<br />

1 8760 2 4<br />

2 8760 8 2<br />

Security A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

115 0.46 4,029.6 $447.29 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

188 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 2 2<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 1.12<br />

58 0.46 4064.64 $451.18 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 2522.88 $13.99 $294.03 4.08<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2<br />

Security B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 4 2<br />

1 8760 4 4<br />

Security C 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

11 8760 2 2<br />

1 8760 4 4<br />

Security D 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

11 8760 2 2<br />

10 8760 10 2<br />

Corridor A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

44 8760 3 0<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2<br />

188 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 4 2<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

188 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 4 2<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.23 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 4.08<br />

58 0.23 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 1.12<br />

58 0.12 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 4.08<br />

58 0.23 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 1.12<br />

58 0.12 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 4.08<br />

57 0.57 4,993.2 $554.25 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.01 52.6 $5.83 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 2<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

11 Stairs A West 8760 5 2<br />

11 Stairs B West 8760 7 2<br />

2<br />

Corridor B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 17 2<br />

1 2920 4 4<br />

2 2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2<br />

94 0.66 5,764.1 $639.81 7 2<br />

94 1.60 13,998.5 $1,553.83 17 2<br />

188 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 4 2<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.29 2540.4 $281.98 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 1576.8 $8.75 $183.77 4.08<br />

58 0.41 3556.56 $394.78 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 2207.52 $12.24 $257.28 4.08<br />

58 0.99 8637.36 $958.75 $150.00 $2,550.00 0.61 5361.12 $29.73 $624.82 4.08<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 3.37<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 420.48 $2.33 $49.01 12.24<br />

Engineering 1st Flr<br />

14 2920 1 2<br />

West<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

73 0.07 213.2 $23.66 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

15 2920 2 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

Reccessed Fixture<br />

57 0.11 332.9 $36.95 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

22 2920 4 1<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

50 0.20 584.0 $64.82 4 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.04 105.12 $11.67 $27.90 $111.60 0.16 478.88 $14.57 $67.73 1.65<br />

3 8760 3 2<br />

Corridor C 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 0.28 2,470.3 $274.21 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 4.08<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

3 8760 14 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.32 11,528.2 $1,279.63 14 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.81 7113.12 $789.56 $150.00 $2,100.00 0.50 4415.04 $24.49 $514.56 4.08<br />

Corridor D 1st Flr<br />

44 8760 2 0<br />

West<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

2 0.00 35.0 $3.89 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage C 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

1<br />

Storage D 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 1 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.19 411.7 $45.70 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 284.7 $1.75 $33.35 4.50


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 3<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

1<br />

Storage E 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $91.40 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 569.4 $3.50 $66.70 4.50<br />

3 2190 34 2<br />

Storage F 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

1 2190 1 4<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 3.20 6,999.2 $776.92 34 2<br />

188 0.19 411.7 $45.70 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.97 4318.68 $479.37 $150.00 $5,100.00 1.22 2680.56 $14.87 $312.41 16.32<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 284.7 $1.75 $33.35 4.50<br />

3<br />

Storage G 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 17 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.60 3,499.6 $388.46 17 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.99 2159.34 $239.69 $150.00 $2,550.00 0.61 1340.28 $7.43 $156.20 16.32<br />

1<br />

Housekeeping 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 10 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.88 5,489.6 $609.35 10 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.58 1693.6 $187.99 $150.00 $1,500.00 1.30 3796 $23.32 $444.68 3.37<br />

3<br />

Storage H 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 27 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 2.54 5,558.2 $616.96 27 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 1.57 3429.54 $380.68 $150.00 $4,050.00 0.97 2128.68 $11.81 $248.09 16.32<br />

3 8760 10 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $914.02 10 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.58 5080.8 $563.97 $150.00 $1,500.00 0.36 3153.6 $17.49 $367.54 4.08<br />

43 Corridor E 1st Flr 8760 1 1<br />

West<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage I 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage J 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.28 617.6 $68.55 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 381.06 $42.30 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 236.52 $1.31 $27.57 16.32<br />

2 8760 11 2<br />

Corridor F 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,005.42 11 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.64 5588.88 $620.37 $150.00 $1,650.00 0.40 3468.96 $19.24 $404.29 4.08<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage K 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 16.32<br />

11 Stairs C West 8760 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.46 4064.64 $451.18 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 2522.88 $13.99 $294.03 4.08<br />

11 8760 11 2<br />

Stairs D West<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,005.42 11 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.64 5588.88 $620.37 $150.00 $1,650.00 0.40 3468.96 $19.24 $404.29 4.08


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 4<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Stairs D West<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

31 8760 20 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

455 9.10 79,716.0 $8,848.48 20 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

33 8760 16 1<br />

Garage A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

39 8760 3 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

295 4.72 41,347.2 $4,589.54 16 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.38 3,285.0 $364.64 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

41<br />

Outside Race St<br />

West<br />

8760 36 1<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down<br />

Light High Pressure<br />

Sodium Fixture<br />

300 10.80 94,608.0 $10,501.49 36 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 288 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 25.92 37,843.2 $4,200.60 288 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 6.91 10091.52 $1,120.16 $89.90 $25,891.20 19.01 27751.68 $524.55 $3,604.99 7.18<br />

Lecture Hall 1st Flr<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

34 1460 10 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 2.13 3,109.8 $345.19 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Lecture Hall<br />

19 1460 4 1<br />

Lobby 1st Flr West<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.36 525.6 $58.34 4 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.10 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $359.60 0.26 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 7.18<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2<br />

Corridor G 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 30 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 2.82 24,703.2 $2,742.06 30 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.74 15242.4 $1,691.91 $150.00 $4,500.00 1.08 9460.8 $52.47 $1,102.62 4.08<br />

19 1460 48 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.32 6,307.2 $700.10 48 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.15 1681.92 $186.69 $89.90 $4,315.20 3.17 4625.28 $87.42 $600.83 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 113C<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 5<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

19 1460 48 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.32 6,307.2 $700.10 48 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.15 1681.92 $186.69 $89.90 $4,315.20 3.17 4625.28 $87.42 $600.83 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 113B<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 4 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 48 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.32 6,307.2 $700.10 48 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.15 1681.92 $186.69 $89.90 $4,315.20 3.17 4625.28 $87.42 $600.83 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 113A<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R6 1st<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr West<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R6 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.38 560.64 $62.23 $89.90 $1,438.40 1.06 1541.76 $29.14 $200.28 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 112B<br />

1 1460 9 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.52 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $1,350.00 1.17 1708.2 $10.49 $200.10 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.38 560.64 $62.23 $89.90 $1,438.40 1.06 1541.76 $29.14 $200.28 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 112A<br />

1 1460 9 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.52 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $1,350.00 1.17 1708.2 $10.49 $200.10 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 6<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R5 1st<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr West<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.43 630.72 $70.01 $89.90 $1,618.20 1.19 1734.48 $32.78 $225.31 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 111A<br />

1 1460 8 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.30 1892.16 $210.03 $89.90 $4,854.60 3.56 5203.44 $98.35 $675.93 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 111B<br />

1 1460 26 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 4.89 7,136.5 $792.15 26 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.51 2201.68 $244.39 $150.00 $3,900.00 3.38 4934.8 $30.32 $578.08 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.34 490.56 $54.45 $89.90 $1,258.60 0.92 1349.04 $25.50 $175.24 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 110B<br />

1 1460 8 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.34 490.56 $54.45 $89.90 $1,258.60 0.92 1349.04 $25.50 $175.24 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 110A<br />

1 1460 8 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.43 630.72 $70.01 $89.90 $1,618.20 1.19 1734.48 $32.78 $225.31 7.18


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 7<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Meeting Rm 109A<br />

1 1460 8 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.30 1892.16 $210.03 $89.90 $4,854.60 3.56 5203.44 $98.35 $675.93 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 109B<br />

1 1460 26 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 4.89 7,136.5 $792.15 26 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.51 2201.68 $244.39 $150.00 $3,900.00 3.38 4934.8 $30.32 $578.08 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R1 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R1 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R2 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

AHU Rm A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,029.3 $114.25 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 635.1 $70.50 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 394.2 $2.19 $45.94 16.32<br />

19 8760 102 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 9.18 80,416.8 $8,926.26 102 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 2.45 21444.48 $2,380.34 $89.90 $9,169.80 6.73 58972.32 $1,114.67 $7,660.59 1.20


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 8<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

34 8760 66 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 14.06 123,148.1 $13,669.44 66 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

20 8760 17 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

23 0.39 3,425.2 $380.19 17 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Main Corridor A<br />

22 8760 12 1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

50 0.60 5,256.0 $583.42 12 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.11 946.08 $105.01 $27.90 $334.80 0.49 4309.92 $131.14 $609.54 0.55<br />

43 8760 10 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.10 876.0 $97.24 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

48 8760 4 4<br />

26W, 4 Lamp, Pendant<br />

Compact Flourescent<br />

Fixture<br />

112 0.45 3,924.5 $435.62 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 8760 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 245.3 $27.23 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet A 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet A 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

2<br />

Storage L 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

1 2920 87 4<br />

Main Kitchen 1st<br />

11 Flr West 2920 8 2<br />

12 2920 3 3<br />

1<br />

Main kitchen A 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

188 16.36 47,759.5 $5,301.31 87 2<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

75 0.23 657.0 $72.93 3 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

2x2, 17W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Troffer Fixture; Metalux Accord<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 5.05 14734.32 $1,635.51 $150.00 $13,050.00 11.31 33025.2 $202.89 $3,868.69 3.37<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

34 0.10 297.84 $33.06 $125.00 $375.00 0.12 359.16 $4.37 $44.24 8.48<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 379.6 $2.33 $44.47 3.37<br />

3<br />

Main Kitchen B 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

1<br />

2<br />

Main Kitchen C 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen D 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 379.6 $2.33 $44.47 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 9<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

2<br />

2<br />

Main Kitchen E 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen F 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2920 3 2<br />

3 2920<br />

Main Kitchen G 1st<br />

7 2<br />

Flr West<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

1<br />

Main Kitchen H 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 6 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

94 0.66 1,921.4 $213.27 7 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 12.24<br />

58 0.41 1185.52 $131.59 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 735.84 $4.08 $85.76 12.24<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

3<br />

Main Kitchen I 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Main Kitchen J 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen K 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen L 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen M<br />

1st Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen N 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen O 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 379.6 $2.33 $44.47 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 379.6 $2.33 $44.47 3.37<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $4.66 $88.94 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 379.6 $2.33 $44.47 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 379.6 $2.33 $44.47 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.13 379.6 $2.33 $44.47 3.37<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet B 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet B 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

1<br />

Storage M 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 8 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 3,293.8 $365.61 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 4.50<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet D 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet D 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 10<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3 2190<br />

Sub Station Rm 1st<br />

12 2<br />

Flr West<br />

43 2190 2 1<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet C 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.13 2,470.3 $274.21 12 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.70 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,800.00 0.43 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 16.32<br />

10 0.02 43.8 $4.86 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet C 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

2<br />

Corridor H 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 8 2<br />

3<br />

Main Storage 1st<br />

2190 99 2<br />

Flr West<br />

43 2190 4 1<br />

3 2190<br />

AHU Rm B 1st Flr<br />

9 2<br />

West<br />

43 2190 2 1<br />

3 2190<br />

AHU Rm C 1st Flr<br />

8 2<br />

West<br />

43 2190 2 1<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet E2<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

94 9.31 20,380.1 $2,262.20 99 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 4064.64 $451.18 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 2522.88 $13.99 $294.03 4.08<br />

58 5.74 12574.98 $1,395.82 $150.00 $14,850.00 3.56 7805.16 $43.29 $909.66 16.32<br />

10 0.04 87.6 $9.72 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.85 1,852.7 $205.65 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1143.18 $126.89 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 709.56 $3.94 $82.70 16.32<br />

10 0.02 43.8 $4.86 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 16.32<br />

10 0.02 43.8 $4.86 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet E2 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet E1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet E1 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

2<br />

Corridor I 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 8 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 4064.64 $451.18 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 2522.88 $13.99 $294.03 4.08<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.30 1892.16 $210.03 $89.90 $4,854.60 3.56 5203.44 $98.35 $675.93 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 108A<br />

1<br />

1st flr West<br />

1460 24 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.39 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $3,600.00 3.12 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.30 1892.16 $210.03 $89.90 $4,854.60 3.56 5203.44 $98.35 $675.93 7.18


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 11<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Meeting Rm 108B<br />

1<br />

1st flr West<br />

1460 24 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

11 8760 8 2<br />

Stairs E West<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

11 8760 11 2<br />

Stairs F West<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

2 8760 20 2<br />

Corridor J 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

43 8760 3 1<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2<br />

Corridor K 1st Flr<br />

8760 30 2<br />

West<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

3<br />

Storage N 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.39 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $3,600.00 3.12 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.46 4064.64 $451.18 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 2522.88 $13.99 $294.03 4.08<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,005.42 11 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.64 5588.88 $620.37 $150.00 $1,650.00 0.40 3468.96 $19.24 $404.29 4.08<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 1.88 16,468.8 $1,828.04 20 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.16 10161.6 $1,127.94 $150.00 $3,000.00 0.72 6307.2 $34.98 $735.08 4.08<br />

10 0.03 262.8 $29.17 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 2.82 24,703.2 $2,742.06 30 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.74 15242.4 $1,691.91 $150.00 $4,500.00 1.08 9460.8 $52.47 $1,102.62 4.08<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage L 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Control Rm 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 8 2<br />

2 2920 6 2<br />

Locker Rm B 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

11 2920 2 2<br />

2 2920 8 2<br />

Locker Rm A 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

11 2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

94 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 6 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 16.32<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 12.24<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.34 490.56 $54.45 $89.90 $1,258.60 0.92 1349.04 $25.50 $175.24 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 102B<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 12<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

19 1460 26 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 2.34 3,416.4 $379.22 26 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.62 911.04 $101.13 $89.90 $2,337.40 1.72 2505.36 $47.36 $325.45 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 102A<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 16 4<br />

43 2920 3 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 3.01 4,391.7 $487.48 16 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.93 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $2,400.00 2.08 3036.8 $18.66 $355.74 6.75<br />

10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 12 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.08 1,576.8 $175.02 12 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.29 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $1,078.80 0.79 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 101C<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 4 4<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 0.75 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 759.2 $4.66 $88.94 6.75<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 12 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.08 1,576.8 $175.02 12 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.29 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $1,078.80 0.79 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 101B<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 4 4<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 0.75 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 759.2 $4.66 $88.94 6.75<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 12 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.08 1,576.8 $175.02 12 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.29 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $1,078.80 0.79 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 101A<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 4 4<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 0.75 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 759.2 $4.66 $88.94 6.75<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 50 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.50 6,570.0 $729.27 50 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.20 1752 $194.47 $89.90 $4,495.00 3.30 4818 $91.07 $625.87 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 103C<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 52 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.68 6,832.8 $758.44 52 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.25 1822.08 $202.25 $89.90 $4,674.80 3.43 5010.72 $94.71 $650.90 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 103B<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

43 2920 4 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 50 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.50 6,570.0 $729.27 50 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.20 1752 $194.47 $89.90 $4,495.00 3.30 4818 $91.07 $625.87 7.18


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 13<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Meeting Rm 103A<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.38 560.64 $62.23 $89.90 $1,438.40 1.06 1541.76 $29.14 $200.28 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 104B<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 9 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.52 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $1,350.00 1.17 1708.2 $10.49 $200.10 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.38 560.64 $62.23 $89.90 $1,438.40 1.06 1541.76 $29.14 $200.28 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 104A<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 9 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

Restroom R8 1st<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr West<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R8 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

Restroom R7 1st<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr West<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R7 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.52 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $1,350.00 1.17 1708.2 $10.49 $200.10 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.30 1892.16 $210.03 $89.90 $4,854.60 3.56 5203.44 $98.35 $675.93 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 105B<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 24 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.39 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $3,600.00 3.12 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.43 630.72 $70.01 $89.90 $1,618.20 1.19 1734.48 $32.78 $225.31 7.18


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 14<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Meeting Rm 105A<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.34 490.56 $54.45 $89.90 $1,258.60 0.92 1349.04 $25.50 $175.24 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 106B<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.34 490.56 $54.45 $89.90 $1,258.60 0.92 1349.04 $25.50 $175.24 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 106A<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.30 1892.16 $210.03 $89.90 $4,854.60 3.56 5203.44 $98.35 $675.93 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 107B<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 24 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.39 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $3,600.00 3.12 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.43 630.72 $70.01 $89.90 $1,618.20 1.19 1734.48 $32.78 $225.31 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm 107A<br />

1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R4 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R4 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 6.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 12.24<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 12.24


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 15<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R3 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 8760 132 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 11.88 104,068.8 $11,551.64 132 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 3.17 27751.68 $3,080.44 $89.90 $11,866.80 8.71 76317.12 $1,442.51 $9,913.71 1.20<br />

34 8760 75 1<br />

22<br />

Main Corridor B<br />

8760 30 1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

20 8760 6 1<br />

48 8760 4 4<br />

43 8760 4 1<br />

11 8760 10 2<br />

Stairs G West<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

27 8760 12 2<br />

Vestibule A 1st Flr<br />

26 West 8760 6 1<br />

35 8760 6 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

26W, 4 Lamp, Pendant<br />

Compact Flourescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

26W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 15.98 139,941.0 $15,533.45 75 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 1.50 13,140.0 $1,458.54 30 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.27 2365.2 $262.54 $27.90 $837.00 1.23 10774.8 $327.84 $1,523.85 0.55<br />

23 0.14 1,208.9 $134.19 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

112 0.45 3,924.5 $435.62 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.04 350.4 $38.89 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $914.02 10 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.58 5080.8 $563.97 $150.00 $1,500.00 0.36 3153.6 $17.49 $367.54 4.08<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

54 0.65 5,676.5 $630.09 12 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.17 1,471.7 $163.36 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $548.41 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

46 8760 40 0<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal<br />

Halide and 26W 1 lamp,<br />

CFL Decorative Fixture<br />

278 11.12 97,411.2 $10,812.64 40 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 8760 39 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 3.51 30,747.6 $3,412.98 39 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.94 8199.36 $910.13 $89.90 $3,506.10 2.57 22548.24 $426.20 $2,929.05 1.20<br />

33 Main Corridor C 8760 28 1<br />

West<br />

34 8760 21 1<br />

43 8760 8 1<br />

20 8760 7 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

295 8.26 72,357.6 $8,031.69 28 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 4.47 39,183.5 $4,349.37 21 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.08 700.8 $77.79 8 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

23 0.16 1,410.4 $156.55 7 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

34<br />

Vestibule B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 9 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 1.92 16,792.9 $1,864.01 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 16<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

34<br />

Vestibule C 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 5 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 1.07 9,329.4 $1,035.56 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

46<br />

Outside Arch St<br />

West<br />

8760 18 0<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal<br />

Halide and 26W 1 lamp,<br />

CFL Decorative Fixture<br />

278 5.00 43,835.0 $4,865.69 18 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

33 8760 132 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

295 38.94 341,114.4 $37,863.70 132 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

32 12th Street Tunnel 8760 80 1<br />

38 8760 66 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp,<br />

Downlight Can Metal<br />

Halide Fixture<br />

400W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted (12th St.)<br />

Fixture<br />

455 36.40 318,864.0 $35,393.90 80 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

455 30.03 263,062.8 $29,199.97 66 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 3610 511 512.64 2,621,098.6 $290,941.94 3610 314 108.656 341927.6 $37,953.97 $321,806.30 203.92 549456.4 $7,235.50 $68,225.16 4.72<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 17<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

CEG Job #: 1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - 1st Floor East<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address: 12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Building SF: XXXXX<br />

Lighting Upgrade - General<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Retro-Unit Watts Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Maintenance Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

3<br />

Gas Meter Rm 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Main Phone Frame<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $0.58 $70.59 17.00<br />

3<br />

Compressor Rm 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.15 $17.65 17.00<br />

3<br />

Machine Rm A 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

3 8760 32 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 3.01 26,350.1 $2,924.86 32 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 1.86 16258.56 $1,804.70 $150.00 $4,800.00 1.15 10091.52 $9.34 $1,129.50 4.25<br />

2<br />

Corridor A 1st Flr<br />

8760 3 2<br />

East<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 2,470.3 $274.21 3 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.17 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 946.08 $0.88 $105.89 4.25<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 8760 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.66 5,764.1 $639.81 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 3556.56 $394.78 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 2207.52 $2.04 $247.08 4.25<br />

Back Hallway 2 1st<br />

39 Flr East 8760 2 1<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 2190 24 2<br />

Hall D Storage 11st<br />

Flr East<br />

43 2190 1 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 2.26 4,940.6 $548.41 24 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 1.39 3048.48 $338.38 $150.00 $3,600.00 0.86 1892.16 $1.75 $211.78 17.00<br />

10 0.01 21.9 $2.43 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 3 2<br />

Stairs A East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 2,470.3 $274.21 3 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.17 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 946.08 $0.88 $105.89 4.25


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 18<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

3 2190 6 2<br />

Hall D Fire Pump<br />

Room 1st Flr East<br />

43 2190 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $0.44 $52.95 17.00<br />

10 0.01 21.9 $2.43 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 2190 15 2<br />

Hall D Electric<br />

Room 1st Flr East<br />

43 2190 2 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 1.41 3,087.9 $342.76 15 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.87 1905.3 $211.49 $150.00 $2,250.00 0.54 1182.6 $1.10 $132.36 17.00<br />

10 0.02 43.8 $4.86 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

14 2920 18 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

73 1.31 3,836.9 $425.89 18 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Hall D Office 1st<br />

2<br />

Flr East<br />

2920 1 2<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

3 2920 1 2<br />

Retail 6 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.10 $11.77 12.75<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.10 $11.77 12.75<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 2920 1 2<br />

Retail 7 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.10 $11.77 12.75<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 8760 7 2<br />

Back Hallway 3 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 0.66 5,764.1 $639.81 7 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.41 3556.56 $394.78 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 2207.52 $2.04 $247.08 4.25<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

31 8760 19 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

455 8.65 75,730.2 $8,406.05 19 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Garage B 1st Flr<br />

33 8760 23 1<br />

East<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

295 6.79 59,436.6 $6,597.46 23 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 19<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

Garage B Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

8760 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $548.41 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 3048.48 $338.38 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 1892.16 $1.75 $211.78 4.25<br />

11 8760 11 2<br />

Stairs B East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,005.42 11 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.64 5588.88 $620.37 $150.00 $1,650.00 0.40 3468.96 $3.21 $388.27 4.25<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 9 2<br />

Stairs C East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 7,411.0 $822.62 9 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.52 4572.72 $507.57 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 2838.24 $2.63 $317.67 4.25<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet F 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet F 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

2 8760 23 2<br />

Back Hallway 1 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 2.16 18,939.1 $2,102.24 23 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.33 11685.84 $1,297.13 $150.00 $3,450.00 0.83 7253.28 $6.72 $811.83 4.25<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $0.78 $94.13 12.75<br />

Restroom R15 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.10 -$2.50 -60.11<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R16<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $0.78 $94.13 12.75<br />

Restroom R16 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.10 -$2.50 -60.11<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 20<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

Room 126 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $0.19 $23.53 12.75<br />

26<br />

Concession Storage<br />

A 1st Flr<br />

2190 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 61.3 $6.81 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 2920 10 1<br />

Concession A 127<br />

1st Flr East<br />

12 2920 3 3<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

28 0.28 817.6 $90.75 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

75 0.23 657.0 $72.93 3 2<br />

2x2, 17W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Troffer Fixture; Metalux Accord<br />

34 0.10 297.84 $33.06 $125.00 $375.00 0.12 359.16 $0.73 $40.60 9.24<br />

1<br />

Storage A 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 3 4<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

Room 128 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 3 2<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.17 381.06 $42.30 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 854.1 $0.88 $95.68 4.70<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 1138.8 $1.17 $127.57 3.53<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.10 $11.77 12.75<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $0.78 $94.13 12.75<br />

Restroom R17 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.10 -$2.50 -60.11<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R18<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $0.78 $94.13 12.75<br />

Restroom R18 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.10 -$2.50 -60.11<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet G 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet G 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 21<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

11 8760 8 2<br />

Stairs D East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.46 4064.64 $451.18 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 2522.88 $2.34 $282.38 4.25<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 8 2<br />

Stairs E East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.46 4064.64 $451.18 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 2522.88 $2.34 $282.38 4.25<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 8760 14 2<br />

Back Hallway 4 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

94 1.32 11,528.2 $1,279.63 14 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.81 7113.12 $789.56 $150.00 $2,100.00 0.50 4415.04 $4.09 $494.16 4.25<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

31 4380 285 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

455 129.68 567,976.5 $63,045.39 285 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

35 4380 47 1<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

94 4.42 19,350.8 $2,147.94 47 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 4380 11 1<br />

Exhibit Hall D 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

19 4380 10 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

10 0.11 481.8 $53.48 11 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.90 3,942.0 $437.56 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 1051.2 $116.68 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 2890.8 $54.64 $375.52 2.39<br />

11 4380 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 2,058.6 $228.50 5 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.29 1270.2 $140.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 788.4 $0.73 $88.24 8.50<br />

26 4380 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 122.6 $13.61 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 Hvac 1 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $0.58 $70.59 17.00<br />

3 Hvac 2 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $0.58 $70.59 17.00<br />

3 Hvac 3 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $0.58 $70.59 17.00<br />

3 Hvac 4 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $0.58 $70.59 17.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 22<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3 Hvac 5 1st Flr East 2190 16 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.50 3,293.8 $365.61 16 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.93 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $2,400.00 0.58 1261.44 $1.17 $141.19 17.00<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Retail 1 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Retail 2 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Retail 3 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Retail 4 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Retail 5 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Room 114 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $0.78 $85.05 3.53<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $0.78 $85.05 3.53<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $0.78 $85.05 3.53<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $0.78 $85.05 3.53<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $0.78 $85.05 3.53<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $0.78 $85.05 3.53<br />

3<br />

Main Water Room<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.15 $17.65 17.00<br />

1<br />

2<br />

1<br />

Room 117 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Corridor B 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Room 115 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 3 4<br />

8760 6 2<br />

2920 3 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 3 2<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $548.41 6 2<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 3 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 1138.8 $1.17 $127.57 3.53<br />

58 0.35 3048.48 $338.38 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 1892.16 $1.75 $211.78 4.25<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 1138.8 $1.17 $127.57 3.53<br />

3<br />

Room 115 Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

1<br />

Room 116 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 3 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 3 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 1138.8 $1.17 $127.57 3.53<br />

3<br />

Room 116 Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

11 8760 10 2<br />

Stair F 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $914.02 10 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.58 5080.8 $563.97 $150.00 $1,500.00 0.36 3153.6 $2.92 $352.97 4.25<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 23<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

2<br />

1<br />

Storage Room 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

Room 118 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 3 2<br />

2920 4 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 617.6 $68.55 3 2<br />

188 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.17 381.06 $42.30 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 236.52 $0.22 $26.47 17.00<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 1518.4 $1.56 $170.10 3.53<br />

3<br />

Machine Room B<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $91.40 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 17.00<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.08 245.28 $0.39 $27.62 21.73<br />

Restroom R9 1st<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 12.75<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R9/R10 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.08 245.28 $0.39 $27.62 21.73<br />

Restroom R10 1st<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 12.75<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet H 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet H 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

3<br />

Storage C 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

11 8760 14 2<br />

Stair G 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.32 11,528.2 $1,279.63 14 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.81 7113.12 $789.56 $150.00 $2,100.00 0.50 4415.04 $4.09 $494.16 4.25<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 9 2<br />

Stair H 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 7,411.0 $822.62 9 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.52 4572.72 $507.57 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 2838.24 $2.63 $317.67 4.25


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 24<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Stair H 1st Flr East<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet I 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet I 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.08 245.28 $0.39 $27.62 21.73<br />

Restroom R11 1st<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 12.75<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R11/R12 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

Restroom R12 1st<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

Flr East<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

5 2920 7 2<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.08 245.28 $0.39 $27.62 21.73<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 12.75<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.66 1,921.4 $213.27 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 1185.52 $131.59 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 735.84 $0.68 $82.36 12.75<br />

6 Restroom R13 1st 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.10 $6.90 21.73<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R13<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

5 2920 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,921.4 $213.27 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 1185.52 $131.59 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 735.84 $0.68 $82.36 12.75<br />

Restroom R14 1st<br />

6 Flr East 2920 1 2<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.10 $6.90 21.73<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 25<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

18<br />

Room 125 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 2 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.23 671.6 $74.55 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Room 119 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 8 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.92 2,686.4 $298.19 8 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Room 119 Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 7 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.81 1,763.0 $195.69 7 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 8760 5 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.14 1,226.4 $136.13 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Corridor C 1st Flr<br />

18 8760 2 3<br />

East<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.23 2,014.8 $223.64 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5<br />

Restroom R5 1st<br />

Flr<br />

2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $0.78 $94.13 12.75<br />

26<br />

Room 124 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 16 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.45 1,308.2 $145.21 16 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

12 2920 4 3<br />

Room 120 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

75 0.30 876.0 $97.24 4 2<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

2x2, 17W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Troffer Fixture; Metalux Accord<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

34 0.14 397.12 $44.08 $125.00 $500.00 0.16 478.88 $0.97 $54.13 9.24<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18 2920 16 3<br />

Room 123 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

26 2920 8 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

115 1.84 5,372.8 $596.38 16 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.22 654.1 $72.60 8 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 8760 6 1<br />

Corridor D 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

3 8760 1 2<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

28 0.17 1,471.7 $163.36 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 823.4 $91.40 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 4.25<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Room 121/122 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.23 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 1261.44 $1.17 $141.19 4.25


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 26<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Stair I East<br />

43 8760 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 2190 4 2<br />

Mechanical Room<br />

1st Flr East<br />

13 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $91.40 4 2<br />

50 0.10 219.0 $24.31 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x2, 17W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fixture; Metalux 2M<br />

Fixture<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 17.00<br />

34 0.07 148.92 $16.53 $125.00 $250.00 0.03 70.08 $0.15 $7.92 31.55<br />

34<br />

Vestibule A 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

8760 9 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 1.92 16,792.9 $1,864.01 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

33 8760 42 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

295 12.39 108,536.4 $12,047.54 42 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

46 8760 32 0<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal<br />

Halide and 26W 1 lamp,<br />

CFL Decorative Fixture<br />

278 8.90 77,929.0 $8,650.11 32 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

34 8760 20 1<br />

22 8760 12 1<br />

35 8760 10 1<br />

26 8760 9 1<br />

Main Corridor A<br />

1st Flr East<br />

49 8760 8 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

50W, 1 Lamp, Direct<br />

Incendescent Track<br />

Mounted Fixture<br />

213 4.26 37,317.6 $4,142.25 20 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.60 5,256.0 $583.42 12 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.11 946.08 $105.01 $27.90 $334.80 0.49 4309.92 $131.14 $609.54 0.55<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $914.02 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.25 2,207.5 $245.03 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.40 3,504.0 $388.94 8 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.07 630.72 $70.01 $27.90 $223.20 0.33 2873.28 $87.42 $406.36 0.55<br />

21 8760 8 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard<br />

Bulb<br />

100 0.80 7,008.0 $777.89 8 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

36 0.29 2522.88 $280.04 $108.90 $871.20 0.51 4485.12 $87.42 $585.27 1.49<br />

43 8760 5 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.05 438.0 $48.62 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 8760 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.18 1,576.8 $175.02 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 1.20<br />

20 8760 2 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

23 0.05 403.0 $44.73 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

34<br />

Vestibule B 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

8760 5 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 1.07 9,329.4 $1,035.56 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

27 8760 12 2<br />

Vestibule C 1st Flr<br />

35 8760 6 1<br />

East<br />

26 8760 6 1<br />

41<br />

Outside Race St<br />

East<br />

8760 56 1<br />

26W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down<br />

Light High Pressure<br />

Sodium Fixture<br />

54 0.65 5,676.5 $630.09 12 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $548.41 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.17 1,471.7 $163.36 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

300 16.80 147,168.0 $16,335.65 56 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 27<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

33 8760 36 1<br />

Outside Arch St<br />

Tunnel East<br />

38 8760 6 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

400W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted (12th St.)<br />

Fixture<br />

295 10.62 93,031.2 $10,326.46 36 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

455 2.73 23,914.8 $2,654.54 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

46<br />

Outside Arch St<br />

East<br />

8760 16 0<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal<br />

Halide and 26W 1 lamp,<br />

CFL Decorative Fixture<br />

278 4.45 38,964.5 $4,325.06 16 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

46<br />

Outside 11th St<br />

East<br />

8760 10 0<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal<br />

Halide and 26W 1 lamp,<br />

CFL Decorative Fixture<br />

278 2.78 24,352.8 $2,703.16 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19<br />

Conf. Rm 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 28 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 2.52 7,358.4 $816.78 28 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.67 1962.24 $217.81 $89.90 $2,517.20 1.85 5396.16 $102.00 $700.97 3.59<br />

18<br />

Conf. Rm Clos.1<br />

1st Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 3 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.35 1,007.4 $111.82 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19<br />

Conf. Rm Clos.2<br />

1st Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 1 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.09 262.8 $29.17 1 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.02 70.08 $7.78 $89.90 $89.90 0.07 192.72 $3.64 $25.03 3.59<br />

26 2920 19 1<br />

16<br />

Open Office Area<br />

1 1st Flr East<br />

2920 1 2<br />

Mezz.<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

32W, 2 Lamp, Parabolic<br />

U-Tube T-12 Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

28 0.53 1,553.4 $172.43 19 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

60 0.06 175.2 $19.45 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

3<br />

IT Closet 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Elec Closet1 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2190 1 2<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Restroom1 1st Flr<br />

5 2920 1 2<br />

East Mezz.<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

14<br />

14<br />

Office1-SJ 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Office2 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

2920 2 2<br />

2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $0.19 $13.81 21.73<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.10 $11.77 12.75<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.10 -$2.50 -60.11<br />

73 0.15 426.3 $47.32 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

73 0.29 852.6 $94.64 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Copy Room 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 34 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 3.06 8,935.2 $991.81 34 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.82 2382.72 $264.48 $89.90 $3,056.60 2.24 6552.48 $123.85 $851.18 3.59


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 28<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Large Conf Rm 1st<br />

41 Flr East Mezz. 2920 4 1<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

17<br />

Open Office Area<br />

2 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

2920 9 2<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down<br />

Light High Pressure<br />

Sodium Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20W, 2 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Prismatic T-<br />

8 Fixture<br />

300 1.20 3,504.0 $388.94 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.45 1,314.0 $145.85 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office3-BR 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18 2920 6 3<br />

Office4-JR 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 3 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $223.64 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.27 788.4 $87.51 3 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.07 210.24 $23.34 $89.90 $269.70 0.20 578.16 $10.93 $75.10 3.59<br />

18 2920 6 3<br />

Office5-MA 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 3 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $223.64 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.27 788.4 $87.51 3 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.07 210.24 $23.34 $89.90 $269.70 0.20 578.16 $10.93 $75.10 3.59<br />

18 2920 6 3<br />

Office6-AY 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 3 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $223.64 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.27 788.4 $87.51 3 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.07 210.24 $23.34 $89.90 $269.70 0.20 578.16 $10.93 $75.10 3.59<br />

18<br />

Open Office Area<br />

2920 56 3<br />

3 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

26 2920 48 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

115 6.44 18,804.8 $2,087.33 56 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 1.34 3,924.5 $435.62 48 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Office7-LJ 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Office8-JRice 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Office9 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19<br />

Office10-AM 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 29<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

18<br />

Office11 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 6 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $223.64 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Office12 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Office13 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office14-SB 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18<br />

Office15-KM 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office16-RK 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18<br />

Office17-GB 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 6 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $223.64 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office18-CM 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office19-TN 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18<br />

Office20-MJ 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office21-EE 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 30<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

18<br />

Office22-KJ 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office23-CH 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office24 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18 2920 4 3<br />

Office25 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.05 140.16 $15.56 $89.90 $179.80 0.13 385.44 $7.29 $50.07 3.59<br />

18<br />

Office26-MA 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Office27-JG 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $149.10 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26<br />

3<br />

3<br />

5<br />

3<br />

Closet 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

IT Closet2 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Computer Rm 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

Restroom2 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Elec Closet2 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2190 1 1<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2920 3 2<br />

2190 1 2<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 61.3 $6.81 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $0.29 $35.30 12.75<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.07 $8.82 17.00<br />

18 2920 8 3<br />

Break Room 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 6 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

115 0.92 2,686.4 $298.19 8 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $175.02 6 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.14 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $539.40 0.40 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 3.59<br />

19 2920 16 1<br />

Conf Rm B 1st Flr<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.44 4,204.8 $466.73 16 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.38 1121.28 $124.46 $89.90 $1,438.40 1.06 3083.52 $58.28 $400.55 3.59


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 31<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

East Mezz.<br />

18 2920 8 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin<br />

Prismatic T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.92 2,686.4 $298.19 8 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26<br />

Hallway 1st Flr<br />

8760 4 1<br />

East Mezz.<br />

43 8760 3 1<br />

57<br />

Reception Area 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

8760 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Halogen<br />

Lamp Fixture<br />

28 0.11 981.1 $108.90 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.03 262.8 $29.17 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

250 0.50 4,380.0 $486.18 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 1737 438 312.18 1,708,559.9 $189,650.15 1737 226 30.254 145300.7 $16,128.37 $82,580.60 29.29 128116.5 $920.41 $15,141.34 5.45<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 32<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

CEG Job #: 1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - 2nd Floor<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address: 12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Building SF: XXXXX<br />

Lighting Upgrade - General<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Retro-Unit Watts Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Maintenance Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

3<br />

Hall C Storage 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 21 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.97 4,323.1 $479.86 21 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 1.22 2667.42 $296.08 $150.00 $3,150.00 0.76 1655.64 $9.18 $192.96 16.32<br />

1 Storage A 2nd Flr 2190 8 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 3,293.8 $365.61 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 4.50<br />

1 Storage B 2nd Flr 2190 4 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 1138.8 $7.00 $133.40 4.50<br />

2 Storage C 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet N<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet N 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3 Storage D 2nd Flr 2190 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,441.0 $159.95 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 889.14 $98.69 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 551.88 $3.06 $64.32 16.32<br />

3 Storage E 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

26<br />

Concession 1 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2920 10 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.28 817.6 $90.75 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

12<br />

1<br />

Concession 1 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

Concession 1<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

2920 3 3<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

75 0.23 657.0 $72.93 3 2<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $91.40 2 2<br />

2x2, 17W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Troffer Fixture; Metalux Accord<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

34 0.10 297.84 $33.06 $125.00 $375.00 0.12 359.16 $4.37 $44.24 8.48<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 569.4 $3.50 $66.70 4.50<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

Corridor A 2nd Flr<br />

43 8730 2 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.02 174.6 $19.38 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 33<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

1 Storage F 2nd Flr 2190 2 4<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

First Aide C 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $91.40 2 2<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 569.4 $3.50 $66.70 4.50<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 1138.8 $7.00 $133.40 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R27 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R27/28 2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R28 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

First Aide B 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 1138.8 $7.00 $133.40 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

11 Stair A 2nd Flr 8760 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 2,470.3 $274.21 3 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.17 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 4.08<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R29 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 34<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R29/30 2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R30 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

3 8760 27 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 2.54 22,232.9 $2,467.85 27 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 1.57 13718.16 $1,522.72 $150.00 $4,050.00 0.97 8514.72 $47.23 $992.36 4.08<br />

Corridor B 2nd Flr<br />

39 8760 4 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

125 0.50 4,380.0 $486.18 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 2920 4 2<br />

Office A 2nd Flr<br />

11 2920 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 420.48 $2.33 $49.01 12.24<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

2 Corridor C 2nd Flr 8760 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 4.08<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet M<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet M 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

2 Office B 2nd Flr 2920 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

Corridor D 2nd Flr<br />

43 8760 3 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.03 262.8 $29.17 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 Storage G 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 35<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet L<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet L 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

2 Office C 2nd Flr 2920 2 2<br />

2 Corridor E 2nd Flr 8760 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

58 0.12 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 4.08<br />

3<br />

Trash Compactor<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 10 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.94 2,058.6 $228.50 10 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.58 1270.2 $140.99 $150.00 $1,500.00 0.36 788.4 $4.37 $91.89 16.32<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Concession 2<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

Concession 2 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

3 Storage H 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Concession 3 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

Concession 3<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $91.40 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $91.40 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 569.4 $3.50 $66.70 4.50<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $4.66 $88.94 3.37<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $4.66 $88.94 3.37<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 569.4 $3.50 $66.70 4.50<br />

3 Storage I 2nd Flr 2190 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.28 617.6 $68.55 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 381.06 $42.30 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 236.52 $1.31 $27.57 16.32<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R31 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R31/32 2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 36<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Restroom R32 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

First Aide A 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.39 1138.8 $7.00 $133.40 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

3 8760 28 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 2.63 23,056.3 $2,559.25 28 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 1.62 14226.24 $1,579.11 $150.00 $4,200.00 1.01 8830.08 $48.97 $1,029.11 4.08<br />

39 Corridor F 2nd Flr 8760 2 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

Corridor G 2nd Flr<br />

43 8760 3 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.03 262.8 $29.17 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Concession 4<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

Concession 4 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $91.40 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 569.4 $3.50 $66.70 4.50<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.26 759.2 $4.66 $88.94 3.37<br />

3 Storage J 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

1 Storage K 2nd Flr 2190 6 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 2,470.3 $274.21 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 1708.2 $10.49 $200.10 4.50<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet Q<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet Q 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3 Storage L 2nd Flr 2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 37<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3 2190 53 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 4.98 10,910.6 $1,211.07 53 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 3.07 6732.06 $747.26 $150.00 $7,950.00 1.91 4178.52 $23.18 $486.99 16.32<br />

2 2190 6 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

Hall A Storage 2nd<br />

16 2190 6 2<br />

Flr<br />

32W, 2 Lamp, Parabolic<br />

U-Tube T-12 Fixture<br />

60 0.36 788.4 $87.51 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2190 3 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.03 65.7 $7.29 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

45 2190 1 1<br />

25W, 1 lamp,<br />

Incandescent exit sign<br />

25 0.03 54.8 $6.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

41 4380 28 1<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down<br />

Light High Pressure<br />

Sodium Fixture<br />

300 8.40 36,792.0 $4,083.91 28 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

58 4380 10 1<br />

??W, 1 Lamp, Pole<br />

Mounted Fixture<br />

0 0.00 0.0 $0.00 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Loading Dock 2nd<br />

42 4380 5 1<br />

Flr<br />

400W, 1 Lamp Down<br />

Light High Pressure<br />

Sodium Fixture<br />

464 2.32 10,161.6 $1,127.94 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

39 4380 2 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

125 0.25 1,095.0 $121.55 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 4380 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 43.8 $4.86 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Loading Dock<br />

Storage A 2nd Flr<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

3<br />

Loading Dock<br />

Storage B 2nd Flr<br />

2190 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $91.40 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 16.32<br />

56 4380 176 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

Incandescent Fixture<br />

90 15.84 69,379.2 $7,701.09 176 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 4.22 18501.12 $2,053.62 $89.90 $15,822.40 11.62 50878.08 $961.67 $6,609.14 2.39<br />

30 4380 96 1<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

1085 104.16 456,220.8 $50,640.51 96 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

35 4380 28 1<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

94 2.63 11,528.2 $1,279.63 28 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Exhibit Hall C 2nd<br />

43 4380 16 1<br />

Flr<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.16 700.8 $77.79 16 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 38<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

19 4380 6 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.54 2,365.2 $262.54 6 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.14 630.72 $70.01 $89.90 $539.40 0.40 1734.48 $32.78 $225.31 2.39<br />

55 4380 6 1<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

295 1.77 7,752.6 $860.54 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 4380 4 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.11 490.6 $54.45 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

30 4380 96 1<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

1085 104.16 456,220.8 $50,640.51 96 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 4380 39 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 3.51 15,373.8 $1,706.49 39 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.94 4099.68 $455.06 $89.90 $3,506.10 2.57 11274.12 $213.10 $1,464.53 2.39<br />

43 4380 13 1<br />

Ehibit Hall B 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

55 4380 6 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

10 0.13 569.4 $63.20 13 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 1.77 7,752.6 $860.54 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

20 4380 3 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

23 0.07 302.2 $33.55 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 4380 4 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.11 490.6 $54.45 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

30 4380 144 1<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

1085 156.24 684,331.2 $75,960.76 144 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

35 4380 28 1<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

94 2.63 11,528.2 $1,279.63 28 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 4380 19 1<br />

Exhibit Hall A 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

55 4380 7 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

10 0.19 832.2 $92.37 19 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 2.07 9,044.7 $1,003.96 7 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

20 4380 6 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

23 0.14 604.4 $67.09 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 4380 4 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.11 490.6 $54.45 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 Storage M 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 39<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

2 Storage N 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R19<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.70 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $1,800.00 0.43 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 12.24<br />

6 2920 7 2<br />

Restroom R19 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $179.24 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 1185.52 $131.59 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.15 429.24 $4.08 $51.73 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.70 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $1,800.00 0.43 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 12.24<br />

6 2920<br />

Restroom R20 2nd<br />

7 2<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R20<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2 Storage O 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

3 Storage P 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $179.24 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 1185.52 $131.59 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.15 429.24 $4.08 $51.73 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R21<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R21 2nd<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 40<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

Restroom R22 2nd<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R22<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3 Storage Q 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

26 2920 21 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.59 1,717.0 $190.58 21 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Business &<br />

16 Imaging <strong>Center</strong> 2920 18 2<br />

2nd Flr<br />

32W, 2 Lamp, Parabolic<br />

U-Tube T-12 Fixture<br />

60 1.08 3,153.6 $350.05 18 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 6 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $175.02 6 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.14 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $539.40 0.40 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 3.59<br />

1 Storage R 2nd Flr 2190 4 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 1138.8 $7.00 $133.40 4.50<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet P<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet P 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

Restroom R33 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R33<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet O<br />

2nd Flr<br />

Elec Closet O 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 41<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

26 Restroom R34 2nd 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 840.96 $4.66 $98.01 12.24<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R34<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

1 Storage S 2nd Flr 2190 4 4<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

Restroom R23 2nd<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

3<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R23<br />

2nd Flr<br />

Janitor Closet R24<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2190 1 2<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

188 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 4 2<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 1138.8 $7.00 $133.40 4.50<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

6 Restroom R24 2nd 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

22 2190 16 1<br />

Storage T 2nd Flr<br />

26 2190 6 1<br />

2 Storage U 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

20 Storage V 2nd Flr 2190 10 1<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

50 0.80 1,752.0 $194.47 16 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.14 315.36 $35.00 $27.90 $446.40 0.66 1436.64 $43.71 $203.18 2.20<br />

28 0.17 367.9 $40.84 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

23 0.23 503.7 $55.91 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 Storage W 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 42<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R25<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

6 2920 7 2<br />

Restroom R25 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

6 2920 7 2<br />

Restroom R26 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R26<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2 Storage X 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2 Storage Y 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

26 8760 147 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $179.24 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.70 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $1,800.00 0.43 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 12.24<br />

58 0.41 1185.52 $131.59 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.15 429.24 $4.08 $51.73 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $179.24 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

58 0.70 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $1,800.00 0.43 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 12.24<br />

58 0.41 1185.52 $131.59 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.15 429.24 $4.08 $51.73 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 -0.01 -23.36 $0.58 -$2.01 -74.63<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

28 4.12 36,056.2 $4,002.23 147 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

46 8760 88 0<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal<br />

Halide and 26W 1 lamp,<br />

CFL Decorative Fixture<br />

278 24.46 214,304.6 $23,787.82 88 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

32 8760 48 1<br />

Main Corridor A<br />

2nd Flr<br />

43 8760 6 1<br />

20 8760 3 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp,<br />

Downlight Can Metal<br />

Halide Fixture<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

455 21.84 191,318.4 $21,236.34 48 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.06 525.6 $58.34 6 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

23 0.07 604.4 $67.09 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 8760 1 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.09 788.4 $87.51 1 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.02 210.24 $23.34 $89.90 $89.90 0.07 578.16 $10.93 $75.10 1.20<br />

26 Esculator A 2nd Flr 8760 35 1<br />

26 8760 26 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.98 8,584.8 $952.91 35 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.73 6,377.3 $707.88 26 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 43<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

21 Esculator B 2nd Flr 8760 8 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard<br />

Bulb<br />

100 0.80 7,008.0 $777.89 8 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

36 0.29 2522.88 $280.04 $108.90 $871.20 0.51 4485.12 $87.42 $585.27 1.49<br />

4 8760 6 1<br />

40W, 1 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

57 0.34 2,995.9 $332.55 6 1<br />

4', 32W, 1 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

28 0.17 1471.68 $163.36 $150.00 $900.00 0.17 1524.24 $5.25 $174.44 5.16<br />

Totals 1756 330 517.20 2,443,485.3 $271,226.87 1756 234 34.304 123184.6 $13,673.49 $95,839.80 37.93 141301.7 $1,780.62 $17,465.11 5.49<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 44<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

CEG Job #: 1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - 3rd Floor<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address: 12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Building SF: XXXXX<br />

Lighting Upgrade - General<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Retro-Unit Watts Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Maintenance Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

19 2920 8 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.72 2,102.4 $233.37 8 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.19 560.64 $62.23 $89.90 $719.20 0.53 1541.76 $29.14 $200.28 3.59<br />

Meeting Rm 300<br />

1 3rd Flr 2920 6 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.26 770.88 $85.57 $89.90 $988.90 0.73 2119.92 $40.07 $275.38 3.59<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 301<br />

2920 6 4<br />

3rd Flr<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.26 770.88 $85.57 $89.90 $988.90 0.73 2119.92 $40.07 $275.38 3.59<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

Meeting Rm 302<br />

3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6<br />

Restroom R46 3rd<br />

2920 3 2<br />

Flr<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 45<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 -0.02 -70.08 $1.75 -$6.03 -74.63<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R45 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 -0.02 -70.08 $1.75 -$6.03 -74.63<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

20<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R45/R46 3rd Flr<br />

2190 1 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

23 0.02 50.4 $5.59 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 Storage U 3rd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet U 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet U 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

303A 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 3036.8 $18.66 $355.74 3.37<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

303B 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 3036.8 $18.66 $355.74 3.37<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 46<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

21 2920 13 1<br />

Office1 3rd Flr<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard<br />

Bulb<br />

100 1.30 3,796.0 $421.36 13 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

36 0.47 1366.56 $151.69 $108.90 $1,415.70 0.83 2429.44 $47.36 $317.02 4.47<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59<br />

3 Office2 3rd Flr 2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 12.24<br />

3 Storage R44 3rd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

Restroom R44 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 -0.02 -70.08 $1.75 -$6.03 -74.63<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R43 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 -0.02 -70.08 $1.75 -$6.03 -74.63<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

20<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R43/R44 3rd Flr<br />

2190 1 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

23 0.02 50.4 $5.59 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 Storage T 3rd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet T 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 47<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet T 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

2 Corridor T 3rd Flr 8760 4 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 4.08<br />

19 Office3 3rd Flr 2920 6 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $175.02 6 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.14 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $539.40 0.40 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 3.59<br />

19 2920 47 1<br />

Meeting Room 304<br />

VIP 3rd Flr<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

90 4.23 12,351.6 $1,371.03 47 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.13 3293.76 $365.61 $89.90 $4,225.30 3.10 9057.84 $171.21 $1,176.63 3.59<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

1 Office4 3rd Flr 2920 6 4<br />

3 Storage S 3rd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2 Corridor S 3rd Flr 8760 5 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.29 2540.4 $281.98 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 1576.8 $8.75 $183.77 4.08<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet S 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet S 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3 Office5 3rd Flr 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

3<br />

Office5 Storage 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59<br />

Meeting Room 305<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

3rd Flr<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 48<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Meeting Room 306<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

3rd Flr<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

307A 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 3036.8 $18.66 $355.74 3.37<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.24 700.8 $77.79 $89.90 $899.00 0.66 1927.2 $36.43 $250.35 3.59<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

307B 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.46 1354.88 $150.39 $150.00 $1,200.00 1.04 3036.8 $18.66 $355.74 3.37<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet R 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet R 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3 Storage R 3rd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R42 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 -0.02 -70.08 $1.75 -$6.03 -74.63


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 49<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R41 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 -0.02 -70.08 $1.75 -$6.03 -74.63<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

20<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R41/R42 3rd Flr<br />

2190 1 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

23 0.02 50.4 $5.59 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 Office A 2nd Flr 2920 4 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 420.48 $2.33 $49.01 12.24<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.26 770.88 $85.57 $89.90 $988.90 0.73 2119.92 $40.07 $275.38 3.59<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

Meeting Room 308<br />

3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.26 770.88 $85.57 $89.90 $988.90 0.73 2119.92 $40.07 $275.38 3.59<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

Meeting Room 309<br />

3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.35 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $900.00 0.78 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 3.37<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 6 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $175.02 6 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.14 420.48 $46.67 $89.90 $539.40 0.40 1156.32 $21.86 $150.21 3.59


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 50<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

1 2920 4 4<br />

Meeting Room 310<br />

3rd Flr<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

188 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.52 1518.4 $9.33 $177.87 3.37<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 2920 1 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 8760 172 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 4.82 42,188.2 $4,682.89 172 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

21 8760 34 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard<br />

Bulb<br />

100 3.40 29,784.0 $3,306.02 34 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

36 1.22 10722.24 $1,190.17 $108.90 $3,702.60 2.18 19061.76 $371.56 $2,487.41 1.49<br />

43 8760 5 1<br />

Main Corridor 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

20 8760 4 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

CFL Replacement Flood<br />

Light<br />

10 0.05 438.0 $48.62 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

23 0.09 805.9 $89.46 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 8760 1 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.09 788.4 $87.51 1 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.02 210.24 $23.34 $89.90 $89.90 0.07 578.16 $10.93 $75.10 1.20<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

21<br />

Overlook Café 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2920 135 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard<br />

Bulb<br />

100 13.50 39,420.0 $4,375.62 135 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

36 4.86 14191.2 $1,575.22 $108.90 $14,701.50 8.64 25228.8 $491.76 $3,292.16 4.47<br />

21 2920 52 1<br />

Retail 3rd Flr<br />

8 2920 36 4<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard<br />

Bulb<br />

2x4, 20W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Parabolic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

100 5.20 15,184.0 $1,685.42 52 1<br />

100 3.60 10,512.0 $1,166.83 36 2<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Parabolic Fixture; Metalux<br />

Paralux II<br />

36 1.87 5466.24 $606.75 $108.90 $5,662.80 3.33 9717.76 $189.42 $1,268.09 4.47<br />

58 2.09 6096.96 $676.76 $150.00 $5,400.00 1.51 4415.04 $83.96 $574.03 9.41<br />

5 2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 420.48 $2.33 $49.01 12.24<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

Retail Restroom1<br />

3rd Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.08 245.28 $2.33 $29.56 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

45 2920 2 1<br />

25W, 1 lamp,<br />

Incandescent exit sign<br />

25 0.05 146.0 $16.21 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 51<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

5 2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 420.48 $2.33 $49.01 12.24<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

Retail Restroom2<br />

3rd Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.08 245.28 $2.33 $29.56 20.30<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

45 2920 2 1<br />

25W, 1 lamp,<br />

Incandescent exit sign<br />

25 0.05 146.0 $16.21 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 902 196 75.48 273,482.1 $30,356.51 902 130 26.712 87616.06 $9,725.38 $77,844.40 42.56 138808.0 $2,128.18 $17,535.88 4.44<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 52<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

CEG Job #: 1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - 2nd Floor Trian Shed<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address: 12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Building SF: XXXXX<br />

Lighting Upgrade - General<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Retro-Unit Watts Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Maintenance Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

26<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Bridge Area <strong>Center</strong><br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 8760 144 1 Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 4.03 35,320.3 $3,920.56 144 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

21<br />

Bridge Area<br />

Windows 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

8760 64 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard<br />

Bulb<br />

100 6.40 56,064.0 $6,223.10 64 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

36 2.30 20183.04 $2,240.32 $108.90 $6,969.60 4.10 35880.96 $699.40 $4,682.18 1.49<br />

28 8760 36 1<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20 0.72 6,307.2 $700.10 36 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Lobby 2nd Flr<br />

19 8760 46 1<br />

Train Shed<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.14 36,266.4 $4,025.57 46 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.10 9671.04 $1,073.49 $89.90 $4,135.40 3.04 26595.36 $502.69 $3,454.78 1.20<br />

45 8760 2 1<br />

25W, 1 lamp,<br />

Incandescent exit sign<br />

25 0.05 438.0 $48.62 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2<br />

3<br />

2<br />

Sercurity W 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

Storage W 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

Registration Office<br />

W 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

8760 2 2<br />

2190 2 2<br />

2920 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.12 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 4.08<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet EE<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

2<br />

2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Elec Closet EE<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

Bathroom1 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

Bathroom2 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 53<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Restroom R38 2nd<br />

6 Flr Train Shed 2920 1 2<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R37 2nd<br />

6 Flr Train Shed 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

2<br />

First Aid E 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 3 2<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.11 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 12.24<br />

3<br />

Storage E 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

2<br />

3<br />

Registration Office<br />

E 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R38/R37 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 2 2<br />

2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet FF<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Elec Closet FF<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R40 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R39 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 54<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R39/R40 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

6<br />

Bathroom3 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

6<br />

Bathroom4 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

2 8760 27 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 2.54 22,232.9 $2,467.85 27 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.57 13718.16 $1,522.72 $150.00 $4,050.00 0.97 8514.72 $47.23 $992.36 4.08<br />

33 8760 10 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

295 2.95 25,842.0 $2,868.46 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.29 2540.4 $281.98 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 1576.8 $8.75 $183.77 4.08<br />

45<br />

West Side Service<br />

Hall 2nd Flr Train<br />

8760 5 1<br />

Shed<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

25W, 1 lamp,<br />

Incandescent exit sign<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

25 0.13 1,095.0 $121.55 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

34 8760 1 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 0.21 1,865.9 $207.11 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2W, LED Retrofitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet<br />

A 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec. Substation<br />

Rm. W 2nd Flr<br />

Train Station<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet<br />

B 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet<br />

C 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

2 8760 27 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 2.54 22,232.9 $2,467.85 27 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.57 13718.16 $1,522.72 $150.00 $4,050.00 0.97 8514.72 $47.23 $992.36 4.08<br />

33 8760 10 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

295 2.95 25,842.0 $2,868.46 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 55<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

11 8760 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

58 0.29 2540.4 $281.98 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 1576.8 $8.75 $183.77 4.08<br />

East Side Service<br />

45 Hall 2nd Flr Train 8760 5 1<br />

Shed<br />

25W, 1 lamp,<br />

Incandescent exit sign<br />

25 0.13 1,095.0 $121.55 5 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

34 8760 1 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

213 0.21 1,865.9 $207.11 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2W, LED Retrofitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet<br />

D 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec. Substation<br />

Rm. E 2nd Flr<br />

Train Station<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet<br />

E 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet<br />

F 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.32 1927.2 $213.92 $89.90 $4,944.50 3.63 5299.8 $100.17 $688.45 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 201A<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 3 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 36 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 3.24 4,730.4 $525.07 36 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.86 1261.44 $140.02 $89.90 $3,236.40 2.38 3468.96 $65.57 $450.62 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 201B<br />

1 1460 24 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.39 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $3,600.00 3.12 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 6.75<br />

43 2920 4 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.32 1927.2 $213.92 $89.90 $4,944.50 3.63 5299.8 $100.17 $688.45 7.18


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 56<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Meeting Rm. 201C<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 3 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.50 735.84 $81.68 $89.90 $1,887.90 1.39 2023.56 $38.25 $262.86 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 202A<br />

1 1460 12 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.70 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,800.00 1.56 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.50 735.84 $81.68 $89.90 $1,887.90 1.39 2023.56 $38.25 $262.86 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 202B<br />

1 1460 12 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.70 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,800.00 1.56 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R36 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R35 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

54 8760 92 1<br />

48W, 1 Lamp, Indirect<br />

Strip Flourescent, HO<br />

T-12 Fixture<br />

70 6.44 56,414.4 $6,262.00 92 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.83 7253.28 $805.11 $27.90 $2,566.80 5.61 49161.12 $1,005.39 $6,462.27 0.40<br />

22 8760 72 1<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

50 3.60 31,536.0 $3,500.50 72 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.65 5676.48 $630.09 $27.90 $2,008.80 2.95 25859.52 $786.82 $3,657.23 0.55


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 57<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Main Corridor 2nd<br />

50 8760 40 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

13W, 2 Lamp, Compact<br />

Flourescent Wall Sconce<br />

fixture<br />

30 1.20 10,512.0 $1,166.83 40 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

24 8760 18 1<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

50 0.90 7,884.0 $875.12 18 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.16 1419.12 $157.52 $27.90 $502.20 0.74 6464.88 $196.71 $914.31 0.55<br />

28 8760 4 1<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20 0.08 700.8 $77.79 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.32 1927.2 $213.92 $89.90 $4,944.50 3.63 5299.8 $100.17 $688.45 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 204A<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 3 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 36 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 3.24 4,730.4 $525.07 36 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.86 1261.44 $140.02 $89.90 $3,236.40 2.38 3468.96 $65.57 $450.62 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 204B<br />

1 1460 24 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.39 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $3,600.00 3.12 4555.2 $27.99 $533.61 6.75<br />

43 2920 4 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 1.32 1927.2 $213.92 $89.90 $4,944.50 3.63 5299.8 $100.17 $688.45 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 204C<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.86 2709.76 $300.78 $150.00 $4,800.00 4.16 6073.6 $37.31 $711.48 6.75<br />

43 2920 3 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.50 735.84 $81.68 $89.90 $1,887.90 1.39 2023.56 $38.25 $262.86 7.18<br />

Meeting Rm. 203A<br />

1 1460 12 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.70 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,800.00 1.56 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.50 735.84 $81.68 $89.90 $1,887.90 1.39 2023.56 $38.25 $262.86 7.18


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 58<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

Meeting Rm. 203B<br />

1 1460 12 4<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.70 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,800.00 1.56 2277.6 $13.99 $266.81 6.75<br />

43 2920 2 1<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R34 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.52 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,350.00 0.32 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 12.24<br />

Restroom R33 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.02 61.32 $0.58 $7.39 20.30<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Fan Room W 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,441.0 $159.95 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 889.14 $98.69 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 551.88 $3.06 $64.32 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Housekeeping W<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 8 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 16.32<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet W<br />

2nd Flr train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

28 8760 12 1<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20 0.24 2,102.4 $233.37 12 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Corridor GG 2nd<br />

2 8760 4 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 4.08<br />

44 8760 2 0<br />

2W, LED Retrofitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

2 0.00 35.0 $3.89 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Side Room GG 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

3<br />

Storage GG 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 59<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet GG<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pump Room GG<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 2 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Elec Closet GG<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 2 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage2 GG 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Fan Room E 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,441.0 $159.95 7 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.41 889.14 $98.69 $150.00 $1,050.00 0.25 551.88 $3.06 $64.32 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Housekeeping E<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet E<br />

2nd Flr train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

28 8760 12 1<br />

Corridor HH 2nd<br />

2 Flr Train Shed 8760 4 2<br />

44 8760 2 0<br />

3<br />

3<br />

Side Room HH 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

Storage1 HH 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2920 2 2<br />

2190 2 2<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrofitted<br />

Exit Sign'<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20 0.24 2,102.4 $233.37 12 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.23 2032.32 $225.59 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 1261.44 $7.00 $147.02 4.08<br />

2 0.00 35.0 $3.89 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 210.24 $1.17 $24.50 12.24<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet HH<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pump Room HH<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 2 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Elec Closet HH<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 2 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage2 HH 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

40 4380 2 1<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Surface<br />

Indirect High Pressure<br />

Sodium Fixture<br />

1100 2.20 9,636.0 $1,069.60 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 60<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

36 4380 2 1<br />

37 4380<br />

Grand Hall 2nd Flr<br />

2 1<br />

Train Shed<br />

47 4380 10 0<br />

53 4380 16 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Surface<br />

Indirect Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Surface<br />

Indirect Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

(2)1000W, HPS, and (2)<br />

400W MH and (1)<br />

1000W MH,<br />

Combination w/<br />

Direction Dampers<br />

60W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted High Pressure<br />

Sodium Wall Sconce<br />

455 0.91 3,985.8 $442.42 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

1085 2.17 9,504.6 $1,055.01 2 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

4195 41.95 183,741.0 $20,395.25 10 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 2.00 8,760.0 $972.36 16 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 1496 221 183.54 737,838.7 $81,900.10 1496 163 41.214 139729.3 $15,509.95 $120,185.20 78.94 261436.4 $4,355.23 $33,374.66 3.60<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 61<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

CEG Job #: 1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - 3rd Floor Trian Shed<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address: 12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Building SF: XXXXX<br />

Lighting Upgrade - General<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Retro-Unit Watts Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Maintenance Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

3<br />

Mech Rm1 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.46 1016.16 $112.79 $150.00 $1,200.00 0.29 630.72 $3.50 $73.51 16.32<br />

3<br />

Mech Rm2 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,029.3 $114.25 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 635.1 $70.50 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 394.2 $2.19 $45.94 16.32<br />

3<br />

Mech Rm2 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.35 762.12 $84.60 $150.00 $900.00 0.22 473.04 $2.62 $55.13 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage1 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 11 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.03 2,264.5 $251.36 11 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.64 1397.22 $155.09 $150.00 $1,650.00 0.40 867.24 $4.81 $101.07 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage2 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $91.40 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Elec Substation Rm<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 12 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.13 2,470.3 $274.21 12 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.70 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,800.00 0.43 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 16.32<br />

3<br />

Fan Room 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 12 2<br />

1 2920 60 4<br />

Ballroom Kitchen<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed<br />

3 2920 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 1.13 2,470.3 $274.21 12 2<br />

188 11.28 32,937.6 $3,656.07 60 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.70 1524.24 $169.19 $150.00 $1,800.00 0.43 946.08 $5.25 $110.26 16.32<br />

58 3.48 10161.6 $1,127.94 $150.00 $9,000.00 7.80 22776 $139.93 $2,668.06 3.37<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

53<br />

Ballroom Service<br />

8760 20 1<br />

Corridor 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

11 8760 20 2<br />

2 8760 94 2<br />

60W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted High Pressure<br />

Sodium Wall Sconce<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

125 2.50 21,900.0 $2,430.90 20 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 1.88 16,468.8 $1,828.04 20 2<br />

94 8.84 77,403.4 $8,591.77 94 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Surface<br />

Mounted Fluorescent Fixture;<br />

Metalux WN fixture<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 1.16 10161.6 $1,127.94 $150.00 $3,000.00 0.72 6307.2 $34.98 $735.08 4.08<br />

58 5.45 47759.52 $5,301.31 $150.00 $14,100.00 3.38 29643.84 $164.41 $3,454.88 4.08<br />

Service Corridor<br />

43 8760 11 1<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

10 0.11 963.6 $106.96 11 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 62<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

19 8760 8 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 0.72 6,307.2 $700.10 8 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 0.19 1681.92 $186.69 $89.90 $719.20 0.53 4625.28 $87.42 $600.83 1.20<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet AA 3rd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet AA<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage3 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

59 2920 15 0 0 0 0.00 0.0 $0.00 15 0 0 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 2920 12 1<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20 0.24 700.8 $77.79 12 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Dressing Room1<br />

5 3rd Flr Tain Station 2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 420.48 $2.33 $49.01 12.24<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

59 2920 15 0 0 0 0.00 0.0 $0.00 15 0 0 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 2920 12 1<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20 0.24 700.8 $77.79 12 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Dressing Room 2<br />

5 3rd Flr Tain Station 2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 677.44 $75.20 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 420.48 $2.33 $49.01 12.24<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 338.72 $37.60 $150.00 $300.00 0.04 122.64 $1.17 $14.78 20.30<br />

2<br />

Bathroom1 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

3<br />

Dimmer Room 3rd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

2<br />

Bathroom2 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

3<br />

Storage4 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet BB 3rd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 63<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet BB<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

3<br />

Ballroom Closet 1-<br />

4 3rd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2190 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $91.40 4 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.23 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $600.00 0.14 315.36 $1.75 $36.75 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage5 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

Storage6 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

9 2920 512 1<br />

32W, 1 lamp, T-8<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

36 18.43 53,821.4 $5,974.18 512 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

51 2920 512 2<br />

100W, 2 Lamp, Pendant<br />

Incondescent Down<br />

Light<br />

100 51.20 149,504.0 $16,594.94 512 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 36<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

36 18.43 53821.44 $5,974.18 $108.90 $55,756.80 32.77 95682.56 $6,021.27 $16,642.04 3.35<br />

19 Ballroom AB 3rd 2920 116 1<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood<br />

Light<br />

90 10.44 30,484.8 $3,383.81 116 1<br />

DIMMABLE 12 Cree LED 24<br />

Watt High Output PAR38 Spot<br />

Lamp<br />

24 2.78 8129.28 $902.35 $89.90 $10,428.40 7.66 22355.52 $422.55 $2,904.02 3.59<br />

52 2920 20 1<br />

60W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted Incondescent<br />

Wall Sconce<br />

60 1.20 3,504.0 $388.94 20 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

45 2920 14 1<br />

25W, 1 lamp,<br />

Incandescent exit sign<br />

25 0.35 1,022.0 $113.44 14 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet CC 3rd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet CC<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

9<br />

Food Staging5 3rd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2920 3 1<br />

32W, 1 lamp, T-8<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

36 0.11 315.4 $35.00 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

2<br />

Bathroom3 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

2x4, 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Recessed<br />

Prismatic Troffer Fixture;<br />

Metalux Accord Recessed<br />

Troffer<br />

58 0.06 169.36 $18.80 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 105.12 $0.58 $12.25 12.24<br />

28 8760 18 1<br />

Corridor1 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

50 8760 4 2<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

13W, 2 Lamp, Compact<br />

Flourescent Wall Sconce<br />

fixture<br />

20 0.36 3,153.6 $350.05 18 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

30 0.12 1,051.2 $116.68 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Janitor Closet R1<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 64<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

29 2920 9 2<br />

13W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30 0.27 788.4 $87.51 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Restroom R1 3rd<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Janitor Closet R2<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

29 2920 9 2<br />

13W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30 0.27 788.4 $87.51 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Restroom R2 3rd<br />

5 Flr Train Shed 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

25<br />

13W, 4 lamp, Upright<br />

Terrace Seating1<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2920 9 4 Lamp Style CFL<br />

Replacement Bulb Light<br />

13 0.12 341.6 $37.92 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

22 2920 36 1<br />

Ballroom<br />

Prefunction 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

43 2920 8 1<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit<br />

Sign<br />

50 1.80 5,256.0 $583.42 36 1<br />

DIMMABLE Cree Chip 9 Watt 3<br />

LED High Output MR16 Mini<br />

Spot<br />

9 0.32 946.08 $105.01 $27.90 $1,004.40 1.48 4309.92 $131.14 $609.54 1.65<br />

10 0.08 233.6 $25.93 8 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

25<br />

13W, 4 lamp, Upright<br />

Terrace Seating2<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2920 9 4 Lamp Style CFL<br />

Replacement Bulb Light<br />

13 0.12 341.6 $37.92 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Janitor Closet R3<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

29 2920 9 2<br />

13W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30 0.27 788.4 $87.51 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Restroom R3 3rd<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Janitor Closet R4<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32


Appendix E - ECM #2 Lighting System Upgrade -Page 65<br />

Investment Grade Lighting Audit<br />

29 2920 9 2<br />

13W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

30 0.27 788.4 $87.51 9 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Restroom R4 3rd<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.29 846.8 $93.99 $150.00 $750.00 0.18 525.6 $2.92 $61.26 12.24<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.17 508.08 $56.40 $150.00 $450.00 0.06 183.96 $1.75 $22.17 20.30<br />

28 8760 18 1<br />

Corridor2 3rd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

50 8760 4 2<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

13W, 2 Lamp, Compact<br />

Flourescent Wall Sconce<br />

fixture<br />

20 0.36 3,153.6 $350.05 18 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

30 0.12 1,051.2 $116.68 4 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet DD 3rd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.12 254.04 $28.20 $150.00 $300.00 0.07 157.68 $0.87 $18.38 16.32<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Phone Closet DD<br />

3rd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 Pendant Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

4', 32W, 2 lamp, T-8 Strip<br />

Fixture; Metalux model SNF<br />

58 0.06 127.02 $14.10 $150.00 $150.00 0.04 78.84 $0.44 $9.19 16.32<br />

9<br />

Food Staging6 3rd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2920 3 1<br />

32W, 1 lamp, T-8<br />

Indirect Strip<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

36 0.11 315.4 $35.00 3 0 NCR 0 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 1723 127 124.15 444,263.4 $49,313.24 1723 92 39.596 151714.4 $16,840.30 $114,108.80 58.92 196825.5 $7,067.30 $28,914.93 3.95<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 1<br />

CEG Job #:<br />

1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> "PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> 1st Flr West"<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address:<br />

12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Lighting Controls<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Lighting Controls Watts Savings Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used (%) kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

24 8760 8 1<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

50 0.40 3,504.0 $388.94 8 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.32 2803 $311.16 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 700.8 $77.79 2.06<br />

Security 1st Flr<br />

18<br />

West<br />

8760 4 3<br />

1 8760 2 4<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

115 0.46 4,029.6 $447.29 4 0<br />

188 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 2 2<br />

2<br />

Security A 1st Flr<br />

8760 8 2<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2<br />

West<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0<br />

2<br />

Security B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 4 2<br />

1 8760 4 4<br />

Security C 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

11 8760 2 2<br />

1 8760 4 4<br />

Security D 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

11 8760 2 2<br />

10<br />

Corridor A 1st Flr<br />

8760 10 2<br />

West<br />

44 8760 3 0<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2<br />

188 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 4 2<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

188 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 4 2<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

115 20% 0.37 3224 $357.83 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 805.92 $89.46 1.79<br />

188 20% 0.30 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

94 20% 0.60 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

10 20% 0.01 70 $7.78 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 17.52 $1.94 82.27<br />

94 20% 0.30 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

188 20% 0.60 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

94 20% 0.15 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

188 20% 0.60 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

94 20% 0.15 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

57 0.57 4,993.2 $554.25 10 0 N/A 57 0% 0.57 4993 $554.25 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.01 52.6 $5.83 3 0 N/A 2 0% 0.01 53 $5.83 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2 N/A 94 0% 0.56 1235 $137.10 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 Stairs A West 8760 5 2<br />

11 Stairs B West 8760 7 2<br />

2<br />

Corridor B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 17 2<br />

1 2920 4 4<br />

2 2920 4 2<br />

Engineering 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

14 2920 1 2<br />

15 2920 2 2<br />

22 2920 4 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

Reccessed Fixture<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2 N/A 94 0% 0.47 4117 $457.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.66 5,764.1 $639.81 7 2 N/A 94 0% 0.66 5764 $639.81 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 1.60 13,998.5 $1,553.83 17 2 N/A 94 0% 1.60 13998 $1,553.83 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

188 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 4 2<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

73 0.07 213.2 $23.66 1 0<br />

57 0.11 332.9 $36.95 2 0<br />

50 0.20 584.0 $64.82 4 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

94 20% 0.30 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

73 20% 0.06 171 $18.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 42.632 $4.73 33.81<br />

57 20% 0.09 266 $29.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 66.576 $7.39 21.65<br />

50 20% 0.16 467 $51.86 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 116.8 $12.96 12.34<br />

3<br />

Corridor C 1st Flr<br />

8760 3 2<br />

West<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 2,470.3 $274.21 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 494.064 $54.84 2.92


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 2<br />

West<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

10 20% 0.01 70 $7.78 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 17.52 $1.94 82.27<br />

3<br />

Storage B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $109.68 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $27.42 5.84<br />

3 8760 14 2<br />

Corridor D 1st Flr<br />

44 West 8760 2 0<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

94 1.32 11,528.2 $1,279.63 14 2 N/A 94 0% 1.32 11528 $1,279.63 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.00 35.0 $3.89 2 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 35 $3.89 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage C 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $109.68 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $27.42 5.84<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Storage D 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

Storage E 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 1 4<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.19 411.7 $45.70 1 2<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $91.40 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

188 20% 0.30 659 $73.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $18.28 8.75<br />

3 2190 34 2<br />

Storage F 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

1 2190 1 4<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 3.20 6,999.2 $776.92 34 2<br />

188 0.19 411.7 $45.70 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 2.56 5599 $621.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.64 1399.848 $155.38 1.03<br />

188 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Storage G 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 17 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.60 3,499.6 $388.46 17 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 1.28 2800 $310.77 $160.00 $160.00 0.32 699.924 $77.69 2.06<br />

1<br />

Housekeeping 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 10 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.88 5,489.6 $609.35 10 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 1.50 4392 $487.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.38 1097.92 $121.87 1.31<br />

3<br />

Storage H 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 27 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 2.54 5,558.2 $616.96 27 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 2.03 4447 $493.57 $160.00 $160.00 0.51 1111.644 $123.39 1.30<br />

3 8760 10 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $914.02 10 2 N/A 94 0% 0.94 8234 $914.02 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Corridor E 1st Flr<br />

43 West 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 18 $1.94 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage I 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $109.68 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $27.42 5.84<br />

3<br />

Storage J 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 617.6 $68.55 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 494 $54.84 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 123.516 $13.71 11.67<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

2 8760 11 2 Recessed Prismatic 94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,005.42 11 2 N/A 94 0% 1.03 9058 $1,005.42 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Corridor F 1st Flr<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

West<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $19.45 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage K 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

11 Stairs C West 8760 8 2<br />

11 8760 11 2<br />

Stairs D West<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2 N/A 94 0% 0.75 6588 $731.21 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,005.42 11 2 N/A 94 0% 1.03 9058 $1,005.42 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $19.45 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

31 8760 20 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Pendant High<br />

Bay Metal Halide Fixture<br />

455 9.10 79,716.0 $8,848.48 20 0 N/A 455 0% 9.10 79716 $8,848.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

33<br />

Garage A 1st Flr<br />

8760 16 1<br />

West<br />

39 8760 3 1<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

295 4.72 41,347.2 $4,589.54 16 0 N/A 295 0% 4.72 41347 $4,589.54 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.38 3,285.0 $364.64 3 0 N/A 125 0% 0.38 3285 $364.64 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $19.45 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 3<br />

41<br />

Outside Race St<br />

West<br />

8760 36 1<br />

19 1460 288 1<br />

Lecture Hall 1st Flr<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

West<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down Light<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

300 10.80 94,608.0 $10,501.49 36 0 N/A 300 0% 10.80 94608 $10,501.49 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 25.92 37,843.2 $4,200.60 288 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 20.74 30275 $3,360.48 $160.00 $160.00 5.18 7568.64 $840.12 0.19<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

34 1460 10 1<br />

Lecture Hall Lobby<br />

19 1460 4 1<br />

1st Flr West<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

213 2.13 3,109.8 $345.19 10 0<br />

90 0.36 525.6 $58.34 4 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

213 20% 1.70 2488 $276.15 $160.00 $160.00 0.43 621.96 $69.04 2.32<br />

90 20% 0.29 420 $46.67 $160.00 $160.00 0.07 105.12 $11.67 13.71<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2<br />

Corridor G 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 30 2<br />

19 1460 48 1<br />

Meeting Rm 113C<br />

1 1460 32 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 2.82 24,703.2 $2,742.06 30 2 N/A 94 0% 2.82 24703 $2,742.06 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 4.32 6,307.2 $700.10 48 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.46 5046 $560.08 $160.00 $160.00 0.86 1261.44 $140.02 1.14<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 48 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 113B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.32 6,307.2 $700.10 48 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.46 5046 $560.08 $160.00 $160.00 0.86 1261.44 $140.02 1.14<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 4 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 N/A 10 0% 0.04 117 $12.96 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 48 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 113A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.32 6,307.2 $700.10 48 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.46 5046 $560.08 $160.00 $160.00 0.86 1261.44 $140.02 1.14<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

Restroom R6 1st Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

West<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $40.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $10.24 15.62<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R6 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 112B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 9 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.15 1682 $186.69 $160.00 $160.00 0.29 420.48 $46.67 3.43<br />

188 20% 1.35 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.34 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 112A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 9 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.15 1682 $186.69 $160.00 $160.00 0.29 420.48 $46.67 3.43<br />

188 20% 1.35 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.34 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

Restroom R5 1st Flr<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

West<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $40.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $10.24 15.62<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 4<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 111A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.30 1892 $210.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.32 473.04 $52.51 3.05<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 111B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 26 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

188 4.89 7,136.5 $792.15 26 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.89 5676 $630.09 $160.00 $160.00 0.97 1419.12 $157.52 1.02<br />

188 20% 3.91 5709 $633.72 $160.00 $160.00 0.98 1427.296 $158.43 1.01<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 110B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.01 1472 $163.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.25 367.92 $40.84 3.92<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 110A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.01 1472 $163.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.25 367.92 $40.84 3.92<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 109A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.30 1892 $210.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.32 473.04 $52.51 3.05<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 109B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 26 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

188 4.89 7,136.5 $792.15 26 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.89 5676 $630.09 $160.00 $160.00 0.97 1419.12 $157.52 1.02<br />

188 20% 3.91 5709 $633.72 $160.00 $160.00 0.98 1427.296 $158.43 1.01<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $73.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $18.28 8.75<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R1 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $12.96 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $3.24 49.36<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R1 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $73.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $18.28 8.75<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R2 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $12.96 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $3.24 49.36<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

3<br />

AHU Rm A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,029.3 $114.25 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 823 $91.40 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 205.86 $22.85 7.00<br />

19 8760 102 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

90 9.18 80,416.8 $8,926.26 102 1 N/A 90 0% 9.18 80417 $8,926.26 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 5<br />

34 8760 66 1<br />

20 8760 17 1<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

213 14.06 123,148.1 $13,669.44 66 0 N/A 213 0% 14.06 123148 $13,669.44 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

23 0.39 3,425.2 $380.19 17 0 N/A 23 0% 0.39 3425 $380.19 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

22 Main Corridor A 1st 8760 12 1<br />

50 0.60 5,256.0 $583.42 12 1 N/A 50 0% 0.60 5256 $583.42 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

Flr West<br />

43 8760 10 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.10 876.0 $97.24 10 0 N/A 10 0% 0.10 876 $97.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

48 8760 4 4<br />

26 8760 1 1<br />

26W, 4 Lamp, Pendant<br />

Compact Flourescent<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

112 0.45 3,924.5 $435.62 4 0 N/A 112 0% 0.45 3924 $435.62 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.03 245.3 $27.23 1 0 N/A 28 0% 0.03 245 $27.23 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet A 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet A 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

2<br />

Storage L 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

1 2920 87 4<br />

Main Kitchen 1st Flr<br />

11 2920 8 2<br />

West<br />

12 2920 3 3<br />

1<br />

Main kitchen A 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

188 16.36 47,759.5 $5,301.31 87 2<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

75 0.23 657.0 $72.93 3 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

188 20% 13.08 38208 $4,241.05 $160.00 $160.00 3.27 9551.904 $1,060.26 0.15<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

75 20% 0.18 526 $58.34 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 131.4 $14.59 10.97<br />

188 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

3<br />

Main Kitchen B 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

1<br />

2<br />

2<br />

2<br />

Main Kitchen C 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen D 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen E 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen F 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2920 2 2<br />

2920 3 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $24.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $6.09 26.26<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $73.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $18.28 8.75<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

2920 7 2<br />

Main Kitchen G 1st<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,921.4 $213.27 7 2<br />

Flr West<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0<br />

1<br />

Main Kitchen H 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 6 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.53 1537 $170.62 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 384.272 $42.65 3.75<br />

10 20% 0.01 23 $2.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 5.84 $0.65 246.82<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

3<br />

Main Kitchen I 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Main Kitchen J 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen K 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen L 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen M 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

188 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

188 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 6<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Main Kitchen N 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

Main Kitchen O 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2920 1 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.19 549.0 $60.93 1 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet B 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet B 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

1<br />

Storage M 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 8 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 3,293.8 $365.61 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 1.20 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet D 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet D 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

2190 12 2<br />

Sub Station Rm 1st<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.13 2,470.3 $274.21 12 2<br />

Flr West<br />

43 2190 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 43.8 $4.86 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.90 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

10 20% 0.02 35 $3.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 8.76 $0.97 164.55<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet C 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet C 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

2<br />

Corridor H 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 8 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2 N/A 94 0% 0.75 6588 $731.21 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

2190 99 2<br />

Main Storage 1st Flr<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 9.31 20,380.1 $2,262.20 99 2<br />

West<br />

43 2190 4 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.04 87.6 $9.72 4 0<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

2190 9 2<br />

AHU Rm B 1st Flr<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 1,852.7 $205.65 9 2<br />

West<br />

43 2190 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 43.8 $4.86 2 0<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

2190 8 2<br />

AHU Rm C 1st Flr<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

West<br />

43 2190 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 43.8 $4.86 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 7.44 16304 $1,809.76 $160.00 $160.00 1.86 4076.028 $452.44 0.35<br />

10 20% 0.03 70 $7.78 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 17.52 $1.94 82.27<br />

94 20% 0.68 1482 $164.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 370.548 $41.13 3.89<br />

10 20% 0.02 35 $3.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 8.76 $0.97 164.55<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

10 20% 0.02 35 $3.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 8.76 $0.97 164.55<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet E2 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet E2 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet E1 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet E1 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

2<br />

Corridor I 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

8760 8 2<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

Meeting Rm 108A<br />

1 1460 24 4<br />

1st flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2 N/A 94 0% 0.75 6588 $731.21 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.89 5676 $630.09 $160.00 $160.00 0.97 1419.12 $157.52 1.02<br />

188 20% 3.61 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.89 5676 $630.09 $160.00 $160.00 0.97 1419.12 $157.52 1.02


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 7<br />

Meeting Rm 108B<br />

1 1460 24 4<br />

1st flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 3.61 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 8 2<br />

Stairs E West<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $731.21 8 2 N/A 94 0% 0.75 6588 $731.21 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $19.45 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 11 2<br />

Stairs F West<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,005.42 11 2 N/A 94 0% 1.03 9058 $1,005.42 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $19.45 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 8760 20 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic 94 1.88 16,468.8 $1,828.04 20 2 N/A 94 0% 1.88 16469 $1,828.04 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

Corridor J 1st Flr<br />

43 West 8760 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 262.8 $29.17 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 263 $29.17 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 18 $1.94 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

2 8760 30 2 Recessed Prismatic 94 2.82 24,703.2 $2,742.06 30 2 N/A 94 0% 2.82 24703 $2,742.06 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Corridor K 1st Flr<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

West<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $9.72 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Storage N 1st flr<br />

West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Storage L 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Control Rm 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

2 2920 6 2<br />

Locker Rm B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

11 2920 2 2<br />

2 2920 8 2<br />

Locker Rm A 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

11 2920 2 2<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

Meeting Rm 102B<br />

1 1460 8 4<br />

1st Flr West<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,646.9 $182.80 6 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

90 20% 1.01 1472 $163.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.25 367.92 $40.84 3.92<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 26 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 102A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 16 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 2.34 3,416.4 $379.22 26 1<br />

188 3.01 4,391.7 $487.48 16 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.87 2733 $303.38 $160.00 $160.00 0.47 683.28 $75.84 2.11<br />

188 20% 2.41 3513 $389.98 $160.00 $160.00 0.60 878.336 $97.50 1.64<br />

43 2920 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 12 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 101C<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 4 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.08 1,576.8 $175.02 12 1<br />

188 0.75 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.86 1261 $140.02 $160.00 $160.00 0.22 315.36 $35.00 4.57<br />

188 20% 0.60 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 12 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 101B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 4 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.08 1,576.8 $175.02 12 1<br />

188 0.75 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.86 1261 $140.02 $160.00 $160.00 0.22 315.36 $35.00 4.57<br />

188 20% 0.60 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 219.584 $24.37 6.56


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 8<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 12 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 101A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 4 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.08 1,576.8 $175.02 12 1<br />

188 0.75 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.86 1261 $140.02 $160.00 $160.00 0.22 315.36 $35.00 4.57<br />

188 20% 0.60 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 50 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 103C<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.50 6,570.0 $729.27 50 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.60 5256 $583.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1314 $145.85 1.10<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 52 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 103B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.68 6,832.8 $758.44 52 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.74 5466 $606.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.94 1366.56 $151.69 1.05<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 4 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 N/A 10 0% 0.04 117 $12.96 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 50 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 103A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.50 6,570.0 $729.27 50 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.60 5256 $583.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1314 $145.85 1.10<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 104B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 9 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.15 1682 $186.69 $160.00 $160.00 0.29 420.48 $46.67 3.43<br />

188 20% 1.35 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.34 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 16 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 104A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 9 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.44 2,102.4 $233.37 16 1<br />

188 1.69 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.15 1682 $186.69 $160.00 $160.00 0.29 420.48 $46.67 3.43<br />

188 20% 1.35 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.34 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

Restroom R8 1st Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

West<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $40.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $10.24 15.62<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R8 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

Restroom R7 1st Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

West<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $51.21 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $40.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $10.24 15.62<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R7 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 105B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 24 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.89 5676 $630.09 $160.00 $160.00 0.97 1419.12 $157.52 1.02<br />

188 20% 3.61 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 9<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 105A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.30 1892 $210.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.32 473.04 $52.51 3.05<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 106B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.01 1472 $163.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.25 367.92 $40.84 3.92<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 14 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 106A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.26 1,839.6 $204.20 14 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.01 1472 $163.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.25 367.92 $40.84 3.92<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 54 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 107B<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 24 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.86 7,095.6 $787.61 54 1<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.89 5676 $630.09 $160.00 $160.00 0.97 1419.12 $157.52 1.02<br />

188 20% 3.61 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 18 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm 107A<br />

1st Flr West<br />

1460 8 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.62 2,365.2 $262.54 18 1<br />

188 1.50 2,195.8 $243.74 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.30 1892 $210.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.32 473.04 $52.51 3.05<br />

188 20% 1.20 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $73.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $18.28 8.75<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R4 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $12.96 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $3.24 49.36<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

3<br />

Jan Closet R4 1st<br />

Flr West<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $73.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $18.28 8.75<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R3 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $16.21 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $12.96 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $3.24 49.36<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

19 8760 132 1<br />

34 8760 75 1<br />

22 8760 30 1<br />

Main Corridor B 1st<br />

20 Flr West 8760 6 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

90 11.88 104,068.8 $11,551.64 132 1 N/A 90 0% 11.88 104069 $11,551.64 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 15.98 139,941.0 $15,533.45 75 0 N/A 213 0% 15.98 139941 $15,533.45 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 1.50 13,140.0 $1,458.54 30 1 N/A 50 0% 1.50 13140 $1,458.54 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

23 0.14 1,208.9 $134.19 6 0 N/A 23 0% 0.14 1209 $134.19 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

48 8760 4 4<br />

26W, 4 Lamp, Pendant<br />

Compact Flourescent<br />

Fixture<br />

112 0.45 3,924.5 $435.62 4 0 N/A 112 0% 0.45 3924 $435.62 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 10<br />

43 8760 4 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.04 350.4 $38.89 4 0 N/A 10 0% 0.04 350 $38.89 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 10 2<br />

Stairs G West<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $914.02 10 2 N/A 94 0% 0.94 8234 $914.02 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $19.45 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $19.45 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

27 8760 12 2<br />

Vestibule A 1st Flr<br />

26 West 8760 6 1<br />

35 8760 6 1<br />

46 8760 40 0<br />

19 8760 39 1<br />

33<br />

Main Corridor C<br />

8760 28 1<br />

West<br />

34 8760 21 1<br />

26W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal Halide<br />

and 26W 1 lamp, CFL<br />

Decorative Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

54 0.65 5,676.5 $630.09 12 0 N/A 54 0% 0.65 5676 $630.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.17 1,471.7 $163.36 6 0 N/A 28 0% 0.17 1472 $163.36 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $548.41 6 0 N/A 94 0% 0.56 4941 $548.41 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

278 11.12 97,411.2 $10,812.64 40 0 N/A 278 0% 11.12 97411 $10,812.64 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 3.51 30,747.6 $3,412.98 39 1 N/A 90 0% 3.51 30748 $3,412.98 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 8.26 72,357.6 $8,031.69 28 0 N/A 295 0% 8.26 72358 $8,031.69 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 4.47 39,183.5 $4,349.37 21 0 N/A 213 0% 4.47 39183 $4,349.37 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 8 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.08 700.8 $77.79 8 0 N/A 10 0% 0.08 701 $77.79 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

20 8760 7 1<br />

34<br />

34<br />

46<br />

Vestibule B 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

Vestibule C 1st Flr<br />

West<br />

Outside Arch St<br />

West<br />

8760 9 1<br />

8760 5 1<br />

8760 18 0<br />

33 8760 132 1<br />

32 8760 80 1<br />

12th Street Tunnel<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal Halide<br />

and 26W 1 lamp, CFL<br />

Decorative Fixture<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Downlight<br />

Can Metal Halide Fixture<br />

23 0.16 1,410.4 $156.55 7 0 N/A 23 0% 0.16 1410 $156.55 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 1.92 16,792.9 $1,864.01 9 0 N/A 213 0% 1.92 16793 $1,864.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 1.07 9,329.4 $1,035.56 5 0 N/A 213 0% 1.07 9329 $1,035.56 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

278 5.00 43,835.0 $4,865.69 18 0 N/A 278 0% 5.00 43835 $4,865.69 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 38.94 341,114.4 $37,863.70 132 0 N/A 295 0% 38.94 341114 $37,863.70 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

455 36.40 318,864.0 $35,393.90 80 0 N/A 455 0% 36.40 318864 $35,393.90 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

38 8760 66 1<br />

400W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted (12th St.) Fixture<br />

455 30.03 263,062.8 $29,199.97 66 0 N/A 455 0% 30.03 263063 $29,199.97 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 3612 511 512.92 2,621,922.0 $291,033.34 3612 314 459.06 2522891 $280,040.85 $27,680.00 53.86 99031.5 $10,992.50 2.52<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 11<br />

CEG Job #:<br />

1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> "PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> 1st Flr East"<br />

KWH COST: $0.202<br />

Address:<br />

12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Lighting Controls<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Lighting Controls Watts Savings Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used (%) kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

3<br />

Gas Meter Rm 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

3<br />

Main Phone Frame<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3<br />

Compressor Rm 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

3<br />

Machine Rm A 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3 8760 32 2<br />

2<br />

Corridor A 1st Flr<br />

8760 3 2<br />

East<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

94 3.01 26,350.1 $5,322.72 32 2 N/A 94 0% 3.01 26350 $5,322.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.28 2,470.3 $499.00 3 2 N/A 94 0% 0.28 2470 $499.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $442.38 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 2190 $442.38 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $17.70 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 88 $17.70 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 8760 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 5,764.1 $1,164.34 7 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.53 4611 $931.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 1152.816 $232.87 0.69<br />

Back Hallway 2 1st<br />

39<br />

Flr East<br />

8760 2 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $442.38 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

125 20% 0.20 1752 $353.90 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 438 $88.48 1.81<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

2190 24 2<br />

94 2.26 4,940.6 $998.01 24 2<br />

Hall D Storage 11st<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 1.80 3953 $798.41 $160.00 $160.00 0.45 988.128 $199.60 0.80<br />

Flr East<br />

43 2190 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 21.9 $4.42 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 22 $4.42 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted 94 0.28 2,470.3 $499.00 3 2 N/A 94 0% 0.28 2470 $499.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Stairs A East<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $17.70 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 88 $17.70 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

2190 6 2<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $249.50 6 2<br />

Hall D Fire Pump<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $199.60 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $49.90 3.21<br />

Room 1st Flr East<br />

43 2190 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 21.9 $4.42 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 22 $4.42 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

2190 15 2<br />

94 1.41 3,087.9 $623.76 15 2<br />

Hall D Electric<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 1.13 2470 $499.00 $160.00 $160.00 0.28 617.58 $124.75 1.28<br />

Room 1st Flr East<br />

43 2190 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 43.8 $8.85 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 44 $8.85 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

14 2920 18 2<br />

2<br />

Hall D Office 1st Flr<br />

2920<br />

East<br />

1 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

73 1.31 3,836.9 $775.05 18 0<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

73 20% 1.05 3070 $620.04 $160.00 $160.00 0.26 767.376 $155.01 1.03<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $11.80 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $11.80 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 12<br />

3 2920 1 2<br />

Retail 6 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $5.90 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $5.90 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 2920 1 2<br />

Retail 7 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $5.90 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $5.90 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

2 8760 7 2 Recessed Prismatic 94 0.66 5,764.1 $1,164.34 7 2<br />

94 20% 0.53 4611 $931.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 1152.816 $232.87 0.69<br />

Back Hallway 3 1st<br />

Sensor<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

Flr East<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

31 8760 19 1<br />

Garage B 1st Flr<br />

33 East 8760 23 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Pendant High<br />

Bay Metal Halide Fixture<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

455 8.65 75,730.2 $15,297.50 19 0 N/A 455 0% 8.65 75730 $15,297.50 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 6.79 59,436.6 $12,006.19 23 0 N/A 295 0% 6.79 59437 $12,006.19 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $17.70 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 88 $17.70 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Garage B Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

8760 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $998.01 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 3953 $798.41 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 988.128 $199.60 0.80<br />

11 8760 11 2<br />

Stairs B East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.03 9,057.8 $1,829.68 11 2 N/A 94 0% 1.03 9058 $1,829.68 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 9 2<br />

Stairs C East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 7,411.0 $1,497.01 9 2 N/A 94 0% 0.85 7411 $1,497.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet F 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet F 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

2 8760 23 2 Recessed Prismatic 94 2.16 18,939.1 $3,825.70 23 2<br />

94 20% 1.73 15151 $3,060.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.43 3787.824 $765.14 0.21<br />

Back Hallway 1 1st<br />

Sensor<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

Flr East<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R15 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $16.52 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $13.21 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $3.30 48.44<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R16<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R16 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $16.52 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $13.21 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $3.30 48.44<br />

3<br />

Room 126 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $110.89 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $88.71 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $22.18 7.21<br />

26<br />

Concession Storage<br />

A 1st Flr<br />

2190 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 122.6 $24.77 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 98 $19.82 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 24.528 $4.95 32.29


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 13<br />

26 2920 10 1<br />

Concession A 127<br />

1st Flr East<br />

12 2920 3 3<br />

1<br />

Storage A 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 3 4<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

Room 128 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

28 0.28 817.6 $165.16 10 0<br />

75 0.23 657.0 $132.71 3 2<br />

188 0.56 1,235.2 $249.50 3 2<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $332.67 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.22 654 $132.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 163.52 $33.03 4.84<br />

75 20% 0.18 526 $106.17 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 131.4 $26.54 6.03<br />

188 20% 0.45 988 $199.60 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $49.90 3.21<br />

188 20% 0.45 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R17 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $16.52 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $13.21 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $3.30 48.44<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R18<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R18 1st<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $16.52 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $13.21 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $3.30 48.44<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet G 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet G 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

11 8760 8 2<br />

Stairs D East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $1,330.68 8 2 N/A 94 0% 0.75 6588 $1,330.68 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 8 2<br />

Stairs E East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 6,587.5 $1,330.68 8 2 N/A 94 0% 0.75 6588 $1,330.68 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

2 8760 14 2 Recessed Prismatic 94 1.32 11,528.2 $2,328.69 14 2<br />

94 20% 1.05 9223 $1,862.95 $160.00 $160.00 0.26 2305.632 $465.74 0.34<br />

Back Hallway 4 1st<br />

Sensor<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

Flr East<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

31 4380 285 1<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Pendant High<br />

Bay Metal Halide Fixture<br />

455 129.68 567,976.5 $114,731.25 285 0 N/A 455 0% 129.68 567977 $114,731.25 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

35 4380 47 1<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

94 4.42 19,350.8 $3,908.87 47 0 N/A 94 0% 4.42 19351 $3,908.87 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 4380 11 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.11 481.8 $97.32 11 0 N/A 10 0% 0.11 482 $97.32 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Exhibit Hall D 1st<br />

19 Flr East<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

4380 10 1<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

90 0.90 3,942.0 $796.28 10 1 N/A 90 0% 0.90 3942 $796.28 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 4380 5 2<br />

26 4380 1 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.47 2,058.6 $415.84 5 2 N/A 94 0% 0.47 2059 $415.84 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.03 122.6 $24.77 1 0 N/A 28 0% 0.03 123 $24.77 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 Hvac 1 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 14<br />

3 Hvac 2 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3 Hvac 3 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3 Hvac 4 1st Flr East 2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3 Hvac 5 1st Flr East 2190 16 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.50 3,293.8 $665.34 16 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 1.20 2635 $532.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 658.752 $133.07 1.20<br />

1 Retail 1 1st Flr East 2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

1 Retail 2 1st Flr East 2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

1 Retail 3 1st Flr East 2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

1 Retail 4 1st Flr East 2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

1 Retail 5 1st Flr East 2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

1<br />

Room 114 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

3<br />

Main Water Room<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

1<br />

2<br />

1<br />

Room 117 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Corridor B 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Room 115 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 3 4<br />

8760 6 2<br />

2920 3 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $332.67 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.45 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $998.01 6 2 N/A 94 0% 0.56 4941 $998.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $332.67 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.45 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3<br />

Room 115 Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

1<br />

Room 116 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 3 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $332.67 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.45 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3<br />

Room 116 Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

11 8760 10 2<br />

Stair F 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $1,663.35 10 2 N/A 94 0% 0.94 8234 $1,663.35 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2<br />

1<br />

Storage Room 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

Room 118 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 3 2<br />

2920 4 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 617.6 $124.75 3 2<br />

188 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 494 $99.80 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 123.516 $24.95 6.41<br />

188 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

3<br />

Machine Room B<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $166.33 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $186.39 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.25 738 $149.11 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 184.544 $37.28 4.29<br />

Restroom R9 1st Flr<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $166.33 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 15<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R9/R10 1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $186.39 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.25 738 $149.11 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 184.544 $37.28 4.29<br />

Restroom R10 1st<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $166.33 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet H 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet H 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Storage C 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

11 8760 14 2<br />

Stair G 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.32 11,528.2 $2,328.69 14 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 1.05 9223 $1,862.95 $160.00 $160.00 0.26 2305.632 $465.74 0.34<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

11 8760 9 2<br />

Stair H 1st Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 7,411.0 $1,497.01 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 5929 $1,197.61 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 1482.192 $299.40 0.53<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet I 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet I 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $186.39 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.25 738 $149.11 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 184.544 $37.28 4.29<br />

Restroom R11 1st<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $166.33 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R11/R12 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

6 2920 4 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $186.39 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.25 738 $149.11 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 184.544 $37.28 4.29<br />

Restroom R12 1st<br />

5 2920 3 2<br />

Flr East<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $166.33 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

5 2920 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,921.4 $388.11 7 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.53 1537 $310.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 384.272 $77.62 2.06<br />

Restroom R13 1st<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $16.52 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $13.21 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $3.30 48.44<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R13<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,921.4 $388.11 7 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.53 1537 $310.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 384.272 $77.62 2.06


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 16<br />

Restroom R14 1st<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr East<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

18<br />

18<br />

18<br />

Room 125 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Room 119 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

Room 119 Storage<br />

1st Flr East<br />

2920 2 3<br />

2920 8 3<br />

2190 7 3<br />

26 8760 5 1<br />

Corridor C 1st Flr<br />

18 East 8760 2 3<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $16.52 1 0<br />

115 0.23 671.6 $135.66 2 0<br />

115 0.92 2,686.4 $542.65 8 0<br />

115 0.81 1,763.0 $356.12 7 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $13.21 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $3.30 48.44<br />

115 20% 0.18 537 $108.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 134.32 $27.13 5.90<br />

115 20% 0.74 2149 $434.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 537.28 $108.53 1.47<br />

115 20% 0.64 1410 $284.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.16 352.59 $71.22 2.25<br />

28 0.14 1,226.4 $247.73 5 0 N/A 28 0% 0.14 1226 $247.73 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

115 0.23 2,014.8 $406.99 2 0 N/A 115 0% 0.23 2015 $406.99 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 Restroom R5 1st Flr 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

26<br />

Room 124 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

2920 16 1<br />

12<br />

Room 120 1st Flr<br />

2920 4 3<br />

East<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18 2920 16 3<br />

Room 123 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

26 2920 8 1<br />

26 8760 6 1<br />

Corridor D 1st Flr<br />

3 East 8760 1 2<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

28 0.45 1,308.2 $264.25 16 0<br />

75 0.30 876.0 $176.95 4 2<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 1.84 5,372.8 $1,085.31 16 0<br />

28 0.22 654.1 $132.12 8 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.36 1047 $211.40 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 261.632 $52.85 3.03<br />

75 20% 0.24 701 $141.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 175.2 $35.39 4.52<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 1.47 4298 $868.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.37 1074.56 $217.06 0.74<br />

28 20% 0.18 523 $105.70 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 130.816 $26.42 6.05<br />

28 0.17 1,471.7 $297.28 6 0 N/A 28 0% 0.17 1472 $297.28 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 823.4 $166.33 1 2 N/A 94 0% 0.09 823 $166.33 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

18<br />

Room 121/122 1st<br />

Flr East<br />

2920 4 3<br />

11 8760 4 2<br />

Stair I East<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $665.34 4 2 N/A 94 0% 0.38 3294 $665.34 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 87.6 $17.70 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 88 $17.70 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 2190 4 2<br />

Mechanical Room<br />

1st Flr East<br />

13 2190 2 2<br />

34<br />

Vestibule A 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

8760 9 1<br />

33 8760 42 1<br />

46 8760 32 0<br />

34 8760 20 1<br />

22 8760 12 1<br />

35 8760 10 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal Halide<br />

and 26W 1 lamp, CFL<br />

Decorative Fixture<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $166.33 4 2<br />

50 0.10 219.0 $44.24 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

50 20% 0.08 175 $35.39 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 43.8 $8.85 18.08<br />

213 1.92 16,792.9 $3,392.17 9 0 N/A 213 0% 1.92 16793 $3,392.17 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 12.39 108,536.4 $21,924.35 42 0 N/A 295 0% 12.39 108536 $21,924.35 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

278 8.90 77,929.0 $15,741.65 32 0 N/A 278 0% 8.90 77929 $15,741.65 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 4.26 37,317.6 $7,538.16 20 0 N/A 213 0% 4.26 37318 $7,538.16 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.60 5,256.0 $1,061.71 12 1 N/A 50 0% 0.60 5256 $1,061.71 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.94 8,234.4 $1,663.35 10 0 N/A 94 0% 0.94 8234 $1,663.35 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 17<br />

26 8760<br />

Main Corridor A 1st<br />

9 1<br />

Flr East<br />

49 8760 8 1<br />

21 8760 8 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

50W, 1 Lamp, Direct<br />

Incendescent Track Mounted<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.25 2,207.5 $445.92 9 0 N/A 28 0% 0.25 2208 $445.92 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.40 3,504.0 $707.81 8 1 N/A 50 0% 0.40 3504 $707.81 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard Bulb<br />

100 0.80 7,008.0 $1,415.62 8 1 N/A 100 0% 0.80 7008 $1,415.62 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 5 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.05 438.0 $88.48 5 0 N/A 10 0% 0.05 438 $88.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 8760 2 1<br />

20 8760 2 1<br />

34<br />

Vestibule B 1st Flr<br />

East<br />

8760 5 1<br />

27 8760 12 2<br />

Vestibule C 1st Flr<br />

35 8760 6 1<br />

East<br />

26 8760 6 1<br />

41 Outside Race St East 8760 56 1<br />

33 8760 36 1<br />

Outside Arch St<br />

Tunnel East<br />

38 8760 6 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

26W, 2 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down Light<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

???W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted (12th St.) Fixture<br />

90 0.18 1,576.8 $318.51 2 1 N/A 90 0% 0.18 1577 $318.51 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

23 0.05 403.0 $81.40 2 0 N/A 23 0% 0.05 403 $81.40 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 1.07 9,329.4 $1,884.54 5 0 N/A 213 0% 1.07 9329 $1,884.54 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

54 0.65 5,676.5 $1,146.65 12 0 N/A 54 0% 0.65 5676 $1,146.65 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.56 4,940.6 $998.01 6 0 N/A 94 0% 0.56 4941 $998.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.17 1,471.7 $297.28 6 0 N/A 28 0% 0.17 1472 $297.28 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

300 16.80 147,168.0 $29,727.94 56 0 N/A 300 0% 16.80 147168 $29,727.94 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 10.62 93,031.2 $18,792.30 36 0 N/A 295 0% 10.62 93031 $18,792.30 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

455 2.73 23,914.8 $4,830.79 6 0 N/A 455 0% 2.73 23915 $4,830.79 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

46 Outside Arch St East 8760 16 0<br />

46 Outside 11th St East 8760 10 0<br />

19<br />

18<br />

19<br />

Conf. Rm 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Conf. Rm Clos.1 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

Conf. Rm Clos.2 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 28 1<br />

2920 3 3<br />

2920 1 1<br />

26 2920 19 1<br />

Open Office Area 1<br />

16 1st Flr East Mezz. 2920 1 2<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal Halide<br />

and 26W 1 lamp, CFL<br />

Decorative Fixture<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal Halide<br />

and 26W 1 lamp, CFL<br />

Decorative Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

32W, 2 Lamp, Parabolic U-<br />

Tube T-12 Fixture<br />

278 4.45 38,964.5 $7,870.82 16 0 N/A 278 0% 4.45 38964 $7,870.82 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

278 2.78 24,352.8 $4,919.27 10 0 N/A 278 0% 2.78 24353 $4,919.27 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 2.52 7,358.4 $1,486.40 28 1<br />

115 0.35 1,007.4 $203.49 3 0<br />

90 0.09 262.8 $53.09 1 1<br />

28 0.53 1,553.4 $313.79 19 0<br />

60 0.06 175.2 $35.39 1 0<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $5.90 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 2.02 5887 $1,189.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.50 1471.68 $297.28 0.54<br />

115 20% 0.28 806 $162.80 $160.00 $160.00 0.07 201.48 $40.70 3.93<br />

90 20% 0.07 210 $42.47 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 52.56 $10.62 15.07<br />

28 20% 0.43 1243 $251.04 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 310.688 $62.76 2.55<br />

60 20% 0.05 140 $28.31 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 35.04 $7.08 22.61<br />

10 20% 0.01 23 $4.72 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 5.84 $1.18 135.63<br />

3<br />

IT Closet 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet1 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $93.19 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $74.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $18.64 8.58<br />

Restroom1 1st Flr<br />

5 2920 1 2<br />

East Mezz.<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

14<br />

14<br />

Office1-SJ 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Office2 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

2920 2 2<br />

2920 4 2<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

32W, 2 lamp, T-8<br />

U-Tube Fixture<br />

73 0.15 426.3 $86.12 2 0<br />

73 0.29 852.6 $172.23 4 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

73 20% 0.12 341 $68.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 85.264 $17.22 9.29<br />

73 20% 0.23 682 $137.79 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 170.528 $34.45 4.64


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 18<br />

18<br />

Copy Room 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

19 2920 34 1<br />

41 Large Conf Rm 1st 2920 4 1<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

17<br />

Open Office Area 2<br />

1st Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 9 2<br />

18<br />

Office3-BR 1st Flr<br />

2920 4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18<br />

Office4-JR 1st Flr<br />

2920 6 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 3 1<br />

18 2920<br />

Office5-MA 1st Flr<br />

6 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 3 1<br />

18<br />

Office6-AY 1st Flr<br />

2920 6 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 3 1<br />

18 2920 56 3<br />

Open Office Area 3<br />

1st Flr East Mezz.<br />

26 2920 48 1<br />

18<br />

18<br />

18<br />

19<br />

18<br />

18<br />

18<br />

Office7-LJ 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Office8-JRice 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

Office9 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

Office10-AM 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Office11 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Office12 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Office13 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

2920 4 3<br />

2920 4 3<br />

2920 10 1<br />

2920 6 3<br />

2920 4 3<br />

2920 4 3<br />

18 2920<br />

Office14-SB 1st Flr<br />

4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18<br />

Office15-KM 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

18 2920<br />

Office16-RK 1st Flr<br />

4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down Light<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20W, 2 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Prismatic T-8<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 3.06 8,935.2 $1,804.91 34 1<br />

300 1.20 3,504.0 $707.81 4 0<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

50 0.45 1,314.0 $265.43 9 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $406.99 6 0<br />

90 0.27 788.4 $159.26 3 1<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $406.99 6 0<br />

90 0.27 788.4 $159.26 3 1<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $406.99 6 0<br />

90 0.27 788.4 $159.26 3 1<br />

115 6.44 18,804.8 $3,798.57 56 0<br />

28 1.34 3,924.5 $792.74 48 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $530.86 10 1<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $406.99 6 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 2.45 7148 $1,443.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.61 1787.04 $360.98 0.44<br />

300 20% 0.96 2803 $566.25 $160.00 $160.00 0.24 700.8 $141.56 1.13<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

50 20% 0.36 1051 $212.34 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 262.8 $53.09 3.01<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.55 1612 $325.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.14 402.96 $81.40 1.97<br />

90 20% 0.22 631 $127.41 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 157.68 $31.85 5.02<br />

115 20% 0.55 1612 $325.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.14 402.96 $81.40 1.97<br />

90 20% 0.22 631 $127.41 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 157.68 $31.85 5.02<br />

115 20% 0.55 1612 $325.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.14 402.96 $81.40 1.97<br />

90 20% 0.22 631 $127.41 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 157.68 $31.85 5.02<br />

115 20% 5.15 15044 $3,038.86 $160.00 $160.00 1.29 3760.96 $759.71 0.21<br />

28 20% 1.08 3140 $634.20 $160.00 $160.00 0.27 784.896 $158.55 1.01<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $424.68 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $106.17 1.51<br />

115 20% 0.55 1612 $325.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.14 402.96 $81.40 1.97<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 19<br />

18<br />

Office17-GB 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 6 3<br />

18 2920<br />

Office18-CM 1st Flr<br />

4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18 2920<br />

Office19-TN 1st Flr<br />

4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18<br />

Office20-MJ 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

18 2920<br />

Office21-EE 1st Flr<br />

4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18<br />

Office22-KJ 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

18 2920<br />

Office23-CH 1st Flr<br />

4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18<br />

Office24 1st Flr<br />

2920 4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18<br />

Office25 1st Flr<br />

2920 4 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 2 1<br />

18<br />

18<br />

26<br />

Office26-MA 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Office27-JG 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

Closet 1st Flr East<br />

Mezz.<br />

2920 4 3<br />

2920 4 3<br />

2190 1 1<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

115 0.69 2,014.8 $406.99 6 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

90 0.18 525.6 $106.17 2 1<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

115 0.46 1,343.2 $271.33 4 0<br />

28 0.03 61.3 $12.39 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

115 20% 0.55 1612 $325.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.14 402.96 $81.40 1.97<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

90 20% 0.14 420 $84.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 105.12 $21.23 7.54<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

115 20% 0.37 1075 $217.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 268.64 $54.27 2.95<br />

28 20% 0.02 49 $9.91 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 12.264 $2.48 64.59<br />

3<br />

IT Closet2 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Computer Rm 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5<br />

Restroom2 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2920 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $166.33 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet2 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

18 2920<br />

Break Room 1st Flr<br />

8 3<br />

East Mezz.<br />

19 2920 6 1<br />

19 2920 16 1<br />

Conf Rm B 1st Flr<br />

East Mezz.<br />

18 2920 8 3<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

40W, 3 Lamp, Recessed<br />

Fluorescent Bipin Prismatic<br />

T-5 Fixture<br />

115 0.92 2,686.4 $542.65 8 0<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $318.51 6 1<br />

90 1.44 4,204.8 $849.37 16 1<br />

115 0.92 2,686.4 $542.65 8 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

115 20% 0.74 2149 $434.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 537.28 $108.53 1.47<br />

90 20% 0.43 1261 $254.81 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 315.36 $63.70 2.51<br />

90 20% 1.15 3364 $679.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.29 840.96 $169.87 0.94<br />

115 20% 0.74 2149 $434.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 537.28 $108.53 1.47<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

26 8760 4 1 Compact Fluorescent 28 0.11 981.1 $198.19 4 0 N/A 28 0% 0.11 981 $198.19 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Hallway 1st Flr East<br />

Fixture<br />

Mezz.<br />

43 8760 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 262.8 $53.09 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 263 $53.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 20<br />

57<br />

Reception Area 1st<br />

Flr East Mezz.<br />

8760 2 1<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Halogen<br />

Lamp Fixture<br />

250 0.50 4,380.0 $884.76 2 0 N/A 250 0% 0.50 4380 $884.76 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 1739 438 312.30 1708827.07 345183.07 1739 226 296.30 1655209.30 334352.28 $26,880.00 15.99 53617.8 $10,830.79 2.48<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 21<br />

CEG Job #:<br />

1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> "PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> 2nd Flr"<br />

KWH COST: $0.202<br />

Address:<br />

12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Lighting Controls<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Lighting Controls Watts Savings Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used (%) kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

3<br />

Hall C Storage 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 21 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.97 4,323.1 $873.26 21 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 1.58 3458 $698.61 $160.00 $160.00 0.39 864.612 $174.65 0.92<br />

1 Storage A 2nd Flr 2190 8 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.50 3,293.8 $665.34 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 1.20 2635 $532.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 658.752 $133.07 1.20<br />

1 Storage B 2nd Flr 2190 4 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

2 Storage C 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet N 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet N 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3 Storage D 2nd Flr 2190 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,441.0 $291.09 7 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.53 1153 $232.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 288.204 $58.22 2.75<br />

3 Storage E 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

26<br />

12<br />

1<br />

Concession 1 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

Concession 1 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

Concession 1<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

2920 10 1<br />

2920 3 3<br />

2190 2 4<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x2, 20W, 3 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.28 817.6 $165.16 10 0<br />

75 0.23 657.0 $132.71 3 2<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $166.33 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.22 654 $132.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 163.52 $33.03 4.84<br />

75 20% 0.18 526 $106.17 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 131.4 $26.54 6.03<br />

188 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $442.38 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 2190 $442.38 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Corridor A 2nd Flr<br />

43 8730 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 174.6 $35.27 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.27 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

1 Storage F 2nd Flr 2190 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $166.33 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

First Aide C 2nd Flr<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $332.67 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.45 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R27 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R27/28 2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 22<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R28 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

First Aide B 2nd Flr<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

11 Stair A 2nd Flr 8760 3 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $332.67 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.45 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

94 0.28 2,470.3 $499.00 3 2 N/A 94 0% 0.28 2470 $499.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R29 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R29/30 2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R30 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

3 8760 27 2<br />

Corridor B 2nd Flr<br />

39 8760 4 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

94 2.54 22,232.9 $4,491.04 27 2 N/A 94 0% 2.54 22233 $4,491.04 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.50 4,380.0 $884.76 4 0 N/A 125 0% 0.50 4380 $884.76 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 2920 4 2<br />

Office A 2nd Flr<br />

11 2920 2 2<br />

2 Corridor C 2nd Flr 8760 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 4 2<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $110.89 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $88.71 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $22.18 7.21<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $332.67 2 2 N/A 94 0% 0.19 1647 $332.67 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet M 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet M 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

2 Office B 2nd Flr 2920 2 2<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

Corridor D 2nd Flr<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $110.89 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $88.71 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $22.18 7.21<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $442.38 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 2190 $442.38 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 262.8 $53.09 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 263 $53.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3 Storage G 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 23<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet L 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet L 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

2 Office C 2nd Flr 2920 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $110.89 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $88.71 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $22.18 7.21<br />

2 Corridor E 2nd Flr 8760 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $332.67 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3<br />

Trash Compactor<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 10 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.94 2,058.6 $415.84 10 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.75 1647 $332.67 $160.00 $160.00 0.19 411.72 $83.17 1.92<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Concession 2<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

Concession 2 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $166.33 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

3 Storage H 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Concession 3 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

Concession 3<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $166.33 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

188 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

3 Storage I 2nd Flr 2190 3 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 617.6 $124.75 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 494 $99.80 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 123.516 $24.95 6.41<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R31 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R31/32 2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R32 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

1 2920 3 4<br />

First Aide A 2nd Flr<br />

11 2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.56 1,646.9 $332.67 3 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $55.44 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.45 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $44.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $11.09 14.43<br />

3 8760 28 2<br />

Corridor F 2nd Flr<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

94 2.63 23,056.3 $4,657.38 28 2 N/A 94 0% 2.63 23056 $4,657.38 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $442.38 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 2190 $442.38 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 175.2 $35.39 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 175 $35.39 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

Corridor G 2nd Flr<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $442.38 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 2190 $442.38 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 262.8 $53.09 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 263 $53.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 24<br />

1<br />

1<br />

Concession 4<br />

Storage 2nd Flr<br />

Concession 4 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 2 4<br />

2920 2 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.38 823.4 $166.33 2 2<br />

188 0.38 1,097.9 $221.78 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

188 20% 0.30 878 $177.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $44.36 3.61<br />

3 Storage J 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

1 Storage K 2nd Flr 2190 6 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 2,470.3 $499.00 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.90 1976 $399.20 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 494.064 $99.80 1.60<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet Q 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet Q 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3 Storage L 2nd Flr 2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $249.50 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $199.60 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $49.90 3.21<br />

3 2190 53 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 4.98 10,910.6 $2,203.94 53 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 3.99 8728 $1,763.15 $160.00 $160.00 1.00 2182.116 $440.79 0.36<br />

2 2190 6 2<br />

Hall A Storage 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

16 2190 6 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

32W, 2 Lamp, Parabolic U-<br />

Tube T-12 Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $249.50 6 2<br />

60 0.36 788.4 $159.26 6 0<br />

43 2190 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 65.7 $13.27 3 0<br />

45 2190 1 1<br />

41 4380 28 1<br />

58 4380 10 1<br />

Loading Dock 2nd<br />

42 4380 5 1<br />

Flr<br />

39 4380 2 1<br />

25W, 1 lamp, Incandescent<br />

exit sign<br />

250W, 1 Lamp Down Light<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

??W, 1 Lamp, Pole Mounted<br />

Fixture<br />

400W, 1 Lamp Down Light<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $199.60 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $49.90 3.21<br />

60 20% 0.29 631 $127.41 $160.00 $160.00 0.07 157.68 $31.85 5.02<br />

10 20% 0.02 53 $10.62 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 13.14 $2.65 60.28<br />

25 0.03 54.8 $11.06 1 0 N/A 25 0% 0.03 55 $11.06 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

300 8.40 36,792.0 $7,431.98 28 0 N/A 300 0% 8.40 36792 $7,431.98 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

0 0.00 0.0 $0.00 10 0 N/A 0 0% 0.00 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

464 2.32 10,161.6 $2,052.64 5 0 N/A 464 0% 2.32 10162 $2,052.64 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.25 1,095.0 $221.19 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 1095 $221.19 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 4380 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 43.8 $8.85 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 44 $8.85 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Loading Dock<br />

Storage A 2nd Flr<br />

2190 6 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $249.50 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $199.60 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $49.90 3.21<br />

3<br />

Loading Dock<br />

Storage B 2nd Flr<br />

2190 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 823.4 $166.33 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.30 659 $133.07 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 164.688 $33.27 4.81<br />

56 4380 176 1<br />

30 4380 96 1<br />

35 4380 28 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

Incandescent Fixture<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

90 15.84 69,379.2 $14,014.60 176 1 N/A 90 0% 15.84 69379 $14,014.60 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

1085 104.16 456,220.8 $92,156.60 96 0 N/A 1085 0% 104.16 456221 $92,156.60 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 2.63 11,528.2 $2,328.69 28 0 N/A 94 0% 2.63 11528 $2,328.69 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 Exhibit Hall C 2nd 4380 16 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.16 700.8 $141.56 16 0 N/A 10 0% 0.16 701 $141.56 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Flr<br />

19 4380 6 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

90 0.54 2,365.2 $477.77 6 1 N/A 90 0% 0.54 2365 $477.77 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

55 4380 6 1<br />

26 4380 4 1<br />

30 4380 96 1<br />

19 4380 39 1<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

295 1.77 7,752.6 $1,566.03 6 0 N/A 295 0% 1.77 7753 $1,566.03 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.11 490.6 $99.09 4 0 N/A 28 0% 0.11 491 $99.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

1085 104.16 456,220.8 $92,156.60 96 0 N/A 1085 0% 104.16 456221 $92,156.60 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 3.51 15,373.8 $3,105.51 39 1 N/A 90 0% 3.51 15374 $3,105.51 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 25<br />

43 4380 13 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.13 569.4 $115.02 13 0 N/A 10 0% 0.13 569 $115.02 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Ehibit Hall B 2nd<br />

55 Flr 4380 6 1<br />

20 4380 3 1<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

295 1.77 7,752.6 $1,566.03 6 0 N/A 295 0% 1.77 7753 $1,566.03 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

23 0.07 302.2 $61.05 3 0 N/A 23 0% 0.07 302 $61.05 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 4380 4 1<br />

30 4380 144 1<br />

35 4380 28 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

70W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

28 0.11 490.6 $99.09 4 0 N/A 28 0% 0.11 491 $99.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

1085 156.24 684,331.2 $138,234.90 144 0 N/A 1085 0% 156.24 684331 $138,234.90 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 2.63 11,528.2 $2,328.69 28 0 N/A 94 0% 2.63 11528 $2,328.69 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 4380 19 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.19 832.2 $168.10 19 0 N/A 10 0% 0.19 832 $168.10 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Exhibit Hall A 2nd<br />

55 Flr 4380 7 1<br />

250W, 1 Lamp, Pendant<br />

High Bay Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

295 2.07 9,044.7 $1,827.03 7 0 N/A 295 0% 2.07 9045 $1,827.03 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

20 4380 6 1<br />

26 4380 4 1<br />

2 Storage M 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2 Storage N 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23 0.14 604.4 $122.10 6 0 N/A 23 0% 0.14 604 $122.10 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.11 490.6 $99.09 4 0 N/A 28 0% 0.11 491 $99.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R19<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $665.34 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.90 2635 $532.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $133.07 1.20<br />

6 2920 7 2<br />

Restroom R19 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $326.18 7 2<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.44 1292 $260.95 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 322.952 $65.24 2.45<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $665.34 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.90 2635 $532.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $133.07 1.20<br />

6 2920 7 2<br />

Restroom R20 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $326.18 7 2<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.44 1292 $260.95 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 322.952 $65.24 2.45<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R20<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

2 Storage O 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

3 Storage P 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R21<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $499.00 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $399.20 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $99.80 1.60


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 26<br />

Restroom R21 2nd<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $93.19 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $74.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $18.64 8.58<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $499.00 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $399.20 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $99.80 1.60<br />

Restroom R22 2nd<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $93.19 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $74.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $18.64 8.58<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R22<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3 Storage Q 2nd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $83.17 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $66.53 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $16.63 9.62<br />

26 2920 21 1<br />

Business & Imaging<br />

16 <strong>Center</strong> 2nd Flr 2920 18 2<br />

19 2920 6 1<br />

1 Storage R 2nd Flr 2190 4 4<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

32W, 2 Lamp, Parabolic U-<br />

Tube T-12 Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

28 0.59 1,717.0 $346.83 21 0<br />

60 1.08 3,153.6 $637.03 18 0<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $318.51 6 1<br />

188 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.47 1374 $277.46 $160.00 $160.00 0.12 343.392 $69.37 2.31<br />

60 20% 0.86 2523 $509.62 $160.00 $160.00 0.22 630.72 $127.41 1.26<br />

90 20% 0.43 1261 $254.81 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 315.36 $63.70 2.51<br />

188 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet P 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet P 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R33 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R33<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet O 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet O 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 2,195.8 $443.56 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1757 $354.85 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $88.71 1.80<br />

Restroom R34 2nd<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

Flr<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $46.60 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $37.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $9.32 17.17<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R34<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

1 Storage S 2nd Flr 2190 4 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 0.75 1,646.9 $332.67 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.60 1318 $266.14 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $66.53 2.40<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $499.00 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $399.20 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $99.80 1.60


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 27<br />

Restroom R23 2nd<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $93.19 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $74.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $18.64 8.58<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R23<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R24<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $499.00 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $399.20 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $99.80 1.60<br />

Restroom R24 2nd<br />

6 2920 2 2<br />

Flr<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.16 461.4 $93.19 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.13 369 $74.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 92.272 $18.64 8.58<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

22 2190 16 1<br />

Storage T 2nd Flr<br />

26 2190 6 1<br />

2 Storage U 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

50 0.80 1,752.0 $353.90 16 1<br />

28 0.17 367.9 $74.32 6 0<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

50 20% 0.64 1402 $283.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.16 350.4 $70.78 2.26<br />

28 20% 0.13 294 $59.46 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 73.584 $14.86 10.76<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

20 Storage V 2nd Flr 2190 10 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

23 0.23 503.7 $101.75 10 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

23 20% 0.18 403 $81.40 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 100.74 $20.35 7.86<br />

2 Storage W 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R25<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $665.34 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.90 2635 $532.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $133.07 1.20<br />

6 2920 7 2<br />

Restroom R25 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $326.18 7 2<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.44 1292 $260.95 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 322.952 $65.24 2.45<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

5 2920 12 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 1.13 3,293.8 $665.34 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.90 2635 $532.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $133.07 1.20<br />

6 2920 7 2<br />

Restroom R26 2nd<br />

Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.55 1,614.8 $326.18 7 2<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $33.03 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.44 1292 $260.95 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 322.952 $65.24 2.45<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $26.42 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $6.61 24.22<br />

7 2920 1 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.05 146.0 $29.49 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.04 117 $23.59 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 29.2 $5.90 27.13<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet R26<br />

2nd Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

2 Storage X 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

2 Storage Y 2nd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

26 8760 147 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $41.58 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $33.27 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $8.32 19.24<br />

28 4.12 36,056.2 $7,283.34 147 0 N/A 28 0% 4.12 36056 $7,283.34 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 28<br />

46 8760 88 0<br />

32 Main Corridor A 8760 48 1<br />

2nd Flr<br />

100W, 2 lamp, Metal Halide<br />

and 26W 1 lamp, CFL<br />

Decorative Fixture<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Downlight<br />

Can Metal Halide Fixture<br />

278 24.46 214,304.6 $43,289.54 88 0 N/A 278 0% 24.46 214305 $43,289.54 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

455 21.84 191,318.4 $38,646.32 48 0 N/A 455 0% 21.84 191318 $38,646.32 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 8760 6 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.06 525.6 $106.17 6 0 N/A 10 0% 0.06 526 $106.17 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

20 8760 3 1<br />

19 8760 1 1<br />

26 Esculator A 2nd Flr 8760 35 1<br />

26 8760 26 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

23 0.07 604.4 $122.10 3 0 N/A 23 0% 0.07 604 $122.10 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.09 788.4 $159.26 1 1 N/A 90 0% 0.09 788 $159.26 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.98 8,584.8 $1,734.13 35 0 N/A 28 0% 0.98 8585 $1,734.13 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

28 0.73 6,377.3 $1,288.21 26 0 N/A 28 0% 0.73 6377 $1,288.21 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

21 Esculator B 2nd Flr 8760 8 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard Bulb<br />

100 0.80 7,008.0 $1,415.62 8 1 N/A 100 0% 0.80 7008 $1,415.62 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

4 8760 6 1<br />

40W, 1 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

57 0.34 2,995.9 $605.18 6 1 N/A 57 0% 0.34 2996 $605.18 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 1756 330 517.20 2,443,485.3 $493,584.04 1756 234 26.8 507.38 2418045 $488,445.17 $21,440.00 9.82 25439.9 $5,138.86 4.17<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 29<br />

CEG Job #:<br />

1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> "PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> 3rd Flr"<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address:<br />

12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Lighting Controls<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Lighting Controls Watts Savings Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used (%) kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

19 2920 8 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

90 0.72 2,102.4 $233.37 8 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.58 1682 $186.69 $160.00 $160.00 0.14 420.48 $46.67 3.43<br />

Meeting Rm 300 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

Meeting Rm 301 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.79 2313 $256.70 $160.00 $160.00 0.20 578.16 $64.18 2.49<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

Meeting Rm 302 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.79 2313 $256.70 $160.00 $160.00 0.20 578.16 $64.18 2.49<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R46 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.12 350 $38.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 87.6 $9.72 16.45<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R45 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.12 350 $38.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 87.6 $9.72 16.45<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

20<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R45/R46 3rd Flr<br />

2190 1 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

23 0.02 50.4 $5.59 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

23 20% 0.02 40 $4.47 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 10.074 $1.12 143.09<br />

3 Storage U 3rd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet U 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 30<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet U 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

303A 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $233.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2.74<br />

188 20% 1.20 3513 $389.98 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 878.336 $97.50 1.64<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

303B 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $233.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2.74<br />

188 20% 1.20 3513 $389.98 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 878.336 $97.50 1.64<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

21 2920 13 1<br />

Office1 3rd Flr<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard Bulb 100 1.30 3,796.0 $421.36 13 1 Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

100 20% 1.04 3037 $337.08 $160.00 $160.00 0.26 759.2 $84.27 1.90<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $233.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2.74<br />

3 Office2 3rd Flr 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

3 Storage R44 3rd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R44 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.12 350 $38.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 87.6 $9.72 16.45<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R43 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.12 350 $38.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 87.6 $9.72 16.45<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

20<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R43/R44 3rd Flr<br />

2190 1 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

23 0.02 50.4 $5.59 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

23 20% 0.02 40 $4.47 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 10.074 $1.12 143.09<br />

3 Storage T 3rd Flr 2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet T 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet T 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

2 Corridor T 3rd Flr 8760 4 2<br />

19 Office3 3rd Flr 2920 6 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2 N/A 94 0% 0.38 3294 $365.61 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $175.02 6 1<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.43 1261 $140.02 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 315.36 $35.00 4.57


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 31<br />

19<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

2920 47 1<br />

90 4.23 12,351.6 $1,371.03 47 1<br />

Meeting Room 304<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.38 9881 $1,096.82 $160.00 $160.00 0.85 2470.32 $274.21 0.58<br />

VIP 3rd Flr<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

1 Office4 3rd Flr 2920 6 4<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

3 Storage S 3rd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

2 Corridor S 3rd Flr 8760 5 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2 N/A 94 0% 0.47 4117 $457.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet S 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet S 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3 Office5 3rd Flr 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

3<br />

Office5 Storage 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Room 305<br />

2920<br />

3rd Flr<br />

6 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $233.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2.74<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Room 306<br />

2920<br />

3rd Flr<br />

6 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $233.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2.74<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

307A 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $233.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2.74<br />

188 20% 1.20 3513 $389.98 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 878.336 $97.50 1.64<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 10 1<br />

1 2920 8 4<br />

Meeting Room<br />

307B 3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90 0.90 2,628.0 $291.71 10 1<br />

188 1.50 4,391.7 $487.48 8 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.72 2102 $233.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.18 525.6 $58.34 2.74<br />

188 20% 1.20 3513 $389.98 $160.00 $160.00 0.30 878.336 $97.50 1.64<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet R 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet R 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3 Storage R 3rd Flr 2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R42 3rd<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 32<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

50 20% 0.12 350 $38.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 87.6 $9.72 16.45<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

5 2920 5 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.47 1,372.4 $152.34 5 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.38 1098 $121.87 $160.00 $160.00 0.09 274.48 $30.47 5.25<br />

6 2920 3 2<br />

Restroom R41 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

7 2920 3 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.24 692.0 $76.82 3 2<br />

50 0.15 438.0 $48.62 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.19 554 $61.45 $160.00 $160.00 0.05 138.408 $15.36 10.41<br />

50 20% 0.12 350 $38.89 $160.00 $160.00 0.03 87.6 $9.72 16.45<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

20<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R41/R42 3rd Flr<br />

2190 1 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

23 0.02 50.4 $5.59 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

23 20% 0.02 40 $4.47 $160.00 $160.00 0.00 10.074 $1.12 143.09<br />

2 Office A 2nd Flr 2920 4 2<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

Meeting Room 308<br />

3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.30 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

90 20% 0.79 2313 $256.70 $160.00 $160.00 0.20 578.16 $64.18 2.49<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 11 1<br />

1 2920 6 4<br />

Meeting Room 309<br />

3rd Flr<br />

20 2920 2 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

90 0.99 2,890.8 $320.88 11 1<br />

188 1.13 3,293.8 $365.61 6 2<br />

23 0.05 134.3 $14.91 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.79 2313 $256.70 $160.00 $160.00 0.20 578.16 $64.18 2.49<br />

188 20% 0.90 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.23 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

23 20% 0.04 107 $11.93 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 26.864 $2.98 53.66<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 2920 6 1<br />

1 2920 4 4<br />

Meeting Room 310<br />

3rd Flr<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

90 0.54 1,576.8 $175.02 6 1<br />

188 0.75 2,195.8 $243.74 4 2<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 0.43 1261 $140.02 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 315.36 $35.00 4.57<br />

188 20% 0.60 1757 $194.99 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 439.168 $48.75 3.28<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

43 2920 1 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.01 29.2 $3.24 1 0 N/A 10 0% 0.01 29 $3.24 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

26 8760 172 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 4.82 42,188.2 $4,682.89 172 0 N/A 28 0% 4.82 42188 $4,682.89 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

21 8760 34 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard Bulb<br />

100 3.40 29,784.0 $3,306.02 34 1 N/A 100 0% 3.40 29784 $3,306.02 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

43 Main Corridor 3rd 8760 5 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.05 438.0 $48.62 5 0 N/A 10 0% 0.05 438 $48.62 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Flr<br />

20 8760 4 1<br />

23W, 1 lamp, Recessed CFL<br />

Replacement Flood Light<br />

23 0.09 805.9 $89.46 4 0 N/A 23 0% 0.09 806 $89.46 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 8760 1 1<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

90 0.09 788.4 $87.51 1 1 N/A 90 0% 0.09 788 $87.51 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 18 $1.94 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

21<br />

Overlook Café 3rd<br />

Flr<br />

2920 135 1<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard Bulb 100 13.50 39,420.0 $4,375.62 135 1 Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

100 20% 10.80 31536 $3,500.50 $160.00 $160.00 2.70 7884 $875.12 0.18<br />

21 2920 52 1<br />

Retail 3rd Flr<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard Bulb 100 5.20 15,184.0 $1,685.42 52 1 Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

100 20% 4.16 12147 $1,348.34 $160.00 $160.00 1.04 3036.8 $337.08 0.47


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 33<br />

Retail 3rd Flr<br />

8 2920 36 4<br />

2x4, 20W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Parabolic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

100 3.60 10,512.0 $1,166.83 36 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

100 20% 2.88 8410 $933.47 $160.00 $160.00 0.72 2102.4 $233.37 0.69<br />

5 2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.30 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

6<br />

Retail Restroom1<br />

2920 4 2<br />

3rd Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

45 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

25W, 1 lamp, Incandescent<br />

exit sign<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.25 738 $81.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 184.544 $20.48 7.81<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

25 0.05 146.0 $16.21 2 0 N/A 25 0% 0.05 146 $16.21 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 4 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.38 1,097.9 $121.87 4 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.30 878 $97.50 $160.00 $160.00 0.08 219.584 $24.37 6.56<br />

6<br />

Retail Restroom2<br />

2920 4 2<br />

3rd Flr<br />

26 2920 2 1<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

79 0.32 922.7 $102.42 4 2<br />

28 0.06 163.5 $18.15 2 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.25 738 $81.94 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 184.544 $20.48 7.81<br />

28 20% 0.04 131 $14.52 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 32.704 $3.63 44.08<br />

25W, 1 lamp, Incandescent<br />

45 2920 2 1<br />

25 0.05 146.0 $16.21 2 0 N/A 25 0% 0.05 146 $16.21 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

exit sign<br />

Totals 904 196 75.67 274,031.1 $30,417.45 904 130 18.2 62.46 235710 $26,163.81 $14,560.00 13.21 38321.1 $4,253.64 3.42<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 34<br />

CEG Job #:<br />

1C09067<br />

Project: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> "PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> 2nd Flr Train Shed"<br />

KWH COST: $0.111<br />

Address:<br />

12th Street<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Lighting Controls<br />

EXISTING LIGHTING PROPOSED LIGHTING SAVINGS<br />

CEG Fixture Yearly No. No. Fixture Fixt Total kWh/Yr Yearly No. No. Lighting Controls Watts Savings Total kWh/Yr Yearly Unit Cost Total kW kWh/Yr Yearly Yearly Simple<br />

Type Location Usage Fixts Lamps Type Watts kW Fixtures $ Cost Fixts Lamps Description Used (%) kW Fixtures $ Cost (INSTALLED) Cost Savings Savings $ Savings Payback<br />

26<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Bridge Area <strong>Center</strong><br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 8760 144 1 Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 4.03 35,320.3 $3,920.56 144 0 N/A 28 0% 4.03 35320 $3,920.56 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

21<br />

Bridge Area<br />

Windows 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

8760 64 1<br />

28 8760 36 1<br />

Lobby 2nd Flr Train<br />

19 Shed 8760 46 1<br />

45 8760 2 1<br />

2<br />

Sercurity W 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

8760 2 2<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Standard Bulb<br />

100 6.40 56,064.0 $6,223.10 64 1 N/A 100 0% 6.40 56064 $6,223.10 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

25W, 1 lamp, Incandescent<br />

exit sign<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

20 0.72 6,307.2 $700.10 36 0 N/A 20 0% 0.72 6307 $700.10 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 4.14 36,266.4 $4,025.57 46 1 N/A 90 0% 4.14 36266 $4,025.57 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

25 0.05 438.0 $48.62 2 0 N/A 25 0% 0.05 438 $48.62 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.19 1,646.9 $182.80 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

3<br />

Storage W 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

2<br />

Registration Office<br />

W 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

2920 2 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet EE<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet EE 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

2<br />

2<br />

Bathroom1 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

Bathroom2 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2920 1 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

94 0.09 274.5 $30.47 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $24.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $6.09 26.26<br />

94 20% 0.08 220 $24.37 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 54.896 $6.09 26.26<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R38 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R37 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

2<br />

First Aid E 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 3 2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.28 823.4 $91.40 3 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.23 659 $73.12 $160.00 $160.00 0.06 164.688 $18.28 8.75<br />

3<br />

Storage E 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

2<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Registration Office<br />

E 2nd Flr Train Shed 2920 2 2 Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 35<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R38/R37 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet FF<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet FF 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R40 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R39 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet<br />

R39/R40 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

6<br />

Bathroom3 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

6<br />

Bathroom4 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2920 1 2<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

2 8760 27 2<br />

33 8760 10 1<br />

11 8760 5 2<br />

West Side Service<br />

45<br />

Hall 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

8760 5 1<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

34 8760 1 1<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

25W, 1 lamp, Incandescent<br />

exit sign<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

94 2.54 22,232.9 $2,467.85 27 2 N/A 94 0% 2.54 22233 $2,467.85 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 2.95 25,842.0 $2,868.46 10 0 N/A 295 0% 2.95 25842 $2,868.46 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2 N/A 94 0% 0.47 4117 $457.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

25 0.13 1,095.0 $121.55 5 0 N/A 25 0% 0.13 1095 $121.55 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 2190 $243.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 0.21 1,865.9 $207.11 1 0 N/A 213 0% 0.21 1866 $207.11 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 18 $1.94 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet A<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec. Substation<br />

Rm. W 2nd Flr Train 2190 6 2<br />

Station<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $109.68 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $27.42 5.84<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet B<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet C<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

2 8760 27 2<br />

33 8760 10 1<br />

11 8760 5 2<br />

East Side Service<br />

45<br />

Hall 2nd Flr Train<br />

Shed<br />

8760 5 1<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

250W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Surface Mounted<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

25W, 1 lamp, Incandescent<br />

exit sign<br />

94 2.54 22,232.9 $2,467.85 27 2 N/A 94 0% 2.54 22233 $2,467.85 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

295 2.95 25,842.0 $2,868.46 10 0 N/A 295 0% 2.95 25842 $2,868.46 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.47 4,117.2 $457.01 5 2 N/A 94 0% 0.47 4117 $457.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

25 0.13 1,095.0 $121.55 5 0 N/A 25 0% 0.13 1095 $121.55 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 36<br />

39 8760 2 1<br />

34 8760 1 1<br />

44 8760 1 0<br />

100W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

High Pressure Sodium<br />

Fixture<br />

175W, 1 lamp Recessed<br />

Metal Halide Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

125 0.25 2,190.0 $243.09 2 0 N/A 125 0% 0.25 2190 $243.09 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

213 0.21 1,865.9 $207.11 1 0 N/A 213 0% 0.21 1866 $207.11 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.00 17.5 $1.94 1 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 18 $1.94 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet D<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Elec. Substation<br />

Rm. E 2nd Flr Train 2190 6 2<br />

Station<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.56 1,235.2 $137.10 6 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.45 988 $109.68 $160.00 $160.00 0.11 247.032 $27.42 5.84<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet E<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed 2190 1 2 40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Oper. Wall Closet F<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 201A<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.96 5782 $641.76 $160.00 $160.00 0.99 1445.4 $160.44 1.00<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 36 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 201B<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

24 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 3.24 4,730.4 $525.07 36 1<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 2.59 3784 $420.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.65 946.08 $105.01 1.52<br />

188 20% 3.61 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

43 2920 4 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 N/A 10 0% 0.04 117 $12.96 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 201C<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.96 5782 $641.76 $160.00 $160.00 0.99 1445.4 $160.44 1.00<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 202A<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

12 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.51 2208 $245.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.38 551.88 $61.26 2.61<br />

188 20% 1.80 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.45 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 202B<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

12 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.51 2208 $245.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.38 551.88 $61.26 2.61<br />

188 20% 1.80 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.45 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R36 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R35 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

54 8760 92 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

48W, 1 Lamp, Indirect Strip<br />

Flourescent, HO T-12<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

70 6.44 56,414.4 $6,262.00 92 1 N/A 70 0% 6.44 56414 $6,262.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 37<br />

22 8760 72 1<br />

50<br />

Main Corridor 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

8760 40 2<br />

24 8760 18 1<br />

28 8760 4 1<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 204A<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

32 4<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Halogen Accent Light<br />

13W, 2 Lamp, Compact<br />

Flourescent Wall Sconce<br />

fixture<br />

50W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

50 3.60 31,536.0 $3,500.50 72 1 N/A 50 0% 3.60 31536 $3,500.50 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

30 1.20 10,512.0 $1,166.83 40 0 N/A 30 0% 1.20 10512 $1,166.83 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

50 0.90 7,884.0 $875.12 18 1 N/A 50 0% 0.90 7884 $875.12 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

20 0.08 700.8 $77.79 4 0 N/A 20 0% 0.08 701 $77.79 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.96 5782 $641.76 $160.00 $160.00 0.99 1445.4 $160.44 1.00<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 36 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 204B<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

24 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 3.24 4,730.4 $525.07 36 1<br />

188 4.51 6,587.5 $731.21 24 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 2.59 3784 $420.06 $160.00 $160.00 0.65 946.08 $105.01 1.52<br />

188 20% 3.61 5270 $584.97 $160.00 $160.00 0.90 1317.504 $146.24 1.09<br />

43 2920 4 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.04 116.8 $12.96 4 0 N/A 10 0% 0.04 117 $12.96 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 55 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 204C<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

32 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 4.95 7,227.0 $802.20 55 1<br />

188 6.02 8,783.4 $974.95 32 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 3.96 5782 $641.76 $160.00 $160.00 0.99 1445.4 $160.44 1.00<br />

188 20% 4.81 7027 $779.96 $160.00 $160.00 1.20 1756.672 $194.99 0.82<br />

43 2920 3 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.03 87.6 $9.72 3 0 N/A 10 0% 0.03 88 $9.72 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 203A<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

12 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.51 2208 $245.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.38 551.88 $61.26 2.61<br />

188 20% 1.80 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.45 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

19 1460 21 1<br />

1<br />

Meeting Rm. 203B<br />

1460<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

12 4<br />

90W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Incandescent Flood Light<br />

2x4, 40W, 4 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

90 1.89 2,759.4 $306.29 21 1<br />

188 2.26 3,293.8 $365.61 12 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

90 20% 1.51 2208 $245.03 $160.00 $160.00 0.38 551.88 $61.26 2.61<br />

188 20% 1.80 2635 $292.49 $160.00 $160.00 0.45 658.752 $73.12 2.19<br />

43 2920 2 1 7W, 1 lamp, CFL Exit Sign 10 0.02 58.4 $6.48 2 0 N/A 10 0% 0.02 58 $6.48 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R34 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

5 2920 9 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.85 2,470.3 $274.21 9 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.68 1976 $219.36 $160.00 $160.00 0.17 494.064 $54.84 2.92<br />

Restroom R33 2nd<br />

6 2920 1 2<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

30W, 2 lamp, T-12 Indirect<br />

Strip Fluorescent Fixture<br />

79 0.08 230.7 $25.61 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

79 20% 0.06 185 $20.48 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 46.136 $5.12 31.24<br />

26 2920 1 1<br />

26W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

28 0.03 81.8 $9.08 1 0<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

28 20% 0.02 65 $7.26 $160.00 $160.00 0.01 16.352 $1.82 88.15<br />

3<br />

Fan Room W 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,441.0 $159.95 7 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.53 1153 $127.96 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 288.204 $31.99 5.00<br />

3<br />

Housekeeping W<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 8 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.75 1,646.9 $182.80 8 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.60 1318 $146.24 $160.00 $160.00 0.15 329.376 $36.56 4.38<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet W<br />

2nd Flr train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

28 8760 12 1<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

20 0.24 2,102.4 $233.37 12 0 N/A 20 0% 0.24 2102 $233.37 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 38<br />

Corridor GG 2nd Flr<br />

2 Train Shed 8760 4 2<br />

44 8760 2 0<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2 N/A 94 0% 0.38 3294 $365.61 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.00 35.0 $3.89 2 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 35 $3.89 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Side Room GG 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

3<br />

Storage GG 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet GG<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Pump Room GG<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet GG 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Storage2 GG 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Fan Room E 2nd Flr<br />

Train Shed<br />

2190 7 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.66 1,441.0 $159.95 7 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.53 1153 $127.96 $160.00 $160.00 0.13 288.204 $31.99 5.00<br />

3<br />

Housekeeping E 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Janitor Closet E 2nd<br />

Flr train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

28 8760 12 1<br />

Corridor HH 2nd Flr<br />

2 Train Shed 8760 4 2<br />

44 8760 2 0<br />

18W, 1 lamp, Recessed<br />

Compact Fluorescent<br />

Fixture<br />

2x4, 40W, 2 lamp, T-12<br />

Recessed Prismatic<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

2W, LED Retrifitted Exit<br />

Sign'<br />

20 0.24 2,102.4 $233.37 12 0 N/A 20 0% 0.24 2102 $233.37 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

94 0.38 3,293.8 $365.61 4 2 N/A 94 0% 0.38 3294 $365.61 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

2 0.00 35.0 $3.89 2 0 N/A 2 0% 0.00 35 $3.89 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

3<br />

Side Room HH 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2920 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 549.0 $60.93 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 439 $48.75 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 109.792 $12.19 13.13<br />

3<br />

Storage1 HH 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Phone Closet HH<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

3<br />

Pump Room HH<br />

2nd Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Elec Closet HH 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 2 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.19 411.7 $45.70 2 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.15 329 $36.56 $160.00 $160.00 0.04 82.344 $9.14 17.51<br />

3<br />

Storage2 HH 2nd<br />

Flr Train Shed<br />

2190 1 2<br />

40W, 2 lamp, T-12 Pendant<br />

Fluorescent Fixture<br />

94 0.09 205.9 $22.85 1 2<br />

Dual Technology Occupancy<br />

Sensor<br />

94 20% 0.08 165 $18.28 $160.00 $160.00 0.02 41.172 $4.57 35.01<br />

40 4380 2 1<br />

36 4380 2 1<br />

37 4380<br />

Grand Hall 2nd Flr<br />

2 1<br />

Train Shed<br />

47 4380 10 0<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Surface<br />

Indirect High Pressure<br />

Sodium Fixture<br />

400W, 1 lamp, Surface<br />

Indirect Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

1000W, 1 lamp, Surface<br />

Indirect Metal Halide<br />

Fixture<br />

(2)1000W, HPS, and (2)<br />

400W MH and (1) 1000W<br />

MH, Combination w/<br />

Direction Dampers<br />

1100 2.20 9,636.0 $1,069.60 2 0 N/A 1100 0% 2.20 9636 $1,069.60 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

455 0.91 3,985.8 $442.42 2 0 N/A 455 0% 0.91 3986 $442.42 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

1085 2.17 9,504.6 $1,055.01 2 0 N/A 1085 0% 2.17 9505 $1,055.01 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

4195 41.95 183,741.0 $20,395.25 10 0 N/A 4195 0% 41.95 183741 $20,395.25 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00


Appendix E - ECM #3 Lighting Controls -Page 39<br />

53 4380 16 1<br />

60W, 1 Lamp, Wall<br />

Mounted High Pressure<br />

Sodium Wall Sconce<br />

125 2.00 8,760.0 $972.36 16 0 N/A 125 0% 2.00 8760 $972.36 $0.00 $0.00 0.00 0 $0.00 0.00<br />

Totals 1492 221 183.23 736,916.0 $81,797.68 1492 163 17.2 164.86 706227.1 $78,391.21 $13,760.00 18.36 30688.9 $3,406.47 4.04<br />

NOTES: 1. Simple Payback noted in this spreadsheet does not include Maintenance Savings and NJ Smart Start Incentives.<br />

2. Lamp totals only include T-12 tube replacment calculations


Appendix E - ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller -Page 1<br />

MONTHLY ENERGY CONSUMPTION<br />

By Concord Engineering Group<br />

------- Monthly Energy Consumption -------<br />

Utility Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total<br />

Alternative: 1<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - Baseline<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 523,333 603,157 563,492 541,137 641,405 286,624 400,852 246,121 554,497 554,599 527,783 426,024 5,869,023<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 889,165 846,732 776,269 824,270 787,147 674,010 758,381 683,077 804,808 841,252 831,988 763,196 9,480,296<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,352 3,371 3,478 3,633 5,712 6,432 6,549 6,554 6,210 4,184 3,614 3,355 6,554<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,253 3,274 3,267 3,526 3,985 6,587 6,872 6,659 6,364 4,111 3,412 3,250 6,872<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 59,414 88,181 18,022 15,771 14,633 16,080 21,616 14,983 18,267 16,940 22,940 84,216 391,065<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 288 365 175 139 60 54 59 54 64 131 151 218<br />

365<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 180 1,703 1,279 2,230 1,287 1,520 363 155 0<br />

8,717<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 89,709 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 32,603,752 lbm/year<br />

Source 194,472 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 252,072 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

50,666 gm/year<br />

Alternative: 2<br />

Pony Electric Chiller<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 523,333 603,157 563,492 550,240 664,352 309,067 424,490 267,255 573,088 571,079 536,247 426,024 6,011,825<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 889,165 846,732 776,269 829,787 812,834 709,114 812,700 710,604 843,155 851,821 836,283 763,196 9,681,661<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,352 3,371 3,575 3,836 5,879 6,667 6,793 6,790 6,398 4,382 3,818 3,355 6,793<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,253 3,274 3,267 3,738 4,073 6,802 7,105 6,882 6,563 4,318 3,628 3,250 7,105<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 59,414 88,181 18,022 12,259 123 0 469 0 1,903 10,059 19,907 84,216 294,552<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 288 365 175 139 7 0 8 0 10 131 151 218<br />

365<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 104 1,380 926 1,767 957 1,157 211 90 0<br />

6,593<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 81,397 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 29,583,110 lbm/year<br />

Source 187,967 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 228,719 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

45,972 gm/year<br />

Savings<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 0 0 0 -9,104 -22,948 -22,442 -23,638 -21,134 -18,591 -16,480 -8,464 0 -142,801<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 0 0 0 -5,517 -25,687 -35,104 -54,319 -27,527 -38,347 -10,568 -4,294 0 -201,365<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 0 0 -98 -203 -167 -235 -244 -236 -187 -199 -204 0<br />

-244<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 0 0 0 -212 -88 -215 -233 -223 -199 -207 -216 0<br />

-233<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 0 0 0 3,512 14,510 16,080 21,148 14,983 16,364 6,881 3,034 0<br />

96,513<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 0 0 0 0 53 54 0 0 54 0 0 0<br />

54


Appendix E - ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller -Page 2<br />

ECM ENERGY SAVINGS<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Month<br />

On Peak Off Peak Metered Billed<br />

Use Use Demand Demand<br />

KWH KWH KW KW<br />

Jan 0 0 0.0 4,426.4<br />

Feb 0 0 0.0 4,426.4<br />

Mar 0 0 -98.0 4,426.4<br />

Apr -9,104 -5,517 -203.0 4,426.4<br />

May -22,948 -25,687 -167.0 4,426.4<br />

Jun -22,442 -35,104 -235.0 4,426.4<br />

Jul -23,638 -54,319 -244.0 4,426.4<br />

Aug -21,134 -27,527 -236.0 4,426.4<br />

Sep -18,591 -38,347 -187.0 4,426.4<br />

Oct -16,480 -10,568 -199.0 4,426.4<br />

Nov -8,464 -4,294 -204.0 4,426.4<br />

Dec 0 0 0.0 4,426.4<br />

Total -142,801 -201,363 0 4,426<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

On Peak Use Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,231.2 $171,384 $60,633 $0.101 403 37.3% 37.3% 25.5%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,565 $66,133 $0.110 355 42.3% 42.3% 15.4%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 522,462 838,766 3,690.0 4,231.2 $161,329 $60,633 $0.119 322 46.6% 46.6% 6.7%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 598,150 968,869 4,603.0 4,603.0 $178,097 $65,961 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.9%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 703,863 1,007,045 4,850.0 4,850.0 $192,215 $69,501 $0.112 353 42.5% 42.5% 15.0%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 758,086 1,159,560 5,289.0 5,289.0 $211,018 $75,791 $0.110 363 41.4% 41.4% 17.3%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 617,682 870,013 4,664.0 4,664.0 $179,857 $66,835 $0.121 319 47.0% 47.0% 5.9%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 612,934 918,926 3,787.0 4,231.2 $168,822 $60,633 $0.110 362 41.4% 41.4% 17.1%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 580,605 966,410 3,930.0 4,231.2 $166,911 $60,633 $0.108 366 41.0% 41.0% 17.9%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 561,816 1,049,996 3,893.0 4,231.2 $168,690 $60,633 $0.105 381 39.4% 39.4% 21.2%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 4,231.2 $160,951 $60,633 $0.119 320 46.9% 46.9% 6.1%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,325,940 11,941,591 5,289 5,289 $2,125,602 $773,737 $0.111 357 42% 42% 15%<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

BASELINE AVERAGE UTILITY HISTORY 2006 - 2008<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

On Peak Use Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

PROPOSED ECM COSTS<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,426.4 $176,916 $63,430 $0.104 385 39.0% 39.0% 22.0%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,713.0 4,713.0 $183,342 $67,537 $0.112 347 43.2% 43.2% 13.6%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 531,566 844,283 3,893.0 4,426.4 $167,320 $63,430 $0.122 311 48.3% 48.3% 3.5%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 621,098 994,556 4,770.0 4,770.0 $184,325 $68,354 $0.114 339 44.3% 44.3% 11.4%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 726,305 1,042,149 5,085.0 5,085.0 $200,704 $72,868 $0.113 348 43.1% 43.1% 13.7%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 781,724 1,213,879 5,533.0 5,533.0 $220,357 $79,288 $0.110 361 41.6% 41.6% 16.8%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 638,816 897,540 4,900.0 4,900.0 $188,109 $70,217 $0.122 314 47.8% 47.8% 4.3%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 631,525 957,273 3,974.0 4,426.4 $176,135 $63,430 $0.111 359 41.8% 41.8% 16.4%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 597,085 976,978 4,129.0 4,426.4 $173,290 $63,430 $0.110 356 42.2% 42.2% 15.6%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 570,280 1,054,290 4,097.0 4,426.4 $174,624 $63,430 $0.107 367 40.9% 40.9% 18.3%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 4,426.4 $166,482 $63,430 $0.123 305 49.1% 49.1% 1.8%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,468,741 12,142,954 5,533 5,533 $2,197,368 $804,564 $0.113 349 43% 43% 14%


Appendix E - ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller -Page 3<br />

ECM #4 - COST ESTIMATE SUMMARY<br />

DESCRIPTION MATERIALS LABOR QTY / % TOTAL<br />

500 Ton Chiller ($/Unit) $180,000 1 $180,000<br />

CHW Pump $10,900 $2,400 2 $26,600<br />

CHW Piping & Fittings (6" Dia) $27 $53 200 $15,900<br />

CHW Piping Insulation $11 $22 200 $6,500<br />

CW Pump $12,000 $2,500 2 $29,000<br />

CW Piping & Fittings (8" Dia) $39 $66 300 $31,500<br />

Controls $20,000 1 $20,000<br />

Chiller Electrical Work $34,844 $17,156 1 $52,000<br />

Pump Electrical Work $3,000 $3,725 2 $13,450<br />

Construction Extras (Equipment Lift, Site Work) $25,000 1 $25,000<br />

Subtotal $399,950<br />

Engineering 10% $39,995<br />

Insurance 10% $39,995<br />

Permitting 5% $19,998<br />

TOTAL $499,938


Appendix E - ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller -Page 4<br />

YR MAXE CHILLER<br />

PERFORMANCE SPECIFICATION<br />

Unit Tag Qty Model No. Capacity (tons) Power Refrigerant<br />

YR400 1 YRXCXDT3-46C 410 460/3/60 R-134A<br />

Unit Data Evaporator Condenser<br />

EWT (°F): 58.00 85.00<br />

LWT (°F): 42.00 95.00<br />

Flow Rate (gpm): 614 1166<br />

Pressure Drop (ft): 11.9 16.6<br />

Fluid Type (%): WATER WATER<br />

Circuit No. of Passes: 2 2<br />

Fouling Factor (ft² °F hr / Btu): 0.00010 0.00025<br />

Tube No. / Description: 271 - 0.025" Enhanced Copper 260 - 0.025" CSL Enhanced Copper<br />

Design Working Pressure (psig): 150 150<br />

Entering Water Nozzle @ Location: 2 12<br />

Leaving Water Nozzle @ Location: 3 13<br />

Water Box Weight, ea (lbs)(2): 589 446<br />

Cover Plate Weight , ea (lbs): 386 251<br />

Return Head Weight (lbs): 165 132<br />

Water Weight (lbs): 1684 1317<br />

Water Volume(gal): 202 158<br />

Per<strong>for</strong>mance Data Electrical Data Other<br />

KW: 260 RLA: 360 Operating Wt. (lbs): 25641<br />

KW/Ton: 0.634 LRA: 2102 Per Isolator (lbs): 6410<br />

NPLV (1): 0.526 Inrush Amps: 945 Refrigerant Wt. (lbs): 1025<br />

Min Circuit Ampacity (Amps): 454 Oil Charge (gal): 10<br />

Max Fuse/Breaker: 800 Motor Wt. (lbs): N/A<br />

Compressor Wt. (lbs): 6895<br />

Oil Separator Wt. (lbs): 2042<br />

Starter Wt. (lbs): 200<br />

Shipping Wt. (lbs): 22640<br />

Notes:<br />

Type Starter: Solid State Starter<br />

(1) Chiller NPLV value calculated to ARI Standard 550/590 equation.<br />

(2) Not including cover plate on marine water boxes.<br />

Project Name: PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong><br />

York Contract No.:<br />

Printed: 01/08/2010 at 10:53<br />

YR400 Per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

Unit Folder: YR400 v1_98.idd Page 1 of 1


Appendix E - ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller -Page 5<br />

BURRIS ENGINEERS, INC.<br />

180 S. Main St, Suite 203<br />

Ambler, PA 19002<br />

(215) 643‐4465<br />

www.burrisengineers.com<br />

Supplemental Chiller Installation<br />

The installation of a new 450 Ton chiller is more involved then the boiler, but is feasible. Based on the<br />

provided equipment catalog cuts, the electrical requirements <strong>for</strong> this size chiller is 329kW maximum,<br />

with maximum running load amps (RLA) of 455A. Assuming 80% power factor as worst case scenario,<br />

this translates into 411.25kVA or 495A at 480 3PH. Based on the National Electrical Code (NEC)<br />

Article 430, the minimum conductor size is based on 125% of full load amps (FLA) as dictated by the<br />

FLA tables of the Article. The FLA in those tables is determined by the motor’s horsepower (HP).<br />

However, since the HP is not given in the catalog cuts, and since the chiller may fall under NEC Article<br />

440 (Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Equipment) which allows the use of manufacturer nameplate<br />

data, the size of the conductors and OCPD will be determined by the amps stated above based on<br />

calculated kVA.<br />

The minimum circuit conductor ampacity <strong>for</strong> the proposed chiller based on a FLA of 495A is 619A.<br />

This ampacity can be achieved by 2 sets of 350kcmil conductors per phase <strong>for</strong> a total ampacity of 620A.<br />

The maximum OCPD <strong>for</strong> the motor circuit based on the use of an inverse-time circuit breaker is 250%<br />

of FLA per NEC Table 430.52. There<strong>for</strong>e, the maximum OCPD would be 1238A circuit breaker.<br />

Rounding down to the next lower standard size breaker provides a 1200A circuit breaker.<br />

Substations #7 & #8, which are located above the mechanical penthouse’s main floor, have many spare<br />

cubicles that can accommodate a 1200A breaker. There are even spare 1200A breakers that were used<br />

<strong>for</strong> temporary installations. From interviewing PCCA staff, BEI believes that the temporary is no longer<br />

needed. There<strong>for</strong>e, we will assume that the existing 1200A spare breaker can be used <strong>for</strong> the proposed<br />

chiller installation. We also believe that there is plenty of electrical capacity on each substation to<br />

accommodate the new chiller based on the previous use of temporary 1200A feeders.<br />

The estimated electrical cost <strong>for</strong> this ECM is $52,000, based on the following:<br />

1. 2 men/40 hours to install (2) 3” EMT conduits (including junction boxes, pull rope, etc.) from<br />

Substation #7 or #8 (which is above the main floor of the mechanical penthouse) to main floor<br />

and prepare <strong>for</strong> cable pull = $8000. This assumes the existing ceiling penetrations below each<br />

substation are available <strong>for</strong> use.<br />

2. 3 men/16 hours to install conductors, splice in any junction boxes installed, and make<br />

terminations on either side of pull = $4800<br />

3. Six (6) conductors (350kcmil) x 200’ x $21.55/ft = $25,860<br />

4. Two (2) conductors (3/0kcmil Ground) x 200’ x $10.46/ft = $4184<br />

5. 3” EMT @ $12/ft x 400’ = $4800<br />

6. Installation of a meter = $1700<br />

7. $2656 in miscellaneous materials, including cleaning and preparing the existing 1200A breaker<br />

<strong>for</strong> re-use


Appendix E - ECM #4 Supplemental Chiller -Page 6<br />

Page 2 of 2<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report - Supplemental Chiller Installation<br />

Figure 1 – Spare 1200A Breaker and cubicles in Substation #7 (similar <strong>for</strong> Substation #8)<br />

Figure 2 – Ceiling Penetration below Substation #7 & Substation #8


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 1<br />

MONTHLY ENERGY CONSUMPTION<br />

By Concord Engineering Group<br />

------- Monthly Energy Consumption -------<br />

Utility Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total<br />

Alternative: 1<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - Baseline<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 555,198 648,625 592,398 573,242 679,755 298,645 376,720 283,581 566,594 589,188 566,734 450,804 6,181,485<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 930,068 900,474 810,514 863,006 839,001 741,771 822,134 752,416 872,805 879,114 881,715 793,551 10,086,567<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,085 2,969 3,033 2,550 3,786 4,809 5,975 5,008 4,320 2,700 2,599 2,366 5,975<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,163 3,440 3,213 3,085 3,953 4,279 6,142 4,554 3,731 2,950 3,301 2,370 6,142<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 61,191 90,018 19,668 19,412 17,891 19,519 28,076 16,619 22,514 20,431 27,109 86,014 428,463<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 290 383 185 143 84 81 84 81 93 135 198 220<br />

383<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 180 1,796 1,434 2,372 1,368 1,663 365 157 0<br />

9,334<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 96,450 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 35,053,804 lbm/year<br />

Source 207,556 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 271,015 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

Alternative: 2<br />

Centrifugal Chiller VFD Retrofit<br />

NOX<br />

54,474 gm/year<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 555,198 648,625 592,398 573,242 662,880 298,645 364,470 283,581 552,859 589,188 566,734 450,804 6,138,625<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 930,068 900,474 810,514 863,006 827,706 729,123 811,315 738,756 860,983 879,114 881,715 793,551 10,026,324<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,085 2,969 3,033 2,550 3,671 4,636 6,041 4,848 4,314 2,700 2,599 2,366 6,041<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,163 3,440 3,213 3,085 3,838 4,257 6,211 4,403 3,616 2,950 3,301 2,370 6,211<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 61,191 90,018 19,668 19,412 17,891 19,519 28,076 16,619 22,514 20,431 27,109 86,014 428,463<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 290 383 185 143 84 81 84 81 93 135 198 220<br />

383<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 180 1,770 1,422 2,351 1,355 1,641 365 157 0<br />

9,241<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 96,105 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 34,928,408 lbm/year<br />

Source 206,521 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 270,045 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

54,279 gm/year<br />

Savings<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 0 0 0 0 16,875 0 12,250 0 13,735 0 0 0<br />

42,860<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 0 0 0 0 11,295 12,648 10,819 13,660 11,822 0 0 0<br />

60,243<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 0 0 0 0 115 173 -66 161 6 0 0 0<br />

-66<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 0 0 0 0 114 22 -69 151 116 0 0 0<br />

-69<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 0 0 0 0<br />

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

0<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

0


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 2<br />

ECM ENERGY SAVINGS<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Month<br />

On Peak Off Peak Metered Billed<br />

Use Use Demand Demand<br />

KWH KWH KW KW<br />

Jan 0 0 0.0 4,284.0<br />

Feb 0 0 0.0 4,284.0<br />

Mar 0 0 0.0 4,284.0<br />

Apr 0 0 0.0 4,284.0<br />

May 16,875 11,295 115.0 4,284.0<br />

Jun 0 12,648 173.0 4,284.0<br />

Jul 12,250 10,819 -66.0 4,284.0<br />

Aug 0 13,660 161.0 4,284.0<br />

Sep 13,735 11,822 6.0 4,284.0<br />

Oct 0 0 0.0 4,284.0<br />

Nov 0 0 0.0 4,284.0<br />

Dec 0 0 0.0 4,284.0<br />

Total 42,860 60,244 173 4,284<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

On Peak<br />

Use<br />

Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,231.2 $171,384 $60,633 $0.101 403 37.3% 37.3% 25.5%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,565 $66,133 $0.110 355 42.3% 42.3% 15.4%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 522,462 838,766 3,690.0 4,231.2 $161,329 $60,633 $0.119 322 46.6% 46.6% 6.7%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 598,150 968,869 4,603.0 4,603.0 $178,097 $65,961 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.9%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 703,863 1,007,045 4,850.0 4,850.0 $192,215 $69,501 $0.112 353 42.5% 42.5% 15.0%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 758,086 1,159,560 5,289.0 5,289.0 $211,018 $75,791 $0.110 363 41.4% 41.4% 17.3%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 617,682 870,013 4,664.0 4,664.0 $179,857 $66,835 $0.121 319 47.0% 47.0% 5.9%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 612,934 918,926 3,787.0 4,231.2 $168,822 $60,633 $0.110 362 41.4% 41.4% 17.1%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 580,605 966,410 3,930.0 4,231.2 $166,911 $60,633 $0.108 366 41.0% 41.0% 17.9%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 561,816 1,049,996 3,893.0 4,231.2 $168,690 $60,633 $0.105 381 39.4% 39.4% 21.2%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 4,231.2 $160,951 $60,633 $0.119 320 46.9% 46.9% 6.1%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,325,940 11,941,591 5,289 5,289 $2,125,602 $773,737 $0.111 357 42% 42% 15%<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

BASELINE AVERAGE UTILITY HISTORY 2006 - 2008<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

On Peak<br />

Use<br />

Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

PROPOSED ECM COSTS<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,284.0 $172,881 $61,390 $0.102 398 37.7% 37.7% 24.5%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,565 $66,133 $0.110 355 42.3% 42.3% 15.4%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 522,462 838,766 3,690.0 4,284.0 $162,825 $61,390 $0.120 318 47.2% 47.2% 5.6%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 581,275 957,574 4,488.0 4,488.0 $173,957 $64,313 $0.113 343 43.7% 43.7% 12.5%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 703,863 994,397 4,677.0 4,677.0 $186,950 $67,021 $0.110 363 41.3% 41.3% 17.4%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 745,836 1,148,741 5,355.0 5,355.0 $212,130 $76,737 $0.112 354 42.4% 42.4% 15.2%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 617,682 856,353 4,503.0 4,503.0 $174,902 $64,528 $0.119 327 45.8% 45.8% 8.4%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 599,199 907,104 3,781.0 4,284.0 $169,476 $61,390 $0.113 352 42.7% 42.7% 14.7%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 580,605 966,410 3,930.0 4,284.0 $168,407 $61,390 $0.109 361 41.5% 41.5% 16.9%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 561,816 1,049,996 3,893.0 4,284.0 $170,186 $61,390 $0.106 376 39.9% 39.9% 20.3%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 4,284.0 $162,447 $61,390 $0.120 316 47.5% 47.5% 5.0%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,283,080 11,881,347 5,355 5,355 $2,120,489 $772,788 $0.111 355 42% 42% 15%


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 3<br />

ECM #5 - COST ESTIMATE SUMMARY<br />

DESCRIPTION MATERIALS LABOR QTY / % TOTAL<br />

Chiller VFD Retrofit by JCI ($/Unit) $225,000 $50,000 2 $550,000<br />

Subtotal $550,000<br />

Engineering 0% $0<br />

Insurance 10% $55,000<br />

Permitting 5% $27,500<br />

TOTAL $632,500


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 4<br />

Issue Date: 12/09<br />

Project: Project<br />

Engineer: Sales Eng<br />

Customer: customer<br />

Program: LTC<br />

Rev: v1_98.idd<br />

Date: 01/18/10<br />

Page: 1 of 1<br />

MODEL YKWHVDJ4-DDF (MOTOR SELECTED BY PROGRAM)<br />

REFRIGERANT 134A GEAR CODE PZ(CALC)<br />

RATED CAPACITY (TR) 1700 SPECIFIED CAPACITY (TR) 1700<br />

INPUT POWER (KW) 957 MAX MOTOR LOAD (KW) 1015<br />

VOLTAGE / HZ 4160 / 60<br />

ORIFICE (VARY) VALVE:4 OPTISOUND CONTROL YES<br />

ISOLATION VALVE NO<br />

FLA 163 LRA 960<br />

INRUSH (AMPS) 960<br />

STARTER SIZE 172<br />

FULL LOAD (kW/TR) 0.563 NPLV 0.488<br />

STARTER TYPE (7) ACROSS-THE-LINE (100%INRUSH) - 3 LEAD<br />

Evaporator<br />

Condenser<br />

FLUID WATER* WATER*<br />

% BY WEIGHT 0.0* 0.0*<br />

TUBE MTI NO. 181* 260*<br />

PASSES 3* 2*<br />

FOUL FACTOR (hr.ft².°F/BTU) 0.00010* 0.00025*<br />

FLUID ENT TEMP (°F) 57.98 85.00*<br />

FLUID LVG TEMP (°F) 42.00* 94.44<br />

FLUID FLOW (gpm) 2550.0* 5000.0*<br />

FLUID PRDROP (ft) 18.4 15.0<br />

(*) Designates Specified Input<br />

IPLV / NPLV CALCULATION:<br />

1<br />

IPLV OR NPLV<br />

=<br />

0.01 0.42 0.45 0.12<br />

+ + +<br />

A B C D<br />

NPLV =<br />

1<br />

2.0481<br />

= 0.488<br />

A = kW / TR AT 100% CAPACITY<br />

B = kW / TR AT 75% CAPACITY<br />

C = kW / TR AT 50% CAPACITY<br />

D = kW / TR AT 25% CAPACITY<br />

WEIGHTED TR /<br />

% Load CAPACITY (TR) ECWT (°F) kW / TR WEIGHT<br />

kW<br />

100 1700.0 85.000 0.563 0.01 0.0178<br />

75 1275.0 75.000 0.491 0.42 0.8554<br />

50 850.0 65.000 0.465 0.45 0.9684<br />

25 425.0 65.000 0.581 0.12 0.2065


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 5<br />

Rating certified in accordance with AHRI STD. 550/590.<br />

Water-chilling packages using the vapor compression cycle certification program.<br />

Compliant with ASHRAE 90.1 - 2004<br />

Compliant with ASHRAE 90.1 - 2007<br />

Materials and construction per mechanical specifications - Form 160.73-EG1.


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 6<br />

Issue Date: 12/09<br />

Project: Project<br />

Engineer: Sales Eng<br />

Customer: customer<br />

Program: LTC<br />

Rev: v1_98.idd<br />

Date: 01/18/10<br />

Page: 1 of 1<br />

MODEL YKWHVDJ4-DDF (MOTOR SELECTED BY PROGRAM)<br />

REFRIGERANT 134A GEAR CODE PZ(CALC)<br />

RATED CAPACITY (TR) 1700 SPECIFIED CAPACITY (TR) 1700<br />

INPUT POWER (KW) 991 MAX MOTOR LOAD (KW) 989<br />

VOLTAGE / HZ 4160 / 60<br />

ORIFICE (VARY) VALVE:4 OPTISOUND CONTROL YES<br />

ISOLATION VALVE NO<br />

FLA 151 LRA 960<br />

MIN CIR. AMPS. 189 MAX C.B. 300<br />

FULL LOAD (kW/TR) 0.583 NPLV 0.361<br />

STARTER TYPE (11) VARIABLE SPEED DRIVE WITH FILTER<br />

Evaporator<br />

Condenser<br />

FLUID WATER* WATER*<br />

% BY WEIGHT 0.0* 0.0*<br />

TUBE MTI NO. 181* 260*<br />

PASSES 3* 2*<br />

FOUL FACTOR (hr.ft².°F/BTU) 0.00010* 0.00025*<br />

FLUID ENT TEMP (°F) 57.98 85.00*<br />

FLUID LVG TEMP (°F) 42.00* 94.44<br />

FLUID FLOW (gpm) 2550.0* 5000.0*<br />

FLUID PRDROP (ft) 18.4 15.0<br />

(*) Designates Specified Input<br />

IPLV / NPLV CALCULATION:<br />

1<br />

IPLV OR NPLV<br />

=<br />

0.01 0.42 0.45 0.12<br />

+ + +<br />

A B C D<br />

NPLV =<br />

1<br />

2.7694<br />

= 0.361<br />

A = kW / TR AT 100% CAPACITY<br />

B = kW / TR AT 75% CAPACITY<br />

C = kW / TR AT 50% CAPACITY<br />

D = kW / TR AT 25% CAPACITY<br />

WEIGHTED TR /<br />

% Load CAPACITY (TR) ECWT (°F) kW / TR WEIGHT<br />

kW<br />

100 1700.0 85.000 0.583 0.01 0.0172<br />

75 1275.0 75.000 0.439 0.42 0.9562<br />

50 850.0 65.000 0.306 0.45 1.4712<br />

25 425.0 65.000 0.369 0.12 0.3248<br />

Rating certified in accordance with AHRI STD. 550/590.<br />

Water-chilling packages using the vapor compression cycle certification program.


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 7<br />

Compliant with ASHRAE 90.1 - 2004<br />

Compliant with ASHRAE 90.1 - 2007<br />

Materials and construction per mechanical specifications - Form 160.73-EG1.


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 8


Appendix E - ECM #5 Chiller VFD Retrofit -Page 9


Appendix E - ECM #6 Demand Response Controls -Page 1<br />

ECM #5 - COST ESTIMATE SUMMARY<br />

DESCRIPTION MATERIALS LABOR QTY / % TOTAL<br />

Demand Response Meter Retrofit $4,000 $8,000 1 $12,000<br />

Controls (Est 20 Pts) $0 $1,200 20 $24,000<br />

Software Programming $10,000 1 $10,000<br />

System Commissioning $5,000 1 $5,000<br />

Subtotal $51,000<br />

Engineering 20% $10,200<br />

Insurance 10% $5,100<br />

Permitting 5% $2,550<br />

TOTAL $68,850


Appendix E - ECM #6 Demand Response Controls -Page 2<br />

ECM ENERGY SAVINGS<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Month<br />

On Peak Off Peak Metered Billed<br />

Use Use Demand Demand<br />

KWH KWH KW KW<br />

Jan 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Feb 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Mar 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Apr 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

May 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Jun 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Jul 24,888 0 439.0 3,880.0<br />

Aug 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Sep 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Oct 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Nov 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Dec 0 0 0.0 3,880.0<br />

Total 24,888 0 439 3,880<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

On Peak Use Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,231.2 $171,384 $60,633 $0.101 403 37.3% 37.3% 25.5%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,565 $66,133 $0.110 355 42.3% 42.3% 15.4%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 522,462 838,766 3,690.0 4,231.2 $161,329 $60,633 $0.119 322 46.6% 46.6% 6.7%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 598,150 968,869 4,603.0 4,603.0 $178,097 $65,961 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.9%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 703,863 1,007,045 4,850.0 4,850.0 $192,215 $69,501 $0.112 353 42.5% 42.5% 15.0%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 758,086 1,159,560 5,289.0 5,289.0 $211,018 $75,791 $0.110 363 41.4% 41.4% 17.3%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 617,682 870,013 4,664.0 4,664.0 $179,857 $66,835 $0.121 319 47.0% 47.0% 5.9%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 612,934 918,926 3,787.0 4,231.2 $168,822 $60,633 $0.110 362 41.4% 41.4% 17.1%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 580,605 966,410 3,930.0 4,231.2 $166,911 $60,633 $0.108 366 41.0% 41.0% 17.9%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 561,816 1,049,996 3,893.0 4,231.2 $168,690 $60,633 $0.105 381 39.4% 39.4% 21.2%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 4,231.2 $160,951 $60,633 $0.119 320 46.9% 46.9% 6.1%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,325,940 11,941,591 5,289 5,289 $2,125,602 $773,737 $0.111 357 42% 42% 15%<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

BASELINE AVERAGE UTILITY HISTORY 2006 - 2008<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

On Peak Use Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

PROPOSED ECM COSTS<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,062.0 $166,589 $58,208 $0.098 419 35.8% 35.8% 28.4%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,565 $66,133 $0.110 355 42.3% 42.3% 15.4%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 522,462 838,766 3,690.0 3,880.0 $151,376 $55,600 $0.111 351 42.8% 42.8% 14.5%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 598,150 968,869 4,603.0 4,603.0 $178,097 $65,961 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.9%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 703,863 1,007,045 4,850.0 4,850.0 $192,215 $69,501 $0.112 353 42.5% 42.5% 15.0%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 733,198 1,159,560 4,850.0 4,850.0 $197,666 $69,501 $0.104 390 38.4% 38.4% 23.1%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 617,682 870,013 4,664.0 4,664.0 $179,857 $66,835 $0.121 319 47.0% 47.0% 5.9%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 612,934 918,926 3,787.0 3,880.0 $158,869 $55,600 $0.104 395 38.0% 38.0% 24.0%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 580,605 966,410 3,930.0 3,930.0 $158,375 $56,317 $0.102 394 38.1% 38.1% 23.8%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 561,816 1,049,996 3,893.0 3,893.0 $159,105 $55,787 $0.099 414 36.2% 36.2% 27.5%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 3,880.0 $150,997 $55,600 $0.112 349 43.0% 43.0% 13.9%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,301,052 11,941,591 4,850 4,850 $2,059,475 $740,761 $0.107 373 40% 40% 19%


Appendix E - ECM #6 Demand Response Controls -Page 3<br />

Issue Date: 12/09<br />

Project: Project<br />

Engineer: Sales Eng<br />

Customer: customer<br />

Program: LTC<br />

Rev: v1_98.idd<br />

Date: 01/18/10<br />

Page: 1 of 1<br />

MODEL YKWHVDJ4-DDF (MOTOR SELECTED BY PROGRAM)<br />

REFRIGERANT 134A GEAR CODE PZ(CALC)<br />

RATED CAPACITY (TR) 1700 SPECIFIED CAPACITY (TR) 1700<br />

INPUT POWER (KW) 957 MAX MOTOR LOAD (KW) 1015<br />

VOLTAGE / HZ 4160 / 60<br />

ORIFICE (VARY) VALVE:4 OPTISOUND CONTROL YES<br />

ISOLATION VALVE NO<br />

FLA 163 LRA 960<br />

INRUSH (AMPS) 960<br />

STARTER SIZE 172<br />

FULL LOAD (kW/TR) 0.563 NPLV 0.488<br />

STARTER TYPE (7) ACROSS-THE-LINE (100%INRUSH) - 3 LEAD<br />

Evaporator<br />

Condenser<br />

FLUID WATER* WATER*<br />

% BY WEIGHT 0.0* 0.0*<br />

TUBE MTI NO. 181* 260*<br />

PASSES 3* 2*<br />

FOUL FACTOR (hr.ft².°F/BTU) 0.00010* 0.00025*<br />

FLUID ENT TEMP (°F) 57.98 85.00*<br />

FLUID LVG TEMP (°F) 42.00* 94.44<br />

FLUID FLOW (gpm) 2550.0* 5000.0*<br />

FLUID PRDROP (ft) 18.4 15.0<br />

(*) Designates Specified Input<br />

IPLV / NPLV CALCULATION:<br />

1<br />

IPLV OR NPLV<br />

=<br />

0.01 0.42 0.45 0.12<br />

+ + +<br />

A B C D<br />

NPLV =<br />

1<br />

2.0481<br />

= 0.488<br />

A = kW / TR AT 100% CAPACITY<br />

B = kW / TR AT 75% CAPACITY<br />

C = kW / TR AT 50% CAPACITY<br />

D = kW / TR AT 25% CAPACITY<br />

WEIGHTED TR /<br />

% Load CAPACITY (TR) ECWT (°F) kW / TR WEIGHT<br />

kW<br />

100 1700.0 85.000 0.563 0.01 0.0178<br />

75 1275.0 75.000 0.491 0.42 0.8554<br />

50 850.0 65.000 0.465 0.45 0.9684<br />

25 425.0 65.000 0.581 0.12 0.2065


Appendix E - ECM #6 Demand Response Controls -Page 4<br />

Rating certified in accordance with AHRI STD. 550/590.<br />

Water-chilling packages using the vapor compression cycle certification program.<br />

Compliant with ASHRAE 90.1 - 2004<br />

Compliant with ASHRAE 90.1 - 2007<br />

Materials and construction per mechanical specifications - Form 160.73-EG1.


Appendix E - ECM #6 Demand Response Controls -Page 5<br />

ABSORPTION CHILLER PART LOAD DATA<br />

Exclusively For:<br />

Job Name: PACC<br />

Absorption Model: YPC-FP-19S-46-H-S-D<br />

Pass Arrangment: 2 EVAP/1 ABS/1 CON<br />

Percent Heat Input 100 68 41 26<br />

PERCENT LOAD: 100 75 50 30<br />

Gas Cons. (insulated, hhv - mbh) 8,430 5,732 3,456 2,192<br />

Coefficient of Per<strong>for</strong>mance 1.00 1.11 1.22 1.16<br />

Capacity <strong>for</strong> rating (tons): 705.0 528.8 352.5 211.5<br />

EVAPORATOR<br />

Chilled Water Flow [GPM] 1054.8 1054.8 1054.8 1054.8<br />

Entering Water Temperature (ºF) 60.0 56.0 52.0 48.8<br />

Leaving Water Temperature (ºF) 44.0 44.0 44.0 44.0<br />

Fouling (hr ft 2 ºF/Btu) 0.00010 0.00010 0.00010 0.00010<br />

Chilled Water Range 16.00 12.00 8.00 4.80<br />

Tube Material<br />

Std. Cu<br />

ABSORBER/CONDENSER<br />

Cooling Water Flow [GPM] 2800.0 2800.0 2800.0 2800.0<br />

Entering Water Temperature (ºF) 85.0 77.5 70.0 70.0<br />

Leaving Water Temperature (ºF) 97.8 86.7 75.9 73.6<br />

Fouling (hr ft 2 ºF/Btu) 0.00025 0.00025 0.00025 0.00025<br />

Tube Material Absorber<br />

Std. Cu<br />

Tube Material Condenser<br />

Std. Cu<br />

IPLV = 1.162<br />

IPLV Calculations per ARI 560-2000<br />

Note 1: Absorber/Condenser Inlet Water Temperature is variable per ARI 560-2000.


Appendix E - ECM #6 Demand Response Controls -Page 6


Appendix E - ECM #6 Demand Response Controls -Page 7<br />

BURRIS ENGINEERS, INC.<br />

180 S. Main St, Suite 203<br />

Ambler, PA 19002<br />

(215) 643‐4465<br />

www.burrisengineers.com<br />

Demand Response Controls<br />

As requested, we reviewed the feasibility of using the existing utility meters to monitor electric usage and demand. The<br />

meters provided by PECO Energy, the electric utility currently serving the PCCA, do have the capability to provide output<br />

signals via “demand contacts.” These are devices that PECO will install <strong>for</strong> use with a customer-owned Energy<br />

Demand/Management System (such as Siemens, Andover, etc.). The output signal is not in<strong>for</strong>mation per se, but pulses that<br />

an Energy Demand/Management System would be able to interpret and use to track electrical usage throughout the day.<br />

The output would be transmitted over a two (2) wire twisted pair to the input of the Energy Demand/Management System.<br />

The pulse would provide kWH and an end of interval pulse, which could be used to sync up with PECO intervals, making<br />

direct comparison with PECO billing data possible.<br />

In speaking with a PECO employee about the topic of demand contacts installed on the existing meters, he stated that the<br />

process starts with the owner contacting their PECO Large Account Representative and requesting the demand contacts be<br />

installed. The contacts will be ordered, and PECO charges $1500 to $1800 <strong>for</strong> the contacts. There is currently a piece of<br />

equipment located at the meter location that may be a demand contacts device (based on the name on the cover) being used<br />

<strong>for</strong> PECO’s normal metering process. If this is correct, and the PCCA is able to tap into the existing demand contacts with<br />

PECO’s permission, the $1500 to $1800 <strong>for</strong> new demand contacts may not be needed. However, since BEI could not<br />

determine exactly what that piece of equipment is, we went with the conservative approach and assumed that demand<br />

contacts would need to be ordered.<br />

With the installation of an Energy Demand/Management System connected to a Building Automation System (BAS), data<br />

obtained from the existing meters can be used to make <strong>energy</strong>-related and operational decisions throughout the day.<br />

As a note, the PECO Representative in<strong>for</strong>med me that PECO will be rolling out a rebate program <strong>for</strong> <strong>energy</strong> conservation<br />

work in March of this year. He stated to take be<strong>for</strong>e and after pictures, save receipts, etc. in order to provide proof of work<br />

per<strong>for</strong>med. The rebate program will accept <strong>energy</strong> conservation work per<strong>for</strong>med back to July 2009.<br />

The estimated electrical cost <strong>for</strong> this ECM is $12,000, based on the following:<br />

1. 2 men/40 hours to install 1000’ ¾” EMT conduit (assumed distance from Main Electric Room where meters are<br />

located to Engineering Department Offices), pull conductors, terminate, etc. = $8000<br />

2. Conductor cost of two (2) #14AWG conductors x 1000’ x $0.315/ft = $630<br />

3. ¾” EMT @ $1/ft x 1000’ = $1000<br />

4. PECO Energy Demand Contact Charge = $1800<br />

5. $570 in miscellaneous material, junction boxes, etc.<br />

Figure 1 – PECO Energy Utility Metering Equipment located in Main Electric Room


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 1<br />

INTELLI-HOOD ENERGY ANALYSIS<br />

PROJECT:<br />

ADDRESS:<br />

APPLICATION:<br />

DATE:<br />

Concord Engineering - Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

1101 Arch St - Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority, <strong>Pennsylvania</strong> 19107<br />

Retrofit / Existing Building<br />

1/13/2010<br />

Total Energy Savings:<br />

Electrical Savings:<br />

Fan Energy Savings:<br />

Heating Savings:<br />

Cooling Savings:<br />

Net Installed Cost:<br />

Installed Cost:<br />

Other Adders & Deducts:<br />

$51,927<br />

/YEAR<br />

232,391 kWh/YEAR<br />

$17,666 /YEAR<br />

$26,131 /YEAR<br />

$8,130 /YEAR<br />

$102,190<br />

$102,190<br />

$0<br />

Payback Period:<br />

2.0<br />

YEARS<br />

Rate of Return:<br />

OVER 5 YEARS:<br />

OVER 10 YEARS:<br />

33%<br />

43%<br />

Environmental Savings:<br />

Current Uncontrolled Cost:<br />

311,404<br />

$117,622<br />

lb CO 2 /YEAR<br />

/YEAR<br />

The calculated savings shown above are based on the store's operating hours, estimated<br />

cooking load, local utility rates, and local climate data.<br />

Please refer to the attached analysis <strong>for</strong> details.<br />

The environmental savings were calculated based on data from the US EIA <strong>report</strong> from 2002.<br />

Melink Corporation<br />

5140 River Valley Road<br />

Mil<strong>for</strong>d, OH 45150


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 2<br />

FAN ENERGY SAVINGS<br />

PROJECT:<br />

Concord Engineering - Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

SITE:<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority, <strong>Pennsylvania</strong>DATE:<br />

1/13/2010<br />

INPUT DATA:<br />

A Operating Hours Per Day<br />

B Operating Days Per Week<br />

C Operating Weeks Per Year<br />

D Horsepower of Fan Motor(s)<br />

E Load Factor of Fan Motor(s)<br />

F Cost Per Kilowatt Hour<br />

CONSTANT EXHAUST VOLUME ANALYSIS:<br />

G Total Time (A x B x C)<br />

H Total KWHR/HP/YR (0.746/System Effic. x G)<br />

VARIABLE EXHAUST VOLUME ANALYSIS:<br />

18<br />

7<br />

52<br />

48.4<br />

0.90<br />

$0.11<br />

6552<br />

5430.9<br />

HRS/DAY<br />

DAYS/WK<br />

WKS/YR<br />

HP<br />

$/KWHR<br />

HRS/YR<br />

KWHR/HP/YR<br />

% Rated % Run Time Output System Input<br />

KWHR/<br />

RPM<br />

H<br />

100%<br />

90%<br />

Time<br />

I<br />

10%<br />

10%<br />

HRS/YR<br />

J=FxI<br />

655.2<br />

655.2<br />

KW/HP<br />

K<br />

0.746<br />

0.544<br />

Effic.<br />

L<br />

0.9<br />

0.9<br />

KW/HP<br />

M=K/L<br />

0.829<br />

0.604<br />

HP/YR<br />

N=JxM<br />

543.1<br />

395.9<br />

80% 10% 655.2 0.382 0.9 0.424<br />

278.1<br />

70% 10% 655.2 0.256 0.9 0.284<br />

186.3<br />

60% 10% 655.2 0.161 0.9 0.179<br />

117.3<br />

50% 25% 1638 0.093 0.9 0.104<br />

169.7<br />

40% 25% 1638 0.048 0.9 0.053<br />

86.9<br />

30% 0% 0 0.020 0.9 0.022<br />

0.0<br />

20%<br />

0%<br />

0<br />

0.006<br />

0.9<br />

0.007<br />

0.0<br />

10% 0% 0 0.001 0.9 0.001<br />

0.0<br />

O Total KWH/HP/YR (Total of Column N)<br />

1777.3<br />

CALCULATION:<br />

(H - O) x D x E x F<br />

UNCONTROLLED COST =<br />

$26,259<br />

SAVINGS =<br />

159,152<br />

$17,666<br />

/YEAR<br />

kWh/YEAR<br />

/YEAR


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 3<br />

HEATING SAVINGS<br />

PROJECT: Concord Engineering - Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

SITE: Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority, <strong>Pennsylvania</strong>DATE:<br />

1/13/2010<br />

INPUT DATA:<br />

A Previous Net Exhaust Volume<br />

B New Net Exhaust Volume (1)<br />

C Winter Building Temperature<br />

D Previous Net Heat Load (2)<br />

E New Net Heat Load (2)<br />

F Operating Hours Per Day<br />

G Operating Days Per Week<br />

H Cost Per Fuel Unit (3)<br />

I Heating Fuel Type<br />

J BTU Per Fuel Unit (4)<br />

K System Efficiency (4)<br />

L Supply Air Heating Multiplier (5)<br />

50759<br />

CFM<br />

31724 CFM<br />

65 F<br />

5,877,522 kBTU<br />

3,673,451 kBTU<br />

18 HRS/DAY<br />

7 DAYS/WK<br />

$1.48<br />

$/UNIT<br />

Natural Gas<br />

100 kBTU/UNIT<br />

1.0<br />

0.80<br />

CALCULATION: (D-E) x L x H / (J x K)<br />

SAVINGS =<br />

1,763,257<br />

$26,131<br />

kBTU/YEAR<br />

/YEAR<br />

CALCULATION: D x L x H / (J x K)<br />

UNCONTROLLED COST =<br />

$69,684<br />

/YEAR<br />

NOTES:<br />

(1) Determine the New Exhaust<br />

Volume by completing TABLE 1.<br />

The New Exhaust Volume equals<br />

the AVG % RPM x the Previous<br />

Exhaust Volume.<br />

% Rated<br />

RPM (F)<br />

100%<br />

TABLE 1<br />

% Run<br />

Time (I)<br />

10%<br />

F x I<br />

10%<br />

90% 10% 9%<br />

(2) Using design weather data<br />

80% 10% 8%<br />

via the Outdoor Airload Calculator<br />

70% 10% 7%<br />

and multiplied by days/year ratio.<br />

60% 10% 6%<br />

50% 25% 13%<br />

(3) Using local <strong>energy</strong> costs.<br />

40% 25% 10%<br />

(4) Using typical system<br />

efficiency.<br />

30%<br />

0%<br />

0%<br />

20% 0% 0%<br />

10% 0% 0%<br />

(5) Estimation Factor AVG % RPM = 63%


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 4<br />

COOLING SAVINGS<br />

PROJECT:<br />

Concord Engineering - Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

SITE: Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority, <strong>Pennsylvania</strong>DATE:<br />

1/13/2010<br />

INPUT DATA:<br />

A Previous Net Exhaust Volume<br />

50759 CFM<br />

B New Net Exhaust Volume (1)<br />

31724 CFM<br />

C Previous Net Cooling Load (2)<br />

2,499,646 kBTU<br />

D New Net Cooling Load (2)<br />

1,562,279 kBTU<br />

E AC Correction Factor (3)<br />

F Cost Per Fuel Unit (5)<br />

1<br />

0.111 $/kWH<br />

G COP (6)<br />

3<br />

H Supply Air Cooling Multiplier (7)<br />

0.80<br />

CALCULATION:<br />

(C - D) x H x E x F / (3.413 x G)<br />

SAVINGS =<br />

73,239<br />

$8,130<br />

kWh/YEAR<br />

/YEAR<br />

CALCULATION:<br />

C x H x E x F / (3.413 x G)<br />

UNCONTROLLED COST =<br />

NOTES:<br />

$21,679<br />

/YEAR<br />

(1) Using New Exhaust Volume from CONDITIONED MAKE-UP AIR<br />

SAVINGS - HEATING on page 2. See Note 1.<br />

(2) Obtained from Outdoor Airload Calculator<br />

(3) Using design weather data.<br />

(4) The multiplier corrects <strong>for</strong> actual % outside air.<br />

(5) Using local <strong>energy</strong> costs.<br />

(6) Using typical system efficiency.<br />

(7) Using cooling supply air factor.


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 5<br />

CASH FLOW ANALYSIS<br />

PROJECT: Concord Engineering - Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

SITE: Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority, <strong>Pennsylvania</strong>DATE:<br />

1/13/2010<br />

INPUT DATA:<br />

FIRST YEAR SAVINGS<br />

$51,927<br />

/YEAR<br />

INITIAL COST PLUS INSTALLATION $102,190<br />

MARGINAL TAX RATE<br />

34%<br />

ESTIMATED ANNUAL INCREASE IN ENERGY COSTS 6%<br />

YEAR<br />

SAVINGS<br />

COST<br />

DEPREC.<br />

%<br />

DEPREC.<br />

$<br />

NET<br />

AFTER-TAX<br />

CASH FLOW<br />

0<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

-$102,190<br />

-$102,190<br />

$51,927<br />

$55,042<br />

$58,345<br />

$61,846<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

20.00<br />

32.00<br />

19.20<br />

11.50<br />

$20,438<br />

$32,701<br />

$19,621<br />

$11,752<br />

$41,221<br />

$47,446<br />

$45,179<br />

$44,814<br />

$65,556 - 11.50 $11,752<br />

$47,263<br />

$69,490<br />

$73,659<br />

-<br />

-<br />

5.80 $5,927<br />

$47,878<br />

$48,615<br />

$78,079 - $51,532<br />

$82,764 -<br />

$54,624<br />

$87,729 -<br />

$57,901<br />

CALCULATIONS:<br />

NET PRESENT VALUE =<br />

$53,476<br />

INTERNAL RATE<br />

5 YEARS @ 12% OF RETURN (IRR) =<br />

NET PRESENT VALUE = $147,584<br />

INTERNAL RATE<br />

10 YEARS @ 12% OF RETURN (IRR) =<br />

33.3%<br />

43.1%<br />

NOTES:<br />

Net After-tax Cash Flow is calculated as follows:<br />

NATCF = SAVINGS - COSTS - TAX RATE(SAVINGS - COSTS - DEPRECIATION)<br />

Net Present Value is calculated as follows:<br />

NPV = C(0) + C(1)/(1 + r) + C(2)/(1 + r)^2 + ... + C(n)/(1 + r)^n<br />

(where C(n) is the net cash flow <strong>for</strong> the nth year and r is the opportunity cost of capital)<br />

IRR is calculated by trial and error using the <strong>for</strong>mula:<br />

NPV = C(0) + C(1)/(1 + IRR) + C(2)/(1 + IRR)^2 + ... + C(n)/(1 + IRR)^n<br />

Depreciation is calculated using the 5-year MACRS schedule


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 6<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority Graphical Summary<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority Estimated<br />

$8,130<br />

$26,131<br />

$17,666<br />

Fan<br />

Cooling<br />

Heating<br />

311,404<br />

LBS. of CO 2 SAVED<br />

311,404<br />

Total Estimated Annual Energy Savings:<br />

$51,927<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority Estimated Average Fan Profile<br />

25%<br />

% Time Running at Speed<br />

20%<br />

15%<br />

10%<br />

5%<br />

0%<br />

30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%<br />

% Fan Speed<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority Estimated Average Fan Speed: 63%


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 7<br />

PROPOSAL # 51971<br />

Proposal Date: 01/12/2010<br />

Expiration Date: 04/12/2010<br />

Page: 1 of 4<br />

Proposal To:<br />

Concord Engineering<br />

520 S. Burnt Mill Rd<br />

Voorhees NJ 08043<br />

USA<br />

Ship To:<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

1101 Arch St<br />

Philadelphia PA 19107<br />

USA<br />

Contact Name: Concept Name: Terms:<br />

Raymond Scelfo Misc, Inst Corp 2% 10, Net 30 Days<br />

Ship Via: Final Destination: Sales Person:<br />

Philadelphia Co _ Philadelphia PA 19107<br />

Burpee, Jeff<br />

Item No. Description Qty Unit Price Extended Price<br />

Melink Corporation IntelliHood Quote: Concord Engineering - Philadelphia<br />

<strong>Convention</strong> Authority.<br />

BUDGETARY QUOTE!<br />

NOTE: This is an Intelli-Hood BUDGETARY Proposal. A <strong>for</strong>mal site survey or<br />

final drawing package review, by an authorized entity, will be required to<br />

validate the financial and contractual terms of this project.<br />

System 1: Kitchen One. 7 Hoods in Total<br />

IH2-System IH2 System Template 1<br />

IOP2-RA IH2 - I/O Processor, Std 4-Channel, Painted Enclosure, Modem, Analog 2 $ 1,980.75 $ 3,961.50<br />

KPD2-PHP IH2 - Keypad (customer service number on label) 2 $ 338.20 $ 676.40<br />

442H056 Box, Weatherproof, 4x4 2 $ 20.43 $ 40.86<br />

442H057 Extension, Box, Weatherproof, 4x4 2 $ 14.73 $ 29.46<br />

CBL2-050 IH2 - 50' Cable 2 $ 85.50 $ 171.00<br />

PF400-B440 IH2 - VFD, AB, 40HP, **460V/3** - Bypass, Basic PF400 1 $ 9,107.65 $ 9,107.65<br />

CBL2-015 IH2 - 15' Cable 2 $ 34.20 $ 68.40<br />

IH2-Hood Intelli-Hood 2 Hood Template 1<br />

TMP2-QS IH2 - Exhaust Temp Sensor - Quick Seal Mount 13 $ 103.55 $ 1,346.15<br />

CBL2-015 IH2 - 15' Cable 8 $ 34.20 $ 273.60<br />

CBL2-TYA IH2- Temperature "Y" and Junction Box 6 $ 108.30 $ 649.80<br />

OSS2-28 IH2 - Optic Sensor Set with 28" Purge Pipes 7 $ 1,216.00 $ 8,512.00<br />

CBL2-030 IH2 - 30' Cable 6 $ 51.30 $ 307.80<br />

CBL2-050 IH2 - 50' Cable 7 $ 85.50 $ 598.50<br />

2013 IH PRE-INSTALL SITE COORDINATION 1 $ 1,350.00 $ 1,350.00<br />

2003 IH INSTALL - Per<strong>for</strong>m installation of demand ventilation controls <strong>for</strong> kitchen 1 $ 10,340.00 $ 10,340.00<br />

2004 IH SU - Per<strong>for</strong>m start up of demand ventilation controls <strong>for</strong> kitchen. 1 $ 2,650.00 $ 2,650.00<br />

2014 IH PROGRAM MANAGEMENT 1 $ 1,250.00 $ 1,250.00<br />

2016 IH CONTRACTOR-PROVIDED SERVICE 1 $ 7,500.00 $ 7,500.00<br />

Subtotal $ 48,833.12<br />

System 2: Kitchen Two. 8 Hoods in Total.<br />

IH2-System IH2 System Template 1


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 8<br />

PROPOSAL # 51971<br />

Proposal Date: 01/12/2010<br />

Expiration Date: 04/12/2010<br />

Page: 2 of 4<br />

Proposal To:<br />

Concord Engineering<br />

520 S. Burnt Mill Rd<br />

Voorhees NJ 08043<br />

USA<br />

Ship To:<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

1101 Arch St<br />

Philadelphia PA 19107<br />

USA<br />

Contact Name: Concept Name: Terms:<br />

Raymond Scelfo Misc, Inst Corp 2% 10, Net 30 Days<br />

Ship Via: Final Destination: Sales Person:<br />

Philadelphia Co _ Philadelphia PA 19107<br />

Burpee, Jeff<br />

Item No. Description Qty Unit Price Extended Price<br />

IOP2-RA IH2 - I/O Processor, Std 4-Channel, Painted Enclosure, Modem, Analog 2 $ 1,980.75 $ 3,961.50<br />

KPD2-PHP IH2 - Keypad (customer service number on label) 2 $ 338.20 $ 676.40<br />

442H056 Box, Weatherproof, 4x4 2 $ 20.43 $ 40.86<br />

442H057 Extension, Box, Weatherproof, 4x4 2 $ 14.73 $ 29.46<br />

CBL2-050 IH2 - 50' Cable 2 $ 85.50 $ 171.00<br />

PF400-B415 IH2 - VFD, AB, 15HP, **460V/3** - Bypass, Basic PF400 2 $ 4,565.70 $ 9,131.40<br />

IH2-Hood Intelli-Hood 2 Hood Template 1<br />

TMP2-QS IH2 - Exhaust Temp Sensor - Quick Seal Mount 16 $ 103.55 $ 1,656.80<br />

CBL2-015 IH2 - 15' Cable 10 $ 34.20 $ 342.00<br />

CBL2-005 IH2 - 5' Cable 8 $ 24.70 $ 197.60<br />

CBL2-TYA IH2- Temperature "Y" and Junction Box 8 $ 108.30 $ 866.40<br />

OSS2-28 IH2 - Optic Sensor Set with 28" Purge Pipes 8 $ 1,216.00 $ 9,728.00<br />

CBL2-030 IH2 - 30' Cable 9 $ 51.30 $ 461.70<br />

CBL2-050 IH2 - 50' Cable 8 $ 85.50 $ 684.00<br />

2013 IH PRE-INSTALL SITE COORDINATION 1 $ 1,350.00 $ 1,350.00<br />

2003 IH INSTALL - Per<strong>for</strong>m installation of demand ventilation controls <strong>for</strong> kitchen 1 $ 11,460.00 $ 11,460.00<br />

2004 IH SU - Per<strong>for</strong>m start up of demand ventilation controls <strong>for</strong> kitchen. 1 $ 2,650.00 $ 2,650.00<br />

2014 IH PROGRAM MANAGEMENT 1 $ 1,250.00 $ 1,250.00<br />

2016 IH CONTRACTOR-PROVIDED SERVICE 1 $ 7,500.00 $ 7,500.00<br />

Subtotal $ 52,157.12<br />

INSTALLATION, ELECTRICAL: Per<strong>for</strong>med by site recommended, local<br />

electrician<br />

* A budgetary proposal number is included as part of the Melink Proposal<br />

* Includes the mounting and wiring of VFD(s) Operator Interface(s), and<br />

Processor(s)<br />

* May also include the Cat5 run from processor(s) to VFD(s)<br />

* Does not include ceiling or floor penetrations<br />

(See contractor’s documentation <strong>for</strong> all relevant terms & conditions of this<br />

service)<br />

MOTOR DISCLAIMER:<br />

* All motors must be 3 phase, inverter duty rated as specified in NEMA<br />

standard MG 1 Part 31<br />

* A separate conduit run is required from each VFD location to its associated<br />

fan


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 9<br />

PROPOSAL # 51971<br />

Proposal Date: 01/12/2010<br />

Expiration Date: 04/12/2010<br />

Page: 3 of 4<br />

Proposal To:<br />

Concord Engineering<br />

520 S. Burnt Mill Rd<br />

Voorhees NJ 08043<br />

USA<br />

Ship To:<br />

Philadelphia <strong>Convention</strong> Authority<br />

1101 Arch St<br />

Philadelphia PA 19107<br />

USA<br />

Contact Name: Concept Name: Terms:<br />

Raymond Scelfo Misc, Inst Corp 2% 10, Net 30 Days<br />

Ship Via: Final Destination: Sales Person:<br />

Philadelphia Co _ Philadelphia PA 19107<br />

Burpee, Jeff<br />

Item No. Description Qty Unit Price Extended Price<br />

* All incoming power must be noise free<br />

Acceptance of this Purchase Order binds the above-named company to the<br />

Scope of Work defined in following project document(s):<br />

Drawing/Revision Date:<br />

Any deviation from the documented scope of work must be approved in writing<br />

by a duly authorized employee of Melink Corporation.<br />

Freight 1,200.00<br />

Prepared By:<br />

Jeffrey Burpee Phone: 513-965-7328 Fax: 513-965-7350 email: jburpee@melinkcorp.com<br />

TOTAL: $ 102,190.24<br />

Melink Corporation 5140 River Valley Road Mil<strong>for</strong>d, Ohio 45150 P: 513-965-7300 F: 513-965-7350 www.melinkcorp.com<br />

Please sign, date, and enter your PO number to accept this proposal and the attached terms and conditions.<br />

Signature:_______________________ Printed Name: ______________________ P.O. #: __________ Date: _________


Appendix E - ECM #7 Kitchen Exhaust Controls -Page 10<br />

PROPOSAL # 51971<br />

TERMS AND CONDITION OF SALE<br />

Proposal Date: 01/12/2010<br />

Expiration Date: 04/12/2010<br />

Page: 4 of 4<br />

Price:<br />

The price quoted in the proposal <strong>for</strong> the products or services is based on the customer supplied in<strong>for</strong>mation at the time of the proposal and is contingent on the site being completely <strong>prepared</strong> <strong>for</strong> the service on the scheduled date according to the Melink<br />

provided Confirmation Checklist. If the site is not completely <strong>prepared</strong> and Melink Corporation must make any additional visits, the customer assumes responsibility and may be subject to charges <strong>for</strong> each additional visit at $150 per hour plus travel expenses,<br />

with a minimum charge of $1,250 per visit. Melink Corporation reserves the right to change the price quoted if it is deemed necessary due to inaccurate in<strong>for</strong>mation or after 90 days from the proposal date. Price applies to the continental U.S. unless otherwise<br />

noted.<br />

Taxes:<br />

Sales tax is not included in the proposal. Sales or other tax or duty Melink Corporation is required to collect upon sale of the merchandise quoted will be applied to the final invoice if proper exemption <strong>for</strong>m is not provided by the customer.<br />

Credit:<br />

All sales are subject to the approval of Melink Corporation credit department. Credit decisions will be based upon credit bureau <strong>report</strong>s and/or external credit references. In the event that credit is denied, advance payment will be required.<br />

Payment:<br />

Payment is due in full 30 days from invoice date and customer may discount invoice amount by 2% if payment is made within 10 days of the invoice date unless otherwise specified on the proposal. All payments shall be sent to: Melink Corporation PO Box<br />

643608, Cincinnati, OH 45264. All invoices not paid within the specified terms may be subject to finance charges of 1.5% per month, credit hold, and/or delay of shipments or services. For all past due accounts Melink Corporation reserves the right to <strong>for</strong>ward<br />

the customer account to an attorney or third party collection agency to receive payment. In the event that the account is turned over to an attorney or third party collection agency, the customer agrees to pay all attorney or collection fees and court costs<br />

incurred.<br />

Delivery:<br />

Product will be shipped via UPS Ground no less than two weeks from the date of Melink Corporation’s acceptance of the customer’s purchase order and receipt of all specifications. Requests <strong>for</strong> delivery of less than two weeks may be subject to Quick Ship<br />

Service Charge not to exceed 5% of the price of the quoted product in addition to UPS Air Freight Charges. If an estimate of time of shipment or delivery has been made in a proposal, it is to be understood that it is approximate only and will begin on the date of<br />

Melink Corporation’s acceptance of the customer’s purchase order and receipt of all specifications; except that in the case of special items considered to be non-standard by Melink Corporation, it will begin on the date which Melink Corporation receives<br />

complete in<strong>for</strong>mation necessary to design and manufacture.<br />

All products are shipped F.O.B., point of shipment. Risk of loss shall transfer to the customer upon tender of goods to the customer, customer representative, or common carrier. The cost of any special packaging or handling caused by the customer’s<br />

requirements or requests shall be added to the amount of the order. If the customer causes or requests a shipment delay, or if Melink Corporation ships or delivers the products erroneously as a result of inaccurate, incomplete or misleading in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

supplied by the customer or its agents or employees, storage and all other additional costs and risks shall be borne solely by the customer. Claims <strong>for</strong> products damaged or lost in transit should be made by the customer to the carrier, as Melink Corporation’s<br />

responsibility ceases upon tender of goods to the customer, customer's representative or common carrier.<br />

Substitutions and Modifications:<br />

Melink Corporation reserves the right to substitute or change materials, parts, product specifications or functional attributes at any time without notice. Melink Corporation also reserves the right to ship product in multiple boxes and/or shipments.<br />

Material Warranty:<br />

Melink Corporation warrants that Melink products shall be free from original defects in workmanship and material <strong>for</strong> three years from the date of shipment provided product has been properly stored, installed, operated, maintained, and serviced. This warranty<br />

does not apply to products which have been subjected to misuse, negligence, accident, or altered or repaired in any way without expressed written authorization from Melink Corporation. The customer assumes responsibility <strong>for</strong> all risks and liabilities<br />

resulting from the use of these products. Melink Corporation is not responsible <strong>for</strong> the cost of removal of the product, damages due to removal, or any expenses incurred in shipping or installation of repaired or replaced product.<br />

Service Warranty:<br />

Melink Corporation warrants the quality of its work. If the customer suspects any deficiency with our work, Melink Corporation will investigate within five business days of receipt of written notification. If it is determined that the deficiency is due to something other<br />

than Melink Corporation’s work, including but not limited to unaddressed punch list items, poor maintenance, routine wear and tear, or manufacturer defect, the customer assumes responsibility and may be subject to charges <strong>for</strong> additional visits at $150 per<br />

hour plus travel expenses, with a minimum charge of $1,250 per visit.<br />

Intellectual Property:<br />

Melink Corporation will take every reasonable ef<strong>for</strong>t to protect the intellectual property rights of its customers. Melink Corporation will not knowingly disclose any design, equipment, installation, or other best practice in<strong>for</strong>mation that may be specific to a particular<br />

customer. Industry norms and trends not specific to the customer are not considered proprietary.<br />

The customer will have all proprietary rights to the data contained in any <strong>report</strong> generated by Melink Corporation as a result of an agreed service contract. Reports will only be distributed to the customer and their approved affiliates, partners, and suppliers.<br />

Melink Corporation will also maintain the minimum number of copies <strong>for</strong> internal records to facilitate communications with the customer and to assist with any future service contracts. The proprietary rights <strong>for</strong> all <strong>report</strong>s will survive as long as the customer<br />

remains a going concern. The proprietary rights do not include the native file or software used to gather the data or generate the <strong>report</strong>.<br />

Cancelation:<br />

The customer may cancel this contract upon written notice to Melink Corporation and only upon such terms as will indemnify and reimburse Melink Corporation <strong>for</strong> all loss or damage resulting from, plus Melink Corporation’s direct costs incurred, overhead,<br />

reasonable profits, costs and expenses to which Melink Corporation has become committed <strong>for</strong> fulfillment of the contract prior to cancellation.<br />

Recommendation Disclaimer:<br />

Melink Corporation may provide HVAC equipment size recommendations based on benchmark data provided by the customer and the industry at large. Such recommendations are not meant to substitute load calculations or other engineering analysis that<br />

might be required. In addition, the customer is responsible <strong>for</strong> confirming structural, electrical, and plumbing requirements to support any equipment recommendations.<br />

Liability and Responsibility:<br />

Melink Corporation assumes no liability or responsibility <strong>for</strong> any acts, misuse of product, advertising, or violations of any local, state or federal regulations or laws violated by the customer. The customer assumes all responsibility <strong>for</strong> his/her acts and is<br />

responsible <strong>for</strong> researching local, state or federal regulations relating to the sale or use of Melink Corporation’s products.<br />

Severability:<br />

The parties agree that each provision contained in these Terms and Conditions of Sale shall be treated as separate and independent clause, and the unen<strong>for</strong>ceability of any one clause shall in no way impair the en<strong>for</strong>ceability of any of the other clauses herein.<br />

Moreover, if one or more of the provisions contained in these Terms and Conditions of Sale shall <strong>for</strong> any reason be held to be excessively broad as to scope, activity or subject so as to be en<strong>for</strong>ceable at all, such provision or provisions shall be construed by<br />

the appropriate judicial body by limiting and reducing it or them, so as to be en<strong>for</strong>ceable to the extent compatible with the applicable law.<br />

Modification:<br />

The Terms and Conditions of Sale set <strong>for</strong>th herein may be accepted only in accordance with their terms. They may not be modified except by written agreement referring specifically to these Terms and Conditions of Sale and signed by a duly authorized<br />

representative of Melink Corporation. Any provisions of the customer’s purchase order, which is inconsistent with the <strong>for</strong>egoing, shall be of no <strong>for</strong>ce and effect.


Appendix E - ECM #8 VFD Domestic Water Booster Pump Package -Page 1<br />

ECM #8 - COST ESTIMATE SUMMARY<br />

DESCRIPTION MATERIALS LABOR QTY / % TOTAL<br />

1700 GPM Dom. Pump Package ($/Unit) $56,000 $13,500 1 $69,500<br />

Controls $3,000 1 $3,000<br />

Pump Electrical Work $3,850 $4,875 1 $8,725<br />

Construction Extras (Equipment Lift, Site Work) $5,000 1 $5,000<br />

Subtotal $86,225<br />

Engineering 10% $8,623<br />

Insurance 10% $8,623<br />

Permitting 5% $4,311<br />

TOTAL $107,781


Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 1<br />

MONTHLY ENERGY CONSUMPTION<br />

By Concord Engineering Group<br />

------- Monthly Energy Consumption -------<br />

Utility Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total<br />

Alternative: 1<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - Baseline<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 555,198 648,625 592,398 573,242 679,755 298,645 376,720 283,581 566,594 589,188 566,734 450,804 6,181,485<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 930,068 900,474 810,514 863,006 839,001 741,771 822,134 752,416 872,805 879,114 881,715 793,551 10,086,567<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,085 2,969 3,033 2,550 3,786 4,809 5,975 5,008 4,320 2,700 2,599 2,366 5,975<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,163 3,440 3,213 3,085 3,953 4,279 6,142 4,554 3,731 2,950 3,301 2,370 6,142<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 61,191 90,018 19,668 19,412 17,891 19,519 28,076 16,619 22,514 20,431 27,109 86,014 428,463<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 290 383 185 143 84 81 84 81 93 135 198 220<br />

383<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 180 1,796 1,434 2,372 1,368 1,663 365 157 0<br />

9,334<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 96,450 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 35,053,804 lbm/year<br />

Source 207,556 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 271,015 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

54,474 gm/year<br />

Alternative: 2<br />

Ice Storage<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 555,198 648,625 592,398 550,994 653,860 250,191 311,763 222,721 509,818 559,707 543,712 450,804 5,849,793<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 943,249 912,394 825,022 916,793 936,093 848,419 923,906 859,730 970,378 961,648 931,051 806,112 10,834,795<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,085 2,969 3,033 2,381 3,763 4,561 5,434 4,613 3,863 2,660 2,437 2,366 5,434<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,163 3,440 3,213 3,085 3,953 4,752 6,277 4,874 4,168 2,950 3,301 2,743 6,277<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 61,191 90,018 19,668 17,326 15,850 11,707 28,944 9,970 23,978 16,056 25,153 86,014 405,874<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 290 383 185 143 84 79 84 84 93 135 198 220<br />

383<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 35 32 39 242 1,801 1,315 2,450 1,324 1,767 402 210 34<br />

9,650<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 95,629 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 34,755,476 lbm/year<br />

Source 209,407 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 268,708 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

54,010 gm/year<br />

Savings<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 0 0 0 22,248 25,895 48,454 64,957 60,860 56,777 29,481 23,021 0 331,693<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) -13,181 -11,920 -14,508 -53,786 -97,092 -106,648 -101,772 -107,315 -97,573 -82,535 -49,336 -12,561 -748,228<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 0 0 0 170 22 249 541 395 457 41 162 0<br />

541<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 0 0 0 0 0 -473 -135 -320 -436 0 0 -372<br />

-473<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 0 0 0 2,086 2,041 7,812 -868 6,650 -1,464 4,376 1,956 0<br />

22,588<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

2


Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 2<br />

ECM ENERGY SAVINGS<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Month<br />

On Peak Off Peak Metered Billed<br />

Use Use Demand Demand<br />

KWH KWH KW KW<br />

Jan 0 -13,181 0.0 3,798.4<br />

Feb 0 -11,920 0.0 3,798.4<br />

Mar 0 -14,508 0.0 3,798.4<br />

Apr 22,248 -53,786 170.0 3,798.4<br />

May 25,895 -97,092 22.0 3,798.4<br />

Jun 48,454 -106,648 249.0 3,798.4<br />

Jul 64,957 -101,722 541.0 3,798.4<br />

Aug 60,860 -107,315 395.0 3,798.4<br />

Sep 56,777 -97,573 457.0 3,798.4<br />

Oct 29,481 -82,535 41.0 3,798.4<br />

Nov 23,021 -49,336 162.0 3,798.4<br />

Dec 0 -12,561 0.0 3,798.4<br />

Total 331,693 -748,177 541 3,798<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

On Peak Use Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,231.2 $171,384 $60,633 $0.101 403 37.3% 37.3% 25.5%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,565 $66,133 $0.110 355 42.3% 42.3% 15.4%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 522,462 838,766 3,690.0 4,231.2 $161,329 $60,633 $0.119 322 46.6% 46.6% 6.7%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 598,150 968,869 4,603.0 4,603.0 $178,097 $65,961 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.9%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 703,863 1,007,045 4,850.0 4,850.0 $192,215 $69,501 $0.112 353 42.5% 42.5% 15.0%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 758,086 1,159,560 5,289.0 5,289.0 $211,018 $75,791 $0.110 363 41.4% 41.4% 17.3%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 617,682 870,013 4,664.0 4,664.0 $179,857 $66,835 $0.121 319 47.0% 47.0% 5.9%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 612,934 918,926 3,787.0 4,231.2 $168,822 $60,633 $0.110 362 41.4% 41.4% 17.1%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 580,605 966,410 3,930.0 4,231.2 $166,911 $60,633 $0.108 366 41.0% 41.0% 17.9%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 561,816 1,049,996 3,893.0 4,231.2 $168,690 $60,633 $0.105 381 39.4% 39.4% 21.2%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 4,231.2 $160,951 $60,633 $0.119 320 46.9% 46.9% 6.1%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,325,940 11,941,591 5,289 5,289 $2,125,602 $773,737 $0.111 357 42% 42% 15%<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

BASELINE AVERAGE UTILITY HISTORY 2006 - 2008<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

On Peak Use Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

PROPOSED ECM COSTS<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,136,876 4,062.0 4,062.0 $166,967 $58,208 $0.097 423 35.5% 35.5% 29.0%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,180,901 4,586.0 4,586.0 $186,106 $65,717 $0.100 404 37.1% 37.1% 25.7%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,026,206 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,981 $66,133 $0.110 358 41.9% 41.9% 16.2%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 500,214 892,552 3,520.0 3,798.4 $149,873 $54,431 $0.108 367 40.9% 40.9% 18.2%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 572,255 1,065,961 4,581.0 4,581.0 $179,406 $65,646 $0.110 358 41.9% 41.9% 16.1%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 655,409 1,113,693 4,601.0 4,601.0 $186,446 $65,932 $0.105 385 39.0% 39.0% 22.0%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 693,129 1,261,282 4,748.0 4,748.0 $196,228 $68,039 $0.100 412 36.4% 36.4% 27.1%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 556,822 977,328 4,269.0 4,269.0 $169,515 $61,175 $0.110 359 41.7% 41.7% 16.5%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 556,157 1,016,499 3,330.0 3,798.4 $157,278 $54,431 $0.100 414 36.2% 36.2% 27.5%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 551,124 1,048,945 3,889.0 3,889.0 $158,609 $55,729 $0.099 411 36.5% 36.5% 27.1%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 538,795 1,099,332 3,731.0 3,798.4 $157,081 $54,431 $0.096 431 34.8% 34.8% 30.4%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 870,193 2,776.0 3,798.4 $149,045 $54,431 $0.109 359 41.7% 41.7% 16.5%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 6,994,247 12,689,768 4,748 4,748 $2,037,536 $724,304 $0.104 390 39% 39% 23%


Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 3<br />

ECM #9 - COST ESTIMATE SUMMARY<br />

DESCRIPTION MATERIALS LABOR QTY / % TOTAL<br />

325 Ton Chiller ($/Unit) $180,000 1 $180,000<br />

Brine Solution / Chiller Pump $10,900 $2,400 2 $26,600<br />

Brine Solution Piping & Fittings (6" Dia) $27 $53 600 $47,700<br />

Brine Solution Piping Insulation $11 $22 600 $19,500<br />

Plate & Frame HX $85,500 $10,000 1 $95,500<br />

Ice Storage Tanks $10,000 20 $200,000<br />

CHW Piping & Fittings (6" Dia) $27 $53 50 $3,975<br />

CHW Piping Insulation $11 $22 50 $1,625<br />

CW Pump $12,000 $2,500 2 $29,000<br />

CW Piping & Fittings (8" Dia) $39 $66 300 $31,500<br />

Controls $25,000 1 $25,000<br />

Chiller Electrical Work $34,844 $17,156 1 $52,000<br />

Pump Electrical Work $3,000 $3,725 2 $13,450<br />

Construction Extras (Equipment Lift, Site Work) $50,000 1 $50,000<br />

Subtotal $775,850<br />

Engineering 10% $77,585<br />

Insurance 10% $77,585<br />

Permitting 5% $38,793<br />

TOTAL $969,813


Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 4<br />

BURRIS ENGINEERS, INC.<br />

180 S. Main St, Suite 203<br />

Ambler, PA 19002<br />

(215) 643‐4465<br />

www.burrisengineers.com<br />

Supplemental Chiller Installation<br />

The installation of a new 450 Ton chiller is more involved then the boiler, but is feasible. Based on the<br />

provided equipment catalog cuts, the electrical requirements <strong>for</strong> this size chiller is 329kW maximum,<br />

with maximum running load amps (RLA) of 455A. Assuming 80% power factor as worst case scenario,<br />

this translates into 411.25kVA or 495A at 480 3PH. Based on the National Electrical Code (NEC)<br />

Article 430, the minimum conductor size is based on 125% of full load amps (FLA) as dictated by the<br />

FLA tables of the Article. The FLA in those tables is determined by the motor’s horsepower (HP).<br />

However, since the HP is not given in the catalog cuts, and since the chiller may fall under NEC Article<br />

440 (Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Equipment) which allows the use of manufacturer nameplate<br />

data, the size of the conductors and OCPD will be determined by the amps stated above based on<br />

calculated kVA.<br />

The minimum circuit conductor ampacity <strong>for</strong> the proposed chiller based on a FLA of 495A is 619A.<br />

This ampacity can be achieved by 2 sets of 350kcmil conductors per phase <strong>for</strong> a total ampacity of 620A.<br />

The maximum OCPD <strong>for</strong> the motor circuit based on the use of an inverse-time circuit breaker is 250%<br />

of FLA per NEC Table 430.52. There<strong>for</strong>e, the maximum OCPD would be 1238A circuit breaker.<br />

Rounding down to the next lower standard size breaker provides a 1200A circuit breaker.<br />

Substations #7 & #8, which are located above the mechanical penthouse’s main floor, have many spare<br />

cubicles that can accommodate a 1200A breaker. There are even spare 1200A breakers that were used<br />

<strong>for</strong> temporary installations. From interviewing PCCA staff, BEI believes that the temporary is no longer<br />

needed. There<strong>for</strong>e, we will assume that the existing 1200A spare breaker can be used <strong>for</strong> the proposed<br />

chiller installation. We also believe that there is plenty of electrical capacity on each substation to<br />

accommodate the new chiller based on the previous use of temporary 1200A feeders.<br />

The estimated electrical cost <strong>for</strong> this ECM is $52,000, based on the following:<br />

1. 2 men/40 hours to install (2) 3” EMT conduits (including junction boxes, pull rope, etc.) from<br />

Substation #7 or #8 (which is above the main floor of the mechanical penthouse) to main floor<br />

and prepare <strong>for</strong> cable pull = $8000. This assumes the existing ceiling penetrations below each<br />

substation are available <strong>for</strong> use.<br />

2. 3 men/16 hours to install conductors, splice in any junction boxes installed, and make<br />

terminations on either side of pull = $4800<br />

3. Six (6) conductors (350kcmil) x 200’ x $21.55/ft = $25,860<br />

4. Two (2) conductors (3/0kcmil Ground) x 200’ x $10.46/ft = $4184<br />

5. 3” EMT @ $12/ft x 400’ = $4800<br />

6. Installation of a meter = $1700<br />

7. $2656 in miscellaneous materials, including cleaning and preparing the existing 1200A breaker<br />

<strong>for</strong> re-use


Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 5<br />

Page 2 of 2<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> Energy Audit Project<br />

Electrical Engineering Report - Supplemental Chiller Installation<br />

Figure 1 – Spare 1200A Breaker and cubicles in Substation #7 (similar <strong>for</strong> Substation #8)<br />

Figure 2 – Ceiling Penetration below Substation #7 & Substation #8


Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 6


Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 7


1 of 2 1/27/2010 12:17 PM<br />

Off-Peak Cooling - ICEBANK Model C - Specifications and Drawings<br />

http://www.calmac.com/products/icebankc_specs.asp?print=1&<br />

Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 8<br />

CALMAC Manufacturing Corporation<br />

3-00 Banta Place<br />

Fair Lawn, NJ 07410 USA<br />

Ph: (201) 797-1511<br />

Fx: (201) 797-1522<br />

Off-Peak Cooling - ICEBANK Model C<br />

Specifications and Drawings<br />

TANK<br />

MODELS<br />

Drawings<br />

Net-Usable<br />

Capacity<br />

Ton-Hrs.<br />

(kWh)<br />

(i)<br />

Max.<br />

Operating<br />

Temp.,<br />

ºF (ºC)<br />

Factory<br />

Tested<br />

Pres.,<br />

psi (kPa)<br />

Max.<br />

Operating<br />

Pres.,<br />

psi (kPa)<br />

(ii)<br />

Dimensions<br />

(ODxH), in.<br />

Dimensions<br />

(WxLxH),<br />

in. (mm)<br />

(iii)<br />

Shipping<br />

Weight,<br />

lb (kg)<br />

(iv)<br />

Weight,<br />

Filled,<br />

lb (kg)<br />

Floor<br />

Loading,<br />

lb/sq.ft.,<br />

(kg/m ²)<br />

1082C 1098C 1105C 1190C 1320C 1500C<br />

View<br />

drawings:<br />

1082C2F<br />

1082C3F<br />

1082C4F,<br />

U4F<br />

Download<br />

CAD<br />

drawings:<br />

1082C2F<br />

1082C3F<br />

1082C4F<br />

1082CU4F<br />

82<br />

(288)<br />

100<br />

(38)<br />

250<br />

(1724)<br />

90<br />

(620)<br />

View<br />

drawings:<br />

1098C2F<br />

1098C3F<br />

1098C4F<br />

Download<br />

CAD<br />

drawings:<br />

1098C2F<br />

1098C3F<br />

1098C4F<br />

98<br />

(345)<br />

100<br />

(38)<br />

250<br />

(1724)<br />

90<br />

(620)<br />

View<br />

drawings:<br />

1105C2F<br />

1105C3F<br />

1105C4F,<br />

U4F<br />

Download CAD<br />

drawings:<br />

1105C2F<br />

1105C3F<br />

1105C4F<br />

1105CU4F<br />

105<br />

(369)<br />

100<br />

(38)<br />

250<br />

(1724)<br />

90<br />

(620)<br />

View<br />

drawings:<br />

1190C2F<br />

1190C3F<br />

1190C4F<br />

Download<br />

CAD<br />

drawings:<br />

1190C2F<br />

1190C3F<br />

1190C4F<br />

162<br />

(570)<br />

100<br />

(38)<br />

250<br />

(1724)<br />

90<br />

(620)<br />

View<br />

drawings:<br />

1320CSF<br />

1320CRF<br />

1320C4F<br />

Download<br />

CAD<br />

drawings:<br />

1320CSF<br />

1320CRF<br />

1320C4F<br />

324<br />

(1140)<br />

100<br />

(38)<br />

250<br />

(1724)<br />

90<br />

(620)<br />

View<br />

drawings:<br />

1500CSF<br />

1500CRF<br />

Download<br />

CAD<br />

drawings:<br />

1500CSF<br />

1500CRF<br />

486<br />

(1710)<br />

100<br />

(38)<br />

250<br />

(1724)<br />

-- -- -- -- -- --<br />

(2F)<br />

73¾ x 75 x 84½<br />

(1875 x 1900 x<br />

2140)<br />

(3F, 4F, U4F)<br />

73¾ x76½ x<br />

84½<br />

(1875 x 1940 x<br />

2140)<br />

1065<br />

(485)<br />

8580<br />

(3890)<br />

286<br />

(1396)<br />

(2F)<br />

89 x 91x 69½<br />

(2260 x 2310<br />

x 1765)<br />

(3F,4F)<br />

89 x 92 x 69½<br />

(2260 x 2340<br />

x 1765)<br />

1275<br />

(580)<br />

10,235<br />

(4645)<br />

237<br />

(1157)<br />

(2F)<br />

73¾ x 75 x 101<br />

(1875 x 1900 x<br />

2590)<br />

(3F, 4F, U4F)<br />

73¾ x 76½ x 102<br />

(1875 x 1940 x<br />

2590)<br />

1315<br />

(595)<br />

10,885<br />

(4935)<br />

363<br />

(1772)<br />

(2F)<br />

89 x 91x 102<br />

(2260 x 2310 x<br />

2590)<br />

(3F, 4F)<br />

89 x 92 x 102<br />

(2260 x 2340 x<br />

2590)<br />

2000<br />

(910)<br />

16,900<br />

(7665)<br />

391<br />

(1909)<br />

(SF)<br />

89 x 181 x 102<br />

(2260 x 4580 x<br />

2590)<br />

(RF)<br />

89 x 180 x 102<br />

(2260 x 4620 x<br />

2590)<br />

4000<br />

(1815)<br />

34,000<br />

(15,420)<br />

391<br />

(1909)<br />

90<br />

(620)<br />

(SF)<br />

89 x 270 x 102<br />

(2260 x 6860<br />

x 2590)<br />

(RF)<br />

89 x 273 x102<br />

(2260 x 6910<br />

x 2590)<br />

6000<br />

(2720)<br />

50,600<br />

(22,950)<br />

391<br />

(1909)


2 of 2 1/27/2010 12:17 PM<br />

Off-Peak Cooling - ICEBANK Model C - Specifications and Drawings<br />

http://www.calmac.com/products/icebankc_specs.asp?print=1&<br />

Appendix E - ECM #9 Chilled Water Thermal Ice Storage -Page 9<br />

Volume Of<br />

Water/Ice,<br />

Gal (l)<br />

Vol.<br />

Solution<br />

in HX,<br />

Gal (l)<br />

Inlet/Outlet<br />

Flange<br />

Connections.<br />

in.<br />

Total Burial<br />

Drawing<br />

820<br />

(3105)<br />

86<br />

(326)<br />

980<br />

(3710)<br />

90<br />

(341)<br />

1045<br />

(3955)<br />

99<br />

(375)<br />

1655<br />

(6265)<br />

157<br />

(594)<br />

3310<br />

(12,530)<br />

315<br />

(1192)<br />

4965<br />

(18,795)<br />

472<br />

(1787)<br />

4 4 4 4 4 4<br />

Full Burial Models 1190XC (2F, 3F, 4F); 1320XC & 1500XC (RF & SF)<br />

i. Typical value, actual varies with conditions<br />

ii. Consult factory <strong>for</strong> higher ratings<br />

iii. Tolerance <strong>for</strong> all dimensions is + 1/2" except "L" <strong>for</strong> Models 1500 and 1320 where + 1".<br />

iv. Shipping weight may vary slightly because of differences in volumes of residual water from hydrostatic test<br />

Partial Burial<br />

http://www.calmac.com/products/icebankc_specs.asp<br />

Copyright 2008 CALMAC Manufacturing Corp. All rights reserved


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 1<br />

MONTHLY ENERGY CONSUMPTION<br />

By Concord Engineering Group<br />

------- Monthly Energy Consumption -------<br />

Utility Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total<br />

Alternative: 1<br />

PA <strong>Convention</strong> <strong>Center</strong> - Baseline<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 555,198 648,625 592,398 573,242 679,755 298,645 376,720 283,581 566,594 589,188 566,734 450,804 6,181,485<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 930,068 900,474 810,514 863,006 839,001 741,771 822,134 752,416 872,805 879,114 881,715 793,551 10,086,567<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 3,085 2,969 3,033 2,550 3,786 4,809 5,975 5,008 4,320 2,700 2,599 2,366 5,975<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 3,163 3,440 3,213 3,085 3,953 4,279 6,142 4,554 3,731 2,950 3,301 2,370 6,142<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 61,191 90,018 19,668 19,412 17,891 19,519 28,076 16,619 22,514 20,431 27,109 86,014 428,463<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 290 383 185 143 84 81 84 81 93 135 198 220<br />

383<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 0 180 1,796 1,434 2,372 1,368 1,663 365 157 0<br />

9,334<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 96,450 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 35,053,804 lbm/year<br />

Source 207,556 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 271,015 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

54,474 gm/year<br />

Alternative: 2<br />

Demand Control Ventilation<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 507,015 586,998 549,232 539,009 631,708 281,958 290,376 271,121 509,227 542,258 525,292 403,008 5,637,202<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 872,275 826,456 763,180 819,990 830,427 712,608 726,893 716,151 811,438 840,626 838,807 732,813 9,491,664<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 2,648 2,709 2,654 2,461 3,619 4,535 5,155 4,861 4,202 3,124 2,512 2,216 5,155<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 2,864 3,082 2,909 2,872 3,872 3,751 5,194 4,256 3,912 2,827 3,129 2,162 5,194<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 33,618 40,138 14,125 8,586 16,480 18,372 28,180 15,629 22,939 12,650 13,622 22,208 246,545<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 153 193 124 80 78 83 84 78 82 85 91 93<br />

193<br />

Water<br />

Cons. (1000gal) 0 0 4 241 1,783 1,348 1,946 1,256 1,614 468 209 0<br />

8,869<br />

Energy Consumption<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis<br />

Building 74,801 Btu/(ft2-year) CO2 27,185,686 lbm/year<br />

Source 177,343 Btu/(ft2-year) SO2 210,183 gm/year<br />

Floor Area 1,019,900 ft2<br />

NOX<br />

42,247 gm/year<br />

Savings<br />

Electric<br />

On-Pk Cons. (kWh) 48,183 61,628 43,166 34,232 48,047 16,686 86,344 12,460 57,368 46,930 41,442 47,796 544,283<br />

Off-Pk Cons. (kWh) 57,793 74,017 47,334 43,017 8,573 29,163 95,241 36,265 61,367 38,488 42,908 60,738 594,904<br />

On-Pk Demand (kW) 437 260 380 89 167 275 820 148 118 -424 87 150<br />

820<br />

Off-Pk Demand (kW) 299 358 304 213 80 528 948 298 -181 123 172 209<br />

948<br />

Gas<br />

On-Pk Cons. (therms) 27,573 49,880 5,544 10,826 1,411 1,147 -104 990 -425 7,781 13,487 63,806 181,917<br />

On-Pk Demand (therms/hr) 137 190 61 62 5 -3 0 0 11 50 107 127<br />

190


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 2<br />

ECM ENERGY SAVINGS<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Month<br />

On Peak Off Peak Metered Billed<br />

Use Use Demand Demand<br />

KWH KWH KW KW<br />

Jan 48,183 57,793 437.0 3,660.0<br />

Feb 61,628 74,017 260.0 3,660.0<br />

Mar 43,166 47,334 380.0 3,660.0<br />

Apr 34,232 43,017 89.0 3,660.0<br />

May 48,047 8,573 167.0 3,660.0<br />

Jun 16,686 29,163 275.0 3,660.0<br />

Jul 86,344 95,241 820.0 3,660.0<br />

Aug 12,460 36,265 148.0 3,660.0<br />

Sep 57,368 61,367 118.0 3,660.0<br />

Oct 46,930 38,488 -424.0 3,660.0<br />

Nov 41,442 42,908 87.0 3,660.0<br />

Dec 47,796 60,738 150.0 3,660.0<br />

Total 544,282 594,904 820 3,660<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

On Peak<br />

Use<br />

Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 579,366 1,123,695 4,062.0 4,231.2 $171,384 $60,633 $0.101 403 37.3% 37.3% 25.5%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 671,022 1,168,981 4,586.0 4,586.0 $185,764 $65,717 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 625,365 1,011,698 4,615.0 4,615.0 $180,565 $66,133 $0.110 355 42.3% 42.3% 15.4%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 522,462 838,766 3,690.0 4,231.2 $161,329 $60,633 $0.119 322 46.6% 46.6% 6.7%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 598,150 968,869 4,603.0 4,603.0 $178,097 $65,961 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.9%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 703,863 1,007,045 4,850.0 4,850.0 $192,215 $69,501 $0.112 353 42.5% 42.5% 15.0%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 758,086 1,159,560 5,289.0 5,289.0 $211,018 $75,791 $0.110 363 41.4% 41.4% 17.3%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 617,682 870,013 4,664.0 4,664.0 $179,857 $66,835 $0.121 319 47.0% 47.0% 5.9%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 612,934 918,926 3,787.0 4,231.2 $168,822 $60,633 $0.110 362 41.4% 41.4% 17.1%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 580,605 966,410 3,930.0 4,231.2 $166,911 $60,633 $0.108 366 41.0% 41.0% 17.9%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 561,816 1,049,996 3,893.0 4,231.2 $168,690 $60,633 $0.105 381 39.4% 39.4% 21.2%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 494,589 857,632 2,776.0 4,231.2 $160,951 $60,633 $0.119 320 46.9% 46.9% 6.1%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 7,325,940 11,941,591 5,289 5,289 $2,125,602 $773,737 $0.111 357 42% 42% 15%<br />

Month<br />

Customer<br />

Charge<br />

Tax Adj<br />

BASELINE AVERAGE UTILITY HISTORY 2006 - 2008<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

Electric Consumption and Damand<br />

On Peak<br />

Use<br />

Off Peak Use<br />

Metered<br />

Demand<br />

PROPOSED ECM COSTS<br />

Billed<br />

Demand<br />

Calculated Cost and Electric Rates<br />

Monthly<br />

Total Cost Demand Rate Full Load<br />

Hrs<br />

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3<br />

$ $ KWH KWH KW KW $ $ $/KWH Hrs % % %<br />

Jan $302.82 -$200.00 531,183 1,065,902 3,625.0 3,660.0 $151,948 $52,448 $0.095 436 34.4% 34.4% 31.2%<br />

Feb $302.82 -$200.00 609,394 1,094,964 4,326.0 4,326.0 $174,237 $61,992 $0.102 394 38.1% 38.1% 23.9%<br />

Mar $302.82 -$200.00 582,199 964,364 4,235.0 4,235.0 $167,013 $60,688 $0.108 365 41.1% 41.1% 17.9%<br />

Apr $302.82 -$200.00 488,230 795,749 3,601.0 3,660.0 $142,777 $52,448 $0.111 351 42.8% 42.8% 14.5%<br />

May $302.82 -$200.00 550,103 960,296 4,436.0 4,436.0 $171,533 $63,568 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.9%<br />

Jun $302.82 -$200.00 687,177 977,882 4,575.0 4,575.0 $182,974 $65,560 $0.110 364 41.2% 41.2% 17.6%<br />

Jul $302.82 -$200.00 671,742 1,064,319 4,469.0 4,469.0 $181,886 $64,041 $0.105 388 38.6% 38.6% 22.8%<br />

Aug $302.82 -$200.00 605,222 833,748 4,516.0 4,516.0 $174,166 $64,714 $0.121 319 47.1% 47.1% 5.8%<br />

Sep $302.82 -$200.00 555,566 857,559 3,669.0 3,669.0 $149,028 $52,577 $0.105 385 38.9% 38.9% 22.1%<br />

Oct $302.82 -$200.00 533,675 927,922 4,354.0 4,354.0 $167,738 $62,393 $0.115 336 44.7% 44.7% 10.6%<br />

Nov $302.82 -$200.00 520,374 1,007,088 3,806.0 3,806.0 $154,041 $54,540 $0.101 401 37.4% 37.4% 25.2%<br />

Dec $302.82 -$200.00 446,793 796,894 2,626.0 3,660.0 $141,442 $52,448 $0.114 340 44.1% 44.1% 11.7%<br />

Total $3,634 -$2,400 6,781,658 11,346,687 4,575 4,575 $1,958,782 $707,415 $0.108 368 41% 41% 18%


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 3<br />

ECM #10 - COST ESTIMATE SUMMARY<br />

DESCRIPTION MATERIALS LABOR QTY / % TOTAL<br />

Fan VFD Installations ($/HP) $177 $42 2,390 $523,410<br />

Fan Motor Replacments ($/HP) $100 $25 2,390 $298,750<br />

CO2 Sensors ($/Sensor) $600 $100 80 $56,000<br />

Controls ($/Point) (10 Pts per AHU) $1,200 510 $612,000<br />

Subtotal $1,490,160<br />

Engineering 10% $149,016<br />

Insurance 10% $149,016<br />

Permitting 5% $74,508<br />

TOTAL $1,862,700


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 4<br />

Technical Specification Sheet<br />

Document No. 149-910<br />

April 30, 2008<br />

QPA20… Series Room Air Quality<br />

Sensors<br />

Description<br />

The QPA20… series room air quality sensors optimize<br />

room com<strong>for</strong>t by enabling demand-controlled<br />

ventilation. The sensors can acquire: CO 2 and volatile<br />

organic compound (VOC) concentrations, relative<br />

humidity, and temperature. Models are available <strong>for</strong><br />

CO 2 , CO 2 /VOC, CO 2 /T, and CO 2 /T/RH.<br />

The sensor evaluates the CO 2 /VOC concentrations<br />

and trans<strong>for</strong>ms it to a 0 to 10 Vdc linear proportional<br />

output signal.<br />

For models with humidity, a capacitive humidity<br />

sensing element changes capacitance as a function of<br />

the relative humidity. An electronic measuring circuit<br />

converts the humidity signal to a continuous 0 to 10<br />

Vdc signal that corresponds to a relative humidity<br />

range of 0 to 100%. For models with temperature, the<br />

sensor acquires room temperature with a sensing<br />

element that changes electrical resistance as a<br />

function of the temperature. The resistance is<br />

converted to an active 0 to 10 Vdc output signal that<br />

corresponds to a temperature range of 32°F to 122°F<br />

(0°C to 50°C) or -31°F to 95°F (-35°C to 35°C).<br />

Sensors with an LCD window display the following<br />

measured values:<br />

• CO 2 in ppm<br />

• CO 2 and VOC as a bar chart (4 bars ≈ 2V,<br />

20 bars ≈ 10V)<br />

• Temperature in °C or °F<br />

• Relative humidity in %<br />

The wall-mounted sensors are suited <strong>for</strong> use with all<br />

systems and devices capable of acquiring and<br />

handling a 0 to 10 Vdc output signal.<br />

Features<br />

• Multisensor <strong>for</strong> CO 2 /VOC, temperature, and<br />

humidity-temperature<br />

• Maintenance-free infrared CO 2 sensing element,<br />

VOC sensing element based on a heated tin<br />

dioxide semiconductor<br />

• 24 Vac operating voltage, 0 to 10 Vdc output<br />

signals<br />

QPA20… Series Room Air Quality Sensor and<br />

QPA20… Series Room Air Quality Sensor with Display.<br />

Ordering In<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

UNIVERSAL SENSOR PROGRAM Q P A 20xx. x<br />

TYPE SENSOR Q<br />

MEASURING FAMILY CO2/VOC P<br />

APPLICATION/LOCATION ROOM A<br />

SENSOR TYPE CO2 2<br />

HOUSING TYPE CO2 HOUSING 0<br />

TEMPERATURE OUTPUT SIGNAL NONE 0<br />

0 TO 10 VOLT 6<br />

RH SIGNAL PRESENT<br />

CO2 OR VOC ONLY: 0 TO 10 VOLT 0<br />

CO2/VOC AND RH: 0 TO 10 VOLT 2<br />

SEPARATOR .<br />

FEATURE DESCRIPTION - ROOM TYPES<br />

WITHOUT DISPLAY <br />

WITH LCD DISPLAY D<br />

Siemens Building Technologies, Inc. Page 1 of 2


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 5<br />

Product Numbers and Specifications<br />

Specification<br />

Product Number<br />

CO 2 measuring range: 0 to 2000 ppm<br />

Accuracy: ≤±50 ppm +2% of measured value<br />

Output signal: 0 to 10 Vdc, linear<br />

Recalibration free: 8 years<br />

VOC sensitivity:<br />

Low (R1), Normal (R2), High (R3)<br />

Temperature measuring range<br />

(slope and intercept):<br />

R2 and R3: 32°F to 122°F<br />

(0°C to 50°C)<br />

R1: -31°F to 95°F (-35°C to 35°C)<br />

Temperature measuring element:<br />

NTC 10K Ω<br />

Measuring accuracy in the range of:<br />

59°F to 95°F (15°C to 35°C):<br />

±1.4°F (+0.8°C)<br />

outside the above range, between:<br />

-31°F to 122°F (-35°C to 50°C):<br />

±1.8°F (+1°C)<br />

Humidity range of use:<br />

0 to 95% rh (noncondensing)<br />

Humidity measuring range:<br />

(slope and intercept) 0 to 100% rh<br />

Measuring accuracy at 73°F (23°C), 24 Vac:<br />

30 to 70% rh: ±3% rh<br />

outside the above range, between:<br />

0 to 95% rh: ±5% rh<br />

Display (LCD) of measured value<br />

QPA2000<br />

QPA2002<br />

QPA2002D<br />

QPA2060<br />

QPA2060D<br />

QPA2062<br />

QPA2062D<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

•<br />

General Specifications<br />

Power Supply:<br />

Operating voltage (SELV): 24 Vac ±20%<br />

Frequency: 50/60 Hz<br />

Power consumption: ≤2 VA<br />

Electrical:<br />

Screw terminals: 2 × 16 AWG or 1 × 14 AWG<br />

Environmental:<br />

Transport:<br />

Temperature: -13°F to 158°F<br />

(-25°C to 70°C)<br />

Humidity: < 95% rh<br />

Physical:<br />

Mounting: On 2 × 4 inch (5 × 10 cm) electrical<br />

conduit box<br />

Weight in lb (kg):<br />

Without display: 0.22 lb (0.10 kg)<br />

With display: 0.26 lb (0.12 kg)<br />

Dimensions<br />

SEN0422R1<br />

3-15/16<br />

(100)<br />

3-1/2<br />

(90)<br />

Dimensions in Inches (mm).<br />

1-7/16<br />

(36)<br />

In<strong>for</strong>mation in this document is based on specifications believed correct at the time of publication. The right is reserved to make changes as<br />

design improvements are introduced. Products or company names mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.<br />

© 2008 Siemens Building Technologies, Inc.<br />

Siemens Building Technologies, Inc.<br />

1000 Deerfield Parkway<br />

Buffalo Grove, IL 60089-4513<br />

Your feedback is important to us. If you have<br />

comments about this document, please send them to<br />

SBT_technical.editor.us.sbt@siemens.com<br />

Document No. 149-910<br />

Country of Origin: US<br />

Page 2 of 2


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 6<br />

Premium, Energy & Standard Efficient Motors<br />

<strong>for</strong> Use on Adjustable Frequency Drives<br />

‣ Premium Efficient Motors meet NEMA MG1 Part 31<br />

‣ Energy Efficient World Motor® & Standard<br />

Efficient meets NEMA MG1 Part 30<br />

‣ Premium Efficient 10:1 Variable Torque (VT),<br />

4:1 Constant Torque (CT)<br />

‣ World Motor 10:1 VT, 2:1 CT<br />

‣ Standard warranty<br />

‣ Allguard Motor Quality System


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 7<br />

Product Overview<br />

U.S. Motors on Adjustable Frequency Drives<br />

There have been many questions asked regarding the suitability of applying U.S. Electrical<br />

Motors on adjustable frequency drives (AFD’s). The intent of this Product Data Sheet is to<br />

clarify under what conditions “Inverter Grade” insulated motors must be applied or when<br />

premium and <strong>energy</strong> efficient motors may be used on AFD’s.<br />

U.S. Motors’ Inverter duty motors with “Inverter Grade®” Insulation exceeded NEMA<br />

MG-1 Part 30 and 31 be<strong>for</strong>e the standards were established. We were a leader in the<br />

development of motors to withstand PWM drives evolution from power transistors to higher<br />

switching frequency IGBT’s. Today, there is an increased need <strong>for</strong> motors <strong>for</strong> light and<br />

medium duty inverter applications. Through continued research and development we are<br />

pleased to announce that all premium, <strong>energy</strong> efficient, and standard motors are now<br />

inverter compatible. All US Motors are manufactured with ALLGUARD® features including<br />

pulse resistant/abrasion wire and 100% solids polyester varnish.<br />

Inverter compatibility of motors is complex. Many factors must be taken into account to<br />

determine the suitability of types of motors. These factors include; torque requirements<br />

(constant or variable), speed range, line/system voltage, cable length between drive and<br />

motor, drive switching (carrier) frequency and the motor construction. Wider speed<br />

ranges, higher voltages, higher switching frequencies and increased cable lengths all<br />

add to the severity of the application and there<strong>for</strong>e the potential <strong>for</strong> premature motor<br />

failure. U.S. Motors has differentiated its products into families <strong>for</strong> your ease of selection<br />

<strong>for</strong> various inverter applications.<br />

Applying “Inverter Grade” Insulation Motors on Adjustable Frequency Drives<br />

U.S. Motors has many stock motor lines with “Inverter Grade®” Insulation. This patented<br />

insulation system exceeds the NEMA MG-1 Part 31 standard and has been proven in<br />

thousands of inverter installations <strong>for</strong> reliability. U.S. Motors puts a minimum of a 3 year<br />

warranty on all motors that include “Inverter Grade Insulation” and does not limit cable<br />

run between the motor and the AFD <strong>for</strong> these motors. U.S. Motors carries stock on the<br />

following “Inverter Grade” insulated motors:<br />

‣ Varidyne® Inverter Duty motors <strong>for</strong> 10:1 Variable Torque and 5:1 Constant Torque<br />

‣ Varidyne Inverter Duty motors <strong>for</strong> 10:1 Constant Torque<br />

‣ Varidyne Vector Duty motors with full torque to 0 speed and 1024ppr, 5-28vdc<br />

encoder<br />

‣ 841 PLUS motors that meet IEEE 841 standard and are suitable <strong>for</strong> 5:1 CT<br />

‣ Can withstand up to 2400 volt transient peaks<br />

These are the most appropriate motors <strong>for</strong> any severe inverter applications or when the<br />

factors affecting motors suitability are undefined (such as spares).


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 8<br />

Product Features<br />

Applying Premium Efficient Motors on Adjustable Frequency Drives<br />

Premium efficient Unimount® (type UTE), Dripproof (type DE/RE), Hostile Duty (type<br />

CTE), Auto Duty (type JDE) and Corro-Duty® (type TCE) motors meet NEMA MG-1,<br />

Section IV, Part 31.40.4.2. All motors have 40°C Ambient, 1.0 Service Factor on inverter<br />

power, 3300 feet maximum altitude and all enclosed motors have Class F Insulation.<br />

They are suitable <strong>for</strong> use with adjustable frequency drives under the following parameters.<br />

Motors manufactured with the AllGuard System that are applied on inverter drives with<br />

output (load) filters may utilize the 230 volt cable distances.<br />

‣ Up to 10:1 speed range on variable torque loads<br />

‣ Up to 4:1 speed range on constant torque loads<br />

‣ 1.0 Service Factor<br />

‣ Standard two year warranty<br />

‣ 600 volt or less line power<br />

‣ Cable limitations per the following table<br />

Maximum cable distance AFD to motor<br />

Switching<br />

Frequency<br />

3Khz<br />

6Khz<br />

9Khz<br />

12Khz<br />

15Khz<br />

20Khz<br />

460 Volt<br />

Premium<br />

196 ft<br />

138 ft<br />

113 ft<br />

98 ft<br />

88 ft<br />

76 ft<br />

230 Volt 380 Volt 575 Volt<br />

Premium Premium Premium<br />

481 ft 295 ft 53 ft<br />

340 ft 209 ft 37 ft<br />

278 ft 170 ft 31 ft<br />

241 ft 148 ft 26 ft<br />

215 ft 132 ft 24 ft<br />

186 ft 114 ft 21 ft<br />

For voltages and switching frequencies not listed above please use the following <strong>for</strong>mula<br />

to determine maximum cable distance:<br />

1328 - (2.15 x Voltage)<br />

Square Root (Switching Freq)<br />

= Feet<br />

For example: a 460 volt motor with a 10khz switching frequency drive would be:<br />

1328 - (2.15 x 460)<br />

10 = 107.2 Feet


Appendix E - ECM #10 Demand Control Ventilation -Page 9<br />

Product Features (continued)<br />

Applying Energy Efficient & Standard Efficient on Adjustable Frequency<br />

Drives<br />

Energy Efficient World Motors Unimount (type FUT), Dripproof (type FD/FR), Hostile<br />

Duty (type FCT), Auto Duty (JAD), and Corro Duty (type FTC) motors meet NEMA<br />

MG-1, Section IV, Part 30.02.2.9. All motors have 40°C Ambient, 1.0 Service Factor<br />

on inverter power, 3300 feet maximum altitude and all enclosed motors have Class<br />

F Insulation. They are suitable <strong>for</strong> use with adjustable frequency drives under the<br />

following parameters.<br />

‣ Up to 10:1 speed range on variable torque loads<br />

‣ Up to 2:1 speed range on constant torque loads<br />

‣ 1.0 Service Factor<br />

‣ Standard one year warranty<br />

‣ 460 volt or less line power<br />

‣ Cable limitations per the following table<br />

Maximum cable distance AFD to motor<br />

Switching 460 Volt 230 Volt 380 Volt<br />

Frequency Energy & Energy & Energy &<br />

Standard Standard Standard<br />

3Khz 103 ft 435 ft 218 ft<br />

6Khz 73 ft 307 ft 154 ft<br />

9Khz 59 ft 251 ft 126 ft<br />

12Khz 51 ft 217 ft 109 ft<br />

15Khz 46 ft 194 ft 98 ft<br />

20Khz 40 ft 168 ft 85 ft<br />

As stated earlier, if application requirements exceed these standards, an output filter<br />

must be applied or an inverter rated Varidyne motor or new 841 PLUS “S” model with<br />

Inverter Grade insulation must be used.<br />

Please direct any questions on this policy to your respective U.S. Motors representative<br />

Emerson Motors<br />

8100 West Florissant Avenue, St. Louis, MO 63136<br />

WWW Home Page: http://www.usmotors.com<br />

REGIONAL OFFICES PHONE FAX<br />

DOMESTIC U.S. SALES (888) 637-7333 (314) 553-1101<br />

INTERNATIONAL SALES (314) 553-3185 (314) 553-2135<br />

MONTREAL, QUEBEC/CANADA (800) 361-5509 (514) 332-5912<br />

TORONTO, ONTARIO/CANADA (905) 475-4670 (905) 475-4672<br />

REGIONAL OFFICES PHONE FAX<br />

MONTERREY, MEXICO (52) 8-389-1312 (52) 8-389-1310<br />

CARACAS, VENEZUELA (58) 02-2377522 (58) 02-2329727<br />

BOGOTA, COLOMBIA (57)1- 439-5420 (57)1- 439-5417<br />

PDS 811-215 02/01<br />

©2001 U.S. Electrical Motors - Prices, specifications and ratings subject to change without notice. Printed in the U.S.A

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!