December 2009 - Indian Airforce
December 2009 - Indian Airforce
December 2009 - Indian Airforce
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
BLAST FROM THE PAST
Chief Editor<br />
Vol. 167 <strong>December</strong> <strong>2009</strong><br />
Gp Capt Sameer Mehra VM<br />
Editors<br />
Wg Cdr GS Bishen<br />
Wg Cdr Vikram Munshi<br />
Editorial Assistants<br />
MWO TS Krishnan<br />
MWO AK Ghosh<br />
Mr Rakesh Kumar Singh<br />
Graphics Design<br />
Sgt G Ramesh<br />
Sgt V Saravanan<br />
Cpl Chetan Chauhan<br />
Designed and Printed by<br />
M/s Brijbasi Art Press Ltd.<br />
E-46/11, Okhla Industrial Area,<br />
Phase - II, New Delhi - 110020<br />
Tele: 011-41707212, 26386232<br />
Articles / Suggestions may be sent to:<br />
Editor, Flight Safety<br />
Institute of Flight Safety<br />
Air Force Palam<br />
New Delhi-110 010<br />
Fax: 011-25675059<br />
e-mail: editorfsmiaf@yahoo.com<br />
flightsafety@dg.iaf.in<br />
Every article must be accompanied<br />
by a brief bio-data and passport<br />
size photograph of the author.<br />
'Flight Safety' can be viewed on the IAF net at<br />
http://www.iaf.in/dg/dgissite/dfsweb/index.htm<br />
Suggestions and inputs on Quality Control<br />
issues of the IAF could be sent to DG(I&S),<br />
IAF by e-mail at the following address:<br />
dg_is@yahoo.com<br />
Round-the-clock contact of Principal Director<br />
Flight Safety: Tele: 011-26172738 (Off)<br />
011-25671488 (Res)<br />
Mob: +91-9717095606<br />
e mail: pdfs_iaf_in@indiatimes.com<br />
inside<br />
2 Your Flying Horoscope<br />
PEG<br />
4 Why Self Medication?<br />
15 Sqn AF<br />
5 Speaking of Safety<br />
Anonymous<br />
6 Look After Your Man - He’s Yours<br />
Mrs Jayanti Naidu<br />
8 Hot Rod<br />
Picerian<br />
10 Hurricane in a Cocktail Glass<br />
Wg Cdr A Agarwal<br />
13 Bar Profits<br />
One Three<br />
14 Instrument Flying<br />
PEG<br />
18 Don Quixote in the Clouds<br />
Wg Cdr Amarjeet Kullar VrC VSM<br />
21 Foolishness<br />
PUG<br />
22 The Story of MET<br />
Wg Cdr CN Venkatraman<br />
24 It isn’t Fair<br />
Anonymous<br />
26 Accident of the Month - 15 Seconds to Live<br />
28 Smile<br />
Picerian<br />
30 Flight Guardian Needs You<br />
31 Rules & Regulations<br />
Anonymous<br />
32 Good Show<br />
34 Well Done<br />
36 Are You a Gambler?<br />
Anonymous<br />
10<br />
2 28<br />
Center Spread<br />
The opinions expressed in the flight safety are the personal views of the<br />
authors, and do not reflect the official policies of Air HQ. Contributions are<br />
welcome, as are comments and criticism. The Editorial Board reserves the<br />
right to make any improvement/change in manuscripts.
Editorial<br />
e have great pleasure in presenting to you this special issue of the Flight Safety<br />
magazine this month. The magazine was born in 1961 as a bi-annual<br />
WNewsletter and was variously known as Flight Safety Newsletter and Flight<br />
Safety Guardian with its frequency of publishing increasing gradually to once in two<br />
months. From Nov 1974 the newsletter was rechristened as Safety Journal and it started<br />
getting published monthly. The Journal was assigned its present title of Flight Safety<br />
Magazine in Oct 1997.<br />
We have taken great pains to rummage through all previous issues of the flight safety<br />
magazine right since its inception to select articles reminiscing the past for this issue, but I<br />
have no doubt in admitting that the effort was entirely worth it. The difficulty in selection of<br />
articles was two fold - one the sheer number of articles we had to go through and second - to<br />
shortlist only a few out of so many good ones.<br />
The articles in this issue will surely give you a glimpse of the <strong>Indian</strong> Air Force of<br />
yesteryears and highlight its transformation into a professional force as it exists now.<br />
In this whole exercise, we realized that we have been sitting on a treasure and we have<br />
now decided to publish one article “from the archives” every month in our magazine<br />
commencing January 2010.<br />
(Sameer Mehra)<br />
Group Captain
PEG<br />
Jan 76<br />
2 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
These forecasts are strictly meant for aircrew. Other<br />
branches are welcome to refer to it at their own risk, if<br />
flying with Air India/IAC and civil flying clubs.<br />
CAPRICORN DEC 22 – JAN 20 You are off to a flying start<br />
and are way ahead of the others. Try and keep it that way.<br />
Hindrances will be many, such as a cantankerous CO, terrible<br />
mess food and ill fitting inners. For luck wear your own flying<br />
clothing – the sweat of others may cause you to really sweat<br />
some day.<br />
AQUARIUS JAN 21 – FEB 19 Though the NAVY has won over<br />
the maritime role, keep yourself upto date in air-sea rescue<br />
procedures and never fly over the sea without a dingy. JAWS<br />
is still a best seller. Try and keep your weight down according<br />
to the new height/weight chart regardless of whether it<br />
causes a heart attack. For luck this year change your brand of<br />
butter from AMUL to SAGAR.<br />
PISCES FEB 20 – MAR 20 To stay in one piece this year use<br />
Janata soap, give your wife that extra allowance she has been<br />
harassing you for and clip your oxygen toggle to your flying<br />
overall. Gen up on your professional subjects not only when<br />
DASI is expected but throughout the year. They are fed up of<br />
howlers. For luck, wear your flying boots while flying – they<br />
are not only meant for walking.<br />
ARIES MAR 21 – APR 20 The year starts off at a slow tempo<br />
but picks up in the second quarter. Watch out for spurious<br />
drinks, dhaba food and false TA claims. If you are a UFSO,<br />
beware of FOD as there will be a spurt of UFO’s seen. Expect<br />
internal squabbles in the family. For luck always have your<br />
eggs double fried at breakfast before you fly.<br />
TAURUS APR 21- MAY 21 This is a good year for you.<br />
Promotions should be fast considering the uncertainty of<br />
DP aircraft and the DP selection amongst aircrew. Be careful<br />
regarding loading and unloading of guns, heavy drinking/<br />
smoking and dust storms. You should be lucky in lotteries<br />
and horse racing. For luck, don’t cheat this year in your PFR.<br />
GEMINI MAY 22 – JUN 21 You are under the influence of<br />
planet Mars as such you might find human beings a bit<br />
exasperating. Restrict your late nights, calling on senior<br />
officers and cribbing. Always wear your bone dome while<br />
riding your scooter. Your brains are required by the service –<br />
inside your skull. Gp Capts and above should be extra careful<br />
of heavy landing. For luck, stick to your pull-out heights.<br />
CANCER JUN 22 – JUL 23 Do be cautious during the first half<br />
of the year. Those caught cheating in promotion exams will<br />
forfeit a year’s seniority. Be cautious in dealings with black<br />
marketeers, contractors and IT officers. Though your birth<br />
sign shows great sexual prowess, be content with the more<br />
common poses, as slipped discs bruised elbows and knees<br />
are not conducive to flight safety. For luck, always rehearse<br />
your critical emergencies before take off.<br />
LEO JUL 24 – AUG 23 A good year to gain rewards and<br />
recognition. Beware of shaky wingmen, hydraulic failures<br />
and wrong flight plans. Concentrate on IF, especially limited<br />
panel. Since you have a special affiliation to all feline animals<br />
with special application to big game, remember shooting<br />
is prohibited throughout the country. For luck, learn range<br />
procedures, observe correct firing ranges and avoid low pull<br />
outs.<br />
VIRGO AUG 24 – SEP 23 Since you make a better<br />
calligrapher than a virgin, put everything in spurious MTG<br />
bills, over logging of actual hours and non payments of<br />
mess bills. Any tree which produces a nut is considered<br />
peculiarly Virgoan, especially to senior officers. This does not<br />
mean merely those with edible nuts. You might have some<br />
difficulty in close formation. For luck, never allow speed to<br />
replace cautious, methodical approach to flight procedures.<br />
LIBRA SEP 24 – OCT 23 ‘Libra weighs in equal scales the<br />
year’ so you get as much good as bad. On the plus side<br />
your have a flying qualification, a coveted posting and twins<br />
if your wife is pregnant. On the minus side you subtract<br />
double charge for house rent, a shaky descent because the<br />
AD 200 and Su are off the air and if your are over 50, a slight<br />
murmur of the heart. For luck all safety officers to do one<br />
Court of Inquiry and not blame the pilot.<br />
SCORPIO OCT 24 – NOV 22 Your sting is the deadliest so<br />
have pity on other pilots. We are still that select ‘few’. You<br />
should be extremely careful of long car journeys, night<br />
cross country flights and bald headed senior officers. Power<br />
corrupts, so you might be given a position to test your power<br />
of corruption. To your advantages will be a thumping P-57,<br />
every chance of a course abroad and an out of turn allotment<br />
of a scooter. For luck this year make a conscientious effort to<br />
avoid birds – the flying variety.<br />
SAGGITARIUS NOV 23 – DEC 21 You should do a lot of<br />
travelling this year. Be extra careful of loss of luggage, loss<br />
of identity card and loss of acting rank. Since you are a<br />
go-getter and add another feather in your cap for making<br />
people work on Sundays, complete their flying task and hate<br />
you. If you have a teenage daughter she might cause some<br />
trouble by wanting to marry out of the community. Be wary<br />
of Air India pilots, college girls and spicy food. Watch out for<br />
‘April’ Fools Day – someone is likely to pull your ------. For<br />
luck this year don’t borrow another’s watch or chinstrap.<br />
The author used to write under the pseudonym ‘PEG’.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 3
15 Sqn AF<br />
Aug 1975<br />
The other day our SFSO gave us a talk about self<br />
medication and its associated hazards. To many of<br />
us it was just that the guy was trying to justify his<br />
existence. To others it was in through one ear and out of<br />
the other. I belonged to the latter category, but lying in<br />
bed last night after a party it came back to me and I was<br />
reminded of an incident which happened some years ago.<br />
I remembered the day, my squadron pal Albert, a sober,<br />
God fearing individual did not return from a medium level<br />
handling sortie. Hours later the crash site was located and<br />
the usual procedures followed. Hardly anything was found<br />
of Old A1 for any pathological examination. The Court<br />
came out with the verdict “UNRESOLVED”. That was the end.<br />
Two young pilots were detailed to pack A1’s belongings<br />
for dispatch to his next of kin. While we were at a game<br />
of bridge on a Saturday afternoon, one of the youngsters<br />
came up to me and said that they had found some testtubes<br />
and coloured strips of paper. Without giving it any<br />
thought I asked him to chuck them and get lost as we were<br />
already two down in a bid of three no-trumps.<br />
After a few years, I happened to get stuck at A1’s home<br />
town for the night. I decided to visit A1’s people and say<br />
‘Hallo’ to them. They were simple folks and the atmosphere<br />
showed simple and austere living. As the evening went by<br />
the story of Old A1 unravelled itself. He was the eldest of<br />
four children and his father, a bank clerk, had died at an<br />
early age. His mother had to take up job in a nearby primary<br />
school to make both ends meet. On commissioning, A1<br />
took on the entire burden and responsibility of the family.<br />
Somehow the topic veered to medical attention in the air<br />
force and I spoke of the specialists and hospitals we have.<br />
Then the old lady said, that in all the seven years A1 was in<br />
the air force, the doctors could not cure him of diabetes.<br />
I was about to say “But --------“, when it all flashed back to<br />
me ------ the incident at the bridge table, when I asked<br />
young Fg Offr Laxman to get lost.<br />
You may ask why he concealed his disease from the<br />
medical authorities. Could he afford to get grounded<br />
and lose approximately 425 bucks a month? What about<br />
the schooling of his younger brothers? What about the<br />
house rent? What about the repayment of the debt of Rs.<br />
10,000/- incurred by his father for his education?<br />
I am sure that all of you will agree that there are<br />
many Alberts sporting oxygen masks, concealing some<br />
malady or other for the fear of getting grounded and<br />
ruining their career. Today’s air force is not reserved for<br />
the rich few. It is formed of pilots from various strata<br />
of society. As such monetary matters assume greater<br />
importance. I can almost hear someone say “THEN WHAT<br />
IS THE SOLUTION”?<br />
As you all know airline pilots have their flying licenses<br />
insured for a six figure amount so that in case they lose it<br />
due to medical or other reasons they will not be on the<br />
street. Therefore, my solution to this grave problem is that<br />
the government insure our flying category so that in the<br />
event of a pilot losing his medical category permanently,<br />
he is not hit financially. I am sure that the cost of a modern<br />
aircraft and the life of a fully trained pilot will more than<br />
balance the cost incurred in such a project and possibly<br />
reduce ‘UNRESOLVED’ accidents.<br />
While it may be obvious, I wish to clarify that the<br />
above story is pure fiction . But it could become a true<br />
life drama.<br />
4 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
Anonymous<br />
Nov-Dec 1971<br />
A<br />
group of birds decided to form a safety program. So they called a meeting and the<br />
Duck stood up and said, “I think we should have a lot of safety meetings. It’s another<br />
way we can get together with the flock and bawl them out.”<br />
But the rooster said, “No, that takes too much time and we’ve got to get the pipe in the<br />
ground”. So the argument went on. The Parrot said, “We don’t need any meeting. Everyone<br />
will be safe because they know it’s the right thing to do”.<br />
All the birds cheered, for they knew that no one tries to get hurt on purpose. Then the<br />
Mockingbird said, “What we need is a lot of posters. We will put posters up all over the place<br />
and we’ll have safety”. The Thrush said, “We don’t want posters,” and the Sparrow said they<br />
do just as well if they had some slides. The Goose stood up and said, “What we really need<br />
is a safety director who’ll be stern.” But the Starling thought it was more important that the<br />
safetyman be a ‘good mixer”. The Blue Jay figured if the safety director laid off the safety<br />
inspection, he’d automatically be popular with everyone.<br />
The real wrangle came over the protective equipment. Some thought everyone should<br />
wear it all the time. Others thought only part of the time and yet others said it should be<br />
written out so they wouldn’t have to make any decision.<br />
So finally, the Owl rose and smoothened his feathers. Everyone grew quiet, for they<br />
knew he had great wisdom. “Friends”, he said, “All this is secondary, I’ll tell you what we<br />
need. What we need is sincerity”. And all the birds applauded and stamped and cooed and<br />
whistled.<br />
“Yes, sir, “repeated the Owl quite pleased with himself, “above everything, we must be<br />
real sincere – even if we don’t mean it”.<br />
And so they formed a safety programme – and it was for birds.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 5
Mrs Jayanti Naidu<br />
Mar 1976<br />
In this the International Womens’ Year, in which<br />
women have expressed their views on every subject,<br />
writing on Flight Safety from a wife’s view point seems<br />
in keeping with the times. To a pilot’s wife, the term<br />
flight safety should signify his well being at work but,<br />
perhaps we take it as a vague jargon, which has nothing<br />
to do with us wives. Technically that may be so. When<br />
faced with a technical crisis during flight, he has his good<br />
training to stand by him. But there are other human<br />
factors which could also involve a pilot in an accident.<br />
Herein, we wives could help. Actually we wives could<br />
help threefold where flight safety is concerned, and<br />
each one a positive contributory factor to his survival<br />
in the air. Our contribution to flight safety would be his<br />
good health, moderation in day to day living and mental<br />
peace.<br />
Health is the first requisite of success in any walk of<br />
life. But in a challenging career like that of a pilot, health<br />
is of paramount importance. The doctors stress the<br />
importance of a well balanced diet to maintain physical<br />
fitness required of a pilot or aircrew, of which we are well<br />
aware. A married officer is entirely dependent on his wife<br />
for his much required nutritious, well balanced and timely<br />
diet. There is no facility for him to have such a diet outside<br />
his home nor could he afford it economically. To begin<br />
with, every knowledgeable wife must ensure that he has<br />
his breakfast before going to work which is a must before<br />
flying. Medically, I need not elaborate on this. A little<br />
planning the previous night and a little determination to<br />
serve with love (the breakfast) in the morning makes it a<br />
simple routine over the years and not a difficult task at<br />
all. Which man will refuse a timely, well laid out, simple<br />
breakfast before rushing to work? But, if the wife seems<br />
tired and reluctant in the morning, most men would<br />
choose peace at home and greasy samosas at work.<br />
Remember Ladies, the “Eagle Eye” is watching you, so do<br />
your duty. Diet charts giving us a good idea of a balanced<br />
meal as per aircrew requirement are readily available and<br />
we could use it as a guide. A conscientious wife merits<br />
cooperation from the husband as well. The type who has<br />
late nights, and rushes off to work, in spite of the wife’s<br />
pleas – has only himself to blame.<br />
6 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
This brings us to the second aspect in<br />
which we wives could help with his flight safety<br />
and that is helping him to practice moderation<br />
in day to day living. Bachelors fondly called<br />
‘Topers’ have been known to turn to moderate<br />
drinkers and smokers after marriage. Not<br />
always a case of getting henpecked, I am<br />
sure. Actually, drinking becomes a ridiculous<br />
pastime when loneliness is<br />
removed from a man’s life. If the<br />
woman is willing to give the<br />
required companionship to her<br />
man, without nagging or taking<br />
drastic views to the way of life<br />
he has been used to, much can<br />
be achieved. Be by his side at<br />
all times and rest assured you<br />
are on the winning side. For<br />
instance, when your husband<br />
drinks excessively, you get<br />
angry and rightly so. But at<br />
times when he is working<br />
long and hard, are you sympathetic and<br />
kind to your bread-earner? In every profession, a time<br />
comes when extra duties are essential like for a farmer<br />
at harvest time; the businessman at boom periods; the<br />
doctors during an epidemic. But a pilot’s overwork has<br />
a special stigma because he is risking his life. The wives<br />
contribution to flight safety comes vividly into focus here.<br />
This is the time to appreciate his stamina and devotion<br />
to duty. Forget your petty grievances and keep smiling.<br />
The hardships you have endured during his absence,<br />
would be taken as your extra duties. And in reward to<br />
such devotion, it is the right of the wife to expect some<br />
cheer, affection from the husband however overworked.<br />
The man who pours out his frustrations at work on the<br />
wife who has patiently awaited his return, is not the type,<br />
I write for.<br />
“But a pilot’s overwork<br />
has a special stigma because<br />
he is risking his life. “<br />
the doorbell to ring after working hours, Lady.<br />
Then learn to curb your quick temper. If you<br />
learn to bestow the natural goodness of your<br />
heart on the man in your life, you could beat all<br />
psychological theories hollow.<br />
Here, most wives would like to ask if it<br />
is really that simple to manage the husband?<br />
It certainly is not. But the effort from our side<br />
is a must. The ups and downs<br />
he faces at work is a battle<br />
he has to fight alone. It is at<br />
home that we can share joys<br />
and sorrows equally. As long<br />
as you keep alive his urge to<br />
live, you have ensured his flight<br />
safety to the best of your ability.<br />
And so may he fly, happily and<br />
securely along with the ‘Bird of<br />
Time’.<br />
The third vital factor to ensure his flight safety is his<br />
mental peace. A person’s frame of mind reflects his day<br />
to day living and naturally the wife plays a major role in<br />
it. Stress and strain at work could be a contributory factor<br />
but here we are concerned with the wife’s view point only.<br />
During flight when critical and instantaneous decisions<br />
have to be taken, an agitated or depressed state of mind<br />
could be dangerous. It is our responsibility to ensure<br />
that he goes to work in a calm state of mind. If you have<br />
had a row, the previous night, you have the whole day<br />
to cry out your sorrow. But the man you send to work<br />
– especially to fly, has no such outlets for his emotions.<br />
His pent up feelings make him dangerously prone to<br />
wrong decisions and actions. No flight is worth such a<br />
consequence. Whatever the quarrel, you would still like<br />
He flew too near the Drogue<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 7
Picerian<br />
Mar 1974<br />
No one could touch me as far as flying was concerned. Well,<br />
almost no one, except, the odd dozen or so, may be two<br />
“dozen or so other pilots around. As I said, I was a hot rod.<br />
In my youth I was a hot rod. I could fly an aircraft to the<br />
limit of its limits. (I had no limits). I could loop it right<br />
side up and upside down. I could do a climbing spin,<br />
a descending climb; turn so tight that I could look up my<br />
own tail pipe. No one could touch me as far as flying was<br />
concerned. Well, almost no one, except, the odd dozen or<br />
so, may be two dozen or so other pilots around. As I said, I<br />
was a hot rod.<br />
One day I was zipping along the runway in my flying<br />
machine. I hadn’t a care in the world and was eager<br />
to get my looping speed down by another ten knots<br />
to set up a record of looping at the lowest speed. Lift<br />
off, undercarriage up, bend the throttle to get it quickly,<br />
check undercarriage up and locked. Hello, the red lights<br />
are going out in an usual sequence, and the nose wheel<br />
locked up last. Queer.<br />
Up at 10,000 feet, the fuel was excessive for the loops<br />
I wanted to practise. Instead of burning off the fuel, I<br />
decided to use the time productively by checking the<br />
undercarriage retraction sequence. Reduce speed and<br />
select down. The nose wheel took long to come down<br />
and locked down last. Now select up. Right is green, the<br />
left is green and finally the nose is green. The sequence<br />
is wrong but what happened when I selected down? So<br />
down once more and watch carefully. Hydraulic pressure<br />
“<br />
is normal, the two main wheels lock down but the nose<br />
wheel is red. 25 sec, 30 sec, 35 sec and finally the nose<br />
wheel is green. Let me jot all this down on my knee pad<br />
or I’ll forget. That’s fine, I have the ‘undercarriage down’<br />
details. Now for the ‘undercarriage up’ details and lever<br />
up. Hydraulic pressure normal. Both main wheels lock<br />
up, but the nose is red. 40 sec, 50 sec, 60 sec and the red<br />
between greens then red then green then red and so<br />
on. All this is most unsatisfactory and the eagerness for<br />
low speed loops is dampened somewhat.<br />
After two orbits for decision making, I decided to<br />
abort and return to base. To be on the safe side, the<br />
undercarriage had better be extended right away.<br />
Down went the lever. The main wheels locked down,<br />
but the nose was red. It was red even after two minutes.<br />
Nothing to worry about. The micro switch must be<br />
playing up. Anyway, no harm in informing the ATC and<br />
having a visual check done. A low fly-by and the ATC<br />
calmly observed that the nose wheel appeared fully up.<br />
Two circuits and bumps later the nose wheel was still<br />
fully up. It was still up 4g later.<br />
Now a ‘main wheel only’ landing became inevitable.<br />
I asked for foam. In classic air force tradition, ATC wanted<br />
to know where I would prefer this to be. Along the<br />
centre of course, where else? The runway was foamed,<br />
8 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
the crash vehicles were cranked up and the ambulance<br />
was straining at the leash. I was cleared to land; the<br />
landing was impeccable and I kept the nose up waiting<br />
for the foam to show up. No foam! The nose was lowered<br />
gently and all was going fine. Suddenly, an obstruction<br />
on the horizon attracted my attention. It was the foam<br />
coming up. It was about five feet high and appeared to<br />
occupy a quarter width of the runway. There was no way<br />
to avoid it.<br />
I ran into this heap at about 60 Kts. Splash ! The<br />
mountain of foam was flattened. I was in and out in a<br />
trice. The aircraft stopped soon after and had suffered<br />
negligible damage. The SATCO came pelting in his jeep.<br />
He said, “I couldn’t understand how this foam in the centre<br />
of the runway would help you”. The flag car arrived in the<br />
nick of time. Everyone took it for granted that a genuine<br />
hot rod like me would naturally do a good job of landing<br />
a stricken aircraft.<br />
Later, a persistent and nagging doubt kept<br />
hammering away at a nerve end in my brain. This was<br />
a feeling that my aircraft was talking to me while I was<br />
fiddling about with the undercarriage and telling me that<br />
it had a bug in the nose wheel. Somewhat like a pet dog<br />
which limps up with a paw extended. But this of course<br />
is nonsense. Whoever heard of an aircraft talking to its<br />
pilot?<br />
Then there is another doubt which assails me. Did I<br />
read somewhere, that if something goes wrong with an<br />
aircraft, a pilot should not try to find out what went wrong<br />
by repeatedly putting the aircraft in the same situation?<br />
Maybe many years ago, when something similar was<br />
described in a magazine? I cannot remember.<br />
While talking about this accident to another hot<br />
rod friend of mine, he remarked that a true hot rod<br />
would have detected the error in sequencing during<br />
initial undercarriage retraction. He would then have<br />
decided to abort, lowered his undercarriage and landed<br />
uneventfully. He would have written down the fault in<br />
the Form 700 and left it to the ground crew to fix the fault.<br />
I got the impression that he was trying to insinuate that<br />
I wasn’t a true hot rod and that I was not doing well for<br />
the fraternity. It’s very well for him to talk disparagingly of<br />
me. I can fly his pants and underpants off him any day.<br />
The final blow fell when this accident was listed as<br />
“Avoidable – Pilot Indiscretion”. This after the cool and<br />
professional manner in which I had handled the whole<br />
situation and landed the aircraft so beautifully that it<br />
was flying a week later. Never moved off the centre line<br />
throughout its landing run, through the foam and all.<br />
There doesn’t appear to be any justice around the way<br />
people pick on the small and insignificant things and<br />
forget the bigger, more important and spectacular ones.<br />
Plain professional jealousy, I think.<br />
The author used to write under the pseudonym Picerian.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 9
Wg Cdr A Agarwal<br />
Nov 2007<br />
I<br />
recently visited the United States for an aviation medicine conference, where I presented a paper<br />
on the shortfalls of Human Factors Analysis and Classification System (HFACS) and some suggested<br />
remedies. The discussion got kind of lively and a lot of views were exchanged. Among the more<br />
vociferous was one lady (for convenience, let’s call her Jane) who was from the US Navy Safety Centre;<br />
the birthplace of HFACS. As time passed the discussion digressed to other flight safety related issues,<br />
including the approach to accidents and their investigation. I have always been interested in finding<br />
out how different Air Forces interpret similar circumstances leading to an accident, in absolutely<br />
different ways. Consequently, I was very interested in obtaining first hand information, if possible, on<br />
how the Americans do it.<br />
“I wish I could see some of your Board of Inquiries (BOI)”, I mentioned to Jane, as we were leaving<br />
at the end of the session.<br />
“There is one being presented tomorrow, right here in New Orleans”, she replied. “I’ll see if I can get<br />
permission to have you in it as an observer”.<br />
“I would really treasure such an opportunity”, I told her and we parted for the day.<br />
The atmosphere in New Orleans is akin to the one found in Goa; given to a lot of bonhomie<br />
and fun. Not many may be aware that Hurricane Katrina, while it destroyed a large part of New<br />
Orleans, is not the most famous hurricane to hit it. The most famous ‘Hurricane’ is<br />
a cocktail concocted at a pub called Pat O’Brien’s and contains about four<br />
ounces of rum. And so, BOI or no BOI, I spent the evening sampling<br />
Hurricanes, while my wife spent it telling me how stupid I<br />
was, spending precious dollars on getting drunk.<br />
It goes without saying that when I got<br />
up to attend the BOI presentation, I had<br />
a hurricane swirling in my head, throwing<br />
hundred pound hammers and attempting to split my<br />
head. I quickly dressed and rushed down to the hotel lobby to find<br />
Jane pacing about agitatedly.<br />
“We are already late”, she mentioned as we sat in her car and broke the sound barrier.<br />
10 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
The presentation hall looked somewhat like a<br />
courtroom. The judge was a guy in naval uniform, with<br />
many stripes on his shoulders. Through my misty, alcohol<br />
laden eyes I could not make out the number of stripes<br />
and hence named him ‘Judge’. The person presenting<br />
the BOI was the President of the Board, a naval Captain.<br />
The presentation had already started as we sneaked in<br />
through the back door. Thankfully, a copy of the ‘Brief<br />
Narrative’ had been placed on every seat, so I did not face<br />
difficulty in comprehending the sequence of events.<br />
In short, what had happened was this: A fighter<br />
aircraft was coming in for landing and the runway<br />
crossing barrier was closed. The light signal for opening<br />
the gate flashed briefly and the operator pressed<br />
the button for opening the barrier, which operated<br />
electrically. As it started opening, an airman on his<br />
motorcycle shot through on to the runway, though the<br />
operator closed the gate almost immediately. The airman<br />
was hit on the head by the wing tip of the landing ac<br />
and died immediately. After deliberating for a long time<br />
about whether the barrier operator or DATCO could be<br />
lying, the BOI determined that the electrical connection<br />
for the light may be faulty, causing it to come on briefly.<br />
The DATCO was blamed for the accident, since he had not<br />
ensured full serviceability. The Judge seemed convinced<br />
with this, and the presentation drifted off into exchange<br />
of pleasantries.<br />
The presentation highlighted the fact that the station<br />
was peculiar, in that the accommodation for personnel<br />
was on one side of the runway, while the workplace was<br />
on the other side. This resulted in nearly 2000 airmen<br />
crossing the runway, four times a day. The station was<br />
a busy training base, with nearly 40,000 take offs and<br />
landings per year.<br />
“Hmm”, she replied glumly. I thought she was angry<br />
at me for being late, but it turned out that she was as<br />
unsatisfied with the verdict, as I was. “Won’t these guys<br />
ever see reason”, she seethed through her clenched jaw,<br />
inadvertently making a pun – the guy who taught the<br />
world about latent and active failures is called James<br />
Reason.<br />
“The way I see it, that there are 2000x4x40000, i.e.<br />
32,00,00,000 chances of a similar collision every year”, I<br />
mentioned. “Therefore, if the ATC guys have managed<br />
to prevent those many accidents every year, they have<br />
actually done a commendable job…”<br />
“And they go ahead and blame them”, she completed<br />
my sentence.<br />
“I always suggest using the concept of substitution”,<br />
I continued. “So let’s ask ourselves a simple question: If<br />
someone else had been the DATCO, can we be sure that<br />
the accident would not have occurred? The answer<br />
would immediately throw up the truth”.<br />
“I am sure that the accident would still have<br />
occurred”, she replied. “Any fool can see that it was waiting<br />
to happen”.<br />
I turned to Jane and asked, “Air Forces around the<br />
world are pretty similar, aren’t they?”<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 11
“Then, who do you think is responsible for the<br />
accident?” I asked.<br />
“The bloody guys who designed this base, for sure”,<br />
she said. “They wrote the script for this accident when<br />
they made the blueprint”.<br />
“Exactly… so blaming the DATCO would not prevent<br />
another, similar accident from taking place”, I mused<br />
aloud.<br />
“If you were asked to recommend steps to prevent<br />
the next accident, what would you suggest?” Jane<br />
asked.<br />
“I would say that the primary reason for the accident<br />
is that airmen are staying on one side of the runway and<br />
have to cross the runway to go to work”, I said.<br />
“Yes, and so…?” Jane asked.<br />
“So, if we want to prevent the next accident, runway<br />
crossing should be avoided. I would suggest building an<br />
under-bridge, to facilitate it”, I said.<br />
“That’s right. Why blame the DATCO?” Jane agreed.<br />
“You are a foreigner, they won’t mind it if you point it out.<br />
Why don’t you tell them?”<br />
It must have been the raging hurricanes that<br />
prompted me to butt in, even though I should have<br />
known better. I briefly wondered if I should say “Mee<br />
Laard” in the true Hindi film style, and then blurted, “Sir, I<br />
don’t think that you have reached the right conclusion”,<br />
which invited a quizzical look from the judge. “About<br />
blaming the DATCO…” I added as if that would clarify<br />
everything.<br />
By now both the Captain and Judge were giving me<br />
rather antagonistic looks. Rather than facing their ire, I<br />
started speaking very fast and explained my reasons for<br />
disagreeing, without pausing for a breath.<br />
“Have you no sense at all, you idiot?” the judge<br />
screamed showing his desperation. “What would the<br />
kids think?” This somehow made very little sense to me.<br />
“Have you any idea of the sick fashion in which you<br />
are behaving”, shrieked the Judge, in a voice which had<br />
by now definitely taken a hysterical and almost feminine<br />
pitch. “The least you can do is to take your shoes off before<br />
lying down” and I opened my eyes. I almost screamed in<br />
panic as I saw my wife standing with a white face pack<br />
and her toothbrush sticking out of her mouth. It looked<br />
like an arrow sticking out of a round, white target (wishful<br />
thinking!!).<br />
She was shaking in rage. “Dare you go out and have<br />
a drink ever again. You have no idea how I dragged you<br />
back from Bourbon Street. And then this…”, she said,<br />
pointing her finger at my shoes. “And, by the way, your<br />
bloody Jane called up. She said she could not get you<br />
permission to attend the presentation tomorrow”.<br />
So here I was brewing a storm in a tea cup – or was it<br />
a Hurricane in a Cocktail Glass.<br />
Those of you who are fortunate enough to be<br />
bachelors, please believe me when I say that the most<br />
effective way to remove a hangover is to have a annoyed<br />
wife, threateningly shaking her finger at you. I sat up<br />
meekly and started untying my laces. While I was doing<br />
so, I wondered how a COI that I once read could enmesh<br />
itself in my dream. Incidentally, the verdict in this COI had<br />
also been the same i.e. the DATCO had been blamed. No<br />
permanent solution had been given and we still depend<br />
on luck to prevent the next accident. So far history has<br />
not repeated itself, and I only hope it stays that way. I<br />
could have carried on with this thought, but I could hear<br />
my wife splashing water on her face…matter of minutes<br />
before she came out of the washroom. Not wanting to<br />
receive another lashing, I quickly changed, brushed my<br />
teeth and went back to sleep. Better to keep your eyes<br />
closed.<br />
12 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
One Three<br />
Apr 1975<br />
This article is entirely fictitious. Any resemblence to<br />
any personality, living or dead, is their fault.<br />
“Abdar, do aur.”<br />
“Not for me, please, after six large I feel<br />
peculiar.”<br />
“Come on. You’re not flying till next week.”<br />
“Yeah. I know – but this is Sunday.”<br />
“O,K. Abdar – do chota.”<br />
“Ah well. Cheers. Oops. Sorry. New tie?”<br />
“No sweat. The whole lot is due for dry cleaning<br />
anyway.”<br />
“Abdar – ek aur.”<br />
“As I was saying, as long as Command can’t identify<br />
with us we’ll continue to get stupid orders. Every time<br />
there is a prang another set of restrictions is laid down.<br />
I’m praying and hoping nobody gets killed on start up,<br />
that will present some problems.<br />
“Oh! Come on. You always exaggerate things. After<br />
all they are the same sort of chaps sitting there. Take old<br />
Bindi – he’s got more hours on MiG’s than you and I have.<br />
He tells me he drafted the last directive.”<br />
“That might be so but then you make sense of the<br />
last restriction. We can barely get airborne now. And<br />
there is such a helluva transition between what we are<br />
allowed to do now and what we are expected to do in<br />
Ops.”<br />
“Abdar – do aur. Yeah you’re right. Six months<br />
seniority now and a VrC next week. I sometimes think,<br />
that wars are organised to stabilise the Air Force list.”<br />
“Say ! Do you remember Jake? He was my flight<br />
commander in ’65. Ah ! He was damn good. I just<br />
couldn’t get the hang of 1vs1 and he spent hours coaxing<br />
me along until suddenly it clicked. He used to watch all<br />
our landings when he wasn’t flying and in the gentlest<br />
possible way encourage us to some sort of precision. And<br />
the airmen used to worship him. He never packed up<br />
before they did and used to say please and thank you.”<br />
“Yeah I remember him but you must admit that half<br />
the things he used to do were because his squadron<br />
commander left him alone to run his flight and the station<br />
commander used to supervise from the air.”<br />
“That damn hog. I believe he’s changed now. Adbar<br />
– do aur. Got ambitious and is waiting for this acting or<br />
substantive. God knows which.”<br />
“You can’t blame him. Constant heat without light<br />
will break anyone in the end. I overheard him the other<br />
day in Delhi saying that the day a C-in-C comes on<br />
inspection and spends the first two hours sitting in Flying<br />
Control, just watching flying and listening, that’s the day<br />
he’ll feel there is some hope. Abdar – do aur. After that<br />
they can look at sanitary diary.”<br />
“I feel sorry for C-in-C’s. The only news they get is<br />
about prangs and accident rates. Plays up hell with a<br />
sense of humour. Specially, when you have never pranged<br />
yourself.”<br />
“Abdar – do aur. Now I’ve heard everything.”<br />
“Sahib – Orange squash sub katam hogiah.”<br />
“Acha ? Do rum laggow.”<br />
The author used to write under the pseudonym ‘One Three’.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 13
PEG<br />
Mar 1978<br />
Are you married? ‘No, Sir’. Are you insured? ‘Yes,<br />
Sir’ ‘Thank God’ ‘Well Youngman, in my twenty<br />
years of flying, I’ve never been taken for such a<br />
ride and considering I’m in the GD branch, that’s saying<br />
something’. You know the closest you came to staying<br />
within limitations was, when you lined up for take-off +5<br />
deg. And that would have ensured, you left the runway at<br />
unstick point if I had not taken over controls. What’s your<br />
problem – wine, women, song? Are you getting enough<br />
flying practice? By the way, what’s happened to your eye?<br />
Seems like a bloodshot. How come! Too many down the<br />
hatch last evening? You youngsters never know where<br />
to draw the line. All I can say is, if you carry on like this,<br />
one day a fire will be reported on approach and that will<br />
be the end of PEG, ‘Period’!<br />
That was the latter part of a debriefing I got on an<br />
IF sortie in the late fifties. The IR examiner from AEB<br />
was a jolly, fair, smiling bouncy individual who used to<br />
get blood red whenever I demonstrated a ‘Twizzel’ in a<br />
‘Vamp’ trainer. For those of you who’ve never had the<br />
opportunity to do a ‘Twizzel’, it is a cross between a steep<br />
turn, a loop and a cork-screw. Why it was ever introduced<br />
into the IF pattern I’ll never know, except to fox poor<br />
individuals like me. Once when I was doing a ‘Twizzel’ I<br />
started descending instead of ascending and he tapped<br />
my left knee and shouted ‘Fathead, you’re descending—<br />
you should be climbing, do something’; so I did something<br />
by increasing bank and ended up in a descending spiral.<br />
He told me to take-off the IF glasses I was wearing and<br />
look outside. I was indeed in a descending spiral, but<br />
since I had removed the IF glasses I concentrated on the<br />
instruments without looking outside and recovered with<br />
MG limits. So he said “if you can recover so well without<br />
glasses’ why can’t you do the same thing with glasses.<br />
‘Yea, why can’t I do the same thing with glasses’.<br />
Did I hear someone say ‘What’s this thing about IF<br />
glasses. You don’t know’. Well, in the days of old, we<br />
usually dressed up for IF. A pair of aircrew glasses were<br />
painted black leaving two apertures measuring 1” x 1/2”<br />
on the bottom inner side of the lens to see through.<br />
Enough to give anyone bloodshot eyes. Just looking<br />
at this contraption I use to get cross eyed, and when I<br />
put them on, I used to disorientate myself sitting in an<br />
armchair. But since most of the other guys used it, I could<br />
14 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
not complain loudly, There were a few other guys who<br />
suffered the same malady, so I consoled myself that may<br />
be the ‘cream’ did suffer. There were also a wide variety of<br />
glasses available. Some had tinted lens for bright sunny<br />
days and some had circular apertures like a camera. As<br />
one schmuck said “Why be a square’. So guys this was the<br />
paraphernalia we used for IF to simulate actual or ideal<br />
conditions, India Mike. Once when it was cloudy and dull,<br />
I borrowed a pair of IF glasses from a night fighter pilot<br />
(the breed is now extinct) and found to my horror they<br />
were tinted. As I put them on at take-off point, I could<br />
not see the instrument panel. I couldn’t then inform my<br />
instructor who was the same fair bouncy individual of my<br />
predicament. So I continued my take-off run staring into<br />
complete darkness. I was saved as we had to abandon<br />
the take-off because of an approaching thunderstorm.<br />
His remarks ‘A very good take-off. If only he knew.<br />
My next forte was ‘Unusual Attitudes’. I don’t know,<br />
but in my 20 years of fighter flying, I’ve never been in such<br />
unusual attitudes that I have experienced in practice<br />
IF sorties. I have been in usual attitudes but never in<br />
‘unusual attitudes’. One safety pilot was a ‘Cruster’ for this.<br />
May be he was born in an unusual attitude and wanted to<br />
return to the same foetal position. He used to take it out<br />
on me. ‘Close your eyes’, he would shout and it sounded<br />
like I’d never open them again. ‘When I tell you to recover,<br />
open your eyes, shout the altitude and recover. Hand me<br />
the aircraft back straight and level. Then followed a series<br />
of manoeuvres a trapeze artist would give her left arm for.<br />
A 7g descending spiral followed by a 6g loop followed by<br />
a wing, followed by a stall turn, followed by me passing<br />
out in the seat. Even if I did have enough courage and<br />
strength to brave the initial onslaught, it always turned<br />
out a losing battle for he had upset all the instruments.<br />
The compass and artificial horizon were both toppled,<br />
two other instruments had been blanked off. I used to<br />
stare at the oxygen gauge, recover and say, you’ve got her<br />
Sir’. ‘Whose got her?’ he would grumble. ‘The way you’ve<br />
recovered even God would find it difficult to recover’. And<br />
with that he would bring the stick back into the pit of his<br />
stomach and I’d pass out again. On re-recovering I would<br />
stare bleary-eyes through the IF glasses at the instrument<br />
panel and wonder if Hell could be worse. Before I could<br />
feel too sad about myself, he would ask me to carry out a<br />
descent on limited panel and my mind would wonder to<br />
the ‘fire on approach’ scene. I managed to come overhead<br />
after tracing a sine curve on radar.<br />
Yet another time it was raining ‘bucket and tubs’, in<br />
Pune in the middle of May. Since I was the junior most<br />
in order of battle, my aircrew cupboard was the smallest<br />
and situated in a leaky corner of the changing room. I<br />
was in the process of emptying rain water from my<br />
flying boots, when the Flt Cdr entered and said ‘Heny<br />
Sprog, go to flying control and file the clearance for Flt<br />
Lt___________’. He is landing from Bangalore in 5 min<br />
and wants further clearance to Kanpur! I said ‘In this rain!’<br />
He said ‘He’s a white card’. I said ‘A W-H-I-T-E C-A-R-D Sir,<br />
very well, right away Sir, rain or no rain’. So I mobiked it to<br />
Flying Control and got the ducking of my life. Ambitious<br />
thoughts flittered though my mind of one day qualifying<br />
for a white card. If these guys could fly in this weather<br />
when I had great difficulty mobiking it, it certainly would<br />
be a great achievement for me. So I spluttered up to the<br />
DATCO and asked him for a clearance form. He said ‘For<br />
what’. I said ‘My Flt Cdr wants to go to Kanpur’. He said<br />
‘you must be joking or you’re off your rocker’. I said ‘He’s<br />
a white card holder’! He said ‘A W-H-I-T-E C-A-R-D’. I said<br />
‘Yes”. He said ‘He’s cleared’. I said ‘I beg your pardon’. He<br />
said ‘He’s cleared’. So you see fellas, once upon a time<br />
your card really meant something – or did it I shudder<br />
to think what weather a MG card holder use to fly in. Or<br />
were there any MGs!<br />
A contemporary of mine related this incident to me<br />
about limited panel flying. After being briefed, he was<br />
told to cut out six instrument blanks and report to the<br />
cockpit. Since it is also known as blind panel flying, evil<br />
thoughts passed through his mind when he saw his<br />
instructor waving a scarf before tucking it into his pocket.<br />
Anyway immediately after take-off, his artificial horizon<br />
was blanked off. Soon the compass followed. As they<br />
were approaching levelling off altitude his altimeter<br />
went. Since he still had the Mach meter and ASI, he could<br />
still work out his height. He was then, briefly shown his<br />
compass heading and asked to do a timed turn onto<br />
another heading. Half-way through the turn, the aircraft<br />
clock was blanked off. He reverted to his watch. Since<br />
by now he was chasing the VSI round the clock, that<br />
instrument was also blanked off, so he transferred his<br />
attention to the cabin altimeter. He was by now reaching<br />
breaking point, so he implored his instructor for the coupde-grace<br />
and asked to be blind folded completely with<br />
the scarf. No, its not a made up yard, but a true incident.<br />
How ridiculous can one get?<br />
The ground subject test that followed the flying<br />
test was also quite amusing. I was once asked this<br />
question ‘An aircraft is flying at 40,000 ft’. The Altimeter<br />
is connected by a tube which trails out of the aircraft and<br />
is vented to the atmosphere at ground level. If the glass<br />
of the instrument in the cockpit is broken what height<br />
would the instrument record. I thought to myself. I had<br />
3 options 40,000 ft, cabin altitude or ground level. He said<br />
‘Right’. He said ‘Supposing I, puncture the tube at a height<br />
of 20,000 ft, what would it then read’. I said ‘ The maker’s<br />
name’. I was, of course, made O I/C Refueling Section for<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 15
two weeks after that, but then if you ask a silly question<br />
-----. Some of the other questions were equally silly and<br />
made no difference to the price of cabbages whether you<br />
knew them or not. Needless to say, I plugged most of the<br />
tests and I seriously thought, about committing harakiri<br />
after pending 129 hrs with my AP 129. Thank goodness<br />
the new AP goes by a different number now.<br />
Quite a few guys must by now be lining up their<br />
bazookas at me, but before they pull the trigger, I would<br />
like them to hear me out first and if at the end they still<br />
are convinced that I need the firing squad then they are<br />
welcome to ‘Fire’---but only through the pages of the<br />
Journal.<br />
Since then many guys have been to other countries<br />
on an exchanges basis to share ideas on flight safety<br />
and fighters tactics. Among the first to go were some<br />
of the ‘pioneers’ of the IF glasses. ‘When they asked<br />
their foreign counterparts if this practice of wearing IF<br />
glasses was sound, their counterparts were completely<br />
flabbergasted. The eyes or vision plays an important<br />
aspect in our orientation and any hindrance to this will<br />
create or enhance disorientation. Like, for example you<br />
are standing on one leg with arms outstretched, the<br />
moment you close your eyes your whole equilibrium goes<br />
for a bunt. Likewise with ‘IF glasses’ since the complete<br />
vision is restricted, guys with a keener sense of balance<br />
are unbalanced. So poor old Peg and a host of others,<br />
with a keener sense of balance had their gyros toppled<br />
before the show started. Anyway, when these pioneers<br />
returned from’ foreign’ ‘IF’ glasses were out. We then<br />
started using the visor with a cover and friends believe it<br />
or not, I made the MG standard in one go and attained a<br />
MG Card within the first seven years of flying. Many years<br />
later when I was teaching a few of the young bods the<br />
finer points of IF, I thought to myself that I must try this<br />
‘IF’ glasses gambit’ on one of the promising youngsters<br />
who was really good in IF. So one day, I made him wear<br />
the glasses for an IF sortie and believe it or not he nearly<br />
executed a perfect ‘screwdriver’ after take-off. So I asked<br />
his trouble and he said, once he put on the glasses it was<br />
like tying his wrist to his ankle and then asking him to<br />
observe normal etiquette at dinning table. I thought the<br />
simile quite appropriate and briefly told him why I tried<br />
it.<br />
‘The Twizzel’ is out. Thank God for small mercies.<br />
The IF pattern now is a well planned and balanced<br />
pattern which average pilots are able to execute within<br />
the prescribed number of practice sortie. The ground<br />
subject tests also follow a more rational approach and<br />
try to find out what you should know rather than what<br />
you shouldn’t know. The periodical checks on a pilot’s<br />
progress in IF are also now well planned and the trainer is<br />
of the same type as the fighter or close to it. Way back in<br />
the fifties, I was in a Hunter sqn which had a Vamp trainer<br />
as the dual aircraft. Hunter trainers had yet not arrived.<br />
You can imagine our plight with flying the powered<br />
control fighter the whole year through and then do your<br />
IF rating on the Vamp trainer. As one guy put it ---‘It’s like<br />
practicing basketball the year through and then taking<br />
part in football’. Anyway we survived. Today, there is a<br />
16 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
of exceptional skill in IF. His limitation were + nothing.<br />
However, this guy was horrified of clouds, rain and poor<br />
visibility. In other words, he was just plain terrified of<br />
bad weather. I can’t vouch for it, but I’m quite sure he<br />
never entered cloud. He was a MG and an IRI, so don’t<br />
ask me how he logged his ‘actual’. He was an exception<br />
rather than the rule which only goes to prove that<br />
simulated experience is one thing but actual another.<br />
A proper blend of the two would give us a safe and<br />
skillful pilot. Our approach now, to IF is truly more<br />
on the professional lines than, from the days of yore.<br />
Our experienced pilots are quite capable of handling<br />
most of the situations the weather Gods are capable of<br />
dealing out. When the Gods are very very angry, most<br />
pilots stay on the deck and leave the arena to Thor and<br />
CO.<br />
more professional approach to IF but one aspect needs<br />
mention. If there were no clouds, no fog, no bad weather,<br />
no dust storms, there would be no need for instrument<br />
flying. Instrument flying therefore came into being<br />
because of bad weather. So to learn instrument flying,<br />
we have to train to fly in bad weather. Everything cannot<br />
be simulated. We have to remove these apprehensions<br />
of low clouds/poor visibility from the minds of pilots.<br />
Then only can we truly say that our pilots have achieved<br />
a high standard of instrument flying. I once knew a pilot<br />
Finally, I’ve just got to mention a briefing I<br />
overheard while passing a neighbouring sqn<br />
crewroom in the good old days. It’s a real yorker. The Flt<br />
Cdr was briefing a youngster on an IF take-off. “When<br />
I tell you to line-up ask permission from Flying Control,<br />
check that the approach and runway are clear and<br />
then line up. After you line-up and have finished your<br />
checks and vital actions, lower your ‘IF’ glasses’. We will<br />
do an IF take-off”. In those days the whole take-off was<br />
done on instruments. Can you beat it? ‘When I say roll,<br />
release brakes, open power and commence roll’. If you<br />
are going left, I’ll say your ‘Zinging’ and if your going<br />
right I’ll say your ‘Zanging’. Now don’t forget ‘if I say you<br />
are zinging means your going to the left and if I say<br />
you are zanging means your going to the right. Right!<br />
Now if I say you’re zinging and zinging means you are<br />
going left and more left and if I say you are zanging and<br />
zanging you’re going right and further right. An if I say<br />
your zinging and then zanging means you are going left<br />
and then right. “Poor chap he was by now zingling. Our Flt<br />
Cdr was made of sterner stuff. ‘Now don’t forget if you’re<br />
zinging apply right rudder, and if you’re zanging apply<br />
left rudder’. Right! And lastly if it gets out of control I’ll<br />
say ‘You’re zinging and zanging and zanging and zinging<br />
and then you’re pranging’. Right! Ok.” “Let’s go.” Go<br />
where! Our poor chap didn’t stand a chance. We’ve come<br />
a long way since then, so now if any of you guys still want<br />
to pull the trigger you’re most welcome. While you’re<br />
deciding, I leave you with this thought; ‘A well adjusted<br />
man is one who can entertain himself, entertain another<br />
and entertain a new thought or idea!.. Keep smiling.<br />
The author used to write under the pseudonym ‘PEG’.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 17
Wg Cdr Amarjeet Kullar VrC VSM<br />
Nov 1977<br />
“In the days of old, when knights were bold,<br />
And bravery and chivalry counted,<br />
A band of aviators, numbers untold,<br />
Really left the world astounded”.<br />
- ANON<br />
The <strong>Indian</strong> Air Force is all of 45 years old. The story<br />
you are going to read actually happened, but far<br />
away and long ago. Such things don’t happen in<br />
the air force anymore, for we’re a truly professional service<br />
now, with very effective supervision and a fanatical bend<br />
towards flight safety. What’s more, this is a first person<br />
story in which the author took part. Others involved have<br />
all met their just desserts, so names have been changed<br />
to protect the innocent and the guilty.<br />
On the 1st day of October, a Russian IL-13 aircraft<br />
was going from Palam to Calcutta. This happened about<br />
twenty years ago (do I detect a horde of film producers<br />
wanting to make a movie ‘ Bees saal pehle’?) and the day<br />
was a Saturday.<br />
First, let me tell you a bit about the IL-13; it was a<br />
Russian transport plane with two piston engines. The<br />
plane was designed to carry twenty six passengers or five<br />
thousand pounds of luggage. It was supposed to return<br />
to Palam at night the next day. Since it meant an ideal<br />
weekend in Calcutta, many people wanted a lift. The<br />
captain of the plane, Flight Lieutenant Charlie Dunn, had<br />
a heart of gold and couldn’t refuse anyone. Eventually,<br />
when it was time to take-off, the IL-13 had ten officers in<br />
it, twenty non-officers (known as ‘airmen’) giving a total<br />
18 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
of thirty passengers. But in addition we also had six<br />
thousand pounds of luggage, two motor cycles ((their<br />
weight was five hundred pounds each) and two scooters<br />
(weighing a total of seven hundred pounds). To say that<br />
the plane was overloaded would be an understatement<br />
of the century. The last passenger was inserted with<br />
a shoe horn (something like sitting on a trunk being<br />
packed when the lid can’t be closed). It was warm and<br />
comfortable inside the IL-13 just as sardines would feel<br />
when they’re all snug in a sardine tin.<br />
There were two friends with me, Pilot Officers<br />
Chinmoy Chatterjee and Debu Basu. I was a Pilot Officer<br />
too, just at the beginning of my flying career. The three<br />
of us shared a common bond – we were all on our way to<br />
Calcutta to meet our respective fiancées. For me, it was<br />
extra special for the 2nd of October was my birthday (it<br />
still is). My parents were very farsighted and arranged<br />
for me to be born on the same date as the Father of the<br />
Nation, Mahatma Gandhi. So I always get a holiday on my<br />
birthday !<br />
But back to the IL-13.<br />
We took off from Palam. Well, just about.<br />
The runway is 13,500 ft long and even the Jumbo Jet<br />
uses a trifle over 4000 ft to get off at Palam. We used the<br />
whole runway, since the Captain disliked available things<br />
not being fully utilized. We staggered in the air with<br />
all of six inches to spare and the IL-13 started climbing<br />
laboriously to 6,500 ft, our assigned cruising level. We<br />
should have normally reached that height within ten<br />
minutes – but took forty five minutes. The weather<br />
expected was fine en route, and both Charlie Dunn and<br />
the navigator Unni had done this trip umpteen times.<br />
And since Unni knew the route like the back of his hand,<br />
he didn’t bother to carry any maps. He couldn’t forget to<br />
have the back of the hand with him or could he?<br />
The moment we reached 6,500 ft we found ourselves<br />
in thick clouds and as it happened, we never saw the<br />
sun, earth, sky or stars in the remainder of that trip. The<br />
fuel consumption was much higher than usual because<br />
of the load and though we should normally have been<br />
able to fly for six hours, the navigator did a quick mental<br />
calculation (he didn’t much care for these new fangled<br />
computers lesser navigators used) and estimated that we<br />
could fly for four and a half hours. Since that was enough<br />
to take us to Calcutta, Charlie Dunn merely shrugged and<br />
took another puff at his pipe.<br />
The Gods were out to teach us a lesson; for in no time,<br />
all our radio navigation aids and our radio telephone<br />
‘packed up’. After three hours, Unni informed Charlie<br />
Dunn that we were completely and hopelessly lost,<br />
since the compass also failed. But he did say, we were<br />
somewhere between Palam and Calcutta to the best<br />
of his knowledge. He was very touchy about the joke<br />
wherein one navigator actually over the Atlantic told<br />
his Captain that according to his calculations they were<br />
above the St Pauls Cathedral in London. The Captain,<br />
another unflappable person like Charlie Dunn, merely<br />
doffed his cap and asked his navigator to do the same.<br />
We finally had half an hour’s fuel left and also just<br />
about that much left for sunset. Charlie Dunn decided<br />
to let down through the cloud even though ere snow<br />
he hadn’t the faintest idea where we were or whether<br />
there was any cloud gap above ground level – we could<br />
as well be flying into the ground in a blaze of glory. A<br />
metaphorical blaze only, since our fuel was almost gone<br />
and there was no risk of an actual fire. Our hearts were<br />
in our throats when we descended through the clouds<br />
towards imminent death. My entire brief life flashed<br />
through my mind and I suddenly found myself an ardent<br />
believer in God and started praying feverishly. I noticed<br />
a lot of other hands joined in prayer too, whilst the<br />
remainders were in deep meditation. The only exception<br />
was Flight Lieutenant Gyan Darshan who was grinning<br />
broadly – he never took life seriously.<br />
We finally came out under the cloud just five<br />
hundred feet above the ground. The sun had set already<br />
and it was getting dark, not helped at all by the fact that it<br />
was drizzling. We had just ten minutes of fuel left and still<br />
had no idea where we were. Charlie Dunn saw a railway<br />
line, and since railway lines normally lead to civilization,<br />
he decided to follow it. He didn’t know whether to turn<br />
right or left. He tossed a coin. It said right. So he turned<br />
left. By now there was just five minutes of fuel left, so<br />
Charlie decided to force land in a paddy field.<br />
His forced landing was a superb piece of airmanship.<br />
He landed with wheels down in a short paddy field. On<br />
his approach to land, I had all the passengers moved to<br />
the sides out of the payload which would have come<br />
crashing forward due to inertia and made mincemeat of<br />
the men in case we decelerated rapidly on touch down or<br />
the undercarriage broke or something. I certainly didn’t<br />
feel the confidence I was displaying for the sake of the<br />
airmen.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 19
The aeroplane came to a stop. It was pitch dark.<br />
Somebody yelled ‘Fire’ and there was immediate panic. I<br />
stood where I was, knowing there was no fuel left to feed<br />
any fire. But a lot of the other passengers made a dash for<br />
the exit, now a good ten feet off the ground, and jumped<br />
out into the darkness. They landed on each other and<br />
one person almost broke his spine in the process. No<br />
amount of saying or shouting ‘Keep Calm! Don’t Panic !”<br />
had any effect at all.<br />
The last person to descend from the plane, after the<br />
step ladder had been fitted, was Charlie Dunn himself,<br />
the Captain being the last off his beleaguered ship. He<br />
was smoking his pipe as usual and merely shrugging<br />
at being complimented on a perfect forced landing. In<br />
the American Air Force he’d probably have been given a<br />
medal for the forced landing.<br />
“Look here chaps”, he said, puffing at his pipe, “You’d<br />
all best disappear before any authorities arrive on the<br />
scene, since you shouldn’t have been on board anyway.<br />
Just forget you ever saw me or heard my name. Nope, I<br />
han’t the faintest idea where we are. Nor can I understand<br />
the language of these natives who’ve gathered around<br />
us with their torches.”<br />
Gyan Darshan didn’t need any further bidding.<br />
He hied off on his motorbike and attended a squadron<br />
party at Kalaikunda that night – it transpired we’d landed<br />
just fifteen miles away from the IAF base there, well and<br />
truly south of our intended route.<br />
The plane was recovered later. It was stripped off<br />
all non essential weight, filled with the very minimum<br />
amount of fuel, and flown out of that paddy field by a test<br />
pilot to Kalaikunda safe. Charlie Dunn was admonished<br />
and Unni stopped relying on his palm of the hand<br />
navigation.<br />
Our troubles though were far from over, Chinmoy and<br />
Debu, both Bengalis could make out the local dialect to an<br />
extent and we were guided through wet paddy fields for<br />
some miles in the dark carrying our luggage on our heads.<br />
That brought us to a road, and very fortunately a bus came<br />
along in minutes. We all piled in. When the conductor<br />
asked us our destination we were dumbfounded, still<br />
having no idea where we were. I had an inspiration and<br />
said ‘Calcutta’ at which the man beamed and rattled off<br />
the name of some incomprehensible railway station. That<br />
involved a bumpy five hour drive and finally we reached<br />
there soon after midnight, to find to our delight that a<br />
train to Calcutta was due in half an hour. We caught that<br />
train, and it got us to Calcutta at 4 AM. At 5:30AM, I was<br />
knocking at my fiancées door. The sight of her stole my<br />
heart away (sh’d already done that anyway) and all she<br />
could say as she beamed and we hugged each other was<br />
‘Happy Birthday, Darling.”<br />
20 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
PUG<br />
Aug 1977<br />
on to where I could see the leader. The map stayed in<br />
my hand without following the navigation. I was literally<br />
being led. I had to shake myself when I saw some ducks<br />
miss me. Rather they saw me and gave me the right of<br />
way. I missed them.<br />
I had this yearning to land soon. On downwind, I<br />
kept repeating “check flaps and undercarriage” thought<br />
they were down and locked. Then came the fear of a flare<br />
out. What relief, I landed OK, just like after the first solo.<br />
Thank God, everything was normal. But the rest of the<br />
day I suffered in silence pondering over my stupidity.<br />
As brand new “Pilot Heads” we marched straight<br />
from the portals of the training institution to<br />
utilise the ‘privileges’ at the Mess bar, all this slow<br />
march to “Ault Lang Syne”. Those were the days we signed<br />
for cokes and cigarettes. We then became more sociable<br />
with the P-57 bit and graduated by drinking till closing<br />
time. Soon, I saw those black patches under my eyes and<br />
they got blacker after every sortie.<br />
So what ! I was young and keen to log a lot of<br />
experience. Besides, the Flt Cdr might think I’m chicken<br />
so there, I was soaring sky high even before the sortie; till<br />
one morning……..<br />
Yes, it was a beautiful clear blue winter morning. The<br />
visibility was so good you could see for ever. The chill<br />
was quite a blessing for in my head were tiny hammers<br />
beating away. The night before, I had drunk myself silly<br />
with close friends at a trivial celebration. I got sick that<br />
night and retched most of the liquor, I had.<br />
I didn’t have the guts to tell the Flt Cdr of my<br />
predicament as his mood would turn sour. But it did. I<br />
just could not catch up in time after take-off. Position<br />
keeping in the fighting position was difficult. I just hung<br />
Boy was I lucky to get back from what a Court of<br />
Inquiry would conclude that – “On a low level navigation<br />
sortie the aircraft crashed and killed the pilot. The exact<br />
cause could not be determined”. Yes, they couldn’t have<br />
determined if I drank that night, my bar book was full ages<br />
ago and I was drinking on some other friend’s account.<br />
Never again, not for all the world, do I want to be six<br />
feet under for such a crazy act?<br />
“Why did I drink myself sick ? Why couldn’t I have<br />
told the Flt Cdr that I was unfit for flying ? Why did I<br />
take-off --- why ? Why ?”<br />
Because of foolishness. Just like the way you want to<br />
belt around on your motor-bike at 100 kmph. Adventure-<br />
--definitely not. This act is beyond any reason and even<br />
instinct. Fools rush in where angels fear to tread.<br />
DFS Comment<br />
Fools never learn. The average man learns from his own<br />
experience. Better ones use other’ss experiences for their<br />
own benefit and learning.<br />
The author used to write under the pseudonym ‘PUG’.<br />
2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 21<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
Wg Cdr CN Venkatraman<br />
Apr 1978<br />
Once upon a time, the pilot of an aircraft came<br />
across a strange kind of obstruction to his flight.<br />
His plane was tossed about roughly. The aircraft<br />
was hit by stones of ice pelted from above. It grew dark<br />
and the pilot was frightened out of his wits. He prayed to<br />
God Almighty to save his life. Luckily God answered his<br />
prayers and he managed to land back safely.<br />
This was an occasion to celebrate and he did so in<br />
the evening at the bar. He recounted his experience to<br />
his friends around. He spoke of his miraculous escape.<br />
This force of fury he had encountered – “What was it” ? he<br />
asked. “Was it that thing called weather?” It was”, said the<br />
barman. In fact, he knew someone in the Met Department<br />
who used to draw figures on a chart and give what was<br />
termed as a weather forecast. The air force pilots should<br />
meet the Met-man and try to get a weather forecast.<br />
The next day the entire squadron invaded the Met<br />
office. The pilots nosed around for quite a while before<br />
they got a forecast. By the time they left the Met office, they<br />
had learnt enough about Met, lows and highs, warms and<br />
cold fronts, clouds and rain, cumulus and cumulonimbus<br />
and what not. It was quite interesting and they thought<br />
they should try to consolidate their knowledge. But<br />
they could not go every day to the Met office. So they<br />
asked the Met office to send them both the chart and the<br />
forecast so that (he prayed to God Almighty) if they lost<br />
either of them, they could still have the other. But the<br />
Met-man would send only the forecast and not the chart.<br />
And the forecast was difficult to understand, for it was<br />
written in a special language. Language was not a strong<br />
point with the air force chaps; they could manage slangs<br />
all right, but they found that the forecast was not related<br />
to the weather and the weather was not related to the<br />
pilot. Dissatisfaction grew and the air force decided to<br />
have both charts and forecasts. And they could also get<br />
Met briefing.<br />
So the Met service for the air force started, when<br />
some officers from the civil Met department came<br />
over and wore the uniform. The new Met officers were<br />
asked to look at the air and issue forecasts for flying and<br />
weather warnings for no flying. Of course, they were free<br />
to make some chart if they liked. They did like too make<br />
charts; they were asked about lows and highs at briefings<br />
and drew bigger and bigger lows and bigger and bigger<br />
highs.<br />
Meanwhile, the civil Met department expanded and<br />
developed. Technology advanced and new techniques<br />
came into being. Radars, computers, satellites and other<br />
new developments, brought about rapid changes. But<br />
the air force Met continued on its beaten tract unaffected<br />
by happenings all over the world. The outlook grew<br />
dim for the Met officers. Soon, many left the air force<br />
and returned to the civil department in search of other<br />
prospects. So the air force started recruiting its own Met<br />
officers. Bright young men with post graduate degrees<br />
went to the selection board to jump over hurdles and<br />
perform acrobatics and were appointed as air force Met<br />
officers. They came with high hopes and settled down to<br />
draw charts and write forecasts. Their eagerness to study<br />
and learn new techniques soon died a natural death. For<br />
22 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
the air force felt that if a Met officer could just look at the<br />
air and give a forecast twenty-five years ago, why could<br />
he not do the same thing now ? Why does he want more<br />
facilities ? The service wants only a forecast from him.<br />
The Met officer was too timid to point out that the air<br />
force itself had changed a lot during the years.<br />
In the good old days it was small. The flying station<br />
was a compact family unit. The lone Met office was an<br />
integral part of the operational staff. He was in close touch<br />
with all flying activities of the station. The flying staff<br />
looked upon him as a consultant and advisor, who knew<br />
more about weather than they themselves did and not as<br />
a trader who dished out weather forecasts. Operational<br />
needs were limited and the demands on the Met officer<br />
were also limited, for everybody knew the limitations of<br />
the Met organisation and nobody expected the Met<br />
officer to be a prophet or a miracle worker.<br />
During the last twenty-five and more years the world<br />
has changed and our air force has also changed a lot. The<br />
country’s population has increased explosively and the<br />
air force has not lagged. Upgradation, expansion and<br />
upgradation have resulted in producing large stations<br />
and big flying units. Increase in population produces<br />
its own problems. Upgradation of posts has meant<br />
downgradation of work. Many pilots now do not see an<br />
aircrew for many days. They naturally do not see the Met<br />
officer. The number of Met officers has also increased and<br />
each station has now three or four of them working in<br />
shifts. But the personal touch with the totality of flying<br />
operations has been lost. They are no longer consultants<br />
and advisers; they have become shopkeepers (without<br />
identity) to dish out forecasts and Met briefings. After the<br />
briefing they have to go and look after their important<br />
secondary duties. But the demands on Met have<br />
multiplied tremendously. The operational needs have<br />
increased. The planning needs have grown on account of<br />
the increasing complexity of flying tasks. And moreover,<br />
a communication gap has come into being between<br />
the Met and the flying personnel. The operational and<br />
planning authorities no longer turn to the Met officer<br />
for consultation or discussion. In the stress and strain<br />
of their decision-making requirements, they ask for a<br />
‘pill’ from the Met officer which they could swallow with<br />
closed eyes. They make demands without caring to know<br />
what is possible and what is not possible in the realm of<br />
weather analysis. They are too busy to take any interest in<br />
the working of the Met organisation or help it to develop<br />
and keep pace with the progress of science all over the<br />
world.<br />
organization within it needs to develop itself to be above<br />
for fulfilling these special needs.<br />
DFS Comments<br />
Affectionately known as “cloudy” the Met man, is<br />
the first person, the operator sees and hears before any<br />
work commences in the field. The pill that he gives us<br />
invariably affects the ensuing day. Most feet that the<br />
weather affects their mood, flying and work in general.<br />
And yet a gloomy day may not necessarily mean a gloomy<br />
disposition for all.<br />
More so, weather has a direct bearing on flying<br />
operations. Aircrew must give the Met man a “feed-back”<br />
on the weather during his sortie and better still, it would<br />
be a good idea if the forecaster took advantage of a trip<br />
in an aircraft and see the environment for himself.<br />
Like someone asked, “If the weather were as<br />
predictable as holidays and eclipses, what in the world<br />
would everybody talk about?”<br />
TWO BIGGEST LIES IN THE IAF<br />
DASI - “We are here to help you”<br />
OC<br />
- “We are glad to have you”<br />
(From the “Are you properly dressed”<br />
mirror of the “Battle Axe” squadron,<br />
when DASI visited the outfit. )<br />
Courtesy DASI Nov 1977<br />
The air force has its special needs and the Met<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 23
Anonymous<br />
May 1978<br />
“How do you mean, snooping?”<br />
“The Station Flight Safety Officer is a real soft touch.<br />
He has a private office and a direct pipeline to the<br />
old man. If he played it right……..”<br />
“What’ll you have? You look a bit frustrated old<br />
Buddy!”<br />
“Yer right, gimme a beer. I had a hell of a day! – And<br />
it’s all because of that guy!”<br />
“Which guy are you referring to?”<br />
“What guy??- Who else – Super-Snoop. You know,<br />
that Station Flight Safety Officer, Flt Lt Dooley. He’s<br />
always nosing around, looking for an accident to happen.<br />
Never gives a minute’s rest. You wouldn’t believe half<br />
of the things he does! He won’t stay in his office where<br />
he’s supposed to, he’s got this little black book that he’s<br />
always writing in, a pocket full of checklists and he’s<br />
always snooping.”<br />
“Well, you know. The Station Flight Safety Officer<br />
is a real soft touch. He has a private office and a direct<br />
pipeline to the old man. If he played it right he could get<br />
himself promoted. If he only knew enough not to rock the<br />
boat. Listen– I’m an old sweat on, I know the score. This<br />
guy is just going about it the wrong way. If I had that job,<br />
I’d send out a few forms, posters and let the other guys do<br />
the work. Same results. Why snoop and get everybody’s<br />
back up. I can tell you, this guy won’t last”.<br />
“Why?”<br />
“Well, for instance. This morning he got the engineers<br />
all stirred up. Got them to fill in some big ditch he found<br />
on the field – a whole 20 feet off the side of the runway!<br />
said it couldn’t wait. Should be done now! He thinks<br />
some aeroplane is going to go off the runway and hit this<br />
ditch! A million to one chance and this guy is worrying.”<br />
“What else?”<br />
24 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
“Oh yeah! He calls up the Station Chief Technical<br />
Officer every time he catches some poor jerk driving a<br />
tug down in the ramp of more than 15 miles an hour. Now<br />
you know that’s stupid! These guys have a lot of work<br />
to do and if they drive faster – they get it done quicker.<br />
Some of these guys can really handle those mules! And<br />
this character, for no reason at all starts cracking down.<br />
These guys are all driving so slow now they’re hazards to<br />
us normal drivers.”<br />
“Another beer?”<br />
“Yeah thanks. And furthermore, if this guy doesn’t<br />
quit poking around in other people’s business, I’m going<br />
to tell him off. We’ve hardly had any accidents around<br />
here and even if we did it would probably be some jerk<br />
pilot who didn’t know his job. Dooley’s a worrier. Always<br />
taking the most pessimistic view of every situation.<br />
Collects rocks, nuts, bolts and metal trash, keeps them in<br />
his office. Thinks he’s Sherlock.Holmes always trying to<br />
find out where they came from – as if that would make any<br />
difference. He’s got ‘FOD’omania! And now he’s talking<br />
about – Would you believe – MICRO FOD! You’d think we<br />
were running a hospital instead of an aerodrome. I never<br />
heard of MICRO FOD. And listen to this. This character<br />
has made up an accident prevention checklist – a mile<br />
long. He gives one to every supervisor – even guys who<br />
have nothing to do with aeroplanes. And he follows them<br />
up by asking question! He reads everybody’s orders and<br />
procedures and gets his nose into everything. He keeps<br />
a bigger cardex file than the IB. You better believe it!<br />
He checks into everything! Just the other day, he starts<br />
looking into everybody’s tool box. Wants a checklist on<br />
every tool box. Talks to all the mechanics. Wastes their<br />
time by showing them flight safety movies in their coffee<br />
breaks. Asks all kinds of nutty questions about morale<br />
and what kind of personal problems these guys have got.<br />
He’s an amateur psychologist! He really believes that if<br />
guys are unhappy, they’re more likely to have accidents.”<br />
Well, I think that he’s doing it all wrong. He’s<br />
been here two years working 24 hours a day, minding<br />
everybody’s business, printing checklists like confetti,<br />
worrying everybody about accidents, looking for dust<br />
and dirt in the hangars, showing movies, giving lectures,<br />
writing memos, letters, checklists – and you know what?”<br />
“No, What?”<br />
“It’s a complete waste of time! We haven’t had an<br />
aircraft accident around here for years!”<br />
“You mean like about two years? Have another<br />
beer.”<br />
“No, let me get this one.”<br />
“No need to. They’re free tonight. Dooley just<br />
got promoted.”<br />
“No! You’re putting me on! I can’t believe<br />
it! That just shows the whole system is<br />
unfair. Here this young smart pants, hardly<br />
dry behind the ears, gets promoted and<br />
for what? And here I am, twice as much<br />
seniority as him, always support the<br />
Mess, laugh at all the CO’s jokes and<br />
what happens to me?<br />
It just isn’t fair!”<br />
“Thanks-just a small one. My wife says I drink too<br />
much. Where was I? Oh yeah, Dooley. As I said, I think<br />
there is something queer about this guy. He believes all<br />
that flight safety jazz. I mean he really believes it! He’s on<br />
the snoop 24 hours a day and never lets anybody forget<br />
about aircraft accidents. I think he is some kind of a nut.<br />
A safety maniac!”<br />
“Yes just once more. That’s my last one! If I drink<br />
any more, old super-snoop will be checking my flight<br />
schedule for tomorrow. Cripes! What can you do about a<br />
guy like that? He’s got everybody on the station thinking<br />
about accidents! I can’t go anywhere on the station<br />
without seeing one of his ghastly posters.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 25
Mar 1974<br />
One hazy, hot day in May 1973 two MiG pilots went up for a practice 1 vs 1 combat sortie. It was a simple sortie,<br />
simpler than the hundreds flown each day at our various fighter squadrons, but there was something special<br />
about this one. For one pilot, his sortie was the end of the road – his clock read z minus 11 min when he took off.<br />
The two aircraft took off, climbed to 6 km and started a briefed air combat situation. They descended to 2 km, called<br />
off the fight and climbed back to 5 km for a second round. Once again, they descended to 2 km and the fight was called<br />
off. The leader’s speed was 550 kmph. The No 2 descended to join up in fighting position but was too close with a large<br />
angle off and consequently flew through behind and below his leader. He then pulled up and perched high, slightly<br />
behind the leader and on his right.<br />
26 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
The leader stopped turning when he saw the fly<br />
through and after a pause started a gentle turn to the<br />
right to see what the No 2 was up to. At this time, the No<br />
2 again tried to join up in fighting. Once again he was too<br />
close and at a large angle off. The descent was steep and<br />
he again flew through behind and below the leader. At<br />
this stage, the leader turned away from the No 2 to help<br />
him join up. But at that instant, the No 2 was in trouble.<br />
He had only 15 seconds to live.<br />
When the leader eventually levelled out and looked<br />
for his No 2, he was nowhere in sight. After a few seconds,<br />
he saw an aircraft far below him and almost immediately<br />
it crashed. The pilot did not survive since he ejected too<br />
late.<br />
What happened? Why did this simple sortie end in<br />
disaster? Let us look at the significant facts.<br />
• The leader was in a gentle level turn maintaining<br />
550 kmph at a height of 2 km indicated, about 1.7 Km<br />
AGL.<br />
• The leader was turning into the No 2.<br />
• The No 2’s fly through is understandable. He<br />
would have tried to stop the fly through by pulling harder.<br />
The speed would have dropped to about 500 kmph.<br />
After flying through, he pulled up and perched high and<br />
behind. The speed would have dropped some more. Say<br />
about 400 to 450 kmph.<br />
• The leader reversed his turn and was again turning<br />
into the No 2.<br />
• The No 2 was set up for another fly through and<br />
could see it coming. He tried to stop it with more<br />
heart than the first time. The speed would have dropped<br />
even more. Say about 400 kmph.<br />
• The descent for the second join up was steep.<br />
• A tight descending turn at about 400 kmph<br />
without reheat was established. The pilot wanted to<br />
avoid getting below his leader and pulled back on the<br />
stick. That is what caused the aircraft to develop a high<br />
sink rate and stall.<br />
Why did the pilot not recover from this stalled<br />
condition?<br />
Presumably because he did not use the correct<br />
technique of centralising the elevator control to permit<br />
the aircraft to stablise in an attitude corresponding to its<br />
flight path and apply full reheat power to get compensated<br />
for the drag rise. Unless this is done the aircraftwill not<br />
accelerate and recovery will be impossible.<br />
Why did the pilot not eject at a safe height?<br />
Most probably he did not know the relationship between<br />
minimum safe ejection height and rate of descent.<br />
What else could have contributed to this accident?<br />
• The pilot most probably forgot to select flaps up<br />
after combat. Extended flaps at reduced speed would<br />
have increased the drag.<br />
• And what about the leader turning into the No 2<br />
while he attempted to join up?<br />
The Air Combat season is with us now and May is not far<br />
away. The time is right for some refresher ground training<br />
to clear up confused ideas. Gen up on the following:<br />
• Low speed and stall characteristics of your aircraft<br />
with particular reference to the onset of the stall without<br />
warning during combat manoeuvring at high angles<br />
of attack and low speeds. Remember that under these<br />
conditions there would be an induced rate of descent<br />
for which the VSI is the only positive guide. To recover,<br />
get your wings level, push the stick forward and build up<br />
speed with reheat, wherever possible. (Unlike the Sukhoi,<br />
there may be warning of stall in the MiG.) Do not get on<br />
the wrong side of the power curve, a high performance<br />
aircraft cannot be manoeuvred in the low speed/high<br />
drag regime without adequate power (reheat).<br />
• Minimum height for safe recovery at various<br />
speeds.<br />
• Minimum safe ejection height, depending on the<br />
rate of descent.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 27
Picerian<br />
Jul 1975<br />
What is stress and what does it do to you? A<br />
chapter in Aviation Psychology explains this in<br />
much detail and the jargon is impressive. While<br />
there are myriad stresses which can attack pilots, I would<br />
like to isolate two which merit a pilot’s consideration<br />
and understanding. These are stresses associated with<br />
ego and survival. I consider these to be most important<br />
because they probably cause more accidents than any<br />
other factor and can strike at pilots any time during<br />
flight.’<br />
Ego stress shows up during any form of competition.<br />
It matters little whether this is in the air, on the ground, in<br />
the class room or at a gunnery range. Sometimes it afflicts<br />
us on the road while driving or even during a friendly<br />
discussion. The trouble starts with the fear of losing or<br />
when you cannot hold your own. Consider a gunnery<br />
sortie. The bullets undershoot and you curse. The bullets<br />
undershoot again and you curse again. The third time<br />
you take it out on the aircraft. What happens under<br />
similar circumstances on the ground? You bash your<br />
hands together or bang your head or fist the furniture.<br />
The important thing to note is that such emotion does<br />
not improve your performance. In fact, it causes further<br />
deterioration. Such behaviour is the first sign of<br />
failure to cope with ego stress. The pressure is on the<br />
individual since you cannot hold your own, you get<br />
into a rage.<br />
Survival stress hits you when you feel your<br />
security is at stake. This usually happens in war or when<br />
a serious flight emergency catches you unawares. Such<br />
stress generates fear which is normally a good thing<br />
for survival. If this fear is not kept under rigid control,<br />
it rapidly becomes panic and a pilot no longer remains<br />
a rational or capable person and an accident becomes<br />
inevitable.<br />
Put in a nutshell, stress causes<br />
emotion. Mild emotion is a<br />
good thing because it<br />
helps us cope with<br />
stress. Strong<br />
emotion spells<br />
disaster. Many<br />
factors control<br />
emotions but<br />
no pilot can<br />
afford to lose<br />
control over his<br />
emotions while<br />
flying. He must<br />
at all times control<br />
his emotions and<br />
remain above himself<br />
and the situation.<br />
28 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
How?<br />
Many years before I learnt about stress and emotion,<br />
I discovered in myself a tendency to lash out when under<br />
ego stress. Loss of temper and rages always decreased<br />
my performance, particularly at the air to ground range<br />
or in air combat and I could see no way to improve when<br />
I desperately wanted to do better. Then one day, when<br />
every fibre within me wanted to throw a fit and when my<br />
muscles were tensed to bash the aircraft, some inner voice<br />
said – relax, smile! I relaxed and smiled. Suddenly I was<br />
able to recollect clearly what had happened and why, and<br />
was easily able to correct my errors. I learnt then, how to<br />
control my emotion and how to keep calm under stress.<br />
For years afterwards I would wriggle my bottom into a<br />
comfortable position and remind myself continuously<br />
to ‘relax and smile’. I became better at my job of flying a<br />
fighter aircraft.<br />
On another occasion, as my aircraft’s wheels<br />
touched the runway, something went wrong and the<br />
aircraft became uncontrollable. In about a micro second<br />
it occurred to me that I was a goner and the almost<br />
instinctive ‘relax – smile’ conditioning took over. In the<br />
next micro second brain, hands and legs were working in<br />
one smooth coordinated effort to survive. It worked.<br />
Stress induced emotion must be kept under control.<br />
If it goes out of control, our margin of attention narrows<br />
and we become less aware of what is happening around<br />
us and lose sight of what needs to be done. I found a<br />
simple way of keeping my emotions under control, no<br />
matter what the stress was. I had to relax and actually<br />
smile. It did not work if I merely said smile and kept a tight<br />
face. The facial muscles had to wear a smiling mask.<br />
Try it sometime. It may work for you.<br />
The author used to write under the pseudonym ‘Picerian’.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 29
Spring 1972<br />
Flight Guardian is the Flight Safety Magazine of the IAF and it has some Very Important Readers. They include :<br />
Chief of Air Staff<br />
Station Commanders<br />
Groundcrew<br />
Scientists<br />
PSOs, AOs C-in-C<br />
Aircrew<br />
Test Pilots<br />
Technicians<br />
And some people we can’t name!<br />
VERY IMPORTANT PEOPLE, all vitally concerned that our aircrew fly well and that our aircraft and equipment<br />
work efficiently. You are one of them.<br />
FLIGHT GUARDIAN is produced directly for you in the service, who fly and YOU who keep them flying. It is<br />
YOUR magazine. It is intended to be a platform for your experience, to share your ideas and problems, to let<br />
you know what people like you are thinking and doing and what is being done to help you do your job well.<br />
FLIGHT GUARDIAN NEEDS YOU<br />
Not only as a reader but also as a contributor. We want those ideas of yours, those arguments, those stories,<br />
those photographs and accounts of what you are doing. We don’t get enough of them. If you’ve got something<br />
interesting to say about flying or maintenance in the IAF, let us have it. Tell us if you like YOUR Flight Guardian<br />
and if you don’t say what you’d like to see in YOUR magazine. If you’ve a suggestion for a good article, push<br />
it along – direct to the Editor, Flight Guardian, Directorate of Flight Safety, Air Headquarters, New Delhi.<br />
THERE ARE ROUGHLY 25,000 WORDS IN AN ISSUE OF FLIGHT GUARDIAN – YOUR’S SHOULD BE SOME OF<br />
THEM<br />
PS: FOR THOSE IN HIGH PLACES: Please don’t forget that in the Flight Guardian you can pass on the distilled<br />
wisdom of your experience to the younger generation.<br />
LET US NOT LOSE THESE PRICELESS BENEFACTIONS FOR EVER.<br />
30 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
Anonymous<br />
The volumes of required reading for aircrew have<br />
multiplied over the last few years to what many now<br />
regard as an unacceptable level. In consequence,<br />
come the magic first day of the month, weighty tomes<br />
of statute legislation and advice are laid upon the ops<br />
desk and opened at the page reserved for signature.<br />
The hurried scrawl inserted, signifying as having read, is<br />
possibly little more than most of these books are worth.<br />
Why do we bother ? No one reads the books regularly<br />
anywhere. The monthly signature is therefore in theory<br />
and practice nothing but a book requirement, or is it ?<br />
Possibly the orders exists to ensure that ‘they’ can<br />
always get you for something, and to give someone the<br />
secondary duty of keeping them up-to date. This aspect is<br />
of some importance. If you are not promptly confronted<br />
with amendments, your officer i/c order books is not<br />
doing his job properly – point No 1. The order books<br />
them selves do have relevance to a new member of the<br />
squadron – point No 2. (He can always spend the first<br />
few days reading them). They have an interest value –<br />
point No 3, since even a cursory browse, if you can’t find<br />
anything better to do, should reveal some error or point<br />
of confliction to produce a heated debate. The books<br />
are informative – point No 4 – usually to tell you what<br />
you’ve done wrong after you’ve done it (and hopefully<br />
before you commit yourself to an incident report). Finally,<br />
point No 5 - should the pen prove to be mightier than the<br />
sword, we may have under our very noses ammunition to<br />
confound the enemy if not to defeat him.<br />
Nov 1977<br />
Seriously though, it is acknowledged that there is<br />
an awful lot to read. We can help ourselves by reviewing<br />
our orders for relevance, and discarding those which are<br />
out of date, or of no consequence. If this is applied, at<br />
unit level, to the order books we are supposed to read,<br />
it is possible to produce a new slim-line series which it is<br />
easier to keep abreast of. We shall still<br />
have to sign the books monthly,<br />
but at least it might be feasible<br />
to read them as well.<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 31
On 28 Jun 09, Sqn Ldr V Valsalan (27028-G) Adm/ATC was detailed as a GCA controller at a<br />
flying base. A scheduled airliner declared an emergency concerning loss of an engine and<br />
requested radar assistance. Sqn Ldr V Valsalan, realising the gravity of the situation, adjusted<br />
the sequence of other arriving traffic and immediately vectored the aircraft for a surveillance<br />
approach, giving the pilot frequent position information to recover the aircraft safely. He<br />
simultaneously alerted the aerodrome controller, who initiated the primary alarm.<br />
Sqn Ldr V Valsalan displayed a high degree of professionalism and situational awareness<br />
in handling a critical emergency to recover an aircraft by the most expeditious means and<br />
contributed towards flight safety.<br />
Good Show Sqn Ldr V Valsalan<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
ON 17 Jul 09, Flt Lt D Autade 27711-G F(P) was detailed to fly a 2 vs 1 DACT sortie. After getting<br />
airborne, there was smoke in the cockpit and he was unable to see the flight instruments<br />
clearly. He gave a call to the leader and took appropriate actions. The smoke however, did not<br />
reduce and an overweight priority landing had to be carried out. Despite being unable to see the<br />
flight instruments clearly and with the aircraft weight well above the normal landing weight, he<br />
managed to recover the aircraft safely.<br />
Flt Lt D Autade 27711-G F(P) recovered the aircraft professionally and helped avert a possible<br />
accident/incident.<br />
Good Show Flt Lt D Autade<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
32 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
On 01 Jul 09, 912376-N LAC CH Appa Rao AF Fit, was detailed as aircraft inspector on a MiG<br />
-21 (T-96) aircraft. During final inspection of the aircraft for a sortie, he noticed the split pin<br />
of the bolt holding the bracket to the fork of the nose oleo missing and indicated the same to the<br />
pilot for aborting the mission.<br />
LAC CH Appa Rao’s observation helped in averting a possible nose wheel tyre deflation or a<br />
tyre burst at a critical stage of flight.<br />
Good Show LAC CH Appa Rao<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
On 26 Aug 09, 914900-L, Leading Aircraftsman Kalva Sudheer Kumar Propulsion Fitter was<br />
deployed in the DSS of a Su- 30 squadron. During a ground run clearance check on the<br />
starboard engine, Leading Aircraftsman Kalva Sudheer Kumar noticed a hair line crack on the<br />
port aero-engine turbine breathing valve of the aircraft. Further inspection revealed a large crack<br />
near the turbine breather valve. Had this crack gone unnoticed it could have led to catastrophic<br />
damage.<br />
Leading Aircraftsman Kalva Sudheer Kumar averted an accident due to his keen observation<br />
and professionalism.<br />
Good Show LAC Kalva Sudheer Kumar<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 33
On 21 Jun 09, 769225-T Sergeant Amar Nath Sharma Flight Engineer was detailed for trade<br />
duties in a Mi-17 IV helicopter for an air maintenance sortie. During the pre flight checks,<br />
he noticed a crack in a remote area of the first support housing the port engine. Detailed<br />
investigations revealed that the crack could have caused a catastrophic failure.<br />
Sgt Amar Nath Sharma displayed a high degree of professionalism and keen sense of<br />
observation which helped in averting a mishap in the air.<br />
Well Done Sgt Amar Nath Sharma<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
On 27 Jul 09, 775113-G Cpl P K Mishra Air Frame Fitter was detailed for servicing on an IL-76<br />
aircraft. In the course of his duty, the airwarrior noticed a crack in the bell crank system of<br />
the middle door. This resulted in arresting further damage to the cargo door. If the crack had<br />
gone unnoticed it could have led to an untoward incident.<br />
Cpl P K Mishra displayed keen sense of involvement and prevented a possible incident in<br />
the air.<br />
Well Done Cpl PK Mishra<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
34 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
On 10 Aug 09, 914853-A Leading Aircraftsman Rajesh Ranjan Propulsion Fitter was detailed<br />
for DI on a Su-30 fighter aircraft. During start up, the air warrior noticed a few drops of fuel<br />
leaking from the starboard engine. He inspected the fuel leak from close quarters and proceeded<br />
to examine the affected panel to rule out fuel accumulation. Subsequently, detailed investigations<br />
revealed fuel leak from the turbo starter fuel pipe union. Had this leak gone unnoticed, it<br />
would have led to serious consequences.<br />
Leading Aircraftsman Rajesh Ranjan showed keen observation and to prevent a possible<br />
incident/ accident.<br />
Well Done LAC Rajesh Ranjan<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
On 03 Aug 09, 914950-F Leading Aircraftsman VK Yadav Engine Fitter was detailed to for DI<br />
on an Avro aircraft. During LFS, the air warrior noticed cracks on the starboard jet pipe tray.<br />
Further investigation revealed hot gas leak through the crack. This could have caused high<br />
temperature around the fuel pipe lines and lead to a major fire in the air.<br />
Leading Aircraftsman VK Yadav, despite his limited experience on the aircraft displayed a<br />
high degree of professionalism and good observation to avert a possible accident.<br />
Well Done LAC VK Yadav<br />
(SS Soman)<br />
Air Cmde<br />
PDFS<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE 2 0 0 9 D e c e m b e r Flight Safety 35
Anonymous<br />
Out of every 330 accidents, 1 person will be killed and 29 injured. Those are pretty good poker playing<br />
odds.<br />
So why all the fuss about safety?<br />
That was the question asked by a class of students attending a safety course. The instructor, anticipating<br />
the query, produced a bottle of white pills.<br />
“In this bottle:”, he announced, “are 330 white pills, each exactly alike in appearance and taste. Three<br />
hundred are harmless candy pills and will produce no ill effects. Twenty-nine pills contain a drug<br />
which causes slight nausea. One contains a poison and will be fatal if taken internally”.<br />
He passed the bottle around and asked each student to take a pill. “Now”, he said, “I want each of you<br />
to swallow the pill you have chosen”.<br />
Not one of the students did.<br />
The instructor made his point.<br />
No matter how great the odds, no one would take the chance.<br />
Yet, in everyday activities, many continue to flaunt the odds by hedging on common sense safety<br />
practices.<br />
Accidents don’t always happen to the other person. Somebody is the one person killed in every 330<br />
accidents.<br />
It could be you.<br />
The odds are 329 to 1. DO YOU WANT TO TAKE THAT CHANCE ?<br />
Nov 1977<br />
36 Flight Safety D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 9<br />
INDIAN AIR FORCE
How many great ideas<br />
end here...<br />
...because your ideas on Flight Safety never get beyond the<br />
stage of a pencil scribble or discussion at the bar. Now we are here<br />
to hear you and spread those ideas throughout the Air Force. Don’t<br />
hesitate, act now, get that paper and pencil and send those articles<br />
you have always wanted to send us.<br />
Feb 1978<br />
Round-the-clock contact of PD Flight Safety: Tele: 011-26187154, Mob: +91-9717095606 e-mail: pdfs_iaf_in@indiatimes.com<br />
Articles/Suggestions may be sent to: Editor, Flight Safety Magazine, Institute of Flight Safety, New Delhi-110 010 e-mail: editorfsmiaf@yahoo.com, editorfsmiaf@rediff.com