12.11.2014 Views

Natural Systems

Natural Systems

Natural Systems

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Relationship Diagram<br />

More Devastating<br />

Effects of Earthquakes<br />

Poor Building Construction<br />

and materials<br />

Increased<br />

Pollution<br />

More Devastating<br />

Effects of Hurricanes<br />

Elimination of<br />

natural protection<br />

Deforestation<br />

and degredation of<br />

Resources<br />

Charcoal Production<br />

Survival<br />

Inequitable Resources<br />

Soil Erosion<br />

Harms Agriculture, Fishing<br />

and <strong>Natural</strong> Habitats<br />

Life Threatening<br />

mudslides & floods<br />

Conflict, Repression,<br />

and Corruption in the<br />

Government<br />

Poverty<br />

Migration to Cities<br />

like Port-au-Prince<br />

Overpopulation<br />

Scarcity of Resources<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Deforestation<br />

Border between Haiti and<br />

the Dominican Republic<br />

highlights the relative<br />

deforestation in Haiti.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Source: National Geographic, 2010.


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Deforestation and Disasters<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Source: ReliefWeb, 2008.


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Alarming Statistics<br />

• Between 10 and 20 million trees are cut down each year<br />

• The annual reforestation rate is 0.7%<br />

• 53,300 trees per year are cut down for businesses to operate<br />

• Over 80% of the Haitian population has no access to electricity and over 90%<br />

uses wood-based charcoal for their daily cooking needs.<br />

• The Haitian government has not made the environment a priority.<br />

• The sale of charcoal is the main source of income for 9% fo the rural population<br />

of Haiti.<br />

Source: Fride, 2008; EarthTrends, 2003; Lewis & Coffey, 1985; Lea, 1996.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

TIMELINE<br />

Timeline of Deforestation in Haiti<br />

1400 1700 1800 1900 2000<br />

1492<br />

When Columbus reached<br />

the Caribbean island of<br />

Hispaniola, he wrote: “No<br />

human has ever beheld a<br />

more beautiful land; nowhere<br />

is nature so immeasurably<br />

lush, so<br />

green, so untouched.”<br />

Over 80% of the island<br />

was covered by lush vegetation.<br />

1700s<br />

Haiti is jewel of the<br />

French Empire, treasured<br />

for lush forests; however,<br />

logging begins as the<br />

french levelled thousands<br />

of hectares of<br />

brigin forest to plant<br />

sugar cane, cotton, and<br />

coffee. Wood was to used<br />

to operate brickworks,<br />

kilns, and tanneries. Trees<br />

were not replanted.<br />

1804<br />

Haiti gains independence<br />

from France, but is stil<br />

threatened with slavery.<br />

1825<br />

1915-1934<br />

Haiti reaches an agreement<br />

with France to pay<br />

them for their independence.<br />

Haitians were<br />

made to pay up to 80%<br />

of the country’s revenue<br />

($21 billion in current<br />

income). To pay the<br />

debt, Haitiains cut down<br />

forests, selling the tropical<br />

hard wood for the<br />

production of French furniture.<br />

Americans occupy Haiti<br />

and concentrate landownership<br />

with disregard<br />

to the land-holders who<br />

were evicted or became<br />

hired farm workers.<br />

“Before the American occupation,<br />

forest cover<br />

was 60% of the total surface<br />

in Haiti. By 1945<br />

forest cover had been<br />

reduced to 21%.<br />

1947<br />

1954<br />

1978<br />

The debt to France is<br />

paid off; however, forestry<br />

continues with the<br />

trees being made ito<br />

charcoal instead of furniture.<br />

Only 6.7% of the country<br />

is still forested (based on<br />

aerial photographs). Of<br />

the 6.7%, 36% had a<br />

dense canopy and 64%<br />

had an open canopy. An<br />

open canopy is a signifiier<br />

active tree cutting<br />

or burning.<br />

1978-1984<br />

Estimated that only 8-9%<br />

of the land remained<br />

under forest<br />

Forest area decreased<br />

from 4 to 13.6%.<br />

1990-2000<br />

1991-1994<br />

Forest reduction of 53%,<br />

compared with an average<br />

loss of 11% and 2%<br />

for Central America/<br />

Caribbean and the world,<br />

respectively.<br />

Deforestation in Haiti accelerated<br />

during the embargo<br />

imposed by the<br />

UN. Kerosene and petrol<br />

were among the products<br />

affected by the economic<br />

blockade. People<br />

had to cut trees for cooking<br />

and lighting needs.<br />

2010<br />

Due to extensive deforestation,<br />

only 1.5 to 2% of<br />

the forest coverage remains<br />

in Haiti.<br />

2015<br />

Estimated that only river<br />

basins in the extreme<br />

southest will have remaining<br />

forest cover.<br />

Year River Basin will be Completely Deforested<br />

Prior to 1985<br />

1990<br />

2000<br />

2010<br />

Forest parcels over 50 km in 1978<br />

Source: Fride, 2008; EarthTrends, 2003; Lewis & Coffey, 1985; Lea, 1996.<br />

Drawn by: Baudler, 2011.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Vegetation and Land Use: 1970<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Forest Cover: 2004<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Land Cover: 2004<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Poverty<br />

Haiti Forest Cover: 2011 Haiti Energy Source: 2011<br />

Forested Land: 2%<br />

Renewable: 1%<br />

Oil: 23%<br />

Poverty causes many Haitians to seek income<br />

from natural resources. The sale of charcoal is<br />

the main source of income for 9% of the rural<br />

population. The charcoal comes from cutting<br />

trees, which accounts for the vast majority of<br />

the biomass used as an energy source by Haiti.<br />

Rural people must be empowered to find alternative<br />

sources of income.<br />

Unforested Land: 98%<br />

Biomass: 76%<br />

Source: UN World Food Programme<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Charcoal Production Areas in Haiti: 1980 to 1900<br />

Charcoal Production Areas in Haiti<br />

Increase in coal production from 1980 to 1990<br />

Source: UNDP Source: Johnson, 2007.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

1980<br />

1990<br />

ì The use of biomass is<br />

the biggest source of<br />

energy for Haiti. The charcoal<br />

and fuelwood industries<br />

are very important to<br />

the peopleís livelihood, but<br />

the practice is not sustainable.<br />

In the mean time, fuelwood<br />

meets 70% of<br />

energy needs. The emergence<br />

of an energy industry<br />

began in the 1940s and<br />

50ís in Haiti, so itis a relatively<br />

recent phenomenom.<br />

The use of the forests has<br />

spread in a matter of ten<br />

years.î Charcoal production<br />

rapidly spread between the<br />

years of 1980 to 1990. ì The<br />

increase in the fuel industry<br />

has exacerbated an already<br />

fragile environment.<br />

Crucial watersheds are destroyed<br />

leaving the land<br />

naked to destruction by<br />

storms which are becoming<br />

stronger every year.î


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster Casualties & Deforestation<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Wasteland - Deforestation in Haiti<br />

Jonathan Auch documents deforestation and charcoal production in Haiti through a series of powerful black and white images. Mr. Auch writes: “Once a<br />

lush island covered in trees Haiti is now 98 percent deforested. Twenty million trees are felled each year to meet the demand for the island’s primary fuel<br />

source; charcoal…. Haiti is quickly reaching an irrecoverable state where the majority of the island will succumb to desertification and become inhabitable.”<br />

Source: Auch, 2011<br />

View of patchwork landscape. 10 to 20 million trees are chopped down<br />

every year.<br />

Hillside scarred from years of deforestation due to charcoal production and<br />

logging. Only 1.5 to 2% of Haiti’s land remains forest.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Wasteland - Deforestation in Haiti<br />

As the mountains are cleared, they are often coverted for mining. Silt is<br />

washed into the ocean from heavy rain, impacting fish and other wildlife.<br />

A rare old growth tree is cut down to be turned into charcoal.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Wasteland - Deforestation in Haiti<br />

Farmers cut and stack wood into piles. They are then burned into charcoal<br />

where they will cure for two weeks.<br />

Charcoal farmer checking his charcoal. “This man was once a rice farmer<br />

but because of cheap imported American rice he was forced to start producing<br />

charcoal to support his family.”<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Wasteland - Deforestation in Haiti<br />

Charcoal market in Port-au-Prince.<br />

A charcoal market worker, known as a charbonniere. “The workers at the<br />

market spend 12 hours a day in the blistering sun on their hands and knees<br />

sorting charcoal into various sizes.”<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Deforestation- Charcoal in Haiti<br />

“The coastal charcoal market in the town of Arcahaie. Charcoal is sorted and<br />

loaded onto trucks for distribution, each bag weighs about 60lbs. Haiti uses<br />

approximetely 720,000 metric tons of charcoal annually.”<br />

“A charbonnière worker. The workers at the market spend 12 hours a day in<br />

the blistering sun on their hands and knees sorting charcoal.”<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Wasteland - Deforestation in Haiti<br />

“The ‘charbonnière’ make deliveries in Port-au-Prince from the market in Les<br />

Arcahaie. Charcoal is used for 76 percent of Haiti’s energy needs and must<br />

be delivered daily to meet demand.”<br />

“Workers take a rare break from loading charcoal into trucks at the market.”<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Reforestation Case Study #1<br />

Haiti Timber Re-Introduction Project (HTRIP):<br />

• is a community-based forestry in Haiti - began from a partnership between Hospital<br />

Albert Schweitzer haiti, interested members of the American forest industry, and other<br />

private donors.<br />

• began in 2006 to enable Haitians to re-create productive forests to improve their environment<br />

and health.<br />

• assists Haitians in growing commercially valuable timber tree species on marginal<br />

hillside lands<br />

• provides the trees and technical expertise while the farmer provides the land and<br />

labor (i.e., land in exchange for seedlings)<br />

• In 2006, over 1,300 trees were planted, with the participation of more than 175 Haitians<br />

• project is located in the mid-to-upper Artibonite Valley, an area with 40 inches of rain<br />

per year, with a dry period from November to March. The soils are very eroded and<br />

calcareous due to their limestone parent material.<br />

• livestock has been a significant challenge to reforestation, as the animals are rarely<br />

kept in enclosures<br />

• chose to begin reforestation with hard, fast-growing tree species: one native species<br />

(Cedrela odorata, Spanish Cedar), one naturalized species (Eucalyptus camadulensis),<br />

and one species that had not been previously introduced to Haiti (Paulownia sp.,<br />

Empress Tree). Paulownia is a fast-growing commercial species which re-sprouts<br />

after harvesting for up to 8 generations.One citrus tree and one nitrogen-fixing tree<br />

(Enterlobium cyclocarpum and Lysiloma sabicu) were also planted for every three<br />

timber trees.<br />

• word about the project is spread to communities at churches and meeting within a<br />

9.3 mile radius of Deschapelles.<br />

• there has been an average mortility rate of 27%<br />

• once the trees begin to mature (5-7 yrs.), the understory will become shaded, requiring<br />

a change in crop type. HTRIP will assist transition to coffee, chocolate, animal<br />

forage...<br />

Source: Sprenkle, 2007; Sprenkle, 2011<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

HTRIP staff meets with community members at a<br />

future planting site.<br />

Volunteers digging a row of holes just below a contour<br />

canal.


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Reforestation Case Study #2 & #3<br />

Dominican Republic plans to reforest border with Haiti<br />

• DR plans to reforest its border with Haiti - first step is to plant 5 million seedlings<br />

• In the first stage, seedlings wiil be planted in nurseries, consisting of pine (3.2 million);<br />

mahogany (500,000); mango (200,000); oak, San Domigo boxwood, and black olive<br />

(250,000 each); and tamarind and guayacan (150,000 each).<br />

• work is expected to cost 35 million pesos (approx. US $980,000). On June 15, 2010,<br />

the DR’s Environment and <strong>Natural</strong> Resources Ministry signed an agreement with the<br />

Border Development Agency to go ahead with the project.<br />

• The goal is to restore land at risk from antural disasters in the Haitian border area and<br />

provide jobs.<br />

Source: InfoSur Hoy, 2011.<br />

Large reforestation Project: AFKB in Bayone<br />

• AFKB is an organization with 155 members<br />

• goal of producing 120,000 seedlings - fruit and forest trees - over two years that will<br />

permit the reforestation of 2 Vesan valleys in Haiti<br />

• funded by the Lambi Fund, which will also provide training on agro forestation techniques,<br />

tools and the equipment to buil 6 tree nurseries.<br />

Source: Lambi Fund, 2011.<br />

Employees of the Dominican Republic planting seedlings<br />

to reforest the border with Haiti.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Large reforestation project in Bayone, Haiti.


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Haiti : Agriculture<br />

Social<br />

Income<br />

Cultivation and<br />

commercialization<br />

of<br />

traditional<br />

foods<br />

Marketing<br />

Trade<br />

Health<br />

Gender Tradition Social<br />

Culture<br />

Agriculture<br />

Valuation of<br />

environmental<br />

services<br />

Recognition of<br />

traditional and<br />

diversified land<br />

use Soils<br />

Water<br />

Climate<br />

Biodiversity<br />

Social<br />

“There is wide agreement that reconstruction will have to<br />

focus substantially on agriculture. The majority of<br />

Haitians live in rural areas and depend on agricultural<br />

activities for their livelihoods.”<br />

– Marc Cohen : Oxfam.org<br />

“When we live in these conditions, we are ready to accept<br />

everything that is offered to us. But it is better to be given<br />

things that are produced locally.”<br />

- Monrocher Antoine: Oxfam.org<br />

Economic<br />

If Haiti is going to be built back better then the international<br />

community needs to generously support the Haitian<br />

government’s agricultural investment plan.”<br />

- Philippe Mathieu : Oxfam.org<br />

Economic<br />

Environmental<br />

Environmental<br />

The combination of deforestation and soil nutrient mining<br />

due to low fertiliser usage has devastated the fertility of<br />

Haiti’s agricultural land. The loss of forest cover contributes<br />

to a topsoil erosion rate of 3 per cent per year.<br />

- Marc Cohen : Oxfam.org<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Diagram adapted from: International Assessment of Agricultural Science and Technology for Development (IAASTD) Report.<br />

http://qewnet.ning.com/forum/topics/mary-gilbert-and-others-report


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Social : History<br />

Haitian Identity : Relationship between Land and Liberty<br />

“Haiti set an example for the world as a pioneer<br />

nation, where a whole people rose from<br />

slavery to national freedom. Attention<br />

must be paid to the deep cultural<br />

importance of land in this struggle.”<br />

“The stability and security that<br />

come from the garden allow individuals<br />

to accept or refuse work,<br />

alleviating some of the damger of<br />

exploitation. Lakou is an ethical<br />

expression of free workers who are<br />

masters of their time and bodies.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

“Lakou is community space composed of houses<br />

populated by several generations of the same<br />

family...The Garden of<br />

the lakou is the basic unit of the Haitian agricultural<br />

world.”<br />

“A family cultivates the necessary foods for consumption<br />

by working together, and seasonal harvests<br />

from the garden allow the family not to be<br />

entirely dependent on outside resources.”<br />

Agriculture<br />

The dream of every<br />

Haitian is to have a<br />

piece of land, and<br />

owning land is linked<br />

to the very idea of<br />

being Haitian because<br />

the land is a symbol of<br />

freedom.”<br />

New Haitian Villages, Steven Holl Architects; Guy Nordenson & Associates; Matthias Schuler, Transolar; Jean Henock<br />

Beauchamps& Araby Smyth. Pamphlet Architecture: 31. Princeton Architectural Press. New York. 2010


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Social : Current<br />

Gender Roles- Women in Agriculture<br />

“In rural areas, men and women played complementary roles. Men were primarily responsible for<br />

farming and, especially, for heavy work, such as tilling. Women, however, often assisted with tasks<br />

such as weeding and harvesting. Women were responsible for selling agricultural produce. In<br />

general, Haitian women participated in the labor force to a much greater extent than did women<br />

in other Latin American countries. Haiti's culture valued women's economic contribution to the<br />

farm in that all income generated through agricultural production belonged to both husband and<br />

wife. Many women also acquired sufficient capital to become full-time market traders, and they<br />

were thus economically independent. The income that they earned from nonfarm business activities<br />

was recognized as their own; they were not required to share it with their husbands.” -Haggerty<br />

http://www.jeansenatfleury.com/wpcontent/uploads/2010/10/Brevil-Merdenie.png;<br />

[accessed Feb. 2011]<br />

Heath- Impact of Cholera on Agricultural Sector<br />

Hurricane Tomas caused flooding and subsequently expanded outbreaks of cholera. “Fears of the<br />

epidemic are causing a rice shortage, as farmers avoid harvesting in the north-west due to fears<br />

that canals and rivers, which irrigate the crops, may be infected...consumers are also avoiding<br />

products from cholera affected regions causing more hardships.”<br />

ABC Rural. Choleral Threatens Haitian Agriculture; [accessed Feb. 2011]<br />

Wealth disparities<br />

80% of the population is living in poverty, like Jealene [the farmer from the economic case strudy]<br />

most people live on less than $2/ day.<br />

“The wealth gap between the impoverisvhed Creole speaking black majority and the French<br />

speaking mulattos, 1% of whom own nearly half of the country’s wealth, remains unaddressed.”<br />

- Schifferes<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.wunrn.com/news/2008/12_08/12_22_08/122208_haiti.htm<br />

[accessed Feb. 2011<br />

Schifferes, Steve. Haiti: An economic Basket-Case; BBC News Online Economics Report. [Updated: March<br />

2004] [Accessed: Jan 2010]


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Social : Current Facts<br />

Total population (millions): 9.2<br />

Life expectancy at birth: 52<br />

Urban population: 38%<br />

Farming population (incl. forestry and fishing) (millions): 5.07<br />

Undernourished population (millions): 5.3<br />

Proportion of undernourished/total population:<br />

58%<br />

Per capita daily calorie intake (kcal/day): 1 840<br />

Per capita daily protein intake (%/ kcal): 9%<br />

Child malnutrition, underweight: 22%<br />

Child malnutrition, stunting: 24%<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://canteensforthechildrenofhaiti.org.p8.hostingprod.com/<br />

http://www.fao.org/countries/55528/en/hti/


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Social : Case Study : LONDON_2045<br />

“New Space for Old Space: An Urban<br />

Vision,” presents a retrospective from the year<br />

2045 imagining the development of CPUL’s in<br />

London, England. Though glamorized it provides<br />

a plausible account for what the city of<br />

London might look like and how it might function<br />

in 35 years if there were immediate development<br />

of CPUL’s.<br />

The account imagines what the life of a<br />

London farmer would be like day to day; harvesting<br />

and selling produce from localized<br />

kiosks, and enjoying a relaxed evening. It hypothesizes<br />

that by 2045 London will have<br />

stopped growing, and that the success of<br />

CPULs will “have grown alongside three main<br />

urban prerequisites: population stability, successful<br />

public transport and borough balance.”<br />

http://www.foodnut.com/431/borough-market-london-uk/<br />

http://golondon.about.com/od/thingstodoinlondon/ig/St-Jamess-Park-Photos/<br />

View-of-London-Eye.htm<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

“New Space for Old Space: An Urban Vision.” Katrin Bohn and Andre Viljoen: In: CPULs Continuous Productive Urban Landscapes:<br />

Designing Urban Agriculture for Sustainable Cities; Pgs: 4-16 Elsevier: Architectural Press; Oxford. Editors: Viljoen,


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Economics : Historic + Current Conditions<br />

HISTORY<br />

1950s Agriculture =<br />

80 % of Labor Force<br />

and<br />

50% Gross Domestic Product<br />

and<br />

90% of Exports<br />

1990s Agriculture =<br />

66 % of Labor Force<br />

and<br />

35% Gross Domestic Product<br />

and<br />

24% of Exports<br />

5% or National Budget =<br />

Ministry of Agriculture<br />

CURRENT<br />

66% of Haitians Depend upon<br />

small scale subsistence farming<br />

yet it only accounts for:<br />

23% of Gross Domestic Product<br />

Factors contributing to the decline of Haitis<br />

agriculture include low levels of agricultural<br />

technology, migration out of rural areas, insecure<br />

land ownership, a lack of capital investment,<br />

high commodity taxes, the low productivity<br />

of undernourished farmers, animal and<br />

plant diseases, and inadequate infrastructure.<br />

Low governmental investment in agricultural<br />

activities<br />

Cash Crops:<br />

Essential Oils<br />

Cocoa Beans<br />

Mangoes<br />

Coffee<br />

Food Crops:<br />

Rice<br />

Beans<br />

Avocados<br />

Pineapples<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

CIA World Factbook; https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ha.html. Updated: Jan 2011 [Accessed: Jan 2011]<br />

Haiti. Richard A. Ha ggerty, ed. Haiti: A Country Study. Washington: GPO for the Library of Congress, 1989. http://countrystudies.us/haiti/<br />

Agriculture, [Accessed: Jan 2011]<br />

http://earthtrends.wri.org/pdf_library/country_profiles/agr_cou_332.pdf [Accessed: Jan 2011]


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Economics : Current : Crops<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations http://faostat.fao.org/desktopdefault.aspx?pageid=342&lang=en&country=93


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Economics : Current : Crops<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations http://faostat.fao.org/desktopdefault.aspx?pageid=342&lang=en&country=93


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Economics : Current : Production v. Exports v. Imports<br />

1000 MT<br />

1000 MT<br />

Sugar<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

0<br />

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010<br />

Rice<br />

350<br />

300<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

0<br />

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010<br />

Coffee<br />

700<br />

Producon<br />

Exports<br />

Imports<br />

Producon<br />

Exports<br />

Imports<br />

1000 MT<br />

1000 MT<br />

Corn<br />

350<br />

300<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

0<br />

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010<br />

Wheat<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

0<br />

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010<br />

Cotton<br />

12<br />

Producon<br />

Exports<br />

Imports<br />

Producon<br />

Exports<br />

Imports<br />

Note:<br />

Production has decreased<br />

and imports have increased<br />

so dramatically in Sugar<br />

and Rice due to trade liberaliztion.<br />

In 1986 the International<br />

Monetary Fund (IMF)<br />

loaned Haiti 24 million<br />

dollars only if they lowered<br />

tariff protections for their<br />

Haitian rice and other agricultural<br />

products to open<br />

up the country’s markets to<br />

competition from outside<br />

countries.<br />

By 1988, so much American<br />

rice had invaded the country<br />

that it became unprofitable<br />

for many Haitian farmers<br />

to continue planting.<br />

1000 60 KG Bags<br />

600<br />

500<br />

400<br />

300<br />

200<br />

100<br />

Producon<br />

Exports<br />

Imports<br />

1000 480lb Bales<br />

10<br />

8<br />

6<br />

4<br />

2<br />

Producon<br />

Exports<br />

Imports<br />

This is compounded by the<br />

population explosion from<br />

5 million in 1990 to 9 million<br />

today<br />

0<br />

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010<br />

0<br />

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Schifferes, Steve. Haiti: An economic Basket-Case; BBC News Online Economics Report. [Updated: March 2004] [Accessed: Jan 2011]<br />

Stabroek Staff. Trade Liberalization Killed Haiti’s Rice Industry. Jan 2010. www.stabroeknews.com. [Accessed: Jan 2011]<br />

www.indexmundi.com/agriculture/?country=ht [Accessed: Jan 2011]


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Economics : Future<br />

Haiti National Agricultural Investment Plan, May 2010<br />

Priority sub-sectors and investment requirements,<br />

Donor Pledges Towards<br />

Haiti’s Agricultural<br />

Reconstruction<br />

Infrastructure<br />

Watershed development<br />

Reforestation<br />

Irrigation<br />

361 MILLION<br />

Inter-<br />

American<br />

Development<br />

Bank<br />

(IDB)<br />

200 MILLION<br />

Production and value chain development<br />

Livestock<br />

Aquaculture and fishing<br />

Crops<br />

Input provision<br />

Credit<br />

Value chain development<br />

Urban and peri-urban agriculture<br />

Local purchase of food aid<br />

346 MILLION<br />

United States<br />

Global<br />

Agriculture<br />

and Food<br />

Security<br />

Program<br />

(GAFSP)<br />

202 MILLION<br />

35 MILLION<br />

Agricultural services and institutions<br />

Extension<br />

Land access and tenure security<br />

Research, training, plant health, institutional support<br />

62 MILLION<br />

International<br />

Fund for<br />

Agricultural<br />

Development<br />

(IFAD)<br />

21 MILLION<br />

France<br />

7 MILLION<br />

TOTAL<br />

769 MILLION<br />

TOTAL<br />

465 MILLION<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Oxfam.org (accessed Jan. 2011) with:<br />

MARNDR (2010), National Agricultural Investment Plan, Port-au-Prince: MARNDR and:<br />

OCHA (http://www.reliefweb.int, accessed 17 September 2010); US government


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Economics : Case Study : Haitian_Mangoes<br />

PLAYERS<br />

Jean Maurice Buteau<br />

- Business Man<br />

- “MANGO MAN”<br />

Jealene Jermus<br />

- FARMER<br />

Pierre Brunache<br />

- USAID: MarChE<br />

- NGO<br />

PROBLEM<br />

Consumers in New York and Miami want mangoes, but Jean Maurice can’t meet the demand.<br />

Haiti acutally grows enough Mangoes to meet demand<br />

Farmers pick Mangoes, but do not clean or store properly for pick up. This results in<br />

marks and bruises on Mangoes, cannot conceptualize 21st century Americans caring about this.<br />

IDEA<br />

Clean the fruit, and transport it in a plastic crate to a facility that is not exposed to the sun<br />

CONCEPT<br />

Involve NGO:<br />

EDUCATE: Provide intermediary to train farmers to use crates, teach them why they would<br />

want to use them, how to accommodate the needs of people living in the 21st century America.<br />

INFRASTRUCTURE: Cant just hand out crates to thousands of dispersed farmers, rather you need a<br />

central place with a simple structure. “Picture a carport, ¼ acre of land with a hose, farmers will bring their mangoes, learn<br />

how to pack the crates correctly, and how to wash the mangoes.”<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

This American Life: Island Time- ACT ONE. 10,000 BRAINIACS Planet Money: National Public Radio News


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Economics : Case Study : Haitian_Mangoes<br />

STEP ONE:<br />

LAND<br />

Jean Maurice contacts someone who knows<br />

Jealene, and puts them in contact with eachother.<br />

Jealene is a Mango farmer with alot of land<br />

looking to possibly double her profits<br />

to $4/day. Jealene must convince over<br />

60 family members, who have claim to land<br />

to donate. After months<br />

of conversation the family agrees to donate.<br />

STEP TWO:<br />

BUILD?<br />

Mid 2008 Late 2008<br />

Jean Maurice contacts Pierre and MarChE<br />

to let them know that land has been<br />

donated and they can begin building<br />

the Mango Carport<br />

NGO [MarChE] tells Jean Maurice, “Great, we<br />

just need to see a copy of the deed..<br />

STEP THREE:<br />

THE DEED<br />

Early 2009<br />

Jealenes family has an ‘understanding’<br />

with original family who owned the land,<br />

but no one knows where to find<br />

original family or deed.<br />

Finally a brother remembers an uncle<br />

who kept papers and was currently<br />

in New York. He sent papers and<br />

deed arrives<br />

STEP FOUR:<br />

THE TRANSFER<br />

Transfer of land deed takes 100s of<br />

steps and 100s of dollars. Not in<br />

NGO’s budget; “DON’T CHANGE THE<br />

BUDGET. ”<br />

Sometimes things happen.. have to find<br />

money<br />

MarChE finds Money<br />

FINAL STEP:<br />

COOPERATIVE<br />

Mid 2009 DEC. 2009<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

SUCCESS they get to the last step.<br />

December 29th, A year and a half after<br />

they began, farmers form cooperative,<br />

and bring document to<br />

Ministry of Social Affairs in Port Au<br />

Prince.<br />

DISASTER<br />

JAN. 2010<br />

EARTHQUAKE:<br />

START OVER?...<br />

2010...<br />

Document that recognizes them,<br />

was at ministry of social affairs, and<br />

this ministry has been “flattened like<br />

a pancake.”<br />

USAID cut funding of MarChE<br />

Mango season<br />

opens crate-less.<br />

This American Life: Island Time- ACT ONE. 10,000 BRAINIACS Planet Money: National Public Radio News


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Environment : Climate<br />

40<br />

35<br />

30<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

Yearly Average Precipitation and Temperature<br />

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec<br />

Precipitation (cm)<br />

Average Temperature (C)<br />

http://www.climatetemp.info/haiti/<br />

Climate<br />

“Haiti has a generally hot and humid<br />

tropical climate. The north wind brings<br />

fog and drizzle, which interrupt Haiti's dry<br />

season from November to January. But during<br />

February through May, the weather is very wet.<br />

Northeast trade winds bring<br />

rains during the wet season.<br />

Rainfall is unevenly distributed.<br />

Heavier rainfall occurs in the southern<br />

peninsula and in the northern plains and<br />

mountains. Rainfall decreases from<br />

east to west across the northern<br />

peninsula. The eastern central region<br />

receives a moderate amount of precipitation,<br />

while the western coast from the northern<br />

peninsula to Port-au-Prince, the capital, is<br />

relatively dry”<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Richard A. Haggerty, ed. Haiti: A Country Study. Washington: GPO for the Library of Congress, 1989.


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Environment : Geography<br />

Geography<br />

Haiti is a country of only about 28,000<br />

square kilometers, about the size of the<br />

state of Maryland. It occupies the western third<br />

of the Caribbean island of Hispaniola<br />

The mainland of Haiti has three regions: the<br />

northern region, which includes the northern<br />

peninsula; the central<br />

region; and the southern region,<br />

which includes the southern peninsula. In<br />

addition, Haiti controls several nearby islands.<br />

http://www.intute.ac.uk/worldguide/html/905_map.html<br />

Numerous rivers and streams, which slow to a<br />

trickle during the dry season and which carry<br />

torrential flows during the wet season, cross<br />

Haiti's plains and mountainous areas. The<br />

largest drainage system in the<br />

country is that of the Artibonite<br />

River.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Richard A. Haggerty, ed. Haiti: A Country Study. Washington: GPO for the Library of Congress, 1989.


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Environment : Land Use<br />

Land area (‘000 ha): 2 756<br />

Arable land (‘000 ha): 780<br />

Proportion of Arable Land : 28%<br />

Permanent crops (‘000 ha): 320<br />

Forest areas (‘000 ha): 105<br />

Irrigated land (‘000 ha): 92<br />

http://www.fao.org/countryprofiles/maps.asp?iso3=HTI&lang=en<br />

Share in total water use by<br />

* agriculture: 93.9%<br />

* industry: 1%<br />

* domestic use: 5.1%<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.fao.org/countries/55528/en/hti/


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Environment : Average Precipitation and Crop Calendar<br />

http://www.fao.org/giews/countrybrief/country.jsp?code=HTI<br />

http://www.bestcountryreports.com/Precipitation_Map_Haiti.html<br />

Haiti’s growing season is year round<br />

There are 2 rainy seasons in Haiti: April-<br />

May and August-October<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.southtravels.com/america/haiti/weather.html


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Environment : Erosion & Deforestation<br />

“The combination of widespread deforestation and the<br />

recent earthquake in Haiti could lead to more landslides in<br />

the already hard-hit country, scientists say (Haiti map).<br />

Many of Haiti's people, the poorest in the Americas,<br />

routinely cut down trees for fuel—either to burn "raw" or<br />

turn into charcoal.<br />

As a result, the destruction of Haiti's natural forests is almost<br />

total, making the Caribbean country one<br />

of the most deforested in the world.<br />

As Haiti's trees have disappeared, landslides have become a<br />

major concern, especially during the rainy season, and the<br />

destabilizing effects of an earthquake on soil only worsen<br />

the problem.<br />

Forest canopies serve as natural buffers against wind and<br />

rain, and the deep roots of trees help keep the granular soil<br />

from shifting.<br />

"If you remove the trees, you have no buffer. So the<br />

water"—and soil—"tends to very quickly move downhill,"<br />

said Mark Ashton, a professor at the Yale School of Forestry<br />

and Environmental Studies.” -National Geographic<br />

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/01/100114-haiti-earthquake-landslides/<br />

The loss of topsoil is devastating to the<br />

practice of agriculture, as nutrients that have<br />

been built up over thousands of years and stored in the soil<br />

can be washed away in a matter of days or years.<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

Than, Ker. “Haiti Earthquake, Deforestation Heighten Landside Risk.” National Geographic News Jan 14, 2010 [Accessed Jan 2011]<br />

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/01/100114-haiti-earthquake-landslides/


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Agriculture : Environment : Case Study : Cuba_Urban Agriculture<br />

‘Urban Agriculture in Havana: Opportunities for the<br />

Future,’ “describes the innovative and comprehensive model<br />

supporting food production within the boundaries of its cities<br />

using a combination of top-down and bottom-up approaches.<br />

With the collapse of the eastern Europe block, and increased<br />

economic and trade sanctions by the United States, in the<br />

1990’s Cuba lost more than 75 percent of its import and export<br />

capacity and was forced to find new ways to supply food to its<br />

citizens.<br />

After 1990, reform was passed in Cuba called the National<br />

Alternative Agriculture Model (NAAM). Similar to Haiti’s current<br />

situation is that Cuba restructured its land property patterns<br />

from the large state-owned farms into smaller units with cooperative<br />

property. This dissemination of land came with support<br />

to many of the new farmers through advice, material support<br />

and encouragement in the management of agricultural<br />

activities, from the Ministry of Agriculture.<br />

There have been many benefits in Cuba, due to urban<br />

agriculture, in social, economic, and environmental dimensions,<br />

including food production and nutritional values, the creation<br />

of jobs, reduced food prices, and organic production methods.<br />

Though Cuba was largely forced to develop its urban agricultural<br />

practices out of necessity, it provides an interesting and<br />

unique case study into the how a small Caribbean Nation like<br />

Haiti might successfully develop agriculture within Port-au-<br />

Prince.<br />

http://www.urbanhabitat.org/node/4845<br />

http://www.treehugger.com/files/2009/05/urban-agriculture-in-cities.php<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion<br />

Agriculture<br />

“Urban Agriculture in Havana: Opportunities for the future.” Jorge Pena Diaz and Professor Phil Harris In: CPULs Continuous Productive Urban<br />

Landscapes: Designing Urban Agriculture for Sustainable Cities; Pgs: 136-145 Elsevier: Architectural Press; Oxford. Editors: Viljoen, Andre; Bohn,


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

<strong>Natural</strong> Hazards<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.reliefweb.int/rw/rwb.nsf/db900sid/MNIN-82YTA9?OpenDocument&query=haiti%20multi-hazard


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Haiti is extremely susceptible to natural<br />

disasters due to many factors.<br />

– High Poverty levels<br />

– Inadaquate building code regulations<br />

and . enforcement<br />

– Loss of stable natural protection due to<br />

deforestation<br />

– Disruption of natural water sheds<br />

– Over population<br />

– Inadaquate disaster response plans<br />

Images: http://www.architectureweek.com/2010/0407/building_1-1.html<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disasters<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.reliefweb.int/rw/rwb.nsf/db900sid/RKRR-8CDR8W?OpenDocument&query=haiti


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

<strong>Natural</strong> Hazards<br />

The January 12th earthquake was compounded<br />

by other events, caused by, and<br />

occurring right after the earthquake.<br />

– The outbreak of cholera exacerbated,<br />

if not caused, by overcrowding<br />

and inadequate sanitary conditions in<br />

displacement camps, land and mud<br />

slides caused by the earthquake,<br />

tropical storms and hurricane Tomas,<br />

and flooding caused by the rainy<br />

season.<br />

http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=haiti-cholera-death-toll-soars-as-election-nears-2010-11-15<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.cdc.gov/haiticholera/update/


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Cholera<br />

http://haiti.humanitarianresponse.info/Portals/0/hti_cholera_cases_110127.pdf<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Erosion<br />

Images taken from Google Earth<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Disaster: Chile compared with Haiti<br />

• Severity of the Disaster was enhanced by<br />

proximity to large populated area.<br />

• When Compared to the February 27th<br />

earthquake in Chile which registered an<br />

8.8 on the Moment Magnitude Scale and<br />

officially killed 452, the Haiti 7.0 earthquake<br />

was far more catastrophic with an<br />

estimated 222,570 deaths..<br />

• Many factors are attributed this difference<br />

in severity.<br />

•<br />

According to USGS reports, compared to<br />

the Chile event, the Haiti earthquake was<br />

shallower, much closer to a large population<br />

center, and highly concentrated<br />

relative to its magnitude value.<br />

• Chile also has very strict seismic building<br />

codes.<br />

http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/blogs/opinionator/arieff/infographicXL.jpg<br />

• “Shake maps” created using the Modified<br />

Mercalli Intensity Scale indicate that haiti<br />

had vastly more structures, occupied by<br />

as many more people, subjected to the<br />

highest levels of shaking<br />

http://www.architectureweek.com/2010/0407/building_1-1.html<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Disaster: Chile compared with Haiti<br />

Extreme example of concrete failure.<br />

The USGS/ EERI<br />

Advance Reconnaissance<br />

Team found<br />

that smooth steel<br />

with inadequately<br />

sized hooks was used<br />

in reinforcing the<br />

concrete of the Hotel<br />

Montana.<br />

http://www.architectureweek.com/cgibin/awimage?dir=2010/0407&article=building_1-2.html&image=14595_image_10.jpg<br />

http://www.architectureweek.com/cgibin/awimage?dir=2010/0407&article=building_1-3.html&image=14596_image_3.jpg<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Earthquakes<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.reliefweb.int/rw/rwb.nsf/db900sid/JOPA-7ZNJWW?OpenDocument


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Earthquakes<br />

• Walter Mooney, a USGS<br />

earthquake expert who<br />

traveled to Haiti as part<br />

of the USGS/ EERI Ad -<br />

vance Reconnaissance<br />

Team says that “The<br />

future is not rosy. They<br />

have to be prepared for<br />

another event of equal<br />

magnitude” within the<br />

next 10 to 20 years, he<br />

says. “Historically, that’s<br />

what happens.”<br />

http://www.architectureweek.com/2010/0407/building_1-1.html<br />

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010/01/18/world/americas/0118-haiti-assess-maps.html<br />

Diagram of the reactions of the 2010 earthquake along Haiti’s southern strike-slip fault<br />

near Port-au-Prince<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Port-a-Piment Watershed<br />

– The Port-a-Piment watershed faces a series<br />

of challenges common throughout Haiti,<br />

vulnerable populations, deteriorating<br />

ecosystems and decreasing yields with a<br />

high livelihood dependency on natural<br />

resource extraction.<br />

– Reports indicated that substantial temporary<br />

in-migration to Port-a-Piment since the<br />

earthquake has increased the population,<br />

exacerbated pressure on natural resources,<br />

and led to food insecurity.<br />

(http://www.haitiregeneration.org/piment_mvp)<br />

http://www.haitiregeneration.org/sites/default/files/HRI_ExecutiveSummary_v1-lowres.pdf<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture<br />

http://www.haitiregeneration.org/sites/default/files/images/project%20area%20map.jpg


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Port-a-Piment Watershed<br />

Watersheds major challenges:<br />

– Extremely low yields for virtually all forms of agriculture<br />

– Unsustainable and environmentally destructive livestock<br />

production<br />

– Low agricultural diversity and minimal rotations and fallow<br />

and nutrient depleted soils<br />

– Destructive cultivation of hillside steep slope zones in the<br />

absence of anti-erosion structures and appropriate long-term<br />

vegetative cover, resulting in massive erosion and<br />

permanent productivity losses.<br />

– Unsustainable harvest of woody biomass, mainly for the<br />

charcoal market, resulting in deforestation and soil erosion<br />

– Problematic land tenure, which constrains efforts to invest in<br />

and sustainable production.<br />

http://www.haitiregeneration.org/sites/default/files/HRI_ExecutiveSummary_v1-lowres.pdf<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture<br />

Images: http://www.haitiregeneration.org/taxonomy/term/30


<strong>Natural</strong> <strong>Systems</strong><br />

Port-a-Piment Watershed<br />

Port-a-Piment Watershed Program <strong>Natural</strong> Hazards<br />

Objectives<br />

The overall objective for the environment sector is to<br />

stop and reverse the trends of environmental degradation<br />

across the watershed. Interventionswill focus on<br />

new techniques for sustainable charcoal production<br />

and rebuilding ecosystem services through innovative<br />

payment schemes and education campaigns. Interventions<br />

willinclude participatory mapping activities to promote<br />

better land use management, the establishment<br />

of tree nurseries, an anti-erosion training program, a<br />

disaster risk reduction program, and a community forestry<br />

and<br />

woodlot program.<br />

(http://www.haitiregeneration.org/piment_mvp)<br />

Deforestation/Reforestation<br />

Erosion/<strong>Natural</strong> Disaster<br />

Agriculture

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!