African Traditional Herbal Research Clinic THE ... - Blackherbals.com
African Traditional Herbal Research Clinic THE ... - Blackherbals.com
African Traditional Herbal Research Clinic THE ... - Blackherbals.com
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Nigeria: Pfizer to Pay<br />
N11.2bn Compensation<br />
How Gowon, Carter Negotiated Out-of-Court<br />
Settlement<br />
Nuruddeen M. Abdallah<br />
1 March 2009<br />
Daily Trust<br />
Abuja — United States pharmaceutical giant, Pfizer,<br />
may have finally agreed to release the sum of $75<br />
million (about N11.250 billion) as <strong>com</strong>pensation over<br />
the 1996 Trovan drug test in Kano State, Sunday Trust<br />
can authoritatively report.<br />
The experiment left over 200 persons, mainly children,<br />
with deformities. Some have died.<br />
A source close to the <strong>com</strong>pany told Sunday Trust last<br />
night in a telephone interview that of the amount, $35<br />
million is going to be shared among the victims as<br />
<strong>com</strong>pensation; $30 million will be paid to Kano State<br />
Government for the construction of modern hospitals;<br />
and the remaining $10 million will be paid to cover<br />
litigation expenses by government on behalf of the<br />
victims.<br />
This development, it was gathered, was the drug<br />
<strong>com</strong>pany's response to a proposal submitted to it in a<br />
meeting held last month in Abuja by the stakeholders'<br />
delegation that included the Kano State Attorney-<br />
General and Commissioner for Justice, Aliyu Umar, a<br />
representative of the victims' parents, Mustapha<br />
Maisikeli, Barrister Maryam Uwais, and the state<br />
Commissioner for Health, Hajiya Aisha Isiyaku Kiru,<br />
the former Head of State, General Yakubu Gowon (rtd)<br />
and former American President Jimmy Carter.<br />
The two former presidents have been brokering an outof-court<br />
resolution of the issue. It was gathered also<br />
that General Gowon has intimated Governor Ibrahim<br />
Shekarau about the giant <strong>com</strong>pany's acceptance of the<br />
proposal. The deal will be sealed in Rome in March this<br />
year.<br />
"The money would be finally released to us in March in<br />
Rome when we are going to meet with General Gowon<br />
and Pfizer's representatives to finalise the deal," a<br />
parent of a victim told this newspaper.<br />
According to him, it is only when the agreement is<br />
written and the money received that the stakeholders<br />
would withdraw both the civil and criminal suits<br />
pending against Pfizer.<br />
When Sunday Trust contacted the drug <strong>com</strong>pany over<br />
the issue, its spokesman Christopher Loder, said in a<br />
statement issued in New York that "the <strong>com</strong>pany does<br />
not believe it is appropriate to <strong>com</strong>ment on the<br />
substance of its discussions with the governments at<br />
this time".<br />
"The Company has made and continued to make<br />
serious efforts to reach an appropriate and amicable<br />
resolution of the Nigerian federal and Kano state cases<br />
pertaining to Trovan. The settlement process is<br />
ongoing, and Pfizer is prepared to stay at the<br />
negotiating table until agreement are reached. We<br />
believe that settlement is in the best interest of all<br />
parties, and will avoid the continued cost and<br />
distraction of litigation, and can help improve and<br />
expand health care for the people of Nigeria," the<br />
statement said.<br />
This settlement follows months of negotiations between<br />
Pfizer and the Kano state government, representing the<br />
victims. The talks were brokered by General Gowon<br />
and US former president Jimmy Carter.<br />
It could be recalled that Kano State had filed civil and<br />
criminal suits against Pfizer, demanding $2.75 billion<br />
in <strong>com</strong>pensation for what it said was an illegal test of<br />
the meningitis vaccine Trovan on 200 children in 1996.<br />
Eleven of those children are alleged to have died from<br />
the drug test which also caused deformities in 189<br />
others. A separate $6.5 billion suit has been lodged<br />
against the US drug firm by the Nigerian federal<br />
government.<br />
Pfizer has denied any wrong-doing and insisted that the<br />
trial conformed to ethical practices and was carried out<br />
with the consent of the Nigerian government, insisting<br />
that "the <strong>com</strong>pany has said all along that all clinical<br />
evidence points to the fact that any deaths or injuries<br />
were the direct result of the devastating meningitis<br />
epidemic, and not the treatment provided to patients in<br />
the Trovan clinical study. With a survival rate of<br />
94.4%, Trovan helped save lives and was at least as<br />
effective as the best treatment available at Kano's<br />
Infectious Disease Hospital (IDH). For patients who<br />
did not participate in the Trovan clinical study, the<br />
survival rate was slightly less than 90%," Pfizer<br />
insisted in a statement.<br />
A source closed to the victims told our reporter in<br />
confidence that it was not true the rumour going round<br />
that it was the government that pressurized them to<br />
accept the drug giant's proposal. The decision, he said,<br />
was borne out of sympathy with the victims and their<br />
parents, as some of them had already died of<br />
frustration.<br />
-30- <strong>Traditional</strong> <strong>African</strong> <strong>Clinic</strong> April 2009<br />
http://allafrica.<strong>com</strong>/stories/200903010014.html<br />
☻☻☻☻☻☻