ANNUAL REPORT 2008 - The New York Landmarks Conservancy
ANNUAL REPORT 2008 - The New York Landmarks Conservancy
ANNUAL REPORT 2008 - The New York Landmarks Conservancy
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> <strong>2008</strong>
Contents<br />
From the President 2<br />
Speaking Out for Preservation 3<br />
Providing Technical Expertise 7<br />
Preserving Sacred Sites 10<br />
Funding Historic Properties 15<br />
Assisting Nonprofits 18<br />
Honoring Excellence 21<br />
Celebrating Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> 24<br />
Special Events 27<br />
Our Supporters 28<br />
Financial Statements 33<br />
Board of Directors and Staff 34<br />
Photo Credits<br />
page 3<br />
page 4, bottom<br />
page 5, left<br />
page 5, right<br />
page 6, top<br />
page 6, bottom<br />
page 7<br />
page 21<br />
page 22, top<br />
page 22, middle<br />
page 22, bottom<br />
page 23, top<br />
page 23, middle<br />
page 23, bottom<br />
courtesy of Governors Island Alliance/ Joseph R. Melanson — www.skypic.com<br />
courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />
courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />
courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />
courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />
courtesy of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />
photo by Aalto Archives, Helsinki<br />
photo by Stephen Aviano, courtesy of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine<br />
courtesy of Wank Adams Slavin Associates LLP<br />
courtesy of Wank Adams Slavin Associates LLP<br />
courtesy of the Lawrence Group<br />
courtesy of Kostow Greenwood Architects LLP<br />
courtesy of Platt Byard Dovell White Architects LLP<br />
courtesy of Kaitsen Woo Architect, P.C.<br />
Additional photography by <strong>Conservancy</strong> staff.<br />
Printing by Lexicon Communications.
From the President<br />
Even as the <strong>Conservancy</strong> experienced the economic shocks faced by so many this year, we continued to fulfill our singular mission: to assist homeowners<br />
and stewards of historic buildings that hold our common architectural heritage. Helping people maintain their homes, nonprofits, and religious<br />
institutions is central to <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>’s economy and quality of life. Maintaining the fabric of our City is especially urgent now.<br />
It is sometimes hard to convey how much we do in a year. We are at the forefront of major issues like Moynihan Station and Governors Island. But much<br />
of our work involves important though little-known buildings far from the center of Manhattan. A lot of it isn’t glamorous — just essential. Fixing leaky<br />
roofs, re-facing crumbling brownstone, helping a community development group create affordable housing in a lovely old building, or assisting a small<br />
congregation with making their church or synagogue more energy efficient.<br />
We are the only ones doing this work.<br />
Five of our low-interest loans this year helped owners in Brooklyn clean and restore brownstone façades, stoops, and ironwork. Our grants to nonprofit<br />
community developers helped with plans to upgrade a former Brooklyn firehouse that now houses low-income apartments and helped turn a former<br />
meeting hall in the Bronx into apartments and retail space.<br />
Our Sacred Sites Program awarded more than a half-million dollars to 51 landmark religious institutions throughout the state. We helped Maspeth,<br />
Queens residents pull off an eleventh-hour rescue of a rare Richard Upjohn-designed church. We usually fight to keep buildings up. But when this rare<br />
survivor couldn’t be moved intact from a development site, we helped find funding and expertise to disassemble and store it. We will continue to work<br />
with the community to rebuild the former church nearby and put it into community use. We also helped the oldest synagogue in Queens with funding<br />
and attaining landmark status.<br />
We are making unprecedented efforts to expand our assistance. We have created new National Register Historic Districts by researching, surveying,<br />
and analyzing areas in Harlem, the Bronx and Brooklyn. <strong>The</strong> State approved our work and officially created these new districts. <strong>The</strong>se listings make the<br />
hundreds of buildings in these areas eligible for our loans and grants.<br />
We continued our multi-year survey of religious institutions to identify Catholic churches and synagogues in need of our technical and financial help.<br />
We shared the results of our Brooklyn Roman Catholic church survey with the Brooklyn-Queens Diocese. We will also prepare nominations to the<br />
National Register for 10 Brooklyn and Queens synagogues we have identified. We intend to survey churches from other denominations in the future.<br />
After years of <strong>Conservancy</strong> pressure, the Gothic revival Renwick Ruin on Roosevelt Island is being stabilized. <strong>The</strong> ruin has tantalized East Side residents<br />
and drivers on the FDR for years. It may now serve as the centerpiece of a new park to be built adjacent to the landmark. And after years of<br />
our working with a broad alliance dedicated to saving St. Brigid’s, an anonymous donor has pledged enough money to restore the oldest surviving Irish<br />
immigrant-built church in the City.<br />
Thank you for recognizing how vital our programs are to <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>’s current — and long-term — viability, and thank you for making our work possible.<br />
Peg Breen, President<br />
2
Speaking Out for Preservation<br />
Governors Island
<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> is a respected voice for<br />
preservation, often leading major campaigns on important issues.<br />
We also advocate for sound preservation laws and policies at the<br />
Federal, State, and local level.<br />
Keeping Governors Island Open to the Public<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> has been a long-time advocate for Governors Island, the<br />
former military facility which has been transformed into a center for tourism,<br />
arts, and recreation; and received a record number of visitors in <strong>2008</strong>.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Island’s 52 historic buildings (including two 19th-century forts) create<br />
a unique cultural and educational experience. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> is a charter<br />
member of the Governors Island Alliance and has supported efforts<br />
to find new uses for the Island while maintaining its historic resources.<br />
When the State announced that it would cut funds for the Island and endanger<br />
its operating budget, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> stepped forward, lobbying<br />
State and City officials to ensure that the $6 million from the State would<br />
be included in the 2010 budget and matched by the City. Future capital<br />
improvements are scheduled to include new park and open space facilities<br />
and stabilization of the historic houses.<br />
Continuing the Fight for Moynihan Station<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> continued to push for a great Moynihan Station despite<br />
the change in State administrations, and we promoted the station as an<br />
important stimulus during the economic downturn.<br />
Plans for Moynihan Station shifted direction after Governor David Paterson<br />
assumed the reins of State government in March. Shortly after that,<br />
Madison Square Garden said it was abandoning plans to move into the<br />
rear of the landmark Farley Post Office and would instead renovate the<br />
existing Garden.<br />
In a speech in September, Governor Paterson said he hoped to build the<br />
Station as the gateway to <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> envisioned by the late Senator Daniel<br />
Patrick Moynihan in the early 1990s. <strong>The</strong> governor said he wanted<br />
a transportation project, first and foremost, not the real estate project<br />
the proposed developers had envisioned. He also requested that the Port<br />
Authority take over the project. Paterson called for: increasing transportation<br />
capacity by expanding the number of tracks under Farley; coordinating<br />
with other major development projects, especially ARC, a new <strong>New</strong><br />
Jersey Transit tunnel under the Hudson; and ensuring that the station was<br />
a development catalyst for Manhattan’s Upper West Side. He asked for a<br />
staff report by October 31 on the station challenges and solutions.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>, along with other “Friends of Moynihan Station” members,<br />
welcomed the new direction and expressed support. We also continued<br />
to emphasize the importance of protecting Farley’s landmark exterior<br />
and beautiful post office lobby.<br />
By year’s end, the Moynihan Station report still was not public. But we<br />
continue to say, “Build Farley now.”<br />
top <strong>The</strong> grand columns of Farley Post Office<br />
bottom Silver Towers at NYU<br />
4
Supporting Landmark Designations<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s testimony – before the <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation<br />
Commission and the City Council – helped achieve designations of<br />
historic districts and individual buildings across the City in <strong>2008</strong>.<br />
We supported the creation of five new districts:<br />
<strong>The</strong> West Chelsea Historic District and NoHo Historic District Extension<br />
recognize the significance of the industrial building. West Chelsea is composed<br />
of late 19th and early 20th century buildings originally used for<br />
manufacturing. <strong>The</strong> third phase of the NoHo designation adds a gritty mix<br />
of 56 buildings exemplifying the range of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>’s architectural styles,<br />
from Federal to Italianate to contemporary design.<br />
Brooklyn districts ranged from the very small to very large. Alice and Agate<br />
Courts in central Brooklyn are two block-long cul-de-sacs of picturesque<br />
Queen Anne row houses. <strong>The</strong> Prospect Heights Historic District contains<br />
more than 800 row houses, and apartment and institutional buildings from<br />
the late 19th and early 20th centuries, with many intact blocks of beautiful<br />
Italianate, neo-Grec, and Second Empire brownstones.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Ridgewood North Historic District, located in southwest Queens,<br />
contains 96 buildings from 1908 — 11 known for their distinguished brick<br />
façades, and for the progressive innovations in the residential tenement<br />
form that they feature.<br />
We also supported fifteen individual landmark designations, including:<br />
Religious properties. Congregation Tifereth Israel in Corona, Queens, and<br />
two churches in the East Village: James Renwick Jr.’s Gothic-style masterpiece,<br />
St. Nicholas of Myra Orthodox Church, and the Russian Orthodox<br />
Cathedral of the Holy Virgin Protection.<br />
Three very different structures within Manhattan. <strong>The</strong> Consolidated Edison<br />
Building, with its clock tower that is visible for miles; McKim Mead<br />
and White’s Hotel Pennsylvania, facing development pressures; and the<br />
Rainbow Room, in Rockefeller Center.<br />
A number of buildings outside Manhattan. <strong>The</strong> Hubbard House at 2138<br />
McDonald Avenue, in Gravesend, Brooklyn, one of the few remaining<br />
Dutch-style houses in the City; the George Cunningham Store in Tottenville,<br />
Staten Island, distinguished by Queen Anne details such as wooden<br />
clapboards and fish-scale shingles; and the Museum Building at the <strong>New</strong><br />
<strong>York</strong> Botanical Garden, which won the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Lucy G. Moses Preservation<br />
Award when it was restored in 2004.<br />
Three buildings used by institutions of higher learning. I.M. Pei’s Silver<br />
Towers complex at NYU, which Robert A.M Stern called “one of the 35<br />
most important Modernist buildings in the City”; 144 West 14th Street, a<br />
seven-story Renaissance-Revival building from 1895-96, now the home<br />
of the Pratt Institute’s Historic Preservation program; and the Baumann<br />
Bros. Building on East 14th Street, best known for its elaborate cast-iron<br />
façade, and now owned by the <strong>New</strong> School.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> continued to advocate for school buildings designed by<br />
C.B.J. Snyder by speaking out for designation of Grammar School No. 9<br />
on West End Avenue.<br />
left Grammar School No. 9, Manhattan<br />
right Alice Court, Brooklyn<br />
5
Speaking Out on Issues<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Public Policy Committee reviewed design proposals<br />
throughout <strong>2008</strong> and approved statements of its views for public hearings<br />
before various agencies.<br />
A proposal by St. Vincent’s Hospital engaged the preservation community<br />
and the <strong>Conservancy</strong> in <strong>2008</strong>. St. Vincent’s presented plans to demolish<br />
all of its historic and contemporary buildings, put up a new hospital where<br />
the O’Toole Building now stands on Seventh Avenue, and sell land that<br />
would become the site of a large residential development. <strong>The</strong> Committee<br />
supported demolition of O’Toole, but did not agree with the loss of other<br />
historic buildings, and suggested that the new hospital’s size be reduced.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Committee supported aspects of a plan to revitalize the South Street<br />
Seaport, but objected to new buildings that would overwhelm the lowrise<br />
structures that comprise the Seaport Historic District.<br />
A transfer of development rights from the General Society for Mechanics<br />
and Tradesmen on West 44th Street to a site at Fifth Avenue and 43rd<br />
Street was found to result in a valid “preservation purpose.” <strong>The</strong> proceeds<br />
of the transfer will finance necessary restoration on the Society’s<br />
landmark building.<br />
Upon reviewing a proposal to transfer development rights from St. Thomas<br />
Church and the University Club to a nearby site west of the Museum<br />
Tower on West 53rd Street, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> requested that restricted<br />
endowments be created for both landmarks, with at least part of the<br />
proceeds from the sale of the air rights specifically targeted for the up<br />
keep of the historic buildings. <strong>The</strong> developers agreed to the request. <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong> also pointed out that the proposed new building would encroach<br />
on a preservation district.<br />
top Prospect Heights, Brooklyn<br />
bottom 144 West 14th Street, Manhattan<br />
Endangered Buildings Initiative<br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong> staff visited the buildings on its EBI “red list” to update their status. Thanks to either landmark designation or owner intervention,<br />
approximately a quarter of the “red” buildings will be removed from the list, as they no longer appear to be threatened.<br />
One of EBI’s successes is the 2005 designation of the Windermere Apartments as an individual landmark. Designed by <strong>The</strong>ophilius Smith in 1880-<br />
81, the Windermere is a complex of three red brick tenement buildings with decorative features in the Gothic, Queen Anne, and Romanesque<br />
styles. Originally it was used as housing for single women, an innovation in the late 19th century. By 2000 the deteriorated building was nearly<br />
empty, but still retained much of its magnificent historic fabric. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> led the push to get it designated.<br />
In <strong>2008</strong>, with the assistance of the Department of Housing Preservation and Development, the Windermere’s tenants brought the building owners<br />
to court to demand that they address various violations the building had earned. HPD filed two other motions: one to seek access to inspect the<br />
property and another to secure it. That motion was granted, and the owner was ordered to secure and seal the building. <strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Law<br />
Department filed an injunction and civil penalties action under the <strong>Landmarks</strong> Law. We hope that this legal pressure will force the owner to either<br />
sell the property or make repairs.<br />
6
Providing Technical Expertise<br />
Edgar J Kaufmann Conference Center, Manhattan
Government agencies, nonprofits, and building owners call upon<br />
our Technical Services staff for expert guidance on restoration<br />
projects, preservation easements, and advisory committees.<br />
Project Guidance<br />
Renwick Ruins, Roosevelt Island, Manhattan<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> has been monitoring the progress of the stabilization<br />
and restoration of the Renwick-designed Smallpox Hospital ruins sited at<br />
the southern tip of Roosevelt Island. <strong>The</strong> goal is to stabilize the structure<br />
as a picturesque ruin so that it may eventually form the centerpiece of a<br />
new public park that will fill the southern tip of the island. Many of the<br />
building’s teetering stones were removed, numbered, and stored on site.<br />
Other features, including the beautiful Gothic-revival oriel windows, have<br />
been dismantled and will be reassembled. In order to brace the walls,<br />
steel piers will be installed inside the building and cables will ensure that<br />
the walls remain in place.<br />
Edgar J Kaufmann Conference Center, Manhattan<br />
After several months of detective work, technical staff has tracked down<br />
the specific type and color of carpeting originally specified by Alvar and<br />
Alisa Aalto for the suite of rooms known as the “Aalto Rooms” – or, more<br />
accurately, the Kaufmann Conference Center at the Institute of International<br />
Education (IIE). <strong>The</strong> original textile was a 100 percent wool carpet<br />
composed of three different earth tones woven in a random pattern to produce<br />
a speckled effect. It also featured an egg-shaped cutout section that<br />
could be unzipped and removed when the occasion called for a dance floor<br />
to be moved in. In late October, the IIE received our report and a sample<br />
of the textile, which was custom-woven by the same North Carolina mill<br />
that produced the original.<br />
Several years ago, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> oversaw the restoration of the center’s<br />
suite of rooms, including repair and repainting of the plaster walls<br />
and undulating ceiling, gentle cleaning of the woodwork paneling trim<br />
and sculptural elements, as well as the replacement of its very tall curtains<br />
with a custom-made reproduction of the original textile, which we<br />
also traced back to the original manufacturer.<br />
Picasso Curtain, Four Seasons Restaurant, Manhattan<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> retained a team of fabric and paint conservators to inspect<br />
and clean a theater curtain painted by Pablo Picasso in 1911, which<br />
now hangs in the Four Seasons restaurant in the Seagram Building. This<br />
gorgeous piece was donated to the <strong>Conservancy</strong> in 2006 with the stipulation<br />
that it not be moved from its current location and that the <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />
oversee its care and maintenance. We arranged to have art and<br />
fabric conservators inspect and clean the artwork over the course of two<br />
weekends in late August. <strong>The</strong> results of the gentle cleaning of the textile<br />
are noticeable, and today the artwork looks brighter and crisper.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> received a full conservation report from the team in late<br />
September. <strong>The</strong> painted curtain, though fragile, shows no signs of ongoing<br />
deterioration and was found to be in stable condition.<br />
8
Old Guard of the City of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Headquarters, Manhattan<br />
<strong>The</strong> Old Guard is a military veterans association founded in 1832. It owns<br />
an historic limestone-fronted townhouse on 91st Street between Riverside<br />
Drive and West End Avenue that serves as the association’s headquarters.<br />
<strong>The</strong> building dates to 1899 and is part of a row of seven houses<br />
designed as an ensemble. It is in generally good condition, but has suffered<br />
from deferred maintenance. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Technical Services<br />
Center undertook a roof-to-basement inspection of the house in order to<br />
prepare an exiting conditions report of the property and establish priorities<br />
for restoration and repair. <strong>The</strong> masonry façades, including the dramatic<br />
bow-fronted limestone front, are in very good condition. However, the<br />
roofs need to be replaced in their entirety. Rainwater is leaking in various<br />
places, causing quite a bit of damage to interior finishes. Additionally, the<br />
front mansard roof, originally clad in terra cotta tiles, is currently missing<br />
them and in need of restoration. An ongoing project, we continue to meet<br />
with representatives from the Old Guard to plan a campaign of roof repair.<br />
European Union House, Manhattan<br />
Technical Services staff are consultants to the architect overseeing the<br />
restoration of 240 East 72nd Street, a townhouse that will be the future<br />
home of the European Union’s Deputy Ambassador to the United Nations.<br />
Part of the project consisted of reconstructing unstable portions of the<br />
rear façade and adding a small conservatory to the back of the house. <strong>The</strong><br />
front façade is being restored to its original appearance; this includes the<br />
reconstruction of the front stoop, which was removed many years ago.<br />
prior page<br />
left and right Renwick Ruins, Roosevelt Island<br />
this page<br />
top<br />
bottom<br />
Picasso Curtain, Four Seasons, Manhattan<br />
Old Guard Headquarters, Manhattan<br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong> Easements<br />
Although the <strong>Conservancy</strong> was in active discussions with a<br />
number of property owners interested in donating a preservation<br />
easement to the <strong>Conservancy</strong>, we did not receive any new donations<br />
in <strong>2008</strong>. However, the staff prepared and submitted to the<br />
National Park Service several “Certification of Significance”<br />
applications. <strong>The</strong>se applications are the first step in the easement<br />
donation process. We look forward to accepting easement<br />
on the properties covered by these applications in 2009.<br />
In the meantime, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> maintained its regular schedule<br />
of inspection of all properties and identified several maintenance<br />
problems at several properties. All these issues have<br />
been addressed or are in the process of being addressed.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> currently holds 45 easements.<br />
9
Preserving Sacred Sites<br />
Ocean Parkway Jewish Center, Brooklyn
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Sacred Sites Program is one of the few programs<br />
in the country dedicated to the preservation of historic religious<br />
properties. Since its establishment in 1986, the program has<br />
awarded more than 1,000 grants, totaling almost $6 million, to more<br />
than 650 institutions throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State. In addition to offering<br />
restoration grants, the program has assisted hundreds of<br />
landmark-quality religious institutions with hands-on technical assistance<br />
and referrals, and offered workshops on the maintenance<br />
and repair of aging roofs, façades, and windows, and associated<br />
financial issues.<br />
For the first time since its launch in 2000, the Sacred Sites Robert<br />
W. Wilson Challenge Grant Program awarded grants in both January<br />
and June, with a total of $300,000 awarded in <strong>2008</strong>. Altogether,<br />
through its 3 grant programs, Sacred Sites awarded 57 grants totaling<br />
more than $550,000 to 51 landmark religious institutions in 33<br />
counties throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State.<br />
In the spring of <strong>2008</strong>, Sacred Sites Director Ann-Isabel Friedman<br />
attended a Historic Districts Council monthly roundtable. She presented<br />
information to a group of 30 neighborhood preservation<br />
advocates on the Sacred Sites Program and ongoing advocacy<br />
and outreach, Catholic church and synagogue surveys, and the<br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong>’s successful collaboration with the Brooklyn-Queens<br />
Diocese. Ms. Friedman encouraged attendees to reach out to their<br />
local religious institutions and participate as neighborhood partners<br />
in capital project planning. In June, Ms. Friedman presented<br />
at a two-day Preservation League of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State Colleagues’<br />
Workshop in Buffalo, focusing on state-wide Catholic church closure<br />
as well as urban property abandonment.<br />
Progress Report<br />
Church and Synagogue Surveys<br />
Sacred Sites staff presented the results of its Brooklyn Roman Catholic<br />
church survey to the Brooklyn-Queens Diocese in the spring. We highlighted<br />
the most significant Brooklyn churches, made recommendations<br />
for National Register listing, and explained which churches would be the<br />
best candidates for <strong>Conservancy</strong> and possible <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State restoration<br />
grant funding. Diocesan officials and real estate staff shared our enthusiasm<br />
for many of the Diocese’s most handsome and historic churches, requesting<br />
that the <strong>Conservancy</strong> share its data with the Diocese real estate<br />
staff and archives. In the summer, a team of three graduate interns from<br />
Columbia University and Pratt Institute extended the survey into Queens,<br />
documenting 100 Roman Catholic churches and 120 synagogues.<br />
As for our synagogue survey, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> was awarded a prestigious<br />
$20,000 Preserve <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> grant, the largest of 16 awarded to nonprofit<br />
groups throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State, to fund the preparation of National<br />
Register nominations for ten Brooklyn and Queens synagogues and former<br />
synagogues. We are also pleased to announce that Roy Zuckerberg, father<br />
of <strong>Conservancy</strong> board member Lloyd Zuckerberg, recently presented a<br />
lead gift to help launch an Historic Synagogues Fund. <strong>Conservancy</strong> efforts<br />
to identify additional donors are ongoing.<br />
top Sacred Sites grantee Grace Church, Lyons, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
bottom Jewish Center of Kings Highway, Brooklyn<br />
11
A Tale of Two Catholic Churches<br />
St. Brigid’s and St. Thomas the Apostle<br />
After several years of energetic community advocacy and fundraising, the<br />
Archdiocese of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> announced in May that an anonymous donor<br />
had offered $20 million to save the parish of St. Brigid’s in the East Village.<br />
<strong>The</strong> church, attributed to Patrick Keely, is the oldest surviving Irish<br />
immigrant-built church in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City and one of the City’s earliest<br />
Gothic Revival churches. <strong>The</strong> 1848 building features a relatively simple<br />
exterior and a soaring, vaulted interior. It closed in 2004 due to significant<br />
structural damage caused by deterioration of the original, below-grade<br />
wood piles.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Archdiocese began demolition work in 2006. Despite overwhelming<br />
odds, a committed and broad alliance of parishioners, East Village preservation<br />
advocates, and prominent Irish-American artists worked tirelessly<br />
to save the church. This unique coalition raised funds for expert legal help,<br />
obtaining a restraining order that barred the Archdiocese from any further<br />
demolition work. <strong>The</strong> lawsuit was dismissed in 2007 but upheld on appeal.<br />
<strong>The</strong> group received permission in January <strong>2008</strong> to bring the case<br />
to the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State Supreme Court. Before the court convened, the<br />
Archdiocese announced the anonymous donation; $10 million would go<br />
to restore the building and reopen it as a parish church, $2 million to establish<br />
an endowment for the parish, and $8 million to support the parish<br />
school and other parochial schools in the Archdiocese.<br />
Throughout this four-year journey, through many ups and downs, the<br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong> advised the “Save St. Brigid’s” alliance, providing technical<br />
advice on building stabilization costs and alternative redevelopment, as<br />
well as outreach to the Archdiocese, news outlets, and the Irish-American<br />
community.<br />
With such a generous gift in hand, the Archdiocese hired the respected<br />
preservation architecture firm Acheson Doyle Partners to restore the<br />
church, which requires extensive underpinning. Officials expect the project<br />
to take a couple of years. Restoration work continues today, and<br />
supporters eagerly await the church’s reopening.<br />
Another Manhattan church which the <strong>Conservancy</strong> has fought to save has<br />
been less fortunate than its downtown neighbor: St. Thomas the Apostle<br />
in Harlem. It shut its doors in 2003 and remains unutilized despite the<br />
strong efforts of local groups, Congressman Rangel, and the <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />
to present the Archdiocese with alternate development plans. Several of<br />
its windows had been promised to an upstate church under construction,<br />
Blessed Kateri Tekawitha church in LaGrangeville, NY.<br />
<strong>The</strong> unusually cohesive suite of windows was designed specifically to<br />
complement St. Thomas’ lacy terra cotta tracery and Gothic-arched openings.<br />
<strong>The</strong> La Grangeville church opened in <strong>2008</strong> without the St. Thomas<br />
windows, pending their removal, restoration, and relocation, which are<br />
expected in 2009.<br />
left St. Brigid’s, overlooking Tompkins Square Park in the East Village<br />
right St. Thomas the Apostle, Harlem<br />
12
In Memoriam<br />
Bay Ridge United Methodist Church<br />
After years of assistance from the <strong>Conservancy</strong>, congregational struggle,<br />
and community advocacy, we were sad to note the demolition of Bay<br />
Ridge United Methodist Church last fall.<br />
Designed by church architect George W. Kramer in 1899-1900, it was<br />
known throughout the neighborhood as the “green church” for its distinctive<br />
green “serpentine” sandstone façade, which had severely deteriorated.<br />
A 2004 <strong>Conservancy</strong> grant helped fund the temporary use of a net<br />
around the church tower to hold falling stone in place. A 2005 <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />
study estimated necessary stone replacement at the clock tower at<br />
$670,000, with comprehensive repairs projected at $6.8 to $8.6 million,<br />
exclusive of interior upgrades or accessibility modifications.<br />
While community advocates hoped for a different outcome, the site was<br />
sold and initially slated for new condominium development. By year’s<br />
end, the declining economy had halted condominium plans. Residents are<br />
hopeful that the site can be returned to community use via development<br />
of a new public school.<br />
11th- Hour Rescue of Rare Upjohn Church<br />
In the spring of <strong>2008</strong>, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> assisted community advocates by<br />
providing referrals and funding for the architectural documentation and<br />
careful disassembly and storage of the former St. Saviour’s, an 1847,<br />
Richard Upjohn designed, carpenter Gothic church in Maspeth, Queens.<br />
<strong>The</strong> wood-frame building was disassembled and moved from its original<br />
site, in anticipation that the 1.5 acre site will be sold for development.<br />
<strong>The</strong> building is in storage, awaiting reassembly on the grounds of All<br />
Faiths Cemetery in Maspeth, Queens, thanks to the hard work of members<br />
of the Juniper Park Civic Association, and emergency funding from the<br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong>, Queens Borough President Helen Marshall, and preservation<br />
advocate Christabel Gough, to retain building professionals experienced<br />
in historic wood-frame construction: Kaitsen Woo Architects, Island<br />
Housewrights, and to video document the building’s dismantling. <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />
referral, the experienced preservation architecture firm Kai Woo<br />
Architects was engaged to prepare plans for a reconstructed St. Saviour’s.<br />
Queens’ Oldest Synagogue Becomes a Landmark<br />
Queens’ oldest surviving synagogue, the 1911 Congregation Tifereth Israel<br />
in Corona, was designated a <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Landmark in early <strong>2008</strong>.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>, working closely with Queens Borough President Helen<br />
Marshall, lent technical and financial assistance to this small Bukharan<br />
Congregation and helped secure $1.1 million in public and more than<br />
$300,000 in private funding for the $1.4 million restoration of the building’s<br />
original wooden siding and windows. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> itself provided<br />
$17,500 in grant support, along with countless hours of free technical<br />
advice by program director Ann-Isabel Friedman. Through Ms. Friedman’s<br />
support, the synagogue was able to secure a $200,000 <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State<br />
Environmental Protection Fund grant, and $90,000 in support from other<br />
foundations. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> will continue to support this project as it<br />
works through the EPF bidding process.<br />
top Bay Ridge United Methodist, Brooklyn<br />
middle St. Saviour’s Church, Maspeth, Queens<br />
bottom Congregation Tifereth Israel, Corona, Queens<br />
13
Sacred Sites and Consulting Grants<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> awards Sacred Sites and Consulting Grants to congregations<br />
of all denominations that are planning or undertaking the restoration<br />
of historic religious properties.<br />
To be eligible, properties must be located in <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State, owned by<br />
a religious institution and actively used for worship, and listed on the<br />
State or National Register of Historic Places or designated pursuant to a<br />
local landmarks ordinance. Eligible properties include, but are not limited<br />
to, churches, synagogues, meetinghouses, mosques, and temples. <strong>The</strong><br />
maximum Sacred Sites Grant is $10,000; in <strong>2008</strong> the average grant award<br />
was about $5,500. <strong>The</strong> maximum Consulting Grant is $7,500; in <strong>2008</strong> the<br />
average award was about $5,300.<br />
Asbury First United Methodist Church, Rochester<br />
Cathedral of All Saints, Albany<br />
Chapin Memorial, Unitarian Universalist Society of Oneonta, Oneonta<br />
Christ Episcopal Church, Sackets Harbor<br />
Christ Temple Church, Rochester<br />
Church For All Nations, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Church of the Ascension, Brooklyn<br />
Church of <strong>The</strong> Resurrection, Kew Gardens<br />
Community Church of East Williston<br />
Eldred Congregational Church, Eldred<br />
Episcopal Church of Saints Peter and John, Auburn<br />
First Baptist Church, Cuba<br />
First Baptist Church of Painted Post<br />
First Presbyterian Church, Cazenovia<br />
First Presbyterian Church, Schenectady<br />
First Presbyterian Church of Wyoming<br />
First United Methodist Church, <strong>New</strong>burgh<br />
Forest Presbyterian Church, Lyons Falls<br />
German Evangelical Lutheran Church of St. Paul, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Grace Episcopal Church, Bronx<br />
Grace Episcopal Church, Canton<br />
Grace Episcopal Church, Lyons<br />
Grace Episcopal Church, Syracuse<br />
Hamilton Monthly Meeting<br />
Immanuel Evangelical Lutheran Church, Kingston<br />
Old First Presbyterian Church, Huntington<br />
Our Lady of Victory / St. Joseph Roman Catholic Church, Rochester<br />
Rugged Cross Baptist Church, Brooklyn<br />
Sacred Heart Basilica, Syracuse<br />
St. Mark’s Evangelical Lutheran Church, Middleburgh<br />
St. Paul’s Church, Salem<br />
St. James Episcopal Church, Skaneateles<br />
St. Luke’s Episcopal Church, Katonah<br />
St. Mary’s Church-in-the-Highlands, Cold Spring<br />
Temple Sinai, Saratoga Springs<br />
<strong>The</strong> Reformed Dutch Church of Poughkeepsie<br />
Tremont Baptist Church, Bronx<br />
Trinity Church, Rensselaerville<br />
Trinity Episcopal Church, Buffalo<br />
Trinity Episcopal Church, Middleville<br />
Trinity Lutheran Church, Long Island City<br />
United Methodist Church of Durham-Oak Hill, Oak Hill<br />
University Parish of St. Joseph’s, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Wanakena Presbyterian Church, Star Lake<br />
Zion Episcopal Church, Morris<br />
Robert W. Wilson<br />
Sacred Sites Challenge Grants<br />
For comprehensive repair and extensive restoration projects, the Robert<br />
W. Wilson Sacred Sites Challenge Grant Program offers matching funds<br />
to churches. <strong>The</strong> majority of matching funds must be donated from new<br />
sources. Since its launch in 2000 the program has funded 65 challenge<br />
grants totaling more than $1.8 million, generating more than 1.9 million in<br />
grant matches that will facilitate the completion of more than $35 million<br />
in restoration of historic religious properties across <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State. In<br />
<strong>2008</strong> grants ranged from $25,000 to $70,000.<br />
Church of St. Ann and the Holy Trinity, Brooklyn<br />
Church of the Ascension, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Flushing Monthly Meeting, Flushing<br />
German Evangelical Lutheran Church of St. Paul, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Rugged Cross Baptist Church, Brooklyn<br />
St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
St. John the Baptist Roman Catholic Church, Brooklyn<br />
St. Mary’s Church-in-the-Highlands, Cold Spring<br />
Union <strong>The</strong>ological Seminary, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
above<br />
Temple Sinai, Saratoga Springs<br />
14
Funding Historic Properties<br />
295 Decatur Street, Brooklyn
<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Historic Properties Fund (HPF) is the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s<br />
main financing vehicle for restoration work throughout <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
City and is one of the largest revolving loan funds for historic preservation<br />
in the nation. <strong>The</strong> Fund has provided almost $18.4 million in<br />
low-interest loans and more than $380,000 in grants since its inception<br />
in 1982. As part of the program, the Fund offers project management<br />
assistance to help owners throughout the financing and<br />
restoration processes.<br />
Fund staff worked on more than 20 buildings of all architectural<br />
styles in <strong>2008</strong>, while continuing its initiative to expand HPF lending<br />
into new neighborhoods.<br />
<strong>2008</strong> Projects — Spotlight on Bedford-Stuyvesant<br />
Brooklyn has received well over half the Fund’s investments since 1982.<br />
This past year was no exception, with five of the Fund’s eight completed<br />
projects located in the borough. Of these five, three are in Bedford-<br />
Stuyvesant, which contains many of the City’s finest collections of row<br />
houses.<br />
HPF provided an $80,000 loan at five percent interest for 10 years to<br />
finance restoration work on the Cummings Residence at 295 Decatur<br />
Street, in the Stuyvesant Heights Historic District. This late 19th century<br />
row house is notable for its red-orange brick and brownstone, with intricate<br />
terra cotta details. <strong>The</strong> loan financed the cleaning and re-pointing of<br />
the masonry façade, cleaning and repair of the decorative elements, and<br />
the restoration of the front door, brownstone stoop, and ironwork. Additionally,<br />
18 windows were replaced, the parlor windows and their stained<br />
glass transoms were restored, and a stained glass window on the third<br />
floor was installed. Kaitsen Woo was the architect, and the contractor<br />
was Progeny Restoration.<br />
With a loan of $270,000 at three percent interest for 10 years, HPF financed<br />
an assortment of restoration work at St. Philip’s Episcopal Church<br />
at 334 MacDonough Street, also in the Stuyvesant Heights Historic District.<br />
St. Philip’s was designed in a picturesque style with English Gothic<br />
precedents by Arne Delhi, a Norwegian architect who lived and worked in<br />
Brooklyn. Over time, the 110-year-old church suffered water-related damage,<br />
and the HPF loan was used to address many of these issues. A few<br />
years ago, a Fund loan of $100,000 helped pay for the restoration of one<br />
of the church’s slate roofs. With the latest round of funding, the church’s<br />
other roofs and windows were repaired, new gutters and leaders were<br />
installed, and the deteriorated interior plaster was repaired and painted.<br />
Additionally, the masonry façade was cleaned and re-pointed, a new<br />
stone step was installed, and the tower windows were restored. Hall<br />
Partnership was the architect, and Henry Restoration was the contractor.<br />
For the Jackman Residence at 112 Hancock Street in the proposed Bedford<br />
National Register Historic District, HPF provided a $60,000 loan at<br />
five percent interest for 10 years to restore a Neo-Grec brownstone built<br />
circa 1880. <strong>The</strong> building’s distinctive iron cresting along the roof and atop<br />
the portico was carefully cleaned, repaired, and repainted. <strong>The</strong> brownstone<br />
façade and stoop were restored, the cornice was cleaned and repainted,<br />
and the ironwork was repaired. Kaitsen Woo was the architect,<br />
and the contractor was Cecil King Stone & Restoration.<br />
16
During the 1990s, the <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission identified several<br />
parts of Bedford-Stuyvesant as “Areas of Interest,” but they were<br />
never developed into districts. In an effort to update this work, Fund staff<br />
conducted a new survey and identified four distinct areas that featured<br />
intact historic row houses: Stuyvesant West, Bedford-Stuyvesant East<br />
Central, Shannon’s Garden, and Cripplebush Road. <strong>The</strong>se potential historic<br />
districts boasted row houses built around the turn of the 20th century<br />
in popular styles of the day: Italianate, Neo-Grec, Second Empire, Queen<br />
Anne, and Romanesque. Most of the buildings in Bedford-Stuyvesant<br />
East Central and Stuyvesant West were built before 1890 by prominent<br />
Brooklyn architects and builders. Shannon’s Garden is a mix of the late<br />
19th and early 20th centuries, with elaborate late-Italianate brownstones<br />
and Neo-Classical stone row houses. <strong>The</strong> Cripplebush Road district is<br />
comprised of several blocks of especially consistent, late-Italianate row<br />
house streetscapes, built between 1885 and 1891. <strong>The</strong> SHPO determined<br />
in November <strong>2008</strong> that these four areas were eligible for listing on the<br />
registers.<br />
With Highland Park’s 120 buildings and the 1,130 properties in the four<br />
Bedford-Stuyvesant areas, a total of 1,250 buildings have been added to<br />
the Fund’s universe of possible work.<br />
<strong>New</strong>ly Eligible State and National Register<br />
Historic Districts<br />
<strong>The</strong> City’s most recent real estate boom greatly increased property values<br />
in neighborhoods traditionally served by the Historic Properties Fund.<br />
In areas where the Fund has completed dozens of projects, such as Fort<br />
Greene, Brooklyn, the need for its assistance has decreased. In response,<br />
Fund staff began a campaign in 2007 to identify new areas for investing<br />
its resources: intact blocks of older properties that could be deemed eligible<br />
for listing in the State and/or National Registers of Historic Places, the<br />
minimum criterion required for Fund assistance. To accomplish this work,<br />
Fund staff and graduate interns researched, surveyed, and analyzed areas<br />
of historic interest and presented potential districts to the State Historic<br />
Preservation Office (SHPO), which then determines a district’s eligibility.<br />
Fund research led to determinations of eligibility for the Bradhurst Historic<br />
District in Harlem and the Windsor Terrace Historic District in Brooklyn.<br />
Five more areas of Brooklyn were added in <strong>2008</strong>: Highland Park in Cypress<br />
Hills and four sections of Bedford-Stuyvesant.<br />
prior page<br />
top Cummings Residence, 295 Decatur Street, Brooklyn<br />
bottom St. Philip’s Episcopal Church, 334 MacDonough Street, Brooklyn<br />
this page<br />
top Jackman Residence, 112 Hancock Street, Brooklyn<br />
bottom 279 Highland Boulevard, Brooklyn<br />
<strong>The</strong> Cypress Hills section of Brooklyn came to the Fund’s attention after<br />
the Pratt Institute Land Use and Historic Preservation Studio produced a<br />
draft study of the neighborhood. Fund staff built upon this information,<br />
as well as two prior studies, and selected Cypress Hill’s Highland Park<br />
neighborhood as a potential historic district. Highland Park is bordered<br />
on three sides by a greenbelt of parks and cemeteries. One part of the<br />
district consists of large free-standing 19th century homes with Spanishtile<br />
roofs. Downhill from the mansions lies an area of two- and three-story<br />
early 20th century row houses built in Eclectic revival styles with Mission<br />
or Craftsman details, and capped by red tile roofs echoing the architecture<br />
of the mansions above. <strong>The</strong> SHPO determined in May <strong>2008</strong> that Highland<br />
Park was eligible for listing on both registers.<br />
17
Assisting Nonprofits<br />
Van Cortlandt House Museum, the Bronx
City Ventures Fund<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s City Ventures Fund (CVF) works with nonprofit<br />
developers to retain or replace the period details of architecturally<br />
significant buildings — not necessarily designated landmarks —<br />
that will be used for affordable housing or neighborhood facilities.<br />
Since its establishment in 1986, CVF has authorized almost $1.4 million<br />
to assist over 840 units of low-income and special needs housing,<br />
as well as community service properties.<br />
CVF came to the aid of two city landmarks in <strong>2008</strong>:<br />
A $7,500 grant was used to retain the services of Thomas Fenniman, a<br />
preservation architect who provided the necessary expertise for the rehabilitation<br />
and restoration of 365 Jay Street in Brooklyn. Constructed<br />
in 1894 in the Romanesque Revival style, this building is listed in the<br />
National Register of Historic Places and is a designated city landmark. It<br />
is composed of brick and terra cotta and has a clock tower. <strong>The</strong> property<br />
originally served as Brooklyn’s Fire Department Headquarters and then as<br />
a firehouse until the 1970s. After a period of vacancy, it was renovated<br />
in 1988 into 18 low-income apartments, but the building was poorly managed.<br />
<strong>The</strong> City assumed ownership in 2005 and asked the Pratt Area<br />
Community Council (PACC) to take over and upgrade the property. PACC<br />
requested the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s help via a CVF grant to underwrite the services<br />
of a preservation consultant to help identify a scope of work and<br />
assist the project architect in incorporating preservation concerns into the<br />
remainder of the project.<br />
614 Courtlandt Avenue in the Bronx is a lovely corner property that was<br />
constructed in 1871-1872 and used for many years as a saloon and meeting<br />
hall for the surrounding German community. It had been vacant for<br />
two decades when the Neighborhood Housing Services Community<br />
Development Corporation (NHS) acquired it from the City in 2006. <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong> authorized a CVF grant of $20,000 for wood window and masonry<br />
issues, while the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City <strong>Landmarks</strong> Preservation Commission<br />
awarded NHS a grant of $40,000 for slate and chimney work. NHS<br />
renovated it for sale as three apartments and retail store space, with the<br />
condition that the new owner occupy either the commercial unit or one of<br />
the apartments. <strong>The</strong> preservation costs of the property were exceptionally<br />
expensive, given the replacement of a dormered slate mansard roof,<br />
cast-iron surrounded wood windows, and an array of masonry issues.<br />
left<br />
right<br />
614 Courtlandt Avenue, the Bronx<br />
365 Jay Street, Brooklyn<br />
19
Emergency Preservation Grant Program<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Emergency Preservation Grant Program,<br />
(EPGP) comes to the rescue when an imminent hazard threatens<br />
a landmark building. <strong>The</strong> program directs its resources toward immediately<br />
needed work on historic properties owned by nonprofit<br />
organizations. Its intention is to address discrete exterior building<br />
problems that have recently arisen, such as new leaks, fire damage,<br />
and falling masonry. <strong>The</strong> EPGP has underwritten more than<br />
$250,000 in grants since 1999.<br />
<strong>The</strong> EPGP assisted six projects in <strong>2008</strong>. In the Bronx, grants went to the<br />
City Island Historical Society and the Van Cortlandt Museum. <strong>The</strong> City<br />
Island Historical Society houses a library and historical collections dedicated<br />
to the history of this small nautical community on the Long Island<br />
Sound. EPGP stepped in to underwrite the restoration of the building’s<br />
entryway after it was destroyed in a fire. A grant of $10,000 helped to<br />
pay for the services of Kaitsen Woo, a preservation architect who prepared<br />
specifications and obtained cost estimates from contractors for the<br />
rebuilding of the entryway in a historically appropriate manner. United<br />
Homesteads of <strong>New</strong> Rochelle was the general contractor.<br />
Meanwhile, the <strong>Conservancy</strong> proudly saw the completion of a nearly decade-long<br />
project in <strong>2008</strong>: the revitalization of the Chapel of the Sisters at<br />
Prospect Cemetery in Queens. During restoration, project staff discovered<br />
that the wood frames for the chapel’s two stained glass windows needed<br />
to be fully replaced at a cost of $38,500, which was not budgeted. <strong>The</strong><br />
stained glass had already been meticulously restored by <strong>The</strong> Gil Studio<br />
and was awaiting installation. To cover the cost of the frames, the <strong>Conservancy</strong><br />
raised $30,000 from the Gerry Charitable Trust and the remainder<br />
from the EPGP.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> and its partners celebrated the chapel’s gorgeous restoration<br />
in September <strong>2008</strong> at a ribbon-cutting event that featured a dedication<br />
to Illinois Jacquet, a heralded tenor saxophonist who lived in Jamaica,<br />
Queens. <strong>York</strong> College’s Jazz Ensemble has been using the chapel<br />
as its home since then and regularly performs for the public there. <strong>The</strong> full<br />
story of the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s involvement in the Initiative can be found in the<br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong>’s Autumn <strong>2008</strong> newsletter.<br />
EPGP also came to the aid of the Williamsburg Art and Historical Center<br />
in Brooklyn, which was in desperate need of repair of its leaking interior<br />
drains. Constructed in 1868 and once home to the former Kings County<br />
Savings Bank, this individually designated City landmark and National<br />
Register property is now a community facility and arts venue. It needs a<br />
great amount of renovation and restoration work that its custodians cannot<br />
afford. Several years ago, an Emergency Preservation Grant was used<br />
for the restoration of its front mansard and roof clock. An EPGP grant of<br />
$5,000 underwrote the drainage repairs.<br />
top<br />
bottom<br />
City Island Historical Society<br />
Williamsburg Art and Historical Society, Brooklyn<br />
20
Honoring Excellence<br />
<strong>The</strong> Cathedral Church of Saint John the Divine
<strong>The</strong> Lucy G. Moses Preservation Awards are the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s<br />
highest honors for outstanding preservation efforts and are named<br />
after a distinguished <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> philanthropist whose generosity<br />
benefited the City for over 50 years. <strong>The</strong> awards ceremony for <strong>2008</strong><br />
was held at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine. We honored two<br />
individuals for their leadership, and nine projects for excellence in<br />
preservation.<br />
Ruth Abram, the founder and former president of the Lower East Side<br />
Tenement Museum, was the recipient of our Preservation Leadership<br />
Award. For twenty years, Ms. Abram has been an outspoken advocate<br />
for the museum and for preservation of the Lower East Side, a community<br />
well known for its architectural history and social significance. When<br />
new development began to threaten those special qualities, Ruth Abram<br />
started a campaign to place the LES on the National Register of Historic<br />
Places, and she continues to petition the City for landmark designation,<br />
which would protect the neighborhood from demolition and guide alterations<br />
and new construction.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Honorable Judith S. Kaye, former Chief Judge of the <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
State Court of Appeals, received our Public Leadership Award. After 15<br />
years as chief judge of the highest court in the state (and the first woman<br />
in that role), Judge Kaye retired in <strong>2008</strong>. She has been an advocate for<br />
preserving the State’s courthouses, and was responsible for many restorations,<br />
including the beautiful 1842 Greek Revival Court of Appeals Hall in<br />
Albany and the stunning First Appellate Courthouse on Madison Square<br />
in Manhattan.<br />
<strong>The</strong> following nine projects were also chosen to receive awards:<br />
Frank Lloyd Wright’s masterpiece, the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum,<br />
is an icon of modern architecture. While the museum has undergone<br />
several renovations, repairs, and additions, this campaign was the first<br />
comprehensive treatment of the envelope. Preliminary work included research,<br />
documentation, and monitoring; construction involved the removal<br />
of 11 coats of paint, infilling of exterior cracks, treatment of corroded<br />
steel, and reinforcement of the concrete. This three-year-long restoration<br />
project was completed just before the museum’s 50th birthday.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Cathedral of St. John the Divine is one of the largest churches<br />
in the world, and the mother church of the Episcopal Diocese of <strong>New</strong><br />
<strong>York</strong>. In late 2001, a six-alarm fire severely damaged the north transept,<br />
destroyed the gift shop, and filled the interior with soot and smoke. A<br />
lengthy cleaning and restoration of the interior was undertaken. Seven<br />
years after the fire, the congregation and the community celebrated rededication<br />
of the Cathedral.<br />
Jamaica Performing Arts Center in Queens is an excellent example<br />
of adaptive reuse. <strong>The</strong> congregation of the former First Reformed Church<br />
in Jamaica was moved from the building in 1973 as part of a City Urban<br />
Redevelopment Project, leaving it empty and abandoned. Local arts and<br />
community groups and the Queens Borough President started the reuse<br />
process in 2004. Today the interior is transformed, with flexible performing<br />
arts and community spaces, while the exterior features a restored<br />
façade, new slate roof, and shining stained glass windows. <strong>The</strong> finished<br />
product shows that historic churches no longer serving a religious function<br />
can have a happy second, secular life.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Beaux-arts façade of the American Irish Historical Society at 991<br />
Fifth Avenue is glowing again after restoration of the brick and limestone<br />
22
swell-front façade and the rusticated limestone base, replacement of<br />
wood windows, and the installation of a new exterior lighting system.<br />
<strong>The</strong> interior also received a museum-quality restoration.<br />
<strong>The</strong> elaborate, stylized interior of the 1913 Longacre <strong>The</strong>atre has been<br />
given new life. Plasterwork details lost to previous repairs were recreated,<br />
gilded moldings and marble surfaces were cleaned and refinished, and<br />
new seats and modernized theatrical systems were installed. Historically<br />
accurate colors dazzle, and the neo-Classical façade once again beckons<br />
theater-goers to 48th Street.<br />
One award was given for a new addition to a historic building. An<br />
18,000-square-foot addition to the Poly Prep Country Day School was<br />
built adjacent to the existing school building in the Park Slope Historic<br />
District. Faced with a challenging site and pressing programmatic needs,<br />
the architects succeeded by integrating traditional architectural elements<br />
into a contemporary design — an approach that can serve as a model for<br />
new additions in many historic districts.<br />
Seventeen years ago, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan proposed transforming<br />
the Farley Post Office into a great train station with a proper<br />
entranceway, to atone for the loss of Penn Station. In <strong>2008</strong> the Empire<br />
State Development Corporation completed a substantial restoration of the<br />
building’s neo-Classical exterior. <strong>The</strong> grand staircase and row of twenty,<br />
53-foot Corinthian columns have been cleaned, repaired, and renovated<br />
to their former glory. Now we await transformation of the interior to realize<br />
Senator Moynihan’s dream of becoming the entrance that <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
deserves.<br />
Meanwhile, two very different residential properties received awards.<br />
When the owners purchased the Italianate row house at 62 East 83rd<br />
Street in 2004, the original stoop and areaway had been removed, and<br />
the façade had lost all its ornamental details. Although the building is<br />
not a designated landmark, the design and construction team held themselves<br />
to that high standard, restoring original details based on historic<br />
documentation.<br />
295 East Eighth Street is the picturesque former home of the Children’s<br />
Aid Society/Tompkins Square Lodging House for Boys and Industrial<br />
School. It was designed by Vaux and Radford and completed in 1887.<br />
Although perhaps best known for his partnership with Frederick Law Olmstead<br />
and their design of Central Park, Calvert Vaux also worked with<br />
George Radford on a dozen elaborately detailed social service agencies.<br />
<strong>The</strong> East Eighth Street building is one of the few that remain. Restoration<br />
included replacement of the slate roof and dormers; cleaning and graffiti<br />
removal of the entire masonry façade; restoration of the ornamental<br />
ironwork, wood front doors, and entryway; and installation of new iron<br />
cresting at the roof.<br />
prior page<br />
top Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, Manhattan<br />
middle Jamaica Performing Arts Center, Queens<br />
bottom American Irish Historical Society, Manhattan<br />
this page<br />
top Longacre <strong>The</strong>ater, Manhattan<br />
middle Poly Prep Country Day School, Manhattan<br />
bottom 295 East Eighth Street, Manhattan<br />
23
Celebrating Living <strong>Landmarks</strong><br />
Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> gala at Cipriani 42nd Street
<strong>2008</strong> Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> Celebration<br />
Each year, <strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> recognizes <strong>New</strong><br />
<strong>York</strong>ers who have made outstanding contributions to the City and<br />
honors them as Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> at our fall gala.<br />
More than 400 guests turned out on Wednesday, November 5, to join the<br />
<strong>Conservancy</strong> in celebrating the <strong>2008</strong> Living <strong>Landmarks</strong> Gala.<br />
We were proud to honor: Rosamond Bernier & John Russell*, Judy<br />
Collins, Osborn Elliot*, Barbara Goldsmith, Phyllis <strong>New</strong>man,<br />
Charles B. Rangel, and Charlie Rose. Congressman Rangel was the<br />
recipient of our Lew Rudin Award for Outstanding Public Service, named<br />
after the late <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> real estate magnate and philanthropist.<br />
Once again Living Landmark host Liz Smith presided over the festivities,<br />
aided by Peter Duchin and his orchestra.<br />
* In memory<br />
top<br />
Charlie Rose, Inger Elliott, Rosamond Bernier, Phyllis <strong>New</strong>man,<br />
Judy Collins, Barbara Goldsmith<br />
middle<br />
Stanford and Sandra Warshawsky<br />
Michael and Karyn Christensen<br />
Marjorie Reed Gordon and Ellery Gordon<br />
bottom<br />
Gurnee Hart, Elizabeth Stribling, Guy Robinson, Marjorie Hart<br />
25
top<br />
Richard and Gloria Moylan<br />
Lauren Bacall<br />
Ray and Veronica Kelly<br />
second row<br />
Anna Casperson, Sallie Abelow, Erik Oken<br />
Martin and Joan Camins, Michael De Chiara<br />
third row<br />
Marla Sabo<br />
Nan and Gay Talese<br />
Duane Hampton<br />
bottom<br />
Barbara Goldsmith, Beth DeWoody, Peg Breen, Frank Sciame<br />
26
Tours and Other Events<br />
Reception at Schinasi Mansion<br />
Nearly 100 guests joined us in May for an exclusive reception and tour of<br />
the landmark Schinasi residence, one of the few surviving single-family<br />
mansions in Manhattan. <strong>The</strong> 12,000-square-foot home was built in 1909<br />
for Morris Schinasi, a Turkish émigré who made his fortune selling tobacco.<br />
<strong>The</strong> architect, William Tuthill, also designed Carnegie Hall.<br />
A Look Inside Google’s NYC Headquarters <br />
Members of our Real Estate and Professional Circles joined us in August<br />
for a private tour of Google’s recently expanded <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City headquarters.<br />
Its initial office space at 76 Ninth Avenue, built in 1930, originally<br />
served as a warehouse for the Port Authority. As the company grew here,<br />
it moved its marketing team to Chelsea Market. This new space, with<br />
its adaptive reuse of an industrial building, is an incredible example of<br />
modern technology within an older frame.<br />
Private Tour of Brooklyn’s U.S. Courthouse<br />
and Post Office<br />
Our tour in August of this spectacularly restored building was led by architect<br />
Michael Nieminen, of R.M. Clement & Frances Halsband Architects,<br />
who worked on its impressive redesign. <strong>The</strong> firm meticulously restored all<br />
the exterior surfaces and windows. Modern offices and courtrooms were<br />
inserted within the shell of the annex building, built in 1930. In the original<br />
section, the magnificent central atrium was returned to full Victorian glory.<br />
Illustrated Lecture on American Beaux-Arts<br />
Architect Richard Morris Hunt<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>, along with the Beaux-Arts Alliance, co-hosted an illustrated<br />
lecture in April by renowned architectural historian David Garrard<br />
Lowe. In his unique and captivating manner, Lowe explored the fascinating<br />
life and work of Richard Morris Hunt, the first American architect to<br />
attend the famous École des Beaux-Arts in Paris. Among Hunt’s most famous<br />
designs is the Tribune Building, one of the City’s first skyscrapers.<br />
Chairman’s Award Honoring Robert A. Levine<br />
More than 130 guests attended the <strong>2008</strong> Chairman’s Award luncheon at<br />
Le Cirque to honor Robert A. Levine, founder and president of RAL Companies<br />
& Affiliates, which develops luxury residential and commercial properties.<br />
Most recently, Levine has breathed new life into a former Brooklyn<br />
industrial building and two older Tribeca buildings by converting them into<br />
housing with associated retail and amenities.<br />
top Schinasi Mansion, Manhattan<br />
middle U.S. Courthouse and Post Office, Brooklyn<br />
bottom Robert A. Levine and Frank J. Sciame, Jr.<br />
27
Our Supporters<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s success depends<br />
on the annual support of our individual, corporate, and foundation<br />
donors. Each year we must raise more than 85 percent<br />
of our operating budget from private sources.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> gratefully acknowledges our partnership<br />
with the following supporters during <strong>2008</strong>.<br />
If any names have been listed incorrectly or omitted, please<br />
accept our apologies and let us know how we may adjust<br />
our records.<br />
Foundations, Corporations,<br />
Public Agencies, &<br />
Other Organizations<br />
$100,000 and above<br />
<strong>The</strong> Robert W. Wilson Charitable Trust<br />
$50,000 - $99,999<br />
Henry & Lucy Moses Fund Inc.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Rhodebeck Charitable Trust<br />
$25,000 - $49,999<br />
<strong>The</strong> Ambrose Monell Foundation<br />
F.J. Sciame Construction Co. Inc.<br />
Gerry Charitable Trust<br />
Lily Auchincloss Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Morris & Alma Schapiro Fund<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Community Trust<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State Council on the Arts<br />
$15,000 - $24,999<br />
<strong>The</strong> Barker Welfare Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Durst Organization<br />
Hagedorn Fund<br />
<strong>The</strong> JPMorgan Chase Foundation<br />
May & Samuel Rudin Family Foundation Inc.<br />
Preservation League of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> State<br />
Stribling & Associates Ltd.<br />
Sugar Foods Corporation<br />
$10,000 - $14,999<br />
Bloomberg<br />
Boies Schiller & Flexner LLP<br />
Bovis Lend Lease LMB<br />
Edith & Herbert Lehman Foundation Inc.<br />
Gladys & Roland Harriman Foundation<br />
James A. Macdonald Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Lucius N. Littauer Foundation Inc.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Marc Haas Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Times<br />
<strong>New</strong>man’s Own Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Overbrook Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Reed Foundation Inc.<br />
Sony Corporation of America<br />
<strong>The</strong> Starr Foundation<br />
Winston & Strawn LLP<br />
$5,000 - $9,999<br />
375 Park Avenue L.P.<br />
42nd Street Fund<br />
Adolph & Ruth Schnurmacher Foundation<br />
Adrian & Jessie Archbold Charitable Trust<br />
AIG Global Real Estate Investment Corp.<br />
Astoria Federal Savings Bank<br />
<strong>The</strong> Blanche Enders Charitable Trust<br />
Cushman & Wakefield<br />
Gilder Foundation<br />
Lehman Brothers Inc.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Yankees Foundation<br />
Northern <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Community Foundation<br />
RAL Development Services LLC<br />
Sciame Development<br />
Specter DeSouza Architects PC<br />
$2,000 - $4,999<br />
Allstate Interior Demolition<br />
Arnow Family Fund<br />
Beyer Blinder Belle<br />
BWD Group<br />
<strong>The</strong> Cowles Charitable Trust<br />
Creative Design Associates LLC<br />
Davis Langdon<br />
<strong>The</strong> Dorothy Strelsin Foundation<br />
Episcopal Diocese of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Hickory Foundation<br />
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners LLC<br />
<strong>The</strong> Howard Bayne Fund<br />
Leon Levy Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Segal Company<br />
<strong>The</strong> Shubert Organization Inc.<br />
Sidney & Judith Kranes Charitable Trust<br />
Van Cleef & Arpels<br />
World Monuments Fund<br />
$1,000 - $1,999<br />
Building Conservation Associates Inc.<br />
Capalino + Company<br />
<strong>The</strong> Cathedral of St. John the Divine<br />
Chanel Inc.<br />
Charina Foundation<br />
Connelly McLaughlin Communications<br />
Estee Lauder Companies Inc.<br />
Façade Maintenance Design P.C.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Gramercy Park Foundation<br />
Green-Wood Cemetery<br />
Helpern Architects<br />
<strong>The</strong> Leonard & Evelyn Lauder Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Loreen Arbus Foundation<br />
<strong>The</strong> Old Stones Foundation<br />
Old Town Bar<br />
<strong>The</strong> Philanthropic Collaborative Inc.<br />
Polshek Partnership Architects<br />
Robert A.M. Stern Architects LLP<br />
Schtiller & Plevy Inc.<br />
Studio for Civil Architecture PLLC<br />
<strong>The</strong> Sulzberger Foundation Inc.<br />
Thomas Manufacturing Inc.<br />
Tishman Construction Corporation of <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong><br />
Vertical Access LLC<br />
<strong>The</strong> West Paces Hotel Group<br />
<strong>The</strong> Yves-Andre Istel Foundation<br />
$500 - $999<br />
<strong>The</strong> Actors Fund<br />
Apple Bank<br />
Atlas Welding & Boiler Repair Inc.<br />
Bertha & Isaac Liberman Foundation Inc.<br />
Cutsogeorge Tooman & Allen Architects P.C.<br />
Eastern Metalworks<br />
Educational Housing Services Inc.<br />
GCP Capital Group LLC<br />
Greater Jamaica Development Corporation<br />
H3 Hardy Collaboration Architecture<br />
Hazardous Elimination Corporation<br />
Henry B. Plant Memorial Fund<br />
Henry C. & Karen J. Barkhorn Foundation<br />
Ingram & Hebron Realty<br />
28
Kaitsen Woo Architect P.C.<br />
Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP<br />
O’Connor Davies Munns & Dobbins LLP<br />
PA Associates<br />
Partnership for <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />
Soil Mechanics<br />
Stribling Marketing Associates<br />
Sunlites Stained Glass<br />
$250 - $499<br />
Alan Hill Design<br />
B.L. Howard Productions<br />
Brooklyn Heights Association Inc.<br />
Cozen O’Connor<br />
First Republic Bank<br />
Goldstein Associates Consulting Engineers PC<br />
Goshow Architects LLP<br />
GVA Williams<br />
ING Clarion Partners LLC<br />
Kliment Halsband Architects<br />
LandAir Project Resources<br />
Levy & Gold LLP<br />
Lexicon Communications Corp.<br />
Ludwig Michael Goldsmith Architects<br />
Metropolis Group Inc.<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Department of Design<br />
& Construction<br />
<strong>The</strong> PAR Group<br />
Pest Elimination Systems Technology<br />
Robert Silman Associates P.C.<br />
Robinson Contracting Inc.<br />
SAM Fundraising Solutions Corp.<br />
Robert Silman Associates P.C.<br />
West <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Restoration of CT Inc.<br />
WolfBlock<br />
<strong>The</strong> Woodstone Company<br />
Individuals<br />
Leader ($50,000 and above)<br />
Robert W. Wilson<br />
Guardian ($25,000 - $49,999)<br />
Barbara L. Goldsmith<br />
Christabel Gough<br />
Mimi Levitt<br />
Dr. & Mrs. Daniel Schapiro<br />
Frank J. Sciame Jr.<br />
Sustainer ($15,000 - $24,999)<br />
Joan Ganz Cooney & Peter G. Peterson<br />
Michael K. De Chiara<br />
Beth Rudin DeWoody<br />
Susanne & Douglas Durst<br />
Brandon Fradd<br />
Alexandra & Paul Herzan<br />
John J. Kerr Jr. & Nora Wren Kerr<br />
William C. Rudin<br />
Elizabeth F. Stribling & Guy Robinson<br />
Barbara & Donald Tober<br />
Stanley & Sandra Warshawsky<br />
Fellow ($10,000 - $14,999)<br />
David Boies<br />
Mildred C. Brinn<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Robert C. Graham Jr.<br />
Holly Hotchner<br />
Robert A. Levine<br />
Allison Simmons Prouty & Norman Prouty<br />
David Reese<br />
Mrs. Edmond J. Safra<br />
Lloyd Zuckerberg & Charlotte Triefus<br />
Society ($5,000 - $9,999)<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Justin Abelow<br />
William G. Bardel<br />
Joan & Martin Camins<br />
Jonathan Caplan<br />
Susan R. Cullman & John J. Kirby Jr.<br />
Inger McCabe Elliott<br />
David & Meade Fogel<br />
Patricia & John Forelle<br />
Richard A. Garvey<br />
Richard Gilder<br />
Marla Sabo<br />
Frances G. Scaife<br />
Marc P. Schappell<br />
Aaron Sosnick<br />
Patricia & David Kenneth Specter<br />
George M. Steinbrenner III<br />
Sue Ann Weinberg<br />
Benefactor ($2,500 - $4,999)<br />
Joan Arnow<br />
John & Caron Avery<br />
Catherine Cahill & William Bernhard<br />
Edward Lee Cave<br />
Ted Hartley & Dina Merrill<br />
Margaret Brennan Hassett<br />
William J. Higgins & Elise M. Quasebarth<br />
Mariana & George Kaufman<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Stephen S. Lash<br />
Arthur L. Loeb<br />
Enid Nemy<br />
Encarnita & Robert Quinlan<br />
David Rockefeller<br />
Daniel & Joanna S. Rose<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Jeffrey A. Rosen<br />
Gerald Schoenfeld<br />
Martin E. Segal<br />
Shelby White<br />
John C. Whitehead<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Richard J. Wilk<br />
Circle ($1,000 - $2,499)<br />
Oscar K. Anderson III & Gillian Blake<br />
Loreen Arbus<br />
Bunty & Tom Armstrong<br />
Sharon & Stephen Baum<br />
Paul Beirne<br />
John Belle<br />
Kelly Killoren Bensimon<br />
Alexander, Nina, & Jamie Bernstein<br />
Charles & Kathryn Berry<br />
Giancarla Berti<br />
Minor L. Bishop<br />
Mr. & Mrs. James A. Block<br />
Stephanie E.K. Borynack<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Alan G. Brenner<br />
David Brown & Helen Gurley Brown<br />
James F. Capalino<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Arthur L. Carter<br />
Pamela Rubin Carter & Jon Carter<br />
Anne & John Coffin<br />
Kent Diebolt<br />
Francine du Plessix Gray<br />
Cynthia Elliott<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Stuart P. Feld<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Luke E. Fichthorn<br />
Jake & Sarah Foley<br />
Andrew C. Friedman<br />
Norton Garfinkle & Sally Minard<br />
Susan & Eli Gilbert<br />
Toni K. Goodale<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Christopher S. Goodman<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Robert Hahn<br />
Clark P. Halstead<br />
Mrs. Andrew Heiskell<br />
David Paul Helpern<br />
Arthur Indursky<br />
Virginia James<br />
Weslie Resnick Janeway & William H. Janeway<br />
Mr. & Mrs. John J. Kenney<br />
Richard M. Kielar<br />
Stephen Kirschenbaum & Andrew Valentine<br />
Arie L. Kopelman<br />
<strong>The</strong> Very Reverend James A. Kowalski<br />
Mathilde Krim<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Leonard A. Lauder<br />
Isabelle R. Leeds<br />
Richard Lefever<br />
Jeffrey Levine<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Noel Levine<br />
Sheldon & Diana Elliott Lidofsky<br />
Nicolas Luchsinger<br />
<strong>The</strong> Honorable & Mrs. Earle I. Mack<br />
Malcolm MacKay<br />
Marjorie Flannigan & Charles D. MacLachlan<br />
Christopher P. Mahan<br />
Joy Marks & Leif Bringslimark<br />
Martin J. McLaughlin<br />
Ronay & Richard Menschel<br />
Reginald Middleton<br />
Gillian & Sylvester Miniter<br />
John Morning<br />
Richard J. & Gloria E. Moylan<br />
Lynn Nesbit<br />
Roy R. Neuberger<br />
29
Erik R. Oken<br />
Mary Ellen & Richard Oldenburg<br />
Mr. & Mrs. George D. O’Neill<br />
Patricia S. Patterson<br />
Raymond Pepi & Karen Arrigoni<br />
Joseph Pierson<br />
Lawrence H. & Catherine Plevy<br />
James & Ellyn Polshek<br />
Paul Provost<br />
Kathleen & Peter Quinn<br />
Mr. & Mrs. William P. Rayner<br />
Michael Rebic<br />
Janet C. Ross<br />
Amy & Howard J. Rubenstein<br />
Sirgay & Judy Goetz Sanger<br />
Sophia D. Schachter<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Irwin Schneiderman<br />
Kay, Bill, Will & Meta Schrenk<br />
Richard Southwick<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Ted Stanley<br />
Joanne M. Stern<br />
Robert A.M. Stern<br />
Gay & Nan Talese<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Charles Tribbitt<br />
Helen S. Tucker<br />
Anne Van Rensselaer<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Guy Wildenstein<br />
George W. Young<br />
Roy J. Zuckerberg<br />
Patron ($500 - $999)<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Leigh J. Abramson<br />
Timothy Allanbrook<br />
Daniel J. Allen<br />
Anonymous<br />
Joan C. Baez<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Henry C. Barkhorn III<br />
Ana Bilski<br />
Matthew Blesso<br />
Allison M. Blinken<br />
Dr. & Mrs. Jeffrey S. Borer<br />
Giosetta Capriati<br />
Guy W. Clark II<br />
Patrick Clark<br />
Cathleen B. Colella<br />
Bruce L. Ehrmann<br />
Dorinda Elliott<br />
Christy Ferer<br />
Cheryl Grandfield & Richard W. Dodd<br />
Mrs. Henry Grunwald<br />
Hugh Hardy<br />
Chris Harris & Elizabeth Parrilli<br />
James W. Hundley III<br />
Josephine Lea Iselin<br />
Reverend John A. Kamas<br />
Sharon King Hoge<br />
Mitchell W. Jacobs<br />
Norman Keller & Denise Sobel<br />
Michèle Gerber Klein<br />
Bernice K. Leber & David Rosenberg<br />
Pauline C. Metcalf<br />
Edward T. Mohylowski<br />
George Neuman<br />
David & Phyllis Oxman<br />
Nicholas & Carol Paumgarten<br />
Mariann G. Perseo<br />
<strong>The</strong> Honorable Nicholas Platt<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Peter O. Price<br />
Richard Rubenstein<br />
Rosalie T. Sayles<br />
Linda & Dick Schapiro<br />
Michael T. Sillerman<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Benjamin F. Stapleton III<br />
Mr. & Mrs. George Sykes<br />
Jack Taylor<br />
F. Carlisle Towery<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Charles M.A. Winn<br />
Richard M. Winn III<br />
Kaitsen Woo<br />
Stuart C. Woods<br />
Kathryn S. Wylde<br />
Howard A. Zipser<br />
Sponsor ($250 - $499)<br />
Mark & Gloria Altherr<br />
Mr. & Mrs. O. Kelley Anderson Jr.<br />
Anonymous<br />
Ruth Aronowitz<br />
Cissy & George Asch<br />
Matthew Bender IV<br />
Mary Brogan<br />
Miriam Cahn<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Thomas A. Cassilly<br />
Daniel F. Crowley III<br />
Florence D’Urso<br />
Lisa A. Easton<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Jack Enders<br />
Gail Erickson & Christa Rice<br />
Linda Feczko<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Lawrence Friedland<br />
David E. Gustafson<br />
Henry G. Hart<br />
Kirk Henckels<br />
Darren Hirsch<br />
Linda & Morton Janklow<br />
Sarah Bradford Landau<br />
Edward F. Lyons Jr.<br />
Mr. & Mrs. David McMurry<br />
Susan Weis Mindel<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Garrett M. Moran<br />
John T. Moran<br />
Mary McGarry & Stanley Okula<br />
Lida Orzeck<br />
Nancy & Otis Pearsall<br />
Anne Perkins<br />
Mrs. Donaldson C. Pillsbury<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Andrew W. Potash<br />
Lynne P. Raymond<br />
Glenn & Lyn Reiter<br />
Mr. & Mrs. William D. Rifkin<br />
Mr. & Mrs. David Santry<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Martin Scherzer<br />
Lisa & Bernard Selz<br />
Patricia Soto<br />
Lesta Summerfield Stacom<br />
James Storrow<br />
Leith ter Meulen<br />
Neal X. Twomey & Rita Kavanagh<br />
Tom Von Essen<br />
Mr. & Mrs. William B. Warren<br />
William O. Wheatley Jr.<br />
Madelyn Wils<br />
Advocate ($100 - $249)<br />
Anonymous<br />
Charlotte P. Armstrong<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Ronald R. Atkins<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Alan Beller<br />
Vincent Benic<br />
Alvin Berr<br />
Madalen A. Bertolini<br />
Keith H. Bigger<br />
David T. Biggs<br />
Barbara Blank<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Allen Blum<br />
Edna L. Breecker<br />
Richard Burlage<br />
Lorenzo Burrows<br />
Albert K. Butzel<br />
Karen McCarthy Cady<br />
Jay E. Cantor<br />
Joan Capelin<br />
Steven Trent Cappel & Katherine H. Fritts<br />
<strong>The</strong> Honorable Diana D. Chapin<br />
Susan Chin<br />
Carol A. Clark<br />
Alice McGown Concagh<br />
Matthew V. Cortellesi<br />
Jane R. Crotty<br />
Anna E. Crouse<br />
Suzanne Davis & Rolf Ohlhausen<br />
Arnaud & Alexandra de Borchgrave<br />
John A. di Domenico<br />
Ann Cynthia Diamond<br />
Eugenia G. Dooley<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Robert R. Douglass<br />
Stewart Driller<br />
Barbara Dudley<br />
Pamela & Adam Emmerich<br />
David E. Finlay<br />
Julia Fishelson<br />
Barbara G. Fleischman<br />
Adaline Frelinghuysen<br />
J. Dermot Frengley<br />
Richard Frey & Janet Landis-Frey<br />
Ann-Isabel Friedman & Seth Maerowitz<br />
Lewis Friedman<br />
Ann W. Gaffney<br />
<strong>The</strong> Honorable Joan Gerner<br />
Ronald C. Goewey & Won S. Barber<br />
30
Ludwig Michael Goldsmith<br />
Rose L. Grobman<br />
Marion O. Harris<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Morrison H. Heckscher<br />
Paul Herther<br />
John J. Hoffmann<br />
Anne Holford-Smith & Jeffrey L. Smith<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Joseph C. Hoopes Jr.<br />
Sarah F. Hunnewell<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Robert D. Huxley<br />
Howard E. Johnson<br />
David A. Katz & Cecilia T. Absher<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Edward Kennedy<br />
Reverend Gerald Keucher &<br />
Reverend John H. Walsted<br />
Phyllis B. Lambert<br />
Richard Leibner<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Edwin Deane Leonard<br />
Brenda Levin<br />
Maura C. Lockhart & James M. Lukenda<br />
Vincent M. Love<br />
Amira Luikart<br />
Ken Lustbader<br />
James MacDonald<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Timothy MacDonald<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Marc Magid<br />
Peter J. Mayer<br />
Kerry Edward McCarthy<br />
Raymond A. McGarrigle<br />
Walter B. Melvin<br />
Roger & Barbara Michaels<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Charles Miesner<br />
Lynden B. Miller<br />
Ann H. Milne<br />
Lawrence K. Moss<br />
Robert Murdock<br />
Scott <strong>New</strong>man<br />
Cesar Neyra<br />
Erika W. Nijenhuis & Christian Bastian<br />
Elizabeth Nisbet & Dale Reynolds<br />
Sidney & Avodah Offit<br />
Everett H. Ortner<br />
Valerie Paley<br />
Marjorie Pearson<br />
Michael Phillips<br />
Robert Pirani<br />
Percy Preston Jr.<br />
Donald & Ilona Quest<br />
John T. Reddick<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Robert Riggs<br />
Paul Rosenfeld<br />
Susan J. Rosenthal & Larry Grosberg<br />
John Rowley<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Fred P. Rubin<br />
Bret & Amy Russell<br />
Marie Elena Saul<br />
Thomas F. Schutte<br />
Philip E. Schwartz<br />
Jane F. Scovell<br />
Patricia Bakwin Selch<br />
Robert A. Silver<br />
John J. Slain<br />
James Somogyi<br />
Susan W. Stachelberg<br />
Martha Roby Stephens<br />
Edmund Sullivan<br />
Donald Swanson<br />
Louise S. Thompson<br />
Susan Tunick<br />
Laurence M. Turk<br />
Paul Wachtel<br />
Felicia Warshawsky<br />
John P. Waugh<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Avrom S. Waxman<br />
Jill C. Weinstein<br />
Nada & David Westerman<br />
Diane White<br />
Ronda F. Wist<br />
Kevin Wolfe<br />
Barbara Wriston<br />
Wolodomyr Wronskyj<br />
Mr. & Mrs. Daniel Zucker<br />
Professional Circle<br />
Benefactor<br />
Beyer Blinder Belle Architects and Planners, LLP<br />
Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc.<br />
Green-Wood Cemetery<br />
Schtiller & Plevy, Inc.<br />
Specter DeSouza Architects, PC<br />
Patron<br />
AKRF, Inc.<br />
Gruzen Samton Planners & Interior Designers<br />
Hazardous Elimination Corporation<br />
Jan Hird Pokorny Associates, Inc.<br />
Nova Restoration of NY, Inc.<br />
Platt Byard Dovell White Architects, LLP<br />
Polshek Partnership Architects<br />
Rambusch Decorating Company, Inc.<br />
Taconic Builders, Inc.<br />
Walter B. Melvin Architects, LLC<br />
Wank Adams Slavin Associates, LLP<br />
Associate<br />
Acheson Doyle Partners<br />
Air-Flo Window Contracting Corp.<br />
Alexander Antonelli Architects PLLC<br />
ALSA Architecture<br />
AltieriSeborWieber, LLC<br />
Annex Masonry Restoration, Inc.<br />
Artisan Restoration Group<br />
Artistic Doors and Windows, Inc.<br />
Penelope Bareau<br />
Belisle Ancestral Doors and Windows<br />
Bell Donnelly Architects and Planners<br />
Jeffrey Berman Architect<br />
William Bialosky Architect<br />
Brisk Waterproofing Company, Inc.<br />
Brownstone Authority, Inc.<br />
Building Conservation Associates, Inc.<br />
Burda Construction Corp.<br />
CetraRuddy, Inc.<br />
Cityproof Corp.<br />
Concord Painting, Inc.<br />
Cooper Robertson & Partners Architecture<br />
Crawford & Stearns<br />
Curtis + Ginsberg Architects, LLP<br />
Darius Toraby Architects, PC<br />
daSILVA Architects<br />
David D. Harlan Architects, LLC<br />
De Groot Historical Restoration, Inc.<br />
Deerpath Construction Corp.<br />
Design Preserve Build (DPB)<br />
Mary B. Dierickx<br />
Domingo Gonzalez Associates<br />
East End Wood Strippers, Inc.<br />
Edelman Sultan Knox Wood Architects, LLP<br />
Edward Kamper Associates<br />
Eipel Barbieri Marschhausen, LLP<br />
Essex Works, Ltd.<br />
F.M. Pucci and Associates, Ltd.<br />
Façade Maintenance Design, PC<br />
Farewell Mills Gatsch Architects, LLC<br />
Femenella and Associates<br />
Ferguson & Shamamian Architects, LLP<br />
Fifty Three Restorations, Inc.<br />
Flickinger Glassworks, Inc.<br />
Franco Restoration & Remodeling Corp.<br />
Françoise Bollack Architects<br />
FXFOWLE Architects, PC<br />
Robert F. Germain P.E., PC<br />
Gertler & Wente Architects, LLP<br />
<strong>The</strong> Gil Studio<br />
Gilsanz Murray Steficek, LLP<br />
Glass & Glass Architects<br />
Glück <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, Inc.<br />
Goshow Architects, LLP<br />
Grand Renovation, Inc.<br />
Hall Partnership Architects, LLP<br />
Helpern Architects<br />
Charles H. Henkels, AIA<br />
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC<br />
Interior Alterations, Inc.<br />
J & R Lamb Studios, Inc.<br />
J. Pontes Corp.<br />
Jablonski Building Conservation, Inc.<br />
Janko Rasic Architects<br />
JELD-WEN Windows & Doors<br />
JMA Consultants, Inc.<br />
John G. Waite Associates Architects PLLC<br />
Joseph K. Blum Co., LLP<br />
Mary Kay Judy<br />
Karp Associates, Inc.<br />
Kathryn Scott Design Studio<br />
Holly Kaye<br />
Michael A. Kaye, Esq.<br />
31
<strong>The</strong> Kibel Companies, LLC<br />
Mitchell Kurtz Architect, PC<br />
LandAir Project Resources<br />
Landmark Facilities Group, Inc.<br />
Lee Harris Pomeroy Associates<br />
Leonard Colchamiro, AIA, PC<br />
Leslie E. Robertson Associates, RLLP<br />
Levien & Company, Inc.<br />
Douglas J. Lister Architect<br />
M & L Steel Ornamental Iron Corp.<br />
Maidman and Mittelman, LLP<br />
Mand Restoration<br />
Marilyn E. Kaplan Preservation Architecture<br />
Peter Marino Architect PLLC<br />
Midtown Preservation, PC<br />
Millwork Specialties<br />
Mitropoulos Architects<br />
Craig Morrison, AIA<br />
Murphy Burnham & Buttrick Architects<br />
<strong>New</strong>man Design<br />
Neuhaus Design Architecture, PC<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City Brickwork Design Center<br />
Nicholson & Galloway, Inc.<br />
Norfast Consulting Group, Inc.<br />
Northeastern Dimensional Millwork, Inc.<br />
Paragon Restoration Corporation<br />
Mariann G. Perseo, Esq.<br />
Jean Parker Phifer, FAIA<br />
Polshek Partnership Architects<br />
Porter Clapp Architects, PC<br />
PreservationDesignGroup/Daniel Koplowitz<br />
Architect<br />
PROSOCO, Inc.<br />
Putnam County Historic Preservation Advisory<br />
Commission<br />
Rand Engineering and Architecture, PC<br />
Renfro Design Group, Inc.<br />
Richard Baronio & Associates<br />
Richbrook Conservation<br />
Robert Silman Associates, PC<br />
Robinson Contracting, Inc.<br />
Rohlf’s Stained & Leaded Glass Studio<br />
Russel Watsky, Inc.<br />
SAM Fundraising Solutions Corp.<br />
Schwartz’s Forge & Metalworks, Inc.<br />
SMA Architecture Planning Interiors, PC<br />
Spirit Ironworks<br />
Harold S. Spitzer Architect, PC<br />
Star Metal, Inc.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Stephen B. Jacobs Group<br />
Swanke Hayden Connell Architects<br />
TMT Restoration Consultants, Ltd.<br />
Tobin + Parnes Design Enterprises<br />
Traditional Line, Ltd.<br />
Turett Collaborative Architects<br />
Universal Builders Supply, Inc.<br />
Urban D.C., Inc.<br />
Vertical Access, LLC<br />
Vestacast<br />
Victor Rothman for Stained Glass<br />
Walter Sedovic Architects<br />
Weidlinger Associates, Inc.<br />
Wireless EDGE Consultants, LLC<br />
WLA Engineering, PC<br />
<strong>The</strong> Woodstone Company<br />
<strong>The</strong> Woodworks Company Ltd<br />
Linda M. Yowell, FAIA<br />
Zubatkin Owner Representation, LLC<br />
Real Estate Circle<br />
Society<br />
Stribling & Associates Ltd.<br />
Benefactor<br />
Friedman & Gotbaum LLP<br />
Patron<br />
6-16 77th Street Owners Corp.<br />
A.R. Walker & Co. Inc.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Malkin Fund Inc.<br />
Associate<br />
Ed Tristram Associates Inc.<br />
Annette Petrusa<br />
Levata Properties LLC<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> Building Congress<br />
S.W. Management LLC<br />
Slater & Beckerman LLP<br />
In-Kind Donations<br />
Cartier<br />
Christie’s<br />
F.J. Sciame Construction<br />
Simpson Thacher & Bartlett<br />
32
Financial Statements<br />
Statement of Activities Year Ended December 31, <strong>2008</strong><br />
Revenue and Support Contributions $ 1,781,944<br />
Government grants 148,100<br />
Other grants 80,000<br />
Investment return used for operations 169,341<br />
Program services income 20,366<br />
Contributed services 180,266<br />
Total Support and Revenue $ 2,380,017<br />
Expenses Program $ 2,307,878<br />
Development 586,971<br />
Administration 373,865<br />
Total Expenses $ 3,268,714<br />
Non-Operating Activities Non-operating investment return (3,161,430)<br />
Change in Net Assets (4,050,127)<br />
Statement of Financial Position Year Ended December 31, <strong>2008</strong><br />
Net Assets, Beginning $ 9,368,464<br />
Net Assets, Ending $ 5,318,337<br />
Assets Cash and cash equivalents $ 419,900<br />
Pledges receivable 640,000<br />
Loans receivable 43,792<br />
Due from NYC Historic Properties Fund 30,251<br />
Prepaid expenses and other assets 62,955<br />
Investments 5,036,869<br />
Property and equipment, net 116,177<br />
Cash held for other agencies 103,539<br />
Total Assets $ 6,453,483<br />
Liabilities Accounts payable and accrued liabilities $ 10,056<br />
Deferred income 34,100<br />
Grants payable 880,287<br />
Deferred rent 107,163<br />
Amounts held for other agencies<br />
Queens Historic Properties Fund 103,380<br />
Greenwich House, Inc. 160<br />
Total Liabilities $ 1,135,146<br />
Net Assets<br />
Unrestricted<br />
Undesignated (777,865)<br />
Board Designated 2,629,378<br />
Total Unrestricted 1,851,513<br />
Temporarily restricted 513,756<br />
Permanently restricted 2,953,068<br />
Total Net Assets $ 5,318,337<br />
Total Liabilities and Net Assets $ 6,453,483<br />
A copy of completed audited financial statements for <strong>2008</strong> may be obtained upon written request from<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> <strong>Landmarks</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong>: One Whitehall Street, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, NY 10004.<br />
33
Board of Directors<br />
Frank J. Sciame, Jr.<br />
Chair<br />
Allison Simmons Prouty, Esq.<br />
Vice Chair<br />
Lloyd P. Zuckerberg<br />
Treasurer<br />
Joan O. Camins<br />
Secretary<br />
Peg Breen<br />
President<br />
Justin Abelow<br />
Oscar K. Anderson III<br />
William G. Bardel<br />
William L. Bernhard<br />
Pamela Rubin Carter, Esq.<br />
Susan R. Cullman<br />
Michael K. De Chiara, Esq.<br />
Douglas Durst<br />
Stuart P. Feld<br />
David L. Fogel<br />
John M. Forelle, Esq.<br />
Brandon Fradd<br />
Richard Garvey<br />
Robert C. Graham Jr.<br />
Holly Hotchner<br />
Susan Henshaw Jones<br />
John J. Kerr Jr., Esq.<br />
John Morning<br />
Reverend Dr. Thomas F. Pike<br />
Marla Sabo<br />
Frances Scaife<br />
Marc P. Schappell<br />
Stuart N. Siegel<br />
David Kenneth Specter, AIA<br />
Elizabeth F. Stribling<br />
Donald G. Tober<br />
Sandra Faith Warshawsky<br />
Advisory Council<br />
Laurie Beckelman<br />
John Belle, FAIA, RIBA<br />
Kathryn McGraw Berry<br />
Reverend Canon George W. Brandt Jr.<br />
Farran Tozer Brown<br />
Anne Coffin<br />
Paul S. Byard, FAIA<br />
Peter Duchin<br />
Norton Garfinkle<br />
Clark P. Halstead<br />
Margaret Brennan Hassett<br />
Paul K. Herzan<br />
Reverend John A. Kamas<br />
Stephen Kirschenbaum<br />
John J. Kerr Jr., Esq.<br />
Parker Ladd<br />
Stephen S. Lash<br />
Mimi Levitt<br />
Malcolm MacKay<br />
Marjorie Flannigan MacLachlan, Esq.<br />
Frederic S. Papert<br />
Robert C. Quinlan<br />
Peter Quinn<br />
Arnold Scaasi<br />
Liz Smith<br />
Joanne M. Stern<br />
Staff<br />
Meral Agish<br />
Development Associate<br />
Karen Ansis<br />
Manager, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />
Historic Properties Fund and City Ventures Fund<br />
Veronica Ball<br />
Associate Director of Development<br />
Peg Breen<br />
President<br />
Marci Fiedler*<br />
Development Associate<br />
Ann-Isabel Friedman<br />
Director, Sacred Sites Program<br />
Andrea Goldwyn<br />
Director of Public Policy<br />
Alison Burke Griffiths*<br />
Publications Manager<br />
Shelley Jane Grossberg<br />
Development Counsel<br />
Ashley J. Hahn<br />
Program Coordinator, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />
Historic Properties Fund<br />
Alex Herrera<br />
Director, Technical Services Center<br />
Robert Irving*<br />
Comptroller<br />
James J. Mahoney<br />
Program Coordinator, <strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong> City<br />
Historic Properties Fund<br />
Colleen Meagher<br />
Manager, Grants and Technical Services<br />
In Memoriam<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Conservancy</strong> lost two long-time friends in <strong>2008</strong>. Board member Paul Byard’s skills as<br />
an architect and attorney were instrumental in the <strong>Conservancy</strong>’s early growth. He helped<br />
us obtain the then-vacant former Federal Archives Building in Greenwich Village and find<br />
a developer for the property. He also devised our Historic Properties Fund — a pioneering<br />
revolving loan fund for preservation — from the building’s proceeds. Roger Lang was our<br />
Public Policy Director for sixteen years. Roger’s encyclopedic knowledge of architecture,<br />
passion for preservation and eloquence made him a respected advocate and popular<br />
ambassador for the <strong>Conservancy</strong>. We miss each one’s expertise, opinions and flair.<br />
Kera Reid<br />
Office Manager<br />
Angel Santa<br />
Comptroller<br />
Amy Sullivan<br />
Senior Manager of Events<br />
L. Daniel Vincent*<br />
Director of Development and Finance<br />
*<strong>2008</strong><br />
34
One Whitehall Street<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>York</strong>, NY 10004<br />
212.995.5260<br />
nylandmarks.org