30.12.2014 Views

EfW DEVELOPMENT GUIDANCE - Wrap

EfW DEVELOPMENT GUIDANCE - Wrap

EfW DEVELOPMENT GUIDANCE - Wrap

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong><br />

<strong>GUIDANCE</strong><br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Potential sources<br />

of funding<br />

Guidance on funding options for<br />

energy from waste development.<br />

1.0 London Green Fund (LGF)<br />

2.0 The Carbon Trust<br />

3.0 EDF Energy Green Fund<br />

4.0 Green Investment Bank (GIB)<br />

5.0 WRAP eQuip Scheme<br />

6.0 Additional sources of information<br />

Funding<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 2


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Potential sources of funding<br />

There are a number of funding options available to assist companies in the<br />

development of sustainable energy facilities, including energy from waste (<strong>EfW</strong>). The<br />

types of funding available are usually project specific and can differ depending on<br />

your location. A selection of the funding options currently available is outlined below.<br />

These funds do not have an advertised end date. However, as sources of funding are<br />

constantly changing to meet market demands, it is worth checking national and local<br />

government websites for updates.<br />

Figure 1: Available funding sources (as August 2012)<br />

Funding<br />

London Green Fund (LGF)<br />

The Carbon Trust<br />

EDF Energy Green Fund<br />

Green Investment Bank (GIB)<br />

WRAP – eQuip<br />

1.0 London Green Fund (LGF)<br />

The London Green Fund (LGF) was launched in 2009. This £100 million fund is<br />

available for investment in schemes that will cut London’s carbon emissions.<br />

The fund consists of £50 million from the European Regional Development Fund<br />

Programme (ERDF), £32 million from the London Development Agency (LDA), and<br />

£18 million from the London Waste and Recycling Board (LWARB). The fund is part<br />

of the Joint European Support for Sustainable Investment in City Areas initiative<br />

(JESSICA) that was developed by the European Commission and the European<br />

Investment Bank. The LGF is managed by the European Investment Bank.<br />

The LGF is divided between two smaller urban development funds, which are<br />

managed independently and invest directly in waste and energy efficiency projects.<br />

The UDFs are the Waste Urban Development Fund (WUDF) with funds of £35 million<br />

and the Energy Efficiency Urban Development Fund, (EEUDF) with funds of £50<br />

million. The fund managers decide the amount to invest in selected projects, based<br />

on an investment policy agreed by the London Green Fund Investment Board. The<br />

fund managers also expect to attract further investment into their UDFs from other<br />

investors. The Waste UDF is managed by Foresight Group LLP and is known as the<br />

‘Foresight Environmental Fund’. It is commercial funding.<br />

The WUDF finances the construction or expansion of waste to energy facilities, value<br />

added re-use, recycling or re-processing facilities and facilities which displace<br />

the use of fossil fuels. To apply for the funding and further details contact the UDF<br />

managers who are responsible for assessing project proposals. Contact details can<br />

be found at:<br />

http://www.lwarb.gov.uk<br />

Funding<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 3


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.0 The Carbon Trust<br />

2.1 Interest free loans.<br />

Small and medium enterprise (SME) businesses in Wales and Northern Ireland can<br />

apply for 0% interest loans of £3,000 - £100,000 from the Carbon Trust to help them<br />

finance and invest in energy saving projects. The repayment period of the loans is<br />

dependent on the individual projects. In Northern Ireland £1,000 can be borrowed for<br />

every 1.5tCO2 saved per year. In Wales, £1,000 is available for every 2.5t CO2 saved.<br />

To be eligible for the loan, SMEs must have incorporated businesses that have<br />

been trading for at least 12 months or non-incorporated businesses trading for at<br />

least 36 months (this will include charities, friendly societies, clubs and similar).<br />

For the purpose of this funding, an SME is defined as a company with ‘fewer than<br />

250 full time or equivalent employees, an annual turnover not exceeding €50m<br />

(approximately £42.5m) and/or assets not exceeding €43m (approximately £36.5m)<br />

and no controlling interest of more than 25% by a non-SME’. More details can be<br />

found at:<br />

2.2 Energy efficiency financing (UK)<br />

In partnership with Siemens, the Carbon Trust offer financing options including<br />

leases and loans from just £1,000 with no maximum limit. Financing is available to<br />

all types of organisations. The repayments are calculated to tie in with the anticipated<br />

energy production and resulting cost savings making the financing option pay for<br />

itself.<br />

To qualify for finance, companies are subject to a credit check and trading history<br />

as this will assist in determining the available finance. Businesses must have been<br />

trading for at least 36 months. In addition to this, an energy saving assessment will<br />

be completed by the Carbon Trust to ensure sufficient savings can be made. More<br />

details can be found at:<br />

http://www.energyefficiencyfinancing.co.uk<br />

http://www.carbontrust.co.uk<br />

Funding<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 4


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

3.0 EDF Energy Green Fund<br />

In 2001 EDF Energy set up the Green Fund using the funds from their Green Tariff.<br />

Every customer contributes an amount to green projects which the company match<br />

pound for pound. The fund is used to help promote the development and installation<br />

of renewable energy technology in communities.<br />

The fund is mainly used to help non-profit organisations set up micro-generation<br />

technologies. Any technology that produces heat and electricity will be considered<br />

and innovative technologies are supported, as long as evidence of successful trials<br />

can be provided.<br />

The fund will provide up to £30,000 (excluding VAT) for a single scheme. The funding<br />

is usually only awarded to schemes that have secured funding from other sources of<br />

an equal or greater amount, and the applicant is also expected to contribute to the<br />

overall cost. The scheme will not be eligible to receive EDF funds if they have already<br />

secured funding from other energy companies.<br />

There are two rounds of funding per year with the closing dates being 28th February<br />

and 31st August. Currently there is no known end date for the fund. All applicants<br />

are scored in two stages against pre-set criteria. Unsuccessful applicants are not<br />

allowed to re-apply for the project in the next funding round, however they can apply<br />

for subsequent rounds. Further details and the application form can be found at:<br />

http://www.edfenergy.com/products-services/for-your-home/our-services/greenenergy-fund.shtml<br />

4.0 Green Investment Bank (GIB)<br />

The Green Investment Bank is being set up by the government to provide the<br />

significant investment that will be required to establish a ‘green economy’ in the UK.<br />

In December 2011 the Department for Business, Skills and Innovation (BIS) published<br />

the criteria for deciding where the bank will be based and what the bank’s first<br />

priorities will be until 2016, which includes energy from waste generation.<br />

A new team will be set up within BIS to drive investment in the UK’s green<br />

infrastructure until the Green Investment Bank is formally established. The UK Green<br />

Investments (UKGI) team will have access to the £100 million made available by the<br />

Government to invest in smaller waste infrastructure projects on a fully commercial<br />

basis. A further £100 million has been provided for investment in the non-domestic<br />

energy efficiency sector for the next financial year. £80 million has been awarded to<br />

fund managers Foresight and Greensphere. UKGI will also be available to co-invest<br />

in offshore wind projects. It is proposed that the GIB project will evolve over three<br />

phases as below:<br />

• UK Green Investments – from 2012 until state aid approval for GIB is granted,<br />

BIS’ UK Green Investments project will make direct investments in green<br />

infrastructure projects.<br />

• Establishment – GIB will be established as a stand-alone institution following<br />

state-aid approval. It is expected that state aid approval will be granted in autumn<br />

2012.<br />

• Full borrowing – from April 2015, the GIB will be given full powers to borrow,<br />

subject to public sector net debt falling as a percentage of GDP and further state<br />

aid approval being granted.<br />

To keep up to date with the GIB developments please visit:<br />

http://www.bis.gov.uk/greeninvestmentbank<br />

Funding<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 5


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

5.0 WRAP eQuip Scheme<br />

The eQuip leasing scheme has been set up by WRAP to help companies secure<br />

financial assistance for new and second hand recycling plants and machinery,<br />

through guaranteeing the future value of plant machinery which is leased. Financial<br />

benefits from the scheme include:<br />

• VAT is charged on each individual rental payment, removing the need for it to be<br />

paid up front;<br />

• lease facilities are generally not payable on demand or subject to annual reviews;<br />

and<br />

• all rental payments made by the company can be set against tax liabilities<br />

To qualify for the scheme, a business must sort, reprocess, recycle or manufacture<br />

products using one of a range of materials that include plastic, organics (In-Vessel<br />

composting or Anaerobic Digestion only), textiles, glass or wood (only treated/<br />

contaminated wood). eQuip can support waste to energy applications but it must be<br />

clearly demonstrated that there is no higher value use for the material.<br />

The eQuip scheme has been designed to process applications quickly - with<br />

applications for equipment up to £250,000 processed in less than one month, and<br />

applications over £250,000 taking a maximum of eight weeks from receipt of the<br />

completed application form. Further details and the application form can be found at:<br />

6.0 Additional Sources of Information<br />

6.1 The Knowledge Transfer Network<br />

Provides advice on funding and networking and recently launched the Energy<br />

Generation and Supply Knowledge Transfer Network which is a useful on line<br />

resource to find funding and partners.<br />

https://connect.innovateuk.org/web/energyktn/overview<br />

6.2 The British Private Equity & Venture Capital Association<br />

The industry body for the private equity and venture capital industry in the UK.<br />

http://www.bvca.co.uk<br />

6.3 The Green Grants Machine<br />

A source of information on grants, loans, awards and other funds available to help<br />

businesses go green.<br />

http://www.greengrantsmachine.co.uk<br />

http://www.wrap.org.uk/content/equip-leasing-made-easy-0<br />

Funding<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 6


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Feasibility, due<br />

diligence and good<br />

practice in <strong>EfW</strong> project<br />

development<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

2.0 Developing a business case<br />

3.0 Energy from waste technologies<br />

4.0 Site selection<br />

5.0 Due diligence<br />

Guidance to help in the feasibility assessment of <strong>EfW</strong><br />

facilities to facilitate the design and feasibility processes<br />

of <strong>EfW</strong> plants.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 7


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

The purpose of this guidance is to provide a source of information for waste<br />

producers and businesses who are interested in developing small scale energy from<br />

waste (<strong>EfW</strong>) plants. This guidance focuses on the feasibility study stage of the project<br />

process.<br />

There are a number of different <strong>EfW</strong> technologies available, including combustion,<br />

AD, gasification and pyrolysis, which can provide an energy recovery option for those<br />

wastes which cannot be re-used, recycled, composted or digested. Projects of this<br />

nature frequently take a period of time to develop and implement so it is prudent to<br />

periodically review the initial feasibility work in light of any changes to feedstock,<br />

legislation/regulations, funding options, progression of new technologies and<br />

observation of lessons learned on similar projects.<br />

An initial, robust feasibility assessment should help to lay the foundations for a<br />

successful project. This document covers the areas of business case development,<br />

site selection, technology options and due diligence. In addition to providing a quick<br />

overview of key project considerations, it also provides useful contacts and sources to<br />

assist with this process.<br />

2.0 Developing a business case<br />

Developing a business case should help to ensure a successful, well planned project,<br />

prior to investing any funds. The business case should help answer the following<br />

questions:<br />

• What are the key legislative and policy issues: should the waste be managed in<br />

an <strong>EfW</strong> facility<br />

• What will the feedstock be<br />

• What is the ‘need’ for the facility in respect to waste management and/or low<br />

carbon energy production<br />

• What are the local waste management options and alternatives<br />

• What is the most appropriate technology for the waste feedstocks being<br />

considered<br />

• Do I have a suitable site<br />

• What size should the facility be<br />

• How much will a facility cost to construct (including the feasibility of heat and<br />

energy off-take/connection to electricity grid and combined heat and power<br />

(CHP))<br />

• How much will the facility cost to operate<br />

• How long will the project take from planning to operation<br />

• Is the project economically viable and how will it be funded<br />

• Have I carried out appropriate project due diligence<br />

• Who will be the project partners<br />

• What legal matters need to be considered<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 8


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.1 Technical feasibility<br />

The first crucial step for a potential <strong>EfW</strong> proposal will be to develop a business model<br />

to determine the most appropriate technology. The specific elements as shown in<br />

Figure 1 will need to be considered within the feasibility assessment before choosing<br />

a technology:<br />

Figure 1 – Typical project feasibility assessment diagram<br />

Planning<br />

and<br />

permitting<br />

Location<br />

Feedstocks –<br />

type of<br />

waste<br />

2.1.1 Location<br />

Before an <strong>EfW</strong> plant can be built, you will need to establish how much land is<br />

required, as technology footprints vary for each type and design of <strong>EfW</strong> plant (see<br />

section 4 – Site selection). The proposal will also need to consider land allocation<br />

for feedstock, waste reception, processing requirements, storage requirements and<br />

other ancillary equipment. Dependant on the outputs of the process (in terms of<br />

heat, steam and/or electricity) you may need to consider heat users, access to an<br />

electricity sub-station or local electricity distributor. Where will the process residues<br />

be managed and is the location well situated to facilities which can manage bottom<br />

ash and flue residues or does this need to be accommodated in your site<br />

Further information can be found in section 4.<br />

Gate Fees<br />

and<br />

revenues<br />

Feasability<br />

assesment<br />

Feedstock<br />

Security<br />

Government<br />

incentives<br />

Energy<br />

production<br />

CAPEX and<br />

OPEX<br />

Operation of<br />

facility<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 9


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.1.2 Feedstock – waste<br />

A market assessment of waste facilities is crucial at the feasibility stage. This would<br />

include a waste forecast, a consideration of policy targets (for example LA recycling)<br />

and evaluation of existing and planned waste capacity within a specified distance<br />

from the proposed location.<br />

The availability of waste feedstock and its variability are key parameters when<br />

determining which technology will be the most suitable for the proposal, as well as<br />

the long term economic viability of a project. The feasibility assessment will need to<br />

include a detailed analysis of the availability and physical & chemical characteristics<br />

of the feedstock. The larger “mass-burn” technologies are less sensitive to<br />

variations in feedstock, however others, such as gasification are more sensitive,<br />

requiring pre-treatment of feedstock.<br />

The physical and chemical properties of the fuel can have an impact on the energy<br />

efficiency, operation and emissions of an <strong>EfW</strong> facility. See forthcoming WRAP<br />

guidance on feedstocks and fuel classification for more detail, but typically the<br />

following factors will need to be evaluated to determine the overall fuel quality:<br />

• biogenic content;<br />

• moisture content;<br />

• ash content;<br />

• net calorific value;<br />

• size and density; and<br />

• chemical content (including chlorine, mercury, cadmium and other heavy<br />

metals).<br />

2.1.3 Fuel preparation<br />

The feedstock may also require further processing before it can be thermally treated.<br />

The type of fuel preparation techniques used would depend on the input fuel and<br />

the <strong>EfW</strong> technology being used. Some of the most commonly used fuel preparation<br />

techniques include:<br />

• sorting;<br />

• biological treatment;<br />

• crushing, grinding, shredding;<br />

• separating;<br />

• screening;<br />

• washing;<br />

• drying, cooling;<br />

• pelletising;<br />

• compacting; and<br />

• dust removal.<br />

2.1.4 Feedstock security<br />

The work involved in the concept, feasibility, design, commissioning and operational<br />

stages of an <strong>EfW</strong> facility represents a large capital investment over a long period of<br />

time. A cost/benefit analysis needs to demonstrate to funders that sufficient suitable<br />

waste feedstock is available over that period to ensure the facility can run at or near<br />

capacity and generate the revenues or savings expected. Developers will also need<br />

to demonstrate feedstock security and consider any changes to their business that<br />

might impact on the quantity or composition of the waste they require.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 10


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.1.5 Electricity and heat production<br />

The UK Government has set an ambitious target to reduce 60% of carbon emissions<br />

by 2050 and has identified the importance of energy recovered from waste in<br />

displacing fossil fuels. <strong>EfW</strong> technology can convert the low entropy chemical energy<br />

in waste derived fuels into high entropy heat, electricity or both.<br />

The ‘amount’ of energy produced depends upon the composition of the feedstock,<br />

the technology used, the boiler and turbine efficiency and how long the facility will<br />

need to operate. The technology selection and set up of the facility will depend<br />

on the desired outputs, which in most cases can be set up to produce direct heat/<br />

steam (most efficient), electricity (least efficient) or a combination of both. For small<br />

and medium enterprises (SMEs) which require a significant supply of heat and/or<br />

power, a nearby <strong>EfW</strong> facility can represent a secure source of power and protect the<br />

business against potential rising energy costs.<br />

2.1.6 Operation of the facility<br />

The operation of <strong>EfW</strong> facilities, particularly advanced thermal treatment plants,<br />

require a greater level of skill and operator knowledge compared to conventional<br />

incinerators. The availability of staff with the required skills will need to be<br />

considered, along with the number of additional staff required to operate the facility.<br />

The feasibility assessment will also need to consider any maintenance costs and<br />

emissions monitoring costs within the business case.<br />

2.1.7 Outline CAPEX and OPEX<br />

A key parameter for the development of a business case is the capital expenditure<br />

(CAPEX) and operational expenditure (OPEX) that is required to purchase and run<br />

the <strong>EfW</strong> equipment over its lifetime. The capital cost represents the estimated total<br />

plant costs, which include but are not limited to: main equipment costs; direct plant<br />

costs; purchase of the land; costs associated with obtaining planning permission;<br />

environmental permits and indirect plant costs. The operational cost includes, but<br />

is not limited to: raw materials; labour; electrical energy consumed; maintenance;<br />

materials consumed; consultant services; general insurance; expenses; local tax;<br />

unforeseen expenses and ash disposal.<br />

2.1.8 Government incentives<br />

There are a number of policies supporting the delivery of <strong>EfW</strong> technologies that fit<br />

within the waste hierarchy. The UK Government is committed to sourcing 15% of its<br />

energy from renewable sources by 2020 and has stated where appropriate that <strong>EfW</strong><br />

can make a contribution to the renewable energy target.<br />

The landfill tax escalator is also acting to reduce the amount of waste sent to<br />

landfill. Gate fees, current disposal costs, and energy/transport requirements are all<br />

considerations which will need to be considered within a business case.<br />

Within the policy framework there are a number of funding opportunities to generate<br />

revenue from energy production that SMEs can now access to build into a business<br />

case for investment in small scale <strong>EfW</strong> technology. These include:<br />

• the Renewables Obligation (RO);<br />

• Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI);<br />

• Combined Heat and Power (CHP); and<br />

• Feed in Tariffs (FiTs).<br />

Where projects involve the export of power to the National Grid, there is the potential<br />

to gain additional revenue through the sale of Renewables Obligations Certificates<br />

(ROCs). ROCs are issued by Ofgem to producers of renewable electricity. As all<br />

energy suppliers have an obligation to provide a certain amount of their electricity<br />

from a renewable source, those suppliers who do not produce renewable energy can<br />

purchase the certificates from those who do, so the ROCs themselves have a market<br />

value, which can add significantly to the income of a renewable energy supplier.<br />

Similarly, where a plant provides direct heat to a heat user the supplier can apply<br />

for payments through the Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI). This works in a similar<br />

manner to the ROCs regime, but supports non-fossil fuel produced heat delivery,<br />

rather than electricity. See WRAP guidance on Financial Incentives for more detail.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 11


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Combined Heat and Power (CHP) is a form of plant design which produces electricity,<br />

but in addition then captures and utilises the waste heat from the process. In this<br />

case, the supplier can choose whether to claim under ROCs for the electricity or to<br />

claim under RHI for the heat, but they cannot claim for both.<br />

Feed in Tariffs (FiTs) are a similar scheme to ROCs but aimed very much at the small<br />

scale. Eligible installations need to be less than 5MW capacity, which would exclude<br />

many <strong>EfW</strong> facilities.<br />

2.1.9 Gate fees and revenue<br />

One of the important factors that determine the projected revenue from an <strong>EfW</strong><br />

facility is its gate fees. This is the fee which is paid by the waste fuel supplier for the<br />

treatment and disposal of waste. The revenue generated from gate fees depends on<br />

the location of the site, the type of process and the capacity of the plant, as well as<br />

other economic factors.<br />

Gate fees are levied on each tonne of waste accepted at site for treatment in order to<br />

offset the total operating cost of the systems. It is customary for operators to include<br />

the profit within the cash flow for calculation of gate fees. The gate fees levied would<br />

also depend on the projected revenues from electricity sales, ROCs, RHI and the<br />

sales of other outputs and residues such as secondary aggregates made from bottom<br />

ash.<br />

2.1.10 Planning and permitting<br />

Planning permission and an Environmental Permit will need to be obtained for<br />

the construction and operation of the facility. It is important to factor in the cost of<br />

preparing a planning and permit application, as well as the time taken to prepare<br />

and determine these applications.<br />

Securing planning is a key project hurdle and it is advisable to carry out initial<br />

planning feasibility work for the proposed site and development at the business case<br />

development stage.<br />

For further information see the WRAP guidance on planning.<br />

For further information see the WRAP guidance on environmental permitting.<br />

2.1.11 Legal agreements<br />

New projects will need to consider contractual arrangements and legal warranties.<br />

It is important that legal advice is sought early within the project development to<br />

scope any potential legal barriers and determine any risks to the business. The<br />

overall business case will need to consider issues such as the utilisation of waste<br />

materials, electricity generation, grid connection agreements, planning conditions<br />

and technology warranties.<br />

Any joint venture or partnerships may have to be warranted, and legal support<br />

may also be required to ensure contracts are in place. Seeking legal advice within<br />

the feasibility phase will provide the necessary evidence for any commercial<br />

commitments that may be required from project concept to delivery.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 12


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

3.0 Energy from waste<br />

technologies<br />

There are a number of <strong>EfW</strong> technologies which can<br />

process waste to generate energy in the form of<br />

electricity, heat or cooling. The most well-known<br />

type of commercial <strong>EfW</strong> plant is the modern waste<br />

incinerator which burns wastes at high temperatures<br />

to produce heat which converts water to steam. The<br />

steam is then used to drive a turbine, generating<br />

electricity which is exported to the National Grid.<br />

There are also other <strong>EfW</strong> technologies generally<br />

referred to as advanced thermal treatments (ATT) or<br />

as advanced conversion technologies (ACT) though<br />

many remain unproven on a commercial scale for<br />

specific feedstock use. Examples across the range of<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> thermal processes include:<br />

• incineration;<br />

• gasification;<br />

• pyrolysis; and<br />

• plasma gasification.<br />

Figure 2 – Incineration plant flow diagram (Otto Simon Ltd)<br />

3.2 Incineration<br />

The most well known thermal process is incineration<br />

and a variety of <strong>EfW</strong> incineration technologies are<br />

available such as fluidised bed or moving grate.<br />

During incineration the waste is burnt in the presence<br />

of oxygen at a high temperature – normally above 850<br />

°C. The process produces steam which can be used<br />

to generate electricity and heat; wastes that are not<br />

incinerated remain as a solid residue.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 13


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

3.3 Gasification<br />

Figure 3 – Gasification plant flow diagram (Otto Simon Ltd)<br />

Gasification is considered a commercial technology<br />

in the coal and chemicals industry and a variety of<br />

gasification designs are available such as up draft,<br />

down draft, entrained flow and fluidised bed reactors.<br />

Gasification is another thermal process during which<br />

a controlled amount of oxygen, air or steam is passed<br />

through the waste preventing full combustion. The<br />

process occurs at high temperatures, normally above<br />

750 °C, producing syngas (‘synthetic gas’, which<br />

typically contains Carbon Monoxide, Hydrogen and<br />

Methane) and a solid residue or char. The syngas can<br />

be burnt to produce steam or converted via a prime<br />

mover such as a gas engine or turbine which can<br />

be used to produce electricity and heat. Gasification<br />

is considered as an advanced thermal treatment<br />

technology, and although not yet commercially<br />

proven in the UK using MSW, there are wood biomass<br />

gasification plants being established across the UK.<br />

The advantages of gasification plants are that they<br />

can be modular and the operating parameters can be<br />

varied to match the variety of feedstock composition.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 14


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

3.4 Pyrolysis<br />

Figure 4 – Pyrolysis plant flow diagram (Otto Simon Ltd)<br />

Historically the pyrolysis process has been used in the<br />

chemical industry to produce charcoal and coke from<br />

wood. During pyrolysis no oxygen is used; the waste<br />

undergoes thermal degradation at temperatures<br />

between 300 °C to 850 °C. The process typically<br />

produces a hydrogen rich syngas (which typically<br />

contains Carbon Monoxide, Hydrogen and Methane),<br />

a liquid oil and a solid char. The relative proportions<br />

of these products can be altered by the speed of the<br />

process and the temperatures at which the reactor<br />

runs. The syngas can be burnt to produce steam or<br />

converted via gas engines to produce electricity and<br />

heat or condensed to produce more oils. Pyrolysis is<br />

not yet developed at a commercial scale within the UK,<br />

although developmental projects are up and running<br />

and reference plants have been built within the EU to<br />

recover organic wastes.<br />

3.5 Plasma gasification<br />

Plasma gasification techniques use an electric<br />

current, an inert carrying gas and powerful electrodes<br />

to create plasma - an ionised gas (not dissimilar to<br />

lightning). In plasma gasification, fuel or waste is<br />

fed to a reactor vessel where it comes into contact<br />

with electrically generated plasma and is heated to<br />

temperatures of up to 6,000ºC. Organic molecules are<br />

converted into a syngas that can be used to generate<br />

electricity and liquid fuels, while most metals melt<br />

or are vaporised and other inorganic solids are<br />

converted into a glass-like substance that can be<br />

marketed to the construction industry as an aggregate<br />

replacement.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 15


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

4.0 Site selection<br />

4.1 The site selection process<br />

Choosing the right site can minimise planning delays and help ensure project<br />

success.<br />

The planning system is plan-led and finding a site which is allocated for an <strong>EfW</strong><br />

facility in an adopted Development Plan will increase the likelihood of success.<br />

Modern <strong>EfW</strong> facilities are industrial in nature and often fit well within an industrial<br />

setting.<br />

The site selection process is very important in determining the correct and most<br />

suitable location for the proposed facility. There is national guidance contained within<br />

Planning Policy Statement 10 (PPS10), its Companion Guide and Supplement to<br />

Planning Policy Statement 1: Planning and Climate Change which deal with location<br />

criteria for such developments. Annex E of PPS10 provides locational criteria which<br />

assist in the site selection process.<br />

4.2 Site selection process check list<br />

The list below provides a check list that should be considered when locating a<br />

potential <strong>EfW</strong> facility.<br />

4.2.1 Availability, location and feedstock<br />

• Is the feedstock readily available in a format that the chosen technology can<br />

treat<br />

• Is the feedstock located within a cost effective distance from the site Road<br />

based transportation should ideally be no more than a 1 hour drive.<br />

• Is the site located close to the primary road network, thereby avoiding residential<br />

and school routes<br />

• Is the site access suitable for HGV movements<br />

• Is the site available and deliverable for the proposed use<br />

• Has there been sufficient consideration for the location where the waste residues<br />

from the <strong>EfW</strong> process will end up, either to be re-processed or disposed of at a<br />

suitably licensed (hazardous) landfill site<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 16


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

4.2.2 Development plan policies:<br />

If you are looking for a site:<br />

• Is there an up to date adopted Waste Core Strategy and supporting development<br />

plan document with sites allocated for waste uses<br />

• Are any of these allocated sites suitable and available for your proposal (see<br />

checklist below)<br />

• If no, does the development plan include a policy for <strong>EfW</strong> proposals on<br />

“unallocated” sites If yes, ensure the site you select adheres to this policy<br />

(checklist below may also assist).<br />

• If there is no up to date waste development plan, is there an emerging waste<br />

plan If so, check if any sites have been nominated for waste uses or nominate<br />

your site for waste use.<br />

If you have a site which you think is suitable for an <strong>EfW</strong> facility:<br />

• check that your site complies with the policies in the adopted development<br />

plan; and<br />

• where there is an emerging plan (one which hasn’t yet been adopted) make<br />

representations to the Planning Authority that your site is available and suitable<br />

for waste uses (use checklist below to help with the assessment).<br />

4.2.3 Location of nearby utilities and grid connection point<br />

• Is there a suitable and viable substation/grid connection point nearby for export<br />

to grid<br />

• Are there any utility constraints that may restrict the construction or operational<br />

elements of the proposed facility<br />

4.2.4 Location of nearby possible heat/cooling customers<br />

• Is there a suitable customer nearby that could utilise either heat or cooling from<br />

the <strong>EfW</strong> process<br />

4.2.5 Land classification/location<br />

• avoid greenbelt - otherwise you will need to demonstrate the very special<br />

circumstances for proposing inappropriate development in green belt land;<br />

• try to utilise previously developed land;<br />

• ideally locate within an industrial setting; and<br />

• try to identify the potential to co-locate with existing or planned waste<br />

management facilities.<br />

4.2.6 Location of sensitive receptors<br />

Ideally the site should not be located within close proximity to:<br />

• residential properties;<br />

• school or colleges;<br />

• Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONBs);<br />

• national parks;<br />

• areas or sites of historic interest (e.g. listed buildings World Heritage Sites,<br />

Conservation Areas); and<br />

• areas of nature conservation interest, e.g., Sites of Special Scientific Interest<br />

(SSSI), Special Area for Conservation (SAC), Special Protection Area (SPA), Local<br />

Nature Reserve (LNR), National Nature Reserve (NNR), Biosphere Reserves or<br />

Global Geoparks etc.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 17


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

4.2.7 Other site sensitivities<br />

Figure 5 – A suitable site location for an <strong>EfW</strong> facility<br />

Sites should ideally not be located within:<br />

• an area liable to flooding;<br />

• an Air Quality Management Area (AQMA); and<br />

• a Ground Water Source Protection Zone (SPZ) 1 as defined by the Environment<br />

agency.<br />

Careful consideration should also be given to the following:<br />

• the impact of the development on aerodrome safeguarding areas depending on<br />

the stack height of the facility;<br />

• the potential of the site to support protected species (ecology) and any<br />

implications that may have for the development; and<br />

• the potential impact of the proposed <strong>EfW</strong> on Special Protection Areas (SPA) and<br />

Special Areas of Conservation (SAC) located near the site. There would need to be<br />

a compelling case in the public interest if the proposed <strong>EfW</strong> is likely to harm the<br />

SPA or SAC through emissions to air and other impacts. It is advisable to review<br />

the Air Pollution Information System information www.apis.ac.uk and contact the<br />

Environment Agency and Natural England on this matter.<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 18


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

5.0 Due diligence<br />

5.1 What is due diligence<br />

Due diligence is a process often undertaken at a time of business acquisition,<br />

restructuring or major project development. The purpose of due diligence is to review<br />

the profile of a company or project to understand any potential risks.<br />

5.2 What does it include<br />

A due diligence audit is normally undertaken to gather information and evidence.<br />

This can include auditing different aspects across a company or project such as<br />

an assessment of liabilities, potential impact on value, environmental compliance,<br />

health and safety and technology.<br />

Figure 6 – Examples of the different audits that can form part of due diligence<br />

Due<br />

Dilligence<br />

5.3 Why is it useful<br />

A due diligence audit can be used to act as a guarantee when undertaking a new<br />

project. Financial institutions, insurance companies and business partners will<br />

want information and evidence to demonstrate investment potential and understand<br />

liabilities.<br />

Environmental<br />

Audit<br />

Technical<br />

Audit<br />

Financial<br />

Audit<br />

Legal<br />

Audit<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Funding Planning Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 19


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Planning<br />

Guidance to explain the planning process and how it<br />

affects energy from waste developments<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

2.0 The planning system<br />

3.0 Development plan led system<br />

4.0 Changes to the planning system<br />

5.0 Design<br />

6.0 Key stages of the planning process<br />

7.0 Health<br />

8.0 Other consents<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 20


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

Following the development of a business case and initial feasibility work, securing<br />

planning permission is the next key step in the delivery of an <strong>EfW</strong> facility.<br />

Understanding the planning process will help you develop a realistic project<br />

programme taking account of:<br />

• time required to prepare a planning application;<br />

• the likely time taken for the planning authority to determine the application; and<br />

• the time required to seek discharge of pre-commencement style planning<br />

conditions which are needed before you can commence construction.<br />

This guidance focuses on <strong>EfW</strong> planning proposals determined under the Town and<br />

Country Planning regime for proposals with a power generation capacity of less than<br />

50MW 1 .<br />

A robust planning application prepared in parallel with an Environmental Permit<br />

application 2 can be cost effective, assists in securing the necessary consents and<br />

minimises the risk of legal challenge to decisions made either by the planning<br />

authority or the EA.<br />

The planning system helps ensure that development takes place in a way which<br />

balances environmental, social and economic impacts in the public interest.<br />

1.1 Planning - quick checklist<br />

Planning can seem a challenge but you can minimize costs and avoid project delays<br />

by understanding the system and following some key steps:<br />

• Make sure your proposal is consistent with the adopted local development plan.<br />

• Establish the key planning considerations – traffic increase, impact on nature<br />

conservation, landscape, local residents etc., and make sure these impacts<br />

are minimised as much as possible through good quality design of the proposal<br />

[Design Council website and BREEAM guidance].<br />

• Consult the planning authority and key statutory consultees, for instance:<br />

EA; Natural England; Design Council; Highways Agency.<br />

• If your site is in an area where a new development plan is being prepared, contact<br />

the LPA, promote your site for inclusion in the development plan and make<br />

representations to ensure that emerging policies support your proposal.<br />

• Consult local people – The Localism Act has introduced a statutory requirement<br />

to consult on certain projects, available from the Communities and Local<br />

Government Guidance It is advisable to discuss the approach to community<br />

consultation with the LPA.<br />

• Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA): in most cases an EIA is mandatory but<br />

you should check with the planning authority at an early stage.<br />

• Allow enough time to prepare a comprehensive Planning Application: agree<br />

with the planning authority the information required in support of the planning<br />

application to avoid delays at a later stage.<br />

1<br />

Energy facilities which generate over 50MW of energy are considered nationally significant<br />

infrastructure projects and will be determined by the National Infrastructure Planning Unit.<br />

2<br />

See WRAP guidance on Environmental Permitting Regulations<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 21


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.0 The planning system<br />

The planning system helps to ensure that development takes place in a way which<br />

balances environmental, social and economic impacts thereby securing sustainable<br />

development.<br />

The core elements of the planning system are:<br />

• preparing development plans; and<br />

• managing the development itself.<br />

These activities are mainly led and undertaken at the local authority level by the<br />

LPA. The LPA is responsible for deciding whether a proposed development should be<br />

allowed to go ahead. In areas where there are two tiers of local authority (county and<br />

district councils), planning applications for waste development, including energy from<br />

waste facilities, should be made to the higher level (county council rather than district<br />

or borough).<br />

Where an LPA:<br />

• refuses planning permission;<br />

• attaches an unreasonable planning condition to a planning approval; or<br />

• delays decision-making beyond a statutory period (13 weeks for a non EIA type<br />

proposal and 16 weeks for an EIA type development (See Section 6.2),<br />

then applicants will have the right to appeal to the Secretary of State. Appeals are usually<br />

considered by a Planning Inspector who is appointed by the Secretary of State.<br />

3.0 Development plan led system<br />

LPAs prepare development plans through consultation with local communities which<br />

set the broad framework for acceptable development in their local area. County<br />

Council Waste Planning Authorities (WPA) will prepare waste core strategies and<br />

development plan documents which guide waste development in the larger county<br />

areas. Unitary authorities will perform both roles. Development plans may allocate<br />

specific sites for waste development and should provide guidance as to the type of<br />

sites which are considered most suitable.<br />

The planning system is a development plan led system. Planning applications have to<br />

be decided in line with the development plan unless there are very good reasons not<br />

to (e.g. the plan is out of date or other material considerations should be given more<br />

weight). Ensuring a planning proposal is consistent with up to date development plan<br />

policies minimises the risk of planning delay or failure.<br />

The Planning Advisory Service and Planning Portal websites provide guidance on the<br />

plan making process.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 22


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

4.0 Changes to the planning system<br />

The Government introduced significant changes to the planning system when the<br />

Localism Act received Royal Assent in November 2011.<br />

4.1 What is new<br />

The Act makes a number of key changes to the planning system:<br />

• a statutory requirement for pre-application consultation;<br />

• neighbourhood planning;<br />

• allows councillors to discuss a planning proposal before it reaches the planning<br />

committee;<br />

• abolishes the Infrastructure Planning Commission which previously determined<br />

applications for energy facilities over 50 MW; and<br />

• abolishes the regional tier of planning policy. Regional Spatial Strategies will no<br />

longer be part of the development plan.<br />

4.2 National Planning Policy Framework<br />

The Government has streamlined national planning guidance by the introduction of<br />

the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), which sets out the government’s<br />

planning policies for England. It replaces the previous Planning Policy Statements<br />

(PPSs)/Planning Policy Guidance Notes (PPGs).<br />

The NPPF states that there is a presumption in favour of sustainable development,<br />

as well as containing general planning policies which will be relevant to energy from<br />

waste development, such as nature conservation, cultural heritage, climate change<br />

etc.<br />

Annex 1 of the NPPF explains how it should be implemented. It specifically excludes<br />

detailed waste policies as a national waste planning policy and will be published<br />

alongside the National Waste Management Plan for England. In the meantime<br />

Planning Policy Statement (PPS) 10: Planning for waste management will remain the<br />

relevant national policy for waste.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 23


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

5.0 Design<br />

Good design is now a core part of Government planning policy. When determining<br />

planning applications local authorities are required to consider design quality. Where<br />

energy from waste proposals involve new buildings or structures a Design and Access<br />

Statement will need to be submitted along with the planning application.<br />

Design is a process which should be a defining part of any project and will evolve as<br />

the project develops. Good design balances the function, quality and impact of the<br />

facility. Further detailed guidance is provided in Designing Waste Facilities- a guide to<br />

modern design in waste.<br />

Further information is available on the BREEAM website: http://www.breeam.org<br />

Guidance on preparing Design and Access Statements is provided in:<br />

Circular 01/2006 Guidance on changes to the development control system:<br />

http://communities.gov.uk/documents/planningandbuilding/pdf/144854.pdf<br />

Design and Access Statements - How to read, write and use them – CABE 2006:<br />

http:/www.cabe.org.uk/publications/design-and-access-statements<br />

Good quality design which incorporates sustainability principles can minimise<br />

planning delay, particularly if the location for the <strong>EfW</strong> facility is located in a visible<br />

and/or sensitive location.<br />

The design needs to be appropriate for the particular site and location. Some<br />

planning authorities will have design guidance for planning proposals – this can be<br />

checked during pre-application discussions with the relevant authority.<br />

Achieving sustainable design of waste facilities is an important part of the design<br />

process. Many local authorities now require sustainability to be considered in planning<br />

applications. The Building Research Establishment’s Environmental Assessment<br />

Method (BREEAM) is a recognised process to guide the design and assess the facility’s<br />

performance in terms of environmental sustainability. Some Local Authorities may have<br />

policies requiring developments to achieve a certain BREEAM rating.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 24


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

6.0 Key stages of the planning process<br />

The Planning Portal www.planningportal.gov.uk provides detailed information<br />

on the planning process and allows applications to be submitted online.<br />

It is advisable to develop a realistic planning programme, preferably at the feasibility<br />

stage of the project. The period for preparing and determining a planning application<br />

can vary significantly according to the level of complexity of the proposal. For<br />

example a development requiring an EIA requires a longer period of time for the<br />

planning application to be prepared.<br />

Other key factors which will impact on planning programmes include carrying out<br />

ecology surveys in the appropriate season or gathering bespoke air quality data<br />

which can be required for <strong>EfW</strong> projects, particularly if the application site is near<br />

sensitive ecology sites.<br />

Figure 1- Key Stages of the Planning Process<br />

Consult<br />

the<br />

community<br />

Initiate<br />

pre-application<br />

discussions<br />

with<br />

Planning<br />

Authority<br />

Confirm if<br />

Environmental<br />

Impact<br />

Assesment is<br />

required<br />

Consult<br />

Prepare<br />

Planning<br />

Appplication<br />

Submit<br />

Planning<br />

Appplication<br />

Local<br />

Authority<br />

Consultation<br />

Sign off<br />

legal<br />

agreements<br />

if applicable<br />

Issue of<br />

Decision<br />

Notice<br />

Discharge<br />

of pre –<br />

commencement<br />

conditions<br />

the Local<br />

Authority<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 25


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

6.1 Initiate pre-application discussions<br />

At the outset, proposals should be discussed with the relevant LPA prior to<br />

submitting the planning application. The LPA will be able to provide advice on the<br />

requirements for the planning applications including the forms, certificates, plans<br />

and supporting information which is required to be submitted with the application.<br />

They should also be able to advise on any key planning issues which are relevant to<br />

the proposed site for the development, and also provide advice on consulting with the<br />

local community and stakeholders prior to the application being submitted, which is<br />

now a legal requirement for certain proposals. All LPAs should be happy to engage<br />

in pre-application discussions. However, it is now becoming common for planning<br />

authorities to charge for this service. It is advisable to check relevant websites or call<br />

the authority planning reception for assistance on this matter.<br />

For proposals in London with a waste capacity over 50,000 tonnes per annum it would<br />

be advisable to also consult the Greater London Authority (GLA). The GLA provides<br />

pre-application advice to developers although there is a charge for this service.<br />

6.2 Confirm whether an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is required.<br />

Certain waste proposals will require an EIA to be carried out. Essentially there are<br />

two categories of development for the purposes of EIA:<br />

• ‘Schedule 1’ developments are those where an EIA is always required. This would<br />

include incineration of hazardous waste or incineration of more than 100 tonnes<br />

per day of non-hazardous waste; and<br />

• ‘Schedule 2’ developments may require an EIA if they fall above certain<br />

thresholds and are likely to have a significant effect. This would include<br />

development which involves incineration (other than that specified in schedule 1<br />

above) or exceeds 0.5 ha or is in a sensitive area e.g. a National Park or Area of<br />

Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB). Guidance states that an EIA is less likely to<br />

be required on waste facilities with a capacity under 50,000 tonnes per annum.<br />

The developer can submit a screening opinion request in order to confirm<br />

whether an EIA would be required.<br />

The EIA Regulations require an EIA to be submitted in support of a proposal which<br />

is likely to have potential significant impacts on the environment. A waste proposal<br />

could have transport, ecology, air quality, noise, archaeology, ground condition,<br />

landscape/visual and flood risk impacts. Where considered significant these will<br />

need to be assessed, with assessments submitted with the planning application to<br />

allow the LPA to consider the potential impacts.<br />

If no EIA is needed then supporting information may still be required, such as a<br />

transport assessment and ecology surveys.<br />

It should be noted that the proposed connection of the <strong>EfW</strong> facility to allow electricity<br />

or heat off-take does not need to form part of the planning application. However,<br />

if the proposal is an EIA type development, any environmental impacts of the<br />

transmission line must be assessed separately.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 26


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

6.3 Undertake pre-application consultation with the local community<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> proposals can be controversial and cause delays during the planning phase.<br />

Local communities can be concerned about a number of issues including:<br />

• increased traffic;<br />

• visual impact;<br />

• noise generation; and<br />

• dust and odour.<br />

Effective communication with the local community and other stakeholders can help<br />

significantly reduce the risk of a planning application being refused and is now a legal<br />

requirement of the planning process for certain proposals.<br />

It is important to consider consultation early in the process in discussion with the<br />

LPA. They may have ideas about who should be consulted and how best to carry out<br />

the consultation. Most authorities will have a Statement of Community Involvement<br />

(SCI) which will set out guidance on pre-application consultation for developers.<br />

There a number of key points to consider:<br />

• Develop a consultation plan: At the outset it is useful to put together a<br />

consultation plan which sets out what you are trying to achieve, who should be<br />

consulted, when and how.<br />

• Deciding who to consult: Different people and organisations will have differing<br />

interests in the proposals. In the case of neighbours to the scheme and Parish/<br />

Town Councils it can help build trust if they are made aware of the proposals<br />

early in the process.<br />

• Deciding how and when to consult: The timing and method of consultation needs<br />

to be appropriate for the audience. It is advisable to give careful consideration to<br />

the way the consultation is carried out, the timing and venue for any events.<br />

• Feedback: It is important to show that you are listening to the local community.<br />

Consultation feedback will need to be analysed and results communicated back<br />

to those involved. Showing how you have taken account of comments and made<br />

changes if possible can be very helpful.<br />

• Managing expectations: The local community may have their own view of what<br />

they can achieve from the consultation process. It is important to manage<br />

expectations and be clear about how they can input into the scheme; and<br />

• Reporting: Most authorities will require a statement to be submitted with the<br />

planning application detailing what pre-application consultation has been carried<br />

out and with whom. The results should therefore be written up and submitted as<br />

supporting information to the application.<br />

The government provides guidance on consultation good practice.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 27


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

6.4 Submitting a planning application<br />

LPAs encourage planning applications to be submitted electronically via the Planning<br />

Portal – www.planningportal.gov.uk<br />

A planning application fee will be payable to the LPA on submission of the application.<br />

The fees will vary according to the type of application made. Guidance can be found at<br />

the Planning Portal:<br />

When the application is submitted the LPA will go through the process of validating<br />

the applications. This involves checking the forms, plans and the planning fee to<br />

make sure the application is complete and valid. If there are any problems the<br />

application is unlikely to progress until the necessary details have been received. If<br />

the application is complete it is confirmed as valid and formally registered, given a<br />

reference number and an acknowledgement letter is sent out.<br />

6.5 Local authority consultation, planning decision & right of appeal<br />

The application is then advertised and internal/external consultations are carried<br />

out by the planning authority. The Town and Country Planning (Development<br />

Management Procedure) Order 2010 sets out the requirements to publicise and<br />

consult on planning applications. The statutory period for consultation is 21 days. The<br />

application is also made publically available, and occupiers of properties immediately<br />

adjacent to the site should be notified, giving them the opportunity to comment<br />

(if they wish). Any written comments received from the public or consultees are<br />

available for anyone to see via the authority.<br />

Energy from waste proposals are classed as a “major development” and should<br />

therefore be determined within 13 weeks or 16 weeks if an EIA is required. It is not<br />

unusual for these statutory periods to be exceeded.<br />

6.6 Community Infrastructure Levy<br />

The Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) allows local authorities in England and<br />

Wales to raise funds from developers undertaking new build projects in their<br />

area. The money can be used to fund a wide range of infrastructure that is needed<br />

as a result of the development. This includes new roads or safer road schemes,<br />

flood defences, schools, hospitals and other health and social care facilities, park<br />

improvements, green spaces, leisure centres, etc.<br />

More information about the CIL can be found via the Department for Communities<br />

and Local Government.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 28


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

6.7 Planning application decision<br />

A decision notice will be issued by the LPA to either approve or refuse the application<br />

which details the reason for the decision. Where permission is granted the decision<br />

notice will include a list of conditions with which the developer must comply. In the<br />

case of a refusal, the decision notice will include reasons for refusal.<br />

It is possible to appeal against a refusal or an unreasonable condition within 6<br />

months of the decision notice being issued. The appeal process is dealt with by the<br />

Planning Inspectorate. Guidance on the appeal system can be found at the Planning<br />

Portal.<br />

6.8 Discharge of pre-commencement planning conditions<br />

Conditions can be attached to planning permissions which are considered necessary,<br />

reasonable, enforceable and relevant to the development permitted. The LPA must<br />

give reasons when attaching conditions to consent.<br />

These could be pre-commencement conditions which require additional information<br />

to be submitted. Conditions should not be imposed which duplicate other regulatory<br />

controls, for example environmental permitting. LPAs do however sometimes impose<br />

conditions which duplicate those covered by the Environmental Permit e.g. covering<br />

details of odour or litter management.<br />

You should be aware that planning decisions can be challenged by judicial review.<br />

For a challenge to be successful the court would need to be satisfied that the local<br />

authority, Planning Inspector or Secretary of State had made an error in law e.g.<br />

misinterpreting or misapplying a policy, or failing to take account of an important<br />

consideration.<br />

The risk of judicial review can be reduced by ensuring that the planning application<br />

is prepared in line with advice received from the planning authority and statutory<br />

consultees. It may also be beneficial to have the planning application and EIA<br />

documents reviewed by a legal adviser to ensure they are legally robust.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 29


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

7.0 Health<br />

Health impacts are frequently cited in connection with proposals for <strong>EfW</strong> facilities,<br />

with the key health concern being the potential risk from emissions to air. Health<br />

protection is an inherent feature during the design, assessment and permitting of<br />

such facilities, and subject to the most stringent of environmental standards.<br />

The Health Protection Agency (HPA) provides advice on the potential impacts of <strong>EfW</strong><br />

facilities to government agencies and departments, public health professionals and<br />

members of the public. They conclude that:<br />

“while it is not possible to rule out adverse health effects from modern, well<br />

regulated municipal waste incinerators 3 with complete certainty, any potential<br />

damage to the health of those living close-by is likely to be very small, if<br />

detectable”.<br />

Modern <strong>EfW</strong> plant have a negligible impact on ambient air quality, and operate to<br />

environmental standards 4 that significantly reduce potential risks to health.<br />

7.1 Planning, permitting and health<br />

Health protection is an inherent feature of the design, assessment and permitting<br />

of <strong>EfW</strong> facilities. A key issue is the sheer weight of technical information produced,<br />

and the ability for the lay person to effectively navigate and comprehend it. As an<br />

example, due to the complex multidisciplinary nature of health, it is typically not<br />

covered under a single heading within Environmental Statements (ESs), but covered<br />

by each technical discipline (i.e. air quality, noise and vibration, transport, socioeconomics,<br />

water, etc.) to standards set to protect both the environment and human<br />

health. Health Impact Assessments (HIA), although not a regulatory requirement to<br />

the UK planning process, are increasingly commissioned to help address this issue.<br />

These draw out, signpost and build upon technical assessment outputs to more<br />

effectively convey health matters to key stakeholders and communities alike.<br />

In order to operate, <strong>EfW</strong> facilities require a permit that is issued by the EA. The EA<br />

considers permit applications through comparing the data for a proposed facility with<br />

the strict emission limits set out in the EU Waste Incineration Directive (2000/76/<br />

EC). This includes key pollutants such as nitrogen dioxide, sulphur dioxide, dioxins<br />

and total dust (including PM10s), the limits for which have been set to protect both<br />

the environment and human health. Should a permit be granted then subsequent<br />

monitoring reports must be provided to the EA to ensure ongoing compliance.<br />

Community health protection is therefore an underlying design feature for such<br />

facilities, enforced through both the regulatory planning and permitting process,<br />

and monitored by the Environment Agency.<br />

1<br />

The HPA position statement adopts a generic <strong>EfW</strong> term to cover all residual waste recovery facilities.<br />

2<br />

See WRAP guidance on WID<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 30


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

8.0 Other consents<br />

Depending on the chosen site location and its surroundings, various licences may<br />

need to be applied for or considered. Some of the consents, if required, can take a<br />

considerable time to obtain or implement. Such as:<br />

• protected species licences;<br />

• grid connection consent;<br />

• building control consent; and<br />

• environmental permit.<br />

8.1 Protected species licences<br />

A licence is required by anyone who wishes to carry out an activity prohibited under<br />

wildlife legislation. Examples which may affect a development include:<br />

• licences to carry out surveys or conservation work;<br />

• licences to disturb or damage the habitat of certain strictly protected<br />

species; and<br />

• licences to possess or keep certain wildlife.<br />

There are different types of licences for a developer, depending on the activity<br />

involved and level of risk to a particular protected species. The licences that need<br />

to be applied for relating to developers and commercial companies are listed on the<br />

Natural England website.<br />

8.3 Building control consent<br />

The building regulations apply to most building work, therefore it is important to<br />

know when approval is needed.<br />

The responsibility for checking that the Building Regulations are met falls to<br />

Building Control Bodies (BCBs) - either from the local authority or the private<br />

sector as an Approved Inspector. If you choose to use an approved inspector then<br />

you should jointly notify the local authority that the approved inspector is carrying<br />

out the building control function for the work. This notification is called an “Initial<br />

Notice”. If you choose to use a local authority, the procedures are set out in the<br />

Building Regulations. Some of them relate to pre-site procedures and others relate<br />

to procedures once work is underway on site. Further information is available at the<br />

Planning Portal website.<br />

8.4 Environmental Permit (EP)<br />

An EP must be secured from the EA in order to operate an <strong>EfW</strong> facility in England<br />

and Wales. See WRAP guidance on Environmental Permitting Regulations for more<br />

detail.<br />

8.2 Grid connection consent<br />

The connection application is the first step of the regulated process to gain a<br />

connection agreement. The connection application results in a Distribution Network<br />

Operator (DNO) offer of terms for connection. DNOs are obliged under their licence<br />

conditions to process a connection application and issue a formal connection offer<br />

within 65 working days.<br />

Planning<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 31


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Environmental<br />

Permitting<br />

Environmental Permits (EP) are required to operate<br />

an energy from waste facility within England and Wales.<br />

1.0 Environmental Permitting<br />

2.0 Waste inputs<br />

3.0 Process control<br />

4.0 Emissions to the environment<br />

5.0 Management and performance monitoring of<br />

the facility<br />

6.0 Commissioning and operation<br />

7.0 Further information<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 32


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.0 Environmental Permitting<br />

Environmental Permits (EP) are required to operate an energy from waste (<strong>EfW</strong>)<br />

facility within England and Wales 1 .<br />

They are the overarching mechanism for regulating <strong>EfW</strong> facilities and are issued<br />

by the Environment Agency (EA) or the facility’s Local Authority (LA). The facility<br />

regulator, and therefore the issuing authority, will depend upon the scale of the<br />

proposed facility and where the activity sits within the confines of the Environmental<br />

Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations (EPR) 2010. Generally, facilities<br />

accepting waste as a fuel and with a capacity in excess of 1 tonne per hour will be<br />

regulated by the EA, and anything less than this by the LA.<br />

For consistency, the term Regulating Authority is used within this guidance note to<br />

mean both the EA and LA where relevant.<br />

If you are considering operating an <strong>EfW</strong> facility you will need to consult with the<br />

appropriate regulator on the scope and extent of the EP you will require. The<br />

appropriate regulator will require a considerable amount of information about the<br />

activity you are proposing to carry out in order to grant an EP. This guidance sets<br />

out some of that information and the process you must undergo to achieve one. The<br />

Regulating Authority requires a considerable amount of information about the activity<br />

you are proposing to carry out in order to grant an EP.<br />

For consistency, this document makes reference to ‘combustion’ and ‘combustion<br />

conditions’ when describing the process under which waste is thermally degraded,<br />

with or without the presence of oxygen, or to generate gases that are subsequently<br />

processed to generate energy. It is recognised that not all thermal treatment<br />

processes are combustion. However, to ensure consistency with Environment Agency<br />

Technical Guidance Notes, which also make the above distinction, combustion and<br />

combustion conditions are used when referencing the thermal breakdown of waste<br />

and the design conditions which lead to the thermal breakdown of such wastes.<br />

1<br />

EPs are issued in Scotland exclusively by SEPA and in Northern Ireland by NIEA.<br />

2<br />

Apply to the EA via http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/business/topics/permitting/32318.aspx or<br />

contact your Local Authority. Fuel usage of over one tonne per hour will require an EA permit, less than<br />

1 tonne per hour an LA permit.<br />

1.1 What is an Environmental Permit <br />

An EP is a permit to operate a facility governed by the requirements of the<br />

Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2010 (EPR). The<br />

regulations cover a range of types of facilities including waste management facilities<br />

such as recycling and recovery facilities and <strong>EfW</strong>.<br />

The EPR were introduced into UK law within England and Wales in 2007 and<br />

combined the Pollution Prevention and Control Regulations and the Waste<br />

Management Licensing Regulations, thereby introducing one environmental<br />

regulation system that covers all aspects of environmental regulation. In 2010 the<br />

EPR were further updated to include water discharges and groundwater activities,<br />

radioactive substances and provisions for a number of other Directives such as the<br />

Mining Waste Directive.<br />

The principal aims of the EPR are to:<br />

• bring Environmental Regulation across England and Wales onto a level playing<br />

field;<br />

• provide protection for the environment by controlling and regulating pollution<br />

control and emissions to air, water and land; and<br />

• emphasise the polluter pays mechanism by making operators liable for the<br />

condition of the land on which they operate.<br />

The EPR introduced a tiered approach to environmental regulation based on the<br />

potential risk to the environment of the proposed activities. Authorisations can be in<br />

the form of registered exemptions; standard rules EPs and bespoke EPs. Exemptions<br />

cover those activities at the lowest risk end of the spectrum while bespoke EPs will<br />

cover higher risk activities - see Section 7 for further information on permit levels.<br />

All <strong>EfW</strong> activities require an EP so operators will need to apply to the relevant<br />

Regulating Authority for an appropriate authorisation 2 . The permit will have<br />

conditions which must be followed to prevent business activities from harming the<br />

environment or human health.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 33


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.2 What are the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2010<br />

The EPR 2007 brought into force the first phase of the Environment Agency’s<br />

environmental permitting system and established a common permitting programme.<br />

The EPR 2010 brought into force the bulk of the second phase of environmental<br />

permitting and extended this common permitting system to cover a wider range of<br />

permitted activities and exemptions 3 .<br />

1.3 Who needs an Environmental Permit<br />

You must have an EP if your business carries out any activity or operation that is<br />

covered by the term Regulated Facility within the context of the EPR. This includes all<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> facilities, but in addition:<br />

• any ‘waste operation’, including waste activities which are technically linked and<br />

could include the treatment and storage of waste, e.g. MRF or waste derived fuel<br />

processer;<br />

• a ‘mobile plant’ used to carry out a waste operation;<br />

• a ‘water discharge activity’; or<br />

• a ‘groundwater activity’.<br />

1.4 Who can apply for an Environmental Permit<br />

The person /organisation in charge of the day to day operation of the facility will be<br />

the ‘Operator’ and therefore will be the person required to apply for the EP<br />

(see footnote 2 re: how to apply for a permit).<br />

3<br />

Environmental Permitting now governs the regulation of facilities that were previously regulated under<br />

the Pollution Prevention and Control Regulations 2000, the Waste Management Licensing Regulations<br />

1994 & its associated Waste Exemptions Scheme, the discharge consenting requirements of the Water<br />

Resources Act 1991, the Radioactive Substances Act 1993 and the Groundwater Regulations 2009.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 34


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.0 Waste inputs<br />

2.1 What controls can a permit set with regards to waste inputs<br />

EPs set controls on the operation of a facility with regards to the throughput, storage<br />

and types of wastes that can be accepted.<br />

Varying levels of control apply to <strong>EfW</strong> with regards to the nature of the waste<br />

proposed to be utilised as the plant fuel. Facilities can accept both hazardous and<br />

non-hazardous waste. However, it is common practice for facilities to be dedicated<br />

to one or the other and given that this guidance is aimed at non-hazardous facilities,<br />

further consideration of hazardous waste facilities is not provided herein.<br />

The major controlling factor on the acceptability of fuel types at an <strong>EfW</strong> facility is the<br />

ability of the fuel to meet the design criteria for the facility and therefore provide the<br />

appropriate technical, economic and environmental fuel mix for the plant 4 . As part of<br />

the EP application process operators will be required to provide detailed calculations<br />

about the net calorific value and chemical composition of the proposed fuel.<br />

2.2 What waste is typically acceptable at <strong>EfW</strong> facilities<br />

The typical waste stream for most current <strong>EfW</strong> facilities is ‘residual waste’, which<br />

is that fraction remaining following the removal of recyclables, either by source<br />

segregation or separation at a treatment facility, such as a MRF.<br />

Typically, the waste is generated by the municipal sector for large scale, local<br />

authority contracted facilities, topped up with wastes from the commercial and<br />

industrial sectors of a similar nature (i.e. office waste).<br />

The EP application needs to include a list of proposed waste for acceptance at the<br />

facility based on the European Waste Catalogue (EWC) code list of wastes.<br />

Smaller scale facilities that do not have the capacity to manage large local authority<br />

contracts are generally operated utilising commercial and industrial wastes of<br />

a similar nature to household wastes, with some facilities aimed specifically at<br />

individual waste types (e.g. waste biomass).<br />

4<br />

See forthcoming WRAP “A classification system to define the quality of waste derived fuels”.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 35


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

3.0 Process control<br />

3.1 What are process controls<br />

Within your EP application you will be required to provide a full description of the<br />

proposed process that will be carried out at the facility. This will include details of<br />

each of the controls to be in place to manage and mitigate the activities on site i.e.<br />

how the flow of waste through the process is controlled to ensure that complete<br />

combustion 5 of the waste stream is achieved and how the fuel is regularised to<br />

ensure a homogenous blend of waste types for calorific value consolidation.<br />

Your EP will set limits for emissions to air, land and water, where relevant. In order<br />

to set suitable limits it is essential that the proposed process to be adopted is<br />

understood and assessed to provide a full understanding of the potential impacts of<br />

the process.<br />

If such identified impacts are considered unacceptable then the Relevant Authority<br />

may require further process controls/evidence of process controls.<br />

When defining process controls, operators are required to take into account technical<br />

compliance standards for their sector as laid out in the European BAT Reference<br />

Documents 6 (BREF’s). These documents set out the accepted/proven methodologies<br />

for pollution control in accordance with the principals of Best Available Techniques<br />

(BAT), as defined by:<br />

• best – means the most effective techniques for achieving a high level of<br />

protection of the environment as a whole;<br />

• available – means techniques developed on a scale which allows them to be<br />

used in the relevant industrial sector, under economically and technically viable<br />

conditions, taking into account the costs and advantages; and<br />

• techniques – includes both the technology and the way the installation is<br />

designed, built, maintained, operated and decommissioned.<br />

From the start of the application process, through the commissioning phase and<br />

throughout operation the operator will need to consider the most appropriate BAT<br />

process controls for their facility.<br />

3.2 Use of raw materials on site<br />

As part of your EP conditions you will be required to keep a record of the raw<br />

materials stored and used on site to demonstrate that you are complying with<br />

appropriate legislation and have adequate risk mitigation measures in place to<br />

manage such materials.<br />

3.3 Interactions with other legislation<br />

Where <strong>EfW</strong> facilities accept waste classified as animal by-products, they are required<br />

to also gain approval under the Animal By-Products Regulations 2011 (ABPR).<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> facilities that only process animal carcasses, or parts of carcasses are exempt<br />

from the WID and are instead regulated by the ABPR. However, plants which process<br />

other types of ABP, such as former foodstuffs, catering waste and manure must be<br />

authorised under the Waste Incineration Directive (WID) 7 .<br />

If more than 1 tonne per hour of ABP is processed, approval is via the EA in England<br />

- less than 1 tonne per hour would require approval through the LA.<br />

5<br />

See Appendix 1 for ‘Environment Agency Technical Guidance Note’ definition of combustion.<br />

6<br />

European Commission Joint Research Centre: http://eippcb.jrc.es/reference<br />

7<br />

See WRAP guidance on WID.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 36


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

4.0 Emissions to the environment<br />

4.1 What emissions are covered<br />

There are two types of emissions that are regulated by the Relevant Authority under<br />

the EPR. These are point source emissions and fugitive emissions.<br />

Point source emissions are single, identifiable, localised emissions to air, water or<br />

land, (such as a stack or a discharge consent to surface water), whereas fugitive<br />

emissions are the diffuse emissions generated as part of the operation of the facility<br />

and can also be to air, water or land (e.g. traffic fumes or dust).<br />

4.2 Emissions to air<br />

In general, <strong>EfW</strong> facilities will generate point source emissions to air (e.g. stack<br />

emissions) and potentially fugitive emissions to air (e.g. dust/odour). The EP is used<br />

to regulate such emissions.<br />

For fugitive emissions, permits generally contain conditions to reduce as far as<br />

practically possible the impacts of any such emissions and in the case of odour,<br />

may require the operator to maintain a management plan detailing the risks and<br />

mitigation measures identified to manage those risks.<br />

Increasingly, operators are also being required to maintain Management Plans for<br />

the control of fugitive emissions of dust both on and off the site. These Management<br />

Plans are also required to consider the potential fire risk caused by dust build up<br />

within operational areas.<br />

For point source emissions to air, operators are generally required to submit<br />

evidence of impacts from the emissions, in the form of air quality assessments and<br />

models to demonstrate that the proposed operation will not have a negative impact<br />

on sensitive locations surrounding the site.<br />

Additionally, the Air Quality Assessment will be required to demonstrate that the<br />

proposed facility can meet the required emission limit values (ELV’s) as defined by<br />

WID for emissions to air from stacks. These ELV’s will be included within the EP<br />

as conditions of operation and the facility will not be permitted to discharge to air<br />

concentrations in excess of the ELV’s set. ELV’s will be set for several key substances<br />

and at a range of operational periods (i.e. 30 minute average/daily average etc).<br />

4.3 Emissions to water<br />

Where facilities are proposing to discharge to either surface water or groundwater,<br />

they will require permission to discharge from the Relevant Authority. This<br />

permission can usually be incorporated into the Environmental Permit.<br />

In accordance with the requirements of the Groundwater Directive, there are<br />

restrictions in place on the type and volume of emissions that can be discharged to<br />

groundwater, and the Relevant Authority will instigate the limits.<br />

Permission to abstract either surface water or groundwater will need to be acquired<br />

from the Environment Agency, where proposed, but cannot be included within the<br />

Environmental Permit. Discharges to foul sewer will need to be applied for directly<br />

from the appropriate Waste Water Treatment Company.<br />

4.4 Emissions to land<br />

Where the <strong>EfW</strong> facility is proposing to send waste products (e.g. incinerator bottom<br />

ash and/or activated powdered carbon residues) to landfill, the type and quantities<br />

of such emissions will be closely monitored by the Environment Agency in order to<br />

ensure that appropriate facilities are used for the type of waste produced.<br />

5<br />

See page 1 for ‘Environment Agency Technical Guidance Note’ definition of combustion.<br />

6<br />

European Commission Joint Research Centre: http://eippcb.jrc.es/reference<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 37


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

5.0 Management and performance<br />

monitoring of the facility<br />

5.1 Environmental Management Systems (EMS)<br />

Operators of <strong>EfW</strong> facilities are required to operate within the confines of an<br />

Environmental Management System. Systems such as the ISO14001 Standard for<br />

EMS are considered by the Environment Agency to provide the greatest level of<br />

environmental management as well as ensuring that operators review performance<br />

on an ongoing basis.<br />

Generally EMS’s will incorporate site procedures and policies for the management of<br />

the operations, and as such usually cover areas including:<br />

• staff training;<br />

• management structure;<br />

• facility energy consumption and generation;<br />

• use of raw materials, including waste and water;<br />

• key performance indicators;<br />

• Accident Management Plan 8 and reporting; and<br />

• technically competent management.<br />

In England, waste facility managers are required to demonstrate that they are<br />

technically competent by complying with the requirements of the Waste Management<br />

Industry Training and Advisory Board’s (WAMITAB) technically competent<br />

management scheme 9 .<br />

5.2 Performance monitoring<br />

As part of the EP monitoring requirements operators will need to monitor and record<br />

their performance including the total amounts of energy consumed and generated at<br />

the site, the water utilisation at the site, including volumes of any water discharged<br />

and the volumes of other raw materials consumed.<br />

Performance data will be collected over differing timescales for different<br />

environmental aspects. For example some air quality monitoring will be continuous<br />

for certain stack emissions whereas groundwater/surface water monitoring, where<br />

required, can be undertaken at monthly frequencies or less. Annual performance<br />

reporting is required to be submitted to the Relevant Authority at the start of the<br />

calendar year and will include a full evaluation of all site monitoring data. Site waste<br />

acceptance/removal data will be required to be submitted to the Environment Agency<br />

on a quarterly basis, by the end of the first month of the next reporting quarter (i.e.<br />

Q1 to be reported by the end of April).<br />

As such it is essential that any EMS in place at the facility captures all of the<br />

performance reporting requirements and therefore manages the monitoring and<br />

reporting of these items.<br />

It will also be necessary for operators to review the sustainable operation of the<br />

facility with reference to continual improvement against any key performance<br />

indicators set e.g. use of water on site, as well as demonstrating energy efficiency<br />

within the site’s operations across the facility.<br />

8<br />

The presence of a site Accident Management Plan and method for reporting of incidents is required<br />

as part of the Environmental Permit. The scope of the Accident Management Plan needs to include all<br />

potential accidents /incidents that could occur within the permit boundary.<br />

9<br />

http://www.wamitab.org.uk/pg/competence/technical-competence-arrangements-in-england-and-wales-<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 38


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

6.0 Commissioning and operation<br />

As part of the EP application process the operator will have had to describe in<br />

detail the process to be carried out on site, including the mitigation measures<br />

designed to ensure the facility does not breach its EP conditions. During initial<br />

commissioning (section 6.1) the operator will need to operate the facility in order to<br />

test these process controls and provide updates/reports to the Relevant Authority<br />

on the progress of the commissioning. It is considered best practice to produce<br />

a Commissioning Plan detailing the key milestones and anticipated completion<br />

timescales for these so that progress can be measured.<br />

Once commissioning is complete and the facility is ready to become permanently<br />

operational, all of the relevant Pre-Operational Conditions as set out in the EP must<br />

have been completed.<br />

6.1 Commissioning<br />

The construction phase of the plant is followed by the commissioning stage. This<br />

is the process by which the facility is tested to verify it functions according to its<br />

design objectives or specifications. The commissioning stage brings the plant up to<br />

operating condition for the first time so as to measure the various parameters which<br />

are monitored during operation.<br />

The various factors considered during this stage include:<br />

• validation: the combustion conditions set at the design stage will need to be<br />

monitored at all stages to ensure they meet the required emission limits;<br />

• emissions: air pollutants including Nitrogen Oxides (NOx), Carbon Monoxide<br />

(CO), total dust, Total Organic Carbon (TOC), Hydrogen Chloride (HCl), Hydrogen<br />

Fluoride (HF), Sulphur Dioxide (SO2), heavy metals and dioxins are continuously<br />

monitored to determine the amount of abatement material to be used for<br />

meeting the limit values in WID during the operational phase. Water emissions<br />

are monitored for possible pollutants and the operator will conduct a continuous<br />

monitoring of residence time, minimum temperature and oxygen content of the<br />

exhaust gas in the furnace; efficiency of operational equipment: the performance<br />

of various industrial equipment is tested against the performance guaranteed by<br />

the technology provider. The performance is tracked against the cost estimate;<br />

• work plan: a work plan is prepared following the identification of commissioning<br />

systems and the scheduled commissioning activities are executed during this<br />

stage;<br />

• start-up efficiency: the design requirements of the plant are identified and<br />

improved during this stage to enable an efficient start-up;<br />

• guidance to operators: the operating procedures of the plant are provided to the<br />

operators and guidance on training processes is defined; and<br />

• noise monitoring: noise monitoring is carried out at this stage and the location,<br />

time, frequency and methods of noise monitoring will be as agreed in the<br />

Environmental Permit issued by the Regulatory Agency.<br />

6.2 Operation<br />

The commissioning phase of the plant is followed by the operational phase. The <strong>EfW</strong><br />

operations will be carried out in accordance with Section 5.1A (2)(c) in Schedule 1 of<br />

the EPR 2010.<br />

During the operational phase, the operator should ensure the following:<br />

• validation: as for the commissioning stage, the combustion conditions are<br />

monitored throughout the delivery to ensure they meet the limits set for the<br />

operational stage. The gas generated by the processing of wastes must be kept<br />

above 850˚C for a minimum of 2 seconds to comply with WID. Emissions from the<br />

plant should not exceed the continuous/periodic emission limits, as described in<br />

Annex II and Annex V of WID;<br />

• measurement: conduct measurement of the noise and vibration of the facility as<br />

mentioned in the noise and vibration plan in the permit; and<br />

• records: keep a record of all the monitoring carried out which includes taking<br />

and analysing samples, instrument measurement (periodic and continual),<br />

calibrations, examinations, tests and surveys and any assessment or evaluation<br />

made on the basis of such data.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 39


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

7.0 Further information<br />

7.1 What types of Environmental Permits can I apply for<br />

There are three levels of environmental authorisation that operators can apply for:<br />

exemptions, Standard Rules EPs and Bespoke EPs.<br />

7.1.1 Exemptions<br />

Exemptions to Environmental Permitting are authorisations under the requirements<br />

of the EPR that cover those activities that are considered to represent the lowest<br />

level of risk to the environment and human health in the context of the EPR. These do<br />

not require a full EP but they do need to be registered by the EA.<br />

7.1.2 Standard Rules Environmental Permits<br />

Standard Rules Environmental Permits are issued by the Environment Agency and<br />

contain fixed conditions for operators. These permits also contain fixed compliance<br />

requirements that operators must confirm that their facilities will comply with (i.e.<br />

proximity to dwellings etc).<br />

7.1.3 Bespoke Environmental Permits<br />

Bespoke Environmental Permits are site specific permits which require full site<br />

specific risk assessment and consideration. These permits cover those activities<br />

considered to represent the highest level of risk to the environment and human<br />

health and include energy from waste installations.<br />

7.2 Do I need to pay for an Environmental Permit<br />

Yes. The Relevant Authority aims to make the level of regulatory effort, and therefore<br />

the charges that it levies, proportionate to the environmental risk of the permitted<br />

activity. The EA does this via its Operational Risk Appraisal scheme (Opra) 10 . The level<br />

of risk and therefore the required regulation is divided into three charging tiers - the<br />

greater the perceived level of risk of the activity, the greater the regulatory effort<br />

required by the Environment Agency and therefore the higher the charging tier.<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> plant will almost always come under Tier 3 and will therefore require full Opra<br />

assessment to ascertain the cost of the EP.<br />

Local Authority EP charges are set annually by Defra and are generally lower than EA<br />

charges (see footnote 2 to determine if you will need an EA permit or LA permit).<br />

7.3 Where can I get further information<br />

Further information on environmental permitting can be found at the following links:-<br />

http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/business/topics/permitting/default.aspx<br />

http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/quality/permitting/<br />

A copy of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2010 can be<br />

found at the following link:-<br />

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukdsi/2010/9780111491423/contents<br />

10<br />

http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/business/regulation/31827.aspx<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

Planning regulations Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 40


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Feedstock<br />

Guidance on the issues which will affect the accessibility,<br />

security and suitability of waste materials as fuel for<br />

energy from waste processes<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

2.0 Feedstock types<br />

3.0 Fuel preparation<br />

4.0 Feedstock security<br />

5.0 Further information<br />

Feedstock<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Outputs<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 41


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

This guidance examines the variables and properties of waste derived fuel materials,<br />

how they can influence the type of processing technology chosen and the different<br />

outputs.<br />

The characteristics of the waste feedstock and its variability are key parameters<br />

when determining which technology will be the most suitable for the <strong>EfW</strong> proposal.<br />

Understanding the composition and variation in the potential feedstocks/fuels will<br />

help operators select the right <strong>EfW</strong> technology, plant design and determine the<br />

overall energy efficiency that is achievable.<br />

A consideration of the potential waste feedstocks which will be available and suitable<br />

for the proposed energy from waste (<strong>EfW</strong>) facility is a key aspect of the development<br />

of the business case for a proposal 1 . A process designed to utilise waste biogenic<br />

content or a processed Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) would suffer operational problems<br />

if suddenly faced with unsorted Commercial and Industrial (C&I) wastes or material<br />

heavily contaminated with food rich material.<br />

The overriding objective of the waste hierarchy is to drive material up the hierarchy<br />

as far as is possible, when it is possible, so as to maximise the potential to divert<br />

waste from landfill. The remaining waste, following recycling, re-use and composting,<br />

should then be managed in recovery facilities such as an <strong>EfW</strong>. These facilities have a<br />

key role to play within the hierarchy to divert residual waste from landfill.<br />

2.0 Feedstock types<br />

The characteristics of the waste feedstock and its variability are key parameters to<br />

examine when determining which technology would be the most suitable for the<br />

proposed facility. The feasibility assessment will need to include a detailed analysis<br />

of the physical and chemical characteristics of the feedstock. Understanding the<br />

composition and variation in the feedstock will help select the right <strong>EfW</strong> technology<br />

at the plant design stage. This will need to be reviewed over the life of the contract<br />

as feedstock composition may change. The larger mass burn technologies are less<br />

sensitive to variations in feedstock, but the smaller-scale, more efficient processes<br />

such as gasification and pyrolysis, are much more sensitive to fuel change, generally<br />

requiring pre-treatment of feedstock.<br />

The physical and chemical properties of the waste can have an impact on the energy<br />

efficiency, operation and emissions of an <strong>EfW</strong> facility, as can factors such as moisture<br />

content, ash content and bulk density. Variety in these factors will define that fuel<br />

and its end usage, and lead to its determination as one of a number of pre-defined<br />

Waste Derived Fuels. Generally, they would be classed under one of the following<br />

headings, due to the factors listed beside them.<br />

Generic fuel type<br />

‘RDF’ – Refuse<br />

Derived Fuel<br />

Biogenic content<br />

‘SRF’ – Solid<br />

Recovered Fuel<br />

Typical calorific<br />

value<br />

10-12 Mj/Kg<br />

15-18 Mj/Kg<br />

18-22 Mj/Kg<br />

Defining factor<br />

Residual material left over following the<br />

separation of recyclable materials in a MRF,<br />

Mechanical Biological Treatments (MBT) or<br />

transfer station<br />

General woody waste material, including<br />

forestry thinnings, joinery waste and clean<br />

or treated wood products<br />

A processed material specifically targeted<br />

for the higher CV fraction of the waste.<br />

Commonly used in cement kiln operations<br />

10<br />

See WRAP guidance on Feasibility and Good Practice<br />

Feedstock<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Outputs<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 42


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

3.0 Fuel preparation<br />

The feedstock may require further processing before it can be thermally treated in<br />

some of the technologies. For instance, some machinery which pyrolyses wood chip<br />

requires the chip to be of a certain and consistent size. The type of fuel preparation<br />

techniques used would depend on the input fuel and the <strong>EfW</strong> technology being used,<br />

but some commonly used fuel preparation techniques include:<br />

• Sorting. Either manual sorting or mechanical sorting in order to identify and<br />

remove any metals, rigid plastics, other recyclable materials or unusable<br />

contaminated materials which aren’t wanted within the fuel. Mechanical sorting<br />

techniques can include over-band magnets, density separators, infra-red optical<br />

scanners or wind blowing sifters.<br />

• Crushing or shredding. This reduces the material to a standard, general, or<br />

given size or can be used to homogenise the physical characteristics.<br />

• Screening. Screens (rotating drum screens, oscillating screens, star screens,<br />

etc.) can help remove aggregates or soil products from the feedstock, leaving a<br />

more usable, higher CV material to make up the fuel.<br />

• Washing. Removes contaminants stuck to the material.<br />

• Drying. Reduces moisture content.<br />

• Homogenisation. Generally the final stage in fuel preparation, these are<br />

processes designed to bulk the material, assist in its transport and storage<br />

or to present the fuel in a certain manner e.g. mixing, blending, compacting,<br />

pelletising or baling.<br />

4.0 Feedstock security<br />

The whole process in setting up an <strong>EfW</strong> facility from concept, feasibility, design,<br />

commissioning to operation represents a significant capital investment over a long<br />

period of time. A cost benefit analysis needs to demonstrate to funders that sufficient<br />

suitable waste feedstock is available over that period to ensure the facility can run<br />

at or near capacity and generate the revenues or savings expected. Developers<br />

will therefore need to demonstrate feedstock security and consider any changes<br />

to their business that might impact on the quantity or composition of the waste<br />

feedstock they use. In some circumstances, it may be found that numerous <strong>EfW</strong><br />

facilities in a small, concentrated area would lead to those facilities competing for<br />

waste feedstocks. This could lead to higher values for the fuels as the plants are<br />

prepared to pay more for the material (or reduce their gate fees) in order to continue<br />

operation. The signing of long term contracts or other business relationships<br />

such as partnerships, joint ventures, vertical integration, etc., can go a long way to<br />

guaranteeing fuel security and feedstock availability.<br />

Feedstock<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Outputs<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 43


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

5.0 Further information<br />

The WRATE (Waste and Resources Assessment Tool for the Environment) can be used<br />

to provide feedstock information useful for determining information for electricity<br />

generation e.g. the moisture content, calorific value, carbon and biogenic carbon<br />

content.<br />

www.environment-agency.gov.uk/research/commercial/102927.aspx<br />

BS EN 15440:2011 – ‘Solid recovered fuels. Methods for the determination of biomass<br />

content’ lists methods to determine the carbonaceous element of the solid recovered<br />

fuel. The biogenic content is required if renewable energy incentive payments are<br />

to be claimed. ROCs or RHI can only be paid on the biogenic element of the fuel, so<br />

plastics for instance will not count toward those payment levels. The determination of<br />

the biogenic element is therefore vital for a number of reasons. This document must<br />

be purchased from the BSi website.<br />

http://shop.bsigroup.com/en/ProductDetail/pid=000000000030255009<br />

Phyllis is a European database able to provide analysis data and information on the<br />

composition of wastes. Available for individual wastes or for a combination of wastes,<br />

it can provide historic data on samples previously analysed and the results stored. It<br />

can provide ultimate analysis (carbon, nitrogen, fluorine, etc), proximate analysis (ash<br />

content, moisture content, etc) biological composition, metal content etc. for a range<br />

of waste materials, grouped into different types.<br />

http://www.ecn.nl/phyllis/info.asp<br />

Feedstock<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Outputs<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 44


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> Outputs<br />

and Residues<br />

1.0 Energy from waste outputs<br />

2.0 Energy from waste residues<br />

Guidance on the management of energy outputs and<br />

residues including air pollution control residues and<br />

incinerator bottom ash<br />

Outputs<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 45


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.0 Energy from waste outputs<br />

The choice of technology, fuel and plant design will generate varying quantities of<br />

energy output and residual material at the end of the treatment process. Operators<br />

will need to consider and evaluate the following within the business case for their<br />

chosen <strong>EfW</strong> technology:<br />

• electricity production;<br />

• heat or cooling potential;<br />

• syngas production,<br />

• management of the outputs and waste residues; and<br />

• current and future markets.<br />

1.1 Electricity production<br />

The most common output from <strong>EfW</strong> facilities will be heat to drive a steam cycle,<br />

which drives a turbine, spinning a magnet against a wire coil to produce electricity.<br />

This will most often be sold to the National Grid, although some facilities will sell<br />

their electricity output directly to industrial users. Electricity produced in this manner<br />

will qualify for ROCs payments 1 for the biogenic fraction of the fuel input 2 .<br />

1.2 Heat production or cooling<br />

1.3 Combined Heat and Power (CHP)<br />

Operators may also want to consider an assessment for potential combined heat<br />

and power (CHP) where electricity is produced as in section 1.1, and then the waste<br />

heat is captured and re-used in a manner similar to section 1.2. This increases the<br />

efficiency of the thermal process significantly. Operators also have the option to<br />

consider exporting the heat to an alternative end market. For example, heat can be<br />

used to generate cooling through a heat exchange system for refrigeration processes.<br />

Heat, steam or cooling energy is relatively complex to export to off-takers and is<br />

dependent on the location and reliability of a suitable consumer. The installation and<br />

management of a network of insulated pipes can considerably increase the cost of a<br />

development.<br />

1.4 Transport Fuels<br />

Although markets are minimal at present, the production of transport fuels from<br />

waste is a technically feasible process garnering much interest on a global stage.<br />

Fuels from unrecyclable plastics, for instance, could help address both landfill and<br />

energy issues. Fossil based plastics, derived from oil, can be broken down into their<br />

constituent elements in order to be refined and processed into diesel fuels.<br />

Industrial users may want to consider producing their own heat by utilising their<br />

own wastes to produce their own fuels. This can provide direct heat for industrial<br />

processes, thereby reducing the dependence on fossil fuels and reducing fossil<br />

carbon releases. Heat produced in this manner could be eligible for incentive<br />

payments under the RHI 3 .<br />

1<br />

See WRAP guidance on Incentives<br />

2<br />

See WRAP guidance on Fuel and Feedstocks<br />

3<br />

See WRAP guidance on Incentives<br />

Outputs<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 46


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.0 Energy from waste residues<br />

Thermal treatment processes do not destroy material. Fuel input is converted, via<br />

an exothermic chemical reaction, to break the bonds of atoms within the fuel and<br />

release certain elements and compounds (e.g. hydrogen, methane, and carbon<br />

monoxide). These chemical compounds can then be combusted to produce heat.<br />

Inevitably, there are compounds which are not usable in this manner and which will<br />

produce wastes and residues. The residues will generally be ashes, aggregates and<br />

particles within the flue gases (see section 2.1). Some of these can be recovered<br />

and recycled and others need to be disposed of in a landfill. Gasification and<br />

pyrolysis processes typically produce a syngas (see Section 2.4), an oil and a solid<br />

char residue. During the plant design process provision should be made within the<br />

site infrastructure for storage of the residues, as well as their treatment, removal,<br />

transport and disposal. Developers should consider how these will be managed<br />

either at the site or taken off site for further recovery or disposal. Operators should<br />

consider the quantities and costs of managing all the outputs and residues within a<br />

recovery plan.<br />

2.1 Fly ash and air pollution control (APC) residues<br />

Fly ash and APC residues are the by-products of the flue gas cleaning process and<br />

are commonly combined. These wastes can become a dust hazard and operators<br />

will need to put in place specific arrangements for their storage, handling and<br />

transportation. APC residue is typically a mixture of ash, carbon and lime. It is a<br />

hazardous waste which is currently disposed of at a hazardous waste landfill or<br />

undergoes further processing such as washing or stabilisation to send to a nonhazardous<br />

landfill. Fly ash, which is a lighter weight ash, can be recovered and used<br />

in a manufacturing process, such as cement manufacture.<br />

2.2 Incinerator bottom ash (IBA)<br />

Following the combustion process non-combustible ash of varying particle size is<br />

produced, often containing mineral material and metals. The ash which falls to the<br />

bottom of the process is typically dry and dusty and operators will need to ensure that<br />

it is appropriately stored in covered containers to prevent emissions to air. Operators<br />

will need to consider dust suppression, containment, transport and recovery or<br />

disposal options. An ‘Incinerator Bottom Ash Quality Protocol’ is currently being<br />

considered through the Waste Protocols project, in an attempt to define an end-ofwaste<br />

point for the material, therefore allowing its further use as, for instance, an<br />

aggregate replacement.<br />

Current waste data shows that over half a million tonnes of IBA goes to landfill each<br />

year in England and Wales. However, as recovery processes have improved this<br />

material can now be processed and recycled back into applications such as aggregate<br />

replacement for sub base road construction, bulk fill, concrete block manufacture or<br />

concrete grouting.<br />

The IBA aggregate produced from municipal waste contains glass, brick, stone,<br />

concrete, ceramics and fused clinker. Processed IBA can comply with EN and<br />

British Standards and the aggregate product has been shown to exhibit engineering<br />

properties which are similar to natural aggregates. Across the UK established<br />

markets for IBA are now opening up which are replacing primary, virgin aggregates<br />

with processed IBA in specific civil engineering applications.<br />

The Highways Agency has been accepting processed incinerator bottom ash (IBA)<br />

as an aggregate in bound and unbound layers in road construction where it meets<br />

aggregate requirements.<br />

Outputs<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 47


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.3 Products and residues from thermal processes<br />

The types of residues will be dependent on the waste fuel used, its composition<br />

and quantity. A modern municipal waste incinerator will typically produce IBA at<br />

around 25% of the input mass. There may also be rejected feedstocks and recovered<br />

waste fractions such as ferrous metals. Operators should separate these two waste<br />

streams (usually with an overband magnet) in order to recycle and recover them.<br />

New processes are being driven by industry such as plasma arc gasification which<br />

utilises an electrically powered plasma stream to raise the temperature to 1500˚C.<br />

This process releases releases a syngas and additionally vitrifies the waste remnants<br />

to provide a safe, stable by product, which can be used as an aggregate replacement.<br />

2.4 Syngas, tars, char and ash<br />

Advanced Conversion Technologies (ACTs) such as gasification and pyrolysis produce<br />

what is known as syngas. This typically consists of hydrogen, methane and carbon<br />

monoxide which can be combusted or turned into a fuel to run a turbine to generate<br />

electricity. Another by-product of ACTs is char, which can be recovered from the<br />

residue and used as a fuel. The tars, char and ash can also be processed for use in<br />

the petrochemical industry and in concrete or asphalt applications. The gases and<br />

oils produced by ACT can be combusted in an engine, gas turbine or boiler to produce<br />

electricity and or heat. Alternatively they can be further processed into a liquid fuel<br />

which can be stored, transported and refined.<br />

Outputs<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Guide<br />

page 48


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Financial incentives<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

2.0 Types of incentives available<br />

Guidance on the financial incentives currently<br />

available to support renewable energy generation<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Feedstock Outputs Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 49


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.0 Introduction<br />

This guidance note details the range of financial incentives currently available to<br />

assist companies in the development of energy from waste facilities e.g. Renewable<br />

Obligation Certificates (ROCs), or Renewable Heat Incentive payments (RHI).<br />

Understanding the potential of financial incentives can prove vital when evaluating<br />

the economic viability of a project and can help construct the feasibility and business<br />

case stages 1 . For example, ROCs payments for electricity generation could prove<br />

to be the deciding factor between a successful project or a loss-making one.<br />

RHI payments could displace the usage of thousands of tonnes of fossil fuels by<br />

promoting the direct utilisation of heat from biogenic content. Exemption from the<br />

Climate Change Levy could prove the deciding factor for moving to renewable energy<br />

generation. However, caution should be advised regarding over-reliance on securing<br />

incentives, some of which may be subject to change prior to facilities coming online<br />

and many of which have review periods planned where values could fall.<br />

To help meet the UK’s target of 15% of the total energy generation from renewable<br />

sources by 2020, a number of financial incentive mechanisms were introduced to<br />

encourage the uptake of renewable energy in the UK (excluding Northern Ireland).<br />

Their purpose was to ‘bridge the gap’ between the cost of the often more expensive<br />

renewable projects when compared to traditional fossil fuel based energy generation.<br />

Due to the varying cost of the different technologies (<strong>EfW</strong>, biomass, on-shore/offshore<br />

wind, etc), different ‘bands’ of payments were introduced, dependent upon<br />

the technology used and the size of the project. As technologies become more<br />

affordable and the requirement for incentives reduces, they are moved from one band<br />

to another and the value of the payments reduce accordingly.<br />

As financial incentive payments could contribute a significant proportion of income<br />

from a project, those that could be secured by the project should be considered at the<br />

feasibility stage 2 . A summary of the current incentives available is provided below.<br />

However as incentive schemes are revised and additional schemes introduced to<br />

meet market demands, it is always worth researching the latest incentive schemes to<br />

ensure the most up to date information is accessed.<br />

Figure 1: Available incentives<br />

Renewable<br />

energy<br />

incentives<br />

Heat<br />

Electricity<br />

Combined Heat and Power Quality Assurance Schemes<br />

(CHPQA)<br />

Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI)<br />

Feed-In Tariffs (FITs)<br />

The Enhanced Capital allowance Scheme (ECA)<br />

Climate Change Levy (CCL)<br />

Combined Heat and Power Quality Assurance Schemes<br />

(CHPQA)<br />

Feed-In Tariffs (FITs)<br />

Renewable Obligation Certificates (ROCs)<br />

(CHPQA Only)<br />

The Enhanced Capital allowance Scheme (ECA)<br />

Climate Change Levy (CCL)<br />

The following paragraphs look at each technology in turn and the financial incentives<br />

which would currently apply.<br />

1<br />

See WRAP Guidance on Feasibility and Good Practice.<br />

2<br />

See WRAP Guidance on Feasibility and Good Practice.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Feedstock Outputs Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 50


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.0 Types of incentives available<br />

2.1 Combined heat and power quality assurance schemes (CHPQA)<br />

Combined heat and power (CHP) facilities utilising waste derived fuels (WDF)<br />

can apply for a number of incentives if they are compliant with the CHPQA. These<br />

incentives include Enhanced Capital Allowances (ECAs), the Climate Change Levy<br />

(CCL) exemption and Renewable Obligation Certificates (ROCs). The ECA and CCL do<br />

not currently have an end date whereas the Renewable Obligation (RO) was initially<br />

introduced as a 25 year instrument ending in 2027. In 2010 this was extended for 10<br />

years for new projects and the RO is now scheduled to end in 2037. These incentives<br />

are described in greater detail below.<br />

Good quality CHP is defined under the CHPQA scheme. This provides a methodology<br />

for assessing the quality of CHP schemes in terms of the energy efficiency and<br />

environmental performance of the plant. To comply with ‘good quality’ the threshold<br />

criteria must be met or exceeded. Threshold criteria are set for quality index (QI)<br />

and power efficiency, and both can be determined from just three sets of data: fuel<br />

used, power generated and heat supplied. Most schemes are expected to meet the<br />

threshold criteria but where either or both the power or QI criterion is not met, only a<br />

portion of the scheme’s fuel input or power output qualifies as good quality CHP.<br />

2.2 Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI)<br />

As the UK uses more energy on producing heat than either electricity or fuel, the UK<br />

Government set up the RHI to encourage the uptake of renewable heat technologies<br />

in domestic and non-domestic sectors by providing a financial incentive. It is<br />

anticipated that the RHI will help the UK Government reach their target of 12% of<br />

heating from renewable sources by 2020.<br />

The scheme will be rolled out in 2 phases:<br />

• Phase 1 opened the RHI to generators in non-domestic sectors (industrial,<br />

commercial, public sector, and not-for-profit) and producers of bio-methane,<br />

then introduced the Renewable Heat Premium Payments (RHPP) scheme to<br />

households in November 2011.<br />

• Phase 2 opens the RHI to domestic installations and is expected to be introduced<br />

in the summer of 2013.<br />

Once a renewable heat system has been installed you must measure the amount<br />

of heat produced and will receive a fixed amount of money for the amount of heat<br />

generated based on the technology type and size. The scheme is administered by<br />

Ofgem who maintain the register of accredited and eligible systems and the tariffs<br />

paid.<br />

Facilities must be accredited by Ofgem before they can apply for the RHI. To become<br />

accredited applicants must demonstrate that they meet eligibility criteria i.e. the<br />

installation is an eligible technology, of an eligible type and size, that the heat is used<br />

for an eligible purpose, metering arrangements are appropriate, and that grants have<br />

not been received.<br />

Only the biogenic fraction of waste is eligible, and only then if it is classed as<br />

‘municipal solid waste 3 ’. Other wastes (fossil based plastics, for instance) are not<br />

eligible. The tariffs currently paid are shown below. Small and medium plants will<br />

receive Tier 1 payment for the first 15% of their annual rated output; the remaining<br />

output will receive the lower Tier 2 rate.<br />

1<br />

Or ‘is like’ Municipal Solid Waste<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Feedstock Outputs Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 51


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Table 1: RHI Tariff rates<br />

Tariff name Eligible technology Eligible sizes<br />

Small biomass<br />

Medium biomass<br />

Large biomass<br />

Solid biomass; or<br />

Municipal Solid<br />

Waste (incl. CHP)<br />

Less than<br />

200 kWth<br />

200 kWth and<br />

above; less than<br />

1000 kWth<br />

1000 kWth and<br />

above<br />

Tariff rate (p/kWh)<br />

from April 2012<br />

Tier 1: 8.3<br />

Tier 2: 2.1<br />

Tier 1: 5.1<br />

Tier 2: 2.1<br />

It is intended that the RHI scheme will run until 2031 and installations will receive<br />

tariffs for 20 years from their installation date. The scheme will be reviewed every<br />

four years with the first review planned for 2014, with any changes implemented in<br />

2015. A consultation on additional technologies and fuel uses is scheduled to take<br />

place in September 2012.<br />

Full guidance on eligibility and how to apply can be found at:<br />

http://www.ofgem.gov.uk/e-serve/RHI/Pages/RHI.aspx<br />

1.0<br />

2.3 Feed-In Tariffs (FITs)<br />

Feed-In Tariffs (FITs) are the Government’s incentive for small-scale (up to 5MW)<br />

renewable electricity generation. From an <strong>EfW</strong> perspective, only micro CHP is eligible<br />

for FITs, however other <strong>EfW</strong> technologies may be introduced in the future.<br />

2.4 The Enhanced Capital Allowance Scheme (ECA)<br />

The ECA scheme is a key part of the government’s programme to manage climate<br />

change and there is currently no planned end date for the scheme. It provides<br />

businesses with enhanced tax relief for investments in equipment that meet<br />

certain energy-saving criteria. An ECA provides 100% tax relief on investments in<br />

energy-saving equipment, providing the application is made in the same year as the<br />

purchase.<br />

The eligibility criteria are reviewed annually and can be used by both businesses and<br />

manufacturers to choose a product with enhanced specifications. A list of eligible<br />

products is available at http://etl.decc.gov.uk/etl/criteria. Certain products which are<br />

not on the list can also be eligible. These are not listed as additional criteria but must<br />

also be met for ECAs to apply. CHP falls under the non-listed product list.<br />

Eligibility for ECAs is one of the fiscal benefits available to good quality CHP certified<br />

under the CHPQA programme. To qualify for the allowances in respect of a CHP<br />

Scheme the operator must have been issued with a Certificate of Energy Efficiency<br />

from the Secretary of State, which is a separate document to the CHPQA Certificate.<br />

For more details on the ECA visit http://etl.decc.gov.uk/<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Feedstock Outputs Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 52


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.5 Climate Change Levy (CCL)<br />

The CCL is a tax on the supply of specific energy products used as fuel for lighting,<br />

heating and power by business consumers in:<br />

• industry;<br />

• commerce;<br />

• agriculture;<br />

• public administration; and<br />

• other services.<br />

The taxable commodities include electricity, natural gas, liquid petroleum gas<br />

(LPG), other gaseous hydrocarbons in a liquid state, coal, coke, and lignite. The CCL<br />

is charged at a specific rate per unit of energy depending on the fuel category and<br />

the energy content of the fuel. If you make taxable supplies of energy, including<br />

self-supplies, you must register for the CCL. There is no threshold for registration,<br />

however some suppliers are exempt and are therefore not required to register.<br />

Renewable electricity sources are exempt from the CCL if the electricity is generated<br />

from sources of energy other than fossil fuels. Municipal and C&I wastes are<br />

regarded as a renewable source for the purposes of the exemption, provided fossil<br />

fuel (e.g. plastic) does not make up 90% or more of its energy content.<br />

Electricity utilities purchase quantities of renewable electricity from renewable<br />

generators over an agreed period of time and enter into separate agreements with<br />

customers to supply them with electricity designated as coming from a renewable<br />

source (e.g. “green” tariffs). The CCL exemption works on an ‘equivalent amount’<br />

basis to take account of the practicalities of distribution. The exempt renewable<br />

supply of electricity must be the same as the amount purchased from renewable<br />

sources. Renewable Levy Exemption Certificates (Renewable LECs) provide part of<br />

the audit trail to demonstrate that the amount of renewable electricity supplied to the<br />

final consumer equals the amount generated from renewable sources. If it does then<br />

that (otherwise taxable) supply is exempt from the CCL.<br />

In England, Wales and Scotland the Office of the gas and electricity markets (Ofgem)<br />

is responsible for accrediting renewable generators and issuing and transferring<br />

renewable LECs.<br />

To be considered exempt under the CCL, a supply of renewable electricity must be<br />

made under a contract that contains a renewable source declaration given by the<br />

supplier and which meets the prescribed conditions. The supplier and generator<br />

of any renewable source of electricity must notify H&M Customs in writing that the<br />

prescribed conditions have been met to qualify as exempt.<br />

For more information on the CCL exemption visit: www.ofgem.gov.uk<br />

2.6 Renewable Obligation Certificates (ROCs)<br />

The Renewable Obligation (RO) is the main support mechanism for larger-scale<br />

renewable electricity projects across the UK; smaller scale generation is mainly<br />

supported through the FITs scheme. It places an obligation on UK electricity<br />

suppliers to source an increasing proportion of the electricity they supply to<br />

customers from renewable sources. The RO will run until 2037, but will close to new<br />

applicants in 2017.<br />

Renewables Obligation Certificates (ROCs) are certificates issued to operators<br />

of accredited renewable generating stations for the eligible renewable electricity<br />

they generate. Operators can then trade the ROCs with other parties, with the<br />

ROCs ultimately being used by suppliers to demonstrate that they have met their<br />

obligation. The number of ROCs received is banded depending on the technology<br />

and takes into account the technologies’ costs, relative maturity and the potential for<br />

future deployment.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Feedstock Outputs Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 53


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Table 2: ROC Banding<br />

Renewable electricity technologies<br />

Current support<br />

ROCs/MWh<br />

Advanced gasification 2<br />

Advanced pyrolysis 2<br />

Dedicated energy crops 2<br />

Dedicated biomass with CHP 2<br />

Dedicated energy crops with CHP 2<br />

Microgeneration 2<br />

Co-firing of energy crops with CHP 1.5<br />

Dedicated biomass 1.5<br />

Energy from waste with CHP 1<br />

Co-firing of biomass with CHP 1<br />

Co-firing of energy crops 1<br />

Standard gasification 1<br />

Standard pyrolysis 1<br />

Co-firing of biomass 0.5<br />

The bands are reviewed every four years with the current level of support shown in<br />

Table 2. Revised bands will be introduced from 1st April 2013 until the scheme closes<br />

in 2017 - these will be available at www.decc.gov.uk<br />

ROCs are tradable and were introduced to generate a market, and be traded at<br />

different prices than the set buy out price, which is set each year. An excess of ROCs<br />

would mean that the price would fall below the buy-out price. Since its introduction<br />

in 2002 the price has fluctuated with the average lowest price at £38 and the average<br />

highest at £53. The buy-out price for 2011/12 is £38.69.<br />

To qualify for ROCs an <strong>EfW</strong> facility must be compliant with the CHPQA. There is no<br />

power efficiency threshold for ROC eligibility; instead this is based on Quality Index<br />

(QI) and Qualifying Power Output (QPO). Eligible electricity generated from a fuel<br />

mix with an energy content derived from plant or animal matter of less than 90%<br />

should get ‘energy from waste with CHP’ ROCs i.e. 1 ROC per MWh, according to the<br />

renewable content of the waste and the QPO/TPO (Total Power Output) ratio, with<br />

nothing on the remainder.<br />

2.7 FITs Contract for Difference<br />

As set out in the Electricity Market Reform White Paper, the Feed in Tariff with<br />

Contract for Difference (FiT CfD) will replace the ROC scheme following its closure<br />

in 2017. The FiT CfD is expected to open in early 2014, giving generators the option<br />

to choose between FiT CfD and ROCs for three years. Applications for new ROC<br />

accreditations can be made up to 31st March 2017.<br />

‘The FiT CfD is a long term contract set at a fixed level under which variable<br />

payments are made to top-up the level of payment to the generator to the agreed<br />

tariff. The FiT payment would be made in addition to the generator’s revenues from<br />

selling electricity in the market. The FiT CfD is a two-way mechanism that has the<br />

potential to see generators return money to consumers if electricity prices are higher<br />

than the agreed tariff’ 4 . Further information can be found at: http://www.decc.gov.uk<br />

2.7.1 Renewable Heat Premium Payments (RHPP)<br />

The Renewable Heat Premium Payment scheme opened in August 2011 and has<br />

been extended, with a second phase running from 1st May 2012 to 31st March 2013,<br />

depending on available funding. The RHPP is a one off payment towards the cost<br />

of renewable technologies’ installation in the home, until the full domestic RHI is<br />

introduced. The RHPP is only available to the domestic sector.<br />

2.7.2 RHI Phase 2<br />

The second phase of the RHI focuses on supporting domestic installations. The UK<br />

Government is due to consult on proposals in September 2012, following which the<br />

domestic element of the RHI will open in Summer 2013. A consultation on additional<br />

technologies and fuel uses will also take place in September 2012.<br />

4<br />

http://www.decc.gov.uk/assets/decc/11/policy-legislation/EMR/2210-emr-white-paper-full-version.pdf<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Feedstock Outputs Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 54


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Waste Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

1.0 The Waste Incineration Directive 2000/76/EC<br />

2.0 The Industrial Emissions Directive<br />

(IED) 2010/75/EU<br />

Guidance on the requirements of the Waste Incineration<br />

Directive and the implications for waste wood biomass<br />

and small scale energy from waste projects<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 55


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Introduction<br />

The Waste Incineration Directive (WID) looks to achieve significant levels of<br />

environmental and human health protection by setting very strict operational and<br />

technical limit values within which facilities are not only required to operate but to<br />

demonstrate their compliance through verification testing and sampling. This is<br />

designed to ensure that thermal treatment and waste to energy facilities across<br />

the European Community are operating within the same operational and technical<br />

constraints, assisting understanding not only for Operators but for Regulators as<br />

well.<br />

WID was recast within the Industrial Emissions Directive (IED) in December 2010,<br />

but is not required to be transposed into UK law until January 2013. Defra consulted<br />

on the required changes to the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales)<br />

Regulations 2010 (EPR) that the implementation of the IED will bring about, including<br />

changes to the permitted emission limit values for emissions to air.<br />

The structure of the guidance relating to WID and IED is set out below and aims to<br />

give you an understanding of what each of the directives’ main aims and objectives<br />

are with reference to thermal treatment activities:<br />

• Waste Incineration Directive<br />

Guidance relating to what the directive is, what’s covered, terminology and when<br />

it applies.<br />

• Process control<br />

Guidance relating to the full process involved at the facility, the use of raw<br />

materials on site and interactions with other legislation.<br />

• Commissioning<br />

Guidance relating to how the commissioning of the facility and directives work<br />

together.<br />

• Operation<br />

Guidance relating to how the directives work during the operation of the <strong>EfW</strong><br />

facility.<br />

• Wood Waste<br />

There are exemptions within WID and the IED on the types of wood waste that can<br />

be burnt before these Directives apply. This section provides guidance relating to<br />

the types of wood that fall within and outside of WID and IED.<br />

• Industrial Emissions Directive<br />

Guidance relating to what the directive is, what changes from WID to IED and<br />

when it applies.<br />

• Further information<br />

Signposts to further useful information and guidance.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 56


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.0 The Waste Incineration Directive<br />

2000/76/EC<br />

The aim of the Waste Incineration Directive (WID) is to prevent or limit, as far as<br />

practicable, any negative effects on the environment. In particular it relates to the<br />

pollution of air, soil, surface and groundwater and the resulting risk to human health<br />

by emissions from the thermal treatment of waste 1 . It looks to achieve significant<br />

levels of environmental and human health protection by setting strict operational and<br />

technical requirements which will enable the implementation of emission limit values<br />

for facilities throughout Europe.<br />

WID was first implemented in the EU in 2000 and imposed stringent requirements on<br />

incineration and co-incineration plants within its scope. These requirements covered<br />

a range of technical and operational aspects including types of waste permitted at<br />

plants, their delivery mechanisms, design of combustion furnaces, abatement plant,<br />

residue handling, monitoring equipment and emission limit values 2 .<br />

WID also required that the above be included within the facility’s operational permit,<br />

and although the majority of WID facilities will be covered by Environmental Permits 3 ,<br />

some facilities will be covered by Local Authority Permits. Such facilities are not<br />

subject to the requirements of WID.<br />

1.1 What is contained within the WID <br />

The operational and technical requirements introduced by the WID covered a range of<br />

aspects as identified above.<br />

These limits included both daily and half hourly limit values for the following<br />

parameters:<br />

• total dust/particulates;<br />

• total organic carbon;<br />

• hydrogen chloride;<br />

• hydrogen fluoride;<br />

• heavy metals;<br />

• dioxins;<br />

• sulphur dioxide; and<br />

• nitrogen dioxide.<br />

As such, WID facilities are required to have flue gas cleaning plants to ‘scrub’ the<br />

gases generated and reduce emissions of the above parameters as far as practically<br />

possible. Such systems must be detailed within the EP application process and<br />

supported by a technical review of the systems selected on a site by site basis.<br />

Further to the above, WID introduced minimum requirements for combustion<br />

conditions at such facilities, including a requirement for combustion gases to be<br />

heated to 850°C 4 for a minimum of 2 seconds in the secondary combustion chamber<br />

to ensure complete combustion of all potentially polluting substances. Such technical<br />

standards are also required to be verified through on site testing/analysis and<br />

reported back to the Environment Agency (EA).<br />

The most relevant requirements relate to the introduction of emission limit values<br />

for facilities applying to thermally treat wastes. WID introduced maximum emission<br />

levels for emissions to air of the most polluting and environmentally harmful<br />

parameters generated during the thermal degradation of wastes.<br />

1<br />

The ‘thermal treatment of waste’ is used here to describe the chemical conversion of all wastes by<br />

thermal treatments including gasification, pyrolysis and incineration. See Appendix 1 for full definition.<br />

2<br />

See Appendix 2 for full list of emission limit values<br />

3<br />

See WRAP Guidance on Environmental Permitting Regulations<br />

4<br />

850°C for non-hazardous waste, 1150°C for hazardous wastes<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 57


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

1.2 When does WID apply to thermal treatment plants<br />

WID applies to almost all processes that burn/incinerate wastes and generate<br />

direct emissions to air from the burning process. Therefore, for advanced thermal<br />

treatment (such as pyrolysis and gasification) WID will only apply where the purpose<br />

of the process is the disposal of materials and the combustion of resultant gases<br />

(rather than the production of vehicle fuel, for instance).<br />

The EA note that European case law and Commission positions continue to develop<br />

on the distinction between the incineration of waste and the use of waste as a fuel for<br />

energy for the purposes (“recovery”) of the Waste Framework Directive.<br />

There are, however, some notable exclusions from WID under Article 2 for plants<br />

treating only the following wastes:<br />

• vegetable waste from agriculture and forestry;<br />

• vegetable waste from the food processing industry, if the heat generated is<br />

recovered;<br />

• fibrous vegetable waste from virgin pulp production and from production of paper<br />

from pulp, if it is co-incinerated at the place of production and the heat generated<br />

is recovered;<br />

• wood waste, with the exception of wood waste which may contain halogenated<br />

organic compounds or heavy metals as a result of treatment with wood<br />

preservatives or coating, and which includes in particular such wood waste<br />

originating from construction and demolition waste;<br />

• cork waste;<br />

• radioactive waste;<br />

• animal carcasses as regulated by Directive 90/667/EEC without prejudice to its<br />

future amendments; and<br />

• waste resulting from the exploration for, and the exploitation of, oil and gas<br />

resources from off-shore installations and incinerated on board the installation.<br />

1.3 Wood Waste & WID Compliance<br />

A specific section of WID covers wood waste (Article 2(2)(a)(iv)). In general, plants<br />

burning ‘clean’ wood waste (containing no evidence of chemical treatments/paints)<br />

would be excluded from the requirements of WID, but the utilisation of ‘treated’ wood<br />

wastes (containing treatments or chemicals, either from product manufacture or<br />

through usage through the wood’s lifetime) would require WID compliance.<br />

In order to use wood waste as a fuel in a plant not operated to WID technical<br />

standards, it would have to be demonstrated that the wood waste wasn’t treated. If<br />

the wood waste contains halogenated organic compounds or heavy metals as a result<br />

of treatment with wood preservatives or coatings, in particular wood originating from<br />

construction and demolition sites, then it will fall under the requirements of WID.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 58


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

2.0 The Industrial Emissions Directive<br />

(IED) 2010/75/EU<br />

The Waste Incineration Directive (WID) as described above has been recast within the<br />

Industrial Emissions Directive (IED) as of December 2010. The purpose of this was to<br />

transpose several pre-existing directives on the control of emissions from industrial<br />

processes into one directive on industrial emissions.<br />

The IED was introduced into European law when it was published in the Official<br />

Journal of the European Community in December 2010 but is not required to be<br />

transposed into UK law until 6th January 2013. Defra recently consulted on the<br />

implementation of the IED in England and Wales and are proposing to introduce<br />

the IED through a recast of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales)<br />

Regulations 2010 in January 2013.<br />

The consultation on the implementation of the IED stated that there will be minimal<br />

changes to the requirements of the WID in the IED. However, Article 42(1) of the IED<br />

removes the waste incineration provisions from gasification and pyrolysis plants “if<br />

the gases resulting from this thermal treatment of waste are purified to such an<br />

extent that they are no longer a waste prior to their incineration and they can cause<br />

emissions no higher than those resulting from the burning of natural gas”.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 59


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Appendix 1 – Incineration Definition<br />

The WID makes specific reference to facilities for the incineration and co-incineration<br />

of wastes and provides the following definitions for these terms in Article 3:<br />

“Incineration plant means any stationary or mobile technical unit and equipment<br />

dedicated to the thermal treatment of waste with or without recovery of the<br />

combustion heat generated. This includes the incineration by oxidation of waste, as<br />

well as other thermal treatment processes such as pyrolysis, gasification or plasma<br />

processes insofar as the substances resulting from the treatment are subsequently<br />

incinerated.”<br />

It goes on to state:<br />

“This definition covers the site and the entire incineration plant including all<br />

incineration, waste reception, storage, on site pre-treatment facilities, waste-fuel<br />

and air supply systems, boiler, facilities for the treatment of exhaust gases, onsite<br />

facilities for treatment or storage of residues and waste water, stack, devices<br />

and systems for controlling incineration operations, recording and monitoring<br />

incineration conditions.”<br />

Co-incineration is defined as:<br />

“any stationary or mobile plant whose main purpose is the generation of energy or<br />

production of material products and:<br />

• which uses waste as a regular or additional fuel; or<br />

• in which waste is thermally treated for the purpose of disposal.”<br />

It can therefore be determined that references within WID, and therefore this<br />

guidance note, to incineration and co-incineration refer to all complex thermal<br />

treatment (<strong>EfW</strong>) processes not necessarily considered as traditional incineration or<br />

co-incineration technologies.<br />

Further to the above, it is noted that not all thermal treatment technologies are<br />

considered to combust materials, particularly if thermal treatment is carried out in<br />

the presence of oxygen.<br />

However, WID and most other thermal treatment guidance notes refer to combustion<br />

processes when describing the thermal breakdown of waste and as such this<br />

definition will also be adopted within this guidance.<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 60


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Appendix 2 – Daily emission limit values<br />

Parameter Unit WID (Annex V)<br />

Total dust mg/Nm3 10<br />

HCl mg/Nm3 10<br />

TOC mg/Nm3 10<br />

CO mg/Nm3 50<br />

HF mg/Nm3 1<br />

SO2 and SO3 mg/Nm3 50<br />

NOx mg/Nm3 200<br />

Sb + As + Pb + Cr + Co +<br />

Cu + Mn + Ni + V<br />

mg/Nm3 0.5<br />

Hg mg/Nm3 0.05<br />

Cd and Tl mg/Nm3 0.05<br />

Dioxins and furans ng/Nm3 0.1<br />

Appendix 3 – When does WID apply <br />

Page 13 - http://www.defra.gov.uk/publications/files/pb13639-<br />

ep2010wasteincineration.pdf<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Guide<br />

page 61


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Glossary<br />

Glossary of terms used throughout the WRAP<br />

<strong>EfW</strong> development guidance on energy from waste<br />

technologies.<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 62


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

AD<br />

AONB<br />

Anaerobic Digestion is a treatment process which harnesses<br />

natural bacteria in the absence of air to produce biogas ( a mixture<br />

of methane and carbon dioxide) and a nutrient rich residue known<br />

as digestate. Anaerobic digestion uses waste biodegradable<br />

materials such as agricultural manure and slurry, food waste and<br />

sewage sludge.<br />

Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONBs) are areas of high<br />

scenic quality that have statutory protection in order to conserve<br />

and enhance the natural beauty of their landscapes. AONB<br />

landscapes range from rugged coastline to water meadows to<br />

gentle lowland and upland moors. http://www.naturalengland.org.<br />

uk/ourwork/conservation/designatedareas/aonb/default.aspx<br />

Air Pollution Control - methods and technologies to minimise air<br />

pollution<br />

Air Pollution Control Residues - Air Pollution Residues are the<br />

by-products from the flue gas clean up processes from high<br />

temperature processes such as municipal waste incinerators<br />

ASCR<br />

ATT<br />

Application Site Condition Report is a report required by the<br />

Environment Agency for any facility that they regulate under the<br />

Environmental Permitting Regulations where there may be a<br />

significant risk to land or groundwater or where one is necessary<br />

to satisfy requirements of the IPPS Directive. The application part<br />

of the site condition report describes and records the condition<br />

of the land and groundwater at a site at the point at which an<br />

Environmental Permit is applied for.<br />

Advanced Thermal Treatment is a term that applies to a range<br />

of technologies that use heat to break down the waste into its<br />

constituent elements . These include gasification, pyrolysis,<br />

plasma arc gasification and thermal depolymerisation.<br />

Incinerator Bottom Ash or furnace bottom ash is the residual<br />

solid material from the combustion process. It is the coarse ash<br />

recovered from the bottom of the furnace / combustion chamber.<br />

Best Available Technique – the most effective and advanced stage<br />

in the development of activities and their methods of operation<br />

which indicate the practical suitability of particular techniques for<br />

providing in principle the basis for emission limit values designed<br />

to prevent/reduce emissions and the impact on the environment.<br />

Biosphere reserve - Biosphere reserves are areas of terrestrial<br />

and coastal ecosystems promoting solutions to reconcile the<br />

conservation of biodiversity with its sustainable use. They are<br />

internationally recognized, nominated by national governments<br />

and remain under sovereign jurisdiction of the states where they<br />

are located. They are designated under UNESCO’s Man and the<br />

Biosphere Programme.<br />

APC<br />

APC Residues<br />

AQMA<br />

Air Quality Management Area – Since December 1997 each<br />

local authority in the UK has been carrying out a review and<br />

assessment of air quality in their area. This involves measuring<br />

air pollution and trying to predict how it will change in the next<br />

few years. The aim of the review is to make sure that the national<br />

air quality objectives will be achieved throughout the UK by the<br />

relevant deadlines. These objectives have been put in place to<br />

protect people’s health and the environment.<br />

If a local authority finds any places where the objectives are not<br />

likely to be achieved, it must declare an Air Quality Management<br />

Area there. This area could be just one or two streets, or it could<br />

be much bigger. http://aqma.defra.gov.uk/<br />

BA<br />

BAT<br />

Biosphere<br />

Reserve<br />

http://www.unesco.org.uk/uploads/biopshere%20reserves%20faq.<br />

pdf<br />

An area declared if pollutant concentrations are identified as<br />

exceeding, or likely to exceed, air quality objectives set out in the<br />

Air Quality Standards (England) Regulations 2007 and prescribed<br />

for Local Air Quality Management (LAQM).<br />

BCB<br />

Building Control Bodies – are bodies that check that building<br />

regulation are being complied with. There are two types either<br />

a Local Authority Building Control or a private sector Approved<br />

inspector Building control.<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 63


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

BIS<br />

BREEAM<br />

CEM<br />

CHP<br />

Department for Business, Innovation and Skills<br />

Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment<br />

Method – a voluntary measurement rating for green buildings<br />

that was established in the UK. It is a tool to measure the<br />

sustainability of new non-domestic buildings.<br />

Continuous Emissions Monitoring.<br />

Combined Heat and Power – is the on-site generation of electricity<br />

and the use of heat that is produced as a by-product.<br />

DAS<br />

Design and Access Statement - A design and access (DAS)<br />

statement is a report accompanying and supporting a planning<br />

application. A DAS should explain the design principles and<br />

concepts that have been applied to particular aspects of the<br />

proposal – these are the amount, layout, scale, landscaping and<br />

appearance of the development. Design and access statements<br />

are documents that explain the design thinking behind a planning<br />

application. There is a statutory requirement to submit a DAS with<br />

most planning applications. Guidance on the need for and content<br />

of DASs is provided by following this link.<br />

CHPQA<br />

CIL<br />

CO2<br />

Co-<br />

Incineration<br />

CV<br />

Quality Assurance for Combined Heat and Power<br />

Community Infrastructure Levy – Planning charge that allows<br />

local authorities to raise funds from developers undertaking<br />

new building projects for needed infrastructure as a result of the<br />

development.<br />

Carbon Dioxide – a greenhouse gas that is the principle form in<br />

which nearly all of the carbon content in the waste is emitted to<br />

the environment.<br />

Co-Incineration - Co-incineration plant is any stationary or<br />

mobile plant whose main purpose is the generation of energy<br />

or production of material products and: which uses wastes as a<br />

regular or additional fuel; or in which waste is thermally treated<br />

for the purpose of disposal.<br />

http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/environment/waste_<br />

management/l28072_en.htm<br />

Calorific Value – is a measure of heating power and refers to<br />

the amount of energy released when a known volume of gas is<br />

completely combusted under specific conditions.<br />

DEFRA<br />

Dioxins and<br />

Furans<br />

DNO<br />

EA<br />

EEUDF<br />

http://www.planningportal.gov.uk/planning/applications/<br />

howtoapply/whattosubmit/designaccess<br />

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs - UK<br />

government department responsible for policy and regulations on<br />

the environment, food and rural affairs.<br />

Dioxins - Dioxins and furans are families of complex chemicals<br />

containing chlorine. There are several hundred dioxin substances.<br />

They are crystalline solids which dissolve in organic (carboncontaining)<br />

solvents, fats and oils - but not in water.<br />

http://apps.sepa.org.uk/spripa/Pages/SubstanceInformation.<br />

aspxpid=115<br />

Distribution Network Operator – Companies licensed to distribute<br />

electricity in Great Britain.<br />

Environment Agency – an executive non-departmental public body<br />

that aims to protect and improve the environment and to promote<br />

sustainable development. The Environment Agency is the main<br />

regulator of discharges to air, water and land and it does this<br />

through the issue of formal consents to discharge or by means of<br />

a permit.<br />

Energy Efficiency Urban Development Fund<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 64


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

<strong>EfW</strong><br />

ELV<br />

Energy from Waste - is a general description for all of the<br />

technologies that can be used to generate energy from the<br />

treatment of waste. It is commonly used to describe the process<br />

where waste is burnt to produce heat and/or electricity. However,<br />

it also covers other thermal technologies such as gasification<br />

and pyrolysis and non-thermal technologies including anaerobic<br />

digestion.<br />

Emission Limit Value – the legally enforceable limit on the<br />

physical, chemical or biological characteristics of a point source<br />

emission to water or air.<br />

Environmental Management Systems – the framework through<br />

which a business’ environmental performance can be monitored,<br />

improved and controlled to reduce its environmental impact.<br />

EN Standards - European Standards<br />

EPR<br />

ERDF<br />

Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations –<br />

these regulations were created to standardise Environmental<br />

Permitting and compliance in England and Wales to protect<br />

human health and the environment. They affect all regulated<br />

facilities that are installations, mobile plant, water operations,<br />

radioactive substances activities, water discharge and<br />

groundwater activities.<br />

European Regional Development Fund Programme<br />

EMS<br />

EN<br />

Environmental<br />

Impact<br />

Assessment<br />

(EIA)<br />

EP<br />

EPC<br />

Environmental Impact Assessment - Environmental Impact<br />

Assessment assesses the environmental effects of major<br />

development proposals.<br />

It seeks to ensure that any decisions affecting the environment are<br />

taken with the knowledge of any potentially significant effects. A<br />

significant effect is determined as a harmful impact of ‘more than<br />

local importance.<br />

The Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact<br />

Assessment) Regulations 2011 set out the requirement and<br />

process for EIA.<br />

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2011/1824/introduction/made<br />

Environmental Permit are permits or exemptions that are<br />

issued under the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales)<br />

Regulations 2007by the Environment Agency and regulate<br />

business activities that could have an impact on the environment<br />

or human health.<br />

Engineering, Procurement and Construction<br />

ESP<br />

EWC<br />

FIT<br />

FBC<br />

FGR<br />

FGT<br />

FGTR<br />

Electrostatic Precipitator – a device for removing small<br />

particulates from a flowing gas using the force of an induced<br />

electrostatic charge. The gas is first passed through an<br />

electrically charged screen that gives a charge to the particles,<br />

then between two charged plates where the particles are attracted<br />

to one surface.<br />

European Waste Catalogue – this classifies waste materials and<br />

categorises them according to what they are and how they were<br />

produced.<br />

Feed-In Tariff<br />

Fluidised Bed Combustion – is a combustion technology whereby<br />

the solid fuels are suspended on upward-blowing jets of air during<br />

the combustion process.<br />

Flue Gas Recirculation – a technique or reducing nitrogen oxides<br />

(NOx) emissions in industrial boilers by recirculating a portion of<br />

the boiler flue gas into the main combustion chamber<br />

Flue Gas Treatment – to comply with emission standards, flue<br />

gases produced by incinerators are treated with activated carbon<br />

to remove contaminants such as gaseous heavy metals and<br />

dioxins produced at levels above permissible limits.<br />

Flue Gas Treatment Residues – are the solid residues from the<br />

chemical treatment of flue gases.<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 65


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

Gasification<br />

Global<br />

Geoparks<br />

Green Belt<br />

GWP<br />

H*<br />

HCl<br />

HGV<br />

HHRA<br />

Gasification - is an Advanced Thermal Treatment technology that<br />

is characterised by the partial oxidation of the feed stock. Oxygen<br />

is added, but not in sufficient quantities to allow the substance<br />

to be completely oxidised and full combustion to occur. The<br />

partial combustion results in the production of ‘Syngas’ which<br />

can be used to substitute natural gas, chemicals, fertilisers,<br />

transportation fuels and hydrogen.<br />

http://www.ciwm.co.uk/CIWM/InformationCentre/AtoZ/Gpages/<br />

Gasification.aspx<br />

Global Geoparks - A Geopark is defined by the United Nations<br />

Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)<br />

in its UNESCO Geoparks International Network of Geoparks<br />

programme as follows:A territory encompassing one or more sites<br />

of scientific importance, not only for geological reasons but also<br />

by virtue of its archaeological, ecological or cultural value.<br />

Green Belt – Land identified within Development Plans to help<br />

control urban growth. Aim of green belt land is to prevent urban<br />

sprawl by keeping land permanently open.<br />

Global Warming Potential – is a relative measure of how much a<br />

given mass of greenhouse gas is estimated to contribute to global<br />

warming.<br />

Horizontal Guidance Note * - these notes provide supplementary<br />

information relevant to all sectors regulated under Environmental<br />

Permitting Regulations, to assist permit applicants in responding<br />

to the requirements described in the Sector Guidance Noted and<br />

the Permit application form.<br />

Hydrogen Chloride<br />

Heavy Goods Vehicle – The common term for goods vehicle over<br />

3.5 tonnes gross Vehicle Weight (The European Union term is<br />

Large Goods Vehicles (LGVs).)<br />

Human Health Risk Assessment – are used to determine if a<br />

particular chemical poses a significant risk to human heath and if<br />

so under what circumstances.<br />

HIA<br />

HPA<br />

IBA<br />

IED<br />

Incineration<br />

IPPC<br />

ISO14001<br />

Health Impact Assessment - Health Impact Assessment (HIA) is<br />

a means of assessing the health impacts of policies, plans and<br />

projects in diverse economic sectors using quantitative, qualitative<br />

and participatory techniques.<br />

http://www.who.int/hia/en/<br />

Health Protection Agency – An agency that provides advice on the<br />

potential impacts of <strong>EfW</strong> facilities to government agencies and<br />

departments, public health professionals and members of the<br />

public.<br />

Incinerator Bottom Ash – is processed from the material<br />

discharged into the burning grate of municipal solid waste<br />

incinerators. They are useful in construction for example as<br />

hardcore, road building and concrete.<br />

Industrial Emissions Directive – combines seven existing<br />

European directives controlling industrial emission into one new<br />

directive and will change the way that existing installations will be<br />

regulated after 2015 and new installations from 2013.<br />

Incineration - is a waste treatment process that involves the<br />

combustion of organic substances contained in waste materials<br />

Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Directive - The aim<br />

of the IPPC Directive (Council Directive 96/61/EC) is to prevent,<br />

reduce and eliminate pollution by prioritizing efforts on the<br />

most significant industrial and agricultural activities. It involves<br />

determining the appropriate controls for industry to protect<br />

the environment through a single Permitting process. To gain a<br />

Permit, Operators will have to show that they have systematically<br />

developed proposals to apply the Best Available Techniques (BAT)<br />

and meet certain other requirements, taking account of relevant<br />

local factors.<br />

International Standard for Environmental Management Systems<br />

- it specifies a framework of control for an Environmental<br />

Management System against which an organization can be<br />

certified by a third party.<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 66


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

JESSICA<br />

Judicial<br />

Review<br />

Listed Building<br />

LDA<br />

LNR<br />

Local<br />

Development<br />

Documents<br />

LGF<br />

LOI<br />

LWARB<br />

MCERTS<br />

Joint European Support for Sustainable Investment in City Areas<br />

Judicial review is a procedure in English administrative law by<br />

which the courts in England and Wales supervise the exercise of<br />

public power on the application of an individual. A person who<br />

feels that an exercise of such power by a government authority,<br />

such as a minister, the local council or a statutory tribunal, is<br />

unlawful, perhaps because it has violated his or her rights, may<br />

apply to the Administrative Court (a division of the High Court) for<br />

judicial review of the decision. There is a statutory basis to legally<br />

challenge planning decisions.<br />

Listed Building - a building that has been placed on the Statutory<br />

List of Buildings of Special Architectural or Historic Interest<br />

London Development Agency<br />

Local Nature Reserve - Local Nature Reserve (or LNR) is a<br />

statutory designation made under Section 21 of the National<br />

Parks and Access to the Countryside Act 1949, and amended by<br />

Schedule 11 of the Natural Environment and Rural Communities<br />

Act 2006, by principal local authorities. Local authorities manage<br />

Local Nature Reserves (LNRs) to maintain and enhance their<br />

special wildlife and geology and provide access to nature for local<br />

communities.<br />

Local Development Documents – are a set of documents specified<br />

in planning law which a local planning authority creates to<br />

describe their strategy for development and the use of land within<br />

their authority.<br />

London Green Fund<br />

Loss on Ignition – is a key indication of good combustion and<br />

equates to the total organic carbon remaining in the residue.<br />

London Waste and Recycling Board<br />

Monitoring Certification Scheme – The Environment Agency’s<br />

Monitoring Certification Scheme for emissions to air, land and<br />

water.<br />

MCR<br />

MG<br />

MSW<br />

MW<br />

MWh<br />

National Park<br />

NNR<br />

NOx<br />

NPPF<br />

OCP<br />

Maximum Continuous Rating – the maximum output that a<br />

generating station is capable of producing continuously under<br />

normal conditions over a year.<br />

Moving Grate – used in incinerators to optimise the movement of<br />

waste through the combustion chamber to allow a more efficient<br />

and complete combustion.<br />

Municipal Solid Waste – waste collected by or on behalf of a local<br />

authority and it comprises mostly household waste.<br />

Mega Watt – a unit of power equal to one million watts.<br />

Mega Watt Hour – the amount of power used if one million watts<br />

are used for 1 hour.<br />

National Park - are extensive tracts of country that are protected<br />

by law for future generations because of their natural beauty and<br />

for the opportunities they offer for open air recreation.<br />

National Nature Reserve - Natural England is the body<br />

empowered to declare NNRs in England, the Reserves being<br />

a selection of the very best parts of England’s Sites of Special<br />

Scientific Interest. It is this underlying designation which gives<br />

NNRs their strong legal protection. The majority also have<br />

European nature conservation designations.<br />

http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/ourwork/conservation/<br />

designatedareas/nnr/default.aspx<br />

Oxides of Nitrogen – refers to nitrogen oxide and nitrogen dioxide<br />

which are produced during combustion.<br />

National Planning Policy Framework – was published in 2011,<br />

replacing planning policy guidance and statements. It sets out the<br />

Government’s planning policy and is a material consideration for<br />

planning decisions.<br />

http://communities.gov.uk/publications/planningandbuilding/nppf<br />

Ozone Creation Potential – indicates the potential capacity of a<br />

volatile organic compound to produce ozone.<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 67


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

PAC<br />

PFA<br />

Planning<br />

Appeal<br />

Polyaromatic<br />

Hydrocarbons<br />

PM10<br />

PM2.5<br />

Powdered Activated Carbon – is used for the treatment of<br />

wastewater. It is added to act as a buffer against the effects of<br />

toxic organics in the wastewater.<br />

Pulverised Fuel Ash also known as ‘fly ash’ is the residual<br />

solid material from the combustion process.. It is the fine ash<br />

recovered from the gas stream.<br />

The Planning Appeal process is designed for anyone who has<br />

applied to their council or national park authority for planning<br />

permission, but is unhappy with the resulting decision, or the lack<br />

of a decision (which should normally be made within 8 or 13/16<br />

weeks).<br />

Polyaromatic Hydrocarbon - Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons<br />

(PAHs are a diverse class of organic compounds. There are several<br />

hundred PAHs, which usually occur as complex mixtures rather<br />

than as individual compounds.PAH are flammable, colourless<br />

solids or crystals at room temperature with no perceptible odour.<br />

http://www.hpa.org.uk/webc/HPAwebFile/<br />

HPAweb_C/1227169968068<br />

Particulate Matter


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

RHI<br />

RO<br />

ROC<br />

SAC<br />

SM<br />

SCR<br />

Screening<br />

Opinion<br />

Scoping<br />

Opinion<br />

SGN<br />

SMEs<br />

Renewable Heat Incentive<br />

Renewables Obligation<br />

Renewables Obligation Certificate<br />

Special Area of Conservation - areas which have been given<br />

special protection under the European Union’s Habitats Directive.<br />

They provide increased protection to a variety of wild animals,<br />

plants and habitats and are a vital part of global efforts to<br />

conserve the world’s biodiversity.<br />

http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/ourwork/conservation/<br />

designatedareas/sac/default.aspx<br />

Scheduled Monument - a scheduled monument is a ‘nationally<br />

important’ archaeological site or historic building, given protection<br />

against unauthorized change.<br />

Selective Catalytic Reduction – is an emissions-reduction<br />

technology that reduces nitrogen oxides (NOx) emissions to very<br />

low levels.<br />

Screening Opinion - Before submitting a planning application,<br />

potential applicants can apply to the local planning authority<br />

for an opinion on whether a development should be subject to<br />

Environmental Impact Assessment, as prescribed in the Town<br />

and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment)<br />

Regulations 2011. This is called a screening opinion.<br />

Scoping Opinion – an opinion on what information should be<br />

included within an Environmental Statement; this is obtained<br />

from the local planning authority in accordance with The Town<br />

and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment)<br />

Regulations 2011.<br />

Sector Guidance Note – IPPS Sector Guidance Notes explain, for<br />

each industrial sector, the information which the applicants for<br />

IPPC permits must supply and the indicative standards which<br />

should normally be met in order to demonstrate compliance with<br />

each of these requirements.<br />

Small and medium enterprises<br />

SNCR<br />

SO2<br />

SOx<br />

SOW<br />

SPA<br />

SPZ<br />

Selective Non Catalytic Reduction – is a method of reducing<br />

nitrogen oxide emissions from power plants that burn biogenic,<br />

waste and coal. The process involves injecting a reagent that<br />

reacts selectively with the nitrogen oxides in the flue gas to<br />

produce nitrogen and water.<br />

Sulphur Dioxide –one of the major sulphides of sulphur produced<br />

during the burning of fossil fuels in power stations and other<br />

boilers.<br />

Sulphur Oxides – Oxides of sulphur<br />

Statement of Works - is a formal document that captures and<br />

defines the work activities, deliverables and timeline a vendor<br />

will execute against in performance of specified work for a<br />

client. Detailed requirements and pricing are usually included<br />

in the Statement Of Work, along with standard regulatory and<br />

governance terms and conditions.<br />

Special Protection Areas - are areas which have been identified<br />

as being of international importance for the breeding, feeding,<br />

wintering or the migration of rare and vulnerable species of<br />

birds found within European Union countries. They are European<br />

designated sites, classified under the ‘Birds Directive 1979’ which<br />

provides enhanced protection given by the Site of Special Scientific<br />

Interest (SSSI) status all SPAs also hold.<br />

http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/ourwork/conservation/<br />

designatedareas/spa/default.aspx<br />

Source Protection Zone – The Environment Agency has defined<br />

Source Protection Zones (SPZs) for groundwater sources such<br />

as wells, boreholes and springs used for drinking water supply.<br />

These zones show the risk of contamination from any activities<br />

that might cause pollution in the area. The closer the activity, the<br />

greater the risk. The maps show three main zones (inner, outer<br />

and total catchment) and a fourth zone of special interest, which is<br />

occasionally applied, to a groundwater source.<br />

http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/homeandleisure/37833.<br />

aspx<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 69


WRAP – <strong>EfW</strong> <strong>DEVELOPMENT</strong> <strong>GUIDANCE</strong> – September 2012<br />

SRF<br />

SSSI<br />

Solid Recovered Fuel – is fuel produced from non-hazardous<br />

Municipal Solid Waste and Commercial and Industrial wastes in<br />

accordance with the requirements of Technical Standard CEN / TC<br />

343.<br />

Site of Special Scientific interest - Sites of Special Scientific<br />

Interest (SSSIs) give legal protection to the best sites for<br />

wildlife and geology in England. They include some of the most<br />

spectacular and beautiful habitats; wetlands teeming with wading<br />

birds, winding chalk rivers, flower-rich meadows, windswept<br />

shingle beaches and remote upland peat bogs. Natural England<br />

now has responsibility for identifying and protecting the SSSIs<br />

in England under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (as<br />

amended).<br />

Waste<br />

Acceptance<br />

Criteria<br />

WAMITAB<br />

Waste Core<br />

Strategies<br />

Waste Acceptance Criteria Procedures are set out in the Council<br />

Decision (2003/33/EC) and in Schedule 10 of the Environmental<br />

Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2010. Waste<br />

producers must sample and characterise their wastes to enable<br />

the correct waste management option.<br />

Waste Management Industry Training and Advisory Board<br />

(WAMITAB)<br />

Waste Core Strategy – is a development plan document prepared<br />

by the planning authority which aims to provide spatial vision,<br />

strategic objectives and core policies for managing waste<br />

throughout an authority<br />

Statement of<br />

Community<br />

Involvement<br />

http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/ourwork/conservation/<br />

designatedareas/sssi/designation.aspx<br />

Statement of Community Involvement - are produced by Local<br />

Authorities to explain to the public how they will be involved<br />

in the preparation of Local Development Documents and the<br />

determination of planning applications<br />

WID<br />

Waste Incineration Directive – governs the thermal treatment<br />

(including combustion, gasification and pyrolysis) of solids or<br />

liquids and aims to limit the risks that waste incineration poses to<br />

the environment and human health. The directive is implemented<br />

through the Environmental Permitting Regulations in England and<br />

Wales<br />

TOC<br />

tpa<br />

tphr<br />

UoS tariffs<br />

VOC<br />

Waste<br />

Total Organic Carbon – the amount of carbon bound in an organic<br />

compound.<br />

tonnes per annum<br />

tonnes per hour<br />

Use of System tariffs – are fees paid to the distribution network<br />

operators by suppliers fro the use of the network infrastructure.<br />

Volatile Organic Compounds – are organic chemicals with a high<br />

vapour pressure that are released into the air.<br />

Any substance or object in the categories set out in Annex 1 of<br />

the Waste Framework Directive (91/156/EEC), which the holder<br />

discards or intends or is required to discard.<br />

World<br />

Heritage Site<br />

WRAP<br />

WTS<br />

WUDF<br />

World Heritage Site - a place (such as a forest, mountain, lake,<br />

desert, monument, building, complex, or city) that is listed by the<br />

UNESCO as of special cultural or physical significance<br />

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Heritage_Site<br />

Waste & Resources Action Programme they work with businesses<br />

and individuals to help them reap the benefits of reducing waste,<br />

develop sustainable products and use resources in an efficient<br />

way.<br />

Waste Transfer Station – a building or site for the temporary<br />

deposition of waste prior to onward transport for further<br />

treatment or disposal.<br />

Urban Waste Development Fund<br />

Glossary<br />

Home<br />

Funding<br />

Feasibility and<br />

Good Practice<br />

Planning<br />

Environmental<br />

permitting<br />

regulations<br />

Feedstock Outputs Financial<br />

Incentives<br />

Waste<br />

Incineration<br />

Directive<br />

Guide<br />

page 70


For further information about<br />

energy from waste please visit:<br />

www.wrap.org.uk/<strong>EfW</strong><br />

While we have tried to make sure this guide is accurate, we cannot accept responsibility or be held legally responsible for any loss or damage arising out of or in connection<br />

with this information being inaccurate, incomplete or misleading. This material is copyrighted. You can copy it free of charge as long as the material is accurate and not used<br />

in a misleading context. You must identify the source of the material and acknowledge our copyright. You must not use material to endorse or suggest we have endorsed<br />

a commercial product or service. Please note that this information was correct at the time of writing, but the regime is liable to change with government policy. WRAP will<br />

endeavour to update this document when changes are made to the regime.<br />

For more details please see our terms and conditions on our website at www.wrap.org.uk<br />

www.wrap.org.uk<br />

Waste & Resources<br />

Action Programme<br />

Helpline freephone: 0808 100 2040<br />

E-mail: info@wrap.org.uk<br />

Home<br />

page 71

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!