Referee Report for Review Article submitted to journal - Versita
Referee Report for Review Article submitted to journal - Versita
Referee Report for Review Article submitted to journal - Versita
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Referee</strong> <strong>Report</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Review</strong> <strong>Article</strong> <strong>to</strong> be considered <strong>for</strong> publication in<br />
Human Movement<br />
Manuscript entitled<br />
Please rate the following aspects of the article:<br />
(if the response is `No’, where possible please suggest improvements on the attached sheet)<br />
Yes/No<br />
Does the title accurately reflect the content of the text?<br />
Is the aim of the review clearly stated?<br />
Does this article represent a significant contribution <strong>to</strong> the published literature?<br />
Is the article sufficiently complete and up-<strong>to</strong>-date?<br />
Is the article clearly written (concise, clear and well organised)?<br />
Is the abstract in<strong>for</strong>mative, providing the essence of the article clearly and concisely?<br />
Are the author’s conclusions adequately supported by references?<br />
Are additional tables or figures needed (please specify the type of figures/tables that<br />
you feel would aid the reader of this article)?<br />
Please indicate if this paper is:<br />
acceptable <strong>for</strong> publication without revisions<br />
acceptable <strong>for</strong> publication with minor revisions<br />
acceptable <strong>for</strong> publication with major revisions<br />
reject<br />
If substantial changes are necessary, would you be happy <strong>to</strong> review a revised version of<br />
the manuscript?<br />
Regardless of acceptability <strong>for</strong> publication, is this <strong>to</strong>pic of high, medium or low interest<br />
Please list your comments <strong>for</strong> the authors on the next page<br />
(specific comments <strong>for</strong> the edi<strong>to</strong>r only should be given in the covering letter).<br />
Any comments or suggestions that you make regarding this manuscript will be<br />
passed on <strong>to</strong> the authors anonymously.<br />
Adis International Ltd.<br />
41 Cen<strong>to</strong>rian Drive, Private Bag 65901, Mairangi Bay, Auckland 10, New Zealand<br />
Telephone +64 9 477 0700, Fax +64 9 477 0781
Comments <strong>to</strong> the Author<br />
Adis International Ltd.<br />
41 Cen<strong>to</strong>rian Drive, Private Bag 65901, Mairangi Bay, Auckland 10, New Zealand<br />
Telephone +64 9 477 0700, Fax +64 9 477 0781
Change language