02.12.2014 Views

ANNUAL REPORT 2008 - The New York Landmarks Conservancy

ANNUAL REPORT 2008 - The New York Landmarks Conservancy

ANNUAL REPORT 2008 - The New York Landmarks Conservancy

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> <strong>2008</strong>


Contents<br />

From the President 2<br />

Speaking Out for Preservation 3<br />

Providing Technical Expertise 7<br />

Preserving Sacred Sites 10<br />

Funding Historic Properties 15<br />

Assisting Nonprofits 18<br />

Honoring Excellence 21<br />

Celebrating Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> 24<br />

Special Events 27<br />

Our Supporters 28<br />

Financial Statements 33<br />

Board of Directors and Staff 34<br />

Photo Credits<br />

page 3<br />

page 4, bottom<br />

page 5, left<br />

page 5, right<br />

page 6, top<br />

page 6, bottom<br />

page 7<br />

page 21<br />

page 22, top<br />

page 22, middle<br />

page 22, bottom<br />

page 23, top<br />

page 23, middle<br />

page 23, bottom<br />

courtesy of Governors Island Alliance/ Joseph R. Melanson — www.skypic.com<br />

courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />

courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />

courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />

courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />

courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />

photo by Aalto Archives, Helsinki<br />

photo by Stephen Aviano, courtesy of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine<br />

courtesy of Wank Adams Slavin Associates LLP<br />

courtesy of Wank Adams Slavin Associates LLP<br />

courtesy of the Lawrence Group<br />

courtesy of Kostow Greenwood Architects LLP<br />

courtesy of Platt Byard Dovell White Architects LLP<br />

courtesy of Kaitsen Woo Architect, P.C.<br />

Additional photography by <strong>Conservancy</strong> staff.<br />

Printing by Lexicon Communications.


From the President<br />

Even as the <strong>Conservancy</strong> experienced the economic shocks faced by so many this year, we continued to fulfill our singular mission: to assist homeowners<br />

and stewards of historic buildings that hold our common architectural heritage. Helping people maintain their homes, nonprofits, and religious<br />

institutions is central to <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>’s economy and quality of life. Maintaining the fabric of our City is especially urgent now.<br />

It is sometimes hard to convey how much we do in a year. We are at the forefront of major issues like Moynihan Station and Governors Island. But much<br />

of our work involves important though little-known buildings far from the center of Manhattan. A lot of it isn’t glamorous — just essential. Fixing leaky<br />

roofs, re-facing crumbling brownstone, helping a community development group create affordable housing in a lovely old building, or assisting a small<br />

congregation with making their church or synagogue more energy efficient.<br />

We are the only ones doing this work.<br />

Five of our low-interest loans this year helped owners in Brooklyn clean and restore brownstone façades, stoops, and ironwork. Our grants to nonprofit<br />

community developers helped with plans to upgrade a former Brooklyn firehouse that now houses low-income apartments and helped turn a former<br />

meeting hall in the Bronx into apartments and retail space.<br />

Our Sacred Sites Program awarded more than a half-million dollars to 51 landmark religious institutions throughout the state. We helped Maspeth,<br />

Queens residents pull off an eleventh-hour rescue of a rare Richard Upjohn-designed church. We usually fight to keep buildings up. But when this rare<br />

survivor couldn’t be moved intact from a development site, we helped find funding and expertise to disassemble and store it. We will continue to work<br />

with the community to rebuild the former church nearby and put it into community use. We also helped the oldest synagogue in Queens with funding<br />

and attaining landmark status.<br />

We are making unprecedented efforts to expand our assistance. We have created new National Register Historic Districts by researching, surveying,<br />

and analyzing areas in Harlem, the Bronx and Brooklyn. <strong>The</strong> State approved our work and officially created these new districts. <strong>The</strong>se listings make the<br />

hundreds of buildings in these areas eligible for our loans and grants.<br />

We continued our multi-year survey of religious institutions to identify Catholic churches and synagogues in need of our technical and financial help.<br />

We shared the results of our Brooklyn Roman Catholic church survey with the Brooklyn-Queens Diocese. We will also prepare nominations to the<br />

National Register for 10 Brooklyn and Queens synagogues we have identified. We intend to survey churches from other denominations in the future.<br />

After years of <strong>Conservancy</strong> pressure, the Gothic revival Renwick Ruin on Roosevelt Island is being stabilized. <strong>The</strong> ruin has tantalized East Side residents<br />

and drivers on the FDR for years. It may now serve as the centerpiece of a new park to be built adjacent to the landmark. And after years of<br />

our working with a broad alliance dedicated to saving St. Brigid’s, an anonymous donor has pledged enough money to restore the oldest surviving Irish<br />

immigrant-built church in the City.<br />

Thank you for recognizing how vital our programs are to <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>’s current — and long-term — viability, and thank you for making our work possible.<br />

Peg Breen, President<br />

2


Speaking Out for Preservation<br />

Governors Island


<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> is a respected voice for<br />

preservation, often leading major campaigns on important issues.<br />

We also advocate for sound preservation laws and policies at the<br />

Federal, State, and local level.<br />

Keeping Governors Island Open to the Public<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> has been a long-time advocate for Governors Island, the<br />

former military facility which has been transformed into a center for tourism,<br />

arts, and recreation; and received a record number of visitors in <strong>2008</strong>.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Island’s 52 historic buildings (including two 19th-century forts) create<br />

a unique cultural and educational experience. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> is a charter<br />

member of the Governors Island Alliance and has supported efforts<br />

to find new uses for the Island while maintaining its historic resources.<br />

When the State announced that it would cut funds for the Island and endanger<br />

its operating budget, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> stepped forward, lobbying<br />

State and City officials to ensure that the $6 million from the State would<br />

be included in the 2010 budget and matched by the City. Future capital<br />

improvements are scheduled to include new park and open space facilities<br />

and stabilization of the historic houses.<br />

Continuing the Fight for Moynihan Station<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> continued to push for a great Moynihan Station despite<br />

the change in State administrations, and we promoted the station as an<br />

important stimulus during the economic downturn.<br />

Plans for Moynihan Station shifted direction after Governor David Paterson<br />

assumed the reins of State government in March. Shortly after that,<br />

Madison Square Garden said it was abandoning plans to move into the<br />

rear of the landmark Farley Post Office and would instead renovate the<br />

existing Garden.<br />

In a speech in September, Governor Paterson said he hoped to build the<br />

Station as the gateway to <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> envisioned by the late Senator Daniel<br />

Patrick Moynihan in the early 1990s. <strong>The</strong> governor said he wanted<br />

a transportation project, first and foremost, not the real estate project<br />

the proposed developers had envisioned. He also requested that the Port<br />

Authority take over the project. Paterson called for: increasing transportation<br />

capacity by expanding the number of tracks under Farley; coordinating<br />

with other major development projects, especially ARC, a new <strong>New</strong><br />

Jersey Transit tunnel under the Hudson; and ensuring that the station was<br />

a development catalyst for Manhattan’s Upper West Side. He asked for a<br />

staff report by October 31 on the station challenges and solutions.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>, along with other “Friends of Moynihan Station” members,<br />

welcomed the new direction and expressed support. We also continued<br />

to emphasize the importance of protecting Farley’s landmark exterior<br />

and beautiful post office lobby.<br />

By year’s end, the Moynihan Station report still was not public. But we<br />

continue to say, “Build Farley now.”<br />

top <strong>The</strong> grand columns of Farley Post Office<br />

bottom Silver Towers at NYU<br />

4


Supporting Landmark Designations<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s testimony – before the <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation<br />

Commission and the City Council – helped achieve designations of<br />

historic districts and individual buildings across the City in <strong>2008</strong>.<br />

We supported the creation of five new districts:<br />

<strong>The</strong> West Chelsea Historic District and NoHo Historic District Extension<br />

recognize the significance of the industrial building. West Chelsea is composed<br />

of late 19th and early 20th century buildings originally used for<br />

manufacturing. <strong>The</strong> third phase of the NoHo designation adds a gritty mix<br />

of 56 buildings exemplifying the range of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>’s architectural styles,<br />

from Federal to Italianate to contemporary design.<br />

Brooklyn districts ranged from the very small to very large. Alice and Agate<br />

Courts in central Brooklyn are two block-long cul-de-sacs of picturesque<br />

Queen Anne row houses. <strong>The</strong> Prospect Heights Historic District contains<br />

more than 800 row houses, and apartment and institutional buildings from<br />

the late 19th and early 20th centuries, with many intact blocks of beautiful<br />

Italianate, neo-Grec, and Second Empire brownstones.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Ridgewood North Historic District, located in southwest Queens,<br />

contains 96 buildings from 1908 — 11 known for their distinguished brick<br />

façades, and for the progressive innovations in the residential tenement<br />

form that they feature.<br />

We also supported fifteen individual landmark designations, including:<br />

Religious properties. Congregation Tifereth Israel in Corona, Queens, and<br />

two churches in the East Village: James Renwick Jr.’s Gothic-style masterpiece,<br />

St. Nicholas of Myra Orthodox Church, and the Russian Orthodox<br />

Cathedral of the Holy Virgin Protection.<br />

Three very different structures within Manhattan. <strong>The</strong> Consolidated Edison<br />

Building, with its clock tower that is visible for miles; McKim Mead<br />

and White’s Hotel Pennsylvania, facing development pressures; and the<br />

Rainbow Room, in Rockefeller Center.<br />

A number of buildings outside Manhattan. <strong>The</strong> Hubbard House at 2138<br />

McDonald Avenue, in Gravesend, Brooklyn, one of the few remaining<br />

Dutch-style houses in the City; the George Cunningham Store in Tottenville,<br />

Staten Island, distinguished by Queen Anne details such as wooden<br />

clapboards and fish-scale shingles; and the Museum Building at the <strong>New</strong><br />

<strong>York</strong> Botanical Garden, which won the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Lucy G. Moses Preservation<br />

Award when it was restored in 2004.<br />

Three buildings used by institutions of higher learning. I.M. Pei’s Silver<br />

Towers complex at NYU, which Robert A.M Stern called “one of the 35<br />

most important Modernist buildings in the City”; 144 West 14th Street, a<br />

seven-story Renaissance-Revival building from 1895-96, now the home<br />

of the Pratt Institute’s Historic Preservation program; and the Baumann<br />

Bros. Building on East 14th Street, best known for its elaborate cast-iron<br />

façade, and now owned by the <strong>New</strong> School.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> continued to advocate for school buildings designed by<br />

C.B.J. Snyder by speaking out for designation of Grammar School No. 9<br />

on West End Avenue.<br />

left Grammar School No. 9, Manhattan<br />

right Alice Court, Brooklyn<br />

5


Speaking Out on Issues<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Public Policy Committee reviewed design proposals<br />

throughout <strong>2008</strong> and approved statements of its views for public hearings<br />

before various agencies.<br />

A proposal by St. Vincent’s Hospital engaged the preservation community<br />

and the <strong>Conservancy</strong> in <strong>2008</strong>. St. Vincent’s presented plans to demolish<br />

all of its historic and contemporary buildings, put up a new hospital where<br />

the O’Toole Building now stands on Seventh Avenue, and sell land that<br />

would become the site of a large residential development. <strong>The</strong> Committee<br />

supported demolition of O’Toole, but did not agree with the loss of other<br />

historic buildings, and suggested that the new hospital’s size be reduced.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Committee supported aspects of a plan to revitalize the South Street<br />

Seaport, but objected to new buildings that would overwhelm the lowrise<br />

structures that comprise the Seaport Historic District.<br />

A transfer of development rights from the General Society for Mechanics<br />

and Tradesmen on West 44th Street to a site at Fifth Avenue and 43rd<br />

Street was found to result in a valid “preservation purpose.” <strong>The</strong> proceeds<br />

of the transfer will finance necessary restoration on the Society’s<br />

landmark building.<br />

Upon reviewing a proposal to transfer development rights from St. Thomas<br />

Church and the University Club to a nearby site west of the Museum<br />

Tower on West 53rd Street, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> requested that restricted<br />

endowments be created for both landmarks, with at least part of the<br />

proceeds from the sale of the air rights specifically targeted for the up<br />

keep of the historic buildings. <strong>The</strong> developers agreed to the request. <strong>The</strong><br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong> also pointed out that the proposed new building would encroach<br />

on a preservation district.<br />

top Prospect Heights, Brooklyn<br />

bottom 144 West 14th Street, Manhattan<br />

Endangered Buildings Initiative<br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong> staff visited the buildings on its EBI “red list” to update their status. Thanks to either landmark designation or owner intervention,<br />

approximately a quarter of the “red” buildings will be removed from the list, as they no longer appear to be threatened.<br />

One of EBI’s successes is the 2005 designation of the Windermere Apartments as an individual landmark. Designed by <strong>The</strong>ophilius Smith in 1880-<br />

81, the Windermere is a complex of three red brick tenement buildings with decorative features in the Gothic, Queen Anne, and Romanesque<br />

styles. Originally it was used as housing for single women, an innovation in the late 19th century. By 2000 the deteriorated building was nearly<br />

empty, but still retained much of its magnificent historic fabric. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> led the push to get it designated.<br />

In <strong>2008</strong>, with the assistance of the Department of Housing Preservation and Development, the Windermere’s tenants brought the building owners<br />

to court to demand that they address various violations the building had earned. HPD filed two other motions: one to seek access to inspect the<br />

property and another to secure it. That motion was granted, and the owner was ordered to secure and seal the building. <strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Law<br />

Department filed an injunction and civil penalties action under the <strong>Landmarks</strong> Law. We hope that this legal pressure will force the owner to either<br />

sell the property or make repairs.<br />

6


Providing Technical Expertise<br />

Edgar J Kaufmann Conference Center, Manhattan


Government agencies, nonprofits, and building owners call upon<br />

our Technical Services staff for expert guidance on restoration<br />

projects, preservation easements, and advisory committees.<br />

Project Guidance<br />

Renwick Ruins, Roosevelt Island, Manhattan<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> has been monitoring the progress of the stabilization<br />

and restoration of the Renwick-designed Smallpox Hospital ruins sited at<br />

the southern tip of Roosevelt Island. <strong>The</strong> goal is to stabilize the structure<br />

as a picturesque ruin so that it may eventually form the centerpiece of a<br />

new public park that will fill the southern tip of the island. Many of the<br />

building’s teetering stones were removed, numbered, and stored on site.<br />

Other features, including the beautiful Gothic-revival oriel windows, have<br />

been dismantled and will be reassembled. In order to brace the walls,<br />

steel piers will be installed inside the building and cables will ensure that<br />

the walls remain in place.<br />

Edgar J Kaufmann Conference Center, Manhattan<br />

After several months of detective work, technical staff has tracked down<br />

the specific type and color of carpeting originally specified by Alvar and<br />

Alisa Aalto for the suite of rooms known as the “Aalto Rooms” – or, more<br />

accurately, the Kaufmann Conference Center at the Institute of International<br />

Education (IIE). <strong>The</strong> original textile was a 100 percent wool carpet<br />

composed of three different earth tones woven in a random pattern to produce<br />

a speckled effect. It also featured an egg-shaped cutout section that<br />

could be unzipped and removed when the occasion called for a dance floor<br />

to be moved in. In late October, the IIE received our report and a sample<br />

of the textile, which was custom-woven by the same North Carolina mill<br />

that produced the original.<br />

Several years ago, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> oversaw the restoration of the center’s<br />

suite of rooms, including repair and repainting of the plaster walls<br />

and undulating ceiling, gentle cleaning of the woodwork paneling trim<br />

and sculptural elements, as well as the replacement of its very tall curtains<br />

with a custom-made reproduction of the original textile, which we<br />

also traced back to the original manufacturer.<br />

Picasso Curtain, Four Seasons Restaurant, Manhattan<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> retained a team of fabric and paint conservators to inspect<br />

and clean a theater curtain painted by Pablo Picasso in 1911, which<br />

now hangs in the Four Seasons restaurant in the Seagram Building. This<br />

gorgeous piece was donated to the <strong>Conservancy</strong> in 2006 with the stipulation<br />

that it not be moved from its current location and that the <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />

oversee its care and maintenance. We arranged to have art and<br />

fabric conservators inspect and clean the artwork over the course of two<br />

weekends in late August. <strong>The</strong> results of the gentle cleaning of the textile<br />

are noticeable, and today the artwork looks brighter and crisper.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> received a full conservation report from the team in late<br />

September. <strong>The</strong> painted curtain, though fragile, shows no signs of ongoing<br />

deterioration and was found to be in stable condition.<br />

8


Old Guard of the City of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Headquarters, Manhattan<br />

<strong>The</strong> Old Guard is a military veterans association founded in 1832. It owns<br />

an historic limestone-fronted townhouse on 91st Street between Riverside<br />

Drive and West End Avenue that serves as the association’s headquarters.<br />

<strong>The</strong> building dates to 1899 and is part of a row of seven houses<br />

designed as an ensemble. It is in generally good condition, but has suffered<br />

from deferred maintenance. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Technical Services<br />

Center undertook a roof-to-basement inspection of the house in order to<br />

prepare an exiting conditions report of the property and establish priorities<br />

for restoration and repair. <strong>The</strong> masonry façades, including the dramatic<br />

bow-fronted limestone front, are in very good condition. However, the<br />

roofs need to be replaced in their entirety. Rainwater is leaking in various<br />

places, causing quite a bit of damage to interior finishes. Additionally, the<br />

front mansard roof, originally clad in terra cotta tiles, is currently missing<br />

them and in need of restoration. An ongoing project, we continue to meet<br />

with representatives from the Old Guard to plan a campaign of roof repair.<br />

European Union House, Manhattan<br />

Technical Services staff are consultants to the architect overseeing the<br />

restoration of 240 East 72nd Street, a townhouse that will be the future<br />

home of the European Union’s Deputy Ambassador to the United Nations.<br />

Part of the project consisted of reconstructing unstable portions of the<br />

rear façade and adding a small conservatory to the back of the house. <strong>The</strong><br />

front façade is being restored to its original appearance; this includes the<br />

reconstruction of the front stoop, which was removed many years ago.<br />

prior page<br />

left and right Renwick Ruins, Roosevelt Island<br />

this page<br />

top<br />

bottom<br />

Picasso Curtain, Four Seasons, Manhattan<br />

Old Guard Headquarters, Manhattan<br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong> Easements<br />

Although the <strong>Conservancy</strong> was in active discussions with a<br />

number of property owners interested in donating a preservation<br />

easement to the <strong>Conservancy</strong>, we did not receive any new donations<br />

in <strong>2008</strong>. However, the staff prepared and submitted to the<br />

National Park Service several “Certification of Significance”<br />

applications. <strong>The</strong>se applications are the first step in the easement<br />

donation process. We look forward to accepting easement<br />

on the properties covered by these applications in 2009.<br />

In the meantime, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> maintained its regular schedule<br />

of inspection of all properties and identified several maintenance<br />

problems at several properties. All these issues have<br />

been addressed or are in the process of being addressed.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> currently holds 45 easements.<br />

9


Preserving Sacred Sites<br />

Ocean Parkway Jewish Center, Brooklyn


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Sacred Sites Program is one of the few programs<br />

in the country dedicated to the preservation of historic religious<br />

properties. Since its establishment in 1986, the program has<br />

awarded more than 1,000 grants, totaling almost $6 million, to more<br />

than 650 institutions throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State. In addition to offering<br />

restoration grants, the program has assisted hundreds of<br />

landmark-quality religious institutions with hands-on technical assistance<br />

and referrals, and offered workshops on the maintenance<br />

and repair of aging roofs, façades, and windows, and associated<br />

financial issues.<br />

For the first time since its launch in 2000, the Sacred Sites Robert<br />

W. Wilson Challenge Grant Program awarded grants in both January<br />

and June, with a total of $300,000 awarded in <strong>2008</strong>. Altogether,<br />

through its 3 grant programs, Sacred Sites awarded 57 grants totaling<br />

more than $550,000 to 51 landmark religious institutions in 33<br />

counties throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State.<br />

In the spring of <strong>2008</strong>, Sacred Sites Director Ann-Isabel Friedman<br />

attended a Historic Districts Council monthly roundtable. She presented<br />

information to a group of 30 neighborhood preservation<br />

advocates on the Sacred Sites Program and ongoing advocacy<br />

and outreach, Catholic church and synagogue surveys, and the<br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong>’s successful collaboration with the Brooklyn-Queens<br />

Diocese. Ms. Friedman encouraged attendees to reach out to their<br />

local religious institutions and participate as neighborhood partners<br />

in capital project planning. In June, Ms. Friedman presented<br />

at a two-day Preservation League of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State Colleagues’<br />

Workshop in Buffalo, focusing on state-wide Catholic church closure<br />

as well as urban property abandonment.<br />

Progress Report<br />

Church and Synagogue Surveys<br />

Sacred Sites staff presented the results of its Brooklyn Roman Catholic<br />

church survey to the Brooklyn-Queens Diocese in the spring. We highlighted<br />

the most significant Brooklyn churches, made recommendations<br />

for National Register listing, and explained which churches would be the<br />

best candidates for <strong>Conservancy</strong> and possible <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State restoration<br />

grant funding. Diocesan officials and real estate staff shared our enthusiasm<br />

for many of the Diocese’s most handsome and historic churches, requesting<br />

that the <strong>Conservancy</strong> share its data with the Diocese real estate<br />

staff and archives. In the summer, a team of three graduate interns from<br />

Columbia University and Pratt Institute extended the survey into Queens,<br />

documenting 100 Roman Catholic churches and 120 synagogues.<br />

As for our synagogue survey, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> was awarded a prestigious<br />

$20,000 Preserve <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> grant, the largest of 16 awarded to nonprofit<br />

groups throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State, to fund the preparation of National<br />

Register nominations for ten Brooklyn and Queens synagogues and former<br />

synagogues. We are also pleased to announce that Roy Zuckerberg, father<br />

of <strong>Conservancy</strong> board member Lloyd Zuckerberg, recently presented a<br />

lead gift to help launch an Historic Synagogues Fund. <strong>Conservancy</strong> efforts<br />

to identify additional donors are ongoing.<br />

top Sacred Sites grantee Grace Church, Lyons, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

bottom Jewish Center of Kings Highway, Brooklyn<br />

11


A Tale of Two Catholic Churches<br />

St. Brigid’s and St. Thomas the Apostle<br />

After several years of energetic community advocacy and fundraising, the<br />

Archdiocese of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> announced in May that an anonymous donor<br />

had offered $20 million to save the parish of St. Brigid’s in the East Village.<br />

<strong>The</strong> church, attributed to Patrick Keely, is the oldest surviving Irish<br />

immigrant-built church in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City and one of the City’s earliest<br />

Gothic Revival churches. <strong>The</strong> 1848 building features a relatively simple<br />

exterior and a soaring, vaulted interior. It closed in 2004 due to significant<br />

structural damage caused by deterioration of the original, below-grade<br />

wood piles.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Archdiocese began demolition work in 2006. Despite overwhelming<br />

odds, a committed and broad alliance of parishioners, East Village preservation<br />

advocates, and prominent Irish-American artists worked tirelessly<br />

to save the church. This unique coalition raised funds for expert legal help,<br />

obtaining a restraining order that barred the Archdiocese from any further<br />

demolition work. <strong>The</strong> lawsuit was dismissed in 2007 but upheld on appeal.<br />

<strong>The</strong> group received permission in January <strong>2008</strong> to bring the case<br />

to the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State Supreme Court. Before the court convened, the<br />

Archdiocese announced the anonymous donation; $10 million would go<br />

to restore the building and reopen it as a parish church, $2 million to establish<br />

an endowment for the parish, and $8 million to support the parish<br />

school and other parochial schools in the Archdiocese.<br />

Throughout this four-year journey, through many ups and downs, the<br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong> advised the “Save St. Brigid’s” alliance, providing technical<br />

advice on building stabilization costs and alternative redevelopment, as<br />

well as outreach to the Archdiocese, news outlets, and the Irish-American<br />

community.<br />

With such a generous gift in hand, the Archdiocese hired the respected<br />

preservation architecture firm Acheson Doyle Partners to restore the<br />

church, which requires extensive underpinning. Officials expect the project<br />

to take a couple of years. Restoration work continues today, and<br />

supporters eagerly await the church’s reopening.<br />

Another Manhattan church which the <strong>Conservancy</strong> has fought to save has<br />

been less fortunate than its downtown neighbor: St. Thomas the Apostle<br />

in Harlem. It shut its doors in 2003 and remains unutilized despite the<br />

strong efforts of local groups, Congressman Rangel, and the <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />

to present the Archdiocese with alternate development plans. Several of<br />

its windows had been promised to an upstate church under construction,<br />

Blessed Kateri Tekawitha church in LaGrangeville, NY.<br />

<strong>The</strong> unusually cohesive suite of windows was designed specifically to<br />

complement St. Thomas’ lacy terra cotta tracery and Gothic-arched openings.<br />

<strong>The</strong> La Grangeville church opened in <strong>2008</strong> without the St. Thomas<br />

windows, pending their removal, restoration, and relocation, which are<br />

expected in 2009.<br />

left St. Brigid’s, overlooking Tompkins Square Park in the East Village<br />

right St. Thomas the Apostle, Harlem<br />

12


In Memoriam<br />

Bay Ridge United Methodist Church<br />

After years of assistance from the <strong>Conservancy</strong>, congregational struggle,<br />

and community advocacy, we were sad to note the demolition of Bay<br />

Ridge United Methodist Church last fall.<br />

Designed by church architect George W. Kramer in 1899-1900, it was<br />

known throughout the neighborhood as the “green church” for its distinctive<br />

green “serpentine” sandstone façade, which had severely deteriorated.<br />

A 2004 <strong>Conservancy</strong> grant helped fund the temporary use of a net<br />

around the church tower to hold falling stone in place. A 2005 <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />

study estimated necessary stone replacement at the clock tower at<br />

$670,000, with comprehensive repairs projected at $6.8 to $8.6 million,<br />

exclusive of interior upgrades or accessibility modifications.<br />

While community advocates hoped for a different outcome, the site was<br />

sold and initially slated for new condominium development. By year’s<br />

end, the declining economy had halted condominium plans. Residents are<br />

hopeful that the site can be returned to community use via development<br />

of a new public school.<br />

11th- Hour Rescue of Rare Upjohn Church<br />

In the spring of <strong>2008</strong>, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> assisted community advocates by<br />

providing referrals and funding for the architectural documentation and<br />

careful disassembly and storage of the former St. Saviour’s, an 1847,<br />

Richard Upjohn designed, carpenter Gothic church in Maspeth, Queens.<br />

<strong>The</strong> wood-frame building was disassembled and moved from its original<br />

site, in anticipation that the 1.5 acre site will be sold for development.<br />

<strong>The</strong> building is in storage, awaiting reassembly on the grounds of All<br />

Faiths Cemetery in Maspeth, Queens, thanks to the hard work of members<br />

of the Juniper Park Civic Association, and emergency funding from the<br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong>, Queens Borough President Helen Marshall, and preservation<br />

advocate Christabel Gough, to retain building professionals experienced<br />

in historic wood-frame construction: Kaitsen Woo Architects, Island<br />

Housewrights, and to video document the building’s dismantling. <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />

referral, the experienced preservation architecture firm Kai Woo<br />

Architects was engaged to prepare plans for a reconstructed St. Saviour’s.<br />

Queens’ Oldest Synagogue Becomes a Landmark<br />

Queens’ oldest surviving synagogue, the 1911 Congregation Tifereth Israel<br />

in Corona, was designated a <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Landmark in early <strong>2008</strong>.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>, working closely with Queens Borough President Helen<br />

Marshall, lent technical and financial assistance to this small Bukharan<br />

Congregation and helped secure $1.1 million in public and more than<br />

$300,000 in private funding for the $1.4 million restoration of the building’s<br />

original wooden siding and windows. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> itself provided<br />

$17,500 in grant support, along with countless hours of free technical<br />

advice by program director Ann-Isabel Friedman. Through Ms. Friedman’s<br />

support, the synagogue was able to secure a $200,000 <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State<br />

Environmental Protection Fund grant, and $90,000 in support from other<br />

foundations. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> will continue to support this project as it<br />

works through the EPF bidding process.<br />

top Bay Ridge United Methodist, Brooklyn<br />

middle St. Saviour’s Church, Maspeth, Queens<br />

bottom Congregation Tifereth Israel, Corona, Queens<br />

13


Sacred Sites and Consulting Grants<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> awards Sacred Sites and Consulting Grants to congregations<br />

of all denominations that are planning or undertaking the restoration<br />

of historic religious properties.<br />

To be eligible, properties must be located in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State, owned by<br />

a religious institution and actively used for worship, and listed on the<br />

State or National Register of Historic Places or designated pursuant to a<br />

local landmarks ordinance. Eligible properties include, but are not limited<br />

to, churches, synagogues, meetinghouses, mosques, and temples. <strong>The</strong><br />

maximum Sacred Sites Grant is $10,000; in <strong>2008</strong> the average grant award<br />

was about $5,500. <strong>The</strong> maximum Consulting Grant is $7,500; in <strong>2008</strong> the<br />

average award was about $5,300.<br />

Asbury First United Methodist Church, Rochester<br />

Cathedral of All Saints, Albany<br />

Chapin Memorial, Unitarian Universalist Society of Oneonta, Oneonta<br />

Christ Episcopal Church, Sackets Harbor<br />

Christ Temple Church, Rochester<br />

Church For All Nations, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

Church of the Ascension, Brooklyn<br />

Church of <strong>The</strong> Resurrection, Kew Gardens<br />

Community Church of East Williston<br />

Eldred Congregational Church, Eldred<br />

Episcopal Church of Saints Peter and John, Auburn<br />

First Baptist Church, Cuba<br />

First Baptist Church of Painted Post<br />

First Presbyterian Church, Cazenovia<br />

First Presbyterian Church, Schenectady<br />

First Presbyterian Church of Wyoming<br />

First United Methodist Church, <strong>New</strong>burgh<br />

Forest Presbyterian Church, Lyons Falls<br />

German Evangelical Lutheran Church of St. Paul, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

Grace Episcopal Church, Bronx<br />

Grace Episcopal Church, Canton<br />

Grace Episcopal Church, Lyons<br />

Grace Episcopal Church, Syracuse<br />

Hamilton Monthly Meeting<br />

Immanuel Evangelical Lutheran Church, Kingston<br />

Old First Presbyterian Church, Huntington<br />

Our Lady of Victory / St. Joseph Roman Catholic Church, Rochester<br />

Rugged Cross Baptist Church, Brooklyn<br />

Sacred Heart Basilica, Syracuse<br />

St. Mark’s Evangelical Lutheran Church, Middleburgh<br />

St. Paul’s Church, Salem<br />

St. James Episcopal Church, Skaneateles<br />

St. Luke’s Episcopal Church, Katonah<br />

St. Mary’s Church-in-the-Highlands, Cold Spring<br />

Temple Sinai, Saratoga Springs<br />

<strong>The</strong> Reformed Dutch Church of Poughkeepsie<br />

Tremont Baptist Church, Bronx<br />

Trinity Church, Rensselaerville<br />

Trinity Episcopal Church, Buffalo<br />

Trinity Episcopal Church, Middleville<br />

Trinity Lutheran Church, Long Island City<br />

United Methodist Church of Durham-Oak Hill, Oak Hill<br />

University Parish of St. Joseph’s, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

Wanakena Presbyterian Church, Star Lake<br />

Zion Episcopal Church, Morris<br />

Robert W. Wilson<br />

Sacred Sites Challenge Grants<br />

For comprehensive repair and extensive restoration projects, the Robert<br />

W. Wilson Sacred Sites Challenge Grant Program offers matching funds<br />

to churches. <strong>The</strong> majority of matching funds must be donated from new<br />

sources. Since its launch in 2000 the program has funded 65 challenge<br />

grants totaling more than $1.8 million, generating more than 1.9 million in<br />

grant matches that will facilitate the completion of more than $35 million<br />

in restoration of historic religious properties across <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State. In<br />

<strong>2008</strong> grants ranged from $25,000 to $70,000.<br />

Church of St. Ann and the Holy Trinity, Brooklyn<br />

Church of the Ascension, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

Flushing Monthly Meeting, Flushing<br />

German Evangelical Lutheran Church of St. Paul, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

Rugged Cross Baptist Church, Brooklyn<br />

St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

St. John the Baptist Roman Catholic Church, Brooklyn<br />

St. Mary’s Church-in-the-Highlands, Cold Spring<br />

Union <strong>The</strong>ological Seminary, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

above<br />

Temple Sinai, Saratoga Springs<br />

14


Funding Historic Properties<br />

295 Decatur Street, Brooklyn


<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Historic Properties Fund (HPF) is the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s<br />

main financing vehicle for restoration work throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

City and is one of the largest revolving loan funds for historic preservation<br />

in the nation. <strong>The</strong> Fund has provided almost $18.4 million in<br />

low-interest loans and more than $380,000 in grants since its inception<br />

in 1982. As part of the program, the Fund offers project management<br />

assistance to help owners throughout the financing and<br />

restoration processes.<br />

Fund staff worked on more than 20 buildings of all architectural<br />

styles in <strong>2008</strong>, while continuing its initiative to expand HPF lending<br />

into new neighborhoods.<br />

<strong>2008</strong> Projects — Spotlight on Bedford-Stuyvesant<br />

Brooklyn has received well over half the Fund’s investments since 1982.<br />

This past year was no exception, with five of the Fund’s eight completed<br />

projects located in the borough. Of these five, three are in Bedford-<br />

Stuyvesant, which contains many of the City’s finest collections of row<br />

houses.<br />

HPF provided an $80,000 loan at five percent interest for 10 years to<br />

finance restoration work on the Cummings Residence at 295 Decatur<br />

Street, in the Stuyvesant Heights Historic District. This late 19th century<br />

row house is notable for its red-orange brick and brownstone, with intricate<br />

terra cotta details. <strong>The</strong> loan financed the cleaning and re-pointing of<br />

the masonry façade, cleaning and repair of the decorative elements, and<br />

the restoration of the front door, brownstone stoop, and ironwork. Additionally,<br />

18 windows were replaced, the parlor windows and their stained<br />

glass transoms were restored, and a stained glass window on the third<br />

floor was installed. Kaitsen Woo was the architect, and the contractor<br />

was Progeny Restoration.<br />

With a loan of $270,000 at three percent interest for 10 years, HPF financed<br />

an assortment of restoration work at St. Philip’s Episcopal Church<br />

at 334 MacDonough Street, also in the Stuyvesant Heights Historic District.<br />

St. Philip’s was designed in a picturesque style with English Gothic<br />

precedents by Arne Delhi, a Norwegian architect who lived and worked in<br />

Brooklyn. Over time, the 110-year-old church suffered water-related damage,<br />

and the HPF loan was used to address many of these issues. A few<br />

years ago, a Fund loan of $100,000 helped pay for the restoration of one<br />

of the church’s slate roofs. With the latest round of funding, the church’s<br />

other roofs and windows were repaired, new gutters and leaders were<br />

installed, and the deteriorated interior plaster was repaired and painted.<br />

Additionally, the masonry façade was cleaned and re-pointed, a new<br />

stone step was installed, and the tower windows were restored. Hall<br />

Partnership was the architect, and Henry Restoration was the contractor.<br />

For the Jackman Residence at 112 Hancock Street in the proposed Bedford<br />

National Register Historic District, HPF provided a $60,000 loan at<br />

five percent interest for 10 years to restore a Neo-Grec brownstone built<br />

circa 1880. <strong>The</strong> building’s distinctive iron cresting along the roof and atop<br />

the portico was carefully cleaned, repaired, and repainted. <strong>The</strong> brownstone<br />

façade and stoop were restored, the cornice was cleaned and repainted,<br />

and the ironwork was repaired. Kaitsen Woo was the architect,<br />

and the contractor was Cecil King Stone & Restoration.<br />

16


During the 1990s, the <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission identified several<br />

parts of Bedford-Stuyvesant as “Areas of Interest,” but they were<br />

never developed into districts. In an effort to update this work, Fund staff<br />

conducted a new survey and identified four distinct areas that featured<br />

intact historic row houses: Stuyvesant West, Bedford-Stuyvesant East<br />

Central, Shannon’s Garden, and Cripplebush Road. <strong>The</strong>se potential historic<br />

districts boasted row houses built around the turn of the 20th century<br />

in popular styles of the day: Italianate, Neo-Grec, Second Empire, Queen<br />

Anne, and Romanesque. Most of the buildings in Bedford-Stuyvesant<br />

East Central and Stuyvesant West were built before 1890 by prominent<br />

Brooklyn architects and builders. Shannon’s Garden is a mix of the late<br />

19th and early 20th centuries, with elaborate late-Italianate brownstones<br />

and Neo-Classical stone row houses. <strong>The</strong> Cripplebush Road district is<br />

comprised of several blocks of especially consistent, late-Italianate row<br />

house streetscapes, built between 1885 and 1891. <strong>The</strong> SHPO determined<br />

in November <strong>2008</strong> that these four areas were eligible for listing on the<br />

registers.<br />

With Highland Park’s 120 buildings and the 1,130 properties in the four<br />

Bedford-Stuyvesant areas, a total of 1,250 buildings have been added to<br />

the Fund’s universe of possible work.<br />

<strong>New</strong>ly Eligible State and National Register<br />

Historic Districts<br />

<strong>The</strong> City’s most recent real estate boom greatly increased property values<br />

in neighborhoods traditionally served by the Historic Properties Fund.<br />

In areas where the Fund has completed dozens of projects, such as Fort<br />

Greene, Brooklyn, the need for its assistance has decreased. In response,<br />

Fund staff began a campaign in 2007 to identify new areas for investing<br />

its resources: intact blocks of older properties that could be deemed eligible<br />

for listing in the State and/or National Registers of Historic Places, the<br />

minimum criterion required for Fund assistance. To accomplish this work,<br />

Fund staff and graduate interns researched, surveyed, and analyzed areas<br />

of historic interest and presented potential districts to the State Historic<br />

Preservation Office (SHPO), which then determines a district’s eligibility.<br />

Fund research led to determinations of eligibility for the Bradhurst Historic<br />

District in Harlem and the Windsor Terrace Historic District in Brooklyn.<br />

Five more areas of Brooklyn were added in <strong>2008</strong>: Highland Park in Cypress<br />

Hills and four sections of Bedford-Stuyvesant.<br />

prior page<br />

top Cummings Residence, 295 Decatur Street, Brooklyn<br />

bottom St. Philip’s Episcopal Church, 334 MacDonough Street, Brooklyn<br />

this page<br />

top Jackman Residence, 112 Hancock Street, Brooklyn<br />

bottom 279 Highland Boulevard, Brooklyn<br />

<strong>The</strong> Cypress Hills section of Brooklyn came to the Fund’s attention after<br />

the Pratt Institute Land Use and Historic Preservation Studio produced a<br />

draft study of the neighborhood. Fund staff built upon this information,<br />

as well as two prior studies, and selected Cypress Hill’s Highland Park<br />

neighborhood as a potential historic district. Highland Park is bordered<br />

on three sides by a greenbelt of parks and cemeteries. One part of the<br />

district consists of large free-standing 19th century homes with Spanishtile<br />

roofs. Downhill from the mansions lies an area of two- and three-story<br />

early 20th century row houses built in Eclectic revival styles with Mission<br />

or Craftsman details, and capped by red tile roofs echoing the architecture<br />

of the mansions above. <strong>The</strong> SHPO determined in May <strong>2008</strong> that Highland<br />

Park was eligible for listing on both registers.<br />

17


Assisting Nonprofits<br />

Van Cortlandt House Museum, the Bronx


City Ventures Fund<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s City Ventures Fund (CVF) works with nonprofit<br />

developers to retain or replace the period details of architecturally<br />

significant buildings — not necessarily designated landmarks —<br />

that will be used for affordable housing or neighborhood facilities.<br />

Since its establishment in 1986, CVF has authorized almost $1.4 million<br />

to assist over 840 units of low-income and special needs housing,<br />

as well as community service properties.<br />

CVF came to the aid of two city landmarks in <strong>2008</strong>:<br />

A $7,500 grant was used to retain the services of Thomas Fenniman, a<br />

preservation architect who provided the necessary expertise for the rehabilitation<br />

and restoration of 365 Jay Street in Brooklyn. Constructed<br />

in 1894 in the Romanesque Revival style, this building is listed in the<br />

National Register of Historic Places and is a designated city landmark. It<br />

is composed of brick and terra cotta and has a clock tower. <strong>The</strong> property<br />

originally served as Brooklyn’s Fire Department Headquarters and then as<br />

a firehouse until the 1970s. After a period of vacancy, it was renovated<br />

in 1988 into 18 low-income apartments, but the building was poorly managed.<br />

<strong>The</strong> City assumed ownership in 2005 and asked the Pratt Area<br />

Community Council (PACC) to take over and upgrade the property. PACC<br />

requested the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s help via a CVF grant to underwrite the services<br />

of a preservation consultant to help identify a scope of work and<br />

assist the project architect in incorporating preservation concerns into the<br />

remainder of the project.<br />

614 Courtlandt Avenue in the Bronx is a lovely corner property that was<br />

constructed in 1871-1872 and used for many years as a saloon and meeting<br />

hall for the surrounding German community. It had been vacant for<br />

two decades when the Neighborhood Housing Services Community<br />

Development Corporation (NHS) acquired it from the City in 2006. <strong>The</strong><br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong> authorized a CVF grant of $20,000 for wood window and masonry<br />

issues, while the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />

awarded NHS a grant of $40,000 for slate and chimney work. NHS<br />

renovated it for sale as three apartments and retail store space, with the<br />

condition that the new owner occupy either the commercial unit or one of<br />

the apartments. <strong>The</strong> preservation costs of the property were exceptionally<br />

expensive, given the replacement of a dormered slate mansard roof,<br />

cast-iron surrounded wood windows, and an array of masonry issues.<br />

left<br />

right<br />

614 Courtlandt Avenue, the Bronx<br />

365 Jay Street, Brooklyn<br />

19


Emergency Preservation Grant Program<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Emergency Preservation Grant Program,<br />

(EPGP) comes to the rescue when an imminent hazard threatens<br />

a landmark building. <strong>The</strong> program directs its resources toward immediately<br />

needed work on historic properties owned by nonprofit<br />

organizations. Its intention is to address discrete exterior building<br />

problems that have recently arisen, such as new leaks, fire damage,<br />

and falling masonry. <strong>The</strong> EPGP has underwritten more than<br />

$250,000 in grants since 1999.<br />

<strong>The</strong> EPGP assisted six projects in <strong>2008</strong>. In the Bronx, grants went to the<br />

City Island Historical Society and the Van Cortlandt Museum. <strong>The</strong> City<br />

Island Historical Society houses a library and historical collections dedicated<br />

to the history of this small nautical community on the Long Island<br />

Sound. EPGP stepped in to underwrite the restoration of the building’s<br />

entryway after it was destroyed in a fire. A grant of $10,000 helped to<br />

pay for the services of Kaitsen Woo, a preservation architect who prepared<br />

specifications and obtained cost estimates from contractors for the<br />

rebuilding of the entryway in a historically appropriate manner. United<br />

Homesteads of <strong>New</strong> Rochelle was the general contractor.<br />

Meanwhile, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> proudly saw the completion of a nearly decade-long<br />

project in <strong>2008</strong>: the revitalization of the Chapel of the Sisters at<br />

Prospect Cemetery in Queens. During restoration, project staff discovered<br />

that the wood frames for the chapel’s two stained glass windows needed<br />

to be fully replaced at a cost of $38,500, which was not budgeted. <strong>The</strong><br />

stained glass had already been meticulously restored by <strong>The</strong> Gil Studio<br />

and was awaiting installation. To cover the cost of the frames, the <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />

raised $30,000 from the Gerry Charitable Trust and the remainder<br />

from the EPGP.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> and its partners celebrated the chapel’s gorgeous restoration<br />

in September <strong>2008</strong> at a ribbon-cutting event that featured a dedication<br />

to Illinois Jacquet, a heralded tenor saxophonist who lived in Jamaica,<br />

Queens. <strong>York</strong> College’s Jazz Ensemble has been using the chapel<br />

as its home since then and regularly performs for the public there. <strong>The</strong> full<br />

story of the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s involvement in the Initiative can be found in the<br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Autumn <strong>2008</strong> newsletter.<br />

EPGP also came to the aid of the Williamsburg Art and Historical Center<br />

in Brooklyn, which was in desperate need of repair of its leaking interior<br />

drains. Constructed in 1868 and once home to the former Kings County<br />

Savings Bank, this individually designated City landmark and National<br />

Register property is now a community facility and arts venue. It needs a<br />

great amount of renovation and restoration work that its custodians cannot<br />

afford. Several years ago, an Emergency Preservation Grant was used<br />

for the restoration of its front mansard and roof clock. An EPGP grant of<br />

$5,000 underwrote the drainage repairs.<br />

top<br />

bottom<br />

City Island Historical Society<br />

Williamsburg Art and Historical Society, Brooklyn<br />

20


Honoring Excellence<br />

<strong>The</strong> Cathedral Church of Saint John the Divine


<strong>The</strong> Lucy G. Moses Preservation Awards are the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s<br />

highest honors for outstanding preservation efforts and are named<br />

after a distinguished <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> philanthropist whose generosity<br />

benefited the City for over 50 years. <strong>The</strong> awards ceremony for <strong>2008</strong><br />

was held at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine. We honored two<br />

individuals for their leadership, and nine projects for excellence in<br />

preservation.<br />

Ruth Abram, the founder and former president of the Lower East Side<br />

Tenement Museum, was the recipient of our Preservation Leadership<br />

Award. For twenty years, Ms. Abram has been an outspoken advocate<br />

for the museum and for preservation of the Lower East Side, a community<br />

well known for its architectural history and social significance. When<br />

new development began to threaten those special qualities, Ruth Abram<br />

started a campaign to place the LES on the National Register of Historic<br />

Places, and she continues to petition the City for landmark designation,<br />

which would protect the neighborhood from demolition and guide alterations<br />

and new construction.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Honorable Judith S. Kaye, former Chief Judge of the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

State Court of Appeals, received our Public Leadership Award. After 15<br />

years as chief judge of the highest court in the state (and the first woman<br />

in that role), Judge Kaye retired in <strong>2008</strong>. She has been an advocate for<br />

preserving the State’s courthouses, and was responsible for many restorations,<br />

including the beautiful 1842 Greek Revival Court of Appeals Hall in<br />

Albany and the stunning First Appellate Courthouse on Madison Square<br />

in Manhattan.<br />

<strong>The</strong> following nine projects were also chosen to receive awards:<br />

Frank Lloyd Wright’s masterpiece, the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum,<br />

is an icon of modern architecture. While the museum has undergone<br />

several renovations, repairs, and additions, this campaign was the first<br />

comprehensive treatment of the envelope. Preliminary work included research,<br />

documentation, and monitoring; construction involved the removal<br />

of 11 coats of paint, infilling of exterior cracks, treatment of corroded<br />

steel, and reinforcement of the concrete. This three-year-long restoration<br />

project was completed just before the museum’s 50th birthday.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Cathedral of St. John the Divine is one of the largest churches<br />

in the world, and the mother church of the Episcopal Diocese of <strong>New</strong><br />

<strong>York</strong>. In late 2001, a six-alarm fire severely damaged the north transept,<br />

destroyed the gift shop, and filled the interior with soot and smoke. A<br />

lengthy cleaning and restoration of the interior was undertaken. Seven<br />

years after the fire, the congregation and the community celebrated rededication<br />

of the Cathedral.<br />

Jamaica Performing Arts Center in Queens is an excellent example<br />

of adaptive reuse. <strong>The</strong> congregation of the former First Reformed Church<br />

in Jamaica was moved from the building in 1973 as part of a City Urban<br />

Redevelopment Project, leaving it empty and abandoned. Local arts and<br />

community groups and the Queens Borough President started the reuse<br />

process in 2004. Today the interior is transformed, with flexible performing<br />

arts and community spaces, while the exterior features a restored<br />

façade, new slate roof, and shining stained glass windows. <strong>The</strong> finished<br />

product shows that historic churches no longer serving a religious function<br />

can have a happy second, secular life.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Beaux-arts façade of the American Irish Historical Society at 991<br />

Fifth Avenue is glowing again after restoration of the brick and limestone<br />

22


swell-front façade and the rusticated limestone base, replacement of<br />

wood windows, and the installation of a new exterior lighting system.<br />

<strong>The</strong> interior also received a museum-quality restoration.<br />

<strong>The</strong> elaborate, stylized interior of the 1913 Longacre <strong>The</strong>atre has been<br />

given new life. Plasterwork details lost to previous repairs were recreated,<br />

gilded moldings and marble surfaces were cleaned and refinished, and<br />

new seats and modernized theatrical systems were installed. Historically<br />

accurate colors dazzle, and the neo-Classical façade once again beckons<br />

theater-goers to 48th Street.<br />

One award was given for a new addition to a historic building. An<br />

18,000-square-foot addition to the Poly Prep Country Day School was<br />

built adjacent to the existing school building in the Park Slope Historic<br />

District. Faced with a challenging site and pressing programmatic needs,<br />

the architects succeeded by integrating traditional architectural elements<br />

into a contemporary design — an approach that can serve as a model for<br />

new additions in many historic districts.<br />

Seventeen years ago, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan proposed transforming<br />

the Farley Post Office into a great train station with a proper<br />

entranceway, to atone for the loss of Penn Station. In <strong>2008</strong> the Empire<br />

State Development Corporation completed a substantial restoration of the<br />

building’s neo-Classical exterior. <strong>The</strong> grand staircase and row of twenty,<br />

53-foot Corinthian columns have been cleaned, repaired, and renovated<br />

to their former glory. Now we await transformation of the interior to realize<br />

Senator Moynihan’s dream of becoming the entrance that <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

deserves.<br />

Meanwhile, two very different residential properties received awards.<br />

When the owners purchased the Italianate row house at 62 East 83rd<br />

Street in 2004, the original stoop and areaway had been removed, and<br />

the façade had lost all its ornamental details. Although the building is<br />

not a designated landmark, the design and construction team held themselves<br />

to that high standard, restoring original details based on historic<br />

documentation.<br />

295 East Eighth Street is the picturesque former home of the Children’s<br />

Aid Society/Tompkins Square Lodging House for Boys and Industrial<br />

School. It was designed by Vaux and Radford and completed in 1887.<br />

Although perhaps best known for his partnership with Frederick Law Olmstead<br />

and their design of Central Park, Calvert Vaux also worked with<br />

George Radford on a dozen elaborately detailed social service agencies.<br />

<strong>The</strong> East Eighth Street building is one of the few that remain. Restoration<br />

included replacement of the slate roof and dormers; cleaning and graffiti<br />

removal of the entire masonry façade; restoration of the ornamental<br />

ironwork, wood front doors, and entryway; and installation of new iron<br />

cresting at the roof.<br />

prior page<br />

top Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, Manhattan<br />

middle Jamaica Performing Arts Center, Queens<br />

bottom American Irish Historical Society, Manhattan<br />

this page<br />

top Longacre <strong>The</strong>ater, Manhattan<br />

middle Poly Prep Country Day School, Manhattan<br />

bottom 295 East Eighth Street, Manhattan<br />

23


Celebrating Living <strong>Landmarks</strong><br />

Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> gala at Cipriani 42nd Street


<strong>2008</strong> Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> Celebration<br />

Each year, <strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> recognizes <strong>New</strong><br />

<strong>York</strong>ers who have made outstanding contributions to the City and<br />

honors them as Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> at our fall gala.<br />

More than 400 guests turned out on Wednesday, November 5, to join the<br />

<strong>Conservancy</strong> in celebrating the <strong>2008</strong> Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> Gala.<br />

We were proud to honor: Rosamond Bernier & John Russell*, Judy<br />

Collins, Osborn Elliot*, Barbara Goldsmith, Phyllis <strong>New</strong>man,<br />

Charles B. Rangel, and Charlie Rose. Congressman Rangel was the<br />

recipient of our Lew Rudin Award for Outstanding Public Service, named<br />

after the late <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> real estate magnate and philanthropist.<br />

Once again Living Landmark host Liz Smith presided over the festivities,<br />

aided by Peter Duchin and his orchestra.<br />

* In memory<br />

top<br />

Charlie Rose, Inger Elliott, Rosamond Bernier, Phyllis <strong>New</strong>man,<br />

Judy Collins, Barbara Goldsmith<br />

middle<br />

Stanford and Sandra Warshawsky<br />

Michael and Karyn Christensen<br />

Marjorie Reed Gordon and Ellery Gordon<br />

bottom<br />

Gurnee Hart, Elizabeth Stribling, Guy Robinson, Marjorie Hart<br />

25


top<br />

Richard and Gloria Moylan<br />

Lauren Bacall<br />

Ray and Veronica Kelly<br />

second row<br />

Anna Casperson, Sallie Abelow, Erik Oken<br />

Martin and Joan Camins, Michael De Chiara<br />

third row<br />

Marla Sabo<br />

Nan and Gay Talese<br />

Duane Hampton<br />

bottom<br />

Barbara Goldsmith, Beth DeWoody, Peg Breen, Frank Sciame<br />

26


Tours and Other Events<br />

Reception at Schinasi Mansion<br />

Nearly 100 guests joined us in May for an exclusive reception and tour of<br />

the landmark Schinasi residence, one of the few surviving single-family<br />

mansions in Manhattan. <strong>The</strong> 12,000-square-foot home was built in 1909<br />

for Morris Schinasi, a Turkish émigré who made his fortune selling tobacco.<br />

<strong>The</strong> architect, William Tuthill, also designed Carnegie Hall.<br />

A Look Inside Google’s NYC Headquarters
<br />

Members of our Real Estate and Professional Circles joined us in August<br />

for a private tour of Google’s recently expanded <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City headquarters.<br />

Its initial office space at 76 Ninth Avenue, built in 1930, originally<br />

served as a warehouse for the Port Authority. As the company grew here,<br />

it moved its marketing team to Chelsea Market. This new space, with<br />

its adaptive reuse of an industrial building, is an incredible example of<br />

modern technology within an older frame.<br />

Private Tour of Brooklyn’s U.S. Courthouse<br />

and Post Office<br />

Our tour in August of this spectacularly restored building was led by architect<br />

Michael Nieminen, of R.M. Clement & Frances Halsband Architects,<br />

who worked on its impressive redesign. <strong>The</strong> firm meticulously restored all<br />

the exterior surfaces and windows. Modern offices and courtrooms were<br />

inserted within the shell of the annex building, built in 1930. In the original<br />

section, the magnificent central atrium was returned to full Victorian glory.<br />

Illustrated Lecture on American Beaux-Arts<br />

Architect Richard Morris Hunt<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>, along with the Beaux-Arts Alliance, co-hosted an illustrated<br />

lecture in April by renowned architectural historian David Garrard<br />

Lowe. In his unique and captivating manner, Lowe explored the fascinating<br />

life and work of Richard Morris Hunt, the first American architect to<br />

attend the famous École des Beaux-Arts in Paris. Among Hunt’s most famous<br />

designs is the Tribune Building, one of the City’s first skyscrapers.<br />

Chairman’s Award Honoring Robert A. Levine<br />

More than 130 guests attended the <strong>2008</strong> Chairman’s Award luncheon at<br />

Le Cirque to honor Robert A. Levine, founder and president of RAL Companies<br />

& Affiliates, which develops luxury residential and commercial properties.<br />

Most recently, Levine has breathed new life into a former Brooklyn<br />

industrial building and two older Tribeca buildings by converting them into<br />

housing with associated retail and amenities.<br />

top Schinasi Mansion, Manhattan<br />

middle U.S. Courthouse and Post Office, Brooklyn<br />

bottom Robert A. Levine and Frank J. Sciame, Jr.<br />

27


Our Supporters<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s success depends<br />

on the annual support of our individual, corporate, and foundation<br />

donors. Each year we must raise more than 85 percent<br />

of our operating budget from private sources.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> gratefully acknowledges our partnership<br />

with the following supporters during <strong>2008</strong>.<br />

If any names have been listed incorrectly or omitted, please<br />

accept our apologies and let us know how we may adjust<br />

our records.<br />

Foundations, Corporations,<br />

Public Agencies, &<br />

Other Organizations<br />

$100,000 and above<br />

<strong>The</strong> Robert W. Wilson Charitable Trust<br />

$50,000 - $99,999<br />

Henry & Lucy Moses Fund Inc.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Rhodebeck Charitable Trust<br />

$25,000 - $49,999<br />

<strong>The</strong> Ambrose Monell Foundation<br />

F.J. Sciame Construction Co. Inc.<br />

Gerry Charitable Trust<br />

Lily Auchincloss Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Morris & Alma Schapiro Fund<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Community Trust<br />

<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State Council on the Arts<br />

$15,000 - $24,999<br />

<strong>The</strong> Barker Welfare Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Durst Organization<br />

Hagedorn Fund<br />

<strong>The</strong> JPMorgan Chase Foundation<br />

May & Samuel Rudin Family Foundation Inc.<br />

Preservation League of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State<br />

Stribling & Associates Ltd.<br />

Sugar Foods Corporation<br />

$10,000 - $14,999<br />

Bloomberg<br />

Boies Schiller & Flexner LLP<br />

Bovis Lend Lease LMB<br />

Edith & Herbert Lehman Foundation Inc.<br />

Gladys & Roland Harriman Foundation<br />

James A. Macdonald Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Lucius N. Littauer Foundation Inc.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Marc Haas Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Times<br />

<strong>New</strong>man’s Own Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Overbrook Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Reed Foundation Inc.<br />

Sony Corporation of America<br />

<strong>The</strong> Starr Foundation<br />

Winston & Strawn LLP<br />

$5,000 - $9,999<br />

375 Park Avenue L.P.<br />

42nd Street Fund<br />

Adolph & Ruth Schnurmacher Foundation<br />

Adrian & Jessie Archbold Charitable Trust<br />

AIG Global Real Estate Investment Corp.<br />

Astoria Federal Savings Bank<br />

<strong>The</strong> Blanche Enders Charitable Trust<br />

Cushman & Wakefield<br />

Gilder Foundation<br />

Lehman Brothers Inc.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Yankees Foundation<br />

Northern <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Community Foundation<br />

RAL Development Services LLC<br />

Sciame Development<br />

Specter DeSouza Architects PC<br />

$2,000 - $4,999<br />

Allstate Interior Demolition<br />

Arnow Family Fund<br />

Beyer Blinder Belle<br />

BWD Group<br />

<strong>The</strong> Cowles Charitable Trust<br />

Creative Design Associates LLC<br />

Davis Langdon<br />

<strong>The</strong> Dorothy Strelsin Foundation<br />

Episcopal Diocese of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

Hickory Foundation<br />

Higgins Quasebarth & Partners LLC<br />

<strong>The</strong> Howard Bayne Fund<br />

Leon Levy Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Segal Company<br />

<strong>The</strong> Shubert Organization Inc.<br />

Sidney & Judith Kranes Charitable Trust<br />

Van Cleef & Arpels<br />

World Monuments Fund<br />

$1,000 - $1,999<br />

Building Conservation Associates Inc.<br />

Capalino + Company<br />

<strong>The</strong> Cathedral of St. John the Divine<br />

Chanel Inc.<br />

Charina Foundation<br />

Connelly McLaughlin Communications<br />

Estee Lauder Companies Inc.<br />

Façade Maintenance Design P.C.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Gramercy Park Foundation<br />

Green-Wood Cemetery<br />

Helpern Architects<br />

<strong>The</strong> Leonard & Evelyn Lauder Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Loreen Arbus Foundation<br />

<strong>The</strong> Old Stones Foundation<br />

Old Town Bar<br />

<strong>The</strong> Philanthropic Collaborative Inc.<br />

Polshek Partnership Architects<br />

Robert A.M. Stern Architects LLP<br />

Schtiller & Plevy Inc.<br />

Studio for Civil Architecture PLLC<br />

<strong>The</strong> Sulzberger Foundation Inc.<br />

Thomas Manufacturing Inc.<br />

Tishman Construction Corporation of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />

Vertical Access LLC<br />

<strong>The</strong> West Paces Hotel Group<br />

<strong>The</strong> Yves-Andre Istel Foundation<br />

$500 - $999<br />

<strong>The</strong> Actors Fund<br />

Apple Bank<br />

Atlas Welding & Boiler Repair Inc.<br />

Bertha & Isaac Liberman Foundation Inc.<br />

Cutsogeorge Tooman & Allen Architects P.C.<br />

Eastern Metalworks<br />

Educational Housing Services Inc.<br />

GCP Capital Group LLC<br />

Greater Jamaica Development Corporation<br />

H3 Hardy Collaboration Architecture<br />

Hazardous Elimination Corporation<br />

Henry B. Plant Memorial Fund<br />

Henry C. & Karen J. Barkhorn Foundation<br />

Ingram & Hebron Realty<br />

28


Kaitsen Woo Architect P.C.<br />

Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP<br />

O’Connor Davies Munns & Dobbins LLP<br />

PA Associates<br />

Partnership for <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />

Soil Mechanics<br />

Stribling Marketing Associates<br />

Sunlites Stained Glass<br />

$250 - $499<br />

Alan Hill Design<br />

B.L. Howard Productions<br />

Brooklyn Heights Association Inc.<br />

Cozen O’Connor<br />

First Republic Bank<br />

Goldstein Associates Consulting Engineers PC<br />

Goshow Architects LLP<br />

GVA Williams<br />

ING Clarion Partners LLC<br />

Kliment Halsband Architects<br />

LandAir Project Resources<br />

Levy & Gold LLP<br />

Lexicon Communications Corp.<br />

Ludwig Michael Goldsmith Architects<br />

Metropolis Group Inc.<br />

<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Department of Design<br />

& Construction<br />

<strong>The</strong> PAR Group<br />

Pest Elimination Systems Technology<br />

Robert Silman Associates P.C.<br />

Robinson Contracting Inc.<br />

SAM Fundraising Solutions Corp.<br />

Robert Silman Associates P.C.<br />

West <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Restoration of CT Inc.<br />

WolfBlock<br />

<strong>The</strong> Woodstone Company<br />

Individuals<br />

Leader ($50,000 and above)<br />

Robert W. Wilson<br />

Guardian ($25,000 - $49,999)<br />

Barbara L. Goldsmith<br />

Christabel Gough<br />

Mimi Levitt<br />

Dr. & Mrs. Daniel Schapiro<br />

Frank J. Sciame Jr.<br />

Sustainer ($15,000 - $24,999)<br />

Joan Ganz Cooney & Peter G. Peterson<br />

Michael K. De Chiara<br />

Beth Rudin DeWoody<br />

Susanne & Douglas Durst<br />

Brandon Fradd<br />

Alexandra & Paul Herzan<br />

John J. Kerr Jr. & Nora Wren Kerr<br />

William C. Rudin<br />

Elizabeth F. Stribling & Guy Robinson<br />

Barbara & Donald Tober<br />

Stanley & Sandra Warshawsky<br />

Fellow ($10,000 - $14,999)<br />

David Boies<br />

Mildred C. Brinn<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Robert C. Graham Jr.<br />

Holly Hotchner<br />

Robert A. Levine<br />

Allison Simmons Prouty & Norman Prouty<br />

David Reese<br />

Mrs. Edmond J. Safra<br />

Lloyd Zuckerberg & Charlotte Triefus<br />

Society ($5,000 - $9,999)<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Justin Abelow<br />

William G. Bardel<br />

Joan & Martin Camins<br />

Jonathan Caplan<br />

Susan R. Cullman & John J. Kirby Jr.<br />

Inger McCabe Elliott<br />

David & Meade Fogel<br />

Patricia & John Forelle<br />

Richard A. Garvey<br />

Richard Gilder<br />

Marla Sabo<br />

Frances G. Scaife<br />

Marc P. Schappell<br />

Aaron Sosnick<br />

Patricia & David Kenneth Specter<br />

George M. Steinbrenner III<br />

Sue Ann Weinberg<br />

Benefactor ($2,500 - $4,999)<br />

Joan Arnow<br />

John & Caron Avery<br />

Catherine Cahill & William Bernhard<br />

Edward Lee Cave<br />

Ted Hartley & Dina Merrill<br />

Margaret Brennan Hassett<br />

William J. Higgins & Elise M. Quasebarth<br />

Mariana & George Kaufman<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Stephen S. Lash<br />

Arthur L. Loeb<br />

Enid Nemy<br />

Encarnita & Robert Quinlan<br />

David Rockefeller<br />

Daniel & Joanna S. Rose<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Jeffrey A. Rosen<br />

Gerald Schoenfeld<br />

Martin E. Segal<br />

Shelby White<br />

John C. Whitehead<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Richard J. Wilk<br />

Circle ($1,000 - $2,499)<br />

Oscar K. Anderson III & Gillian Blake<br />

Loreen Arbus<br />

Bunty & Tom Armstrong<br />

Sharon & Stephen Baum<br />

Paul Beirne<br />

John Belle<br />

Kelly Killoren Bensimon<br />

Alexander, Nina, & Jamie Bernstein<br />

Charles & Kathryn Berry<br />

Giancarla Berti<br />

Minor L. Bishop<br />

Mr. & Mrs. James A. Block<br />

Stephanie E.K. Borynack<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Alan G. Brenner<br />

David Brown & Helen Gurley Brown<br />

James F. Capalino<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Arthur L. Carter<br />

Pamela Rubin Carter & Jon Carter<br />

Anne & John Coffin<br />

Kent Diebolt<br />

Francine du Plessix Gray<br />

Cynthia Elliott<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Stuart P. Feld<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Luke E. Fichthorn<br />

Jake & Sarah Foley<br />

Andrew C. Friedman<br />

Norton Garfinkle & Sally Minard<br />

Susan & Eli Gilbert<br />

Toni K. Goodale<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Christopher S. Goodman<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Robert Hahn<br />

Clark P. Halstead<br />

Mrs. Andrew Heiskell<br />

David Paul Helpern<br />

Arthur Indursky<br />

Virginia James<br />

Weslie Resnick Janeway & William H. Janeway<br />

Mr. & Mrs. John J. Kenney<br />

Richard M. Kielar<br />

Stephen Kirschenbaum & Andrew Valentine<br />

Arie L. Kopelman<br />

<strong>The</strong> Very Reverend James A. Kowalski<br />

Mathilde Krim<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Leonard A. Lauder<br />

Isabelle R. Leeds<br />

Richard Lefever<br />

Jeffrey Levine<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Noel Levine<br />

Sheldon & Diana Elliott Lidofsky<br />

Nicolas Luchsinger<br />

<strong>The</strong> Honorable & Mrs. Earle I. Mack<br />

Malcolm MacKay<br />

Marjorie Flannigan & Charles D. MacLachlan<br />

Christopher P. Mahan<br />

Joy Marks & Leif Bringslimark<br />

Martin J. McLaughlin<br />

Ronay & Richard Menschel<br />

Reginald Middleton<br />

Gillian & Sylvester Miniter<br />

John Morning<br />

Richard J. & Gloria E. Moylan<br />

Lynn Nesbit<br />

Roy R. Neuberger<br />

29


Erik R. Oken<br />

Mary Ellen & Richard Oldenburg<br />

Mr. & Mrs. George D. O’Neill<br />

Patricia S. Patterson<br />

Raymond Pepi & Karen Arrigoni<br />

Joseph Pierson<br />

Lawrence H. & Catherine Plevy<br />

James & Ellyn Polshek<br />

Paul Provost<br />

Kathleen & Peter Quinn<br />

Mr. & Mrs. William P. Rayner<br />

Michael Rebic<br />

Janet C. Ross<br />

Amy & Howard J. Rubenstein<br />

Sirgay & Judy Goetz Sanger<br />

Sophia D. Schachter<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Irwin Schneiderman<br />

Kay, Bill, Will & Meta Schrenk<br />

Richard Southwick<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Ted Stanley<br />

Joanne M. Stern<br />

Robert A.M. Stern<br />

Gay & Nan Talese<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Charles Tribbitt<br />

Helen S. Tucker<br />

Anne Van Rensselaer<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Guy Wildenstein<br />

George W. Young<br />

Roy J. Zuckerberg<br />

Patron ($500 - $999)<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Leigh J. Abramson<br />

Timothy Allanbrook<br />

Daniel J. Allen<br />

Anonymous<br />

Joan C. Baez<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Henry C. Barkhorn III<br />

Ana Bilski<br />

Matthew Blesso<br />

Allison M. Blinken<br />

Dr. & Mrs. Jeffrey S. Borer<br />

Giosetta Capriati<br />

Guy W. Clark II<br />

Patrick Clark<br />

Cathleen B. Colella<br />

Bruce L. Ehrmann<br />

Dorinda Elliott<br />

Christy Ferer<br />

Cheryl Grandfield & Richard W. Dodd<br />

Mrs. Henry Grunwald<br />

Hugh Hardy<br />

Chris Harris & Elizabeth Parrilli<br />

James W. Hundley III<br />

Josephine Lea Iselin<br />

Reverend John A. Kamas<br />

Sharon King Hoge<br />

Mitchell W. Jacobs<br />

Norman Keller & Denise Sobel<br />

Michèle Gerber Klein<br />

Bernice K. Leber & David Rosenberg<br />

Pauline C. Metcalf<br />

Edward T. Mohylowski<br />

George Neuman<br />

David & Phyllis Oxman<br />

Nicholas & Carol Paumgarten<br />

Mariann G. Perseo<br />

<strong>The</strong> Honorable Nicholas Platt<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Peter O. Price<br />

Richard Rubenstein<br />

Rosalie T. Sayles<br />

Linda & Dick Schapiro<br />

Michael T. Sillerman<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Benjamin F. Stapleton III<br />

Mr. & Mrs. George Sykes<br />

Jack Taylor<br />

F. Carlisle Towery<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Charles M.A. Winn<br />

Richard M. Winn III<br />

Kaitsen Woo<br />

Stuart C. Woods<br />

Kathryn S. Wylde<br />

Howard A. Zipser<br />

Sponsor ($250 - $499)<br />

Mark & Gloria Altherr<br />

Mr. & Mrs. O. Kelley Anderson Jr.<br />

Anonymous<br />

Ruth Aronowitz<br />

Cissy & George Asch<br />

Matthew Bender IV<br />

Mary Brogan<br />

Miriam Cahn<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Thomas A. Cassilly<br />

Daniel F. Crowley III<br />

Florence D’Urso<br />

Lisa A. Easton<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Jack Enders<br />

Gail Erickson & Christa Rice<br />

Linda Feczko<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Lawrence Friedland<br />

David E. Gustafson<br />

Henry G. Hart<br />

Kirk Henckels<br />

Darren Hirsch<br />

Linda & Morton Janklow<br />

Sarah Bradford Landau<br />

Edward F. Lyons Jr.<br />

Mr. & Mrs. David McMurry<br />

Susan Weis Mindel<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Garrett M. Moran<br />

John T. Moran<br />

Mary McGarry & Stanley Okula<br />

Lida Orzeck<br />

Nancy & Otis Pearsall<br />

Anne Perkins<br />

Mrs. Donaldson C. Pillsbury<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Andrew W. Potash<br />

Lynne P. Raymond<br />

Glenn & Lyn Reiter<br />

Mr. & Mrs. William D. Rifkin<br />

Mr. & Mrs. David Santry<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Martin Scherzer<br />

Lisa & Bernard Selz<br />

Patricia Soto<br />

Lesta Summerfield Stacom<br />

James Storrow<br />

Leith ter Meulen<br />

Neal X. Twomey & Rita Kavanagh<br />

Tom Von Essen<br />

Mr. & Mrs. William B. Warren<br />

William O. Wheatley Jr.<br />

Madelyn Wils<br />

Advocate ($100 - $249)<br />

Anonymous<br />

Charlotte P. Armstrong<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Ronald R. Atkins<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Alan Beller<br />

Vincent Benic<br />

Alvin Berr<br />

Madalen A. Bertolini<br />

Keith H. Bigger<br />

David T. Biggs<br />

Barbara Blank<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Allen Blum<br />

Edna L. Breecker<br />

Richard Burlage<br />

Lorenzo Burrows<br />

Albert K. Butzel<br />

Karen McCarthy Cady<br />

Jay E. Cantor<br />

Joan Capelin<br />

Steven Trent Cappel & Katherine H. Fritts<br />

<strong>The</strong> Honorable Diana D. Chapin<br />

Susan Chin<br />

Carol A. Clark<br />

Alice McGown Concagh<br />

Matthew V. Cortellesi<br />

Jane R. Crotty<br />

Anna E. Crouse<br />

Suzanne Davis & Rolf Ohlhausen<br />

Arnaud & Alexandra de Borchgrave<br />

John A. di Domenico<br />

Ann Cynthia Diamond<br />

Eugenia G. Dooley<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Robert R. Douglass<br />

Stewart Driller<br />

Barbara Dudley<br />

Pamela & Adam Emmerich<br />

David E. Finlay<br />

Julia Fishelson<br />

Barbara G. Fleischman<br />

Adaline Frelinghuysen<br />

J. Dermot Frengley<br />

Richard Frey & Janet Landis-Frey<br />

Ann-Isabel Friedman & Seth Maerowitz<br />

Lewis Friedman<br />

Ann W. Gaffney<br />

<strong>The</strong> Honorable Joan Gerner<br />

Ronald C. Goewey & Won S. Barber<br />

30


Ludwig Michael Goldsmith<br />

Rose L. Grobman<br />

Marion O. Harris<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Morrison H. Heckscher<br />

Paul Herther<br />

John J. Hoffmann<br />

Anne Holford-Smith & Jeffrey L. Smith<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Joseph C. Hoopes Jr.<br />

Sarah F. Hunnewell<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Robert D. Huxley<br />

Howard E. Johnson<br />

David A. Katz & Cecilia T. Absher<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Edward Kennedy<br />

Reverend Gerald Keucher &<br />

Reverend John H. Walsted<br />

Phyllis B. Lambert<br />

Richard Leibner<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Edwin Deane Leonard<br />

Brenda Levin<br />

Maura C. Lockhart & James M. Lukenda<br />

Vincent M. Love<br />

Amira Luikart<br />

Ken Lustbader<br />

James MacDonald<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Timothy MacDonald<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Marc Magid<br />

Peter J. Mayer<br />

Kerry Edward McCarthy<br />

Raymond A. McGarrigle<br />

Walter B. Melvin<br />

Roger & Barbara Michaels<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Charles Miesner<br />

Lynden B. Miller<br />

Ann H. Milne<br />

Lawrence K. Moss<br />

Robert Murdock<br />

Scott <strong>New</strong>man<br />

Cesar Neyra<br />

Erika W. Nijenhuis & Christian Bastian<br />

Elizabeth Nisbet & Dale Reynolds<br />

Sidney & Avodah Offit<br />

Everett H. Ortner<br />

Valerie Paley<br />

Marjorie Pearson<br />

Michael Phillips<br />

Robert Pirani<br />

Percy Preston Jr.<br />

Donald & Ilona Quest<br />

John T. Reddick<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Robert Riggs<br />

Paul Rosenfeld<br />

Susan J. Rosenthal & Larry Grosberg<br />

John Rowley<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Fred P. Rubin<br />

Bret & Amy Russell<br />

Marie Elena Saul<br />

Thomas F. Schutte<br />

Philip E. Schwartz<br />

Jane F. Scovell<br />

Patricia Bakwin Selch<br />

Robert A. Silver<br />

John J. Slain<br />

James Somogyi<br />

Susan W. Stachelberg<br />

Martha Roby Stephens<br />

Edmund Sullivan<br />

Donald Swanson<br />

Louise S. Thompson<br />

Susan Tunick<br />

Laurence M. Turk<br />

Paul Wachtel<br />

Felicia Warshawsky<br />

John P. Waugh<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Avrom S. Waxman<br />

Jill C. Weinstein<br />

Nada & David Westerman<br />

Diane White<br />

Ronda F. Wist<br />

Kevin Wolfe<br />

Barbara Wriston<br />

Wolodomyr Wronskyj<br />

Mr. & Mrs. Daniel Zucker<br />

Professional Circle<br />

Benefactor<br />

Beyer Blinder Belle Architects and Planners, LLP<br />

Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc.<br />

Green-Wood Cemetery<br />

Schtiller & Plevy, Inc.<br />

Specter DeSouza Architects, PC<br />

Patron<br />

AKRF, Inc.<br />

Gruzen Samton Planners & Interior Designers<br />

Hazardous Elimination Corporation<br />

Jan Hird Pokorny Associates, Inc.<br />

Nova Restoration of NY, Inc.<br />

Platt Byard Dovell White Architects, LLP<br />

Polshek Partnership Architects<br />

Rambusch Decorating Company, Inc.<br />

Taconic Builders, Inc.<br />

Walter B. Melvin Architects, LLC<br />

Wank Adams Slavin Associates, LLP<br />

Associate<br />

Acheson Doyle Partners<br />

Air-Flo Window Contracting Corp.<br />

Alexander Antonelli Architects PLLC<br />

ALSA Architecture<br />

AltieriSeborWieber, LLC<br />

Annex Masonry Restoration, Inc.<br />

Artisan Restoration Group<br />

Artistic Doors and Windows, Inc.<br />

Penelope Bareau<br />

Belisle Ancestral Doors and Windows<br />

Bell Donnelly Architects and Planners<br />

Jeffrey Berman Architect<br />

William Bialosky Architect<br />

Brisk Waterproofing Company, Inc.<br />

Brownstone Authority, Inc.<br />

Building Conservation Associates, Inc.<br />

Burda Construction Corp.<br />

CetraRuddy, Inc.<br />

Cityproof Corp.<br />

Concord Painting, Inc.<br />

Cooper Robertson & Partners Architecture<br />

Crawford & Stearns<br />

Curtis + Ginsberg Architects, LLP<br />

Darius Toraby Architects, PC<br />

daSILVA Architects<br />

David D. Harlan Architects, LLC<br />

De Groot Historical Restoration, Inc.<br />

Deerpath Construction Corp.<br />

Design Preserve Build (DPB)<br />

Mary B. Dierickx<br />

Domingo Gonzalez Associates<br />

East End Wood Strippers, Inc.<br />

Edelman Sultan Knox Wood Architects, LLP<br />

Edward Kamper Associates<br />

Eipel Barbieri Marschhausen, LLP<br />

Essex Works, Ltd.<br />

F.M. Pucci and Associates, Ltd.<br />

Façade Maintenance Design, PC<br />

Farewell Mills Gatsch Architects, LLC<br />

Femenella and Associates<br />

Ferguson & Shamamian Architects, LLP<br />

Fifty Three Restorations, Inc.<br />

Flickinger Glassworks, Inc.<br />

Franco Restoration & Remodeling Corp.<br />

Françoise Bollack Architects<br />

FXFOWLE Architects, PC<br />

Robert F. Germain P.E., PC<br />

Gertler & Wente Architects, LLP<br />

<strong>The</strong> Gil Studio<br />

Gilsanz Murray Steficek, LLP<br />

Glass & Glass Architects<br />

Glück <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, Inc.<br />

Goshow Architects, LLP<br />

Grand Renovation, Inc.<br />

Hall Partnership Architects, LLP<br />

Helpern Architects<br />

Charles H. Henkels, AIA<br />

Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC<br />

Interior Alterations, Inc.<br />

J & R Lamb Studios, Inc.<br />

J. Pontes Corp.<br />

Jablonski Building Conservation, Inc.<br />

Janko Rasic Architects<br />

JELD-WEN Windows & Doors<br />

JMA Consultants, Inc.<br />

John G. Waite Associates Architects PLLC<br />

Joseph K. Blum Co., LLP<br />

Mary Kay Judy<br />

Karp Associates, Inc.<br />

Kathryn Scott Design Studio<br />

Holly Kaye<br />

Michael A. Kaye, Esq.<br />

31


<strong>The</strong> Kibel Companies, LLC<br />

Mitchell Kurtz Architect, PC<br />

LandAir Project Resources<br />

Landmark Facilities Group, Inc.<br />

Lee Harris Pomeroy Associates<br />

Leonard Colchamiro, AIA, PC<br />

Leslie E. Robertson Associates, RLLP<br />

Levien & Company, Inc.<br />

Douglas J. Lister Architect<br />

M & L Steel Ornamental Iron Corp.<br />

Maidman and Mittelman, LLP<br />

Mand Restoration<br />

Marilyn E. Kaplan Preservation Architecture<br />

Peter Marino Architect PLLC<br />

Midtown Preservation, PC<br />

Millwork Specialties<br />

Mitropoulos Architects<br />

Craig Morrison, AIA<br />

Murphy Burnham & Buttrick Architects<br />

<strong>New</strong>man Design<br />

Neuhaus Design Architecture, PC<br />

<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Brickwork Design Center<br />

Nicholson & Galloway, Inc.<br />

Norfast Consulting Group, Inc.<br />

Northeastern Dimensional Millwork, Inc.<br />

Paragon Restoration Corporation<br />

Mariann G. Perseo, Esq.<br />

Jean Parker Phifer, FAIA<br />

Polshek Partnership Architects<br />

Porter Clapp Architects, PC<br />

PreservationDesignGroup/Daniel Koplowitz<br />

Architect<br />

PROSOCO, Inc.<br />

Putnam County Historic Preservation Advisory<br />

Commission<br />

Rand Engineering and Architecture, PC<br />

Renfro Design Group, Inc.<br />

Richard Baronio & Associates<br />

Richbrook Conservation<br />

Robert Silman Associates, PC<br />

Robinson Contracting, Inc.<br />

Rohlf’s Stained & Leaded Glass Studio<br />

Russel Watsky, Inc.<br />

SAM Fundraising Solutions Corp.<br />

Schwartz’s Forge & Metalworks, Inc.<br />

SMA Architecture Planning Interiors, PC<br />

Spirit Ironworks<br />

Harold S. Spitzer Architect, PC<br />

Star Metal, Inc.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Stephen B. Jacobs Group<br />

Swanke Hayden Connell Architects<br />

TMT Restoration Consultants, Ltd.<br />

Tobin + Parnes Design Enterprises<br />

Traditional Line, Ltd.<br />

Turett Collaborative Architects<br />

Universal Builders Supply, Inc.<br />

Urban D.C., Inc.<br />

Vertical Access, LLC<br />

Vestacast<br />

Victor Rothman for Stained Glass<br />

Walter Sedovic Architects<br />

Weidlinger Associates, Inc.<br />

Wireless EDGE Consultants, LLC<br />

WLA Engineering, PC<br />

<strong>The</strong> Woodstone Company<br />

<strong>The</strong> Woodworks Company Ltd<br />

Linda M. Yowell, FAIA<br />

Zubatkin Owner Representation, LLC<br />

Real Estate Circle<br />

Society<br />

Stribling & Associates Ltd.<br />

Benefactor<br />

Friedman & Gotbaum LLP<br />

Patron<br />

6-16 77th Street Owners Corp.<br />

A.R. Walker & Co. Inc.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Malkin Fund Inc.<br />

Associate<br />

Ed Tristram Associates Inc.<br />

Annette Petrusa<br />

Levata Properties LLC<br />

<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Building Congress<br />

S.W. Management LLC<br />

Slater & Beckerman LLP<br />

In-Kind Donations<br />

Cartier<br />

Christie’s<br />

F.J. Sciame Construction<br />

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett<br />

32


Financial Statements<br />

Statement of Activities Year Ended December 31, <strong>2008</strong><br />

Revenue and Support Contributions $ 1,781,944<br />

Government grants 148,100<br />

Other grants 80,000<br />

Investment return used for operations 169,341<br />

Program services income 20,366<br />

Contributed services 180,266<br />

Total Support and Revenue $ 2,380,017<br />

Expenses Program $ 2,307,878<br />

Development 586,971<br />

Administration 373,865<br />

Total Expenses $ 3,268,714<br />

Non-Operating Activities Non-operating investment return (3,161,430)<br />

Change in Net Assets (4,050,127)<br />

Statement of Financial Position Year Ended December 31, <strong>2008</strong><br />

Net Assets, Beginning $ 9,368,464<br />

Net Assets, Ending $ 5,318,337<br />

Assets Cash and cash equivalents $ 419,900<br />

Pledges receivable 640,000<br />

Loans receivable 43,792<br />

Due from NYC Historic Properties Fund 30,251<br />

Prepaid expenses and other assets 62,955<br />

Investments 5,036,869<br />

Property and equipment, net 116,177<br />

Cash held for other agencies 103,539<br />

Total Assets $ 6,453,483<br />

Liabilities Accounts payable and accrued liabilities $ 10,056<br />

Deferred income 34,100<br />

Grants payable 880,287<br />

Deferred rent 107,163<br />

Amounts held for other agencies<br />

Queens Historic Properties Fund 103,380<br />

Greenwich House, Inc. 160<br />

Total Liabilities $ 1,135,146<br />

Net Assets<br />

Unrestricted<br />

Undesignated (777,865)<br />

Board Designated 2,629,378<br />

Total Unrestricted 1,851,513<br />

Temporarily restricted 513,756<br />

Permanently restricted 2,953,068<br />

Total Net Assets $ 5,318,337<br />

Total Liabilities and Net Assets $ 6,453,483<br />

A copy of completed audited financial statements for <strong>2008</strong> may be obtained upon written request from<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>: One Whitehall Street, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, NY 10004.<br />

33


Board of Directors<br />

Frank J. Sciame, Jr.<br />

Chair<br />

Allison Simmons Prouty, Esq.<br />

Vice Chair<br />

Lloyd P. Zuckerberg<br />

Treasurer<br />

Joan O. Camins<br />

Secretary<br />

Peg Breen<br />

President<br />

Justin Abelow<br />

Oscar K. Anderson III<br />

William G. Bardel<br />

William L. Bernhard<br />

Pamela Rubin Carter, Esq.<br />

Susan R. Cullman<br />

Michael K. De Chiara, Esq.<br />

Douglas Durst<br />

Stuart P. Feld<br />

David L. Fogel<br />

John M. Forelle, Esq.<br />

Brandon Fradd<br />

Richard Garvey<br />

Robert C. Graham Jr.<br />

Holly Hotchner<br />

Susan Henshaw Jones<br />

John J. Kerr Jr., Esq.<br />

John Morning<br />

Reverend Dr. Thomas F. Pike<br />

Marla Sabo<br />

Frances Scaife<br />

Marc P. Schappell<br />

Stuart N. Siegel<br />

David Kenneth Specter, AIA<br />

Elizabeth F. Stribling<br />

Donald G. Tober<br />

Sandra Faith Warshawsky<br />

Advisory Council<br />

Laurie Beckelman<br />

John Belle, FAIA, RIBA<br />

Kathryn McGraw Berry<br />

Reverend Canon George W. Brandt Jr.<br />

Farran Tozer Brown<br />

Anne Coffin<br />

Paul S. Byard, FAIA<br />

Peter Duchin<br />

Norton Garfinkle<br />

Clark P. Halstead<br />

Margaret Brennan Hassett<br />

Paul K. Herzan<br />

Reverend John A. Kamas<br />

Stephen Kirschenbaum<br />

John J. Kerr Jr., Esq.<br />

Parker Ladd<br />

Stephen S. Lash<br />

Mimi Levitt<br />

Malcolm MacKay<br />

Marjorie Flannigan MacLachlan, Esq.<br />

Frederic S. Papert<br />

Robert C. Quinlan<br />

Peter Quinn<br />

Arnold Scaasi<br />

Liz Smith<br />

Joanne M. Stern<br />

Staff<br />

Meral Agish<br />

Development Associate<br />

Karen Ansis<br />

Manager, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />

Historic Properties Fund and City Ventures Fund<br />

Veronica Ball<br />

Associate Director of Development<br />

Peg Breen<br />

President<br />

Marci Fiedler*<br />

Development Associate<br />

Ann-Isabel Friedman<br />

Director, Sacred Sites Program<br />

Andrea Goldwyn<br />

Director of Public Policy<br />

Alison Burke Griffiths*<br />

Publications Manager<br />

Shelley Jane Grossberg<br />

Development Counsel<br />

Ashley J. Hahn<br />

Program Coordinator, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />

Historic Properties Fund<br />

Alex Herrera<br />

Director, Technical Services Center<br />

Robert Irving*<br />

Comptroller<br />

James J. Mahoney<br />

Program Coordinator, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />

Historic Properties Fund<br />

Colleen Meagher<br />

Manager, Grants and Technical Services<br />

In Memoriam<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> lost two long-time friends in <strong>2008</strong>. Board member Paul Byard’s skills as<br />

an architect and attorney were instrumental in the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s early growth. He helped<br />

us obtain the then-vacant former Federal Archives Building in Greenwich Village and find<br />

a developer for the property. He also devised our Historic Properties Fund — a pioneering<br />

revolving loan fund for preservation — from the building’s proceeds. Roger Lang was our<br />

Public Policy Director for sixteen years. Roger’s encyclopedic knowledge of architecture,<br />

passion for preservation and eloquence made him a respected advocate and popular<br />

ambassador for the <strong>Conservancy</strong>. We miss each one’s expertise, opinions and flair.<br />

Kera Reid<br />

Office Manager<br />

Angel Santa<br />

Comptroller<br />

Amy Sullivan<br />

Senior Manager of Events<br />

L. Daniel Vincent*<br />

Director of Development and Finance<br />

*<strong>2008</strong><br />

34


One Whitehall Street<br />

<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, NY 10004<br />

212.995.5260<br />

nylandmarks.org

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!