LL4 Teacher Guidance - WJEC
LL4 Teacher Guidance - WJEC
LL4 Teacher Guidance - WJEC
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
GCE TEACHER GUIDANCE<br />
ENGLISH LANGUAGE<br />
& LITERATURE <strong>LL4</strong>
<strong>LL4</strong> <strong>Teacher</strong> <strong>Guidance</strong><br />
Introduction<br />
This document is intended to offer guidance and support to teachers in<br />
preparing students for the first summer examination in summer 2010.<br />
There are 4 sections to this document:<br />
• The specification requirements for <strong>LL4</strong><br />
• Preparing for the question paper with the revised rubric for Section B<br />
• Candidate responses to <strong>LL4</strong> January 2010<br />
• Specimen Paper (revised March 2010) and assessment grid.
The specification requirements for <strong>LL4</strong><br />
LL 4 – 30% Comparative Textual Analysis and Review (synoptic) 80 marks<br />
Section A: Comparative analysis of texts - 40 marks<br />
Relevant assessment objectives: AO1 AO2 AO3<br />
Candidates will be required to answer one compulsory question in this section. The<br />
question will require candidates to produce a detailed comparative analysis of three<br />
unseen texts of different genres, chosen from a range of types and periods. The<br />
focus of the analysis will be provided in the question. In their response to the<br />
question, candidates are expected to select and apply relevant linguistic and literary<br />
approaches from their integrated studies across the course as a whole.<br />
Section B: Reviewing approaches ('open' text – clean copy) – 40 marks<br />
Relevant assessment objectives: AO1 AO2 AO3<br />
Candidates will be required to answer one question in this section, from a choice of<br />
five. Each question will require a piece of extended writing designed to allow<br />
candidates to reflect on insights gained from integrated linguistic and literary study<br />
across the whole A level course. In preparation for this question, candidates are<br />
required to study one text from the list below:<br />
Charles Dickens: Hard Times (Penguin)<br />
Emily Bronte: Wuthering Heights (Penguin)<br />
George Orwell: Shooting an Elephant: and Other<br />
Essays (Penguin)<br />
ed. Ian Jack: The Granta Book of Reportage<br />
(Classics of Reportage) (Granta Books)<br />
Ted Hughes: Birthday Letters (Faber)<br />
T.S. Eliot: Selected Poems (Faber)<br />
A clean copy (no annotation) of the set text studied must be taken into the<br />
examination.<br />
Note: no other texts or material may be taken into the examination.<br />
The questions set will not be directly linked to the prescribed texts, but will invite<br />
discussion of aspects of integrated study which will involve detailed knowledge of<br />
these texts as well as comparative reference to at least one other text (literary/non-<br />
spoken/written) studied in the course as a whole or selected for wider<br />
literary,<br />
independent study. The selected prescribed text should be regarded as the ‘core’<br />
text, and will require sustained reference and more detailed discussion than the<br />
text/texts discussed for comparative reference, which should be regarded as the<br />
‘partner’ text(s).<br />
Candidates are not required to quote from their partner texts, but if they wish to they<br />
may.<br />
Candidates should prepare for the following aspects of integrated study:<br />
• presentation of characters/people<br />
• themes e.g. family life, power, love
• narrative technique<br />
• influence of contextual factors in the production and reception of texts<br />
• importance of setting/location<br />
• language variation according to time, place, context<br />
• different readers’ or listeners’ interpretations of individual texts.<br />
Addressing the Assessment Objectives in <strong>LL4</strong> Sections A and B<br />
The same weighting of assessment objectives applies to both sections of the paper:<br />
<strong>LL4</strong> % AO1% AO2% AO3%<br />
SECTION A 30 (15) 6 (3) 12 (6) 12 (6)<br />
SECTION B 30 (15) 6 (3) 12 (6)<br />
12 (6)<br />
AS TOTAL <strong>LL4</strong> 60 (30) 12 (12) 24 (6) 24 (12)<br />
The notional distribution of marks for both sec tions is therefore:<br />
AO1: 8 marks AO2: 16 marks AO3: 16 marks<br />
This weighting is reflected in the tasks for both sections, as candidates should be<br />
equally engaged with analysing a range of texts, considering the significance of<br />
contextual factors and exploring relat ionships between the unseen texts in Section A<br />
and between the set text and other text(s) studied on the course in Section B:<br />
• select and apply relevant concepts and approaches from integrated linguistic<br />
and literary study, using appropriate terminology and accurate, coherent<br />
written expression (AO1);<br />
• demonstrate detailed critical understanding in analysing the ways in which<br />
structure, form and language shape meanings in a range of spoken and<br />
written texts (AO2);<br />
• use integrated approaches to explore relationships between texts, analysing<br />
and evaluating the significance of contextual factors in their production and<br />
reception (AO3).
Preparing for the <strong>LL4</strong> Question Paper- revised rubric<br />
The <strong>LL4</strong> question paper for summer 2010 onwards features a revised rubric which is<br />
intended to improve and simplify the instructions for Section B.<br />
The main changes are the removal of the text box containing the list of set texts, and also<br />
the removal of bullet points in all the questions. The general rubric will also be more<br />
streamlined and ask candidates to make comparative reference to at least one other text,<br />
either studied on the course or selected for wider independent study.<br />
The decision to make these changes, while still keeping to the requirements of the<br />
specification, was taken in the light of candidate responses to the first January paper.<br />
The revised rubric should enable candidates to apply their knowledge and skills in a more<br />
focused way, whilst still maintaining the stretch and challenge required of this paper. The<br />
revised specimen paper, which includes these revisions, appears at the end of this<br />
document, but it can also be downloaded as a separate document.<br />
The basic approach to all Section B questions remains the same: candidates need to<br />
answer one of the five questions with sustained reference to their set core text and<br />
comparative reference to one or more texts. They must use integrated approaches and<br />
consider contextual factors. The general rubric as it stands on the first specimen paper and<br />
first January paper asks for literary and non-literary texts, written and spoken, but the new<br />
rubric allows candidates to choose any one or more type of text to illuminate discussion of<br />
the core text. While some candidates might offer a range of references, including their own<br />
reading, others may feel more comfortable drawing on one or more of their AS texts or their<br />
Shakespeare LL3 text. Candidates who only offer one text will not be disadvantaged,<br />
provided that they produce a response that offers valid connections which are relevant to<br />
their discussion of the question they are answering.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s who prepare their students by exposing them to a variety of text types and<br />
encouraging them to undertake wider independent reading in addition to revisiting their AS<br />
texts and LL3 texts will enable their students to draw from a rich pool of resources in<br />
answering their chosen question.<br />
Our advice still holds that in making comparative connections, candidates should focus on<br />
producing quality rather than quantity, ensuring that their connections are used meaningfully<br />
and purposefully to illuminate their discussion of the core text. As a rough guide, two-thirds<br />
of the essay should address the core text, with a third on the selected ‘partner’ text(s).<br />
The Examiner’s Report for the first January paper should be read in conjunction with this<br />
document.
<strong>LL4</strong> Section A: Comparative Textual Analysis<br />
Candidate response January 2010<br />
Question 1<br />
Using integrated approaches, compare and contrast how Hadrian’s Wall is presented<br />
in Texts A-C.<br />
In your response you must analyse and evaluate how the different contexts and purposes of<br />
the texts influence linguistic choice. You must also consider how effective each text is in<br />
developing its ideas.<br />
All three texts use various literary and linguistic techniques in their shared relaxed approach<br />
to the description of Hadrian’s Wall. While texts B and C are written ultimately to inform their<br />
audience of a history of the wall, the author of text A assumes the role of a Roman guard,<br />
and tells more of the hardships and details of his life within the context of his station as a<br />
guard.<br />
Each text uses various techniques to create a light and often amusing tone. This is<br />
particularly notable in texts B and C as they both use modern language, phrases and idioms<br />
imposed on a historical context, with the intent to entertain.<br />
Text B is written purposefully for younger readers, and so while Terry Deary aims to capture<br />
their imagination, it is important that there is an undercurrent of informative details<br />
throughout. One way in which the author entertains his readers is through the repetition of<br />
the modifier ‘rotten’ in the first line, which is used for its alliterative effect when placed with<br />
‘Romans’, and ‘ruthless’, and creates the impression the author relishes their rottenness, as<br />
he repeats the idea. Deary then combines the two adjectives ‘rotten’ and ‘ruthless’ to form<br />
‘Rotless’, an imaginary word, end-focused to amuse the younger reader.<br />
There are several examples of Deary’s use of alliteration in this piece. For example, the<br />
phrase ‘worked on the wild wall’ uses the alliterated ‘w’ sound to create an almost<br />
onomatopoeic effect, in mimicking the breathing sound of the wind. The rhythm of this<br />
phrase also allows the stress to fall on the pre-modifier ‘wild’, as a dactyl is used, and this<br />
heavy stress emphasises to create a dramatic suspense for what is to come in the rest of the<br />
book. This effect, along with Deary’s use of ellipsis, are particularly important as the purpose<br />
of the extract is to grab the interest of the young reader and spark their imagination, in that it<br />
is an introductory passage and will want to entice the reader to continue with the book.<br />
In text A, Auden also uses alliteration for its onomatopoeic effect, in the first line of the poem.<br />
Here, the alliterated ‘w’s of ‘wet wind blows’ indicated the same wildness of the surroundings<br />
Comment [L1]: AO3<br />
Comparative approach from<br />
outset<br />
Comment [L2]: AO2<br />
Appreciates humour<br />
Comment [L3]: AO2<br />
Audience<br />
Comment [L4]: AO1 Range of<br />
terms used<br />
Comment [L5]: AO2 Explores<br />
impact of language choices<br />
Comment [L6]: AO3 Close<br />
comparison
achieved by Deary in text B. What Auden also achieves is a sense of the harshness of the<br />
soldier’s surroundings, through the three heavily stressed monosyllables (spondee).<br />
A further linguistic device used by Deary is assonance in the phrase ‘wicked Pictish winds’,<br />
which indicates the harsh environmental conditions by the brisk phonetics of the phrase. The<br />
assonance and alliteration used by Deary when describing the setting is particularly<br />
important as this is an introduction, and they help to imaginatively set the scene in the minds<br />
of the reader.<br />
This structural device is also used by Auden in that he opens the poem with details of the<br />
soldier’s harsh surroundings, which as well as creating empathy for the character depicted,<br />
sets in context his position in life, as Auden is assuming the role of a fictional character who<br />
must be introduced to the reader.<br />
Interestingly, Auden holds in dichotomy the ideas of the soldiers harsh living conditions in<br />
relation to the weather and natural surroundings, through the juxtaposition of the external<br />
and internal hardships of the first three couplets of the poem. What this achieves is a sense<br />
that the wildness of the surroundings truly impact on the people who live and work around<br />
the wall, and this gives the reader an impression of the power of Hadrian’s Wall.<br />
This connection between the wildness of the weather and the power of the wall is made in<br />
both texts A and B, and particularly in text A, could be seen to be an example of pathetic<br />
fallacy, in that the ‘wet winds’ and the mist that ‘creeps’ are reflective of the soldier’s<br />
miserable state of mind.<br />
In the poem, it is perhaps surprising then that the character of the soldier chooses to return<br />
to the idea of nature in the final line. By end focusing ‘sky’, a hopeful note is created through<br />
the idea of vastness, as if he sees the sky as an escape from the petty trivialities of life on<br />
the wall. This hopeful, human idea creates empathy for the character, as it appears a<br />
timeless image, connecting the reader with the historical context, and also in emphasising<br />
the harshness of his daily life.<br />
An important link between all three passages is this link between modern ideas in a historical<br />
context, as this makes the ideas discussed more accessible for a modern reader, and in<br />
texts B and C, helps create a lighter tone.<br />
In text C, the author uses modern idioms such as ‘does exactly what it says on the tin’ and<br />
‘put une chausette in it, Napoleon’ for comedic effect, as they seem incongruous with the<br />
historical setting of the wall, and also minimise the ‘respect’ usually shown to the events of<br />
great historical significance, i.e. the French Revolution or the building of Hadrian’s Wall.<br />
Text C also imposes modern ideas on the historical context through the use of rhetorical<br />
interrogative, ‘Had Hadrian not dined out in gastronomic Glasgow’ which achieves humour<br />
through the mismatch of time periods/cultural references. The author of this text uses these<br />
techniques to lighten the tone, and make Hadrian’s Wall seem more accessible to a modern<br />
Comment [L7]: AO3 Literary<br />
context<br />
Comment [L8]: AO1<br />
Sophisticated expression of ideas<br />
Comment [L9]: AO3<br />
Comparisons sustained<br />
Comment [L10]: AO3 Subtle<br />
appreciation of context<br />
Comment [L11]: AO1<br />
Terminology
eader. It is clear through the cultural references of ‘Edinburgh Festival’ and the use of<br />
French in the English idiom stated previously, that the intended audience is more culturally<br />
aware than that of text B.<br />
In text B, Deary similarly uses modern references imposed on the historical context, but<br />
instead used the alliterated simile, ‘plague of pasta’ when describing the Roman empire for<br />
its comedic effect through its phonetics, ridiculousness as an image, and portrayal of a<br />
modern stereotype in a historical context.<br />
A further way in which the authors of text B and C create a casual tone include their<br />
manipulation of the mode of address. In text B, this is particularly important as it changes<br />
from third person narrative to second person, when the author addresses the reader as ‘you’<br />
in the seventh paragraph. Here, imperatives such as ‘imagine’ are foregrounded, and they<br />
instruct the reader with the aim of capturing the young reader’s imagination.<br />
The author of text C uses as informal tone throughout. using parenthesis to create the<br />
impression of an ‘inside joke’, again using imperatives such as ‘calm down’, but here this is<br />
more for comedic purpose than to capture the reader’s imagination like in text B.<br />
A final comparison to be made between texts A and B is the use of parallelism. In text A, this<br />
is achieved in the line ‘I want my girl and I want my pay’. The rhythmical effect perhaps<br />
imitates the predictability of his life as a Roman soldier, and the simplistic language used to<br />
create an impression of his desperation through his demand of basic needs.<br />
Terry Deary uses parallelism for a very different reason, in the repetition of the phrase ‘let<br />
me imagine it for you. Let me tell you.’ Here, this repetition again creates a rhythmical effect,<br />
but is more to adopt the role of the story teller in that the imperative draws the reader into the<br />
book.<br />
To conclude, all three texts are written with the purpose of informing the reader, although<br />
texts B and C achieve this through stated historical facts whilst text A gives a personal<br />
account through connecting with a fictional historical character.<br />
Texts B and C have a lighter tone to them, to amuse whilst informing, delivered by<br />
manipulation of the mode of address, alliteration and inclusion of modern ideas in a historical<br />
context.<br />
Comment [L12]: AO1<br />
Phonology and imagery<br />
Comment [L13]: AO3<br />
Compares mode of address<br />
Comment [L14]: AO1<br />
Grammar<br />
Examiner’s Comment:<br />
AO1 (Band 4+) Thorough knowledge and understanding gained from integrated study.<br />
Terminology is used sensitively and addresses a wide range of features. Written expression<br />
is confident and fluent. Material is well organised.<br />
AO2 (Band 4+) Perceptive awareness of how choices of form, structure and language affect<br />
readers. Confident evaluation of techniques. Explores attitudes and values meaningfully
through sustained focus in how language is used to create different impacts on different<br />
audiences.<br />
AO3 (Band 4+) Confident awareness and discussion of relationships between texts, making<br />
specific and productive connections. Subtle appreciation of contextual factors and their<br />
significance.<br />
Mark: 40/40
<strong>LL4</strong> Section B: Reviewing Approaches<br />
Candidate response January 2010<br />
Question 2<br />
Discuss how the theme of power is presented in the texts you have studied.<br />
Core Text ‘Wuthering Heights’<br />
Often power is presented in texts as a negative quality where it is abused to teach a moral<br />
lesson of hubris or greed. Less often, power is shown with positive aspects, in political<br />
speeches in particular assuring listeners such power will be put to good use. Themes of<br />
power have changed over time regarding gender and relationships owing to contextual<br />
factors such as feminism.<br />
‘Wuthering Heights’, the nineteenth century novel, depicts the oppression of women by<br />
powerful men in their relationships. In chapter 12 Brontë portrays Isabella as weak and<br />
submissive when she runs away with Heathcliff conforming to the gothic conventions of<br />
weak female characters. Isabella’s weak character is juxtaposed with Heathcliff’s causing<br />
him to appear much more powerful. Brontë’s use of the noun phrase, ‘real little fool’,<br />
demeans any power Isabella may hold with emphasis on the pre-modifier ‘little’. Heathcliff’s<br />
power over her is also suggested by his treatment of her such as calling her a ‘mere slut’,<br />
throwing a knife at her and hanging up ‘her little dog’ but ‘no brutality disgusted her’. Such<br />
events heighten the power of Heathcliff through specific choice of the lexis ‘flung’ which<br />
suggests it was a reckless action rather than thrown.<br />
Similarly, Stephen King’s modern horror novel, ‘Rose Madder’, consists of specific modifiers<br />
and lexis to heighten the power of the male gender over the female gender. This is shown in<br />
the prologue where Rose’s husband is careless and violent whilst Rose is having a<br />
miscarriage on the floor. The use of simile which includes the verb ‘rips’, the adjective<br />
‘monstrous’ and comparison ‘like a hacksaw blade’ all connote violence and pain as it is<br />
describing the pain of Rosie’s miscarriage with her husband’s ignorance when he hums<br />
‘When a man loves a woman’, showing his sadistic nature and power over Rosie; much<br />
similar to Heathcliff and Isabella’s relationship which is also violent. Since ‘Wuthering<br />
Heights’ was written earlier when subjects of pregnancy or miscarriage were seen as a<br />
taboo, such topics are not discussed like it is explored in King’s novel.<br />
Nevertheless, ‘Wuthering Heights’ was already seen as controversial due to the excessive<br />
passion within the novel between Catherine and Heathcliff. The theme of power is exploited<br />
through Catherine and Heathcliff’s passion in Volume two, chapter one where they reunited<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>15]: AO3<br />
Coherent overview<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>16]: AO2<br />
genre<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>17]: AO2<br />
selects firmly<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>18]: AO2<br />
impressive analysis<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>19]: AO3<br />
explicit link
as lovers for the final time before Catherine’s death. Brontë’s use of animalistic lexis,<br />
‘foamed like a mad dog’, ‘eyes flashed fiercely’ and ‘heaved convulsively’ to describe<br />
Heathcliff shows the excessiveness of Heathcliff’s desire and possession of Catherine. Such<br />
lexis remove all qualities of a man from Heathcliff showing this love is more powerful than<br />
the conventional love as it is extreme and nothing a human has experience. This moment is<br />
the climactic moment of the novel, enabling, in particular, the readers of the nineteenth<br />
century to be drawn into the second half of the novel, as the volumes were sold as separate<br />
books at that time.<br />
The power of passion is also shown in Churchill’s speech around the 1930s to boost the<br />
morale of listeners in Britain, as Britain appeared to be failing in the battle. Churchill uses<br />
many pauses to enable his message to sink into the listeners’ minds, to inevitable brainwash<br />
them with positivity. Also, use of future tense verbs and inclusive language such as ‘we will<br />
fight…’ portrays that the listeners are not alone, it is a team effort and there is hope. In<br />
contrast, in ‘Antigone’, a Greek play of around 440AD, shows abusiveness of power like<br />
Heathcliff as Creon becomes too proud, almost like a god therefore takes a fall from his<br />
staus costing him his wife and his son; all due to hubris. This shows a political and moral<br />
message relevant to audiences of ‘Antigone’s’ time as well as politics today.<br />
In ‘Wuthering Heights’ the power of money is also shown as it drives the plots such as:<br />
Catherine’s motive to marry Edgar which was social ambition and wealth in chapter ten;<br />
Heathcliff’s corrupt motive to marry Isabella to gain property and finally the forced marriage<br />
between Catherine and Linton so Heathcliff could inherit the property. All of which are<br />
narrative devices to cause conflict within the novel, where Brontë plays with the readers’<br />
hopes of a happy ending. In the romantic poet Shelley’s ‘Ozymandias’, the sonnet shows the<br />
power of time and nature portraying the insignificance of political ruler ‘Ozymandias’<br />
compared to time which could be applied to political rulers of all times teaching readers a<br />
lesson that the power of man is nothing; art and nature hold greater power typical of the<br />
Romanticists.<br />
Overall, power is depicted negatively to mainly teach the corruption and responsibilities of<br />
power to audiences but in speeches it can be used to persuade and boost morale. In<br />
particular, the power of gender has changed although some relationships remain with the<br />
male in the powerful role.<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>20]: clearly<br />
organises<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>21]: AO2<br />
writer’s techniques<br />
Comment [<strong>WJEC</strong>22]: AO3<br />
context<br />
Examiner’s Comment<br />
AO1 (Band 4+) Excellent organisation. Fluency throughout. Confident use of integrated<br />
approaches and terms.
AO2 (Band 4) Relevant selections. Analyses ideas and details with assurance.<br />
AO3 (Band 4+) Impressive range and linking. Several different contextual considerations<br />
discussed.<br />
Mark:38/40
GENERAL CERTIFICATE OF EDUCATION<br />
TYSTYSGRIF ADDYSG GYFFREDINOL<br />
2009 - 2010<br />
ENGLISH LANGUAGE & LITERATURE ADVANCED<br />
<strong>LL4</strong> SPECIMEN QUESTION PAPER<br />
(REVISED RUBRIC issued March 2010)
GCE A level<br />
1174/01 New A2<br />
ENGLISH LANGUAGE & LITERATURE<br />
<strong>LL4</strong>: Comparative Textual Analysis and Review<br />
2½hours<br />
ADDITIONAL MATERIALS<br />
In addition to this examination paper, you will need:<br />
• a 'clean' copy (i.e. with no annotation) of the text you have studied for Section B;<br />
• a 12 page answer book.<br />
INSTRUCTIONS TO CANDIDATES<br />
Answer the compulsory question in Section A.<br />
Answer one question from Section B.<br />
INFORMATION FOR CANDIDATES<br />
Section A and Section B both carry 40 marks.<br />
In both sections, you will be assessed on your ability to:<br />
• select and apply relevant concepts and approaches from integrated linguistic and literary<br />
study, using appropriate terminology and accurate, coherent written expression (AO1)<br />
• demonstrate detailed critical understanding in analysing the ways in which structure, form<br />
and language shape meanings in a range of spoken and written texts (AO2)<br />
• Use integrated approaches to explore relationships between texts, analysing and<br />
evaluating the significance of contextual factors in their production and reception (AO3).<br />
You are reminded that assessment will take into account the quality of written<br />
communication used in your answers.
Section A: Comparative Textual Analysis<br />
Answer the following compulsory question.<br />
1. This question is based on all three texts which follow.<br />
TEXT A<br />
The opening section of Lines Composed a Few Miles above Tintern Abbey, On Revisiting<br />
the Banks of the Wye during a Tour, July 13, 1798 by William Wordsworth (1770-1850).<br />
In this poem, Wordsworth describes the landscape around Tintern Abbey, South Wales,<br />
and his feelings at seeing it again after a five year interval. The whole poem is 159 lines<br />
long.<br />
TEXT B<br />
A transcription of the opening of the radio drama, Under Milk Wood by Dylan Thomas<br />
(1914-1953) as performed in 1988 with Sir Anthony Hopkins as First Voice. The<br />
opening describes the fictional Welsh town of Llareggub and its sleeping characters. It<br />
was first published in 1954, then later performed as a stage play and a film. First Voice<br />
functions as a narrator.<br />
TEXT C<br />
A page from the official Ministry of Tourism for India website (2004).<br />
Using integrated approaches, compare and contrast how a sense of place<br />
is created in Texts A-C.<br />
In your response, you must analyse and evaluate how the different contexts and<br />
purposes of the texts influence linguistic choice. You must also consider how<br />
effective each passage is in developing a sense of place.
Text A: the opening of the poem, ‘Tintern Abbey’, by William Wordsworth.<br />
Five years have passed; five summers, with the length<br />
Of five long winters! and again I hear<br />
These waters, rolling from their mountain-springs<br />
With a soft inland murmur.--Once again<br />
5 Do I behold these steep and lofty cliffs,<br />
That on a wild secluded scene impress<br />
Thoughts of more deep seclusion; and connect<br />
The landscape with the quiet of the sky.<br />
The day is come when I again repose<br />
10 Here, under this dark sycamore, and view<br />
These plots of cottage-ground, these orchard-tufts,<br />
Which at this season, with their unripe fruits,<br />
Are clad in one green hue, and lose themselves<br />
'Mid groves and copses. Once again I see<br />
15 These hedge-rows, hardly hedge-rows, little lines<br />
Of sportive wood run wild: these pastoral farms,<br />
Green to the very door; and wreaths of smoke<br />
Sent up, in silence, from among the trees!<br />
With some uncertain notice, as might seem<br />
20 Of vagrant dwellers in the houseless woods,<br />
Or of some Hermit's cave, where by his fire<br />
The Hermit sits alone.<br />
These beauteous forms,<br />
Through a long absence, have not been to me<br />
As is a landscape to a blind man's eye:<br />
25 But oft, in lonely rooms, and 'mid the din<br />
Of towns and cities, I have owed to them,<br />
In hours of weariness, sensations sweet,<br />
Felt in the blood, and felt along the heart;<br />
And passing even into my purer mind<br />
30 With tranquil restoration.<br />
Text B: the opening of Under Milk Wood by Dylan Thomas.<br />
Key to discourse features<br />
word underlining indicates a stressed syllable<br />
(.) a micropause<br />
(1) a timed pause in seconds<br />
◦word◦ whispered word<br />
[italics] stage directions<br />
[Silence]<br />
FIRST VOICE [very softly]: to begin (1.5) at the beginning (2) it is Spring (.) moonless<br />
night in the small town (0.5) starless (.) and bible-black (1) the cobblestreets silent and the<br />
hunched courters'-and- rabbits' wood (0.5) limping invisible down to the sloeblack 1 (0.5) slow<br />
(0.5) black (.) crowblack (.) fishingboat-bobbing sea (1) the houses are blind as moles (.)
though moles see fine tonight in the snouting velvet dingles 2 (0.5) or blind as Captain Cat (.)<br />
there in the muffled middle by the pump and the town clock (.) the shops in mourning (.) the<br />
Welfare Hall in widows' weeds 3 (1) and all the people of the lulled and dumbfound town (.)<br />
are ◦sleeping now◦<br />
1 2<br />
sloe: the small blue-black fruit of the blackthorn shrub dingle: a small wooded valley<br />
3 widows’ weeds: the black clothes traditionally worn as a sign of mourning<br />
Text C: a page from the official Ministry of Tourism for India website<br />
India's amazing diversity offers you everything you could ever want in a<br />
holiday. From the moment that you set foot in<br />
India to be greeted by a graceful namaste, a<br />
gesture that denotes both welcome and respect,<br />
you are on the way to one of the most<br />
rewarding experiences of your life. Bounded by<br />
the majestic Himalayan ranges in the north and<br />
edged by a spectacular coastline surrounded by<br />
three seas, India is a vivid kaleidoscope of<br />
landscapes, magnificent historical sites and<br />
royal cities, golden beaches, misty mountain<br />
retreats, colorful people, rich cultures and<br />
festivities.<br />
At any part of the year India can offer you a<br />
dazzling array of destinations and<br />
experiences. In summer, when the<br />
subcontinent is sizzling, there are spectacular<br />
retreats amidst the heady beauty of the<br />
Himalayas or the lush heights of the Western<br />
Ghats with cool trekking trails, tall peaks to conqueror stretches of white<br />
water for the adventure seekers.<br />
In the cool of an Indian winter, cities come alive with cultural feasts of music<br />
and dance. The balmy weather is an ideal time for you to go century<br />
hopping in romantic cities studded with medieval forts and palaces. The sun<br />
drenched beaches are inviting and wildlife sanctuaries with their abundance<br />
of flora and fauna are a buzz with the nurture of the young.<br />
You can taste the delights of the Indian monsoon<br />
anywhere in the country- on a camel safari in the<br />
Rajasthan desert when nature comes alive and the<br />
peacocks dance; along the west coast where the<br />
relentless slanting rain paints the countryside in brilliant<br />
greens or even trekking amidst the stark grandeur of<br />
mountain valleys lying in the rain shadow of the<br />
Himalayas.<br />
Experience exotic India; live like a maharaja in the rich<br />
ambiance of royal forts and palaces that are now heritage<br />
hotels; luxuriate in the serene beauty of a coral island with<br />
its turquoise lagoon; participate in the exuberance of a<br />
village fair or a colorful festival; day dream on a house boat drifting down<br />
the palm - fringed backwaters; delight in the grace of a dancer or shop till<br />
you drop - buying exquisite silks, carved figurines, brass and silver ware,<br />
marble inlaid with semi-precious stones, finely crafted jewelry, miniature<br />
paintings, carpets ....at unbelievable prices. India, always warm and inviting,<br />
is a place of infinite variety - one that favors you with a different facet of its<br />
fascination every time you come on a visit.
Section B: Reviewing Approaches<br />
.<br />
You will need a 'clean' copy (no annotation) of the text which you have studied for this<br />
section in order to answer one of the following questions.<br />
Answer one of the questions below.<br />
Your response must include:<br />
• sustained reference to your chosen set text;<br />
• comparative reference to at least one other text that you have either studied as<br />
part of the course or selected for wider independent study.<br />
Either,<br />
2. Explore the different ways children and childhood are presented in the texts you have<br />
studied.<br />
Or,<br />
In your response you must use integrated literary and linguistic approaches and<br />
consider the significance of contextual factors.<br />
3. Analyse the range of techniques used to engage the reader’s or audience’s attention in<br />
the texts you have studied.<br />
Or,<br />
Or,<br />
Or,<br />
In your response you must use integrated literary and linguistic approaches and<br />
consider the significance of contextual factors.<br />
4. ‘Writers and speakers today have more freedom to choose their content and style than<br />
they ever did’. How far do you agree with this statement<br />
In your response you must use integrated literary and linguistic approaches and<br />
consider the significance of contextual factors.<br />
5. Evaluate the importance of a sense of place in the texts you have studied.<br />
In your response you must use integrated literary and linguistic approaches and<br />
consider the significance of contextual factors.<br />
6. ‘It is impossible for an Englishman to open his mouth without making some other<br />
Englishman hate or despise him’. Explore the presentation of different accents and<br />
dialects in the texts you have studied.<br />
In your response you must use integrated literary and linguistic approaches and<br />
consider the significance of contextual factors.
A2 ENGLISH LANGUAGE & LITERATURE<br />
Bands<br />
1<br />
Low<br />
Mid<br />
High<br />
2<br />
Low<br />
Mid<br />
High<br />
Marks<br />
0-10<br />
0-4<br />
5-6<br />
7-10<br />
11-20<br />
11-14<br />
15-16<br />
17-20<br />
A01<br />
Select and apply relevant concepts<br />
and approaches from integrated<br />
linguistic and literary study, using<br />
appropriate terminology and<br />
accurate, coherent written<br />
expression.<br />
Weighting: 8 marks<br />
Limited evidence of integrated study.<br />
Minimal, unconvincing application of<br />
concepts and approaches. Written<br />
expression often has lapses in<br />
accuracy and clarity. Response may<br />
lack organisation Basic terminology<br />
often misunderstood and misapplied.<br />
Some basic evidence of integrated<br />
study. Some application of key<br />
concepts and approaches. Some use<br />
of key terminology. Generally clear<br />
expression, but with lapses in<br />
accuracy. Straightforward vocabulary<br />
and sentence organisation. Clear<br />
organisation towards top of band.<br />
<strong>LL4</strong> SECTIONS A and B<br />
A02<br />
Demonstrate detailed critical<br />
understanding in analysing the ways in<br />
which structure, form and language<br />
shape meanings in a range of spoken<br />
and written texts.<br />
Weighting: 16 marks<br />
Limited awareness of how some of the<br />
most obvious choices in form, structure<br />
and vocabulary create basic meanings.<br />
Some difficulty in understanding meaning<br />
in texts.<br />
Some awareness of some key language<br />
features. Analysis mainly at word level at<br />
bottom of band.<br />
Clear grasp of basic meaning. Texts<br />
understood on a straightforward level.<br />
Some generalisation and simplification.<br />
Adequate awareness of genre, more<br />
secure towards top of band.<br />
AO3<br />
Use integrated approaches to explore<br />
relationships between texts, analysing<br />
and evaluating the significance of<br />
contextual factors in their production<br />
and reception.<br />
Weighting: 16 marks<br />
Some simplistic awareness of the<br />
broadest contextual factors. Limited<br />
sense of genre.<br />
Limited evidence of understanding basic<br />
points of comparison and contrast. Texts<br />
may be discussed individually and<br />
unevenly.<br />
Reasonable observations of some key<br />
contextual factors. Some relevant<br />
discussion of how different contexts<br />
influence the way the texts have been/are<br />
received, more relevant towards top of<br />
band. Selection and discussion of some of<br />
the more obvious points of comparison<br />
and contrast.<br />
A01<br />
Select and apply relevant concepts<br />
and approaches from integrated<br />
linguistic and literary study, using<br />
appropriate terminology and<br />
accurate, coherent written<br />
expression.<br />
Weighting: 8 marks<br />
Limited evidence of integrated study.<br />
Minimal, unconvincing application of<br />
concepts and approaches. Written<br />
expression often has lapses in accuracy<br />
and clarity. Response may lack<br />
organisation Basic terminology often<br />
misunderstood and misapplied.<br />
Some basic evidence of integrated<br />
study. Some application of key<br />
concepts and approaches. Some use of<br />
key terminology. Generally clear<br />
expression, but with lapses in accuracy.<br />
Straightforward vocabulary and<br />
sentence organisation. Clear<br />
organisation towards top of band.<br />
3<br />
Low<br />
Mid<br />
High<br />
21-30<br />
21-24<br />
25-26<br />
27-30<br />
Clear evidence of integrated study.<br />
Purposeful use of appropriate<br />
terminology. Relevant and purposeful<br />
application of some relevant key<br />
concepts and approaches. Generally<br />
accurate, coherent expression.<br />
Effective organisation, particularly<br />
towards top of band.<br />
More sustained focus on language used to<br />
create meaning, including some<br />
convincing phrase and sentence level<br />
analysis. Sensible use of key literary and<br />
linguistic concepts and approaches.<br />
Sound reading of implicit meaning, with<br />
increasingly detailed appreciation of<br />
writers’/speakers’ techniques.<br />
Sensible and clear awareness of the<br />
influence of some key contextual factors<br />
on the production and reception of texts.<br />
Some sensible evaluation of how different<br />
audiences/readers in different times might<br />
respond. Able to present generally<br />
convincing overview. Points for<br />
comparison and contrast are well-chosen<br />
and clearly argued.<br />
Clear evidence of integrated study.<br />
Purposeful use of appropriate<br />
terminology. Relevant and purposeful<br />
application of some relevant key<br />
concepts and approaches. Generally<br />
accurate, coherent expression.<br />
Effective organisation, particularly<br />
towards top of band.<br />
4<br />
Low<br />
Mid<br />
High<br />
31-40<br />
31-34<br />
35-36<br />
37-40<br />
Thorough knowledge, understanding<br />
and insights gained from integrated<br />
study. Sophisticated application of<br />
concepts and a wide range of<br />
approaches. Accurate and sensitive<br />
use of terminology. Very wellorganised.<br />
Written expression is confident, fluent,<br />
with varying degrees of flair. Mature<br />
vocabulary.<br />
Perceptive awareness of how choices of<br />
form, structure and language affect<br />
readers and audiences. Assured reading<br />
of texts. Convincing and perceptive subtextual<br />
exploration. Some evidence of<br />
originality may be shown. Clear and<br />
sustained focus throughout response.<br />
Confident evaluation of the impact of<br />
contextual factors in shaping the<br />
production of texts and influencing<br />
different audiences/readers at different<br />
times.<br />
Points of comparison and contrast are<br />
astute and illuminating. Title/question<br />
addressed consistently and perceptively.<br />
Thorough knowledge, understanding<br />
and insights gained from integrated<br />
study. Sophisticated application of<br />
concepts and a wide range of<br />
approaches. Accurate and sensitive use<br />
of terminology. Very well-organised.<br />
Written expression is confident, fluent,<br />
with varying degrees of flair. Mature<br />
vocabulary.